i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n...

43
bJoA1qcq gJ fljj CLCqL !UCIU1TU © UO1CC !2 AU O iJJC 20(11CC' poi.i cciou o cxr uoi o cxcccq i,io bisi.bpe w pc dnoiGq iporn cxbJ!c bCuu!22!ou © J2 P /kkflJCIJJ H' Bfl!CL O1JC4O CO!.2U! uq bOJO Y b1U!' VII LJU2 .C2GLACq' LC 1JJ02G 0j flJC IUJJ0L2 uq UOi 1JJ02C 0j JC W1!OIJVI BULCVfl O ECOIJOWIC KC2CLCW !u I i.U ouj EWUCG cuq uq oucwi.? couowjc yU? obu!ou2 cxbLcq IJJC JoLJq UJC 0L COUJWCU2 uq 2flC210U2' JJJ12 bbCL 12 bL1 0 J4BEK2 Lc2cn.cp bLouluJ2 b1.pcibu2 IIJ IJC !IUCUJL!01J uq UmCLO 2W!UL2 1 ]4CM AOLI( flU!ACL2!A ),9IC flUAGL2A uq CU%' h0 JW1JJC J3C11 BCW1JF' bGL KCUC1J Qflq0 KC KCU joop 9uq IJJC C°°° cwo 3\1 122OU2 jp12 brbci 12 IVC bLcj!uJprn1.? ACL2!ou o cjwblCL !' ipc OflUE0U ,qououbp 'lflIJC c"p'q i'w on 1OO 22CJJA2CU2 VACUJIC I4VflOJ1VT BfIKEVR Oh ECOMONIC KE2EVKCH ft04flU bTIL J4O' 140 0j0 V' bC2CUfl O!13C40 COL2CHT J1!HCW H' B(IUCL V]4D EXCHVWE KylE CKI2E2 Oh YO1'1ElVKA COOBDII4VJJO4 V CEI4IEK-bEWIbHEKA !ODE ]4BEK IAOBKIMO bVbEK 2E11E2

Transcript of i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n...

Page 1: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

bJoA1qcq gJ fljj CLCqL !UCIU1TU © UO1CC !2 AU O iJJC 20(11CC'poi.i cciou o cxr uoi o cxcccq i,io bisi.bpe w pc dnoiGq iporn cxbJ!c bCuu!22!ou© J2 P /kkflJCIJJ H' Bfl!CL O1JC4O CO!.2U! uq bOJO Y b1U!' VII LJU2 .C2GLACq'

LC 1JJ02G 0j flJC IUJJ0L2 uq UOi 1JJ02C 0j JC W1!OIJVI BULCVfl O ECOIJOWIC KC2CLCW!u I i.U ouj EWUCG cuq uq oucwi.? couowjc yU? obu!ou2 cxbLcqIJJC JoLJq UJC 0L COUJWCU2 uq 2flC210U2' JJJ12 bbCL 12 bL10J4BEK2 Lc2cn.cp bLouluJ2b1.pcibu2 IIJ IJC !IUCUJL!01J uq UmCLO 2W!UL2 1 ]4CM AOLI( flU!ACL2!A ),9IC flUAGL2A uq

CU%' h0 JW1JJC J3C11 BCW1JF' bGL KCUC1J Qflq0 KC KCU joop 9uq IJJCC°°° cwo 3\1 122OU2

jp12 brbci 12 IVC bLcj!uJprn1.? ACL2!ou o cjwblCL !' ipc OflUE0U ,qououbp

'lflIJC

c"p'q i'won1OO 22CJJA2CU2 VACUJICI4VflOJ1VT BfIKEVR Oh ECOMONIC KE2EVKCH

ft04flU bTIL J4O' 140

0j0 V' bC2CUfl

O!13C40 COL2CHTJ1!HCW H' B(IUCL

V]4D EXCHVWE KylE CKI2E2Oh YO1'1ElVKA COOBDII4VJJO4V CEI4IEK-bEWIbHEKA !ODE

]4BEK IAOBKIMO bVbEK 2E1�1E2

Page 2: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

OM 1q nthoW M3IT4 Q1 3nu1

J3QOM yslaHqLgaq-sIaThHD A MOITA'IIG$IOOD YSIAT1OM 10

HLID HTA$1 HO4AHDXH UMA

TDAHTHA

norisl3qoo3 lo nwobAsid £ lo anripno bits 1ii1sbom d1 1sns iqsq r1T

3isI nsthx3 its u nuli Fi3nuoD vIdqFI3 3no1q-noia11th lo iihor11us vis33nom (1i nw13d

.bo112 bnsm3b is its 'd iid i i3n) 3113 11311w 33iv3b isnoiisfln1-iis its s 15up3 3d 1211m ifl3n3d bits :333mrn 3d oi b3nisli2no3 i 13r1qn3I 3(13 111 noivzt3qooD

di lo iah3 bxi1st3n £ (131(1w ni sw owl 3a831 35 rs 513(11 isdi I3bom wO .Ils iol

.313m3 (sm m312 315! 3nsr13x3

3iln3bom £ i (13nqrI3 3(11 lo 3flO231 3V11B13qoo3 b3nis112no3 3(11 113(1w i IIi1 3rIT

w31 £ sd 2noiisuIsv3b is1 s(1 muhdiIiiip 3viisl3qooo-non 3111 311(1w norlSulsv3b nommo Isubivthth ii11 03 itI vi h3nuo3 v,idqhI Ii ii'13 3iI nBf13x3 nA .3flifluo3

ion i boik 131n3D 3111 ,2B3 bno 3f11 nI .in3m3515 3vlsl3qoo3 3111 no 33fl51 03 3VIifl33f1i

3mo 33 ;rnuhdiliup3 3V11z13qoo3 b3fli5112fl03 3(11 (1! fiOlisLJIBV3b 1R13n3 £ 13t1 03 1f1J0fl3 31E1

33ns1 vIsi3nom (ft nb1sm jnuhdiliup3 (1sT4 di ni 31JIsv3b bluow 3fl1flUO3 13r1qn3 3(11 10

3W .Isnoilsi 'C13vit11o3 ai ctzsM 03 1101a13V31 ir11 nI .visiioinsqx srnm m3l 3111 111

£Q-1 iii 51Mg 343 lo 3qs11o3 3111 fI1131qI33n! iol 3Idslsq !u13u £ s 1,bom iit3 13110

rn,aioD ohs3nsiO l3liufl .H (113111W

3irnono3H 10 in3mnsqQ iti1oq bits irnonoH lo 1IIJ351 III 3mo$1 10 (11a13vInU 3bfldffl5D 10 (ii13ViitU

Q1 3fI3112O siV nib1iufl nido51 ni1uA smo$1 1ôIOO 3IJ113VA biwbi

YJATI QQQ FID 3bfldffl6D MOUDMDI UEITIWJ

$138J4 bits

iinc .A 0105q 1oo(13 no1iW woibooW

1i13Vi1IU f10i33f1fl1

1O1-t48O 1J4 noinh

Page 3: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

J,Oflc) COOLqIJçOU 9Uq 6XC}WU6 LS6 CL262

B'J4J &uq 66CI!A6 6xGJJ9IJ6 204.JJG bGLib}JGL

J /6JJLG IIJJJ boeJçrAG GXçGLINJJcJG2 1OW UJOIJGL? 6XbU2TOU2 TUo D°62 cOOb6Lçou iii j,GL!bpGL?. mJ€ qGLeuc6

23 JJJ6 coobGLçT GcJrnJTpLIITUJ .•i QbTw mouGçr.X boIrc? TJuqeL 2?JJJUJGcL!c coob6L!ou . 52

2 I bOJ!C? 9L66IU6Uç8 9vq UJOIJBJ poiouçj 6dfI!2.

2 IIJm6çLiC COOb6LS4OU !' b6LJbp6L

3 wp 6dInJpLfrw5 ff6cçiOU J1UC4JOU2 11.1 JJ& uq cp bGLibp6L?4• r QbçiIU9 IJJOIJGT. bopc2 Ju JJG E6L!BPGL?LP'-'!' UfflJJ6L uq 6 o LGJ!IJm6U42 !u bGL!bpGL 12

3f JJJG 261m-LGqrIcGq OLUJ Jf32 b61" o boJTc?.-uJsL2 1335 JJJG bGL!bPGL GOIUJçLIG2 JO

2 I LP6 C6U6L COHUL?

3 V C6ULb6L!bP6L uJoqGJ

EXCPIJ LG CL!262 uq 2b6crrjccTA6 CJ2 2

i 1ucLoqncciou 3

COU4U2

Page 4: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

o CoIJ2Jqcr. ipicp cci LIIJ62 o p6 9UT6 Uij bopc?. cooLqu&vJou J6&2!pJG 11JpipçX ( wjj cpe qG LprJTc?) o & jjxq 6Xcp9IJG Lc6 L61IXJG !c !2 CLIf(4ff

ju !A6JJ6L uq poti JuL-boubp6L coob6Lc!ou 6UJJUC62 cp6 &-COIIUcLIS2.

NUJJ p6 OcJJ6I. sdrnJipLut iqçp nucooLqrs9cGq JrLG q6A&JiIc4JOIJ2 p) i "pc oCOITUL62 J0L cJJG 2flXJ6 6XOGUOII2 pocJc O J1JCLO6COIJO1U!C nuqcm6uJ2 J6L62JJOMIJ 6 cJJccLcc6Lr6q p? cOoLqpW;6q 2?UJG4LIC 2IJ3JJ LG1flIflU6IJ p Ji

edfnJpLrnu 9JJocJou JJUqGL coob6L!ou mou bGL!bP6L2 COJWL62 !2EOL 2011J6 L6JTçJOI32 O 41J6 6XOGUOf1 8OCJ O LIJCLOGCOIJOUJ1C6L66 o bojc? cooLqJucrou iuou coimLs ou b6L!bpGL oj cp 22GIJq6A9JIrcrou tç ru Aaiu L6 jj €uqouoii iipj citc q6b6rlq oil JJ6lutub ru GXCU6 L6 OflOlidU rp9'uqoumGrrç o b6 &uq A6L6IJITUJ6L O COTULT6 cJTc qecq p9'uqou cJ16 jxcq 6XCJI9IJ6 LG L6!IlJG JJ66UCG Jjfl2 bbGL MIJJ U9J?6 GdrnJ1pL !' JJ!CJJ OJJGL JJ!U2 P6!IJ 6dHJ JG

O 1ç2 CITLL6UC? D°6 coobeLc!ou 9Wou b6L!bp6r. GOI!UcL!62 1U9JCG 9 qrIGL-2JJOCJ( TJ 4}JG C6IJ6L COJIUL 6u6Lçu bLGuTL coiiq 6u6LJTq bbL6c!-

c°'q rmbcç ou pG 2pJp42. o 9'u GXC9UG LG 2X24Gm o & qmuq

9iJ GXCUG LG boficrG2 I3SO COJIU4Li6 LIJ9fflU rib beL!bpsL? oTIJOL62 cJJG WjG bjsXq pA 4JJG CO0LU0U (oL jcjc o cooLqrucou) o IIJOIJGçLACOUCJII2JOLJ2 LGiC}J6q EiI?}JTIJ 2ITCJJ L9UJGMOLJ 11J9A 6 W2J691IJ 2 JJG iJ9JA2I26XCJJIJ6 LG bttiçA TIJ2 C6U6L cOruLA pi bb6L PI6 LH6 JJç }JG

biuc O U 6XOGUOf2 jJocjc 4p J1IJ6LIJJG2 2çpiJTçA OJ JJ6 C11LLGIJ?

ou cjie qnacrLr6Irc bLopJGIu cGq pA LGbL62Guc!A6 COITUçLA 111 JG b6LTbJJ6LA nilEircpiu JJ6 p.&InG1JOLJ o nuiJ4GL9 bG3 1U0q6J2 jAb!crJJA pGA oc1r2

I/\tO2 JJGOLGçiCrJ IJ9JA262 cLG JJ6 q6usr2G O JxGq GXCJJUG L9G LG1WGsmq6LJAIJ JJG 6XGpIJG L8'6 LL9'U6I11GIJ1

CITLL6UCA CLI2IR 9 bLimLJJA CL12J o bocA cooLqrucrozJ 6CJJU!2UJcooLqTucJoxr jj coucLpcI1Jou o bb6L !2 bLoAqc & UJO6J 21I1IJ6 O IJ-CL1212 o u GXC}J9UG LG 2A2GIJJ 12 2Xmbçoru o IIT2IIWCJGIJc o ruGGcçiAG bojicA9'cGq cptonj C1A6 coob6Lçrou uiou bojicA uJGL2 jwoe pA qejjrnçrors rrpG qr2LuBrAG O 1IJçGLu1OIJ9 WOU67LA 2 cpGA crir G GOfIIIGL-cojjb26 o içou ooqw HOM6A6L 2AuJUJ6cL!C q2crLp9irc62 bGL 2G IJGGq uo

bLG221JL62 u JJG JQ(J2 MGLG CGA q66LJiJIJul 0j VJJGCJILLGIJCA CL262 2RG6bU EITLob6 !u J8O5 Jq T?33 113 2IJJG tA&X rur-6U6L coiiuiA fluqofrpcGqJA Q€iWil mcçiou bJJ'AGq cu1crJ LOfG ILl

CJNUG qo lJO 2IJLAJAG 26L101T2 2AuJuJGçLic qi2cJTLprJc62 oujuu 113bo2c-WL jn2coLA bLoAiqG2 eIuqeucG 2A2çGIU2 o jxq (oL drrnr-xeq) GX-

j juLoqrrc4oU

Page 5: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

SIdiaEsI i isc{qhsq 111 noiiqoo sri bi 9r1 no blitid ew .aiIn irio -isJni on rbirlw o3 niboDD 1frQ 0S1O \ OI1fr £ I9bfIfJ hio

bn9 su Di3n9bi si tii 9rxrrnOD aeInrr 9Jd&nO1ns ai n9mesr Inoitsn bssnth1oo3 1o t 9rLt rriJoftteeH .oq t 318119w lo Isvel L&Mfl9bi n niv&f qu

1inoiior{ A .L8i1svo1inxoD awo lo ai nsmsiuipsi rbua nri8oqmi d E9iI -.BffDoe &iiswani nthivoiq lo pi1idioq sc{ ieqm&f nL8ranoa Thips

hnibl 9n1t lo a9insninoD 9rsvb lo 9DfI391 9f1 ni e1qmxs io' .noitnrufI 3i3

lo bn 13fl9 en{ lo weiv lo Jniioq 9rLf moil iqq inro iii b9s'LsnI (si1inIro3 ien{qnsq sn1f o b9qa9i L{iIW i'n t9 9fOf{W S .s 19n{qn9q sn1

1in nriiqobs 'd 1Io-19i9d 3d slqioniiq ni bkro3 si1iTwoD 1sn1qil9q en1I

sn1 ised o (bsbe1e 1mobnBi fdiBaoq) medt lo wel s Ino eiuiipsi oc Jsn{ s1dsrn nbLBm lo 'ti1idiaoqmi sdt tsn1 eveiled eW .aaoD rienntaujbs isa99n men1 rbJJ eIsm nisievoe 1snxoisn lo io1 er{ bnis fn9ffr'8q-ebi iisniinioo

'Iiups IMnoiiod thnoisn s niaoqmi tznI 2worf ieqsq air[T .Jniianoni-ernL sm rmiiidilhrpe bs3sniEriooDmJ aS ot betsnthiooo s moil I13iWa 9ni n1LsJanoD

1Sni9frLSbIIIJ1 0t ?IDOIIE ei1t lo 9fl81 9fflOE iol thnoisi !9Vit39ll0D 3d -bs need evsr{ &no1 nriIIfiIth-u1s Ic slidilinpe n0itSt39qX9 Lsnjoisi 9fqitIIJM

n9m99iA ets.H 9fLS±?X 9ni lo 9Bqslloc eniI lo noisrisJqxe e1dieoq s as benxsv snff ev1oviii ieerboqr1 lo evilsnieila niism sifT .COI this @I nihnb (1VI$13)

noiibbs nI .ath3nemsbnurl lo ioivsnfed ed 10 amiet in 3qs11o) sr1 lo noitsnsIqxe -nennsbmñ 9ILI fI0ffI5 ,

(abonf lo emoibrra io) o 1snoitsn Ic ioivsnfed nievib Ii3aiisq SIS n{i9w nevi nls9d evsnf Jsrli aIsJ

bns 1St5IIOifi 1snoisn neIeVth niifti '1dsmuesxq 4evsl to timi io ehq ainiemnevom Isliqso LiDnSnfi fsnioi&rnsnii Ic noitsn!iedi1 er1 bns eiDiIoq 1sD8f!

-.slqxs a1s3nemsbnxñ Ic \1O9JS3 9iLt orii ffi lebom mO .bA 91ni2 enli iebrw Ic 9IIJ1 sdt bebnfiDni oi benemus ai JnsmabmR Ic i9 snif bebivoiq nioitsri

-s i9tnI9D etht bus 9flflIJ0D 19r1qrIsq sn{t Ic iorvsrfsd enft i isi1 er1 -cm elqiMiim 1o i1idioq 9nI fiio 9hr! ton eob nl3sOlqqs mo eliriW .xer1o

s1in nvi nibIJbnri) eIs3nIsnriabrIuI iI9V[ ioI sildiliripe (aiJoens3asiani) 18un9m -11199 elqiffiim edT .eispinu sis sndLEwps Ii fl9V9 niuouft aso 1i (erris erLf Ic ns ioI siidiliiipe isnemom eIqiMlJm no 1si tasinoo d anoisnrs1qxe siidil

alslriemsbrml noi,lsnulnoo3 i1oq Isniotsnisni lo sloi enlt no ai ieq.sq Birb lo airDol rxism 9nfT

-eni 0 .meia etsi ensnfoxe us lo 'i1idsa snI niinimieeb lOtDSI eI s as s) bsaqslloo M513 ed srfI ti1idiasoq ei±t nfifnfirf 1iowsmsiI 1sieio aitht sif has ais1sm olloq tsnjoiisn rionns noiJsisqoo3 nzebffiuiani lo saIJI3Dsd

.'19n1qi19q enLt lo iedmem eni io1 siorb 1SIIOis1 19Vi91I0D s asw emoxftro -non o 9visi9qoo3 moil nftiwa s 1o aeneuipeeno enf a9IsaS ieqsq erfT

-ne io nislqxe oci a9ob uud 2sh1ucoD 'ien1qneq snf noms lOivSff9d evisieqoo boiieq erfi ui benuixo fIDtiwE £ r1DiJ srf ievewod 9Dn9biv9 ai sieuiT .i ssineob

ns es1iitaoq ton eeob lebom iuro snf stoT4 .aiaii snf nibeceiq 'Is3sthemrni ISdT .isniqiie erf bus iefEIsD erb nsswsd qir1anois!ei i1sii enf iii snsnfo

erLi eiujo 10 .ixcor1uioin1i (.s\&A) evisieqooo-non ed o bemnreas ai qinfanois1ei

Page 6: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

2

EWFAoc€ irq obrrnoxi bo1j olr icp j,t.X C1IIG o GXCjThUG L96 iIThc&prpA "crc zuboLçucG o JJ64A6 (6um.j !u JI2l x 6LGuqnw) ot c1o€ (ELuc6)

JJLJJGd6 CJ9JG LG thGJl qociiuiuq PA K6IU j116LU [raa E!CP6UU uq MAbJo

poc bopci 4JJ9 7LG (poiiuq O p6) !UGOU226Uc thCI3 cJJ6 U6JtT!6 q66IJCG o9uq 4JJ6 UJGCPrU!C2 O 9 2b6crrJsc7AG CJ JJGIJ IJc!O1JJ IIçJJOL1çI62 bJa2JrG &q-CL1262 JJJG L2 bbLocp bou6GL6q p?. [J} OCii22 Oil JJG cIMUJU JJG JGL9çflL6 6L6 L6 prcjj? bbLocpe vo WOq6JJpJ 6XC}JIJG L9.G

EXCPU6 L46 CL2G2 rnq 2b6cnJ!AG CJ(2

OITL COIJ2çLITCçIOW

p64tA66IJ ftAo 9.JJOC9.p0U2 36CJ1OIJ 12C1J2262 IJ6 EISI/'I CJ12!2 !' cP JJJ OOJJOMG 2GCcTOU Oil 22'JIUJJGçLIC coob6t9.çioir cloIJ exbjoi qTJGLGIJCG2

JJJG tOIJLcJJ 26COu 2 q6Ao6q 4JJG cp9.L9.ccGL!9.c!OU O JJG j,p 6dcrpL!IrwJ!6Lc1ILG Oil 6XCJJ&UG L9.6 CLr2G2 !U 26COU P16 bL6u J 26Cc!Ofl

JJJG bcb6L 12 OL9.UTGq 9.2 OJJOth2 TGL 9. pLT6 L6I CIA 0Jdcriou2becrIJ9.ciAC ccc9.cJ Jpi2 b9.bGL bLoAJqe2 6OL6G9.J meIAoLc o 9.qqLG22bGLcGbJoil o JGAGJ o coobeLtçTou Tu bopc W9.JUU 6U6L9.6 6UGL9.fl6oircome o COIICGLGq GLOLç f66b 41JJ6 JcvI co6cp6L 1 C}J9.IJG !U cr16

cp€ EJ5I'I Oil 9. IJGIA 249.JDJG b9p: JJ62G bopcX WG9fiL62 MGLG p? uo W6&U2 pG

p?. CO2W6C CJJ9.IJ6 UI cp CCLW9.U 2COJTIU L9ç& tI9.2 CJ69.LJ? TU2IIWCICU bjrcqGI9pT9.cou o 2JuJ6 cUI.LGUc (cpe Jp9.) ou jçp o 6bcGlup6L 9.ccolub9.uTGq9.2 9.13 !IJqC9OL O 9. 29.JJ !U EJSJ1'I 9.2 9. bopc? cooLqJIJ9.c!OIJ InGc9.U2m1 LP6LU9.J.C6L2 ILl G9.LJ? 6b46mpGL J33 MGLG GOLLGCçJ2 !UcGLbLGcGq p2 pIJ9.ucr9.J IU9.4Gf7

JJJJ6LG !2 C9.2JJ9 6AI6UC6 cP9.I JJG L6d(IGU brrppc CJ9.2JJG2 9.IUOIJ EIUObU boJ!c2JJ9.bbGuGq cpe €uq o vunac m cpc cpueq cp6 mooq o U9.irCT9. LJG2p61. T5 JUc6L62 q1GLGucT9.2 -g-c\ ]JG D"39.1.J IA6LG 2iLbLI2JIJJ? joIi jjicc

9. GIA IA6GJ2 pOL6 JJG oiruq !I3 ruJq 2€bçGIU-2LtGJ?. OC1TUJ6U6 9.22G btic qq uoc 6tIT 9.uçJcib9.çG pG GL1212 JIIJcIJ ACL

O JJG hG4bJJ6L? i'- GIUbILIC&J r91116 ou fl/ CLi212 T p9.2 p6613 GXçGiJ-

4JJ9. JJJ2 OJT1GOUJG U3iJJç }J9.A6 66I3 9. COIJGGcIAGJ2 L9.cIOiI9.J CJJOIcG OL llJ6UJGL2

\cicco" 6C9.U2G O IU2ITWC1611 coobGL9.iou 9.LUOU 139çIOIJ9.J bopc UJ9.J6L2 9.Uq

OfIL cJJ6OLGJC9.J L&1JJ6IAOLJ pIJJJTp2 cp bo22pJcA cpc cr'sEAT COJJ9.b2Gq

b6L!bP6L? 9 9. tAJJOJG JJO!AGA6L i1ucp9.u6qIAJJGIJ 9.G2 coob6L9.!AGJ2\ JJJ6 CGUGL2 L69.Cc!OIJ ITIJCcO1J A2—-A2OIJ69.L boj1c7 /AJJJ pG IA6U bGLJbp6L rc UOu-COObGL9.ciLGjA

rmb[rc9.cIou 4JJ9. JJGL6 12 9. L91JG O A&J1162 OL }J6 pTUq9.UJGLJc9.J OL IAJJ!CP cr16 C6I

9.Cc10U2 9.IJJOIJ JJ6 11J6I1J6L2 o cj-16 b6L!bPGLX' I 9.CJ OLIL IJJOCJGJ }I9.2 JJ6 131CCIAGU flU9.IU6IJ9.J2 G l6L6IJ q6b6UqIJ Oil ?JJG IJ9.JIL6 O JJ6 2cL9.cG!C lJç6L-9.CcJOU2 CO26il pX cJJG CGUGL (çpG A9.J116 !c 9.22IU2 4O L2 IJJOUC? 2cocj<) MJJ OL

Page 7: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

cL9Cç2. LJou9i exbGcç ou pocp (oue—bGLoq) !UGLG2c L'ç2 iiq rJoWpJIcimbGq6cç CLGqIpTJTçX o b6 bGL€cç cErbic2J wopiJ!c? ruq ouG-bGLioq cou-9€ mcrJbJG iu2ç9iJnJeon2 Gd1nJipL i1 bobirt uioqcj !U JTçGLcITLG FJ2211U1G2

pj& cjJ 6xbGcfl!ou2 W€ p6cAA6€u cJJG bLAç6 vq Biippc 2GCOL W2 cpe coInmiwGuj qcuq p6 mioi1uceq brLç? !2 orjX rub6qGccJ7. cLGq-

nUqUJG1Jc9J24G xmoinicq bLJ lu p6 Gcouq ou& moueçt?. bojTc? obcrirjj?. Lbouq2moueç9tX boJTc?: iii L2 ou IuouG?, 2IIbbJk 12 cou Jaç6IJ zp 66U2G ocJ9II26) GJJ6LJ obçnnj (couciueuc) bopc7 LIIJG coiupuJ2 LG1UJ62 O

6C62 !JJ6L oi uoç &puqou cp b1A (ço 6XGLCT26 62cbGCOU2GL2 C02f 2 &Uq PGIJ6U2 O W9U 1JI3 JJ6 bG OL UOGL bGLroq uq L-

corrciueuc LITJ6 OL eççrii J16 6XCLJ6 L&G EGP b6LToq flJG boJ!c UJGLJIJIJC1J IJJLJ642 J52JJGL 6XCJJ91T6 L6 CL12I2 !2 rIUbJGW6IJ4ç1OIJ O2uq\oL cJJG GS2!PI4 O q66UTJ & b cp 2 p61IJ p cJJG JUcGLIJ!OUJbbLocp rn 6XCUG 1cL!2i2 pa uoçpu o LG2GLAG2

p2uqou }JG GXCJJ91JG Lf6 bL14 fruqeL C6LIJ C1LCflUJ24IJCG2 yGCOLq!I3 4O cJJ!2

u 1ui&jouiX pJ pn uoç gu?. bL!c6 IpG?. w GLGOLG uq obçiuj o12 266U comurçm€rrç cpuoo?. oL L&JT1GJJ nuq€ppj coU2GdflGIJcG2 oMpO &IG 22f1UJG AG ooq LGf20LT2 b6 CIILLGUC?. - 0L GxrubG[r] uq ou uq iipeijuq [ Ocfcr JO0J2 gç obçnuu bojic?. UJJGL22GJ [mi m] D6 MOCIC uq QLrJJT [i] DLGU uq J/\W2OU [rT1 J/I920u

JAJJ6 2GCOUq bbioscjr cpiubou6q p?. jooq Bpi1q uq flOLIJG [j]111 W.JIJCJJ LJO CJ OCGITT.2 uq b 21TLAA62L626L1.G2 jqrn O flJ 6XC}J9U6 L9'ç€ CL122 uq GOJJgJD2G o bLiç?. UOJGL OIJG!U2cIJGOfl2 6cImppLlEr LG bopj 0136 CpLCcGLGq p? LIlLY Oil rIxç6LIJcoIJJb6Loq qnuu Mpicp xq 6XCJJJJ6 L6 LGJWG pi uoç ?.Gç coJJbeGqqiuiou o pe bLJAçG 2GCOL OU OIJG bLçicrqrL L6iW6 o GxbGcççrou2 GAGL?.

pscome uqecGLu Je ïç q€b6uq2 ou Y6SC 1flJCGLW LG.&Lq1U COOL-

q2cn22Ou T11 C4TT! [io]) ju c o r 2b6cIJJcrJ.6 JVCJCbGcç2 g 2ITWCi6U 1J11IU6L O O4JJ6L 6IJ42 MJJ qo 20 2U3G chuG (ccpijiojq J6A6J p?. J36L26JJ JJJGU 130 0116 Mill TCJ( JJG CIILLGIJC?. 111JJ622 2JJG GX-20 130 2!uTe 2b6cJTJ9coL cu qLJAG LG2GLAG2 cJJGiL 131313111311131

Ic (pi.€ 2uJjj ue MOLJJ LG cL6qlç-coIJ2çL9lIJGq uq qo uoc coJnqG)013 OCCIILLGIICG o g 2b6CIIJ!AG 49CJc Ou2iq6L UJ4CG2 !AGLG GIJc2

11 2 21T?62JGq opcjq {J] bojcrn 2'LG i1JCO1J2i2GIJç ttçp gb6 0IJJTA C011-

JjJG GXCç o ir xcpiro 19ç6 GL12J2 JJ0MGAGL uJg?. uoç G qGç6L1iJiU6cpG q?.uinic oj g coJJba6 pL011JJ poiç p?. & 2bGCfIJc1AG &cc&CJc

couqlciou uq !uc6L62c-a6u2!4!I. iuou2. qmuq bLoAqG2 g 21u3bJ6 LgUJGMoLC ouoc 6&2!PJG yqqu bGL6cç TuçGLuiouJ cbicj tuoprjiç?. g M6J lJ0-LpJL&G

IU!2P o pceq GXC9UG L42G L6JI1JG GI6U i 2b6cJJJch!.G MGLG

u (xouon) Joi.6L pom.Tq ou Tuç6LIJçJoLTJ L62GLAG2 119'çi1L9J coJb2GGXCGG2 cpG LOiIqJ 0 1130116?. q€mvq gç g xeq excjjuG rç MT3613 cocrbjGq6XGT3UG LçG bgij1* ju LflUJIJ2 woqej qouJG2cic cLGqç Gxbu2ou bGL2!2VGuJ?

Page 8: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

nsrnnobn6d 311J o xoJa svhq 9r1 d beft Ii1iddoiq r{t toefii .sw

visnom er{ neriW .boiieq fx9n 9u1 niurb 191i3111 i1oq r1 d eq r1 lo 9tsvnq sf1 -cs 1dth91 irnmoDe1q o ti1id er1 sv&1 ton ob esiJiiorItxc aboifa (aIJonox9) no 1no ton neni3noD 9Th 2911ri iIoq neJiano-91rIi iob

19v91 sr1 no o21 ftid ,bnmsb sis bn. ivitDnbo1q ite3mob i3o1ev o s19d 1th3iqT .anoisbsqxs 192 9Svi1q uOn9obn9 no 2i iuf 3 29SW lo

2nox3b9qx9 iisii3 9Bnib1oo 3n9 s3viiq c{3icfw ill mhrhdilhfp9 9110 3ixs 111w

i rnniidiliups 13on 91111w ss3i ai3ni Isnimon bn sw Lsnimon wol no sitf 3r13 23Dn8c1 silT .2s3i 3sisini bns esw !&rimori r1iif cf bssil9r8r1c sis bohsq sf13 niiicb benobn.sds 3 on ai i3hsq s3s.r 9n8rbX9 bseq i3nerwD B8 03 913311 asil 109fI3 aA .9110 1)110392 s113 iii wol innhdiJiups 3xfi 9r13 iii itir1

-39qx9 aiob s3viiq edi lo noinib1ooD 9113 nilibnu e3irz$±rn 9113 3nod8 bsw3iv 3d n sq srl3 lo 3iIid$iv 9(13 rIinuf1fl9bfflr svBw sviJJ3lirn9q2 s anoi33

o3 ai JfT .isr{3o srI3 o3 anoi3Bbsqxs lo 9ffl(91 9110 moil rh3iw8 1191)1)112 i as 21 aii s3ii 9n&1c)xs n lo nirni3 b.sxs 3(13 r{38o1qq$ bno 9113 ill 0218

.93$n11111939b111 33 svitsLcJr)9q2 8 rl3iw esbi3rlio3 Si2ilO 9381 9il&13x9 118 ['I1 rIsnrLJ1>I ill 89v19291 Iii qmi4 s3siib sifT 311188 Isi3neD 9r13 lo asvi asi 18noi3srris3ni 9(13 no

2i 39)hBfll 9fL8fl3x9 9(13 111 a9i3um3loqqo 9B13id'LS 3uo 91111 o3 1aes5Oen al ;t$1i3

9vi3iaoq £ lo 11o138q1313116 LII 9f10ffl iol brI8meb srI3 iii qoib 1srni3 £ 'd bsninils3sb 03 )1t3 evi3J3hJDsq2 8 lol icdT .eieh sif 3 tIs noi38iDslqsb Dfl911IJ3 lo stsi

93131 en$±)X9 Ii !19v9W0H i.9vi3i2n9a3e9193rn ed 3eum bn8msb 9110ffl 111DI)O

s rxthn919b lo 838oD 918119W 9Vi8293X3 03 252flO291 thnoi36i as iisea eis 892i13

9vi31311J39q8 .s lo 931198d$ 9113 Iii 111390 sm S98fl9 11OIJE 38113 91di820q '111L8319) ei 9113 lo 3ivi3ianea 3aeis3ni srl3 lo as1biei .e.i B9V19291 18110138rfl93111 no

bns) sIdia2oq 1nL83193 918 218113 8 111b9O91q 892801 9V1929$I .'9fl0ffl 101 bnsm9b o2 bsbnem '1938i1qo1qq8

, [11} bIth32dO lo )howems11 erI3 iii oalz (1e)1i1 Jeom

9101 on s1q binow . sq 838801 3V19291 3iiU t.noiaiemth 1$39rxOfn £ 91)1113111 03 as .3i1oq 9381 9n.sr13xe erf3 niriirrrxs3eb ni

Isnoi3si I9born 1)1113 bl9IiadO d be3&ovbs 3noi 91{ 3 9)183 9W 198 aiil3 nI 'snoM .noi33nlñ asol 11310qm93193rn ns eirninim 38113 819)Ism 'Di1oq oi32emob

131)121103 3bi1qx9 9W ob 1011 9vi3ianea-3291e3ni 3d o3 bSmx;Bas 3on 21 basmsb ai tho ii,o aA .svi3Detdo na as 10 3riisl3anoD a as 1911319 29V19291 1srioi3srne3ni

3i1idiv 9113 nLn1m1e3sb ill noiJ8nibloo9 ioi1oq lo alevel 3nsl3Iuib lo 91019(13 289132

eiaLsns s113 3irno 0815 SW ieqiq e113 lo 1101819V a1113 iii 93si ensff3xe b9xfi i3 lo noii839eqxs ef1J lo ea3a 3axfi 9(13 asslbb8 3ori oh 9W .9.1 noi3snno1 98W lo

Iifiddoiq sr{3 rbiilw iii rbsoiqq$ n&ninX erft o rlOi&193X9 vi3mIoD-1t[rJm nu3ei3rii nA 'nsm wod rio abnqsb Itu19D ni3 if tiw vtkiaq bexft 13rnJOD VI9dqi19 £ lo eqJIIoD sni lo

bris rbsh9O iii bninol ed ns eq iieif3 bsnobui.sds 'bssiLs svsd 9i1nzjO Vjelfqfl99 191130 2 -b9 i1ii1 fflOñ flOi3st9qX9 lo d3iw nI9bbI1 s 9vi3iaae-e!eith i bxismeb '9flOffl nedWE

ciii lo noisno bernrorioiq £ ni3iw betsbos besbni i eq ciii lo vti1idibs73 wol oJ iilidi .eriom Diiemob ioI bnisnnieb

Page 9: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

as as.sw Lsnirrion nbIT .iotsa ildrcq 91b bns 10b92 svhq Sib risswsd sms bluoib 11 .thisincrxevo Dbemob id rththin noiar3sb Di!oq BuooI SW fISVi

B911fl t&b Isbom SIb lo 9IIJIfl Sib £i WIffbOfl Bi 9191{3 t&IJ i9V9W0E1 L9F) 9d (svbsleqoo3-rron io svisisqooo) nsvi 'iol) £ildilisJps anosri nani sIqiJiim tno

nssvTSd sms noiLsbsqxe sib iii (aisLm 'siIoq sib norna sma srb lo a9fSfl

aiidiliiips sldiasoq lo 9a 9rb no s1 .219)IJ3ffl Di1oq sib bna anss stavFiq

a iii naib \rnJo3-ithIm a iii si.sI 11abnatadna (Iniaiiqiua ori) ai Diioq 1snobanistni lo s1ox sviabb sib eae iefnso sa1q o ai Lso irso aA .Isbom

tqo sw ernisi otai snsrbxs bsxi a 10 'ii!idaiv sib fILflhfIfl9t9b Hi nobanibioo 9JqiJIicIrI 1o aia1sris Lsrrnol sib ssabad 9V.591 of airno1 airb hub o f on isbio iii

.ahdiliups aiio9iianaani

leborri 1qh-n9D A

Dnt9iTrIrrr15 I1iñ sw rbiulw lo V aifi ej1t sirmo I + V lo afaiauio3 amono>s sifT silT .sucs sib al tasl sib sliuiw insaa sib Ic cnst sib nsasIqei bria

Lsnisrion a asbivoiq 3i anI .a3thai19)a1ar{D 9L1IflJJ 991ib asif 19fl9D rbwoi lo sai sib nail i iec{tai Isvs1 sib nthsia 'd sloifw a as sib iol iJqtiJo lo lsvsf tst siLt nsewtsd naqeioaib on ai sisrb bnoDs2 •iqo siLt lo

siLt ath,slIa said ausnobafthii on taib oa tuqiiio (nsnrolqme-lluR) 1sbnsoq bns ssiimioo 118 aiLt bsrrrnesa si ti biirfT .rmshdiliucps Jrisaianoo-srnii a iii 1flOflOD9

aib r19119D sib iLtiw fsviaIc!Dx9 asiviss bna sboo 18si sbait -xsrlqns sib iii sbsit no bssoqmi si rrobiiesI ufoiss oVI .s1dii19n si sbai vjisrfqn9-atni ai -iq 'ccl lda1ebiBnoD sis1suia sib asfiulqmis noiq1imeaa suiT .auniab faiorisrifi iii

bsfalsi anoitaisbiano thbnsaasni ujd eviansni-aideLs lo noisaimo silt nitirn iLtiw siicJiaqsb lo ainioq sub siasifqms oT .sssnsvitLteqmo isdquis-aiini ot

-hirnth sib niubiw siaIana mo 58D oI ssoorb sw emrstamsfl1 zi3aixs sib ot sqa9m biabnats ati riiiqoba SrIIa \3i!oq 1S9H0ffl 1anoitarnsrn na lo *toW9ffLBñ lai

abouf a lado1 lo baqnii sib no asnid noibintsnoD Iaobsiosib mO .snoirIevnoo isi1qims sib lo asi3iloq sib bna orxam1oh9q sib no istns3 sib iii ithtaniiio sasma na Si nisismi (aujonsoxs) lo eiuoa fno siLt smo1emsr1T .ashtmioo bsiavbom Si a*oula I no siasrfqine sifT .'mtimo msns) sib iii boula bnsmsb

-nsqxs laDafi siLl as thus sib 10 saqalloD erLi aibssiq ata1 bssila siLl d ,saslsibsnoVl .noilsDfIirw nanneD ibiw bstai3oaas mood 3n9rnfesvni sib bna noia

io a±orl noinstLtsdua vonemmuio aasqmoons ot bebnatxs vjiass ed bliroo qicfsa mo .s sib tuioda nobqmuuaas mo 11ani'1 .esridwlaib itouiboxq sbia-1qquue

sib slnansaib qlsif 111w Dbai1awmu slidw ssLtJnico imsdqhsq sib 10 'LtSrnIne .aisii sf am snadoxs uia iii nobanibmooo 'i1oq 1o slom fiioeqs

-xs sma bna airirLtimaol famxrtan iii sma stsm ssmstni n.sib meiLto asldaimsv hA .muuiidifiucps s3nadmurtsib-oms a iii alsvsl misub inoil anoztaweb lo smmst iii besasmq

a if 11w bsxshrui sma ssimnuuoo msi1qims sub ehiulw bsna1a sma asldaimav metnsD hA

..zb IrI) noai9bn9H-iixIonsD iistani iol

8

Page 10: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

couauc cGLm i qLobb6q ro ojo2LicJ 2bG9cns oijq p €dinij —ou. + u(j — EOL uoouJ 2JwbJiczcA cJJ

cib ()

cnLL6uc?) iuq b cp C/6 bLrco J6A6J o cp b64bP6I 2 t MJJOJ& !2!IU!JLJ b" P6 CDb 6JOL O p6 b6LTbJJ6LK cO1mcL). (r" joc

(2)

CJJ91J6 LS6 O h6LibJJGI? cP CtcCffLL6ITC? bGL '!4 O CGUGL2 C1TLLGI3C) uq jc p uouru&j 6X-

awj abo 6XCU€ Lace o cp b6L!bP6L colJIJçLA (GxbLq 92 S COJ1uL?2ii coumuci bLc6 IJq6X 2 q6U6q 92 tOJJOffk2 G 4JG 110W-

T2 qeuocq 'c6LG pG GXbGCç941011 ob6LçoL COUqT4!O1J9J 011 rUJOwJ9çJOu 9A9Jj9pJ6 !U b6Loq

6xb6cGq bLoboL!ou9J L96 O CJJ9'U6 !U 2 COLJ2IIUJGL bLrcG uq&xJJJ6 L69J iUç6L62 L9G 111 C6U6L 2 !2 UOIIJIJJ9J !IJ6L6 L9G W!U112 JJ6

= — — ()IIJç€L62 L9G uq 911 9L696 qzuruq 2poCj y:L96 o bGLibJJGL2. r-g-s 4JJ6 C6U6L (qeu6q pGJ0tA) JJ6 C6116L2 LG9J

J'69J LG9'G 6UJ9IJ p C6U46L qeb6uq2 011 fTG GGCAG L69J 6XCJJ911G

()!2 qGUOcGq ! C6I3c6 CDTD 6U0L46 wnJu&J bLoqncç O J9poL2 L69J L'9G JJJG JJJOIJGA !A96 U cJJG CG11GL

12 2HbbJ6q ru6Jcic9JJ? 9uq bojç W9XiWJTU coUJbGçiçiAG LW2 GdII9çG

=(j_c)s (T)

bjo?ujsuç IS 211p)GC4 q6cL692Ju LGIJ1LIJ2 2c9JG:

ircbc 2s1bbJ? !IJ cJJG C6U6L quoeq p? q6cGLIlfllJT2c!C IIUCf1OIJ 0 GIll-

T LP6 CGU46L COflU4L?.

b9L9mGGL2

b9beL CLGGJ J6GL2 (pocj JOA6LC&2G 9uq 1rbbGLc6) L6J6L cox uç bo2rçrAG2frp2cLbc 0L = 3 " 1A flIJJG22 0JJGLftJ26 GXbj!C!cJX 249G cfJLO1IJJ0JL cpG

Page 11: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

nrli I . .i9lris) sill ier{qiis siLt lo elrci sri&bxs 1ei evibe1Is silT d rrevi

(s')

oi siIqq rhiriw) .noiiqrrmauioa ru tioqini o eii1 lnlrioD ruimruaA j JCfJ rsris) sill (-islnsD sill ot at flew a eshIrnioD ier1qns erIl lo rbse

ewollol a bsiiftsb

(8) > > 0 - = ( - + -1)

lnsthviiJps ci riDiriw ll&l sno rjdl acel ed ol fioqmi ol lianeqoq sill lFilcei eW

is1i 185k) smoDsd 11kw cA .Isbom we iii noilquuicno iii .thcS srco\ nhrwcas oi ther bus alsitrisisftib lasielni Issi tsrf I li1idiacoq sill luo cslin noilqmrucas cull

.CrIoiiDslib stieoqqo ui evom iedqiis bn isluieD rxeswled n0itsi39Iq9b betDeqx9

sill ui miihdiliisps .noilDriuI bnsrneb enom Jioolv lnslano3 s ruirrnaaA asiliupsi lsham snom

(Q)

I —

I boiisq lo bus sill IA .bolc 'enom lanhnon et191n93 sill celorieb sieriw

ssw bsvisado bus benurnleleb ci ?bolc enom ielnsD sill s'o' ci lsrll rIoiJ3rnñ evilDeLdo ileriT .1 boh9q ui thlisveiq ew 9flOffl sill ecoor{3 eislle

ln9muiolqine-HuJI sill moil 1nenPo!qm9 lo rioilsivsb bela&)siol 9111 9imuiim ol ai

evloe eill sio1sidT (ois ol bsiLmion 91911) level

I (ru) 1amm

Lrwps s-is C95W Lsuirrion Isill ceiIqmi ahil *uu — 'ru eni .(().pe ol th)ejdlse

lo 1no noilrnij1 ci (luiq.liJo io) lrisrno1qme bus lqqrue snom b9ID9qxe 9111 01 :anoilsvoimi 'islenom

(01) = (11) =

29IfIJJO3 ierLqrie 911T .C -lisa niau erurlT .ielnsD sift as ofonsbeI em.se sill evsd aeiltrmo3 ier1quie em isilqhs sill ruisi1ehi3isrh anoilsiipe -\qa sill -iolsrIslqx9

.wolsd ii9V1 (1) u(i

— 1) =

(CI) u3— = — ur

01

Page 12: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

couqTcou mrrç pojq OL &uX b9'TL 0 CIILLGUC!6 !U dIG 2?2ç6UrL4ocG dp9'ç JA6U () içp beqGcç crbiçj U30p!J! LIUCOAGLGq !UcGLG2c b9'LIçX

= + .Ec.s.c+I — ()couqrcrou pojq2:2ffp2drccrcGa UI buirç s'su42 boLoJJo 20 dJJ9'd }JG JflJCOAGLG 1IJçGLG2 bstiç7

M6 IJ9'JJ? 9'21flIJ6 9'226d2 6IJ0UTIJ9'G JJ qfl6LGIJI CJILLGUG!G2 9'LG bGLGcd

—(51)

(50)

— = (Jo)

'u cp b6LJbpeL? q6uhJuGq 9' oJJot!29'IJ9'JO RJçp 4JJG CGU6L LG9'J UJOUGA 9'J9'UCG2 UJOUGX II9'G2 9'Uq Gwbfo?rnGIJç

—) +b (re)

G MLIççGU 92 &LI4JJIIJG1C 9'AGL9€G O 4JJG JL pJJ96L9'J LG9'J GXCJJ9'IJ6 L9'62

ELOUI GcIII9'çiOU () rç 0JJ0b'2 JJ9' JJG C6UdGL2 L69'J GJ6CdTAG GXCJJ91JG L9'IG . C9'IJ

b + (j)— — ;--r + (JQ)

B9'J !3iGLGd 9Uq GxcjJ9'u.G L9'G !U JJG COIJUfL?L 9'LG

t\ uq \ 9'LG !u2dG9'q qGIJcc&J rn pocp cJJG C6UdL &uq JJG bGL!bJJGL296C2 9'JJ b6L!BP6L COITUçLTG2 ccI1\ JJJG OJJGL pGJJ9'AJ0Ls'J b9'L9'WGdGL2

IWC6L9'1U 12 dJJGLG0L6 9' b6LflLp9çOIJ 0 9'LG9'G qmiq !IJ cTJG CGUd6L /ITJCJJ2bGC!JC J 2JJ0C]C2 JJTU JJG bGL!bpGL?. GOITUçLIG2 JJJJ6 0U 2011LG6 0 GXO6U0JT2GdH9'dIOIJ (J2) 12 COIJ29'IJ dJJ9'd !2 HG 9'P2dL9'Cd L0W CoimdL-2bGcqc 9'IJ UIG-D!UGLGUdIX LOUJ cJGm9'Uq Gdfl9'çJOU ifi cP C'd C0JIIJdL?. ( cp b9'L9'WGçGL ' !IJ

= ' + —(j)

GdfJ9'iou OL COLTIJçL? S2 orldbfTd:

LG9'J GXCJJ9'UG L9'G O G01TUdL) LGJ9'd1AG dO cG1 GIJGL2 JIJçO GUJ9'IJ2!AGJ). pom (co) C6IJc GOiJIJdL7 JJJ!2 !2 cIJG L69'201J A}J OIJJX d}JG pJ9'cGL9'J 92211W6 p9'ç bGLJbpGLl. C0JJUL1G2 rnJboLd (GxboLd) O0q2 9'1J 2GLAICG2 GXCJJI-

= '' +b — (J)

D6UIJG LG9'J GXCJJ9'UG L9'G O dJJG bGLJbpGL? CO1IIJL -- cPG CGIJc 92

Page 13: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

Is)L6m-Di1oq 91I o 29D1191919lq gg iiniso \1SIlq11&I 9v1 rI92S1q9i Z UI thOILIJS Diloq 9f{i lo 2sDuI9leIelq edT

:() bru3 (l) () anoi8IJp9 Ui fi9Vi 91

() I > \ > 0

(1) 0 < + — + —

() eiwietho I = Ii 0 = l21ron9ox9 eri 293o119b bns fkiiq eJi en.6fbxe b9Dnuonn erL i eisrfw -J&flSfLthffl erLf 9IInIEIn 2I9)thm-'DilOq .eq 91{t riinobrisd lo JBOD 9113119W I13V1

.enilirl 9infini erl ievo benft9b rioLtonth eol evLtibbs—emii £ lo II0dJ$ID9qX9 I&i ai nibrrth o1 boneq 9lni2 edT .\ be3orieb 8i ioth flmoDBib siti1odic13 edT

alevel tei&t iisii moil lCD bn.8 nsiir'oIqms JbE lo IIOth.8IVeb erlzt flu Di131h&fp

sriJ ai riDiriw) trremo1qme lo level t9L8 9if t8r1 soVI .i9vib9q291 bn. rnhJndilhl5pe alibi 3b9qxs-I8n0i131 srft 8be9Dxe (isrIqiie edt iii e1eriwisv9 9ffl88

bi8bn8a 9r1 riiwolloI .oie o L811p9 ax lebom aids rn dDidw rl9V9i I131fl8fi 10 -iotaib (eld.svom9inu brI.8) auoneoxs lo eauosd i1f b9rmraas 81 1 2II0ifl9VfiOD

fL8boa ax Isvef fuqiio so-s erlJ shm lod.8I isdghe er1 iii anoit IIeeW9d iftnoD £ noire lo noiJ33I1qmx 18oits1oeI{f nwod flew silT .I.8nniitqod15a

un r{iiw muhdiliirps ins L$r{.t ai 8tn1.81IaI1Oo mithdiliLrpe briB 290n91e191q oifdiiq

'monooe eni bns noiooll.8 a9d-e1fi srf ioqqira on e9ob rioreioath m.t9nOm bins ooae1-bfiJ3th>J-13l-a) asid i&ioiithIni ins d beioells ax ieniqiie 9d1 10

a (nobloD-ons8 -eb ai n1) xen1qiis er1 iii anermiil.8e1 () bins ().p9 o nibioooA 13.8 lqmi ( level besis aii rnoil a si 9nBr1oxe b9i11391 en1f lo 2iIOi.8IV

as booiaisbmJ 3aed 9113 22OD saer{T ''.o ot fsrrps Iaoo ewllew mira-qnisjl auonsoxe sib iiiliebmr atasietnii 1soiiloq sldsfiiwssip-non lo sns ebiw erb iol s

m8fflIWJS±) Dii2iIBfl0iB11 ff011 flifi131 91J3J 9f$31 9fi&lDX9 fl9Vi .s 10 eaneleb erb ;9ouIeIrfini bns rIoifPfI1qei eiaeq lo eaol 1.srioieaeloiq lo 81891 ot oo-c boos oilduq s ai ilid8ta eisi 9aBdox9 sr{ Isiled bs9lqa9biws beftei 081.8 'ism

-liii isnoiLsflnii-bcis (elcJiaaoq) ai morI bsln.sIrieaib nedw neve tnih iiwo ai iii

iiaoo rIoi.81JL8v9b eaerh lo anoisbniio1 (monooe-fsobiloq) eaioelq edT .anoiJsoilq

-isfil bsisIs-i-itotnoO-onsI ib lo 'svina bsisbqn mi sbxvoiq inihsdsT bus 09qB 'mofloD9-n9qo its ill s1ns

-Jidibs'iD bits noifsfiiqsi lo eof bus qit niblivd iionøobns siLt lsbianoD fon sob I9bom 1110T

sisJsii a9Iom9m ot svIsuro izfsi 9W bi1qmi L83ifIsnS io'I .vi1oq vxstenorn lo ii •

('ifoq sintirl fijods noitsbsqxs artol isttsI sib nsrlw) i1dnq silt iol bus sitr'ioithut 9ift iol fi-isq bsxII sift uinobnsdu iol viLitnsq sift ,howsznsñ sqt-nobioO-onsa bsbiitsi asL s iii

s ni i!dx;q sift 10 uvt frsmifinuq mxihcfifiups sib d bsnirrrz9f9b !ai;oneobns sd bliow . toa i,orzsoxs us eoqini of b9911 on sd bliow sjsilT •sithorifiis sift if tiw sins bstseqsi •fiIidsfDs1t {si.tIsris lo rrossi io isqsq iI1i Iii bsirixiq f on i sfsif nil1sbom s rbu

Page 14: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

13

LG1UT6

i.xq biTpJic GCIOL j}JGIL 6Xr26UC6 UWA fJ9iL6 q6 p?J7rII 6[GC tOL cpG xGq 6XCJJUG LtG4p6 bop) o wizjçibj GdrnJ!P1J 111 JJG q2imJspOu m6 pçu

pJ 6u6 o .çicJ6 IA4G pajq ([iiI uq [j]) boiu oiiç iUc6 cbG

— ä)3 + —t)} (58)

(se)

113 GdIl T0U2 (5) (30Y (30) •iq (j)Ou2iqGL UOM oplGcçiA6 ITUCTOU OL c'c CoIIJJLA J1çp0L1A 2 iAGH

}JG 66C2 OJ q6AflçJoU O11J icc OL 0136 b6Loqibcq JJ112 o 2mubçrou2 ST8tVc66E cpc iu u iuçGLGmboLrJ moqj

oj pe bLiJçG 26GOL2 11J0L1UçTOU 26ç cpe 1IJG 6U MG C0IJ4LCI26XC}J9'U6 LG !2 26f I6 CM 9LG 12 CJ102611 2 E6JJ 0çJJ 9i62 9L6uqGbeuq6IJc 0 E!JGCJJ6L Le9JiuuJ6Uc }J&2 OCCITLLG 01 110f QIJCG IJ0UJJIJ9J

b6LJbp6L2. coimçue xcpu LG irpqceq ow cp bLGAioIr2 b&Loq— (ak)= (5)

uq ():GAOJAG C0u2J24eUJ? MJ4JJ Gxcp9'u6 Lce b6qiGq ! GdIwçou ()GX46LIJJ A9J1TG O JJ6 CIILLeuC? JJJG bLJcG J6AJ 2 GL6OLG I22IUU6JJ6LG 12 130 TU62CbpJ6 c0LTT1cç p6E.66U }3G 0p6CiA62 0L JJ6 1IJçGLIJ IJq 4}J6cP ETN CL1212 JIJ mncp 0 tA}W 0H0R2 M6 2}3JJ LçJJGL OCH2 013 ?JJG C26 !4JGL6I12J1IJG€J 6XCJJtIJ6 LG L6J6AU 92 ij3e2 UJTJJI 6 III cJJG 9UJ?2i2 o9L6 uoç iucG162l6q 113 UJ?TU cp !wbJ!cc!o1J2 0 CJJO!CG 0 9U JIJC0LLGCGdITIAYJGU4 40 201136 J6A6J 0j, 4JJ6 L6J GX(41UG LçG 1 cJJ!2 bb6L MGLUTUq 4JJ4 J0L A6IJ A9J116 0 JJ6 0L6!IJ CDb JX11J fuq 12

IThr? GA0JAG piTç uoç uJq6b6uq6uJ? L0113 69'Cp oper i 2J3OJIq G CGbç ruQAGL 1UJ6 JJG CM JGAGJ i± tuq 4JJ6 UOUJTIJ9'I GXC91J6 L&G LGç

2JG o VJJG 2pocJ.c pJu qomeaclc 6C0U0uJX0 L69JJUIJJ6IJ2 113 cp€ bLGucG o bcijc CoUçTIJG1JCiG2 !G qGbGuqu 013A971JG2 CIJ pG Lçi0IJJi6q JIJ GLUT2 0J GC3bG cG JJ0M!IJ 0L cp bo22pJc2AJJJG UJ024 couqiiqG JL1G CJMGAGWGU 0 T2 OçJJGL OplGCç!AG2 JIJcGUJJGqT9'cG

JJ 0AGLIJWGU42 MiJJ JM?2 jG JJG CIJLLGLTC? J0 OL GdinrJ6uJ2 26 Ic c JJG]GCçJAG2 40 G6U2G 0 JJG C11LL6IJ 6XCJJIJG L1J'G 1JGJiipJ6 AJ1T6 2IJ2&uq 6XGLIJJ C1LC1flU2IJCG2 bopc?. I1cJJ0L!c M!JJ 2J1p0LqUcG !42 0JJ6L op-IJoImcGq LG4 iJ GxçLGmGJX pTp AJ13G o c rrubJiG2 LG9LqG22 O !IJGLIJ9T

cj pimb-2nm C0&2 C JJ6 boJ!c?. 1TJJoLic M!IJ b? T. ! LGIJGG2 J2 U-1JTçIJJ6IJç p?i JJG bopci I1IJJ0LTI JJG bG (uo IJJ9GL ir?6X126UCG 0 CO SC& COj0\ 92 9 qc1&s: JJG JJ1GL GLG6 0 GOUT-9LG JJ0A6AGL JLLGJGA91J1 0L ofJL bfTLbo2 21mbJ? W9LJCG b9Lçicth9uç2 9JCG ç}JG

Page 15: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

(OC) 0 = (IC) 0 =

19Iiqn9 srLf moiI e19flib 931I9 9f!f noibrrn1 9vGb9Ldo srj a tr1 oVI n9rrrolqm9 lo 19v91 1J Ji (0C) flOiBJJp9 £11 IIWOI{8 1B1iI .2J3W 991r1i lii

.aBid irioiIfini on ei 9191{t oa , (oie) rI9rnoIqm9 lo 9LBI IBlffJI3fI 9fli aISIrp9 '

9LU3fbX .fI3aflO) El 9$t 19V9! siiq srlt (IC) nothiipe 111 rrwOfIE a bno39 sisift :u 19v91 srq srf 10 ff1a8d91" s o bi1 on oh 91o1919rI E9rLSrf 91 s 9n&i3xe na sv&1 ion aeob 19rIsD 911i b1idT .iliib i1t IBvsI e3nq OLI Ei

• (iswl stii nirFx9 iw 3m ol 8ni1i1 rLtiw b9siDoas aoI 91su19w io) ii

rnioE1 b93ubo1-im9 9rIT 1.C

lo \19viEJJIx9 anoibii1 a B91d3i1v euonobn9 Ith 2E9lqxs 9W noibs EirIi ciT

1si Liiii1id er1 I9biano3 iEii .E91cLBrIv loilnoD io bsnim13i9b9iq B1fO1I9OX9 rirrIJo9 IslrI9D 9111 brii 1111UJOD i 9111 n99W19d Lsiinel9IIth 1i

($C) — —

I) + ( — — =

9B1 3E9I9IIU 9J319VI3 sill a9flinIJOD vi3I1qn3q V 9111 19V0 InuB sill nbls1 vH 3d 111w i3nsD eili bn 19f1qrI5 sill u09w19d LsiinsieThb

(CC) ( —

£+)( — I) + =

lo noiLsioslq9b 10 sii b9b9qX9 sill bn thiinsi11th sii ieieini 1I9i 9(11 irfl 91014

nOib9lLb 9i1WE 9111 iii 9VOffl 'i9rlqfl9 bii 191115C) fI99Wi9d 911 9f1J3fbX9 £891 9111

.noiiqmueno cii 9n'co\ i eiørIi Ii ai isril \1 > \ Ii '1no bn Ii rIoiiirpe iniol b&rrbsi 9111 sii9lD1S±) ol IJJlql9rl 91,6 qeie 9liib9ffl19ifli W91 A

noiEE9lqxs uoiveiq ecu niau i21i1 .sisi 9fLBrIDX9 11391 9Vith)9fi9 &i9TI9D eril ioI sloifw ,S aJ3 monos sill Ia inino iiosi 1111w ioi (n

— ( —1) = — _____

iii rIoi.1J3IJp9 9Mi519Thb Di f{DOi ibio Jeifi £ n11ido 9W

* r / () \f

51911W

__________ (—1)u'

= (—I)+ — (—1)+ —r

soqmi sw e1dhv nb1ool bl13wloI i eii nriDxs issi sviiDsIls 9(11 aA

(CC) noiisicpe nivIo .noilibno3 'wbwiod s noiithnoD Lsfurni91 elddisd-on Bb19r noiiibnoD ibrmod s rbiia rIiiw

(C) + ( — ____ =

Page 16: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

a13 benfleb i 3 91911W

(BC) ( ( 1)s

-iii srH nssw9d eneieflib sr1 no r{od Bbneqeb 9I 9fIfbX9 1ei vth&fle edT sit 1iipe fiDifiw) is.tneD sd iii bn isr1qiie BE1 Iii iiodsvouiiii 119flOffl iTI9I

!bn (ieneD ei1 bns is11qheq 91f fri a19V91 3n9nro1qrn9 er1f neewd eDns19th -eb Lssi IIJfIñ bst3eqxe bn rxerrirn no eIdiisv nbEoo1 bww'io's sr1 uou11

(SI) bn8meb urIT .19r1qn9 erLf ot vLts1ei ieneD etht iii boi12 bnsm 9fl&1DX9 I91 219trI9D eift 9aii 19r{qne BfLi rh ILSf{J isisI 19iI9D SLIt ni

erLt iii fLSfb ieita1 19f1I9D ss1 iii ?borle 1qqir snom s sIisIw esiD91qq of eti -rbot sifT .sI3ice1q9b o 9is SfLBrix9 191 tneD 9Itt eeir& ier1qne

1SflOifl19tfli IflO lo IEInsrnbnrR er1t ot borle IJOfl9OX9 ecu eIdiisv ineBsIq' SI{t i lo fIOiBib39i TW eilt tJ3Lfi rIiiaf1qff19 ied I .1flOflO39

9T1 I9VO 9M1scI1IJieib bn&neb eiiriñ beoeqxe bus 3neiirrn lo 9uLsV beirnioth .noiiori einftni

91{1 1811f worf O (aiioibe 1I1LS1d9JS idth) b1W1O i1ii i i tX9V1

ai istrisD 9r1 -r-ru inrroD vx9dqn9 1o e en&bxe 1.sei

(@) + — — 'c ( —

I) =

91911W

_____ ________ — I (

=

191191 ND 9rfi iO anOitBIrp9 miol beDub91-ims 3111 9h1W SW 1fsni'I

(fl) \ + w + — — — I) + ] =

s.t isJneD 9r1 s--s eti 9fLsdc'x9 1&iimon 1ies1id er1 bn

(I) + us — s + n ( + )

— — u — I) + )

111 n9mniIBeI 10 9iB bns iedmijci riirniT 1

\ç19r{qH9q 9f{ i1oq ienom er1 lo misiidiliiipe dBiT'1 srlt 9fl9iDU31F) bn.s I3Jflt&IoD won

s113 o ierfqnsq eth i eeiitiii V 91b b1U3 ISIieD erLi 1199w19d em Lii brqx s 19qsq iiJi ni 1ns hR 91111w 3I1rLt sv-isdo o nsiioqmi oats ai tI

m9r{ 91q19Ifli9I ot biswo1i1isii ai i ,

*oda siLt 1 eia siLt 1o aiIoit3rnJ1 a ai tsiLi

nro ri8ani io1 .b i9qa ai / d bswohlol aasoiq 3ims1rb siLt eno srn lo amie iii bbJo3 s33qa 9ti Lu

bssiiiuno1 anoibsa ixsn 911 i ni n9mh1i1891 i lo nimi siLt lo aia'1sns .rioitiiIo lo 9tnTta siLt o rzoitsflibom iojsm inoithw anne 3irnJcIb ni ta& sd LIns1sviup9

Page 17: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

-murr) 9viI9qoo3 3 IooI If 1w 9W rI01tD92 fxerr 9E1 ru fl9Vi iol

91.8 inD bn$ isrfqne rfod lo 1rzoibrith svib9Ldo IirIW •9m (ii sri3 9L8 8noLtrJio svi18lsqoo3 bru i1aiT4 9rf rjoiiori tirzfini flB 19V0 beuifteb J o sw 29iti1oIf1J6 9u1 boiiq rfr 1i b9r1ido 9d bkrow 18rf oiI

91fT .1no \ 10 nothDnlñ 9vib91dO boi13q-91nia srL rxiiminim 'd II&iqo -lol 9rfJ noi18ftufqrrii 9IdlebinoD EiI1t 1O 9)LB1II 18113 Ieborii 9113 Io e191

ssw rfioirb 1911ti9 19V0-11& throqms193ni on ai 919r1J !18I1 .rnwo1

-non 916 sw anoi3iiloe 3nB18ianoc-9mii 9rii bruo3 .noi18Iuixuios SB Ifuo1rI 10 sinuI be18qIDi3rLB bn JIISTIIIcI :e9ie18i o3 bebnsi 918 rxi19bi2 IIMI3IB 9r{t i 18r1) sm srI3 10 1o181r1 aq siIJ 'd b e116 on 918 anoia 'DiIoq

bus s1 1s1IIf9IJ11 ow3 sr1 Isbom 1110 efirfw biirfT .(anoiJ3s lo 2S31I9JJ9 b9lsvoDmJ 9113 bus e93s1 Jsis3ni IssI sf13 rfruoiif 3) anoxis3Dsqxs no1oo1-biswio1

S183 'fl5 9VIOVIIi 30(1 ob (a)uxoi3iu1o slddurd—on 3i (aqir1enoi18f9i v3i18q 389193T11

9f13 18(13 fIoi3qffIuIa6 srIJ mofi smo) Isbom sfi ui "DifnBrib ',Ino srfT .s1dsi18v -111011 39LB3 9113 lo ioiv&Lsd 9113 ff1011 931L8Vb6 ui bohsq 5110 39 i 9BW 9uI0ffl

rIb1oo1-b1sw1o1 sri 3 riiroiuf 3 bus 2SIlJnruOD isr1qhsq suf 3 10 9181 snsrbxs lsth 111 5I 9113 1011 iiiJ3sa 96W \91I0ffl 111 sI 9113 ir13isM .esfdsiisv 1snoi1819qx9

-sbelq 1sqo1q £ II 31I5e91 9351 9rLsrlDX9 Isrthnon 3sis3 srIi lo nothsriimie3sb 9113

.Isborn srI3 lo ririol bSoIJbel sri 3 riiisJns eldsiisv sls3a b9n1m193 3i snom Di391rI0b lo Sf13 916 831191r11n18rn Di1oq 9113 Isbom wo ui eIufW

nooun 11539fI01fl lo arIflS3 Lii tIIJ91 1110 91X5 03 ifI91ff9vffO) 'llsnoths3on ai oJni 5110-03-9110 935IfLB13 ,qu39e iuo ni rbir1w (m

— m bns un

— .('r bus c) 3rI9rn101qm9

\j19r1qFI9 th ai1oq Isenom L€rniqO

ow3 a9ffldmO3 sn3IIuJOD \19rfqn9q 9Vi383fl9E51q91 5 101 91111 DiIoq L6ffuIJqo SLIT

3ns3ianO &iJL8v 9113 no S)1S3 9f10ffl 5113 9110 ru .ascru9-i 1539EI0ffl 311919111b

s113 bns bsnobnsds ei sq eii3 sno isif 3 sri 3 nI .eq sili lo 1sviviu 9113 r{Jiw

-sriom Lsrni3qo sri 3 isbierroD .a163119m.sbnlñ o3 abnoqaei ILsini3qo lqqLr suom 9r1sff3XS JLISTWO 9113 9D110 .bsriobnsds nisd sq si13 no LsnoiJibnoo 'çiloq 183

11kw 1s)Lsm oi1oq 9113 3nisI18noD 1o 3ssJ (nibthd) s 19no1 on ai 3h.sq s18i

ii13 3iio11iroiifT .19b9I 19dL9)b,s3 £ 3on ai 1$3119D eri3 Lsri3 grIiias11qm9 r13-xow ai 3101

m,Lto us --as 1as14 slq 19r1qn9 9rf lo 19dm9m Lsicbivthth bns is3n d3 noibsa

ni nsvi as 1e3ri) 9113 bns iiedqn&1 s113 Lu 95W 19flOffl 35913 9w oibe ssr13 IiI's 3n9iino3-9mi3 Ii 9?Lsm 03 iioi3qnxuaas 3dij 9113 'hs9ID i thf 3 bs9ds boh9q 9(10 39a 975 assw

.bs1sbin03 918 aiioi3xi1o iii . boñ bnsm3b 93s915 9113 lo 110ii8i1591 s113 nsvi ((I).p9) (1013.811p9 moll f93oM lo 3as-i edi iii PsiDi1oq vy339n0m bns sw I13vi as nbLs3 bna 89vi ai 38113) 193usD sd3

bus 'iinuJoD 79r1qi7e s ui insmofqme nsew3sd luoi3sIs7 sno-o3--euuo S oals i 919113 m93aa sñ 3 .9351 9ff&13X9 LsrnmOn au

Page 18: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

sr1 ibi niBoorb 'd noibnitI o1 9cf 9iminim

(A) o = (- —

) {( —

f)3\ + } + — =

niv1oa eq srf ninobnd no LanoitibnoD ot 19191 LI'E" qi1oe19qIJ rI isr{w ab1ii iJoq 1Btnom iJniio srL iol noi91qxs evod. 9r1

— — — + A — — —

91911W

() (—I)3+ l9bfflJ eBol 9r1t Ii 1no bn Ii q s±t ninobnds iol tqo Iliw 19)I&n DiIoq 91{T

mii-qxmI &rIJ nihubni flOiBIJiBV9b i rIiw beiDoas BO! 9fI II&1t 191BI i 9q 3 8O3 911I9W

(8k) � { [G - + - - - + - c }

hñr1iani t9 91qffli A eq sri J no Isnoilibno3 0i 19191 "XI ' 91911W

sd n e9mi91 ow r1 nsewsd slni thfotiw thmitqo sr{t 9i19bS1S113 o '.sw .wo11o1 a

9311919fith &rI as ($I 9rI r1iio1eorxsrI) erI sxifisCl

-n.sd 919W sq erf Ii 9Js1 en&bxs erLi lo suliv (neorIo llmiqo) sr1I risewsd -fish EI bsOn9b sd Iliw $1CI sifT .etsi enirbxe smt srI buss benob

9q srft lo tuiemnobnssds sib no IsrxoiUbnoo rn1isvsiq essi snssr1oxe sib noiin + = sd ffiw

isrbsot (1$.) ui niauc vd bsriissfdo sd n& $IU sib 101 nOiaa9lqx9 nA etssl erissrbxs Lisnimon sult 101 111101 b93u1b91 srlt riJiw

— n3(A— )

— (ur

— — + (A — =

() {( - - [A - ( + ) ]} noiiDnhrl ss ass $JG sub riiirwsi id Idss19biano3 bsfiulqrnia 9d n133 noiaaslqxe airiT

sib iii — qss Isvef enq sib 10 — qss nsrrro1qms sib 191th9 lo :B9f1Ii91 etssi srL6L13Xs svz rxis1ss ow

(8k) ( - ) [)] = ( - -1)3 + ] =

noitssiclssve sift esvfovni Ino (8k) 5ffli91 sissI 9nssci3xs lo 9310113 IssrriiJqo Sift 93fli noissups niiriadira awoI1o1 i level 93fl 9ift bas qss Jn9rrno1qms 9rft lo

'ci

Page 19: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

40 L69C1 uI0IrGç9L2. 6XbU2J0U U cps b6L!bP6LA p?. !IJGL692!U 42 OMIJ IIJ01JG?Ed1J!0U (21) LGAG9J 4JJI CU% bUç% 4G C7c6L t1IT 9JAY9?2 jiiq obc!w91

j' (c--\) (2)

tJJ6L6

= + - (2r)

iç obcnn9j uJ0IJec9L2 bopc2 !2 iu p?.bJ2 M92}J LG.9LqJ622 0 tAp6JpeL bGL!bPGLX COHIJcL!62 C00LIJ9G cJJG!L 9C0II2cou2iqGL L2 JJ6 L69CçJOU pmCciOu LT IJ6 CGI6L 2!' IPG C611L 9JH9)2

z Jf61C4OU 1JUC4OU2 JIJ JJ6 C6U6L 911q bGL!b}J6L?.

L9G C9IJ jILJGL L011J JJ6 b9Lrç? p?20W6 mEniu liJflJ0iT4 LJ6LJI3 9IJ? LG9JT.ImJGIJç6C0JJ 4JJ6 jxeq coeç 0 pcruqoimuc IJJeUe p9 2JJ9q0tt Jo9çiIJ GXGJJ9IJ6

9CL022 GXC9U6 LGIIU62 q6cq62 M4J6JJGL OL LJOç 0 99UOIJ bç26L60L6 wo q6L6IJCG2 }JL2 iu oiii. bbLo9cp pe biipjc 26COL

9 IJJ9L1IJ 2fIWCiGU4 COAGL X6q C02 0 9p9UqoUTU b JJJGLG 9L6Jx6q biu4 92 20011 92 }JG 290JA 09IIJ GXCJJ91J6 L9G 6XC662 xGq L9'çGbuç) goui GJ0 JU 0fL 26çIIb flJ6 0AGLIJIJ36U4 liUJJ CJJOO2G 99IJ0U

92 20011 92 4JJG b9çp 0 JJG }J&qoM J0911J 6XCJJ9U6 L9G GL02262 jxeq2bGcIlJ9crAe 99CJC q6bf6çrU L62GLA62 uq 0LGJIJ 911 99IJ0UWGIJ 0J JJG xcqtuoqGj2 jjooq uq C9LPGL [ii] 2JJot&Gq }JG bL!A96 2GCOL 'n J1IJCab6CffJ9ciAG 949CJC2 U C0IJ4GX 0 JJG L2-GIJ6L&J0IJ 2bGCJIJ9cIAG 9cç9CT

H0 qo JJI2 LG2uIJ LGJ96 GX!2IU J!ceL9dnLG 011 CIaLGrrc? GL2G2 9uq

c + !1. Iv 5 .(20)

= —

i obçrnr&j UJ0LJGç9L2 bojicA C9JJ IJ0fi G couJbJGceJX cp9L&cc6Lrq 92 0JJ0i2IT2iU (f) GXC9U6 L9G pG}J9AJOL 0 1IJG b6L!bPGL COIIJJçLA rmbpqGIJG 2UIXJçLJC9JJ? 0L poçji bo2i4iA6 IJq U69ç!A6 L9G2 0 qGA9JfI9cTOIr B?0 99IJ0IJ1U çJJG o cpç c 12 C0IJ2ç9IJ irqqipieq p? LiJJç JJ9Uq iqe o 9OAG rIJGdn9JTc) L9U2J9G2 cpG MGR9LG co2cVP VL!6L 911 obi!m9J q6MrJJ9c10U (oL LGA9pT9cJOU) jp I9JrrG

p3 0JJGL 1A0L2 JJ6LG 6C12ç2 9 jmepojq A9Jfl6 oJ 2JJ9Oll qGbLGc9cou L9G

c[ +(r — )1 ()() JJoJq2:() 1114o ed (f@) 4JJ9 JJG 9frçJJ0LTci2 ffUJJ 9p9LTqOU b6 r uq 01JI2. 1 G0IJcffç0IJ

Page 20: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

bnJ3 rioibs '\pifoq \1&9fIOLfl Ei i3II9D i1 lo w9iv lo rrioq sr1 moii 1qqrr S1 9 9iTftIUO 1sr1qn9 9r1 lo rfre b noi iJoq ienom eifl (() .ps) I9Ialq ti ns'iO i rioiThrfrii 9rIT

o i1idtarii 19v91 ethq lo 0D 9rf niwm r1J 9Jsup9 8VSw1 19iI9D 9r1 9rIJ oT .Isvel stcn 1siun r13 o isoIo n9ffno1qffl9 niniid moil atft9rI9d sf1

noiBiDwIq9b tuod uiiid 19ifqfl9J SL1 Lxi nOiBflqX9 1t9fIOffI i1 ffl9X9 ILsI 111w ian) r1 iii NC) i1 9L1 9rLBffDxe Lsei evib9fis a19r1qhs sif 10

91I1O lo ai iTreiTnoIqffl9 19tnC) 9rIT .Bboo bshoqmi lo e)nq r1 iIfiw

vitsriom sr1 Ia threei s a 9Io1e1er{T .3ioq 1cuenom nwo ei d b9b91ts 1no -cioiaaqxe iom mo-il !niwn 9r1 Ls ff9nsd 9rf 19f1qi19 9rf Lii noiariqx9

i13r1iLs 10 taos r1 8b99x9 (ND reriD r1 9ihd8 o) oi1oq 19flOffl -nom a'ishiD 9ñ 1nup9an0D .13v91 eiM er1 bno'sd fn9rrro1qrne rIias9IDm

.9iDi1oq 1t9U0ffl inoirxqxe 910111 nem91qmi o ni11iw ed 111w thor13irs isf iol rxoibnijl noib91 9r1 etao n9mnifs91 rnurE-qmrJI lo rz&9-iq 9113 o3 siC1 � Ii :8IJ0IJ11I3II0DBth ai t3nuoD isr1qiis9 9vi LI sxqsl er{3

() 3— + J- J Ii 91111W

— — + ) + + —

— P3+ =

/

() + - A - - 1)3+

( ) ct noifs 19EIq o f39qe91 riiw fclem9lqmo3 3i9fBtfe s vc rIoifD eii 91oin k T9.s1q l9v9n9IJW .ssxni ieIq lo noiis L&nifqo sr1I lo sbnfinsm di Ii bns oIqoisrieO !wohca see) 0 < trn Ii ylno bn Ii i 3si{ noii zd lo 9bIJfinm

-b-iwqxi 9d binow ie'&Lq lo sviuo noi ssrx 9S3 x9's!q-ow3 sr1$ ni .(8IJ ie19qrnD(

£ b89farIi i noib x3nuo 0 > t'\ n9rb vifsn 21 nSX{W niqo12 .noibs t -x3n1co3 of i3qex if 3kw A3i%

fhcmi2 ii3nno3 'rIIqi19 nr1w th;i b oIffisrt2 £ 21 lo noisi9-Iq9b L6ex A' 2iJojvdo sJ .((t).pe) 4iT9D 9113 -- 29i6i39lqSb nenirn i9v9 ii&sd bnsqxe hico

A .'!qq1;2 9nom iid3 92913r1i 79fIqI79 9113 Ui 29IfrncoD wsl £ ino ibiilw iii 9113 i b19i1id i lo r1oiLsbs1q9b £ wsz 3iioda aniid fnuoD iii noinqxe ifnom

03 3D9q29 113 iw 5i•I 911U&)X9 1S91 L6193131id 9113 lo iti3i.fB19 silT .

(CC) sfsz snrbxe 1ss .\1 > ioI svifi2oq 1i,oiridmnii ai rbidw

, (

— 1)3 of 1sxips ibs1 ni i ilqqiJ2 snom sib

•.shirnro vz91iqn9 isibo 11 no anoiw3i9q9I svi! 11kw i3rwo eno iii noinqx9 ri -ievswoH

v-lfrnJoD Ui n0i2rx6qX9 ns 1sai)9iq aioM .sns32 i3sriom -usd3 9nsr1o iton ob sd3 Ii nsvs -i39-lqsb of bn 0 < Ii xsfuisD srI it ths.6 93Si 9IIsfbX9 Lssx .'k. IirnroD s3sio9-Iqq8 of 2bnsf

ti isvo licvsiq k Trtnuo3 ni noiaflsqxs 'C1tenom £ lo B.139119 lb9übni ssiIf ust) .0> % Ii Ii sits sdt lo 13nsbnsqsbni 9V1fL3911 ('CC) noiitaups d ei noiisisp 2irf it of iswns silT ¶bIs tsib

ii lo nsjjp9nO s 25 293si)sIq9b 12uJoxiidmsrn, sits-i svjibs1Is Issi 'isr1qiis SIlT . lo rzi \19IIqns9 9113 Lii 29FIfflflOD ko 392d1F2 ns d noi2nJiqxs istsnom

@1

Page 21: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

srr3mroa rsr{qiq erLi lo rb89 lo rioibrric1 r101i3891 V srLJ 161 noiaeiqxe eriT sri bn8 )bOJa 19f10ffl 8ti VdflhJO3 ienqrie £1D85 io1 tJ$f[ 1891D i 9)16111 ffl98\

ixrmo ieriqiieT erf ciomA 91$ enorn &19neD crqco 3SY 91$ bni k rnuo lo iq 'ri lo )13otE enom erff noiaasqxe itenom 'c 'rmoo o 98flO897 89d srf :eviioq ai Ii hio bn$ Ii

II itnnio cr1 lqqII2 ierzom iemob lo 9S9IDIll fli3 ei1qmi 12IJoIridm8nu 916 aJcr9fruJ12ni 3i1oq teiiimo ier1qhe O >

-$s1q1erIi 1110 0 iIiS 81 3I19iffi90D 9J1 lo 9bIJffI6m sr1 bri.s rri edT sair&sd tIoqqJre erf rnxiiidiliirpe rIasT4 erft bus anoibnth rIoifaBs1 sr1 lo noi

sriqne-.sitrrI eA .mei erD ui 2levolliqe Di1oq lo ioLscibni Ditethtrr 6 o nhoqmi i ti jebom wo lo rIothrlo8 ed cii elm lsbirr £ \61q aeth1Lsn19xe

.1iseb ui anoisoi1qmi bus eiuzri iierLl e1srI8

• ( () .ps) ierieO er{ lo ehsm Eboo er{ ui noiithrio cmihdiliuipe euI iebi&ioD

1idB nsnhs 's rtruuo ierlqhs 9rLf lo n0itsiD91qeb 1891 6 j61Jp9 2rnhft 19rD0 ui 10 isrisD eu 3 ui 19rLh9 b&rnboiq Bboo 9rLt mon sw 1erI9D erli ui bn6meb

eriJ 21 aicfT •

aboo 's rmoD b16wo bus er{qiie erD lo i er1 2lswoI t13 i nuo ui rioiari$qxe isecrom rDiw b96ioaas b3e isrieC) e± iii 'lqquc8 as 1ev9woH .yienqhe effi lo 3ei edi iii bnsmeb 9i69TS e) •sisi 32919iru 1691 2193neD ec{J cil 1161 S 891lci91 muriidiliupe b9n$rbrw 81

a3aood bus ae13rrno) ierl3o 9113 cr1 9361 389193ui 1891 eui3 alewol 10 JIsI erfi lo 39$qmi -sts erfi ai airiT •iiiq3uo aienqneq sib iol bnsmeb

erli nhswoI d bnsrrxeb Lsdo1 asase:rxri ii : r3nuo3 Iii noiansqxs Ls39rIom £ •9t81 329193111 1D110W"

erli lo i)Ltas1e ed3 lo ebii3insin 9113 bus nia 9f13 8 91911 819335ffl 16(1W

9361 SWI&bXe 1691 ?S 13u1J03 o3 3DSqael rI3IW c 1IiTIIJO3 LU 1 3361 3asis3iii 1691

bns () —

1\ o3 1sirpe ai vtiDi3a6le 2ir{T •() .p c1 nsvi 13iDi1qmi 3s*i$m aboo us 3jd3 isdcnsme$1 • lo eviJssn e113 o3 lsnoitioqolq

, (OI) d

sii18v svi3iaoq A •193II9 9113 I11J01I{3 292f3CJ 'isr1qneq sr13 noms floi3D13193r11

111 flOiaflI3qXS 1s39nOm 3srIi fIJ39LU lo euclsv eis1 s o3 nibr1oqa911o3 lo enBxbXs 1891 Lsie3slid .'i lo r1013$iDslq9b s 2981J8 cbirlw) i 1inuoo ierfqne

•3uqiujo 1931193 iol basmeb ui 1161 eu3I 8 errirrn93eb 111w (ie3neD erli 1131w e3si 03 svsrl Iliw 93i3i 389193111 1691 eil3 193cre3 sd3 ui 1qqua Di3asmob fI9Vi 8 10'

edi ui scuibeb airfT •3uq3uio i3IIe3 iol 33*1$ffi 9113 S3SldiIiIJp9-91 03 3oI s Ilsi es1 won ierlT •291131wo3 1er1qneq 191130 erli o3 be33uiiansi3 al e3si 3asisJni 1631

111w bn$ ie3neD sri 3 d3iw 9351 ensrfrxs 1691 Lsie3slid blo usd3 36 bnsrnsb axe •noi3siDelqqs 1691 6 erierisqxe

9113 19V0 a1u$vslq 339119 LU\3-1 31 9db O <z II 9361 9nsd3x9 Issu 9113 :u3nicoc uenqius sno c1 uioian6qxe usienom s lo e11e

'Iqq:r txiqfno 91 bns s,+ = noi3DllIñ bnnisb snom 3i3oI9v 3ui8ano3 sr1 n9viO 'IinuoD (9w benucn1si9beq brn) I > i if iiw t&fi woHo1 ii

— 3t) = jt noibrw1

au biu I1snoihoqoiq nsdi as1 3ijd bo3e nom Lcixirnon 3j if3iw aseiiij zoisfi9b qUO iii orrri 9113 rb3rn i11i (I.p9) b1im9b 99iS Lii 9S913fli if T •brniqxs flJq3LJo Lss'x

•931 3a919311i isi sifi lo 1Ls £ bzi noiiioeiqeb 1E91 E 9Ii1rp91 'Lqqx

Page 22: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

J}JG 2}JOCJ oiJ 0 b91.çcfrJoL 6L6U rnço 26W6U 00 jJ6 ow? oj JJ6 GAGUç I26J12 0 C011L26 2çL0Tçj0L0Lq IL0IJ2J9cG 9fl 249ç6m611ç2 c0uc6Lrnu JJG 66Cl2 0 fI6

}IG 291116 LOJG 9 g062 JU OIIL 26cilb)cou2Jnubrou ejçici o W0U&?L q6W9Uq (r bweçGL !II }r6!L usoqj bJo?2 Tp2ç0IJc0JJ?2JlbbJX !UCL692 ou J00J6 oucbrrç VLG oiruq 6 Wf10fl2 92 JJ6? g6bsuq 011 JI6 2TG 0IULUOçIOLTOJ W0U60L J4JJ W000bOJ1241C 2JJbbp6U JJJG G6C2 O 0LG1U moU

y dooJ IAGJ? 2JImJOL L621rJç 12 COIJ2Jq6L6q p? 2446J 911q [J21 III J1GL woq; o

CO11UçL? L6A911162 JIJ2ç6Oq

C0I11JçL1 IJq2 obcimj CGAJuI6 ITU2I fIG C" ff41611 201116 OJJGL BGLIbPGLA

fIG b MJJ6IJ fIG 2J30CJC 1JJ2 p6çMG6U uq JU J2 GdIrJJJpLJrnIJ 110 B61!BPGLAO bGL!bp6L) COJmcLJe2 L6AJ1I6 VJIGJL CHLLGUCJG2 MP!T6 UI1IJJGL —\f 1IJ9IJçcJIJ

— W9JIJJIJ fIG bG ff41611 fIG 2OC JJ2 6M66U €Uq 9 UfII1Jf)GL 1Ab6LTbP6LCofruçLiGa (tiup 0 'sj ) qGA9JIIG CIIILLGUCIG2 N1PTG t unmpeL

p?. JG 2UJ6 b6LGGIJç6 ff43611 2JJOCJC 12 211J9'JJGL fJ11U ¶1 1J1fl1J6L OfIG 2JJOCJ 12 J91GL fl b61ibP6L COJIIJcL!62 1OJUfX LGA9J1I6 cpGJL CIILLGIJC!62

EGLrbP6L COI1UçLIG2 OiIJf?. 6AJJI6 fJG!L CIILLGIJCIG2 j)) fiG 2IUJG b6Lc6u6 M6IJ

bGL!bP61. COIUJfIJ62 q66uq b ff41611 fIG 2pOcI pG4M6GIJ , &uq rjJG CO1T2çUç OAGL MP-P f512 JU miuq MG 2}JOtA JJ JU 6dflTJJpLJffUJ JJOL I30 IOIJ91 COUAGUTGIJC& ! 12 MOLfJ rrOçrcrii pç f1626 fJL62J30Jq2 UG6 iioç

uq uq aircp yJçpOJTJJ MG qLob fIG 2flp2cLbc

2b1P- Iuço AG 26UJGU2 qGJu6q rn GUJJ2 o OuTL 1LG2OJ2 (q6uocGqM6 J0C112 011 JJ6 OJJOMrIJ .42p GdLrJJJpLJImr jpe 2JIbbOLç 0J 2}JOCJ<

3 MP GdlTfflpI4llUJ

111 ¶I1J?. OfJGL COffl3çL)

AICG A6L2& i < f3G 2DB III 0116 COfflJçL2 JUCLG62 MJfJ UJOU691A iIJUOIç!0U

= — ( — < o .c> o (22)

II? IGA6J OJ JJG pocjc JILT pLOW MG JNAG

9j OfJGL EGUbPGLX COfrUL162 6C9II26 i JOMGL2 fIG 2JJ0M qGbLeccJou LG OLIU0IJG91? GXbU2!OU 113 0U6 COJ1IJLX ceuq GUJ3UCG fIG 2p11JcA 0 fIG BG ID

u imboLuç imbpcou o ' qOUJJI3Uç GxbGuqP-rnG-c IJJU G6C &6SC-23\SC\TSS GGCcJGXCIJ6 LG2 qGbLGCWlG f1U2I fIG JJ}JJ2 J2 fIG C226 O cJUCLG9'2G III JJ b6LJbP6L C011IJ1LJG2 qo IJO Gxb9iJq 114J116 cJJGJL pJJcGLJ LGJGXbIJ2iOU p) 0136 GOfIUL JJA6 cJJG ObbO2JçG 21U: fIG LGJ JuGLG2c LCG irnrçG01IU4LJG2 QU fIG OJI6L jiuq ! < o 3G 2b!JJOAGL2 922OCG MJçp 1110116ç9'LAu61ppoL III GL1IJ2 0 fIG rUç6LUçJ0IJJ COUJb64JçJA6IJG22 O fIG OfJGL bGL!bP6L9 boiçLAG GXbrU2TOIMflLX bO1JC!62 J fIG bGLJbpGL?. 916 42jJGLGOLG cp?bbLGcJç6a 911q fJG L6J !IJIGLG2ç LG 9'JJ2 P3 fIG LG24 0 fIG b6L!bp6L? NJP

Page 23: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

-oq) nivIovni 9moaJIJo inuiidilhcp9 no aifi aeairDol flOiUIO8 lo 9t51IB iicO

lo noi iL9I B lo 9XI9iX9 91{1 91nt9s[nOD .9L1IUJO 9IIIO d noiuIsv9b (Idie niniBni6m rI99w9d n919fiibni Bi 'I3nhro3 sr{ 11311e = sa bor1 r1

Iooe i1iom rrno nsano thb1oi1 sri son) i ninobimds brxs eq 9d ts thiow 19r1o nI rniio iii sqmi inoithfini ns svsrl bluow bor{e iri rktiw beboaas '15nOi29D91 bn isnoisfi9b srI srLt €as sri d um i 91 IsrLt BB0 n9rrIniLf3s1 1m18-qffIUf 9ri ot thxip is sq er{t lo n91sb 9IiJ

-9vitii9q1no3 Isn19x9 voiqmi o isbio ni b9nobrLsds i 'itsq r{ nc{w bsnnDrIi

i idi tsd ai;oivdo i fi (O) anoiibno3 't1 .bnsrneb 391B ood bns 9n iii itnuo de iol o LBIJp9 ai S fs b9tsIsIv9 $I2 erli Ii 1no bn Ii eIdieoq

:ier1qiie 911

() = i bus eq £ neswtsd n919Thbfli 9i5 9i1f1IJ0D \19f1qi19 eILt fb rzviO

eif 1 exri2 .uii1sei o ebieb Bu{ 9fli1I1J0D lo iedrmin ui "V d eoneb er1 esrxeoieq s cf (ILsmiqo) eusLsveb eq efi nobn.Bds o 9oorb Lsri

Bi 961 noiiD91q9b

- IA

(xc) = b] —— = —

er{f bru ietneJ eri lo anoinsñ noibei rIi oJni noiasiqxe airL nijjliadu2 inulidilinpe ui 3I siiniro 10 9fn93i9q sr1t er1 riivIo bn.s ier1qiie

'd nevi i ein ed o wiuo iiro ioI eq sri nobuud anm

(8) —

A — — _______ — +

] -, =

sr1 lo 1eismsv3q 9c{f lo anoiiouith sic (4 i...

I = A) 8tfl9i3ffi90D eiit 91911W

I e1dT iii b9iwmnw2 as 1ebom

I JAT —

{{( + — I) + I}(I\\

— [+

91911W

(I -V3 (—I)(+)

(\X —

Page 24: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

qthLecrçrou L&6 O bGLJbPGLA 2 9. MJJOJG %--S% CGIJcGL

coui.ieq u pe pç ibpe ru qrGL6u &? p? bJocc!u JJG 9.AGL9.G9.CcIJJ qebciiou Lç6 J,pG bp cp pocow bLG2Guç2 J6 IoLW9.fIoUcpG 2ecouq L&bp bJoc2 for. cp conuçr.?. puqou b COJTI3çL?

L9.cçioU OJ GOlflJcL!G2 &p9.uqouiu JJ6 b6 uç JIbboLc o 1JJG 2pocJ cJpG edInJipLimJJ onicoiu€ !2 iflnic6q p JflL6 j jpc 9.bp cob bloc2

qTGLt bo' OL 9.U?. L69Ji9.ç1OU O 2JJOCJC GAGLJ MJJGIJ JJGIL GXCJJ9.JJ€ L9.4G bopcrn2

LIbpGLA CO1flJUG cpc 29.L Oj p6!IJ TqGUciG9.J 9.J20 2&LG 29.WG JGAGJ O MGJt9.LG

ic porrjq pe 2ç16226q JJ9.4 JU 149.2P GdHII!PL!ITUI JiUGL COJJ2JqGL9.çOLTa bbG tOL <LGA9.JJTG cP6!L CraLGIJC?. jOL c MTJTTG 9.JJ COIIUçLJG2 MIII W9.IIJ9.IU fJJG L1u1J9'cGL9.J

rIr9.Tu4frU!IJ b6 9.1J JG4JJJ 4}JG CnLLGIJC?. 9.bbLGci9.çG p?' c fjj COITIJçLJG MJJJ

2OC ( 9.uq c) 211CJ3 JJ9. 69C}J UqAIqfJ9.J co1mçL? ij pG rrqLsuç 6MGGUlIT €drnppiirur i EE4JJ p bo2epJe 6IJ6 cptpojq A9.J11G2 OL ci'MJJ!TG GXbLG22JOIJ (g) 6UG2 UfflUGL O COJmcL16 puqourn b

=

9AGL9.G 9.CI19.J 9.bbLGcI9.çjou tç iu bGLbpGL !2pffc GA9.JfI9.4TOU p? IJOIJ& 12 bGLjcçJ? 2?tIUUJ6çLIG LOL 9. 2JJOCjC — cIJG

JJJG C9.26 O 9.13 GthT!JipL!flUJ IIiAOIAlI1 9. tGA9.JfI9.c!OU p? (bo22JpJX) 201336 COIIIJcL!62OL LG2OL LGMTJIT9.cJoIr

LOL TOG1C2 21119.JJGL cp9.IJ 4JJ6 bGL1bJJGL2 COJTUL!62 M1JJ 6!cJJGL "JUc'J JJG bG

TI GOJTIJ4LIG2 113 JJ6 bGLbjsGL? MIJJ qcA9.J1r6 pX 29.WG obcm9.J L9.G 5

2oJI\!u OL }JG coaG2bouqiu cplG2pojq A9.JJIG2 9.Uq J0L 2J30GJC2 J9.L6LG9.U pG qGGLuJu6q p? 2Gc!u v o uq = u dirou () 9.IJq

GoIlucL!62 MJfl pG IJqGL61Jc 6MGGIJ U39.]U9.TIJTIJ ]J6 b9.LTc? 9.IJq qGA9.JIrjU p? cCOU2L9.IU cpc G 9.11 IUçGGL JJJG L9.IJG O A9.JIIG2 OL JJG 2JJOCJ 2uICIJ cPc JT

(r6 < J) - UOçG JJ9. OL GXbo2icroIJ9.I CO1JAG1J1GIJC6 MG i]JOLG

p? cpe 9.C4 cpcv rurr2c JIG Gc.th66U 0 uq IJfl6L o couiufL!62 !IT cp€ açGW4OIJGGJG22 L9.II6 O 2OC2 MJçplU MJJJCp Out COIJIGCçJrLG 12 A9.JIq !2 puJJ6q

bJGuJGucIu 9. qGA9.Ir9.cJOu 12

9.LS9.çG O6 JJ9. mJJJ Gx-9.uçG qeucc9.J GoIrucL!62 2G O GOuJUçLIG2 1111-

L9.G b9.L!X bLoArqGq c}J9'c LGdI1LGq 1JJJUJGL O COITUcL!62 qGA9.JJ16 U JJ6iuqGGq TIJqGLG13c GMG6IJ puqorru OL 1U9.TTJç9.I1JI1J 9.IJUOJJUCG 6XCJJ9.IJG

EduT9.c!011 () nubji 111 9.CCOL9.UCG M4J3 Out CO1J16CIIflG 69.CJJ coiiiiçt?.

TccGL A9.Lr9.pjG 12 bo2!c!/6)LG9.Ji9.ciOu O J3G 2JJOCJC (MpGLG 4 C9.II G JJOMU cpc cpG COGWG!GIJc O J3G

O 9.L6 GXC9.IJG L9.G JJG 9.LG bLTCG JGA6J J36 bLGqGçGLmrnGq M9.G t9.G2 9.IJq1136 bLoboLcorr o cofIucL!G2 9.p9'IJqOIJU JJ6 be III GdIIJ13pLIHUJ !2 9' 131369.1 urucc1ou

Page 25: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

Ier1qH9 9rI In noih3I9qooD Di9mrrn(,8

InoiBn193r1i niv1ovni rfai14 o3 svi3&nsfis 1sioivr19d s 3.a 1oo1 sw fIO13D9 2U13 nI ni319qooD e9fl3fIiJ0) 19riqns 116 &1 uio iJOO 9W 9&) sLIT .noi3nibioo 'i1oq

ai3asmob iisrIJ b mii srIJ (aunim) d bsrnasm a sith1sw nioL iieii3 91fflDCBffi oJ XR JY —) rioibrith o1 1.6rni3qo 9113 3n9a91q91 \3ifoq i3sriom 193Ti9D srI 3 awo11ol 3r1w iii -ibioo SI.B 99113 19f139fIW 10 13fI9bn9qsbni ier1qiio9 9113 iii excn1oq o3 3rst

srIJ ni bsvisnsq ai noi3isqoo 3.r13 ai aiasr13oqrl bsn163ni.6m iuO .3on io bs3n -d.B 9101919113 9W 89vibeLdo 16nisJni rio saurxoiqino s1d.s3qsomc 11.6 a$ 1931193

01.isr1qxisq 9i1 3 bn 1931193 9113 n9sW39d n0iJB19qo03 ib19i 29iwai rrioil 36r3 9n3rmo) rissw3sd 23rI9mq-ebi 3.611 3 smhraaB SW ieLsn.6 srI3 3iior1uoidi oaIA

.3uo bsliri 518

\iup9 liPriohor1 Isnoisn bns mi jj0q i. -ILS 3011 b9911 irIi I.63iiTI9bL I1.61U3DIJ13E 91.6 29113111103 1e11qn9 Its i1iiorI3 119v3

svsir1 isrI3i9 blijow sif 3 muiidifircpe SYI I9OO3 6 Lii 313 1qmi 11aDi3mo3 BSX1I 10 93n9321X9 9113 1auoivdO .asioiloq 9111.62 9113 iqobs o eisllsw Isiips

aIoor12 tLsrrl2 iol !3s113 a9ilqrni '3hsq e113 ninobnsds lo 3203 -cj (1nu2)

svsri 03 (e!v1 9LBIISW Isrioi3ci 9r13 lo rrwe 9113 ab1s91 as) 3n9i3ffi9 sd 3r1im 3i

911 3 sIsm bliiow th{3 o-s Ii 119V9 siiIsvsb esn3riiJoD wsl .s

.2siinsq bsxfi usd3 o3 bi3 3d3 29n3r11;oo 1IU3ffi91 s113 nsr{3 lb suow 29i13111103

b9i01f1e ed n.& bsvusado i 10 noi3srIssu eri3 euolsd bsibseu if19ffl991i3 11.611

-3i31sq 9113 nsri3 ,

(3rsq buirli 9ffl02 10 3nsm9vIovni 9113 ñijouff 3 1di2Boq) 3.oq- lo 2111193 lii bsfiiosqB sd '1no b9sn 3nsm9e1s 9vi3su9qoo3s Iii 3riisu3ario noi3.sqi

9vi3s19qoo) 9r13 usbnn 91.6119W b93sqx9 911 3 :noi3Dnth 22o1 911310 SJJLSV ts srI 3

Ii 91.6119W b93sqxe Sf13 11811 3 noi3sn usr1qius rbss iol 2291 011 ed 32nm 3nsmssus rfDidw 3nsrnssus sni-us 1o bnbl airiT .das4 s1q 03 919W riOi3ii usr1qris £1369

-irtrij 9f11 &it k1SX9 edt o 4&{t tijo b3thoq svd roufii irio ,nois9qiiIJi aiii ood oT8' b9niur19brnJ aj 1LUJ0D 19tn9 eril iii )hlSd L8irre evi x9ano eib lo ii1idthai

bn nieIA) lerilie -1sr1qi1e srfl lo lasielni exLt ni ed on m noilrxilyioo rIqrIsq-79ln93 (CO1} iLLiiO

dliw tiDOaS lLIi99VO 1snoi3n lo aoi en 3 3&l noi iebrno i3nsme 9113 ririonI . £ iii liDjiqifil 91IJbXfl3 1S3[fbUfleid 9113 n{iw abbo i8 Si 9991 9V13sleqOOD S rnaiLsei Ls3iliqme 9ldiaaoq 9113 nibisei anoiisiebianoD 'n ebi 11iV9I buss qsclea

9W :V9lss13S ni11ebom 1110 nxIisbnii noi3vi3om aiioivdo uss si 919113 )L1ow9mss11 ss rkira lo ems 1S39nom ' ico-i3hjrn s ui noi33Istni 'piloq lo alreqss 9a01{3 no 9IlrleDrIo3 03 iiisw

lnbiv 1i911l lo eliqs ui 911cls1e3i1 eril ui bsnimsxs 1n1uoiou{3 099d lou evsd issI os i1oq ieubeñw Si aeibbs ot 3nsw 9w noi3asup eufT .anoiis3ilqmi 'j3iioq buss ti93tii L&)ii9lOSdi

'nLsm u1.l ui ni3sthho bonls ss d beef1 %3 LiW?% a911ihi1JO 9S0113 nomss noilssniblooD

utetaa eull ae1un (sIoñw £ S me3aa 911 1 ioI boda nn us r511113) melsa 9113 lo 'Cx3lnsoD

no a9S1rO qsrles wO .

>bs,tth eviisLiieqa bus ssth9 'Dn9nsr3 ol e1dsenLsrv (esel 10) eiom u1sali moil svit39do thsui vro of betsIsl 'Lbeiib $15 ibiuiw ems '(i31flJO-1lJflm s lo S3Dsqass saorlf

.a-riro3eb iaaeeejuu, 3neaelqeI binow snoi3siIssiene 1si3eioer11 svil3sqIeq siril

Page 26: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

11 xthw anoisii 'rer1qne 9rb aebivoiq bas 'tni8hecfw etnirni1s r1od 91qinhq iii iisrriq bFiow rf lo e9tsfE e1diovthrii taiii sasm&ii lo onol 01i,1 is1!sw 1snoi&i brn anoibs iloq 1.snoiui r{fod iii 291I9191ib oc-.s

-1sqOO L19ffIEX1Y2 lo oa 9r1 o i1f81i6 erL! IJ91 Iliw 9w woI1o1 ñw iii 1811 9 i 'c1Inu1o 19f1qn9 91Hia rb lo ioiv.srled 9rit rhiriw iii fl9ffl9I 9v1i8 1f mo iT1emniIi . Ii :9IouIw aB 19r1qi19 9r1t lo 101VJ3119c1 919V SrLf oi

woo 10 .niiom 9WJ3 9r{t d 1)118 '1rcoenfLcsmie rriLB9i asinno3 \19Iiqi19q -9b birloriE arlOLf8fl \19r1qn99 1L6 t811t niaoqmi 11iB1auI0D B lo 9Dfl9d8 Bill Iii 119V9

o BIdiaBoq aviLs i 1i ( 'd b9llJaBBrn) 'li1&netx9 er{:1 10 91 ns iol Lltho siitsv anoilsn \19r1qfl9 116 isilt 911JuI9 cxl r[iiorie 9lB1 ?b0112 9113 lo 9IJISV 8 9111ff11939b

13fl9ffI99 9vi38lBq000 b91IiI3ano3nhJ 118 [Ii 119V9 L18Di139rnh1n2 91118v9b 111w

nokqmuaas 1110 1o 9fl919b iii bi Bd 01 910111 i 919113 38113 19V9Wor1 9V9II9d sW

sd '81fl 1i 2fIOi3ibIIOD 1116319D iebiui 313111 ILBL11 10iVJ3119d 9Vi31319qOO) Oi139frIm1 lo -miiq" 13 213 eaoqmi o 1121w eW .1Oiv$119d evisisqooo bsDiIieBlrnJ riiw 3119:12121103

rneIdolq 110i3Siffl1X$ffl 111i01 srI iii 111)3 Ho1ro1\ 1)11OS1)H £ "9V131

-1311 1sr1qn9 011 38113 253832 3111131321103 aiufT .3rI9ine91s 9v13819qoo3 SI13 iiiuiflsb '[LB 111311:1 lb 9210W 1i 9)Lsm o-t rbliiow 31i3 31IBffl991$ 1I6 ofii 193119 £1133 IIOxl

flOfl18 219V91 9113119W 111 \DnSqe1D2ib 011 191130 uI .11013.811 '19r1qi19 isifo 110133113291 2irIT .25DrI81IJI1) \ILB 191)1111 b93311n19q 21 29113111103 \1511qfl9 9111

-1L1311193X9 19Ifqi19-813fli 118 11911W 293812fI8lJ 219v91 'ii1i3Ij oct-is L&13119bi b

lo 110i33113291 11 oiii 3io 1)91111 9113 a3119r11'6q-9bie b118 31111033.6 0111i fl9183 91.8 ii .a:1nemul:12111 oi1oq sif:1 lo sai' 3nJ9rnm2

-V8Ibd 9vi31319q003 3i1391r1m28" lo 3I1idi22oq 9111 1110 91111 SW 1III16filL1I1J i loiv.8fled 9v1:1$lsq003 n3srnma cxl 9Vi:1.81n9:1I.s 1no srI3 :15ifqi19 SI13 III 101 '1sr1qn9q us lo a1vs1 '3i1i3u 0-1 9111 52VJO3 lo 4eai'I isbnU .ris14 bBIJlIbnuj

silT .3On 10 fli1891 9fi3 15113911W lo 229th11391 91fl$2 9111 a6w18 9113 2911:1111109

10 mLssi 9113 £11 2911 3111p )St0flOS\ lo noiJqmIJ2aB 1150 101 fI0i389fiil8IJ1 brniol sd 11133 *10W 38 fl0xl0i13291 airi 3 lo arrnol leblurl 'dJu1i1 .1fflOE1O3O 11331311oq

.'8JD 19V9 21982W91I 9113 Iii

-13l9qooD 3rhf9mffl 19b11U 3i1oq u3i9nom I&rriizqO floi

-sd 19vib9lb sr11 1I83i139flh11r'2 bs bn s36rnbl003 291131W09 19nqx19 118 II '9fL1 ai 3f{3 is3nsD 91±! 61S-i3-21S 139113 1)119TUJD 91rIi2

13 91911W 's113 Ii 28 9111311

-1311 iirI lo rioi3sfhii b118 irismoIqme 110 2330lb9 13nh1O3 22013 5113118 9118fI19i11i

LsnoxlibrIo3 3i1oq 1J3f911Offl I8mllqo 9113 32Ift l9bi2uIOC) .291311oq '18i91IOm 181101:1

eth ief113 i srb q- beibei ed Lno 1183 fJi9ffl9S1j3 9Vits1eqoo3 SXIi Ii ievewoH0 ibse lol tsif I iii rii ai :1ni tario3 noiiqbii&q esb nsrlt bsv-iedo need asxf 10 noi:1si oI besiIei sill n&1 ssi on ed b1iiorf I1oE11379qOO3 iebrw eo1 bsiIthx sib lo noisiLssi

.rfM 1q eriniio ff6 Ii 91Ili.fl9 o1 rfJJon9 9I13f V,liL ileIXS sib lo 9I1 13 .swLs i 9l8iLt ,bod ei 'uis iol siweliJ1

.3nsmes13 evil6leqooD begiTIano3nic 1113 111 911113v9b 111w anoiti ierfqris 118 IB1b

Page 27: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

nommo i1 sri n9viO .eq 9d lo nsmnobnBdi oitemma b9&zib1oo £3 110

anoiJnift svib€Ldo 3ismob 10 mr; b9tdi9w 1Lsup9 9rLi ai noitDrrrñ 9Vib9[d0

flaif S II1UJO3 \I9r{qn9 evi' rx9a91q9 3r1t Iii Iqqica 3LI0ffl LBmiIqo 911

(Os) 0 = — + o}o + —

_9q r1 d iokv&19d thJmm' b ibioo o 219191 ? tqi1219qU2 9r1I 91911W

-9b wob&1E niwo1!o'I sr{ iIqmi 1qqrce nom thrniqo 9rfT .iirWOD 19dqn 2shrnro 19riqh9 ILf3 Iii IB3itnebi won i tr1i 91 LroiJi91q

— — — ) °K + — + =

(lo) - - n - ( + ) K}} _ 91911W

(SO) (+o)A (++1 1O291 Iliw a19)LBm \DiJoq rnhsiidifficp9 d8th'I 3r{ lo aithns mo ifiw oLsri 8

2sin9nIJD iemob r1J lo rIoiuLBv9b mo il0iU1V91 Di1eIusrne besriibmoo s o Ii 1rio bn Ii

<{ { - + - - - p) + - n)J }

() 9d n 911n Di1oq air1 ilOitDSB ir0iv9iq sr{t iii bsniLf tb 9fI ruwolioJ

$1G2 r1t 10 ammst ilk nstnw

(0)

-X9 10 saiorID thrniqo erb 11a4 1q 29i1ilIJ0D Lsubivthni 91911W sa&) 9r1 iii eA

-nJ3dS lo ao 9r{t rLfiw $IU 9Ikt lo noaruqino 9uI 291111p91 9ffli91 9S1 9n8rfD .Di191fl snqomqq 911J cii beaa9IqX3 q 911i rxinob

muhdiIhJp9 eviJ319qoOD edT t.ö lo loiv&d9d 3nt9fflflP2 benib1ooD lo 9?D 9r{t cii \3iIoq '189ilOffl thmiqo 511T

Ii :auioithiiiñ iiOibei ciiwoiloI 9IFt 2911qm3 meilqne 9rLf ill 9iTkWO V 91f1 � (nb) —

n( + ) + + r — }

)

Page 28: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

O 4J16 JJOCJCGL 91G GX-U4G fTUCr4JTtJ poii ilJ1TCp W6 UOIJ UJJOLI1I62 t b1 rtGL cjJG LGJ!&cJOU

jjn nmbçrou qoe uo AIO16 }T6 gu 1c91 CO5212ç6UC? o cp uoqj ixrot N€ Gç-

zt-nsç q6rJccfbGcc!ou2) 2ffWG CLO22 6drIJ!pLs 20 &rj b6LbP6' G0fIUIJ62 ILciuGq 22nuTbc!ou cp9 uormuij a ( bL6 2GG0L2 bLeq6Gurnu6q GX-GIT226 LTJ bL6AOfl2 26COU2 1JJ6 COWb9LT2OU !2 c9LLGq OfI IJIJq6L 4JJG fflBU-ijr!2 ciou !2 qoçq o 6d1rJp4IruJ rJJocrçJou2 q-

GLGUCGO DOGe coob6Lou J 4G bGLIbpGL? UJ6 c qp-

L6A9JffG 0L c'a oUcj? q6A9JJ16 0L uq 10!IJcTX mucu cp biii COOLqTUçGq a?ium6çuc 6dnJ7pLiI1w b&LJbPGL?. C0flUfL!G2 iiUjJ oucjX

CIJ6L tMJJ G IIJJbJ6W6LTçGq 0L L6 7IOU2 0 20GJC 2UJJJGL JJ9J —29mG o 4JJ6 bGL!bPGLA CLTLLGIJCIG2

— (c + ) (r—

——

—(c + )

——

I + fC!1416L6

=IfJ

=— \w) —

IVBI'EtAJJGLG cJJG b9L9UJG4GL2 4 9LG queq LU J9€ 3:

(@)

+ — + + + v—

LG20L o cooqmq a)dIJIJJGçLJC qGA9JIJ9coIJ i IJq OU !2orJuu 0L GdnJJJpLJnIJJ )icjqa toJJoMiIJ conqrou: 4JJG hGL!bPGL P/4JJ

riUCiOIJ 12 2tUG 2 JJ9 JAGIJ JU 6thJ9J0IJ (j)TJG CGIJcGL C0frUçL? 9J?2 bfñ2 MP -c-ssa i.ibpei Jc2 LGCç0IJ

= + — + + ( + —

MJJTJ6 J

Page 29: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

3on ai 19r{qn9 &rf 3 iol s3io1f9 feed r13 ci noi319q0o3 Di139nhrnc 19113911W

isr1qhs er1 d anoibJ3 Di1oq nornrno .bn&{ 9110 9113 nO .3119b1V9 1tsibirimi i1oq 'm3snom ei3rrno L&cbkvibth rbe lo a3e1Ie 3991thr1i 9113 Ith 9iL8rn93rIi nsI3 3orI SiB 23D3I13 1&iis3xe 989113 1I0i31th13fD yE1 .9iB119W 29f13rnJ03 ierl3o rio 19(130 sr{3 nO .irniiidiliijpe r1a4 th isLsm iloq sri 3 d noi3Sl9bianoD o3iri

.berIii3anoD ci 110133mñ 9Vi3D9[,dO 3riioj i&dqns sf13 10 f1O13iffl1XBffl 9113 brxr1 io anoi3inr1vsb i3smrrwe (3.o-t3 bnB 3i-) lo 3nsffl9liIJpSi 9r1 3 lo 98U&)9

s3ufoadB cii) sis1 i13nebfflure ci boife 9r13 11911w '1no b93neinefqmi 9U3 erioitGrsLsvel bs3&iibiooo 10 380D lnue 9113 1o 'ithirso rkue d 3rie1rn8q silJ 1i3eii o3 (sulsv

moil f11fflS1I93E jIoi3s1sqoo) moil B111B SI13 2U11T .sq 9113 lo 3nemnObrLBds

10 AI s113 d 3safio 13iBq 918 e19vo111qa \19r1qi19q_Ls1fni 10 noi38i1S111931Ii 9113

ebiow 191130 iii .

JnL6T3er1o i3einrrna .s o3 3osjdire 3n9rn991 n lo 3i1idixsfl 101 sq SI13 nobfiBd.8 3nob C9il3IflJOD 1erfqii9 9113 er13 saaD erI3 ed bIllJo3 3i

&moa3uo culT .rnrciidilirsps aci3emrrna (bsni.&i3ano3) 8 111 eborle '1Larne \19v131s1e1"

8Si131IIJo) 19r1qi1S 9113 lo 11111 8 9(13 lo airiie3 lii) JfISi3fflSffl i11.8i3oe ed bIIJo3 cii rnuiidiliiips i1cVI (berrisi3anoonii) 9113 03 bsiBqmoD (erioi3Dnrñ ceol

ed i-ioiio\-.n blriow 31 .sq 9113 nobn&1.8 bluow eeri3wcoo 'isi1qne 9113 lo 3sadiic

nOi3s19qo0) b9ni.813an0nrs iebrw rrmiidiliiips 9113 o3 bsisqmoo 3nernkflsni 116iDoa iedqns1 s113 lo 3eadisa d sq 9113 lo 3nslnnobrL8d8 svlovni oct13 bfirow ibiriw .9111313193i1 9(13 cii firo be3nioq 'lL81J81c 29110 3113 moil 3rieielhb cnoassi io .B9iI3IIIJOD

.919(1 svibIthOlql93rnJoD sd sm noii.8niblooD viIoq (bsni6138no3)

—X9 '1B9nofrI ffiOlT! 9i1Is1n9Xe 9viieoq rliiw eisIIeW .t.E1

.ierIqiis &r1 in EfloiEfIsq

'3i1idom Ls3iq 1.8noii.8rnsini iDsIIeq rlliw 93.81 9n.8rbx9 ni3.soft Issi1 .s isbirU X9 iB39nom 33ns1.8d no 3&{3 309qx9 ew 3kbiii e.sw thnimon mn-ho11c bn.8

289n9v13133qmo3 1.8rIoi3sEnsJni s113 119810W blirow 13nuo9 'isr1qns '11B 111 noiaciBq srb lebmI 3.8113 nworlc sv.8rI sW . 0 < ei 3.8113 i3nuoo \19nqi19 isñ3o 1I13 lo

noien.8qxs iJ339nom lo a3s11e -sin 3.8113 noiiqmueas bsni.B3ni.8m (0 < ) isriqiis sf13 lo 3ci srI3 iii a3Dells i ai ievo IiBvslq

won eW ii1oq siI3 iii a3n9irI91qmo Di9L813e 91.8 a3nsxmn3ani 'i.s3enom '1s3snom lo noiecimensiJ LBnoi3mns3ni s113 lo euroi3.83ilqmi 51.8113W sib o3 irrn3

-si-lomB 193nsD srb cii bn.8rneb s3.8exB 03 a±)oñc lo 93ci9B91 9113 111

:eeiDiIoq

r3nuio lo 9113119w 110 11'95tS 3l3S%0c 13 81311 k 13wJo) iii noicnf3qxe i.83

srLt iii bn.smsb s3.891.8 03 ?borlec 98&) 9113 3eifi i9b181103 eiri3 992 oT ifa nejlw 'isi1qiis 9113 111 noiJ.8Lr1.8veb nommo isn3 o3 r1uone r1ii{ ci 3.8113

(3nerrno1qme bn.8) '1qqcrc enom 9113 IIsVi bn8d 91109113 riO .r1a14 Iq eeki3nuo

no noin.8qX9 'j.83srIOrn 13nLr03 redqrzs na lo 3391i9 L63o3 ei3 3sr13 19v9woff s3oM 'enorn nsvi [1tiv sit&sd svi3ioq i (tnsD sri 3 b) i3nico \39I1qr19 193130 'IIS 111 51.8115W

.93.81 3eis3ni Lse1 bFiow sr{3 'jswoI 3i ssw

Page 30: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

i orii lups riir1 rsr1o ti1ani bor{ sr{ o esirLv r9riir1 Iffl,OD flu

(ND) oiiq Dismob Io f9vsI 19r1irJ i oni e1o1I9ñt brie noitEi9Iqeb ier1r1 Ioicnsrxi eufi iiod asr1oqiri iijo isbmr brtif ier{o scfJ itO . irnco ioI

\rrnJoD ir1qns'I i9r{O d noiiJLBv9b S Di1oq L69flO1fl O -1isq I93rIsD 9r1 -L-rs Dfl9TIIfl c '1fUJOD lo noisiiqqs its eubni 111w

StJ3 o sri 'ro IiTwoD io1 9Df19iJ9flO3 'isnoisfini ui isafio rIOifLBqX9 VLEt9flOffl £ Ic 19voI1iq 1SflOi3Sff19fli 9ñt aA .I9fnsD 9r1 iii brlsm9b

-thqo srlt eir1sv ist fI9flhJD i biswo ND irnso &)IJb9l k rtwro iii srnoDed \nx co ni (sq 9d riinobasds rio 1snoiibnoD) ai1oq 1&t91IOffl LBm

.119)103' sins 91h vEE .915119w bus ffl9ifl1O1qffI9 i IIiaB913ili isn0ia11Sqx9 elOffl Sf13' iij bnsmsb 9Vi3'89C £ lo 1tfIIi0) (U 89)Ii9ff92flOD 1SflOi3'Sfi9b 9(13'

£ 2SDlJbni k vI3'nuloD cii noibsiinoD 's9noni s 119(1w bsrisqrnsb ed 111w 193'rIsD

.193'1193 9(13' %iS-i-?.tS Dfl9T[UD ?i \13'ffhJOD lo 1101 i)91q9b

-rmoD iii noiansqxs 'is3'snom s 03' 915119w a\i v13'nuJoD lo saiioqei 5(13' 1thmio'I bs3'SIIIDI& 9d n& 3'sofl SiDfl911IfD 1i911 3' ni3'3'1 B9i13'ruJoD rl3'od rio IsrroiJibrioD

-o1qms 13'nUoD 03' 3'Dsq91 rl3'iw noi3'anrñ aaol 'u 13'rwo3 n1 x3'ne1sIIib d bn 3'risrno1qms lo Isvel imJhdiliup9 5113' is noiaBsiqxs eirl3' iii3'siithvs bits 3'nsm

:3'sofl s isbm aehq

(8b) ( — =

ti svods sd llivi Isvsl siiq muuidiliijps riasVI sf13' lo asiilsv sis1 I3'n9ioffihcE io Isvsl 3'sis3' a3'i wolsd sd 111w 3'rismo1qme imiiidilinpe rfaBfrI bits) Isvsl 3'srs3'

nOiEnBqxe 153'9[iOffl s :svi3'ioq zi nedw svi3'ssri 9101919(13' zi (8b) noiazeiqx3 .(. snsasq srl3' iii zblorl afiaoqqo sifT s '13'rmo3 Iii 915119W B 891D i3'rmoa iii

Lii flOi3'3S13'flOD S 9I53' ND 9(13' wofsd won zi as : zbor1z 9vi3's9n sis1 lo . '13'ri11Oo (Ii 3'iI9lII9VOlqffll 915119W s d3'iw bslsiDoeas sd Iliw k iirmoD

i1qqriz snom Ismi3qo sf13' lo noi3'sfiiml9leb sri3' rrmiidi1iicpe evi3'slsqooD s nI .z3'D9fl5 Lsins3'xs 989(13' 10 93n93'BIX9 srI 3' 3'rwoos o3'rii 9)153' 111w 19r1qi19 9113' Lii

-lsvsb nommo s isii3' 03' rfioris sis1 zi 3'srIi .borfe sc{3' Ia noi3'si1ssi 'ps iol (iDSI3'noD io) bnsqxs 03' brisi Iliw slodw s as 19uIqn9 sf13' (noi3'sii1svsi) noi3'ir

.mhci1di1i1cps rIasT4 5 iii rzsrf3' rmthdiliitps svi3'slsqooD Di13'91nffiE s ni siom

'iInJro3 Thd Iqqi; 'nom 1i brisqxe k, 'iiitiroo ibidw cii as 9r13' isbiano3 oIs ns 9W cr1 1qqir i9nom if 3' rl3iW .tenD xf 3' iv-s-iv si snsthxs isnimocr bexil £ aths3'nism s ci IT rf 3' bni3 trr9rrPoIqm9 cl3'od tizsq 3'nmrn ecl3' q o [auon9obrx9 rii3'ai(bs

b miet cr1 .0 < b9bivolq k vIiru ro d noiansqx9 1a3'9iIom s ñ3'iw 9B&7Dni 111w iriuo3 aiilt 9101979113' bhioi1 vjivibs lo level erl3' cm 9aselDni ciS lo 8W9fl boos ed3' rxoibruj1 o1 z3'iwo3

lo noitssiIt lo ens•i icsv,Iei eñi 79V0 .19V91 eriq ier1iif s lo W9fl bsd sd 3' 3'arnss ts ed s cr1 lsmi3qo i noilsxclsvsb nommoa s doidw iol ?bod sxl3' 10 sir1sv sor1t ci 3'srl3') boi{ erl3'

11S3 ilmet iz1T .iensl edi e3'snimob 111w 3'oslie isitnol sd3' (mcthdiliups evi3's&qoo3 smm 93ne9Thb ed3' o. Iimoihoqorq i $1U ed3' lo sisirp edi 3'sc{3' rii3'on 'd ber1ai1ds3s 9d 1!is9

• (3'nsrnnIiLs9i lo ioo 1nu &d3' lo 3'ea) 3'soft £ iebxw aaol eri3 bits sq £ isbrn; o1 eif neewied

ed wd3' n& nsrIJiD 3'i eq sd3 vIirwo3 s ito ioq i.a3'enom 'k i3'niro lo f1s silT

Page 31: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

snsrbxe 9v1b&fi9 brIE L6'19BIiEE .0 mhJildiIiup9 OW 911i Lii e9tJ31 9fl&bX9 9II lo ioiv&fd SL{1 t81t1IO3 nOLfD9a irIT

.9IocIw s a 19r{qn9 i{ ioI bits 19v91 rtrruo isirbivibiti L'S s i{fod arioif&oIIS enoLisi1s91 l9bianoo Irio Iliw sw 1iir{J thnoiston bits 'fiDi1qfflie 10 L6 9rft Io'f

r1 BfIiSS 1101351115V9b s bits sq s sis a9vi s3is 9113 iol )bof{E srii 10

3SI13 sw s riDiJa ni )bork erI3 Ic hoqqlJa srI 3 3n3si 9W 03 i 3srfT .stnsD 9V13S91I 9LBI 3uo riilin Jsini3qo I9V9fl i i3ni;o isr1qns £ d rioiisriLsvsi s

1101a1193X9 silT .is3neD sf13 iii bamsb (9113 lo a9JJLBV bs3iuioib 3iiissiq) .woIloI 03 ai1n 9113 lo 'CISllo1o) sIqrIIiB S i 9.&) IBI91I9 9113 o3

i eisrI3 isi1qiis srI3 111±1W tsr13 lIworiB 9V51l 9W fI013)92 auoivslq 9i13 iii lo rioiaaimnsi3 Lsnoi3sirisini srI3 LI3IW bs3siDoaas Vii1S1fl9X9 915119W svi3iaoq S

i1oq 'is3sno1n anoi3qmIJs iiio iebnTJ .svi3iaoq 21 11911W \Diloq 'is3snom iIoq 9vi3sisqoo ni3smrn s 03 bslsqmo3 9VI3Dfl3291 003 9d Ifiw rk.sM isbiur

.a9iiIlsrrIe3X9 110112 291I,Brr193fI1 'IIuI1 3sr13

-oqoic d b9i1smrnuJ2 is3lssisil Ei B9tB1 9fl5fI3X9 lo lOivBII9d 15i311919'Rib SLIT

-sq lo 2398 3nsisThb ioi . bits iri1 d be i3BuhIi bits 1 1rroir{3 I noi3i sq 9113 nobrisds 3sr13 29i13111J00 lo 916112 9113 3oIq sixsi1 929r13 sxiisv ais3erasi

sV13o9fI9 siI3 bits — s3si noi3xr1svsb Lsirbivthrii 1ami3qo srl3

ssl3 1o iloqqrr2 9113 3arIiss (( —

193119C) 9113 s--tt e3si noi3siilsveb 9113 rnrthdiIiiips rIasl4 srI3 o3 819191 sthl biloe 9r13 ai1qsi us nI bor1 bnsmsb

.iioi3oI1 9Vi3519q000 9113 03 91111 berlasb 291d5115V 929113 rioi3rnfisb '8 . bits 2b1o11891113 OW3 9113 38Ifi isbi&iioC)

JsrIJ 'i3niroo isr1qneq ns Ic 9351 91I.&if3X9 9113 III qfflIJ( eIS 9113 9115859ffl

s lo esia e113 no isbnxcod iswol 9113 ai 3sr13) eq 9113 nobnsds o3 Ismi3qo 3i abniEl

oals 'sii3 noiiwi3anoo d ievosxoF/I (is3nsD srI3 3iii 3rI9ffmith91 lsis3slid worla o3 'aB5 1 31 .sq 9113 thiobrxzds lo 3aoo sisilew 1snoi3sui sf13 srnaissm

woHo1 e - 1

______ ________________ I - + = 1)3+ ) J

9113 lo 9flS7 3nsv9191 eif 3 vo 9viierI i ebi-b1wd-3191 9113 ni m3 3.IJ sill 9vod b9xsaib A lii 1iism'oIqms lo iiorbrnil 9vjJs9fl £ Ej 73nhJo I5ilqfl9c S 10 $1G 9113 () d oa1A .bor12

isvo svi3ssn lR1,oJ;id1nSn1r i (1) noias1qxe sill 91o919dT .9iTIrnJoo '1911qi75 791130 9113

rioi3snLsvei lsmilqo Ia 9.BD sill ,u18s sriO .0 II31W bsbo *orle sill lo snsi sill uisvi) both sr1 lo rioiisiLssi 9VilS5n s lo sn9sq siLt iii :eni iii 1kEtiw s sv!ovni 1no

.s y13n1103 iii S7SIISW sDnbe7 k TtnhJo3 d iioinqxs £ ( nsie1srq 3iislbIlIIp 979113 tisilw 9bi3rn0 1f1Sa9)en (.srxiI owi siFt sioI&isd3 bn8) anoii6)o1Ls owl 9113 isill s3oVI

= .s.i) sisllsw 9i73flh1o3 791130 no izoLb.s i1oq a lnIJo3 sno lo 3fls lsrnsixs on ai nrii ai 5 bns iisswlsd 9Df1979Iib Ino 9113 sdi slon 3xsi 9113 iii 3i1siipecii 9113 9v07q oT8

bsnisldo ai lsrll ()\. norbnth S isbianoD .5 iii (% —

1)3 'd b9Slqe7 ai S iii lsl9mSlfq 9113 9111517EV s —

1)3 io) nilir3i3ac1ija d (5 o) 5 moil

+ ) =()\

Page 32: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

s iii I9rIir1 Iairoiridmsnrc ai sfsi noisHthv9b thmiqo eldiaaoq e911sme r1 &{ :flOi&OIIE daVI

() + ) < —

1)3+ } 1

aqmirj, er1 nuiqmo 11311w $ 91Ui lo 1qi bnosa r1 ru risiqq ai ffuasi airiT .I9vitD9qa91 brig b1or1a9Irf L 3 sti noiisisthvsb 9rft ui

sts1nLsq lo 9E rI9I9flib io1 eiiri'I ni b9tanfIi oath ai tIiiaex ma sifT sq sr1 ruiruobrid. lo 3rIuoD isq aoo sithlsw thrruiruim srf fnib1oD3A .aerithv

.mirhdilinps iiisunrna bssnibioo in rr&1 riasM ru 9fIff{ EBwth ai .noiIxaoqoiq aifi mo oJ niirt won rx&

rxo sucs'cw. thnoo I ioiiaoqoi ikui ois sur unt o\a \o as'os

(OV)

aish1 mithdiIiirps ifasl'l S in .sift borth er1 lo sijlsv bIor[asiii sr1 isbiarioD thisrn 51IJ ts

. ( = ) aefttmro Ith in 'd noisxjthveb Dnf9rnrira s

Ifs isvo rrnia si1 d nhrLsvsb 10 nisq rI39w9d nsisfiibrui ai 'insjo usvs lo su) esmisi owi snfi rusowisd 1siineifiib siis1Isw erIJ Io a9rrnJcoD isr1qiis9

iixuiobrisds 10 tao 9Vis11Jm11D 1so er1 o Isups 11Dsxe ai (ateoD n9n1ntLBs1 91Tf bod2 siLt lo 19V91 9fflJ3 9ILt iol 15V9WOf1 fIOibIflaIIOD H .3V sq 9f1t

ui isrIucf 916 isr1qne9 91L1 Lii ) d LIOitSiJIBV9b bsithisn rnoil anis 915119W

aoxs aIsLin9191ib sithlew lo mire sr1 :rnuiidiliirps 3i1sinm'e bstsnthiooo siLt (@) 'IiIsipsni maii (sloleisifT .0 < 11511W risn1t i9rjir1 1iite ci a9i1ruuo

EiniSt 111 9ffii91 9S1 91IB11DX9 owt SIkt ill 15itru919Iib 9113115w siLt fflBC91X9 bins svsrl sw ssi noLisiDsiqeb wobsrfc siLt lo

(1,)

-rlaeirLt siLt bor1e srli lo sie siLt ni ruia69IDuIi ci sJsi noit8iDeiq9b wobsife siLt cA iswol sd teirm noLtsurlsvsb DrI9rnflFB bStsrIibioo3 s isiit Jsrb ioI suthv blo

.bS 11J311t

-sMijmie a9fllmIo') I1I 'c1 tii9rfluIufJ39i £ )bOdc 9111 lo noitiidiitaib io3 .r1as4 isbnic rusrfl ioivsn{sd svitisisqoo Di1temm'c isbnu iIsIi1 910111 Ci Iaucoen

ruoitsi1qmi ssibsmmi ms atrusasiqei ti as ththqiuse sd tori bliiorla Muicsi culT 18t9nOm fsnoitsrnstni lo mahusurbsm siLt tirods anoitqmuaa bsnistnism no

9aoqrrn a191sm-M1oq risrfw' ti trig rioel9brIsH bus n9nonsD as :noiaaimansi usrthsi siom ruiob iol allso ruoitsieq000 19r1tons sno no esitulsnistxs svitieoq

wollo1 ii —

1)3 � (V —

1)3 . iii nioirni cILazinoonom i ()\ tSt1 9visdO .iLsupni 9r{ ni1iiv

— 1)3)" � (t

IC

Page 33: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

biLll qcruu 1p6 G9LJ) o cp ErntI)opcX UJ9fCGL2 ijj pu€ iiijn c pow moocp 9uq L6dffGu L69I5W6iJ2 ( rrnjrt

(J j] b

— .c) >— \o. 5 ()

wur r c coo ccc 'I\irçucs&.sc coob.coIl (a 5

bLObO214!0U 3 cIS? 1I013 o\ c cn o c

MGAGL?JJ6J622 !'3 J3G 9L69G cji€ O1JOI1J bLobo2J!ou pojq2:cofruçL? orrjq 6A9JJ16 !'3 J,492J3 9fl0C9c!OU ( >ffLJJGU b6ubp6L COIIIJçLJS2 L62014 COOLqu9c6q q6A9JIl941OIJ2 IIJJTCp p6JOLG 9IJ2

E!I1L6 3 2p0M2 cpT2 LG2HJ 12 9cçrr9JJ?. drnçs GUGL9J 92 rç ur pojq 9J20113 9 C0OLIJ9G 2?JIJ1U6ç4C 6dITTJTpLIdflXr

qGA9JrI!u cpG qsbL6cJ&Tou L9G I1UCJ6L 492 12 TJ!P6L cJJ9IJ 4}JG qGbLGcr9ciOu L9G— B6d() XçGiiç 92 GdrnppLJnm p92 201116 C0IrUIL162

6MG6IJ 9 G0OLJU96 be IJq 9 COOLU946 2?.urm6uC q6A9Ir9crOu 12

ou2iq6L 9 L69p9çiou o 2pocj.c 2JTC JJG beLibp6L? 12 JuqTGL6IJ1

C0Il0&S OS SOS UIc 111 2C COOlt ll-o\ cos ri o 'o cn sccr uics COOI ILIC Il O\ \OL \I 22

ib?\ cor\ cr co so s c jcr ccI-bLobo2i.cJon c o\ cço&r o\ oc \o.OIl 4J36TL

JjJ6 IJ6X bLoboaiiou tOGJ1262 013 IJJG uJ9IJ1f1zqG 0 LG9T!mn6IJc2 L9JJGL r9UJ6A6J O 2}JOCJ( 113 CGUcGL

I'3 C926 9 COObGL9çiAG 9L66fflGIJ 6AGL2 J622 GXCJJ9I1G L9cG 249piJJ OL O'Il\12 soc. pgu jm6pojq 9 iipicp 9 J692c 0116 coIiuçLA L69J!IJ2 smqGI. '4}38

boiuç OL 9 6IJ6L9JJ6q q6A9JiT9i0IJ JIIJGL 2mIJJ6cLTc coob6t9c!ouc0IrLJ.Ju9cioU o b9L9meçoL2 (imbj2iiu 9 pTpGL rIJIJ9ciOI19L2 P! pIJ T'3 E!I1LG

IJl2 12 uoç 6U6L9J L6211Jç; EJJJLG 3 2O2 bo22!p!J OL 201116

LJG2 MIJJ m91U9fl3 bc ITIJ6L coob6L&!A6 9L66LUGIJç 69L2 Gmbp92!IJ201116 C01111çL162 M1JJ qsA9JJI6 !IJ 9 492 GdJT!J!pLrnm MJJ!16 9fl bGLbPGL GOIIIJ-

916 b022pJG 9J20 0L Q JIJ E!JiL6 OL 1IJ249UCG A6IJ !2 Gth6GU Q 9IJqLG9J1Inu6uc2 O1?-CO11L 92 JJ1JCO0LW96 qGA9JITI9cTOu2 p & 21J2G 0 GOflIJçLIG2

JG22 fl0MGAGL 22flJI136çL!C COOLqJU9çIOU 1JG6 hOc rmbj) IIJOLG LGdI1GLTV

Page 34: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

srI o 9I9V 9fL rtht8t d !9ithbrnmi b9fiul9v Bd no noiiaoqoI iifT ((1) noiup9) 1str19D 91{ s-i-% 9t1 H8113X9 I9f1qi19

(CT) + — + (

— ( + ) =

sviioq i noiSiDs1q9b 989v.8 r{J r1 niqqs i 3i noia891qx9 2irb moi'1

9I9VS 9Vibfl9i 910ffl A .\19r1qnsq 9r1 Lii nom S £19V13 9r1 Io noibruñ A ei rioibsiqsb 9B19V iswol ni hresi 1 airm daB4 ibrm viIoq irsJsnom

nois!;J3v9b svisfIe 9i{f lo a3olq 9f1 d fl9Vi 81 8111c29i 923rb 10 Ei29fI)H'2 1ir1q.s .C bn srniT lo motod sr1 s isr1qnsq sr1 ni 29B1

110 )iloq ii&tsnom 2VLtL1IJO3 19r1qfl9 £ 10 X3119 i8mSJx9 9rJf lo SIIJiBII 91ff .noiiaoqoiq 2Ir{f iol 91EflOitE1 9I1J 29bIvolq 51.8119W e9irtflhf0D 19r1qrr9 19r1O 9i1

-v sriJ iidi1iips iLtod iii srcLBveb e9iirmoo Ith 9113ffl of r1iroris 91Bf aborl2 io'T

9viLSlSqOOD 3iIt9fflffl2 13 Lii 19113I od 11kw 'tsr1qiisq ei1 irk '1qqira 9fIOffl 9S19 -bnoqBsno3 11kw stsi noitsinlsvsb silT .iniriidiliups rfaiI'1 iii ri&l nuriidiliips

ts) abonfE 1911i3m2 io1 .mishdifircps svitslsqoo3 thtsrriini sr1t ni isrfirl sd Irxi -dilinrpe DhtsfIurna b9riib1ooD iii enrisvsb eshnuo3 ff8 sLsm o ilzions 91131

iteriom srsvi wol 11Emiqod1r2 13 ni 31icsi 11ite mnthdilinps rla8T4 13 (miiii siLt iii n.8rb iswol noiisiD91q9b 91319V13 n.t niIqmi 19f{qfl91 srLt iii rioian13qx9

.fioit13niblooo 3i19rrmPe lo 9213D

siLt o aborfB siLt lo fbi iLBs1 io1 thiLf sLsJ ie eot 4 bri rioiiaoqoi ni 19r1ir1 '1aijoicidm.snij 81 3E1 rIoii8nLBvsb 'csui siLt

, ( < ) lo riii

1.8miqo 21trrnoD irbns sib nsrfw L19V9 noLt.8Do1th oiifsrnmi b9f&iibioo3 13

s nil iedu1 ai (sq sib nurxobnsd.8 i no I.8noiibnoD) sJsi nloi313iDelqsb

on iol lo boothodr1isn tisI silt iii abor12 WOil l9biafIOD .rrmiidiliirps ti bnfi blow esiitmroo iscfqns 9m08 slixfw 9Jdi22oq 2k noitiIsL8v9b Di1terrrnr

f{af3Vl 13 )bOrl2 silt lo 119112 HI .rlasi4 nr'slq asdw sulsveb ot I8initqo 13 n.r1t '\3i1oq 113tsnorn 18noian13qx9 siom '?d b9thst131.8rf3 21 miciidiliupe

mo siste uID sw eirdT £ sn.ci' nil irwork 21 tiIidia8oq 2lrlT .sno svii.Blsqoo3 :noitieoqolq tasI

i:ic sc\t 1irOD tr orco\ s \o n1oiti2oqoIq sisk oic kis 'o\ *o s \o on \o ssurc •s'oA. .n sir knso3 sno

boc i ri iio içs \ .i ni soc tits s\.,tV i ici sM

2891t2 sr1J a noitfI9tt.8 LsiDsqB svisasb noitiaoqolq aIrit lo anoitaoilqmi sifT 11a4 iii ierluf sd birco3 si11sw taoq xs 2913W iI9v1 101 313ilt ti1idiaaoq 911t

9J33 silt sd 111w aisff .imriidilucps oi1ieinhxiya bStI3nILbloO9 13 111 LISELt IrlLJildLElIIps

Dntsmxrna bstsriiIYIooD 13 19i1t ot rfuons s113l ton 9113 tsift lo BSIJLBV iol smoa d IlOit.61cI13V9b bst13niblooDfrn 1113 9311bf1i ot ilrione 9i131 tlJd noitBIJthvsb

rxoitJilsqoo9 on IDorla 9r1t lo esirLsv 119112 1O1 .mIIildiIiLJps rlaal4 s iii ashtnuJo9 .noi313lsqooD (bsnialtanoD siolsisilt bn13) Di1tsmme 29tl3IIiffIOb

Page 35: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

L69 i1JçGLGç L$4G

Exb&!ou9I noisr bojic?. iii u?. coinj). (C6U6L OL BGLIbP6LX) jo jO12 }J6 MOLJ

JrJJ?. IIJcGLIJJJ62 9J T1J4L8-b6LibJJ6L?. iU6LUçiOU9J 2bJJJoAsL2 t4OG cpc IIIJqGL011 ptuqornu cJJG b6 COLUILUOU 6A9uiEfOU L6 RUj P6 CJJ91

COJJ6C1AG li6Jt9t6 GO24 O LGU61U ou 4JJG cowmrçrxrGzJç b6 CozKouJLIC coob6LcrA6) qprçrou IJUJ6 co o b6x 2 pp GUOfl O262OCJ 113 JJ6 CGI1GL JJG J,GLibpGL?. ijj uoç o iwbJGmsuc r1oiu (e?.uJmGc-

G G2CIJG p? ii2iu LG2JTJ?2 II! oin. 26CJOU 2 I'-' LG2bOU2G 0 & q6UJ9Uq2?.2çGm (ruq bGLJbpGL?. cormçL1 LG -cs 2iimji. GCJJ ocpsL) onccowc!ow JO JJG GX46U cps coob6LçLA.6 p6pAioL bLGInJ2 ! 4JJ6 bGLTbp6L? o

V' GXC}J1t1JG L6 9LLUG1UGU 12 bLriu9uJ?. rzrcp&uizu oi bopc?. cooLqrnI-12 obiri'j pom iça qomc bornj 0 AJ6tAqsuJIJq 2JJOCJC cjJG 2?.2ç6w p?. jciij qow2c bLic 1.126 po/.G cp JGAGJ cpçcoobGL1AGjA jç qo UO LGG o 6U6C 0 011.13 TLG?JçG}16 04JJ6L 2q& 2fL!IJ Bo!u 0 OJU 9U9J?.212 12 4JJG C6UGL 1161.61. 9C2

JJG ecp Tq6 orrjq p6u6ç potu (co21X) Wo1J6çrLX GXbIJ2ToIJ 111comjrcc o ru46L6ec2 p6cM661I C'-' svq JJ6 b6Lbp6L?. 2 11}J0JG qrI6boFcA obçiou2 1A6 OC112 OIl 916 JJO26 obGu JJ6 b6LIbJJGL?. COIfllpLiG2 CTAGIJ

1 qqL622Ju JJG 122116 O iiubrcç o 2fIC qJ2çfILp9JCG 013 JJ6 2?.2çGIIJC0mflJL?.

TU cp C6IJ6L 6IJ6Lç1U bL2mL62 0L 913 bbL6Gi9!0U O JJG CJJLLGIJC?. O J.r12! 2?açGW !2 9 J9LG 92?.IIJIUGçLIC ql2çm.p911C6 III JJG 0LLU Oj & qmuq 2JJOCJC&L 1J6IJJ0L cpiorrp !I746LIJ&cOIJ3J comb e;!c!A6u622 JJJG 2OJrLcG 0 GIJ2!0U

E"JT JJ6 JUc6LIJ9c1O1J9J O 111O1J691?. bojic?. !U 2?.2ç6W !2 pG-OIIC0IJ36 O lo!IJc 9C4132 I3Jbfl62 fl6LGU4 j61.6j2 O U9!O1J9J 11.6jL6 I-3OccoLqiU 1AIGJJ 1-c3 iq6IJçiCJ COfflJ4LJG2 qo 1J04 LGG coob6L9'çG !GIJ0LCGJ6 ouT?. r cJJG?. C0IJ0LUJ JJG bLrncthjG 0 u9'r0U9' JJ0LJ0LTç9'J GdiIrç?.6 Mrfl!u o cooq1uce b011c162' H06A6L iIJ6LIJ9'çJ01J9j 9L66GIJ2 916JJ6 CGUGL 9'j1A9A2 bj9'?.2 j4B2JJ Sr--S\1% JJ6 b6L!bP6L?. J,GLJbp6L). CofrIicL!62 1.119'?.9' bLjcG J6A6J bojic?. 13J9'JGL2 ill jJ6 C613GL 9L6 9'uq1IJ1IIJJ6IJI !2 J622 cJJ9'IJ bGL6c LLP6 CGU6L bLoI.q6e IJOUJ!IJ9'j 2c9'piJ!1?. p?.GXC}39'IJG L9'G 9'L66IJJ6IJ 12 26613 92 9' ciniijçmeijç 9'JJ30JIJJ cJJ6 C011J-

JJ6 92GUCG 0 0JJ6L columiçtUGuç UJGCJJ9'1J12LU2 JJJJG

rLuq6LJ?4u L9'c!ou9'rG 0L p çJJG LeCoUi4Ou p?. bGLbJJGL2 cofmcL!ce oL$'çG JGx!piJi* h0Lm9']J?. }J!2 !2 LebL626uçGq p?. }JG 211hJJ C02l O LG9'JTUUJGIJc Jp6LJbJJGL?. GOJJU4L1G2 9'LG6 OU 4JJG qG2JL9'pTJTc?. (nb o JTmIJIJ GXCJ39'UG

LG249'G T36 J9'U 69'JUG2 0J 0111 L9U3GM0LjC ETL2c UqAq119'J b6bJ9'?.eq p? boJIc? cooLqm9'çIou 9'flJ0IJ cp beL!bpGL?. COIJUçLI62' 1319'?. 6 PGIBPIJL61JCK GL1262 ! 9' 2?.2GIU 0 jXGq 6XCJJ9'UG L9'G2 9'IJq 9'qqLG22 dIG E22JJG 0 dG LOJGIIJJqIIJ Oil jJG L62111d2 o 4JJG BLGJ.JOJI2 26Cd!011 11.6 11011. J1LIJ O JJG 9IJ9'J?.212 O CIIL-

b0IT cooLquou uq 6XCJUA3 r.9ç CI 262

Page 36: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

(IIma) nommo 9iithIrI9tx9 sa9113 lo 91113&1 erI3 icod nox3qmIJ8a beris3nim .i91r190 91L1 Lii aboik I oJ noqa9x b93&IiblooD at3 fnsi;psiV wis a3rI9frrrIiL91

noiin9qoo) 9113 lo iai s 1i18fflhq i ms3 9E1 e1IJ3fbx9 &113 lo iain A 313 9113 319113 )11OW9rfl1311 I&i331o911 3 irco nI .3i arri.3arca bn13 enfisb 3arLt

-iO0 91:13 313 31I3X9 91:13 o3 3aii'1 .19mn9 sm ith3 s rbiriw iii ow3 3s91 ii3rnro Lsijbivibrii miri&bsm 3n9msno1n9 9Vi3D9I9 LI aIDi3I 9m9r1D rioi3srith

iierl3 o3 rithior 'Iq bnB 3n9m991B erI3 no 99f191 o3 Bvi3n9DfIi 1113 9v13r1 Sw113

aiain 93131 91IBr1DX9 1113 1o aie9113oq11 9113 r1uori31A .anoi3Dmrl noi si L&jbivibni

3rx9Jia11oD L69i01 lo 9IJE2i 3 asaisi lofv&d9d 3nthvsb ll131Jbivibni mon f1mm93 9)Js1q 3aifl e113 iii ms3 sf13 lo 3usq 3d o3 3qe ei13riI;oD 3nBivsb sf13 bib r1w -

1113113 i13J 3id 3ij 9113 lo nOd1113eI 13 19b!1IoD .Di3aiI139lIIIJ 3ori i 3i

f13noi313n noii1JL13vsb b9ith19rI9 13 esiuJpe rioi3nibiooo sIirIN . siici'1 ru

91iri'I jis is3IA . 19 119113 "9v 03 b93qm93 9d m ai113m i1oq noi3i3uL13v9b 9113 sL63 m 3i lo 3rfii 9113 03 tairL mithdilirrpe 1fa1314 £3 ii asura

moil 19f1qrI9q 9113 lo 3ai 9113 wa bri13 9113 dioads 03 )fl9111JD sf0 3au[ lo .a391Js3 93131 9f11311DX9 bsDrrnoxm13 erI3 110 uii9nsi lo inemaa13nsdm9 slit

(sisI) 9113 4aT4 b93iJJibHIJ 03 atI9V9I 91011w a 't9f1q119 9113 Ii aa91911391I04

-)9fl9 9113 vjd13iDelqq13 v1ibom ot tn9iDflIuB 9d ion ffiw uiruroo 9110 'd noii13IJI13veb nimIras) t9*I13m 9III iBril 111 bo112 a ioI .1931193 9113 lo 91)613 lo ami3 9Vi3

11391 1931193 9113 10 noitai3elqqa 91d131E £ th)eqx9 (ioivar{ed 9viia1eqoo) Drrt9mrn'a -eb faijbivibni mio1im 1Lsm 9v13Bl3qooD r1uoir13 beveirba 9d oi s3a1 9w3rbx9 9110 'd f10i31311113v9b is1 a asjr1T .1911qne sf13 iii 691D1I911iJ 1113 lo arioisij1sv

minadD9m 93131 9r1srfDx9 91:13 tacIt aJnaqiDiilsq 39*Lsm 03 a16ni 11a91D 'j1inhcoD

a 03 bmioi a611 9Div9b noiianlbloo3 a s £ 911ri1 iii bsiai3aijlli ai aiairo £ lo issm 9113 lo IIoiis3eIqlsirIi bnoa A

Ls3rioiior1 1noiIan 11911W ) 9f1131 9113 111 bor1e sf13 1o noii.siLs91 £ 9)IaT

a '1itaic 03 r1hcon9 ia1 ion tud emI 61 313113 borla ie3iis3 £ 91J82i 1113 6i \i1J1p9 9viial9qooD S II .669136 9Idal9bi2nOD :19bm1 me3ae 9113 aiuq noi±sulavsb 9vi3)9II0D

ifieuisd iorma3 3i auiosd qqsr{rurr 6j 1931193 9113 61Iavs1q sq edi 1o 92n919b srli ni \Di1oq 'iaisnom 113fl0j6fl13X9 91011! 13 lo 63D9l19 1511193X9 9v1fieOq 9113 moñ

Iisirbivibni 9113 313113 9v19319q 69113111103 ie1fqi199 9111136 9113 tA .19liqi19q .rfh1 9113 rloii8uIav9b LBIS313ILIIIJ a mon 6fIS

(laalsvinIJ-rlori ai 3arIi) svi3sIsa tird beisniblooD 13 niJnems1qrni lo msldoiq silT 1n9V9 aifi9IIsd bna 23803 ati nitirdiiiaib lo '6W 011 6i 91911335113 ai noiiaIcIJ3vsb

lo Joi i29T r1oi3s19binoD 'monoo9 L&i3iloq t 2tnioq 92llrOD lo rioiteeiip iifToc .trjsmseis LsnoLIs3rnstni silt abswot ebzriis nin6dD ism 'DiIoq

9jTrnI0D 11.8 (3911W .*iowsmsil wo lo noian9tx9 sldiBaoq.8 thnoi3nsm elirfwr1ixow i ctIC

(snthvsi o) 9u16v9b siini,o lo t9 ls1nDxhEq ibiilw Lsi3n9bi ii I9Iiqrx9I 9ilt (31

nhJo3 (rsswt9d 9DnSlslIib (1Lsm) £ sDlrboItrn woVI .s3.8rihrnstsbni ai nuthdifwps riasM 13 Lii risdT .(1 < vijnijo lo asid uanoi3sfttji silt lo a3n&iim-is3sb sif 3 xii a

on bliiow s iini;o mithdi1iipe ml if bsqxs binow sw 1sbom u;o lo iol sd. nibnsxs .asid isnoifini isnoita ati 1o iisd siTtnno3 nu;L8vsb lo sxf lo h13q sd Ii1.8.a99n i 1i j9bom mo xii anoiIsxDi1qmi 1ioivjxrlsd isxfhxñ on asri qq13r1nn ni9d 1n9D exlT

.ton io einiboo vxsufqiisq sift issbeilw lo aeLbisei dasVI 1q o bsmias

Page 37: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

0111. uJoqGJ) JJ6 6JJ9MOL O 4JG 2A2ç6W tAJ6IJ 6LG 12 2.MJC}J 111 2L9'ç6JC 6JJ9?UOL O IJJG1A6IT W91U6IJJ2 uq L11J62 O }JG 1flUG (2 oirjq 6 JG C2G MIf GXO6UO112 IJJOIJGXC9J p6 A16th6 2b6CIiJçJAG 9JCJC EA6U thJ360 JJ6 iU2f9Jç9U60fl2 6dIlTJTpLillm !2 11IJ!dJIG tOLO 4G W6 OL 2211IJJb410U2 pOUç I1&ITL6 O JJ6 2Lç6iC I 6L101J p64.th661J 1€

f açcp L0IU OIJG 11J2ç9VUG0JTa 6d1111!pLlfiW uop (oL IA6IJ TU1UGIJJ2 9uq LIIJ2Cm.L6IJç 9Jq tI1IULG L66 g6UJ9IJq 2JJOCJ2 UI IJJ6 CGUc€L coizuiI.X

JJJT2 tIrnqw6uJ ! I4126J 0LtA0Lq-J0OJCJIf I LpJ& L6 AflpJ6 !IJtOLWO0 011qI2çLIpI1cIoIJJ !22n62 IJ cj q6iJ o coob6LI6 boJc162imbq o qwoq 2pocJ2 i' nmjL pou3 66L9J J2C9J AaçGm Lu9k J2O pGJb ojiJJ6 0 J6 6XCU6 L0IG2 12 G1JJJIIC6 p? 9X62 9Uq cjoç LGqJ rcG 112Xmw6çLic

JJ9AG 66I1 2Irq6q 66IJ21A6JX IAcpru o ob4umi CIILLGUcX tL6 10 211CJ1 LI116MOLJcjJc 2q6 bm6uç2 JJLOi1 4L9U26L2 (qncp 6 9A6 LflJG oiiç III 0111.

Bmc6L COL2G1 uq J626Uçi [I2]) 32bojic? GL2 cmo bLGc0IUUn A%--S buisçc 2GCOL2 (op2Gq S1JMI uqwu bopj 1oru qT2çuprTçrou2 o oiiçbii bL!c62 uq GXCJJJG LG2 EJJGIJ JJG

62iJX 20MU OL & IAGIJ qT2çLJpcI4Jou O p6 GXO6UOH 2OCJ(2 fGLG LGunçmuç cp b6 (rwbpci !u cç cp9'ç cp6 L69'puuJ6uc coç c r rnc6) ïç r1TUGL corr2Jq6Lciow G!A611 cp !mbG4.Gcc cLeqjpiji o bopc?. IJJ9'J(GL2 COW-

uq LflJG2 o JJG 9mG) pocijq pG GxbGCcsq !U cpe CJ2 0 UJOGJ2LG mfITbJG flJ2UU60fl2 GdmflpLIT pqçibje iU2ç1JçUGouT2 GdfflJJpLrn (L0L '"WLJ'.G2 uq pe boJ!c2. 1U9JC6L2 COOLqUc6 ou bLc!ccJJL cdrnflpLIIlm MGU ?GLGL11J62 0T: }J WOIJGILX (J,2p OL coob6LiAG) uq p? ttc? iii ncp

pX IJJG w9LJ6c2 A!6U ou nçnte couqircc o uourQ. boJ!c? ucJ1Iqu JGomq p? COIJ21qGLIJ q12çLiprrcou OJ 2JJOCJ2 O 911 GXO6IJOI12 yrnqrxuuc&jo bLeqGç6LmnGq IJOUJTU9J PJ Ec9T!0112 O IJJ6 J1c1ILG buce JGAGJ 916Or. nucooqueq obçimj auccpe2 peçeeu GXCrISUG LçG L6TIUG2 916 J1IJC1OIJ2pijiç2) o t bee: iJ JJLG2JJOJ !Sj1162 JOL cJJG 2OCJ qGçGLmJUJU pocp cooLqu9'ceqA9119'pJ62 HJ1GL uounuj br LGqIJGG 46 2çpiJc (uq A-A42G 26C40L 6XbGCçç1OIJ2 916 r.eeqsq 1U JJG JGAGJ O bLGq6çGLIJJTUGq rJormuJ

bie LOJ6 L6L2 cJJGIL CçJAG LOJ& !U OFJL L91IJ6/OLJC br.i-uatA6L dcrnçioi 12 coubjex GCfJ2G IJJ91JCG2 poçj 911 Cc!AG 9uq

12 JJG LOf 6 O W91JC642 !U 9' CLI2!2 0 9'U GXCJJ&UG L9'46 2?'2ç6LU JJJGpom cpe bornç o /GM O, cpe b6LIbpGL). 9' 9' COJJ6ClAGM6J9'LG mwou poçp &ç je/ej o iJqiAqrr9'J bGLthP6L? co111JçL7 uq6L2 o W9'LJG bLe2IuG2 cpe? oiijq UOU66J622 pG C0IJ22cGU (cor.r2cL9'u6q)cpe2e qeA9'JJT9'oIJ2 m jooj pJcG s q2oLqGLJ? L62boU26 pA qoureçc bojicA w-

rmbjeiueuç rnJcooLqu9'ceq q6A9'JuT9'fTouw EAGU ru eAe o rJ2A2çGW !2 !U 2ITCJJ 9' c9'G ! cocrjq pG COTJGCIJAGJA L9'çIOIJ9'J LGAGL MPUJ9'XUJjSG çJJG 0 j bojcA W9'JCGL2 LG9'J6 IJJ9'C çJJGIIJ0IJG1LA 29'IJCG 1U çJJG 2X2çGIfl IJJOLG exb9'u2lou9'LA (rjpocip 1J04 PA GUOiT1 oIJJGçLIC cooLqu9'ciorJ c9'ImOç: 201116 2H26 0 cOrnJ4L!G2 oirjq qGA9'J1JG UJ9]TIJ çJJG9'Aorqeq III 9' ethnjipLrur edrnjrpLrirru MorrJq 9'ccoIubfrfJ 1JJ9'c 2Am-

( lJJ6 jO22 111 M69'LG GLOW COIJ2cL9'lIJGq coobGL9'Ae PGJJ9'A!OL !2 b9'LlJA9'CL022 U9'çIOIJW J0L LG9'J9'OU2 O JJG 2jJOCj iiuqei COu2!qeL9'lOu (!IJ cJJG I9ue

Page 38: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

O COuILG G cowpIJ6q w nX IJIIWGL o q6.6IJ4 M?(çThcJJ?L qom6rc CL6qiç 6xbJxmiOu) jj626 cjn q!"c uoiou o abGcuJcu6 4qc C9V2BCIIJcLe6 CJ OCCIfLLGUCS ijjo COI1L6 qGbGuq ou L6 o

o Tuc6LuOu9J boLtoJ!o jp L6bLG6u42 iLq jquq Op? uicpOLicG2 cp6 9u cib9pou ot TGL bLoppjçA o r cuj RTJJ 9J2 pc occqWOIJG? qGW9lIq pflJCcJOU (uo moqjjeq J56L6) uq q-poc (riig JJGLGOL6 UOIJ-L6C) pGpAJoLOAGLIXW6IJ C9IJ 6 AGM6 2 €couq jiuq o bGcrrJrcAc M!fl' U !U6LG-GIJ2iA€

OcJJGL

2iG o JJG GO9JJçJOIJ 20 cji cOIJ2iq6LçJOtJ2 9LG H0 iuqebGuqGu O GTCJJCOIIL2& IJJ6 jpooq 0 J1LTLG CO0b6LIA6 P6JJA!OL W IJO pG ruqsbGIJqeLrc o6U62 L0IIJ JL6G O9ç 0 IJG COLG -c-n JJG OuJ2JqGL2 CIrLLGIJC!G2 OTAP HOC?!OU 4JJG 2pTJTA OJ pTJ9c6LJ GXCJJIJ6 LG2 ID jJG COLG CJ6LJ2b6LTbPGL COirUcLIG2 JjJLOfIjJ JJG qT2cfr2eioIJ OJpe moie bJn2IpJe O1 COIIL2& !T. JJ6L6 201.116 t- p6c6LOGIJ6!c WOU 4P2?2cemcICJJ? excjirqe oJJ6L2 beLibp6L?. COITTUçLI62 HCJJ COfl0U UJJI0LUJ fIUTJ&6LJ pceq 6XCJJIJ6 L6 ie --s cpe C6UcGL (cje COLe) MprcpG!4p6L 10!u &u 6UJL6 C61161. (bLe2JnupJ?. ijoç iuçpociç p6 Jf6L2 beLmT2iou) 01.LGbTcG cjie ojq teeiueuj E01. exwb1& C0L6 o GEA E6LibpeL? COHIJçLI62 rr?IJJ6L2 IJJ9X 0LW C09JT4I01J2 cpç ! 11GM 9L66W6IJ2 UIOIJ 2fJ2G2 0 JJG bJGL2beLcGiAGq cjrnue iu uurie o cpe me 2 9' LG2JIJ4 o CL!2!2 boj!cA6XC&UG L9'G 2?.2GW m&? pe iuL!U2c9'IJ?. WOLG oL L9'IJG qebGuqu ouU9'ITL6 0 0U0TIJ &UJ6 gmou bojicX 1JJ9'J(GL2 JJJGLG0LG bo2-cL!2!2 jpceqJ6A6J o tA9'G2 uq qoiieçc ruçeLe2ç L9'62 A9'L2. rçp 1U9'LfG2 bGLcGbçrou o jJeb&.so pon cpe pjcepooq o ITçJILG coobeL9'çrAc p6JJ9'AIOL nr bojic mus jjrecou2qeL9'Jou2 E!L2c JIJ JJ6 JJJ 0 CLi2i2 bLIA&çG 9'GU2 Lu9'? tuoqI cJJG!L

jce oue woqejjcq ru our. bber. cpe 9U2IAGL cp d1Is!ou qebeuq2 OIlbojic cooLqIJ&çu LU6CJJ9'UT2IIT p 24çI0U&L GUAIL0IJUIGIJ

2?açGIn o jxeq GXCJJ9'U6 L&cG2 2111./JAG 9' CL1212 cpc brr2 iuo dne2c!olrcj.re !UcGLU9'c!0u9'T teemeuç ou boj!cA cooLq!u9'cowIJ0çTJTU pLT 9' JU9'IJCJ9'J GXBLG22IOU 0 qJ9'ç jeq pe pLGJUU nb o,

9' b2e L6JGCçI0IJ o bojic? III&JC6L2) cpoicG2 uq s' ciir.r.euc? CL!2!2 orijq peJJDq9'W6IJ9' J JJJ2 2GIJ26 P6IJ&A!OL 0 jU9'IJCJ9'J W9'LJG2 UJ9'2 G 26611

9'IJq pGIJ62 o q6Guqiu be 1A6IJ 4JJ6 CIILLGIJç LG9'JT9'çJ0u 0 {JJ6 20CJ( ofJIG 0IJ4C0G O L9'4J0IJ9'J qGci2ToIJ U1JC1IJ p? qowG2çJc 9'JI4JJOLIIG2 22622 C022

011 pe 0JIGL puq ouce Gxb6cçJou2 9'LG OLIIJGq GXCJJ9'IJG L9'jG bojiciG2 &LG

Page 39: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

IUA60L OCOP6L II-T2{r] VIHJT4U K T3Fi5F C1aL6UG fIG JIJ2JG 4OL) I14!0U9J

cP flJ!c&f (IJOUJ ECOUOUJTC 'onLiwj j prA bb[j] 2OU b"T If [I2I C!UIU rnq jO2Ju EE VT Leqpipc?: cP O

IAIO116 cq!c uq J9IIfC!I7 rr nr-[] umm j [j} j,oqj O tJ91JC6-O-J?dJJ6Uç CLI262 aOULIJ9T o

c61132 '1O1TLIJJ O Iu6Lil9c!oI EC0U01II!C2 5O JT2[ii] CLIII! A [TI1 II?IU IJq 261JiU yççCJC OU EXCPJG jg•c ?-

CEbB D!2Cn22!OU },b6L I.40 TO22 4OAGIJJGL[Jo] CWI' uq {iaa] coucoa 2becssJJA6

6XC}J9'LTG L&46 LGJUJ62 hATE 24L b6L2 bb jo-[] jooq B'1D 'qGGb uq oc6J?u HOLUG [rI EA0IuT!011 O

2W6 rrn6n ExarbJ62 .OJ1LIJ9J Oj ECOUOmC2 J J-J[] jjooq Jfh 9q bGGL VF C9P6L [Jt] C0IIb2!U EXC!JIJG grçG jçGiuJG2:

bb€L2 OU ECOUOmIC ycIAIç? i bb 2J-T3U[] E!P66U B iq c MThJ0 [j] JjJG mJ24'pJG EVF2 BLOONfl2

222fO bOIJC?LWJ6L2 dfI9rL.c6LIA 1011L1191 Oj ECOUOmIC2 JO0 VfJ1I2I bb

[€] DL9GU y uq JfJf2OU IIf [j] L6qp!flc o boW! AGL2ITI2 LGqpJ!c?

JfG Jç6!LUG fIG ECOUOWIC '1OnLIWJ J0 3t12[2] DG KOCI 91J CLIII! [J0] E!2C9J b0JTC! uq cJJG CJ0!C6 O EXCPU

qGb6uqGLT ECOUO VUJJ bLG22 JJ[I C"°"4 V'I 'q DM GIJq6L2OIJ [JI] jOIJG49LA bOJ!C?. !" i'-

83 1-2TT2cLG!C 211P2cIcfI4G2 ruq C0mbJ6m6U2 JOIILIJ9J O J,OjçCJ ECOUO

[] B'I° '1 y CGUTObJO2 Jq J }GWb6LGL [r82] v\pTIc!wLT(Gc Qj!oboJ:

J4flLIJ JçTç6 oqej 'O11LI39J O OJ4CJ ECOUOIII J 2IO[} BLLO Jf1 iq D W Cq' [r] v b02!c!AG JjJ6OL? O I/\I0UGcL bOJ!C?

Ei1L0bGU flU!0U lABElS MOLICTLT bb6L 4O f22O[TI VT!U f uq p QUIT! [J21 O'- JJ6 E62!p!J!T O OL J/\JfrJc-2b6Gq

HG.GL6UCG2

Page 40: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

38

Oj I11lGLU9OU9J ECOUOLU!C2 AOl JJJ 4OLJJ-}jOJJUq CJT I2 OLJJCOUJTU91Jq }oflc? COoLq!U!ou iii omu uq j< icoo (Gq HqpooJ

[511 bGL22OU J 0 J'PI1!"! [188Y Iuc6ucAG2: I!4T!0U2

MJcp &ij QbJIJJJ2IIJ bOJTC? I/\JJC6L flrnA6Lrc?L O A°J IUTUJ6O 'HU6[sol Oi" } C1TC!U IJq ]91J ffçJ3GLJ9Jq [180fPP V CffLLGUCX CL!2 j/\oqGJ

C1JLLGUC2 CM2!2 J/\JJWG0 J,AI&LGJJ OL4JJGOLU1IJ IIJ JJG ECOUOIIJ!C O1TLIJJ[10] oIcua E CifICTU uq yju IIJJ6LJIJq [J] jojic? A16HLG2 jioiq

JCLOGCOUOIJJIC2 CJ 1J!UGOCJJLTG 4G 9'IJq cJJG C11LL6U CCOJ1U4 U OflIJjOIJ2 Ot IU!0IJ

[JI oP.Iq vr q M [io] 2c!cT-bL!cG O6J2 o QJJ4bflç ?JJG EX-

bGL IThID

[1 opcq I/SI [108'f] LP6 F0!C ° C1JLL6UC CLT26 IA.BEIS MPJ!" b

T4BEB MoIcru bb6L 3Q30[i1 opciq I/SI [ioo1 DG2cP!J!!U ETL6Cc2 oEXCPUG jsi EcbG CJIT262,

VI1JGLICU ECOUOC }ç6AJGR[jI pejq j/U [jQ] JçJOUJ q BJ1JcG o hGU2 CL!2G2

Page 41: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

0,

C

C) r C) E

CD

C

.0

to

0 C,

U\J

Rtl

5T5

no6L

)6V

eb

Isub

ibru

ee

i rio

deul

svsb

18

r1qr

1e

a.c

$r.c

oo

. D

IO

.D

St

.v

uai

c uo

. oo

- S

00-

vo-

C.,

0)

C)

.0

.0

Page 42: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

I I I I

I 1 I I

sii

nodI

vb

Iubi

vibn

i J

I —

_

I

I

I I

I I

I

I C

) C

C

C E

C

C 0 0 7c

I I I I I I

I I I I I I I

Page 43: i £ 3iln3bom - Willem Buiterwillembuiter.com/center-periphery.pdf · 2020. 1. 8. · isa99n rienntaujbs .aaoD eW eveiled tsn1 sdt 'ti1idiaoqmi lo nbLBm s1dsrn iisniinioo fn9ffr'8q-ebi

r)

C) C 1,

C) r -D

C

) E

C) C -D

CD

0 C)

f.)

I,1\J

RtA

no

iusv

sb

lsub

Mbr

lI V

1 rr

0) r w

I —

I I I I I I

I I I I I