8/20/2019 Pedro Igor Duarte, A095 874 153 (BIA July 8, 2015)

1/6

Poarch, ChristinePoarch L aw Firm,PC203 South College AvenueSalem, VA 24153

Name:DUARTE,PEDROIGOR

U.S. Departmnt of Justice

Executive Oce r Immigation Revew

Board of Immigtion ApelsOce of h Crk

5107 Leesburg Pike, Sut 200Fal Chc. Vn 53

DHS IT.ork Co PrisonOR3400 Concord oadYork,PA 17402

A 095-87 4-153

Date of this notice 7 /8/2015

nclosed s a copy of he Board's decison and orde n the aboe-reerenced case.

ncosure

Mb B

Sncerel,

Do ctDona CrChie Clek

j

For more unpublished BIA decisions, visitwww.irac.net/unpublished/index/

      g         

  g     p  p         

       

       

     

Cite as: Pedro Igor Duarte, A095 874 153 (BIA July 8, 2015)

8/20/2019 Pedro Igor Duarte, A095 874 153 (BIA July 8, 2015)

2/6

U.S epament f JusticeExecutive Ofce r Imiation Review

Decision of e Bod of Igtion Appeas

Flls Chch, Vrginia 2053

F: A095 874 153 - York, PA

I r: PERO IGO ARTE k Pdro gor

IN MOVAL PROCEEING

 PPEL

 :

ON BEHAF OF PONENT: Cr Loh Porh Eqr

ON BEHAF OF H: y T Bbor Aoy

ORE:

JUL - 8 2015

 T Bod h dvd h h D o Hold y' (DH) l h

 b hdr See 8 CFR § 10034 hr og ow dg br h Bod

 h rord rd o h Io Co who r o

OR THE BOR

      g           g     p  p         

       

       

     

Cite as: Pedro Igor Duarte, A095 874 153 (BIA July 8, 2015)

8/20/2019 Pedro Igor Duarte, A095 874 153 (BIA July 8, 2015)

3/6

I •

�·

Poarch Law irm PC

Poh Chrstne

UNITED SAES DEPARME OF JUSICEEXECUIVE OICE OR IMMIGIO REVIEW

IMMIGRAION COUR

300 CONCORD ROD, SUIE 2

YORK PA 740

20 Souh Colege Avee

Sae A 245

I HE MATR O

DARE PEDRO IGOR

9488-0

FILE 05-8753

UABLE O ORWARD NO ADDRESS PROIDED

DE: Apr 10 205

' ACED IS A COPY O E DECISIO O E MMIGRION JUDGE. IS DECISON4

IS FINA UNESS APPEA IS FILED I E BORD O IMMIGION APPESWIIN 30 CAEDAR DAYS O E DAE O E MAILNG O IS WRIEN DECISIO.

SEE E ENCLOSED ORMS AD INSRUCIOS OR PROPERLY PREARIG YOUR APPE

YOR NOICE O APPEA AACED DOCUMENS AD EE OR EE WAIVER REQUESMS BE MAILED O BORD O IMMIGRAION APPEAS

OFICE OF E CLERK

07 eesb Pike Se 2000

AS CURCH VA 20530

AACED IS A COP O E DECISIO O HE IMMIGAION UDGE AS HE RESUL

O YOUR AILURE O APPEAR A YOUR SCEDULED DEPORAIO OR REMOVL EARNG

IS DECISION IS INAL UNLESS A MOION O REOPEN S IED IN ACCORDACE

SECION 2B) (3 O E IMIGRAON ND NIONLIY AC 8 USC.SECION 252B{ IN DEPORAIO PROCEEDGS OR SECION 240 6

8 USC SECION 229 6 IN REMOVAL PROCEEDINGS. IF YOU ILE MOIOO REOPEN YOUR MOIO MUS E ILED I IS COUR

OER

IMMIGON COUR

300 COCORD ROAD SUIE 2

YORK PA 702

DVQ

COUR CERK

IMMGRIO COUR

CC DISRIC COUNSEL C/ YOK PRISON

300 CONCORD ROAD

YOR A 702000

      g         

  g     p  p             ,   

       

     

8/20/2019 Pedro Igor Duarte, A095 874 153 (BIA July 8, 2015)

4/6

.

.

IN THE MAER OF:

DUARTE dro gor

Respnet

UNITED STATES DEPARTMEN OF JUSICEEXECUTIVE OFFICE FOR IMMIGRAION REVIEW

UNITED SATES IMMIGRTION COURT

YORK, PENNSYLVNIA

) IN REMOVL PROCEEDINGS)) Fe# 095-87413

ON BEHLF OF RESPONDENT: ) ON BEHALF OF HE DHS

ra co qhr oarch q.

Mtin: rmao by od

Ruling on Motion ad Ore

od a 29yarod g ma a a av ad cz of raz who

acao  r ajum of au urua o § 24 adm wh a § 212(h)

wavr o admby a grad by a mmgrao judg o ay 5 2010 a aco h rova rocdg o ovbr 1 2014 wh roa rvc of a oc oar orm 862 od ha ubd a oo o ra; h govr haubd a rf uor of ovably.

od ad covcd o a fraud volao of . § 1341 o arch 6

24 ad ry rvg h ro c of 24 oh h crux of rod'

moo ha h add guy o $900 o o a a ru of h covco ad hrfor h

govrm cao burd o roo by car ad covcg vdc r §240(c)(3)() o abh h rmovaby ovrm cou o o h r a

agrm ad h a cooquy arg ha rod agrd ha h o o h vc

xcdd $1000; govr cou ao o ou ha h aou of ruo od

wa $28210

od do o du ha h fdra covco cou a raud of

oy ha h o a a ru of h covco wa l ha $1000 h hrhod amouudr 101(a)(43)(()() h rgard rod mhaz ha h add guy oou 12 ad 3 of h dcm whr ach cou h o amou a $300

ovm cou do o co ha rod add guy o cou 13 or ha h oa lo umrad wh h hr cou $9000 argu ha rod

ckogd h wr guy a exhibit ad h a colloquy exhibit J ha h oal o a grar ha $100 h my o

Exhibit C h udg rcg a guly a o cou 12 ad 3 xhibit H

 h dcm ag 3 of whch cf a o amou o $3000 for ach cou h wra agrm ur h aragah d "a rod rcogz ha hr

1

             

     p  p         

       

       

     

8/20/2019 Pedro Igor Duarte, A095 874 153 (BIA July 8, 2015)

5/6

may b mmgraon consquncs o hs guly pla and ha a loss amon xcdng $1000wll · prsumpvly rsl n hs rmoval Govrnmn counsl rads hs as rspondnaknowldgng ha h loss xcdd $1000 Th cour rads hs as no mor hanrspondn bng apprsd o h mmgraon consqncs f h chos o plad gly; hsnocaon dos no n any way qua o rspondn acknowldgng ha h s pladng guly o a loss xcdng $10000 or ohrws bnds hm hro

Th pla colloquy a eiit - also dos no rval any admsson by rsondn hahs gly pla ncluds h loss o Connnal Arlns (couns 13) xcdng $1000 On pag12 o h docmn h proscuor norms h dsrc cour ha h "nr loss amoun for

 h whol cr s sll ovr n grand Jus prvously on pag 11 h proscor nrms hdsrc cor ha n paragraph wo o h pla agrmn [rspondn] s pladng guly omal raud n volaon o Tl 18 Und Sas Cod Scon 1341 whr h loss amounxcds $10 rmoval s prsumpvly mandaory. Whn h cour askd rspondnwhhr h dscussd "hs wh hs aorny manng h mmgraon consquncs o hsguly pla), rspondn rpld ys.

Whhr h dral proscuor blvd ha rspondn agrd ha h was pladng

gly o a loss grar han $1000 s nhr hr nor hr s clar ha h pladd gly o only couns 13 no ha h was pladng guly o causng h loss o Connnal Arlns ofmor han $100. Whl prhaps h languag n h pla agrmn could b mprovd formor clary hs sgnaur hron dos no n any way alr h acal guly pla. Undr hparagraph nld "Chang o Pla sas ha Dndan xprssly and qvocallyadms ha h commd h crms chargd n Couns 13 o h ndcmn Whl allcouns whn h ndcmn do rlc losss mch grar han $10000. all ohr couns arrrlvan

As rspondn pons ou h Thrd Crc rqrs actual losss undr INA §11a)43)M)) and mor spccally h losss us b hrd o an acual ons andsch losss ay no ncld any amouns basd on acqual or dsmssd cons. Alaka v. A'Gn. 456 F.3d 88 106 3d Cr. 206) hold was lgal rror or h IJ o consdr hamoun o nndd loss  r all o h chargs rahr han h sngl coun or whch sh wasconvcd)

Fnally n hs parcular cas h rsuon amoun s rrlan snc w now hspcc amoun o loss. Rsuon may only b consdrd h loss amoun s no ohrwsclar rom h convcon rcord n Mnro v Ashcrof 353 F.3d 225 3d Cr 203) h ThrdCrcu phld h Boards ndng ha h alns convcon nvolvd a loss xcdng $100and hror h rducon n rsuon had no lgal c on ha ac Thus h corconcludd inter aia,  ha h

"amon of rson ordrd as a rsl o a convcon may b hlpl o acours nqury no h amoun o loss o h vcm f h pla agrmn or hndcm s unclar as o h loss srd. B whn h amon o rsuonordrd s no basd on a ndng as o h amoun o h loss .  h amo orson s no conrollng.

2

      g           g     p  p         

       

       

     

8/20/2019 Pedro Igor Duarte, A095 874 153 (BIA July 8, 2015)

6/6

� .

Based upon the foregoing, the cout concurs with respondent that thegovrment as not met its burden of proof tat the conviction loss exceeded $10000.s requied or an aggravated eony faud conviction as set f t at INA §101(a)(43)M)(i) Wile these poceedings must be teminated by all appearancesespodent seems utimatey headed  r reova given his crimina arrest record fhistory is any indication uess he quickly reorms, respondent wi be back be e thecour at some point in the future The outcoe of that case soud be freboding torespondent The folowing order is hereby entered

Oder: The ground of aggravated felony A § 237(a 2)(A)iii), is dismissed and theseemova proceedings ar y rminted "

Ar 10 2015

ater A Durlingmmigration Judg

3

      g           g     p  p