ATP TBZLn ?USTA@ @UABLAU<nBnOP? ATP L>BUn< S<CP?nZPnA

Kwzloo qrw gr wrvwxg~kxpdq uljkwvlq wkhRklolsslqhv iurp dsxuho~ wkhruhwlfdoshuvshfwlyh0 Ehuwdlqo~qrwlq d vrflhw~zkhuh dfwvriylrohqfh duhhyhu~gd~ rffxuuhqfhv0Ehuwdlqo~qrwzkhuh kxpdq uljkwvlvd pdwwhuri olih dqg ghdwkwrpdq~ Hlolslqrv. hvshfldoo~wkrvhfuxvkhge~ wkhzhljkw ri wkhhqruprxv jds ehwzhhq wkhulfk dqg wkhsrru dqg. lqsduwlfxodu.wkrvhfdxjkw ehwzhhq wkhghdgo~furvviluhvri wkhfrppxqlvwlqvxujhqwvdqg wkhplolwdu~dqg srolfh hvwdeolvkphqwv0Vklv kdg ehhqwkh fdvh gxulqj wkh gd~v ri pduwldo uxoh xqghu iruphu RuhvlghqwHhuglqdqgOdufrv. dqg. lwlv fodlphg. vr lwkdvdovrehhq xqghu wkhuxohriklvvxffhvvru.Erud°rq Ctxlqr0

Vklv sdshu zloo wu~wr h}soruh wkhuhdvrqv zk~. ghvslwh wkhuhvwrudwlrqri ghprfudwlf uxoh. wkh ylrodwlrq ri kxpdq uljkwv kdvuhpdlqhg d judyh sureohp lq wkhRklolsslqhv0 Kqwklvfrqqhfwlrq. lwzloolqtxluh lqwrwkhsureohp duhdvlq wkhsurprwlrq dqg surwhfwlrqri kxpdquljkwvxqghu Ouv0Ctxlqr'v uxoh0Kwzloo dovrwu~wrfrqwulexwh.hyhq lq dyhu~ plqlpdo zd~. wrwkhehwwhuphqwri wkhvlwxdwlrqe~ uhfrpphqglqjvrph uhphgldo vwhsvwkdwfrxog eh wdnhqe~ wkhjryhuqphqw0 Vkhdxwkrufdqqrw suhwhqgwkdwklv lghdv duhruljlqdo0 Qqh zd~ ru wkhrwkhu.wkhvhpxvw kdyh vxuidfhg lq orfdo dqg lqwhuqdwlrqdoglvfxvvlrqv derxw wkhkxpdq uljkwvvlwxdwlrqlq wkhRklolsslqhv0 Tdwkhu.wkhremhfwlyhri wkhwklv sdshu lv wr ghyhors wkhvh lghdv zlwklq d ixqfwlrqdo ohjdoiudphzrun0

Hru wkhsxusrvhv ri wklvvwxg~.wkhwhup"kxpdq uljkwv"vkrxogeh xqghuvwrrg dv dqdorjrxv wr flylo dqg srolwlfdouljkwv.iru wkhuhdvrqwkdwwkhRklolsslqh Erqvwlwxwlrqjlyhv hpskdvlv wr flylo dqg srolwlfdouljkwv0 Oruhryhu. zkloh wkhdxwkru uhfrjql°hv wkhlqglylvlelolw~dqglqwhughshqghqfh ri flylo dqg srolwlfdouljkwvdqg hfrqrplf.o vrfldo dqgfxowxudouljkwv.lwlv wkhiruphu vhwri uljkwvwkdwlv prvw ylvleo~ylrodwhglq Rklolsslqh vrflhw~0

,?ssistant Orofessor, Wqlyhuvlw~ri wkhRklolsslqhv. Eroohjh ri Ndz> NN0D0(3;:7).F0R0 Eroohjh ri Ndz> NN0O0(3;:9). Olfkljdq Ndz Ufkrro0

oEQPUV0.duw0i^. vhf0 34. sdu0 30

Covr. lwpxvw eh fodulilhg wkdwwkhfryhudjh ri wklvsdshu duhkxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqv dwwulexwdeohwr wkh jryhuqphqw0 Vkh dxwkrudjuhhv zlwk ghihqghuv ri wkhRklolsslqhv' kxpdq uljkwvuhfrug wkdwhyhqjurxsv rssrvhg wrwkhjryhuqphqw duhjxlow~ri kxpdq uljkwdexvhv. exwkh kdv gholehudwho~fkrvhq wrfrqfhqwudwhrq wkrvhwkdwpd~ eh wudfhgwrwkh jryhuqphqw iru wkh uhdvrq wkdwxqghu wkh Erqvwlwxwlrq dqglqwhuqdwlrqdolqvwuxphqwv.lwlv Uwdwhdexvh wkdwlv sulpdulo~ vrxjkw wrehfkhfnhg0

Vkh uhodwlyho~eorrgohvv GFUC Thyrowri 3;:8 xvkhuhg lq dqlqlwldohxskruld dprqj wkhshrsoh ri wkhRklolsslqhv0 Vkh dvvxpswlrqe~ Ouv0Erud°rq Ermxdqjfr Ctxlqr ri wkhsuhvlghqf~. wkhuhvwrudwlrqrighprfudwlf jryhuqphqw vwuxfwxuhv.dqg wkh udwlilfdwlrq ri d qhzErqvwlwxwlrqhqghg wzr ghfdghv ri dxwrfudwlfuxoh0 Phhgohvv wr vd~.wkhvhhyhqwv khljkwhqhg wkh h}shfwdwlrqv ri d shrsoh kxqju~ irusrolwlfdo.hfrqrplf dqg vrfldo fkdqjhv0

VkhCtxlqr jryhuqphqw lqlwldoo~vkrzhg vljqv ri lwvfrpplwphqwwr hiihfw wkhvhfkdqjhv0 Kwfrqvlghuhg sdudprxqw wkhsurprwlrq dqgsurwhfwlrqri kxpdq uljkwv05Jxpdq uljkwvzdv rqh ri wkhnh~ lvvxhvriwkhfdpsdljq ri Ouv0Ctxlqr dqg vkh sohgjhg wr dozd~v xskrog wkhkxpdq uljkwvri wkhHlolslqr shrsoh05

Kpphgldwho~diwhukhu dvfhqvlrq wrwkhsuhvlghqf~. Ouv0Ctxlqrwrrn vhyhudovwhsviru wkhdgydqfhphqw ri kxpdq uljkwv0Ukhdqqrxqfhgwkdwdoosrolwlfdo sulvrqhuv zrxog eh uhohdvhge~ Hheuxdu~ 49. 3;:9>uhvwruhgwkh zulw ri kdehdv frusxv> dqg hvwdeolvkhgd RuhvlghqwldoErpplwwhh rq Jxpdq Tljkwv(REJT) fkdluhg e~ Uhq0LrvhY0 Flrnqr. dohdglqj kxpdq uljkwv dgyrfdwh06 Vkh Rklolsslqhv udwlilhg wkhErqyhqwlrq CjdlqvwVruwxuhdqg wkhKqwhuqdwlrqdoEryhqdqw rq Elylo dqgRrolwlfdoTljkwv lq Lxqhdqg Qfwrehu ri 3;:8 dqg d uhylvhgeloori uljkwv.zklfk h}suhvvo~surklelwhg wruwxuhdqg wkhlpsrvlwlroa ri wkhghdwkshqdow~.zdv pdgh wkhfruqhuvwrqh ri d qhz Erqvwlwxwlrqzklfk zdvehlqj gudiwhge~ wkhErqvwlwxwlrqdoErpplvvlrq0v KqPryhpehu ri 3;:8.

42HHKEGQHVJG RTGUUUGETGVCT[ CPF RpWRRKPG EQOOKUUKQPQP JWOCP Topuuv0I RTKOGT QP VJG JWOCP TKIiKVUKUUWGKP eQN R!qxRRoPGv< KUUWGUCPF CPUYGT 3(3;;3)0

3Hd.• dw3/406COPGUV[ KPVGTPCVKQPCN03;:9 COPGUV[ KPVGTPCVKQPCNTGK'rTV 482 (3;:9)0RHd.• dw4830 0

Ouv0Ctxlqr uhshdohg.dprqj rwkhuv.RuhvlghqwldoFhfuhhv Pr0 3:99 dqg3:99/C lvvxhg e~ Ou0Odufrv. zklfk dxwkrul°hg wkhghwhqwlrqzlwkrxwuhfrxuvh wrwkhfrxuwvri shuvrqv dffxvhg ri qdwlrqdovhfxulw~riihqvhv08

Ukh dovr uhvwruhgwkhruljlqdo shqdowlhviru wkhvhriihqvhv. zklfk Ou0Odufrv kdg gudvwlfdoo~lqfuhdvhggxulqj klv whqxuh'B

Cpqhvw~ Kqwhuqdwlrqdouhfhlyhg ihzhu uhsruwvri kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqv lq 3;:8 wkdq lq suhylrxv ~hduv0 Kq wkdw~hdu. ryhu 722srolwlfdo sulvrqhuv ghwdlqhg e~ Ou0 Odufrv zlwkrxw fkdujhv wkurxjkRuhvlghqwldoErpplwphqw Qughuv (REQv) ru RuhyhqwlyhFhwhqwlrqCfwlrqv (RFCv) zhuh uhohdvhg0:

Jrzhyhu. wkhsurplvh ri wkhCtxlqr jryhuqphqw zdv pduuhg e~wzr vljqlilfdqw srolwlfdoidfwruv0

Hluvw.wkhuhhvwdeolvkphqwri wkhhohfwrudov~vwhpkdv uhvxowhgodujho~lq wkhuhvxuuhfwlrqri wkhsrzhu ri wkhwudglwlrqdofrusrudwh dqgodqgkroglqj holwhv0CGolwhghprfudf~ kdg rqfh djdlq uhduhg lwvxjo~khdg0 Vkh idloxuh ri wkhCtxlqr jryhuqphqw wr hiihfw ixqgdphqwdofkdqjhv lv gxh wr wkhidfwwkdwwkhvrfldo vwuxfwxuhirxqghg rq zhdowk.xsrq zklfk wkh suhvhqw ohdghuvkls lv edvhg. kdv uhpdlqhg lqwdfw0Erqvhuydwlyh irufhv. zklfk grplqdwhg wkh qdwlrqdo dqg orfdoohdghuvkls.idlohg wrdgguhvvwkhsureohp ri sryhuw~dqg vhhnvroxwlrqvwrforvh wkhzlghqlqj jds ehwzhhq wkhulfk dqg wkhsrru0 Vklv ylfwru~rifrqvhuydwlyhsrzhuv lv prvw hylghqwlq wkhErqjuhvv ri wkhRklolsslqhvzkhuh wkhodz hqdfwhgidlohg wrsurylgh iru d jhqxlqh djuduldq uhirupsurjudp0oQ

Vklv revhuydwlrq lv hfkrhg e~ Ou0 Odkexe WKJdt. vshfldodgylvhu wrwkhW0P0Fhyhorsphqw Rurjudp Cgplqlvwudwru.zkr flwhgwkh"holwlvw"jryhuqphqw lq wkhRklolsslqhv dv wkhvrxufh ri lqvwdelolw~0ooJhrevhuyhg wkdw"wkhHlolslqr plolwdu~.lqgxvwuldodqg odqgorug fodvvhvgrplqdwhg wkhirupxodwlrq ri jryhuqphqw srolflhv dqg eorfnhg pdmrusrolwlfdo fkdqjhv qhhghg iru Rklolsslqh hfrqrplf dqg vrfldoghyhorsphqw0"34

Uhfrqgo~. diwhuuhdol°lqj lq wkh GFUC Thyrow ri 3;:8 wkhslyrwdo uroh lwsod~v lq wkhedodqfh ri srzhu. wkhRklolsslqh plolwdu~kdv wdnhqlwxsrq lwvhoiwrsod~d grplqdqw urohlq srvw/Odufrv srolwlfv0

61d..9G}hf0 Qughu Pr0 3:9 (3;:9)081d.GTrXzl{ austTV u{ JVul. 4 KfbbNYed 3 (3;:;)0!Nld.KoVkhEkurqlfoh. Qfw032. 3;;3. s0 30121d.

Vkhuh kdg ehhq vhyhq (9) idlohg coup o' etats Kvlqfh Ouv0 Ctxlqr'vdvfhqvlrq wrwkhsuhvlghqf~0

Covr. wkh plolwdu~ kdv ehhq uhvlvwdqwwr wkh kxpdq uljkwvlqlwldwlyhvri Ouv0Ctxlqr0 Vkh qhhg iru d wrxjk frxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~srolf~ kdv riwhqehhq flwhg dv d udwlrqdohiru wklvdssduhqwuhvlvwdqfh0350

Qq wkhsrolf~ ohyho.wkhvhidfwruv kdyh sxvkhg wkhCtxlqrjryhuqphqw lqwr dedqgrqlqj d srolwlfdo vroxwlrq wr wkhfrppxqlvwlqvxujhqf~ lq idyru ri d plolwdu~vroxwlrq. i.e., d srolf~ ri "wrwdozdu"djdlqvwwkhlqvxujhqwv0 Rlyrwdolq wklvsrolf~ vkliwzdv wkhfroodsvh riwkh shdfh qhjrwldwlrqv ehwzhhq wkh jryhuqphqw dqg wkh PdwlrqdoFhprfudwlf Hurqwlq Ldqxdu~3;:9 iroorzlqj d pdvvdfuh ri shdvdqwvzkrvwdjhgd ghprqvwudwlrqlq wkhylflqlw~ri wkhsuhvlghqwldosdodfh036Vklvsrolf~ vkliwzdv hiihfwhgrq wzr iurqwv<(d) wkurxjk hvfdodwhgplolwdu~dfwlylw~>dqg (e) wkurxjk wkhdssrlqwphqw ri uhwluhgplolwdu~riilfhuv wrdgplqlvwudwlyhsrvlwlrqv lq wkhh}hfxwlyheudqfk0o7

Ulqfh wkhOdufrv uhjlph. wkhRklolsslqh plolwdu~kdv hvsrxvhgd frxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~ vwudwhj~srsxoduo~ nqrzq dvNrz Kqwhqvlw~Erqiolfw(NKE)038Gvvhqwldoo~.lwlv "wrwdozdu dwwkhjudvvurrwvohyhov0"oBKwkdvehhq ghilqhg dv<

000 d olplwhg srolwlfr/plolwdu~ vwuxjjoh wr dfklhyh d srolwlfdo. vrfldo.hfrqrplf ru sv~fkrorjlfdo remhfwlyh0Kwlv riwhq surwudfwhgdqg udqjhviurp glsorpdwlf. hfrqrplf dqg sv~fkrorjlfdo suhvvxuhv wkurxjkwhuurulvp dqg lqvxujhqf~0 NKElv jhqhudoo~ frqilqhg wr d jhrjudsklfduhd.dqg lv riwhq fkdudfwhul°hge~ frqvwudlqwvrq zhdsrqu~. wdfwlfvdqgwkhohyhori ylrohqfh03:

l3Ree F0 Xl°pdqrv. Eanning the Elames of Hnsurgency, PCK32>a>CNOKFYGGM.Ldqxdu~5F. 3;;30

l4?quino Rays ?nswer to Serrorism is Lilitary ?ction Mot Kand Qeform, RklolsslqhPhzv. Odufk 47/53. 3;:9. ss0 3/4 lq F0 D0 UKKKTOGTdqg U0 T0 UJCNQO. VJGRJq00KRRKPGUTGCFGT63; (3;:9)0

o7Vklv lv prvw fohduo~ghprqvwudwhge~ wkhghflvlrq. d sduwri wkhCuphg HIufhv 3;::Cfwlrq Rodq. wr dssrlqw uhwluhgjhqhudov dqg plolwdu~riilfhuv wrgluhfwwkhEQoWowu~'UG}sruwRurfhvvlqj \rqhv dqg khdg rwkhuflyloldq srvlwlrqv. dqg wkhRuhvlghqw'vsursrvdo0 lq G}hf0Qughu Pr0 4;4. wkdwFhihqvh Uhfuhwdu~Hlgho Tdprv eh hohydwhgwr wkhqhz srvw ri Xlfh/Erppdqghu/lq/Eklhi ri wkhCuphg Hrufhv0 Rklolsslqh Fdlo~ Ioreh. Pry0 39. 3;::< Rlqwljqj Dd~dq. Uhsw037. 3;::0

38KPVGT/CIGPE[YQTMKPIITQWRKPNKE.VQVCNYCT< DCUKEFQEWOGPuvWUGF4E.sVJGEQPHGTGPEGQP Nrz KPVGPUKV[37 (3;:9)0

17/d. -3:H0 O0 IN[PP. UGEWTKV[CUUKUVCPEGCPF Nrz KPVGPUKV[EQPiNKEV< C

EJCNNGPIGVQGZEGooGPEG3 (3;:9)0

Vkh NKE Rurjudp ri joredo frxqwhu/uhyroxwlrq lv srsxoduo~nqrzq dv wkhThdjdq Frfwulqh0Vkhjrdo ri wklvgrfwulqhzdv qrwrqo~ wrfrqwdlq Urylhwsrzhu lq wkhVklugYruog exwwruhyhuvhUrylhwjdlqv e~ dsurfhvv ri dwwulwlrqri wkhshufhlyhg shulskhu~ ri Urylhwlqioxhqfh0K;

NKE. wkhuhiruh.lv qrw frqyhqwlrqdo zduiduh dwd orzhu vfdoh. exw lvhvvhqwldoo~d srolwlfdo zduiduh ehwzhhq dqwdjrqlvwlf vrflr/srolwlfdov~vwhpv<zhvwhuqolehudoghprfudf~ dqg frppxqlvp042

Vkh NKE surjudp hpskdvl°hv wkuhh pdlq hohphqwv< (3)uhvwulfwlqjwkhvfrsh ri dfwlylw~ri fulwlfvri ru srolwlfdorssrvlwlrq wrwkhjryhuqphqw> (4) lqfuhdvlqj wkhurohsod~hg e~ flyloldqv lq wkhzdu. erwkdv djhqwv dqg wdujhwvri wkhplolwdu~>dqg (5) hvfdodwlqjwkhvfdoh rigluhfwplolwdu~dfwlrq043

Dhiruh wkhGFUC Thyrowri 3;:8. Ouv0Ctxlqr. dv d suhvlghqwldofdqglgdwh. sohgjhg wr vroyh wkhlqvxujhqf~ sureohp wkurxjk shdfhixophdqv0 Jhu dssurdfk zdv wzr/surqjhg< dgguhvvlqj wkhhfrqrplfsureohpv ri wkhshrsoh dqg frqgxfwlqj shdfh wdonvzlwk wkhPdwlrqdoFhprfudwlf Hurqw0 Wqiruwxqdwho~.srvlwlrqv kdughqhg dqg zlwk wkhfroodsvh ri wkh shdfh wdonv.wkh survshfwv iru d shdfhixo vroxwlrqglpphg0

Vkxv. lq d pdmru vshhfk gholyhuhgvrph wzr prqwkv odwhu.Ouv0Ctxlqr dqqrxqfhg wkhsrolf~ uhyhuvdodiwhud idlohg erpe dwwdfn0Ukhvdlg<

Vr rxu hqhplhv. ohwph vd~ wkdwqrwklqj zloo lqwlplgdwhwklvRuhvlghqw.000 Fhdwk krogv qr ihdu iru xv. qhlwkhuiru wkh Erppdqghu/lq/Eklhiqru iru vroglhuv lq wkh olqh000 Qqh qdwlrq. rqh duphg irufhv. dfwlqjwkhhqhuj~ dqg gluhfwlrK·0ri d vlqjoh kdqg. zloo vplw• wkhirhv rq wkhohiwdqg rq wkhuljkw0 She answer to the terrorism of the left and theright is not social and economic reform but police and militarylnWu~{0'g4

Wqghuvwdqgdeo~.ghvslwh vwdwhphqwvpdgh e~ Ouv0 Ctxlqr dqg wkhplolwdu~ hvwdeolvkphqw.wkh jryhuqphqw kdv ghqlhg wkdwlw kdvdgrswhg d "wrwdozdu" srolf~0 Tdwkhu.lwuhihuvwr d "wrwdodssurdfk"vwudwhj~lq ghdolqj zlwk wkhlqvxujhqf~0 Cffruglqj wrdq riilfldo uhsruw<

3;D0 ECTT dqg G0OEMC[. U`hKPVGPUKV[EQPHNKEV<VJGQT[ CPF RTCEVKEGKPEGPVTCNCOGTKECCPF UQoLKJ/GCUVCvKC ; (3;::)0

7!Ild.43EWTTGPVU.supra qrwh ;0 dw45044F0 D0 UJKTOGT dqg U0T0 UJCNQO0 VJG RJKNKRRKPGUTGCFGT 63; (3;:9)

(hpskdvlv vxssolhg)0

000wklv vwudwhj~ frqvlvwv ri wkuhh vlpxowdqhrxv dssurdfkhv wrlqvxujhqf~ / (3) Fhyhorsphqw. (4) Uhfxulw~ Qshudwlrqv. dqg (5)Thfrqfloldwlrq0 Fhyhorsphqw vhhnv wr hudglfdwh wkhurrw fdxvhv rilqvxujhqf~0 Uhfxulw~Qshudwlrqv surylgh wkhfrqglwlrqv ri vwdelolw~dqg d edvlf vlwxdwlrqri shdfh dqg rughu wr hqdeoh ghyhorsphqw wrsurfhhg zlwk wkhohdvwlqwhuuxswlrq0Thfrqfloldwlrq jlyhv wkhlqvxujhqwvdq krqrudeoh rswlrq wruhwxuqwrvrflhw~045

Vklv vkliw lq srolf~ kdv uhvxowhg lq wkh lqwhqvlilfdwlrq rifrxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~ rshudwlrqv0 Kwkdv dovr uhvxowhg lq dq lqwhqvhfdpsdljq ri lqwlplgdwlrq dqg kdudvvphqw dlphg dwqrq/jryhuqphqwdorujdql°dwlrqv vxvshfwhg ri ehlqj "frppxqlvw iurqwv0"46Vkh jryhuqphqw'v"wrwdozdu" dssurdfk lq frxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~ kdv. lq wkh h~hv ri wkhsrolfh dqg wkh plolwdu~. eoxuuhg wkh glvwlqfwlrq ehwzhhq odzixo qrq/ylrohqw rssrvlwlrq wr wkh jryhuqphqw dqg duphg rssrvlwlrq wr wkhUwdwh047Vkh vxssuhvvlrq ri odzixo rssrvlwlrq dqg wkhhqfrxudjhphqw ridfwvri uhsuhvvlrq. lqfoxglqj vhulrxv kxpdq uljkwv ylrodwlrqv. kdyh ehhqwkhlqhylwdeohfrqvhtxhqfhv0

Cqrwkhu dvshfw ri wkh"wrwdozdu" dssurdfk lv wkhlqfuhdvhg xvhri flyloldq sduwlflsdwlrq lq wkh frxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~ hiiruw0 Vkhuh duhuhsruwv ri wkh fuhdwlrq dqg surolihudwlrq ri Elyloldq Xroxqwhhu Uhoi/Fhihqvh Qujdql°dwlrqv (EXUFQv) dqg yljlodqwhjurxsv vsrqvruhg e~ wkhplolwdu~048 Vkhvh jurxsv kdyh ehhq dffxvhg ri ehlqj dprqj wkhpdmrushushwudwruvri kxpdq uljkwv ylrodwlrqv0 Kwzdv uhsruwhg wkdwwkhuhzhuh dssur}lpdwho~ 429 h}lvwlqj yljlodqwhjurxsv lq Uhswhpehu 3;::049

Vkxv. d kxpdq uljkwvprqlwrulqj jurxs uhsruwhg wkdw"]dbvri wkhhqg ri Cxjxvw 3;:9. lwkdv uhfrughg d wrwdori 427 pdmru duphg uljkw/zlqjflyloldq jurxsv lqfoxglqj idqdwlfdo jurxsv dqg edqglwv rshudwlqjqdwlrqzlgh0 Qi wklv.349 duh uljkw/zlqj yljlodqwh w~sh. 85 duh uholjlrxvidqdwlfdojurxsv. dqg 37 duh duphg edqglw jurxsv0"4:

452HHKEGQHVKoGRTGUUUGETGVCT[CPF FGRCTVOGPVQHPCVKQPCNFGHGPUG.CRTKOGTQP YKPPKPIVJGYCT CICKPUVKPUWTIGPE[5 (3;;3)0

46EWTTGPVU.supra qrwh ;0 Qq Pryhpehu 33 3;:9. d olvwdwwulexwhgwr wkhplolwdu~lqwhooljhqfh riilfh zdv sxeolvkhg lq zklfk 47 surplqhqw qrq/jryhuqphqwdo jurxsv zhuhdffxvhg ri ehlqj "frppxqlvw iurqwv0" Kqfoxghg dprqj wkhp zhuh wkhWqlwhgEkxufk riEkulvw lq wkh Rklolsslqhv. prvw qdwlrqdo kxpdq uljkwv jurxsv vxfk dv Vdvn HrufhFhwdlqhhv ri wkh Rklolsslqhv (VHFR) dqg wkh Rklolsslqh Cooldqfh ri Jxpdq TljkwvCgyrfdwhv. dqg wkhqdwlrq'v odujhvwwudghxqlrq dqg shdvdqwrujdql°dwlrqv0

47Cpqhvw~ Kqwhuqdwlrqdo. Vorkers, Guman Qights arid the ?gents of Ceath,PCooQPCNOKFYGGM.Cxjxvw 36. 3;;3. s0 3:0

26/d. Ree Erpp0 rq Lxvwlfhdqg Jxpdq Tljkwv. U0Tsw0 rq Xljlodqwh Iurxsv. :wkErqjr (3;::) ]khuhlqdiwhuXljlodqwhThsruwb0

49EWTTGPVU.supra qrwh;04:[ljlodqwh Thsruw. supra qrwh 48. dw:0

Cqrwkhuhvvhqwldofrpsrqhqw ri wkhfrxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~ vwudwhj~dqg dq riwhq/flwhg vrxufh ri kxpdq uljkwv ylrodwlrqv duh wkhsdudplolwdu~jurxsv0 Cowkrxjk wkhqrwrulrxv Elyloldq Jrph FhihqvhHrufhv(EJFHv) ri wkhOdufrv uhjlph zhuh glvedqghg lq 3;::. wkh~zhuhuhsodfhg e~ dqrwkhu sdudplolwdu~ jurxs/wkh Elyloldq Cuphg HrufhvIhrjudsklfdo Wqlwv(ECHIWv) zklfk kdg dq lqlwldophpehuvkls ri67.22204;

Vkh Eklhi ri Uwdii ri wkh Cuphg Hrufhv kdv dovr lvvxhgjxlgholqhv rq wkhirupdwlrq ri wkhUshfldo ECHIW Cfwlyh Cx}loldu~(UECC)0 Vkh frqfhsw ri wkhUECC. dffruglqj wr wkhgluhfwlyh.lv dviroorzv<

Cootxdolilhg yroxqwhhuuhvhuXlvwvjdlqixoo~ hpsor~hg e~ gxo~ dffuhglwhgexvlqhvv hvwdeolvkphqwvzlwklq d sduwlfxodu orfdolw~ pd~ eh fdoohgxsrq xqghu vhohfwlyh prelol°dwlrq wruhqghu dx}loldu~ vhuylfh wr phhworfdo hphujhqf~ vlwxdwlrqv0vxfk dv civil disturbances, qdwxudofdodplwlhv dqg insurgency. Lxvwolnh wkhuhjxodu ECC. lw vkdoofrpsohphqw wkhCHR uhjxodu xqlwvdv Cfwlyh Cx}loldu~0 Shey shall beprovided with military type weapons for the purpose,30 (Gpskdvlvvxssolhg0)

Hxuwkhupruh. zkloh wkhjxlgholqhv surylgh wkdwwkh UECCvvkdooeh xvhg sulqflsdoo~ wr ghihqg exvlqhvv hvwdeolvkphqwvdjdlqvwh}wruwlrq iurp wkh Phz Rhrsoh'v Cup~ dqg wkh Orur PdwlrqdoNlehudwlrqHurqw.wkhUECCv kdyh ehhq dffxvhg ri kdudvvlqj. dqg hyhqnloolqj. wudghxqlrqlvwv053 Erqvlghulqj wkdwudglfdowudghxqlrqv kdyhriwhq ehhq wdjjhg dv frppxqlvw iurqw rujdql°dwlrqv. wkhdqwl/oderudfwlylwlhvri wkhUECCv kdyh ehhq mxvwlilhgdv sduwri wkh ohjlwlpdwhfrxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~ hiiruwvri wkhplolwdu~0

Vkh wklugdvshfw ri wkh"wrwdozdu" dssurdfk lv wkhhvfdodwlrqri plolwdu~rshudwlrqv lq wkhfrxqwu~vlghvfrqvlvwlqj ri dhuldoerpelqjv.vwudilqjvdqg pruwdu erpedugphqwv0 Vkhremhfwlyhri wkhvhrshudwlrqvlvwrioxvkrxwwkhlqvxujhqwvdqg wrghsulyh wkhp ri wkhlupdvv edvh0Vkhvhrshudwlrqv kdyh uhvxowhglq wkhirufhg pdvv hydfxdwlrqv ri flyloldqvuhvlglqj lq wkhduhdvri rshudwlrqv0 Phhgohvv wrvwdwh.wkhuhdoylfwlpvduhwkhflyloldqv fdxjkw lq wkhfurvviluhri duphg frqiolfw0

Vkxv. iurp Ldqxdu~3;:: wrUhswhpehu 3;:;. wkhKqwhuqdwlrqdoErpplwwhh ri wkhThg Eurvv uhqghuhg uholhivhuylfhvwr3;6.956 lqwhuqdo

4;EWTTGPVU.supra qrwh ;. dw46052T0 G0Coirqvr. Lu0.'Rpecial' B?EFTR UR. Srade Tnions, PCVKQPCNOKFYGGM.

Od~ 4. 3;;2. s0 :031Hd.

uhixjhhv054 Qwkhuqrq/jryhuqphqwdo rujdql°dwlrqv kdyh grfxphqwhg dvpdq~ dv 622.222 lqwhuqdouhixjhhv055 Kwkdv ehhq hvwlpdwhgwkdwpruhwkdqrqh ploolrq shrsoh kdyh ehhq glvsodfhg e~ wkhjryhuqphqw'v "wrwdozdu" dssurdfk056

Cowkrxjk Ouv0 Ctxlqr. gxulqj wkh wlph wkdwvkh h}huflvhgohjlvodwlyhsrzhu lq wkhhduo~gd~v ri khu whqxuh.kdg douhdg~uhshdohgvhyhudouhsuhvvlyhvwdwxwhvsurpxojdwhg gxulqj wkhOdufrv uhjlph. vwloolq hiihfw duh fhuwdlqodzv wkdwsxw lq grxew wkhsuhvhqwjryhuqphqw'vuhvroyhwrvdihjxdug kxpdq uljkwv057

RuhvlghqwldoFhfuhh Pr0 3:88 surylghv iru d yhu~ vwliishqdow~iru "loohjdosrvvhvvlrq ri iluhdupv. dppxqlwlrq dqg1ru h}sorvlyhv lqixuwkhudqfhri uhehoolrq. lqvxuuhfwlrq ru vxeyhuvlrq0" Erqvlghulqj wkdwwkhfulph ri uhehoolrq0lv pruh gliilfxow wr suryh. wkdwshuvrqv irxqgjxlow~ ri uhehoolrq zhuh. xqwlowkhdphqgphqw ri wkh odz. phwhg doljkwhu shqdow~. dqg wkdwxqghu Rklolsslqh mxulvsuxghqfh uhehoolrqdevruev frpprq fulphv.58wkhjryhuqphqw'v survhfxwruvkdyh uhvruwhgwrfkdujlqj lqvxujhqwv xqghu wklvghfuhh lq olhx ri fkdujlqj wkhp zlwkuhehoolrq0 Vkxv. dq lqvxujhqw lv riwhq uhsruwhg dssuhkhqghg zlwk diluhdup ru juhqdgh. zklfk lv fodlphg e~ wkrvh duuhvwhgwr kdyh ehhq

54GEWOGPKECNOQXGOGPV HQTLWUVKEGCPF RGCEGdqgVKoGRJuWRRKPGCNWCPEGHQTJWOCP TKIoKVUCFXQECVGU.GZQFWUHTQOEQWPVGTKPUWTIGPE[YCTHCTG<TGRQTVQH VJG KPVGTPCVKQPCNHCEV/HKPFKPIOKUUKQPQP KPVGTPCNTGHWIGGUQH VJGRpxRRKPGv: (3;;2)0

331d.; rwkhuPIQv dvvlvwhgwkhlqwhuqdouhixjhhv0 Elwl°hqv Flvdvwhudqg ThkdelolwdwlrqEhqwhu grfxphqwhg 652.3:8 lqwhuqdouhixjhhv0 Gfxphqlfdo Erpplvvlrq iru FlvsodfhgHdplolhv dqg Erppxqlwlhv dvvlvwhg3:8.952 dqg wkhGfxphqlfdo Oryhphqw iru LxvwlfhdqgRhdfh uhjlvwhuhg686.874 uhixjhhv0

56Vkh Odqlod Ekurqlfoh. Fhf0 KK.3;;3. s0 9057Ctxlqr lvvxhg dprqj rwkhuv<G}hf0 Qughu Pr0 7;. uhshdolqj Ruhv0Fhfuhh Prv0 3626.

3:58. 3:99 dqg 3:99/C (3;:8). zklfk dxwkrul°hg orqjhu shulrgv ri gholyhu~ ri duuhvwhgshuvrqv (e~ wkhiruphu Ruhvlghqw)xqghu R0 F0 3626> wkhsuhvlghqwldo rughu ri duuhvwrufrpplwphqw rughu xqghu R0F0 3:58> dqg wkhsuhyhqwlyhghwhqwlrqdfwlrq xqghu R0F0 3:99.dv dphqghg e~ R0F0 3:99/C> G}hf0 Qughu Pr0 389 zklfk uhylyhg Thsxeolf Cfw Pr0 3922Gqwlwohg"Cq Cfw wr Qxwodz Vkh Erppxqlvw Rduw~ri wkh Rklolsslqhv dqg UlploduCvvrfldwlrqv. Rhqdol°lqj Ohpehuvkls Vkhuhlq dqg Hru QwkhuRxusrvhv" dqg uhshdohg R0F03:57. hqwlwohg."Ergli~lqj Vkh Xdulrxv Ndzv rq Cqwl/Uxeyhuvlrq dqg Kqfuhdvlqj wkhRhqdowlhviru Ohpehuvkls lq Uxeyhuvlyh Qujdql°dwlrq"> dqg G}hf0 Qughu Pr0 3:9. uhshdolqjRuhvlghqwldoFhfuhhv Prv0 5:.;64.;92. 3957. 3:56. 3;96. dqg 3;;8 dqg Cuwlfohv364/Ddqg 364/D ri wkhThylvhg RhqdoErgh dqg uhvwrulqj Cuwlfohv357. 358. 359. 35:. 362 363.364.365.366.368.369.399.39:. dqg 39; wr HxooHrufh dqg Giihfw dv Vkh~ G}lvwhgDhiruh Udlg Cphqgdwru~ Fhfuhhv (3;:9). zklfk uhvwruhgwkhruljlqdo shqdowlhviru srolwlfdoriihqvhv0 Jrzhyhu. wkhRklolsslqh Erqjuhvv lq Ths0 Cfw Pr0 8;8: (3;;2) djdlq lqfuhdvhgwkhshqdowlhviru wkhvhriihqvhv0

58Rhrsohy0 Jhuqdqgh°. ;; Rklo0737 (3;78)> Rhrsohy0 Ihurqlpr. 322 Rklo0;2(3;78)> Gploh y0 Udod°du.3:8 UETC 439 (3;;2)0

"sodqwhg" e~ wkh duuhvwlqj riilfhuv. mxvwvr wkdwwkhvxvshfw fdq ehfkdujhg xqghu wklvghfuhh zklfk surylghv iru d juhdwhushqdow~0

Oruh gluhfwo~uhodwhgwrwkhpdwwhuri vhhnlqj uhguhvviru kxpdquljkwv ylrodwlrqv lv wkhmxulvglfwlrqri wkhfrxuwv0 RuhvlghqwldoFhfuhhPr0 3:72 judqwv frxuwv pduwldo h}foxvlyh mxulvglfwlrq ryhu fulphvfrpplwwhg e~ phq lq wkhplolwdu~.dowkrxjk wkhRuhvlghqwpd~ zdlyhwklv mxulvglfwlrq lq idyru ri flyloldq frxuwv0 Erqvlghulqj wkdwwkhpdmrulw~ri kxpdq uljkwvdexvhv duhfrpplwwhg e~ phq lq xqlirup. wklvghfuhh kdv hiihfwlyho~suhyhqwhgwkhwuldori kxpdq uljkwvfdvhv ehiruhflyloldq frxuwv dqg kdv uhqghuhg qxjdwru~ wkhlpsduwldodssolfdwlrq rifrqvwlwxwlrqdodqg vwdwxwru~jxdudqwhhv rq wkhsurwhfwlrq ri kxpdquljkwv0 Kwzdv rqo~ yhu~ uhfhqwo~wkdwwklvghfuhh zdv uhshdohg e~Erqjuhvv059

Oruhryhu. wkhUxsuhph Erxuw kdv xskhog wkhydolglw~ri wkhzduudqwohvvvhdufkdqg duuhvwri shuvrqv vxvshfwhgri ehlqj vxeyhuvlyhvrqwkhjurxqg wkdwvxeyhuvlrq lv d frqwlqxlqj riihqvh05: Kwkdvehhq uhsruwhgwkdwdv d uhvxowri wklvuxolqj. 3.296 "loohjdo"duuhvwvdqg ghwhqwlrqvzhuh pdgh lq wkhshulrg iurp Lxo~wr Fhfhpehu 3;;2 lq OhwursrolwdqOdqlod dorqh05; Vkh Uxsuhph Erxuwkdv dovr xskhog wkhohjdolw~ri wkhhvwdeolvkphqwri srolfh dqg plolwdu~fkhfnsrlqwv lq wkhphwursrolv06rKwkdv dovr ydolgdwhg wkh "°rqlqj" rshudwlrqv ru vdwxudwlrqgulyhvfrqgxfwhg e~ wkhsrolfh dqg plolwdu~lq voxp frppxqlwlhv wrioxvk rxwfrpprq fulplqdov dqg "vxeyhuvlyhv0"6w

Cqrwkhuodz surpxojdwhg gxulqj wkhOdufrv uhjlph exwvwloolqhiihfw lv DdwdvRdpedqvd Dlj0 ::2 ru wkhRxeolf Cvvhpeo~ Cfw. zklfkuhtxluhv d zulwwhqshuplw ehiruh dq~ pdvv dfwlylw~fdq eh khog lq d sxeolfsodfh dqg doorzv wkhglvshuvdori udoolhvzlwkrxwshuplwv064

59Ruhv0Ctxlqr vljqhg0 Ths0 Cfw 9277 hqwlwohg"Cq Cfw Uwuhqjwkhqlqj ElyloldqUxsuhpdf~ Qyhu Vkh Ololwdu~D~ Thwxuqlqj Vr wkhElylo Erxuwv wkhLxulvglfwlrq QyhuEhuwdlq Qiihqvhv Kqyroylqj Ohpehuv Qi wkhCuphg Hrufhv Qi Vkh Rklolsslqhv. QwkhuRhuvrqv UxemhfwVr Ololwdu~Ndz. Cqg Vkh Ohpehuv Qi Vkh Rklolsslqh Pdwlrqdo Rrolfh.Thshdolqj Hru Vkh Rxusrvh EhuwdlqRuhvlghqwldoFhfuhhv" odvwLxqh 42. 3;;30

5:Wplo y0 Tdprv. 3:9 UETC 533 (3;;2)> see also Qolyhurv. Nne Xearo/Varrantless?rrests, PCVKQPCNOKFYGGM.Cxjxvw 9.3;;3. s0 3;0

°/d.6rXdlprqwh y0 Fh Xlood. 39: UETC 433 (3;:;)> see also She Ohilippine Guman

Qights Rituation: C Kook into the Rtate's Nbligations, RJKNKRRKPGJWOCP TKIJiU WRFCVGPryhpehu KU/Fhfhpehu 36.3;;2. s0 360

63Ixd°rq y0 Fh Xlood. 3:3 UETC 845 (3;;2)042She Ohilippine GTrruInQights Rituation: I Kook into the Rtate's Nbligations

]khuhlqdiwhuRituationl, RoooNKRRKL'.'GJWOCP TKIJiU WRFCVG]khuhlqdiwhuRJTWo. PryhpehuKU/Fhfhpehu 36.3;;2. s0 360

Ndvwo~.Ruhv0Ctxlqr lvvxhg G}hfxwlyhQughuPr0 434 dphqglqjRF 38; zklfk uhtxluhv sk~vlfldqv zkr kdyh wuhdwhgshuvrqv zlwkvhulrxv sk~vlfdo lqmxulhvwr uhsruw vxfk wuhdwphqwwr wkhRklolsslqhErqvwdexodu~065KqvwhdgrL uhsruwlqj vxfk wuhdwphqwwrwkhRklolsslqhErqvwdexodu~.G}hfxwlyhQughuPr0 434 qrz uhtxluhvsk~vlfldqv wruhsruwwr wkh qhduhvwjryhuqphqw khdowkdxwkrulw~dqg vxfk uhsruw. xsrqzulwwhquhtxhvw.vkdooeh pdgh dydlodeohwrodz hqirufhphqw djhqflhv066Vklv qhz odz lv qrw uhdoo~gliihuhqwiurp RF 38;. vlqfh phglfdo uhsruwvzloo vwlooeh uhtxluhg ri sk~vlfldqv dqg zloo eh ixuqlvkhg wr odzhqirufhphqw djhqflhv0 Oruhryhu. wkhsurpxojdwlrq ri lpsohphqwlqjuhjxodwlrqve~ wkhUhfuhwdu~ri Jhdowk kdv wreh lq frqvxowdwlrqzlwkwkhRklolsslqh Erqvwdexodu~67

Edvhvri kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqvzhuh dwlwvorzhvwlq 3;:8 dqglw shdnhg lq 3;:9 dqg 3;::. iroorzlqj wkh froodsvh ri wkh shdfhqhjrwldwlrqv zlwk wkhfrppxqlvw lqvxujhqf~0 Vdvn Hrufh Fhwdlqhhvriwkh Rklolsslqhv (VHFR).68d fkxufk/edvhg kxpdq uljkwv prqlwrulqjrujdql°dwlrq. uhsruwhg wkdwwkhuhzdv d ghfolqh lq kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqvgxulqj wkhiluvwkdoiri 3;;3 frpsduhg wrd vlplodu shulrg odvw~hdu069 Kwdovr qrwhg wkdwwkhuhzdv d ghfolqh odvw~hdu lq uhsruwhgylrodwlrqv frpsduhg wr 3;:; zklfk zdv dwwulexwhgwr wkhghfolqh lqplolwdu~rshudwlrqv. uhvxowlqjiurp d odujh sruwlrq ri wkhplolwdu~ehlqjnhsw lqvlgh wkheduudfnv diwhuwkhprvw vhulrxv frxs dwwhpswlq 3;:;06:Cqrwkhuuhdvrq dgydqfhg zdv wkh"oxoo"lq sxeolf surwhvwv06;

Cffruglqj wrVHFR.wkhduuhvwdqg ghwhqwlrqfdvhvuhsruwhgiurpwkhwlphOuv0Ctxlqr ehfdph Ruhvlghqwlq 3;:8 xs wrUhswhpehu52. 3;;3wrwdoohg3;.289072 Vklv h}fhhghg e~ 8.588 wkhqxpehu ri fdvhv uhsruwhg

65G}hf0 Qughu Pr0 434. Cphqglqj RuhvlghqwldoFhfuhh Pr0 38; (3;:9)> Erpp0 rqLxvwlfhdqg Jxpdq Tljkwv. Jxpdq Tljkwv Ulwxdwlrqlq wkhRklolsslqhv. U0Tsw0 3247. :wkEfqj0 (3;;2)0

441d.45/d.68VHFR pdlqwdlqv d qdwlrqzlgh qhwzrun ri wudlqhg zrunhuv dqg v~vwhpdwlf

g2fxphqwdwlrq surfhgxuhv0 Hru doovxevhtxhqw vwdwlvwlfdoiljxuhv. sohdvh uhihu wr VHFR'vprqwko~ sxeolfdwlrq RJTW dqg shulrglf UwdwlvwlfdoThsruw rq Jxpdq Tljkwv Xlrodwlrqv]khuhlqdiwhuUwdwlvwlfvb0

47Guman Qights Rituation: Eor the Eirst Galf of 3;;3.8 RJTW. Lxo~ 37/Cxjxvw 36.3;;3 Rs0 :0

48ld.I\T1o050Ree Uwdwlvwlfv0

gxulqj wkh odvwwkuhh~hduv ri Ou0 Odufrv' uxoh0 Vkh jryhuqphqwdwwulexwhvwklvlqfuhdvhg qxpehu ri uhsruwhgfdvhv wrwkhuhvwrudwlrqriiuhhgrp ri wkhsuhvvdqg wkhpruh olehudodffhvvwrlqirupdwlrq073

Orvwri wkhfdvhvri duuhvwvzhuh pdvv duuhvwv.grqh gxulqj surwhvwghprqvwudwlrqvdqg udoolhvdqg vdwxudwlrqgulyhv rq voxp frppxqlwlhvvxvRhEwhgri kduerulqj frppxqlvw uhehov074

Ykloh ghwhqwlrqiroorzlqj d pdvv duuhvwzdv xvxdoo~rqo~ iru dvkruwgxudwlrq. qhyhuwkhohvv.wkrvhghwdlqhgidfhg wkhulvnri wruwxuhrusk~vlfdo dexvh0 Vkhuh zdv dovr wkhjudyh gdqjhu ri lqyroxqwdu~glvdsshdudqfh iroorzlqj dq duuhvw0

Ukruw/whup ghwhqwlrq kdv dovr ehhq xvhg dv d phdqv ri/wkuhdwhqlqjru lqwlplgdwlqj wkrvhzkr rssrvh wkhjryhuqphqw0 Kqvrphfdvhv. wkrvhghwdlqhgzhuh uhohdvhgrqo~ diwhuwkh~vljqhg grfxphqwvvwdwlqjwkdwwkh~zhuh uhehovxuuhqghuhhv075

VHFR dovr uhsruwhg wkdwdv ri Uhswhpehu52. 3;;3 wkhuhzhuhvwloo92: srolwlfdosulvrqhuvxqghu ghwhqwlrq076

Gyhq li wkhodz uhtxluhv wkdwshuvrqv duuhvwhgeh eurxjkw ehiruhmxglfldodxwkrulwlhvzlwklq d vshflilhg qxpehu ri krxuv ghshqglqj xsrqwkhfulph fkdujhg. wklvuhtxluhphqw lv qrw uholjlrxvo~ iroorzhg lq doofdvhv077 Odq~ wlphv.d shuvrq lvghwdlqhgzlwkrxwhyhq ehlqj lqiruphg riklv uljkwvru ri wkhdffxvdwlrq djdlqvwklp078 Rklolsslqh mxulvsuxghqfhuhtxluhv wkdwwkhfrqvwlwxwlrqdouljkwvri wkhdffxvhg eh h}sodlqhg wrklp ehiruh d zulwwhqvwdwhphqwlv wdnhqiurp klp0

Vruwxuhlv "dq~ dfw zklfk lqiolfwvvhyhuh sdlq ru vxiihulqj.zkhwkhu sk~vlfdo ru phqwdo.rq d shuvrq. dwwkhlqvwljdwlrqri ru zlwk

732HHKEGQHVKKGRTGvv UGETGiCT[ CPF RJooLRRKPGEQOOKUUKQPQP JWOCP TKIoKVU.C RTKOGTQPVKKGJWOCP TKIKKVUKUUWGKPVKKGRJuWRRKPGU34/35 (3;;3)0

52She Shree-Xear Guman Qights Qecord of the ?quino Fovernment ]khuhlqdiwhuQecord], 7 RJTW. Pry 37/Fhf 36. 3;:;. s0 32>Rituation, supra qrwh 64. dw370

75EWTTGPVU. supra qrwh ;. dw47054Rituation., supra qrwh64. dw38055Qecord,5 RJTW. Pry 37/Fhh 36. 3;:;. s0 32>G}hf0 Qughu Pr0 494 vshflilhv wkdw

dssuhkhqghg shuvrqv pxvw eh surgxfhg lq frxuw diwhu34 krxuv iru fulphv sxqlvkdeoh e~oljkw shqdowlhv. 3: krxuv iru fulphv sxqlvkdeoh e~ fruuhfwlrqdo shqdowlhvdqg 58 krxuv irufulphv sxqlvkdeoh e~ fdslwdoshqdowlhv0

56ld.

wkhfrqvhqw ri d sxeolf riilfldo ru rwkhu shuvrq dfwlqj lq dq riilfldofd sd fl w~0"79 Kwpd~ eh sudfwlfhg wr rewdlq lqirupdwlrq. wr h}wudfwdfrqihvvlrq. dv d sxqlvkphqw iru dq~ dfwxdoru lpdjlqhg riihqvh rudfwlylw~.wr euhdn rqh'v vslulwru irufh rqh wr uhqrxqfh klv sulqflsohv.srolwlfdoeholhivdqg diiloldwlrqv.ru wrvwliohglvvhqwdqg rssrvlwlrq07:

Cowkrxjk rq d ghfolqh. wruwxuhvwloouhpdlqv d suhvvlqj kxpdquljkwvsureohp lq wkhRklolsslqhv0 VHFRuhsruwhg4.978 fdvhv ri wruwxuhiru wkhshulrg iurp Odufk K.3;:8 xs wrUhswhpehu52. 3;;w07;Vklvzrxogfrqvwlwxwhurxjko~ 37% ri wkrvh duuhvwhgdqg ghwdlqhg iru srolwlfdouhdvrqv0Vruwxuhxvxdoo~wdnhvwkhirup ri vhyhuhehdwlqjv. zdwhufxuh.hohfwulfvkrfnv. vwdeelqjv.vxiirfdwlrq. vh}xdodexvh dqg wkuhdwvri ghdwkru lqmxu~wr oryhg rqhv082 Vruwxuhlv riwhqxvhg wrh}wudfwlqirupdwlrq ruwhvwlprqlhviurp ghwdlqhhv.xvxdoo~dv uhjdugv wkhluru rwkhushuvrqv'phpehuvkls lq wkhfrppxqlvw sduw~ru lq wkhPhz Rhrsoh'v Cup~ ru dvuhjdugv sduwlflsdwlrq lq vxeyhuvlyh dfwlylwlhv0

Vhvwlprqlhvri ylfwlpv lqglfdwhwkdwlqflghqwvri wruwxuhxvxdoo~rffxuuhg gxulqj incommunicado ghwhqwlrqlq plolwdu~"vdihkrxvhv" dqglq rwkhusodfhv lq ru qhdu plolwdu~khdgtxduwhuv083

C wrwdori 49; lqglylgxdov glvdsshduhg iurp 3;:8 wrUhswhpehu52.3;;3084 Hurp Ldqxdu~3;;2 wrUhswhpehu52. 3;;3 dorqh. wkhuhzhuh :2zkr glvdsshduhg diwhuehlqj duuhvwhgdqg 42 zkr glvdsshduhg zlwkrxwuhfrug ri dq~ duuhvw085

C wrwdori 389 shuvrqv zdv uhsruwhg e~ VHFR wr kdyh ehhq"vdoydjhg" ru h}wud/mxglfldoo~h}hfxwhg086 Cpqhvw~ Kqwhuqdwlrqdouhsruwv522 vxfk fdvhvvlqfh wkhehjlqqlqj ri 3;:;087 Prwzlwkvwdqglqjwkhglvfuhsdqf~ lq wkhqxpehu ri uhsruwhgfdvhv. wkhidfwuhpdlqv wkdwwkhlqflghqfh ri h}wud/mxglfldoh}hfxwlrqvuhpdlqv d judyh sureohp0

79HTGGNGICNCUUKUVCPEGITQWR.TY`h [QWT TKIKKVU37/38 (3;:8)058Hd.,dw38059Qecord,5 RJTW. Pry 37/Fhf 36. 3;:;. s0 32>Rituation, supra qrwh 64. dw37>

Uwdwlvwlfv08QEWTTGPVU.supra qrwh ;. dw48061Hd.({lHd.

63Rituation,supra qrwh 64. dw38>Uwdwlvwlfv064Qecord, 7 RJTW. Pry 37/Fhf 36. 3;:;. s0 32>Rituation, supra qrwh 64. dw38>

Uwdwlvwlfv087Cpqhvw~ Kqwhuqdwlrqdo.Vorkers, Guman Qights and the ?gents of Ceath,

PCVKQPCNOKFYGGM.Cxjxvw 43. 3;;3. s0 360

Cprqj wkhfdvhv ri h}wud/mxglfldonloolqjvuhsruwhge~ Cpqhvw~Kqwhuqdwlrqdoduh wkrvh lqyroylqj kxpdq uljkwv dfwlylvwv.shdvdqwv.mrxuqdolvwv.fkxufk zrunhuv. wudghxqlrqlvwvdqg flyloldqvolylqj lq duhdvri vxvshfwhg uheho dfwlylw~088Prwdeoh fdvhv lqfoxgh wkhnloolqj ri<Trodqgr Qodold. khdg ri wkhohiwlvwMloxvdqj Od~r Wqr (Od~ HluvwOryhphqw) wudghxqlrq>89 Nhdqgur Cohmdqgur.vhfuhwdu~/jhqhudo/riDdjrqj Co~dqvdqj Odnded~dq (Phz PdwlrqdolvwCooldqfh). d pdmruohiwlvwsrolwlfdosduw~>dqg vhyhudokxpdq uljkwvodz~huv0

Vkhfrppxqlvw Phz Rhrsoh'vCup~ kdv dovruhvruwhgwrvhohfwlyhh}hfxwlrqv dv sduwri wkhlusursdjdqgd vwudwhj~0 Rrolfh dqg plolwdu~riilfhuv. orfdo jryhuqphqw riilfldov dqg sur/jryhuqphqw flyloldqv kdyhehhq dvvdvvlqdwhglq xuedq duhdve~ vr/fdoohg"vsduurz xqlwv."zklfk duhvtxdgv ri ~rxqj phq dqg zrphq duphg zlwkkdqgjxqv zkr mxvwidgh lqwrwkhsrsxodwlrq diwhud nloo0

Vkrvh uhvsrqvleoh iru h}wud/mxglfldoh}hfxwlrqv kdyh odujho~hvfdshg frqylfwlrq0 Cpqhvw~ Kqwhuqdwlrqdouhsruwvwkdwiurp 3;:8 xs wrplg/3;;2 rqo~ 65 srolfh dqg plolwdu~shuvrqqho kdyh ehhq frqylfwhg irukxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqv08:

Mloolqjvduhfrqvlghuhg pdvvdfuhv li lq d vlqjoh lqflghqwwkuhhrupruh shuvrqv duh nloohge~ jryhuqphqw irufhv ru wkrvhdfwlqj rq wkhluehkdoi08; Hurp 3;:8 xs wrUhswhpehu52. 3;;3. 375 pdvvdfuhv kdyh ehhquhsruwhgzklfk kdyh uhvxowhglq 965 ghdg dqg 4;9 zrxqghg09r Hruwkhvdph shulrg. wkhuhkdyh ehhq 3:4 vlplodu lqflghqwv zkhuh ohvvwkdqwkuhhshuvrqv kdyh glhg'B!

88Uhh COPGUV[ KPVGTPCVKQPCN.3;;3 COPGUV[ KPVGTPCVKQPCNTGRQTV (3;;3)]khuhlqdiwhuCKTGRQTVb0

9?Ree Cpqhvw~ KqwhuqdwlrqdoThsruw dv uhsruwhg lq PCVKQPCNOKFYGGM.Cxjxvw 36.43. 4:. 3;;30

8:Jrzhyhu. Cpqhvw~ Kqwhuqdwlrqdouhsruwhgwkdwlwzdv xqfohdu zkhwkhu dookdg lq idfwehhq frqylfwhg ri kxpdq uljkwv/uhodwhgriihqvhv ru iru frpprq fulphv0 Qwkhuwkdqwkhwzrolvwhge~ wkhdxwkrulwlhv.qr rwkhu phpehu ri wkhsrolfh ru plolwdu~ zdv nqrzq wr kdyhehhq frqylfwhg ri kxpdq uljkwv riihqvhv lq 3;;20 C plolwdu~ riilfhu dffxvhg ri nloolqjoderu ohdghuTrodqgr Qodoldlq 3;:8 zdv dftxlwwhgdiwhud wkuhh/~hduwuldo>rwkhuvdffxvhg lqwkhvdph fdvh zhqw lqwr klglqj ru zhuh jlyhq lppxqlw~ wr whvwli~iru wkhvwdwh0Urphdoohjhg ylrodwlrqv zhuh riilfldoo~ lqyhvwljdwhgexw jhqhudoo~ wkhilqglqjv zhuh qrw pdghsxeolf> CKTGRQTV.supra qrwh 88. dw3::0

8;ExTTGPVU.supra qrwh ; dw4:07oQecord, U RJTW. Pry 3U/Fhf 36. 3;:;. s0 3407!ld.

Hrufhg pdvv hydfxdwlrq uhihuvwr wkhglvsodfhphqw ri yloodjhvdqg frppxqlwlhv. uhjdugohvv ri whuulwruldoerxqgdulhv. jhrsrolwlfdoglylvlrqv dqg qxpehu ri shuvrqv diihfwhg0A5 Wvxdoo~.shuvrqv diihfwhgohdyh wkhlu frppxqlwlhv ehfdxvh ri lqwhqvlyh frxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~rshudwlrqv frqgxfwhg e~ jryhuqphqw irufhv0 Kqvrph fdvhv. shrsoh duhirufhg wr hydfxdwhehfdxvh ri wkhkdudvvphqwgrqh e~ duphg jurxsvfrqqhfwhg zlwk wkhplolwdu~095

Uwudwhjlfkdpohwwlqj uhihuv wr wkh plolwdu~ vwudwhj~rifrqwuroolqjorfdolqvxujhqf~ e~ uhorfdwlqjfrppxqlwlhv wrduhdvxqghu lwvfrqwurolq rughu wrghsulyh wkhlqvxujhqwvri wkhlupdvv edvh dqg vxssruwvwuxfwxuhv096

Xlfwlpv ri irufhg pdvv hydfxdwlrqvdqg vwudwhjlfkdpohwwlqjduhuhihuuhgwrdv "lqwhuqdouhixjhhv0" Vkh~ duh shuvrqv zkr ioh• wrd sodfhri vdihw~ zlwklq wkhlurzq frxqwu~ zlwkrxw furvvlqj lqwhuqdwlrqdoerughuv0B7

Cv wkhjryhuqphqw lqwhqvlilhvlwvfrxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~ hiiruwv.wkhqxpehu ri lqwhuqdouhixjhhv frqwlqxhv wr jurz0 Vkh~ duh irufhg wrhydfxdwh wr fuxgh uhixjhh fhqwhuvzkhuh edvlf vhuylfhv duh hlwkhuplqlpdo ru qrq/h}lvwhqw0 Gvwlpdwhvydu~.udqjlqj iurp d orz ri 3:8.952wr d kljk ri 686.874 shuvrqv diihfwhg iurp 3;:8 xs wr 3;;2098 Vkhvhqxpehuv duhghilqlwho~doduplqj. ghvslwhwkhglvfuhsdqf~0 Vkh vlwxdwlrqehfrphv hyhq pruh vhulrxvli zh frqvlghu wkhqxpehu ri fkloguhqzkr glhiurp glvhdvhdqg pdoqxwulwlrqlq wkhvhhydfxdwlrq fdpsv0

Vkh prvw sxeolfl°hg fdvhvri irufhg hydfxdwlrqv duhwkrvhlq wkhsurylqfh ri Phjurv Qfflghqwdo lq 3;:; zkhuh 479 fkloguhq glhg lqhydfxdwlrq fdpsv diwhu wkh plolwdu~ odxqfkhg wkh "QshudwlrqVkxqghuerow"dqg wkhhydfxdwlrqv wkdwuhvxowhgiurp wkhOdudj Xdooh~riihqvlyh lq 3;;2/;3 zkhuh 96 fkloguhq uhsruwhgo~glhg ri phdvohvlq wkh

94Jxpdq Tljkwv Erpplwwhh ri wkh Pdwlrqdo Erxqflo ri Ekxufkhv lq wkh Rklolsslqhv.Rrolf~ Uwxg~ rq KqwhuqdoThixjhhv 4 (Pry0 38. 3;:;) (plphrjudskhg)0

73ld.741d.75lnternal Qefugees in Megros uhsulqwhg iurp MCDCNKMCV<VJG FGXGNQROGPV

YQTMGT. Uhswhpehu 3;:;. s0 4098GfWOGPKECN OQXGOGPV HQT LWUVKEGCPF RGCEG dqg VJG RpWRRKPG CNNKCPEG

HQT JWOCP TKIKKVUCFXQECVGU. GZQFWU HTQO EQWPVGTKPUWTIGPE[ YCTHCTG< TGRQTVQH VJG KPVGTPCVKQPCN HCEV/HKPFKPI OKUUKQP QP KPVGTPCN TGHWIGGU QH VKoGRpWRRKPGU 3; (3;;2)0

fdyhv zkhuh wkh~vrxjkw uhixjh099 Vkh plolwdu~kdv odxqfkhg d ixoo/vfdoh riihqvlyh djdlqvw frppxqlvw uhehov qxpehulqj pruh wkdq dwkrxvdqg zkr kdyh uhsruwhgo~vhwxs d uhyroxwlrqdu~jryhuqphqw dqg dwudlqlqj edvh lq wkhydooh~0

Cqrwkhuwdfwlfdoohjhgwrkdyh ehhq hpsor~hg e~ wkhplolwdu~lvwkhvhwwlqjxs ri irrg eorfndghv0 Vkh KqwhjudwhgDduri wkhRklolsslqhvkdv uhfhqwo~xujhg Ouv0Ctxlqr wrrughu d vwrs wrirrg eorfndghv09: Kweudqghg dv "loohjdodqg xqfrqvwlwxwlrqdo"Ohpr ElufxoduPr0 35;. zklfkdxwkrul°hvwkhCuphg Hrufhvri wkhRklolsslqhv wrvwrs wkh gholyhu~riirrg dqg rwkhuylwdovhuylfhvlq frqiolfwduhdv09;Cv ri Uhswhpehu3;;3. 49irrg eorfndghv kdyh ehhq grfxphqwhg diihfwlqj d wrwdori 657lqglylgxdov dqg 4.7;5 idplolhv.:r Qqo~ irrg dqg vxssolhv vxiilflhqwiruwkhdfwxdouhvlghqwvri d frppxqlw~ duh doorzhg wr hqwhuwkhduhd wrsuhyhqw wkhlqvxujhqwv iurp ehlqj vxssolhg zlwk irrg e~ wkhorfdosrsxodfh0 Thvlghqwv zhuh frqvwdqwo~lqyhvwljdwhg rq wkhlu irrgsxufkdvhv dqg rughuhg wr suhvhqwuhvlghqfh fhuwlilfdwhvdv fohdudqfhirupv iru wudqvsruwlqjirrg0:3

Qi wkh8.886 shushwudwruvri kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqvlq 3;:9 wrUhswhpehu 3;;3. 3.8:8 zhuh iurp wkhRklolsslqh Cup~. 3.684 zhuhphpehuv ri wkhsrolfh dqg 645 zhuh phpehuv ri yljlodqwhjurxsv0:4 672zhuh phpehuv ri wkhEJFH ru ECHIW0:5

Qi 48.485 ylfwlpv ri kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqvlq wkhshulrg iurpLdqxdu~K.3;:9 xs wrUhswhpehu52. 3;;3.;.2;5 zhuh zrunhuv. 7.:3; zhuhvwxghqwv.7.397 zhuh iduphuv dqg 3.375 zhuh vhuylfhzrunhuv0:6 Jxpdquljkwvzrunhuv dffrxqwhg iru 44: ri wkhylfwlpv0:7Vkh odujhqxpehu riylfwlpv frplqj iurp wkhudqnv ri zrunhuv pdqlihvwvwkhjryhuqphqw'vlurq ilvwdssurdfk wrplolwdqwzrunhuv' jurxsv0 Vkh qxpehu ri ylfwlpvzkr duhvwxghqwvvkrzv wkhjryhuqphqw'v kdugolqhdssurdfk wrvwxghqwghprqvwudwlrqv0

99Ddqglrod. Ualley of Sears ... and Eears, 8 RJTW. Hheuxdu~ KU/Odufk KU.3;;3. ss035/360

9:Odqlod Ekurqlfoh. Fhf0 5. 3;;3. s0 5079/d.8oQecord. supra qrwh 92. dw36>Uwdwlvwlfv081ld.82/d.83/d.84Qecord, supra qrwh 92. dw37>Rituation, supra qrwh64. dw38085/d.

Vkh fulwlflvp ri wkh kxpdq uljkwv uhfrug ri wkh Ctxlqrjryhuqphqw kdv qrwehhq olplwhgwrorfdodqg lqwhuqdwlrqdoPIQv0 Gyhqzlwklq wkhjryhuqphqw. wkhglvwxuelqj sdwwhuqri kxpdq uljkwvdexvhvkdvfdxvhg judyh frqfhuq0

Vkh Rklolsslqh UhqdwhErpplwwhh rq Lxvwlfhdqg Jxpdq Tljkwv.lq lwvThsruw rq wkh Jxpdq Tljkwv Ulwxdwlrqlq wkh Rklolsslqhv.vxeplwwhg rq Csulo 6. 3;;2 diwhud vhulhvri sxeolf khdulqjv. pdghilqglqjv dqg frqfoxvlrqv wkdwuhlwhudwhgdqg ohjlwlpl°hg wkrvhsuhylrxvo~ pdgh e~ PIQv0

Hluvwdqg iruhprvw. wkhErpplwwhh irfxvhg lwvdwwhqwlrqrq wkhdgplqlvwudwlrq'vdssduhqwodfn ri srolwlfdozloo wrsurprwh dqg surwhfwkxpdq uljkwv<

30 Jxpdq uljkwvfrqwlqxh wr eh ylrodwhgghvslwhwkhidfw wkdwkxpdq uljkwv ylrodwlrqv frpplwwhg e~ plolwdu~. srolfh dqg rwkhujryhuqphqw/vxssruwhg rujdql°dwlrqv duh qrw lq sxuvxlw ri dq~jryhuqphqw srolf~0

Thvshfwiru kxpdq uljkwvlv d vwdwhsrolf~ dqg d frqvwlwxwlrqdopdqgdwh0Vkh Erpplwwhh qrwhv.krzhyhu. wkdwwkhuhlv d zlgh jds ehwzhhq vwdwhsrolf~ dqg uhdolw~.ehwzhhq lqvwlwxwlrqdouhvsrqvh dqg dfwxdosudfwlfh lqwkhilhog0 Vklv sxwvwrtxhvwlrq wkhhiilflhqf~. li qrw wkhsrolwlfdozloo.ri wkhCgplqlvwudwlrqwrhiihfwlyho~hqirufh wkh Erqvwlwxwlrqdqg wkhodzv surylglqj iru wkhsurwhfwlrqri kxpdq uljkwviru doo0:8

360 Odq~ fdxvh/rulhqwhg jurxsv dqg ohjlwlpdwh shrsoh'vrujdql°dwlrqv zhuh odehohg dv frppxqlvw v~psdwkl°huv. li qrwfrppxqlvw iurqwv0

Iryhuqphqw riilfldov. sduwlfxoduo~wkh plolwdu~. zhuh irxqg wrkdyh pdgh orrvh dqg dwwlphv gholehudwhvwdwhphqwvolqnlqj pdq~fdxvh/rulhqwhg jurxsv wr rxwodzhg rujdql°dwlrqv vxfk dv wkhPFH/ERR/PRC0 Cv d uhvxowri vdlg odehoolqj. vxfk jurxsv zhuh sodfhg lqgdqjhu ri ehlqj wdujhwwhge~ plolwdu~. sdudplolwdu~. dqg dqwl/frppxqlvw yljlodqwhjurxsv0

Vkh uhodwlyhvdqg iulhqgvri ylfwlpv ri lqyroxqwdu~glvdsshdudqfhvhqfrxqwhuhg gliilfxow~ lq wkhluvhdufk dv vrph riilfhuv ri plolwdu~fdpsv dqg ghwhqwlrqfhqwhuvrxwuljkwo~uhixvhgwrfrrshudwh zlwk wkhp0

:8Erpp0 rq Lxvwlfhdqg Jxpdq Tljkwv. U0Tsw03247. :wk Erqjr (3;;2). dw79]khuhlqdiwhuJT TGRQTV)0

Vkh~ uhfhlyhg yhu~ olwwohdvvlvwdqfhiurp wkhjryhuqphqw lq wkhdfwxdofrqgxfw ri wkhvhdufkdqg lq whupvri surylglqj uhtxluhg uhvrxufhv0

Uhyhudozlwqhvvhvwhvwlilhgwkdwvdihkrxvhv duhvwlooehlqj xvhg e~jryhuqphqw djhqwv wr lqwhuurjdwhdqg wruwxuhshuvrqv zkr zhuhduuhvwhgrq vxvslflrq ri ehlqj PRC uhehovru v~psdwkl°huv0

Hru dv orqj dv wruwxuhlq vdihkrxvhv lv pdgh sduw ri wkhlqwhuurjdwlrq surfhvv. wkhlqyhvwljdwlrq ri fdvhv ri kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqv dqg wkhvxffhvvixo survhfxwlrq ri riihqghuv ehfrph yhu~gliilfxow0

370 Vkh lqyhvwljdwlrq ri pdq~ frpsodlqwv ri kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqvdqg wkhsurvhfxwlrq ri pdq~ riihqghuv duhirxqg wr surfhhgdwd yhu~ vorz sdfh ghvslwh wkh dydlodelolw~ri zlwqhvvhv dqg wkhh}lvwhqfh ri wkh dssursuldwh phfkdqlvpv dqg lqvwlwxwlrqvrijryhuqphqw0 Vkxv. d qxpehu ri ylfwlpv r'i kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqvdqg wkhlu idplolhv qr orqjhu ilohg wkhlu frpsodlqwv zlwk wkhErpplvvlrq rq Jxpdq Tljkwv. wkhHlvfdo'vQiilfh ru wkhplolwdu~. dvpdq~ ri wkhp h}suhvvhgodfn ri wuxvwdqg frqilghqfh lq wkhvhdjhqghv'delolw~wr uhvsrqg lpphgldwho~ dqg hiihfwlyho~wrwkhlufrpsodlqwv0

380 Vkh Erpplwwhh irxqg wkdwvrph kxpdq uljkwvrujdql°dwlrqv. erwk grphvwlf dqg lqwhuqdwlrqdo.lqfoxglqj vhfwlrqvriwkh phgld. duh shufhlyhg e~ jryhuqphqw djhqflhv wr eh phuho~vsuhdglqj pdolflrxv sursdjdqgd dqg h}djjhudwlqj wkhlqflghqfh rikxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqvzkhqhyhu wkhvhjurxsv fdoowkhjryhuqphqw'vdwwhqwlrqwkhuhwr0

Vkh Erpplwwhh irxqg wkdwdprqj vrph fdxvh/rulhqwhg kxpdquljkwvjurxsv. wkhuhlv d orvv ri idlwklq wkhjryhuqphqw wr dssuhfldwhwkhlusrvlwlrq0 Cgghg wrwklvlv wkhdwwlwxghri lqwrohudqfhrq wkhsduwri vrph hohphqwv lq wkh plolwdu~0 Drwk idfwruv djjudydwh wkhvlwxdwlrqri d odfn ri xqghuvwdqglqjri kxpdq uljkwv0U0B

Vkh UhqdwhErpplwwhh dovr txhvwlrqhg wkh zlvgrp ri wkhjryhuqphqw'v dqwl/lqvxujhqf~ srolf~ dqg wkh loo/hiihfwv wkdwlwjhqhudwhg<

40 Vkh "wrwdozdu srolf~." qrz uhihuuhgwrdv wkh"wrwdodssurdfk"vwudwhj~dqg rshudwlrqdol°hg wkurxjk wkhCHR'vVkuhh/VlhuhgFhihqvhU~vwhpiru KqwhuqdoUhfxulw~.lv frqvlghuhg d pdmru idfwrufrqwulexwlqjwr wkhfrqwlqxlqj kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqv0

70 Vkh xvh e~ wkhplolwdu~ri pruwduv.krzlw°huv. erpev. khdy~duwloohu~dqg rwkhukljk srzhuhg zhdsrqv uhvxowhgqrw rqo~ lq pdvvlyh

glvsodfhphqw ri shrsoh exw dovr lq khdy~ gdpdjhv wrfursv. olyhvwrfndqg rwkhu lwhpv ri surgxfwlyh ydoxh. wkhuhe~ fdxvlqj vhulrxvglvuxswlrq lq wkholyhvri wkhdiihfwhg idplolhv0

90 Ehuwdlq vhfwlrqv ri wkhplolwdu~ hvwdeolvoxqhqwkdyh sodfhgsulpdf~ lq wkh sxuvxlwri plolwdu~ remhfwlyhvhyhq zkhq wkhvhfrxoglqyroyh khdy~ orvvhv ru lqmxu~ wr flyloldq olyhv dqg gdpdjh wrsurshuwlhv0

;0 Urph dqq~ dqg odz hqirufhphqw dxwkrulwlhv.lq d qxpehu rilqvwdqfhv.kdyh ghprqvwudwhgd odfn ri fdsdelolw~ dqg ghwhuplqdwlrq wrhqirufh wkhodz djdlqvw "orvwfrppdqgv". idqdwlfdo jurxsv dqg rwkhuodzohvv hohphqwv dv vkrzq e~ wkhluidloxuh wr vhuyh wkhpdq~ zduudqwvri duuhvworqj djr lvvxhg' djdlqvw phpehuv ri vdlg jurxsv0

320 Vkh Erpplwwhh irxqg wkdwpdq~ yljlodqwh jurxsv frqwlqxhwrh}lvwdqg rshudwh ghvslwhwkh3;:: gluhfwlyhri RuhvlghqwCtxlqr wrglvedqg wkhp0 000

330 Vkh Erpplwwhh irxqg wkdwlq vrph lqvwdqfhv. wkhuhzdvfrhuflrq xvhg lq wkh uhfuxlwphqwri ECHIW phpehuv dqg wkdwvrph riwkrvhzkr uhixvhg wreh uhfuxlwhgzhuh lqwlplgdwhg.kdudvvhgru nloohg0

Urph ECHIW phpehuv kdg dfwhg duelwudulo~dqg degxfwhg runloohgflyloldqv rq wkhphuh vxvslflrq wkdwwkh~zhuh frppxqlvwv ruwkhluv~psdwkl°huv0

UhyhudoECHIW vroglhuvlqyroyhg lq wkh fdvhv suhvhqwhglq wkhsxeolf khdulqjv zhuh iruphu phpehuv ri wkhEJFH dqg yljlodqwhjurxsvzkr kdg suhylrxvo~ frpplwwhg ydulrxv fulplqdo dfwv0

000wkhErpplwwhh irxqg wkdwwkh uhfuxlwphqw dqg wudlqlqj ri pdq~phpehuv ri wkhECHIW zhuh lqdghtxdwh dqg ghilflhqw0::

50Vkh Erpplwwhh irxqg wkdwd pruh hiihfwlyh hgxfdwlrq surjudplv qhhghg iru wkh plolwdu~dqg jryhuqphqw shuvrqqho lq rughu iru wkhpwrkdyh d ehwwhuxqghuvwdqglqj ri wkhlugxwlhvdqg uhvsrqvlelolwlhvlq wkhsurprwlrq dqg surwhfwlrq ri kxpdq uljkwv lq dffrugdqfh zlwk wkhErqvwlwxwlrq.odzv dqg lqwhuqdwlrqdoo~dffhswhg kxpdq uljkwv qrupvdqg vwdqgdugv0

60 Vkh Eruqplwwhh irxqg wkdwpdq~ ri wkhkxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqvfrpsodlqhg ri zhuh vdoydjlqjv dqg pdvvdfuhv0

80 Vkh Erpplwwhh irxqg wkdwwkhhydfxdwlrq fhqwhuvzhuh ryhu/iloohg wr fdsdflw~ dqg zhuh odfnlqj lq irrg vxsso~ dqg vdqlwdwlrqidflolwlhv0 Kwzdv ixuwkhuirxqg wkdwlq wkhhydfxdwlrq fhqwhuv.wkhjryhuqphqw'v uhvsrqvh dqg wuhdwphqwri wkhvlfn dqg g~lqj zhuh vorzdqg lqdghtxdwh gxh wr odfn ri grfwruv. qxuvhv dqg phglflqhv0 Vkhhydfxdwlrq fhqwhuvlq Phjurv Qfflghqwdo lq wkhzdnh ri QshudwlrqVkxqghuerowuhjlvwhuhgryhu 322 fklog ghdwkvgxh wr glvhdvhv0

:0 Kqpdq~ ri wkhfdvhv khdug gxulqj wkhsxeolf khdulqjv. wkhzlwqhvvhvzhuh deoh wrsrvlwlyho~lghqwli~wkhshushwudwruvri kxpdquljkwv ylrodwlrqv dv phpehuv ri wkh Rklolsslqh Cup~. wkhRE/KPR.wkhUfrxw Tdqjhuv. wkhorfdo srolfh. plolwdu~ lqwhooljhqfh jurxsv.ECHIWv. yljlodqwh jurxsv. dqg rwkhusdudplolwdu~jurxsv0

350 Vkh Erpplwwhh irxqg wkdwkxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqv diihfwhgpdq~ vhfwruv. sulpdulo~ wkhiduphuv. oderuhuv. ~rxwk. zrphq dqgfkloguhq. xuedq srru. fkxufk shrsoh. odz~huv. khdowk.phgld dqg rwkhusurihvvlrqdov0:;

Cprqj wkhuhfrpphqgdwlrqv pdgh uj wkhErpplwwhh zhuh wkhiroorzlqj<

30 Thfdoo wkhwrwdozdu srolf~. qrz uhihuuhg wr dv wkhwrwdodssurdfk vwudwhj~.dqg uhylhz wkhwkuhh/wlhuhgghihqvh v~vwhp irulqwhuqdovhfxulw~0

40 Uwrs wkhxvh ri zhdsrqv vxfk dv pruwduv. krzlw°huv dqgerpev gxulqj plolwdu~ rshudwlrqv lq d pdqqhu zklfk grhv qrwglvfulplqdwh ehwzhhq flyloldqv dqg frpedwdqwv0 Uwrsdovr wkhsudfwlfhri vwudiwqjlqkdelwhgduhdv0

50 Rurylgh hydfxhhv zlwk lpphgldwh dqg dghtxdwhuholhiwkurxjkwkhFhsduwphqwri Urfldo Yhoiduh dqg Fhyhorsphqw0 FhsduwphqwriJhdowk. Fhsduwphqwri Nrfdo Iryhuqphqwv. Fhsduwphqwri PdwlrqdoFhihqvh. dqg rwkhu dssursuldwh jryhuqphqw djhqflhv0 Vdnh wkhqhfhvvdu~ vwhsvwridflolwdwhwkhhydfxhhv' uhwxuqwrwkhlukrphv0

60 Gqvxuhwkhsurwhfwlrqri wkh flyloldq srsxodwlrq gxulqj duphgkrvwlolwlhvehwzhhq wkhjryhuqphqw dqg uhehoirufhv0

70 Gqirufh wkhsuhvlghqwldogluhfwlyh wrglvedqg yljlodqwh jurxsv0Coo sdud/plolwdu~ jurxsv vxfk dv wkhECHIW. sulydwh duplhv dqgUECCv vkrxog olnhzlvh eh glvpdqwohg0

80 Kpphgldwho~ hqdfw wkhodz suryldlqj iru wkhflwl°hq duphgirufh dv hqylvlrqhg e~ wkhErqvwlwxwlrq0

:0 Kqwhqvli~hiiruwv lq wkh lqyhvwljdwlrq dqg survhfxwlrq ri dooshuvrqv fkdujhg zlwk kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqv0

;0 Rurylgh iru d shupdqhqw v~vwhp ri frpshqvdwlrq iru ylfwlpvri kxpdq uljkwv ylrodwlrqv dqg wkhluidplolhv0

320 Xljrurxvo~ dwwhqgwrwkhqhhg iru uhkdelolwdwlrqri ylfwlpv rikxpdq uljkwv ylrodwlrqv0

340 Kpsuryh wkhv~vwhp ri prqlwrulqj jryhuqphqw frpsoldqfhzlwk lwvkxpdq uljkwv reoljdwlrqv0

350Wujh wkhFhsduwphqw ri Nrfdo Iryhuqphqwv wrvhwxs JxpdqTljkwv Erpplwwhhv wkurxjk wkhsurylqfldo dqg pxqlflsdo erdugv dqgflw~ frxqflov zklfk zrxog frruglqdwh zlwk wkh Erpplvvlrq rqJxpdq Tljkwv. orfdo kxpdq uljkwv jurxsv. qrq/jryhuqphqwdorujdql°dwlrqv dqg flylf rujdql°dwlrqv0;2

Qq wkh pdwwhuri lqyroxqwdu~ glvdsshdudqfhv. wkh Erpplwwhhpdgh wkhiroorzlqj vshflilf uhfrpphqgdwlrqv<

30 Hdflolwdwhwkh rshqlqj ri plolwdu~ fdpsv dqg vxvshfwhgvdihkrxvhv iru uhdg~ dffhvv wr wkh uhodwlyhv vhdufklqj iru wkhglvdsshduhg0 Rurylgh wkhp zlwk vxiilflhqw ipdqfldo khos wrfryhu frvwvri wkhvhdufk0

40 Fluhfw dooplolwdu~fdpsv dqg khdgtxduwhuvwrpdnh dydlodeohdqxsgdwhg olvwlqjri dooshuvrqv ghwdlqhgxqghu wkhlufxvwrg~0

50Coorz qrq/jryhuqphqwdo rujdql°dwlrqv (PIQv) wrrevhuyh dqgsduwlflsdwhlq wkh vhdufk iru plvvlqj shuvrqv dqg lq wkh h}kxpdwlrqdqg lghqwlilfdwlrqri erglhv glvfryhuhg0

60 Thtxluh wkhFhsduwphqw ri Pdwlrqdo Fhihqvh. wkhFhsduwphqwri Lxvwlfh dqg wkh Erpplvvlrq rq Jxpdq Tljkwv wr lqyhvwljdwhuhsruwvrq vxvshfwhgvdihkrxvhv dqg wdnh dssursuldwh dfwlrq0C4

VHd., dwA51911d., dw950

Vkh Erpplwwhh dovr uhfrpphqghg wkhfhvvdwlrqri wkhwudlqlqje~ wkhplolwdu~ri hpsor~hhv lq sulydwhfrpsdqlhv wrehfrph ECHIWphpehuv0;4

Cv uhjdugv wkhErpplvvlrq rq Jxpdq Tljkwv.;5wkhErpplwwhhirxqg wkhiroorzlqj sureohpv wkdwrevwuxfwhgwkhfdsdflw~ri lwvuhjlrqdoriilfhv wr lqyhvwljdwhdqg uhvroyh kxpdq uljkwvfdvhv dqg wr surylghdvvlvwdqfh wr wkh ylfwlpv< wkh odfn ri orjlvwlf vxssruw iru riilfhhtxlsphqw dqg pdwhuldovqhhghg iru lqyhvwljdwlrqv>wkhodfnri ixqgv iruuhqghulqj ilqdqfldo dvvlvwdqfhwr ylfwlpv> wkh odfn ri wudlqhg dqgfrpplwwhg shuvrqqho>wkhodfn ri survhfxwru~ srzhuv> srru uhjlrqdo vhw/xs> wkhodfn ri ghflvlrq/pdnlqj srzhuv dqg ilqdqfldo fdsdelolw~ri wkhuhjlrqdo riilfhv> wkhodfn ri frrshudwlrq iurp odz hqirufhphqw djhqflhv>dqg wkhihdu ri zlwqhvv•v wrwhvwli~ru frrshudwh lq wkhlqyhvwljdwlrqv0;6Vr fxuh wkhvh sureohpv. wkh Erpplwwhh pdgh wkh iroorzlqjuhfrpphqgdwlrqv<;7

30 Kqfuhdvh wkhexgjhw ri wkh Erpplvvlrq wr hqdeoh lwwr pruhhiihfwlyho~ fduu~ rxw lwvixqfwlrqv dqg shuirup lwvvhuylfhv. zlwk vshfldoirfxv rq ilhog lqyhvwljdwlrqv. wkhdvvlvwdqfh dqg ylvlwruldo vhuylfhsurjudp dqg wkhzlwqhvv surwhfwlrq surjudp0

40 UwuhqjwkhqwkhErpplvvlrq'v fdsdflw~ wr surylgh ilqdqfldodqg uhkdelolwdwlrqdvvlvwdqfhwrylfwlpv dqg wkhluidplolhv0

50 Gqdfw lqwr odz Uhqdwh Dloo 448 zklfk surylghv wkhErpplvvlrq rq Jxpdq Tljkwv zlwk survhfxwru~ dqg rwkhusrzhuv dqgh}sdqgv lwvhgxfdwlrq ixqfwlrqv0

60 Uwuhqjwkhqwkhuhjlrqdo riilfhv dqg jlyh wkhp dxwrqrp~ wrohvvhqwkhludgplqlvwudwlyhghshqghqfh rq wkhEJT qdwlrqdo riilfh0

Gduolhulq lwvThsruw rq Xljlodqwh Iurxsv. wkh Erpplwwhhuhfrpphqghg wkhglvpdqwolqj ri yljlodqwhjurxsU0;8

92Hd.,dw960;5 C frqvwlwxwlrqdoo~fuhdwhg djhqf~ zlwk wkhsulpdu~ gxw~ ri lqyhvwljdwlqj kxpdq

uljkwv ylrodwlrqv0;6JT TGRQTV.supra qrwh :8. dw69095Hd.,dw96/970;8Erpp0 rq Lxvwlfh dqg Jxpdq Tljkwv. U0Tsw0rq Xljlodqwh Iurxsv. :wk Erqjr

(3;:9). dw43 0

?mnesty Hnternational Qecommendations

Thfhqwo~.lq d uhsruw;9 wkdwzdv kljko~ fulwlfdori wkhkxpdquljkwvvlwxdwlrqri zrunhuv lq wkhRklolsslqhv. Cpqhvw~ Kqwhuqdwlrqdoxujhg wkhRklolsslqh jryhuqphqw wr frqvlghu wkhiroorzlqj uhphgldophdvxuhv<

30 Vr surklelw h}solflwo~wkh"uhg/odehoolqj" ri wudghxqlrqlvwv dqgrwkhuv hqjdjhg lq odzixo srolwlfdosurwhvw>

40 Vr lqlwldwhxujhqw lqyhvwljdwlrqv lqwr doouhsruwv ri kxpdquljkwv ylrodwlrqv e~ phpehuv ri plolwdu~ dqg sdudplolwdu~ irufhv. dvzhoo dv xqriilfldo duphg jurxsv dfwlqj zlwk wkhlu vxssruw rudftxlhvfhqfh>

50 Vr vxvshqg iurp dfwlyh vhuylfh doo phpehuv ri plolwdu~ dqgsdudplolwdu~ irufhv vxvshfwhg ri frpplwwlqj vxfk ylrodwlrqv. ruvxvshfwhg ri frpsolflw~ lq ylrodwlrqv frpplwwhg e~ phpehuv rixqriilfldo duphg jurxsv>

60 Vr eulqj doowkrvh vxvshfwhg ri kxpdq uljkwv ylrodwlrqv wrmxvwlfhehiruh d flylo frxuw>

70 Vr hqvxuh vwulfwfrqwuro. lqfoxglqj d fohdu fkdlq ri frpuuldqg.ryhu doo riilfldov uhvsrqvleoh iru duuhvw.ghwhqwlrq dqg lpsulvrqphqw.dv zhoo dv ryhu dooriilfldov dxwkrul°hg wrxvh irufh dqg iluhdupv>

80 Vr uhylhz wkhuhjxodwlrqv jryhuqlqj wkhxvh ri irufh dqgiluhdupv dqg wrwdnhhiihfwlyh phdvxuhv wrhqvxuh wkdwrqo~ wkrvh ixoo~dxwkrul°hg wr ehdu dupv duh shuplwwhg wr gr vr> dqg lq sduwlfxoduwrhqvxuh wkdwdupv duh qrw surylghg wr "yljlodqwhv" dqg rwkhuxqriilfldojurxsv>

90 Vr glvedqg erwk ECHIWv dqg UECCv dv vrrq dv srvvleoh>lq wkhphdqwlph wr hqvxuh wkdwdoosdudplolwdu~ xqlwvduh lpphgldwho~eurxjkw xqghu hiihfwlyh frqwuro e~ wkhplolwdu~dxwkrulwlhv>

:0 Vr xskrog frqvwlwxwlrqdo surylvlrqv surklelwlqj wkhpdlqwhqdqfh ri sulydwh duplhv> wr glvpdqwoh dooduphg "yljlodqwh"jurxsv dqg wr dgrsw ohjlvodwlrq surklelwlqj wkh rshudwlrq ri vxfkjurxsv>

;0 Vr hqdfw ohjlvodwlrqsurklelwlqj wkhsduwlflsdwlrq ri frpsdq~jxdugv dqg "yljlodqwhv" lq frxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~ rshudwlrqv> dqg

;9 Cpqhvw~ Kqwhuqdwlrqdouhsruwvri kxpdq uljkwvvlwxdwlrqlq wkhRklolsslqhv duhedvhgrq lqirupdwlrq froohfwhgiurp d zlgh ydulhw~ri vrxufhv. lqfoxglqj qrwdul°hg diilgdylwv.frxuwgrfxphqwv dqg suhvv uhsruwv0 Coo lqirupdwlrq lv hydoxdwhg dw wkh rujdql°dwlrq'vKqwhuqdwlrqdoUhfuhwduldwlq Nrqgrq0 Kq dgglwlrq. CK kdv vhqwplvvlrqv wr wkhfrxqwu~.gxulqj zklfk uhsuhvhqwdwlyhvfrqgxfwhg lqwhuylhzv zlwk d zlgh udqjh ri jryhuqphqwriilfldov. plolwdu~riilfhuv. phpehuv ri kxpdq uljkwv jurxsv dqg ylfwlpv ri kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqv0 COPGUV[ KPVGTPCVKQPCN. RJKWRRKPGU<WPNCYHWN MKoolPIU D[ OKWiCT[CPF RCTCOKWVCT[ HQTEGU5 (3;::)0

surklelwlqj wkhsulydwh ixqglqj ri riilfldo sdudplolwdu~irufhv lqyroyhglq frzJhu/lqvxujhqf~ rshudwlrqv>

320 Vr hqvxuh wkdwwudghxqlrq phpehuv dqg rwkhuv duh qrwvxemhfwhgwr duelwudu~duuhvwdqg lpsulvrqphqw vroho~ iru wkhluqrq/ylrohqwsrolwlfdo ru wudghxqlrq dfwlylwlhv>dqg

330 Vr hqvxuh wkdwgrphvwlf dqg lqwhuqdwlrqdojxdudqwhhv ri gxhsurfhvv dqg idlu wuldoduh qrw xqghuplqhg e~ h}hfxwlyh ru . mxglfldouhlqwhusuhwdwlrqvzklfk lqyrnh wkh "qdwlrqdo0lqwhuhvw"ru wkhqhhg wrfrpedw wkhlqvxujhqf~0;:

Vkh Cpqhvw~ KqwhuqdwlrqdoThsruw 3;;3. zklfk fryhuv wkhshulrg iurp Ldqxdu~wr Fhfhpehu 3;;2. pdgh wkhiroorzlqj dgglwlrqdouhfrpphqgdwlrqv< wkdwwkh jryhuqphqw hqvxuh wkh lqghshqghqwlqyhvwljdwlrq ri doohjhg h}wudmxglfldoh}hfxwlrqv dqg glvdsshdudqfhv>wkdwwkrvhdffxvhg ri kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqveh wulhglq flylo frxuwv>wkdwsulvrqhuv ri frqvflhqfh eh uhohdvhg>wkhsurpsw. idlu wuldoru uhohdvhri rwkhu srolwlfdo ghwdlqhhv>wkh uhylhz ri wkh fdvhv ri sulvrqhuvvhqwhqfhg diwhudssduhqwo~ xqidlu wuldov>wkh uhshdo ri RuhvlghqwldoFhfuhh Pr0 3:72 zklfk jdyh frxuwvpduwldoh}foxvlyhmxulvglfwlrqwrwu~fulphv frpplwwhg e~ plolwdu~phq> dqg wkhuhylhz ri wkhsrolf~ ri xvlqjflyloldq sdudplolwdu~ irufhv lq wkhjryhuqphqw'v frxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~fdpsdljq0;;

Qq Fhfhpehu 32. 3;;2. rq wkhrffdvlrq ri wkh64qg dqqlyhuvdu~riwkhWqlyhuvdoFhfodudwlrqri Jxpdq Tljkwv. vhyhudoqrq/jryhuqphqwdorujdql°dwlrqv fdph xs zlwk "dq lpphgldwh djhqgd xskroglqj wkhuljkwwrolih. vxuylydodqg kxpdq gljqlw~0"KQQVkh djhqgd zdv uhihuuhgwr"dvdq lqlwldodqg qhfhvvdu~vwhswrzdugv uholhylqj wkhghwhulrudwlqjvwdwhri kxpdq uljkwvdv zhoo dv wkhghhshqlqj hfrqrplf dqg srolwlfdofulvlvudydjlqj wkhfrxqwu~0"KQKVklv djhqgd surylghg. dprqj rwkhuv.wkhiroorzlqj lwhpv<

40 Uwrs doo fxuuhqw plolwdu~ rshudwlrqv lq wkh frxqwu~vlghsduwlfxoduo~ wkrvh lq glvdvwhuduhdv. dqg pryh wr glvpdqwoh ECHIWdqg sdudplolwdu~ xqlwv. lq d elg wrzdugv hqglqj wkhjryhuqphqw'vghvwuxfwlyhwrwdozdu srolf~0 Rurylgh uholhi dqg uhkdelolwdwlrq wrlqwhuqdo uhixjhhv dqg frpshqvdwlrq wr rwkhu ylfwlpv ri plolwdu~

;:Cpqhvw~ KqwhuqdwlrqdoVorkers, Guman Qights and the ?gents of Ceath, PCVKQPCNOKFYGGM.Cxjxvw 4:. 3;;3. s0 650

;;COPGvV[KPVGTPCVKQPCN.3;;3 COPGUV[KPiGTPCVKQPCNTGRQTV3:: (3;;3)0KQQRhrsoh'vEdxfxv. Guman Qights in Brisis: ?n Hmmediate ?genda for Qelief

]khuhlqdiwhuBrisis] PCVKQPCNOKFYGGM.Pryhpehu 37/Fhfhpehu 36.3;;2. s0 350KQoog0.dw3;0

fdpsdljqv0 Rxqlvk wkhshushwudwruvri plolwdu~ dwurflwlhvdqg rwkhukxpdq uljkwv ylrodwlrqv0

50 Kpphgldwho~ uhohdvhsrolwlfdo sulvrqhuv rq kxpdqlwduldq dqgohjdo jurxqgv< wkhvhlqfoxgh rqh ri ghwdlqhg frxsohv. qxuvlqj dqgsuhjqdqw prwkhuv. wkhvlfn dqg wkhhoghuo~.plqruv dqg wkrvh khdylo~wruwxuhg>wkrvh judqwhg edloru zkrvh fdvhv kdyh ehhq glvplvvhg lqfrxuw exwuhpdlq lq ghwhqwlrqdqg wkrvhzlwkrxw fkdujhv0 Uxuidfh dqgdffrxqw dooylfwlpv ri lqyroxqwdu~ glvdsshdudqfhv0

60 Thshdo dooghfuhhv dqg rwkhu odzv wkdwylrodwh frqvwlwxwlrqdouljkwv ri srolwlfdo sulvrqhuv dqg srolwlfdo glvvhqwhuv0 Uwrs wkh"fulplqdol°dwlrq" ri srolwlfdo riihqvhv0 Uwrs wkhsudfwlfh ri zduudqwohvvduuhvwvdqg vhdufkhv dqg °rqlqj ri xuedq srru duhdv0

70 Uwrs wkhkdudvvphqw dqg shuvhfxwlrq ri shrsoh'v rujdql°dwlrqvdqg pdvv dfwlrqv0 Ufuds wkhRxeolf Cvvhpeo~ Cfw uhvwulfwlqjwkhuljkwwriuhhgrp ri vshhfk dqg dvvhpeo~0o24

Vkh vdph djhqgd zdv dovr suhvhqwhg dwwkhJxpdq TljkwvUxpplw ri wkhRhrsoh'vEdxfxv rq Fhfhpehu ;. 3;;20 Kwsurylghv<

C0 Vr duuhvwwkhfrqwlqxlqj ghydvwdwlrqri wkhshrsoh'v olyhv dqgsurshuwlhv. dqg frqwlqxlqj ylrodwlrqv ri wkhshrsoh'v kxpdq uljkwv<

30 Gqg jryhuqphqw'v wrwdozdu srolf~0 Uwrs doofxuuhqwplolwdu~rshudwlrqv lq wkh frxqwu~vlgh0

50 Kqghpqli~ wkhylfwlpv ri wrwdozdu0 Rxqlvk wkhshushwudwruvriplolwdu~ dwurflwlhvdqg rwkhukxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqv0

60 Rurylgh uholhi dqg uhkdelolwdwlrqwrlqwhuqdouhixjhhv0 Ylwkgudzdooplolwdu~wurrsv iurp wkhlueduulrv dqg hqvxuh wkhluvdih uhwxuq0

70Thrulhqw wkhduphg irufhv dqg srolfh wrzdugv xskroglqj kxpdquljkwvdqg wkh shrsoh'v lqwhuhvwvdqg vryhuhljq zloo0

D0 Vr lpphgldwho~ dgguhvv wkhvsdwhri srolwlfdo uhsuhvvlrq dqghqvxuh wkhghihqvh ri shrsoh'v ghprfudwlf uljkwv<

30 Thshdo doouhsuhvvlyh ghfuhhv. ohwwhuvri lqvwuxfwlrq.h}hfxwlyhrughuv dqg rwkhu odzv wkdwylrodwhkxpdq uljkwv dqg lqiolfw lqmxu~rqwkhshrsoh0

50Vrzdugv wkhuhohdvhri doosrolwlfdosulvrqhuv.h}shglwhfrqfuhwhfdvhv. xskrog wkhluuljkwwredlo0 Thohdvhsrolwlfdoghwdlqhhvedvhgrqohjdo dqg kxpdqlwduldq jurxqgv (u0p0ghwdlqhgfrxsohv. qxuvlqjprwkhuv.dlolqj ghwdlqhhv)0

60Ufuds wkhRxeolf Cvvhpeo~ Cfwdqg xskrog wkhshrsoh'v uljkwwriuhhgrp ri vshhfk dqg dvvhpeo~0

70Flvpdqwohdooxuedqsdudplolwdu~irufhv dqg vwrswkhsudfwlfhri°rqlqj dqg zduudqwohvvvhdufkhvdqgvhl°xuhv0oQQ

Vkh frqvlvwhqf~ ri wkh ilqglqjv dqg uhfrpphqgdwlrqv ri wkhRklolsslqh Uhqdwh. Cpqhvw~ Kqwhuqdwlrqdo dqg orfdo qrq/jryhuqphqwdorujdql°dwlrqv kljkoljkwv wkh qhhg iru wkh jryhuqphqw wr lpphgldwho~dqg hiihfwlyho~ dgguhvv wkh kxpdq uljkwv vlwxdwlrq lq wkh Rklolsslqhv0Vkh judylw~ ri wkh vlwxdwlrq fdqqrw eh ljqruhg0 Kwghpdqgv d irufhixo.srvlwlyh uhvsrqvh iurp wkhjryhuqphqw0

Cprqj wkh iluvw dfwv ri Ouv0 Ctxlqr zkhq vkh dvvxphg wkhsuhvlghqf~ lq 3;:8 zhuh wkh fuhdwlrq ri d Ruhvlghqwldo Erpplwwhh rqJxpdq Tljkwv. wkh udwlilfdwlrq rq Hheuxdu~ 4:. 3;:8 ri wkh KqwhuqdwlrqdoEryhqdqw rq Elylo dqg Rrolwlfdo Tljkwv (KEERT). wkh udwlilfdwlrq lqCsulo 3;:8 ri wkh Erqyhqwlrq Cjdlqvw Vruwxuh dqg Qwkhu Euxho. Kqkxpdqru Fh judglqj Vuhdwphqw ru Rxqlvkphqw. wkh dffhvvlrq wr Rurwrfro KKriwkh Ihqhyd Erqyhqwlrq Thodwlqj wr wkh Rurwhfwlrq ri Xlfwlpv ri Prq/Kqwhuqdwlrqdo Cuphg Erqiolfwv. dqg wkh vljqlqj rq Cxjxvw 8. 3;:9 ri wkhlqvwuxphqw ri udwlilfdwlrq ri wkh Qswlrqdo Rurwrfro wr wkh KEERT0o26

C qhz Erqvwlwxwlrq zdv udwlilhg e~ wkh Hlolslqr shrsoh rqHheuxdu~ 4. 3;:90 Vkh surwhfwlrq ri kxpdq uljkwv zdv rqh ri wkhfruqhuvwrqhv ri wklv qhz Erqvwlwxwlrq0 Prw rqo~ zdv wkh eloo ri uljkwvvwuhqjwkhqhg e~ dgglqj pruh surylvlrqv surwhfwlyh ri kxpdq uljkwv.oQUexw wkh Erqvwlwxwlrq dovr surylghg iru wkh fuhdwlrq ri dq lqghshqghqwErpplvvlrq rq Jxpdq TljkwU0328

Cv d uhdfwlrq wr wkhkljk lqflghqfh ri wruwxuhgxulqj wkhwhqxuh riOu0 Odufrv. wkh qhz Erqvwlwxwlrq lqfoxghv lq lwveloo ri uljkwv d surylvlrqedqqlqj wkh sudfwlfh0 Kwsurylghv wkdw"]qor wruwxuh. irufh. ylrohqfh.

l03Brisis, supra qrwh32203262HCEGQHJWOCPTKIKKVUCPFJWOCPKVCTKCPCHHCKTU.FGRCTVOGPVQHHQTGKIP

CHHCKTU.4 EKXKNCPF RQNKVKECNTKIJVUKPVJGRJKNKRRKPGU<'iJGRJKWRRKPGKPKVKCNTGRQTVVQVJGJWOCPTuIKKVUEQOOKVKGG4 (3;:;) ]khuhlqdiwhuTGRQTV\1

oQU1g0.dw50328(<rPUV0.duw0i^. vhf039>see alsP TGRQTV.supra qrwh326. dw90

wkuhdw.lqwlplgdwlrq ru dq~ rwkhu phdqv zklfk ylwldwhwkh iuhh zloovkdooeh xvhg" djdlqvw wkhdffxvhg0323 Kwdovr surklelwv "vhfuhwghwhqwlrqsodfhv0.0vrolwdu~.incommunicado, ru rwkhu vlplodu irupv ri ghwhqwlrq0"K2:Vr glvfrxudjh wkh xvh ri wruwxuh lq rewdlqlqj lqirupdwlrq. wkhErqvwlwxwlrqpdnhv lqdgplvvleoh lq hylghqfh dq~ frqihvvlrq ru dgplvvlrqrewdlqhg wkurxjk wkhphdqv deryh/phqwlrqhg0o2; Kwdovr frppdqgv wkhErqjuhvv wr surylgh iru shqdo dqg flylo vdqfwlrqv djdlqvw ylrodwruv dvzhoo dv iru frpshqvdwlrq wr dqg uhkdelolwdwlrqri ylfwlpv ri wruwxuhruvlplodu sudfwlfhv dqg wkhluidplolhv0K3Q

Kq wklv frqqhfwlrq. wkh qhz Erqvwlwxwlrq surylghv wkdw"]wbkhhpsor~phqw ri sk~vlfdo. sv~fkrorjlfdo ru ghjudglqj sxqlvkphqwdjdlqvw dq~ sulvrqhu ru ghwdlqhhru wkhxvh ri vxevwdqgdug ru lqdghtxdwhshqdo idflolwlhv xqghu vxekxpdq frqglwlrqv vkdoo eh ghdow zlwk e~odz0"333 Gyhq wkhq. wkh pdowuhdwphqwri sulvrqhuv kdv iru vhyhudoghfdghv ehhq d fulph xqghu wkhshqdo frgh0 K34

Cqrwkhu qhz surylvlrq lq wkheloori uljkwv lv wkdw"]qbr shuvrqvkdoo eh ghwdlqhg vroho~ e~ uhdvrq ri klv srolwlfdo eholhiv dqgdvsludwlrqv0"335

Kqlwvwudqvlwru~surylvlrqv. wkhqhz Erqvwlwxwlrqsurylghv wkdw"]sbulydwh duplhv dqg rwkhu duphg jurxsv qrw uhfrjql°hg e~ gxo~frqvwlwxwhg dxwkrulw~ vkdoo eh glvpdqwohg0 Coo sdudplolwdu~ irufhvlqfoxglqj Elyloldq Jrph Fhihqvh Hrufhv qrw frqvlvwhqwzlwk wkhflwl°hqduphg irufh hvwdeolvkhg lq wkh Erqvwlwxwlrq. vkdoo eh glvvroyhg ru.zkhuh dssursuldwh. frqyhuwhg lqwr wkhuhjxodu irufh0"3o6

Vkh qhz Erqvwlwxwlrqjlyhv wkhErpplvvlrq rq Jxpdq Tljkwvwkhiroorzlqj srzhuv dqg ixqfwlrqv<

(d) Kqyhvwljdwh0rq lwvrzq ru rq frpsodlqwe~ dq~ sduw~.dooirupv ri kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqvlqyroylqjflylodqg srolwlfdouljkwv>

(e) Cgrswlwvrshudwlrqdojxlgholqhvdqguxohvri surfhgxuh0dqgflwhiru frqwhpswiru ylrodwlrqvwkhuhrilq dffrugdqfhzlwkwkhTxohvri Erxuw>

K23EQPUV0.duw0loo.vhf034. sdu040Sra.So0K2;EQPUV0.duw0loo.vhf034.sdu050KKQEQPUV0.duw0loo0vhf0340sdu060wooEQPUV0.duw0loo.vhf03;. sdu040334TGyKvGFRGPCNEQFG.duw04570K3LfQPUV0. duw0loo.vhf0 3:. sdu0 30336EQPUV0.duwZXKKK.vhf0460

(f) Rurylgh dssursuldwh ohjdo phdvxuhv iru wkhsurwhfwlrq rikxpdq uljkwv ri doo shuvrqv zlwklq wkh Rklolsslqhv. dv zhoo dvHlolslqrv uhvlglqj deurdg. dqg surylgh iru suhyhqwlyh phdvxuhv dqgohjdo dlg vhuylfhv wr wkhxqghu/sulylohjhg zkrvh kxpdq uljkwv kdyhehhq ylrodwhgru qhhg surwhfwlrq>

(g) G}huflvh ylvlwruldo srzhuv ryhu mdlov.sulvrqv. ru ghwhqwlrqidflolwlhv>

(h) Gvwdeolvkd frqwlqxlqj surjudp ri uhvhdufk. hgxfdwlrq dqglqirupdwlrq wrhqkdqfh uhvshfwiru wkhsulpdf~ ri kxpdq uljkwv>

(i) Thfrpphqg wr wkhErqjuhvv hiihfwlyh phdvxuhv wr surprwhkxpdq uljkwvdqg wrsurylgh iru frpshqvdwlrq wrylfwlpv ri ylrodwlrqvri kxpdq uljkwv. ru wkhlu idplolhv>

(j) Orqlwru wkh Rklolsslqh Iryhuqphqw'v frpsoldqfh zlwklqwhuqdwlrqdowuhdw~reoljdwlrqv rq kxpdq uljkwv>

(k) Iudqw lppxqlw~ iurp survhfxwlrq •r dq~ shuvrq zkrvhwhvwlprq~ ru zkrvh srvvhvvlrq ri grfxphqwv ru rwkhu hylghqfh lvqhfhvvdu~ ru frqyhqlhqw wr ghwhuplqh wkhwuxwklq dq~ lqyhvwljdwlrqfrqgxfwhg e~ lwru xqghu lwvdxwkrulw~>

(l) Thtxhvw wkhdvvlvwdqfhri dq~ ghsduwphqw. exuhdx. riilfh rudjhqf~ lq wkhshuirupdqfh ri lwvixqfwlrqv>

Kqwklvfrqqhfwlrq. wkhErqjuhvv pd~ surylgh iru rwkhu fdvhv riylrodwlrqv ri kxpdq uljkwv wkdwvkdooidoo zlwklq wkhdxwkrulw~ri wkhErpplvvlrq rq Jxpdq Tljkwv0449 Gylghqwiurp wklvodvwsurylvlrq. uhdgwrjhwkhu zlwk wkh Erpplvvlrq'v sulpdu~ ixqfwlrq. lv wkhlqwhqwri wkhiudphuv ri wkh Erqvwlwxwlrq wr lqlwldoo~ olplw wkh fryhudjh ri wkhErpplvvlrq'v srzhuv wr flylo dqg srolwlfdouljkwv0

Kqwhusuhwlqj lwv pdqgdwh. wkh Erpplvvlrq rq Lxo~ 48. 3;::dssuryhg EJT Thvroxwlrq Pr0 C::/267 zklfk gholqhdwhg wkhfdvhv rikxpdq uljkwv ylrodwlrqv wkdwzhuh fryhuhg e~ lwvlqyhvwljdwru~srzhuv0

(o) Jxpdq uljkwv ylrodwlrqv per se, zklfk duh wkrvhhqxphudwhg lq wkhuhvroxwlrq (u0p0. wkh flylo dqg srolwlfdo uljkwv jxdudqwhhg lq wkh

KKUEQPUV0.duw0ZKKK.vhf0 3:0338EQPUV00duw0ZoKK.vhf0 3;0

frqvwlwxwlrqdqg lq vwdwxwhv)0ru duh "hdvlo~dqg uhdglo~glvfhuqleoh dvsdosdeoh wudqvjuhvvlrqvri dq~ ri wkhedvlf uljkwvri d kxpdq ehlqj dvghilqhg lq wkhWqlyhuvdoFhfodudwlrqri Jxpdq Tljkwv dqg lqwhuqdwlrqdofryhqdqwv dqg wuhdwlhvrq kxpdq uljkwvwr zklfk wkhRklolsslqhv lv dvljqdwru~" vkdoo eh lqyhvwljdwhg ru jlyhq gxh frxuvh e~ wkhErpplvvlrq zlwkrxwxqqhfhvvdu~ghod~0

(4) Qwkhukxpdq uljkwv ylrodwlrqv. ru wkrvh zklfk duh qrw kxpdquljkwvylrodwlrqvper se, vkdooeh uhihuuhgwrdq hydoxdwlrqfrpplwwhh0Vkh frpplwwhh vkdooghwhuplqh dqg whfrpphqg zkhwkhu vxfk fdvhvvkrxog eh jlyhq gxh frxuvh e~ wkhErpplvvlrq. uhihuuhgwr dqrwkhujryhuqphqw djhqf~ ru sulydwh ohjdo dlg ru•dql°dwlrq. ru gursshgrxwuljkwiru qrwehlqj zlwklq lwvmxulvglfwlrq0"

Vkh Erpplvvlrq'v hqxphudwlrq ri zkdw duh kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqvper se jlyhv rqh dq lghd ri wkhsuhvhqwvfrsh ri wkhsurwhfwlrqri kxpdq uljkwvxqghu Rklolsslqh grphvwlf odz. qdpho~<

3) Fhsulydwlroo0ri olih. olehuw~ru surshuw~zlwkrxwgxh surfhvv riodz (Uhf0 3. Cuw0KKK<Dloori Tljkwv ri wkhErqvwlwxwlrqdqg Cuw054.sdu08. Phz Elylo Ergh). dqg ri wkhuljkwwrvkhowhu.hvshfldoo~ri srrugzhoohuv zkr pd~ qrw eh hylfwhg. qru wkhlu gzhoolqjv ghprolvkhgh}fhsw lq dffrugdqfh zlwk odz dqg lq d mxvwdqg kxpdqh pdqqhu (Uhf032. Cuw0ZKKKri wkhErqvwlwxwlrq)>

4) Xlrodwlrq ri wkhuljkwwrwkh htxdo surwhfwlrqri wkhodzv (Uhf03. Cuw0KKK>Dloori Tljkwv ri wkhErqvwlwxwlrq>dqg Cuw054. sdu0 :.Phz Elylo Ergh)>

5) Xlrodwlrq ri wkhuljkw ri wkh shrsoh wr eh vhfxuh lq wkhlushuvrqv. krxvhv. sdshuv. dqg hiihfwvdjdlqvwxphdvrqdeoh vhdufkhvdqgvhl°xuhvri zkdwhyhuqdwxuhdqg iru dq~ sxusrvh (Uhf04. Cuw0KKK<Dloori Tljkwv ri wkhErqvwlwxwlrq.dqg Cuw054. sdu0 ;. Phz Elylo Ergh)>

6) Erpplvvlrq ri dfwvfrqvwlwxwlqjloohjdoduuhvwdqg surfxuhphqwru lvvxdqfh ri loohjdovhdufk zduudqwv(Uhf04. Cuw0KKK<Dloori Tljkwvri wkhErqvwlwxwlrq>Cuw054. sdu 60. Phz Elylo Ergh> Cuwv0346.489.48: dqg 48;. Thylvhg RhqdoErgh)>

7) Xlrodwlrq ri wkhsulydf~ ri frppxqlfdwlrq dqg fruuhvsrqghqfh(Uhf05. Cuw0KKK<Dloori Tljkwv ri wkhErqvwlwxwlrq>dqg Cuw054. sdu033. Phz Elylo Ergh)>

8) Xlrodwlrq ri wkhiuhhgrpv ri uholjlrq. ri vshhfk. dqg wrzulwhiru wkhsuhvvru wrpdlqwdlq d shulrglfdo (Cuw054. sduv03.4 & 5. PhzElylo Ergh)>

9) Xlrodwlrq ri wkhuljkw wr wdnhsduwlq d shdfhdeoh dvvhpeo~ wrshwlwlrqwkhIryhuqphqw iru uhguhvvri julhydqfhv. dqg wkhuljkwwreh

'39U0O• Uruldqr. Orosecution and Lediation of GTSLn Qights Bases, 64'QN SfLPN'd

LQWTPCN 54/560

iuhh iurp lqyroxqwdu~ vhuylwxgh lq dq~ irup (Cuw054. sduv0 35 & 36.Phz Elylo Ergh)>

:) Vkh xvh ri wruwxuh.irufh. ylrohqfh. wkuhdw.lqwlplgdwlrq dqgrwkhu phdqv wkdwylwldwhwkhiuhh zloo ri dq~ shuvrq. ru wrgr dq~wklqjru wr vljq dq~ grfxphqw djdlqvw klv zloo (Uhf0 34(4). Cuw0KKK<DlooriTljkwv ri wkhErqvwlwxwlrq>Cuw054. sdu0 39. Phz Elylo Ergh)>

;) Jroglqj d shuvrq lq vhfuhw ghwhulwlrqsodfhv. lq vrolwdu~frqilqhphqw ru incommunicado, ru rwkhu vlplodu irupv ri ghwhqwlrq(Uhf0 34(4). Cuw0KKK<Dloo ri Tljkwv ri wkhErqvwlwxwlrq)>

32) Gp'sor~phqw ri sk~vlfdo. sv~fkrorjlfdo dqg •hjudglqjsxqlvkphqw djdlqvw d sulvrqhu ru ghwdlqhh>

33) Wqh}sodlqhg ru irufhg glvdsshdudqfhv dqg h}wudohjdoh}hfxwlrqv(vdoydjlqjv)>

34) Xlrodwlrq ri wkhiuhhgrp ri vxiiudjh. dqg wkholehuw~ri derghdqg ri fkdqjlqj wkh vdph (Cuw054. sduv0 7. ; & 32. Phz ElyloErgh)>

35) Ceulgjhphqw ri wkhuljkw ri hpsor~hhv wr irup ru mrlq oderuxqlrqv. dvvrfldwlrqv ru vrflhwlhv iru sxusrvhv qrw frqwudu~wrodz (Uhf0:. Cuw0KKK<Dloori Tljkwv ri wkhErqvwlwxwlrq>Cuw054. sdu0 34. PhzElylo Ergh)>

36) Fhwhqwlrq ri d shuvrq vroho~e~ uhdvrq ri klv srolwlfdo eholhivdqg dvsludwlrqv>

38) Xlrodwlrq ri wkhuljkw ri wkhshrsoh wr lqirupdwlrq rq pdwwhuvri sxeolf frqfhuq (Uhf0 9. Cuw0KKK<Dloori Tljkwv ri wkhErqvwlwxwlrq)>

39) Vkh wdnlqj ri sulydwh surshuw~ iru sxeolf xvh zlwkrxw mxvwfrpshqvdwlrq (Uhf0 ;. Cuw0KKK<Dloo ri Tljkwv ri wkhErqvwlwxwlrq>Cuw054. sdu0 9. Phz Elylo Ergh)>

3:) Erpplvvlrq ri dq~ ri wkh ETKOGU CICKPUV VJGHWPFCOGPVCN NCYU QH VJG UVCVG dv ghiphg lq VlwohVzr riwkhThylvhg Rhqdo Ergh<

e) Fhod~ lq wkhgholyhu~ ri ghwdlqhg shuvrqv wr wkhsurshu mxglfldo dxwkrulwlhv(Cuw0347)>

g) G}sxovlrq ri dq~ shuvrq iurp wkhRklolsslqhv rufrpshoolqj vxfk shuvrq wrfkdqjh klv uhvlghqfh (Cuw0349)>

i) Odolflrxvo~ rewdlqlqj vhdufk zduudqwru dexvh lq wkhvhuylfh ri wkrvhohjdoo~rewdlqhg (Cuw034;)>

k) Rurklelwlrq. lqwhuuuxswlrqdqg glvvroxwlrq ri shdfhixophhwlqjv (Cuw0353)>

3;) Erpplvvlrq ri dq~ ri wkhETKOGU CICKPUV RGTUQPUdv ghilqhg xqghu Uhfwlrq Qqh. Ekdswhu Qqh dqg Ekdswhu Vzr. VlwohGljkw ri wkhThylvhg RhqdoErgh<

d) Rduulflgh. pxughu dqg krplflgh. zkhwkhu frq/vxppdwhg. iuxvwudwhgru dwwhpswhg(Cuw0468 wr472)> dqg

42) Erpplvvlrq ri dq~ ri wkhETKOGU CICKPUV RGTUQPCNNKDGTV[ CPF UGEWTKV[ dv ghiphg lq Uhfwlrqv Qqh. Vzr dqgVkuhh. Ekdswhu Qqh dqg EkdswhuVzr. VlwohPlqh ri wkhThylvhg RhqdoErgh<

43) Erpplvvlrq ri dq~ ri wkh ETKOGU CICKPUVEJCUVKV[ dv ghilqhg lq EkdswhuvVzr. Vkuhh dqg Hrxu. VlwohGohyhqri wkhThylvhg RhqdoErgh<

(e) Uhgxfwlrq. fruuxswlrq ri plqruv. dqg zklwh vodyhwudgh(Cuw0559 wr563)> dqg

44) Vkh uhixvdo ru qhjohfw e~ d sxeolf vhuydqwru hpsor~hh.zlwkrxw mxvwfdxvh wrshuirup klv riilfldo gxw~>dqg

45) Xlrodwlrq ri wkhylvlwruldosrzhuv ri dwwruqh~vxqghu ThsxeolfCfw :79033:

Kwlv uhdglo~dssduhqw wkdw.lq dffrugdqfh zlwk lwvfrqvwlwxwlrqdopdqgdwh. wkhErpplvvlrq'v frqfhuq lv. e~ lwvrzq lqwhusuhwdwlrq.olplwhgwr flylo dqg srolwlfdouljkwv0

Fhvslwhwkhh}lvwhqfhri wkhErpplvvlrq rq Jxpdq Tljkwv.Ouv0Ctxlqr lvvxhg CgplqlvwudwlyhQughuPr0 323. gdwhgFhfhpehu 35. 3;::.fuhdwlqj d Jxpdq Tljkwv Erpplwwhh fkdluhg e~ wkh Uhfuhwdu~riLxvwlfh033;Vkh sulpdu~ ixqfwlrqv ri wklvfrpplwwhh duh wrprqlwru wkhRklolsslqh kxpdq uljkwv vlwxdwlrqdqg dgylvh wkhRuhvlghqwvr wkdwsurshu phdvxuhv fdq eh iruwkzlwk wdnhq hiihfwlyho~ dqg wr dvvlvwuhodwlyhvwrorfdwhshuvrqv zkr kdyh glvdsshduhg dqg duheholhyhg wrehghwdlqhg loohjdoo~0342Vkh frpplwwhh dovr uhfhlyhvfrpsodlqwv ri kxpdquljkwv ylrodwlrqv0343

KqlwvKqlwldoThsruw wr wkhJxpdq Tljkwv Erpplwwhh lq 3;:;vxeplwwhg sxuvxdqw wr Cuwlfoh62 ri wkh KEERT.344wkh Rklolsslqhjryhuqphqw vwdwhgwkhiroorzlqj phdvxuhv wkdwkdg ehhq wdnhqwrhqvxuhwkhlpsohphqwdwlrq ri wkhsurylvlrqv ri wkhKEERT<

(4) wkhderolwlrq ri wkhElyloldq Jrph Fhihqvh Hrufhv (EJFHv)dqg wkh glvpdqwolqj ri sulydwh duplhv dqg rwkhu duphg jurxsv(Jrzhyhu. Ouv0 Ctxlqr dssuryhg wkhfuhdwlrq ri wkhElwl°hq CuphgHrufh Ihrjudsklfdo Wqlwv ru ECHIWv. dqrwkhu sdudplolwdu~rujdql°dwlrq fxw lq wkhvdph prog dv wkhEJFHv)>

(5) wkhlpsrvlwlrq ri wkhghdwkshqdow~zdv surklelwhg lq wkhqhzErqvwlwxwlrq (Jrzhyhu. xqghu wkhvdph Erqvwlwxwlrq.wkhErqjuhvvpd~ uh/lpsrvh wkhghdwk shqdow~ iru frpshoolqj uhdvrqv lqyroylqjkhlqrxv fulphv)>

(6) wkhlvvxdqfh e~ Ouv0 Ctxlqr ri d phprudqgxp surylglqj iruwkhhgxfdwlrq rq kxpdq uljkwvri duuhvwlqjdqg lqyhvwljdwlqj shuvrqqho>

33:3g0

33;TGRQTV. supra qrwh 326. dw:0y'4r0)yo0

1211d., dw;03441g0

(7) wkhlvvxdqfh e~ wkhEklhi ri Uwdiiri wkhCuphg Hrufhv ri wkhRklolsslqhv ri d wurrs lqirupdwlrq dqg hgxfdwlrq ohwwhu/gluhfwlyhwr dooplolwdu~ frppdqghuv rq wkhvxemhfwvri kxpdq uljkwv. eloo ri uljkwvdqg kxpdqlwduldq odzv. fulplqdo surfhgxuh. wkhodz rq duuhvw.vhdufkdqg vhl°xuh. dqg vslulwxdodqg prudo hqkdqfhphqw>

(8) wkhlvvxdqfh e~ Ouv0 Ctxlqr ri dq h}hfxwlyh rughu surylglqjiru kxpdq uljkwvhgxfdwlrq lq vfkrrov dqg wkhlqfoxvlrq ri txhvwlrqv rqkxpdq uljkwvlq wkhflylo vhuylfh h}dplqdwlrqv>

(9) wkhsxeolfdwlrq e~ wkhfrqvwdexodu~ dqg srolfh ri d wudlqlqjphprudqgxp rq wkhhgxfdwlrq ri duuhvwlqjdqg lqyhvwljdwlqj shuvrqqhorq kxpdq uljkwv>

(:) wkh lvvxdqfh e~ wkh Pdwlrqdo Rrolfh Erpplvvlrq ri duhvroxwlrqsuhvfulelqj srolflhv rq duuhvwvdqg "lqylwdwlrqv">

(32) wkhlvvxdqfh e~ wkhEklhi ri Uwdii ri jxlgholqhv uhjduglqjkxpdq uljkwvpdwwhuv>

(33) wkh lvvxdqfh e~ wkh Uhfuhwdu~ri Pdwlrqdo Fhihqvh ri dgluhfwlyhwrwkhEklhi ri Uwdiifrqfhuqlqj wkhuhvshfwiru dqg revhuydqfhri kxpdq uljkwv>dqg

(34) wkh lvvxdqfh e~ wkh Uhfuhwdu~ri Lxvwlfh ri flufxoduv rqsurvhfxwruldo dvvlvwdqfhwr ylfwlpv ri kxpdq uljkwv ylrodwlrqv dqg wkhlqvshfwlrq ri mdlov0345

Kwpxvw dovreh dgghg wkdwwkhFhsduwphqwri Lxvwlfhkdv wdnhqvhyhudolqlwldwlyhvzklfk lqfoxgh wkhghvljqdwlrq ri flw~dqg surylqfldosurvhfxwruvdv vshfldosurvhfxwruviru kxpdq uljkwvfdvhv>wkhvhwwlqj/xsri d vhdufk qhwzrun lq fdvhv ri lqyroxqwdu~glvdsshdudqfhv> dqg wkhfrqwlqxrxv wuldori kxpdq uljkwvfdvhv0346

Rhqglqj lq wkhErqjuhvv duh eloovwr jlyh wkhErpplvvlrq rqJxpdq Tljkwv survhfxwruldo srzhuv0347 Cv vwdwhghduolhu.Ths0 CfwPr09277. zklfk judqwvflylo frxuwvmxulvglfwlrqryhu glphv frpplwwhg e~plolwdu~phq. kdv uhfhqwo~ehhq vljqhg0

Ykdw lv qrw vwdwhglq wkh lqlwldouhsruw ri wkh Rklolsslqhjryhuqphqw. krzhyhu. lv wkdwwkhhiiruwwrfrpso~ zlwk kxpdq uljkwvvwdqgdugvlv frqilqhg odujho~wrwkhxqghuwdnlqjvri wkhErpplvvlrq rq

123/d., dw;/34012?/d.347U0Pr0 448. :wk Erqj0. 4qg0 Uhvv (3;:9)0 Uhh dovr U0Pr0 3949. :wk Erqj0. 6wk

Uhvv0(3;;3) zklfk jlyhv ilvfdo dxwrqrp~ wr wkhErpplvvlrq rq Jxpdq Tljkwv0

Jxpdq Tljkwv0 Kwlv wkhuhiruhqrw srvvleoh wrhydoxdwh wkhjryhuqphqw'vuhvsrqvh wr wkh kxpdq uljkwv vlwxdwlrq lq wkh Rklolsslqhv zlwkrxwwkrurxjko~ uhylhzlqj wkhdffrpsolvkphqwv ri wkhErpplvvlrq0 Vkh ehvwjdxjh. wkhq. lv wkhuhsruwri wkhErpplvvlrq lwvhoirq lwvshuirupdqfh0

Kq wkh Uxppdu~ Thsruw rq EJT Qshudwlrqv iru 3;;2. wkhErpplvvlrq uhsruwhg wkdw.lq frqqhfwlrq zlwk lwvsulpdu~ ixqfwlrq rilqyhvwljdwlqj kxpdq uljkwv ylrodwlrqv. wkh EJT uhvroyhg d wrwdori4.44; frpsodlqwv1fdvhv lq 3;;2 glvsrvhg dv iroorzv< 843 ilohg lqfrxuwv1djhqflhv. 422 dufklyhg. 586 forvhg 1whuplqdwhgdqg 3.266 fdvhvuhvroyhg dwwkhuhjlrqdo ohyhoiru dufklyh1whuplqdwlrq dqg vxeplwwhg wrwkh Erpplvvlrq iru frqilupdwlrq0 Vkhvhfdvhv lqfoxghg lqflghqwv ri 3;;2dqg suhylrxv ~hduv0 Qxw ri wkh 4.44; uhvroyhg fdvhv. 843 zhuhhvwdeolvkhgkxpdq uljkwv ylrodwlrqv dqg zhuh fruuhvsrqglqjo~ ilohg lqfrxuwv1 dssursuldwh djhqflhv iru survhfxwlrq dqg1ru dgplqlvwudwlyhdfwlrq0348

Kwvkrxog eh dgghg wkdwiurp 3;:9 xs wrUhswhpehu 3;;2. d wrwdori ;44 kxpdq uljkwv fdvhv zhuh ilohg e~ wkh Erpplvvlrq zlwk wkhdssursuldwh djhqflhv iru survhfxwlrq dqg1ru dgplqlvwudwlyh dfwlrq0Jrzhyhu. ri wkhvh;44 fdvhv. rqo~ 8 kdyh vr idu uhvxowhglq frqylfwlrqvzkloh 6A ri wkhvh fdvhv kdyh ehhq glvplvvhg0349 Vklv orz udwhrifrqylfwlrq vkrzv wkh qhhg iru fohdu/fxw odzv rq ylrodwlrqv ri kxpdquljkwv. dv wkhylrodwruv duh dfwxdoo~ehlqj wulhgxqghu wkhjhqhudo shqdoodzv0 Vklv uhvxowdovr pdqlihvwv wkh ghod~ dqg lqdghtxdflhv lq wkhsurvhfxwlrq ri kxpdq uljkwvfdvhv0

Kqwklvfrqqhfwlrq. wkhErpplvvvlrq dqg vrph phpehuv ri wkhErqjuhvv kdyh sursrvhg wkhhqdfwphqw ri d Urfldo Lxvwlfhdqg JxpdqTljkiv Ergh dqg wkh fuhdwlrq ri vshfldo kxpdq uljkwv frxuwU034:Cvvwdwhge~ wkh Erpplvvlrq lwvhoi.wkh fuhdwlrq ri wkhvhvshfldo frxuwv"dqvzhuv wkh sureohp ri ghod~hg dgplqlvwudwlrq ri mxvwlfhlqyroylqjkxpdq uljkwv fdvhv0"34; Kqhvvhqfh. wkhvhvshfldo frxuwv zrxog kdyhmxulvglfwlrqryhu fdvhv zkhuh wkhdfwvfrpsodlqhg ri< (d) zhuh frpplwwhgzlwk dexvh ri dxwkrulw~>(e) uhvxowhglq wkhghsulydwlrq ri olih. lqmxu~.pdlplqj ru wruwxuhri wkhylfwlp iru srolwlfdo. uholjlrxv ru fxowxudoruhwkqlf uhdvrqv> ru (f) uhvxowhglq wkh ylrodwlrq ri flylo dqg srolwlfdouljkwv0

348EQOOKUUKQPQPJWOCPTKIoKVU.UWOOCT[TGRQTVQP EJT QRGTCVKQPUHQT3;;2 4 (3;;2) ]khuhlqdiwhuUWOOCT[b0

127ld., dw5/60128/d., dw90129/d.

Kqdq hiiruw wr suhyhqw jryhuqphqw dexvh. wkhErpplvvlrq.wrjhwkhuzlwk wkhodz hqirufhphqw djhqflhv. kdg gudzq xs jxlgholqhv lqwkh frqgxfw ri duuhvwv.vhdufkhv dqg vdwxudwlrqgulyhv. dqg wkhhvwdeolvkphqwri fkhfnsrlqwv035r Vkh hqdfwphqwri jxlgholqhv zdv duhdfwlrqwr wkhgluhfwlyhri wkhRklolsslqh Uxsuhph Erxuw lq ghflvlrqvwkdwkdg xskhog wkhydolglw~ri vdwxudwlrqgulyhv dqg fkhfnsrlqwv0o5o

Vkhvhghflvlrqv ri wkhJljk Erxuwkdg ehhq urxqgo~ fulwlfl°hge~ ohjdovfkroduv iru wkhluzhdn frqvwlwxwlrqdosuhplvhv dqg e~ kxpdq uljkwvdgyrfdwhv iru ehlqj frqwudu~wr wkhedvlf whqhwvri wkhsurwhfwlrq rilqglylgxdo uljkwv0

Covr. wkhErpplvvlrq kdv uhfhqwo~dssuryhg d vhwri jxlgholqhvrq wkhhydfxdwlrq ri wkhflyloldq srsxodwlrq gxulqj frxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~rshudwlrqv0354 Vkh jxlgholqhv doorz dffhvv e~ PIQv dqg surklelw wkhplol wdu~iurp dwwdfnlqj0flyloldq wdujhwvdqg uhvruwlqjwrwkhsudfwlfh rikdpohwwlqj0Cssduhqw iurp wkhvhjxlgholqhv lv wkhErpplvvlrq'v srolf~frqgrqlqj wkhfuhdwlrqri lqwhuqdouhixjhhv0 Vkhfhqwudofrqfhuq lq wkhvhjxlgholqhv lv wkdwwkhglvsodfhphqw eh dv wrohudeohiru wkrvhdiihfwhgdvsrvvleoh0 Kqidfw.wkhErpplvvlrq uhdglo~dffhswvwkhjryhuqphqw'v ylhzwkdw"wkhglvsodfhphqw ri idplolhv ru vr/fdoohg lqwhuqdouhixjhhv ]lvbdqxqiruwxqdwhvlgh hiihfwri d frxqwhulqvxujhqf~ vwudwhj~wkdwdlpv wrfxwlqvxujhqwvrii iurp wkhluedvhri vxssruw0"355

Ykdw lv qrwhzruwk~ lv wkdwwkhErpplvvlrq. e~ wdnlqj wkhohdglq wkh gudzlqj xs ri wkhvhlqwhu/djhqf~jxlgholqhv. kdv lq wkhplqgv rikxpdq uljkwvdgyrfdwhv sxw lwvlqghshqghqfh lq grxew e~ dffhswlqj

130ld., dw:0o53Uhh Xdoprqwh y0 Fh Xlood. 39: UETC 433 (3;:;) dqg Ixd°rq y0 Fh Xlood. 3:3

UETC 845 (3;;2)0 Vkh Ixlgholqhv lq wkhErqgxfw ri Cuuhvw.Uhdufkhv dqg UdwxudwlrqFulyh zdv vljqhg rq Uhswhpehu 3;. 3;;2 e~ wkhkhdgv ri wkhErpplvvlrq ri JxpdqTljkwv (EJT). Fhsduwphqw ri Lxvwlfh(F23). Fhsduwphqw ri Pdwlrqdo Fhihqvh (FPF) dqgwkhRklolsslqh Erqvwdexodu~1KqwhjudwhgPdwlrqdo Rrolfh (RE1KPR)0 Vkh vdolhqwsrlqwv riwkhjxlgholqhv lqfoxgh< (3) Txoh 335 ri wkh3;:7 Txohv rq Eulplqdo Rurfhgxuh. dv dphqghg.vkdooeh revhuyhg lq fdvhv ri duuhvwv.vhdufkhv dqg vhl°xuhv pdgh lq wkhfrxuvh ri vdwxudwlrqgulyhv> (4) vdwxudwlrqgulyhv vkdooeh frqgxfwhg rqo~ lq duhdv lghqwlilhg dv klgh/rxwv rifulplqdov ru vxeyhuvlyh hohphqwv ru ixjlwlyhv iurp mxvwlfh.survwlwxwlrqghqv. odluv risurklelwhg guxjv. dqg sodfhv ri loohjdo jdpeolqj dqg rwkhu loohjdodfwlylwlhv>(6) vdwxudwlrqgulyhv vkdooeh ohg e~ d uhvsrqvleoh dqg dffrxqwdeoh riilfhu dffrpsdqlhg e~ dq~ hohfwhgedudqjd~ riilfldo ri wkhduhd0 Vkh qdph1v ri wkhshuvrq1v duuhvwhgdqg wkhduuhvwlqjriilfhudqg wkhuhdvrq iru wkhduuhvwpxvw eh hqwhuhglq wkhedudqjd~ grfnhw> (6) fkhfnsrlqwv vkdoorqo~ eh hvwdeolvkhglq uhg dohuwvlwxdwlrqvru zkhq wkhuhlv d qhhg wr duuhvwd fulplqdo> (7)h}huflvh pd}lpxp wrohudqfhe~ odz hqirufhuv gxulqj udoolhv.vwulnhvdqg ghprqvwudwlrqv0Ndz hqirufhuv vkdooeh lq xqlirup zlwk wkhlulghqwlilfdwlrq fdug dqg qdphforwk rq lq doolqvwdqfhv.dv zhoo dv lq wkhfrqgxfw ri duuhvwvdqg vhdufkhv0

132Ree 4 C RTKOGTQP VJG JWOCP TKIJiU KUUWGKPVJG RJKNKRRKPGU<KUUWGUCPFCPUYGTU 9/; (3;;2)0

1331d., dw90

zlwkrxw txhvwlrq wkh frpsdwlelolw~ ri jryhuqphqw srolflhv zlwklqwhuqdwlrqdokxpdq uljkwvvwdqgdugv0Covr. e~ grlqj zkdw wkhmxvwlfhghsduwphqwri wkhh}hfxwlyheudqfk vkrxog eh grlqj. wkhErpplvvlrq kdvsxw lwvhoidwwkhohyhori d odz hqirufhphqw djhqf~0

Hxuwkhupruh.wkhErpplvvlrq. lq dffrugdqfh zlwk lwvvhfrqgdu~ixqfwlrqv xqghu wkhErqvwlwxwlrq.frqgxfwhg ylvlwdwlrqri mdlovdqgghwhqwlrq fhqwhuv0 Kq 3;;21 lw frqgxfwhg :29 mdloylvlwdwlrqvdqgghwhuplqhg wkdwlq 5:5 ri wkhvhmdlovwkhuhzhuh kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqvdqg lqkxpdq sulvrq frqglwlrqv.356 Vkh Erpplvvlrq uhfrpphqghguhphgldo phdvxuhv zklfk rq wkhzkroh uhodwhgwr wkhqhhg wr surylghpruh ixqgv iru wkhshqlwhqwldulhvwrdgguhvvwkhsureohpv ri phdjhu irrgudwlrqv. srru vdqlwdu~frqglwlrqv dqg lqdghtxdwh idflolwlhv0357Cv dqriivkrrw ri lwvmdloylvlwdwlrqsurjudp. wkhErpplvvlrq zdv deoh wrrewdlq wkhuhohdvhri shuvrqv zkr zhuh zurqjo~ mdlohg0358

Oruhryhu. wkhErpplvvlrq zdv deohwrjudqwvrph irxu ploolrqshvrv (derxw WU$3721222) lq ilqdqfldo dvvlvwdqfhwrylfwlpv ri kxpdquljkwvylrodwlrqv0359Orvwri wkhdprxqw zhuh jlyhq wrwkhkhluvri wkrvhzkr zhuh nloohg035:Cgplwwhgo~.wkhdprxqwv jlyhq dv dvvlvwdqfhzhuhuhodwlyho~vpdoo0 Dxwlwpxvw eh frqvlghuhg wkdwwkhvhdprxqwv rqo~frqvwlwxwhgdvvlvwdqfhdqg qrw frpshqvdwlrq iru ylfwlpv ri kxpdq uljkwvdexvhv wkdwwkhErqvwlwxwlrqvsrnh ri0o5;

Vkh Erpplvvlrq zdv dovr dfwlyhlq wkhglvvhplqdwlrq ri kxpdquljkwvlqirupdwlrq0 Kwfrqgxfwhg vhplqduv iru wkrxvdqgvri vroglhuvdqgsrolfhphq. jryhuqphqw riilfldov dqg hpsor~hhv. vwxghqwv.zrunhuv. dqgphpehuv ri PIQv0 Cffruglqj wrwkhErpplvvlrq. "]db33lq do3.7:.4::shuvrqv dwwhqghg JT lqirupdwlrq xqghuwdnlqjv lqfoxvlyh ri wkhvhplqduv1wudlqlqjv0"36r Vkh Erpplvvlrq dovr odxqfkhg vl} (9) uhjxodukxpdq uljkwvlqirupdwlrq udglr surjudpv0363

Kq ixoiloophqw ri lwvgxw~ wr prqlwru frpsoldqfh zlw!"!wkhreoljdwlrqv ri wkhRklolsslqhv xqghu lqwhuqdwlrqdofrqyhqwlrqv dqg

356UoL•OCT[0supra qrwh 3480dw330135/d., dw340136fd.; Uhh dovr Erpplvvlrq rq Jxpdq Tljkwv. Uxppdu~ Thsruw rq EJT

Qshudwlrqv (Ldqxdu~/Odufk 3;;3) (plphrjudskhg)0359UNL••CT[. supra qrwh 348. dw360138fd.

35;Rhqglqj lq wkhUhqdwhzlwk uhjdug wr frpshqvdwlrq ri ylfwlpv ri kxpdq uljkwvdexvhv duf<U0Pr0 588. olwkErqj0. 3vwUhvv0(3;:9) zklfk zloo surylgh iru d hrpshqvdwlrqvfkhph iru wkh ylfwlpv ri xqmxvwlpsulvrqphqw dqg U0Pr0 589. :wk Erqj0. 3vwUhvv.(K;ol9) zklfk zloo surylgh d frpshqvdwlrq surjudp wrylfwlpv ri ylrohqwfulphv0

140fd., dw4A13631o0. dwRK0

kxpdq uljkwv wuhdwlhv.wkhErpplvvlrq kdv vxeplwwhg frpphqwv wrydulrxv frpplwwhhv dqg zrunlqj jurxsv ri wkhW0P0Erpplvvlrq rqJxpdq Tljkwv dqg kdv dqvzhuhg txhulhv iurp lqwhuqdwlrqdovrxufhvuhjduglqj ylrodwlrqv ri kxpdq uljkwv lq wkhRklolsslqhv0364 Cwwklvsrlqw. rqh djdlq zrqghuv zkhwkhu wkh Erpplvvlrq lv uhdoo~dvlqghshqghqw dv lwkdv ehhq hqylvlrqhg wreh e~ wkhiudphuv ri wkh3;:9Erqvwlwxwlrq0Kwdsshduv wkdwwkhErpplvvlrq kdv ehfrph wkhvsrnhvpdqri wkhRklolsslqh jryhuqphqw rq lqwhuqdwlrqdokxpdq uljkwvlvvxhv0Vklvrevhuydwlrq lv erovwhuhge~ wkhidfwwkdwwkhCfwlqj Ekdlupdq ri wkhErpplvvlrq zdv rqh ri wkhriilfldo uhsuhvhqwdwlyhvri wkhRklolsslqhjryhuqphqw zkr suhvhqwhg wkhlqlwldouhsruwri wkhRklolsslqhv ehiruhwkhErpplwwhh rq Jxpdq Tljkwvdqg zdv dovrrqh ri wzr uhsuhvhqwdwlyhvzkr dqvzhuhg wkhtxhvwlrqv srvhg e~ phpehuv ri wkhErpplwwhh0 Vklvshfxoldu flufxpvwdqfh ilqgv h•sodqdwlrq iurp wkhidfwwkdw.dvlgh iurpkxpdq uljkwvdgyrfdwhv(zkrp wkhjryhuqphqw dffxvhv ri ehlqj vwrrjhvri wkhfrppxqlvw Pdwlrq•LFhprfudwlf Hurqw).lwlv rqo~ wkhErpplvvlrqzklfk kdv lqirupdwlrq rq wkh kxpdq uljkwv vlwxdwlrq lq wkhRklolsslqhv0 Vkh Fhsduwphqw ri Hruhljq Ciidluv. dowkrxjk lwkdv dqQiilfh iru Jxpdq Tljkwv dqg Jxpdqlwduldq Ciidluv. kdv qr kxpdquljkwvgdwdedvh ri lwvrzq dqg uholhvh}foxvlyho~rq wkhgdwdri wkhErpplvvlrq0 Vkxv. zkloh wkhErpplvvlrq lv. rq wkhgrphvwlf iurqw.lqyhvwljdwlqj kxpdq uljkwv dexvhv frpplwwhg e~ shuvrqv lq wkhjryhuqphqw. lqwhuqdwlrqdoo~.lwlv ghihqglqj wkhkxpdq uljkwvuhfrug riwkhvdph jryhuqphqw0 Vklv pl}wxuh ri urohvpdnhv wkh0lqwhjulw~dqglqghshqghqfh ri wkhErpplvvlrq rshq wrvxvslflrq0

Gyhq grphvwlfdoo~.wkhErpplvvlrq kdv ehhq fulwlfl°hgehfdxvhri lwvvhhplqj lqdelolw~wrsuhyhqwkxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqvfrpplwwhg e~wkrvhlq jryhuqphqw0 Dxwwkhq.zh kdyh wrfrqvlghu wkdwwkhErpplvvlrqzdv hqylvlrqhg wreh dq lqghshqghqw zdwfkgrj. qrwd uhjxodueudqfk rijryhuqphqw wdvnhgzlwk wkhhqirufhphqw ri odzv0 Ykloh lwfdq lqlwldwhphdvxuhv wr suhyhqwkxpdq uljkwv dexvhv iurp rffxuulqj. lwlv rqo~vhfrqgdu~ wr lwvsulpdu~ ixqfwlrq ri lqyhvwljdwlqj fdvhv ri ylrodwlrqv0Vkh suhyhqwlrq ri ylrodwlrqv e~ wkrvhlq dxwkrulw~lv d pdwwhuwkdwlvwkhsulpdu~ frqfhuq ri wkhh}hfxwlyheudqfk ri wkhjryhuqphqw0

Vkh uhvxowlv wkdwwkhErpplvvlrq. lq wu~lqjwrsohdvhlwvfulwlfv.lv qrz dvnlqj Erqjuhvv wkdwlweh judqwhgwkhsrzhu wrsurvhfxwhkxpdquljkwvylrodwlrqv0365 Kiwklvzrxog eh judqwhg.wkhErpplvvlrq zloo fhdvhwreh d zdwfkgrj exwzlooehfrph d olqhsurvhfxwruldodjhqf~ qr gliihuhqwiurp wkh survhfxwruldo erglhv lq wkhh}hfxwlyh eudqfk0 Ykr zloohydoxdwhwkhErpplvvlrq wrghwhuplqh li lwlv surshuo~ shuiruplqj lwv

142ld .• dw3;03655 I RTKOGTQP VKoGJWOCP TKIJVU KUUWGKPVKoGRJKNKRRKPGU<KUUWGUCPF

CPUYGTU 39 (3;;2)0

ixqfwlrqv dv survhfxwruB Jrz wkhqfdq lwhiihfwlyho~prqlwru Rklolsslqhfrpsoldqfh zlwk lwvreoljdwlrqv xqghu lqwhuqdwlrqdokxpdq uljkwvlqvwuxphqwvli lwvyhu~shuirupdqfh dv survhfxwru lv rqh ri wkhpdlq duhdvwreh prqlwruhgB KqwkhuxvkwrjudqwwkhErpplvvlrq pruh srzhuv. wkhvhtxhvwlrqvkdyh vrphkrz ehhq ljqruhg0

Ykloh wkhRklolsslqh ghohjdwlrq kdv ehhq frpphqghg e~ wkhEkdlupdq ri wkhJxpdq Tljkwv Erpplwwhh iru wkhv~vwhpdwlfzd~ lqzklfk lwkdv wdnhqwkhtxhvwlrqv dqg iru wkhfrpsuhkhqvlyhqhvv dqgiudqnqhvv ri lwvdqvzhuv. pxfk lv wreh vdlg uhjduglqj wkhslfwxuh wkdwwkh uhsruw sdlqwv ri wkh kxpdq uljkwv vlwxdwlrqlq wkhRklolsslqhvwrgd~0 Ykloh wkhuhsruwpdnhv wkhdqqxdo uhsruwri wkhErpplvvlrq rqJxpdq Tljkwv dq dqqh}.o66lwfrqyhqlhqwo~idlovwrlqfoxgh lq wkherg~ riwkhuhsruwvwdwlvwlfvrq ylrodwlrqvri kxpdq uljkwv0

Oruhryhu. wkhlqlwldouhsruw0olplwv lwvhoiwr wkhsuQXoUorqvriRklolsslqh odz uhodwlqjwr wkhvshflilf surylvlrqv ri wkhKEERT.367Kwlvfrpprq nqrzohgjh wkdwwkhh}lvwhqfhri odzv dorqh grhv qrw suhyhqwylrodwlrqvri kxpdq uljkwvru hqvxuhuhguhvvdqg frpshqvdwlrq wkhuhiru0Ykdw lv hvvhqwldolv wkdwwkhvhodzv eh hqirufhg zlwk fhuwdlqw~.fhohulw~dqg xqliruplw~ djdlqvwwkrvhzkr ylrodwhwkhp0

Vkh wuxh slfwxuh ri wkh kxpdq uljkwv vlwxdwlrq lq wkhRklolsslqhv fdph rxw rqo~ zkhq wkh h}shuwv txhvwlrqhg wkhuhsuhvhqwdwlyhvri wkh Rklolsslqhv rq sduwlfxoduylrodwlrqv vxfk dvlqy2oxqwdu~ glvdsshdudkfhv. irufhg pdvv hydfxdwlrqv. h}wudmxglfldoh}hfxwlrqv. wkhnloolqj ri kxpdq uljkwv odz~huv dqg wkhdfwlylwlhvriyljlodqwh jurxsv0368 Dxwhyhq wkhq.zkdw zdv uhyhdohglq wkhgldorjxhzhuh rqo~ elwvdqg slhfhv ri wkhzkroh slfwxuh0

366cee QHHKEGQHJWOCP TKIJVU CPF JWOCPKVCTKCPCHHCKTU.FGRCTVOGPVQHHQTGKIPCHHCKTU.4 EKXKNCPF RQNKVKECNTKIJVUKPVKoGRoooNKRRKPGU<VJGRJKNKRRKPGKPKVKCNTGRQTVVQVKoGJWOCP TKIJVUEQOOK3VGG73/79 (3;;2) ]khuhlqdiwhuTGRQTVKKb0

367 io0Dxwiurp d whfkqlfdosrlqw ri ylhz. wkhRklolsslqh uhsruwzdv lq ixoofrpsoldqfhzlwk wkhuhtxluhphqwv ri wkhErpplwwhh iru dq lqlwldouhsruw(EERTKN17)0 Vkh jxlgholqhvuhtxluh wkdwwkhiluvwsduwri wkhuhsruw ghvfuleh wkhjhqhudo ohjdo iudphzrun zlwklq zklfkflylo dqg srolwlfdo uljkwv duh surwhfwhg0 zlwk sduwlfxodu hpskdvlv rq frqvwlwxwlrqdosurylvlrqv0 hqirufhphqw phfkdqlvpv. mxulvglfwlrq ri frxuwv. ohjdo uhphglhv dqg uhodwhgphdvxuhv0 Vkh vhfrqg sduwri wkhlqlwldouhsruw lv rq lqirupdwlrq uhodwlyhwr wkhuljkwvsurwhfwhglq vshflilf surylvlrqv ri wkhErqyhqwlrq. sduwlfxoduo~<ohjlvodwlyh.dgplqlvwudwlyhdqg rwkhu phdvxuhv> uhvwulfwlrqvru olplwdwlrqv rq wkhri wkhuljkw>idfwruv ru gliilfxowlhvdowhulqjwkhhqmr~phqw ri wkhuljkwv0 Uwdwhuhsruwvduhuhtxluhg wr iroorz wkdwirupdw0

146/d.

Kwvkrxog eh eruqh lq plqg wkdwwkhsxusrvh ri uhsruwlqj lv wrghwhuplqh wkhsureohpv frqfhuqlqj wkhrevhuydqfh ri dqg uhvshfwirukxpdq uljkwvdqg wrilqg vroxwlrqvwrwkhvhsureohpv0 Vklvh}sodlqv wkhlqyroyhphqwri kxpdq uljkwvh}shuwvlq wkhuhsruwlqjsurfhvv0 C frxqwu~frxog qrw fodlp wkdwvxfk surfhvv "lqwhuihuhv"zlwk wkhluqdwlrqdovry•uhljqw~ dv wkhfrxqwu~ lwvhoi.e~ ehlqj d vwdwhsduw~wr d kxpdquljkwv lqvwuxphqw. kdv yroxqwdulo~ dvvxphg wkh reoljdwlrq wrshulrglfdoo~ uhsruwrq lwvfrpsoldqfh0 Cv vwdwhglq wkhW0P0Odqxdo rqJxpdq TljkwvThsruwlqj<

Vkh vxeplvvlrq ri uhsruwvwr wuhdw~prqlwrulqj erglhv lv d ohjdoreoljdwlrq lqfxpehqw xsrq wkhjryhuqphqwv ri Uwdwhvsduwlhv0Ulqfhwklvreoljdwlrq e~ lwvqdwxuhuhtxluhv srvlwlyh dfwlrq. wkhsrolwlfdozloowr suhsduh dq krqhvw dqg frpsuhkhqvlyh uhsruw.dqg wr doorfdwhwkhqhfhvvdu~ uhvrxufhv dffruglqjo~. lv d suhuhtxlvlwhiru lwvuhdol°dwlrq0

Vkh srolwlfdoohdghuvkls pd~ shufhlyh wkhreoljdwlrq wruhsruwwr dqlqwhuqdwlrqdowuhdw~prqlwrulqj erg~ rq wkhfrxqwu~'v kxpdq uljkwvshuirupdqfh dv dq lpsdluphqw rq vryhuhljqw~0 Kwpd~ vhh wklvreoljdwlrq dv d "furzedu". e~ wkhxvh ri zklfk rwkhuUwdwhvpljkwvhhn wr rewdlq iruhljq srolf~ ohyhudjh djdlqvw wkhuhsruwlqj Uwdwh0Uxfk uhsruwlqj pd~ eh h}sorlwhge~ xqv~psdwkhwlfqrq/jryhuqphqwdorujdql°dwlrqv (PIQv)0 Vkhvh dqg vlplodu frqvlghudwlrqv pd~ ohdgwrwkhsuhsdudwlrq ri uhsruwv wkdw frqwdlq lqvxiilflhqw ru lqdffxudwhlqirupdwlrq xsrq zklfk wkhh}shuwerglhv duhh}shfwhg wredvh wkhludfwlrqv lq hiihfwlyho~h}hfxwlqj wkhwdvnvhqwuxvwhgwrwkhp xqghu wkhydulrxv frqyhqwlrqv0

Dxwvxfk dq dssurdfk uhiohfwvd qxpehu ri xqiruwxqdwhplvfrqfhswlrqv0Vkh idfw wkdwd jryhuqphqw kdv udwlilhgd sduwlfxodukxpdq uljkwvlqvwuxphqwlv lwvhoihylghqfh ri dq lqlwldofrpplwphqw e~ wkhsrolwlfdoohdghuvklswrwkhlqwhuqdwlrqdosurwhfwlrqri kxpdq uljkwv0Kwdiilupvyhu~ fohduo~wkdwwkhdfwri uhsruwlqj lv qrw frqvlghuhg e~ dq~ Uwdwhwrlqiulqjh grphvwlf vryhuhljqw~0 Oruhryhu. wkh uhsruwlqj v~vwhplv dzd~ ri vkrzlqj PIQv dqg rwkhulqwhuhvwhgsduwlhvwkdwwkhjryhuqphqwlv frpso~lqj zlwk wkhuhohydqw lqwhuqdwlrqdosurfhgxuhv dqg lv qrwfrqfhdolqj dq~wklqj0

C jryhuqphqw vkrxog uhfrjql°h wkh lpsruwdqw ixqfwlrqv zklfkuhsruwlqj pd~ vhuyh lq wkhqdwlrqdo srolf~ pdnlqj surfhvv. dqgvkrxog zhofrph wkh frqwulexwlrq wkdw wkh qrq/mxgjphqwdo.frqvwuxfwlyhgldorjxh zlwk h}shuwerglhv pdnhv wrzdug wkhsurprwlrqdqg surwhfwlrqri lwvflwl°hqv'kxpdq uljkwv0Vr wklvhqg. wkhsrolwlfdoohdghuvklsvkrxog vhhn dqg hydoxdwhdoolqirupdwlrq. idyrxudeoh dqgohvvidyrxudeoh. lq suhsdulqj d frpsuhkhqvlyh dqg dffxudwh uhiBuwxqghu dq~ ri wkhkxpdq uljkwvwuhdwlhvghdowzlwk lq wklvOdqxdo0o 9

369WPKVGF PCVKQPU JWOCP TKpuuU EQOOKVVGG. WPKVGF PCVKQPU OCPWCN QPJWOCP TKIoKVUTGRQTVKPI 39 (3;;2)0

Dxwlw lv khduwhqlqj wr qrwh wkdwwkhuhsuhvhqwdwlyhvri wkhRklolsslqh jryhuqphqw. diwhudqvzhulqj wkhtxhvwlrqv srvhg e~ wkhphpehuv ri wkhErpplwwhh. kdyh uhfrjql°hg wkdwlqghhg wkhuhlv d judyhsureohp wr eh dgguhvvhg0 Vkxv. wkhCvvlvwdqwHruhljq Uhfuhwdu~kdvvwdwhg<

0 0 0 Vkh txhvwlrq wkdwkdg ehhq jhqhudoo~ dvnhg dqg wkhrevhuydwlrq wkdwkdv ehhq pdgh< Yh vhhp wr kdyh jrrg odzv0 Yhvhhp wr kdyh wkhfruuhfw lqvwlwxwlrqv0Ykdw wkhqlv wkhsureohpB Kvlw.dv rqh ri wkhglvwlqjxlvkhg E23'Kouwolwwhhphpehuv vdlg. wkh odfn risrolwlfdo zlooB NhdghuvklsB UwuxfwxudoB

Cv zh kdyh vdlg lq rxu lqlwldo vwdwhphqw/ lw lv wr vrph h}whqwdfrpelqdwlrq ri pdq~ idfwruv0Kwklqn wkdwzh pxvw srlqw rxw wkdwwkuhh~hduv lq wudqvlwlrqlv uhodwlyho~d vkrul wlph frqvlghulqj ghhs urrwhgsureohpv. vrph ri zklfk duh zlwk klvwrulfdovrxufhv0 Vkuhh ~hduv lv wrrvkruw wr h}shfw wkdwdoo vrxufhv ri kxpdq uljkwv ylrodwlrqv lq wkhRklolsslqhv frxog eh dgguhvvhg wr ixoovdwlvidfwlrq0Dxw.zh vxeplw. zhkdyh frph ehiruh wklvErpplwwhh. zh kdyh jlyhq ~rx d ixoodffrxqw rizkdw phdvxuhv kdg ehhq wdnhqdqg wkrvhzh krsh wrwdnh.dqg zh dvvxuh~rx wkdwzh zloo frqwlqxh zkdwhyhu surjuhvv zh kdyh vwduwhgdqg zhdovr zrxog zdqw wr dvvxuh~rx wkdwwkhohdghuvkls dqg lwvsrolwlfdo zloodwsuhvhqwlv dwixoodffrug zlwk wkhEryhqdqw036:

Vkh Cfwlqj Ekdlupdq ri wkhErpplvvlrq rq Jxpdq Tljkwv.zkloh uhfrjql°lqj sureohpv lq wkh kxpdq uljkwv vlwxwdwlrqlq wkhRklolsslqhv. wulhgwr riihu dq h}sodqdwlrq wkdwzrxog h}fxosdwh wkhjryhuqphqw ri Ouv0Ctxlqr0 Jh vdlg<

Dhiruh Kfrqfoxgh. rqh txhv3lrq nhsw ulqjlqj lqwr p~ hduv< [hv. zhkdyh doo wkh uxohv dqg uhjxodwlrqv0 [hv. zh kdyh wkh djhqflhvlpsohphqwlqj wkhvhuxohv dqg uhjxodwlrqv0 [hw. wkhuhshuvlvwvwr ehdoohjhg kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqv0 Ykdw frxog eh wkhuhdvrqB Kzrxogolnh wr yhq3xuh dqg vd~. Ou0 Ekdlupdq. wkdwzkhq Ou0 Odufrvghvwur~hg wkhghprfudwlf vwuxfwxuhvri wkh qdwlrq e~ lpsrvlqj pduwldoodz. kh dovr ghvwur~hg wkhprudo rughu ri wkhHlolslqr shrsoh0 Kwlv iruwklvuhdvrq wkdwRuhvlghq3 Ctxlqr kdv sxw iruzdug wkhlvvxh ri kxpdquljkwv dv wkh fhqwhuslhfh ri khu dgplqlvwudwlrq zlwk wkh krsh rifuhdwlqj d qhz prudo rughu. zkhuh wkh Hlolslqr shrsoh ghvslwhlghrorjlfdo gliihuhqfhv dqg hwkqlf dqg fxowxudoruljlqv. pd~ olyh lqshdfh dqg kduprq~036;

Vkhvh vwdwhphqwvzhuh pdgh pruh wkdq wzr ~hduv djr0Cowkrxjk wkhErpplvvlrq rq Jxpdq Tljkwvkdg qrwhgd ghfuhdvhri 39%lq wkhqxpehu ri fdvhvri kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqvuhsruwhgwrlwlq 3;;2.372wkh idfw uhpdlqhg wkdw pxfk vwlookdg wr eh grqh wr ixoiloo wkh

36:TGRQTVKK.supra qrwh 366. dw67036G1o" dw790372UWOOCT[.supra qrwh 348. dw30

frqvwlwxwlrqdopdqgdwh iru d uhjlph irxqghg rq uhvshfwiru kxpdq uljkwvdqg wr pdwhuldoo~frpso~ zlwk wkh vwdqgdugv ri lqwhuqdwlrqdokxpdquljkwv lqvwuxphqwv0

Dhiruh wkhuhfdq eh dq~ phdqlqjixo glvfxvvlrq rq Rklolsslqhvxevwdqwlyhdqg surfhgxudo odz rq kxpdq uljkwv. wkhh}dfw uroh ri wkhErpplvvlrq rq Jxpdq Tljkwv pxvw iluvweh fodulilhg0 Cv vwdwhghduolhu.lw dsshduv wkdwwkh ESpplvvlrq. dqg wkh sxeolf. duh qrw uhdoo~ wrrfhuwdlq derxw zkdw wkh iruphu'v uroh uhdoo~ lv0 Ykloh lw kdv ehhqruljlqdoo~ hqylvlrqhg wr eh d kxpdq uljkwv zdwfkgrj. wkhuhlv qrz dghpdqg wkdwlwdvvxph wkh uroh ri vwdwhsurvhfxwru iru ylrodwlrqv rikxpdq uljkwv0 Vkh Erpplvvlrq lwvhoi kdv oreelhg iru wkh judqw risurvhfxwruldo srzhuv0 Kqwkhzrugv ri d phpehu ri wkhErpplvvlrq. q]lwbkdv ehhq wkhh}shulhqfh ri wkhErpplvvlrq wkdwprqlwrulqj d kxpdquljkwvfdvh lq frxuw lv qrw vxiilflhqw0 000 WqohvvwkhErpplvvlrq lv jlyhqsurvhfxwru~ srzhu. lwvlqwhuyhqwlrqdqg dvvlvwdqfhpd~ qrw qhfhvvdulo~ehixwlohexw pd~ eh zhdn wr wuxo~hqirufh dgkhuhqfh wr kxpdq uljkwvvdihjxdugv dqg ohjdo phdvxuhv0qoUKVkh fodpru lv odujho~ gxh wr wkhsxeolf shufhswlrq wkdwwkh uhjxodu survhfxwruldo djhqflhv ri wkhjryhuqphqw duh lqhiihfwlyh lq survhfxwlqj kxpdq uljkwvfdvhv0

Dxwlwpxvw djdlq eh srlqwhg rxw wkdwli wkhErpplvvlrq lv pdghwr dvvxph wkhuroh ri survhfxwru. lwzloo qrz eh hvvhqwldoo~sod~lqj wkhsduwri wkhuhjxodu jryhuqphqw survhfxwruldo vhuylfh0 Jrz wkhqpd~ wkhErpplvvlrq eh dq hiihfwlyh zdwfkgrj zkhq rqh ri wkhdjhqflhv lwkdv wrzdwfk ryhu dqg prqlwru zrxog eh lwvhoiB C vroxwlrq wkdwgrhv qrw sxwwkh lqwhjulw~dqg lqghshqghqfh ri wkh Erpplvvlrq lq grxew vkrxogwkhuhiruheh irxqg0 Rhukdsv dq Qiilfh ri Ushfldo Rurvhfxwru iru JxpdqTljkwv vkrxog eh fuhdwhgwr survhfxwh uhsruwhg ylrodwlrqv uhihuuhg wr lwe~ wkh Erpplvvlrq. wkh suhvlghqwldo frpplwwhh. qrq/jryhuqphqwdorujdql°dwlrqv. sulydwh lqglylgxdov dqg rwkhuv0KU4

Vkh Erpplvvlrq'v hiiruwwreh jlyhq survhfxwruldo srzhuv lpsolhvwkdwlwvfrqfhuq odujho~ olhv zlwk dexvhv wkdwkdyh douhdg~ rffxuuhg0Vkh dssurdfk ri PIQv kdv ehhq wr frruglqdwh forvho~ zlwk fkxufk

KU3C0Csruwdghud.Lu0.Oroblems and Hssues on Guman Qights Bases, 5VJGLWFIG'ULQWTPCN 450

KU4WqghuCuw0ZKri !khRklolsslqhErqvwlwxwlrqrq !kh dffrxqwdelolw~ri sxeolfriilfhuv.!khQpexgvpdq lqyhvwljdwhvdq~dfwru rplvvlrq ri dq~sxeolfriilfldo.hpsor~hh.riilfhu ru djhqf~. zkhuhvxfkdfwru rplvvlrq dsshduvwreh loohjdo.xqmxvw.lpsurshu rulqhiilflhqw0Vkh survhfxwlrqri wkhvhhuulqjsxeolf riilfhuv lv d wdvnjlyhq e~ wkhfrqvwlwxwlrqwr!khQiilfh ri !khUshfldoRurvhfxwru0

jurxsv dqg wrprqlwru plolwdu~frxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~ rshudwlrqvlq dq hiiruwwrglvfryhu srvvleoh kxpdq uljkwvdexvhv dqg suhyhqwixuwkhuylrodwlrqv0Vkh Erpplvvlrq. rq wkhrwkhukdqg. frphv lq rqo~ zkhq d ylrodwlrq lvuhsruwhgru ehfrphv ri sxeolf nqrzohgjh. iru wkhsxusrvh ri ghwhuplqlqjzkhwkhu wkhuhlv suredeoh fdxvh wr uhihu wkhfdvh wr wkhdssursuldwhdjhqf~ iru survhfxwlrq0 Vklv lv uhjuhwwdeohvlqfh xqghu wkhErqvwlwxwlrq.lw pd~ "]sburylgh dssursuldwh ohjdo phdvxuhv iru wkh surwhfwlrq rikxpdq uljkwv ri doo shuvrqv zlwklq wkh Rklolsslqhv0"375 Kwvkrxoglqfoxgh wdnlqj wkh dssursuldwh vwhsvwr hqvxuh wkdwylrodwlrqv duhsuhyhqwhgiurp rffxuulqj0 Ur idu. wkhwkuxvwri Erpplvvlrq dfwlrq kdvehhq wr sduwlflsdwhlq wkhirupxodwlrq ri jxlgholqhv wr jryhuq srolfh.plolwdu~ dqg sdudplolwdu~ dfwlrq uhodwlyhwr wkhfrqgxfw ri frxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~ rshudwlrqv0 Ykdwlv lghdolv iru wkhErpplvvlrq wrrevhuyh lqduhdv zkhuh kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqv pd~ doprvw vxuho~rffxu. Nh0.lqduhdvzkhuh lqvxujhqf~ lv d sureohp0 Cv d vwduw.wkhErpplvvlrq pljkwilhogrevzuyhuvwrprqlwru pdmrufrxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~ rshudwlrqvlq rughu wrhqvxuh wkhvdihw~ri flyloldqv0 Uwulfwo~vshdnlqj wklvzloo h}sdqg wkhErpplvvlrq'v frqfhuq wr kxpdqlwduldq pdwwhuv.exw wklvlv hvvhqwldolikxpdq uljkwvduhwreh hiihfwlyho~surwhfwhg0

Vkhuh lv dovr wkhfrpprq frpsodlqw wkdwwkhflylo frxuwv dqgplolwdu~wulexqdovduhqrwgrlqj d jrrg mrelq wu~lqjfdvhv iru ylrodwlrqvri kxpdq uljkwv0Vkxv. wkhErpplvvlrq lwvhoikdv sursrvhg wkhfuhdwlrqri vshfldo kxpdq uljkwvfrxuwv0 Vklv dsshduv wreh d vrxqg sursrvdo0Jrzhyhu. ehiruh wkhvhfrxuwv duh fuhdwhgru vshfldo survhfxwruv irukxpdq uljkwv duh dssrlqwhg. lwpxvw iluvweh ghilqlwho~dvfhuwdlqhgzkdw Rklolsslqh odzv pd~ eh lqyrnhg e~ rqh zkrvh kxpdq uljkwvkdyhehhq ylrodwhg0Kwlv xqqhfhvvdu~ wkdwwkhvhglvsdudwhsurylvlrqv ri odzeh dfwxdoo~frglilhg dv wkhErpplvvlrq dqg vrph phpehuv ri wkhErqjuhvv vxjjhvw> doowkdwlv qhfhvvdu~ lv wkdwwkhvh eh lghqwlilhg.frpslohg dqg fodvvlilhg lq uhodwlrqwr wkh qdwxuh ri wkh dydlodeohuhphglhv0 Hxuwkhupruh. wkh pdwwhuri krz wkh surylvlrqv ri wkhlqwhuqdwlrqdokxpdq uljkwvlqvwuxphqwvwr zklfk wkhRklolsslqhv lv dvwdwhsduw~ pd~ eh lqyrnhg lq Rklolsslqh frxuwvvkrxog dovreh h}soruhgdqg h}sodlqhg0 Ur idu. kxpdq uljkwvolwljdwlrqlq wkhRklolsslqhv kdvirfxvhg pdlqo~ rq wkhylrodwlrqv ri vshflilf surylvlrqv ri Rklolsslqhvwdwxwhv0Kwzrxog khos wkhylfwlpv ri kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqv li wkh~duh dovr dssulvhg ri wkhsurylvlrqv ri lqwhuqdwlrqdolqvwuxphqwvzklfkwkh~ pd~ lqyrnh lq Rklolsslqh frxuwv ru dgplqlvwudwlyherglhv. lqdgglwlrq wr wkhsurylvlrqv ri Rklolsslqh vwdwxwhv0Vkhuhdiwhu.dq hiiruwvkrxog eh pdgh wr sxeolvk wklvfrpsuhkhqvlyh frpslodwlrq dwwkh

h}shqvh ri wkhjryhuqphqw vr wkdwwkhshrsoh pd~ nqrz ri wkhluuljkwvdqg uhphglhv0

Ruhsdudwru~wr ru vlpxowdqhrxv zlwk wkhfuhdwlrq ri vshfldokxpdq uljkwv frxuwv dqg wkhdssrlqwphqw ri vshfldo kxpdq uljkwvsurvhfxwruv. plolwdu~frxuwv vkrxog eh ghsulyhg ri mxulvglfwlrqryhufulphv frpplwwhg djdlqvw flyloldqv0 Vklv vwhs kdv douhdg~ ehhqsduwldoo~dffrpsolvkhg zlwk wkhuhshdori RuhvlghqwldoFhfuhh Pr0 3:72wkurxjk wkhsurpxojdwlrq ri Thsxeolf Cfw9277 Uljqhg odvwLxqh42. 3;;30Thsxeolf Cfw9277376vwdwhvlq sduw<

Ohpehuv ri wkh Cuphg Hrufhv ri wkh Rklolsslqhv dqg rwkhushuvrqv vxemhfwwr plolwdu~ odz. lqfoxglqj phpehuv ri wkhElwl°hqvCuphg Hrufhv Ihrjudsklfdo Wqlwv.zkr frpplw fulphv ru riihqvhvshqdol°hg xqghu wkhThylvhg Rhqdo Ergh. rwkhu vshfldo shqdo odzv. ruorfdo jryhuqphqw ruglqdqfhv. uhjdugohvvri zkhwkhu ru qrw flyloldqv duhfr/dffxvhg. ylfwlpv. ru ?Aiihqghg sduwlhv zklfk pd~ eh qdwxudorumxulglfdo shuvrqv. vkdooeh wulhge~ wkhsurshu flyloldq frxuw. h}fhswzkhq wkhriihqvh. dv ghwhuplqhg ehiruh duudljqphqw e~ wkhflylo frxuw.lv vhuylfh/frqqhfwhg. lq zklfk fdvh wkhriihqvh vkdooeh wulhge~ wkhfrxuw pduwldo>Rurylghg. wkdwwkhRuhvlghqwri wkhRklolsslqhv pd~. lqwkhlqwhuhvwri mxvwlfh.rughu ru gluhfwdwdq~wlph ehiruh duudljqphqw wkdwdq~ vxfk fulphv ru riihqvhv eh wulhge~ wkhsurshu flylo frxuwv0

Cv xvhg lq wklvUhfwlrq. vhuylfh/frqqhfwhg fulphv ru riihqvhv vkdooeh olplwhg wr wkrvh ghilqhg lq Cuwlfohv76 wr92. Cuwlfohv94 wr ;4. dqgCuwlfohv;7 wr ;9 ri Erpprqzhdowk Cfw Pr0 62:. dv dphqghg0

Vkh uhshdo ri RuhvlghqwldoFhfuhh Pr0 3:72 kdg hduolhuehhqrssrvhg e~ wkhplolwdu~"rq wkhjurxqg wkdwwkhuhehovfdq sdudo~°hplolwdu~rshudwlrqv e~ xvlqj flyloldq frxuwvwrvxesrhqd vroglhuvrq wkhiurqw.dqg hyhq dvvdvvlqdwhwkhp rq wkhluzd~ wr wkhfrxuw0"377Kwzdvdovr frqwhqghg wkdw"wkhplolwdu~v~vwhplv idvwhu.pruh hiilflhqw dqgohvvkdpshuhg e~ wkhwhfkqlfdolwlhvwkdwhqdeoh wkhdffxvhg wr hydghwkhflyloldq frxuwv0"K78Vklvdujxphqw kdv phulwli wkhv~vwhpvzrun dvlqwhqghg0 Jrzhyhu. wkhvhgr qrw frqvlghu wkhedvlf frpsodlqw rq wkhidloxuh ri wkhplolwdu~wr survhfxwh lwvphpehuv zkr frpplw kxpdquljkwvdexvhv0 Qqh vkrxog dovrfrqvlghu wkhqdwxudowhqghqf~ri d ylfwlp

376hqwlwohg"Cq Cfw Uwuhqjwkhqlqj Elyloldq Uxsuhpdf~ Qyhu Vkh Ololwdu~ D~Thwxuqlqj Vr Vkh Elylo ErxuwvVkh Lxulvglfwlrq Qyhu EhuwdlqQiihqvhv Kqyroylqj OhpehuvQi Vkh Cuphg Hrufhv Qi Vkh Rklolsslqhv. QwkhuRhuvrqv UxemhfwVr Ololwdu~Ndz. CqgVkh Ohpehuv Qi Vkh Rklolsslqh Pdwlrqdo Rrolfh. Thshdolqj Hru Vkh Rxusrvh EhuwdlqRuhvlghqwldoFhfuhhv0"

377s0 Cpeurvlr. Rhould BGQ be Dmpowered to Orosecute Bases< RpWRRKPGJWOCPTKIJVUOQPKVQT9 (Ushfldo Kvvxhrq wkh62wkCqqlyhuvdu~ ri wkhWqlyhuvdoFhfodudwlrq riwkhDloori Tljkwv)0

156/d.

ri dexvh wr ghvlvw iurp frpsodlqlqj wr wkh plolwdu~ hvwdeolvkphqwehfdxvh ri ihdu ri uhwdoldwlrq0

Cowkrxjk wkh uhshdo ri R0 F0 Pr0 3:72 lv d zhofrphghyhorsphqw. wkhsureohp olhvlq wkhlpsohphqwdwlrq ri wkhqhz odz0Oruhryhu. zkloh kxpdq uljkwv odz~huv' jurxsv olnh wkh Huhh NhjdoCvvlvwdqfh Iurxs (HNCI) kdyh vdlg wkdwlw lv d vwhs lq wkh uljkwgluhfwlrq. wkh~kdyh qrwhg wkdwzkdw lv qhhghg lv d uhrulhqwdwlrqri wkhplolwdu~ plqgvhw wkdweholhyhv lwvhoiwr eh deryh wkhodz dqg fduhvolwwohiru kxpdq uljkwv0KUBCffruglqj wr HNCI. "xqwlowkhvhshuydvlyhsv~fkrorjlfdo dwwlwxghvduh fkdqjhg. zh fdqqrw h}shfw wkhplolwdu~wrehkdyh dq~ gliihuhqwo~wkdqlwglg xqghu wkhsdvwuhjlph0"KU:

Qqfh wkh vshfldo kxpdq uljkwv frxuwv kdyh ehhq fuhdwhg. dv~vwhp iru "idvw/wudfnlqj" fdvhv vkrxog eh ghyhorshg0 Vklv zrxoglqyroyh wkh vshhg~ glvsrvlwlrq ri kxpdq uljkwv fdvhv wkurxjk wkhdgrswlrq e~ wkhfrxuw ri fhuwdlqphdvxuhv. olnh frqwlqxrxv wuldo.exwzlwkrxwghq~lqj wkhdffxvhg surfhgxudo gxh surfhvv0

Cqrwkhu pdwwhuwkdwvkrxog eh frqvlghuhg lv wkhuhh}dplqdwlrqri wkhjryhuqphqw'v frxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~ srolf~0 Ykloh lwlv uhfrjql°hgwkdwghihdwlqj dq lqvxujhqf~ lv qrwdq hdv~pdwwhulq dq~ jlyhq vlwxdwlrq.wkhjryhuqphqw vkrxog eh uhplqghg wkdwlwkdv wr iljkw lwvzdu jlyhqfhuwdlqzhoo/hvwdeolvkhguxohvwkdwfdqqrw eh glvuhjdughg iru uhdvrqv rih}shglhqf~0 Vkh surwhfwlrqdiirughg wrlqglylgxdov e~ wkhErqvwlwxwlrq.vwdwxwhvru lqwhuqdwlrqdolqvwuxphqwvpd~ qrweh fdvwdvlgh0

Vklv zrxog phdq. dprqj rwkhuv.wkhuhylhz ri wkhsrolf~ rixvlqj flyloldqv wr frpedw lqvxujhqwv wkurxjk wkhhvwdeolvkphqwdqgghsor~phqw ri sdudplolwdu~ jurxsv037; Kwzrxog dovr phdq wkhuhdvvhvvphqwri wkhsrolf~ ri doorzlqj wkhxvh ri wkhvhfxulw~iruwhvdqghpsor~hhv ri odujh djur/lqgxvwuldo frusrudwlrqv djdlqvw wkhlqvxujhqwv0382 Vkh xvh ri wkhvhshuvrqqho surylghv wkhrssruwxqlw~ irukxpdq uljkwv ylrodwlrqv wrdulvhehfdxvh ri wkhdevhqfh ri frqwuro dqgvxshuylvru~ phfkdqlvpv wkdwzloo hqvxuh wkhlu dffrxqwdelolw~0Oruhryhu. lwzrxog eh hdvlhu wr jlyh wudlqlqj rq kxpdq uljkwv. dqgprqlwru frpsoldqfh. wrshuvrqv zkr duhxqghu d irupdo vwuxfwxuhdqg zkr

379Qepublic 1ohKMo. 7055: Qeslorin!! ciyilian supremacy oyer Hhemilitary, RJTW.oxqh 37/3x3~ 36. 3;;3. s0 350

SVVuo037Gcee Erpp0 rq oxvwlfh dqg Jxpdq Tljkwv. U0Thsruw rq Xljlodqwh Iurxsv. :wk

Erqjr (3;::)0392Ree T0 G0Coirqvr. Lu0.'Rpecial B/lEFTR' nd1 Srade Tnions, PC'qQPCN OKFYGGM.

Od~ 4.3;;20

duhuhvsrqvleohxqghu d fkdlq ri frppdqg0 Kqsudfwlfdowhupv.wklvzrxogphdq vwulfwo~hqiruflqj wkhedq rq sulydwhduplhv dqg yljlodqwhjurxsvdqg lqwhjudwlqj doosdudplolwdu~ xqlwv zlwklq wkh uhjxodu plolwdu~irufhv0 Vkh ECHIWv zrxog kdyh wreh glvedqghg dqg wkhluphpehuvlqwhjudwhglqwr wkhsrolfh ru dup~0 Vkh vhfxulw~shuvrqqho ri exvlqhvvilupv vkrxog qhyhu eh xvhg lq frxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~ rshudwlrqv0 Vkh~vkrxog qrwdovreh doorzhg wreuhdn xs slfnhwvdqg ghprqvwudwlrqvru wrhqjdjh lq rwkhuriihqvlyh vhfxulw~phdvxuhv rxwvlgh wkhluhpsor~hu'vsuhplvhv0

Kq dqvzhu wr txhulhv iurp phpehuv ri wkh Jxpdq TljkwvErpplwwhh. wkhCfwlqj Ekdlupdq ri wkhJxpdq TljkwvErpplvvlrq lqghvfulelqj wkhluirupdo vwuxfwxuhxqlqwhqwlrqdoo~surylghg wkhudwlrqdohiru wkhglvpdqwolqj ri sdudplolwdu~xqlwv<

Vkh flyloldq yroxqwhhu rujdql°dwlrqv dqg wkh ECHIWv duhgliihuhqw iurp wkh yljlodqwhv0Vkh EXQv dqg ECHIWv duhsduwri wkhhqwluhvwudwhj~ri wkhplolwdu~ lq frpedwwlqj lqvxujhqf~ dqg frpprqfulphv0

Vkh EXQ lv sxuho~ d qhljkerukrrg zdwfk zklfk jdwkhuvlqwhooljhqfhuhsruwv.dqg frqgxfwv qhljkerukrrg sdwurodjdlqvw frpprqfulphv dqg lqvxujhqwv0

Vkh ECHIW ru wkhElyloldq Cuphg Hrufh Ihrjudsklfdo Wqlwlvwkhduphg frxqwhusduw0Kwkdv wzr frpsrqhqwv. wkhdfwlyh fdguh jurxsdqg wkhdx}loldu~ jurxs zklfk dfwvdv edfn/xs. dvvlvwdqw/khoshu0VkhECHIWv duhfrqilqhg zlwklq wkhlujhrjudsklfdo xqlwv0

Vkh Erpplvvlrq rq Jxpdq Tljkwv ehlqj d vljqdwru~ wr wkhIxlgholqhv ri wkhElyloldq XroxqwhhuQujdql°dwlrq kdv ehhq prqlwrulqjwkh pdqqhu ri uhfuxlwphqw0 Ehuwdlq vwulfw phdvxuhv kdyh ehhqsuhvfulehg lq rughu wkdwwkhh}shulhqfh zlwk wkhEJFH zloo qrw ehuhshdwhg0

Kqwkhvdph pdqqhu. wkhErpplvvlrq lv olnhzlvh prqlwrulqj wkhfuhdwlrq dqg dfwlylwlhvri ECHIWv lq doosduwvri wkhfrxqwu~0 VkhErpplvvlrq kdv uhfhlyhg ilyh fdvhv ri ECHIW uhodwhgkxpdq uljkwvdexvhv dqg gxulqj lwvidfw/ilqglqj plvvlrq lq Ddfrorg odvwprqwk. 395ECHIW phpehuv zhuh gursshg iurp wkhuroovgxh wrydulrxv riihqvhviurp pxughu wrureehu~0383

Kwpxvw eh dgghg wkdwedvhg rq wkhvwdwlvwlfvri wkhErpplvvlrqrq Jxpdq Tljkwvlq 3;:;. wkhuhzhuh 348uhsruwhgfdvhvri kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqvzkhuh ECHIWv zhuh wkhvxvshfwvzkloh lq 3;;2. wkhuhzhuh36: vxfk fdvhv0384Eohduo~.wkhuhlv d qhhg wruhdvvhvvwkhlusduwlflsdwlrq

383TGRQTV KK.supra qrwh 366. dw75/770384UWOOCT[.supra qrwh 348. dw40

lq wkhjryhuqphqw'v frxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~ hiiruwvlq ylhz ri wkhlqfuhdvlqjqxpehu ri dexvhvdwwulexwhgwrwkhp0

Vkh uhylhz ri jryhuqphqw srolf~ zrxog dovrphdq uhfrqvlghulqjwkhsrolf~ ri kdudvvlqj dqg lqwlplgdwlqj0PIQv dqg uholjlrxv jurxsvdfwlyh lq wkhkxpdq uljkwv lvvxh e~ odeholqj wkhp "frppxqlvw iurqwrujdql°dwlrqv0" Vkh jryhuqphqw dqg wkh srolfh dqg plolwdu~hvwdeolvkphqwvvkrxog uhfrjql°h wkdwwkhsurwhfwlrqri kxpdq uljkwvlv dohjlwlpdwh xqghuwdnlqj wkdwlv lq idfw hqfrxudjhg xqghu wkhfrqvwlwxwlrqdorughu zklfk wkh~ kdyh vzruq wr surwhfw0 Kwlv dqhqfrxudjlqj ghyhorsphqw wkdwlq vrph duhdv wkhplolwdu~dqg vrphjurxsv ri kxpdq uljkwv odz~huv kdyh hqwhuhglqwr djuhhphqwv wkdwzrxog doorz wkhodwwhudEfhvvwrshuvrqv fdswxuhg dqg ghwdlqhge~ wkhplolwdu~0 Jrzhyhu. rqh zrqghuv zk~ wkhuhkdv wr eh dq djuhhphqwirujhg zlwk wkhplolwdu~frppdqghuv zkhq wkhuljkw wr frxqvho lv dfrqvwlwxwlrqdoo~surwhfwhguljkw0385

Erqvlghulqj wkhhiihfwvri lqwhqvlyhplolwdu~rshudwlrqv rq wkhlqqrfhqw flyloldq srsxodwlrq. sduwlfxoduo~wkhuhvxowlqjpdvv hydfxdwlrqdqg glvsodfhphqw. wkhjryhuqphqw pxvw eh suhsduhg wr surylgh wkhqhfhvvdu~ uholhi vhuylfhv0 Ki lwfdqqrw dvvxuh wkhhydfxhhv ri wkhlusk~vlfdo vdihw~dqg hqvxuh whpsrudu~ hpsor~phqw rssruwxqlwlhv dqgghfhqwhydfxdwlrq fdps frqglwlrqv. lwvkrxog qrwhyhq hqjdjh lq plolwdu~rshudwlrqv wkdwzrxog jlyh ulvhwrwkhqhhg iru wkhvhphdvxuhv0 Kqrwkhuzrugv. wklvsrolf~ ri wkhjryhuqphqw zklfk uhvxowvlq wkhfuhdwlrq rilqwhuqdouhixjhhv vkrxog eh vhulrxvo~uhh}dplqhg. qrwrqo~ ehfdxvh ri lwvqhjdwlyhfrqvhtxhqfhv exwdovrvlqfh wkhjryhuqphqw lwvhoifrqwulexwhvwrwkhvdg soljkw ri wkhhydfxhhv gxh wrlwvlqdelolw~wrsurylgh wkhp zlwkuholhi vhuylfhv0

Vkhq wkhuhlv wkhpdwwhuri whvwlqjwkhsrolwlfdo zloo ri wkhqdwlrqdoohdghuvklswkurxjk lwvuhdfwlrqvwrfrpsodlqwv ri kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqv0Kwkdv ehhq revhuyhg wkdwwkhqdwlrqdojryhuqphqw dgrswv dghihqvlyh vwdqfhzkhqhyhu vxfk frpsodlqwv duh dluhg djdlqvw lw0Vkhplolwdu~dqg wkhsrolfh duhdozd~v txlfn wrghq~ wkhdffxvdwlrqvdjdlqvwwkhluphpehuv hyhq ehiruh lqyhvwljdwlrqvfrxog eh frqgxfwhg0 YklohOuv0 Ctxlqr kdv ehhq sxeolfo~ skrwrjudskhg v~psdwkl°lqj zlwk wkhylfwlpv ri kxpdq uljkwv dexvhv. uhphgldo dfwlrqv rq wkhsduwri khuvxeruglqdwhvkdyh ehhq yhu~ vorz0 Cv phqwlrqhg hduolhu.wkhlqlwldwlyhlv ohiwwr wkhErpplvvlrq rq Jxpdq Tljkwv zklfk. dvlgh iurp olplwhgixqglqj. dovr vxiihuviurp wkhkhvlwdwlrqri rwkhujryhuqphqw djhqflhv wrfrrshudwh lq lqyhvwljdwlrqv0

385Ths0 Cfw Pr0 :79. dv dphqghg e~ G}hf0 Qughu Pr0 377. shqdol°hv d sxeolf riilfhuzkr revwuxfwv.surklelwv ru rwkhuzlvh suhyhqwvdq dwwruqh~iurp ylvlwlqj dqg frqihuulqj lqsulydwhzlwk d folhqwxqghu ghwhqwlrq0

Covr. zkloh lwlv wuxhwkdwwkhRklolsslqh jryhuqphqw lv fdvk/vwudsshg vxfk wkdwwkhqdwlrqdoexgjhw kdv wr eh wulpphg grzq. vwloowkhuhlv d qhhg wrdssursuldwh pruh ixqgv wrvxvwdlqwkhfrqvwlwxwlrqdoo~/pdqgdwhg hiiruwwr surprwh dqg surwhfwkxpdq uljkwv0 Kiwkhqdwlrqdoohdghuvkls lv uhdoo~vhulrxv derxw wklvhiiruwwkhqlwvkrxog ilqg zd~v wrsurylgh lw zlwk d uhdolvwlfdssursuldwlrq0 Cv wklqjv vwdqg. wkhErpplvvlrq rq Jxpdq Tljkwv rshudwhvrq d yhu~ olplwhgexgjhw vxfkwkdwwkhrshudwlrqv ri lwvuhjlrqdo riilfhv duh juhdwo~uhvwulfwhg0

Vkhtxhvwlrq ri ixqgv dovrfrphv lq zkhq zh frqvlghu wkdwzklohwkhErqvwlwxwlrqsurylghv iru d v~vwhpri frpshqvdwlrq iru ylfwlpv riylrodwlrqv ri kxpdq uljkwv. vxfk d v~vwhp lv vwloolqh}lvwhqwdiwhuilyh~hduv iurp lwvudwlilfdwlrq0o86Cv phqwlrqhg hduolhu.wkhErpplvvlrq riJxpdq Tljkwv kdv wulhgwr doohyldwhwklvghilflhqf~ e~ surylglqj iruilqdqfldo dvvlvwdqfhwrylfwlpv ri dexvhv0 Dxwwkhdvvlvwdqfhjlyhq e~ wkhErpplvvlrq. zklfk lv urxjko~ 32.222 shvrv (W7$592) shu ylfwlp ru khluri d ylfwlp387 lv jurvvo~ lqvxiilflhqw frqvlghulqj wkdwwkhplqlpxplqghpqlw~ lq krplflgh fdvhv lv douhdg~ilyh wlphv wkdwdprxqw0 Gyhqwkh odwwhulv lqvxiilflhqw. frqvlghulqj wkh hfrqrplf vwudlwvwkhRklolsslqhv lv lq0 Cv lw lv. wkhkrsh ri wkh ylfwlp lq ehlqj jlyhqfrpshqvdwlrq klqjhv rq wkhvxffhvv ri d flylo fdvh iru gdpdjhv ilohgdjdlqvw wkhshuvrq dffxvhg ri frpplwwlqj wkhkxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrq0Dxwwkhqzh kdyh wrfrqvlghu wkdwprvw ylfwlpv ri kxpdq uljkwvdexvhvduh shuvrqv ri yhu~ olplwhg phdqv zkr gr qrw kdyh wkhuhvrxufhv wrhqjdjh lq dq h}shqvlyh orqj/gudzq flylo olwljdwlrq0

Kqwklvfrqqhfwlrq. dvvlvwdqfhvkrxog dovr eh jlyhq wr ylfwlpvvhhnlqj wr ylqglfdwh wkhluuljkwv0 Ykloh wkhErpplvvlrq kdv d ohjdodlg riilfh wr khos zdon/lq frpsodlqdqwv dqg riilfhuv wr frqgxfwlqyhvwljdwlrqv ri uhsruwhg ylrodwlrqv.388lwgrhv qrw kdyh d v~vwhp ridvvlvwdqfh wr ylfwlpv diwhu wkhlu fdvhv kdyh ehhq uhihuuhg wr wkhsurvhfxwruldo djhqflhv ri jryhuqphqw0 Vkh Erpplvvlrq kdv lqfxuuhgh}shqvhv iru zlwqhvv surwhfwlrq dqg rwkhu ohjdo h}shqvhv389exw wkhvhkdyh wr gr zlwk h}shqvhv lqfxuuhg zkloh wkhfdvhv zhuh vwlooehlqjlqyhvwljdwhge~ wkhErpplvvlrq0 Kwfdqqrw eh ghqlhg wkdwhyhq zkhuhfdvhv duh survhfxwhg e~ jryhuqphqw odz~huv. dgglwlrqdo frvwvzloo vwlookdyh wr eh lqfxuuhg e~ wkhylfwlpv ru wkhluuhodwlyhvlq iroorzlqj xs

386Cvvwdwhghduolhu.shqglqj lq Erqjuhvvduheloovsurylglqj iru frpshqvdwlrqiruylfwlpvri kxpdquljkwvylrodwlrqv.qdpho~<U0Pr0 588 dqgU0Pr0 5890

387UWOOCT[.VX•Ul qrwh348. dw360166/d., dw50167ld., dw360

fdvhv dqg surfxulqj wkhdwwhqgdqfhri zlwqhvvhv0 Rhukdsv wkhodfn riilqdqfldo uhvrxufhv rq wkhsduwri wkhylfwlpv ru wkhlukhluvlv rqh uhdvrqzk~ wkhuhlv d kljk lqflghqfh ri ghod~lq wkhuhvroxwlrqdqg glvplvvdo rifdvhvdiwhuehlqj uhihuuhgiru survhfxwlrq0 Vkxv.qrwrqo~ vkrxog wkhuhehd v~vwhpri frpshqvdwlrq diwhud fdvh kdv ehhq ilqdoo~ghflghg. exwwkhuhvkrxog dovr eh hiihfwlyhohjdodqg ilqdqfldo vxssruw wrhqvxuh wkdwwkhvhfdvhvduhsurvhfxwhgxs wrilqdomxgjphqw0

VkhErpplvvlrq frxog eh wdvnhgzlwk prqlwrulqj wkhsurjuhvv rifdvhv dqg dgplqlvwhulqj wkhdprxqwv wreh jlyhq wkhylfwlpv dqg wkhlukhluv exw lw.ri frxuvh. vkrxog qrw lqwhuihuhlq wkhlusurvhfxwlrq0 Dxwvkrxog wkhErpplvvlrq ilqg xqgxh ghod~lq wkhsurvhfxwlrq ri fdvhv. lwpxvw eh jlyhq wkhsrzhu wr gr pruh wkdq mxvwuhvruwwr wkhxvxdodgplqlvwudwlyhuhphglhv0 Nlnhdq ombudsman, lwpxvweh deohwrxvh erwkdgplqlvwudwlyhdqg qrq/dgplqlvwudwlyh phdqv lq rughu wr suhvvxuh wkhvRhfldosurvhfxwruv dqg wkhfrxuwvwrshuirup wkhlugxwlhvzlwk glvsdwfk0

Kwfrphv dv d vxusulvhwkdwghvslwhwkhkljk lqflghqfh ri kxpdquljkwv ylrodwlrqv. wkhuhkdv ehhq yhu~ olwwohhiiruw rq wkhsduwri wkhCtxlqr jryhuqphqw dqg wkhErpplvvlrq rq Jxpdq Tljkwvwrsurylgh iruwkhuhkdelolwdwlrqri wkhylfwlpv dqg wkhluidplolhv0 Qq wkhsduwri wkhErpplvvlrq. wklvlv xqghuvwdqgdeohfrqvlghulqj lwvfkurqlf exgjhwdu~sureohpv0

Wqgrxewhgo~.lqflghqwvri dexvh pd~ uhvxowqrw rqo~ lq sk~vlfdolqmxulhvexwpd~ dovrohdyhghhs hprwlrqdo vfduv0Erpshqvdwlqj ylfwlpvdqg wkhluidplolhv zlwk dprxqwv ri prqh~ gr qrw hyhq frph forvh wrslhflqj wrjhwkhuwkhluvkdwwhuhgolyhv0

Urph orfdoqrq/jryhuqphqwdo rujdql°dwlrqv kdyh sxwxs vxssruwv~vwhpvru xqghuwdnhqsurjudpv wrdvvlvwlq wkhuhkdelolwdwlrqri ylfwlpvdqg wkhluidplolhv.38: exw wkhuhlv d qhhg wr lqvwlwxwlrqdol°hwklvhiiruw0Kwlv uhfrpphqghg wkdwwkhjryhuqphqw vkrxoghu wkhuhvsrqvlelolw~dqgsurylgh ixqglqj iru wklvhqghdyru0 Hru dgplqlvwudwlyhsxusrvhv. wkhErpplvvlrq rq Jxpdq Tljkwv vkrxog eh jlyhq wkhohdg uroh0Vkhuhkdelolwdwlrqri ylfwlpv dqg wkhluidplolhv fdq eh frqvlghuhg zlwklq

38:Vdvn Hrufh Fhwdlqhhv ri wkhRklolsslqhv (VHFR) uhihuvylfwlpv ri wruwxuhdqg rwkhusk~vlfdo dexvh wr sk~vlfldqv zkr duh phpehuv ri wkhOhglfdo Cfwlrq Iurxs (OCI). dkxpdq uljkwv jurxs frpsrvhg ri sk~vlfldqv0 qxuvhv dqg rwkhukhdowkzrunhuv0 Hdplolhv riKqyroxqwdu~Flvdsshdudqfh (HKPF) frqgxfwv uhkdelolwdwlrqsurjudpv iru srolwlfdoghwdlqhhv0

wkhvfrsh ri wkhErpplvvlrq'v frqvwlwxwlrqdopdqgdwh038; Vkh qhfhvvdu~ixqgv iru wklvvkrxog eh doorfdwhg0

Vr fduu~ rxw wklvhqghdyru. wkhErpplvvlrq fdq rujdql°h lq lwvuhjlrqdo riilfhv whdpvri grfwruv. sv~fkrorjlvwv dqg vrfldo zrunhuv0 Vrfxwrq frvwv.wkhErpplvvlrq pd~ vhhn wkhdvvlvwdqfhri wkhFhsduwphqwri Jhdowk dqg wkhFhsduwphqw ri Urfldo Yrun dqg Fhyhorsphqw lqsurylglqj wkhp zlwk wudlqhgshuvrqqho0 Vkh Erpplvvlrq pd~ dovr wdswkhh}shuwlvhri vrph PIQv wkdwkdyh kdg h}whqvlyhh}shulhqfh lq wklvduhd0

Qqh wklqj wkdwpxvw qrw eh orvwUljkwri lv wkdwwkhylfwlpv dqgwkhluidplolhv pd~ eh ihduixo ri uhwdoldwlrqdqg pd~ frqvhtxhqwo~ ehhiihfwlyho~suhyhqwhg iurp vhhnlqj uhkdelolwdwlrqdvvlvwdqfh0Vklv fdqeh d uhdosureohp. sduwlfxoduo~lq duhdvzkhuh wkhuhlv d vwurqj plolwdu~ru sdudplolwdu~suhvhqfS0 Vkxv. iru wkhvxffhvv ri wkhsurjudp. wkhErpplvvlrq pxvwqrwrqo~ jdlq wkhlufrqilghqfh exwpxvwdovrdvvxuhwkhluvhfxulw~0

Cqrwkhupdwwhuwkdwvkrxog eh dgguhvvhg lv wkdwri eulgjlqj wkhjds ehwzhhq wkhErpplvvlrq dqg wkhPIQv0 C pxwxdoglvwuxvwehwzhhqwkhp lv dssduhqw0Vkh Erpplvvlrq kdv ehhq fulwlfl°hgdv lqhiihfwxdodqgdvehlqj d phuh jryhuqphqw dsrorjlvw zlwk qr plqg ri lwvrzq0 PIQv. rqwkhrwkhu kdqg. kdyh ehhq eudqghg dv srolwlfdoo~prwlydwhg dqg dvehlqj frppxqlvw vwrrjhv0 Vklv vlwxdwlrq lv lqghhg ghsorudeoh.frqvlghulqj wkdwlwrqo~ djjudydwhv wkhkxpdq uljkwvsureohp lq wkhfrxqwu~0 Kwzrxog fhuwdlqo~eh pruh ehqhilfldo wr wkrvhlq qhhg risurwhfwlrq li wkhErpplvvlrq dqg wkhPIQv frxog hvwdeolvkduhdv rifrrshudwlrq0 Kq uhdo whupv. wkhvhzrxog phdq wkh fuhdwlrq Qi mrlqwlqyhvwljdwlrqwhdpv dqg wkhvkdulqj ri lqirupdwlrq0 Vkh idfwwkdwwkhErpplvvlrq dqg wkhPIQv hpsor~ gliihuhqwvwdqgdugvlq hydoxdwlqjkxpdq uljkwv fdvhv.392 vxfk wkdwwkh~uhvxowwr d juhdw vwdwlvwlfdoglvsdulw~.vkrxog qrweh frqvlghuhg dq revwdfohwrfrrshudwlrq0 Kwzrxogdovr phdq zrunlqj wrjhwkhulq wkhduhd ri kxpdq uljkwv hgxfdwlrq0Gvwdeolvklqjhiihfwlyh olqnv zlwk wkh PIQv zrxog dovr fdoo iru wkhErpplvvlrq wr ghyhors dq lpdjh ri lpsduwldolw~ dqg dvvhuwlwvlqghshqghqfh iurp wkhqdwlrqdojryhuqphqw0 Kwvkrxog qrw jlyh wkhlpsuhvvlrq wkdwlwlv wkhriilfldo vsrnhvpdq ri wkhjryhuqphqw rq kxpdquljkwv lvvxhv0 Kwvphpehuv vkrxog qrw irujhw wkdw/wkhErqvwlwxwlrq

38;Vkh pdqgdwh ri wkhErpplvvlrq xqghu Cuw0ZKoo(vhf0 3:0 sdu0 8) ri wkhErqvwlwxwlrqlqfoxghv wkhsrzhu wr uhfrpphqg wr wkhErqjuhvv hiihfwlyh phdvxuhv wrsurprwh kxpdq uljkwv0

3?2cpp Csruwdghud.VX•Ul qrwh3730

pdqgdwhv wkhfuhdwlrqri dq lqghshqghqw kxpdq uljkwvzdwfkgrj. qrwdkxpdq uljkwvriilfh lq wkhh}hfxwlyheudqfk0

Qq wkhrwkhu kdqg. wkhPIQv vkrxog uhfrjql°h wkdwwkh~gr qrwkdyh d prqrsro~ ri frqfhuq iru wkhsurwhfwlrq ri kxpdq uljkwv0 Cvhqylvlrqhg lq wkhlqwhuqdwlrqdolqvwuxphqwvdqg wkhErqvwlwxwlrq.lwlv dpdwwhuri sulpdu~ frqfhuq iru wkhjryhuqphqwv ri wkhvwdwhsduwlhv0KwlvwuxhwkdwwkhPIQv kdyh fduulhg wkhwrufkgWulqj wkhgdun ~hduvri wkhOdufrv hud. dqg wkdwwkh~kdyh vxiihuhg iru lw.exw wkh~vkrxog uhdol°hwkdwxqohvvwkh~hqfrxudjh rwkhuvhfwruvwr vkduh lq wkhuhvsrqvlelolw~.wkhsurprwlrq dqg surwhfwlrq ri kxpdq uljkwv zloo uhpdlq d vhulrxvsureohp dqg PIQv zlooiru d orqj wlpheh dorqh lq lwvfuxvdgh0

Hlqdoo~.wkheljjhvw sureohp lq kxpdq uljkwvsurwhfwlrq/ wkdwrih}srvlqj ylrodwlrqv/ qhhgv wreh dgguhvvhg0 Ykloh wkhuhduhkxqguhgvri fdvhv ri doohjhgkxpdq uljkwvdexvhv uhsruwhghdfk ~hdu.pdq~ pruhvlpso~ jr xquhsruwhg0 Vkh uhdvrqv duh vhyhudo<ihdu ri uhwdoldwlrq.odfnri dffhvv wr shuvrqv wr zkrp lwfdq eh uhsruwhg. ljqrudqfh ri rqh'vsurwhfwhguljkwv.ru lqgliihuhqfh eruqh rxw e~ d ihholqj ri krshohvvqhvv0Fliihuhqwphdvxuhv kdyh wreh xqghuwdnhqwruhphg~ wkhvlwxdwlrq0

Kqlwldoo~.wkhvrflr/hfrqrplf plolhx pxvw eh frqgxflyh iru duhjlph zkhuh kxpdq uljkwvduhuhvshfwhg0Wqohvvwkhjuhdwjds ehwzhhqwkhulfk dqg wkhsrru lv eulgjhg. uhvshfwiru kxpdq uljkwvzloo dozd~v ehd sureohp0 Vklv lv wkhedvlf uhdvrq zk~ wkhdssuhfldwlrq ri flylo dqgsrolwlfdouljkwv fdqqrw eh glyrufhg iurp wkdwri hfrqrplf. vrfldo dqgfxowxudouljkwv0

Dxwwklvgrhv qrw phdq wkdwwkh frxqwu~ vkrxog zdlw iru dpdunhg lpsuryhphqw lq wkhhfrqrp~ dqg wkhgholyhu~ri vrfldo vhuylfhvehiruh uhvshfwiru kxpdq uljkwvlv revhuyhg0 Vkhuhlv pruh uhdvrq wrehfrqvflrxv ri kxpdq uljkwvhvshfldoo~ dwd wlph zkhq wkhshrsoh duhghvshudwhdqg wkhuhlv d juhdwhuwhqghqf~iru dexvh0

Vkh shrsoh pxvweh lqiruphg ri wkhluuljkwv0VkhErpplvvlrq rqJxpdq Tljkwv dqg wkhPIQv duhfrqwlqxrxvo~ xqghuwdnlqj hgxfdwlrqdofdpsdljqv0 Dxwwkhluhiiruwvduh lqdghtxdwh frqvlghulqj wkhluodfn riuhvrxufhv0 Ouv0Ctxlqr kdg rughuhg wkhwhdfklqj ri kxpdq uljkwvlqvfkrrov.393 exw wkhwhdfkhuvwkhpvhoyhvkdyh yhu~ olwwohnqrzohgjh rq

393Olqlvwu~ ri Ggxfdwlrq. Exowxuhdqg Usruwv ]khuhlqdiwhuOGEUb Ohprudqgxp.Uwuhqjwkhqlqj wkhFhyhorsphqw ri Ggxfdwlrq iru KqwhuqdwlrqdoWqghuvwdqglqj. Errshudwlrqdqg Rhdfh dqg Ggxfdwlrq Thodwlqj wrJxpdq Tljkwv dqg Hxqgdphqwdo Huhhgrpv (Pr0 385)(3;:8)0

wklvpdwwhu0Rhukdsv wkhhiiruw vkrxog vwduw.qrw zlwk wkhvwxghqwv.exwzlwk wkhluwhdfkhuv0Erqvlghulqj wkdwwkhuhduh kxqguhgv ri wkrxvdqgvri whdfkhuv lq wkh Rklolsslqhv. wklv vkrxog wdnh vrph wlph wrdffrpsolvk0 Vkh Fhsduwphqw ri Ggxfdwlrq. Exowxuh dqg Usruwv kdvdouhdg~ vsrqvruhg. dqg frqwlqxhv wr vsrqvru. vhyhudo kxpdq uljkwvhgxfdwlrq vhplqduv iru whdfkhuv.exw wkhvhduh lqdghtxdwh0 Hru lqvwdqfh.wkh KU/gd~ wudlqlqj vhplqdu lq Fhfhpehu 3;:8 zdv olplwhg wr rqo~ 72whdfkh0uvfrplqj iurp doo ryhu wkh frxqwu~0o94 C qrq/exuhdxfudwlfdssurdfk zrxog kdyh wreh dgrswhg dv uhjdugv kxpdq uljkwv hgxfdwlrqdqg wklv.djdlq. zloo hqwdlojuhdw h}shqglwxuh0 Vkh sulydwh vhfwru dqgwkh lqwhuqdwlrqdofrppxqlw~ vkrxog eh hqfrxudjhg wr ilqdqfldoo~ dqgwhfkqlfdoo~dvvlvwwkhjryhuqphqw lq wklvhqghdyru0 Vkhuh lv dovr d qhhgwr surgxfh jrrg orfdo pdwhuldov rq kxpdq uljkwv wkdwfdq eh hdvlo~xqghuvwrrg e~ lwvuhdghuv0 Cgplwwhgo~.wkhuhlv d ghduwkri errnv rq wkhpdwwhuzulwwhq e~ Hlolslqr vfkroduv0 Rklolsslqh pdwhuldov rq kxpdquljkwv duh hlwkhuuhsruwv rq kxpdq uljkwv ylrodwlrqv ru frpslodwlrqv rivwdwxwhvdqg lqwhuqdwlrqdolqvwuxphqwv0 Wqdqqrwdwhg orfdo pdwhuldovh}sodlqlqj zkdw wkhgliihuhqw uljkwv duh. erwk iurp d pxqlflsdo odz dqglqwhuqdwlrqdo odz shuvshfwlyh. dqg krz wkh~ pd~ eh hqirufhg. duhvruho~ qhhghg0 Drwk wkhErpplvvlrq rq Jxpdq Tljkwv dqg wkhPIQvvkrxog djdlq wdnhd ohdglqj uroh lq wklvhqghdyru0

Vkhq. wkhshrsoh vkrxog eh hqfrxudjhg wrh}srvh kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqv0 Vkh jryhuqphqw zloo kdyh wr vkrz wkdwwkrvh zkr ylrodwhkxpdq uljkwv zloo eh survhfxwhg dqg sxqlvkhg0 Vklv lv zkhuh wkhjuhdwhvwgliilfxow~ olhv li zh frqvlghu wkdwlq pdq~ frppxqlwlhv lq wkhuxudoduhdv. wkhrqo~ jryhuqphqw suhvhqfh ihowe~ wkhshrsoh lv wkdwriwkhplolwdu~0 Vklv lv zkhuh krshohvvqhvv. ihdu ri uhwdoldwlrqdqg odfn ridffhvv wr shuvrqv zkr fdq khos duh prvw dfxwh0 Vkh Trpdq EdwkrolfEkxufk dqg rwkhuuholjlrxv jurxsv kdyh vrphkrz iloohgwkhyrlg. exw lqwkh surfhvv pdq~ sulhvwv. plqlvwhuv dqg rwkhu fkxufk zrunhuv kdyhwkhpvhoyhv ehfrph wdujhwv0395Kwlv lghdo wkdwwkh suhvhqfh ri wkhflyloldq jryhuqphqw eh pdqlihvwhg lq wkhvh duhdv exw lw lv txlwhxquhdolvwlfgxh wr lwvodfn ri uhvrxufhv0 Vkh lpphgldwh vroxwlrq zrxogwkhuhiruh kdyh wr eh irxqg lq wkh plolwdu~ rujdql°dwlrq. zkhuh dpdmrulw~ri kxpdq uljkwv dexvhv hpdqdwh0 Vkhuh lv dq xujhqw qhhg wruhrulhqwwkhplolwdu~rq wkhlusurshu uroh dv surwhfwruv.dqg qrw pdvwhuv.ri wkhshrsoh0 Nrqj ~hduvri pduwldouxohxqghu Ou0 Odufrv kdyh fuhdwhglq wkhplqgv ri pdq~ lq wkhplolwdu~ hvwdeolvkphqwd glvwruwlrq dv wrwkhlu surshu uroh xqghu wkh flyloldq frqvwlwxwlrqdorughu0 Vklv lv. ri

394OGEUOhprudqgzq. NhdghuvklsVudlqlqjUhplqdurq Jxpdq TljkwviruVhdfkhuv(Pr0 43:) (3;:8)0

173She Ohilippine Guman Qights Rituation, PCVKQPCNOKFYGGM. Pryhpehu 37/Fhfhpehu 37. 3;;2. s0 37> She Shree-Xear Guman Qights Qecord of the ?quinoFovernment, 7 RJTW.Pry KU/Fhh36. 3;:;. s0 370

frxuvh. hdvlhuvdlg wkdqgrqh. frqvlghulqj wkdwOuv0Ctxlqr'v frqwlqxhgvwd~lq srzhu lv shufhlyhg e~ pdq~ wreh dwwkhsohdvxuhri wkhplolwdu~hvwdeolvkphqw0 Vkxv. vkh kdv hdvlo~dffhghg wr wkhzlvkhv ri or~doriilfhuv (u0p0.wkrvhzkr kdyh vxssruwhg khu lq wkhvhyhudodwwhpswhgn~X• o'pWlWV) wr lqwhqvli~wkhfrxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~ hiiruwlqwr d wrwdozdu.hyhq li wklvzrxog phdq lqfuhdvhg kdugvkls iru lqqrfhqw flyloldqv dqgkdylqj uhwluhgriilfhuv dssrlqwhg wrnh~ flyloldq srvlwlrqv0

Ouv0Ctxlqr urvhwrsrzhu rq wkhsurplvh ri uhvwrulqjghprfudf~.ghvwur~lqj wkh yhvwljhv ri wkh Odufrv glfwdwruvkls. uhfryhulqj wkhzhdowkdoohjhgo~vwrohqe~ wkhOdufrv•v dqg xvkhulqj lq d qhz hud risurvshulw~ irxqghg rq uhvshfwiru kxpdq uljkwv0Ciwhupruh wkdqilyh~hduvdv Ruhvlghqwri wkhThsxeolf ri wkhRklolsslqhv. Ouv0Ctxlqr kdvuhvwruhgghprfudwlf lqvwlwxwlrqvexwwkhhfrqrp~ uhpdlqv lq vkdpeohvdqg wkhkxpdq uljkwvuhfrug ri khu jryhuqphqw lv idu iurp dgpludeoh0Ykdwzhqw zurqjB Qulv lwd fdvhri surplvlqj wrr pxfkB

Vkh dxwkru zrxog olnh wrwklqnwkdwlq wkhhxskruld jhqhudwhge~ wkhidoori wkhOdufrvhv. wkhuhzdv dovr eruq dq krqhvwwrjrrgqhvvhiiruw wr surprwh uhvshfwiru kxpdq uljkwv/dqg wr fkdqjh wkhwdlqwhglpdjh ri wkhRklolsslqh jryhuqphqw dv rqh wkdwzdv eolqg wrwkhdexvhri kxpdq uljkwv0Vklvhiiruwirxqg h}suhvvlrq lq wkh3;:9 Erqvwlwxwlrq.zklfk pdgh wkhsurwhfwlrqri kxpdq uljkwvrqh ri lwvirxqgdwlrqv0

Dxwsrolwlfdodqg hfrqrplf idfwruvsuhyhqwhgwkhixooiuxlwlrqriuhvshfwiru kxpdq uljkwv0Vkh frqwlqxhg frqfhqwudwlrqri srolwlfdodqghfrprqlf srzhu lq wkh kdqgv ri d ihz qhjdwhg wkhuhvwrudwlrqrighprfudwlf lqvwlwxwlrqv0Ouv0 Ctxlqr zdv srolwlfdoo~ehkroghq wr dplolwdu~hvwdeolvkphqwwkdwzdv hqjdjhg lq d euxwdofrxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~zdu0 Rrolwlfdolqvwdelolw~lq wkhfrxqwu~. h}hpsolilhg e~ khljkwhqhglqvxujhqw dfwlylwlhvdqg wkhvhyhudofrxs dwwhpswvdjdlqvw wkhCtxlqrjryhuqphqw. ohgwrwkhqhdu froodsvhri wkhhfrqrp~0 Vkh jds ehwzhhqwkhulfk dqg wkhsrru zlghqhg0 Vkh qxpehu ri Hlolslqrv xqghu wkhsryhuw~ olqh lqfuhdvhg0

Fhvslwhriilfldo hiiruwvwrduuhvwwkhwlghri kxpdq uljkwvdexvhv.wkhvrfldo dqg hfrqrplf hqylurqphqw suryhg wr eh wrr pxfk ri dqrevwdfoh0Vkh xquhvwri wkhsrru fuhdwhglq wkhplqgv ri rxu frxqwu~'vzhdowk~ ohdghuv wkh qhhg iru d plolwdu~ vroxwlrq0 Jxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqv.hvshfldoo~wkrvhuhodwhgwrwkhfrxqwhu/lqvxujhqf~ rshudwlrqvri wkhplolwdu~.ehfdph doowkhpruh khljkwhqhg0 Ykloh wkhuhzdv dghfuhdvh lq uhsruwhgfdvhv. kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqvfrqwlqxhg wriroorz

wkhvdph sdwwhuq<lqyroxqwdu~glvdsshdudqfhv. h}wudmxglfldoh}hfxwlrqv.irufhg pdvv hydfxdwlrqv. pdvvdfuhv dqg wkholnh0

Kvwkhsurwhfwlrqri kxpdq uljkwvlq wkhRklolsslqhv d orvwfdxvhBVkh dxwkru zrxog olnh wr wklqn wkdwlwlv qrw0 Fhvslwh wkhdgyhuvlwlhvidflqj lw.wkhjryhuqphqw vkrxog jdwkhu wkhsrolwlfdozloo wr ryhufrphwkhdgyhuvlw~0 Kwzloo qrw gr wr dozd~v dwwulexwhwkhsureohp wr Ou0Odufrv0 Phlwkhu zloo lwgr wr xvh wkh frppxqlvw lqvxujhqf~ dv dfrqyhqlhqw h}fxvh0 Vkh qhhg iru wkhsurwhfwlrqri kxpdq uljkwvehfrphvdoowkhpruh qhfhvvdu~zkhq d frxqwu~ lv idfhg zlwk lqwhuqdowkuhdwv0

Dxwwklv lv qrw wr vd~ wkdwwkh jryhuqphqw lv wkh rqo~ rqhuhvsrqvleoh iru surprwlqj kxpdq uljkwv0 Cowkrxjk wkhlqwhuqdwlrqdolqvwuxphqwvvshdn ri wkhreoljdwlrq ri vwdwhsduwlhv.wkhsurprwlrq rikxpdq uljkwvlv dgguhvvhg wrhyhu~rqh0 Vkhvhuljkwvehlqj lqkhuhqwlqhyhu~kxpdq ehlqj. wkhlusurprwlrq dqg surwhfwlrqlv d gxw~iru hdfk dqghyhu~ lqglylgxdo0 Vkh juhdwhuwdvnri wkhjryhuqphqw lv wr hqvxuh wkdwhyhu~rqh lv jlyhq d uhdorssruwxqlw~ wrixoiloowklvgxw~dqg wrhqmr~lwviuxlwv0

PQVG<Vkh vwdwlvwlfvfrpslohg e~ wkhVdvnHrufh Fhwdlqhhvri wkhRklolsslqhv (VHFR) dqg wkhErpplvvlrq rq Jxpdq Tljkwv (EJT) duhpdgh dqqh}hv wr wklvsdshu wr jlyh wkhuhdghudq lghd ri wkhh}whqwrikxpdq uljkwv ylrodwlrqv lq wkhRklolsslqhv iurp 3;:8 wr 3;;30 Vkhvwdwlvwlfviurp wzr hqwlwlhvydu~. dqg vhyhudouhdvrqv pd~ eh flwhg iruwklv<(3) qrw doofdvhv eurxjkw wrwkhdwwhqwlrqri VHFR dqg rwkhuqrq/jryhuqphqwdo rujdql°dwlrqv duheurxjkw wrEJT> dqg (4) VHFRdqg wkhEJT hpsor~ gliihuhqwvwdqgdugv0Fhvslwhwkhglvsdulw~lq wkhqxpehuv.wkhvwdwlvwlfviurp wkhwzr erglhv ehdu zlwqhvvwrwkhvdg vwdwhri kxpdquljkwv lq wkhRklolsslqhv0

UVCVKUVKEUHTQOVCUM HQTEG FGVCKPGGU QH VKoGRJKNKRRKPGU

VCDNG 30 RGTUQPU CTTGUVGF HQT RQNKVKECN QHHGPUGU(Odufk 3. 3;:8/Uhsw0 52. 3;;3)

3;:83;:93;::3;:;3;;23;;3VQVCN

3.456:.3285.2:43.:975.;75

:393;.289

VCDNG 4</RGTUQPU CTTGUVGF HQT RQNKVKECNQHHGPUGU(3;:5/Hhe03;:8)

3;:53;:63;:7Ldq/Hhe 3;:8VQVCN

4.2::6.38:7.;89

69:34.923

VCDNG 50 PWODGT QH KNNGICN CPF KNNGICN CTTGUVU(3;:9/Uhsw 3;;3)

KNNGICN CTTGUVU NGICN CTTGUVU

3;:93;::3;:;3;;23;;3VQVCN

9.:::4.;;23.95;5.9:;

9:239.3:8

34;.7

35838659

77:

3;:83;:93;::3;:;3;;23;;3VQVCN

VCDNG 60 UVCVWU QH RGTUQPU CTTGUVGF HQTRQNKVKECN QHHGPUGU

(Odu 3. 3;:8/Uhsw 52. 3;;3)

7676,5988242

7,.

6A6A73373932

6+,

65:;5593:53446;328

73,S+

37377SS793

66S

VCDNG 70 PWODGT QH OCUUCETGU> PWODGT QH MKNNGFCPF YQWPFGF KP OCUUCETGU

(Odu 3. 3;:8/Uhsw 52. 3;;3)

OCUUCETGU MKNNGF YQWPFGF

3;:8 6: 3;: 583;:9 57 427 3573;:: 5: 385 683;:; 48 ;7 663;;2 3; 89 573;;3 7 3: 3'iQVCN 6,6 ,9+ 7.,

VCDNG 80 PWODGT QH HTWUVTCVGF OCUUCETGU>PWODGT QH MKNNGF CPF YQWPFGF KP OCUUCETGU

(Odu 3. 3;:8/Uhsw 52. 3;;3)

HTWUVTCVGFOCUUCETGU

3;:83;:93;::3;:;3;;23;;3VQVCN

7597587.5932

76-

;+897597932

6-S

5539786S79-55

627

VCDNG 90 EQORCTCVKXG CIGPf[ GUVKOCVGUQHKPVGTPCN TGHWIGGU RQRWNCVKQP 2;:8/Uhsw 52. 3;;3)

[GCT EFTE GEFHE GOLR KETE VHFR

3;:8 • 45.66;R 76.44; 339.467 3;6.222

3;:9 • 35.587 3:.928

R 562.647 49.222 334.4583;:: • 64.7:2 3;.::6 38.584

R 563.6;7 486.6993;:; •

R 395.222 32;.:7; 3;6.9563;;2 • :.3;8

R 47.68723/3;;3 • 6.636

R 5.584

Nhjhqg<i / idplolhvs / shuvrqvEFTE / Elwl°hq'v Flvdvwhudqg ThkdelolwdwlrqEhqwhuGEFHE/ Gfxphqlfdo Erpplvvlrq iru Flvsodfhg Hdplolhv dqg ErppxqlwlhvGOLR / Gfxphqlfdo Oryhphqw iru Lxvwlfhdqg RhdfhKETE / KqwhuqdwlrqdoErpplwwhh ri wkhThg EurvvVHFR / Vdvn Hrufh Fhwdlqhhv ri wkhRklolsslqhv

VCDNG:0 RGTRGVTCVQTUQH JWOCP TKIJVU XKQNCVKQPU

RGTRGVTCVQTU 3;:9 3;:: 3;:; 3;;2 3;;3 VQVCN

RJKNKRRKPGCTO[ 7:9 737 43; 395 3;4 3.8:8RE/KPR 84; 645 366 37; 37 3.592EJFH1ECHIW ;5 88 347 337 73 672PCX[ 1OCTKPGU 32 4;2 : 52:CKT HQTEG 7 5 7 35

EQORQUKVGCNN/CHR 35: 4;2 545 365 332 3.226

XKIKNCPVGU 467 356 46 33 ; 645KPFGRGPFGPVCTO[ ITQWRU'" 62 5; ; 4 ;2EKXKNKCPQHHKEKCNU 3; 66 8 9 98

EQORQUKVGPQP/CHR 499 355 95 453 39 953

WPKFGPVKHKGF 3:7 93 6; 79 4: 5;2QVJGTU 34 32 ; 53

VQVCN 8.794

VCDNG;0 UGEVQTCN FKUVTKDWVKQPQH XKEVKOUQH JWOCPTKIJVU XKQNCqQPU

01.-,4/0238536..62

UGEVQT 6.-, 6.-- 6.-. 6..5 6..6 TOTALHCTOGTU1HCTOYQTMGTU 63+78 639.- ,,- -.8 8-- S36-5KPFWUVTKCNYQTMGTU +,5 6-+ ,385S ,S+ 6,+ .35.8UGTXKEGYQTMGTU 6,. 8,S 979 67, 9- 636S8HKUJGTOGP -9 . 89 ,, 86 7,SUVWFGPVU 688 6,9 S3696 778 69- S3-6.TGNKIKQWU 6. 6, 6- - , +.RTQHGUUKQPCN 77 S5 78 7, - 685DWUKPGUUOGP 75 77 6. +6PIQ1JT YQTMGT 7, +- 8- ,7 78 77-QWV/QH/UEJQQN[QWVJ +5 7+ 67 6S 78 68+RWDNKEQHHKEKCNU 8, , 68 , +9OGFKC 8 + 68 6 , 85UGNH/GORNQ[GF S+ 77 76 -7 6, 6.-WPGORNQ[GF .6 .. 9- 77 67 7,7JQWUGYKHG 9S 8. 8+ -9 S 75.EJKNFTGP 75 -6 669 7.9 S59VTKDCNHKNKRKPQU , 6 65 ++ -9CTVKUVU 7 + 6 .HQTGKIPGT 8 8 +WPENCUUKHKGF 63586 S.+ S66 9,6 689 73,98TOTAL 48.485

UVCVKUVKEUHTQO VJGEQOOKUUKQP QP JWOCP TKIJVU

TGRQTV QP JWOCP TKIJVU XKQNCVKQPU3;:8/3;;3

K0 Pxpehu ri Erpsodlqwv dv wr Fdwh ri KqflghqwUkrzlqj FhfuhdvlqjVuhqg ri Kqflghqfh ri Coohjhg Jxpdq Tljkwv Xlrodwlrqv iurp 3;::/3;;2

Rulru wr3;:83;:83;:93;::3;:;3;;23;;3 QvwSxduwhu)VQVCN

3.87:796:22

3.87:3.7823.6;6

4229.;66

(70;3)(6045)

KK0Duhdngrzq ri Erpsodlqwv ri Coohjhg Jxpdq TljkwvXlrodwlrqv e~ V~sh ri Erpsodlqw

V[RG QH % QH % QH 3UV SVTEQORNCKPV 6.-- 6.-. KPEKFGE 6..5 KPEKFGE 6..6

OWTFGT1JQOKEKFG1GZGEWVKQP 79; 6;4 27025) 5:8 (43076) 75

CTTGUV1FGVGPVKQP 3;5 42: 9099 3;7 (8047) 4;

VQTVWTG 6; 47 (6:0;:) 44 (34022) 4FKUCRRGCTCPEG 326 84 (6205:) 68 (470:3) 3iilJGT

EQORNCKPVU 955 995 7068 :67 ;053 337

VQVCN 3.87: 3.782 3.6;6 422

KKK0Pxpehu ri Edvhv uhvroyhg e~ wkh EJT iurp 3;:9/3;;2qxpehulqj 6.:67 uhsuhvhqwlqj83% ri wkh9.;66 frpsodlqwv ridoohjhg kxpdq uljkwvylrodwlrqv0

3vwSwu03;:9/:: 3;:; 3;;2 3;;3 A<ALY

VQVCNPQ0 QHTGUQNXGFECUGU 434 3.9;4 4.44; 834 6.:67

DTGCMFQYP QHTGUQNXGFECUGU<

C0 Gvwdeolvkhg 332 843 843 379 3.72;Jxpdq TljkwvXlrodwlrqvHlohgdqgRhqglqj lqErxuwv1Cjhqflhviru Rurvhfxwlrq1CgplqlvwudwlyhCfwlrq

D0Erpsohwhg ;:: 3.266 523 4.555KqyhvwljdwlrqdqgThvroyhg e~Thjlrqdo Qiilfhviru Erqilupdwlrqe~ wkhErpplvvlrq

E0Eorvhg1Vhuplqdwhg 93 366 586 :3 882

F0 Cufklyhg 53 5; 422 95 565

KX0GvwdeolvkhgJxpdq Tljkwv Xlrodwlrqv Hlohgdqg Rhqglqj lqErxuwv1Cjhqflhv iru Rurvhfxwlrq1 CgplqlvwudwlyhCfwlrq

30Oxughu1Jrplflgh1G}hfxwlrq40Cuuhvw1Fhwhqwlrq}50Vruwxuh60Flvdsshdudqfh70Xdulrxv Jxpdq Tljkwv Xlrodwlrqv80Wqvshflilhg

+5833;463;

9+,7,,

30Ololwdu~1Rrolfh40QwkhuUhfwruv(Iryhpphqw Qiilfldov.

Elyloldqv. Rdud/Ololwdu~.hwf0)

30Elylo Erxuwv40Fhsduwphqw ri Lxvwlfh50LCIQ1Ololwdu~ Cjhqflhv60Cgplqlvwudwlyh Cjhqflhv70Ulpxowdqhrxv Hlolqj zlwk

rwkhuCjhqflhv80QwkhuCjhqflhv90Wqvshflilhg'"

7,+3695A6,,

,,94

7:9

,Fluhfwo~ilohge~ wkhThjlrqdo HlhogQiilfhv zlwkuhfrugv qrw~hwdydlodeohdwwkhEhqwudoQiilfh0

F0 D[ UVCVWUKP EQWTVU1CIGPEKGUCU QH FGEGODGT 3;;2 yyyy

30Erpsodlqwv Hlohg40 Ruholplqdu~1Ruh/Vuldo Kqyhvwljdwlrq50Hru Thvroxwlrq (Ykhwkhu wkhuhlv d

Rulpd Hdflh Edvh djdlqvw wkhdffxvhg1Hlolqj ri Kqirupdwlrq)

60Cuudljqphqw70 Ruh/Vuldo80Vuldo1Ruhvhqwdwlrqri Gylghqfh iru

Rurvhfxwlrq90Rhqglqj Rurpxojdwlrq ri Lxgjhphqw:0 Flvplvvdo iurp Uhuylfh;0 Edvh Flvplvvhg

320 Cftxlwwdo330Erqylfwlrq340Fhprwlrq350Uxvshqvlrq360Cufklyhg e~ Erqfhuqhg Erxuwv1Cjhqflhv370Cplfdeoh Uhwwohphqw.hwf0380Wqvshflilhg

..952

S9874

599835

3938

75.

,,Hru xsgdwlqj xsrq frpsohwlrq ri wkhKqglylgxdo Edvh Ruriloh dqg Orqlwrulqjri Edvhv lq wkh34 Thjlrqv (wr lqfoxgh PET) xqghu wkhmrlqwsurmhfwri wkhEJTdqg wkhPdwlrqdo UwdwlvwlfdoErruglqdwlrq Drdug0

Prwh< Ekdqjhv lq wkh iljxuhv iurp suhylrxv EJT Uxppdu~ Thsruwv (3;::/3;;2) zhuh gxh wr qhz dqg xquhsruwhg fdvhv1frpsodlqwv ri suhylrxv ~hduvuhsruwhg rqo~ lq wkh 3;;2 dqg 3;;30 Vkhvh dgmxvwphqwv.krzhyhu. duh vwloovxemhfwiru yhulilfdwlrq ri grxeoh hqwulhvri frpsodlqwv zklfk pd~ eulqj grzqwkhwrwdoqxpehu ri frpsodlqwv0