!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$5(!"#$%&'(")"*)#+,)-&')./&0&1")"*)2+"$+3451")+6178"*)

677897:;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

)(9*.+/04+6178":))(<C! !DEFG7HD8(IDEJFDFF@DF(KDE(HELDK(

=C! $M7MD:D8MF;(NL8NG?F@DF(D8(79O@DPD8(778(E?@:MDG@>JD(JI7G@MD@MFMD7:F(

((((((((+@>G7HD(<5(($KDDNQ(IDMQL?9DE(RD88@F($ME77M(

+@>G7HD(=5((SEDFD8M7TD((

(((((/89DEPLDJ(U#?@:MDG@>JD(*I7G@MD@MFMD7:F(@8(.D9DEG789V;((

((((($789E7(O78(&FFD8(D8(-LFW(O78(37:KD8C(

+@>G7HD(B5((SEDFD8M7TD(XG@K(MD(37MDC(

+@>G7HD(Y5((SEDFD8M7TD("E@N(%?@MD8C(

+@>G7HD(Z5((SEDFD8M7TD()@:(O78(!DDGD8C(

( ((((((( ( ((

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

KC=(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B((((

;<<=)>:)?<@A=BC<D)!<@EA<AA9<A)

KCB(

)()VERSLAG WERKSESSIE GROEP 1 (((>F)?GG@AH<=@GD;<)'DFKEDJFGD@9@8H5(RD88@F($ME77M([($789E7(O78(&FFD8(RDDG8D:DEF5(3QE@FT78(&G9DEG@DFMD8;(+DE879D\D(-78FD8;(+E7:(O78(R??ED8;(1@:(+E@GG;(1DFF7($M7QG@D;(#L]DEM(-78()@>8M>DF;(07EG@DF(O78(R@DFMC(((;")0"",*"3"#4)8"#2"1"*%++#0&1"*)0")8+,1"*0")$%7,&2"&242"734:)<C! 4LLH97GD:(^FG7KD89_(=C! 47OD8]D9E@>`(#L\DE97:(BC! 477J(L:(%DD?I7E9D8;(RD(.@>D(SGD7MF(YC! 3?GD:]LENQ(^@8(LKE@NQT8H_(ZC! )7E789D(%DGaFM79(^7`HDEL89_(bC! +ELDJDEKGD@8(%DGaFM79(cC! #@>8]LLH(dC! R?@8(&G:DED(eC! &G:DED(+?@MD8(((IF);<)E!B=9H<9HAH<BJA)DKL)9DH@G;KMH9<)<D)?<@C<=9NE9DC))(H"73473"*42",,&*1:)(!LLEP@\DE5(]@>(47OD8]D9E@>`(]@>OLLE]DDG9(478F($:@M;(]@>(477J(L:(%DD?I7E9D8(F?KDEO@FLE(FM79C(/ODEDD8JL:FTHD(DfKDETFD5(L87g78JDG@>J(7ENQ@MDNM;(L87g78JDG@>J(FMD9D8]L?IJ?89@HD;(HD:DD8MDG@>J(FMD9D8]L?IJ?89@HD;(ODEMDHD8ILLE9@HDE(IDGFM789C($L:F5(L87g78JDG@>J(G789FNQ7KF7ENQ@MDNM;(L87g78JDG@>J(N?GM??EQ@FMLE@N?F;(J?8FM(^7K7EMD(NL::@FF@DF_;(DfKDETFD(LK(7`ELDKC((O"++#0",&*14$70"#:)(•! "E(@F(DD8(KG78HED8FC(•! "E(@F(FL:F(IDG;(FL:F(8@DM(DD8(D@8997M?:(]DK77G9C((

(•! "E(@F(7GT>9(DD8(J79DEC(•! "E(@F(FL:F(DD8(U:@FF@L8(FM7MD:D8MV;(]@>OC(47OD8]D9E@>`(#L\DE97:5(O@F@D5(

U%LI(L8(7ENQ@MDNM?ED;(%LI(L8(NLGL?EVC(•! /K9E7NQM(MD7:5(KE@:7@E(QDM(]DLLE9DGD8(O78(KG788D8;(FL:F(DD8(

]ED9DED(J@>J(LK(L8MI@JJDG@8HD8C(•! 07MD(O78(OE@>QD@95(QLHD(:7MD(O78(OE@>QD@9C(((B7#0)87*)0")708&4"#&*1:)(•! &9O@DF(7785(LK9E7NQMHDODE;(@8@T7TD`8D:DE(L`(LK9E7NQMHDODE(D8(

7ENQ@MDNMC(•! 0DD9D8JD8([(]DLLE9DGD8C((•! +DFNQD@9D8(ELG;(9@D8FM]77E(778(9D(LK9E7NQM([(KE@JJDGD89(FL:F(]?@MD8(

9D(KG78HED8PD8C((J&44&"P+6178":(•! /KH7OD85(FMD9DG@>JD(LKH7OD;(@8K7FF@8H(@8`E7FME?NM??E(D8(J?8FMIDEJD8;(

KEL>DNMD8(@8(Q7OD8HD]@D9C(•! 0@FF@D5(ODEQLHD8(:@8@:7GD(JI7G@MD@M;(E?@:MD(HDOD8(778(DfNDGGD8MD(

@8@T7TDOD8C(RLLEODEM7GD8(]DGD@9C(•! S7FF@D(LODE]ED8HD8C(•! /87g78JDG@>J(79O@DFC((•! +Dh@89@H@8H(9@FN?FF@DFC(•! 0@FF@D(i(MD7:(Q7OD8]D9E@>`5(]DHDGD@9D8(KEL>DNMD8(D8(L8MI@JJDG@8HD8(

9LLE(LKE?JJD89D(FM79C(

B7*07Q.246/*2"*)8++#)."2)"R"Q5"S)708&4"#"*:)•! 'LD9D(OLLEP@\DE(DEH(]DG78HE@>JC(•! SEL]GDD:5(MDE?HMEDJJD89D(LODEQD@9C(•! R?@9DG@>JD(LK9E7NQMC(((

KCZ(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

)()VERVOLG VERSLAG WERKSESSIE GROEP 1 ((

(TF)D9<K!<)GUCB?<D)(•! &78>7HD8(HD]@D9FL8MI@JJDG@8HC(/7C(UDOD8MFV(L:(9a87:@DJ(LK(H78H(MD(

]ED8HD8;(OLLE]DDG9(,+&(S7EJFM79C(•! 6LEH9E7HD8(OLLE(:DDE(NL8T8?jMD@M(EL89(]@>PL89DED(@8FK788@8HD8(D8(

KEL>DNMD8;(PL7GF(XGLE@79DC(•! &78>7HDE(L8MI@JJDG@8HD8(87:D8F(L89DE8D:DEFC(•! /KMDGFL:(O78(I77E9D8(D8(]DG78HD85(JI7G@MD@M(ODEFMDEJD8C(•! %DED8(O78(+DGH@h5(F7:D8]ED8HD8(O78(GLFFD(@8@T7TDOD8C(•! 0DDE(77897NQM(OLLE(QDM(E?@:MDG@>JD(JI7G@MD@MFHDFKEDJC(•! )DGFM789FLEH78@F7TDF(7GF(@8MDE9@FN@KG@87@ED(79O@DF]?ED7?F(D8(

L8MIDEKD89(79O@FD?EC(•! 1LDJL:FTHD(MQD:7VF(D8(LKH7OD85(PLEH;(JE@:K;(EDH@L87GD(LKH7OD8;(I7MDE;(

@8`E7;(FGLLK;(GDDHFM789;(:DDE(7HD89DED8C()VF)D9<K!<)@G=)P)O9N;@BC<)W)H<BJA(•! ,8FKDGD8(LK(L8MI@JJDG@8HD8(@8(9D(:7EJM(^NE@F@F_C(•! XGDf@]DG(L:H778(:DM(ODE789DE@8HD8(^i(MD7:F(]DFM778(?@M(:D8FD8;(9DPD(

J?88D8(kDf@]DGDE(L:H778(:DM(ODE789DE@8HD8(978(]DGD@9(L`(K7K@DE_C(•! 0DDE(77897NQM(OLLE(9E77HOG7J(K?]G@DJC(SELl7NTD`(E@NQT8H(K?]G@DJ([(:DDE(

@8(HDFKEDJ(:DM(K?]G@DJC(•! 0DDE(877E(]?@MD8(MLDC(+@>OLLE]DDG9(9LLE(FLN@7G(:D9@75(?@MGDH;(JI7G@MD@M(

G7MD8(P@D8;(789DEF(J@>JD8C(•! 0DDE(DO7G?7TDC(•! 0DDE(7HD89DED8(O78(L89DEIDEKD8C(•! 'DD8(L8MIDEK;(IDG(:DD9D8JD8(D8(]DLLE9DGD8C(•! !LLE7G(J@DPD8([(L89DEFMD?8D8(]@>(JD?PDFC(V3QLLFD(aL?E(]7\GDFV(•! +DG78HD8(LODEFT>HD8C(4DM(J?88D8(LODEP@D8(O78(QDM(HDQDDGC(•! i(MD7:(@F(HDD8(KEL>DNMHELDK(L`(NL8NDFF@DMD7:C(•! 4DM(HDIDMD8(O78(DD8(KEL>DNM;(KEL>DNMHD]@D9;(NL8T8?jMD@MC(

KCb(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

(XF)D9<K!<)@G=)P)O9N;@BC<)GDH!<@U<D;<);9AM9U=9D<A:)•! &`87:D(O78(9D(ELGC(•! /8MIDEK(D8(L8MIDEKD89(79O@DFC()YF)BBD;BMZHAGUKDH)?GG@);<)HG<EGJAH:)•! 6@>8(:D8FD8(7G(i(MD7:(:LDm(•! &GGD(HD:DD8MD8(DD8(L87g78JDG@>J(JI7G@MD@MFMD7:(L`(NL::@FF@Dm(•! 0DDE(9E77HOG7J(K?]G@DJC(•! 0DDE(K7ETN?G@DED8(9@D(JI7G@MD@M(I@GGD8(H778(]LEHD8C(

)()VERSLAG WERKSESSIE GROEP 2 >F)?GG@AH<=@GD;<(('DFKEDJFGD@9DE5(XG@K(MD8(37MD((RDDG8D:DEF5(&]D(!DD8FME7;(4D8E@D\D($789DEF;(1L8(O78(9DE(*EDDn;("G@FD(3LD8D8;(07E@78(O78(9DE(+E@8J;(#L](+DDEJD8F(((;")0"",*"3"#4)8"#2"1"*%++#0&1"*)0")8+,1"*0")$%7,&2"&242"734:)<C! $NQ?@>MHE77`(&E8QD:(=C! .ZA(#7:FKLG(BC! R?@OD8OLLE9D(3LEE@9LE(YC! $?KDEO@F@D(,8ODE978(ZC! 47EM(O78(6?@9(bC! +@>O78J("8FNQD9D(cC! 1D7:(QDE]DFMD::@8H(((((IF);<)E!B=9H<9HAH<BJA)DKL)9DH@G;KMH9<)<D)?<@C<=9NE9DC))(H"73473"*42",,&*1:)(•! 'D:DD8MDG@>JD(9DDG8D:DEF(D8(L87g78JDG@>JD(DfMDE8D8C(•! $L:F(DD8(7`HDO77E9@H9D(O78(IDGFM789C(.@DM(7GGD:77GC(•! !LLE]DDG9(F?KDEO@F@D(,8ODE9785(HD:DD8MDG@>J(F?KDEO@FLE;(

KELHE7::787HDE;(IDGFM789C((

B7#0)87*)0")708&4"#&*1:)(•! "E(@F(DD8(J79DE5(]@>OC(]DDG9JI7G@MD@MFKG78;(:7FMDEKG78;(FMEDDJKG78;(

7:]@TD9LN?:D8M(DM(NDMDE7C(•! &9O@DF(7785(LK9E7NQMHDODE;(KELO@8N@D;(HD:DD8MD;(NLEKLE7TDC(•! 0DD9D8JD8([(]DLLE9DGD8([(KLG@TDJD(@8MDEOD8TDFC((((

(J&44&"P+6178":(•! /KH7OD85((

•! $MD9DG@>JD(LKH7OD85(HD`7FDDE9D(L8MI@JJDG@8H(ILL8I@>J;(DGJD(`7FD(DD8(HLD9(D@89]DDG9;(]DDG9JI7G@MD@M(MD(L8MI@JJDGD8(]D]L?I@8HC(

•! ,8`E7FME?NM??E([(J?8FMIDEJD85(]DHDGD@9D8(@8Q??E(FKDN@7G@FMD8;(LKFMDGGD8(7:]@TD9LN?:D8MD8C(

•! 0@FF@D5((•! !LLEMH78H(D8(E?@:MDG@>JD(JI7G@MD@M(]DI7JD8((•! !DEFMDEJD8(FLN@77GlDNL8L:@FNQD(FME?NM??E(•! !DE]@89D8(FM7TL8lND8ME?:((•! $7:D8Q78H(]DI7JD8((•! )77E]LEHD8(E?@:MDG@>JD(JI7G@MD@M(D8([(L`(]DDG9JI7G@MD@MC(

((((

KCc(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

)()VERVOLG VERSLAG WERKSESSIE GROEP 2 (TF)D9<K!<)GUCB?<D)(•! *I7G@MD@M(:DM(:@89DE(HDG9C(•! ,8MDHE7GD(]D879DE@8H(O78(9D(LK9E7NQMC(•! U!G@DHI@DGV(KEL>DNMD8(^I@8lI@8;(oooo(F@M?7TD_(•! 1LDJL:FTHD(MQD:7VF(D8(LKH7OD85(QDE]DFMD::@8H;(QDEFME?NM?EDE@8H;(

JE@:KHD]@D9D8C((((((((

(VF)D9<K!<)@G==<D)(•! !ELDH(778(M7`DG((

((

KCd(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

)()VERSLAG WERKSESSIE GROEP 3 1. VOORSTELRONDE 'DFKEDJFGD@9DE5(-D`(0?QED8(RDDG8D:DEF5(0@EMD(#LPD:L89;(&GHL8($NQ??E:78;(SDMDE(9D(#?aMDE;("E@N(%?@>MD8;(%7?ED8F(O78(1@DG;(S7?G(*E7:DE;(,:JD(0?G9DEF;(R778(MDE(&ODFM;(07E@78(O78(9DE(+E@8JC(((;")0"",*"3"#4)8"#2"1"*%++#0&1"*)0")8+,1"*0")$%7,&2"&242"734:)<C! %DD?I7E9D8(6?@9IDFM(=C! %789FNQ7KKD8(O78(&GG?ED(BC! &`FG?@M9@>J(YC! )7MDEG@8@D(ZC! )DGFM789FNL::@FF@D(6778FM79(bC! ,8ODE978(((IF);<)E!B=9H<9HAH<BJAL)9DH@G;KMH9<)<D)?<@C<=9NE9DC))(H"73473"*42",,&*1:)("fKDETFD5(L87g78JDG@>J(7ENQ@MDNM;(L87g78JDG@>J(FMD9D8]L?IJ?89@HD;(L87g78JDG@>J(G789FNQ7KF7ENQ@MDNM;(HD:DD8MDG@>J(FMD9D8]L?IJ?89@HD;(ODEMDHD8ILLE9@HDE(IDGFM789C($L::@HD(MD7:F(L87g78JDG@>J;(789DED(MD7:F(9DDGF(L87g78JDG@>JC((B7#0)87*)0")%"#$(773."0"*)"*)0")708&4"#&*1:)(•! &9O@FDE@8H5(L87g78JDG@>JD(GD9D8(]DG78HE@>JC(•! !7FM(J79DE;(]@>OC(DD8(O@F@D(OLLE(QDM(HD]@D9;(]DDG9JI7G@MD@MFKG78;(

7:]@TD9LN?:D8MC(•! !7FM(E@M:D(O78(ODEH79DED8C(

(

(()(((

O"++#0",&*14$70"#:)•! )DGFM789F8LM7;(]DDG9JI7G@MD@MFKG78;(7:]@TD9LN?:D8M;(O@F@D(DMNC()J&44&"P+6178":(•! /KH7OD85(IDGFM789;(FMD9DG@>JD(D8(G789FNQ7KKDG@>JD(LKH7OD8;(N?GM??EQ@FMLE@D;(

@8K7FF@8H(@8`E7FME?NM??E(D8(9@>JC(•! 0@FF@D5(L87g78JDG@>JD(MLDMF@8H;(L89DEFMD?8D8(LK9E7NQMHDODEF(]@>(:7JD8(

JD?PDF5(]@>OC(I77E(IDG(D8(I77E(8@DM(:DDE(@8ODFMDED8C(.79D8JD8(LODE(ODE9@D8:L9DGGD8(^G789FNQ7KKD8(O78(7GG?ED_C((

•! 'DD8(L8MIDEKD89D(ELGC(•! 3LGGDNTD`(HDQD?HD8(]DQDED8C(•! XE@F(QL?9D8(O78(KEL>DNMD8;(KEL>DNMLEH78@F7TDF(DMNC(•! #@NQT8H(HDOD8(778(QDM(MLM77GC(•! !7J@8QL?9DG@>JD(]DHDGD@9@8H;(JG78J]LE9C(•! *I7G@MD@M(@F(HDD8(G?fD;(QDM(GLL8MC(•! 4DGKD8(L:(:D8FD8(MD(]DHDGD@9D8(]@>(QDM(OLLEFMDGGD8(QLD(@DMF(DE?@M(H77M(P@D8C((J""#%77#0")W)2"73:)•! ,8MDHE77GC(•! 'DD8(]DG78H;(KLG@TDJ(JGD?EGLLFC(•! $T:?GDED89D(`?8NTD5(JI7G@MD@M;(F7:D8(877E(LKGLFF@8HC(•! 'DQD?HD8([(FK@DHDG([`E@FFD(]G@JC((B7*07Q.246/*2"*)8++#)."2)"R"Q5"S)708&4"#"*:)•! /87g78JDG@>JQD@9(@F(]DG78HE@>J(•! 4LD5('DD8(9E?J;(HDD8(E?HHDFKE77J;(OE@>(OLDGD8(L:(79O@DF(MD(HDOD8C(

!DEMEL?ID8(8L9@HC(/87g78JDG@>JD(GD9D85(+DG78HDGLLF;(OE@>D(KLF@TD;(@8MDHDE;(NL:KGD:D8M7@EC(

•! 077E(LLJ5(QDM(79O@DF(:LDM(L87g78JDG@>J(P@>8;(8@DM(KDE(FD(9D(GD9D8C(((((

KCe(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

)()VERSLAG WERKSESSIE GROEP 3 TF)D9<K!<)GUCB?<D)))•! /ODEQD@9(]G@>n(HDD8(LK9E7NQMHDODEC(•! ,8@T7TDOD8(G?JJD8(OLLE7G(9LLE(KEL`DFF@L87GF(DE]@>(MD(]DMEDJJD8C(•! "NLGLH@FNQ(9??EP77:C(((

VF)D9<K!<)@G==<D))(•! /ODEQD@9(:LDM(FT:?GDED85(778>7HDE;(QDG9DE(778FKEDDJK?8M;(

9DFJ?89@HD8;(O@F@D(^HDP7:D8G@>J_C(

KC<A(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

)()VERSLAG WERKSESSIE GROEP 4 >F! ?GG@AH<=@GD;<)'DFKEDJFGD@9DE5(07ET>8(/LFMDEQ?@F(RDDG8D:DEF5(R78@DGGD(.@D9DEDE;(/88L(!G7789DED8;()@:(O78(!DDGD8;(&8HDG@p?D(0DEHGDE;("HL8(*?NQGD@8;(4@G9D(*GLLFMDEP@DG;(3QE@FT78(+E77J;(478F($M7GGDEC((;")0"",*"3"#4)8"#2"1"*%++#0&1"*)0")8+,1"*0")$%7,&2"&242"734:)<C! RD(3D8ME7GD(&F(l(XEaFGq8(=C! R?@8(D8(+LFNQ(37FME@N?:(BC! ,8ODE978(YC! 6778l,-(ZC! RD8(4DG9DE(bC! /LFMP778((

IF);<)E!B=9H<9HAH<BJAL)9DH@G;KMH9<)<D)?<@C<=9NE9DC))(H"73473"*42",,&*1:)("fKDETFD5(L87g78JDG@>J(7ENQ@MDNM;(L87g78JDG@>J(FMD9D8]L?IJ?89@HD;(L87g78JDG@>J(G789FNQ7KF7ENQ@MDNM;(ODEMDHD8ILLE9@HDEF(IDGFM789(D8(7:]MDG@>JD(LEH78@F7TDFC(/K9E7NQMHDODEF5(SS$;(S?]G@DJD(FDNMLEC((B7#0)87*)0")%"#$(773."0"*)"*)0")708&4"#&*1:)(•! &9O@FDE@8H5(L87g78JDG@>JD(GD9D8(]DG78HE@>JC(•! !7FM(J79DE(:DM(>?E@9@FNQD(FM7M?F(OLLE7`(O7FMGDHHD8C(•! /K(T>9(]DMELJJD8(ILE9D8(^OELDH;(O787`(QDM(]DH@8(O78(DD8(KELNDF_C(•! &:]MDG@>JD(ODEMDHD8ILLE9@H@8H(D8(FMD?8(]DG78HE@>J(L:(E?H(EDNQM(MD(

J?88D8(QL?9D8C((

(((

KC<<(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

•! !7FM(E@M:D(O78(ODEH79DED8C(•! RDFJ?89@HD8(@8(MD7:(9@D8D8(]@>(UD@HD8V(9DFJ?89@HQD@9(MD(]G@>OD8C(•! 3L::?8@N7TD(D8(FNQDMFO77E9@HQD@9(]DG78HE@>J()O"++#0",&*14$70"#:)•! )DGFM789F8LM7;(]DDG9JI7G@MD@MFKG78;(7:]@TD9LN?:D8M;(O@F@D(DMNC()J&44&"P+6178":(•! XE@FFD(]G@J(]DG78HE@>JC(•! %78HD(MDE:@>8(@8(9D(H7MD8(QL?9D8(^HDIDMD8_C(•! ,8MDHE7GD(]G@JC(•! &`PL89DEG@>JD(JGD@8D(KG788D8(7`FMD::D8(l(r($7:D8Q78HC(•! +DIL8DEFK7ETN@K7TD(L`(]DIL8DEF]DG78H(:DD8D:D8C(•! !@8HDE(79C(SLGFC($@H87GDED8(D8(DE(I7M(:DD(9LD8C((J""#%77#0")W)2"73:)•! 0DDM]77EQD@9(EDF?GM7MD8(9LLE5(

•! 3L8F@FMD8TD(HD]@D9(^E?@:MDG@>JD(JI7G@MD@MF8@OD7?(D8(F7:D8Q78H_(•! )DEJD8(:DM(:@8@:7GD(JI7G@MD@M(^9ED:KDG_(

(B7*07Q.246/*2"*)8++#)."2)"R"Q5"S)708&4"#"*:)•! &:]@TD(@F(8L9@H;(:77E(>D(J?8M(QDM(8@DM(7`9I@8HD8C(.@DM(LODE7G(@F(F7:D8IDEJ@8H(

D8(LODEGDH(O78PDG`FKEDJD89(M?FFD8(9D(ODEFNQ@GGD89D(]DG78HQD]]D89D8(D8(LEH78@F7TDFC(

•! 6LEHK?8MD85(/89DEQL?9(D8(]DQDDE(D8(LKD8]7ED(E?@:MD(((((

)()VERVOLG VERSLAG WERKSESSIE GROEP 4 (((((((

((((((

((((((((((((

((

KC<=(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

(TF)D9<K!<)GUCB?<D)(•! &78K7FFD8(778(OE77H(HDFM??E9D(:7EJMC(•! /:H778(:DM(T>9DG@>JQD@9(O78(HD]E?@JC(•! +DFM??EG@>JD(I@G(]DG78HE@>JC(()VF)D9<K!<)@G=)P)O9N;@BC<)W)H<BJA(•! 0DDE(:DD9D8JD8(778(9D(OLLEJ78MC(•! *D88@F(O78(ME78F`LE:7TDKELNDFFD8C(•! "8H7HD:D8M(O78(MD7:GD9D8(8DM(PL(]DG78HE@>J(7GF(O7JJD88@FC(

XF)D9<K!<)@G=)P)O9N;@BC<)GDH!<@U<D;<);9AM9U=9D<A:)•! +@>9E7HD(778(@9D8TMD@MFOLE:@8HC(•! &89DED(9DFJ?89@HQD9D8(^8@DM(L8MIDEKD89_(778O?GGD89C(•! #?@:DED(]G@J(978(D@HD8(O77E9@HQD@9(8L9@HC(•! i(MD7:F(HD:DD8MD85(77897NQM(OLLE(LKD8]7ED(E?@:MD;(@8NGC(LKD8]7ED(

E?@:MDlL8MIDEKDE(@8(MD7:;(I78M(LKD8]7ED(E?@:MD(@F(HD:DD8MDG@>JD(ODE78MILLE9DG@>JQD@9C(

•! 1LDOLDHD8(NL::?8@N7TDlFKDN@7G@FM(@8(QDM(MD7:C()YF)BBD;BMZHAGUKDH)?GG@);<)HG<EGJAH:)•! +?EHDEF(7GF(LK9E7NQMHDODE(L8HDID8FMC(RDPD(J@>JD8(978(7GGDD8(977E(QDM(

KEL>DNM(97M(Q?8(778H77MC((

(

)() (

(

KCe(KCe(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B((()

;<<=)I:)AHBH<J<DHAL)MGDM=KA9<AL)B;?9<[<D)(

(

)()

AHBH<J<DHA)))A272"3"*24)"*)Q+*Q,/4&"4)8++#7S177*0)77*)0")%"#$4"44&"4:))Z"2)-"++#0","*)"*)3""0"*$"*)\!&3)87*)?"","*]:)<C! +DLLE9DGD8(H77M(@8(9D(MLDJL:FM(:DDE(LODE(]?F@8DFF(N7FDF;(

:@89DE(7GGDD8(LODE(DD8(KG78C(=C! 0DDE(GLFFD(@8@T7TDOD8(9?F(:DDE(8LL9P77J(L:(F7:D8Q78H(MD(

L8MI@JJDGD8C(BC! 0DD9D8JD8(HDE@NQM(LK(I77E9D(NED7TD(^K?]G@DJ;(KE@O77M;(

E?@:MDG@>J;(O7FMHLD9_(YC! 0DDE(:DD9D8JD8(@8(QDM(KELNDF;(:@89DE(DE877FMC()^/*Q5+*"#"*)87*)$%7,&2"&242"734)\+*0"#(+"$]:)<C! "D8(MD7:(@F(DsDNTDODE(7GF(9D(>?@FMD(NL:KDMD8TDF(P@>8(ODED8@H9;(

NL8`LE:(9D(9E@D(/VF(O78(QDM(FKDDGODG95(/8MIDEK;(/:HDO@8H(D8(/K9E7NQMC(

!",427*0)"*)/&28+"#&*141"#&Q.2")2"734)\^"0"#75")@/&32",&'$")$%7,&2"&2]:)<C! )DGFM789F79O@DF(JL:M(MD(G77M(@8(KELNDFFD8C(=C! *&.(]DK7G@8H(GLLKM(PLV8(O77EM(8@DM5(7:]MD87ED8(P@\D8(8@DM(MD(

I7NQMD8(LK(QDM(]DLLE9DGD8(O78(DD8(P@DJD8Q?@F(D8(789DED(HD]L?ID8(@8(Q?8(NL8MDfMC(

BC! +@>(LKH7OD8(PL?(:DDE(77897NQM(:LDMD8(P@>8(OLLE(U:DDJLKKDGD89D(]DG78HD8VC(R@M(HDG9M(]@>OLLE]DDG9(OLLE(@8`E7FME?NM??ELKH7OD8;(I77E(L8MI@JJDG@8HD8(]ED9DE(P@>8(978(7GGDD8(QDM(7F`7GMC("E(O7GM(ODDG(JI7G@MD@M(MD(]DQ7GD8(9LLE(]ED9DE(877E(@8`E7FME?NM??ELKH7OD8(MD(J@>JD8C(R@M(J78(:DM(JI7G@MD@MFMD7:F;(I78M(9DPD(P@>8(HDE@NQM(LK(Fa8DEH@DC(

))(

(

KC<Y(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

)()

AHBH<J<DHA))(

KC<Z(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

G31"8&*14%"2)"*)$%7,&2"&242"734)\J++&%77#24]:)<C! 'LD9D(L:HDO@8HFJI7G@MD@M(@F(QDM(9LDG(O78(9D(L:HDO@8HFIDMC(RD(

8@D?ID(IDM(]@D9M(ODDG(E?@:MD5(7:]@TDF(J?88D8(HELLM(ILE9D8(HD`LE:?GDDE9C(6D(]@D9M(DNQMDE(LLJ(9D(E?@:MD(OLLE(ID@8@H(L`(HDD8(7:]@TDF(LK(QDM(HD]@D9(O78(E?@:MDG@>JD(JI7G@MD@MC(

=C! 3#&5(79O@FDDEM(L:(QDM(JI7G@MD@MF]DHE@K(E?@:DE(MD(Q78MDED8C((BC! XD9DE7TD(#?@:MDG@>JD(JI7G@MD@M(79O@FDDEM(L:(DD8(L:HDO@8HFO@F@D(

ODEKG@NQM(MD(FMDGGD8(OLLE(HD:DD8MD8;(@8NG?F@D`(DD8(79O@DFNL::@FF@D(9@D(ODEKG@NQM(LODE(9D(L:HDO@8HFJI7G@MD@M(]DLLE9DDGMC(

@/&32",&'$")$%7,&2"&2)"*)@/&32",&'$")E%7,&2"&242"734)\<#&$)=/&2"*]:)<C! +DMEDn(7GT>9(QDM(EDF?GM77M(HD9DDG9(9LLE(9D(:@99DGD8C(=C! RD(E?@:MDG@>JD(JI7G@MD@M(O78(QDM(G789FNQ7K(D8(9D(79LE7TD(O78(

QDM(G789FNQ7K(P@>8(@8(.D9DEG789(MDE?H(MD(OLDED8(LK(DD8(G78H(OLGHDQL?9D8(DD8QD@9(O78(Q789DGD8(D8(DD8(DO@9D8MD(UPDG`ODEJG7ED89D(MLKLHE7tDVC(,8(QDM(]DI7JD8(O78(9DPD(JI7G@MD@M(G@HM(DD8(]DG78HE@>JD(ELG(OLLE(JI7G@MD@MFMD7:F(^/8PD(J@89DED8(:LDMD8(QDM(LODE(ZA(>77E(LLJ(8LH(]DHE@>KD8_C(

BC! *I7G@MD@MFMD7:F(J?88D8(]@>9E7HD8(778(QDM(OLLEJL:D8(97M(KELHE7::7uF(D8(LKH7OD8(@8(9D(MLDJL:FM(O78?@M(DD8(L89DEQ789DG@8H(:DM(9D(F7:D8GDO@8H(HDFM7GMD(JE@>HD8C(

YC! RD(L87g78JDG@>JD(D8(HDP7HQD]]D89D(KLF@TD(O78(i(MD7:F(@F(DFFD8TDDGC(

ZC! *I7G@MD@MF]LEH@8H(@8(E?@:MDG@>JD(KG78OLE:@8H(OE77HM(:DDE(77897NQM(D8(DD8(HEL89@HDE(ME7>DNMC(

(((((

MGDM=KA9<A)!<@EA<AA9<A))())))))))

G6178"*)8++#)0")2+"$+342)0&")8#71"*)+3)$%7,&2"&24-+#1&*1:)

)=7*04Q.766",&'$")+6178"*:)•! /KH7OD8(OLLEMJL:D89(?@M(QDM(RDGM7KELHE7::7(^I7MDE:7NQ@8D_C(•! #@O@DEL8MI@JJDG@8HD8C(•! R@>JD8KELHE7::7;(QDM(ODEFMDEJD8(O78(9D(9@>JD8C(•! &`FG?@M9@>JC(

•! "NLGLH@DC(•! !DEO78H@8HFLKH7OD(87\D(J?8FMIDEJD8C(•! "8DEH@DME78F@TDC()A2"0",&'$")+6178"*:)•! $MD9DG@>JD(GLN7TDF(I77E(?EHD8TD(@FC(•! )@8JDGHD]@D9D8(

•! *78MLED8GLN7TDF(•! %DDHFM789(•! *E@:K(•! 4DE]DFMD::@8H(•! 4DEFME?NM?EDE@8H(

))(

)

)()

KC<b(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

@+,)$%7,&2"&242"734)&*)0")2+"$+342:))•! /LE9DDGFOLE:@8H(9LLE(HDP7HQD]]D89D(9DFJ?89@HD8C(•! !DE@tDDE]7ED(LLE9DDGFOLE:@8HC(•! /KH7OD8(@8(DD8(HELMDE(ODE]789(KG77MFD8C(•! 0@89DE(7:]MDG@>J;(:DDE(P@NQM]77E(OLLE(QDM(K?]G@DJC(

•! ,8MDHE7MLE(E?@:MDG@>JD(D8(K?]G@DJD(I77E9D8C(•! ,8MDHEDED89;(]LOD8(FDNMLE77G;(KE7H:7TFNQ(D8(NL8MDfM?DDGC(•! /89DEFMD?8D8(O78(DD8(@8@T7TD`8D:DE(L:(P@>8(@9DD(PL(HLD9(:LHDG@>J(

OLE:(MD(HDOD8C(•! 0DDE(E?@:MDG@>J(DNL8L:@FNQD(DfKDEMFC(•! !DEE@>JD8;(`7N@G@MDED8;(NL::?8@NDED8;(LODEM?@HD8(D8(]DGL8D8C(

•! 0DDE(NL8NDKMD8(L8MI@JJDGD8C(•! 0DDE(F7:D8IDEJ@8H(D8(@8MDE7NTDC(3L::?8@N7TD(:DM(K?]G@DJC(•! "D8(JI7G@MD@MFMD7:(OLE:M(9D(NL8T8?D(`7NMLEC(4DM(HDIDMD8(O78(DD8(

HD]@D9(LK(KELNDFC(

))(

)

)()

B;?9<[<D)DBB@)BBD=<9;9DC)?BD);<)!<@EA<AA9<A))))B08&"("*)77*)#/&32",&'$")$%7,&2"&242"734:)

)

<C! )DDF(PLEHO?G9@H(:DM(QDM(HDOD8(O78(9D(877:(UJI7G@MD@MFMD7:VC(

RD8J(HLD9(87(L`(QDM(MD7:(OLG9LD89D((L87g78JDG@>J(@F;(

HDP7HQD]]D89(@F(D8(9D(877:(JI7G@MD@MFMD7:(ODE9@D8MC(

=C! 4DM(]DLLE9DGD8(H77M(@8(9D(MLDJL:FM(:DDE(LODE(]?F@8DFFN7FDF(978(

7GGDD8(LODE(KG788D8C()DDF(Q@DELK(OLLE]DED@9(D8(PLEH(OLLE(9D(

>?@FMD(MD7:F7:D8FMDGG@8H;(]@>OLLE]DDG9(9LLE(KG78DNL8L:D8(MD(

]DMEDJJD8(L`(789DED(O7J9DFJ?89@HQD@9;(K7FFD89(]@>(9D(LKH7OD8;(

9@D(FKDGD8C(/LJ(J?88D8(UH7FMVGD9D8(]@>9E7HD8(778(DD8(DOD8I@NQTH((((

(((((((MD7:(D8(79O@DFC(

BC! RD(MLDJL:FM(P7G(GD@9D8(MLM(:DDE(GLFFD(@8@T7TDOD8C(((

*I7G@MD@MFMD7:F(J?88D8(]@>9E7HD8(F7:D8Q78H(MD(]DI7JD8C(

YC! 6LEH(97M(>D(J?8M(L:H778(:DM(T>9DG@>JQD@9(D8(PLEH(OLLE(JD88@F(O78(

ME78F`LE:7TDKELNDFFD8C(

ZC! 6LEH(OLLE(DD8(@8MDHDE(MD7:C(6LEH(OLLE(ODEMEL?ID8(D8(9E77HOG7JC(

bC! $NQ?@`(OELDH(@8(QDM(KELNDF(778C(

(

)

(

KC<c(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

cC(((+ED8H(DDEFM(9D(E789OLLEI77E9D8(LK(LE9D5(J79DE;(>?@FMD(DfKDETFD;((

(((((((L87g78JDG@>J(>7[8DDC(((

dC((((6LEH(OLLE(DD8(NL:KGD:D8M7@E(MD7:5(p?7(DfKDETFD;(:77E(LLJ(@8(

(((((((HD9E7H;(D8(NL::?8@N7TDOD(O77E9@HQD9D8C((

eC! 6LEH(OLLE(MD7:GD9D8(:DM(HLD9D(NL::?8@N7TDOD(O77E9@HQD9D8C(

<AC! "D8(JI7G@MD@MFMD7:(@F(HDD8(L8MIDEKMD7:C(6D(9D8JM(:DD;(@F(

(((((((778>7HDE;(9E77HM(]@>(778(9D(@9D8TMD@MFl(D8(LLE9DDGFOLE:@8H(D8(

(((((((9E77HM(PLEH(OLLE(F7:D8Q78H(]@>(GLFFD(@8@T7TDOD8C(

<<C((6LEH(OLLE(DD8(MD7:(:DM(DD8(UE?@:D(]G@JV;(I77E9LLE(ODE]789D8(

(((((((J?88D8(ILE9D8(HDGDH9(D8(7GMDE87TDOD8(D8(8?78ND(HDMLL89C(

<=C(RE77H(]@>(778(MLDJL:FTHD(LKH7OD8(D8(K7F(?I(QL?9@8H(778C(0@89DE((

((((((7?MLE@M7@E(D8(MLDMFD89;(:DDE(:DD9D8JD89C(

<BC("DEFM(L8MI@JJDG@8HFE@NQT8H(778HDOD8;(]DFMD::@8H(OLGHMC(

<YC(%77M(P@D8(97M(DD8(MD7:(LLJ(HDG9(J78(LKGDODED8C(

)

)()O9N=BC<D))

+@>G7HD(<5(($KDDNQ(RD88@F($ME77M(

+@>G7HD(=5((SEDFD8M7TD(L89DEPLDJ(U#?@:MDG@>JD(*I7G@MD@MFMD7:F(@8(.D9DEG789V;($789E7(O78(&FFD8(D8(-LFW(O78(37:KD8C(

+@>G7HD(B5((SEDFD8M7TD(XG@K(MD8(37MD(

+@>G7HD(Y5((SEDFD8M7TD("E@N(%?@MD8(

+@>G7HD(Z5((SEDFD8M7TD()@:(O78(!DDGD8(())

)

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

AU<<MZ))!<HZGK;<@)C<J<<DH<)[BBDAHB;);<DD9A)AH@BBH))(()!",$+342%++#0)"*)*+5"4)(((4DM(]DG78H(O78(JI7G@MD@MFMD7:F(D8(F?KDEO@FLEFNQ7K(@F(P@NQM]77E(]@>(9D(L8MI@JJDG@8HD8(9@D(@8(6778FM79(KG77MFO@89D8C(R@M(FKDDGM(OLLE7G(@8(QDM(ND8ME?:KG78(,8ODE978(DD8(HELMD(ELGC(/89DE(GD@9@8H(O78(F?KDEO@FLE($>LDE9($LDMDEF(@F(DD8(79O@DFMD7:(7NTD`C(((/LJ(@8(QDM(6778,-(/8MI@JJDG@8HFKG78(@F(DD8(F?KDEO@FLE;(XE@MF(S7G:]LL:;(7NTD`C(4@>(FM??EM(778(9D(OLLEJ78M(D8(79O@FDDEM(LODE(9D(@8@T7TDOD8(D8(KEL>DNMD8(D8(9LDM(9@M(877FM(QDM(79O@DFMD7:C((()@>(QD]]D8(:DM(,8ODE978(8LH(8DM(QDM(:L:D8M?:(J?88D8(:DDK7JJD8;(:77E(DD8(HDHDOD8(@F(97M(HELLMFNQ7G@HD(:7FMDEKG788D8(D8(L:O78HE@>JD(HD]@D9FL8MI@JJDG@8HD8(D8(KEL>DNMD8(OLLEGLK@H(MLM(QDM(ODEGD9D8(]DQLED8C(R@M(P7G(:@FFNQ@D8(G78HDE(9?ED8(978(L8F(G@D`(@FC()D(P?GGD8(MDE?H(H778(877E(DD8(LEH78@FNQD(L8MI@JJDG@8H(O78(9D(FM79(9@D(HD]7FDDE9(@F(LK(9D(NL8NEDMD(]DQLDnD(D8(OE77HC(RD(:7EJM(@F(8@DM(G78HDE(778]L9(HDFM??E9C(((+@88D8(6778,-(]DO@89M(P@NQ(QDM(4D:]E?HMDEED@8;(9D(]DG78HE@>JFMD(QDEL8MI@JJDG@8H(O78(9@M(:L:D8MC(/8HDODDE(YZ(QDNM7ED(OLLE:7G@H(9D`D8F@DMDEED@8(ILE9M(HD`7FDDE9(L8MI@JJDG9(9LLE(QDM(#@>JF(!7FMHLD9(D8(/8MI@JJDG@8HF]D9E@>`C((((

)

((((!!

)

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

"D8(N?GM??EQ@FMLE@FNQD(&87GaFD(D8(+DDG9JI7G@MD@MFKG78(G@HHD8(MD8(HEL89FG7H(778(DD8(L8MI@JJDGJ79DE(:DM(DD8(QLHD(HE779(O78(kDf@]@G@MD@MC(4@DE@8(@F(LLJ(ODDG(KG77MF(@F(OLLE(T>9DG@>JQD@9(9@D(:7f@:77G(<A(>77E(:7H(9?ED8C((R77E(L8MFM77M(9D(?@M97H@8H(QLD(9D(JI7G@MD@M(MD(I77E]LEHD8(L`(>?@FM(LK(KG77MFD8(DD8(T>9>D(GLF(MD(G7MD8(L:(9D(L8MI@JJDG@8H(8@DM(MD(ED::D8C((((R77E877FM(P@>8(I@>(@8(9DPD(FM79(LLJ(]DP@H(:DM(9D(4DEOLE:@8HF7HD897(O78(6778FM79C(4DM(879D8JD8(LODE(L8PD(ELG(7GF(HD:DD8MD(D8(9@D(LLJ(LK8@D?I(?@MO@89D8C(((4DM(UL8MFG7JJD8V(O78(7GGDEGD@(KELND9?EDGD(J8DGK?8MD8(D8(QDM(GLFG7MD8(O78(HD:DD8MDG@>JD(EDHDGHDO@8H(D8(PDG`F(IDGFM789F]DGD@9(]DQLED8(977E]@>C()D(P@D8(]@>OLLE]DDG9(T>9DG@>JQD@9(7GF(DD8(@8(MD(PD\D8(FME7MDH@D(L:(9D(FM79(@8(]DIDH@8H(MD(QL?9D8C(()@>(:7JD8(]DI?FMD(JD?PDF(OLLE(QDM(FT:?GDED8(O78(@8@T7TDOD8(9@D(]@>9E7HD8(778(]??EM;(I@>J(D8(FM79C(0DM(DD8(:@8@:?:(778(]DGD::DE@8HD8C()@>(:7JD8(LLJ(]DI?FMD(JD?PDF(OLLE(HD]@D9D8(9@D(PDDE(J78FE@>J(P@>8(OLLE(L8MI@JJDG@8HD8;(LLJ(8?(@8(9DPD(T>9(O78(EDG7TDOD(FTGFM789(O78(HD]@D9FL8MI@JJDG@8HC(4@DE(P?GGD8(L8PD(@8FK788@8HD8(@8MD8F@DODE(P@>8C((((()())))(

)()

)

!!

)

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

?<@?G=C)AU<<MZ))!<HZGK;<@);<DD9A)AH@BBH))((U,F(GLFG7MD8(DEHm(,F(T>9DG@>JQD@9(DD8(HDO77E(OLLE(JI7G@MD@MmV(((!E7HD8(I77E(?(P@NQ(O78977H(IDGG@NQM(LLJ(:DD(]DP@H(:LDM(QL?9D8C()7M(@F(9D(ELG(O78(JI7G@MD@MFMD7:F(@8(9D(MLDJL:FM;(I788DDE(P@>8(PD(DsDNTD`m()DGG@NQM(@F(97M(778(9D(OLLEJ78M(O78(KELNDFFD8;(]@>(QDM(@8@T7TD`v(((4LD(]DLLE9DDG(>D(KG788D8(9@D(@8(ME78F`LE:7TDHD]@D9D8(ID@8@H(ED`DED8TD(D8(@9D8TMD@M(J?88D8(L8MGD8D8(778(QDM(ODEGD9D8C(0DM(HD]L?ID8(9@D(G78HP77:778(ODE9I@>8D8C(,F(DGJD(8@D?I]L?I(978(HLD9(D8(:LL@m((R@M(P@>8(?@M97HD89D(OE7HD8;(I77ELK(@J(QLLK(97M(?(9DPD(97H(DD8(78MILLE9(P?GM(L8M9DJJD8C((((

!"#$%#&'(

&(

STERKESTEDENBOUW

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Sandra van Assen & José van Campen Werkbijeenkomst 12 juni 2013

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

Vandaag…

Werkbijeenkomst! Uitvoeringsgerichte kwaliteitsteams Onderzoek januari 2012 – december 2013 Organisatie bijeenkomst: Gemeente Zaanstad en Federatie Welstand

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

Presentatie:

1.! Het onderzoek

2.! Onderzoeksportfolio

3.! Enkele bevindingen

4.! Vragen voor vandaag

1. Het onderzoek

)()

)

(

)

U@<A<DHBH9<)NGA_)?BD)MBJU<D)<D)ABD;@B)?BD)BAA<D)GD;<@[G<E)@K9JH<=9NE<)E!B=9H<9HAH<BJA)9D)D=`)a>()(((((

(

!"#$%#&'(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

!"#$%#&'(

!(

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Betrokkenen

•! Onderzoeksteam •! Inspirator

•! Begeleidingscommissie •! Stimuleringsfonds

•! Organisatoren werkbijeenkomsten

•! Deelnemers werkbijeenkomsten •! Schrijvers essays •! Filmteam

Q team Duivenvoorde (film), deelnemers werkbijeenkomst gebiedsgerichte teams (2x), Begeleidingsgroep, Q team Regio G-A

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Aanleiding, waarom onderzoek? •!! !Observatie: K-teams ‘verschijnen’ steeds vaker in planvorming •! Vrijheid van werken, toegespitst op opgave (i.t.t.

welstandscommissie) •! Nauwelijks onderzoek, nauwelijks uitwisseling van ervaring •! Betekenis voor ruimtelijke kwaliteit onduidelijk

•! Werkwijze voor buitenstaanders een ‘black box’

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

‘verschijnen’ steeds vaker in

Vrijheid van werken, toegespitst op opgave (i.t.t.

Nauwelijks onderzoek, nauwelijks uitwisseling van

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Doelen van het onderzoek Inzicht verkrijgen in: •! Betekenis voor ontwerpproces

•! Inzet teams, wanneer, hoe, kosten? •! Effectiviteit, kan het beter?

•! Zichtbaarder maken van teams & praktijk

•! Praktische adviezen regie ruimtelijke kwaliteit! ((

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Definitie (Ruimtelijk kwaliteitsteam: •! Multidisciplinair team van meerdere deskundigen

m.b.t. ruimtelijke kwaliteit. •! Vaak zijn de deskundigen onafhankelijk en aangesteld

op persoonlijke titel. •! Doel van een ruimtelijk kwaliteitsteam is het

stimuleren en/of borgen van de ruimtelijke kwaliteit door middel van advisering aan beleidsvormende en/of uitvoerende partijen.

•! Benoemd en gefinancierd door een of meerdere private en/of publieke partijen.

! (((

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

meerdere deskundigen

en aangesteld

)()

)

(

)

U@<A<DHBH9<)NGA_)?BD)MBJU<D)<D)ABD;@B)?BD)BAA<D)`)aI()(((((

(

!"#$%#&'(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

!"#$%#&'(

'(

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Raakvlakken Hors categorie:

•! Task force of aanjaagteam (geen planadvisering of beoordelingen)

! Geen team: •! stadsarchitect, supervisor, previsor of

gemandateerde met ambtelijke ondersteuning

•! welstandscommissie met alleen architecten •! ontwerpatelier (gericht op ontwerpen) •! jury/beoordelingscommissie ! Twijfelgevallen: •! supervisieteams •! brede commissies ruimtelijke kwaliteit •! interne (ambtelijke) teams (((((

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

force of aanjaagteam (geen planadvisering of beoordelingen)

stadsarchitect, supervisor, previsor of gemandateerde met ambtelijke ondersteuning

Taskplanadvisering of beoordelingen)

Geen team: stadsarchitect, supervisor, gemandateerde met ambtelijke ondersteuning

welstandscommissie met alleen architecten ontwerpatelier (gericht op ontwerpen)jury/beoordelingscommissie

Twijfelgevallen:

•

Twijfelgevallen:

••

•

•••

Twijfelgevallen:

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

Categorieën! ! Categorieën:

•! Uitvoeringsgericht •! Gebiedsgericht

•! Themagericht

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Uitvoeringsgericht kwaliteitsteam

!(

een uitvoeringsgericht kwaliteitsteam bewaakt de ruimtelijke ambities van een stedenbouwkundig, infrastructureel en/of landschappelijk plan en begeleidt en beoordeelt de afzonderlijke ontwerpen op hun bijdrage aan de ruimtelijke kwaliteit van het plangebied als geheel. ((

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Gebiedsgericht kwaliteitsteam

een gebiedsgericht kwaliteitsteam is een stuwende kracht tussen de (democratisch vastgestelde) visie en de uiteenlopende (geplande en spontane) initiatieven van private en publieke partijen in een cyclisch proces. ! ((

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

een gebiedsgericht kwaliteitsteam is een stuwende kracht tussen de (democratisch vastgestelde) visie en de uiteenlopende (geplande en spontane) initiatieven van private en publieke

)()

)

(

)

U@<A<DHBH9<)NGA_)?BD)MBJU<D)<D)ABD;@B)?BD)BAA<D)`)aT()(((((

(

!"#$%#&'(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

!"#$%#&'(

"(

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

Themagericht kwaliteitsteam

!(

een themagericht kwaliteitsteam is een bron van kennis en ervaring over het betreffende thema en begeleidt initiatiefnemers naar een oplossing met optimale ruimtelijke kwaliteit. ((

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

Voorbeeld

Kwaliteitsteam Duivenvoordecorridor

Filmflits:

!!!!!!!!!!

!

)*+,--.../0123245/617-.836)9:5832;5<+=805;>?538@=+8A5BC<C#DEFGH!1@IJ3<!'%K(((((

"#$%&#'!%()!(*!++$!,-.+&/($01!%(+!2+&0)!$(+)!($!3451!%6*!#/*!2+!7(8.9+*!2(//+$!/#)+$!:(+$!8;+)+$!2+!33<=:+/>!?+@&6(0+$A!B+!#CDE++&)!F8!E(#!&+A86(*0/(0'!,-.+&/($0!;.+$+$A!B+!0;8)!%#$!($!-;6)6@+=.#?!E#$!G($#!H;;0!#/!%;+!(0!%+!/($0!E(#!;$:+!*()+I!+$!8;+)!%#$!%(&+C)!*C,+&8!E+&?&;)+$A!!!J0!,+@!:+!@+(%+$!;.!/+60!8;8+$)!8(%%+$!($!%+!K/8!?+:+)'!!=!%+:+!E#$!LAMN!);)!OAMP!H:+/>!*);..+$1!%;+)!(+!$(+)!#6);8#D*C,I!#!E;/?+$%+!E#$!PAMP!);)!QAPP!!!!4()!#//+8##/!+E+$!;+>+$+$!2;+$*%#?8;&?+$!($!R##$*)#%A!!

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

Voorbeeld

Kwaliteitsteam Regio Groningen-Assen

Filmflits:

!!!!!!!!!!

!

)*+,--.../0123245/617-.836)9:5832;5<+=805;>?538@=+8A5BC<+#.L5M4NF6AJ3<"HK((((

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

Voorbeeld

Ervenconsulenten

Film: binnenkort op www.ruimtelijkekwaliteitsteams.nl

!!!!!!!!!!

!

www.ruimtelijkekwaliteitsteams.nl

(((

)()

)

(

)

U@<A<DHBH9<)NGA_)?BD)MBJU<D)<D)ABD;@B)?BD)BAA<D)`)aV()(((((

(

!"#$%#&'(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

!"#$%#&'(

)(

2. Onderzoeksportfolio

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Inventarisatie

februari 2013: 122 teams

(((((((

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

Werkbijeenkomsten

(

Deelnemers werkbijeenkomst gebiedsgerichte teams

n

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Profielen: gefilmd en op papier

!"#$!"#$%&'#())*+'#%&#%,%&+$-!&.#/-.!/0#0.&01+,,&0

2!/3#&'

!"#$%&&'#(')*#+,-."/0'1)%&'(%(')*%)+,-.''/(0%1',/))1+%'2%321',/))1+0%3,'/%''2%4/''+%.5)6)%32(7'/8,/))1.(9::'2%'2%/9-*('6-;:'%(<'*)=.%4-22'2%<'(%7'/:1'4-'+%,)2%+'%/'1-3,-.-'%!/32-21'2%>..'2?%&'(%@7)6-('-(.(')*%)+,-.''/(%32)A<)2:'6-;:%'2%-2('1/))6?%B'%4-;''2:3*.('2%C-;2%-2%8/-25-8'%38'24))/%'2%,-2+'2%)A<)2:'6-;:%,)2%+'%(<'*)(-':%'2%+'%D)1'2+)+/9:('=%38%,'/.5<-66'2+'%86'::'2%-2%+'%/'1-3%86))(.?%E-;+'2.%+'%4-;''2:3*.('2%73/+'2%-2%''2%384397'2+'0%5366'1-)6'%+-)6331%+'%)+,-'.,/)1'2%'2%(<'*)=.%4'.8/3:'2?%B'%)+,-'C'2%C-;2%1/)(-.%'2%73/+'2%)6(-;+%38%.5</-A(%9-(1'4/)5<(0%*''.()6%4-22'2%(7''%7':'2?%2'-3,-$'#4'('#1)%&'(%@7)6-('-(.(')*%)+,-.''/(%4/''+%'2%+-,'/.F%,)2%+'%86)22'2%,33/%+'%<'/G32(7-::'6-21%,)2%''2%+3/8.5'2(/9*%3A%+'%))26'1%,)2%''2%4-22'2<),'2%(3(%)+,-'C'2%3,'/%+'%'5323*-.5<'%)1'2+)%,)2%+'%/'1-30%(/)5H.%,)2%2-'97'%8/3G,-25-)6'%7'1'20%1'*''2('6-;:'%.(/95(99/86)22'2%'2%7332,-.-'.%3A%+'%<'/-;:G-21%,)2%+'%/'1-32)6'%732-214397)A.8/):'2?%&'(%(')*%)+,-.''/(%38%4).-.%,)2%,)::'22-.0%'/,)/-21%'2%3,'/(9-1-21.:/)5<(0%2-'(%38%4).-.%,)2%A3/*'6'%D*)5<(=?%B-(%/'.96(''/(%-2%))2.5<'/8-21%,)2%86)22'20%<'(%I7''/J%-2%','27-5<(%4/'21'2%,)2%86)22'2%'2%)*4-(-'.0%<'(%I7''/J%-2%6-;2%4/'21'2%,)2%86)22'2%'2%8/):(-;:%'2%+'%)1'2+'/-21%,)2%,33/%+'%/'1-3%/'6',)2('%(<'*)=.?%K':'/%38%8/3;'5(2-,')9%<'44'2%+'%)+,-'C'2%,)2%<'(%(')*%,''6%-2,63'+%'2%73/+'2%C-;%2)1'23'1%)6(-;+%3,'/1'23*'2?%L3:%4'6'-+.*)(-1%-.%'/%.8/):'%,)2%''2%+9-+'6-;:'%+33/7'/:-210%4-;,33/4''6+%7)(%4'(/'A(%+'%4-;.('66-21%,)2%+'%/'1-32)6'%732-214397)*4-(-'.?%&''6%5325/''(%<)+%<'(%@7)6-('-(.(')*%,)2%+'%"'1-3%!/32-21'2%>..'2%''2%5'2(/)6'%/36%4-;%+'%%4'23'*-21%,)2%''2%-2('2+)2(%,33/%B'%@32-21.).%I<'(%1'4-'+%(9..'2%!/32-21'2%'2%>..'2J0%4'6).(%*'(%+'%MC3':(35<(%2))/%+'%3,'/:3'8'6'2+'%7))/+'%'2%4'(':'2-.%,)2%+'%@32-21.).N%'2%+'%))2.('66-21%,)2%''2%DO223,)(-'(')*%732'2=0%4'+3'6+%)6.%:)()6P.)(3/%,33/%+'%.(-61',)66'2%732-2143978/3+95(-'?%Q'/+'/%3/1)2-.''/(%<'(%(')*%)A%'2%(3'%''2%C31'2))*+'%"'1-3)5)+'*-'%7))/4-;%(<'*)=.%'2%32+'/7'/8'2%D*'(%+'%4'2'2%38%()A'6=%:922'2%73/+'2%+33/+)5<(?

567')83"&0/'0/9/'".1) ) ) :';0'(9<'-0=4/

>/"-/1)) ) ) ) ) ?@@@)A0#<'9/'&(BC)90#(9)?@@D)0#)4%0(0<')9".'#9/'&&0#<

E0#(("/%.1) ) ) ) F#;'7""&(

F7(-"=4/<'$'-1) ) ) >/%%-<-,'7)G'<0,$090'):-,#0#<'#H!99'#)

5""8I.0990'1) ) ) ) J'3"8'#)$"#)(')83"&0/'0/9".;0/0'9C)(0');0##'#)(')-'<0,)K0L#)<'+,-.%&''-(),.)%0/)/')8%##'#)<-,'0'#)/,/)) ) )

) ) ) ) ) (').''9/)""#/-'88'&0L8')3,,#H)3'-8-'<0,)$"#)M'('-&"#(N)

!"-()I)O0LK')$"#)"($09'-'#1) ) F#"+4"#8'&0L8C)=,"=4'#(C)9/0.%&'-'#()'#)0#970-'-'#(C)<''#)7-,/,=,&

!($0'9$,-.1) ) ) ) 2'-9&"<C)4"#(-'080#<),+)"($0'9

P-'Q%'#/0'1) ) ) ) R)")S)8''-)7'-)L""-

!($0'9)""#1) ) ) ) >/%%-<-,'7C)<'.''#/'9)'#)7-,$0#=0'9)'#)"#('-')7"-/0L'#C)3""-,#('-)9/"8'4,&('-9

!($0'9<';0'(),+)&,="/0'1) ) G'<0,):-,#0#<'#H!99'#)AT?)<'.''#/'#C)?)7-,$0#=0'9B

U"('-1)) ) ) ) G'<0,$090'):-,#0#<'#H!99'#

F7'#;""-C)L")I)#'') ) ) V

W''-)0#+,)I)3';90/'1) ) ) >'=-'/"-09)X'/'-)W0=4'&)>=4""7)'#)4//71II333N-'<0,<-,#0#<'#"99'#N#&I#&I,$'-H,#9I,-<"#,<-".HTI83"&0/'0/9/'".I

,+$&0,%&''#0.45567899:6;-<86=-,8>5?@-ABC?D@EFCG@C6EF89:E9H'8D;-IC?-$8EF:B-AE5?E:G95?9J8==:BCC6H'8D;-+6?5BD-!:8K?D56G-A5?D:675:=:6H

B-/:%R-;*32.%-.%6)2+.5<)8.)/5<-('5(%'2%''2%,)2%+'%+/-'%38/-5<('/.%,)2%&STSR%U)2+.5<)8.)/5<-('5('2?%R-2+.%$%3:(34'/%V#$$%-.%<-;%&3316'/))/%U)2+.5<)8.)/5<-('5(99/%))2%+'%)A+'6-21%W/4)2-.*%,)2%+'%A)596('-(%X397:92+'%EW%B'6A(?%&)2%Y-5<'6%-.%)+,-.'9/%38%<'(%4/'+'%('//'-2%,)2%5325'8(32(7-::'6-210%.('+'24397%'2%)/5<-('5(99/?%>/236+%"'-;2+3/8%7'/:(%)6.%32+'/C3':'/%38%<'(%.2-;,6):%,)2%.35-))6G596(9/'6'%32(7-::'6-21'20%.('+'24397%'2%.('+'6-;:'%,'/2-'97-21?

'LW�SURÀHO�LV�PHGH�PRJHOLMN�JHPDDN�GRRU�

!"#$%&"'()*+ ,#*)-.%/0"'*.)#1

23*%4"560-

SURMHFWHQ�UHJLRSDUN�*URQLQJHQ�$VVHQ-RVp�YDQ�&DPSHQ�HQ�6DQGUD�YDQ�$VVHQ��ODDWVW�ELMJHZHUNW�RS����PDDUW�����

:G@T

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

!"#$!"#$:G@T

)()

)

(

)

U@<A<DHBH9<)NGA_)?BD)MBJU<D)<D)ABD;@B)?BD)BAA<D)`)aX()(((((

(

!"#$%#&'(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

!"#$%#&'(

%(

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Interviews

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

!"#$%&$#'(%&#)%*+%##,%-#.+,#//*,0+1%#,%-#.##,-$23*0*,0+4$,+).245#%

6#.)%7*33#/'$$8(%%9#)%:%)#;<+%*,%=;;.%3#%$,)=#.8$80;-#%)2++#,%=;/%#,%+4"*8%3.#*0)%)#%-;//#,%%

>*#'%?;''#.(%@#%)#.<%'=;/*)#*)+)#;<%*+%0#3#-;/2##.3A%-##/%)#;<+%B*C,%D#B*0%<#)%'/#*,#.#%3*,0#,A%'/#*,#%$,)=*''#/*,0#,%%

!$,%E#,"$#-#,(%@#%D.#3#%0#D*#3+$,)=*''#/*,0%D*C%"#)%8.$C#4)%>*,0%F).#4")%-.;;0)%##,%;3#G2;)#%-#.);/*,0%-;,%D#/#*3%

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Essays

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

Kwaliteitsteams avant-la-lettre •! Is onafhankelijk team voor

ruimtelijke kwaliteit van alle tijden? •! Wat kunnen we van onze

voorgangers leren? •! Verhouding RO-beleid en

kwaliteitsteams?

Het teamwerk •! Hoe werkt intercollegiaal

beoordelingsproces? •! Intermenselijke dynamiek en

(sociaal)psychologische factoren •! Wat is meerwaarde van het

‘teamwork’ en wat zijn de valkuilen?

(

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Observaties en evaluaties

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

Bijdrage aan de praktijk:

•! Bijdrage evaluaties (oa. team Ring Utrecht)

•! Antwoord en hulp bij adviesvragen: startvragen en startbijeenkomsten

•! Vragen over status, samenstelling team, advisering, do’s & don’t’s

•! Verhouding RO-beleid en kwaliteitsteams?

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Website: > 19.000 bezoekers in 1 jaar

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

)()

)

(

)

U@<A<DHBH9<)NGA_)?BD)MBJU<D)<D)ABD;@B)?BD)BAA<D)`)aY()(((((

(

!"#$%#&'(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

!"#$%#&'(

)(

3. Enkele bevindingen

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Werkwijze en samenstelling !(

(

! Geen twee teams gelijk! ((((((((

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Werkwijze en samenstelling

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

!(

(

!Beoordelingskaders: •! Uitvoeringsgericht: beeldkwaliteitsplan – welstandnota •! Gebiedsgericht: (structuur)visie – masterplan Procedureel: > 50% geen vastgesteld protocol Samenstelling: •! Uitvoeringsgericht: stedenbouw, architectuur, openbare ruimte (+

welstand) •! Gebiedsgericht: stedenbouw, landschap, infrastructuur, openbare

ruimte, milieu, cultuurhistorie ((((((((

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Onafhankelijkheid

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

!Wat is onafhankelijkheid? Geheel uit onafhankelijke leden: ! •! Uitvoeringsgericht: 20% •! Gebiedsgericht: 15% Meer dan de helft onafhankelijke leden: •! Uitvoeringsgericht: 70% •! Gebiedsgericht: 45% Belangrijk voor onafhankelijkheid o.a.: •! Agenda •! Openbaarheid •! Financiering •! Secretariaat •! Onafhankelijk en openbaar advies(

(

)()

)

(

)

U@<A<DHBH9<)NGA_)?BD)MBJU<D)<D)ABD;@B)?BD)BAA<D)`)ab()(((((

(

!"#$%#&'(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

!"#$%#&'(

)(

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Houdingen

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

!((

(

Autoritair ((((Afwachtend Los zand Meedenkend Actief (

( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ((( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ((

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Individualiteit en gezamenlijkheid

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland

!(

(!!!Wat is de waarde van de kwaliteitsadvisering?

Hoe wordt die waarde duidelijk?

Waar ‘blijft’ de gemeenschappelijke kennis? ((

(

!"#$%#&'(

)(

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Rol in planvormingsproces !!

Aard van de advisering: initiëren -> visievormen -> begeleiden -> beoordelen Uitvoeringsgericht: begeleiden en beoordelen Gebiedsgericht: alle fasen + beleid Themagericht: begeleiden!

*+,-./0(123456768(9367(26(:6;267:642(68(5<7=><==7?(@;9A<(:6<(367:BB;(C4D(:6<(A;BB<D6E((((

*A27B>:<(*0F/1GH,(F6(IB<6(3B8(>98>766<:642(3B8(26(5A6;76J6;5K:6<(@B267E(LBB7(99@(26(79;(68(5<B<=5(3B8(:6<(<6BI(68(26(:96366;:642(68(5997<(245>4A;4865(2BB748E(((((

*LM.NO+M(F6(PQ546@6(7=4I<6?(IBB7(99@(26(A9;4R6@6?(IBB<5>:BAA6;4D@6(68(6>989I45>:6(>98<6S<E(-6;@6(C6;B8J68(5A6;68(67T(-B<(45(26(A954R6(3B8(26(9A27B>:<J6367(68(26(B>:<67J7982(3B8(26(98<U67A67E((

F.('(*VW(F6(3BB724J:642(68(6X6>R34<64<(3B8(:6<(7=4I<6;4D@(@UB;4<64<5<6BI(C4D(3B8(:6<(B23456768(9367(668(7=4I<6;4D@(*8<U67A(:B8J<(5BI68(I6<(26(Y@68845(68(:9=248J(<68(9AZ4>:<6(3B8[(26(<U66(B82676(*V5\(26(*A27B>:<(68(26(*IJ6348JE(H6<(B23456768(45(J668(<6>:89>7BR5>:6(6S67>4R6(9P(:6<(BP348@68(3B8(>74<674BE(H6<(JBB<(9I(:6<(48<67A76<6768(3B8(668(484RBR6P(48(24<(5A66;36;2E((

H6<((5AB8848J536;2((<=5568(26('(*V5((

C6ABB;<(26((

U67@U4DZ6(68(6X6>R34<64<(3B8((668((

7=4I<6;4D@(@UB;4<64<5<6BI((

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland Spanningsveld omgeving-opdracht-ontwerp

Ruimtelijke Kwaliteitsteams in Nederland werp

)()

)

(

)

U@<A<DHBH9<)NGA_)?BD)MBJU<D)<D)ABD;@B)?BD)BAA<D)`)ac()(((((

(

!"#$%#&'(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

!"#$%#"&'

"'

()*+',-.'/0,-1'2*3-4,-53'

600.7,021'890)*,-*,7,-0:7'"!#;#!$"&'

<:=->*.=7?90)*,-*,'

*.'2-'<:=->*.=79-,@''

ABB*9003,7C'

D5*:,-)*E?-'890)*,-*,'F'--.'*.,3B254G-'

•! D5*:,-)*E?-'?90)*,-*,'H'2-'90032-'2*-'E-'0)7'

=-I35*?-3'B+'--.'I-+00)2':B:-.,',B-?-.,'00.'E-'

B:=->*.=J'K)257'L-B.*-'M0.7-.1'N3*?'O0.7'8)*E.'-.'P05)'<+20:'

•! O-,'BB32--)'B>-3'35*:,-)*E?-'?90)*,-*,'*7'257'

0Q0.?-)*E?'>0.@'

–!2-'=-I35*?-3'-.'R*E.'I-)0.=-.'–!2-'+)00,7'–!S-,':B:-.,'*.'2-'GE2'

D5*:,-)*E?-'?90)*,-*,'H'75IE-4G-TU'

V03-.23-4S,1'W*.-X#9*E?'/03.*77-.)0.2-'

)()

)

(

)

U@<A<DHBH9<)^=9U)H<D)MBH<)d)^<;<@BH9<)@K9JH<=9NE<)E!B=9H<9H)`)a>()(((((

(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

!"#$%#"&'

!'

()*+,-.*/0-'123.*,-*,4'&'23356-7'

•! 8-95)*0:23356-';<)7=>?7--.@'

•! A?-0?+:,23356-';6))5B33+@'

•! C-.-D*7E:23356-';+??*@''

@'

F39*<?5)+#+3,5*G''

!"#$#%&'"()*+,-$.)

/#"&--,)*+,-$.))

!"#,#.&'"()*+,-$.)

01,213++,)*+,-$.)

8-95)*0:23356-'

C-.-D*7E:23356-'

A?-0?+:,23356-'

222H2-50I35,7-5:H7-,'

J-'K37,5-00-.*/0-'L7-.2-E?+E-D*7E' M3:):4'6-'3),?2-E'

•! N5*+3*5-'<)7=>-'I5-D3.--5,'9?D-7':-=)763*5-'

9-.37E-7''

•! 8-D?.E4'3O??I'D37'

:-=)763*5-'9-.37E-7'

•! F300-7'*7'P-,'B376'Q'

B300-7'*7'6-'P376H'J):'

D--.'/)5*:,-5*/R'D-5,53E*7ER'0?:,-7'

•! L,)6*-'JKL4'E-95)*0'*7D-:,-5*7E''

*7'2-E'3.:'D.*-E2*-.'D??5''

*7D-:,-5*7E'*7'+--0?II-.-76-''

9-.37E-7''

)()

)

(

)

U@<A<DHBH9<)^=9U)H<D)MBH<)d)^<;<@BH9<)@K9JH<=9NE<)E!B=9H<9H)`aI()(((((

(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

!"#$%#"&'

&'

()*+,+'-../0++,1+)'-2)'34)+/56+'

76+8'2,,++)'++)'0/95':!"#$%"&'()&*+,)(-"("./;'<22/'..*=''•! >9,899/?638./63>?+'@28/.)+)'

•! 0+,2)5+)'-2)'A+83+/3'+)'-.+852)5+/3'

•! B*..)'+)'122/<++'38213@/.<.C+'

•! D>?++@-22/8#0+,2)5+)'

76+8 2,,++) ++) 0/95':!"#$%"&'()&*+!"#$%"&'()&*+!"#$%"&'()& ,)(-"("./;'<22/'..*=''

E96<8+,6F*+'*G2,68+68'H'6)8+5/22,'

•! I.)>,936+='/96<8+,6F*+'*G2,68+68'5228'.<'1+'J68/9-622)3+'G22/1+)K'6)'>.<06)2C+'<+8'1+'LM206N./9<O#0+,2)5+)<28/6PQ'

•! J+/+638'@.,6C+*+'*+9R+3'.-+/'@/+-2,+/+)1+'@/6<26/+'N9)>C+'+)'3+>9)126/+'0+,2)5+)'

!! J+/+638'?+8'365)2,+/+)'+)'0+8/+**+)'-2)'<++#

*.@@+,+)1+'0+,2)5+)'

!! J+/+638'0./56)5'6)'?+8'EQSQ#@/.>+3'

!! J+/+638K'F9638'-2)G+5+'1+'0+,2)5+)K'++)'0+,2)5+,.R+'

21-63+9/'

•! T+'>.)>,936+3'968'.)R+'+/-2/6)5+)'<+8'1+R+'<2)6+/'-2)'G+/*+)='•! "Q'*G2,68+68'2,3'@90,6+*'0+,2)5'<U+8'2,CF1'++)'5+3@/+*3.)1+/G+/@'R6F)'

•! !Q'0+-.+51'5+R25'<.+8'++)'-636+'.@'*G2,68+68'N./<9,+/+)K'+)'@/6./68+68+)'38+,,+)'

•! &Q'.<5+-6)53*G2,68+68'63'1+'/+39,82)8+'-2)'@2336+K'-636+K'-2*<2)3>?2@'+)'1221*/2>?8'

•! VQ'*G2,68+68'.)838228')6+8'1../')./<+)K'>/68+/62K'8.+83+)'+)'389/+)'W'>/9>622,'63'1+'L<+8?.16+*'-2)'?+8'1+3*9)165+)../1++,O'

<+8'.)2X2)*+,6F*'21-6+3'22)'0+-.+51'5+R25'2,3'/+39,8228'

S<5+-6)53G+8'W'++)-.9165'0+8+/'

•! LY.+1+'.<5+-6)53*G2,68+68O'63'12)*R6F'Z..6G22/83'?..N11.+,'-2)'1+'.<5+-6)53G+8K')2238'[5+R.)1\'+)'

[-+6,65\'

•! Y+<++)8+)'])'@2/C>9,6+/+)'?+00+)'++)'R./5@,6>?8'-../'.<5+-6)53*G2,68+68'

•! ^2363@/6)>6@+3='–!_NG+56)53/96<8+'-../',.*22,'0+3899/'`')./<2NG6F*6)5'–!J2)'N9)>C+3>?+616)5')22/'6)8+5/2C+':6@-')6+83'<25K'8+)R6F'8.+5+3822)'G./18'?+8='2,,+3'<25K'8+)R6F'-+/0.1+);'

–! (+)-.9165'^+8+/':a$'G+b+)K'"$$'_<-^\3'GQ.Q'0.9G0+3,968;'–!J../8R+c)5'-2)'d20.K'<22/')9'.@'0+,+613)6-+29'+)'>.<@,+8+/'

)()

)

(

)

U@<A<DHBH9<)^=9U)H<D)MBH<)d)^<;<@BH9<)@K9JH<=9NE<)E!B=9H<9H)`aT()(((((

(

!"#$%#"&'

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

!"#$%#"&'

('

•! )*+,-./+01,2'2,32'4'./0256*,/2,/7''–!83+,*,/,'9,+,30'–!)*+,-./+0-.0.,'–!)*+,-./+0:3;/'–! <3;/=<5>+5;**;'–! <5>?,@2A,036.2'–!)*+,-./+0-,5+6//./+''

•! )*+,-./+0:3;/'BC'A,02,**./+0:3;/'DE'A.,F2'-,,3'G,H.A.3.2,.2'->>5'./2,+5;;3'56.*2,3.?I'I1;3.2,.20A,3,.F'

•! J,'I;F,50'1;;5A.//,/'A,03>2,/'1>5F27'./2,+5;3,'>*+,-./+0-.0.,',/'A,3,.F05,+,30'B@K'1,302;/F0/>2;E'2,5'6.21,5I./+'-;/'/>L,0'./'M,2')*+,-./+0:3;/'

)*+,-./+01,2N'/>+'1;2'A,2,5'

•! O1;3.2,.20A,+5.:'-,556.*,/'BP987'Q>,I'/.,2',,/'A;3;/0'2600,/'A,0@M,5*./+'

,/'>/21.II,3./+N'*;;5'3,,5'F,'R,3-,F,5,#3,07'A,M>6F'FSS5'>/21.II,3./+E'

•! T;;I'F,')*+,-./+0-.0.,'>>I'->>5'+,*,,/2,/'-,5:3.@M2'

•! U2,3'VV/';F-.,0@>**.00.,'-,5:3.@M2'F.,'F,'W+>,F,'>*+,-./+0I1;3.2,.2X'A,>>5F,,32N'*,2';30'1,Y,3.?I'*./.*6*'F,',5K+>,F#2;I,/'

•! Z3;/I,5,/F'A,3,.F'>*'I1;3.2,.2'-;/'M,2'+,*,,/2,A,02665'2,'-,502,5I,/'

•! ):F5;@M2';;/'F,'-;I1,5,3F'-;/'>/21,5:,50',/';F-.0,650'56.*2,3.?I,'I1;3.2,.27'–!<5>K,00.>/;3.0,,5'./2,+5;;3'I1;3.2,.20;F-.,0';;/'M,2'A,->,+F'+,Q;+['A,/>,*'F,'*;;20@M;::,3.?I,'*,,51;;5F,'V/'A5,/+'F,'0,@2>5;3,'@>/0,\6,/L,0'./'A,,3F'

–!],,0';3,52'>:'*,,I>::,3,/F,'A,3;/+,/',/'*,,I>::,3,/F,'*>*,/2,/'

Dank voor uw aandacht!

!"#$%&'#((&)*+&*,-&%&'.&/0)*123+2*

)()

)

(

)

U@<A<DHBH9<)^=9U)H<D)MBH<)d)^<;<@BH9<)@K9JH<=9NE<)E!B=9H<9H)`)aV()(((((

(

!"#$%#"&'

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

)()

)

(

)

U@<A<DHBH9<)<@9M)=K9H<D)d)@9NEAB;?9A<K@)?GG@)=BD;AMZBU)<D)!BH<@)\ABJ<D?BHH9DC]()(((((

(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

Beperkte ruimte, onbeperkte kwaliteit

Ruimtelijkekwaliteitsteams in NL

Eric Luiten Rijksadviseur Landschap en Water

College van Rijksadviseurs

ruimtelijke kwaliteit • ambitie met beperkte operationalisering

• niet objectiveerbaar, wel verifieerbaar

• boven-sectoraal, integrerend concept

• pragmatisch en contextueel getoonzet

ruimtelijke kwaliteit: firmitas utilitas venustas

ruimtelijke kwaliteit: K = R / M

)()

)

(

)

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

ruimtelijke kwaliteit: volgehouden eenheid van handelen

ruimtelijke kwaliteit:

evidente, zelfverklarende topografie

U@<A<DHBH9<)<@9M)=K9H<D)d)@9NEAB;?9A<K@)?GG@)=BD;AMZBU)<D)!BH<@)\ABJ<D?BHH9DC]()(((((

(

Naar een protocol voor ruimtelijke kwaliteit? - plankadering expliciete kwalitatieve ambitie

- planvorming kwaliteit in de vraagspecificatie

- planuitvoering integraal ruimtelijk en technisch ontwerp

- planoplevering vaststellen van de toegevoegde waarde

Kwaliteitsborging met q-teams - gefaciliteerd door de opdrachtgever(s) - volstrekt onafhankelijke professionals - gezaghebbend, ervaren, mondig - voorbereiding, aanbesteding, uitvoering - verifieerbare oordeelsvorming

!

!"#

• $%&– "#$%&$'(#)(*+',-..%/(0$(+123,$4$(45.3,%$,%&6#'7(8..3%($6(

-.&%8#10

– 90-,&$1'(2,:(-$';166,6;-$'3$6,6;

• $"'()– <6%$;'.%#'(-.6(,60,-,01$$3(+',-..%(,6,%,.%,$)(,6=%#%(-.&%;#$0>?(

'1,7%$3,:4> $6(+123,$4> !""#$%-#3(;$8$$3

– @$7.60.%$$'0$(%#%(A%#$B$;;,6;C(-$';166,6;-$'3$6,6;

D5.3,%$,%&%$.7(,6(&%$0$3,:4$(#6%5,44$3,6;$6

*#+,-

• $%&– !""#$ 8$%(+',7.,'$(+'#E$&(.3&(%#$%&$'

• $"'()– %& 8$%(+',7.,'$(+'#E$&(.3&(;$7.60.%$$'0$(,6%$;'.%#'

D5.3,%$,%&%$.7(,6(&%$0$3,:4$(#6%5,44$3,6;$6

!

"#$%$&'()*+$,'$%*-&.*#/$)/0.#'+$*/1+-2$*2//3!"#$%&'%&(&'#)(4'.'$*2-5*6'0*2-5*4$$&$5

*+,&'-&

• .#(– 7//3*/2$38$'%*+$3$+'..$$3%$*+$,'$%./5#9'))$&'5+*

#3-5.:/30$3$5%*5--3*11. $5*13'2--#

– ;-.#$31&-55'5+*$5*%--32-5*-:+$&$'%$*,$.#$00'5+.1&-55$5

• .+/0&– <3/5%$'+$5-3$5*5/%'+$5*=)//1)3->8#'+$*23--+?*@'#*/0*0$#*

'5'#'-#'$2$5*#$*)/0$5

– A5#9'))$&'5+.3'>8#'5+*--5+$+$2$5B*,$.#$00'5+*2/&+#*1-..$5%*

'5'#'-#'$:

C9-&'#$'#.#$-0*'5*.#$%$&'()$*/5#9'))$&'5+$5

)()

)

(

)

U@<A<DHBH9<)!9J)?BD)?<<=<D)\UI)U@GN<MHJBDBC<J<DHL)AHB?<AHL)O<C<=<9;9DCAC@G<U)GD;<@[G<E])()(((((

(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

!

!"#$%&'

• ()*– "#$%&$'($'(&)*'+,$-$'(

– "$-.*,$**$'($'(&%-+//$'

• ("+$,– 0$--)12$'3(/+4),)%$-$'($'(4#55.')4$-$'

– 67$-%.)*$'($'(8$,#'$'

9:+,)%$)%&%$+5()'(&%$;$,)12$(#'%:)22$,)'*$'

-./.+.&,%.

• <#'4$=%>#'%:)22$,)'*(.')%(8)''$'(*-#%$(=-#/$&&)#'$,$(

?$;$-,+';&$(=-#1$4%#'%:)22$,)'*&8$;-)17$'()'(+/*$,#=$'(

;$4$'').5

9:+,)%$)%&%$+5(8)1(&%$;$,)12$(#'%:)22$,)'*

!

!"#$%&'$(()%*

• +"&– "#$%&'($)*'+,-&.'/0'/1

– 230'/&1+&'45-$14567#-4&$,-'('+8##/9::%5'$8

• +,-.'– 230'/&1+$-&';/:('+/#$%&'($)*6 '4,-,%$145'+4,-4'0&'-

– 230'/&1+$-&';/:('+8##/9::%5'$8

<.:($&'$&1&':%1+$-+1&'8'($)*'+,-&.$**'($-;'-

/)%"%0)$-)%*

• +"&– =<+>:-+8'+;'?$'81,-&.$**'($-;

• +,-.'– =<+>:-+8'+0/,)'4&,-&.$**'($-;+

)()

)

(

)

U@<A<DHBH9<)!9J)?BD)?<<=<D)\UI)U@GN<MHJBDBC<J<DHL)AHB?<AHL)O<C<=<9;9DCAC@G<U)GD;<@[G<E]()(((((

(

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

Colofon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`(0?QED8(^)6.4_;(07ET>8(/LFMDEQ?@F(^RLEK;(FM79(D8(G789_C(R78@DGGD(.@D9DEDE(^'D]@D9FL8MI@JJDG@8HC8?_C((&89EW('L?M(^$789E7(O78(&FFD8($MD9D8]L?I_(D8(&H8DF('7G7:7(^$789E7(O78(&FFD8($MD9D8]L?I_C($T:?GDE@8HF`L89F(OLLE(3ED7TDOD(@89?FME@DC((6@D(LLJ(QDM(ODEFG7H(O78('D]@D9FL8MI@JJDG@8HC8?(LK5(Q\K5[[IIICHD]@D9FL8MI@JJDG@8HC8?[7ETJDG[ZAdZlE?@:MDG@>JDlJI7G@MD@MFMD7:Fl]G7NJl]LflHDLKD89(("##$%#&'!()!*+$,!)-(.!

!"#$%&'()"#*+,-"".*/0$1((2,1!/"#,.'$'"#,341"(#2,01"%,-*"(*)&%,1",1$1"&0$(,.(."R"#%&.R;(<=(>?8@(=A<B(

((((