N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi...

65
N?_iht|@?_?} |i 6tU@* AiLh) Lu |i hUi wii* w@hi?Ui a ht|@?L @?_ Aihh) a 6|3}ih@*_ Th* 2c 2fff

Transcript of N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi...

Page 1: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

N?_iht|@?_�?} |�i 6�tU@* A�iLh) Lu |�i �h�Ui

wi�i*�

w@�hi?Ui a� ��h�t|�@?L @?_ Aihh) a� 6�|3}ih@*_

�Th�* �2c 2fff

Devwudfw

Zh uhylhz wkh �vfdo wkhru| ri wkh sulfh ohyho1 Zh sodfh vshfldo hpskd0

vlv rq wkh wkhru|*v lpsolfdwlrqv iru wkh ihdvlelolw| dqg ghvludelolw| ri sulfh

vwdelolw|1

�Zh kdyh ehqh�whg iurp glvfxvvlrqv zlwk Vwhidqld Doedqhvl/ Pdufr Edvvhwwr/ Fkduohv Fduo0vwurp/ Pduwlq Hlfkhqedxp/ dqg Wlprwk| Ixhuvw1 Zh duh sduwlfxoduo| judwhixo iru wkh wluhohvvh�ruwv ri Mrkq Frfkudqh/ Fkulvwrskhu Vlpv dqg Plfkdho Zrrgirug wr hgxfdwh xv rq wkh �vfdowkhru|1 Fkulvwldqr dfnqrzohgjhv �qdqfldo vxssruw iurp dq QVI judqw wr wkh Qdwlrqdo Exuhdxri Hfrqrplf Uhvhdufk1

Page 2: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

�L?|i?|t

� W?|hL_�U|�L? � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �2 � �?i��ih�L_ ,UL?L4) � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � b

2�� 5@h}i?| @?_ @**@Ui<t N?T*i@t@?| �L?i|@h�t| �h�|�4i|�U � � � � � b2�2 A�i 6�tU@* A�iLh) � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �f2�� W?|ihThi|�?} +�U@h_�@? @?_ ?L?�+�U@h_�@? 6�tU@* �L*�U) � � � � � � ��2�e Wt |�i 6A�w 5i?t�M*iq �? �?@*L}) �i|�ii? |�i 6A�w @?_ ��UhLtLu| ��2�D Wt |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? �tt�4T|�L? ,4T�h�U@**) �*@�t�M*iq � � � � � �e2�S A�i �h�Ui wi�i* �? @ Lh*_ ��|� �L BL�ih?4i?|��hL��_i_ �L?i) �S

� A�i 6�tU@* A�iLh) W? Bi?ih@* ,^��*�Mh��4 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �.��� Wt |�i �h�Ui wi�i* ��ih_i|ih4�?i_ �? |�i 6A�wq � � � � � � � � � � �H��2 Wt |�i 6A�w 6h@}�*iq � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 2���� A�i 6A�w ��|� 5|LU�@t|�U 6�tU@* �L*�U) � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 2D

����� +@?_L4 6�tU@* �L*�U) � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 2S����2 W?�@|�L? `�|� +@?_L4 6�tU@* �L*�U) � � � � � � � � � � � � 2.����� LL_uLh_<t +i@**) N?T*i@t@?| �h�|�4i|�U � � � � � � � � � �f

��e A�i 6A�w @?_ |�i �L?|hL* Lu ��ih@}i W?�@|�L? � � � � � � � � � � ��e A�i 6A�w @?_ |�i �T|�4@* #i}hii Lu �h�Ui W?t|@M�*�|) � � � � � � � � � ��

e�� A�i �L_i* � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �ee�2 A�i +@4ti) ,^��*�Mh��4 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �.e�� � ��4ih�U@* , @4T*i � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � efe�e 5�44@h) � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � e�

D �L?U*�t�L? � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � e�� A�i wL}�U@* �L�ihi?Ui Lu 6�tU@* A�iLh) � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � Df

��� A�i w�U@t�5|L!i) �@t���hi_�| BLL_ �L_i* � � � � � � � � � � � � D������ OL�ti�L*_t � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � D�����2 BL�ih?4i?| � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � DD����� 6�h4t � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � DS����e ,^��*�Mh��4 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � D.

��2 �L?t|@?| �L?i) BhL�|� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � D.��2�� � ��@h@U|ih�3@|�L? +it�*| uLh ,^��*�Mh�@ � � � � � � � � � � DH��2�2 ��*|�T*i ,^��*�Mh�@ `�|� +�U@h_�@?c �L?t|@?| �L?i) BhL�|� Db��2�� N?�^�i ,^��*�Mh��4 `�|� ?L?�+�U@h_�@?c �L?t|@?| �L?i)

BhL�|� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � S���� 6� i_ W?|ihit| +@|i �L*�U�it � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � S�

2

Page 3: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

�� W?|hL_�U|�L?

�h�Ui t|@M�*�|) �t @? �4TLh|@?| }L@* Lu T�M*�U TL*�U)� AL hi@U� |��t }L@*c |�L !i) ^�it|�L?t4�t| Mi @__hitti_G

� OL� U@? Th�Ui t|@M�*�|) Mi @U��i�i_q

� OL� 4�U� Th�Ui t|@M�*�|) �t _it�h@M*iq

5|@?_@h_ 4L?i|@h�t| _LU|h�?i Lgiht @ t�4T*i @?t�ih |L |�i �ht| ^�it|�L?G 4@!i t�hi |�i Ui?�|h@* M@?! �@t @? �?�@�ih�?} UL44�|4i?| |L Th�Ui t|@M�*�|)� +iUi?|*)c @ }hL�T Lu iUL?L4�t|t�@t Mi}�? |L hi|��?! |�i uL�?_@|�L?t Lu |��t _LU|h�?i� A��t �@t }��i? h�ti |L @? @*|ih?@|��i��i�c �?_ih ���U� @ |L�}�c �?_iTi?_i?| Ui?|h@* M@?! �t ?L| t��U�i?| |L }�@h@?|ii Th�Uit|@M�*�|)� N?_ih |��t ��i�c Th�Ui t|@M�*�|) hi^��hit ?L| L?*) @? @TThLTh�@|i 4L?i|@h) TL*�U)cM�| @*tL @? @TThLTh�@|i �tU@* TL*�U)�� �iU@�ti �tU@* TL*�U) hiUi��it tL 4�U� @||i?|�L? �?|��t ?i� ��i� @ML�| |�i _i|ih4�?@?|t Lu |�i Th�Ui *i�i*c ��U�@i* LL_uLh_ �@t U@**i_ �| |�i6�tU@* A�iLh) Lu |�i �h�Ui wi�i* E6A�w��2

�L?i|@h�t| _LU|h�?i @*tL hiUL}?�3it |�@| ML|� �tU@* @?_ 4L?i|@h) TL*�U) 4�t| Mi ti*iU|i_�? |�i @TThLTh�@|i �@) �u Th�Ui t|@M�*�|) �t |L Mi @U��i�i_� OL�i�ihc |��t _LU|h�?i �L*_t |�@|�u |�i Ui?|h@* M@?! �t |L�}�c |��t ��** @�|L4@|�U@**) UL4Ti* |�i �tU@* @�|�Lh�|�it |L @_LT| @?@TThLTh�@|i �tU@* TL*�U)�� A�i 6A�w _i?�it |��t� W| t@)t |�@|c �?*itt tTiU�@* t|iTt @hi |@!i?|L i?t�hi |�@| @TThLTh�@|i �tU@* TL*�U�it @hi |@!i?c |�i }L@* Lu Th�Ui t|@M�*�|) 4@) hi4@�?i*�t��i hi}@h_*itt Lu �L� |L�}� @?_ �?_iTi?_i?| |�i Ui?|h@* M@?! �t�

A�i 6A�w �@t �4TLh|@?| �4T*�U@|�L?t uLh |�i �@) Ui?|h@* M@?!t UL?_�U| M�t�?itt� A�iUL?�i?|�L?@* ��i� �@t uLt|ihi_ |�i ?L|�L? |�@| Ui?|h@* M@?!iht t�L�*_ t|@) @�@) uhL4 |�i�tU@* @�|�Lh�|�itc �? Lh_ih |L hi_�Ui |�i *�!i*��LL_ Lu Mi�?} Thitt�hi_ �?|L 4@!�?} TLLh4L?i|@h) TL*�U) _iU�t�L?t� A�i 6A�w �@t |�i �4T*�U@|�L? |�@| Ui?|h@* M@?!iht ��|� @4@?_@|i |L uLt|ih Th�Ui t|@M�*�|) ?ii_ |L _L 4Lhi |�@? ��t| 4@!i t�hi |�@| |�i�h L�? �L�ti�t �? Lh_ih� A�i) 4�t| @*tL UL?��?Ui |�i �tU@* @�|�Lh�|) |L @_LT| |�i @TThLTh�@|i �tU@*TL*�U)�

4Lqghhg Frfkudqh +5333, dsshduv wr jr vr idu dv wr vd| wkdw prqhwdu| srolf| pd| eh hvvhq0wldoo| luuhohydqw wr sulfh ghwhuplqdwlrq1 Kh wdnhv wklv srvlwlrq ehfdxvh/ lq klv ylhz/ jryhuqphqw0surylghg wudqvdfwlrqv dvvhwv duh d ydqlvklqj frpsrqhqw ri doo wkh �qdqfldo dvvhwv wkdw duh wudghg1

5Sdshuv wkdw dgyrfdwh wkh IWSO lqfoxgh Ehqkdele/ Vfkplww0Jurkh dqg Xuleh +5333,/Frfkudqh +4<<;/ 5333,/ Gxsru +5333,/ Ohhshu +4<<4,/ Vlpv +4<<7/ 4<<<,/ Zrrgirug +4<<7/ 4<<8/4<<9/ 4<<:/ 4<<;d/ 4<<<,1 Iru fulwlfdo uhylhzv ri wkh IWSO/ vhh Exlwhu +4<<<,/ Fduovwurp dqgIxhuvw +5333,/ Nrfkhuodnrwd dqg Skhodq +4<<<, dqg PfFdooxp +4<<;,1

6Wkh fodvvlf vwdwhphqw lv Vdujhqw dqg Zdoodfh +4<;4,1 Vhh hvshfldoo| wkh odvw sdudjudsk riwkhlu sdshu1

Page 4: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

A�i 6A�w *�|ih@|�hi @*tL _h@�t @||i?|�L? |L |�i tiUL?_ ^�it|�L?c ���U� �t ML|� �4TLh|@?|@?_ _��U�*|� 5�4t E�bbb� @?_ LL_uLh_ E�bbH� TL�?| L�| |�@| @**L��?} |�i Th�Ui *i�i*|L ��U|�@|i ��|� �?i TiU|i_ t�LU!t |L |�i }L�ih?4i?| M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?| ThL_�Uit T�M*�U�?@?Ui Mi?i�|t�e 6Lh i @4T*ic �u @ M@_ �tU@* t�LU! *�!i @ �@h Lh ?@|�h@* _�t@t|ih _h��it �T|�i Th�Ui *i�i*c |��t �t i^���@*i?| |L |@ �?} �L*_iht Lu |�i }L�ih?4i?|<t ?L4�?@* *�@M�*�|�it�A��t |@ ThL4L|it i�U�i?U) |L |�i i |i?| |�@| �| Tih4�|t !iiT�?} *@MLh |@ h@|it t4LL|��W? Th@U|�Uic |��t Mi?i�| �t *�!i*) |L Mi 4�|�}@|i_ M) ��@|i�ih _�t|Lh|�L?@h) ULt|t 4@) Mi@ttLU�@|i_ ��|� Th�Ui �?t|@M�*�|)�D �LU�h@?i E�bbb� �t 4�?_u�* Lu |�iti ULt|t ��i?c �? ��t@?@*)t�tc �i t�4T*) |@!it �| uLh }h@?|i_ |�@| UL4T*i|i Th�Ui t|@M�*�|) �t @ u�?_@4i?|@* tLU�@*LM�iU|��i�S 5�4t E�bbb� U*@�4t |�@| |�i T�M*�U �?@?Ui Mi?i�|t L�ih��i*4 |�i _�t|Lh|�L?@h)ULt|t @ttLU�@|i_ ��|� �L*@|�*i Th�Uitc @?_ tL �i UL?�iU|�hit |�@| UL4T*i|i Th�Ui t|@M�*�|) �t?L?�LT|�4@*� � UL?��?U�?} @?t�ih |L |�i tiUL?_ ^�it|�L? @�@�|t @ ^�@?|�|@|��i t|�_) ���U�U@hiu�**) M@*@?Uit Mi?i�|t @?_ ULt|t�

A��t hi��i� i T*@�?t |�i 6A�w @?_ i*@MLh@|it L? �|t �4T*�U@|�L?t uLh |�i |�L ^�it|�L?t*�t|i_ @ML�ic @t �i** @t uLh L|�ih �tt�it� W? |�i hi4@�?_ih Lu |��t �?|hL_�U|�L?c �i ThL��_i@? L�ih��i� Lu |�i @?@*)t�t� i �ht| _�tU�tt |�i Uh�U�@* @tt�4T|�L? |�@| _�gihi?|�@|it |�i6A�w uhL4 |�i UL?�i?|�L?@* ��i�� �i |c �i t�44@h�3i tL4i Lu |�i !i) �tt�it |�@| 4�t| MiUL?uhL?|i_ �? @?) @ttitt4i?| Lu |�i 6A�w� i |�i? Mh�i�) _itUh�Mi L|�ih �tt�it @__hitti_M) |�i 6A�w *�|ih@|�hi� 6�?@**)c �i i4T�@t�3i |�i UL??iU|�L? Mi|�ii? |�i 6A�w @?_ |�i|h@_�|�L?@* +@4ti) *�|ih@|�hi L? LT|�4@* 4L?i|@h) @?_ �tU@* TL*�U)�

`�@| #�t|�?}��t�it |�i 6A�wq

A�i _�gihi?Ui Mi|�ii? |�i UL?�i?|�L?@* ��i� @?_ |�i 6A�w _Lit ?L| *�i �? @?) ihhLhLu *L}�U�. W?t|i@_c |�i) _�gih L? �L� |�i) ��i� @ T@h|�U�*@h i^�@|�L?c |�i }L�ih?4i?|<t�?|ih|i4TLh@* M�_}i| i^�@|�L?� A�@| i^�@|�L? t@)t |�@| |�i �@*�i Lu |�i }L�ih?4i?| _iM| �ti^�@* |L |�i Thiti?| _�tUL�?|i_ �@*�i Lu u�|�hi }L�ih?4i?| |@ hi�i?�it ?i| Lu i Ti?_�|�hitE��i�c t�hT*�tit�c ��ihi ML|� |�i _iM| @?_ t�hT*�tit @hi _i?L4�?@|i_ �? �?�|t Lu }LL_t� A��t

7Iru suhylrxv glvfxvvlrqv/ vhh Fkdul/ Fkulvwldqr dqg Nhkrh +4<<7,/ Mxgg +4<;<, dqg Oxfdvdqg Vwrnh| +4<;6,1

8Vhh Zrrgirug +4<<;/ ss1 8<093,/ zkr hoderudwhv rq wklv srlqw19Frfkudqh +4<<<, hpskdvl}hv wkh qhhg iru vrph w|sh ri jryhuqphqw vhfxulw| zkrvh sd|r�

�xfwxdwhv lq wkh uljkw zd| zlwk vkrfnv wr wkh jryhuqphqw exgjhw frqvwudlqw/ exw zklfk grhvqrw jhqhudwh wkh vruw ri glvwruwlrqdu| frvwv dvvrfldwhg zlwk d �xfwxdwlqj sulfh ohyho1

:Wkhuh duh dxwkruv zkr duh frqfhuqhg derxw wkh srvvlelolw| wkdw IWSO pd| eh orjlfdoo|lqfrkhuhqw +Exlwhu/ 4<<<,1 Zh sduwldoo| dgguhvv wkhvh frqfhuqv/ e| glvsod|lqj d fodvv ri hfrqrplfhqylurqphqwv lq zklfk wkh IWSO lv orjlfdoo| vrxqg1

e

Page 5: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

i^�@|�L? �t i Thitti_ @t uL**L�tG

�' Thiti?| �@*�i Lu u�|�hi t�hT*�titc E����

��ihi � �t |�i L�|t|@?_�?} ?L4�?@* _iM| Lu |�i }L�ih?4i?|c @?_ � �t |�i Th�Ui *i�i*� A�iUL?�i?|�L?@* ��i� �L*_t |�@| |��t i^�@|�L? �t @ UL?t|h@�?| L? |�i }L�ih?4i?|<t |@ @?_i Ti?_�|�hi TL*�U)�H A�@| �tc TL*�U) 4�t| Mi ti| tL |�@| |�i h�}�| �@?_ t�_i i^�@*t |�i *iu|c��@|i�ih |�i �@*�i Lu � �t� �UULh_�?} |L |��t ��i�c ��i? tL4i|��?} �@TTi?t |L _�t|�hME����c |�i }L�ih?4i?| 4�t| @*|ih �|t i Ti?_�|�hit Lh �|t |@ it |L hit|Lhi i^�@*�|)� �_�LU@|itLu |�i 6A�w @h}�i |�@| |�ihi �t ?L|��?} �?�ihi?| |L }L�ih?4i?| Lh |L tLU�i|) |�@| hi^��hit}L�ih?4i?|t |L |hi@| |��t i^�@|�L? @t @ UL?t|h@�?| L? TL*�U)� W? |�i�h ��i�c |�i �?|ih|i4TLh@*M�_}i| i^�@|�L? �t �?t|i@_ @? i^��*�Mh��4 UL?_�|�L?� �UULh_�?} |L @_�LU@|it Lu |�i 6A�wc��i? tL4i|��?} �@TTi?t |�@| |�hi@|i?t |L _�t|�hM |��t i^�@|�L?c |�i? |�i 4@h!i| U*i@h�?}4iU�@?�t4 4L�it |�i Th�Ui *i�i*c �c |L hit|Lhi i^�@*�|)�

A�i @tt�4T|�L? |�@| }L�ih?4i?| TL*�U) �t ?L| U@*�Mh@|i_ |L t@|�tu) |�i �?|ih|i4TLh@*M�_}i| i^�@|�L? uLh @** � �@t Mii? U@**i_ |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L? M) LL_uLh_� �?�L|�ih �@) Lu t|@|�?} |��t @tt�4T|�L? �t |�@| �u |�i hi@* �@*�i Lu }L�ih?4i?| _iM| �ihi |L}hL� i T*Lt��i*)c ?L @_��t|4i?|t |L �tU@* @?_ 4L?i|@h) TL*�U) �L�*_ Mi 4@_i |L !iiT �| �?*�?i�b

�ttitt�?} |�i 6A�w

AL i�@*�@|i |�i 6A�wc �| �t �tiu�* |L uLU�t L? |�i uL**L��?} TLt�|��i @?_ ?Lh4@|��i�tt�it� Wt |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L? i4T�h�U@**) T*@�t�M*iq�f #Lit |�i 6A�w ThL��_i @UL4Ti**�?} i T*@?@|�L? Lu iT�tL_it Lu ��}� �?�@|�L?q #Lit |�i 6A�w ThL��_i �tiu�* �?T�|�?|L |�i _it�}? Lu tLU�@**) i�U�i?| TL*�U�itq

;Lq rxu qrwlrq ri wd{hv zh lqfoxgh vhljqrudjh uhyhqxhv dqg wd{hv rq wkh uhwxuq wr jryhuqphqwghew/ l1h1/ ghidxow1

<Whfkqlfdoo|/ zh duh h{sorlwlqj wkh htxlydohqfh ehwzhhq wkh lqwhuwhpsrudo exgjhw htxdwlrqdqg d fhuwdlq wudqvyhuvdolw| frqglwlrq1 Wklv htxlydohqfh lv glvfxvvhg odwhu lq wkh wh{w/ dqg lq wkhdsshqgl{1Wkh IWSO grhv qrw dqwlflsdwh wkdw h{sorglqj ghew zrxog hyhu eh revhuyhg1 Wkh lghd lv wkdw

dv orqj dv wkhuh lv devroxwho| qr grxew derxw wkh jryhuqphqw*v frpplwphqw wr qrw dgmxvwlqj�vfdo srolf| lq wkh idfh ri dq h{sorglqj ghew/ wkhq sulfhv zloo uhvsrqg lq vxfk d zd| wkdw wkhghew zloo qrw h{sorgh lq wkh �uvw sodfh1

43Dvvhvvlqj wkh hpslulfdo sodxvlelolw| ri wkh qrq0Ulfdugldq dvvxpswlrq srvhv d vshfldo fkdo0ohqjh/ ehfdxvh lw fdqqrw eh grqh edvhg rq wlph vhulhv dorqh1 Iru ixuwkhu glvfxvvlrq/ vhh vhfwlrq518 ehorz1

D

Page 6: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

W| �t U*i@h |�@| |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L? �t ?L| @ }LL_ U�@h@U|ih�3@|�L? Lu TL*�U)�? @** |�4it @?_ T*@Uit� �u|i? }L�ih?4i?|t _L tii4 hi@_) |L @_��t| �tU@* TL*�U) ��i? |�i_iM| }i|t *@h}i� �?i i @4T*i �t |�i N?�|i_ 5|@|it �? |�i �bHft @?_ �bbftc ��i? }L�ih?4i?|_iM| t|@h|i_ |L �?Uhi@ti @?_ |�ihi �@t UL?t�_ih@M*i Thitt�hi uLh tL4i UL4M�?@|�L? Lu @ |@ �?Uhi@ti @?_ @? i Ti?_�|�hi _iUhi@ti |L Mh�?} |�i _iM| M@U! �?|L *�?i��� �?L|�ih i @4T*i�t |�i �@@t|h�U�| |hi@|)c �? ���U� |�i 4i4Miht Lu |�i ,�hLTi@? N?�L? uLh4@**) hiULh_ |�i�h�?|i?|�L? |L @_��t| �tU@* TL*�U) �? |�i i�i?| |�@| |�i _iM| }hL�t |LL *@h}i� � |��h_ i @4T*i�t |�i W?|ih?@|�L?@* �L?i|@h) 6�?_ EW�6�� A�@| Lh}@?�3@|�L? �tit @? @hh@) Lu t@?U|�L?t @?_hi�@h_t |L i?UL�h@}i 4i4Mih UL�?|h�it |L !iiT |�i�h _iM| �? *�?i M) t��|@M*) @_��t|�?} |�i�h�tU@* TL*�U)�

��|c uLh |�i 6A�w |L Mi @? �?|ihit|�?} TLt�|��i |�iLh)c �| �t ?L| ?iUitt@h) |�@| �| @*�@)t�L*_t� �t i4T�@t�3i_ M) LL_uLh_ E�bbH@�c �| 4@) ThL��_i @ �tiu�* U�@h@U|ih�3@|�L? Lu@U|�@* TL*�U�it �? tL4i UL?|i |tc i�i? �u �| _Lit ?L| �? L|�iht� 6Lh i @4T*ic |�i Tih�L_ Lu |�i�bSft @?_ �b.ft �t @ |�4i ��i? |�i }L�ih?4i?| M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?| �t itti?|�@**) @Mti?| uhL4t|@?_@h_ 4@UhLiUL?L4�U 4L_i*tc @?_ T*@)t *�||*i hL*i �? ki)?it�@? TL*�U) @?@*)t�t E5@h}i?|E�bH.c T� ��2��� �t @ hit�*|c �| �t Tih�@Tt hi@tL?@M*i |L t�TTLti |�@| |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@?@tt�4T|�L? �i*_ uLh |�@| Tih�L_��2 �?L|�ih i @4T*i �t ThL��_i_ M) wL)L E�bbb�c ��L @h}�it|�@| �h@3�*�@? TL*�U) �? |�i *@|i �b.ft @?_ i@h*) �bHft �@t ?L?�+�U@h_�@?� wL)L @h}�it |�@||�i 6A�w ThL��_it @ UL4Ti**�?} i T*@?@|�L? Lu |�i ��}� �?�@|�L? i Tih�i?Ui_ M) �h@3�* �?|��t Tih�L_���

,�i? �u �? Th@U|�Ui TL*�U) �@t ?i�ih Mii? ?L?�+�U@h_�@?c |�i 6A�w 4�}�| t|�** Mi �?�|ihit|�?} @t @ ?Lh4@|��i |�iLh)� A�ihi @hi |�L hi@tL?t ��) |��t 4�}�| Mi tL� 6�ht|c @t_�tU�tti_ *@|ihc LT|�4@* TL*�U�it 4�}�| |�i4ti*�it Mi ?L?�+�U@h_�@?��e 5iUL?_c |�i 6A�wUL�*_ tih�i @t �tiu�* �?T�| |L TL*�U) _it�}?c i�i? �u ?L?�+�U@h_�@? TL*�U�it @hi �? Th@U|�UicM@_� AL tii ��) |�iti TL*�U�it 4�}�| Mi M@_c UL?t�_ih *i}�t*@|Lht *���?} �? @ ?L?�+�U@h_�@?hi}�4i� N?_iht|@?_�?} |�@| |@ U�|t Lh �?Uhi@tit �? }L�ih?4i?| tTi?_�?} _L ?L| ?iUitt@h�*)�@�i |L Mi T@�_ M) ��}�ih |@ it *@|ih L?c |�i) 4@) Mi |i4T|i_ |L i4Mh@Ui TL*�U�it ���U��4T*) |LL 4�U� tTi?_�?} @?_ |LL 4�U� _iM|� +it|h�U|�?} �tU@* TL*�U) M) T*@U�?} @ *�4�|@�

44Zrrgirug +4<<;d, dfnqrzohgjhv wkdw wkh srolwlfdo uhdfwlrq wr jurzlqj ghew lq wkh 4<;3v dqg4<<3v +dv zhoo dv rwkhu frqvlghudwlrqv, lqglfdwhv wkdw XV srolf| lv suredeo| qrw zhoo fkdudfwhul}hgdv qrq0Ulfdugldq gxulqj wkh sdvw wzr ghfdghv +vhh dovr vhfwlrq 617 ehorz,1 Kh dujxhv wkdw hduolhuhslvrghv lq XV srvwzdu klvwru| 0 iru h{dpsoh/ wkh 4<9804<:< shulrg 0 pljkw eh fkdudfwhul}hg lqwklv zd|1

45Vhh Zrrgirug +4<<;d, iru dq hoderudwlrq rq wkh dujxphqw wkdw XV srolf| zdv qrq0Ulfdugldqlq wkh 4<93v dqg 4<:3v1

46Rqh grhv zrqghu zkhwkhu lw pdnhv vhqvh wr dvvxph wkdw d wkhru|/ olnh wkh IWSO/ zklfkirfxvhv rq wkh orqj0uxq surshuwlhv ri �vfdo srolf|/ krogv ryhu vrph vxeshulrgv dqg qrw rwkhuv1

47Vhh Vlpv +4<<<, dqg Zrrgirug +4<<;,1

S

Page 7: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

|�L? L? }L�ih?4i?| _iM| 4@) Mi @? igiU|��i �@) |L _i@* ��|� |��t !�?_ Lu ThLM*i4��D �)it|@M*�t��?} |�i *L}�U@* TLtt�M�*�|) Lu ?L?�+�U@h_�@? TL*�U)c |�i 6A�w �? igiU| �4T*�it |�@|t�U� TL*�U�it UL�*_ LUU�hc �? |�i @Mti?Ui Lu tTiU��U 4i@t�hit |L h�*i |�i4 L�|� �t @ hit�*|c|�i 6A�w U@? Mi �ti_ |L @h|�U�*@|i @ h@|�L?@*i uLh |�i |)Ti Lu _iM| *�4�|@|�L?t �4TLti_ M)|�i W�6 @?_ M) |�i �@@t|h�U�| |hi@|)�

�|�ih Wtt�it �__hitti_ M) |�i 6A�w

�*|�L�}� �i t|hitt |�i �4T*�U@|�L?t Lu |�i 6A�w uLh |�i |�L ^�it|�L?t U�|i_ @ML�ic |�i)@hi ?L| |�i i U*�t��i Lh i�i? Th�4@h) uLU�t Lu |�i *�|ih@|�hi� A�i 6A�w �@t T*i?|) |L Lgihci�i? uLh TiLT*i ��|� ?L �?|ihit| �? L�h |�L ^�it|�L?t� �_�LU@|it Lu |�i 6A�w i4T�@t�3i|�i �@*�i Lu |�i�h uh@4i�Lh! uLh �?_iht|@?_�?} Th�Ui *i�i* _i|ih4�?@|�L? �? ti||�?}t �? ���U�|h@_�|�L?@* ^�@?|�|)�|�iLhi|�U hi@tL?�?} Mhi@!t _L�?� A��t U@? �@TTi?c uLh i @4T*ic �u|�i 4L?i|@h) @�|�Lh�|) @_LT|t @ TL*�U) Lu Ti}}�?} |�i h@|i Lu �?|ihit|c tL |�@| |�i t�TT*)Lu 4L?i) hitTL?_t T@tt��i*) |L _i4@?_� A��t U@ti _itih�it i4T�@t�t MiU@�ti �?|ihit| h@|i|@h}i|t @hi |�L�}�| |L T*@) @? �4TLh|@?| hL*i �? 4L?i|@h) TL*�U) �? Th@U|�Ui EA@)*Lh E�bb�����S

�?L|�ih tUi?@h�L Lu TL|i?|�@* �?|ihit| LUU�ht ��i? Th��@|i |h@?t@U|�L?t �?�L*�i ?L �ti Lu}L�ih?4i?|�ThL��_i_ 4L?i)� A��t T@Tih Thiti?|t i @4T*it |L �**�t|h@|i |�i �?|ihit| h@|iTi}}�?} @?_ U@t�*itt iUL?L4) tUi?@h�Lt�

6h@?! +@4ti) @?_ |�i 6A�w

i @*tL �ti L�h U@t�*itt iUL?L4) i @4T*i |L TL�?| L�| |�i T@h@**i*t Mi|�ii? |�i 6A�w@?_ |�i |h@_�|�L?@* *�|ih@|�hi L? LT|�4@* 4L?i|@h) @?_ �tU@* TL*�U) �?tT�hi_ M) 6h@?! +@4ti)E�b2.� @?_ hi��?|hL_�Ui_ �?|L 4@UhLiUL?L4�Ut M) w�U@t @?_ 5|L!i) E�bH����. W? |�i +@4ti)

48Fkdul dqg Nhkrh +4<<<, ghvfuleh d prgho lq zklfk frxqwulhv irup d prqhwdu| xqlrq dqg/devhqw ghew frqvwudlqwv/ wkh uhvxow lv h{fhvvlyh ghew1 Zrrgirug +4<<9, dujxhv wkdw d xqlrqzlwkrxw ghew frqvwudlqwv lv olnho| wr hqg xs zlwk h{fhvvlyh sulfh yrodwlolw|1 Klv uhdvrqlqj xvhvwkh nlqg ri orjlf vxuyh|hg lq wklv sdshu1 Kh qrwhv wkdw li srolf| lv qrq0Ulfdugldq/ wkhq �vfdovkrfnv pxvw vkrz xs dv vkrfnv wr wkh sulfh ohyho/ uhjdugohvv ri prqhwdu| srolf| +zh fdoo wklvZrrgirug*v Uhdoo| Xqsohdvdqw dulwkphwlf lq vhfwlrq 616 ehorz,1 Kh dujxhv wkdw sulfh ohyholqvwdelolw| dulvlqj iurp wklv vrxufh lv olnho| wr eh h{fhvvlyh lq d prqhwdu| xqlrq wkdw dgrswv dqrq0Ulfdugldq srolf|1 Lw lv suhflvho| ehfdxvh kh wklqnv wkdw d qrq0Ulfdugldq srolf| lv d uhdolvwlfsrvvlelolw| 0 d srvvlelolw| zklfk kh wklqnv lq wklv fdvh lv edg 0 wkdw kh dssuryhv ri wkh h{solflwghew uhvwulfwlrqv lqfrusrudwhg lqwr wkh Pddvwulfkw wuhdw|1 Iru dqrwkhu/ vlplodu/ glvfxvvlrq ri wkhsrwhqwldo gdqjhuv ri qrq0Ulfdugldq srolf|/ vhh Zrrgirug +4<<;/ s1 93,1

49Iru d uhfhqw dqdo|vlv ri wkh fdvh lq zklfk wkh lqwhuhvw udwh lv qrw shjjhg/ exw lv doorzhgwr pryh durxqg zlwk yduldwlrqv lq wkh vwdwh ri wkh hfrqrp|/ vhh Ehqkdele/ Vfkplww0Jurkh dqgXuleh +5333,1

4:Wkhvh sdudoohov duh hpskdvl}hg lq Vlpv +4<<<, dqg Zrrgirug +4<<;,1

.

Page 8: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

*�|ih@|�hic }L�ih?4i?| �TL*�U)< �t @ ti^�i?Ui Lu @U|�L?t E|@ h@|itc i Ti?_�|�hitc i|U�� �?_i i_M) |�i _@|i @?_ E�? 4L_i*t ��|� �?Uih|@�?|)� M) |�i hi@*�3i_ �@*�i Lu t�LU!t� �iU@�ti |�itiTL*�U�it @hi ?L| u�?U|�L?t Lu T@t| Th�Uitc |�ihi _L i �t| Th�Uit t�U� |�@| |�i _iM| i T*L_it@?_ �L�ti�L*_t hiu�ti |L M�) �|� 5�U� TLtt�M�*�|�it @hi Lu ?L UL?Uih? �? |�i +@4ti) *�|ih@|�hiMiU@�ti |�i }L�ih?4i?| �t ��i�i_ @t ti*iU|�?} �|t TL*�U) MiuLhi Th�Uit @hi _i|ih4�?i_c @?_�| �t |@!i? uLh }h@?|i_ |�@| L?*) i^��*�Mh��4 Th�Uit LUU�h��H W? i^��*�Mh��4c _i4@?_ i^�@*tt�TT*) �? @** 4@h!i|tc �?U*�_�?} 4@h!i|t uLh }L�ih?4i?| _iM|��b i |��?! Lu ?L?�+�U@h_�@?TL*�U�it @t ULhhitTL?_�?} |L |�i |)Ti Lu TL*�U�it UL?|i4T*@|i_ �? |�i +@4ti) *�|ih@|�hi�

W? |�i +@4ti) *�|ih@|�hic |�ihi �t @ UL?Uih? |�@| TL*�U�it 4@) ?L| Mi |�4i�UL?t�t|i?|c �?|�i ti?ti |�@| �| �t ?L| UL?t�t|i?| ��|� |�i }L�ih?4i?|<t �?Ui?|��it |L @U|�@**) �4T*i4i?||�i4 �? hi@* |�4i� i |��?! |�@| |�i UL?Uih?t @ML�| |�4i UL?t�t|i?U) �? |�i +@4ti)*�|ih@|�hi 4@) @*tL @TT*) |L |�i 6A�w� AL tii ��)c UL?t�_ih @}@�? |�i t�|�@|�L? �? ���U� |�iTh�Ui *i�i* h�tit ��i? |�ihi �t @ M@_ t�LU! |L |�i }L�ih?4i?| M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?|� W? @ �Lh*_*�!i |��tc Th��@|i @}i?|t 4@) t�tTiU| |�@| }L�ih?4i?|t ��** uhi^�i?|*) hitLh| |L ��}� Th�Uit @t@? i@t) �@) |L hi?i}i L? _iM|� W? |��t U@tic |�i TL*�U) �L�*_ M@U!�hic ��|� @}i?|t hiu�t�?}|L @UU�4�*@|i }L�ih?4i?| _iM| �? |�i �ht| T*@Ui� AL @�L�_ |��t L�|UL4ic �| �t ?iUitt@h) |LUhi_�M*) UL?��?Ui TL|i?|�@* �L*_iht Lu }L�ih?4i?| _iM| |�@| |�i) ��** hiUi��i t�Mt�_�it ��i?}LL_ |��?}t �@TTi? |L |�i }L�ih?4i?| UL?t|h@�?|�2f OL�i�ihc |�ihi 4@) Mi |�4it @?_ T*@Uit��ihi |�i �?t|�|�|�L?@* @?_ L|�ih tLU�@* t|h�U|�hit ?ii_i_ |L @U��i�i |�i hi^��hi_ _i}hii LuUhi_�M*) _L ?L| i �t|�

A�i hi4@�?_ih Lu |�i T@Tih �t Lh}@?�3i_ @t uL**L�t� 5iU|�L? 2 4@!it 4Lt| Lu L�h TL�?|t�? @ L?i�Tih�L_ i?��hL?4i?|� �) @_LT|�?} t�U� @ t�4T*i ti|�T �i @hi @M*i |L }i| |L |�i M@t�U�_i@t ��|�L�| |iU�?�U@* UL4T*�U@|�L?t� �| |�i t@4i |�4ic |�ihi @hi tL4i �tt�it |�@| t�4T*)

4;Lpsolflwo|/ zh duh wdnlqj d sduwlfxodu vwdqg rq zkdw frqvwlwxwhv cjryhuqphqw srolf|* lq dUdpvh|0rswlpdo srolf| vhwwlqj1 Vwulfwo| vshdnlqj/ doo wkdw Udpvh| wkhru| whoov xv lv zkdw jry0huqphqw dfwlrqv duh wdnhq lq wkh ehvw htxloleulxp1 Wkhuh pd| zhoo eh pdq| gl�huhqw jryhuqphqwsrolf| uxohv zklfk uhvxow lq wkh vdph Udpvh| htxloleulxp/ zkhuh d srolf| uxoh vshfl�hv jryhuq0phqw dfwlrqv dv d ixqfwlrq ri wkh uhdol}dwlrq ri h{rjhqrxv dqg hqgrjhqrxv yduldeohv1 Gl�huhqwsrolf| uxohv lpso| gl�huhqw srolf| dfwlrqv rxw ri htxloleulxp1 Wkh glvwlqfwlrq ehwzhhq wkh jry0huqphqw*v srolf| uxoh dqg wkh Udpvh| htxloleulxp rxwfrphv lv fodul�hg lq Zrrgirug +4<<;/4<<<,1Kh frpsxwhv Udpvh| htxloleulxp rxwfrphv dqg wkhq vhdufkhv iru Wd|oru +4<<6,0olnh lqwhuhvw udwhuxohv zklfk vxssruw wkrvh rxwfrphv dv dq htxloleulxp1 Lq wklv sdshu/ zh wdnh wkh srvlwlrq wkdwwkh jryhuqphqw*v srolf| dfwlrqv lq d Udpvh| htxloleulxp duh wkh jryhuqphqw*v srolf| uxoh1

4<Lq Udpvh| wkhru| dqg lq wkh IWSO/ wkhuh h{lvw pdunhw sulfhv zkhuh jryhuqphqw srolf|frpplwv lw wr grlqj lqihdvleoh wklqjv1 Iru h{dpsoh/ wkhuh pd| eh sulfhv zkhuh lw frpplwv wrsd|lqj iru jrrgv zlwk prqh| �qdqfhg iurp qhz ghew lvvxhv zklfk qr rqh ex|v1 E| irfxvlqjrq htxloleulxp sulfhv rqo|/ vwdqgdug sudfwlfh ljqruhv wkhvh srvvlelolwlhv1 Edvvhwwr +5333, dujxhvwkdw wklv lv d plvwdnh/ dqg sursrvhv dowhuqdwlyh htxloleulxp frqfhswv wr ghdo zlwk wkh sureohp1

53Vhh Fkdul/ Fkulvwldqr dqg Nhkrh +4<<4, iru d ghwdlohg dqdo|vlv1

H

Page 9: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

U@??L| Mi _�tU�tti_ �? @ L?i Tih�L_ i?��hL?4i?|� i _iuih |�iti |L tiU|�L? �� 5iU|�L?e Thiti?|t @ t�4T*i 4L_i* uLh |��?!�?} @ML�| |�i _it�h@M�*�|) Lu Th�Ui ��U|�@|�L?t �?_ih|�i 6A�w �? @? i?��hL?4i?| ��|� ?L }L�ih?4i?|�ThL��_i_ 4L?i)� 5iU|�L? D ThL��_it @t�44�?}��T�

2� � �?i��ih�L_ ,UL?L4)

�t ?L|i_ �? |�i �?|hL_�U|�L?c |�i !i) _i�?�?} U�@h@U|ih�t|�U Lu |�i 6A�w �t |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@?@tt�4T|�L? L? �tU@* TL*�U)� A�i Mit| �@) |L �?_iht|@?_ |��t @tt�4T|�L? @?_ ^��U!*) }i| |L|�i �i@h| Lu |�i 6A�w �t |L }L |L @ L?i Tih�L_ 4L_i*�2� A�@|<t ��@| �i _L �ihi�

i Mi}�? ��|� |�i UL?�i?|�L?@* ��t_L4c |�i U*@tt�U 5@h}i?| @?_ @**@Ui E�bH�� E5`�@?@*)t�t� i |�i? i T*@�? �L� |�i 6A�w _�giht uhL4 |��t UL?�i?|�L?@* ��t_L4G |�i 5`@?@*)t�t @_LT|t @ +�U@h_�@? ��i� @?_ |�i 6A�w @_LT|t |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? ��i� @ML�| TL*�U)�i i T*Lhi �@h�L�t �?|ihThi|@|�L?t Lu |�iti @tt�4T|�L?t @?_ UL?U*�_i |�@| |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@?

@tt�4T|�L? hi^��hit |�@| |�i }L�ih?4i?| �t @M*i |L UL44�| �? @_�@?Ui |L �|t TL*�U) @U|�L?t�i |�i? @t! �L� �i U@? }L @ML�| @ttitt�?} |�i i4T�h�U@* T*@�t�M�*�|) Lu |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@?

@tt�4T|�L?� W? |�i �?@* t�MtiU|�L?c �i i T*@�? �L� |�i 6A�w U@? Mi �ti_ |L t|�_) |�iTh�Ui *i�i* �? @ �Lh*_ ��ihi }L�ih?4i?| ThL��_i_ �@| 4L?i) �@t �@?�t�i_�

2��� 5@h}i?| @?_ @**@Ui<t N?T*i@t@?| �L?i|@h�t| �h�|�4i|�U

5�TTLti |�@| �? |�i 4Lh?�?} Lu |�i L?*) _@) �? |��t 4L_i*c Th��@|i @}i?|t @hi �L*_�?} @ }��i?@4L�?| Lu }L�ih?4i?| _iM|c K� Oihi @?_ |�hL�}�L�| |��t T@Tihc �i @tt�4i |�@| }L�ih?4i?|_iM| �t ?L?�?i}@|��iG @}i?|t U@??L| MLhhL� uhL4 |�i }L�ih?4i?|� W? |�i 5` 4L_i*c |�i_iM| �t � i_ �? hi@* |ih4t� W| �t @ UL44�|4i?| |L T@) @ � i_ hi@* @4L�?| Lu }LL_tc t@) ULh?�

Oihi �t |�i }L�ih?4i?|<t M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?|G

K� n rs n r6 ' K�

A�i *iu| @?_ h�}�| t�_i Lu |��t i^�@|�L? t�44@h�3it |�i tL�hUit @?_ �titc hitTiU|��i*)c LuULh? |L |�i }L�ih?4i?|� A�i �ht| tL�hUi Lu u�?_tc K�c �t ULh? |�i }L�ih?4i?| hiUi��it uhL4@?) �L�ti�L*_t ��L T�hU�@ti ?i� _iM| �? |�i i�i?�?}� A�i tiUL?_ |ih4c rs c �t |@ it ?i| LutTi?_�?}c @?_ |�i |��h_ |ih4 �t ti�}?Lh@}i @h�t�?} uhL4 }L�ih?4i?| t�TT*�i_ �@| U�hhi?U)�A�i |ih4c Kc L? |�i h�}�| t�_i Lu |�i M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?| �t |�i Th�?U�T*i @?_ �?|ihit| L? |�iT@t| }L�ih?4i?| _iM|�

54Zh duh judwhixo wr Pdufr Edvvhwwr iru vxjjhvwlqj wklv wr xv1

b

Page 10: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

�T|�4�3�?} �L�ti�L*_t ��** LM��L�t*) ?i�ih U�LLti K� : f @?_ |�i) @hi UL?t|h@�?i_ uhL4ti||�?} K� f M) @tt�4T|�L?� 5Lc �L�ti�L*_ LT|�4�3@|�L? �4T*�it |�@| K� 4�t| Mi 3ihL�W4TLt�?} |��tc �i }i| |�i �?|ih|i4TLh@* }L�ih?4i?| M�_}i| i^�@|�L?G

K ' rs n r6� E2���

A�i 4@�? UL?U*�t�L?t Lu |�i 5` @?@*)t�t 4@) Mi �?_iht|LL_ uhL4 |��t i^�@|�L?� 5�TTLti @�*LLti< �tU@* TL*�U) �t @_LT|i_c ��i�c rs �t hi_�Ui_� A�i?c t�4T*i @h�|�4i|�U _�U|@|it |�@| |�i4L?i|@h) @�|�Lh�|) 4�t| �?Uhi@ti r6� N?_ih ?Lh4@* U�hU�4t|@?Uitc |��t |h@?t*@|it �?|L @?�?Uhi@ti �? �?�@|�L?�22 W? @ 4�*|�Tih�L_ 4L_i* |�ihi �t tL4i _�tUhi|�L? @ML�| |�4�?}� A�ih�ti �? �?�@|�L? U@? LUU�h *@|ihc tLL?ihc Lh �| UL�*_ Mi tThi@_ L�| L�ih |�4i� ��|c ��@|i�ih|�i |�4�?}c �u |�i �tU@* @�|�Lh�|) hi_�Uit rs c |�i @h�|�4i|�U _h��it L?i |L |�i ��i� |�@|�?�@|�L? 4�t| @| tL4i TL�?| }L �T� A��t �t |�i tL�hUi Lu |�i u@4L�t |�|*i |L |�i 5@h}i?| @?_@**@Ui T@Tihc �5L4i N?T*i@t@?| �L?i|@h�t| �h�|�4i|�U<�A�i t@4i @h�|�4i|�U t�}}it|t @ tL*�|�L? |L |�i �?�@|�L? ThLM*i4G _it�}? Ui?|h@* M@?!t tL

|�@| |�i) U@? Uhi_�M*) UL44�| |L ?L| �U@��?} �?< |L @? �hhitTL?t�M*i �tU@* @�|�Lh�|) ��L ti|trs *L�� BL�ih?4i?|t @hL�?_ |�i �Lh*_ �@�i tL�}�| |L �4T*i4i?| |��t M) 4@!�?} Ui?|h@*M@?!t �?_iTi?_i?| @?_ _�hiU|�?} |�i4 |L @tt�}? @ ��}� Th�Lh�|) |L �?�@|�L?� A�i ?L|�L?�t |�@| ��|� |�i 4L?i|@h) @�|�Lh�|) UL4T*i|i*) UL44�||i_ |L @ � i_ �@*�i uLh r6c |�i@h�|�4i|�U uLhUit |�i �tU@* @�|�Lh�|) |L @_LT| |�i �tU@* TL*�U) UL?t�t|i?| ��|� �|� A��t �t |�iM@t�t uLh |�i U�hhi?| UL?�i?|�L?@* ��i� |�@| |L @U��i�i @ t|@M*i Th�Ui *i�i*c �| �t t��U�i?| |L�@�i @ |L�}�c �?_iTi?_i?| Ui?|h@* M@?! ���U� �t uLU�ti_ L? Th�Uit�

2�2� A�i 6�tU@* A�iLh)

�UULh_�?} |L @_�LU@|it Lu |�i 6A�w |�i 5` uh@4i�Lh! 4@) ?L| Mi |�i L?i |�@| �t hi*i�@?|uLh iUL?L4�it *�!i |�i N5� W? Th@U|�Ui }L�ih?4i?| _iM| �t @ UL44�|4i?| |L _i*��ih @ Uih|@�?@4L�?| Lu |�i _L4it|�U U�hhi?U)c ?L| }LL_t� A��t Uhi@|it ?i� TLtt�M�*�|�it�

55E| qrupdo/ zh phdq wkdw wkh hfrqrp| lv rq wkh culjkw* vlgh ri wkh Od�hu fxuyh1 Khuh lv deulhi h{sodqdwlrq1 Vhljqrudjh lv wkh qrplqdo lqfuhdvh lq wkh vwrfn ri prqh|/ glylghg e| wkh sulfhohyho1 D frqyhqlhqw irupxod iru wklv ehfrphv dydlodeoh li zh whpsrudulo| uhlqwhusuhw rxu prghodv d pxowlshulrg prgho lq d vwhdg| vwdwh1 Ohw wkh ghpdqg iru uhdo edodqfhv eh p @ h{s+���,>zkhuh � A 3> � lv wkh jurvv lq�dwlrq udwh iurp wklv shulrg wr wkh qh{w/ dqg p lv wkh vwrfn riprqh|/ glylghg e| wkh sulfh ohyho1 Wkhq/ vhljqrudjh lv mxvw p+4 � 4@�, @ h{s+���,+4 � 4@�,=Iru lq�dwlrq udwhv ehorz �� @ +� �

s�5 . 7�,@+5�,> vhljqrudjh lv lqfuhdvlqj lq lq�dwlrq/ dqg

iru lq�dwlrq udwhv deryh wklv srlqw/ vhljqrudjh lv ghfuhdvlqj1 Wkh culjkw* vlgh ri wkh Od�hu fxuyhuhihuv wr lq�dwlrq udwhv ehorz ��=

�f

Page 11: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

wi|<t hi_L |�i Thi��L�t @?@*)t�t ��|� K hiT*@Ui_ M) �c ?L4�?@* _iM|� A��t �t |�i }L�ih?�4i?|<t M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?|G

�� n ��rs n r6

�' �� E2�2�

�t MiuLhic LT|�4�3�?} �L�ti�L*_t ��** ?L| M�) @?) }L�ih?4i?| _iM| �? |�i i�i?�?}� `�|�_i4@?_ @| 3ihLc |�i L?*) i^��*�Mh��4 U@? Mi @| �� ' f� ,^�@|�L? E2�2� ��|� �� ' f �t |�i}L�ih?4i?|<t �?|ih|i4TLh@* M�_}i| i^�@|�L?G

� ' ��rs n r6

�� E2���

�L�c � �t @? i?_L}i?L�t �@h�@M*i� Wu |�i �tU@* @�|�Lh�|�it 4@!i rs t4@**c |�ihi �t ?L� ?L@h�|�4i|�U |�@| UL4Ti*t |�i 4L?i|@h) @�|�Lh�|�it |L h@�ti r6� Wu |�i 4L?i|@h) @�|�Lh�|�it�L*_ u@t| |L r6 ���*i |�i �tU@* @�|�Lh�|�it hi_�Ui rs c |�i? |��t i^�@|�L? U@? UL?|�?�i |L Mit@|�t�i_ @t *L?} @t � ��4Tt� A��t �t ��@| @_�LU@|it Lu |�i 6A�w i TiU| �L�*_ �@TTi?�

2��� W?|ihThi|�?} +�U@h_�@? @?_ ?L?�+�U@h_�@? 6�tU@* �L*�U)

�| |��t TL�?|c �i U*@h�u) |�L !i) UL?UiT|t� 6�tU@* @?_ 4L?i|@h) TL*�U) @hi t@�_ |L Mi ?L?�

+�U@h_�@? �u r � rs n r6 �t U�Lti? �? @ �@) |�@| _Lit ?L| }�@h@?|ii |�@| |�i �?|ih|i4TLh@*M�_}i| i^�@|�L?c E2���c �t t@|�t�i_ uLh @** TLtt�M*i Th�Uit� W? UL?|h@t|c r �t @ +�U@h_�@? �tU@*TL*�U) �u �| �t U�Lti? �? @ �@) |�@| }�@h@?|iit |�@| |�i �?|ih|i4TLh@* M�_}i| i^�@|�L? �tt@|�t�i_ ?L 4@||ih ��@| � �t hi@*�3i_� W? L�h t�?}*i Tih�L_ 4L_i*c |�i L?*) �@) |��t U@?�@TTi? �t �u r �t @ T@h|�U�*@h u�?U|�L? Lu |�i Th�Ui *i�i*c rE� � ' �*�� A�i @tt�4T|�L? |�@|�tU@* @?_ 4L?i|@h) TL*�U) @hi ?L?�+�U@h_�@? �t ��@| _i�?it |�i 6A�w�

OL� @hi �i |L �?|ihThi| ?L?�+�U@h_�@? TL*�U)q W? Th�?U�T*ic |�L �?|ihThi|@|�L?t @hiTLtt�M*i� A�i �ht| L?i 4@) tii4 *�!i |�i ?@|�h@* L?i �?�|�@**)� OL�i�ihc L? u�h|�ih hi�iU|�L?�| 4@!it ?L ti?ti� N?_ih |��t �?|ihThi|@|�L?c |�i }L�ih?4i?| �t t�4T*) �?UL?Uih?i_ @ML�||�i �?|ih|i4TLh@* M�_}i| i^�@|�L? ��i? �| U�LLtit r� A��t UL�*_ hi�iU| i�|�ih |�@| �| �t?L| @�@hi Lu �|t i �t|i?Uic Lh �| t�4T*) _Lit ?L| U@hi� Wu |�i }L�ih?4i?| �ihi UL4T*i|i*)�?UL?Uih?i_ ��|� �?|ih|i4TLh@* M�_}i| M@*@?Uic |�i? �| �t �4TLtt�M*i |L �?_iht|@?_ ��) �i�@�i @?) |@ it� �Mti?| UL?Uih?t |�@| t|i4 uhL4 |�i i �t|i?Ui Lu |�i �?|ih|i4TLh@* M�_}i|i^�@|�L?c MLhhL��?} �t @*�@)t @ 4Lhi @TTi@*�?} LT|�L? |�@? h@�t�?} |@ it MiU@�ti |�i *@||ihThL_�Ui _i@_�i�}�| *Lttit� ��|c �u }L�ih?4i?|t _�_?<| h@�ti |@ itc r �L�*_ Mi ?i}@|��i @?_|�ihi �L�*_ Mi ?L TLt�|��i � |�@| t@|�t�it |�i �?|ih|i4TLh@* M�_}i| i^�@|�L?� 5Lc �u �i@_LT| |��t �?|ihThi|@|�L? Lu ?L?�+�U@h_�@? TL*�U) |�i @TT@hi?| i �t|i?Ui Lu i^��*�Mh��4 �t @T�33*i� A��t �?|ihThi|@|�L? _itih�it ?L u�h|�ih UL?t�_ih@|�L?�

Wt �| TLtt�M*i |L hiUL?U�*i |�i ?L|�L? |�@| |�i }L�ih?4i?| U@hit @ML�| �?|ih|i4TLh@*M�_}i| M@*@?Ui ��|� |�i ?L|�L? |�@| r �t ti| i L}i?L�t*)c @?_ ?L| @t @ u�?U|�L? Lu �q A�i

��

Page 12: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

@?t�ih �t �)it<c �u �i �4@}�?i |�@| |�i }L�ih?4i?| UL44�|t �|ti*u |L r �? @_�@?Uic MiuLhi� �t _i|ih4�?i_� i �**�t|h@|i |��t �? |�L �@)t� A�i �ht| �t M@ti_ L? |�i T@h@M*i Lu |�i@*h@t�@? @�U|�L?iihc ��L �i*Tt |�i iUL?L4) �?_ |�i i^��*�Mh��4 Th�Ui *i�i*� N?_ih |�i

?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L?c |�i }L�ih?4i?| @??L�?Uit r MiuLhi |�i @*h@t�@? @�U|�L?iihUL?_�U|t |�i @�U|�L? |L �?_ |�i 4@h!i|�U*i@h�?} Th�Ui *i�i*� `�i? |�i }L�ih?4i?| ti*iU|trc �| �?_iht|@?_t u�**) |�@| �L�ti�L*_t ��** M�) 3ihL �� �? i^��*�Mh��4� OL�i�ihc MiU@�tiLu �|t �ht| 4L�ih @_�@?|@}ic |�i }L�ih?4i?| !?L�t |�@| �| U@? �? igiU| uLhUi |�i @*h@t�@?@�U|�L?iih |L T�U! � tL |�@| � ' �*r�

��h tiUL?_ �**�t|h@|�L? �t M@ti_ L? @? @?@*L}) _h@�? uhL4 i�ih)_@) *�ui� � Ti_it|h�@? @| @UhLtt��@*! ��L �@?|t @�|L4LM�*i |h@�U |L t|LT ��** tL4i|�4it t|iT L?|L |�i t|hii| 4@!�?}@ t�L� Lu Mi�?} �?UL?Uih?i_ @ML�| |�i L?UL4�?} U@ht� Wt �| |�@| t�U� @ TihtL? hi@**)_Lit?<| U@hi @ML�| |�i ThLtTiU| Lu Mi�?} t|h�U! @?_ !�**i_q �u UL�hti ?L|� A�i) i TiU||�@| L?UL4�?} @�|L4LM�*itc tii�?} |�i UL44�|4i?| |L UhLtt hi}@h_*itt Lu UL?ti^�i?Uitc��** t|LT h@|�ih |�@? t�gih |�i �LhhLh Lu @? @UU�_i?|� N?_ih @ ?L?�+�U@h_�@? �tU@* TL*�U)c|�i }L�ih?4i?| @_LT|t @? @TThL@U� @?@*L}L�t |L |�@| Lu |�i Ti_it|h�@?� A�i }L�ih?4i?|<t�TL*�U)< �t t�4T*) @? @U|�L?c r� W? Th�?U�T*ic @ � UL�*_ LUU�h ���U� �L�*_ T�| |�i }L�ih?4i?|�? |�i �tU@**) i T*Lt��i t�|�@|�L? ��ihi �| Lgiht _iM| |�@| |�i 4@h!i| hiu�tit |L @MtLhMc��i�c ��ihi �� : f� OL�i�ihc �u |�i 4@h!i| �t UL4T*i|i*) UL?��?Ui_ Lu |�i }L�ih?4i?|<tUL44�|4i?| |L r |�i?c *�!i |�i @�|L4LM�*i |�@| t|LTt uLh |�i Ti_it|h�@?c |�i 4@h!i| ��**}i?ih@|i @ � ���U� }�@h@?|iit |�@| _iM| �t ?L| i Uitt��i E�? |��t U@tic �i Uitt��i< t�4T*)4i@?t }hi@|ih |�@? 3ihL�� A�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? }L�ih?4i?| �t M@?!�?} L? |�i �_i@ |�@| |�i4@h!i| @M�Lht ?L?�i^��*�Mh��4 � @t 4�U� @t _h��iht @M�Lh ��||�?} Ti_it|h�@?t�2�

�*|�L�}� |�i �ti Lu |�i �Lh_ �UL44�|4i?|< �? |��t UL?|i | �t UL?t�t|i?| ��|� |�i |iU�?�U@*iUL?L4�Ut *�|ih@|�hic �| 4@) ?i�ih|�i*itt }i?ih@|i UL?u�t�L? MiU@�ti �| �@t �@h�L�t 4i@?�?}t�? i�ih)_@) *@?}�@}i� �) t@)�?} |�@| |�i }L�ih?4i?| �@t UL44�|4i?|c �i 4i@? L?*) |�@| �|�4L�it �ht|<c MiuLhi Th�Uit @hi ti|� i _L ?L| ?iUitt@h�*) 4i@? |L �4T*) |�@| |�i }L�ih?4i?|<t

56Dv wkh dqdorj| vxjjhvwv/ wkhuh lv d srwhqwldo iru wurxeoh li frpplwphqw lv qrw fuhgleoh1 Li wkhrqfrplqj wud�f lv qrw frpsohwho| frqylqfhg derxw wkh shghvwuldq*v frpplwphqw +vd|/ gulyhuveholhyh wkh shghvwuldq lv vqhdnlqj jodqfhv dw wkh rqfrplqj wud�f/ uhdg| wr pdnh dgmxvwphqwvlq fdvh vrphwklqj jrhv zurqj,/ wkhq plvfdofxodwlrqv fdq ohdg wr wudjlf froolvlrq1 Zh dujxh+vhh hvshfldoo| vhfwlrq 717 ehorz, wkdw vrphwklqj olnh wklv lv srvvleoh li sulydwh djhqwv duh qrwfrpsohwho| frqylqfhg ri wkh jryhuqphqw*v frpplwphqw wr d qrq0Ulfdugldq �vfdo srolf|1 Lq wklvfdvh/ pdunhwv pljkw surgxfh wkh czurqj* sulfhv/ ohdglqj wr h{fhvvlyh jryhuqphqw ghew lq wkhvhqvh wkdw wkh sulydwh vhfwru uhixvhv wr sxufkdvh lw1 Wklv vhhpv wr eh wkh nlqg ri rxwfrph wkdwfrqfhuqv Exlwhu +4<<<,1 Kh uhihuv wr wkh csdlqixo* �vfdo dgmxvwphqwv wkdw pxvw eh pdgh zkhq wkhcUlfdugldq uhdolw| gdzqv* dqg wkh sulydwh vhfwru uhixvhv wr ex| jryhuqphqw ghew1 Zh gr qrw phdqwr vxjjhvw wkdw fdwdvwurskh zloo dozd|v rffxu li wkhuh lv xqfhuwdlqw| derxw jryhuqphqw srolf|1Dv vhfwlrq 616 vkrzv/ wkh qrq0Ulfdugldq dvvxpswlrq lv shuihfwo| frqvlvwhqw zlwk d vwrfkdvwlf�vfdo srolf|1

�2

Page 13: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

4L|��it @hi *@�_@M*ic Lh |�@| �|t @M�*�|) |L 4L�i �ht| hi�iU|t t|hi?}|� Lu U�@h@U|ih L? |�iT@h| Lu }L�ih?4i?| TL*�U) 4@!iht� 6Lh i @4T*ic @ }L�ih?4i?| |�@| �t TihTi|�@**) �? }h�_*LU!MiU@�ti *i}�t*@|Lht U@??L| hi@U� @}hii4i?| @U|t ��|� UL44�|4i?| �? L�h �t@}i Lu |�i |ih4�2e

�L� UL?t�_ih +�U@h_�@? TL*�U�it� 6Lh |�i T�hTLti Lu L�h @?@*)t�tc �i _L ?L| ?ii_ |L |@!i@ TLt�|�L? L? |�i hi*@|�L?t��T Mi|�ii? |�iti TL*�U�it @?_ |�i }L�ih?4i?|<t @M�*�|) |L UL44�|�5|�**c �i t�tTiU| |�@| +�U@h_�@? TL*�U�it @hi UL?t�t|i?| ��|� @?) _i}hii Lu UL44�|4i?|�

�*|�L�}� |�i) _L?<| �ti |��t *@?}�@}ic �| tii4t u@�h |L t@) |�@| 5` @_LT| @ +�U@h_�@?tTiU��U@|�L? Lu TL*�U)� AL tii |��tc ?L|i �ht| |�@| �u �i @hi |L |��?! Lu |�i�h @?@*)t�t @t@TT*)�?} |L @ hi@*�t|�U 4L_ih? iUL?L4)c |�i? �i 4�t| |��?! Lu |�i hi@* }L�ih?4i?| _iM|c Kc�? |�i�h 4L_i* E��i�c K �? E2���� @t �*� � `�|� _�gihi?| �@*�it Lu �c |�i �@*�i Lu K U�@?}itc*i@_�?} |L @_��t|4i?|t �? r6 n rs �?_ih |�i 5` @?@*)t�t� A��t �t ��) �i �?|ihThi| 5` @t@_LT|�?} |�i @tt�4T|�L? |�@| TL*�U) �t +�U@h_�@?�

2�e� Wt |�i 6A�w 5i?t�M*iq �? �?@*L}) �i|�ii? |�i 6A�w @?_ ��UhLtLu|

N?_ih |�i 6A�w |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �t _i|ih4�?i_ M) E2��� Lh E����� � hi@tL?@M*i ^�it|�L? @| |��tTL�?| �tc �_Lit |��t �@�i @?) ti?t�M*i �?|ihThi|@|�L?q< �| �ht| }*@?Uic |��t �@) Lu _i|ih4�?�?}� 4@) tii4 *�!i tL4i tLh| Lu @UUL�?|�?} }�44�U!h) ��|�L�| @?) t�Mt|@?|��i �?|ihit|� ��|c|��t �t ?L| |�i U@ti� �t i4T�@t�3i_ �? �LU�h@?i E2fff�c |�i Th�Ui Lu ��UhLtLu| t�@hit �t_i|ih4�?i_ �? |��t �@) |LL- N?_ih |�i 6A�wc |�i hi*@|�L?t��T Lu |�i }L�ih?4i?| |L �|tML?_ �L*_iht �t tL4i��@| *�!i |�@| Mi|�ii? ��UhLtLu| @?_ �|t i^��|) �L*_iht�

A�i 4@?@}iht Lu ��UhLtLu| @*tL �Lh! |L ti| @t�_i hi@* L�|T�| uLh i^��|) �L*_iht� ���UhLtLu|<t 4L|��it uLh _L�?} |��t @hi _�gihi?| |�@? |�i }L�ih?4i?|<t� ��|c |�@| �t ?L| |�iTL�?|� A�i TL�?| �t |�@| ��UhLtLu| _Lit ?L| U@*�Mh@|i �|t _���_i?_ t|hi@4 |L }�@h@?|ii |�@||�i Thiti?| �@*�i uLh4�*@ uLh �|t t|LU! Th�Ui �L*_tc uLh @** TLtt�M*i �@*�it Lu |�i t|LU! Th�Ui�W?t|i@_c |�i 4iU�@?�t4 LTih@|it �? ThiU�ti*) |�i LTTLt�|i _�hiU|�L?� �@h!i| |h@_iht uLhiU@t|��@| ��UhLtLu| �t }L�?} |L }i?ih@|i uLh |�i4c |�i) |�i? U@*U�*@|i |�i h@|�L Lu |�@| |L |�i?�4Mih Lu t�@hit L�|t|@?_�?}c @?_ |�@|<t |�i t|LU! Th�Ui- �_�LU@|it Lu |�i 6A�w @h}�i|�@| |�i _i|ih4�?@|�L? Lu |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �? @? @U|�@* iUL?L4) �Lh!t �? i @U|*) |�i t@4i�@)� A�i }L�ih?4i?| _Lit ?L| U@*�Mh@|i r |L i?t�hi |�@| �|t Thiti?| �@*�i M�_}i| i^�@|�L?cE2��� �L*_t uLh @** � � W?t|i@_c ML?_ �L*_iht �}�hi L�| �L� 4@?) }LL_tc rc |�i }L�ih?4i?|�t ti||�?} @t�_i uLh |�i4 @?_ U@*U�*@|i |�i Th�Ui *i�i* @t |�i h@|�L Lu � |L r�

57Lq sulydwh frppxqlfdwlrq/ Fkulvwrskhu Vlpv srlqwhg rxw wkdw rxu qrwlrq ri cfrpplwphqw*hqfrpsdvvhv c111wkh frpplwphqw ri wzr shghvwuldqv zkr hqwhu d furvvzdon zkloh hqjdjhg lq d�vw �jkw1 Ihz grxew wkdw wkh| duh qrw zdwfklqj wud�f*1

��

Page 14: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

2�D� Wt |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? �tt�4T|�L? ,4T�h�U@**) �*@�t�M*iq

W? @ttitt�?} |�i 6A�w @t @ TLt�|��i |�iLh) uLh @ T@h|�U�*@h |�4i Tih�L_c @ !i) �tt�i |LUL?uhL?| �t |�i T*@�t�M�*�|) Lu |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L?� � t�4T*i i @4�?@|�L? Lu |�i|�4i tih�it _@|@ �L?<| �i*T� N?_ih ML|� |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @?_ |�i +�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L?tc�i i TiU| |L tii r ' �*�� A�i L?*) _�hiU| �@) |L _�t|�?}��t� Mi|�ii? |�i |�L @tt�4T|�L?t �t|L tii ��@| r *LL!t *�!i ��i? |�i iUL?L4) �t L�| Lu i^��*�Mh��4� �UULh_�?} |L |�i +�U@h_�@?@tt�4T|�L?c r �L�*_ @_��t| ��|� � |L Thitih�i r ' �*�� �UULh_�?} |L |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@?@tt�4T|�L? r �t *�!i @ �|�*�|) u�?U|�L? T@h@4i|ih� W|t �@*�i �L�*_ hi4@�? �?U�@?}i_c tL |�@|r �L�*_ ?L| i^�@* �*� L�| Lu i^��*�Mh��4� A��t 4@) tL�?_ *�!i @? i@t) |��?} |L U�iU!G��t| UL4T@hi r @?_ �*� L�| Lu i^��*�Mh��4� A�i ThLM*i4 �t |�@|c @UULh_�?} |L |�i |�iLh�itUL?t�_ihi_ �ihic L?*) i^��*�Mh��4 �@*�it Lu r @hi hiULh_i_ �? |�i _@|@�2D

i _L?<| |��?! |��t 4i@?t |�ihi �t ?L �@) |L U�LLti Mi|�ii? |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @?_|�i +�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L?t� W? u@U|c �i |��?! |�ihi @hi |�L �@)t |L }L� �?i �t |L |h)|L i |h@TL*@|i ��@| �t hi@tL?@M*i L�| Lu i^��*�Mh��4 Mi�@��Lh M@ti_ L? ��@| �i tii �?i^��*�Mh��4�2S �?L|�ih �@) �t |L ��i� |�i 6A�w @t @ t|@h|�?} TL�?| uLh @ ?@|�h@* ti| Lu@� �*�@h) @tt�4T|�L?t ���U� _L hit|h�U| |�4i tih�it _@|@c @?_ |�i? |it| |�Lti @tt�4T|�L?t�2.

Wu |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L? *i@_t �t |L @ �tiu�* ti| Lu |�iLh�it �? |��t �@)c |��t �L�*_|�T |�i M@*@?Ui �? u@�Lh Lu |�@| @tt�4T|�L?� i ?L� _�tU�tt |�iti |�L @TThL@U�it�

, |h@TL*@|�?} ��| Lu ,^��*�Mh��4 6hL4 ,^��*�Mh��4

�UULh_�?} |L |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L?c |�i }L�ih?4i?|<t TL*�U) �t @ UL44�|4i?||L @ T@h|�U�*@h @U|�L?c r� N?_ih |�i +�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L?c TL*�U) �t @ t|h@|i}) uLh ti||�?} r@t @ u�?U|�L? Lu |�i hi@* _iM|� Wu }L�ih?4i?|t _�hiU|*) hiULh_i_ �? �h�|�?} ��@| |�i�h TL*�U)�tc |��t �L�*_ �i*T �t |L _�tUh�4�?@|i Mi|�ii? |�i |�L @tt�4T|�L?t� A�ihi @hi |�L i @4T*it��ihi |��t tii4t |L �@�i �@TTi?i_c @?_c ��|� L?i �4TLh|@?| U@�i@|c |�i hit�*|t @TTi@h|L u@�Lh |�i +�U@h_�@? L�ih |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L?� A�i �@@t|h�U�| |hi@|) hi^��hit|�i 4i4Miht Lu |�i ,�hLTi@? N?�L? |L �@�i @ TL*�U) Lu @_��t|�?} |�i�h �tU@* �@h�@M*it

58Lw lv shukdsv reylrxv wkdw wklv uhvxow frqwlqxhv wr krog/ hyhq li wkhuh duh pxowlsoh shulrgvdqg wkhuh lv xqfhuwdlqw|1

59Wkhuh duh h{dpsohv ri prghov lq zklfk wkh htxloleulxp wlph vhulhv gdwd frqwdlq lqirupdwlrqderxw zkdw kdsshqv rxw ri htxloleulxp1 Iru h{dpsoh/ lq Juhhq dqg Sruwhu +4<;7, olplwhglqirupdwlrq kdv wkh frqvhtxhqfh wkdw wklqjv kdsshq lq htxloleulxp zklfk duh revhuydwlrqdoo|htxlydohqw wr djhqwv* kdylqj ghyldwhg iurp wkh htxloleulxp1 Hyhq wkrxjk djhqwv grq*w dfwxdoo|ghyldwh lq wkh htxloleulxp/ wkh| pxvw qhyhuwkhohvv eh sxqlvkhg dv wkrxjk wkh| kdg ghyldwhg dvd fuhgleoh vljqdo wr doo ri zkdw zrxog kdsshq li d ghyldwlrq uhdoo| glg rffxu1 Lq wklv vhqvh/ wkhhyhqwv lq htxloleulxp surylgh hylghqfh ri zkdw zrxog kdsshq rxw ri htxloleulxp1

5:Iru d wkrurxjk glvfxvvlrq ri wklv vwudwhj|/ vhh Zrrgirug +4<<;d,1

�e

Page 15: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

�? U@ti |�i�h hi@* _iM| t�L�*_ }i| *@h}i� A�i W�6 �Lh!t �? |�i t@4i �@)c M) Mh�?}�?}Thitt�hi |L Mi@h L? �|t 4i4Miht |L @_��t| �tU@* �@h�@M*it �u |�i�h hi@* _iM| }i|t L�| Lu �@?_�i |��?! �| �t u@�h |L t@) |�@| �u tL4i�L� @ ?L?�i^��*�Mh��4 � �ihi U@**i_ L�|c |�iti |�L

�?t|�|�|�L?@* @hh@?}i4i?|t �L�*_ �Lh! |L }i?ih@|i @? @_��t|4i?| �? r� �@t�@* i @4�?@|�L?Lu |�i E@_4�||i_*)c i^��*�Mh��4-� |�4i tih�it _@|@ t�}}it|t |�i t@4i� W? Th@U|�Uic ��i? |�it�3i Lu |�i _iM| }i|t *@h}ic TL*�|�U@* Thitt�hit |i?_ |L UL4i �?|L T*@) |L @_��t| |�i t�hT*�t |LMh�?} |�i _iM| M@U! �?|L *�?i� A��t �@TTi?i_ �? |�i N5 �? |�i *@|i �bHft @?_ �bbftc ��i?|�i ui_ih@* _iM| Mi}@? |L }hL� t�}?��U@?|*)c ThL_�U�?} TL*�|�U@* t�TTLh| uLh h@�t�?} |@ it@?_%Lh hi_�U�?} tTi?_�?}�

�L�c uLh |�i U@�i@| 4i?|�L?i_ �? |�i Thi��L�t T@h@}h@T�� A�i i @4T*it U�|i_ _L t�}}it||�@| |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L? 4@) Mi �4T*@�t�M*i @t @ U�@h@U|ih�3@|�L? Lu U�hhi?| TL*�U)�? ,�hLTic |�i N5 @?_ tL4i i4ih}�?} 4@h!i| iUL?L4�it� OL�i�ihc @t i4T�@t�3i_ �? |�i�?|hL_�U|�L?c |�i) _L ?L| it|@M*�t� |�@| |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L? �t �4T*@�t�M*i uLh @**

|�4it @?_ T*@Uit�

Wt |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? �tt�4T|�L? @ BLL_ 5|@h|�?} �L�?|q

� _�gihi?| @TThL@U� |L @ttitt�?} |�i i4T�h�U@* �@*�i Lu |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L?@t!t �L� }LL_ @ T*@|uLh4 �| �t uLh _i�i*LT�?} �tiu�* |it|@M*i hit|h�U|�L?t� A�ihi �t ?L tT@Ui|L T�ht�i |��t �ihic Mi)L?_ 4i?|�L?�?} |�@| |�ihi �t �?|ihit|�?} �Lh! �?_ih�@)� W? T@h|�U��*@hc �@?3L?ih�c ��4M) @?_ #�M@ E�bb.�c �LU�h@?i E�bbHc�bbb�c wL)L E�bbb� @?_ LL_uLh_E�bbH@� �@�i T�ht�i_ |�i @tt�4T|�L? Lu t|@|�t|�U@* i L}i?i�|) Lu |�i }L�ih?4i?| t�hT*�t�A��t �t ?L| @? �4T*�U@|�L? Lu |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L? Tih tic M�| |�@| @tt�4T|�L? _Lit?@|�h@**) *i@_ L?i |L �|�

A��t @TThL@U� U@? Tih�@Tt Mit| Mi �?_iht|LL_ �t�?} @? @?@*L}) @||h�M�|i_ M) �LU�h@?iE�bbH� |L �i?�@4�? 6h�i_4@?� �L?t�_ih |�i i^�@|�L? Lu i U�@?}ic

�T ' �tc

��ihi � �t 4L?i)c T �t �i*LU�|)c @?_ t �t L�|T�|� A��t i^�@|�L? @t �| t|@?_t �@t ?L |it|@M*i�4T*�U@|�L?tc t�?Ui ��|�L�| @__�|�L?@* @tt�4T|�L?t �| �t ��t| @ _i�?�|�L? Lu T� 5|�**c �u �?ULh�TLh@|�?} t�4T*ic T*@�t�M*ic @tt�4T|�L?t UL?�ih|t �| �?|L @ |�iLh) |�@| �i*Tt �t �?_iht|@?__@|@ Mi||ihc |�i? �i t@) |�i i^�@|�L? Lu i U�@?}i �t i4T�h�U@**) �tiu�*�2H W? @ t�4�*@h �@)c�| 4@) |�h? L�| |�@| |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L? �t @ }LL_ t|@h|�?} TL�?| uLh �_i?|�u)�?}t�4T*i @� �*�@h) @tt�4T|�L?t |�@| UL?�ih| |�i 6A�w �?|L @ �tiu�*c |it|@M*i |�iLh)� Wu tLc|��t �L�*_ �i*T ��?_�U@|i |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L? @t @ �tiu�* i4T�h�U@* @tt�4T|�L?�

5;Dq h{dpsoh ri vxfk dq dvvxpswlrq lv wkh vshfl�fdwlrq wkdw Y kdv d vlpsoh ixqfwlrqdouhodwlrqvkls wr wkh qrplqdo udwh ri lqwhuhvw1

�D

Page 16: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

�*|�L�}� L�h �?U*�?@|�L? �t |L Mi t!iT|�U@* Lu |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L?c |�i 6A�w�t t|�** �ih) 4�U� �? �|t �?u@?U)� W| hi4@�?t |L Mi tii? ��ihi |�i 6A�w |@!it �t @?_��@| LMtih�@|�L?t �| �i*Tt �t |L i T*@�?� A�i �?�|�@* hit�*|t @hi ThL4�t�?}c |�L�}� ?L|�?UL?|hL�iht�@*� �LU�h@?i E�bbHc�bbb� @?_ LL_uLh_ E�bbH@� @h}�i |�@| |�i �iht�L? Lu |�i6A�w |�@| @tt�4it @ t|@|�t|�U@**) i L}i?L�t t�hT*�t ThLUitt �t �i*Tu�* uLh �?_iht|@?_�?}|�i _)?@4�Ut Lu N5 �?�@|�L? �? |�i �b.ftc @?_ wL)L E�bbb� @h}�it |�@| �| �t �tiu�* uLh�?_iht|@?_�?} |�i ��}� �?�@|�L? i Tih�i?Ui_ M) �h@3�* �? |�i �bHft�

A�ihi �t @?L|�ih *�|ih@|�hic t|@h|i_ M) �@*�L E�b.H�c k)_*@?_ @?_ �hitUL|| E�b..� @?_�@hhL @?_ BLh_L? E�bH��c ���U� TLt�|t |�@| |�i @Mti?Ui Lu UL44�|4i?| �? }L�ih?4i?| TL*�U)U@? @UUL�?| uLh |�i ��}� �?�@|�L? iT�tL_it 4i?|�L?i_ �? |�i Thi��L�t T@h@}h@T�� �?i �@)|L @ttitt |�i 6A�w �t |L UL4T@hi �|t @M�*�|) |L @UUL�?| uLh i Tih�i?Uit *�!i |�iti ��|� |�@|Lu |�i |�4i UL?t�t|i?U) *�|ih@|�hi� W| �t ?L| LM��L�t ��@| |�i L�|UL4i Lu |��t UL4T@h�tL?�L�*_ Mi� �U�@**�4 E�bb.�c @4L?} L|�ihtc �@t @h}�i_ |�@| |�4i �?UL?t�t|i?U) �t ?L| @�tiu�* i T*@?@|�L? Lu iT�tL_it Lu ��}� �?�@|�L?� Whi*@?_ E�bbH� �@t @h}�i_ |�i L|�ih �@)c|�@| @Mti?Ui Lu UL44�|4i?| �t �tiu�*�2b

2�S� A�i �h�Ui wi�i* �? @ Lh*_ ��|� �L BL�ih?4i?|��hL��_i_ �L?i)

�? �4TLh|@?| ��h|�i |�@| tL4i @_�LU@|it Lu |�i 6A�w U*@�4 uLh |�i�h |�iLh) �t |�@| �|ThL��_it @ �@) Lu |��?!�?} @ML�| |�i Th�Ui *i�i* |�@| �Lh!t i�i? �? @ �Lh*_ ��ihi |�i_i4@?_ @?_ t�TT*) uLh }L�ih?4i?| �@| 4L?i) �t ?L?i �t|i?|� �LU�h@?i E�bbHc 2fff� @h}�it|�@| |��t �t Lu �?|ihit| MiU@�tic |L @ �ht| @TThL �4@|�L?c �i �@�i @*hi@_) hi@U�i_ |�@| TL�?|��f

A�i M@t�U T�iUit Lu |�i @h}�4i?| @hi @*hi@_) �? T*@Ui� N?_ih |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T�|�L? |�@| rs n r6 �t i L}i?L�tc E2��� _i|ih4�?it |�i Th�Ui *i�i*� �L|i |�@| |��t UL?U*�t�L?�@t hi@U�i_ ��|�L�| hiuihi?Ui |L 4L?i) Lh ��i|�ih �| �t i�i? Thiti?| �? |�i iUL?L4)� A�@|<t|�i |�T Lg uLh |�i hit�*| |L UL4iG |�i Th�Ui *i�i* U@? Mi T�??i_ _L�?c i�i? �u |�ihi �t ?L

}L�ih?4i?| ThL��_i_ 4L?i) �? |�i iUL?L4)�AL tii |��tc �4@}�?i |�@| |h@_i �? |�i iUL?L4) �t U@hh�i_ L�| M) M@h|ih� ,^���@*i?|*)c L?i

UL�*_ |��?! Lu @ tUi?@h�L �? ���U� |h@_it @hi �?@?Ui_ ��|� |�i i U�@?}i Lu �?@?U�@* U*@�4tL? Th��@|i*) �i*_ @tti|t� A�iti |h@_it UL�*_ i�i? Mi _i?L4�?@|i_ �? �_L**@ht<� A�i !i) |��?}

5<Iru ixuwkhu glvfxvvlrq/ vhh Doedqhvl/ Fkdul dqg Fkulvwldqr +4<<<, dqg Fkulvwldqr dqg Jxvw+5333d/e,1

63Dffruglqj wr Zrrgirug +4<<;/ 4<<;d/ 4<<;e,/ wkh dvvxpswlrq wkdw prqh| ghpdqg dqgvxsso| duh olwhudoo| qrqh{lvwhqw lv wrr h{wuhph1 Kh suhihuv wr dqdo|}h zkdw kh fdoov d cfdvkohvvolplw*1 Wklv lv dq hfrqrp| lq zklfk wkh ghpdqg iru prqh| lv vr vpdoo wkdw vhljqrudjh lv qhjoljleohdqg fdq/ wr d �uvw dssur{lpdwlrq/ eh vdiho| ljqruhg lq wkh jryhuqphqw*v exgjhw frqvwudlqw +erwkwkh �rz exgjhw frqvwudlqw dqg wkh lqwhuwhpsrudo exgjhw htxdwlrq,1 Krzhyhu/ wkh ghpdqg iruprqh| lv vx�flhqwo| odujh wkdw wkh fhqwudo edqn fdq vwloo frqwuro wkh udwh ri lqwhuhvw1

�S

Page 17: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

�ihi �t |�@| }L�ih?4i?|�ThL��_i_ 4L?i) E�_L**@ht<� t�4T*) _Lit ?L| i �t|�`�@| �t ?L4�?@*c _L**@h _i?L4�?@|i_ }L�ih?4i?| _iM| �? |��t �Lh*_ ��|� ?L _L**@htq

W| LM��L�t*) �t ?L| @ T*i_}i |L _i*��ih }L�ih?4i?|�ThL��_i_ 4L?i)c MiU@�ti |�ihi �t ?L?i-W?t|i@_c �| �t @ T*i_}i |L _i*��ih � _L**@ht �Lh|� Lu }LL_t |L |�i Mi@hih Lu �� A�i uLh4@*LM*�}@|�L? *i@�it LTi? i @U|*) �L� 4@?) }LL_t � _L**@ht ULhhitTL?_t |Lc MiU@�ti |�i Th�Ui*i�i* �t *iu| �?tTiU��i_� W? |��t ti?tic �| �t *�!i hi@*��Lh*_ N5 }L�ih?4i?| _iM|��� A�i Th�Ui*i�i* |�@| �t hi@*�3i_ �t _i|ih4�?i_ M) |�i }L�ih?4i?|<t �tU@* _iU�t�L?t� A�i �tU@* _iU�t�L?thit�*| �? |�i hi@* t�hT*�tc rc ���U� �t ��@| |�i }L�ih?4i?| @U|�@**) �@t @�@�*@M*i uLh T@)�?}Lg |�i ML?_ �L*_iht� `�|� |�i @4L�?| Lu }LL_t @�@�*@M*i |L T@) |�i ML?_ �L*_iht i^�@*|L rc @?_ |�i ?L4�?@* �@*�i Lu _iM| i^�@* |L �c |�i ?@|�h@* _i�?�|�L? Lu |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �t� ' �*r�

�| |��t TL�?|c �| 4@) tii4 *�!i |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �? @ �Lh*_ ��|� ?L }L�ih?4i?|�ThL��_i_4L?i) �t @ �ti*itt @TTi?_@}ic ��|� ?L 4i@?�?}u�* u�?U|�L?� W? tiU|�L? e Mi*L� �i t�@**tii |�@| |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �? t�U� @? iUL?L4) _Lit �@�i @ TL|i?|�@**) �4TLh|@?| hL*i |L T*@)c�i*T�?} |L �4T*i4i?| @? i�U�i?| �tU@* TL*�U)�

�� A�i 6�tU@* A�iLh) W? Bi?ih@* ,^��*�Mh��4

A��t tiU|�L? @__hittit �@h�L�t �tt�it ���U� �i U@??L| @__hitt �? |�i L?i Tih�L_ i @4T*i�A�i �ht| �tt�i �i UL?uhL?| �t L?i |�@| �i i TiU| @?) hi@_ih ��L 4@!it �| |�hL�}� |�iThi��L�t tiU|�L? |L Mi UL?Uih?i_ @ML�|� A�@| tiU|�L? t�L�t �L� @? i^�@|�L? ?L| �t�@**)�ti_ �? |�i UL?|i | Lu Th�Ui _i|ih4�?@|�L?c |�i }L�ih?4i?|<t �?|ih|i4TLh@* M�_}i| i^�@|�L?cU@? T�? _L�? |�i Th�Ui *i�i*� A��t ?@|�h@**) *i@_t |L |�i ^�it|�L?G ���|c �i @*hi@_) �@�i

@ |�iLh) Lu |�i Th�Ui *i�i*� Wu �i @_LT| |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L? L? TL*�U) �L?<| |�iTh�Ui *i�i* Mi L�ih_i|ih4�?i_q< i**c �| 4�}�| Mi� A�@| _iTi?_t L? �L� �i �it� L�| |�ihit| Lu |�i iUL?L4)� Wu |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �ihi L�ih_i|ih4�?i_c |��t �L�*_ �4T*) |�@| |�ihi �t?L i^��*�Mh��4 i UiT| �? |�i uLh|��|L�t U@ti ��ihi |�i }L�ih?4i?| �@TTi?i_ |L T�U! ��t||�i h�}�| �@*�i uLh r� W| �t u@�h |L t@) |�@| �u |��t �ihi |�i t�|�@|�L? uLh @** hi@tL?@M*i �@)tLu 4L_i*�?} |�i hit| Lu |�i iUL?L4)c |�i? |�i 6A�w �L�*_ Mi �? |hL�M*i� W? |��t U@tic �|�L�*_ ?L| Mi @ *L}�U@**) UL�ihi?| 4@UhLiUL?L4�U 4L_i*� ��|c |��t |�h?t L�| ?L| |L Mi |�iU@ti� �i*L�c �i ��** �it� L�| |�i hit| Lu |�i iUL?L4) �? ��@| @TTi@ht |L Mi @ hi@tL?@M*i�@)c @?_ �i ��** tii |�@| |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �t �?�^�i*) _i|ih4�?i_� i _L |��t �? |�i UL?|i |Lu @ �ih) t�4T*i i @4T*i� A�i �tt�i �t @__hitti_ 4Lhi h�}LhL�t*) �? |�i @TTi?_� �

64Wkh XV jryhuqphqw dovr r�huv lqgh{hg ghew/ zklfk grhv fruuhvsrqg wr d frpplwphqw wrgholyhu d vshfl�f dprxqw ri d edvnhw ri jrrgv1 Lqgh{hg ghew lv vpdoo lq wkh jryhuqphqw*v sruwirolrri oldelolwlhv1

�.

Page 18: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

i |�i? |�h? |L @? �tt�i ���U� �i |��?! �t Lu }hi@|ih UL?Uih?� i _�tT*@) i��_i?Ui���U� t�}}it|t |�@| |L �ti |�i 6A�w L?i �@t |L |@!i |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L? �ih)

tih�L�t*)� 5ii4�?}*) |�?) _iT@h|�hit uhL4 |�@| @tt�4T|�L? �? |�i _�hiU|�L? Lu @**L��?} uLhtL4i ti?t�|���|) �? |�i t�hT*�t |L |�i hi@* _iM| U@�tit |�i 6A�w<t @M�*�|) |L T�? _L�? |�iTh�Ui *i�i* |L UL**@Tti�

A�i |��h_ t�MtiU|�L? t�L�t �L� t�LU!t |L �tU@* TL*�U) �4T@U| L? |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �? |�i6A�w� i t�L� |�@| �| �t TLtt�M*i uLh |�i 4L?i|@h) @�|�Lh�|) |L UL?|hL* |�i @�ih@}i �?�@|�L?h@|i �? |��t U@ti� OL�i�ihc @UULh_�?} |L @? �4TLh|@?| hit�*| _�i |L LL_uLh_c �| �t �4TLtt�M*iuLh |�i Ui?|h@* M@?! |L ti| |�i �@h�@?Ui Lu �?�@|�L? |L 3ihL ��i? |�ihi �t �?t|@M�*�|) �? �tU@*TL*�U)�

A�i �?@* t�MtiU|�L? hi��t�|t |�i @M�*�|) Lu |�i Ui?|h@* M@?! |L UL?|hL* @�ih@}i �?�@|�L?�?_ih |�i 6A�w� W| t�L�t |�@| UL?�i?|�L?@* ��i�t @ML�| �L� |L UL?|hL* @�ih@}i �?�@|�L?UL�*_ @U|�@**) tT@h! @? i T*Lt��i �)Tih�?�@|�L?� 5Lc ���*i �| �t ui@t�M*i uLh |�i Ui?|h@* M@?!|L UL?|hL* @�ih@}i �?�@|�L? �?_ih |�i 6A�wc |�i 4i|�L_ uLh _L�?} tL 4�t| Mi _it�}?i_ ��|�U@hi�

���� Wt |�i �h�Ui wi�i* ��ih_i|ih4�?i_ �? |�i 6A�wq

i Mi}�? |��t t�MtiU|�L? M) ThL��_�?} @ }i?ih@* _�tU�tt�L? Lu |�i �tt�it �?�L*�i_ �? _i|ih�4�?�?} |�i Th�Ui *i�i*� i |�i? |�h? |L @ tTiU��U i @4T*i �? ���U� |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �t �?�^�i*)_i|ih4�?i_ M) |�i 6A�w�

Bi?ih@* #�tU�tt�L?

W| �t i@t) |L �?_ i @4T*it Lu |�i 6A�w ��ihi |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �t L�ih_i|ih4�?i_� +iU@**|�i i^�@|�L? Lu i U�@?}ic ���U� �@t _�tU�tti_ @ML�i� i hiThL_�Ui �| �ihic uLh UL?�i?�i?UiG

�T ' �t�

W? |h@_�|�L?@*c L*_�u@t��L?i_ 4L?i|@h�t4c T �t @tt�4i_ |L Mi @ ?�4Mih � i_ M) |iU�?L*L})ct �t _i|ih4�?i_ i L}i?L�t*)c @?_ 4L?i|@h) TL*�U) |@!it |�i uLh4 Lu @ U�L�Ui Lu � � W? |��t4L_i*c � �t LM��L�t*) _i|ih4�?i_ M) |�i i^�@|�L? Lu i U�@?}i� Wu |�i hit| Lu |�i iUL?L4) �ihiU�@h@U|ih�3i_ M) |�iti @tt�4T|�L?tc |�i? @ *L}�U@**) UL�ihi?| 6A�w �L�*_ Mi �4TLtt�M*i��2

65Ilqlwh krul}rq prghov lq zklfk wkh vlpsoh txdqwlw| htxdwlrq krogv lq wkh odvw shulrg/ exwyhorflw| lv dq lqfuhdvlqj ixqfwlrq ri wkh qrplqdo lqwhuhvw udwh lq wkh suhylrxv shulrgv/ dovr kdyhwkh surshuw| wkdw wkh sulfh ohyho lv ryhughwhuplqhg +vhh Exlwhu +4<<<,1, Wkh uhdvrqlqj lv vlploduwr zkdw zh kdyh lq wkh wh{w1 Lq wkrvh prghov/ wkh htxloleulxp sulfh ohyho pxvw vdwlvi| d �uvwrughu gl�huhqfh htxdwlrq1 Doo wkh htxloleulxp sulfhv duh wkhq slqqhg grzq e| wkh idfw wkdw wkhsulfh ohyho lv slqqhg grzq lq wkh odvw shulrg1 Wkh olnholkrrg wkdw wklv sulfh ohyho frlqflghv zlwkwkh rqh surgxfhg e| wkh lqwhuwhpsrudo exgjhw htxdwlrq ri wkh jryhuqphqw vhhpv vpdoo1 Wkhprvw olnho| rxwfrph lv wkdw wkh sulfh ohyho lv ryhughwhuplqhg lq wklv prgho1

�H

Page 19: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

��|c i@U� Lu |�i @tt�4T|�L?t Lu |h@_�|�L?@*c L*_�u@t��L?i_ 4L?i|@h�t4 �@�i Mii? hi�iU|i_L? i4T�h�U@* }hL�?_t� 6�ht|c T i ��M�|t �ih) t�Mt|@?|�@* ��U|�@|�L?t �? |�i _@|@� A�i@tt�4T|�L? |�@| T �t � i_ �@t Mii? hiT*@Ui_ �? 4L_ih? 4L_i*t M) @? �?Uhi@t�?} u�?U|�L? Lu|�i ?L4�?@* h@|i Lu �?|ihit|� �?L|�ih ThLTih|) Lu |�i 4L_ih? |�iLh) �t |�@| i TiU|i_ �?�@|�L?T*@)t @? �4TLh|@?| hL*i �? _i|ih4�?�?} -� `�|� |�iti |�L ui@|�hitc �| U@? Mi t�L�? |�@|@ *L}�U@**) UL�ihi?| 6A�w �t TLtt�M*i� AL tii |��tc ?L|i |�@| |�iti U�@?}it U@�ti i TiU|i_u�|�hi � <t |L i?|ih |�i i^�@|�L? Lu i U�@?}i ��@ T� A��t Uhi@|it |�i TLtt�M�*�|) |�@| |�ihi@hi 4@?) � ThLUittit |�@| U@? t@|�tu) |��t i^�@|�L?c *i@��?} hLL4 uLh |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@?@tt�4T|�L? |L T�? _L�? L?i Lu |�i4� A��t TLtt�M�*�|) �t �**�t|h@|i_ �? @ UL4T*i|i*) �Lh!i_i @4T*i �? |�i @TTi?_� ���

5iUL?_c |�i @tt�4T|�L? |�@| t �t i L}i?L�t �@t Mii? ^�it|�L?i_� A�ihi �t }i?ih@*@}hii4i?| |�@|c @| *i@t| |�i t�Lh| h�? 4L�i4i?|t �? t @hi �?��i?Ui_ M) 4L�i4i?|t �? T c �@?_ �� `�i? 4L_i*t @hi UL?t|h�U|i_ |�@| U@T|�hi |��tc L?i �?_t |�@| i TiU|i_ u�|�hi � <ti?|ih �?|L |�i _i|ih4�?@|�L? Lu t� �t �? |�i i @4T*i Lu |�i Thi��L�t T@h@}h@T�c |�i hit�*|U@? Mi |�@| |�ihi @hi 4�*|�T*i � ThLUittit |�@| U@? t@|�tu) |�i i^�@|�L? Lu i U�@?}i� �}@�?c|��t *i@�it hLL4 uLh |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L? |L T�? _L�? L?i Lu |�i4��e

A��h_c |�ihi �t @ ?i@h*) �?��iht@* UL?ti?t�t |�@| i L}i?L�t � hiThiti?|t @ TLLh U�@h�@U|ih�3@|�L? Lu 4L?i|@h) TL*�U)� 6Lh i @4T*ic A@)*Lh E�bb�� �@t @h}�i_ |�@|c �? Th@U|�Uic4L?i|@h) TL*�U) �t Mit| |�L�}�| Lu @t @ h�*i uLh ti||�?} |�i h@|i Lu �?|ihit|� W? |��t U@tic �MiUL4it @? i?_L}i?L�t �@h�@M*i� i U@? tii �? |�i i^�@|�L? Lu i U�@?}i |�@| �u - �t |�ii L}i?L�t TL*�U) �@h�@M*ic @t LTTLti_ |L �c |�i? T �t T�??i_ _L�?� ��|c |�ihi @hi ?L� |�L

i?_L}i?L�t �@h�@M*itc � @?_ �c �? |��t i^�@|�L?� Bi?ih@**)c �?_ih |�iti U�hU�4t|@?Uitc �@?_ � @hi ?L| T�??i_ _L�?� A�ihi �tc �? @ ti?tic @ 4�tt�?} i^�@|�L?� �}@�?c |�ihi �t hLL4uLh |�i 6A�w |L �| �?�

�? , @4T*i

�i |c �i Thiti?| @ t�4T*ic 4�*|�Tih�L_ 4L_i* iUL?L4) �? ���U� |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �t �?�^�i*)_i|ih4�?i_ �? |�i 6A�w� A�ihi �t ?L *@t| Tih�L_c @?_ |�4i �t �?_i i_ M) | ' fc �c 2c ��� �

66H{dpsohv olnh wklv duh dovr suhvhqwhg lq Eurfn +4<:8,/ Revwihog dqg Urjr� +4<;6, dqgPdwvx|dpd +4<<4,1 Dq h{dpsoh wdnhq iurp Zrrgirug +4<<7, dsshduv lq wkh dsshqgl{ wr wklvsdshu1

67Wkh fdvk lq dgydqfh prgho glvsod|hg lq Fkulvwldqr/ Hlfkhqedxp dqg Hydqv +4<<;, lv dqh{dpsoh ri wklv1 Ehfdxvh wklv lv d fdvk lq dgydqfh prgho/ yhorflw| lv �{hg dqg idfwruv glvfxvvhg lqwkh suhylrxv sdudjudsk duh uxohg rxw1 Wkdw sdshu vkrzv wkdw iru ydulrxv gl�huhqw vshfl�fdwlrqvri wkh prqhwdu| srolf| uxoh iru vhohfwlqj Pw> wkh prgho kdv d frqwlqxxp ri htxloleuld1 Li wkhqrq0Ulfdugldq dvvxpswlrq zhuh dgrswhg lq wklv prgho/ wkh htxloloeulxp zrxog eh slqqhg grzq1Iru rwkhu h{dpsohv olnh wklv/ vhh Fduovwurp dqg Ixhuvw +4<<;,1

�b

Page 20: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

5�TTLti |�@| L�|T�|c tc �t |�i t@4i uLh i@U� _@|ic |� �L?i) _i4@?_ _iTi?_t L? |�i h@|i Lu�?|ihit|G

�|

�|

' �-3k| c k : f� E����

A�i T@h@4i|ihc �c U@T|�hit L|�ih |��?}t E*�!i �?UL4i� ���U� @*tL �4T@U| L? 4L?i) _i4@?_cM�| ���U� @hi �ihi @tt�4i_ |L Mi UL?t|@?|� �*tLc �| �t |�i t|LU! Lu 4L?i) @| |�i Mi}�??�?}Lu Tih�L_ |c �| �t |�i Th�Ui *i�i* _�h�?} Tih�L_ | @?_ -| �t |�i ?L4�?@* h@|i Lu �?|ihit| L?}L�ih?4i?| ML?_t �i*_ uhL4 |�i Mi}�??�?} Lu Tih�L_ | |L |�i Mi}�??�?} Lu Tih�L_ |n�� A�i6�t�ih i^�@|�L? �L*_tG

� n o ' E� n-|��|

�|n�

� E��2�

A�i i Thitt�L? L? |�i h�}�| �t |�i hi@* h@|i Lu �?|ihit| L? ML?_t T@)�?} ?L4�?@* h@|i Luhi|�h?c -|� A�i |ih4c o : fc �t |�i h@|i @| ���U� �L�ti�L*_t _�tUL�?| u�|�hi �|�*�|)� A��tT�?t _L�? |�i hi@* h@|i Lu �?|ihit|�

� hi@tL?@M*i tTiU��U@|�L? Lu 4L?i|@h) TL*�U) �t |�@| |�i Ui?|h@* M@?! |@h}i|t |�i ?L4�?@*h@|i Lu �?|ihit|� 6Lh T�hTLtit Lu |�i i TLt�|�L?c �i @_LT| @? i |hi4i �iht�L? Lu |��tc �? ���U��| Ti}t |�i h@|i Lu �?|ihit| |L @ UL?t|@?|c - : f� �t �i ��** tii Mi*L�c �| @UUL4T*�t� |��tM) t�TT*)�?} ��@|i�ih 4L?i) |�i Th��@|i iUL?L4) _i4@?_t @| |��t h@|i Lu �?|ihit|� A�i�?|ihit| h@|i Ti} T�?t _L�? ti�}?Lh@}iG

r6| ��| ��|3�

�|

'�|

�|

��|3�

�|

�|3�

�|3�

W4TLt�?} |�i 4L?i) _i4@?_ @?_ 6�t�ih i^�@|�L?tc E���� � E��2�c @?_ |�i TL*�U) h�*ic -| ' -c�i �?_�D

r6 ' �-3k-� o

� n-c | ' fc �c 2c ��� � E����

�L?t�t|i?| ��|� |�i 6A�wc �i @tt�4i |�@| |�i Th�4@h) M�_}i| t�hT*�tc rs| c �t ?L?�+�U@h_�@?�i @_LT| |�i t�4T*it| t�U� TL*�U)c L?i �? ���U� rs| �t t�4T*) @ UL?t|@?|c rs � 5Lc ?i| }L�ih?�

4i?| hi�i?�it uhL4 @** tL�hUitc i U*�_�?} �?|ihit| T@)4i?|tc �t

r| ' r ' rs n r6 : f� E��e�

AL UL4T*i|i |�i _itUh�T|�L? Lu |�i }L�ih?4i?|c �i Thiti?| |�i Tih�L_ | M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?|�i @tt�4i |�@| |�i }L�ih?4i?| _iM| �t UL4TLti_ Lu L?i�Tih�L_ _�tUL�?| ML?_t� A�@| �tc

68Lpsolflwo|/ zh kdyh dvvxphg wkdw wkh lqwhuhvw udwh shj zdv lq sodfh lq shulrg �4 wrr1 Wklv lvgrqh iru vlpsolflw|1 D pruh uljrurxv wuhdwphqw/ zklfk grhv qrw pdnh wklv dvvxpswlrq/ dsshduvlq wkh dsshqgl{1

2f

Page 21: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

|�i @4L�?| Lu MLhhL��?} �? Tih�L_ | �t �|n�*E� n-� @?_ |�i @4L�?| T@�_ �? Tih�L_ |n � �t�|n�� A�i Tih�L_ | }L�ih?4i?| M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?| �tG

�|n�

� n-n �|r ' �|c | ' fc �c 2c ��� E��D�

A�i |ih4t L? |�i *iu| Lu |�i i^�@*�|) @hi |�i }L�ih?4i?|<t tL�hUit Lu u�?_t @?_ |�i |ih4t L?|�i h�}�| @hi |�i �tit Lu u�?_t |L T@) Lg |�i _iM|��S W| �t UL?�i?�i?| |L hi�h�|i |��t i Thitt�L?�? hi@* |ih4tc ��i�c �? |ih4t Lu K| � �|*�|� #���_�?} E��D� M) �|c |@!�?} �?|L @UUL�?| |�i 6�t�ihi^�@|�L?c E��2�c @?_ hi@hh@?}�?}c �i LM|@�?G

K|n� ' E� n o�EK| � r�� E��S�

6�?@**)c �i _i�i*LT |�i 4�*|�Tih�L_ @?@*L} Lu �� ' f �? |�i Thi��L�t tiU|�L?� +iU@** |�i*L}�U |�@| �i �ti_ |�ihi� 6�ht|c �� : f �t ?L| LT|�4@* t�?Ui �L�ti�L*_t UL�*_ �?Uhi@ti �|�*�|)M) h@�t�?} UL?t�4T|�L? @?_ �?@?U�?} �| ��|� @ hi_�U|�L? Lu ��� 5iUL?_c @ ?i}@|��i �@*�i Lu�� �t @*tL ?L| LT|�4@*c t�?Ui �i hi4L�i_ �| uhL4 |�i ui@t�M*i ti| M) @tt�4T|�L?� i UL?|�?�i|L @tt�4i |�@| �L*_�?}t Lu }L�ih?4i?| ML?_t 4�t| Mi ?L?�?i}@|��i� A�@| �tc �L�ti�L*_tL?*) *i?_ |L |�i }L�ih?4i?|� A�i) _L ?L| MLhhL� uhL4 �|�

A�i @?@*L} Lu �� ' f �? |��t ti||�?} �t

*�4A<"

�A

E� n-�A' f� E��.�

A�@| �L�ti�L*_ LT|�4�3@|�L? �4T*�it |��t UL?_�|�L? �t it|@M*�t�i_ �t�?} |�i t@4i |)Ti Luhi@tL?�?} �ti_ |L it|@M*�t� �� ' f� A�i *�4�| U@??L| Mi TLt�|��ic uLh L|�ih��ti �L�ti�L*_tUL�*_ �?Uhi@ti �|�*�|) M) hi_�U�?} |�i�h �L*_�?}t Lu }L�ih?4i?| _iM|� AL tii |��tc t�TTLti|�@| |�i *�4�| �t TLt�|��i� A��t �4T*�it |�@|c i�i?|�@**) @| *i@t|c |�i }L�ih?4i?| _iM| }hL�t@| |�i h@|i Lu �?|ihit|� A�@| �tc �| ' �|WE� n -�|3|

W

c | � |W uLh tL4i |W� ��|c @| |��tTL�?|c |�i }L�ih?4i?| �t i?}@}i_ �? @ �L?3� tU�i4i ��|� �L�ti�L*_t� A�i Th�?U�T*i @?_�?|ihit| L? _iM| UL4�?} _�i �t �?@?Ui_ i?|�hi*) L�| Lu ?i�*) �tt�i_ _iM|c uLhi�ih� N?_ih|�iti U�hU�4t|@?Uitc |�i �L�ti�L*_ U@? _L Mi||ih M) t�4T*) t@)�?} �?L< |L |�i �L?3� }@4i�W| U@? _L tL M) UL?t�4�?} |�i Th�?U�T*i @?_ �?|ihit| L? _iM| UL4�?} _�i �? L?i Tih�L_@?_ |�i? ?i�ih @}@�? �L*_�?} @?) 4Lhi }L�ih?4i?| _iM|� A�i �L�ti�L*_ �t Mi||ih Lg _L�?}|��t MiU@�ti |�i @U|�L? @**L�t �| @ L?i�|�4i �?Uhi@ti �? UL?t�4T|�L? ��|�L�| }i?ih@|�?} @?ii_ |L hi_�Ui UL?t�4T|�L? @| @?) L|�ih _@|i� �? LT|�4�3�?} �L�ti�L*_ �L�*_ ?L| T@tt �T

69Dq dowhuqdwlyh uhsuhvhqwdwlrq/ zklfk kdv vrph wkhruhwlfdo dgydqwdjhv/ h{suhvvhv wkh jryhuq0phqw*v exgjhw htxdwlrq lq whupv ri lwv wrwdo qrplqdo oldelolwlhv/ Ew .Pw�4= Zh zrun zlwk wklvdowhuqdwlyh uhsuhvhqwdwlrq lq wkh dsshqgl{1

2�

Page 22: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

@? LTTLh|�?�|) *�!i |��t� A��t �t ��) �L�ti�L*_ LT|�4�3@|�L? �4T*�it |�@| |�i @ML�i *�4�|U@??L| Mi TLt�|��i� A�i *�4�| U@??L| Mi ?i}@|��i i�|�ihc MiU@�ti �i _L?<| @**L� �| f��L?_�|�L? E��.� �t U@**i_ |�i |h@?t�iht@*�|) UL?_�|�L?�

W| �t UL?�i?�i?| uLh �t |L i Thitt |�i |h@?t�iht@*�|) UL?_�|�L? �? hi@* |ih4tc @u|ih t�M�t|�|�|�?} L�| uLh |�i ?L4�?@* h@|i Lu �?|ihit| uhL4 |�i 6�t�ih i^�@|�L?c E��2�� Nt�?} |�@|i^�@|�L?c �i �?_�.

E� n-�| ' E� n o�|�|

�f

c | ' �c 2c ��� c

tL |�@| �A*E� n-�A ' �fKA*E� n o�A � A�i?c |�i |h@?t�iht@*�|) UL?_�|�L? U@? Mi �h�||i?

*�4A<"

KA

E� n o�A' fc KA '

�A

�A

� E��H�

i �@�i ?L� t|@|i_ |�i i?|�hi 4L_i*� A�i T@h| UL4�?} uhL4 |�i �L�ti�L*_ �t }��i?M) E����c E��2�c E��H� @?_ |�i UL?_�|�L?c �| � f� A�i }L�ih?4i?| �t t�44@h�3i_ M) �|tTL*�U)c E��e�c @?_ �|t �L� M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?|c E��S�� i @t!c _Lit |��t iUL?L4) �?�^�i*)_i|ih4�?i |�i Th�Ui *i�i*q AL tii |�@| �| _Litc ?L|i �ht| |�@| |�i 4L?i) _i4@?_ i^�@|�L?@?_ |�i }L�ih?4i?| TL*�U) Lu Ti}}�?} |�i h@|i Lu �?|ihit| �@�i |�i igiU| Lu T�??�?} _L�?hi@* M@*@?Uitc M�| ?L| � Lh � tiT@h@|i*)� #L�M*i � @?_ �c @?_ |�Lti i^�@|�L?t hi4@�?i_t@|�t�i_� A�i t@4i �t |h�i Lu |�i 6�t�ih i^�@|�L?� #L�M*i � @| @** _@|itc @?_ |�@| UL?|�?�it|L �L*_ |LL� 5Lc |�i *i�i* Lu |�i 4L?i) t|LU! @?_ |�i Th�Ui *i�i* @hi ?L| T�??i_ _L�?� W| |�h?tL�| |�@| |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? tTiU��U@|�L? Lu }L�ih?4i?| TL*�U)c |L}i|�ih ��|� |�i �L�ti�L*_<t|h@?t�iht@*�|) UL?_�|�L? @hi i?L�}� |L T�? _L�? |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �?�^�i*)�

AL tii |�@| |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �t �?�^�i*) _i|ih4�?i_c UL?t�_ih 6�}�hi �c ���U� }h@T�t |�i}L�ih?4i?| M�_}i| i^�@|�L?c K� ' E� n o�EK � r�� A�i �ih|�U@* @ �t 4i@t�hit K� @?_ |�i�Lh�3L?|@* @ �t 4i@t�hit K� A�i eD _i}hii *�?i �t @*tL �?U*�_i_ �? |�i �}�hi uLh UL?�i?�i?Ui��L|i �L� |�i �?|ihUiT| uLh |�i M�_}i| i^�@|�L? �t ?i}@|��ic @?_ �L� �| U�|t |�i eD _i}hii *�?iuhL4 Mi*L�� W|t t*LTi �t t|iiTih |�@? |�@| Lu |�i eD _i}hii *�?i MiU@�ti Lu L�h @tt�4T|�L?co : f� A�i _�@}h@4 U@? Mi �ti_ |L tii ��@| �@TTi?t |L K L�ih |�4i uLh @?) �?�|�@* �@*�i Lu

6:Iru h{dpsoh/ iru w @ 5

+4 .U,5@

�+4 .U,

S4S5

� �+4 .U,

S3S4

�S5S3

@ +4 . u,5S5S3

=

22

Page 23: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

K��H #i?L|i |�i �@*�i Lu K ��ihi |�i M�_}i| i^�@|�L? �?|ihtiU|t |�i eD _i}hii *�?i M) KW G

KW '� n o

or '

"[|'f

r

E� n o�|� E��b�

�t |�i *@t| i^�@*�|) �?_�U@|itc KW �t |�i Thiti?| �@*�i Lu |�i u�|�hi t�hT*�tit��L�c |�i �@*�i Lu K �? Tih�L_ fc Kfc �t @? i?_L}i?L�t �@h�@M*i� �*|�L�}� |�i ?L4�?@* _iM|c

�fc �t Thi_i|ih4�?i_ @| _@|i fc |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �t ?L|� �L?t�_ih |�hii TLtt�M�*�|�it� 5�TTLtif � Kf KW� A�i �}�hi �?_�U@|it |�@| K ^��U!*) tT�h@*t �?|L |�i ?i}@|��i 3L?ic ��L*@|�?}?L?�?i}@|���|) UL?t|h@�?| L? |�i �L�ti�L*_<t �L*_�?}t Lu _iM|��b �L� UL?t�_ih Kf : KW� W?|��t U@tic |�i _�@}h@4 �?_�U@|it |�@| |�i _iM| _��ih}it |L T*�t �?�?�|)� AL tii ��@| |�i}hL�|� h@|i Lu |�i _iM| UL?�ih}it |Lc _���_i E��S� M) K| G

K|n�K|

' E� n o�E��r

K|��

5�?Uic @t K| }hL�tc r MiUL4it hi*@|��i*) t4@**c |�i }hL�|� h@|i Lu K| i�i?|�@**) UL?�ih}it |L� n o� �| |��t TL�?|c |�i _iM| �@t MiUL4i tL *@h}i |�@| r �tc M) UL4T@h�tL?c �?t�}?��U@?|*)t4@**� ,tti?|�@**)c |�i }L�ih?4i?| �t ?L� h�??�?} @ �L?3� tU�i4i� 6Lh |�i hi@tL?t }��i?@ML�ic �| �t ?L| �? |�i �L�ti�L*_<t �?|ihit| |L T@h|�U�T@|i �? |��t tU�i4i E|iU�?�U@**)c |�i�L�ti�L*_<t |h@?t�iht@*�|) UL?_�|�L?c E��H�c �t ��L*@|i_�� 5�?Ui |�i �L�ti�L*_t ��** ?L| �L*_|��t _iM|c �i UL?U*�_i |�@| Kf : KW _L ?L| ULhhitTL?_ |L i^��*�Mh�@�

A��t *i@�it L?*) Kf ' KW |L UL?t�_ih� 5�?Ui |�i *i�i* Lu hi@* _iM| �t � i_ �? |��t U@tic|�i |h@?t�iht@*�|) UL?_�|�L? �t ?L� |h���@**) t@|�t�i_� 5Lc L?*) �f ' �f*K

W �t UL?t�t|i?| ��|�i^��*�Mh��4� i UL?U*�_i |�@| |��t �iht�L? Lu |�i 6A�w �t @? �?|ih?@**) UL?t�t|i?| |�iLh) Lu|�i Th�Ui *i�i*�

��2� Wt |�i 6A�w 6h@}�*iq

A�i @tt�4T|�L?t �?_ih*)�?} iUL?L4�t|t< |�iLh�it @hic @| Mit|c L?*) @TThL �4@|�L?t� i_L?<| |��?! Lu |�i4 @t Mi�?} i @U|*) |h�i� A��t �t ��) �i |h�t| |�iLh�it 4Lhi �u �i �@�ihi@tL? |L Mi*�i�i |�i�h Ui?|h@* �4T*�U@|�L?t ��** ?L| U�@?}i �u �i @*|ih |�i @tt�4T|�L?t @*�||*i� ��|c �u !i) �4T*�U@|�L?t i�@TLh@|i ��|� t4@** U�@?}itc T@h|�U�*@h*) U�@?}it |�@| @hi

6;Wr vhh wklv/ vshfli| dq lqlwldo ydoxh iru e rq wkh krul}rqwdo d{lv1 Wkhq/ gr wkh iroorzlqj= jrlq d yhuwlfdo gluhfwlrq wr wkh exgjhw olqh> pryh krul}rqwdoo| wr wkh 78 ghjuhh olqh> pryh yhuwlfdoo|wr wkh exgjhw olqh/ dqg vr rq1

6<Lpsolflwo|/ zh kdyh uxohg rxw wkh srvvlelolw| wkdw qhjdwlyh e lpsolhv d qhjdwlyh S= Wklv fdqqrweh/ vlqfh S3 lv srvlwlyh iru 3 � e3 ? e�= Wkh Ilvkhu htxdwlrq +615, wkhq slqv grzq wkh sulfh sdwkiru Sw> dqg wklv fdqqrw surgxfh d qhjdwlyh Sw li S3 A 3=

2�

Page 24: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

@h}�@M*) �? |�i _�hiU|�L? Lu }hi@|ih i4T�h�U@* T*@�t�M�*�|)c |�i? |�ihi �t hi@tL? uLh UL?Uih?�W? |��t U@tic �i t@) @ |�iLh) �t uh@}�*i�

Oihic �i _itUh�Mi L?i UL?Uih? @ML�| |�i TLtt�M*i uh@}�*�|) Lu |�i 6A�wc M@ti_ L? �@?�3L?ih�c ��4M) @?_ #�M@ E�bb.�� i t�L� |�@| t4@**c T*@�t�M*i Tih|�hM@|�L?t L? ?L?�+�U@h_�@? TL*�U) *i@_ |L @ UL**@Tti �? |�i 6A�w<t @M�*�|) |L T�? _L�? |�i Th�Ui *i�i*�ef

�L?t�_ih |�i uL**L��?} @*|ih?@|��i |L |�i U@?L?�U@* ?L?�+�U@h_�@? TL*�U) Lu t�4T*) ti||�?} r|L @ UL?t|@?|� 5�TTLti r ' 0Kc ��ihi f 0 � �� `�|� |��t TL*�U)c K� ' E� n o�E�� 0�Kc Lh

K|

E� n o�|' E�� 0�|

�f

�fc

tL |�@| |�i |h@?t�iht@*�|) UL?_�|�L? �t t@|�t�i_ uLh @** �f : f� �*i@h*)c |��t �t @ +�U@h_�@?TL*�U)� `�|� |��t TL*�U)c |�i 6A�w _Lit ?L| T�? _L�? |�i Th�Ui *i�i*� �L�c |��t TL*�U) 4@)@TTi@h |L Mi @ �ih) M�} Tih|�hM@|�L? L? |�i TL*�U)c r| ' r� �ih�@Tt tLc M�| |�ihi @hi U*LtiUL�t�?t |L �| �? ���U� |�i Tih|�hM@|�L? @TTi@ht |L Mi 4�U� t4@**ih�

�L?t�_ih |�i uL**L��?} @*|ih?@|��i |L |�i U@?L?�U@* ?L?�+�U@h_�@? TL*�U)G

r| '

+� 1

�non �no3�

�noK| K| : 7K

r K| � 7Kc E���f�

��ihi

f � � �c1

�� �:

� n o

orc

� n o

or 7K

1

�� ��

W? |��t U@tic @t *L?} @t |�i hi@* _iM| �t Mi*L� tL4i �TTih ML�?_c 7Kc |�i? |�i TL*�U) �t ��@|�i �@�i Mii? @?@*)3�?}� ��|c @t tLL? @t K| i Uii_t 7K @ t��|U� LUU�ht @?_ �tU@* TL*�U) �t@_��t|i_ |L Mh�?} |�i _iM| M@U! �?|L *�?i�

�*|�L�}� |�i @*}iMh@�U hiThiti?|@|�L? Lu |��t TL*�U) 4@) tii4 uLhM�__�?}c �| �t ^��|i i@t)|L @?@*)3i �| ��|� |�i �i*T Lu @ }h@T� *�!i |�i L?i �? 6�}�hi 2� �L|i |�@| uLh K| : 7Kc |�i hi@*_iM| i�L*�it @UULh_�?} |L |�i uL**L��?} i^�@|�L?G

K|n� ' �K| n k�

73Zrrgirug +4<<;, dujxhv wkdw wkhuh pd| eh d orfdo vhqvh lq zklfk wkh IWSO*v delolw| wrslq grzq wkh sulfh ohyho vxuylyhv wkh vruw ri shuwxuedwlrqv zh frqvlghu khuh1 Kh dovr glvfxvvhvyhuvlrqv ri wkh prgho zlwk ohduqlqj zklfk pd| vxuylyh wkhvh shuwxuedwlrqv1

2e

Page 25: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

Wu �| uL**L�i_ |��t i^�@|�L? uLhi�ihc |�i hi@* _iM| �L�*_ i�i?|�@**) UL?�ih}i |L �K ' 1*E�� ���A��t i^�@|�L?c @t �i** @t E��S�c @hi }h@T�i_ �? 6�}�hi 2�

� t�4�*@|�L? Lu |�i hi@* _iM| �?_ih |�i �tU@* TL*�U) �? E���f� �t i ��M�|i_ �? 6�}�hi 2�A�i t�4�*@|�L? �t �?�|�@|i_ ��|� |�i �?_�U@|i_ �@*�i Lu Kf� �L|i �L� |�i hi@* _iM| �?�|�@**)uL**L�t |�i t|iiT *�?i ��|� t*LTi �no : � �?|�* �| T@ttit 7Kc ��i? �| t|@h|t |L uL**L� |�i �@||ih*�?i ��|� t*LTi � �� �** T@|�t ��|� Kf � KW @hi UL?t�t|i?| ��|� |�i |h@?t�iht@*�|) UL?_�|�L?MiU@�ti |�i) @** UL?�ih}i |L @ �?�|i �@*�ic i�|�ih KW Lh �K� 5Lc ��|� |�i }��i? U�@?}i �? TL*�U)c|�i 6A�w *Ltit �|t @M�*�|) |L T�? _L�? |�i Th�Ui *i�i*�

A��t Tih|�hM@|�L? L? |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? TL*�U) tii4t *�!i @ hi@*�t|�U L?i� �| *L� *i�i*tLu _iM| �tU@* TL*�U) �t i L}i?L�tc ��t| *�!i �? |�i U@?L?�U@* ?L?�+�U@h_�@? TL*�U)� ��|c �u |�i_iM| t�L�*_ }i| L�| Lu *�?ic |�i? �tU@* TL*�U) @_��t|t |L Mh�?} �| �?_ih UL?|hL*� A��t h�?}t|h�i �? *�}�| Lu |�i N5 i Tih�i?Ui �? |�i �bHft @?_ �bbft @?_ �? *�}�| Lu |�i ThL��t�L?t Lu|�i �@@t|h�U�| |hi@|) ���U� *�4�| |�i hi@* _iM|t Lu |�i 4i4Mih UL�?|h�it �? |�i ,�hLTi@?N?�L?�

���� A�i 6A�w ��|� 5|LU�@t|�U 6�tU@* �L*�U)

NT |L ?L�c �i �@�i �**�t|h@|i_ ?L?�+�U@h_�@? �tU@* TL*�U) ��|� r| ' rc @ UL?t|@?|� ��|c |�iitti?Ui Lu |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? �tU@* TL*�U) �t t�4T*) |�@| r| �t ?L| U@*�Mh@|i_ |L t@|�tu) |�i�?|ih|i4TLh@* M�_}i| i^�@|�L? uLh @** Th�Uit� W| �t UL4T@|�M*i ��|� @ 4�U� *@h}ih U*@tt LutTiU��U@|�L?t uLh r| |�@? r| ' r� Oihic �i t|�_) ?L?�+�U@h_�@? r|<t ���U� @hi h@?_L4� i�ti |��t |L 4@!i |�hii TL�?|t�

6�ht|c �i t�L� |�@| �@hhL<t E�b.b� u@4L�t TL*�U) Lu @MtLhM�?} �tU@* t�LU!t M) h@�t�?}|@ it �? |�i u�|�hi U@? Mi hiThiti?|i_ @t ?L?�+�U@h_�@? �tU@* TL*�U)�e� �t �i i T*@�? Mi*L�c|��t �t @? �4TLh|@?| i @4T*ic �? T@h| MiU@�ti �| �i*Tt U*@h�u) |�i _i�?�|�L? Lu ?L?�+�U@h_�@?TL*�U)c @t �| �t �ti_ �? |�i 6A�w� A��t hi^��hit U*@h��U@|�L?c MiU@�ti |�ihi @hi L|�ih 4i@?�?}tL?i 4�}�| 4�t|@!i?*) @||@U� |L |�i �Lh_c �?L?�+�U@h_�@?<c M@ti_ L? iUL?L4�t|t< i�ih)_@)�t@}i Lu |�i �Lh_c �+�U@h_�@?<�

5iUL?_c �i t�L� |�@| �? }i?ih@* � �?*itt TL*�U) �t Lu |�i uLh4 @_�LU@|i_ M) �@hhL � �tU@*t�LU!t U@�ti |�i �?�@|�L? h@|i |L ��U|�@|i h@?_L4*) @ML�| �|t @�ih@}i� A�i @�ih@}i �@*�iLu �?�@|�L? �t _i|ih4�?i_ M) |�i �@*�i Lu |�i 4L?i|@h) @�|�Lh�|)<t �?|ihit| h@|i Ti}�

A��h_c �i _itUh�Mi @? �4TLh|@?| hit�*| _�i |L LL_uLh_ E�bbSc �bbH�� Oi t�L�t |�@|c�?_ih |�i 6A�wc �u |�ihi �t �?t|@M�*�|) �? �tU@* TL*�U) |�i? |��t 4�t| �4T@U| L? |�i Th�Ui*i�i*c ?L 4@||ih �L� UL44�||i_ |�i 4L?i|@h) @�|�Lh�|) �t |L Th�Ui t|@M�*�|)�e2 i U@** |��t

74Wkdw wkh Eduur srolf| fdq dovr eh uhsuhvhqwhg dv Ulfdugldq vhhpv reylrxv/ dqg vr zh grqrw glvfxvv wklv1

75Lpsolflwo|/ zh kdyh lq plqg qrq0Ulfdugldq srolflhv rwkhu wkdq wkh w|sh dgyrfdwhg e| Eduur

2D

Page 26: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

t|h�!�?} hit�*| LL_uLh_<t +i@**) N?T*i@t@?| �h�|�4i|�Uc |L UL?|h@t| �| ��|� 5`<t u@4L�t|�|*i� LL_uLh_<t @h�|�4i|�U �t i�i? |L�}�ih |�@? 5`<t� �t ?L|i_ @ML�ic 5` @h}�i |�@|�u |�i Ui?|h@* M@?! �t �i@!c |�i? |�i �tU@* @�|�Lh�|�it U@? T�t� �| �?|L ThL_�U�?} Th�Ui�?t|@M�*�|)� OL�i�ihc |��t Titt�4�t|�U E��?T*i@t@?|<� UL?U*�t�L? Lu 5` �t M@*@?Ui_ M) |�i�hLT|�4�t4 |�@| �u |�i Ui?|h@* M@?! ��t| �@?}t |L�}�c |�i? |�i ThLM*i4 Lu Th�Ui t|@M�*�|) �ttL*�i_� wLL!�?} @| |��t uhL4 |�i TihtTiU|��i Lu |�i 6A�wc LL_uLh_ @h}�it |�@| �| _Lit?<|4@||ih �L� |L�}� |�i Ui?|h@* M@?! �t� W| t|�** U@??L| t|@M�*�3i |�i Th�Ui *i�i*�e�

������ +@?_L4 6�tU@* �L*�U)

5�TTLti |�i t�hT*�t LMi)t |�i uL**L��?} �ht| Lh_ih @�|Lhi}hitt��i hiThiti?|@|�L?G

r|n� ' E�� 4�rn 4r| n 0|n�� E�����

Oihic 0|n� �t @? ��_c ���|i ?L�ti ThLUittc �?_iTi?_i?| Lu r|3�c � � f� � TLt�|��i hi@*�3@|�L?Lu 0| �?_�Uit @ U�@?}i �? |�i _@|i | }L�ih?4i?| t�hT*�t @?_ �? |�i i TiU|i_ �@*�i Lu u�|�hi}L�ih?4i?| t�hT*�tit� wi| �� _i?L|i |��t igiU| @| _@|i |n �c uLh � � fG

��0| ' .|r|n� � .|3�r|n�c � � fc �f � �� E���2�

Oihic .| _i?L|it |�i i TiU|@|�L? LTih@|Lhc UL?_�|�L?@* L? �?uLh4@|�L? @�@�*@M*i @| _@|i |E.|r| ' r|�� `�i? |�i t�hT*�t �@t |�i |�4i tih�it hiThiti?|@|�L?c E�����c |�i?

�� ' 4��

�u UL�htic E���2� @TT*�it 4Lhi }i?ih@**)c i�i? ��i? r| _Lit ?L| �@�i |�i |�4i tih�it hiThi�ti?|@|�L? }��i? �? E������ i U@? _i�?i |�i Thiti?| �@*�i Lu |�i �4T@U| Lu 0| L? U�hhi?| @?_i TiU|i_ u�|�hi t�hT*�tit @t uL**L�tG

��

� n o

�0| � 0| n

��

� n o0| n

�2

E� n o�20| n ���

W? |�i U@ti Lu E�����c |��t �tG

��

� n o

�'

� n o

� n o � 4�

`�i? 4 ' fc tL |�@| r| �t ��_c |�i? |�i Thiti?| �@*�i |ih4 �t ��t| �?�|)� W? |��t U@tic |�iigiU| Lu @? �??L�@|�L? �? |�i t�hT*�t �t *�4�|i_ |L |�i U�hhi?| t�hT*�t L?*)� �t 4 �?Uhi@tit

+4<:<,176Exw/ uhfdoo rxu vhfrqg srlqw/ wkdw wkh fhqwudo edqn fdq frqwuro wkh dyhudjh lq�dwlrq udwh1

2S

Page 27: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

@ML�i 3ihLc |�i? |�i Thiti?| �@*�i |ih4 �?Uhi@tit |L |@!i �?|L @UUL�?| |�i u�|�hi igiU|t Lu@? �??L�@|�L?� �i}@|��i �@*�it Lu 4 U@�ti |�i Thiti?| �@*�i |ih4t |L u@**c @t �??L�@|�L?t �?|�i U�hhi?| t�hT*�t }i?ih@|i i TiU|i_ hi_�U|�L?t �? |�i u�|�hi t�hT*�t�

W| �t �?|ihit|�?} |L UL4T@hi |�i |)Ti Lu �tU@* TL*�U) UL?t�_ihi_ �? E����� ��|� |�i tLh| Lu�tU@* TL*�U) @_�LU@|i_ �? �@hhL E�b.b�� �@hhL @h}�it |�@| @ ?i}@|��i t�LU! |L }L�ih?4i?|�?@?Uit E_�i |Lc t@)c @ �@h� t�L�*_ Mi 4i| M) @ *@h}i �?Uhi@ti �? _iM|c UL�T*i_ ��|� @UL?t|@?| �?Uhi@ti �? |�i *@MLh |@ h@|i |�@| �t t��U�i?| |L T@) Lg |�i �?|ihit| @?_ Th�?U�T@*L? |�@| _iM| L�ih |�4i� W? T@h|�U�*@hc �@hhL E�b.b� @_�LU@|it �tU@* TL*�U�it Lu |�i uLh4G

��

� n o

�' f�

, @4T*it �?U*�_iGee

�f ' �c �� ' � E� n o� c Lhc �f ' �c �� ' ��� n o

2

��c � � ��

A�@| �tc

r| ' rn 0| � E� n o� 0|3�c Lhc r| ' rn 0| �"[�'�

�� n o

2

��0|3��

A�iti i @4T*it @hi �tiu�* �? T@h| MiU@�ti |�i) �i*T �i@_ Lg TL|i?|�@* 4�t�?_iht|@?_�?}t@ML�| |�i _i�?�|�L? Lu �?L?�+�U@h_�@?< TL*�U)� W? i�ih)_@) _�tU�tt�L?c |�i �Lh_ �+�U@h_�@?<�t �ti_ �? @ �@h�i|) Lu ti?tit� 5L4i|�4it iUL?L4�t|t �ti �| |L hiuih |L @ TL*�U) �? ���U� @U�hhi?| |@ U�| �t �?@?Ui_ M) �?Uhi@tit �? u�|�hi |@ it |�@| @hi *@h}i i?L�}� �? Thiti?| �@*�i|L 4@|U� |�i U�hhi?| U�|�eD W| �t U*i@h uhL4 |�i ThiUi_�?} _�tU�tt�L? |�@| |��t |)Ti Lu TL*�U)U@? Mi T@h| Lu @ ?L?�+�U@h_�@? hi}�4i�

N?_ih |�i |)Ti Lu �tU@* TL*�U) ��t| _�tU�tti_c |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �t �?t�*@|i_ uhL4 �tU@*t�LU!t� 5�LU!t |L |�i hi@* Th�4@h) t�hT*�t @hi �?@?Ui_ M) @TThLTh�@|i 4L�i4i?|t �? |�iLTTLt�|i _�hiU|�L? *@|ih L?� i ��** t�L� �? |�i ?i | t�MtiU|�L?c |�@| ��i? � 9' fc |�i?t�hT*�t t�LU!t @hi @| *i@t| T@h|�@**) �?@?Ui_ M) 4L�i4i?|t �? |�i Th�Ui *i�i*�

����2� W?�@|�L? `�|� +@?_L4 6�tU@* �L*�U)

i UL?|�?�i |L @tt�4i |�@| TL*�U) Ti}t -| ' -c tL |�@| |�i ti�}?Lh@}i UL4TL?i?| Lu r|�t |�i UL?t|@?| �@*�i }��i? �? E����� �t @ hit�*|c |�i h@?_L4 ?@|�hi Lu r| �? E����� hi�iU|t

77Vhh/ iru h{dpsoh/ Zrrgirug +4<<;,/ irrwqrwh 4;178Rqh h{dpsoh lv Kd|dvkl +4<;<,1

2.

Page 28: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

h@?_L4?itt �? �tU@* TL*�U)� A�i 6�t�ih i^�@|�L? t|�** �L*_tc @*|�L�}� �| 4�t| Mi @_��t|i_ |L|@!i �?|L @UUL�?| �?Uih|@�?|)G

� n o ' E� n-�.|

�|

�|n�

c

��ihi .| �t |�i UL?_�|�L?@* i TiU|@|�L?c }��i? �?uLh4@|�L? @�@�*@M*i @| |�4i |� A��t i Thitt�L?t�L�t |�@| |�i Ui?|h@* M@?! UL?|hL*t |�i i TiU|i_ h@|i Lu _i�@|�L? |�hL�}� �|t U�L�Ui Lu -�A��t |h@?t*@|it �?|L UL?|hL* L�ih |�i @�ih@}i h@|i Lu _i�@|�L? M) |�i u@U|c . d.| E�|*�|n��o '. E�|*�|n�� �

W4TLt�?} |�i t��|@M*) @_��t|i_ �iht�L? Lu |�i �L�ti�L*_<t |h@?t�iht@*�|) UL?_�|�L?c E��H�c

2H

Page 29: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

L? |�i }L�ih?4i?|<t �L� M�_}i| i^�@|�L?c |�i �?|ih|i4TLh@* M�_}i| i^�@|�L? �t ?L�eSG

�|

�|

' .|

"[�'f

r|n�

E� n o��' r

�� n o

o

�#�� 4

� n o � 4

$n

#� n o

� n o � 4

$r|� E�����

i ?L� �@�i @ UL4T*i|i*) tTiU��i_ |�iLh) Lu |�i Th�Ui *i�i* @?_ �?�@|�L?� �?i �@) |L�?_iht|@?_ |��t �t |L tii �L� |�i 4L_i* U@? Mi �ti_ |L t�4�*@|i @ ti^�i?Ui Lu Th�Uitc uLh@ }��i? hi@*�3@|�L? Lu Th�4@h) t�hT*�tit� A��tc t�TTLti �i �@�i @ |�4i tih�itc rfc r�c ���crA uhL4 E�����c @?_ @? �?�|�@* *i�i* Lu |�i ?L4�?@* _iM|c �f�

e. A�i?c �f �t UL4T�|i_ M)i�@*�@|�?} E����� @| | ' f� �u|ih |��tc �� �t UL4T�|i_ uhL4 |�i }L�ih?4i?|<t �L� M�_}i|

79Wr vhh krz wklv lv ghulyhg/ frqvlghu �uvw wkh h{suhvvlrq wr wkh uljkw ri wkh �uvw htxdolw| lq+6146,1 Qrwh iurp wkh Ilvkhu htxdwlrq=

4

Sw.m+4 .Uw.m,@ Hw.m

�4

+4 . u,Sw.m.4

�> doo w> m � 3=

Wkhq/ wkh �rz exgjhw frqvwudlqw ri wkh jryhuqphqw fdq eh zulwwhq

Ew.m

Sw.m

@ vw.m .Ew.m.4

Sw.m+4 .Uw.m,@ vw.m .

4

4 . uHw.m

Ew.m.4

Sw.m.4

>

ru/ diwhu dsso|lqj wkh odz ri lwhudwhg pdwkhpdwlfdo h{shfwdwlrqv=

Hw

Ew.m

Sw.m

@ Hwvw.m .4

4 . uHw

Ew.m.4

Sw.m.4

+--,

Vxevwlwxwh wklv/ iru m @ 3> lqwr wkh shulrg w �rz exgjhw frqvwudlqw ri wkh jryhuqphqw=

Ew

Sw

@ vw .4

4 . u

Ew.4

Sw+4 .U,

@ vw .4

4 . uHw

Ew.4

Sw.4

>

Dsso|lqj +--, uhshdwhgo| wr wklv h{suhvvlrq/ iru m @ 4> 5> === uhvxowv lq wkh h{suhvvlrq wr wkh uljkw ri

wkh �uvw htxdolw| lq +6146,/ li zh dsso| wkh wudqvyhuvdolw| frqglwlrq/ olpW$4H3eW@ +4 . u,W @ 31Wr rewdlq wkh h{suhvvlrq wr wkh uljkw ri wkh vhfrqg htxdolw| lq +6146,/ �uvw vroyh +6144, wr �qg=

Hw

vw.m

+4 . u,m@ v

+�4

4 . u

�m

��

4 . u

�m,.

��

4 . u

�m

vw>

iru m @ 3> 4> 5> === Wkhq vxevwlwxwh wklv lqwr +6146, dqg dsso| wkh jhrphwulf vxp irupxod17:Lw vkrxog eh reylrxv krz wklv surfhgxuh frxog eh dgdswhg wr dffrpprgdwh dq| rwkhu wlph

vhulhv uhsuhvhqwdwlrq iru vw=

2b

Page 30: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

i^�@|�L?c �|n� ' E� n -�E�| � �|r|�c uLh | ' f� � ti^�i?Uic �fc ��c ���c �A �t LM|@�?i_ M)TihuLh4�?} |�iti U@*U�*@|�L?t �? ti^�i?Uic uLh | ' fc �c 2c ���c A�

�t ?L|i_ MiuLhic |�i �?|ihit| h@|i Ti} }�@h@?|iit |�@| �? |�iti t�4�*@|�L?t |�i i TiU|i_h@|i Lu �?�@|�L? E@U|�@**)c _i�@|�L? |L Mi |iU�?�U@**) ULhhiU|� �t UL?t|@?|� �t @ hit�*|c |�ih@|i Lu �?�@|�L? �|ti*u ��** Mi @TThL �4@|i*) �?ULhhi*@|i_ L�ih |�4i� A��t *@||ih ui@|�hi �t @?@h|�u@U| Lu |�i UL?t|@?| �?|ihit| h@|i Ti}� Wu |�i �?|ihit| h@|i h�*i �ihi �?t|i@_ _iTi?_i?| L?T@t| �?|ihit| h@|it @?_%Lh T@t| �?�@|�L?c |�i? Thit�4@M*) Tiht�t|i?Ui �L�*_ @TTi@h �? |�i4L_i*<t �?�@|�L? ThLUitt�eH

�?i U@? LM|@�? u�h|�ih �?t�}�| �?|L E����� M) t�M|h@U|�?} .|3��|*�| uhL4 �|G

�|

�|

� .|3�

��|

�|

�'

#� n o

� n o � 4

$Er| � .|3�r|� E���e�

' ��

� n o

�0|

A��t t@)t |�@| @ _@|i | t�LU! �? |�i Th�4@h) t�hT*�t �?_�Uit @ UL?|i4TLh@?iL�t U�@?}i �?|�i hi@* �@*�i Lu |�i _iM| i^�@* |L |�i Thiti?| �@*�i Lu |�i t�LU!�eb 5�?Ui �| �t Thi_i|ih4�?i_@| |�4i |c |�i U�@?}i �t MhL�}�| @ML�| i?|�hi*) M) @ U�@?}i �? |�i Th�Ui *i�i*�Df

6�tU@* TL*�U�it *�!i E���e� �?_ihtULhi |�i u@U| |�@| 4L�i4i?|t �? |�i Th�Ui *i�i* @hi @?@*|ih?@|��i |L �@hhL<t �@) Lu �?@?U�?} t�LU!t |L |�i Th�4@h) t�hT*�t� � ��4T �? |�i Th�Ui*i�i* @U|t *�!i @ U@T�|@* *i�) L? |�i �L*_iht Lu }L�ih?4i?| ML?_tc @?_ |�@| �i*Tt |L �?@?Ui}L�ih?4i?| tTi?_�?} ��t| @t t�hi*) @t |�i tLh| Lu |@ it |�@| @hi �?U*�_i_ �? |�i Th�4@h)t�hT*�t� W? tiU|�L? e Mi*L�c �i _itUh�Mi @? i?��hL?4i?| �? ���U� |�i i�U�i?| �tU@* TL*�U)�t Lu |��t |)Ti�

������ LL_uLh_<t +i@**) N?T*i@t@?| �h�|�4i|�U

LL_uLh_<t @h}�4i?| |�@| �?t|@M�*�|) �? �tU@* TL*�U) 4�t| �4T@U| L? |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �t @t�4T*i ThLLu M) UL?|h@_�U|�L?� A��tc t�TTLti |�@| |�i 4L?i|@h) @�|�Lh�|) U@? TihuiU|*)

7;Or|r +4<<<, hpskdvl}hv wklv lq klv glvfxvvlrq ri wkh shuvlvwhqw ulvh lq lq�dwlrq revhuyhg lqEud}lo lq wkh 4<;3v1

7<Lw lv shukdsv reylrxv wkdw wkh dqdo|vlv ri sulfh ghwhuplqdwlrq xqghu wkh IWSO lv vlploduwr wkh dqdo|vlv ri frqvxpswlrq lq wkh shupdqhqw lqfrph k|srwkhvlv1 Iru d uhylhz zklfk xvhvpxfk ri wkh vdph dojheud xvhg khuh/ vhh Fkulvwldqr +4<;:,1

83Wr vhh wklv/ glylgh erwk vlghv ri +6147, e| Ew dqg/ wdnlqj lqwr dffrxqw/ Hw�4Ew @ Ew =

4

Sw

�Hw�4

�4

Sw

�@

4

Ew

#

�4

4 . u

�%w=

�f

Page 31: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

t|@M�*�3i �?�@|�L? @?_ |�i Th�Ui *i�i*� A��t �4T*�it |�@| �|n� ' �|c tL |�@| |�i ?L4�?@* h@|iLu �?|ihit| � i_ @?_ i^�@* |L |�i hi@* h@|i� A��t �? |�h? �4T*�it |�@| ti�}?Lh@}ic r6c �t 3ihL��t @ hit�*|c r| ' rs| � �L�c t�TTLti �tU@* TL*�U) �t t|LU�@t|�Uc ��|� �E�*E� n o�� 9' f� A�i?c@UULh_�?} |L E���e�c �| hitTL?_t |L �??L�@|�L?t �? r|� ��|c |�@| UL?|h@_�U|t L�h @tt�4T|�L?|�@| �| �t UL?t|@?|� W| uL**L�t |�@| ��|� t�LU!t |L �tU@* TL*�U)c �| 4@) ?L| Mi ui@t�M*i uLh |�i4L?i|@h) @�|�Lh�|) |L �?t�*@|i |�i Th�Ui *i�i* uhL4 |�Lti t�LU!t�

W? �?|ihThi|�?} |��tc �| �t �4TLh|@?| |L Mi@h �? 4�?_ |�i u@U| |�@| |�i 4L?i|@h) @�|�Lh�|)U@? UL?|hL* |�i i TiU|i_ h@|i Lu �?�@|�L? �? |�i 6A�w� 6Lh LL_uLh_<t +i@**) N?T*i@t@?|�h�|�4i|�U |L Mi �?T*i@t@?| �? u@U|c hi^��hit |�@| t�LU!t |L |�i hi@*�3i_ Th�Ui *i�i* �@�itLU�@**) �?i�U�i?| UL?ti^�i?Uit� W? 4@?) iUL?L4�U i?��hL?4i?|tc |��t �t ?L| |�i U@tic @?_L?*) |�i i TiU|i_ �?�@|�L? h@|i 4@||iht Etiic i�}�c ��@h�c ��h�t|�@?L @?_ ki�Li E�bb����5�LU!t |L |�i hi@*�3i_ Th�Ui *i�i* @hi ULt|*) �? i?��hL?4i?|t ��ihi |�ihi @hi ?L4�?@* h�}�_�|�it@?_ ��ihi @}i?|t @hi �i|ihL}i?iL�t�D�

��e� A�i 6A�w @?_ |�i �L?|hL* Lu ��ih@}i W?�@|�L?

A�i Thi��L�t t�MtiU|�L? t�L�i_ |�@| |�i 4L?i|@h) @�|�Lh�|) U@? UL?|hL* |�i @�ih@}i h@|i Lu�?�@|�L? M) Ti}}�?} |�i ?L4�?@* �?|ihit| h@|i |L @? @TThLTh�@|i �@*�i�D2 W? TL*�U) _�tU�tt�L?t@ML�| �?�@|�L?c �| �t tL4i|�4it t�}}it|i_ |�@| �?�@|�L? U@? Mi UL?|hL**i_ 4Lhi igiU|��i*)��|� @? �?|ihit| h@|i h�*i |�@| hitTL?_t @}}hitt��i*) |L �?�@|�L?� W? |��t tiU|�L?c �i t�L�|�@| t�U� @ 4L?i|@h) TL*�U) UL�*_ �? u@U| *i@_ |L _�t@t|ihc �u �tU@* TL*�U) �ihi ?L?�+�U@h_�@?�

5�TTLti |�@| |�i 4L?i|@h) @�|�Lh�|) @_��t|t |�i �?|ihit| h@|i @UULh_�?} |L |�i uL**L��?}h�*iG

� n-| ' kf n k�Z|c Z| ' �|*�|3��

A�i 4L?i|@h) @�|�Lh�|) �4T*i4i?|t |��t h�*i M) @_��t|�?} |�i 4L?i) t�TT*) tL |�@| 4L?i)_i4@?_ �t t@|�t�i_ @| |�i |@h}i|i_ h@|i Lu �?|ihit|� �? �@}}hitt��i< �?|ihit| h@|i h�*i �t L?i �?���U� k� �t *@h}i� 6Lh i @4T*ic A@)*Lh E�bb�� �@t @h}�i_ |�@| k� t�L�*_ Mi @hL�?_ ��D� A��t4i@?t |�@| �u �?�@|�L? h�tit M) � TihUi?|@}i TL�?|c |�i? |�i Ui?|h@* M@?! h@�tit |�i ?L4�?@*h@|i Lu �?|ihit| M) ��D TihUi?|@}i TL�?|t� �UULh_�?} |L UL?�i?|�L?@* ��t_L4c @? @}}hitt��i�?|ihit| h@|i h�*i *�!i |��t �t @ }LL_ �@) |L !iiT �?�@|�L? �?_ih UL?|hL*� �t �i t�@** tiic |��t�t ?L| ?iUitt@h�*) |�i U@ti �u TL*�U) �t ?L?�+�U@h_�@?�

i t�TTLti |�@| |�i hit| Lu |�i iUL?L4) ULhhitTL?_t |L |�i L?i �? |�i i @4T*i �? tiU|�L?���� �t �? |�@| 4L_i* iUL?L4)c �i @tt�4i |�@| |�ihi �t ?L �?Uih|@�?|)c t�?Ui |�@| �t ?L|

84Vhh Zrrgirug +4<<9, iru dq hqylurqphqw zlwk hqgrjhqrxv surgxfwlrq dqg vwlfn| sulfhv1Zlwk vwlfn| sulfhv/ vkrfnv wr wkh djjuhjdwh sulfh ohyho glvwruw wkh doorfdwlrq ri uhvrxufhv dfurvvwkh surgxfwlrq ri gl�huhqw jrrgv1 Wkh| dovr glvwruw djjuhjdwh rxwsxw1

85Vhh vhfwlrq 61615 deryh1

��

Page 32: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

itti?|�@* |L |�i @?@*)t�t �ihi� �L4M�?�?} |�i �?|ihit| h@|i h�*i ��|� |�i 6�t�ih i^�@|�L?cE��2�c �i LM|@�? |�i uL**L��?} i Thitt�L?c ���U� 4�t| �L*_ �? i^��*�Mh��4G

Z|n� 'kf

� n on

k�

� n oZ|�

�L?t�_ih @? @}}hitt��i �?|ihit| h@|i h�*ic ��|� k�*E�n o� : �� A�i hi*@|�L?t��T Mi|�ii? Z|n�@?_ Z| �t _iT�U|i_ �? 6�}�hi �� �L|i |�@| |�ihi �t @ T@h|�U�*@h �?�@|�L? h@|ic ZWc t�U� |�@| �uZ| ' ZWc |�i? Z|n� ' ZW |LL� OL�i�ihc �u |�i �?�|�@* �?�@|�L? h@|i t�L�*_ Mi }hi@|ih |�@? ZWc|�i? Z| }Lit |L T*�t �?�?�|)c @t | }i|t *@h}i� A��t TLtt�M�*�|) �t �**�t|h@|i_ �? 6�}�hi �c ��ihi�?�@|�L? t|@h|t ��|� Zf �? Tih�L_ f @?_ |�i? i T*L_it�

�t �? |�i 4L_i* iUL?L4) �? tiU|�L? ���c |�i �?�|�@* Th�Ui *i�i* �t _i|ih4�?i_ M) �tU@*TL*�U) @UULh_�?} |L |�i �?|ih|i4TLh@* M�_}i| i^�@|�L?c E��b�� AiU�?�U@**)c r �t ?L� ?L *L?}ih@ UL?t|@?|� A��t �t MiU@�ti |�i �@h�@|�L?t �? �?�@|�L? U@�ti ti�}?Lh@}i |L �@h) L�ih |�4i|LL� OL�i�ihc �i @tt�4i |�@| ti�}?Lh@}i hi�i?�it @hi t4@** i?L�}� |L �}?Lhic tL |�@| r �tUL4TLti_ L?*) Lu rs � i UL?|�?�i |L @tt�4i |�@| rs �t UL?t|@?|�D� 5Lc |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �?Tih�L_ f �t _i|ih4�?i_ M) �f ' �f*K

Wc ��ihi �f �t |�i �?�|�@* ?L4�?@* _iM| @?_ KW �t _i�?i_�? E��b��

`�|� �f _i|ih4�?i_ M) |�i �?|ih|i4TLh@* M�_}i| i^�@|�L?c @?_ �3� _i|ih4�?i_ M) ��t�|Lh)c Zf �t �?�^�i*) T�??i_ _L�?� ��|c |�ihi �t ?L �@) |L h�*i L�| |�i TLtt�M�*�|) |�@| |��t�@*�i Lu Zf *�it |L |�i h�}�| Lu ZWc �? ���U� U@ti @? i T*L_�?} �?�@|�L? LUU�ht�De

�?i �@) |L }@�? �?|��|�L? �?|L |�i 4iU�@?�Ut Lu |��t i T*L_�?} �?�@|�L? uLU�tit L? |�i}L�ih?4i?|<t M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?|c E��D�� 6hL4 |�@| i^�@|�L?c �i tii |�@| @ ��}�ih ?L4�?@*�?|ihit| h@|i *i@_t |L @ 4Lhi h@T�_ �?Uhi@ti �? |�i ?L4�?@* _iM|c �|n�� ��|c �?_ih |�i@tt�4T|�L? |�@| |�i L�|*LL! uLh |�i �tU@* Th�4@h) t�hT*�t _Lit ?L| U�@?}ic |��t 4i@?t |�@||�i hi@* �@*�i Lu |�i _iM| hi4@�?t UL?t|@?|� `�|� |�i ?L4�?@* _iM| }hL��?} 4Lhi ^��U!*)@?_ �|t hi@* �@*�i UL?t|@?|c �?�@|�L? 4�t| h�ti� A�i Ui?|h@* M@?!<t 4L?i|@h) TL*�U) hitTL?_t|L |�i h�ti �? �?�@|�L? M) _h���?} |�i �?|ihit| h@|i �T i�i? u�h|�ihc @?_ |��t *i@_t |L @?@__�|�L?@* �?Uhi@ti �? �?�@|�L?� A��t U�hU�*@hc ti*u�hi�?uLhU�?} ThLUitt �t ��@| *i@_t |L |�ii T*Lt�L? �? �?�@|�L?�

A�i TLtt�M�*�|) ��t| L�|*�?i_c ��ihiM) @? @}}hitt��i �?|ihit| h@|i h�*i *i@_t |L @? i T*L_��?} �?�@|�L?c 4@) tii4 TiU�*�@h� +iUL}?�3�?} |��t @TTi@h@?Uic wL)L E�bbb� hiuiht |L |��t @t@ �|�}�| 4L?i) T@h@_L <� �UULh_�?} |L |�i 4L_i*c �u �?t|i@_ Lu Mi�?} @}}hitt��ic |�i Ui?|h@*M@?! @_LT|i_ @ 4Lhi @UUL44L_@|�?} t|@?Ui M) U�LLt�?} @ �@*�i Lu k� t�Mt|@?|�@**) *itt

86Lq h�hfw/ zh dvvxph wkh hfrqrp| lv lq wkh cfdvkohvv olplw* glvfxvvhg e| Zrrgirug +4<<;/4<<;d/ 4<<;e,/ dqg gh�qhg lq dq hduolhu irrwqrwh1

87Wklv vlwxdwlrq lv rqh lq zklfk �vfdo srolf| dqg prqhwdu| srolf| duh erwk dfwlyh/ lq wkh vhqvhgh�qhg e| Ohhshu +4<<4,1 Rxu dqdo|vlv lv frqvlvwhqw zlwk Ohhshu*v/ zklfk frqfoxghv wkdw irudoprvw doo ydoxhv ri �vfdo srolf|/ vi > wkhuh grhv qrw h{lvw d vwdwlrqdu| htxloleulxp lq�dwlrq udwh1

�2

Page 33: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

|�@? �?�|)c |�i? i T*L_�?} �?�@|�L? UL�*_ ?L| LUU�h� i t@� |��t �? |�i Thi��L�t t�MtiU|�L?c�ihi �| �@t t�L�? |�@| ��|� k� ' f �?�@|�L? ��U|�@|it @hL�?_ @ UL?t|@?| �@*�i� W| �t i@t)|L UL?�h4 �t�?} |�i |)Ti Lu *L}�U �? 6�}�hi �c |�@| |�i t@4i �t |h�i uLh f k� ��

+i*@|��i |L @ t�4T*i 4L?i|@h�t| TihtTiU|��ic |�i hit�*| |�@| @_LT|�?} @? @}}hitt��i t|@?Ui@}@�?t| �?�@|�L? M) �?Uhi@t�?} k� 4@) UL?�ih| @ t|@M*i �?�@|�L? �?|L @? i T*L_�?} �?�@|�L? �tUih|@�?*) @ T@h@_L �DD OL�i�ihc �i �@�i ��t| tii? |�@| �| U@? LUU�h �? @ UL�ihi?| iUL?L4�U4L_i*� �LhiL�ihc wL)L E�bbb� @h}�it |�@| |�i 4L_i* U@T|�hit |�i M@t�U uLhUit _h���?}|�i |@!iLg �? �?�@|�L? �? �h@3�* �? |�i i@h*) �bHft� �*|�L�}� �i @hi t!iT|�U@* |�@| |L�}�4L?i|@h) TL*�U) �@t |�i U@�ti Lu �h@3�*<t ��}� �?�@|�L?c |�i �)TL|�it�t Uih|@�?*) _Lit tii4�?|h�}��?}�

A�i i T*L_�?} �?�@|�L? tUi?@h�L ��t| _itUh�Mi_ �@t Mii? �ti_ M) LL_uLh_ E�bbH@c TT��bb�eff� |L �?_iht|@?_ |�i ?@|�hi Lu �tU@* TL*�U) �? |�i N5 �? |�i T@t| |�L _iU@_it� OiLMtih�it |�@| E�� iUL?L4i|h�U it|�4@|it Lu |�i 6i_<t TL*�U) h�*i �? |�i �bHft @?_ �bbft T*@Uik� t�Mt|@?|�@**) @ML�i �?�|) Etii �*@h�_@c B@*� @?_ Bih|*ih E�bbH�� @?_ E��� |�ihi �t ?Li��_i?Ui Lu �?t|@M�*�|) �? N5 �?�@|�L?� Oi UL?U*�_it uhL4 E�� @?_ E��� |�@| TL*�U) �? |�i N5_�h�?} |��t |�4ic 4�t| ?L| Mi ?L?�+�U@h_�@?�

e� A�i 6A�w @?_ |�i �T|�4@* #i}hii Lu �h�Ui W?t|@M�*�|)

A�i 6A�w *�|ih@|�hi �@t @*tL _h@�? @||i?|�L? |L |�i TLtt�M�*�|) |�@| tL4i Th�Ui �?t|@M�*�|)4@) Mi _it�h@M*i ��i? |�ihi @hi �?@�L�_@M*i t�LU!t |L |�i }L�ih?4i?| M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?|E5�4t E�bbb�c LL_uLh_ E�bbH��� `�i? |�ihi �t ?L4�?@* }L�ih?4i?| _iM|c �?@?|�U�T@|i_t�LU!t |L |�i Th�Ui *i�i* @U| *�!i U@T�|@* *i��it L? ML?_ �L*_iht� A�i �_i@ �t |�@| �| �t i�U�i?||L @MtLhM �?@?|�U�T@|i_ t�LU!t ��|� U@T�|@* *i��itc h@|�ih |�@? M) U�@?}�?} _�t|Lh|�L?@h)|@ it�

i �**�t|h@|i |�iti LMtih�@|�L?t �? |�i t�4T*it| TLtt�M*i 4L_i*�DS +i*@|��i |L L�h L?i�Tih�L_ 4L_i* �? tiU|�L? 2c |�i 4L_i* �?ULhTLh@|it |�L UL4T*�U@|�L?t |�@| @hi itti?|�@* uLh|�i T�hTLti @| �@?_� 6�ht|c �i ?ii_ |L |@!i �?|L @UUL�?| TLtt�M*i _�t|Lh|�L?@h) igiU|t L?|�i ML?_ @UU�4�*@|�L? _iU�t�L? @h�t�?} uhL4 Th�Ui *i�i* �?t|@M�*�|)� 6Lh |��t hi@tL?c �i @_LT|@ |�L�Tih�L_ ti|�T� A�i ML?_ @UU�4�*@|�L? _iU�t�L? �t |@!i? �? |�i �ht| Tih�L_c @?_ |�i}L�ih?4i?| tTi?_�?} t�LU! @?_ Th�Ui *i�i* �?Uih|@�?|) LUU�ht �? |�i tiUL?_ Tih�L_� 5iUL?_c

88Wljkw prqh| sdudgr{hv dovr h{lvw lq hqylurqphqwv zlwk Ulfdugldq �vfdo srolf|1 Iru h{dpsoh/Vdujhqw dqg Zdoodfh +4<;4, vkrzhg/ lq vxfk dq hqylurqphqw/ d wljkw prqhwdu| srolf| pd| ohdgwr dq lpphgldwh ulvh lq lq�dwlrq1 Vhh Nrfkhuodnrwd dqg Skhodq +4<<<, iru d glvfxvvlrq ri d wljkwprqh| sdudgr{ lq wkh IWSO1

89Wkh h{dpsoh looxvwudwhv wkh uhvxowv rq wkh ghvludelolw| ri wd{ vprrwklqj dqg yrodwloh sulfhvuhsruwhg lq Fkdul/ Fkulvwldqr dqg Nhkrh +4<<4,1

��

Page 34: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

|�i 4L_i* 4�t| U@T|�hi |�i ?L|�L? |�@| |@ it @hi _�t|Lh|�L?@h)� �UULh_�?}*)c �i @tt�4i |�@|*@MLh t�TT*) �t i?_L}i?L�t @?_ |@ it @hi h@�ti_ �t�?} @ ThLTLh|�L?@* |@ L? *@MLh �?UL4i�

A�i M@t�U ti|�T Lu |�i 4L_i* �t @? i @4T*i Lu |�i 6A�w MiU@�ti }L�ih?4i?| TL*�U)c |�iU�L�Ui Lu *@MLh |@ h@|itc �t ?L?�+�U@h_�@?� i �**�t|h@|i �L� @_�LU@|it Lu |�i 6A�w t|�_)|�i LT|�4@* _i}hii Lu Th�Ui t|@M�*�|) M) i @4�?�?} |�i �Mit|< i^��*�Mh��4 Lu t�U� @ 4L_i*Etiic i�}�c 5�4t E�bbb� @?_ LL_uLh_ E�bbH��� A��t i^��*�Mh��4 �t ��@| |�i *�|ih@|�hi L?LT|�4@* �tU@* @?_ 4L?i|@h) TL*�U) Etiic i�}�c w�U@t @?_ 5|L!i) E�bH��� U@**t |�i +@4ti)i^��*�Mh��4�

A�i �ht| t�MtiU|�L? Mi*L� _itUh�Mit |�i 4L_i*� AL t�4T*�u) |�i @?@*)t�tc |�i 4L_i* _Lit?L| �?U*�_i 4L?i)� � UL?ti^�i?Ui Lu |��t �t |�@| |�i 4L_i* UL?t|�|�|it @?L|�ih �**�t|h@|�L? LuTh�Ui _i|ih4�?@|�L? �? @? iUL?L4) ��|� ?L }L�ih?4i?|�ThL��_i_ 4L?i)� A�i ?i | t�MtiU|�L?U�@h@U|ih�3it |�i Mit| E��i�c |�i +@4ti)� i^��*�Mh��4 �? |��t iUL?L4)� i |�i? Thiti?| @?�4ih�U@* i @4T*i ���U� �**�t|h@|it |�i hL*i Lu Th�Ui �?t|@M�*�|) �? Mh�?}�?} @ML�| i�U�i?|hitL�hUi @**LU@|�L? �? |�i 4L_i*� i @ttitt |�i hit�*|t �? @ t�44@h) tiU|�L?�

e��� A�i �L_i*

A�i iUL?L4) �t UL4TLti_ Lu �h4tc �L�ti�L*_t @?_ @ }L�ih?4i?|� OL�ti�L*_t @?_ �h4t�?|ih@U| �? UL4Ti|�|��i 4@h!i|t� A�i }L�ih?4i?| 4�t| �?@?Ui @? i L}i?L�t*) }��i? *i�i*Lu i Ti?_�|�hit� W| _Lit tL M) *i�)�?} @ _�t|Lh|�L?@h) |@ h@|i L? *@MLh @?_ TLtt�M*) @*tLM) �tt��?} _iM|� A�ihi �t ?L �?Uih|@�?|) �? |�i �ht| Tih�L_� OL�i�ihc |�ihi �t �?Uih|@�?|)�? |�i tiUL?_ Tih�L_<t *i�i* Lu }L�ih?4i?| tTi?_�?}� 5Ti?_�?} UL�*_ Mi ��}� Lh *L�c ��|�ThLM@M�*�|) �%2 i@U�c ��|� |�i �?Uih|@�?|) Mi�?} hitL*�i_ @| |�i Mi}�??�?} Lu |�i tiUL?_ Ti�h�L_� �L?t�t|i?| ��|� |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L?c |�i }L�ih?4i?| UL44�|t |L �|t TL*�U�itMiuLhi |�i �ht| Tih�L_� Ah@_i LUU�ht M) M@h|ihc @?_ |�ihi �t ?L 4L?i) �? |�i 4L_i*�D.

6�h4t �@�i @UUitt |L @ *�?i@h ThL_�U|�L? |iU�?L*L})G

+ ' ?c +� ' ?�c +, ' ?,c

��ihi + @?_ ? _i?L|i L�|T�| @?_ *@MLh �? |�i �ht| Tih�L_ @?_ +�c ?� _i?L|i L�|T�| @?_*@MLh �? |�i tiUL?_ Tih�L_c � ' �c ,� A�i t�TihtUh�T| � Lh , �?_�U@|it |�i tiUL?_ Tih�L_ ��i?}L�ih?4i?| tTi?_�?} �t ��}� Lh *L�c hitTiU|��i*)� A�i *�?i@h�|) �? |�i ThL_�U|�L? u�?U|�L?}�@h@?|iit |�@| |�i hi@* �@}i �t @*�@)t �?�|) �? i^��*�Mh��4c @?_ tL uhL4 �ihi L? �i t�4T*)�4TLti |��t @?_ _L ?L| hiuih |L �h4t @?)4Lhi�

8:Zh frxog lpdjlqh wkdw wkhuh lv clqvlgh prqh|*/ dqg wkdw wudgh lv dffrpsolvkhg wkurxjk dqh�flhqw h{fkdqjh ri lrx*v1

�e

Page 35: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

�hiuihi?Uit Lu �L�ti�L*_t L�ih UL?t�4T|�L? @?_ *@MLh L�ih |�i |�L Tih�L_t |@!i |�iuL**L��?} uLh4G

LE%� ' S��

2?2 n

2q��S� �

2

�?��2�

n�S, �

2

�?,�2��

c f � q � �c Ee���

��ihi S _i?L|it UL?t�4T|�L? �? |�i �ht| Tih�L_ @?_ q �t |�i _�tUL�?| h@|ic ��|� q ' E�no�3��5�4�*@h*)c S� _i?L|it UL?t�4T|�L? �? |�i tiUL?_ Tih�L_c UL?_�|�L?@* L? |�i hi@*�3@|�L? Lu}L�ih?4i?| tTi?_�?}c � ' �c ,� �*tLc q �t |�i _�tUL�?| h@|i Lu |�i �L�ti�L*_c @?_ |�i ?�4Mih��*2< MiuLhi q ULhhitTL?_t |L |�i ThLM@M�*�|) Lu |�i � Lh , t|@|i Lu |�i �Lh*_� 6�?@**)c

% ' ESc S�c S,c ?c ?�c ?,�� Ee�2�

A�i *�?i@h�^�@_h@|�U t|h�U|�hi Lu Thiuihi?Uit �t U�Lti? |L i?t�hi |�@| |�i @?@*)t�t �t t�4T*i�A�i �L�ti�L*_<t Tih�L_ � M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?| �tG

��

� n-n �S � � n � E�� ��?c Ee���

��ihi � �t |�i Tih�L_ � Th�Ui *i�i*c � �t |�i ?L4�?@* ML?_t |�@| |�i �L�ti�L*_ �?�ih�|t uhL4|�i T@t|c @?_ - �t |�i ?L4�?@* h@|i Lu �?|ihit|� �*tLc � _i?L|it |�i |@ h@|i L? *@MLh @?_�� _i?L|it ML?_t @U^��hi_ uhL4 |�i }L�ih?4i?|� A�i �L�ti�L*_<t M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?| �? |�itiUL?_ Tih�L_c UL?_�|�L?@* L? |�i hi@*�3@|�L? Lu �?Uih|@�?|)c �t

� �S� � �� n � �E�� ���?�c � ,S, � �� n � ,E�� � ,�?,� Ee�e�

�}@�?c t�TihtUh�T|t �?_�U@|i |�i hi@*�3@|�L? Lu |�i i L}i?L�t }L�ih?4i?| tTi?_�?} t�LU!�A�ihi �t ?L }L�ih?4i?|�t�TT*�i_ 4L?i) �? |��t iUL?L4)�

A�i �L�ti�L*_ 4@ �4�3it �|�*�|) M) U�L�Ui Lu ?L?�?i}@|��i �@*�it uLh ��c Sc S�c S,c ?c?�c ?,� W| 4�t| @*tL hitTiU| |�i M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?|t ��t| tTiU��i_c @?_ �| |@!it Th�Uit @?_|�i �?|ihit| h@|i @t }��i? @?_ Mi)L?_ �|t UL?|hL*� A�i ,�*ih i^�@|�L?t @ttLU�@|i_ ��|� |�i�L�ti�L*_<t LT|�4@* U�L�Ui Lu *@MLh @?_ ML?_t @hiG

? ' �� �c ?� ' �� ��c ?, ' �� � ,c�

E� n-��'

2q�

� �n

� ,

�� Ee�D�

A�i *@t| Lu |�iti t@)t |�@| |�i i TiU|i_ }hLtt hi@* h@|i Lu hi|�h? L? ML?_t 4�t| Mi �*q�A�@| |��t �t |h�ic �?_iTi?_i?| Lu |�i �?|ih|i4TLh@* T@||ih? Lu UL?t�4T|�L?c hi�iU|t L�h@tt�4T|�L? |�@| �|�*�|) �t *�?i@h �? UL?t�4T|�L?�

�D

Page 36: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

A�i }L�ih?4i?|<t M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?|t �? |�i �ht| @?_ tiUL?_ Tih�L_t @hiG

��

� n-n ��? � � n �}

� ���?� � �� n � �}� Ee�S�

� ,� ,?, � �� n � ,},�

Oihic } _i?L|it }L�ih?4i?| UL?t�4T|�L? �? |�i �ht| Tih�L_c @?_ }� _i?L|it Tih�L_ 2 }L�ih?�4i?| UL?t�4T|�L?c � ' �c ,� W?tTiU|�L? Lu |�i i^�@|�L?t Lu L�h 4L_i* hi�i@*t |�@| - @TTi@hti�ih)��ihi @t E� n-�*� �c E� n -�*� ,c Lh ��*E� n -��DH A��tc �i U@??L| T�? _L�? i@U� Lu-c � �c � ,c @?_ �� tiT@h@|i*)� 6Lh |��t hi@tL?c �i @_LT| |�i ?Lh4@*�3@|�L?c - ' fc uhL4 �ihiL?� BL�ih?4i?| TL*�U) �t @ �iU|Lh Lu |�hii ?�4Mihtc Zc ��ihi

Z '��c ��c � ,

��

A��t �t @ ?L?�+�U@h_�@? TL*�U)� A�ihi �t ?L ti| Lu �@*�it uLh Z �@��?} |�i ThLTih|) |�@| |�i}L�ih?4i?|<t �?|ih|i4TLh@* M�_}i| i^�@|�L? Etii Mi*L�� �t t@|�t�i_ uLh @** Th�Uit�

�L4M�?�?} |�i }L�ih?4i?| @?_ �L�ti�L*_ M�_}i| i^�@|�L?tc �i LM|@�? |�i hitL�hUiUL?t|h@�?|tG

Sn } � ?c S� n }� � ?�c S, n }, � ?,� Ee�.�

A�ihi @hi �f �@h�@M*it |L Mi _i|ih4�?i_ �? i^��*�Mh��4G

�c� �c � ,c ��c Sc S�c S,c ?c ?�c ?,�

A�i) @hi _i|ih4�?i_ M) |�i |�hii �L�ti�L*_ M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?|tc Ee����Ee�e�c i�@*�@|i_ ��|� @t|h�U| i^�@*�|)( |�i uL�h �L�ti�L*_ ,�*ih i^�@|�L?tc Ee�D�( @?_ |�i |�hii hitL�hUi UL?t|h@�?|tcEe�.�� A�iti �f i^�@|�L?tc |L}i|�ih ��|� |�i hi^��hi4i?|c �c� �c � , : fc U�@h@U|ih�3i i^���*�Mh��4 E�u L?i i �t|t-� @ttLU�@|i_ ��|� @ }��i? }L�ih?4i?| TL*�U)� A�i 4@TT�?} uhL4 Z |L|�iti �@h�@M*it �t t�?}*i��@*�i_� i _i?L|i |�i u�?U|�L? hi*@|�?} |�i *@t| t� Lu |�iti �@h�@M*it|L Z M)

%EZ�c

��ihi % �t _i�?i_ �? Ee�2��

8;Wkh vwdwhphqw lv reylrxvo| wuxh lq wkh fdvh ri wkh krxvhkrog Hxohu htxdwlrq lq +718,1 Wr vhhwkdw lw lv dovr wuxh ri +716,0+717, dqg +719,/ uhsodfh E3 e| �E3 @ E3@+4 . U, lq wkrvh htxdwlrqv/dqg wkhq glylgh wkh shulrg 5 exgjhw frqvwudlqwv e| 4 . U=

�S

Page 37: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

e�2� A�i +@4ti) ,^��*�Mh��4

A�i +@4ti) i^��*�Mh��4 �t |�i L?i @ttLU�@|i_ ��|� |�i TL*�U�itc Zc ���U� tL*�i |�i ThLM*i4

4@ Z

LE%EZ��c

t�M�iU| |L |�i hi^��hi4i?| |�@| Th�Uit Mi t|h�U|*) TLt�|��ic �� � f @?_ |�i i*i4i?|t �? % Mi?L?�?i}@|��i�Db A�i +@4ti) i^��*�Mh��4 �t i@t) |L UL4T�|i �? |��t 4L_i* iUL?L4)�

�u|ih t�Mt|�|�|�?} L�| uLh |�i i?_L}i?L�t �@h�@M*it �? |ih4t Lu Z �? Ee�.� @?_ Ee�D�c �i�?_ |�@| |�i �|�*�|) u�?U|�L? �@t |�i uL**L��?} hiThiti?|@|�L?G

LE%EZ�� ' �� 2 ��

2q�����2

n�� ,�2�

n Vc Ee�H�

��ihi V �t @ UL?t|@?|�Sf AL UL4T*i|i |�i t|@|i4i?| Lu |�i +@4ti) ThLM*i4c �i ?ii_ @ t�4T*ihiThiti?|@|�L? Lu |�i hit|h�U|�L?t T*@Ui_ L? Z M) |�i hi^��hi4i?| |�@| Th�Uit Mi TLt�|��i� ��|cMiuLhi �i _L |��tc �i 4�t| UL?uhL?| @ |iU�?�U@* �tt�i�

W| �t �i** !?L�? �? |�i *�|ih@|�hi L? +@4ti) i^��*�Mh�@ |�@| �| �t i�U�i?| |Lc �? igiU|chi?i}i L? |�i �?�|�@* ?L4�?@* _iM|c �c M) ti*iU|�?} TL*�U�it ���U� ThL_�Ui @? �?�?�|i �ht|Tih�L_ Th�Ui *i�i*� �**L��?} |��t |L �@TTi? �ihi �L�*_ T*�?}i �t �?|L i L|�U 4@|�i4@|�U@*�tt�itc ���*i _�t|h@U|�?} �t uhL4 |�i Ui?|h@* uLU�t Lu |�i i @4T*i� A�i uLU�t Lu |�i i @4T*i �tL? |�i _it�h@M�*�|) Lu *i||�?} Th�Uit �? |�i tiUL?_ Tih�L_ hi@U| |L |�i hi@*�3@|�L? Lu }L�ih?4i?|tTi?_�?} �? |�@| Tih�L_� `�|� |��t �? 4�?_c �i t�4T*) � |�i Tih�L_ � Th�Ui *i�i* @| � ' ��5�?Ui |�i ?L4�?@* _iM|c �c �t }��i? uhL4 |�i T@t|c �| uL**L�t |�@| �i �@�i � i_ |�i �?�|�@*hi@* _iM|� W| �t �4TLh|@?| |L i4T�@t�3ic �L�i�ihc |�@| �i _L ?L| � |�i tiUL?_ Tih�L_ Th�Ui*i�i*t�S�

A�i hit|h�U|�L? T*@Ui_ L? Z Lu |�i hi^��hi4i?|c � ' �c �t i@t) |L _i|ih4�?i� i _LtL M) i Thitt�?} |�i }L�ih?4i?|<t �ht| Tih�L_ �?|ih|i4TLh@* M�_}i| i^�@|�L? �? |ih4t Lu

8<Vhh El}hu dqg Mxgg +4<;<,/ Fkdul/ Fkulvwldqr dqg Nhkrh +4<<4,/ Mxgg +4<;<,/ Oxfdv dqgVwrnh| +4<;6,/ dprqj rwkhuv1

93Khuh/

� @ 5

�4

5� j .

4

5��4� jk � jo

��=

Wr vhh krz zh rewdlq wklv h{suhvvlrq/ qrwh wkdw f� +4@5,q5 lv | � j � +4@5,q5 diwhu xvlqj wkhuhvrxufh frqvwudlqw/ | @ f.j= Lpsrvlqj q @ 4�� wkhq |lhogv wkdw f�+4@5,q5 lv +4@5,+4��5,�j=

94Fkdul/ Fkulvwldqr dqg Nhkrh +4<<4, frqiurqw wkh vdph sureohp1 Wkh| ghdo zlwk lw e| vhwwlqjwkh lqlwldo ghew wr }hur1 Lq rxu frqwh{w wkdw fuhdwhv d sureohp ehfdxvh lw ohdyhv xv zlwkrxw dqdelolw| wr slq grzq S=

�.

Page 38: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

Z� AL LM|@�? |��tc UL4M�?i |�i �L�ti�L*_<t �?|ih|i4TLh@* ,�*ih i^�@|�L?c Ee�D�c ��|� |�i}L�ih?4i?|<t M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?|tc Ee�S�G

� � �E�� ��� } n�

2qk��E�� ���� }� n � ,E�� � ,�� },

lc Ee�b�

��ihi �i �@�i �4TLti_ � ' �� A�i hit|h�U|�L?t L? tiUL?_ Tih�L_ Th�Uit @hi LM|@�?i_ uhL4|�i �?|ih|i4TLh@* }L�ih?4i?| M�_}i| i^�@|�L?t |�@| LM|@�? �? |�Lti Tih�L_tG

��E�� ���� }� � fc � ,E�� � ,�� }, � f� Ee��f�

A�i +@4ti) ThLM*i4c 4L_��i_ |L �?ULhTLh@|i |�i hit|h�U|�L?c � ' �c �t ti| �T �? w@}h@?}�@?uLh4 @t uL**L�tG

4@ �c��c� ,

��2 ��

2q����

�2

n�� ,�2�

nb��E�� ��� } n

2qk��E�� ���� }� n � ,E�� � ,�� },

l� �

n>�k��E�� ���� }�

ln >,

k� ,E�� � ,�� },

lc

��ihi bc >�c >, � f @hi w@}h@?}i 4�*|�T*�iht�S2 A�i ?iUitt@h) @?_ t��U�i?| UL?_�|�L?t@ttLU�@|i_ ��|� |�i 4@ �4�4 @hi |�i �?i^�@*�|) UL?t|h@�?|t L? |�i 4�*|�T*�ihtc bc >�c >, � fc|�i �?i^�@*�|) UL?t|h@�?|t �? Ee�b��Ee��f�c |�i �UL4T*i4i?|@h) t*@U!?itt< UL?_�|�L?tG

f ' b��E�� ��� } n

2qk��E�� ���� }� n � ,E�� � ,�� },

l��

�c

f ' >�k��E�� ���� }�

lc Ee����

f ' >,k� ,E�� � ,�� },

lc

@?_ |�i |�hii �ht| Lh_ih UL?_�|�L?t ULhhitTL?_�?} |L �c ��c � ,� �u|ih hi@hh@?}�?}c |�iti @hiG

b '2�

�� 2�c

95Rxu prgho gl�huv iurp Vlpv* +4<<<, prgho lq wzr uhvshfwv1 Iluvw/ rxuv kdv rqo| wzr shulrgv/zkloh Vlpv* prgho kdv dq lq�qlwh krul}rq1 Vhfrqg/ zh prgho djhqwv dw wkh ohyho ri suhihuhqfhvdqg whfkqrorj|/ zkloh Vlpv dgrswv d uhgxfhg irup uhsuhvhqwdwlrq dqdorjrxv wr wkh rqh lq Eduur+4<:<,1 Rxu uhgxfhg irup xwlolw| ixqfwlrq frlqflghv zlwk Vlpv*/ exw rxu exgjhw frqvwudlqw grhvqrw1 Vlpv +4<<<, prghov wd{hv dv oxps vxp wd{hv lq wkh exgjhw frqvwudlqw/ zkhuhdv zh wdnhlqwr dffrxqw wkh glvwruwlrqdu| h�hfwv ri wd{dwlrq1 Iru h{dpsoh/ Vlpv zrxog kdyh � lq wkh exgjhwfrqvwudlqw/ udwkhu wkdq wkh �+4 � �, wkdw dsshduv lq rxuv1 Wkh frqfoxvlrqv ri wkh dqdo|vlv duhqrw vhqvlwlyh wr wkhvh gl�huhqfhv1

�H

Page 39: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

>� ' q

%��

�� 2���

�� 2�

&Ee��2�

>, ' q

%2� ,

�� 2� ,�

2�

�� 2�

&�

i tL*�i |�i EUL?t|h@�?i_� +@4ti) ThLM*i4 M) �?_�?} 4�*|�T*�ihtc bc >�c >,c @?_ TL*�U�itc�c ��c � ,c |�@| t@|�tu) |�iti UL?_�|�L?t�

�?Ui |�i +@4ti) TL*�U�it �@�i Mii? �_i?|��i_c ?c ?�c ?, @hi LM|@�?i_ uhL4 Ee�D� @?_ ScS�c S, @hi LM|@�?i_ uhL4 Ee�.�� A�i?c ��c � � @?_ � , @hi LM|@�?i_ M) tL*��?} Ee�S�� 5i�ih@*^�@*�|@|��i ui@|�hit Lu |�i tL*�|�L? @hi �44i_�@|i*) @TT@hi?|� 6�ht|c |�i �i@! �?i^�@*�|) �?Ee�b� �t t@|�t�i_ @t @ t|h�U| i^�@*�|)�S� A��t �t ?L| t�hTh�t�?}� Wu �| �ihi L|�ih��tic |�i? |@ it�L�*_ Mi ��}�ih |�@? ?iUitt@h) @?_c }��i? |�i uLh4 Lu Thiuihi?Uitc |��t �t UL�?|ihThL_�U|��i��*tLc |�i u@U| |�@| |�i Tih�L_ f �?|ih|i4TLh@* M�_}i| i^�@|�L? �t t@|�t�i_ @t @ t|h�U| i^�@*�|)4i@?t |�@| �| �L�*_ �@�i Mii? LT|�4@* |L �?�@|i @�@) |�i �?�|�@* _iM| M) ti||�?} � '4c �u�i �@_ ?L| �4TLti_ |�i hi^��hi4i?| |�@| |�i }L�ih?4i?| T@) Lg � ��|� � ' ��Se 5iUL?_c�}?Lh�?} |�i hi^��hi4i?|t �4TLti_ M) |�i ?L?�?i}@|���|) UL?t|h@�?|t L? Th�Uit �? |�i tiUL?_Tih�L_c |�i? |�i LT|�4@* L�|UL4i �t � ' �� ' � ,� AL tii |��tc ?L|i |�@| |�i �ht| Lh_ihUL?_�|�L?t �? |��t U@ti @hi Ee��2� ��|� >� � >, � f� A�i?c �| �t LM��L�t M) �?tTiU|�?} |�itiUL?_ |�L i^�@|�L?t �? Ee�S� |�@| � � : � , @t *L?} @t }� : },� A��h_c �? Th@U|�Ui |�iUL?t|@?| |@ h@|i TL*�U) �t ?L| ?iUitt@h�*) ui@t�M*ic t�?Ui �| 4@) UL?��U| ��|� |�i hi^��hi4i?||�@| Th�Uit Mi TLt�|��i� ��|c �? |��t U@tic |�i Th�Ui ��U|�@|�L?t @UhLtt t|@|it Lu ?@|�hi @hii�i? 4Lhi i |hi4i� 5�TTLtic uLh i @4T*ic |�@| |�i UL?t|@?| |@ h@|i TL*�U) �t �?UL?t�t|i?|��|� |�i �ht| Lu |�i |�L �?i^�@*�|�it �? Ee��f�� A�i?c >� : f @?_ �� : � @?_c M) Ee����c��E������}� ' f� A�i *@||ih �4T*�it |�@| |�i }L�ih?4i?| �?�@|it @�@) |�i _iM| UL4T*i|i*)�? t|@|i �c ��|� � � '4� AL i?t�hi |�@| �L�ti�L*_t t|�** �@�i @? �?Ui?|��i �? |�i �ht| Tih�L_|L @UU�4�*@|i _iM|c Ee�D� �?_�U@|it |�@| � , 4�t| t@|�tu) � , ' Eq*2�� E� n -� ' q*2 �? |��tU@ti� A�@| �tc |�i hi@* h@|i Lu hi|�h? L? _iM| �?|L t|@|i , 4�t| Mi ��}��

96Khuh lv d surri e| frqwudglfwlrq1 Wkxv/ vxssrvh wkh zhdn lqhtxdolw| lq +71<, zhuh d vwulfwlqhtxdolw|1 Wkhq/ e| wkh �uvw h{suhvvlrq lq hdfk ri +7144, dqg +7145,/ zh kdyh � @ 3 dqg� @ 3= Wkh vwulfw lqhtxdolw| lq +71<, wkhq lpsolhv wkdw dw ohdvw rqh ri wkh zhdn lqhtxdolwlhv lq+7143, lv vwulfw1 Wkdw lpsolhv/ e| +7144,/ wkdw wkh dvvrfldwhg pxowlsolhu lv }hur1 Exw wkhq/ +7145,lpsolhv wkdw wkh dvvrfldwhg wd{ udwh lv }hur1 Exw/ wklv frqwudglfwv wkdw wkh sulpdu| vxusoxv lvqrq0qhjdwlyh lq wkdw shulrg1

97Lq wkdw fdvh/ wkh frqvwudlqw zrxog kdyh ehhq +7144, zlwkrxw wkh whup/ �E=

�b

Page 40: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

e��� � ��4ih�U@* , @4T*i

A��t tiU|�L? t|�_�it @ ?�4ih�U@* i @4T*i |L �**�t|h@|i |�i ThLTih|�it Lu � � @?_ � , �? |�i+@4ti) i^��*�Mh��4� � ?@|�h@* Mi?U�4@h! |L UL?t�_ih �t |�i ?L _iM| i^��*�Mh��4G |�i L?i�? ���U� � �t ti*iU|i_ tL |�@| �� ' f @?_ �� @?_ � , @hi ti*iU|i_ tL |�i UL?t|h@�?|t �? Ee��f�@hi t@|�t�i_ @t i @U| i^�@*�|�it� `�|� |��t @t @ Mi?U�4@h!c �i |�i? 4L�i L? |L i�@*�@|i |�i+@4ti) i^��*�Mh��4 �? ���U� �� : f @?_ |L UL?t�_ih � � @?_ � ,�

AL tii �L� |@ it @hi _i|ih4�?i_ �? |�i Mi?U�4@h! i^��*�Mh��4c UL?t�_ih 6�}�hi e� A�@|}h@T�t �? ' �E� � �� uLh � 5 Efc ��� �L|i |�@| �i �@�i @ t�?}*i�Ti@!i_ w@gih U�h�i �?L�h 4L_i* iUL?L4)� A�i �Lh�3L?|@* *�?it �?_�U@|i |�i hi�i?�i hi^��hi4i?|t �? |�i �ht| @?_tiUL?_ Tih�L_t� i �@�i @tt�4i_ |�@| |�i �ht| Tih�L_ hi�i?�i hi^��hi4i?|c � n }c �t f�2f�A�i tiUL?_ Tih�L_ hi�i?�i hi^��hi4i?| �t }� ' f��D ��i? }L�ih?4i?| tTi?_�?} �t ��}� @?_}, ' f�fD ��i? }L�ih?4i?| tTi?_�?} �t *L�� A�i Mi?U�4@h! i^��*�Mh��4 hi^��hit |�@| � c�� @?_ � , Mi ti| @t �?_�U@|i_ L? |�i �Lh�3L?|@* @ �t� W? T@h|�U�*@hc � ' f�2Hc �� ' f��H @?_� , ' f�fDc @u|ih hL�?_�?}� A�i �@*�i Lu Ee�H� �? |��t i^��*�Mh��4 �t �f�fbe�c �}?Lh�?} V @?_ti||�?} q ' f�b.� �L|i �L� �ih) �?i�i? |�i |@ h@|it @hi L�ih |�4i @?_ L�ih t|@|it Lu ?@|�hi�

�L� UL?t�_ih |�i +@4ti) |@ h@|it� i ThLUii_ �?_ih |�i UL?�iU|�hic t�Mti^�i?|*)�ih��i_c |�@| |�i) @hi LT|�4@**) U�Lti? |L Mi @ UL?t|@?|c � Wc @UhLtt _@|it @?_ t|@|it� i @*tL�ti |�i u@U|c it|@M*�t�i_ �? |�i Thi��L�t t�MtiU|�L?c |�@| |�i UL?t|h@�?|c Ee�b�c �t M�?_�?}�A�ihi @hi |�L UL?t|@?| |@ h@|it |�@| tL*�i Ee�b� i�@*�@|i_ @t @ t|h�U| i^�@*�|)� B��i?Thiuihi?Uitc Ee�H�c �i }L ��|� |�i *L�ih L?ic � W ' f��bc @u|ih hL�?_�?}� AL �ih�u) |�@| |��ttL*�it |�i +@4ti) ThLM*i4c �i ?ii_ |L UL?�h4 |�@| Ee��f� @hi t@|�t�i_� W?_ii_ |�i) @hic��|� �WE�� �W�� }� ' f�fffH @?_ � WE�� � W�� }, ' f��f�

5L*��?} |�i �ht| i Thitt�L? �? Ee�S�c �i �?_ |�@| �� ' f�fD� W? @__�|�L?c �i �?_ uhL4 |�itiUL?_ |�L i Thitt�L?t �? Ee�S� |�@| � � ' Se�S. @?_ � , ' f�eb� ,tti?|�@**)c |�i }L�ih?4i?|hi?i}t L? |�i _iM| �? Tih�L_ � @?_ T@)t @? @||h@U|��i �ffI h@|i Lu hi|�h? �? t|@|i ,� 6�?@**)c|�i �|�*�|) Lu |��t i^��*�Mh��4 �t �f�fS.e� A�i hit�*|t ��t| _itUh�Mi_c T*�t |�i UL?t�4T|�L?@?_ *@MLh @**LU@|�L?t @hi t�44@h�3i_ �? A@M*i �� A�i !i) |��?} |L ?L|i �t |�@| M) �tt��?}_iM|c �| �t TLtt�M*i |L t|@M�*�3i i4T*L)4i?| @?_ UL?t�4T|�L? @UhLtt _@|it� �) �tt��?} |�i_iM| �? ?L4�?@* |ih4tc @?_ @**L��?} |�i Th�Ui *i�i* |L ��U|�@|ic �| �t TLtt�M*i |L 4@!i |�iT@)Lg L? |�@| _iM| t|@|i UL?|�?}i?|c �? hi@* |ih4t�

ef

Page 41: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

A@M*i �G A�L ,^��*�Mh�@V@h�@M*i �i?U�4@h!c �L #iM| E�� ' f� +@4ti)� � �� � �� Se�S.� , �� f�eb? f�.2 f�H2?� f�H2 f�H2?, f�bD f�H2S f�D2 f�S2S� f�S. f�S.S, f�bf f�..� f�2H f��b�� f��H f��b� , f�fD f��b} n� f�2f f�2f}� f��D f��D}, f�fD f�fD�� f�f f�fD�|�*�|) �f�fbe� �f�fS.e�L|iG �� � �?L| @TT*�U@M*i<�

e�e� 5�44@h)

i �@�i _itUh�Mi_ @ 4L_i* �? ���U� �| �t T@h| Lu @? i�U�i?| �tU@* ThL}h@4 |L �tt�i ?L4�?@*_iM| @?_ |�i? @**L� |�i Th�Ui *i�i* |L ��U|�@|i� �*|�L�}� �i _i4L?t|h@|i_ |��t �?_�?}�? @? iUL?L4) ��|� ?L }L�ih?4i?|�ThL��_i_ 4L?i)c |��t ui@|�hi Lu L�h 4L_i* T*@)t ?Lu�?_@4i?|@* hL*i �? |�i hit�*|� A�i t@4i hit�*| �@t LM|@�?i_ �? ��@h�c ��h�t|�@?L @?_ki�Li E�bb�� @?_ LL_uLh_ E�bbH� �t�?} 4L_i*t �? ���U� |�ihi �t 4L?i)�

W? L�h 4L_i*c |�i i^��*�Mh��4 �t i^���@*i?| |L L?i �? ���U� |�i }L�ih?4i?| �tt�it _iM| �?|�i �ht| Tih�L_ ��Lti T@)Lg �t _i?L4�?@|i_ �? hi@* |ih4tc @?_ ��ihi |�i T@)Lg �t i T*�U�|*)UL?|�?}i?| L? |�i hi@*�3@|�L? Lu }L�ih?4i?| tTi?_�?} �? |�i tiUL?_ Tih�L_�SD `�i? tii?uhL4 |��t TihtTiU|��ic |�i ?@|�h@* ^�it|�L? |L @t! �tc ���) ?L| ��t| �ti |�i t|@|i UL?|�?}i?|_iM| t|h@|i})c h@|�ih |�@? }L |L |�i |hL�M*i Lu �tt��?} ?L4�?@* _iM| @?_ @**L� |�i t|@|iUL?|�?}i?U) |L @h�ti MiU@�ti Lu ��U|�@|�L?t �? |�i Th�Ui *i�i*q<

AL @__hitt |��t ^�it|�L?c L?i ?ii_t |L �?�L!i UL?t�_ih@|�L?t |�@| @hi ?L| �? |�i 4L_i*��?i TL|i?|�@* @_�@?|@}i Lu |�i ?L4�?@* _iM| t|h@|i}) �t |�@| �| �t *�!i*) |L �@�i *L�ih ULt|t

98Oxfdv dqg Vwrnh| +4<;6, hpskdvl}hg wkh ghvludelolw| ri wklv w|sh ri ghew1

e�

Page 42: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

Lu @_4�?�t|h@|�L? @?_ �?uLh4@|�L? @U^��t�|�L?� A��t �t MiU@�ti |�i @TThLTh�@|i hitTL?ti Lu|�i hi@* T@)Lg L? |�i _iM| |L t�LU!t �t @U��i�i_ @�|L4@|�U@**) @t @ M)�ThL_�U| Lu |�i Th�Ui��U|�@|�L?t }i?ih@|i_ �? |�i 4@h!i| U*i@h�?} ThLUitt E5�4t E�bbb�c LL_uLh_ E�bbH���

��|c |�ihi @hi hi@tL?t |�@| |��t 4@) ThL��_i @? L�ih*) LT|�4�t|�U ��i� L? |�i ?L4�?@*_iM| t|h@|i})� 6Lh i @4T*ic �u |�ihi @hi tL4i t|�U!) Th�Uitc |�i? ��U|�@|�L?t �? |�i Th�Ui*i�i* UL�*_ _�t|Lh| hitL�hUi @**LU@|�L?t� W? @__�|�L?c Th�Ui �L*@|�*�|) 4@) �?|ihuihi ��|� Th��@|iUL?|h@U|t M) �?_�U�?} hi@**LU@|�L?t Lu �i@*|� @4L?} Th��@|i @}i?|t� �hit�4@M*)c @ �iht�L?Lu |�i +@4ti) ThLM*i4 ���U� �?ULhTLh@|it |�Lti ULt|t �L�*_ t|�** i ��M�| Th�Ui ��U|�@|�L?t���|c |�Lti ��U|�@|�L?t @hi *�!i*) |L Mi t4@**ih�SS A�i �?uLh4@|�L? ThLM*i4 Lu _it�}?�?} @�tU@* t)t|i4 ���U� ThLTih*) M@*@?Ui_ Mi?i�|t @?_ ULt|t �L�*_ Thit�4@M*) Mi �ih) }hi@|chi_�U�?} |�i ULt| @_�@?|@}it Lu |�i ?L4�?@* _iM| t|h@|i}) |�@| �i @**�_i_ |L @ML�i�

A�ihi �t @?L|�ih hi@tL? |L ^�it|�L? |�i @_�@?|@}it Lu ML|� |�i ?L4�?@* @?_ hi@*�t|@|iUL?|�?}i?| _iM| t|h@|i}�it� N?*itt |�i }L�ih?4i?| �@t t�Mt|@?|�@* @M�*�|) |L UL44�| |L �|tTL*�U�itc i�|�ih t|h@|i}) UL�*_ �ih) �i** M@U!�hi� A��t TLtt�M�*�|) U@? Mi tii? �? |�i i @4T*i�+iU@** �L� �i TL�?|i_ L�| |�@| �| �t i�U�i?| �? |�i �ht| Tih�L_ uLh |�i }L�ih?4i?| |L �?�@|i@�@) |�i _iM|� ��|c ?L|i |�@| ��i? |�4i 4L�it uLh�@h_ L?i Tih�L_c |�i? |�i tiUL?_ Tih�L_MiUL4it |�i �ht| Tih�L_� `�i? |�@| |�4i @hh��itc �| �t @}@�? �? |�i }L�ih?4i?|<t �?|ihit| |L�?�@|i @�@) |�i _iM|- OL�ti�L*_t ��L �?_iht|@?_ |��t �? |�i �ht| Tih�L_ 4@) �i** U�LLti?L| |L @UU�4�*@|i @?) _iM| �? |�i �ht| T*@Ui�S. �L�c |��t U@ti �@t i U*�_i_ �? L�h @?@*)t�tMiU@�ti Lu |�i @tt�4T|�L? |�@| TL*�U) �t ?L?�+�U@h_�@?G |�i TL*�U) �t ��t| @ ti^�i?Ui Lu?�4Miht E|@ h@|it� |�hL�}� |�4ic @?_ |�i TLtt�M�*�|) Lu @_��t|�?} |�i4 i TLt| �t h�*i_ L�|���|c �t |��t @ hi@*�t|�U @tt�4T|�L?q #Lit �| @tt�4i |�@| }L�ih?4i?|t �@�i 4Lhi UL44�|4i?|TL�ih |�@? |�i) @U|�@**) �@�iq A�i *�|ih@|�hi L? +@4ti) TL*�U) �@t }i?ih@**) UL?U*�_i_

99Lw zrxog eh yhu| lqwhuhvwlqj wr lqyhvwljdwh wklv txhvwlrq lq txdqwlwdwlyh prghov1 Wkhuh lvd srvvlelolw| wkdw wkh h�flhqw ghjuhh ri yrodwlolw| lq sulfhv zrxog eh uhgxfhg wr }hur li sulfhyrodwlolw| lqwurgxfhg glvwruwlrqv1 Fkdul/ Fkulvwldqr dqg Nhkrh +4<<7, dujxh wkdw lq sulqflsohwkhuh lv d ydulhw| ri zd|v wr dfklhyh vwdwh0frqwlqjhqf| lq �vfdo srolf|1 Li wkhuh zhuh frvwv wrxvlqj wkh sulfh ohyho iru wklv/ wkhq wkh h�flhqw wklqj wr gr zrxog eh wr xvh rqh ri wkh rwkhuzd|v1 Rqo| li wkhuh zhuh frvwv dvvrfldwhg zlwk doo zd|v ri dfklhylqj vwdwh0frqwlqjhqf| lq �vfdosrolf|/ zrxog vrph yrodwlolw| lq sulfhv eh ghvludeoh1

9:D uhfhqw sdshu e| Vlpv +4<<<, frqvlghuv d sursrvdo wkdw Ph{lfr dgrsw wkh XV groodu dv lwvqdwlrqdo fxuuhqf|1 Kh fulwlfl}hv wkh sursrvdo rq wkh jurxqgv wkdw/ zlwk wkh Ph{lfdq qdwlrqdo ghewghqrplqdwhg lq dqrwkhu fxuuhqf|/ wkh Ph{lfdq jryhuqphqw orvhv wkh �vfdo ehqh�wv ri wkh srolf|ghvfulehg lq wkh wh{w1 Wkdw lv/ lw zrxog qrw eh deoh wr shulrglfdoo| uhqhjh rq dqg shulrglfdoo|vxevlgl}h kroghuv ri lwv ghew wkurxjk �xfwxdwlrqv lq wkh Ph{lfdq sulfh ohyho1 Rxu srlqw khuh lvwkdw jlylqj xs wklv rswlrq pd| qrw eh yhu| frvwo| wr Ph{lfr/ li wkh Ph{lfdq jryhuqphqw odfnvfuhglelolw|1 Lqghhg/ jlylqj xs wkh rswlrq pd| eh d jrrg wklqj1 Lq wkh devhqfh ri fuhglelolw|/dwwhpswv wr xvh wkh rswlrq pd| ohdg wr wkh glvdvwhurxv vlwxdwlrq lq zklfk hyhu|rqh mxvw uhixvhvwr ex| Ph{lfdq jryhuqphqw ghew1

e2

Page 43: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

|�@| |�i @?t�ih �t �)it<c @?_ �@t 4L�i_ L? |L i^��*�Mh��4 UL?UiT|t |�@| _L ?L| Thit�4i tL4�U� UL44�|4i?| TL�ih�

��|c �? Th�?U�T*i L?i U@? @*tL 4@!i |�i U@ti |�@| |�i _i}hii Lu UL44�|4i?| ?ii_i_uLh |�i TL*�U) |L �Lh! �t ?L| �4T*@�t�M*) *@h}i� A��t 4�}�| Mi tL �u |�i hi^��hi_ Th�Ui��U|�@|�L?t LUU�hhi_ @�|L4@|�U@**)c �? @ �@) |�@| *i}�t*@|�hit �@�i _��U�*|) �?|ihuih�?}��|�� 6Lh i @4T*ic a�__ E�bHb� �@t t�}}it|i_ |�@| Th�Ui 4L�i4i?|t �? |�i N5 iUL?L4)ULhhitTL?_ hL�}�*) |L ��@| @? i�U�i?| �tU@* ThL}h@4 hi^��hit� Oi ?L|it |�@| }LL_ t�LU!t|L |�i }L�ih?4i?| M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?|c *�!i |iU�?L*L}) t�LU!tc |i?_ |L ThL_�Ui @ ?i}@|��it�LU! |L |�i Th�Ui *i�i*c }i?ih@|�?} |h@?tuiht |L �L*_iht Lu }L�ih?4i?| ML?_t� 5�4�*@h*)c M@_t�LU!t *�!i @ ��4T �? }L�ih?4i?| tTi?_�?} _�i |L �@h Lh ?@|�h@* _�t@t|ihc |i?_ |L _h��i |�iTh�Ui *i�i* �Tc |@ �?} }L�ih?4i?| ML?_ �L*_iht�

5Lc L�h TL�?| �t ?L| |�@| |�i _i}hii Lu UL44�|4i?| hi^��hi_ uLh |�i �L*@|�*i Th�Ui t|h@|i})�t ?iUitt@h�*) |LL }hi@|� ��h TL�?| �t L?*) |�@| UL44�|4i?| �t @ u�?_@4i?|@* @tt�4T|�L? Lu|�i �L*@|�*i Th�Ui t|h@|i})� W? |�i @Mti?Ui Lu UL44�|4i?|c |�i t|h@|i}) �t *�!i*) |L M@U!�hi�

D� �L?U*�t�L?

`�@| �?t�}�|t _Lit |�i 6A�w ThL��_i �?|L |�i |�L ^�it|�L?t @ML�| Th�Ui t|@M�*�|) U�|i_ @||�i Mi}�??�?} Lu |��t T@Tihq �L?�i?|�L?@* ��t_L4 �L*_t |�@| �u |�ihi �t ?L _L�M| @ML�||�i Ui?|h@* M@?!<t UL44�|4i?| |L *L� @?_ t|@M*i �?�@|�L?c |�i? |�@| �t ��@| ��** �@TTi?�SH

�UULh_�?} |L |�i 6A�wc |��t L�iht|@|it |�i UL?|hL* |�@| @ Ui?|h@* M@?! @U|�@**) �@t� 5|�**c�| hi4@�?t @? LTi? ^�it|�L? ��t| �L� ti�ihi |�i *�4�|@|�L?t L? |�i Ui?|h@* M@?!<t TL�ih@hi� W| �t TLtt�M*i |�@| |�iti *�4�|@|�L?t @hi ?L| �ih) }hi@| uLh 4L_ih? _i�i*LTi_ iUL?L4�it�W? |�i 6A�w 4L_i*t |�@| �i t|�_�i_c |�i Ui?|h@* M@?! U@? _i|ih4�?i |�i @�ih@}i h@|i Lu�?�@|�L?� W| �t |�i �@h�@?Ui Lu �?�@|�L? |�@| �| U@??L| TihuiU|*) UL?|hL*� A�i ThLM*i4 �t |�@|�| U@??L| i*�4�?@|i |�i �4T@U| L? |�i Th�Ui *i�i* Lu t�LU!t |L �tU@* TL*�U)� ��|c �? @ 4L_ih?it|ih? iUL?L4) |�i t|LU! Lu L�|t|@?_�?} ?L4�?@* }L�ih?4i?| *�@M�*�|�it �t ^��|i *@h}i �

a�__<t E�bHb� it|�4@|i uLh |�i N5 T�|t �| @| L?i )i@h<t B#�� A��t 4i@?t |�@| @ hi*@|��i*)t4@** U�@?}i �? |�i Th�Ui *i�i* U@? @MtLhM @ u@�h*) *@h}i �tU@* TL*�U) t�LU!�Sb 5Lc �? Th@U|�Ui�| 4@) Mi |�@| |�i UL?�i?|�L?@* @?t�ih |L |�i �ht| ^�it|�L? 4@) Mi hL�}�*) |�i h�}�| L?ici�i? �?_ih |�i 6A�w�

+i}@h_�?} |�i tiUL?_ ^�it|�L?c 5�4t E�bbb� �@t t|hitti_ |�i TL|i?|�@* Mi?i�|t Lu Th�Ui�L*@|�*�|)�.f V@h�@|�L?t �? |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �? hitTL?ti |L �tU@* t�LU!t �@�i |�i igiU| Lu |@ �?}

9;Vhh Vdujhqw dqg Zdoodfh +4<;9,/ odvw sdudjudsk19<Wklv srlqw kdv dovr ehhq vwuhvvhg e| Vlpv +4<<<,1:3Zrrgirug +4<<;, kdv pdgh d vlplodu vxjjhvwlrq1 Wkh uhvxow kdv dovr ehhq rewdlqhg lq Fkdul/

Fkulvwldqr dqg Nhkrh +4<<4,1

e�

Page 44: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

�L*_iht Lu ?L4�?@* }L�ih?4i?| *�@M�*�|�it� N?_ih Uih|@�? U�hU�4t|@?Uitc |��t U@? Mi �ti_|L i?�@?Ui |�i L�ih@** i�U�i?U) Lu }L�ih?4i?| �tU@* @?_ 4L?i|@h) TL*�U)� ��|c |��t hit�*|@*tL h@�tit ^�it|�L?t� W| �t LM|@�?i_ uLh @? i?��hL?4i?| ��|� ui� Lu |�i uh�U|�L?t LMtih�i_�? @U|�@* iUL?L4�itc |�@| 4@!i Th�Ui �L*@|�*�|) ULt|*)� `�i|�ih |�i hit�*| �L�*_ t�h���i|�i �?|hL_�U|�L? Lu @ hi@*�t|�U ti| Lu uh�U|�L?tc @?_ @ hi@*�t|�U ti| Lu @*|ih?@|��i 4i|�L_t uLh_i@*�?} ��|� �tU@* t�LU!t �t �?U*i@h @| |��t |�4i�

ee

Page 45: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

+iuihi?Uit

d�o �*M@?it�c 5|iu@?�@c V�V� ��@h� @?_ w@�hi?Ui a� ��h�t|�@?Lc �bbbc �OL� ��}�t |�i A�4i �L?t�t|i?U) �hLM*i4 �? �L?i|@h) �L*�U)q<c 4@?�tUh�T|�

d2o �|!itL?c �?_hi�c V�V� ��@h� @?_ �@|h�U! ki�Lic �bbbc �A@ �?} �@T�|@* W?�UL4iG � �@_ W_i@c< 6i_ih@* +itih�i �@?! Lu ��??i@TL*�t "�@h|ih*) +i��i�c�L*� 2�c ?L� �c t�44ihc TT� ���.�

d�o �@hhLc +LMih| a�c �b.ec ��hi BL�ih?4i?| �L?_t �i| i@*|�qc< aL�h?@* Lu

�L*�|�U@* ,UL?L4)c H2 ES�c TT� �fbD����.�

deo �@hhLc +LMih| a�c �b.bc ��? |�i #i|ih4�?@|�L? Lu |�i BL�ih?4i?| #iM|c<aL�h?@* Lu �L*�|�U@* ,UL?L4)c H. EDGT@h| ��c bef�b.��

dDo �@hhLc +LMih| a�c @?_ #@��_ �� BLh_L?c �bH�c �� �Lt�|��i A�iLh) Lu �L?i�|@h) �L*�U) �? @ �@|�h@* +@|i �L_i*c< aL�h?@* Lu �L*�|�U@* ,UL?L4) b� E���}�t|�G DHb�S�f�

dSo �@tti||Lc �@hULc 2fffc �W?�@|�L?c ,^��*�Mh��4 @?_ BL�ih?4i?| �L44�|�4i?|c< 4@?�tUh�T|c �Lh|��it|ih? N?��iht�|)�

d.o �i?�@M�M aittc 5|iT�@?�i 5U�4�||�BhL�i @?_ �@h|�? Nh�Mic 2fffc ���L�_�?}w�^��_�|) Ah@Ttc< 4@?�tUh�T|�

dHo ��3ihc #@��_ 5�c @?_ ki??i|� a�__c �bHbc �A@ @|�L? @?_ N?Uih|@�?|)c< �4ih�

�U@? ,UL?L4�U +i��i�c .b E2�c ������S�

dbo �hLU!c `�**�@4 ��c �b.Dc �� 5�4T*i �ihuiU| 6Lhit�}�| �L?i|@h) �L_i*c< aL�h�?@* Lu �L?i|@h) ,UL?L4�Ut �G �����Df�

d�fo ���|ihc `�**i4 O�c �bbbc �A�i 6@**@U) Lu |�i 6�tU@* A�iLh) Lu |�i �h�Ui wi�i*c<�?T�M*�t�i_ 4@?�tUh�T|c #iUi4Mih �fc �@?! Lu ,?}*@?_�

d��o �@*�Lc B��**ih4Lc �b.Hc ��? |�i A�4i �L?t�t|i?U) Lu �T|�4@* �L*�U) �? @�L?i|@h) ,UL?L4)c< ,UL?L4i|h�U@c VL*� eSc �L� Sc �e����e2S�

d�2o �@?3L?ih�c �@||�i� ��c +LMih| ,� ��4M)c �i�3@_ A� #�M@c �bb.c �Wt |�i�h�Ui wi�i* #i|ih4�?i_ M) |�i �ii_t Lu 6�tU@* 5L*�i?U)q<c Lh!�?} �@TihcBiLh}i|L�? N?��iht�|)�

eD

Page 46: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

d��o �@h*t|hL4c ��@h*it A�c @?_ A�4L|�) 6�iht|c �bbHc �+i@* W?_i|ih4�?@U) �?�L?i|@h) �L_i*t ��|� �L4�?@* W?|ihit| +@|i #�t|Lh|�L?tG A�i �hLM*i4 ��|�W?�@|�L? A@h}i|tc< 6i_ih@* +itih�i �@?! Lu �*i�i*@?_ Lh!�?} �@Tih bH�H�

d�eo �@h*t|hL4c ��@h*it A�c @?_ A�4L|�) 6�iht|c 2fffc �A�i 6�tU@* A�iLh) Lu |�i�h�Ui wi�i*c< 6i_ih@* +itih�i �@?! Lu �*i�i*@?_ ,UL?L4�U +i��i�c uLh|�UL4��?}�

d�Do ��@h�c V�V�c w@�hi?Ui a� ��h�t|�@?Lc @?_ �@|h�U! ki�Lic �bb�c ��T|�4@*6�tU@* @?_ �L?i|@h) �L*�U)G 5L4i +iUi?| +it�*|t<c aL�h?@* Lu �L?i)c �hi_�|

@?_ �@?!�?}c �L*� 2�c ?L� �c ��}�t|�

d�So ��@h�c V�V�c @?_ �@|h�U! ki�Lic �bbfc �5�t|@�?@M*i �*@?tc< aL�h?@* Lu �L*�|��U@* ,UL?L4)c bHc TT� .H��Hf2�

d�.o ��@h�c V�V�c @?_ �@|h�U! ki�Lic �bbbc �6hii +�_�?} �hLM*i4t �? @ �L?i|@h)N?�L?c< �Lh!�?} T@Tihc N?��iht�|) Lu ��??itL|@�

d�Ho ��h�t|�@?Lc w@�hi?Ui a�c �bH.c �`�) Wt �L?t�4T|�L? witt VL*@|�*i A�@?W?UL4iq< 6i_ih@* +itih�i �@?! Lu ��??i@TL*�t "�@h|ih*) +i��i��

d�bo ��h�t|�@?Lc w@�hi?Ui a�c @?_ ��h�t|LT�ih B�t|c 2fff@c �A�i Bhi@| W?�@|�L?Lu |�i �b.ftc< 4@?�tUh�T|�

d2fo ��h�t|�@?Lc w@�hi?Ui a�c @?_ ��h�t|LT�ih B�t|c 2fffMc �A�i , TiU|@|�L?tAh@T O)TL|�it�tc< 6i_ih@* +itih�i �@?! Lu ���U@}L ,UL?L4�U �ihtTiU|��itcuLh|�UL4�?}�

d2�o ��h�t|�@?Lc w@�hi?Ui a�c �@h|�? ,�U�i?M@�4 @?_ ��@h*it ,�@?tc �bbHc ��L_�i*�?} �L?i)c< �@|�L?@* ��hi@� Lu ,UL?L4�U +iti@hU� Lh!�?} �@Tih ?�4MihS�.��

d22o �LU�h@?ic aL�?c �bbHc �� 6h�U|�L?*itt V�i� Lu N5 W?�@|�L?c< ��,+ �@UhLi�

UL?L4�Ut �??�@* �bbHc �WA �hittc TT� �2���He�

d2�o �LU�h@?ic aL�?c �bbbc �wL?}�Aih4 #iM| @?_ �T|�4@* �L*�U) �? |�i 6�tU@*A�iLh) Lu |�i �h�Ui wi�i*c< 4@?�tUh�T|c a�?i �S�

d2eo �LU�h@?ic aL�?c 2fffc ��L?i) @t 5|LU!G �h�Ui wi�i* #i|ih4�?@|�L? `�|��L �L?i) #i4@?_c< �@|�L?@* ��hi@� Lu ,UL?L4�U +iti@hU� Lh!�?} �@Tih.ebH�

eS

Page 47: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

d2Do �*@h�_@c +�U�@h_c aLh_� B@*� @?_ �@h! Bih|*ihc �bbHc ��L?i|@h) �L*�U) +�*it@?_ �@UhLiUL?L4�U 5|@M�*�|)G ,��_i?Ui @?_ 5L4i A�iLh)c< �@|�L?@* ��hi@�Lu ,UL?L4�U +iti@hU� Lh!�?} �@Tih See2�

d2So #�TLhc ��**c 2fffc �, U�@?}i +@|it @?_ |�i 6�tU@* A�iLh) Lu |�i �h�Ui wi�i*c<aL�h?@* Lu �L?i|@h) ,UL?L4�Utc uLh|�UL4�?}�

d2.o Bhii?c ,_�@h_ a�c @?_ +LMih| O� �Lh|ihc �bHec ��L?��LLTih@|��i �L**�t�L?N?_ih W4TihuiU| �h�Ui W?uLh4@|�L?c< ,UL?L4i|h�U@c D2 E��c TT� H.��ff�

d2Ho O@)@t��c 6�4�Lc �bHbc �Wt a@T@?<t 5@��?} +@|i O�}�q<c 6i_ih@* +itih�i �@?!Lu ��??i@TL*�t "�@h|ih*) +i��i�c 5Th�?}c VL*� �� �L� 2�

d2bo Whi*@?_c �i|ih ��c �bbHc �#Lit |�i A�4i��L?t�t|i?U) �hLM*i4 , T*@�? |�i�i�@��Lh Lu W?�@|�L? �? |�i N?�|i_ 5|@|itqc< 4@?�tUh�T|c #iT@h|4i?| Lu ,UL�?L4�Utc �Lt|L? �L**i}i�

d�fo a�__c ki??i|�c �bHbc ��T|�4@* A@ @|�L? �? #)?@4�Uc 5|LU�@t|�U ,UL?L4�itGA�iLh) @?_ ,��_i?Uic< �?T�M*�t�i_ 4@?�tUh�T|c OLL�ih W?t|�|�|�L?c 5|@?uLh_N?��iht�|)�

d��o kLU�ih*@!L|@c �@h@)@?@c @?_ ��h�t|LT�ih ��i*@?c �bbbc �, T*@�?�?} |�i 6�t�U@* A�iLh) Lu |�i �h�Ui wi�i*c< 6i_ih@* +itih�i �@?! Lu ��??i@TL*�t"�@h|ih*)

+i��i�c �L*� 2�c ?L� ec 6@**c TT� �e�2��

d�2o k)_*@?_c 6�?? ,�c @?_ ,_�@h_ �� �hitUL||c �b..c �+�*it +@|�ih A�@? #�t�Uhi|�L?G A�i W?UL?t�t|i?U) Lu �T|�4@* �*@?tc< aL�h?@* Lu �L*�|�U@* ,UL?L4)c�L*� HDc ?L� �c a�?ic T@}it e.��b��

d��o wiiTihc ,h�Uc �bb�c �,^��*�Mh�@ N?_ih �U|��i @?_ �@tt��i �L?i|@h) @?_ 6�tU@*�L*�U�itc< aL�h?@* Lu �L?i|@h) ,UL?L4�Ut 2.G �2b��e.�

d�eo wL)Lc ,_�@h_Lc �bbbc �A�}�| �L?i) �@h@_L L? |�i wLLtiG � 6�tU@*�t| O)Tih��?�@|�L?c< �?T�M*�t�i_ 4@?�tUh�T|c ki??i_) 5U�LL* Lu BL�ih?4i?|c O@h�@h_N?��iht�|)�

d�Do w�U@tc +LMih| ,�c ah�c �bbfc �5�TT*)�5�_i ,UL?L4�UtG �? �?@*)|�U@* +i��i�c<� uLh_ ,UL?L4�U �@Tihtc e2 E2�c �Th�*c TT� 2b����S�

d�So w�U@tc +LMih| ,�c ah�c @?_ �@?U) 5|L!i)c �bH�c ��T|�4@* 6�tU@* @?_ �L?i|@h)�L*�U) �? @? ,UL?L4) `�|�L�| �@T�|@*c< aL�h?@* Lu �L?i|@h) ,UL?L4�Utc �2cDD�b��

e.

Page 48: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

d�.o �@|t�)@4@c k�4�?Lh�c �bb�c �,?_L}i?L�t �h�Ui 6*�U|�@|�L?t �? @? �T|��4�3�?} �L_i* Lu @ �L?i|@h) ,UL?L4)c< ,UL?L4i|h�U@ �L*� Dbc ?L� Sc TT��S�.��S���

d�Ho �U�@**�4c �i??i|| A�c �bb.c ��h�U�@* Wtt�it �L?Uih?�?} �i?|h@* �@?! W?_i�Ti?_i?Uic< aL�h?@* Lu �L?i|@h) ,UL?L4�Ut �bc a�?ic TT� bb���2�

d�bo �U�@**�4c �i??i|| A�c �bbHc �W?_i|ih4�?@U)c ��MM*it @?_ |�i 6�tU@* A�iLh)Lu |�i �h�Ui wi�i*c< �@|�L?@* ��hi@� Lu ,UL?L4�U +iti@hU� Lh!�?} �@TihSeDS�

defo �Mt|ui*_c �@�h�Ui @?_ ki??i|� +L}Lgc �bH�c �5TiU�*@|��i O)Tih�?�@|�L?t �?�@ �4�3�?} �L_i*tG �@? i +�*i A�i4 ��|q<c aL�h?@* Lu �L*�|�U@* ,UL?�

L4)c �L*� b�c ?L� e�

de�o +@4ti)c 6h@?! ��c �b2.c �� �L?|h�M�|�L? |L |�i A�iLh) Lu A@ @|�L?c< ,UL�?L4�U aL�h?@* �.c TT� e.�S��

de2o 5@h}i?|c A�L4@tc @?_ �i�* @**@Uic �b.Dc �+@|�L?@* , TiU|@|�L?tc |�i �T|��4@* �L?i|@h) W?t|h�4i?|c @?_ |�i �T|�4@* �L?i) 5�TT*) +�*ic< aL�h?@* Lu�L*�|�U@* ,UL?L4) H�G TT� 2e��2De�

de�o 5@h}i?|c A�L4@tc @?_ �i�* @**@Uic �bH�c �5L4i N?T*i@t@?| �L?i|@h�t|�h�|�4i|�Uc< 6i_ih@* +itih�i �@?! Lu ��??i@TL*�t "�@h|ih*) +i��i��

deeo 5@h}i?|c A�L4@tc �bH.c �@UhLiUL?L4�U A�iLh)c 2?_ i_�|�L?c �U@_i4�U�hitt�

deDo 5�4tc ��h�t|LT�ihc �bbec �� 5�4T*i �L_i* uLh |�i #i|ih4�?@|�L? Lu |�i �h�Uiwi�i* @?_ |�i W?|ih@U|�L? Lu �L?i|@h) @?_ 6�tU@* �L*�U)c< ,UL?L4�U A�iLh)

ec �H���bb�

deSo 5�4tc ��h�t|LT�ihc �bbbc �6�tU@* �L?ti^�i?Uit uLh �i �UL Lu �_LT|�?} |�i#L**@hc< �?T�M*�t�i_ 4@?�tUh�T|�

de.o 5|L!i)c �@?U) w�c �bb�c ��hi_�M*i ��M*�U �L*�U)c< aL�h?@* Lu ,UL?L4�U #)�

?@4�Ut @?_ �L?|hL*c �D Ee�c TT� S2.�SDS�

deHo 5|L!i)c �@?U) w�c @?_ +LMih| ,� w�U@tc ah�c ��|� ,_�@h_ �� �hitUL||c �bHbc+iU�ht��i �i|�L_t �? ,UL?L4�U #)?@4�Utc O@h�@h_ N?��iht�|) �hitt�

eH

Page 49: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

debo A@)*Lhc aL�? ��c �bb�c �#�tUhi|�L? Viht�t �L*�U) +�*it �? �h@U|�Uic< �@h?i}�i�+LU�it|ih �L?uihi?Ui 5ih�it L? ��M*�U �L*�U) �bG �bD�2�e�

dDfo LL_uLh_c ��U�@i*c �bbec ��L?i|@h) �L*�U) @?_ �h�Ui wi�i* #i|ih4�?@U) �?@ �@t��W?��_�@?Ui ,UL?L4)c< ,UL?L4�U A�iLh) ec �eD��Hb�

dD�o LL_uLh_c ��U�@i*c �bbDc ��h�Ui wi�i* #i|ih4�?@U) `�|�L�| �L?|hL* Lu @�L?i|@h) �}}hi}@|ic< �@h?i}�i�+LU�it|ih 5ih�it L? ��M*�U �L*�U) e�c ��eS�

dD2o LL_uLh_c ��U�@i*c �bbSc ��L?|hL* Lu |�i ��M*�U #iM|G � +i^��hi4i?| uLh�h�Ui 5|@M�*�|)q<c �@|�L?@* ��hi@� Lu ,UL?L4�U +iti@hU� Lh!�?} T@Tih ?�4�Mih DSHe�

dD�o LL_uLh_c ��U�@i*c �bbHc ���M*�U #iM| @?_ |�i �h�Ui wi�i*c< 4@?�tUh�T|c�h�?Ui|L? N?��iht�|)c a�*) .�

dDeo LL_uLh_c ��U�@i*c �bbH@c ��L44i?| L? �LU�h@?ic< ��,+ �@UhLiUL?L4�Ut

�??�@* �bbHc �WA �hittc TT� �bf�e�H�

dDDo LL_uLh_c ��U�@i*c �bbHMc �#L�?} `�|�L�| �L?i)G �L?|hL**�?} W?�@|�L? �?@ �Lt|��L?i|@h) Lh*_c< +i��i� Lu ,UL?L4�U #)?@4�Utc �G �.��2�b�

dDSo LL_uLh_c ��U�@i*c �bbbc ��T|�4@* �L*�U) W?ih|�@c< 4@?�tUh�T|c �h�?Ui|L?N?��iht�|)c a�?i�

eb

Page 50: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

�� A�i wL}�U@* �L�ihi?Ui Lu 6�tU@* A�iLh)

�L|i?|�@**)c @? �4TLh|@?| UL?Uih? hi}@h_�?} |�i 6A�w �@t |L _L ��|� �|t �?|ih?@* *L}�U@*UL?t�t|i?U)� `�i? |�i 6A�w �tit |�i �?|ih|i4TLh@* }L�ih?4i?| M�_}i| i^�@|�L? |L T�?_L�? |�i Th�Ui *i�i*c �t |�@| Th�Ui *i�i* UL?t�t|i?| ��|� |�i Th�Ui *i�i* _i|ih4�?i_ M) |�ihit| Lu |�i iUL?L4)q W? tL4i U@titc |�i @?t�ih �t �?L<�.� #L |�iti U@tit �@hh@?| @ }i?ih@*UL?U*�t�L? |�@| |�i 6A�w �t ?L| *L}�U@**) UL�ihi?|q i |��?! ?L|� ,?L�}� �?|ihit|�?}i @4T*it U@? Mi UL?t|h�U|i_ �? ���U� |�i �tU@* |�iLh) �t *L}�U@**) UL�ihi?|� �?i i @4T*i�t }��i? �? |�i ML_) Lu |�i T@Tih� A�i TL�?| �t @*tL �**�t|h@|i_ �? ti�ih@* @h|�U*it Lu @ tTiU�@*�tt�i �? ,UL?L4�U A�iLh) �? �bbe� W? |��t @TTi?_� c �i Thiti?| @?L|�ih i @4T*i�

A�i 4L_i* �i �Lh! ��|� �t |�i U@t��Uhi_�| }LL_ 4L_i* Lu w�U@t @?_ 5|L!i) E�bH��� i_L |�i @?@*)t�t uLh @ h@?}i Lu T@h@4i|ih �@*�it ���U� �?U*�_it |�i i4T�h�U@**) T*@�t�M*i L?itc@UULh_�?} |L |�i it|�4@|it hiTLh|i_ �? ��@h�c ��h�t|�@?L @?_ ki�Li E�bb��� i t!�T _i|@�*i_ThLLut �? Uih|@�? T*@Uitc |�L�}� ?i�ih ��|�L�| ThL��_�?} |�i �?|��|�L? uLh |�i @h}�4i?|�A�i hi@_ih ��L ��t�it |L tii @? i |i?t��i @?_ h�}LhL�t |hi@|4i?| Lu |�i ThLTih|�it Lu |�ii^��*�Mh�@ Lu |��t 4L_i* t�L�*_ UL?t�*| LL_uLh_ E�bbe�� W? igiU|c |��t @TTi?_� Thiti?|t@? i |i?_i_ i @4T*i |L �**�t|h@|i ��t �hLTLt�|�L?t 2 @?_ �f @| |�i *i�i* Lu @? @_�@?Ui_�?_ih}h@_�@|i Lh �ht| )i@h }h@_�@|i iUL?L4�Ut UL�hti�

i �ht| UL?t�_ih |�i U@ti ��ihi 4L?i|@h) TL*�U) �t U�@h@U|ih�3i_ M) @ UL?t|@?| 4L?i)}hL�|� h@|i� i t�L� |�@| |�i 4L_i* �@t @ �?�^�i i^��*�Mh��4 ��i? |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@?@tt�4T|�L? �t @_LT|i_� i |�i? UL?t�_ih |�i U@ti ��ihi |�i 4L?i|@h) @�|�Lh�|) Ti}t |�ih@|i Lu �?|ihit|� �}@�?c E*�!i |�i i @4T*i �? |�i |i |� |�i 4L_i* �@t @ �?�^�i i^��*�Mh��4��i? @ ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L? �t @_LT|i_� `�i? |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L? �t ?L|

@_LT|i_c |�i? |�i 4L_i* u@�*t |L i ��M�| @ �?�^�i i^��*�Mh��4� W? |��t U@tic |�i 4L_i*hiThL_�Uit |�i U*@tt�U 5@h}i?| @?_ @**@Ui E�b.D� hit�*| |�@| |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �t �?_i|ih4�?@|i�5Lc uhL4 @ |iU�?�U@* t|@?_TL�?|c |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? @tt�4T|�L? �t @ _i��Ui |�@| U@? i*�4�?@|i|�i �Th�Ui *i�i* �?_i|ih4�?@U)< @ttLU�@|i_ ��|� �?|ihit| h@|i Ti}}�?} |�@| 5@h}i?| @?_ @**@Ui@?@*)3i_�.2

A�i �ht| tiU|�L? Mi*L� _itUh�Mit |�i @}i?|t Lu |�i 4L_i*c @?_ _i�?it i^��*�Mh��4� A�iuL**L��?} tiU|�L? @__hittit |�i U@ti ��i? 4L?i|@h) TL*�U) �t U�@h@U|ih�3i_ M) UL?t|@?| 4L?i)}hL�|� @?_ |�i �?@* tiU|�L? @__hittit |�i �?|ihit| h@|i Ti}}�?} U@ti�

:4D vlpsoh h{dpsoh ri wklv/ lq zklfk wkh wudglwlrqdo txdqwlw| wkhru| krogv/ zdv suhvhqwhglq wkh erg| ri wkh sdshu1 Lq wkh prgho ri Revwihog dqg Urjr� +4<;6,/ wkhuh lv d frxqwdeohvhw ri htxloleuld1 Wkh Ulfdugldq dvvxpswlrq grhv qrw vlw frpiruwdeo| zlwk wkdw prgho ehfdxvhwkh olnholkrrg wkdw wkh �vfdo dqg prqhwdw| dxwkrulwlhv zrxog slfn d �vfdo srolf| wkdw zrxog ehfrqvlvwhqw zlwk rqh ri wkrvh htxloleuld vhhpv volp1 Dqrwkhu h{dpsoh dsshduv lq Exlwhu +4<<<,1

:5Wklv lv krz Nrfkhuodnrwd dqg Skhodq +4<<<, lqwhusuhw wkh IWSO1

Df

Page 51: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

���� A�i w�U@t�5|L!i) �@t���hi_�| BLL_ �L_i*

������ OL�ti�L*_t

A�i OL�ti�L*_ �hLM*i4 @?_ �L?t|h@�?|t

A�i 4L_i* @Mt|h@U|t uhL4 _�gihi?Uit Mi|�ii? �L�ti�L*_t M) @tt�4�?} |�i) @hi @** �_i?�|�U@*� W? @__�|�L?c �L�ti�L*_t @hi @tt�4i_ |L *��i �?�?�|i*) *L?}� A��t UL�*_ Mi �?|ihThi|i_cuL**L��?} �@hhL E�b.e�c @t hi�iU|�?} |�@| i@U� �L�ti�L*_ @U|�@**) *��it @ �?�|i @4L�?| Lu|�4ic M�| U@hit �? @ T@h|�U�*@h �@) @ML�| �|t LgtTh�?}�

A�i Thiuihi?Uit Lu |�i hiThiti?|@|��i �L�ti�L*_ @hi @t uL**L�tG

"[|'f

q|�ES|�c �ES� ' *L}ES�c f q �c

S ' dE�� j�SD� n jSD2o�

D c

��ihi f j � @?_ S| _i?L|it UL?t�4T|�L? tih��Uit� W? L�h @?@*)t�tc �i hit|h�U| D |L|�i h@?}i f D �� ��@h�c ��h�t|�@?L @?_ ki�Li E�bb�� @h}�i |�@| |��t �t |�i i4T�h�U@**)hi*i�@?| U@ti� �@ti_ L? TLt|��@h N5 _@|@c |�i�h TL�?| it|�4@|it @hi j ' f�D. @?_ D ' f�H��

�L?t�4T|�L? tih��Uit @hi }i?ih@|i_ M) |�i @U^��t�|�L? Lu |�L 4@h!i|�ThL_�Ui_ }LL_tc @t�?_�U@|i_� �?i Lu |�itic S�|c �t U@**i_ @ �U@t� }LL_< @?_ |�i L|�ihc S2|c �t @ �Uhi_�| }LL_<� ALT�hU�@ti |�i U@t� }LL_c �L�ti�L*_t ?ii_ |L ti| @t�_i U@t� �? @_�@?Ui�

AL 4@!i |�i ?L|�L? ��? @_�@?Ui< ThiU�tic |�i 4L_i* @_LT|t @ T@h|�U�*@h |�4�?} ti|�T�W| �t @tt�4i_ |�@| i@U� Tih�L_ �t _���_i_ �?|L |�L T@h|t� W? |�i �ht| T@h| E|�i �4Lh?�?}<�c|�i �L�ti�L*_ T@h|�U�T@|it �? @? @tti| 4@h!i|c @?_ �? |�i tiUL?_ T@h| E|�i �@u|ih?LL?<� |�i�L�ti�L*_ T@h|�U�T@|it �? @ }LL_t 4@h!i|� A�i U@t� |�@| �L�ti�L*_t ?ii_ |L T�hU�@ti S�| �?|�i @u|ih?LL? Lu @ }��i? _@) 4�t| Mi ti| @t�_i @| |�i i?_ Lu @tti| 4@h!i| |h@_�?} |�@| t@4i4Lh?�?}� A�i) �L*_ |�iti M@*@?Uit �_*i �?|�* |�i 4Lh?�?} Lu |�i uL**L��?} _@)c ��i? @U|�@*T@)4i?| �t _�i� �hi_�| }LL_t �Lh! @ *�||*i _�gihi?|*)� 6Lh |�itic |�i �L�ti�L*_ �@t ?L ?ii_|L @UU�4�*@|i U@t� �? @_�@?Ui� A�i �L�ti�L*_ t�4T*) T@)t uLh |�i }LL_t ��|� U@t� �? |�i?i | 4Lh?�?}<t @tti| 4@h!i|�

�i U@hiu�* ?L| |L Mi 4�t*i_ M) |�i *@Mi*t L? |�iti }LL_t� W| �t ?L| |�@| L?i U@? Mi ML�}�|�L? Uhi_�|< �? |�i ?Lh4@* ti?tic @?_ |�i L|�ih ?L|� �L|� }LL_t @hi T@�_ �? U@t� |�i 4Lh?�?}@u|ih |�i T�hU�@ti� �L Uhi_�| �t Mi�?} Lgihi_ M) |�i ti**ih �? i�|�ih U@ti� A�i _�gihi?UiMi|�ii? |�i }LL_t �t t�4T*) |�@| �? |�i U@ti Lu L?i E|�i U@t� }LL_�c |�i �L�ti�L*_ �@t |LuLhui�| �?|ihit|� A��t �t MiU@�ti |L M�) �|c |�i �L�ti�L*_ �@t |L U@hh) �_*i U@t� M@*@?Uit �? �|tTLU!i| |�hL�}�L�| |�i @u|ih?LL?� 6hL4 |�i TL�?| Lu ��i� Lu |�i ti**ih |�i }LL_t @hi @U|�@**)UL4T*i|i*) |�i t@4i� A�i |ih4t Lu |�i |h@?t@U|�L? @hi �_i?|�U@*G U@t� L?*)c |L Mi _i*��ihi_|�i 4Lh?�?} @u|ih |�i t@*i�

D�

Page 52: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

A�i _�t|�?U|�L? Mi|�ii? U@t� @?_ Uhi_�| }LL_t 4@) @| �ht| tii4 @h|��U�@*� W? u@U|c �|�t @ U*i�ih _i��Ui uLh U@T|�h�?} |�i ?L|�L? |�@| |h@?t@U|�L?t �? tL4i }LL_t @hi 4Lhi U@t��?|i?t��i |�@? �? L|�iht� W| ��** }��i h�ti |L @ _i4@?_ uLh 4L?i)c L?i |�@| �t @ u�?U|�L? Lu|�i h@|i Lu �?|ihit|�

i @tt�4i |�@| |�i 4@h}�?@* h@|i Lu |h@?tuLh4@|�L? �? ThL_�U|�L? �t �?�|) Mi|�ii? |�i|�L }LL_t� �iU@�ti Lu |��tc |�i Th�Ui Lu |�i |�L }LL_tc �|c �t �_i?|�U@* �? i^��*�Mh��4� �*tLc�? @?) i^��*�Mh��4 �| 4�t| Mi |�@| -| � f @?_ �| : f� �@h!i| U*i@h�?} �t �4TLtt�M*i �u i�|�ihLu |�iti |�L UL?_�|�L?t u@�*t |L Mi t@|�t�i_�

wi| �| _i?L|i |�i �L�ti�L*_<t �?@?U�@* @tti|t @| |�i i?_ Lu @tti| 4@h!i| |h@_�?}� W?|�i �ht| Tih�L_c | ' fc |��t �t t�4T*) @ }��i? ?�4Mihc �f� A�i �L�ti�L*_ U@? @**LU@|i �| @tuL**L�tG

�_| n

�_|n�

� n-|

n A| � �|c | ' fc �c 2c ���c E����

��ihi �_| _i?L|it 4L?i) M@*@?Uit( �_

|n� _i?L|it }L�ih?4i?| _iM| ���U� ULt|t �_|n�*E�n-|�

|L_@) @?_ T@)t Lg �_|n� �? |�i ?i | Tih�L_<t @tti| 4@h!i|( @?_ A| _i?L|it *�4T t�4 |@ it�

A�i hi@tL? |�i �L�ti�L*_ _Lit ?L| t�4T*) ti| �_| |L 3ihL �t |�@|c @t ?L|i_ @ML�ic �u �| ��t�it

|L UL?t�4i U@t� }LL_tc �| 4�t| ti| U@t� @t�_i �? @_�@?UiG

�|S�| ��_| �

�tti|t @| |�i Mi}�??�?} Lu |�i ?i | Tih�L_ @hiG

�|n� ' �_| n �|E+ � S�| � S2|� n�_

|n�� E��2�

Oihic �_| �t |�i U@t� M@*@?Uit U@hh�i_ �?|L |�i Thi��L�t Tih�L_<t }LL_t 4@h!i|( �|+ �t hiUi�T|t

uhL4 |�i t@*i Lu + �? |�i Thi��L�t Tih�L_<t }LL_t 4@h!i|( �| ES�| n S2|� hiThiti?|t |�i M�** }LL_tT�hU�@ti_ �? |�i Thi��L�t Tih�L_<t }LL_t 4@h!i|( @?_ �_

|n� �t hiUi�T|t uhL4 }L�ih?4i?| _iM|T�hU�@ti_ �? |�i Thi��L�t Tih�L_<t @tti| 4@h!i|�

6Lh T�hTLtit Lu }@�?�?} �?|��|�L?c �| �t �tiu�* |L uL**L� @ t�}}it|�L? �? LL_uLh_ E�bbe�@?_ �h�|i E���� @?_ E��2� �? @ t*�}�|*) _�gihi?| uLh4� #i�?i �tTi?_�?}<G

7| ' �|S�c| n�|S2c|� n-|

n���

� n-|

���_

| � �|S�c|��

W? |��t 4i@t�hi Lu tTi?_�?}c i Uitt �L*_�?}t Lu 4L?i) M@*@?Uit @ML�i ��@| �t ?ii_i_ uLh|�i U@t� �? @_�@?Ui UL?t|h@�?| �@t @ TLt�|��i Th�Uic �u -| : f� �*tLc |�i hi*@|��i �Th�Uit< L?S�c| @?_ S2c| @UU�h@|i*) hi�iU| |�@| |�i uLh4ih �?�L*�it t@Uh��U�?} �?|ihit| i@h?�?}t� #i�?i��?UL4i<c U|G

U| '�|+

� n-|

� A|�

D2

Page 53: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

#���_i ML|� t�_it Lu E��2� M) � n-|c @?_ |�i? t�Mt|�|�|i L�| uLh �_|n�*E� n-|� �t�?} E����

|L LM|@�?G�|n� � E� n-|�E�| n U| � 7|�� E����

5Lc |�i @UU�4�*@|�L? Lu |�i �L�ti�L*_ @tti|t LMi)t |�i �t�@* t�4T*i i^�@|�L? L?i �?_t �? @?L?�4L?i|@h)c t�?}*i }LL_ 4L_i* iUL?L4)�

5L4i tLh| Lu *L�ih ML�?_ UL?t|h@�?| 4�t| Mi T*@Ui_ L? �| |L i?t�hi |�@| |�i �L�ti�L*_�@t @ ML�?_i_ UL?t�4T|�L? ti|� i �4TLti |�@| |�i U�hhi?| �@*�i Lu @tti|t 4�t| i�i?|�@**)Mi ?L?�?i}@|��iG

*�4A<"

^A�A � fc E��e�

��ihi

^A '�

E� n-f�� E� n-�� ��� E� n-A3��c ^f ' ��

W| �t i@t) |L �ih�u) |�@| E�����E��e� @hi i^���@*i?| |L |�i �t�@* t�?}*i Thiti?|��@*�i M�_}i|UL?t|h@�?| uLh UL?t�4T|�L?c 7|c @?_ �?UL4ic U|�

.�

i t�TTLti |�@| @| i@U� _@|i |�i �L�ti�L*_ U�LLtit S�c|n�c S2c|n� � fc �_|n�c �

_|n�n�c � � fc

|L 4@ �4�3i �|t �|�*�|) t�M�iU| |L |�i hit|h�U|�L?t ��t| _itUh�Mi_ @?_ |@!�?} �|c -|n�c �|n�c� � fc @t }��i? @?_ Mi)L?_ �|t UL?|hL*�.e

�iUitt@h) @?_ 5��U�i?| �L?_�|�L?t uLh OL�ti�L*_ �T|�4�3@|�L?

A�i �L�ti�L*_ �ht| Lh_ih UL?_�|�L?t @hi @t uL**L�tG

�2c|�|

' q��c|n��|n�

c E��D�

:6Wr vhh wklv/ qrwh �uvw wkdw e| uhfxuvlyh vxevwlwxwlrq/ +D16, lpsolhv

tWDW � D3 .W�4[w@3

tw+Lw � Vw,=

Gulylqj W $4> zh rewdlq=4[w@3

twVw � D3 .4[w@3

twLw=

Wklv vkrzv wkdw +D16,0+D17, lpso| wkh vwdqgdug vlqjoh0htxdwlrq exgjhw frqvwudlqw1 Wr hvwdeolvkwkh uhyhuvh/ vlpso| vkrz wkdw li iVw> Lwj> w @ 3> 4> === vdwlvi| wkh exgjhw frqvwudlqw/ wkhq wkh| dovrvdwlvi| +D16,0+D17,1 Wkdw wkh suhvhqw ydoxh ri lqfrph lv �qlwh zloo eh d ihdwxuh ri htxloleulxp1Rwkhuzlvh/ ghpdqg zrxog eh xqerxqghg dqg qr htxloleulxp frxog h{lvw1

:7Lw lv hdv| wr yhuli| wkdw lq dq| htxloleulxp/ lw pxvw eh wkdw Uw � 3 dqg Sw A 3= Pdunhwfohdulqj lv lpsrvvleoh li hlwkhu ri wkhvh wzr frqglwlrqv idlov wr eh vdwlv�hg1

D�

Page 54: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

@?_ ��c|�2c|

' � n-|� E��S�

Oihic ��c| _i?L|it |�i T@h|�@* _ih��@|��i Lu �|�*�|) ��|� hitTiU| |L S�c|c � ' �c 2� AL �?_iht|@?_��) |�i �ht| Lu |�iti ,�*ih i^�@|�L?t �t �4T*�i_ M) �L�ti�L*_ LT|�4�3@|�L?c UL?t�_ih |�i uL*�*L��?} @h}�4i?|� 5�TTLti |�i �L�ti�L*_ hi_�Uit �|t T�hU�@tit Lu Uhi_�| }LL_t �? |�i Tih�L_| }LL_t 4@h!i| M) L?i _L**@h @?_ @TT*�it |�@| _L**@h |L @__�|�L?@* U@t� }LL_t UL?t�4T|�L?�? |�i Tih�L_ | n � }LL_t 4@h!i|� A�i ULt| Lu |��t �t |�@| Uhi_�| }LL_ UL?t�4T|�L? |L_@)_hLTt M) �*�|c ���U� |h@?t*@|it �?|L @? �44i_�@|i u@** �? �|�*�|) Lu �2c|*�|� A��t hi_�U|�L? Lui Ti?_�|�hit uhiit L?i _L**@h �? |�i @tti| 4@h!i| ?i | Tih�L_c ���U� U@? Mi @TT*�i_ |L�@h_t|�i U@t� �? @_�@?Ui UL?t|h@�?| uLh T�hU�@t�?} �*�|n� �?�|t Lu |�i U@t� }LL_ �? ?i | Tih�L_<t}LL_t 4@h!i|� A�i �|�*�|) Mi?i�| Lu |��tc uhL4 |�i t|@?_TL�?| Lu Tih�L_ |c �t q��c|n�*�|n��Wu |�i }@�? �ihi i Uii_i_ |�i ULt|c LM��L�t*) |�i �L�ti�L*_ UL�*_ ?L| Mi LT|�4�3�?}c Lh �i�L�*_ �@�i uL�?_ @ U�@?}i �? �|t T*@? ���U� �L�*_ �4ThL�i �|�*�|)� 5�4�*@h*)c �u |�i }@�?�ihi *itt |�@? |�i ULt|c |�i? |�i �L�ti�L*_ UL�*_ h@�ti �|�*�|) M) �?Uhi@t�?} Uhi_�| }LL_tUL?t�4T|�L? �? Tih�L_ | @?_ hi_�U�?} U@t� }LL_t UL?t�4T|�L? �? Tih�L_ |n�� �T|�4�3@|�L?hi^��hit |�@| ?i�|�ih Lu |�iti t|h@|i}�it Mi @M*i |L h@�ti �|�*�|)c @?_ |��t �t ��) |�i �ht| ,�*ihi^�@|�L? @ML�i �t @? �4T*�U@|�L? Lu �L�ti�L*_ LT|�4�3@|�L?�

A�i tiUL?_ ,�*ih i^�@|�L? @ML�i �t @*tL �4T*�i_ M) �L�ti�L*_ LT|�4�3@|�L?� A��t �tit|@M*�t�i_ M) @? @h}�4i?| t�4�*@h |L |�i L?i �? |�i Thi��L�t T@h@}h@T�� A�i @h}�4i?|i T*L�|t |�i |h@_i�Lg Mi|�ii? U@t� @?_ Uhi_�| }LL_t ��|��? |�i t@4i Tih�L_� A�i �L�ti�L*_U@? �?Uhi@ti U�hhi?| Tih�L_ U@t� }LL_t UL?t�4T|�L? M) hi_�U�?} �|t @U^��t�|�L? Lu }L�ih?4i?|_iM|� A��t hi_�Uit �|t U@t� hiUi�T|t �? |�i ?i | Tih�L_<t @tti| 4@h!i|c hi_�U�?} |�i U@t�@�@�*@M*i uLh Uhi_�| 4@h!i| }LL_ UL?t�4T|�L? |L_@)� �L|i |�@| |��t ,�*ih i^�@|�L? 4@!itUL?t�_ih@M*i ti?tiG ��i? - �t ��}�c �| �4T*�it |�@| �� �t hi*@|��i*) ��}�c tL |�@| S� �t hi*@|��i*)*L�� A��t 4@!it ti?ti MiU@�ti ��}� - h@�tit |�i ULt| |L �L�ti�L*_t Lu T�hU�@t�?} S��

A�ihi �t @*tL @ UL?_�|�L? @ttLU�@|i_ ��|� |�i U@t� �? @_�@?Ui UL?t|h@�?|c ���U� �i �h�|i@t uL**L�tG

-|E�|S�| ��_| � ' fc E��.�

�t ?L|i_ @ML�ic L?*) |�i U@tic -| � fc ?ii_t |L Mi UL?t�_ihi_� 5�?Uic �? @__�|�L?c �|S�|��_|

U@??L| Mi ?i}@|��ic E��.� �t @ 4@|�i4@|�U@**) UL?U�ti �@) Lu t|@|�?}G �u -| : f �| uL**L�t|�@| �|S�| ' �_

| c ���*i �u -| ' fc |�i? @** �i !?L� �t �|S�| � �_| � A�i !i) |��?}c uhL4 |�i

TL�?| Lu ��i� Lu |�i @?@*)t�t Mi*L�c �t |�@| ��i? -| : fc |�i U@t� �? @_�@?Ui UL?t|h@�?| �L*_t@t @ t|h�U| i^�@*�|)� A��t 4@!it ti?ti� `�i? |�i �?|ihit| h@|i �t TLt�|��ic �| �t �?UL?t�t|i?|��|� LT|�4�3@|�L? |L U@hh) U@t� �? |�i @u|ih?LL? |�@| �t ?L| @MtL*�|i*) ?iUitt@h)�

W? @__�|�L? |L E��D��E��.�c |�i uL**L��?} |h@?t�iht@*�|) UL?_�|�L? �t @*tL �4T*�i_ M) �L�ti�

De

Page 55: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

�L*_ LT|�4�3@|�L?G*�4A<"

^A�A ' f� E��H@�

A�i �?|��|�L? uLh |��t UL?_�|�L? �t t|h@�}�|uLh�@h_� AL tii |�@| |�i *�4�| U@??L| Mi TLt�|��it�TTLtic L? |�i UL?|h@h)c |�@| �| �t� W? |��t U@tic �| }hL�t @| @ h@|i u@t|ih |�@? |�i h@|iLu �?|ihit|� ��|c |�i? �| �t ui@t�M*i uLh �L�ti�L*_t |L �?Uhi@ti tTi?_�?} �? L?i _@|i ��|�L�|hi_�U�?} �| �? @?L|�ih� Wu |��t i |h@ tTi?_�?} �ihi �?@?Ui_ M) @ *L@?c |�i TL�ih Lu UL4TL�?_�?|ihit| �L�*_ U@�ti |�i hit�*|�?} _iM| |L tT�h@* �T�@h_ @| @ h@|i i^�@* |L |�i h@|i Lu �?|ihit|�OL�i�ihc ��|� |L|@* @tti|t h�t�?} @| @? i�i? }hi@|ih h@|ic |�i �L�ti�L*_<t ?i| @tti| TLt�|�L?�L�*_ hi4@�? UL?t�t|i?| ��|� E��e�� A�i �?Uhi@ti �? UL?t�4T|�L? �?@?Ui_ �? |��t �@) h@�tit�|�*�|) MiU@�ti Lu ?L?t@|�@|�L?c @?_ tL �i �@�i @ UL?|h@_�U|�L?� A��tc LT|�4�3@|�L? �4T*�it|�@| |�i @ML�i i Thitt�L? U@??L| Mi TLt�|��i� W| U@??L| Mi ?i}@|��i MiU@�ti Lu |�i hit|h�U|�L?cE��e��

6Lh T�hTLtit Lu @?@*)t�tc �| �t UL?�i?�i?| |L �h�|i |�i |h@?t�iht@*�|) UL?_�|�L? �? @ _�gihi?|uLh4� �L4M�?�?} E��D� @?_ E��S�c �i �?_ ��c| ' qE� n -|���c|n��|*�|n�� 5�Mt|�|�|�?} |��t�?|L |�i i Thitt�L? uLh ^|c �i �?_

^| '

#�f��cf

$qA��c|�|

c | ' fc �c 2c ��� E��b�

�u|ih 4�*|�T*)�?} ML|� t�_it Lu E��H@� M) |�i TLt�|��i UL?t|@?|c �f*��cfc |�i |h@?t�iht@*�|)UL?_�|�L? hi_�Uit |LG

*�4A<"

qA��cA�A

�A

' f� E���f�

W| |�h?t L�| |�@| E��D��E���f� @hi ?L| ��t| ?iUitt@h) uLh LT|�4�3@|�L?� A�i) @hi @*tL t��U�i?|�A��t �t i@t�*) it|@M*�t�i_ ��|� @ t��|@M*) @_��t|i_ �iht�L? Lu |�i ThLLu |L 5|L!i) @?_ w�U@tc��|� �hitUL|| E�bHb�c A�iLhi4 e��D�

����2� BL�ih?4i?|

A�i }L�ih?4i?| T�hU�@tit ?L }LL_tc @?_ L?*) T@h|�U�T@|it �? |�i @tti| 4@h!i|� W|t tL�hUitLu u�?_t �? |�i @tti| 4@h!i| @hi ?i� _iM| �tt�itc |@ hi�i?�it @?_ ?i�*) Uhi@|i_ 4L?i)c�r

| ��r|3�� W| �tit |�iti u�?_t |L T@) �|t L�|t|@?_�?} _iM| LM*�}@|�L?tc �r

| � ,^�@|�?} tL�hUit@?_ �tit Lu u�?_tG

�r|n�

� n-|

n A| n�r| ��r

|3� ' �r| �

�| |�4i |c |�i }L�ih?4i?| |@!it�r|3� @?_ �

r| @t }��i?c | ' fc �c��� � �| _@|i fc �r

3�n�rf ' �f�

BL�ih?4i?| TL*�U) �t @ ti^�i?Ui Lu �r|n�<tc A|<tc @?_ �r

| <t |�@| t@|�tu) |��t �L� M�_}i|UL?t|h@�?|�

DD

Page 56: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

A��t M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?| U@? @*tL Mi �h�||i? @t uL**L�tG

�r|n�

� n-|

n A| n-|

� n-|

�| ' �r| c

��ihi �r| 4i@t�hit |L|@* ?L4�?@* @tti|tc �r

| ' �r| n�r

|3�c @?_ �rf ' �f� +iU�ht��i*) t�Mt|��

|�|�?} |��t i Thitt�L? uLh�@h_c �i �?_ |�@| uLh i@U� � i_ A G

^A�rA n

A3�[|'f

^|

�A| n

-|

� n-|

�|

�' �f� E�����

A�i Thiti?Ui Lu -|�|*E�n-|� hi�iU|t |�i �?|ihit| ULt|t |�i }L�ih?4i?| t@�it ��i? �| �tt�it4L?i) h@|�ih |�@? ML?_t� A�i }L�ih?4i?|<t ��?|ih|i4TLh@* M�_}i| i^�@|�L?< �t |�i @ML�ii Thitt�L?c ��|� ^A�

rA @Mti?| @?_ A � � hiT*@Ui_ M) 4 G

"[|'f

^|

�A| n

-|

� n-|

�|

�' �f� E���2�

A�i L?*) hit|h�U|�L? �i �@�i T*@Ui_ L? }L�ih?4i?| TL*�U) �t |�@| |�i �L� M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?|�t t@|�t�i_ uLh @** TLtt�M*i �@*�it Lu Th�Uitc i^|c �|c -|c | � fj� A�@| �tc �i hi^��hi |�@|E����� �L*_� ��|c ?L @tt�4T|�L? �@t Mii? 4@_i |�@| E���2� �L*_t uLh @** TLtt�M*i Th�Uit�BL�ih?4i?| TL*�U) �t t@�_ |L Mi +�U@h_�@? �u E���2� �L*_t uLh @** TLtt�M*i Th�Uit� BL�ih?4i?|TL*�U) �t ?L?�+�U@h_�@? �u E���2� �L*_t L?*) @| |�i i^��*�Mh��4 Th�Uit� E i t�@** tii |�@|c@| i^��*�Mh��4 Th�Uitc E���2� 4�t| Mi t@|�t�i_ hi}@h_*itt Lu ��i|�ih }L�ih?4i?| TL*�U) �t+�U@h_�@? Lh ?L?�+�U@h_�@?� A��t uL**L�t uhL4 E��H@� @?_ |�i u@U| |�@|c �? i^��*�Mh��4c�r

| ' �|��W| |�h?t L�| |�@| E����� UL?�ih}it |L E���2� �uc @?_ L?*) �uc

^A�rA $ f� E�����

�UULh_�?} |L |��t hit�*|c �i U@? i^���@*i?|*) _i�?i @ +�U@h_�@? TL*�U) @t L?i |�@| i?uLhUitE����� @| @** TLtt�M*i Th�Uit @?_ @ ?L?�+�U@h_�@? TL*�U) @t L?i |�@| _Lit ?L|�

������ 6�h4t

6�h4t �? |��t iUL?L4) @hi t�4T*i� A�i) M�) + uhL4 �L�ti�L*_t @?_ |h@?tuLh4 |��t �?|L U@t�@?_ Uhi_�| }LL_t� B��i? |�i @tt�4i_ *�?i@h�|) Lu |�i ThL_�U|�L? |iU�?L*L})c |�i hitL�hUiUL?t|h@�?| |�h?t L�| |L �@�i |�i uL**L��?} uLh4G

S�| n S2| ' +� E���e�

DS

Page 57: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

����e� ,^��*�Mh��4

� }i?ih@* i^��*�Mh��4 uLh |��t iUL?L4) �t @ ti^�i?Ui Lu Th�Uit @?_ �?|ihit| h@|itc �| @?_ -|c@ ti^�i?Ui Lu UL?t�4T|�L?tc S�|c S2|c @?_ @ ti^�i?Ui Lu 4L?i) t�TT*�it @?_ ML?_tc �|n� @?_�|n� t�U� |�@| �L�ti�L*_t LT|�4�3ic |�i }L�ih?4i?| �L� M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?| �t t@|�t�i_c @?_4@h!i|t U*i@h� �L?_ 4@h!i| U*i@h�?} hi^��hit

�r|n� ' �_

|n� ' fc

4L?i) 4@h!i| U*i@h�?} hi^��hit�r

| ' �_| '�|c

t@)c uLh | � f� A�iti UL?_�|�L?t �4T*) |�@| �|n� '�_| n�_

|n� ' �r|n�� BLL_t 4@h!i| U*i@h�?}

ULhhitTL?_t |L |�i hitL�hUi UL?t|h@�?|c E���e��� ui@|�hi Lu i^��*�Mh��4 ���U� ��** Mi �tiu�* �? |�i @?@*)t�t �t

� n-| '�� j

j

��3D|

� �c �| �S�|S2|

� E���D�

i LM|@�? |��t �t�?} E��S� @?_ L�h T@h@4i|h�U uLh4 uLh |�i �|�*�|) u�?U|�L?� `�i? -| : �c�i U@? hi�h�|i |��t |L LM|@�? |�i 4L_i*<t �4L?i) _i4@?_< u�?U|�L?� A�i M�?_�?} U@t� �?@_�@?Ui UL?t|h@�?|c S�| ' 6|c @?_ |�i hitL�hUi UL?t|h@�?| �4T*) �| ' 6|*E+ �6|�� 5L*��?}E���D� uLh 6| )�i*_tG

6| '+

� nk

j

�3jE� n-|�

l �

�3D

� E���S�

��2� �L?t|@?| �L?i) BhL�|�

Oihic �i UL?t�_ih |�i ti| Lu i^��*�Mh�@ @ttLU�@|i_ ��|� @ � i_ 4L?i) }hL�|� h@|i TL*�U)� it�L� |�@| |�ihi �t L?i i^��*�Mh��4 �? ���U� �?�@|�L? �t UL?t|@?| @?_ i^�@* |L |�i 4L?i)}hL�|�� A�ihi �t @*tL @ UL?|�?��4 Lu i^��*�Mh�@ ��|� i T*Lt��i �?�@|�L?�

i t�TTLti |�@| |�i }L�ih?4i?| ti|t �r|n� ' f uLh @** | � f M) T@)�?} Lg |�i i?|�hi t|LU!

Lu _iM| �? |�i �ht| Tih�L_� W? @__�|�L?c �| ti|t �r| ' >�r

|3�c uLh | ' fc �c ��� c ��ihi > � ���L?i) }hL�|� �t @UUL4T*�t�i_ M) 4i@?t Lu *�4T t�4 |@ |h@?tuiht� W? T@h|�U�*@hG

Af ' �rf � E>� ���r

3�c

A| ' �E>� ���r|3�c | � ��

W| �t t|h@�}�|uLh�@h_ |L �ih�u) |�@| ��|� |��t tTiU��U@|�L? Lu TL*�U)c |�ihi @hi 4@?) Th�Uiti^�i?Uit t�U� |�@| E���f� �t t@|�t�i_� AiU�?�U@**)c �| _Lit ?L| �| �?|L L�h uLh4@* _i�?�|�L?

D.

Page 58: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

Lu @ +�U@h_�@? TL*�U)c MiU@�ti E���f� �t ?L| t@|�t�i_ uLh @** Th�Uit� AL tii |��tc ?L|i |�@|�?_ih |��t TL*�U)c �| �t UL4TLti_ L?*) Lu |�i 4L?i) t�TT*)� A�i?c E���f� �L�*_ Mi ��L*@|i_�u |�i Th�Ui *i�i* ui** t��U�i?|*) h@T�_*)� 5|�**c uLh Th@U|�U@* T�hTLtit �| �t ?L| |LL 4�t*i@_�?}|L |��?! Lu |��t @t @ +�U@h_�@? TL*�U)�

W| �t �tiu�* |L hi�h�|i |�i �L�ti�L*_<t _)?@4�U ,�*ih i^�@|�L? M) 4�*|�T*)�?} ML|� t�_itLu E��D� M) �| @?_ �t�?} �|n� ' >�| |L LM|@�?G

�2c|6| 'q

>��c|n�6|n�c 6| �

�|

�|

� E���.�

� ti^�i?Ui Lu Th�Uit @?_ ^�@?|�|�it hiThiti?|t @? i^��*�Mh��4 �uc @?_ L?*) �uc E��.��E���e�@?_ �| : fc -|c S�|c S2| � f @hi t@|�t�i_�

��2��� � ��@h@U|ih�3@|�L? +it�*| uLh ,^��*�Mh�@

i ��** ?L� t�4T*�u) |�i i^��*�Mh��4 UL?_�|�L?t |L LM|@�? @ �tiu�* ti| Lu t��U�i?| UL?_�|�L?tuLh i^��*�Mh�@ �? ���U� |�i U@t� �? @_�@?Ui UL?t|h@�?| M�?_t� W? |��t U@ti E���e� @**L�t L?i|L i Thitt E���.� @t @ _�gihi?Ui i^�@|�L? �? 6| @?_ 6|n� @*L?i� �*tLc |�i u@U| |�@| |�i U@t��? @_�@?Ui UL?t|h@�?| M�?_t �4T*�it |�@| �| �? E���D� U@? Mi �h�||i?G

�| '6|

+ �6|

Nt�?} |��t ?L|@|�L?c E���.� U@? Mi i Thitti_ @t @ _�gihi?Ui i^�@|�L? �? �| @?_ �|n�G

@E�|� ' KE�|n��c E���H�

��ihi

@E�� 'j�

E�� j��D n jc E���b�

@�E�� 'j

dE�� j��D n jo2dE�� j� E�� D��D n jo �

@?_

KE�� 'q E�� j�

>

�D

E�� j��D n jE��2f�

K�E�� 'q E�� j�

>

�D3�Dj

dE�� j��D n jo2�

DH

Page 59: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

Oihic @� @?_ K� hiThiti?| |�i _ih��@|��it Lu @ @?_ Kc hitTiU|��i*)c ��|� hitTiU| |L �� A�i|h@?t�iht@*�|) UL?_�|�L? hi_�Uitc �? |�i Thiti?| ?L|@|�L?c |LG

*�4A<"

qA KE�A � ' f� E��2��

i @hi ?L� �? @ TLt�|�L? |L t|@|i L�h U�@h@U|ih�3@|�L? hit�*|�

�hLTLt�|�L? ���� 5�TTLti �| � fc | ' fc �c 2c ���c t@|�t�it E���H�c E��2�� @?_ E���D��A�i?c �| ULhhitTL?_t |L @? i^��*�Mh��4�

�hLLuG h�|i

6| ' +�|

� n �|

c �| '�|

6|

c

-| 'j

�� j

��3D

|

c S2| '+

� n �|

c S�| ' S2|�|c

@?_ �ih�u) |�@| @** |�i i^��*�Mh��4 UL?_�|�L?t @hi t@|�t�i_ @| |�iti Th�Uit@?_ ^�@?|�|�it� ",#

��2�2� ��*|�T*i ,^��*�Mh�@ `�|� +�U@h_�@?c �L?t|@?| �L?i) BhL�|�

i ��** �ti |�i U�@h@U|ih�3@|�L? hit�*| |L t�L� |�@| |�ihi �t @ UL?|�?��4 Lu i^��*�Mh�@ �?|��t iUL?L4) ��i? |�i 4L?i) }hL�|� h@|ic >c �t UL?t|@?| @?_ }hi@|ih |�@? �?�|)� �L|i �ht|uhL4 E���H� |�@| |�ihi �t i @U|*) L?i i^��*�Mh��4 ��|� �| ' �W uLh @** |G

�W '

%�� j

j

q

>

& �

�3D

� E��22�

W| �t i@t�*) �ih��i_ |�@| |��t t@|�t�it |�i UL?_�|�L?t Lu |�i U�@h@U|ih�3@|�L? hit�*|� 6Lh i �@4T*ic t�Mt|�|�|�?} �W �?|L E���D� )�i*_t |�i hit�*| |�@| |�i �?|ihit| h@|i �t TLt�|��ic ��|�� n - ' >*q� A��t �t }hi@|ih |�@? �?�|) M) L�h @tt�4T|�L?t L? > @?_ q� �iU@�ti hi@*M@*@?Uit @hi UL?t|@?| �? |��t i^��*�Mh��4c |�i h@|i Lu �?�@|�L? �t i^�@* |L >�

A�i �?|��|�L? �?_ih*)�?} E��22� �t t|h@�}�|uLh�@h_� A�i hi*@|��i ^�@?|�|) Lu U@t� }LL_tUL?t�4i_ �? |�i i^��*�Mh��4 E��i�c �W� �t �?Uhi@t�?} �? � � jc ���U� �t |�i hi*@|��i �i�}�|�? �|�*�|) L? |�iti }LL_t� W| �t _iUhi@t�?} �? |�i 4L?i) }hL�|� h@|ic >c MiU@�ti �?Uhi@tit�? > h@�tit |�i ?L4�?@* h@|i Lu �?|ihit|c ���U� �?Uhi@tit |�i ULt| Lu |�i U@t� }LL_� 6�?@**)cUL?t�_ih D $ �� A��t �t i@t�it| |L �?|ihThi| ��i? j ' �*2� W? |��t U@tic |�i |�L UL?t�4T|�L?}LL_t @hi TihuiU| t�Mt|�|�|it� �L?ti^�i?|*)c �u |�i U@t� }LL_ �t 4Lhi i Ti?t��i |�@? |�i

Db

Page 60: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

Uhi_�| }LL_c @t �t |�i U@ti ��i? > � �c 3ihL U@t� }LL_t ��** Mi UL?t�4i_c @?_ �W ' f @tD $ ��

i ?L� t�L� |�@| |�ihi @hi L|�ih i^��*�Mh�@ |LLc �? ���U� �?�@|�L? i Uii_t >� AL _L |��tc�i �ht| t|�_) |�i ThLTih|�it Lu |�i u�?U|�L?tc @E�� @?_ KE���

�UULh_�?} |L E���b�c @Ef� ' f @?_ @�Ef� ' �� �*tLc @�E�� : f uLh @** � � f� �| |�i t@4i|�4ic E��2f� �?_�U@|it |�@| KEf� ' fc K�E�� $ 4 @t � $ fc @?_ K�E�� : f uLh � : f� A�itiLMtih�@|�L?t it|@M*�t� |�@| @E�� @?_ KE�� UL�?U�_i @| � ' fc ��|� K h�t�?} 4Lhi t|iiT*) |�@?@ uLh t4@** �@*�it Lu ��

6hL4 |�i _�tU�tt�L? *i@_�?} �T |L E��22�c �i !?L� |�@| |�ihi �t @ �?�^�i �@*�i Lu � : fc?@4i*) �W �? E��22�c ��ihi @E�� ' KE��� 5�?Ui |�i |�L u�?U|�L?t @hi UL?|�?�L�t uLh f � �Wc �| uL**L�t |�@| KE�� : @E�� uLh � �? |��t �?|ih�@*c @?_ |�@| @ �t t|iiTih |�@? K @|� ' �W� A�i *@||ih LMtih�@|�L? U@? Mi UL?�h4i_ M) _�hiU| _�gihi?|�@|�L?c ���U� )�i*_tG

@�E�W�

K�E�W�'��� j

j

� �

�3D

��� D

D

�#q

>

$ D

�3D

n�

D: ��

A�i t|h�U| �?i^�@*�|) hi�iU|t |�@| |�i i Thitt�L? �44i_�@|i*) @u|ih |�i i^�@*�|) �t TLt�|��i@?_ |�@| �*D : � MiU@�ti f D ��

��h hit�*|t L? |�i @ @?_ K u�?U|�L?t @hi t�44@h�3i_ �? 6�}�hi �� �L|i �L� K h�tit @ML�i@c @?_ |�i? UhLttit L?Ui� ,�i?|�@**)c |�i |�L U�h�it @hi T@h@**i*c t�?Ui @�E�� @?_ K�E�� ML|�UL?�ih}i |L 3ihL @t � $ 4� i U@? �ti |��t _�@}h@4 |L t|�_) |�i ti| Lu i^��*�Mh�@ uLh |�i4L_i*�

�L?t�_ih @? @hM�|h@h�*) ti*iU|i_ �f �W� AL _i|ih4�?i |�i �@*�i Lu �� �4T*�i_ M) E���H�c_h@� @ *�?i �? |�i �ih|�U@* _�hiU|�L? �T |L @E�f�� A�i?c �_i?|�u) @ �� t�U� |�@| KE��� i^�@*t@E�f�� A��t U@? Mi uL�?_ M) uL**L��?} @ �Lh�3L?|@* *�?i |L |�i *iu| Lu @E�f�c �?|�* �| �?|ihtiU|t|�i K U�h�i� A�i ThLTih|�it Lu |�iti U�h�it |�@| �i �@�i _ih��i_ }�@h@?|ii |�@| t�U� @?�?|ihtiU|�L? ��** LUU�h uLh @ TLt�|��i �@*�i Lu �� `�|� �� �? �@?_c UL4T�|i �2 �? |�i t@4i�@)c @?_ tL L?�

W| t�L�*_ Mi U*i@h |�@| |�i ti^�i?Ui Lu �|<t UL4T�|i_ �? |��t �@) UL?�ih}it |L f� �*L?}|��t T@|�c KE�|� � f @?_ KE�|� $ f @t | $ 4� �iU@�ti K �t ML�?_i_ @ML�i @*L?} |�i T@|�cE��2�� �t t@|�t�i_� �*tLc �t�?}G E�� �| _iU*�?it 4L?L|L?�U@**)( E��� - : f @| �W( @?_ E�����| : f uLh @ }��i? |c E���D� �4T*�it |�@| -| : f uLh i@U� |� A��t it|@M*�t�it |�@| |�i ti^�i?Ui��t| UL4T�|i_ UL?t|�|�|it @? i^��*�Mh��4�.D ��|c |�i t@4i @h}�4i?| U@? Mi @TT*�i_ uLh i@U�f �| �W� W? i@U� Lu |�iti i^��*�Mh�@ |�ihi �t @ �)Tih�?�@|�L?c @t �| $ f�.S

:8Uhfdoo/ lq frqvwuxfwlqj +D14;, zh dvvxphg wkdw wkh fdvk lq dgydqfh frqvwudlqw lv elqglqj1Wklv dvvxpswlrq kdv ehhq yhul�hg iru z3 ? z�=

:9Rxu uhvxowv zrxog qrw eh vljql�fdqwo| d�hfwhg li zh doorzhg oderu wr eh hqgrjhqrxv1 Lqwur0

Sf

Page 61: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

��2��� N?�^�i ,^��*�Mh��4 `�|� ?L?�+�U@h_�@?c �L?t|@?| �L?i) BhL�|�

A�i Thi��L�t t�MtiU|�L? t�L�i_ |�@| ��|� @ T@h|�U�*@h +�U@h_�@? TL*�U)c UL?t|@?| 4L?i)}hL�|� hit�*|t �? @ UL?|�?��4 Lu i^��*�Mh�@� Oihi �t @ T@h|�U�*@h ?L?�+�U@h_�@? TL*�U)G

A| ' �|r�-|

� n-|

�|c

��ihi r �t @ TLt�|��i UL?t|@?|� W| �t i@t) |L �ih�u) |�@| |�i ti| Lu i^��*�Mh�@ �?_ih |��t TL*�U)�t @ t|h�U| t�Mti| Lu |�i ti| Lu i^��*�Mh�@ @?@*)3i_ �? Thi��L�t tiU|�L?� A��tc �i UL?U*�_i |�@|��|� UL?t|@?| 4L?i) }hL�|�c @ ?L?�+�U@h_�@? TL*�U) _Lit ?L| *i@_ |L @? L�ih_i|ih4�?i_Th�Ui *i�i*�

���� 6� i_ W?|ihit| +@|i �L*�U�it

A��t tiU|�L? UL?t�_iht |�L hiThiti?|@|�L?t Lu TL*�U) �? ���U� |�i }L�ih?4i?| Ti}t |�i ?L4��?@* h@|i Lu �?|ihit| |L @ UL?t|@?| �@*�ic - : f� W? |�i �ht| hiThiti?|@|�L?c �tU@* TL*�U) �t+�U@h_�@? @?_ |�ihi i �t|t @ UL?|�?��4 Lu i^��*�Mh�@� W? |�i tiUL?_c TL*�U) �t ?L?�+�U@h_�@?@?_ |�i i^��*�Mh��4c �u �| i �t|tc �t �?�^�i�

A�i � i_ �@*�i Lu - T�?t _L�? 6 Etii E���S��c S� @?_ S2G

S� ' 6c S2 ' + � S��

�t @ UL?ti^�i?Uic |�i 4@h}�?@* �|�*�|) Lu |�i U@t� }LL_ �t UL?t|@?|c tL |�@|

�|n�

�|

' qE� n-�c uLh @** |�

�L?t�_ih |�i uL**L��?} |�L tTiU��U@|�L?t Lu TL*�U)G

A| ' �-

� n-6�| n 0�| E��2��

A| ' �-

� n-6�| n _�|�

gxflqj oderu dv d wklug dujxphqw lq wkh xwlolw| ixqfwlrq kdv wkh h�hfw ri dgglqj dq h{wud Hxohuhtxdwlrq/ �x6@x5 @ i 3+o,> zkhuh i 3+o, ghqrwhv wkh pdujlqdo surgxfw ri oderu/ o> dqg x6 ghqrwhvwkh pdujlqdo xwlolw| ri oderu1 Ihdvlelolw| uhvwulfwv o wr olh lq vrph vxevsdfh/ o 5 G +iru h{dpsoh Gpljkw eh wkh xqlw lqwhuydo,1 Dovr/ | @ i+o, ghqrwhv wkh surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrq1 Frpelqlqj wkh qhzHxohu htxdwlrq zlwk wkh uhvrxufh frqvwudlqw surgxfhv d ixqfwlrq/ o @ I +z,> zkhuh I kdv d qlfhdqdo|wlfdo fkdudfwhul}dwlrq zlwk vwdqgdug suhihuhqfhv dqg whfkqrorj|1 Wr �qg dq htxloleulxp/rqh zrxog vwloo vwduw e| orrnlqj iru zw*v wkdw vroyh wkh gl�huhqfh htxdwlrq/ D+zw, @ E+zw.4,=Rqh zrxog wkhq kdyh wr yhuli| I +z, 5 G> lq dgglwlrq wr wkh rwkhu frqglwlrqv olvwhg lq wkhfkdudfwhul}dwlrq uhvxow/ ehiruh yhuli|lqj wkdw wkh fdqglgdwh zw*v uhsuhvhqw dq htxloleulxp1

S�

Page 62: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

��ihi _ �t @ ?L?�?i}@|��i UL?t|@?| @?_ f 0 � �� i ��** tii |�@| |�i �ht| TL*�U) �t+�U@h_�@?c ���*i |�i tiUL?_ �t ?L|� A�iti TL*�U�it 4@) �?�|�@**) @TTi@h t|h@?}ic M�| �i �LTi|�@| �? @ 4L4i?| �| ��** MiUL4i U*i@h ��@| |�i 4L|��@|�L? uLh |�i4 �t� +iU@** |�@| |L_i|ih4�?i ��i|�ih @ TL*�U) �t +�U@h_�@? Lh ?L| hi^��hit _i|ih4�?�?} ��i|�ih E����� �L*_tuLh @** TLtt�M*i Th�Uit Lh ��i|�ih �| L?*) �L*_t uLh i^��*�Mh��4 Th�Uit�

AL �?�it|�}@|i |��t u�h|�ihc �| �t UL?�i?�i?| |L �h�|i |�i �L� M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?| �? hi@*|ih4tG

q@|n� n �| n-

� n-6 ' @|�

Oihic @|n� ' �|n�*�|n� @?_ �| ' A|*�|� 5�Mt|�|�|�?} |�i �ht| tTiU��U@|�L? Lu TL*�U) �? E��2���?|L |�i �L� M�_}i| UL?t|h@�?|G

@|n� '�� 0

q@| E��2e�

i tii! |L �?_iht|@?_ �L� �@| � q|@| i�L*�it @t |$4� AL tii ��)c ?L|i |�@|c M) t�Mt|�|�|�?}uhL4 E��b�G

^A�A ' �fqA�A

�A

' �f�@A � E��2D�

+iU@** |�@| @ TL*�U) |�@| 4@!it ^A�A $ f uLh @** TLtt�M*i Th�Uit ULhhitTL?_t |L @ +�U@h_�@?TL*�U) @?_ L?i |�@| 4@!it |��t �@TTi? L?*) uLh |�i i^��*�Mh��4 Th�Uit �t @ ?L?�+�U@h_�@?TL*�U)�

��*|�T*)�?} ML|� t�_it Lu E��2e� M) q|n�c �i �?_

�@|n� ' E�� 0��@| ' E�� 0�|�@fc

Lhc �t�?} E��2D�G^A�A ' E�� 0�|�f $ f�

A��t it|@M*�t�it |�@| |�i �ht| TL*�U) �? E��2�� �t +�U@h_�@?� A�i }L�ih?4i?|<t TL*�U) Thi�i?|t|�i _iM| uhL4 i T*L_�?} |LL u@t|c hi}@h_*itt Lu ��@| �@TTi?t� �t @ hit�*|c |�i �?|ih|i4TLh@*M�_}i| i^�@|�L? ThL��_it ?L �tiu�* hit|h�U|�L? uLh T�??�?} _L�? Th�Uit�

�L� UL?t�_ih |�i tiUL?_ TL*�U) �? E��2��� 6Lh |��t TL*�U)c |L|@* hi@* @tti|t i�L*�i @tuL**L�tG

@|n� '�

qE@| � _� �

A�i TL*�U) 4@!it |�i i�L*�|�L? Lu |L|@* @tti| i L}i?L�tc ���*i *i||�?} |�i Th��@|i iUL?L4)_i|ih4�?i |�i Mhi@!_L�? Lu hi@* @tti|t Mi|�ii? 4L?i) @?_ ML?_t tL |�@| �| �t UL?t�t|i?|��|� |�i �?|ihit| h@|i Ti}� 5L*�i |��t uLh @| @?_ |�i? 4�*|�T*) M) q| G

q|@| ' @f �_

�� qn

_

�� qq|c

S2

Page 63: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

tL |�@|

q|@| $�f

�f

�_

�� qc

��ihi �i �@�i �ti_ @f ' �f*�f� A��t �t @ ?L?�+�U@h_�@? TL*�U) MiU@�ti q|@| $ f uLh L?*)L?i �@*�i Lu �fc |�i L?i |�@| t@|�t�itG

�f

�f

'_

�� q�

i U@? ?L� t�44@h�3i L�h hit�*|t uLh |�i �?|ihit| h@|i Ti}� Wu �| �t @UUL4T@?�i_ M)@ +�U@h_�@? TL*�U)c |�i? |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �t ?L| T�??i_ _L�? M) |�i �?|ih|i4TLh@* M�_}i|i^�@|�L?c ?Lh M) |�i hit| Lu |�i 4L_i*� A�i 4L_i* L?*) T�?t _L�?�|*�| @?_ �|n�*�|c M�| ?L||�i ?�4ih@|Lh @?_ _i?L4�?@|Lh |ih4t� N?_ih |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? TL*�U)c |�i �?|ih|i4TLh@*M�_}i| i^�@|�L? t�TT*�it |�i i |h@ i^�@|�L? ?ii_i_� �?Ui @}@�?c |�i Th�Ui *i�i* �t ?L|L�ih_i|ih4�?i_ �?_ih |�i ?L?�+�U@h_�@? TL*�U)�

S�

Page 64: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

End of Period Real Debt

Beginning of Period Real Debt

Figure 1: Debt Evolution Under non-Ricardian Fiscal Policy

End of Period Real Debt

Beginning of Period Real Debt

Figure 2: Debt Evolution Under Perturbed Fiscal Policy

0

0.05

0.10

0.15

0.20

0.25

0.30

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

Revenues

Labor Tax Rate,

Figure 4: Revenues From Labor Tax

45o

b* b* b~

45o

b0

Figure A: Equilibrium in the Cash-Credit Good Model

_b

D�Z�� �E �Z�

E�Z�

D�Z�

Z*Z0Z1Z2

τ τ τ

B + g

g

g

τ

Page 65: N? iht|@? ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i*faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/research/fiscal/review5.pdfN?_iht|@?_ ?} |i 6 tU@* AiLh) Lu |i ˘h Ui wi i* w@ hi?Uia ˇh t| @?L@?_Aihh)a

0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3 0.35-0.1

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

Inflation in Previous Period

Infla

tion

in N

ext P

erio

d

Figure 3: Evolution of Inflation Under Aggressive Interest Rate Rule and non-Ricardian Policy

π*π

0