Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

128
Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal !"#$%&’’()’(#*!+ M.J. van Reen ,-. 0110

Transcript of Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Page 1: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologischeproblemen rondbochtverbeteringenin de Waal!"#$%&''()'(#*!+

M.J. van Reen

,-./0110

Page 2: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft
Page 3: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics Voorwoord

Voorwoord

&.2/ 345267--89-85:3;/ .5/ 7-/ 348<=7.=;/ 93=/,.>=/ 5267.-/?.9.-:-/ $-@A=.-B/ 33=/ 7-/ $-@A=.5@A-%=.9-85.2-.2/93=/&-:42C/&-/D-7<-:.=;/93=/A-2/<=7-8E<-B/F35/<,/--=/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;2-/9.=7-=/9<<8/7-/,<84<:<;.5@A-/G8<D:-,-=/8<=7/D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;/E<3:5/ 2<-;-G352/ .=/7-H33:/ 2-8/ 9-8D-2-8.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ 9338D33=D8--72-C/I<-F-:/ 7-E-/,3328-;-:/ .5/ 2<-;-G352/ .=/ 78.-D<@A2-=J/.5/.=/7.2/<=7-8E<-B/9<<83:/7-/D<@A2/D.>/#.=2/!=78.-5/D-B-B-=C/&-/<G:<55.=;/7.-=7-2-/F<87-=/D-B-B-=/2-=/<GE.@A2-/93=/7-/A6.7.;-/<=7-8A<67552832-;.-/<G/D35.5/93=/D3;;-8-=C

I-2/345267--8F-8B/.5/6.2;-9<-87/D.>/H*/K/&-:42/IL7836:.@5/MH*/52332/9<<8/H32-8:<<GB6=7.;*3D<832<8.6,N/ -=/ .5/ --=/ <G783@A2/ 93=/ (.>B5F32-852332/ [email protected]/ O<52PQ-7-8:3=7C(.>B5F32-852332/A--42/7338,--/9<<8/--=/7--:/93=/7-/[email protected].=;/93=/A-2/<=7-8E<-B/;-E<8;7C&-/ D-;-:-.7.=;/ 93=6.2/H*/ K/ &-:42/ IL7836:.@5/ .5/ .=2-8=/ ;[email protected]/ .=/ A-2/ B37-8/ 93=/ 7-<=7-852-6=.=;/ 93=/ H*/ 33=/ 7-/ $%/ &-:42/ .=/ A-2/ B37-8/ 93=/ A-2/ Q-7-8:3=75/ ?-=286,/ 9<<8(.9.-8B6=7-C/&-/--852-/,33=7/93=/A-2/<=7-8E<-B/.5/7<<8;-D83@A2/D.>/H*/K/&-:42/IL7836:.@5CR=/ 7-/ ,33=7-=/ <B2<D-8/ -=/ =<9-,D-8/ A-D/ .B/ --=/ ;-7--:2-/ 93=/ A-2/ <=7-8E<-B/ D.>(.>B5F32-852332/ [email protected]/O<52PQ-7-8:3=7/,<;-=/ 6.29<-8-=C/ $-=5:<22-/ A-D/ .B/ A-2/ <=7-8E<-B9-87-8/9<<82;-E-2/-=/34;-8<=7/D.>/H*/K/&-:42/IL7836:.@5C

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email protected]

S.>/A-2/5@A8.>9-=/93=/A-2/9-85:3;/.5/-8/93=6.2/;-;33=/732/7-/:-E-8/--=/E-B-8-/D35.5B-==.5/A--42,-2/ D-28-BB.=;/ 2<2/ 8.9.-8,<84<:<;.-/ -=/ 7338/ D.>B<,-=7-/ G8<@-55-=C/ R=/ A<<47526B/ 0/ .57-5<=73=B5/ 2<@A/ =<;/ F32/ 3@A2-8;8<=7.=4<8,32.-/ A.-8<9-8/ <G;-=<,-=/ -=/ .=/ 7-/ D.>:3;-/ .533=96::-=7-/.=4<8,32.-/;-;-9-=/<9-8/7-/9-85@A.::-=7-/8-4-8-=2.-9:3BB-=/-=/,--22-@A=.-B-=&-/<GD<6F/93=/A-2/9-85:3;/9<:;2/7-/9<:;<87-/93=/A-2/<=7-8E<-B/-=/.5/7338,--/;-7--:2-:.>B<<B/3:5/E<73=.;/;-5@A8-9-=/-=/2-/:-E-=C

VCTC/93=/(--=/&-:42J/,-./0110

Page 4: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

Voorwoord WL | Delft Hydraulics

Page 5: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics i

Inhoud

!"#$%&'()&*"+,-.)

!"#$%&'()&/(0.11.)

!"#$%&'()&2345-%")+.)

!"#$%&'()&678051.)

6(8.)'(%%")+

9&:)1.";")+<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<9=9

>&?5-3515+"$@A.&05@A%'.-$@A"#)$.1.) <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<>=9

0C^/R=:-.7.=; CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC0_^

0C0/S<@A2/E<=7-8/D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=; CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC0_^

0C\/S<@A2/,-2/D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=; CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC0_\

B&C.$@A-"#'")+&'()&;.&05@A%.) <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<B=9

\C^/R=:-.7.=; CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC\_^

\C0/'8:-@<,/MD<7-,B8.DD-=N CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC\_\

\C\/Q.>,-;-=/M9352-/:33;N CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC\_`

\C`/#.=2/!=78.-5/M9352-/:33;NCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC\_a

D&2)(17%"$@A.&0.-.4.)")+.)<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<D=9

`C^/R=:-.7.=; CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC`_^

`C0/V3Y.,3:-/7.-G2-/=3352/9352-/:33; CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC`_^

`C\/V3Y.,3:-/7.-G2-/,-2/938.[8-=7-/33=:-;A<<;2-/-=/D8--72-CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC`_b

`C`/&[email protected] CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC`_^0

E&2)(17$.&8.%&0.A,1F&'()&2-@G".H<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<E=9

cC^/R=:-.7.=; CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCc_^

Page 6: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

i i WL | Delft Hydraulics

cC0/&.,-=5.-5/<=2;8<=7.=;-=CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCc_^

cC\/$.>759-8:<<G/<=2;8<=7.=;-=/-=/33=E3=7.=;-= CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCc_\

cC`/)338D33=D8--72-/9<<8/-=/=3/7-/33=:-; CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCc_\

cCc/*3=;59-8A3=;CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCc_\

cCa/&F3859-8A3=; CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCc_\

cCd/&[email protected] CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCc_c

I&JFK.%&.)&"#4")+&'()&L.13%BL&'55-&6")%&2);-".$ <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<I=9

aC^/R=:-.7.=; CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCa_^

aC0/'-87-8-/5.,6:32.-5/-=/9-83=7-8.=;-=/D.>/33=:-;/93=/9352-/:33;CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCa_^

aC\/OGE-2/93=/A-2/,<7-: CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCa_`

aC`/+:<D3:-/.>B.=;CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCa_^1

aCc/&[email protected] CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCa_^b

M&?5+.1"#4.&'.-0.%.-")+.)&05;[email protected]")+$@5)$%-,@%".$ <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<M=9

dC^/R=:-.7.=; CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_^

dC0/V<;-:.>B-/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;-= CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_^

dC\/#.,6:32.-/,-2/&-:42\&CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_c

dC\C^/)-8:-=;-= CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_cdC\C0/)-8:33;7/9-8:-=;-= CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_ddC\C\/":36F-8/-.=723:67 CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_^1dC\C`/+-:-.7-:.>B-/-.=79-85,3::.=; CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_^0dC\Cc/+-:-.7-:.>B-/-.=79-8D8-7.=;CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_^\dC\Ca/H-;D3;;-8-=/93=/7-/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_^cdC\Cd/#2<82-=/.=/A-2/-8<5.-;32 CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_^adC\Ce/S<7-,9-8:<<G/2-=/D-A<-9-/93=/9<82-Y/-Y@:67-8CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_^e

dC`/&[email protected] CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_^b

N&G.-+.1"#4")+&'()&;.&85+.1"#4.&'.-0.%.-")+.) <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<N=9

eC^/R=:-.7.=; CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCe_^

eC0/$-@A=.5@A-/34F-;.=;-=CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCe_^

eC\/'@<=<,.5@A-/34F-;.=;-= CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCe_c

eC`/&[email protected] CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCe_b

Page 7: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics i i i

O&L"$@,$$". <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<O=9

9P&Q5)@1,$".$&.)&(()0.'.1")+.)<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<9P=9

^1C^/?<=@:65.-5CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC^1_^

^1C0/!3=D-9-:.=;-= CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC^1_\

!"%.-(%,,-1"#$%

Page 8: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

i v WL | Delft Hydraulics

Page 9: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics v

Lijst van Figuren

".;668/^P^f/#28<<,;-D.-7/93=/7-/(.>=/,-2/--=/6.25=-7-/93=/Q-7-8:3=7/-=/7-/\/D<@A2-=CCC^_\

".;668/0P^f/O=2F.BB-:.=;/7F3859-8A3=;/.=/--=/D<@A2 CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC0_0

".;668/0P0f/#G.833:528<,.=;/MUC/Q6L2-=NCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC0_0

".;668/0P\f/)352-/:33;/MUC/Q6L2-=N CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC0_`

".;668/0P`f/][email protected]@A-25J/D<9-=33=E.@A2/;8-=5/9352-/:33;/-=/3::69.3:-/7--: CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC0_c

".;668/0Pcf/S<7-,B8.DD-=/MUC/Q6L2-=NCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC0_a

".;668/\P^f/H33:D<@A2/D.>/'8:-@<,/,-2/D<7-,:.;;.=; CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC\_\

".;668/\P0f/H33:D<@A2/D.>/Q.>,-;-=/,-2/D<7-,:.;;.=; CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC\_c

".;668/\P\f/H33:D<@A2/D.>/#.=2/!=78.-5/,-2/D<7-,:.;;.=;CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC\_a

".;668/\P`f/\P&/33=E.@A2/93=/A-2/-.=7-/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/93=34/D-=-7-=528<<,5 CCCCCCCCCCCCCCC\_d

".;668/\Pcf/U8.D9:3,,-=/D<9-=528<<,5/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/93=/#.=2/!=78.-5CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC\_e

".;668/`P^f/#23=7338734F.>B.=;/93=/7-/;-,-2-=/7.-G2-/<G/7-/9352-/:33;/MD6.2-=D<@A2NCCCCCC`_0

".;668/`P0f/][email protected]@A-25/7F385G8<4.-: CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC`_c

".;668/`P\f/S-8-B-=7/7F385G8<4.-:/-=/;-,-2-=/7F385G8<4.-: CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC`_b

".;668/`P`f/&.-G2-/-8<5.-5:-64/6.2;-E-2/2-;-=/938.[8-=7-/D<7-,283=5G<82 CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC`_b

".;668/`Pcf/(-:32.-/,3YC/7.-G2-/P/33=:-;A<<;2-J/93=/9352-/:33;/#2C/!=78.-5/MS9g^`1,NCCCC`_^^

".;668/`Paf/(-:32.-/,3YC/7.-G2-/P/D8--72-/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/#2C/!=78.-5/MA9/g/cJdb/,NCCCCCC`_^0

".;668/aP^f/O9-8E.@A2/93=/A-2/&-:42\&/8-B-=8<<52-8P283>-@2/B,8C/b^eJd/2<2/bc\J1 CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCa_`

".;668/aP0f/&-23.:/93=/A-2/8-B-=8<<52-8/M2CAC9C/#.=2/!=78.-5J/E.-/".;668/aP^N CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCa_a

".;668/aP\f/(6FA-.75@<,D.=32.-5/<G/B,8/b0cJd/M7.BB-/:.>=/g/;-,C/93=/7-/G-.:.=;-=N^CCCCa_^0

".;668/aP`f/(6FA-.75@<,D.=32.-5/<G/B,8/b0aJd/M7.BB-/:.>=/g/;-,C/93=/7-/G-.:.=;-=N CCCCCa_^0

".;668/aPcf/(6FA-.75@<,D.=32.-5/<G/B,8/b0dJd/M7.BB-/:.>=/g/;-,C/93=/7-/G-.:.=;-=N^CCCCa_^\

".;668/aPaf/(6FA-.75@<,D.=32.-5/<G/B,8/b0eJa/M7.BB-/:.>=/g/;-,C/93=/7-/G-.:.=;-=N CCCCCa_^\

".;668/aPdf/'8<5.-;32/-=/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/<G/9-85@A.::-=7-/2.>7-=/M349<-8/^a11/,\X5NCCCCCCa_^c

".;668/aPef/!49<-89-8:<<G/^bbb/2<2/-=/,-2/011^/-=/;-5@A-,32.5--87-/349<-8/MH33:N CCCCCCa_^a

".;668/aPbf/S<7-,9-8:<<G/2CAC9C/B,8C/b0eJc/<G/^e,/6.2/7-/8-@A2-8P=<8,33::.>= CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCa_^a

".;668/aP^1f/)-85@A.:/2655-=/-2,33:/;-,.77-:7-/349<-8/-=/;-5@A-,32.5--87-/349<-8CCCCCCCCa_^d

".;668/aP^^f/)[email protected]/93=/86FA-7-=/33=/7-/A3=7/93=/7-/52<<,5=-:A-7-=CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCa_^d

".;668/aP^0f/S<7-,A<<;2-/;-.>B2/5.,6:32.-,<7-:/93=/B,8/b0`J0/2<2/b0bJ`/M=3/`/>338N CCCCa_^e

".;668/dP^f/S<9-=33=E.@A2/93=/7-/9-8:-=;7-/9352-/:33;/MB,8C/b0aJdd/2X,/b\^J^bN CCCCCCCCCCCCCd_c

".;668/dP0f/*3=;5G8<4.-:-=/<G/@.8@3/^e/,-2-8/6.2/7-/=<8,33::.>=CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_a

Page 10: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

v i WL | Delft Hydraulics

".;668/dP\f/&F385G8<4.-:/2-8/A<<;2-/93=/B,8C/b0bJbc/M.=/7-/D<@A2/93=/OG.>=-=N CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_a

".;668/dP`f/&F385G8<4.-:/<G/@.8@3/c11/,/D-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/7-/9352-/:33; CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_d

".;668/dPcf/S<9-=33=E.@A2/9-8:33;7-/9-8:-=;7-/9352-/:33;/MB,8C/b0aJdd/2X,/b\^J^bN CCCCCCCCd_e

".;668/dPaf/&F385G8<4.-:/2-8/A<<;2-/93=/B,8C/b0bJe`/M.=/7-/D<@A2/93=/OG.>=-=N CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_e

".;668/dPdf/&F385G8<4.-:/2-8/A<<;2-/93=/B,8C/b0eJc/MD-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/7-/9352-/:33;N CCd_b

".;668/dPef/*3=;5G8<4.-:/<G/\c/,/6.2/:.=B-8P=<8,33::.>=/93=34/B,8C/b0dJ\/2X,/b\^Jb CCCCCCCCCd_b

".;668/dPbf/*3=;5G8<4.-:/<G/b1/,/6.2/8-@A2-8P=<8,33::.>=/93=34/B,8C/b0dJ\/2X,/b\^Jb CCCCCd_^1

".;668/dP^1f/S<9-=33=E.@A2/9352-/:33;/,-2/4:36F-8/-.=723:67/B,8C/b0aJdd/2X,/b\^J^bCCCCd_^^

".;668/dP^^f/*3=;5G8<4.-:/<G/\c/,/6.2/:.=B-8P=<8,33::.>=/93=34/B,8C/b0dJ\/2X,/b\^Jb CCCCCd_^^

".;668/dP^0f/*3=;5G8<4.-:/<G/b1/,/6.2/8-@A2-8P=<8,33::.>=/93=34/B,8C/b0dJ\/2X,/b\^Jb CCCd_^0

".;668/dP^\f/S<9-=33=E.@A2/;-:-.7-:.>B-/-.=79-85,3::.=;/MB,8C/b0dJ\/2X,/b0bJ`0NCCCCCCCCCCd_^\

".;668/dP^`f/S<9-=33=E.@A2/;-:-.7-:.>B-/-.=79-8D8-7.=;/MB,8C/b0dJ\/2X,/b0bJ`0N CCCCCCCCCCCd_^`

".;668/dP^cf/&F385G8<4.-:/2-8/A<<;2-/93=/B,8C/b0eJc CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_^`

".;668/dP^af/)-8:<<G/93=/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/.=/7-/2.>7/2CAC9C/B,8C/b0eJc/=3/D3;;[email protected]_^c

".;668/dP^df/)-8:<<G/93=/A-2/-8<5.-;32/.=/7-/2.>7/2CAC9C/B,8C/b0eJ0e/=3/52<[email protected] CCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_^a

".;668/dP^ef/)-8:<<G/93=/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/.=/7-/2.>7/2CAC9C/B,8C/b0eJc/=3/52<[email protected]_^d

".;668/dP^bf/S.==-=D<@A2/OG.>=-=/b1,/6.2/:.=B-8P=<8,33::.>=J/=3/52<[email protected] CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_^d

".;668/dP01f/S<7-,9-8:<<G/A-2/3::69.3:-/;-7--:2-/=3352/7-/9352-/:33;/2CAC9C/B,8C/b0eJ^CCCd_^e

".;668/eP^f/*3=;5G8<4.-:/93=34/B,8C/b0dJ\/<G/^e/,/6.2/7-/:.=B-8P=<8,33::.>= CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCe_\

".;668/eP0f/*3=;5G8<4.-:/93=34/B,8C/b0dJ\/<G/^e/,/6.2/7-/8-@A2-8P=<8,33::.>= CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCe_`

".;668/eP\f/Q-22</@<=23=2-/F3387-/MQ?HN/9<<8/9-85@A.::-=7-/7.5@<=2<G-8@-=23;-5CCCCCCCCCCCe_d

".;668/eP`f/Q-22</@<=23=2-/F3387-/MQ?HN/B<52-=9-8;-:.>B.=;/,-2/34F.>B.=;-=/2<2/c1h CCCe_e

Page 11: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics v i i

Lijst van Tabellen

$3D-:/\P^f/+-;-9-=5/93=/7-/D<@A2-=/'8:-@<,J/Q.>,-;-=/-=/#.=2/!=78.-5 CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC\_0

$3D-:/`P^f/)-8;-:.>B.=;-=/-=/<=D-B-=7-CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC`_\

$3D-:/`P0f/S-8-B-=.=;/,3Y.,3:-/7.-G2-/<=2;8<=7.=;55:-64/-=/7F3859-8A3=; CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC`_d

$3D-:/`P\f/S-8-B-=.=;/33=/7-/A3=7/93=/9-8;-:.>B.=;/M`C^eNCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC`_e

$3D-:/`P`f/)38.3D-:-/33=:-;7.-G2-/9352-/:33;/93=/^`1/,/D8--7CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC`_^1

$3D-:/`Pcf/)38.3D-:-/D8--72-/9352-/:33;/93=/cJdb/,/33=:-;A<<;2-CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC`_^^

$3D-:/aP^f/'=B-:-/F3387-/9<<8/(R)OVPD-8-B-=.=;-=/6.2/#286.B5,3/-2/3:C/^bb` CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCa_0

$3D-:/aP0f/?AZELPF3387-/9<<8/7-/9352-/:33;/6.2/I<,D-8;-=/-2/3:C/^bbcCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCa_0

$3D-:/aP\f/+-,C/B<88-:7.3,-2-8/6.2/I<,D-8;-=/-2/3:C/^bbc/3C7CAC9C/<=7-8E<-B/"6;8<CCCCCCCCCa_\

$3D-:/aP`f/!3=G355.=;5:-=;2-/9<<8/D<@A2/93=/#.=2/!=78.-5CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCa_c

$3D-:/aPcf/'=B-:-/B383B2-8.52.-B-=/93=/A-2/,<7-:CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCa_d

$3D-:/aPaf/?AZELPF3387-/9<<8/9352-/:3;-=J/;-D86.B2/.=/,<7-::-=/<4/6.2/<=7-8E<-BCCCCCCCCCCCa_^^

$3D-:/aPdf/&.,-=5.-5/-8<5.-5:-64/-=/-8<5.-;32/#2C/!=78.-5 CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCa_^`

$3D-:/dP^f/'.5-=/F338/7-/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;-=/33=/;-2<-252/F<87-=CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_0

$3D-:/dP0f/V<;-:.>B-/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;-= CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_0

$3D-:/dP\f/?<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;-=CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_\

$3D-:/dP`f/S3;;-8P/-=/52<[email protected]/2-=/<GE.@A2-/93=/7-/2.>7CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCd_`

$3D-:/eP^f/'.5-=/F338/7-/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;-=/33=/;-2<-252/F<87-=CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCe_^

$3D-:/eP0f/$<-25.=;/93=/7-/,<;-:.>B-/<G:<55.=;-=/33=/7-/-.5-=CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCe_0

$3D-:/eP\f/+-D86.B2-/G8.>E-=/9<<8/0110CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCe_c

$3D-:/eP`f/I<-9--:A-7-=/;-D86.B2/<,/Q?H/2-/D-G3:-= CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCe_a

Page 12: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

v i i i WL | Delft Hydraulics

Page 13: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics i x

Lijst van Afkortingen

2345-%")+ C.%.4.)"$0& 2F--7.,-=5.<=33:\& 78.-7.,-=5.<=33:!&?] !@<652.@/&<GG:-8/?688-=2/]8<4.:-8!QR 347-:.=;/.=4<8,32.-/F32-8/M347-:.=;/93=/(.>B5F32-852332NSO# S-5:.55-=7/O=7-852-6=-=7/#L52--,S() S3;;-8/(-4-8-=2.-/):3B??( ?-=283:-/?<,,.55.-/9<<8/7-/(.>=93382&+]# &.44-8-=2.3:/+:<D3:/]<5.2.<=.=;/#L52-,&OQ &[email protected]/O<52/Q-7-8:3=7/[email protected]/93=/(.>B5F32-852332N+R# +-<;834.5@A/R=4<8,32.-/#L52--,R!I( R=2-8=32.<=3:/!55<@.32.<=/IL7836:.@/-=;.=--8.=;/3=7/(-5-38@AT&] T338:.>B5-/&F385/]-.:.=;B,8C B.:<,-2-8833.**H# *33;/*33;H32-8/#G8.=;V+& V.=52/+-G-.:7-/&.-G2-VIH V332;-9-=7/I<<;/H32-8/MD.>/--=/349<-8/93=/^a111/,\X5NQ!] Q<8,33:/!,52-873,5/]-.:Q?H Q-22</?<=23=2-/H3387-O*! O9-8--=;-B<,-=/*3;-/!49<-8/MD.>/--=/349<-8/93=/be`/,\X5/D.>/*<D.2ANO*( O9-8--=;-B<,-=/*3;-/(.9.-8523=7O*H O9-8--=;-B<,-=/*3;-/H32-8523=7(RUi (.>B5.=52.2662/9<<8/U652/-=/i--(R)?OV (R)-8/3=7/?O3523:/V<8GA<:<L(Ri! (.>B5R=52.2662/9<<8/R=2-;833:/i<-2F32-8D-A--8/-=/!493:F32-8D-A3=7-:.=;(H# (.>B5F32-852332#))0 $F--7-/#286@26685@A-,3/)-8B--8/-=/)-89<-8$%& $-@A=.5@A-/%=.9-85.2-.2/&-:42H* H32-8:<<GB6=7.;/*3D<832<8.6,J/H*/!/&-:42/IL7836:.@5

Page 14: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

x WL | Delft Hydraulics

Page 15: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics x i

Lijst van Symbolen

6780551 C.%.4.)"$ '-=A-.7" 8-:32.-9-/[email protected] jPk# @<=523=2-/93=/)<=/Ul8,l=/M#/g/1J`N j,k$ #A.-:75G383,-2-8 jPk% @<683=2/;-23:/M9<<8/D-8-B-=.=;/362<,32.5@A-/523G;8<<22-N jPk& F32-87.-G2- j,k' 9.5@<5.2-.2 j,0X5k&D 9-8A<67.=;f/E3=7/<G/7-/9352-/:33;/,-2/7-/,3Y.,3:-/7.B2-

F338/7-/9352-/:33;/;--=/.=9:<-7/<G/A--42jPk

(4 @3:.D832.-/@<[44.@.[=2/9<<8/283=5G<82/<9-8/7-/9352-/:33; jPk), 5<<82-:.>B-/[email protected]/MD<7-,N,32-8.33: jB;X,\k(G<8 G<8<5.2-.2 jhk)5 5<<82-:.>B-/[email protected]/9352-/52<4 jB;X,\k*5 33=G355.=;5:-=;2-/D<7-,9-852<8.=; j,k+523 @<[44.@.[=2/9<<8/=6,-8.-B-/523D.:.2-.2 jPk)F 5<<82-:.>B-/[email protected]/F32-8 jB;X,\k*F 33=G355.=;5:-=;2-/F32-8D-F-;.=; j,k"Y @-:;8<<22-/.=/:3=;58.@A2.=; j,k"L @-:;8<<22-/.=/7F3858.@A2.=; j,k! 5G.833:528<,.=;@<[44.@.[=2 jPk35 @<[email protected]/43@2<8/9<<8/D<7-,A-::.=; jPkS D8--72- j,k? @<[44.@.[=2/93=/?AZEL j,^X0X5k@/D-7 D<7-,A<<;2-/5=-:A-.7/M7-/5=-:A-.7/93=/D<7-,9-852<8.=;N j,X5k&c1 ,-7.3=-/B<88-:7.3,-2-8 j,k4M$N 7F385A-::.=;5-44-@2 jPk; 9-85=-::.=;/2-=/;-9<:;-/93=/7-/EF3382-B83@A2 j,X50kA ;-,.77-:7-/7.-G2- j,kR F32-85G.-;-:9-8A3=; jPkR] [email protected]/G383,-2-8/R]/g/*5/X/*F jPkB 86FA-.7/9<:;-=5/Q.B68375- j,k*& 7-,G.=;5:-=;2-/93=/7-/G<.=2PD38 j,k, @<[44.@.[=2/.=/5-7.,-=2283=5G<824<8,6:- j5`X,\k, F.>E-/93=/A-2/283=59-853:-/9-8:<<G/93=/7-/D<7-,/M,H33:/g/^N jPk= -YG<=-=2/.=/5-7.,-=2283=5G<824<8,6:- jPkm 7-D.-2J/9<:6,-/F32-8283=5G<82/G-8/--=A-.7/93=/2.>7 j,\X5k( D<@A252833:/93=/7-/8.9.-8 j,k# 9<:6,-/5-7.,-=2283=5G<82/G-8/--=A-.7/93=/2.>7 j,\X5k5.=/, 7F3859-8A3=; jPk6 ;-,.77-:7-/528<<,5=-:A-.7 j,X5kE3 3::69.3:-/7.B2-/<G/7-/9352-/:33; j,kE4 A<<;2-/93=/7-/9352-/:33; j,k

Page 16: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

x i i WL | Delft Hydraulics

Page 17: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics Samenvatting 1

Samenvatting

&-/H33:/D-A<<82/2<2/7-/D-:3=;8.>B52-/5@A--G93382F-;-=/93=/'68<G3C/O,/<<B/.=/7-/2<-B<,52;-=<-;/ 86.,2-/ 2-/ D.-7-=/ 9<<8/ 7-/ 5@A--G93382J/ .5/ D-5:<2-=/ <,/ 7-/ ;-;383=7--87-/,.=.,3:-7.-G2-/ -=/ D8--72-/ 2-/ 9-8;8<2-=C/ &-/ ,.=.,3:-/ 34,-2.=;-=/ 7.-/ D.>/ ,332;-9-=7/ :33;F32-8;-;383=7--87/E6::-=/F<87-=/E.>=/^d1/,-2-8/D8--7/-=/0Je1/,-2-8/7.-GC/V-2/=3,-/.=/D<@A2-=D:.>B2/732/7-/D8--72-/M53,-=/,-2/7-/7.-G2-N/=.-2/;-A33:7/F<872C/&<<8/=32668:.>B-/G8<@-55-=<=252332/ --=/ 7.-G-/ D6.2-=D<@A2/ -=/ --=/ <=7.-G-/ D.==-=D<@A2C/O,/ 7.2/ =32668:.>B-/ G8<@-5/ 2-D-W=9:<-7-=/-=/2-/8-76@-8-=/E.>=/-8/9-85@A.::-=7-/,<;-:.>BA-7-=C/R=/7-/H33:/E.>=/732/<G/7.2,<,-=2/ --=/ 9352-/ :33;/ -=/ D<7-,B8.DD-=C/ '-=/ 9352-/ :33;/ .5/ --=/ D<7-,@<[email protected]/ .=/ 7-D6.2-=D<@A2J/,-2/52-=-=/93=/--=/76573=.;-/;8<<22-/732/7-E-/523D.-:/E.>=C/S<7-,B8.DD-=/E.>=B8.DD-=/7.-/<=7-8/F32-8/<G/7-/D<7-,/93=/7-/8.9.-8/.=/7-/D6.2-=D<@A2/ :.;;-=/-=/7.-/3:5/A-2F38-/--=/<=7-8D8<B-=/9352-/:33;/9<8,-=C/&-/D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;5@<[email protected]/E<8;-=/-89<<8732/ 7-/ D6.2-=D<@A2/ =.-2/ B3=/ 6.25@A68-=J/,338/ 33=;-E.-=/ -8/ --=/ ;-:.>B-/ A<-9--:A-.7/ F32-87<<8/7-/8.9.-8/;332J/E3:/7-/D.==-=D<@A2/-8<7-8-=C/R=/7-/D<@A2/D.>/'8:-@<,/E.>=/D<7-,B8.DD-=33=;-:-;7/ M^bbaN/<,/7-/ 8.9.-8D8--72-/ 2-/9-8;8<2-=C/ R=/ 7-/ D<@A2-=/D.>/Q.>,-;-=/ M^beeN/ -=#.=2/!=78.-5/M^bbbN/.5/--=/9352-/:33;/33=;-:-;7C

'-=/ @<[email protected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

Q3352/7-/;6=52.;-/F-8B.=;/93=/7-/D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;5@<[email protected]/D:.>B-=/E-/<<B/=37-:.;--44-@2-=/2-/A-DD-=J/78.-/526B5C/S.>/3::-/78.-/7-/D<@A2-=/M'8:-@<,J/Q.>,-;-=/-=/#.=2/!=78.-5N28--72/-8/D-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/7-/@<[email protected]/--=/!"#$%"&'('$")*+'/<G/ .=/7-/D.==-=D<@A2C/ R=7-/D6.2-=D<@A2/7338-=2-;-=/28--72/-8/D-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/7-/@<[email protected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email protected]/ 3387C/ H338D.>/ 7-/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ <G:<55.=;-=/ E<F-:2-@A=.5@A/3:5/-@<=<,.5@A-/2-;-=/-:B338/E.>=/34;-F<;-=C

I-2/<=7-8E<-B/.5/<G;-7--:7/.=/--=/33=23:/<G--=9<:;-=7-/<=7-87-:-=C/Q3/7-/3=3:L5-/93=/7-D<7-,G-.:.=;-=/.5/-8/,-2/F32/--=9<67.;-/3=3:L2.5@A-/9-8;-:.>B.=;-=/7-/<=2;8<=7.=;57.-G2-6.2;-8-B-=7/ =3352/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;C/ #3,-=/,-2/ 7-/ 3=3:L5-/ -=/ 3=3:L2.5@A-/ D-=37-8.=;/ E.>=/ -89-85@A.::-=7-/<G:<55.=;-=/<G;-52-:7/-=/,-2/&-:42\&/A-2/-9-=F.@A2/93=/7-/D<7-,/D-8-B-=7C$<2/5:<2/E.>=/7-/6.2B<,52-=/E<F-:/2-@A=.5@A-/3:5/-@<=<,.5@A-/,-2/-:B338/9-8;-:-B-=C

Page 18: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

Samenvatting 2 WL | Delft Hydraulics

0&(+1!"2."."3"&!24,-'-'14"2%"'2)"5*+423(&20,67$"8&-/ D<7-,:.;;.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ H33:/ F<872/ >338:.>B5/ 2F--/ B--8/ ;-,-2-=/ -=/ .=/ 7-/ D<@A2-=/ D.>'8:-@<,J/ Q.>,-;-=/ -=/ #.=2/ !=78.-5/ =<;/ --=5/ 2F--/ B--8C/ &-E-/ G-.:.=;-=/ ;-D-68-=/ 93=34^bbb/ ,-2/ ,6:2.D-3,P,-2.=;-=C/ &-E-/ ,--2;-;-9-=5/ F<87-=/ <G;-5:3;-=/ E<732/ -8/ D.>/ -:B-;-,-2-=/7.-G2-/--=/YP/-=/LP@<n87.=332/A<<82C/I-2/D-B.>B-=/93=/7-E-/86.,2-:.>B-/;-;-9-=5/.5,<;-:.>B/ ,-2/ --=/ ;-<;834.5@A/ .=4<8,32.-5L52--,/ M34;-B<82/ +R#NC/ !8@).-F/ .5/ E<o=/ +R#PG8<;83,,3J/ 732/ .5/ ;-D86.B2/ <,/ 7-/ ,--2;-;-9-=5/ 2-/ D-B.>B-=C/ V-2/ !8@).-F/ -=/ [email protected]:73389<<8/ <=2F.BB-:7-/ -Y2-=5.-5/ E.>=/ 7-/ ;-;-9-=5/ ;-3=3:L5--87C/ S.>/ 7-/ 3=3:L5-/ 93=,--2;-;-9-=5/ .5/ ;-B-B-=/ =338/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ <=2F.BB-:.=;-=/ 93=/ 7-/ D<7-,/ 8<=7/ 7-D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;5@<[email protected]/ I.-86.2/ D:.>B2/ 732/ 7-/ -8<5.-;32-=/ D-=-7-=528<<,5/ 93=/ 7-@<[email protected]/98.>/523D.-:/E.>=/-=/F-.=.;/4:[email protected]/9-82<=-=/.=/7-/2.>7/-=/8-7-:.>B/@<=523=2/E.>=,-2/ 938.[8-=7-/ 349<-8-=C/ &-/ 5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/ -=/ 7-/ -8<5.-5:-64/ 7338-=2-;-=/ 938.[8-=33=E.-=:.>B/.=/7-/2.>7C/$655-=/7-/349<-8/-=/7-/D<7-,A<<;2-/B<,2/6.2/7-/,--2;-;-9-=5/;--=76.7-:.>B-/ 8-:32.-/ =338/ 9<8-=C/ &-/ ;-9<=7-=/ F3387-=/ ,-2/ D-A6:G/ 93=/ 7-/ 3=3:L5-/ 9<<8/ 7-9-85@A.::-=7-/G8<D:-,-=/7.-=-=/2-9-=5/3:5/.>B.=;/9<<8/7-/5.,6:32.-/,-2/&-:42\&C

0&(+1'$!65"2*$'#,*99$&."&V-2/D-A6:G/93=/--=9<67.;-/3=3:L2.5@A-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/.5/A-2/D<7-,9-8:<<G/.=/7F3858.@A2.=;D-G33:7/-=/9-8;-:-B-=/,-2/7-/;-,.77-:7-/D<7-,:.;;.=;C/$-9-=5/.5/;-B-B-=/=338/7-/.=9:<-793=/ 7-/ D8--72-/ -=/ 33=:-;A<<;2-/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ <G/ 7-/ -8<5.-/ -8=3352C/ &.2/ .5/,-2/ =3,-.=2-8-553=2/D.>/<=7-8/,--8/--=/9-8:-=;.=;/93=/7-/9352-/:33;C

:"+/';:2!$%*+('$"!&-:42\&/ .5/ --=/ F.5B6=7.;/ 5.,6:32.-G8<;83,,3/ 732/ E--8/ ;[email protected]/ .5/ <,/ 7-8;-:.>B-,<84<:<;.5@A-/5.2632.-5/2-/5.,6:-8-=C/$-=/--852-/.5/93=/7-/A6.7.;-/5.2632.-/93=/7-/9352-/:33;--=/G8<2<2LG-P,<7-:/;-,33B2J/732/,-2/D-A6:G/93=/--=/.>B.=;/E</.5/34;-52-:7/732/7-/8-56:232-=6.2/7-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/<9-8--=B<,-=/,-2/7-/D-8-B-=7-/F3387-/6.2/7-/G-.:.=;-=C/'@A2-8/3::--=9<<8/7-/D<@A2/93=/#.=2/!=78.-5J/<,732/7-E-/D<@A2/A-2/,--52/68;-=2/--=/76.7-:.>B-/<G:<55.=;=<7.;/A--42/-=/-8/D.==-=/A-2/2.>75D-52-B/93=/A-2/345267--8<=7-8E<-B/;--=/2.>7/[email protected]/.5;-F--52/9<<8/7-/D<@A2-=/'8:-@<,/-=/Q.>,-;-=C

V-2/ D-A6:G/ 93=/&-:42\&/ E.>=/ -8/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/,<;-:.>B-/ @<[email protected]/ <G:<55.=;-=/ .=/ A-2,<7-:/ .=;-9<-87/ -=/ 7<<8;-8-B-=7C/ &-E-/ D-8-B-=.=;-=/ E.>=/ 6.2;-9<-87/ ,-2/ --=/ @<=523=2-349<-8/ 93=/ ^a11/ ,\X5C/ &-/ D-5@A<6F7-/ @<[email protected]/ <G:<55.=;-=/ E.>=/ <=7-8/ 3=7-8-f9-8:-=;-=/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ M.=/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ 9<8,-=NJ/ 9-8D8-7-=/ -=/ 9-85,3::-=/ &-@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;-=/E.>=/D-B-B-=/2-=/<GE.@A2-/93=/A-2/D3;;-8-=/93=/A-2/5-7.,-=2C/%.27-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/D:--B/732/,-2/=3,-/9-8:-=;-=/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/-=/D3;;-8-=/@CpC/52<82-=/2<27-/ D-52-/ <G:<55.=;-=/ :-.7-=C/ &-/ ,<;-:.>B-/ <G:<55.=;-=/ 3:5/ D<7-,5@A-8,-=/ -=/ 9<82-Y-Y@:67-8/E.>=/.=/7-/9-8;-:.>B-=7-/D-5@A<6F.=;-=/=.-2/,--;-=<,-=C

Page 19: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics Samenvatting 3

<&#",+$&."23",."+$=9$&.23(&2%-."+$=9"2-4+-!!$&."&)3=/ 7-/ <G:<55.=;-=/ D:.>B2/ ;--=/ 93=/ 3::-=/ 7-/ \/ G8<D:-,-=/ 9<::-7.;/ 2-/ 9-8A-:G-=C/ Q3/ 7-2<-25.=;/33=/7-/-.5-=/D:.>42/ -8/--=/33=23:/<G:<55.=;-=/<9-8/F338D.>/9-8:-=;-=/ M7<<8/,.77-:93=/ 9-8:-=;.=;/ <=7-8/ ;-:.>B-/ A<<;2-J/ 9-8:33;7/ 9-8:-=;-=/ <4/ <=7-8/ --=/ 4:36F-8/ 23:67N/ -=D3;;-8-=/@CpC/52<82-=/2<2/7-/<G:<55.=;-=/D-A<8-=C/&-E-/<G:<55.=;-=/E.>=/-9-=--=5/9-8;-:-B-=33=/7-/A3=7/93=/B<52-=C/&-/B<52-=/7.-/;-,33B2/F<87-=/9<<8/D3;;-8-=/-=/52<82-=/B<,-=/-:B>338/2-86;/-=/E.>=/<9-8/c1/>338/9-87--:7/-=/7-/B<52-=/93=/7-/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;-=/E.>=<9-8/ 0/ >338/ 9-87--:7C/ O,/ --=/ 9-8;-:.>B/ 2655-=/ D-.7-/ ,<;-:.>B/ 2-/ ,3B-=/ E.>=/ 93=/ 3::-<G:<55.=;-=/7-/=-22</@<=23=2-/F3387-=/D-8-B-=7C/&-/B-65/93=/7-/;<-7B<<G52-/<G:<55.=;/.5<=7-8/3=7-8-/34A3=B-:.>B/93=/A-2/2-/A3=2-8-=/7.5@<=2<G-8@-=23;-C/S.>/--=/9-83=7-8.=;/93=/7-D3;;-8A<-9--:A-7-=/9-83=7-82/7-/B-6E-/=32668:.>B/<<BC

'-=/9-8:-=;.=;/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/93=/#.=2/!=78.-5/2<2/.=/7-/D<@A2/93=/OG.>=-=/:.>B2/A-2/D-52-8-56:2332/2-/;-9-=/<G/E<F-:/2-@A=.5@A-/3:5/-@<=<,.5@A-/34F-;.=;-=C/&-/9-8:-=;.=;/E3:/73=,<-2-=/D-5233=/6.2/--=/9-8:-=;7-/9-8:3;.=;/<4/<=7-8/--=/4:36F/23:67C/&-E-/@<[email protected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email protected]/9<<8/A-2/-8<5.-;32/ E<o=/ \/ >338/76682C/I-2/F-;D3;;-8-=93=/ 5-7.,-=2/ A--42/ 5:-@A25/ .=9:<-7/ 93=/ B<82-/ 7668/ <G/ 7-/ D6:2C/ &-E-/ -Y283/ 7.-G2-J/ E3:34A3=B-:.>B/93=/7-/A<-9--:A-.7J/D.==-=/@.8@3/-=B-:-/,33=7-=/F--8/E.>=/ 2-86;;-D83@A2/=3387-/[email protected]

Page 20: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

Samenvatting 4 WL | Delft Hydraulics

Page 21: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 1 – 1

1 Inleiding

&.2/ 345267--89-85:3;/ .5/ A-2/ 345267--8F-8B/ 93=/ VCTC/ 93=/ (--=/ =338/ 7-/ qV<84<:<;.5@A-G8<D:-,-=/8<=7/D<@A29-8D-2-8.=;-=/.=/7-/H33:r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`J/ F338/ 7-/ ,3Y.,3:-/ 7.-G2-/ =3352/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ F<872/ D-B-B-=/ ,-2/ --=938.[8-=7-/ 33=:-;A<<;2-/ <4/ D8--72-/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;C/I<<47526B/ c/ ;--42/ 7-/ D-:3=;8.>B52-@<=@:65.-5/F--8/7.-/E.>=/;-28<BB-=/33=/7-/A3=7/93=/3=3:L5-5/93=/D<7-,G-.:.=;-=C

)3=34/A<<47526B/a/.5/[email protected]/;-B-B-=/=338/7-/D<@A2/D.>/#.=2/!=78.-5C/V-2/.=/A<<47526B/a7-/<GE-2/93=/A-2/,<7-:/732/33=/7-/A3=7/93=/--=/.>B.=;/F<872/34;-52-,7/<G/7-/F-8B-:.>BA-.7CR=/ A<<47526B/ d/ F<87-=/ --=/ 33=23:/ ,<;-:.>B-/ <G:<55.=;-=/ D-5@A8-9-=J/ F33893=/ -8/ =3/ --=5-:[email protected]/--=/33=23:/.5/7<<8;-8-B-=7C/&-/,--52/<G2.,3:-/<G:<55.=;/.5/ 2-=5:<22-/;-B<E-=/7<<87-E-/ 34/ 2-/ F-;-=/ 2-=/ <GE.@A2-/ 93=/ E<F-:/ 2-@A=.5@A-/ 3:5/ -@<=<,.5@A-/ 35G-@2-=J/ E<3:5/ .=A<<47526B/e/52332/9-8,-:7C/I-2/9-85:3;/-.=7.;2/,-2/[email protected]/.=/A<<47526B/bJ/,-2/2<2/5:<2/.=A<<47526B/^1/7-/@<=@:65.-5/-=/33=D-9-:.=;C

Q3/7-/.=A<675<G;39-/.5/--=/<9-8E.@A2/;-;-9-=/93=/7-/;-D86.B2-/34B<82.=;-=/-=/5L,D<:-=C

S.>/ 7.2/ A<<479-85:3;/ A<<82/ --=/ 33=23:/ D.>:3;-=J/ <G;-=<,-=/ .=/ --=/ 3G382/ 83GG<82C/ I.-8.=/ .59-8,-:7/F-:B-/;-;-9-=5/E.>=/;-D86.B2/9<<8/7-/3=3:L5-/93=/7-/,-2.=;-=/MD.>:3;-/!N/,-2/7-3=3:L5-/E-:4/MD.>:3;-/'N/-=/7-/,<;-:.>B-/4<62-=/.=/7-/;-D86.B2-/,--2;-;-9-=5/ .=/D.>:3;-/&C$-9-=5/ .5/ .=/ 7-/ D.>:3;-/ =<;/ .=4<8,32.-/ ;-;-9-=/ <9-8/ 7-/ 8-:32.-5/ 2655-=/ 7-/ 9-85@A.::-=7-8-4-8-=2.-9:3BB-=/MD.>:3;-/SN/-=/9-85@A.::-=/2655-=/5.=;:-P/-=/,6:2.D-3,/MD.>:3;-/?NC

&-/ H33:/ D-A<<82/ 2<2/ 7-/ D-:3=;8.>B52-/ 5@A--G93382F-;-=/ 93=/ '68<G3C/ R=/ A-2/ 2F--7-#286@26685@A-,3/)-8B--8/-=/)-89<-8/M#))0N/.5/7-/H33:/3:5/A<<47283=5G<8235/33=;-76.7C/I-2;<-7/B6==-=/46=@2.<=-8-=/93=/7-/H33:/3:5/A<<47283=5G<8235/9<<8/7-/5@A--G93382/F<872/,-2=3,-/ 7<<8/ 7-/ D8--72-/ -=/ 7-/ 7.-G2-/ D-G33:7C/ R=/ ^bb\/ .5/ --=/ =<23/ q$<-B<,529.5.-/ H33:I<<47283=5G<8235r/9-85@A-=-=J/F338.=/--=/9-886.,.=;/93=/7-/H33:/F<872/33=D-9<:-=C/&-E-9-886.,.=;/.5/=<<7E3B-:.>B/<,/7-/;8<-./93=/A-2/5@A--G93382283=5G<82/.=/E<F-:/.=2-=5.2-.2/3:5@[email protected]/86.,2-/2-/D.-7-=C/OG/D35.5/93=/7-/=<23/A--42/7-/,.=.52-8/93=/)-8B--8/-=/H32-852332D-5:<2-=/7-/,.=.,3:-/34,-2.=;-=/93=/7-/9338;-6:/2-/9-8;8<2-=C/R=/^bb`/.5/A-2/E<;-=33,7-H33:G8<;83,,3/93=/52382/;-;33=J/732/2<2/7<-:/A--42/-8/9<<8/2-/E<8;-=/732/7-/H33:/--=/9:<22-J9-.:.;-/-=/-44.@.[=2-/5@A--G933828<62-/D:.>42C/&-/,.=.,3:-/34,-2.=;-=/E.>=/<G/7.2/,<,-=2/--=9338;-6:D8--72-/93=/^c1/,-2-8/D.>/--=/F32-87.-G2-/93=/0Jc1/,-2-8/D.>/O9-8--=;-B<,-=/*3;-(.9.-8523=7/ MO*(NC/ &-E-/ ,<-2-=/ 9<:;-=5/ 7-/ 7<-:52-::.=;/ 93=/ A-2/ H33:G8<>-@2/ F<87-=33=;-G352/ 9<:;-=5/ D-:-.75938.3=2/ RRD/ 6.2/ q$<-B<,529.5.-/ H33:/ I<<47283=5G<8235rC/ I.-8D.>,<-2/--=/9338;-6:D8--72-/93=/^d1/,-2-8/-=/--=/F32-87.-G2-/93=/0Je1/,-2-8/33=F-E.;/E.>=D.>/O*(C/I-2/.5/7-/D-7<-:.=;/732/7-E-/9-8;8<2-/9338;-6:/.=/01^1/B3=/F<87-=/;-;383=7--87C

Page 22: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

1 – 2 WL | Delft Hydraulics

&-/ 9-886.,.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ H33:/ 7.-=2/ 2-/ E<8;-=/ 9<<8/ --=/ 9:<22-8-/ -=/ 9-.:.;-8-9-8B--8534F.BB-:.=;/93=/A-2/5@A--G933829-8B--8C/$-9-=5/E<8;2/7-/9-87.-G.=;/93=/1J\1/,-2-8J2-=/<GE.@A2-/93=/7-/A6.7.;-/P0Jc1/,,k/O*(J/9<<8/--=/9-8:3;.=;/93=/7-/283=5G<82B<52-=C/&-E-9-8:3;.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ 283=5G<82B<52-=/ <=252332/ 7<<8/ 7-/ ;8<2-8-/ 7.-G;3=;J/ 7.-/ 7-/ ,<;-:.>BA-.7D.-72/<,/,--8/983@A2/G-8/93382/,--/2-/B6==-=/=-,-=C/&.2/B3=/<G:<G-=/2<2/--=/9-8:3;.=;/93=7-/283=5G<82B<52-=/93=/0\/2<2/b^/,.:><-=/'68</Mc1/2<2/011/,.:><-=/;6:7-=/34A3=B-:.>B/93=/A-22-/ 9<:;-=/ 5@-=38.<N/ G-8/ >338/ M3:765/ =<23/ RRR/ -.=783GG<823;-/ q$<-B<,529.5.-/ H33:I<<47283=5G<8235rNC

O,/ 33=/ 7-/ ;-52-:7-/ -.5-=/ 2-/ 9<:7<-=/ E.>=/ 9<<8/ 7-/ B=-:G6=2-=/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ ,3328-;-:-=<=2F<8G-=/ME.-/U86.2F3;-=/-=/)3=/7-8/+8334/M^bbdNNC/&.2/B6==-=/<=7-8/3=7-8-/E.>=f/9352-@<[email protected]/ M9352-/ :33;/ <4/ D<7-,B8.DD-=N/ .=/ D<@A2-=/,-2/ 33=96::-=7/ D3;;-8-=C/ &-/ 9352-@<[email protected]/ :-.7-=J/ =3352/ 7-/ 9<<85G-:7-/ 9<<87-:.;-/ 9-85@A.>=5-:-=J/ <<B/ 2<2/ 7-/ 9<<85G-:7-=37-:.;-/9-85@A.>=5-:-=C/R=/7.2/<=7-8E<-B/E3:/3::--=/;-B-B-=/F<87-=/=338/7-/,<84<:<;.5@A--44-@2-=/ <G/ -=/ 8<=7/ 9352-/ :3;-=/ -=/ D<7-,B8.DD-=C/ I-2/ <=7-8E<-B/ E3:/ [email protected]/ <G/ 7-D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;5@<[email protected]/ 93=/ 7-/ D<@A2/ D.>/ '8:-@<,J/ 7-/ D<@A2/ D.>/ Q.>,-;-=/ -=/ 7-D<@A2/D.>/#.=2/!=78.-5/E.>=/;-8.@A2C/$-9-=5/E3:/F<87-=/;-B-B-=/=338/,<;-:.>B/<G:<55.=;-=CR=/7-/D.>:3;-/.5/--=/D-B=<G2-/<,5@A8.>9.=;/93=/B-=,-8B-=/93=/7-/78.-/D<@A2-=/;-;-9-=/F338A-2/<=7-8E<-B/D-28-BB.=;/<G/A--42/-=/--=/[email protected]/<,5@A8.>9.=;/93=/7-/D-=<7.;7-/G:657-/[email protected]/;-;-9-=5C

R=/7-/G83B2.>B/D:.>B2/732/7-E-/,3328-;-:-=/=.-2/E<=7-8/,--8/2<2/7-/;-F-=52-/8-56:232-=/:-.7-=CR=/A-2/;-93:/,-2/7-/9352-/:33;/D.>/Q.>,-;-=J/F35/D.>/7-/33=:-;/7-/7<-:52-::.=;/<,/--=/D8--72-93=/^c1/,-2-8/D.>/--=/7.-G2-/93=/0Jc1/,-2-8/2-/9-8B8.>;-=C/&<<8/--=/33=G355.=;/33=/7-/-.5-=9<:7<-2/ 7-/ D8--72-/ =.-2/,--8C/ &-/ 9352-/ :33;/ D.>/ #.=2/ !=78.-5/ F35/ D-7<-:7/ <,/ ^d1/,-2-8D8--72-/2-/9-8B8.>;-=/D.>/--=/7.-G2-/93=/0Je1/,-2-8C/&-E-/D8--72-/.5/.=/7-/D<@A2/F-:/;-A33:7,338/D-=-7-=528<<,5/>6.52/=.-2/,--8C/)-87-8/D:.>B2/732/A-2/E<;-=33,7-/-.=7-44-@2/93=/9352-:3;-=/-=/D<7-,B8.DD-=/<G/3::-/78.-/7-/ :<@32.-5/<G28--72C/'@A2-8/=.-2/<G/3::-/ :<@32.-5/ .=/7-E-:47-/,32-C/V-2/=3,-/7-/<=2F.BB-:.=;-=/93=/7-/D<7-,/=3/7-/D<@A2/93=/#.=2/!=78.-5/;--427-/=<7.;-/G8<D:-,-=C

R=/7.2/<=7-8E<-B/.5/E<9--:/,<;-:.>B/7-/B.:<,-28-8.=;/33=;-A<67-=/E<3:5/7-E-/:3=;5/7-/H33:;-:72C/&-E-/B.:<,-28-8.=;/D-;.=2/D.>/7-/S<7-=5--/MA-2/V--8/93=/U<=523=ENJ/93=34/F338/7-E-<G:<<G2/ :3=;5/ 7-/ 35/ 93=/ 7-/ 8.9.-8/ 8.@A2.=;/ 7-/ E--C/ U.:<,-2-8/ ecdJaad/ .5/ 7-/ F3387-/ 7.-;-7-4.=.--87/ .5/ 2-8/ A<<;2-/ 93=/7-/ ;8-=5/Q-7-8:3=7P&6.25:3=7C/I.-8/ B<,2/7-/(.>=/ A-2/ --852Q-7-8:3=7/D.==-=J/7-/:.=B-8<-9-8/.5/7338/=<;/&6.25/;8<=7;-D.-7C/$-8/A<<;2-/93=/B.:<,-2-8eacJc^c/.5/<<B/7-/:.=B-8<-9-8/Q-7-8:3=75/;8<=7;-D.-7C

Page 23: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 1 – 3

".;668/^P^f #28<<,;-D.-7/93=/7-/(.>=/,-2/--=/6.25=-7-/93=/Q-7-8:3=7/-=/7-/\/D<@A2-=

Probleemstelling

i<3:5/A.-89<<8/D:--BJ/E.>=/-8/9-85@A.::-=7-/,3328-;-:-=/[email protected]/<,/.=/01^1/33=/7-/-.593=/--=/9338;-6:D8--72-/93=/^d1/,-2-8/,-2/--=/F32-87.-G2-/93=/0Je1/,-2-8/2-/9<:7<-=C/!3=7-E-/,3328-;-:-=/E.22-=/-@A2-8/<<B/=-9-=-44-@2-=/7.-/2<2/A.=7-8/<4/G8<D:-,-=/B6==-=/:-.7-=CR=/7.2/<=7-8E<-B/F<872/--=/78.-23:/:<@32.-5/D-B-B-=J/=3,-:.>B/M.=/528<<,34F33825-/8.@A2.=;Nf7-/D<@A2/D.>/'8:-@<,J/7-/D<@A2/D.>/Q.>,-;-=/-=/7-/D<@A2/D.>/#.=2/!=78.-5J/E.-/".;668/^P^CM9<<8233=/ 5.,G-:F-;/ 33=;-76.7/ 3:5/ [email protected]:.>B/ '8:-@<,J/ Q.>,-;-=/ -=/ #.=2/ !=78.-5NC)<<8/--=/[email protected]/D-5@A8.>9.=;/E.-/A<<47526B/0J/S-5@A8.>9.=;/93=/7-/D<@A2-=C

!::-/78.-/7-/D<@A2-=/9-82<=-=/D-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/7-/D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;/--=/-8<5.-;32/ .=7-/D6.2-=D<@A2/-=/33=E3=7.=;/.=/7-/D.==-=D<@A2C/&-E-/9-85@A.>=5-:-=/;-9-=/G8<D:-,-=/9<<87-/D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;J/[email protected]:.>B/9<<8/7-/93387.-G2-/D.>/7-/9-8-.52-/D8--72-C/R=/7-/D<@A2D.>/ '8:-@<,/ .5/ ;-D86.B/ ;-,33B2/ 93=/ D<7-,B8.DD-=s/ F3387<<8/ 7-/ F32-87.-G2-/ .=/ 7-D6.2-=D<@A2/ 2655-=/7-/D<7-,B8.DD-=/;8<2-8/ .5C/&-/7.-G2-/ 2655-=/7-/D<7-,B8.DD-=/ .5/ .=/7-:<<G/93=/7-/2.>7/34;-=<,-=C/7<<8732/-8/5-7.,-=2/.5/34;-E-2/ME<3:5/9-8F3@A2/.5NC

Page 24: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

1 – 4 WL | Delft Hydraulics

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

#3,-=9322-=7/.5/-8/<G/-:B/93=/7-E-/78.-/:<@32.-5/--=/78.-23:/G8<D:-,-=/2-/<[email protected]=C/&-78.-/G8<D:-,-=/7.-/E.@A/9<<87<-=/E.>=/<G/2-/5G:.25-=/ .=/G8<D:-,-=/,-2/ 2-@A=.5@A-/<<8E33BM7-/--852-/2F--N/-=/;-9<:;-=/A.-893=/M7-/7-87-NC

^C/ &-/D<7-,/D-=-7-=528<<,5/ -=X<4/ 2-8/ A<<;2-/ 93=/7-/ D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;/ :.;2/ M2-N/ A<<;JF32/M,<;-:.>BN/:-.72/2<2/<=7.-G2-5C

0C/ Q3352/ -=X<4/ 3@A2-8/ 7-/ D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;/ 28--72/ -8<5.-/ <GJ/ F32/ M,<;-:.>BN/ :-.72/ 2<2.=523D.:.2-.2/ -=/ 9-89<8,.=;J/F32/F--8/ B3=/ :-.7-=/ 2<2/,.=7-8/ ;<-7/ 46=@2.<=-8-=/ 93=/ 7-D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;C

\C/ '8/ .5/;--=/76.7-:.>BA-.7/<4/--=/@<[email protected]/73=/F-:/--=/=.-2/@<[email protected]/,3328-;-:E<8;2/ 9<<8/ 7-/ ,--52/ -44.@.[=2-/ -=/ ,--52/ [email protected]/ <G:<55.=;J/ F32/ :-.72/ 2<2<=76.7-:.>BA-.7/2-=/33=E.-=/93=/7-/-44.@.[=2.-/93=/A-2/A6.7.;-/D3;;-8-=C

Doelstelling

&-/G8.,3.8-/7<-:52-::.=;/93=/7.2/<=7-8E<-BJ/7.-/9<:;2/6.2/7-/G8<D:--,52-::.=;J/:6.72/3:5/9<:;2f

-. OG:<55.=;-=/ 33=783;-=/ F338,--/ 7-/ ,<84<:<;.5@A-/ G8<D:-,-=/ 7.-/ <G28-7-=/ D.>D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;/.=/7-/78.-/D<@A2-=/A-2/D-52/F<87-=/9-8A<:G-=J/9<<8/E<F-:/2-@A=.5@A-3:5/-@<=<,.5@A/35G-@2-=C

Q3352/7-/G8.,3.8-/7<-:52-::.=;/.5/=<;/--=/33=23:/56DP/-=/=-9-=7<-:52-::.=;-=/7.-/93=/D-:3=;E.>=/<,/7-/G8.,3.8-/7<-:52-::.=;/2-/A3:-=f

-. S-G3:-=/F-:B-/G383,-2-85/7-/,--52-/.=9:<-7/A-DD-=/<G/7-E-/G8<D:-,-=s-. !=3:L5-/93=/7-/,<;-:.>BA-7-=/7.-/:-.7-=/2<2/7-/;-@<=5232--87-/G8<D:-,-=s-. $.>75@A3:-=/93=/7-/,<84<:<;.5@A-/G8<D:-,-=/D-G3:-=s-. S-G3:-=/F32/7-/-44-@2-=/E.>=/93=/,<;-:.>B-/<G:<55.=;-=s-. !4F-;.=;/93=/7-/,<;-:.>B-/<G:<55.=;/p63/F-8B.=;J/-44-@2-=/-=/B<52-=C

Page 25: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 1 – 5

Probleemafbakening

&-/@<,G:-Y.2-.2/93=/7-/,<84<:<;.5@A-/G8<D:-,-=/E<8;2/9<<8/--=/=<<7;-7F<=;-=/D-G-8B.=;93=/ A-2/ <=7-8E<-BC/ &.2/ <=7-8E<-B/ .5/ .=/ A-2/ B37-8/ 93=/ 345267--8F-8B/ 33=/ 7-/ $-@A=.5@A-%=.9-85.2-.2/&-:42/6.2;-9<-87/-=/A--42/<,/7.-/8-7-=/73=/--=/D-G-8B2-/2.>757668/93=/<=;-9--8--=/A3:4/>338J/F338D.==-=/A-2/<=7-8E<-B/,<-2/F<87-=/9-88.@A2C/V-7-/7<<8/7-E-/D-G-8B.=;/-=7<<8/ A-2/ D-F652/ .=G-8B-=/ 93=/ 7-/ @<,G:-Y-/ G8<D:-,32.-B/ .5/ --=/ 33=23:G8<D:--,34D3B-=.=;-=/;-7-4.=.--87f

-. I-2/<=7-8E<-B/B.>B2/3::--=/=338/7-/D<@A2-=/'8:-@<,J/Q.>,-;-=/-=/#.=2/!=78.-5J/F338D.>3::--=/7-/7.8-@2-/<,;-9.=;/F<872/,--;-=<,-=s

-. !:5/ 7.8-@2-/ <,;-9.=;/ F<872/ A-2/ ;-A-:-/ ;-D.-7/ 2655-=/ 7-/ D3=7.>B-=/ .=/ D-5@A<6F.=;;-=<,-=s

-. &-/ <G:<55.=;/F<872/ =.-2/ ;-E<@A2/ .=/ A-2/ 9-8:-;;-=/ 93=/ 7-/ 8.9.-8J/ D-A3:9-/ <G/ E<73=.;-F.>E-/732/7.2/,<;-:.>B/ .5/ D.==-=/7-/ D-5233=7-/ :33;F32-8D-7G8<4.:-8.=;C/&.2/ .=/ 9-8D3=7,-2/,.:.-62-@A=.5@A-/D-G-8B.=;-=s

-. &-/ ;-9<:;-=/ 93=/ 33=G355.=;-=/ -=/ 9-8G:3325.=;-=/ 93=/ 7-/ 9338;-6:/ F<87-=/ =.-2,--;-=<,-=s

-. '8/F<87-=/;--=/<G:<55.=;-=/;-E<@A2/D6.2-=/D-:-.75938.3=2/RRD/6.2/q$<-B<,529.5.-/H33:I<<47283=5G<8235rJ/732/F.:/E-;;-=/--=/9338D33=D8--72-/93=/^d1/,-2-8/D.>/--=/7.-G2-/93=0Je1/,-2-8s

-. &-/,<;-:.>BA-.7/93=/--=/:.=-3.8-/3=3:L5-/93=/7-/[email protected]/2655-=/7-/5-7.,-=2D-F-;.=;-=/ F32-8D-F-;.=;/ F<872/ <=7-8E<@A2s/ .=7.-=/ ,<;-:.>B/ F<872/ 7-E-/ 3=3:L5-/ .=/ --=2.>7D-52-B/93=/,3Y.,33:/--=/,33=7/6.2;-F-8B2s

-. U8.D93BG8<@-55-=/93::-=/D6.2-=/7.2/<=7-8E<-B/-=/E6::-=/=.-2/F<87-=/6.2;-E<@A2s-. '8/F<872/ .=/A-2/<=7-8E<-B/6.2;-;33=/93=/--=/O*!/ M<9-8--=;-B<,-=/ :33;F32-8/349<-8N

93=/be`/,\X5s-. &-/ :.;;.=;/93=/7-/ D<@A2-=/ .=/ 7-/ 8.9.-8/ M3::-/ 78.-/ 7-/ D<@A2-=/ E.>=/ 8-@A25-/ D<@A2-=N/ -=

-9-=26-:-/ .=9:<-7-=/93=/7-/ B-65/ 93=/7-/ 5@A--G93382/ <,/ .=/ 7-/ <GP/ <4/ 3493382/ 7<<8/ 7-D.==-=/73=/F-:/7<<8/7-/D6.2-=D<@A2/ 2-/938-=/M.=/9-8D3=7/,-2/-44-@2/7<<8/8-2<68528<<,<G/7-/D<7-,N/E.>=/A.-8/;--=/<=7-8F-8G/93=/<=7-8E<-BC

Page 26: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

1 – 6 WL | Delft Hydraulics

Page 27: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 2 – 1

2 Morfologische bochtverschijnselen

2.1 Inleiding

R=/7.2/A<<47526B/F<872/D-B=<G2/7-/528<,.=;/-=/7-/,<84<:<;.-/D-A3=7-:7/93=/--=/3::69.3:-8.9.-8C/&-E-/D-5@A8.>9.=;-=/E.>=/-9-=--=5/2-86;/2-/9.=7-=/.=/9-85@A.::-=7-/:.2-832668D8<==-=ME<3:5/ &-/ )8.-=7/ M0111NJ/ #286.B5,3/ M^bbdN/ -=/ T3=5-=/ M^bdbNNs/ -@A2-8J/ -=.;-3@A2-8;8<=7.=4<8,32.-/ 93=/ 7-/ ,<84<:<;.5@A-/ 9-85@A.>=5-:-=/ .5/ F-=5-:.>B/ D.>/ A-2/ :-E-=/ -=D-;8.>G-=/93=/A-2/ 9-85:3;/ -=/ .5/ 7-8A3:9-/ <G;-=<,-=C/ R=/ G383;8334/ 0C0/ .5/ --=/ D-5@A8.>9.=;;-;-9-=/93=/7-/528<,.=;/.=/--=/D<@A2/93=/--=/3::69.3:-/8.9.-8C/)-89<:;-=5/F<872/.=/G383;83340C\/D-5@A8-9-=/F32/7-/;-9<:;-=/E.>=/93=/9-83=7-8.=;-=/<G/7-/D<7-,/.=/@<,D.=32.-/,-2/7-528<,.=;/-=/7-/7338D.>/53,-=A3=;-=7-/,<84<:<;.5@A-/33=G355.=;-=C

2.2 Bocht zonder bodembescherming

R=/3::69.3:-/,-3=7-8-=7-/8.9.-8-=/9-83=7-82/7-/9<8,/93=/7-/8.9.-8/-=/765/7-/D<7-,/@<=2.=6C$-;-=F<<87.;/.5/9<<8/7-/,--52-/D<@A2-=/M.=/.-7-8/;-93:/7-/D-5@A<6F7-/D<@A2-=N/7-/:.;;.=;93=/7-/8.9.-8/E<73=.;/9352;-:-;7/732/7-E-/E.@A/=.-2/,--8/9-8G:33252s/-@A2-8J/7-/D<7-,/93=/7-8.9.-8/D:.>42/9-83=7-8:.>BC/I-2/D<7-,9-8:<<G/E3:/.=/--=/D<@A2/--=/7F385A-::.=;/33==-,-=/,-2A-2/7.-G52-/G6=2/.=/7-/D6.2-=D<@A2/-=/--=/<=7.-G-8/7--:/ .=/7-/D.==-=D<@A2C/&.2/=32668:.>B-G8<@-5/F<872/9-8<<8E33B2/7<<8/7-/5G.833:528<,.=;/7.-/<9-8/7-/D<7-,/=338/7-/D.==-=D<@A2/.5;-8.@A2J/E.-/".;668/0P^P4C

S-B=<G2/D-5@A8-9-=/B<,2/7-/<=2F.BB-:.=;/93=/7-/ 5G.833:528<<,/<G/7-/ 9<:;-=7-/F.>E-/ 2<2523=7/ME.-/".;668/0P^Nf

3N/ &<<8/ 7-/ ,.77-:G6=29:.-7-=7-/ 5@A.>=B83@A2/ 7<<8/ 7-/ ;-B8<,7-/ 528<,.=;/ F<872/ A-2F32-8/=338/7-/D6.2-=D<@A2/2<-;-786B2C/&.2/:-.72/-82<-/732/7-/F32-85G.-;-:/=338/D6.2-=2<-/<G:<<G2/M9-8;-:.>BD338/,-2/A-2/8<-8-=/.=/--=/B<G>-/B<44.-Ns

DN/ &<<8732/A-2/F32-8/.=/7-/D6.2-=D<@A2/--=/A<;-8/=.9-36/A--42/.5/7-/AL78<5232.5@A-/786B.=/7-/D6.2-=D<@A2/;8<2-8/73=/.=/7-/D.==-=D<@A2s

@N/ &-/ ,.77-:G6=29:.-7-=7-/ B83@A2/ A3=;2/ 53,-=/ ,-2/ 7-/ 528<<,5=-:A-.7/ -=/ .5/ =.-26=.4<8,/<9-8/7-/9-82.@33:/9-87--:7J/,338/.5/,3Y.,33:/33=/7-/F32-85G.-;-:/-=/=6:/33=7-/D<7-,s

7N/ &-/8-56:2-8-=7-/AL78<5232.5@A-/786B;837.[=2/.5/6=.4<8,/9-87--:7/<9-8/7-/9-82.@33:/C/R=@<,D.=32.-/,-2/7-/=.-2P6=.4<8,/9-87--:7-/@-=28.46;33:B83@A2/<=252332/-8/--=/;:<D33:M732/F.:/E-;;-=/;-,.77-:7-/<9-8/7-/9-82.@33:N/-9-=F.@A2s

-N/ S-.7-/B83@A2-=/D.>/-:B338/<G;-2-:7/MF338D.>/7-/@-=28.46;33:B83@A2/=338/7-/D6.2-=D<@A2.5/;-8.@A2/-=/ 7-/ 8-56:2-8-=7-/AL78<5232.5@A-/B83@A2/ =338/ 7-/ D.==-=D<@A2N/ :-9-82/ --=B83@A259-87-:.=;/ <G/ 7.-/ <G/ 7-/ D<7-,/ =338/ 7-/ D.==-=D<@A2/ .5/ ;-8.@A2/ -=/ 33=/ A-2F32-8<GG-89:3B/=338/7-/D6.2-=D<@A2s

4N/ &<<8/7-/ 8-56:2-8-=7-/5G3==.=;59-85@A.::-=/33=/7-/D<9-=/ -=/<=7-8B3=2/ <=252332/ [email protected]@6:32.-528<,.=;/ .=/ 7-/ 7F3858.@A2.=;J/ 53,-=/,-2/ 7-/ :3=;5528<,.=;/ 7<<8/ 7-/ D<@A2<=252332/-8/3:5/A-2/F38-/--=/5G.833:9<8,.;-/528<,.=;J/E.-/".;668/0P0C

Page 28: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

2 – 2 WL | Delft Hydraulics

3N/,.77-:G6=29:.-7-=7-/B83@A2 DN/AL78<5232.5@A-/786B9-87-:.=; @N/9-82.@3:-/9-87-:.=;/93=/7-////,.77-:G6=2/9:.-7-=7-/B83@A2

7N/8-56:2-8-=7-////5G3==.=;59-87-:.=;-=

-N/;-5<,,--87-/5G3==.=; 4N/5G.833:528<,.=;

".;668/0P^f O=2F.BB-:.=;/7F3859-8A3=;/.=/--=/D<@A2

&-/,32-/F338.=/93=/7-/ 5G.833:528<,.=;/7-/9<::-7.;-/<=2F.BB-:7-/ 2<-523=7/D-=37-87/A3=;2<=7-8/3=7-8/34/93=/7-/:-=;2-/93=/7-/D<@A2C/&-/D<@A2/,<-2/--=/E<73=.;-/:-=;2-/A-DD-=/732/7-5G.833:528<<,/ E.@A/ B3=/ <=2F.BB-:-=s/ .=/ 7.-/ -.=72<-523=7/ 5G8-B-=/ F-/ 73=/ 93=/ --=/ 3Y.33:P5L,,-28.5@A-/528<,.=;J/732/F.:/E-;;-=/732/-8/;--=/9-83=7-8.=;/93=/A-2/528<<,D--:7/<G28--72.=/7-/:3=;58.@A2.=;/93=/7-/D<@A2C/!Y.33:P5L,,-28.5@A-/528<,.=;/E<6/<G28-7-=/.=/--=/D<@A293=/<=-.=7.;-/:-=;2-C

".;668/0P0f #G.833:528<,.=;/MUC/Q6L2-=N

Page 29: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 2 – 3

&-/ 5G.833:528<<,/ 33=/ 7-/ D<7-,/ :<<G2/ 93=/ 7-/ D6.2-=D<@A2/ =338/ 7-/ D.==-=D<@A2C/ S.>/ --=3::69.3:-/ D<7-,/ <=252332/ 73387<<8/ --=/ [email protected]==.=;/ <G/ A-2/ 5-7.,-=2/ 7.-/ =338/ 7-D.==-=D<@A2/.5/;-8.@A2C/&-E-/[email protected]==.=;/F<872/2-;-=;-F-8B2/7<<8732/7-/D-F-;.=;/93=--=/5-7.,-=2B<88-:/F<872/;-A.=7-87/7<<8/A-2/<,:.;;-=7-/,32-8.33:C/S.>/ --=/E<73=.;/;8<[email protected]==.=;/ 732/ 7-E-/ F--8523=7/ F<872/ <9-8F<==-=J/ F<872/ 7.2/ =338/ 7-/ D.==-=D<@A2;-283=5G<82--87C/I-2/5-7.,-=2/A<<G2/E.@A/.=/7-/D.==-=D<@A2/<GJ/<,732/A-2/=.-2/F-;/B3=/.=7F3858.@A2.=;C/ I.-87<<8/ <=252332/ --=/ =338/ 7-/ D.==-=D<@A2/ <G:<G-=7-/ D<7-,A-::.=;C/ &-E-7F385A-::.=;/E<8;2/9<<8/--=/-Y283/B83@A2/<G/A-2/5-7.,-=2/:3=;5/7-/A-::.=;/=338/D-=-7-=/M=3387-/D6.2-=D<@A2NC/!:5/7-/[email protected]==.=;/7<<8/7-/33=78.>9-=7-/5G.833:528<,.=;/.=/-9-=F.@A2/.5,-2/ 7-/ [email protected]==.=;/ 93=/ A-2/ 5-7.,-=2/ :3=;5/ 7-/ A-::.=;/ .5/ -8/ 5G83B-/ 93=/ -9-=F.@A2MF--8;-;-9-=/.=/4<8,6:-P9<8,J/E.-/4<8,6:-/`C^0NC/R=/3::69.3:-/8.9.-8-=/,-2/938.[8-=7-/349<-8.5/ 7-E-/ [email protected]/ 765/ -9-=--=5/ 938.[8-=7C/ &-/ 2.>7/ 7.-/ =<7.;/ .5/ 9<<8/ A-2/ 2<2-9-=F.@A2/ B<,-=/93=/7-/ D<7-,/ .5/ 528-B/ 34A3=B-:.>B/ 93=/7-/ 349<-8/ -=/ 7-/ <,93=;/ 93=/ 7-9-852<8.=;C/ '8/ .5/ A.-8D.>/ 5G83B-/ 93=/ --=/ A-852-:2.>7/ 93=/ -=B-:-/ ,33=7-=/ 2<2/ -=B-:-/ >38-=C)-87-8/ 28-7-=/ =<;/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ 3=7-8-/ 9-852<8.=;-=/ <GJ/ E<3:5/ D.>9<<8D--:7/ 7<<88-2<68528<<,/93=/5@A--G93382J/D3;;-8F-8BE33,A-7-=/-=/7-/.=9:<-7/93=/B8.DD-=C)-852<8.=;-=/ 7.-/ A-2/ =32668:.>B-/ <=;-52<<87-/ 9-8:<<G/ 93=/ A-2/ 7F3859-8A3=;/ D-W=9:<-7-=F<87-=/ -@A2-8/ <<B/ 7<-:D-F652/ 33=;-:-;7/ <,/ >6.52/ --=/ 7.-G-8-/ D.==-=D<@A2/ 2-/ @8-[8-=C)<<8D--:7-=/ A.-893=/ E.>=/ --=/ 9352-/ :33;/ <4/ D<7-,B8.DD-=J/ E<3:5/ D-5@A8-9-=/ 52332/ .=G383;8334/0C\C

2.3 Bocht met bodembescherming

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email protected]/ E-:4/ --=/D-:-,,-8.=;9<<8/ 7-/ 5@A--G93382/ 9<8,-=C/ &<<8/ A-2/ 2<-G355-=/ 93=/ D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;/ F<872/ --=5<<82;-:.>B/8-56:2332/3:5/,-2/D3;;-8-=/9-8B8-;-=J/-@A2-8/93=/D:.>9-=7-/3387/7<<8/9-83=7-8.=;93=/ A-2/ -9-=F.@A2C/ &-/ D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;/ B3=/ <G/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ ,3=.-8-=/ F<87-=33=;-:-;7s/ 7-/ .=/ 7.2/ <=7-8E<-B/ D-B-B-=/ @<[email protected]/ D-G-8B-=/ E.@A/ 2<2/ --=/ 9352-/ :33;/ <4D<7-,B8.DD-=C

Vaste laag

'-=/9352-/:33;/B3=/D-5233=/6.2/D.>9<<8D--:7/ :<5/;-52<82/,32-8.33:J/93=/E<73=.;/4<8,332/@CpC;-F.@A2/ 732/ A-2/,32-8.33:/ D:.>42/ :.;;-=/ -=/ 765/ 2-=/ <GE.@A2-/ 93=/ A-2/ F32-8/ 9352/ :.;2/ <G/ 7-D<7-,C

Page 30: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

2 – 4 WL | Delft Hydraulics

".;668/0P\f/)352-/:33;/MUC/Q6L2-=N

R=/ --=/ <=9-852<<87-/ 5.2632.-J/ E<=7-8/ 9352-/ :33;J/ E<6/ 7-/ D6.2-=D<@A2/ E.@A/ 9-87.-G-=/ -=/ 7-D.==-=D<@A2/9-8<=7.-G-=C/&<<8/7-/9352-/:33;/B3=/7-/D6.2-=D<@A2/=.-2/,--8/7.-G-8/F<87-=/-=7338,--/ .5/ 7-/ 7.-G2-/ .=/ 7-/ D6.2-=D<@A2/ 9352;-:-;7C/ I-2/ 9352:-;;-=/ 93=/ 7-/ A<<;2-/ .=/ 7-D6.2-=D<@A2J/E<8;2/9<<8/--=/9-8B:-.=.=;/93=/A-2/AL7836:.5@A-/G8<4.-:/-=/7338,--/--=/A<;-8-528<<,5=-:A-.7C/&<<8/7-E-/A<;-8-/528<<,5=-:A-.7/28--72/-8<5.-/<GJ/-@A2-8/.=/7-/D6.2-=D<@A2.5/ 7.2/ =.-2/,<;-:.>B/ 93=F-;-/7-/ 9352-/ :33;C/ R=/ 7-/ D.==-=D<@A2/ .5/ -8<5.-/ -@A2-8/ =<;/ 52--75,<;-:.>BJ/F3387<<8/ 7-/ D<7-,/7338/ E3:/ -8<7-8-=/ -=/73:-=C/Q3352/ A-2/ 9-8B:-.=7-/<GG-89:3B93=/7-/D6.2-=D<@A2/.5/7-/86FA-.7/MD.>/;-D86.B/93=/52<8252--=N/2<-;-=<,-=/D.>/7-/D<@A2/93=Q.>,-;-=/-=/#.=2/!=78.-5/-=/ E3:/ -8/ 73387<<8/ -9-=--=5/,.=7-8/F32-8/ 7<<8/ 7-/ D6.2-=D<@A2528<,-=/ -=/,--8/ 7<<8/ 7-/ D.==-=D<@A2/ M,-2/ --=/ A<;-8-/ 5=-:A-.7/ -=/ 765/,--8/ -8<5.-NC/ $-8G:3325-/93=/7-/9352-/ :33;/ .5/;--=/5-7.,-=2/<G/ 2-/=-,-=/ .=/7-/D6.2-=D<@A2C/I.-87<<8/ .5/ 7-5-@6=73.8-/ 528<,.=;J/ 2-=/;-9<:;-/93=/7-/D<@A2J/<=9-8E37.;7/,-2/ 5-7.,-=2C/&-E-/ 528<,.=;B3=/<G/7-/9352-/:33;/;--=/5-7.,-=2/<G=-,-=/M<,732/A-2/=.-2/33=F-E.;/.5NJ/-8<5.-/E3:/765/G35<G28-7-=/<G/7-/ G:3325/F338/ 5-7.,-=2/ <G;-=<,-=/ B3=/F<87-=J/F32/ .=/ 7-/ D.==-=D<@A2/ A-2;-93:/ .5C/ &65/ 7<<8/ A-2/ 33=:-;;-=/ 93=/ --=/ 9352-/ :33;J/ A-2/ 9-8A<;-=/ 93=/ 7-/ D6.2-=D<@A2J-8<7--82/7-/D<7-,/93=/7-/D.==-=D<@A2/ME.-/".;668/0P\NC

&-/9352-/:33;/A--42/765/7-/9<:;-=7-/B-=,-8B-=f

-. 9352:-;;-=/93=/7-/D<7-,/.=/7-/D6.2-=D<@A2s-. 9-8B:-.=-=/<GG-89:3B2-/7F385G8<4.-:s-. 9-8A<;.=;/93=/7-/86FA-.7/MD.>/Q.>,-;-=/-=/#.=2/!=78.-5Ns-. D-W=9:<-7.=;/93=/A-2/D<7-,283=5G<82C

O9-8.;-/-44-@2-=f-. <G526F.=;s-. .=9:<-7/<G/D<7-,73:.=;/M8-,,-=7/D<9-=528<<,5J/9-852-8B-=7/D-=-7-=528<<,5NC

Page 31: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 2 – 5

Q37-:.;-/ -44-@2-=/ 93=/ --=/ 9352-/ :33;/ E.>=/ <=7-8/ 3=7-8-/ <G526F.=;/ 93=/ A-2/ F32-8J/ F32/ D.>A<;-/ 349<-8G.-B-=/ =37-:.;-/ ;-9<:;-=/ B3=/ A-DD-=C/ '-=/ 3=7-8/ =37-:.;/ -44-@2/ .5/ 7-D<7-,73:.=;/D-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/ME.-/$33:J/^bb`NC/*<B33:/E.>=/-8/ME<3:5/D.>/7-G8<D:--,52-::.=;/F-87/9-8,-:7N/--=/33=23:/=37-:.;-/-44-@2-=/F338/ 2-/ =-,-=J/ =3,-:.>Bf/ M^N-8<5.-5:-64/=3352/7-/9352-/:33;J/M0N/-8<5.-;32/-=/M\N/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/D-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/7-9352-/:33;C

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`C

".;668/0P`f ][email protected]@A-25J/D<9-=33=E.@A2/;8-=5/9352-/:33;/-=/3::69.3:-/7--:

I.-87<<8/B3=/7-/D<7-,/F<87-=/6.2;-5@A6687/2<2/<=7-8/7-/<=7-8B3=2/93=/7-/@<[email protected]/&.2B3=/ ;-9338/ 9<<8/ 7-/ 523D.:.2-.2/ ,-2/ E.@A/ ,--D8-=;-=J/ A<-F-:/ 732/ =<;/ =.-2/ ,-2--=/ [email protected]:.-5/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/A<-42/2-/D-2-B-=-=/<9-8/,.=7-8/73=/^1/,/D8--72-/ME.-/$3=B^bbe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

!::69.33:

%9: %3::69.33:

)352-/:33;

)-82.@3:-/F-89-:5

+:37(6F

Page 32: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

2 – 6 WL | Delft Hydraulics

Bodemkribben

S<7-,B8.DD-=/A-DD-=/--=/5<<82;-:.>B/-44-@2/3:5/--=/9352-/:33;J/,338/.=/,.=7-8-/,32-C/I-2/.53:5/A-2/F38-/--=/<=7-8D8<B-=/9352-/:33;J/E.-/".;668/0PcC/'-=/9-85@A.:/2655-=/D<7-,B8.DD-=-=/ --=/ 9352-/ :33;/ .5/ 732/ D<7-,B8.DD-=/ 7-/ 8.@A2.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ 5G.833:528<<,/ D-W=9:<-7-=C/ &-D<7-,B8.DD-=/ F<87-=/ E</ ;-G:33252/ 732/ 7-E-/ 2-;-=/ 7-/ D<7-,528<,.=;58.@A2.=;/ .=/ 5233=sA.-87<<8/F<872/ A-2/ E3=7283=5G<82/ <9-8/ 7-/ D<7-,/93=/7-/ D6.2-=D<@A2/ =338/ 7-/ D.==-=D<@A2;-7--:2-:.>B/2-;-=;-A<67-=C&-/F-8B.=;/D-8652/,-2/=3,-/<G/M#F3=-=D-8;/^bb^Nf

-. D-W=9:<-7.=;/528<<,G8<4.-:s-. D-W=9:<-7.=;/5G.833:528<<,s-. D-W=9:<-7.=;/8.@A2.=;/93=/A-2/D<7-,283=5G<82C

&-/ F-8B.=;/ 93=/ D<7-,B8.DD-=/ .5/ ,.=7-8/ 73=/ 7.-/ 93=/ --=/ 9352-/ :33;J/ F3387<<8/ 7-D.==-=D<@A2/,.=7-8/9-8:33;2/-=/7338,--/7-/8.9.-8/,.=7-8/9-8D8--7C/I.-82-;-=<9-8/52332/7327-/B<52-=/93=/D<7-,B8.DD-=/:3;-8/E.>=/.=/9-8;-:.>B.=;/,-2/7.-/93=/--=/9352-/:33;/-=/732/7-7.,-=5.-5/93=/7-/-.=79-85@A.>=5-:-=J/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/-=/-8<5.-;32J/B:-.=-8/E.>=C

".;668/0Pcf S<7-,B8.DD-=/MUC/Q6L2-=N

Page 33: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 3 – 1

3 Beschrijving van de bochten

3.1 Inleiding

&-/78.-/ D<@A2-=/7.-/ .=/ 7.2/ <=7-8E<-B/F<87-=/ <=7-8E<@A2/ E.>=/ .=/ 528<<,34F33825-/ 8.@A2.=;'8:-@<,/ MB.:<,-2-8833./ MB,8CNC/ ed\J0/ P/ edaJ1NJ/ Q.>,-;-=/ MB,8C/ ee\J1/ P/ eecJ1N/ -=/ #.=2!=78.-5/ MB,8C/ b0cJ1/ P/ b0eJ0NC/ &-E-/ 78.-/ D<@A2-=/ F<87-=/ D-B-B-=/ <,732/ .=/ 3::-/ 78.-@<[email protected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beeNJ/e>338/:32-8/9-89<:;-=5/7-/D<7-,B8.DD-=/.=/'8:-@<,/M;-8--7/.=/^bbaJ/G8<-4/.=/^beb/P/^bb1N/-=\/,33=7-=/=3/7-/<G:-9-8.=;/93=/'8:-@<,/.5/D-;<==-=/,-2/7-/33=:-;/93=/7-/9352-/ :33;/ .=#.=2/!=78.-5/M;-8--7/.=/^bbbNC/!::-/78.-/7-/D<@A2-=/E.>=/D<@A2-=/=338/8-@A25/M;-B-B-=/.=/7-G<5.2.-9-/8.@A2.=;/<9-8/7-/35J/528<<,34F33825NJ/,338/F-:/,-2/9-85@A.::-=7-/D<<;5283:-=C/I-28.9.-89-8:<<G/ 9<<8/ -=/ 3@A2-8/ 7-/ D<@A2-=/ 9-85@A.:2/ -9-=--=5/ 93=/ -:B338C/ &-/ <,93=;/ 93=G8<D:-,-=/,-2/D-28-BB.=;/2<2/-8<5.-/-=/5-7.,-=232.-/.5/3=7-85/p63/;8<<22-J/,338/7-/3387/93=7-/ G8<D:-,-=/ .5/ 9-8;-:.>BD338C/ R=/ $3D-:/ \P^/ .5/ 93=/ 7-/ 78.-/ D<@A2-=/ --=/ 33=23:/ ;-;-9-=5<G;-=<,-=/,-2/9-8,-:7.=;/93=/7-/D8<=C/Q.-2/3::-/F3387-=/E.>=/9-8,-:7/-=/7-/F3387-=/7.-E.>=/9-8,-:7J/E.>=/34B<,52.;/6.2/--=/5-:-@2/33=23:/;-D86.B2-/:.2-832668/-=/.5/7338,--/<<B/=.-29<::-7.;C/&-/F3387-=/;-9-=/F-:/--=/.=786B/F32/7-/7.,-=5.-5/D-28-42/-=/;-9-=/-9-=--=5/7-7.9-85.2-.2/33=/F338,--/A-2E-:47-/F<872/D-5@A8-9-=/.=/7-/:.2-832668C

Page 34: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

3 – 2 WL | Delft Hydraulics

J8$@A-"#'")+ R-1.@58 S"#8.+.) 6")%&2);-".$

+.+.'.)$ 0-5) +.+.'.)$ 0-5) +.+.'.)$ 0-5)

5<<82/D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=; D<7-,PB8.DD-=

9352-/:33; 9352-/:33;

33=:-;G-8.<7- ^bb`P^bba ^beaP^bee H<:2-85 ^bbdP^bbb '-87-=t1^

33=23: c`/AC<CACc1Pa1,

$-8F-:/tbe ^ ^

D-;.=/B.:<,-28-8.=;/jB,k ed\J^dc U<<L/tbd ee\J/^e U33.>/tb` b0cJ1 '-87-=t1^

-.=7/B.:<,-28-8.=;/jB,k edaJ1 U<<L/tbd eecJ^ U33.>/tb` b0eJ0 '-87-=t1^

b0eJ^ H.:D-85o11

,.=C/7.-G2-/@<[email protected]<9/S()^/j,k

\Jc1 ?!&P2-BC':5@A<2/tb`

/\Jc1 ?!&P2-BC$A.-:B.=;t11

\Jc1 '-87-=t1^

:-=;2-/@<[email protected]/j,k 0e0c 37A9/U<<Lobd

0111 37A9/U33.>tb`

\^1^J\a '-87-=t1^

D8--72-D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;/j,k

/^c1 H<:2-85tbe

^`1 '-87-=t1^

D<<;5283:-=:33;F32-8D-7j,k

uaed1 &<6D-=tbd

dc1J/0/-=^ee1

#286.B5,3tec

^\d1/-=^b11

'-87-=t1^

A<-B/2655-=/7-q8-@A2523=7-=r/M9<<8P=3Nj;837-=k

c1< ,-2.=;/6.22-B-=.=;

dc1 ,-2.=;/6.22-B-=.=;

cc< ,-2.=;/6.22-B-=.=;

D8--72-/:33;F32-8D-7/j,k 0`1 S38=-9-:7tb\

0`1 H<:2-85tbe

0`1 H.:D-85t11

0a1 &<6D-=tbd

0c1 $/9C7CU33.>/tb`

0a1 #286.B5,3tbc

9338D33=9-8D8-7.=;/j,k 01Pc1 $33:/tbe c1/M<:80Jc1N

\1/M<:80Je1N

#2668P;8<-GH33:/tbcD

01Pc1 E.-/D.>:3;-'

9338D33=D8--72-/j,k ^`cP^dc $33:/tbe ^`1M<:80Jc1N

^01M<:80Je1N

#2668P;8<-GH33:/tbcD

1^d1 E.-/D.>:3;-'

@<[44.@.[=2/93=/?AZELj,^X0X5k

\a/P/`` &<6D-=tbd

\1 U33.>/tb` E.-/$3D-:/aPc/;-D86.B2-F3387-/6.2

\\/MBg1JbN '55-=/tee ,<7-:D-8-B-=.=;-=.-2

93=/`c/=338`1

#F3=-=PD-8;/tb^

93=/``/=338\d

#F3=-PD-8;/tb^

=338/33=:-.7.=;/93=,-2.=;-=

$3D-:/\P^f +-;-9-=5/93=/7-/D<@A2-=/'8:-@<,J/Q.>,-;-=/-=/#.=2/!=78.-5

//////////////////////////////////////////////////////>2?@7A2)(..",2,"/","&'$"23+(9

Page 35: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 3 – 3

3.2 Erlecom (bodemkribben)

".;668/\P^f H33:D<@A2/D.>/'8:-@<,/,-2/D<7-,:.;;.=;

&-/D<@A2/D.>/'8:-@<,/D-9.=72/E.@A/<=;-9--8/c/ B.:<,-2-8/ D-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/7-/ 5G:.25.=;,-2/A-2/]3==-87-=5-/U3=33:C/I-2/ D-28-42/ --=/D<@A2/ =338/ 8-@A25J/F338D.>/ 7-/ D<7-,/93=/7-D6.2-=D<@A2/.5/9<<8E.-=/93=/D<7-,B8.DD-=C/R=/".;668/\P^/E.>=/7-/D<7-,B8.DD-=/3:5/q5,3::-:.>=2>-5r/ 2-/E.-=/7.-/<=;-9--8/a1/,-2-8/93=/-:B338/34:.;;-=/,-2/73382655-=/--=/-8<7--8D38-D<7-,J/2-/A-8B-==-=/33=/7-/;8<2-8-/7.-G2-5C/S-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/B.:<,-2-8833./edaJ1/.5/.=7-/D6.2-=D<@A2/--=/-8<5.-;32/F338=--,D338C

R=/ 7-/ G-8.<7-/ >6=./ ^beb/ -=/ ,-./ ^bb1/ .5/ --=/ <=7-8E<-B/ ;-F--52/ ,-2/ --=/ G8<-4/ 93=/ ^^D<7-,B8.DD-=J/<G;-D<6F7/6.2/E<;-=33,7-/E3=7F<852-=/MG<:LG8<GL:--=E3BB-=/;-96:7/,-2E3=7NC/Q3/-93:632.-/93=/7-E-/G8<-4/.5/.=/7-/G-8.<7-/5-G2-,D-8/^bb`/2<2/5-G2-,D-8/^bba/A-2283>-@2/6.2;-D8-.7/,-2/c`/52<8252-=-=/D<7-,B8.DD-=C/&-E-/E.>=/33=;-:-;7/.=/A-2/283>-@2/2655-=B.:<,-2-8/ ed\J^dc/ -=/ edaJ1C/ R=/ ^bb\/ .5/ A.-82<-/ D-5:<2-=J/ <=73=B5/ 732/ 7-/ D-<<;7-9338D33=9-8D8-7.=;/93=/`1/,-2-8/=338/9-8F3@A2.=;J/D.>/--=/D<7-,B8.D34523=7/93=/d1/,/=.-2;-8-3:.5--87/ B<=/F<87-=/ MS38=-9-:7/ -=/#286.B5,3/^bb\/ -=/^bb`NC/ R=/F-8B-:.>BA-.7/ D:.>B2J33=/7-/A3=7/93=/,6:2.D-3,P,-2.=;-=J/7.2/7<-:/-@A2-8/F-:/D-8-.B2/2-/E.>=/ME.-/2-9-=5/".;668'P0^/.=/D.>:3;-/'N/D.>/--=/D<7-,B8.D34523=7/93=/a1/,-2-8C

Page 36: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

3 – 4 WL | Delft Hydraulics

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d1,/=338/a1,C/H.=52/93=/7-/9338D33=D8--72-/2655-=/^beb/-=/^bbd/F35/;-,.77-:7/c1,-2-8/2655-=/ed\Jc/-=/ed`Jc/B.:<,-2-8/-=/:-9-87-/7338,--/9<:7<-=7-/-Y283/D8--72-C/$655-=B.:<,-2-8/ ed`Jc/ -=/ edcJc/ .5/ 7-/ 9338D33=D8--72-/ ,-2/ 5:-@A25/ 01/ ,-2-8/ 2<-;-=<,-=/ M$33:^bbeNC/ &.2/ 93:2/ 53,-=/ ,-2/ 7-/ 52-8B-/ B8<,,.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ 8.9.-8D<@A2J/ F3387<<8/ --=/ 52-8B7F3859-8A3=;/<=252332/-=/7-/D<7-,B8.DD-=/<=9<:7<-=7-/2-;-=-44-@2/:-9-8-=C/&-/A<-B/7.-/7-D<7-,B8.DD-=/,3B-=/.5/adJc2/ 2-=/<GE.@A2-/93=/7-/833B:.>=/93=/7-/D6.2-=D<@A2J/F338D.>/7-8.@A2.=;/93=/7-/B8.DD-=/2-;-=/7-/528<,.=;/;-8.@A2/.5C

&<<8/7-/9-8B:-.=.=;/93=/A-2/<GG-89:3B/93=/A-2/7F385G8<4.-:/-=/7<<8732/--=/86F-8-/D<7-,/.5<=25233=/E3:/<G526F.=;/G:3325/9.=7-=C/&-/A<<;2-/93=/7-E-/<G526F.=;/.5/34A3=B-:.>B/93=/A-27-D.-2J/ =3,-:.>B/ D.>/ --=/ A<;-8/ 7-D.-2/ E3:/ 7-/ <G526F.=;/ B:-.=-8/ E.>=C/ &.2/ B<,2/ 7<<8732/ 7-8.9.-8/7-/D<7-,B8.DD-=/,.=7-8/q9<-:2rC/S.>/ --=/F32-8523=7/<9-8--=B<,-=7/,-2/O*(/ Mbe`,\X5N/ E3:/ D<9-=528<<,5/ 93=/ 7-/ D<7-,B8.DD-=/ --=/ F32-8523=759-8A<;.=;/ 93=/ D.>=3/ 1J^1,-2-8/<G28-7-=J/2-8F.>:/7.2/D.>/--=/349<-8/93=/^c111/,\X5/<=;-9--8/^/v/0/@-=2.,-2-8/E3:/E.>=ME.-/$-8F-:/ -=/)-8F-L/ M^bbeN/ -=/ 2-9-=5/&<6D-=/ M^bbdN/ <9-8/ 7.2/ <=7-8F-8GNC/&<<8732/ 7-F32-8523=759-8A<;.=;/.=9:<-7/A--42/ 2<2/9<<8D.>/A-2/ 5G:.25.=;5G6=2/D.>/7-/]3==-87-=5-/U<GJM-=/E-:45/2<2/9<<8D.>/*<D.2ANJ/E3:/,--8/F32-8/A-2/]3==-87-=5-/U3=33:/.=/528<,-=C/&.2/E3:/D.>349<-8-=/93=/be`/,\X5/-=/^c111/,\X5J/<G/7-/S<9-=P(.>=J/[email protected]:.>B/^^/,\X5/-=/^b/,\X5E.>=C/)-8F3@A2/F<872/732/7-E-/F3387-=/-=.;5E.=5/33=/7-/A<;-/B3=2/E.>=C

3.3 Nijmegen (vaste laag)

Q338/ 7-/ H33:D<@A2/ .=/ Q.>,-;-=/ .5/ 3:/ <G/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ G6=2-=/ <=7-8E<-B/ 9-88.@A2C/ )--:A.-893=/ A-DD-=/ --=/ <G:<55.=;/ ;-D<7-=/ 9<<8/ --=/ D-2-8-/ D-9338D338A-.7/ 93=/ 7-/ H33:/ 2-8G:3325-C/ &<<8/ A-2/ 52--75/ .=2-=5.-9-8/ ;-F<87-=/ 5@A--G933829-8B--8/ F35/ --=9338;-6:9-8D8-7.=;/ =<<7E3B-:.>BJ/ <,/ 7-/ ;8<2-8-/ .=2-=5.2-.2/ -=/ 93382/ ,-2/ ;8<2-8-/ 5@A-G-=,<;-:.>B/ 2-/,3B-=C/$655-=/^bea/ -=/^bee/ .5/ .=/ 7-/H33:D<@A2/ 2-/Q.>,-;-=/ --=/ 9352-/ :33;33=;-:-;7J/<G/D35.5/93=/<=7-8/3=7-8-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/93=/A-2/H32-8:<<GB6=7.;/*3D<832<8.6,93=/ #26.B5,3/ M^bec/ -=/ ^beaNC/ &-E-/ 9352-/ :33;/ ,<-52/ 2<2/ 7-/ D-=<7.;7-/ 9338D33=D8--72-:-.7-=C/&-E-/,3328-;-:/D:--B/.=7-87337/A-2/9-8F3@A2-/-44-@2/2-/D-F-8B52-::.;-=C/&-E-/9352-:33;/F35/7-/--852-/93=/E.>=/5<<82/.=/7-/H33:/-=/A--42/E.>=/F-8B.=;/D-F-E-=C

Page 37: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 3 – 5

".;668/\P0f H33:D<@A2/D.>/Q.>,-;-=/,-2/D<7-,:.;;.=;

R=/ ".;668/ \P0/ .5/ --=/ D<7-,G-.:.=;/ 2-/ E.-=/ 93=/ 01/ 2<2/ -=/ ,-2/ 0\/ ,3382/ 011^/ ,-2D-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/B.:<,-2-8833./eecJ^/M=.-2/33=;-;-9-=/.=/D<9-=5233=7-/4.;668N/76.7-:.>B--=/-8<5.-;32/E.@A2D338/.=/7-/D6.2-=D<@A2C/&-/9352-/:33;/D-;.=2/D.>/B.:<,-2-833./ee\J0/-=/A-2-.=723:67/-.=7.;2/2-8/A<<;2-/93=/B.:<,-2-833./eecJ^C

$.>7-=5/ 7-/ 33=:-;/ F38-=/ 3:/ ;8<2-/ 9-852<8.=;-=/ ;-@<=5232--87/ 2655-=/ B,8C/ ee\J0/ -=/ B,8Cee\JdJ/F338/93=34/7-/8.9.-8P35/2<2/33=/7-/*-=25-/E.>7-/9--:/E3=7/F-87/F-;;-5G<-:7C/&3387<<8F35/7-/G<5.2.-9-/F-8B.=;/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/3:/,-2--=/76.7-:.>BC

&-/D<@A2/D.>/Q.>,-;-=/B-=,-8B2/E.@A/7<<8/E.>=/B:-.=-/D<<;52833:/ Mdc1/,-2-8NC/O=7-8E<-B=338/9-886.,.=;/A.-893=/M2<2/\c11/,-2-8N/,33B2-/76.7-:.>B/732/7.2/=.-2/A33:D338/.5/93=F-;-<=7-8/ 3=7-8-/ 7-/ :3=75@A3GG-:.>B-/ D-2-B-=.5J/ =32668F3387-=/ -=/ D-D<6F.=;XD<6FG:3==-=C!3=5:6.2-=7/ <G/ 7-E-/ D<@A2/ D-9.=72/ E.@A/ --=/ B37-J/ :3=;5/ --=/ 98.>F-:/ 8-@A2526B/ 9<<8/ A-233=:-;;-=/93=/5@A-G-=J/F32/<G/E.>=/D-682/-Y283/9338D8--72-/-=/,3=<-698--8D338A-.7/9833;2C!3=5:6.2-=7/<G/7.2/ 8-@A2-/;-7--:2-/D-9.=72/E.@A/--=/D<@A2/ =338/ 8-@A25/ <=7-8/ 7-/ 5G<<8D86;7<<8J/F338/2-8/A<<;2-/93=/B,8C/eec/7-/9352-/:33;/-.=7.;2C/&-/5G<<8D86;/D.>/Q.>,-;-=/A--422-=/ <GE.@A2-/ 93=/ 7-/ 98<-;-8-/ D86;/ --=/ ;8<2-8-/ <9-85G3==.=;J/ ,338/ 7-5<=73=B5/ D:.>42/ --=G.>:-8/ 5233=/ .=/A-2/ :33;F32-8D-7/7.-/ .=9:<-7/A--42/<G/7-/ 528<,.=;/-=/7-/ D<7-,:.;;.=;C/&-9352-/:33;/A--42/--=/D8--72-/93=/<=;-9--8/^c1/,-2-8C

Page 38: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

3 – 6 WL | Delft Hydraulics

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bbcD/-=/$33:/^bbdNC

$655-=/ B.:<,-2-8833./ ee0Ja/ -=/ B.:<,-2-8833./ ee`J1/ .5/ --=/ ;:[email protected]:-/ :33;/ 33=F-E.;/ 7.--9-=--=5/46=;--82/3:5/q9352-r/ :33;C/&-/5-7.,-=232.-/7.-/E.@A/D-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/7-/9352-:33;/9<<87<-2J/:-9-82/=.-2/E<9--:/A.=7-8/<G/9<<8/7-/5@A--G93382/73=/D.>/,-2/#.=2/!=78.-5C/&.2B<,2/7<<8732/7-/9338;-6:/.=/Q.>,-;-=/,--8/.=/7-/D6.2-=D<@A2/:.;2C

3.4 Sint Andries (vaste laag)

$-8/ A<<;2-/ 93=/ #.=2/ !=78.-5/ :.;2/ --=/ 8-@A2-8D<@A2/ .=/ 7-/ H33:C/ !:/ .=/ ^bdb/ .5/ 7<<8/ A-2H32-8:<<GB6=7.;/*3D<832<8.6,/ --=/,<7-:<=7-8E<-B/ =338/ D<@A29-8D-2-8.=;/ ;-733=J/ -@A2-8,-2/--=/3=7-8-/7<-:52-::.=;/73=/7-/A6.7.;-/ME.-/H.:B-=5J/^bdbNC/R=/7-/G-8.<7-/>3=638./^bbd2<2/ 4-D8638./ ^bbb/ .5/ --=/ 9352-/ :33;/ 33=;-:-;7/ <,/ 7-/ A6.7.;-/ D8--72-/ 93=/ 7-/ 8.9.-8/ 2-9-8;8<2-=C/&-/7<-:52-::.=;/93=/7-E-/:33;/.5/<,/2-/E<8;-=/9<<8/--=/9338;-6:D8--72-/93=/^ac,-2-8/ D.>/ --=/ 7.-G2-/ 93=/ 0Je1/,C/ &-/ <<85G8<=B-:.>B-/ <GE-2/ F35/ <,/ --=/ D8--72-/ 93=/ ^d1,-2-8/ 2-/ 8-3:.5-8-=J/ ,338/ 732/ D:--B/ 2.>7-=5/ A-2/ <=2F-8G/ =.-2/ ,<;-:.>BC/ i<7<-=7-/ .5/ --=D8--72-/ 93=/ ^ac/ ,-2-8/ ;-3@@-G2--87J/ F3387<<8/ ,-2/ D-A6:G/ 93=/ 377.2.<=--:/ D3;;-8-=/ <43=7-8-/,3328-;-:-=/7-/<9-8.;-/c/,-2-8/,<-2/F<87-=/;-8-3:.5--87C

".;668/\P\f H33:D<@A2/D.>/#.=2/!=78.-5/,-2/D<7-,:.;;.=;

Page 39: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 3 – 7

R=/".;668/\P\/.5/7-/D<7-,:.;;.=;/93=/D<@A2/D.>/#.=2/!=78.-5/E.@A2D338C/V-2/D-=-7-=528<<,593=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ MB,8/ b0eJ1N/ .=/ 7-/ D6.2-=D<@A2/ --=/ -8<5.-;32/ -=/ .=/ 7-/ D.==-=D<@A2/ --=5-7.,-=232.-D6:2C/)3=34/B.:<,-2-8833./b0aJ1/.5/7-/E.>7-:.=;5-/D-;8-=E.=;/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/.=7-/D.==-=D<@A2/E.@A2D338C/&.2/B<,2/7<<8732/=3352/7-/9352-/:33;/.=/7-/D.==-=D<@A2/7-/D<7-,.5/6.2;-5@A6687/<=7-8/A-2/=.9-36/93=/7-/9352-/:33;C/$655-=/B.:<,-2-8833./b0cJ1/MD-;.=/93=/7-9352-/ :33;N/ -=/ b0aJ1/ .5/ =<;/ E3=7/ <G/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ E.@A2D338C/ R=/ ".;668/ \P`/ .5/ 93=/ --=5<<82;-:.>B-/,6:2.D-3,PG-.:.=;/7-/D<7-,/3:5/ \P&/ 4.;668/F--8;-;-9-=C/ R=/".;668/ \P`/ .5/ 7-9352-/ :33;/ F338=--,D338/ ,-2/ 7-/ <=2;8<=7.=;-=/ -8=3352/ M7-/ 5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/ F35/ 2.>7-=57-E-/G-.:.=;/=<;/=.-2/33=F-E.;NC/&-/qG.-B-=r/33=/7-/E.>B3=2/E.>=/B8.DD-=C

".;668/\P`f \P&/33=E.@A2/93=/A-2/-.=7-/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/93=34/D-=-7-=528<<,5

&-/9352-/:33;/.5/33=;-:-;7/2655-=/B.:<,-2-8/b0cJ1/-=/b0eJ0/,-2/--=/D8--72-/93=/^`1/,-2-8-=/--=/:-=;2-/93=/\^11/,-2-8C/+-7--:2-:.>B/=3352/7-/9352-/:33;/.5/--=/=32668:.>B-/9352-/:33;/2-9.=7-=J/=3,-:.>B/--=/B:-.:33;C/&-E-/E<8;2/53,-=/,-2/7-/33=;-D83@A2-/9352-/:33;/2-8/A<<;2-93=/ B.:<,-2-8/ b0dJ1/ <9-8/ --=/ :-=;2-/ 93=/ ^11/ ,-2-8/ 9<<8/ --=/ ;-A--:/ 9352/ D<7-,G8<4.-:C&<<8732/.=/7-/D.==-=D<@A2/M<G/7-/B:-.:33;NJ/76.=9<8,.=;/<G28--72/<=252<=7/--=/<=7.-G2-J/7.-.5/ 9-8A<:G-=/7<<8/ 7-/ B:-.:33;/ 2<2/ --=/7.-G2-/ 93=/ \Jc1/,-2-8/ <=7-8/ O*H/ M<9-8--=;-B<,-=:3;-/F32-8523=7N/F-;/2-/D3;;-8-=C/I.-87<<8/:-9-82/7-/76.=9<8,.=;/;--=/G8<D:-,-=/,--8/<G9<<8/7-/ 5@A--G93382C/$-8/A<<;2-/93=/B.:<,-2-8/b0aJ0/E32/=<;/--=/<67-/B8.D@<[email protected]/7.-^11/,-2-8/7-/8.9.-8/ .=/523B/-=/d1/@-=2.,-2-8/D<9-=/7-/<,:.;;-=7-/D<7-,/6.2523BC/&-E-/ .534;-9:3B2/2<2/<G/A<<;2-/93=/7-/<,:.;;-=7-/D<7-,C

)3=34/B.:<,-2-8/b0aJ1/l/b0dJ1/F<872/A-2/;-A-:-/D<7-,283=5G<82/9.3/A-2/8-@A2-8;-7--:2-/93=7-/8.9.-8J/7-/D.==-=D<@A2J/34;-9<-87C/&-/5=-:A-7-=/E.>=/A.-8/:<B33:/E-:45/A<;-8/73=/7.-/.=/7-D6.2-=D<@A2C/I-2/5-7.,-=2/D:.>42/2<2/<=;-9--8/b0eJc/9<<8=3,-:.>B/33=/7-/8-@A2-8<-9-8C

Q3352/7-/9352-/:33;/.5/.=/7-/D.==-=D<@A2/--=/-8<5.-;-6:/<=25233=C/OG/--=/33=23:/G:3325-=/.57-/;-6:/E</7.-G/732/7-E-/2<2/<=7-8/7-/46=7-8.=;57.-G2-/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/.5/;-[8<7--87C

#28<<,8.@A2.=;

Page 40: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

3 – 8 WL | Delft Hydraulics

&-/ .=9:<-7/93=/7-/ B8.D93BB-=/ 7<<8/ =--8F-8B.=;/ -=/F-89-:52832-=/ D:.>B2/ --=/ 8-:32.-4/ ;8<2-.=9:<-7/2-/A-DD-=C/ME.-/".;668/\C`J/,-2/--=/9<<8D--:7/93=/7-/E<;-=33,7-/B8.D9:3,,-=/.=7-/ D<7-,J/ <=25233=/ 7<<8/ 7-/ B8.DD-=/ -=/ 7-/ F32-8528<,.=;NC/ $.>7-=5/ 7-/ 33=:-;/ .5/ 7-D.==-=D<@A2/2-=/D-A<-9-/93=/--=/9338;-6:/6.2;-D3;;-87/F32/,<;-:.>B/9<<8/--=/9-85=-::.=;93=/A-2/<=25233=/93=/7-/-8<5.-;-6:/B3=/A-DD-=/;-E<8;7C

S.>/ --=/ A<;-/ 349<-8/ 28--72/ 9<<8/ -=/ <G/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ 33=E3=7.=;/ <GJ/,338/ D.>/ --=/ 7338<G9<:;-=7-/93:/9-87F.>=2/7-E-/F--8C/&-/E3=7D3=B-=/ .=/A-2/ :33;F32-8D-7/9<<8/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;2655-=/B.:<,-2-8/b0\Je/-=/b0cJe/B6==-=/D.>/5=-:/93::-=7/F32-8/G8<D:-,-=/<G:-9-8-=C/&-E-E3=7D3=B-=/ <=252<=7-=/ 7<<8/ E3=7283=5G<82/ 93=6.2/ 7-/ B8.D93BB-=C/ S.>/ A<<;F32-8/ ;332/ 7-<=2E3=7.=;/D.>/I--55-:2/,--528<,-=/-=/28--72/34E-22.=;/<G/.=/7-/B8.D93BB-=C/S.>/73:.=;/93=A-2/F32-8/F<872/7.2/7<<8/=--8528<,.=;/<G;-=<,-=/-=/<G=.-6F/.=/7-/8.9.-8/34;-E-2/:3=;5/7-F-89-:52832-=/7.-/<=7-8/`c/;837-=/7-/8.9.-8/.=/:3;-=C/&<<8/7-/;-7--:2-:.>B-/B8.D93B345:6.2.=;.5/7.2/G8<D:--,/9<<8/--=/;8<<2/7--:/9-8A<:G-=C/ME.-/'-87-=J/011^N/$-9-=5/7.-=2/A-2/,32-8.33:732/.5/;-D86.B2/9<<8/7-/B8.D93B345:6.2.=;/3:5/D8-6B52--=7-G<2/9<<8/5G<-7-.5-=7-/8-G3832.-5C

".;668/\Pcf U8.D9:3,,-=/D<9-=528<<,5/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/93=/#.=2/!=78.-5

S-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/28--72/--=/-8<5.-;32/<GC/&.2/-8<5.-;32/.5/=3/33=:-;/93=/7-9352-/:33;/9-8:-=;7/.=/7-/8.@A2.=;/93=/7-/D<@A2/OG.>=-=C/&-/8-:32.-4/5-7.,-=2P38,-/528<<,7.-/A.-87<<8/<=252332/E<6/.=/7-/D.==-=D<@A2/93=/OG.>=-=/>6.52/F-:/F--8/5-7.,-=2/<G=-,-=CH3387<<8/ -8/ 7<<8/ 7-/ <G;-F-B2-/ -8<5.-B83@A2-=/ --=/9-8D8-7.=;/<G28--7/ .=/ 7-/ D.==-=D<@A293=/OG.>=-=C

!"#$%&'(

Page 41: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 3 – 9

I-2/379.-5/.5/<,/7.2/-8<5.-;32/<=;-,<-.7/2-/:32-=/M9<:;-=5/'-87-=/011^NC/Q3352/A-2/-8<5.-;3228--72/33=E3=7.=;/<GJ/7.2/:-9-87-/2<2/-.=7/^bbbJ/^1/,33=7-=/=3/7-/33=:-;J/;--=/G8<D:-,-=<GJ/,338/2-;-=F<<87.;/D-9.=72/E.@A/7338/8-;-:,32.;/7-/,.=52/;-G-.:7-/7.-G2-/MV+&N/ .=/7.28.9.-8283>-@2C

$.>7-=5/7-/33=:-;/2837-=/--=/33=23:/G8<D:-,-=/<G/7.-/=.-2/F38-=/9<<8E.-=/D.>/A-2/<=2F-8GCi</5@A6687-/7-/D<7-,/=3352/7-/=-2/33=;-:-;7-/2<G:33;/,-2--=/6.2/-=/5:<-;/5-7.,-=2/=--8D-=-7-=528<<,5/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;C/ '-=/ D3;;-8@[email protected]/ 93=/ ^1C111/ ,\XF--B/ D:--B/ =.-29<:7<-=7-C/ R=/ A-2/ <=2F-8G/ F35/ 8-B-=.=;/ ;-A<67-=/ ,-2/ --=/ 33=96::.=;/ 93=/ ac111/ ,\JM.=@:65.-4/^^h/-8<5.-9-8:.-5NJ/,338/7.2/.5/D.>=3/0`1C111/,\/;-F<87-=/M--=/<9-85@A8.>7.=;/93=0adhJ/F32/ 765/ --=/<=9-8F3@A2-/ -8<5.-/ ;34/ 93=/\`0h/ .=/ G:3325/ 93=/^^hNC/&.2/ B<,2/ 7<<8<=7-8/3=7-8-/7-/F-8B.=;/93=/A-2/33=;-:-;7-/7--:/7-/9352-/:33;/-=/7-/,3=.-8/93=/A-2/52<82-=93=/A-2/E3=7J/ 7<<8/ A-2/ E3=7/=3,-:.>B/ q9:<-.-=7r/ 2-/ 52<82-=C/$-9-=5/ .5/ -8/ ;-B<E-=/<,/93=D<9-=528<<,5/=338/D-=-7-=528<<,5/2-/F-8B-=/<,/E</,.=/,<;-:.>B/E3=7/<G/A-2/F-8BM48<=2N2-/B8.>;-=/F3387<<8/A-2/F-8B/-9-=26--:/<=>6.52/B3=/F<87-=/.=;-,-2-=C

Page 42: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

3 – 1 0 WL | Delft Hydraulics

Page 43: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 4 – 1

4 Analytische berekeningen

4.1 Inleiding

!=3:L2.5@A-/ D-8-B-=.=;-=/ B6==-=/ A-:G-=/ <,/ .=E.@A2/ 2-/ B8.>;-=/ .=/ 9-85@A.>=5-:-=/ 7.-/ 93=D-:3=;/E.>=C/OG/D35.5/93=/7.2/ .=E.@A2/ .5/A-2/,<;-:.>B/<,/3:/<G/9<<8A3=7/--=/ .=5@A322.=;/ 2-,3B-=/93=/F32/A-2/-44-@2/.5/93=/D-G33:7-/,3328-;-:-=C/&338,--/B3=/A-2/33=23:/3:2-8=32.-9-=732/ 7.-=2/ 2-/F<87-=/<=7-8E<@A2/ MD.>9<<8D--:7/,-2/ D-A6:G/ 93=/ --=/ .=;-F.BB-:7/F.5B6=7.;,<7-:/3:5/;-D86.B2/.=/7.2/<=7-8E<-BN/F<87-=/9-8B:-.=7C

R=/7.2/[email protected]/;-93:/B6==-=/3=3:L2.5@A-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/;-D86.B2/F<87-=/<,/7-/.=9:<-7/=32-/;33=/93=/-9-=26-:-/9-83=7-8.=;-=/.=/7-/9352-/:33;/@<=4.;6832.-C/V--8/[email protected]/7.-=2/.=/7.2<=7-8E<-B/=3;-;33=/2-/F<87-=/F32/7-/.=9:<-7/.5/93=/F.>E.;.=;-=/.=/A<<;2-:.;;.=;J/D8--72--=/ :-=;2-/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;C/ R=/ [email protected]/ B3=/ <<B/ 7-/ 86FA-.7/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ F<87-=D-W=9:<-7C

!3=93=B-:.>B/F35/A-2/7-/D-7<-:.=;/<,/ 2F--/3=3:L2.5@A-/D-=37-8.=;-=/ 2-/ <=2F.BB-:-=C/&---852-/ D-=37-8.=;/ A--42/ D-28-BB.=;/ <G/ 7-/ D<7-,:.;;.=;/ =3352/ --=/ 9352-/ :33;/ 9<<8/ --=;-;-9-=/ 8.9.-8;-7--:2-/ ,-2/ D-G33:7-/ B383B2-8.52.-B-=J/ 3:5/ 349<-8J/ 9-8A3=;J/ D8--72-JB<88-:7.3,-2-8J/ 86FA-.7J/ 5-7.,-=2/ 283=5G<82/ -=/ ;-;-9-=/ D<@A252833:C/ i</ --=/ 34:-.7.=;/ .53::--=/,<;-:.>B/ 9<<8/ --=/ 3Y.33:P5L,,-28.5@A-/ 5.2632.-J/F338D.>/ 9<<825/ 9-8<=7-852-:7/F<872732/3:/A-2/5-7.,-=2283=5G<82/G:3325/9.=72/.=/A-2/3::69.3:-/;-7--:2-/732/8-52--82/=3352/7-/9352-:33;C/&-/2F--7-/3=3:L2.5@A-/D-=37-8.=;/7.-=7-/D-28-BB.=;/2-/A-DD-=/<G/7-/<,523=7.;A-7-=D-=-7-=528<<,5/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;C/ R=/ [email protected]/ .5/ A-2/ ,<;-:.>B/ <,/ ,-2/ --=/ 3=3:L2.5@A-D-=37-8.=;/--=/--852-/5@A322.=;/2-/;-9-=/93=/M^N/A-2/7.-G-/-8<5.-;32/732/3@A2-8/7-/9352-/:33;<=252332/-=/M0N/7-/ 5-7.,-=232.-D6:2J/D-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/A-2/3::69.3:-/;-7--:2-/F338/3:/A-25-7.,-=2/F<872/;-283=5G<82--87C/V-2/7-/:33252-/D-=37-8.=;/E<6/A-2/,<;-:.>B/E.>=/<,/9352/<G9<<8A3=7/7-/.=9:<-7/93=/D.>9<<8D--:7/9-8:-=;-=/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/.=/2-/5@A322-=C

&<<8/ 2.>7;-D8-B/ .5/A-2/ 5:-@A25/,<;-:.>B/;-D:-B-=/<,/7-/--852-/3=3:L5-/6.2/ 2-/9<-8-=/-=/7-8-56:232-=/ A.-893=/ F<87-=/ .=/ 7.2/ A<<47526B/ ;-G8-5-=2--87/ -=/ D-5G8<B-=C/ &.2/ ;-D-682/ .=G383;8334/`C0C/&-/34;-:-.7-/6.2786BB.=;/F<872/;-9-8.4.--87/9<<8/7-/5.2632.-/.=/7-/D<@A2/93=#.=2/!=78.-5J/F338D.>/7-/34;-:-.7-/3=3:L2.5@A-/6.2786BB.=;/9<<8/7-/,3Y.,3:-/7.-G2-/=3352/7-9352-/:33;/F<872/9-8;-:-B-=/,-2/A-2/;-,.77-:7-/93=/7-/;-,-2-=/F3387-=C/)-89<:;-=5/F<872.=/G383;8334/`C\/-9-=--=5/9<<8/7-/D<@A2/D.>/#.=2/!=78.-5J/765/,-2/7-E-:47-/G383,-2-85J/--=3=3:L5-/6.2;-9<-87/<,/7-/.=9:<-7/93=/9-85@A.::-=7-/33=:-;A<<;2-5/-=/9-85@A.::-=7-/D8--72-593=/7-/9352-/:33;/<G/7-/,3Y.,3:-/7.-G2-/=3352/7-/9352-/:33;/2-/D-G3:-=C

4.2 Maximale diepte naast vaste laag

V-2/=3,-/=3352/7-/9352-/:33;/93=/#.=2/!=78.-5/28-7-=/8-:32.-4/;8<2-/7.-G2-5/<GC/&-E-/G:-BB-=B6==-=/E-:45/:3;-8/73=/7-/<=7-8B3=2/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/6.2B<,-=C/O,/--=/.7--/2-/B8.>;-=/93=7-/7.-G2-/93=/7-E-/<=2;8<=7.=;-=/E.>=/<8.[=2-8-=7-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/;-,33B2C

Page 44: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

4 – 2 WL | Delft Hydraulics

S-:3=;8.>B-/6.2;3=;5G6=2-=/E.>=/732/F<872/ 6.2;-;33=/93=/ --=/9<::-7.;/ <=2F.BB-:7-/ 3Y.33:P5L,,-28.5@A-/ 5.2632.-/ -=/ 732/ A-2/ D<7-,283=5G<82/ 93=/ A-2/ 5-7.,-=2/ ;-A--:/ 7<<8/ 7-D.==-=D<@A2/9-8:<<G2C/H338D.>/A-2/ 2F--7-/6.2;3=;5G6=2/,.=/<4/,--8/9<:;2/6.2/7-/--852-J/ .=@<,D.=32.-/,-2/--=/9352-/:33;C/!3=/7-/A3=7/93=/7-/G-.:.=;-=/D:.>B2/732/.=/7-/D<@A2/D.>/#.=2!=78.-5/ ;8<4F-;/ 93=34/ B.:<,-2-8/ b0aJ1/ l/ b0dJ1/ A-2/ D<7-,283=5G<82/ 7<<8/ 7-/ D.==-=D<@A2;332/ ME.-/H.:D-85/ 0111J/ !:GA-=/ -=/ #,-7-5/ ^bbbNC/ i.-/ -9-=--=5/ ".;668/ `P^J/ A.-8.=/ .5/ 7-523=7338734F.>B.=;/93=/7-/;-,.77-:7-/7.-G2-/6.2;-E-2C/I.-8.=/.5/-8/F338/-8/E3=7/<G/7-/9352-:33;/:.;2/--=/B:-.=-/34F.>B.=;/2-/E.-=C/OG/7-/9352-/:33;/F338/;--=/E3=7/33=F-E.;/.5J/.5/-8/--=;8<2-/34F.>B.=;/2-/E.-=J/2-=/;-9<:;-/93=/A-2/;8<9-/,32-8.33:/93=/7-/9352-/:33;C/R=/".;668/`P^.5/2-/E.-=/732/A-2/E3=7/<G/7-/9352-/:33;/E.@A/=338/7-/D.==-=D<@A2/9-8G:33252C

".;668/`P^f #23=7338734F.>B.=;/93=/7-/;-,-2-=/7.-G2-/<G/7-/9352-/:33;/MD6.2-=D<@A2N

R=/ 7-/ D-8-B-=.=;-=/ .5/ 6.2;-;33=/ 93=/ --=/ @<=523=2-/ 349<-8C/ Q3352/ 7-/ @<=523=2-/ 349<-8/ .5;-B<E-=/<,/7-/7338D.>/D-A<8-=7-/BPF3387-/@<=523=2/2-/A<67-=/9<<8/E<F-:/7-/9352-/:33;/3:57-/3::69.3:-/D<7-,C/V-2/=3,-/9<<8/A-2/3::69.3:-/;-7--:2-/.5/7.2/=.-2/28.9.33:/ME.-/H.:D-85/-=$-=/S8.=B-/^bbbNC

&-/D-8-B-=.=;/B<,2/B<82/F-;/<G/A-2/9<:;-=7-/=--8f

-. '-=/@<=523=2-/349<-8/,-2/--=/7338D.>/D-A<8-=7-/9352-/F32-8A<<;2-/D<9-=/7-/9352-:33;/-=/--=/@<=523=2-/5-7.,-=2349<-8s

-. &-/349<-8/<9-8/7-/9352-/ :33;/-=/A-2/3::69.3:-/7--:/ .5/;-:.>B/33=/7-/ 2<23:-/349<-8/-=-9-=--=5/.5/7-/5-7.,-=2349<-8/<9-8/D-.7-/7-:-=/;-:.>B/33=/7-/2<23:-/5-7.,-=2349<-8CM,-2/ --=/ 5-7.,-=2349<-8/ <9-8/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ ;-:.>B/ 33=/ =6:N/ H338D.>/ .=/ 7-9-8;-:.>B.=;/ 9<<8/ A-2/ 5-7.,-=2349<-8/ 7-/ @<[44.@.[=2/ 9<<8/ 7-5-7.,-=2283=5G<824<8,6:-/<=7-8/3=7-8-/34A3=B-:.>B/.5/93=/7-/86FA-.7s

Page 45: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 4 – 3

-. &-/ 528<<,5=-:A-.7/F<872/ D-8-B-=7/,-2/ D-A6:G/ 93=/ 7-/ 4<8,6:-/ 93=/ ?AZEL/F-:B-34A3=B-:.>B/.5/93=/7-/86FA-.7/93=/7-/D<7-,J/F32-87.-G2-/-=/A-2/:3=;59-8A3=;s

-. &-/ 86FA-.7/ 93=/ 7-/ D<7-,/ .5/ 34A3=B-:.>B/ 93=/ 7-/ F32-87.-G2-/ -=/ --=/ @<=523=2/ BPF3387-/ -=/ A-2/ :3=;59-8A3=;/ .5/ 34A3=B-:.>B/ 93=/ 7-/ 528<<,5=-:A-.7J/ 86FA-.7/ -=F32-87.-G2-s

-. '8/E.>=/e/9-8;-:.>B.=;-=/<G;-52-:7/,-2/e/<=D-B-=7-=J/E.-/$3D-:/`P^/M9<<8/D-2-B-=.593=/7-/5L,D<:-=/E.-/7-/D-28-44-=7-/4<8,6:-/<4/7-/:.>52/93=/5L,D<:-=Nf

G.-+.1"#4")+ *5-8,1. J)0.4.);.

528<<,5=-:A-.7/M0YN M`C^N %9J/%3J/?9J/?3J/A3J/.3

86FA-.7/M0YN M`C0N ?9J/?3J/A3

@<=523=2-/F32-8349<-8 M`C\N A3J/%9J/%3

@<=523=2-/5-7.,-=2349<-8 M`C`N ,9J/,3J/%9J/%3

@<[44.@.[=2/5-7.,-=2283=5G<82 M`CcN ,9J/,3J/?9J/?3

%9J/%3J/?9J/?3J/A3J/.3J/,9J/,3

$3D-:/`P^f )-8;-:.>B.=;-=/-=/<=D-B-=7-

-. %.2/ 7-E-/ 9-8;-:.>B.=;-=/ .5/ 7-/ ;-,.77-:7-/ F32-87.-G2-/ 93=/ A-2/ 3::69.3:-/ 7--:/ 2-D-8-B-=-=J/F338D.>/3:/A-2/5-7.,-=2/7<<8/7-/D.==-=D<@A2/;332s

-. '8/ .5/ -@A2-8/ 5G83B-/ 93=/ --=/ D<@A2/ F3387<<8/ --=/ 7F3859-8A3=;/ E3:/ <G28-7-=C/ &-D8--72-/-=/;-,.77-:7-/7.-G2-/:-9-82/A-2/=322-/<GG-89:3B/D<9-=/A-2/3::69.3:-/7--:s

-. &-/,3Y.,3:-/7.-G2-/=3352/7-/9352-/:33;/.=/@<,D.=32.-/,-2/A-2/D<7-,9-8A3=;/,<-2--=/;-:.>B/<GG-89:3B2-/A-DD-=/3:5/D-8-B-=7/,-2/7-/;-,.77-:7-/7.-G2-s

-. I-2/ 7F3859-8A3=;/F<872/ =3352/ --=/ 33=23:/ 9352-/ G383,-2-85/ D-G33:7/ 7<<8/ 7-/ 52833:93=/7-/D<@A2J/A-2/:3=;59-8A3=;J/7-/86FA-.7/-=/7-/7.-G2-s

-. I.-8D.>/ .5/6.2;-;33=/93=/7-/;-,.77-:7-/ 5=-:A-.7/-=/A--42/7-/ 7.-G2-/ .=9:<-7/<G/7-86FA-.7/ME.-/9-8;-:.>B.=;/`C^bNs/7-E-/A--42/53,-=/,-2/7-/7.-G2-/F--8/.=9:<-7/<G/A-2:3=;59-8A3=;/ ME.-/ 9-8;-:.>B.=;/ `C01NC/ I-2/ :3=;59-8A3=;/ 9-83=7-82/ MF<872/ 52-.:-8NJ<,732/3:/A-2/5-7.,-=2/9.3/--=/B:-.=-8/<GG-89:3B/,<-2/F<87-=/;-283=5G<82--87C

)<<8/7-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/E.>=/<=7-85233=7-/9-8;-:.>B.=;-=/;-D86.B2f

M3N/4<8,6:-/93=/?AZELf

u C hi= M`C^N

,-2f

Ch

k= FHGIKJ18

12log M`C0N

Page 46: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

4 – 4 WL | Delft Hydraulics

6/g/;-,.77-:7-/528<<,5=-:A-.7/j,X5k?/g/@<[44.@.[=2/93=/?AZEL/j,^X0X5kA/g/;-,.77-:7-/7.-G2-/j,k./g/F32-85G.-;-:9-8A3=;/jPkB/g/86FA-.7/9<:;-=5/Q.B68375-/j,k

MDN/@<=2.=6W2-.259-8;-:.>B.=;f

Q Bhu= M`C\N

m/g/7-D.-2J/9<:6,-/F32-8283=5G<82/G-8/--=A-.7/93=/2.>7/j,\X5kS/g/D8--72-/j,k

M@N/5-7.,-=2/283=5G<824<8,6:-f

S Bmun= M`C`N

,-2

mgC D

= 0 053 2

50

,

∆M`CcN

,-2f

∆ = −ρ ρρ

s w

w

M`CaN

#/g/9<:6,-/5-7.,-=2283=5G<82/G-8/--=A-.7/93=/2.>7/j,\X5k,/g/@<[44.@.[=2/.=/5-7.,-=2283=5G<824<8,6:-/j5`X,\k=/g/-YG<=-=2/.=/5-7.,-=2283=5G<824<8,6:-/jPk;/g/9-85=-::.=;/2-=/;-9<:;-/93=/7-/EF3382-B83@A2/j,X50k"/g/8-:32.-9-/[email protected]/jPk)5/g/5<<82-:.>B-/[email protected]/9352-/52<4/jB;X,\k)/g/5<<82-:.>B-/[email protected]/F32-8/jB;X,\k&c1/g/,-7.3=-/B<88-:7.3,-2-8/j,k

!3=/7-/A3=7/93=/7-E-/9-8;-:.>B.=;-=/.5/A-2/9<:;-=7-/52-:5-:/9-8;-:.>B.=;-=/<G;-52-:7f

Q B h u B h ut v v v a a a= + M`CdN

S B m u B m ut v v vn

a a an= + M`CeN

,-2/7-/.=7-Y/q2r/9<<8/2<233:J/q9r/9<<8/9352-/:33;/-=/q3r/9<<8/3::69.3:-/:33;C/I-2/;332/A.-8D.><,/7-/;-,.77-:7-/9<<8/7-/D-28-44-=7-/;8<<2A-.7C

Page 47: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 4 – 5

A9

S9 S3

"S3

A3

A,3Y

Y/g ^ 0 CC

,

".;668/`P0f ][email protected]@A-25/7F385G8<4.-:

&-/33==3,-/732/-8/;--=/5-7.,-=2/<9-8/7-/9352-/ :33;/528<<,2/-=/765/3::-5/9.3/A-2/3::69.3:-7--:/;332/:-.72/2<2f/ B m uv v v

n = 0 /-=/765/ S B m u St a a an

a= =

&<<8/ =6/ 9-8;-:.>B.=;/ M`CeN/ <,/ 2-/ 5@A8.>9-=/ =338/ *(/ -=/ 7-E-/ 9-89<:;-=5/ .=/ 2-/ 96::-=/ .=9-8;-:.>B.=;/M`CdNJ/F338D.>/*3/.5/A-85@A8-9-=/9<:;-=5/9-8;-:.>B.=;/M`C^NJ/9<:;2f

Q B C h i h B m St v v v v a a a t

nn n n= +− −3

212

1 1 1c h c h c h c h c h M`CbN

V-2/7-E-/9-8;-:.>B.=;/B3=/5(/F<87-=/<G;-:<52f

h Q B m Sa a a a t

nn n n=− −1 1 1c h c h c h M`C^1N

,-2f

Q Q B C h ia t v v v v= −32

12c h c h M`C^^N

&-/<GG-89:3B2-/93=/A-2/528<<,9<-8-=7-/3::69.3:-/7--:/.5/A.-8,--/2-/D-8-B-=-=C/&-/;-9<=7-=F3387-=/9<<8/5(/.5/-@A2-8/--=/;-,.77-:7-/F3387-C/I-2/9-8:<<G/93=/7-/7.-G2-/.5/34A3=B-:.>B93=/A-2/7F3859-8A3=;/732/E.@A/ .=/7-/D<@A2/ .=52-:2C/&.2/7F3859-8A3=;/ .5/ 2-/ D-G3:-=/,-2/ 7-<=7-85233=7-/4<8,6:-/ME.-/#286.B5,3/-2/3:C/^becNf

sin β θ= Afh

Rb g M`C^0N

,-2f

Ag

C= −FHG

IKJ

212κ κ

M`C^\N

Page 48: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

4 – 6 WL | Delft Hydraulics

-=

fD

hθ θb g = FHG

IKJ9

0 3,

M`C^`N

,-2f

θ = hi

D∆M`C^cN

5.=/,/g/7F3859-8A3=;/jPk!/g/5G.833:528<,.=;@<[44.@.[=2/jPk4M$N/g/7F385A-::.=;5-44-@2/jPk(/g/D<@A252833:/93=/7-/8.9.-8/j,k#/g/@<=523=2-/93=/)<=/Ul8,l=/M#/g/1J`N/j,k$/g/#A.-:75G383,-2-8/jPk

&-/<GG-89:3B2-/.5/=6/;-:.>B/33=/7-/5<,,32.-/93=/A-2/G8<76B2/93=/7-/;-,.77-:7-/A<<;2-/93=-:B-/7-:23/S/,-2/7-:23/SJ/=3,-:.>Bf

A B hh h

Ba a aa a

ax

xx x

x= =

+FHG

IKJ

LNM

OQP

+

=∑ 1

20

M`C^aN

,-2f

h hB

a aa

x x

x

+= +

1 sin βM`C^dN

H338.=/ A-2/ [email protected]/ qYr/ 52332/ 9<<8/ A-2/ D-5@A<6F7-/ qG382>-r/ 7-:23/ S/ ,-2/ D.>D-A<8-=7-;-,.77-:7-/A<<;2-/93=/A-2/D-28-44-=7-/qG382>-r/ME.-/".;668/`P0NCV-2/;-D86.B/,3B.=;/93=/7-/;-,.77-:7-/7.-G2-/93=/A-2/3::69.3:-/7--:/B3=/A.-8/7-/<GG-89:3B2-93=/93=/7-/=322-/7F3857<<85=-7-/D-8-B-=7/F<87-=C/)-89<:;-=5/.5/7-E-/;-:.>B/2-/52-::-=/33=9-8;-:.>B.=;/M`C^aNC/&.2/:-9-82/7-/9<:;-=7-/9-8;-:.>B.=;/<G/F3386.2/ ha0

/.2-832.-4/B3=/F<87-=

<G;-:<52C

A B h hB g

C

D

h

h i

D

h

RBa a a a

a

a

a

a

a a

a

a

xa

x

x

x

x

x x

x x x

x= = + −

FHG

IKJFHGIKJ

LNMM

OQPP

RS|T|

UV|W|

L

NMMM

O

QPPP

=∑ 2

21 9

2

0 3 1

0 κ κ

,

∆M`C^eN

,-2f

Ch

kaa

ax

x= 1812

log M`C^bN

Page 49: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 4 – 7

-=

iU

C haa

a ax

x x

=2

2 M`C01N

)<<8/7-/D<@A2/.=/#.=2/!=78.-5/.5/A-2/--=/-=/3=7-8/7<<8;-8-B-=7C/&-/D-8-B-=7-/F3387-=/E.>=9-8,-:7/ .=/ $3D-:/ `P0C/ '-=/ ;-7--:2-/ 93=/ 7-/ 6.29<-8/ 52332/ -9-=--=5/ 9-8,-:7/ .=/ 7-E-/ 23D-:C+-B<E-=/ .5/ 9<<8/ --=/ ,332;-9-=7-/ 349<-8/ 93=/ ^a11/ ,\X5/ ,-2/ D-28-BB.=;/ 2<2/ A-25-7.,-=2349<-8/M$-=/S8.=B-/0111NJ/,-2/--=/7338D.>/D-A<8-=7-/A<<;2-/D<9-=/7-/9352-/ :33;93=/ cJec/ ,-2-8C/ &-/ <9-8.;-/ F3387-=/ E.>=/ <=7-8/ 3=7-8-/ 34B<,52.;/ 6.2/ 7-/ (.9.-8B6=7.;-R=4<8,32.-,3G/93=/(.>B5F32-852332C/R=/7-E-/D-8-B-=.=;/,<-2/<,/q,r/6.2/2-/B6==-=/8-B-=-=?3/D-B-=7/E.>=C/I.-89<<8/F<872/--=/-Y283/.2-832.-5:3;/;-,33B2/<,/7-/>6.52-/F3387-/93=/?3/2-9.=7-=C

:)'5.- T"%'5.-

6780551 U((-;. R.)A."; 6780551 U((-;. R.)A.";

)F ^111 B;X,\ ?9 \`Jb ,^X0X5

)5 0ac1 B;X,\ , eJ`'P1c 5`X,\

&c1 1J110 , 69 1Jdc ,X5

5 1J11d ,\X5 m9 a1b ,\X5

m2 ^a11 ,\X5 m3 b^^ ,\X5

A9 cJec ,0X5 A3 eJ^^ ,

S2 0a1 , ?3 `^J0^ ,^X0X5

S9 ^`1 , !3 b^e ,0

S3 ^01 , 63 ^J1d ,X5

B9 1Je ,

B3 1Jc ,

U 1C` P

= c P

.9 eC1'P1c P

$3D-:/`P0f S-8-B-=.=;/,3Y.,3:-/7.-G2-/<=2;8<=7.=;55:-64/-=/7F3859-8A3=;

Page 50: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

4 – 8 WL | Delft Hydraulics

R=/$3D-:/`P\/E.>=/7-/F3387-=/;-;-9-=/,-2/--=/.=2-893:/93=/^1/,-2-8J/F338D.>/7-/83=7/93=/7-9352-/:33;/<9-8--=B<,2/,-2/^eb1/,-2-8/6.2/A-2/B8<,2-,.77-:G6=2/93=/7-/D<@A2C

V

W8X

"(

WYX

Q(

W89Z>Z$X

9&5F&[

WYX

A(

W8X

JF8.-4")+

^eb1 dJd/w/^1Pc `^Ja aaJa eJc\ =3352/9352-/:33;

^ee1 dJb/w/^1Pc `^Jc aaJb eJ\e

^ed1 eJ^/w/^1Pc `^J\ adJ0 eJ0\

^ea1 eJ\/w/^1Pc `^J0 adJa eJ1e

^ec1 eJc/w/^1Pc `^J1 adJb dJb`

^e`1 eJe/w/^1Pc `1Jb aeJ0 dJdb

^e\1 1C1111b `1Jd aeJa dJa` 3::69.33:

^e01 1C1111b `1Ja aeJb dJc1 /MD.==-=ND<@A2

^e^1 1C1111b `1J` abJ\ dJ\c

^e11 1C111^1 `1J\ abJd dJ0^

^db1 1C111^1 `1J^ d1J1 dJ1d

^de1 1C111^1 `1J1 d1J` aJb0

^dd1 1C111^^ \bJe d1Jb aJde 8-@A2-8<-9-8

$3D-:/`P\f S-8-B-=.=;/33=/7-/A3=7/93=/9-8;-:.>B.=;/M`C^eN

R=/$3D-:/`P\/;-;-9-=/F3387-/9<<8/7-/A<-B/ M^/<G/ CCN/B<,2/<=;-9--8/<9-8--=/,-2/38@5.=M,NM9<<8/ B:-.=-/ A<-B-=N/ R=/ ".;668/ `P\/ .5/ 7-/ D-8-B-=7-/ 7.-G2-/ 6.2;-E-2/ 2-;-=/ 7-/ 34523=7/ 2-=<GE.@A2-/93=/A-2/,.77-:G6=2/93=/7-/D<@A2J/F338.=/ 2-9-=5/--=/7F385G8<4.-:/ 2-8/ A<<;2-/ 93=B.:<,-2-8833./ b0aJc/ ;-,.77-:7/ <9-8/ 7-/ G-8.<7-/ ^bbb/ 2<2/ -=/ ,-2/ 011^/ -9-=--=5/ .5F--8;-;-9-=C/I.-86.2/D:.>B2/732/.=/F-8B-:.>BA-.7/--=/.-25/52-.:-8/23:67/9<<87<-2/73=/6.2/7-E-3=3:L2.5@A-/ D-8-B-=.=;/ =338/ 9<8-=/ B<,2C/ $-9-=5/ .5/ 7-/ ,3Y.,3:-/ 7.-G2-/ D-8-B-=7/ 6.2/ A-2;-,.77-:7-/93=/7-/D<7-,G-.:.=;-=/.-25/B:-.=-8/73=/,-2/D-A6:G/93=/3=3:L2.5@A-/D-8-B-=.=;J--=/9-85@A.:/93=/<=;-9--8/c/v/a/hC/I-2/2<23:-/AL7836:.5@A-/<GG-89:3B/M9<:;-=5/A-2/D-8-B-=7-;-,.77-:7-/93=/7-/D<7-,G-.:.=;-=N/.5/B:-.=-8/73=/3=3:L2.5@A/D-8-B-=7/M<=;-9--8/a/v/d/hNCO9-8/7-/D-8-B-=.=;/.5/=37-8A3=7/;--=/.>B.=;/,--8/6.2;-9<-87C

Page 51: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 4 – 9

Dwarsdoorsnede bodem

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

1750180018501900195020002050

afstand vh middelpunt van de bocht

Wat

erdi

epte

bij

Q=

1520

m3 /s

Berekend dwarsprofiel

Gemiddeld dwarsprofiel thv kmr 927(1999 t/m 2001)

".;668/`P\f S-8-B-=7/7F385G8<4.-:/-=/;-,-2-=/7F385G8<4.-:

R=/ ".;668/ `P`/ .5/ 7-/ 7.-G2-/ =3352/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ 33=;-;-9-=/ D.>/ --=/ ;-:.>BD:.>9-=7/ 7-D.-2Mmg^a11/ ,\X5NJ/ ,338/ --=/ 938.[8-=7-/ 5-7.,-=2349<-8C/ I.-86.2/ D:.>B2/ 732/ D.>/ ;8<2-8-D<7-,283=5G<82-=/7-/7.-G2-/,.=7-8/52-8B/34=--,2C

Ontgrondingsdiepte t.o.v. bodemtransport

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

0.00E+00 5.00E+05 1.00E+06 1.50E+06 2.00E+06 2.50E+06

Bodemtransport per jaar [m3/jaar]

Die

pte

naas

t va

ste

laag

[m

]

Diepte naast vaste laag

".;668/`P`f &.-G2-/-8<5.-5:-64/6.2;-E-2/2-;-=/938.[8-=7-/D<7-,283=5G<82

4.3 Maximale diepte met variërende aanleghoogte en breedte

&-E-:47-/D-8-B-=.=;/ME<3:5/x`C0N/.5/6.2;-9<-87/9<<8/9-85@A.::-=7-/33=:-;A<<;2-5/MA9N/93=/7-9352-/ :33;/ .=/ 9-8;-:.>B.=;/,-2/ 7-/ 7338D.>/ D-A<8-=7-/,3Y.,3:-/ 7.-G2-/ =3352/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;MA,3YNC/&-E-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/ E.>=/ 6.2;-9<-87/<,/--=/ .7--/ 2-/ B8.>;-=/F32/ 9<<8/ --=/ A<<;2-/ 7-9352-/ :33;/<=;-9--8/E<6/,<-2-=/A-DD-=/E<73=.;/732/--=/,.=7-8/7.-G-/-8<5.-;-6:/=3352/7-9352-/:33;/<=252332C/&-E-/A<<;2-/B3=/93=/D-:3=;/E.>=/D.>/-9-=26-:-/9-8:-=;.=;/93=/7-/9352-:33;/<,/7-/.=9:<-7/93=/7-/A<<;2-/-893=/<G/7-/3::69.3:-/D<7-,/2-/9-8;-:.>B-=C

Page 52: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

4 – 1 0 WL | Delft Hydraulics

S.>/7-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/E.>=/-9-=--=5/7-/F3387-=/;-D86.B2/E<3:5/.=/$3D-:/`P0/9-8,-:7/.5/D.>/7-.=9<-8;-;-9-=5C/ &.2/ :-9-82/ 7-/ 9<:;-=7-/ F3387-=/ <G/ .=/ 23D-:9<8,/ M$3D-:/ `P\NC/ I.-8D.>/ .5;-B<E-=/9<<8/ --=/ .=2-893:/ 93=/^1/,-2-8/ .=/ 7-/ 7F3858.@A2.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ 8.9.-8/ -=/ .5/ -8/ 93=6.2;-;33=/732/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ --=/D8--72-/ A--42/ 93=/ ^`1/,-2-8/ ME<3:5/ 7-E-/ D.>/ #.=2/!=78.-5/ .533=;-:-;7NC

!"#$%

&"W89Z>Z$X

'"#$(%

')#$(%

&)W89Z>Z$

$)

#*+,$(%

!-.$#$%

/)#$,*%

!$)0#$%

!$)01,1!"#2%

\Cc \1Cba 0c` ^0aa `\Cc0 dC^'P1c ^1Cb^ 1Cbd ^0C1` \C``

`C1 \0C1^ \0^ ^^bb `\C^` dC\'P1c ^1C\b 1Cba ^^C`b 0Ced

`Cc \0Cb\ \b` ^^0a `0Cd1 dCc'P1c bCe0 1Cba ^1Cee 0C`0

cC1 \\Cdc `d\ ^1`d `0C^b dCe'P1c bC01 1Cbc ^1C00 0C1`

cCc \`Cc1 ccd ba\ `^Ca1 eC^'P1c eCc0 1Cb` bCc^ ^Cd\

aC1 \cC^e a`d ed\ `1Cb^ eCa'P1c dCe1 1Cb\ eCd` ^C`a

aCc \cCe1 d`\ ddd `1C1b bC^'P1c dC1\ 1Cb0 dCb0 ^C00

dC1 \aC\e e`` ada \bC^0 bCe'P1c aC0^ 1Cb^ dC1` ^C1^

$3D-:/`P`f )38.3D-:-/33=:-;7.-G2-/9352-/:33;/93=/^`1/,/D8--7

S.>/ 7-/ 9<<8;33=7-/ D-8-B-=.=;-=/ .5/ -8/ 93=/ 6.2;-;33=J/ 732/ --=/ D-G33:7-/ A<-9--:A-.7/ F32-8<9-8/7-/9352-/:33;/528<<,2C/S.>/--=/7.-G-8/;-:-;-=/9352-/:33;/528<<,2/-8/765/,--8/F32-8/<9-87-/9352-/ :33;C/I-2/ <9-8.;-/ 7--:/F<872/ 34;-9<-87/ <9-8/ A-2/ 3::69.3:-/ 7--:/ -=/ E<8;2/ 9<<8/ A-2E3=7283=5G<82/<9-8/7-/D<7-,C/&-E-/8-7-=-8.=;/.5/-@A2-8/3::--=/;-:7.;/3:5/A-2/F32-8/732/<9-8A-2/3::69.3:-/7--:/528<<,2J/7-/@[email protected]/A--42/<,/7.2/283=5G<82/2-/D-F-8B52-::.;-=C/)<<8732/7.2G6=2/-@A2-8/F<872/D-8-.B2J/E3:/7-/A<<;2-/93=/7-/3::69.3:-/D<7-,/;8<2-8/E.>=/73=/7.-/93=/7-9352-/ :33;C/S.>/ --=/A<;-8-/3::69.3:-/D<7-,/73=/7-/9352-/ :33;/E3:/-8/E3=7/<G/7-/9352-/ :33;B<,-=/2-/:.;;-=/-=/A.-87<<8/.5/7-/3=3:L5-/5:-@A25/;-:7.;/2<2/7338/F338/A,3YXA9/;-:.>B/.5/33=/^C

&-/33=:-;7.-G2-/MA9/J/--852-/B<:<,N/6.2;-E-2/2-;-=/7-/,3Y.,3:-/7.-G2-/MA,3YN/<G/7-/:.=B-8/35-=/ 7-/ 9-8A<67.=;/ 2655-=/ D-.7-/ MA,3YXA9N/ <G/ 7-/ 8-@A2-8/ 35J/ :-9-82/ 7-/ 9<:;-=7-/ ;834.-B/ <GM".;668/`PcNC

Page 53: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 4 – 1 1

hmax tov hv

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

2 3 4 5 6 7 8

hv

h max

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

hm

ax /

hv

Waterdiepte direct naast vaste laag

verhouding hmax / hv

".;668/`Pcf (-:32.-/,3YC/7.-G2-/P/33=:-;A<<;2-J/93=/9352-/:33;/#2C/!=78.-5/MS9g^`1,N

)<<8;33=7-/.5/D-B-B-=/2-=/<GE.@A2-/93=/--=/@<=523=2-/D8--72-/93=/7-/9352-/ :33;C/&-E-:47-5<<82/ D-8-B-=.=;/ .5/ ;-733=/ ,-2/ --=/ @<=523=2-/ A<<;2-/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;J/ ,338/ ,-2/ --=938.3D-:-/D8--72-CI.-8/;-:72/-9-=--=5/F--8/--=/5<<82;-:.>B-/D-G-8B.=;/3:5/7-/A.-89<<8/D-28-44-=7-/33==3,-J732/ 3:/ A-2/ D<7-,283=5G<82/ 7<<8/ 7-/ D.==-=D<@A2/ ;332C/ S.>/ --=/ 9352-/ :33;/ <9-8/ 7-/ ;-A-:-D8--72-/E<6/9<:;-=5/7-/;-A3=2--87-/33==3,-/;--=/D<7-,283=5G<82/E.>=J/33=;-E.-=/-8/;--=3::69.3:-/D.==-=D<@A2/.5C/S.>/--=/9352-/:33;/<9-8/7-/;-A-:-/D8--72-/E<6/.=/F-8B-:.>BA-.7/765:-.7-=/2<2/5-7.,-=2/<G/7-/9352-/:33;C

3-.$W8X

4"W8X

4)W8X

'"#$(%

')#$(%

&)W89Z>Z$

$)

#*+,$(%

!-.$#$%

/)#$,*%

!$)0#$%

!$)01,14"#2%

^b11 1 0a1 1 ^c01 `1Cc eCb'P1c dC\d 1Cdb bC0b 0

^eb1 01 0`1 ed ^`\\ `1Cc eCe'P1c dC`^ 1Ce^ bC^e 1C`a

^ee1 `1 001 ^d` ^\`a `1Cc eCe'P1c dC`c 1Ce0 bC1b 1C0\

^ed1 a1 011 0a^ ^0cb `1Ca eCe'P1c dCc0 1Ce` bC10 1C^c

^ea1 e1 ^e1 \`e ^^d0 `1Cd eCd'P1c dCa1 1Cea eCbd 1C^^

^ec1 ^11 ^a1 `\c ^1ec `1Ce eCa'P1c dCd0 1Cee eCbc 1C1b

^e`1 ^01 ^`1 c00 bbe `^C1 eCc'P1c dCee 1Cb1 eCbe 1C1d

^e\1 ^`1 ^01 a1b b^^ `^C0 eC`'P1c eC^^ 1Cb` bC1d 1C1a

^e01 ^a1 ^11 aba e0` `^Cc eC0'P1c eC`c 1Cbe bC0d 1C1a

^e^1 ^e1 e1 de\ d\d `0C1 dCb'P1c eCbe ^C1\ bCaa 1C1c

^e11 011 a1 ed1 ac1 `0Cd dCc'P1c bCea ^C^1 ^1C`1 1C1c

$3D-:/`Pcf )38.3D-:-/D8--72-/9352-/:33;/93=/cJdb/,/33=:-;A<<;2-

Page 54: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

4 – 1 2 WL | Delft Hydraulics

&-/9-8A<67.=;/A,3YXS9/M:.=B-8/35N/-=/A,3Y/M8-@A2-8/35N/6.2;-E-2/2-;-=/7-/D8--72-/93=/7-/9352-:33;/:-9-82/7-/9<:;-=7-/;834.-B/M".;668/`PaNC

hmax tov Bv

0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0.3

0.35

0.4

0.45

0.5

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 240

Bv

h max

/ B

v

8

8.5

9

9.5

10

10.5

hm

ax

verhouding hmax / Bv

Waterdiepte direct naast vaste laag

".;668/`Paf (-:32.-/,3YC/7.-G2-/P/D8--72-/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/#2C/!=78.-5/MA9/g/cJdb/,N

4.4 Discussie

&-/9<:;-=7-/G6=2-=/F<87-=/=<;/<G;-,-8B2f

-. !:/A-2/D<7-,283=5G<82/F<872/9.3/7-/D.==-=D<@A2/;-283=5G<82--87&-E-/33==3,-/.5/93=/;8<<2/D-:3=;/D.>/7-/;-:7.;A-.7/93=/7-/;-D86.B2-/,-2A<7-/<,,-2/D-A6:G/93=/3=3:L2.5@A-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/7-/7.-G2-/=3352/7-/9352-/ :33;/2-/D-G3:-=C&-/;-:7.;A-.7/A.-893=/.5/ .=/A-2/D-;.=/93=/7-/9352-/ :33;/=.-2/ >6.52C/&-/ :<@32.-/F338;--=/E3=7/,--8/<9-8/7-/9352-/ :33;/F<872/;-283=5G<82--87J/ .5/ .=/7.2/ <=7-8E<-B/=.-2D-B-B-=C/ '@A2-8/ 9<:;-=5/ 7-/ ;-D86.B2-/ D8<==-=/ -=/ 33=/ 7-/ A3=7/ 93=/ ,6:2.D-3,PG-.:.=;-=/.5/F-:/76.7-:.>B/732/A-2/5-7.,-=2/93=/7-/D6.2-=D<@A2/E.@A/9-8G:33252/=3387-/D.==-=D<@A2/-=/;--=/E3=7/,--8/<9-8/A-2/D-=-7-=528<<,5-/7--:/93=/7-/9352-/:33;;332C

-. !Y.33:P5L,,-28.5@A-/528<,.=;R=/ 7-/ D-8-B-=.=;-=/ F<872/ -893=/ 6.2;-;33=/ 732/ 3Y.33:P5L,,-28.5@A-/ 528<,.=;<G28--72C/&-/33=G355.=;5:-=;2-/93=/7-/F32-8528<,.=;/ .5/ B:-.=-8/ 73=/7-/ 33=F-E.;-:-=;2-/ 93=/ 7-/ D<@A2C/ '@A2-8/ E3:/ 7-/ .7-3:-/ 3Y.33:P5L,,-28.5@A-/ 528<,.=;/ E.@A/ =.-29<::-7.;/ A<-9-=/ 9<<8/ 2-/ 7<-=J/ A.-8/ E6::-=/ 7<<8/ 3=7-8/ 43@2<8-=/ 9-852<8.=;-=/ .=<G28-7-=C/ &<<8/ D.>9<<8D--:7/ --=/ 9-85@A.::-=7/ D<7-,9-8:<<GJ/ ;--=/ ;-:.>B,32.;-D<<;5283:-=/ -=/ 528-B73,,-=C/ R=/ 7-/ D-8-B-=.=;/ .5/ A.-8/ -@A2-8/ ;--=/ 8-B-=.=;,--;-A<67-=/ -=/ .5/ ,[email protected]=/ =.-2/ 7-/ >6.52-/ F--8;39-/ 93=/ 7-/ F-8B-:.>BA-.7D-5@A8-9-=C

Page 55: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 4 – 1 3

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

-. +-D86.B/?AZELPF3387-/<4/7-/BPF3387-/93=/Q.B68375-S.>/7-/3=3:L2.5@A-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/.5/;-D86.B/;-,33B2/93=/--=/9352-/BPF3387-/,-2/--=733833=/ ;-B<GG-:7-/ ?AZELPF3387-/ 7.-/ 938.--82/ ,-2/ 7-/ F32-87.-G2-C/ &-/ B-6E-A.-89<<8/ .5/ ;-D35--87/ <G/ A-2/ 379.-5/ ;-;-9-=/ .=/)3=/ 7-8/U33.>/ M^bb`N/ <,/ D.>/ --=9352-/ :33;/ 2-/ 8-B-=-=/,-2/ --=/BPF3387-C/S.>/ 7-/ D-8-B-=.=;-=/,-2/&-:42\&/ .5/ A.-8-@A2-8/ 93=/ 34;-E.-=/<,732/ --=/ @<=523=2-/ BPF3387-/9<<8/ --=/ 3::69.3:-/ D<7-,J/,-2938.[8-=7-/ 76.=A<<;2-5J/ ,.=7-8/ 8-[-:/ F<872/ ;-3@A2/ 73=/ --=/ @<=523=2-/ ?AZELPF3387-C/i<3:5/A.-89<<8/3:/33=;-;-9-=/:.>B2/--=/@<=523=2-/BPF3387-/D.>/--=/9352-/:33;8-[-:J/<,732/7-E-/F-.=.;/9-83=7-82/.=/A<<;2-C/'@A2-8/9<<8/7-/3::69.3:-/D<7-,/.5/--=@<=523=2-/BPF3387-/7.5@623D-:J/E-:45/D.>/--=/@<=523=2-/349<-8J/<,732/7-/76.=-=/E.@A7<<8/7-/8.9.-8/9-8G:3325-=/-=/E<7<-=7-/765/<<B/7-/7338D.>/D-A<8-=7-/86FA-.7C

-. ?<=523=2-/349<-8/MmN)<<8/7-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/.5/;-D86.B/;-,33B2/93=/--=/@<=523=2-/349<-8/MmNC/&-E-/B-6E-.5/;-,33B2/<,/7-/D-8-B-=7-/7.-G2-/2-/B6==-=/9-8;-:.>B-=/,-2/7-/;-,.77-:7-/7.-G2-93=/7-/,6:2.D-3,PD<7-,G-.:.=;-=/93=/\/ >338C/I.-8D.>/ .5/7-/[email protected]/93=D-:3=;C/ V-2/ 7-E-/ ,-2A<7-/ F<872/ 765/ =.-2/ A-2/ 7.-G52/ ,<;-:.>B-/ G6=2/ 93=/ 7-<=2;8<=7.=;55:-64/D-8-B-=7J/7.-/D.>/--=/A<;-8-/349<-8/<G/E3:/28-7-=C/&-8A3:9-/;--427-/ 7.-G2-/ 93=/7-/ D-8-B-=.=;/ --=/ [email protected]/ 93=/7-/ ;-9<:;-=/93=/ --=/ 9-85@A.::-=7-33=:-;D8--72-/ <4/ A<<;2-/ -=/ .=/ ,.=7-8-/ ,32-/ 7-/ 7.-G2-/ 93=/ <=7-8,.>=.=;/ 93=/ 7-9352-/ :33;C/S.>/ --=/ ;8<2-8-/ 349<-8/ E3:/ 7-/ A-::.=;/ 93=/ A-2/ 23:67/ .=/ 7-/ D.==-=D<@A252-.:-8/F<87-=/-=/D.>/--=/;-:.>B-/=322-/7<<85=-7-/--=/;8<2-8-/7.-G2-/=3352/7-/9352-:33;/;-9-=C

-. I<-9--:A-.7/93=/A-2/>338:.>B5/MD<7-,N5-7.,-=2283=5G<82&-/D-8-B-=.=;/.5/6.2;-9<-87/,-2/ZZ=/9352-/A<-9--:A-.7/5-7.,-=2283=5G<82C/&-/7.-G2-93=/ 7-/ <=2;8<=7.=;55:-64/ 9-83=7-82/ D.>/ --=/ 3=7-8-/ A<-9--:A-.7/ 283=5G<82/ -=/ --=;-:.>BD:.>9-=7/ 7-D.-2C/ &-/ 938.32.-/ .=/ 5-7.,-=2283=5G<82/ A--42/ -@A2-8/ --=/ B:-.=-938.32.-/<G/7-/7.-G2-/2<2/;-9<:;/E.-/".;668/`P\C

Page 56: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

4 – 1 4 WL | Delft Hydraulics

Page 57: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 5 – 1

5 Analyse met behulp van ArcView

5.1 Inleiding

R=/ 7.2/ A<<47526B/ F<87-=/ 7-/ D-:3=;8.>B52-/ @<=@:65.-5/ -=/ D.>E<=7-8A-7-=/ ;-,-:7/ 7.-/ =3389<8-=/E.>=/;-B<,-=/6.2/7-/3=3:L5-/,-2/D-A6:G/93=/!8@).-F/6.2;-9<-87/D.>/(.>B5F32-852332P&OQC/ [email protected]/ <<52PQ-7-8:3=7N/ !8@).-F/ .5/ --=/ +R#PG8<;83,,3/ M+-<;834.5@A/ R=4<8,32.-#L52--,NJ/,-2/=3,-/D-7<-:7/<,/7323/2-/G8-5-=2-8-=J/,338/F338,--/<<B/--=/33=23:/5.,G-:-3=3:L5-5/B6==-=/F<87-=/6.2;-9<-87/M<G2-::-=J/3428-BB-=/-=/5<,,-8-=/93=/86.,2-:.>B-/7323NCR=/D.>:3;-/'/.5/7-/3=3:L5-/6.2;-D8-.7-8/D-5@A8-9-=J/F338/73=/<<B/A--=/9-8F-E-=/F<872/9<<8=37-8-/.=4<8,32.-C

)<<8/7-/3=3:L5-/.5/--=/33=23:/-Y283/-Y2-=5.-5/93=/!8@).-F/;-D86.B2J/7.-/;-7--:2-:.>B/[email protected]:9<<8/ (.>B5F32-852332/ M(H#N/ E.>=/ <=2F.BB-:7C/ R=/ A-2/ D.>E<=7-8/ #G32.3:/ !=3:L52/ M9<<8/ A-2B6==-=/D-F-8B-=/93=/7323N/-=/7-/-Y2-=5.-/)338;-6:/M93=/(H#/&[email protected]/Q<<87E--/9<<8/A-2,3B-=/ 93=/ G8<4.-:-=J/ :3=;5/ --=/ E-:4/ 2-/ 7-4.=.[8-=/ :.>=NC/ Q3352/ 7-/ ;-D86.B2-/ G-.:.=;-=/ -=;-;-9-=5/ME<3:5/E.>=/<G;-=<,-=/.=/D.>:3;-/!N/E.>=/-8/=<;/3=7-8-/;-;-9-=5/;-D86.B2J/7.-/7<<8(.>B5F32-852332/E.>=/2<-;-:-9-87C/I-2/;332/A.-8D.>/,-2/=3,-/<,/2<G<;834.5@A-/<=7-8;8<=7-=J:6@A24<2<o5J/ 9338;-6:PJ/ :33;F32-8D-7P/ -=/ A<<;F32-8D-7D-;8-=E.=;-=/ -=/ 8.9.-8B.:<,-28-8.=;C)3=/7-/9-85@A.::-=7-/D<@A2-=/F<87-=/7-/9<:;-=7-/<=7-8F-8G-=/D-5@A8-9-=f

-. &.,-=5.-5/-=/<=2;8<=7.=;-=/Mx/cC0Ns-. $.>79-8:<<G/<=2;8<=7.=;-=/-=/33=E3=7.=;-=/Mx/cC\Ns-. )338D33=D8--72-/9<<8/-=/=3/7-/33=:-;/Mx/cC`Ns-. *3=;59-8A3=;/Mx/cCcNs-. &F3859-8A3=;/Mx/cCaNC

R=/7-/4.;68-=/,-2/,6:2.D-3,PG-.:.=;-=/.5/--=/3=7-8-/:-;-=73/;-D86.B2/73=/7-/.=/A<<47526B/\F--8;-;-9-=/<9-8E.@A254.;68-=/D.>/7-/D-5@A8.>9.=;/93=/7-/D<@A2-=J/8-7-=/A.-89<<8/.5/732/--=2-/ ;-7-23.::--87-/ F--8;39-=/ <=<9-8E.@A2-:.>B/ F-87J/ 9<<8/ 7-/ 9--:3:/ B:-.=-8-/ 4.;68-=/ .=/ 7.2A<<47526BC

5.2 Dimensies ontgrondingen

R=/A-2/3:;-,--=/B3=/F<87-=/;-52-:7/732/7-/-8<5.-;32-=/D-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/7-/9352-/:3;-=/XD<7-,B8.DD-=/ 98.>/ 523D.-:/ E.>=/ .=/ 7-/ 2.>7C/ &-/ <=2;8<=7.=;-=/ =3352/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ 93=/ #.=2!=78.-5/ E.>=/ >6.52/ E--8/ 938.[8-=7s/ 7.2/ ;-:72/ 9<<8/ E<F-:/ 7-/ 7.-G2-/ -=/ :-=;2-/ 3:5/ 7-/ :<@32.--893=C

I-2/ -8<5.-;32/ D-=-7-=528<<,5/ D.>/ #.=2/ !=78.-5/ A--42/ 7-/ ;8<<252-/ 34,-2.=;-=/ ,-2/ --=;-,.77-:7-/:-=;2-/93=/D.>=3/a11/,-2-8C/I-2/-8<5.-;32/D.>/Q.>,-;-=/.5/F32/B:-.=-8J/,338/A--42--=/:-=;2-/93=/;-:.>B-/<87-J/<=;-9--8/c11/,-2-8C

Page 58: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

5 – 2 WL | Delft Hydraulics

I-2/-8<5.-;32/D.>/'8:-@<,/.5/33=E.-=:.>B/B:-.=-8f/7-/:-=;2-/.5/<=;-9--8/011/,-2-8C/&-/D8--72-93=/7-/<=2;8<=7.=;/B<,2/D.>/3::-/78.-/7-/D<@A2-=/F-:/8-7-:.>B/,-2/-:B338/<9-8--=J/=3,-:.>B.=/7-/<87-/93=/^11/,-2-8C/H338D.>/7-E-/D8--72-/D.>/3::-/78.-/7-/D<@A2-=/98.>/523D.-:/.5/.=/7-:<<G/93=/7-/2.>7/-=/F-.=.;/.=9:<-7/9-82<<=2/93=/7-/349<-8C/&-E-/D8--72-/A3=;2/F3385@A.>=:.>B52-8B/ 53,-=/ ,-2/ 7-/ D8--72-/ 93=/ 7-/ D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;5@<[email protected]/ )3=34/ A-2/ -.=7-MD-=-7-=528<<,5N/ 93=/ 7-/ D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;5@<[email protected]/ F<872/ A-2/ -8<5.-;32/ 93=34/ A-2D-;.=J/F338/A-2/7-/,3Y.,3:-/D8--72-/A--42J/52--75/5,3::-8C

&-/ ;-,.77-:7-/ 7.-G2-/ 93=/ 7-/ -8<5.-;32-=/ E.>=/ 3::-,33:/ 93=/ 7-E-:47-/ <87-/ 93=/ ;8<<22-JF338D.>/7.-/93=/#.=2/!=78.-5/.-25/;8<2-8/.5/2-=/<GE.@A2-/93=/A-2/8-4-8-=2.-9:3B/M'8:-@<,/cJ\`,J/Q.>,-;-=/cJ\d/,/-=/#.=2/!=78.-5/cJb1/,NC/&-/;-,.77-:7-/,3Y.,3:-/ 7.-G2-/ .5/ .=/#.=2!=78.-5/A-2/;8<<252-J/=3,-:.>B/eJb1/,/F32/86.,/0Jc/,/,--8/.5/73=/'8:-@<,/-=/Q.>,-;-=J/7.-D-.7-/7-E-:47-/<87-/93=/;8<<22-/A-DD-=/MaJ^\/,/8-5GC/aJ\d/,NC

S.>/7-/3=3:L5-/.5/;-D86.B/;-,33B2/93=/7-/[email protected]/,6:2.D-3,/G-.:.=;-=C/&-/[email protected].=;:-D-3,/G-.:.=;-=/M93=/9<<8/^bbbN/E.>=/D6.2-=/D-5@A<6F.=;/;-:32-=/93=F-;-/9-85@A.::-=2655-=/ 7-/ 5.=;:-D-3,/ -=/,6:2.D-3,/ G-.:.=;-=C/ $-9-=5/ 7.-=2/ <G;-,-8B2/ 2-/ F<87-=/ 732/ 7-,62:.D-3,/G-.:.=;-=/93=/^bbbJ/9<<8/7-/D<@A2/ .=/#.=2/!=78.-5J/,-2.=;-=/E.>=/7.8-@2/=3/A-2;-8--7/ B<,-=/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ .=/ -.=7/ 7-@-,D-8/ M<G:-9-8.=;/ D-;.=/ ^bbbNC/ &-/ D<@A2-='8:-@<,/-=/Q.>,-;-=/E.>=/;-8--7/5.=75/^bba/[email protected]:.>B/^bee/-=/A-DD-=/,--8/2.>7/;-A37<,/2<2/--=/-9-=F.@A252<-523=7/2-/B<,-=C

S.>/#.=2/!=78.-5/=--,2/7-/,3Y.,3:-/7.-G2-/-=/7-/;-,.77-:7-/7.-G2-/93=/7-/<=2;8<=7.=;-==<;/52--75/2<-/.=/7-/2.>7C/&-/D-5@A<6F7-/G-.:.=;-=/52382-=/7.8-@2/=3/7-/33=:-;/93=/7-/9352-:33;/ .=/ #.=2/ !=78.-5C/ &.2/ E<6/ 765/ 76.7-=/ <G/ --=/ =<;/ =.-2/ D-8-.B2/ [email protected]/ &-;-,.77-:7-/ 7.-G2-/ 9-82<<=2/ -@A2-8/ --=/ B:-.=-/ 523=7338734F.>B.=;/ 2-=/ <GE.@A2-/ 93=/ A-2;-,.77-:7-/F32/D-2-B-=2/732/A-2/-8<5.-;32/=3/33=:-;/E--8/5=-:/.5/9-87.-G2/-=/=6/=36F-:.>B5=<;/2<-=--,2C/&.2/:.>B2/.=/<9-8--=52-,,.=;/,-2/7-/F338=-,.=;/732/7-/-8<5.-/3:/ 2.>7-=5/7-33=:-;/.5/<G;-28-7-=/M'-87-=J/011^NC

I-2/ =<;/ 3:2.>7/ <G28-7-=/ 93=/ -8<7-8-=/ -=/ 5-7.,-=2-8-=/ :.>B2/ -9-=--=5/ .=/ <9-8--=52-,,.=;,-2/U:3355-=/-=/#:<44/M0111N/F338/9<<8/;8<-./-=/7-,G.=;/93=/0&P9-85@A.>=5-:-=/2.>75@A3:-=E.>=/9-8,-:7/93=/-=B-:-/>38-=C

&-/<=2;8<=7.=;55:-64J/7.-/E.@A/3::--=/D.>/#.=2/!=78.-5/9<<87<-2J/A--42/--=/938.[8-=7-/7.-G2-J:-=;2-/-=/:<@32.-C/)<<8/7-/34,-2.=;-=/93=/7-E-/<=2;8<=7.=;55:-64/.5/;--=/76.7-:.>B-/8-:32.-,-2/7-/349<-8C/&.-/;-:72/9<<8/E<F-:/7-/ 2<23:-/ :-=;2-/3:5/7-/,3Y.,3:-/7.-G2-C/H-:/ .5/D.>/7-D-8-B-=.=;/93=/7-/;-,.77-:7-/D<7-,7.-G2-/93=/7-/5:-64/76.7-:.>B/;-F<87-=/732/7-E-/@.8@3^J1/2<2/^J`/,-2-8/<=7-8/7-/D<9-=B3=2/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/:.;2C/&-/@<[email protected]/7.B2-/93=/7-/9352-:33;/ .5/ ;-,.77-:7/ <=;-9--8/ ^/ ,-2-8J/ F32/ 765/ D-2-B-=2/ 732/ 7-/ D<7-,/ =3352/ 7-/ 9352-;-,.77-:7/;-:.>B/<4/:3;-8/:.;2/73=/7-/<=7-8B3=2/93=/7-/9352-/:33;C

Page 59: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 5 – 3

5.3 Tijdsverloop ontgrondingen en aanzandingen

'8/ B6==-=/ ;8<4F-;/ 2F--/ @<=@:65.-5/ ;-28<BB-=/ F<87-=C/ &-/ --852-/ .5/ 732/ 7-/ -8<5.-;32-=D-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/7-/D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;5@<[email protected]/98.>/ 523D.-:/E.>=C/&-/ 2F--7-/ .5/7327-/ 5-7.,-=232.-D6:2-=/ >6.52/ =.-2/ 523D.-:/ E.>=C/ &-/ .=523D.:.2-.2/ 93=/ 7-/ 5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/ .5F3385@A.>=:.>B/ --=/ 5@A.>=/ .=523D.:.2-.2/ 732/ --=/ 7.8-@2/ ;-9<:;/ 93=/ 7-/ 6.2;-9<-87-D3;;-8F-8BE33,A-7-=C

)<<8/7-/D<@A2-=/Q.>,-;-=/-=/'8:-@<,/D:.>B2/732/7-/7.-G2-J/9-8<<8E33B2/7<<8/F-89-:52832-=J;8<2-8/ .5/ 73=/7-/ 7.-G2-/ 9-8<<8E33B2/ 2-=/ ;-9<:;-/ 93=/7-/ D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;5@<[email protected]/ R=#.=2/!=78.-5/7338-=2-;-=/.5/7-/7.-G2-/93=/7-/<=2;8<=7.=;/3@A2-8/7-/9352-/:33;/;8<2-8/73=/7-7.-G2-/9-8<<8E33B2/7<<8/7-/B8.DD-=C

)-87-8/ D:.>B2/ 732/ 7-/ [email protected]/ D3;;-8;-;-9-=5/ <=9<:7<-=7-/ E.>=/ <,/ --=/ 8-:32.-/ <G/ 2-52-::-=/ 2655-=/ 7-/ 349<-8/ -=/ 7-/ -8<5.-/ @pC/ 5-7.,-=232.-/ D-=-7-=528<<,5/ 93=/ 7-D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;5@<[email protected]/$-9-=5/.5/93=/--=/33=23:/G-.:.=;-=/7-/7326,/93=/7-/,-2.=;<=D-B-=7/<4/.5/7-/33=;-;-9-=/D3;;-8G-8.<7-/2-/86.,/<,/--=/=36FB-68.;-/3=3:L5-/,<;-:.>B2-/,3B-=C

5.4 Vaarbaanbreedte voor en na de aanleg

R=/ A-2/ 3:;-,--=/;-:72/ 732/ 7-/ D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;5@<[email protected]/ --=/9-8D8-7.=;/93=/7-/ D<@A2<G:-9-8-=C/ &-/ 9352-/ :33;/ .=/ Q.>,-;-=/ A--42/ 7-/ ;8<<252-/ 9-8D8-7.=;/ <G;-:-9-87J/ 7.2/ B<,2F3385@A.>=:.>B/<=7-8,--8/7<<8732/7-/D8--72-/9<<8/7-/33=:-;/E--8/B:-.=/F35/ M<=;-9--8/^^1,NC/&-/D<@A2/.=/'8:-@<,/A--42/7-/B:-.=52-/9-8D8-7.=;/<G;-:-9-87J/,338/.5/.=/<87-/93=/;8<<22--9-=/D8--7/3:5/7-/D<@A2/.=/Q.>,-;-=C/&<<8/7-/33=E3=7.=;-=/D-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/7-/9352-:33;/D.>/Q.>,-;-=/<=252332/-@A2-8/9-85,3::.=;/93=/7-/8.9.-8C/&-/D<7-,B8.DD-=/D.>/'8:-@<,E<8;-=/9<<8/--=/<=;-9--8/9-8;-:.>BD38-/9338D33=D8--72-/3:5/7-/9352-/:33;/.=/Q.>,-;-=C

5.5 Langsverhang

I-2/ 9-8:<<G/ 93=/ A-2/ :3=;59-8A3=;/ .=/ 7-/ D<7-,/ .=/ 7-/ D.==-=D<@A2-=/ .5/ 9<<8/ 3::-/ 78.-/ 7-D<@A2-=/ E--8/ 938.[8-=7J/ A-2/ ;-,.77-:7-/ D<7-,9-8:<<G/ :332/ D.>/ --=/ ;-,.77-:7-/ 93=/ \/ >338=<;/52--75/--=/q;8.::.;r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

5.6 Dwarsverhang

)<<8/3::-/78.-/7-/D<@A2-=/;-:72/732/A-2/9-8:<<G/93=/7-/7F385A-::.=;/52-8B/F<872/D-G33:7/7<<87-/ 33=F-E.;A-.7/ 93=/ B8.DD-=C/V-2/ =3,-/ .=/ 7-/ D<@A2/ 93=/ #.=2/ !=78.-5/ .5/ ;--=/ 76.7-:.>B9-8:<<G/ 93=/ A-2/ 7F3859-8A3=;/ 2-/ A-8B-==-=C/ R=/ 7-/ D<@A2/ 93=/ #.=2/ !=78.-5/ B<,2/ F-:/ 7-<=2;8<=7.=;/.=/7-/D.==-=D<@A2/=3352/7-/9352-/:33;/=338/9<8-=C

Page 60: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

5 – 4 WL | Delft Hydraulics

Q3352/7-/9352-/:33;/.=/Q.>,-;-=/28--72/E<o=/<=2;8<=7.=;55:-64/=.-2/<GC/)<<8/A-2/F-:/<4/=.-2<G28-7-=/93=/<=2;8<=7.=;-=/=3352/7-/D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;/E.>=/--=/33=23:/,<;-:.>B-/<<8E3B-=7.-/.=/7-/3=3:L5-/=338/9<8-=/B<,-=f

-. 8-:32.-9-/A<<;2-/9352-/:33;s-. 8-:32.-9-/D8--72-/9352-/:33;s-. =.-2/9<::-7.;/3Y.33:P5L,,-28.5@A-/528<,.=;s-. D<@A252833:/-=/5@A-8G2-/93=/7-/D<@A2s-. :-=;2-/93=/7-/D<@A2s-. .=9:<-7/B8.DD-=/-=/G.>:-85/-=/8.9.-8D-;8-=E.=;C

&-/7.-G2-/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/.=/Q.>,-;-=/.5/93=/;-:.>B-/<87-/3:5/7.-/ .=/#.=2/!=78.-5/MD-.7-<=;-9--8/\Jc1/,/<=7-8/A-2/8-4-8-=2.-9:3BNC/&-/D<9-=B3=2/93=/7-/D<7-,B8.DD-=/A-DD-=/--=9-8;-:.>BD38-/7.-G2-/93=/\Jc1/,-2-8/2-=/<GE.@A2-/93=/A-2/8-4-8-=2.-9:3BC/I.-87<<8/E<6/-8/;--=9-85@A.:/2-/9-8F3@A2-=/E.>=C/&-/8-:32.-9-/D8--72-/93=/7-/D<7-,D-5@A-8,.=;5@<[email protected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cc</2655-=/7-/8-@A2523=7-=/9<<8/-=/=3/7-/D<@A2/.=/Q.>,-;-=/.5/732/dc<C/R=/7-/D<@A2D.>/ '8:-@<,/ .5/ -9-=--=5/ ;--=/ 5G83B-/ 93=/ --=/ <=2;8<=7.=;55:-64J/ 7-/ 7.-G2-/ 2655-=/ 7-D<7-,B8.DD-=/<=7-8:.=;/9-85@A.:2/F-:C/&.2/ 9-85@A.:/F<872/F3385@A.>=:.>B/ 9-8<<8E33B2/ 7<<8:<B3:-/9-85@A.>=5-:-=/E<3:5/B8.D9:3,,-=C/$-8/G:3325-/93=/7-E-/:<B33:/7.-G-8-/<=2;8<=7.=;-=<=252332/ --=/ 7F3859-8A3=;/ ME.-/ D.>9<<8D--:7/ D.>:3;-/ 'J/ ".;668/ 'P\^J/ ,-2/ =3,-7F3857<<85=-7-/ "P"o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

Page 61: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 5 – 5

5.7 Discussie

&-/9<:;-=7-/G6=2-=/F<87-=/=<;/<G;-,-8B2f

-. "<62-=/.=/7-/,--2;-;-9-=5/ME.-/D.>:3;-/&N&-/ 3=3:L5-/ 7.-/ 6.2;-9<-87/ .5/ ,-2/ D-A6:G/ 93=/ !8@).-F/ A3=;2/ 52-8B/ 34/ 93=/ 7-;-D86.B2-/ ;-;-9-=5C/ S.>/ A-2/ 9-8E3,-:-=/ A.-893=/ D:--B/ <G/ --=/ 33=23:/ G6=2-=/ 7329-85@A.::-=7-/ 4<62-=/ .=/ 7-/ ;-;-9-=5/ E.22-=/ 7.-/ 7-/ D-28<6FD338A-.7/ -893=/ B6==-=D-W=9:<-7-=C/ )<<8/ --=/ <G5<,,.=;/ 93=/ ,<;-:.>B-/ 4<62-=/ F<872/ 9-8F-E-=/ =338D.>:3;-/&C/)<<8/--=/33=23:/G-.:.=;-=/.5/D-B-=7/732/-8/4<62-=/.=/E.22-=/<4/732/;-;-9-=5,.55-=C/i</.5/93=/5<,,.;-/G-.:.=;-=/=.-2/D-B-=7/F3==--8/E-/[email protected]/E.>=/;-,-2-=.=/A-2/D-28-44-=7-/;-D.-7/-=/.5/3:5/33==3,-/A-2/,.77-=/93=/7-/33=;-;-9-=/G-8.<7-;-D86.B2C/I.-87<<8/ <=252332/ 765/ --=/ E-B-8-/ <==36FB-68.;A-.7C/ )-87-8/ E.>=/ -8/ =<;9-85@A.::-=/ 2655-=/ D.>9<<8D--:7/ 7-/ ,--2,-2A<7-/ F338,--/ 7-/ 9-85@A.::-=7-G-.:.=;-=/E.>=/;-,-2-=C/)3=/7.2/5<<82/,<;-:.>B-/4<62-=/.5/=.-2/D-B-=7/F32/7-/;8<<22--=/8.@A2.=;/.5/-=/B3=/A-2/9<<8B<,-=/732/3::-/B:-.=-/9-8F338:<<5D38-/4<62-=/2-/53,-==.-2/,--8/9-8F338:<<5D338/E.>=C/'@A2-8/.5/-8/;--=/<=7-8E<-B/;-733=/=338/7-/;8<<22--=/5G8-.7.=;/93=/7-/4<62-=C/&-/,<;-:.>B-/4<62-=/F<87-=/3::--=/9-8,-:7C

-. S-G3:.=;/93=/A-2/;-7--:2-/F32/2<2/-8<5.-;32J/P5:-64/<4/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/A<<82)<<8/ 7-/ D-G3:.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ <,93=;/ 93=/ 7-/ 9-85@A.>=5-:-=/ 8<=7/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ E.>=9-85@A.::-=7-/ ,-2A<7-=/ <,/ 7-E-/ 2-/ D-G3:-=J/ <=7-8/ 3=7-8-/ D.>9<<8D--:7f:33;52-XA<<;52-/G6=2J/9<:6,-5J/D8--72-X:-=;2-J/:<@32.-/2-=/<GE.@A2-/93=/7-/9352-/:33;<4/9-85@A.:/,-2/5.2632.-/9<<8/7-/33=:-;/93=/7-/9352-/ :33;C/H32/D-28-42/7-/;-7--:2-5F338/ -8<5.-/ <G28--72/ .5/ ;-B-B-=/ =338/ 7-/,3Y.,3:-/ 7.-G2-J/,338/ -9-=--=5/ =338/ 7-D8--72-/ -=/ :-=;2-C/ V-2/ =3,-/ 7.-/ :33252-/ 2F--/ E.>=/ E--8/ 34A3=B-:.>B/ 93=/ F338/ E-;-,-2-=/F<87-=J/732/F.:/E-;;-=/<G/F-:B-/7.-G2-C/&-/7.-G2-/<4/D<7-,A<<;2-/F<872D-G33:7/7<<8/F32/3::-,33:/2<2/-8<5.-;32/@Cp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

Page 62: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

5 – 6 WL | Delft Hydraulics

-. S3;;-8;-;-9-=5/<=9<::-7.;%.2/ 7-/ D-8-B-=.=;-=/ D:.>B2/ 732/ <G/ D-G33:7-/ ,<,-=2-=/ E--8/ 9--:/ -8<5.-/ <45-7.,-=232.-/ .5/;-F--52/ 2-=/<GE.@A2-/93=/3=7-8-/G-8.<7-=C/H3385@A.>=:.>B/ .5/ 732/ 2-F.>2-=/.5/33=/A-2/<=2D8-B-=/93=/D3;;-8;-;-9-=5/F32/G-8/7-4.=.2.-/:-.72/2<2/--=/<=>6.52D--:7/ 93=/ A-2/ ;-@<88.;--87-/ 9-8:<<G/ 93=/ 7-/ D<7-,/ 8<=7/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;C/ &-D3;;-8;-;-9-=5/ E.>=/ 9-8B8-;-=/ 9.3/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ D8<==-=/ M6.2/ 9-85@A.::-=7-D-52-BB-=J/E.-/D.>:3;-/!N/F3387<<8/=.-2/76.7-:.>B/ .5/A<-/7-/<=7-8:.=;-/9-8A<67.=;2655-=/ 7-/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ ;-D86.B2-/ F3387-=/ .5f/ D.>9<<8D--:7/ .=/ A-2/ F-8B/ ;-,-2-=B6D.-B-/ ,-2-85J/ <G/ A-2/ [email protected]/ ;-,-2-=J/ <G/ 7-/ 52<82J/ 9<:;-=5/ (.>B5F32-852332/ <49<:;-=5/A-2/D3;;-8D-78.>4/MA.-8/,3;/D.>/--=/E-:47-/,-2A<7-/=32668:.>B/;--=/9-85@A.:.=/E.22-=NC

-. S-G3:.=;/;-,.77-:7-/<9-8/--=/D-G-8B2/33=23:/G-.:.=;-=&<<8/ A-2/ =.-2/ ;-D86.B-=/ 93=/ 7-/ 5.=;:-D-3,PG-.:.=;-=/ F<872/ 7-/ 73235-2/ ,-2,--2;-;-9-=5/D-G-8B2/2<2/\/>338C/I.-8D.>/E.>=/9<<8/3::-/\/7-/D<@A2-=/F-:/7-/,-2.=;-=;-D86.B2/<9-8/A-2/E-:47-/2.>75D-52-BC/S.>/#.=2/!=78.-5/E.>=/7.2/-@A2-8/F-:/7-/,-2.=;-=7.8-@2/=3/7-/33=:-;/-=/ .5/=<;/;--=/5G83B-/93=/--=/ [email protected]/ -=/ 73387<<8,.=7-8/;<-7/9-8;-:.>BD338/ 2655-=/7-/ D<@A2-=/<=7-8:.=;C/&<<8732/ 7-/ D<7-,:.;;.=;D-B-B-=/.5/<9-8/--=/G-8.<7-/93=/\/>338/.5/A-2/33=23:/,-2.=;-=/.=/E-B-8-/E.=/D-G-8B2C&.2/B<,2/<=7-8/3=7-8-/2-86;/.=/7-/;-,.77-:7-/D<7-,:.;;.=;/E<3:5/F--8;-;-9-=/.=9-85@A.::-=7-/G8<4.-:-=C/'-=/;8<2-8-/73235-2/9-8;8<<2/7-/5232.52.5@A-/=36FB-68.;A-.793=/A-2/;-,.77-:7/D<7-,9-8:<<GC

Page 63: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 6 – 1

6 Opzet en ijking van Delft3D voor SintAndries

6.1 Inleiding

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f/ &-:42\&P"*OH/ -=/ &-:42\&PVO(/ M,-2/ &-:42\&P$(!Q/ -=&-:42\&PSO$NJ/ 7-E-/ D-8-B-=-=/ [email protected]:.>B/ 7-/ 528<,.=;/ -=/ 7-/ 7338D.>/ D-A<8-=7-,<84<:<;.5@A-/ 9-83=7-8.=;-=/ 93=/ 7-/ D<7-,C/Q3352/ 7-E-/,<76:-5/ .5/ ;-D86.B/ ;-,33B2/ 93=&-:42P(+"+(R&/ -=/ &-:42Pm%R?URQJ/ <,/ [email protected]:.>B/ --=/ ;8.7/ 2-/ 7-4.=.[8-=/ -=/ <,/ 7-D-;.=:.;;.=;/93=/7-/D<7-,/ 2-/7-4.=.[8-=C/)<<8/7-/=3D-F-8B.=;/93=/7-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/ 52332&-:42P+]]/2-8/[email protected].=;J/,338/.5/;-D86.B/;-,33B2/93=/&-:42\&Pm%R?U]*O$J/93=F-;-/--=--=9<67.;-8/-=/9--:E.>7.;-8/;-D86.BC

&-/<GE-2/93=/A-2/<=7-8E<-B/F35/<,/3::-/78.-/7-/D<@A2-=/2-/D-B.>B-=J/E<732/-8/3:;-,-=-8-@<=@:65.-5/ E<67-=/ B6==-=/F<87-=/ ;-28<BB-=J/ 9<<8/,<;-:.>B-/ <G:<55.=;-=C/ I-2/ 6.2F-8B-=93=/3::-/78.-/7-/D<@A2-=/D:--B/=.-2/,<;-:.>B/;-E.-=/7-/[email protected]/2.>7C/+-B<E-=/.5/<,/ZZ=D<@A2/6.2/ 2-/F-8B-=Jf/A.-8D.>/ .5/;-B<E-=/9<<8/7-/D<@A2/7.-/7-/;8<<252-/G8<D:-,-=/<G:-9-82J=3,-:.>B/7.-/D.>/#.=2/!=78.-5C

R=/G383;8334/aC0/F<872/ .=/;8<2-/ :.>=-=/33=;-;-9-=/F-:B-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/-=/34F-;.=;-=/E.>=;-,33B2/D.>/7-/@<[email protected]/93=/7-/9352-/ :33;/93=/#.=2/!=78.-5J/E<3:5/7-E-/ .5/33=;-:-;7C/R=G383;8334/aC\/F<87-=/7-/34F-;.=;-=/-=/B-6E-/9-8,-:7/7.-/E.>=/;-D86.B2/9<<8/A-2/,3B-=/93=A-2/,<7-:C/ I.-8D.>/ E.>=/ --=/ 33=23:/ 34F.>B.=;-=/ 2-=/ <GE.@A2-/ 93=/ 7-/ --87-8-/ D-8-B-=.=;-=9-8,-:7J/7.-/-9-=--=5/9-8B:3387/F<87-=C/&-/:33252-/G383;8334/93=/A-2/A<<47526B/D-5@A8.>427-/.>B.=;-=/93=/A-2/@<,G62-8,<7-:/,-2/7-/,-2.=;/.=/7-/D<@A2/93=/#.=2/!=78.-5C

6.2 Eerdere simulaties en veranderingen bij aanleg van vastelaag

&-/ D-8-B-=.=;-=/ 7.-/ 2-=/ ;8<=75:3;/ :.;;-=/ 33=/ A-2/ <=2F-8G/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ 93=/ #.=2!=78.-5/E.>=/6.2;-9<-87/7<<8/H*/!/&-:42/IL7836:.@5C/&-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/E.>=/6.2;-9<-87/,-2D-A6:G/ 93=/ (R)?OV/ M(R)-8/ 3=7/ ?O3523:/ V<8GA<:<;LNC/ &-/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ <=7-8E<-B-=/ E.>=6.2;-9<-87/.=/7-/G-8.<7-/93=/^bb`/2<2/-=/,-2/^bbaC/&-/--852-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/ME.-/#286.B5,3/-23:CJ/^bb`N/F38-=/<,/2-/<=7-8E<-B-=/F32/7-/,<;-:.>BA-7-=/E.>=/9<<8/9-8D-2-8.=;/M9-8;8<2-=N93=/ 7-/ 9338D33=D8--72-/ 7<<8/,.77-:/ 93=/ --=/ 9352-/ :33;C/)-85@A.::-=7-/ @<[email protected]<8,-=E.>=/ 7<<8;-8-B-=7C/H338D.>/ E<F-:/ 938.32.-/ .=/ :-=;2-/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ 3:5/ 938.32.-/,-2/ 7-D8--72-/D-B-B-=/.5C

Page 64: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

6 – 2 WL | Delft Hydraulics

$-9-=5/.5/7-/.=9:<-7/93=/7-/9-85@A.::-=7-/A-::.=;-=/33=/A-2/D-;.=/-=/-.=7/93=/7-/9352-/:33;D-8-B-=7C/'=B-:-/B383B2-8.52.-B-=/F3387-=/9<<8/7.2/,<7-:/E.>=/F--8;-;-9-=/.=/$3D-:/aP^C

6780551 U((-;. R.)A.";

"Y/M@-:;8<<22-/:3=;58.@A2.=;N ^11 ,

"L/M@-:;8<<22-/7F3858.@A2.=;N 0c/M;-7C/^0N ,

?3::69.33: `c ,^X0X5

?9352-/:33; \c ,^X0X5

&c1 1J11^ ,

m ^c11 ,\X5

A;-,.77-:7 cJ01 ,

(4/M@3:.D832.-/@<[44.@.[=2N 1J^ P

$3D-:/aP^f '=B-:-/F3387-/9<<8/(R)OVPD-8-B-=.=;-=/6.2/#286.B5,3/-2/3:C/^bb`

'8/ .5/;-D86.B/;-,33B2/93=/7-/ 283=5G<824<8,6:-5/V-L-8P]-2-8/ -=/Vy::-8/ -=/ 7-/ 7.-G2-5/ E.>=9-8;-:-B-=/,-2/A-2/8-4-8-=2.-9:3B/93=/^bb^J/A-2/O*Hob^C

OG/ 00/ 4-D8638./ ^bbc/ .5/ D-5:<2-=/ <,/ .=/ 7-/ D<@A2/ 93=/ #.=2/ !=78.-5/ --=/ 9352-/ :33;/ 33=/ 2-:-;;-=C/ $-=/ 2.>7-/ 93=/ 732/ D-5:6.2/ F-87/ --=/ 9-89<:;<=7-8E<-B/ =338/ 9-8D-2-8.=;-=/ 93=/ A-2<=2F-8G/ 6.2;-9<-87J/ ;-8.@A2/ <G/ E<F-:/ ,<84<:<;.5@A-/ 3:5/ 4.=3=@.[:-/ 9-8D-2-8.=;-=C/ &-E-:33252-/7<-:52-::.=;/F-87/.=/7-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/9-87.5@<=2.=6--87/7<<8/E<9--:/,<;-:.>B/7-/9352-:33;/2-/9-8B<82-=/-=/ 2-/9-85,3::-=C/&-/B-65/<,/7.2/9-89<:;<=7-8E<-B/ ME.-/#286.B5,3/-2/3:C^bbcN/ 6.2/ 2-/ 9<-8-=/ .5/ 2<2/ 523=7/ ;-B<,-=/ 2.>7-=5/ A-2/ 9<<8<=2F-8G/ ME.-/ I<,D-8;-=/ -2/ 3:C^bbc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qS<@A29-8D-2-8.=;/#2C/!=78.-5/)352-:33;r/93=/I<,D-8;-=/-2/3:C/^bbc/B<,2/=338/9<8-=/732/--=/:33;<GD<6F/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/A-2D-52/B3=/D-5233=/6.2/--=/:33;/93=/`1X^11/,,/1J`/,/7.B/-=/7338<G/--=/2<G:33;/93=/`1P011/B;93=/ 1Je/ ,/ 7.B/ M&c1/ g/ 1J`^/ ,NC/ &-E-/ 2<G:33;/ A--42/ 3:5/ 86FA-.7/ --=/ ?AZELPF3387-/ E<3:59-8,-:7/.=/$3D-:/aP0C/MF338D.>/.=/4<8,6:-/M`C0N/.=/G:3325/93=/qBrJ/q0&c1r/.5/;-D86.B2N

23'5.-$"%,(%". A&W8X Q&W89Z>Z$X

VIH^ ^0J1 `1

O*H \Jec \0

$3D-:/aP0f ?AZELPF3387-/9<<8/7-/9352-/:33;/6.2/I<,D-8;-=/-2/3:C/^bbc

//////////////////////////////////////////////////////>2BCDA2%(('."3"&#25--.28('",

Page 65: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 6 – 3

&-/ B<88-:7.3,-2-8/ F338,--/ .5/ ;-8-B-=7/ 9<<8/ A-2/ 3::69.3:-/ 7--:/ .5/ 34B<,52.;/ 6.2/ --=<=7-8E<-B/7<<8/"6;8<J/E.-/$3D-:/aP\C

\.-@.)%(+.& 45--.1$41.").-&;()

].8";;.1;.&;"(8.%.-&W8X

&^c 1J`1/w/^1P\

&c1 ^J1b/w/^1P\

&ec \Jcd/w/^1P\

$3D-:/aP\f +-,C/B<88-:7.3,-2-8/6.2/I<,D-8;-=/-2/3:C/^bbc/3C7CAC9C/<=7-8E<-B/"6;8<

%.2/ A-2/ 9-89<:;<=7-8E<-B/ q&-/H33:/ D.>/ #2C/!=78.-5r/ 93=/ #286.B5,3/ -2/ 3:C/ 6.2/ ^bbc/F<872;-@<=@:67--87/732/--=/9-8B<82-/9352-/ :33;/,<;-:.>B/ .5/ .=7.-=/7-E-/9-8B<82.=;/33=/A-2/-.=793=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ G:3325/ 9.=72/ M765/ ;--=/ 9-8B<82.=;/ .=/ A-2/ D-;.=J/ 732/ F.:/ E-;;-=/ :32-8D-;.==-=NC/ '9-=--=5/ F<872/ -8/ --=/ 9-85,3::.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ 8.9.-8/ ;-379.5--87J/ E<3:5/ =3,-:.>BF<872/ 9-8,-:7f/ qI-2/ D:.>B2/ 732/ 8.9.-89-85,3::.=;/ 2<2/ --=/ 33=E.-=:.>B-/ [email protected]/ 93=/ 7-/ 2-D3;;-8-=/A<-9--:A-7-=/:-.72r

R=/ q)352-/ :33;J/ D<@A2/ #2C/ !=78.-5f/ #@A-25<=2F-8Gr/ ME.-/ #2668;8<-G/ H33:/ ^bbc3N/ F<8727-4.=.2.-4/7-/B-6E-/9352;-:-;7/9<<8/--=/B<82-/9352-/ :33;/,-2/--=/52-.:/ -.=723:67/ M^f^11J/7-9-8B<82-/ 9-85.-NJ/ --=/ D8--72-/ 93=/ ^`1/,/ -=/ --=/,3Y.,3:-/ A<<;2-/ 93=/ P\Jac/,/O*HC/&-;-379.5--87-/ 8.9.-89-85,3::.=;/ F<872/ .=/ 7-/ B-6E-/ D6.2-=/ D-5@A<6F.=;/ ;-:32-=J/ <,732/ 7-8.9.-89-85,3::.=;/;--=/.=9:<-7/A--42/<G/7-/3=3:L5-/9<<8/7-/ :3LP<62/ C/)-85,3::-=/F<872/G358337E33,/3:5/,--8/76.7-:.>BA-.7/9-8B8-;-=/.5/<9-8/7-/F-8B.=;/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/9<:;-=5/A-2D-28-44-=7-/83GG<82C

R=/q&-23.:<=2F-8G/)352-/*33;/D<@A2/#2C/!=78.-5r/ME.-/U8--B-J/^bbaN/F<872/A-2/<=2F-8G/93=7-/9352-/:33;/6.2;-F-8B2/-=/F<87-=/=<;/F32/33=G355.=;-=/33=/A-2/:-=;2-G8<4.-:/;-733=/<,G83B2.5@A-/8-7-=-=C/)<<8/A-2/7-23.:<=2F-8G/.5/<=7-8/3=7-8-/--=/D<7-,<=7-8E<-B/6.2;-9<-87CI.-86.2/D:.>B2/732/ .=/7-/D<@A2/93=/#.=2/!=78.-5/;8<4/E3=7J/9--:3:/;8.=7.;/E.2/,-2/G:3325-:.>B;8.=7:3;-=J/9--=P/-=/B:-.34E-22.=;-=C/&-/=<,.=3:-/B<88-:7.3,-2-8/7.-/F<872/33=;-A<67-=/.57-8A3:9-/ 1J11\/ ,C/ +-B<E-=/ .5/ 9<<8/ 33=:-;/ 93=/ D<9-=P/ =338/ D-=-7-=528<<,5J/ <,732/ q7-528<,.=;/D-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/A-2/7--:/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/732/8--75/.5/33=;-:-;7J/E--8/;-8.=;.5/-=/A-2/E3=7G8<4.-:/,.=7-8/-8<7--82rC

R=/ 7-/ G83B2.>B/F35/ 7-/ 8-7-=/ 9<<8/ A-2/F-8B-=/ 93=/ D<9-=P/ =338/ D-=-7-=528<<,5/ 732J/ 3:5/ -83=7-85<,/;-F-8B2/E<6/F<87-=J/-8/F3385@A.>=:.>B/E3=7/<G/A-2/F-8B/E<6/B<,-=/-=/732/73=/7-A<<;2-D-G3:.=;/93=/A-2/F-8B/E<6/B6==-=/D-:-,,-8-=C/'9-=--=5/F-87/9-8<=7-852-:7/732/7--8<5.-/ D-=-7-=528<<,5/ 93=/ A-2/ 52<8248<=2/ 3@@-G23D-:/ E<6/ E.>=C/ $.>7-=5/ 7-/ 33=:-;/ .5/ A-2:3=;5G8<4.-:/33=;-G352/<,732/7-/9352-/:33;/D.==-=/A-2/=362.5@A/G8<4.-:/78-.;7-/2-/B<,-=C

&-/33=;-:-;7-/A-::.=;/F35/E<73=.;/732/7-E-/4:36F-8/.5/73=/7-/A-::.=;/93=/A-2/8-4-8-=2.-9:3BMF32/9<:;-=5/A-2/7-23.:<=2F-8G/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/7-/D-7<-:.=;/F35NC/'@A2-8/7-/A<<;2-/93=/7-9352-/:33;/F35/E<73=.;J/732/--=/9-8:3;.=;/=<<7E3B-:.>B/F35/<,/A-2/=362.5@A-/G8<4.-:/9-.:.;/2-52-::-=C

Page 66: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

6 – 4 WL | Delft Hydraulics

6.3 Opzet van het model

I-2/ 8-B-=,<7-:/ .5/ --=/ 2F--7.,-=5.<=33:/ M0&N/,<7-:/ <G/ D35.5/ 93=/ A-2/ &-:42\&/ 5<42F38-G3BB-2C/&338D.>/F<872/-@A2-8/F-:/--=/-Y283/D-8-B-=.=;/F<872/6.2;-9<-87J/<,/A-2/\&P-44-@293=/7-/ 5G.833:528<,.=;/ .=/ 8-B-=.=;/ 2-/D8-=;-=J/F3387<<8/A-2/,<7-:/3:5/A-2/F38-/p635.P\&F<872C

R=/A-2/,<7-:/:.;2/7-/=3786B/<G/7-/D<@A2/D.>/#.=2/!=78.-5/F338/7-/9352-/:33;/.5/33=;-D83@A2C)<<8/ 7-/ <GE-2/ 93=/ A-2/ ,<7-:/ .5/ .=/ D-:3=;8.>B-/ ,32-/ ;-D86.B/ ;-,33B2/ 93=/ --87-8-<=7-8E<-B-=/-=/-8938.=;-=/7.-/E.>=/<G;-733=/,-2/,<7-::-8.=;/93=/7-/H33:/.=/&-:42\&C/V-2=3,-/ F<872/ A.-8D.>/ ;-8-4-8--87/ 33=/ A-2/ 9-85:3;/ qV<84<:<;.5@A-/ 5267.-/ SO#/ S3;;-8-=MS-5:.55-=7/ O=7-852-6=-=7/ #L52--,/ S3;;-8-=N/ ,-2/ &-:420&P(.9.-8-=r/ 93=/ ?CTC#:<44/ 6.2<B2<D-8/ 011^C/ $-9-=5/ .5/ ;-D86.B/ ;-,33B2/ 93=/ --87-8/ D-8-B-=.=;-=/ 7.-/ E.>=/ ;-,33B2/ ,-2(R)?OV/ME.-/#286.B5,3/-2/3:C/^bb`/-=/^bbcNC

R=/A-2/,<7-:/ .5/7-/;-<,-28.-/93=/A-2/ :33;F32-8D-7/3:5/,332;-9-=7/D-5@A<6F7J/ 33=;-E.-=A-2/A<<;F32-8D-7/--=/5-@6=73.8-/8<:/5G--:2/ME.-/U:3355-=/-=/#:<44/0111NC/I-2/,<7-:/9<<8E.-2=.-2/.=/-44-@2-=/7.-/<=25233=/7<<8/A-2/.=P/-=/6.2528<,-=/93=/A-2/A<<;F32-8D-7C/R=/A-2/,<7-:E.>=/;--=/B8.DD-=/M-=/B8.D93BB-=N/<G;-=<,-=/-=/E<7<-=7-/B<,2/A-2/9-85@A.>=5-:/732/7<<8B8.DD-=/M-=/B8.D93BB-=N/<=252332/=.-2/2-86;/.=/A-2/,<7-:C/&-/9-85@A.>=5-:-=/9-8<<8E33B2/7<<8B8.DD-=/M<=2;8<=7.=;5B6.:-=/-=/B8.D9:3,,-=N/F<87-=/D-5@A<6F7/3:5/9-85@A.>=5-:-=/7.-/E.>=;-56G-8G<=--87/<G/7-/;-,.77-:7-/D<7-,:.;;.=;C

I-2/ :33;F32-8D-7/ .5/ ,-2/ --=/ B8<,:.>=.;/ 8-B-=8<<52-8/ D-:-;7J/ F338D.>/ 7-/ 83=7-=/ 93=/ A-28<<52-8/ 7-/ =<8,33::.>=-=/ 9<:;-=C/ &-/ =<8,33::.>=-=/ E.>=/ 7-/ :.>=-=/ 7.-/ 7-/ B8.DB<GG-=/ ,-28-@A2-/:.>=526BB-=/9-8D.=72C/I.-87<<8/<=25233=/B:-.=-/B=.B>-5/.=/7-/83=7/93=/A-2/,<7-:J/,3389<:;-=5/#:<44/M011^N/;-9-=/7-E-/B:-.=-/M523D.-:-N/9-852<8.=;-=/<=9<:7<-=7-/33=:-.7.=;/<,7-/=<8,33::.>=-=/--852/;:37/ 2-/,3B-=C/I-2/8-B-=8<<52-8/D-;.=2/<G/B,8/b^eJd/ M&8-6,-:N/-=:<<G2/7<<8/2<2/33=/B,8C/bc\J1/M+<8.=@A-,NC/I-2/2<23:-/,<7-:/9<<8/7-/D<@A2/93=/#.=2/!=78.-5.5/ 7338,--/ @.8@3/ \`/ B.:<,-2-8/ ME.-/ ".;668/ aP^/ 9<<8/ A-2/ <9-8E.@A2/ 93=/ A-2/ &-:42\&8-B-=8<<52-8P283>-@2NC

".;668/aP^f O9-8E.@A2/93=/A-2/&-:42\&/8-B-=8<<52-8P283>-@2/B,8C/b^eJd/2<2/bc\J1

&-/ D-=-7-=P/ -=/ D<9-=;8-=5/ E.>=/ E<73=.;/ ;-B<E-=/ 732/ --=/ 9-852<8.=;/ 7.-/ E.@A/ 9<<8/ E<6B6==-=/ 7<-=/ 33=/ 7-/ D<9-=83=7/ =.-2/ .=/ 7-/ D-5@A<6F7-/ 5.,6:32.-2.>7/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ A33:2M6.2;-;33=/.5/93=/^Jc/B.:<,-2-8/G-8/>338/-=/5.,6:32.-2.>7/93=/`/>338NC/)-87-8/.5/7-/:<@32.-/93=7-/D<9-=83=7/E</;-B<E-=/732/7-E-/E<9--:/,<;-:.>B/.=/--=/8-@A2/526B/8.9.-8/D-9.=72J/E<732/3:5D<9-=83=79<<8F3387-/--=/8-@A2:.>=.;/9-87--:7/7-D.-2/B3=/F<87-=/<G;-:-;7C/&-/<=7-883=7/.5E</9-8/,<;-:.>B/;-B<E-=/[email protected]@3/0c/B,N/93=34/7-/9352-/:33;C&-/8-7-=/73389<<8/.5/<,/6.2/2-/5:6.2-=/732/-9-=26-:-/9-852<8.=;-=/7.-/E.@A/7338/9<<8/B6==-=7<-=J/.=9:<-7/6.2<-4-=-=/<G/7-/D<7-,:.;;.=;/.=/7-/D<@A2/93=/#.=2/!=78.-5C

".;668/aC0

Page 67: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 6 – 5

I-2/ 8-B-=8<<52-8/ A--42/ <G/ 7-/ 8.9.-8P35/ --=/ @-:;8<<22-/ 93=/ c1/ ,-2-8/ -=/ 938.--82/ 9-87-8<=;-9--8/2655-=/`\/-=/ca/,-2-8C/&-/@-:;8<<22-/.=/7F3858.@A2.=;/938.--82/2655-=/7-/^a/-=/\1,-2-8/9<<8/A-2/;-A-:-/,<7-:/,-2/--=/;-,.77-:7-/93=/^e/,-2-8f/.=/7-/D<@A2/93=/#.=2/!=78.-5.5/--=/5G8-.7.=;/2655-=/7-/^a/-=/0\/,-2-8/,-2/-9-=--=5/--=/;-,.77-:7-/93=/^e/,-2-8C/I-22<23:-/8<<52-8/D-932/ad`/@-::-=/.=/7-/:-=;2-8.@A2.=;/-=/^`/.=/7-/7F3858.@A2.=;/-=/7338,--/765--=/2<233:/33=23:/@-::-=/93=/b`\aC

&-/33=G355.=;5:-=;2-/9<<8/7-/0&PF32-8D-F-;.=;/-=/7-/0&PD<7-,9-852<8.=;J/ .5/7-/34523=7F338<9-8/--=/9-85@A.>=5-:/2<2/9<::-/<=2F.BB-:.=;/B<,2s/7-/,335F.>72-/93=/A-2/8-B-=8<<52-8,<-2/9--:/B:-.=-8/E.>=/73=/7-E-/:-=;2-J/<,/7-E-/9-85@A.>=5-:-=/.=/A-2/,<7-:/>6.52/2-/B6==-=5.,6:-8-=C

&338D.>/ .5/ 7-/ 33=G355.=;5:-=;2-/ 9<<8/ 7-/F32-8D-F-;.=;/ ME.-/ #286.B5,3/ -=/?8<532<J/ ^bebN;-7-4.=.--87/3:5f

λ w

C h

g=

20

2MaC^N

,-2f*F/g/33=G355.=;5:-=;2-/F32-8D-F-;.=;/j,k

&-/ 33=G355.=;5:-=;2-/ 9<<8/ 7-/ D<7-,9-852<8.=;/ ME.-/ #286.B5,3/ -=/ ?8<532<J/ ^bebN/ .5;-7-4.=.--87/3:5f

λπ

θs mh

B

hf=

FHGIKJ

12 0

0

2

0( )b g MaC0N

,-2f*5/g/33=G355.=;5:-=;2-/D<7-,9-852<8.=;/j,k,/g/F.>E-/93=/A-2/283=59-853:-/9-8:<<G/93=/7-/D<7-,/MD.>/,-3=7-8-=7-/8.9.-8-=J/,g^N/jPk4M$N/g/7F385A-::.=;5-44-@2/jPk/ME.-/4<8,6:-/M`C^`NN

&-/33=G355.=;5:-=;2-/93=/7-/D<7-,9-852<8.=;/.5/D.>/--=/F32-8523=7/93=/<=;-9--8/c/,-2-8/.=7-/ <87-/ 93=/ `e1/ ,-2-8/ ME.-/ $3D-:/ aP\NJ/ E<732/ 7-/ 8<<52-834523=7-=/ ;<-7/ D.==-=/ 7-E-33=G355.=;5:-=;2-/G355-=C

2()F($$")+$1.)+%. U((-;. R.)A.";

*F //a\d ,

*5 //`e^ ,

$3D-:/aP`f !3=G355.=;5:-=;2-/9<<8/D<@A2/93=/#.=2/!=78.-5

%.2/<=7-8E<-B/93=/#@A-G,3=/M011^N/D:--B/732/7-/A<<;2-/93=/7-/D3=B-=/.=/7-/D.==-=D<@A2M-=/7-/7.-G2-/ .=/7-/D6.2-=D<@A2N/8<=7/7-/9338;-6:D-;8-=E.=;/F-87/<9-85@A32C/&32/76.72/<G--=/2-/;8<2-/52-.:A-.7/93=/7-/D3=B-=C&-E-/.5/,-2/D-A6:G/93=/7-/ .>B.=;543@2<8/q!5A:7r/M35/g/@<[email protected]/43@2<8/9<<8/D<7-,A-::.=;N33=;-G352/M.=/<9-8--=52-,,.=;/,-2/7-/--87-8/2<-;-G352-/F3387-/9<<8/7-/@35-P5267L/q

Page 68: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

6 – 6 WL | Delft Hydraulics

)352-/ :33;/ D.>/ Q.>,-;-=rJ/ H<:2-85J/ ^bbe/ -=/ qV<84<:<;.5@A-/ 5267.-/ SO#/ S3;;-8-=/ ,-2&-:420&P(.9.-8-=rJ/#:<44J/011^NC/!3=G355.=;/93=/7-E-/ .>B.=;543@2<8/A--42/ 2<2/;-9<:;/732/7-7-,G.=;5:-=;2-/*7/M7-,G.=;5:-=;2-/93=/7-/G<.=2PD38N/F<872/;-@<88.;--87/7<<8/--=/9-8:3;.=;-=/F32/:-.72/2<2/--=/9-8:3;.=;/93=/7-/[email protected],-2-8/MR]NC/H338D.>/7-/[email protected],-2-8JR]J/7-/9-8A<67.=;/ .5/ 2655-=/7-/33=G355.=;5:-=;2-/9<<8/7-/F32-8D-F-;.=;/ M*FN/ -=/ 9<<8/ A-25-7.,-=2/M*5NJ/R]/g/*5X*F/ME.-/#286.B5,3/-2/3:C/^be`NC

)<<8/ =36FB-68.;-/ F32-8D-F-;.=;5D-8-B-=.=;-=/ .5/ --=/ :<<78-@A2-/ A<-B/ 2655-=/ 7-:.>=526BB-=/ ;-F-=52J/ E<732/ --=/ <82A<;<=33:/ 8<<52-8/ <=252332C/ I-2/ B8<,:.>=.;-/ 8-B-=8<<52-893=/A-2/,<7-:/ .5/<G;-D<6F7/6.2/ 8-@A2-/ :.>=526BB-=/F3387<<8/A<-B-=/<=25233=/ 2655-=/7-E-:.>=526BB-=C/ &.2/ B8<,:.>=.;-/ 8-B-=8<<52-8/ .5/ 73389<<8/ 73=/ <<B/ ;-<82A<;<=3:.5--87C/ &-<82A<;<=3:.2-.2/F<872/6.2;-786B2/ .=/--=/<82A<;<=3:.2-.25G383,-2-8/M7-/@<5.=65/93=/7-/A<-BNF32/9<<8/A-2/;-A-:-/,<7-:/,3Y.,33:/1J11c/.5/-=/D.>/#.=2/!=78.-5/E-:45/,338/,3Y.,33:/1J11\M;-,.77-:7/1J11^NC/H338D.>/2<2/1J10/.=/<G-=/;-D.-7-=/3:5/3@@-G23D-:/F<872/D-5@A<6F7/-=/D.>83=7-=/5<,5/E-:45/--=/A<;-8-/F3387-C/i<732/7-/<82A<;<=3:.2-.2/93=/A-2/;-D86.B2-/,<7-:/3:5E--8/;<-7/.5/2-/D-5@A<6F-=C

".;668/aP0f &-23.:/93=/A-2/8-B-=8<<52-8/M2CAC9C/#.=2/!=78.-5J/E.-/".;668/aP^N

&-/9352-/:33;/.5/.=/A-2/,<7-:/33=;-D83@A2/,-2/D-A6:G/93=/&-:42Pm%R?URQC/&-/D-;8-=E.=;/93=--=/9352-/:33;/B3=/-@A2-8/3::--=/F<87-=/33=;-:-;7/<G/A-2/9<<834/;-7-4.=.--87-/8<<52-8C/&.2B3=/ 765/ D-2-B-=-=/ 732/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ =.-2/ -Y3@2/ 7-E-:47-/ D8--72-/ -=/ :-=;2-/ B8.>;2/ 3:5/ .=F-8B-:.>BA-.7C/&-/D8--72-/7.-/7-/9352-/:33;/.=/A-2/,<7-:/A--42/.5/@.8@3/^\0/,/-=/7338,--/765e/ ,-2-8/ [email protected]@3/ chN/ 5,3::-8/ 73=/ .=/ F-8B-:.>BA-.7C/ '-=/ 4.>=-8/ 8<<52-8/ E<6/ 7.2/ B6==-=9<<8B<,-=J/,338/ 7338/ .5/ 93=/ 34;-E.-=J/ <,732/ 7-/ 34F.>B.=;/F3385@A.>=:.>B/F-.=.;/ .=9:<-7A--42/<G/7-/,<84<:<;.5@A-/9-85@A.>=5-:-=CI-2/ :-=;2-G8<4.-:/ 93=/7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ .5/ <9-8;-=<,-=/ E<3:5/ 9-8,-:7/ .=/ A-2/ 83GG<82/ q]8<>-@29352-/:33;/#.=2/!=78.-5J/D-5:.57<@6,-=2rJ/'-87-=/M011^NC

Page 69: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 6 – 7

&-/34F.>B.=;/93=/7-/ :-=;2-/ 93=/A-2/,<7-:/ 2-=/ <GE.@A2-/ 93=/ 7-/F-8B-:.>BA-.7/ .5/ ^1/,[email protected]@3/1J\h/:3=;-8N/-=/E3:/7338,--/;--=/5.;=.4.@3=2/9-85@A.:/<G/B6==-=/:-9-8-=C/R=/$3D-:/aPc.5/--=/33=23:/B-=23::-=/F--8;-;-9-=C/'=B-:-/A.-893=/E.>=/A.-8=3/B<82/2<-;-:.@A2C

6780551 U((-;. R.)A.";

m/H33: ^a11 ,\X5

"Y c1 ,

"L ^e ,

&c1 1J110 ,

S //0a1 ,

(G<8 `1 h

(4/M')!#$/.=/&-:42\&N 1J^ P

+523/M!*"#$!/6.2/&-:42\&N \c P

%/M?<683=2/;-23:N 1Jb P

35/M!#I*&/6.2/&-:42\&N 1Jd P

?/3::69.33: c1 ,^X0X5

?/9352-/:33; \c ,^X0X5

), 0ac1 B;X,\

)F ^111 B;X,\

' ^3^1Pa ,0X5

$3D-:/aPcf '=B-:-/B383B2-8.52.-B-=/93=/A-2/,<7-:

'8/ .5/ ;-D86.B/ ;-,33B2/ 93=/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ ?AZELPF3387-=/ 9<<8/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ -=/ 9<<8/ A-23::69.3:-/ 7--:C/S.>/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ .5/ ;-B<E-=/ 9<<8/ --=/ <G:<G-=7-/ 86FA-.7/ 93=/ D-=-7-=/ 2<2D<9-=33=/A-2/D-;.=23:67C/&<<8732/.=/A-2/D-;.=/E3=7/<G/7-/9352-/:33;/B<,2/2-/:.;;-=J/E3:/7-86FA-.7/ 52-8B/ 34=-,-=/ -=/ 7-/ ?AZELPF3387-/ 765/ 52-8B/ 2<-=-,-=C/ +-B<E-=/ .5/ 9<<8/ A-2;-D86.B/93=/7-/?AZELPF3387-/.=/G:3325/93=/D.>9<<8D--:7/--=/BPF3387-/7.-/9<<8/A-2/;-D86.B93=/7-/9352-/ :33;/:<;.5@A-8/E<6/E.>=J/,338/9<<8/7-/52-8B/9-83=7-8-=7-/D-77.=;59<8,-=/<GA-2/ 3::69.3:-/ 7--:/ -@A2-8/ >6.52/ F--8/ =.-2C/ T6.52/ 9<<8/ 7-E-/ :33252-/ .5/ .=/ A-2/ ,<7-:/ ;-B<E-=M-@A2-8J/ =3/ F32/ D-8-B-=.=;-=/,-2/ BPF3387-/ D:--B/ 732/ 7.2/ ,.=/ <4/,--8/ A-2E-:47-/ 8-56:2332<G:-9-87-NC/&-/B-6E-/93=/7-/?AZELPF3387-/ .5/ 2<2/ 523=7/;-B<,-=/ 2.>7-=5/7-/ .>B.=;/93=/A-2,<7-:J/E.-/G383;8334/aC`/-=/.=/53,-=A3=;/,-2/9<<8;33=7-/<=7-8E<-B-=C

!:5/83=79<<8F3387-/33=/7-/D<9-=;8-=5/.5/--=/349<-89<<8F3387-/;-7-4.=.--87/93=/^a11,\X5ME.-/ #:<44J/ 011^NC/)<<8/ 7-/ <=7-8;8-=5/ .5/ --=/F32-8A<<;2-/ ;-7-4.=.--87/ D.>/ --=/ 349<-8/ 93=^a11,\X5/ 93=/ 1Jb1/,/ M2-=/ <GE.@A2-/ 93=/Q<8,33:/!,52-873,5/ ]-.:J/ Q!]NC/ I.-8/ .5/ D-F652;-B<E-=/9<<8/--=/83=79<<8F3387-/.=/7-/9<8,/93=/--=/F32-8A<<;2-J/E<732/.=/A-2/,<7-:/;--=@<=2.=6W2-.25G8<D:-,-=/B6==-=/<=25233=C

Page 70: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

6 – 8 WL | Delft Hydraulics

'8/.5/;-D86.B/;-,33B2/93=/7-/ 283=5G<824<8,6:-/93=/'=;-:6=7/-=/I3=5-=/M2<233:/ 283=5G<82NC&-E-/ .5/ .=/ A-2/ 9-8:-7-=/ 933B/ ;-D86.B2/ -@A2-8/ ,-2/ --=/ 43@2<8/ 93=/ 1Jc/ MA.-8D.>/ BF3,/ --=>338283=5G<82/ 6.2/ 93=/ <=;-9--8/ \11C111/ ,\X>338NC/ (-@-=2-/ <=7-8E<-B-=/ 93=/ (Ri!M(.>B5.=52.2662/ 9<<8/ .=2-;833:/ E<-2F32-8D-A--8/ -=/ 3493:F32-8D-A3=7-:.=;N/ A-DD-=/ [email protected];-F-E-=/732/7-/>338283=5G<82-=/.=/7-/<87-/93=/1Ja/Y/^1a/v/1Jd/Y/^1a/,\X>338/<G28-7-=/.=/7-H33:C/H3387<<8/--=/q9-8,-=.;96:7.;.=;543@2<8r/93=/^/7338<,/;-8-@A293387.;7/:.>B2/-=/;[email protected]/ 2-=/ <GE.@A2-/ 93=/ 7-/ 283=5G<824<8,6:-/ A<-42/ 2-/ F<87-=/ ;-D86.B2C/ R=/ 7-/ @35-P5267Lq9352-/ :33;/Q.>,-;-=r/A--42/H<:2-85/ M^bbeN/ ;-8-B-=7/,-2/ 7-/V-L-8P]-2-8/ -=/Vy::-8/ 2LG-283=5G<824<8,6:-J/ ,-2/ 9-8;-:.>BD338/ 8-56:2332/ 3:5/ ,-2/ 7-/ '=;-:6=7/ -=/ I3=5-=283=5G<824<8,6:-/ F32/ D-28-42/ 7-/ ,<84<:<;.5@A-/ -.=75.2632.-C/ I.-8/ .5/ -@A2-8/ ;-B<E-=/ 9<<8'=;-:6=7/ -=/ I3=5-=J/ 93=F-;-/ 7-/ ;<-7-/ -8938.=;-=/ 7.-/ D.>/ &-:42\&PD-8-B-=.=;/ 9<<8/ 7-H33:/A.-86.2/9<<82BF3,-=/ME.-/#:<44J/011^NC

R=/ 7-/ D-8-B-=.=;-=/ E.>=/ ;8<<25@A3:.;-/ 9-83=7-8.=;-=/ ME<3:5/ 7-/ 362<=<,-/ D<7-,73:.=;ND6.2-=/D-5@A<6F.=;/;-:32-=C

':B-/,<84<:<;.5@A-/D-8-B-=.=;/ .5/;-52382/,-2/--=/F32-8D-F-;.=;5D-8-B-=.=;/E<732/;-52382F<872/ ,-2/ --=/ 523D.-:/ 528<,.=;5D--:7C/ I.-87<<8/ 28-7-=/ .=/ A-2/ D-;.=/ ;--=.=5G--:9-85@A.>=5-:-=/<GC

&-/D<7-,/F338,--/7-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/E.>=/;-52382/.5/7-/D<7-,/E<3:5/7-E-/6.2/7-/D-8-B-=.=;-=93=/?CTC/#:<44/ME.-/#:<44J/011^N/BF3,C/&-E-/.5/9-89<:;-=5/.=/A-2/,<7-:/.=;-9<-87/-=/=<;/--=B--8/,-2/--=/5.,6:32.-2.>7/93=/`/>338/7<<8;-8-B-=7C/'8/2837-=/-@A2-8/;--=/=<-,-=5F3387.;-9-83=7-8.=;-=/<G/M/u^h/93=/7-/7.-G2-NJ/E<3:5/2-/9-8F3@A2-=/F35C

+-8-B-=7/ .5/ ,-2/ 938.3D-:-/ 2.>75523GG-=J/ E<73=.;/ 732/ -8/ G35/ ,-2/ 7-/ ,<84<:<;.5@A-D-8-B-=.=;-=/ F<872/ D-;<==-=/ =3732/ 7-/ F32-8D-F-;.=;5D-8-B-=.=;/ ;-@<=9-8;--87/ F35M9-85@A.:/ 2655-=/<G--=9<:;-=7-/ 2.>7523GG-=/B:-.=-8/ .5/73=/1J11c/,X5NC/I.-87<<8/F<87-=/7-.=5G--:9-85@A.>=5-:-=/7.-/7<<8/7-/=.-6F-/528<,.=;/E.>=/<=25233=/M7<<8/9-83=7-8.=;-=/.=/7-D<7-,N/6.2;-5:<2-=C

&-/;8<<22-/93=/A-2/ 283=5G<82/<9-8/7-/9352-/ :33;/F<872/ D-W=9:<-7/7<<8/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ -=/7-:33;7.B2-/ <G/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ 93=/ 3::69.33:/,32-8.33:/ .=/ @<,D.=32.-/,-2/ 7-/ F32-87.-G2-C/ ME.-9<<8/,--8/ .=4</ #286.B5,3/ M^bbbNNC/&-/ [email protected]@2<8/ 9<<8/ A-2/ 283=5G<82/ .=/ &-:42\&/F<872D-G33:7/ 9<:;-=5/ 4<8,6:-/ MaC\NJ/ E<3:5/ ;-7-4.=.--87/ .=/ &-:42\&C/ M&.2/ B<,2/ <9-8--=/ ,-2/ 7-7-4.=.2.-/ E<3:5/ #286.B5,3/ ;-D86.B2J/ -@A2-8/ F-:/ .=/ --=/ .-25/ 3=7-8-/ 9<8,NC/ &-/ .=/ A-2/,<7-:;-D86.B2-/F3387-/.5/1J^J/F32/--=/;-D86.B-:.>B-/F3387-/.5C

α η ηηηf

b b

b

b

als

als=

−RST

≥<

1

21

1b g MaC\N

,-2f

ηε ηb

f a

f a

z z

z=

−+b g MaC`N

Page 71: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 6 – 9

,-2f

&D/g/9-8A<67.=;f/E3=7/<G/7-/9352-/:33;/X,3YC/7.B2-/F338/7-/9352-/:33;/;--=/.=9:<-7/A--42/jPk6/g/;-,.77-:7-/528<<,5=-:A-.7/j,X5kE3/g/3::69.3:-/7.B2-/<G/7-/9352-/:33;/j,kE4/g/A<<;2-/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/j,k(4/g/@3:.D832.-/@<[44.@.[=2/9<<8/283=5G<82/<9-8/7-/9352-/:33;/j,k&/g/F32-87.-G2-/j,k

&<<8/A-2/;-D86.B/93=/A-2/B8<,:.>=.;/8-B-=8<<52-8/<=25233=/B:-.=-/9-852<8.=;-=/.=/7-/D<7-,2-8/G:3325-/93=/7-/B:-.=-/B=.B>-5/<G/7-/B8.DB<GC/&-E-/7.5@<=2.=6W2-.2/:-.72/2<2/B:-.=-/52<8.=;-=.=/7-/D<7-,:.;;.=;/M9-8;-:.>BD338/,-2/7-/B8.D9:3,,-=/.=/52-8B/;-8-76@--87-/9<8,NC/&-E-52<8.=;-=/B6==-=/:-.7-=/2<2/=6,-8.-B-/4<62-=/M<G5:.=;-8.=;N/-=/.=523D.:.2-.25G8<D:-,-=C/O,7.2/2-/9<<8B<,-=/.5/-=.;-/7-,G.=;/.=/A-2/5L52--,/;-D83@A2/9.3/7-/@<[44.@.[=2/!*"!#$!C/&-F3387-/\c/.5/--=/F3387-/7.-/93B-8/9<<8/7.2/5<<82/5.2632.-5/F<872/;-D86.B2/9<<8/7-/G383,-2-8!*"#$!J/E<3:5/7-E-/.=/&-:42\&/.5/;-=<-,7C

)<<8/ 7-/ 2.>7523G/ ;8<<22-/ .5/ ;-B<E-=/ 9<<8/ 362<,32.5@A-/ 2.>7523GG-=/ 33=/ 7-/ A3=7/ 93=/ A-2?<683=2/;-23:C/&-/362<,32.5@A-/2.>7523G/9<:;-=5/A-2/?<683=2/523D.:[email protected]/:6.72f

c t

xbed∆∆

< 1 MaCcN

,-2f@/D-7/g/D<7-,A<<;2-/5=-:A-.7/M7-/5=-:A-.7/93=/D<7-,9-852<8.=;N/j,X5k"2/g/523G/;8<<22-/.=/7-/2.>7/j5k"Y/g/523G/;8<<22-/.=/7-/86.,2-/M.=/7.2/,<7-:/@.8@3/c1/,J/@-:;8<<22-/.=/YP8.@A2.=;/j,k

I.-8D.>/E<6/--=/F3387-/7.-/=37-82/2<2/ZZ=/765/7-/;8<<252-/2.>7523G/<G:-9-8-=/-=/E<7<-=7-/7-,.=52-/8-B-=2.>7/9-8;-=C/&338D.>/7.-=2/<G;-,-8B2/2-/F<87-=/732/--=/F3387-/7.@A2/D.>/ZZ=/B3=:-.7-=/2<2/ .=523D.:.2-.2/93=/A-2/,<7-:J/933B/F<872/7-8A3:9-/--=/F3387-/93=/1Ja/ .=/7.2/ 5<<825.2632.-5/;-D86.B2C/V-2/=3,-/D.>/9352-/:3;-=/=--,2/7-/5=-:A-.7/93=/7-/D<7-,9-852<8.=;-=/2<-ME.-/#286.B5,3J/^bbbNC/'@A2-8/=3/D-8-B-=.=;-=/,-2/8-B-=,<7-:/,-2/7-/F3387-/1Jb/D:--B/732A-2/,<7-:/73=/=<;/52--75/523D.-:/D:--4J/F32/7-/8-B-=2.>7/,-2/E<o=/0ch/9-8B<822-C

)<<8/ 7-/ B<88-:7.3,-2-8/ 93=/7-/ 3::69.3:-/ D<7-,/ .5/ 6.2;-;33=/93=/ --=/B<88-:;8<<22-/ 7.-/ A-2;-,.77-:7-/.5/93=/F3387-=/;-9<=7-=/D.>/--87-8-/D<7-,<=7-8E<-B-=/ME.-/G383;8334/aC0N/-=33=/7-/A3=7/93=/D<7-,<=7-8E<-B-=/;-733=/7<<8/VI/Q-7-8:3=7/S)/MG8<>-@2/HbeC^aaCO^>3=638./^bbbNC/+-B<E-=/.5/9<<8/--=/6=.4<8,-/9-87-:.=;/93=/7-/5-7.,-=2P7.3,-2-8/93=/1J110,C

Page 72: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

6 – 1 0 WL | Delft Hydraulics

6.4 Globale ijking

R=/7-E-/G383;8334/F<872/7-/.>B.=;/93=/A-2/,<7-:/D-5@A8-9-=C/I-2/,<7-:/.5/E</;-B<E-=/732/A-2E</ ;<-7/ ,<;-:.>B/ 9<:7<-2/ 33=/ 7-/ 2-/ 2<-25-=/ F3387-/ 93=/ 7-/ D<7-,:.;;.=;J/ F-:B-/ <<B,332;-9-=7/E.>=/9<<8/7-/7-4.=.2.-/93=/7-/G8<D:-,-=C/&-/ .=9:<-7/93=/7-/9352-/ :33;/<G/A-25-7.,-=2283=5G<82/F<872/ .=/&-:42\&/ <=7-8/ 3=7-8/ D-G33:7/ 7<<8/ ')!#$/ M(4N/ 7-E-/ F3387-/ .5E<73=.;/;-.>B2/732/--=/E</8-3:.52.5@A/,<;-:.>B/E3=7283=5G<82/<9-8/7-/9352-/:33;/<G28--72C

'8/E<6/;-.>B2/B6==-=/F<87-=/<G/<=7-8/3=7-8-f

-. D<7-,:.;;.=;s-. 5=-:A-7-=s-. .=9:<-7/9352-/:33;/<G/5-7.,-=2283=5G<82s-. 5-7.,-=2283=5G<82/.=/@<,D.=32.-/,-2/7-/283=5G<824<8,6:-s-. 5-7.,-=29-87-:.=;C

)3=F-;-/A-2/2-/:332/[email protected]/B<,-=/93=/;-;-9-=5/.5/7-/.>B.=;/33=/7-/A3=7/93=/5=-:A-7-==37-8A3=7/6.2;-9<-87/-=/7.-=2/7338<,/3:5/[email protected]/&-/.>B.=;/.5/73387<<8/3::--=/;-D35--87<G/ 7-/ ,<84<:<;.5@A-/ [email protected]/ 93=/ 7-/ D<7-,/ 8<=7/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;C/ '@A2-8/ 7<<8,.77-:/93=/7-/[email protected]/,-2/D-A6:G/93=/7-/528<<,5=-:A-7-=/D:.>B2/732/-8/--=/E-:47-/B-659<<8/ 7-/ 86FA-7-=/ ;-,33B2/ 7.-=2/ 2-/ F<87-=/ 3:5/ D.>/ 7-/ .>B.=;/ 33=/ 7-/ A3=7/ 93=/ 7-D<7-,:.;;.=;C

Q3352/7-/.>B.=;/93=/9-85@A.::-=7-/86FA-7-=/93=/7-/D<7-,/E<6/--=/.>B.=;/6.2;-9<-87/B6==-=F<87-=/93=/A-2/5-7.,-=2283=5G<82/.=/@<,D.=32.-/,-2/7-/283=5G<824<8,6:-/-=/7-/D.>D-A<8-=7-G383,-2-85/ -=/ @<[44.@.[=2-=C/ &-E-/ F3387-/ E.>=/ E<3:5/ .=/ G383;8334/ a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email protected]/-=/?<=@:65.-/-=/33=D-9-:.=;-=C

&-/6.2B<,52-=/93=/A-2/,<7-:/9<<8/7-/D<7-,:.;;.=;/D:-B-=/52-8B/34A3=B-:.>B/2-/E.>=/93=/7-?AZELPF3387-C/ '8/ E.>=/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ F3387-=/ ;-D86.B2/ .=/ 9<<8;33=7-/ <=7-8E<-B-=/ 9<<8,<7-::-8.=;/ 93=/ 9352-/ :3;-=/ ,-2/ --=/ 9-8;-:.>BD38-/ 86FA-.7/ MQ.>,-;-=/ -=/ #.=2/ !=78.-5NJ3:5,-7-/<=7-8E<-B/93=/7-/D<7-,86FA-.7/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/D.>/Q.>,-;-=/ME.-/)3=/7-8/U33.>M^bb`NJ/ '55-=/ M^beeNJ/ &<6D-=/ M^bbdN/ -=/ #F3=-=D-8;/ -2/ 3:C/ M^bb^NNC/ R=/ $3D-:/ aPa/ .5/ --=<9-8E.@A2/93=/-=B-:-/;-D86.B2-/F3387-=/.=/,<7-::-=/-=/F3387-=/7.-/E.>=/;-9<=7-=/33=/7-A3=7/93=/<=7-8E<-B/=3/7-/33=:-;/M--=/-=/3=7-8/ .5/3:/--87-8/ .=/7.2/9-85:3;/<G;-=<,-=J/E.-<=7-8/3=7-8-/$3D-:/\P^/-=/G383;834-=/aC0/-=/aC\NC

Page 73: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 6 – 1 1

!5@(%". ?5;.1 J);.-K5.4 C-5)

Q.>,-;-= \\ '55-=/^bee

Q.>,-;-= MB/g/^/v/^Jc/,N 9.3/)3=/7-8/U33.>/Mob`Nf/S-8-B-=.=;/UPF3387-/D8.-4/93=/H*/33=/(H#/^bb1

Q.>,-;-= \d/P/`` #F3=-=D-8;/^bb^

Q.>,-;-= \1 )3=/7-8/U33.>/^bb`

#.=2/!=78.-5 \c #286.B5,3/-2/3:C/^bb`

#.=2/!=78.-5 //\c I<,D-8;-=/-2/3:C/^bbc

'8:-@<,/X/Q.>,-;-= \a/P/`` &<6D-=/^bbd

$3D-:/aPaf ?AZELPF3387-/9<<8/9352-/:3;-=J/;-D86.B2/.=/,<7-::-=/<4/6.2/<=7-8E<-B

&-/?AZELPF3387-/9<<8/7-/9352-/:33;/E3:/33=/7-/A3=7/93=/--=/D-8-B-=.=;/,-2/4<8,6:-/M`C0N--=/F3387-/A-DD-=/2655-=/7-/\1/-=/`1/,^X0X5/D.>/--=/F32-87.-G2-/93=/cJe/,-2-8/MA.-8D.>/E.>=7-/;8-=E-=/D-G33:7/7<<8/D.>/qBrJ/7-/F3387-/^/Y/&c1/2<2/\/Y/&c1/2-/;-D86.B-=NC/&-E-/F3387-/.59<<8/--=/9352-/:33;/.=/A-2/D-;.=/E-B-8/7.5@623D-:J/33=;-E.-=/7<<8/E3=7/<G/7-/9352-/:33;/--=;:377-8-/ <GG-89:3B/ <=252332C/ &-/ D6.2-=D<@A2/ E3:/ 7<<8/ 7-/ 9-8<=7.-G.=;/ 7<<8/ 7-@<[email protected]/93=/<=;-9--8/^J01/,/7-5<=73=B5/--=/:3;-8-/?AZELPF3387-/A-DD-=/73=/7-D.==-=D<@A2C/ )<<8/ A-2/ 3::69.3:-/ 7--:/ F<87-=/ 9--:3:/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ ?AZELPF3387-=33=;-A<67-=f/7.2/F<872/<=7-8/3=7-8-/9-8<<8E33B2/7<<8/7-/9-85@A.::-=7-/D-77.=;59<8,-=/7.-B6==-=/<G28-7-=C/)38.[8-=7/93=/\d/,^X0X5/ME.-/D.>9<<8D--:7f/'55-=J/^beeN/2<2/zc1/,^X0X5/ME.-D.>9<<8D--:7f/ *3,D--B/ -=/ V<55-:,3=J/ ^bbeNC/ %.2/ 7-/ .>B.=;5D-8-B-=.=;-=/ D:.>B2/ 732/ 7-?AZELPF3387-=/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ -=/ A-2/ 3::69.3:-/ 7--:/ A-2/ D-52/ F<872/ F--8;-;-9-=/ ,[email protected]:.>B/\c/,^X0X5/-=/c1/,^X0X5C

&-/7.-G2-/93=/7-/<=2;8<=7.=;55:-64/-=/ 93=/A-2/ -8<5.-;32/ E.>=/ ;-2<-252/ 33=/A-2/ ;-,.77-:7-93=/ 7-/ ,6:2.D-3,PG-.:.=;-=J/ 6.2;-9<-87/ .=/ 7-/ G-8.<7-/ 93=/ ^bbb/ 2<2/ -=/ ,-2/ 011^/ ME.-A<<47526B/c/-=/D.>:3;-/'/9<<8/7-/;-,.77-:7-/F3387-NC/R=/".;668/aP\/2<2/-=/,-2/aPc/E.>=/7-E-;-,.77-:7-=/ 6.2;-E-2/ 53,-=/ ,-2/ 7-/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ 7F385G8<4.-:-=/ 6.2/ 7-5.,6:32.-D-8-B-=.=;-=C/ &-/ .=/ 7-/ :-;-=73/ ;-D86.B2-/ F3387-/ )*\c/ !)c1/ 52332/ 9<<8/ )352-*33;/-=/!::6).3:-/7--:/,-2/7-/?AZELPF3387-C

Page 74: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

6 – 1 2 WL | Delft Hydraulics

".;668/aP\f (6FA-.75@<,D.=32.-5/<G/B,8/b0cJd/M7.BB-/:.>=/g/;-,C/93=/7-/G-.:.=;-=N^

".;668/aP`f (6FA-.75@<,D.=32.-5/<G/B,8/b0aJd/M7.BB-/:.>=/g/;-,C/93=/7-/G-.:.=;-=N

//////////////////////////////////////////////////////>27E2!'(('23--,27(!'"2E((.F2072!'(('23--,20++*7$(+"2#""+2%"'2#((,(65'",2#"2G5HI1J8((,#"

Page 75: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 6 – 1 3

".;668/aPcf (6FA-.75@<,D.=32.-5/<G/B,8/b0dJd/M7.BB-/:.>=/g/;-,C/93=/7-/G-.:.=;-=N^

".;668/aPaf (6FA-.75@<,D.=32.-5/<G/B,8/b0eJa/M7.BB-/:.>=/g/;-,C/93=/7-/G-.:.=;-=N

//////////////////////////////////////////////////////>27E2!'(('23--,27(!'"2E((.F2072!'(('23--,20++*7$(+"2#""+2%"'2#((,(65'",2#"2G5HI1J8((,#"

Page 76: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

6 – 1 4 WL | Delft Hydraulics

R=/".;668/aP\/2<2/-=/,-2/aPa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c/-=/D.>:3;-/'/5233=/53,-=;-932/.=/$3D-:/aPd/M,32-=/.=/,-2-85,-2/7-/523=7338734F.>B.=;/6.2;-786B2/.=/A-2/G-8@-=23;-/93=/A-2/;-,.77-:7-NC

].8<&;".F%.&WY8&CVGX ?(^<&+.8<&;".F%.&WY8&CVGX !.)+%.&W8X

'8<5.-5:-64 `Jae/M`hN^ aJc1/MahN ^`e1/M01hN

'8<5.-;32 cJb1/M0hN eJ\`/M^^hN cbc/MchN

_8(%.)&")&Y8&S2\`

'8<5.-5:-64 //\J\1 //cJ^1

'8<5.-;32 //`Ja1 //dJ11

$3D-:/aPdf/&.,-=5.-5/-8<5.-5:-64/-=/-8<5.-;32/#2C/!=78.-5

V-2/--=/9-8;-:.>B.=;/93=/7-/7.,-=5.-5/E<3:5/9-8,-:7/.=/$3D-:/aPd/D:.>B-=/7-/?AZELPF3387-=2655-=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ -=/ A-2/ 3::69.3:-/ 7--:/ [email protected]:.>B/ \c,^X0X5/ -=/ c1/ ,^X0X5/ A-2/ D-52<9-8--=/2-/B<,-=/,-2/7-/F-8B-:.>BA-.7C/)<<8/7-/,3Y.,3:-/7.-G2-/E.-/".;668/aP^1J/F338/--=,3Y.,3:-/7.-G2-/33=F-E.;/.5/93=/@.8@3/PdJ^1/,/Q!]C/&-/,3Y.,3:-/7.-G2-/9<<8/7-/-8<5.-5:-64B<,2/ .=/ 7-/ D-8-B-=.=;-=/ ,-2/ --=/ @<=523=2-/ 349<-8/ =.-2/ 2<2/ 523=7s/ 7338-=2-;-=/ .5/ 7-;-,.77-:7-/7.-G2-/93=/P\J\1/,-2-8/Q!]/.=/7-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/F-:/F338=--,D338JE.-/".;668/aP`C

Q3/--=/5.,6:32.-2.>7/93=/\/>338/M,-2/@<=523=2-/349<-8N/.5/-8/=36F-:.>B5/=<;/9-83=7-8.=;/.=/7-D<7-,/F338=--,D338J/E.-/".;668/aPd/-=/.5/--=/5.,6:32.-2.>7/93=/\/>338/33==-,-:.>BC

^/>3=638./^bbb/M52382N ^/4-D8638./^bbb/M=3/^/,33=7N

//////////////////////////////////////////////////////>2K'(&#((,#(/8$=9$&.2'"&2-4I$65'"23(&25"'2."%$##"+#"2$&24,-6"&'"&

Page 77: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 6 – 1 5

^/,3382/^bbb/M=3/0/,33=7-=N ^/3G8.:/^bbb/M=3/\/,33=7-=N

^/>3=638./0111/M=3/^/>338N ^/>3=638./011^/M=3/0/>338N

^/>3=638./0110/M=3/\/>338N ^/>3=638./011\/M=3/`/>338N

".;668/aPdf '8<5.-;32/-=/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/<G/9-85@A.::-=7-/2.>7-=/M349<-8/^a11/,\X5N

Q3/7-/.>B.=;/.5/9<<8/A-2/,<7-:/--=/D-8-B-=.=;/6.2;-9<-87/,-2/--=/938.[8-=7-/349<-8C/)<<87-E-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/.5/;-D86.B/;-,33B2/93=/--=/;-5@A-,32.5--87-/AL78<;8334/ME.-/D.>:3;-/+-=/ ".;668/ aPeNC/ I.-8.=/ .5/ 7-/ 349<-8J/ E<3:5/ 7-E-/ E.@A/ .=/ 7-/ >38-=/ ^bbb/ 2<2/ -=/ ,-2/ 011^9<<87--7J/;-5@A-,32.5--87C/&-E-/.5/9-8;-:-B-=/,-2/--=/@<=523=2-/349<-8J/<,/2-/@<=28<:-8-=<4/7-/;-5@A-,32.5--87-/F.55-:-=7-/349<-8/A-2E-:47-/-.=78-56:2332/<G:-9-87-J/E.-/".;668/aPbC)<<8/ A-2/ A<<;52-/ G6=2/ 93=/ 7-/ D6:2/ E.>=/ .5/ 7-/ D<7-,:.;;.=;/ D.>/ --=/ @<=523=2-/ 349<-8/ -=938.[8-=7-/349<-8/.=/".;668/aPb/F--8;-;-9-=C/I.-86.2/D:.>B2/732/7-/@<=523=2-/349<-8/,-2/A-2;-,.77-:7-/ 93=/ 7-/ 938.[8-=7-/ 349<-8/ <9-8--=B<,2C/ )<<8/ A-2/ -8<5.-;32/ D:.>B2/ -8/ --=<=7-85@A322.=;/93=/7-/7.-G2-/<G/2-/28-7-=/9<<8/7-/D<7-,:.;;.=;/D.>/--=/@<=523=2-/349<-8C

Page 78: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

6 – 1 6 WL | Delft Hydraulics

Waalafvoer en geschematiseerde afvoer

0

750

1500

2250

3000

3750

4500

5250

600031

-12-

1998

01-0

3-19

99

30-0

4-19

99

29-0

6-19

99

28-0

8-19

99

27-1

0-19

99

26-1

2-19

99

24-0

2-20

00

24-0

4-20

00

23-0

6-20

00

22-0

8-20

00

21-1

0-20

00

20-1

2-20

00

18-0

2-20

01

19-0

4-20

01

18-0

6-20

01

17-0

8-20

01

16-1

0-20

01

15-1

2-20

01

Datum [dd-mm-jjjj]

Deb

iet

[m3 /s

]

Debiet

Geschematiseerddebiet

".;668/aPef !49<-89-8:<<G/^bbb/2<2/-=/,-2/011^/-=/;-5@A-,32.5--87-/349<-8/MH33:N

Q37-8A3=7/ .5/ 9<<8/ 7-/ 349<-8/ ;-8-B-=7/ ,-2/ 7-/ ;-,.77-:7-/ 349<-8/ G-8/ -2,33:C/ S.>/ 7-;-5@A-,32.5--87-/ AL78<;8334/ E<67-=/ =3,-:.>B/ --=/ 33=23:/ 33=G355.=;-=/ -=/ D-8-B-=.=;-=,<-2-=/ F<87-=/ 6.2;-9<-87C/ Q3,-:.>Bf/ @<=28<:-/ <4/ A-2/ 2<233:/ 283=5G<82/ ;-:.>B/ .5/ 33=/ A-2283=5G<82/ ,-2/ --=/ ;-,.77-:7-/ 349<-8/ -=/ --=/ @<[email protected]/ <G/ 7-/ ;-,.77-:7-/ G.-B349<-8-=M33=;-E.-=/=.-2/7-/;-A-:-/349<-8/7<<8/A-2/:33;F32-8D-7/;332J/A-2/A<<;F32-8D-7/528<<,2/73=<<B/,--NC/+-E.-=/7-/<,93=;8.>B-/8-B-=2.>7/[email protected]@3/001/668///b/73;-=N/7.-/=<<7E3B-:.>B/.5/D.>7-8;-:.>B-/D-8-B-=.=;-=J/.5/7-E-/5:-@A25/ZZ=/,33:/6.2;-9<-87C

".;668/aPbf S<7-,9-8:<<G/2CAC9C/B,8C/b0eJc/<G/^e,/6.2/7-/8-@A2-8P=<8,33::.>=

Page 79: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 6 – 1 7

)-85@A.:/ 2655-=/;-5@A-,32.5--87-/ AL78<;8334/ -=/ 7-/ -2,33:/ ;-,.77-:7-/ AL78<;8334/ .5/ @.8@31J^/,-2-8C/&-/;-5@A-,32.5--87-/AL78<;8334/ .5/ 7.-G-8/ 2-8/ A<<;2-/ 93=/A-2/ -8<5.-;32/ -=/ @.8@31J1\/,-2-8/<=7.-G-8/2-8/A<<;2-/93=/7-/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2J/E.-/".;668/aPbC/&-/;-5@A-,32.5--87-349<-8/-=/7-/-2,33:/;-,.77-:7-/349<-8/5233=/9-8,-:7/.=/D.>:3;-/+/-=/".;668/aPeC

".;668/aP^1f )-85@A.:/2655-=/-2,33:/;-,.77-:7-/349<-8/-=/;-5@A-,32.5--87-/349<-8

!3=/ 7-/ A3=7/ 7-/ 528<<,5=-:A-.7/ ,-2/ !&?]P,-2.=;-=/ M!@<652.@/ &<GG:-8/ ?688-=2/ ]8<4.:-8P,-2.=;-=N/.5/-8/--=/[email protected]/6.2;-9<-87/<G/7-/;-B<E-=/9-8A<67.=;/2655-=/7-/86FA-.7/93=A-2/ 3::69.3:-/ 7--:/ -=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;C/ &.2/ .5/ =.-2/ ;-D86.B2/ 9<<8/ 7-/ .>B.=;/ 93=/ A-2/ ,<7-:J93=F-;-/ A-2/ =.-2/ --87-8/ [email protected]/ B6==-=/ E.>=/ 93=/ 7-/ ;-;-9-=5C/ R=/ ".;668/ aPb/ E.>=/ 7-7.-G2-/;-,.77-:7-/5=-:A-7-=/6.2;-E-2/34B<,52.;/93=/7-/!&?]P,-2.=;-=/-=/7-/D-8-B-=.=;-=,-2/D-A6:G/93=/&-:42\&C/&-/!&?]P,-2.=;-=/E.>=/6.2;-9<-87/<G/^a/,-./011^/,-2/--=/349<-893=/^bd1/,\X5J/7-/5=-:A-7-=/6.2/7-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/93=/&-:42\&/E.>=/-9-=--=5/;-D35--87/<G--=/ 349<-8/ 93=/ ^bd1/,\X5C/ &-/ !&?]P,-2.=;-=/ E.>=/ ;-,-2-=/ 93=/ B8.D93B/ =338/ B8.D93BJ/ .=".;668/aPb/.5/-@A2-8/3::--=/A-2/;-7--:2-/F--8;-;-9-=/2655-=/7-/=<8,33::.>=-=/.=C

Diepte gemiddelde stroomsnelheden16 mei 2001 met Q=1970m3/s

0.60

0.80

1.00

1.20

1.40

1.60

1.80

0.00 40.00 80.00 120.00 160.00 200.00 240.00 280.00

Afstand vanaf linker-normaallijn [m]

Stro

omsn

elhe

id [

m/s

]

ADCP meting

VL30 AV45

VL30 AV50

VL35 AV45

VL35 AV50

VL40 AV50

".;668/aP^^f )[email protected]/ 93=/ 86FA-7-=/ 33=/ 7-/ A3=7/ 93=/ 7-/ 52<<,5=-:A-7-=

Page 80: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

6 – 1 8 WL | Delft Hydraulics

I-2/9-8:<<G/93=/7-/528<<,5=-:A-.7/.5/<9-8/7-/D8--72-/938.[8-=7C/%.2/".;668/aPb/.5/-@A2-8/<G2-/ ,3B-=/ 732/ 7-/ @<,D.=32.-/ 93=/ ?9352-/ :33;/ g/ \c/ ,^X0X5/ -=/ ?3::69.33:/ g/ c1/ ,^X0X5/ A-2/ D-52<9-8--=B<,2C/&-E-/@<,D.=32.-/B<,2/<9-8--=/,-2/7-/F3387-/33=/7-/A3=7/93=/7-/.>B.=;/93=7-/ D<7-,7.-G2-/ 8<=7/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;C/ &-/ [email protected]/ 33=/ 7-/ A3=7/ 93=/ 7-/ 528<<,5=-:A-7-=D-9-52.;7/765/7-/B-65/9<<8/7-/;-B<E-=/?AZELPF3387-=C

'8/ .5/ ;--=/ .>B.=;/ 6.2;-9<-87/ =338/ 7-/ 5-7.,-=29-87-:.=;/ <9-8/ 7-/ 7F385833.-=/ .=/ 7-/ D<@A2C)<<8/A-2/ 2<233:/ 283=5G<82/ .5/6.2;-;33=/93=/7-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/93=/?CTC/#:<44/ ME.-/#:<44J/011^NF338.=/A-2/,<7-:/9<:7--7/33=/--=/>338283=5G<82/93=/a11C111/2<2/d11C111/,\X>338/F32/.=/7-<87-/:.;2/93=/A-2/H33:283=5G<82/93=/@.8@3/ae0C111/,\X>338C

'8/E.>=/2-9-=5/D-8-B-=.=;-=/6.2;-9<-87/,-2/9-85@A.::-=7-/(4PF3387-=/M@3:.D832.-/@<[44.@.[=29<<8/283=5G<82/<9-8/7-/9352-/:33;NC/&<<8/33=G355.=;/93=/7-E-/43@2<8/.5/;-G8<D--87/A-2E3=79-8:<<G/<9-8/7-/9352-/:33;/E<73=.;/33=/2-/G355-=J/732/7-E-/<9-8--=52-,2/,-2/7-,6:2.D-3,PG-.:.=;-=C/R=/A-2/&-:42\&P,<7-:/q:<G-=r/<9-8/7-/;-A-:-/9352-/:33;q5-7.,-=2D6:2>-5r/7.-/.=/7-/,6:2.D-3,P,-2.=;-=/=.-2/E.>=/F338;-=<,-=C/&.2/9-85@A.>=5-:B<,2/7<<8/7-/F.>E-/93=/,<7-::-8-=/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/-=/A-2/E3=7283=5G<82/7338<9-8/A--=J/E.-9-8;-:.>B.=;/MaC\N/9<<8/7-/[email protected]@<[44.@.[=2/9<<8/283=5G<82/<9-8/7-/9352-/:33;C/&-E-q5-.,-=2D6:2>-5/E.>=/<=7-8/3=7-8-/E.@A2D338/.=/".;668/aP^1

&-/D<7-,A<<;2-/93=/A-2/;-.>B2-/5.,6:32.-,<7-:/.5/F--8;-;-9-=/.=/".;668/aP^1C

".;668/aP^0f S<7-,A<<;2-/;-.>B2/5.,6:32.-,<7-:/93=/B,8/b0`J0/2<2/b0bJ`/M=3/`/>338N

Page 81: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 6 – 1 9

6.5 Discussie

&-/9<:;-=7-/G6=2-=/F<87-=/=<;/<G;-,-8B2f

-. S8--72-/93=/7-/9352-/:33;&-/D8--72-/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/.5/.=/F-8B-:.>BA-.7/<=;-9--8/^`1/,-2-8C/&-/D8--72-/.=A-2/,<7-:/.5/@.8@3/^\0/,-2-8/M--=/9-85@A.:/93=/@.8@3/c/hNC/&.2/9-85@A.:/B<,2/7<<8/A-2;-B<E-=/ 8<<52-8/ 732/ ;-D86.B2/ .5C/ )<<8/ --=/ =36FB-68.;-8/ ,3329<-8.=;/ E<6/ 7-E-4.>=,3E.;-8/ ,<-2-=/ E.>=/ <4/ E<73=.;/ 9-87--:7/ 732/ 7-/ D8--7/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;<9-8--=B<,2/,-2/7-/8<<52-8G6=2-=/93=/A-2/8-B-=8<<52-8C/I.-8/.5/93=34/;-E.-=/<,732A-2/9-8F3@A2-/9-85@A.:/732/A.-87<<8/<=252332/=.A.:/.5C/&-/:-=;2-/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/.=A-2/ ,<7-:/ A3=;2/ -9-=--=5/ 34/ 93=/ 7-/ :<@32.-/ 93=/ 7-/ 8<<52-8G6=2-=J/ A.-8D.>/ .5/ A-29-85@A.:/5:-@A25/1J\/h/.=/9-8;-:.>B.=;/,-2/7-/F-8B-:.>BA-.7C

-. +-D86.B/?AZELPF3387-/<4/7-/BPF3387-/93=/Q.B68375-i<3:5/3:/D.>/7-/3=3:L2.5@A-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/.5/D-5@A8-9-=/.5/.=/A-2/,<7-:/;-8-B-=7/,-2?AZELPF3387-J/ ,-2/ =3,-/ 9<<8/ A-2/ 3::69.3:-/ 7--:/ 732/ 7<<8/ 76.=-=/ 52-8B/ F<872D-.=9:<-7/ .5/9<<8/--=/?AZELPF3387-/;-B<E-=C/&.2/A<672/ .=/732/9<<8/7-/ 9352-/ :33;<<B/,-2/--=/?AZELPF3387-/;-8-B-=7/7.-=2/2-/F<87-=/M.=/&-:42\&/.5/G-8/,<7-:/ZZ=86FA-.75G383,-2-8/ 2-/ 7-4.=.[8-=NC/ &-/ ?AZELPF3387-/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ .5/ 52-8B34A3=B-:.>B/ 93=/ A-2/ F-:/ <4/ =.-2/ 9<<8B<,-=/ 93=/ 5-7.,-=2/ <G/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;C/ V-25-7.,-=2/<G/7-/9352-/ :33;/;332/7-/?AZELPF3387-/52-8B/<,A<<;/-=/7-/86FA-.7/765<,:33;C/R=/A-2/,<7-:/.5/;-B<E-=/9<<8/--=/34:<G-=7-/?AZELPF3387-J/F338D.>/ .=/A-2D-;.=/7-/9352-/ :33;/7-E-:47-/ 86FA-.7/ A--42/ 3:5/ A-2/ 3::69.3:-/ ;-7--:2-C/&-/ 86FA-.7=--,2/9-89<:;-=5/2<-/<9-8/7-/:-=;2-/732/<<B/7-/A<<;2-/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/2<-=--,2MA-2/D-;.=23:67NC/&-E-/2<-=3,-/93=/7-/?AZELPF3387-/E<6/-.;-=:.>B/D-G33:7/,<-2-=F<87-=/ 33=/7-/ A3=7/93=/A-2/F-:/ <4/ =.-2/ 33=F-E.;/ E.>=/ 93=/ 5-7.,-=2/ <G/ 7-/ 9352-:33;J/E.-/!3=D-9-:.=;-=/-=/A-2/<=7-85233=7-/G6=2C

-. OG:<G-=7-/?AZELPF3387-/I-2/ ;-D86.B/ 93=/ --=/ <G:<G-=7-/ ?AZELPF3387-/ .5/ E<3:5/ A.-89<<8/ D-5G8<B-=7.5@623D-:/<,732/93=/2-/9<8-=/=.-2/D-B-=7/.5/<4/<G/7.-/:<@32.-/7337F-8B-:.>B/E3=7/<G7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ B<,2/ 2-/ :.;;-=C/ I-2/ 93=/ 2-/ 9<8-=/ 7-4.=.[8-=/ 93=/ --=/ ?AZELPF3387-D-W=9:<-7/ 7-/ 528<,.=;/ -=/ 7338,--/ 7-/ :.;;.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ D<7-,C/ I.-87<<8/ .5/ A-2D.>9<<8D--:7/,<;-:.>B/ 732/ 34A3=B-:.>B/ 93=/ 7-/ ;-B<E-=/?AZELPF3387-/ 5-7.,-=232.-<G28--72J/2-8F.>:/732/=<8,33:/=.-2/E<6/;-D-68-=C

-. RTB.=;&-/-.;-=:.>B-/.>B.=;/.5/.=/7.2/<=7-8E<-B/5:-@A25/;-D35--87/<G/7-/D<7-,:.;;.=;/8<=77-/9352-/:33;C/&.2/.5/-@A2-8/F-:/7-/D-:3=;8.>B52-/-=/,--52/,332;-9-=7-/G383,-2-8/.=A-2/ <=7-8E<-BJ/ ,338/ 7-/ .>B.=;/ B3=/ 6.2;-D8-.7-8/ -=/ 7338,--/ 9<::-7.;-8C/ i<3:5/ .=A<<47526B/a/ 3:/ .5/ 33=;-;-9-=/B3=/ 7-/ .>B.=;/,-2/ D-A6:G/ 93=f/ 5-7.,-=2283=5G<82/ .=@<,D.=32.-/,-2/7-/ 283=5G<824<8,6:-/-=/ 5-7.,-=29-87-:.=;/F<87-=/6.2;-9<-87C/V-2D-A6:G/ 93=/ 7-/ [email protected]/ 93=/ 7-/ 86FA-7-=/ 33=/ 7-/ A3=7/ 93=/ 7-/ 528<<,5=-:A-7-=D:.>B2/7-/>6.52-/B-6E-/;-,33B2/ 2-/E.>=/9<<8/7-/86FA-7-=C/!@A2-834/B3=/765/F<87-=;-52-:7/732/--=/.>B.=;/33=/7-/A3=7/93=/7-/528<<,5=-:A-7-=/=.-2/E<6/:-.7-=/2<2/--=3=7-8-/B-6E-/93=/7-/D<7-,86FA-7-=C

Page 82: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

6 – 2 0 WL | Delft Hydraulics

-. Q6,-8.-B-/-=/,<7-:P<=9<:B<,-=A-7-=I-2/ ;-D86.B/ 93=/ A-2/ @<,G62-8,<7-:/ D8-=;2/ --=/ 33=23:/ =37-:-=/ ,-2/ E.@A/ ,--34A3=B-:.>B/93=/A-2/,<7-:C/&-/<G93::-=752-/34F.>B.=;-=/7.-/.=/A-2/;-D86.B2-/,<7-:<G28-7-=/ 2-=/ <GE.@A2-/ 93=/ 7-/ ,6:2.D-3,P,-2.=;-=/ E.>=f/ q:<G-=7-/ D6:2-=/ <9-8/ 7-9352-/ :33;r/ -=/ B:-.=-/ 52<8.=;-=/ 33=/ 7-/ 83=7-=/ 93=/ A-2/ ,<7-:C/ &-/ :33252-/ F<87-=;-9<8,7/7<<8/7-/B:-.=-/B=.B>-5/ 2655-=/7-/ 8-@A2-/ :.>=-=/93=/7-/ 8<<52-8@-::-=/-=/7-2<2523=7B<,.=;/93=/7-/D6.2-=83=7-=/93=/A-2/,<7-:/ M,-2/ D-A6:G/ 93=/ 8-@A2-/ :.>=-=2655-=/7-/B8.DB<GG-=/.=NC/&-/9-852<8.=;-=/7.-/A.-86.2/9<<829:<-.-=/E.>=/E--8/B:-.=/-=A-DD-=/ ;--=/ 5.;=.4.@3=2-/ .=9:<-7/ <G/ 7-/ D<7-,/ 8<=7/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;C/ &-/ q:<G-=7-D6:2-=/ <9-8/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;r/ E<8;-=/ F3385@A.>=:.>B/ -9-=--=5/ =.-2/ 9<<8/ ;8<2-9-83=7-8.=;-=/.=/7-/D<7-,C/&-E-/E3=7<GA<G.=;-=/<G/7-/9352-/:33;/<=25233=/7<<8/7-F.>E-/F338<G/ 7-/ [email protected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

-. $83=5G<824<8,6:-&-/ .=/ A-2/ ,<7-:/ ;-D86.B2-/ 283=5G<824<8,6:-/ .5/ 93=/ '=;-:6=7PI3=5-=C/ &-E-/ .5/ .=--87-8/ <=7-8E<-B/ <<B/ ;-D86.B2J/ ,338/ 732/ ;-:72/ -9-=--=5/ 9<<8/ 3=7-8-283=5G<824<8,6:-5C/I-2/;-D86.B/93=/'=;-:6=7PI3=5-=/.5/.=/7-E-/5267.-/=.-2/;-2<-252<G/>6.52A-.7C/'9-=3:5/--=/33=23:/F3387-=/7.-/ .=9:<-7/6.2<-4-=-=/<G/7-/;8<<22-/93=A-2/283=5G<82C/)--:3:/D-28-42/A-2/F3387-=/7.-/;-D86.B2/E.>=/.=/A-2/<=7-8E<-B/93=/#:<44.=/ 011^/ =338/ qV<84<:<;.5@A-/ 5267.-/ SO#/S3;;-8-=/,-2/&-:420&P(.9.-8-=r/F338.=A-2/,<7-:/D-52<=7/6.2/7-/;-A-:-/H33:C

-. +-;837--87/5-7.,-=2R=/A-2/,<7-:/.5/;-D86.B/;-,33B2/93=/--=/6=.4<8,-/B<88-:7.3,-2-8/M1J10,N/9<<8/7-3::69.3:-/D<7-,C/R=/F-8B-:.>BA-.7/E.2/A.-8/--=/5G8-.7.=;/.=J/E<3:5/-9-=--=5/3:/D:.>B233=/7-/A3=7/93=/7-/9-85@A.::-=7-/D<7-,<=7-8E<-B-=/,-2/9-85@A.::-=7-/F3387-=/-=9-87-:.=;-=C/)<<8/--=/3:;-,--=/D--:7/93=/A-2/D<7-,9-8:<<G/D:.>B2/A-2/;-D86.B/93=--=/ 6=.4<8,-/ B<88-:7.3,-2-8/ ;<-7/ 2-/ 9<:7<-=/ -=/ .5/ 34;-E.-=/ 93=/ A-2/ ;-D86.B/ 93=;-;837--87/5-7.,-=2J/,-7-/<,/7-/8-B-=2.>7/93=/A-2/,<7-:/2-/D-G-8B-=C

-. OG:<55.=;-=/D-8-B-=7/,-2/--=/@<=523=2/7-D.-2&-/ @<[email protected]/ <G:<55.=;-=/ E.>=/ 5:-@A25/ ,-2/ --=/ @<=523=2-/ 349<-8/ D-8-B-=7CI.-89<<8/ .5/;-B<E-=/<,732/A-2/ 2-=/--852-/<,/7-/[email protected]/93=/7-/D<7-,;332/ -=/ A-2/ 2-=/ 2F--7-/ 7-/ 8-B-=2.>7/ 33=E.-=:.>B/ 9-8B<82/ Ma/ l/ e/ 668/ ,-2/ @<=523=2-349<-8/2-;-=/^1/73;-=/,-2/-2,33:/;-,.77-:7-/349<-8NC/)<<8/A-2/G8<2<2LG-/,<7-:/.5F-:/ ;-8-B-=7/ ,-2/ --=/ ;-938.--87-/ 349<-8/ -=/ 7338/ D:.>B2/ 732/ ,-2/ =3,-/ D.>/ 7-D<7-,:.;;.=;/93=/7-/ 5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/7-E-/ 8-7-:.>B/<9-8--=B<,-=/,-2/-:B338J/ E.-D.>:3;-/+N

Page 83: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 6 – 2 1

-. R=9:<-7/93=/B8.DD-=/<G/7-/D<7-,R=/ A-2/,<7-:/ E.>=/ 7-/ B8.DD-=/ -=/ 7-/ .=9:<-7/ 93=/ 7-/ B8.DD-=/ <G/ 7-/ D<7-,/ D6.2-=D-5@A<6F.=;/;-:32-=C/I.-87<<8/<=2D8--B2/.=/A-2/,<7-:/G-8/7-4.=.2.-/--=/9-85@A.>=5-:J-@A2-8/ 7-E-/ 9-85@A.>=5-:-=/ B<,-=/ <9-8/ 7-/ G8.,3.8-/ 9-85@A.>=5-:-=/ A--=/ -=/ E.>=:<B33:C/ &-/ ;-D86.B2-/ ,<7-::-=/ F<87-=/ <=7-8:.=;/ ,-2/ -:B338/ 9-8;-:-B-=/ .=/ [email protected]/ 93=/ 7-/ D<7-,/ -=/ 7338D.>/ .5/ 7-/ :<B3:-/ 5-@6=73.8-/ .=9:<-7/ 93=B8.DD-=/93=/<=7-8;[email protected]/D-:3=;C/OG/7-/:<B3:-/7.-G2-/9<<8/7-/<=2;8<=7.=;55:-64/<49<<8/7-/7.-G2-/2655-=/7-/D<7-,B8.DD-=/D.>/'8:-@<,/B3=/7-/.=9:<-7/93=/7-/B8.DD-=-@A2-8/F-:/93=/D-:3=;/E.>=C

-. +:[email protected]:-/:33;/,<7-::-8-=R=/ A-2/ ,<7-:/ 93=/ #.=2/ !=78.-5/ .5/ .=/ 7-/ D.==-=D<@A2/ 7-/ ;:[email protected]:-/ :33;/ =.-2;-,<7-::--87C/&-E-/F-8B2/7338/3:5/A-2/F38-/3:5/--=/9352-/:33;C/&-/33=F-E.;A-.7/93=7-/;:[email protected]:-/ :33;/ .5/ D.>/ 7-/ ;-,.77-:7-/ D<7-,:.;;.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ D.==-=D<@A2/ 76.7-:.>BE.@A2D338/M7-/8-52/E.>=/76.=-=/-=/9-8G:3325-=/.=/7-/ :<<G/93=/7-/ 2.>7NC/&<<8/A-2/=.-2,<7-::-8-=/ 93=/ 7-/ ;:[email protected]:-/ :33;/ F<87-=/ G-8/ 7-4.=.2.-/ =.-2/ 3::-/ 9-85@A.>=5-:-=,--;-=<,-=C

-. T338:.>B5/5-7.,-=2283=5G<82/D.>/938.3D-:-/349<-8&-/ D-8-B-=.=;/ 93=/ D<7-,A<<;2-/ 93=/ 7-/ 5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/ .=/ A-2/ ,<7-:/ ,-2/ --=938.3D-:-/ 349<-8/ B<,2J/ E<3:5/ 3:/ --87-8/ D-5@A8-9-=J/ ;<-7/ <9-8--=/ ,-2/ 7-D<7-,A<<;2-/ D.>/ --=/ @<=523=2-/ 349<-8C/ &-/ D-8-B-=.=;/ 9<<8/ A-2/ ,<7-:/ ,-2/ --=938.3D-:-/349<-8/.5/-@A2-8/=.-2/;-.>B2/<G/7-/F-8B-:.>B-/5-7.,-=2349<-8C/&-E-/E<6/.=A-2/,<7-:/,<;-:.>B/2-/A<<;/E.>=C/&-/;-,.77-:7-/349<-8/<9-8/7-/;-5@A-,32.5--87-/<4-2,33:/;-,.77-:7-/349<-8/:.;2/=3,-:.>B/@.8@3/0c1/,\/A<;-8/73=/7-/@<=523=2-/349<[email protected]:.>B/@.8@3/^ec1/,\X5/-=/^a11/,\X5N

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

Page 84: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

6 – 2 2 WL | Delft Hydraulics

Page 85: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 7 – 1

7 Mogelijke verbeteringenbodembeschermingsconstructies

7.1 Inleiding

R=/7.2/A<<47526B/F<87-=/,<;-:.>B-/@<[email protected]/9-8D-2-8.=;-=/9-8,-:7C/&-E-/<G:<55.=;-=A-DD-=/3::-,33:/2<2/7<-:/<,/7-/,<84<:<;.5@A-/G8<D:-,-=/2-/8-76@-8-=C/&-/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2JD-=-7-=528<<,5/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;J/ A--42/ 7338D.>/ 7-/ A<<47G8.<8.2-.2C/ &-E-/ ,<-2/ E<73=.;F<87-=/33=;-G352/732/--=/7.-G;3=;/93=/0Je1/B3=/F<87-=/;-8-3:.5--87C/&338=3352/.5/A-2/93=D-:3=;/732/7-/9-8D-2-8.=;-=/33=/7-/9352-/:33;/7-/7.-G2-/93=/A-2/-8<5.-;32/-=/7-/-8<5.-5:-649-8,.=7-8-=C/&-E-/-8<5.-:<@32.-5/9<8,-=/7<<8/<=7-8,.>=.=;/93=/7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ --=/;-93389<<8/7-/523D.:.2-.2C/i<3:5/3:/.=/A<<47526B/0/.5/9-8,-:7/A<-42/7.2/D.>/;-7--:2-:.>B-/9-8E3BB.=;93=/7-/9352-/:33;/=<;/=.-2/2<2/<=>6.52/46=@2.<=-8-=/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/2-/:-.7-=C/)-8D-2-8.=;-=M@CpC/9-85:-@A2-8.=;-=N/F<87-=/3::--=/BF3:.232.-4/D-<<87--:7C

R=/G383;8334/dC0/F<872/--=/33=23:/,<;-:.>B-/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;-=/D-5@A8-9-=C/)3=/7-E-<G:<55.=;-=/ E3:/ <G/9<<8A3=7/ --=/ 33=23:/ 3:/ 3493::-=C/)3=/ 7-/ @<[email protected]/ <G:<55.=;-=/ 7.-E.>=/D-8-B-=7J/E.>=/.=/G383;8334/dC\/7-/8-56:232-=/D-B=<G2/F--8;-;-9-=/ME.-/D.>:3;-/I/9<<86.2;-D8-.7-8-/F--8;39-/93=/7-/8-56:232-=/-=/B<82-/D-5@A8.>9.=;/93=/7-/<G:<55.=;-=NC

7.2 Mogelijke constructieve oplossingen

!::-8--852/ F<87-=/ A.-8=3/ 7-/ G8<D:--,52-::.=;-=/ E<3:5/ 7.-/ 5233=/ 9-8,-:7/ .=/ A<<47526B/ ^J;[email protected].@--87/ 9<<8/ 7-/ D<@A2/ 93=/ #.=2/ !=78.-5J/ E<73=.;/ 732/ 7-/ <G:<55.=;/ ;-2<-252/ B3=F<87-=C/&-/G8<D:-,-=/F338/--=/<G:<55.=;/9<<8/.5/;-E<@A2J/E.>=/.=/--=/78.-23:/<=7-87-:-=/2-<[email protected]=J/F338D.>/7-/--852-/7-/;8<<252-/G8.<8.2-.2/A--42C

-. #-7.,-=232.-D6:2J/ =3,-:.>Bf/ --=/ 2-/ A<;-/ D<7-,A<<;2-/ .=/ 7-/ D.==-=D<@A2D-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/M2655-=/B,8/b0e/-=/b0bN

]8<D:--,f F32-87.-G2-/9<:7<-2/=.-2/33=/7-/-.5s/bch/93=/7-/2.>7/P0Je1,/D.>/O*!

+-F-=52f F32-87.-G2-/10Je1,/M4/5/P^Ja^/-=/P^Jad/,/Q!]N-. '8<5.-;32J/ =3,-:.>B/ --=/ ;32/,-2/ --=/ 7.-G2-/ ;8<2-8/ 73=/ 7-/ <=7-8B3=2/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-

:33;J/D-=-7-=528<<,5/.=/7-/D6.2-=D<@A2/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/M2655-=/B,8/b0e/-=/b0bN]8<D:--,f 523D.:.2-.2/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/.=/;-9338J/7<<8/<=7-8,.>=.=;/

F32/E<6/B6==-=/:-.7-=/2<2/7.546=@2.<=-8-=C+-F-=52f F32-87.-G2-/5/`Jc1,/MM4/1/P\J\d/,/Q!]N

-. '8<5.-5:-64J/=3,-:.>B/--=/5:-64/,-2/--=/7.-G2-/;8<2-8/73=/7-/<=7-8B3=2/93=/7-/9352-:33;J/.=/7-/D.==-=D<@A2/=3352/7-/9352-/:33;

]8<D:--,f 523D.:.2-.2/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/.=/;-9338J/7<<8/<=7-8,.>=.=;/F32/E<6/B6==-=/:-.7-=/2<2/7.546=@2.<=-8-=C

+-F-=52f F32-87.-G2-/5/`Jc1,/MM4/1/P\J^d/-=/P\J\1/,/Q!]N

Page 86: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

7 – 2 WL | Delft Hydraulics

)-87-8/ ,<-2/ 7-/ 33=G355.=;/ E</ F<87-=/ ;-B<E-=/ 732/ E<F-:/ 7-/ ,<84<:<;.5@A-/ G8<D:-,-=F<87-=/ 9-8A<:G-=/ 3:5/ 7-/ -.5/ 732/ <9-8/ --=/ D8--72-/ 93=/ ^d1/ ,/ --=/ 7.-G;3=;/ 93=/ 0Je1/ ,;-;383=7--87/B3=/F<87-=C/)<<8;33=7-/52332/53,-=;-932/.=/$3D-:/dP^C/H338D.>/7-/7.-G2-/2-8G:3325-/93=/A-2/-8<5.-;32/-=/7-/-8<5.-5:-64/,<-2/9<:7<-=/33=/7-/,.=.,3:-/7.-G2-J/E<3:5/7.-9<<82B<,2/6.2/A-2/AL7836:.5@A/G8<4.-:C/S.>/A-2/B6==-=/9<:7<-=/F<872/<<B/9<:733=/33=/7-/-.5F32/ D-28-42/ 7-/ 5-7.,-=232.-D6:2J/ ,338/ 7-E-/ .5/ -@A2-8/ 3G382/ <G;-=<,-=/ <,/ A-2/ G8<D:-,-=76.7-:.>B-8/2-/B6==-=/[email protected].@-8-=C

?5-3515+"$@A'.-$@A"#)$.1

\-501..8 ].H.)$%&Z&R"$&_;".F%.&(<;<A<'<&A.%&CVG>PP9`

#-7.,-=232.-D6:2 F32-87.-G2- 5/P^Ja^/-=/P^Jad/,/Q!]/M8-5GC/B,8/b0e/-=/b0bN

'8<5.-;32 523D.:.2-.2 1/P\J\d/,/Q!]/M2CAC9C/B,8C/b0eJ0N

'8<5.-5:-64 523D.:.2-.2 1/P\J^d/-=/P\J\1/,/Q!]/M8-5GC/B,8/b0a/-=/b0eN

J'.-"+.&@-"%.-"(

IL7836:.5@A/G8<4.-: D8--72-J/7.-G2- 1/^d1/,/D.>/1/0Je1/,

$3D-:/dP^f '.5-=/F338/7-/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;-=/33=/;-2<-252/F<87-=

V<;-:.>B-/ @<[email protected]/ <G:<55.=;-=/ 5233=/ 9-8,-:7/ .=/ $3D-:/ dP0C/ R=/ D.>:3;-/ +/ F<872/ G-8<G:<55.=;/--=/[email protected]@A-25/;-2<<=7/-=/.=/A-2/B<82/A-2/D-<<;7-/-44-@2C

JF15$$")+ 2()F($$")+ V.$%-"@%".&@<a<&.33.@%"'"%."%

)352-/:33;f 86FA-.7/33=G355-= ;-D86.B2/9<<8/.>B.=;/ME.-/x/aC`N

9-8:-=;-=

9-8:33;7/9-8:-=;-=

9-8A<;-= <=,<;-:.>B/.C9C,C/=362.5@A/G8<4.-:

9-8:3;-= 2-@A=.5@A/E--8/;-@<,G:.@--87

4:36F-8/-.=723:67

;-:-.7-:.>B-/-.=79-85,3::.=;

;-:-.7-:.>B-/-.=79-8D8-7.=;

<9-8;3=;/D.==-=D<@A2/;-:-.7-:.>B F-.=.;/.=9:<-7/M#286.B5,3/-2/3:C/^bbcN

9-8D8-7-=/;-A-:-/:-=;2- F-.=.;/.=9:<-7/M#286.B5,3/-2/3:C/^bbcN

O9-8.;- D<7-,5@A-8,-=

<GG-89:3B2-5@A-8,-=/M78.>9-=7N =362.5@A-/D-:-,,-8.=;-=

8.9.-8/9-85,3::-= E.-/#286.B5,3/-2/3:C/^bbc

9<82-Y/-Y@:67-8

$3D-:/dP0f V<;-:.>B-/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;-=

'-=/<9-8E.@A2/93=/7-/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;-=/.5/;-;-9-=/.=/$3D-:/dP\/-=/.=/D.>:3;-/+C

Page 87: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 7 – 3

JF15$$")+ \-")@"F.$@A.%$&_K".&0"#1(+.&]` L5.1Z-.;.)

]8<2<2LG-9352-/:33;

///////////////

#28<<,8.@A2.=;

e^1/,^111/, ^\c1/,^11/,

P

)-8:-=;7-9352-/:33;

#28<<,8.@A2.=;

e^1/,^111/, ^111/, ^\c1/,^11/,

9-8:-=;.=; S-=-=7-=528<<,5-G8<D:-,-=9-8G:3325-=/E<732/-8;--=/A.=7-8<G28--72C

)-8:-=;7-9-8:33;7-9352-/:33;

#28<<,8.@A2.=;

e^1/,^111/, ^111/, ^\c1/,^11/,

9-8:33;7-/9-8:-=;.=; R7-,/33=/9-8:-=;7-9352-/:33;/,338D-5G38.=;/,32-8.33:-=/-44-@2/93=/-8<5.-9-8,.=7-8-=C

)352-/:33;/,-24:36F-8-.=723:67

#28<<,8.@A2.=;

e^1/,^111/, ^111/, ^\c1/,^11/,

":36F-8/-.=723:67 .7-,/-=/;-:-.7-:.>B-<9-8;3=;/93=/7-86F-8-/9352-/:33;=338/A-2/3::69.3:-7--:C

+-:-.7-:.>B-9-85,3::.=;

#28<<,8.@A2.=;

V-2/;-:-.7-:.>B-/9-85,3::.=;I6.7.;-/5.2632.-

)352-/:33; )352-/:33;

/^01/,

/^`1/,

+-:-.7-:.>B-<9-8;3=;/9<<8/--=A-89-87-:.=;/93=F32-8/-=/5-7.,-=2C

+-:-.7-:.>B-9-8D8-7.=;

#28<<,8.@A2.=;

V-2/;-:-.7-:.>B-/9-8D8-7.=;I6.7.;-/5.2632.-

)352-/:33; )352-/:33;

/^01/,

/^`1/,

I-2/;32/E<73=.;9-8;8<2-=/732/7-E---=/9338;-6:<G:-9-82/,-29<:7<-=7-/D8--72-C

S<7-,5@A-8,-=

#28<<,8.@A2.=;

I6.7.;-/5.2632.-

)352-/:33;

V-2/D<7-,5@A-8,-=

)352-/:33;

I-2/5-7.,-=2/93=/7-D.==-=D<@A2/2-86;=338/7-/D6.2-=D<@A27.8.;-8-=C

)<82-Y'Y@:67-8 #28<<,8.@A2.=;

I6.7.;-/5.2632.-

)352-/:33;

V-2/9<82-Y/-Y@:67-8

)352-/:33;

!

! ������������������������������������������������������������������

&<<85=-7-/!P!

E3=7283=5G<82

I-2/5-7.,-=2/.=/--=q;<<2r/93=;-=/-==338/7-/D6.2-=D<@A2M;32N/7.8.;-8-=C

$3D-:/dP\f ?<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;-=

Page 88: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

7 – 4 WL | Delft Hydraulics

Q3352/7-/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;-=/E.>=/-8/7-/,<;-:.>BA-7-=/<,/7-/G8<D:-,-=/,-2/D3;;-8-=@CpC/ 52<82-=/ 2-/ 9-8A-:G-=C/ R=/ A-2/ B37-8/ 9<<8/ 7-/ D3;;-8P/ -=/ 52<82,<;-:.>BA-7-=/ .5/ A-22.>759-8:<<G/93=/7-/,<84<:<;.5@A-/9-85@A.>=5-:-=/93=/D-:3=;C/O,/--=/9-8;-:.>B/ 2-/ B6==-=,3B-=/2655-=/A-2/-44-@2/93=/D3;;-8-=/-=/7-/@<[email protected]/,3328-;-:-=/.5/--=/33=23:/<G2.-5D-B-B-=J/ 9<<8/ --=/ <9-8E.@A2/ E.-/ $3D-:/ dP`C/ I.-8.=/ .5/ ,-2/ =3,-/ A-2/ 2.>759-8:<<G/ 93=/ 7-,<84<:<;.5@A-/G8<@-55-=/93=/D-:3=;C

2@%". Q5);"%".$ 23'5.-&W8BZ$X

b55+%.&W8&S2\Xc&b5.'..1A.";&W8BX

S3;;-8-= 5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/F-;D3;;-8-= m/g/^a11/,\X5

P0J`c/,/Q!]/-=///^\dC111/,\

#2<82-= -8<5.-;32/7.@A252<82-= m/g/^a11/,\X5

P0J`c/,/Q!]/-=///^c^C111/,\

;--=/[email protected] @<=523=2-/349<-8 m/g/^a11/,\X5

;-5@A-,32.5--87-/349<-8 938.[8-=7/E.-/D.>:3;-/+

$3D-:/dP`f S3;;-8P/-=/52<[email protected]/2-=/<GE.@A2-/93=/7-/2.>7

Q3352/ 7-/,<;-:.>B-/ <G:<55.=;-=/ ;-G8-5-=2--87/ .=/ $3D-:/ dP0/ 52332/ 33=;-9-=/ 732/ --=/ 33=23:<G:<55.=;-=/<G/9<<8A3=7/3493::-=C/&-E-/<G:<55.=;-=/E6::-=/73=/<<B/=.-2/F<87-=/6.2;-F-8B2CR=/ G383;8334/ dC\/ 5233=/ 7-/ D-:3=;8.>B52-/ @<=@:65.-5/ ,-2/ 4.;68-=/ 7.-/ 9<:;-=/ 6.2/ 7-D-8-B-=.=;-=C

&-/,-2/&-:42\&/;-5.,6:--87-/<G:<55.=;-=/E.>=f

-. 9-8:-=;-=s-. 9-8:33;7/9-8:-=;-=s-. 4:36F-8/-.=723:67s-. ;-:-.7-:.>B-/-.=79-85,3::.=;s-. ;-:-.7-:.>B-/-.=79-8D8-7.=;s-. F-;D3;;-8-=/93=/7-/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2s-. 52<82-=/.=/A-2/-8<5.-;32C

R=/ &-:42\&/ .5/ ;--=/ 5.,6:32.-/ ;-733=/ ,-2/ --=/ 9<82-Y/ -Y@:67-8J/ ,338/ -8/ .5/ F-:/ A-2D<7-,9-8:<<G/.=/7-/2.>7/D-B-B-=/9<<8f

-. 2<-G355.=;/9<82-Y/-Y@:67-8C

$-9-=5/E.>=/0/5.2632.-5/;-5.,6:--87/F338D.>/;--=/[email protected]/F<872/<=7-8=<,-=J/=3,-:.>B/ MD-.7-<G;-=<,-=/.=/D.>:3;-/+Nf

-. @<=523=2-/349<-8/MG8<2<2LG-/D-8-B-=.=;Ns-. 938.[8-=7-/349<-8/M;-5@A-,32.5--87/-=/,-2/-2,33:;-,.77-:7-/349<-8NC

Page 89: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 7 – 5

R=/[email protected]/.5/7-/,<;-:.>BA-.7/q(6FA-.7/33=G355-=r/3:/D-B-B-=/.=/G383;8334/aC`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dc/,X5J/E.-/I<,D-8;-=/-2/3:CJ/M^bbcNNC

7.3 Simulatie met Delft3D

R=/7-E-/ G383;8334/ E.>=/ 7-/ D-:3=;8.>B52-/ 6.2B<,52-=/93=/7-/&-:42\&P5.,6:32.-5/ <G;-=<,-=Ci.-/ D.>:3;-/I/9<<8/ --=/D-5@A8.>9.=;/93=/7-/ <G:<55.=;-=/ @Cp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

7.3.1 Verlengen

S.>/A-2/9-8:-=;-=/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/2<2/.=/7-/D<@A2/D.>/OG.>=-=/B<,-=/7-/D-=-7-=528<<,5-,<84<:<;.5@A-/ 9-85@A.>=5-:-=/ <G/ --=/ ;6=52.;-/ :<@32.-/ .=/ 7-/ 8.9.-8/ 2-/ :.;;-=C/ I-2/ -8<5.-;32B<,2/.=/7-/7<<8;33=5/<=7.-G-/D.==-=D<@A2/-=/7-/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/.=/7-/7<<8;33=5/7.-G-8-D6.2-=D<@A2C/I.-87<<8/ E.>=/ 7-/ -.=79-85@A.>=5-:-=/,.=7-8/ 52-8B/ 73=/D.>/ A-2/ G8<2<2LG-J/,338=<;/F-:/33=F-E.;J/E.-/".;668/dP^/-=/".;668/dP0C

".;668/dP^f S<9-=33=E.@A2/93=/7-/9-8:-=;7-/9352-/:33;/MB,8C/b0aJdd/2X,/b\^J^bN

Page 90: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

7 – 6 WL | Delft Hydraulics

".;668/dP0f *3=;5G8<4.-:-=/<G/@.8@3/^e/,-2-8/6.2/7-/=<8,33::.>=

I-2/:.=B-8;-7--:2-/93=/".;668/dP0/.5/76.7-:.>B/E.@A2D338/732/7<<8/A-2/9-8:-=;-=/93=/7-/9352-:33;/A-2/G8<D:--,/F<872/<G;-5@A<9-=J/,338/<<B/F<872/;-8-76@--87C/R=/A-2/8-@A2-8/;-7--:2-.5/--=/[email protected].=;/93=/7-/D6:2/E.@A2D338/-=/--=/9-8,.=7-8.=;/93=/7-/A<<;2-J/F3387<<8/7-E-2-8/A<<;2-/93=/7-/D6:2/<G/^e/,/6.2/ 7-/ 8-@A2-8P=<8,33::.>=/ <=7-8/ 7-/ 9352;-52-:7-/ -.5/ D:.>42C)<<8/A-2/E-:47-/ :3=;5G8<4.-:/B3=/F<87-=/<G;-,-8B2/732/--=/9-8:-=;.=;/=36F-:.>B5/ .=9:<-7A--42/<G/7-/A<<;2-/93=/7-/D.==-=D<@A2/93=/#.=2/!=78.-5C

&-/ 9-83=7-8.=;/ 7.-/ .=/ 7-/ D<@A2/ D.>/OG.>=-=/ <G28--72J/ .5/ E.@A2D338/ .=/ ".;668/ dP\J/ F32/ --=7F3857<<85=-7-/ .5/<G/<=;-9--8/`11/,-2-8/D-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/A-2/-.=7/93=/7-/9-8:-=;7-9352-/:33;C/I.-8.=/.5/7-/9-83=7-8.=;/93=/7-/D<7-,A-::.=;/76.7-:.>B/2-/E.-=C/&-/D<7-,/.5/D.>A-2/G8<2<2LG-/2-8/A<<;2-/93=/7-/:.=B-8P=<8,33::.>=J/F32/7-/D.==-=D<@A2/.5J/M-9-=--=5/:.=B5/.=".;668/dP\N/A<;-8/73=/A-2/;-F-=52-/=.9-36/93=/P0Je1,/MS()011^NC/S.>/--=/9-8:-=;.=;/93=7-/9352-/ :33;/2<2/ .=/7-/D<@A2/D.>/OG.>=-=/28--72/A.-8/ >6.52/A-2/ :33;52-/G6=2/<GJ/ 2-8F.>:/ .=/7-D6.2-=D<@A2J/2-8/G:3325-/93=/7-/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2J/--=/B:-.=-8-/F32-87.-G2-/<=252332C/&-/7.-G2-.=/ 7-/ D6.2-=D<@A2/ .5/ -@A2-8/ =<;/F-:/ 52--75/ ;8<2-8/ 73=/ 7-/ ;-F-=52-/ 7.-G2-/ 93=/ 0Je1/,-2-8<=7-8/A-2/8-4-8-=2.-9:3BC

".;668/dP\f &F385G8<4.-:/2-8/A<<;2-/93=/B,8C/b0bJbc/M.=/7-/D<@A2/93=/OG.>=-=N

Page 91: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 7 – 7

R=/".;668/dP`/E.>=/93=/E<F-:/A-2/G8<2<2LG-/3:5/7-/9-8:-=;7-/9352-/:33;/--=/7F385G8<4.-:/93=7-/D<7-,/;-;-9-=/<G/--=/34523=7/93=/@.8@3/c11,/D-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/A-2/-.=7/93=/7-/9352-:33;C/I-2/A.-8.=/;-2-B-=7-/S()011^/.5/A.-8/5:-@A25/2-8/[email protected]/33=;-E.-=/2655-=/D-.7-G6=2-=/--=/9-85@A.:/93=/1J^,/E.2C/%.2/".;668/dP`/D:.>B2/732/,-2/=3,-/7-/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/--=526B/,.=7-8/A<<;/.5C/&.2/F<872/7<<8/7-/5G.833:528<<,/9-8<<8E33B2/7.-/>6.52/A-2/5-7.,-=2/93=7-/D6.2-=D<@A2/8.@A2.=;/7-/D.==-=D<@A2/526682C

".;668/dP`f &F385G8<4.-:/<G/@.8@3/c11/,/D-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/7-/9352-/:33;

7.3.2 Verlaagd verlengen

I-2/9-8:33;7/9-8:-=;-=/.5/<G/7-E-:47-/[email protected]/3:5/A-2/9-8:-=;-=/;-D35--87/ME.-/G383;8334dC\C^NJ/,338/7<<8/7-/B:-.=-8-/@<[email protected]/--=/D-5G38.=;/93=/,32-8.33:s/,--8/A.-8<9-8/.=A<<47526B/eC/".;668/dPc/;--42/--=/<9-8E.@A2/93=/7-/D<7-,A<<;2-C

Page 92: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

7 – 8 WL | Delft Hydraulics

".;668/dPcf S<9-=33=E.@A2/9-8:33;7-/9-8:-=;7-/9352-/:33;/MB,8C/b0aJdd/2X,/b\^J^bN

i<3:5/D:.>B2/6.2/".;668/dPa/F<872/7-/7F385A-::.=;/93=/7-/D<7-,/.=/7-/D<@A2/D.>/OG.>=-=/4:.=B;-8-76@--87/ -=/ 9-82<<=2/ --=/ ,.=7-8/ 52-.:/ 9-8:<<G/ -=/ E-:45/ --=/ B3=2-:.=;/ 93=/ A-2/ G8<4.-:C$-9-=5/9<:7<-2/7-/D.==-=D<@A2/93=/OG.>=-=/,-2/ D-A6:G/ 93=/7-E-/ @<[email protected]/ <G:<55.=;33=/7-/;-F-=52-/7.-G2-/93=/0Je1,/<=7-8/A-2/8-4-8-=2.-9:3BJ/2-8F.>:/732/D.>/A-2/G8<2<2LG-/=.-2A-2/;-93:/.5C

".;668/dPaf &F385G8<4.-:/2-8/A<<;2-/93=/B,8C/b0bJe`/M.=/7-/D<@A2/93=/OG.>=-=N

Page 93: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 7 – 9

R=/ ".;668/ dPd/ E.>=/ 9<<8/ E<F-:/ A-2/ G8<2<2LG-/ 3:5/ 7-/ 9-8:33;7-/ 9-8:-=;7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ 7-,<84<:<;.5@A-/-.=79-85@A.>=5-:-=/<G/--=/34523=7/93=/<=;-9--8/c11,/F--8;-;-9-=C/H338D.>7-/7.-G2-/93=/A-2/;32/76.7-:.>B/.5/;-8-76@--87C

".;668/dPdf &F385G8<4.-:/2-8/A<<;2-/93=/B,8C/b0eJc/MD-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/7-/9352-/:33;N

&-/[email protected]/93=/7-/7.-G2-/93=/A-2/;32/.5/76.7-:.>B/E.@A2D338/.=/--=/:3=;5G8<4.-:J/;-=<,-=/<G--=/34523=7/93=/\c/,/6.2/7-/:.=B-8P=<8,33::.>=C/I.-86.2/D:.>B2/<=7-8/3=7-8-/<<B/732/A.-8,--.=/7-/D.==-=D<@A2/93=/OG.>=-=/ M2655-=/7-/ 0c11,/-=/\111,N/,-2/ 7-/ 9-8:33;7-/9-8:-=;7-9352-/:33;/F<872/9<:733=/33=/7-/7.-G2-/93=/,.=.,33:/0Je1,/<=7-8/A-2/8-4-8-=2.-9:3BC

".;668/dPef *3=;5G8<4.-:/<G/\c/,/6.2/:.=B-8P=<8,33::.>=/93=34/B,8C/b0dJ\/2X,/b\^Jb

Page 94: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

7 – 1 0 WL | Delft Hydraulics

".;668/dPb/:332/<9-8/--=E-:47-/34523=7/--=/:3=;5G8<4.-:/E.-=J/-@A2-8/<G/--=/34523=7/93=/b1,93=6.2/ 7-/ 8-@A2-8P=<8,33::.>=C/ I-2/ 9-8:<<G/ 93=/ A-2/ :3=;5G8<4.-:/ .5/ 7<<8/ 7-/ 9-8:33;7-9-8:-=;.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ F32/ ;-:.>B,32.;-8/ ;-F<87-=/ -=/ 9<:7<-2/ 7338,--/ 33=/ 7-,.=.,3:-/7.-G2-/93=/0Je1,/<=7-8/A-2/8-4-8-=2.-9:3BC

".;668/dPbf *3=;5G8<4.-:/<G/b1/,/6.2/8-@A2-8P=<8,33::.>=/93=34/B,8C/b0dJ\/2X,/b\^Jb

7.3.3 Flauwer eindtalud

&-/ <G:<55.=;/ ,-2/ --=/ 4:36F-8/ 23:67/ .5/ --=/ 5<<82/ @<,D.=32.-/ 93=/ --=/ 9-8:-=;.=;/ -=/ --=9-8:3;.=;J/,338/--=/;-:-.7-:.>B-/<9-8;3=;/7.-=2/-9-=--=5/9<<8/<,/7-/<9-8;3=;/2655-=/9352-:33;/ -=/ 3::69.3:-/ D<7-,/ ;-:-.7-:.>B-8/ 2-/ B6==-=/ :32-=/ 9-8:<G-=C/ &32/ :33252-/ .5/ 7-;-5.,6:--87-/,3329<-8.=;/2-=/7-:-/;-:6B2/<,732/33=/A-2/-.=7/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/=<;/52--75--=/-8<5.-;32/<=252332J/E.-/".;668/dP^1/-=/dP^^C

Page 95: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 7 – 1 1

".;668/dP^1f S<9-=33=E.@A2/9352-/:33;/,-2/4:36F-8/-.=723:67/B,8C/b0aJdd/2X,/b\^J^b

".;668/dP^^f *3=;5G8<4.-:/<G/\c/,/6.2/:.=B-8P=<8,33::.>=/93=34/B,8C/b0dJ\/2X,/b\^Jb

Page 96: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

7 – 1 2 WL | Delft Hydraulics

I-2/ :3=;5G8<4.-:/ <G/ --=/ 34523=7/ 93=/ b1/ ,/ 6.2/ 7-/ 8-@A2-8P=<8,33::.>=/ :332/ E.-=/ 732/ 7-5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/ 34=--,2/,-2/ 86.,/--=/,-2-8/ ME.-/ ".;668/ dP^0NC/&338-=2-;-=/F<872/ .=/ 7-D6.2-=D<@A2/D.>/OG.>=-=/ M2655-=/00c1/ -=/\dc1/,-2-8N/,--8/ 5-7.,-=2/ 34;-E-2/ -=/ =--,2/ 7-F32-87.-G2-/34J/-@A2-8/=<;/86.,5@A<<25/M1Jdc,N/<=7-8/A-2/,3Y.,3:-/D<7-,=.9-36C

".;668/dP^0f *3=;5G8<4.-:/<G/b1/,/6.2/8-@A2-8P=<8,33::.>=/93=34/B,8C/b0dJ\/2X,/b\^Jb

7.3.4 Geleidelijke eindversmalling

'-=/;-:-.7-:.>B-/9-85,3::.=;/33=/A-2/-.=7/,<-2/-89<<8/E<8;-=/732/A-2/5-7.,-=2/732/E.@A/33=7-/8-@A2-8<-9-8/D-9.=72/7-/,<;-:.>BA-.7/A--42/<,/E.@A/F--8/2-/B6==-=/A-852-::-=C/R=/".;668dP^\/.5/E.@A2D338/732/7.2/5:-@A25/.=/E--8/;-8.=;-/,32-/<G28--72C/I.-8D.>/.5/E-B-8/=<;/7.5@623D-:<9-8/ F32/ 9<<8/ --=/ 34523=7/ 7-E-/ 9-85,3::.=;/ ,<-2/ G:3325/ 9.=7-=s/ 7-/ A6.7.;-/ @<=4.;6832.-:-9-82/;--=/D-76.7-=7-/9-8D-2-8.=;/<GC/&-/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/.5/=3;-=<-;/;-:.>B/;-D:-9-=/p63A<<;2-/-=/.5/<=;-9--8/^11/,/528<<,<GF33825/B<,-=/2-/:.;;-=C/&-/7.-G2-/.=/A-2/-8<5.-;32/.59-85:-@A2-87J/732/F.:/ E-;;-=/1J`c/,/7.-G-8/;-F<87-=C/&.2/ .5/ --=/9-8;8<2.=;/93=/@.8@3/ ahCI-2/;32/.5/-@A2-8/F-:/34;-=<,-=/p63/<GG-89:3B/732/D-=-7-=/7-/46=7-8.=;/93=/7-/9352-/:33;:.;2C

Page 97: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 7 – 1 3

".;668/dP^\f S<9-=33=E.@A2/;-:-.7-:.>B-/-.=79-85,3::.=;/MB,8C/b0dJ\/2X,/b0bJ`0N

7.3.5 Geleidelijke eindverbreding

&-/;-:-.7-:.>B-/-.=79-8D8-7.=;/A--42/2<2/7<-:/A-2/5-7.,-=2/=<;/,--8/=338/7-/8-@A2-8<-9-8/2-;-:-.7-=J/E<73=.;/732/7-/D6:2/A<;-8/F<872/,338/F-:/5,3::-8/-=/E<7<-=7-/7-/D8--72-/93=/7-9338;-6:/ 93=/ ^d1/ ,-2-8/ F-:/ F<872/ ;-A33:7C/ I.-8D.>/ E<6/ A-2/ ;32/ ;8<2-8/ F<87-=C/ %.2/ 7-D-8-B-=.=;-=/D:.>B2/7.2/-@A2-8/=.-2/<G/2-/;33=/ME.-/".;668/dP^`NC/I-2/;32/F<872/D<9-=528<<,5.-25/D8-7-8/M-=B-:-/,-2-85NJ/,338/D:.>42/<=;-9--8/<G/;-:.>B-/7.-G2-C/&-/D6:2/F<872/.=7-87337A<;-8/ [email protected]@3/ 1Jc,J/ E.-/ ".;668/ dP^cN/ -=/ ;-7--:2-:.>B/ 52-.:-8/,338/ 7-/ ;-F-=52-/ D8--72-/,-2D.>D-A<8-=7-/ 7.-G2-/ F<872/ =.-2/ ;-A33:7/ -=/ E-:45/ =.-2/ 9-8D-2-87/ M<4/ 9-85:-@A2-87NC/ I.-8D.>;-:72J/ =-2/ 3:5/ D.>/ 7-/ ;-:-.7-:.>B-/ 9-85,3::.=;J/ 732/ 7-/ ;-B<E-=/ 34523=7/ F338<9-8/ 7-E-9-83=7-8.=;/ G:3325/ 9.=72J/ 7.5@623D-:/ .5C/ )<<83:5=<;/ :.>B2/ 7-E-/ <G:<55.=;/ =.-2/ ;[email protected]/ R=".;668/ dP^c/ .5/ F-:/ E.@A2D338/ 732/ 7-/ 5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/ 5,3::-8/ F<872C/ &-/ 34=3,-/ 93=/ 7-D8--72-/ 93=/ 7-/ 5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/ 28--72/ -@A2-8/ 3::--=/ <G/ D-=-7-=/ 7-/ P0Je1,/ S()011^/ -=:-9-82/E<7<-=7-/;--=/-Y283/D8--72-/<GC

Page 98: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

7 – 1 4 WL | Delft Hydraulics

".;668/dP^`f S<9-=33=E.@A2/;-:-.7-:.>B-/-.=79-8D8-7.=;/MB,8C/b0dJ\/2X,/b0bJ`0N

".;668/dP^cf &F385G8<4.-:/2-8/A<<;2-/93=/B,8C/b0eJc

Page 99: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 7 – 1 5

7.3.6 Wegbaggeren van de sedimentatiebult

I-2/F-;D3;;-8-=/93=/7-/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/9<<8B<,2/=.-2/A-2/G8<D:--,/-=/.5/7-8A3:9-/;--=@<[email protected]/ <G:<55.=;J/ ,338/ 7.-=2/ 2-8/ 9-8;-:.>B.=;C/ &-/ 7.-G2-/ 2<2/ F338<G/ 7-5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/.5/F-;;-A33:7/.5/;-:.>B/33=/7-/A<<;2-/93=/7-/D<9-=B3=2/93=/7-/9352-/:33;CV-2/7-E-/7.-G2-/F<872/--=/<9-87.-G2-/93=/@.8@3/1Jec/,/;-@8-[-87C/&-E-/-Y283/7.-G2-/7.-=2-89<<8/ 732/ -8/ 2655-=/ 7-/ D3;;[email protected]/ --=/ E</ ;8<<2/ ,<;-:.>B/ G-8.<7-/ E.2C/ I.-8D.>/ .5/ --=D3;;-8@[email protected]/ 93=/ @.8@3/ ^\dC111/,\/ =<7.;/ MF33893=/ @.8@3/ ^11C111,\/ <=7-8/ 7-/ P0Je1,S()011^NC/V-2/D.>9<<8D--:7/--=/;-,.77-:7-/D3;;-8@[email protected]/93=/`11/,\X668J/.5/7338/@.8@3\`1/ 668/ D3;;-82.>7/ 9<<8/ =<7.;C/ %.2/ ".;668/ dP^a/ D:.>B2/ 732/ A-2/ A-852-:/ 93=/ A-25-7.,-=232.-G8<@-5/7-/D6:2/D.==-=/-=B-:-/,33=7-=/F--8/ 2<2/<G/--=/ 2-/;8<2-/A<<;2-/ MA<;-873=/ 7-/ ;8-=5/ 93=/ 0Je1/ ,/ <=7-8/ A-2/ 8-4-8-=2.-9:3BN/ A--42/ ;-D83@A2C/ &-E-/ D-8-B-=.=;/ .5;-D35--87/<G/--=/@<=523=2-/349<-8/93=/^a11/,\X5C/S.>/D.>9<<8D--:7/--=/:3;-8-/349<-8/E3:/[email protected]/93=/7-/7.-G2-/,.=7-8/ 5=-:/9-8:<G-=C/&-5<=73=B5/ .5/A-2/A-852-:/ 5=-::-8/ 73=/ .=/ --==<8,3:-/ D<@A2/ [email protected]@3/ ^`/ ,\X73;XB,J/ E.-/ )3=/ 7-=/ S833B/ -=/ $-8,-5J/ 011^NC/ Q3/ @.8@3/ `,33=7-=/.5/7-/D<7-,/<G/7-/,3Y.,3:-/A<<;2-J/.=/7.-/G-8.<7-/.5/765/--=/A-852-:/93=/^11C111,\/<G;-28-7-=C

".;668/dP^af )-8:<<G/93=/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/.=/7-/2.>7/2CAC9C/B,8C/b0eJc/=3/D3;;[email protected]

I-2/F-;D3;;-8-=/93=/7-/D6:2/A--42/<G/7-/7.-G2-/93=/A-2/;32/F-.=.;/.=9:<-7J/=3,-:.>Bf/1J^1/,5-7.,-=232.-/ <G/ --=/7.-G2-/ 93=/ @.8@3/ aJ\1/,/ M// 0hNC/&-E-/1J^1/,-2-8/ .5/ =3/ ^/ >338/ -@A2-83:F--8/D.>=3/;-8-76@--87/2<2/<G/7-/<<85G8<=B-:.>B-/7.-G2-C/&-/9-8<=7.-G.=;/93=/A-2/;32/7<<8A-2/D3;;-8-=/93=/7-/D6:2/<=252332J/7<<8732/-8/,.=7-8/F32-8/7<<8/A-2/-8<5.-;32/528<<,2C/I-2G8<4.-:/ 2-8/ A<<;2-/ 93=/ 7-/ 5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/ .5/ 7<<8/ 7-/ D3;;[email protected]/ 9-8;8<<2/ -=/ E<7<-=7-528<<,2/ ,--8/ F32-8/ <9-8/ 7-/ q5-7.,-=232.-D6:2rJ/ 2<2732/ 7-/ D6:2/ F--8/ ;8<-.2/ -=/ 7-/ 7.-G2-9-89<:;-=5/.=/A-2/-8<5.-;32/F--8/2<-=--,2C

Page 100: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

7 – 1 6 WL | Delft Hydraulics

7.3.7 Storten in het erosiegat

I-2/52<82-=/.=/A-2/-8<5.-;32/ .5/D-B-B-=/<,/7-/7338D.>/A<8-=7-/2.>75@A33:/ 2-/D-G3:-=/F338.=A-2/;32/<=252332C/ R=/A<<47526B/a/D:--B/3:/732/A-2/;32/=3/7-/33=:-;/93=/A-2/G8<2<2LG-/ .=/ A-2D-;.=/ 5=-:/<=2F.BB-:2/ -=/7338=3/ :3=;E33,/=338/ E.>=/ [email protected]/ ;332C/ R=/ 7.2/ ;-93:/ .5D-B-B-=/A<-/A-2/;32/E.@A/<=2F.BB-:2/3:5/A-2/-8<5.-;32/.=/A-2/G8<2<2LG-/F<872/7.@A2;-52<82/=3/0>338C/%.2/".;668/dP^d/D:.>B2/732/7.2/=-2/3:5/D.>/A-2/<=2F.BB-:-=/93=/7-/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/D.==-=-=B-:-/ ,33=7-=/ ;-D-682C/ R=/ 2-;-=52-::.=;/ 2<2/ A-2/ G8<@-5/ D.>/ 7-/ 5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/ 76682/ 7-<=2F.BB-:.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ [email protected]/ =3D.>/ 7-/ =<8,33::.>=/ :3=;-8/ 73=/ D.>/ 9-87-8/ F-;;-:-;-=/G6=2-=C

".;668/dP^df )-8:<<G/93=/A-2/-8<5.-;32/.=/7-/2.>7/2CAC9C/B,8C/b0eJ0e/=3/52<[email protected]

S.>/A-2/52<82-=/93=/A-2/;32/28--72/-@A2-8/<<B/=<;/A-2/9-85@A.>=5-:/<G/732/7-/5-7.,-=232.-D6:234=--,2C/&<<8/A-2/52<82-=/.=/A-2/-8<5.-;32/F<872/A-2/G8<4.-:/9-8B:-.=7/-=/7-/528<<,5=-:A-.79-8A<<;7J/F3387<<8/-8<5.-/<G28--72/93=/7-/D6:2C/'@A2-8/A-2/-8<5.-;32/A-852-:2/E.@A/.=/-=B-:-,33=7-=/F338=3/7-/ 5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/F--8/;8<-.2J/ E.-/".;668/dP^eC/I-2/9-85@A.>=5-:/732/7-5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/ =.-2/ 2<2/ 7-/ <<85G8<=B-:.>B-/ A<<;2-/ 33=;8<-.2/ B<,2/ 7<<8/ A-2/ 4-.2/ 732/ 7-D3;;[email protected]/.5/2<-;-G352/0/>338/=3/7-/33=:-;/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/-=/7-/D<7-,/7338D.>/=<;/=.-2;-A--:/.=/-9-=F.@A2/F35C

S.>/A-2/7.@A252<82-=/93=/A-2/-8<5.-;32/ :.;2/ --=/D3;;[email protected]/93=/7-/ 5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/9<<8/7-A3=7C/ O,/ --=/ E</ 76.7-:.>B/ ,<;-:.>B/ D--:7/ 2-/ B8.>;-=/ 93=/ 7-/ .=;8-G-=/ E.>=/ 7-E-/ 3G382D-B-B-=C/'-=/<=7-8E<-B/=338/--=/@<,D.=32.-/93=/,3328-;-:-=/F<872/73=/<<B/33=D-9<:-=J7.2/;-:72/E<F-:/9<<8/D3;;-8-=/-=/52<82-=/3:5/9<<8/7-/@<[email protected]/,3328-;-:-=C

Page 101: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 7 – 1 7

".;668/dP^ef )-8:<<G/93=/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/.=/7-/2.>7/2CAC9C/B,8C/b0eJc/=3/52<[email protected]

I-2/ 52<82-=/ .=/ A-2/ -8<5.-;32/ A--42J/ E<3:5/ 3:/ 6.2/ --87-8/ <=7-8E<-B/ D:--B/ ME.-/ '-87-=/ 011^NJ;-9<:;-=/ 9<<8/ 7-/ D.==-=D<@A2/ D.>/ OG.>=-=C/ %.2/ ".;668/ dP^b/ M2CAC9C/ B,8C/ b\1JcN/ D:.>B2/ 7.2.=7-87337J/-@A2-8/E.>=/7-/;-9<:;-=/,338/=-2/B8.2.-BC

".;668/dP^bf S.==-=D<@A2/OG.>=-=/b1,/6.2/:.=B-8P=<8,33::.>=J/=3/52<[email protected]

Page 102: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

7 – 1 8 WL | Delft Hydraulics

7.3.8 Bodemverloop ten behoeve van vortex excluder

)<<8/A-2/2<-G355-=/93=/--=/9<82-Y/-Y@:67-8/.5/7-/A<<;2-:.;;.=;/93=/D-:3=;/-=/7-/938.32.-/.=A-2/ D<7-,9-8:<<G/ .=/ 7-/ 2.>7C/ R=/ ".;668/ dP01/ .5/ A-2/ D<7-,9-8:<<G/ F--8;-;-9-=/ D.>/ --=938.[8-=7-/349<-8/M-2,33:;-,.77-:7NC/'-=/9<82-Y/-Y@:67-8/.5/--=/9352-/@<[email protected]/7.-/.=/--=D<7-,/F<872/ 33=;-:-;7/,-2/ --=/ 938.[8-=7-/ A<<;2-/ .=/ A-2/ ;-93:/ D.>/ #.=2/ !=78.-5C/ !:5/ 7-D<7-,/A<;-8/F<872/73=/7-/D<9-=B3=2/93=/7-/9<82-Y/-Y@:67-8/E3:/7-E-/7.@A2/B6==-=/5:.DD-=-=/ 73387<<8/ 2.>7-:.>B/ =.-2/ ,--8/ 46=@2.<=-8-=C/ &-/ A<;-8-/ D<7-,A<<;2-/ 28--72/ <G/ D.>/ A<;-349<-8-=/ -=/ E3:/ 73=/,.=7-8/ 5=-:/ G8<D:-,-=/ ;-9-=/ 9<<8/ 7-/ 7.-G;3=;/ 93=/ 7-/ 5@A--G93382CS-:3=;8.>B/7338D.>/.5/F-:/732/3:5/A-2/F32-8/F--8/733:2/7-/9<82-Y/-Y@:67-8/E.>=/F-8B.=;/A-8932C

������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

����������������

������������������������������������������������

����������������������������������������

����

������������������������������������������������

����������������

����������������������������������������������������������������

������������������������������������������������

����������������

����������������������������������������������������������������

��������������������������������

�������������������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������������������������������������

�����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

�����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

������������������������

���������������������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

�������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

�������������������������������������������������������������������

���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

�������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

����������

�������������������������������������������������������

Bodem verloop naast eind vaste laag

-2.5

-2

-1.5

-1

-0.5

0

jan-99 apr-99 jul-99 okt-99 feb-00 mei-00 aug-00 dec-00 mrt-01 jun-01 sep-01 jan-02

Tijd [dd-mmm-jj]

Bod

emho

ogte

[m

NA

P]

������������kmr.928,1 op 90muit rechter-normaallijn

kmr.928,1 op 35muit rechter-normaallijn

".;668/dP01f S<7-,9-8:<<G/A-2/3::69.3:-/;-7--:2-/=3352/7-/9352-/:33;/2CAC9C/B,8C/b0eJ^

R=/".;668/dP01/E.>=/7-/\/A<<;F32-8G.-B-=/2-86;/2-/9.=7-=/.=/7-/A<<;2-:.;;.=;/93=/7-/D<7-,CQ3352/ A-2/ 9-8:<<G/ .=/ A-2/ D-;.=/ -=/ 7-/ 3:;-,--=/ 73:-=7-/ 28-=7/ 93=/ 7-/ D<7-,/ ME.-/ ,--8A.-8<9-8/.=/D.>:3;-/+N/.5/--=/938.32.-/93=/<=;-9--8/1Jd1/,/F338/2-/=-,-=/<G/A-2/G6=2/\c/,6.2/7-/8-@A2-8P=<8,33::.>=C/OG/b1/,-2-8/6.2/7-/8-@A2-8P=<8,33::.>=/.5/7.2/=<;/E<o=/1J`1/,C

)<<8/7-/B-65/93=/7-/33=:-;/93=/--=/9<82-Y/-Y@:67-8/.5/D-:3=;8.>B/732/7-E-/=3/A<<;F32-8/-=765/--=/A<<;/D<7-,=.9-36J/F--8/<G-=/B<,2/ 2-/ :.;;-=/-=/7-/F-8B.=;/A-8932C/I.-89<<8/E3:--=/=37-8/<=7-8E<-B/=<7.;/E.>=s/E.-/A-2/A<<47526B/?<=@:65.-5/-=/33=D-9-:.=;-=C/&.2/=37-8<=7-8E<-B/E<6/D.>9<<8D--:7/B6==-=/D-5233=/6.2/<=7-8/3=7-8-/5@A33:,<7-::-=/<=7-8E<-BC/&-938.32.-/.=/D<7-,A<<;2-/93=/@.8@3/1Jd1/,/.5/7-/;-,.77-:7-/D<7-,:.;;.=;J/7-/D<9-=B3=2/93=7-/9<82-Y/-Y@:67-8/E3:/A.-8/D<9-=/6.2/,<-2-=/52-B-=C/R=/.-7-8/;-93:/;-768-=7-/A-2/,-8-=7--:93=/A-2/>338C

Page 103: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 7 – 1 9

7.4 Discussie

I-2/9<:;-=7-/G6=2/F<872/=<;/<G;-,-8B2f

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

Page 104: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

7 – 2 0 WL | Delft Hydraulics

Page 105: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 8 – 1

8 Vergelijking van de mogelijke verbeteringen

8.1 Inleiding

R=/A<<47526B/d/.5/93=/--=/33=23:/,<;-:.>B-/<G:<55.=;-=/3:/--=/5-:[email protected]/;-,33B2/F-:B-/F-:/-==.-2/E.>=/D-8-B-=7/,-2/D-A6:G/93=/&-:42\&C/ R=/7.2/A<<47526B/F<872/--=/34F-;.=;/;-,33B22655-=/ 7-/ 2-@A=.5@A-/ -=/ -@<=<,.5@A-/ B-=,-8B-=/ 93=/ 7-/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ <G:<55.=;-=C/ $-=--852-/ F<87-=/ .=/ G383;8334/ eC0/ 7-/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ D-8-B-=7-/ @<[email protected]/ <G/ 2-@A=.5@A-35G-@2-=/D-5@A<6F7C/&338D.>/ .5/ --=/34F-;.=;/;-,33B2/=338/,<;-:.>B-/ 2<-G35D338A-.7/,-2A-2/D-A33:7-/-44-@2/-=/--=/9-8;-:.>B.=;/33=/7-/;-52-:7-/-.5-=C/&-/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;-=7.-/ 73386.2/ 9<:;-=/F<87-=/ .=/ G383;8334/ eC\/ <G/ -@<=<,.5@A-/ 35G-@2-=/ 9-8;-:-B-=C/ $-9-=5F<872/.=/G383;8334/eC\/7-/<G:<55.=;/,-2/D-A6:G/93=/D3;;-8-=/D-5@A8-9-=C

8.2 Technische afwegingen

&-/.=/A<<47526B/d/D-B-B-=/,<;-:.>B-/<G:<55.=;-=/E.>=f-. 9-8:-=;-=s-. 9-8:33;7/9-8:-=;-=s-. 4:36F-8/-.=723:67s-. ;-:-.7-:.>B-/-.=79-85,3::.=;s-. ;-:-.7-:.>B-/-.=79-8D8-7.=;s-. F-;D3;;-8-=/93=/7-/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2s-. 52<82-=/.=/A-2/-8<5.-;32C

$-9-=5/.5/;-B-B-=/=338/A-2/D<7-,9-8:<<G/33=/A-2/-.=7-/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/9<<8/7-/2<-G355.=;93=/ --=/ 9<82-Y/ -Y@:67-8J/ A.-8/ E.>=/ -@A2-8/ ;--=/ D-8-B-=.=;-=/ ,--/ 6.2;-9<-87/ -=/ F<8727-8A3:9-/ =.-2/ .=/ D-5@A<6F.=;/ ;-=<,-=/ .=/ 7.2/ A<<47526BC/ &.2/ ;-:72/ <<B/ 9<<8/ 7-D<7-,5@A-8,-=/33=/A-2/-.=7/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/.=/7-/D.==-=D<@A2C

&-/ <G:<55.=;-=/ ,<-2-=/ 9<:7<-=/ 33=/ 7-/ .=/ $3D-:/ dP^/ ;-52-:7-/ F3387-C/ )<<8/ 7-<9-8E.@A2-:.>BA-.7/F<872/$3D-:/dP^/A.-8/.=/--=/.-25/;-F.>E.;7-/9<8,/3:5/$3D-:/eP^/A-8A33:7C

?5-3515+"$@A'.-$@A"#)$.1

\-501..8 ].H.)$%&Z&R"$&_;".F%.&(<;<A<'<&A.%&CVG>PP9`

^ #-7.,-=232.-D6:2 F32-87.-G2- 5/P^Ja^/-=/P^Jad/,/Q!]/M8-5GC/B,8/b0e/-=/b0bN

0 '8<5.-;32 523D.:.2-.2 1/P\J\d/,/Q!]/M2CAC9C/B,8C/b0eJ0N

\ '8<5.-5:-64 523D.:.2-.2 1/P\J^d/-=/P\J\1/,/Q!]/M8-5GC/B,8/b0a/-=/b0eN

O9-8.;-/@8.2-8.3

` IL7836:.5@A/G8<4.-: D8--72-J/7.-G2- 1/^d1/,/D.>/1/0Je1/,

$3D-:/eP^f '.5-=/F338/7-/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;-=/33=/;-2<-252/F<87-=

Page 106: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

8 – 2 WL | Delft Hydraulics

&-/-.5-=/F33833=/7-/<G:<55.=;/,<-2/9<:7<-=/5233=/;-;-9-=/.=/$3D-:/eP^J/F338D.>/7-/--852--=/:33252-/-.5/7-/A<<;52-/G8.<8.2-.2/A-DD-=C/&-/<9-8.;-/2F--J/=6,,-8/0/-=/\J/E.>=/93=/,.=7-8A<;-/G8.<8.2-.2C/&-/9-8,-:7-=/7.-G2-/ E.>=/ 7-/ 7.-G2-/ D-8-B-=7/,-2/ --=/ @<=523=2-/ 349<-8/ -=E6::-=/D.>/--=/938.[8-=7-/M-=/765/<<B/A<;-8-N/349<-8/7.-G-8/B6==-=/E.>=J/E.-/".;668/"Pc/M.=7-/ D.>:3;-NC/ R=/ $3D-:/ eP0/ E.>=/ 7-/ ,<;-:.>B-/ <G:<55.=;-=/ 9-8;-:-B-=/ ,-2/ 7-/ -.5-=C/ &-;-5.,6:--87-/ <G:<55.=;-=/ 9<:7<-=/ .=/ ;--=/ 93=/ 7-/ ;-93::-=/ 33=/ 7-/ 523D.:.2-.25P-.5J/ 2-=;-9<:;-/93=/7-/-8<5.-5:-64C/&<<8/--=/3=7-8-/ 86FA-.7/93=/7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ 2<-/ 2-/ G355-=/B3=7-E-/ 7.-G2-/ F<87-=/ 9-8B:-.=7J/ E.-/ A<<47526B/ `J/ !=3:L2.5@A-/ D-8-B-=.=;-=C/ '-=/ D:.>9-=7-9-83=7-8.=;/93=/7-/86FA-.7/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/.5/-@A2-8/--=/;-@<,G:.@--87-/<G:<55.=;J/<,7324.>=/,32-8.33:/7<<8/7-/528<,.=;/-8<7--82C/'-=/,<;-:.>B-/3=7-8-/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;/E<6B6==-=/ E.>=/ A-2/ 2<-G355-=/ 93=/ 528-B73,,-=/ E<732/ 7-/ .=9:<-7/ 93=/ B8.D9:3,,-=/ :<B33:9-87F.>=2C/ $-9-=5/ <=252332/ 7<<8/ 528-B73,,-=/ --=/ ;-:-.7-:.>B-/ -=/ ,.=7-8/ 268D6:-=2-528<,.=;C/&-/.=/$3D-:/eP0/9-8,-:7-/F3387-/2655-=/A33B>-5/.5/7-/D8--72-/93=/A-2/G8<4.-:/D.>0Je1/,/7.-G/9<<8/7-/D<@A2/D.>/OG.>=-=C

R"$

JF15$$")+

9& 0,1%H(%.-;".F%.

5555&Y9cIM&8&S2\

[email protected]`

>& .-5$".+(%$%(0"1"%."%

1111&YBcBM&8&S2\

[email protected]`

B& .-5$".$1.,3$%(0"1"%."%

1111&YBcBP&8&S2\

D& F-53".10-..;%.c&;".F%.

1111&9MP&0"#&1111&>cNP8

_D8--72-/OG.>=-=`

]8<2<2LG-/XA6.7.;-/9352-/:33;

P1Je1 P/dJ^1 P/\J\1/M;-,CN

P/cJ^1/M,3YCN

^c1,/M01c/,N

)-8:-=;-= P0J^1 P/cJb1 .7-, 0a1,/M0a1/,N

9-8:33;79-8:-=;-=

P^Je1 P/`Jcc .7-, 0a1,/M0a1/,N

4:36F-8/-.=723:67 P0J11 PcJ1c .7-, 0a1,/M0a1/,N

;-:-.7-:.>B--.=79-85,3::.=;

P1Jec P/dJcc .7-, ^a1,/M01c/,N

;-:-.7-:.>B--.=79-8D8-7.=;

P1Jec PdJ01 .7-, ^a1,/M01c/,N

F-;D3;;-8-=5-7.,-=232.-D6:2

5/P^JadM`/,33=7-=N

5PaJ^c^ .7-, 0a1/,/M5/0a1/,N0

52<82-=/ .=/ A-2-8<5.-;32

5/^JadPMd/,33=7-=N\

1/P\J\dMc/,33=7-=N

.7-, M^d1/,M1^ac,601c,NN`

$3D-:/eP0f $<-25.=;/93=/7-/,<;-:.>B-/<G:<55.=;-=/33=/7-/-.5-=

//////////////////////////////////////////////////////>2D((,#"2$!2&$"'23",."+$=9)((,2%"'2-3",$."2-%#('2#"L2)(..",(6'$"2$!2*$'."3-",#L2&(2M2=((,M27",),"#$&.2',""#'2N2%((&#"&2&(2)(..",(6'$"2-42"&2)+$=/'26$,6(2O2%((&#"&2-42""&2),""#'"23(&MNP%;2:$"4'"28-,#'2."5((+#2-3",2""&2),""#'"23(&2>QP%2*$'2#"2+$&9",J&-,%((++$=&R27",!%(++$&.2',""#'2-42&(26$,6(2""&25(+/2=((,F2&(2(&#",5(+/2=((,2$!2#"2),""#'"2."5""+25",!'"+#STMPU%V

Page 107: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 8 – 3

%.2/23D-:/eP0/D:.>B2/732/;--=/93=/7-/<G:<55.=;-=/9<:7<-2/33=/3::-/-.5-=C/'@A2-8/7-/--852-/M=8C^N/-=/7-/:33252-/M=8C/`N/E.>=/7-/,--52/D-:3=;8.>B-J/A.-833=/9<:7<-=/7-/<G:<55.=;-=f

-. 9-8:-=;-=s-. 9-8:33;7/9-8:-=;-=s-. 4:36F-8/23:67s-. F-;D3;;-8-=/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2s-. 52<82-=/.=/A-2/-8<5.-;32C

&-/--852-/78.-/<G:<55.=;-=/E.>=/,.=/<4/,--8/93=/;-:.>B-/3387f/A-2/D-28-42/--=/9-8:-=;.=;/93=7-/ A6.7.;-/ 9352-/ :33;/ .=/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ 9<8,-=C/ &-/ <G:<55.=;-=/ 9<:7<-=/ 3::-,33:/ 33=/ 7-E-:47-/-.5-=/F-:/-=/7-E-:47-/-.5-=/=.-2C/&-/<G:<55.=;f/9-8:33;7-/9-8:-=;.=;/93=/7-/9352-/:33;9<:7<-2/A-2/D-52/<G/7-/,3Y.,3:-/7.-G2-/93=/A-2/-8<5.-;32/2-=/<GE.@A2-/93=/7-/3=7-8-/2F--C/R=".;668/eP^/.5/--=/:3=;5G8<4.-:/;-;-9-=/,-2/7338.=/A-2/9-8:<<G/93=/7-/D<7-,/<G/^e/,/6.2/7-:.=B-8P=<8,33::.>=/-=/.=/".;668/eP0/A-2/:3=;5G8<4.-:/<G/^e/,/6.2/7-/8-@A2-8P=<8,33::.>=C

".;668/eP^f *3=;5G8<4.-:/93=34/B,8C/b0dJ\/<G/^e/,/6.2/7-/:.=B-8P=<8,33::.>=

Page 108: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

8 – 4 WL | Delft Hydraulics

".;668/eP0f *3=;5G8<4.-:/93=34/B,8C/b0dJ\/<G/^e/,/6.2/7-/8-@A2-8P=<8,33::.>=

S.>/7-/<G:<55.=;-=/qF-;D3;;-8-=/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2r/-=/q52<82-=/.=/A-2/-8<5.-;32r/.5/A-2/-44-@2-@A2-8/93=/B<82-8-/7668/73=/D.>/7-/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;-=C/&32/D-2-B-=2/732/7-/D3;;[email protected];-:,32.;/,<-2/F<87-=/A-8A33:7C/I-2/A-8A3:-=/93=/7-/D3;;[email protected]/A3=;2/<=7-8,--8/34/93=7-/ A<-9--:A-.7/ 7.-/F<872/F-;;-A33:7C/ '@A2-8/ .5/ -8/ F3385@A.>=:.>B/ ;--=/ 8-[:-/ A<-9--:A-.7,<;-:.>B/E<73=.;/732/,338/^/B--8/.=/7-/0/>338/;-D3;;-87/A<-42/2-/F<87-=C/&.2/B<,2/7<<8/7-8-:32.-4/5=-::-/A-852-:2.>7C/%.2/".;668/dP^`/.5/34/2-/:-.7-=/732/7-/52.>;5=-:A-.7/93=/7-/D<7-,@.8@3/1J01/,-2-8/G-8/,33=7/D-7833;2C/O,/--=/A-8A3:.=;52.>7/93=/0/>338/2-/B6==-=/A3=7A39-=.5/765/,.=.,33:/--=/;32/=<7.;/93=/`Je1/,-2-8/<=7-8/A-2/8-4-8-=2.-9:3BC$655-=/--=/8.9.-8D8--72-/93=/0a1,/-=/2<2/--=/D8--72-/93=/^d1/,J/2-=/<GE.@A2-/93=/7-/:.=B-8P=<8,33::.>=/E.2/--=/G-8.<7-/93=/@.8@3/0/F-B-=C/)-8;-:-B-=/,-2/--=/D8--72-/93=/^d1/,/93=347-/ :.=B-8P=<8,33::.>=/ .5/--=/52<[email protected]/ .=/A-2/-8<5.-;32/ [email protected]/ 9<<8/ 7-/ 5-7.,-=232.-D6:273=/--=/D3;;[email protected]/93=/7-/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2C/I.-8D.>/7.-=2/F-:/2-/F<87-=/<G;-,-8B2/732/A-2D.>/A-2/52<82-=/<,/:<5/,32-8.33:/;332/732/5=-::-8/E3:/-8<7-8-=/-=/765/--87-8/73=/d/,33=7-=--=/A-8A3:.=;/=<7.;/A--42/-=/F-:/--=/D8--72-/F<872/;-A33:7/93=/^d1/,J/,338/73=/F-:/.=/--=9-8:-;7-/9338;-6:/2-;-=/7-/:.=B-8P=<8,33::.>=/33=C

&-/9.>4/<G:<55.=;-=/7.-/9<:7<-=/33=/7-/-.5/9<<8/7-/F32-87.-G2-/-=/7-/D8--72-J/7.-G2-/93=/7-8.9.-8/ E.>=/ 3::-/ 9.>4/ 2-@A=.5@A/ 6.29<-8D338C/ )<<8732/ 7-E-/ -@A2-8/ -@<=<,.5@A/ F<87-=D-5@A<6F7/B3=/93=/7-/<G:<55.=;/q9-8:-=;-=rJ/E<=7-8/=37-8-/D-8-B-=.=;-=J/;-52-:7/F<87-=732/9<<8/7-E-/<G:<55.=;J/33=E.-=:.>B/,--8/,32-8.33:/=<7.;/.5C/I.-87<<8/93:2/7-E-/E-B-8/34/2-=<GE.@A2-/93=/7-/3=7-8-/<G:<55.=;-=/.=/7-/-@<=<,.5@A-/34F-;.=;-=C

Page 109: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 8 – 5

8.3 Economische afwegingen

R=/G383;8334/eC0/E.>=/--=/9.>423:/<G:<55.=;-=/<9-8;-D:-9-=/=3/ 2<-25.=;/33=/7-/-.5-=C/I.-8/ .5=<;/ZZ=/<G:<55.=;/M9-8:-=;-=N/34;-93::-=J/<,732/7-E-/<G/9<<8A3=7/,.=7-8/E<6/5@<8-=/p63-@<=<,.5@A-/34F-;.=;-=J/93=F-;-/@.8@3/A-2/76DD-:-/33=/,32-8.33:B<52-=C&-/<G2.-5/7.-/<9-8D:.>9-=/E.>=f

-. 9-8:33;7/9-8:-=;-=s-. 4:36F-8/23:67s-. F-;D3;;-8-=/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2s-. 52<82-=/.=/A-2/-8<5.-;32C

)3=/7-E-/<G:<55.=;-=/E.>=/7-/--852-/2F--/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;-=/-=/D.-7-=/--=/D:.>9-=7-<G:<55.=;C/&-/:33252-/2F--/D.-7-=/--=/<G:<55.=;/93=/2.>7-:.>B-/3387/-=/7.-=-=/.=/7-/:<<G/93=7-/2.>7/A-8A33:7/2-/F<87-=C

)<<8/ 7-/ D-8-B-=.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ -@<=<,.5@A-/ 34F-;.=;-=/ .5/ ;-B-B-=/ =338/ 7-/ B<52-=/ 93=/ 7-9-85@A.::-=7-/<G:<55.=;-=C/&-/A.-89<<8/ ;-A3=2--87-/ G8.>E-=/ E.>=/ ;-8-:32--87/ 33=/7-/ B<52-=93=/7-/33=:-;/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/.=/#.=2/!=78.-5/7.-/D-;.=/^bbb/.5/<G;-:-9-87C/)<<8/7-/G8.>593=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ .5/ 7-/ D862<G8.>5/ ;-D86.B2J/ F32/ =--8B<,2/ <G/ <=;-9--8/ 7-/ 34;-8-B-=7-33==--,5<,/93=/A-2/D-52-BJ/;-7--:7/7<<8/A-2/<GG-89:3B/Mg/`\cC111/,0N/93=/7-/9352-/:33;C)<<8/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ B<,2/ A.-8/ 73=/ 6.2/ @.8@3/ a1JP/ {X,0C/ &.2/ .5/ .=@:65.-4/ --=/ 9-8A<;.=;/ 93=<=;-9--8/ ^1h/ .=/ 9-8D3=7/ ,-2/ G8.>5.=7-Y/ -2@-2-83/ -=/ -Y@:65.-4/ D2FC/ &-/ ;-5@A322-D-28<6FD338A-.75,38;-/ B<,2/ A.-8D.>/ <G/ E<o=/ ^1hJ/ 9<:;-=5/ (.>B5F32-852332C/ )<<8D3;;-8F-8BE33,A-7-=/.5/<G/9-8;-:.>BD38-/F.>E-/7-/G8.>5/D-G33:7C/S.>/7-/G8.>5/G-8/9.-8B3=2-,-2-8/ D.>/ 7-/ 33=:-;/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ .5/ 6.2;-;33=/ 93=/ --=/ :33;7.B2-/ 93=/ ^J0/ ,/ D.>/ --=A3:9-8.=;/A.-893=/=-,-=/7-/B<52-=/-9-=--=5/33=E.-=:.>B/34C/&-/33==--,5<,/93=/7-/9352-:33;/93=/#.=2/!=78.-5/D-52332/9<<8/@.8@3/`1h/6.2/B<52-=/9<<8/A-2/:-9-8-=/93=/A-2/,32-8.33:9<<8/7-/9352-/:33;C/I.-86.2/9<:;2/D.>/;-:.>B/D:.>9-=7-/<9-8.;-/B<52-=/--=/G8.>5/93=/`e/{X,0C&-/G8.>E-=/F338,--/;-8-B-=7/.5J/E.>=/9-8,-:7/.=/$3D-:/eP\C

C.)(8")+ \-"#$ R.)A.";

52<82F-8B/M3=7-8-/:<@32.-/;-D3;;-87N \Jc1 {X,\

D3;;-8F-8B/M.=@:C/283=5G<82/-=/9-8F-8B.=;N \Jc1 {X,\

D3;;-8-=/-=/349<-8-=/M3:5/.=76528.-E3=7N /1J11 {X,\

33=D8-=;-=/9352-/:33;/^J0, a1J11 {X,0

33=D8-=;-=/9352-/:33;/1Ja, `eJ11 {X,0

>338:.>B5/<=7-8A<67/93=/7-/9352-/:33; =.A.: {X>338

$3D-:/eP\f +-D86.B2-/G8.>E-=/9<<8/0110

&-/<G:<55.=;/9<<8/--=/9-8:-=;7-/9-8:33;7-/9352-/ :33;/-=/--=/9352-/ :33;/,-2/ 4:36F-8/ 23:67A-DD-=/--=/9-8;-:.>BD38-/<GG-89:3B2-C

Page 110: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

8 – 6 WL | Delft Hydraulics

)<<8/7-/<G:<55.=;/,-2/--=/4:36F-8/23:67/.5/F32/,--8/,32-8.33:/=<7.;/M//^aC111,\gNJ/73=/--=9352-/:33;/,-2/--=/;-,.77-:7-/7.B2-/93=/1Ja,/-=/A.-86.2/9<:;2/7-8A3:9-/--=/G8.>5/93=/@.8@3c1J11/{X,0C/)<<8/7-/:-9-=57668/F<872/6.2/;-;33=/93=/--=/G-8.<7-/93=/c1/>338C&-/ 9-8;-:.>B.=;/ F<872/ ;-,33B2/ 9<<8/ 7-/ B<52-=/ 93=/ A-2/ A6.7.;-/ >338/ M0110NC/ V-2/ --=7.5@<=2<G-8@-=23;-/ 93=/ ch/ <,/ 7-/Q-22</?<=23=2-/H3387-/ MQ?HN/ 6.2/ 2-/ 8-B-=-=/ M.=/ 7-E-D-5@A<6F.=;/F<87-=/7-/D32-=/3:5/=6:/9-8<=7-852-:7J/E<732/7-/$<23:-/?<=523=2-/U<52-=/M$?UN;-:.>B/.5/7-/Q?HNC

JF15$$")+ b5.'..1A."; R33.@%".'.&F.-"5;. 2()%(1&A.-A(1")+

9-8:33;7/9-8:-=;-= ^e0C111,0 c1/>338 ^

4:36F-8/23:67 ^e0C111,0 c1/>338 ^

F-;D3;;-8-=/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2 ^\dC111/,\ `/,33=7-= ^11/M0Y/G-8/>338N

52<82-=/.=/A-2/-8<5.-;32 ^c^C111/,\ u/d/,33=7-= dc/M^JcY/G-8/>338N

$3D-:/eP`f I<-9--:A-7-=/;-D86.B2/<,/Q?H/2-/D-G3:-=

G.-1((+;&'.-1.)+.)^e0C111/,0/Y/`eJ11/{X,0/g/{/eCd11C111JPI-2/2<233:D-783;/9-87.5@<=2.=6--87J/,-2/--=/7.5@<=2<G-8@-=23;-/93=/ch/-=/D<6F2.>7/93=/0>338/:-9-82/<GfQ?Hf {/`C\c1C111/Y/3==6W2-.2M0N/g/{/`C\c1C111/Y/^Jea///{/eC011C111

*1(,H.-&/(1,;^e0C111/,0/Y/c1J11/{X,0/g/{/bC^11C111JPI-2/2<233:D-783;/9-87.5@<=2.=6--87J/,-2/--=/7.5@<=2<G-8@-=23;-/93=/ch/-=/D<6F2.>7/93=/0>338/:-9-82/<GfQ?Hf {/`Ccc1C111/Y/3==6W2-.2M0N/g/{/`Ccc1C111/Y/^Jea///{/eCc11C111

U.+0(++.-.)&$.;"8.)%(%".0,1%0/Y/^\dC111/,\/Y/\Jc1/{X,\/g/{/ba1C111/G-8/>338I-2/2<233:D-783;/9-87.5@<=2.=6--87J/,-2/--=/7.5@<=2<G-8@-=23;-/93=/ch/:-9-82/<GfQ?Hf {/ba1C111/Y/3==6W2-.2Mc1N/g/{/ba1C111/Y/^eJ0a///{/^dCa11C111

6%5-%.)&")&A.%&.-5$".+(%^Jc/Y/^c^C111/,\/Y/\Jc1/{X,\/g/{/e11C111/G-8/>338

7-/>38-=/011\/2<2/-=/,-2/01c0/9-87.5@<=2.=6--87/:-9-82/<GfI-2/2<233:D-783;/9-87.5@<=2.=6--87J/,-2/--=/7.5@<=2<G-8@-=23;-/93=/ch/:-9-82/<GfQ?Hf {/ba1C111/Y/3==6W2-.2Mc1N/g/{/ba1C111/Y/^eJ0a///{/^`Cc11C111

%.2/9<<8;33=7-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/D:.>B2/732/A-2/9-8:33;7/9-8:-=;-=/93=/7-/9352-/ :33;/7-/,--52-@<=<,.5@A-/<G:<55.=;/E<6/E.>=C/'@A2-8/D.>/--=/3=7-8/7.5@<=2<G-8@-=23;-/93=/@.8@3/^1Jch/<4,--8/D:.>B2/A-2/52<82-=/.=/A-2/-8<5.-;32/A-2/9<<87-:.;52/2-/E.>=J/E.-/".;668/eP^C

Page 111: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 8 – 7

Netto Contante Waarde

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20Discontopercentage [%]

NC

W [

milj

oen

en e

uro

's]

Verlengde verlaagde vaste laag

Vaste laag met flauw er eindtalud

Wegbaggeren sedimentatiebult

Storten in het erosiegat

".;668/eP\f Q-22</@<=23=2-/F3387-/MQ?HN/9<<8/9-85@A.::-=7-/7.5@<=2<G-8@-=23;-5

%.2/".;668/eP\/D:.>B2/765/732/=338/;-:3=;/A-2/7.5@<=2<G-8@-=23;-/7-/B-65/9<<8/7-/<G:<55.=;E3:/9-83=7-8-=C/&-/A<<;2-/93=/7-/7.5@<=2<9<-2/ Mg7.5@<=2<G-8@-=23;-N/F<872/9--:3:/<G/--=78.-23:^/9-85@A.::-=7-/F.>E-=/D-G33:7J/7-/>6.52-/F3387-/.5/73=/<<B/=.-2/E<=7-8/,--8/2-/;-9-=C!3=/ 7-/ A3=7/ 93=/ A-2/ <GG<826=.2LP@<52/ D-;.=5-:/ -=/ <G/ D35.5/ 93=/ 7-/ ,38B28-=2-/ ;332/ 7-9<<8B-68/6.2/=338/--=/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;C/&-/<=7-8A<675B<52-=/A-DD-=/A.-8<G/F-.=.;.=9:<-7C/S.>/>338:.>B5-/<=7-8A<675B<52-=/93=/,--8/73=/{/^11C111/[email protected]=/7-/@<[email protected]<G:<55.=;-=/=338/D<9-=/<G/-=/.5/A-2/5@A3B-:G6=2/2655-=/D3;;-8-=/-=/@<[email protected]/9-85@A<9-==338/b/h/M.CGC9C/^1hNC/$-9-=5/,<-2/-8/D.>/7-/B-6E-/9<<8/D3;;-8-=/=<;/8-B-=.=;/,--/F<87-=;-A<67-=/732/2.>7-=5/7-/F-8BE33,A-7-=/7-/5@A--G93382/F<872/D-:-,,-87C

)<<8/--=/>6.52-/B-65/93=/--=/<G:<55.=;/E3:/2-=/--852-/--=/33=23:/<G2.,3:.532.-/5:3;-=/,<-2-=F<87-=/;-,33B2J/9<<8/E<F-:/7-/@<[email protected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

//////////////////////////////////////////////////////>2S>V2(+!28"",.(3"23(&2#"2W%(('!65(44"+$=9"2'$=#!3--,9"*,LF2SMV23-+."&!25"'2-44-,'*&$'1J6-!')".$&!"+2"&2S;V2-42)(!$!23(&2#"2%(,9',"&'"

Page 112: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

8 – 8 WL | Delft Hydraulics

R=/".;668/eP`/E.>=/7-/;-,.77-:7-/B<52-=/9<<8/--=/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;/6.2;-E-2/2-;-=/7.-93=/ --=/ 2.>7-:.>B-/ <G:<55.=;C/ I.-8.=/ .5/ -9-=--=5/ 7-/ [email protected].=;/ 33=;-;-9-=/ 3:5/ -8/ c1h,.=7-8/;-D3;;-87/A<-42/ 2-/F<87-=C/ R=/ 732/ ;-93:/ E3:/ A-2/ D3;;-8-=/ @CpC/ 52<82-=/ 7-/ 9<<8B-689-87.-=-=J/ 2-=/ <GE.@A2-/ 93=/ --=/ @<[email protected]/ <G:<55.=;C/ R=/ A-2E-:47-/ 4.;668/ .5/ 2-9-=533=;-;-9-=/F32/7-/[email protected].=;/.5/3:5/7-/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;/2<2/c1h/76687-8/F<872C/R=732/;-93:/D:.>B2/A-2/B-6E-G6=2/D.>/--=/7.5@<=2<G-8@-=23;-/93=/d/h/2-/:.;;-=C

Netto contante waarde

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

Discontopercentage [%

NC

W [

milj

oen

en e

uro

's]

gem. Constructief

gem. baggeren/storten

".;668/eP`f Q-22</@<=23=2-/F3387-/MQ?HN/B<52-=9-8;-:.>B.=;/,-2/34F.>B.=;-=/2<2/c1h

I-2/;-A--:/9-83=7-82/.=7.-=/A-2/;-D3;;-87-/5-7.,-=2/6.2/7-/8.9.-8/,3;/F<87-=/<G;-=<,-=CS.>/D3;;-8F-8BE33,A-7-=/D.>/7-/33=:-;/93=/7-/9352-/ :33;/93=/#.=2/!=78.-5/ .5/ 7.2/ ;-D-6829<<8/--=/A<-9--:A-.7/7.-/;-:.>B/F35/33=/A-2/ 2-86;;-52<82/,32-8.33:/9<<8/7-/9352-/ :33;C/I-2;-D3;;-87-/5-7.,-=2/M<G/A-2/5-7.,-=2/;-D3;;-87/2-=/D-A<-9-/93=/7-/A39-=.=;3=;/=3N/F3593=/ 7.-=/ 3387/ 732/ 7.2/ 3:5/ .=76528.-E3=7/ 9-8B<@A2/ B<=/ F<87-=C/ I-2/ A6.7.;-/ D-:-.7/ .5/ -8<G;-8.@A2/732/3::--=/E3=7/6.2/7-/8.9.-8/;-A33:7/,3;/F<87-=/D-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/7-/D86;/93=i3:2D<,,-:C/S.>/A-2/F.>E.;-=/93=/7-E-/;8-=5J/.=/D<9-=528<<,5-/8.@A2.=;J/F<872/7-/<G:<55.=;<,/2-/D3;;-8-=/-@<=<,.5@A/A-2/33=28-BB-:.>B52C/&-/2-/9-8F.>7-8-=/A<-9--:A-.7/E3=7/B3=/73=F3385@A.>=:.>B/ qB<52-:<<5r/ F<87-=/ 9-8F.>7-87J/ F3387<<8/ 6.2/ G668/ -@<=<,.5@A-/ 8-7-=/ 7-<G:<55.=;/7<<8/,.77-:/93=/F-;D3;;-8-=/93=/7-/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/7-/9<<8B-68/9-87.-=2C/&-2-@A=.5@A-/ 34F-;.=;/ 7.-/ 7338D.>/ 73=/ =<;/ ;-,33B2/ ,<-2/ F<87-=/ .5/ 7-/ 34F-;.=;/ <4/ A-23@@-G23D-:/ .5/ 8-;-:,32.;/ --=/ D-:-,,-8.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ 5@A--G93382/ 2-/ A-DD-=/ 7<<8D3;;-8F-8BE33,A-7-=C/ &338=3352/ A--42/ D3;;-8-=/ A-2/ 9<<87--:/ 732/ A-2/ --=/ 4:-Y.D-:-8-<G:<55.=;/ .5/ -=/ .=/ 7-/ 2<-B<,52/ --=/ ,--8/ E-B-8A-.7/ B3=/ D.-7-=C/ I.-89<<8/ .5/ -@A2-8/ --=G8<D3D.:.52.5@A/9-89<:;<=7-8E<-B/--=/,<;-:.>BA-.7/<,/A.-8/6.25:6.25-:/<9-8/2-/D.-7-=C

Page 113: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 8 – 9

8.4 Discussie

&-/9<:;-=7-/G6=2-=/F<87-=/=<;/<G;-,-8B2f

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bch/93=/7-/2.>7/F<87-=/;-A33:7C/H<872/7-A.=7-8/93=/D3;;-8-=/D-5@A<6F7/3:5/--=/73;/9-8;-:.>BD338/,-2/A-2/=.-2/A3:-=/93=/7-D8--72-/-=/7.-G2-/93=F-;-/7-/:3;-/349<-8J/73=/,<-2/7-/D3;;[email protected]/B<82-8/E.>=/73=^e/ 73;-=/ G-8/ >338C/ S.>/ 7-/ D-B-B-=/ A<-9--:A-7-=/ .5/ 732/ A<<;52/ F3385@A.>=:.>B<=,<;-:.>BJ/ F3387<<8/ 93=6.2/ 7.-/ <G2.-B/ 7-/ ,<;-:.>BA-.7/ 9<<8/ D3;;-8-=/ 34/ E<693::-=C

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email protected]/ <G:<55.=;-=/9-8;-=/ -=7-8A3:9-/ ,3325@A3GG-:.>B/ --=/ ;8<2-8-/ 7833;:352/ 9<8,-=C/ &.2/ B3=/ F-:/ F--89-8,.=7-87/ F<87-=/ 7<<8/ A-2/ ;-:7/ 9<<8/ D3;;-8-=/ 7-/ --852-/ 0/ >338/ 33=/ 3=7-8-7<-:-.=7-=/ 2-/ D-52-7-=J/ F3387<<8/ ,--8/ G8<4.>2/ ;-A33:7/ B3=/ F<87-=C/ &-E-34F-;.=;-=/ 9<-8-=/ 2-/ 9-8/ <,/ .=/ A-2/ B37-8/ 93=/ 7.2/ <=7-8E<-B/ 6.2/ 2-/ 9<-8-=J/,338B6==-=/E-B-8/.=/--=/D-:3=;8.>B-/,32-/7-/8.@A2.=;/93=/7-/B-6E-/D-G3:-=C

-. ]8.>E-=/93=/7-/<G:<55.=;-=&-/;-D86.B2-/G8.>E-=/B6==-=/3:2.>7/2-8/[email protected]/F<87-=/;-52-:7J/A<-/E<8;96:7.;/-==36FB-68.;/<<B/D-=37-87C/&-/G8.>E-=/E.>=/93=/E<9--:/ 43@2<8-=/ 34A3=B-:.>B/ 732/ A-2<=7<-=:.>B/.5/<,/3:/7.-/43@2<8-=/E</.=/2-/5@A322-=/732/7-/>6.52-/G8.>5/F<872/9-8B8-;-=CR=/7.2/<=7-8E<-B/;332/A-2/<,/--=/D--:7/2-/B8.>;-=/93=/7-/B<52-=/2-=/<GE.@A2-/93=/7-9-85@A.::-=7-/<G:<55.=;-=J/F3387<<8/7-/=36FB-68.;A-.7/93=/,.=7-8/D-:3=;/.5C/!3=A-2/-.=7/93=/7-/9-8;-:.>B.=;/D:.>B2/732/7-/G8.>E-=/9<<8/--=/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;/<4--=/ <G:<55.=;/ ,-2/ D-A6:G/ 93=/ D3;;-8-=/ @CpC/ 52<82-=/ 8-7-:.>B/ 6.2/ -:B338/ :.;;-=CI.-87<<8/E.>=/A--:/=36FB-68.;-/G8.>E-=/-9-=--=5/93=/,.=7-8/D-:3=;C

Page 114: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft
Page 115: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 9 – 1

9 Discussie

$.>7-=5/ A-2/ A.-89<<8/ D-5@A8-9-=/ <=7-8E<-B/ E.>=/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ 8-B-=,-2A<7-=/ -=9-8;-:.>B.=;-=/ ;-D86.B2J/ -=/ E.>=/ --=/ 33=23:/ 33==3,-5/ -=/ 9-8<=7-852-::.=;-=/ ;-733=C/ '-=;-7--:2-/93=/7-E-/9-8<=7-852-::.=;-=/-=/33==3,-5/.5/<G/E.>=/,.=52/-=.;5E.=5/7.5@623D-:/-=E<67-=/,<;-:.>B/D.>/--=/3=7-8-/33=G3B/2<2/--=/.-25/3=7-8/8-56:2332/B6==-=/:-.7-=C

R=/ A-2/ 9-85:3;/ .5/ <G/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ G6=2-=/ 3:/ 33=;-;-9-=/ F338<,/ D-G33:7-/ B-6E-=/ E.>=;-,33B2C/ R=/7-/--87-8-/A<<47526BB-=/E.>=/3:/--=/33=23:/[email protected]=2-=/;-=<-,7/J/7.-/33=A-2/-.=7/93=/A-2/7-5D-28-44-=7-/A<<47526B/E.>=/D-5G8<B-=C/R=/7.2/A<<47526B/F<872/--=/33=23:93=/7-E-/E3B-=/=<;,33:5/,338/=6/.=/,--8/3:;-,-=-/E.=/D-5G8<B-=/-=/D-@<,,-=238.--87C&338=3352/E.>=/-8/--=/33=23:/G6=2-=/7.-/.=/7-/9<<8;33=7-/A<<47526BB-=/5:-@A25/2-8:<<G5/33=7-/<87-/.5/;-F--52/-=/7.-/--=/=37-8-/6.2F-8B.=;/D-A<-9-=C

&-/9<:;-=7-/G6=2-=/B<,-=/3@A2-8--=9<:;-=5/33=/7-/<87-/.=/7.2/A<<47526Bf

-. Q36FB-68.;A-.7/-=/@<,G:--2A-.7/93=/7-/;-D86.B2-/;-;-9-=5s-. +-9<:;7-/33=G3Bs-. V<;-:.>BA-7-=/-=/D-G-8B.=;-=/93=/7-/;-D86.B2-/q.=5286,-=2-=rs-. ?<=523=2-/9-8565/938.[8-=7-/349<-8s-. S<7-,5@A-8,-=/-=/q9<82-Y/-Y@:67-8rs-. U-6E-/9<<8/6.2-.=7-:.>B-/<G:<55.=;s-. $<-G35D338A-.7/<G/7-/D<@A2-=/D.>/'8:-@<,/-=/Q.>,-;-=s-. !3=D-9<:-=/9-89<:;<=7-8E<-BC

X(*89"*,$.5"$#2"&26-%4+""'5"$#23(&2#"2."),*$9'"2."."3"&!)<<8/ A-2/ <=7-8E<-B/ E.>=/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ ;-;-9-=5/ ;-D86.B2C/ &-/ ;-D86.B2-/ ;-;-9-=5/ E.>=3::-,33:/;-;-9-=5/7.-/8--75/.=;-F<==-=/F38-=/9<<8732/33=/7.2/<=7-8E<-B/F-87/D-;<==-=C'8/E.>=/=.-2/[email protected]:/9<<8/A-2/<=7-8E<-B/;-;-9-=5/ .=;-F<==-=C/'8/ .5/765/;-D86.B/;-,33B293=/;-;-9-=5J/7.-/=.-2/[email protected]/9<<8/A-2/<=7-8E<-B/,338/933B/9<<8/--=/3=7-8-/8-7-=/E.>=9-8E3,-:7C/ &.2/ ;-:72/ [email protected]:/ 9<<8/ 7-/ D3;;-8;-;-9-=5C/ )-87-8/ F38-=/ =.-2/ 3::-/ D-=<7.;7-;-;-9-=5/,-2--=/[email protected]/F32/<G/5<,,.;-/G6=2-=/9<<8/F32/9-8283;.=;/A--42/ ;-E<8;7C$<@A/B3=/.=/A-2/3:;-,--=/;-52-:7/F<87-=/732/--=/;<-7-/-=/98.>/9<::-7.;-/5-2/;-;-9-=5/ [email protected].=;/A--42/;-5233=J/7.-/A-2/,<;-:.>B/A--42/;-,33B2/<,/--=/<=7-8E<-B/93=/9<:7<-=7-BF3:.2-.2/ 6.2/ 2-/ 9<-8-=C/ I-2/ -=.;-/ 9<<8D-A<67/ ;-:72/ ,[email protected]=/ 2-=/ 33=E.-=/ 93=/ 7-D3;;-8;-;-9-=5J/7.-/=.-2/;-,3BB-:.>B/@<=28<:--8D338/E.>=C/S.>/9-89<:;<=7-8E<-B/.5/A-2/-@A2-88337E33,/<,/E</98<-;/,<;-:.>B/76.7-:.>B/2-/4<8,6:-8-=/F-:B-/;-;-9-=5/=<<7E3B-:.>B/E.>=JF-:B-/ F-8BE33,A-7-=/ 7338/ -9-=26--:/ =<;/ 9<<8/ =<7.;/ E.>=/ -=/ F32/ =<;/ 33=/ -Y2839-:7.=4<8,32.-/9-8E3,-:7/,<-2/F<87-=C/!3=/7-/A3=7/93=/7-E-/.=4<8,32.-/B3=/A-2/<=7-8E<-B73=/F<87-=/D.>;-52-:7/F32/D-28-42/,<;-:.>BP/-=/<=,<;-:.>BA-7-=C

Page 116: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

9 – 2 WL | Delft Hydraulics

Y"3-+.#"2((&4(9&-/;-9<:;7-/9<:;<87-/.=/A-2/<=7-8E<-B/D-52<=7/6.2/:.2-8326685267.-J/3=3:L5-/,-2/D-A6:G/93=!8@).-FJ/ 3=3:L2.5@A-/ D-8-B-=.=;-=J/ 5.,6:32.-5/ ,-2/ &-:42\&/ -=/ --=/ 9-8;-:.>B.=;/ 93=/ 7-B<52-=C/!::-/<=7-87-:-=/F<87-=/E.=9<:/;-3@A2J/-=/A-DD-=/D.>;-783;-=/33=/A-2/<=7-8E<-BC/&-3=3:L2.5@A-/ D-8-B-=.=;-=/ E<67-=/ -@A2-8/ ,[email protected]=/ 3:/ --87-8/ 6.2;-9<-87/ A-DD-=/ ,<-2-=F<87-=C/&-E-/ 345@A322.=;-=/D.-7-=/=3,-:.>B/ --=/ <=7-852-6=.=;/ 2-=/ 33=E.-=/ 93=/ 7-/ B-6E-93=/,<;-:.>B-/<G:<55.=;-=J/,338/A377-=/<<B/B6==-=/7.-=-=/<,/D-2-8/8.@A2.=;/2-/;-9-=/33=7-/3=3:L5-5/,-2/!8@).-FC/&-/3=3:L5-5/,-2/!8@).-F/;39-=/--=/;<-7/D--:7/93=/7-/<,93=;93=/ 7-/ ,<84<:<;.5@A-/ -44-@2-=J/ ,338/ -8/ 9<:;7-/ ;--=/ 76.7-:.>B-/ 8-:32.-/ 2655-=/ 7-9-83=7-8.=;-=/ .=/ 7-/ D<7-,/ -=/ 7-/ 349<-8C/&.2/ B3=/ <=7-8,--8/ B<,-=/ 7<<8/ 7-/ [email protected],6:2.D-3,P;-;-9-=5J/ 7.-/ =.-2/ ;-,-2-=/ E.>=/ <9-8/ A-2/ ;-A-:-/ 349<-8D-8-.B/ M,3Y.,3:-/ -=,.=.,3:-/ 349<-8-=NC/ I-2/ D-5267-8-=/ 93=/ \/ D<@A2-=/ D:--B/ --=/ 2-/ <,93=;8.>B/ <=7-8E<-BD.==-=/7-/[email protected]/2.>7/-=/.5/7338<,/<<B/A3:9-8F-;-/D-G-8B2C

B-."+$=95"#"&2"&2)"4",9$&."&23(&2W$&!',*%"&'"&LR=/ A-2/ <=7-8E<-B/ .5/ ;-D86.B/ ;-,33B2/ 93=/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ 5<42F38-G3BB-22-=/ ME<3:5/ <=7-83=7-8-f/ !8@).-FJ/ &-:42\&J/ 'Y@-:J/ H<87J/ V32:3DJ/ ]3.=25A<G/ ]8<J/ m6.@BG:<2NJ/ F338D.>!8@).-F/ -=/ &-:42\&/ 7-/ ,--52/ @[email protected]:-/ 5<42F38-G3BB-22-=/ E.>=/ ;-F--52C/ !8@).-F/ .5/ ,-2=3,-/;[email protected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p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email protected]/<G:<55.=;-=/E.>=/;-,33B2/,-2/--=/@<=523=2-/349<-893=/^a11/,\X5C/ R=/ 7-/ G83B2.>B/ 28--72/ -@A2-8/ .=/ 7-/ 8.9.-8/ --=/F.55-:-=7-/ 349<-8/ <GC/S.>/ --=6.2;-9<-87-/9-8;-:.>B.=;/2655-=/--=/5.,6:32.-/,-2/--=/@<=523=2-/q7<,.=3=2-r/349<-8/-=/--=,-2/--=/938.[8-=7-/349<-8J/D:.>B-=/7-E-/9<<8/7-/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/;-,.77-:7/;<-7/<9-8--=/2-B<,-=C/'@A2-8/.5/-8/;--=/@<=28<:-/6.2;-9<-87/<G/A-2/2<23:-/5-7.,-=2283=5G<82C/&-/6.2B<,52-=93=/ 7-/ D-8-B-=.=;-=/ ;-9-=/ 7-/ ;-,.77-:7-/ D<7-,:.;;.=;/ .=/ 7-/ [email protected]/ F--8C)<<8/ 7-/ ,3Y.,3:-/ <4/ ,.=.,3:-/ D<7-,A<<;2-/ 7.-=2/ A-2/ F-:/ 7-/ 33=D-9-:.=;/ <,/ ,-2/ --=938.[8-=7-/ 349<-8/ 2-/ 8-B-=-=C/ I-2/ F<872/ 7338<,/ 33=D-9<:-=/ <,/ 9<<8/ 7-/ <G:<55.=;/ 7.-6.2-.=7-:.>B/F<872/;-G8-4-8--87/3:5=<;/--=/5.,6:32.-/,-2/938.[8-=7-/349<-8/6.2/2-/9<-8-=C/

Page 117: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 9 – 3

?-#"%!65",%"&2"&2W3-,'"[2"[6+*#",L&-/<G:<55.=;-=/7.-/,-2/&-:42/\&/E.>=/<=7-8E<@A2J/E.>=/33=G355.=;-=/93=/7-/9352-/:33;C/'-=.=2-8-553=2-/,<;-:.>BA-.7/ .5/-@A2-8/<,/2-/G8<D-8-=/A-2/ 2-9--:/33=/5-7.,-=2/ 283=5G<82/ .=/7-D.==-=D<@A2/E</5=-:/,<;-:.>B/=338/7-/A-2/;32/D-=-7-=528<<,5/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/2-/D8-=;-=CI.-89<<8/ B3=/ ,<;-:.>B/ E<F-:/ --=/ <G:<55.=;/ ,-2/ D<7-,5@A-8,-=/ 3:5/ --=/ E<;-=33,7-q9<82-Y/-Y@:67-8r/7.-=-=C/'-=/9<82-Y/-Y@:67-8/.5/,-2/&-:42\&/=.-2/6.2/2-/8-B-=-=/-=/A.-89<<8E3:/--=/3=7-8/5<<82/<=7-8E<-B/=<7.;/E.>=C/&-E-/<G:<55.=;/B3=/=-2/3:5/D<7-,5@A-8,-=/9<<8,-2/=3,-/7-/D<@A2/93=/Q.>,-;-=/.=2-8-553=2/E.>=J/9<<83:/<,732/A-2/G8<D:--,/93=/-8<5.-;32-=/ 5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/ D.>/ 7-/ B-8=/ F<872/ 33=;-932f/ ;-G8<D--87/ F<872/ 7-/ <=;6=52.;-5-7.,-=2XF32-8/ 9-8A<67.=;/ E</ 5=-:/ ,<;-:.>B/ 2-/ 9-8D-2-8-=C/ &-/ F-8B.=;/ 93=/ --=/ 9<82-Y-Y@:67-8/B3=/,-2/=3,-/.=/--=/5@A33:,<7-:/<G/E.>=/[email protected]/F<87-=/D-5267--87J/F338D.><,/2-/D-;.==-=/A-2/,<;-:.>B/33=D-9-:.=;/9-87.-=2/<,/.=/--=/:3D<832<8.6,;<<2/-=.;/[email protected]<=7-8E<-B/6.2/2-/9<-8-=/9<<8732/--=/-@A2/5@A33:,<7-:/F<872/;-D<6F7/C/$-9-=5/7.-=2/.=/--=98<-;/5237.6,/=3;-73@A2/2-/F<87-=/A<-/--=/7-8;-:.>B-/9<82-Y/-Y@:67-8/;-D<6F7/E<6/B6==-=F<87-=J/-=/<4/7.2/--=/-44-@2/A--42/<G/7-/F-8B.=;C/V<;-:.>B-/@<[email protected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email protected]=3:L5-J/F338/9-85@A.::-=7-/F-;.=;543@2<8-=/7-/B-65B6==-=/D-W=9:<-7-=C/'-=/93=/7-/D-:3=;8.>B-/43@2<8-=/7338D.>/.5/7-/-9-=26-:-/5@A--G5A.=7-82.>7-=5/D3;;-8-=C/&-/3:2-8=32.-9-/<G:<55.=;-=/E<3:5/--=/9<82-Y/-Y@:67-8/-=/D<7-,5@A-8,-=E.>=/A.-8/=.-2/,--;-=<,-=/.=/7-/2-@A=.5@A-/-=/-@<=<,.5@A-/34F-;.=;-=C/&-E-/E6::-=/33=/7-A3=7/93=/--=/=37-8/<=7-8E<-B/ME.-/A.-8=3N/3:5=<;/,--;-F<;-=/7.-=-=/2-/F<87-=C

]-"4(!)((,5"$#2-42#"2)-65'"&2)$=2^,+"6-%2"&2X$=%"."&_%.2/ A-2/ <=7-8E<-B/ B<,2/ =338/ 9<8-=/ 732/ 93=/ 7-/ @<[email protected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email protected]/93=/7-/34523=7/:3=;5/7-/8.9.-8/:.>B2/73=/<<B/=<<7E3B-:.>BC

Page 118: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

9 – 4 WL | Delft Hydraulics

'@A2-8/ A-2/ D35.5P.7--/ 93=/ 7-/ <G:<55.=;J/ =3,-:.>B/ ,-2/ A-2/ -8<5.-;32/ .=/ 7-/ <=7.-G-D.==-=D<@A2/ B<,2/ -=/ 7-/ 5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/ .=/ 7-/ 7.-G-8-/ D6.2-=D<@A2J/ B3=/ ;-A3=7A3347D:.>9-=C/ )<<8/ Q.>,-;-=/ E3:/ --=/ 9-8;-:.>BD38-/ <G:<55.=;/ F-.=.;/ [email protected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i-B-8/9<<8/7-/D<@A2/D.>/Q.>,-;-=/;-:72/732/=37-8/<=7-8E<-B/=<<7E3B-:.>B/.5C/0(&)"3-+"&23",3-+.-&#",I-"9R=/ A-2/ 9-8:-=;7-/ 93=/ A-2/ A6.7.;-/ <=7-8E<-B/ E.>=/ =<;/ --=/ 33=23:/ 9-89<:;<=7-8E<-B-=F-=5-:.>BC/+:<D33:/B3=/<[email protected]/F<87-=/;-,33B2/.=/7-/9<:;-=7-/<=7-8E<-B-=f

-. =37-8/<=7-8E<-B/=338/7-/9-8:-=;.=;/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/.=/#2C/!=78.-5s-. =37-8/ <=7-8E<-B/ =338/ A-2/ <G2.,3:.5-8-=/ 93=/ A-2/ D3;;-8-=/ 3:5/ <G:<55.=;/ D.>/ #2C

!=78.-5s-. =37-8/ <=7-8E<-B/ =338/ --=/ <G:<55.=;/ 9<<8/ #2C/ !=78.-5/ ,-2/ D-A6:G/ 93=

D<7-,5@A-8,-=s-. =37-8/ <=7-8E<-B/ =338/ <G:<55.=;-=/ 9<<8/ '8:-@<,J/ ,-2/ =3,-/ 2-=/ 33=E.-=/ 93=/ A-2

7<<8E-22-=/93=/7-/D<7-,B8.DD-=s-. [email protected]<=7-8E<-B/=338/7-/,<;-:.>B-/2<-G355.=;/93=/--=/9<82-Y/-Y@:67-8J/<,/=3/2-

;33=/<4/7-E-/<G:<55.=;/,-2/=3,-/9<<8/Q.>,-;-=J/,338/,<;-:.>B/<<B/9<<8/7-/3=7-8-D<@A2-=J/ 2-@A=.5@A/ --=/;<-7-/<G:<55.=;/;--42J/ -=/ E</ >3J/ 33=96::-=7/<=7-8E<-B/<,7-E-/<G:<55.=;/2-/<G2.,3:.5-8-=s

-. <=7-8:.=;-/ 9-8;-:.>B.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ 9<<8P/ -=/ =37-:-=/ 93=/ 7-/ ,<;-:.>B-<G:<55.=;-=/ 9<<8/ 7-/ 78.-/ D<@A2-=/ -=/ A-2/ G-8/ D<@A2/ B<,-=/ 2<2/ 7-/ ,--52/ <G2.,3:-<G:<55.=;s

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o5/ 2-=/ 33=E.-=/ 93=/ A-2/ 349<-89-8:<<G<=7-8E<@A2/ B6==-=/ F<87-=/ A<-/ :3=;/ --=/ D3;;-8<G:<55.=;/ [email protected]/ D:.>42C/ S.>/ 7.2<=7-8E<-BJ/732/,-2/&-:42\&/B3=/F<87-=/6.2;-9<-87J/B3=/<<B/7-/,<;-:.>BA-.7/93=q<9-8D3;;-8-=r/ -=/ A-2/ 8-=7-,-=2/ -893=/ .=/ D-5@A<6F.=;/F<87-=/ ;-=<,-=C/Q37-8<=7-8E<-B/=338/--=/<G:<55.=;/9<<8/#2C/!=78.-5/,-2/D-A6:G/93=/D<7-,5@A-8,-=J/7.-<G/E.@A/--=/.=2-8-553=2-/-=/7.8-@2-/<G:<55.=;/9<<8/E<F-:/7-/D6:2/3:5/A-2/;32/.5J/B3=-9-=--=5/,-2/ D-A6:G/ 93=/&-:42\&/ ;-D-68-=C/ #.=75/ -=.;-/ 2.>7/ .5/ A-2/ =3,-:.>B/ <<B,<;-:.>B/ <,/ .=/ &-:42\&/ A-2/ -44-@2/ 93=/ D<7-,5@A-8,-=/ 2-/ 5.,6:-8-=C

Page 119: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 9 – 5

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email protected]<=7-8E<-B/=338/7-/F-8B.=;/=<7.;J<,/=3/2-/;33=/<4/7-E-/<G:<55.=;/2-@A=.5@A/;-E.-=/--=/;<-7-/<G:<55.=;/;--42C/O,/2-D-;.==-=/E<6/.=/--=/5.,G-:-/<G52-::.=;/.=/--=/;<<2/=3;-;33=/B6==-=/F<87-=/<4/7-D-<<;7-/F-89-:/.=/7-/-Y@:67-8/<=252332/-=/F32/A-2/-44-@2/<G/A-2/5-7.,-=2283=5G<82/.5C)-89<:;-=5/E<6/=3;-;33=/,<-2-=/F<87-=/<4/-8/--=/8.5.@</.5/732/7-/9<82-Y/-Y@:67-8q7.@A25:332r/ D.>/ --=/ -9-=26-:-/ 9-8A<;.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ D<7-,/ ME.-/ G383;8334/ dC\CeN/ !:53:2-8=32.-4/ <4/ 2-8/ 33=96::.=;/ B3=/ ;-73@A2/ F<87-=/ 33=/ <=7-8E<-B/ .=/ A-2/ \&/,<7-:?"|J/ F338.=/ ;-7-23.::--87/ ;-8-B-=7/ B3=/ F<87-=/ 33=/ 7-/ \&/ 528<,.=;/ .=/ -=/ D.>@<[email protected]/V<@A2/--=/9<82-Y/-Y@:67-8/--=/.=2-8-553=2-/<G:<55.=;/:.>B-=J/73=/7.-=29-87-8/ =3;-73@A2/ 2-/ F<87-=/ <9-8/ 7-/ @<[email protected]/ 9<8,;-9.=;J/ -=/ 33=/ 7-,<;-:.>BA-.7/<,/:32-8/9-83=7-8.=;-=/33=/2-/D8-=;-=/<4/33=/7-/,<;-:.>BA-.7/<,/7--Y@:67-8/-9-=26--:/:32-8/;-A--:/2-/9-8F.>7-8-=J/A-2;--=/9<<8B<,2/732/--=/@<[email protected]:32-8/ --=/ D-:-,,-8.=;/ ;332/ 9<8,-=C/ $<-G355.=;/ 93=/ --=/ -Y@:67-8/ -=X<4D<7-,5@A-8,-=/.5/,-2/=3,-/.=2-8-553=2/9<<8/Q.>,-;-=J/,338/B6==-=/,<;-:.>B/<<B9<<8/'8:-@<,/-=/#.=2/!=78.-5/ --=/6.2B<,52/ D.-7-=C/'-=/ [email protected]/ <=7-8E<-B/=338A-2/-44-@2/93=/7-/B8.D9:3,,-=/<G/7-/ -8<5.-;-6:/ =3352/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/B3=/ -9-=--=5E--8/ .=2-8-553=2/ E.>=C/ $-=5:<22-/ 7.-=2/ .=/ --=/ D-G33:7-/ 435-/ 3:5=<;/ --=/ ;<-7-<=7-8:.=;-/ 9-8;-:.>B.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ 9<<8P/ -=/ =37-:-=/ 93=/ 7-/ ,<;-:.>B-<G:<55.=;-=/9<<8/7-/78.-/D<@A2-=/;-,33B2/2-/F<87-=/<,/G-8/D<@A2/2-/B<,-=/2<2/7-,--52/<G2.,3:-/<G:<55.=;CC/I-2/.5/9-8523=7.;/=6/9352/<9-8/7-/2-/A3=2-8-=/@8.2-8.3/=3/2-7-=B-=C

/

Page 120: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

9 – 6 WL | Delft Hydraulics

Page 121: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 1 0 – 1

10 Conclusies en aanbevelingen

R=/ 7.2/ A<<47526B/ F<87-=/ 7-/ D-:3=;8.>B52-/ @<=@:65.-5/ ;-;-9-=/ -=/ =37-8/ 2<-;-:.@A2C/ &-@<=@:65.-5/D.-7-=/<,/2-/D-;.==-=/3=2F<<87/<G/7-/G8.,3.8-/7<-:52-::.=;/E<3:5/9-8,-:7/.=/A-2D-;.=/93=/A-2/9-85:3;C/)-89<:;-=5/F<87-=/--=/33=23:/3=7-8-/@<=@:65.-5/9-8,-:7/7.-/6.2/A-2<=7-8E<-B/ E.>=/ ;-9<:;7C/ %.2/ 7-/ @<=@:65.-5/ 9<:;-=/ -=B-:-/ 33=D-9-:.=;-=/ 9<<89-89<:;<=7-8E<-B-=/-=/,<;-:.>B-/9-8D-2-8.=;-=/@CpC/6.2D8-.7.=;-=/93=/7-/<G:<55.=;-=C/&-@<=@:65.-5/ -=/ 33=D-9-:.=;-=/ E.>=/ ,-2/ =3,-/ ;-8.@A2/ <G/ 7-/ D<@A2/ 93=/ #.=2/ !=78.-5J/ ,338B6==-=/ME<3:5/.=/7-/[email protected]/3:/9-8,-:7/.5N/<<B/7--:5/F<87-=/2<-;-G352/<G/7-/D<@A2-=/D.>'8:-@<,/-=/Q.>,-;-=C

10.1 Conclusies

!:5/G8.,3.8-/@<=@:65.-/B3=/F<87-=/;-52-:7/732/--=/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;/.=/7-/9<8,/93=--=/ 9-8:-=;.=;/ <=7-8/ --=/ 23:67/ <4/ 9-8:3;.=;/ 2-@A=.5@A/ ,<;-:.>B/ .5/ -=/ F3385@A.>=:.>B-@<=<,.5@A/7-/9<<8B-68/A--42C/S.>/7-E-/@<=@:65.-/A<8-=/-@A2-8/F-:/-=B-:-/B3=22-B-=.=;-=JE<3:5/3:/33=;-;-9-=/.5/ .=/7-/&[email protected]/V-2/=3,-/7-/F.>E-/93=/-@<=<,.5@A/9-8;-:.>B-=/ .5D-G3:-=7/9<<8/7-/@<=@:65.-C/)<<8/--=/@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;/,<-2/-8/.=/ZZ=/B--8/,--8/;-:[email protected]/E.>=J/2-8F.>:/9<<8/D3;;-8-=/,--8/5G8-.7.=;/33=F-E.;/.5J/F3387<<8/7.2/@6,6:32.-476687-8/ .5C/ )3=6.2/ =362.5@A/ <<;G6=2/ .5/ D3;;-8-=/ -9-=--=5/ --=/ D-:-,,-8.=;/ 7<<8/ 7-2.>7-:.>B-/ D-G-8B.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ 9338D33=D8--72-C/ I-2/ 9<<87--:/ 93=/ D3;;-8-=/ .5/ 732/ -8/,.=7-88.5.@<o5/ 33=/ 9-8D<=7-=/ E.>=/ -=/ A-2/ 4:-Y.D-:-8/ .5/ .=/ 2-/ E-22-=C/ &-5<=73=B5/ 9-87.-=2/ --=@<[email protected]/<G:<55.=;/7-/9<<8B-68J/93=F-;-/7-/2-@A=.5@A-/-=/-@<=<,.5@A-/35G-@2-=C/'-=9-8:-=;.=;/D.-72/ 5:-@A25/ --=/ <G:<55.=;/ 9<<8/ A-2/ -8<5.-;32/ -=/ 7-/ 5-7.,-=232.-D6:2C/)<<8/ 7-7.-G2-/93=/7-/-8<5.-5:-64/F<872/;--=/<G:<55.=;/,-2/D-A6:G/93=/9-8:-=;.=;/93=/7-/9352-/:33;;-D<7-=C/ &-/ <G:<55.=;/ .5/ ;-8.@A2/ <G/ 7-/ D<@A2/ D.>/ #.=2/ !=78.-5/ -=/ .5/ D-8-B-=7/ ,-2/ --=@<=523=2-/349<-8/93=/^a11/,\X5C

Q3352/ 7-/ G8.,3.8-/ @<=@:65.-/ .5/ -8/ =<;/ --=/ 33=23:/ @<=@:65.-5/ F-:B-/ G6=25;-F.>5/ F<87-=9-8,-:7C

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p63/7.-G2-/3:5/p63/:<@32.-C

Page 122: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

1 0 – 2 WL | Delft Hydraulics

-. $.>75@A3:-=/33=/7-/A3=7/93=/3=3:L5-/93=/7-/,--2;-;-9-=5I-2/-8<5.-;32/.5/.=/7-/2.>7/523D.-:J/F3387<<8/M9<<8/'8:-@<,/-=/Q.>,-;-=N/,-2/D-A6:G93=/ 7-/ ;-D86.B2-/ 3=3:L5-/ ;--=/ A-852-:2.>7/ <4/ 33=G355.=;52.>7/ .5/ 34/ 2-/ :-.7-=/ C/ &-2.>75@A33:/ 9<<8/ 7-/ <=2F.BB-:.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ [email protected]/ 9<<8/ A-2/ -8<5.-;32/ 93=#.=2/!=78.-5/ .5/-=B-:-/ >38-=C/&-/,3Y.,3:-/7.-G2-/93=/A-2/;32/ .5/E-:45/\/ >338/=3/7-33=:-;/=<;/52--75/;8<-.-=7C/S.>/7-/D<@A2/93=/'8:-@<,/.5/=3/\/>338/-@A2-8/3:/F-:/--=;-:.>B-8/ 9-8:<<G/ 93=/ 7-/ D<7-,/ 2-/ E.-=/ .=/ 7-/ 2.>7J/ F3387<<8/ ;8<4F-;/ ;-52-:7/ B3=F<87-=/732/7-/<=2F.BB-:.=;/93=/A-2/;32/--=/2.>75@A33:/93=/\/>338/A--42C/'@A2-8J/.=/A-2D-;.=/ 9-8:<<G2/ 7-/ <=2F.BB-:.=;/ 93=/ A-2/ -8<5.-;32/ 33=E.-=:.>B/ 5=-::-8f/ .=/ -=B-:-,33=7-=/<=252332/e1/h/93=/7-/7.-G2-/93=/A-2/-8<5.-;32C/I.-8D.>/7.-=2/F-:/2-/F<87-=<G;-,-8B2/732/A-2/;32/D.>/#.=2/!=78.-5/7<<8/D3;;-8-=/B6=52,32.;/.5/9-8:-=;7/-=/765=.-2/ ;-A--:/ <G/ =32668:.>B-/ F.>E-/ .5/ <=25233=/ -=/ 7-/ D<7-,/ 9-85=-:7/ 2<2/ [email protected]/.5/;-B<,-=C

-. R=9:<-7/93=/86FA-7-='-=/ 86F-8-/ 9352-/ :33;/ ;--42/ --=/ ;8<2-8-/ 7.-G2-/ =3352/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;C/ '-=/ ;:377-8-3::69.3:-/D<7-,/9-8;8<<2/7-/7.-G2-/=3352/7-/9352-/:33;C/'-=/9-8;-:.>BD38-/9-886F.=;93=/7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ 2-=/ <GE.@A2-/ 93=/ --=/;:377-8-/ 3::69.3:-/ D<7-,/ A--42/ --=/ ;8<2-8-44-@2/<G/7-/7.-G2-/93=/7-/9352-/:33;C/&65/--=/9-8:3;.=;/93=/7-/?AZELPF3387-/93=/c,^X0X5/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ A--42/ --=/ ;8<2-8-/F-8B.=;/ <G/ 7-/ 7.-G2-/ 73=/ --=/ c/,^X0X59-8A<;.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ ?AZELPF3387-/ 93=/ A-2/ 3::69.3:-/ 7--:C/ )-83=7-8.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ ?PF3387-/93=/7-/3::69.3:-/:33;/:.>B2/=.-2/,<;-:.>BJ/,338/<<B/--=/9-83=7-8.=;/93=/7-/?PF3387-/93=/7-/9352-/:33;/.5/,<-.:.>B/2-/8-3:.5-8-=C

-. !49<-8&-/ @<=523=2-/ 349<-8/ ;--42/ --=/ ;<-7/ D--:7/ 93=/ 7-/ D<7-,A<<;2-/ 93=/ 7-5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/2-=/<GE.@A2-/93=/7-/;-5@A-,32.5--87-/349<-8/<4/-2,33:;-,.77-:7-349<-8C/ '-=/ @<=523=2-/ 349<-8/ ;--42/ --=/ <9-85@A322.=;/ 93=/ 7-/ D<7-,A<<;2-/ 2-=<GE.@A2-/ 93=/ 7-/ 938.[8-=7-/ D<7-,A<<;2-C/ &-/ ;-5@A-,32.5--87-/ 349<-8/ -=/ 7--2,33:;-,.77-:7-/349<-8/9-82<=-=/--=/9-8;-:.>BD338/9-8:<<G/93=/7-/D<7-,A<<;2-/.=7-/2.>7/9<<8/E<F-:/7-/5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/3:5/A-2/-8<5.-;32C

-. $.>75@A3:-=/33=/7-/A3=7/93=/&-:42\&/D-8-B-=.=;-=S.>/7-/&-:42\&/D-8-B-=.=;-=/ .5/A-2/,<84<:<;.5@A/-9-=F.@A2/ 8<=7/7-/9352-/ :33;/[email protected]@3/ \/ >338/ D-8-.B2C/ I-2/ -8<5.-;32/ D-=-7-=528<<,5/ <=2F.BB-:2/ E.@A/ .=/ 7-/ --852-,33=7-=/E--8/5=-:C/Q3/@.8@3/\/>338/.5/--=/[email protected]/D-8-.B2C/&-E-/2.>757668B<,2/ ;<-7/ <9-8--=/ ,-2/ 7-/ ;-9<=7-=/ F3387-/ 6.2/ 7-/ 3=3:L5-/ ,-2/ D-A6:G/ 93=!8@).-FC/&-/A-852-:2.>7/93=/A-2/7.@A2;-52<82-/-8<5.-;32/.5/-=B-:-/,33=7-=/2<2732/7-D<7-,7.-G2-/ <=7-8/ 7-/ @<[email protected]/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ B<,2C/ I-2/ D-8-.B-=/ 93=/ 7-6.2-.=7-:.>B-/[email protected]/=--,2/--=/2.>75D-52-B/93=/@.8@3/0/>338/.=/D-5:3;C/&-A-852-:2.>7/ 93=/ 7-/ 5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/ 9-8:<<G2/ 5=-::-8/ 73=/ D.>/ A-2/ -8<5.-;32C/ &[email protected]/93=/A-2/;32/F<872/=3/86.,/^/>338/D-8-.B2J/2-8F.>:/7-/D6:2/3:/D.==-=-=B-:-/,33=7-=/.5/;-;8<-.7/2<2/D<9-=/7-/,3Y.,33:/;-F-=52-/D<7-,A<<;2-C

Page 123: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 1 0 – 3

-. ?<[email protected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email protected]/7.-/--=/D:.>9-=7-/<G:<55.=;/D.-72/9<<8/7-/7.-G2-93=/7-/-8<5.-5:-64/:3=;5/7-/9352-/:33;/.5/=.-2/;-9<=7-=C

-. S3;;-8-=/@Cp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

-. $-@A=.5@A-/9<<8B-6853:2-8=32.-4i<F-:/ --=/ G-8,3=-=2-/ @<[email protected]/ <G:<55.=;/ 3:5/ --=/ 8-G-2-8-=7-/ D3;;[email protected]=/ --=/ <G:<55.=;/ 9<<8/ 7-/ ;8<<252-/ G8<D:-,-=C/ +--=/ 93=/ 7-/ D-8-B-=7-<G:<55.=;-=/D.-72/9<<8/3::-/78.-/7-/G8<D:-,-=/--=/9<:7<-=7-/<G:<55.=;C/S3;;-8-=9<:7<-2/ 3::--=/ 3:5/ 7-/ D3;;[email protected]/ E-:4/ =.-2/ --=/ 2-/ ;8<2-/ D-:-,,-8.=;/ 93=/ 7-9338D33=D8--72-/<G:-9-82C

-. '@<=<,.5@A-/9<<8B-68S.>/9-8;-:.>B.=;/,-2/D-A6:G/93=/7-/Q?H/M=-22</@<=23=2-/F3387-N/;332/7-/9<<8B-686.2/ =338/ A-2/ 9-8:-=;-=/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;C/ '@A2-8J/ D.>/ ,.=7-8/ D3;;-8-=/ -=/ D.>/ A-2,<;-=/ 349<-8-=/ 93=/ A-2/ 5-7.,-=2/ 6.2/ 7-/ 8.9.-8/ F<872/ 7-/ -@<=<,.5@A-/ 9<<8B-68D3;;-8-=C/&-/9-8:-=;7-/9352-/:33;/B3=/9-8D-2-87/F<87-=/7<<8/--=/<G2.,3:.532.-/6.22-/9<-8-=/<,/7-/33=:-;B<52-=/2-/8-76@-8-=J/E<73=.;/732/7-/D<7-,:.;;.=;/=<;/>6.529<:7<-2/33=/7-/2-@A=.5@A-/-.5-=C

10.2 Aanbevelingen

R=/ A-2/ 9-85:3;/ .5/ <G/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ G:3325-=/ 9-8,-:7/ 732/ =37-8/ <=7-8E<-B/ =<<7E3B-:.>B/ <4F-=5-:.>B/ .5C/&32/ =37-8/ <=7-8E<-B/B3=/D-5233=/6.2/ 6.2D8-.7.=;/ 93=/ A-2/ A6.7.;-/ <=7-8E<-BJ,338/ B3=/ <<B/ D-5233=/ 6.2/ 33=96::.=;-=/ A.-8<GC/ $-9-=5/ E.>=/ -8/ 33=D-9-:.=;-=/ ;-733=/ <9-8,<;-:.>B/9-8D-2-8.=;-=/9<<8/9-8;-:.>BD338/<=7-8E<-B/.=/7-/2<-B<,52C/i<3:5/3:/.=/7-/[email protected]/9-8,-:7/.5/A-2/,<;-:.>B/<,/<G/9-85@A.::-=7-/G6=2-=/A-2/A6.7.;-/<=7-8E<-B/2-/9-87.-G-=/-=9-8D8-7-=C/ $-9-=5/ A--42/ A-2/ <<B/ =<;/ 7-/ 33=D-9-:.=;/ 2-/ :-22-=/ <G/ 7-/ 9<:;-=7-/ G6=2-=JD-28-44-=7-f

-. +-;-9-=5s-. !452-::.=;-=/93=/A-2/,<7-:s-. OG:<55.=;-=C

Page 124: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

1 0 – 4 WL | Delft Hydraulics

Y"."3"&!-. )-8D-2-8.=;/.=/7-/G-.:;-;-9-=5

)<<8/--=/9-89<:;<=7-8E<-B/<4/9-8;-:.>BD338/<=7-8E<-B/.5/A-2/33=/2-/D-9-:-=/<,/[email protected]/;-;-9-=5/;-5286@268--87-8/2-/9-8F-8B-=/-=/D-A-8-=C/&-/9-8D-2-8G6=2-=A.-8.=/E.>=/<=7-8/3=7-8-/2-/9.=7-=/.=/D.>:3;-/&C/R=/D.>:3;-/&/5233=/,<;-:.>B-/4<62-=JA-2/F<872/ 33=D-9<:-=/<,/76.7-:.>BA-.7/ 2-/ B8.>;-=/<9-8/F-:B-/ <87-/ 93=/;8<<22-/ 7-4<62/.=/7-/,--2;-;-9-=5/A--42C/$-9-=5/.5/A-2/33=/2-/D-9-:-=/<,/--=/--=76.7.;-/F.>E-93=/D-A--8/ 2-/ A-DD-=J/ E<732/ D.>9<<8D--:7/,338/ 5:-@A25/ ZZ=/9-85.-/ 93=/ --=/ G-.:.=;[email protected]/.5/,-2/7338D.>/9-8,-:7/7-/6.2;-9<-87-/D-F-8B.=;-=/93=/7-/;-;-9-=5C

-. ]-.:.=;-=/<=7-8/9-85@A.::-=7-/<,523=7.;A-7-=/6.29<-8-=)<<8/,<84<:<;.5@A/ 9-8:<<G/ E.>=/,--87-8-/ D<7-,G-.:.=;-=/F-=5-:.>B/ -=/,-2/ =3,-2.>7-=5/--=/;-938.--87-8/349<-8D-8-.BC/I.-87<<8/F<872/<<B/--=/D--:7/9-8B8-;-=/93=7-/D<7-,/2.>7-=5/A<<;F32-8C

0/!'"++$&."&23(&25"'2%-#"+-. )38.3D-:-/86FA-7-=

R=/&-:42\&/ 7.-=2/ 93=/ 2-9<8-=/ 2-/ F<87-=/ <G;-;-9-=/ F32/ 9<<8/ 86FA-.7/ 7-/ D<7-,A--42C/V-2/=3,-/9<<8/--=/9352-/ :33;/ .5/7.2/ -=.;5E.=5/38D.283.8C/&<<8732/E3=7/<G/7-9352-/ :33;/ B<,2J/ 9-83=7-82/ 7-/ 86FA-.7/ 33=E.-=:.>Bs/ -@A2-8J/ .=/ &-:42\&/ D:.>42/ 7-E-;-:.>BC/ &-/ 86FA-.7/ E<6/ -.;-=:.>B/ 33=/ 7-/ A3=7/ 93=/ 7-/ ;8<<22-/ 93=/ A-2D<7-,,32-8.33:J/ .=/ @<,D.=32.-/ ,-2/ 7-/ 7.-G2-J/ G:3325-:.>B/ ,<-2-=/ F<87-=6.2;-8-B-=7/ 9<<8732/ 7-/ &-:42\&P"*OH/ ,<76:-/ F<872/ 7<<8:<G-=C/ I.-8,--/ F<8729<<8B<,-=/732/7-/9<<834/<G;-:-;7-/86FA-.7/7-/528<,.=;/D-W=9:<-72/-=/7338,--/A-25-7.,-=2283=5G<82J/ 2-8F.>:/ 7-/ 86FA-.7/ 34A3=B-:.>B/ .5/ 93=/ 7-/ D<7-,7.-G2-/ -=D<7-,,32-8.33:C

-. )-85@A.>=5-:-=/<G/7-/9352-/:33;&<<8/7-/B-6E-/.=/[email protected]/93=/5-7.,-=2283=5G<82/<9-8/7-/9352-/:33;/<=25233=/-8/=6/.=7-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/3:5/A-2/F38-/ q:<G-=7-/D6:2-=r/ <G/7-/ 9352-/ :33;C/&-E-/;-9-=/,-2=3,-/ .=/ A-2/ D<9-=33=E.@A2/ -=/ 7-/ :3=;57<<85=-7-/ 93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ :<B33:/ --=9-82-B-=7/-=/765/<=>6.52/D--:7C/'-=/33=G355.=;/A.-8<G/E3:/=.-2/7-/F-8B.=;/93=/7-5.,6:32.-/ 93=/ --=/ 9352-/ :33;/ 9-8D-2-8-=J/,338/F-:/ --=/ 8-[:-8/ D--:7/ ;-9-=/ 93=/ 7-D<7-,A<<;2-/2-8/A<<;2-/93=/7-/9352-/:33;C

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

Page 125: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics 1 0 – 5

-. S-8-B-=.=;-=/,-2/938.[8-=7-/349<-8&-/ D-8-B-=.=;-=/ E.>=/ 6.2;-9<-87/ 9<<8/ --=/ @<=523=2-/ 349<-8C/ R=/ F-8B-:.>BA-.7/ E3:7-E-/349<-8/=.-2/@<=523=2/E.>=/-=/9<<8/7-/A3=7/:.;2/<,/D-5233=7-/D-8-B-=.=;-=/,-2--=/M;-5@A-,32.5--87-N/349<-8/=3/2-/8-B-=-=C/'-=/;8<<2/9-85@A.:/.=/7-/D<7-,/F<872=.-2/ 9-8F3@A2C/&-/A-852-:2.>7/ 93=/ D3;;-8-=/ -=/ 52<82-=/ B3=/ 7<<8/ --=/ 3=7-8-/ 349<-833=E.-=:.>B/F<87-=/D-W=9:<-7/-=/<=7-8E<-B/A.-8=338/F<872/73=/<<B/33=D-9<:-=/9<<8--=/9-89<:;5267.-C

<4+-!!$&."&-. )-85@A.::-=7-/@<=4.;6832.-5/93=/<G:<55.=;-=

&-/ <G:<55.=;-=/ E.>=/ 34A3=B-:.>B/ 93=/ 7-/ ;-B<E-=/ 7.,-=5.-5C/ R=/ 7-E-/ 7.,-=5.-5/ .5-@A2-8/--=/938.32.-/,<;-:.>BJ/F32/A-2/-44-@2/93=/7-/<G:<55.=;/B3=/D-W=9:<-7-=C/V-2=3,-/7-/B-6E-/D.>/A-2/;-:-.7-:.>B/9-85,3::-=/@CpC/9-8D8-7-=/93=/7-/9352-/ :33;/B3==<;3:/ F32/ .=9:<-7/ A-DD-=C/ '9-=E</ B3=/ 7-/ :-=;2-/ 93=/ 7-/ 9-8:-=;.=;/ F<87-=;-938.--87/-=/F338,--/ .=9:<-7/<G/7-/D<7-,:.;;.=;/B3=/F<87-=/6.2;-<-4-=7C/'-=<G2.,3:.532.-/93=/7-/9-85@A.::-=7-/<G:<55.=;-=/F<872/73=/<<B/52-8B/33=D-9<:-=C

-. ?<,D.=32.-5/93=/<G:<55.=;-='-=/ <G2.,3:.532.-/ 93=/ 7-/ <G:<55.=;-=/ B3=/ D-5233=/ 6.2/ --=/ @<,D.=32.-/ 93=<G:<55.=;-=/ <,/ --=/ ;<-7/ @<,G8<,.5/ 2-/ 9.=7-=/ 2655-=/ 7-/ 9-85@A.::-=7-,<;-:.>BA-7-=C/ I-2/ D-8-B-=-=/ 93=/ 9-85@A.::-=7-/ @<,D.=32.-5/ 93=/ 7-/ ,<;-:.>B-<G:<55.=;-=/.5/33=/2-/D-9-:-=C

-. Q.-2/;-5.,6:--87-/<G:<55.=;-=Q.-2/3::-/<G:<55.=;-=/7.-/E.>=/9-8,-:7/.=/G383;8334/dC0/E.>=/,-2/D-A6:G/93=/&-:42\&D-8-B-=7C/ V-2/ =3,-/ 9<<8/ D<7-,5@A-8,-=/ -=/ --=/ 9<82-Y/ -Y@:67-8/ .5/ --=/ =37-8<=7-8E<-B/ 93=/ A-2/ -44-@2/ <G/ 7-/ 5-7.,-=232.-D6:2/ F-=5-:.>BJ/ D.>9<<8D--:7/ ,-233=96::-=7-/ D-8-B-=.=;-=/ M9<<8/ 7-/ D<7-,5@A-8,-=N/ -=/ ,-2/ --=/ 4L5.5@A/ ,<7-:M9<<8/7-/9<82-Y/-Y@:67-8NC/&-E-/<G:<55.=;-=/E<8;-=/9<<8/--=/A-89-87-:.=;/93=/A-25-7.,-=2/ <9-8/ 7-/ 8.9.-8/ -=/ B6==-=/ F3385@A.>=:.>B/ ,-2/ =3,-/ .=/ Q.>,-;-=/ F338D-=-7-=528<<,5/;--=/2-;-=;-52-:7-/D<@A2/33=F-E.;/.5J/--=/<G:<55.=;/D.-7-=C

-. O=2;8<=7.=;55:-64&-/7.-G2-/ 93=/7-/ <=2;8<=7.=;55:-64/F<872/ D.>/ ;--=/93=/7-/ <G:<55.=;-=/9-8D-2-87CI.-89<<8/ 7.-=2/ --852/ 2-/F<87-=/<=7-8E<@A2/ A<-/ ;8<<2/ 7-/ B3=5/ <G/ .=52<82-=/ 93=/ 7-9352-/ :33;/ .5/ .=/ E.>7-:.=;5-/ 8.@A2.=;C/i-:45/ D.>/ A-2/ ;-7--:2-:.>B/ .=52<82-=XF-;E3BB-=93=/ 7-/ 9352-/ :33;/ D:.>42/ 7-/ F-8B.=;J/ E<3:5/ 6.2/ 7-/ 3=3:L2.5@A-/ D-8-B-=.=;-=/ D:--BJ9<:7<-=7-C/&<<8/D.>9<<8D--:7/528-B73,,-=/.=/33=5:6.2.=;/<G/7-/B8.DD-=/2-/G:3325-=B3=/ --=/ ;-:-.7-:.>B-8/ 528<,.=;5D--:7/ F<87-=/ ;-@8-[-87J/ 7.2/ D.-72/ F3385@A.>=:.>BG:3325-:.>B/--=/9-8D-2-8.=;/93=/7-/D<7-,C/&-/[email protected]/A.-893=/B3=/.=/--=/=37-8<=7-8E<-B/F<87-=/;-3=3:L5--87C

Page 126: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

1 0 – 6 WL | Delft Hydraulics

Page 127: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de Waal Q3074 mei 2002Afstudeerverslag

WL | Delft Hydraulics L i t . – 1

Literatuur

!:GA-=J/TC/93=J/#,-7-5/(CJ/^bbbJ/0#3$"!2'`(`3`2#"2",-!$"2&((!'2#"23(!'"2+((.2K'`20&#,$"!J/,-,<J/!P)*PbbC\\bJ(H#J/&OQ

S38=-9-:7/ICTCJ/QC/#286.B5,3J/^bb\/?-#"%9,$))"&2D((+)-65'2^,+"6-%2J2@$36-%J)","9"&$&."&23--,2*$'),"$#$&.)-#"%9,$))"&3"+#J/9-85:3;/8-B-=<=7-8E<-B/m^c1`J/H*/!/&-:42/IL7836:.@5

S38=-9-:7J/ICTCJ/^bb`J/0#3$"!2)-#"%9,$))"&2^,+"6-%J/D68-365267.-/m^ecaJ/H*/!/&-:42/IL7836:.@5S833B/HC'CHC/93=/7-=J/!C]C]C/$-8,-5J/011^F2?-#"%5",!'"+2&(2)(..","&2$&2#"2D((+F25((+)((,5"$#!'*#$"J

](``1J/IU)S8.=B-J/HCSCVC/2-=J/0111J/K"#$%"&'5*$!5-*#$&.2@$=&'(99"&J/$%/&-:42J/]!O/?68565/,<7-8=-/8.9.-8B6=7-/^e/G;CJ

V(`&<6D-=J/QCJ/^bbcJ/\&"+4*&'"&(&(+1!"2D((+2J20&(+1!"23(&2!65""43((,'9&"+4*&'"&2-42#"2?-3"&J@$=&2"&2D((+_

-4+-!!$&.!,$65'$&."&J/=<23/bcC11cJ/(H#J/(Ri!&<6D-=J/QCJ/^bbdJ/?-#"%9,$))"&2$&2#"2D((+2)$=2^,+"6-%2J20&(+1!"23(&2-4!'*8$&.2"&251#,(*+$!65"

)-#"%,*85"$#J/83GG<82/bdC1c1J/(H#J/(Ri!&<6D-=J/QCJ/(/93=/7-8/)--=J/011^J/0&(+1!"2<E@23",5(&.+$=&2D((+F2B"'5-#"2"&24,-6"#*,"23--,2)","9"$&.23(&

5"'2?(..",2@"/","&'$"27+(92S?@7VJ/(Ri!/83GG<82/011^C10eJ/R#SQ/b1\abc\e01J/(H#J/(Ri!'-87-=J/IC!C]CJ/^bbcJ/a,-="6'4+(&23(!'"2+((.2K'`20&#,$"!2J2#"'($+-&'8",42"&2)"!'"9!3--,)","$#$&."&J/83GG<82/!P

)*Pbc111/X/HP#!Pbc10^J/(H#J/&OQ'-87-=J/IC!C]CJ/011^J/a,-="6'23(!'"2+((.2K'`20&#,$"!J/S-5:.57<@6,-=2/6.29<-8.=;5435-J/(H#J/&OQ'55-=J/TC!C"CJ/^beeJ/<&#",I-"92&((,23",(&#",$&.2$&2)-#"%,*85"$#2'"&2."3-+."23(&2#"2)-65'3",)"'",$&.23(&2#"

D((+2'"2X$=%"."&J/=<23/eeC10bJ/(H#J/&.-=52/D.==-=F32-8-=/X/(Ri!I<,D-8;-=J/)CJ/-2/3:CJ/^bbcJ/?-65'3",)"'",$&.2K'`20&#,$"!F23(!'"2+((.2S3--,JV-&'8",4F2DJK0JbUPMMF2?:DK0J

bUPPOJ/7-4.=.2.-4/9<<8<=2F-8GJ/(H#J/&OQT3=5-=J/]C]AC/-2/3:CJ/^bdbJ/a,$&6$4+"!2-/2@$3",2"&.$&"",$&.2J2'5"2&-&J'$#(+2(++*3$(+2,$3",J/R#SQ/1P0d\P1^^\bP^J

*<=7<=f/].2,3=

U33.>J/$C/93=/7-8J/^bb`F2D((+)-65'2X$=%"."&2J2K',-%$&.!8"",!'(&#23(!'"2+((.J/D68-365267.-/m^e1aJ/H*/!/&-:42IL7836:.@5

U.GG-85:6.>5J/TC$C(CJ/0111J/?"!+$!#-6*%"&'2*$'3-",$&.!/(!"2?"!'"92<XJOPNF2?(..",4,-.,(%%(2>bbbJD-5:.57<@6,-=2J/S3;PbbP^beJ/(H#P&OQ

U:3355-=J/+CTCJ/?CTC/#:<44J/0111J/7--,!4"++$&.2)-#"%+$..$&.2"&25",!'"+,"+('$"!23--,2)(..","&2-42#"2D((+2J""&3-*#$."2,"+('$"!2"&2)"&-#$.#2-&#",I-"9J/83GG<82/m0aabJ/H*/!/&-:42/IL7836:.@5

U<<:F.>BJ/TCJ/^bb0J/<E@2c>bb>`PdF2)"4(+$&.23(&2#"2<3",""&."9-%"&2E(."2@$3$",!'(&#2S<E@V2>bb>`P23--,2#"@$=&'(99"&J/(3GG<82=6,,-8/!QRR/^bb0C^J/(H#J/[email protected]/+-:7-8:3=7

U<<LJ/!CJ/VC/$33:J/^bbdJ/C1#,(*+$!65"2"&2%-,/-+-.$!65"2%-&$'-,$&.2)-#"%9,$))"&2^,+"6-%2J20&(+1!"2"&"3(+*('$"2]P2"&2]>J/83GG<82/9-8.5-\C1/SPHSPbd11^J/(H#J/&OQ

U8--B-/]CHCJ/^bbaJ/:"'($+J-&'8",423(!'"2+((.2K'`20&#,$"!F2D((+4,-="6'F23(!'"2+((.2K'`20&#,$"!J/7-23.:P<=2F-8GJ!P)*Pba111J/I35B<=.=;J/U<=.=B:.>B/R=;-=.-685P/-=/[email protected]@2-=D68-36

U86.2F3;-=J/]C+CJ/^bbdJ/a,-="6'4+(&2)(..","&J/9-85.-/^C1J/HPS+Pbd10aJ/(H#J/&OQU86.2F3;-=J/]C+CJ/&C/93=/7-8/+8334J/^bbdJ/a,-="6'&-'(2D((+2J23",#$"4$&.2"&23",),"#$&.23(&2#"23((,8".2'*!!"&

#"2a(&&",#"&!65"2\-42"&2e(+')-%%"+J/G8<>-@2=<23/SPU#Pba1^cJ/(H#J/&OQ*3,D--B/TCTC]CJ/'C/V<55-:,3=J/^bbeJ2C*$#$."2"&25$!'-,$!65"2,$3$",9*&#$."24(,(%"'",!23(&2#"2X"#",+(&#!"

@$=&'(99"&J/9-85:3;/D68-365267.-/m0\e0J/H*/!/&-:42/IL7836:.@5O<52-8A<4J/#CJ/0111J/K$&.+")"(%23",!*!2B*+'$)"(%J/^"&2-&#",I-"92&((,2#"23",!65$++"&2$&25--.'"+$..$&.23(&2#"

,$3$",)-#"%2'*!!"&2""&2!$&.+")"(%J2"&2%*+'$)"(%2"65-+--#J/<=7-8E<-B583GG<82J/(H#P&OQ/347C/!QR]8<>-@2D68-36/H33:J/^bb\J/]-"9-%!'3$!$"2D((+25--/#',(&!4-,'(!J/Q<23/RRR/-.=783GG<823;-J/(H#J/&[email protected]

+-:7-8:3=7#@A-G,3=J/"C'CJ/011^J/B-,/-+-.$"23(&2#"2B$##"&JD((+2I-&#",2"&2%"'2)(..","&2J2]-"'!$&.23(&

3--,!4"++$&.!%"'5-#"2%"'20,67$"8J/345267--8<=7-8E<-B/m0d\`J/H*/!/&-:42/IL7836:.@5

Page 128: Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen ... - TU Delft

mei 2002 Q3074 Morfologische problemen rond bochtverbeteringen in de WaalAfstudeerverslag

L i t . – 2 WL | Delft Hydraulics

#:<44J/?CTCJ/011^J/B-,/-+-.$!65"2!'*#$"2?<K2?(..","&2%"'2:"+/'M:J@$3$",""&J/9-85:3;/G383::-:5267.-J/H*/!/&-:42IL7836:.@5

#286.B5,3J/QCJ/^becJ/D((+)-65'2X$=%"."&2J2-&#",I-"9F2$&2#"25*$#$."2!$'*('$"F2&((,25"'2"//"6'23(&2""&2W+(&."L3(!'"2+((.2-42#"2)-#"%+$..$&.J/=<23/8-B-=,<7-:<=7-8E<-B/V/^0de/7--:/)R/X/(/0^\bJ/H*/!/&-:42IL7836:.@5

#286.B5,3J/QCJ/^beaJ/D((+)-65'2X$=%"."&2J2((&3*++"&#2-&#",I-"92&((,25"'2"//"6'23(&2""&2W+(&."L23(!'"2+((.2-4#"23((,."*+),""#'"J/9-85:3;/,<7-:<=7-8E<-B/V/^0de/7--:/)J/H*/!/&-:42/IL7836:.@5

#286.B5,3J/QCJ/^bbdJ/G*,!*!2MJ:2B-,/-+-.$"J/H*/!/&-:42/IL7836:.@5/X/$-@A=.5@A-/%=.9-85.2-.2/&-:42#286.B5,3J/QCJ/^bbbJ/B('5"%('$6(+2%-#"++$&.2-/2)"#+-(#2',(&!4-,'2-3",2&-&J",-#$)+"2+(1",!J/R!I(/#L,G<5.6,

(.9-8J/?<3523:/3=7/-52638.=-/,<8GA<7L=3,.@5J/+-=<93J/R23:.[J/)<:C/RJ/G;C/ebPbeC#286.B5,3J/QCJ/!C/?8<532<J/^bebJ/0&(+1!$!2-/2(2MJ:2)"#2'-4-.,(4512%-#"+2/-,2,$3",!J/.=f/(.9-8/,-3=7-8.=;J

!+%J/H32-8/(-@<68@-5/V<=<;83GALJ/)<:/^0J/H35A.=;2<=/&C?C#286.B5,3J/QCJ/?C/":<B5283J/UCHC/O:5-=J/ICTC/7-/)8.-=7J/^be`J/?"#2#"/-,%('$-&2$&26*,3"#2(++*3$(+265(&&"+!J/.=f

T<68=3:/<4/IL7836:.@/(-5-38@AJ/9<:/0\J/^becJ/=<C/^J/G;C/cdPdb#286.B5,3J/QCJ/&CIC/H.:B-=5J/TC+CIC/S8-,-8J/^bbcJ/:"2D((+2)$=2K'`20&#,$"!2J27((,8".3",)"'",$&.2#--,

((&),"&."&23(!'"2+((.J/33=96::-=7-/(.9@<,/D-8-B-=.=;-=/m^bdeJ/H*/!/&-:42/IL7836:.@5#286.B5,3J/QCJ/VCVC/*3;6EE.J/TC+CIC/S8-,,-8J/^bb`J/@$3",2D((+2('2K$&'20&#,$"!2J2f%4,-3"%"&'2-/2'5"

&(3$.()$+$'126-&#$'$-&!2)12%"(&!2-/2(2/$["#2+(1",J/(.9@<,/@<,G6232.<=5/m^deeJ/H*/!/&-:42IL7836:.@5

#2668;8<-G/H33:J/^bbc/3J/7(!'"2+((.2)-65'2K'`20&#,$"!A2!65"'!-&'8",4J/5@A-25<=2F-8GJ/!P)*Pbc1c`/MHP?+Pbc10dJ/HP#+Pbc1^bNJ/(H#J/&OQ

#2668;8<-G/H33:J/^bbcDJ/?"!+$!#-6*%"&'2(+'",&('$"3"2%((',"."+"&2'",23",)"'",$&.23(&25"'23((,8".4,-/$"+2$&2#")-65'2K'`20&#,$"!J/S-5:.57<@6,-=2/#2C/!=78.-5/HP?+Pbc11\J/HP#+Pbc11aJ/(H#

#F3=-=D-8;J/$CJ/IC/I39.=;3J/VCICRC/#@A8<GGJ/VC/S<-85J/^bb^J/D((+25--/#',(&!4-,'(!2,$3$",9*&#$."%((',"."+"&J/=<23/}/D.>:3;-=/(Ri!b^C1\1/+*&b^X1\J/(H#J/(Ri!J/&[email protected]/+-:7-8:3=7

$33:J/VCJ/^bb`J/<&'8$99"+$&.2!6"&(,$-d!2(*'-&-%"2)-#"%-&'8$99"+$&.2D((+J/=<23/b`C1a0J/(H#J/(Ri!$33:J/VCJ/^bbeJ/?-#"%9,$))"&2^,+"6-%2J27((,)((&),""#'"J/,-,</HPS+Pbe1`dJ/(H#J/&OQ$3=BJ/"C$C+CJ/^bbe3J/<&'.,-&#$&."&2)$=23(!'"2+((.2)-65'2)$=2K'`20&#,$"!2SD((+VJ/,-,<J/(H#J/&OQ$3=BJ/"C$C+CJ/^bbeDJ/7",!+(.2)$=""&9-%!'23(&2"[4",'!2-3",2-&'.,-&#$&.!4,-)+"%('$"923(!'"2+((.2)-65'2)$=2K'`

0&#,$"!2SD((+VJ/,-,<J/(H#J/&OQ

$-8F-:J/*CJ/!C/)-8F-LJ/^bbeJ/^//"6'"&2)-#"%9,$))"&2^,+"6-%J/83GG<82/m/0`0bJ/H*/!/&-:42/IL7836:.@5)8.-=7J/ICTC/7-J/0111J/@$3$",8('",)-*89*&#"J/@<::-;-7.@2332/?$F3\\`1J/$-@A=.5@A-/%=.9-85.2-.2/&-:42J/"3@6:2-.2

7-8/?.9.-:-/$-@A=.-B)8.-5J/(C/7-J/011^J/K$&.+")"(%23",!*!2B*+'$)"(%F2"&$."2-4%",9$&."&2&((,2((&+"$#$&.23(&25"'2,(44-,'

K$&.+")"(%23",!*!2B*+'$)"(%J/,-,</93=/0`/>3=638./011^J/(H#J/&OQ)668-=J/HC'C/93=J/0111F27",."+$=9$&.2)-#"%4"$+$&."&2K$&.+")"(%gB*+'$)"(%2?-3"&,$=&JD((+2=*+$2-9'-)",

>bbbJ/F-8B7<@6,-=2/0111Cb`YJ/(H#J/(Ri!H.:D-85J/!CHC'CJ/0111J/?-#"%',(&!4-,'2&((!'23(!'"2+((.2K'`20&#,$"!2J2C((+)((,5"$#2:*&"2],(9$&.2$&

)-65'!$'*('$"!J/83GG<82J/%=.9-85.2-.2/%28-@A2J/93B;8<-G/"L5.5@A-/+-<;834.-H.:D-85J/!CHC'CJ/HCSCVC/2-=/S8.=B-J/^bbbJ/:"3"+-4%"&'2-/2!*)(h*"-!2#*&"!2$&2'5"2@5$&"2(&#2D((+F2'5"

X"'5",+(&#!`2024,"+$%$&(,12&-'"J/G;C\1\P\^0J/R?+/X/(H#J/(Ri!

H.:B-=5J/&CICJ/^bdbJ/?-65'3",)"'",$&.23(&2#"2D((+2)$=2K'`20&#,$"!J/9-85:3;/,<7-:<=7-8E<-B/V^0c^J/H*/!&-:42/IL7836:.@5

H<:2-85J/!C"CJ/^bbeJ/)352-/:33;/D.>/Q.>,-;-=/P@35-P5267L/.=/A-2/B37-8/93=/B-==.5<=2F.BB-:.=;/0&P,<84<:<;.-J83GG<82/beC1ceJ/(H#J/(Ri!