2017 c10 9 F - Ming Yi's Personal Website · 2020. 6. 24. · 2003⁄ o[ (u¥›E„˘†L˘ ) ......

<�6Ä��U�EµÄu]�)EUpÖ�À�

o[

u¥�E�Æ²LÆ�

2017c 10� 9F

ïÄÄÅ

ïÄÄÅ

�8.�-�¿�µ

�IJÑ±/�Uó�!�U)�Ú�UÔ60�Ø%�ó

�4.0ÔÑ

{IKJÑ±EâUå�Ø%�2ó�zÔÑ

/¥I�E20250ÔÑ

2002c§ó�zÚ&EzKÜ��´

| ó��Uz�'�))�.O�Å

�Åu20V70c��)§1980c¥Ió�è�Òm©Ú?¿òÙ

^uó��!DÚ��UE±9�úgÄz�õ��¡

o[ (u¥�E�Æ²LÆ�) <�6Ä��U�EµÄu]�)EUpÖ�À� 2017c 10� 9F 2 / 32

ïÄÄÅ

�Å�`³

Jpè�)��Ç!U?�¬�þ

±ÅKUE�~§3A^�Å��XÚ�§ó��Çké�J,§

Ø=UØmäó�§ ��°Ý�d<óö��d70%Jp

�98% ±þ£Ût�§1986¤

¥Ió��ÅA^yG

®²ÊHA^

±2004c�~§��k80%±þ��¥.ó�è��C��

Å§¿�25%�m�è�C�10�9±þ��Å

è��N��UzY²¿Øp

16.34%�è��C��Å§30%�è�=C�1-2��Å


ïÄÄÅ

ó��ÅA^Y²$��Ï

/<�ù|0º��þídNÄå§EU¤�p§½|Ø(½

è�"yÄå

NÄå�EUY²�$

�â/ÊÊ0w«§¥I<��²þ��c�=�7.85c§=¦�

2010c/8Ê0�²þÉ��c��=k8.81c§��Ð¥É��

§Ý

Figure 1: xN��


ïÄÄÅ

ó��ÅA^��U

<å]�Y²Jp

¥I�p�.�)<êÅcO\§2016c®²O\�765�§ýO

�2030c�k27%�NÄåäk�ÆÆ{§ù®�C�!{�u�I

[Y²

<�6Äé<å]��K�

2000c§6Ä<�5��1.21·§�2015c6Ä<�®²��

2.47·§�8�<¥Òk��´6Ä<�

±1Êg<�Ê��~,ù��Ï6Ä<��²þÉ��c��10.1

c§�puÓÏ²þ7.85c�²þY²§Ù¥�;9±þÆ{Ó'�

�15.5%§Ø=�pu��¬�4.8%�'~§�pu¢�/NÄ

å9.9%�Y²

¢5<�¥5gÙ¦¢�NÄ<�²þÉ��c��11.9 c§

5gà~�²þ�9.33c§þpu¢�/�<��9.05c£Ç�É§

2003¤


ïÄÄÅ

�©�Ü6��z

�©|^<�Ê�±9è��*êâ�[�<�6Äéè��

ÅÚ?�K�§¿��<�6Ä��9ÙK��VÉ�

5§3dÄ:þl]�-EUpÖ��Ý?�Ú)º�^Å�

�©��z

|^�¢��*êâïÄ<�6Äéó��Uz?§�K�§W

ÖISyk�ïÄ�x

�©�(ØL²/<�ù|0��¿Ø�ù§�5��±ÏL

<å]�È\±9ó��UzY²�J,-�/<�ù|0��

K¡K�

�©¿3J2yk�<��üAT�\À<��þJ,§ó��

=.,?�ATX<â�¸�ï�


©znã

©znã

£¬�K�))NÄåEU(�À�

$EUNÄå

�þ�$EU£¬6\§éw,�/�NÄå§AO´�/$EUN

Äå¬É�ÀÂ£Card, 2001; Peri and Sparber, 2007¤

£¬ÀÂ6\/�NÄå½|§AO´$EUNÄå�6\��E

�è�Jø�þídNÄå§l ¬ò��/è�gÄz)��?

§£Lewis, 2011¤

Ù¦©z£Altonji and Card, 1991; Peri and Sparber, 2007; Ottaviano

and Peri, 2008; Blau and Kahn, 2012¤


©znã

pEUNÄå))'uH-1B\y

Doran et al. (2014) uyH-1B\y�ü¿vkéè�ïu�)wÍK

�

ÏLH-1B\y?\�£¬��U uSTEM1�§�STEM1�¥£

¬��/Ø¬�m�Â\�å��£Hanson and Slaughter, 2016¤


©znã

NÄåEU(��Eâ?Ú

õêïÄ@�Eâ?Ú´EU �.�£Goldin and Katz,

1998;Acemoglu and Zilibotti, 2001¤±>MA^��\:

õêïÄþuy>M�pEUNÄåpÖ§UJpNÄ)�Ç§�

5wÍ�ó]Äd£DiNardo and Pischke, 1997; Feenstra and Hanson,

1999;Caselli and Coleman, 2001; Dunne et al., 2004¤


©znã

NÄåEU(��Eâ?Ú

ó�gÄz�NÄå

O�Eâ3ó�)�¥�A^ÏL~�ïá!$1ÚiÒ�mé�§

ÝþJp)��Ç§Ó��JpéÅìö�EU��¦£Bartel et

al., 2007¤

{ü)�?ÖVSE,�!�~5?Ö£Autor et al., 2003; Acemoglu

and Restrepo, 2016¤

Acemoglu and Restrepo (2017)$^{I1�±9NÄåêâlnØÚ

¢y�Ýu�ó�Åì<A^é�/Ò�Úó]�K�§uyÅì

<(¢éó]ÚÒ��)K¡K�§Ù¥7+ó<¤É�ÀÂ��


©znã

'u¥I�ïÄ

Imbert et al.(2017)uyà~£¬¬ü$¢½ó]Y²§O\è��

Q§Jpó�O\�£ISà�¬d�Úíÿ^�¤

ISéuù�¯K�ïÄ�´îØv§õ�½5ïÄ£od§

2012¤

±��Ú�ïû£2007¤|^wÅ½��mS�êâ¢y�<

�6ÄK�<å]�Y²? �^u��(�,?�äNÅ�

Ù¦©z��ÚÚ�¯£2010¤!pÅ�£2012¤�


©znã

�©éyk©z��z

lþã©zÎn¥�±wÑ§yk©z�o==ïÄ£¬éNÄ½

|�K�§�o��ïÄ�ÅA^�NÄåEU(��m��p'

X§�k©zònö(Üå5�§=kLewis(2011) �[�£

¬Jp$EUNÄåø�? ò�gÄz?§ù�Å�§±��

Ú�ïû£2007¤�3<�6Ä³��,?þ?1&¢§�ù

ïÄ3êâÚ�{þÑ�3�"�"


ïÄb`

ïÄb`

ü�¯¢

�âyk©z��§ó��ÅoNþ�pEUNÄåpÖ§�$E

UNÄå/¤O�"

¥I6Ä<��N��§Ý�,�$§�´%pu²þY²§$

�pu¢<��É��Y²"

b`µ<�6Ä¬éè��ÅA^Y²�)��K�§íÄó��

Uz,??§"


�{�êâ

�{�êâ

<�6ÄA�))Äu/ÊÊ0êâ�©Û

6Ä<�5

6Ä<��

6Ä<��<å]��¤


�{�êâ <�6Ä

Figure 2: 6Ä<�5 ©Ùo[ (u¥�E�Æ²LÆ�) <�6Ä��U�EµÄu]�)EUpÖ�À� 2017c 10� 9F 15 / 32

�{�êâ <�6Ä

Table 1: 6Ä<��6Ä<��£cn¤

�° Ó'£%¤ �° Ó'£%¤ �° Ó'£%¤

�I 2À 34.2 úô 8.46 þ° 6.55

�® à� 14.9 ô� 10.13 2À 7.84

U9 à� 22.8 �® 19.98 ìÀ 5.99

à� �® 41.58 U9 12.51 S�� 5.61

ìÜ �® 17.62 à� 11.64 S�� 10.34

S�� w 18.88 à� 14.22 �® 13.06

�w �® 13.71 3� 10.95 ìÀ 10.29

3� �w 24.72 ìÀ 17.75 ç9ô 14.61

ç9ô �w 24.19 ìÀ 20.12 à� 11.31

þ° ô� 32.41 S 18.06 úô 14.43

ô� þ° 37.01 2À 8.8 úô 8.43

úô þ° 19.92 ô� 12.65 2À 9.27

S ô� 25.11 þ° 22.91 úô 18.71

4ï 2À 30.37 þ° 10.44 úô 9.09

ôÜ 2À 44.67 úô 22.57 4ï 15.48

ìÀ �® 15.98 2À 8.97 U9 8.5

àH 2À 34.16 #õ 10.42 �® 9.86

�� 2À 52.24 úô 8.73 4ï 4.4

�H 2À 76.43 úô 4.55 2Ü 2.46

2À �H 10.84 ôÜ 10.01 2Ü 9.02

2Ü 2À 87.32 °H 1.72 úô 1.71

°H 2À 56.4 �H 4.77 �� 4.56

� 2À 35.69 oA 12.36 úô 8.88

oA 2À 41.84 úô 8.54 #õ 6.67

B² 2À 35.52 úô 17.68 �H 10.65

�H oA 16.98 2À 12 ô� 11.87

Üõ oA 32.45 ñÜ 9.35 � 7.56

ñÜ 2À 26.57 #õ 8.3 �® 6.19

[� #õ 38.47 ñÜ 9.09 wg 7.16

�° [� 22.85 #õ 11.45 ñÜ 7.54

wg #õ 19.28 [� 12.11 ñÜ 11.77

#õ oA 13.21 þ° 9.96 ô� 9.39


�{�êâ <�6Ä

Table 2: 6Ä<�<å]��¤

�S6Ä<� �6Ä<�

Ð¥9±e p¥ �Æ;�9±þ Ð¥9±e p¥ �Æ;�9±þ

1 2À 2À ô� 2À 2À �®

2 oA ìÀ 2À úô �® 2À

3 ìÀ ô� ìÀ þ° þ° þ°

4 ô� à� �w ô� úô ñÜ

5 úô oA àH 4ï ô� ô�

6 àH àH þ° �® ìÀ ��

7 �w �� #õ �� oA

8 �� úô oA ìÀ 4ï �w

9 4ï þ° à� �H oA �

10 �H �H �H à� à� ìÀ

ÀÜÓ'£%¤ 14.03 20.04 20.89 58.36 62.43 42.27

¥ÜÜÓ'£%¤ 31.98 24.91 27.75 5.38 7.78 24.58

Ó'£%¤ 46.02 44.94 48.65 63.74 70.21 66.85


�{�êâ ¢y�.

¢y�.

lnComputerij =

lnComouter∗ij lnComouter∗ij > 0

0 lnComouter∗ij ≤ 0

Ù¥§

lnComouter∗ij =α+βlnimmigrantj +γX +eij


�{�êâ êâ£ã

êâ£ã

êâ5

2004c¥Ió�è�êâ¥

íØ�È�!�ó<ê!o]�Ú�½]�"��P¹!íØo]

�!�½]�!�½]�À�Ú�ó<ê�K�P¹!íØ�ó<ê

�u30!�È��u500 ��Ú�½]��u100��P¹��"

éCþ3þe1%�Y²þ?1 �?n"

2000c1Êg<�Ê�©{êâ±95¥I{½�¬²LÚOc�6


�{�êâ êâ£ã

Table 3: Ì�Cþ£ã5ÚO

��þ þ� IO� ��

è�£2004c¤

�Åþ 217100 1.697 1.265 0 5.537

m\Ç 217100 0.593 0.314 0 15.73

]7�Ý 217100 225.85 427.407 1.158 26481.03

<å]�Ý\ 217100 0.01 0.293 0 14.912

y76þ 189406 6.895 1.688 0 11.483

è�5� 217100 9.72 1.372 7.173 13.887

]�6Ä5 217100 0.039 0.326 -15.36 0.998

{£2000c¤

o6Ä<� 2762 11.344 1.205 5.293 14.739

{S 2762 10.337 0.864 2.773 13.152

�S{ 2762 9.667 1.435 3.807 13.396

� 2762 9.876 1.87 3.219 14.423

<þGDP 2211 9.204 0.822 6.513 11.443

��Y² 2762 2.076 0.128 -0.01 2.472

��Ó' 2762 33.664 19.775 0.1 81.18

n�Ó' 2762 25.766 14.644 2.23 96.7

�à' 2762 30.519 22.626 2.36 98.91


¢y(J ÄO£8

Table 4: ÄO£8

Tobit IV-Tobit

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

6Ä<� 0.305*** 0.076*** 0.680***

-0.003 -0.005 -0.082

{S 0.058*** -0.027*** 0.230**

-0.004 -0.005 -0.097

�S{ 0.174*** 0.061*** 0.391***

-0.004 -0.005 -0.097

� 0.063*** 0.029*** 0.387***

-0.003 -0.005 -0.056

è�A� N N Y Y Y Y

/«A� N N Y Y Y Y

1�J[ N N Y Y Y Y

�°J[ N N Y Y Y Y

pseudo

R2

0.02 0.021 0.214 0.214 ) )

Wald ) ) ) ) 60.35*** 63.07***

AR ) ) ) ) 78.98*** 78.77***

chi2 ) ) ) ) 129731.892 112950.376

��þ 217100 217100 141344 141344 141320 141320


¢y(J ÄO£8(J

Table 5: ©/«£8

ÀÜ/« ¥Ü/« ÜÜ/«

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

6Ä<� 0.062*** 0.079*** 0.023*

(-0.006) (-0.019) (-0.013)

{S -0.037*** -0.008 -0.039**

(-0.007) (-0.019) (-0.016)

�S{ 0.051*** 0.111*** 0.038**

(-0.007) (-0.017) (-0.017)

� 0.026*** -0.003 0.038**

(-0.007) (-0.016) (-0.015)

è�A� Y Y Y Y Y Y

/«A� Y Y Y Y Y Y

1�J[ Y Y Y Y Y Y

�°J[ Y Y Y Y Y Y

pseudo

R2

0.204 0.204 0.228 0.229 0.235 0.235

��þ 97456 97456 43888 43864 16052 16052


¢y(J ÄO£8(J

Table 6: ©¤k�

Ikè� 8Nè� ]è� ¬Eè�

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8)

6Ä<� 0.064*** 0.02 0.076*** 0.079***

(-0.023) (-0.015) (-0.013) (-0.006)

{S -0.047* 0.001 -0.016 -0.008

(-0.025) (-0.017) (-0.014) (-0.006)

�S{ 0.115*** 0.060*** 0.063*** 0.039***

(-0.024) (-0.016) (-0.015) (-0.006)

� 0.011 -0.024 0.025* 0.036***

(-0.024) (-0.015) (-0.015) (-0.006)

è�A� Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y

/«A� Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y

1�J[ Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y

�°J[ Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y

pseudo

R2

0.253 0.254 0.17 0.17 0.186 0.186 0.204 0.204

��þ 8030 8030 14419 14419 24683 24683 94212 94212


�^Å� EU�¤

Table 7: EU�¤

$EU $EU ¥�EU ¥�EU pEU pEU

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

6Ä<� -0.005 -0.001 0.005***

(-0.003) (-0.003) (-0.002)

{S -0.006 0.007** -0.001

(-0.004) (-0.003) (-0.002)

�S{ -0.009** 0.002 0.007***

(-0.004) (-0.003) (-0.002)

� 0.013*** -0.012*** -0.001

(-0.004) (-0.003) (-0.002)

��Y² -0.076** -0.074** 0.042* 0.043* 0.034** 0.032**

(-0.031) (-0.032) (-0.025) (-0.025) -0.015 (-0.015)

��Ó' 0.188*** 0.190*** -0.139*** -0.113*** -0.050*** -0.077***

(-0.021) (-0.024) (-0.016) (-0.018) -0.009 (-0.01)

n�Ó' -0.032 -0.042 -0.054** -0.027 0.085*** 0.069***

(-0.037) (-0.037) (-0.027) (-0.028) -0.018 (-0.018)

�à<� -0.002*** -0.001*** 0.001*** 0.001*** 0.000*** 0.000***

(0.000) (0.000) (0.000) (0.000) (0.000) (0.000)

«{ Y Y Y Y Y Y

¢½?O Y Y Y Y Y Y

R2 0.267 0.281 0.191 0.2 0.331 0.35

��þ 2765 2765 2765 2765 2765 2765


�^Å� EU�¤

Table 8: <�6Ä�EU�¤CÄ

ýéþ '

$EU ¥�EU pEU $EU ¥�EU pEU

�S{ 0.035*** 0.079*** 0.136*** -0.007*** 0.002 0.005***

(-0.008) (-0.014) (-0.021) (-0.002) (-0.001) (-0.001)

� 0.014*** 0.015 0.110*** -0.002* -0.001 0.004***

(-0.005) (-0.011) (-0.015) (-0.001) (-0.001) (-0.001)

�à<�Ó

'

-0.018* 0.005 -0.003 -0.002 0.002 0.000

(-0.01) (-0.02) (-0.016) (-0.003) (-0.003) (-0.001)

��Ó' -0.048 0.124 0.451*** 0.013 0.001 -0.014**

(-0.037) (-0.081) (-0.126) (-0.008) (-0.006) (-0.006)

n�Ó' -0.062* 0.016 0.135 0.013* 0.003 -0.015***

(-0.035) (-0.093) (-0.162) (-0.008) (-0.005) (-0.005)

<þGDP -0.014 -0.034* -0.145*** -0.012*** 0.002 0.010***

(-0.009) (-0.018) (-0.027) (-0.002) (-0.002) (-0.001)

<þè/¡

È

-0.132*** -0.080** -0.281** -0.009** 0.008** 0.001

(-0.044) (-0.037) (-0.123) (-0.004) (-0.004) (-0.003)

�½�A Y Y Y Y Y Y

�m�A Y Y Y Y Y Y

R2 0.197 0.606 0.92 0.811 0.568 0.778

��þ 3965 3965 3965 3965 3965 3965


�^Å� Ù¦Å�

Table 9: Ù¦�^Å�))|db`

ÆdUå NÄå¤�

(1) (2) (3) (4)

6Ä<� 30.374 0.020*

(-34.661) (-0.011)

{S 165.888*** 0.015

(-42.674) (-0.032)

�S{ 157.487*** 0.021

(-38.057) (-0.02)

� -242.481*** 0.001

(-38.459) (-0.013)

è�A� Y Y Y Y

/«A� Y Y Y Y

1�J[ Y Y Y Y

�°J[ Y Y Y Y

R2 0.37 0.37 0.765 0.766

��þ 141344 141344 1874 1874


è5u�9ÿÐ è5u�

Table 10: è5u��

EâÚ? ��IV ÿþØ� OLS

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8)

6Ä<� 0.636*** 0.270*** 0.071*** 0.067***

(-0.068) (-0.046) (-0.005) (-0.004)

{S 0.139 -0.659** -0.038*** -0.027***

(-0.147) (-0.299) (-0.005) (-0.005)

�S{ 0.306** -2.488*** 0.060*** 0.057***

(-0.15) (-0.471) (-0.005) (-0.005)

� 0.373*** 3.395*** 0.036*** 0.020***

(-0.05) (-0.619) (-0.005) (-0.005)

FDI 0.008*** -0.020***

(-0.003) (-0.004)

è�A� Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y

/«A� Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y

1�J[ Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y

�°J[ Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y

Wald ) ) 22.25*** 261.13*** ) ) ) )

pseudo

R2

) ) ) ) 0.242 0.242 ) )

chi2 126203.99 116665.6 192661.04 63487.19 ) ) ) )

R2 ) ) ) ) ) ) 0.541 0.541

��þ 135431 135431 185715 185715 141344 141344 141344 141344



Table 11: è5u��

�Ñ�è� Ñ�è� ð�1�

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

6Ä<� 0.077*** 0.042* 0.093***

(-0.005) (-0.022) (-0.028)

{S -0.025*** -0.072*** -0.055**

(-0.006) (-0.023) (-0.027)

�S{ 0.060*** 0.071*** 0.075***

(-0.006) (-0.023) (-0.027)

� 0.028*** 0.033 0.058**

(-0.005) (-0.022) (-0.025)

è�A� Y Y Y Y Y Y

/«A� Y Y Y Y Y Y

1�J[ Y Y Y Y Y Y

�°J[ Y Y Y Y Y Y

pseudo

R2

0.209 0.209 0.284 0.285 0.247 0.235

��þ 132666 132666 8678 8678 5470 5470



Table 12: ¿�é�ÅA^�K�

Eâ¿� ½|¿�§Ý

(1) (2) (3) (4)

6Ä<� 0.076*** 0.093***

(-0.005) (-0.005)

{S -0.028*** -0.032***

(-0.006) (-0.006)

�S{ 0.067*** 0.055***

(-0.006) (-0.006)

� 0.022*** 0.047***

(-0.006) (-0.006)

1�SY² -61.468*** -61.382***

(-16.83) (-16.77)

½|¿� 0.162 0.172

(-0.195) (-0.195)

è�A� Y Y Y Y

/«A� Y Y Y Y

1�J[ Y Y Y N

�°J[ Y Y Y Y

pseudo R2 0.223 0.223 0.189 0.189

��þ 119143 119143 141344 141344



Table 13: ár��

árJ ár´

(1) (2) (3) (4)

6Ä<� 0.048** 0.070***

(-0.02) (-0.014)

{S -0.082*** -0.088***

(-0.028) (-0.015)

�S{ 0.03 0.105***

(-0.018) (-0.014)

� 0.090*** 0.025*

(-0.033) (-0.015)

è�A� Y Y Y Y

/«A� Y Y Y Y

1�J[ Y Y Y Y

�°J[ Y Y Y Y

pseudo

R2

0.226 0.227 0.221 0.221

��þ 12021 12021 35860 35860


è5u�9ÿÐ ÿÐ©Û

Table 14: �ÅA^�è�)�Ç

OLS ?n�A�.

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)

�Åê 0.029*** 0.061*** 0.057*** 1.724*** 1.200***

(-0.004) (-0.004) (-0.004) (-0.044) (-0.062)

è�A� Y Y Y Y Y

1�J[ N Y Y Y Y

�°J[ N N Y Y Y

rho -0.598***

-0.017

lambda -0.546***

-0.033

R2 0.114 0.122 0.137 - -

��þ 160364 160364 160364 118818 118818


(Ø

(Ø

<�6Äéó�è��ÅA^�)�¡K�§\¯ó��Uz,?�

?§"

3«©6Ä<�5 �§(Jw«�S{±9�S6Ä<��O\þr

?ó��Å�A^§Ù¥�S<�6Ä��A��è"

<�6Ä�K�´ÊH/§é¥!À!¥ÜÜ/«�ó�gÄzY²Ñå

�r?�^§�K�§ÝÚ�^5 �3É�5"

«©è�¤k��§Ø8Nè�§<�6ÄéIk!¬E±9è��

ÅA^Y²þkwÍr?�^§Ù¥é¬Eè��K��wÍ"

<�6Ä\¯ó��Uz?§Ì�´ÏLJp6\/<å]�Y²5¢y

/§dd�)�]�- EUpÖ�A-uè�é��Uz,?�I

¦"


2017 c10 9 F - Ming Yi's Personal Website · 2020. 6. 24. · 2003⁄ o[ (u¥›E„˘†L˘ ) ......

Documents

Transcript of 2017 c10 9 F - Ming Yi's Personal Website · 2020. 6. 24. · 2003⁄ o[ (u¥›E„˘†L˘ ) ......