B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

41
Concept House Ontwikkeing van een duurzaam huis in een sociaal duurzame context 01-11-2022 Wim Poelman, Concept House 1

Transcript of B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

Page 1: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 1

Concept House

Ontwikkeing van een duurzaam huis in een sociaal duurzame context

Page 2: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 2

Concept House

• Initiatief: gepensioneerde ondernemer in de bouwsector die gelooft in volledig geïndustrialiseerde woningen

• Uitdaging opgepakt door: Prof. Mick Eekhout, Chair of Product Development TU Delft

• Projectleider beginfase: Dr. Wim Poelman• Project leader realisatiefase: Dr. Arjan van Timmeren

Page 3: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 3

Waarom een Concept House van uit de TU Delft?

• Onafhankelijk van practische sociale beperkingen • Onafhankelijk van economische beperkingen • Gelegenheid om zelf te bepalen wat er gebeurt• Gelegenheid om resultaten te onderzoeken• Gelegenheid voor derden om te zien en te leren• Gelegenheid om reproduceerbaar onderzoek te doen• Gelegenheid om de industrie te stimuleren

Page 4: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 4

Voorwaarden:

• Conceptuele ideeën• Visie op de toekomst• Financiële ruimte• Geschikte partners• Materialen en componenten• Mankracht• Locatie

Page 5: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 5

Partners

• Voor elk betrokken materiaal/component zijn partners vereist

• Het aantal partners groeide voortdurend• Sociale complexiteit groeide voortdurend• Aantal stakeholder = aantal belangen

Page 6: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 6

Initiële componenten

Page 7: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 7

Stakeholders and interests

• Onderwijsinstituten: TU Delft – kennis– onderzoek

• Building companies: 10 partners– kennis, – nieuwe opdrachten– uitstraling

• Suppliers: 30 industries– verkoop

• Local governments: Rotterdam– prestige

Page 8: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 8

Conceptuele ideeën

• Overvloed aan ideeën• Selectie criteria• Technische haalbaarheid• Sociale haalbaarheid• Vooroordelen (hout?)• Impact van de innovatie• Niet te veel in een keer willen

Page 9: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House

Sustainability as a new item

9

Sustainable scheme single house, Arjan van Timmeren

Page 10: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 10

Three goals

Industrieel Gestapelde bouwDuurzaam

Plug & Play ApartementenEnergie voorziening

Page 11: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 11

Methaphors

Page 12: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 12

Early ideas

High density apartments

Page 13: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 13

Designs Concept House Urban Villa

Page 14: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 14

Model Concept House Urban Villa

Page 15: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 15

Materials & Components

• Compromis tussen:– Wat kan gesponsord worden– Wat is in overeenstemming met de doelstellingen

Page 16: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 16

Human Resources

Reguliere staf:- Twee onderzoekers aan de TU in Delft (Industrial

Design Engineering and Architecture)Flexible staf (gesponsorde uren):- Een groot aantal mensen vanuit:

- Hogeschool Rotterdam- Albeda College- Vanuit toeleverende bedrijven

Page 17: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 17

Location in Rotterdam Harbour area

Page 18: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 18

De realisatie van start30 Juni 2011

Mick Eekhout (TU Delft) and Bert Hooijer (Rotterdam)

Page 19: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 19

Product Development OrganogramMick Eekhout

Page 20: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 20

Financieel ‘kaartenhuis’

Page 21: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 21

Construction/Structures study

Page 22: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 22

Creative studies for prototype

Page 23: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 23

Development of prototype

2009 model 2011 prototype2010 details

Page 24: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 24

Presentatie van concepten

Teneinde interesse te wekken

2009

2010

Page 25: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 25

Applications on location

Voorstel in Delft / Rotterdam

Page 26: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 26

Finally real location in Rotterdam

In urban renewal neighbourhood

Page 27: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 27

Gebruikte materialen

• Hout (7,5 meter overspanning)• Houtvezelplaat• Cellulose isolatie• Keramiek• Aluminium• Gips• Kit (was niet de bedoeling)• Staal (voor demonstratieopstelling)

Page 28: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 28

Composition of construction

Page 29: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 29

Detail roof/wall/floor

Page 30: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 30

Energy & climate section

Page 31: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 31

The assembly adventure

Prefabrication: installation in 5 days watertight

Page 32: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 32

People present on location during assembly

Page 33: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 33

Prototype impression

As built situation 2012

Page 34: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 34

Technical evaluation Transition traditional to IDF mindset

• Partner Unica used to measure bathrooms. Not necessary anymore.

• Partner MdR was confronted with another steel building sequence.

• Partner VDM had calculated 1500 KG for the bathroom. This turned out to be 4000 KG, leading to many unexpected adaptations.

• The Solarlux façade was not adapted for housing. • The FAAY electrical wall channels were not tuned with the

timber building structure of VDM.

1

Page 35: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 35

• Insufficient attention for flexibility, resulting in problems in electrical installation.

• Flexibility lacked between floors and walls by partner Unica. • The electricity channels in the floor not properly produced. • The drawings of FAAY came too late.• FAAY refused flexible wiring in the ceiling. • Electric wiring in the façade by VDM became unattainable by

the outside ceramic cladding.• Holes for toilets were not realised in the factory but on the

spot.

Technical evaluation 2

Page 36: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 36

• The screws for mounting inner walls to floor were too long.• Integration partner Niko (Home control) and Itho

(Autotemp) turned out to be impossible, because of intellectual property.

• A decentralised ventilation system of Renson per room, was taken at the last moment

• The architecture of the installation space had to be changed dramatically at the last moment and improvised.

• Partner Unica was too late with detailing and drawing result inefficient use of space.

Technical evaluation 3

Page 37: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 37

• Rainwater drainage was forgotten.• Partner Icopal ordered insufficient materials. Improvisation

is necessary. • Partner VDM changes drawings, made by TU Delft. Partner

Justimax had to draw the cladding a second time.• The holes in the ceramic tiles of partner Mosa were

wrongly drilled. 120 m2 has to be redone. • Obsolete tiles could be returned to Mosa for recycling. But

the tiles went to a common waste processor. • Consoles for the solar protection system of partner Renson

came too late. Causing extra hiring of aerial platform.

Technical evaluation 4

Page 38: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 38

• The edge of the roof is not realized according to drawings, resulting in improvisation.

• Inaccurate connection between the inner walls on the structure of VDM were done by forbidden PUR.

• The ceiling was made seamless although industrial seams were acceptable.

• Materials as the floor made installation dangerous and troublesome.

Technical evaluation 5

Page 39: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 39

Conclusions

• A step into sustainable building practice • For cooperation between companies and universities is a

challenge.• It is difficult to involve companies in futuristic developments. • The strategy to build a complete house turned out to be

effective. All parties participated with a great motivation. • The project disturbs the primary process of the companies.• Parties are experienced better results. • The change of project leaders at TU Delft gave instability. • Necessary permission next steps of finance determined

further possibilities.

1

Page 40: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 40

Conclusions

• Difficult to plan a project in changing. • Experimenting and building are no friends. • Difficult to mobilize knowledge at the university and to link it

to practical experience of companies. • The culture at the university did not contributed to the

project. However the guts and perseverance happen to be present in the chair holder Mick Eekhout.

• Politics form an important success factor. Not only the product, but also the context is important.

• Concept House Village might be a useful platform just as Booosting and Barba House.

2

Page 41: B&i2013 donderdag 12.00_zaal_d_concepthouse

13-04-2023 Wim Poelman, Concept House 41

Concept House Urban Villa

Next experimental phase to take 2-3 years in a recession period in the building industry.