dbs cfcfhut,kj ]yj,t,c^ hjvtksf itcofdkfcf] hovtyf vjbs[jdc lf …...xdtyb qvthsbc obyfit lqtib...
Transcript of dbs cfcfhut,kj ]yj,t,c^ hjvtksf itcofdkfcf] hovtyf vjbs[jdc lf …...xdtyb qvthsbc obyfit lqtib...
oobyfvlt,fht obuyb ,fdidt,bcsdbcff ufvbpyekb&
vbcb vbpfybf^ smdty itbcofdkjs lf xfodlts
flfvbfybc ,eyt,fib fhct,ek cbvidtybthtc& obuybc
vj]ekj,f v]bhtf^ vfuhfv udwthf^ hjv smdtyb ]j-
lybc^ uh.yj,t,bcf lf fphjdyt,bc xfvj'fkb,t,fib vy-
bidytkjdfy odkbkc itbnfyc& fv obuyib smdty bgj-
dbs cfcfhut,kj ]yj,t,c^ hjvtksf itcofdkfcf]
hovtyf vjbs[jdc lf hjvkbsf] qvthsbc cf[tkbs
vjybzt,ek idt,fc^ qvthssfy vbf[kjt,bc .fkfc bu-
h.yj,s& cbn'dbcf lf m]tdbc thsbfyj,bc 'dtkfpt rf-
hub vjltkbc^ jwf[bcf lf cfpjufljt,hbdb ][jdh-
t,bc cf'hltybc - pytj,bc ghby]bgt,c xfodlt,bs lf
smdtyb ]yj,bcvj'dfhtj,bcfsdbc lfvf[fcbfst,tk c[df
rbs[dt,cf] ufc]tvs gfce[c& udwthf^ hjv rbs[dbcfc
xfeabmhlt,bs lf itbvt]yt,s^ se hbc ufrtsd,fc
vjbs[jdc xdtyufy qvthsb lf bct vjbm]tdbs^
hjujh] qvthsc vjtojyt,f^ vbc vbth frh.fkekbc
ufrtst,fc vjthblt,bs&
xdtyb s[jdyff^ smdty v[jkjl cbrtsbc rtst,f
ufub[fhlts lf ,jhjnt,fc upf itevjrkjs^ flfvb-
fybc uekb bctsb afmbpb eylf b'jc^ hjv zbfyzdtk-
fcf] rb vjthbljc& ][jdht,fib egbhfntcj,f v[jk-
jl cbrtstc vbfybzjs - tcff xdtyb gfce[cbvut,kj,f
lf smdty] qvthsbc obyfit fv gfce[bcvut,kj,bs ey-
lf b'js& smdtyb udwthf lf lbl bvtlt,cf] dfv'fh-
t,s smdtypt&
dianeTis saqmeTa sammarTvelos gamomcemloba
xtvc cfhoveyjt,fc
dcofdkj,
lbfytsbc cfmvtsf cfvvfhs-
dtkjc ufvjv]tvkj,f% 625
cf,fdidj obuyt,b% 159
ntmcnt,bc itvlutykt,b%
fhafckfy lehveib
/fnbwt bibkfrb
bkbfc fckfyb
ythbvfy ujmxtujp rfhfstmbyb
uhfabrbc vjynf;b%
tlfv lf ve/fvvtl
yeh fy,fhkb
uhfabrbc itvchekt,kt,b%
f/vtl mfhfsfib
tvbyt mfktkb
bcvfbk /f''b ueh,tsxb
gtlfujubehb rjyceknfynb%
tlfvb
bkecnhf]bf
sehues bkvfpbcf
ufvjv]tvtkb%
sehmtsbc lbfytsbc ajylbc
cfufvjv]tvkj cnfv,f
cfdfzhj cfmvtsf
cfvvfhsdtkj^ fyrfhf
ntk& (0312) 354 91 31
fyrfhf^ bdkbcb 2004
ISBN 975-19-3595-4
sfhuvyf%
igc @sfhwbvfyvf# m& ,fsevb^
mesfbcbc m& ~19
o b y f c b n ' d f j , f
cf'dfhtkj ,fdidt,j!
xdtyb uekt,b smdtylfvb^ cb'dfhekbs ats-
mfdc& tc obuyb fv cb'dfhekc ufvj[fnfdc lf
vfssdbcff ufyresdybkb^ dby] cofdkbc fsd-
bct,bc cfertstcj [fyfib lfepfhtkbf&
bckfvb fkfvfpt,c lf frtsbkij,bkt,c xd-
tyc cekc& fkkf/bc cb'dfhekbcf lf rtsbkb
pytj,bc it.tyf cofdkbsff itcf.kt,tkb& v[j-
kjl vfiby dbmyt,bs qvthsbc hxtekyb& obyfv-
lt,fht obuyb ,fdidt,bcsdbcff ufvbpyekb& vbcb
vbpfybf^ smdty itbcofdkjs lf xfodlts flfvb-
fybc ,eyt,fib fhct,ek cbvidtybthtc& obuybc
vj]ekj,f v]bhtf^ vfuhfv udwthf^ hjv smd-
tyb ]jlybc^ uh.yj,t,bcf lf fphjdyt,bc xfvj-
'fkb,t,fib vybidytkjdfy odkbkc itbnfyc& fv
obuyib smdty bgjdbs cfcfhut,kj ]yj,t,c^
hjvtksf itcofdkfcf] hovtyf vjbs[jdc lf
hjvkbsf] qvthsbc cf[tkbs vjybzt,ek idt-
,fc^ qvthssfy vbf[kjt,bc .fkfc buh.yj,s&
cbn'dbcf lf m]tdbc thsbfyj,bc 'dtkfpt rfhub
vjltkbc^ jwf[bcf lf cfpjufljt,hbdb ][jdh-
t,bc cf'hltybc - pytj,bc ghby]bgt,c xfodlt,-
bs lf smdtyb ]yj,bcvj'dfhtj,bcfsdbc lf-
vf[fcbfst,tk c[df rbs[dt,cf] ufc]tvs gfce[c&
udwthf^ hjv rbs[dbcfc xfeabmhlt,bs lf it-
bvt]yt,s^ se hbc ufrtsd,fc vjbs[jdc xdtyufy
qvthsb lf bct vjbm]tdbs^ hjujh] qvthsc
vjtojyt,f^ vbc vbth frh.fkekbc ufrtst,fc
vjthblt,bs&
xdtyb s[jdyff^ smdty v[jkjl cbrtsbc rt-
st,f ufub[fhlts lf ,jhjnt,fc upf itevjr-
kjs^ flfvbfybc uekb bctsb afmbpb eylf b'-
jc^ hjv zbfyzdtkfcf] rb vjthbljc& ][jdht-
,fib egbhfntcj,f v[jkjl cbrtstc vbfybzjs
- tcff xdtyb gfce[cbvut,kj,f lf smdty] qvt-
hsbc obyfit fv gfce[bcvut,kj,bs eylf b'js&
smdtyb udwthf lf lbl bvtlt,cf] dfv'fht,s
smdtypt&
lbfytsbc cfmvtsf cfvvfhsdtkj
sarCevi
hovtyf 4
rfhb gbhdtkb
xdtyb ufvxtyb qvthsb% fkkf/b 6
rfhb vtjht
1& qvthsbc v,h.fyt,kj,fib v‘jab
cekbthb vjcfvcf[ehtt,b _ fyutkjpt,b 11
2& &qdsbehb ]jlybc o’fhjt,b% ovbylf obuyt,b 12
3& qvthsbc ufvjupfdybkb hxtekb obyfv.qdht,b%
iefvfdkt,b 13
4& fv mdt’ybc vbqvf _ cfbmbj ][jdht,f 15
5& qdsbcvbthb e]dktkb pjvt,b%
,tlbcothf lf ufyut,f 17
qdsbcvcf[eht,f
rfhb gbhdtkb
xdtyb qvthsbc obyfit lqtib [eswth
kj]df (yfvfpb) 23
rfhb vtjht
sfdbcsfdbc ufodhsyf lf yt,bc’jabc cofdkf%
vfh[df 28
rfhb vtcfvt
1& qvthsbc ,j.t,ekbc itafct,f lf _ ptmfsb 31
2& cbovbylbcfrty vupfdhj,f _ /fwb 33
py tj, f
rfhb gbhdtkb
1& bckfvb kfvfpb pytj,ff 38
2& .dbhafcb ve/fvvtl iefvfdfkb^
hjujh] pytj,bc o’fhj 40
rfhb vtjht
dfklt,ekt,t,b sfdbcsfdbcf lf xdtyb
jwf[bc obyfit 42
rfhb vtcfvt
vjdfktj,t,b ufhtvjcf lf vstkb
rf]j,hbj,bc obyfit 46
hovtyf
@@//ttbb^̂ vvjjhhoovveeyyttyyjj!!
bbooffvvttss ffkkkkff//bb^̂ vvbbccbb
iieeffvvffddffkkbb llff oobbuuyybb^̂
hhjjvvttkkbb]] uuffhhllvvjjeeddkkbbyyff
ssffddbbcc iieeffvvffddffkkcc^̂ oobbuuyybb^̂
hhjjvvttkkbb]]
uuffhhllvvjjffddkkbbyyff ffllhhtt&&
ddbbyy]] eeffhh//''jjaacc ffkkkkff//cc^̂
vvbbcc ffyyuuttkkjjpptt,,cc^̂ vvbbcc
llff oobbuuyytt,,cc^̂ vvbbcc iieeffvvffdd-
kktt,,cc eerrffyyffrryyttkk llqqttcc^̂
eerrddtt ]]lleeyytt,,eekkbbff
eerrbblleehhttccbbcc ]]lleeyytt,,bbss&&
(cehf mfkt,b-yybcf
fbfsb% 136)
iittbbccooffddkktt^̂ uuffvvjjbbrrddkkbbtt ^̂ bbaabbmmhhtt
1& fv cbn'dt,bc vybidytkj,t,b rfh-
ufl itbcofdkts lf lfbvf[cjdhts^
xfbothts e,bc obuyfrib lf fh lfbd-
bo'js% bvfyb (hovtyf)^
vevbyb (vjhoveyt)^ bckfvb^ veckb-
vfyb^ df/b&
2& 'jdtklqbeh cfcfe,hj tyfpt
lfothts bctsb fylfpt,b fy ufvjyfsm-
dfvt,b^ hjvkt,ib] mdtvjs vj]tvek
cbn'dfsfufy ths-thsb bmyt,f ufvj'ty-
t,ekb% fkkf/b^ fyutkjpb^ 'ehfyb^
iefvfdfkb^ cfbmbj^ ufyrbs[dbc lqt
('bfvtsb)& fv cbn'dt,bc ufvj'tyt,bc vb-
ptpbc itcf[t, fv[fyfut,sfy thsfl bv-
cwtkts&
3& htkbubbc reknehbcf lf ,fdi-
dsf pytj,hbdb fqphlbc itcf[t, ,td-
hb obuyb brbs[ts&
h
o
v
t
y
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
4
xxttvvc
cffhoovvee
yyjjtt,ffc
ddcooffddkkjj
,
fkkf/bc ufxtybk 'dtkf fhc-
t,fsf ijhbc flfvbfyc ufycfres-
ht,ekb flubkb erfdbf& fv ufyc-
fresht,ekj,bc vbybzt,bc 'dtk-
fpt .bhbsflb afmnjhb fphjdy-
t,bc eyfhbf& flfvbfyb fphjdyt,bc
cfiefkt,bs ufyfc[dfdt,c rfhucf
lf ]elc^ kfvfpcf lf eiyjc^
cojhcf lf fhfcojhc& flfvbfybc-
fsdbc lfvf[fcbfst,tkbf c[dflfc-
[df vjs[jdyt,b^ hjujhb]ff%
zfvf^ cvf^ .bkb lf c[df& se rb
tctyb lffrklt,f^ c[tekb vbc
aeym]bt,c dth itfchekt,c lf
wfycfq fhct,j,fc dth uffuh.t-
kt,c& fctdt dth it.kt,c^ abmhc^ cb'dfhekc^ cb-
[fhekc^ voe[fht,fc& vcufdcb fhfabpbjkjubehb^
flfvbfybcfsdbc 'dtkfpt cfzbhj cekbthb cfhxj
hovtyff& v[jkjl fv cfzbhjt,fsf epheydtk'jabc
itvltu vbfqotdc flfvbfyb yfvldbk ,tlybtht,fcf
lf cbvidbltc& hovtyf^ tzdbc ufhtit lfwtht,f lf
ylj,ff&
flfvbfyb^ hjvtkb] bofvt,c^ vjhoveyt (vevbyb)
/mdbf& xdtyb cfhoveyjt,bc^ bckfvbc hovtybc ghby-
]bgt,b tmdc stvfl itb.kt,f ufydb[bkjs& tctybf%
fkkf/bc^ fyutkjpt,bc^ ovbylf obuyt,bc^ fkkf/bc
iefvfdkt,bc^ ufyrbs[dbc lqbc^ ,tlbcothbcf lf uf-
yut,bc hovtyf^ 'dtkf tctyb rb 'ehfybc ntmcn @fv-
tyse#-ibf xfvjsdkbkb&
se rb @ffvtyse# fh b]bs^
eahjct,bcfufy bcofdkts&
h
o
v
t
y
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
5
c
h
o
v
t
y
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
6
rrffhhbb ggbbhhddttkkbb
elbltcb ufvxtyb$fkkf/b
@@ddbbyy]] ffkkkkff//cc bbooffvvtt,,cc^̂ffkkkkff//bb vvbbcc
uueekkcc ccbbccoojjhhbbccffrrttyy
vvbbvvffhhssffddcc&& ffkkkkff//bb ''ddttkkffaahhbbcc
qqbbhhcctteekkffll vv]]jjllyyttff&&##
(cehf stf,eyb^ fbfsb 11)
hovtybc cfae.dkt,bc ]tynhc @fkkf-
/bc hovtyf# itflutyc& fkkf/bc hovtyf
vbc ]yj,fc cfzbhjt,c& vbcb sdbct,t,bc
itcofdkf vbcb ufvjupfdybkb iefvfdkt-
,blfy lf
ovbylf obu-
yt,blfy itu-
db.kbf& tc
]yj,t,b vb-
cbdt kfvfp
cf[tkt,ibf
ufysfdct,e-
kb^ hjvkt-
,cf] vskbf-
yj,fib
@ t c v f b
[ e c y f #
tojlt,f
@@ffkkkkff//cc ffmmddcc ccffeerr-
eessttccjj ccff[[ttkktt,,bb&&
iittttddttllhhttss vvffcc
((ffkkkkff//cc))
vvffssbbss&& ((ccffeerrttssttccjj
ccff[[ttkktt,,bbss))##
(cehf fhfab-vfqkj,yb
fbfsb 180)
h
o
v
t
y
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
7
fkkf/bc sdbct,t,b (tgbstnt,b)
fkkf/b^ hjvtkb] udofvc lf cb'dfhekbs vjdb[ctybt,s^ 'dtkfpt
kfvfpb lf 'dtkfpt vfqfkb sdbct,t,bc vmjytf%
fkkf/b 'dtkfpt eptyftcb lf vfhflbekb fhct,ff& vbc fhct,j,fc
lfcfo'bcb fh fmdc lf vfhflbekfl bfhct,t,c& thsbf lf evfufkbsjf&
fh] thsb fhct,f vfc fh /ufdc& bc hfbvtpt lfvjrblt,ekb fhff^ bc
'dtkfc lf 'dtkfathc tcfzbhjt,f& cfv'fhjib hf] fhct,j,c^ 'dtkfc
yfvldbkb gfnhjyb bcff&
ce,esb% * pjuuflb tgbstnb^ tct buub fv cf[tkbc mdti
uufthsbfyt,ekb sdbct,t,b pjuuflb [fcbfsbcff&&
gbhflb tgbstnt,b ce,esb * tgbstnt,b
dewelb
fhct,j,c
/fbfsbbc etzdtkfl ]j][fkbf
bkbvb‘dtkfathb b]bc
ctvb'dtkfathb tcvbc
,fcfhb'dtkfathc [tlfdc
mtkfvbvfhsfk lf kfvfp cbn'dfc bn'dbc
bhfltsfdbcb yt,f-ccehdbkbcufy[jh]btkt,bc .fkfitcotdc
'elhtsb'dtkfahbc ufrtst,bc .fkf itcotdc
st'dbybuffxtyc^ hfcf] vjbcehdt,c
'bltv
lfcf,fvb fh fmdc
,t'f
ecfchekjf
df/lfybtsb
thsbf
ve/ffktatsey
kbk /fdflbc
ufxtybkt,c fh /ufdc
'bfv ,b ytacb/b
hfbvtpt lf dbyvtpt
lfvjrblt,ekb fhff
h
o
v
t
y
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
8
bc erdlfdbf^ vbc ufhlf 'dtkfathb
lhjt,bsbf& vfy 'dtkf lf 'dtkfathb b]bc& vfc
fhfathb lftvfkt,f& xdtyib fhct,ekb abmht,b
vskbfyfl b]bc& cflf] eylf db'js^ xdtyb
'dtkf cbn'df tcvbc lf 'dtkfathc [tlfdc&
'dtkfc s[jdyf-dtlht,f tcvbc lf vfs
vjs[jdyt,pt htfubht,c& ,h.fyt,t,cf lf cehd-
bkt,c flfvbfyt,c iefvfdkt,bc vtidtj,bs
f]yj,t,c& hf] cehc^ lfvjerblt,kfl frtst,c^
vbc cehdbkt,c oby dthfdby fqelut,f& 'dtkf
cehdbkc hjujh] vfc eylf^ bct bchekt,c&
hj]f hfbvtpt bn'dbc%@ufxylb#^ vfibydt
ufxylt,f& vstkb cfv'fhj vfy uffxbyf& 'dtkf
vbc vbth ufxtybkb hfbvt vbpybs fhct,j,c lf
'dtkfathb thsvfytssfyff itho'vekb&
bbaabbmmhhttss ssmmddttyycc uuffhhiittvvjj vv’’jjaabb
ffhhcctt,,tt,,bbcc uuffxxttyybbcc vvbbppyybbcc iittccff[[tt,,&& vvffss
iijjhhbbcc ssee ffhhbbcc bbccttssbb^̂ hhjjvvttkkbb]] ssmmddttyybb
ffpphhbbss^̂ nn''eebbkkffllffff uuffxxttyybbkkbb?? ffvv ccffrrbbss[[pptt
ffvv[[ffyyffuutt,,ssffyy bbvvccwwttkkttss&& iitttt]]ffllttss
ffqqvvjjxxbbyyjjss ''ddttkkff ffhhcctt,,bbcc uuffxxttyybbcc vvbbppttppbb&&
h
o
v
t
y
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
9
ffkkkkff//bbcc ccff[[ttkkbbss&&&&&&
bvbcfsdbc^ hjv dbofvjs fkkf/b^ fe]bkt,kfl
eylf udb'dfhltc bc& cb'dfhekb rb vfhnj cbn'-
dbs fh ufvjb[fnt,f^ fhfvtl cfmvbsf lf m]tdbs
lflfcneht,ff cfzbhj& dbcf] fkkf/b cofvc^ vbc
,h.fyt,t,cf lf vjs[jdyt,cf] eylf fchekt,ltc&
flfvbfyvf^ hjvtkvf] b]bc^ hjv vfc fkkf/b 'jd-
tksdbc [tlfdc^ cfresfhb vjmvtlt,bs fkkf/bc
rvf'jabkt,bc vjcfgjdt,kfl eylf bpheyjc& tc rb
'jdtksdbc fkkf/bc uf[ctyt,bsff itcf.kt,tkb&
flfvbfybcfufy fkkf/bc uf[ctyt,bc ths-thsb ybi-
fyb 'dtkf cfmvbc lfo't,bc oby @,bcvbkkf/#-bc sm-
vff& ,bcvbkkf/-bc smvf @,bcvbkkf/bhhf/vfybhhf-
/bv# obyflflt,bc smvfc ybiyfdc& vbcb vybidytkj,ff%
@vjo'fkt lf itvo'fkt,tkb fkkf/bc cf[tkbs&#
fv ufvj[fnekt,bc vjrktl ufvjsmvf @,bcvbkkf/#
cbn'dbsf] itb.kt,f& vybidytkj,f rb thsbf& ,bcv-
bkkf/-bc smvbs xdty cfv hfvtc dfrtst,s%
& fkkf/bcflvb xdtyc hovtyfc cbn'dbs
dflfcneht,s&& fvf se bv cfmvbcfsdbc fkkf/bcfufy
lf[vfht,fc dbs[jds&& fkkf/sfy xdtyc 'jayfc dflfcneht,s
fkkf/bc ufycfresht,ek cf[tksfufy idblb vfsu-
fyb lfbptgbhts lf rdbhbc 'jdtk lqtc fv
cbn'dfsfufy ths-tthsbc ufvj'tyt,bs vfc ittdtl-
hts& vfufkbsfl^ ity /fabpb (lfv]fdb) [fh^ xtvj
fkkf/j! 'jdtkudfhb ]elbcf lf cbukf[tt,bcfufy
lfvb]fdb&#
,bcvbkkff/bhhf
/vffybhhf/bbv
h
o
v
t
y
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
10
mmddttvvjjss vvjj]]ttvveekkbbff ''jjddttkkllqqbbeehh vvttnn''ddttkktt,,ffiibb [[iibbhhffll
uuffvvjj''ttyytt,,eekkbb ffaajjhhbbppvvtt,,bb llff uuffvvjjyyffssmmddffvvtt,,bb&& uuffhhiittvvjjvv''jjaassff
llff[[vvffhhtt,,bbss ttcc ccbbff uuffffaaffhhssjjttss^̂ hhffnnjjvvffff ffvv uuffvvjjyyffssmmddffvvtt,,ccff llff
ffaajjhhbbppvvtt,,iibb ccbbnn''ddff
* fkkf/b# [ibhfl
ufvj'tyt,ekb? fvbc itcf[t,
fv[fyfut,sfy bvcwtkts&
* fkkf/vf ltlbfy vfvbfyb
ufupfhljc!
* fkkf/vf vjsvbyt,bc eyfhb
vju]ts!
* fkkf/vf cf'dfhtkc itu'fhjs!
* fkkf/vf ,fhfmf vju]ts!
* se rb fkkf/b ths rfhc
lfubrtnfdc^ vtjhtc ufubqt,c!
* xbnb^ hjvtkb] dth ahbyfdc^
fkkf/b vfc lf,fk njnc vbex-
tyc!
* fkkf/b fvfuc fh lfubrfhufdc!
* fkkf/vf se vju]f^e][j vjb-
nfyc^ ybfqdfhb vjbnfyc^ mfhb
vjbnfyc!
* fkkf/vf cbrtst vju]ts!
* uafhfdlts fkkf/b!
* fkkf/bc yfsmdfvb fcheklt,f!
* fkkf/vf cbvidblt vju]ts!
* fkkf/vf f][jyjc!
* hj]f fkkf/b vj'dfht
ut'jkt,f^ [vfkb [bcf] hjv
b'jc^ ufzhbc!
* fkkf/c flfvbfybcfsdbc thsb
gbhb lf jhb 'ehb vbe]bf^
hfsf thsb smdfc lf jhb ufbu-
jyjcj!
* utibyjltc fkkf/bc!
* fkkf/b thsb^ cbn’df thsb!
* fkkf/b thsb^ iefvfdfkb
cfvfhskbfyb^ ,flfub ifdb^ vfo-
jyb stshb!
* se rb fkkf/b lft[vfht,f
sfdbc vjyf-vcf[ehc^ 'dtkfathb
hbupt bmyt,f!
flfvbfyc^ hjvtkcf] fkkf/b cofvc
ª dbcf] fkkf/b e'dfhc^ bc fkkf/cf] e'dfhc&
ª dby] b]bc^ hjv fkkf/b 'dtkfathc [tlfdc lf 'dtkfathb tcvbc^
bc vfhnjj,bcfc^ bct hjujh] c[dt,sfy thsfl^ gfnbjcyfl lf qbhctek-
fl bm]tdf^ thsuekbf^ dby] b]bc^ hjv fkkf/b cfvfhskbfybf lf cbvfh-
skbc smvf e'dfhc^ bc dbyvtc ecfvfhskjl fh vjtm]tdf lf fh] ecfvfh-
skj,bc obyfit vjb[hbc mtlc&
ª dby] b]bc^ hjv fkkf/c 'dtkf dtlht,f tcvbc^ bc 'jdtksdbc
fkkf/c vbtylj,f lf ittrtlkt,f^ 'dtkfyfbhb cb.ytkbc lfcf.ktdfl
.fkf vjtvfnt,f&
ª dby] b]bc ufxtybc vbpfyb - cfblfy vjlbc lf cfbs vblbc^ bc sfdc
bvtlbfyfl uh.yj,c&
h
o
v
t
y
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
11
rrffhhbb vvttjjhhtt
1& fkkf/bc v,h'fyt,kj,fib v'jabcekbthb vjcfvcf[ehtt,b$
fyutkjpt,b
fkkf/bc vbth cbyfskbcfufy ufxtybk
lf sdfkbs e[bkfd fhct,t,c fyutkjp-
t,b (vtktmb-vtkfbmt) /mdbf& fyutkjpt,b
fh zfvty lf fh cdfvty^ vfs cmtcj,hbdb
vjs[jdyt,b fh f[fcbfst,s& fkkf/bc ,h-
.fyt,t,c e'j'vfyjl fchekt,ty^ lqbcbsf
lf qfvbs ufyeo'dtnkbd fkkf/c f[ctyt-
,ty^ vjhoveytsfsdbc qvthsc tdtlht,bfy&
'dtkf vfsufyc c[dflfc[df vjdfktj,f fr-
bchbf^ vfsb pecnb hb][db v[jkjl fk-
kf/vf b]bc& xdtysdbc ]yj,bkbf js[b fy-
utkjpb% wt,hfbkb^ vbmfbkb^ bchfabkb
lf fphfbkb&
@@llff^̂ffkkkkff//cc ssff''ddffyycc
cc]]ttvvcc vvbbooffvvlltt
ssffddllff[[hhbbss ((ccttwwllttcc
ee..qqddyybbcc))^̂ hhff]]ff
ffhhbbffyy ]]ffssffccff iibbyyff
llff llttllffvvbbooffcc ppttllff
cceekkbbtthhssffuuffyybb llff
ffyyuuttkkjjpptt,,bb]]
((vvttkkffbbmmtt,,bb]])) llff
bbccbbyybb hhjjllbb mmttllvvttll-
bblleehhjj,,ttyy!!&&&&&&
(cehf yf/kb-aenrfhb&
fbfsb 49)
ffllffvvbbffyycc^̂ hhjjvvttkkccff]] ccooffvvcc ffyyuuttkkjjpptt,,bb^̂ vvffyy
ª b]bc^ hjv fhfclhjc vfhnj fhff& fkkf/b vfc vafhdtkb
fyutkjpt,bc vtidtj,bs 'jdtksdbc lf 'dtkufy b]fdc&
ª b]bc^ hjv vothfkb fyutkjpt,b vbcsdbc (mbhfvty
mffsb,by) vbc 'dtkf rfhucf lf ]el cfmvtc cothty^
fvbnjv eahj 'ehflqt,bs bm]tdf&
ª b]bc^ hjv fyutkjpt,b vbcsdbc qvthsc tdtlht,bfy^
fvbnjv sdbsjyf] vbcsdbc lf 'dtkf veckbvfybcsdbc
qvthsc tdtlht,f&
h
o
v
t
y
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
12
qdsbehb wjlybco.fhjt,b$
ovbylf obuyt,b
ovbylf obuyt,b^ bctsb obuyt,bf^ hjvkt,b]
vjdktybkbf flfvbfyt,bcfsdbc lf itb]fdty
fkkf/bc othbkt,c^ ,h.fyt,t,c lf frh.fkd-
t,c& tc obuyt,b fvmdt'yfl cbrtsbc^ cbvfhsk-
bc^ cbkfvfpbc it]yj,bc lf ]elbcfufy lfafh-
dbc vbpybs fkkf/bc vbth flfvbyt,bcfsdbc ,j-
.t,ekb cojhb upbc vfxdtyt,tkbf& tc obuyt,-
bf% stdhfsb (sjhf)^ pt,ehb (acfkveyt,b)^
bywbkb (cf[fht,f) lf 'ehfyb& ovbylf obuyt,b^
hf] ufyc[dfdt,ek lhjcf lf ufyc[dfdt,ek
[fk[sfsdbc b'jc ufhlvjdktybkb^ 'dtkf
ths ufvj.f[bkc bcf[fdc vbpyfl% cfqb hovtyf^
cojhb mvtlt,f^ rfhub pytj,f& fv obuysfufy
pjuyb ufhrdtekb cfpjufljt,bcfsdbc^ [jkj
,jkj obuyb 'ehfyb rb chekbfl rf]j,hbj-
,bcsdbcff ufhlvjdktybkb& fkkf/bc ,jkj
othbkb 'ehfyb^ hjvtkb] ltlfvbobc lfcfch-
ekfvlt vjmvtlt,fib bmyt,f^ xdtyc cf'dfhtk
ve/fvvtl iefvfdfkc ufvjtupfdyf& c[df obuysf
jhbubyfkt,b fqfh fhct,j,c& 'ehfyb (bctf
itvjyf[ekb)^ thsb fcj,uthf] rb fhff it]d-
kbkb lf mdt'ybc lfcfchekfvlt ite]dktk-
fl uffuh.tkt,c fhct,j,fc& ltlfvbofpt obuy-
sfufy 'dtkfpt [ibhfl 'ehfyb brbs[t,f^ hf-
lufy vbcb rbs[df] qdsbcvcf[eht,ff&
@@&&&&&&ffkkkkff//vvff vvjjffdd-
kkbbyyff iieeffvvffddffkkbb
vvff[[ffhhjj,,kkffll llff
vvffaahhss[[bbkktt,,kkffll llff
vvffssssffyy tthhssffllddtt
uuffhhllvvjjffddkkbbyyff
zzttiivvffhhbbnntt,,bbcc oobbuuyybb^̂
ffllffvvbbffyyssff iijjhhbbcc
eessffyy[[vvjjtt,,ffssff
uuffllffccffoo''ddttnnffll&&&&&&##
(cehf ,f'fhf-aehb^
fbfsb 213)
tt..bbttss^̂ ffkkkkff//bbcc vvbbtthh uuffhhllvvjjddkkttyybbkk
oobbuuyyssffuuffyy ''eehhffyypptt ffllhhtt ffhhcctt,,eekkbb oobbuuyytt,,bb
hhjjvvttkk iieeffvvffddffkkcc uuffvvjjttuuppffyyff!!??
h
o
v
t
y
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
13
3& ltlfvbofpt vjdktybkb fkkf/bc hxtekyb$ iefvfdkt,b
@@llff ffhh vvjjuuddbbddkkttyybbff
iieeffvvffddkkyybb cc[[ddff hhffvv
vvbbppyybbss^̂ ssee ffhhff
vvff[[ffhhjj,,kkffll llff uuffcc-
ffaahhss[[bbkktt,,kkffll^̂ [[jjkkjj
ddbbyy]] bbhhoovveeyyff llff rrttss-
bbkkbb //mmvvyyff^̂ ffhh ttmmvvyyttss
vvffss iibbiibb llff ffhh]]ff
llffvvooee[[hhllyyttyy&&##
(cehf cfmjytkb-tyffvb^
fbfsb 48)
ffllffvvbbffyyvvff^̂ hhjjvvttkkvvff]] bbooffvvff oobbuuyytt,,bb&&&&&&
ª b]bc^ hjv fkkf/b flfvbfyt,c fvmdt'ybeh
][jdht,fib vfhnjl fh lfnjdt,c lf vfs cojh
upfc exdtyt,c&
ª ]lbkj,c^ hjv fkkf/bc
othbkb ufbujc lf
itfchekjc&
ª fkkf/bc obuyt,c
rbs[ekj,c lf b]bc^ hjv
hfcf] rbs[ekj,c^cekbth
cbvidbltc f.ktdc lf cekc
]elb phf[dt,bcfufy fsfdbceakt,c&
ª b]bc^ hjv hj]f 'ehfyc fbqt,c [tkib^ vbc
vcufdcfl vbkbjyj,bs flfvbfyb bubdt obuyc
rbs[ekj,c lf fvbs thsbfyj,bc^ vskbfyj,bc
uh.yj,t,b .kbthlt,f&
‘ehffyb
c[dflfc[df lhjc cojhb upbc vfxd-
tyt,kfl ufvjupfdybkb obuyt,b
flfvbfyt,bcfsdbc bjkfl ufcfut,b lf
itcfchekt,tkb hjv 'jabkb'j^
fkkf/vf iefvfdkt,b vjfdkbyf& vfs
fkkf/bc othbkbc f[cybc^ cofdkt,bcf
lf itchekt,bc vjdfktj,f eyfrkjl
itfchektc& bcbyb ][jdht,bc 'dtkf
cathjib cfvfufkbsjyb b'dyty&
h
o
v
t
y
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
14
bbccooffddkkttss ''eehhffyyiibb vvjj[[ccttyybbtt,,eekkbb iieeffvvffdd-
kktt,,bbcc ccff[[ttkktt,,bb^̂ uuffvvjjbbrrddkkbbttss llqqttcc ffvv
ccff[[ttkkssffuuffyy hhjjvvkktt,,bb uuffvvjjbb''ttyytt,,ff&&
iefvfdkt,vf vjhoveyt lf rtsbkbcv'jatkb flfvb-
fyt,bcfsdbc uflvjcf]tvb kfvfpb wbklj udf[fhtc&
vfs fkkf/bc ,h.fyt,t,bc itechekt,kj,bs vjcfkj-
lytkb ]elb cbvgnjvt,bc itcf[t,f] ufycfresht,bs
ufudfahs[bktc& iefvfdkt,c htgenf]bbc ufvj egbhf-
ntcj,f /mjylfs vbybzt,ekb& fkkf/vf flfvbfyt,c .f-
kbfy ,tdhb iefvfdfkb vjedkbyf^ vfuhfv vfsufy 'e-
hfyib v[jkjl j]lf[esb iefvfdkbc cf[tkbf yf[ct-
yt,b&
fkkf/bc 'dtkfpt ,jkj othbkbc - 'ehfybc xdty-
fvlt vjvnfyb ,jkj iefvfdfkb xdtyb cf'dfhtkb ve-
/fvvtlbf& bc fkkf/bc vbth vjdktybk iefvfdfksfufy
'dtkfpt ,jkjc vjdkbyt,ekbf rf]j,hbj,bc gfnhj-
yj,bcf lf vjo'fkt,bc vbcbbs& bc 'ehfybc ][jdht,fib
ufvnfht,tkb^ cfvfufkbsj flfvbfyb b'j&
ffllffvvbbffyybb^̂ hhjjvvttkkccff]] ccooffvvcc iieeffvvffddkktt,,bb&&&&&&
ª 'dtkf cathjib vfsufy bqt,c vfufkbsc&
ª ]lbkj,c^ hjv iefvfdfksf vcufdcfl vbcf,f.b
b'jc&
ª iefvfdfksf m]tdt,cf lf vjmvtlt,t,c
cofdkj,c lf ]lbkj,c bcbyb ][jdht,fib
ufvjb'tyjc&
ª b]bc^ hjv iefvfdkt,b 'dtkfc vbvfhs cfvfh
skbfyb b'dyty lf ]lbkj,c^ hjv sdbsjyf]
vfscfdbs cfvfhskbfyb b'jc&
h
o
v
t
y
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
15
iittfflluubbyyttss uuffvvjjyyffssmmddffvvtt,,bb^̂ hhjjvvttkkiibb]] uuffyyrrbbss[[ddbbcc
((vvff//iitthhbbcc)) llqqtt bbmmyytt,,ff yyff[[ccttyytt,,bb&& bbvvccwwttkkttss ffvv[[ffyyffuutt,,ssffyy
vvffss iittccff[[tt,,^̂ ssee hhff aajjhhvvbbssffff bbccbbyybb uuffvvjj''ttyytt,,eekkbb&&
@@eettzzddttkkffll&& qqddss-
bbccvvjjiibbiiyybb ,,ffqqtt,,iibb llff
oo''ffhhjjtt,,ssffyy llffvvrrdd-
bbllhhlltt,,bbffyy&&&&&&
((llff^̂ vvffss ttnn''ddbbffyy))%%
@@iittllbbss bbmm^̂ vviiddbblljj,,bbssff^̂
eeccffaahhss[[jjyybb!!## llff^̂
ffqqvvjjddee[[ffggffddss ppbbppqqccff&&
vvffssccff uueekktt,,ssffccff iibbyyff
ffhhcctt,,eekkccff^̂ llff
..vvtt,,ffllmm]]tteekkyybb^̂ ggbbhh-
bbccggbbhh nnff[[nnccffhhtt]]kktt,,pptt
vvcc[[lljjvvffhhttyybb
((bbuuffyy]][[hhjjvvtt,,ttyy))&& ffhh
uuffttrrffhhtt,,ffss bbmm((iibb)) vvffss
llffqqkkbbkkjj,,ff llff
ffhh]]ffhhffccjjllttcc bbmmbbllffyy ffhh
bbmmyytt,,bbffyy bbccbbyybb
uuffvvjj//uuddhhbbkkyybb##&&
(cehf-/bwhb^
fbfsb 45-48)&
cb]j][kt]f lf cbrdlbkb] fkkf-
/vf lffotcf& 'dtkfathb^ hf] cekbt-
hbf ltlfvbofpt^ b,flt,f^ xylt,f^ ][j-
dhj,c lf rdlt,f& itvjlujvfpt ajsk-
t,b bo't,ty uf'dbskt,fc lf ]dtyfc* uf-
pfa[ekbc lflujvfcsfy thsfl [tt,b
bo't,ty ufvodfyt,fc^ f'dfdlt,bfy lf yf-
'jac b.ktdbfy& fctf flfvbfyt,b]& ths
lqtc 'dtkf flfvbfyb eylf vjrdltc^
vfuhfv cbrdlbkb 'dtkfahbc lfcfche-
kb fhff^ bc f[fkb^ ufyc[dfdt,ekb lf
vfhflbekb ][jdht,bc lfcfo'bcbf&
bct^ hjujh] 'dtkf fhct,f^ cfv'fh-
j]^ hjvtkib] xdty d][jdhj,s^ lfc-
hekt,flbf& cfv'fhjc lfchekt,fcf lf
ufyflueht,fc 'bfvtsbc lqt /mdbf&
'bfvtsbc vjcdkbc lhj fkkf/bc uf-
hlf fhfdby b]bc& bc vjekjlytkfl
vjdf& 'bfvtsbc itvlujvb gthbjlb cfbm-
bjc ][jdht,ff&
4& cfbmbj w[jdht,f
h
o
v
t
y
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
16
fkkf/vf vbobthb ][jdht,f flfvbfysf ufvjcf]ltkfl uffxbyf&
fkkf/b vbcb ,h.fyt,t,bc itvchekt,kt,c lf fhfitvchekt,kt-
,cf] cfbmbjib cfvfhskbfyfl ufycwbc& fvmdt'ybehb ][jdht,f cf-
bmbjc cfvpflbcbf& xdtyc vbth ufrtsdt,ekvf cfmvtt,vf cfbmbj upf
eylf ufudbyfsjc& cfbmbj ][jdht,f 'dtkf xdtysfufybc [tkf[fkb
uf]j][kt,bcf lf cfvfhskbfyfl ufycwbc lqblfy bo't,f& ufcfv-
fhskt,bc (vf/ithbc) lqtc 'dtkf fkkf/bc obyfit ofhclut,f& fv-
mdt'yfl^ dbcf] v]bhtjltyb cbrtst fctdt seylf] v]bhtjltyb cb-
ukf[t ufertst,bf^ bm ‘jdtkbdt tctyb ufvjxylt,f&
bc^ dbyf] fvmdt'yfl fkkf/bc ,h.fyt,t,bc itcf,fvbcfl fh b][-
jdhf^ fh vjbyfybf lf fh tgfnbf^ lfcfcwtkfl wjwj[tsib ofdf&
bcbyb rb^ dby] fkkf/bc ,h.fyt,t,bc itcf,fvbcfl b][jdhtc^ yf-
bh-yfbhb wbkljt,bs^ 'jdtkudfhb [bkbsf lf cfhxjsb fqcfd-
ct cfvjs[tib b][jdht,ty& vfssdbc bm fh] vodtkb cb][tf lf
fh] ufv'byfdb cb]bdt& bc^ hf] sdfkt,c fv mdt’yfl yfyf[b fmdc
lf hf] cekcf] vjtcehdt,f^ cfvjs[tib 'dtkfahbs ufevfcg-
by.klt,bfy&
ffllffvvbbffyybb^̂ hhjjvvttkkccff]] ccffbbmmbbjj ccooffvvcc^̂ vvffyy
ª b]bc^ hjv 'dtkf vbcb cfm]btkb^ rfhubf se ]elbf^
feyfpqfeht,tkb (ufyerbs[fdb) fh lfhxt,f&
ª b]bc^ hjv cfvjs[tib vbcsdbc ufvpflt,ekb^ fkkf/bctekb
wbkljt,bc vbcfqt,fl vbcb ,h.fyt,t,bc itchekt,f
fe]bkt,tkbf
ª b]bc^ hjv fvmdt'ybehb ][jdht,f bctf^ hjujh] 'fyf^
cfbmbj rb vjcfdkbc fqt,bc lhj& fvbnjv fvmdt'ybehb
][jdht,bc 'dtkfpt rfhufl ufvj'tyt,fc ]lbkj,c&
ª b]bc^ hjv cecnbc vbth .kbthbcfufy fcfqt,bc fqt,bc lhj
etzdtkfl lflut,f* fvbnjv ecfvfhskjl fhfdbc fh
tm]tdf&
ccffvvjjss[[ttiibb ffkkkkff//vvff hhff ccff[[bbcc ccffhhxxjjtt,,bb
uubbyyllffss hhjjvv vvjjuuffhhssddffcc????
h
o
v
t
y
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
17
5& qdsbcvbthb ewdktkb rfyjyt,b$,tlbcothf lf ufyut,f
fkkf/vf cfv'fhjc ufxtyfvlt b]jlf se hf^
hjlbc lf hfyfbhfl vj[lt,jlf& bvbnjv^hjv cfv-
'fhjc ufvxtyb lf vfcib 'dtkfahbc vnrb]tl ufy-
vcfpqdhtkb sdbsjyff& fkkf/vf flfvbfyb uffxbyf
lf vjmvtlt,bcf lf m]tdbc sfdbceakt,f vbc]f& fl-
fvbfybcfsdbc tc ufvj]lff^ cojh upfc fbhxtdc se
fhfcojhc& fkkf/vf b]bc^ flfvbfyb cfresfh m]-
tdfpt hf itltuc vbbqt,c& fkkf/bc vbth 'dtkfa-
thpt pjvbcf lf hbubc obyfcofh ufycfpqdhfc^ fl-
fvbfyt,bc itcf[t, 'dtkfahbc ]jlyfcf lf vfsb
][jdht,bc ofhvfhsdfc ,tlbcothf /mdbf^ [jkj fv
]jlybc ufy[jh]btkt,fc lf c[dflfc[df vjdktyt-
,bc vj[ltyfc _ ufyut,f&
llff^̂ ffhhff ffhhcc
ffhhhhff^̂ hhbbccbb
ccffuuffyy..eehhbb]] xxddttyy
ffhh uuffuuddffxxyyllttcc^̂
llff ((vvffbbyy]])) ffhh
uuffhhllvvjjddffddkkttyyss
vvffcc^̂ uuffyyccffppqqdd-
hheekk jjllttyyjj,,ffpptt
vvttnncc&&
(cehf /bwhb^
fbfsb 21)
dby] hovtybc utvc
uf'dt,f& uflfhxt,f
flfvbfyc^ hjvtkcf] cofvc
,tlbcothf&&&
ª cwthf^ hjv fkkf/vf
'dtkfathb b]bc lf vbc ufhtit
thsb ajsjkb] rb fh
ufby.htdf&
ª 'ehflqt,fc fm]tdc fkkf/bc
vbth cfv'fhjib xfvj'fkb,t,ek
ojyfcojhj,fc lf ]lbkj,c fh
lffhqdbjc bub&
ª b]bc^ hjv fkkf/vf 'dtkfathb
thsbfyb cbcntvbs uffxbyf lf
hjujh] fv cbcntvbc thsb
yfobkb^ itv[dtlhb cb.ytktt,bc
obyfit ,h.jkbcfc fkkf/c
vbtylj,f&
h
o
v
t
y
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
18
hf/vfyb [fh* ufyehxtdkfl 'dtkfcb vjo'fkt [fh^ xdty itudbo'fkt&
hf/bvb [fh* ity vj'dfcsf cb'dfhekbs itvvrj,tkb [fh^ ityc
cf'dfhtksf hbut,ib vbudbqt
'ellecb [fh* 'jdtkudfh yfrkjdfyt,fsfufy ijhc [fh^ cb,bkobcfu-
fy ufudovbylt
ctkfvb [fh* 'jdtkudfhb cfahs[bcfufy lfv]fdb [fh^ ibibcfufy ufl-
fudfhxbyt
vevbyb [fh* uekt,pt ylj,bc vjvatyb [fh^ xdtyb itylfvb ylj,f
ufyfvnrb]t
fpbpb [fh* ecfchekj lf evfqktcb qbhct,bc gfnhjyb [fh^ xdty
eqbhcc ye ufu[dlb
vestmt,,bhb [fh* 'dtkfathpt lblb [fh^ vtlblehj,bcfufy lfudb]fdb
,ffhb [fh* 'dtkfathc thsvfytsbc itcfathc uffxty^ xdty fv sfy[vj,fc
ye xfvjudfijht,
vecfddbhb [fh* 'dtkf fhct,fc kfvfp ajhvfc f.ktd^ xdty fv cbkfvf-
pbc ityfhxeyt,bc .fkf vjudt]
qfaafhb [fh* .fkbfy^ .fkbfy^ vgfnbt,tkb [fh^ xdty ityb gfnbt,bc
ufhtit ye lfudnjdt,&
dt//f,b [fh* cfxemht,bc e[dfl vjv]tvb [fh^ xdty ityb cfxemht,bs
ufudf[fht
htppf'b [fh* 'dtkfpt cfhxjc vbv]tvb [fh^ xdtyc ceahfc eo'fkj,jl
ye lfnjdt,
atssf[b [fh* 'dtkfahbc ,jkjvlt ufvqt,b [fh^ ][dbhoby rfhc ye
lfudbrtnfd
fkbvb [fh* 'dtkfahbc chek'kabkfl v]jlyt [fh^ xdty e]jlby-
hj,bcfufy lfudbafht
ff,blb [fh* cehdbkbcfvt,h itvdbohjt,tkb [fh^ xdty ye itudfdbo-
hjdt,
,fcbsb [fh* cehdbkbcfvt,h ufvafhsjdt,tkb [fh^ xdty sfdbceakfl
vjudfsmvtdbyt cekb
‘ff,blb [fh* cehdbkbcfvt,h lfvvlf,kt,tkb [fh^ xdty ye
lfudfv]bht,
hfab [fh* cehdbkbcfvt,h fvvfqkt,tkb [fh^ xdty
fudfvfqkt
vebpb [fh* gfnbdbcf lf qbhct,bc vjv]tvb [fh^ xdty qbhct,f vjudt]
vepbkb [fh* lfvvlf,kt,tkb lf fhfhj,fl vm]tdb [fh^xdty fh lfud-
fvlf,kj
xtvj fkkf/j!
xtvj fkkf/j!
h
o
v
t
y
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
19
ctvbb [fh* afhekb^ qbf^ 'dtkfyfbhb cbn'dbc vcvtytkb [fh^ xdty itypt
it[vbfyt,bcfufy ye lfudfijht,
,fcbhb [fh* 'dtkfathc vstkb cbafmbpbs [tlfd^ xdty cbafmbpbc lfcfyf[b
sdfkt,b vjudt]
fflkb [fh* yfvldbkb cbvfhskbc ufvnfht,tkb [fh^ xdty odfkt,fc ufl-
fudfhxbyt
kfnbab [fh* cbrtst lf lbcekjdyt,f e[dfl ufmdc^ xdty cbrtsbc pqdfh-
pt udfnfht
/f,bhb [fh* 'dtkf cfmvbc itcf[t, byajhvbht,ekb [fh^ xdty xdtyc itcf[t, fhf-
byajhvbht,ekc ye lfudnjdt,
/fkbvb [fh* ityc ufxtybkt,pt kvj,bthfl vjvg'hj,b [fh^ xdty kvj,bthfl
vjg'hj,f udfcofdkt
fpbvb [fh* cblblbcf lf ,ho'bydfkt,bc gfnhjyb [fh^ xdty ye lfudfv]bht,
qfaehb [fh* ityc vjyf-vjhxbkt,pt ]jldt,bc vgfnbt,tkb [fh^ xdtyb ]jldt,b
itudbylt
itmehb [fh* vflkj,t,bc vbvqt,b [fh^ vflkbtht,bc smvbc
itcf.kt,kj,f vjudt]
/fabpb [fh* 'dtkfahbc lfv]dtkb [fh^ xdty cbukf[tt,bcfufy lfudb]fdb
/fcb,b [fh* 'dtkfathpt gfce[bc vjvs[jdyb [fh^ xdty bcts vlujvfhtj-
,fib ye xfudfult,^ hjv gfce[b dth ufu]ts
mthbvb [fh* cbrtsbcf lf gfnbdbc e[dfl ufv]tvb [fh^ xdty ueke[dj,f
udfcofdkt
hfmb,b [fh* 'dtkf fhct,bc vtsdfk'eht [fh^ ye lfbdbo't, xdtypt
sdfkbc ltdyt,fc
vewb,b [fh* s[jdyf dtlht,bc vbvqt,b [fh^ xdtyc dtlht,fc egfce[jl
ye lfnjdt,
/fmbvb [fh* 'dtkfahbc sfdbc flubkfc ufvrtst,tkb [fh^ xdty ecfhut,-
kj cfmvtt,c xfvjudfijht
dtlelb [fh* ityb vjyf-vjhxbkt,b .fkbfy ub'dfhc^ xdty cb'dfhekb
udfcofdkt
,fbcb [fh* vrdlht,bc ufv]j][kt,tkb [fh^ xdty ,tlybthfl ufudf]j][kt
it/blb [fh* 'dtkfahbc vjovt [fh^ xdtyufy itylfvb cb'dfhekbc vjovt b'fdb
/f''b [fh* thsfl thsb ztivfhbnt,f ity [fh^ xdty ztivfhbnt,f isfudfujyt
dtmbkb [fh* ity [fh bc^ dbcf] vbtylj,bfy^ xdty itypt vbylj,fc ye
lfudfdbo't,
'fdbb [fh* .fkbc gfnhjyb [fh^ xdty ityb cb'dfhekbs ufudf.kbtht
vtsbyb [fh* iteh'tdtkb [fh^ xdty xdtyb cbcecnbc fvfhf ye vbudfnjdt,
dtkb [fh* vjhoveytsf vj'dfht [fh^ xdty vj'dfhtl vbudbqt
/fvblb [fh* mt,bc qbhcb [fh^ xdty itylfvb mt,bc cbfvjdyt,f vjudfybzt
q
d
s
b
c
v
c
f
[
e
h
t
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
20
qdsbcvcf[eht,f
@@ccssmmddbb ((vvee//ffvvvvttll))%%
eettzzddttkkffll^̂ xxttvvbb
kkjj]]ddff llff xxttvvbb
oobbhhddffyybb^̂ xxttvvbb
ccbb]]jj]][[kktt llff
xxttvvbb ccbbrrddllbbkkbb
ccffvv''ffhhjjff qqvvtthhss-
bbcc-ffkkkkff//bbccssddbbccff&&##
(cehf tyfvb-cfmjytkb&
fbfsb 162)
xxttvvc
cffhoovvee
yyjjtt,ffc
ddcooffddkkjj
,
iittbbccooffddkktt^̂ uuffvvjjbbrrddkkbbtt ^̂ bbaabbmmhhtt
1& mtkbvtb it/fltsb^ yfvfpb (kj]df) vfh[-
df^ ptmfsb lf /fwb eahjct,c ittrbs[ts^ fv
cbn'dfsf vybidytkj,t,bc fy kj]dt,bc itcf[-
t, ktmcb^ vjs[hj,f fy ufvj]fyf b]bfy se
fhf& hfcf] bcofdkbs^ hdtekib xfothts&
2& fv rfhbc vt]flbytj,bc gthbjlib fv[-
fyfut,sfy itsfy[vt,bs sbsj rdbhf sbsjtek
cfrbs[c lfesvts% wfvtt,bcf lf cfcekbthj
gbhsf rdbhtekb^ ufzbhdt,eksf lf[vfht,bc
rdbhtekb lf c[df&
3& fkkf/bc cb'dfhekbc vjgjdt,bc vbpybs
ufrdst,ekb 'dtkf cfmvt qdsbcvcf[eht,ff& 'j-
dtklqbehb ][jdht,bc vfufkbst,bs fv cfrb-
s[pt fv[fyfut,sfy bcfe,hts&
4& hfvfpybc sdt hfnjvff vybidytkjdfyb lf
hfnjvff 'flbhbc qfvt fsfc sdtpt vtnfl [t-
bhbfyb&
5& ,tdhb brbs[ts obuyt,b htkbubbc rek-
nehbcf lf ,fdidsf fqphlbc
itcf[t,& mdtvjs vj]tvekb lbfytsbc cfmvt-
sf ufvjv]tvkj,bc obuyt,blfy
qdsbcvcf[eht,bc itcf[t, fhct,ekb itvlt-
ub sfdt,b ofbrbs[ts%
f& wb,bc bkvb/fkb^ vt/vts cjbvtyb
,& hfvfpfyb lf vfh[df^ ctbatssby bfpbwb
u& frh.fkekt,b lf lblb ]jldt,b bckfvbc
htkbubfib& kesab itysehmb
q
d
s
b
c
v
c
f
[
e
h
t
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
21
qdsbcvcf[eht,f qvthspt uekbsflfl vbv[hj,f^ vbc
obyfit mtlbc vj[hf lf vfcpt vb'jkff& qdsbcvcf[eht,f
ufvxtybc cb'dfhekbc itltubf lf v[jkjl fkkf/bcfsd-
bc rtslt,f& 'dtkf qdsbcvcf[eht,fib qvthsbc hovtyff
ufvj[fnekb& flfvbfyb ufvxtybc cb'dfhekc hjujh
ufvjfdktyc? fy se b]bc dbyvtv^ hbs bmyt,f bub rvf'-
jabkb?
fkkf/vf 'ehfyib .dbhafc iefvfdfkc fct e,h.fyf%
es[fhb (ve/fvvtl)% se fkkf/b ub'dfhs^ vfiby vjv'tdbs
vt^ hjv fkkf/vf itub'dfhjc smdty lf itubyljs smd-
tydt ]jldt,b^ fkkf/b itvylj,b lf itvo'yfhjt,tkbf&#
cehf fkb bvhfyb^ fbfsb 31) tct bub^ qdsbcvcf[eht,f
v[jkjl xdtyc .dbhafc iefvfdfkpt lfwtht,bs^ vbc
upfpt uf'jkbsff itcf.kt,tkb& hf smvf eylf^ 'dtkf
qdsbcvcf[eht,bc fhcb^ fkkf/cf lf .dbhafc iefvfdfkpt
lfwtht,f lf vfspt lfvjrblt,ekt,bc ufvj[fndff^
hjvtkb] mtkbvtb it/fltsibf xfvj'fkb,t,ekb%
hovtyblfy vjvlbyfht flfvbfybc lflt,bsb lf
cfcfhut,kj 'dtkf cfmvt qdsbcvcf[eht,fl bsdkt,f&
fkkf/bc upfpt ufhwf^ cbrtstpt^ of[fkbct,f^ ,jhjnt-
,fpt oby fqlujvf^ 'ehfybc rbs[df yfvfpb^ vfh[df^ ptmf-
sb lf fct itvltu bckfvbc .bhbsflb qdsbcvcf[eht,t,bf&
fv qdsbcvcf[eht,fsf lhjc^ flubkbc^ itchekt,bc aj-
hvfcf lf hfjltyj,fc xdtyb cfhoveyjt,f udfcofdkbc& zr-
dbfy^ vjobaek lf cfzbhj gbhj,t,bc vmjyt 'dtkf vec-
kbvfyc fv qdsbcvcf[eht,fsf itchekt,f tdfkt,f& fv sd-
bct,t,bc vmjyt flfvbfyc vemtkktab (gfce[bcvut,tkb)
/mdbf&
mmttkkbbvvttbb iitt//ffllttssbb%% vvwwtthhff^̂ hhjjvv ffkkkkff//bbcc uuffhhllff cc[[ddff
qqvvtthhssbb ffhh ffhhcctt,,jj,,cc llff vvjjoovvtt ddffhh^̂ hhjjvv vvee//ffvvvvttllbb vvbbccbb
vvccff[[eehhbb llff iieeffvvffddffkkbbff&&
q
d
s
b
c
v
c
f
[
e
h
t
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
22
llffssddffkkttss tthhssbb llqqbbcc uuffyyvvffddkkjj,,ffiibb
yyffkkjj]]bb [[eessbb yyffvvffppbbcc kkjj]]ddbbccffcc
ccbbnn''ddff @@ffkkkkff//ee ttmm,,tthh##-cc hhffvvllttyywwtthh ddbbvvttjjhhtt,,ss&&
eeaahhjjcctt,,ssffyy tthhssffll bbvvccwwttkkttss ffvv ccbbnn''ddbbcc
vvyybbiiddyyttkkjj,,ffccff llff xxddttyycc ''jjddttkkllqqbbeehh ]][[jjddhhtt,,ffiibb
vvbbccbb fflluubbkkbbcc iittccff[[tt,,&&&&
aaffhh..bb ((ccffddffkklltt,,eekkjj))
vjmvtlt,t,b^ hjvtksf itchekt,fcf] xdtyb cfhoveyjt,f fe]-
bkt,kfl vjbs[jdc lf 'dtkf vjobaekbc v[hblfy fe]bkt,kfl
ufcfrtst,tkbf^ itechekt,kj,f rb ]jldfl bsdkt,f& vfufkbsfl
yfvfpbc kj]df^ cfvfhskbfyfl vjm]tdf& cbn'dbc fh ufnt[f&
/fhfvb (frh.fkekb)
vjmvtlt,t,b^ hjvkt,cf] xdtyb cfhoveyjt,f vstkb cbvrf]hbs
rh.fkfdc^ bc hf] veckbvfyvf fh eylf uffrtsjc^ se uffrtst,c
]jldfc xfbltyc& hjujhb]ff vfufkbsfl% n'ebkbc smvf^ zjhfj,f^
mehlj,f lf c[df&
ceyytsb (iefvfdkbc yfvjmvtlfhb)
vjmvtlt,t,b^ hjvkt,cf] xdtyb iefvfdfkb frtst,lf lf hjvt-
ksf ufrtst,fcf] ehxtdlf flfvbfyt,c^ hjujhb]ff vfufkbsfl%
flfvbfysf vbvfhs vjvqbvfhb cf[bs 'jayf& r,bkt,bc vjdkf^ rj-
[nfl xf]vf lf c[df&
vtmhe/b (vjeojyfhb)
vjmvtlt,t,b^ hjvkt,b] xdtyc cfhoveyjt,fib brh.fkt,f^ vfuh-
fv vbcb frh.fkekj,f vnrb]t cfvnrb]tt,c fh t'hlyj,f& hju-
jhb]ff vfufkbsfl% kj]dbcfc c[df hfvtpt 'ehflqt,bc vbm]tdf
lf c[df&
ve/f,b
vjmvtlt,t,b^ hjvtksf ufrtst,bc v[hbd veckbvfyt,c bckfvb fh-
xtdfyc enjdt,c& hjujhb]ff vfufkbsfl% .bkb^ ctbhyj,f^ pj-
vbtht,bs dfzhj,f lf c[df&
q
d
s
b
c
v
c
f
[
e
h
t
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
23
rrffhhbb ggbbhhddttkkbb
qvthsbc obyfit lqtib[es]th kjwdf$ yfvfpb
bckfvbc .bhbsfl gbhj,fsfufy ths-thsb yfvf-
pbc kj]dff _ qvthsbc uf[ctyt,f lf vfcpt
dtlht,bc vbpybs ufhrdtek lhjt,ib^ ufhrdtekb
hbnefkbs lqtib [eswth itcfchekt,t,kb
afh.bf& yfvfpb flfvbfyc cekbthfl qvthssfy
ffvfqkt,c& bub hovtybc itvltu cfhoveyjt,bc
'dtkfpt vybidytkjdfyb ,h.fyt,ff&
yfvfpbc lhjekb itchekt,f^ fkkf/bc 'dtkf-
pt cf'dfhtkb mvtlt,ff& bckfvbc obyf htkbubt,-
ib] kj]df afh.b b'j& hfbvt ufvjedfkb vbptp-
bc ufhtit kj]dbc itechekt,kj,f lblb
]jldff& yfvfpbc kj]df cfdfklt,ekjf vfibyf]^
hj]f o'fkb fh vjbgjdt,f (stbtvvevbs)^ [jkj
fdflv'jaj,bcfc vwljvfhtl fy vojkbfhtl
kj]df] itb.kt,f&
@@eettzzddttkkffll^̂ vvtt
ddffhh ffkkkkff//bb^̂ ffhh
ffhhcctt,,jj,,cc
qqvvtthhssbb uuffhhllff
xxttvvbbccff&& ffvvbbnnjjvv
vvttssff''ddffyytt vvtt llff
iittffcchheekktt yyffvvff-
ppbb xxttvvbb
[[ccttyytt,,bbccffssddbbcc##&&
(cehf nf /f^
fbfsb 14)
kkjj]]ddff^̂ hhoovvttyybbcc ccff..bbhhrrddttkkbb^̂
vvjjhhoovveeyybbcc ffvvffqqkktt,,ffff^̂
xxddttyybb ssddffkkbbcc ccbbyyffsskkttff^̂
ccffvvjjss[[bbcc uuffccffqqtt,,bbff&&
q
d
s
b
c
v
c
f
[
e
h
t
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
24
yyffvvffppbbcc aaffhh..tt,,bb ((ffee]]bbkktt,,kkjj,,tt,,bb))
yfvfpc 12 afh.b fmdc& 6 kj]dbc lfo't,fvlt rtslt,f^ vfs kj]dbc
ufht gbhj,t,b /mdbf& 6 rb kj]dbc ibuybs [jh]btklt,f^ vfs
kj]dbc iblf gbhj,t,b /mdbf&
I& yfvfpbc gbhj,t,bkj]df flfvbfycf lf fkkf/c ijhbc thsudfhb it[dtlhff& fctsb
vybidytkjdfyb it[dtlhf vjevpflt,kfl fh itb.kt,f& kj]dbcfsdbc
vjcfvpflt,tkb gbhj,t,bf%
1& /fltcbcfufy sf/fhtsb - fye cekbthb cb,by.ehbcfufy
ufceasfdt,f& flfvbfyb ufvxtybc obyfit 'jdtkudfhb
efh'jabsbcfufy ufyovtylbkb lf ufceasfdt,ekb eylf
ofhclutc^ f,ltcb lf qeckb^ kj]dfvlt ufceasfdt,fc
ybiyfdc&
2& ytwfctsbcfufy sf/fhtsb - cfkj]fdb flubkb lf vkj]dtkbc
nfycf]vtkb^ hjvtkb] vfc f]dbf^ ceasf eylf b'jc& xdtyb
.dbhafcb iefvfdfkb ,h.fyt,c% @cbceasfdt kj]dbc ufcfqt,bf#&
3& ctshb fdhtsb - cfcbh][j flubkt,bc lfafhdfc /mdbf&
yfvfpbc vkj]dtkvf kj]dbc lhjc c[tekbc pjubthsb
flubkb eylf lfbafhjc&
4& bcsb',fkb 'b,kt - mff,tc vbvfhsekt,bs lujvfc ybiyfdc^
uekbs fkkf/bcfrty vbg'hj,fc ufvj[fnfdc&
5& df’bs - 'dtkf kj]dfc sfdbcb lhj fmdc lf bv lhjc
bkj]t,f& xf.byt,bc fy lfdbo't,bc itvs[dtdfib sfdbc lhjpt
itechekt,tkb yfvfpbc kj]dfcf] sfdbcb fmdc&
6& (ybtsb) ufyphf[df - kj]df
ufycfpqdhekb vjmvtlt,bc
v[jkjl abpbrehb itchekt,f fhff& bub
fv vjmvtlt,bc bubdt kj]dbc^
fkkf/bcflvb dfklt,ekt,bc vbpybs
cekbthb ufyo'j,bc itmvyff^ hfcf]
sfyf[kfdc c[dflfc[df ibyffhcbc
ntmcnt,bc ofhvjsmvf&
q
d
s
b
c
v
c
f
[
e
h
t
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
25
(ve/fvvtl) ofbrbs[t obuyb ('ehfyb)^
hjvtkb] isfutujyf lf itfchekt kj]df
- yfvfpb& etzdtkfl kj]df - yfvfpb (flfvb-
fyc) eyfvecj,fcf lf cbukf[tc lff]bkt,c
esejl^ fkkf/bc [ctyt,f 'dtkfpt elblt-
cbf lf fkkf/vf eo'bc hfcf] cxflb[fhs#
(cehf fymt,es-j,j,f^ fbfsb 45)
II&& kkjj]]ddbbcc iibbllff ccffddffkklltt,,eekkjj ggbbhhjj,,tt,,bb
flfvbfyb^ hjvtkvf] kj]dbc ufht cfdfklt,-
ekj gbhj,t,b itfchekf^ erdt ite.kbf yfvfpb
bkj]jc& kj]dbc lhjcf] fhct,j,c fe]bkt,t-
kb itcfchekt,tkb gbhj,t,b^ hjvtkcf] yfvfp-
bc iblf cfdfklt,ekhj gbhj,t,b /mdbf& tctybf%
11&& basbsf/ (cfo'bcb) stm,bhb - 'dtkf kj]-
df fe]bkt,kfl fkkf/bc lblt,bc ufvjv[fndt-
kb cbn’df^ @fkkf/e tm,th#-bc smvbs bo't,f&
22&& 'bfvb (lujvf) -dbcf] .fkf itcotdc^ kj]df
at[pt lujvbs eylf itfchekjc&
33&& 'bhffsb (rbs[df) - 'ehfybc fbfst,bc rbs[df
44&& hemeqb (otkib vj[hf) - [tkt,bc ve[kt-
,pt lfo'j,bs fkkf/bc obyfit otkib vj[hf&
55&& ctwlt-fkkf/bc obyfit^ ie,kbs^ ][dbhbs^
jhbdt ve[kbs^ [tkt,bs^ at[bc sbst,bs .bhc
it[t,f
66&& ‘fltb f[bht (,jkj lfwljvf)-kj]dbc ,j-
kjc tsst/bbfsbc^ dtlht,bc (lebc) rbs[dbc lf-
vsfdht,fvlt vj]lff&
hflufyf] cfhoveyjt,bc fhcb thsqvthsb-
fyj,fib vlujvfhtj,c& kj]dbc wueaehfl (wf-
vffsbs) itchekt,f ertstcbf^ fvfcsfy thsfl bc-
tsb kj]dt,b] fhct,j,c^ hjvtksf itchekt,f
wueaehflff fe]bkt,tkb& fctst,bf% rdbhfib
ths[tk wevbc (gfhfcrtdbc) kj]df lf otk-
boflib jhwth ,fbhfvbc kj]df&
vvee//ffvvvvttll iieeffvvffdd-
ffkkvvff tthhss llqqttcc
ffvv[[ffyyffuutt,,cc eess[[hhff%%
@@ssmmddttyycc rrffhhtt,,ssffyy
vvllbbyyffhhtt^̂ hhjjvv
vvbbttllbbyytt,,jjllttcc llff
llqqttiibb [[eesswwtthh
hhjjvv llffbb,,ffyyjjss^̂
hhffbbvvtt zzeezz''bb
llffuuhhxxtt,,ffssjj??## @@
ffhhff##- wweeggffccee[[ttcc
ffvv[[ffyyffuutt,,vvff&& vvffiibbyy
iieeffvvffddffkkvvff
,,hh..ffyyff%%@@ffbb [[eessbb
llhhjjbbcc yyffvvffppbbcc
kkjj]]ddff]] ffccttff&&
ffkkkkff//bb ffllffvvbbffyycc
yyffvvffppbbcc kkjj]]ddbbss
]]jjllddtt,,bbccffuuffyy
ffssffddbbcceeaakktt,,cc##
(ovbylf /flbcb)&
q
d
s
b
c
v
c
f
[
e
h
t
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
26
uuffyy,,ffyyddbbcc aaffhh..tt,,bb
1& gbhbc qhec ufvj,fyf
2& ][dbhbc qhec ufvj,fyf
3& vstkb c[tekbc lf,fyf
ff,,llttccbbcc aaffhh..tt,,bb
1& [tkt,bcf lf gbhbcf[bc lf,fyf
2& vrkfdt,bc lf,fyf blf'dt,bc xfsdkbs
3& sfdbc^ cek ]jnf thsb vtjs[tlb yfobkbc lfcdtkt,f -
vtc/b
4& at[t,bc lf,fyf rjzt,bc xfsdkbs&
ssttbbttvveevvbbcc aaffhh..tt,,bb
1& ufyphf[df -ybtsbc ufrtst,f
2& ceasf vbofot [tkt,bs jhwth it[t,f^ gbhdtkb it[t,bcfc
cf[tpt [tkt,bc xfvjcvf^ vtjht it[t,bcfc vrkfdt,pt [tkbc
vjcvf (vtc/bc ufrtst,f)&
ufvjbrdkbts mdtvjs
vj]tvekb vtxtsbc
utuvf& vtxtsbc
[tkv.qdfytkbc
vbth utuvfpt ]baht,bs
fqybiyekb yfobkt,bc
cf[tkt,b itbcofdkts
lf lfothts&
4
5
6
3
2
1
q
d
s
b
c
v
c
f
[
e
h
t
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
27
ffllffvvbbffyybb^̂ hhjjvvttkkbb]] ffcchheekktt,,cc kkjj]]ddffcc
ª 'dtkf ,by.ehb lf ]elb vjmvtlt,bcfufy lf]ekbf&
fkkf/bc cblbflbc [ibhfl [ctyt,bs vbclfvb hovtyfc
b.kbtht,c&
ª 'jdtksdbc qvthsc b[ctyt,c^ vstk lqtc 'dtkf vjmvtlt,bs
]lbkj,c fkkf/bc rvf'jabkt,f vjbgjdjc&
ª f,ltcc fbqt,c lf sfdbc cbceasfdtc vbfm]tdc 'ehflqt,fc^
ceasfl 'jayfc txdtdf&
ª ufhlf fcvbcf^ f,ltcb vfc cekbth cbvnrb]tc /vfnt,c&
ª lfotct,ek lhjt,ib yfvfpbc kj]dbs cf][jdht,tkb
lhjbc lfutuvdfc cofdkj,c&
ª ufhrdtekb lhjbc vjyfrdtst,ib 'jdtklqbeh
][jdht,bctek cfmvtc^ af]bae]cf lf iajsc ufyijhlt,f
lf qvthssfy lfrfdibht,bc ,tlybtht,fc tpbfht,f&
ª tvjhxbkt,f lblb fkf/bc ,h.fyt,fc% @/tb^ vjhoveytyj!
t.bts lf[vfht,f (fkkf/bcf) vjsvbyt,fib lf kj]dfib^ bc
etzdtkfl vjvsvtyt,sfyff#& (cehf aehb ,f'fhf^ fbfsb 153)
yfvfpbc kj]dbs ufbyfst,c cekc lf ufb.kbtht,c hovtyfc&
ª t.ktdf cfiefkt,f^lhj lf flubkb^ hfsf ufvj[fnjc
fkkf/bcflvb vflkbtht,f c[tekbs^ tybs^
ujyt,bs^ uekbs&
q
d
s
b
c
v
c
f
[
e
h
t
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
28
rrffhhbb vvttjjhhtt
wel cfmvtsfufy xfvjijht,bcvfcofdkt,tkb$ vfh[df
hfvfpfybc sdbc vfh[df^ bckfvbc ths-thsb
.bhbsflb cfae.dtksfufybf& vfh[df fhbc vec-
kbvfybc vbth lbkbc ]bcrhblfy cfqfvjvlt it-
uyt,ekfl zfvbcf lf cvbcfufy sfditrfdt,f^
cmtcj,hbdb rfdibhbc ufvjhb][df& vfh[df fk-
kf/bc rvf'jabkt,bc vjgjdt,bc vbpybs eylf
itchekltc&
flfvbfyvf itcf.kt,tkbf vupfdhj,bcf lf
fdflv'jaj,bc lhjc fh bvfh[jc^ vfuhfv hj-
]f fvudfhb vlujvfhtj,f lfcheklt,f^ ufvjn-
jdt,ekb vfh[df eylf ffyfpqfehjc^ dbcf] fm-
dc bctsb iteo'dtntkb fdflv'jaj,f^ hjvtk-
b] vfh[dfib [tkc eikbc^ bc 'jdtkb evfh[fdb
lqbc cfyf]dkjl ths ufvjcfc'blc - ablbtc
ufc]tvc^ bc^ dby] fh vfh[ekj,c lf vjthbl-
t,f zfvfcf lf cvfc^ c[df vfh[eksf sfylfcoh-
t,bs^ tc bmyt,f vbc vbth vfh[ekj,bcf lf hf-
vfpybc sdbcflvb gfnbdbc]tvf& cfqfvjc cthj,bc
(bashbc) lhjvlt ituyt,ekfl hfbvtc zfvf^
cvf lf cmtcj,hbdb rfdibhb vfh[dfc ufnt[c&
@@//ttbb^̂ vvjjhhoovveeyyttyyjj!!
ssmmddttyy llffuuttdd-
ffkklltt,,eekkffss
vvffhh[[ddff^̂ hhjjuujjhh]]
llffttddffkklltt,,ee-
kkff ttcc ssmmddttyycc
oobbyyffvvjjhh,,ttllss&&
bbvvttllbbff^̂ ssmmddttyy
qqddssbbcc vvjjiibbiiyybb
bbmmyytt,,bbss&&##
(cehf aehb-
,f'fhf fbfsb 183)
hhffcc yybbiiyyffddcc vvffhh[[ddff^̂ vvffhh[[ddbbcc ''jjddttkkllqqbbee-
hhbb llffcchheekktt,,ff^̂ vvffhh[[ddbbcc uuffnntt[[ff^̂
vvjjyyff[[ttss kkttmmccbbrrjjyytt,,iibb^̂ //rrbbss[[ttss eeaahhjjcctt,,cc llff
bbccooffddkkttss vvffssbb vvyybbiiddyyttkkjj,,tt,,bb&&
q
d
s
b
c
v
c
f
[
e
h
t
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
29
bvcfmb% vfh[dbc lfo't,bc lhj& ufysbflfvlt ]jnfsb flht&
lbkbc yfvfpbc lhjbc lfcfo'bcb&
basfhb% vfh[dbc 'jdtklqbehb lfvsfdht,bc lhj^ vpbc xfcdk-
bcf lf cfqfvjc yfvfpbc lhjbc lfcfo'bcb&
'fpf% hfvfpybc sdtib vupfdhj,bc fy fdflv'jaj,bc ufvj vfh[-
dbc itechekt,kj,bc itvltu^ [tkcf'htk lhjc^ ufvjnjdt,ekb
sbsjtekb lqbcfsdbc thsb lqbc vfh[dbs fyfpqfeht,f&
ablbt% gbhjdyt,bc vbth sfdbc lhjpt ufvjnjdt,ekb^ itvlt-
uib rb cfgfnbj vbptpbc ufvj feyfpqfeht,tkb thsb lqbc vfh[-
dbc cfyf]dkjl qfhb,pt bvltyb cfzvkbc cfafcehbc vb]tvf^ hfvl-
tycf] ths lqtib sfdfl zfvc^ fy thsb qfhb,bc thsb lqbs lfge-
ht,f&&
ffllffvvbbffyybb^̂ hhjjvvttkkbb]] vvffhh[[eekkjj,,cc
ª ufycfresht,ekb wbkljc vbqt,bc eakt,fc vjbgjdt,c& ve/fvvtl
iefvfdfkb udfv]yj,c fkkf/bc ,h.fyt,fc% @@vvffhh[[ddff xxttvvssddbbccffff^̂ vvbbcc
ccffppqqffeehhcc vvtt uuffdd]]ttvv## (ovbylf /flbcb)&
ª sfdbcbdt yt,bs fbqt,c [tkc sfdbc ]el cehdbkt,pt lf
sfdlfzthbkj,fc bcofdkbc&
ª ibvibkbsf lf o'ehdbkbs ufvjodtekb cb.ytkbc ufy]lbs
ufb.kbtht,c fvnfyj,fcf lf vjsvbyt,fc& ve/fvvtl iefvfdfkb
,h.fyt,c% @@vvffhh[[ddff vvjjssvvbbyytt,,bbcc yyff[[ttddffhhbbff## (ovbylf /flbcb)&
ª sfdbc ecfpqdhj cehdbkt,cf lf dyt,t,c lfbjrt,c^ flfvbfysf
ijhbc ecbfvjdyt,bc vjvnfy pqdfhuflfcek cfm]btkc lfsvj,c&
ª tyfc e]typehj lf e[fvcb cbn'dt,bcfufy lfb]fdc& ve/fvvtl
iefvfdfkb ,h.fyt,c% @@ssee rrbb ddbbyyvvtt rrbbyyrrkkffjj,,ffcc ffyy xx[[ee,,cc
llffuubboo''tt,,ss^̂ eess[[ffhhbbss^̂ vvffhh[[eekkbb ddffhhjj## (ovbylf /flbcb)
ª vfcpt eahj ufzbhdt,fib v'jasf vlujvfhtj,fc vb[dlt,f lf vfs
lfcf[vfht,kfl 'dtkf qjytc b[vfhc&
ª b]bc^ hjv vfh[dbs^ hovtybsf lf cfvfubthjc v[jkjl fkkf/bcfufy
kjlbybs^ ofhcekib xfltybkb ]jldt,b tgfnbt,f lf
cb]j][kbc lfhxtybk lhjc ovbylfl ufnfht,fc
itelut,f^ ]jldt,bcf lf cbukf[tt,bcfufy ijhc lflut,f&
ª lfhoveylt,f^ hjv sthsvtnb sdbc ufyvfdkj,fib 'jdtklqbehb
][jdht,bc hbnvbc it]dkf ite.kbf& fvudfhfl^ sdbsjyf] vb[dlt,f^
hjv cbrtsbcf lf cbkfvfpbcfrty itvj,heyt,f itcf.kt,tkbf&
q
d
s
b
c
v
c
f
[
e
h
t
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
30
mdtvjs vj]tvekbf lqbehbc thsb yfobkb& bub ufcfhsj,fl
ofbrbd[ts^ hflufy pjubthsb cbn'df lfibahekbf^ c]flts
fvj[cyfs ibahb&
tthhssbb ddffhhllbbcc aajjssjjkkbb vvjjuujjyytt,,ffssff hhddtteekkiibb
2255 llttrrttvv,,tthhbb^̂
lqtc xdtyc jwf[ib v[bfhekt,ff& ltlfv cfvpfhtekjib cfmvtt,b
vjfsfdf lf cfxmfhjl cf'blkt,pt ufdblf& ,f,ef ,t,bfc 'fdbc vjleq-
t,fc s[jdc& ,t,bf vfc fahs[bkt,c& ,f,ef fv,j,c% @ye vcf'dtlehj,&
vstkb &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& sdbc ufyvfdkj,fib vt ity 'fdfc fqfh vjus[jd#&
,f,ef 'fdbc ufhtit dth uf.kt,c^ dyf[js sfdbc cbn'dfc hjujh itf-
chekt,c& lqtc gbhdtkb &&&&&&&&&&&&&& yfvfpb eylf itchekltc& gbhdtk
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& eylf fdluts&
ltlfc des[fhb^ hjv oktekc hfvfpfyib sfdblfy ,jkjvlt
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& dbvfh[ekt,lb^ .fkbfy ufe[fhlf& df[ivj,bc itvltu f,ltcb
fdbqts lf wfvtib ofdtlbs& wfvt [fk[bs b'j cfdct& kj]dbc itvltu
wfvblfy ufvjvcdktk flfvbfyt,c de]mbht lf tysepbfpvbs fqcfdct
pqdf [fk[b hjv dyf[t^ qvthsbcflvb vflkbtht,f ufvjdsmdb&
2266 llttrrttvv,,tthhbb
crjkfib lfvfdbo'lf^ hjv vfh[ekb db'fdb lf o'fkb lfdkbt& ,t-
,bfv fvb[cyf^ hjv fvbs vfh[df fh ufnt[bkf^ hflufy tc ituyt,ekfl
fh ufvbrtst,bf lf vbs[hf% @ity fkkf/c e'dfh[fh& yf[t^ hjujh lf-
ut[vfhf o'ehdbkbc vjrdkfib& @vt] vb'dfhc fkkf/b#-degfce[t vt& hj-
]f vjvibdlf^ ,f,efv vbhxbf^ hfbvtsb ufdhsj,bkb'fdb& xtvc vbth yf-
[ek ufcfhsj,ib sdbsjyf] xfdbshbt& thsfl fvjd[ctybs ufptsib uf-
vjmdt'yt,ekb vfh[dbc rhjcdjhlb& vt rbs[dt,b ofdbrbs[t& ,f,efv gf-
ce[t,b ufc]f& e/! hfvltyb hfv b]bc ,f,extvvf&
ltlfv hfvfpfybcfsdbc ufycfresht,ekb ht]tgnbs nr,bktekb lf-
fvpflf& hj]f nr,bktekbfyb staib oby vbdbxjxt^ ,f,efv vbs[hf%
@&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& ceahf 'dtkfpt cfertstcj vjvtynbf bvbcfsdbc^ hjv flfvb-
fyvf vjsvbyt,f lf phlbkj,f fcofdkjc cfresfh sfdc&# lf sfdpt [t-
kb uflfvbcdf& &&&&&&&&&&&& rbs[dfvlt ]jnf lhj b'j lfhxtybkb& lhj .f-
kbfy ytkf uflbjlf& &&&&&&&&& [vf ufbcvf @qvthsj xtvj^ hf rfhubf tc
tpybc [vf# -dsmdb vt& 'dtkfv ufbqbvf&
q
d
s
b
c
v
c
f
[
e
h
t
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
31
rrffhhbb vvttccffvvtt
1& fkkf/bc ,j't,eksfufyvbcsdbcdt lf[fh}df$ ptmfsbbckfvbc .bhbsflb cfae.dkt,blfy ths-thsb ptm-
fsbf& ptmfsb mjyt,bs ufotekb qdsbcvcf[eht,ff& pt-
mfsb ybiyfdc^ hjv gbhflb cfzbhjt,t,bc lfrvf'jab-
kt,bc itvltu^ thsb okbc ufyvfdkj,fib ityf[ekb
ufhrdtekb hfjltyj,bc mjyt,blfy ufhrdtekb yfob-
kb (.bhbsflfl jhvj]blfy thsb) otkboflib ths-
[tk ufzbhdt,ekt,c eylf vbt]tc& ptmfsb^ 'ehfyib
sbsmvbc ‘dtkufy yfvfpsfy thsflff yf[ctyt,b& tct
bub^ ptmfsvf veckbvfybc ][jdht,fib yfvfpbc vcufd-
cfl vfcbehb flubkb eylf lfbzbhjc% @fkkf/vf vt
cb]j][kbc vfy.bkpt kj]df lf ptmfsb vb,h.fyf#
(cehf vthbtvb^ fbfsb 31)
ptmfsb fhbc^ fhf vlblhbc o'fkj,f qfhb,bc vbv-
fhs^ fhfvtl qfhb,bc obkb vlblhbc mjyt,blfy& @vl-
blhbc mjyt,fib obkb fmdc lf[vfht,bc vs[jdytkcf
lf e.keh-eemjytkc# (cehf pfhbfsb^ fbfsb 19)& vl-
blfhvf flfvbfyvf ptmfsbc vb]tvbcfc eylf t]fljc^
hjv ptmfsbc fvqt,c uekb fh fnrbyjc^ hflufy cb-
rtsbc ufrtst,f lf itvltu lf'dtlht,f cbrtsbc aez-
fl xfdkbc vbptpb uf[lt,f^ itb.kt,f thsb it[tldbs
xfyltc^ hjv ptmfsbc uflf[lbs mjyt,f rkt,ekj,c^
vfuhfv mjyt,f hjvkbc ptmfsb] uflf[lbkbf^ fkk-
f/bc vj]tvekb ,fhfmfsb ufvhfdklt,f& @vfufkbsb
bvfsb^ dby] sfdbfys mjyt,fc fkkf/bc upfpt [fhw-
fdty^ /ufdc vfufkbsc vfh]dkbcfc^ hjvtkb] idblb
sfdsfdbs fqvjf]tyf lf sbsjtek bv sfdsfdib fcb
vfh]dfkbf& fkkf/b evhfdkt,c bvfc^ dbcsdbcf] /c-
ehc& fkkf/b 'jdkbcvjv]dtkb lf v]jlytf&# (ce-
hf aehb-,f'fhf^ fbfsb 261)&
vvbbbbqqtt vvffssbb
mmjjyytt,,bbllffyy
ccffvvjjoo''ffkkjj -
ppttmmffssbb^̂ hhffssff
vvbbccbbss uuffyy-
bboovvbbyylljj llff
uuffyyffvvhhssttkklltt
llff llffkkjj]]tt
bbccbbyybb&&&&&&
(ffkfab - yflfd-
kb^ fbfsb 103)
@esejl
uflfhxyty
vjhoveytt,b^
hjvkt,b]
sfdbfysb
kj]dbcfc
vjibiyb fhbfy
lf hjvkt,b]
efphjcufy
pehuitm]tekyb
fhbfy lf
hjvtkt,b]
ptmfsbc
uflfv[ltkyb
fhbfy#
(cehf vjhoveytyb^
fbfsb 1_4)
q
d
s
b
c
v
c
f
[
e
h
t
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
32
ppttmmffssbbcc ssddffkkccffpphhbbccbbss
iittffaaffccttss mmddttvvjjss vvjj]]ttvveekkbb
bbyyeecc ttvvhhttcc kkttmmccbb llff ssmmddttyybb
iitt[[ttlleekktt,,tt,,bb ffvv[[ffyyffuutt,,cc
uuffeeppbbffhhttss&&
mmjjyytt,,bbcc vvttggffnnhhjjyytt^̂ ccbbvvllbbllhh-
bbcc vvttggffnnhhjjyytt^̂ ff,,ff^̂ vvbbss[[ffhh ccffll
ffhhbbcc ggbbhhddttkkbb vvttggffnnhhjjyytt??
ccbb''ffkk,,ttff mmjjyytt,,ff]] llff ccbb''ffkk,,ttff
ccbbvvllbbllhhtt]] vvbbllbb ff,,ff ]]jjnnff
[[yybbss^̂ iittyy]] ssffddbb iittbbmm]]bbtt&&
@]jnf vjo'fkt,f (cflf'f) ,tdh e,tleht,fc uffmfho'kt,c&#
ufvjyfsmdfvbc fphbc itcf[t, fv[fyfut,sfy bvcwtkts&
ffllffvvbbffyybb^̂ hhjjvvttkkbb]] ppttmmffsscc bb[[llbbcc
ª ufbceasfdt,c sfdc bctsb ]elb xdtdt,bcfufy^ hjujhb]ff tujbpvb^
cb.eyot lf cbfvf't&
ª uff]yj,btht,c^ hjv fkkf/bc ,j.t,ekb mjyt,bcfsdbc vflkj,bc
uflf[lff cfzbhj lf tc v[jkjl cbn'dbthfl fh fhbc cfrvfhbcb&
ª vjyfobktj,fc bqt,c vlblfhsf lf qfhb,sf ijhbc trjyjvbrehb
esfyfcojhj,bc lf.ktdfib& fvudfhfl^ vfc sfdbcb odkbkb itfmdc
vlblfhcf lf qfhb,c ijhbc blevfkb cbf[kjdbc^ ehsbth
gfnbdbc]tvbcf lf ehsbths cb'dfhekbc xfvj'fkb,t,fib^
cfpjufljt,fib vidblj,bc lf cj]bfkehb sfyfcojhj,bc
lfv'fht,fib&
ª [tkc eo'j,c cfpjufljt,fib bctsb ]elb lf cfvfh][dbyj
mvtlt,t,bc fqvja[dhfc^ hjujhb]ff% vfs[jdhj,f^ mehlj,f^
'fxfqj,f lf c[df&
ª cfpjufljt,fib cfresfh /evfyeh vjdfktj,t,c vb[dlt,f lf
thsbfyj,bc uh.yj,f vjtvfnt,f^ hjujh] c[tekbc thsb yfobkbc
fnrbdt,bcfc c[df jhufyjt,b] uh.yj,ty fdflv'jaj,fc^
itcf,fvbcfl cfpjufljt,fib fhct,ekb ghj,ktvt,bc ufvj nrbdbkc
sdbsjyf] buh.yj,c lf vfs lf.ktdfib sfdbc odkbkc itbnfyc&
ª sfdbcsfdc cfresfhb aekbcf lf mjyt,bc vjyj,bcfufy
ufbsfdbceakt,c^ fqbfht,c^ hjv vbc [tks fhct,ekb mjyt,bc
yfvldbkb vtgfnhjyt fkkf/bf&
ª uf]tvbs^ ufpbfht,bs^ vj.vtpt ufzbhdt,bc ;fvc lf[vfht,bs^
.bhbsflb flfvbfyehb qbhct,t,bs fqbzehdt,f lf .dbhafcb
ve/fvvtl iefvfdkbc yf,h.fyt,bc sfyf[vfl ,tlybthb bmyt,f%
@vbv]tvb [tkb fvqt, [tkpt egbhfntcbf#&
q
d
s
b
c
v
c
f
[
e
h
t
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
33
//ffwwjj,,ffpptt yyffvv''jjaa ssmmddttyycc ff[[kkjj,,ttkkcc ((yyff]]yyjj,,cc)) //rrbbss[[ttss^̂ ssee
hhff vvjjbbyyff[[eekkff llff hhff bbuuhh..yyjj bbmm&&
2& vjupfehj,f ovbylfflubkt,ib$ /f}j,f
/fwj,f bckfvbc ths-thsb .bhbsflb cfae.dt-
ksfufybf& /fwj,f mjyt,bsf lf c[tekbs itcfch-
ekt,tkb qdsbcvcf[eht,ff& /fwj,f okbc ufhrd-
tek lhjc vtmfib v'jab mff,tcf lf ufhrdtekb
ovbylf flubkt,bc vjyf[ekt,fc ybiyfdc& tc fhbc
bc okbehb itrht,bc lhj lf flubkb^ cflf] th-
svfytsbc vbvfhs sfyfcojh dbsfhtfib brhb,t,bfy
c[dflfc[df hfcbc^ cmtcbc^ tybc^ cj]bfkehb vlu-
jvfhtj,bcf lf fcfrbc flfvbfyt,b&
/fwj,bc lhjc vjcfyf[ekt,tkb ovbylf flub-
kt,bf% mfkfm vtmfib vlt,fht mff,t^ cfaf^ vthdt^
fhfafnb^ vepltkbat^ vbyf&
@@&&&&&&&&ffkkkkff//bbcc
uueekkbbccffssddbbcc ffvv
ccff[[kkbbcc ((mmff,,bbcc))
vvjjddkkff-ggffnnhhjjyyjj,,ff
ddffkklltt,,eekktt,,ffff
ffllffvvbbffyytt,,pptt^̂ bbvvff-
sspptt^̂ ddbbccff]]
..ffkkee..cc vvbbccbb
vvjjyyff[[eekktt,,ff##
(cehf fkb bvhfyb^
fbfsb 97)
vtmfc ufhitvj vvbbmmffssffll ojlt,ekb flubkt,b //ffhhttvvbbcc (/fwj,bcfsdbc vj-
otchbut,bc) nthbnjhbbc cfpqdht,c vjb]fdc& fv cfpqdht,sfy vbcdkbc itvl-
tu nfycf]vtkb^ at[cf]vtkb lf obylt,b eylf ufb[flj lf lf jh gbhcf-
[j]ib eylf itt[dbj^ /fwj,bcfsdbc ufyphf[df fye ybtsb eylf uffrtsj lf
ssttkk,,bbtt (kt,,tbm fkkf/evvt kt,,tbm) ofhvjsmdf& fvhbufl^ erdt bb//hhffvviibb
bv'jat,b lf /fwj,bc qdsbcvcf[eht,f lfo't,ekbf& /fwj,bc sdtt,ib c[df
hbnefkt,b otcbc vb[tldbs eylf itchekltc& /fwj,bc [dtlhbc itvs[dtd-
fib fv itcf.kt,kj,bcf lf cfiefkt,bc vjv]tvb fkkf/bc vbvfhs vflkj,bc
ufvj[fndbc vbpybs 'eh,fyb eylf lfbrkfc& fvbs /fwj,f lfcheklt,f&
//ffwwjj,,bbcc aaffhh..tt,,bbbb//hhffvvbb - flfvbfyb^ hjvtkb] /fwj,bcfsdbc ufyphf[dfc /'jac^ ybtsc uf-
frtst,c lf stk,btc ofhvjsmdfvc^ c[df lhjib yjhvfkehb vjmvtlt,t,b% 'd-
fdbkbc vjo'dtnf^ [bc vjzhf^ odthbc ufgfhcdf^ svbc itrhtzf^ itrthbkb n-
fycf]vkbc xf]vf^ yflbhj,f lf vcufdcb pjubthsb cfmvtt,b^ /fwj,bc gthb-
jlib fh eyklf uffrtsjc&
mmffff,,ttpptt ufhc itvjdkbc hbnefkb- ifdb mdf (/fwthektcdtlbc) thsb re-
s[blfy itvjdkbc lfo't,f lf mff,tpt idblwth ufhitvjdkf&
ffhhffaaffnnpptt iittxxtthhtt,,ff - /fwt,bc vbth vtmfc cfv[hts fqvjcfdktsbs vlt,-
fht fhfafnbc vsfpt fcdkf lf 'eh,fybc ,fbhfvfvlt thsb lqbs flht^ hfvl-
tybvt [ybs bm ufxtht,f&
q
d
s
b
c
v
c
f
[
e
h
t
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
34
stk,bt
qvthsj xtvj@ityc ,h.fyt,t,pt vjhxbkt,fc lblb cbfvjdyt,bs
dfqbfht,& vpflf dfh ityb ,h.fyt,bc itcfchekt,kfl^'jdkbc-
itv.kt xtvj fkkf/j& ity [fh xtvb thsflthsb
cflblt,t,kb^mt,f-lblt,f itysdbcff& xtvpt ,j.t,ekb 'dtkf
cbrtst ity utresdybc^ 'dtkfathb itybf&&& fh fhct,j,c ityb
vjpbfht lf sfyfcojhb&
'eh,ybc itobhdbc qdsbcvcf[eht,f^ hjujh] gbhjdyt,bcfsdbc^
fctdt cfpjufljt,bcfsdbc c[dflfc[df cf[bc cfhut,kj,bc vjvnfyb
qdsbcvcf[eht,ff& 'eh,ybc itvobhdtkb fkkf/pt lfvjrblt,ek-
t,fc fqbfht,c lf cfpjufljt,fib .vj,bcf lf ehsbthslf[vfht-
,bc lfvrdblht,fib itfmdc odkbkb&
flfvbfyb^ hjvtkb] /fwj,fc fchekt,c%
ª cflf nfycf]vtkib c[df /fwt,sfy thsfl sfyfcojh gbhj,t,ib
vjmvtlt,bs sfyfcojhj,bc uh.yj,t,c ufyfdbsfht,c&
ª sfyfvlt,j,f^ ojlt,f^ cbvlblht^ mjyt,f lf vcufdcb behblbekb lf
trjyjvbrehb qbht,ekt,t,bc ofhvfdkj,fib rbltd ths[tk
lfhoveylt,f^ cfvfhskbfyj,bc uh.yj,fc ufybdbsfht,c&
ª hfcbc^ cmtcbc^ tybc^ fcfrbcf lf c[df 'jdtkudfhb ufyc[dfdt,bc
lhjt,bsj,fc lf evybidytkj,fc vb[dlt,f& bckfvbc^ .vj,bc
'dtkf flfvbfybc uf]yj,f-lff[kjt,bc vybidytkj,fc ufbut,c&
ª fkkf/bc obyfit flfvbfyt,bc yfvjmvtlfhbc ufvj ufyrbs[dbc lqtc
ufb[ctyt,c lf cfbmbjcfsdbc vpflt,bc fe]bkt,kj,bc fphc
ufybvnrb]t,c&
ª vjsvbyt,fc^ cb.ytktt,pt ufvrkfdt,fc^ wueaehb vjmvtlt,bc eyfhc^
ehsbthlf[vfht,bcf lf cjkblfhj,bc vcufdc kfvfp
sdbct,t,c itb.tyc&
ª fkkf/bc vbth vfcpt yf,j.t,b wfyvhstkj,bc^ vj[th[t,bc^ mjyt,bc^
cbvlblhbcf lf vcufdcb cbrtsbcfsdbc vflkj,fc b[lbc&
ª .dbhafcb ve/fvvtl iefvfdkbcf lf vbcb sfyfvjfphtt,bc yfv'jab
ª flubkt,bc vjyf[ekt,bs vfs vbth lfnjdt,ek othbkc eahj
rfhufl tgfnhjyt,f&
ª cfhoveyjt,bc gbhjdyekb v[fhbc ufhlf vbc cfpjufljt,hbd
vybidytkj,fcf] itb]yj,c^ [fk[bc obyfit eakt,t,bcf lf
vjdfkjt,t,bc vbvfhs gfce[bcvut,kj,fc fbqt,c&
q
d
s
b
c
v
c
f
[
e
h
t
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
35
1& veckbvfyt,bc lqtcfcofekb^ hjv-
tkb] otkboflib jhwth nfhlt,f
2& vetpbybc vbth vhtdkbc cfkj]fd-
fl vb[vj,f
3& hbnefkb vtmfib& veckbvfysf lq-
tcfcofekb^ veckbvfysf vbth pbk/bwbc
sdtib vtmfib vjcfyf[ekt,kfl ofcdkf
4& qfhb,t,pt ufcf]tvb vjo'fkt,f
5& hfvfpfybc sdbc 27-t qfvt^ hjltc-
f] 'ehfyvf bo'j xfvjcdkf
6& vtxtsib vhtdksfy thsfl yfvfpbc
itchekt,f
7& vjo'fkt,f^ hjvtkcf] hfvfpfybc
sdtib ufbqt,ty
8& &bckfvbc ths-thsb .bhbsflb gbh-
j,f& @[esb cf[bc cfzvtkb^ thsvfytsc
fh trfht,f& jhb lqtc vjtcohj^ cfvb
qfvtc tafht,f&#
9& kj]df^ hjvtkb] hfvfpfybc
sdtib nfhlt,f .bkbcobyf kj]dbc
itvltu&
10& xdtyb cfhoveyjt,f-veckbvfysf
cfhoveyjt,bc cf[tkojlt,f
11& veckbvfysf cfkj]fdb flubkb-
qvthsbc cf[kb&
12& &zfvbc lhj vfh[dbc gthbjlib^&
vfh[dbc lfo't,fvlt ]jnf flht
13& vbyfhtsblfy cfkj]fdfl vjojl-
t,f
14& bvfvbc vbth vtxtsib ofhvjsmve-
kb vjojlt,f gfhfcrtdj,bs (wevbc kj-
]df) lf lqtcfcofekt,pt&
15& bfcblfy (qfvbc kj]dfc) lbkfvlt
itcfchekt,tkb fhfcfdfklt,ekj kj-
]df&
16& ovbylf vsf cfelbc fhf,tsib
17& cfvb ve[kb kj]df^ .bkbcobyf
kj]dbc itvltu
18&fhfcfdfklt,ekj kj]df^ hjvtk-
cf] vjhoveyt veckbvfyb fchekt,c&
rrhhjjccddjjhhllbb
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
36
pytj,f xxttvvc
cffhoovvee
yyjjtt,ffc
ddcooffddkkjj
,
iittbbccooffddkktt^̂ uuffvvjjbbrrddkkbbtt ^̂ bbaabbmmhhtt
11&& itbcofdkts cbn'dt,b% afh.b^
dfwb,b^ ceyytsb^ ve,f/b^ vec-
st/f,b lf vtuj,ht,sfy
thsfl bvcwtkts vfs ijhbc
c[dfj,t,pt
22&& rtsbkb pytj,f ][jdht,bc
rfyjyfl hjv dfm]bjs^
fvbcfsdbc hf eylf ufdfrt
sjsj
33&& ths thsb vybidytkjdfyb
flfvbfybc ][jdht,bc bcn-
jhbf ufvjbrdkbts lf vbcb
cfvfufkbsj m]tdt,b fv[f-
yfut,c uff]fybs&
44&& bvcwtkts smdtyb 'dtkfpt
kfvfpb lf ufvjhxtekb
pytj,hbdb m]tdbc itcf[t, lf
lfabmhlbs^ hf cfhutkj,f
vjfmdc smdtysdbc vfc&
55&& hfc uffrtst,c veckbvfyb^
hjvtkvf] b]bc sfdbcsfdbcf
lf jwf[bc obyfit fhct,ekb
vjdfktj,t,b?
66&& hfc [dlt,bs ve/fvvtl
iefvfdkbc cbn'dt,blfy -
@,fdidb veckbvyfl b,flt,f#
77&& bvcwtkts f[kj,kt,sfy lf
cs[jdts ubfv,jy^ hfc [tlfd
ty bcbyb ve/fvvtl iefvfdkbc
pytj,fib?
88&& hfc uffrtst,c veckbvfyb^
hjvtkvf] b]bc ufhtvjcf lf
vstkb rf]j,hbj,bc obyfit
fhct,ekb cfresfhb vjd-
fktj,t,b?
99&& ofbrbs[ts xdtyb .dbhafcb
iefvfdkbc ufvjcfs[jdt,t-
kb vbvfhsdf (dtlf [es,bt)
lf vjyf[ts vfcib pytj,hbdb
lfhbut,t,b&
1100&& hjujh fe[cybs vtuj,fhc rf-
hub pytj,bc cfhut,kbfyj,fc&
1111&& htkbubbc reknehbcf lf
pytj,bc itcf[t, fhct,ekb
obuyt,blfy fy mdtvjs
lfcf[tkt,ekb lbfytsbc cf-
mvtsf cfvvfhsdtkjc ufvjv-
]tvkj,bc obuyt,blfy pytj-
,bc itcf[t, itvltub sfdt,b
ofbrbs[ts%
ff&& bbcckkffvvbbcc ppyyttjj,,ff llff cceekkbbtthhbb
vvjjddffkkttjj,,tt,,bb%% bbhhff//bbvv ffuuff//
xxee,,eemmwwee
,,&& ccbbrrttssbbcc uuffccffvvhhwwttkkjj%% ppffhh-
bbaatt wwffyyffyybb
gg&& ccbb''ddffhheekkbb llff vvttuujj,,hhjj,,ff
ffbbffsstt,,bbcc llff //ffllbbcctt,,bbcc aajjyy-
pptt%% bbccvvffbbkk rrffhhffuujjppbb&&
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
37
ccbb]]jj]][[kkbbcc uuffvvjj..ff[[bbkkbb
thsb rf]b idbksfy thsfl ctbhyj,lf& ,fdidvf e]f,tlfl
ofb,jh.brf lf vbofpt lft]f& @f/# lfb'dbhf ,fdidvf& vfs vj-
gbhlfgbht vsbc vodthdfkblfy @f/ !# vjtcvfs& ,fdidvf ]y-
j,bcvj'dfhtj,bs /rbs[f% @ity dbyf [fh ?# @ity dbyf [fh?#
vjtcvf gfce[fl& fvwthfl erdt uf,hfpt,ekvf lfb'dbhf% #ity
thsb vibifhf [fh!# @ity thsb vibifhf [fh!# vjdblf [vf
vsblfy& ,fdidb vfvfc vbe,heylf% @hf [lt,f vfvf?# vfvfvbcb
vsbcrty it,heylf lf itc.f[f% @itybs fqahsjdfyt,ekb
dfh&# @itybs fqahsjdfyt,ekb dfh#^ b'j gfce[b& vfvfv rb-
ltd itc.f[f% @ity lblt,ekb [fh# @ity lblt,ekb [fh# b'j
gfce[b& ,fdidc .fkbfy uferdbhlf^ vfuhfv hf [lt,jlf dth
vbv[dlfhb'j^ vfvfvbcvf fe[cyf% @fvfc ufvj.f[bkb^ tmj /mdbf^
cbyfvldbktib rb tc xdtyb ][jdht,ff& ][jdht,f velfv vfcpt
vb]tvekc erfy lfub,heyt,c#
ccff''ddffhhttkkbb
iieeffvvffddffkkbb ffcctt
,,hh..ffyytt,,cc%% @@ssee
hhjjvvttkkbbvvtt ssmmdd-
ttyyssffuuffyybb
..vvbbccssddbbccff]] ffhh
bbcceehhddtt,,cc bbvvffcc^̂
hhff]] ssffddbbccssddbbcc
cceehhcc^̂ yyffvvllddbbkkbb
vvjjhhoovveeyytt
ffhhffff##
(ovbylf /flbcb)&
flfvbfyt,b thsvfytsbc cfhrtyb fhbfy& xdtyb
][jdht,bc lf ehsbthsj,t,bc cnbkbc ufyvcfpq-
dhtkb thsvfytsbc vbvfhs xdtyb lfvjrblt,ekt-
,t,bf& hjujh] udbylf^ hjv xdty vjudtm]yty^ bct
vjdtm]ts c[dfc& hf] udbylf hjv db[bkjs^ xdty]
bc eylf de.qdyfs c[dfc^ se cb'dfhekc dtkj-
lt,bs^ cb'dfhekb^ se cbyfpt udbylf^ cbyfpt^ se
gfnbdbc]tvfc vjdtkbs^ gfnbdbc]tvf&&& hf] fh ud-
bylf hjv itudtvs[dtc^ c[dfc bvfc ye ufdertst-
,s& bvbcfsdbc hjv vnhj,fc fh uflfdt'fhjs^
vnhj,fc ye ufdfrtst,s^ se udbylf hjv tujbc-
nj,fc fh uflfdt'fhjs^ tujbcnehfl fh eylf
vjdbm]ts& bvbcfsdbc^ hjv ecfvfhskj,fib fh
vjd[lts^ ecfvfhskj,f fh eylf xfdblbyjs&
jjmmhhjjcc oottccbb%%
hjujh] ity ubylf^ hjv vjutm]yty^
ity] bctdt vjtmt]b&
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
38
rrffhhbb ggbbhhddttkkbb
1& bckfvb kfvfpb pytj,ffrfhub pytj,f fhbc^ flfvbfybc cojhb otct,bc m]tdfib fcf[df lf
xdtdfl m]tdf& bckfvbc 'dtkfpt vybidytkjdfyb vbpfyb bcff^hjv flfvb-
fyb b'jc pytj,hbdfl xfvj'fkb,t,ekb^ .dbhafcb ve/fvvtl iefvfd-
fkb ,h.fyt,c% @vt rfhub pytj,bc chek'jabcfsdbc dfh ufvjupfdy-
bkb# (ovbylf /flbcb)&
veckbvfyb flfvbfybc afcb^ vbcb pytj,bc cbkfvfpbs bpjvt,f^ hj]f
/rbs[tc .dbhafc ve/fvvtl iefvfdfkc%@dby fhbfy fkkf/bcfsdbc 'dt-
kfpt cf'dfhtkb flfvbfyt,b? iefvfdfkvf egfce[f% @dby] 'dtkfpt cfe-
rtstcj pytj,bc vmjytyb fhbfy# (ovbylf /flbcb)&
bckfvb^ hovtybcf lf qdsbcvcf[eht,bc cfae.dtkpt flfvbfyt,bc ]e-
lb sdbct,t,bcf lf xdtdt,bcfufy sfdbc lfqotdfc lf rfhub pytj,bc vb-
qt,fc bcf[fdc vbpyfl& obyf sfdtt,ib fkkf/pt^ vbc fyutkjpt,pt^ ob-
uyt,pt^ iefvfdkt,pt^ cfbmbjpt^ ,tlbcothfcf lf ufyut,fpt^ vjhoveyt^
vkj]dtk^ vfh[dbc itvchekt,tk^ /fwj,fpt ofvcdktk lf ptmfsbc
uflfv[ltk flfvbfysf vbth it.tybk kfvfp sdbct,t,pt ufdfvf[dbkts
'ehflqt,f& fvfcsfy thsfl hovtybcf lf flfvbfybc qdsbcvcf[eht,bc
[fhbc[b] pytj,bc cbkfvfptcsfyff lfrfdibht,ekb^ fkkf/bc rvf'jab-
kt,bc vjgjdt,bc upf] rfhu pytj,fptf lfvjrblt,ekb&
bct^ hjujh] hovtybcf lf qds-
bcvcf[eht,bc cfae.dkt,b^ 'ehfyb-lfy
lf .dbhafcb iefvfdkbc ceyytst,bcfufy
dbcofdkts^ se hf fhbc rfhub^ kfvf-
pb^ cfcfhut,kj lf fvfcsfyfdt hf fhbc
]elb^ fhfcojhb lf cfpbfyj& bvbcfsd-
bc^ hjv rfhub pytj,bc db'js^ qvths-
bc ,h.fyt,t,c eylf lfdtvjhxbkjs^ fr-
ddbbyy]] ffkkkkff//bbccrrttyy ggbbhhcc
bb,,hheeyytt,,cc^̂ llffttvvjjhhxxbbkktt,,ff
vvffcc llff rrttssbbkkbbcc vvmmyyttkkbb
bbmmyytt,,ff^̂ bbcc xxffzzbblltt,,eekkbbff
vvnnrrbb]]tt yyffccrrddcc llff vvbbccbb
ccffmmvvtttt,,bbcc ccff,,jjkkjjjj iittllttuubb
ffkkkkff//bbccrrttyyffff vvbbvvffhhsseekkbb
(cehf kj'vfyb^ fbfsb 22)
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
39
h.fkekc eylf vjdthbljs& tc ,h.fyt,t,b lf frh.fkdt,b thsv-
fytssfy rfdibhibf&
kfvfpb xdtdf^ hjvtkb] xdty udf[fcbfst,c^ sfdbcsfy thsfl rfhu
sdbct,t,c itud.tyc^ ]elb xdtdt,bcfufy ufyijht,fcf lf sfdbc lfqotd-
fib lfudt[vfht,f& flfvbfyb^ hjvtkb] ]lbkj,c b'jc cfvfhskbfyb^
c[dbcb eakt,t,bc vbvfhsf] gfnbdbc]tvbs vjbm]tdf& ltl-vfvfc^ fv-
[fyfut,c^ yfstcfdt,c^ ev]hjct,cf lf eahjct,c^ fkkf/bc ufxtybkc
gfnbdbc]tvbs vjtg'hj,f& fkkf/bc vbvfhs gfnbdbc]tvbc uh.yj,f vfc
gfce[cbvut,kj,t,c itf[ctyt,c&
ahsfvjnt[bkb xbnbcflvb^ mexfib vnbhfkb ,fdidbcflvb^ evotjc-
flvb lf lf[vfht,bc vs[jdytkbcflvb gfce[cbvut,kj,fc buh.yj,c tu-
jbcnj,fc lfsvj,c lf sfdufvjlt,bs lfbo't,c qvthsbcflvb vcf[eh-
t,fc& vbc bhudkbd cb,hfkekbsf lf jgnbvbcnehfl ufb[tlfdc lf ,j-
.t,ekb cbrtstt,bcfsdbc fkkf/bcflvb vflkbtht,fc ufvjsmdfvc& tc
vflkj,f vbc hovtyfc uff.kbtht,c& hovtyf rb ufv,tlfj,fc it/vfnt,c&
ecfvfhskj,bcf lf ite,hfkt,kj,bc obyffqvltu vfvf]fl b,h.-
jkt,c& fv ,h.jkbcfc cbvnrb]t lf vjsvbyt,f vjtvfnt,f& vjsvbyt,f
vfc ieqkbcfufy lfb]fdc& ,jhjnt,fpt cbrtsbs oby fqlujvfc bcofd-
kbc& fv[fyfuc^ hjvtkb] vb]tvek cbn'dfc fh fchekt,c^ vb]tvekb
cbn'dbc itchekt,bs sdbsjy vfufkbsc vbc]tvc&
cbn'dbc itchekt,bs gfnbdbc]tvfc lfbvcf[eht,c^ thsuek vtuj-
,hj,fc lffv'fht,c& c[dt,sfy vtuj,hj,f vfc iehbfyj,bcfufy lfb]fdc^
bc cfpjufljt,fc lf rjktut,c thsuekt,fc fxdtyt,c& fhfdbc lf fhf-
athc fh lffv]bht,c& vb[dlt,f^ hjv fkkf/bc vbth ufxtybk 'dtkf
fhct,fib cbkfvfpt fhct,j,c& ][jdht,fc rtsbkb sdfkbs it[ytlfdc
lf ,tlybthb bmyt,f^ fv[fyfut,c qbvbkbs vbtcfkvt,f^ vbc ,tlybtht,fc
ufhitvjv'jas ufepbfht,c&
.dbhafcb ve/fvvtl iefvfdfkb ,h.fyt,c% @bc dby]
gfnfht,c cb'dfhekbs lf cbyfpbs fh vjtg'hj,f lf
eahjct,bc afcb fh b]bc^ xdtysfufyb fhff# (ovbylf /flbcb)
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
40
2& 'dbhafcb ve/fvvtl iefvfdfkb^hjujhw pytj,bc o.fhj
.dbhafcb ve/fvvtl iefvfdfkb^ hj]f fkkf/bc oth-
bkt,bc flfvbfyt,pt uflf]tvbc vjdfktj,fc fchekt,-
lf^ bvfdlhjekfl fv othbksf vjs[jdyt,bc 'dtkfpt
cfertstcjl itvchekt,tkb egbhdtktcfl sdbsjy
b'j& vbcb ][jdht,f 'dtkfpt cfertstcj cf[tkv.qdfy-
tkjf xdtysdbc bvbc v[hbd^ se hjujh eylf vjdbm]-
ts^ hfyfbh ufvjedfk vlujvfhtj,fib] eylf
fqvjdxylts& itudb.kbf .dbhafcb ve/fvvtl iefvfdkbc
][jdht,fc uflfdfdkjs sdfkb^ vfufkbsb fdbqjs lf
vfc vbd,f.js&
hf vlujvfhtj,fib^ hjujh bm]tjlf bc? hjltcf]
vbc ][jdht,fc itbcofdkbs^ fqvjfxtys efvhfd
vfufkbsc bvbcfc^ se hjujh bm]tjlf c[dflfc[df
vlujvfhtj,fib& hf] cojhb upbc vfxdtyt,tkb bmyt,f
smdtysdbc& fb hfvltybvt vfufkbsb smdtyc ][jdht,fib
vjcfkjlytkb vlujvfhtj,bcf lf hjujh vfufkbsc
udf.ktdc .dbhafcb iefvfdfkb&
ª hj]f vlblfhb lf mjyt,bc gfnhjyb [fh^ ufb-[ctyt .dbhafcb ve/fvvtl iefvfdkbc ueke[dj,f^ hj-
]f vfc mfhfdyt,b lf/'fdlf lf dfzhj,lf&
ª hj]f qfhb,b lf emjytkb [fh^ babmht bv vj-
svbyt,bc itcf[t,^ hj]f .dbhafcvf iefvfdfkvf cfvij-
,kj^ mjyt,f^ 'dtkfathb hf] uffxylf^ vbfnjdf lf vt-
mflfy vtlbyfib uflfcf[klf&
ª rkfcbc jhufybpfnjhj,bcfc ufb[ctyt .dbhafcb
ve/fvvtl iefvfdkbc cfvfhskbfyb vjm]tdf sfdbcb lh-
jbc vfqfkb ohbc cfpjufljt,bc vbvfhs^ hj]f bcbyb
vfc lftvjhxbkyty&
ª hj]f sfdc cecnfl lf vfhnjl uh.yj,^ ofhv-
ddaabb]]ffdd^̂
ffkkkkff//bbcc
iieeffvvffddffkkiibb
ffhhbbcc vvffuuffkkbb-
ssbb ssmmddttyyssdd-
bbcc^̂ bbvvbbccffssdd-
bbcc^̂ ddbbyy]]
vvjjttkkbbcc
ffkkkkff//bbcc
oobbyyffiitt ooffhh-
lluujjvvffcc llff
eerrffyyffccrryyttkk
llqqttcc llff
ff[[ccttyytt,,cc
ffkkkkff//cc
uuffvveellvvtt,,bbss
(cehf f/pf,b^
fbfsb 21)
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
41
jblubyt .dbhafc ve/fvvtl iefvfdfkpt vtmfib sfdclfnt[bkb ufzb-
hdt,f lf odfkt,f&
ª hfbvt cfmvtib ufvfhwdt,bcfc^ vfufkbsb fbqt^ ,tlbhib^ /eytby-
cf lf vtmfib vnht,pt ,ho'bydfkt ufvfhwdt,bcfc .dbhafcb ve/fvvtl
iefvfdkbc vjmvtlt,bcfufy&
ª lfvfh][t,bcfc babmht .dbhafcb ve/fvvtl iefvfdkbc m]tdfpt^
hj]f bc e/elbc ,h.jkfib lfqegek (it/bl) lf lfzhbk sfdbc
vtuj,ht,c ijhbc lfvoe[ht,ekb lflbjlf^ vfuhfv bvtlc vfby] fh
/rfhufdlf&
ª se dbyvtc fcofdkb^ ufb[ctyt se hjujh fcofdkblf
cfvkj]dtkjib fv[fyfut,c .dbhafcb ve/fvvtl iefvfdfkb&
ª se rb dbyvtcufy hfbvtc cofdkj,^ babmht bvbc itcf[t,^ se
hjujh cofdkj,lf .dbhafcb ve/fvvtl iefvfdfkb qdsbeh v]yt,t,c
wt,hfbkbc obyfit lfxjmbkb&
ª se ubylf^ hjv 'jdtkudfhb lfv[vfhtc ufhtit^ cbrtsbcfsdbc
b,h.jkj lf cfvfhsfkb ufyf[jh]btkj^ ufb[ctyt lhj^ hjltcf]
.dbhafcb ve/fvvtl iefvfdfkb vtmfib cecnb b'j^ vfuhfv cfvfhsfkcf
lf ztivfhbnt,fc vfby] [vfvfqkf f][flt,lf&
ª se rb vjcfvfhskt fy hfbvt sfvfiib vcfwb [fh^ babmht bvfpt^
hj]f bckfvbc vjcdkfvlt /fwthektcdtlbc (ifdb mdbc) sfdbc flubkpt
lflt,bc uekbcfsdbc^ x[e,fvlt vbcekvf ‘ehtbibc njvbc kbltht,vf
hfnjv lfsfy[vlyty .dbhafcb ve/fvvtl iefvfdkbc vjcfvfhsktj,fc
lf vfy hjujhb uflfo'dtnbkt,f vbbqj&
fv[fyfut,sfy thsfl babmhts veckbvfyb flfvb-
fybc sfdbcsfdbcf lf jwf[bc obyfit fhct,ekb vjd-
fktj,t,bc itcf[t,& 'dtkfv fy,fybc hbuc vbf'jk-
jc sdfkb lf vfcpt vjotekb fcjsb lfo't,ekb
obyflflt,f itflubyjc&
vfufkbsfl%
f) fkkf/bcflvb qdsbcvcf[eht,f veckbvfybc vjdfktj,ff&
,) ,fdidt,vf eylf lfewthjy vij,kt,c lf itbcofdkjy^
hf tdfkt,f veckbvfyc&
u) ufzbhdt,eksf lf[vfht,f veckbvfybc vjdfktj,ff&
dby] cfsfyflj obyflflt,fc dth itflutyc^ sfvfiblfy ufdf&
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
42
rrffhhbb vvttjjhhtt
xdtyb sfdbcf lf xdtyb j}f[bcobyfit fhct,ekb vjdfktj,t,b
@@iittyyvvff qqvvtthhssvvff
,,hh..ffyyff^̂ hhjjvv ffhh
ttssff''ddffyyjjss cc[[ddffcc^̂
uuffhhllff vvbbccbbccff llff
rrttssbbkkffll
vvjjttmmtt]]bbss
vviijj,,kktt,,cc&& ssee
vvjj[[ee]]lltt,,ff iittyyss-
ffyy^̂ tthhssbb vvffssuuffyybb
ffhh jjhhssffddtt^̂ ffhh
eess[[hhff vvffss @@ee//##-
bb]] rrbb^̂ llff ffhh]]
llffnneemmccjj bbccbbyybb^̂
nnrr,,bbkkbb ccbbnn''ddff
eess[[ffhhbb vvffss&&
uuffllffffaaffhhtt vvffss
((jjhhssffddttcc)) ssffddff-
ppbbffyyjj,,bbcc aahhssff
ccbb,,hhffkkeekkbbss llff
ssmmddbb%% xxttvvjj qqvvtthh-
ssjj^̂ iittbboo''ffkktt
bbccbbyybb^̂ hhjjuujjhh]]
ffqqvvppffhhllttcc vvtt
ggffnnffhhffjj,,bbccffcc##
(cehf bchf^
fbfsb 23-24)
xdty^ hjvkt,cf] udofvc^ hjv fkkf/b 'jdt-
ksdbc 'dtkfathc [tlfdc^ 'dtkf xdtyb vjmvtlt,f
afhekb se qbf ]yj,bkbf vbcsdbc^ xdtyc m]td-
t,c fvbc vb[tldbs dfy[jh]btkt,s& tc hovtyf
flfvbfyc vbcb cfmvbfyj,bc itltut,c fsdfkbcoby-
t,byt,c lf sfdbc vjdfktj,fib itvfdfkb cfmvtt-
,bc chekafcjdyfl itchekt,bcfrty vbvfhsfdc&
fvfc gfce[bcvut,kj,f /mdbf& gfce[bcvut,kj,f udf-
rbchbf^ hjujh] fkkf/bc^ flfvbfyt,bcf lf 'dt-
kf c[df ufxtybksf vbvfhs^ fctdt xdtyb cfresf-
hb sfdbcf lf xdtybdt jwf[bc vbvfhs& flfvbfyvf
c[dbc obyfit fqt,ekb gfce[bcvut,kj,t,b hjv
itfchekjc^ fvbcfsdbc wth sfdbcsf dbc obyfit
fhct,ekb gfce[bcvut,kj,t,b eylf itfchekjc&
@vfi lffltm cojh
upfc^ b'fd
vfhs
fkb^ bct^ hj
ujh] ut,h.fyf!
(cehf /elb^ fbfsb 112)
@fh
xffuljs
cfresfhb sfdb
cfresfhb [tk
t,bs cfahs
[tib#&
(cehf aehb-,f'fhf^ fbfsb 195)
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
43
ª .dbhafcb ve/fvvtl iefvfdfkb ,h.fyt,c%@'dtkf ,fdidb veckbvyfl
b,flt,f# xdtyc ,eyt,fib v'jab sfylf'jkbkb cfvfhskbfyj,bcf lf
cbcgtnfrbc lf]df xdtyb cfresfhb sfdbc vbvfhs ths-thsb
evsfdhtcb vjdfktj,fsfufybf& hovtyf flfvbfybc 'dtkfpt .bhbsflb
vjs[jdybkt,ff& flfvbfyb v[jkjl hovtybs /gjdt,c cbvidbltc&
cbylbcb v[jkjl rfhub lf kfvfpb m]tdt,bs buh.yj,c idt,fc&
ª flfvbfybc zrebcf lf ujyt,bc vjs[jdybkt,f ]jlyff& se rb ]jlyf
hovtyfib ufthsbfylt,f^ flfvbfyb 'jdtkudfhb ,jhjnt,bcfufy
lf]ekb bmyt,f&
ª ]jlybc vbqt,bc eyfhb flfvbfybcfsdbc yf,j.t,b .fkbfy
vybidytkjdfyb cbrtstf& flfvbfyb^ hjvtkb] fv eyfhc fh ufvjb'tyt,c^
sfdbc zrefcf lf ujyt,fc ecfvfhskjl tm]tdf lf fkkf/bc vbth
,j.t,ekb fv cbrtsbcfsdbc vflkbtht,fc fh ufvj[fnfdc^
qvthsbcfufy lfbcwt,f
ª flfvbfyb^ se rb v]jlyt lf vjhoveytf^ qdsbcvcf[eht,bc itchekt,bc
fe]bkt,kj,fc buh.yj,c& qdsbcvcf[eht,f^ rb bct^ hjujh] fkkf/bc
vbvfhs gfnbdbc]tvf^ gbhjdyt,bc fvmdt'ybehb lf cfbmbjc ,tlybtht,bc
gbhj,ff& fvmdt'ybcf lf cfbmbjc ,tlybtht,bc vcehdtkb
flfvbfybcfsdbc^ sfdbcsfdbc obyfit fhct,ek vjdfktj,fsfufy
'dtkfpt vybidytkjdfyb qdsbcvcf[eht,bc itchekt,ff&
ª flfvbfyvf^ hjv 'dtkf tc vjdfktj,f itfchekjc^ fvbcfsdbc abpbreh
wfyvhstkj,fc eylf ufeahs[bkltc& xdtyb c[tekb lf
wfyvhstkj,f fkkf/bc vbth xdtypt vj]tvekb fyf,fhbf& 'dtkfyb fv
fyf,hbc lf]dbc vjdfktyb dfhs& xdtyb .dbhafcb iefvfdfkb ,h.fyt,c%
@ityb c[tekbc obyfit gfce[b eylf fuj# (ovbylf /flbcb)&
ª flfvbfyvf gbhdtkfl 'dtkfpt f[kj,kt,bc obyfit fhct,ekb
vjdfktj,t,b eylf itfchekjc& fv f[kj,tksfufy 'dtkfpt gbhdtkb
ltl-vfvff& vfs fh] cbn'dbs^ fh] m]tdbs lf fh] vjmvtlt,t,bs
fhfdbsfh itvs[dtdfib fh eylf dfo'byjs^ vfs vjvqbvfhb cf[bs lf
nr,bkb tybs eylf vjdtathjs^ vfsb cehdbkbcfvt,h vjmvtlt,f
xdtyc vjdfktj,t,c ijhbcff&
@fkkf/bcfsdbc 'dtkfpt cf'dfhtkb vjmvtlt,f sfdbc
lhjpt kj]df lf ltl-vfvfpt cbrtsbc ufrtst,ff#
(ovbylf /flbcb)
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
44
ssffddbbccssffddbbccff llff jjwwff[[bbcc oobbyyffiitt ffhhcctt,,eekkbb ppyyttjj,,hhbbddbb
vvjjddffkkttjj,,tt,,bbcc vv]]jjllyytt vveecckkbbvvffyybb
ª cfmvtc^ hjvtkcf] frtst,c& ]lbkj,c hjv rfhufl uffrtsjc^ hflu-
fyf] b]bc^ hjv fkkf/bcf lf sfdbcb cbylbcbc obyfit dfklt,ekbf&
ª bvbcfsdbc bhwt,f& hjv hf] vfc fcofdktc^ rfhufl lfbcofdkjc lf
]jlyf fbvfqkjc&
ª fhf vfhnj c[dt,bc obyfit^ fhfvtl cfresfhb sfdbc vbvfhsf]
cfvfhskbfybf&
ª se rb rtsbklqtj,fcf lf cbe[dtc vbfqotdc^ qvthsc vflkj,fc
itcobhfdc& se ufzbhdt,fcf lf [tkvjrktj,fib xfdfhlf^ fh itibylt,f&
b]bc^ hjv hfcf] eylf uflft'fhjc& 'dtkfathib vbcsdbc cbrtst lf cbkfvf-
pt fhct,j,c&
ª b]bc^ hjv hf] vbc itcf.kt,kj,fc fqtvfnt,f^ bvfpt gfce[bcvut,tkb
fhff& vbc itcf.kt,kj,t,pt fqvfnt,ekb cfmvbc itechekt,kj,bc ufvj
oe[bkb fh fmdc^ hflufy - @fkkf/b fhfdbc frbcht,c bvfc^ hf] flfvbfybc
.fkfc fqtvfnt,f# (cehf ,f'fhf aehb&286)
ª b]bc^ hjv hjujh] rfhub^ bct ]elb cfmvbcfsdbc cfvfubthjc vbbqt,c&jwf[ib vbc gfce[bcvut,kj,fib fhct,ekb vjdfktj,t,bc c[dfpt lfrbcht,fc
fh ]lbkj,c&
ª tujbcnj,fc ufyijhlt,f^ jwf[bc otdht,bc vbvfhs vbcb cb'dfhekb
lf cbf[kjdt vjbvfnt,c^ b]bc^ hjv tc c[dt,sfy lfvjrblt,ekt,fib
lflt,bs ve[nc itbnfyc&
ª .dbhafcb ve/fvvtl iefvfdkbc ][jdht,blfy fbqt,c vfufkbsc& sfdbc
jwf[cf lf yfstcfdt,c ijhbc ehsbthsj,t,c vbc vjmvtlt,t,c itecf,fvt,c&
ª ghj,ktvt,bc obyfit cecnb fhff& ]lbkj,c^ hjv vjfudfhjc&
ª b]bc^ hjv edb]fl vjmvtlt,f ufv,tlfj,f rb fhf^ obylfe[tlfj,f lfe]jlbyfhj,ff&
ª ]lbkj,c^ hjv 'jdtksdbc cojhfl vjbm]tc&
sfdb smdtysdbc cfj]yt,j ghjacbbc flfvbfyfl ofhvjblu-
byts& vfufkbsfl% by;bythb^ tmbvb^ vfcofdkt,tkb^ vahbyfdb^
fhmbntmnjhb&&& xfvjf'fkb,ts^ se hfc eylf vbfm]bjs 'e-
hflqt,f cfvcf[eht,hbdb vjdfktj,bc itchekt,bcfc&
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
45
bbvvccwwttkkttss mmddttvvjjss vvjj]]ttvveekkbb ccffrrbbss[[tt,,bbcc iittccff[[tt,,&&
& babmhts xdtyb c[tekbc jhufyjt,bc vjdfktj,t,bc
itcf[t,& hf vj[lt,f^ se rb xdtyc jhufyjsfufy
ths thsb sfdbc aeym]bfc fh itfchekt,c?
& hf fhbc jwf[bc otdhsf vjdfktj,t,b? hf vj[lt,f^
se rb jwf[bc otdht,b vjdfktj,t,c fh
itfchekt,ty?
ª fhfcjltc esfd,jkjl fh lf[fhwfdc aekc^ cb.eyobcfufy
ijhc lufc^ eahjct,bcf lf gfnfht,bc obyfit kvj,bthfl^
vjsvbyt,bs lf gfnbdbc]tvbs bm]tdf&
ª efh'jabsb cbnef]bt,bc lhjc cfmvtc fexmfht,kfl^
feqtkdt,kfl^ cbvidblbc lf]dbs vbelut,f& eh'tdfl lf
vnrb]t yt,bc'jabs vjmvtlt,c&
ª ][jdht,fc fkkf/bcvbthb otct,bc vb[tldbs vjbo'j,c lf
,jkjvlt eibihfl lf 'ehflqt,bs itentdc cb.ytktt,c&
ª fh itiehlt,f sfdbcb .vt,bc fy c[dt,bc^ 'dtkfc vbvfhs
cekuh.tkbf&
ª vbc 'dtkf vjmvtlt,fcf lf cbn'dfib thsuekt,f buh.yj,f&
mmddttvvjjss vvjj]]ttvveekkbbff mm]]ttddbbcc ppjjuubbtthhssbb oottccbb&& rrffhhuubb vveecckkbbvv-
ffyybbccffssddbbcc vvbbccffqqtt,, vvjjmmvvttlltt,,ffcc cc ((ccoojjhhbb))^̂ vvbbeeqqtt,,ttkk
vvjjmmvvttlltt,,ffcc ff ((ffhhffccoojjhhbb)) ,,uutthhff llffeeccddbbss&&
( ) fh bmehlt,c
( ) cbn'dfc fh itbyf[fdc^ zjhbrfyff
( ) fpfhnek sfvfic fh sfvfij,c
( ) tujbcnbf^ 'jdtksdbc sfdbcsfdpt
abmhj,c
( ) ufzbhdt,ekt,c t[vfht,f
( ) c[dbc mjyt,fc eyt,fhsjl fbqt,c
( ) sfdbc ufvjcfhxtyc e'eht,c&
c[dbcfc vybidytkj,fc fh fybzt,c&
( ) bcts cfcvtkt,c fh b'tyt,c^
hjvtkb] vfc pbfyc vbf'tyt,c
( ) vfcpt vb,fht,ek^ lfnjdt,ek
mjyt,fc fh egfnhjyt,c
( ) gbhjdyt,bc eakt,fc
eahs[bklt,f^ dbyvtc ecfvfhskjl
fh tm]tdf&
( ) /fhfvc fh itzfvc^ /fkfk
vjut,fc t.t,c&
( ) cbn'dfc fh itfchekt,c
( ) pjvfcf lf ojyfib vjfn'et,c
( ) j,jkcf lf ufzbhdt,ekc lfb]fdc
( ) fxmfht,ekb lf vjesvtytkbf
( ) vjgbhlfgbhtc vjfn'et,c
( ) fh bvheit,c
( ) vjvqbvfhbf^ dbyvtc fh tehxt,f
( ) mhsfvc fbqt,c lf vbc]tvc
( ) dfkbc lhjekfl uflfv[ltkb
fhff
( ) ufrtst,ek cbrtstc lff'dtlhbc
( ) 'dtkfahbc vbvfhs /evfyehb lf
vjo'fktf&
( ) n'ebkc fh bn'dbc&
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
46
rrffhhbb vvttccffvvtt
vjdfktj,t,b xdtyb ufhtvjcf lfrfwj,hbj,bc obyfit
@@//ttbb vvjjhhoovveeyyttyyjj!!
bb''ffddbbss
ffkkkkff//ssffyy ((vvffhhss-
ffkk)) iitteeddffkkyybb
ccbbvvffhhsskkbbccffssddbbcc
vvjjoovvttjj,,ffiibb&& ffhh
uubb,,bb..uujjss ((ssmmddttyy))
[[ffkk[[bbcc
vv..eekkddffhhtt,,ffvv
eeccffvvffhhsskkjj,,bbccffrr-
ttyy&& bb''ffddbbss ccffvvffhh-
sskkbbffyyyybb&&&&!! ttcc
eeaahhjj ff[[kkjjff
qqddssbbccvvjjiibb-
iijj,,ffccssffyy llff
uuttiibbyyjjllttss
ffkkkkff//bbccff^̂
eettzzddttkkffll
ffkkkkff//bb vv]]jjllyyttff
hhffccff]]
ccxxffllbb[[ffhhss##
(cehf vfblt-ceahf^
fbfsb 8)
bckfvbc pytj,f 'dtkf flfvbfybc .bhbsfl
eakt,t,pt gfnbdbc]tvfc vjbs[jdc& 'dtkf flfvb-
fyc^ mjyt,bc fkfkb upbs ijdybc^ flfvbfyt,pt
gfnbdbc vbut,bc^ c[df flfvbfyt,sfy sfyfcojhj,-
bc^ gbhfl cfmvtt,ib xfehtdkj,bc^ rdt,bc^ lf,by-
fdt,bcf lf vcufdcb .bhbsflb vjs[jdybkt,t,bc
lfrvf'jabkt,bc eakt,f uffxybf&
veckbvfyt,b 'dtkf fqvcfht,kj,bc flfvbfysf
eakt,t,c gfnbdbc]tvbs tg'hj,bfy& eahj vtnb]^
vfs .vt,fl vbbxytdty lf sfdc vjdfktl sdkbfy
v[fhib fvjeluyty ufzbhdt,fib lf lft[vfhjy
cb.ytktt,bc uflfkf[dfib& ufcfzbhib xfdfhly-
bkbc ghj,ktvfc vjyljvt,bs^ uekbsflfl lf
lfepfht,kfl vjudfht,fc ]lbkj,ty& dby]
,jhjnt,fc ufertst,c^ vfs vbvfhs vbvntdt,tkyb
fhbfy^ cb.ekdbkc fh fnfht,ty& bvbcfsdbc^ hjv
bubdt cbukf[t vtjhtl fh vjedblts& sflfhbubs
lf 'ehflqt,bs bm]tdbfy&
xdtyc .dbhafc iefvfdfkc /rbs[tc% @'dtkf-
pt [tbhbfyb flfvbfyb dbyff?
iefvfdfkvf egfce[f% @flfvbfyb^ hjvtkcf]
cfpjufljt,bcfsdbc 'dtkfpt
vtnb cbrtst vjfmdc#& (ovbylf /flbcb)
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
47
@@//ttbb vvjjhhoovveeyyttyyjj!!
tt..bbttss llff[[vvffhhtt,,ff
((ffkkkkff//bbccff))
vvjjssvvbbyytt,,ffccff llff
kkjj]]ddffiibb&&
eettzzddttkkffll
ffkkkkff//bb vvjjvvssvv-
ttyytt,,ssffyyffff##
(cehf-aehb^
fbfsb 153)
@ehoveyjt,b fkkf/cf lf ztivfhbn vjhoveytt,c fn'et,ty&&&
fhflf^
v[jkjl cfresfh sfdc fn'et,ty lf dth] rb [dlt,bfy#
(cehf-aehb^ fbfsb)
f[ctybs hfc ybiyfdc @[fkfcb cbn'df lf uekohatkj,f?#
ff[[ccttyybbss^̂ hhffcc yybbiiyyffddcc ##ssffddbbcc vvjjnn''eett,,ff&&## ??
veckbvfyt,b 'jdtksdbc ufycfresht,ekb
phlbkj,bs bm]tdbfy& hj]f dbyvtc it[dlt,bfy^
tcfkvt,bfy^ kfvfpb cbn'dt,bs vbvfhsfdty& hj-
]f ufzbhdt,fib v'jac yf[fdty^ vbcb lf[vfht,bc-
fsdbc c[dfc fh tkjlt,bfy& sdbsjy t[vfht,bfy&
ufhitvj lflt,bsb ]dkbkt,t,bc ufnfht,bc tyt-
hubfc cfresfh sfdib gjekj,ty& &qbhct,t,pt^
afctekj,t,pt lf eakt,t,pt se bmyf itvjn-
tdf^ ,jkjvlt b,h.jkt,ty& dbc vbvfhsf] eylf
b'jc^ ecfvfhskj,fc fh ittuet,bfy& ecfvfhsk-
j,fib xfdfhlybksf eakt,t,c b]fdty& b]bfy^
hjv cfhxj /fkfkb upbs eylf bijdjy^ fh bd-
bo't,ty .dbhafcb ve/fvvtl iefvfdkbc cbn'dt,c%
@dby] dfzhj,fib cbvfhsktc fh uflfe[dtdc^ uf-
yrbs[dbc lqtc iefvfdkt,sfy thsfl bmyt,f# (ov-
bylf /flbcb) bcbyb ufyehxtdkfl 'dtkfc% vlbl-
fhcf lf qfhb,c^ .kbthcf lf cecnc^ thsyfbh-
fl tg'hj,bfy& vfs cwthfs^ hjv .kbthb rb fh
fhbc vfhsfkb^ fhfvtl vfhsfkbf .kbthb& b]bc^
hjv bc^ hf] vbc cfresht,fibf^fkkf/bc vbth
vfcpt vb,fht,ekb fyf,ht,bf& &flfvbfyt,b^ dbcf]
bcbyb t[vfht,bfy^ vfs obyfit sfdc dfklt,ekfl
fh xfsdkbfy&
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
48
flfvbfyb^ hjvtkvf] b]bc ufhtvjcf lf
'dtkf flfvbfybc obyfit sfdbcb
vjdfktj,t,b&
ª b]bc^ hjv vfhnj sfdbcsdbc fh ][jdhj,c
lf t]lt,f^ hf] itb.kt,f vtnb cbrtst
frtsjc flfvbfyt,bcfsdbc
ª fv[fyfuj,fcf lf vtuj,hj,fc lbl
vybidytkj,fc fybzt,c^ vfssfy 'jdtksdbc
thsuekbf&
ª hf cfblevkj,t,cf] uffylj,ty^ itbyf[fdc&
c[dbcb ][jdht,bc vbvfhs gfnbdbc]tvbsff
ufyo'j,bkb&
ª pehuc erfy dbyvtc ]elfl fh f[ctyt,c^
fh] ]elc ufbabmht,c&
ª c[dfc fh lfc]byt,c& b]bc^ hjv vbc obyfit
v'jab] vbcyfbhb flfvbfybf lf fvbc
vb[tldbs vjmvtlt,c&
ª uf,hfpt,bcfc ite.kbf ,hfpbc lfjrt,f^
]lbkj,c^ bct bvjmvtljc^ hjv ,jkjc fh
byfyjc&
ª eahjccf lf ev]hjcc^ ufyehxtdkfl
'dtkfc sfdfpbfyfl tg'hj,f&
ª ptmfsbc^ abshbc lf vcufdcb
vfnthbfkehb dfklt,ekt,t,bc
itchekt,bs fh bafhukt,f& b]bc^ hjv
qbvbkb] rb ths thsb lf[vfht,f lf
cbrtstf&
@@//ttbb vvjjhhoovveeyy-
ttyyjj!!ffhh iitt[[ddbbllttss
ssmmddttyybb ccff[[kkssffdd-
ccbbcc uuffhhllff cc[[ddff
ccff[[kkiibb^̂
ddbbllhhtt yytt,,ffcc ffhh
ffbbqqtt,,ss llff ffhh
vvbbttccffkkvvtt,,bbss bbvv
ccff[[kkbbcc oottddhhtt,,cc&&
ttcc eerrttssttccbbff
ssmmddttyyssddbbcc&&
bbvvttllbbff llffee-
aabbmmhhlltt,,bbss##
(cehf yehb -cbyfskt^
fbfsb 27)&
ddffbb^̂ ppeehhuucc eerrffyy
vvjjkkffggffhhrrtttt,,ccff
llff ssddffkk-ooffhh,,bbcc
vvjjmmvvttlltt,,bbss^̂
vvbbvvbbrrbbss cc[[ddbbcc
vvffcc[[hhffll
ffvvuulltt,,tt,,cc^̂hhjjvvkktt
,,bb]] mmjjyytt,,ffcc
ffuuhhjjddtt,,ttyy llff
uuffvveellvvtt,,bbss
bbssddkkbbffyy vvffcc##
(cehf-/evtpt^
fbfsb 1-2)
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
49
ª b]bc^ hjv yfvldbkb lf[vfht,f v[jkjl
rtsbkb cfmvtt,bs itb.kt,f& ]lbkj,c
]elb cfmvtt,bc xfvltyyb xfvjfijhjc fv
cfmvbfyj,fc&
ª vbcufy lf[vfht,bc vs[jdytk flfvbfyc
sfyfeuh.yhj,c lf ]elfl fh vbvfhsfdc&
'jdtksdbc f[cjdc fkkf/bc lfhbut,f -
@ahs[bkfl^ vs[jdytkt,c fh ufeo'ht!#
(cehf le/f^ fbfsb 10)
ª b]bc^ hjv uf]tvbs fhfathb vjfrklt,f
lf cwthf^ hjv vbcb mjyt,bc ,fhfmf
ufpbfht,bc itvs[dtdfib vjbvfnt,c&
ª hj]f dbyvtpt lf[vfht,f eylf^ ufb[ctyt,c
fkkf/bc lfhbut,fc% @dth vbcodlt,bs
cbrtstc^ dblhtvlbc fh ufc]tvs
bvfsfufy^ hf] ut.dbhafct,fs^ [jkj
hfcf] bvjo'fkt,kt,s^ etzdtkfl^
fkkf/vf] eo'bc (cehf fkb bvhfyb
fbfsb 92)& bv mjyt,fc rb fh ufc]tvc^ hf]
fh vjcojyc lf hbc uflfult,f] eylf^
fhfvtl kfvfp lf rfhu mjyt,fc ufc]tvc&
ª lf[vfht,fc v[bfhekb cf[bs ufcotdc lf
fh lff'dtlhbc&
ª lf[vfht,fc c[dbc lfcfyf[fl fh frtst,c^
bct vjbm]tdf^ hjv vfhwdtyf [tkbs
vb]tvekc^ vfh][tyf [tkb dth [tlfdltc&
@@ //ttbb vvjjhhoovveeyy-
ttyyjj!! ffhh zzffvvjjss
mmjjyytt,,ff ssmmddttyybb
ssmmddttyy iieeff eevvffhh-
sskkjjll^̂ uuffhhttiitt
((bbvvbbccff))^̂ ssee
bbmmyytt,,ff ((ssmmddttyyiibb))
ddffzzhhjj,,ff-uuffhhbbuutt,,ff
ssmmddttyybbddtt
eehhssbbtthhssssffyy[[vvjj,,
bbss llff ffhh __
vvjj//rrkkffss
cceekktt,,bb ssmmddttyybb&&
eettzzddttkkffll^̂
ffkkkkff//bbff ssmmddttyybb
iittvvoo''yyffhhtt,,ttkkbb##
(cehf ybcf^
fbfsb 29)
@etzdtkfl bcbyb&
hjvkt,vf] smdtyc
xdtyb qvthsb
fkkf/bf& itvltu
cgtnfrb
][jdht,bs
][jdhj,ty^ fh
bmyt,f vfssdbc
ibib lf fh]
lfvoe[hlt,bfy&
fb^ bcbyb fhbfy
cfvjs[bc vrdbl-
hyb^ cflf]
cfvelfvjl
lfhxt,bfy^
cfpqfehfl bvbcf^
hfcf]
frtst,lyty#&
(cehf f/mfab&
fbfsb 13-14)
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
50
yytt,,bbccvvbbtthh ddbbyyvvttpptt vvjj[[vvjj,,ff
yjdtkf t[t,f js[ gbhj-
dyt,fc& tctybf ''ddttkkff^̂ tthhssbb
vvffssuuffyybb^̂ yytt,,bbccvvbbtthhbb lf ffhh-
ffddbbyy&&
vybidytkjdfyb cfmvt
eylf ufrtst,ekb'j lf
''ddttkkffcc cwthjlf^ hjv fv
cfmvtc tthhssbb vvffssuuffyybb uffrt-
st,lf& cbyfvldbktib fv cfmvbc ufrts-
t,f yytt,,bbccvvbbtthhccff]] itt.kj^ vfuhfv ffhhffddbbyy fh uffrtsf&
fvbc ufvj tthhssbb vvffssuuffyybb .fkbfy uf,hfplf^ hflufyf] cfmvt ''ddttkkffccbb b'j&
''ddttkkff abmhj,lf^ hjv fv cfmvbc ufrtst,f yytt,,bbccvvbbtthhcc itt.kj^ vfuhfv
ddbbyyvvtt dth [dlt,jlf^ hjv ''ddttkkff fvfc dth uffrtst,lf& cfmvt^ hjvkbc uf-
rtst,f yytt,,bbccvvbbtthhcc itt.kj^ hj]f ffhhffddbbyy fh uffrtsf^ ,jkjc ''ddttkkffvv
tthhssbb vvffssuuffyybb lfflfyfifekf&
ª bc mdtitdhljvt,c lf thsfl vjveifdt flfvbfyt,c
cfvfhskbfyfl lf cb,hfkekbs tm]tdf
ª bvbcfsdbc^ hjv dbyvtc ecfvfhskjl fh vjtm]tc^ 'ehflqt,bs
vjmvtlt,c& j,btmnehbf^ vbcb f[kj,tkb] hjv ecfvfhskjl
bm]tjltc^ bc cfvfhskbfyj,bc v[fhtpt lflut,f&
ª b]bc^ hjv fkkf/b cfvfhskbfybf lf vfc tylj,f&
ª dbyvtc fh itf]ltyc& xdtyb .dbhafcb iefvfdfkb ,h.fyt,c%
@vjvn'et,tkb fy lfvpfhfkt,tkb fy ],bthb xdtysfufyb fhff#
(ovbylf /flbcb)
ª 'jdtksdbc cbn'dbc gfnhjybf& fhfdbsfh itvs[dtdfib fh
n'ebc&
ª hj]f vtpj,tkb edfi[vjlff^ sdbsjy vf.qfhb fh lfodt,f&
ª fdflv'jat,c vjbyf[ekt,c&
ª j,kt,c b]fdc lf 'ehflqt,fc fm]tdc&
rbs[dt,b itafct,bcfsdbc%1& se uflft'fhts bcts itvs[dtdfc^
hj]f gfce[cbvut,kj,fc 'dtkf c[dfpt
fult,c? hf cf[bc ghj,ktvt,b vj/'dt,f
fvfc?
2& se fhbfy smdtyc bhudkbd bctsb
gbhjdyt,t,b^ hjvkt,b] gbhjdyekcf
se cfpjufljt,hbd gfce[bcvut,kj,t,c
bct fchekt,ty fh] rb lfc]lt,fs%@ vt
hf vtyfqdkt,f^ c[dt,vf blfhljy#
&bvcwtkts fv[fyfut,sfy fv flfvbfyt,bc
vbth cfpjufljt,hbd cfmvbfyj,fib vjy-
fobktj,bc sfj,fpt&
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
51
oovvbbyyllff jjvvffhhbbcc ccffvvffhhssffkkbb
ovbylf jvfhb sfdbcb [fkbaj,bc gthbjlib ths
cfqfvjc sfdbc jsf[ib veifj,lf& fv lhjc cnevfhb
todbf& jvfhvf cnevfhb sfdfpbfyfl vbbqj lf vfcsfy
vecfbab ufvfhsf& ovbylf jvfhb vfibydt ofvjluf lf
cfystkb xffmhj^ vbc yf]dkfl c[df cfystkb ffysj^
cnevfhb ufj]t,ekb e'eht,lf ovbylf jvfhc& dth-
fathb uftuj^ ,jkjc dtqfh vjbsvbyf lf /rbs[f%
@tct] cfystkbf lf bc^ vtjht] cfystkb b'j& jh-
bdt thsyfbhfl fyfst,c& thsb hfnjv xffmht lf vtjht
ffyst?
ovbylf jvfhvf fct egfce[f%
@cfystkb^ hjvtkb] xfdfmht^ [fk[bc aekbsff yf-
'blb& hj]f gbhfl cfveifjc dfchekt,^ fv[fyfut,c dt-
cfe,ht,b^ bv cfyskbc cfhut,kj,bc eakt,f fhf vfm-
dc& fvbnjv cfystkb xfdfmht lf xtvb aekbs yf'blb
fdfyst&#
1& fv ntmcnbc vb[tldbs cfvfhskbfyj,f hf vjmvt-
lt,fibf ufvj[fnekb?
2& gfnfhf e'ehflqt,j,bc ufvj se ituvs[dtdbfs
bctsb hfv^ hjvtkb] ecfvfhskj,fc iteo'j,lf [t-
kc? lffcf[tkts vfufkbsb&
3& fv ntmcnbc vb[tldbs itt]flts ufycfwjs cf[t-
kvobaj vjqdfobc gfce[cbvut,kj,f cfpjufljt,bc
obyfit&
hjujh bvjmvtlt,c ehsbthslf[vfht,f cfpju-
fljt,hbd ehsbthsj,t,pt? fv rbs[dfpt
fv[fyfut,sfy bvcwtkts& fv[fyfut,sfy bvcwtkts
se hjujh offmtpt,s ufhitvj v'jas bvbcfs-
dbc^ hjv b'dyty ehsbthslf[vfht,bc vjcehytyb?
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
52
vfhsfkb cbn'df lf qbvbkb veckbvfyb flfvbfybcfsdbc
sfdbc ufhitvjv'jasf obyfit ths-tthsb gfce[bcvut,kj,ff&
smdty] veckbvfyb cfpjufljt,bc vbvfhs gfce[bcvut,kj,bc
[esb vfufkbsb lfcff[tkts&
@@vveecckkbbvvffyybb
vveecckkbbvvffyybbcc ..vvffff&&
vvffcc ffhh
eeqqffkkffnntt,,cc&&
zzhhbbkkjj,,ffcc ffhh
vvbbff''ttyytt,,cc^̂
ffhh llffffvv]]bbhhtt,,cc##
(ovbylf /flbcb)
@@vvjjhhoovveeyytt
((vveevvbbyybb)) bbccttssbb
ddbbyyvvttff^̂ hhjjvvttkkbb]]
ffllffvvbbffyytt,,cc
iittttoo''jj,,ff llff
ffllffvvbbffyytt,,bb]]
iittttoo''jj,,bbffyy vvffcc&&
ccbbrrttsstt ffhhffff
bbccttss ffllffvvbbffyyiibb^̂
hhjjvvttkkbb]]
ffhh ffvv''ffhhtt,,cc
ff[[kkjj,,kkjj,,ffcc llff
ffhh]] vvffccssffyy
ffhhbbcc
iittccff..kktt,,ttkkbb
ff[[kkjj,,kkjj
,,bbcc llffvv''ffhhtt,,ff##
(ovbylf /flbcb)
hhffcc uuddffccooffddkkbbcc ..ddbbhhaaffccbb
vvee//ffvvvvttll iieeffvvffddffkkbb
ª dby] vjhoveyt .vbc cf-
zbhjt,t,c lffrvf'jabkt,c^
fkkf/b vfcf] sfdbc cfzbhj-
t,t,c lfervf'jabkt,c!
ª dby] veckbvfyc ufzbh-
dt,bcfufy b[cybc^ fkkf/b vfc
ufyrbs[dbc lqtc ufycf]ltkc
uflffhxtyc&
ª dby] veckbvfyc xff]vt-
dc^ fkkf/b vfc ufyrbs[dbc
lqtc xff]vtdc (ovbylf /flbcb)
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
53
llff[[vvffhhtt,,bbcc ..ffkkff ''ddttkkffcc iittccoottddcc
crjkbc rtlkt,pt sfdbceafkb flubkb fqfh b'j& v[fhlfz-
thbcf lf lf[vfht,bc cfpjufljt,hbdb jhufybpf]bf ufcek rdbh-
fc vtpj,tk mfkfmib vjv[lfhb vbobc.dhbc itltufl lfpfhfkt,-
eksf lfcf[vfht,kfl fabit,bs e[vj,lf vjcofdktt,c& ,fdidt,b
nhfutlbbc itltufl ecf[krfhjl lfhxtybk^ f[kj,kt,lfrfhu-
ek^ vibth lf vo'ehdfkt flfvbfysf lfcf[vfht,kfl aecaect,-
lyty& [ibhfl bcvjlf vjojlt,f% @lf[vfht,bc .fkf 'dtkfc itc-
otdc#& sev]f [ectbyb abmhj,lf^ hjv cbn'df fh b'j cojhb^ vb-
cb fphbs^ ufzbhdt,eksf lfcf[vfht,kfl cfzbhj b'j cbvlbl-
ht& vfvbc cbrdlbkbc itvltu [ectbybc vfnthbfkehb vlujvfht-
j,f ufefhtclf lf lfpfhfkt,eksf lfcf[vfht,kfl vbcf]tvb
aekb fh /mjylf& cfmdtkvjmvtlj fm]bfv cfv lqtc ufcnfyf& ,j-
kjc ituhjdt,ekb ybdst,bc cfndbhsj vfymfyfpt lfndbhsdfc
iteluyty& [ectbyb [tkib gfrtnbs vjrh.fkt,bs uftvupfdhf cr-
jkfib& rfht,sfy sfyfrkfctkb jcvfyb itvj[dlf& &fh] jcvfybc
vfnthbfkehb vlujvfhtj,f b'j rfhub& ltlfvbcb lfvkfut,kfl
veifj,lf& jcvfyb vfymfyfpt ybdst,bc ndbhsdbs lfqkbkb'j& vfy
[ectbyc lfyf[dbcsfyfdt gfrtnbc itcf[t, /rbs[f% hfc fupfdyb
vbobc.dhbc pjyfib? [ectbyvf egfce[f% tc xtvb ,fdidj,bc
lhjbyltkb cf,fybf^ hj]f lfd,flt,ekdfh^ ltlfc iterthbyt,bf&
cfvoe[fhjl^ vbc ufvj'tyt,fvlt ufhlf]dkbkf& ltlbc cf[cjdhfl
dbyf[fdlb& vbobc.dhbc pjyfib^ rfhdt,ib lfhxtybk ,fdidt,c dby
b]bc^ hjujh c]bdfs^ erdt lhjf^ fv cf,fyvf ufzbhdt,fib v'jab
uffs,jc& cbyfvldbktib bm lblb lf[vfht,bc ufupfdyff cfzbhj
fct evybidytkjdfytcb rb fhf& &jcvfyvf fv[fyfuc egfce[f& cekf]
fh dabmhj,^ hjv evybidytkjf^ lblb lf gfnfhf lf[vfht,f fh
fhct,j,c& uf]tvekb 'dtkfathb vbc flubkfc lf cfvfubthjc
yf[fdc& vt rb cf,fyb] fh vfmdc^ hjv vbd]t^ vfuhfv fh] vbabmhbf^
hjv fh dt[vfht,b& fct hjv vtabmhf^ cfndbhsj vfymfyfpt thsb
vndbhsfdbs yfrkt,b bmyt,jlf lf fvbnjv cfndbhsj lfudbfyt-
,bs ofdbljlf& vt^ vbobc.dhbs lfpfhfkt,ekt,pt lf[vfht,bcfs-
dbc fkkf/c dtdtlht,b&
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
54
hjujh eylf vjbm]tc fbit?
o'kbc ufvf][tkt,tkb ,frbc ufceasfdt,bcfc
,frblfy lfqdhbkb ][tkb o'kbs fbitc sfyfrk-
fctkvf afnbvfv [tkt,b lf cf[t lfbodf& afnbvfcs-
dbc lfcf[vfht,kfl crjkfib aekbc ituhjdt,f
lfbo'tc& afnbvfc se [tkt,cf lf cf[tpt cfcohfa-
jl vrehyfkj,f fh xfenfhlt,jlf^ lfvodhj,bc
rdfkb itb.kt,f lfhxtyjlf& fbit idblb sdt rjvgbenthbc cf'blkfl
aekc fuhjdt,lf& fqfh b]jlf hf tmyf^ @bvfc dbqf]f vfby]
lft[vfht,f# ufbabmhf fbitv& hflufyf] rjvgbenthbc 'bldf vbcsdbc
.fkbfy vybidytkjdfyb b'j&
hjujh vjbm]tjlbs fcts vlujvfhtj,fib hjv 'jabkb'fdbs?
lfothts vjs[hj,bc ufuh.tkt,f&
.dbhafcb ve/fvvtl iefvfdfkb ,h.fyt,c%
@veckbvfyb veckbvfybc .vff vfc ite,hfkt,kfl fh vjtm]tdf^
vfc cfahs[tib vfhnjl fh lfnjdt,c&#
(veckbvb^ ,bhhb^ 58)
''eehhffyyiibb oovvbbyyllff kkjj''vvffyybb iiddbbkkcc ffccttss llffhhbbuutt,,ffcc ff..kkttddcc%%
/tb idbkj! etzdtkfl^ ityb ufrtst,ekb cfmvtt,b vljudbc vfh]dkbc
jltyf] hjv b'jc lf vbvfkekb rkltib fy ]fsf ibyf^ fylf ltlfvbofib^
cfzbhj lhjc ufvjfvpteht,c vfc fkkf/b& hfvtse fkkf/b 'jdtkbdtc
v]jlytf lf v]yj,bthbf (cehf kj'vfyb& fbfsb 16)&
@cbrtst /mty pqdfib uflffult^se vfc stdpb dth
vb[dlt,f& ufvxtyvf b]bc&#
@vflkb /mtyb mdfpt lflt^ ufbfht^ oby lfud[lt,f#
fv fylfpbc itcf[t, fv[fyfut,sfy bvcwtkts&
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
55
rrhhjjccddjjhhllbb
1& fkkf/bc othbkt,bc iefvfd-
fkpt xfvjvnfyb fyutkjpbc
cf[tkb
2& ]jldbksf cfv'jatkb cfbm-
bjib
3& vtxtsbc ptvjs fqvfhsekb
rjirb^ cfblfyf] vkj]dtkt,c
cfkj]fdfl e[vj,ty&
4& velvbdb cfv'jatkb flubkb
fv mdt'ybc itvltu
5& fkkf/b
6& lfvwtht,tkb^ hjvtkcf]
cofvc
7& bckfvbc vbvltdfhb
8& fkkf/bc cf[tkt,bc rht,e-
kb& fkkf/bc kfvfpb cf[tkt,b
9& bc^ hf] yfvldbkbf^ n'ebkb
fh fhbc& cbyfvldbkt
10 ovbylf o'fkb vtmfib
11& vflkbfy [fk[sf cfv'-
jatkb cfbmbjib
12& xdtyb cfhoveyjt,f
13& fkkf/bc vbth btcj iefvf-
dfkpt ufhlvjdktybkb obuybc
cf[tkb&
14& b,hf/bv iefvfdkbc idbkb^
hjvtkb] vfvfc 'eh,yfl eylf it-
tobhf&
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
56
rhjcdjhlb ud& 55
rhjcdjhlb ud& 35
rrhhjjccddjjhhlltt,,bbcc ggffccee[[tt,,bb
p
y
t
j
,
f
x
t
v
c
c
f
h
o
v
e
y
j
t
,
f
c
d
c
o
f
d
k
j
,
55