1NC Okinawa Round III UT

8/8/2019 1NC Okinawa Round III UT

1/15


2/15

L$X^MH


3/15

XBDMQCOGK OX XQOUUOGK OG QCM CMLUQX B@ QCM B^ÛMXXMA' QCM D]@@JMA HUOMXB@ C]GKMU LGA X]EBUAOGLQOBG LUM UMXBGLQOGK BG LG OGHUMLXOGKJ_ KJBELJXHLJM' QCM UMXBGLGHM B@ HBJJMHQOPM BUKLGOYLQOBG* QULGXGLQOBGLJAOLX^BUL* KJBELJ JLEBU DOKULQOBG* OX MDMUKOGK @UBD QCM U]EEJM B@ QCMKJBELJ MHBGBD_' QCM OGX]UKMGH_ OX HBDOGK QCM \]MXQOBG OX [CLQ QLHQOHX[OJJ QCM XQLQM ]XM OG UMX^BGXM' QCM L@@OUDLQOPM AMDLGA OX QCM @OUXQ PBJJM_OG QCM HB]GQMU$OGX]UKMGH_* L XJ_ DLGM]PMU B@ HB$B^QLQOBG* HB]GQMU$UMPBJ]QOBG OG QCM GLDM B@ DBAMULQMA HLÔQLJOXD'

Qcm Ogpoxoejm Hbddoqqmm* lg lgbgydb}x kub}~ b` @umghc Ogqmjjmhq}ljx' 5>>?'VQcm Hbdogk Ogx}uumhqobg*cqq~9""qluglh?'òjmx'{bua~umxx'hbd"5>>?">1"qcmhbdogx}uRebbfjmq'~a`*

Mpmuybgm lkummx' Oqx leb}q qb ms~jbam' Oq ox lhfgb{jmakma* {oqc l xmuob}x lga xmj`$od~buqlgq jbbf* ogqcm hbuuoabux b` qcm Lxxmdejy* i}xq lx ymxqmualy oq {lx um~mlqma og qcm hl`x' Qcmum ox l hmuqlog ~jmlx}um oghljh}jlqogk qcm uoxfx' Ljumlay* {m lum ~umxmgqma {oqc l amqlojma dmg} b` ~umpmgqopm dmlx}umx `bu

xmh}uogk qcm qmuuoqbuy' Qcm Gm{ _mlux `mxqopoqomx qlfm l amhoxopm q}ug gmsq ymlu qcmumjj em gb byxqmux* mgiby qcmd {cojmyb} hlg, Qb ~umpmgq qcm hmjmeulqobgx ùbd emogk qbqljjy mhjo~xma ey qcm qulaoqobglj aoxbuamu* 80*>>> hb~x lga


4/15

b` 5>>;* clpm ljumlay ~ubpoama xmpmulj ~umhmamgqx' Qcm odlkm b` uokcq {ogk xq}amgqx og Glgqmuum

l~~jl}aogk lx qcm ~bjohm ms~mjjma qcmou hjlxxdlqmx b``mux l xdljj kjod~xm b` {clq qcm `}q}um cbjax

og xqbum'

Oq kbmx {oqcb}q xlyogk qclq qcm lqqlhcdmgq b` qcm @umghc qb qcm xqlqm qcm k}lulgqbu b` }gopmuxlj plj}mx* qcm jlxq uld~luqlklogxq qcm aoxlxqmu ox l ~lqcbjbky qclq ox ao`òh}jq qb }gab' Oqx lebpm ljj l òhqobg qclq gb jbgkmu fgb{x cb{ qb

hluuy bg' B}u kbpmugbux qcmdxmjpmx oghumlxogkjy hbgxoamu oq lx l }xmjmxx mgh}deulghm emhl}xmqcmy* lq jmlxq* qlfm qcm hbg`johq `bu {clq oq ox dojoqluojy' Qcmy clpm gb hbd~jms leb}q xmgaogk og mjoqm lgqoqmuubuoxq }goqxqb x}ea}m uobqx* bu qb joemulqm l umhyhjogk hmgqmu bhh}~oma ey oqx {bufmux' Lx qcm {mj`lum xqlqm hbjjl~xmx* {mxmm qcm mdmukmghm b` l eu}qm hbg`johq emq{mmg qcbxm {cb amxoum buamu lgaqcbxm {cb abgq' Mpmuyqcogk qclq @umghc ~bjoqohx clx emmg lejm qb amlhqoplqm ox og qcm ~ubhmxx b` }gjmlxcogk oqxmj`' Oq{ojj gmpmu em lejm qb ~ubhmxx ljj qclq oq clx um~umxxma' Og qcm laplghma amkumm b` xbholj

amhbd~bxoqobg* {m hlg hb}gq bg qcm hbdogk dbpmdmgq qb òga qcm gmhmxxluy eumlqc b` gocojoxd'

[cohc {ojj gbq dmlg qclq oq {bgq em ms~bxma qb bqcmu jodoqx '

Umpbj}qobgluy dbpmdmgqx ab gbq x~umla ey hbgqldoglqobg e}q ey umxbglghm' Xbdmqcogk qclq ox

hbgxqoq}qma cmum umxbglqmx {oqc qcm xcbhf {lpm mdoqqma ey xbdmqcogk hbgxqoq}qma bpmu qcmum' L

ebay qclq umxbglqmx abmx xb lhhbuaogk qb oqx b{g dbam' Lg ogx}uumhqobg ox gbq jofm l ~jlk}m bu l `bumxq òum

l jogmlu ~ubhmxx {cohc x~umlax ùbd ~jlhm qb ~jlhm l`qmu lg ogoqolj x~luf' Oq ulqcmu qlfmx qcm xcl~m b` l d}xoh*{cbxm `bhlj ~bogqx* qcb}kc aox~muxma og qodm lga x~lhm* x}hhmma og od~bxogk qcm ucyqcd b` qcmou

b{g poeulqobgx* lj{lyx qlfogk bg dbum amgxoqy' Qb qcm ~bogq qclq lgy umq}ug qb gbudlj ox gb jbgkmu

amxoulejm bu mpmg odlkoglejm' [cmg {m x~mlf b` Md~oum {m gldm qcm dmhclgoxdx b` ~b{mu qclq ~umpmgqopmjy

lga x}ukohljjy xqo`jm lgy umpbj}qobgluy emhbdogk og l xoq}lqobg' Og qcox xmgxm* Md~oum ox gbq lg mgmdy qclq

hbgùbgqx }x cmla$bg' Oq ox l ucyqcd qclq od~bxmx oqxmj`* l {ly b` aox~mgxogk lga aox~muxogk

umljoqy' Jmxx lg buamu b` qcm {buja qclg oqx xla* cmlpy lga dojoqluoxqoh jo|}oalqobg'[clq {m dmlg ey qcm ~luqy b` ogx}ukmgqx ox qcm xfmqhcogk b}q b` l hbd~jmqmjy bqcmu hbd~bxoqobg* lg bqcmu xoam b` umljoqy* {cohc

ùbd Kummhm qb qcm @umghc elgjom}mx 5 ox xmmfogk oqx hbgxoxqmghy' Oq ox gb{ ~}ejohjy }gamuxqbba qclq huoxox xoq}lqobgx lum xb

dlgy b~~buq}goqomx `bu qcm umxqu}hq}uogk b` abdoglqobg' Qcox ox {cy Xlufby hlg lggb}ghm* {oqcb}q xmmdogk qb

jom qbb d}hc* qclq qcm òglgholj huoxox ox qcm mga b` l {buja* lga qclq 5>>? {ojj xmm @ulghm mgqmu l gm{ mul' Qcox hclulam b`lg mhbgbdoh huoxox ox x}~~bxma qb em l gbpmjqy9 {m lum x}~~bxma qb em og qcm al{g b` l gm{

m~bhc {cmum {m {ojj ljj ibog qbkmqcmu og òkcqogk ogm|}ljoqy lga kjbelj {ludogk' E}q `bu b}u

kmgmulqobg {cohc {lx ebug og qcm huoxox lga clx fgb{g gbqcogk e}q mhbgbdoh* òglgholj* xbholjlga mhbjbkohlj huoxox qcox ox ulqcmu ao`òh}jq qb lhhm~q' Qcmy {bgq `bbj }x lklog* {oqc lgbqcmu

ub}ga gb{ {m xqluq ljj bpmu lklog lga oqx i}xq l |}mxqobg b` qokcqmgogk b}u emjqx `bu l joqqjm {cojm' Qb qmjj qcm

qu}qc* qcm aoxlxqub}x }gmd~jbydmgq òk}umx gb jbgkmu ~ubpbfm lgy `mmjogk og }x' Huoxox ox l dmlgx

b` kbpmugogk' Og l {buja qclq xmmdx qb cbja qbkmqcmu bgjy qcub}kc qcm ogògoqm dlglkmdmgq b` oqxb{g hbjjl~xm'

[clq qcox {lu ox emogk `b}kcq bpmu ox gbq pluob}x {lyx b` dlglkogk xbhomqy* e}q ouuma}hoejm lga

ouumhbghojlejm oamlx b` cl~~ogmxx lga qcmou {bujax' [m fgb{ oq* lga xb ab qcm ~b{mux qclq em' Qcmdojoqlgq umdglgqx qclq xmm }x lj{lyx dbum g}dmub}x* lj{lyx dbum oamgqoòlejm lum qmluogk b}q qcmou clou

quyogk qb òq }x ogqb joqqjm hbd~luqdmgqx og qcmou joqqjm cmlax ' Qcmy cbja b}q qcmou ludx qb }x og buamu qb emqqmux}``bhlqm }x* {oqc qcmou `loj}umx* qcmou ~luljyxox* qcmou xq}~oa ~ubejmdlqohx' @ubd mjmhqobgx qb qulgxoqobgx* dojoqlgqx {ojj gmpmu emlgyqcogk bqcmu qclg qclq {cohc aoxqlghmx }x* mlhc qodm l joqqjm `luqcmu* ùbd qcm ~bxxoeojoqy b` hbdd}goxd' J}hfojy {m {ojjlhhbddbalqm gmoqcmu qumlxbg gbu amhm~qobg bu d}hc jbgkmu'

Qcm ~lxq clx kopmg }x d}hc qbb dlgy ela lgx{mux `bu }x gbq qb xmm qclq qcm doxqlfmx {mum og qcm |}mxqobgx qcmdxmjpmx' Qcmum

ox gb gmma qb hcbbxm emq{mmg qcm `mqoxcoxd b` x~bgqlgmoqy lga buklgolqobglj hbgqubj6 emq{mmgqcm hbdm bgm* hbdm ljj b` lhqopoxq gmq{bufx lga qcm aoxho~jogm b` comuluhcy6 emq{mmg lhqogkamx~mulqmjy gb{ lga {loqogk amx~mulqmjy `bu jlqmu6 emq{mmg eulhfmqogk qclq {cohc ox qb em jopma lga ms~muodmgqma og qcm gldm b`l ~lulaoxm qclq xmmdx dbum lga dbum jofm l cmjj qcm jbgkmu oq ox ~}q b`` lga `jbkkogk qcm amla cbuxm b` cb{ ~jlgqogk hluubqx ox

mgb}kc qb jmlpm qcox gokcqdlum Buklgolqobgx lum bexqlhjmx qb buklgoogk b}uxmjpmx' Og qu}qc* qcmum ox gb kl~ emq{mmg


5/15

{clq {m lum* {clq {m ab* lga {clq {m lum emhbdogk ' Buklgolqobgx ~bjoqohlj bu jlebu* `lxhoxq bu lgluhcoxq lj{lyx emkog ey xm~lulqogk* ~ulhqohljjy* qcmxm lx~mhqx b` msoxqmghm' Oqx qcmg mlxy `bu qcmd qb ~umxmgq qcmou oaobqoh `budljoxd lx qcm

xbjm umdmay qb qcox xm~lulqobg' Qb buklgom ox gbq qb kopm l xqu}hq}um qb {mlfgmxx' Oq ox lebpm ljj qb `budebgax ebgax qclq lum ey gb dmlgx gm}qulj qmuuoejm ebgax' Qcm amkumm b` buklgolqobg ox dmlx}uma ey qcm ogqmgxoqy b`xcluogk dlqmuolj lga x~ouoq}lj'

@ubd gb{ bg* qb dlqmuoljjy buklgom `bu x}upoplj ox qb dlqmuoljjy buklgom `bu lqqlhf' Mpmuy{cmum* l

gm{ oaml b` hbdd}goxd ox qb em mjlebulqma' Og qcm xclab{x b` elu ubbdx* og ~uogq xcb~x* x|}lqx*`ludx* bhh}~oma kydglxo}dx* gm{ hbd~johoqomx lum qb em ebug' Qcmxm ~umhob}x hbggoplghmx d}xq gbq emum`}xma qcm gmhmxxluy dmlgx `bu qcm am~jbydmgq b` qcmou `buhmx' Cmum jomx qcm qu}jy umpbj}qobgluy ~bqmgqoljoqy b`

qcm ~umxmgq' Qcm oghumlxogkjy ùm|}mgq xfoudoxcmx clpm qcox `budoalejm |}ljoqy9 qclq qcmy lum lj{lyx lg bhhlxobg `bu

hbd~johoqomx b` qcox qy~m* xbdmqodmx m~cmdmulj* e}q xbdmqodmx ljxb }gemqulylejm' [cmg l `m{ qcb}xlga yb}gk

~mb~jm òga qcm amqmudoglqobg qb lxxloj qcox {buja* yb}a clpm qb em lx xq}~oa lx l hb~ qb xmmf b}q

l òglgholj quloj* l jmlamu* bu l xgoqhc'

Q{b hmgq}uomx b` hl~oqljoxd lga dlufmq gocojoxd clpm eub}kcq }x qb qcm dbxqmsqumdm ljomglqobgx ùbd b}u xmjpmx* ùbd bqcmux* ùbd {bujax' Qcm òhqobg b` qcmogaopoa}lj clx amhbd~bxma lq qcm xldm x~mma qclq oq {lx emhbdogk umlj' Hcojaumg b` qcm

dmqub~bjox* {m b``mu qcox {lkmu9 qclq oqx og qcm dbxq ~ub`b}ga am~uoplqobg b` msoxqmghm*~mu~mq}ljjy xqo jma* ~mu~mq}ljjy hbgi}uma l{ly* qclq qcm ~bxxoeojoqy b`hbdd}goxd umxoamx'[cmg ljj ox xloa lga abgm* oqx {oqc lg mgqoum lgqcub~bjbky qclq {m lum lq {lu' [oqc qcm pmuy oaml b` dlg' Hbdd}goxd qcmg* lx ~umx}~~bxoqobg lga lx ms~muodmgq' Xcluogk b` l

xmgxoeojoqy lga mjlebulqobg b` xcluogk' Qcm }ghbpmuogk b` {clq ox hbddbg lga qcm e}ojaogk b` l `buhm' Hbdd}goxd lx qcm dlquos b` l dmqoh}jb}x* l}alhob}x lxxl}jq bg abdoglqobg'

Lx l hljj lga lx l gldm `bu ljj {bujax umxoxqogk od~muolj ~lhoòhlqobg* ljj xbjoaluoqomx ouuma}hoejm qb qcm umokg b` hbddbaoqomx* ljj ùomgaxco~x lxx}dogk qcm gmhmxxoqomx b` {lu'

hbdd}goxd' [m fgb{ oqx l qmud qb em }xma {oqc hl}qobg' Gbq emhl}xm* og qcm kumlq ~lulam b` {buax* oq dly gb jbgkmu em pmuy `lxcobglejm' E}q emhl}xm b}u {buxq mgmdomx clpm}xma oq* lga hbgqog}m qb ab xb' [m ogxoxq' Hmuqlog {buax lum jofm elqqjmkub}gax9 qcmou dmlgogk* umpbj}qobgluy bu umlhqobgluy* ox l pohqbuy* qb em qbug ùbd qcm il{x b` xqu}kkjm'

Amxmuqogk hjlxxohlj ~bjoqohx dmlgx `lhogk }~ qb {lu* {cohc ox ljxb xoq}lqma bg qcm qmuulog b` jlgk}lkm' Bu ulqcmu* og qcm {ly qclq {buax* kmxq}umx lga jo`m lum ogxm~lulejy jogfma' O`

bgm ~}qx xb d}hc m``buq ogqb od~uoxbgogk lx qmuubuoxqx l `m{ yb}gk hbdd}goxqx {cb lum x}~~bxma qb clpm ~luqoho~lqma og ~}ejoxcogk Qcm Hbdogk Ogx}uumhqobg* oq ox gbq emhl}xm b` l

qcb}kcq huodm* e}q ulqcmu emhl}xm qcmy dokcq mdebay l hmuqlog hbgxoxqmghy emq{mmg lhqx lga qcb}kcq' Xbdmqcogk {cohc ox ulumjy qumlqma {oqc jmgomghy' [clq qcmxm ~mb~jm lum

lhh}xma b` ox gbq qb clpm {uoqqmg l ebbf* gbu mpmg qb clpm ~cyxohljjy lqqlhfma qcm xlhubxlghq `jb{x qclq ouuoklqm qcm dmqub~bjox' Oqx qclq qcmy dokcq ~bxxoejy clpm hbgùbgqma qcmxm

`jb{x {oqc qcm amgxoqy b` l ~bjoqohlj qcb}kcq lga ~bxoqobg' Qclq lg lhq hb}ja clpm dlam xmgxm lhhbuaogk qb lgbqcmu hbgxoxqmghy b` qcm {buja qclg qcm amxmuqma bgm b` Md~oum' Lgqo$

qmuubuoxd hjlodx qb lqqlhf qcm ~bxxoejm `}q}um b` l huodoglj lxxbholqobg' E}q {clq ox umljjy emogk lqqlhfma ox qcm `}q}um b` qcm xoq}lqobg' Qcm ~bxxoeojoqy qclq emcoga mpmuy kubhmu l

`m{ ela ogqmgqobgx lum coaogk* lga emcoga mpmuy qcb}kcq* qcm lhqx qclq oq hljjx `bu' Qcm ~bxxoeojoqy ms~umxxma ey lg oaml b` ~bjoqohx lgbgydb}x e}q {mjhbdogk* aoxxmdoglqm lga

}ghbgqubjjlejm {cohc hlggbq em umjmklqma qb qcm xqbumubbd b` ùmmabd b` ms~umxxobg'

Qcmum umdlogx xhluhmjy lgy ab}eq qclq yb}qc {ojj em qcm òuxq qb xlplkmjy hbgùbgq ~b{mu' Qcmxm

jlxq `m{ ymlux* ùbd qcm uobqx b` X~uogk 5>>< og Ljkmuol qb qcbxm b` Amhmdemu 5>>3 og Kummhm* lumgbqcogk e}q l xmuomx b` {lugogk xokgx og qcox umklua' Qcbxm {cb 8> bu 1> ymlux lkb umpbjqma lklogxq qcmou ~lumgqx{ojj gbq cmxoqlqm qb uma}hm qcox qb l hbg`johq emq{mmg kmgmulqobgx* o` gbq qb l ~umaohqlejm xyd~qbd b` labjmxhmghm' Qcm bgjy `}q}umb` l kmgmulqobg ox qb em qcm ~umhmaogk bgm* bg l ub}qm qclq jmlax ogmpoqlejy qb qcm hmdmqmuy' Qulaoqobg {b}ja clpm oq qclq

mpmuyqcogk emkogx {oqc l xbholj dbpmdmgq' Mx~mholjjy lq l dbdmgq {cmg qcm jm`q* {cohc clx xqojj gbq ògoxcma amhbd~bxogk*cy~bhuoqohljjy quomx qb umklog oqx humaoeojoqy og

qcm xqummqx' Mshm~q qclq og qcm xqummqx oq gb jbgkmu clx l dbgb~bjy' I}xq jbbf lq cb{* {oqc mlhc gm{ dbeojolqobg b`cokc xhcbbj xq}amgqx lx {oqc mpmuyqcogk qcm jm`q xqojj alumx qb x}~~buq l uo`q hbgqog}ljjy {oamgx emq{mmg

qcmou {cogogk amdlgax lga qcm jmpmj b` pobjmghm lga amqmudoglqobg b` qcm dbpmdmgq'

@ubd qcox uo`q {m d}xq e}oja l qumghc' O` {m xmm l x}hhmxxobg b` dbpmdmgqx c}uuyogk bgm l`qmu qcm

bqcmu* {oqcb}q jmlpogk lgyqcogk poxoejm emcoga qcmd* oq d}xq gbgmqcmjmxx em ladoqqmaqclq xbdmqcogk ~muxoxqx' L ~b{amu quloj jogfx {clq og mlhc mpmgq clx gbq jmq oqxmj` em hl~q}uma ey qcm lex}ua qmd~buljoqy b` qcm {oqcaul{lj b` l gm{jl{* bu xbdm bqcmu ~umqmsq' Og òqx lga xqluqx* lga og oqx b{g ucyqcd* {m lum xmmogk xbdmqcogk jofm l `buhm qlfm xcl~m' L `buhm qclq abmx gbq xmupm oqx qodm e}q od~bxmx oq* xojmgqjy'

Oq ox gb jbgkmu l dlqqmu b` `bumqmjjogk qcm hbjjl~xm bu am~ohqogk qcm ~bxxoeojoqomx b` iby' [cmqcmu oq hbdmx xbbgmu bu jlqmu* qcm ~bogq ox qb ~um~lum `bu oq' Oqx gbq l |}mxqobg b` ~ubpoaogk

l xhcmdl `bu {clq lg ogx}uumhqobg xcb}ja em* e}q b` qlfogk qcm ~bxxoeojoqy b` lg }~uoxogk `bu {clq oq gmpmu xcb}ja clpm hmlxma emogk9 l poqlj od~}jxm b` yb}qc lx d}hc lx l ~b~}jlu

{oxabd' O` bgm fgb{x cb{ qb dbpm* qcm lexmghm b` l xhcmdl ox gbq lg bexqlhjm e}q lg b~~buq}goqy'@bu qcm ogx}ukmgqx* oq ox qcm xbjm x~lhm qclq hlg k}lulgqmm qcm mxxmgqolj9 fmm~ogkqcm ogoqolqopm' [clq umdlogx qb em humlqma* qb em qmgama lx bgm qmgax l òum* ox l hmuqlogb}qjbbf* l hmuqlog qlhqohlj `mpmu* {cohc bghm oq clx mdmukma* mpmg gb{* umpmljx oqxmj` lx amqmudoglgq lga l hbgxqlgq xb}uhm b` amqmudoglqobg' Ljumlayhmuqlog |}mxqobgx clpm emmg umpopma qclq bgjy ymxqmualy dly clpm xmmdma kubqmx|}m bu b}qdbama6 qcmy gmma qb em xmoma }~bg* gbq og buamu qb umx~bga qb qcmd amògoqopmjy* e}q qb

dlfm qcmd jopm' Clpogk ~bxma qcmd lgm{ ox gbq qcm jmlxq b` qcm Kummf }~uoxogkx pouq}mx9 Cb{ abmx l xoq}lqobg b` kmgmuljoma uobqogk emhbdm lg ogx}uumhqobgluy xoq}lqobg2 [clq qb

ab bghm qcm xqummqx clpm emmg qlfmg* bghm qcm ~bjohm clpm emmg xb}gajy am`mlqma qcmum2 Ab qcm ~lujoldmgqx xqojj amxmupm qb em lqqlhfma2 [clq ox qcm ~ulhqohlj dmlgogk b` am~bxogk

~b{mu jbhljjy2 Cb{ qb amhoam2 Cb{ qb x}exoxq2 cb{ qb òga mlhc bqcmu2


6/15


7/15

JOGF $ MQCOHX

QCM L@@OUDLQOPMX HLJJ @BU UMX^BGXOEOJOQ_ QB QCM BQCMU OX GBQ UMXOXQLGHM*OQ OX DLXX ^LULJ_XOX' MDÔUM @]GHQOBGX MPMU_[CMUM GBQCOGK OX CL^^MGOGK'MPMU_[CMUM QCM XOQ]LQOBG HLG EM XLOA QB EM QLFMG HLUM B@' QCM HLJJ @BU]GOPMUXLJ MQCOHX OX HBGH]UUMGQ [OQC DMGOLJ* ^LUQOLJ* ^LQCMQOH JMKLJUMPOXOBG'

QCM L@@OUDLQOPM KOPMX ]^ BG MQCOHX QCM DBDMGQ OQ X]UUMGAMUX QCMKJBELJ HOPOJ [LU' OQ GMKBQOLQMX* OQ X]EDOQX* OQ UMPOXMX OQX MQCOHLJAMDLGAX QB LHHBDLALQM MJOQMX' B]U ^BXOQOBG OG QCM KJBELJ HOPOJ[LU OX QCLQ B@ LG L]QBGBDB]X DLQMUOLJ @BUHM$ LGBG_DB]X XMJ@BUKLGOYLQOBG OX QCM BGJ_ [L_ QB MXHL^M QCM AMXMUQ QCLQ OXHJLXXOHLJ ^BJOQOHX'

Qcm Ogpoxoejm Hbddoqqmm' Hljj' 5>>?' ~' =$8'E}q {clq ox dbxq xquofogk* `bu qcm qodm emogk* ox gbq qcm luubklghm b` md~oum* e}q ulqcmu qcm {mlfgmxx b`

qcm hb}gqmu$lqqlhf' Jofm l hbjbxxlj ~luljyxox' L dlxx ~luljyxox' [cohc {ojj xbdmqodmx xly {cmg oq xqojj

x~mlfx qclq qcmum ox gbqcogk qb ab* xbdmqodmx hbghmam {cmg ~}xcma qb oqx jodoq qclq qcmum ox xbd}hc qb ab' [cohc ox qb xly qcm xldm qcogk'

Qcmg* bg qcm ùogkm b` qcox ~luljyxox* qcmum ox qcm xbdmqcogk* lgyqcogk* clx qb em abgm b` qcm lhqopoxqx'

Xmlqqjm* ûlk}m* Kmgbl* qcm xqu}kkjm lklogxq kd bu qcm dbpmdmgqx b` qcm }gmd~jbyma* {m clpm ~jlyma b}u

~luq* {m clpm qlfmg xoamx og qcm xqu}kkjmx b` qcmxm jlxq ymlux6 lga hmuqlogjy gbq qcm xoam b`lqq lh bu qcm Q}qmEolghcm' Qcm `bjfjbum b` ~ubqmxqx gb jbgkmu mgqmuqlogx }x' Og qcm jlxq amhlam* {m clpm xmmg qcm a}jjdbgbjbk}m b` Dlusoxd$Jmgogoxd umk}ukoqlqm ubd xqojj i}pmgojm db}qcx' [m clpm xmmg qcm ~}umxq

lgluhcoxd gmklqm ljxb {clq oq hlggbq hbd~umcmga'[m clpm xmmg qcm dbxq qmaob}x mhbgbdoxd qclq b`Jm Dbgam Ao~jbdlqo|}m emhbdogk qcm gm{ ~b~}jlu

umjokobg' LgaGmkuooxd od~bxogk oqxmj` lx qcm bgjy ljqmuglqopm qb qcm ogqmjjmhq}lj ub}q b` qcm kjbelj jm`q'Jm`qoxq dojoqlgqoxd clx mpmuy{cmum kbgm elhf qb uloxogk oqx qbqqmuogk hbgxqu}hqobgx* oqx am~umxxopm

gmq{bufx* }gqoj mscl}xqobg'

Oq qbbf gb dbum qclg qcumm ymlux `bu qcm hb~x* }gobgx* lga bqcmu og`budlje}uml}hulhomx qb aoxdlgqjm qcm xcbuq$jopma lgqo$kjbeljoxlqobg dbpmdmgq' Qb hbgqubjoq' Qb aopoam oq ogqb xm~lulqm lumlx b` xqu}kkjm* mlhc lx ~ubòqlejm lx oq ox xqmuojm'Og qcmxm qodmx* ùbd Alpbx qb ^buqb Ljmkum* ùbd qcm dmam`qb qcm hgq* hl~oqljoxd lga lgqo$hl~oqljoxdamxhuoem qcm xldm lexmgq cbuobg' Qcm xldm qu}ghlqma ~ubx~mhq b`dlglkogk qcm aoxlxqmu'[clq mpmgq}ljjy b~~bxmx qcox ~umplojogk amxbjlqobg ox dmumjy lgbqcmu amxbjlqobg* i}xq bgm qclq ox gbq lx

{mjjxqbhfma'

Mpmuy{cmum qcmum ox qcm xldm oaobqoh oaml b` cl~~ogmxx'

Qcm xldm kldmx b` ~b{mu qclq lum ~luljyxma {oqc `mlu'

Qcm xldm aoxludogk x}~muòholjoqy' Qcm xldm mdbqobglj

ojjoqmulhy' Qcm xldm amxmuq'

[m xly qclq qcmxm qodmx lum l amxmuq* lga qclq qcox amxmuq oghmxxlgqjy amm~mgx' Qcox ox gb ~bmqoh ampohm* oq ox

mpoamgq' Lg mpoamgq {cohc clueb}ux dlgy bqcmux' Gbqlejy qcm u}~q}um {oqc ljj qclq ~ubqmxqx* ljj qclqamgb}ghmx* lga ljj qclq kjbxxmx bpmu qcm aoxlxqmu'

[cbmpmu amgb}ghmx msmd~qx qcmdxmjpmx'Mpmuyqcogk l~~mlux lx o` jm`qoxqx {mum lhh}d}jlqogk umlxbgx qb umpbjq qcm xldm {ly l dlglkmu

lhh}d}jlqmx qcm dmlgx qb abdoglqm' Qclq ox qb xly {oqc qcm xldm amjokcq' Qcm amxmuq ox qcm ~ubkumxxopmam~b~}jlqobg b` {buja x qcm cleoq {m clpm lab~qma qb jopm lx o`{m {mum gbq b` qcox {buja' Qcm amxmuq ox ~umxmgq ogqcm hbgqog}b}x* dlxxopm lga ~ubkulddma ~ubjmqluolgoxlqobg b` ~b~}jlqobgx*

i}xq lx oq ox ~umxmgq og qcm x}e}uelg x~ul{j b` @jbuoal* {cmum qcm doxmuy jomx ~umhoxmjy og qcm `lhq qclq gb bgmxmmdx qb `mmj oq'

Qclq qcm amxmuq b` b}u qodm ox gbq ~muhmopma bgjy dlfmx oq cluxcmu'

Xbdm clpm quoma qb gldm qcm amxmuq' Qb ~bogq b}q {clq clx qb em `b}kcq gbq lx qcm lhqobg b` l `bumokg lkmgq e}q lx l x}d b` umjlqobgx' Qcmy qljfma leb}q x~mhqlhjm* eob~b{mu bu

md~oum' E}q qcox ljxb laama qb qcm h}uumgq hbg`}xobg'


8/15

Qcm x~mhqlhjm ox gbq lg mlxy leeumpolqobg `bu qcm dlxxdmaol' Oq jomx lx d}hc og qcm hu}mjqy {oqc {cohc mpmuyqcogk mgajmxxjy qcub{x }x elhf qb b}u b{g odlkm'

Eob~b{mu ox gbq l xygbgyd `bu xbholj xmh}uoqy* qcm {mj`lum xqlqm bu qcm ~cludlhm}qohlj oga}xquy* e}q oq

^jmlxlgqjy jbakmx oqxmj` og qcm hlum qclq {m qlfm b` b}u ~umqqy ebaomx* og l hmuqlog ~cyxohljmxqulgkmdmgq qb

bgmxmj` lx {mjj lx qb bqcmux' Md~oum ox gbq xbdm foga b` msqulqmuumxquolj mgqoqy* l {buja{oam hbgx~oulhy b`kbpmugdmgqx* oglgholj gmq{bufx* qmhcgbhulqx* lga d}jqoglqobglj hbu~bulqobgx'

Md~oum ox mpmuy{cmum gbqcogk ox cl~~mgogk ' Mpmuy{cmum qcogkx lum {bufogk '[cmumpmu qcm gbudlj

xoq}lqobg ~umplojx' Ey aogq b` xmmogk qcm mgmdy lx l x}eimhq qclq `lhmx }x ogxqmla b``mmjogkoq lx lumjlqobgxco~ qclq cbjax }x {m hbgògm b}uxmjpmx qb qcm xqu}kkjm lklogxq hbgògmdmgq'

[m um~uba}hm }gamu qcm ~umqmsq b` lg ljqmuglqopm qcm {buxq foga b` abdoglgq umjlqobgxco~x' [m xqluqxmjjogk lx l hbddbaoqy qcm pmuy xqu}kkjm lklogxq qcm hbddbaoqy' Cmghm {m kmq qcm l}qcbuoqomx b` qcm lgqo$

l}qcbuoqluolg xqu}kkjm* hcl}pogoxq mdogoxd* lga lgqo$`lxhoxq jyghcogkx'

Lq mpmuy dbdmgq {m lum qlfogk ~luq og l xoq}lqobg' [oqcog l xoq}lqobg qcmum lum gb x}eimhqx lga beimhqx O

lga qcm bqcmu* dy amxoumx lga umljoqy bgjy l x}d b` umjlqobgxco~x* l x}d b` qcm `jb{x qclq qulpmuxm oq'

Qcmum ox l kmgmulj hbgqmsq hl~oqljoxd* hopojoxlqobg* md~oum* hljj oq {clq yb} {oxc qclq gbq bgjyogqmgax qb hbgqubj mlhc xoq}lqobg e}q* mpmg {buxm* quomx qb dlfm x}um qclq qcmum ox* lxb`qmg lx ~bxxoejm* gb xoq}lqobg 'Qcm xqummqx lga qcm cb}xmx* qcm jlgk}lkm lga qcm l``mhqx* lga qcm {buja{oam qmd~b qclq xmqx qcm ~lhm b` oq

ljj* clpm emmg lai}xqma bu qclq ~}u~bxm bgjy' [bujax lum mpmuy{cmum hljoeulqma qb xjoam ey bu okgbum mlhc

bqcmu'Qcm gbudlj xoq}lqobg ox qcox lexmghm b` xoq}lqobg' Qb kmq buklgoxma dmlgx9 qb xqluqùbd qcm xoq}lqobg lga gbq aoxdoxx oq' Qb qlfm xoamx {oqcog oq ' [mlpogk Qcm gmhmxxluydlqmuolj* l``mhqopm lga ~bjoqohlj xbjoaluoqomx' Qcox ox {clq lgy xquofm abmx og lgyb`òhm* og lgy `lhqbuy' Qcox ox {clq lgy klgk abmx' Lgy umpbj}qobgluy bu hb}gqmu$umpbj}qobgluy ~luqy'Qb kmq buklgoxma dmlgx9 qb kopm x}exqlghm qb qcm xoq}lqobg'

Dlfogk oq umlj* qlgkoejm'

Umljoqy ox gbq hl~oqljoxq'

Qcm ~bxoqobg {oqcog l xoq}lqobg amqmudogmx qcm gmma qb `bukm ljjolghmx* lga `bu qclq ~}u~bxm qb mxqlejoxc

xbdm jogmx b` hbdd}gohlqobg* xbdm {oamu houh}jlqobg'

Og q}ug qcbxm gm{ jogfx umhbgòk}um qcm xoq}lqobg' Qcm gldm {m kopm qb qcm xoq}lqobg qclq {m lum og ox

{buja hopoj {lu' @bu qcmum ox gb jbgkmu lgyqcogk qclq hlg jodoq qcm hbgùbgqlqobg emq{mmg qcm b~~bxogk`buhmx' Gbq mpmg jl{* {cohc hbdmx ogqb ~jly lx bgm dbum `bud b` qcm kmgmuljoxma hbgùbgqlqobg'

Qcm {m qclq x~mlfx cmum ox gbq l amjodoqlejm* oxbjlqma {m* qcm {m b` l kub}~' Oq ox qcm {m b` l ~bxoqobg' Ogqcmxm qodmx qcox ~bxoqobg ox lxxmuqma lx l ab}ejm xmhmxxobg9 xmhmxxobg òuxq {oqc qcm ~ubhmxx b` hl~oqljoxq

pljbuoxlqobg6 qcmg xmhmxxobg {oqc ljj qcm xqmuojoqy mgqlojma ey l dmum b~~bxoqobg qbmd~oum* msqul$~lujoldmgqluy bu bqcmu{oxm6 qc}x l xmhmxxobg {oqc qcmjm`q' Cmumxmhmxxobg dmlgx jmxx l ~ulhqohlj um`}xlj qb hbdd}gohlqm qclg l aox~bxoqobg qb `budx b` hbdd}gohlqobg

xb ogqmgxm qclq* {cmg ~}q ogqb ~ulhqohm* qcmy xglqhc ùbd qcm mgmdy dbxq b` oqx `buhm' Qb ~}q oq euom`jy*

x}hc l ~bxoqobg um`mux qb qcm `buhm

b` ouu}~qobg b` qcm Ejlhf ^lgqcmux lga qcm hbjjmhqopm hlgqmmgx b` qcm KmudlgL}qbgbdmg* qb qcm qummcb}xmx lga luq b` xlebqlkm b` qcm Euoqoxc gmb$j}aaoqmx* qb qcm hlum`}j hcbohm b` {buax b` qcm ulaohlj

`mdogoxqx* qb qcm dlxx xmj`$uma}hqobgx b` qcm Oqljolg l}qbgbdoxqx* lga qcm ludma iby b` qcm I}gm 5ga

Dbpmdmgq'@ubd gb{ bg ljj ùomgaxco~ ox ~bjoqohlj' Qcm }gjodoqma mxhljlqobg b` hbgqubj ox l cb~mjmxx umx~bgxm qb qcm

~umaohqlejm eumlfab{gx b` qcm xyxqmd' Gbqcogk qclq ox ms~umxxma og qcm fgb{g aoxquoe}qobg b` ~bjoqohlj

oamgqoqomx ox lejm qb jmla emybga qcm aoxlxqmu'

Qcmum`bum* {m emkog ey {oqcaul{ogk ùbd qcmd' [m hbgqmxq gbqcogk* {m amdlga gbqcogk' [mhbgxqoq}qm b}uxmjpmx lx l `buhm * lx l dlqmuolj `buhm* lx lg l}qbgbdb}x dlqmuolj`buhm {oqcog qcm {buja hopoj {lu' Qcox hljj xmqx b}q qcm hbgaoqobgx'


9/15

ÛBQMXQ B@ XOGKJM OXX]MX [OJJ EM LEXBUEMA E_ QCM X_XQMD AMDBEOJOYOGKLGQO$HLÔQLJOXQ M@@BUQX

CMUBA 5>>1 VIldmx* kmqqogk ùmm* ;qc maoqobg* cqq~9""ildmxcmuba'og`b"2

xmh4ebbf&oa4< T$LH[m hlggbq amxquby hl~oqljoxd {oqc xogkjm$oxx}m hld~lokgx* ymq qcmkumlq e}jf b` ulaohljx mgmuky ox x~mgq bg qcmxm hld~lokgx' Qcmum lumabmgx b` qcmd9 hld~lokgx qb am`mga lebuqobg uokcqx* dlogqlog umgqhbgqubj* cljq {cljogk* ~ubcoeoq qbsoh a}d~ogk* xqb~ qcm {lu bg au}kx*xqb~ ~bjohm eu}qljoqy* xqb~ }gobg e}xqogk* lebjoxc qcm amlqc ~mgljqy*xqb~ qcm jbkkogk b` uma{bbax* b}qjl{ qcm eley xmlj fojj* elg kmgmqohljjydbaoòma `bbax* xqb~ qcm [buja Elgf lga qcm [buja Qulam Buklgolqobg*xqb~ kjbelj {ludogk* lga bg lga bg' [clq {m lum abogk ox x~mgaogkb}u jopmx quyogk qb òs l xyxqmd qclq kmgmulqmx mpojx `lxqmu qclg {m hlgmpmu mulaohlqm qcmd' Ljqcb}kc xbdm b` qcmxm hld~lokgx }xm aoumhqlhqobg #m'k'* x~ofmx og qcm qummx qb xqb~ qcm hclog xl{x bu Kummg~mlhmeblqx og ùbgq b` qcm {cljogk xco~x qb ejbhf qcm clu~bbgx/* `bu qcm dbxq~luq qcm hld~lokgx lum lodma lq ~lxxogk jmkoxjlqobg og Hbgkumxx qbhbuumhq qcm ~ubejmd' ]g`buq}glqmjy* um`budx qclq lum {bg og bgmamhlam* l`qmu mgajmxx lkoqlqobg* hlg em mlxojy {o~ma b`` qcm ebbfx qcm`bjjb{ogk amhlam* l`qmu qcm ~ubqmxqmux clpm kbgm cbdm bu l gm{ladogoxqulqobg hbdmx qb ~b{mu'Qcmxm xqu}kkjmx ljj clpm plj}m lga lumgmmama' Hb}ja lgybgm qcogf qclq qcm hld~lokgx lklogxq kjbelj{ludogk* qb ùmm Jmbglua ^mjqomu* bu qb loa qcm Mlxq Qodbumxm b}kcq qbem lelgabgma2 Xogkjm$oxx}m hld~lokgx fmm~ }x l{lum b` {clq+x {ubgklga xbdmqodmx mpmg {og klogx' E}q og lga b` qcmdxmjpmx* qcmy hlggbqamxquby hl~oqljoxd* lga qc}x hlggbq umljjy òs qcogkx' Oq ox }qb~olg qbemjompm qclq {m hlg um`bud hl~oqljoxd' Dbxq b` qcmxm mpojx hlg bgjy emmulaohlqma `bu kbba o` {m amxquby hl~oqljoxd oqxmj` lga humlqm l gm{hopojolqobg' [m hlggbq l``bua qb lod `bu lgyqcogk jmxx' B}u pmuyx}upoplj ox lq xqlfm' Qcmum ox bgm xogkjm$oxx}m hld~lokg O hlg{cbjmcmluqmajy mgabuxm9 qcm qbqlj lga ~mudlgmgq mulaohlqobg b`hl~oqljoxd

Gbudlj Dmlgx ox qclq qcm qubb~x {b}ja kb qb K}ld'Cmoxmu >? Ildmx Cmoxmu* Qcm Gm{ Ldmuohlg* cqq~9""{{{'qcmgm{ldmuohlg'hbd"ogams'~c~"}xgm{x"`bumokg$~bjohy"500?

Lxum~buqma ey QcmGm{Ldmuohlg'hbd xmpmulj dbgqcx lkb* qcm ]goqma Xqlqmx ox ~umxmgqjy xco`qogkqmgx b` qcb}xlgax b` dojoqluy ~muxbglj lga `ldojy dmdemux ùbd elxmx og Il~lg qbms~lgama `lhojoqomx og qcm ]'X' qmuuoqbuy b` K}ld* {oqc qcm Il~lgmxm kbpmugdmgq

~lyogk bpmu l qcoua b` qcm hbxq b` qcm umjbhlqobg' L dlibu umlxbg `bu qcm umam~jbydmgq b` qcmxmqubb~x ox qcm oghumlxma qmgxobgx emq{mmg Ldmuohlg xmupohm ~muxbggmj lga qcm x}uub}gaogk hbdd}goqomx og Bfogl{l'

Qcox xcbumx }~ ]'X' dojoqluy hbgqubj bpmu qcm kjbem lga mgx}umx ]'X' hbjbgolj u}jm lgamgpoubgdmgqlj amxqu}hqobg b` `bumxqx og K}ld'Lkgbqm 5> ALUOB LKGBQM b` qcm Fybab Gm{x* Qcm Il~lg Qodmx Bgjogm* Dlfmbpmu qb q}ug K}ld ogqb Fmy ]'X'`buqumxx* * Um~bxqma bg hbddbg aumldx*cqq~9""{{{'hbddbgaumldx'buk"cmlajogm"5>">


10/15

Qcm ]goqma Xqlqmx ~jlgx qb `buqo`y K}ld* }~kulaogk oqx dojoqluy ogùlxqu}hq}um bg qcmoxjlga ogqb l xqulqmkoh xqlkogk ~bxq qclq {b}ja ljjb{ ul~oa lhhmxx qb ~bqmgqolj `jlxc~bogqx og qcm ^lhoòh umkobg' Q{b @$55 Ul~qbux lga l E$5 X~ouoq ebdemu am~jbyma qb Lgamuxmg Lou @buhmElxm* K}ld* `jy og `budlqobg bpmu qcm ^lhoòh Bhmlg' #]'X Lou @buhm ~cbqb"Dlxqmu Xkq' Fmpog I' Ku}mg{lja/ Dbumxmupohm dmdemux* oghj}aogk ?*>> qulgxomgq xmupohm

ulgfx* dlogjy ùbd glpy hluuomu xquofm kub}~x' Qcm %bpmuluhcogk ~}u~bxm% b` emmògk}~ K}ld lx l dojoqluy `buqumxx ox %qb ~ubpoam d}q}lj am`mgxm* amqmu lkkumxxobg lgaaoxx}lam hbmuhobg og qcm [mxqmug ^lho oh umkobg* lhhbuaogk qb l aul`q od~lhq um~buqumhmgqjy umjmlxma ey qcm ]'X' Am`mgxm Am~luqdmgq' Qcm e}oja}~ {ojj ljjb{ ]'X' `buhmxqb umx~bga qb umkobglj qcumlqx lga huoxmx og l %`jmsoejm% lga %qodmjy dlggmu% lx qcmy{buf qb %am`mga ]'X'* Il~lg lga ljjoma ogqmumxqx*% qcm xq}ay xlyx' %Dbpogk qcmxm`buhmx qb K}ld {b}ja ~jlhm qcmd bg qcm `}uqcmxq `bu{lua mjmdmgq b` xbpmumokg ]'X'qmuuoqbuy og qcm ^lhoòh* qcmumey dlsodoogk qcmou ùmmabd b` lhqobg'% Lhhbuaogk qb qcmum~buq* qcm ]goqma Xqlqmx mgpoxobgx K}ld lx l %jbhlj hbddlga lga hbgqubj xqu}hq}um% dlggma* m|}o~~ma* qulogma

lga x}xqlogma ey l dbamug jbkoxqohx ogùlxqu}hq}um' Qcm umjbhlqobg lga e}oja}~ hbxq* oghj}aogkms~lgxobg b` ogùlxqu}hq}um gmmama qb dlogqlog l ~mudlgmgq elxm `bu dluogmx lga]'X' Ludy qubb~x bg K}ld lga Qogolg* lg oxjlga fd qb qcm gbuqcmlxq* ox ~mkkma

lq !? eojjobg b` qcm qbqlj' Qcm ~jlg mgqlojx%oghumlxma b~mulqobglj lhqopoqomx*% dbum ùm|}mgq emuqcogk ey louhul`q hluuomux lga bqcmu {luxco~x*e}ojaogk K}ld+x Lgamuxmg Lou @buhm Elxm {ojj em ms~lgama qb oghj}am dluogm lou mjmdmgqx' L gm{ dluogm elxm {ojjem e}ojq %uokcq gmsq abbu*% qcm xq}ay xlyx' Qcm ]'X' ljxb ~jlgx qb ms~lga oqx jopm òum qulogogk ulgkmx bg Qogolg* {cmumleb}q 5>> bu dbum dluogmx hb}ja %umljoxqohljjy qulog% {oqc qcmou {ml~bgx lga m|}o~dmgq %{oqcb}q umxquohqobgx'% L]'X' Ludy Lou lga Doxxojm Am`mgxm Qlxf @buhm ox ljxb ~ub~bxma `bu K}ld qb ~ubqmhq qcm oxjlga lga ]'X' `buhmx qcmumlklogxq qcm qcumlq b` eljjoxqoh doxxojmx' Qcm ]'X dojoqluy ox emmògk }~ oqx ~umxmghm bg K}ld l`qmu ljjomx og qcm ^lhoòh $qcm ^cojo~~ogmx* Qclojlga* L}xquljol* Xb}qc Fbuml lga Xogkl~bum $ q}ugma ab{g ]'X' um|}mxqx `bu ~mudlgmgq elxogk b`

]'X' `buhmx bg qcmou xboj' Ljumlay lpolqobg qulogogk ulgkmx lga }~kulaogk cluebux* {clupmxlga ~buqx' hbghmugx lum emogk uloxma bpmu ~jlgx qb qulgx`bud K}ld ogqb %ld}jqoxmupohm dojoqluy elxm'% %Xbdm b` qcm lumlx qclq qcmy+um ~jlggogk qb hbgpmuq ogqbòuogk ulgkmx oghj}am ~uoxqogm jodmxqbgm `bumxqma lumlx qclq {ojj um|}oum xbdmhjmluogk b` glqopm `bumxq qummx*% eobjbkoxq Im`ùmy \}oq}k}l xloa' I}aoqc K}qcmuq* lxmglqbu og qcm K}ld Jmkoxjlq}um {cb hcloux qcm dojoqluy e}oja}~ hbddoqqmm* oxhbghmugma bpmu %jlga hbgamdglqobg bu jlga qlfogkx'% %Qclq ox l pmuy mdbqobgljoxx}m `bu qcm ~mb~jm b` K}ld emhl}xm b` {clq cl~~mgma l`qmu [buja [lu OO* {cmumqcm `mamulj kbpmugdmgq hbgamdgma xb d}hc jlga bg K}ld' [m abg+q {lgq l um~mlqb` qclq*% xcm xloa' Cmguy Xod~xbg* kmgmulj dlglkmu b` qcm K}ld Ulhogk @mamulqobg* xloa qcm ]'X' dojoqluy lodxqb qlfm cox ulhm qulhf

Lga* qcm lexmghm b` coxqbuohlj$dlqmuoljoxq huoqohoxd k}lulgqmmx qcm msoxqmghmb` ]'X' mshm~qobgljoxd' Qcm xqlqmx lqqmd~q qb bpmuhbdm qcm hbgqulaohqobgxb` hl~oqljoxd umx}jqx og gm{ `budx b` od~muolj pobjmghm h}jdoglqogk ogmsqoghqobg'

@bxqmu* Bumkbg ]gopmuxoqy Am~luqdmgq b` Xbhobjbky ûb`mxxbu* >=#Ibcg E'* Dbgqcjy Umpom{*cqq~9""{{{'dbgqcjyumpom{'buk">?>=ie`'cqd* Xm~qmdemu*/

@ubd qcm jbgkmu pom{ b``muma ey l coxqbuohlj$dlqmuoljoxq huoqo|}m b` hl~oqljoxd* qcm aoumhqobg qclq {b}ja em qlfmg

ey ]'X' od~muoljoxd `bjjb{ogk qcm `ljj b` qcm Xbpomq ]gobg {lx gmpmu og ab}eq' Hl~oqljoxd ey oqx pmuy jbkoh ox l

kjbeljjy ms~lgxopm xyxqmd' Qcm hbgqulaohqobg emq{mmg oqx qulgxglqobglj mhbgbdoh lx~oulqobgx lga qcm lhq qclq

~bjoqohljjy oq umdlogx ubbqma og ~luqoh}jlu glqobg xqlqmx ox ogx}udb}gqlejm bu qcm xyxqmd' _mq* ojj$`lqma lqqmd~qx ey
http://www.monthlyreview.org/0905jbf.htmhttp://www.monthlyreview.org/0905jbf.htmhttp://www.monthlyreview.org/0905jbf.htm


11/15

ogaopoa}lj xqlqmx qb bpmuhbdm qcox hbgqulaohqobg lum i}xq lx d}hc l ~luq b` oqx `}galdmgqlj jbkoh' Og ~umxmgq {buja

houh}dxqlghmx* {cmg bgm hl~oqljoxq xqlqm clx l pouq}lj dbgb~bjy b` qcm dmlgx b` amxqu}hqobg* qcm qmd~qlqobg `bu

qclq xqlqm qb lqqmd~q qb xmom `}jj$x~mhqu}d abdoglghm lga qb qulgx`bud oqxmj` ogqb qcm am `lhqb kjbelj xqlqm

kbpmugogk qcm {buja mhbgbdy ox ouumxoxqoejm' Lx qcm gbqma Dlusolg ~cojbxb~cmu Oxqpg Dxubx bexmupma og

Xbholjoxd bu Elueluoxd2 #5>>>= oxx}m b` @bumokg ^bjohy9 Qcm ]goqma Xqlqmx clx gmpmu mgabuxma qcm~bjohy b` gb òuxq }xm* gbq a}uogk dy xmpmg ymlux lx xmhumqluy bu xoghm'[m clpm emmg lga umdlog ~um~luma qbogoqolqm qcm }xm b` g}hjmlu {ml~bgxey qcm amhoxobg b` bgm ~muxbg* qcm ~umxoamgqlklogxq moqcmu l g}hjmlu bu

gbgg}hjmlu mgmdy {cmgmpmu{m emjompm oq ox og b}u ogqmumxq qb ab xb'Qcm glqobg {oqc qcm kumlqmxqhbgpmgqobglj dojoqluy `buhm lga qcm {ojjogkgmxx qb }xm oq }gojlqmuljjy qb mgjlukm oqx kjbelj ~b{mu ox ljxb qcm glqobg

{oqc qcm kumlqmxq g}hjmlu `buhm lga qcm umlaogmxx qb }xm oq {cmgmpmu oq xmmx òqxmqqogk qcm {cbjm {buja bg makm'Qcm glqobg qclq hbgquoe}qmx dbum qb hluebg aobsoam mdoxxobgx jmlaogk qb kjbelj {ludogk qclg lgy bqcmu#um~umxmgqogk l~~ubsodlqmjy l |}luqmu b` qcm {bujax qbqlj/clx emhbdm qcm kumlqmxq bexqlhjm qb laaumxxogk kjbelj{ludogk lga qcm {bujax kub{ogk mgpoubgdmgqlj ~ubejmdxuloxogk qcm ~bxxoeojoqy b` qcm hbjjl~xm b` hopojolqobg

oqxmj` o` ~umxmgq qumgax hbgqog}m'Qcm ]goqma Xqlqmx ox xmmfogk qb msmuhoxm xbpmumokg l}qcbuoqy bpmu qcm ~jlgmqa}uogk l qodm b` {oamgogk kjbelj huoxox9 mhbgbdoh xqlkglqobg* oghumlxogk ~bjluolqobg emq{mmg qcm kjbelj uohc lga

qcm kjbelj ~bbu* {mlfmgogk ]'X' mhbgbdoh cmkmdbgy* kub{ogk g}hjmlu qcumlqx* lga amm~mgogk mhbjbkohlj

amhjogm' Qcm umx}jq ox l cmokcqmgogk b` ogqmuglqobglj ogxqleojoqy'Bqcmu ~bqmgqolj `buhmx lum mdmukogk og qcm {buja*x}hc lx qcm M}ub~mlg Hbdd}goqy lga Hcogl* qclq hb}ja mpmgq}ljjy hcljjmgkm ]'X' ~b{mu* umkobgljjy lga mpmg

kjbeljjy' Qcoua {buja umpbj}qobgx* `lu ùbd hmlxogk* lum emkoggogk qb klog dbdmgq}d lklog* xydebjoma eyPmgm}mjlx Ebjopluolg Umpbj}qobg }gamu C}kb Hcpm']'X' lqqmd~qx qb qokcqmg oqx od~muolj kuo~ bg qcm DoaajmMlxq lga oqx boj clpm cla qb hb~m {oqc l òmuhm* xmmdogkjy }gxqb~~lejm* Oul|o umxoxqlghm* kmgmulqogk hbgaoqobgx b`

od~muolj bpmuxqumqhc' [oqc qcm ]goqma Xqlqmx eulgaoxcogk oqx g}hjmlu luxmglj lga um`}xogk qb x}~~buq ogqmuglqobglj

lkummdmgqx bg qcm hbgqubj b` x}hc {ml~bgx*g}hjmlu ~ubjo`mulqobg ox hbgqog}ogk' Gm{ glqobgx* x}hc lx GbuqcFbuml* lum mgqmuogk bu hlg em ms~mhqma xbbg qb mgqmuqcm g}hjmlu hj}e' Qmuubuoxq ejb{elhf ubd od~muoljoxq{lux og qcm qcoua {buja ox gb{ l {mjj$umhbkgoma umljoqy* kmgmulqogk uoxogk `mlu b` `}uqcmu qmuubuoxq lqqlhfx og Gm{

_buf* Jbgabg* lga mjxm{cmum'X}hc plxq lga bpmujl~~ogk coxqbuohlj hbgqulaohqobgx* ubbqma og qcm hbdeogma lga}gmpmg ampmjb~dmgq b` qcm kjbelj hl~oqljoxq mhbgbdy ljbgk {oqc qcm ]'X' auopm `bu ~jlgmqluy abdoglqobg*

`bumxclab{ {clq ox ~bqmgqoljjy qcm dbxq algkmub}x ~muoba og qcm coxqbuy b` od~muoljoxd'

QCM LJQMUGLQOPM OX QB CLPM LG OGX]UUMHQOBG qb x}~~buq hbdd}glj umjlqobgx b`xbjoaluoqy'BGJ_ E_ UMIMHQOGK HLÔQLJOXD+X AUOPM QB HBDDBAO@_ HLG [M LHHMJMULQM QCMOGX]UKMGQ LJQMUGLQOPMX LUOXOGK LJJ LUB]GA ]X' QCOX OX HUOQOHLJ$ [M D]XQHLJJ HLÔQLJOXD+X EJ]@@ B@ QCMUM OX GB LJQMUGLQOPM BU [M [OJJ LJJ @LHM

QCM M\]LJOQ_ B@ G]HJMLU MSQOGHQOBG'Dluh}xm* Kmudlg ^cojbxb~cmu lga ûb`mxxbu lq Hbj}deol lga Cluplua*


12/15

qcm ljqmuglqopm qbaly* oq {b}ja gbq em qclq b` lg ljqmuglqopm6 qcm ~bxxoeojoqomxb` qcm gm{ xbhomqy lum x}`òhomgqjy %lexqulhq*% o'm'* umdbpma ùbd lgaoghbgku}b}x {oqc qcm mxqlejoxcma }gopmuxm qb am`y lgy lqqmd~q qb oamgqo`yqcmd og qmudx b` qcox }gopmuxm' Cb{mpmu* qcm |}mxqobg hlggbq em eu}xcmalxoam ey

xlyogk qclq {clq dlqqmux qbaly ox qcm amxqu}hqobg b` qcm bja* b` qcm ~b{muxqclq em* dlfogk {ly `bu qcm mdmukmghm b` qcm gm{' X}hc lg lgx{mu gmkjmhqxqcm mxxmgqolj `lhq qclq qcm bja ox gbq xod~jy ela* qclq oq amjopmux qcm kbbax*lga qclq ~mb~jm clpm l umlj xqlfm og oq' Qcmum hlg em xbhomqomx {cohc lumd}hc {buxm qcmum lum x}hc xbhomqomx qbaly' Qcm xyxqmd b` hbu~bulqmhl~oqljoxd clx qcm uokcq qb ogxoxq qclq qcbxm {cb {buf `bu oqx um~jlhmdmgqi}xqo`y qcmou lhqobg'E}q qcm amdlga qb xqlqm qcm hbghumqm ljqmuglqopmx ox i}xqoòma `bu ymq lgbqcmuumlxbg' Gmklqopm qcogfogk aul{x {clqmpmu `buhm oq dly clpm ùbd oqxmd~ouohlj elxox9 qcm lhq}lj c}dlg hbgaoqobg og qcm kopmg xbhomqy* lga qcm%kopmg% ~bxxoeojoqomx qb qulgxhmga qcox hbgaoqobg* qb mgjlukm qcm umljd b`

ùmmabd' Og qcox xmgxm* gmklqopm qcogfogk ox ey pouq}m b` oqx b{g ogqmugljhbghm~qx %~bxoqopm%9 buomgqma qb{lua* lga hbd~umcmgaogk l `}q}um {cohc ox%hbgqlogma% og qcm ~umxmgq' Lga og qcox hbgqlogdmgq#{cohc ox lg od~buqlgq lx~mhq b`qcm kmgmulj hbgqlogdmgq ~bjohy ~}ux}ma ey qcm mxqlejoxcma xbhomqomx/* qcm `}q}um l~~mlux lx~bxxoejm joemulqobg' Oq ox gbq qcm bgjy ljqmuglqopm9 qcm lapmgq b` l jbgk ~muobab` %hopojoma% elueluoxd* {oqc bu {oqcb}q qcm g}hjmlu amxqu}hqobg* ox m|}ljjyhbgqlogma og qcm ~umxmgq' Gmklqopm qcogfogk* lga qcm ~ulsox k}oama ey oq* oxqcm ~bxoqopm lga ~bxoqogk m``buq qb ~umpmgq qcox }qqmu gmklqopoqy'Qcm hbghm~q b` qcm ~uodluy* ogoqolj ogxqoq}qobgx b` joemulqobg ox `ldojolu mgb}kc lga hbghumqm

mgb}kc9 hbjjmhqopm b{gmuxco~* hbjjmhqopm hbgqubj lga ~jlggogk b` qcm dmlgx b`~uba}hqobg lga aoxquoe}qobg' Qcox ox qcm `b}galqobg* l gmhmxxluy e}q gbq

x}`òhomgq hbgaoqobg `bu qcm ljqmuglqopm9 oq {b}ja dlfm ~bxxoejm qcm }xlkm b`ljj lplojlejm umxb}uhmx `bu qcm lebjoqobg b` ~bpmuqy* {cohc ox qcm ~umum|}oxoqm`bu qcm q}ug ùbd |}lgqoqy ogqb |}ljoqy9 qcm humlqobg b` l umljoqy og lhhbualghm{oqc qcm gm{ xmgxoqopoqy lga qcm gm{ hbgxhob}xgmxx' Qcox kblj od~jomxumimhqobg b` qcbxm ~bjohomx b` umhbgxqu}hqobg* gb dlqqmu cb{ umpbj}qobgluy*{cohc lum eb}ga qb ~mu~mq}lqm #bu qb ogquba}hm/ qcm ~lqqmug b` qcm }gùmmxbhomqomx lga qcmou gmmax' X}hc `ljxm ~bjohy ox ~mucl~x emxq x}ddma }~ ogqcm `bud}jl %qb hlqhc }~ {oqc* lga qb bpmuqlfm qcm ~uba}hqopoqy jmpmj b` qcmlaplghma hl~oqljoxq hb}gquomx'% [clq ox {ubgk {oqc qcox `bud}jl ox gbq qcmmd~clxox bg qcm ul~oa od~ubpmdmgq b` qcm dlqmuolj hbgaoqobgx e}q bg qcmdbamj k}oaogk qcmou od~ubpmdmgq' Qcm dbamj amgomx qcm ljqmuglqopm* qcm

|}ljoqlqopm ao``mumghm' Qcm jlqqmu ox gbq* lga hlggbq em* qcm umx}jq b` qcm `lxqmxq ~bxxoejmlqqlogdmgq b` hl~oqljoxq ~uba}hqopoqy* e}q ulqcmu qcm ampmjb~dmgq b` gm{ dbamx lga mgax b`

~uba}hqobg %gm{% gbq bgjy #lga ~mucl~x gbq lq ljj/ {oqc umx~mhq qb qmhcgohljoggbplqobgx lga ~uba}hqobg umjlqobgx* e}q {oqc umx~mhq qb qcm ao``mumgq c}dlggmmax lga qcm ao``mumgq c}dlg umjlqobgxco~x og {bufogk `bu qcm xlqox`lhqobg b`qcmxm gmmax' Qcmxm gm{ umjlqobgxco~x {b}ja em qcm umx}jq b` l %eobjbkohlj% xbjoaluoqy og{buf lga ~}u~bxm* ms~umxxopm b` l qu}m cludbgy emq{mmg xbholj lgaogaopoa}lj gmmax lga kbljx* emq{mmg umhbkgoma gmhmxxoqy lga ùmm


13/15

ampmjb~dmgq $qcm mslhq b~~bxoqm b` qcm ladogoxqmuma lga mg`buhma cludbgybuklgoma og qcm laplghma hl~oqljoxq #lga xbholjoxq2/ hb}gquomx' Oq ox qcm odlkm b` qcoxxbjoaluoqy lx mjmdmgqlj* ogxqoghq}lj* humlqopm `buhm {cohc qcm yb}gk ulaohljx xmm og H}el* og qcm

k}muuojjlx* og qcm Hcogmxm h}jq}ulj umpbj}qobg'

Xbjoaluoqy lga hbb~mulqobg9 gbq ljj qcmou `budx lum joemulqogk' @lxhoxd lga dojoqluoxd clpm

ampmjb~ma l amlajy m`òhomgq xbjoaluoqy' Xbholjoxq xbjoaluoqy ox l}qbgbdy9 xmjàmqmudoglqobg emkogxlq cbdm $lga qclq ox {oqc mpmuy O* lga qcm [m {cbd qcm O hcbbxmx' Lga qcox mga d}xq ogamma

l~~mlu og qcm dmlgx qb lqqlog oq* qclq ox qb xly* og qcm xqulqmky b` qcbxm {cb* {oqcog qcm msoxqogkxbhomqy* {buf `bu qcm gm{ bgm' O` qcm xbholjoxq umjlqobgxco~x b` ~uba}hqobg lum qb em lgm{ {ly b` jo`m* l gm{ @bud b` jo`m* qcmg qcmou msoxqmgqolj |}ljoqy d}xq xcb{`buqc* lgqoho~lqma lga amdbgxqulqma* og qcm òkcq `bu qcmouumljolqobg' Ms~jboqlqobg og ljj oqx `budx d}xq clpm aoxl~~mluma ùbd qcox òkcq9ùbd qcm {buf umjlqobgxco~x ldbgk qcm òkcqmux lx {mjj lx ùbd qcmou ogaopoa}lj umjlqobgxco~x']gamuxqlgaogk* qmgamugmxx qb{lua mlhc bqcmu* qcm ogxqoghq}lj hbgxhob}xgmxxb` qclq {cohc ox mpoj* `ljxm* qcm cmuoqlkm b` b~~umxxobg* {b}ja qcmg qmxqo`y qbqcm l}qcmgqohoqy b` qcm umemjjobg' Og xcbuq* qcm mhbgbdoh* ~bjoqohlj* lga h}jq}ulj `mlq}umx b`

l hjlxxjmxx xbhomqy d}xq clpm emhbdm qcm elxoh gmmax b` qcbxm {cb òkcq `bu oq'Qcox ogkumxxobgb` qcm `}q}um ogqb qcm ~umxmgq* qcox am~qc aodmgxobg b` qcm umemjjobg lhhb}gqx*og qcm jlxq lgljyxox* `bu qcm oghbd~lqoeojoqy {oqc qcm qulaoqobglj `budx b` qcm ~bjoqohlj xqu}kkjm'Qcm gm{ ulaohljoxd dojoqlqmx lklogxq qcm hmgquljoma e}uml}hulqoh hbdd}goxqlx {mjj lx lklogxq qcm xmdo$amdbhulqoh joemulj buklgolqobg' Qcmum ox l xqubgkmjmdmgq b` x~bgqlgmoqy* mpmg lgluhcoxd* og qcox umemjjobg* ms~umxxobg b` qcmgm{ xmgxoeojoqy* xmgxoqopoqy lklogxq abdoglqobg9 qcm `mmjogk* qcm l{lumgmxx*qclq qcm iby b` ùmmabd lga qcm gmma qb em ùmm d}xq ~umhmam joemulqobg'Qcmum`bum qcm lpmuxobg lklogxq ~ummxqlejoxcma Jmlamux* l~~lulqhcofx b` ljj xbuqx* ~bjoqoholgx gbdlqqmu cb{ jm`qoxq'Qcm ogoqolqopm xco`qx qb xdljj kub}~x* {oamjy ao``}xma* {oqc lcokc amkumm b` l}qbgbdy* dbeojoqy* `jmsoeojoqy'

HBGQOG]MAGbq umkumxxobg qb l ~umpob}x xqlkm b` hopojolqobg* e}q umq}ug qb lg odlkogluyqmd~x ~mua} og qcm umlj jo`m b` dlgfoga9 ~ubkumxx qb l xqlkm b` hopojolqobg{cmum Vc}Tdlg clx jmlugma qb lxf `bu qcm xlfm b` {cbd bu b` {clq cmVbu xcmTbuklgomx cox xbhomqy6 qcm xqlkm {cmum cm hcmhfx lga ~mucl~x mpmg cljqx cox oghmxxlgqxqu}kkjm `bu msoxqmghm bg lg mgjlukma xhljm* x}upmyx {clq clx emmg lhcompma qcub}kc hmgq}uomx b`doxmuy lga cmhlqbdex b` pohqodx* lga amhoamx qclq oq ox mgb}kc* lga qclq oq ox qodm qb mgiby{clq cm clx lga {clq hlg em um~uba}hma lga umògma {oqc l dogod}d b`ljomglqma jlebu9gbq qcm luumxq bu uma}hqobg b` qmhcgohlj ~ubkumxx* e}q qcmmjodoglqobg b` qcbxm b` oqx `mlq}umx {cohc ~mu~mq}lqm dlg+x x}eimhqobg qb qcml~~lulq}x lga qcm ogqmgxoòhlqobg b` qcm xqu}kkjm `bu msoxqmghm$qb {buf

cluamu og buamu qb kmq dbum b` qcm dmuhclgaoxm qclq clx qb em xbja' Og bqcmu{buax* mjmhquoòhlqobg ogamma* lgaljj qmhcgohlj ampohmx {cohc ljjmpolqm lga~ubqmhq jo`m* ljj qcm dmhclgolqobg {cohc ùmmx c}dlg mgmuky lga qodm* ljjqcm xqlgaluaolqobg {cohc abmx l{ly {oqc x~}uob}x lga ~lulxoqluolg%~muxbgljoma% xmupohmx ulqcmu qclg d}jqo~jyogk qcmd lga qcm klakmqx lgaqbfmgx b` ms~jboqlqopm l`ò}mghm' Og qmudx b` qcm jlqqmu #lga bgjy og qmudx b` qcm jlqqmu/*qcox {b}ja hmuqlogjy em l umkumxxobg $e}q ùmmabd ùbd qcm u}jm b` dmuhclgaoxm bpmu dlg ox l~umhbgaoqobg b` ùmmabd'


14/15

Qcm hbgxqu}hqobg b` l ùmm xbhomqy {b}ja humlqm gm{ oghmgqopmx `bu {buf' Ogqcm ms~jboqlqopm xbhomqomx* qcm xb$hljjma {buf ogxqoghq ox dlogjy qcm #dbum bu jmxxm``mhqopmjy/ ogqubimhqma gmhmxxoqy qb ~mu`bud ~uba}hqopmjy og buamu qb mlug ljopogk' E}q qcm jo`m ogxqoghqx qcmdxmjpmx xquopm `bu qcm }goòhlqobg lgamgclghmdmgq b` jo`m6 og gbgum~umxxopm x}ejodlqobg qcmy {b}ja ~ubpoam qcm

joeoaoglj mgmuky `bu {buf bg qcm ampmjb~dmgq b` l umljoqy {cohc gb jbgkmuamdlgax qcm ms~jboqlqopm um~umxxobg b` qcm ^jmlx}um ûogho~jm' Qcm%oghmgqopmx% {b}ja qcmg em e}ojq ogqb qcm ogxqoghq}lj xqu}hq}um b` dmg' Qcmouxmgxoeojoqy {b}ja umkoxqmu* lx eobjbkohlj umlhqobgx* qcm ao``mumghm emq{mmg qcm}kjy lga qcm eml}qo`}j* emq{mmg hljd lga gboxm* qmgamugmxx lga eu}qljoqy*ogqmjjokmghm lga xq}~oaoqy* iby lga `}g* lga oq {b}ja hbuumjlqm qcox aoxqoghqobg{oqc qclq emq{mmg ùmmabd lga xmupoq}am' @um}a+x jlxq qcmbumqohlj hbghm~qobgumhbkgomx qcm mubqoh ogxqoghqx lx {buf ogxqoghqx ${buf `bu qcm humlqobg b` lxmgx}b}x mgpoubgdmgq'Qcm xbholj ms~umxxobg b` qcm joemulqma {buf ogxqoghq oxhbb~mulqobg* {cohc* kub}gama og xbjoaluoqy* aoumhqx qcm buklgolqobg b` qcmumljd b` gmhmxxoqy lga qcm ampmjb~dmgq b` qcm umljd b` ùmmabd' Lga qcmum

ox lg lgx{mu qb qcm |}mxqobg {cohc qub}ejmx qcm dogax b` xb dlgy dmg b`kbba {ojj9 {clq lum qcm ~mb~jm og l ùmm xbhomqy kbogk qb ab2 Qcm lgx{mu{cohc* O emjompm* xquofmx lq qcm cmluq b` qcm dlqqmu {lx kopmg ey l yb}gkejlhf kouj' Xcm xloa9 `bu qcm òuxq qodm og b}u jo`m* {m xcljj em ùmm qb qcogfleb}q {clq {m lum kbogk qb ab'


15/15

1NC Okinawa Round III UT

Documents

Transcript of 1NC Okinawa Round III UT