jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG...

65
i JIGU O JJC OI1LCG b1Lbp2 ui? pc dnoGq miporn GxbpcT bcuM!iou bLoAJqcq JJJT 1frJ cLqL rucjnqiu © uopcc © p? jccpq p JLGGIJJflF \f UIJ Lc2GLAq 2IJOLf 2GCJOLJ2 O 1GX4 UO O cxcq MO opc &rnpoL uq uo O2C opC ,iouq BflLfl oTEcououJTc cc1Lcp jpi b&bci J2 oU/1pEBr i.tcp bi.ouim rn f1OL uiqJ yu? obiuiou cxbLcq LG buj 'v o j J 020 ' 221C}Jf1G \fliCUflG 1.4VIIOI4VF BflffEVfl Oh EGOk1OIALIG KEEYICH JoLjuIJ b&bCL o j 5 jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ VIOEI'tL VI4D ocivr bBOCE22E 2bflK] Ik1 flMIOk1 3g/: DEhIWW 1411EK tAOJKII1G bVbEI 2E11E2

Transcript of jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG...

Page 1: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

i JIGU O JJC OI1LCG

b1Lbp2 ui? pc dnoGq miporn GxbpcT bcuM!iou bLoAJqcq JJJT 1frJ cLqL rucjnqiu © uopcc© p? jccpq p JLGGIJJflF \f UIJ Lc2GLAq 2IJOLf 2GCJOLJ2 O 1GX4 UO O cxcq MO

opc &rnpoL uq uo O2C opC ,iouq BflLfl oTEcououJTc cc1Lcpjpi b&bci J2 oU/1pEBr i.tcp bi.ouim rn f1OL uiqJ yu? obiuiou cxbLcq LG

buj'v o j

J 020 ' 221C}Jf1G \fliCUflG

1.4VIIOI4VF BflffEVfl Oh EGOk1OIALIG KEEYICH

JoLjuIJ b&bCL o j5

jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ

VIOEI'tL VI4D ocivr bBOCE22E2bflK] Ik1 flMIOk1 3g/: DEhIWW

1411EK tAOJ�KII1G bVbEI 2E1�1E2

Page 2: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

wuupcLoLuq .1BEIcGuJpL!q I"IV O5J3H1L1Lq flu!AL2JADCbI4WCU 0[ ECOUOUJ!C2

if ELGGW&IJ

LO/14JJ ju IJJfU? iuqn2uc2

JUCL121IJ MOLJCGL q2iLc2 JOL IIUJOU2 uq p? LfJ2JU qu2iA TpoIc CLWCJJ JGAGJ J9L L1bJq

qcLcucc cdruuou bLoqncc2 2bnM2 oi f'rnou LoMp jJJG DGbLG22!0U JUJWUGq 11 2bfTJ4 p?

JOM P' III2 OUC ITU!0U2 JU COULOJ OT pc LC1CAJU{ IJJLLJ(GT JJJ LC2II!T 12 J UOUJJUGJL

OLIJJTU iuq &CTAJO L12C2 MJJJ qCU21A JJGU TJJ2 MJjJ qGu2T{) EWb10GL obbo2JTou 12 pJp ¶U

ciij iuq cwbJo?cL obbo2TJou pop o MJJJCp qGbuq OU JJG bLobo!.pou oLrUiGq flUJOU

I UJOq fiuJouriou f2 pG OfICOUJG LLOIJJ 1 COIJUiC PCWCGIJ IHJ!OU\MOLJCCL OthJIJfLJ&

t LP LOMJJ O yUJLJCU Jqu1iou O FPOL (\fEr') IIUJOU2

JJJG LOThJJ OJ, GlO JTJJ1UJIG2 MJJJ JIUI GbO UUTUCJJ OL OL U1!U riq

3 JJJG Miqc2bLc1q fl2G OT LGCOUWOU 2IJJJ(G2 qnLJu I àO2 2bfl14

r' jpc npidnA o bni. ju nuiouiiou 1CLO22 COflUTLJG2 bu4Tcn1&LJA JU pG DCbL22!0U

LOfIL biccc2 oj cAiqcucG LG oJjGLGq OL qJJ2 iuthLcToU:

LL0CG22 JJJU JL0W CM DC&I JCJ2JiOIJ nJq d02OT IIJqfTUJ OLIJ!OU2 (Gb) JqGL2pb

i- abrn4 12 GGL rniqciooq 12LG2f1I.IJJ FLOW DGbL2210U 2bLJCGq uqoGuofl2 2OCJJ

jpi2 bbL XJUJ!UG2 qJG 2bfIT4 TU fl I1IJJOUJ2UJ qnuu OLT DGbLG22!0U JL11G2

VB1W1C1

I7POL wqJc2bijI4BEK //OLJUU WJbCL J,O QOJ5jçcpn.q B ELGCUJJ1Jiuq OCJ1J hLOCC2222brn42 !U flUJOU LoMqJ: DT!U!JJ OUJC1JI2

Page 3: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

$

uq tp sbbLobqst GOflIJtGL scwsj to su1 AGU IJtG t5tOU) I COU6L J6fl2CObG OL 1JtGLbL€t5t!OU 9IJq OIJJA JUJtq bop!J!A 0L 4G2qIJ pU6thLGtS4Ou2 (1epcLc qo MG

BGCSflG 1116 GXb9IJ2!OU O IIU!OIJ!2U1 W U!G C0I11UL? 11J S JJG b€qoq J65A62 WPC}J

N4JSi ! W4 JGSC?J

q't UISJCG Ij7 bGI4Oq S UJOW61U W W JJZOL) O fl JSJOL LJ9t!OU 91Jq 1 20b

ocisJ qAiisuc pquq qJG LOthqJ u ITUOU5OU D!q 1116 TÔO ut!wqOuSJ jGSC?

M92 It bSLr-suq-bSLccJ oj qic uounsj bstcw o nuou q6AGJobwcu qic su nuq6LJ?u

H2 qr D6bi.2aiou OMqI o fl flUOU!2W nu!dnc GAGUt u nsqc nuou JI2tL

r' rG!E iib jITLLS) 1JSJt6L K6flW6L L62qGut K002GA6!t 9UJOU OtJJGI2 ItM92 911 GLS O

qGAGjobuJGut o iJJG Ufl2t4SJ rwou auq qJG abGqtjc psujc sug b6L2ou9Jqce ot qic --wi

6uJbJrn2 011 tJJG fiSUGL Ct tJJG qLSUJStjC GJG1J42 211LLOmJqpJ JG OUJJ9tOU O qJG CIO tP

flCC611T flOIJ9tOI1 O qiG pJfTG-cOJJSL MOLJC OLG w tP TÔ3O J90L 4OL91J bjscG L69t

i.onb!u O 1UOU' JG COI 0 1q1t4 OL1JTt!O1J2 (ClOY JIJ GxbJ5nmJ qi

sjo snocJstGq w qiG qGAGJobuJGut o Ufl2P4SJ flUOU2 SlJq qJG 0UJJSqOU 0 S 11GM USqOUSJ

4LSUJGMO4C jOL Gp2JJu IUqOU2 1J tJJG flUtG 2t9t JJJG T3O2 koiip o nuouw /1i92

tG 191t-H51416A Yct (To') suq GLJ(T11J f62JStOU coutwnG2 to bwJ4qG t6

I.4St'O"J r'Spo KGJStIOU2 vct (fi9uGL VC4) W Tô3. (c6 ETflIG fl JpG JjSuGL Vct woqq

2pa1.bt wcI.Gs u qGuA occnu.!u '141111116 2nbwG con1.t qGq2ou nbpojqu 1IJG

yUJG4CSU JSPOL LGISIIOU2 2A2tGUJ ,swczbsqou u mqou GxbjoqGq w w ioo aqqi

fl2• JUpOL JJJatOL) yjsu? BusJ)t2 iici, tG qIJI. wuJu bo!IU u qic qGAcJobwGut o tp

JJIG Tô3O D6bt!ou w,itp o mjouw qjc wot anqGq 9Uq 2CZ12G bGLoq u

Page 4: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

3

Gxc6b11oIrnJJ) I9LG 2b1fl4 poU "!W b91.9116J2 U fl JJ20L? 911q 1J OWGL c0mW462 92 IiGJJ

0 201116 GdITTjipLIflUJ A9Jn6 fIG 6xb9112!ou O 11UO1JThW !IJ WG D6bLG!OU 61.9 !A92 911

L96 IUJO1J I.0!i4J 19JC62 1116 0LUJ O 2G0U1Jfl0fl2 2b(T142M 1.9JI6L J91J LSqI19J JOJ2PC OHI1J

2C2 OIl mJOU UJGUJPGI2}JTb OL 4G fl16 962 9uq O1JGL C01UU462 2}JOM 11'

o fluouw: jpc nuqpqAG

flJG A9IJ196 boiu oj IfOLJC6L2' 111J!O1J2 sUq LUJ2

L9UJGN0LJC OL G249pJj2ppJ IW!0112 911q COJJGC11AG P9L9111U 92 JGCOUJG onwjoqq LOU1

conGc11AG P9L9!1JiU fIG j69CX o p€ DGbL.622!ou-G1.9 2bm4 dn!6 qq6i6u: 911

ii€ii bwij€iu 4NGUlX 01. 11JL X6912 9O I1J1 1JJ6 MGM DG9J G219PJ2J6q pj€ 2X6w o,

2bnW 1}J6 JàQ02 10 ]Ø2 q6cJG 04 b4A916 26C10L qGu2A 10 bLG-DGbLG22!OU J6A6J2 pGJ!62 1116

MJflC}J A91.? L0W bGI4Oq O b614OJ 911q COmUL)I O comj&' V2 O IJ6 jG9C? 0 WG DGbI.20U-

wq6uq nuou Lo#qJ jG w qIG Guqo6uo(T2 20c19j bL.occ22 U0 111 IJIG JJ!2014CSJ q69TJ

911q b0GU119JJ? u.ib6J Wo26 bwcG22 u b!cnJ q!LGq!0U2 9 OuJJ9iA6 4!w62 piu ip€ ic€? o

b6I2OU9!G2 !" 1116 D6b22!0U fl'1111 2WG 2!UC GAGIU2 9uq bGI2OU2 !IJU6 bLoc62262

COUIJJCI OAGL OL9IJ11OU 92 ObbO2Gq iO 911 GXbj91J9!OU w016q !U 2bGqc GAGUI2 sug

€xbjsuiou 0i WG D622!011 GXbG4GIJcG !U 16U1J2 O 9 6UGL9J €oi) o cwbJo)GL-cwbJo?cG

GLG D6bI2T0U M92 0116 O flUjOU L0N4JI ju W9UA C0mU462 f112 j€92 1116 01I41 911

boqw i juq ip mouuJ Gu6L9JJ) LOM2 u q2coII1JffOfl2 2btILl2 9uq bGI4Oq o J6

DGb1.622!011-6 GXbG4GUCG u jj o qGAGJobwGIu2 !U OWGL COW462 uq w OWGL !WG

Page 5: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

3

1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U

BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU qGIJ2!A 111 bqA96 2GCIOL 2b11L12 suq 111

bGqoq2 o qGcfluG

p1cI.692G2 p1 mroU qG1J2X ponjq 6L LOW fIG b9UGuI o qccI.G9262 p1 nuou q611214). qmu

p1 fIG L9G 0 L0thfY p1 9qqjfoif 0L 2b1U42 o pG s LthI bp6uowGuoir fIG bu o

G GxbGqGq p? 91J? uJOqGJ 0 L9IJOUJ UIICUT94OIJ2 p1 I.0MfJ' GAGU !!4f12OUJG 91110-COLI.6J9f011

2flC 911 Gb120qG UJGWpGL2Jfb ponq oii UJOLG I2bqJ? p1 GM C0Ufflfl2 ?.6912 fI9U MortJq

CS1J p€ qGAGJobGq jfl14}JGL ] 9 2b1T14 J 1116911 9 21J91J) CouC61uLsGq Gb20q6 o mnou i.oiEjr u

Q0p1 pG?ouq fIG A12119j b!cWt fIG UOfOU suq lIG9WG1U 0 2bIT1.211 p1 mfoU L0MfJ

9 21)1114 p1 b11pjc-2GqoL IIIJ 011 2W L0W 9P01U TÔQS 10 J5 OL 20

W02 9U9J?22 qGLGUf9G pG/AGGU fIG UAO bGL!0(12b 911q 2p9Jj qo 20 9120 Ill gqq!fOUb fJGL6 12

LGbOI4Gq p? JLth 91IC JIGp1 (1à82) qo6 U0 G 9J (1o18Y DmUf 01) (Jà48) uq

11111011 WGWPGL2IJTbb 011 M11!C1J J L6JX 2J10M2 9 L6 pIU fIG 26462 0 mijou uJGuJpGL2p!b

Tô34 10 J3 JÔ"15 10 Iô'I 21)11142 !2 dnGa1ou9pJG BIG Bm.G911 0 '9p0L 29f2fC2 26462 011

911q 10 J4 JjJIGfI6L MG 2}I0flJ qyq fIG DGbLG22!OU-GL9 LO!AfJ 0 mnoIf2W U0 fIG

2J10/A2 fAG 21)11142 p1 IUJIOU 6U2 1880 10 188Q' T8Ô 10 10'i IÔIQ 10 J5J J3'c 10 JÔ3Ô

(f fIG OAGL9JJ b9I4GLU !2 2fJJ qowtq p? qGAGJobWGu42 p1 fIG bqA9 2G(40L ObfUJG4C2

j91.6J? ib1.62G1U fISt 2GC0L p1fIG 1ô02 J10MGA6L bt1pj!C-2GC10L 1UI!OIf2W &.GM zIIpaWuf9JJX'

W02 0 fIG bG40q ITIfOU2 !AGLG COIICGIUI3IGq I fIG b4As 2GC40L 2OfIG qGu2!1A fI1LG2

E1AII.G J 2}J0th2 fIG bicw 0 11111011 q6u2A J fIG fl f.OW 1880 fILO1TJJ I0L

BI6 yUJGUC9II JXbGUGUCG

Page 6: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

qcu2sA iionjq JAG coqcq 5p261u oqq

qGu2isA 1;64J (4ponp uJGwp6I2pb ucLG926q) 21T624pJ tJISt St J6525 201116 01; 4}J6 1Ô302 9P1 1.I1

SCJJIGAGq 01. W9USU6 2!UJbJA 1;LOUJ 5}J6 1ô302 2bm.r p1 1;SC1 6ttAGGU JÔ3Ô Jq Tô'4S 11111011

'!5P joqq jjsi. II JJ1T2 sLnspjX pwnps nuou 24L6Ut to JGAGJ2 tj'st onjq UGAGL JJS/.6 p6611

R4W P°SW EUJOJIA' 4pC 34 40 J3 21)1114 NS2 1;0Jj0li6 pA 4116 J45 tO JÔ4 2brn4 9220Css€q

I1IJ!OIJT2UJ !U 4}J6 18802 th02 qnG U J0L6 1)514404116 LOh!4JJ 01; 4116 }(IJJJ42 01; r'SPoL) P11 1104

01; 1111101112111 (tJ16 J2 40 Tô0t 21)1114 M92 L6J546q tO 4116 1;OLUJS5IOIJ 01; 4116 TJ' 4116 WCI.6526 UI

(qnuIJ JJoLq Jj,012 9uq fl 4116 0A6WWGUt 6IJC0(TLS6 261416W6U4 01; q2bntG2) 01.116th 1;0U112

01; Ufl24(49J 11U!01J2 ESLJ!GL 21)11142 thGLG 0220C946 IA!SJJ 6!SIJGL 211p2W114!AG J69J CJJSUC2

JS0L JS!I2 suq !U 41161194(11.6 01; 11141011 0L9I410t!0112 4S4 CL605G S ,,U6E1 IUI!0IJ!2WII U 1116 1;OLUJ

OCCITU.Gq WS bGSCGtIUJG bGLIOq 01; }J}J 11UGWbJOAUJGU4 t !I92 a220CSs6q !41 !1J110A9110112 1J

L0N41J 01; q6u2A suq 01; q61J2A 1)61. AGot 01; suA 2b11W 1 couse 40 4116 041161. 2bm42' t

H° qoG2 4116 1ô3'I 5° Jô3ô D6bI.622!011-2b1T14 Joojc pi 4}412 C0U56X4 p joq 4JIG J91.624

IIIJ!0U qcusA

COU4LS24' S26U4 tJJG b640q2 01; 21)1114' fl (1141011 J1!24OLA !2 cJrnucs646q pA sqnsj 61.02101101;

qG112sA JpG ob5!wG54c2, LG9U 01; 4}J6 qsw 12 1104 abnqon2: 2bm42 p1 Lo!iqJ 91.6 i.sj j

CJ(mJbGq 4064GL 411911 GCLG02G2 p1 q6IJ2tA suq 91.6 woLG pjijA C0U.6J946 sjrnu v'.c qGCJpIG2 iu

01; 09) fIG CJJ9116 !2 9J20 J1}JJA coUcGUtLStGq: 9p12 p111141011 qG112sA 91.6 WOLG J!ICGIA to G

b6LC6uw6 bopu2) 01.411911 p111011-21)1114 bGqOq2 ilJI6u q6u24A qGcJp1cq (011 SAGLSG S1ThI1T9 J022

bonu2) 411911 p1411611011-21)1114 b640q2 ilGU q6u2A 1JCL6926 (911 SA6LSG SUIJIISJ ot o

fIG CJJ5IJG p1 q6U24A 2 J9L6L pi 4116 21)1114 b640q2 (911 SA6LS6 SUUJISJ SJ 01; 55 b6LC6UW6

Page 7: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

2

1}J9 bn qiu o b!on bm.i 1116 11P!dff!A 0 L0N4}1 9UJ0U GX!RJ (IUTOU2 9uq qIG

j0U1J901J 0 11GM mnou 9u i &ion JJJ2 JJGjb2 6xb19111 G I.G96L W9UUTq6 0j

H0MGAGL UI JG Jà3O bi.oboou o jic toM1T1 ooj 1p6 0LuJ 0j 1p6

U694X GAGL) (1111011 GXbGUGIJCG2 wGwpGI2Jnb 112

1p W'4PJ !uJbj? JSL6 C}J9UG2 !' qGu2A flJG 19P16 }J0M !IJ 9UX C926b flJS w s bm

nbMw 4J16 WG 0 CJJ91JG U J0U wGwp612pb qm4u A914øfl2 bn 91.6 o LG9 i:jiai

J1 0A6L219162 k0M4J1 U 1fl10U qGu2A 1J IJGA91U qqCIOU u b640q2 oj GCOUOUIIC

I LGbOI4 WG 0!!411 U 16L1112 0 bGLc61U9G C}J9UG2 !1J 9p20j(uG w6uJpGL2pb NP!J

2RUJUJ914G W J)P16 5 BGC9(126 I qo U0 J19A6 !1J0LUJ90IJ 011 GUJb1OXUJGIJI /AIJIJW 69C}1 (UJ!0IJ2

J 9uq LPI J 9uq 1J 1J16 LGJGASUt IJOU-2b1U4 b640q2 1116 L611JI2 0 W!2 9119J

(1o82) J P 6XSIJJT1JGq Wc I.oN$JJ oj, uqii4qnj T0U2 iii 0flL 2bnL12 qGui6q u nrc

111 1LSq0U9JJ? uoumiou 0CCflb9!0U2 OL xJqn214Ge" fl21J q919 L0UJ 1LO 91J 2PGUW

M}IGLG (UJT0I1 MGI.G q0u9JJ? COUCGIUL94Gq C1.69!0U 0 11GM flU!0U Monjq qC9G mJ0u

U9IiOM nqqclouw jJ1fl2' 6Xb9112!0U 0 6XI2PU (W!0112 MonJq qc9G 0L91J19!0U 0 GC0I2

9uq JJ6 br.6-CIO uqn249J (UJ01J 2flCJJ 92 JJG JGL2 9J20 psq L6J9!AG

WG DGbLG22!OU GXb91J2!0U W02 IUJJOIJ2 MGLG 0L9IJThG 0119 CL9j 922 M!W GXbJ!C!1

bTcn flU!U2 bi.oAqG 9 q2sLG91Gq b!cuu.G o qi€ bm4 bwcc p) 0L91J940W

q9 011 0US90U p? qn2Q 91.6 JU14G G0LG 1116 JÔ2O Pu j&T1.G2 011 wGuJpcL2pb 0L

yfl6UJ9A6J? 11GM OL GX!211U IUJTOU2 conjq Gxb9uq iuo bI.GA!on2J? uou-mJ!ou EXWIU

C9Lb6U4GL2 flhJiOU UJ1U 0LGX9UJbjG 2flCc6221JTJJ? 0L91JSG C91bGIUGL2 !' IJOIJITU!0IJ

2bflW EX2W (U0U2 M!flJ !AGIJ n42qC0I12 corqq LG9fl? TUCI.GS2G WGL i.cbI.c2Gu4ow Jpc

JJJG1.G 91.6 M0 bOaa!pJG M9?2 RI M}JICJI 9LG9IG (WT0UJW C9U U1CLG926 LSbiqJ) w

Page 8: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

b€uoq 11 9JJ C0JP462 OL M}J!CP q19 GX!21

140LM9)' suq V"1'-9J!9 WG 69L1A Too2 DGI12!1 9J20 L6M W6 joqq J9L i

qGu2!A L026 2JrnthJX u 11J6 uq 2W162 nut6q uqouf G6uJJ9u? JAGGU D6uuJL1e

LoM111 2b1TI42 JJ9AG OcCm.LGq I W11JJJ? 2IUJfl9L b640q2 11' 111021 C0m11462 [,OL !U2191JC6 mnou

t0ii$p 49J1J WG OLUJ 0 2119th cOIJc6IJIL9IGq 2b11LI2 111 W6UJp6I2IJIY EA6U WOLG 214Jq11 111I01J

W021 9qA9IJCGq c9b!J121 conIu4G2 MG juq bsUGu 2UJ9L o fy GxbG4cUcG: rwou

C0111J4U62 11111011 kO!14JJ 92 HI 9C p6611 JG22 q12c01W11fl0112 111911 HI 1p6 fl*1116C1 2W162 P111 HI

JAG WJJJ1 GXbGC4 10 266 j622 )nujb? bS1I6LU2 0 (1111011 LDM1JJ HI OIJJ6L C0mJ1U62 p1201116

COIIIJILIG2 92 JAGJJ CIAGU 1116 JJ!21O4C9jj) C0ULOU191!0IJ91 J9OL LGJ9I!0U2 O 6 flIJ1G 2191G2

VLG 2b11u2 111 110U ko!14p m11dnc o IJIG fl116q 21916201. qo IIJGX CJ19L9(4G146 OIJJGL

EXb646Uc6 0 0}JGL. COJ1IULIG2

JGL 1p6 9G2 0 JG9J CJJ9UG2 (EL66w9u ToQ)

2flC 92 46 1491!0U9J EqflC91OU V220C!9110U (14Ev) UO 111110112) 9uq LO!14 o GX!21!U mnou

11IJTOIJI2UJ 11111GM 91.692 'W1I6M 01. C9-U6 OL91J91!0U2 (1p6 2JA1cp 0 6WbJ0?66 9220C19P0112

1ÔQ5 10 TÔ5 J192 2!UJ!J9L bWbGI1162 10 1J1G 2bflLI2 2}JOMIJ TJ JflpjG s: Lsb!q Gxb9u2iou o

h!U9lJ) 11016 41911116 2bITLL 1101 C0A6LG pi 416 WpjG HJAOA1IJ bnpjrc 26C10L !A0LJ612 HI

Q9J6011 ToQO)

1119*4(614194 J9OL 11121049112 9AG 24LG22G 111 41GL q62C14b410u2 o IJJG bG4Oq (BGLII2IG!U JT

1.619110112 494 W96 4112 2bm.4 2ow64mJ q*4GL6U1 1 j9C4 1112 11112 269 C}19U6 HI 416 J9OL

IOUIJVPOU 04 11GM (11110112 111 416 D6b1622101I 61.9 2fl6242 9 I2G9cJJ9u61, 111 I9p0L-uJ9u96uJ6U1

Page 9: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

1116 b€qOq !AJIGU }19q We!' 2bm.r

9 1JJ9LQ1 21911211c: ipG 1uJM6}u6q 9A6L96 O C}19UG2 Lu q6IJ21X OL 1116 CO(TUILIG2 Lu b914 o

2!GC[ ILuJG ft1Iq0li2 0L IJIG b640q2 10 241IUW91.!6 ljIG b91iGu, pm 1JJG U369U C}J9U6 q6u2!A 2

q6LGU1 1!UJG2 9UJOU 1JJG 0011111462 fIG WpJG 2 HA1T1H 6C9fl26 P' (126q qGLGIJ1JX

wq-32-fi0LJq JJ91. fi b€qoq W1° °' Lu16I/J 1G DGb62!0U sirq °'-'I Lu

9AG A6U L09 j!uJG wnbLu2 w 1J16 19P16 9uq JI9A6 Lu bn.!Gnjt couibi.q 1G

JÔ802 10 IPG W!q-JôO D6J2!A 21PJ Lu IÔJO-JÔJQ' suq 1JJG 1ô202 9uq 1ôQ02

qGIJ2jA OCCJTLLGq Lu U69L1) 9JJ 0 1}I6 C0m1P462 Lu 1116 Tô5O suqLu UJ9IOUIA 0j COUIJILIG2 Lu 11's

P6Lu OII1219I1q GXb110U Lu OWGL b640q2 q6u21) M92 219J6 0L9JJLu D6C1W62 Lu

(3 bGLCGUI 10 4 bGLCGuly II LG/i Lu 1116 UJS1OUA 0 COIUJILIG2 Lu 1116 JôO21 ftJ1JJ W6 fl••

(5Q bGLGGIU 10 'f 2 bGI.G6U1) LOUJ 1ô3ô 10 J43 (3S bGIcGIJ1 jO J(J b6Lc6U1) LOW 1Ô42 10 Jf9

yju&jouJ q6u21A )•mIJbcq L0UJ 1ô1O 10 Jô13 (12 1Uj10 53 bGLcGIu) LOW TÔJQ 10 jØ

/A9 f Lu W wq-3Ø2\fio4q J!ØL fi b6140(1 J0L LuUC6 Lu 1116 flIJTIG(j

q6cjp16 flIqOIJ wGwpGL2}Jb 2bm32 SJJ 0 1116 C0W46 0L ft 11Tc}I J J19A6919 Lu 1116 TôOO Lu

L0M4}J 9CL022 C01U14L162 1J191 GU9JG2 1116 10 J9p6j 1}JG b6140q2 92 1!W62 0j 2bm.r 219P1J!A 01.

1p6LG916L fIG W021 21Lfl1J b9UGUJ Lu 1P Cj9W !2 1116 2!W!1914A Lu 111021 bGuoq2 Lu miou

GCSI12G O 1J16 M! 2nb&c2!ou O I.6G 1L96 1TIJT0U2 iiq IJIIUIpGI. 0 C01U111462

[5 C0m14462 flIJl!J IJYG unq J32-fiOLJq p/9L fl b€qoq IA}JGu Q6uJJ9u? 9uq ynI. GxcjnqGq

WGUJPGI2IJ!1) q9w JJJGLG !2 Lu10IIM9110U OIl COmJI4G2 Lu IPG JôOO2 Q C011U11462 Lu IàTOTÔJ(?

16 19PJ6 GL2 LOW bGI4Oq 10 b640q qnG 10 qGqIJ 9A9Ij9pfflU o mJ!ou

qGu2A SCI.022 comwca 1J191 111JJ!II12 1116 2Uqj94A Lu W 1WU O 2bflLi2 fIG UUUJ6L O

L'P!6 3 bwAIq 9 Wfl bcpuG o c 11W6 b9gGuI o 1G to1!p 01. 6CJUG 01; (tU!0U

Page 10: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

2

!t2 t!UJW

bsI.ticnj9q? 11G9J fIG 0UM6L dnGatou L619t62 to tJJG q)1J9UqC2 0 LONJ fIG J9UGL L6J9t62 to

bGuOq2 9CW22 COI11Jt462 pICJPqpJ tJJG IbI.G22!ou 11416110116 W}Jt jJ91G GxbGctGq J!0IJ2 tO PG

2bflU2 suq 2O !AJ19i !2 4}19t bLOCG22 fiJI) q062 1UJO1J LO1ItJJ occm. L0P2!UII9L

9Oflt IIJG L0N4JJ O flO1J!9t!0U 12 tjJGLG !2 9 2p1JG IflJq6LjXp1 2OCVJ bLocG22 10L L0N4JJ p)

b9UGuJ p1 tJJ2 2GGUpIj) pJpo2bt9pJ6 bGI4Oq OL mqOIJ2UJ JJJ!2 LGRJ914A L9262 uio dnt!ou2

J!O1J2W P1 t}J6 ff2 !2 UOt 91 !20i9t1 COmUL? bp6uowGuolr P115 L.9t}JGL GX6WbJJG2 9 GU6L9J

t}J9t (UJ!OIJT2UJ 61JGL9JJ? kOMa P1 nqq€u 2JJ9Lb 2bm42 suq tp9i IJIG DGbLG22O1J 21)1114 o

p1 2ITUJ coucjaqc tP9t 959 011 flU0U q6u2A 0L tJIG fl sIJq OSIIGL COI1IJ54G2 2}J0R2

D6b622!011 2!tflStiOlJ

2bGCflJC bOJ!t!C91 6A61152 j)flt 1.9SJJGL 9 UJOLG mIq9uJGuWj LG2bOIJ2G O GUJbjo?GG2 to tJJ6

2!WH9MA pi tJJG b9ttGUJ 2fl62t2 tJJ9t t11JO1J9t!01J 111 5116 D6bL622!OIJ qq hot LGUGCS CO111JtL?-

4OL!A9? qGu2A p1CLG926q LOW J3 "t P1 T5 5043 bGLCGIJ5 P1 Tà3ô 9U 20 0U fIG

bGLcchJt P1 TÔ4O P1 EI911CG q6u2sX il61Jt LOW O P1 JÔ32 to 32 bGLcGUt P1 Jô3 P1

tLGUJ 111) GSLflGL)' p1 tG flI515G (pJqow q6U25X nwb€q i.ow bGLcGut P1 1ô33 to 33 j

(spc DGbI22!0U GXbG4GUCG 0 DGUUJL1 U b91.51c1159V !2 uJ2jGsqu D1JT2P qGU2tA PGU

p15116 flhljtGq 259tG2 tJ10fl}1 P1 20JG C9262 tpc IUCLG92G R92 J622 COUCGU5L9tG 1 9 G!A )G9L2

2bm4) fIG 59J)J6 2J1011i2 51195 ITIJjOU qcIJ2s) L026 bqoL to 5116 9P1 2GAGLØJ C0m14462 92 !16JJ 92

20UJ6114195 qfl6LGI1t )G912 2J10M11 0L 5116 COJTU5I4GZ 50 C9bUILG 5116 t!WP1 04 tJJG!L bsicnj

JflJ6 OCP2G2 011 mJou q6u2A P1 tJIG D6b2!ou to joqq /J9I. jj bG4oq (Mtp

Page 11: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

W9IJ O JI6 1j9poL9oL 01J koccqm.GipG M9!0U91 r'POL KGISOU2 9o.q (MrKB)

WOqGj WffCG2 11U!OU 40LUJ9!01J 911 OITICOWG 0 9 P9G pGlMGGIJ W9U9GWGIU suq J90L I.91}J6L

p61J62\C022\211GUJ2 W4 9CCLIIG iO 46 UAO 2qG2 L0UJ GLGU4 JGAGJ2 O K1U0UW0U fIG

W9U9GWGIU 911q J9pOL 1I 1J16 0UIJ910U 0 flU0II2 9uq IJ0IIjW691J62 !U 1116

AX UJ0GJ C0Uc6III191G2 011 !A0 92b6q2 0 mnorn9pou: WG COUUICI p€6u

2nqqGlI 2p9Lb CJJ9UG2 U ITU0U q6u2A-q2co1unImG2--942c I.0W 4}J6 bLocG2z oi oL9u9!ou

92 C99JX252 OL p4?GI2 0L JI6 L0N41I bLOCG22' I j9) 0fU U 11112 2G0U 9 W06j !U pcp

GU9CWJGIU 0 bC JOO 9U 20 0U fi!4JI°fll q61JA1116 !Wb0U11 o b914!cn19L J9fl2 OL 6AGIJ2

ft9U6L 'TC1 111 EL9UCG pGC9fl2G 0 4p6 BJIIUJ 0AGLUUJGIU HI jL91JCG 111 9U9q9 6C9I126 0 JI6

L62flT11U L0W bOJC9J ob-qoiius1 cp9uG2: HI110112 L6i u WG nu6q 2w162 PGC9H2G o ji

mrou2W 1I bi.!cnJ91COIIIUL!G2 GUGLSJJ) 11UGLbL6 1J16 I.0I#I 0 (TIJ!OU!ZUJ HI 1}JG!L cOmjp 92

W0GJ2 211622 flJG 6X06U0fl2 2}I0CJC (T2IT9JJA G1IGL91Gq PX bO!!11C91 40LC62 W2049U2 0

pGJI9ATOL 0 1110fl2911C12 OL WIJJ0II2 0 1JqJAqfl9j2 9C4U !U L62b01126 0 0116 VUOWGL fIG J9UGL

}J6 CHIJJJTI911AG P6P9A!0L 0j pqiqqnj M0LJC612 I11JT0U2 911q JU1I2 fIG OCA12 !2 011 1}JG

uJGuJpGI2jnb fIG 0LUJ6L WOCjGJ2 2LG2 WG mJqGLJ)IJ bwc pX /ACJ oL91JT9!oU OCCIII2

6UiIL0UW6IU9J C9UG2 GIIGL9G COWU 611 I1I36J? J9LG L62b011262 HI 011IGLIIT26 219PJ6 ITIJIOIJ

26C0U 916 2WU9-Uj COUJb9I.911A6 2W1C2 1111691. 1110q612 U MpCp UJ922!A6 2J10CJC2 OL

CGLI9IIJ couq4ou2 91.6 uJ6--uJ0qGJ2 0 11bb!U C0U19!0U 2Gfl-0L9u6q cowbj6xi fIG

ftJJ!CJJ JIG bwc 0 L01A11J CI.69G2 11011-111169141162 11191 bt.oqJTcG bp92G 119U2W0U2 il6U

jj#o jTh62 0 W0GJ2 C9U GUGL94G 21)11142 11111111011 &0#4Jf fIG II2j 916 UJ0GJ2 111

2bfl4

Page 12: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

JO

uJGwpGL2\GwbJOAuJGui !U Wi 2GOL 1. ! WG uouJJ9J,, L9j6 o qGbL6c9Jou o qGu2A qaG

/AJJGLG flWIOM = 111!OU qGIJ2IA !U V JA6U bwqnc 11394(64 JU 9 bi.cnj ?cV q6J6q

fli4IOM4 = (I - L) IU4IOW + WEI11 (j)

jJJ6 9CJ(0U6 0 4JJ2 UJoqGJ J2 911 9CC0(flJ41J q61U 0L flUJOU q6u2A:

WGUJp6L2jThb'

0LVU1J 241.GU4JJ 4262 V1J GWbJO?GL obbo2!ou jjj bo46iuJj? bLoqncu 2bm4 w

cowb€!4!AG q!29qAVUwc !IJ p6!u 0LVIJ6q JJ1112' 94201116 I.91J6 0 JIIJ!OU q6u2' mi!ou

1111T011 qGU24) 4262' IWTOU2 }JVA6 JUCI.6926q LG2OITLC62 40(126 0L OL 1JJ11 Vuq JJLUI2 266 J622

24L61J4JJ 40 0LVIJ6 116/A 1JUl12 Vuq JUJ12 J19A6 V J9L6 I1JC6UIAG 40 01)1)026 0LV11J91101J V2

COJJGCPAG p9L9nnhJ IUWG I.6J6AVIJ W914(64 fiJJ6U (1111011 qGII2iA 2 J0/A LUJ0U2 }JVAG 1!4416

0L91J!S6 OL 01)1)026 OL9UJ94J0U qGbGuq C4JCVJJ? 011 4JJ6 b6LC6UIV6 0L9U6 OL C0A6LG p?

6UJbj0?612 p4u 0 4J16 C911JbVJ11 uq 46 WC6U4!A62 J1V4 4J1G?JJVAG 40 (126 4J16!L I.620fl1C62 10

jJ16 wOqGJ 6UCL9462 UOlIflhI6S44A 1J 0L9U1J 6C9fl26 4JI6 L620flLC62 J10IJ2 OL

UJV)OL 0VJ 0 4JI6 fi91JGL VC4 M92 40 I191J20U11 4J312 bLocG22 11140 9 26CL64 VJJ04 GJ6CIIOU

I.6211J5 /A92 V JVLG 1u1113p61. 0 0161J P!UGL L6C0U!4!01J 24L!1(C2 q1T41J UJVIJ? (1111011 2bI1L12 y

UJ9US6UJ6U4 WJJJ4 L61126 40 L6C0IJTS6 9(1111011 6AGU 1j A114ff9JJ)i 944 MOLJCGL2 2nbboLIGq ! ll'bGL 5}1G PVUJG UJ041 P26U4 4J16 241.11(6 4J1L694 p? /AOLJ(612 40 11111)026 GCOUOWIC C0212 011

fl2flJ GCOUOUJJC UJII2CJG 40 0LG6 GWbJO?612 40 9GG6b4 9 (W1011 94 W6!L /AOLJCbJVGG (Dm7101) Jo)

6IJA12962 b.0L 40 4416 thVU6L VC4 0L9UJ94!0U /A92 J9L6JA 9 W96L 0 24IS461C /AOL1(612

Page 13: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

JJ

bLoqncwiw OAGL 201MG L9u6: V WV22AG ITIJ!OIJ I4AG W!JU b? 0 uncp wow wsi V

qmnimjmi wwLu2 B'U 1 2 9j20 b022!p16 01G 01. Obb JIVAG WCLG921J 1M9LU9J

ouJ6wp6L2p!b 9uq OOU0UVJ 011 01.g01111 G014' GWbJ0?GL ObbO214iOIJ EAIJJ 9J20 }JVAG

I1'' C0uq401J9j 011 GwbJOXGL 0bb02111017' 11101.6 01. 1J••1J 6O14 114JJ ?46Jq quJup6q oiiqi

0LUY 0116 b022!P!JUA 2 1 P2 WSJ bL0(IflC11A!4 W POW 0IG suq 0bW20

0 20142' W qqoico >0 q\qob}, < 0 c)ouq 1pT2' 14 2 q1jcnJ4 40 2b6C 11U1C1101J91

fIG (UJC40U J 2 6 jcc) GJGWG1U O w0q6J y 11414611' j 2 V bwqncou mjcou

!AG2 400bb02flJ (WIOIJ quAG2

4JJ6L620flLcG2 tIIJ!01J2 IJ6 0 0LV1J1J uq = 16201T1.G62 W91J96UJGIJ4

= I(0I�C Obb) (5)

W JVpOL 9IJq WVUVGUJ6U4 GA04G 40 01. 1J11 01. 0bb02!1J oLsnV11ou:

fIG JCGX 0 W UJOqcJ 2 4}J6 1.946 0 UGli 0L91J94!01J' thJJ!CJJ qGbcuq2 OUWG L620m.C62

b9C1C9G W W94 26C40L W94 CVII wqrIcc GWbJ0)6L ObbO2!11011 4o flU!U2

PLIJW 4° CL6946 JGAGJ bjV?41J GJq,, jlJ 461.1112 04 V 2IIJ6

6GC42 0 ITIJ101J19110U 00 ULUJ2 W4 c0wb646 III WG2JG 91.69' suq OUWG VPA o COJJGC4AG

I 16U"6 flJ4IOW 92 fliJiOli qcu2I4A IJ V bwqnc4 W9LJC64 pGCvn2G W6 wOqGJ 0C1T2G2 017W6

W6 1AGIJ ?G9L

X64 p6617 0L9I1Gq 911q 114161.6 MEfi = 4116 '11° 0 176th W6WGL2 0LVIJGq 40 6Wbj0)UJ6IJ4 !"

2V)' 40 914411017 0 UJ6W612 01. JU1J2 01.4176 &0th4J70 GWbJOXUJGIJ4 IJ UGM 111.01241794 JJVAG 1704

Page 14: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

iom 9d Idgim--nslq nsoh9rnA rft--nnsd 31ni s bnuois noitioqqo iso1qrns ;3vhb

.I3o1qm3 Isubivibni 'd tho1 nsili thiinsio noirw thts19b ni li9xni

no abnqb 1dsmuiq 0510 .qqo bits 0510 ioI anoiisup9 9iiup5I I3bom sill so13 oT

29ub iiscll gnibnsq mo-n -isdmsm niix ol liIsnsd Isitnsloq 9111 ;asouosi noliw 3thlix

o bits noitsinoirw lo ,show noicwnon ol ationsci sill ;aisdrnsm wsn 3nisinB1o no snom

.ioivsclsd gnisimitqo noiiw lo ffnol smoa moñ nithjasi 0510 snismi 1ibasi bfuoo snO .no

sill :llsma sd Iliw 0510 1noilsinoinu 10 alsvsl wol cisv Is Isill ai 2511Up51 lsbom 'm IsriW

Isili 138qx3 I .aiiJsqms nisJnsio ol stovsb 01 o-woasi 9111 vsd Ion asob 1qmia noiiw

svibs11 vsci 111w noirw sill liansb iliil Is :noitsthnoinu b alsvsl ilid Is wol oals ai 0510

gnibnsqxs mo-il sittil nis 111w a-isdmsm anitaixs bits 1iodsl iol Ishsm sill isvo IolIrio3

wsn , aizs1ls ISsIIIf iluoixll als)how noiiwnon ol svolliqa alilsnsd noirw II .qiilaisdrnsm

aasl io siom alisI nsrll asth 0510 Isili slsIiJlaoq I 'li3i1qmia 'ioI .sIilil 1153 oals 'sm ais*tow

sill lo aslsmilas arrnil no abnsqsb noilslsi qq silT .140114U 1111w lls3i1od1risq

atiolls lo aasooua 1sli1 sill lo lnsmaasaas -usd1 ;noimrnon io noinu 3niIslsqo lo alao\alilsnsd

al qq .noinLr sill lsdmoo 01 svsil sth aso,uoasi sill bits ;asviib 3nixinsio nolnu lsslsb ol

3ths1q 1sv1 s ifalldslas 01 lssw 001 ai noliw sill 11 :wol ai MOIMU nsdw 113114 sd 01 18)li1

3flPS d s3slnsvbzaib svililsqmo3 £ 3nhsllua 1th bsirt3io 193 oilw armil io139a s th 'b1sil

ni rmil noiiwnon s :Il3irl al T40114U nsilw 113111 sd Ion sm io sm qq .atilonsd\as3sw 19143111

asltn noiiw d 9Izisqo laum Ii auista audI nistnism 01 IsdI bnil 'sm Is*tsm noinu 'lhsmhq s

asvnb 3itSfl531O ulo 3111111311 asowoasi sldslsbiano3 bnsqa -io assw isrl3iil io noirw 'sq bits

ns rrnfl sill Ii 1bnsd isrilo sill nO .at-iolls 3nLJns31o noirw saoqqo 01 svilns3ni sill 3nbubs-i

11i55 oX slds sd sm Ii aieAiow ittiw alns-i imono3e 3nhsda biovn bits nolnunon nismsi

Page 15: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

floitCI31 91(1(11 tfl591t11fl0fl 9131112 £ 1no 91W91 23ii1E1IB 91(1 aA .alflolq ñgizf 11noitq3ox9

I ,

isdmm w9n ninis o 229O01 91(3 ol b3ov9b xwoai 1(3 bits tian9b noiiw 1139w39d

.140114U lo nohm,1 3ninllb s 1qmi2 21 noiiieoqqo 'I8(o1qm3 351(3 (n3ilqmia ,oI 911flJ2B

noinu iii 2qmuj q15112 t&tg 'libs91 151(3 noiisupe 93n913Thb ls3nilnon £ 21 t1u3I 311T

owl 315 313113 5w3iI 10 A i15q nI .

thsn11non 1siln9 31(3 3wiqso -wiI '.1ianb

2013 fl2n3b noinU 'U inuhdi1i1Ip9 9Idslanu 9110 bits *U bits 0 1shdilhipe noims 31ds1

nI .(,1Ofl4Ui < (qqoos1o)1 =W3'frl n&fw h9qo1q siom) qq abx9 0510 19v9n911w

• (13v31 wol 191(109(1102 io) 0 21 tnioq noi1s.inoirw Isilini 3113151(3 9U225 I 9111311 iu 10 fi tis f1iik doirlw ,noilssinsglO 101 91129b 99o1qm9-noim1 3113111 325913(11 1511b513 £ O3s 31111111133H

doidw no1is.inomu ol noltl2oqqo 13o1qm3 111 92s9-139b 1subsig £10 rw3 0510 sift Inswqu

ai tnioq s313i-135 lilnu flan9b IlOfflU 3111(10 33&113 0(1 3V511 9rwqqo 31(1 &iswnwob 2311112

11013311111 3fl1X11t831O 3113 fIX 925513ffl 9113 a nsq iii .(0)NO < (0)0510 3-1311w lnioq 31(1 :bsibs91

•*U rrwhdiliup9 31(1 03 fl2n9b ni rwqe 113bb112 £ 213111231 911T .noiiSUflZ 21(13 233B313 *0510 03

.ansb noimi iii 29nib9b qisck bits thuq2 n9bbu2 rftod atoib91q 191)0(11 id3 abns3 ii 2A

cr1 anohw 93s1q2!b ol lluoiThb 21 ii ,(a9hinuo3 191(30 1tEffi bits) 29is1 belinU 9113 cii iua

s 3nhiup5l d lIu3iThb hs1u3i1IEq Isifi 3bsm 33A 13n3sW silT .321x3 vsift 31911w 25061q)hOW

b9lov 2-13)how 11911W 'hio qirIanoiisI91 noinu s bn9 blIXoo rn-ill £ isifi oz 9ooiq noils3flhll339b

3tBittfflul9 (19Vi139119 bIuo3 19WO 3fuftICgIsd 311O11 ifliw ifrill £ 1(3110113 1t011W 9113 vlitiob ol

tn9rn3oslq91 111 3nt3nnd bits 1n3rn39i3s 3itiitisgisd 3V13391103 £ 0331110303 3111211151 d arroirni

I j(3uorli 2s3si bsiuiU 9113 -io1 .)1311132 (101111191111k dm3rn noinii b 2doj 31119)18301 219)110W

333113 auouth3noib s 1131,2 3v511 ion ob 1ian3b soubsi siii qq0 o 0510 cli 2311112 Is1(i 9f!U1225

lo ihssnilnon di aui1T .1Y10114U I boh9q 119V13 £ ni iiansb lo 2201 rrwmixsrn i1i 1srn bits

Page 16: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

N

mJ!01J940U EAJJTC}J pi G L9W6M0LjC !A6U 90A6 2}J2 fJ6 0KG CflUG J 0fIGL UJG

pn2w622 j69q6L2pb 06L2 9 b061U9JJA 20U csuqqs 0L L9j2J !A0LJC6L qG2p.6 0L

co 1°P" r' FGIA!2 fl6 W91J1UTqG °1 fI6 D6b22!0U uq COU2G&TGIU !022 0 p6J!6 p1

UJCGIU!A62 0 I11J0U2 cjnqp PJ1J0A9!0IJ2 p1 flhJ0U 21U1CU11.6 211CJ1 92 fIG 0LUJ9J0U 0 fIG

9IJ 022 0 flIJ!01f9l0U fIG LG2O11LCG2 uq wcGIu!AG2 CpJ JUJJ2 9uq fIG LG2OAILCG2 9uq

}11240U91J2 2p.G22 fIG 9U!Wq62 04 MOLJCGL2b qGbGUqGIu OIl 4J1G!L 922622 WGIU 0 fI6 TflCGP p6u62

f1626 19C0L2 picpiq fIG MG/fl D691 J9OL bOllC!62' U0I9pj? fIG fti9IIGL VC f191 UJ02 J90L

OAGL JW6 p1 9 b9LfCnJ9L 26Up1 E°1. fIG flIJ6 W62 RI fIG D6bI.G20U bLoqb

1° 0 1U4JJGL' !4 !2 U6C6229L)1 ID 2b6C)1 fIG 9CIDI2 JU(GJ)1 ID 2JJ fIG 0KG 911(1 Obb

04q0LcG ii W91(62 bwqnc 11191.1(612 CLP1C9J pJ 9u9J)1pJ mou

G C01ICGIUL9G(1 p1 2GJGGq 2GC0I2 92 ObbO2Gq ID GACUj)1 2bLG9q 0CL022 26C1012 UI fIG

UICG1WAG 0L UUJJ2 ID 01)1)026 111110112 9JJ2 /14f1 }JJJGL JGAGJ2 0 qG1J2A 911(1 fI9 (UJIOIJI2UJ RIfJ

bp92G 0 9 2b(T fJGLG M!JJ PG C01J2qGpJ6 C011U!C1 PIIi W W!2 C0UU!C M!JJ qulpJ2p 92 fIG

!2 C0UJL0IIWf OIl OAGL fIG IlIf OIl !I PTIIOU fIG J0jC 0 fIG W0Gj 2flG212 f191 p1 fIG 694)1

GXI9IJ qGu2!A f16 1(6)1 COU(1p10U 0L 0/flfJ 21)111.12 L9fJGL fI911 L9(1fl9J &0N41J 0 UIfOIfS9fOU

p1(6JA 1.6194011 pGuflGGu fI6L ffJJOCSf OIl 0 LG2OIILCG2 jO 0L91I 1I 01. 0bbO2p1 9CfA!)1 q

bwqnc GII(1061I0112 2b(TLI2 !flJJGIJ 11111011 911(1 fLUJ2 P9UJG OAGL 0L91JJ11 (1I4AG2 !AGU fIG

9bbflC9pJG ID 9JJ p12fUTfOU9J 2GUp12 01.111116 bG4Oq2 pm L9fIGL ID 1I}IJJU fIG bOGIIf9j 0L

fIG bOpU 0 ff2 GXGLC!26 12 IIOj ID qG4AG fIG IIIfOU LOMfJ 01. qGCJp1G 6(1110112

qGcjp1G 2qG

puo lnwb2 ID IIGthGthT1J1pfnUJ 011 fIG I.0/flfJ 21(16 pm bLoqnc .9q1w1 qwb p1(161124)1 OIl fIG

fIG WOGJ 119II2tOUIJ2 .Lq1T9J CJJ91JG2 p1 fIG fl1JqGLJXp1 G2jLG 0L OL obbo2jou ID 1111101112111

Page 17: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

1?

qbrnG jpo GxbGu2 oiijq k€qc1 LOH4JJ omI!ouw w ncp UWG boq

fAOLJ u ojq I) oAGuJUJ6IU2 GGJ( iO wsquic bwqnqou pA wnnwinj

bsuGuJ iu N4flC m110w2w LOft Ill M9L bGuOq2 (L6cJj 1p6 LO!14p flnonporn WG qAIJCq

p€ cuqcc cqoi. 01. OAGu7w61J (pc Jc oqq ji.j su oiij

u qu2A u bqi€ GCOL uq1T24G2 0flG 0 JJG 2GLAKG2 PIU tWIG LON4JJ o

bcurnuu 9uq ccbq b o VWGL4CSU ocA pi poip abm.12 WGLG 11p21WJ

nutou qGU2A o mibt.cccqcucq JGAGJ2 iq wr pLOn}J W6 1ÔQ02 S 169W io UJ9JCG 11UI0112

1116 ii ioo b21ou-2bI uq ip jjoijq ji. j bnu isq uq 3W

U iiq ftoLJq jj9I. bni. ii uq

qLSUJ9C bGI4Oq 0 fl' flhJTOU JI2IOLA

mnoursjou BLonuq 1jJ€ liø4 pn o 1126 lJJ9i 9uq oql6i GIqqGIJcG o c pj ou qj6wo2

comi.A ilp bju 01. JGAGJ PSi U!U fl(T 4J16 S2JC oj qII2 b9bGL uo o GxbJ9jIJ

o uoumnorn6q uu2y qJG uc6IU!AG o GwbjoAGI2 o obboc "411 p wncp jc JJSU UJ

E°' COIW4I)t !A1J 6XGU2IOIJ O coflGqiAG p9L9UJUJ C01UL9C42 (Low JIG OL9UG 2GCOL

PGIJGW2 uq O242 O q6L61U b91.1162 qJ6L61UJA nJ qqcLGIu C0111U1462 EOL 6xguJbJ6 111 9

cowb6u2ou uq pcucj bcjc WOLGOAGL' 1]JG 291116 GCOUOUJ!C C1191JG2 WU 9J6L W6

6wbjoA6G2 suq ULW2 9uq U!OU2 p9 9Lf19pJX 2p6q OAGL w6 'ucG !1J2UU!0U2 6C1

OWGL CO1UW4G2 0116 WA cow€ nb !I4jJ 9 2111J1J9L J!2 O jJ6 UCG1U!A62 O OA6LIJUJ6IU2

LGqITccq cwb1oAci obbo2joir UJ9JU flOIJ91jOU G92GLb GAGU 92G1U 9 W 0K0 EP1.

bGLoq 2JTC 92 46 fioqq ft9L 01. JOLJ J9L J 2bm42 Gcouow!c pooul2 wp 9A6

Page 18: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

JQ

CJG21IJ6L (Jg) r'G11CIJ4GUPGL 91I LGqGJ (J3) JpG 'C4 92qGb IAJJGU nuiou2 c9u

9W4Pfl4G2 211111191.146112 40 W91I) Of16!. 9u9J?z42: B' (1o2W DGLPGL 911q (j)91111024 61JfL6J) flG 40 fIG jGT2J9fAG WG92flL62 o [) b QojcflGJq (j)

I4 cj91wq fI94: Jpc C9UG !'J fIG 1Um.G o yuJG4c9u j91)oL ,,pcp 4ø0J( bJ9cG lu

(jj b ix) 911q GAO4G2 U11TCJJ O JJ2 bwjonG cJJ9blGL 40 OO2GA6J4 uq P12 9qwnJ24L4iOw

qGCJ9LG2 4}194 yuIGuC91J j9p0L. P124OL? 400JC 911 GAG1U1fTJ W1U "4W fIG COUJ!U O fIG J,4Gfl D69L

C9JJ ff2 JJJG W024 L9qc9J b1GcG O JG2j9fOU GAG!. Gu9C4Gq (yJ91.G TÔ.8 I) 5Q B6U1246!IJ

M4!°'J91 UCj1124I49J J�GJ9fOII2 v (wflci) suq fIG fl9UGL VC4 2OUJG }JSAG O1JG 20 91. 92 40

21q1CIGIJ4 40 2b94C fIG L0!A4JJ 04 JUJTOU2 fIG? bJ9CG LG94 !AGIJI5 011 fIG GU9C4WGU4 O fIG

fIG AIGJA fJ94 S 2AWbSfIG4!C 9qUf1J24L4OU 111 th92 11GC6229L) uq bGL4JSb2 GAGIJ

f6 CiO p? 9 .onb o UJUOAS4IAG iUUOII J696L2 jq p? O}ThI f F/A!2 NSU? 9USJ?242 9flJGL6 40

1�0026AG14 yqUJpJ25!S4OU fIG b92296 o bw-JSpoL j4GIA D691 1G!219f0U' SIIq fIG OU1JS41OU o

I MIJJ C9fl fIG 5Ob-(j0H1J JJThOfIG 12 f191 fIG Jô302 L0114JJ LG2(TJ56q 4L0W fIG qGC2o1J2 O fIG

OC(T2Gq 011 fIG bO22lpJG C9491?4!C WJG O b9LI!CITJ9L 2OCSJ 9C4012 fIG 4J124 !1J46LbL649fOU 1141!C}J

JJIGLG 91.6 IJAO W4GLbLG4SfOU2 0 fIG CWT2G2 0 fIG JÔ302 2bm4 U fIG flU4G 24S4G2b G9C}I

2flLbU2UJ

(J33) bGLIJSB2 UI 'JO OfIGL bGUOq 04 yUIG4C9U jf24OL)i 92 fIG I.OIIt4}I O (UfOUT2UJ 2GGWG 20

yUJG4C9II 4L9G 1111101112W 114JJ pGCOWG !'J fIG UGX4 qGcSqG 9 WOLG 1)046114 2OCT91 1UUflGUC

p) CJI9IIG2 MPTCP qG25WX fIG p922 011 NP1C11 !4 12 GLGC4G 266110 LGS2OU 40 PGITGAG f194

qU2449J LG1S4TO1J2 qGcJs1.Gq: yw6qC9u 5L9G mfOUj2W 12 2JOMJ) PG!IJ fluI4Gq 113 WUnGUCG

B9L11GU fIG LG2qGIU O fIG yUJGI4CSIJ EC0IJOWIC V220C!9f011 (1EV)1 suq 911 GXbGLI !

DGbLG22!OU-GLS 2b1TL4 CSUJG 92 9 2JJOCJC 40 fIG GXbGLI2 0 142 qOq I" JÔ3S QGOLG H9LOJ

Page 19: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

pXbOfJG2Ie

2UJJ onjq JJSAG p6611 2flp291IfVJ 1.0J!41J 0 mf01J9f OIl 1I fIG J9G JàO2 &CCOLCjU 0 fI2

WUPGUcG2 0AGUJUJG1U9[ bojc) 2GII1 JJJ� suq fIG fi9UGL VCL 911q opu r' FG/11 fIGLG

ff110132 Ob6L9 1g 92 uq/qqff9J 9G1U2 MJIO2G COJJGCf AG 9C0U qGGUMG2 flW01I1.9f Oil 9U

9220C9G !IfJ pp 0pJG22UG22 jJf2 JJTh0fIG22 21122G2 fIG 9Cf/4fG2 0 Ii04(G12' fLUJ2 911q

qGAGJOIr J ff2 J4GJA flUTOIf2W C911 WJi 1I 911 GCOIJOUfC LGC0AGL? GAGU i fIG LGCOAGL) !2 21!Ij

q1Lcc41011 o WOAGWGIU 1U fIG Gc0u0wX LSfJGL 4}J911 fIG JGAGJ iis cicj ii jjotiu mou o

fI9 fIG L!GAInJcG--1022 oj O1)2 01. 42J( fIGLGo—-tA92 GxcGbfou9j u fIG €bI.2!ou 911q ip fIG

911 wbi.oAu bo2ou w fI 191)01. W9(G m,oue 1GU o ko!A (jj b ) HG 9LflG

D9A!22 fIG0L) 0 flifOiJ L0IAfI GxGwbJ!UG2 W!2 A!GEA: MJJGU J90L 92 1119101. L!GA9UCG2 911Cj

ebc 0L ff131011 L0M4JI GW9U9G2 I.0W lioLJ(G12' I C9JJ ff2 fIG poow-nb JIThOfJG2!2 flOLSCG

011 jG9qGL2Jqb MGLG GI10GU0IT2 LG2b01J262 0 fIG CJI91JG A!GR2 o Gwbjo)662 2WC6 fIG

4GA91JC62 0j GWbJ0?GG2 9uq fJGL J022 o 4SfI U P1T2W622 J69qGL2pb QOAGUJUJGIJt bOJ!CJG2 9uq

PJIGthLGWIi0II l0 !2 dnG qGw1u I 12 fJ9 fIG C919J?i2 0L fIG TÔ302 2b1114 !A92 fIG

JbI22io1r

LGUJ0AG J)1 uq GR2 U0ff1J UJITCII tAonjq JJ9AG p9bbGuGq 011 fIG JUJTOU LOiU 1I fIG

fIG W0IIGUJGIU NonJq jISAG 4OJI1IqGLGq 9uq Gxbp.Gq1 (b xxy J92 20LX 12 p92C9jj? fI91

fIG co M92 J9LGJ? fIG CLG9f 011 0 0JflJ r' F6N12 li4fJOJU M}102G JG9qGL2JJ1) uq 132UCii

'10P' r J'G1iU2 III 0U11flI fIG CIO 9J209 CLWC9J COUJbOIJGIU UI LOM4JI CCOLfflI 10 IL9

0 IJJ9UGL 20wGilJrnc A91491U 0 fIG 10b-qOMU 11Th0fI6212 12 fISt fIG JG9qGL2Jfb bLoAqGq p?

qGCJ9I.G fI9t fIG bI.G2IqGIU 1U2 XOn ° 1°W (92 W0116 dIO 0L91III bO24GL) 2ULGI)1 !1 91J

Page 20: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

Jg

!AOLJ(GL 0L9IJ1S941011 }ISAG COWG 0L1 40 (TIJI01JTG fIG 111922 bwqncpou rnqfl24uG2

40 W1CG LG956L 1J!4!9fA6 4JJSU fIG '!(}' pq 2JJ01I ITb 50 f195 bOWS 0'- UJ!IJ5 SUOfIGL oui o

bi.oqncsou uqr12s4G2 01. W}J5 201116 GuSLGbLGuGm49j mqou J6SGL 9/6 2sGbbGq ou!si.q

JT0U2 JJ9I6 GAGIJIJTSJJ) LG2bouqGq 40 fIG obboi.nuWG2 s0qcq pX !i0LJC6L q2C0U46U5 !' 111922

WOLG fJI.01TJJ 4LSf0U9J L6C01I!4!0U 24LflCG2 VP2GIJI 1OJIU r' ['GM!2 suq fIG CLO' onJq yj-

DGb22!ou-2bm4' pq C0UW22 j9J6 40 6119C4 fIG fi91JGL VC4' UJjJ14 111110112 JJSAG GxbSuqGq

2fl!c1GIJ4j? 40 jcb fIG M68}J56q 2ITUJ S0A6 fIG CI4fCST ISjfl6 I fIG C926 o fiG JÔ302

9Cjn24 40 fIG C}I91IG b61419b2 92G1J4 0116 9C40L' OfJGL CS112SJ 9C50L2 thorljq }ISAG UCL692G

LGdflaG2 9 11101.6 COWbJGX fJOfl}J5 GXbGUUJGIJ4 fISS 92262262 }IOM fIG LGUJ9UJTIJ 9C40L2 W!jJ4

W JfCJI 0116 LGUJOAG2 X suq 1J01q2 GAGLAfIT1J 6526 fIG 29111G I�S11JGL' fIG CO11II4GL 59C1fl9J

onjq }JSbb6U SP2GUS fIG 02GLA6 X 2J1011Jq IJY1 P6 9 2!UJbJG C64642 bsupa2 fJ01TJJ4 GXbG4WGUS

2bflLl fJSS MOfl5 1105 LG1GCS G!SJIGL pTh0fI62!2 11(14 5416 COmJ4GL 4;SCUI9J 491. qGs6L1JJuu liJJ95

br2mJrnpJ? 1A6 201116 iiG5Ji5 50 954 4;SCSOL2 suq 541(12 JG9 40 9 UJ115SI-C91129J GXb5911941011 04; fIG

RG1Ju6q 211111 40 C5GSGUIJIIJG R1CJJ 265 04; 4;9C50L2 M92 WOLG 5UJb0I4S1J4 2IICP 9 CSJC11JS54OU tionjq

uo 0116 04; 9ccGb451I fIG sob-qoiiu 25oL) 011416 poow-nb 25OL? pn oj bi.145ouiu fIG

Monjq qGb6uq 011ff2 2ITUr p1 ff2 C926' fI6 522116 04; qGciqW PG1JiGGU fIG 5!10 WSGLbLGWfOIJ2 52

011604; 4516 4;9C5012' suq M! 52152 011 mf0IJs550w pi fIG E!" S (ll9L9W 0KG - Obb

liG1JJ5Gq 211W 04; C0114I4IT541J 4;9C40L2' RX' 6XC6G(5G 201116 CL555C9J It9JflG' /IJIGLG ) WGS2ITL.62

LGCOAGL? 4;LOUI 6C01J0uJ5C L6C62250U 0116 conjq 56141W956j) 9L1TG 45194 fIG 21)111.5 691J !1JJ6U

Occnu.Gq q1TU1J 4116 ]4Gft DT' M92 SCCOWb9IJ5Gq p? fIG ClO 21)545' 911(5 0CCJ.6(5 5119 bGqOq 04;

JpGLG bwpJGui2 Ill qI4;4;6L6u4!9wJ pGUAGGU 541626 GXb59U9450112 JuG J3O2 21)1114

Page 21: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

JO

9uq ,j9poL940LX 646C440112 40L MOL4(6L2 40 C410026 /14165416L OL 1105 5JJG? M91156 50 m440IJGb

01J24q6L 1JL24 4416 6Aiq61Jc6 011 L6CO14444O11 24Lfl(62 D62b!46 4416 CL6944011 04 4416 ]4f'Jfl

bGL4oq

29) 9 M69J(GL j90L 19M' 4416L6 241JJ onJq JrnA6 p6611 S WSOL 11144011 2bfILI 111 4416 D6bL622!0U

ycs 41914110 G46C4 0114416 6A6U42 04 4416 b640q IT4 54194 94)261154416 'fC5 OL 111 5416 bI.G2GucG O

q646LWWflJ 0L9U4S540U suq COJJGCS4AG psL94uJ1J 9S1J6UJ61U2 J42 062 1104 1116911 44194 4416

q6241.62 0L 1111401442W suq 6WbJOX6L obbo2444ou 41140 9 4622 14046114 911(4 C0U4L01159440U94 UJ06 40L

611Cj06I10I12 OIT4COWG 04 flh1401J41J b22m2--9 0A6UJUJ6U4 11169112 40L CJJ91J1J6JJ41J MOLJ(6L

M92 4622 911 GX06110I12 CJ191J6 411 L64W6 44194 C91126(4 441611114011 2bflL5 suq UJOL6 911

O4 MOLJ(6L2\JOCSJ 11*110112 Ui s pouow-nb 0L91J411J G40W bLOW 41142 b6L2bGC44AG 4416 /J91J6L

6XbJ91J9440U 04 4416 DGbLG22!011-GLS 2b1114 41194 bJ9C62 I.G946L M64JJ5 0115416 4IIqGbGuqGIJs 9C54A44462

D959 L6J9441J 50 944 SJILGG 04 541626 46242 LG1GCS 4416 sob-qoMu }1Th04116242 411 49A0L 04 911

p) 4116 M6M 4)6944419115416 (4(J) Monjq 941J 46M6L U36U1p612 411911 4416 ClO 11114011W

4416 y}J' (UJT0I12 MJI4CJJ JSCJ(6q 5416 q?U19U34c 469q6L2p4b o f'GM42 0*1(4 M4I4CJJ MGLG 4622 49A0L6q

11GM 111140112 4114416 ClO oJq JJSAG LGJJ6(4 011 CGU4LSJ (T11q2 OL 0LS1J4411 9224249UC6 911(444194

mfl0I14944011 011C6 4416 p61164442 O 4416 2GCLG4 4)94404 bwc622 M92 62s9pj42p6q 54195 4416 P11W 04 4416

C0U.6C4 MOJlJq 6xb6c4: 44194 LGC01J444O11 2SLfl(62 thonjq 1104 C0114411116 404)6 9 WS0L woqc o

GXS6IJ4 40 MJI4CJJ 4416 ojq yrkJ 111140112 LG2boUqGq 504416 11GM 241119440W J 5116 sob-qofM1 9119J?i242 42

2nbbJous: 4416 65611450 MJJ4CJJ 4416 11GM ClO mJJOIJ2 M6LG 411 4SC4 94(46(4 p) 4416 46qGLS44O11 ouq 4416

4pLuJ6q 4JIL0ITJJ 44J'J 6j6C510112 AGL2II2 4416 L6C01I4540U 241.flC62 5416 J642JS540U /A92 q624u6q 40

JJ9AG 6X9U1fl16q 5411.66 92b6C52 04 4416 ff1140IJ4954011 q14A6 04 5416 b6LJoq 4416 6X56114 40 114J4CJ1 111140112

jO 922622 4416 sob-qoitu suq p0440w-nb 4U46thL6494!0112 04 4416 b224o11-6.s 2bm4 i

Page 22: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

noitiiiooi d 2tS tsw scli i!uoiiIt bits OEQt 31tt ni b9s.irtsIo w i9*Iow lo 19dmUft Lui

anoito15 gninthgisd Xoubnoo ot biEoa iodaJ iti b19b1o fl9v52oo$I n9dw Et nI .Ahi

9d rsdr awod2 ô 1dsT .ihow OOOOOV vo niv1ovth Ihi2 noirinoi w ol3rb

hn$wnwob nibiwir 1a1L itU2fl3 ni b9Ftsv sAht2 noitinooi ni b3v!ovni 21*iow lo ,dmnn

1lir rud beIq9oos 13nisith 9mozd wboooiq X3A no!rs15$L ,odsj thnoirsT4 DIii L

iA insW cft b9is1ob tiuoD 3rn91qu 9ift nøifw VEQI as srsl as dgiif niniEmt

rnshoqmi its oaI iw a9tht noiiinoo5I isdr rosi 5di i gnithcpua ioM .Isnoiiufiranoo

b9thn1o w aishow 9lom ,11s19v0 bits NI ,DQf iii rihinsio to boc{i9rn

HSLWI r1uo-idi b&inso w nsdi liuqa QI-4QI 3Itt th a1hra noirinoo duoidi

irff .

anoito19 $IJT4 Liv noillim 0. .1 av a9Ahta noirinooi duoiitt noillim 8. t : anoiio19

19ñ5 noirsinsio noifw Io aaeoolq io 5wisn 311j bnscfo vsif sm hA 9(11 lsiIl a9U2

2i slsb c1i lo noitslsrlcp3tni 3tsmi1i3! A .bkto wdrrwn 1auos d1 bnsrb Ii asifi iom

B bisio 9v5d bluow is(1i 291h12 noi1inoo91 ioI b9rutiIadu2 1sis1 wbomq no110519 &ifi 15111

mis1 3111 aso 311i ai aith II .'sw tsnoirsrnoiInoo 3iom s th meinoiiui b thwoi 9Idsisqmoo

.b&nsdns ai n9vhb nwob-qor nsifi i&ilrsi n9vhb qu moflod asw tIuq2 b9asd-noiaa1q9U 91(1 lsifl

its lo 33(132dB ifi th QEQI If3uolIfi binoinu '1liñaaooua 9vs11 tif3im ahow nsm woH

r1uoiii1 beinsio rosi ni oifw isdmun 311t 3d bluow 9tSmi129 Isrninim A iub9ooIq 110113913

lo EE 21 29)11-112 noijinoo51 duoicfi bins,o aihow noillim 8.1 3111 :a9Arfla noirmnooi

nsM .A 91d51 xibn3qqA th brioqi noillirn lo qirlai3dmem noimj th ifiwo QE-EQ1 &ft

io 29*112 l9rttis in9ads 9am qirfa13dm9m tsdl 02 &fIOlflU fl112ix3 bethol 8211103 1o 1213)hOW

1s-wi1uons-non lo i1iwoi 91(1 or 3rsnoli-Ioqolq 1qmia asw ifiwo aiifl II .2110113919 81$LJM

I .artoaiq 00000Q 10 1QEQI oi EQ1 moiI 81 d n9ah 8vBIf bluow qhfai3dm3m 1n9mo1qm3

0

Page 23: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

1Q1 of VEQI rff mo-il anoinu bsniol svsd bhiow anoq nsm won fzibsiq of vd ton 111w

asw boh9q -131151 silt ni cltwoi sift fsrlf ston '1qmia tud 113A insW sift fnsads borisq

.noifB1i3s1 lss(1 w*I oniffiw ,I isW bhoW iii lsdll of slds'isqmoo

OlD lo iloum woH .anoirw OlD lo ifiwol3 9111 no snsbivs sift fxsn isbianoD

bits anoimi auomonolus bits ihow lo asifivitos rft moil (191s1 bstluasi diwm3 qiilaisdmsm

cs3itiaas OlD Isilnso nwob-qot mo-ft Ik)um worl

ni 515W aO1.QI bits aOEI sift iii asvhb gniirtsio fnsrioqmi taom sift lo owT

saorfw rinfl fitsitimob is1 £ dhiw aiofosa bsi1oqogi1o '(lifi1f iffod 1Issfa bits aslidomofus

sill nio1qms aishow 9lidomofus sifT .iofzsa silt iii aasooua bssfnwisu '(Ilsuliiv noifssinoimi

svthods woismirn isñs noitsins-io iisilf fqsos of iotoM lirisitsi) bsnol lhfa itwob-tia

all iol asinorn OlD no '(lsviansfth 1sri ion bib (WAU) ais*toW ofuA bsfinU sift fuH .aliolls

silt lo iotaiif silT .anoifsIsqo all iol qiifaisbssl OlD isilfo io aiwsJ no ion aasooua niins3io

J1A sift id ai-io11s bs1nud lls-isnsg of fosjdua sthnsgio of nhif aisthow lo iofa £ ai noimi

.qicla-isbssl OlD sill d 1tasbom 1no bsbis bits qirlaisbssl sbivoiq of

bits qu isa OlD sift Jssf a nil .fns-isThb stiup asw a-is*iowlssf a sill lo noifssins3lo sill'

a-is*iow sniM bsfirtU sill bits .(DOW) ssnimmoD nixiitsgiO is)how1sst sill bsbmft

I aill atnoinU aishow1ssf sill srwM qi1i1f as llsw as 'snom bits aisslnsaio bsbivotq

anoimi itsqmo sift lo 1-Ioqqua sift niitis d sms 1svswoil 41woi sill lo ilouM .ln9biasiq

Ii aslsm iloiriw anoicw fnsbnsqsbth mo-ft asvlsamsdt isThid of qu isa bsd amiil Issfa sill isift

fssi sill 1lif .IIsw as svhb audi of 15f3s1s113 qu-moflod instioqmi its asw sisdi fsiliiBsI3

1ssl 2.U sill lo bs&f sill bits aiwsj nsswfscf anoifsilosn silt 1111w Sf1153 DOW2 sill lo aasooua

Page 24: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

tuoitiiw nsqmoo 191s1 9th binsio tsth thtsm ioob bo1o s--,o1'sT noiM 1noitioqoD

.I9bom nwob-qot 9th 2iiI tsth noirw s to 9Iqmsx9 mriq 9th 9IS how1t2 edT .ethi2 £

-moflod WAU edt wollol anoiiw OlD iii iehow Io toitssinsio eth bib tnetxe tsclw oT

noiteup ic1t iewns ot 'sw enO cniettsq nwob-qot 219*10w199t2 edt ot beoqqo .s iriettsq qu

edt tsth iuoei gniinsgio bits lsionsnfl edt ot gniblo3os noiiw OlD ethoetso ot i noiiur eoift ni qirfdmem lo dtwoi io qithiedmem 9th tasiinoo ot bits fiteth evEs noitwiebel

ot evs OlD edt 'nom lo tiwoms edt no stsb tn9e1q V eldsT .boheq emit tnsvelei edt

.Vt ni noinu cbse lo iedmem ieq isllob eift evi bits ,lFQt ot moil noinu uohsv

10 ews9m tnstioqmi its i ti Mo119 OLD 1 iotsoibni e1o edt ton i tioqqu Isi3nsniI eliriW

work eldsi 911T .anisqmE3 ithinsio isluoirisq th asw noitib1 Lsitneo 9th bevlovni woif

.iedmem ieq nevi tnuoms 9th ni bits nevia ienom lo tnuoms enhIo2ds 9th ni noitsFisv ebiw

fvits1i bevieoe-i WAU edt 1eet bcis otus iii noitsinoinu lo viotthi edt dtiw tnetinoD

th qir1iedmem 4.QI 9th tsitnoo 8 elcisT .tol s benistdo te*iow1eet 9th e!Mw 'enom elflil

I .Vt iii l9dm9m 19q 119Vi rloqqu2 OLD lo tiwoms edt ot n1b1o33s 2JIOIffU OlD jiohsv edt

edt lo Itnebneqebni besirtsio isdmern VEQI eq OO.& nsth ae1 3nivieoel nonu 9th tseit

elidw ;Ot) edt no tnebneqsb nied s -iedmem isq OO2 nsdt eiomnivieosi eoth ;OID

A .quoi etsiberinetni its itt nted zs 3no3ets3 L OO. bits OO. newted anivieo5l nonu

bits otuA edt iii beton s 1iisd duoi i iot&ibth 31ni2 s no besd eq't ith lo noits3i1k.sI3

edT .2noirw -isluoitisq lo 29not1r1 edt thiw tn9t2inO3 (11s1en9 2i flOit53fli2513 fit 32&) Ie9ia

rliwoia bits noitstinol eoc1w noinu d betsnimob IQU asw OLD 9th IQI iii tsth i hsl ith1ht

eoiwt nsdt eiom eis e-iedT .tloqqu2 nisinsio bits lsi3nsnhI OLD no 1tse'i bebneq9b ton bad

th nsth i-Ioqqu2 Isi3nsnil OlD elttil 1evits1ei bevieo tath 2noicw edt ni 19dm9m fl5m 25

Page 25: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

MGLG 9J2O 9JA91flSG pA MOI.JCGL qG2p.62 to ffl11UG 111 L62b01126 to tJJG bw!ou couqou

LtJJGL tpu pA tp obbowwt!G2 CI.G9tGq pA tp6 fi9UGL Yct GJGCt011 bwcGqm.6 bGL 26 tJJGA

to jpt OL uJ6wpGI2pb pA UA9J do nIou2 /1410 tJJLGStGU6 W6!L 1m42q!ctuou

F9P01.2 t1JOIT11 wGwp6L2pb L6M J OtIJGL 111110112 92 M6JJ J40 20W6 GxtGue vr}J' 1UJOU2 M6LG

FGM!2 bnuccq /141611 G dnt 1116 VhF to ow t}J6 dIO) 1116 J9!1MSA d16L1( 9uq tJic flnJqw

G1JGLSJ tL9IJ2bOLI MOLJ(G12 nU!OIJ 1116 dSI.b61Jt612 (/111026 PG 9111 H11tCPG2OU M92 JJG UJ9TJ

bwqnctou J6 169uJ2t612b iiqicp qGIiGjObGq LGOU9j COU4GLGIJCG2 to CL69tG 9 wnJt-pJqn2tLA

comJtLA(Q916u2ou JOQO b jjy 111 b914 to cowbGtG '14tIJ 11JG flVIA J 91.692 j11(6 91Lbj9U6

MIJ!C11 tL9U20UJJG !42Gj p1tO O1J6 O 1116 LG9t 111922 bwqnctiou mJou2 p1

b€uoq: tp IIpTC}1 jrnq obbo2Gq p1q112t1491 mioiiw rn iut6urnj VH qGp9tc2' pnt

5' UJIJJTOIJ OL tJJG dIO (266 J9P1G y 26A6L91 VhF 111110112 UJ96 bn.JcnJ9qA J9LG 9W2 111 iJJG

BGtMGGU jo uq rots tp yjj' 9pJGq wTII!ou wGuJp6I2 cowbi.q p14W 9 91U o,

ffp.69qA j9L6)

}rnAwuo w6wp6L2 b4oL to j3 (91tponJJ 20W6 1om1qpJ oL9U9t!O172 J1JC6 tJ16 flJGI2 MGLG

w6wp6L2pb p1 II/hF (11110112 GXCGGqGq tIJG LO//4JJ W mJ1u GAGIJ i MG COI1Ut tG dIO92

L62b01126 to tji€ 11GM COwbGtpJ 6GL9tO11 (QffJGu2ou JoQO) 11GG1 4G 9P20111t6 L0MtJJ O

cio U1J!OU2 pm 1n91O1. COwbouGut O (1UO11 Gxb911210u 111 t6 bGLOq M92 pG

JJJG w02t LSUJ9PC JJ1240U62 O 4J1G D6bL622!0u2b1114 OCfl2 011 t}16 LO/14p 0 tPG 11GM

F6M!2 to CLG9tG 4LOflJG2 JOL t6 VhF CLSt m11ou2)

211CC622 (9uq MGLG wotA9tcq 1622 pA tPG qG2LG O MOL1(6L2 to Op1 dIO 111110112 tJJ9lJ pA OJJ1J F

woucA to 2OWG oinxiu quAG2 2rrcp oz cou2tulct!ou MOL1(6L tpt jJ9Cj LGI9t!AGJA IWIG

W026 4P4 LGCGIAGq cOu2qGL9pj6 2(TbbOW 0116 1.692011 OI. 11112 12 t}19t tPG dO 9A6 COu2qGL9pJ6

Page 26: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

3,t

19L6JA 017 9G4!A!4!62 0 JOCSJ mJ01q242

111! wouobojA 0 2JqjJGq CL912 /i0LJCG12 111 bsi.cnjst !°J!4!' MJJGLG 0L9IJS4i0U q€b€uq€q

y11402' gnppGL JJJG I.694 211CC622 0 4116 VEF C0I4LtIC4!0U mJ!0112 1" 4116 J946 Jô302 L.66C46q

JAGLG U CjJ124L!G2 qouJpJS4Gq pA Gil !9LG GUJbJOAGI2' 044611 J0C546q U S 21JJ6 97.69: 24!'

GX46U 411611. 0L9U95!0U 40 4J16 2011411 N°24 0 46 211CC62211J 1JG1i co 11W0172' pA COIULS24'

q iroin qq IIIG 2911161114116 1119101. sbbsi.€j bwqncu s1.€s2 u 4J16 J,4014J1' 1T4 ui 4°

W91J119CW1.612 6q6L9410u siiq GGC41A6JA pcJb!1J 4116W 40 ojobojc 4G wq11241.A vcn.

Sw6wGU42 jpc jj Sccowbfl2pcq 'J b514 4p1onJJ SL91UU iiqqJ 4116 pjnwuon2 cosj

LW2 46 1411W 9A€ 4}JGW S I)SLqCITJSL 1112414115101791 261J 4JJL011JJ lI41TCp40 qcAGJob €qoi.s

51194 U-'"2 W95 2!U1 "1W 4J16 11111017 R6L6 1104 UA61J 0115 0 1T211JG22 pA 1J0IJJT0U COWbG4!4012

cj41csjjX 071 6259pJ2jJpJ 207176 J0LW 0 01. 94 J6924 L€!0I1SJ MS6 bsu€ur 20

flh14C 249462' JJSq 2rqGLGq UJ922!AG J02262 0 UJCUJp€12J41b 1116 211CC622 0 GSCJJ 0 41762€ 111710172

ios 40 Jô33 I bgi.pcnjsv 5p flJj' SJJ€U 5116 J9LG25 GXGUJbjSL 0 uqn2449j 1175101112W 1114116

b640q2 o LG94 i.oiip ojjoEi6q pA coJJSb2G2 4JJLOflJJOfl4 w6!L iJ!24o462 EWW

QU4 fiOLJ(612 flIJ!OIJ (IFGlifl) VII 5171.66 J!0U2 obGLS4Gq COWbG4!4!A6 n1q1125462 VI! psq

//0L1(G12 (flNll)' 4176 VJWSIJJ5(1 C!°41JW IAO4(6L2 (vcfiY 91Jq wG pJ4GLuSsiOuSJ r'q

J0026A6J4 q1JJpJ24L95!011,2 4flT 40 1TJ 01. LGpnflq 41'! uJ6uJp6r2pb p926: w nu46q LAUIJG

0ujA 4171.66 yjj' (J946L uo) 117510172 6xb046q 5116 Obbo14mJ15A !L24 .csscq pA 4176

obbowA CLGSscq WOL6 pA M0LJ(6L q62L62 sjisii pA 0A6UJ11J6IJ5 I6!2J95101Y

1116 bLOpJ6UJ 0L 4116 f[,[' 111110112 M92 40 65 511611. 4 51J 6SL, 40 491(6 SA91J4S6 0 S UJSI4(G5

Page 27: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

-iom i fi noi831q9U i5910 9th 111 mthioiiw lo fn9rnqolsv3b 9th bitsaisbnu of mu ni

nszb fssi lo bohsq s iii nifsiqo 3anoq9I itwob-mottod Jon93obn9 ItS lo Aniulf of hñw

.9vhb noifssinoirw b81 nwob-qof oifi1sa91 £ 1o nsth minoinu iol iib how iti

arbU boh9q ninflU A soQ iiulW :t1oiuI3I1o3

fi213q fsth 29mo3fuo itisfl9o th-bo! fum fi ttnir1i13b' 3d of fit9v9 ishioirisq £ io'I

niifiomo b5qol3v9b 9v51f bhioo f9i3o2 3df 9fsI2 Insld £ n9vi 1neifw bohsq 5lutul mo ofth

1f fsth b9v9iI3d OôQI bits O?.Qt ni nithw .tIsns iocIsl bits itshofaiH .fn5I9IIib I3V

91dsf bits !sifnsfdu £ th3uboiq afn3vo rbu w fA 13nsW 9th bits J-wqa-noi1q9U

bA -iensW edt nimeN of nib-iox)A .efsf 2 befinU edt iol rnet gninisisd vii1Io

iodsl fnebneqebth bits eis! £10 rlbwmg eift of 1uormone befudiifnoo Idsn0if9upitLr

Irlebom £ 1o tlsq e!ds-li2eb £ .s fnernevom fsrff 1o eoitsfqeos edt of bits iitemevom

loof iotthf iodsl itsoiiemA tsrfi sfoiw niefirieH (Q14 .q S1 nime1'1) "t9i3o itsoriemA

edt bet2zifnoo nET 4QI nI .(xi .q II) !seU w'1 edt 1o nimoo edt dtiw Irwt IuI:tneve its

fi tEch gitifon "OEQf hse edt ni bfix fsctt en(f edt dtiw sbof 1o fnernevom iodsl

1Is3iiiIoq Jse! 2fi efs-ieqo fi d3idw noqu 1ve1 edt bits ,tsei s emif xi2 fuods eis iecfmun

(8O .q 1t.ôQf) ttbebnsqxs (1fseI3 need sd eifivifos ifoiseaori bits

edt bits fianeb noinu no rinqa II isW bhoW bits noi2eiqeQ dt lo belle erff QI nI

of beqqo-ib sd fianeb noinu iobe-efsvhq .fneiellib efiup tseqqs meta artoifsfei iodsl 2.U

-rtoi2i3eb Isnoifsn lo 1-isq £ anointi ebstn fsdt bioooz !siooa edT .aOOQI-bim edt lo 1v1 91ff

tteei1-noinu edt 1eea a1eo!qme lo iedmun niase-ioth ciA .itwob neloicf asif nbtsm

Page 28: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

flUjOU2 0j 2flb6LA2O12 bw2ou9J2 UOL UJ91J9GL2 bLOW 4116 GWbjO?GL 2q6 5jJ6 VCS 11191(62 5

1iO4jJ1IJ C}JOICG 411944116 fi911GL C5 O4GL2 fIG j9pOL L6j9jOU2 COqG bt.oAqc2 110 bj9CG OL

cowb9u? flIJiOU2--4jJ94 2OWG 0 411626 !AOLJ(6L2 W9? bL66L 404116 259Lj( COjJ6C5A6 OL

jOL 1Js6LuJ6q946 0L91194j0U2--259 922OC94101J2 M0Lj(2 cO1T11CjJ2 OL WOLG b6)OL9PA6j?

qowus occnb94!ou2 46 ycs' N45}J 112 1915-H914JG? 1JJ61JqUJ6U12' jSJ2 so bweqqG 9uA bJ966

2flbGL/426 04jJ6L2 MJJGLG /AJJ!56-COH9L W91J96Lj9J uq bt.o622ousj O2 MOnJq COU2S!41146 4116

6UA29jU 9 thoLjq jU //pcp nb//Lq2 oj 3 bGLcGIIS O; IJ0U-UJ91196LjSj ftOLj(GL2 thonjq

IImiJp6L 0 1TIJ9L bL9C4CG2 cowWu6q p? GWbjO?6L2 b6L 6j66410u J192 42611 2119Lb1X 46A6L

4}194 4116 VCS 9A6 50 MOLJ(612 /1410 /19IJ5 40 rW!O1JSG }19A6 q6 jSGSO p6611 GjWU946q 92 4116

0L9UGL2 955JG 601.G 4116 L4r'BB 9uq COITL52 92 1)91.5 O 4116 6j6641011 bI.oc622 fiG bLoSGcS!ou2

UTUIGq 4116 bL0C622 O (Wj0Uj94OU 1U0 S j69J241C p112jU622' 111 //41CjJ UUJJ2 suq mou

/!92 111 4}JG j/c bw221ou ?6912 bqoL 40 42 6119C41JJ6114 bLOW 4116 IW!OU 2q6 4116 /A9U6L VCS

99111--JJ92 9416 41161)101)0141011 0j U0U94C(TJUTL9T !/oL1(G12 UI 111410112 2 pGjOM MS4 11

9 L9UJGtAOLJ( W95 2 9Lrwpj? 0fl5WOG(f 0116 WS1OL bm.bo2G 0 4116 VC5--50 6UCOS6 COJJ6CSIA6

L6j941ou2: s 1194101191 j9OL COqG' S2G 011 4G fi91JGL VCS 92 suiciiqq ju GU2fl!1J ?69L2 JJJ!2 12

LGUJSJ2 4041412 qs? 2 411611941011,2 j69j jLSUJ6ROL1( 0L couqncsp b9ASSG 2GC5OL jSpOL

JJJ2 (j062 1104' IJOMGA6L' W69U 41194 4116 bGLjOq qq1104 j69A6 S 1924!11 j69CX J/J194

110U64j16j622--ISSJIGL 4119119 CLjS!CSJ WU411J bOIIS 111 JSPOL Ij95011

9 qIACL2IOU LOW yIJJG4CVIJ 1GXCGb41OUSj!2W,,--9 j011 suq jUIbOLI9US qAGL20u' p114 9 qycou

2661(250 0L9I41G fIG DCbLG22!OI1 9uq fiOLj p/9L fl LOR4 0 JT0I412W 411112 J001(2 WOLG j11(6

621)011264116 m410u-L66 !1oLjq 9C4 W94 !2 /14195 4j16X 5L11J? /E91J5 /I4JGU 5jJ6L OMU MOLJ( 0LC6

GU/4LOIJUJGU4 4jI94 ouj? LG4L0L9CjG LjjI4-t!411 q6oJo1T62 01166 2O11j15 Aj9U? 411.1112 W4 qo uos

Page 29: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

3tsrrIitisI mo ovi td3im i&fr anoiisthimio i*tow 1-ioqqim bits qu o rrn11 ioI 1911i

noinu rn3bn9q9bth its lo tioii 9051q)how 1i91t1 1s nohsinsio smo tnsw oitw i*iow oi oiov

851JkI iir 1rnsrioqmi tom 2qsfh9 (noiiw nsqmoo 9Iit) virolloo anisisc1 ifoiriw

bits rn3m9snsm ns9vfl3d noiisinoiInoo 9dr b&ub91 ron asd srwb900lq nonsiqi H .l3ifions or 3ni1t eno moil ii b3frrlolans,i 1qmi2 asd rud 1noirsinoinu ivo 8o1qm3

roA -19nsW 9dr tsifw b9ouboq sd noi1s151 iodsl iob oilduq lo noitsh,i 3rsr 1rsirnoo ! ibum c(iiw 'rnonoo sift lo rtsq rsrlt ni m9ta ninigisd svitoI1oo 9!dsa s--ron Psi!

idi ts is ioto 3isvhq bits 3ilduq r1r th 2w51 31!i A .2aoo1q rthinsio 511r iti noiisinoilnoo

m 3onert9Ilth 9dr i on91&11ib HuI iol nOasi 91f1 rsc(r b3u1s 9vsrf I ishimx2 '1dsno2.s31 nithw

3iIduq lo nsrlt noirs.insgio oqqo or isnsm iot 9rsvhq 10 9nniI1iw bits 3virn3on &ih

.rflo-iq 3rffloqlo3 lo anoas tol !dsfrwatq at9gsnsm toh tods! b9bornruo its otth 29rsr b9rinU 91h bo*o1 asd ,nsW &ir rsdi wiv M

9Iir orni vom (Irnuo3 as siriIst t9)hsm tods! ff1 ton ob tsdt *iowomst1 anoits!t

t3A tnsW 3dr isdi t3itO3 1tqxs iodsl 'nsM .8n0 bts1oai its ton i -wno ra1fl-rn9wr

lo oi1bq silt tuods ss-igsib nsfio 'sdt ifuocft monoos 2.U sift ifl tsno1 on jhowsmst1

bits tnem9asnsm 1todsi 'd nsvi wsiv gnhsIlib sift th nss sd itso as rrno1st wsl todsi

tn9rn9snsM-ts)hoW lo stuu1 sift no noiimmoD 1QI\Et sift stolsd ts1oif32 rnsbnsqsbni

bits qiiftsdmsrn noinu arrrtfl ts*iow edT .DQQt todsJ lo tnsm:hsqeU 2 .U) anoitnls$I

sift or atnsmbnsms 1steve stiqaeb rita .OEI edt soni 1isst benscf svrnf monoos

Isnoitutitzni its nits9t3 bsgnsib ion asil wsl sift 1o e-wi3int2 3iasd sift ioA tensW

nsvotq asd isrit sno tud noinu ton crni1 ats*iow 2.U tsdtisn qIsd isdt rsbsirdistt

tIlt 111w wsl sift iii i1irl ns isift insrngsitsm bits todsl 10 tss1 sift nsvi snsib 01 tiuoiThb

Page 30: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

D6b62!0U 2bnLI 2flLbq2Gq B9UJGU vuq O56L Op26LA612 J W6 b€qcxj

2nqqGuJX &op9pj? 2nth42W WG cnu.ciu ci.ob o GxbGLI2 9uq j9OL 2O49U2 92 lJJflCp 92 ipG

L62nLGucG O mJOU q6u2A VIJOWGL J22OU 12 W5 9UA 2fTCp L62TLGUC6 O flIJOU2W /Mfl COUJG

GWbJO)66 qqiu pm. o nuou ciyA L9WGL p9u bu!cnj J9/i2 i.€ u6c6229LA OL 9u?

0j nU1OIJT2W 1" W6 fluG 962 1116 J6220U I.OW W6 DGbL622!OU 6Xb646Uc6 12 jis pououi-nb

6912 w bwp9pJ) JJ-bJsccq M° bjvnpJG jSpOL jM L6OLW 12 J11J 40 uqnc 9 pni.

4J16 9J9UG O bOMGL 99UJ24 4p6L 2qG flJ6 j62201J J qI.9M L0W 4}J6 D6&622!OU-2bm4 12 41194

Page 31: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

A0LJC: 1A[CWTJJ9U Tô18

OP1J yuqLGM 9IJj GJ b64W11 }{IOLA O OITL U fIG flU1Gq I.4COUJUJOIJ IOPIJ K' D'4 I 2° HGIGU F 2IJU' E11 UGTW9J' HE 0J9Uq'

WAVIJOJ1C}J'

Brnu' 9uJG2 Ci.Got J'oOGAGj1: w r!ou g fIG Eox Aoq(: LCO BLCG

jpwou: Bm.G oj w!ousJ y1Js1t2' j3

B(TGS1T 0j L4!OIJSJ V!2' D GCOL) O fl '9JOL pI2LTWPO1J TS-83 EqUOU

flflLGfl O 145JOU9T V1!t2' JÔÔ2

Hm.G9n oj 4OUVJ yiL flIJOU GwpGL2pTb ug EUIiJ D Bo°I j JJJmJou:

-. JJJG JJTLp1TJGII AI2 W611 JOLJ( Houou-y!!ww TJ•

J ô20•

BGLIJGTU' ILAflJ JJIG L4GM DG1 C01JCf B ffWUJt bO!TCA flmiI2iA o t.€'

J33

CWCUUf' OJJ!°' DGCGWPGL 5 J3)' VUJG4C1J EGOIJOUJ!C OCOU bI29ug

B9UJGU' GGOLG Hoiq' b!q'uJ qq1.G22 O fIG fI IJ1JIT91 GGf1J O fIG VEV'

1ô80

BW' uq K°P6 bucG j,LoJG o fluou pLoHrjr ujuq: B!! J9cJc/t6fl'

OflUJffJ Ocououic 83(3) (vnf12 [Q): '43t-1W

V2JJGIJGJ1GL' ØLjG) uq 1OPU if bGUCGF UJGI.!CSU JLsqG flIJOU QLO!!4' TôOO-JÔQO'

qGLGIJGG

Page 32: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

30

hLG Tô0

GTG0U' JjUJ4GU JJJG jp CJJIJGIJG o ip yjj' 9p4q) v: H'.'q nAG!A

5'c (yi.cp j): bbj-E.6GuJ9W jçcjrnq B fl1!0U! C°" 0 JJG bUflC 2GC10L 0I1UJJ 01; ECOUOUJTC

flIJJAGL2i 01; j49229C}Jfl2GU2 UJJUJGOb OC0PGL J

4GqW9IJ QGL MG/A F4TUJG2 01; flIJTOU GUJpGL2pb WG flUGq J0-JôT'f

uqjb Et.9u1c WG MG/A J)GJ joiou: F!ffJG-BW/AU 3

JomJ poL ug WG MG/A DGSJ (nuTAGI2! 01; Jj2couir qoif Iô2.)•

JJGUJ oppcu /JLU (JJJG 01; 11J6 J9IJGL VC W DGLPGL jjOU U1 qMJ1J

J2C0U211J' Tô2V

p) yjou DGLPGL suq q/A jomJ tqi2oIf Jcou2w: flWAGI2! 01;

qGJw9u' ITL& JII6 DJ 2GU4IA!A 0 rPOL PUGLG22') U p0L IJg JG MG/A jj

19cuJ!Jjsu' JôI8 1Q3-TÔT

JJU2 iu0 p0L jnc qicq p) cjrnq ' ['G2GL 9uq o2Gbp 2jJT2GL Mc/1

DIWJ0b 0JJIJ j jpG DGAGjobWGU4 01; r'p° o1ou: V JJJG0LG4CJ EL9UJG/A04C W

01; lii!2C01111 J,LG22

D6LPGL P4fl0U suq E/AW J0mJ JpOL ug IIJG MG/A D6! yiqoir fii2c0u2!1J: flWAG2!A

(vnfl24 bb jj-3DA! Hoc B JJJG JJJG0Q 01; flIJIOU GL0!A11J OA1L1GLJ? 0JTUJffJ 01; ECOUOW!C

flUIGq 4U162 O0AGU1WG &4U4W OWGG TÔCOmJCU 01; ECOU0W!C yqAa0L2 EGOUOUJTC KGIOI4 01; WG bL6gGIu TÔÔQ ,piuoIr DC:

Page 33: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

3J

DG JôJ

cpIJGIq6L crn6I y B4 -flOIX O QGLUJ1J JLqG fl1JOU BO1ThJ QGurn1u): yJ-IJj

2CIJ1G2UJGL VLLPJTL JJJG coum o 46M jj flo2ou: nonuou jiiJrn

ji.o) -o uq yj 2PGJW f1uou om.ccpooj fi ØU1UG w: II�DI2 io

JÔQ

JLSG flWOU GwpGI2pb J-JôQ5 J,46Ri AO4C MBEI� 9IJq COj(TWp flWAGI2!A

W ØL91JTh6 fpOI. 1J 1JJG4CSIJ }{!aOL) WGR Aoqc: Hd6L uq KOli JÔ4

JÔÔ1 b4 OECD JT

OECD (OLSIfliOIJ OL ECOUOUJ!C C°°-!°' uq DGAGJObUJGUi) EuJbjowGIu o1Ji v'J

flWAGI2IIX 01 C}JCO b'2 JÔ20

LsIJ!!21 HU1 y "i EWUX CISM( BLOMW EWW IJJG RIJGL ycj 19-H9'1JG CP!CO if':

1�06' J3

rGnC}JGIIPGL IJHJ!UJ E"1IP D 6hGJ ug G 4GH DG1 MGM jo4C: HSIJL suq

I ô8)

KJ91.G 9LJ pTqJCWJ DG CJ!OU O WG JJIJ6L 1J1JGO r'" JG!4G!A (}SJJ

CP!CO TÔ&

ooIqj6!qb yJ. LIJG GCJJG O pLb1JXGq OL ni ji uq cpic9o: flU AGL2 O

GA!GEi (Gb1GwpGL T8.Y

ojqjq fOL2 OLUOU O W J.4' D!: bS14 fl yUJG4cu b0W!cI 2C!GIJGG

HU! flU AGL2IA unsQ j

pcjr jopw jpc 1wb9c1 01; IIJG Jj1JGL VC1OJ jL9G flUOU QL0M4jJ EcOIJOUJTG2 J2O'

Page 34: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

33

J6j4I0IJ2 jJ4OU DC: fl1JGq WG2 QOAGLIJUJGIU b'11UW O1;U DGCGWPGL

-. JGboL1 ug GcouJuJGugou: coww!!ou oIJ ,njm.c 01; oLL-uGwGul

OW Jj9? Tô'V

fi04GL-1JUGUJG1U JS5J0IJ pmoir DC: flIJ6 QOAGUThMGIJI b4"WJ

rnq D€bwc1U 01; ['spoL E9C uqpi boi.i: cowwou ou ip hlUm.G o

QOAGUJUJGIU bLWW Ø1;Jc6' 1Ô80

9ug EuJb!o OCS!OU TÔÔ. B"J1W SO 21JOU DC: flUUG

rnq bsiwGu4 o r'po.' w1i.GsT 01; r'p° D' 01; 4ouj flIrou

TÔ RITJJGU roo W0U DC: flUUG 49G G0AGUJUJGIU i'-'uw ow

fl161 DGbI4W6IJI O1; FP° 01; 0L 21C HugpooJ 01; p0L C2

girnuL ZflG Jj9z}mJoIf DC: flUUG 21G2 QOA6UflJJGU L1Ji!J Ø1;1;I JQ-

flUGq 2W DGbSLWJGIU 01; r'9POL B"" 01; r'P0L 2!!C EuJbjo?mGu ug unuR

QOAGUJUJGU4 bLUUW OW T

Toso-To: iJcsj jpJ6 U50U DC: nuuq 2l

uq l9G2 j€bi.iwcui 01; C0WWG JJJG 4j0U JIJGOUJ 9Ug L0flC4 yccomu 01; 1J1G

DC: flIJUG HG2 GOAGUJUJGIU bL!IU!1J OUJCG TQQ

fluUG 2WG2 flflI9I1 01; IVG CGII12 f0U-4GUJJ EGOUOWTC ULO/!W TQO-TôQ JV2}JW0IJ

° TV P!"°" DC: nmcq 219G2 QOAGLIJUJGIU BLIU!LJ OW JÔQO

fluicq WiG flflIIT 01; JJG J{?404C9J 01; 1JInuq 1B C°J°"!1 J)J

Page 35: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

33

-. LSG flIJJOU Gwp6upTbDPviAJL GJJG E1 ObGJ JG flUOIJ W E" 46jJGLjsuq: DGAGIUGV

JjAGU cuw mJq j3

jo?w2Jd j•e• suq wbjowui ug js w qi flIJG j,jcii oqc:

Page 36: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

om.cc: ybb€uqpc v w bbi.

C0CC)C

032

0)0)0)0)0)0)0)0)0)0)0) 0)0)0)0)0)0)0 'V 0 vU 10 0 vU 0 It) 0 It) 0 vU vU C It) 0 It) 0 rOI- I- 0) 0)Q) 03 - — (I C.l C C 4

flIThOU2 J88O-Tô2

E!1U6 j GI J,GLCGIJWG O 4OU-V14C111rnt1 fiO4CGI2 )jpo /I.G jGwpGI2 O

0

00Q

0•

I

03

04

Page 37: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

2fluq2 bits ths3nllno4 : wi'1

:A T$IA1

yfieneO noinU

(0510) aeo,uoae5I pniinspi0 (O) ae3luoae5l gniaoqqO bns

:a T$LA

sldsfe) (muhdiliupe

yfi2neO noinU

neriw fianeb wen) (*0510 of aeah 0510

(0510) eeoiuoee5I nixinsg1O (O) eeoiuoae5l niaoqqO bns

0 I6difli)

(yfianeb

qq

eIdsia) eldstanu) (muhdiliupe (mundiliupe

'U 0

Page 38: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

CJJ91JG W q6IJ2 W 416 U1 thrn.i Asi.

nJ WG )GI2 J!4161J Q1J2 iti uq iip6u q6u2A ir B' Um.62 si. jJ6 S 6ISG2 o 11J6

2bGcJGq ?6m2 1116 LS q6U! !U flJG UOIJ2bIU4 bcLoq2 51.6 jjJG SA6L5G SIJIJ!ISJ CJJ91J62

4oG2: jpc t.9G qcu2A u qic 2bm4 boq !2 !UJbI) WG 9AGL96 SIIIJflSj CJ1SIJ6 1I1 1116

om.cG: jspnjsq ow mJou q6u2 spac iii ybb€uqnc jpj6 v

VII 33 OR QT -08

T0-Jôô2 5Qt 19 5 OR 53 -0Q

Jô42-1ô.0 345 54 8 OR -0Jô42-Jô2 345 J4Ô TO OR 40 -0Q

1ô3ô-Jô45 52 52 1 J0 5 -18

JÔSJ-1ô34 112 Q 04 -1.5

1ôO4-IÔTQ TTÔ 09 -08

J88Q-I8ô 03 -131880-1883 58 3

oubm.VII 51 5.5

Tô451ô42 52 345 3 3•J

1ô34-1ô3ô 112 5Q 2 T5

JoJc?-1o5J ÔQ T9 2 1Q

18ôô-1ôOI 11Ô 2 14J883-Jô8 58 3

7 D6U2IO 7 D6U!OJUUWJ EWSI )65t2 VA6L56 * A' AGLS6

D6U2J QLGR D6U E6!!D6U1A A651.2 fip6U A65L2 )jjJGU

LLSPJG 1 CPSU62 U flUOU DGU2!A U 6I4O1j2 obriu uq 011161. 64Oq2 J88O-12

Page 39: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

:3-'

y4fl2!CISIJ2 118 54 So 51

JAJUJ1GIJIJCG O 1A 382 133 T'4

Cflfl2 308 135 05

FOUPOL6 55 131 83 1

PoLGL2 (Hoq CG(2) * -JWUROLJCGL2 JOOq 22

H0GI % KG2WnL9IU I3fl -3

GJ\b0UGL\bJ921!C 20 2 520 45

IFO/MI 342 SI

% 040 31 32

ObGLSTU EUW6G2 000

O EJCi4CJ JJOLJCGL2)

IBE/A (pJcLu9pouJ LO64JOO 5 13

flE (fl"iI E!GC14C91 ftOLJ(GL2)

cowwmJ!cou --

ClOt ULGX4IIG J5 88 4

C'-'U 21 55 TQS

J3ucJq9)GL2 IJ 41 0

BOIIGUJJ1CGL2 515 113 -12

VITIOWOP!IG -- * 21

180-TO04 1O1-JO5I 1034-1030 1045-1012

jpjc : cccuc QLoftqJ oj flUOU wp€i.p!b !'J jq flU!0U2 qmu 2bm.t

Page 40: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

fiOOqtAOLJCGL2

flI! JOLJCGL2

f1VIfA J3.0 SO -IQ

C0JGIJ Jo4(G12)

flECR (nul E°°'l iq J3SÔ 31

jLS1J2bOL t/OLJCGL2 -- -- 88

JL9*J (Lcc v'.IooL) 15 81

JGUJ2GI2 J4

MOLJC6I2

jJG6WJGWJ ftOLJCGI2 1518 'tO 52 52

2GLA!CG EUJbJO?GG2 -- * J83

WTPPGL *

JGJ suq fiJJoJc2vJc -- 11

j1i9X C!GP 2'4O 5Q8 '95

540 -Q '92 Q2

34 5ObGiW EIJW62 J82Q 20 QQ -5

Page 41: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

om.cG: jW?i uq PGU!U (J82Y ybbGuqpc B Lw)t (1oQ2)b LP! VI q y•

14mMP6L2 LGbOI4Gq LG OL JJG b€qoq I2ô-JO't

6I4mJJpGL2 LGbOLlGq 40L iJIG bc4oq iooo-o

qW111P6'2 LGbOLiGq 91.G 4OL JIG bG4Oq JØJ-Ø3

J4I1UJ6L2 LGboLGq 9L6 OL W6 bG4Oq JôOô-W

IMIIUJPGI2 LGboLGq 916 J0L IjJG bGLOqj-LGbOLGq G OL G GL!cXI Iô4O-

*flU!0U JAS2 UGBj) CLGSG q(u4u JJ UJ6 bcLOq

(mfl) OL 46 2SUJG 1WG b640q2 fitJJGIJ SJJSPJG I fl26 JLO) uq jJpu qw

qauu pG op€uou b6Loq JJIG J.Lo) suq 2PGU!U (1ô82) qwqi owGfi4J tLOUJ jo?

MoG2: WG9U2 4P91 W6 q mJ A91JSPjG fl2JTJJ) GC9fl2G 1JJ6 flUOU cq uO GX!2

CoUi!UflGq:

Page 42: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

40

TO0 4OiJAA U2G2 iP EISU sbu ps, epiab qp

J32\JOLJq fiL fl J/I22U OW4G2 VIT2U4

10502: €xccbou 9LG 1AcqcIJ vuq viJJ

JJo sqqousj UAG COmU4c2 sir: 9U9 IJc iP ccLjJq /M49uq

14oLMs) VJ!WG COU4G2 LG: fluiGq w1G2' flIJ4Gq ypi&jouf QGuJJ9U? liGGU DG4e

q6u2!A OL JJG C01Wi462 OAGL 4G LGJ6A1J1 b€40q

V1'H Uq 4G!A csuq jpG UJG9IJ c}J92IG 1U qGu2 2 pG JIAG}UG 9A6L9G CJJ9IJG U

rmwpn1 w°" 21Ic1r 'i'' nh'uI cqJ4o162: COW4G2 coAGI.Gq vn1I.! DG1JUJLr LL1JC6 QGUJJ9U JJ9Uq I1J bni

J0802\10002 JJ w qGu2A -Q J3 0j 18 IIJ

TO02 &.0114J1 th1V qAcI2A J3 O 18 1426

2TIP1JTA 0 15 O J' w0q621 CJJSIJ62

T002 -S 10 O J4 UJO621 Cp9IJG2

t/L II 2bfl14 o :io 426

10502 juqGu2A -o

JAoLJq JJSL I 2btfl4 W qGu2A o 5 1126

TOT 0-TQ 1P!J!A 0 Q U26 Q JJ

10002 1JCL692W ITU!OU q6IJ2A 0 O 426D61!A

1J Cp9L9C464SOUc3C41!0U CPg1J6 1116 dnpWpAc

G4oq 1AI61 °. C°'IU4 11J1 E1

JpJG 3: v c6uw O CJHIJ U flhJ!OUjS1!O1J W 46 6A6JOb6q )øLJ

Page 43: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

onLcG2: (j iwq bL!CG (To8o) cPu!c (JooJ) OECD (jjy

TO2 4° Tooo: OECD (jj)

JQØ2: iJ eM4491Jq 1JJ2

3

Page 44: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

BW Iq bU6 (Jo8o) N2aGL (oY

gGIJUJ9i.( pq 9!LJ) aG9qX LO/#4JJ pGoLG 9Uq 9GL WG DGbL!0U

jj (j) (j) 33

iisq yuqow 55Q (Jofl) 33T (Joio)

liq9Uq STJ (Jô58) 5 (Jô35)

EAGqGU (J33) (J3) SR

I4OLN ITS (Jô5) 45ô (J3ô) SR

5Q3 (Jô58) '430 (1o35) 'vs

o (1o32) 5'cj (Io3,)

DGUUJtJ(, 3Q5 (Joso) 'QQ (Jo3o)

JVQ (Ta3) 55s (Jo38)

3'4ô (J33) 388 (1ô3ó) o.€jo 2bm4 jjc 2bm.i 9UG bci. AG

DGIJ2!A uq VAGLSG yuuij

j,spj : flUJOIJ DGIJVA !" WG 1ô302 W J6GUJ C0111W462

Page 45: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

43

2GLAG2 58 QØ

QOAGLUUJGUJ 8 2 JOR 11'

nnu dnu)qu suq O!J Q3

wqjqw suq COULftCI1OU 223 3K!W I.91J2bOLWJ!OU - - 223 -

JLIJ2bOL4OW cOwwnu!COIr uq IU!J!4!G - 200 08rnwpGL uq jnwp bwqncia 100 JJJ TQO

L6X4!162 JR J 305

CPGW!C9J LnppGC CJ' J92 9uq O1J6 '44 J35

['G94JGL uq JGSIJJGL bwqnc 53J JQ

bsb6L bquu uq bnpjI2p!u SOR 58 385

ooq qLuJe uq opco 22 5,4• J 5 Q

CI01VP1 2J 238

GISJ2 uq uJCpuGL) JJO - S'4R

L?SIJtT9CUU4IJ IT - STJ '4OS

A1uITsClflLnJ, - 10c? 552 '40• J

I33 1Ô32 JÔ3Ô

pJqfl24L?

JJG : fluou D6UTI O WG DGbLou-fioLJq JL II bm4

Page 46: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

omcc: isnJ q h4c (JO) suq fl bi.pii€uo oi uJGLc€ (JQQy

cwbjoAwGIU q9 LOW WG fl2 DGbLflJJGUi O cOUjjJGc flhJG2 9T. opucq p? qAqu rwiou wcwpcl2pTb n' siiq b'1 (J8o) ispjc

,TJJ !WG ! LOW BIT" q bJc6 (J9Ø) WJG 33

LUPJG cOIJUIUIGq

Page 47: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

5Lfl(G ELOUJ Jô3 5° JÔ42 11KG MFI�B LGbOLIGq WG IJmJJpGL 0 ll0LJCGL2 G!PIG50 A056

woujijA MFJ�B 9qn25Gq 5L0W U2C9J AGSi. P!2 50 PG 011 C9JGUqL A691. cowbpjc o p€

W5I5IC2 916 LOW 495I0UJ pipoi. K6JS5!01J2 091q1 yIJIJJThJ Gb0L I11J6 1ô3-V11G JÔ4Q "!sp

LGC0IJE5i0U 5U1CG2 /1JJGIG sp 0fl50UJG ii 2fl25SU5j oLb914J ipi o jjc EJGCS!0U

flJA0JA6 1J J0G U4J(6 pA p€ bGLC6U5G 0 il0LJCGL2 SJJG ffl LGbOLSGq 9 p6u UA0jA6 111

M056: I GswsGq sJJG UflUJGL 0L9U2G pA Lccou!s!ou 25Lflc62 pA wnJ5!bjA!u 5JJ6 U1TUJ6L LGboLIGq

1Ô42 2à5 43200 1031350 2523 3b000 15

J49 3 5J3b38 5ô'82 9812 1'08I000 3

Jô'43 514 14 241J 4435 J15231000 4

JÔ45 84 2ô'8 4.ô0 4185 115811000 4

1ô41 142 4441221 3388 330 1'OOJ bOO 52

T40 1J1024 28102J 1880 2000

Jô3ô 882 1351034 ôô18L 33l000 51

1ô38 8Q 1J013ô8 8Q10'ct Ô'4Ô 58Q1000 54

5500 ô411805 J1'00 08 5Q51000

JÔ3Q 80ô S5b013 5521'4ô8 1Q3 b4b000

T32 2Q0 5051118 1Q31213- - -

TÔ34 25 .0Y10i 224III22 258 301000

5LI1C62

UJ(G 25U1C62 AO5UJ flUIOU K6COWUOU

5L!ICG2 jçccomnou JçCCO1JI5OU E!GCS!0112 EIGCS!OU flUIS2 fluTomGq pA

J6C01I1POIJ ftOLJC6*2 UI OLtCGL2 Ui B6C0IJWOU flOWCL2 UI flOL1(GL

AG9L L4PUJPGL O L4flWP612 O MUUJPGL O wnUJpGz. O M11UJPGL O bGC6U6 O

JSpJ6 L4flWPGL 0 J/04(612 Oij1 pA jA oGcoIJs!o11 s-1c q pA W1�FB E!GC5!0I

Page 48: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

4Q

1Ø' TÔ8Q YI Jô3-Tô4

om.cG: jccoiJou 2LflC6 q i.ow qJ€ fl BIILG9IT o r'9POL 2Waic2 ouirjA r'poI. icA!!

!TJ 1UJ!12 A01U JUJ 01191.6 92G 011 JJ 9qn2pJJGuc

(UJTOII M92 T29 1JJ6L 1119U i6 UJTUJPGL IAjJO A0l.6 mJ0U JJJG IJ(TUJPGL2 UIJJG cOjfTwu 0L MOLJ(6L2

b9bGL (QIGpT2cjJ ' 06L G!GP!CP c24w96q 1J9 1116 UIIUJpGL 0 M04(612 UI mfl2 il01J p? 4}76

IJJG umiipt 1E4J0 J016q (UJ!01J pn U0 WG IJIIUJp6I. 1I 616C1!0112 MJIGLG 4p6 IW0U li0W 6I.UJ

Q COIUJIJITGq

Page 49: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

b9C1P01 thOLrGLZ

0!! T1

0U! uq bLoG22!OU9J

McbsbGL G'N 41

IAUCb Jt!!J! Jq 2WGJtGL Q5 318

I4!WG 4ô I

A9U1JG % JnbprnJqw

JGEU!IJ 1

r'OU2IJOI6 so

Iwu 2!b suq j so j 03

IuJ9uq BOPJJU 0 S00

D!4C20bflVtM J10 J500

}/TUJWL6 4 452

EJ QJ922JOliGL2 J4 85

G6L9J 108 33J9WJ EdfT!bWGu 1 4

D!2!I!612 30

D!GC92I2 13 5Q0

C0IJ2WC!OU 3T3 TS'5O

C0WWt113iC9!0U 8 Q 18

C9IJ1JL 82

3 00WTOWOPIJG Q0

VLCP!42 49 1500

VJW" 1A°4 Z30

flIJIOIJ V22T2IJcG ill Ofl29U2 O ','22!2succ bGL GUJpGL u

bGL GUJ6L !IJ iJJG IIJ!9G2 92 O 1O3.

1PJ : y222J QIAGU P WG dO jO M9!OU9J VWJ!9G JO3-JO4J E!W9i V!2WIJc

Page 50: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

?GL P' S](GU gIG wGuJpGLaJgb !1J gIG UGBL6 AjJSJG ?GSL

wcwp€i.jnb UI J3 L0W jLO? (Jô2) 9JG -5 JJJGU jL0? wbOI4Gq 110 uJGuJpGI2pb 1J

onLcG: I j;LOUJ QffJGU2OU (JQo) pJG 5 cojnunj 5 I qiqq cojaum p? mnou

ET6C4CJ uq jjjO J9Ob!CJ SRO

wqo J6CJIUCj9U J 23

J00qMO4(GL2 82

jo? uq 140A6j1?i 23 Ti ot

JGXflG 133

1OJô 812

2WW nmcibj CA 134 STJO

21106 95

J1TppGL 53

K6U suq 6b91.LUJG1U 151 305

jqjo uq j6j6LSbJ1 33 OO20UG 1 •5

Page 51: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

WO2 LCCGU CIO-ll!!0U AGL

pc /JJGU SIUTOU M2 UO ujjicq JA!4J1dO (fl?iM D!I4C 20 JJ M!JJ 1G flJfLMY ncq pc

nu,ou2 IACu 20W6 CCIUL9J nbboLr IIJ VCM flYJJA nq II Thfl 9UJOIJ OGL tG cxcjnqcq OW

4oG: jcnjcqow jpc , uq WGUJPGL2JJ!b qw jow jioA (Jo2Y pi y- ucjnq oujA

J 28'tQ00 C0U2W1C!0U D!1!C 20

Jo ioooo jcxqc yz.uc %V pbpnqtu12 1 O22000 flV/A EIGL!C 1�TIPPGL

bci. j3 WCUJpGL flIJ!OU2 qcwpcL2pth

DOUVL2 Oq) J?-J4J J4rIWpCL Oj J43 y1oL flU 0U2 III QLO(lb

V!24CG

jpj g: y[cwpcL2pb I" ClO flioiia !u v°q!" o DcbGuqcucc ou cio E!uc!1

Page 52: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

orn.cc: J).OA (J pjc v-j

dO - JôJ JÔ8 J)g3g 5J9 3Q4

bIfIWPGI2 32 3 44 29 Q3 8J 114

1U1GL 3 JOJ J03 114 131

ObG.!U8 EUIUCCL 32 32 93 43 28 Qk4 J3J3 J 33 93 3à 4J 3

BO!1CUJJ1CL2 1? JQ 18 38 33 93

OPGL BnhJqfu jL6

1101G1 83 JJO Jô4 J8X 311 33Q 3Qô 33E1CC!1 9 1O J32 J9Q 303

CI.bCUGL2 13 J20 30ô 5J2 312 333 3?

J(CL 31 32 30 8J 23

JCW!JC1GLJC 13 18 34 30 21 .4 83 80

jCUJ21GL JQ3 188 323 39 943 '18 2ôC1J1U1 o8 IJQ IQX 11 JX8 3OX 3J3 48

VII' 33J8 3?JQ 3J80 3?4.X 328 9393 ?JXÔ

J3? JÔ3Q J3X J38 JÔ3Ô 1ô40 JÔ9J J95

jpjc o: AjCuJpCL2pb !U ipon2uq Lu yjj' uq CIO J32-193

Page 53: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

ASUSIJOU HI 4J1626 621!w962:

BGI0M L6b0L UAG qcLc1u J1UIOIJ UJGwp6L2j1b 26462 0L J33-J 2JJ0M W6 L91J6 0

Wi1J 9Uq UJS1JU1q6 O 4}J6 CJJ9U62 062 pi 20W6 C9262 0L 1.6920112 114 91.6 (TUCJG9L

WCI.6926 !11 wGuJpG12pb LOW J3 WL0(T}J Jô3ô uq L0W JJ 01. Jf WL01TP Jf 4G

W626 6L6U62 ! !2 U0 2flth42!1J 11191 /1411J6 9Jj 6XW1J1 G21UJ916q 26462 20li 9 2JJ9Lb

(Q9j6u2011 TôQO b 1116 C0UGWb0L91J60112 ffl'2 62PUJ946 0L 1Ô3Ô tA92 '4 WIjJIOIV (3JAGU

4JJ6!L 1)61. C9b!9 6G2 0 1116 CIOb suq 491 9CU191 w6u1p6L2}nb wju ooo'ooo,

9A6 9 w6wp612p1b 62!w946 o j uJjJflou: JJ6 uqcs6q l1J9 w suJT!962 M6L6 uo biiXpi

clob bPfl!1) AflLL9) R92 JIUcGLISIU 9po1T1 w0w6p6L2p!b !U J3 11416111)61. C9b!W b9)UJ6IU2

U ooq 2W1JqiUF 911q q1162 b9)4U uJcwpGL2b 1J19 bLOqlTcG il46 A949110W EAGU fl16 69 0 16

qGL6uc62 GJA66IJ COUAGIU!0U 2P.GUfJJ 9U w6wp6L2}qb CJ9UJ2 6L61162 PGUAGGU W6W6L2

11IGLG COUJbGPU H6 9J20 C0UL9242 JJT2 624IUJ962 MIflJ 111026 0 IAOIW91J flIGL6 91.6

bG4Oq 9uq q62c4p62 2011J6 0 1116 b1.opJ6w2 0 q66UJJupJ u16u1p6L21J!b 9 9 UJG 1141611 ITIJ!0112

Q9J6112011 (JoQo bb 28'4-2&) L0U2 q61U UITIMpGL2 0L J4O1T2 111110112 P11116 D6bL622!011

911211C9J VP2l.L2 siiq Br2 B1TH6P1J2 211CJ1 92 fl BITI.69(T 0 'pOL 911211C2 (1o20Y

(1o82) u1 4JJ6 BI1.69n 0 '9p0L W11211C2 (LGboI4Gq 11 A6L26 bnpj!c9!ou2 2J1C 92 A9140fl2

D6bL622!0U LS (Suq GSLJ!GL) 11JI.011J1 W6 Jo2 111626 ucJflq6 J).o? (J ji.o? uq p6ujJ1GL6 91.6 116U191!AG 621U19462 04 flIJ!OU wGuJpGL2pb 0L 4jJ6 flh16q 2S62 flJ9I COAGL 1J16

bb6uqp y: nuiou wpcI2p1b uq DGu&

Page 54: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

25

3TGU2OU 261.162 1116 fiOJUJU 6UG2 2J10M2 J9L6 IUCL626 111 wcwpcI2pIb 1ô3Q-Jô3 P TI

2JJ0M2 WJIC}J L69I6L 2b1fl4 u uJGwp6L2pb ivu iwW6 iLo OL LLO q

JJJ6 qj6L6UCG2 9UJOIJ W646 SLG J9L621 !IJ Jô3 uq Jô3 il4JGU tJJG i2q

1ô'c18 12000 12050 Tf23

1àt 12'I14 J'42ô2

1ô'I 1tô4 1353 13212

JÔ42 J525 T558

1ô4't 1'4QSJ 15Q58 15Q02

Jôt3 J3I5 11815 15103

1ô'I5 10Q5 10500 102Qô

1iT 10't8 8à8 Ô0J 833ô 8Q14

TI0 8ôN .S85 2S't QQÔ 8101

1Ô3Ô 8ô80 22Q Q08 QQ8O 32

J38 85Q2 p080 Q1ô3 2ô1't 345

1Ô3 5J8 2.80 2ô53 2080 33't

13Q 't1 '410. 431Q '41Q4 402

1ô32 3S8 323

1ô34 35Iô 3Q0ô

Tô33 582 5ô3 32ô

BF2 LLO ViBEB jLOA c pjiu ojw9u

flrnou j,6wp6I2Jnb (ooo)

Page 55: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

01.

01J16L 26462 01. AHU9IJI2 0 fIG bi.ucnjt 2bflcW fI91 I CJJO2G M!Jj 1J(U JJ01161GL 96C1 fIG P92!C

L9bq L0thfJ I p926 lilA 6241119162 011 416 fl 26462 2bJ!C6q 10 04161. 26462 fl26 o HUA o 416

qn62-b9?4u UJGUJpGL2' 92 fIG OU1J6L WHA !AG 9 pGUGL uqc94ou 0 CJJ91JG2 !1J b640q2 o

UJGH2IU.62 4191 I.GJ6C4 416 PL09G21 b0221p16 UJ6UJPGL2P!I) 11 401I2 10 41026 W16q 10 SIIIJ(THJ

PGV!GGU JG jt.oA 6241119462 suq fIG j.oA suq 2jJG1J G24UJ94G2 Huq JJHAG 9 wjq b6I.Guc6 0L

9uHJA!u mJ0U kOllLtjJ U fIG fl2 B1 p6C921T6 I 9UJ mIGS2A 9p01T4 416 mJGxbjHiuGq Cp9IJG2

JJJGLG 2 110 24L0U 1.69201110 b1.6L 416 B2 01. 1LOA 01. ILOA q 21164W H49 40L

92 qAqn9J (Uf 0112 20flJJ1 10 1(GGb 11301.6 0 416 1162 OL 416W26JA62

AflU3A2 G24UJHIG2 0L 416 CIO !111!C1I UJHA 9AG IWGL2494G GAGU qnG2-b9ApJ wGwpGL21nb

j33 Huq J34 ll' (}HJGIJ2OU 26462 1126 VT' $uq 1Iq6b6uqGui (114011 949 40G4JJGL !1P bIfT!b

XG9L 1T1 442 q062 LcHqJA GXbJ9IIJ 201136 0 436 GLGUCG2 6411GGU 41626 264G2 b9U!c11194X u

21164W 91.6 926 OIl 416 WGL JLOA 4(TL62 !A!fJ 9qJ121uJ6u42 L0W 42C9J AGHL 10 C9J611q9L

I.Gb0LL2 ft41cjJ UJHA UCJfl6 b6L20u2 11410 qo 1104 b9A q1162' b!cnJ9qA w ir.oA suq

11TI.62 91.6 pH2Gq OU flG2 W6WpGL2p!b i#44JG 416 ffl 949 91.6 q64A6q Low imou

j1ji) qo 41626462 fl6L JJJG J HUq J,LoA q q146L bI.G2nurnpJX 691166 1i.oA

WW J4'4 10 T48 41911 0C2 416 J'2 26462

cowb91.HpJG 40416 Br'2 W Tô'18 4IGA 2JJ0!A J91.6L 624UJ91G 11CLG92G2 11 (11J0U WGWpGL2Jfb

£LoA 01. jLoX Huq 2P4W 26462 9114 2WCG 436 jLoA HUq jLoA 91J 2JJGUTU 919 91.6 LoflJ4A

21S69pJ6 91U2 III UJGWpGL2plbJpG 11 26462 9J20 2J10M2 H j91.GL 41CL6926 1" J45-43 41911416

201116114191 flGLGIJ4 4UJpI HIiq W91JlflqG2 01. 416 D6b1.622!011 E'. 2b1TL1 fl1 ll 24 jJ 2JJ011

HJj2 20L4 0 fIG CJJH1JG U WGWPGL2II!b W fI B1'2 1W jJIG q4GLG1JCG2 !U 41626462 !WbIA

Page 56: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

° Jô2 J 1126q fIG ECOIIOW!C KGbOLI 0j fIG LGgGIu WPJG -4 0L 1ô30 l0JôQ I 1126(1

BI6 U0U9L1.CfT11ThSJ GUIbJOAUJGU4 26462 91.6 qG4A6q jLOW 26A6L9j 20111.C62 92 /A6JJ hO'.

OAGLI9b A691. JÔN

EUGqUJSU (Jo) 2b1!CGq O 11F2-26462 (!i2611 9(1il2$(1 0 P6 OIl 9 Ci cowbpJG p9212) s fIG

mJ!0112 hO'. fIG 1)6140(1 1880 O 1ô13 J (126(1 fIG 26462 01; flhJ!OIJ wGuJp6L2pb LGbo'.q pA c'.jq

uJGwp6L2pb !11 1ô30 11126462 D-.'9T 911(1 D-45 u'!2 GJ!W1I9G2 C'(1 wGuJpGL2 01; fl

LG1;GL o fl wGuJpGL2 o1; ffl'!0U2 Oil fIG p9212 o fIG fl b'.oboLl!ou o jpo'. mou

LGbOI4Gq 111 fl2 BIILG9I1 01; fIG CGU2 (j)b 2G4G2 D-3 9q112TGq 20 fI9 fIG q99

OAGLJ9I) A69L p6W6GIJ fIG Br'2 911(1 Cb2 2G4G2 h°'. fIG 1)640(1 T8Ô ° TÔ5Ô I (126 fIG Hr'2

pA fI6 B111-6'T 01; 'Po'. 2f2f(2 (J80Y 2b1!C6(1 ° 6 C0IJ2!2G1U MIfI fIG Cb2 91 fIG

OL1!'!0ITh 1ô8S-183 6(1!1!oU (1o85) t9PJG 1. bLOW 130 0 Tô I 1126 fIG 26462 LGbOLlGq

I W6 Cb2 1I1TU1PGL2 LG1)oL1(1 1' BITLGSR 01; MS!OU9J V1!'. D!LGCOLA o1; n i'p°'-

bLoboI41ou9G o fIG cp91JG !AGu u i'.oA 9uq 2JJGUUJ (Jo8Y 9JG 3-10 Es'. Tô8-Tô80'

Jô8Sb i G2fIJJ9IGq UJGUJpGL2JJ!b fJ9 AG9L pA 9221J!U fIG Cp91J6 PGuiGGu JgJ q J83

bG'.cGIfl9G 01; M96 9uq 29J9LA MOLICGL2 MJI0 MGLG niJOu UJGWJ)6L2 V2 fIGLG 9LG 110 II1TUJ6L2 1;oL.

E'.'fI D9 B001C 1ôô3 (JooY WPJG 1 M!fJ fIG JÔ8J 11111MPG'. 92G(1 011 IjIG LGbOLIGq

umIipGL2 '.0'.1(1 1;L011J fIG Cb2 111 B"691T 01; l49fOU9J VU2 flulTOil GWp'!b 9ug

1;'.ow J' EWbJ0AWGIU ug LIJU 91IrT91.A JôQ ho'. fIG 1)6140(1 T83 O 1ôô4 I (126 fIG

oujA ° 0p59II fIG 1;!fT1.62 I 2b1!CG2 10GfIGL flLGG qfl1;GLGIU 2G462 ui'G 1ôô2 urnJJpGL2 COUJG

/1JJTC1J I GI4AG 9q6u2A 26462 BI6 11111011 UJGUJpGL2pb m.62 LG1;6L 0 fl 11111011 uIGuJpG'.2

26462 1;1.OW 1880 O OGfIGL MIfI 9 2UlJG 1IOU-9L1CfTJW1.9J GUJbJOAWGU4 26462' 1;LOW

BI6 62fUJ9G2 LGbOLLGq 111 ybb€iiqix I9pJG VT bLOA!qG OUG C011fI1110112 flI'!OU WGUIPGL2J'!b

Page 57: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

v-Joe.

c2TW9Gq GUJbJO)UJGIU p) 922flUJJ !1 LG1A bLobo.i!ousG O bObflj9OU 92 LcboLIcq pi 26462

26962 y- EpJJ 92 1JJ6L6 91.6110 91JUKWJ 1JOU94C(TWTL9J 6WbJO?UJ6U 26462 1)401. 0

wqp 9uq j 9bbJGq iJ16 wqGx lJnuJp6L2 O fIG JÔOO UO1J94Cn1W121 6Wbj0?WGIU qw w

26462 VO L0W fIG 291116 JOJflUJ6 1]JO2G 9W 91.6911 wqcx O W911J10fl12 P1 1JOU94CflJU112J

IT26 iGqw P1 W fl2 D6b91.W361U O COI11.C 26962 V- EOL 188Ô ° 18ÔÔ I

fIG q949 UIfl DGbSI4UJGIU O (OUJUJ6LCG JQ 26962 V-88 EOL fiG X6912 TôOO ° TÔSÔ I

Page 58: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

J82 23ô J5'Ô22

J82 214 130J0

18ô4 QS 1J5Q

183 .03 J5Q84 222

18Ô5 1SÔ22 238

T8M .23 J5382

18ô0 I5S 1J80 203

J88ô 25 1J4TJ

1888 215 JJbJ4 248

188 858 10ô38 V2

1882 1020 1005 ô.ô0

1882 45 J0'422 408

1884 343 T0'SSÔ 332

1883 58 ÔÔÔ3 5o

1885 523 52Ô

1881 JQ à250

1880 à584 121

(000) (000)

WGUJPGI2P!b EwbJo?WGIU (bGLcGlU)

AGL 2puJ94Gq MOU9LICI1JWL91 flhJTOU DGIJ!A

9G2 1880-1àô2bbGuqp v JjG j: MGä quwi o flUOU GWpGLJJjb u 4G flIJG

Page 59: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

1012 5312 53l'tO 1000

JOlt 5303 53lOO J035

1013 5t3Q s,4143 1000

1015 51513 531101 024

Toil 51123 55b003

1010 11003 5J'0 018

1000 11802 511503

1008 S'OOO 101520 J038

JoO SlOSi 501253 082

IOOQ J8O2 50'OQO

1002 5'OOJ i80 T00

ioot slOot it0 il81003 11085 J828 1110

1005 T4 I3O2 8tO

1001 1SQ2 J5O4

1000 110S8 i2'i.8 Q8

1800 30 141088

1808 Q5t T3225

J8O 13"408 t03

(000) (000)Gwp6Lzp1b EUJbJ0XWGIU (bcLcGu)

4OU4CnJUTLJ flUTOU DGU!A

Page 60: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

1Ô34 Sô23

1Ô33 53bMJ

1Ô33 5Th58 T5JÔ3J

Tô30 JTT

TÔSÔ J0tQ

1ô58 3S52 3023 T0Q

JÔ5 352 30t8J T08

JoS 3S'I8 30'2ôô 10Q1

JS2 3SS4 5oJ J084

Jo5I 3bSOô JFS3

1Ô53 3'58J 5ô'53J TJSS

1Ô55 32T 13'tS

TSI 54'245 Tt0

JÔSO Sf3i TQÔ

JaJ SS0 J3tJ

JJ8 3'042 5QI3S 1125

JÔT S'QÔT S280S J0I3

TÔJQ S4QT 52b2J0 Ô22

(000) (000),4GwpGI2JJ!b EWbJ0WGIU (},GLcGIU)

AGL MOU4Cfl1UTLST flIJ!OU D6U2!

Page 61: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

Jô3 1Q3I 20535 35R8

1231'4 t88S2 3113

JÔ21 JI'ÔQS

10 132 42555 30't

J3ô0 138 310

JÔ'Ig J3852 'N8ôT 3080

t3b88J 354

J38Ô 4JbQ,f 33•32

138S8 I01M 34'53

Jô1,t T38 tT883 351

T13 15 f15 3002

Tô't5 J00SS 't0h1

1Ô41 3Q229 SQ

1ó40 8'41Q 353Q SQ 00

Jô3ô 30QJ8 SQ3

Jô3 SoS0o SQQ

QQ0 3r0SQ

JÔ3Q 382J So08S 135'4

1ô3 3'4Q0 Sf023 J5.(000) (000)

GwpGI2Jnb (bGI.cGul)A6L 2UW9Gq 4OIJ94CflJ1mSJ flUOU JGIJ2

Page 62: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

Q0

Jô JQ2 I3Q2 S2"t

JISJJ 5Q02

Tô0 J8J3 .0880 5QI0

TÔÔ 18'380 0384 SQJJ

1ÔQ8

JôQ 2'803

J3S Q3Ô0J

J03 01't4 5Q3

TQ3 J2'ô2'I 2QQ05 SWJ

To5 TQ0N 22'2J 5882

TôJ T2T 38Ô

TÔQO 4S03

Jôô JQ'2S 23SÔ 3J01

JÔ28 JNS 2J1Q8 3501

T2 T0 2518t 3JT

1Ô2Q 25t08 35S5

Jô2 TQ'553 0Q2 350J

TÔ�4 JQ432 4ô0SS 333

(000) (000)

y1GwpcI2pTb EwbJoThicIU (b6I.cGIu)AGL MOIW4CITJmUJ flUOU

Page 63: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

TÔT TQ8 J08'5Q W30

Tôô0 JQ10 J0ÔUÔ J30

JQ'ÔQJ J08Ô2 J5L00S T0SI0 JQTQ

TÔ8 JÔJ3 T0JbÔ8

TÔ8 ÔÔ311 L0J8 JI

JN0 ô4t08 J3T83 ô0bJ5

J85 T828 50.3

T8T J&20 SJt0

Jô80 500 ô040 S553

50ô8Q 8Ô8S3

S522

JÔ0IQ 5T0

Ô38S 5388

J8'Ô3

TÔ03

IÔ3 ô0 5V

(000) (000)jl6wp€I2p1b EWb!OXWGIU (bGL.cGu4)

OIJ4CffjWLJ flhJTOU DGIJI4

Page 64: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

Q3

JÔÔ2 I30 JJQQ0Ô T'V03

Tôà'I TQ40 JI4031

1ôô3 IQ'2 IT030

1ÔÔ5 TQ3ô0 J090'4 120à

(000) (000)GwpGI2p1b EuJbJo)wGIU (bGLccIu)

AG9L MOU4CITII flWOIJ DGzJa!A

Page 65: jJcpJLq p LLUJflJ - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1IJ0u-2bm41, b640q2 2JJOMU pi j9JG I p1qc9c fJ91 fIG q621191Gq b640q2 WGG f1626 CI.U640U BIG 24I2C9J 111692111.62 0 CJJ9UG2 P1 if 2 11U!OU

)onbna

- d = qq 313dw bn [J.MOIWJ ]d - 1.MOIV1U s = 0510 dw a 3lqmie odi ii! .1

.no l3blo bno s i noiiEup niflib 3di CJ4OJT4U 3

A$1114 od (EEQI II! .noitn3fl moe aveb an&1a LsoI odilo thmit silT . ilsvs2ooSI 4IEQ1 nI .'lut iii nsvi aw noitaxinokiu no tnsmoi3a i iltiw ebo3 swift silT .bssq

r1iw anoxt3sls 8 bbd sdi bns anoitsls ninigid twbnoo o bisoH iodaJ sth b3l3blo

ASIM sib bstl3sb fluoD smsiqu2 srb EQI nI .siov OOOO lstmixo1qqB

no iaA i3nW odi b322sq sinoD silT .noiaisb .oD v-ijhjoq 15td35d32 silt iii lsnoituiitano3nu

2noiisIsSl iodJ lsnoitsM ni tiuoD srnsiqu2 2.U silt sd blsdqu 2sw t3A silT 2Q1 lu1

.(VEQI lhqA) nililusJ bna 2snot .v bisoa