;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0...

43

Transcript of ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0...

Page 1: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

����� ����� ����� ����� ������� � ���������� � ���� ��"!��#�$���%�� ���'&(������*)+���,�-(��� ���/.10�� �����32 �����4 56�,��� 7�8����-�,�������� �9�,�:�

;=<:>@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK�CMLONP�Q�RTS=U�VWQ RYXEZ(Q�[�\]Z^XMU(_`Z^U�a�bcU�adU�Q efZgS�hi_jakRYXMRYl=RTU$mon�U(eTp$U�[MU(q$msrutwv

x <:>BF+yuADCE?Bz({j<:>B?uN|�U(}jQ eYRTV~U�_�R-� ��\$R�Q�RTXEadRTX�Z(a^mo�,r�n�U�eTp$U([�U(q

� FjADFj>B��FH���-;j�jFjFj?|�U(}jQ eYRTV~U�_�R-� ��\$R�Q�RTXEadRTX�Z(a^mo�,r�n�U�eTp$U([�U(q

�DU�ZgSo_=XEZ(Q�[�eYU(}j��eTR����$����m���l=_=U�������

���$�$���T���@���$�,���$�*�g�Y�d =�$¡o���*¡=�^��¢\]Q _j£�eYXM_=U|¤l`£���X�R

|�U(}jQ eYRTV~U�_�R-� ��\$R�Q�RTXEadRTX�Z(a��_=XM¥$U(efakX�Rkq�����ruQ�[MX¦�§��eT_oXEQ�mjn�U�eTp$U([�U(q

n�U�eTp$U([�U(q$m�rut©¨ ªs����� «­¬�®����¯$°�±o²s³µ´�±µ¶¸·=¯�¹µ°�¹�º¼»=¶¸³$½=¶�¾$¶�¿cºk¶¸²$À

ÁÃÂ�Ä �T���Å$Æ]Ç Ä �$�T����$¡�Ç­�^ÈEÉ(Æ$Çd�Y�Ê�YË�Æ�Å�Ì�̦Í�Ç­�ÎÇ Ä ÈÏ�Ð��$�TÑ$Ò

Ó

Page 2: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

ÔJÕ�Ö(LDA�<@�jL

t×eYU([MX�Q Ø=[�U�Q _j£~}=eYU�Z^X�akU�Z^[�Q�aYakXÏÙµZ(Q RYXM��_W����RYl=V~��efa�X�a�U�aTadU(_�RYXEQ�[µ�§��e�adljZ(Z^UÚaTa¼�§lo[�RTeYU�Q RYV~U(_sR-� �OZ(Q _jZ*U(e(vZ(|ÜÛÝtÞV~XEZ*eT�$Q�eTefQÚqoa�Q _j£ßS=XMà�S=«­£�U(_jadXMRdqá��[MX�à���_sljZ^[�U(��RYXE£�UâZ�S=XM}jaQ eYU"_o� ¥$U�[�Ø=X���RTUÚZgS=_o��[M��à�X�U�a,ãcS=X�ZgSQ eYUWصU�XM_=à�ljadU�£äX�_jZ^eYU�Q�adXM_=à�[MqåXM_ßZ(Q�_jZ^U(e�eYU�akUÚQ e�Z�SDvÃn�q+Q�[M[M��ãcX�_=à�RTS=UWV~��_=XMRY��eYXM_=à�� �ÝU(æ�}oeTU�aYakXM��_[MU�¥$U([Ea��§��eÜRTS=��ljaTQ�_j£=aÜ� �uà�U(_=U�aÜadXMVçl=[MRfQ _=U���ljad[Mq$moakljZ�SèRYU�ZgSo_=XEé$l=U�a�VWQ(qW[MUÚQ�£"RY�WQ�V~��eTUZ^��V~}=[MU�RTUl=_j£sU(e�adR�Q _`£�XM_=àÝ� ��RTS=UuV~��[�U�Z^l=[�Q eD¥�Q eYXEQ�RTXM��_ja�Q�V~��_=à�RTloV~��efaBQ�_j£wS=U(_jZ*U�RT�êQëÙj_=U(e:Q _`£ìV~��eTU-XM_s�§��eT«VWQ�RTXM¥$UÝZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙ�Z�Q RTX���_Dv-��SoU�Q ØoXM[MX�Rdq�RY�~adljZ(Z^U�aYa¼�§l=[�[Mqâ£�XEadRTX�_=à�l=X�akSWØjU(Rdã�U(U�_~RTl=Vâ��e�Z^[�Q�aTadU�aÜíiQ�[MeYU�Q�£�qps_=��ãc_+��e�q$U(R�RY�èØjU�£�XEaYZ^��¥$U(eTU�£jîcljakX�_=à�à�U�_=U~U(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_ã=Q RfQèXEaQ _ßXMV~}j��eTR�Q�_�RQ�ak}jU�Z^R�����RTS=X�a_=��¥$U([ïQ }=}=eY�$Q�ZgS�RT�âZ(Q _jZ*U(ecZ^[�Q�aYakXÏÙµZ(Q RYXM��_ïv

hi_�RTS=X�aB}jQ�}µU�e(m$ã�U�Z^��V~}jQ�eTU�RYS=Uc}jU(ek�§��eTVWQ�_jZ^Uc���D£sXÏð�U(eTU�_�R-£sXEaTZ*eTXMVâXM_jQ�RTXM��_�V~U(RTSo�s£=aï�§��e-RTS=U�Z^[�Q�aYakXM«Ù�Z(Q�RTX���_W� �-RYl=V~��e�a�Ø`Q�akUÚ£"��_Wà�U(_=U�U(æs}=eTU�aYakX���_�£=Q RfQ�vu��S=U�adU,VâU(RTS=�s£oa�XM_jZ^[�lj£�U ¢ _=U�Q�eTU�adRc_=U(XMà�S�Øj��eZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙjU�e�a^mj[MX�_=U�Q�eÜ£�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ _sRcQ�_jQ [�q=adXEa*mDQ _j£åZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙ�Z�Q RTX���_�RTeTU�U�a^vÝh¼_���l=e�Z^��V~}jQ�eTXEad��_Dmjã�UJQ [�ak�Z^��_jakX�£�U(e�eTU�Z^U�_�RcVWQ�ZgSoXM_=UÜ[�U�Q eY_=XM_oà~Q�}=}=eT�¸Q�Z�S=U�aÜadljZ�S�Q�acØjQ�à�à�X�_=à�Q _j£èØj�$�¸akRTX�_=à=vÜñåU�XM_s¥$U�akRYXMà¸Q RTURTSoU"l`akUW� �Ý}=eTUÚ£�XEZ^RYXM��_+¥$��RYU�awRT�åQ�aTakUÚaTa�RTS=U�Z^��_�Ù�£�U(_`Z^U~� �êU�Q�Z�S+}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTXM��_Dv+��SoU"VâU(RTS=�s£oawQ eYUQ }o}=[MX�U�£~RT�ç£=Q�R�Q�adU(R�ac�§eT��VòRTS=eYU(UÜeTUÚZ^U(_sRT[Mqç}=l=Øo[MXEadS=U�£~Z�Q _jZ^U�ecà�U(_=U�U(æs}=eYU�aTadXM��_�adRTlj£�X�U�a^v

ó F={@ô~K�AD?@Ö=õ |¤X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ _sRuQ _jQ�[MqoakXEa*ö=VWQ�Z�S=X�_=U¤[�U�Q eY_=XM_oà=ö=¥�Q eYXEQ Øo[MUakU([�U�Z^RYXM��_ïö�V~X�Z^eT�¸Q eTefQ(q�U(æs}jU(eT«XMVâU(_�R�ö$Z(Q�_jZ^U(e�ö=RTl=V~��ecZ^[�Q�aYa^v

Page 3: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

÷ ø ���:�-�"!�0��u������

tÞeYU([MX�Q Ø=[�U~Q�_j£+}=eTU�Z*XEakUâZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙ�Z�Q RTX���_ß� ��RYl=V~��e�a,X�a,U�aYakU(_sRTX�Q [-�§��eçakl`Z(Z^U�aYa¼�§l=[-RTeYU�Q RYV~U(_sR�� �êZ(Q _=«Z^U(e�v�r-l=eYeTU(_sR-V~U(RYS=�s£=aO�§��ecZ^[�Q�aYakXÏ�§qsXM_oà,Ssl=VWQ�_�VÎQ [MX�à�_jQ�_jZ^X�U�aBeTU�[Mqw��_WQw¥�Q eYXMU(Rdqw���@V~��eY}=S=��[M��à�XEZ(Q�[imZ^[�XM_=X�Z(Q [­m=Q _`£ùV~��[MU�Z*l=[EQ�e�¥�Q eYXEQ Øo[MU�a*vÜhi_�ad}=XMRYU�� �-eYU�Z^U(_sR¤}oeT��à�eTU�aYa^m�RYS=U(eYU�Q eYUçakRYXM[M[Dlo_jZ^U(eYR�Q X�_�RYXMU�a�X�_£�X�Q à�_o�$akX�a^vuú=l=eTRYS=U(eTVâ��eTU¸m]X�R�X�a�[MXMp$U�[MqwRYSjQ R�RTSoUÜU(æsXEakRYXM_=àJZ^[EQ�aTadU�acQ eYU,SoU(RTU(eY��à�U(_=U(��ljacQ _j£�Z^��Vâ}=eTX�akU£�X�akU�Q�akU�a�ãcS=X�ZgS�Q�eTU�V~��[�U�Z^l=[�Q eY[Mqç£�X�akRTX�_jZ^R�Q _j£~�§��[M[���ã�£�X¦ð�U(eTU(_sR�Z^[�XM_=X�Z(Q [�Z^��l=e�adU�a^vuZ(|ÜÛÜtûV~XEZ^eY�$Q�eT«e�Q(qoa�Q _j£�S=XMà�S=«­£�U(_jadXMRdqè��[MXMà���_sljZ^[�U(��RYXE£�UçZ�S=XM}`aÜQ eYU�_=��¥$U([@Ø=X���RTUÚZgS=_o��[M��à�X�U�a¤ãcS=X�ZgSåQ�eTUçصU�XM_=àWljadU�£XM_`Z^eTU�Q�akX�_=à�[�q,X�_çZ(Q _`Z^U(e@eTU�adU�Q efZgS�üý��m$¬sm Ó �¸m$��¬=m$��ª=m$����þiv:n�qwQ�[M[�� ãcX�_=àÜRYS=UcV~��_oXMRT��eTX�_=à¤����U(æ�}oeTU�aYakXM��_[MU�¥$U([Ea��§��e�RYS=��ljaYQ _j£oaë���@à�U(_=UÚacakXMVçl=[�R�Q _oU(��ljad[Mqâü Ó m Ó �=m Ó ¬=m Ó ¨�m=��®=ms��¨�þimoakljZ�SçRTU�Z�S=_=X�é]l=UÚaOVÎQÚq[MU�Q�£RT�ÎQ�V~��eYU�Z^��V~}=[�U(RTUÜlo_j£�U(efakR�Q�_j£�X�_=àW� �uRTS=UV~��[�U�Z^l=[�Q ec¥�Q eYXEQ�RTXM��_jaÜQ�V~��_=àâRTl=V~��e�a�Q _j£�S=U(_`Z^UwRY�Q"Ùj_=U�e�Q _`£HVâ��eTUçeTU�[MXEQ�Ø=[MUâZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙ�Z�Q RTX���_DvÊh¼_ßRYS=U~ã���e�£=aw���Ýt¤[MX�ÿ�Q�£sU(S �fÇwÅ�Ì�Ò ü � þ ¢�� hi_j£�U(UÚ£�mBRYS=U_=U(ã V~U(RYS=�s£=aÜ� ��à�U(_=UçU(æ�}oeTU�aYakXM��_á}oeT� Ù`[MXM_oà�Z(Q�[M[B�§��e�Q~eTU(¥sXEadU�£å£�U^Ùj_=X�RTX���_å� �cãcS`Q RwX�a�£�U(U(V~UÚ£�Q� £sXEakUÚQ�akU � v����S=UÜãuU�Q [�RTSç� �@à�U(_=UÜU(æs}=eYU�aTadXM��_â£=Q�R�Qw_=��ãûQ(¥�Q XM[�Q Ø=[�U¤}j�¸akU�a-_�l=VâU(eT��lja-akR�Q�RTX�akRTX�Z(Q [�é$l=U�adRTXM��_ja�efQ _=à�«XM_oàÎ�§eY��V RTS=UâQ _jQ�[MqoakX�aê���cX�VWQ à�U�aë}oeT�s£�ljZ*U�£ùØsq�V~X�Z^eT�¸Q eTefQ(q"U�æ�}jU(eYXMV~U(_sR�acQ�_j£�RTS=UçadRTlj£�q����cRYS=U¥�Q eYXEQ ØoXM[MX�Rdqä���V~U�Q�adl=eTUÚ£ à�U(_=U�U�æ�}=eYU�aTadXM��_�[MU(¥$U([�aWü Ó�Ó mc����þim¤RY�+RTSoUáU([�ljZ^X�£=Q RYXM��_1� �JØ=XM�sZ�S=U(V~X�Z(Q [}jQ�RTSsãcQ(q=a*v��¤U�eTU�ã�U��§�sZ^lja¤��_�RTS=UJZ^[EQ�aTakX¦Ù�Z(Q�RTXM��_è���-RTl=Vâ��e�acljadXM_=à~à�U(_=UU(æ�}oeTU�aYakXM��_�£=Q�R�QsvÜ��S=U(eYUQ eYUèRYS=eTU(U�VWQ X�_ßRkqs}jU�aw� �JadR�Q RYXEadRTXEZ�Q [�}=eT��Ø=[MU(VÎawQ�aYak�sZ^X�Q RYU�£ ãcX�RTS1RTl=V~��eçZ^[EQ�aTadXÏÙ�Z(Q�RTX���_ ¢ í§X î�RYS=UXE£sU(_�RYXÏÙ�Z�Q RTX���_å� ��_=U�ã��(l=_=ps_=��ãc_ßRTl=Vâ��e�Z*[EQ�aYakU�a�ljakX�_=àèà�U(_=U~U�æ�}=eYU�aTadXM��_+}=eT��Ùj[MUÚa,« �^Ì Æ¸�*Çd�*�WÅ$¡=Å�Ì�ÍÚ��ÈÏ���Æs¡]��Æ( j�*� ��ÈÏ���Y�ùÌM�YÅ$�*¡=ÈE¡�� mÜí X�X î�RTS=U�Z^[�Q�aYakXÏÙµZ(Q RYXM��_Ã� ��VWQ�[MX�à�_jQ�_jZ^XMUÚaêX�_�RY�èps_=��ãc_1Z^[EQ�aTakUÚaw« �$ÈÏ���(�*È���ÈE¡=Å$¡�ÇÅ$¡=Å�̦Í(��ÈÏ��=��ÆÚ j�*���(ÈÏ���Y��ÌM�YÅ$�*¡=ÈE¡�� muQ _j£�í§XMXMX§î�RTS=UWXE£sU(_�RYXÏÙ�Z�Q RTX���_å� � � VWQ�eTp$U(e��~à�U(_=UÚawRTSjQ�RZ�SjQ efQ�Z^RYU(eTX�ÿ(UÜRTSoU�£�X¦ð�U�eTU(_sR¤RYl=V~��e�Z^[EQ�aTakUÚaë« �(Å$�*ÈEÅ$É^ÌM������ÌM�Y�^Ç­ÈE�$¡ v�t¤_�l=_sljakljQ�[��§UÚQ RTloeTUw���-RTSoXEac_=U(ãRdq�}jUÜ���-£oQ R�QwX�a�RYS=UÜ¥$U(eYq�[EQ eYà�UÜ_sl=VçØjU(e-� �:¥�Q�eTX�Q Ø=[�U�a¤í§à�U(_=UÚagî�eYU([EQ�RTX�¥$U¤RY��RTS=UÜ_sl=VçØjU(e�� �:��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�«RTX���_jací§RTl=V~��e�aYQ V~}o[MU�a�î�ö�RYS=Uc}=l=Ø=[�XEZ^[�q�Q(¥�Q XM[�Q Ø=[�U�£=Q RfQ�adU(R�a-Z^l=eYeTU(_sRT[�qZ^��_sR�Q�XM_�à�U�_=UcU(æs}=eTU�aYakX���_ç£=Q�R�Q�§��e�sm ����� « Ó �sm �����èà�U(_oU�a¤��_å[MUÚaTa¤RYSjQ _ Ó ���Î��ØjakU�eT¥�Q RYXM��_`a^vçn���RYS�_�l=VçØjU(e�a�Q eYU�U(æs}µUÚZ^RTU�£WRT�Wà�eY��ã�mRTSoUw_sl=V�ØjU(eu� �-à�U(_=U�aceTUÚQ�Z�S=XM_=àâQ eY��l=_`£ Ó ���sm ������m@Q�_èU�adRTXMVÎQ RTU��§��eÜRYS=U�RT��RfQ [�_sl=VçØjU(e����-à�U(_oU�aëX�_RTSoU,Ssl=VWQ�_~à�U�_=��V~U¸v

bcU�Z^U(_sR-}=l=Ø=[�XEZ(Q�RTXM��_ja���_�Z(Q�_jZ^U(e�Z^[EQ�aTadXÏÙ�Z(Q�RTX���_WljakX�_=à�à�U�_=UÜU(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_W£oQ R�Q�SjQ(¥$UÜVWQ�XM_=[�qw�§�sZ^ljadU�£��_RTS=UOZ^[MljadRTU(e@Q�_jQ [�q=adXEa����=Øj��RYSwRYl=V~��eïaTQ�V~}=[MUÚa�Q _`£,à�U�_=U�a^m�Q�_j£,X�_jZ^[�lj£�U-Q�}=}=[MX�Z(Q RYXM��_ja�� �oS=XMU�e�Q efZgSoXM«Z(Q�[DZ^[�ljakRYU(eTX�_=à�V~U(RTSo�s£=aÜüý��ms¬=ms��¬=m=��ª=mo���=m=¬�� þïQ _j£~}jQ�eTRTX�RTX���_=X�_=àwV~U�RTS=�s£=a-adljZgSÎQ�acakU�[Ï�§«§��eTà¸Q _=X�ÿ(XM_oàVWQ�}ja�ü Ó ��þ­vB�ÝakXM_oà�Q�Z^loRTUc[MU�l=p$U(V~X�Q�aDQ�a�QÜRTU�adR�Z�Q�akU¸m�����[MloØ ��Ç:Å�ÌMÒ ü Ó ��þs[M�$��p$UÚ£wXM_sRT��ص��RTSçRTS=U�Z*[MljadRTU(eQ _`Q [MqoakX�aBQ�_j£wRTSoUc£�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ _sR�Q _jQ�[MqoakXEaD� ��RYl=V~��efa�ljakX�_=àÜà�U(_=U�U�æ�}=eYU�aTadXM��_w£oQ R�Qsv-ú=��e:Z^[MljadRTU(e@Q�_jQ [�«qoakXEa*m���e � Z^[EQ�aTaÜ£�X�aTZ^��¥$U(eYq��smDakU�[Ï�§«§��eTà¸Q _=X�ÿ(XM_oà~VWQ }`awík\��ÝPáîuã�U(eYUçQ }=}o[MXMUÚ£èRT�~RYS=U�à�U(_oU�U(æ�}oeTU�aYakXM��_£=Q�R�QWQ _j£�RTSoU�RTl=V~��e¤à�eT��l=}ja,eYU(¥$U�Q�[MU�£~ØsqèRTSoXEa¤V~U�RTS=�s£èãuU(eTUJZ^��V~}`Q eTUÚ£èRT�~ps_=��ãc_+Z*[EQ�aYakU�a*vwú=��e£�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ _sR�Q _jQ�[MqoakX�a^mD��e � Z*[EQ�aYaÜ}=eTU�£sXEZ^RYXM��_���m�����[�l=Ø ��ÇÜÅ�Ì�Ò }=eY��}j�$adU�£+Q~ã�U(X�à�SsRTU�£èà�U(_=U�¥$��RTXM_oàaTZ�S=U(VâU�ãcSoXEZ�S�RTl=eY_ja���l=RuRT��ØjU�Q,V~X�_=��e@¥�Q eTX�Q _sR-� �@Q�ad}µUÚZ^XEQ�[jZ(Q�adU¤���D[�XM_=U�Q�e-£�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ _sR@Q _jQ�[MqoakX�a�§��eV�lo[MRTX�¥�Q eTX�Q RYU�_=��eYVWQ [uZ^[�Q�aTa£�U(_jadXMRYXMU�a*vWt¤[MX�ÿ�Q�£�U�S ��ÇÅ�ÌMÒ üý� þuakRYlj£�XMUÚ£áà�U(_oU~U(æs}=eTU�aYakX���_+X�_áRYS=URTSoeTU(UçV~�$adR�}=eTU(¥�Q�[MU(_sRQ�£�l=[�Rw[�q�V~}oS=��X�£"VWQ�[MXMà�_jQ _`Z^XMU�a*v~��ãu�è}=eYU(¥�X���ljad[Mq�l=_oeTU�Z^��à�_=X�ÿ(U�£�Rdq�}jU�a�� �£�X¦ð�l`akU�[EQ eYà�U�n�«­Z^U([�[�[�q�Vâ}=S=��VÎQ�m�ãcXMRTSΣ�XEadRTXM_`Z^R-Z^[�XM_=X�Z(Q [=ØjU(S`QÚ¥sXM��e�a*m]ãuU(eTU�XE£sU(_�RYXÏÙjUÚ£,ØjQ�akU�£���_~à�U�_=UU(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_�£=Q�R�Q�vut¤¥$U(efQ à�UÜ[MX�_=p�Q à�U�S=X�U(e�Q�e�Z�S=XEZ�Q [DZ*[MljadRTU(eYXM_=àãcQ�acljadU�£"RY��XE£�U(_sRTX¦�§q�RYS=U�Rdã���RTloV~��eakloØ�Z*[EQ�aYakU�açQ�açã�U([�[cQ�a�RT�åà�eY��l=}�à�U(_=U�a�ãcXMRYS1akXMVâXM[EQ�ewU(æs}=eYU�aTadXM��_ß}jQ�RTRYU(eT_jaçQ�Z*eT�$aYaìRYS=U�£sXÏð�U(eTU�_�R

¬

Page 4: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

aTQ�V~}=[�U�a^vWbc�$aYa ��Ç�Å�ÌMÒ ü ����þ-ljakU�£ÃZ(|ÜÛÜt V~XEZ*eT�$Q�eTefQÚqoaÜRT�ÊakRTl`£�qáà�U(_=U~U�æ�}=eYU�aTadXM��_+XM_åRTS=UÎ����Z^U([�[[MX�_=U�a¤�§eT��V RYS=UWÛÜQ�RTX���_jQ�[¤ruQ _`Z^U(e�hi_jadRTX�RTl=RYU � a�Q _sRTX�«iZ�Q _jZ^U�ew£seTl=àåaYZ^eTU(U�_ í­Û,ruh����]îfv��¤X�U(e�Q�e�Z�S=XEZ(Q�[Z^[�ljakRYU(eTX�_=à�� �:RTS=U�Z*U([M[j[MX�_=U�a�ØjQ�akU�£~��_âà�U(_=UÝU(æ�}oeTU�aYakXM��_W£=Q�R�QweTU�¥$U�Q [�U�£�Q�Z*��eTeYU�ak}j��_j£�U(_jZ*UÜØjU(Rdã�U(U(_à�U�_=UwU(æs}=eYU�aTadXM��_ÊQ _j£èRYXEaYakl=U� �-��eTXMà�XM_�� �uRTS=URTl=Vâ��e�a*v��¤X�U(e�Q�e�Z�S=XEZ(Q�[DZ^[�ljakRYU(eTX�_=àçãcQ�aÝQ [Ead��l`akU�£èRY�à�eY��l=}�à�U(_oU�aëãcX�RTS�akX�V~XM[�Q e-U(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_W}jQ�RTRTU�eT_jacQ�Z^eT�¸aTa¤RYS=UZ^U([M[j[�XM_=U�a*v

��S=UWRTSoeTU(U~eYU�Z^U(_sR�adRTlj£sXMU�a��dljadRçZ^XMRYU�£åQ eTUWX�_jakRfQ _jZ^UÚaw� �êQùà�eT��ãcXM_=à�Øj�s£�qß���ÜeYU�akU�Q�e�Z�SDm�XM_ßãcS=X�ZgSà�U�_=UÜU(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_~}oeT� Ù`[MXM_oàwXEa-ljakUÚ£�RT�J£�XEadRTXM_oà�l=X�akS~ØjU(Rdã�U�U(_�ps_=��ãc_WRTl=Vâ��euZ^[EQ�aTadU�a�Q�_j£�RT��X�£�U(_sRTX¦�§q}=eYU(¥�X���ljad[Mqçl=_=eYU�Z^��à�_=XMÿ�U�£~Q _`£"Z*[MXM_oXEZ(Q�[M[MqçadXMà�_=XÏÙ�Z�Q _sRcakloØ�Z*[EQ�aYakU�ac� �:RTloV~��efa^v�hi_j£sU(U�£�m��¤��[Ml=Ø ��Ç�Å�ÌMÒü Ó �(þjZ*��_jZ^[�lj£�UcRYSjQ R � ��S=XEa�U(æs}jU(eTX�U(_jZ^U-l=_`£�U(e�aYZ^��eYU�a�RTS=U��­Q�Z^R�RYSjQ R�[�U(l=p$U(VâXEQc£�X�Q à�_o�$akX�a�eTU(VWQ�XM_jaDXMVâ«}jU(ek�§UÚZ^R�Q _j£�Z*��l=[�£"ØjU(_=U^Ù`Rë�§eY��V QìØ`Q RTRYU(eTqW����U�æ�}=eYU�aTadXM��_=« Ø`Q�akUÚ£"}=eYU�£�XEZ*RT��efa��§��e¤¥�Q�eTXM��ljaÜZ(Q�_jZ^U(efa^vPè�$adR�XMV~}j��eYR�Q�_�RY[Mq$m�RYS=UçRTU�Z�S=_=X�é]l=U� �ëZ^[EQ�aTa,}oeTU�£�X�Z^RTX���_åZ(Q�_áØjUâQ }=}o[MXMUÚ£ùRY�è£sXEakRYXM_jZ*RTXM��_ja¤eYU([EQ�RTXM_oàRT�ç�§l=RTl=eYU�Z^[�XM_=X�Z(Q [���l=RfZ^��VâU�a^mjadljZgSÊQ�aÜ£seTl=à~eYU�ak}j��_jakU���e�akl=eY¥�X�¥�Q [��sv�h¼_�RTS=UJaTQ�V~Uw¥$U(X�_Dm=t�[MXMÿÚQ�£�U(S��Ç�Å�ÌMÒ ü ��þ � v�vMv�Q�_�RYXEZ^X�}jQ RYUÜRTS`Q R�à�[M��ØjQ [@adl=eT¥$U�q=a�����à�U(_=U�U(æs}=eTU�aYakX���_WXM_�Z(Q�_jZ^U(e�m=akl`ZgS�Q�acã�U�}=eYU�akU�_�RS=U(eYU$m�ãcX�[M[jXE£sU(_�RYXÏ�§qçQ�adVWQ [�[µ_sl=VçØjU(e-� �:VWQ eYp$U(e�à�U�_=U�a�RTS`Q RcãcXM[�[jصU�ljadU�£~RT�çadRTe�Q�RTX¦�§q�}jQ�RTX�U(_�Rfa�X�_�RY�V~��[MU�Z^lo[EQ eY[MqÜeYU([MU�¥�Q�_�ROZ(Q RYU(à���eTXMUÚaBãcS=XEZ�S�ãcXM[�[=XMVâ}=eT��¥$U-RTS=U�}=eYU�Z^XEadXM��_çQ _j£�}j� ãuU(e-� ��Z^[MX�_=XEZ(Q�[$RTeYXEQ [�a��sv��S=UWQ�Ø=XM[�XMRdqèRY��adljZ(Z^U�aYa¼�§l=[�[MqÊ£�XEadRTXM_oà�l=X�akS+ØjU(Rdã�U�U(_�RTl=Vâ��eZ^[EQ�aTadU�a�í­Q [MeYU�Q�£sq�p�_=��ãc_+��ewq$U(R�RY�èØjU£�X�aTZ^��¥$U(eYU�£µîuljakX�_=àèà�U(_=UçU(æ�}oeTU�aYakXM��_å£=Q RfQ"X�aêRYS�l`a,Q�_+XMVâ}µ��eTRfQ _sR�Q�ad}µUÚZ^R�� ��RTSoXEa¤_=��¥$U([OQ }=}=eY�$Q�ZgSRT�ÎZ(Q _jZ*U(eÜZ*[EQ�aYakX¦Ù�Z(Q RYXM��_Dv,\$���­Q e�m�V~�¸akR�}=l=Ø=[�XEakSoU�£"}jQ�}jU(e�a¤��_�RTl=Vâ��eÝZ^[EQ�aTakX¦Ù�Z(Q�RTXM��_èSjQ(¥$UJQ }=}=[�XMU�£Q�akX�_=à�[�UÜRTUÚZgS=_oXEé$l=UcRT�çQ�adXM_=à�[MU�à�U(_=U�U(æs}=eYU�aTadXM��_Σ=Q RfQ�akU�R(v-hiR�X�a�SjQ�e�£~RT�çQ�aTakUÚaTa�RTSoUÜV~U(eYXMR�a�����U�Q�ZgSRTUÚZgS=_oXEé$l=U¤X�_WRTS=UQ Ø`akU(_jZ*Uw� �OQçZ^��V~}oeTU(S=U�_jakX�¥$U�Z^��V~}`Q e�Q�RTX�¥$U�akRYlj£�q$v

hi_WRTS=X�a�}jQ�}µU�e(m=ã�UZ^��V~}jQ�eTUÜRYS=UÜ}jU(ek�§��eTVWQ�_jZ^UÜ���-£sXÏð�U(eTU�_�R�£�XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_jQ�RTX���_çV~U(RTSo�s£=aO�§��ecRTS=UZ^[�Q�ak«akX¦Ù�Z(Q�RTXM��_+� �ÝRTloV~��efa,ØjQ�akU�£+��_ßà�U(_=U~U(æs}=eYU�aTadXM��_ß}=eY� Ùj[�U�a^vÊ��S=U�akUWV~U�RTS=�s£=a�XM_jZ*[Mlj£�UçRTefQ�£�X�RTX���_jQ�[��_oU�a-akljZ�S~Q�a�_=U�Q eYU�akR-_=U�XMà�SsØj��efa�Q�_j£�[MXM_oU�Q e-£sXEaTZ*eTXMVâXM_jQ�_�R@Q�_jQ [�q=adXEa^msQ�a�ã�U�[M[oQ�a�V~��eYUcV~�s£�U(eY_���_=UÚaakl`ZgS1Q�açZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙ�Z�Q RTX���_1RTeTU�U�a^vßhi_ß��l=eâZ^��V~}jQ eYXEad��_Dm-ã�U�Q [�ak�ÃZ^��_`akXE£sU(e�eTU�Z*U(_�RVWQ�Z�S=X�_=U�[�U�Q eY_=XM_oàQ }o}=eT�¸Q�Z�S=U�aÜadljZgS�Q�a¤ØjQ à�à�X�_=àWQ _`£"Øj�$�$adRTXM_oà=v¤ñåUwX�_�¥$UÚakRTX�à$Q�RTU�RTS=U�ljadUw���-}=eTUÚ£�XEZ^RYXM��_"¥$��RTU�acRT�âQ�ad«akUÚaTacRTS=U�Z*��_�Ù�£sU(_jZ^U�� �OU�Q�Z�S~}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTXM��_Dv-��S=U�V~U(RYS=�s£=auQ eTUJQ }=}o[MXMUÚ£�RT�çRTS=eYU(UÜeYU�Z^U(_sRT[�q�}=loØ=[MX�akS=U�££=Q�R�Q�adU(R�a ¢ RYS=Uw[�U(l=p$U(V~X�Q�í­t�� ����tÜP��Bîë£=Q RfQ�akU�R,���!�¤��[Ml=Ø �fÇ�Å�ÌMÒ ü Ó ��þ­mµRYS=Uw[�q�V~}oS=��VWQ£=Q RfQ�adU(R�� �t¤[�XMÿ�Q�£�U(S ��Ç�Å�ÌMÒ üý� þimoQ _j£WRTS=U����Z(Q�_jZ^U(e�Z*U([M[�[MXM_oU�íiÛ,ruh-���]î�£=Q RfQ�akU�R¤���ubë�¸aTa ��ÇcÅ�Ì�Ò ü ��� þiv

��S=UÜ}`Q }jU(e�X�a���eTà$Q�_=XMÿ�U�£~Q�a��§��[�[M��ã�a^v�\$UÚZ^RTX���_â�wZ^��_�RfQ XM_`a�Q,ØoeTXMU*�DXM_sRTeY�s£�ljZ^RYXM��_~RT�RTS=UÜØoXM��[���à�qçQ _j£RTUÚZgS=_o��[M��à�q����@Z(|ÜÛÝt V~XEZ^eY�$Q�eTe�Q(qoa^v�\$U�Z*RTXM��_ç¬w£�X�aTZ^l`aTakUÚaORYS=U�£�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ RYXM��_V~U(RYS=�s£=a-Z^��_`akXE£sU(eTU�£XM_RTS=Uc}`Q }jU(e(v:��S=U�£=Q�R�Q�adU(R�a:Q eTU�£sU�aTZ^eYXMØjU�£�XM_�\¸U�Z^RTX���_ª=m$Q�[M��_oà,ãcX�RTS}=eTU([�XMV~X�_jQ eYqÜ£oQ R�Q�}=eT�sZ^UÚaTakX�_=àakRYU(}ja*vÞ��SoU+adRTlj£�qû£sU�akX�à�_��§��eWRTS=UÃZ^��V~}jQ eYXEad��_�� �çRYS=Uå£�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ RYXM��_1V~U(RYS=�s£=a�X�a"£sXEaTZ*ljaTadU�£XM_û\$U�Z^RYXM��_��+Q�_j£ RYS=UèeYU�aklo[MR�a�� �RYS=UåakRYlj£�q1Q eYU�}=eTU�adU(_sRTU�£ßXM_×\¸U�Z^RTX���_ ��v©úBX�_jQ [�[Mq$m¤\¸U�Z^RTX���_û�akloV~VWQ eYXMÿ(UÚaB��l=ecÙj_j£sXM_=à¸a¤Q�_j£"��l=RT[�XM_=U�a���}jU(_�é]l=UÚakRTX���_ja*v

" # �ì�%$"4��-��0���! ��� �c�'& ( � ���������-���*)Ê���S=UçU(¥$U(eÜX�_jZ^eYU�Q�adXM_=àWe�Q�RTUâQ R�ãcS=X�ZgSåà�U(_o��V~U�aÝQ eTUçØjU(XM_oàèadU�é$l=U(_jZ^UÚ£èSjQ�a���}jU(_=U�£ÃQÎ_oU(ã Q�eTU�QW� �à�U�_=��V~U�eTUÚakU�Q�e�Z�SDm]�§l=_`Z^RTX���_jQ�[�à�U�_=��V~X�Z(a^m$ãcS=X�ZgSâXEa�Z*��_jZ^U�eT_=U�£çãcXMRTSÎQ�aTadXMà�_=XM_=à�ØoXM��[���à�XEZ(Q�[µ�§l=_jZ*RTXM��_RT�ê|ÜÛÜt adU�é$l=U(_jZ^UÚa^vDñ�XMRYS�RTS=U�Z^��V~}o[MU(RYU-|ÜÛÜt1akU�é$l=U(_jZ*U�a�����VWQ _sqÜà�U�_=��V~UÚaBQ�[MeTUÚQ�£�q�ps_=��ãc_Wí �(Ò+��ÒRTSoUwq$U�Q�akR�, Ò:�^�*�����(ÈÏ��Å�� mjRTS=UeT��l=_j£èã���eTV - Ò-��Ì��.�$Å$¡]� m�RYS=U,�§eYl=XMR0/jq�1 Ò2����Ì Å$¡=�3�$Å �*Çk�g� m�Q _j£WVWQ _sq

ª

Page 5: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

ØjQ�Z^RTU(eYXEQ$îcQ�_j£"RYS=UwSsl=VWQ�_~à�U(_o��V~U�ã�U�[M[���_�XMRfa�ãcQ(qWRT�çصU�XM_=à��§l=[M[�qWakUÚé]l=U�_jZ^U�£�moQ _�U�aYakU(_sRTX�Q [ïQ _j£�§��eYV~XE£oQ Ø=[�U¤RfQ�akpâXEa�RT�ç£sU^Ùj_=UÜRYS=U�eT��[MUÜ����U�Q�ZgSâà�U(_=UQ�_j£~l=_j£�U(efakRfQ _j£WS=��ã×RYS=UÜà�U�_=��V~U��§l=_jZ^RYXM��_`aQ�aÝQìãcS=��[MU$v�hi_=_=��¥�Q RYXM¥$U�Q�}=}=eY�$Q�Z�S=U�a*mDakl`ZgSÊQ�acRTS=UJZ(|ÜÛÜt©Q _`£è��[MX�à���_�ljZ*[MU(��RTXE£sUÜV~XEZ*eT�$Q�eTefQÚqâRTU�Z�S=«_=��[M��à�XMU�a*mBSjQ(¥$U�ØjU(U(_H£�U(¥$U([���}jU�£èRT�WU(æs}=[���XMR|ÜÛÝt akU�é$l=U(_jZ*U~£=Q�R�Q�Q _j£áqsXMU�[E£"X�_��§��eYVWQ RYXM��_+Q�ص��l=Rà�U�_=UcU(æs}=eTU�aYakX���_w[�U(¥$U([�aµ�§��e�U(_sRTX�eTU-à�U�_=��V~UÚa^v�Û�U(æ�R�m ãuU�Ø=eYXMU /`q,eYU(¥sXMU(ãåØjQ�adXEZ�à�U(_=U(RYXEZ�_o��RTX���_ja@ljakU^�§lo[�§��eÝQ _Wl=_`£�U(e�adR�Q�_j£�XM_oà����-V~XEZ*eT�$Q�eTefQÚq�U�æ�}jU(eYXMV~U(_sR�a*v

t �s�*¡µ� Z^��_jakX�akR�a�� �JQåakU(à�V~U(_sRw����|ÝÛÜt'ãcS=XEZ�S1Z^�s£�U�aì�§��e~Q�}jQ�eTRTX�Z^l=[�Q e  ��T��Çd�*ÈE¡ m-RTS=U�l=[MRYXMVWQ�RTUU(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_ç� �@RYS=U¤à�U(_=U(RYXEZ�X�_��§��eYVWQ RYXM��_ïv�t ���Y�54�Í��*ÈEÉ��$¡=Æs�^ÌM�*ÈE�Å$�(ÈE� ��e�1�6 � V~��[�U�Z^l=[�U�X�a�Q£���loØ=[MU(«akRYe�Q�_j£�U�£�}j��[MqsV~U(e:Z^��V~}j�$akUÚ£w� ���§��l=e�ØjQ�akX�ZëV~��[MU�Z*l=[EQ�eDl=_=XMRfa-Z(Q [�[MU�£�_�ljZ*[MU(��RTXE£sU�a^v87-Q�Z�S ¡=Æs�^ÌM�Y��Ç­ÈE���Z^��V~}=eTX�akU�a-Qw}=So�$ak}oSjQ RYUwà�eY��l=}ïmjQ�£�U(��æ�qseTX�Øj�$akUêakl=à¸Q e(mjQ�_j£~��_=U���� ���$Æs�Ü¡=ÈMÇ­�T�3���*¡�É�Å ���T� v-��S=UÜ�§��loe£�X¦ð�U�eTU(_sR�ØjQ�akU�a��§��lo_j£~XM_W|ÜÛÝt/Q�eTUQ�£sU(_=XM_oU�íit,îfm�à�ljQ _=X�_=Uçí9��î�mjZ*q�RY�$akX�_=U�ídrcî�mjQ _`£ÎRYS�qsV~X�_=U�íi�¤îfv��S=UWRdã��åZ�SjQ X�_ja�Q eYUèS=U�[E£áRY��à�U�RTS=U(eçØsq+S�qo£�eY��à�U�_äØj��_j£=a�ØjU(Rdã�U�U(_+_=X�RTeT��à�U(_ßØjQ�akU�a*m�ãcXMRYSßØjQ�adU(«}jQ�XMeTX�_=à��sZ(Z^l=eYeTX�_=àQ�Z(Z^��e�£�X�_=à�RT�RTS=U��§��[M[M��ãcX�_=à�eTl=[�U ¢ �×}`Q XMefa�ãcXMRTSWr�m$Q�_j£~t }jQ�XMe�a�ãcX�RTSâ�Üv]ñ�SoXM[MUQ�|ÜÛÜt+V~��[�U�Z^l=[�UDXEaDØ=l=X�[MRµ�§eY��V Q��§��loeT«§[MU(RYRTU(e@Q�[M}=SjQ�ØjU(R(m�}oeT��RYU(XM_`aDQ eTU�akU�é$l=U(_`Z^U�aµ���jRdã�U(_sRdqÜ£sXÏð�U(eTU�_�RRdq�}jU�a���� Å:��ÈE¡=�çÅ$�(ÈE� � v���SoU¤U(æs}=eYU�aTadXM��_ç� �ïRTS=U�à�U�_=U(RTX�Z�XM_��§��eTVWQ�RTX���_çakRY��eYU�£�XM_�RYS=UÝ|ÜÛÜt�V~��[�U�Z^l=[�U�sZ(Z^loe�a�XM_ Rdãu�+adR�Q à�U�a ¢ í X î Ç­�TÅ$¡$���(�^È  jÇ­ÈE�$¡ mc£sl=eTX�_=àáãcSoXEZ�S |ÝÛÜt'XEa�RTe�Q�_jaTZ*eTXMØjU�£ßXM_sRT� ���T�����*¡��s�*��*ÈEÉ��$¡=Æ��*ÌM�*ÈE�èÅ$��ÈE� ��e �<; 6 � m@QèadXM_=à�[MU(«­akRYe�Q�_j£�U�£+Z*��V~}=[�U(VçU(_�RfQ eYqWZ^��}sqå� �cRYS=U~ØjQ�akUWadU�é$l=U(_jZ^U�X�_RTSoU�|ÜÛÜt V~��[MU�Z^lo[MU$m(ãcX�RTSçRTS=UcØjQ�akU�l=e�Q�Z^XM[ïíi�,îDeYU(}=[�Q�Z^X�_=àÜRTSsqsV~XM_=U¸ö$í XMX§î Ç­�TÅ$¡]�*̦Å�Ç­ÈE�$¡ ms£�l=eYXM_=à�ãcS=X�ZgSVWb�ÛÜt�XEa¤RYe�Q�_jak[�Q RTUÚ£ùRY�"}oeT�s£�ljZ*UçQÎ}oeT��RYU(XM_ïv���S=UçZ^��eTeTUÚak}j��_j£sU(_jZ^UçØjU(Rdã�U(U(_Ê|ÜÛÜt � aë�§��loeT«§[MU(RYRTU(eQ [�}=SjQ�صU�R�Q�_j£çQ¤}=eT��RTU(X�_ � a@RkãuU(_sRkqs«§[MU(RYRTU(eïQ [M}oSjQ ØjU(R-XEa:ak}jU�Z^X¦ÙjU�£wØsq,RYS=U ���*¡j��ÇiÈE�������� m�ãcS=X�ZgS�eYU([EQ�RTU�a_sljZ^[MU���RTX�£�U�RYeTX�}=[MU(RfaBRT�JQ V~X�_=�ÝQ�Z^X�£=a^v�\$U�U��¤eYX>=âRTSja ��ÇOÅ�ÌMÒ ü Ó ®�þ`�§��euQ _çXM_sRTeT�s£sljZ^RTX���_çRT��RTSoU¤eYU([MU(¥�Q�_�RØ=X���[M��à�q$v

|¤X¦ð�U�eTU(_sR�}=eT��}jU(eTRYXMU�aw����à�U(_oU"U�æ�}=eYU�aTadXM��_ Z�Q _ßØjU�akRYlj£�X�U�£+ljakX�_=àáVâXEZ^eY�$Q eYe�Q(qoa^m�adljZ�S Q�aìU�æ�}=eYU�ak«akX���_åQ�RÜRTS=U�RYe�Q�_jaTZ^eYXM}=RYXM��_���eÜRYe�Q _`ak[EQ�RTX���_�[MU�¥$U([imjQ�_j£�akl=Ø�Z^U�[M[Mlo[EQ e�[M�sZ�Q [MX�ÿ�Q RYXM��_�� �uà�U(_oU�}=eT�s£�l`Z^R�a*vPèXEZ*eT�$Q�eTefQÚqoa�£�U(eTX�¥$UÜRTSoU(XMec}j��ã�U(eÝQ _`£èl=_=XM¥$U�e�aTQ�[MX�Rkq��§eT��V Qìp$U(qâ}=eT��}µU�eTRdqW� �u|ÜÛÝt Vâ��[MUÚZ^l=[MUÚa�£�U(«aTZ*eTXMØjU�£�Q Øj��¥$U ¢���:�¤ jÌM�����*¡sÇiÅ$�*ÍWÉ�Å ���3M oÅ$ÈE�^ÈE¡?� vÜ��S=URTU(eYV Ä Í�É(�*ÈE�$È>@�Å�ÇiÈE�$¡ eTU^�§U�e�acRT�~RYS=U�Q�_=_=U�Q�[MXM_oà� ��_�l`Z^[MU(X�Z�Q�Z^X�£�akRTefQ _j£oaê�§eT��V £�X¦ð�U(eTU(_sR�ad��l=efZ^U�aÜQ�Z(Z^��ef£�XM_oà"RY�WRTS=U�ØjQ�akU(«§}jQ�XMeTX�_=àWeTl=[�U�a^v�D�è£oQ RTU¸mQ RYRTU(_sRTX���_ßSjQ�a,�§�sZ^ljaTadU�£ä}oeTXMVÎQ eTX�[Mq���_ U�æ�}=eYU�aTadXM��_ßQ R�RYS=UWRTe�Q�_jaTZ*eTXM}oRTXM��_1akR�Q�à�U$m È ÒE�(Ò m-��_ßVWb�ÛÜt[MU�¥$U([Ea*vBt�[MRTSo��l=à�S"RYS=UÜeYU(à�l=[�Q RYXM��_W����}=eY��RYU(XM_Wadq�_sRTSoU�akX�a�XM_ÎQ�Z^U([M[jX�a�Ø�qç_=��V~U�Q�_ja�eTU(à�l=[EQ�RTU�£Wad��[MU�[MqØsqèVWb�ÛÜt�[MU(¥$U�[Ea^mjVWb�ÛÜt�[MU(¥$U�[Ea�akU(_jadXMRYXM¥$U([�q~eTU /`U�Z^RÜRYS=U�Rdq�}jUçQ _`£áadR�Q RYU����cRYS=UçZ^U([�[iv���Wl=RYXM[MX�ÿ(URTSoU¤Ssq�ØoeTXE£sXMÿ�Q�RTXM��_�}=eT��}jU(eTRdq�� ��|ÜÛÜtwm ���:�¤ jÌM�����*¡�Ç­Å$�*Í |ÝÛÜt ��e � 1�6 � X�aO��Ø=R�Q�XM_=UÚ£J�§eY��V VWb�ÛÜtØsqèeTU�¥$U(e�adUwRTefQ _jaYZ^eTX�}=RTX���_Dv��S=U(eYUçQ eYUç£�XÏð�U(eYU(_�R�Rdq�}jU�a�� �cVâXEZ^eY�$Q eYe�Q(q�akqoakRYU(VWa^mjXM_`Z^[Mlj£sXM_=àâZ(|ÜÛÜtV~X�Z^eT�¸Q eTefQ(q=aü ��¨�m Ó �=m Ó ¬�þ-Q _j£�S=X�à�S=«­£�U(_jadXMRdqè��[MX�à���_sljZ^[�U(��RYXE£�UJQ eYe�Q(q=açü Ó ¨ þ­ö�RTSoUç£�U�aTZ*eTXM}oRTXM��_�ØjU([M��ã�§�sZ^ljadU�ac��_èRYS=UÜ�§��eYV~U(e(v

Z(|ÜÛÝt V~X�Z^eT�¸Q eYe�Q(q=a-Z^��_jakX�akRc����RYS=��ljaYQ _j£oaë���@XM_j£�X�¥�X�£�ljQ�[D|ÜÛÜtûakUÚé]l=U�_jZ^U�a-}=eTX�_�RYU�£ìX�_�Q,S=X�à�S�£�U(_=«akX�Rdq�Q eYe�Q(qè��_+Q~à�[EQ�aYa,V~X�Z^eT�¸aTZ^��}jU�ak[�XE£�U¸vw��S=UçeTU�[EQ RYXM¥$UQ Øol=_j£=Q�_jZ^U~���cRTSoU�akUç|ÜÛÝt akU�é$l=U(_jZ*U�aëX�_Rdã��å|ÜÛÝtÞ��eçZ(|ÝÛÜt'aTQ�V~}=[�U�aÜVWQ(qáØjU�Q�aYakU�aYakU�£+ØsqáV~��_=XMRY��eYXM_=à�RTS=U�£�X¦ð�U�eTU(_sRTX�Q [-S�qsØ=eYXE£�X�ÿ�Q RYXM��_� �ÝRTSoU�Rdã��åaYQ V~}o[MU�aÜRT��RTS=UÎakU�é$l=U(_jZ*U�a,��_+RTS=UÎQ eTefQ(q$v��D��RTS=X�a,U(_j£�m�RTS=U~Rdãu��|ÜÛÜtòaTQ Vâ}=[MU�aÜ��eÇ­Å$�A����ÇE� Q�eTUW[EQ�صU�[MU�£ßljakX�_=à+£sXÏð�U(eTU�_�RB/jl=��eYU�aTZ*U(_�Râ£�q$U�a~í �(Ò+��Ò Q�eTU�£�«�/jl=��eTU�aYZ^U(_sR~£sq$Uèr-q=�åQ _`£�Qà�eYU(U(_=«�/jl=��eTU�aYZ^U(_sR�£�q$U�r-q=¬$î�m=RYS=U(_èVâXMæsU�£�Q�_j£"SsqsØ=eTX�£�XMÿ(UÚ£�ãcXMRYS"RYS=UQ eYe�Q(q$U�£W|ÜÛÜt©akUÚé]l=U�_jZ^U�a���e ��T�$É^�Y� íE�§��[�[M��ãcXM_=à�RYS=U�£�U^Ù`_=XMRYXM��_����@}=eT��ØjU�Q _j£çR�Q eYà�U(R�Q�£���}=RTUÚ£�XM_çRTS=UÝ�$Q _sljQ�eTq Ó ¨�¨�¨�adl=}=}=[�U(V~U(_sR

Page 6: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

RT�ÃÛÜQ�RTl=eYUC��U(_=U(RYXEZ(aWü Ó þ îfv+të�§RYU(e�RTSoXEa�Z^��V~}jU(RTX�RTXM¥$U�SsqsØ=eTX�£�XMÿ�Q�RTX���_Dm�/jlo��eTUÚaTZ^U(_`Z^U~V~U�Q�akl=eYU(V~U(_sR�aQ eYUwVWQ�£�U�adU(}jQ efQ RYU([Mq~�§��e�U�Q�ZgS�£�q$UQ R�U�Q�ZgS�ak}j��RÜ��_�RTS=UJQ eTefQ(q$v���SoUwe�Q�RTX������-RTS=UB/jl=��e¤X�_�RYU(_jakX�Rdq�§��e�U�Q�ZgS�ak}j��RÜXEacXM_j£sXEZ(Q�RTXM¥$UÝ� �-RYS=U�eTU([�Q RTX�¥$U�Q Øol=_j£=Q�_jZ^U�� �ORTS=UJZ^��eYeTU�ad}µ��_j£�X�_=à~|ÝÛÜt adU�é]loU(_jZ^UÜX�_RTSoUwRdã��âaTQ�V~}=[MUÚa,í­akU(UED ¹s¹�FHG�I�I¸³`°�±j°:º�J�¹=°�±�K�L¸³s²-º9M�NPOQIs¯:L?K$¹�R=°¸³`¶:I �§��eÜV~��eTU�XM_��§��eTVWQ�RTX���_W��_�RYS=UV~U�Q�akl=eYU(V~U(_sR����S/jl=��eTU�aYZ^U(_jZ^UÝXM_sRTU(_jadXMRYXMU�a�î�vtÜadXE£�U��§eT��V3RYS=U�U(_=��eTV~��lja¤aYZ^XMU�_�RYXÏÙ�ZÜ}j��RYU(_�RYXEQ�[B���c|ÝÛÜt/V~X�Z^eT�¸Q eYe�Q(q=acRT�âS=U([M}�XM_�l=_j£�U(efakRfQ _j£�X�_=àà�U�_=UweYU(à�l=[�Q RYXM��_åQ�_j£èXM_sRTU�e�Q�Z*RTXM��_ja^mjV~X�Z^eT�¸Q eTefQ(q=a�SjQ(¥$U¥$U(eTq~X�V~}j��eYR�Q _sR�Q }o}=[MX�Z(Q RYXM��_`a¤XM_�}=SjQ eYVWQ «Z^U(loRTXEZ�Q [uQ _j£ßZ^[�XM_=X�Z(Q [-eYU�akU�Q�e�Z�SDv�n�qÃZ^��Vâ}jQ eYXM_=àWà�U�_=UWU(æ�}oeTU�aYakXM��_+XM_Ã_=��eYVWQ [uQ _`£ä£sXEakUÚQ�akU�Z^U�[M[Ea*mV~X�Z^eT�¸Q eTefQ(q=a¤VÎQÚqWØjU~ljadU�£�RT�WXE£�U�_�RYXÏ�§q�£sXEakUÚQ�akUçà�U�_=U�a�Q _j£åR�Q eYà�U(Rfa¤�§��ewRYS=U(efQ }jU(l=RYXEZ�£�eYl=à$a*vW��S=Uaklo}=}=[MU�V~U(_sR�RT�âÛÜQ�RTl=eYUT��U(_=U(RYXEZ(a�ü Ó þ:Q _j£WRTS=UØj�$��pU1*6 �WVùÈE�(�T��Å$�*�TÅ�Í(�BX¤�ZYc�YÅ$�^Ç­ÈE��Å�Ì��� $ ��Y� Å$� Äü ��® þ=}oeT��¥�X�£�U�à�U(_=U(efQ [=��¥$U(eY¥�X�U(ã�aD� ��V~XEZ*eT�$Q�eTefQÚq�RYU�ZgSo_=��[���à�X�U�a@Q _j£�� ��£�XÏð�U(eYU(_�R:Q eYU�Q�a����DQ�}=}=[�XEZ(Q�RTXM��_� �OV~XEZ^eY�$Q�eTe�Q(qoa^v

PèXEZ*eT�$Q�eTefQÚqoa�Q eTUØjU(XM_=àâQ }o}=[MX�U�£"X�_jZ^eTUÚQ�akX�_=à�[�q~XM_ÊZ(Q _`Z^U(e�eTU�adU�Q efZgSWRT�ÎakRTl`£�qWRTS=UV~��[�U�Z^l=[�Q e�¥�Q�eTXEQ�«RTX���_jaÝQ V~��_=à�RYl=V~��e�a�ü �sm�¬=m Ó �sm���¬=m���ªjmj����þ­v¤��SoXEaÜadS=��l=[�£"[�U�Q�£WRT�WQ�_�XMV~}=eY��¥$U�£~Z^[�Q�aTadXÏÙ�Z�Q RTX���_�� �RTloV~��efa^m$ãcS=XEZ�SçXM_~RYl=eT_WadS=��lo[E£�eYU�akl=[�R�X�_�}=eY��à�eTU�aYakU�a�X�_�RYS=UÜ}=eYU(¥$U(_sRTXM��_çQ _j£~RYeTU�Q�RTV~U(_sR����:Z(Q _jZ*U(e(vt¤_�X�V~}j��eTRfQ _sR�Q�ad}jU�Z^R�� ��RTS=X�a¤U(_j£�UÚQÚ¥$��eÜXEaÜRYS=UçQ Ø=X�[MX�RkqWRY�"}oeTU�£�X�Z^RÜRYl=V~��eÝRkqs}jU�a¤��_áRYS=U�Ø`Q�akX�aÜ� �à�U�_=U~U(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_ߣoQ R�QsváñåU~eTU�¥�X�U(ã ØjU([M��ã�Qè_sl=V�ØjU(e����Ü}=eYU�£�X�Z^RTX���_åV~U(RTSo�s£=awQ�_j£ßQ�aTadU�aTa�RTSoU(XMe}jU(ek�§��eTVWQ�_jZ^UÜ��_èRYS=U�RTS=eYU(U�Z(Q�_jZ^U(e�£=Q�R�Q�akU(Rfa¤£�UÚaTZ^eYXMØjU�£~XM_�\$U�Z*RTXM��_Wª=v

[ � ����c���� ����,�-���� � �¤�- ��"!��

ú=��ec��l=ec}=l=eY}µ�¸akU$m=à�U(_=UÜU�æ�}=eYU�aTadXM��_W£=Q RfQw��_]\~à�U�_=U�a��§��e!^WVWb�ÛÜt�aTQ�V~}=[MUÚa�VWQ(qwØjUakloV~VWQ eYXMÿ(UÚ£ØsqßQ __^a`�\ßVWQ�RTeTX�æUb c9íed�f+g^îfm�ãcSoU(eTUhd�f+gç£�U(_o��RTUÚaìRYS=UWU(æ�}oeTU�aYakXM��_ [�U(¥$U([-� ��à�U(_=Uåí ¥�Q�eTXEQ�Ø=[MU�îi+XM_ßVWb�ÛÜt�aTQ�V~}=[MUÊí ��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_�î]jYv ��S=UWU(æs}=eYU�aTadXM��_ß[�U(¥$U([Ea�V~XMà�S�RØjUèU(X�RTS=U(eJQ Øjad��[�l=RTUÃí �(Ò+��Ò��[�XMà���_sljZ^[MU���RTX�£�U�Q�eTe�Q(qoa�ljakUÚ£"RT��}oeT�s£�ljZ*UwRTSoU,[�U(l=p$U(VâXMQ�£=Q�R�Q�akU(R*î���eceTU([�Q RTX�¥$UÜãcXMRYSWeTU�ad}µUÚZ^RcRT��RYS=UU(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_+[�U(¥$U([�aê����QåakloXMR�Q�Ø=[Mqã�U^Ù`_=U�£ßZ^��VâV~��_�eYU^�§U(eTU�_jZ^UâaTQ Vâ}=[MU�í �(Ò+��Ò Z(|ÜÛÜt V~X�Z^eT�¸Q eTefQ(q=aljadU�£"RY��}=eT�s£�l`Z^UwRYS=U�[MqsV~}=S=��VWQ�Q _j£�Û,ruh�����£=Q�R�Q�akU(Rfagî�vuñ�S=U(_WRTS=U�VWb�ÛÜtûaTQ�V~}=[MUÚa�صU�[M��_oà�RY�ps_=��ãc_ßZ^[EQ�aTadU�a~í �(Ò+�sÒ �§��[�[MX�Z^l=[EQ�e�[MqsV~}=S=��VWQ]îfm�RTS=UΣ=Q RfQ"�§��e�U�Q�ZgS+��ØjakU�eT¥�Q RYXM��_1Z^��_jakX�akR� �êQ"à�U�_=UU(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_�}=eY� Ùj[�Ulk fmc íed�fonqpqrqrqr p3d�fts�î�Q _`£�Q"Z*[EQ�aYa¤[EQ�ØjU([Suvfim È ÒE��Ò m�� ��}=eTU�£sXEZ^RY��e�¥�Q�eTX�Q Ø=[�U�a�k f:Q _j£eTUÚak}j��_jadUwu f v�ú=��eBx Z^[�Q�aYakU�a*m�RTS=UâZ^[�Q�aTa�[EQ ØjU([�a�u f Q�eTUç£�U^Ù`_=U�£èRT�WØjUçXM_sRTU(à�U(e�ace�Q�_=à�X�_=à"�§eY��V Ó RY�x+v�ñåU,[�U(R!^zyÝ£�U(_=��RTUwRYS=U�_�loV�ØjU(e-� �O��ØjadU(eT¥�Q RYXM��_jaëØjU([���_=à�XM_=àçRT�çZ*[EQ�aYa|{`vt  ����Y�$ÈE�^Ç­�$� ��e �^̦Š����È }c�g� �§��e*x RYl=V~��e�Z*[EQ�aYakU�ac}jQ�eTRTX�RTX���_ja¤RYS=Uak}jQ�Z^U]~ ���uà�U(_=UU(æs}=eTU�aYakX���_W}=eT��«Ùj[�U�aìX�_�RY��x £�XEa��d��X�_�Râakl=Ø`akU(Rfa^m�� n pqrqr�r p3����m�akljZ�S�RTSjQ�R��§��eÎQäaYQ V~}o[MUWãcXMRYS�U(æ�}oeTU�aYakXM��_ }=eY� Ùj[�Uk�c©í�d n pqr�rqrzp3d s î�����y�RTS=U�}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTU�£~Z*[EQ�aYa�XEa�{jv��eTU�£sXEZ^RY��e�a-Q�eTUÜØ=loXM[MR��§eY��V�}jQ�adR�U(æs}jU(eTX�U(_jZ^U$m È ÒE�(Ò m]�§eY��V ��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_ja�ãcS=X�ZgSâQ eYUÜps_=��ãc_�RY�wØjU([M��_=àRT�âZ^U(eYR�Q�XM_WZ^[�Q�aYakU�a*v�\$ljZ�S"��ØjakU�eT¥�Q RYXM��_`aÜZ^��Vâ}=eTX�akU�RTS=U ÌM�YÅ$�*¡=ÈE¡��~����Ç���� ,?�� c��$íAk8n�p3u�n�î3pqr�rqr p(íAk ����p3uv�q��î��$v0��eTUÚ£�XEZ^RY��efa�VWQ(q�RTS=U(_WØjU�Q�}=}=[�XMU�£�RY�~Q Çd�T�*Ç�����ÇB�  ,��� c��qk8nqpqrqr�rzp�k ���z�$m$RT��}=eYU�£�XEZ*RB�§��euU�Q�Z�S���ØjadU(eT¥�Q�RTXM��_wk fjXM_çRTS=UcRYU�akRuadU(R-XMR�a-Z^[�Q�aYa�uvfiv-hi_çRTS=U�U(¥$U(_sRRTS`Q R�RYS=U*u5f�Q eYU¤ps_=��ãc_Dm�RYS=U�}=eTU�£sXEZ^RYU�£�Q _j£çRTeTloUÜZ^[�Q�aYakU�a�VWQ(qwØjU�Z*��V~}jQ�eTU�£wRY�wU�adRTX�VWQ RYU�RTSoU¤U(eYeT��e

Page 7: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

e�Q�RTU�� �ORTS=U�}=eYU�£�XEZ*RT��e�v

ñåU�£�U(_o��RTUåQÃZ^[EQ�aTakX¦ÙjU(eçØ=l=X�[MRw�§eT��V Qá[�U�Q eY_=XM_oà+adU(R � Øsq���í���p � îföcRTS=U�}=eYU�£�X�Z^RTU�£ßZ^[�Q�aYaì�§��eWQ�_��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_�k XEaB��íAkmp � î�vJn�U([M��ã�m�ãuU�eTU(¥sXMU(ã©Ø=eYXMU /`qèQW_�loV�ØjU(ec���cã�U�[M[M«§ps_=��ãc_å£�XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_jQ�RTX���_V~U(RYS=�s£=a*v0�¤U�_=U(e�Q�[DeTU^�§U�eTU(_jZ*U�a���_èRYS=U�RT��}=XEZÜ� ��£�XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_jQ�_�ROQ _jQ�[MqoakXEacXM_`Z^[Mlj£sUçü ����mj� Ó mj��� þ­v�!��� �w���Q !¡ ¢¤£���¥!¡8¦S¢¤§�����¨z¢���©ª��¥!¦0¥m«¤¦0¥!¦m£�¬!�����úBX�e�akRêQ }=}=[�XMU�£èX�_ Ó ¨�¬��"Øsq�P+vDncQ�eT_jQ�e�£1ü ª�þuQ�R,RYS=Uçakloà�à�UÚakRTX���_+����b�vDtwvDú@XEakSoU(eçü Ó ª�þ­m%­ ÈÏ� Ä �*�w̦ÈE¡��YÅ$�ç�$ÈÏ���(�^È���ÈE¡oÅ$¡�ÇÅ$¡=Å�̦ÍÚ��ÈÏ��� ­ � 1 � ��X�a,ØjQ�akU�£+��_HÙ`_j£�XM_oàè[MX�_=U�Q�e�Z^��V�Ø=X�_jQ RYXM��_ja�k8®á� ��RYS=U~à�U�_=UU(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_W[MU�¥$U([EaSkUc í�d�nqpqr�rqrzp3d�s�î-ãcX�RTSW[EQ�eTà�U�efQ RTX��$ac� �-ØjU(RdãuU(U(_=«§à�eY��l=}ja�RY��ãcX�RTS=X�_=«§à�eT��l=}ja�akl=V� ��aTé$ljQ eYU�awüý���smj� Ó mj����þ­v-��S=XEa�Z^eYXMRTU�eTXM��_~XEacXM_sRTloXMRTX�¥$U([MqJQ }=}jU�Q�[MX�_=à=mjØjU�Z(Q l`akUwX�RcXEa�U�Q�akX�U(ecRT�çRTU([�[�RYS=UZ^[�Q�aTadU�awQ�}jQ eYRwljadXM_=à�¥�Q�eTXEQ�Ø=[MUÚaìíE�§l=_jZ^RYXM��_ja,����¥�Q�eTX�Q Ø=[�U�agî��§��ewãcSoXEZ�SáRYS=U~ØjU(Rdã�U(U�_=« à�eT��l=}jawadl=V6� �aTé$ljQ�eTU�acXEa�[�Q eTà�U�eTU([�Q RTX�¥$U¤RY��RYS=U�ãcXMRYS=XM_=«§à�eY��l=}`a¤adl=V'� ��aTé$ljQ eYU�a^v

ú=��eQ _¯^°`±\�[�U�Q eY_=XM_=àÎakU(R£=Q�R�Q"VÎQ RTeYXMæ±b+mDRYS=U�[MX�_=U�Q eêZ^��VçØ=XM_`Q RTX���_�bh²"� ��RYS=UçZ^��[Ml=V~_`a¤� �HbSjQ�a�e�Q RYXM������ØjU(Rdã�U�U(_=«§à�eT��l=}ja�RY��ãcXMRTSoXM_=«§à�eY��l=}jacadl=V'���-aYé]ljQ�eTU�a-à�X�¥$U(_~Øsqw®�³o´µ®Q¶v®�³�·¤®�m�ãcS=U(eYUB´Q _`£U· £�U(_o��RTUeTU�ad}jU�Z^RTX�¥$U([MqçRTSoU�\�`]\"VWQ�RTeYXEZ^U�a-� �uØjU(Rdã�U(U�_=« à�eT��l=}ja�Q _j£èãcX�RTS=X�_=« à�eT��l=}jaÜadl=V3� �aTé$ljQ�eTU�a*v���S=U~U(æsRTeYU(V~U�¥�Q [�l=U�a�� �*®�³¸´µ®�¶v®�³¹·�®+Q�eTU~��Ø=R�Q�XM_=UÚ£Ã�§eY��V6RTS=UâU(XMà�U(_�¥�Q�[Ml=U�a�Q�_j£áU(X�à�U(_=«¥$U�Z^RY��efaë����·�º n ´~vÝ��S=U�VWQ�RTeTX�æC·�º n ´ÞSjQ�aÜQ RÝV~�$adR�»µc©V~XM_jíex½¼ Ó p�\µî�_=��_=«§ÿ(U(eY�~U(X�à�U(_s¥�Q [MloU�a^m¾ nC¿ ¾ÁÀ ¿ r�rqr ¿ ¾Á m�ãcXMRYS1Z^��eYeTU�ad}µ��_j£�X�_=à�[MX�_=U�Q eY[MqåXM_j£sU(}jU(_j£�U(_sR�U(XMà�U(_s¥$U�Z^RT��e�a�à n p�à À pqrqrqr p�à  v��S=U �$ÈÏ�����^È���ÈE¡=Å$¡sÇ��(Å$�*ÈEÅ$É^ÌM�Y� Q�eTUâ£�U^Ùj_=UÚ£áRT��صUÅÄ�Æ�cÇk Ã8ÆMm�È�c Ó pqrqr�r p3»$m�Q _`£áXM_å}jQ eYRTX�Z^l=[EQ�e(m8à nVWQ�æ�X�V~XMÿ*U�aS® ³ ´µ®Q¶v® ³ ·¤®�vú=��e�Q�_è��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_Ck�c�íed�nqpqrqrqrÉp3d�s�î�m=[MU�R

Ê y í.k�îSc ÂË Æ+Ì n íTí.kC¼ÎÍk y îeÃ Æ î À£�U(_o��RTUcX�R�a-íiaYé]ljQ�eTU�£jî87�ljZ^[MX�£�U�Q�_�£�X�akR�Q�_jZ^U$m�XM_�RYU(eTVÎa�� ��RTS=U�£�XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_`Q _sR�¥�Q eYXEQ Øo[MU�a*m �§eT��V RTSoU Ó `�\¥$U�Z^RY��eu� �uZ^[�Q�aYa�{~Q(¥$U(efQ à�U�a<Ík y �§��ecRYS=U�[MU�Q�eT_=X�_=àçakU�R � v-��S=U�}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTU�£~Z*[EQ�aYa��§��e���ØjadU(eT¥�Q�RTXM��_Ck�X�aÏ í.kmp � îSc Q eTà�V~XM_ y Ê y íAk�î3pRTS`Q R�XEa^msRTS=UZ^[�Q�aYaëãcS=�¸akUV~U�Q _â¥$U�Z^RT��e�X�acZ^[M�¸akU�adRcRT�]k�XM_WRTS=Uad}jQ�Z^U� �O£�XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_`Q _sR�¥�Q�eTXEQ�Ø=[MUÚa^vúS�D|�tÞXEaQè_=��_o« }jQ�e�Q�V~U(RTeYXEZ�V~U(RYS=�s£áãcS=X�ZgSÃQ [�ak�åQ eYXEadU�a,X�_ßQè}jQ efQ V~U�RTeTX�Z�adU(RTRYXM_=àov�ú=��eÐx c#�Z^[�Q�aTadU�a^muúS�D|�t'q�X�U([E£=a�RTS=U�aYQ V~UWZ*[EQ�aYakX¦ÙjU(eçQ�a�RTSoU"VÎQ æsXMV�l=V [MXMp$U�[MXMSo�$�s£ä£sXEaTZ*eTXMVâXM_jQ�_�RÜeYl=[MU~�§��eVçl=[MRYXM¥�Q eYXEQ RYU�_=��eYVWQ [-Z*[EQ�aYaÜ£�U(_`akXMRYXMU�a�ãcXMRTSåRTSoUçaTQ VâUçZ^��¥�Q�eTX�Q _jZ^U�VÎQ RTeYXMæÃü ��� þcí­akU(U�ØjU([���ã Z(Q�akU Ó�§��e*x½cû�]îfv�!��Ñ Ò ¦SÓ!��©ÕÔ�© £���Ö�¡�£��� !×!×�§Ø§�����¨z¢���©W��¥!¦0¥m«Î¢zÔ!£�¡8�hi_+Q�akX�RTljQ�RTXM��_+ãcS=U(eYU�RYS=UâZ^[EQ�aTawZ*��_j£�X�RTX���_jQ�[�£sU(_jakX�RTX�U�a0\�Ù$í.k�ÚÛuÜcÝ{=îÝQ eYU~p�_o� ãc_ïmBRTSoU ��Å54�È���ÆP�̦ÈÏÑ$�fÌ¦È Ä ��� �Þ��VC� � �$ÈÏ�����^È���ÈE¡=Å$¡sÇ��^Æ$ÌM� }oeTU�£�X�Z^R�a�RTS=UâZ^[EQ�aTa�� �ÝQ _Ã��ØjadU(eT¥�Q RYXM��_Ükßc3íed�n pqrqr�r p3d�s(îÜØsqRTS`Q R�ãcS=XEZ�S�à�X�¥$U�a¤RYS=U�[EQ�eTà�UÚakR�[MX�p$U([MX�S=�$�s£èRT�±k-m È ÒE�(Ò m@Ø�q Ï í.k�î�c Q eYà�VWQ�æ y \ÁÙ]í.k�ÚÛu�cà{=îfv~í ñ�SoU(_

Page 8: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

RTSoU�Z^[EQ�aTauZ^��_j£sXMRTX���_jQ�[�£�U(_jadXMRTX�U�a-Q eYU¤�§l=[M[�q�p�_o� ãc_ïm=Qw[MUÚQ eT_oXM_=àakU�R�XEa-_=��Ru_=U(U�£sU�£�Q�_j£~RTS=UêZ^[EQ�aTakX¦ÙjU(eXEauakX�V~}=[Mq Ï íAk�îfvÏîhi_~}=efQ�Z^RYXEZ^U$m$S=��ãuU(¥$U(e(m$U(¥$U�_~XÏ�@RYS=U¤�§��eYVWa�����RYS=U�Z^[�Q�aYacZ^��_j£sXMRTX���_jQ�[D£�U�_jakX�RTXMUÚa�Q eYUps_=��ãc_Dm=RTS=U�XMe�}`Q e�Q�V~U(RYU(e�a-V�ljadR�ØjU�U�akRYXMVWQ�RTU�£w�§eT��V3Qw[MUÚQ eT_oXM_=àçadU(R(v-�ÜadXM_=à�}`Q e�Q�V~U(RYU(e�U�adRTX�VWQ RYU�aXM_�}o[EQ�Z*Uc� �DRYS=Ucl=_=ps_=��ãc_ç}jQ efQ V~U(RYU(e�aDqsXMU([�£=a�RYS=U ��Å:�¤ jÌM�*��Å54�È���ÆP� ̦ÈÏÑ$��Ì È Ä � �����$ÈÏ���(�*È���ÈE¡=Å$¡�Ç:�*Æ]ÌM� vú=��e�V�lo[MRTX�¥�Q eTX�Q RYUÜ_=��eYVWQ [@Z*[EQ�aYaÜ£�U(_`akXMRYXMU�a*m È ÒE�(Ò m=�§��e!k�ÚÛuwcá{±âäãáí�å y p æ y î�mjRTS=UJP��ߣ�XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_jQ�_�ReTlo[MU�XEa

Ï íAk�îSc Q eTà�V~XM_ y�ç í.k±¼�å y î�æ º ny íAkè¼�å y î ³:é [M��àBÚ+æ y Ú�ê!rhi_Wà�U(_=U�e�Q [­m=RTS=X�a�XEacQ�é$ljQ�£se�Q RYXEZ�£�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ _sR-eTl=[�U$v-hi_�RYU(eTU�adRTX�_=à�ad}µUÚZ^XEQ�[@Z(Q�adU�a�XM_jZ*[Mlj£�U ¢

Ó vcñ�S=U�_�RTS=UçZ^[�Q�aYaÜ£�U(_jadXMRYXMU�acSjQ(¥$UwRYS=UçaTQ�V~U�Z^��¥�Q eYXEQ�_jZ^U�VWQ�RTeTX�æ�mzæ�yµcÕæ�mDRTSoUç£�XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_jQ�_�ReYl=[MUÜX�aëØ`Q�akUÚ£Î��_èRYS=UaTé$ljQ eYU,���-RTSoUwP�Q�SjQ [�Q _=��Ø=XEa�£�X�akR�Q�_jZ^UQ _`£"XEa�[�XM_=UÚQ eÏ íAk�îSc Q eTà�V~XM_ y íAk±¼�å y î�æ º n í.kC¼¯å y î ³ r

��vcñ�S=U�_�RTS=UJZ^[EQ�aTaÜ£�U�_jakX�RTXMUÚaëSjQ(¥$U£�X�Q à���_jQ [uZ^��¥�Q eYXEQ�_jZ^UwVÎQ RTeYXEZ^UÚa^m�ë y c©£�X�Q àjíeì Ày n pqrqrqr p�ì Ày s îfmRYS=U£�XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_jQ�_�R-eYl=[MUÜX�a�à�X�¥$U(_WØ�qâQ�£=£sXMRTX�¥$U�é$ljQ�£�efQ RYXEZ�Z^��_sRTeYXMØ=loRTXM��_ja��§eT��V3U�Q�Z�S~¥�Q eYXEQ Øo[MU

Ï íAk�îmcûQ�eTà�VâXM_ y sËg Ì nîí íed�gm¼�å y g(î Àì Ày g é [M��à�ì Ày gðï r¬�v�hi_wRYS=XEa@akX�V~}=[�U�akRïZ(Q�adU$m�ãcS=U(_RTS=U�Z^[EQ�aTa�£sU(_jakX�RTX�U�a�SjQ(¥$U�RYS=UcaYQ V~Uu£�X�Q à���_jQ [`Z^��¥�Q�eTX�Q _jZ^UuVWQ RYeTX�æëWcû£�XEQ�àjí�ì Àn pqrqrqr p3ì Às î�m=RYS=U£�XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_jQ�_�R-eYl=[MUÜX�a�[MX�_=U�Q e�Q�_j£"à�XM¥$U(_âØ�q

Ï í.k�îmc�Q�eTà�VâXM_ y sËg Ì n íedÁg%¼�å y g(î Àì Àg rñåU~eTU^�§U�ewRT�Êak}jU�Z^X�Q [�Z(Q�adU�a��èQ�_j£ß¬�Q�a�£�X�Q à���_jQ [�é$ljQ�£�e�Q�RTXEZ�íi|<ñÝ|�t,î�Q�_j£+[MXM_oU�Q eçíi|*�D|¤t,î£sXEak«Z^eYXMV~X�_jQ _sRÜQ�_jQ [�q=adXEa*m�eYU�ak}jU�Z*RTXM¥$U�[Mq$vú=��e�RTS=UâZ^��eTeTUÚak}j��_j£sXM_=à�aTQ�V~}=[�UçP�� £�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ _sR¤eYl=[MUÚa^m�RYS=U}j��}=lo[EQ RYXM��_äVâU�Q _�¥$U�Z*RT��efa�Q _j£+Z*� ¥�Q�eTXEQ�_jZ^UçVWQ RYeTX�Z^U�aÜQ�eTU~U�adRTX�VWQ RYU�£"�§eT��V6Q"[MUÚQ eT_oXM_=àÊakU(R � m�ØsqRTSoU�aTQ�V~}=[�U,VâU�Q _W¥$U�Z^RY��efa¤Q�_j£�Z^��¥�Q eTX�Q _jZ*UwVWQ�RTeTX�Z^U�a*m=eTU�ad}µUÚZ^RTX�¥$U([Mq ¢Tòå y cóÍk y Q _j£ òæ y cÕô y vÜú=��eRTSoU�Z^��_jakRfQ _sRÜZ^��¥�Q eYXEQ�_jZ^UwVÎQ RTeYXMæâZ(Q�adU$mjRTS=U�}j�$��[�U�£èU�akRYXMVWQ�RTUÜ���uRTS=UZ^��V~V~��_ÎZ^��¥�Q�eTX�Q _jZ^UVWQ RYeTX�æXEa�l`akU�£ ¢ òæõcÎö y í�^Éy�¼ Ó î�ôÉyq¶$íe^÷¼�xáîfv\$X�V~XM[�Q eu£�XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_`Q _sR�eTl=[�U�acQ�a�Q Øj��¥$UQ eYXEakU�X�_WQ�ncQ(q$U�adXEQ�_WZ^��_sRTU�æ�R�m�ãcS=U(eYUÜRTSoU,}oeTU�£�X�Z^RTUÚ£~Z^[EQ�aTa�X�aZ�S=�$adU(_WRT�çVWQ æsXMV~X¦ÿ(UcRYS=U�}j�$akRYU(eTX���eÝZ^[EQ�aTa�}=eY��ØjQ�Ø=XM[�XMRYXMU�a8\�Ù$í�uwcß{îÚ k�îÝü ��� þ­vhi_~��_oUÜ� �@RYS=UëÙ`e�akR�Q }=}o[MXEZ�Q RTX���_ja-� �:Q�£�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ RYXM��_wV~U(RYS=�s£�RT�wà�U(_=UÜU�æ�}=eYU�aTadXM��_W£=Q RfQ�m��¤��[Ml=Ø ��ÇÅ�ÌMÒ ü Ó ��þ�}=eY��}j�$adU�£+Q � ãuU(XMà�S�RYU�£è¥$��RYXM_=àWaYZgSoU(V~Uv�,�§��e,ØoXM_jQ�eTqåZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙ�Z�Q RTX���_Dv��S=X�aêVâU(RTS=�s£èRYl=eT_`a��loR,RY�WصUçQ~V~X�_=��e�¥�Q eYXEQ _sR�� �uRTSoU~aYQ V~}=[�U�P��+eTlo[MUçZ^��eTeTUÚak}j��_j£sXM_=àWRT��ad}µUÚZ^XEQ�[-Z(Q�adUç¬�vçú=��eÜRdãu�Z^[�Q�aTadU�a�{]c Ó Q�_j£W��mjRTS=UaYQ V~}=[�UÜP��åeTl=[�U�Z^[EQ�aTadXÏÙjU�acQ�_è��ØjakU(eY¥�Q RTX���_èkUc í�d�nqpqrqrqrÉp3d�s�îuQ�a Ó X¦ðsËg Ì n íedÁg%¼ Íd À gfî Àòì Àg ¿ sËg Ì n í�d�gm¼ Íd�nAg�î Àòì Àg p

®

Page 9: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

RTS`Q R�XEa^msXÏð sËg Ì n í Íd�nAgm¼ Íd À g*îòì Àg ø d g ¼ í Íd�nAg é Íd À g*î� ù ¿ �Pr

��S=Uâ£�XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_`Q _sRë�§l=_`Z^RTX���_ßZ(Q�_áØjU~eYU(ãceTX�RTRYU(_åQ�aEö gÉú g*mBãcS=U�eTU ú gµcDz�g�í�d�g!¼�û9g*îfmS²�gµc3í Íd�nAgH¼Íd À g^î�¶ òì Àg mBQ�_j£Üû9gBc�í ÍdQnAg é Íd À gfî�¶��svç��S=XEa¤X�aÜQ [�V~�$adRÜRTSoUçaTQ VâU,�§l=_jZ*RTXM��_åQ�aÜljadU�£èXM_Ü����[�l=Ø ��ÇÜÅ�Ì�Ò mU(æoZ^U(}=RD�§��e%²üg:ãcS=XEZ�ST����[Ml=Ø ��Ç:Å�ÌMÒ £�U^Ùj_oU�Q�aS²�g�c©í ÍdQnAgP¼ Íd À g�î�¶¸í òì�nAg é òì À gfî�v-Û¤��RB��_=[MqXEa òì�nAg é òì À g-Q�_l=_sljakl`Q [@ãcQ(q~RT�ÎZ(Q [�Z^l=[EQ�RTUÜRYS=U�adR�Q�_j£=Q ef£èU(eTeY��e�� �uQç£�X¦ð�U�eTU(_jZ*U$m=Ø=l=R�SjQ(¥�X�_=àçakRfQ _j£oQ e�£�£sU(¥�X�Q RYXM��_`aXM_`akRTUÚQ�£~� �-¥�Q�eTXEQ�_jZ^U�a�X�_WRTS=U£�U(_o��V~X�_jQ RY��ec� �%²�gc}=eY�s£�ljZ^U�acRTSoU,ãceY��_=àçl=_=X�R�a*vú=��eU�Q�Z�Sá}oeTU�£�X�Z^RTX���_åVWQ�£sU�Ø�q�RYS=UWZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙjU�e(mS����[MloØ ��Ç�Å�ÌMÒ Q�[Eak�Ê£�U^Ùj_oU~QW}=eTU�£sXEZ^RYXM��_ÃakRYeTU(_oà�RTSïm��\jm=ãcS=X�ZgSWXM_`£�XEZ(Q�RTU�a-RTS=U � VWQ eYà�XM_W����¥sXEZ^RY��eYq��

ýlôÜc VÎQ æjí9þÁnqp þ À î8¼+V~X�_jí9þÁnqp þ À îVÎQ æjí9þÁnqp þ À î é V~XM_�í9þÁnqp þ À î p

ãcS=U(eYU�þ�nwc ö g VWQ�æjí ú g�p��$îQ _j£Þþ À c ö g VWQ�æjí�¼ ú g�p��]îfv°����[�l=Ø ��Ç�Å�Ì�Ò ZgS=�$�¸akUÊQ�Z^��_jadU(eT¥�Q�RTXM¥$U}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTXM��_ßakRYeTU(_oà�RTSßRYS=eTU�adS=��[�£+� �Jv ¬èØjU([M��ã ãcS=X�ZgSÃ_=�á}oeTU�£�X�Z^RTX���_jaQ eYU"VÎQ�£�U$vÊ��S=UW}=eTU�£sXEZ^RYXM��_akRYeTU(_oà�RTS`a"� �Å����[MloØ ��ÇâÅ�ÌMÒ Q eYUáeYU([EQ�RTU�£ RY�äRYS=Uå}=eTU�£sXEZ^RYXM��_�¥$��RTU�aW£�U*Ùj_=U�£ X�_/\$UÚZ^RTX���_û¬�v �H�§��eQ à�à�eYU(à$Q�RTU�£W}=eTU�£sXEZ^RY��e�a*v-t¤_WQ�_jQ [���à�loUw� �:RTSoUÜ¥$��RYU�a�� �u\$U�Z^RYXM��_W¬�v �,�§��ecRTSoU,à�U(_=UÜ¥$��RTX�_=à�}=eTUÚ£�XEZ^RY��eXEaÜà�XM¥$U(_�Øsq�VWQ æjí�þÁnqp þ À î�¶$í�þÁn é þ À îBc VÎQ æjí9þÁnqp þ À î�¶$í VÎQ æjí9þÁnqp þ À î é V~X�_jí9þÁnqp þ À îTî ¿ ýlô�vâÛ¤��RYURTS`Q R�S=U(eTUÝRTS=U�¥$��RYXM_=à�X�a���¥$U(ecà�U(_oU�a�e�Q�RTS=U(ecRYSjQ _�}=eTUÚ£�XEZ^RY��efa^v

�!��� ÿ�¡�¦S¢�¡8��«Þ¥!¡8���  ��E×�¢�¨ £9¦m���Á���|¡ ¢��Û¤U�Q�eTU�adR¤_oU(XMà�S�Øj��eJíiÛÜÛ,î-VâU(RTS=�s£oa¤Q�eTU�ØjQ�akU�£è��_åQ~£�XEadR�Q�_jZ^U,�§lo_jZ^RTX���_W�§��eÜ}jQ�XMefa¤� �-��ØjakU�eT¥�Q RYXM��_`a^makl`ZgSåQ�aêRYS=U]7�ljZ^[�XE£�U�Q�_�£�X�akRfQ _jZ^U���eÜ��_oU�V~X�_�l`a�RTS=UçZ^��eTeYU([EQ�RTXM��_Dv�ú=��e�RTSoUwà�U�_=U�U(æs}=eTU�aYakX���_å£=Q�R�QZ^��_jakX�£�U(eTUÚ£äS=U(eYU$m-RTS=UÊ£�XEadR�Q _`Z^UèØjU(Rdã�U�U(_ßRkãu�áVÎb¤ÛÜt�aTQ�V~}=[�U�a^m-ãcXMRYS à�U�_=UèU(æs}=eYU�aTadXM��_1}=eT��Ùj[MUÚakÞc�íedQn�pqrqrqr p�dÁs�î�Q _`£ k ³ c�í�d ³ n pqr�rqrzp3d ³s îfm�XEa¤Ø`Q�akUÚ£è��_åRTS=UçZ^��eTeYU([EQ�RTXM��_�ØjU(Rdã�U(U(_�RTS=U�XMe�Rkãu�~à�U�_=UU(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_W}=eY� Ùj[�U�a ¢

Ù��� ��zc ö sg Ì n í�d g ¼ Ídïîfí�d ³g ¼ Íd ³ î� ö sg Ì n íedÁg%¼ Íd�î À � ö sg Ì n í�d ³g ¼ Íd ³ î À r��S=Uµ{ ¡j�YÅ$�g�T�*Çu¡µ�*È�� Ä É��$� eYl=[MU¸m=£�l=U�RY�çúBXMæâQ _j£è�¤�s£�à�U�awü Ó ��þim�}oeT�sZ^U(UÚ£=a¤Q�a��§��[�[M��ã�a�RT�âZ^[EQ�aTadXÏ�§qçRTU�adRakU�RÜ��ØjadU(eT¥�Q�RTXM��_ja,��_áRYS=U�ØjQ�akXEaÜ���cRTSoU�[MU�Q�eT_=X�_=àWakU�R(v�ú=��e�U�Q�ZgS�U�[MU(V~U�_�RuXM_åRTS=U�RYU�akR�adU(R ¢ í§X î�Ù`_j£RTSoU<{JZ^[M�¸akU�adR-��ØjadU(eT¥�Q RYXM��_ja�X�_�RTS=U�[MU�Q�eT_=X�_=àakU(R�msQ _j£Wí X�X îD}=eYU�£�X�Z^R�RTSoUÜZ^[�Q�aYaOØsq�VWQ5�d��eTX�Rkq�¥$��RTU$m È ÒE��Ò mZ�S=�$�$adUwRTSoUwZ*[EQ�aYa�RTSjQ�R¤X�a�V~�$adRcZ^��V~V~��_~Q�V~��_=àçRTSo�$akUµ{ç_=U(X�à�SsØj��e�a*v��S=UW_sl=V�ØjU(e����Ü_=U�XMà�SsØj��efa {åXEaZgSo�$akU�_äØsqßZ^eY�$aYak«§¥�Q�[MX�£=Q RYXM��_ïm�RYSjQ R�X�a^m-Ø�qåeTl=_o_=XM_=à�RYS=UW_=U�Q�eTU�adR_=U(X�à�SsØj��eZ^[EQ�aTadXÏÙjU(e���_åRTSoU�[MU�Q�eT_=X�_=àWakU�RÜ��_=[�q$vE7�Q�ZgS���ØjakU�eT¥�Q RYXM��_åXM_�RYS=U�[MUÚQ eT_oXM_=àWadU(RÜX�a¤RTeYU�Q RYU�£XM_WRYl=eT_ÊQ�a¤X¦��X�Rcã�U(eYU,X�_èRYS=U�RTU�adRÜadU(R ¢ XMRfac£�XEadR�Q _`Z^UwRY�~Q�[M[D� �ORTS=U��RTSoU(e¤[�U�Q eY_=XM_oàçakU(R���ØjadU(eT¥�Q�RTXM��_jaí U�æ=Z^U�}=RBX�R�adU([Ï�*îDX�a�Z^��Vâ}=l=RTUÚ£wQ _`£ìX�R�XEa�Z*[EQ�aYakX¦ÙjU�£wØsq,RYS=Uc_=U�Q�eTU�adR-_=U(XMà�S�Øj��e�eTl=[�U$v���SoU�Z^[EQ�aTakX¦Ù�Z(Q�RTXM��_�§��e@U�Q�ZgSÜ[�U�Q eY_=XM_oàÜadU(RD��ØjadU(eT¥�Q�RTXM��_wX�a�RTS=U(_Z^��V~}jQ�eTU�£¤RY�¤RYS=U-RTeYl=RTSRT�c}=eY�s£�ljZ^UuRTS=UuZ^eY�$aTad« ¥�Q�[MXE£oQ RTX���_U(eYeT��e�efQ RTU¸v���S=XEa�XEa�£���_oUw�§��eQ~_�l=VçØjU(e�� ��{ � awí§S=U(eTUw{��Î� Ó p�r¹r¹r�p�� Ó ��î�Q _`£ùRYS=Uw{"�§��eÜãcS=X�ZgS�RYS=UZ^eY�$aTad« ¥�Q�[MXE£oQ RTX���_�U(eTeY��ece�Q�RTUXEacakVÎQ [M[�U�akR-X�a�eTU(RfQ XM_oU�£��§��ecljadUw��_WRYS=U�RTU�adR�akU(R�v

¨

Page 10: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

�!�� �Ü£�¦m�������B¨ ¦S«Á�9×�¥ «�¢�¡�¡8�� ÈE¡oÅ$�^ÍwÇ­�g���c�*Ç­�^Æs�^Ç­Æ����Y���^̦Š����È }c�*�T� Q eTUêZ^��_jadRTeYljZ^RTUÚ£ìØsq�eYU(}jU�Q RYU�£~ad}=[MX�R�a�� �:adl=ØjakU�R�aÜí _o�s£�U�agî:� �@RYS=UV~U�Q�akl=eYU(V~U(_sR�ak}`Q�Z^U±~9X�_�RY�"Rdãu��£�U�aYZ^U(_j£oQ _sRwadl=ØjadU(R�a*m-akR�Q�eTRYXM_=à�ãcX�RTS¯~ X�R�adU([Ï�YvÅ7�Q�ZgSÃRTU(eYV~XM_jQ�[akloØjakU(RcX�a�Q�aTakX�à�_=UÚ£~Q�Z^[EQ�aTa-[EQ ØjU([ïQ _j£~RYS=UÜeTUÚakl=[�RTXM_oàw}jQ�eTRTX�RTX���_~���2~ Z*��eTeYU�ak}j��_j£=acRT�wRYS=U�Z^[�Q�aYakXÏÙ`U(e(v

��S=U(eYU�Q eYU¤RYS=eTU(UcVÎQ XM_JQ�ad}µUÚZ^R�a�RT��RYeTU(U�Z^��_jakRYeTljZ*RTXM��_ ¢ í§X îDRYS=UÝakU([�U�Z^RTX���_� �DRYS=U�ak}o[MXMRfa^öjí X�X î�RTS=UÝ£�U�Z*XM«akX���_~RY��£�UÚZ^[EQ�eTUÝQ,_=�s£�UÝRTU(eYV~XM_jQ�[���e�RY��Z^��_�RYXM_sl=UÜad}=[MX�RTRYXM_=àoöµí§XMX�X îDRYS=U�Q�aYakX�à�_=V~U�_�R����@U�Q�Z�SçRTU(eYV~XM_jQ�[_=�s£�URT�çQçZ^[EQ�aTa*v

|¤X¦ð�U�eTU(_sRÜRTeYU(UâZ^[EQ�aTakX¦ÙjU(efaêl`akUâ£�XÏð�U(eYU(_�RêQ }=}=eY�$Q�ZgS=UÚa,RT�Ê£�U�Q�[�ãcX�RTSåRTS=UÚakU�RTSoeTU(UçXEaYakl=U�a*vw�¤U�eTU$m�ãuUljadU�RYS=U�- ��;  «]- ̦Š����È }u��Å�Ç­ÈE�$¡ù�Ý¡=�÷;Ý�.�$�g�Y����ÈE�$¡  �g���T� «cV~U�RTS=�s£�£�UÚaTZ^eYXMØjU�£èXM_Ãn�eTU�XMVWQ�_ �fÇ�Å�ÌMÒü ¨�þuQ _j£�XMV~}o[MU(VçU(_sRTU�£ÎX�_áRYS=UWrutÜb�� ad� �§RdãcQ�eTUç¥$U(e�adXM��_ Ó v ¬ Ó �åíiQ [�ak��XMV~}=[�U(VçU(_$RTU�£~X�_áRYS=U"\¸«���[Ml`a�§l=_jZ*RTXM��_ ¹=³=¶s¶���� îfvB\$X�_=à�[�U�}=eYl=_=U�£wRYeTU(U�a:Q eTUcà�eT��ãc_çljakX�_=à Ó ��« �§��[E£çZ^eT�¸aTad« ¥�Q [�XE£=Q�RTX���_��§��e-U�akRYXMVWQ�RTX�_=àRTSoUwZ*[EQ�aYakX¦Ù�Z(Q RYXM��_"U�eTeT��e(v

�!��� ������¢�¡��0¦S«Á��¥��ਠ£�¦m�������B¡ ¢��n�eTU�XMVWQ�_ûü �smë��þc�§��l=_`£ RTSjQ�R�à¸Q XM_`aÎX�_�Q�Z(Z^l=efQ�Z^q1Z^��l=[E£ßصU���Ø=R�Q�XM_=UÚ£äØsq Åq���$�g�.�$Å�Ç­ÈE¡��� ��g�Y�$ÈE�^Ç­�$�T�Ø=l=X�[MR¤�§eY��V }jU(eYRTl=eYصUÚ£ù¥$U(efakX���_jaÜ� ��RTS=U�[�U�Q eY_=XM_oàèadU(RçíiadU(U~\$U�Z^RYXM��_ja�¬�v �sv Ó Q _`£+¬�v ��v ���§��ew£sXÏð�U(eTU�_�RV~U(RYS=�s£=aë�§��e�à�U(_=U�e�Q RYXM_=àW}jU(eYRTl=eYصUÚ£ù[�U�Q eY_=XM_=à�adU(R�a�î�vçhi_åZ^[EQ�aTakX¦Ù�Z(Q�RTXM��_DmDRTS=UçVçl=[MRYXM}=[�UÜ¥$U(e�adXM��_jaÜ� �RTSoUè}=eYU�£�XEZ*RT��efa�Z�Q _ ØjUÊQ à�à�eTU(à¸Q RYU�£ Ø�q  j̦Æs�TÅ�Ì ÈMÇiÍÜ����ÇiÈE¡�� m È ÒE��Ò m�RTS=U � ãcX�_=_=XM_oà:�+Z^[�Q�aYaìX�aìRYS=Uè��_=UØjU(XM_oàè}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTU�£áØsq�RTSoU~[EQ�eTà�UÚakR�_sl=V�ØjU(eÝ� �Ý}=eTU�£sXEZ^RY��e�a*v���S=U~ØoXEQ�a�Q�_j£á¥�Q eYXEQ�_jZ^U~}=eY��}jU(eYRTXMUÚaw� �Q à�à�eYU(à$Q�RTU�£ß}=eTU�£sXEZ^RY��e�awãuU(eTUÎakRTl`£�XMU�£+X�_ n�eYU(XMVÎQ _ ü �(þ­v+��S=UWp$U(qåRT��X�V~}=eY� ¥$UÚ£áQ�Z(Z^l=efQ�Z^qåXEawRYS=U}j�$aYakXMØo[MU�XM_jadR�Q�Ø=XM[�XMRdq�� �:RTS=U�}=eYU�£�X�Z^RTX���_~V~U�RTS=�s£�m È ÒE�(Ò m�ãcSoU(RTS=U�e�akVWQ�[M[�ZgS`Q _=à�U�a�XM_WRTSoU,[�U�Q eY_=XM_oà�akU�ReTUÚakl=[�RcXM_W[EQ�eTà�UJZgS`Q _=à�U�a�XM_�RTS=U�}=eYU�£�XEZ*RT��e�v-�¤_jadR�Q Øo[MU�}=eT�sZ*U�£�l=eYU�aëRYU(_j£WRT�çصU�_=U^ÙjRcRYS=U�V~�$adR��§eT��VQ à�à�eYU(à$Q�RTXM��_Dvár-[�Q�aTadXÏÙ�Z�Q RTX���_ßRTeYU(U�aÜRTU�_j£áRT��ØjU~l=_jadR�Q Øo[MU~ãcS=X�[MU$m��§��ewU(æoQ V~}o[MU$m�_oU�Q eYU�akR_=U(XMà�S�Øj��eV~U(RYS=�s£=aÜRTU�_j£ùRY�èØjUWadR�Q Øo[MU$v~ñåU�ãcX�[M[-RTSslja�Q à�à�eYU(à$Q�RTUW��_=[�q�RTS=U�rutÜb��/}oeTU�£�X�Z^RT��e�a*vW��S=U�RYeTU(UÚaljadU�£ì�§��euQ�à�à�eYU(à$Q�RTX���_�Q eYUÜVWQ æsXMVÎQ [ � U�æ�}=[���efQ RT��eTqÁ�,RYeTU(U�a*m$XM_çRTS=UÝakU(_`akUÜRYSjQ RuRTS=U(qJQ eYUÜà�eY� ãc_âl=_�RYXM[U�Q�ZgSWRTU�eTV~X�_jQ [j_=�s£�UJZ^��_sR�Q�XM_ja���ØjakU�eT¥�Q RYXM��_`a��§eY��V'��_=[Mq�Q�akX�_=à�[�UZ^[EQ�aTa^v

Pè��eYUÜ}=eYU�Z^XEadU([Mq¸m�[MU(R!��í��¹p ��� îu£�U�_=��RYUÜRTS=UêZ^[EQ�aTakX¦ÙjU(euØ=l=XM[�R��§eT��V�RTSoUlûTRYSW}µU�eTRTloeTØjU�£�[�U�Q eY_=XM_=àJakU(R ���Q _`£ì[�U(R�� � £�U(_=��RTU�RTS=UcãuU(XMà�S�R�à�XM¥$U(_�RY��}=eTU�£sXEZ^RYXM��_`aBVWQ�£sUcØ�qRTS=X�a�Z*[EQ�aYakX¦ÙjU(e(v:��S=Uc}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTU�£�Z^[�Q�aYa�§��eÝQ _W��ØjakU(eY¥�Q RTX���_èkáX�a�à�XM¥$U�_"Øsq

Q�eTà�VÎQ æ y Ë � � �! í9�JíAkmp ��� îmcÎ{=î3pãcS=U(eYU í�rÏî-£sU(_=��RYU�a�RTSoU,X�_j£�X�Z(Q RY��e��§l=_jZ*RTXM��_Dm=U�é$ljQ [�XM_=à Ó X¦��RYS=UZ^��_`£�XMRYXM��_WX�_"}`Q eTU�_�RYS=U�akUÚa�XEa�RTeYl=U$mQ _`£è�w��RYS=U(eYãcXEakU¸v

ú=��e�Q�à�à�eTU(à¸Q RTUÚ£áZ^[�Q�aYakXÏÙ`U(e�a*m  ����Y�$ÈE�^ÇiÈE�$¡��(��Çd�T� í��#"wî�Q�aTadU�aTadXM_=àWRTSoU�akRYeTU(_oà�RTS�����Q�}oeTU�£�X�Z^RTX���_�VWQ(qØjU£�U^Ùj_=UÚ£â�§��e¤UÚQ�Z�S"��ØjakU�eT¥�Q RYXM��_ïv���S=U�}=eYU�£�X�Z^RTX���_~¥$��RTUÜ�§��e�Q�_è��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_CkåXEac£sU^Ùj_=U�£~RY��ØjU

ýlþçíAk�îSc VWQ æ y ö � � �! í���íAkmp ��� îSc¤{=îö � � � rÓ �

Page 11: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

ñ�S=U(_�RYS=Uw}jU(eYRTl=eYØjU�£è[MU�Q�eT_=X�_=àâakU(RfaÜQ eYUwà�X�¥$U(_èUÚé]ljQ�[BãuU(XMà�S�Rfa^m È ÒE�(Ò � � c Ó m�RYS=Uw}oeTU�£�X�Z^RTX���_�¥$��RTUXEacadXMV~}o[MqçRTS=U�}=eY��}j��eYRTXM��_�� �-¥$��RTU�a��§��e�RTSoU � ãcXM_=_oXM_=àü��Z^[�Q�aYa^mjeTU(à¸Q e�£s[MU�aYaë���-ãcS=U(RYS=U(ecXMRcX�a¤Z*��eTeYU�Z^R��eÝ_=��R�v���eTU�£sXEZ^RYXM��_�¥$��RYU�aëØjU([���_=àâRT�åüý��p Ó þivÜ��SoUwS=��}µU�X�aëRYSjQ RÝRTS=U�VWQ�à�_=X�RTlj£sU,���uRTS=U}=eTU�£sXEZ^RYXM��_¥$��RYU¤ãcX�[M[=eYU /jU�Z*R�S=��ãûZ^��_sÙ�£�U(_sR�ã�UÝZ(Q�_~ØjU¤���@Q,à�XM¥$U(_�}oeTU�£�X�Z^RTX���_Dv:Û¤��RYU¤RYSjQ Rc\sZ�SjQ�}=XMeYU ��ÇOÅ�ÌMÒ üý�]��þljadU,}oeTU�£�X�Z^RTX���_W¥$��RYU�a^msãcS=XEZ�SWRTS=U�q~Z(Q�[M[ � ã�U(X�à�SsR�a��sm=RT�çZ(Q�[EZ^lo[EQ RYU�RTS=U(X�ecZ^[�Q�aYakXÏÙµZ(Q RYXM��_WVWQ�eTà�XM_ja*v��S=U(eYU�Q eTU�Rdã��åVWQ X�_ßZ^[EQ�aTadU�aì����V~U(RYS=�s£=a,�§��e�à�U(_=U(efQ RTX�_=àå}µU�eTRTloeTØjU�£ä¥$U�e�akX���_jaw����RTSoU"[�U�Q eY_=XM_oàakU�R ¢ ØjQ�à�à�X�_=àçQ _`£"Øj�$�$adRTXM_oà=vuh¼_WRYS=U É �$��R�akRYe�Q�} Åq�q� eYU(à$Q�R ÈE¡�� ��e É�Åq�q�$ÈE¡�� }=eY�sZ^U�£�loeTUâü ��þim�}jU(eYRTl=eYØjU�£[MUÚQ eT_oXM_=àWadU(R�a�� �cRYS=UçaTQ�V~U�adXMÿ(UçQ�aÜRTS=U���eTXMà�XM_jQ�[�[MUÚQ eT_oXM_=àWadU(R�Q�eTU��§��eTVâU�£"Øsq"�§��eTV~X�_=à�Øj�$��R�akRYe�Q�}eTU�}=[MX�Z(Q RYU�a�� �:RTS=UÜ[�U�Q eY_=XM_oà�akU�R(v-hi_ É���� �*ÇiÈE¡?� RYS=U�£=Q�R�QçQ eYUÜeTU(«­aTQ�V~}=[�U�£ Å$�$Å^ jÇ­È�� ��Ì Í Q _j£~RTSoU,}oeTU�£�X�Z^«RT��e�a�Q eYUwQ�à�à�eTU(à¸Q RTUÚ£èØ�q Ð��*È�� Ä Çd�Y� ¥$��RYXM_=à�ü Ó � þ­v$&%(')%�* + ®-,.,0/�1�,243.1&5768®-8v®-9;:=<>8?/�@BA�3&3C<>D�<8v®-6 % hi_èRYS=U�adXMV~}o[MU�adR��§��eTV � �uØjQ�à�à�X�_=à=m�}µU�eTRTloeTØjU�£�[MU�Q�eT_=X�_=à~adU(R�a�� �RTSoUÜaYQ V~U�akXMÿ�U�Q�a�RYS=U���eTX�à�X�_jQ [=[�U�Q eY_=XM_oàwadU(RuQ eYU��§��eTVâU�£wØ�qJ£�e�Q(ãcX�_=à�Q�R�efQ _j£s��V ãcXMRYS�eYU(}=[�Q�Z^U(VâU(_�R�§eT��V©RTS=Uu[MU�Q�eT_=X�_=àÜadU(R(m È ÒE�(Ò m�ØsqÜ�§��eYV~XM_=àc_o��_=«§}jQ efQ V~U�RTeTX�Z�ص�$��R�adRTe�Q�}�eYU(}=[�XEZ(Q�RTU�a�����RYS=U�[�U�Q eY_=XM_oàÜadU(R(v��eTU�£sXEZ^RY��e�auQ eYUÜØ=l=X�[MR��§��ecU�Q�ZgSç}jU(eTRYl=eTØjU�£W£=Q�R�Q�akU(R�Q _j£WQ à�à�eYU(à$Q�RTU�£~Øsq�}=[�l=e�Q�[MX�Rkq�¥$��RTX�_=àçí�� � c Ó îfv

tÜa�£�U(V~��_jakRYe�Q�RTU�£~XM_Ên�eTU(X�VWQ _ùü � þ­mµRYS=UwØ`Q à�à�XM_=àâ}=eT�sZ^UÚ£�l=eTU�S`Q�ac¥�Q�[MljQ�Ø=[MUØ�qs«§}=eT�s£�l`Z^R�a*vÜtcR¤U�Q�ZgSXMRYU(e�Q�RTX���_Dm:Q Øj��l=Rç¬$�FE � ��RYS=U~��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_jawX�_+RTS=Uç��eYXMà�XM_jQ�[�[MUÚQ eT_oXM_=à�akU�R�£���_=��R�Q�}=}jU�Q e�X�_áRYS=UØj�$��RfakRTefQ }�[�U�Q eY_=XM_=àåadU(R � � v+��S=U�adU �$Æ]Ç.d�k��dÉ�Åq� ��ØjadU(eT¥�Q RYXM��_jaìqsXMU�[E£åQ _ lo_�ljadU�£+RTU�adR�adU(Rw�§��e�RYS=U}=eYU�£�XEZ*RT��eµ�Jí��¹p � � îÜãcXMRYSá_o�èQ�£=£�X�RTXM��_jQ [�Z^��Vâ}=l=RTX�_=àWZ^�¸akR�v~��S=U~��l=RT«§� �§«§ØjQ�à���ØjadU(eT¥�Q RYXM��_jawZ(Q�_+ØjUljadU�£~RT�çU�akRYXMVWQ�RTU�V~XEaYZ^[EQ�aTakX¦Ù�Z(Q�RTXM��_~e�Q�RTU�a����-ØjQ�à�à�UÚ£"}=eYU�£�XEZ*RT��efacQ�a��§��[�[M��ã�a ¢

Ó^0G Ë f IH u5fKJc Q�eTà�VWQ æ y ËL �NMPO ��QR� S�QUT�VW�XFY�Z í���íAk f.p ��� îmc¤{=î\[�r��SjQ�RcXEa^m��§��e�U�Q�ZgSç��ØjadU(eT¥�Q�RTXM��_åíAk f p�u f î�X�_~RTS=U�[MUÚQ eT_oXM_=àJakU(R � m=Q�}=eTUÚ£�XEZ^RYXM��_�X�aO��Ø=R�Q�XM_=UÚ£ÎØsqçQ à�à�eYU(«à$Q�RTX�_=àèRYS=UçZ^[EQ�aTadXÏÙjU(efal��í���p � � îÝakljZ�SåRTSjQ�R�í.k f p3u f î÷¶� � � vç��S=U���l=RT«§� �§«§ØjQ à�UÚakRTX�VWQ RYUw���cRTSoU�U(eYeT��ee�Q�RTU�XEa�RYS=U�U(eTeY��e�e�Q�RTUÜ�§��ecRYS=U�akU���l=RT«§� �§«§ØjQ àW}=eYU�£�X�Z^RTX���_ja*v

t�à�U(_oU(e�Q�[B}=eY��Ø=[�U(V'���-RTS=U�_=��_=«§}jQ efQ V~U(RYeTX�ZêØj�$��R�akRYe�Q�}ù�§��eÜadVWQ [�[D£=Q�R�Q�adU(R�acXEacRTSoUw£sXEaTZ*eTU(RYU(_=U�aYa�� �RTSoUWaTQ�V~}=[MX�_=à�ak}jQ�Z^U$vèñåUW£�UÚaTZ^eYXMØjU~_=U(æsR�Rdã��èVâU(RTS=�s£oaê�§��eà�U(RYRTX�_=àåQ eY��l=_j£+RYS=XEa�}=eT��Ø=[MU(V ¢ RYS=U}jQ�e�Q VâU(RTeYXEZ¤Øj�$��RfakRYe�Q }åQ�_j£"RYS=U�ljakU����uZ^��_s¥$U(æç}jakU�lj£���«­£=Q�R�Q�v

]!®-8v®-9;:=<8/�@^A�3&3-<D�<>85®_6 % hi_áRYS=XEaÜ}jQ�e�Q VâU(RTeYXEZ,�§��eYV � ��ØjQ�à�à�XM_=àom�}µU�eTRTloeTØjU�£�[MU�Q�eT_=X�_=à�akU(RfawQ eYUà�U�_=U(e�Q�RTU�£ûQ�Z�Z^��ef£�XM_=àßRY� QßV~XMæsRTloeTUW� �JV�l=[�RTX�¥�Q�eTX�Q RTU�_=��eYVWQ [JíiP4"�Û,îì£�XEadRTeTX�Ø=l=RYXM��_`aèí }jU(efak��_`Q [Z^��V~V�lo_=XEZ*Q RYXM��_�ãcX�RTS�P�Q eYp�¥�Q�_è£sU(e��DQ�Q _�îfvcú=��e�UÚQ�Z�SWZ^[EQ�aTa�{jmsRTS=UÝV~U�Q _â¥$U�Z^RT��euQ _j£�Z^��¥�Q�eTX�Q _jZ^UVWQ�RTeTX�æw����RYS=UÜVçl=[MRYXM¥�Q eYXEQ RYUc_=��eYVWQ [�£�X�akRYeTXMØol=RTX���_WQ�eTUÜRfQ p$U(_~RY�wØjU�RTS=UêZ^[EQ�aTa�aYQ V~}o[MU�V~U�Q _ç¥$U�Z^RY��eQ _`£"Z*� ¥�Q�eTXEQ�_jZ^UÜVÎQ RTeYXMæ�m�eTUÚak}jU�Z^RYXM¥$U([�q$v@��S=U�Z^[�Q�aTa-V~XMæsXM_oà,}oeT��Ø`Q Ø=X�[MXMRYXMU�a-Q�eTU�R�Q�p$U(_~RT�ØjU,RYS=U�Z^[�Q�aYa}=eY��}j��eYRTXM��_ja¤X�_"RYS=UQ�Z^RYljQ [@[MUÚQ eT_oXM_=àçadU(R(v-ñáU�eYU�é]loXMeTUÝRTSjQ�RÜQ�R¤[�U�Q�adRc��_=U���Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_�ØjUaTQ Vâ}=[MU�£�§eT��VÞUÚQ�Z�SWZ^[EQ�aTa*vm�OeYU�£�X�Z^RT��e�a�Q�eTUÜØol=XM[�RO�§��ecU�Q�Z�Sç}µU�eTRTloeTØjU�£W£=Q RfQ�adU(R�Q _j£âQ à�à�eTU(à¸Q RYU�£"Øsq�}=[Mloe�Q [�XMRdq¥$��RYXM_=àÃí�� � c Ó î�vWñáUWZ*��_jadXE£�U(eJaTQ�V~}=[MX�_=à��§eY��V6V�l=[�RTX�¥�Q�eTX�Q RTU�_o��eTVÎQ [u£�XEadRTeYXMØ=l=RYXM��_jaÜãcXMRTSÃص��RTS

Ó�Ó

Page 12: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

£�X�Q à���_jQ [:Q _`£"_=��_=«i£sXEQ à���_jQ�[-Z^��¥�Q eYXEQ _`Z^U�VWQ RYeTXEZ*U�a^v

`a3.1QÃ)::kb6�D�:dc�e�3C5fe�®g<v® % �¤X�¥$U(_Që[�U�Q eY_=XM_oàÜadU(R � c��$í.k8n p3u?ngî�pqrqrqr p(í.k �q��p�u5����î3�$m$n�eYU(XMVWQ�_çü ®(þoakl=à�«à�UÚakR�acZ*eTU�Q�RTXM_oà�}µU�eTRTloeTØjU�£"[�U�Q eY_=XM_oà�akU�R�a�ØjQ�akU�£W��_ ���$¡�� ��4 =���*Æs�$��d�$Å�ǭů� - Y 10��vÁ7-Q�Z�S"}jU(eYRTl=eYØjU�£[MUÚQ eT_oXM_=àçadU(RcXEa�à�U(_=U(efQ RTUÚ£ÎØsq~eYU(}jU�Q RYXM_=àçRTS=UÜ�§��[M[M��ãcX�_=àµ^.G"RYXMV~UÚa ¢Ó vÜ\$U�[MU�Z^RuRdã���XM_`akR�Q�_jZ^U�aÜí.kmp3u=î-Q _`£áíAk ³ p3u ³ î�Q RcefQ _j£s��V'�§eT��V'RTS=U�[�U�Q eY_=XM_=àçadU(R � v��vÜ\$U�[MU�Z^R�Q RcefQ _j£���V Qì_sl=VçصU�e ú �§eT��VòRTS=U�XM_sRTU�eT¥�Q [Oü ��p Ê þimj�ih Ê h Ó m�Q�_j£~[MU(R!Äwc Ó ¼ ú v¬�v���S=U�_=U�ã×X�_jakRfQ _jZ^U�X�aÜíAk ³Û³�p3u ³ ³Mî-ãcS=U(eYUEu ³ ³Qc_u~Q _`£÷k ³ ³�c_Ä�k é ú k ³¦v

tÜa-XM_~ØjQ�à�à�XM_=àomµVçl=[MRYXM}=[�UcQ�[MRTU�eTU�£�[�U�Q eY_=XM_oà�akU�R�a ��� m�� �:RTSoU�aTQ�V~U�akX�ÿ(UÝQ�a�RTSoU,��eTX�à�XM_`Q [�[�U�Q eY_=XM_oà�akU�R� mïQ eTUçà�U�_=U(e�Q�RTU�£�Q�_j£�Q à�à�eYU(à$Q�RTU�£áØsqW}=[Mloe�Q [�XMRdqW¥$��RYXM_=àovwÛ¤��RTURTSjQ�R,ãcSoU(_ Ê XEaÜ�smOr��-| eTU�£sljZ^U�aRT��Ø`Q à�à�XM_=àomjQ _j£~RYSjQ RuRTS=UÜ[�Q eYà�U(e Ê m=RTS=U�à�eYU�Q RYU(ecRTS=UêQ V~��l=_�R-���-adV~�$��RYS=XM_=àov�hi_~}=efQ�Z^RYXEZ^U¸m]ãcSoU(_�QRTUÚakR�akU�RcXEa�_=��RÜQ(¥�Q X�[EQ Øo[MU Ê Z*��l=[�£ÎØjUJZgS=�¸akU(_WØsq~Z*eT�$aYak«§¥�Q [MX�£=Q RYXM��_Dv$&%(')%kj + 3&30Dl</N1�,n��$�$adRTX�_=àáã�Q�a,ÙjefakRç}=eT��}j�$akUÚ£äØsq+ú=eTU�l=_j£ßQ _j£�\sZ�SjQ }=X�eTUåü Ó ��þivÜ��U(eTU$m�RYS=U�£=Q RfQ�Q eYU"eYU(«­aTQ Vâ}=[MU�£Å$�$Å^ jÇ­È�� ��Ì¦Í ad�èRTS`Q RwRYS=U~ãuU(XMà�S�RfaêX�_+RTSoU�eYU(«iaYQ V~}o[MXM_oàèQ�eTU~X�_jZ^eYU�Q�adU�£Ê�§��e�RTS=�¸akUWZ�Q�akUÚa,V~�¸akR�� �§RYU(_V~X�aTZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙjUÚ£�vc��S=UJQ à�à�eTU(à¸Q RYXM��_å� �u}=eYU�£�X�Z^RT��e�acXEa�£���_=U�Øsq Ð��gÈ�� Ä Çk�Y� ¥$��RYXM_=àov¤Pè��eTU}=eTU�Z*XEakU�[Mq$m��§��eQ�[MU�Q�eT_=X�_=àçakU(R � c��$íAk8n�p3u�n^î�pqrqrqrÉp(íAk ����p3uv�q�=î3�$ms[MU(RB�3\Ánqpqrqrqr p�\P�q���£�U(_=��RTUwRYS=U�eTU(«­aTQ�V~}=[�XM_=à}=eT��Ø=«Q ØoXM[MX�RTX�U�a^m=X�_=XMRYXEQ [�XMÿ(UÚ£ÎRY�~ØjU�U�é$ljQ [­vÜ��S=UwûYRTSÊakRTU�}�� �uRTS=U�Øj�$�¸akRTX�_=à�Q [�à���eYXMRYS=V ü �(þuíiQ _ÃQ�£oQ }=RfQ RTX���_� �Im ²=°!n�LPL=¯�¹ îïXEaÓ v��ÜadXM_=àåRTSoUåZ^l=eTeYU(_sR�eYU(«iaYQ V~}o[MXM_oà�}=eT��ØjQ Ø=X�[MX�RTXMUÚa÷�3\Ánqpqrqrqr p�\P�q���$mcaYQ V~}=[�UWãcXMRTS�eYU(}=[�Q�Z^U(VâU(_�R�§eY��V � RT��à�U(RÜQw[�U�Q eY_=XM_oàçakU(R ��� � ��akXMÿ�UB^0G�v

��v�n�l=X�[E£~QçZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙjU�e���í��¹p ��� î-ØjQ�akU�£W��_ ��� v¬�v�bcl=_�RTSoUw[MUÚQ eT_oXM_=àâakU(R � RTS=eY��l=à�S�RTS=UJZ^[EQ�aTadXÏÙjU(eB��í��¹p ��� î�Q�_j£è[MU(R Ê fSc Ó XÏ�-RYS=Uµj RYSåZ(Q�adUwX�aZ^[�Q�aYakXÏÙ`U�£~XM_jZ^��eTeYU�Z^RT[�qçQ _j£ Ê f cû�ì��RTS=U�eTãcXEadU$v

ª=v�|¤U*Ùj_=U o � c Ë f \�f Ê f Q _`£ p � c©í Ó ¼ o � î�¶ o �Q�_j£"l=}�£=Q�RTURTS=U�eTU�«iaYQ V~}=[�XM_=à}=eT��ØjQ ØoXM[MX�RTX�U�aO�§��e¤RYS=Uçí9û é Ó îdadR�akRYU(}èØsq

\�f c \�f�p�q Q�ö f \ f p q Q� rtë�§RYU(e�´�akRYU(}ja^m=RYS=UZ^[EQ�aTadXÏÙjU(efa���í��¹p � n î3p�rqrqrzp���í���p �sr îuQ�eTUQ à�à�eYU(à$Q�RTU�£èØsq~ã�U�XMà�SsRTUÚ£�¥$��RYXM_=àom�ãcXMRYS��í��¹p � � îcSjQ(¥sXM_=àWãuU(XMà�S�Rt� � c [���àjí\p � î�vJh¼_�RYS=UçU(¥$U(_sR¤RYSjQ R o � ¿ Ó ¶Ú�"��e o � c �~RYS=U�eTU(«­aTQ�V~}=[�XM_=à}=eY��ØjQ�Ø=XM[�XMRTX�U�aÜQ�eTUçeTU�adU(R�RT�èØjUçU�é$ljQ [­v�Û���RTUçRTS`Q RwØ`Q à�à�XM_=à�XEa�Qèad}jU�Z^XEQ�[-Z(Q�akU~���cØj�$�$adRTXM_oà=m�ãcS=U(eYURTSoU�\�f � a�Q eYU�l=_=XÏ�§��eTV3Q�RcU�Q�Z�SWadRTU(}WQ�_j£"RYS=UÜ}jU(eYRTl=eYصUÚ£Î}oeTU�£�X�Z^RT��e�auQ eTU�à�XM¥$U(_~UÚé]ljQ�[�ãuU(XMà�S�RuXM_~RYS=U¥$��RYXM_=àov

Ó �

Page 13: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

u �9�,�:� �ì��! ���-�wvj���-�"���,�������4 ���� x¤¦S«�¦m��¡ «Á�y&%N*.%�* z|{ 9;6�}�3.9�®~e8®d<v®_D�:=<��S=X�aè£=Q�R�Q�adU(RåZ^��V~U�a��§eT��V Q1akRTl`£�q�� �çà�U(_=U+U�æ�}=eYU�aTadXM��_�XM_�RYS=U+RYS=eTU(UåV~�¸akRè}oeTU(¥�Q [�U(_sRèQ�£�l=[�R[MqsV~}=So��XE£�VWQ�[MXMà�_jQ _`Z^XMU�a ¢ n�«­Z^U([�[�Z�S=eY��_=X�Zê[�q�Vâ}=S=�sZ^qsRTX�Zë[�U(l=p$U(V~X�Q�íin�«dr�� �Bî�m=�§��[�[MX�Z^l=[EQ�e-[MqsV~}=S=��VWQíiú2�Bî�mjQ _`£è£�X¦ð�l`akU�[EQ�eTà�Un�«­Z^U([�[�[MqsV~}=So��VWQ�íi|*�Dn¤r��BîÜí­t¤[MX�ÿ�Q�£�U�S ��ÇcÅ�Ì�Ò ü ��þimD ¹�¹PF�G�IPIF�j¶�±�L��¶!��R:RPRcºT¯�¹j°�±�K�L�³�²-ºT¶¸²�ÀQIs¾�¿=�ÁF D L���° î�v���U(_oU�U(æ�}oeTU�aYakXM��_è[�U(¥$U([Ea�ãuU(eTU�VâU�Q�adl=eTU�£~ljad«XM_oà�Q�ak}jU�Z^X�Q [MX�ÿ(U�£�Z(|ÜÛÝt V~XEZ^eY�$Q�eTe�Q(q$m(RYS=U!��qsV~}=S=�sZ�S=XM}ïm�Z^��_�RfQ X�_=XM_=àÝà�U(_=UÚaORYSjQ ROQ eTU�}=eYU^�§U(eTU�_�RYXEQ [�[MqU(æs}=eTUÚaTakUÚ£ìX�_�[�q�V~}oS=��X�£wZ^U([�[EaB��e�ãcS=X�ZgSçQ�eTUÜ���Dps_=��ãc_~XMVâV�l=_=��[���à�XEZ(Q�[���e���_jZ^��[M��à�XEZ(Q�[�X�V~}j��eTRfQ _jZ*U$vhi_�UÚQ�Z�S�V~X�Z^eT�¸Q eYe�Q(q�U(æ�}jU(eYXMV~U�_�R�m /jl=��eYU�aTZ*U(_�RuZ(|ÝÛÜt R�Q�eTà�U�R�a�ãuU(eTUc}oeTU(}jQ�eTU�£��§eT��V�Q�_�U�æ�}jU(eYXMV~U(_o«R�Q�[BVÎb¤ÛÜt aTQ Vâ}=[MUçí eYU�£�«�/jl=��eTU�aYZ^U(_sRÜ£�q$U�r-qo�]î�Q�_j£�Q�eTU^�§U(eYU(_jZ^U�VWb�ÛÜt�aYQ V~}o[MU£�U(eYXM¥$U�£ì�§eY��V Q}j�$��[c���ݨ�£�XÏð�U(eYU(_�R�[�q�V~}oS=��VWQçZ^U([�[-[MXM_oU�a�í à�eYU(U(_=«�/jl=��eTU�aYZ^U(_sR£�q$Uèr-qo¬]î�v���S=X�awakRYlj£�q+}oeT�s£�ljZ*U�£à�U�_=U�U(æs}=eTU�aYakX���_ã=Q RfQâ�§��e!\Uc©ª�p���®��Wà�U(_=UÚaêX�_�^°c ® Ó VWb�ÛÜt©aTQ Vâ}=[MU�a*vw��SoU�VWb¤ÛÝt/aYQ V~}o[MU�aZ^��V~}=eTX�akUÝ��¨�Z(Q�akU�a����-n�«dr�� � í­Z^[EQ�aTa Ó îfmj¨�Z(Q�adU�a�� �OúS�ßíiZ^[�Q�aYac�]î�moQ _j£Wª$¬�Z(Q�akU�a����-|*�Dn¤r�� íiZ^[�Q�aYa¬]îfv-��S=U£=Q RfQ�Q eYUwZ*��[M[�U�Z^RYU�£wXM_sRT�JQ _�® Ó `~ª$��®���VWQ RYeTX�ælb c í�d�ftg*îfm�ãcS=U(eYUEd�f+gc£sU(_=��RYU�a�RTSoUÜØjQ�adU�[M��à$Q�eTXMRYS=V � �ïRTS=U�r-qo� ��r-qo¬|/`l=��eYU�aTZ^U�_jZ^Uce�Q�RTX��ê�§��e-à�U(_=U�iwX�_�VWb�ÛÜtßaTQ�V~}=[�U!jTv�úBX�à�l=eYU Ó £�XEad}=[EQ(qoaXMVÎQ à�UÚaO����RYS=U�® Ó `â® Ó Z^��eTeYU([EQ�RTXM��_~VWQ�RTeTX�æwØjU(Rdã�U�U(_~à�U�_=UÜU(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_~}oeT� Ù`[MU�a��§��ecRTSoU�® Ó RYl=V~��efa^vtÜa@£�U(V~��_jakRYe�Q�RTU�£�Ø�qt¤[�XMÿ�Q�£�U(S ��Ç:Å�ÌMÒ ü ��þim�RYS=Uc|��Dn¤r��WZ^[�Q�aYaBXEaDS=U(RYU(eT��à�U(_=U���lja�Q�_j£�Z^��V~}=eTX�akU�a�Rdãu�£�X�akRTX�_jZ^R�akl=Ø�Z^[�Q�aTadU�acãcXMRTSΣ�XÏð�U(eYU(_�R�Z^[MX�_=XEZ�Q [jØjU(SjQ(¥�X���efa^v��¤��ã�U(¥$U(e�m�XMRcX�a�_=��_=U(RYS=U([MUÚaTac£�X�akRTX�_jZ^R-�§eT��VRTSoU���RTSoU(eÜRdã��WZ*[EQ�aYakU�a*mDn�«dr�� � Q _`£áúS��mïQ _j£�XM_å\$U�Z^RYXM��_å�çã�UçZ^��V~}jQ eYUwRYS=UçQ Ø=X�[MX�Rkqâ� ��£sXÏð�U(eTU�_�R£�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ RYXM��_çV~U(RYS=�s£=a�RY�ç£�XEadRTXM_oà�l=X�akSWØjU(Rdã�U(U(_WRYS=U�akU�RYS=eTU(UêZ^[EQ�aTakUÚa^v

Á�Á�Á ��[EQ�Z*Uwú@XMà�loeTU Ó Q Øj��loRÜS=U(eYU Á�Á�Áy&%N*.%kj z :gc��.:g9�/.®Be�®g<v®-D�:!<��S=UW[MU�l=p$U(V~X�Q"£oQ R�Q�akU(RçXEa�£sU�aTZ^eYXMØjU�£+XM_ßRYS=UèeYU�Z^U(_sRw}jQ�}jU(e����µ����[�l=Ø ��Ì�Å�Ì�Ò ü Ó ��þ�Q _j£1QÚ¥�Q�XM[EQ�Ø=[MUQ R�D ¹s¹�FHG�IPI?R�RPRuº��j¶�±�L���¶OºAR�´:º(�ï´ ¹uºT¶�²]À�I��C�=� vu��S=XEa�£oQ R�Q�akU(RåZ*��V~U�a~�§eT��V Q�adRTlj£�q � �âà�U(_=UÃU(æ�«}=eYU�aTadXM��_ÃXM_+Rdã���Rdq�}jU�a�� �êQ�Z^l=RYU�[�U(l=p$U(VâXEQ�a ¢ Q�Z^l=RYU~[MqsV~}=S=��Ø=[EQ�akRYXEZw[MU�l=p$U(V~X�Qèí­t�� �Bî�Q�_j£ßQ�Z^l=RYUVçq$U([M��XE£ä[�U(l=p$U(VâXMQßíitÝP��Bî�v���U(_=U+U(æs}=eYU�aTadXM��_û[MU�¥$U([Ea�ãuU(eTUåV~U�Q�akl=eYU�£ ljadXM_=àûtëð�qsV~U(RYeTXMæßS=X�à�S=«£�U(_`akXMRdqå��[�XMà���_�l`Z^[MU(��RTX�£�U~Q�eTefQÚqoa�Z^��_�RfQ XM_oXM_=àÅ\ac#��p�® Ó ��S�l=VÎQ _åà�U(_=UÚa^vå��S=U�£=Q RfQ�Z^��Vâ}=eTX�akUçª��Z(Q�akU�a����ut�� � í­¬�®çn�«iZ^U�[M[�t�� �+Q�_j£è¨ç��«iZ*U([M[ït�� �BîcQ�_j£W���çZ(Q�adU�ac� �OtÜP���v��S=Uw�§��[M[M��ãcX�_=à�}oeTU(«§}=eT�sZ*U�aTadXM_=à�akRYU(}ja¤ãuU(eTUJQ }=}o[MXMUÚ£áí }jU(efak��_jQ [uZ^��V~V�lo_=XEZ*Q RYXM��_ïm���Q�Ø=[M�W�@Q VÎQÚq$�sî ¢í X§î�RTS=eYU�akSo��[E£sXM_=à ¢ /j�$��e���� Ó ���+Q _`£ Z^U(X�[MX�_=àè��� Ó �sm ������öí XMX§î¤Ùj[�RTU(eYXM_=à ¢ U(æoZ^[MljadXM��_ä����à�U�_=U�awãcXMRYSVWQ�æ ¶ïV~XM_bh ��Q�_j£+í VÎQ æ!¼èV~X�_µî�h�������m�ãcSoU(eTUVWQ æWQ�_j£èV~X�_"eYU^�§U(eceYU�ak}jU�Z^RYXM¥$U([�q�RY��RYS=UwVÎQ æsXM«Vçl=V3Q _`£ùV~X�_=XMV�loV U(æ�}oeTU�aYakXM��_�[MU(¥$U�[Ea�� ��Q~}jQ�eTRTX�Z^l=[�Q e�à�U(_=UçQ�Z^eT�¸aTaÜVWb�ÛÜt©aTQ�V~}=[MUÚa^ö@í XMX�X îuØjQ�adUÓ ��[M��à$Q�eTXMRYS=V~X�ZëRYe�Q _`a¼�§��eYVWQ RYXM��_Dv

��S=U�£oQ R�Q�Q�eTUÜRYS=U(_Wadl=V~VWQ�eTX�ÿ(U�£wØsqçQ���� `ì¬��]� Ó VÎQ RTeYXMæEb c í�d�ftg*î�msãcS=U(eTU|d�f+gc£sU(_=��RYU�a�RTSoUÜØjQ�adUÓ �w[���à¸Q eTX�RTS=Vò� �:RTS=U�U(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_~[�U(¥$U([=�§��ecà�U(_=U�içXM_~VÎb¤ÛÜtûaTQ�V~}=[�U�jTv-ú@XMà�loeTU���£�X�ak}=[�Q(q=a-XMVWQ�à�U�a� �ORTS=U����T`��Ú��Z*��eTeYU([EQ�RTX���_WVWQ RYeTX�æ�ØjU(Rdã�U�U(_~à�U�_=U�U(æ�}oeTU�aYakXM��_W}=eT��Ùj[MU�a��§��e¤RYS=U�����RTl=Vâ��e�a*v

Ó ¬

Page 14: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

hi_�RTS=X�a�akRYlj£�q$m�RTS=U�£=Q�R�Q�Q eYU�Q [�eTU�Q�£�q�£�X�¥�X�£�U�£�XM_sRT��Q¤[�U�Q eY_=XM_oà�akU(R:� �ï¬�®ÜVWb�ÛÜtßaTQ�V~}=[MUÚaBQ�_j£�Q�RTU�adRakU�R�� ��¬ ª�VWb�ÛÜtßaTQ Vâ}=[MU�a*v@��S=U¤��ØjakU�eT¥�Q RYXM��_`aOX�_�RTS=UcRdãu��akU(Rfa-Z(Q V~U��§eY��V�£�X¦ð�U�eTU(_sRB[�Q Øja-Q�_j£ìãuU(eTUZ^��[M[MUÚZ^RTU�£Q R-£sXÏð�U(eTU�_�R�RYXMV~UÚa^vD��S=UcRYU�akRuadU(R�XEa:Q�Z^RYljQ [�[MqwVâ��eTU-S=U�RTU(eY��à�U�_=U(��l`aORYSjQ _çRTSoUc[MU�Q�eT_=X�_=à�akU�RQ�acXMR�Z^��Vâ}=eTX�akU�auQwØ=eT�¸Q�£�U(e�e�Q�_=à�U����uaTQ�V~}=[MUÚa^m$XM_jZ*[Mlj£�X�_=à�aYQ V~}o[MU�a��§eT��Vò}µU�eTXM}oS=U(e�Q�[�Ø=[��$�s£�Q�a�ãuU([M[Q�a�Øj��_=UWVWQ�eTeT��ã�m��§eT��V9Z�S=X�[E£�S=�$�s£ÃtÜP�� }jQ RYXMU(_sR�a*m�Q�_j£ù�§eT��V [�Q Øj��efQ RY��eTX�U�awRTS`Q Rwl`akU�£+£sXÏð�U(eTU�_�RaTQ�V~}=[�Uw}=eYU(}jQ efQ RYXM��_�}oeT��RY�sZ^��[�a^v�hi_+\$UÚZ^RTX���_��~ãuUçQ�£=£�eYU�aTa�RTS=U�X�V~}jQ�Z*R¤����RYS=XEa�S=U(RTU�eT��à�U(_=U(X�Rdq"��_RTSoU,}jU(ed�§��eYVWQ _jZ*UÜ� �-RYS=U�}=eTUÚ£�XEZ^RY��efa^v

Á�Á�Á ��[EQ�Z*Uwú@XMà�loeTU��çQ Øj��loRÜS=U(eYU Á�Á�Áy&%N*.%�$ 2�`����.��e8®d<v®-D�:!<hi_ RYS=XEa~adRTlj£sq$m�Z(|ÜÛÜt3V~XEZ^eY�$Q�eTe�Q(qoawã�U(eYUèljadU�£ RT�ÃU(æ=Q�V~XM_oU"RYS=Uè¥�Q�eTXEQ�RTX���_�XM_�à�U(_=U�U(æ�}oeTU�aYakXM��_Q Vâ��_=àWRTSoUç���WZ^U([�[B[�XM_=U�ac�§eT��V RYS=UçÛÜQ�RTXM��_jQ [uruQ _jZ^U�ewhi_jadRTX�RTl=RYU � aÜQ�_�RYXM«­Z(Q _`Z^U(e�£�eYl=à�aTZ^eYU(U(_ßí­Û,ruh���$îcí­bë�¸aTa �fÇ�Å�Ì�Ò üý����þim:D ¹�¹PFHG�IPIF�j¶�±�L?�j¶g�vR�RPRuº�¯ ¹=°�±:KQL¸³$²uºf¶�²$ÀQI�±.�s´!�d� îfvD��S=UÝZ^U([M[o[MXM_oU�a-Q eTUê£�U(eTX�¥$U�£�§eT��V RTl=Vâ��e�a@ãcXMRTSâ£�X¦ð�U�eTU(_sR-akX�RTU�a����@��eTX�à�X�_ ¢ ��Ø=eYU�Q�adR(ms�wZ^U�_�RYe�Q [o_=U(eT¥$��lja-akqoakRYU(V'ídruÛ,\=î�m=�ÝZ^��[M��_ïm�w[MU�l=p$U(V~X�Q�m�®wV~U([�Q _=��VWQ�m¸¨,_=��_=«iadVWQ [�[M«­Z^U([�[M«§[Ml=_=à�«iZ�Q e�Z*XM_=��VWQ,í­Û,\=r��Brcîfmj�,��¥�Q eTX�Q _Dmj��}=eT�¸akRfQ RTU¸mj¨eTU�_jQ [­m Ó l=_=ps_=��ãc_Dv0��U(_=UÜU�æ�}=eYU�aTadXM��_�ã�Q�a�adRTlj£sXMU�£�l`akXM_oà�Z(|ÜÛÝt V~X�Z^eT�¸Q eYe�Q(q=a@ãcXMRTSâ¨�m¦����¬�ak}j��RYRTU�£Z(|ÜÛÝt×adU�é]loU(_jZ^U�a*v�ú=��e-U�Q�ZgSâ� �@RTSoUÜ���wZ^U([�[j[MXM_oU�a^m5/`l=��eYU�aTZ^U�_�R�Z(|ÜÛÜt RfQ eTà�U(R�a�ãuU(eTUc}oeTU(}jQ�eTU�£��§eT��VQ _ßVWb�ÛÜt aTQ Vâ}=[MU�í eYU�£�«�/jl=��eYU�aTZ*U(_�RJ£�q$UWr-q=�$î�v���S=UâeTU^�§U(eYU(_jZ^UçaYQ V~}o[MU�í à�eYU(U(_=«�/jl=��eTU�aYZ^U(_sR�£�q$Ur-qo¬]î@ljakUÚ£ìX�_~Q�[M[jS�qsØ=eYXE£�X�ÿ�Q RYXM��_`aBãcQ�aO}oeTU(}jQ�eTU�£�Øsq�}µ�$��[MX�_=àwU�é$ljQ�[=V~XMæsRTloeTU�aD� �ïVWb¤ÛÝtH�§eT��V Ó ��� �RTSoUcZ^U([�[�[�XM_=UÚa^v@���ÝXM_s¥$U�akRYXMà$Q�RTU-RTSoUceTU(}=eY�s£�ljZ^X�Ø=XM[�XMRdqÜ����RYS=U�U�_�RYXMeTU-U(æs}jU(eTX�V~U(_sR�í­Z^U([M[sZ*l=[MRYl=eTU$m�VWb�ÛÜtXEad��[�Q RTX���_Dm$[�Q ØjU([MX�_=à=m�S�qsØ=eTX�£�XMÿÚQ RTX���_Dm�U(RfZ�vÏîfm$Q¤[MU�l=p$U(V~X�QÜí���������t,î:Q _`£�Q¤ØoeTU�Q�akRuZ(Q _`Z^U(ecí­Páruú���î:Z^U([�[[MX�_=Uçã�U(eYU�RYS=U���Ø��dU�Z^R�� ��RYS=eTU�U�X�_j£�U(}jU(_j£sU(_�R�V~X�Z^eT�¸Q eYe�Q(qèU(æs}jU(eTX�V~U(_sR�a*v~n�U�Z(Q�ljakUç� ��RYS=U(X�ewadVWQ [�[Z^[�Q�aTaakX�ÿ(U$mDRTS=UâRkãu�W}=eT�¸akR�Q�RTU�Z^U([�[�[MX�_=Uç��ØjadU(eT¥�Q RYXM��_ja,ãuU(eTUçU(æoZ^[Mlj£sU�£Ê�§eY��V ��l=eçQ _jQ�[MqoakX�a^m�Q�a,ãuU([M[Q�aÜRYS=U�lo_=p�_o� ãc_ÃZ^U([�[B[�XM_=U���ØjakU�eT¥�Q RYXM��_ïv�tc�§RTU(e�aYZ^eTU�U(_=XM_oà~��l=R�à�U(_=U�aÜãcXMRYSáVâ��eTURTSjQ�_+�~V~X�aTadXM_=à£=Q�R�Qw}j��X�_�Rfa^m=RTSoU�£=Q RfQ�Q eYUwZ*��[M[�U�Z^RYU�£wXM_sRT�JQ�� Ó `â��� ª�ªçVWQ�RTeTX�æµb c©í�d�ftg*î�msãcS=U(eYUBd�ftg�£�U�_=��RYU�a�RYS=UØjQ�akU���[M��à$Q�eTXMRYS=V'����RYS=U�r-qo� ��r-q=¬l/jl=��eTU�aYZ^U(_jZ^U�efQ RTX��w�§��e�à�U(_oU�i~X�_WVWb¤ÛÝt×aYQ V~}=[�UBjTv-úBX�à�l=eYU¬£�X�ak}=[�QÚqoa�X�VWQ à�U�aB����RYS=UÜ� Ó `ç� Ó Z^��eYeTU([�Q RYXM��_çVWQ�RTeTX�æ�ØjU(Rdã�U(U(_çà�U�_=UÜU(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_ç}=eT��Ùj[MUÚaO�§��euRTS=Uê� ÓZ^U([�[�[�XM_=U�a*v

Á�Á�Á ��[EQ�Z*Uwú@XMà�loeTU�¬çQ Øj��loRÜS=U(eYU Á�Á�Á ���Ñ ��©��BÔ�«�¦S«Á��× ¥ ×s�C©W�����Á��¥��à§�¦S«Á¦ú=��e@RTS=U-[�q�V~}oS=��VWQ-Q�_j£wÛ,ruh�����£=Q RfQ�m$ad��V~UOQ eTefQ(q=a@Z^��_sR�Q�XM_Qc_�l=VçØjU(e����jà�U�_=U�a�ãcXMRYSwl=_oeTU([�XEQ Øo[MU���eV~X�aTakX�_=à�£=Q�R�Qwí§RTS=UuV~U�Q _�}jU(efZ^U(_sR�Q à�U-� ��V~XEaYakX�_=àc£=Q�R�Q¤}j��XM_sR�aB}jU(e:Q eYe�Q(q�XEa@��v �!E��§��e�RYS=U-[MqsV~}=S=��VWQ£=Q�R�QèQ�_j£ß¬�v ¬=E'�§��eRTS=UâÛ,ruhÜ���è£=Q�R�Q$î�v�\$��V~Uç� ��RYS=Uâ£�XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_jQ�RTX���_èVâU(RTS=�s£oaêU�æ=Q�V~XM_=UÚ£èS=U(eTUQ eYU�Q�Ø=[MU�RT�ߣ�UÚQ [�ãcXMRTS1V~XEaYakX�_=àå£=Q RfQ í ��Ò+��Ò rutÝb��¤î�m�S=��ãuU(¥$U(e(mu��RTSoU(e�a�eTU�é$l=X�eTU�Z^��Vâ}=[MU(RYUW£=Q�R�Qí ��Ò+��Ò úBX�akS=U(eu[MX�_=U�Q e�£�XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_`Q _sR�Q�_jQ [�q=adXEa�î�v-ú=��ecX�V~}=l=RYXM_=à�RTSoUÜV~XEaYakX�_=à�£=Q�R�Qsm=ã�UÜljadUQ�akXMVâ}=[MUB{_=U�Q�eTU�adR¤_oU(XMà�S�Øj��eÝQ [�à���eTXMRYS=V�m=X�_"ãcSoXEZ�S"RYS=Uw_oU(XMà�S�Øj��efaÜQ eYU�RTS=Uà�U(_=UÚa¤Q�_j£èRTS=U£�X�akRfQ _jZ^UØjU(Rdã�U(U(__=U(X�à�SsØj��e�a�XEa�ØjQ�adU�£á��_ÃRTS=U(X�eZ^��eYeTU([�Q RTX���_DvWú=��ewU�Q�ZgSåà�U(_oU�ãcX�RTS+V~X�aTadXM_=àW£oQ R�Q ¢ í X îÝZ^��V~}=l=RYU�XMRfaZ^��eTeTU�[EQ RYXM��_"ãcX�RTS�Q [�[D��RYS=U(e�\µ¼ Ó à�U(_=U�a*mjQ _j£åí XMX§îB�§��e¤U�Q�ZgSWV~X�aTadXM_=àU(_�RYeTq$msXE£�U�_�RYXÏ�§q�RTSoUT{ç_=U�Q�eTU�adR

Ó ª

Page 15: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

à�U�_=U�aÜSjQ(¥�X�_=àWZ^��V~}=[�U(RTUJ£=Q RfQâ�§��e�RTS=X�aêU�_�RYeTq�Q�_j£�XMV~}=loRTUwRYS=U�V~X�aTakX�_=à~U(_sRTeYqèØsqèRYS=UçQ(¥$U(e�Q�à�Uç� �RTSoUwZ*��eTeYU�ak}j��_j£�XM_oà�U(_sRTeYXMU�a��§��e�RTS=Uµ{ç_=U(X�à�SsØj��e�a*v�ñåU�ljakUÚ£h{]cû�sv ���� �0«Á¦H¥ §�¦S¢�§���� ¦S«���× ¥hiR�XEaçZ^��VâV~��_+}oe�Q�Z*RTXEZ*U"RY�ál`akUèRYS=U�Z*��eTeYU([EQ�RTX���_ßØjU(Rdã�U(U(_ßRYS=Uèà�U(_=UWU(æs}=eTU�aYakX���_ }oeT� Ù`[MU�a�� ��Rdãu�VWb�ÛÜt aYQ V~}o[MU�a¤RY�èV~UÚQ�akloeTU�RTSoU(XMe�adXMV~X�[EQ�eTXMRdqÃü �smD��¬=m@����þ¤vWr-��_jadU�é$l=U(_sRT[Mq¸m�ãuU~adR�Q�_j£=Q ef£�XMÿ�U�RYS=U��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_jaÜí­Q eTefQ(q=a�î�RT�SjQ(¥$U¤VâU�Q _ç�Q _j£~¥�Q eYXEQ _`Z^U Ó Q�Z^eY�$aYa�¥�Q�eTX�Q Ø=[�U�a¤í§à�U(_=UÚagî�v@ñ�XMRYS~RTS=UÝ£=Q�R�QakRfQ _j£oQ e�£sXMÿ(U�£çXM_~RYS=XEa��­Q�akSoXM��_ïm=RTS=U�£sXEakRfQ _jZ*UÜØjU(Rdã�U(U(_çRdã��VWb¤ÛÝt�aTQ Vâ}=[MU�a�VWQ(q�ØjUÜV~UÚQ�akloeTU�£�ØsqRTSoU(XMe!7�ljZ^[�XE£�UÚQ _W£�X�akRfQ _jZ^U¸v ��� �Ρ%¥!¡���¡8£�¡�¨z«Á��× ¥tÞ[�Q eTà�U~_sl=V�ØjU(e�����à�U(_=UÚa,U(æsS=XMØoXMR�_=U�Q�eçZ^��_jadR�Q�_�RU(æ�}oeTU�aYakXM��_+[MU�¥$U([Ea�Q�Z*eT�$aYa�aTQ�V~}=[MUÚa^vWñáU~RYS�l`a}jU(ek�§��eTV3Qw}oeTU([�XMV~X�_jQ eYq�akU�[MU�Z^RYXM��_�����à�U(_=U�a���_"RYS=UÜØjQ�akX�a�� �:RTS=U�e�Q�RTX���� �:RTS=U(X�e-صU�RkãuU(U(_=«§à�eY��l=}`aëRY�ãcXMRYS=XM_o« à�eT��lo}ja¤adl=V'���uaTé$ljQ eYU�a^vuú=��e�Q�à�U(_oU�ijmsRTS=X�aëefQ RTX���XEa´Tômôuí¹i=î·�ô�ôuí�i`î c ö f ö y í�uvfzc¤{=îfí Íd y g%¼ Íd�� g^î Àö f ö y íeu f c�{=î�íed f+g ¼ Íd�y g î À pãcS=U(eYU Íd�� gê£�U(_=��RTU�acRTS=UçQ(¥$U(efQ à�UwU(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_�[MU(¥$U([�� �uà�U�_=U�i�Q�Z^eY�$aYaÜQ [�[-aTQ�V~}=[MUÚacQ _j£ Íd y gê£�U(_o��RTUÚaRTSoU�Q(¥$U(e�Q�à�UWU(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_1[MU(¥$U([u� ��à�U(_=UÅißQ�Z^eY�$aTaâaTQ Vâ}=[MU�awØjU([���_=à�XM_=àÃRT�ÃZ^[EQ�aTa÷{jv1ñáUÊZ^��V~}`Q eTU}=eYU�£�XEZ*RT��efa�ØjQ�akU�£~��_"RYS=U�\~à�U(_=U�a-ãcXMRTSWRYS=UÜ[EQ�eTà�U�akRH´Tô�ô ¶?·�ô�ôåefQ RTX��$a*v�ñåU�Q [�ak��Ø=eYXMU /`qçZ^��_jadXE£�U�eak[�XMà�S�RY[MqçV~��eYU�Z^��Vâ}=[MX�Z(Q RYU�£ì¥�Q�eTXEQ�Ø=[MUadU([MU�Z*RTXM��_WZ^eYXMRTU�eTXEQçík\$UÚZ^RTX���_jac��Q�_j£è�$î�v

243-<: % ����[�l=Ø �fÇ�Å�ÌMÒ ü Ó ��þDljakUQç£�XÏð�U(eYU(_sRcV~U(RTSo�s£â�§��eÜadR�Q�_j£=Q ef£�XMÿ�XM_=àçRTS=U£=Q�R�QçQ _j£~�§��eÝakU([�U�Z^RYXM_=àà�U�_=U�a�RYSjQ _�£�UÚaTZ^eYXMØjU�£çQ Øj��¥$U$vm��eTXM��e�RY��RTS=U�[M��à$Q eYXMRYS=V~XEZcRTefQ _jai�§��eYVWQ RYXM��_ÎQ _j£~Q(�§RTU(euRTS=eYU�akSo��[E£sXM_=àomQÜadl=ØjakU�R�� �Á\�à�U(_oU�aBQ�eTU�adU([MU�Z*RTU�£���_�RTSoU�ØjQ�akXEa�����RYS=UcadR�Q�RTXEadRTX�Z(aS²�g ¢ RYS=Um\Q¶Ú�êà�U(_=U�a@ãcXMRTSRTS=Uc[�Q eYà�U�adR²�g�Q�_j£ùRYS=UE\Q¶��~à�U(_=U�aÜãcXMRYS�RTS=UçadVWQ [�[MU�adR�²�gJíiakU�U~\$U�Z^RYXM��_å¬sv ���§��e�RYS=Uç£�U^Ùj_oXMRTX���_����!²�g^îfvT����[�l=Ø��Ç�Å�ÌMÒ �§��l=_j£]\÷cû����RT�çØjUQ�£�U�é$ljQ�RTU,�§��e¤RYS=Ut�� ����tÝP��+£=Q RfQ�adU(R(vc��SoUw[MUÚQ eT_oXM_=àç£=Q�R�Q�VWQ RYeTX�æ�X�aRTSoU(_~[M��à�«§RTefQ _jai�§��eTVâU�£~Q _`£ÎX�R�auZ^��[�l=V~_ja�í§à�U(_oU�agîuQ�eTU�adR�Q _`£=Q ef£�XMÿ(UÚ£�RT��SjQ(¥$U�V~U�Q�_~��Q�_j£�¥�Q eYXEQ _`Z^UÓ v-��SoU�é]l`Q _sRTXMRYXMU�amû9g�Q eYU�Z^��V~}=l=RYU�£,�§eT��VÞRYS=XEa�RTefQ _jai�§��eYV~U�£çQ _j£WakRfQ _j£oQ e�£sXMÿ(U�£�VWQ�RTeTX�æ�v@��S=UÝRTU�adRakU�Rc£=Q�R�Q�Q eYU�Q [�ak��[���à�«§RTefQ _jai�§��eYV~U�£~Q�_j£~à�U(_=UÚa�Q eYU�akRfQ _j£oQ e�£sXMÿ(U�£~ljadXM_=àRTS=UÝ[MU�Q�eT_=X�_=à�adU(RcQ(¥$U(efQ à�UÚaQ _`£"¥�Q eYXEQ _`Z^U�a^v

ú=��e�RTS=UaYQ p$U�� �OZ^��Vâ}=[MU(RYU(_=U�aYa^m$��loeÜZ^��V~}jQ�eTXEad��_�akRYlj£�qWXM_`Z^[Mlj£sU�a�RYS=U�ã�U(X�à�SsRTU�£�¥$��RTX�_=à~aYZgSoU(V~U�� �����[�l=Ø ��Ç�Å�ÌMÒ ãcX�RTSè² g Z(Q [�Z^l=[�Q RTUÚ£Îl`akXM_oàçakR�Q�_j£=Q�e�£�£�U(¥sXEQ�RTX���_ja�X�_jakRYU�Q�£~� �O¥�Q�eTX�Q _jZ^UÚacQ _j£WãcXMRTSWRYS=U£=Q�R�Q~}=eT�sZ*U�aTadU�£�Q�a�£�U�aYZ^eTX�ØjU�£"X�_èRTSoU�}=eTU(¥sXM��lja¤}jQ�e�Q�à�e�Q�}=SDvwñåUweYU^�§U(e�RT�WRTSoUweTUÚakl=[�RTXM_oà~}=eTUÚ£�XEZ^RY��eQ�a � ����[Ml=Ø��âQ _j£WXMR�X�aë����X�_�RYU(eTUÚakRcRT�çZ*��V~}jQ�eTU�XMRfa�}jU(ek�§��eTVWQ�_jZ^UÜRY��RYSjQ R�� �O|��D|�t/ãcXMRYSWRTS=U£=Q�R�Q}=eY�sZ^U�aTadXM_=àâakRYU(}ja����c\$U�Z^RYXM��_ja�ª=v ¬�Q _j£Wª=v ªov

� � ��0�!è) !��,���4��

hi_èRYS=U�Q�ØjakU(_`Z^Uw����à�U(_sl=XM_=U�RYU�akR�adU(R�a*mµRYS=U�£sXÏð�U(eTU�_�Rc}=eYU�£�X�Z^RT��e�a�Q eTUçZ*��V~}jQ�eTU�£~ØjQ�akU�£è��_èefQ _j£���V£�X�¥�X�akXM��_jaÜ� �ÝU�Q�Z�Sã=Q RfQ�akU�R�XM_sRT��Qè[MU�Q�eT_=X�_=à�akU(R � Q�_j£ßQ"RTUÚakR�adU(R � v���S=U(eYUWQ eYU�_o��ãcXE£�U([�qåQ�Z^«

Ó �

Page 16: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

Z^U(}oRTU�£~à�loXE£�U([�XM_=UÚa��§��eÝZgS=�$�¸akX�_=à~RTSoUweTU�[EQ RYXM¥$U�adXMÿ(U����-RTS=UÚakU�Q�eTRYXÏÙ�Z^X�Q [D[�U�Q eY_=XM_=àâakU�R�a�Q _j£WRTU�adRÜadU(R�a*vt }j�$aYakXMØo[MUçZ�S=��X�Z^UwX�a¤RT�~[�U�Q(¥$Uw��l=RQ�e�Q�_j£���Vâ[Mq�akU([�U�Z^RYU�£ Ó �=E3� �uRYS=U�XM_jadR�Q�_jZ^U�a¤RY�WljakUçQ�a,QçRTU�adRakU�R�í �(Ò+��Ò n�eTU(X�VWQ _Hü � þ§î�vµ��� ãuU(¥$U(e�mµX�_���l=eZ(Q�akU$mDRTUÚakR�adU(R�a�Z^��_�RfQ XM_oXM_=à Ó �!E3� ��RTS=Uç£=Q�R�Q�Q eTUç_=��RaklP=WZ^X�U(_sRT[Mq�[�Q eYà�U�RT�ç}=eT��¥sXE£�UQ�£�U�é$ljQ RYUw£sXEaTZ*eTXMVâXM_jQ�RTXM��_�ØjU(RdãuU(U(_~RYS=UZ^[EQ�aTakX¦ÙjU(efa^v�\$X�_jZ^U���l=ecVÎQ XM_}=l=eY}j�$akU�X�a�RT�âZ^��Vâ}jQ eYUwZ*[EQ�aYakX¦ÙjU(e�a*m�efQ RTSoU(e¤RYSjQ _�U�akRYXMVWQ�RTUÜà�U(_=U(efQ [�XMÿ�Q�RTXM��_WU(eTeY��e�e�Q RYU�a^m=ãuU�Z�S=�$�$adURT�âaTQ�Z^eTX¦Ù�Z^UÜRYe�Q�XM_=X�_=àç£=Q RfQ~Q _`£ÎX�_jZ^eYU�Q�adU,RYU�akR�adU(R�akX�ÿ(U�RT����_=UwRYS=XMef£Î����RYS=U£=Q RfQ"í­� ¢ Ó aYZgSoU(V~U�îfv

hi_�RYS=U�}=eTX�_jZ^XM}`Q [jZ^��V~}jQ�eTXEad��_Dm��§��e�UÚQ�Z�S�[MU�Q�eT_=X�_=àakU(R��(RTUÚakRuakU(R�íe�B\����¤\=î:eTl=_ïm�RTSoU0\�à�U�_=U�a�ãcXMRYS�RYS=U[EQ�eTà�U�akRдTô�ô ¶?·�ô�ô Q eTUâakU�[MU�Z^RYU�£èljadXM_=à�RTS=Uç[MU�Q�eT_=X�_=à�akU(R ¢ \Ücò���Î�§��ewRYS=U�[�q�Vâ}=S=��VÎQ�£=Q�R�Q�akU(R�m\Þc'ª¸�"�§��eRTS=U~[�U(l=p$U(VâXEQç£=Q RfQ�akU�R(muQ _j£C\Þc#¬��"�§��ewRTSoUWÛ,ruh�����£=Q�R�Q�akU(R�väí­ú=��e�Q�Z*��V~}jQ�eTX�ak��_XM_s¥$��[�¥�X�_=à�Q�[M[�}oeTU�£�X�Z^RT��e�a*m�ú@XEakSoU(e-[MXM_oU�Q eu£�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ _sR-Q _`Q [MqoakX�a�adU(R�auQ _~l=}o}µU�e�[MX�V~XMR:��_~RYS=U�akX�ÿ(U�� �RTSoU,à�U(_=UakU�RcصUÚZ(Q ljadUw����efQ _=pWXEaYakl=UÚa^vÏî

Û¤U(æsR(ms}=eTUÚ£�XEZ^RY��efacQ eTUZ^��_jakRYeTljZ*RTU�£~ljadXM_=àçRTS=U�[�U�Q eY_=XM_=àçadU(R�Q _`£"RTUÚakR�akU�RcU(eTeY��ece�Q�RTU�acQ�eTU��Ø=RfQ XM_oU�£Øsq+Q�}=}=[MqsXM_oàèRTSoU~}=eTUÚ£�XEZ^RY��efaêRY��RTS=UâRTU�adR�akU�R(v�t¤à�à�eYU(à$Q�RTU�£á}oeTU�£�X�Z^RT��e�açí ØjQ�à�à�X�_=àåQ _`£HØj�$�¸akRTX�_=à�îQ eYU~Ø=l=X�[MR��§eT��V ´ c3��� � }jakU�lj£��:��[MUÚQ eT_oXM_=àÊakU(Rfa~í XM_`Z^eTU�Q�akX�_=àèRYS=U~_sl=V�ØjU(e�����XMRTU�e�Q RYXM��_ja�£�XE£s_ � RakU�U(V9RT�ÃQÚð�U�Z*R�RTS=UW��loR�Z^��V~U�î�vßú=��e"r��-|wm-adU(¥$U(e�Q�[c¥�Q [MloU�aw� ��RYS=UW}jQ efQ V~U�RTU(e Ê Q eYUèU(æoQ V~X�_=U�£ ¢Ê cär Ó p r ���Pp�r ��p rÏ�Ú��p Ó v��S=X�a�U(_�RYXMeYUÜ}=eT�sZ*U�£�l=eYU,X�aëeYU(}jU�Q RYU�£±ã½c Ó ���ìRYXMV~U�a*v

�s:gD�< D�:!<�:d883.8¡8v®d<:gD % 7-Q�ZgSè�B\��Ú�¤\WeTl=_�q�X�U([E£=auQìRYU�akR�adU(RcU(eYeT��ecefQ RYU,�§��ecUÚQ�Z�S"}oeTU�£�X�Z^RT��e(ö=Øj��æ�«}=[���R�acQ�eTUljakU�£~RY�~adl=V~VWQ�eTXMÿ�UcRTS=U�adU�U(eTeY��ece�Q�RTU�ac��¥$U(e�RYS=U�eTl=_`a^v

¢�A�D�:g8ðÃ�®d</�301&5¤£�/�D�:�:g8?83.8�8v®d<:gD % ñåU�Q�[Ead�¤eYU�Z^��ef£Ü��ØjadU(eT¥�Q RYXM��_=« ãcX�akUcU(eYeT��eDe�Q RYU�a^m È ÒE�(Ò m(�§��e:Qëà�XM¥$U(_��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_Dm�RYS=U�}=eY��}j��eYRTXM��_á���uRTXMVâU�a�XMR�ãcQ�aÜZ^[EQ�aTadXÏÙjU�£èX�_jZ^��eTeTUÚZ^RT[�q�í ��l=RÜ� �uRYS=Uµ�B\��Ú�¤\èeYl=_ja¤X�_ãcS=X�ZgS�XMRcãcQ�a¤XM_�RTS=URTU�adRÜadU(R^îfv��¤Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_=«§ãcXEadU�U(eTeY��e�e�Q RYU�aÜZ(Q�_èØjU�adl=V~VWQ�eTX�ÿ(U�£�Øsq~V~U�Q�_jac� �akloeT¥sXM¥�Q [=}o[M��Rfa^m È ÒE��Ò m]Øsq�}=[M��RTRYXM_=àQ à¸Q X�_jakR�þ¥E RTS=U��§efQ�Z^RYXM��_�� ����ØjadU(eT¥�Q�RTXM��_ja�ãcXMRYS���ØjadU(eT¥�Q RYXM��_=« ãcX�akUU(eYeT��e-efQ RTU�[MUÚaTa�RTSjQ�_ Ó ¼ þaE~v:ú`��e�U�Q�ZgS���ØjakU�eT¥�Q RYXM��_ïm�}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTXM��_�¥$��RTU�aD�§��ecQ�à�à�eTU(à¸Q RTUÚ£�}=eTUÚ£�XEZ^RY��efaQ eYU~eTUÚZ^��ef£�U�£áU�Q�ZgSåRTX�V~U�RTS`Q Rw}`Q eTRYXEZ^lo[EQ e��ØjadU(eT¥�Q�RTXM��_ßXEa,X�_áRYS=U~RYU�akRJakU(R�v~"-��RYU�aê�§��ewX�_j£�XM¥sXE£sljQ [��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_ja�Q eYU�akl=VâVWQ eYXMÿ(U�£wØsqçص��æs}=[M��R�acQ�_j£WZ^��V~}`Q eTUÚ£�RT��RYS=UÜ��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_=«§ãcXEadUwU(eYeT��eue�Q�RTU�a*v

¦B®-8/.®-A�§N:¨D�:g§N:g@F</�301 % ��S=UwU*ð�UÚZ^Rc� �uXM_`Z^eTU�Q�akX�_=àWí¹\Cc �����]î���eÝ£�U�Z*eTU�Q�akXM_oàèí�\Cc Ó �]îcRYS=Uw_sl=VçØjU(e� �@¥�Q�eTXEQ�Ø=[MUÚa�XEa-U(æoQ V~X�_=U�£�vDt � akVÎQ eTRYU(e3�B´Tômô ¶�·�ômôÃZ^eTX�RTU(eYXM��_�X�a�Q [�ak�JQ }=}=[�XMU�£�RT��RYS=U�[MqsV~}=S=��VWQ£=Q�R�Q�v ú=��eµ\¤c Ó �áà�U(_oU�a^mcRTSoXEaçZ^eTX�RTU(eYXM��_1Z^��_jakX�akRfa�� �adU([MUÚZ^RTX�_=àáRYS=U���à�U�_=U�a�ãcX�RTS RYS=Uè[�Q eYà�U�adR´Tômô ¶�·�ômôûe�Q RYXM�ÃíiQ�a�ØjU^�§��eYU�î�Q�_j£+RTS=UW�Wà�U(_oU�a,ãcX�RTS+RYS=U�[�Q eYà�U�adRµ´Tômô ¶�·�ômôûe�Q RYXM��ãcS=U(_+RYS=URdã��W[EQ�eTà�U�akRZ^[�Q�aTadU�a�í­n�«kr�� ��Q�_j£+|��Dn¤r��BîêQ eYU�}j�$��[�U�£�vè\$l`ZgSÃQèZ^eYXMRYU(eTX���_åakSo��l=[�£áQ�[M[M��ã صU�RTRTU�e£�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ RYXM��_ç� �ORTS=UakVÎQ [M[�U(euúS�åZ^[EQ�aTa�íiúBX�à�l=eYU Ó ®$î�v

Á�Á�Á �O[�Q�Z^UêúBXMà�l=eTU Ó ®çQ Øj��l=RÜS=U(eYU Á�Á�ÁÓ �

Page 17: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

© ª �,��0�&*���

«!��� ¬T¡8��«õ��¡ «õ¡ ¢�¢�×�¢�¢�¦S«Á¡��ú=��e�RTS=U�VWQ�XM_WZ*��V~}jQ�eTX�ak��_ïmjúBXMà�l=eTU�a�ªom��smj��m�Q _j£���£sXEak}o[EQ(q~Øj��æ�}=[���Rfaë���-RTS=U�U(eYeT��e¤efQ RTUÚa��§��e¤U�Q�ZgSZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙjU�e�ljadXM_=à�RYS=U� ¢ Ó aYZgS=U�V~U$v@ú=��ecRTSoUÜ[MU(lop$U(V~XEQÝ£=Q RfQ�akU�R(m=ã�UZ^��V~}jQ�eTU�£~Z*[EQ�aYakX¦ÙjU(e�a-ØjQ�adU�£"��_RTSoU(XMe�Q�Ø=XM[�XMRdq~RT�â£�X�akRTX�_=à�loXEakSÊt�� �á�§eT��V%tÝP�� í Rdã���«iZ*[EQ�aYaë}oeT��Øo[MU(VèîuQ�_j£"RY�W£�X�akRTX�_=à�loXEakS�ØjU(Rdã�U(U(_t�� �ßn�«­Z^U([M[­m=t�� �Ã��«iZ^U�[M[imjQ�_j£ètÝP�� í RYS=eTU(U�«iZ^[�Q�aYaë}=eY��Ø=[�U(Vèîfv���S=U�Ùjà�loeTU�a��§��e�U�Q�Z�S�£oQ R�Q�akU(RêZ^��_=«R�Q�XM_åRTS=eYU(Uw}`Q _=U([�a ¢ Øj��æ�}o[M��RfaÜ� �cU�eTeT��e�e�Q RYU�aë�§��ew£sXEaTZ*eTXMVâXM_jQ�_�R�Q�_jQ [�q=adXEa�íi|�t,î�mjØj��æ�}=[���Rfaê���cU(eYeT��ee�Q�RTU�a¤�§��eìrutÝb���« Ø`Q�akUÚ£áZ^[�Q�aYakXÏÙ`U(e�a*mBQ�_j£�ص��æs}=[M��R�aÜ� ��U(eTeY��e�e�Q�RTU�a�Z^��V~}jQ�eTXM_oà~RTS=U�_oU�Q eYU�akR�_=U(X�à�S=«Øj��eZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙjU�eÜRT�WRTSoU�صUÚakR|¤t Q�_j£+rutÜb���«§ØjQ�adU�£áZ*[EQ�aYakX¦ÙjU(e�a*v�hiRÜãcQ�aÜ� �§RTU�_�SjQ ef£ùRY�è£sXEakRYXM_=à�l=XEadSØjU(Rdã�U(U�_~RTS=U�ØjU�adRÜrutÜb���«§ØjQ�adU�£èZ^[�Q�aYakXÏÙ`U(e�a*m=Q�a�Øj�$�¸akRTX�_=àWQ�_j£ùr��-|�RTU(_`£�U�£~RT��SjQ(¥$UÜ¥$U�eTqâakXMVâXM[EQ�eU(eYeT��ecefQ RYU�a^vchi_�Z(Q�akU�acãcS=U(_WRTSoUwØjU�akR�Z*[EQ�aYakX¦ÙjU(e�acSjQ�£"RTSoUwaYQ V~UÝV~U�£�X�Q _~U(eYeT��e¤efQ RTU¸m=ã�UZgSo�$akU�RYS=UZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙjU�ewãcXMRYSßRTS=U�akVÎQ [M[�U�akR�V~UÚQ _+U(eYeT��e�e�Q RYU$vßhi_ßà�U(_=U�e�Q [­m�RTS=UW_=UÚQ eTUÚakR�_=U(X�à�SsØj��eçQ _`£ |��D|�t}=eYU�£�XEZ*RT��efa¤SjQ�£èRTS=UçadVWQ [�[MU�adRcU(eTeY��eÜefQ RTUÚa^m�ãcS=X�[MUJúS�D|¤t©SjQ�£�RTSoUwS=X�à�S=U�adRÜU(eYeT��eÝe�Q RYU�a^v�ñ�XMRYSèRYS=UU(æoZ^U(}=RYXM��_~� �:RTS=UÛ,ruhu����£=Q�R�QsmµRYS=U�U(eTeY��ece�Q�RTU�acadU(U(V~UÚ£J�­Q�XMeT[�q�[���ã×à�XM¥$U(_~RYS=U�[MX�V~XMRYU�£�Q V~��l=_sRc� �£=Q�R�Q�v

Á�Á�Á ��[EQ�Z^UúBXMà�l=eTUÚa�ª=mj��mj�sm���Q�Øj��l=RÜSoU(eTU Á�Á�Á24:P®-8:gD�<b1�:d/�,.}�A�3.8D % ��S=U~}`Q e�Q�V~U(RYU(el{�����RTS=Uç_=U�Q�eTU�adRw_=U(X�à�SsØj��ew}oeTU�£�X�Z^RT��e�ãcQ�aakU([�U�Z^RYU�£ùØsqZ^eY�$aTad« ¥�Q�[MXE£oQ RTX���_ßQ�_j£áã�Q�aÜljakl`Q [M[�qåé]loXMRTUçadVWQ [�[B�§��e�U�Q�ZgSã=Q�R�Q�adU(R ¢ Ó ��e�Î�§��eQ�ص��l=R�SjQ�[Ï�c���cRYS=UeTlo_jawQ�_j£áà�U�_=U(e�Q�[M[�q�[MU�aYaêRYSjQ _1�$vW��S=X�awakloà�à�UÚakR�awRYSjQ R¥$U(eTq�à��$�s£ß}=eTU�£sXEZ^RYXM��_`aÜZ(Q _ÃصUâ��Ø=RfQ XM_oU�£�§eT��V'RTSoU�Z^[�Q�aTa����-RTSoU,��ØjakU�eT¥�Q RYXM��_�V~�$adRcS=XMà�S=[MqÎZ^��eYeTU([�Q RTUÚ£ÎRY��RYS=U���ØjadU(eT¥�Q�RTXM��_èRY��ØjUw}oeTU�£�X�Z^RTUÚ£�v7�æ=Q�V~XM_`Q RTX���_ç� �:RTS=UêZ^��eYeTU([�Q RTX���_~VÎQ RTeYXEZ^UÚaBØjU(Rdã�U(U(_çVWb�ÛÜt�aTQ�V~}=[�U�acíiúBX�à�l=eYU�a Ó mj��m=Q�_j£W¬]î-à�XM¥$U�aQ _çU(æs}=[EQ�_jQ RYXM��_ì�§��e�RYS=Ucà��$�s£~}jU(ed�§��eTVÎQ _jZ^Uu� �ï_=U�Q eYU�akR-_=U�XMà�SsØj��euZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙjU�e�a^v:ú=��e-RTS=Um\�à�U(_=U�a�ãcXMRYSRTSoUw[EQ�eTà�U�akRÜefQ RYXM�~����´Tômô ¶?·áômôûí�\Cc©�����§��eÜ[�q�V~}oS=��VWQ£=Q RfQ�m�\�c�ª¸�ì�§��eÝ[MU(l=p$U�V~X�Qw£=Q�R�Q�mïQ _j£\wcû¬��Ü�§��e-Û�ruhB���w£=Q�R�Q]îfm$��ØjadU(eT¥�Q RYXM��_ja�ãcX�RTS=X�_�RTS=UÝaTQ�V~UcZ^[�Q�aYaORYU(_j£�RT��SjQ(¥$U�SoXMà�Sç}j�$adXMRTX�¥$U�Z^��eYeTU(«[EQ�RTX���_jaÜí§}jQ RfZgS=UÚa�� �-eYU�£WQ [M��_=àçRTS=U£�X�Q à���_jQ [§î�mjãcS=XM[�UÜ��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_jacØjU([M��_=à�X�_=à�RY�~£sXÏð�U(eTU�_�R�Z^[EQ�aTakUÚaRTU�_j£"RY�~SjQ(¥$UwS=X�à�S�_=U(à$Q�RTX�¥$U�Z^��eTeTU�[EQ RYXM��_ja,í§}jQ RfZgSoU�a¤� �Oà�eTU�U(_�� ðÃRTS=UJ£�XEQ�à���_jQ [§î�v���S=X�a¤}jQ RYRTU(eY_èX�aVçljZgS�V~��eYUçakl=ØoRT[MU��§��eRTS=UâZ^��eTeTU�[EQ RYXM��_áVWQ�RTeYXEZ^U�acØjQ�akU�£á��_ßQ [�[-à�U(_=UÚa,Q�_j£áX�R,X�aÜRT�èØjUçU(æs}µUÚZ^RTU�£RTS`Q R-RTS=U�_=U�Q�eTU�adR-_=U(XMà�S�Øj��e�VâU(RTS=�s£wØjU(_oU^ÙjR�a�à�eTU�Q�RT[Mqw�§eY��V RYS=UcXM_=X�RTX�Q [jadU([MU�Z*RTXM��_w���@¥�Q�eTX�Q Ø=[�U�a^v:��S=U}jQ�RTRTU�eT_�XEa:Q [Ead��V�ljZ�SakRYeT��_oà�U(e��§��e:RTS=Uc[�q�V~}oS=��VWQcQ�_j£�[MU(l=p$U�V~X�Qc£=Q RfQêRYSjQ _��§��e:RTS=U�Û,ruh@����£=Q�R�Qsv

­�/�D�}�:g8®§�/N1�:P®-8¡e�/�D�@!8/N9;/�1�®-1.<µ®-18®-§ { D�/�D % �¤_WRYS=Uw��}=}j�$akX�RTUU(_j£"����RYS=Uw}jU(ed�§��eYVWQ _jZ*U�ak}jU�Z^RYeTl=VXEaúS�D|�twv���_=UW}j�$aYakXMØo[MUWeTU�Q�ak��_H�§��e�RTS=Uâ}µ�$��e~}jU(ek�§��eTVWQ�_jZ^Uç� �êúS�D|�t#X�a,RYSjQ R�X�RwXEa�Q � à�[���ØjQ�[��V~U(RYS=�s£�m È ÒE�(Ò m-XMR�Øj��eTeT��ã�açakRYeTU(_=à�RTSß�§eT��V RTS=UWØ=l=[�p+� �ÝRTSoUè£oQ R�QsmcQ _`£äQ�a�Q�eTUÚakl=[�R�ak��V~U~��ØjakU(eY«¥�Q RYXM��_`awVWQ(q�_=��R�ØjUWã�U([�[-eTU(}=eYU�akU�_�RYU�£áØsqáRYS=UW£�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ _sRÜ¥�Q eYXEQ Øo[MU�açí ��_o[Mq+��_=U�£�XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_jQ�_�R¥�Q eYXEQ Øo[MU��§��e�RTS=UW[MU�l=p$U(V~X�Q~£=Q RfQ�adU(RçQ _j£+Rdã��è�§��e�RTS=UW[�q�V~}oS=��VWQâ£=Q RfQ�akU�R^î�vÃhi_ Z*��_sRTe�Q�akR�m�_=UÚQ eT«U�adRw_=U(X�à�SsØj��ewVâU(RTS=�s£oa,Q�eTU � [M�sZ(Q�[��svèPè��eTU~X�V~}j��eTRfQ _sRT[�q$m�ãcXMRYS+[MX�V~XMRYU�£è£oQ R�Q�Q�_j£+Q~�­Q XMeY[Mq�[�Q eTà�U_sl=V�ØjU(e�� �uà�U(_=U�a0\�mDRTS=U�VWQ�RTeYXEZ^U�ac� �uØjU(Rdã�U�U(_=«§à�eT��l=}ja�Q _`£ùãcX�RTS=X�_=« à�eT��l=}ja�akl=V � �ëaTé$ljQ eYU�aÜVWQ(qØjU�é]l=X�RTUçl=_jadR�Q Øo[MU�Q _j£+}=eY��¥�X�£�U~}j�$��eçU�akRYXMVWQ�RTU�aÜ���ÜRYS=UWZ^��eTeTUÚak}j��_j£sXM_=àå}j��}=l=[�Q RYXM��_ é]l`Q _sRTXMRYXMU�a*vñåUwadS=��ã�ØjU([M��ãûRTSjQ�R¤RYS=U�}jU(ek�§��eTVWQ�_jZ^UÜ���uúS�D|�t/Z�Q _�£�e�Q�VWQ RYXEZ(Q�[M[�q�X�V~}=eT��¥$UcãcS=U�_èRTSoU,_sl=VçØjU(e� �u¥�Q eYXEQ�Ø=[MU�aÜX�a¤£�UÚZ^eTU�Q�akU�£èRY�]\ c Ó �"Q�_j£�RTS=U�¥�Q eYXEQ�Ø=[MU�aÝQ eTUçadU([MUÚZ^RTU�£�Q�Z(Z*��e�£sXM_=à~RY��Q � adVWQ eYRTU(e��

Ó �

Page 18: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

´Tômô ¶�·�ômôûZ^eYXMRTU�eTXM��_Dv~t�[Eak�om�Q�aw£�U�aYZ^eTX�ØjU�£ù_oU(æ�R�m@|��D|¤tmBãcS=X�ZgSåXMà�_=��eYU�awZ^��eTeYU([EQ�RTXM��_jaÜØjU(Rdã�U(U(_à�U�_=U�a^m=eYU�aklo[MR�a�X�_W}=eTU�£sXEZ^RY��e�a�ãcX�RTSWVçljZgSçeTUÚ£�ljZ^U�£çV~XEaYZ^[EQ�aTakX¦Ù�Z(Q�RTXM��_~e�Q�RTU�a*v

¯B/A®_,03.18®-§se�/�D�@!8/N9;/�1�®-1.<E®-1�®_§ { D�/�D % t�akX�V~}=[�UÜP���£�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ _sR�eYl=[MU¤�§��ecV�lo[MRTX�¥�Q eTX�Q RYUc_=��eYVWQ [Z^[�Q�aTa-£�U�_jakX�RTXMUÚaOãcX�RTSâ£�XEQ�à���_jQ [ïZ^��¥�Q�eTX�Q _jZ^UcVÎQ RTeYXEZ^UÚaB}=eT�s£sljZ^U�£�XMV~}oeTU�aYakXM¥$U�[MqÜ[�� ã1V~XEaYZ^[EQ�aTadXÏÙ�Z(Q�RTX���_e�Q�RTU�aZ^��Vâ}jQ eYU�£èRT��V~��eYUçak��}oS=XEadRTXEZ�Q RTUÚ£ù}=eYU�£�X�Z^RT��e�a�akljZ�SÃQ�a,Ø`Q à�à�U�£+Z^[�Q�aYakXÏÙµZ(Q RYXM��_åRTeYU(U�a*v�ñ�XMRYSRTSoU,U�æ=Z^U�}=RTX���_~����RYS=U�[MqsV~}=S=��VWQ�£=Q RfQ�akU�R(m=[MX�_=U�Q�ecZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙjU�e�aÜíi|*�D|¤t,îfm=ãcS=XEZ�SWQ�aTakloV~UQ�Z^��V~Vâ��_Z^��¥�Q eYXEQ _`Z^UcVWQ RYeTX�æ,�§��e-RYS=UÜ£sXÏð�U(eTU�_�R-Z*[EQ�aYakU�a*m$q�X�U([E£�UÚ£,[M��ãuU(e�U(eYeT��e-efQ RTUÚaORYSjQ _Îé]ljQ�£�e�Q�RTX�ZcZ^[EQ�aTakX¦ÙjU(efaíi|BñÜ|�t,îfm�ãcSoXEZ�S+Q�[M[M��ã £�XÏð�U(eYU(_�RZ^[�Q�aYa,Z*� ¥�Q�eTXEQ�_jZ^UçVWQ RYeTX�Z^U�a^vâ��S=Uç}µU�ek�§��eYVWQ _`Z^U����Ý|��D|�tÞãcQ�aU�ad}µUÚZ^XEQ�[M[MqÎakRTeYXMpsXM_=àw�§��eÜRTSoU�Û,ruhu���~£=Q�R�Q�akU(R�m�ãcS=U(eYUwXMR�}jU(ek�§��eTV~UÚ£ÎØjU(RYRTU(e�RTS`Q _�Q�_�qW����RYS=Uw��RTS=U�eZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙjU�e�a^vu��Sslja^m��§��e¤RYS=U£=Q RfQ�akU�R�aÜZ^��_jakX�£�U(eYU�£~S=U(eTU¸m=[EQ eYà�U�à$Q�XM_jacXM_ÊQ�Z(Z*l=e�Q�Z^q~ã�U�eTU���Ø=RfQ X�_=U�£"ØsqXMà�_=��eYXM_=àJZ^��eYeTU([�Q RYXM��_`a�ØjU(Rdã�U(U�_�à�U(_=U�a*v�\$ljZ�S�}=eYU�£�X�Z^RT��e�a�Q�eTUÝak��V~U(RTX�V~U�a@Z(Q [�[MU�£ � _`Q XM¥$UÝncQ(q$U�a��smsQ�aRTSoU(q�Q�eTXEadU¤X�_çQ�ncQÚq$UÚakXEQ�_çakU(RYRTX�_=àÜãcS=U(eYUcRTS=U�}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTU�£Z^[EQ�aTa�XEa�RTSoUc��_=U�ãcXMRYS�VWQ æsXMVçl=Vû}µ�¸akRYU(eTX���e}=eY��ØjQ�Ø=XM[�XMRdql\ÁÙ$í�uTc¤{ Ú k�î�v°±:d/�,.}0<:geÕÃ)3-</N1�,²D�@}�:g9;:³3-´~µ¶3.§Nc�A ��Ç�Å�Ì�Ò % ú=��e�RTSoU"ØoXM_jQ�eTqßZ^[�Q�aYaw[MU(l=p$U�V~X�Q"£oQ R�Q�akU(R�m�ãuUQ [�ak�WU(æoQ V~X�_=U�£WRTS=Uç}jU(ek�§��eTVWQ�_jZ^U�� ��RTS=Uç¥�Q eYXEQ _sR�� �ë|��D|¤t XMVâ}=[MU(VçU(_sRdU�£~XM_��¤��[Ml=Ø ��Ç�Å�Ì�Ò ü Ó ��þimÈ ÒE�(Ò mD|*�D|¤t ãcXMRYS�² g Z(Q�[EZ^lo[EQ RYU�£èljadXM_=àWadR�Q�_j£=Q ef£á£sU(¥�X�Q RYXM��_`a¤XM_jadRTU�Q�£è� ��¥�Q�eTX�Q _jZ^UÚaÜQ _j£èãcX�RTS�RYS=U£=Q�R�Q"}oeT�sZ^U�aYakU�£ÃQ�aw£sU�aTZ^eYXMØjU�£åQ R�RTSoU�U(_`£á� �Ý\$U�Z^RYXM��_åª=výª=vW��S=X�aÜV~U(RTSo�s£äí � ����[�l=Ø��]îÝ}jU(ek�§��eTV~U�£akX�V~XM[�Q eY[MqÜRY�,Øj�$�¸akRTX�_=à�Q�_j£ç|<ñÝ|¤twm�Ø=l=R-ãcQ�aOX�_��§U(eYXM��e:RT��_=U�Q�eTU�adR�_=U(X�à�Ssص��e�auQ _j£�U�ak}jU�Z*XEQ [�[Mq|��D|�tãcS=X�ZgSçSjQ�£WQ�V~U�£�X�Q _�U(eYeT��eue�Q�RTUÜ���@ÿ(U(eT�ov-Û¤��RYU¤RYSjQ RcX�_~Z*��_sRTe�Q�akRcRY�wRTSoU�Q à�à�eTU�à$Q RYU�£~}=eTUÚ£�XEZ^RY��efaOX�_ØjQ�à�à�X�_=àWQ�_j£~ص�$�¸akRYXM_=àom�RTS=U � ¥$��RTX�_=à:��XEa���¥$U(eu¥�Q eTX�Q Ø=[�U�aÜí SoU(eTU�à�U�_=U�agî-efQ RYS=U(e�RTSjQ�_"}oeTU�£�X�Z^RT��e�a*v·®,.,.8:d,�®d<:ge�`a· ¸¹� % rutÜb���«§ØjQ�akU�£�}=eTU�£sXEZ^RY��e�a�S`Q�£,}jU(ed�§��eYVWQ _jZ*U�XM_sRTU(eYV~U�£�X�Q RYUBØjU(Rdã�U�U(_�úS�D|�tQ _`£~|��D|�t×Q�_j£ì_oU�Q eYU�akR-_=U(X�à�SsØj��e�a*v-t¤à�à�eTU(à¸Q RYU�£ì}oeTU�£�X�Z^RT��e�a�ã�U�eTUcà�U�_=U(e�Q�[M[�qwV~��eTU�Q�Z�Z^l=e�Q�RTUcRYSjQ _Q�akX�_=à�[�U~RTeYU(U~}=eYU�£�X�Z^RT��e(vå��S=UW}jQ efQ V~U�RTeTX�Zì¥$U�e�akX���_+���ÜØ`Q à�à�XM_=à1íiP4"êÛ,î�}µU�ek�§��eYV~U�£áãu��efakU~RYSjQ _RTSoU"_o��_=«§}jQ efQ V~U�RTeTX�Z��§��eTVÎa~íkr��-| Q _j£1akRfQ _j£=Q�e�£ ØjQ�à�à�XM_=àsî�vû��S=XEa�VWQ(qåصUW�§��eâQ _sq+� �,akU(¥$U(efQ [eTUÚQ�ak��_ja^m�XM_jZ^[�lj£�X�_=à�_o��_=«§_=��eYVWQ [�XMRdqWQ�_j£è[M��ã©aYQ V~}=[�UakXMÿ�Uê�§��eÜRTSoUwU�adRTXMVÎQ RTX���_W� �ORTS=UçZ^[�Q�aYaëV~UÚQ _jaQ _`£+Z^��¥�Q eTX�Q _jZ*U�VWQ�RTeYXEZ^U�a*v~�ÜadXM_=à�£�X�Q à���_jQ�[cZ^��¥�Q eYXEQ _`Z^U�VÎQ RTeYXEZ^UÚaë�§��eRTS=UâZ^[EQ�aTa£�U(_jadXMRTX�U�a�£�XE£s_ � RakU�U(V~U�£�RT��S=U�[M}åí eYU�akl=[�R�a�_=��R�akS=��ãc_�îfvër��-| rutÜb���Q _`£"Øj�$�$adRTXM_oà~}jU(ek�§��eTV~U�£çصU�RTRTU�e�RTS`Q _è��RTS=U�eQ à�à�eYU(à$Q�RTU�£á}oeTU�£�X�Z^RT��e�a*v�h¼_`Z^eTU�Q�akX�_=à~RTSoU�_�l=VçØjU(e�� �uØjQ à�à�X�_=àè��eÜØj�$�$akRYXM_=à�XMRYU(e�Q�RTXM��_jaë�§eY��V6���~RY�Ó ���Ü£�X�£�_ � R:QÚð�U�Z*RBRYS=U�}jU(ed�§��eTVÎQ _jZ^U:� ��RTS=Uu}=eTUÚ£�XEZ^RY��efa^v@��S=UcZ*��_s¥$U(æÜ}jadU(lj£���«i£=Q�R�Q¤VâU(RTS=�s££�U(}jU(_j£oa��_ÊQ�}jQ�e�Q VâU(RTU(e Ê �1üý��p Ó þiv¤\$U�¥$U(e�Q�[D¥�Q�[Ml=UÚaë��� Ê ã�U(eYU,RYeTX�U�£�m Ê cZr ����p r Ó p�r ���Pp r ��p r¦���Pp Ó m�Q�_j£"RYS=U¥�Q [�l=U~� � Ê ãcXMRTSßRYS=UWakVÎQ [M[�U�akR�RYU�akRJakU(R�U(eYeT��ewe�Q�RTUWãcQ�aweTU(RfQ X�_=U�£�våú=��eU�Q�Z�Sߣ=Q�R�Q�adU(RçRTS=X�a,¥�Q [�l=URTloeT_=U�£+��l=R�RY��ØjU"ØjU(RdãuU(U(_Îr ��Q�_j£ Ó mcadl=à�à�U�akRYXM_=àåRTSjQ�R�RYS=U~}jU(ed�§��eTVÎQ _jZ^Uâ� ��r��-| X�aw_=��R�¥$U�eTqakU�_jakX�RTXM¥$UâRT�åRTS=UW¥�Q [�l=UW� � Ê Z*��_sRTeT��[M[�XM_=à�RYS=U�£�U(à�eYU(UW� �adV~�$��RYS=XM_oà=vßñáU�ljakU�£ Ê cØrÏ����XM_ßRYS=UZ^��V~}jQ eYXEad��_Dv

«!��Ñ ��¥!§���º!��§<Ô*¦m£h©ª����¨ £�¦m�������B¨ ¦S«���×�¥½¢�¦S«Á¡��ñåU�Q [�ak�~p$U�}=R¤RYe�Q�ZgpW� �O��ØjadU(eT¥�Q RYXM��_=« ãcX�akUçV~XEaYZ^[EQ�aTadXÏÙ�Z(Q�RTX���_~efQ RTUÚaÜQ _j£è}oeTU�£�X�Z^RTX���_�¥$��RTUÚaë��¥$U(ecRYS=UeTlo_ja^v��S=XEa�Rkqs}jUw���cXM_s�§��eTVÎQ RTX���_ÊZ^��l=[�£"ØjU�ljadU^�§l=[B�§��eÜRTS=U�X�£�U(_sRTX¦Ù�Z(Q RYXM��_è� �u}j�$aYakX�Ø=[Mq�V~XEad[EQ ØjU([�U�£��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_ja*v

Ó ®

Page 19: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

úBX�à�l=eYU�a Ó �sm Ó�Ó m Ó �smçQ _j£ Ó ¬û£�XEad}=[EQ(q akl=eY¥�X�¥�Q�[�}=[M��R�aè�§��e�RYS=U+�§e�Q�Z*RTXM��_©� �W��ØjakU(eY¥�Q RTX���_ja�ãcXMRYS��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_=«§ãcXEadUèU(eYeT��e�efQ RYU"[�U�aTa�RTSjQ�_ Ó ¼äþaE~vÃ��S=U�adUÎÙ`à�l=eYU�a�Q [�ak�åXM[M[�ljakRYe�Q�RTU~RYS=UWà��$�s£ }jU(eT«�§��eYVWQ _`Z^UÜ� �O_=U�Q eYU�akRc_oU(XMà�S�Øj��efa¤Q�_j£W|��D|�t Q _`£"RTSoU,}j�$��eÜ}jU(ek�§��eTVWQ�_jZ^UÜ���-úS�D|�twv

Á�Á�Á ��[EQ�Z*Uwú@XMà�loeTU�a Ó ��m Ó�Ó m Ó ��m Ó ¬çQ Øj��loR¤S=U�eTU Á�Á�Áú=��eâQ à�à�eTU�à$Q RYU�£ }=eYU�£�XEZ*RT��efa^m�}oeTU�£�X�Z^RTX���_ߥ$��RYU�a�VWQ(qáØjUèl`akU�£ßRT�Ãakl=V~VÎQ eTX�ÿ(UçRTS=UÊakRTeYU(_=à�RTS ���JQ}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTXM��_Dv�úBX�à�l=eYU�a Ó ªom Ó �sm Ó ��m�Q�_j£ Ó �W£�X�ak}=[�QÚq�}=[M��R�aÜ� ��RTS=Uç}=eY��}j��eYRTXM��_+� �ÝZ*��eTeYU�Z^R�Z*[EQ�aYakX¦Ù�Z(Q «RTX���_ja-Q�_j£�RTSoeTU(U�_�loV�ØjU(e:akl=VâVWQ eYXMU�a-í V~UÚ£�XEQ�_çQ _j£�[M��ã�U�e�Q�_j£�l=}o}µU�e�é$ljQ�eTRTX�[MU�a�îD� �@RYS=U�}=eTU�£sXEZ^RYXM��_¥$��RYU�a¤�§��e�U�Q�ZgS���ØjakU(eY¥�Q RTX���_�í§��¥$U(eBã �B\����¤\åeYl=_jagîfv~��S=Uâé$ljQ [�XMR�Q�RTX�¥$U�Z^��eTeTUÚak}j��_j£sU(_jZ^UçØjU(Rdã�U(U(_¥$��RYU�a�Q _`£ä}=eY��}j��eYRTXM��_ja�����Z^��eTeYU�Z^RçZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙ�Z�Q RTX���_ja�adl=à�à�U�akRfaìRYSjQ Rç¥$��RYU�a�Q eYUWà��$�s£�XM_j£�X�Z(Q RY��efaw� �RTSoUWQ Ø=X�[MX�Rkq�����U�Q�Z�S+}=eYU�£�X�Z^RT��ewRT�ÊZ^[EQ�aTadXÏ�§qÃQè}jQ eYRTXEZ*l=[EQ�ew��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_1Z^��eYeTU�Z*RT[Mq¸vè��S=Uâ}=eTU�£sXEZ^RYXM��_akRYeTU(_oà�RTS`aë��������[Ml=Ø ��ÇcÅ�ÌMÒ ü Ó �(þ:akU(U(VòRT�çصUS=XMà�S=[Mqâ¥�Q�eTX�Q Ø=[�U�Q _`£èZ^��_jakU(eY¥�Q RTX�¥$U�XM_�Z^��Vâ}jQ eYXEak��_èRY�RTSoU,}oeT��}j��eTRTX���_ja�� �OZ^��eYeTU�Z^Rc}oeTU�£�X�Z^RTX���_ja*v

Á�Á�Á ��[EQ�Z*Uwú@XMà�loeTU�a Ó ª=m Ó ��m Ó ��m Ó �JQ Øj��loR¤S=U�eTU Á�Á�Áz|{ 9;6�}�3.9�® % ú=��eRTS=Uç[MqsV~}=S=��VWQ�£=Q�R�Q�adU(R(m�Rdãu�"��ØjakU�eT¥�Q RYXM��_`a,RTU�_j£�U�£�RT��صUçV~��eTUç£�X¸=WZ^lo[MRÜRY�Z^[�Q�aTadXÏ�§qåQ�_j£ùS`Q�£+adVWQ [�[MU(e�}=eTUÚ£�XEZ^RYXM��_á¥$��RTU�a*mBQ�a,X�_j£�XEZ�Q RTUÚ£èXM_ÃúBXMà�l=eTU Ó ªov~��S=U�Ù`e�akR���ØjakU(eY¥�Q RTX���_í X�_j£�U(æ Ó m��]r�� ��«d���sö���qsV~}=S�_=�s£sUv�]îXEa�Q�n�«dr�� ��Z(Q�akU$m-Ø=l=R�RYS=UWVWb¤ÛÝtÞaYQ V~}=[�U�ã�Q�a�}=eTU�}jQ eYU�£�§eT��V Q�[MqsV~}=Så_=�s£�UèØoXM��}`akqßad}µUÚZ^XMV~U�_áefQ RTSoU(e�RTSjQ�_ä�§eY��V9}jU(eYXM}=S=U�e�Q [cØo[M�$�s£ Z*U([M[�awQ�aw�§��e���RTS=U�en�«dr�� �/Z�Q�akUÚa^v���S=X�aì��ØjakU�eT¥�Q RYXM��_1RTU(_`£�U�£äRY�áØjUÊZ^[EQ�aTakX¦ÙjU�£ßQ�açQ _ úS�©Z(Q�adU$m-}µU�eTSjQ�}ja�eTU�/jU�Z^RYXM_=àRTX�aTadl=UÜaYQ V~}o[MXM_oà=v@��S=U���RTSoU(e-��ØjadU(eT¥�Q RYXM��_èí§XM_j£�U�æ�¬�¨sm � |��Br���«i��� ª¸����î-XEa�ØjU([�XMU(¥$U�£�RT��ØjUÜQ�|��Dn¤r��Z(Q�akU�Q�_j£èRTU�_j£=a¤RY��ØjUçZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙjUÚ£"Q�aÜQ _åú2�äZ�Q�akU¸v¤��SoUw��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_ja¤�§eT��V3RTS=UJakU�Z^��_j£�Z^[�Q�aTa*m�Z*��eT«eTUÚak}j��_j£sXM_=à�RT��úS� Z�Q�akUÚa^mDã�U(eYUwà�U(_=U(efQ [M[�qèSjQ�e�£�U�e,RY�W}=eTU�£sXEZ^R�Q�_j£�SjQ�£åakVWQ�[M[�U(e¤}oeTU�£�X�Z^RTX���_�¥$��RTUÚaRTS`Q _å��ØjadU(eT¥�Q RYXM��_jaê�§eY��V ��RYS=U(e�Z*[EQ�aYakU�a*vç��S=XEaÜVWQ(qWØjU~£�loU�RT�èRYS=Uw�­Q�Z*R,RYSjQ RZ^[�Q�aYa,�~��_=[Mq�SjQ�a¨��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_ja*v

z :gc��0:g9;/A® % ú=��e�RYS=UWRkãu��«­Z^[EQ�aTaw[�U(l=p$U(V~X�QW£=Q�R�Q�adU(R(m-RTSoeTU(U~��ØjakU�eT¥�Q RYXM��_`aìRYU(_j£�U�£+RY��صU�£�X¸=WZ*l=[MRRT�åZ*[EQ�aYakX¦�§q+Q�_j£+SjQ�£ßakVÎQ [M[�U(e�}=eTUÚ£�XEZ^RYXM��_á¥$��RTU�a*m-Q�awXM_`£�XEZ(Q�RTU�£åXM_ßúBX�à�l=eYU Ó �sv+��ãu��� �ÝRTS=U�adUWQ eYURTSo��l=à�S�RÜRY�~ØjUçtÜP��+Z(Q�akU�aí XM_`£�XEZ^UÚac��®~Q�_j£á����mDZ*��eTeYU�ak}j��_j£�XM_oà~RT�~X�_j£�X�Z^U�acª$®~Q�_j£á����X�_�úBX�à�l=eYUÓ �$î�Q�_j£áRTSoU���RTSoU(e�Q�_+t�� ����«­Z^U([�[-Z(Q�akU�í XM_`£�U(æ��$�$m-Z^��eTeYU�ak}j��_`£�XM_=à�RT�WXM_`£�U(æèªs�~X�_+úBX�à�l=eYU Ó �]îfv��ØjakU�eT¥�Q RYXM��_`a����åQ _j£ß�]�WãuU(eTUâ}jQ eYR�����RTS=UWRTUÚakR�adU(R�XM_ÃRTS=U�����[�l=Ø ��ÇÅ�ÌMÒ }jQ }jU(eâQ _`£HS`Q�£+[M��ã}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTXM��_~adRTeYU(_=à�RYSja�� �uv �]�êQ _j£�v Ó ��mseTU�ad}µUÚZ^RTX�¥$U([Mq$v8�¤Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_W��®wãcQ�a-}jQ eYRc� �@RYS=U¤[�U�Q eY_=XM_oà�akU�RQ _`£"SjQ�£èQw}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTXM��_�akRTeYU(_=à�RTSW� ��výª�ª�X�_"RYS=U(X�e�Z^eT�¸aTak«§¥�Q [�XE£=Q�RTXM��_�adRTlj£�q¸v

2�`��»�0� % ��S=Uc}jU(ek�§��eTVWQ�_jZ^Uu� �DRYS=Uc}=eYU�£�XEZ*RT��efaBãcQ�a�V�ljZ�S�ã���e�akUc�§��e-RYS=U�Û,ruh@����£=Q RfQ�adU(R-RTSjQ�_ì�§��eRTSoU¤��RTS=U(e-Rdã��ê£=Q RfQ�akU�R�a^vu��S=X�aOX�a�}=eT��ØjQ Ø=[�qç£�l=U�RT��RTSoUÜadVWQ [�[=Z^[�Q�aYa�adXMÿ(UÚa�Q _j£çRTS=UcS=U�RTU(eY��à�U�_=U(XMRdq� �ak��V~U�� �-RYS=U�Z*[EQ�aYakU�a�í ØoeTU�Q�akRÝQ _j£�Û,\or��Brcî�vDr-U(eTRfQ XM_ÊZ^[EQ�aTadU�aëãuU(eTU�U�Q�akX�U(e¤RY��}oeTU�£�X�Z^RcRTS`Q _���RYS=U(efaí ��Ò+��Ò VâU([EQ�_=��VWQsm [�U(l=p$U(VâXEQ�m�Z*��[M��_�î�vm��ØjakU(eY¥�Q RTX���_jaB�§eY��V RTSoU�akU�Z^[�Q�aYakU�aBU�æ�S=X�Ø=XMROakRTeY��_=àZ^��eTeYU([EQ�RTXM��_Q Vâ��_=à~RYS=U(VWadU([M¥$UÚa^msQ�aÜXM_`£�XEZ(Q�RTU�£WØ�qWRYS=Uw}jQ�R�Z�S=U�a¤���ueTU�£�Q [M��_=àWRTS=UJ£�XEQ�à���_jQ [-� �uRYS=U�Z^��eTeYU([EQ�RTXM��_VWQ�RTeTX�Z^U�a�íiúBX�à�l=eYU~¬$î�vW��S=UçRTeYXM}=[�XEZ(Q�RTU�[�U(l=p$U(V~X�Q~í���������t,îêQ _j£åØ=eTU�Q�akRJZ(Q _jZ*U(eçíiPáruú���îÜaYQ V~}o[MU�aã�U�eTUcQ�[Ead�wadRTeY��_=à�[MqçZ^��eTeTU�[EQ RYU�£�m$adl=à�à�U�akRYXM_=à�à��$�s£�eTU(}oeT�s£�ljZ*XMØ=X�[MXMRdq�� ��RYS=UcU(æs}µU�eTXMVâU(_�RfQ [�}=eT�sZ^UÚ£�l=eTU¸v

Ó ¨

Page 20: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

«!��� �° !×���¨ ¡á×��B��¢�¡8§���¨z«�×m¢�º2¦S¢���¦|�*£9¡8�hi_+à�U�_=U(e�Q�[imD�§��e�RTSoU�[�q�V~}oS=��VWQç��e�[MU�l=p$U(V~X�Q~£=Q�R�Q�akU(Rfa^m�XM_`Z^eTU�Q�akX�_=àèRYS=U~_sl=V�ØjU(eÝ� �Ý¥�Q�eTX�Q Ø=[�U�a,RY�\wcû������£sXE£�_ � RuQÚð�U�Z^Rcà�eTU�Q�RT[MqçRTSoUÜ}jU(ek�§��eTVWQ�_jZ^U�� �@RTSoUÜ¥�Q eTX���lja�}oeTU�£�X�Z^RT��e�a�íiúBX�à�l=eYU�®]îfvm�¤��ã�U(¥$U(e�m�§��eRTS=UâÛ,ruhÜ���è£=Q�R�Q�akU(R�mBRTSoU~U(eTeY��e�e�Q�RTU�a�ã�U(eYU�à�U(_oU(e�Q�[M[Mq�[���ã�U(e¤�§��e�\�c������+íiúBX�à�l=eYU~¨$î�vW��S=X�aXEa�}=eT��ØjQ Øo[Mqߣ�loU~RT��RYS=UW[EQ eYà�U(e_�loV�ØjU(e�� �ÝZ*[EQ�aYakU�a�Q�_j£+RTS=Uç�­Q�Z^R�RYSjQ R�ãcX�RTSßQ�adVWQ [�[�\ßQ�Z^eTl`£�U´Tômô ¶�·�ômôåZ^eYXMRTU�eTXM��_�XEad_ � R-Q�Ø=[MU�RT��}=X�Zgpl=}ç¥�Q�eTX�Q Ø=[�U�a�RTSjQ�Rc£�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ RYU�ØjU(RdãuU(U(_çQ [�[jRTS=U�Z^[�Q�aYakU�a*v|¤U�Z*eTU�Q�akXM_oà RTSoUá_sl=VçصU�e~� �ç¥�Q eYXEQ�Ø=[MU�a~RY�Ü\Ýc Ó � eTU�adl=[MRYU�£�XM_ Q _�X�V~}=eT��¥$U�£ß}jU(ek�§��eTVWQ�_jZ^Uå� �úS�D|�twv$��S=UcX�_jZ^eYU�Q�adUcXM_w}jU(ed�§��eYVWQ _jZ*Uc� �ïúS�D|�t ãcQ�a�U(¥$U�_wV~��eTU�}oeT��_o��l=_jZ*U�£ìãcX�RTS�RYS=U � adVWQ eYRTU(e��´Tômô ¶�·�ômôûZ^eYXMRTU�eTXM��_ßí eYU�akl=[�R�a�akSo� ãc_Ã��_=[�qè�§��e�RTS=Uç[MqsV~}=So��VWQç£=Q RfQ�adU(R^îfv~��S=U~}jU(ed�§��eYVWQ _jZ*U�� �|��D|�t Q�_j£�|<ñÝ|¤t©ãcQ�a¤_=��RÝ¥$U(eTqWadU(_jadXMRTX�¥$U�RT�çRTS=U_�l=VçØjU(ec� �u}=eYU�£�X�Z^RT��ec¥�Q�eTX�Q Ø=[�U�a^m�Q [�RTS=��l=à�S�X�RXMVâ}=eT��¥$U�£�ad[MXMà�S�RY[MqãcXMRTSâRTS=UÜ_sl=VçØjU(e-� �@¥�Q eYXEQ Øo[MU�a*v-��S=UÜXMVâ}=eT��¥$U(VçU(_$R�ã�Q�a�Vâ��eTU�}=eY��_=��l=_jZ^U�£��§��eRTSoUwÛ�ruh����ç£=Q�R�Q�m��§��e¤RYS=U�eTU�Q�ak��_jaëVâU(_�RYXM��_=U�£çQ Øj��¥$U$v

Á�Á�Á �O[�Q�Z^UúBX�à�l=eYU�ac®�mj¨çQ Øj��l=R¤SoU(eTU Á�Á�Á«!�� ¼�¡ «Á¡ ¢�×s�0¡S¥!¡8��«�¬ ��¥½�ß×�£�Ô�� ¾g¿®À.Á�±£�¡�¦S¢z¥!��¥�� ¦0¥!§½«Á¡��P«Þ�Á¡ «Á��D��Q�£o£�eTU�aYa�RTS=U�XMV~}`Q�Z^R@� �@S=U�RTU(eY��à�U�_=U(XMRdq���_çRTSoU¤}jU(ed�§��eTVÎQ _jZ^Uc���DRYS=U¤}oeTU�£�X�Z^RT��e�a*m]ãuU�Z^��_`akRTeYljZ^RYU�£Q�_=U�Q eYU�akRc_oU(XMà�S�Øj��eÝZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙjU�ecØjQ�adU�£"��_èRTSoUw¬�®ì��ØjakU�eT¥�Q RYXM��_`a¤ØjU([M��_=à�X�_=à�RY��RYS=U���eYXMà�X�_jQ [D[�U�Q eY_=XM_oàakU�RÜQ�_j£è}=eTUÚ£�XEZ^RYU�£~RTS=UeTU(VÎQ XM_oXM_=àç¬�ª~RTU�adR�akU�R¤��ØjakU(eY¥�Q RTX���_ja�ljakX�_=à~RTSoXEa�Z^[EQ�aTakX¦ÙjU(e�v¤��SoUweTUÚakl=[�RTXM_oàU(eYeT��eÝe�Q RYU�ã�Q�a�akX�V~XM[�Q ecRY�èQ~Rdqs}=XEZ(Q�[BU�eTeT��eÜe�Q�RTUçãcS=U(_å¬�®"��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_ja�Q eYUçaTQ�V~}=[MUÚ£�Q RÜefQ _j£���V�§eT��V RYS=U~}j�$��[�U�£ß£=Q RfQèRT�è�§��eTV Q"[MUÚQ eT_oXM_=àÊakU(RJQ _j£+RTSoU~eTU(VÎQ XM_oXM_=à�¬ ªåQ�eTU~l`akU�£+Q�a�QèRTU�adR�adU(R(v��Sslja^m=S=U�RTU(eY��à�U�_=U(XMRdqçXM_~RYS=U���eYXMà�X�_jQ [D[�U�Q eY_=XM_oàçQ _j£WRTU�adR�akU(Rfac£��$U�ac_=��R�adU(U(V�RT�çSjQ(¥$UÜV�l`ZgSç� �uQ�_XMVâ}jQ�Z^Ru��_W}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTXM��_W}µ��ãuU(e(v

�D�wU(æoQ V~X�_=UcãcS=U(RYS=U(e-RTSoU(eTUÝQ eYU�akqoakRYU(VWQ RYXEZc£�X¦ð�U(eTU(_`Z^U�a�XM_çà�U(_oUÜU(æs}=eTU�aYakX���_çصU�RkãuU(U(_çRTS=U���eYXMà�XM_jQ�[[MUÚQ eT_oXM_=àçadU(R�Q _j£WRTU�adRÜadU(R(m=RYS=U���ØjadU(eT¥�Q�RTXM��_ja�Z^��V~X�_=à,�§eY��V3RTSoU,[�U�Q eY_=XM_oàçakU(RcãuU(eTU�[EQ�ØjU([MU�£WQ�a������Q _`£ùRYS=�$adUì�§eY��V RTSoU�RTU�adR�akU(RQ�a<� Ó �svìñåU�RTSoU(_á}jU(ed�§��eYV~U�£èQ~V~X�_=X8�B\��Ú�¤\�e�Q�_j£���V eYU�aTQ�V~}=[�XM_=àakRYlj£�qÃíi� ¢ Ó aTZ�S=U(V~U�î�v��¤_j£�U�e¤RYS=Uµ��_=��£�XÏð�U(eYU(_jZ^Uv��Ssq�}j��RYS=U�adXEa^mïQ~���!E'V~X�aTZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙ�Z�Q RTX���_We�Q�RTU�X�aU(æs}jU�Z^RTUÚ£�v�hi_~eYU�Q [�XMRdq$m�ãuUÜ��ØjadU(eT¥$UÚ£~Q,V~UÚQ _çV~XEaYZ^[EQ�aTakX¦Ù�Z(Q�RTXM��_�efQ RYUÜ� �OQ Øj��loR����=Eâv-�D��¥$U(eTX¦�§q�RTSjQ�R���!E X�a�X�_j£�U(U�£�ãcSjQ�R�ã�UÝã���lo[E£�U(æ�}jU�Z*R�lo_j£�U(eu_=��£�X¦ð�U(eTU(_`Z^U$m$ã�U�}jU(eTVçl=RTUÚ£wRTS=UÜ[�Q ØjU([�a�Q�R�efQ _j£���VãcXMRYS+eTUÚak}jU�Z^RRT��RTSoU"à�U(_=U~U�æ�}=eYU�aTadXM��_+}=eT��Ùj[MUÚawQ _`£äeTU�}µUÚQ RTUÚ£áRTS=Uâ}=eT�sZ^UÚ£�l=eTUW��_äRYS=U~}jU(eYV�l=RYU�££=Q�R�Q�v-ñåUw£sXE£~��ØjadU(eT¥$UQ�ص��l=RÝ���=E�V~X�aTZ^[�Q�aYakXÏÙµZ(Q RYXM��_çe�Q�RTU$v

à � ����¤0��:������

ñåU¤SjQ(¥$U�Z^��V~}jQ�eTU�£wRYS=U¤}jU(ed�§��eYVWQ _jZ*Uc� �@£sXÏð�U(eTU�_�Ru£�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ RYXM��_�V~U�RTS=�s£=aB�§��e�RYS=UÝZ^[EQ�aTakX¦Ù�Z(Q�RTXM��_� �ORTl=V~��e�acljakX�_=àçà�U(_=UU(æs}=eTU�aYakX���_�£oQ R�Q��§eT��V3RYS=eTU(U�eYU�Z^U(_sR�akRYlj£�XMUÚa^vc��S=Ue�Q�_=p�X�_=à$a�� �-RYS=U�Z^[�Q�aYakXM«ÙjU(efa�ã�U(eYU�akX�V~XM[�Q euQ�Z*eT�$aYa¤£oQ R�Q�akU(Rfa¤Q�_j£~RTS=U�VWQ�XM_âZ^��_`Z^[MljadXM��_Dm��§��ecRYS=U�akU£=Q�R�Q�akU(Rfa^m=XEa�RYSjQ R�adXMV~}o[MUZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙjU�e�acakl`ZgS�Q�a�|��D|�t©Q _j£W_=U�Q eYU�akR�_=U(X�à�SsØj��e�a�}jU(ed�§��eYV eYU(VWQ�eTp�Q Ø=[�q�ã�U([�[DZ^��V~}jQ�eTU�£~RT��Vâ��eTUak��}=S=X�akRTX�Z(Q RYU�£~V~U(RYS=�s£=acakl`ZgS�Q�a�Q à�à�eYU(à$Q�RTU�£�Z^[EQ�aTakX¦Ù�Z(Q�RTXM��_WRTeTU�U�a^v

���

Page 21: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

hi_ß��l=eç}=eTX�_jZ^X�}jQ [�Z^��V~}`Q eTX�ak��_Dm�ãcXMRYS�Q _ßX�_�RYU(eTV~UÚ£�XEQ�RTUç_�l=VçØjU(e�� ��}oeTU�£�X�Z^RT��ew¥�Q eYXEQ�Ø=[MU�a�adU([MUÚZ^RTU�£Q�Z�Z^��ef£�XM_=àWRY�èQWZ^eYlj£�U]´Tômô ¶�·�ômô Z^eTX�RTU(eYXM��_ïm�_=U�Q�eTU�adR,_oU(XMà�S�Øj��eZ^[�Q�aYakXÏÙ`U(e�aÜQ�_j£å|��D|¤t SjQ�£ùRYS=U[M��ãuU�akR�U(eYeT��e�efQ RTUÚa^mBãcSoXM[MUâúS�D|�t S`Q�£áRYS=U~S=X�à�S=U�adR(vèrutÜb:��« ØjQ�akU�£ÃZ^[EQ�aTakX¦ÙjU(efaêS`Q�£á}jU(ed�§��eTVÎQ _jZ^UXM_sRTU�eTV~U�£sXEQ RYU�صU�RkãuU(U(_ÊúS�D|¤t�Q _`£ù_=UÚQ eTUÚakRÜ_=U�XMà�SsØj��efa,Q�_j£+|��D|�twm�ãcX�RTSåQ�à�à�eYU(à$Q�RTU�£ÃZ^[EQ�aTakX¦ÙjU(efaØjU(XM_oà�V~��eTUQ�Z�Z^l=e�Q�RTURTSjQ�_�QçakXM_oà�[MURTeYU(U$vu��S=Uwà�eTU�Q�RTU�adRÜà$Q�XM_ja��§eT��V%Q�à�à�eTU(à¸Q RTX���_åã�U(eYU���Ø=RfQ XM_oU�£Øsq�Øj�$�$adRTX�_=à~Q�_j£~ØjQ à�à�X�_=à�ãcXMRYSùr��-|wvo��S=UÜX�V~}=eT��¥$U(VçU(_sRB����r��-|���¥$U(euakRfQ _j£=Q�e�£WØjQ à�à�XM_oàWí _=��_=«}jQ�e�Q VâU(RTeYXEZ�Øj�$��R�adRTefQ }WaYQ V~}=[�U�agîjVÎQÚqÝصU�£sl=U�RY�ÜRTS=U-�­Q�Z^R:RTSjQ�R�r��-| à�U(Rfa�Q eY��l=_j£�RTSoUc£�X�aTZ^eYU(RTU(_oU�aTa� �uRYS=UçaTQ�V~}=[MX�_=àçak}`Q�Z^U�Øsq�aTQ Vâ}=[MX�_=àì�§eY��V Q~akV~�$��RTS=UÚ£"¥$U(efakXM��_è���cRTSoUwU(V~}oXMeTX�Z(Q [ïZ�v £�v �Yv�ú=��eÜRYS=U£=Q�R�Q�adU(R�a�Z*��_jadXE£�U(eYU�£áS=U�eTU$m�RYS=UW£�U(à�eTU(Uâ� �ÝakVâ�$��RTSoXM_=à�ã�Q�a,�­Q X�eT[�q�S=XMà�S×í Ê c rÏ�Ú�]î�vå��S=Uâ[EQ�Z�på� �Q�Z�Z^l=e�Q�Z^qè����úS�D|¤t X�aë[�XMp$U([�qW£�l=U�RY�~RTSoU�}µ�$��e�U�akRYXMVWQ�RTXM��_è���cZ*� ¥�Q�eTXEQ�_jZ^UVWQ RYeTXEZ*U�a�ãcXMRYSåQ"adVWQ [�[RTefQ X�_=XM_=àadU(RcQ�_j£~Q¤�­Q X�eT[Mq�[�Q eYà�U�_�l=VçØjU(e����Dà�U�_=U�a�\�v-hi_j£�U(U�£�m�£sU�Z^eTUÚQ�akX�_=à�RTS=U�_sl=V�ØjU(e@� �@¥�Q�eTXEQ�Ø=[MUÚaeTUÚakl=[�RTU�£�X�_WQ _WX�V~}=eT��¥$U�£w}jU(ed�§��eYVWQ _jZ*U¤���-úS�D|�twvst¤[�ak�=msXMà�_=��eYXM_=àçZ^��eTeYU([EQ�RTXM��_ja�ØjU(RdãuU(U(_~à�U(_=U�auQ�aXM_�|��D|�t/}oeT�s£�ljZ*U�£"X�V~}=eTUÚaTakX�¥$U([¦qw[�� ã V~XEaYZ^[EQ�aTakX¦Ù�Z(Q�RTXM��_�efQ RYU�a¤Z*��V~}jQ�eTU�£çRT�çV~��eYU�ak��}=S=XEadRTX�Z(Q RYU�£Z^[�Q�aTadXÏÙjU�e�a^v�ú`��e¤RYS=UwØoXM_jQ�eTq�Z^[EQ�aTac[MU(lop$U(V~XEQ�£=Q�R�Q�akU(R�mD|��D|�t/}jU(ek�§��eTV~UÚ£ÎØjU(RYRTU(ecRYSjQ _�RYS=UweYU([EQ�RTU�£à�U�_=U�¥$��RTX�_=àWaTZ�S=U(VâUw� �*����[MloØ ��ÇÝÅ�ÌMÒ ü Ó ��þiv���S=X�aÜXEa�£�l=UçRT�WRTSoU~Z^��eTeYU�Z^RTUÚ£è¥�Q�eTX�Q _jZ^UâZ(Q�[EZ^l=[�Q RYXM��_Q _`£"}jU(ek�§��eTV~X�_=àw¥�Q�eTXEQ�Ø=[MUadU([MU�Z*RTXM��_~��_ÊQ [�eTU�Q�£�q~[M��à�«§RTefQ _jai�§��eTVâU�£W£=Q RfQ�v

ñåUèØ=eYXMU /jq1Q�£=£�eTUÚaTakUÚ£ RTS=U�XMV~}jQ�Z^R�� �¥�Q eYXEQ�Ø=[MUÊakU([�U�Z^RTX���_1��_�RTSoUèeTU�[EQ RYXM¥$UW}jU(ek�§��eTVWQ�_jZ^UW� �RYS=UZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙjU�e�a^v-ú=��ecRTS=UÜ[�q�Vâ}=S=��VÎQ,Q�_j£~[MU(lop$U(V~XEQÝ£=Q RfQ�akU�R�a^mjRTSoU,}jU(ed�§��eYVWQ _jZ*U¤���-RTS=Uê£�XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_jQ�RTX���_V~U(RYS=�s£=ac��RYS=U(e�RTSjQ�_åúS�D|¤t�ã�Q�aë�­Q�XMeT[�q~XM_`akU(_jadXMRYXM¥$U�RT�çRTS=U_�loV�ØjU(eu� �u}=eTUÚ£�XEZ^RY��ec¥�Q eYXEQ�Ø=[MU�a*v���S=UQ�Z�Z^l=e�Q�Z^qß� �ú2�D|¤t3XMV~}=eY��¥$U�£+£�efQ VWQ�RTXEZ�Q [M[�qù�§��el\�c Ó �å¥�Q�eTX�Q Ø=[�U�a�adU([MUÚZ^RTU�£ÃQ�Z(Z^��e�£�X�_=à+RY�áRYS=U� adVWQ eYRTU(e��l´Tômô ¶�·�ômôåZ^eYXMRYU(eTX���_Dv2�¤��ã�U(¥$U(e�m�ãcXMRYS=��loR�Z(Q eYU^�§l=[j}=eTU�«iaYZ^eTU(U�_=XM_=à�����RYS=UÜ¥�Q eYXEQ Øo[MU�a*m]ãuUØjU([MX�U(¥$UçRTSjQ�R�_=U�Q eYU�akR_=U(X�à�Ssص��e(mu|��D|�twm���e~rutÜb:��« ØjQ�akU�£ßZ^[�Q�aYakXÏÙ`U(e�aQ eTUW}=eYU^�§U(efQ Ø=[�U~RT�åúS�D|�twvú=��e�RTS=UÛ,ruhu���~£oQ R�QsmµX�_jZ^eYU�Q�adXM_=à�RYS=Uw_sl=VçصU�e�� �O}=eTU�£sXEZ^RY��ec¥�Q eYXEQ Øo[MU�acRT�E\÷cû������X�V~}=eY� ¥$UÚ£ìRYS=UQ�Z�Z^l=e�Q�Z^q~����RYS=UZ^[EQ�aTakX¦ÙjU(efa^v

PèXEaYZ^[EQ�aTadXÏÙ�Z(Q�RTX���_We�Q�RTU�a��§��e¤RYS=U£�XÏð�U(eYU(_�R�Z*[EQ�aYakX¦ÙjU(e�a�ãuU(eTUÝU�akRYXMVWQ�RTU�£�Ø`Q�akUÚ£"��_�e�Q�_j£���V £�X�¥�X�akX���_ja� �:U�Q�ZgSW£oQ R�Q�akU(RcX�_�RY�çQw[MU�Q�eT_=X�_=à�adU(R�Q _`£"QwRYU�akR�akU(R�Z*��V~}=eYXEadXM_=à�eTUÚak}jU�Z^RYXM¥$U([�q�Rkãu�wRYS=XMef£=acQ _j£~��_=URTSoXMe�£+����RTS=U�£=Q�R�Q í­� ¢ Ó aYQ V~}=[�XM_=àÊaTZ�S=U(V~U�î�v°��_=UW_=U�U�£=a�RT�ã�XEadRTXM_oà�l=X�akSßØjU(Rdã�U(U(_ÃRkãu�áRfQ�adp=a ¢U�adRTXMVÎQ RTX�_=àwVâXEaTZ*[EQ�aYakX¦Ù�Z(Q RYXM��_~e�Q�RTU�a*m È ÒE�(Ò m=UÚakRTX�VWQ RYXM_=à�RYS=U�}=eT��ØjQ ØoXM[MX�Rdq~RTSjQ�RÜQ�à�X�¥$U(_�Z^[EQ�aTadXÏÙjU(ecãcX�[M[V~X�aTZ^[�Q�aTadXÏ�§qWQç_=U(ã aTQ�V~}=[MU£�efQ(ãc_ù�§eY��V%RYS=U�aYQ V~UJ£�XEadRTeYXMØ=l=RYXM��_åQ�a¤RYS=U�[MU�Q�eT_=X�_=àWadU(R�íiQ�[Ead�WZ(Q [�[MU�£à�U�_=U(e�Q�[MX�ÿ�Q RYXM��_�U�eTeT��e^îfm$Q _j£çZ^��V~}jQ eYXM_=àÝRTS=UcV~X�aTZ^[�Q�aYakXÏÙµZ(Q RYXM��_�efQ RTUÚaO���DRdã��Ý��e�V~��eTU�Z^[EQ�aTakX¦ÙjU(efa�íiadU(U£�X�aTZ^ljaYakX���_WXM_èr-S`Q }=RYU(e��w� �ObëX�}=[MU�q�ü ����þ§î�v:��S=UakU�Z^��_j£~R�Q�akp�m�ãcS=X�ZgS~X�a���l=ecVÎQ XM_âZ^��_jZ^U(eY_~S=U(eYU$m�X�ae�Q�RTS=U�eÜU�Q�adXMU(eêQ�a�Z^[EQ�aTadXÏÙjU(efaÜQ eYUçZ^��Vâ}jQ eYU�£èljakX�_=à~RYS=UçaTQ�V~UwRYU�akRakU�R(v�ñáUçZ�S=�$adUçQW� ¢ Ó aTZ�S=U(V~U$me�Q�RTS=U�e�RYSjQ _�RYS=Uè}jU(eYSjQ }ja~V~��eTU�akRfQ _j£oQ e�£�¨ ¢ Ó aYZgS=U�V~U~XM_1RTS=U�VWQ�Z�S=X�_=UW[MU�Q�eT_=X�_=àá[�XMRYU(e�Q�RTl=eYU$mØjU�Z(Q�ljakU��§��e���l=eÝ£=Q RfQ�adU(R�a¤RYS=U�[EQ�RTU(eÝaTZ�S=U(V~U�eTUÚakl=[�RTU�£~XM_�¥$U(eTqâakVÎQ [M[�RTU�adRÜadU(R�a�Q _`£"V~��eTU�£�X¸=WZ*l=[MR£�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ RYXM��_çØjU(Rdã�U(U�_"RYS=UZ^[EQ�aTadXÏÙjU(efac£�l=U�RT�çRTSoUw£sXEaTZ*eTU(RYU(_=U�aYa�� �ORTS=U�U(eYeT��e�e�Q�RTU�a*v�h �@��l=e¤VÎQ XM_Z^��_jZ^U(eY_�ã�Q�a�RT�U�akRYXMVWQ�RTU�à�U(_=U(efQ [�XMÿ�Q�RTXM��_�U�eTeT��e(msQ�� ¢ Ó aTZ�S=U(V~Uuã���l=[E£�ØjU¤ã�Q�akRYU^�§l=[j� ��aTZ(Q�e�Z^UÝ£=Q�R�QãcS=X�ZgSÃZ^��lo[E£���RTSoU(eTãcX�akU~ØjUçljakU�£��§��ewRYe�Q�XM_=X�_=à=vWt¤[�ak�omBã�Uçã���l=[E£å_=U(U�£�V�l`ZgS�[�Q eTà�U(e£=Q RfQ�adU(R�awRY�à�U�RceTU�Q�ak��_`Q Ø=[�qWQ�Z(Z*l=e�Q�RTUÜU�adRTX�VWQ RYU�a�� �:U(eTeY��e�efQ RYU�a^v-Û¤��RTUÜRYSjQ R�adXM_jZ*UÜã�U�Q�eTU�}jU(ek�§��eTV~X�_=à�¥�Q eTX�Q Ø=[�UakU�[MU�Z^RYXM��_���_çRTS=U�[MU�Q�eT_=X�_=à�adU(R�í�´Tômô ¶�·�ômô�Z*eTXMRYU(eTX���_�îfm�RTSoU¤��l=RT«§� �§«§ØjQ à�VâU(RTS=�s£~í­n�eTU(X�VWQ _âüý� þ îD�§��eU�adRTXMVÎQ RTX�_=àÜV~X�aTZ^[�Q�aYakXÏÙµZ(Q RYXM��_�efQ RYU�a�eTU�adl=[MRfa�XM_ç��¥$U(eT[�q���}=RYXMV~X�akRTX�Z�U�akRYXMVWQ�RTU�aD� �@RYS=U�U(eTeY��e�efQ RYU�a-Q _j£S=U(_`Z^UÜXEac_=��R�Q }=}=eY��}=eYXEQ�RTUwSoU(eTU$v

� Ó

Page 22: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

��S=U(eYU~Q�eTU��­Q�Z^RY��efa,��RYS=U(eRTSjQ�_+Q�Z(Z^l=efQ�Z^q�ãcS=X�ZgSÃZ^��_�RYeTXMØol=RTU�RY�èRTSoU�V~U�eTXMRfaë���ÝQ"à�XM¥$U(_åZ^[�Q�aYakXÏÙ`U(e(v��S=U�adUÜXM_`Z^[Mlj£sUÜadXMV~}=[�XEZ^X¦RdqQ _j£çXM_jadXMà�SsR�à¸Q X�_=U�£�X�_�RY�,RYS=UÜ}=eYU�£�X�Z^RTX�¥$U�akRTeYljZ^RYl=eTU�� �:RTS=UÝ£=Q�R�Q�vu|��D|�tXEaÜU�Q�akqåRT�WXMVâ}=[MU(VçU(_sR�Q _j£åSjQ�£áeYU(VWQ�eTp�Q Ø=[�qè[�� ã U(eTeY��e�e�Q�RTU�a�XM_å��l=eJakRYlj£�q$m@Ø=l=R�XMR�XMà�_=��eYU�awZ*��eT«eTU�[EQ RYXM��_ja�ØjU(Rdã�U(U(_W}=eYU�£�X�Z^RT��ec¥�Q�eTX�Q Ø=[�U�aÜí à�U(_=U�a�î�vu��S=U�akUZ^��eTeYU([EQ�RTXM��_ja�Q eTU�Ø=X���[���à�X�Z(Q [DeYU�Q [�XMRYXMU�auQ _j£ãcS=U(_�Vâ��eTU�£=Q RfQ¤ØjU�Z^��V~UcQ(¥�Q X�[EQ Øo[MU�ãuUcVWQ(q¤Ùj_j£wRYSjQ R-X�à�_=��eTXM_oàÜRTS=U�V/X�aB}=eY��Ø=[�U(VWQ RYXEZ�vït¤[Ead�=m:�D|�tí ãcX�RTSW£sXEQ à���_jQ�[D��e�Q eTØoXMRTefQ eYq~Z^��¥�Q eYXEQ�_jZ^UÜVWQ�RTeYXMæjîDXEa-l=_jQ Øo[MU�RT��SjQ�_j£�[MUÝXM_sRTU(efQ�Z^RYXM��_`aOØjU(RdãuU(U(_ç}=eTU(«£�X�Z^RT��e,¥�Q�eTXEQ�Ø=[MUÚa^v÷��U(_oU�X�_�RYU(e�Q�Z^RTX���_jaÜQ�eTUçXMV~}j��eTR�Q�_�R�Ø=X���[���à�X�Z(Q [�[MqÊQ _j£�VWQ(q�Z^��_�RYeTX�Ø=l=RTU�RY��Z^[�Q�aYa£�X�akRTX�_jZ^RYXM��_`a^ö$XMà�_=��eYXM_=àRTS=U(V�XEa�_=��R�£�U�adXMe�Q�Ø=[MU¸v�Û¤U�Q�eTU�adR-_=U(XMà�S�Øj��ecZ^[�Q�aTadXÏÙjU�e�a-Q eYU�akX�V~}=[MU¸m�XM_sRTl=X�RTX�¥$UQ _`£ÎS`Q�£~XMV~}oeTU�aYakXM¥$U�[Mq�[M��ã�U(eYeT��ecefQ RYU�acZ^��Vâ}jQ eYU�£ìRY��V~��eYUÜad��}=SoXEakRYXEZ(Q�RTU�£âZ^[EQ�aTakX¦ÙjU(efa^v�ñ�S=X�[MUÜRYS=U(qQ eYU�Q Ø=[�U~RT�åSjQ _`£�[MU~X�_�RYU(e�Q�Z^RTX���_ja�ØjU(Rdã�U(U(_Ãà�U(_=UÚa^m-RTS=U(qã��Ãak��X�_ Q � Ø=[EQ�Zgps«§Øµ��æÁ�èãcQ(qßQ�_j£+à�XM¥$U¥$U(eYq�[MXMRYRT[�UcXM_jadXMà�SsR�X�_�RY�wRYS=UÜadRTeYljZ^RTloeTUÜ���@RTS=U�£oQ R�Qsv�n�qçZ*��_sRTe�Q�akR�mjZ^[EQ�aTakX¦Ù�Z(Q�RTXM��_�RYeTU(UÚa�Q eYU�Z(Q�}jQ Ø=[�URT��U(æs}=[M��XMR�Q�_j£ùeYU(¥$U�Q�[�XM_sRTU(efQ�Z^RYXM��_jaÜصU�RkãuU(U(_�¥�Q eYXEQ�Ø=[MU�a*v~�DeTU(UÚa,Q�eTUçU�Q�adq�RT��XM_sRTU(eY}=eTU(RêQ _j£�q�X�U([E£XM_s�§��eTVÎQ RTX���_ß��_1RTS=U�eTU([�Q RYXM��_`akS=X�} ØjU(Rdã�U(U�_ä}oeTU�£�X�Z^RT��e�¥�Q eTX�Q Ø=[�U�açQ _j£ eYU�ak}j��_`akU�a�Ø�qß}jU(ed�§��eTVâXM_=àakRYU(}sãcXEakU¥�Q eTX�Q Ø=[�UakU([�U�Z^RTX���_DvH�¤��ã�U(¥$U(e�m=Z^[�Q�aYakXÏÙµZ(Q RYXM��_�RTeYU(U�acRTU(_j£WRT�~ØjUl=_jakRfQ Ø=[�U�Q�_j£è[EQ�ZgpsXM_=à�X�_Q�Z�Z^l=e�Q�Z^q$vÃ��S=U(XMeJQ�Z(Z*l=e�Q�Z^qßZ(Q�_äØjUWà�eYU�Q RY[Mq+X�V~}=eY� ¥$UÚ£èØ�qßQ�à�à�eTU(à¸Q RTX���_ í ØjQ�à�à�X�_=àå��eçص�$�¸akRYXM_=àsî�vt¤[�RTS=��l=à�S�ak��V~U�adXMV~}=[�XEZ^X�Rdq,X�a�[M�¸akRcØsqWQ à�à�eTU�à$Q RYXM_=àçRTeYU(U�a*m=Q à�à�eYU(à$Q�RTXM��_�VWQ(q�ØjU,l`akU�£WQ�ac}jQ�eTRc� ��Q¥�Q eYXEQ Øo[MUÝakU([�U�Z^RTX���_âQ }=}oeT�$Q�ZgSÊíiú=eTX�£�[MqsQ�_j£�Q�_j£"\$}jU(UÚ£�m�ãu��eTp�X�_~}=eY��à�eYU�aTa�î�v-t�ljakU*�§l=[�Øsq�«§}=eY�s£�ljZ^Ru� �Q à�à�eYU(à$Q�RTU�£�RYeTU(U�Z*[EQ�aYakX¦ÙjU(e�a:Q eTUcRYS=Uc}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTXM��_�¥$��RYU�aBãcS=X�ZgSçZ(Q�_�ØjUcljadU�£�RT�Q�aYakU�aYaORYS=UÝZ^��_�Ùµ£�U(_jZ^U� �ïU�Q�Z�S�}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTXM��_DvDñáUcS`QÚ¥$Uu��_=[�q�[M�$��p$U�£�Q R-}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTXM��_w¥$��RTU�aBX�_çQ�é]ljQ�[MX�R�Q RYXM¥$U-VWQ�_=_=U(e�ö�XMR�ãu��l=[�£ØjU~XM_sRTU�eTU�adRTXM_oà~RT�ÊZ(Q eYeTq���loR�Q"Vâ��eTUçé$ljQ�_�RYXMR�Q�RTX�¥$UçQ _jQ�[MqoakXEaQ _j£åU(æ�}o[M��eYU�RYS=UçljakU~����RTS=eYU�akSo��[E£oa�§��e�VWQ�p�X�_=àw��e¤_=��R¤VÎQ psXM_=àJQì}jQ�eTRYXEZ^l=[�Q ec}=eYU�£�X�Z^RTX���_Dv:Û¤��RYU,RYSjQ R�RTSoUwZ*��_jZ^[�ljakX���_jaceTUÚQ�Z�S=U�£�X�_è��loeakRYlj£�qWã�U�eTU�ØjQ�adU�£"��_åQ�Z*��V~}jQ�eTX�ak��_W���cZ*[EQ�aYakX¦ÙjU(e�a���_è¥$U(eYqWakVÎQ [M[ï£=Q RfQ�adU(R�a¤ØsqWVWQ�Z�S=X�_=U¤[�U�Q eY_=XM_oàakRfQ _j£oQ e�£oa^vutÜa�V~��eTU�£=Q�R�QwØjU�Z^��V~U�Q(¥�Q XM[�Q Ø=[�U$m$ã�UÝZ(Q _âU(æ�}jU�Z*R�RY�w��ØjakU(eY¥$UÜQ�_WXMV~}=eY��¥$U(V�U*_sRBX�_�RYS=U}jU(ek�§��eTVWQ�_jZ^Uc���:Q à�à�eTU(à¸Q RYU�£WZ^[EQ�aTakX¦ÙjU(efaOeYU([EQ�RTX�¥$UcRT��adXMV~}o[MU(e:Z^[EQ�aTadXÏÙjU(efa^msQ�a-RTeYU(U�a-akS=��l=[E£çصUÝQ Øo[MUÜRY�Z^��eTeTUÚZ^RT[�q"X�£�U(_sRTX¦�§q~XM_sRTU(efQ�Z^RYXM��_ja^vÜñåUwVWQ(q�Q [�ak�~ØjUâQ Ø=[�UwRY�"l`akU�RTSoU�akU�V~U�RTS=�s£=acRT�âà$Q X�_+QçصU�RTRTU�el=_j£sU(e�adR�Q _`£�XM_=àç� �ORTS=U�}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTXM¥$U�adRTeYljZ^RTloeTU�� �-RYS=U£=Q RfQ�v

��l=eWadRTlj£�q1£�X�£ _=��RâXM_jZ^[�lj£�U�Z^U(eYR�Q�XM_ }j��}=l=[EQ�e�Z^[EQ�aTakX¦ÙjU(efaJ�§eY��V RYS=U"Ù`U([E£ß� �VWQ�Z�S=X�_=UW[MU�Q�eT_=X�_=à=makl`ZgS�Q�ac_=U(loe�Q [D_oU(Rdã���eYp=aÜí­bëX�}=[MU�q�ü ����þ§î-��e�adl=}=}j��eYRÜ¥$U�Z^RY��e�VÎQ�Z�S=XM_=UÚaëíd\!"�Páî�í�"�Q�}=_=X�p�üý¬ Ó þ îfvBñåU£�U([�XMØjU(efQ RTU�[MqåZ�S=�$�$adU"RY��[M�$��p Q�RçakX�V~}=[MU�VâU(RTS=�s£oa,ãcS=X�ZgS+eYU�é$l=XMeYU~[MX�RTRT[�U�RYe�Q�XM_=X�_=à=våñ�S=XM[�U"\!"êP�aQ eYU~eTUÚZ^U(XM¥sXM_oà~QW[M��R� �ÝQ�RTRTU�_�RYXM��_ÃQ _`£áSjQ(¥$U�ØjU(U�_+Q�}=}=[MX�U�£åakljZ(Z*U�aTai�§l=[M[�q�RT��ad��V~U�}oeT��Øo[MU(VWaí �(Ò+��ÒSjQ�_j£�ãceTX�RTRYU(_~£sXMà�X�R�eTUÚZ^��à�_=XMRYXM��_�î�m$RTS=U�qweTUÚé]l=X�eTUuV~��eYUcRTe�Q�XM_=X�_=àÜRYSjQ _~RYS=UcV~U(RYS=�s£=a�Z*��_jadXE£�U(eYU�£�S=U(eTUí ��Ò+��Ò Z�S=��X�Z^Uw���cp$U(eY_=U([D�§l=_jZ^RYXM��_�x Q�_j£+aYZ(Q [�Uw�­Q�Z^RY��e ¾ î�vçt¤[�ak�om�RTS=U�à�U(_=U(efQ [�XMÿ�Q�RTXM��_�� �Ý\!"�P�a¤RY�V~��eTU�RTSjQ�_�Rdã��âZ^[EQ�aTakUÚa¤XEac_=��RÝ��Øs¥�X���lja*v¤ñåU�Q eYUçQ(ãcQ eYUw���cQ��§U(ã©Q }o}=[MX�Z(Q RYXM��_`a¤� �c\Ä"�P�aëRY�~à�U�_=UU(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_W£oQ R�Qsvë\Ä"�P�a�ã�U(eYU�Q }=}o[MXMUÚ£�RT�RTS=U�t*� ����tÜP��å£=Q RfQ�m=Ø=loRc£�X�£�_ � RuXMV~}oeT��¥$U���¥$U(e�QwakX�V~«}=[�Uw_=U�Q�eTU�adR¤_oU(XMà�S�Øj��e���eê|��D|¤t Z^[EQ�aTadXÏÙjU(eí }jU(efak��_jQ [-Z*��V~Vçl=_=X�Z(Q�RTXM��_Dm=\sQ X�e�Q~PèX�Q _�îfv�h¼_�Q�_=��RYS=U(eQ }o}=[MX�Z(Q RYXM��_ïm�n�eY� ãc_ ��ÇÅ�ÌMÒ ü Ó ��þ�ljadU�£ \Ä"�P�a,RY�+Z^[�Q�aYakXÏ�§qåà�U�_=U�a^m-e�Q�RTS=U�e�RTSjQ�_ VWb�ÛÜt�aTQ Vâ}=[MU�a*v��S=U(qçZ*��_jadXE£�U(eYU�£���_=[�q�Ø=XM_jQ�eTqâZ^[EQ�aTadXÏÙ�Z(Q�RTX���_�í È ÒE�(Ò m$U�Q�ZgSâZ^[EQ�aTa-¥$U(e�adlja�XMR�a-Z^��V~}=[�U(V~U*_�R*î�Q _j£ì�§��l=_j£RTS`Q R�\Ä"�P�aÜ��l=RY}µU�ek�§��eYV~U�£åZ^eT�¸aTa�Å$¥�Q [�XE£=Q�RTU�£álo_jQ à�à�eTU�à$Q RYU�£ßZ^[EQ�aTadXÏÙ�Z(Q�RTX���_åRTeTU�U�a�Q _j£+ú2�D|¤twvDñåU[M�$��p$U�£�X�_�RY�wQ�}=}=[�q�X�_=àw[���à�X�akRYXEZÜ£�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ RYXM��_�Q _`£"Q�}jU(e�Z^U�}=RTeY��_WZ^[�Q�aYakXÏÙ`U(eÜí­bëX�}=[MU(qÎü ��� þ î:RT�RTS=U�adU£=Q�R�Q�adU(R�a*m�Ø=l=Rç��loe�}=eTU([�XMV~X�_jQ eYq�eTl=_`aìãuU(eTU~_o��RçU(_jZ^��l=e�Q�à�XM_oà=v1ú`��e�[���à�XEakRYXEZW£�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ RYXM��_ïm�ãuUU(_jZ*��l=_sRTU(eYU�£�RTS=UÜãuU([M[�« ps_=��ãc_âakXMRYljQ RYXM��_~� �:XM_�Ù`_=XMRYU¤}jQ�e�Q�V~U(RTU�e�UÚakRTX�VWQ RYU�a��§��ec}µU�ek�§U�Z^R-[�XM_=U�Q�euakU(}jQ�«e�Q�RTX���_w����RTS=U�Z^[EQ�aTakUÚa���_�RTS=U-[MUÚQ eT_oXM_=àÝakU(R�vBñåU�RYS=U(_�Z*��_jadXE£�U(eYU�£�bë�¸akU(_sØ=[�Q RTR � aD}jU(e�Z^U�}=RTeY��_w[�U�Q eY_=XM_oàeTlo[MU�ãcSoXEZ�S�XEa�ad}µUÚZ^XÏÙ�Z�Q [M[�q�£�U�adXMà�_=U�£,�§��e-[�XM_=U�Q�eT[�q�akU(}`Q e�Q�Ø=[MUÝZ^[�Q�aTadU�a^v:��S=Uc}jU(e�Z*U(}=RTeY��_�RYU�akR-adU(R�U(eYeT��e

���

Page 23: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

e�Q�RTU�a�ãuU(eTU�£�XEaYQ }=}j��X�_�RYXM_=àov�ñáU�SjQ(¥$U�_o��RuZ^��_`akXE£sU(eTU�£wVâ��eTU�ak��}=S=XEadRTX�Z(Q RYU�£ì}jU(efZ^U(}=RYeT��_çQ [Mà���eYXMRTSoVWa^v

t ¥$U(eYq,X�V~}j��eYR�Q _sR�X�aTakloUcãcS=XEZ�S�eTU(VÎQ XM_`a�RY�,ØjUÝQ�£=£seTU�aYakU�£�XEaBRYS=UcXE£sU(_�RYXÏÙ�Z�Q RTX���_���� � VÎQ eTp$U�e3�cà�U(_=UÚa�§��e�RTloV~��e�Z^[�Q�aYakU�a*vcú=��e�V~��eYU,RYSjQ _�Rdãu�çZ^[EQ�aTakUÚa^m�Q�Z^eYlj£�UJZ^eTX�RTU(eYXM��_W[�XMp$UB´Tômô ¶�·�ômô+X�aëà�U(_=U(efQ [�[Mql=_jQ�Ø=[MUÝRT�w}oXEZ�p�l=}~¥�Q eYXEQ Øo[MU�a�RTS`Q R�£�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ RYU�ØjU(Rdã�U(U�_~Q�[M[jRTS=UêZ^[EQ�aTakUÚa¤í �E��Ò X�V~}=eT��¥$U(VçU(_sRBl`akXM_oàRTSoU � adVWQ eYRTU(e���´Tômô ¶?·áômô�Z^eYXMRYU(eTX���_Ü�§��e@RTS=Uu[MqsV~}=S=��VWQ�£oQ R�Q�akU(R*î�v:h¼R:Q [�ak�ÜRYU(_j£=aDRT�Ý}=XEZ�pÜl=}à�U(_=UÚaRTS`Q R�Q eYU�S=XMà�S=[MqâZ^��eYeTU([�Q RYU�£WQ _j£W£��$U�ad_ � RceYU(¥$U�Q�[�XM_sRTU�e�Q�Z*RTXM��_ja�ØjU(RdãuU(U(_~à�U(_=U�a*v�ñ�XMRTS�Q�_�qç¥�Q eTX�Q Ø=[�UakU�[MU�Z^RYXM��_åQ }=}=eY�$Q�ZgSDm@ã�UçV�l`akRÜØjUâQÚã�Q eYU~� ��RTS=UçXEaYakl=Uç� �ÝadR�Q RYXEadRTXEZ�Q [ �g��Ò Ø=X���[M��à�X�Z(Q [uakX�à�_=X¦Ù�Z(Q�_jZ^U$vt/}ol=eTU([�qWakRfQ RYXEakRYXEZ(Q�[�Q�}=}=eY�$Q�Z�S�VWQ(q~X�£�U(_sRTXÏ�§qâà�U(_=UÚaëRYSjQ RÜeYU /jU�Z*RcRTXEaYakl=UçaYQ V~}o[MXM_oàçQ�a¤��}=}j�$akUÚ£ùRY�Ø=X���[M��à�X�Z(Q [�[MqçXM_sRTU(eYU�akRYXM_=àJQ _j£W}µ�¸aTadXMØ=[�q"lo_=p�_o� ãc_�£�X¦ð�U(eTU(_`Z^U�a�ØjU(Rdã�U(U�_~RTS=U�¥�Q eYXM��ljaëRYl=V~��e�a^v

·®@�&1�3=£�§�:de�,.9;:d1.<DñåUWQ eYU"à�e�Q�RTU^�§l=[uRT�åtÜadSßt¤[�XMÿ�Q�£�U(SDm2��Q Rçn�eY� ãc_ïm-PèXMp$U]7�XEadU(_1Q _j£ß|¤��l=àåbë�¸aTa,�§��e�XM_sRTeT�s£sljZ^XM_oàljaÜRT�âRTS=X�aê}oeT��Øo[MU(V Q _`£Ê�§��e,à�XM¥sXM_=àâlja�Q�Z(Z^UÚaTa¤RY�~RTS=U�XMe�£=Q�R�QsvwñáU�S`QÚ¥$UçQ�[Ead�èQ�}=}=eYU�Z^XEQ�RTU�£��:Q Ø=[���@Q VWQ(q$� � aBQ�aTadXEakRfQ _jZ*U¤ãcX�RTSçRTS=U�t�� ���ÚtÜP��è£oQ R�Qsv-úBXM_`Q [M[�q$m�ãuUcã���lo[E£w[MX�p$U�RY�,RYSjQ _op]��U(�n�eTU(X�VWQ _DmÆ-��efQ V½�ÝQ R�m�|ÝQÚ¥sXE£WÛ¤U�[Eak��_DmjP�Q eYp~¥�Q _Ê£�U(e!�DQ�Q�_åQ _j£BÆ-U(UE�¤ãcQ¥ÆuQ _oàì�§��ecVWQ _sq�SoU([M}��§lo[@£�XEaYZ^ljak«akX���_ja�Q _`£èakloà�à�UÚakRTX���_ja*m�Q�_j£ù\]Q V3n�l=RYRTeYU(qì�§��e¤SoXEa�_=U�Q�eTU�adRc_=U(X�à�Ssص��e¤eY��l=RYXM_=U¸v

��S=X�aèã���eYp×ã�Q�a�adl=}=}j��eYRTU�£�XM_©}jQ�eTR�Ø�q Q _ Pá\sb�h~}µ�¸akRf£��sZ^RT��e�Q�[ì�§U([�[M��ã�akSoXM} íd\s|,î�mÝQ��-P�P�nn�l=eYeT��loà�Sjad« ñåU([M[�Z^��VâU��§U([M[�� ã�adS=XM}�íi�$ú-î�msQ _j£~Øsq�RTS=UêÛÜh�� RYS=eT��l=à�SWà�efQ _sRc®�b Ó �ÜP���¨�������t�íi����\=îfvª �Ü�$�Ü�-�,�����,�

ü Ó þ��S=Uçr-S=XM}=}oXM_=àçúB��eTU�Z�Q�akR�v0, Æ( $ jÌM�����*¡�Ç�Ç­� 6 Å�Ç­Æs�g��ÇÜ�*¡µ��Ç­ÈE�g� m�� Ó m Ó ¨�¨�¨�vüý� þtwv:twv�t¤[�XMÿ�Q�£�U(SDm@P+v:nÜvS7�XEadU(_Dm-b�vS7cv�|ÜQ(¥sXEa*m�r�v-P�Q�m-h�v�\jv2���$aYak�$a*mctwv:bë�¸akU(_sãcQ�[E£�m-�=v-r�v

n���[�£�eTX�Zgp�m��wv�\sQ ØjU(R�mÜ�Üvu��efQ _Dm�È�v#Æ-lDm��=v�h�v��B��ã�U([�[im���v|ÆuQ _oà=m��v�7cv�P�Q�eTRTX­mc�ÜvuPè�$��eTU¸m�=v��¤l`£=ak��_û��e(m���vH��lDmÜ|wvunÜv���U(ãcX�a^m�b�v���X�ØjakS=X�e�Q�_=XimB�wvc\$S=U�eT[M�sZ�p�mëñ©v�r�vër-SjQ�_DmÜ�Üv�r�v��eTU(X�_=U(e�m�|wvï|wvµñåU(X�akU(_sØ=l=eYà�U(e�m��=v �vDt¤eTVâXMR�Q�à�U$mjb�vjñ+Q�eT_=p$U$m�b�vz��U(¥sq$mjñ©v�ñ�XM[�ak��_DmDP+v�b,v��eTU(¥$U�e(m��=v-r�v�n�qse�£�m:|wv�n���R�adRTU(X�_DmS�@v%�v:n�eT��ãc_Dm-Q _`£Ü��v-P+v�\$R�Q�lj£�R(vÊ|¤XÏð�U(eYU(_�RRdq�}jU�a�� �£�X¦ð�l`akU�[EQ�eTà�UwØ=«­Z^U([�[D[MqsV~}=S=��VWQÜXE£�U(_sRTX¦ÙjU�£~Øsq"à�U(_=UU(æ�}oeTU�aYakXM��_è}=eY� Ùj[�XM_=àov�6 Å�Ç­Æ���� mjª$��¬ ¢ ����¬>Å� Ó�Ó m���������v

üý¬ þ�wv�t¤[M��_Dm�ÛwvjncQ eYp�Q�X-|wv�twv�Û¤��RYRTU(eYVWQ _Dm.��vz��XEadSDmB\jv.ÆÜØjQ�eTefQ�mD|wv�P�Q�Z�p�m�Q�_j£�twvj�=vÉ��U(¥�X�_=U$vn�eT�¸Q�£W}jQ RYRTU(eY_jaë����à�U(_=U�U(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_WeTU�¥$U�Q [�U�£�ØsqWZ^[Ml`akRTU�eTXM_oàçQ _jQ�[MqoakXEa����-RTloV~��e�Q _j£W_=��eYVWQ [Z^��[M��_ßRYXEaTadl=U�a�}=eT��صUÚ£HØsq���[�XMà���_sljZ^[MU���RTX�£�UâQ eTefQ(q=a*v Y��T��� Ò 6 Å�Ç ÌMÒu����Å$��Ò , �(È Ò mu¨�� ¢ �$�(ª$��Ås�$�����smÓ ¨�¨�¨sv

ü ª�þP+vjncQ eY_jQ ef£�v-��S=UakUÚZ^l=[EQ�ec¥�Q eTX�Q RYXM��_`aë���-adp�l=[�[@ZgS`Q e�Q�Z^RTU�e�a�XM_ç�§��l=eÝakU(eYXMU�a-� �-U�à�qs}=RTX�Q _�akpsl=[M[�a^v�Ý¡=¡=Å�Ìý�ç�k�¹É�Æv���*¡=ÈE�g� mï� ¢ ¬�����Ås¬]� Ó m Ó ¨�¬���v

��¬

Page 24: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

üý� þE��v�n�eTU(X�VWQ _Dv@ncQ�à�à�X�_=àç}=eTU�£sXEZ^RY��e�a*v VùÅ$� Ä ÈE¡µ�����YÅ$�*¡=ÈE¡�� mj� ª ¢ Ó ��¬>Å Ó ª$�sm Ó ¨�¨���vüý� þE��v�n�eTU(X�VWQ _ïv ��l=RY« ���§« ØjQ�à U�adRTX�VWQ RYXM��_ïv �DU�Z�S=_=XEZ�Q [�eTU(}j��eYR(mw\$RfQ RYXEakRYXEZ(aW|¤U�}jQ eYRTV~U(_sR(m��wvÏr�v

n�U(eYp$U([MU(q¸m Ó ¨�¨���v

ü �(þE��v�n�eTU(X�VWQ _Dv@t¤efZ^XM_oà�Z^[�Q�aTadXÏÙjU�e�a^v �Ý¡o¡=Å�Ì �J�k� , ÇiÅ�Ç­ÈÏ�*Ç­ÈE�g� mj��� ¢ ®�� Ó Å]®�� ªjm Ó ¨�¨�®�vüý® þE��v�n�eTU(X�VWQ _Dv��ÝakXM_oà�Z^��_s¥$U(æ�}jakU(l`£���«­£=Q RfQÜRT�cXM_`Z^eTU�Q�akU-}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTXM��_Q�Z(Z^loe�Q�Z*q$v$�DU�ZgSo_=XEZ(Q�[$bcU(}j��eYR

� Ó ¬�mD\$R�Q�RTX�akRTX�Z(ac|¤U(}`Q eTRYV~U(_sR(ms�wv¦r�v=n�U(eYp$U([MU(q¸m$P�Q efZgS Ó ¨�¨�®sv

üý¨ þE��v�n�eTU(X�VWQ _Dmo�=vz�vjú`eYXMU�£sVWQ _Dmob,vz��[�akS=U(_ïm�Q�_j£ùr�v��=v�\¸RT��_oU$v]- ̦Š����È }u��Å�Ç­ÈE�$¡áÅ$¡=�W���.�$�g�T����ÈE�$¡Ç­�g���T� v ��S=U�ñ+Q�£=akãu��eYRTSûakRfQ RYXEakRYXEZ(a3�(}=eY��ØjQ�Ø=XM[�XMRdq1akU(eYXMU�a*v�ñÃQ�£oakã���eTRYS�hi_sRTU(eY_jQ RYXM��_`Q [B�¤eY��l=}ïmÓ ¨�® ªov

ü Ó � þP+vm�Bv�\`v-n�eT��ãc_Dm�ñ©v-Ûwv0��eYl=_j£�q$mu|wv���XM_DmuÛwv�r-eYXEakRYXEQ�_=XM_=X­m�r�v�ñ©v�\¸l=à�_=U�R(mc�Üv�\jv-ú=l=eYU(q$mP+vjt¤eYU�a���e�vMm=Q�_j£è|v��ÜQ ljaYak[�U(e(v��Ü_=��ãc[MUÚ£�à�U(«§ØjQ�akU�£WQ _`Q [MqoakX�aë����VâXEZ^eY�$Q eYe�Q(q�à�U�_=U�U(æ�}oeTU�aYakXM��_£=Q�R�Q�Ø�q~l`akXM_oà~adl=}j��eTR�¥$U�Z^RY��euVWQ�Z�S=XM_oU�a^v Yc�Y��� Ò 6 Å�ǧÌMÒD����Å$��Ò , ��È Ò mj¨]� ¢ �����>Ås���]�¸mB��������v

ü Ó�Ó þ�Æ�v�r-S=U�_Dm�7cv�b�v�|¤��loà�S=U(eYRdq$m�Q�_j£wP+vv��v�n�X�RTRY_=U(e(v�b�Q RTX���«§ØjQ�adU�£w£sU�Z^XEadXM��_jaDQ _j£�RTS=U�é]l`Q _sRTXMRfQ RYXM¥$UQ _`Q [MqoakX�aë���-Z�£�_jQ�V~XEZ^eY�$Q�eTe�Q(q�X�VWQ à�U�a^v�Ê �$Æs�^¡oÅ�Ì@�k� � ÈE�:���Y�$ÈE��Å�Ì�ËB jÇ­ÈE�g� mj� ¢ ¬���ª?Å]¬]�(ªom Ó ¨�¨$�$v

ü Ó � þ�=v���vo|¤U�bcXEadXim!"�v=b�vshiq$U(e(msQ _`£÷�@vQ�vsn�eT��ãc_Dv27Oæs}=[���eTX�_=àwRYS=UÜV~U�R�Q Øj��[MXEZcQ�_j£~à�U(_oU(RTX�Z¤Z^��_�RYeT��[� �Oà�U(_=U�U(æs}=eYU�aTadXM��_W��_�Qwà�U�_=��V~X�ZÜaTZ�Q [MU¸v0, �(È �*¡=�^� m��$��® ¢ ��®��>Ås��®��=m Ó ¨�¨]�¸v

ü Ó ¬ þP+v�nÜv�7�XEadU(_Dm:�@v��Üvs\$}jU([M[�VWQ _Dmv�@v �v$n�eY��ãc_Dm�Q�_j£ç|wv�n���R�adRTU(X�_Dvµr-[�ljakRYU(e�Q�_jQ [�q=adXEa�Q�_j£ç£�XEad}=[EQ(q� �Oà�U(_=��V~U(«§ãcXE£�UÝU(æ�}oeTU�aYakXM��_W}jQ RYRTU(eY_ja^v Y��T��� Ò 6 Å�ǧÌMÒD����Å$��Ò , �(È Ò mj¨�� ¢ Ó ª¸®���¬>Å Ó ª$®$��®=m Ó ¨�¨�®�v

ü Ó ª�þb�v�twv-ú@XEakSoU(e(vû��S=U�ljakU�����V�lo[MRTX�}=[MUâV~U�Q�adl=eTU�V~U(_$R�a�XM_1R�Q æs��_o��V~X�ZÎ}oeT��Øo[MU(VWa*v �Ý¡=¡=Å�ÌÝ�k�É�Æ5�s�*¡=ÈE�g� mB� ¢ Ó ��¨>Å Ó ®�®�m Ó ¨�¬��svü Ó � þE7cvDúBX�æèQ�_j£å�=v �¤�s£�à�U�a^v|¤XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_`Q RT��eTqWQ�_jQ [�q=adXEa*m�_o��_=}jQ�e�Q�V~U(RTeYXEZ£�XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_jQ�RTX���_ ¢ Z*��_jadXEak«

RTU�_jZ^qè}oeT��}jU(eYRTX�U�a^v��DU�Z�S=_=X�Z(Q [@eTU(}j��eTR(m:b¤Q�_j£���[M}=SÃúBXMU�[E£�m���U�æ=Q�a ¢ �,\stÝú×\sZgSo�$��[-� �ët¤¥�X�Q RYXM��_PèU�£�X�Z^XM_oU$m Ó ¨�� Ó v

ü Ó � þ�Æ�v@ú=eTU(lo_j£áQ�_j£+b�v87ëv�\sZ�SjQ�}=XMeYU$vçtÞ£�UÚZ^XEadXM��_o« RYS=U(��eYU(RTX�Zwà�U(_oU(e�Q�[MXMÿÚQ RTX���_å� ����_=«§[MX�_=U�[�U�Q eY_=XM_oàQ _`£�Q _�Q�}=}=[�XEZ(Q�RTXM��_èRY��Øj�$�$adRTX�_=à=viÊ �$Æ��*¡=Å�Ì@�k�J���:�¤ �Æ$Çk�*�Å$¡=����ÍÚ�*Çd���Þ���(È �*¡=�^�Y� mD��� ¢ Ó�Ó ¨>Å Ó ¬�¨smÓ ¨�¨]�¸v

ü Ó �(þ�Üv�b,v!�¤��[Ml=ØïmÜ|wv���v¤\$[���_=X�V�m��Bv��BQ�VWQ(q$�=mÜr�v!�¤ljQ ef£�mÜP+v!�ÜQ�Q�adU(_�ØjU(U�p�mÝ�=v��Bv�PèU�adXMeT��¥�m�wv¤r-��[M[�U(e(m�P+v���v�����Sïm��=vcb,vu|¤��ãc_=X�_=à=m�P+vutwv¤ruQ�[MXMà�XMl=eYXim¤r�v�|wv�n�[M�$��VçÙjU([E£�m�Q�_j£ß7cv¤\`v�DQ _`£�U(e(vuPè��[�U�Z^l=[�Q e�Z^[EQ�aTakX¦Ù�Z(Q�RTXM��_W� �uZ(Q�_jZ^U(e ¢ Z^[�Q�aYa¤£�X�aTZ^��¥$U(eYqçQ _j£�Z^[EQ�aTa�}=eYU�£�X�Z^RTX���_~Øsq~à�U�_=UU(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_WV~��_=XMRY��eTX�_=à=vm, �(È �*¡o�^� mD��®�� ¢ ��¬ Ó Ås��¬]�sm Ó ¨�¨�¨sv

ü Ó ® þtwvj�=v�ú�vz��eTX¸=~RYSja^mj�=vÉ�wvjPèXM[�[MU(e�m=|wvj�ÜvD\$l=ÿ�l=p�X­mjb,v�r�vÉ��U(ãu��_sRTXM_ïmjQ _j£èñ©vjP+v ��U([MØjQ�eTR�v �Ý¡Ì ¡sÇi�Y� �$Æs�^Ç­ÈE�$¡�Ç­�¡ÇÜ�*¡µ��Ç­ÈE�¤�Ý¡=Å�̦Í(��ÈÏ� vµñ©v:�v�ú=eTU�U(VWQ _Q�_j£Îr-��V~}jQ�_�q$m¸Û¤U(ã�Æ-��eYp�m¸� RTSçU�£�X�RTX���_DmÓ ¨�¨��sv

� ª

Page 25: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

ü Ó ¨ þ|wv:�=v����sZ�psSjQ eYR(mS�v���v:|¤��_oà=m-P+v�r�v@n�q�eY_=U$m@P+v@�ÜvBú=��[M[MU�RTRTX�U$mDP+v&"�vS�ÝQ [�[M�=m:P+v�\jv�r-S=U(U$mP+vcPèX�RTRTVÎQ _=_Dmcr�v�ñÃQ _=àom�P+vs�Ü��ØjQ(qsQ�akSoXim�Q _j£Î�wv��¤��eYRT��_DvÕ7�æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_�V~��_=XMRY��eYXM_=à+ØsqSsq�Ø=eYXE£�X�ÿ�Q RYXM��_äRY�áSoXMà�So«i£�U�_jakX�Rkqß��[MXMà���_sljZ^[�U(��RYXE£�UWQ�eTefQÚqoa^vÎ6 Å�Ç­Æ���� � ÈE��Çd�Y� Ä ¡=��̦�3�$Í m Ó ª ¢ Ó �$���>ÅÓ ��®��sm Ó ¨�¨���v

ü ��� þa��v&"�v@P�Q e�£sXEQ�m:�=v@�Üv��ÜU(_sR(m:Q _j£Ã�=vBP+v@n�X�Ø=Ø�q¸v VùÆ]Ì ÇiÈ��(Å$�*ÈEÅ�Çd�ì�Ý¡oÅ�̦ÍÚ��ÈÏ� vWtÜZ�Q�£�U(VâXEZl��eYU�aTa*mhi_jZ�v�mµ\sQ�_�|¤X�U(à��om Ó ¨]�Ú¨�v

ü � Ó þµ�v=�=voP�Zq�DQ�Z�S=[EQ�_DvS1 ÈÏ���(�*È���ÈE¡=Å$¡�Ç-Å$¡oÅ�̦ÍÚ��ÈÏ�Å$¡o�J�*Ç­Å�ÇiÈÏ�*Ç­ÈE��Å�Ì� oÅ�ǧÇk�g�^¡W�g�Y���3�$¡oÈMÇiÈE�$¡ vDñ�X�[MU(q$msÛ¤U�ãÆ-��eYp�m Ó ¨�¨��svü ��� þP+vDtwvïÛ¤U(ãcRT��_Dm�r�v@P+v&�ÜU(_j£�ÿ(X���efakpsXimBr�vB\`vBbcXEZ�S=V~��_j£�m�ú�vDb�vDn�[EQ�RTRY_=U(e(mïQ _j£���v�ñ©vï�cakl=X­v��_û£�XÏð�U(eYU(_sRTXEQ�[c¥�Q eTX�Q Ø=X�[MX�RkqÃ� �U(æs}=eTU�aYakX���_ efQ RYXM�$a ¢ h¼Vâ}=eT��¥sXM_=àåadR�Q RYXEadRTXEZ�Q [�XM_��§U(eYU(_jZ^U�Q�ص��l=R

à�U�_=U�U�æ�}=eYU�aTadXM��_+Z�SjQ _oà�U�aÜ�§eT��V VâXEZ^eY�$Q eYe�Q(q�£=Q RfQ�vW�DU�Z�S=_=XEZ�Q [-bcU(}j��eYR Ó ¬�¨sm-|¤U(}jQ�eTRTVâU(_�RÝ� �n�XM�¸akRfQ RTX�akRYXEZ(acQ�_j£èPèU�£sXEZ(Q�[Dhi_��§��eYVWQ RYXEZ(a*ms�¤ñ P�Q�£�XEad��_Dm Ó ¨�¨�¨�v

ü ��¬ þ�r�vcP+v��@U(eT��lDm,\jv�\jvc��U^ð�eTU�q$m�P+v�¥�Q _ £�UåbcXt�d_DmÜr�vctvcbëU�U�a^m�P+vcnÜv�7�XEakU�_Dm�|wv��Üvcbë�¸aTa*mtwvÉ�BU(eYà$Q VâU(_jaTZ�S=X�p$� ¥�m=r�vDú�vjñ�XM[�[MXEQ�VWa^mj\jv.È�vÎÍjSslDm��=v�r�v�ú�vÉ��U(U$mD|vz�DQ�akS=p�Q eYXimD|vB\$SjQ�[M��_ïm�BvP�wv¸n�eT��ãc_Dm$Q�_j£�|wv$n���R�akRYU(XM_ïvj|¤XEadRTXM_`Z^RTX�¥$U�à�U(_=UcU(æs}=eYU�aTadXM��_}jQ RYRTU(eY_ja�XM_�Ssl=VWQ�_wVWQ�V~V~Q�eTqU(}=X�RTS=U�[MXEQ�[DZ^U�[M[EauQ _j£~Ø=eYU�Q�adRÜZ�Q _jZ^U�e�a^v Y��Y� ��Ò 6 Å�Ç Ì�Ò��ë��Å$��Ò , �(È Ò m�¨�� ¢ ¨�� Ó ��Ås¨�� Ó �sm Ó ¨�¨�¨�v

ü ��ª�þ�=v@b,v8�B��[M[�Q�Z�p�mBr�v:P+v �BU(eY��lDm:twvDtwv@t¤[�XMÿ�Q�£�U(SDmïP+vBnÜvî7OX�akU(_ïmBtv��@U(eTà¸Q V~U(_`aTZ�S=XMp$��¥�m�r�v@ú�vñ�XM[�[MX�Q VWa*mB\jv�\`vB��U*ð�eYU(q$m:|wv�n���R�akRYU(XM_ïm�Q _`£Ü�Bvm�wv:n�eT��ãc_Dv���U(_=��VâU(« ãcX�£�UçQ _`Q [MqoakX�a,���Ý£�_jQZ^��}�qs« _sl=VçØjU(ecZ�SjQ _oà�U�a�ljadXM_=àâZ(£�_`QwV~XEZ^eY�$Q�eTe�Q(qoa^vm6 Å�Ç­Æ����iÇÜ�*¡µ�fÇiÈE�g� m���¬ ¢ ª Ó Å$ª¸��m Ó ¨�¨�¨sv

ü ��� þnÜv@|wv�bcXM}o[MU(q$v Y�Å�ǧÇk�g�^¡1�g�Y���3�$¡=ÈMÇ­ÈE�$¡ßÅ$¡=�á¡j�*Æ��YÅ�Ìu¡µ��Ç­Ð��$�fÑ�� vHruQ�V�ØoeTXE£sà�Uâ�¤_=XM¥$U�e�akX�RdqC��eYU�aTa*mruQ VçØ=eYXE£�à�U$m=Û¤U�ãÏÆ���eTp�m Ó ¨�¨���v

ü ��� þ|wv@�Üv�bc�$aYa^m:�wvB\sZ�S=U(ed�YmBP+v@nÜv 7�X�akU(_Dm-r�v@P+v �BU(eY��lDm2�Bv�\$}jU([M[�VWQ _ïm�"�v@hiq$U(e(mB\`vO\`vB��U*ð�eYU(q$mP+v"�Q�_�£�U�bëX+�d_Dm�P+v�ñ+Q�[MRTS`Q V�m�twv?�BU(eYà$Q�V~U(_jaYZgS=X�p$��¥�m*�=v$r�v�ú�vv��U�U$m�|v��DQ�akS=p�Q eYXims|wv$\$SjQ�[M��_ïm�Üv��vDPèq$U(efa^mD�=vïÛwvµñåU(X�_jakRYU(XM_Dm�|wvDn���R�adRTU(X�_DmDQ _`£U�@v��vDn�eT��ãc_Dv�\$qoakRTU�VWQ RYXEZÜ¥�Q eTX�Q RYXM��_�X�_à�U�_=U¤U�æ�}=eYU�aTadXM��_�}jQ�RTRYU(eT_ja�X�_�Ssl=VWQ�_çZ(Q _jZ*U(euZ^U([M[s[MX�_=U�a*v 6 Å�ÇiÆs�g�»Çê�g¡µ��Ç­ÈE�g� mj� ª ¢ ���$��Å]��¬ ªom���������v

ü �$�(þb�vS7cv�\sZgS`Q }=X�eTU$m�Æ�v@ú`eYU(l=_j£�mS�Bv:ncQ eYRT[MU�RTR(m@Q�_j£+ñ©vO\`vS��U(U$v�n��$�$adRTX�_=àèRYS=U~VWQ�eTà�X�_ ¢ QW_=U(ãU(æs}=[EQ�_jQ RYXM��_Î�§��e�RYS=UÜU^ð�U�Z^RYXM¥$U(_oU�aTa�� �:¥$��RYXM_=àV~U(RYS=�s£=a^v �Ý¡=¡oÅ�Ì �J�k� , Ç­Å�Ç­ÈÏ�*ÇiÈE�g� m���� ¢ Ó ��� Ó Å Ó ��®��smÓ ¨�¨�®sv

ü ��® þP+v=\sZ�S=U(_jQsm�U�£�X�RT��e(vS1�6 �¤VåÈE�(�Y��Å$�^�YÅ$ÍÚ�!X��¤Y��TÅ$�*ÇiÈE��Å�Ì=�u $ ��T��Å$� Ä v���æ$�§��e�£â�¤_=XM¥$U�e�akX�Rdql��eYU�aTa*mÓ ¨�¨�¨sv

ü ��¨ þP+v=\sZ�S=U(_jQsm=|wvj\$SjQ [���_Dmob,vsñ©vs|ÜQ(¥�X�a^m=Q�_j£w�@vQ�vsn�eT��ãc_DvSñ�ljQ _sRTX�R�Q RYXM¥$U�V~��_oXMRT��eTX�_=à�� �@à�U�_=UU(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_~}`Q RTRYU(eT_`a�ãcXMRYSWQwZ*��V~}=[�U(V~U(_$RfQ eYqw£s_jQwV~XEZ*eT�$Q�eTefQÚq¸v , ��È �*¡=�^� m��]�Ú� ¢ ª¸�]�lÅ$ª��Ú��m Ó ¨�¨���v

ü ¬�� þb�v���XMØ`akS=X�e�Q _oXim-�ÜvS�ÝQ�akRYXMU$m-P+v87�XEadU(_Dm-|wv:bë�¸aTa*m�|wv:n���RfakRTU�XM_Dm-Q�_j£��Bv�n�eY��ãc_Dvár-[Ml`akRTU�eTXM_oàV~U(RYS=�s£=aì�§��eWRTS=UåQ�_jQ [�q=adXEa~� �J£�_jQ+V~X�Z^eT�¸Q eYe�Q(q1£=Q RfQ�v���UÚZgS=_oXEZ(Q�[¤eYU(}j��eTR�mÜ|¤U�}jQ eYRTV~U(_sRç� ��¤U�Q�[MRYSèbcU�adU�Q efZgSWQ�_j£C�@��[MX�Z^q$mj\$R�Q�_��§��ef£è�¤_=X�¥$U(e�adXMRdq$m Ó ¨�¨�¨�v

ü ¬ Ó þ�"�v�Ûwv�"uQ }o_=XMp�v Â�Ä ��¡oÅ�ÇiÆs�g�J�k�w�*Ç­Å�ÇiÈÏ�*Ç­ÈE��Å�Ì�ÌM�YÅ$�*¡=ÈE¡���Ç Ä �Y�$�*Í vw\$RfQ RYXEakRYXEZ(ac�§��eÜU(_oà�XM_oU(U(eTX�_=àâQ _j£XM_s�§��eTVÎQ RTX���_WaYZ^XMU�_jZ^U$vj\$}=eTX�_=à�U�e(mjÛ¤U(ãÏÆ-��eTp�mj� _j£~U�£�X�RTX���_Dmj�������sv

���

Page 26: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

DLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBL

FLFLFLFLFLFLFLFLFL

CLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐ C

LL-7

0;L

ym

ph n

ode

CLL-1

3

CLL-3

9

CLL-5

9

CLL-7

1;R

ichte

r’s

CLL-7

1

CLL-6

5

CLL-2

4

CLL-1

6

CLL-5

8

CLL-2

1

CLL-6

1

CLL-6

6;S

L106

CLL-5

7

CLL-6

9

CLL-1

7

CLL-1

0

CLL-5

3

CLL-1

9

CLL-2

9

CLL-5

1

CLL-4

8

CLL-4

9

CLL-6

8

CLL-1

4

CLL-1

5

CLL-6

7

CLL-6

0

CLL-2

2

FL-5

;CD

19+

FL-6

;CD

19+

FL-1

1;C

D19+

FL-1

1

FL-1

0

FL-1

0;C

D19+

FL-1

2;C

D19+

FL-9

;CD

19+

FL-9

DLC

L-0

042

DLC

L-0

021

DLC

L-0

036;O

CT

DLC

L-0

039

DLC

L-0

007

DLC

L-0

031

DLC

L-0

011

DLC

L-0

034

DLC

L-0

030

DLC

L-0

029

DLC

L-0

004

DLC

L-0

006

DLC

L-0

017

DLC

L-0

040

DLC

L-0

025

DLC

L-0

028

DLC

L-0

032

DLC

L-0

033

DLC

L-0

015

DLC

L-0

005

DLC

L-0

023

DLC

L-0

027

DLC

L-0

024

DLC

L-0

026

DLC

L-0

019

DLC

L-0

014

DLC

L-0

002

DLC

L-0

016

DLC

L-0

020

DLC

L-0

003

DLC

L-0

048

DLC

L-0

013

DLC

L-0

001

DLC

L-0

018

DLC

L-0

008

DLC

L-0

052

DLC

L-0

037

DLC

L-0

012

DLC

L-0

010

DLC

L-0

051

DLC

L-0

035

DLC

L-0

009

DLC

L-0

041

DLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBLDLCBL

FLFLFLFLFLFLFLFLFL

CLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐCLLÐ C

LL-7

0;L

ym

ph n

ode

CLL-1

3

CLL-3

9

CLL-5

9

CLL-7

1;R

ichte

r’s

CLL-7

1

CLL-6

5

CLL-2

4

CLL-1

6

CLL-5

8

CLL-2

1

CLL-6

1

CLL-6

6;S

L106

CLL-5

7

CLL-6

9

CLL-1

7

CLL-1

0

CLL-5

3

CLL-1

9

CLL-2

9

CLL-5

1

CLL-4

8

CLL-4

9

CLL-6

8

CLL-1

4

CLL-1

5

CLL-6

7

CLL-6

0

CLL-2

2

FL-5

;CD

19+

FL-6

;CD

19+

FL-1

1;C

D19+

FL-1

1

FL-1

0

FL-1

0;C

D19+

FL-1

2;C

D19+

FL-9

;CD

19+

FL-9

DLC

L-0

042

DLC

L-0

021

DLC

L-0

036;O

CT

DLC

L-0

039

DLC

L-0

007

DLC

L-0

031

DLC

L-0

011

DLC

L-0

034

DLC

L-0

030

DLC

L-0

029

DLC

L-0

004

DLC

L-0

006

DLC

L-0

017

DLC

L-0

040

DLC

L-0

025

DLC

L-0

028

DLC

L-0

032

DLC

L-0

033

DLC

L-0

015

DLC

L-0

005

DLC

L-0

023

DLC

L-0

027

DLC

L-0

024

DLC

L-0

026

DLC

L-0

019

DLC

L-0

014

DLC

L-0

002

DLC

L-0

016

DLC

L-0

020

DLC

L-0

003

DLC

L-0

048

DLC

L-0

013

DLC

L-0

001

DLC

L-0

018

DLC

L-0

008

DLC

L-0

052

DLC

L-0

037

DLC

L-0

012

DLC

L-0

010

DLC

L-0

051

DLC

L-0

035

DLC

L-0

009

DLC

L-0

041

úBX�à�l=eYU Ó ¢0�-Í?�¤  Ä �:��Å��$Å�Ç­ÅT - �$�*�g��Ì Å�ÇiÈE�$¡è��Å�Çi�*È>4 v-hiVWQ à�U�a����-Z*��eTeYU([EQ�RTX���_WVWQ RYeTX�æw�§��e�® Ó VWb�ÛÜtaTQ�V~}=[�U�a^msØjQ�adU�£"��_èU(æs}=eTUÚaTakX���_W}=eY� Ùj[�U�a��§��eÝQ [�[�\ c ª�p���®���à�U(_=U�a�í [�U^�§R^îOQ _j£~�§��e�RTS=U!\÷c ����à�U(_=UÚaãcXMRYS�RYS=Uc[EQ�eTà�U�akR�´Tômô ¶�·�ômô�e�Q�RTX���í§eTX�à�SsR^î�v-r-��eYeTU([�Q RTX���_ja����@��Q eYU¤eYU(}=eTUÚakU(_sRTU�£wX�_�Ø=[EQ�Zgp�m�X�_jZ^eTUÚQ�ak«XM_oà�[Mqç}j�$adXMRTX�¥$U�Z^��eTeTU�[EQ RYXM��_ja�Q�eTU�eTU(}oeTU�adU(_�RYU�£�ãcXMRTSWeYU�£=a�����X�_jZ^eYU�Q�adXM_=àXM_sRTU(_jadXMRdq$msQ _`£ÎX�_jZ^eYU�Q�adXM_=à�[Mq_=U(à¸Q RYXM¥$UcZ*��eTeYU([EQ�RTX���_ja�Q�eTUueTU(}=eYU�akU�_�RYU�£,ãcX�RTS�à�eYU(U(_jaD� ��X�_jZ^eTUÚQ�akX�_=àÜX�_�RYU(_jakX�Rdq$vD��S=UcVWb�ÛÜt+aYQ V~}o[MU�aQ eYU���e�£sU(eTU�£~ØsqWZ^[�Q�aTa*m�Ùje�adRÜn�«dr�� ��m=RTSoU(_�úS��m�Q�_j£�Ùj_jQ�[M[MqÎ|��Dn¤r���v

���

Page 27: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

AMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAML

ALL-TALL-TALL-TALL-TALL-TALL-TALL-TALL-TALL-TALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑ A

LL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-TÒ

ALL-TÒ

ALL-TÒ

ALL-TÒ

ALL-TÒ

ALL-TÒ

ALL-TÒ

ALL-TÒ

ALL-TÒ A

MLÒ

AM

LÒA

MLÒ

AM

LÒA

MLÒ

AM

LÒA

MLÒ

AM

LÒA

MLÒ

AM

LÒA

MLÒ

AM

LÒA

MLÒ

AM

LÒA

MLÒ

AM

LÒA

MLÒ

AM

LÒA

MLÒ

AM

LÒA

MLÒ

AM

LÒA

MLÒ

AM

LÒA

MLÒ

AMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAMLAML

ALL-TALL-TALL-TALL-TALL-TALL-TALL-TALL-TALL-TALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑALL-BÑ A

LL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-BÒ

ALL-TÒ

ALL-TÒ

ALL-TÒ

ALL-TÒ

ALL-TÒ

ALL-TÒ

ALL-TÒ

ALL-TÒ

ALL-TÒ A

MLÒ

AM

AM

AM

AM

AM

AM

AM

AM

AM

AM

AM

AM

AM

AM

AM

AM

AM

AM

AM

AM

AM

AM

AM

AM

úBX�à�l=eYUç� ¢<�:�*Æ�Ñ$����ÈEÅ��$Å�Ç­Å÷ - �$�^����̦Å�Ç­ÈE�$¡U��Å�Ç­�^È>4 vwhiVWQ�à�U�ac� �ëZ^��eYeTU([�Q RTX���_�VWQ RYeTXMæ~�§��ew���~VWb�ÛÜtaTQ�V~}=[�U�a^m�ØjQ�adU�£���_çU(æ�}oeTU�aYakXM��_�}=eT��Ùj[MUÚa��§��e8\wcû¬�pf�]� Ó à�U(_oU�a�í [�U^�§R^î�Q _j£w�§��e�RYS=Um\÷c ª$�Üà�U(_oU�aBãcXMRYSRTSoU,[�Q eYà�U�adR!´Tô�ô ¶?·�ô�ôÃe�Q�RTXM���§��ecRYS=U�RTS=eYU(Ut�� �ån�«iZ^U�[M[imst�� �Ã��«iZ^U�[M[DQ�_j£ètÝP��áZ^[�Q�aYakU�aÜí§eTXMà�S�R*î�vr-��eYeTU([�Q RYXM��_`aë���u��Q�eTUeTU(}=eYU�akU�_�RYU�£�XM_WØ=[�Q�Z�p�m=X�_jZ^eYU�Q�adXM_=à�[Mqç}µ�¸akX�RTXM¥$UZ^��eTeYU([EQ�RTXM��_ja�Q eTU�eYU(}=eTUÚakU(_sRTU�£ãcXMRYS~eTUÚ£=a�� �@X�_jZ^eTUÚQ�akX�_=àwX�_�RYU(_jadXMRdq$msQ _j£çXM_jZ^eYU�Q�adXM_=à�[Mqç_=U(à¸Q RTX�¥$UÜZ*��eTeYU([EQ�RTX���_jacQ�eTUÜeYU(}=eTUÚakU(_sRTU�£�ãcXMRYSà�eYU(U(_ja�� ��X�_jZ^eTUÚQ�akX�_=àWXM_sRTU(_`akXMRdq$vâ��S=UçVWb¤ÛÝt aTQ Vâ}=[MU�aÝQ eTUâ��e�£sU(eTU�£åØ�qåZ^[�Q�aYa^m�Ù`e�akRJt�� ��n�«­Z^U([M[­mRTSoU(_�t�� �+��«­Z^U([M[­m=Q�_j£�Ùj_jQ [�[MqWtÝP���v

�]�

Page 28: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

SN12C.CL9008..RENAL

TK.10.CL9024.RENAL

ACHN.CL9023.RENAL

UO.31.CL9004..RENAL

CAKI.1.CL9015.RENALÐX786.0..CL9018.RENALÓRXF.393.CL9016..RENAL

A498.CL9013.RENALÔSNB.75.CL12005.RENAL

OVCAR.5.CL6003.OVARIAN

SK.OV.3.CL6011.OVARIAN

IGROV1.CL6010.OVARIAN

OVCAR.4..CL6002..OVARIAN

OVCAR.3.CL6001.OVARIAN

OVCAR.8.CL6005.OVARIAN

NCI.H522.CL1003..NSCLC

NCI.H23.CL1001..NSCLC

NCI.H322.CL1017.NSCLC

NCI.H460.CL1021.NSCLC

A549.CL1004..NSCLC

EKVX..CL1008.NSCLC

HOP.92..CL1029.NSCLC

NCI.H226.CL1013..NSCLC

HOP.62.CL1026.NSCLC

SK.MEL.2.CL10005.MELANOMA

UACC.62.CL10020.MELANOMA

MALME.3M.CL10002.MELANOMA

UACC.257CL10021.MELANOMA

SK.MEL.28.CL10008.MELANOMAÕ M.14.CL10014.MELANOMA

SK.MEL.5.CL10007.MELANOMA

LOXIMVI..CL10001..MELANOMA

SR.CL7019..LEUKEMIAÕCCRF.CEM.CL7003.LEUKEMIA

MOLT.4.CL7006.LEUKEMIA

HL.60..CL7008...LEUKEMIA

K562B.repro

K562A.repro

K.562..CL7005..LEUKEMIA

RPMI.8226.CL7010..LEUKEMIA

HT.29...CL4001..COLON

COLO205.CL4010.COLONÐHCC.2998.CL4002.COLON

KM12..CL4017.COLON

HCT.15.CL4015..COLON

SW.620.CL4009.COLON

HCT.116.CL4003.COLON

SF.268..CL12014.CNS

SF.539..CL12016.CNS

SF.295.CL12015.CNSÕSNB.19.CL12002.CNSÕ U251.CL12009.CNS

MDA.N.CL5012..BREAST

MDA.MB.435.CL5011..BREAST

T.47D..CL5014..BREAST

MCF7D.repro

MCF7A.repro

MCF7.CL5001..BREAST

MDA.MB.231.CL5005..BREAST

BT.549.CL5013.BREAST

HS.578T.CL5006..BREAST

BR

EA

ST

1

BR

EA

ST

2

BR

EA

ST

3

BR

EA

ST

4

BR

EA

ST

4A

BR

EA

ST

4D

BR

EA

ST

5

BR

EA

ST

6

BR

EA

ST

7

CN

S1

CN

S2

CN

S3

CN

S4

CN

S5

CO

LO

N1

CO

LO

N2

CO

LO

N3

CO

LO

N4

CO

LO

N5

CO

LO

N6

CO

LO

N7

LE

UK

EM

IA1

LE

UK

EM

IA2

LE

UK

EM

IA2A

LE

UK

EM

IA2B

LE

UK

EM

IA3

LE

UK

EM

IA4

LE

UK

EM

IA5

LE

UK

EM

IA6

ME

LA

NO

MA

1

ME

LA

NO

MA

2

ME

LA

NO

MA

3

ME

LA

NO

MA

4

ME

LA

NO

MA

5

ME

LA

NO

MA

6

ME

LA

NO

MA

7

ME

LA

NO

MA

8

NS

CLC

1

NS

CLC

2

NS

CLC

3

NS

CLC

4

NS

CLC

5

NS

CLC

6

NS

CLC

7

NS

CLC

8

NS

CLC

9

OV

AR

IAN

1

OV

AR

IAN

2

OV

AR

IAN

3

OV

AR

IAN

4

OV

AR

IAN

5

OV

AR

IAN

6

RE

NA

L1

RE

NA

L2

RE

NA

L3

RE

NA

L4

RE

NA

L5

RE

NA

L6

RE

NA

L7

RE

NA

L8

RE

NA

L9

SN12C.CL9008..RENALÕ TK.10.CL9024.RENAL

ACHN.CL9023.RENALÔUO.31.CL9004..RENAL

CAKI.1.CL9015.RENAL

X786.0..CL9018.RENALÓRXF.393.CL9016..RENAL

A498.CL9013.RENALÔSNB.75.CL12005.RENAL

OVCAR.5.CL6003.OVARIAN

SK.OV.3.CL6011.OVARIANÕIGROV1.CL6010.OVARIAN

OVCAR.4..CL6002..OVARIANÖ OVCAR.3.CL6001.OVARIAN

OVCAR.8.CL6005.OVARIAN

NCI.H522.CL1003..NSCLC

NCI.H23.CL1001..NSCLC

NCI.H322.CL1017.NSCLC

NCI.H460.CL1021.NSCLC

A549.CL1004..NSCLC

EKVX..CL1008.NSCLC

HOP.92..CL1029.NSCLC

NCI.H226.CL1013..NSCLC

HOP.62.CL1026.NSCLC

SK.MEL.2.CL10005.MELANOMAÕUACC.62.CL10020.MELANOMA

MALME.3M.CL10002.MELANOMA

UACC.257CL10021.MELANOMA

SK.MEL.28.CL10008.MELANOMA

M.14.CL10014.MELANOMA

SK.MEL.5.CL10007.MELANOMAÕLOXIMVI..CL10001..MELANOMA

SR.CL7019..LEUKEMIA

CCRF.CEM.CL7003.LEUKEMIAÐ MOLT.4.CL7006.LEUKEMIA

HL.60..CL7008...LEUKEMIA

K562B.repro

K562A.repro

K.562..CL7005..LEUKEMIA

RPMI.8226.CL7010..LEUKEMIA

HT.29...CL4001..COLON

COLO205.CL4010.COLON

HCC.2998.CL4002.COLON

KM12..CL4017.COLON

HCT.15.CL4015..COLON

SW.620.CL4009.COLON

HCT.116.CL4003.COLON

SF.268..CL12014.CNSÕSF.539..CL12016.CNSÕSF.295.CL12015.CNSÕSNB.19.CL12002.CNSÕ U251.CL12009.CNS

MDA.N.CL5012..BREAST

MDA.MB.435.CL5011..BREAST

T.47D..CL5014..BREAST× MCF7D.repro

MCF7A.repro

MCF7.CL5001..BREAST

MDA.MB.231.CL5005..BREAST

BT.549.CL5013.BREAST

HS.578T.CL5006..BREAST

BR

EA

ST

1

BR

EA

ST

2

BR

EA

ST

3

BR

EA

ST

4

BR

EA

ST

4A

BR

EA

ST

4D

BR

EA

ST

5

BR

EA

ST

6

BR

EA

ST

7

CN

S1

CN

S2

CN

S3

CN

S4

CN

S5

CO

LO

N1

CO

LO

N2

CO

LO

N3

CO

LO

N4

CO

LO

N5

CO

LO

N6

CO

LO

N7

LE

UK

EM

IA1

LE

UK

EM

IA2

LE

UK

EM

IA2A

LE

UK

EM

IA2B

LE

UK

EM

IA3

LE

UK

EM

IA4

LE

UK

EM

IA5

LE

UK

EM

IA6

ME

LA

NO

MA

1

ME

LA

NO

MA

2

ME

LA

NO

MA

3

ME

LA

NO

MA

4

ME

LA

NO

MA

5

ME

LA

NO

MA

6

ME

LA

NO

MA

7

ME

LA

NO

MA

8

NS

CLC

1

NS

CLC

2

NS

CLC

3

NS

CLC

4

NS

CLC

5

NS

CLC

6

NS

CLC

7

NS

CLC

8

NS

CLC

9

OV

AR

IAN

1

OV

AR

IAN

2

OV

AR

IAN

3

OV

AR

IAN

4

OV

AR

IAN

5

OV

AR

IAN

6

RE

NA

L1

RE

NA

L2

RE

NA

L3

RE

NA

L4

RE

NA

L5

RE

NA

L6

RE

NA

L7

RE

NA

L8

RE

NA

L9

úBX�à�l=eYUW¬ ¢ 6Ð-�ÌBØ!Ù �$Å�Ç­Å - �$�^����̦Å�Ç­ÈE�$¡°��Å�Ç­�*È>4 v+hiVWQ�à�U�aÜ� �êZ^��eTeTU�[EQ RYXM��_äVÎQ RTeYXMæè�§��eç� Ó VWb�ÛÜtaTQ�V~}=[�U�a^mDØjQ�akU�£á��_ßU(æ�}oeTU�aYakXM��_á}oeT� Ù`[MU�aÜ�§��e�\�cò��p���ª�ª�à�U�_=U�a�í§[MU^�§R*îÝQ _j£á�§��eRTS=UE\Þc�¬��èà�U(_=UÚaãcXMRYS�RYS=Uc[EQ�eTà�U�akR�´Tômô ¶�·�ômô�e�Q�RTX���í§eTX�à�SsR^î�v-r-��eYeTU([�Q RTX���_ja����@��Q eYU¤eYU(}=eTUÚakU(_sRTU�£wX�_�Ø=[EQ�Zgp�m�X�_jZ^eTUÚQ�ak«XM_oà�[Mqç}j�$adXMRTX�¥$U�Z^��eTeTU�[EQ RYXM��_ja�Q�eTU�eTU(}oeTU�adU(_�RYU�£�ãcXMRTSWeYU�£=a�����X�_jZ^eYU�Q�adXM_=àXM_sRTU(_jadXMRdq$msQ _`£ÎX�_jZ^eYU�Q�adXM_=à�[Mq_=U(à¸Q RYXM¥$UcZ*��eTeYU([EQ�RTX���_ja�Q�eTUueTU(}=eYU�akU�_�RYU�£,ãcX�RTS�à�eYU(U(_jaD� ��X�_jZ^eTUÚQ�akX�_=àÜX�_�RYU(_jakX�Rdq$vD��S=UcVWb�ÛÜt+aYQ V~}o[MU�aQ eYUw��e�£�U(eYU�£"ØsqWZ^[�Q�aYa ¢ � é ��Ø=eYU�Q�adR(m��ÎruÛ,\`m��JZ^��[���_Dm�� é ��[MU(lop$U(V~XEQsms®ìV~U�[EQ _o��VWQsm�¨âÛ,\=r��Br�m����¥�Q eTX�Q _Dmj¨�eTU�_jQ [­v

��®

Page 29: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

0.0

0.4

0.8

FLDAÚ

DLDAÛ

DQDAÛ

test

se

t e

rro

r ra

te

Discriminant analysis

0.0

0.4

0.8

CARTÜ

BagÝ

CPDÜ

MVNÞ

BoostÝ

test

se

t e

rro

r ra

te

CART-based classifiers

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

NNß

DQDAÛ

Boost CARTà

test

se

t e

rro

r ra

te

Main comparison: NN, best DA, best CART

úBX�à�l=eYUcª ¢��OÍ��¤  Ä �:��Å��$Å�Ç­Ål  �T�*Ç����fÇ��*�*�T�$�c�YÅ�Çk�Y� vBn���æs}=[M��R�aB���DRYU�akR-adU(R�U(eYeT��e�e�Q�RTU�aB�§��eOZ^[EQ�aTakX¦ÙjU(efaØ=l=X�[MR�ljadXM_=à�RTS=UE\Üc'���"à�U(_=U�aÜãcXMRYS+RTSoU�[�Q eTà�U�akRE´Tômô ¶�·�ômôuömã c Ó �����B\����¤\åeTlo_ja¤�§��e�� ¢ ÓaTQ�V~}=[�XM_=àJaTZ�S=U(V~U$v

��¨

Page 30: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

0.0

0.4

0.8

FLDAÚ

DLDAÛ

DQDAÛ

Golubá

test

se

t e

rro

r ra

te

Discriminant analysis

0.0

0.4

0.8

CARTÜ

BagÝ

CPDÜ

MVNÞ

BoostÝ

test

se

t e

rro

r ra

te

CART-based classifiers

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

NNß

DLDAÛ

Boost CARTà

test

se

t e

rro

r ra

te

Main comparison: NN, best DA, best CART

úBX�à�l=eYU�� ¢!���*Æ�Ñ$����ÈEÅW�$Å�Ç­Å?â�Ç­Ð����^̦Š�����T�Ð Â �T�*Ç����fÇÜ�*�^�Y�$�Ü�TÅ�Çd�T� vcn���æs}=[M��R�ac� �-RYU�akRÝakU�R¤U(eYeT��e¤efQ RTUÚa�§��euZ^[�Q�aYakXÏÙ`U(e�aBØol=XM[�R�ljakX�_=à�RTS=Um\±c�ª$�Üà�U(_=U�a�ãcXMRYS�RTS=Uc[�Q eYà�U�adR0´Tômô ¶?·áômôuöPã½c Ó ���l�B\��Ú�¤\�eTl=_`a�§��eÝ� ¢ Ó aTQ Vâ}=[MX�_=à�aYZgS=U�V~U$v

¬��

Page 31: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

0.0

0.4

0.8

FLDAÚ

DLDAÛ

DQDAÛ

test

se

t e

rro

r ra

te

Discriminant analysis

0.0

0.4

0.8

CARTÜ

BagÝ

CPDÜ

MVNÞ

BoostÝ

test

se

t e

rro

r ra

te

CART-based classifiers

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

NNß

DLDAÛ

Bag CARTà

test

se

t e

rro

r ra

te

Main comparison: NN, best DA, best CART

úBX�à�l=eYU�� ¢0�:�*ƸѸ����ÈEÅ~�$Å�Ç­Å?â�Ç Ä �g���Ý�^̦Š�����Y�l  �T�*Ç����fÇë�g�^�Y�$�¤�YÅ�Çk�T� v:n���æ�}=[���Rfa�� �@RYU�akR�akU(RcU�eTeT��e�efQ RTUÚa�§��euZ^[�Q�aYakXÏÙ`U(e�aBØol=XM[�R�ljakX�_=à�RTS=Um\±c�ª$�Üà�U(_=U�a�ãcXMRYS�RTS=Uc[�Q eYà�U�adR0´Tômô ¶?·áômôuöPã½c Ó ���l�B\��Ú�¤\�eTl=_`a�§��eÝ� ¢ Ó aTQ Vâ}=[MX�_=à�aYZgS=U�V~U$v

¬ Ó

Page 32: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

0.0

0.4

0.8

FLDAÚ

DLDAÛ

DQDAÛ

test

se

t e

rro

r ra

te

Discriminant analysis

0.0

0.4

0.8

CARTÜ

BagÝ

CPDÜ

MVNÞ

BoostÝ

test

se

t e

rro

r ra

te

CART-based classifiers

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

NNß

DLDAÛ

Boost CARTà

test

se

t e

rro

r ra

te

Main comparison: NN, best DA, best CART

úBX�à�l=eYU~� ¢ 6Ð-�ÌiØ!Ù �$Å�Çiű  �Y�*Ç�����Ç,�g�^�Y�$�,�YÅ�Çk�Y� v�n�� æs}=[���R�a�� �uRTU�adR�akU�RÜU(eTeY��eÜefQ RYU�aë�§��eêZ^[EQ�aTakX¦ÙjU(efaØ=l=X�[MR�ljadXM_=à�RTS=UE\Üc'¬��"à�U(_=U�aÜãcXMRYS+RTSoU�[�Q eTà�U�akRE´Tômô ¶�·�ômôuömã c Ó �����B\����¤\åeTlo_ja¤�§��e�� ¢ ÓaTQ�V~}=[�XM_=àJaTZ�S=U(V~U$v

¬��

Page 33: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

F 50Ú

F 10Ú

F 10*Ú

DL 10Û

DL 10*Û

DL 50Û

DL 200Û

DQ 10Û

DQ 10*Û

DQ 50Û

DQ 200Û

test

se

t e

rro

r ra

te

úBX�à�l=eYU�® ¢��OÍ��¤  Ä �:��Å~�$Å�Ç­Å÷  �T�*Ç�����ÇÜ�*�*�T�$���TÅ�Çd�T� vÝn�� æs}=[���R�ac� �uRYU�akRÝakU(RÝU(eTeY��e�e�Q RYU�aë�§��e�úBXEadS=U(e[MX�_=U�Q�e~£�X�aTZ^eYXMV~X�_jQ _sRQ _jQ�[MqoakX�aèíiú�îfm-£�XEQ�à���_jQ [�[MX�_=U�Q�eç£�XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_jQ�_�RJQ _jQ�[MqoakX�a"í­|��BîçQ _`£�£�XEQ�à���_`Q [é$ljQ�£�efQ RYXEZç£�XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_jQ�_�RÝQ _`Q [MqoakX�a�í­|<ñ�îÜØjQ�akU�£á��_+RTSoUl\�c Ó �Pp�����p������èà�U(_=U�aÜãcX�RTS+RYS=U�[�Q eYà�U�adR´Tômô ¶�·�ômô�Q _`£Þ\ c Ó �ßà�U(_oU�aWZgS=�¸akU(_ Q�Z�Z^��ef£�XM_=àßRY� RTSoU � akVWQ�eTRTU�e3��´Tômô ¶�·�ômô�Z^eTX�RTU(eYXM��_Döã½c Ó ���T�B\Á���¤\WeTlo_ja��§��eÝ� ¢ Ó aYZgSoU(V~U$v

¬�¬

Page 34: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

FLDA30Ú

DLDA 10Û

DLDA 30Û

DLDA 200Û

test

se

t e

rro

r ra

te

Linear Discriminant Analysis

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

CPD 30ã

CPD 200ã

Boost 30à

Boost 200à

test

se

t e

rro

r ra

te

CART- Bagging with CPD and Boosting

úBX�à�l=eYUܨ ¢ 6Ð-�Ì�Ø!Ù �$Å�ÇiÅl  �T�*ÇB����Ç��g�^�Y�$�c�TÅ�Çd�T� v�n���æs}=[M��R�a�� �@RYU�akRuakU�R�U�eTeT��e-e�Q RYU�aB�§��e�£�XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_jQ�_�RQ _`Q [MqoakX�aÜQ _`£HrutÜb:��« ØjQ�akU�£�Z*[EQ�aYakX¦ÙjU(e�a�ØjQ�adU�£è��_è\ c Ó �Pp�¬���p������~à�U(_=U�a*ö�ã'c Ó ���±�B\��Ú�¤\�eTl=_`a�§��eÝ� ¢ Ó aTZ�S=U(V~U$v

¬ ª

Page 35: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

V

Pro

port

ion o

f observ

ations p

redic

ted c

orr

ectly a

t le

ast V

% o

f th

e r

uns

0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

NNFLDADLDADQDACARTBag CARTCPD CARTMVN CARTBoost CART

úBX�à�l=eYU Ó � ¢0�-Í?�¤  Ä �:��ÅÜ�$Å�Ç­Å<-�$Ég���g� �(Å�Ç­ÈE�$¡�dÐ:ÈÏ���,�g�^�Y�$���TÅ�Çd�T� v:ú`efQ�Z^RYXM��_w� ����ØjakU(eY¥�Q RTX���_ja�}=eYU�£�X�Z^RTU�£Z^��eTeTUÚZ^RT[�qçQ Rc[MUÚQ�akR!þ¥E � �:RTS=UÝRTXMVâU�í ��loRc� �@RTSoU,eYl=_ja��§��ecãcS=X�ZgSWQ�à�X�¥$U(_~��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_WØjU([M��_=à�U�£~RY�RTSoU,RYU�akR�adU(R^î��§��e0\wcû���ìà�U(_=U�a*ö�ã½c Ó ���T�B\��Ú�¤\WeTl=_`a��§��eÝ� ¢ Ó aYQ V~}=[�XM_=àJaTZ�S=U(V~U¸v

¬��

Page 36: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

V

Pro

port

ion o

f observ

ations p

redic

ted c

orr

ectly a

t le

ast V

% o

f th

e r

uns

0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

NNFLDADLDADQDAGolubCARTBag CARTCPD CARTMVN CARTBoost CART

úBX�à�l=eYU Ó�Ó ¢S���gƸÑ$� ��ÈEÅ,�$Å�Ç­Å?âDÇ­Ð����^̦Š�����Y�0:�$Ég���*���(Å�Ç­ÈE�$¡�dÐ�ÈÏ�����*�*�T�$�-�TÅ�Çd�T� v@ú=e�Q�Z^RTX���_�� �o��ØjadU(eT¥�Q�RTXM��_ja}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTU�£�Z^��eYeTU�Z^RY[Mq�Q R�[�U�Q�adRlþiE'����RYS=UçRTXMVâU�í§��l=R�����RYS=UçeTl=_jac�§��e�ãcS=XEZ�SåQ~à�X�¥$U(_è��ØjakU(eY¥�Q RTX���_ØjU([M��_=à�UÚ£"RT��RYS=U�RTU�adR�akU(R*î��§��e�\wc�ª$��à�U(_oU�a^ö�ã½c Ó ���]�B\����¤\WeYl=_ja��§��eÝ� ¢ Ó aTZ�S=U(V~U$v

¬��

Page 37: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

V

Pro

port

ion o

f observ

ations p

redic

ted c

orr

ectly a

t le

ast V

% o

f th

e r

uns

0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

NNFLDADLDADQDACARTBag CARTCPD CARTMVN CARTBoost CART

úBX�à�l=eYU Ó � ¢��:�*Æ�Ñ$����ÈEÅW�$Å�ÇiÅ?âuÇ Ä �g����^Ì Å �����T�EÜ�$Ég���g� �(Å�Ç­ÈE�$¡�dÐ:ÈÏ���~�*�*�T�$�Ü�YÅ�Çk�T� vuú=e�Q�Z^RTX���_è���-��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�«RTX���_jaD}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTU�£ÜZ*��eTeYU�Z^RY[Mq�Q R@[MUÚQ�akRSþaE�� �`RTS=U-RTX�V~Uuí ��loRB���=RYS=U-eTl=_ja��§��e@ãcS=X�ZgS�Qcà�X�¥$U(_Ü��ØjakU(eY¥�Q RTX���_ØjU([M��_=à�UÚ£"RT��RYS=U�RTU�adR�akU(R*î��§��e�\wc�ª$��à�U(_oU�a^ö�ã½c Ó ���]�B\����¤\WeYl=_ja��§��eÝ� ¢ Ó aTZ�S=U(V~U$v

¬]�

Page 38: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

V

Pro

port

ion o

f observ

ations p

redic

ted c

orr

ectly a

t le

ast V

% o

f th

e r

uns

0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

NNFLDADLDADQDACARTBag CARTCPD CARTMVN CARTBoost CART

úBX�à�l=eYU Ó ¬ ¢ 6Ð-�Ì®Ø!Ù �$Å�Ç­ÅC�$Ég���*���(Å�ÇiÈE�$¡PdÐ�ÈÏ���è�g�^�Y�$���TÅ�Çd�T� vçú`efQ�Z^RYXM��_á������ØjadU(eT¥�Q RYXM��_ja,}=eYU�£�X�Z^RTU�£Z^��eTeTUÚZ^RT[�qçQ Rc[MUÚQ�akR!þ¥E � �:RTS=UÝRTXMVâU�í ��loRc� �@RTSoU,eYl=_ja��§��ecãcS=X�ZgSWQ�à�X�¥$U(_~��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_WØjU([M��_=à�U�£~RY�RTSoU,RYU�akR�adU(R^î��§��e0\wcû¬��ìà�U(_=U�a*ö�ã½c Ó ���T�B\��Ú�¤\WeTl=_`a��§��eÝ� ¢ Ó aYZgS=U�V~U$v

¬�®

Page 39: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •• • •

• • •

••

• •

• • • • •

• • • • • • • • • • •

••

• • • • • ••

• • • • • • • • ••

• • ••

••

•• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

• •• •

• • • • •

• • • • • • • • • • ••

•• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

••• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

Observations

0

1

PV

qu

art

ile

s

0ä1

Pe

rce

nta

ge

of c

orre

ct p

red

ictio

ns

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80

• ••

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ••

• • • • • • • • • ••

• •

• • • • •

• • • • • • • • • • •

•• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

•• • • •

Baggingå

• • • • • ••

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •• • •

• •• •

••

••

• •

• • • • • • ••

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

••• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

• • • ••

• •• • • • • • • •

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

•• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •• • • • • • • •

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ••

Observations

0

1

PV

qu

art

ile

s

0æ1

Pe

rce

nta

ge

of c

orre

ct p

red

ictio

ns

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •• •

• • • • •

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

Bagging CPDå

•• •

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •• • • • • • • •

• • •• • •

••

• •

••

•• •

• • • • • •• • • • •

• •• • • • • •

•• • • •

• • • • ••

• • ••

• ••

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •• • •

• • ••

•• •

• ••

• •

• • • • • • • • • • •

• •• • • • • •

•• • • • • • • • • • • • •

•• ••

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •• • •

• • • •• • •

• • • • •

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

Observations

0

1

PV

qu

art

ile

s

0æ1

Pe

rce

nta

ge

of c

orre

ct p

red

ictio

ns

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •• •

••

• •

• • • • •

• • • • • • • • • • •

•• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

•• • • •

Boostingå

úBX�à�l=eYU Ó ª ¢C�-Í?�¤  Ä �:��Å��$Å�ÇiÅUBY��g�Y�$ÈE�^Ç­ÈE�$¡��(��Çk�Y� v��O[���Rfaw� �Ý}µU�e�Z^U(_sR�Q�à�UW� �êZ^��eTeTUÚZ^Rw}=eYU�£�X�Z^RTX���_jaí RY��}å}jQ _oU([ î�Q _j£�RTSoeTU(U�_sl=VçصU�e�akl=V~VÎQ eTX�U�aÜí VâU�£�XEQ�_Dm=[M��ãuU(eÜQ�_j£�l=}=}jU(e�é$ljQ eYRTX�[MU�îc���u}=eTU�£sXEZ^RYXM��_¥$��RYU�ací [�� ãuU(e�}jQ�_=U([§îB�§��e-U�Q�ZgSç��Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�RTX���_Dvu��S=U���ØjadU(eT¥�Q RYXM��_ja�Q�eTUÜ��e�£�U(eYU�£�Ø�qçZ^[�Q�aYa ¢ n�«dr�� ��m=ú2��m|��Dn¤r���vDr-[EQ�aTakX¦ÙjU(efa�ØjQ�adU�£"��_w\wcû����à�U�_=U�a^ö�ã½c Ó ���]�B\����¤\WeYl=_ja��§��eÜ� ¢ Ó aTZ�S=U(V~U¸v

¬�¨

Page 40: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

• • • • ••

• • •

• • • • •• • • • •

•• •

•• • • • • • • •

••

• • • •• • •

• • •

•• •

• • •

•• •

•• •

• • • • • • ••

•• • • •

• • • • ••

• • ••

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •• • • • • • • • • • • •

••

• •• • •

•• • •

• ••

• • • • • • • ••

• • • ••

• • • • • • • • ••

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •• • • • •

•• • • • •

•• • • • • • • •

•• • • •

Observations

0

1

PV

qu

art

ile

s 0ä1

Pe

rce

nta

ge

of c

orre

ct p

red

ictio

ns

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70

• • • • • • • • •

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ••

••

• • •

• • •• •

•• • • • • • • •

• • • •

Baggingå

• • • • ••

• • ••

• • • ••

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •• • • •

••

•• • •

• •• • •

••

••

••

• • • • • • •• •

• • • •

• • • • ••

• • ••

• • • ••

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •• • •

• • ••

• •• • •

•• •

•• •

•• • • • • • •

• •

• • • •

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ••

•• •

• • ••

• ••

• • •• • • • • • •

••

• • • ••

Observations

0

1

PV

qu

art

ile

s 0æ1

Pe

rce

nta

ge

of c

orre

ct p

red

ictio

ns

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

••

• • •

• • • • ••

• • • • • • • •

• • • •

Bagging CPDå

• • • • ••

• • •

•• • •

• ••

•• • •

•• • •

• • ••

• • • •• • • • • •

• • • ••

••

•• •

•• •

•• •

•• •

• • • • • • •• •

•• • •

• • • • ••

• • ••

• • • • •• • • • •

•• • • • • •

•• • • •

• • • • • •• • • • • •

••

• •• • •

•• •

•• •

• • • • • • ••

•• • • •

• • • • ••

• • ••

• • • • • • • • • ••

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ••

•• •

• • ••

• • • • ••

• • • • • • • ••

• • • ••

Observations

0

1

PV

qu

art

ile

s 0æ1

Pe

rce

nta

ge

of c

orre

ct p

red

ictio

ns

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70

• • • • • • • • ••

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ••

••

• • ••

• • • • ••

• • • • • • • ••

• • • •

Boostingå

• •• • •

• • •

•• • •

••

•• • •

•• •

• • ••

• ••

•• • • •

••

•• •

• ••

••

• • •

• ••

• ••

• •• •

•• •

• •• •

••

• •• • •

• • •

•• • •

••

•• • •

••

• •• • •

•• •

•• • • • •

••

• • •• •

••

••

• • •

• ••

• ••

• •• •

•• •

••

• •• •

• •• • •

• • •

•• • •

••

•• • •

••

• •• • •

•• •

• • • • • ••

• • •• •

••

••

• • •

• ••

• ••

• • • ••

• •• •

• •• •

Observations

0

1

PS

qu

art

ile

s 0æ1

Pe

rce

nta

ge

of c

orre

ct p

red

ictio

ns

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70

• • • • • • • • •

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

Golub PSç

úBX�à�l=eYU Ó � ¢U�:�*Æ�Ñ$����ÈEÅ+�$Å�Ç­Å?âÇiÐ��ß�^Ì Å �����T�èlYc���Y�$ÈE�^Ç­ÈE�$¡Þ�(��Çd�T� v���[M��R�a�� ��}jU(efZ^U(_sR�Q�à�UW� �Z*��eTeYU�Z^R}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTXM��_jaÜí RY��}�}jQ _=U�[ îuQ _`£"RTSoeTU(U�_sl=V�ØjU(e�akl=VâVWQ eYXMU�ací VâU�£�XEQ�_Dm�[���ã�U(e�Q _j£Wl=}=}jU(eÝé]ljQ�eTRYXM[MU�î-� �}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTXM��_è¥$��RTU�aÜQ�_j£�}=eTU�£sXEZ^RYXM��_ÊakRYeTU(_=à�RTSja�í§[M��ã�U(e�}jQ�_=U([ îu�§��eÜU�Q�ZgS���ØjakU�eT¥�Q RYXM��_ïv���S=U���Ø`akU(eY¥�Q�«RTX���_ja@Q eYUc��ef£�U(eTUÚ£,Øsq�Z^[EQ�aTa ¢ t�� �ì�§��[M[�� ãuU�£,Øsq�tÜP���v$r-[EQ�aTadXÏÙjU(efa�Ø`Q�akUÚ£w��_B\wc�ª$��à�U(_=UÚa^ö:ã½c Ó ����B\��Ú�¤\WeTl=_ja��§��eÜ� ¢ Ó aTZ�S=U(VâU$v

ª$�

Page 41: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

• • • • •

• • ••

•• •

• •

••

••

• • • • • • • • •• • • •

• ••

• ••

• • • ••

••

• • •

• ••

• ••

• • • • • • •

••

• • •

• • • • ••

• • • ••

• •• •

• • • • •

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • ••

• • •• • • •

••

••

• • •

• ••

• • • • • • • • • ••

••

• • •

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ••

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ••

•• • •

•• • • • • • • • • • • • • •

• •• • •

Observations

0

1

PV

qu

art

ile

s

0ä1

Pe

rce

nta

ge

of c

orre

ct p

red

ictio

ns

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70

• • • • • • • • •

• • ••

• • • • • ••

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ••

• • • •

• • • • • ••

• • • • • • • • • ••

••

• • •

Baggingå

• • • • ••

• • • ••

••

••

••

••

• • •

• • • • •• •

••

• •

••

•• • • •

•• • •

• • •

• ••

• • •• • • • • • •

•• •

• • •

• • • • ••

• • • ••

• •• •

• • • • •

• • ••

• • • • •• • • •

• •

••

•• • • •

••

• •

• • •

• • • • • • • • • • • • ••

• •

• • •

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ••

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • ••

• • • • • • • ••

• •• • •

•• • • • • • • • • • • • •

•• •

• • •

Observations

0

1

PV

qu

art

ile

s

0æ1

Pe

rce

nta

ge

of c

orre

ct p

red

ictio

ns

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70

• • • • • • • • •

• • ••

• • • • • ••

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

• ••

• • • •

••

• • • ••

• • • • • • • • • • • • • •

••

• • •

Bagging CPDå

• ••

• •

• • •

•• • •

• •

••

••

•• • •

• ••

••

• •• •

• •

• • ••

• • ••

• •

• • •

• • •• •

•• • • •

• • •

••

•• • •

• • • • •

• • •

•• • •

• •• •

••

•• • •

• • • • •• • • •

• •

••

• •• • • •

••

• •

• • •

• • •• •

•• • • • • • •

••

• • • •

• • • • ••

• • •

•• • • •

•• • • • •

•• • • • • • • • • • •

• • • ••

•• • • • • • •

•• •

• • •

• • •• •

•• • • • • • •

••

•• • •

Observations

0

1

PV

qu

art

ile

s

0æ1

Pe

rce

nta

ge

of c

orre

ct p

red

ictio

ns

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70

• • • • • • • • •

• • • • •• • • • •

•• • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

• ••

• • • •

•• • •

•• • • • • • • • • • • • • •

• • • •

Boostingå

úBX�à�l=eYU Ó � ¢w���*Æ�Ñ$����ÈEÅå�$Å�Ç­Å?âÜÇ Ä �g���â�^̦Š�����Y�w�Y��g�Y�$ÈE�^Ç­ÈE�$¡��(��Çd�T� vC��[���R�a�� ��}jU(efZ^U(_sR�Q à�U~� �ÝZ*��eTeYU�Z^R}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTXM��_jaÜí RY��}�}jQ _=U�[ îuQ _`£"RTSoeTU(U�_sl=V�ØjU(e�akl=VâVWQ eYXMU�ací VâU�£�XEQ�_Dm�[���ã�U(e�Q _j£Wl=}=}jU(eÝé]ljQ�eTRYXM[MU�î-� �}=eYU�£�XEZ*RTXM��_è¥$��RTU�a�í [�� ãuU(e�}jQ _=U�[ î��§��eÜU�Q�Z�Sè��ØjakU�eT¥�Q RYXM��_ïvw��S=U���ØjakU�eT¥�Q RYXM��_`a,Q�eTU��e�£sU(eTU�£èØsq�Z^[EQ�aTa ¢t�� �ßn�«­Z^U([M[­m=t�� �ß��«­Z^U([�[imjtÜP���v�r-[�Q�aTadXÏÙjU�e�a¤ØjQ�akU�£W��_±\Cc ª$��à�U(_=U�a*özã c Ó ���±�B\����¤\WeYl=_jaë�§��e� ¢ Ó aTZ�S=U(V~U$v

ª Ó

Page 42: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

• • •

•• •

•• •

• • • • • • •• • • • •

••

••

••

• •• • • • • • • • •

• • • • • • • • • • • • •• • • • • •

•• •• • •

• • ••

• •• • • • • • •

• •• • •

• ••

••

• •• • • •

• • • • •• • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

• • • •

•• •

•• •

• • •

•• •

• • • • • • •

• • • • ••

• • ••

••

• ••

• •• • • • • •

• • ••

• • • • • • • • • • •• • • •

••

Observations

0

1

PV

qu

art

ile

s

0ä1

Pe

rce

nta

ge

of c

orre

ct p

red

ictio

ns

0 10 20 30 40 50 60

• ••

• • •

•• •

••

••

• • • •

•• •

••

• •• • •

• ••

• ••

••

••

••

• •• •

• •• •

Baggingå

•• •

• • ••

• •• • • • • •

• •• •

• • ••

• •

• •

• •• • • •

• • • • • • • • •• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

••

• •• • •

•• •

• •• • • •

• •• • • •

• • •

• •

• •

•• • •

• • • • • • • • •• • • •

• • • • • • • • • • • • ••

• •• • •

• •

• •• •

• •• •

• • • ••

• • ••

• •

••

• • • • •• •

• • • • • •• • • •

• • • • •• • • • • •

• ••

Observations

0

1

PV

qu

art

ile

s

0æ1

Pe

rce

nta

ge

of c

orre

ct p

red

ictio

ns

0 10 20 30 40 50 60

• ••

• • •

••

• • • • ••

••

• •• •

• • • •

• •

• • •• •

••

• ••

••

••

• • • ••

• •

• • • • • ••

Bagging CPDå

• • •

• • ••

• •• • • • • • •

• • • • ••

•• •

••

• •• • • •

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •• • •• • •

• • ••

• •• • • • • • •

• • • • ••

•• •

••

• •• • • •

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ••

••

• • •

• • •

•• •

• • • • • • •• • • • •

•• • •

• ••

• •• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

• • • ••

• •

Observations

0

1

PV

qu

art

ile

s

0æ1

Pe

rce

nta

ge

of c

orre

ct p

red

ictio

ns

0 10 20 30 40 50 60

• • •

• • •

• ••

••

••

• • • •

•• •

• •

••

••

•• •

••

••

• • •

•• •

• •

•• • • •

Boostingå

úBX�à�l=eYU Ó � ¢ 6Ð-�Ì®Ø!Ù �$Å�ÇiÅC�Y��g�Y�$ÈE�^Ç­ÈE�$¡Ü�(��Çd�T� vµ��[���R�aÜ���c}jU(e�Z*U(_�RfQ à�U�� ��Z*��eTeYU�Z^RÜ}oeTU�£�X�Z^RTX���_jaí RT��}}jQ�_=U([ îuQ�_j£"RYS=eTU�U,_sl=VçØjU(ecadl=V~VWQ�eTXMUÚaëí§V~U�£�X�Q _Dms[M��ã�U�ecQ _`£èl=}=}jU(e�é$ljQ eYRTXM[�U�î-� �O}=eTU�£sXEZ^RYXM��_â¥$��RTUÚaí [���ã�U(e�}jQ�_=U([ îÜ�§��ewU�Q�ZgSÃ��ØjadU(eT¥�Q RYXM��_Dv+��S=Uâ��ØjadU(eT¥�Q RYXM��_ja�Q�eTU~��e�£�U�eTU�£+ØsqåZ^[EQ�aTa ¢ � é �èØ=eYU�Q�adR(mu�ruÛ,\jm@�~Z*��[M��_Dm�� é �Î[�U(l=p$U(VâXEQ�mj®~V~U�[EQ _o��VWQsm�¨WÛ,\=r��Br�m@�~��¥�Q eTX�Q _Dm:¨~eTU(_jQ�[iv~r-[EQ�aTadXÏÙjU(efaÜØjQ�adU�£��_Å\wcû¬���à�U(_oU�a^ö�ã½c Ó ���]�B\����¤\WeYl=_ja��§��eÝ� ¢ Ó aTZ�S=U(V~U$v

ª$�

Page 43: ;=@?BADCE>@FHGJI@?BK CMLON - Harvard …bcb.dfci.harvard.edu/~gp/teaching/688/dudoit2000.pdfø :-"!0 u tÞeYU([MX Q Ø=[ U~Q _j£+}=eTU Z*XEakUâZ^[ Q aTadXÏÙ Z Q RTX

top 5 genesè

log(R

/G,2

)

-50

5

Lymphoma: log(R/G) by class for 5 genes with largest BSS/WSS

• •

• •

• ••

••

••

••

••

• •

••

• •

• •

• •

••

••

••

top 5 genesè

log(R

/G,2

)

-50

5

Lymphoma: log(R/G) by class for 5 genes with largest BSS/WSS two largest classes pooled (B-CLL and DLBCL)

••

••

••

•••

•••

• •

••

••

• •

••

••

••

••

••

úBX�à�l=eYU Ó ® ¢0�-Í?�¤  Ä �:��Å��$Å�ÇiÅ�Ò PèU�£�X�Q _WQ�_j£~l=}=}jU(ecQ�_j£~[M��ã�U�e�é$ljQ�eTRTX�[MU�a-� �@à�U(_=UÜU(æs}=eYU�aTadXM��_â[MU(¥$U([�aí Ø`Q�akU��è[���à$Q�eTX�RTS=V6� �ÝRTS=U�r-q=�:��r-qo¬h/jlo��eTUÚaTZ^U(_`Z^U~e�Q�RTX���îÜãcX�RTS=X�_+U�Q�ZgS+���ÜRYS=UWRTS=eYU(Uç[MqsV~}=S=��VWQZ^[�Q�aTadU�a^vuhi_WRTS=URT��}WÙjà�loeTU$m=RYS=U�à�U(_=UÚa¤Q�eTUw��e�£�U�eTU�£WQ�Z�Z^��ef£�XM_=àçRT�çRTSoU(XMe!´Tômô ¶�·�ômô+efQ RYXM�=vu��S=U�adU�,à�U(_=U�a-adljZ(Z^U�aYa¼�§l=[�[MqJ£�XEaYZ^eTX�V~XM_jQ�RTUuصU�RkãuU(U(_çRTS=U�Rdã���[EQ�eTà�U�akR�Z^[EQ�aTakUÚaëí­Z^[EQ�aTa Ó ��eun�«dr�� �áQ�_j£~Z^[�Q�aYa¬w��e�|*�Dn¤r��Bî�Ø=loR�_=��RcصU�RkãuU(U(_~RYS=U�adVWQ [�[MU�adR�Z*[EQ�aYaÜíiZ^[�Q�aYac�w��e�úS�BîuQ�_j£~RTS=UÜRdãu��[EQ eYà�U�adR(v-hi_~RYS=UØj��RYRT��V6Ùjà�l=eYU$mBRYS=U~à�U(_=U�a�Q eYU~��ef£�U(eYU�£+Q�Z�Z^��ef£�XM_=à�RT��RTS=U(X�eE´Tô�ô ¶?·�ô�ôûefQ RTX��èãcX�RTSåRTS=U~[�Q eYà�U�adRRdã���Z^[�Q�aTadU�a,}j�$��[MU�£�v���S=U�adU~�Wà�U(_oU�awadljZ(Z^U�aYa¼�§l=[�[MqÊ£�XÏð�U(eYU(_�RYXEQ�RTU�ØjU(Rdã�U(U�_+Z^[�Q�aYaw�èQ�_j£áRYS=U���RTS=U�eRdã��çZ^[�Q�aYakU�a*v

ª$¬