1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² (...

194

Transcript of 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² (...

Page 1: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

������������� ������������������ ������������� �����!���"�

#%$ � ��& #'$ ��( �"��� $ & ���)��������*)��

+-,/.1020436587:9;74.1<>=@?A5236043B=�7C36DE�F

GIHKJLH/M�N/OQPSR

TVU EXW .Y747436D%7C<Z74[X3 O 549\D U 9;743 T^] [X<V<>_`<\ab7C[X3R =�.Yc>3B5402.Y7 F <\aed)9\020C9 ] [ U 023B727C0/+ W [X3B54087�.Y=@fg9\5274.h9\_ia U _YjX_1_ W 36=�7

<\ab7C[X3k543Bl U .1523 W 36=�7C0man<>5o74[X3kDX36p>52363q<\a

, MkrtsKMkuvM�w ? H�JLPbM T M ? Hyx

d�9 F{z}|>|>|

,/3Bfg9\587 W 36=�7y<\a r < W f U 7C3B5 TV] .13B= ] 3

Page 2: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

]~ r <\f F 52.1p>[�7 E�F G [X.1[X<\=Xp P U z}|\|>|+�_Y_ u .1p>[�7C0 u 36023658c>36D

Page 3: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

������������� ������������������ ������������� �����!���"�

#%$ � ��& #'$ ��( �"��� $ & ���)��������*)��

+-,/.1020436587:9;74.1<>=@?A5236043B=�7C36DE�F

GIHKJLH/M�N/OQPSR

+�f�fX54<}c>3BD{9\0m74<�087 F _13�9\=XD ] <>=�7436=�7 E�Fi�

� 9;7C[�5 F = Ti� d ] � .1=�_13 F\� r [g9\.Y5

� ��� 5 UX] 3 r 54<;a�7 � d�3 W�E 3B5

,/<>=g9;_1D w � s <}�y04_Y3 F>� d�3 W�E 365

� 9 W 360K? � r 9\_1_19\= � d�3 W�E 365

r � d)9\=�. � 52.102[X=g9 � d�3 W�E 365

� 9 W 360 w � � U 52<>043 � ,/36fg9;527 W 36=�7 r [g9;.15,/36fX9\527 W 3B=�7y<;a r < W f U 74365 T^] .136= ] 3

Page 4: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

�i���Z�����\�:���g���:�e���C�L���:�:�}�����k�V�Z ¢¡)�\�i£����:�L���:�:�}���/¤V¥¦�\�V§�¨6¥�¡' ¢¥�¡���\�i£©�Z�«ª6�C���n¬g���C��­o¥��g��¥® ®¡�¯

Page 5: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

����°�& $�± ���� -²�( ��&v�³�

w .152027�9\=�D�an<\543 W <>087 � J ��< U _1D�_Y.1´\3�7C<3�µ^fX5236040 W¶F 02.1= ] 36523"74[g9\=X´�0%7C< W¶F 9\D�cV.102<>5 �� 9;7C[�5 F =�d ] � .1=X_Y3 F an<\5q[�365 ] <>=�7454. E U 7C.Y<>=".1="7C[X3�DX3�c>36_Y<>f W 36=�7�<\a W¶F 5436023�9\5 ] [�9\=�D�[X3B5p U .YDg9\= ] [email protected]= W¶F fX54<;an360402.1<>=X9\_mp>54<}�m74[ � � .Y74[X< U 7�[X3B5 E 54<�9\DcV.102.1<>= � DX363Bf·.Y=X04.Yp>[�7 � 9;=XD027454<>=�p©3B= ] < U 5C9\p>3 W 3B=�7 � 7C[�.10o��<>54´'��< U _YD�=�<\7K[g9�c>3 E 3B36=�f¸<>0204. E _13 �J �t< U _1D�_1.1´;3¹74<K74[g9\=X´ � 5 UX] 3 r 54<\a�7e9\=XD � 9 W .Y3 r 9\_1_19\=�an<>5b743�9 ] [�.1=Xp W 3¹04< U =XD�543B04369\5 ] [

fX52.1= ] .1fX_Y360m<>[email protected]. E U [email protected]=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>='523B7454.13�c;9\_`9\=XD%74[X36.Y5oc\9;_ U 9 E _13�9\D^c^. ] 3 �J �t< U _1D{_Y.1´;3k74<«7C[X9\=X´%7C[X3�543B027/<;a W¶F ] < W�W .Y7474363 � ,/<>= s <}�y04_13 F 9;=XD"d)9\=�. � 52.104[�=g9

an<>5o74[X36.Y5oc\9;_ U 9 E _13 ] < W©W 36=�740�9;=XD@0 U p>p\360274.1<>=�0 �J ��< U _YD"_1.1´;3¶7C<%74[g9\=X´)9\_1_¢fX543B0436=�7�9\=XD"fg9;027 W 3 W�E 36520�<\aº7C[X3 r 36=�74365�an<>5 J =�7C3B_1_Y.1p>3B=�7

J =�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\= u 3B7454.13�c;9\_b9;7�74[X3 R =X.Yc\365402.Y7 F <\a¹d)9;040C9 ] [ U 043B727C0 � + W [�3654087 � J �o9\0�an<>527 U =g9;74336=�< U p>[»7C< E 3Z9 W 3 W�E 365�<\aA7C[X.Y0�an54.Y36=XD�_ F>� 36=�¼2< F .1=Xp � 9\=XD»087C. W U _h9;74.1=Xp�543B04369\5 ] [ ] < W�W U^½=X.¾7 F � J ="fg9\5274. ]BU _h9\5 � J ��< U _1D»_Y.1´;3¶7C<'74[g9\=X´ � 543B=XDX<>= r 9\[X<V<>={an<>5�[X.10�fX543B_1. W .1=X9\5 F ��<>54´<>=�D�.1027454. E U 7C3BD�.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>="543�7C52.13Bc;9\_¹9\5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 52360Z9\=�D�[X.10�´�.1=XDX=�36040�7C<�7 U 7C<\5 W 3©7C[�304. W U _19;7C.Y<>=q743 ] [X=�.1l U 360 � J �t< U _1D�_Y.1´\3¹7C<�74[g9\=X´ � 9 F ?b<>=�7C3oan<>5¢fX54<V<\a ½ 523�9\D�.1=Xp W¶F fX54<>fi<>049\_ �J ��< U _1D»_Y.1´;3q74<«7C[g9;=X´�< U 5�023 ] 523B7C9\5 F\� � 9�7C3Zd�<>5 UX¿B¿ . � an<>5�[X365/´�.Y=XDX=X3B040k9\=XD)3BÀ ] .Y36=�7k9\0 ½04.Y027C9\= ] 3��y[X3B=X3Bc\365 J =X3B36DX3BD �J ��< U _YD»_1.Y´\3¶74<'7C[g9\=�´{9\_Y_ W¶F an54.Y36=XD�0 J [X9}c\3 W 3�7�.1=»+ W [X3B54087 � � .Y7C[�< U 7�74[X3 W�� 7C[�3

_h9;027�jXc\3�9\=XD³9{[g9\_¾a F 3�9\520Z�t< U _1D[g9�c>3 E 3636= U = E 3�9\549 E _Y3 � J =fg9\587C. ]6U _19\5 � J ��< U _1D_Y.1´\37C<{74[g9\=X´"7C[�3 r [X.1=�36043 ] < W�W U =X.¾7 F .Y=�7C[�3@,/36fg9\587 W 36=�7�<;a r < W f U 7C365 T^] .Y36= ] 3@9\=XD�7C[�3G .1=�0 W 36.1087C3B5ta¦9 W .1_ F �J �t< U _1D�_1.Y´\3«74<)7C[X9\=X´ W�F [ U 0 E 9\=XD � � .19\= W .1= � 9\=Xp � an<>5¶[X.Y0�_1<}c\3 � U =XD�3654087:9\=�DX.1=Xp �

9\=XD{9 E 04<\_ U 743�a¦9\.¾7C[).Y= W¶F 9 E .1_1.¾7C.Y360 � J <}��3 W¶F 04<>= � P U [g9\= � 9\=Xp � an<>5�[X.10Kan< U 5 ½ F 369\5�_Y.Yan3�y.Y74[X< U 7y[�.10 W <\7C[X3B5y9\54< U =XD � J �y.Y04[@[X3 ] < U _1D U =XDX3B54087:9\=XD W 3/�y[�36=�[X3kp>54<}�y0 U f �

c

Page 6: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

J DX3BDX. ] 9;7C3%7C[�.10�DX.102043B527:9�7C.1<\=³74< W¶F fg9\543B=�7C0 � H 9\< P U 9\=�D � .h9;=Xp>l�. U P . U � an<>5�74[X36.Y5_1<}c\3 � ] 9\52.1=Xp � 0C9 ] 54.¾j ] 3 � 9;=XD'0 U fXf¸<\527 � J �y.Y_1_�9\_¾�o9 F 0 E 3Kp>5C9;743Ba U _�7C< W¶F fg9\5236=�7C0 � �y[X<�[X9}c\39\_¾�o9 F 0ep>.¾c>36= W 3 W <\543�74[g9\=¶�y[X9;7 J ] < U _1D¶3Bc>3B5A9\02´qan<>5 � J 3B04fi3 ] .h9\_Y_ F 9\fXf�543 ] .h9;743�74[g9;7®74[X3 F7C369 ] [ W 3¹74[X3¹f¸<>02.Y74.Yc>3�9;727C.Y7 U DX3A7C<�0 U 58cV.Yc>3�.1=k7C[X.Y0b��<>52_1D � J 9\_102<�D�36DX. ] 9;743¹74[X.10bDX.102043B527:9�7C.1<\=7C< W¶F�E 54<\74[X365 �¹Á .Y= F . P UI� s [X3'DX523�9 W 0¶��3'�t3B543%02[g9\54.Y=Xp{D U 54.1=�p{< U 5 ] [X.1_YDX[X<V<^D�[X9}c\39\_¾�o9 F 0 E 363B={7C[X3�p>54369;7C3B027/.Y=X04f�.15C9�7C.1<\=@an<\5 W 3�74< W <Âc\3¶<>={9\=XD�a¦9 ] 3��y[X9;7C3�c>365 ] [X9\_1_Y36=Xp>3W 9 F 9\fXfi3�9\5 �s [X.10 W 9�7C3652.h9\_S.Y0 E 9;0436D»<\=)�t<\54´@0 U f�f¸<>587C3BD».1=)fX9\527 E�F 7C[�3 N 9�7C.1<\=g9\_ T^] .Y36= ] 3 w < U = ½

Dg9;74.1<>= � P . E 5C9\5 F <\a r <\=Xp>543B040�9\=XD»,/3Bfg9\527 W 3B=�7�<\a r < W�W 3B5 ] 3 U =XD�365 ] <^<\f¸3B5C9;74.Yc>3�9\p>52363 ½W 36=�7%= U W�E 365@úà r ½ |�Ä;Å>|>Æ�Ä\Ç^� 9;=XD�.1=�fX9\527 E�F ,/3Ban36=�043"+�D�c;9\= ] 36D u 36023�9\5 ] [!?A54<¼23 ] 740+�p\36= ] FXÈ JÉsKM U =XDX3B5q+ u ?i+Ê<>54DX3B5�= U W�E 365q,/Ë Æ>Ì�� .Y040 U 36D E�F à T r È +�Í T ] <>=�7C5C9 ] 7q= U W ½E 365 w z}|\Æ�Ä\Ì ½ |�Î ½ r ½ Å�Ä\Ç�Î � +�= F <>f�.1=X.Y<>=X0 � jg=XDX.Y=Xp>0k9\=XD ] <>= ] _ U 04.Y<>=X0�<>5�543 ] < W�W 3B=XDg9;74.1<>=X03�µ^fX5236020436D�.1=)74[X.10 W 9;743652.h9\_b9\523�7C[X3Z9 U 7C[X<\5�9\=XD»DX<%=�<\7�=X3 ] 36020C9\52.1_ F 543�Ïg3 ] 7�7C[X<\043Z<\aº7C[�304fi<>=X02<>540 �

cV.

Page 7: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

���������������

������������� ������������������ ������������� �����!���"�

#%$ � ��& #'$ ��( �"��� $ & ���)��������*)��

d�+ x z}|>|>|

GIHKJLH/M�N/OQPSR���ÐT^]\� � sKM�N/Oq�\JoR�N�JÒÑ Ã u T JÉstx

d �ÐT^]\� � JLN T smJÉsyRKs à Mkw³rmM d)? R�smJLN�OQs à roH�N/M�PbMkO/x �roHKJLN à T Ã�+ r +/,�ùd xQM�w T rtJ à N/r à T

?A[ � , � � R�N�JÒÑ Ã u T JÉstxÓM�w d�+ TXT + roH�R T Ã sms T +/d H Ã u T s

,/.1523 ] 7436D E�Fi� ?A52<\an360204<>5 � 9;7C[X5 F = T¸� d ] � .1=�_13 F

+�0K.1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>=@3�µ^fX_1<VDX3B0�9 ] 54<>020�7C[�3 J =�7C3B54=X3�7k9\=XD�.1=�7C549\=X3�7C0 � .1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>=%543�7C52.13Bc;9\_Ô JLu�Õ 0 F 02743 W 0 W U 087 ] <>f¸3k�y.Y74[�74[X3 ] [g9;_1_13B=Xp>3k<\aA0 ] 9\_Y3 � H <Â��74<«fX52<}c^.YDX3¶0 ] 9\_19 E _Y3qfi3658an<>5 ½W 9\= ] 3�an<>5t549\fX.1D�_ F .1= ] 54369\04.Y=Xp�Dg9;7C9Z9\=XD'��<>54´�_Y<�9\DX0o.Y0 ] 52.Y74. ] 9;_i.Y=«7C[�3�DX3602.1p>=%<\aS=�3�µV7yp>36= ½36549;7C.Y<>=".1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>={543�7C52.13Bc;9\_®0 F 02743 W 0 � s [�.10kDX.102043B527:9�7C.1<\= 087 U D�.1360k0 ] 9\_19 E _13ZD�.1027454. E U 7C3BDJLu 9\5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 543B0q74[g9;7k=X<;7�<\=X_ F fX54<}cV.1DX3�l U . ] ´»543602f¸<\=X043 E U 7�9\_Y04< W 9;.1=�7:9\.Y="9 ]6] 36f�7C9 E _Y3543�7C52.13Bc;9\_�9 ]B]6U 549 ] F � M U 5¶DX.1087C54. E U 7436D�9\5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 52360Z3�µ^fX_Y<>.Y7�fg9\549\_1_Y36_Y.10 W .1=�.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=543�7C52.13Bc;9\_Ö<>=�9 ] _ U 087C3B5m<\a®fX9\5C9\_Y_13B_ JLu 023658c>36520 U 02.1=Xp�0 F^W�W 3B7C52. ] W U _Y74.1fX52< ] 360402<>540 � 9\=XD U 023fg9\587C.19\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=�9\=XD�0236_13 ] 74.1<>=9\0��t3B_1_o9;0 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�0236_13 ] 74.1<>=�74<»543B027C52. ] 77C[�3q023�9\5 ] [�74<©9Z0 W 9\_Y_Ifi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3k<\aeDg9�7:9��y[X.1_Y3 W 9\.1=�7:9;.1=X.Y=Xp�543�7C52.13Bc;9\_I9 ]6]BU 5C9 ] F �� 3ºjg52027¢.1=�c>3B027C.Yp�9;743 U 02.1=XpKfg9\587C.19\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=�an<>5 JLu 0 F 087C3 W 0 � � 3¹3�µ�9 W .1=�3

l U 365 F _Y< ] 9\_1.¾7 F .1=�523�9\_�0 F 02743 W 0 � [X<}�×7C<�0236_13 ] 7@9�fX9\5274.h9\_y543BfX_1. ] 9 E 9\043BD�<>=�543B_13�c\9;= ] 3 �

c^.Y.

Page 8: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

[X<}�!74<�_1<�9\D ½ E 9\_19\= ] 3 E 3B7É��3636=�543BfX_1. ] 9\0m9;=XD%7C[X3k<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 9\0o�t3B_1_S9\0 U f¸Dg9�7C.1=�p<}c>3B54[X369\DX0�9\=�D)02745C9;7436p>.Y360 � M U 5�52360 U _Y740�02[X<}��7C[g9;7y74[X36523¶3�µ^.Y027C0K0 U À ] .13B=�7�l U 365 F _Y< ] 9\_1.¾7 F7C<�¼ U 027C.¾a F fg9;527C.19\_i5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>=«an<>5t.1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=©523B7C52.13�c\9;_ � M U 5mfX52<>fi<>043BD�5236fX_Y. ] 9¶043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=9\_Yp><>54.¾7C[ W 3Bظ3 ] 74.Yc\36_ F 043B_13 ] 7C0e5236_Y3Bc;9\=�7Afg9\587C.19\_�5436f�_1. ] 9\0 � 9\=XDZ.Y0®.1=�3�µ^f¸3B=X04.¾c>3o74</. W fX_13 W 3B=�7 �M U 5t3�cV.1DX3B= ] 3k9\_Y04<�.1=XDX. ] 9;74360º7C[g9�7ofg9\587C.19\_�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>=©9 ] [X.13�c>3B0 E 3�747C3B5tfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�7C[X9\=] 9 ] [X.1=Xp¶l U 3654.Y360 �XE 3 ] 9 U 043�74[X3/543BfX_1. ] 9q0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=%9\_1p\<>54.¾7C[ W jX=XDX0o02. W .1_h9;54.Y7 F¶E 3�7É�t3B36=@=X<>= ½.1D�36=�7C. ] 9\_Il U 3B54.Y360 � 9;=XD�74[ U 0�.Y= ] 523�9\02360y< E 023658c>36D)_1< ] 9\_Y.Y7 F �� 3 U 043"9�c;9\_Y.1Dg9�7C36DÙ04. W U _h9�7C<>5Z7C<�f¸3B52an<>5 W 9�DX3B7C9\.1_Y36D�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3)3Bc;9\_ U 9;74.1<>=³<\a

DX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D JLu 9;5 ] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 52360 � � 3¶3Úµ�f�_1<>523¶[X<}� E 36027�7C< E U .1_YD�fg9;5C9\_Y_136_ JLu 023652c\36520 U 04.Y=Xp0 FVW�W 3�7C52. ] W U _Y7C.YfX54< ] 3B0402<>540 � 3Bc;9\_ U 9;743�7C[X3�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3/<\abfg9\587C.19\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=«543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=9\=XD ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 9\=�D ] < W fg9\523t7C[X3mfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3o<\aifg9\587C.19\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=¶543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=�y.Y74[ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%fg9\587C.Y74.1<>=�.1=XpZ9;0o�t3B_1_S9\0 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=%0236_13 ] 74.1<>= � +o7K_19\027m��3�f�54360236=�7�3�µ^f¸3B54. ½W 36=�7C0�an<\5�023�9\5 ] [X.1=Xp'9©7C3B5C9 E�F 7C3�<;aA7C3�µV7 � � 3¶9\_102<«3ÚµX9 W .Y=X3¶fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 ] [g9;=Xp>360/�y[�36=��3 U 023�an3B��365K_h9\52p>3/043B52c\36540 � a¦9;027C3B5y043658c>3B540 � 9\=XD�_1<\=Xp>365tl U 3654.Y360 �M U 5«52360 U _Y7C0�04[�<Â�×74[g9;7 E 3 ] 9 U 023 JLu 0 F 02743 W 0'[g9�c>3�[X3�9�c F ] < W f U 7C9;7C.Y<>=g9\_y9\=�D J È M

_1<>9\DX0 � 7C[�3/= U W�E 365o<\a r ? R 0 � DX.Y04´�0 � 9\=XD'74[X54369\DX0 W U 027 E 3 ] 9\543�a U _1_ F©E 9\_h9\= ] 36D©7C<Z9 ] [�.13Bc\30 ] 9\_h9 E _13%fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 � M U 5�543B0 U _¾7C0�04[X<}�Û7C[g9;7�fg9;527C.19\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>=�.Y0 W UX] [W <>543m3�ØÖ3 ] 7C.¾c>3K9;7ºDX3 ] 523�9\02.1=Xpk7C[X3yl U 3B5 F 543B04fi<>=X023y74. W 3t7C[X9\= ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�fg9\587C.Y74.1<>=�.1=XpKan<>5º9_1<>9\DX36D%0 F 027C3 W�� 3Bc>3B=��y.¾7C[ ����Üt��� 543B04< U 5 ] 3B0 � 9\=XD%.¾7o5236l U .152360m<>=�_ F©W <VDX36087ml U 365 F _Y< ] 9\_1.¾7 F �M U 5`543B0 U _¾7C0b9\_Y04<m04[�<Â��7C[g9�7Sfg9\5274.h9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=/5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=/f¸3B52an<>5 W 0 E 3�747C3B5`7C[g9\= ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=��y[X3B=74[X36523%3�µ^.1087C0�36=�< U p>[�l U 3B5 F _Y< ] 9\_1.¾7 F>� 9;=XD�.Y7Zfi3658an<>5 W 0���<>52043%�y[X36=7C[�3] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�9 ]6] 36020q.Y0�a¦9\.Y54_ F U =X.¾an<>5 W 9;a�74365 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�0236_13 ] 74.1<>= � w .1=g9;_1_ F < U 5�52360 U _Y740/04[X<}�7C[X9;7y543BfX_1. ] 9�9\=XD ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=%0236_13 ] 74.1<>= ] 9;= E 3 ] < W�E .1=X3BD@74<�fX54<}cV.1DX3kl U . ] ´'543B04fi<>=X043k7C. W 3an<>5�9©7C3B5C9 E�F 7C3�<;aA7C3�µV7 � r [g9\=Xp\360/<\aº0 F 027C3 W ] <>=�jgp U 5C9;74.1<>=X0�DX<'=X<;7/04.Yp>=X.¾j ] 9\=�74_ F ] [g9\=�p>37C[�3�5236_h9�7C.Yc\3�. W f�54<}c>3 W 3B=�740¢D U 3¹74<�fg9;527C.19\_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=k543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=k9;=XD ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=k0236_13 ] 74.1<>= �9\_¾7C[X< U p>['7C[X3 F 9;ظ3 ] 7y74[X3q9 E 04<\_ U 743�543602f¸<\=X043k7C. W 3 �

cV.1.Y.

Page 9: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

�©����� $·# � $ &v���)&v��

Ý/ÞXß�à

á'â�ã�ä"åqæèç¹é/ê{ë%ì�é�ä)íZî ���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q���q�>ï

á%ð©îIí�ñ%á'â¶í ���q���q�q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q���eïSò¦ò

çºóÂîIíôå�õöíoá%ðZçºé�î �q�q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q�Q÷Sòøò¦ò

çºóÂîIíôå�õöõoó}ë@ù%ñ'é�î �q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q���¹÷Iï

â¶ú Þ�ûbü}à�ý

þgÿ ó6ä�í�ñ'å�ê@ù)â¶í�ó}å�ä ���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q���q� þ

z � z s [X3q?A54< E _Y3 W <;a T^] 9\_13�.Y= J =�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>= u 3B7454.Y3Bc;9\_ �q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q���q� zz � Ä u 3B04369\5 ] [ T^U W�W 9\5 F �q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q���q� Ä

z � Ä � z ?¢9\5C9;_1_13B_ J =�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>= u 3�7C52.13Bc;9\_ U 04.Y=Xp T FVW©W 3B7454. ] d U _Y74.1fX52< ] 360402<>540 �q� Çz � Ä � Ä ?¢9\5274.h9\_ r <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= u 3BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= �k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q���q� Îz � Ä � Ç r <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= T 3B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q���q���z � Ä � Ë TV] 9\_19 E _13/,/.1027454. E U 7C3BD@+�5 ] [�.Y7C3 ] 7 U 543B0 �q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q���q���

z � Ç u 3B04369\5 ] [ r <>=�7C54. E U 74.1<>=X0 �q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q���q���z � Ë T 7C5 UX] 7 U 543k<\ab7C[�3�,/.Y040236527C9;7C.Y<>= �q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q���q� Ì

�Iÿ ñ'é�ç¹ákí�é�ê æèå�ñ'ã �k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q���q���Ä � z J =�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>= u 3�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_ � 9 ] ´�p>54< U =XD ���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q���q� |

Ä � z � z u 3B7454.Y3Bc;9\_Sd�<VDX3B_10 ���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q���q� |Ä � z � Ä J =�DX3�µ^.1=�p ���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� z}ÇÄ � z � Ç Ãeظ3 ] 7C.Yc\36=X3B040 �q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� z}Ç

Ä � Ä ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3k<\a®,/.1027454. E U 7C3BD J =�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>= u 3B7454.Y3Bc;9\_ �q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� z ËÄ � Ç ÃeØÖ3 ] 7C.¾c>3B=X36020�<\a®,/.1087C54. E U 7436D J =�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\= u 3�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_ �q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� z �

Ä � Ç � z + U 7C< W 9;74. ] r <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= T 3B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= ���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� z �

.¾µ

Page 10: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

Ä � Ç � Ä u 360 U _Y7�d�3654p\.1=Xp �q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ä\Å

Ä � Ë ?®9\549\_1_Y36_ J =�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>= u 3B7454.Y3Bc;9\_ ���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ä\ÅÄ � Î ,�9;7:9 u 36f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>= �k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ä\Ç

Ä � Î � z u 36f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>= T 745C9;7436p>.Y360 ���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ä\ÇÄ � Î � Ä T 3652c\365 T 36_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= �q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ä Ë

�Iÿ î��{îIí�é/ì á'ñ'â��ó6íqé�â¶í¶ù%ñ'é�î ���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� ��Ç � z r _1.Y36=�7C0 ���q���q�q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ä\|Ç � Ä r <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0m9\=XD J = Á U 3B5 F T 3B52c\36540 �q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ä\|Ç � Ç r <>=X=X3 ] 74.1<>= � 54<\´\365 �q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ç>Å

Ç � Ç � z r <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= T 3B_13 ] 7C<\5 �q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ç>ÅÇ � Ç � Ä u 36f�_1. ] 9 T 36_Y3 ] 7C<>5 �q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ç�zÇ � Ç � Ç J =�74365C9 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 �q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ç�z

�Sÿ Ý á'ñkíqó6á%ç�â�å�ç�çºé�â¶í�ó}å�ä ñ'é Ý çºóÂâ¶ákí�ó}å�ä ���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� � �Ë � z + ]B] 36020 r [X9\5C9 ] 7C3B54.1087C. ] 0y.1= u 3�9\_ JLu T F 087C3 W 0 �q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ç>Ç

Ë � z � z u 9;74.1<Z<\a Á U 365 F ?A54< ] 360204.Y=Xp«9;=XD),/< ]6U W 3B=�7y+ ]6] 36040 �k���q���q�q��� Ç�ÎË � z � Ä Á U 3B5 F P < ] 9\_Y.Y7 F �q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ç �Ë � z � Ç M c\3654_19\f@<\a Á U 3654.Y360 M c>3B5 s . W 3 �k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ç>|

Ë � Ä s [X3q?®9\587C.19\_ u 36fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\='+�5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 543 �k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ë ÄË � Ç ?®9\587C.19\_ u 36fX_Y. ] 9 T 36_13 ] 74.1<>= � 9\0236D�<>= u 3B_13�c\9;= ] 3 ���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ë>Ë

Ë � Ç � z u 9\=X´�.Y=Xp�?®9\587C.h9;_ u 36fX_Y. ] 9;0o�y.Y7C[%74[X3 J =�an365236= ] 3 N 3�7É�t<\54´�d�<VDX36_ ��� Ë ÎË � Ç � Ä Ã®µ^fi3654. W 3B=�7:9\_ T 3B7474.1=Xp\0 ���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Î\ÅË � Ç � Ç r < W fg9;54.1=�p u 9\=�´V.Y=Xp w U = ] 74.1<>=�0 �k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Î ËË � Ç � Ë Ãeظ3 ] 7C.Yc\36=X3B040K�y.Y7C[ u 36fX_Y. ] 9;7C3BD Á U 3B54.Y360 ���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Î\ÌË � Ç � Î Ãeظ3 ] 7C.Yc\36=X3B040K�y.Y7C[ R =X543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D Á U 3652.1360 �q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Æ�ÄË � Ç � Æ TVU W©W 9\5 F �k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Æ �

Ë � Ë P <�9\D � 9\_19\= ] .Y=Xp ���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Æ>ÌË � Î T fg9 ] 3q9\=XD s . W 3 M c>3652[X3�9;DX0�an<>5o74[X3 u 3BfX_1. ] 9 T 3B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�,�9;7:9 E 9\043 ���q�q��� Æ>|

Ë � Î � z T fg9 ] 3 M c>3B54[X369\D �q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Æ>|Ë � Î � Ä s . W 3 M c\3654[�3�9\D �q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q����� Å

Ë � Æ R fiDg9;74.1=Xp ���q�q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q����� ÄË � Æ � z r <\027C0man<>5 R f¸Dg9�7C.1=�p u 3BfX_1. ] 9\0 �q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q����� ÄË � Æ � Ä r <\027C0man<>5 R f¸Dg9�7C.1=�p�7C[X3 u 36fX_Y. ] 9 T 36_13 ] 74.1<>=�,�9;7C9 E 9\023 ���q���q�q����� ËË � Æ � Ç R f¸DX9;7C.Y=Xp T 7C549;7C3Bp>.13B0 �q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q����� Î

µ

Page 11: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

Ë ��� T^U W�W 9;5 F ���q�q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q����� Æ

�Iÿ í���é îÖóBì-ù@ç¹ákí�ó}å�ä ìöå�ê%é�ç �q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� ��Î � z T F 02743 W d�369\0 U 523 W 36=�7C0�9\=XD Ñ 9\_Y.1Dg9;74.1<>= �k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q����� |

Î � z � z Á U 3B5 F Ãec;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>= s . W 3 �q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ì>ÅÎ � z � Ä ,/< ]6U W 3B=�7 u 3B7454.Y3Bc;9\_ s . W 3 ���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ì�ÄÎ � z � Ç N 3B7É��<>54´ s . W 3 ���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ì>ÇÎ � z � Ë r <\=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= � 54<>´;365 s . W 3 �q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ì>ÇÎ � z � Î Ñ 9;_1.1DX9;7C.Y<>=«<\ab7C[�3 Á U 3B5 F Ãec;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>=�d�<VDX36_ �q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ì�Î

Î � Ä r <>=�jgp U 5C9;74.1<>=�?¢9\5C9 W 3B7436520 �q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� |>Å

�Iÿ Ý é�ñ%õmåZñ%ìvá%ä"â�é�é���á%ç¹ù@ákí�ó}å�ä å�õvå�ù%ñèê%ó}î`íqñ'óBðZù�íqé�êèóBä��õmåZñ%ìváqíqóÂå�ä ñ'é�í�ñ«óBé��/á%ç!î��{îIí�é�ì ���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q����� Æ � z ?®9\549\_1_Y36_ J =�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>= u 3B7454.Y3Bc;9\_ R 04.1=�p T FVW�W 3�7C52. ] d U _Y7C.YfX54< ] 3B0402<>540 �q�q��� |>Ì

Æ � z � z s [�543�9;DX.1=Xp �k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Å\ÅÆ � z � Ä s [�3 H 9\54D^�o9\523 � 9\_h9\= ] .1=�pZ+ ] 7 �k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Å\ÆÆ � z � Ç ?¢9\5274.Y74.1<>=X.Y=Xp Ñ 3B540 U 0 u 36fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= ���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z>z\zÆ � z � Ë TVU W©W 9\5 F �k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z>z �

Æ � Ä ?®9\587C.19\_ r <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= u 36f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>={.Y=»9@,/.1027454. E U 7C3BD J =�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\= u 3�7C52.13Bc;9\_T F 02743 W ���q���q�q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z>z�Ì

Æ � Ä � z Ñ 9;5 F .1=XpZ74[X3q,/.102745C9 ] 7C.Y=XpZ?¢3B5 ] 36=�7:9\p\3 �q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z>z�|Æ � Ä � Ä ?¢9\5274.h9\_ u 3BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= Ñ 3B540 U 0 r <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=%?¢9\5274.Y74.1<>=X.Y=Xp �k���q���q�q� zÂÄVzÆ � Ä � Ç Ñ 9;5 F .1=XpZ74[X3 u 3BfX_1. ] 9;74.1=XpZ?b365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3 �q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� zÂÄVzÆ � Ä � Ë Ñ 9;5 F .1=XpZ74[X3 r <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= T . ¿ 3 ���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� zÂÄ;ÇÆ � Ä � Î u 36f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>= H .136549\5 ] [ F �q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� zÂÄ;ÇÆ � Ä � Æ TVU W©W 9\5 F �k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� zÂÄ �

Æ � Ç r <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= T 36_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�.Y=�9�,/.Y027454. E U 7C3BD J =^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>= u 3B7454.13�c;9\_ T F 02743 W �q� zÂÄ �Æ � Ç � z Ñ 9;5 F .1=Xpk7C[�3 r <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�+ ]6] 36020 T ´\3���9\=XD©74[X3 T 36_Y3 ] 74.1<>=«?¢3B5 ] 3B=�7 ½

9;p>3 ���q�q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� zÂÄ;ÌÆ � Ç � Ä Ñ 9;5 F .1=XpZ74[X3 N U W�E 365m<;a r <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 �q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Ç>ÄÆ � Ç � Ç r <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= T 3B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= Ñ 36520 U 0�?®9;527C.19\_ r <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= u 36fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\= �q�q� z}Ç\ÇÆ � Ç � Ë TVU W©W 9\5 F �k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Ç>Î

Æ � Ë T^U W�W 9;5 F ���q�q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Ç\Æ

¸ÿ í�åqævá'ñ%ê îÖé�á'ñ'â��ó6ä»ë á í�é/ñ%á%ð���íqé å�õ í�é��@í �q�k���q���q�q� þ�� �

µ^.

Page 12: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

�^� z s [X3 T . ¿ 360y<\a u 36f�_1. ] 9\0 � u 3BfX_1. ] 9 T 36_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�,�9�7:9 E 9;043 � 9;=XD r <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= T 3 ½_13 ] 7C.Y<>=@,�9;7C9 E 9\02360 �k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Ç\|

�^� Ä ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 R 02.1=Xp Á U 3652.13B0y�y.¾7C[�9\=@+�c\36549\p>3q<\a s ��< s 365 W 0 ���q���q�q� z Ë Å�^� Ç ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3��y.Y74[ P 9\52p>365y,/.Y04´�0 �q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z Ë\Ë�^� Ë ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3��y.Y74[ w 9\087C3B5 T 3658c>36520/9\=�D N 3B7É��<>54´ �q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z Ë Î�^� Î ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3��y.Y74[ P <>=�p>365 Á U 3B54.13B0 ���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z Ë ��^� Æ T^U W�W 9;5 F ���q�q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z Ë |

�Iÿ â�å�ä"â¶ç¹ù{îÖó}å�ä"î �q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� þ����Ì � z T^U W�W 9;54.13B0 ���q�q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� zÂÎ;ÅÌ � Ä r <>=�7C52. E U 74.1<>=�0 �q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� zÂÎ;ÇÌ � Ç w U 7 U 523 � <\54´ �q�q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� zÂÎ Ë

á ÝqÝ é�ä�ê%óÂâ�é�î

á ÿ í�ñ'éqâôâ�å�ç¹ç¹é�â¶íqóÂå�ä»î �q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� þ���+ � z ,�9;7:9 T < U 5 ] 360 �q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� zÂÎ �+ � Ä T 7:9�7C.1087C. ] 0o<\a syu à r�r <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0 ���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Æ\Å

ð ÿ á%â�â�é�îbî³çoå'ë á%ä)á%ç��{îÖó}î �q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� þ��`þ��� z s [X3 syH/M d�+ T P <>p �q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Æ^z

��� z � z Á U 3B5 F P < ] 9\_Y.Y7 F �q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Æ^z��� z � Ä ,/< ]6U W 3B=�7y+ ]6] 36040�?®9;727C3B54=X0 ���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Æ>Î

��� Ä s [X3qîµ ] .Y743 P <>p ���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Æ\|

ð�óBðZç¹ó}å'ë%ñ'á Ý ��� �q�q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� þ���

µ�.Y.

Page 13: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

������� $Ù# �«������"�

í Þ��! ¦à Ý/ÞXß�à

Ë � z u 9�7C.1<\0o<\a¢l U 3654.Y360�9\=XD@DX< ]6U W 36=�740�.Y='7C[X3 syH/M d�+ T _Y<>p � �q�k���q���q�q��� Ç>Æ

Ë � Ä Á U 365 F _1< ] 9\_Y.Y7 F .1=%74[X3k_1<>p>0 � �q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ç>Ì

Ë � Ç Á U 365 F <}c>3652_h9\f�<}c>3B5y74. W 3�.1='74[X3 syH/M d�+ T _1<>p �Ù�q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ë Å

Ë � Ë T 7:9�7C.1087C. ] 0o<\a®fg9\587C.h9;_Ö543BfX_1. ] 9\0 �q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Î\Ç

Ë � Î r < W fg9\54.Y=Xp'549\=X´�.1=Xp%a U = ] 7C.Y<>=X0 U 02.1=Xp@02[X<>527kl U 3B54.Y360k<>=»7C[X3 Ä O � syu à rÄ#"�Ç ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= Ô 5236fX_Y. ] 9\0 E U .Y_Y7o�y.¾7C[%7C<>f Ä\Å>Å D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0 Õ �q�k���q���q�q��� Î>Î

Ë � Æ ÃeØÖ3 ] 7C.¾c>3B=X36020/<\aADX.¾ØÖ3B543B=�7�5C9;=X´�.1=Xp�a U = ] 74.1<>=�0 U 02.1=Xp©04[X<\527�l U 3654.Y360�<>=�74[X3Ä O � syu à r Ä$"kÇ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= Ô 5436f�_1. ] 9\0 E U .1_Y7t�y.Y7C[@7C<\f Ä;Å>Å DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 Õ ��� Î �

Ë ��� u 3BfX_1. ] 9�0236_13 ] 74.1<>=%an<>5m5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36D@l U 3B54.13B0 ���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Î\|

Ë � Ì ÃeØÖ3 ] 7C.¾c>3B=X36020q<;a�5236fX_Y. ] 9©043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>={an<>5�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3BD»l U 3652.1360 Ô 3�9 ] ["7454.19\_¢[X9\0|>| ¼ U DXp>3BD�l U 3B54.Y360 Õ �k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Æ�z

Ë � | u 3BfX_1. ] 9�0236_13 ] 74.1<>=%an<>5 U =�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3BD@l U 3654.Y360 �q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Æ>Ç

Ë � z}Å ÃeØÖ3 ] 7C.¾c>3B=X36020�<\a U =X5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36D@l U 3B54.13B0 Ô 3�9 ] [@7C52.h9\_¸[g9\0 Î\Å l U 3652.13B0 Õ ���q�q��� Æ>Æ

Ë � z>z T fg9 ] 3k<Âc\3652[X3�9\D�an<>5o7C[�3q5236fX_Y. ] 9�0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=@Dg9�7:9 E 9;043 ���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Æ>|

Ë � zÂÄ s . W 3�<}c\3654[�3�9\D»an<>5K04369\5 ] [X.Y=Xp«74[X3�543BfX_1. ] 9�0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=)Dg9;7C9 E 9\023¶an<>5y7C[X3 Ä\ÅO ��] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= Ô 043 ] <>=�DX0 Õ �¢�q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q����� z

Ë � z}Ç R fiDg9;74.1=Xp�74. W 3�an<>5m543BfX_1. ] 9\0o�y.¾7C[@DX.¾ØÖ3B5436=�7K04. ¿ 3B0 Ô [X< U 520 Õ � �q�k���q���q�q����� Ç

Ë � z Ë R fiDg9;74.1=Xp�74. W 3�an<>5m543BfX_1. ] 9Z043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=@Dg9;7C9 E 9\023 Ô W .Y= U 7C3B0 Õ � �k���q���q�q����� Ë

Î � z s 3B5 W 3�c;9\_ U 9�7C.1<\='7C. W 3�c;9\_Y.1Dg9;74.1<>= �^�q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ì>Æ

Î � Ä Á U 365 F%W <VDX3B_Öc;9\_1.YDg9;7C.Y<>= �-���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ì �

µ^.1.Y.

Page 14: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

Î � Ç ,/.1087C54. E U 74.1<>='<;a U =�DX3652360274. W 9;7C3BD�l U 3B54.Y360 �©���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ì �

Î � Ë ?¢3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3�DX.Yظ365236= ] 3t<\aX9�c>36549\p>3¹543B04fi<>=X043¹7C. W 3B0 E 3B7É��363B=�7C[X3¹. W fX_Y3 W 36= ½7:9;74.1<>=@9;=XD�02. W U _h9;74<>5 �©���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ì>Ì

Π� Πr <>=�jgp U 5C9;74.1<>=@fg9;5C9 W 3B7436540 ���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� |�z

Î � Æ s [X3�c;9\_ U 3B0 U 043BD�.Y=@74365 W 0yfi365ml U 365 F � �k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� |�Ä

Æ � z r <>=�jgp U 5C9;74.1<>=@fg9;5C9 W 3B7436540oan<\5mfg9\5C9;_1_13B_Ö3Úµ�fi3652. W 36=�7C0 �¢�q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� |>|

Æ � Ä r <>=�jgp U 5C9;74.1<>=@fg9;5C9 W 3B7436540oan<\5m5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>='3Úµ�fi3652. W 36=�7C0 �����q�k���q���q�q� z>z�|

Æ � Ç r <>=�jgp U 5C9;74.1<>=@fg9;5C9 W 3B7436540oan<\5 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=@3�µ^f¸3B54. W 3B=�740 � ���q�q� zÂÄ;Ì

Æ � Ë s [X3'fi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3%<\a ] < W©W 9\=XD�0q74[g9;7�p\<^3B0¶7C<)74[X3 W <>027�an543Bl U 36=�7C_ F U 0236D] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= ���q�q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� zÂÄ;|

�^� z r <>=�jgp U 5C9;74.1<>=@fg9;5C9 W 3B7436540oan<\5o7C36549 E�F 7C3q3�µ^f¸3B54. W 3B=�740 �q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Ç\|

�^� Ä s [X3k543BfX_1. ] 9Z04. ¿ 3 E 9\0236D�<>=%7C[X3qîµ ] .Y743k_1<>p �q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z Ë Å

+ � z s [X3 syu à r�r <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 �q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Æ\Å

��� z s [X3k027C9;7C.Y027C. ] 0oan52< W 7C[�3 syH�M d�+ T _1<>p Ô J8Õ �q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Æ\Ç

��� Ä s [X3k027C9;7C.Y027C. ] 0oan52< W 7C[�3 syH�M d�+ T _1<>p Ô J4J8Õ �q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Æ Ë

��� Ç s [X3k027C9;7C.Y027C. ] 0oan52< W 7C[�3 syH�M d�+ T _1<>p Ô J4J2J8Õ �q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Æ\Æ

��� Ë s [X3k027C9;7C.Y027C. ] 0oan52< W 7C[�3 syH�M d�+ T _1<>p Ô Ñ/J8Õ �q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Æ �

��� Î s [X3k027C9;7C.Y027C. ] 0oan52< W 7C[�3 syH�M d�+ T _1<>p Ô ÑkÕ �q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Æ\Ì

��� Æ ,/< ]BU W 36=�7K9 ]6] 36020�087:9;74.10274. ] 0oan54< W 74[X3 syH/M d�+ T _Y<>p �q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z � Å

����� s [X3k027C9;7C.Y027C. ] 0oan52< W 7C[�3�îµ ] .¾7C3k_1<\p �A���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z � z

µ^.Yc

Page 15: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

������� $Ù# # ��²��!���"�

õ ò ß�%SýÂà Ý/ÞXß�à

Ä � z ,/< ]BU W 36=�7y543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_I.Y=�an365236= ] 3k=X3B7É��<>54´ �k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� z>z

Ç � z +�5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 543B0Kan<\5mDX.1087C54. E U [email protected]=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>=«523B7C52.13�c\9;_ �®�q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ä\Ì

Ë � z îµ ] 3652f�7C0yan54< W 7C[X3 syH/M d�+ T 9;=XD)îµ ] .¾7C3k_1<\p>0 �Ó�q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ç�Î

Ë � Ä s [X3k543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=%[X.Y36549\5 ] [ F � �q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ë Ç

Ë � Ç s [X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%543�7C52.13Bc;9\_Ö.1=�an3B5436= ] 3k=X3B7É��<>52´ � �q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ë Î

Ë � Ë s [X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%5C9;=X´�.1=XpZa U = ] 7C.Y<>[email protected]= J = Á U 365 F ���q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ë Æ

Ë � Î s [X3k543BfX_1. ] 9Z043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%a U = ] 74.1<>= � �q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ë Ì

Ë � Æ s [X3{5236_h9�7C.1<\=X04[X.Yf E 3B7É��363B=�DX< ]BU W 36=�7«an5236l U 36= ] .13B0%.1=ÙDX.Yظ365236=�7'5236fX_Y. ] 9;0�y.Y74[�D�.Yظ36543B=�7�02. ¿ 360 ���q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ë |

Î � z Á U 365 F 3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>='7C. W .Y=Xp¶c;9\_ U 360 Ô 043 ] <>=XDX0 Õ � �q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ì�z

Î � Ä N 3�7É�t<>52´'7C. W 3�c;9\_ U 360 Ô 043 ] <>=XDX0 Õ � �q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ì>Ç

Î � Ç r <>=X=X3 ] 74.1<>= E 54<\´\365m74. W 3�c;9\_ U 3B0 Ô 043 ] <>=�DX0 Õ ���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� Ì Ë

Î � Ë Ñ 9\_1.YDg9;74.1<>=©<\a¢74[X3kf¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3 U 02.1=Xp�fg9\587C.19\_Ö5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\= ���q�k���q���q�q��� Ì>|

Î � Î Á U 365 F 7C3B5 W an5236l U 36= ] F DX.1087C52. E U 74.1<>=�0 �t�q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� |>Ç

Î � Æ Á U 365 F 7C3B5 W an5236l U 36= ] F DX.1087C52. E U 74.1<>=�0t�y.Y74[�.Y= ] 523�9\02.1=Xp ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=«04. ¿ 3 ���q��� | Ë

Æ � z s [X3kfg9\549\_1_Y36_ J = Á U 365 F 023658c>365 �q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q��� |>|

Æ � Ä ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3q9\0o7C[�3q= U W¶E 3B5K<;a¢74[X54369\DX0K.1= ] 543�9;04360 Ô DX.102´ E <;747C_Y36=X3 ] ´ Õ � � z}Å^z

µVc

Page 16: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

Æ � Ç ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�9\0�7C[X3/= U W¶E 3B5o<\a`7C[�543�9;DX0o.1= ] 54369\043B0 Ô r ? R E <\7474_13B=X3 ] ´ Õ � � z}Å\Ç

Æ � Ë ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�9\0m7C[X3q= U W�E 365K<\a®74[X54369\DX0K.1= ] 543�9;04360 Ô r ? R 0�9\=XD�DX.102´�0�9\523�t3B_1_ E 9\_h9\= ] 36D Õ � ���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Å Ë

Æ � Î ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�9\0¹7C[X3�[g9\54D^�o9\523 ] <\=�jgp U 549;7C.Y<>= ] [g9;=Xp>360oan<\5o9¶Ë O �·] <>_1_Y3 ]�½7C.Y<>= ���q���q���q�q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Å �

Æ � Æ J = ] 523�9\02.1=Xpq7C[X3K= U W�E 365¹<\aID�.104´�0ºc>3B540 U 0o.1= ] 54369\04.Y=Xpq74[X3KDg9;7:9k04. ¿ 3Kf¸3B5�D�.104´9\0o7C[�3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=%04. ¿ 3k.1= ] 543�9;04360 � �q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z>z�Å

Æ ��� ?®9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xp�c>36520 U 0ya U _Y_I543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=«an<\5y9 z}Æ O ��] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �º�k���q���q�q� z>z�Ç

Æ � Ì ?®9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xp�c>36520 U 0Kfg9\587C.19\_I543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=©an<>5y9 z}Æ O ��] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= ���q���q�q� z>z�Æ

Æ � | Ñ 9\5 F .Y=Xp�7C[X3kDX.Y02745C9 ] 7C.1=�p�fi365 ] 3B=�7C9\p>3 ��q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� zÂÄ;Å

Æ � z}Å Ñ 9\5 F .Y=Xp�7C[X3k5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=%f¸3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3 � �q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� zÂÄ\Ä

Æ � z>z Ñ 9\5 F .Y=Xp�7C[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=%02. ¿ 3 ���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� zÂÄ Ë

Æ � zÂÄ ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3��y.Y74[�9Z[X.Y36549\5 ] [ F <\a¢543BfX_1. ] 9\0 � �q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� zÂÄ;Æ

Æ � z}Ç ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3º�y.Y7C[ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�0236_13 ] 74.1<>=kan<>5 Ä>Î\Æ O � <\a�Dg9;7:9y<>= Ì 023658c>36520 ��� z}Ç^z

Æ � z Ë Ñ 9\5 F .Y=Xp�7C[X3k= U W�E 365y<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0tan<\5 Ä>Î\Æ O � <\a¢Dg9;7C9Z<>= Ì 023652c\36520 �m�q� z}Ç>Ä

Æ � zÂÎ r <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\='043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�c\36520 U 0Kfg9\587C.h9;_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>='5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\= � �k���q���q�q� z}Ç\Ç

Æ � z}Æ r <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=©c>36520 U 0mfX9\5274.h9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=Zan<>5 Ä>Î\Æ O � <>=Ì 043658c>3B540 ���q���q�q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z}Ç Ë

�^� z ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3¶�y[X3B=»04369\5 ] [X.Y=Xp@9©74365C9 E�F 743Z<\aA7C3Úµ^7 U 04.Y=Xp'l U 3652.13B0��y.Y74[»9\=9�c>36549\p>3k<\a Ä 74365 W 0 �!�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z Ë Ä

�^� Ä ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3��y[X36=�04369\5 ] [�.1=Xp©9�7436549 E�F 743k<\a¢743�µV7 U 04.Y=Xp�_h9\52p>365oD�.104´�0 �q�q� z Ë\Ë

�^� Ç ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3t�y[X3B=�043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xpq9�7C36549 E�F 7C3m<\a�7C3ÚµV7 U 04.Y=Xp�a¦9\087C365A023658c>36520¹9\=XD=X3B7É��<>52´ �q���q�q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z Ë Æ

�^� Ë ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3¶�y[X3B="043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp�9©7C3B5C9 E�F 7C3Z<\aº743�µV7 U 04.Y=Xp%9\="9�c\365C9;p>3Z<\a Ì7C3B5 W 0 �q���q���q�q���k�q���q���q�q���q���q�k���q�q���q���q�q���q�k���q���q�q� z Ë Ì

µVcV.

Page 17: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

���v�'&����)� (

��&v��� $ !�v����� $ &

(*)+( �-,�./&10�243657.!8 2*9»�;:=<>57.@?+A �BA�9C2*0 8D<FE�?G24A �H.IE�0 ?7.=JK<>5J =�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\= u 3B7454.Y3Bc;9\_ Ô JLu�Õ .Y0 ] <>= ] 3B54=X3BD��y.Y74[¶_1< ] 9�7C.1=�pKD�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0®5236_Y3Bc;9\=�7®74<�7C[�3t.1=^an<>5 ½W 9;7C.Y<>=%=X363BDX0�<;a U 0236540 � ,/.1087C54. E U [email protected]=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>=%543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_`fX52<}c^.YDX360K.1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>=%9 ]B] 3B0407C<k7C3ÚµV7 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0ADX.1087C52. E U 7436D�9 ] 54<>020t9k=X3B7É��<>52´ � +�0¹.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=¶3�µ^fX_1<VDX3B0�3�c>365 F �y[X36523 �.1= ] 54369\04.Y=Xp>_ F�W 9\= F c>3B=XDX<>520y9\=XD U 0236540tDX.1087C54. E U 743/9\=XD%023�9\5 ] [%7C[X3B.15t.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=Z74[X54< U p>[7C[�3 J =�7C3B54=X3�7y9\=XD©.1=�7C549\=X3B740 � s [X3�Dg9;7:9kc><>_ U W 3�9qDX.1087C54. E U 7436D JLu 0 F 087C3 W W U 087 ] <>fi3��y.Y74[.10�=X3�9;54.1=�p�7C[�3«7C3B5C9 E�F 7C3%_Y3Bc>3B_ � w <\5¶3�µ�9 W fX_Y3 � +�_Y7:9 Ñ .1087:9 � 9���3 E 04369\5 ] [3B=Xp>.1=�3 � ] _h9\. W 07C[X9;7�.¾7y04369\5 ] [X3B0/<}c>3B5 z Ë Å�W .1_1_Y.1<>=��t3 E fg9\p\360ML ËON � �y[X. ] [�.1=XDX. ] 9;74360m7C[X9;7�.¾7C0y04369\5 ] [)04fg9 ] 3.10�9\_Y543�9;D F 043Bc\36549\_®[ U =XD�5436D»p\.1p�9 E�F 7C3B0 � J =)7C[X.Y0�D�.1040236587:9;74.1<>= � ��3�.1=�c>3B0274.1p�9;743�D�.1027454. E U 7C3BD9\5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 543B0©74[g9;7©0 ] 9;_13%�y.Y74[·5C9;fX.1DX_ F .Y= ] 523�9\02.1=Xp Dg9;7C9�9\=XD³�t<\54´�_1<�9;DX0 � 9;=XD·=X<;7©<\=X_ FfX52<ÂcV.YDX3kl U . ] ´'523604fi<>=X023 E U 7�9\_102< W 9\.Y=�7C9\.1='9 ]6] 36f�7C9 E _13k523B7C52.13�c\9;_`9 ]6]BU 5C9 ] F �� [X3B=���3 a¦9 ] 3 9[ U p\3�= U W�E 365@<\aq7C3ÚµV7 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0%9\=XD�7C523 W 36=XDX< U 0���<>52´V_Y<�9\DX0 � 7C[�3jg52027q54369 ] 74.1<>= .10/74< U 023©_Y<\7C0�<;at[g9;54D��t9\543�543B04< U 5 ] 3B0 � R 04.Y=Xp�_1<\740�<\at[X9\54D��t9\523©523604< U 5 ] 360DX<V360�[X3B_1f»02<>_Yc\3�7C[X3ZfX52< E _Y3 W �¶� 3 ] 9 U 043�.1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>=�523B7454.13�c;9\_®.Y0k9\=».1=X[�36543B=�7C_ F fg9\549\_1_Y36_9\fXf�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>= � �t3 ] 9\=Ù3�µ^3 ]BU 7C3»l U 3B54.Y360«.Y=XDX3Bf¸3B=XDX36=�74_ F>� 9\=XD·��3 ] 9\=·DX.¾cV.1DX3�9 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=.1=�74<«043�c>3B5C9\_efX9\5274.Y7C.Y<>=X0�9\=XD{3Úµ^3 ]6U 7C3�9«l U 365 F <\= W U _¾7C.1f�_13kfg9\587C.Y74.1<>=�0�9;7K7C[�3�0C9 W 3�74. W 3 �s [X3B543Ban<\543 � ��3 W 9 F 36.¾7C[X3B5 U 043�9 W U _Y74.1fX52< ] 360204<>5e74<�.Y= ] 523�9\023y74[X3yfX54< ] 3B0402.1=Xp ] 9\fX9 E .1_Y.Y7 F <\a3�9 ] [�02.1=Xp>_Y3/043B52c\365 � <>5 U 043 W U _¾7C.1f�_13 W 9 ] [X.Y=X360m0 UX] [@7C[g9;7y369 ] [ W 9 ] [�.1=X3�fX52< ] 360204360�9Zfg9\587<\aÖDg9;7:9k9\=�D���<>54´�_Y<�9\DX0 � H <}�t3�c>3B5 U 02.1=Xpq_1<\740A<\a¸[g9\54D^�o9\523�523602< U 5 ] 360�DX<^3B0�=�<\7º=X3 ] 36020C9\52.1_ FfX52<^D U�] 3«[�.1p>[�f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 � 04.Y= ] 3%9�04.Y=Xp>_13 E <\7474_136=�3 ] ´ ] 9\=�DX36p>549\DX3©f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 � � 3=X3B36D'7C< ] 9\523Ba U _Y_ F�E 9\_19\= ] 3�7C[�3�[g9\52D��t9\543�9;=XD'04<;a�7É�o9\523/543B04< U 5 ] 3B0o7C<�3B=X0 U 543/fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3

z

Page 18: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

. W fX52<Âc\3 W 36=�7C0 � J ="9\DXDX.¾7C.Y<>= � .1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=�523B7454.13�c;9\_®.Y0/9«523604< U 5 ] 3 ½ .Y=�7C36=�04.Yc\3�9\fXfX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= �+Ê0 F 02743 W 7C[g9�7�023�9\5 ] [X360�[ U =XDX5236DX0�<;a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0�<>5�7C[g9;7q523 ] 3B.Yc\360 W .1_Y_1.Y<>=X0�<;ao543Bl U 36087C09'Dg9 F 9;_Y7C[�< U p>[{.¾7/<>=�_ F 043�9;5 ] [X3B0�9'0 W 9;_1_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= ] < U _1D{7C9\´\3 W .1= U 74360�74< ] < W fX_Y3B7C3¶9543Bl U 36087 � �y[X. ] [�.10 E 3 F <>=XD�<>=X_1.Y=X3 U 0236520QP�7C<>_Y365C9;= ] 3/an<>5o�t9\.¾7C.1=�p�an<>5y9Z543602f¸<\=X043 �u 36027454. ] 7C.Y=Xp�74[X3'023�9\5 ] [�7C<)74[X3 W <>027¶543B_13Bc;9\=�7 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0k.10¶9��o9 F <\ayfX52<^D U�] .1=�p)l U . ] ´543B04fi<>=X023 �y[X.Y_13 W 9\.Y=�7C9\.1=�.1=Xp�9 ]6] 36f�7C9 E _13"523B7C52.13�c\9;_/9 ]B]6U 549 ] F\��E 3 ] 9 U 023"043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp³an3��t3B5] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0e7C9\´\3B0�_Y36020¹74. W 3 � H <}�t3�c>365 � 0236_13 ] 74.1=Xpk7C[X3 W <>027¹543B_13�c\9;=�7 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0 W 9 F ��<>54´.1=�3Bظ3 ] 74.Yc\36_ F �y[X3B=74[X3%543B_13�c\9;=�7�DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0�9 E < U 7Z9)7C<>fX. ] 9\523'0 ] 9;7474365236D³<Âc\365�9{_19\54p>3= U W�E 365K<\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0 � J ={9;DXDX.Y74.1<>= � 3�µ ] 3B0402.Yc>3��t<>52´�_1<�9\D�0�9\523k027C.Y_1_`9 E _13�7C<�<}c>3B52�y[X3B_ W 9043B52c\365y7C[g9;7K.Y0oan5436l U 3B=�7C_ F ] [X<>043B= �w <>5e3Úµ ] 360204.Yc\3K��<>52´V_Y<�9\DX0 � 7C[X3y<>=�_ F 04<>_ U 7C.Y<>=�.10¢7C<kDX.1087C52. E U 743t��<>54´�_1<>9\DX0e<>=�9�04.Y=Xp>_Y3t043B52c\365<}c>3B5�023Bc>3B5C9\_�R2.YDX36=�7C. ] 9\_TS%043B52c>3B540 � �y[X. ] [ 543Bl U .152360ka U _1_e<\5qfX9\5274.h9\_eDX9;7:9%543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= � s [X3[ U p>3q= U W�E 365y<\a¢DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0K.1=�9Z_h9\52p>3 ½ 0 ] 9\_13 JLu 0 F 027C3 W fX54<>[�. E .¾7C0oa U _Y_IDg9;7C9�5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= �� 3¶.1=�c\360274.1p�9�7C3q5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y=Xp�fg9\52740�<;a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 E�F D�.104023 W .1=g9�7C.1=�p�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0 E 9;0436D)<>=l U 365 F _1< ] 9;_1.Y7 F\� 523604< U 5 ] 360 � 9\=XD�9 ]B] 3B040¹fg9;74743652=X0º<>5e<\74[X365 ] <>=X02745C9\.Y=�7C0º.1=Z<>52DX365e74<k5436f�_1. ] 9;7C39\0o_Y.Y727C_13yDg9�7:9�9\0tf¸<>0204. E _13�9\=XD W 9\.1=�7C9\.1=©9 ]6] 36f�7C9 E _Y3/543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_¸9 ]6]BU 5C9 ] F � J =@9¶D�.1027454. E U 7C3BDJLu 0 F 087C3 W�� fX9\5274.h9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=»5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=»043B52c>3B0¶7É��<)f U 52f¸<\04360 � DX.Y027C52. E U 7C.1=�p%3�µ ] 3B0404.¾c>3��<>54´�_1<>9\DX0K9\=XD@543B027454. ] 7C.Y=XpZ7C[X3k04369\5 ] [�7C<�9Z0 W 9\_1_Öf¸3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3k<\a®Dg9;7C9 �J =@7C[X.Y0mDX.1020436587:9;74.1<>= � �t3q.1=�c\360274.1p�9�7C3/7C[�3q0 ] 9\_19 E _Y3k9\5 ] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 54360y7C[X9;7y3�µ^fX_Y<>.Y7yfg9;5C9\_Y_136_Y.10 WE�F DX.Y027454. E U 7C.Y=Xp¶Dg9�7:9¶<}c>3B5y9 ] _ U 0274365o<;a¢0 FVW©W 3B7454. ] W U _¾7C.1f�54< ] 360204<>520 � 9\=XD U 023�fg9\587C.h9;_ ] <>_ ½_13 ] 74.1<>= 543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=�9\=XD ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= 0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>= 7C<{023�9\5 ] [9\0¶_Y.Y727C_13ZDX9;7:9�9\0¶fi<>0402. E _Y3��y[�.1_13W 9\.1=�7:9;.1=X.Y=XpK9 ]6] 36f�7C9 E _13�543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_^9 ]6]BU 5C9 ] F � � 3t9\_102</< E 023652c\3 ] [g9\549 ] 743652.10274. ] 0e<\a JLu �t<>52´ ½_1<>9\DX0y9\=XD JLu 0 F 087C3 W 0K.1=@<>52DX365m7C< U 023�7C[X3 W 9\0y9�p U .1DX3B_1.Y=X3 �

(*)VU �H.XWY.X<K0�:�, �[Z68D8\<K0�]s [X.Y0�DX.Y04043B527C9;7C.Y<>={027 U DX.Y360/DX.Y027454. E U 7C3BD{9\5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 543B0/7C[g9�7/0 ] 9\_13q�y.Y74[{5C9\f�.1DX_ F .1= ] 543�9;04.1=�pDg9;7C9�9;=XD³��<>52´V_Y<�9\DX0 � 9\=XD³=X<\7�<>=�_ F fX52<^D UX] 3�l U . ] ´543B04fi<>=X023�74. W 3 E U 7«9\_102< W 9\.Y=�7C9\.1=

Ä

Page 19: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

9 ]B] 36f^7:9 E _Y3¶523B7C52.13�c\9;_®9 ]B]6U 549 ] F � M U 5�9\5 ] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 54360�.1= ] <>54fi<>5C9�7C3kfg9\549\_1_Y36_S.1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>=%543 ½7C52.13�c\9;_ � fX9\5274.h9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>='543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= � 9\=�D ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=«0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � � 3k. W fX_Y3 W 36=�7m9Z02. W U^½_h9�7C<>5ºan<>5tD�.1027454. E U 7C3BD%9\5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 543B0 � 9\=�D«c;9\_1.YDg9;7C3K.Y7o9\p�9\.Y=X027¹7C[�3/fX54<;7C<\7 F fi3�. W fX_13 W 3B=�7C9 ½7C.Y<>= � � 3 U 023�7C[�3�c;9\_1.YDg9;7436D)02. W U _h9;74<>5o7C<©3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C3q0 F 02743 W f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3k�y.Y7C[{9�c;9\54.Y3B7 F<\am��<>54´�_Y<�9\DX0 � � 3%9\_102<).Y=�c\36087C.1p>9;7C3©[X<}� 74<)5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C3'9�0 W 9\_1_ºfi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3'<\ayDX9;7:9{9;=XD043B_13 ] 7K543B_13Bc;9\=�7Kfg9\587C.19\_Ö5236fX_Y. ] 9;0 �s [X3'.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>="523B7C52.13�c\9;_�3B=Xp>.1=�3 U 0236D�.1=�7C[X.Y0�DX.Y040236527C9;7C.Y<>=�.Y0 J = Á U 3B5 F L z ËON � �y[�. ] [�.Y0E 9\0236D³<>=�7C[�3%.1=�an3B5436= ] 3@=X3B7É��<>52´�543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_ W <VDX36_�L � Ä N � s [X3B543�9\543'7É��< W 9}¼2<>5�54369\04<\=X07C< ] [X<^<\043 J = Á U 3B5 F � w .Y54087 � .¾7/.Y0/9'fX52<Âc\36="3Bظ3 ] 7C.¾c>3Z543�7C52.13Bc;9\_b36=�p>.1=X3^L Ç>ÆV�IÇ � �IÇ>ÌV�IÇ>|�� Ë Å N7C[X9;7�36=g9 E _13B0Z< U 5�523604369\5 ] [³7C<»fX52<}c^.YDX3%[X.Yp>[�543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_t9 ]6]BU 5C9 ] F �³T 3 ] <>=�D � .¾7�.Y0 U 043BDÙ.Y=� 3 E 04369\5 ] [�.1=Xp � _h9\52p>3�_Y. E 549\54.Y360 � ] < W fX9\=X.13B0 � 9\=XD{p><}c\3654= W 3B=�7q9;p>36= ] .13B0/0 UX] [ 9\0 P . E 5C9;5 F<\a r <\=Xp>543B040 � � [X.¾7C3 H < U 023 � � 3B027�? U E _1.102[X.1=�p � 9\=XD P <\7 U 0ML Ë Æ N � w <>5y7C[X3�3�µ^f¸3B54. W 3B=�740�.Y=7C[�.10oDX.Y040236527C9;7C.Y<>= � �t3k. W fX_Y3 W 36=�7t< U 5m04. W U _h9�7C<>5 U 04.Y=Xp�7C[�3 W 369\0 U 523 W 36=�7C0man52< W J = Á U 365 Fc>3B5402.1<>= Ç � z 9\=XD«c;9\_Y.1Dg9�7C3m.Y7�9\p>9\.1=X087�9�fX52<\7C<\7 F fi3�. W fX_Y3 W 36=�7:9�7C.1<\=Z<>='9 Ç ½ r ? R Ä>Î\Å d H/G,�à r +�_YfX[g9�an<>5¹9q[�3�9�cV.1_ F _Y<�9\DX3BD©0 F 027C3 W � � 3�9\_102<qD�.10 ]BU 040¹7C[X3K043B=X04.¾7C.¾c^.¾7 F <\aI< U 5�52360 U _Y740�y.Y74[@543602f¸3 ] 7K7C<�< U 5 E 9;043k0 F 02743 W �

þgÿT�`ÿ¦þ Ý/ÞXýÂÞ� _ ¦à` óbaXced ýOf�Þ�ü ò d�a³ñ à�ü}ý ò à ï Þ� 4%�g ò a ß î�h f-f�à�ü}ý òji ì %� nü ò ûbý d i à`gkg d ýlg+�_¾7C[X< U p>[%7C[X3�f�543BcV.Y< U 0y543B043�9;5 ] [)[X9\0yDX3 W <>=X087C5C9�7C36D�.1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>=«523B7454.13�c;9\_I.10m369\04.Y_ F fg9\5 ½9\_Y_136_Y. ¿ 36D � .Y7/7 F fX. ] 9\_Y_ F .1=�c>3B0274.1p�9;7436D 9\= JLu 0 F 027C3 W <>="9%DX.1087C52. E U 7436D W 3 W <>5 F\�IW 9\0402.Yc>3B_ Ffg9\549\_1_Y36_of�54< ] 360204.Y=Xp Ô d{d)? Õ W 9 ] [X.Y=X3 Ô 3 � p � r d ½ Î �y.Y74[ Æ�ÎV� Î\Ç\Æ f�54< ] 360204.Y=Xp�3B_13 W 36=�740 Õ ��y[X. ] [).10yc>3B5 F 3�µ^fi36=X02.Yc\3Z9\=XD�=X363BDX0�02f¸3 ] .h9;_1. ¿ 36D�9\_1p\<>54.¾7C[ W 0t7C<�7:9\´;3¶9;D�c;9\=�7:9\p>3q<\a®[g9\54D ½�t9\543�543602< U 5 ] 3606L Æ���Ä^z;��Ä;Æ��^Î � �VÆ>Æ��VÆ � �VÆ>Ì N Ô T 3 ] 7C.Y<>= Ä � ˶D�360 ] 54. E 3B0t7C[X3KfX523BcV.1< U 0t543B04369\5 ] [ Õ �� <\74[»7C[X3Z[X.Yp>[»fX52. ] 3�9\=XD»7C[X3Z=�3636D"an<>5/02f¸3 ] .19\_1. ¿ 36D"9;_1p><>52.Y74[ W 0KfX52<>[X. E .Y7/0 UX] [ W 9 ] [�.1=X3B0an54< WÓE 3B.1=Xpk�y.1DX3B_ F U 0436D � J = ] <>=�745C9\087 � 0 FVW©W 3B7454. ] W U _Y74.1fX52< ] 360402<>540 Ô T d)? Õ 9\523mc>365 F fi<>f ½U _19\5¹9\=XD%9;ظ<>52Dg9 E _Y3 � ú9\02.1_ F U fXp>549\DX.1=�p¶3�µ^.Y027C.Y=Xp¶02<\a�7É�t9\543�an52< W 04.Y=Xp>_Y3 ½ r ? R W 9 ] [X.1=X3B0¹74<T d)?A0K.10y9\=�<\7C[X3B5K9\D�c;9\=�7:9\p\3�<\a U 04.1=�p T d�?º0 �

Ç

Page 20: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

r U 525436=�74_ F>� ] < W©W 365 ] .19\_/.1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>=�543�7C52.13Bc;9\_�0 F 027C3 W 0 � 0 UX] [v9\0 � 3 E 023�9\5 ] [�36=Xp\.1=X3B0+�_¾7:9 Ñ .1087:9ML Ë$Ng9;=XD J =�an<>043B36´�L Ë Î N � [g9;=XDX_13�7C543 W 3B=XDX< U 0A_1<�9\D�0 E�F 3�µ^fX_Y<>.Y74.1=XpK7C[X3mfg9;5C9\_Y_136_Y.10 W. W fX_Y. ] .¾7K.1=»7C[X3B.15�7C9\04´�0�9\=XD U 023 T d)?A0q74<�0 U fXfi<>527�74[X36.Y5�043B52cV. ] 360 � +�_Y7C[�< U p>[".Y7/.10 ] _13�9;57C[X9;7k7C[X3 W <>543 r ? R 0�9\=XD DX.102´�0 F < U [g9�c\3�74[X3 W <>523Z_1<�9\D»74[X3©0 F 027C3 W ] 9\= [g9\=XD�_13 � 7C[�3. W fi<>527C9\=�7kl U 360274.1<>=�0�9\523©[X<}� W UX] [�<\a��y[X. ] [�[X9\54D��t9\523«9\=�D��y[g9;7�04<\a�7É�t9\523«02745 UX] 7 U 523.10�=X3B36DX3BD·7C<�3�µ^fX_Y<>.Y7Z74[X36023)543B04< U 5 ] 3B0 � R =^an<>527 U =g9;7436_ F\� ] < W©W 365 ] .19\_o0 F 087C3 W 0«[X9}c\3)=X<;7f U E _1.102[X36Dk7C[�36.15S[g9;54D��t9\543�9\=XDq04<;a�7É�o9\523 ] <>=�jgp U 5C9;74.1<>=X0 � s [�3�fX523BcV.1< U 0¢5236023�9\5 ] [¶<>= T d)?A0.1=�c\360274.1p�9�7C36D�9�fX9\527q<\at0 F 02743 W�� 0 U�] [�9\0�7C[X3�DX.Y04´»0 F 087C3 W L Ë � Nº<>5k.¾7 ] < W fg9\5236D�74[X3 ] <>087a¦9 ] 7C<>520¶<\ao74[X3 T d�?-9;5 ] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 523«�y.Y74[�<\74[X365¶9\5 ] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 54360^L Ä\Å N � u 3 ] 3B=�74_ F 7C[X3 syu à r] <\=�an365236= ] 3�5436fi<>587C36D«54360 U _Y740o<>=%9�04.1=�p>_13Kl U 365 F Ô 5C9;74[X365t74[g9\=%9�_1<�9\D�36D«0 F 027C3 W Õ 9\p�9\.Y=X027t9z}Å>Å O � ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=mL Ë Ä N � �y[X36523t04< W 3º<\a�.Y7C0Sfg9;527C. ] .Yfg9;7C3BDk.1=X087C.Y7 U 7C.Y<>=X0 U 0236D T d)?A0 � N <>=X3º<\a7C[�3 ] < W�W 365 ] .h9\_i0 F 087C3 W 0y9\=XD'74[X3�fX523BcV.1< U 0o543B043�9;5 ] [�<>= T d)?A0y543Bf¸<\527C3BD%[X<}��74< E 9\_19\= ] 3[g9\52D��t9\543Z9;=XD{04<;a�7É�o9\523�543B04< U 5 ] 3B0�.1={<\54DX3B5�7C<'9 ] [X.13�c>3�0 ] 9\_19 E _Y3�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3¶.1=)9 T d)?0 F 087C3 W �J =�7C[X.Y0�D�.1040236587:9;74.1<>= � �t3 ] <\=XD UX] 7{90 F 02743 W 9;7C. ] 027 U D F <>=!9�fX52<}c>36=!3Bظ3 ] 74.Yc\3�0 F 087C3 WU 02.1=XpZ0 F^W�W 3B7C52. ] W U _Y74.1fX52< ] 360204<>520 U =XDX3B5y9¶c;9\54.Y3B7 F <\ab543�9;_1.1087C. ] ��<>54´�_Y<�9\DX0y9\=�D%[g9\54D^�o9\523] <\=�jgp U 549;7C.Y<>=X0 � R =X_Y.1´\3/74[X3kfX543�cV.1< U 0y523604369\5 ] [��y[X36523q74[X3��t<\54´�_1<�9;DX0y<>=X_ F .1= ] _ U D�3�l U 365 F] < W©W 9\=XDX0 � < U 5e��<>52´V_Y<�9\DX0º9;543y9 W . µV7 U 523o<\ai7C[X52363 JLu ] < W©W 9\=XD�0 � l U 365 F\� 0 U W�W 9;5 F>� 9;=XDDX< ]6U W 36=�7 ] < W©W 9\=XDX0 � �y[X. ] [�fX52<}c^.YDX360q9 W <>543Z523�9\_Y.10274. ] .1=�c>3B027C.Yp�9;74.1<>= � M U 5/�t<>52´�_1<�9\D�0W . W . ] 7C[X3�027:9�7C.1087C. ] 0�an52< W 543�9;_Ö0 F 087C3 W _1<>p>0 � , U 52.1=Xp�< U 5o.Y=�c\36087C.1p>9;7C.Y<>= � �t3�DX3 W <\=X02745C9;743[X<}��7C< E 9\_h9;= ] 3K7C[X3/[X9\54D��t9\523�9\=XD'02<\a�7É�t9\543��y.¾7C['523602f¸3 ] 7o74<�= U W�E 365t<;a`7C[X523�9\DX0 � r ? R 0 �9\=XD"DX.Y04´�0q9\0/7C[�3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\={04. ¿ 3Z.1= ] 54369\043B0 � � 3�.1=�c>3B027C.Yp�9;743�7C[X3�a¦9 ] 7C<>520/7C[g9�7q9;ØÖ3 ] 7k7C[�3=X3 ] 36020C9\5 F = U W�E 365�<\am7C[X523�9\D�0 � � 3'DX3 W <>=�027C549;7C3©0 F 02743 W 0 ] 9;_h9 E .Y_1.¾7 F �y[X36=�74[X3'0 F 087C3 W.10���36_Y_ E 9\_19\= ] 36D � 9\=XD��y[X3B=Ù<>=�3�<;aK74[X3@[g9\52D��o9;543 ] < W fi<>=X36=�740�.Y0Z9 E <;747C_Y36=X3 ] ´ � M U 5543B0 U _¾7C0'f�54<}cV.1DX3�.1=X02.1p>[�7C0�an<>5 E U .1_YDX.1=�p�[X.Yp>[�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 JLu 043658c>3B540 U 02.1=Xp�0 FVW©W 3B7454. ]W U _¾7C.YfX54< ] 3B0404<\540 �

Ë

Page 21: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

þgÿT�`ÿT� Ý/ÞXý}ü ò Þ� ând j nà i ü ò d�a�ñ à�û! ò_i Þ�ü ò d�au 36fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=�[g9\0A_Y<>=Xp E 3636= U 0236D�.1=�7C[�3�9;543�9;0A<\aÖD�.1027454. E U 7C3BD�jg_13m0 F 027C3 W 0¹9\=�D�D�.1027454. E U 7C3BDDg9;7C9 E 9\023«0 F 087C3 W 0�.Y=�<\54DX3B5�7C<�. W fX54<}c\3©0 F 087C3 W fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3©9\=XD�9�c\9;.1_h9 E .1_Y.Y7 F L z;�eÄ^�bÇ��z}Æ��¹z}|��eÄ Ë �eÄ>Î^�®Ç>Å^� Ë Ç^� Ë>Ë �AÎVz\�eÆ>Î^�®Æ\|�� � Æ N Ô 04363 T 3 ] 74.1<>= Ä � Î an<\5¶DX3�7:9\.Y_136D�DX.10 ]6U 0204.1<\=X0 Õ �,�9;7C9 E 9\023�c>36=�DX<>540�0 UX] [�9\0 M 5C9 ] _13 � J =^an<>5 W .¾µ � 9\=XD T FVE 9\023©<;ØÖ3B5q5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=)7C3 ] [X=X.Yl U 360.1="7C[�36.15qfX52<^D U�] 7C0oL Æ>Å N � H <}�t3�c>3B5 � 7C[�36543©9\523©023Bc>3B5C9\_�DX.1087C.Y= ] 74.1<>=X0�74[g9;7 W 9;´\3�7C[X.Y0q��<>54´U =X.Yl U 3 � w .Y54027 � .1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>=)523B7C52.13�c\9;_e.10�DX.¾ØÖ3B543B=�7kan52< W 74[X3Zan< ]BU 0k<\atf�543BcV.Y< U 0kDg9;7C9 E 9\0239\=XD�jg_Y3'0 F 087C3 W ��<>52´ � J =�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=�523B7454.13�c;9\_t0 F 087C3 W 0�9\523'�t<>52´�.1=Xp"<>=�743�µV7 � �y[X. ] [.Y0U =X087C5 UX] 7 U 543BD�9\=�D».10�p\36=X3B5C9\_Y_ F 54369\D ½ <\=X_ F � s [X3ZDg9;7C9 E 9\023Z9\=XD{jX_13¶0 F 027C3 W 0k9;543¶��<>54´�.Y=Xp<>=�087C5 U�] 7 U 5436DDg9�7:9{0 U�] [Ù9;0Z543 ] <>54D�0�9\=XD�< E ¼23 ] 740 � 9\=XD�74[X3%Dg9;7C9).10�523�9\D ½ �y54.¾7C3 � s [X36.Y5��<>54´³an< ]BU 043B0'<>=�9\_Yp><>54.¾7C[ W 0Zan<>5 U f¸Dg9�7C.1=�p�54369\D ½ �y52.Y743)Dg9;7C9�7C<�3B=X0 U 543 ] <\=X04.Y027C3B= ] F <\aDX.¾ØÖ3B5436=�7 ] <>fX.Y360t<;aSDg9;7:9 � J =%9\DXDX.¾7C.Y<>= � 027C5 UX] 7 U 543BD%Dg9;7C9 E 9\023�9\=XD'jg_Y3�0 F 087C3 W 0 ] 9\='04. W f�_ FU 023�7C[�3�023B7 W 3 W�E 3B5402[X.1f�7C<kjg=XD%9k543BfX_1. ] 9 � �y[�.1_13y.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=Z523B7C52.13�c\9;_g=X363BDX0o9k043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=a U = ] 7C.Y<>=�74<)DX3�7C365 W .Y=X3Z�y[X3B74[X365�9�543BfX_1. ] 9 ] <>=�7C9\.1=X0�9\_Y_ � 04< W 3 � <>5q=X<>=X3©<\at74[X3«5236_13�c;9\=�7DX< ]6U W 36=�740K.Y=@<>54DX3B5m7C< W 9;.1=�7:9\.Y='543�7C52.13Bc;9\_Ö3Bظ3 ] 74.Yc\36=X3B040 �u 3 ] 3B=�7C_ F\� 523604369\5 ] [�36540m[X9}c\3 U 043BD%543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=�.1=�7C[X3 � 3 E an<>5¹DX< ]BU W 36=�7m9 ]B] 3B040pL Î^� � � � Ì N �O 36=X3B5C9\_Y_ F>� 74[X3 F ] 9 ] [X3«fi<>f U _h9\5�DX< ]6U W 3B=�740�.Y=�9@[X.Y365C9;5 ] [ F <\aofX52<�µ F 023658c>36520¶�y[X. ] [�9\523_1< ] 9�7C36D E 3B7É��363B= ] _1.13B=�7C0m9\=�D � 3 E 043B52c\36540y7C<Z5236D U�] 3 J =�7C3652=X3B7y745C9;À ]\� +�_Y7C[�< U p>['��3q9\_102<9\DX<\f�7%9�5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=Ù[�.136549\5 ] [ F 7C<�087C<>523�74[X3{DX< ]6U W 36=�740'<\a/74[X3 W <>027©an5436l U 3B=�7C_ F U 0236Dl U 3652.13B0 � < U 5t5436f�_1. ] 9\0m9\523/04369\5 ] [X9 E _13k9;=XD%7C[ U 0 ] 9;=�02f¸3B36D U f E <\7C[%l U 3B5 F 9\=�D�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7fX52< ] 360402.1=Xp �+�0¶0 U p>p\36027436D E�F < U 5¶_Y<>p{9\=X9\_ F 043B0 � ��3%=X363BD�7C<{02f¸3B36D U f E <\74[�l U 365 F fX52< ] 360402.1=Xp"9;=XDDX< ]6U W 36=�7�9 ]B] 36020�74< W 9�µ^. W . ¿ 3�f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3�. W fX52<Âc\3 W 36=�7C0 � M =X3��t9 F 74<)9 ] [X.13�c>3�7C[X.Y0p><�9;_X.10e74< ] 9 ] [X3y7C[X3 W <>027Aan5236l U 36=�74_ F U 0236D«l U 3B54.Y360�9\_1<>=�p/�y.Y7C[Z74[X36.Y5º74<>f�DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0 � 9;=XDDX<»087C54.Y=Xp ] < W fX9\54.Y04<>= 7C<{DX3�7C3B5 W .1=X3��y[X3B74[X365�9{l U 3B5 F .Y0 ] 9 ] [X36D � H <}�t3�c>365 U 02.1=Xp�7C[X.Y09\fXf�54<�9 ] [ ] 9\=©=X<\7 W 9;7 ] [«9 ] 9 ] [X36D«l U 365 F �y[X3B=«7C[�3�=X3���l U 365 F .Y0¹9 E < U 7º7C[X3K0C9 W 3y7C<>fX. ] �E U 7 U 02360¹DX.Yظ365236=�7tl U 3B5 F 7C3B5 W 0º<>5ºDX.Yظ365236=�7�74365 W an<>5 W 0 � J =«< U 5º_Y<>p>0 ��Ç>Î#q 7C< Æ�Ä#q <;aÖ7C[�3

Î

Page 22: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

7C<\fX. ] 0�7C[g9�7k< ]B]6U 5 W <>543q7C[g9;= <\= ] 3 ] <>=�7:9\.Y= W <>523¶7C[X9\="<>=X3 U =X.Yl U 3Zl U 365 F 7C[g9�7�543�7 U 52=X07C[�3©049 W 3Z74<>f Ä;Å DX< ]6U W 3B=�740 � � 3�04<>_¾c>3�7C[X.Y0qf�54< E _Y3 W E�F 087C<>52.1=Xp�9�023�9\5 ] [g9 E _Y3©5236fX_Y. ] 9<\ab7C[X3/74<>f@DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0man<>5m369 ] [�l U 365 F .Y=X02743�9\D@<\a ] 9 ] [X.1=Xp�l U 3B5 F 52360 U _Y7C0 � s [X.10y02745 UX] 7 U 52336=X9 E _13B0A< U 5A0 F 087C3 W 7C<�DX3�7C3 ] 7º�y[X3B74[X365ºl U 3652.13B0�9 E < U 7e7C[X3m049 W 3o7C<>fX. ] E U 7 U 04.1=�pqD�.Yظ36543B=�77C3B5 W 0A9\523t.1=�7C[X3o5236fX_Y. ] 9 � �y[X. ] [�.1= ] 543�9;04360®l U 365 F _1< ] 9\_Y.Y7 F 9\0 ] < W fg9\5236D¶74< ] 9 ] [�.1=Xp�l U 3B54.13B0�y[X. ] [�5236l U .152360yl U 3652.13B0K74< W 9;7 ] [�3Úµ�9 ] 74_ F �� 3�an<>543y�t3�3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C3y[X<}� W UX] [«fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�. W fX52<}c>3 W 36=�7¹fg9\587C.19\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=Z543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=] 9;= F .13B_1D � ��3�.Y=�c\36087C.1p>9;7C3m7É��<¶fX52< E _13 W 0Ajg52027 � s [X3yjg54087tfX52< E _Y3 W .Y0º�y[�3B7C[�365�74[X36523�3Úµ^.1027400 U À ] .13B=�7el U 365 F _Y< ] 9\_1.¾7 F .1=�54369\_^0 F 027C3 W 0 � w <>527 U =g9;7436_ F>� 7C[X3t9 ]6] 36040®_1<>p>0b<\ag523�9\_ JLu 0 F 087C3 W 0DX3 W <>=�027C549;7C3�7C[X3B543/.Y0t0 U�] [%_1< ] 9\_Y.Y7 F Ô 04363�+�fXfi36=XDX. µ � Õ � s [X3�023 ] <>=XD%fX52< E _13 W .Y0��y[X3�7C[X3B5��3 ] 9\={jg=�D�9;=»3Bظ3 ] 74.Yc\3�7C<V<>_b74<%043B_13 ] 7k9'543B_13�c\9;=�7/fg9\5274.h9\_S5236fX_Y. ] 9 � 04.Y= ] 3¶=X<\7k9\_Y_¢fX9\5274.h9\_543BfX_1. ] 9\0©9\523�3Bl U 9\_1_ F <>5©=�3�9\52_ F 36l U 9;_1_ F 3�ØÖ3 ] 74.Yc>3�an<>5©9�l U 365 F �!T 36_Y3 ] 7C.1=�p�543BfX_1. ] 9\0/¼ U 087E 9\0236D�<>=�_Y<�9\D@DX<V360K=X<\7 W 9\.1=�7:9;.1=@9 ]B] 36f^7:9 E _Y3k543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_S9 ]B]6U 549 ] F\� 9;=XD{9Za¦9\027 JLu 0 F 087C3 W�y.Y74[X< U 7�9 ]6] 36f�7C9 E _Y3«543�7C52.13Bc;9\_�9 ]B]6U 549 ] F .10 U 043B_136020 � J =�74[X.10�DX.102043B527:9�7C.1<\= � ��3@9\Dg9\f^7¶7C[�3] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�523B7454.13�c;9\_o.1=^an36543B= ] 3@=X3�7É�t<\54´ W <^D�36_tan<>5¶0436_Y3 ] 7C.1=�p�9»5236_13�c;9\=�7�fg9\5274.h9\_�543BfX_1. ] 9 �� 3�fX54<\f¸<>023Z9«=X3��-5436f�_1. ] 9«043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=)a U = ] 7C.Y<>= � ] < W fg9\523�.Y7K�y.Y74[)7C[�3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=)549\=X´�.1=�pa U = ] 7C.Y<>=1L zÂÎ N � 9;=XD@DX3 W <>=X087C5C9�7C3�.Y740m3Bظ3 ] 7C.Yc\36=X3B040 U 04.Y=Xp�9 Ä O ��] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%9\=�D)9 Ä\Å O �] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= �+�a�74365k04<\_YcV.1=Xp%74[X3©f�54< E _Y3 W <\ao3�ØÖ3 ] 7C.¾c>3B=X36020�.1="fg9\587C.19\_e543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= � �t3�.1=�c\360274.1p�9�7C3�_1<�9;DE 9\_19\= ] .1=Xp � U f¸DX9;7C.Y=Xp�027C549;7C3Bp>.13B0 � 9\=XD�<}c>3B54[X369\DX0�an<\5 E U .1_YDX.1=XpZ5236fX_Y. ] 9\0K9\=XD�5436f�_1. ] 9Z0436_Y3 ]Ú½7C.Y<>=»Dg9;7C9 E 9\02360 � � 3Z7C[�36= 3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C3�74[X3Zf¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3Z<\a�fg9\587C.19\_®5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\= E�F c;9\5 F .1=�p= U W 3654< U 0ºfg9\5C9 W 3�7C36520 � 0 UX] [«9;0 ] < W�W 9;=XD�9\5452.Yc;9\_^5C9;743 � DX.Y027C549 ] 74.1=Xp�f¸3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3 � 5236fX_Y. ] 9;7 ½.1=�p�f¸3B5 ] 36=�7:9\p\3 � 9\=XD ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=©04. ¿ 3 � � 3 ] < W fg9;543�74[X3�f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3/<;a¢fX9\5274.Y7C.Y<>=X.Y=Xp¶9;=XD543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=«<Âc\365�9\DXDX.¾7C.Y<>=g9\_¸[g9\54D^�o9\523k543602< U 5 ] 360 �

Æ

Page 23: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

þgÿT�`ÿT� â�d _ ¦à i ü ò d�a�î à` ¦à i ü ò d�as [X3/f�543BcV.Y< U 0t5236023�9\5 ] [�<\= ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=«an< ]6U 02360o<>=©7C[X3�3Bظ3 ] 74.Yc\36=X3B040y<\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � [X<}��7C<q5C9\=�´ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 Ô 02363 T 3 ] 7C.Y<>= Ä � Ç Õ �VE U 7¹DX<^3B0�=�<\7¹.1= ] _ U DX3yfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 33Bc;9\_ U 9;74.1<>= � J =�7C[�.10KDX.1020436587:9;74.1<>= � ��3¶f�54360236=�7�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�3�c\9;_ U 9;74.1<>=@an<>5 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�043 ½_13 ] 74.1<>= U 04.1=�pq.Y=�an365236= ] 3m=X3B7É��<>52´ � � 3mDX3 W <>=�027C549;7C3o74[X3m043B=X04.¾7C.¾c^.¾7 F <\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�y.Y74['543B04fi3 ] 7m7C<¶74[X3�= U W�E 365t<\a`7C<>f ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0¹043�9;5 ] [X3BD�9;=XD'7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=«9 ]6] 3B040m02´\3B�9;a�74365 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�0236_13 ] 74.1<>= � � 3 ] < W fg9\523'7C[X3@fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3%<\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=Ù9;=XDfg9\587C.19\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=%5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= �

þgÿT�`ÿr� î i Þ� nÞ��! ¦à ê ò gBü}ý ò �F%`ü}à`s á ý i ú ò ü}à i üt%SýÂà`gs [X3qfX543�cV.1< U 0y523604369\5 ] [�<>=�DX.1087C54. E U 7436D JLu 0 F 087C3 W 0���<>52´V0K<>=�9�5436_19;7C.¾c>3B_ F 0 W 9\_1_`9 W < U =�7<\a�Dg9;7C9 � M =X_ F 7É�t<@��<>54´�0q.1=�c>3B027C.Yp�9;743 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>={04. ¿ 3B0q<;a W <>543�74[g9\= z}Å>Å O � Ô 02363 T 3 ]Ú½7C.Y<>= Ä � Ä Õ � M U 5«DX.Y027454. E U 7C3BD JLu 0 F 02743 W 04. W U _h9;74360�04369\5 ] [X.Y=Xp�<}c\365%9"7C36549 E�F 7C3{<\a�7C3�µV7 �9\=XD�.Y= ] <>52f¸<\5C9;74360'7C3 ] [X=X<>_Y<>p>.Y360«74[g9;7@DX<=X<\7@3Úµ^[email protected]=�7C[X3"fX523BcV.1< U 0%543B043�9;5 ] [ � 0 UX] [�9;0fg9\587C.19\_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>='5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=@9\=XD ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � � 3�D�3 W <>=X02745C9;743�7C[X3k<}c>3B54[X369\DX0<\ay.Y= ] <>52f¸<\5C9;74.1=Xp@7C[X3B043'743 ] [X=X<\_1<>p>.Y360 � ] < W fg9\523«. W fX_Y3 W 36=�7:9�7C.1<\=�<>f^7C.1<\=X0 � 9;=XD�3Bc;9\_ U 9;743fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3/�y.¾7C[�9Zc\9;54.13�7 F <\ab��<>54´�_1<>9\DX0 �

(*)eu �H.XWY.X<K0�:�, �v24AwEY0 ?G36Z[E�?72xA�Ws [X3 W <>027k. W fi<>527C9\=�7�fX52< E _13 W an<>5 JLu 0 F 027C3 W 0q.10/74<�9;747C9\.1=»l U . ] ´{543B04fi<>=X043�an<>5�549\fX.1D�_ F.1= ] 54369\04.Y=Xp{Dg9�7:9{9\=�D��t<\54´�_1<�9;DX0¶�y[X.Y_13 W 9\.Y=�7:9\[email protected]�c\9;_t9 ]B]6U 549 ] F � s [X.10�DX.102043B527:9 ½7C.Y<>=)f�54360236=�7C0k9©04.1p\=X.Yj ] 9\=�7�087C3Bf{7C<}�o9;54DX0�02<>_YcV.1=�p�74[X.10�´\3 F fX54< E _13 W � s [X3 ] <>=�7C54. E U 74.1<>=X0.1= ] _ U DX3 �

y w .Y54087`�t<>52´k<>=�fX9\5274.h9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=k9\=XD�0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�.Y=�.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=/523B7454.13�c;9\_ �

z ¼ U 027C.¾a F .1=XpZ7C[�3 U 043Ba U _1=X3B040K<\a®fX9\5274.h9\_¸5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>='an<>5 JLu E 9\043BD)<>=%7C549 ] 3B0Q{

z D�3Bc>3B_1<>f�.1=Xp©9Z5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>=%9\5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 523${

Page 24: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

z D�3Bc>3B_1<>f�.1=Xp³9\=�3Bظ3 ] 7C.¾c>3"543BfX_1. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�a U = ] 7C.1<\=�9\=XDDX3 W <>=X087C5C9�7C.1=�p�.Y740fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3${

z 3B0274. W 9;7C.Y=Xp U fiDg9;7C.Y=Xp ] <>087C0man<>5m5236fX_Y. ] 9;0y9\=XD�5436f�_1. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=@Dg9;7:9 E 9\043O{

z f�54<>fi<>04.Y=Xp U fiDg9;7C.Y=Xp�02745C9;7436p>.Y360 �

y T^] 9\_h9 E _13/D�.1027454. E U 7C3BD�9\5 ] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 54360�9\=XD�9\=@3Bc;9\_ U 9;74.1<>=%<\ab7C[�36.15mfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 �

z . W f�_13 W 36=�74.1=XpZ9;=XD�c;9\_Y.1Dg9�7C.1=�p�9�04. W U _h9;74<>5�an<\5mDX.1087C54. E U 7436D JLu 0 F 02743 W 0Q{

z fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�3�c;9\_ U 9�7C.1<\=³<;a�fg9\549\_1_Y36_o023652c\36520 U 04.Y=Xp�0 FVW©W 3B7454. ] W U _Y7C.YfX54< ] 3B0 ½02<>540b{

z fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3k3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>='<\a®fg9\5274.h9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>='5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=I{

z ] < W fg9\54.Y04<>=@<\a¢fg9\587C.19\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=%5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=%9\=XD ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>='fX9\5274.Y7C.Y<>=X.Y=Xp�{

z fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3k3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>='<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>='043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=I{

z ] < W fg9\54.Y04<>=@<\a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=%0236_13 ] 74.1<>=�9\=XD@fg9;527C.19\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=«5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>=I{

z W 3 ] [X9\=X.10 W 0man<>5m023�9\5 ] [X.1=�p«9�7C3B5C9 E�F 7C3q<\ab7C3Úµ^7 �

(*)_| �}E�0 Z�:�E�Z�0�./249~E�,�.v �?7WYWY.X0YEY<FE�?724As [X3o523 W 9\.1=�DX365¢<\ag7C[X3�DX.102043B527:9�7C.1<\=�.10¢<>54p�9;=X. ¿ 36DZ9\0ban<>_1_Y<}�y0 � r [g9\f�74365 ÄKE 54.Y3BÏ F .1=�7454<VD UX] 3B07C[�3 E 9\02. ]/] <>= ] 3Bf�7C0 U [email protected]='.1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>=©523B7454.13�c;9\_Ö9;=XD%543�c^.Y3B�y0m5236_h9�7C36D'��<>52´ � r [g9;f�7C3B5 ÇDX3B0 ] 52. E 360�< U 5/DX.1087C52. E U 7436D{.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=�543�7C52.13Bc;9\_¢9\5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 543B0 � r [g9\f�74365�Ë'.Y=�c>36087C.Yp�9;7C3B0.1020 U 3B0©5236_19;7C3BD³74<�fg9;527C.19\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= � r [g9\f�74365 Î D�360 ] 54. E 3B0�74[X3�02. W U _h9;74.1<>=W <^DX3B_�9;=XD�.Y7C0bc;9\_1.YDg9;7C.Y<>= � r [g9;f�7C3B5 Æ 3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C3B0®7C[X3mfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3t<\aifg9;5C9\_Y_136_�.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=543�7C52.13Bc;9\_ U 04.1=�p�0 FVW©W 3B7454. ] W U _Y7C.YfX54< ] 3B0402<>540 � 9;=XD 74[X3�f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3�<\ao9@D�.1027454. E U 7C3BD JLu0 F 087C3 W �y.¾7C[�fg9\5274.h9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>=�9\=XD ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � r [X9\f�7C3B5 � fX5236043B=�7C03�µ^fi3652. W 36=�7C0@7C[g9�7 U 043"7C[X3B043"7C3 ] [�=X<>_1<\p>.13B0@74<Ù023�9\5 ] [�9�7C3B5C9 E�F 7C3�<\a�743�µV7 � r [g9\f�74365 Ì0 U W©W 9\54. ¿ 3B0o7C[X3kDX.Y04043B527C9;7C.Y<>=�9\[email protected]=XD�. ] 9�7C360oa U 7 U 523q5236023�9\5 ] [)DX.Y543 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 �

Ì

Page 25: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

���v�'&����)� U

�����©�"���� ± $ ��°

J =�7C[�.10 ] [g9;f�7C3B5 � �t3 E 52.13�Ï F .Y=�7454<VD UX] 3 E 9\02. ]{] <>= ] 3Bf�7C0 U 0436D�.Y=�.1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=³523B7454.13�c;9\_ �9\=XD"523BcV.13�� 74[X3Z543B043�9;5 ] [ 5436_19;7C3BD»7C<'7C[�.10/DX.Y040236527C9;7C.Y<>= � � 3Z.Y=�7C54<VD UX] 3Z543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_ W <VDX36_Y0 �.1=�DX3�µ^.1=�p � 9\=XD W 3�9\0 U 543B0/an<>5/523B7C52.13�c\9;_®3Bظ3 ] 7C.¾c>36=�36040q.1= T 3 ] 74.1<>= Ä � z � � 3ZDX.10 ]6U 020�5436_19;7C3BD��<>54´©<>=%f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3/.Y='DX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D%.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=�543�7C52.13Bc;9\_¸.1= T 3 ] 74.1<>= Ä � Ä^� 3Bظ3 ] 7C.Yc\36=X3B040.1=�D�.1027454. E U 7C3BD.1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=�543�7C52.13Bc;9\_t.1= T 3 ] 7C.Y<>= Ä � Ç�� fX9\5C9\_Y_13B_�.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=�543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_o.Y=T 3 ] 7C.Y<>= Ä � Ë � 9\=XD@Dg9;7C9�5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>='.1= T 3 ] 74.1<>= Ä � Î �

Uw)+( �BA�9C240 8\<FE�?724A �H.IEY0 ?G.=JK<>5©��<K: ���*0�2xZ6A���Iÿ¦þ�ÿ¦þ ñ à�ü}ý ò à ï Þ� ì�d sSà� _gJ =�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=�523B7C52.13�c\9;_b.Y0�74[X3¶fX52< ] 36020/<\aº.1D�36=�7C.¾a F .Y=Xp©9\=XD{523B7C52.13�c^.Y=Xp«5236_Y3Bc;9\=�7/DX< ]6U W 3B=�740E 9\0236D»<>={9 U 02365QP 0�l U 365 F � +�={.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=@543�7C52.13Bc;9\_S0 F 087C3 W ] <\=X04.Y027C0�<\ae7C[�54363 E 9\04. ] 3B_13 ½W 36=�7C0 � 9yDX< ]6U W 36=�7b543BfX543B043B=�7C9;7C.Y<>= � 9Kl U 3B5 F 5236fX5236043B=�7:9;74.1<>= � 9\=XDq9 W 369\0 U 523º<\a�02. W .1_19\54.¾7 FE 3B7É��3636=�l U 3652.13B0�9;=XD%DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0 � s [X3�DX< ]6U W 36=�7y543BfX543B043B=�7C9;7C.Y<>=@fX54<}cV.1D�360y9¶an<>5 W 9\_iDX3 ½0 ] 54.Yf�7C.Y<>=<\a�74[X3�.1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\= ] <\=�7C9\.1=�36D³.1=�7C[X3�DX< ]6U W 36=�740Q{m7C[X3@l U 3B5 F 543BfX543B043B=�7C9;7C.Y<>=fX52<ÂcV.YDX360�9©an<>5 W 9\_`DX3B0 ] 54.1f^7C.1<\=)<\a U 04365bP 0�.1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=%=X363BDI{`9\=XD�7C[X3�04. W .1_19\54.¾7 F«W 3�9;0 U 523DX3�jg=X360'74[X3{5 U _13B0%9\=XD�fX52< ] 36D U 54360'an<\5 W 9;7 ] [X.Y=Xp�74[X3{l U 3B5 F 9;=XD�543B_13Bc;9\=�7«DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 �s [X3B043Z7C[X52363Z3B_13 W 36=�740 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.¾c>3B_ F DX3BjX=X3�9'543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_ W <VDX36_ � s [X3 W <>027 ] < W�W <\= W <VD ½36_Y0¶.Y= ] _ U DX3©74[X3 � <V<>_Y3�9\= W <VDX36_�L � Ç N � 7C[X3©c>3 ] 7C<>5Z02fg9 ] 3 W <VDX3B_�L Æ>Ç Nt9\0�. W fX_Y3 W 36=�7C3BD�.Y=T d�+ u®s L z}Å N � 74[X3©f�54< E 9 E .1_Y.10274. ] W <VDX36_;L � Ç N � 9;=XD�74[X3©.Y=�an365236= ] 3«=X3�7É�t<\54´ W <VDX3B_;L � Ä Nt9;0. W fX_Y3 W 36=�7C3BD�.Y= J = Á U 365 F L z Ë#N � � 3 E 52.13BÏ F DX360 ] 54. E 3q7C[X3B043 W <VDX36_Y0 E 3B_1<}� � J =�7C[X.Y0y74[X3602.10 ���3 U 023�7C[X3k.1=^an36543B= ] 3k=X3�7É�t<\54´ W <VDX3B_ ��E U 7y< U 5y543B0 U _¾7C0K9\fXf�_ F 74<�<\7C[X3B5 W <VDX36_Y0 �

|

Page 26: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

í¶ú à ðdId nà�Þ a�ì�d sSà� J = � <V<>_Y3�9\=�543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_!L � Ç N � 9qDX< ]BU W 36=�7t.Y0�5236fX52360236=�7C3BD�9;0o9�023B7t<\aI7C3B5 W 0w�t�w�/�������k�T�������7�l� ��y[X3B543'369 ] [-�V�m.10�9�74365 W 7C[X9;7Z9\f�f¸369\540�.1=�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7��t� � + l U 3B5 F .Y0�5236fX52360236=�7C3BD·9\0¶9� <V<>_1369\=«3Úµ^fX543B0404.Y<>=@<\aS7C3B5 W 0 U 02.1=Xp�74[X3/027C9\=XDg9;54D � <V<>_1369\=«<\f¸3B5C9;74<>540 � �\�i£ � ��� � 9;=XD �Ö��� �+ôD�< ]BU W 3B=�7 W 9�7 ] [X3B0«7C[X3�l U 365 F .Ya�7C[X3�043B7'<\a�7C3B5 W 0'9\0204< ] .h9�7C36DÙ�y.Y7C[Ù7C[X3{D�< ]BU W 3B=�70C9�7C.108jg360m74[X3 � <^<\_13�9;=�3Úµ^fX543B0404.Y<>=�74[g9;7y5236fX5236043B=�7C0�74[X3kl U 365 F � s [X3�52360 U _Y7y<\ab7C[�3ql U 3B5 F .Y07C[�3q023B7K<\a W 9�7 ] [X.Y=Xp�DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 �

í¶ú à � à i ü d ý î ûbÞ i à ì�d sSà� s [X3«c\3 ] 7C<>5�02fg9 ] 3 W <VDX3B_�L Æ>Ç Nt36=X[X9\= ] 3B0¶7C[�3'DX< ]6U W 36=�7�5236fX52360236=�7:9;74.1<>=�<;am7C[X3 � <^<\_13�9;=W <^DX3B_ E�F 9\0402.1p>=X.Y=Xp©9���36.Yp>[�7�74<©369 ] [)7C3B5 W 74[g9;7�9\fXfi3�9\520�.Y=)9�DX< ]6U W 36=�7 � + D�< ]BU W 3B=�7.10q7C[X3B=�543BfX543B0436=�7436D³9\0Z9�c\3 ] 7C<>5�<;am7C365 W ��36.Yp>[�7C0 � s [X3'= U W�E 365¶<\ayDX. W 36=�04.1<\=X0�.Y=�7C[�3c>3 ] 74<>5m04fg9 ] 3/.Y0t36l U 9;_Ö7C<¶74[X3/= U W�E 365t<\a`7C3B5 W 0 U [email protected]=©74[X3/<}c>3B5C9\_Y_ÖDX< ]6U W 3B=�7 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �s [X3y�t3B.1p>[�7�<\a`9�7C3B5 W .Y=«9kDX< ]6U W 36=�7�.10 ] 9\_ ]BU _h9;7436D U 04.Y=Xp�9ka U = ] 7C.Y<>=�<\aÖ74[X3yan<>5 W �+�6�7�e�7� ��y[X3B543M�+� Ô 74365 W an543Bl U 36= ] F �t3B.1p>[�7 Õ .Y0�9«a U = ] 7C.Y<>=»<\aº7C[X3Z= U W¶E 3B5�<\a¹< ]B]6U 525436= ] 360k<\a¹7C[�37C3B5 W �y.¾7C[X.Y=�7C[X3KDX< ]6U W 36=�7 � 9\=�D����7� Ô .1=�c>3B54043KDX< ]6U W 36=�7¹an543Bl U 36= ] F ��36.Yp>[�7 Õ .10¹9\=�.1=�c\3654023a U = ] 7C.Y<>=@<\a¢74[X3�7C<\7C9\_I= U W�E 365y<\a¢DX< ]6U W 36=�740K74[g9;7 ] <\=�7C9\.1=%74[X3�7C365 W �+ l U 365 F .1=�74[X3'c>3 ] 74<>5�04fg9 ] 3 W <VDX36_�.10¶7454369;7C3BDÙ9;0Z.YaK.Y7���36523¶¼ U 027�9\=�<\7C[X3B5ZDX< ]6U W 36=�7 �9\_Y_1<}�y.1=Xp 7C[X3"049 W 3�c>3 ] 7C<>5@5236fX5236043B=�7:9;74.1<>=�7C< E 3 U 043BDan<>5«l U 3654.Y360�9\0'an<>5«DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 �s [X.Y0�5236fX52360236=�7:9;74.1<>=Ù=g9;7 U 5C9\_Y_ F _13�9;DX0Z7C<"7C[X3 U 043�<\a�7C[X3@c>3 ] 7C<\5©.Y=X=X365�fX52<^D UX] 740«9\0�7C[�3W 3�9\0 U 543�<\aº04. W .Y_h9\52.Y7 F©E 3�7É�t3B36=»7C[X3¶l U 365 F 9\=XD{9«DX< ]6U W 36=�7 � s [X.10 W 369\0 U 543�.Y0K7 F fX. ] 9\_Y_ F=X<>5 W 9;_1. ¿ 36D«an<\5oc>3 ] 7C<>5y_Y36=Xp\74[ � 0 UX] [�74[g9;7m7C[�3�9 ] 7 U 9\_I04. W .Y_h9\52.Y7 F�W 3�9\0 U 543�.Y0o7C[X3 ] <>04.Y=X3�<\a7C[�3¶9\=�p>_13 E 3B7É��363B={7C[X3k7É�t<�c>3 ] 7C<\540 � +Ka�7C3B5�9;_1_`<\a¢7C[X3kDX< ]6U W 36=�740�.1=%74[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�[X9}c\3E 3636= ] < W fg9\5236D�7C<�74[X3Kl U 365 F\� 74[X3�0 F 087C3 W 02<>52740¹74[X3�DX< ]6U W 3B=�740 E�F DX3 ] 54369\04.Y=Xp¶02. W .1_19\54.¾7 FW 3�9\0 U 543q9\=XD�543�7 U 52=X0K9Z5C9\=X´;36D�_1.1087C.Y=Xp�<\a¢DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0�9\0m7C[�3q52360 U _Y7y<\ab7C[�3ql U 3B5 F �

z}Å

Page 27: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

Query

d1 d2

r1

c1

r2

c2 c3

r3

c

dn

rm

dn-1

m

Concepts

Documents

Query Concepts

Document

Network

Query

Network

... ... ...

.... ... ...

.... ... ...

Qõ ò ß�%býÂà �Iÿ¦þgÿ ,/< ]BU W 36=�7y543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_I.Y=�an365236= ] 3k=X3B7É��<>54´

í¶ú à{Ýqý d �bÞ�� ò ò gBü ò_i ì�d sbà` s [X3�fX54< E 9 E .1_Y.1087C. ] 543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_ W <^DX3B_pL � Ç NK.10 E 9\0236D�<>=7C[�3)?A54< E 9 E .Y_1.Y7 F u 9;=X´�.1=Xp�?A54.1= ] . ½fX_Y3�L Æ�Ä N � �y[X. ] ["027:9�7C360k7C[X9;7k9\= .1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>=�523B7454.13�c;9\_e0 F 087C3 W .Y0 W <\027�3�ØÖ3 ] 7C.¾c>3��y[X36= .Y7543B04fi<>=XDX0�74<"9\=�3�µ^fX5236020436DÙ.1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>=�=�3636D�y.Y74[�9{_1.Y027¶<\aKDX< ]BU W 36=�7C0Z549\=X´\3BD.1=�7C[�3DX3 ] 54369\04.Y=Xp»<>52DX365�<;a�f�54< E 9 E .1_Y.Y7 F <\ay5236_13�c;9\= ] 3 � 9\=XD�7C[�3'fX54< E 9 E .Y_1.Y74.13B0�9;543'3B027C. W 9�7C36D9;09 ]B]6U 549;7C3B_ F 9\0�fi<>0204. E _13qp>.Yc\36=»9\_Y_`7C[X3¶9}c;9\.Y_h9 E _13�.1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>= � J =�7C[X.Y0 W <^DX3B_ � 74[X3Z9\=X08�t3B57C<�9�l U 3B5 F .10�p>3B=X36549;7C3BD E�F 36087C. W 9;74.1=Xp�� Ô_�O �¡¢ k£�¤¦¥ ��§¨� Õ Ô 7C[�3�fX52< E 9 E .1_1.¾7 F <\a�7C[X3�.1=^an<>5 ½W 9;7C.Y<>=@=X363BD E 3B.1=Xp�0C9�7C.108jg36D�p>.Yc\36=�DX< ]BU W 36=�7�� Õ an<>5y3Bc\365 F DX< ]6U W 3B=�7 � 9\=XD)549\=X´�.1=�p©7C[�3DX< ]6U W 36=�740©9 ]6] <\54DX.Y=Xp{7C<»7C[�36043@3B027C. W 9�7C360 � R 04.1=�p � 9 F 360bPº74[X36<\543 W 9\=XD³9{043�7©<;a�.Y=XDX3 ½fi36=XDX3B= ] 3�9\020 U W f�7C.Y<>=X0@9 E < U 7«7C[X3"DX.Y027C52. E U 7C.1<\=�<\ak7C3B5 W 0%.1=�DX< ]6U W 36=�740�9;=XD�l U 3654.Y360 �� Ô_�O �¡_ k£`¤¦¥ ��§ � Õ ] 9\= E 3�3�µ^fX543B040236D³9\0�9�a U = ] 7C.Y<>=�<;at7C[�3«fX52< E 9 E .Y_1.¾7C.13B0/<\a�7C[X3�7C3B5 W 0�.Y=v�9\fXfi3�9;54.1=�p'.1={5236_Y3Bc;9\=�7k9\=XD»=�<>= ½ 5236_Y3Bc;9\=�7�DX< ]6U W 36=�740 � ,/.Yظ365236=�7/.Y=XDX36fi36=�DX36= ] 3�9\040 U W f ½7C.Y<>=X0�_13�9;D)7C<%DX.¾ØÖ3B543B=�7�an<>5 W 0�<\aA74[X3¶a U = ] 7C.Y<>= � s [X3 W <>087/fi<>f U _19\5�a U = ] 74.1<>=X0/9\543�.Y=)7C[�3] 9�7C36p\<>5 F <;a!�+�~���e�7�{087 F _Y3 �

í¶ú à óba�c àVýÂà a i à ä à�üC© d ýtª ì�d sbà` s [X3o.Y=�an365236= ] 3o=X3�7É�t<>52´ W <^D�36_�L � Ä N�p\36=X3B5C9\_Y. ¿ 3B0¢74[X3ofX52< E 9 E .Y_1.Y027C. ] W <VDX3B_ E�F c^.Y3B�y.Y=Xp/.1=^an<>5 ½W 9;7C.Y<>=�543�7C52.13Bc;9\_�9\0º9\=�.1=^an36543B= ] 3m<\5e3BcV.1D�36=�7C.19\_X54369\04<\=X.1=Xp�f�54< ] 36020 � +�=�.Y=�an365236= ] 3m=X3B7É��<>52´

z>z

Page 28: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

.10®9�DX.Y543 ] 7C3BD � 9 ] F ] _1. ] DX36fi36=�DX36= ] F p>549\fX[ Ô ,K+ OqÕ .Y=¶�y[X. ] [Z=�<^DX3B0e543BfX543B043B=�7¹fX52<>fi<>04.¾7C.1<\=g9\_c;9\54.19 E _Y360b<>5 ] <>=X087:9\=�7C0º9;=XD�36D�p>360e5236fX52360236=�7ºDX36fi36=�DX36= ] 3y5436_19;7C.Y<>=X0 E 3B7É��3636=�fX52<>fi<>04.¾7C.1<\=X0 �J a¸9/fX54<\f¸<>02.Y74.1<>=�5236fX52360236=�7C3BD E�F =X<VDX3F«1R ] 9 U 02360+S�<>5®. W fX_1.Y360`7C[X3mf�54<>fi<>04.¾7C.Y<>=¶5236fX5236043B=�7C36DE�F =X<VDX3n¬ � ��3¶DX549}��9�DX.Y543 ] 7C3BD�3BDXp>3kan54< W «)7C<m¬ � s [X3�=X<VDX3�¬ ] <>=�7:9;.1=X0�9 ¡ � ¥=­�®�¤ � � �j¯7C[X9;7¶02f¸3 ] .¾jg360M� Ô ¬ § « Õ an<\5¶9\_Y_ºf¸<>0204. E _13�c;9\_ U 3B0�<;ao7C[X3�7É�t<{c;9\52.h9 E _1360 � � [X36=�9)=X<VDX3«[g9;0W U _¾7C.YfX_13�fg9;5436=�740 � 74[X3�_1.Y=X´ W 9;7C52.¾µ�02f¸3 ] .YjX360�74[X3¶DX3Bf¸3B=XDX3B= ] 3Z<>=�7C[X3�023B7�<\aºfg9\5236=�7C0�9;=XD] [g9\549 ] 743652. ¿ 3B0¹74[X3KDX36fi36=XD�36= ] 3�543B_h9;74.1<>=�04[X.Yf E 3B7É��363B=«7C[X9;7¹=X<^D�3�9;=XD'9\_Y_X=X<VDX360º5236fX5236043B=�7 ½.1=�p�.Y7C0®f¸<\7436=�7C.19\_ ] 9 U 02360 � O .Yc\36=�9�043�7º<\aifX54.Y<>5efX52< E 9 E .1_1.¾7C.Y360San<>5®7C[�3m54<V<\7A<\a�7C[�3y,K+ O � 7C[�3=X3�7É�t<>52´ ] 9\= E 3 U 0436D 7C< ] < W f U 7C3�7C[�3�f�54< E 9 E .1_Y.Y7 F <>5�DX36p\54363�<\a E 3B_1.Y3Ba�9\0402< ] .h9;7436D»�y.Y74[9\_Y_Ö543 W 9;.1=X.Y=XpZ=X<VDX360 �s [X3�.1=�an3B5436= ] 3¶=�3B7É��<>54´ W <VDX3B_ U 043BD{an<>5 J = Á U 365 F L z ËON � 04[X<}�y=».1= w .Yp U 543 Ä � z>� ] <\=X04.Y027C0�<\a7É��< ] < W fi<>=X3B=�7y=X3B7É��<>54´�0 � 9ZDX< ]6U W 36=�7K=X3B7É��<>52´@9\=XD�9Zl U 365 F =�3B7É��<>54´ � s [X3�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7=X3�7É�t<>52´ ] <>=X02.102740«<\akD�< ]BU W 3B=�7«=X<VDX3B0 Ô �#� Õ � 9\=XD ] <>= ] 36f�7'5436f�54360236=�7:9�7C.1<\=�=X<VDX360 Ô_� � Õ � +DX< ]6U W 36=�7t=X<^D�3 ] <>52543B04fi<>=XDX0t74<Z9¶DX< ]6U W 3B=�7 � + ] <>= ] 3Bf�7m=X<VDX3 ] <>52543602f¸<\=XDX0o7C<�9\='.1=�DX3�µU =X.¾7 � 9�7C3B5 W <>5©9�fX[�5C9\023 � s [X3)_Y.1=X´�an52< W 9v�#��=X<^D�3�7C<�9 � �'=�<^DX3 W 369\=X0�7C[g9�7«7C[�3DX< ]6U W 36=�7;�#�`.Y0mR49 E < U 7�S�7C[X3�fg9;527C. ]6U _19\5 ] <>= ] 36f�7 � � � s [X3�l U 365 F =X3B7É��<>52´ ] <>=�04.1087C0m<\ab7C[�3l U 365 F ] <>= ] 36f�7�=X<^D�360 Ô_° � Õ 9;=XD)7C[�3�l U 3B5 F =X<^D�3 Ôj± Õ � + l U 365 F ] <>= ] 3Bf�7 ] <>54523604fi<>=XD�0�7C<«9E 9\02. ]ZU =�.Y7 U 0236D�74< ] <>=X087C5 UX] 7¶9%l U 365 F � s [�3©l U 3B5 F ] <\= ] 3Bf�7q=X<^D�360qDX3Bjg=�3�74[X3 W 9;fXfX.1=�pE 3B7É��3636= 7C[X3 ] <>= ] 3Bf�7C0k.Y="74[X3ZDX< ]6U W 36=�7 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=»9;=XD»7C[X3 ] <\= ] 3Bf�7C0k.1=»74[X3Zl U 365 F � J =J = Á U 3B5 F>� 3�9 ] [³l U 365 F ] <>= ] 36f^7©[X9\0�3�µ�9 ] 74_ F <\=X3%fg9\5236=�7�.1=�7C[X3@DX< ]6U W 3B=�7�=�3B7É��<>54´ � +l U 365 F =X<VDX3k5436f�54360236=�7C0�9\[email protected]=XD�.YcV.1D U 9\_Öl U 3B5 F �s [X3'.Y=�an365236= ] 3'=X3�7É�t<>52´�.Y0 U 0236D E�F 9;727:9 ] [�.1=Xp�7C[X3'l U 3B5 F =X3B7É��<>54´ 7C<)74[X3«_Y3�9�c>3B0Z<\am7C[�3DX< ]6U W 36=�7�=X3B7É��<>52´ � s <�fX54<VD UX] 3¶9 E 36_1.Y3Ba¢0 ] <>543kan<>5yDX< ]6U W 36=�7[�t� � ��3¶9;040 U W 3k7C[g9�7��t���� �l²�  9;=XDM�¦�;�³� ¤B¡_´�  an<>5®9;_1_ ­¶µ��· � 9\=XD ] <>=XDX.¾7C.Y<>=q74[X3ofX52< E 9 E .1_1.¾7C.Y360I7C[�54< U p\[¶7C[X3�=X3B7É��<>52´7C<�< E 7:9\.Y=�� Ô¢¸ §¨�t� Õ � J = J = Á U 365 F\� 7C[X3 E 36_Y.13Bagc;9\_ U 3 ª���¹ ¥ �n� �º�ºan<>5 ] <>= ] 3Bf�7 � ��.Y=ZDX< ]BU W 36=�7*�t�¹.Y09;�+�x�»�e�7��087 F _13�a U = ] 74.1<>= � s [X3tc;9\_ U 3¹<\a ª���¹ ¥ �n� �º�A.10b_h9;54p>3B5S�y[�36= � ��< ]B]6U 520 W <>543ºan543Bl U 36=�7C_ F .Y=

zÂÄ

Page 29: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

7C[�3��l��9\=XD�_13B040ean5236l U 36=�74_ F .Y=�7C[X3y36=�74.1543 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � s [X3y0 F 02743 W fX5236043B=�7C0º7C[X3mDX< ]6U W 3B=�7407C< U 0236520 E�F 7C[�3q<\54DX3B5m<\a¢74[X36.Y5 E 3B_1.13�ab0 ] <\54360 �

�Iÿ¦þ�ÿT� óQa sbà ÷Sò a ßJ =XDX3Úµ^.1=Xp».Y0�9)087:9\=XDX9\54D ] < W fi<>=X3B=�7�.1=�9)543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_¹0 F 02743 W 7C<{. W fX52<}c>3©74[X3'023�9\5 ] [³3�À ½] .Y36= ] F �eT .1p>=X9;7 U 523¹jX_1360xL Ä\Ì N^9\=XD�.1=�c>3B527436D�.Y=XDX3�µqjg_Y360xL Æ ËON^9\543º7É��</f¸<\f U _h9;5bDX9;7:9y02745 UX] 7 U 52360an<>5/.Y=XDX3Úµ�.Y=Xp � +Ó02.1p>=g9�7 U 523¶jg_13 ] <>=�7C9\.1=X0�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7�04.Yp>=g9;7 U 543B0 � <>=�3�an<>5/3�9 ] [ D�< ]BU W 3B=�7.1= 7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � +ÛDX< ]BU W 36=�7�02.1p>=g9�7 U 523©.Y0�9 E .Y7 ½ 027454.1=�p ] 543�9�7C36D E�F 9\fXf�_ F .1=Xp)9�[g9;04[a U = ] 7C.Y<>=%7C<�3�9 ] [@7C3B5 W .1=%7C[X3�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7 � , U 54.Y=XpZl U 365 F 3Bc;9\_ U 9;74.1<>= � 7C[X3k0 F 087C3 W ] 54369;7C3B09'04.Yp>=g9;7 U 543�an<>5�74[X3Zl U 365 F .1={74[X3�049 W 3��o9 F 9;0/an<>5�DX< ]6U W 3B=�740k9\=XD W 9;7 ] [�360/7C[�3Zl U 365 F7C<¶9¶DX< ]6U W 36=�7 � .¾aÖ7C[�3�.1=�743654023 ] 7C.1<\='<\aI74[X3�l U 3B5 F 04.1p\=g9;7 U 543�9\=XD%9qDX< ]BU W 36=�7o02.1p>=g9�7 U 523�.Y036l U 9;_X7C<�7C[X3yl U 3B5 F 04.Yp>=g9;7 U 543 � H <}��3Bc\365¹04.1= ] 3yDX.Yظ365236=�7º7C3B5 W 0 W 9 F [X9}c\3K74[X3y0C9 W 3m04.Yp>=g9 ½7 U 543 � 9�DX< ]6U W 36=�7º7C[X9;7¹DX<^3B0º=X<\7 W 9;7 ] [�7C[X3yl U 3B5 F .1=Za¦9 ] 7 ] < U _1D E 3oÏ�9;p>p>36D©9\0 W 9;7 ] [X.Y=Xp ��y[X. ] [�.Y0 ] 9\_Y_136D �B�$¹Ð�}�/¬V¥�� ¯ T .1p>=g9�7 U 523/jg_13B0y7 F fX. ] 9\_Y_ F 0 U f�f¸<>587y7C[X3 � <V<>_1369\= W <^DX3B_I<>=X_ F �+�=.Y=�c\36587C36D.Y=XDX3�µ�jg_13 ] <>=�7:9;.1=X0�9\=�.Y=�c>36587C3BDÙ_Y.1027�an<>5¶3�c>3B5 F 7C3B5 W 7C[g9;7Z9\fXfi3�9\520Z.1=�7C[�3] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � +ô74365 W P 0«.1=�c\36527436D�_1.Y027©.1DX3B=�7C.YjX360%9\_Y_y<\a�7C[X3)DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0«74[g9;7 ] <>=�7:9;.1=�7C[�3] <\54543B04fi<>=XDX.Y=XpZ7C3B5 W � , U 54.Y=XpZl U 365 F 3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>= � 74[X3k0 F 02743 W W 9;7 ] [�360m7C[X3kl U 3B5 F 74<�D�< ]Ú½U W 36=�7C0 E�F < E 7C9\.1=X.Y=Xpm7C[X3º.Y=�c\36587C36D¶_1.1087Ian<>5`7C[�3�l U 3B5 F 7C3B5 W 0¢9;=XD�f�54< ] 360204.Y=Xp�74[X3�D�< ]BU W 3B=�736=�7454.13B0y.1=%7C[X<\043k_1.Y027C0 � J =�c>3B527C3BD)jg_Y360y9\523kc\365 F Ïg3�µ^. E _13q9\=XD@0 U fXfi<>527�9\_Y_Ö543�7C52.13Bc;9\_ W <VDX36_Y0 �u 3 ] 3B=�7C_ F G < E 36_ ���b�$¹¾¯ L � | NVp>.¾c>3 E <\74[Z9\=g9\_ F 7C. ] 9\_�9\=XD¶3 W fX.152. ] 9;_>543B0 U _¾7C0®74[g9;7¢04[X<}�³.1=�c>3B527436Djg_Y360q9\543�0 U f¸3B54.1<\5/7C<�04.1p\=g9;7 U 543Zjg_13B0�.Y= 9\_1_A9;04fi3 ] 740 � 5436p>9\54DX_Y36020�<\a�7C[X3�523B7C52.13�c\9;_ W <VDX36_Y0 �J = Á U 3B5 F U 02360K.1=�c>3B527C3BD�jX_1360 �

�Iÿ¦þ�ÿT� é�¼ à i ü ònï à a à�gQgs [X3K3Bظ3 ] 7C.Yc\36=X3B040m<\aI9q523B7454.13�c;9\_g0 F 02743 W .10¹9 W 369\0 U 523�<;aI[X<}����36_Y_�74[X3K0 F 02743 W 5C9\=�´V0�543B_13 ½c;9\=�7oDX< ]6U W 3B=�740o9\[�3�9\D©<\a`=X<>= ½ 543B_13�c\9;=�7�<>=X3B0 � J =©74[X.10º7C[�3604.Y0 � �t3K�y.1_1_ U 043�R23�ØÖ3 ] 74.Yc>3B=X36020�S7C<¶543Ban3B5t7C<¶543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_¸9 ]6]BU 5C9 ] F 3Úµ^fX_1. ] .Y74_ F\� 9;=XD�R2fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3bS�74<�543�an365t74<�3�µ^3 ]BU 7C.Y<>='7C. W 3

z}Ç

Page 30: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

9\=XD 0 F 087C3 W 74[X54< U p>[Xf U 7 � s [X3�7É��< W <>087��y.1DX3B_ F U 0436D�543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_e3�ØÖ3 ] 74.Yc>3B=X36020 W 3�9\0 U 543B09\523 ÝqýÂà i�ò g ò d�a Ô ? Õ 9;=XD ñ à i Þ� j Ô u�Õ DX3Bjg=�36D{9;0oan<>_1_Y<Â�y0 �

?A543 ] .102.1<>=�� N U W¶E 3B5K<;a®5236_13�c;9\=�7�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0y543�7 U 52=X36DN U W¶E 3B5m<\a®D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0K543B7 U 54=�36D

u 3 ] 9\_Y_ � N U W�E 365m<\a®5436_Y3Bc;9\=�7yDX< ]6U W 36=�740K523B7 U 54=X3BDs <\7C9\_I= U W�E 365y<\a¢543B_13�c\9;=�7KDX< ]6U W 3B=�740y.1=%7C[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0

�?A543 ] .102.1<>=·.10'9 W 369\0 U 543{<\ak02f¸3 ] .19\_1.¾7 Fv½ [X<}�×�t3B_1_y7C[X3{0 F 027C3 W 523B7C52.13�c>360«<>=X_ F 5236_13�c;9\=�7DX< ]6U W 36=�740 � u 3 ] 9\_Y_®.10/9 W 369\0 U 523�<\a ] < W fX_Y3B7436=X3B040 ½ [X<}�-�t3B_1_®74[X3�0 F 087C3 W 523B7454.13�c>3B0k9\_1_7C[�3�5236_13�c;9\=�7�DX< ]6U W 3B=�740 � J =�fX5C9 ] 7C. ] 3 � 3Bظ3 ] 74.Yc\36=X3B040�.10y3�c\9;_ U 9;7436D E�F 7É�t< W 3B74[X<VDX0 � s [X3jg52027 W 3B74[X<^D¶.10®74</fX543B043B=�7A74[X3mfX523 ] .Y04.Y<>=¶jgp U 54360e9;7A043B_13 ] 7C3BD�= U W�E 3B540e<;a¸D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0 � 0 UX] [9\0 Î^�¢z�Å��¢z}Î^�IÄ;Å�� 9;=XD Î\Å DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 � s [X3�043 ] <>=XD»<>=�3�.10y7C<©fX_1<\7�fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>={9;7�027C9\=XDg9\52D_13�c>3B_o<\ay543 ] 9\_Y_10 � s [�3 z>z f¸<\.1=�7 u È ? W 3�7C[X<VD�DX3BjX=X360ZfX523 ] .104.Y<>=9;7�74[X3 z>z 523 ] 9\_1_�_13Bc\36_Y0Å � Å��IÅ � z>�¸Å � Ä^� �¾�¾� �¢z � Å ��T .Y= ] 3�543 ] 9\_1_b.1= ] 54369\043B0�9;7�DX.10 ] 543�7C3�fi<>.Y=�740K74[g9;7�DX<'=X<\7�=X3 ] 36020C9\52.1_ F] <\54543B04fi<>=XD«74<q74[X36023 z>z f¸<\.1=�7C0 � 9k027C9\=XDg9\52D'.1=�743654fi<>_19;7C.Y<>=�9\_1p\<>54.¾7C[ W .10 U 043BD«7C< ] 9\_ ]6U _19;7C3fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>= 9;7 z>z f¸<\.1=�7C0mL Æ ËON � J ="7C[X.Y0/7C[X3B04.10 � �t3 U 023 �¦�C�¿¾ ��À��$¹ L Ç>Ì N � 9 syu à r 3�c\9;_ U 9;74.1<>=fX52<>p>5C9 W�� 7C< ] 9\_ ]6U _19;7C3�74[X3kfX543 ] .Y04.1<\= ½ 523 ] 9;_1_¸7C9 E _Y3 �

Uw)VU &Á.X0�9C240 8\<>A�:=.Â249@ �?7W`EY0 ?G36Z[E�.X� �BA�9C240 8\<FE�?724A �H.IEY0 ?G.=JK<>5,/.1087C52. E U 7436D JLu 0 F 02743 W 0º36=g9 E _13 U 0236520e7C<�04. W U _¾7:9\=X3B< U 02_ F 9 ]6] 36020 W U _Y74.1fX_Y3¹743�µV7 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0DX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D�<}c>3B5�7C[�3�=X3�7É�t<\54´ � += U W¶E 3B5�<\aÖ027 U DX.13B0t[g9�c\3�.1=�c\360274.1p�9�7C36D�7C[�3�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3<\a�DX.1087C54. E U 7436D JLu 0 F 02743 W 0ÃL z>z>�mzÂÄ��yz}Ç^�¹Ä\Å^� Ë z>�¹Î\ÇV�¹Î\Æ��¹Î\Ì��¹Î;|^� � Å^� � z N � d�<>087«<;a�7C[�3fX523BcV.1< U 0k��<>52´»3�µ^f¸3B54. W 3B=�740q�y.¾7C[ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0/_Y36020q74[g9\= z O � 9\=XD"an< ]BU 043B0�<>= 04fi363BD U f<\a�l U 365 F fX54< ] 3B0404.Y=Xpan<>5@9\= U =X_Y<�9\DX3BD�0 F 087C3 W �y[X36=!9 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�.10%DX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D�<}c>3B5043�c>3B5C9\_�043658c>3B540�L z>z>� Ë z;�®Î;Ç��¢Î\Æ��¢Î\Ì^�¢Î\| N � M =X_ F r < U cV543 U 5 ���/�$¹¾¯ L Ä\Å N � 9\=XD r 9\[X<V<>=�9;=XDd ] � .Y=X_13 F L zÂÄ^�`z}Ç N U 043k02. W U _19;7C.Y<>=«74<�3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�7y�y.Y74[ W <>523/7C[g9;= z}Å\Å O � <\a¢Dg9;7:9 �

z Ë

Page 31: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

d)9 ] _13B<^D ���t�$¹¾¯ � �tU 54´;<}�y04´�. � 9\=XD)d)9\587C.Y= ���t�$¹¾¯ E U .1_¾7m7C[X3B.15mDX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D JLu 0 F 027C3 W 0�<>=�9=X3�7É�t<>52´"<\atc\365 F 02_1<}�Q023652c\36520�L z\z\� Ë z\�¢Î\ÆV�bÎ\Ì��bÎ\| N � s [X3 W 9 ] [X.Y=X360�74[X3 F U 0236D�9;543 J � d? r È Í s � J � d ? r È + s � 9;=XD·+�fXfX_13)d)9 ] .1=�7C<\04[ J2J � 9\=XD³7C[X3�_1.Y=X´�02f¸3B36D�.Y0 |\Æ>Å>Å"E 9 U D �d)9 ] _13B<^D ���m�$¹¾¯ 3Úµ�f�_1<>523q087C549;7C3Bp>.13B0yan<\5KD�.1027454. E U 7C.Y=Xp�7C[�3�.Y=XDX3�µ@jX_13k9\=XD�7C[X3�743�µV7�jX_13�L Î;Æ N ��tU 52´\<}�y04´�. ] < W fg9\543B0 U =X.Yan<>5 W _ F DX.Y027454. E U 7C.Y=Xpk043658c>3B5ta U = ] 7C.1<\=g9\_1.¾7 F c\36540 U 0o02fX_1.¾747C.Y=Xp�a U = ]Ú½7C.Y<>=g9\_Y.Y7 F 9 ] 52<>040q7C[X3�043B52c\36540kL z\z N � H 9\5 W 9\= �����$¹¾¯ 543Bf¸<\527�f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�.1=�9�D�.1027454. E U 7C3BDfX52<\7C<\7 F fi3�0 F 087C3 W U 04.Y=Xp'087:9;74.10274. ] 9\_S5C9\=X´�.Y=XpÃL Ë z N � d)9;527C.Y= ���y�$¹¾¯ ] <\=X04.YDX365K7C[X3�3�ØÖ3 ] 740/<\ac;9\54.Y< U 0yDg9;7C9 ] 9 ] [X.Y=Xp©087C549;7C3Bp>.13B0K<\= E 52<Â�y02.1=Xp©9\=XD�04369\5 ] [�543602f¸<\=X043q7C. W 3mL Î\Ì��iÎ\| N �mT .1= ] 37C[�36043t3�9\52_ F ��<>54´�0e3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�7b�y.Y74[¶<>52DX36520®<\a W 9\p>=�.Y7 U DX3º04_1<}��365 W 9 ] [�.1=X3B0®9\=�D�=X3B7É��<>52´V0 �7C[�3q.Y=�7C3652fX543�7:9;74.1<>=@<\ab7C[�36.15m52360 U _Y740�9;543�[g9\52D�74<�9\fXfX_ F 7C<�7C<VDg9 F P 0y0 F 087C3 W 0 �P .1=%9;=XD G [X< U . W fX_13 W 3B=�7t9¶DX.Y027454. E U 7C3BD JLu 0 F 027C3 W <>=@9�=X3B7É��<>54´©<\a U f'74< z}Å ,�à r Î\Å>Å\Å��<>54´�027C9;7C.Y<>=X0 U 02.1=Xp�? Ñ d Ô ?®9\549\_1_Y36_ Ñ .Y527 U 9\_Id�9 ] [X.1=�3 Õ 7C< ] <^<\54DX.Y=g9;7C3K�t<\54´'9;=XD%=X3B7É��<>52´] < W©W U =X. ] 9;7C.Y<>=�L Î\Ç N � s [X3 F U 043�9oc\9;54.h9�7C.1<\=�<\a^74[X3º04.Yp>=g9;7 U 543Ajg_Y3¹3B= ] <VDX.Y=Xpy0 ] [X3 W 3º7C< W 9;fDX< ]6U W 36=�7 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0/<}c>365�74[X3�=X3B7É��<>54´ � s [X3 F 3�µ^fi3654. W 3B=�7��y.Y7C[ 9 z}Å>Å d �-] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=9\=XD"9 Ä;Å>Å d ��] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=)9\=XD»02[X<}�ö_19\54p>3�04fi363BD U fX0�an<>5�9«04.Y=Xp>_13�l U 365 F D U 3¶74<%fg9\549\_1_Y36_DX.Y04´%9 ]B] 3B040 �s < W 9;04. ] ���º�$¹¾¯ 3�µ�9 W .1=�3Kan< U 5�fi<>0402. E _Y3�D�.1027454. E U 7C3BD©<\54p�9\=�. ¿ 9�7C.1<\=�an<\5¹74[X3�.Y=�c\36587C36D«.1=XDX. ] 3B0.1={9 E <V<>_1369\={523B7C52.13�c\9;_¢0 F 087C3 W�� 0 F 027C3 W�� [�<>027 � J È M E U 0 � 9;=XD»0 F 02743 W <\54p�9\=�. ¿ 9�7C.1<\=X0L � Å��� z N � J =)7C[X3�0 F 02743 W <>54p�9;=X. ¿ 9;7C.Y<>= � .1=�c\36527436D»_Y.102740�9;543¶D�.1027454. E U 7C3BD)3�c>36=�_ F 9 ] 52<>040�9;_1_`DX.Y04´�0.1="7C[�3©0 F 087C3 W 9;=XD�369 ] [�DX.Y04´»[X<\_1DX0�7C[�3©049 W 3�= U W�E 365q<\a�7C365 W 0b{ J =�74[X3�[X<>027¶9\=XD J È ME U 0�<>54p>9\=X. ¿ 9;7C.Y<>=X0 � DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0t9\543�DX.1087C54. E U 7436D�3Bc>3B=X_ F <}c>3B5t[X<>087C0�<>5 J È M E U 043B0 � 9;=XD«7C[�3.1=�c\36527436D�_1.Y027C0m<\=�369 ] [�[X<>027K9;=XD J È M E U 0K9\523�3Bc\36=X_ F DX.1087C52. E U 7436D@<}c>3B5KD�.104´�0K9;727:9 ] [X3BD�74<7C[�3m[X<>027¹9;=XD J È M E U 0Q{ J =Z7C[X3mDX.Y04´q<>54p>9\=X. ¿ 9;7C.Y<>= � DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0º9\523mDX.1087C52. E U 7436DZ3�c>36=�_ F <}c>3B59\_Y_ÖDX.Y04´�0K9\=XD�9\=�.1=�c>3B527C3BD�.Y=XDX3Úµ@.10 E U .1_¾7oan<>5m3�9 ] [�DX.Y04´ � s [X3 F <\ØÖ3B5m3 W fX.152. ] 9\_Ö52360 U _Y7C0oan<\50 F 087C3 W 0y�y.Y7C[ U f@7C<�Ë�[X<>087C0 U 04.Y=Xp E <\74[@0 F =�7C[X3�7C. ] 9\=XD�9 ] 7 U 9\_I��<>52´V_Y<�9\DX0 � s [X36.Y5K52360 U _Y740U 02.1=Xp�0 F =�74[X3B74. ] �t<\54´�_1<�9;DX0'7C[g9�7@5436f�54360236=�7C0�9�_13Bp�9\_�DX< ]BU W 36=�7@Dg9;7C9 E 9\023"9\=XD�9\020 U W 3l U 365 F 7C365 W 0�9\523 U =X.Yan<\5 W _ F DX.1087C54. E U 7436D³04[X<}� 74[g9;7�7C[X3�[X<>087«<\54p�9\=�. ¿ 9�7C.1<\=�.10Z0 U f¸3B54.1<\5

zÂÎ

Page 32: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

9\=XD�7C[X3K0 F 087C3 W <>52p�9\=X. ¿ 9;74.1<>=Zfi3658an<>5 W 0¹��<>52027�D U 3�74<q74[X3 E <\727C_Y36=X3 ] ´�<;a P 9\= E 9\=XD��y.YD�7C[ �s [X3B.15K54360 U _Y740 U 04.1=�p'9 ] 7 U 9\_`��<>54´�_Y<�9\DX0yan54< W 9 Ä O � JLN T ?ºÃ r 9 E 087C5C9 ] 7�Dg9;7:9 E 9\043q�y[X36523.1=�c\36527436D�_1.1087C0m��36543q543B_h9;74.Yc\36_ F 04[X<\527�04[X<}��74[g9;7K7C[X3k0 F 087C3 W <>52p�9\=X. ¿ 9;74.1<>=%fi3658an<>5 W 0 E 3B027 �E 3 ] 9 U 043%.¾7�DX<V360�=�<\7Zfg9 F 74<{04f�_1.Y7�7C[X3«04[X<>587Z_1.Y02740�9 ] 54<>020�7C[X3'[�<>02740 � s [X36.Y5¶543B0 U _¾7C0 ] 9\==X<\7�DX.Y543 ] 7C_ F 9\fXfX_ F 7C<�< U 5q0 F 02743 W 0 �AE 3 ] 9 U 043�7C[X3©l U 365 F 7C3B5 W 0�.Y=�< U 5�3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�740�9\52304´;3B��36D � < U 5A523B7C52.13�c\9;_X0 F 02743 W .Y0A9/a U _1_ ½ 7C3ÚµV7A543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_^0 F 02743 W U 02.1=Xp�7C[�3K.Y=�an365236= ] 3m=X3B7É��<>52´W <^DX3B_ � 9\=XD@�t3k3�µ^fi3652. W 36=�7y�y.Y7C[ U f@7C<�9Z7C3B5C9 E�F 7C3k<\a¢7C3�µV7 �u . E 36.152< ½ N 3B74< ���¹�$¹¾¯ ] < W fg9\523�74[X3�p>_Y< E 9\_�.Y=XDX3�µ©<>52p�9\=X. ¿ 9;74.1<>= Ô 0 F 027C3 W <>52p�9\=X. ¿ 9;74.1<>= Õ 9;=XD7C[�3�_Y< ] 9\_e.Y=XDX3�µ»<>54p�9;=X. ¿ 9;7C.Y<>= Ô DX.Y04´{<\54p�9\=�. ¿ 9�7C.1<\= Õ an<>5q9%543�7C52.13Bc;9\_A0 F 027C3 W E 9\043BD�<>="7C[�3c>3 ] 74<>5%04fg9 ] 3 W <VDX3B_ U 02.1=Xp9 z O � syu à r Ç ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=·9\=XD Î\Å syu à r Ç l U 3B54.13B0¶L Æ^z N �s [X3 F 04[X<}�Ó7C[X9;7�7C[X3�p>_Y< E 9\_e.Y=XDX3Úµ"<>54p>9\=X. ¿ 9;7C.Y<>=»fi3652an<\5 W 0 E 3�747C3B5�7C[g9\="7C[�3©_Y< ] 9\_e.1=�DX3�µ<>52p�9\=X. ¿ 9;74.1<>="�y[X36= U 02.1=Xp»9 z�Å>Å d E f�0Z=X3B7É��<>54´ �¹E U 7Zfi3658an<>5 W 0���<>52043'�y[X3B= U 04.1=�p"9 Ìd E f�0m=X3B7É��<>54´ � J =%< U 5�0 F 02743 W�� ��3�DX<�=X<\7�a¦9�c><>5t74[X3/p>_Y< E 9\_�.Y=XDX3�µ«<>52p�9\=X. ¿ 9;74.1<>= Ô 0 F 087C3 W<>52p�9\=X. ¿ 9;74.1<>= Õ �\E 3 ] 9 U 043K< U 5º0 F 087C3 W fX54< ] 3B04043B0 Ç <>54D�36540º<\a W 9\p>=X.¾7 U DX3o9\0 W UX] [�Dg9;7:9 � 9;=XD��3'.1=�c>3B0274.1p�9;743©fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3«. W fX52<}c>3 W 36=�740¶D U 3�7C<�043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp»9)0 W 9\_Y_Af¸<\527C.Y<>= <\amDg9;7C9.1=�027C369\D�<\ae9;_1_¸74[X3kDg9;7C9 �r < U cV523 U 5 �����$¹¾¯ 9\=X9\_ F ¿ 3�7C[X3)f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3{9;=XD ] <>087'a¦9 ] 7C<>520«<\ak023�9\5 ] [X.1=Xp�_19\54p\3�743�µV7] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 Ô U f·7C< z>zÂÄ O � Õ L Ä\Å N � s [�3 F U 043�04. W U _h9;74.1<>= W <^D�36_10Z74<�.1=�c>3B0274.1p�9;743�74[X543B3DX.¾ØÖ3B5436=�7�[g9\52D��o9;543�9\5 ] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 54360t9\=XD�04369\5 ] [%9;_1p><>52.Y74[ W 0®.1= ] _ U DX.Y=Xpq9 W 9\.Y=�an5C9 W 3o0 F 087C3 WU 02.1=Xp�9;=�.1=�c>3B527436D�_1.Y027 JLu 0 F 087C3 W�� 9 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=¶<\a uKJ T r fX52< ] 360204<>520 U 04.Y=Xp�9�0 U f¸3B54. W fi<>043BDJLu 0 F 02743 W�� 9\=�D'9k04fi3 ] .19\_�f U 52f¸<>023 W 9 ] [X.Y=X3K9\5 ] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 543�74[g9;7 U 043B0o9qDX.1523 ] 7¹023�9\5 ] [ � s [X3an< ]6U 0�<\aA7C[X3q�t<\54´�.10�<\=»9\=g9\_ F ¿ .1=�p©7C[�3�7C549\DX3B<\Ø E 3B7É��363B="f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�9;=XD ] <\027 � s [X36.Y5543B0 U _¾7C0�02[X<}�ö7C[X9;7/7C[�3 W 9\.Y=�an5C9 W 3 ] <>=�jXp U 5C9�7C.1<\={.10/74[X3 W <\027 ] <>027k3�ØÖ3 ] 7C.¾c>3 � s [X3 F 9\_102<0 U p>p>36087�74[g9;7 U 04.Y=Xp«9;=).1=�c\36527436D{_Y.1087K9\_1p><\54.Y74[ W <\={9�=X3B7É��<>54´�<\a¢�t<>52´�027:9�7C.1<\=X0���< U _YD E 3E 36=X3�j ] .19\_ E U 7y7C[�3 F 9\523 ] <>= ] 3652=X36D)9 E < U 7m7C[X3 ] < W f�_13�µ^.¾7 F �r 9\[X<V<>=�9\=XD�d ] � .1=�_13 F 5236fi<>527�9�04. W U _h9;74.1<>=)027 U D F <>=�9@_h9\52p>3 ½ 0 ] 9\_13ZDX.Y027454. E U 7C3BD�.1=^an<>5 ½W 9;7C.Y<>=�543�7C52.13Bc;9\_K0 F 087C3 W L zÂÄ N E U .Y_Y7'<\=�9=�3B7É��<>54´�<;a¶,�à r Î\Å\Å>Å �t<\54´�027C9;7C.Y<>=X0 � s [X3 F

z}Æ

Page 33: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

W <^DX3B_A9\=XD 9\=X9\_ F ¿ 3�9 ] < W f�_13B743�0 F 087C3 W E 9\043BD�<>= 9%027C9;7C3Z<\a¹7C[�3�9\527k3�ØÖ3 ] 7C.¾c>3�543�7C52.13Bc;9\_36=�p>.1=X3 � J = Á U 365 F L z ËON � s [X3 F 3�µ^fi3654. W 3B=�7/�y.Y74[ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0 U f»74< zÂÄ\Ì O �vU 04.1=�p@9%c;9\52. ½3B7 F <\aS�t<>52´�_1<�9\D�0y9\=XD%.1=�c\360274.1p�9�7C3�[X<}��DX.Yظ365236=�7y0 F 02743 W fg9;5C9 W 3B7436540o9;ØÖ3 ] 7yfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 39\=XD)0 ] 9;_h9 E .Y_1.¾7 F <\aº9�DX.1087C52. E U 7436D JLu 0 F 027C3 W � J =)74[X36.Y5�.Y=�c\36087C.1p>9;7C.Y<>= � 7C[X3 F 04. W fX_Y.Ya F 369 ] [043B52c\365Z9\0¶9�02.1=Xp>_Y3 r ? R 0 F 02743 W 7C[g9;7�[g9\=�DX_13B0�9 z O �-] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � s [�3 F 04[X<}�Ê7C[g9�7¶.Y=W 9\= F .1=X087:9\= ] 360�9�02. W fX_13kDX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D�9\5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 543�f¸3B52an<>5 W 0y��36_1_ U =�DX365�_h9\52p>3 � 523�9\_Y.10274. ]] <\=�jgp U 549;7C.Y<>=X0 �J =k7C[X.Y0bD�.1040236587:9;74.1<>= � ��3 U 043�9K02. W U _19;7C<\5Ö7C<K3�µ^fi3654. W 3B=�7b�y.¾7C[ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 U fq74<�9m7C3B5C9 E�F 7C3 �� 3�DX.Y027454. E U 7C3KDg9;7C9q<}c>3B5o9 ] _ U 027C3B5�<;a`0 FVW�W 3�7C54. ] W U _Y74.1fX52< ] 360204<>520 � 9\=XD©.1= ] _ U DX3y7C[�3 ] < W ½fi<>=X36=�740¶7C[g9�7�DX<{=�<\7�3Úµ�.Y027Z.Y=�74[X3'fX523BcV.1< U 0�543B043�9;5 ] [ � ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= 0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�9\=XD�fX9\5274.h9\_] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�fX9\5274.Y7C.Y<>= � M U 5Z�t<>52´�_1<�9\D�0Z.1= ] _ U DX3'74[X543B3 JLu ] < W�W 9\=XDX0 � l U 365 F>� 0 U W�W 9\5 F>�9\=XD DX< ]6U W 36=�7 ] < W©W 9\=XDX0 � � 3©9\=g9;_ F ¿ 3�74[X3©_Y<>p>0�an52< W 523�9\_ JLu 0 F 087C3 W 0�9\=XD U 043Z74[X36.Y5027C9;7C.Y0274. ] 0K9\0�9©p U .1DX3B_1.Y=X3�<\aA< U 5y��<>52´V_Y<�9\DX0 � � 3q3�µ^fX_Y<>543 E 9\_19\= ] .1=Xp�[g9\52D��t9\543�543602< U 5 ] 360 �.1D�36=�7C.¾a F)E <\7474_13B=X3 ] ´�0 � 9\=XD".Y=�c\36087C.1p>9;7C3Zfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3Zp�9\.1=�0/<\a¹fg9\549\_1_Y36_1.Y0 W�� ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\={043 ½_13 ] 74.1<>= � 9\=XD�fg9\587C.h9;_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=%5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\= �

Uw)eu �ÅÄ�.�:�E�?VJx.�A�.XWYWÆ2*9� ³?GWBE�0 ?G36Z[EY.�� �BA�9C2*0 8D<FE�?72xA �H.IE�0 ?7.=JK<>5s < W 9\.1=�7:9;.1=k3Bظ3 ] 7C.Yc\36=X3B040A<\a�DX.1087C52. E U 7436D�.1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=�543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_ � 74[X3t0 F 087C3 W W U 027 E 3t9 E _137C<�043B_13 ] 7¢74[X3 W <>087®5236_Y3Bc;9\=�7®0 U E 023B7e<;a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0`.Y=�<>52DX365S7C<�543BD UX] 3¹7C[X3�04369\5 ] [�02fg9 ] 3 Ô ��¬g�¾:�l¹Ç¹1�¿¾��¦¥ ���¶�}��¹1�¿¾��ø¥ ���/�i�C�\ªQ¹1���qÕ 9\=XD W 3B54p>3e74[X3�52360 U _Y740ban52< W DX.¾ØÖ3B5436=�7 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 Ô �n¬g�t�C�:��¡�¹ ��«���ø§\¥��V§y�i�C�\ªQ¹1��� ���y�n¬g��¾:�l¹Ç¹1�¿¾��¦¥ �����Ú¡���¥ ���¶�i�C�\ªQ¹1���qÕ � s [X3m��<>54´Z<>= ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=Z0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�.Y0DX.Y543 ] 7C_ F«E 36=X3�j ] .19\_I7C<�74[X3k3�µ^3 ]BU 7C.Y<>=�f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3/<\a®9�DX.Y027C52. E U [email protected]=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=©0 F 02743 W��04.Y= ] 3k<\a ] < U 54023�023�9\5 ] [X.1=Xp�an3B��365 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0t7:9\´;360K_13B040m7C. W 3 �

�IÿT�`ÿ¦þ á %Sü d f�Þ^ü òji ând j nà i ü ò d�a·î à` ¦à i ü ò d�a,�9\= ¿ .1p ���©�$¹¾¯ L Ä\Ç N U 043�9³[X.Y36549\5 ] [ F <\a E 54<\´\36520�74< W 9\.Y=�7C9\.1=�.Y=XDX. ] 360'an<\5�9 E 02745C9 ] 7C0@<\afX52. W 9\5 F Dg9;7C9 E 9\02360 Ô .1=�DX.YcV.1D U 9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 Õ 9\=XD�0 U fXfi<>587 � <^<>_Y3�9\=Z´;3 F ��<>54D W 9;7 ] [X.1=Xp/74<

z �

Page 34: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

_1< ] 9�7C3t74[X3yfX54. W 9\5 F DX9;7:9 E 9\043B0 � s [X.Y0 E 54<>´;365¹9\5 ] [�.Y7C3 ] 7 U 543y.10º9 ] < W fi<>=X3B=�7�<;a¸74[X3 H 9\58c>360870 F 087C3 W L | Nb9\=�D U 04360y7C[�3�ÃA020436= ] 3¶0 F 027C3 W L Ç�Î N`7C<�p>3B=X36549;7C3�7C[�3 W 3B7C9Z.1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\= �eT .1= ] 3E 52<>´\3B540/<>=�_ F ´;3636f»fX9\5274.h9\_`.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=@9 E < U 7�3�9 ] [{fX54. W 9;5 F DX9;7:9 E 9\043 � .¾a U 0236540bPÖl U 3B54.13B0DX<"=X<\7 U 023@´\3 F ��<>54D�0«.1=�74[X3 E 54<\´\36520 � 74[X3 F [g9�c>3�DX.YÀ ]6U _Y7 F jX=XDX.1=�p"74[[email protected]>[�7ZfX54. W 9;5 FDg9;7C9 E 9\02360 �Ñ <V<>54[X3B360 ���Ö�$¹¾¯ 3�µ^fX_Y<>.Y7¸7C[X3º04. W .Y_h9\52.Y7 F <;a�9o=�3B��l U 3B5 F 74<yfX543�c^.Y< U 02_ F 3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C3BDql U 3B54.Y360*L � Ë$N �s [X3 F U 023Z5436_Y3Bc;9\= ] 3K¼ U DXp W 3B=�740�an<>5�fX543�c^.Y< U 0/l U 3B54.Y360/7C< ] < W f U 743¶7C[X3¶= U W�E 3B5/<\aºDX< ]6UV½W 36=�7C0¹7C<q543B7454.Y3Bc>3Kan54< W 369 ] [ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � s [X.Y0¹743 ] [X=X.Yl U 3/<>=X_ F ��<>54´�0tan<>5º5236_h9�7C.Yc\36_ F 027C9;7C. ]] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 � J =)9\D�DX.Y74.1<>= � 5436_Y3Bc;9\= ] 3t¼ U DXp W 36=�7C0�9\523q=�<\7�9\_Y�t9 F 0�9�c;9\.1_19 E _13Kan<>5m�y.1DX3B_ F D�.10 ½7C52. E U 7C36D ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0 �OkP¢M TXT»U 02360¶D�< ]BU W 3B=�7�an5236l U 36= ] F .1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=)an<>5k3�9 ] [�.1=XDX.¾cV.1D U 9;_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>={7C<�36087C. ½W 9;7C3��y[�3B7C[�365 � 9;=XD@[X<}� W 9\= F>� f¸<\7436=�7C.19\_1_ F 5436_Y3Bc;9\=�7mDX< ]6U W 3B=�740y9\543�.Y=@9 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=ÃL Ç�Ä^�Ç�z N � J =�.Y740 E <V<>_1369\=�c>3B5404.Y<>= � .Y7º3B027C. W 9�7C360A74[X3y= U W�E 3B5�<;aÖfi<\7C3B=�7C.h9;_1_ F 543B_13�c\9;=�7¹DX< ]6U W 3B=�740.1= ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=-Èè9\0�§¨È^§B�`É;ÊrËÇÌ Ô �7� Ê_Í § È�§ Õ � �y[�36543^�q.10�9)7C365 W .Y=�7C[�3%l U 365 F ± � �7� Ê .Y0¶7C[�3= U W�E 365m<\abDX< ]6U W 3B=�740m.1='74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=~È ] <>=�7C9\.1=X.Y=Xp� � 9;=XDΧ¨È^§�.10t74[X3�= U W�E 365o<;a¢D�< ]Ú½U W 36=�7C0m.Y='7C[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=^È � J =@.¾7C0tc\3 ] 74<>5 ½ 04fg9 ] 3�c>3B5404.Y<>= � .¾7o5C9;=X´�0y74[X3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 E 9\0236D<>=«74[X3�0 U W <\a`7C[X3�9�c>36549\p>3���36.Yp>[�7m<\a`369 ] [%l U 365 F 74365 W Ô¢Ï Ê Í �7�tÊ Õ � �y[�36543 Ï Ê`.10¹7C[X3�0 U W <\a��36.1p\[�740�<;aÖ7C[�3y74365 W �e<}c>3B5o9\_Y_XDX< ]6U W 36=�7C0¹.1=Z74[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�È � s [�3 OkPbM T�T 9\f�fX54<�9 ] [©.Y03�9;04.1_ F 9\f�fX_1.Y36D%7C<�_h9\52p>3/= U W�E 36520�<;a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 ��E 3 ] 9 U 043 OqPbM TXT 0274<>543B0�<\=X_ F D�< ]BU W 3B=�7an543Bl U 36= ] F 9\=XD@7C<\7C9\_¸��36.Yp>[�7K.1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=©an<>5o369 ] [@7C365 W .1=@369 ] [ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � H <Â��3Bc\365K.Y7403Bظ3 ] 7C.¾c>36=�36040�543 W 9\.Y=X0 U =XD�3B7C3B5 W .1=X3BD�D U 3�7C<�_1. W .¾7C36D«3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>= �s [X3 N 3B7C023658a«0 F 087C3 W .10{9;=-3Úµ�9 W f�_13�<;a©.Y= ] <\54fi<>5C9;74.1=XpÙ+ J 7C3 ] [X=X<>_Y<>p F 7C<�_1< ] 9�7C3 ] <>_ ½_13 ] 74.1<>=X0ÁL z}Ì N � N 3�7C023652aq3Úµ^745C9 ] 7C0'087C5 UX] 7 U 543BD � D�.10C9 W�E .1p U 9;7C3BDÙ5236fX52360236=�7:9;74.1<>=�0'an54< W 7C[�3l U 3652.13B0%9\=XD W 9;7 ] [X360�7C[X3B043»l U 365 F 5236fX52360236=�7:9;74.1<>=�0«7C<�[X9\=XD ½Ò] <VDX36D�5236fX52360236=�7:9;74.1<>=�0'<\a7C[�3�9\5 ] [X.¾c>3B0 Ô .1=XD�.YcV.1D U 9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0 Õ U 04.Y=Xp@043 W 9\=�74. ] ´�=X<}�y_13BDXp>3�an52< W � <>54D N 3B7 Ô 9%043 ½W 9\=�7C. ] 74[X36049 U 5 U 0 Õ 9;=XD¶9;=¶<>= ½ _1.Y=X3 � 3 E 0274365bP 0¢DX. ] 7C.1<\=g9\5 F � d�9\= U 9\_1_ F ] <>=X02745 UX] 7C.Y=Xp/9\5 ] [X.Yc\3543BfX543B043B=�7C9;7C.Y<>=X0 W 9;´\360m74[X.10y9\f�fX54<�9 ] [�<>=�_ F f�5C9 ] 7C. ] 9\_Öan<>5y9�0 W 9\_Y_Ö= U W�E 365y<\a®9\5 ] [�.Yc>3B0 �

z}Ì

Page 35: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

w U [X5�fX52<>f¸<\04360©9"DX3 ] .104.Y<>= ½ 7C[X3B<>543�7C. ] 9;fXfX54<>9 ] [Ù74< 02<>_Yc\3�74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=fX54< E ½_13 W L Ä\| N � H 3 W 9\´\3B0�DX3 ] .102.1<>=X0 E�F U 04.Y=Xp'7C[X3Z3Úµ^f¸3 ] 7C3BD�523 ] 9\_1_ ½ fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>= ]BU 52c\3 � 3�µ^fi3 ] 7436D= U W�E 365�<\a¹5236_13�c;9\=�7kDX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 � 9\=XD ] <>087�a¦9 ] 74<>540�an<>5/l U 365 F fX52< ] 360402.1=Xp�9\=�D D�< ]BU W 3B=�7DX3B_1.Yc\365 F � H 3kDX<V360y=X<\7y5236fi<>527y<\=�3�ØÖ3 ] 7C.¾c>3B=X36020 �r 9\_Y_h9\= ���t�$¹¾¯ 9;Dg9\f�7m74[X3�DX< ]6U W 36=�7K.1=�an3B543B= ] 3k=X3�7É�t<>52´«7C<�549\=X´�.1=Xp ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0 E�F 04. W f�_ F543BfX_h9 ] .1=�p@74[X3«D�< ]BU W 3B=�7¶=X<VDX3Z�y.Y74[�74[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= =�<^DX3ÁL zÂÎV�¢Î Ë$N �@T . W .Y_h9\5K7C< OqPbM TXT �7C[�3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>={543�7C52.13Bc;9\_®.1=�an3B5436= ] 3Z=X3�7É�t<>52´»0274<>543B0�DX< ]BU W 36=�7kan5436l U 3B= ] .Y360q9\=XD»74365 W an543 ½l U 36= ] .13B0�an<>5�369 ] [�74365 W � s [X3«l U 3B5 F fX52< ] 360204.1=�p).10/74[X3�0C9 W 3�9\0q74[g9;7q.1=»74[X3©D�< ]BU W 3B=�7.1=^an36543B= ] 3y=X3�7É�t<\54´ � 3Úµ ] 36f^7o9\_Y_�fX52<�µ�. W .¾7 F <\f¸3B5C9;74<>540º9\523m543BfX_h9 ] 36DZ�y.Y74[Z7C[X3 � <V<>_Y3�9\=Z+ N ,<>fi36549;7C<>520 � ÃeØÖ3 ] 7C.¾c>3B=X36020%.10«D�3 W <>=X02745C9;7436D·�y.¾7C[³7C[X3{3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�740 U 02.1=Xp�74[X3 J = Á U 365 F543�7C52.13Bc;9\_A0 F 027C3 W 9\=XD Ç syu à r ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0�<\a z O � 3�9 ] [ � s [X3�54360 U _Y740�02[X<}�Q7C[X9;7k7C[X.Y0W 3B7C[�<^D ] 9\=�0236_Y3 ] 7©7C[X3�7C<>f Î\Ŧq <\a�0 U E ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0«9;=XD·p>3�7%9 E < U 7�7C[�3{0C9 W 3�_13Bc\36_K<\a3Bظ3 ] 7C.¾c>36=�36040�9\0k043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp{9\_Y_e0 U E ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0 � s [X3�04.1p\=X.Yj ] 9\= ] 3�<;at7C[�.10/��<>54´».Y0k74[g9;7q.Y704[�<Â�y0m74[g9;7t743 ] [X=�.1l U 360m�y[X. ] [�9\543�3Bظ3 ] 74.Yc\3kan<\5tDX< ]6U W 36=�7m523B7454.13�c;9\_I9\523/9\_Y04<�3�ØÖ3 ] 74.Yc>3/an<\5] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=%0236_13 ] 74.1<>= �Í U 9\=XD r 9\_1_19\=�fX5236043B=�7«a U 587C[X3B5�3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�740�an<>5 U 02.1=Xp"7C[�3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_m.1=^an365 ½36= ] 3«=�3B7É��<>54´ W <VDX3B_e7C<)023�9\5 ] [�7C[�3�74<>f z}Å#q <\ao0 U E ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0 � J = 7C[X3B.15 E 9\0236_Y.1=X3 � 7C[�3fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>={DX52<>f{an<>5�74[X3¶7C<\f Ç>Å DX< ]6U W 36=�740/.10 Ç\Ŧq ] < W fg9\5236D{�y.Y74[»04369\5 ] [X.Y=Xp'7C[�3¶�y[X<>_Y3] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � s [X3 F . W fX54<}c\3o7C[X3K9 ]B]6U 549 ] F <\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=Z0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>= E�F 9\D�DX.1=Xp�f�[X5C9\02360¹.1=Z7C[�3] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>='0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=%.Y=XDX3Úµ%9\=�D U 04.1=�pZl U 365 F 3�µ^fg9\=X02.1<>=1L �#� N �º� F U 04.1=�pZl U 365 F 3�µ^fg9\=X02.1<>= �7C[�3/fX543 ] .Y04.1<\=«DX52<>f%<\aI74[X3�7C<\f Ç>Å DX< ]6U W 3B=�740o543BD UX] 360o7C<¶9\54< U =XD z}Ŧq �A��U 7t74[X3 F fg9 F an<\57C[�.10tf�543 ] .102.1<>=©. W fX54<}c>3 W 3B=�7��y.¾7C[«74[X3�74. W 3Kan<>5¹l U 365 F 3Úµ^fg9\=X02.1<>= Ô 3�µ^3 ]BU 7C.Y=Xp�7C[�3�<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_l U 365 F 9\=XD�9\=g9;_ F ¿ .Y=Xp�.Y7C0o74<>f@DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0 Õ 9\=XD@7C[X3�7C. W 3�7C<�fX54< ] 3B040K9\DXD�.Y7C.Y<>=g9\_ Ä\Å 7C3B5 W 0<>5mfX[�5C9\02360�9\DXDX3BD E�F l U 365 F 3�µ^fg9\=�04.1<\=�an<>5m369 ] [�l U 365 F �+ W <>=Xp�7C[X3�9\fXfX52<�9 ] [X3B0�an<>5 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � 7C[�3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_S.1=^an36543B= ] 3¶=X3B7 ½��<>54´ W <^D�36_`.10m74[X3k<>=X3k7C[g9;7K[g9;0 E 363B=�7436027436D W <>523/7C[X<>52< U p>[�_ F 74[g9\=�<\7C[X3B540�9\=XD�04[X<}�y=

z}|

Page 36: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

7C< E 3�7C[X3 W <>027y3�ØÖ3 ] 7C.¾c>3 � J =@7C[�.10mDX.Y04043B527C9;7C.Y<>= � ��3 U 043k7C[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=«.1=�an3B5436= ] 3k=X3B7É��<>52´W <^DX3B_Ö7C<�0236_13 ] 7 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 � 9\=�D)9\DX9\f�7m7C[�.10 W <VDX3B_Ö7C<�043B_13 ] 7�9Z5436_Y3Bc;9\=�7Kfg9\587C.h9;_Ö543BfX_1. ] 9 �

�IÿT�`ÿT� ñ à`gk%! �ü ì àVýÂß ò a ßs [X3�f�54< E _Y3 W <\aº52360 U _Y7 W 3652p>.1=�p«9\52.102360�an52< W .1= ] < W fX9\5C9 E _13k5C9\=�´V.Y=Xp«0 ] <>52360�523B7 U 54=X3BD E�F04369\5 ] [�360�<\at7C[X3�DX.Yظ365236=�7 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0k.1=�9�D�.1027454. E U 7C3BD�3B=�cV.Y54<>= W 36=�7 � ,/.1543 ] 74_ F»W 3652p>.1=Xp543B0 U _¾7C0 E 9\0236D�<>=%7C[X3k.1= ] < W fg9\549 E _13�0 ] <\54360y[ U 587C0K3Bظ3 ] 74.Yc\36=X3B040ML zÂÎ^� � Ë$N �Ñ <V<>54[X3B360 �����$¹¾¯ fX52<>fi<>043�9\f�fX54<�9 ] [X360 E 9\0236D"<>=»DX< ]6U W 3B=�7k549\=X´�.1=�p>0�9\=XD"fX523BcV.1< U 0�543B_13 ½c;9\= ] 3/¼ U DXp W 36=�7C0�L � Ë$N � s [X3�jg54087¶9;fXfX54<>9 ] [".10/7C<@.Y=�743652_13�9�c\3�74[X3�DX< ]6U W 36=�7k5C9;=X´�.1=Xp>0k.Y=9{54< U =XD ½ 54< E .Y=�a¦9\04[�.1<>= � s [X3@043 ] <>=�D·9\f�fX54<�9 ] [³.Y0 U =X3�c>3B=·.1=�743654_Y3�9�cV.1=Xp �AE .h9\0236D E�F 7C[�33�µ^fi3 ] 7C36D�5236_Y3Bc;9\= ] 3)<\a/74[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=³74<�7C[�3)l U 365 F � s [X3 F DX3 W <>=X087C549;7C3�3Bظ3 ] 7C.Yc\36=X3B040U 02.1=Xp�7C[X3 syu à r ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0 � s [X3�9\fXfX52<�9 ] [).Y0Kc\365 F 3�ØÖ3 ] 74.Yc>3k�y[X3B=»9�l U 3B5 F ] 9;=�jg=XD)9fX523BcV.1< U 0�543B043 W�E _h9;= ] 3 � s [X3Z9\f�fX54<�9 ] [ ] 9\= E 3�369\04.Y_ F 9\DX9\f�7C3BD)7C<«043�9;5 ] [ U 02.1=Xp'D�.Yظ36543B=�7543�7C52.13Bc;9\_Ö0 F 02743 W 0 � H <}�t3�c>3B5 � 5436_Y3Bc;9\= ] 3t¼ U DXp W 36=�7C0K9\523k=X<\7K9\_¾�o9 F 0K9}c;9\.Y_h9 E _13 �r 9\_Y_h9\= ���A�$¹¾¯ fX52<>f¸<\043K9 W 3652p>.1=Xpk9;fXfX54<>9 ] [©74[g9;7t9\040 U W 3B0¹74[X3K0 ] <\54360¹an<>5 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=Z5C9;=X´ ½.1=�p�9\523t9�c;9\.Y_h9 E _Y3A9\=XD U 043¹7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=k0 ] <>543B0¢7C<y��36.1p\[�7®DX< ]6U W 36=�7¢0 ] <\54360ban54< W D�.Yظ36543B=�7] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0pL zÂÎ N � s [X.10�9\fXf�54<�9 ] [�.10y3�ØÖ3 ] 7C.¾c>3k�y[X36=�7C[X3q0C9 W 3k543�7C52.13Bc;9\_Ö0 F 02743 W .10 U 0236D�74<04369\5 ] [ 9\_Y_S<\aA7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 � 9\=XD{��<>52´V0�an<>5�D F =g9 W . ]¶] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 � s [X3¶3Bظ3 ] 74.Yc\36=X3B040k<\a7C[�.10K9\fXfX52<�9 ] [�.10mDX3 W <\=X02745C9;7436D).Y=%7C[X3k3�µ^fi3652. W 36=�7C0y�y.Y74[@74[X3 J = Á U 365 F 543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_I0 F 087C3 W<>= Ç syu à r ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0�<\a z O � 369 ] [ � u 9\=X´�.Y=Xp E 9\043BD�<>= 7C[X.Y0�9;fXfX54<>9 ] [�.Y0�9 E < U 7¶9;03Bظ3 ] 7C.¾c>3�9\0�549\=X´�.1=�p E 9;0436D�<>=�p>_1< E 9\_I0 ] <>543B0/9\=�D W <>543�3�ØÖ3 ] 74.Yc>3q7C[g9;= Ñ <V<>54[�36360 ���m�$¹¾¯ P 0 �� 3 U 043k7C[X.Y0y9\fXfX52<�9 ] [�.1=@< U 5m0 F 087C3 W �

Uw)_| &Á<K0�<>5G5G.�5«�BA�9C2*0 8D<FE�?72xA �H.IE�0 ?7.=JK<>5+�_¾7C[X< U p>[�DX.1087C52. E U 7436D�.1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>=¶523B7454.13�c;9\_X3�µ^fX_Y<>.Y740Afg9\549\_1_Y36_1.Y0 W�� ��3 U 043 �o�\�2�$¹Ç¹1��¹`Ð��������CÑ���\�¦¥ ���¶Òy���ø�Ú¥ ��À��$¹ 7C<@543�an365�7C<%.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=�543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_e. W f�_13 W 36=�7436D»<>= 9'7C.Yp>[�7C_ F ] < U fX_13BDW U _¾7C.YfX54< ] 3B0404<\5o.1=%7C[�.10mDX.Y04043B527C9;7C.Y<>= �

Ä\Å

Page 37: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

s [X3B543)[X9}c\3 E 3636=·9�= U W�E 365©<\a/fX9\f¸3B540©5436p>9\54DX.Y=Xp U 04.Y=Xp W U _Y7C.YfX54< ] 3B0402<>5 W 9 ] [X.1=X3B0�an<\5.1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>={523B7C52.13�c\9;_�L Æ^�bÄ\Å��bÄ^z;�bÄ\Æ�� Ë � �¢Æ � �SÆ>Ì��SÆ\Æ N � d�<\027�<\a�74[X3 W U 043©9@D�.1027454. E U 7C3BDW 3 W <>5 F\�XW 9;0404.¾c>3B_ F fg9;5C9\_Y_136_ÖfX54< ] 3B0404.Y=Xp Ô d)?º? Õ 9;5 ] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 523~L Æ��iÄ^z\�iÄ\Æ��iÎ � �¸Æ\Æ^��Æ � ��Æ\Ì N �J =«74[X.10¹DX.102043B527:9�7C.1<\= � ��3�.Y=�c>36087C.Yp�9;7C3�[X<}��7C<�3�µ^fX_1<\.Y7�0 FVW©W 3B7454. ] W U _Y7C.YfX54< ] 3B0402<>540 Ô T d�?º0 Õ7C< E U .1_1D«fg9\5C9;_1_13B_ JLu 043658c>3B540 ��E 3 ] 9 U 043 T d)?A0K9\523/7C[X3 W <>027of¸<>f U _h9\5o9\=XD�9;ظ<>54Dg9 E _13 W U _ ½7C.YfX54< ] 3B0402<>540�74<^DX9 F � s [X3ZfX543�cV.1< U 0��t<>52´ U 02.1=Xp T d)?A0�36.Y74[X365 ] < W fg9\52360�74[X3 ] <\027�a¦9 ] 7C<>520<\a T d)?Ù9;5 ] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 523��y.¾7C[«<;7C[X3B5o9\5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 543B0o<>5¹.Y7¹.1=�c\360274.1p�9�7C360t9¶0 U E 043�7m<\aI74[X3�0 F 087C3 W0 U�] [�9\0Z7C[X3�DX.Y04´�0 F 087C3 W L Ë � N � +�_Y7C[�< U p>[ ] < W�W 365 ] .h9\_�.1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>=�543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_o0 F 027C3 W 0 �0 U�] [�9\0�7C[X3 � 3 E 043�9;5 ] [�3B=Xp>.1=�360k+�_¾7:9 Ñ .1027C9@9\=XD J =�an<>043B36´"3�µ^fX_Y<>.Y7kfX9\5C9\_Y_13B_1.10 W�� fg9\549\_1_Y36_] < W f U 7C36520 � 9\=�DZ<\7C[X3B5®<>f^7C. W . ¿ 9;7C.Y<>=X0`7C<�0 U fXfi<>527®7C[X3B.15®023658c^. ] 3B0 � 7C[X3 F [X9}c\3m=X<\7Af U E _1.Y04[X3BD7C[�36.15m[X9\54D��t9\523�9;=XD�02<\a�7É�t9\543 ] <>=^jgp U 549;7C.Y<>=X0 �r < U cV523 U 5 �����$¹¾¯ 9;=g9\_ F ¿ 3�7C[X3�745C9\DX3B<\Ø E 3B7É��363B=�fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3�9;=XD ] <>087��y[X36=�043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp_h9;54p>3k7C3Úµ^7 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0�L Ä\Å N � s [X3 F U 043¶04. W U _h9;74.1<>= W <^DX3B_10y7C<'.Y=�c>36087C.Yp�9;7C3q7C[X52363�D�.Yظ36543B=�7[g9\52D��t9\543�9\5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 543B0 � 9 W 9;.1=�an549 W 3 � 9 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>={<;a uyJ T r f�54< ] 360204<>520 ] <>=X=�3 ] 7436D E�F9'=X3�7É�t<>52´ � 9\=XD"9'04fi3 ] .h9\_¢f U 52f¸<>023 W 9 ] [X.1=X3 � s [X3Z3�µ^fi3652. W 36=�7C0 U 04.1=�p@9 W 9\.Y=�an5C9 W 3q9\523W <>027�543B_h9;7436D7C< < U 5Z��<>54´ � s [X3 F³W 369\0 U 523%7C[X3�543B04fi<>=X043�7C. W 3 U =�DX365�DX.Yظ365236=�7©l U 365 F9\5254.Yc;9\_¸5C9;74360�9\[email protected]�36=�7C.¾a F 7C[�3�l U 3B5 F 9\5254.Yc;9\_¸5C9;743�7C[X3k0 F 087C3 W ] 9\=�0 U fXfi<>527y�y.¾7C[X.Y= Ç>Å ½ Ë Å043 ] <>=�DX0 �¹� F U 02.1=Xp¶9�Ë ½ r ? RJ � d Ç\Å>|>Å�È Ë Å>Å Ã W 9\.1=^an5C9 W 3 � 74[X3 F 9 ] [X.Y3Bc\3/Ë Î 043�9;5 ] [X3B0mf¸3B5W .1= U 7C3/�y[�36=)023�9\5 ] [X.1=�p«9 z Ë O ��] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= �� 36<\=Xp'9\=�D M W .Y3 ] .1=X02´V.`.Y=�c>36087C.Yp�9;7C3k7É��<«.1=�c\36527436D)jX_13qfg9\5274.Y74.1<>=X.Y=Xp�0 ] [X3 W 360/.Y=)9�04[g9;5436D ½3Bc\365 F 74[X.1=�p W U _Y74.1fX52< ] 360402<>5®0 F 027C3 W L Ë � N � M =X3o0 ] [X3 W 3yfg9\5274.Y74.1<>=X0S7C[�3mf¸<>087C.Y=Xp�jg_Y3 E�F 74365 W.1D�36=�7C.¾jg36520y�y[�.1_13�7C[X3k<\74[X365y0 ] [�3 W 3qfX9\5274.Y7C.Y<>=X0t74[X3kf¸<\027C.Y=XpZjg_13 E�F D�< ]BU W 3B=�7�.YDX36=�74.Yjg3B540 �s [X3 F an< ]BU 0Z<>=�7C[�3%3Bظ3 ] 7�<;a�9;DXDX.1=�p»DX.102´V0�<>=�0 F 027C3 W f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3 � s [X3 F 04[�<Â�Û7C[g9�7543B04fi<>=X023q74. W 3/DX3 ] 54369\043B0/9\0m7C[�3�= U W�E 365y<\a¢DX.Y04´�0y.1= ] 543�9;04360 U f@7C<�04< W 3�7C[�543602[X<>_YD � ?®9\5 ½7C.¾7C.Y<>=X.1=�p E 9\043BD�<>=�74365 W .1DX3B=�74.Yjg3B540qf¸3B52an<>5 W 0k7C[�3 E 36027��y[X36=�7C[X3�7C3B5 W DX.1087C52. E U 74.1<>=".Y0_13B040�02´\3B��36D Ô . � 3 � � �y[X3B= 74[X3Z7C365 W DX.Y027454. E U 7C.Y<>=».1={74[X3Zl U 365 F .10 U =�.Yan<>5 W _ F D�.1027454. E U 7C3BD Õ �

Ä^z

Page 38: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

?®9;527C.¾7C.Y<>=X.1=�p E 9;0436D%<\=%DX< ]BU W 36=�7o.YDX36=�7C.¾jg36520ofi3652an<\5 W 0�7C[�3 E 36027t�y[X36=%7C3B5 W DX.1087C52. E U 74.1<>=.10m[�.1p>[X_ F 02´\3��t3BD �u 3 ] 3B=�7C_ F 7C[�3 syu à r ] <>=�an365236= ] 3ÓL Ë Ä N�5436fi<>587C36D·54360 U _Y740©an<>5 T d)?A0«74<�fX52< ] 36040'9�04.Y=Xp>_13l U 365 F Ô 5C9�7C[X3B5y74[g9\=�.1=�9�_Y<�9\DX3BD�0 F 087C3 W 9;0K��3¶DX<�[X3B543 Õ <>=)9 z}Å\Å O �] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � s [X36.Y5a¦9\087C36087 T d)?v0 F 087C3 W U 043BD9 Ì r ? R Ä;Æ>Æ d H�G +�_1f�[g9��y.¾7C[ Ì DX.102´V0�9\=XD�9 ] [�.13Bc\36D�7C[�3543B04fi<>=X023t7C. W 3ºan<>5¢9�04.Y=Xp>_13ºl U 3B5 F _Y36020¢7C[X9\= Ä 023 ] <>=XD � J =¶74[X.10b543Bf¸<\527 � 7C[X3 J = Á U 365 F 0 F 087C3 WU 0236D»9�Ë r ? R z}Æ � d H�G T^U = R _Y745C9�9\=XD)9 ] [X.13�c>3BD Î\Å>Å 043 ] <>=XDX0�an<>5�9�l U 365 F>�iE 3 ] 9 U 023�.Y7U 0236D)02_1<}��365yfX54< ] 3B0402<>540�9\=XD@c>3B5 F _1<\=XpZl U 3652.1360 Ô W <>523/7C[g9;= Î\Å 74365 W 0 Õ �M 7C[X3B5®5236_h9�7C36D�027 U DX.13B0 U 023yd)?º?A0A9\=XD¶an< ]6U 0®<>=�[�<Â��74<�02f¸3B36D U f�02.1=Xp>_Y3ºl U 365 F fX54< ] 3B0402.1=Xp �T 7C9\=�jg_Y_ ���m�$¹¾¯ . W fX_13 W 3B=�7m7C[X3B.15 JLu 0 F 02743 W <>=@7C[X3 ] <>=�=X3 ] 7C.1<\= W 9 ] [X.1=�3 Ô r d Õ � �y[X. ] [).Y09©jg=�3 ½ p\5C9\.Y=X36D �¸W 9;0404.¾c>3B_ F fg9\549\_1_Y36_`DX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D ½ W 3 W <>5 F T J d�, 9;5 ] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 523¶�y.Y74[ U f)74<Æ�Î^�ÐÎ\Ç>Æ fX54< ] 3B0402.1=Xp%3B_13 W 36=�740�L Æ\Æ^�IÆ � �IÆ\Ì N ��� 9\.Y_13 F 9\=�D H 9��y´�.1=Xp%5236fi<>527�7C[X3B.15 JLu 0 F 087C3 W<>= w U ¼2.Y740 U +/? z}Å>Å\Å�� �y[X. ] [©.10º9 zÂÄ\Ì ½ =X<^D�3mDX.1087C54. E U 7436D ½ W 3 W <>5 F�W U _Y7C. ] < W f U 74365A9;=XD©369 ] [=X<VDX3�[g9\0�9 Ä>Î d H/GÙr ? R 9\=XD z}Æ d � W 3 W <>5 F L Æ N � r 52.1=Xp>369\= �����$¹¾¯ 9\=XD�ÃAan549\. W .1D�.10�����$¹¾¯ . W fX_Y3 W 36=�7¶74[X36.Y5 JLu 0 F 087C3 W 0�<>=³9"745C9\=X02f U 74365�=X3B7É��<>52´ � �y[X. ] [ E 3B_1<>=�p>0¶7C<"7C[�3d J d), ] _19\040y<\a¢fg9\549\_1_Y36_ ] < W f U 7C3B540nL Ä^z\�iÄ\Æ N �J =7C[X.Y0�D�.1040236587:9;74.1<>= � ��3�an< ]6U 0�<\=·9»fg9\549\_1_Y36_�043658c>3B5 E U .Y_Y7Z<\=Ù0 F^W�W 3B7C52. ] W U _Y7C.YfX54< ] 3B0 ½04<\540o9;=XD%9\=g9;_ F ¿ 3�[X<}��D�.Yظ36543B=�7o0 F 087C3 W fg9\549 W 3B7C3B540�0 UX] [@9\0¹7C[X3�= U W�E 3B5t<\aÖ7C[X523�9\DX0 � 7C[�3= U W�E 365�<\a r ? R 0 � 9\=�D)7C[X3q= U W�E 365�<\aADX.Y04´�0�9�ØÖ3 ] 7�74[X3qf¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3q<\aº9©[�3�9�c F _Y<�9\DX3BD0 F 087C3 W Ô 04363 T 3 ] 74.1<>= Æ � z Õ �º� 3B04.YDX360 W 369\0 U 54.1=�p�523602f¸<>=�043k7C. W 3 � �t3�9\_Y04< W 369\0 U 543�7C[X3k0 F 0 ½7C3 W U 7C.1_Y. ¿ 9;7C.Y<>=�9\=XD'.Y=�c\36087C.1p>9;7C3/[�<Â��74< E 9\_19\= ] 3�[g9\52D��o9;543/523604< U 5 ] 360 � � 3/<>=X_ F ] <>=X02.1DX3B5fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xp E 9;0436D»<\={DX< ]6U W 36=�7/.YDX36=�74.Yjg3B540/.Y=)< U 5�3�µ^fi3654. W 3B=�7C0/<>=)fg9\5C9;_1_13B_ JLu 023658c>365 �E 3 ] 9 U 043%< E 043658c;9;7C.Y<>=X0�<>=�l U 3B5 F 7C365 W an5236l U 3B= ] F D�.1027454. E U 7C.Y<>=X0q.1=�f�543BcV.Y< U 0¶��<>54´�04[X<}�7C[X9;7kl U 365 F 7C3B5 W DX.Y027454. E U 7C.Y<>={.10�02´\3��t3BD�9\=XD U 0236540k7C3B=XD"7C< U 023�an5236l U 3B=�74_ F U 0236D"7C3B5 W 0.1=%74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�L zÂÄ N �

Ä>Ä

Page 39: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

Uw)VÔ ³<FEY<Ê�H.!Õ65G?7:=<FE�?72xA�IÿT�`ÿ¦þ ñ à�ûF òji Þ^ü ò d�a�î ü�ý�Þ^ü}à�ß ò à`gu 36fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=[X9\0 E 363B=�027 U DX.13BD�.1=!9\54369\0)<\a�DX.1087C54. E U 7436D�jX_13 0 F 02743 W 0"9\=XD!D�.1027454. E U 7C3BDDg9;7C9 E 9\023@0 F 02743 W 0«.1=<>52DX365Z74<�. W fX52<}c>3@0 F 02743 W 9�c;9\.1_19 E .1_Y.Y7 F 9\=�DÙfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 � d UX] [��<>54´ � 3602f¸3 ] .h9;_1_ F 369\54_ F ��<>52´ � an< ]6U 02360Z<>=�9}c;9\.Y_h9 E .1_1.¾7 F D U 3'7C<{5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=HL Ä^�®Ç^�tz}Æ��¹z}|��Ä>Î^��Ç>Å���Î^z>��Æ�Î^��Æ>| N � u 36_19;7C.¾c>36_ F an3B� fg9\fi36520)an< ]6U 0�<>=�f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3�D U 3�74<�543BfX_1. ] 9 ½7C.Y<>=1L z;�iÄ Ë � Ë\Ë � � Æ N �u 36fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\= 087C549;7C3Bp>.13B0 ] 9;= E 3 ] _19\0402.Yjg3BD�9\0�027C9;7C. ] 9\=�D�D F =g9 W . ] 543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= �SE 9;0436D�<>=�y[X3B=�7C[X3©0 F 02743 W DX3 ] .1DX3B0¶�y[g9;7q7C<�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3 � s [X3 w .Y_13�+�_Y_1< ] 9;74.1<>="?A52< E _13 W Ô w +�? Õ .Y09\=3�µ�9 W fX_Y3%<\a�087:9;74. ] 5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\= � �y[X3B543�Dg9;7:9».Y0Z5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3BD9;7�DX3B04.1p\=³74. W 3 E 9\0236D³<>=fX52< E 9 E _Y3«9 ]6] 3B040�fX9;74743654=�0 � 9\=XD�543 W 9\.Y=X0 U = ] [g9\=�p>36D�D U 54.1=�p)5 U =�7C. W 3ÅL Ä Ë$N � s [X3©027C9;7C. ]0 ] [�3 W 3o�t<>52´�0e�t3B_1_�.¾ag7C[X3o9 ]6] 36040ºfg9�747C3B54=Z.Y0e´�=X<}�y=©9�fX54.Y<>54. � H <Â��3Bc\365¹9 ]B] 36020Afg9;727C3652=X0º9\523=X<\7o9\_Y�t9 F 0ofX543BDX. ] 7:9 E _13 � J =%<>54DX3B5�74<�<}c>365 ] < W 3/7C[�.10¹DX5C9�� E 9 ] ´ � 523604369\5 ] [�36540y[g9�c\3/027C9\527436D7C<y087 U D F 9;fXfX54<>9 ] [X360S7C<yD F =g9 W . ] DX9;7:9m543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=ML z>� Ë\Ë � � Æ N � w <\5`3�µ�9 W fX_13 � + ] [g9\5 F 9�9;=XDG DX<>=�.1´'fX52<>fi<>043�9�D F =X9 W . ] 5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>=%0 ] [�3 W 3 E 9\0236D{<\=�74[X3�< E ¼23 ] 7�9 ]B] 36020�fg9�747C3B54=-L z N.1=�9{DX.1087C54. E U 7436D�Dg9�7:9 E 9;043%0 F 087C3 W � s [X3 F U 043%9)jX=X.Y743%9 U 74< W 9�7C<>= E 9\043BD027C5 UX] 7 U 543'74<W 9\.1=�7:9;.1='087:9;74.10274. ] 0m9 E < U 7y54369\DX0K9\=XD%�y52.Y7C3B0 � 9;=XD U 043k.Y7m74<Z_1369\54=�9 ]B] 36020yfg9;74743652=X0 � s [X3 FU 023�f�5436D�. ] 7436D�9 ]6] 36020�0236l U 36= ] 360q7C<@D F =g9 W . ] 9\_1_ F 5436<\54DX3B5 � 543BfX_1. ] 9;743 � <>5�D�36_13�7C3 ] <>fX.13B0�<\aDg9;7C9Z.1=%7C[X3k=X3�7É�t<\54´%.1=@<>52DX365m74<�5236D U�] 3q=X3B7É��<>54´ W 36020C9\p\3 ] <>02740 �u 36fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=�087C549;7C3Bp>.13B0o9\_Y04< ] 9\= E 3 ] _h9\0204.YjX36D'9;0t3�9;p>365�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>= Ô 0 F = ] [�54<>=X< U 0m543BfX_1. ] 9 ½7C.Y<>= Õ 9\=XD©_h9 ¿ F 543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= Ô 9\0 F = ] [X52<>=X< U 0t543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= Õ ��E 9\0236D©<>=«[X<}��74<�DX3B_1.¾c>365 U fiDg9;743.1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>=Z7C<�9\_Y_�5436f�_1. ] 9\06L Ç>Ç���Æ>Å N � ú9\p>3B5o543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= W 9;´\360 ] [X9\=Xp>3B0o7C<Z9\_Y_�5436f�_1. ] 9\0o9�77C[�3/0C9 W 3�74. W 3�.Y='<>52DX365t74<�p U 9;5C9\=�7C3B3/027454. ] 7oDX9;7:9 ] <>=�c>3B54p>3B= ] 3q9\=XD'74[X3 W <>027 U f ½ 7C< ½ Dg9;7C3Dg9;7C9 � P 9 ¿ F 5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=�. W©W 36DX.19;7C3B_ F 523 ] <>54DX0�.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=�9 E < U 7Z5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36D�9 ] 74.YcV.Y74.1360E U 7KDX3B_1.¾c>36520m7C[X3 W _h9;74365 � ,�9;7:9��y.Y_1_ ] <>=�c>3B54p>3q7C< ] <>=�04.1087C3B=�7yc;9\_ U 360y<}c>3B5K74. W 3 �s [X3��t<>52´�<>=·5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=�.1=³DX.1087C52. E U 7436Djg_13@0 F 087C3 W 0«9\=XD·DX9;7:9 E 9\043�0 F 02743 W 0 ] 9\=·=X<;7DX.Y543 ] 7C_ F 9\fXf�_ F 74<©< U 5o�t<\54´ ��E 3 ] 9 U 023q74[X3k< E ¼23 ] 7C0m��3¶9;543��t<\54´�.1=Xp�<>=�9\523�DX.Yظ365236=�7yan54< W

Ä\Ç

Page 40: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

7C[�36.1520 � M U 5'< E ¼23 ] 740�9\543)743�µV7 � p>36=�365C9;_1_ F 523�9\D ½ <>=X_ F � �y[X.Y_13)74[X36.Y5«< E ¼23 ] 740�9;543)jg_Y360'<\502745 UX] 7 U 5236D543 ] <>52DX0 � 9\=XD�54369\D ½ �y54.Y743 � s [X3"Dg9;7C9 ] <>=�04.1087C3B= ] F .Y0«7C[ U 0 ] 54.¾7C. ] 9\_K.1=·74[X36.Y59\fXf�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>=X0 � M a ] < U 54023¶�t3 ] 9\= E <>5452<}�v04< W 3¶.YDX3�9\0�an54< W 7C[�36.15K�t<\54´ � an<>5K3�µ�9 W fX_13 � ��3] <\=X02745 UX] 7�< U 5m5436f�_1. ] 9\0 E 9\0236D�<>=�9 ]6] 36040Kfg9;727C3B54=X0 �u 3 ] 3B=�7C_ F\� 5236023�9\5 ] [X36520¶[g9�c>3 U 0236D 5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>={7C3 ] [X=X.Yl U 360k7C<@04<>_¾c>3Z7C[�3�f�54< E _Y3 W <;at0 ] 9\_Y37C[X9;7b< ]B]6U 520®.1=k_19\54p>3 ½ 0 ] 9\_Y3ADX.1087C54. E U 7436Dq.1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=�0 F 02743 W 0®0 U�] [Z9\0`7C[X3 � 3 E � � 9�7 ¿ ���`�$¹¾¯543Bf¸<\527C3BD·9"fX52<\7C<\7 F fi3�<;a/9"0 ] 9\_h9 E _13 � 3 E 023658c>365ÁL Ë | N � s [X3 F 7C523�9;7�043�c>3B5C9\_K.1DX3B=�7C. ] 9\_1_ F] <\=�jgp U 5236D H�sms ? 043B52c>3B540�9\0%9 ] _ U 087C3B5 � 9\=XD U 023{7C[X3{, N T Ô ,/< W 9\.Y= N 9 W 3 T F 02743 W Õ043B52cV. ] 3q74<�DX.1087C54. E U 743 H�sms ?�543Bl U 36087C0�9 ] 52<>040y7C[X3 ] _ U 087C365y.Y=@9�52< U =XD ½ 54< E .1='a¦9\02[X.1<>= �� 3B027:9�cV54<\0�fX52<>fi<>043B0�9%[X.Y36549\5 ] [X. ] 9\_®DX3 W 9\=XD ½ E 9\0236D"543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>={087C549;7C3Bp F 7C[X9;7k<>f�74. W 9\_1_ FDX.Y04043 W .Y=g9;74360º.1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>=¶an54< W .Y740¹f�54<VD UX] 3B5¹74<�023658c>36520t7C[X9;7�9\543 ] _Y<>043B5º74<�.¾7C0 ] <\=X0 U W 36520.1=%74[X3�3B=�c^.Y54<>= W 3B=�7K<\a¢7C[X3 � 3 E L � N � s [X3�_Y3Bc\36_S<\a¢DX.102043 W .1=X9;7C.Y<>=%DX36fi36=�DX0�<>=@7C[�3qfi<>f UV½_h9;54.Y7 F <\aÖ74[g9;7¹DX< ]6U W 36=�7 Ô 5236_h9�7C.Yc\3o7C<q<\7C[�365¹DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0¹.1=�7C[X3y0 F 087C3 W Õ 9\=XD�7C[X3K3�µ^fi3 ] 7436D543BD UX] 7C.1<\=�.Y='7C5C9�À ] 74[g9;7K543B0 U _¾7C0man54< W .Y740mDX.102043 W .1=X9;7C.Y<>= �� 9\3B=�7C0 ] [ �����$¹¾¯ . W f�_13 W 36=�7«9�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=Ù0 F 02743 W ] 9\_1_Y36D r p u È �P`J T Ô r 9 ] [X.1=Xp�p\<^3B0u 36fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\= È � 3 E P < ] 9;74.1<>=�9;=XD J =�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>= T 3652cV. ] 3 Õ L Î N � +�0@74[X36.Y5'=g9 W 3{0 U p>p>3B027C0 �r p u È �P`J T 7 U 52=X0 � 3 E ] 9 ] [�360%.1=�74<�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3BD�043B52c\36540�9\0«=X363BDX36D � J =�9\DXDX.¾7C.Y<>= � 7C[�3fX52. W 9\5 F 023652c\36520oan<>52�t9\54D©7C[X3�Dg9;7:9q7C<�74[X36.Y5t5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36D©043B52c>3B540 � +�=g9 W 3�023652cV. ] 3 �P`J T .Y0U 0236D�74< W 9\=X9\p>3k9\=XD@523604<\_Yc>3qDX.¾ØÖ3B5436=�7 ] <>fX.13B0y<\a®DX9;7:9 �+�_¾7C[X< U p>[���3%9\_Y04<{<>52p�9\=X. ¿ 3�543BfX_1. ] 9\0¶9\0Z9)[X.Y36549\5 ] [ F>� < U 5���<>54´�.10�DX.Yظ365236=�7¶an52< W 74[X36023��<>54´�0�<>= � 3 E 043658c>3B540 �ºE 3 ] 9 U 043«< U 5¶0 F 027C3 W .Y0�9)523B7C52.13�c\9;_¹0 F 027C3 W �y[X.Y_13�7C[X3B.15�043658c>3B540<>=X_ F ] <>=�7:9\.Y= � 3 E DX< ]6U W 36=�740 �

�IÿT�`ÿT� î à�ý ï àVý î à` nà i ü ò d�a� [X3B= W U _Y74.1fX_Y3@5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>=³043658c>3B540@3�µ^.1087'.Y=·7C[X3)0 F 02743 W�� 74[X3{0 F 087C3 W =X363BDX0«74<�043B_13 ] 79�R E 36087�S�023652c\[email protected]=·<>54DX3B5©74< W .Y=X. W . ¿ 3%=X3B7É��<>54´³7C549;À ] 9\=XD�DX.Y027454. E U 7C3�7C[X3)��<>52´V_Y<�9\D �

Ä Ë

Page 41: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

s [X3q04. W fX_Y36087y027C549;7C3Bp F .Y0K549\=XDX< W 043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�9 W <\=Xp�9�023B7K<\ae5236fX_Y. ] 9\0pL Ë | N � H <Â��3Bc\365K7C[X.Y09\fXf�54<�9 ] [�<>=�_ F ��<>52´V0A�y[X3B=�74[X3m=X3�7É�t<>52´�9\=XD�043B52c\365A7C. W 3B0®an<>5e5236l U 36087C0�9\543m=�3�9\52_ F 3Bl U 9\_ �O U F 7C<>=9\=XD TV] [��t9\587 ¿ .1=�c>3B027C.Yp�9;743{043�c>36549\_�043B52c\365�_1< ] 9;74.1<>=³7C3 ] [�=X.1l U 3B0 E 9\043BD<\=[�<>f] < U =�7C0�9\0%9�DX.Y027C9\= ] 3 W 3�9;0 U 523{7C<�_1< ] 9�7C3�74[X3»=X369\5 E�F 023658c>36520-L Ç Ë$N � s [X3 F ] <>_Y_13 ] 7'7C[�3.1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>=�9 E < U 7�[X<>f ] < U =�7C0 E�F U 02.1=Xp�52< U 74365t0 U fXfi<>527 � 52< U 743�fX52< E .1=�p � 9;=XD'[X<>f ½É] < U =�7fX52< E .1=�p � s [�3 F 04[�<Â� 7C[X9;7@54< U 7C3»fX52< E .1=�p�.10%9 W 3B7C[�<^D��y.¾7C[�9�54369\04<>=X9 E _13 ] <>027�9;=XD[X<>f ½É] < U =�7mfX54< E .1=Xp¶.10�74[X3 W <>027tf¸<\527:9 E _13 W 3�7C[X<VD � +�_1_�7C[X3B.15 W 3B74[X<VDX0o=X3B36D'7C[�3/=X3B7É��<>52´7C<\f¸<>_Y<>p F 9\0e74[X3m.1=Xf U 7 � H <}�t3�c>3B5�´�=X<}�y_13BDXp>3m<\a�74[X3m=X3B7É��<>52´¶7C<>fi<>_Y<>p F .10e02< W 3B7C. W 3B0e[g9\52D7C<�9 ] l U .1523 �r 9\587C365'9\=XD r 52<Âc\36_Y_h9�fX52<>fi<>043)9�D F =g9 W . ] 043658c>3B5%0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�02745C9;7436p FÙE 9\0236D�<>=�52< U =XD ½7C52.1f W 3�9;0 U 523 W 36=�7�9\=XD�9}c;9\.Y_h9 E _13 E 9\=XD^�y.1D�74['L z � N � J =�<\54DX3B5�7C< W 3�9;0 U 523«7C[X3«9�c\9;.1_h9 E _13E 9\=�D��y.1D�74[ � 74[X3 F D�3Bc>3B_1<>f%7É��<Z7C<V<>_10 � � ? umM � ÃÙ�y[X. ] [ U 043B0�à roH�M fg9 ] ´;3B740K74< W 3�9;0 U 5237C[�3 E <\727C_Y36=X3 ] ´¶_1.Y=X´q04fi3636D�<\aifg9;74[X0 E 3B7É��3636=�[X<>087C0º.1=�74[X3 J =�7C3B54=X3�7 � 9\=XD r ? umM � à �y[�. ] [36087C. W 9;74360º7C[X3 ] <>=�p>36087C.1<\=%9\_1<\=Xp¶9�fg9;7C[ � s [X3 F 04[�<Â��74[g9;7ofi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�<;aI7C[X.Y0t0 F 087C3 W .Y0W UX] [ E 3B727C365A74[g9\=Z7C[X<\043m<\a U 04.Y=Xp�[X<>f ] < U =�7C0�9\0º9 W 3�9\0 U 543 � s [X3 F 9;_104<�D�.10 ] <}c>365A74[g9;7A7C[�3043B52c\365t_Y<�9\D�.10¹9\=©. W f¸<\527:9;=�7®a¦9 ] 74<>5A7C<qDX3B74365 W .1=�3K74[X3 E 3B027o023658c>365 ��E U 7¹74[X36.Y5º3�µ^f¸3B54. W 3B=�740DX<{=�<\7�02[X<}�Û. W f�54<}c>3 W 3B=�7 U 04.Y=Xp�74[X.10qa¦9 ] 74<>5¶D U 3©74<)7C[X3«[X.1p>[�<}c>3652[X3�9;D�<\a W 369\0 U 54.1=�p043B52c\365K_1<�9\D �� [g9�747:9 ] [g9\5n¼23B3 ���o�$¹¾¯ .1=�c\360274.1p�9�7C3 U 04.Y=Xp'9\f�fX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= ½ _h9 F 3B5y9\= F ] 9\087C.1=�p©7C<©043B_13 ] 7�74[X3 E 36087043B52c\365xL Ì N � s [X3 F fX54<>fi<>023�9op\36=X3B5C9\_�9;5 ] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 523Aan<>5I043B52c\365S043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= E 9\043BDk<>=q9\fXfX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\= ½_h9 F 365@9\= F ] 9\087C.Y=Xp � �y[�. ] [ ] 9\=0 U fXf¸<\527�9\= F�W 3B7454. ];� J =�fg9;527C. ]6U _19\5 � 74[X3 F D�.10 ]BU 040%an< U 5W 3B7C52. ] 0 � 043658c>3B5q523602f¸<>=�043Z7C. W 3 � 043B52c\365 ½ 7C< ½ÒU 043B5�7C[X52< U p>[Xf U 7 � 023658c>365q_1<>9\D � 9;=XD»fX54< ] 3B0402<>5_1<>9\D � s [X3 F U 023/7C[X3�9;= F ] 9\027KDX< W 9\.Y=«=g9 W 3�74<Z.1DX3B=�74.Ya F 543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D'=X3�7É�t<\54´'023652cV. ] 360 � +�=+/, N Ô 9;= F ] 9\027�DX< W 9\.1=@=g9 W 3 Õ 543B04<>_¾c>3B5�.10 U 0236D{74<©523604<\_Yc>3q7C[X3�=g9 W 3 � s [�3 F .1=�c>3B027C.Yp�9;743an< U 5¶f¸<>0204. E _13%9;fXfX54<>9 ] [X360�74< W 9;.1=�7:9\.Y=�.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>= .1=�74[X3%9\= F ] 9\087�043658c>3B540QPADX9;7:9 E 9\043 �543 W <;7C3@043B52c>3B5'fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3@fX52< E .Y=Xp � 023658c>365©f U 02[ � 54369\DX.1=�p�023652c\365'_Y<>p>0 � 9\=�D U 02365«3Úµ ½fi3654.Y36= ] 3 � s [�36.15k52360 U _Y7C0q04[�<Â�Ó74[g9;7q043B52c\365�f U 04[�9;=XD�523�9\DX.Y=Xp�043658c>3B5¶_1<\p>0 ] 9\=�543B0 U _¾7¶.Y=

Ä>Î

Page 42: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

[X.Yp>[ ½ 9 ]6]6U 5C9 ] F>�ºE U 7Z74[X3 F 5236l U .Y543 W <VDX.¾j ] 9;74.1<>=�0�<\a ]6U 54543B=�7©023658c>36520©.Y=�<>54D�365�7C< ] <>_1_Y3 ] 77C[�3 W 3B7454. ] 0Q{ U 02365�3�µ^fi3654.Y36= ] 3)f U 7C0�7C[X3@_1369\027�<}c>3B54[X369\D�<>= ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1=Xp W 3B7C52. ] 0 �¹E U 7�.Y7409 ]B]6U 549 ] F .Y0m_1<}��9;=XD�c;9\52.13BD �s [X3�9 E <Âc\3�743 ] [X=X<\_1<>p>.Y360b9\523�DX.Y543 ] 7C_ F 9\f�fX_1. ] 9 E _Y3e7C<K< U 5S�t<\54´/7C<K[X3B_1f U 0bjg=�D�9y043658c>3B5¢�y.Y74[7C[�3t_1369\027¢_1<>9\DX36D¶<>5¢.Y=�74[X3t=X369\543B027Af�_h9 ] 3 � H <}�t3�c>3B5e7C[X3B543o.Y0®9KfX54< E _13 W .Y=¶< U 5b0 F 087C3 W 7C[g9�7DX<V360�=X<;7k3�µ^.1087k.1=)74[X36.Y5�0 F 02743 W 0 � [X<}�-7C<%043B_13 ] 7q9%543BfX_1. ] 9 E 9;0436D <>=»5236_13�c;9\= ] 3 �SE 3 ] 9 U 023��3 <\=X_ F fg9\5274.h9\_Y_ F 543BfX_1. ] 9;743 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0©�y[X. ] [_1369\DX0'7C<fg9;527C.19\_�5236fX_Y. ] 9\0@9\=XD�<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0m74[g9;7�9\543�=X<\7�36l U 9\_Y_ F 3Bظ3 ] 7C.¾c>3¶an<>5�9«p>.¾c>3B=)l U 365 F � � 3�fX54<>fi<>023�9\=»9;fXfX54<>9 ] [7C<�0236_13 ] 7Kfg9\587C.19\_I543BfX_1. ] 9\0 E 9\043BD)<>=@5236_13�c;9\= ] 3q9\=�D�023652c\365K_1<�9;D �

Ä\Æ

Page 43: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

���v�'&����)� u

�}Ö-������( ������������� �����!���"�

s [X.Y0 ] [g9;f�7C3B5�DX3B0 ] 52. E 360y7C[X3�9\5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 543B0�<\ae< U 5yDX.1087C52. E U 7436D�.1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>=%543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_`0 F 0 ½7C3 W�� 9\0%04[�<Â�y=�.1= w .Yp U 523 Ç � z � s [X3"DX.1087C52. E U 7436D�0 F 087C3 W 3B=g9 E _Y360 W U _¾7C.YfX_13 ] _1.Y36=�7C0'74<04. W U _¾7:9\=X3B< U 02_ F 9 ]6] 3B040 W U _Y74.1fX_Y3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0A<}c>3B5t9k=X3�7É�t<>52´ � +�0�02[X<}�y='.1= w .Yp U 543 Ç � z Ô 9 Õ �7C[�3 E 9;04. ]@] < W fi<>=X3B=�7C0�<\a�74[X3�0 F 02743 W 9\543�9"043B7©<\a ] _1.Y36=�7C0 � 9 ] <\=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 52<>´\3B5 � 9;=XD9»043�7©<;a J = Á U 3B5 F 023652c\36520©an<>5Z087C<>52.1=Xp".1=�DX3�µ^36D ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 � �y[X36523)9;543 ] <>=�=X3 ] 7C36D E�F 9=X3�7É�t<>52´ � J =�74[X.10%D�.1040236587:9;74.1<>= � ��3 U 043 9�_1< ] 9\_�9\523�9�=X3B7É��<>52´ � J =�<>52DX365'74<�. W fX54<}c\30 F 087C3 W fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3q9\=�D)36_Y. W .1=g9�7C3 E <\727C_13B=X3 ] ´�0 � ��3�9\D�D�a U _Y_`<>5yfg9\5274.h9\_Ö5436f�_1. ] 9\0y<\a ] <>_ ½_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 � ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�0236_13 ] 74<>540 � 543BfX_1. ] 9©0236_Y3 ] 74<>540 � 9\=XD)5436f�_1. ] 9\0K<\aA7C[X3 ] <>=X=�3 ] 74.1<>= E 54<>´;365 �w .Yp U 543 Ç � z Ô E Õ 9\=XD Ô ] Õ .Y_1_ U 02745C9;743k7É��<%3�µ�9 W fX_Y360/<\aº< U 5�fi<\7C3B=�7C.h9;_®9\5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 52360 � J = w .1p ½U 523 Ç � z Ô E Õ � �t3©9\DXD�9 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=»0436_Y3 ] 7C<>5q.1="7C[X3 ] <\=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 54<>´;365�74<�0236_Y3 ] 7q7C[�3 W <>027543B_13�c\9;=�7 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0m<\={9©l U 3B5 F ½ E�F ½ l U 3B5 F)E 9\04.Y0�9;=XD)5236027454. ] 7K7C[X3q04369\5 ] [{74<�74[X3¶0236_13 ] 7436D] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 � J = w .1p U 543 Ç � z Ô ] Õ � ��3 E U .Y_1D³fg9\587C.h9;_K5236fX_Y. ] 9\0�an<\5�74[X3)<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0 �9\DXD�9�5236fX_Y. ] 9�0436_Y3 ] 7C<>5m.Y='7C[X3 ] <>=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 54<\´\36520m7C<ZDX.Y543 ] 7K9\0 W 9\= F l U 3B54.13B0K9\0mf¸<\0404. E _137C<)5436_Y3Bc;9\=�7Zfg9;527C.19\_¹5436f�_1. ] 9\0 � 9\=XD�an<>5q7C[X3%l U 3B54.13B0�p><>.Y=Xp)74<)7C[X3«<>54.Yp>.1=g9;_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � ��3U 023'9 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= 0236_Y3 ] 74<>5k7C<)5236087C54. ] 7q7C[X3�04369\5 ] [�74<�74[X3 W <>087�5236_Y3Bc;9\=�7 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0 � w <>5[X.Yp>[@f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 � �t3 E U .Y_1D%3�9 ] [�023652c\365K<>=�9�0 FVW©W 3B7454. ] W U _Y74.1fX52< ] 360402<>5 ] < W f U 7C3B5 � J =7C[�3©5236027¶<\at74[X.10 ] [g9\f^7C365 � ��3«DX3B0 ] 54. E 3©74[X3�a U = ] 74.1<>=X9\_1.¾7 F <\am369 ] [ ] < W fi<>=X3B=�7¶9;=XD�74[X36.Y5.1=�74365C9 ] 7C.Y<>=X0m.Y=�D�3B7:9;.1_10 �

Ä �

Page 44: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

: Connection Broker:

:

Client 1

Client 2

Client m

InQuery Server 1

InQuery Server n

InQuery Server 2

:::

Collections

Ô 9 Õ

:

Selector:

:

Client 1

Client 2

Client m

InQuery Server 1

InQuery Server n

InQuery Server 2

:::

Collections

Connection Broker

Collection

Ô E Õ

:

:

Selector

:

Client 1

Client 2

Client m

Connection Broker

InQuery Server 1

::

InQuery Server k

OriginalCollections

InQuery Server k+1

InQuery Server p

::

Replica 1

InQuery Server n Replica q

ReplicaSelector

Collection

Ô ] Õõ ò ß�%SýÂà �Iÿøþgÿ +�5 ] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 54360yan<>5mDX.Y027454. E U 7C3BD�.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=©543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_ �

Ä\Ì

Page 45: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

u})+( �Î5G?7.!AxEYWs [X3 ] _1.Y36=�7C0©9\523�_Y.1p>[�7É��36.1p\[�7�fX52< ] 360204360©7C[g9;7�fX52<}c^.YDX3{9 U 02365«.Y=�7C3658a¦9 ] 3@7C< 7C[X3�543�7C52.13Bc;9\_0 F 087C3 W � r _1.Y36=�7C0�.1=�7C3B5C9 ] 7¶�y.¾7C[�74[X3'DX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D JLu 0 F 087C3 W E�F ] <>=X=X3 ] 74.1=Xp)74<)7C[�3 ] <>= ½=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 52<>´\3B5 � s [X3 ] _Y.13B=�740�.Y=X.Y74.h9;743�9\_1_e��<>54´ .1= 7C[X3©0 F 02743 W��AE U 7¶f¸3B52an<>5 W c\365 F _Y.Y7474_13] < W f U 7:9;74.1<>= � s [X3 F .Y040 U 3 JLu ] < W©W 9\=XDX0o9\=XD%7C[X3B=%�o9\.¾7oan<>5o523602f¸<>=�04360 � s [X3 ] _1.Y36=�7C0 ] 9\=.1020 U 3©7C[X3'3B=�7C.1523'5C9;=Xp>3«<;a JLu ] < W©W 9\=XDX0 E U 7 � .1=�74[X.10¶DX.1020436587:9;74.1<>= � ��3'an< ]BU 0�<>=�74[X543B3E 9\02. ] JLu ] < W©W 9\=XD�0 � ¨6¡g����� � ��¡V�Z���\��� � 9\=�D £V��¾�¡V�«���g�º�:���¦�Ú¥ ��À��$¹ ] < W�W 9\=�DX0 �J = J = Á U 365 F>� l U 3652.13B0 ] < U _YD E 3o=X9;7 U 549\_X_19\=Xp U 9;p>3tl U 3B54.13B0º<>5e02745 UX] 7 U 5236D�l U 3652.1360 � � 3oan< ]6U 0<>=�=g9�7 U 549\_t_19\=Xp U 9;p>3«l U 3B54.13B0�.1=�74[X.10�D�.1040236587:9;74.1<>= � + =X9;7 U 549\_t_19\=Xp U 9\p>3^× %Sà�ý h i d f �f�Þ a s ] <>=�04.1087C0�<\aA9�043B7�<\a¢�t<>52DX0�<\5�fX[�5C9\02360 Ô 7C3B5 W 0 Õ � 0 UX] [»9\0oR2.1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>=%543�7C52.13Bc;9\_TS �<>51R2DX.Y027454. E U 7C3BDÙ0 F 087C3 W � S Á U 365 F 523602f¸<>=�04360 ] <>=X02.1087«<\a/9 _Y.1087�<\a/DX< ]6U W 3B=�7©.1D�36=�7C.¾jg365205C9;=X´\3BD E�F�E 36_Y.13Bamc;9\_ U 360��y[�. ] [36087C. W 9;743«7C[X3%f�54< E 9 E .1_Y.Y7 F 7C[g9�7Z7C[X3%DX< ]6U W 3B=�7�049;7C.Y02jg3B07C[�3q.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=©=X363BD �w <>5`3�9 ] [�l U 3B5 F>� 9 ] _1.Y36=�7 W 9 F < E 7C9\.1=�<>=�3¹<\5`043Bc\36549\_�0 U W�W 9;54.13B0I<>=q543B_13Bc;9\=�7SDX< ]6U W 3B=�740 E�F043B=XDX.Y=Xp gk%�f-f�Þ�ý h i d f-f�Þ a s�g � +0 U W�W 9;5 F ] < W©W 9\=XD ] <>=�04.1087C0¹<\aS9k043�7o<\a`D�< ]BU W 3B=�7.1D�36=�7C.¾jg36520�9\=XD»7C[�36.15 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=).YDX36=�7C.¾jg36520 � s [X3�0 U W�W 9\5 F .1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>=)<;at9'D�< ]BU W 3B=�77 F fX. ] 9\_1_ F ] <\=X04.Y027C0�<\aÖ74[X3y7C.Y74_13K9\=XD�7C[X3yjg52027tan3���043B=�7436= ] 360o<;aI7C[X3KDX< ]6U W 36=�7 � J 7 W 9 F 9\_102<.1= ] _ U DX3�.1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>=«0 UX] [{9\0y02< U 5 ] 3¶9;=XD@<>54p�9;=X. ¿ 9;7C.Y<>= �+ ] _1.Y36=�7 W 9 F 9\_102<�523B7454.13�c>3 ] < W fX_13�7C3�DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0 E�F 0236=XDX.Y=Xp»9 s d i %�f�à a ü»ýÂà�ü}ý ò à ï Þ� i d f-f�Þ a s � s [X3 ] < W©W 9\=XD ] <>=X02.102740S<\aX9mDX< ]6U W 3B=�7b.YDX36=�7C.¾jg365I9\=XD�9 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=/.1DX3B=�7C.YjX365 �J =¶523602f¸<>=�043 � 74[X3¹0 F 02743 W 543B7 U 54=�0¢7C[�3 ] < W f�_13B743¹743�µV7¢<\aX7C[�3�DX< ]6U W 3B=�7¢an54< W 7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �

u})VU �-245G5G.X:�E�?G24A�WH<>A�� �BAnØÙZ�.�0�] �;.X0�J4.X0�W+ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�.10b9�023B7¢<\aXD�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0S7C[X3¹543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_�0 F 087C3 W .Y0S��<>52´V.Y=XpK<>= � +³_h9;54p>3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=] < U _1D ] <\=�7C9\.1= W .1_Y_1.Y<>=X0S3Bc\36= E .1_1_Y.1<>=�0b<;aÖDX< ]6U W 3B=�740 � w <>5®04. W fX_Y. ] .¾7 F>� �t3K9\020 U W 3o7C[X3B543K9\523=X<�<}c>3B54_19\fX0 E 3B7É��363B=©DX< ]6U W 3B=�740e.1=�9\= F 7É��< ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 � J =�74[X.10eD�.1040236587:9;74.1<>= � �t3 U 043o7C[�3J = Á U 3B5 F 523B7C52.13�c\9;_®36=�p>.1=X3^L z Ë � � Ä NA9\0�< U 5�7436087 E 36D"7C<%.1=�DX3�µ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0/9;=XD"fX54<}cV.1DX3 JLu

Ä\|

Page 46: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

043B52cV. ] 360�0 UX] [9\0�3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y=Xp@l U 3654.Y360 � < E 7:9;.1=X.Y=Xp@0 U W�W 9;5 F .1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>= � 9\=�D�543�7C54.Y3BcV.1=�pDX< ]6U W 36=�740 � � 3K523Ban3B5e7C<k7C[X3y043B52c\365�9\0A7C[X3 J = Á U 3B5 F 023652c\365 � s [�3 J = Á U 365 F 023658c>365t9 ]6] 36f�7409 ] < W�W 9;=XDqan52< W 74[X3 ] <>=X=X3 ] 74.1<>= E 54<>´;365 � fX52< ] 360402360®74[X3 ] < W�W 9;=XD � 9\=XDq543�7 U 52=X0®.¾7C0S543B0 U _¾7E 9 ] ´'74<Z7C[X3 ] <\=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 54<>´;365 �

u})eu �-24A6A�.X:�E�?724A �Ó0�2*�4.X0r _1.Y36=�7C0�9\=XD J = Á U 365 F 023658c>36520 ] < W�W U =�. ] 9�7C3mcV.h9q74[X3 ] <>=X=X3 ] 74.1<>= E 54<>´;365 � s [X3 ] <\=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>=E 52<>´\3B5�.10�9'fX52< ] 36020/7C[g9;7/´\363BfX0�7C549 ] ´)<\a�9\_Y_¢5236p>.Y027436543BD ] _Y.136=�740�9\=XD J = Á U 3B5 F 043658c>3B540 � +] _Y.13B=�7e0436=�DX0¹9 ] < W�W 9;=XD¶7C</74[X3 ] <>=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 54<\´\365e�y[�. ] [Zan<>52�t9\52DX0A.Y7¢7C</7C[�3y9\fXfX52<>fX54.19;7C3J = Á U 3B5 F 023658c>36520 � s [X3 ] <>=X=X3 ] 74.1<>= E 54<>´;365 W 9\.1=�7:9;.1=X0S.1=�74365 W 36D�.h9;743t543B0 U _¾7C0®an<\5 ] < W©W 9\=XDX07C[X9;7y.1=�c><\_Yc>3 W U _Y7C.YfX_13 J = Á U 3B5 F 043B52c\36540 � � [�36=�9\= J = Á U 365 F 043658c>3B5�523B7 U 54=X0K9Z543B0 U _¾7 � 7C[�3] <\=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 54<>´;365 W 3B54p>3B0y.Y7m�y.Y74[@<\7C[X3B5y54360 U _Y740 � +�a�74365K9\_Y_ J = Á U 365 F 043B52c>3B540�.1=�c><>_¾c>3BD�.Y=9 ] < W�W 9\=�D�523B7 U 54={52360 U _Y740 � 7C[X3 ] <>=�=X3 ] 7C.1<\= E 52<>´\3B5�043B=XDX0K7C[X3qjg=g9\_S543B0 U _¾7�74<�74[X3 ] _1.Y36=�7 �� 3B04.1D�360�´\3B36fX.Y=Xp»7C5C9 ] ´�<\a�9\_1_ ] _Y.136=�740Z9\=XD J = Á U 3B5 F 023652c\36520 � ��3 W 9 F 9\_102<{36=X[X9\= ] 3@7C[�3] <\=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 54<>´;365m7C<�fi3652an<\5 W ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=%0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=@<>5m5236fX_Y. ] 9�0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= �

�IÿT�`ÿ¦þ â�d _ ¦à i ü ò d�a�î à` ¦à i ü d ý� [X3B=�7C[X3B543«9\543«9�_h9;54p>3�= U W�E 365�<\a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 � ��3 U 043%9 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>="0436_Y3 ] 7C<>5q7C<{9 U 7C< ½W 9;7C. ] 9\_Y_ F 0236_13 ] 7o74[X3 W <>027o5436_Y3Bc;9\=�7 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0�<>=@9�l U 365 F ½ E�F ½ l U 365 F@E 9\04.Y0 � + ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=043B_13 ] 7C<\5 W 9\.Y=�7C9\.1=�0m9 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=@Dg9;7:9 E 9\043�74[g9;7 ] <>=�7C9\.1=X0 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= ½ _13�c>3B_Ö.1=^an<>5 ½W 9;7C.Y<>=�<>=�Dg9�7:9»DX.1087C52. E U 7436D�<}c>3B5�9\_1_ J = Á U 365 F 043B52c\36540 � � [X36=7C[�3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�043B_13 ] 7C<\5543 ] 3B.Yc>3B0'9"l U 365 F>� .¾7�043�9;5 ] [X3B0«7C[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=0236_13 ] 74.1<>=Dg9;7C9 E 9\023)9;=XDÙ523B7 U 54=X0«9 _Y.1087Z<\a7C[�3 W <>027�543B_13Bc;9\=�7 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=".1DX3B=�7C.YjX36540¶9\=XD ] <>52543602f¸<\=XDX.1=�p ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= 5C9\=�´V.Y=Xp)0 ] <>52360 �s [X3 ] <>=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 52<>´\3B5 U 043B0/7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=)549\=X´�.1=Xp«0 ] <\54360/74<«��36.1p\[�7/DX< ]BU W 36=�7�0 ] <>543B0an54< W DX.Yظ365236=�7 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0y.1=@<>52DX365y7C<©fX54<VD UX] 3 ] < W fX9\5C9 E _13�<}c>3B5C9\_Y_bD�< ]BU W 3B=�7�549\=X´�.1=Xp\0Ô 02363oL z}Î N Õ �

Ç>Å

Page 47: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

�IÿT�`ÿT� ñ à�ûF òji Þ î à` ¦à i ü d ý� [X3B=���3�<>=�_ F 5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3k9Z0 W 9\_Y_If¸<\527C.Y<>=%<\ab7C[X3q<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= Ô 0 Õ an<>5y3BÀ ] .136= ] F>� ��3=X3B36DZ9y543BfX_1. ] 9y0436_Y3 ] 7C<>5S7C<KDX.1523 ] 7®9;0 W 9\= F l U 3652.1360®9\0bf¸<>0204. E _13A7C<Kfg9\587C.19\_>543BfX_1. ] 9\0 E 9;0436D¶<>=E <\7C[@543B_13�c\9;= ] 3q9\=XD�_1<>9\DX0 � +�0y<>fXfi<>043BD�7C< ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=%0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=%�y[X. ] [�549\=X´�0KDX.10�¼ U = ] 74.Yc\3] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 � 5236fX_Y. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�549\=X´�0efg9\587C.19\_�543BfX_1. ] 9\0®9\=XD¶74[X3o<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= Ô 0 Õ � �y[�. ] [[X<>_YD)9�0 U E 043�7�543B_h9;74.1<>=X02[X.1f � +vfg9\587C.19\_`543BfX_1. ] 9 ] < U _1D E 3�9�5236fX_Y. ] 9�<\ae9�02.1=Xp>_Y3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �<>5y9Z543BfX_1. ] 9�<\a¢043�c>3B5C9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0 � J = w .1p U 543 Ç � z Ô ] Õ � �t3�cV.13���9\_Y_Ö<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0m9;09©�y[X<\_13 � 9\=XD E U .1_YD)fg9\587C.19\_S5436f�_1. ] 9\0yan<>5�74[X3¶�y[X<>_Y3¶<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0 � J =»< U 5�0 F 02743 W����3�<>52p�9\=X. ¿ 3�< U 5mfg9\5274.h9\_¸543BfX_1. ] 9\0y9\0K9Z[X.Y365C9;5 ] [ Fi� 9Z0 W 9\_Y_1365t5436f�_1. ] 9�.10y9�0 U E 043B7�<\a¢_h9\52p>365543BfX_1. ] 9\0K9\=�D�7C[�3¶<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= Ô 0 Õ Ô 043B3 T 3 ] 7C.Y<>=)Ë � Ä an<>5yDX3B7C9\.1_Y0 Õ � + 5236fX_Y. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C<\5W 9\.1=�7:9;.1=X0�9@5236fX_Y. ] 9'0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=»Dg9;7:9 E 9\043�9\=�D"74[X3�_1<�9;D{.1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>=)<\a�3�9 ] [�023652c\365 � w <>53�9 ] [�l U 365 F ] < W�W 9\=XD � 74[X3�5436f�_1. ] 9'043B_13 ] 7C<>5k023�9\5 ] [X360q7C[X.Y0�Dg9;7:9 E 9\043©9\=XD"523B7 U 54=X0q36.¾7C[X3B59'543BfX_1. ] 9'.YDX36=�7C.¾jg365�.YaA7C[�36543�.Y0�9'543B_13Bc;9\=�7k5236fX_Y. ] 9 � <>5k9 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=).1DX3B=�74.Yjg3B5 � � [X36="7C[�3543BfX_1. ] 9�0436_Y3 ] 7C<>5�543B7 U 54=�0Z9)543BfX_1. ] [email protected]=�7C.YjX365 � .Y7�0436=�DX0¶7C[�3'l U 365 F 74<)7C[X3©543BfX_1. ] 9�.¾ao.¾7¶.Y0=X<\7�<}c>3B54_1<>9\DX36D � <\74[X3658�y.1043�.Y7�043B=XDX0�74[X3¶l U 3B5 F 7C<'9�_h9\52p>365K543BfX_1. ] 9�<>5y7C[X3�043658c>3B5 Ô 0 Õ 7C[g9�70274<>543 Ô 0 Õ 74[X3k<>54.Yp>.1=X9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= Ô 0 Õ �

�IÿT�`ÿT� óQa ü�àVýÂÞ i ü ò d�a gw <>5�9)l U 365 F ] < W©W 9\=XD � 7C[�3 ] <>=�=X3 ] 7C.1<\= E 54<\´\365 ] < U _YD�fi3658an<>5 W DX.¾ØÖ3B5436=�7�a U = ] 74.1<>=�0�9 ]Ú½] <\54DX.Y=Xp%7C<%7C[X3�0 F 087C3 W 9;5 ] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 523 � J ="7C[X3 E 9\023�0 F 02743 W .1_Y_ U 087C5C9�7C36D).1= w .1p U 543 Ç � z Ô 9 Õ �7C[�3 ] <>=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 54<>´;365q0436=�DX0¶7C[�3©l U 3B5 F 7C<�9\_1_ J = Á U 365 F 023658c>36520 � 9\=�D�7C[�36= W 3652p>360k7C[�3543B0 U _¾7C0 � J =�7C[X3m0 F 027C3 W .1_Y_ U 087C549;7C3BD�.1= w .1p U 523 Ç � z Ô E Õ � 74[X3 ] <\=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 54<>´;365 U 02360º9 ] <>_1_Y3 ]�½7C.Y<>=�0436_Y3 ] 7C<>5m7C<©< E 7C9\.1=�9�_1.1087K<\a®74<>f ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0 � 0236=XDX0K7C[X3ql U 365 F 7C<�7C[X3 ] <>52543B04fi<>=XDX.Y=XpJ = Á U 3B5 F 043658c>3B540 W 9\.1=�7:9;.1=X.Y=Xp'7C[X3B043 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0 � 9\=XD�74[X36= W 3652p>360q7C[X3©543B0 U _¾7C0 � J =�7C[�30 F 087C3 W .Y_1_ U 027C549;7C3BD'.1= w .Yp U 523 Ç � z Ô ] Õ � 7C[X3 ] <>=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 54<>´;365mjg52027 U 043B0�9Z543BfX_1. ] 9Z043B_13 ] 7C<\57C<ZD�3B7C3B5 W .1=X3��y[X3B74[X365m7C[�36543�.Y0y9�fg9\587C.h9;_¸5236fX_Y. ] 9q7C[g9;7y.Y0o=X<\7o<>=X_ F 543B_13�c\9;=�7t7C<Z7C[X3�l U 3B5 F\�E U 7m9\_102<�=X<\7m<}c\3654_Y<�9\DX3BDI{ J a`74[X36523�.10t<\=X3 � 74[X3 ] <>=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 52<>´\3B5m0436=�DX0m7C[X3/l U 3B5 F 7C<�7C[�3

�z

Page 48: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

J = Á U 3B5 F 023652c\365 Ô 0 Õ 74[g9;7 W 9\.1=�7C9\.1= 7C[X3%5236_13�c;9\=�7Z543BfX_1. ] 9 � <\74[X3658�y.1023%.Y7 U 04360�9 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=043B_13 ] 7C<\5º74<�< E 7:9\.Y=�9q_Y.1027e<\aÖ74<>f ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0e< U 7¹<\a¸7C[X3y<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 � 9;=XD©0236=XD�0�7C[�3l U 365 F 7C<Z7C[�3 J = Á U 365 F 023658c>36520�74[g9;7 W 9\.1=�7:9;.1=«74[X3k0436_Y3 ] 7C36D ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 �w <>5o9�0 U W�W 9;5 F ] < W©W 9\=XD � 7C[�3 ] <>=�=X3 ] 7C.1<\= E 54<>´;365o0236=XD�0o7C[X3 ] < W�W 9\=�D©7C<�7C[X3 J = Á U 365 F043B52c\36540b�y[X<>023�.YDX36=�7C.¾jg36520b9\543ºDX3B0 ] 52. E 36D�.1=�7C[X3 ] < W©W 9\=XD � s [X3 ] <\=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 54<>´;365 W 3B54p>3B07C[�3q0 U W�W 9\5 F .Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=©543602f¸<\=X043B0/9\=XD�043B=XDX0�9Z04.1=�p>_13 W 36020C9\p>3 E 9 ] ´«7C<Z7C[�3 ] _1.Y36=�7 �w <>5¹9qD�< ]BU W 3B=�7t523B7C52.13�c\9;_ ] < W�W 9;=XD � 7C[�3 ] <>=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 54<>´;365t0236=XD�0�7C[�3 ] < W©W 9\=XDZ74<�7C[�3J = Á U 3B5 F 043B52c>3B5�74[g9;7 ] <>=�7:9;.1=X0m7C[�3¶DX< ]6U W 36=�7 � 9;=XD�74[X36=�an<>52�t9\54D�0K74[X3�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7�74<©7C[�3] _Y.13B=�7K9;0K02<^<\=�9;0K.¾7m543 ] 3B.Yc>3B0�74[X3kDX< ]BU W 36=�7man54< W 7C[X3 J = Á U 3B5 F 023652c\365 �

Ç�Ä

Page 49: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

���v�'&����)� |

&���{������ � $ ����� ����� $ & ���Á& �������"��� $ &

?®9;527C.19\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=·5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=·.10©7C5 U _ F U 043�a U _�an<>5«.1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=Ù523B7C52.13�c\9;_�<>=�_ F �y[X36=�.Y70C9�7C.108jg360m74[X3�an<>_1_Y<Â�y.Y=Xp¶an< U 5 ] <>=XD�.Y7C.Y<>=X0 �

z � Á U 3B5 F 9\=XD�DX< ]BU W 36=�7/9 ]6] 3B0402360/_Y< ] 9\_1. ¿ 3�.1=�9�0 W 9\_1_`fi<>5274.1<>=@<\aA9 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=%�y.¾7C[X.Y=9Zfi3654.Y<^D@<\ab7C. W 3 �

Ä � s [X3B543q.10y9\=@3�ØÖ3 ] 7C.¾c>3k7C<V<>_Ö74<�0236_Y3 ] 7�9Z543B_13�c\9;=�7Kfg9;527C.19\_Ö5236fX_Y. ] 9 �

Ç � s [X3�74. W 3k9\=XD@04fg9 ] 3q<Âc\3652[X3�9\D�0�an<>5m5236fX_Y. ] 9�0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�9\523k543�9;04<>=g9 E _13 �

Ë � s [X3 U fiDg9;74.1=Xp ] <>02740�9\523�54369\04<>=X9 E _13 �

J =·74[X.10 ] [g9\f�74365 � ��3{DX.Y0 ]BU 040«74[X3).Y040 U 360'5236_19;7C3BDÙ7C< 7C[X3B043 ] <>=XDX.¾7C.Y<>=X0 � s [X3)543 W 9\.Y=XDX365<\aK7C[X.Y0 ] [g9\f�74365�.10Z<>52p�9\=X. ¿ 3BDÙ9;0�an<>_1_Y<Â�y0 � �t3@3ÚµX9 W .Y=X3'7C[X3@_Y< ] 9\_1.¾7 F .Y=543�9;_m0 F 02743 W 0©.Y=T 3 ] 7C.Y<>=�Ë � z>� fX543B043B=�7�< U 5qfg9\5274.h9\_A5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= 9\5 ] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 543«.Y= T 3 ] 74.1<>=�Ë � Ä^� 3Úµ�f�_1<>523©[X<}�7C<)0436_Y3 ] 7�9)543B_13Bc;9\=�7Z5236fX_Y. ] 9).1= T 3 ] 74.1<>=�Ë � Ç^� DX.10 ]6U 020Z[X<}� 74<»043B_13 ] 7�9{543BfX_1. ] 9 E 9\043BD<>=_1<>9\DX0�.Y= T 3 ] 7C.1<\=�Ë � Ë � .1=�c>3B027C.Yp�9;743%04fg9 ] 3�9\=XD�7C. W 3©<}c>3652[X3�9;DX0�an<\5¶7C[X3%5236fX_Y. ] 9)043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=Dg9;7C9 E 9\023�.1= T 3 ] 7C.Y<>=%Ë � Î^� .Y=�c\36087C.1p>9;7C3 U fiDg9;74.1=Xp ] <>02740K9\=XD@02745C9;7436p>.Y360m.1= T 3 ] 74.1<>=@Ë � Æ�� 9;=XD0 U W©W 9\54. ¿ 3/.Y= T 3 ] 7C.1<\=�Ë ���^�

|[)+( �':=:=.XW�W�-,�<K0�<K:�E�.X0 ?7W`E�?G:=WH?GA �H.X<>5«��� ��];W`EY.�8DW� 3%3�µ�9 W .1=X3«74[X3%_1< ] 9;_1.Y7 F <;a�9 ]6] 3B040�.1=�74[X3%_1<\p>0¶<\aK523�9\_ JLu 0 F 02743 W 0 � � 3@9\=g9;_ F ¿ 3«7É��<043B52c\365%9 ]B] 3B040'_Y<>p>0 � <>=X3@an54< W syH�M d�+ T L Î>Ä N � 9\=XD³7C[X3�<\7C[X3B5©an52< W îµ ] .Y743ÎL Ä � N � s [X3syH/M d�+ T 0 F 02743 W .Y0�9)_Y36p>.Y04_h9�7C.Yc\3©.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>="023652cV. ] 3%<\am74[X3 R �ÐT¸� r <\=Xp>543B040�74[X54< U p>[

Ç>Ç

Page 50: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

7C[�3 P . E 549\5 F <\a r <>=Xp\5436020 � �y[X. ] [ U 043B0 J = Á U 365 F 9\0�74[X3�523B7454.13�c;9\_S36=Xp>.Y=X3 � J 7 ] <\=�7C9\.1=�0�7C[�3a U _Y_I7C3�µV7�<\aº9\_Y_ E .1_1_Y0m.1=�7C52<^D UX] 3BD).1=�7C[X3 z}Å�z 087 ½ z}Å�Î 7C[ r <>=Xp>52360402360k9\0y��36_1_¢9\0K7C[X3k7C3Úµ^7�<\a7C[�3 r <>=�p>543B0404.Y<>=g9\_ u 3 ] <>54DX0kan<>5�7C[�<>043 r <>=Xp>52360204360 � � 3©9\=g9\_ F ¿ 3Z7C[X3�_1<\p>0k<\a syH�M d�+ TE 3B7É��3636= � U _ F�z Ë�9;=XD T 36f�743 W�E 365 z}Ç��Az}|\|>Ì � , U 54.Y=Xp'7C[�.10kf¸3B54.Y<^D � ��3�< E 7:9;.1=X3BD"74[X3�a U _1_Dg9 F _1<\p>0oan<>5yË Å Dg9 F 0 � 9;=XD�fX9\5274.h9\_`_Y<>p>0m<>=@7C[X3q543 W 9;.1=X.Y=Xp Ä>Ä Dg9 F 0 � s [X3q54369\04<>=�0�an<>5m7C[�3_h9�747C3B5K�t9\0�_19 ] ´@<\aºDX.102´�02fg9 ] 3�.1=)74[X3 W 9\.1_Y.1=XpZ0 F 027C3 W <\aA74[X3 P . E 5C9\5 F <;a r <>=Xp>5236040/�y[�36=7C[�3 F 0236=�7 U 0�74[X3%_1<>p\0 � s [X3@îµ ] .¾7C3%0 F 087C3 W fX54<}cV.1DX3B0Z<>=X_Y.1=X3©043�9;5 ] [�an<>5 W <>543�7C[g9;= Î\ÅW .1_1_Y.1<>= � 3 E fg9\p>3B0 � � 3k< E 7:9\.Y=X36D%7C[�3�îµ ] .¾7C3�an<>5m7C[�3qDX9 F <\a T 36f�743 W�E 365 z}Æ��Öz}|>| �^�w .Yp U 543¹Ë � z _1.Y02740¢02< W 3�3�µ ] 3B54f�740Aan54< W 7C[�3 syH/M d�+ T 9\=XD¶74[X3mîµ ] .Y743o_1<\p>0 � s [X3 syH�M d�+ T_1<\p>0 ] <>=�7C9\.1=q.1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>=/<>= E <;7C[kl U 365 F 9;=XD�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7 ] < W�W 9\=�DX0 � w <>5`3�9 ] [ ] < W�W 9\=XD �7C[�3�0 F 02743 W 543 ] <>52DX0m7C[X3�DX9;7C3k9\=�D@74. W 3�an<>5o523 ] 36.YcV.Y=XpZ7C[X3 ] < W©W 9\=XD � 7C[�3�Dg9;7:9 E 9\043k.YDX36= ½7C.¾jg365 � 9\=XD»7C[�3Z543602f¸<\=X043�7C. W 3 � J = 9\DXD�.Y7C.Y<>= � an<\5/3�9 ] [ l U 365 F>� 7C[�3�0 F 027C3 W 543 ] <>52DX0kl U 365 F7C3B5 W 0A9\=XD ] 543�9�7C360º9/023658c>365 ½ 02.1DX3m7C3 W fi<>549\5 F jg_13¹7C<�049}c\3m7C[X3m023�9\5 ] [©52360 U _Y7C0b{ w <\5®3�9 ] [�D�< ]Ú½U W 36=�7 ] < W�W 9\=�D � 7C[X3q0 F 02743 W 543 ] <>54D�0�.Y740�523Ban3B5436= ] 3¶74<%9�743 W f¸<>549\5 F jX_13k7C[g9;7�0C9�c\360/7C[�304369\5 ] [�543B0 U _¾7C0oan<>5o74[X3 ] <>52543602f¸<\=XDX.1=�p�l U 3B5 F � s [X3qîµ ] .¾7C3k_1<>pZ<\=X_ F ] <>=�7:9;.1=X0m.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=<>=»l U 3B5 F ] < W�W 9\=�DX0 � J 7 ] <>=�7:9\.Y=X0�74[X3 U 02365�.1D�36=�7C.¾jg365 � 7C[X3¶Dg9;7C3�9\=XD{7C. W 3qan<>5�523 ] 36.YcV.Y=Xp7C[�3ql U 3B5 F 9\=�D�l U 3B5 F 7C3B5 W 0oan<>5m3�9 ] [)l U 365 F �J =�3�µ�9 W .1=X.Y=Xp�7C[X3k_Y<>p>0 � �t3qfg9\.YD�9;747436=�7C.Y<>=%7C<Z7C[X3�an<>_Y_1<}�y.1=�p ] [g9\549 ] 743654.Y0274. ] 0 �

z � s [X3m549;7C.Y<�<\ail U 3B5 F f�54< ] 360204.Y=Xpk9\=XDZDX< ]6U W 3B=�7A9 ]6] 36040 � s [X3m5C9�7C.1<�DX3B74365 W .Y=X360®�y[�. ] [Dg9�7:9 E 9;043 ] < W fi<>=X3B=�7C0¶��3'=X3B36D�7C<{5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3�7C< W 9�µ^. W . ¿ 3�74[X3 E 36=X3�jX7Z<\ayfX9\5274.h9\_] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=«5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>= �

Ä � Á U 3B5 F _Y< ] 9\_1.¾7 F �y.¾7C[X.Y=k9Kfi3652.1<VD�<\aV7C. W 3 � �y[�. ] [qDX3B74365 W .1=�360I7C[�3 U 043Ba U _1=X3B040b<\a�fX9\5274.h9\_5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\= �

Ç � s [X3K<}c>3B54_h9;f«<\aÖl U 3654.Y360 E 3�7É�t3B36='DX9 F 0t9\=XD��t3B36´�0 � �y[�. ] [«D�3B7C3B5 W .1=X3B0º[X<}��<\a�7C3B=���3=X3B36D@7C< U fiDg9;7C3�74[X3k5436f�_1. ] 9\0 �

Ç Ë

Page 51: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

ÚtÛbÜtÝoÞÅß#à7á#Ý Úbâvã�Ú�ä åCælÝbç$àCÝlèmébç�Útélê�æ�á#Ý�ë�Ü~ì�é�áká#ÛCëtíOèîkîkîQîkîkîkîkîQîkîkîkîkîQîkîkîQîQîkîQîkîbîkîQîQîkîQîkîbîkîkîbîkîQîkîQîQîkîbîkîQîkîQîQîkîbîkîkîQîQîQîkîbîkîkîQîQîQîkîkîbîkîQîQîkîQîkîbîkîQîQîkîï ßQætÝÅð¿æOñÃò+ó�ôQô�õGò+ó�õ¢öbó�ò�÷k÷QøQù�êlò�ôkö�õ}úlñlà�ñQÝbû�ü�ò^è�Ýtê�äVýï ßQætÝÅð¿æOñÃò+ó�ôQô�õGò+ó�õ¢ök÷�ò�÷k÷QøQù�êlò�ôkö�õ�Ü�ÛbþQÿlÛbû�Ýbç çtÝkñlàCÝ���Ûlê�Ü üeôÁè�Ýtê�äVýï ßQætÝÅð¿æOñÃò+ó�ôQô�õGò�ö�õ¢ô���ò�÷k÷QøQù^çBò�ôkö�õ����kß�� õkä�ÜtÝ�álÿ� ��ç¦ò�ôkö�ñ¿ç�����÷���õ_Ýkø��köQô õü�ôÃè�Ýtê�äVýï ßQætÝÅð¿æOñÃò+ó�ôQô�õGò�ö�õ¢ô���ò�÷k÷QøQù�êlò�ôkö�õ����kß-òBõkä�ÜtÝ�álÿ� �Qêtò�ôkö#ò��Bò��tê���õ_Ý#ò����Q÷Q÷�õ�üeôÁè�Ýlê�äVýï ßQætÝÅð¿æOñÃò+ó�ôQô�õGò�ö�õ¢ôkö�ò�÷k÷QøQù�êlò�ôkö�õ���ÛbÜ#àCÝ�ëkÜ$è1ü�òoè�Ýlê�äeýï ßQætÝÅð¿æOñÃò+ó�ôQô�õGò�ö�õ¢ôk÷�ò�÷k÷QøQù�êlò�ôkö�õ����kß'ä��ÜtÝ�álÿ �Qêlò�ôQöbþ��lð������¶ü���è�Ýlê�äVýï ßQætÝÅð¿æOñÃò+ó�ôQô�õGò�ö�õ7ò���ò�÷k÷QøQù�êlò�ôkö�õ�ç�Ý�ñlà��#à¿é�ë ��ÿlÝ�ç$è�Ýlê�ækÜ#àCé�ëÎü�ò^èCÝlê�äVýï ßQætÝÅð¿æOñÃò+ó�ôQô�õGò�ö�õ7ò�ø�ò�÷k÷QøQù^çBò�ôkö�õ�ã�ç#àCÛ�ë�ðQÛbû�Û�ü�ò^è�Ýtê�äVýï ßQætÝÅð¿æOñÃò+ó�ôQô�õGò�ö�õ!�kô�ò�÷k÷QøQù^çBò�ô���õ����kß�" õkä�ÜtÝ�álÿ� ��ç¦ò�ô���â�ø��kÛ��$#�õ_Ý��böbó�ø���õ�ü�òoè�Ýlê�äVýï ßQætÝÅð¿æOñÃò+ó�ôQô�õGò�ö�õ!�bó�ò�÷k÷QøQù�êlò�ôkö�õ����kß�� õkä�ÜtÝ�álÿ� �Qêtò�ôkö�%bóQë�û�õQõü�ôÃè�Ýtê�äVýï ßQætÝÅð¿æOñÃò+ó�ôQô�õGò�ö�õ!�kø�ò�÷k÷QøQù�êlò�ôkö�õ����kß�& äGò�økø�� õmü���è�Ýlê�äVý')(�*,+.-0/�13254�6�798:25;�<=6>01@?BADCFEHGJILKM;�NO¦è�Ýbç�ã�Ú�ä ÚtÛbÜtÝ~Þ�ß#à7á#Ý åCætÝbç#àCÝlè

îkîkîQîkîkîkîkîQîkîkîkîkîQîkîkîQîQîkîQîkîbîkîQîQîkîQîkîbîkîkîbîkîQîkîQîQîkîbîkîQîkîQîQîkîbîkîkîQîQîQîkîbîkîkîQîQîQîkîkîbîkîQîQîkîQîkîbîöbókÚbâ�Út÷���âkó��0����"$ò��#ò ÷�"kôk÷$ò��#ò��#òP�bótö Ûbí�Û�á`è�á#Ûbç��Q#tébÜtÝ�ñöbókÚbâ�Út÷���âkó��0����"$ò��#ò ÷�"kôk÷$ò��#ò��#òP�bókó Ûbí�Û�á`è�á#Ûbç��Q#tébÜtÝ�ñ�ÜQælñtè�Ûâl÷bóQÚ0���kö������køkö��$ò+Ú�ì ÷�"kôk÷$ò��#ò�öbó�öbót÷ èkà�ÜtÝ�á#Û�ÿ#èâl÷bóQÚ0���kö������køkö��$ò+Ú�ì ÷�"kôk÷$ò��#ò�öbó�ökö#ò èkà�ÜtÝ�á#Û�ÿâl÷bóQÚ0���kö������køkö��$ò+Ú�ì ÷�"kôk÷$ò��#ò�öbó������ èkà�ÜtÝ�á#Û�ÿ¶è�Ýbç�R�Ýbç$èâl÷bóQÚ0���kö������køkö��$ò+Ú�ì ÷�"kôk÷$ò��#ò�öbó�÷#ò�ø èkà�ÜtÝ�á#Û�ÿSR#à�çkÜbælÛ�ñâl÷bóQÚ0���kö������køkö��$ò+Ú�ì ÷�"kôk÷$ò��#ò��kô�"kôk÷ TtÝ�ú1èkà�ÜtÝ�á#Û�ÿ#è

')U�*,+V-0/313254�657W8:25;�<X65>01@+V-0/3YZ651FKM;�Nõ ò ß�%Sý�à �Sÿøþgÿ îµ ] 3B54f�740Kan52< W 7C[�3 syH�M d�+ T 9\=XD�îµ ] .Y743q_Y<>p>0 �

�Sÿ¦þ�ÿ¦þ ñ Þ�ü ò dvd c\[ %SàVý h Ý�ý d i à`gkg ò a ß�Þ a s ê^d i %�f�à a ü á i¦i à�gQg� 3©´�=X<}� 9\= JLu 0 F 027C3 W [g9\0�74[X543B3 E 9\04. ] JLu ] < W©W 9\=XDX0 � l U 3B5 F\� 0 U W�W 9\5 F\� 9;=XD�DX< ]6UV½W 36=�7 ] < W�W 9\=XDX0 � + W <>=�p)7C[X3 W�� l U 3B5 F ] < W©W 9\=XD�0Z9 ]6] 36020�74365 W .1=�c>3B527436D_1.Y027�jg_Y360¶74<fX52<^D U�] 3�9�549\=X´\3BD@_1.1087t<;aS5436_Y3Bc;9\=�7mDX< ]6U W 3B=�7o.1DX3B=�74.Yjg3B540b{�0 U W©W 9\5 F ] < W©W 9\=XDX0t9\=XD'D�< ]Ú½U W 36=�7 ] < W�W 9\=XDX0�9 ]B] 36020«DX< ]6U W 3B=�7©.1=�c\36527436DÙ_1.1087Zjg_13B0�9\=XD7C[X3�<>54.Yp>.1=X9\_tDg9�7:9»jg_13B0�74<< E 7C9\.1=%0 U W�W 9\5 F .Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=�an<>5y9�043�7K<\abDX< ]BU W 36=�7C0K9\=XD%74[X3�a U _1_i7C3�µV7y<\a®9ZDX< ]6U W 36=�7 �+ ]B] <>52DX.1=�p 74< 74[X3�DX9;7:9 E 9\043 ] < W fi<>=X3B=�740©369 ] [ ] < W�W 9\=�D·9 ]B] 3B04043B0 � ��3 ] 9;7C3Bp><>54. ¿ 3%7C[�3] < W©W 9\=XDX0�.1=�7C<«7É��< ] 9;7436p><\54.13B0 � l U 365 F fX54< ] 3B0404.Y=Xp%7C[g9�7�.1= ] _ U D�360�74[X3Zl U 365 F ] < W�W 9\=XD �9\=XD)DX< ]BU W 36=�7/9 ]6] 3B040/74[g9;7�.1= ] _ U DX3B0 E <\7C[�0 U W�W 9\5 F 9\=�D{DX< ]6U W 36=�7 ] < W�W 9;=XDX0 � J aº<>=�3

Ç�Î

Page 52: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

]�^ 1�2YM1�7D_.`0;�/ ^ <a13b�657(�c�132�($N�1 <dYMb0YM< ^ < <e(f-�YM< ^ <g _ g�h i g _kj h l g _ m h l4n132�/�13b�6�($N�1D;�8o`�;�/ ^ <d1�b�657,8)(�KpKMYpb NdqBYp6> Ypb\2�($b0r�7g�s�g m g�g3s j�m j g�sut m t g�svl m l g3suw m w�g�sux m x g�suy m y0g3s5g m�m g m g�s j$m�m z{j$m�m| w�h y�} i0hkw�} w0h j } t0h | } t0h x�} m h t�} m hkw�} m h l�} m hkw�} m h x�}í Þ��! ¦à �Sÿøþgÿ u 9;7C.Y<>0o<\a¢l U 3652.13B0�9\=�D�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0K.1='7C[�3 syH�M d�+ T _1<>p �

<\ag74[X3 W 9 ]6] < U =�7C0ean<\5¢7C[�3 W 9}¼2<>54.¾7 F <;a�0 F 02743 W fX52< ] 360204.1=�p�7C. W 3 � ��3m<>=X_ F =X3B36DZ7C<�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C39Z0 U E 043B7�<\a®Dg9;7:9 E 9\043 ] < W fi<>=X3B=�7C0m7C<�. W fX52<Âc\3�0 F 02743 W fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3 �� 3Z3�µ�9 W .1=X3¶74[X3 syH/M d�+ T _Y<>p>0Kan<>5�7C[�3Z5C9;74.1<'<\a¹l U 3B5 F fX52< ] 360204.1=�p�9;=XD"DX< ]BU W 36=�7k9 ]Ú½] 3B0402360 � �y[X36523 � <>=�74[X3¶9�c\365C9;p>3 � 7C[X3q0 F 02743 W 543 ] 36.¾c>3B0 Î\|�Ä;Ì l U 3B54.13B0/9\=�D z}Å Ë Ç>Ç D�< ]BU W 3B=�7] < W©W 9\=XDX0�fi365�Dg9 F � � 3�DX<�=�<\7�3�µ�9 W .1=X3%7C[�3)îµ ] .¾7C3�_1<>p � 04.Y= ] 3�.Y7�D�<^3B0©=X<;7 ] <>=�7:9\.Y=.1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>=�9 E < U 7oD�< ]BU W 3B=�7y9 ]6] 36020 � s 9 E _13�Ë � z _1.1087C0º7C[X3/9}c\36549\p>3 ��W .Y=X. W U W�� 9\=�D W 9µ ½. W U W 5C9;74.1<>0�<\a¹l U 3654.Y360k9\=�D{c^.Y3B��36D"DX< ]6U W 36=�740�f¸3B5/Dg9 F>� 9\=�D{7C[X3Z9�c\365C9;p>3Zf¸3B5 ] 36=�7:9\p\360<\aecV.Y3B��36D"DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0K7C[g9�7�9\523¶5C9;=X´\3BD"9\0�an52< W ® 7C< ¥�Ô 043B3 s 9 E _13 ��� Æ .1=�+�fXfi36=�DX.¾µ �an<>5 W <\543�DX3B7C9\.1_Y0 Õ � M =³7C[X3)9}c\36549\p>3 � an<>5�3�9 ] [�l U 365 F ] < W©W 9\=XD � 7C[�3 U 02365«cV.13��t3BD z � |DX< ]6U W 36=�740 �4� Î � ̦q'�X|>Å � Î#q 9\=XD | �^� Ì#q <;ab74[X3/DX< ]6U W 3B=�740o7C[X3 U 0436520ocV.13B��36D%��36523q549\=X´;36D.1=@7C[�3q74<>f z}Å^� 74[X3k7C<>f Ç>Å�� 9\=XD�7C[X3k7C<>f Î\Å�� 543B04fi3 ] 7C.Yc\36_ F � M =X_ F�Å � Ʀq <\aADX< ]6U W 36=�740�7C[�3U 0236540ycV.13��t3BD���36543q5C9;=X´\3BD�[X.Yp>[X3B5o7C[g9\= Ä\Å>Å �T .Y= ] 3'��3@DX<»=X<\7�[g9�c\3�0 F 027C3 W W 3�9\0 U 543 W 3B=�740�<\ay7C[X3 syH�M d�+ T 0 F 02743 W�� ��3@360274. W 9;7C37C[�3�fi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3�<\a�74[X3%7C<\7C9\_m0 F 02743 W fX52< ] 360402.1=Xp 7C. W 3 U 0236D³an<>5�3�9 ] [³7 F fi3�<\a JLu ] < W ½W 9\=XDX0 E�FE U .Y_1DX.Y=Xp"9"7436087«Dg9�7:9 E 9;043 U 04.Y=Xp 74[X3 r <>=Xp>5236040 u 3 ] <\54DÙan<\5 z�Å>Ç 54D r <>=Xp\5436020Ô Ä;Ç�Î d � �`Ä � |\|�Ä DX< ]6U W 3B=�740 Õ � �y[X. ] [).10/9©fg9\527�<\aA7C[�3 syu à r Ë ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=ÎL Ç>| N®9\=XD»<>=�3<\aA74[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0 syH�M d�+ T .10 U 04.Y=Xp � � 3�549\=)74[X3�74<>f z}Å>Å\Å U =X.Yl U 3�l U 3652.13B0/.1020 U 3BD»<>=� U _ F)z Ë �Öz}|>|\Ì 9\p�9\.Y=X027�7C[X.Y0t7C3B027yDg9�7:9 E 9;043 � s [�3k9}c\36549\p>3/7C3B5 W 0ofi365ol U 3B5 F an<>5�7C[X3B043 z}Å>Å\ÅU =X.Yl U 3©l U 3B54.Y360��t9\0 z � | � � 3«9\020 U W 3�3�9 ] [�0 U W�W 9;5 F ] < W©W 9\=XD 543�7 U 52=X0k7C[X3©0 U W�W 9;5 F.1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>=)an<>5 z}Å DX< ]6U W 36=�740 � 9;=XD ] 9\_ ]BU _h9�7C3�7C[�3«9�c>3B5C9\p\3«= U W�E 365k<\at0 U W�W 9;5 F ] < W ½W 9\=XD E 9\043BD�<>="7C[X3©DX< ]6U W 36=�7q5C9\=�´V0q7C[X3 U 0236540qcV.13B��36D�.1= s 9 E _13�Ë � z � w <>5k3�9 ] [�l U 365 F

Ç>Æ

Page 53: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

] < W©W 9\=XD � 7C[X3 U 043B5K.Y040 U 36D z � Î 0 U W�W 9\5 F ] < W�W 9\=XDX0 � � [X36=@��3�< E 7:9;.1=X3BD'7C[X3/74. W 360�an<\5fX52< ] 360402.1=Xp©3�9 ] [�7 F f¸3q<\a ] < W�W 9\=�DX0 � ��3�023B7K7C[X3q5C9�7C.1<�<\ab7C[�3q74[X543B3 E 9;04. ] JLu ] < W©W 9\=XDX0Ô l U 3B5 Fi� 0 U W�W 9;5 Fi� D�< ]BU W 3B=�7 Õ 7C< E 3 z>�¾z � Î^� ÄV� 9\=XD ] [X.Y_1_13BD)7C[�3Z0 F 02743 W E�F 523�9\D�.1=Xp@9'_19\54p>3jg_Y3 E 3�an<>543�fX52< ] 360204.1=�p�369 ] [ JLu ] < W©W 9\=XD � s [�3�5C9;74.1<Z<\aS7C. W 3 U 043BD�an<>5tfX54< ] 3B0404.Y=Xp�l U 365 F] < W©W 9\=XD � 0 U W�W 9;5 F ] < W©W 9\=XD � 9\=XD�DX< ]6U W 36=�7 ] < W�W 9\=XDX0m.Y0 z\�Yz � Ä^� Å � Å � � �y[X. ] [ W 3�9\=�07C[�3/l U 365 F fX54< ] 3B0402.1=Xp�9 ]B] < U =�7436D%an<>5oË\Ë q <\aS7C<\7C9\_¸f�54< ] 360204.Y=XpZ7C. W 3 � < E 7C9\.1=�.1=Xp�0 U W�W 9;5 F.1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>='9 ]6] < U =�7C36D�an<>5 Î\Ǧq'� 9\=�D�DX< ]6U W 3B=�7y523B7454.13�c;9\_`9 ]B] < U =�7436D�an<\5 Ǧq �M U 5e9;=g9\_ F 02.10®0 U p>p>3B02740e7C[g9;7®< U 5¢fg9\5274.h9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�543BfX_1. ] 9�02[X< U _YD E 3 E 3B=X3Bj ] .h9;_Van<>5¢04fi363BD ½.1=�p U f E <\7C[�l U 3B5 F fX54< ] 3B0404.Y=Xp"9\=XD�DX< ]BU W 36=�7�9 ]B] 36020 Ô 0 U W©W 9\5 F 9\=�D�DX< ]6U W 36=�7 ] < W ½W 9\=XDX0 Õ � 02.1= ] 3�369 ] [�<\a�7C[X3 W 9 ]6] < U =�7C0«9\_ W <>087�9 [g9;_Ya/<;a�7C[�3�74<\7:9\_m0 F 027C3 W f�54< ] 360204.Y=Xp7C. W 3 �

�Sÿ¦þ�ÿT� [ %bà�ý h·ç*d i Þ� ò ü h� 3¶3�µ�9 W .1=�3�7C[�3¶l U 365 F _Y< ] 9\_1.¾7 F .1=�7C[X3 syH/M d�+ T 9\=XD)74[X3Zîµ ] .Y743¶_Y<>p>0 ��T .Y= ] 3q7C[X3�_1<>p>0DX<»=X<;7 ] <\=�7C9\.1=�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7Z.1DX3B=�7C.YjX36540¶543B7 U 54=�36D�an54< W 369 ] [l U 365 F 3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>= � ��3 E U .1_Y77C3B027ZDX9;7:9 E 9\043B0 � w <>5¶l U 3B54.13B0�an54< W 74[X3 syH/M d�+ T _1<>p � �t3'5236549\=9\_1_¹l U 3652.13B0�9\p�9\.Y=X027¶97C3B027@Dg9�7:9 E 9;043)74[g9;7 U 02360'74[X3 r <>=Xp\5436020 u 3 ] <>52D�an<>5 z}Å\Ç 54D r <\=Xp>543B040 Ô Ä;Ç�Î d � �oÄ � |>|>ÄDX< ]6U W 36=�740 Õ � w <>5«l U 3B54.13B0'an54< W 7C[�3"Ãeµ ] .Y7C3»_Y<>p � ��3»5436549\=�9\_Y_�l U 3652.13B0@9\p�9\.Y=X027'9�7C36087Dg9;7C9 E 9\023 U 02.1=Xp�DX<}�y=X_1<>9\DX0�<\a/7C[�3���3 E 02.Y74360'<>fi36549;7C3BD E�F 7C36=Ù+ U 087C549\_1.19\= R =X.Yc\365204.Y74.13B0Ô � Ä>Î d � ��Ì^z}Ç>Ç ËkDX< ]6U W 36=�740 Õ � �y[X. ] [©.10�9qfX9\527�<\aI74[X3 syu à r Æ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= Ô 043B3�+�f�f¸3B=XDX.¾µ+ Õ � � 3 U 043�74[X3�7436027tDg9;7C9 E 9\02360t74<�9 U 74< W 9;7C. ] 9\_Y_ F ] _ U 087C3B5tl U 3652.13B0 � � 3�p>52< U f«74[X3�l U 3B54.13B0�y[X<>023«7C<\f Ä\Å D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0 ] < W fX_13�7C36_ F <}c>3652_h9\f�9\0¶9�7C<>fX. ] � . � 3 � � ��3«cV.13B�Ó74[X36023'DX.Y027C.Y= ] 7l U 3652.13B0�9;0y74[X3k0C9 W 3 �s 9 E _13qË � Ä 02[X<}�y0�7C[�3�087:9;74.10274. ] 0�<>=�l U 365 F _Y< ] 9\_1.¾7 F an52< W 7C[X3 syH/M d�+ T 9\=XD)îµ ] .Y743¶_1<\p>0 �� 3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7Z74[X3�9}c\36549\p>3�= U W�E 3B5©<;a/l U 3652.13B0 � U =�.1l U 3�l U 3654.Y360 � 7C<>f�. ] 0 � 74<>fX. ] 0�< ]B]6U 5254.1=�p<>= ] 3 � 7C<>f�. ] 0¹< ]6]6U 5454.Y=Xp W <>523K74[g9\=©<>= ] 3 � 9;=XD©74<>fX. ] 0¹74[g9;7 ] <>=�7C9\.1= W <\543m7C[g9;=«<>=X3 U =X.Yl U 3l U 365 F � � 3�9\_Y04<'f�54360236=�7k7C[X3Zfi365 ] 3B=�7C9\p>3Z<\a¹l U 3B54.13B0/7C[g9�7 ] <>52543B04fi<>=XD»7C<'74[X3�7C<>f{74<>fX. ] 0 �

Ç �

Page 54: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

~ ^ < h ?�;�40Y�/37~ ^ < h ^ b Y ]�^ 1 ;�/�/ ^ 252YMb0N <a;�21F6>�($b <a;�251F6> (�bL;�b01]�^ 1�2YM1�7 ]�^ 1�2YM1�7 65;$65(�K ;�b /�1 ;�b /31 ^ b Y ]�^ 1 ]�^ 1�2�y0g�l�t ' |�| m t * l�y | x ' l�x�w�g * l m x�i j y�y�y ' | g�} * g�gPy0g '�j i�} * l�g j4�1�25/313b�65(�N�1�7W;�8 ]�^ 1�2YM1�7 6>�(f6B6;�4�6;�4 YM/�7B(�/3/3; ^ b�6,8:;�2g m�m j$m�m w m�m g m�m�m j$m�m�mj g�h j } j y0h | } l g�h w�} w$l hMg�} | t h m }')(�*�� ^ 1325�eKp;�/3(�KpYp6!��YMb�6>01@?BADCFEHGJILKM;�N h~ ^ < h ?�;�40Y�/37~ ^ < h ^ b Y ]�^ 1 ;�/�/ ^ 252YMb0N <a;�21F6>�($b <a;�251F6> (�bL;�b01]�^ 1�2YM1�7 ]�^ 1�2YM1�7 65;$65(�K ;�b /�1 ;�b /31 ^ b Y ]�^ 1 ]�^ 1�2�l�i�i�y�t�x ' l�l�l�y�i�i * t�x�w j | x ' t j�m i�y | * j l�i$l m w g�i�x�x | j�' | i�} * w j | t�t '�j gf} * t j | w m4�1�25/313b�65(�N�1�7W;�8 ]�^ 1�2YM1�7 6>�(f6B6;�4�6;�4 YM/�7B(�/3/3; ^ b�6,8:;�2w m�m g m�m�m w m�m�m g m�m�m�m j$m�m�m�mg j h t�} g�x0h m } j | h i�} t�l h l�} l j h m }')U�*�� ^ 1�2��KM;�/3(�KpYp6!��YMb�65>01@+V-0/�Yp61�KM;�N hí Þ��F nà �SÿT�Iÿ Á U 365 F _1< ] 9\_Y.Y7 F .1=%74[X3k_1<>p>0 �

s 9 E _13�Ë � Ä Ô 9 Õ 02[X<}�y0K74[X3k9�c>36549\p>3k= U W�E 36520K.Y=%7C[X3 syH�M d�+ T _Y<>p>0o<}c\365m7C[X3�Ë Å DX9 F 0m�y.Y74[a U _Y_tDg9 F _Y<>p>0 Ô 02363 s 9 E _13 ��� z 9\=XD s 9 E _Y3 ��� Ä .Y=³+�fXfi36=XDX. µ � an<>5 W <>543%D�3B7:9;.1_10 Õ � s [X3= U W�E 36520�.Y=�74[X3"fg9\5236=�7C[X3B043B0).1= ] <>_ U W =X0 z 9\=XD Ä 9\543»7C[�3 = U W¶E 3B540@<\a�l U 3B54.Y360%7C[g9�79 ] 7 U 9\_Y_ F an< U =XD W 9�7 ] [X.Y=Xp{DX< ]6U W 36=�740¶an54< W < U 5¶7C3B027ZDg9�7:9 E 9;043 � T < W 3«l U 3654.Y360�D�.1D�=X<;7jg=XD)9\= F�W 9;7 ] [X.1=�p�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7 � D U 3k7C< W .10204fi36_Y_1.1=�p � <>5y02. W fX_ F«E 3 ] 9 U 023¶7C[�3�l U 3B5 F 7C3B5 W 0DX.YD·=X<\7©3�µ^.Y027©.1=Ù74[X3�7436087'Dg9;7C9 E 9\023 � s [X3�027:9�7C.1087C. ] 0�04[X<}� 7C[X9;7«<\=Ù7C[�3{9�c>3B5C9\p>3 � � ztq<\ay7C<\fX. ] 0�< ]B]6U 5¶<>= ] 3 � 9\=XD�7C[�3%543 W 9\.Y=X.1=Xp Ä\|¦q <\ay7C<\fX. ] 0Z9 ]6] < U =�7Zan<>5 Æ>Ǧq <\aKl U 3654.Y360 �+ W <>=Xp"7C[�3�74<>fX. ] 0�74[g9;7©< ]B]6U 5 W <>543%7C[X9\=·<>= ] 3 �oÇ�Î#q Ô Ë zÂÄ Õ ] <>=�7C9\.1=X0 W <>543%7C[X9\=·<>=�3U =X.Yl U 3'l U 365 F>� �y[X. ] [ W 369\=X0�l U 3B5 F fX9;74743654= W 9;7 ] [��t< U _1D�=X<;7¶jg=XD�74[X.10�<}c>3652_h9\f � s [X37C<\f Ä � Î#q <\a¢74<>fX. ] 0 Ô 74<>f z}Å>Å 7C<\fX. ] 0 Õ 9 ]6] < U =�7yan<>5 Ä^z � Ä#q <\a®l U 3B54.Y360 � 9\=�D�74[X3�7C<>f zÂÄ#q <\a7C<\fX. ] 0 Ô 7C[�3k74<>f Î\Å>Å 7C<>f�. ] 0 Õ 9 ]6] < U =�7yan<>5mË z � Î#q �s 9 E _13AË � Ä Ô E Õ 02[X<}�y0b74[X3A= U W�E 36540S.Y=/7C[X3ºÃ®µ ] .¾7C3º_1<>pt<>= T 36f�743 W�E 365 z}Æ^��z}|>| �^� s [X3º= U W�E 36520.1=k7C[�3�fg9;5436=�74[X3602360A9\523¹74[X3¹= U W�E 3B540b<\agl U 3B54.13B0b74[g9;7®9 ] 7 U 9\_Y_ F an< U =XD W 9;7 ] [X.1=XpyDX< ]6U W 3B=�740an54< W < U 5k7C36087¶DX9;7:9 E 9\043 � s [X3«087:9;74.10274. ] 0�02[X<}�Ó7C[g9;7q7C[�3«Ã®µ ] .¾7C3«l U 3B54.Y360�9\_102<�[g9�c\3'[X.1p\[

Ç>Ì

Page 55: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

l U 365 F _1< ] 9\_Y.Y7 Fi� � |¦q <;at7C<\fX. ] 0q< ]6]BU 5q<>= ] 3 � 9\=�D 74[X3©523 W 9\.1=�.1=Xp Ä^ztq <\at74<>fX. ] 0q9 ]6] < U =�7an<>5 Æ^ztq <;a�l U 3B54.Y360Q{t+ W <>=Xp{7C[�3'7C<>fX. ] 0¶74[g9;7Z< ]6]BU 545236D W <>543«74[g9\=<>= ] 3 �¹Æ�Ä#q Ô Ç>Ä � Î\Å Õ] <\=�7C9\.1= W <>523�7C[g9;=�<\=X3 U =X.Yl U 3�l U 365 F � s [X3�7C<>f Ä#q <\aS7C<>f�. ] 0 Ô 7C<>f Î\Å>Å 74<>fX. ] 0 Õ 9 ]6] < U =�7an<>5 zÂÄ � Ǧq <\ayl U 3B54.13B0 � 9;=XD�7C[�3©7C<\f z}Ŧq <\at7C<>fX. ] 0 Ô 7C[�3©7C<\f Ä\Å>Å\Å>Å 74<>fX. ] 0 Õ 9 ]6] < U =�7¶an<\5Ë Ä � Ŧq �s [X3B043�027C9;7C.Y027C. ] 0�0 U p>p>3B027�7C[X9;7�.Y7/.10/fi<>0402. E _Y3¶an<>5 U 0/7C<@543BfX_1. ] 9;743�9%0 W 9\_1_bfi<>5274.1<>={<;a ] <>_ ½_13 ] 74.1<>={74[g9;7 ] <>=�7:9\.Y=X0�DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0�an<>5�7C[X3�74<>f"l U 3654.Y360 � J =�9;DXDX.Y74.1<>= � 04.Y= ] 3�9%02.1p>=X.¾j ] 9;=�79 W < U =�7�<\a�74<>fX. ] 0 ] <>=�7:9;.1=X0 W <\543%7C[g9;=·<>=X3 U =X.Yl U 3�l U 3B5 F\� ] 9 ] [X.Y=Xp�l U 3B54.Y360 W 9 FW .1040W 9\= F <}c>3652_h9\f�0 E 3B7É��363B={l U 3652.13B0K�y.¾7C[�DX.Yظ365236=�7y7C365 W 0m74[g9;7K.1=%a¦9 ] 7�523B7 U 54=@7C[X3k049 W 3�74<>fDX< ]6U W 36=�740 � J =X087C3�9;D � ��3 W 9\´;3�< U 5t543BfX_1. ] 9\0�04369\5 ] [g9 E _13�74<�. W fX52<Âc\3 E <\7C[«l U 365 F fX52< ] 36040 ½.1=�p©9;=XD@DX< ]BU W 36=�7�9 ]6] 36040 �

�Sÿ¦þ�ÿT� å ï àVýl nÞXû d c\[ %bà�ý ò à�g å ï à�ý í ò f�àJ ='7C[�.10t023 ] 7C.1<\= � ��3/3�µ�9 W .1=X3�[X<}� W 9\= F l U 3654.Y360o<\=@9¶p>.Yc\36=%Dg9 F©W 9�7 ] [@9�74<>fX. ] an54< W 7C[�3fX523BcV.1< U 0®Dg9 F 0®.Y=�7C[�3 syH/M d�+ T _1<\p>0 � � 3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7S7C[X3�f¸3B5 ] 36=�7:9\p\360e<\aXl U 3654.Y360b7C[g9;7®9\fXfi3�9;5.1=@7C[�3�fX523BcV.1< U 0�DX9 F\� 9;=XD�.Y=�74[X3qfX543�c^.Y< U 0K043�c>36=»DX9 F 0 � � 3�9\_102< ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7m7C[X3qf¸3B5 ] 36=�7:9\p\360<\aAl U 3B54.Y360y7C[g9;7�9\fXfi3�9;5�<>=)9©fg9;527C. ]6U _19\5mDg9 F <>5�9©fg9\587C. ]6U _19\5o�t3B36´ � .Y=)<>52DX365y7C<�3�µ�9 W .1=�3l U 365 F <}c>3B54_h9;f <}c\365�7C. W 3 � s 9 E _Y3ZË � Ç 0 U W�W 9;54. ¿ 360�74[X3Z027C9;7C.Y0274. ] 0 Ô 043B3 s 9 E _13 ��� Ç ½É��� Î an<\5W <>543�DX3�7:9\.Y_10 Õ �s 9 E _13ZË � Ç Ô 9 Õ 02[X<}�y0q74[X3�9�c>36549\p>3�f¸3B5 ] 36=�7:9\p\360k<\a�l U 3654.Y360k<>= 9%p>.Yc\36="Dg9 F 0 UX] [�74[g9;7�7C[�37C<\fX. ] 0t<\a`74[X36023�l U 3654.Y360 W 9;7 ] [%9¶7C<>f�. ] � <>5�<>=X3/<\a`74[X3�74<>f z}Å>Å\Å 7C<\fX. ] 0�an54< W 74[X3�fX523BcV.1< U 0Dg9 F <\5�7C[X3¶fX543�c^.Y< U 0/��363B´ � 523604fi3 ] 7C.¾c>36_ F � � 3 ] 9\_ ]6U _19;7C3q7C[X3Z= U W�E 36520�.1=)74[X3�7:9 E _13qan54< WÄ\Ì Dg9 F 0�<;ao< U 5�_Y<>p>0 � � 3�3�µ ] _ U DX3Z7C[�3�jg52027 � Dg9 F 0¶9\=�D�.Y= ] _ U DX3�7C[�3©023 ] <\=XD�Dg9 F <;at7C[�3543 W 9;.1=X.Y=Xp«fg9;.1540�<;a�DX9 F 0��y[X. ] [ [X9}c\3Za U _1_¢_1<>p>0�an<>5 E <;7C[»Dg9 F 0 � � 3Z3�µ ] _ U DX3�74[X3�Dg9 F 0k.Y=7C[�3�jg52027/��363B´�7C<©36=g9 E _13 ] < W fg9\52.104<\=X0 E 3B7É��363B="74[X3¶= U W¶E 3B540�an<>5y7C[�3�fX543�cV.1< U 0�Dg9 F 9;=XD7C[�3qf�543BcV.Y< U 0m�t3B36´ �

Ç>|

Page 56: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

CJc�1325KM(�4�qBYp6>6> 1�4021�c�Yp; ^ 7,`0(�� 6> 1�4021�c�Yp; ^ 7Wq 1�13r(�c�1 h <aYMb h <a($- (�c�1 h <aYpb h <e(f-($KMK l�t hpgf} t0g�h j } y g�hMg�} w | h y�} l�i0hMg�} y j h x�}6;�4 g m�m�m t j h l�} j g�h t�} | y0hMg�} t$l h x�} j x0h j } |�| h y�}')(�*W;fc�1325KM(�4�qBYp6>�6>01�4 21�c�YM; ^ 7B`0(���')7�* hCJc�1325KM(�4�qBYp6>|�� g3l � i�y 65>01�q 1�13r�;�b |�� g�l$s |�� j�m � i�y`0(f651 ($KMK 65;�4 w m�m 6;�4 g m�m�m ($KMK 6;�4 w m�m 65;�4 g m�m�m|�� gPw l�t h t�} j l�h y�} t m hMg�} b � ( b � ( b � (|�� g�x l j h x�} j l�h m } j i0h j } b � ( b � ( b � (|�� g | l j h m } j t h w�} j y0h | } b � ( b � ( b � (|�� j g l g�h x�} j t h x�} j y0hkw�} x m h j } j i0h m } t�x h m }|�� j�j l j h w�} j l�h m } j y0h y�} x m h | } j i0h y�} t�x h y�}|�� j t l g�h l�} j t h l�} j y0h | } x0g�h m } j i0h j } t�x h y�}|�� t0g t�y h w�} j g�h i�} j x0h l�} w$i0hMg�} j | h t�} t$l�h j }y � g3l t�y hpgf} j g�h t�} j x0h m } wfl h x�} j x0h y�} t j h t�}y � j y t$l�h t�} g�y h t�} j t0h l�} wfl h m } j t0hkw�} t m h | }i � g�g l�l�h m } y0h | } j�j h j } y j h | } w$l hkw�} x$l�h w�}')U�*,;fc�1325KM(�4�qBYZ65>�(a4 ($26Y�/ ^ K�($2B`0(���;�2,q 1�13r h

í Þ��! nà �SÿT�`ÿ Á U 3B5 F <}c\3654_19\f�<Âc\365m7C. W 3�.Y='7C[X3 syH/M d�+ T _Y<>p �

� [X3B=< U 5'543BfX_1. ] 9 ] <>=�7:9\.Y=X0'7C[�3{7C<>f�DX< ]6U W 3B=�740'an<>5%9\_Y_K74[X3{7C<\fX. ] 0'< ]B]6U 5254.Y=Xp�<>=�7C[�3fX523BcV.1< U 0%Dg9 F>� Ë Ç � ztq <\aql U 3654.Y360 W 9;7 ] [�9 7C<>fX. ] .1=Ù7C[X3»5236fX_Y. ] 9 <>=�7C[�3"9}c\36549\p>3 � �y.Y74[7C[�3 W .1=X. W U W <\a Ç�z � Ä#q 9\=XD)74[X3 W 9�µ^. W U W <\a Ì�z � ztq � � [X36=»< U 5�5236fX_Y. ] 9�¼ U 087 ] <\=�7C9\.1=�0DX< ]6U W 36=�740�an<>5k7C[X3�7C<>f z}Å>Å>Å 7C<>f�. ] 0q< ]6]6U 5454.Y=Xp)<\=�7C[�3«fX523BcV.1< U 0¶Dg9 F>�eÇ�Ä � Ë q <\aml U 3B54.13B0W 9;7 ] [³9»7C<>fX. ] .1=�7C[�3�5236fX_Y. ] 9{<>=�7C[X3�9�c>36549\p>3 � �y.Y74[�7C[X3 W .1=X. W U W <\a ÄVz � Ç#q 9\=XD7C[�3W 9�µ^. W U W <;a � Ì � ztq � � [X3B=�< U 5¶5236fX_Y. ] 9 ] <\=�7C9\.1=�0�DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0�an<>5¶9;_1_º7C<>fX. ] 0�< ]B]6U 5254.1=�p<>="7C[X3�fX523BcV.1< U 0q023Bc\36=�Dg9 F 0 �eÎ �^� ̦q <\a�l U 3652.1360 W 9;7 ] [X3BD�9%7C<>f�. ] .1="7C[�3�5236fX_Y. ] 9@<\=�7C[�39�c>3B5C9\p>3 � �y.Y7C[@7C[�3 W .1=X. W U W <\aeË �^� Å#q 9\=XD�7C[X3 W 9�µ^. W U W <\a Ì�Ä � Ʀq � � [X3B=)< U 5K5236fX_Y. ] 9] <\=�7C9\.1=�0�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0�an<>5Z7C[X3@7C<>f z}Å>Å\Å 74<>fX. ] 0�< ]B]6U 5254.Y=Xp�<\=³74[X3�f�543BcV.Y< U 0�043�c>36=�DX9 F 0 �7C[�3 Ç Ë � Ʀq <;aAl U 3652.1360 W 9�7 ] [{9Z7C<\fX. ] <>=�74[X3�9}c\36549\p>3 � �y.Y74[�74[X3 W .1=X. W U W <\a Ä\Æ � Ä#q 9;=XD7C[�3 W 9�µ^. W U W <\a �#�^� ̦q � +�0 ] < W fX9\543BD'�y.Y7C['74[X3�<}c>3B54_h9;f@�y.¾7C['74[X3�fX543�cV.1< U 0mDX9 F\�gÇ Ë � ztq

Ë Å

Page 57: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

9\=XD Æ ��� qèW <>543�l U 3B54.13B0 W 9;7 ] [�9%7C<\fX. ] .1=»74[X3©5236fX_Y. ] 9'<\at74[X3©f�543BcV.Y< U 0��t3B36´ � �y[X3B=���3543BfX_1. ] 9;743k9\_1_i7C<>f�. ] 0y9;=XD�74<>f z}Å>Å>Å 74<>fX. ] 0 � 523604fi3 ] 7C.¾c>36_ F �s 9 E _13�Ë � Ç Ô E Õ 04[X<}�y0m7C[X3/9}c\36549\p>3�fi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>360m<\abl U 3B54.13B0m<>=%9�p>.¾c>3B=%Dg9 F 0 U�] [@74[g9;7o74[X36023l U 3652.13B0 W 9;7 ] [X3BD�9 74<>fX. ] � <>5�<>=X3�<\a/74[X3�74<>f Î;Å>Å�� <>5�<>=X3�<\a�74[X3�74<>f z�Å>Å>Å 74<>fX. ] 0�<>=� U _ F!z Ë �qz�|>|>Ì 9\=�D�.1=·74[X3{�t3B36´³an54< W � U _ F�z Ë�74< � U _ F�Ä\Å��kz}|\|>Ì�� 543B04fi3 ] 7C.Yc\36_ F � s [X3027C9;7C.Y0274. ] 0Z02[X<}� 7C[X9;7�7 F f�. ] 9;_1_ F l U 365 F <}c>3652_h9\f7C3B=XDX0�7C<"DX3 ] 54369\043�9\0Z7C. W 3%3B_h9\f�04360 �tE U 7< ]6] 9;04.1<\=g9\_1_ F l U 3B5 F <}c>3B54_19\f ] < U _YD©.Y= ] 523�9\023K02.1p>=�.Yj ] 9\=�7C_ F\� 3 � p � <>= |�È^z>zÂÈ;|>Ì � J =�74[X3K7 F fX. ] 9\_Dg9 F 0��y[X3B={7C[X3ql U 365 F <}c\3654_19\f)D�3 ] 523�9\023 � 7C[X3�DX3 ] 543�9;043¶.Y0Kc\365 F p>549\D U 9;_ � an<>5K3�µ�9 W fX_13 � _13B7Ô W�� = Õ 5236fX52360236=�7C0Z7C[�3«l U 365 F <}c>3B54_19\f E 3B7É��3636=�74[X3'Dg9 F Ô 0 Õ <\a ® 9\=�D�7C[X3©Dg9 F <\a ¥ � 7C[�3DX.¾ØÖ3B5436= ] 3 E 3B7É��3636= Ô � ÈVz Ë � � ÈVzÂÎ Õ 9\=�D Ô � È^z Ë � � È^z � Õ .10 z � Ç#q%�Az � Ǧq'� 9\=�D z � Ë q �y[X3B= ��3543BfX_1. ] 9;743@9\_1_o74<>fX. ] 0 � 7C[X3%74<>f Î\Å\Å 74<>fX. ] 0 � 9\=XD³7C<>f z}Å>Å>Å 74<>fX. ] 0�<>= � ÈVz Ë � 543602f¸3 ] 74.Yc>3B_ F �s [X3ZDX.¾ØÖ3B543B= ] 3 E 3B7É��363B= Ô � È^z Ë ½G� È>Ä;Å�� � È>Ä^z Õ 9\=XD Ô � È^z Ë ½7� È>Ä\Å^� � È\Ä\Ç Õ .10 Å � ̦q'�IÅ � Ä#q'� 9;=XDÅ � ̦q �y[X36=���3%543BfX_1. ] 9;743'9\_Y_º74<>fX. ] 0 � 74[X3«74<>f Î\Å>Å^� 9\=XD�74<>f z}Å>Å>Å 7C<>f�. ] 0¶<>= � È^z Ë ½G� È\Ä\Å��543B04fi3 ] 7C.Yc\36_ F �s [X3@027C9;7C.Y0274. ] 0¶<>=l U 365 F <Âc\3652_h9\f0 U p>p>36087C0�7C[g9�7Z.Yay��3�5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3«74[X3'7C<\f74<>fX. ] 0Z<>=�7C[�3fX523BcV.1< U 0®Dg9 F 0 � 02.1p>=X.¾j ] 9;=�7®9 W < U =�7e<;agl U 3652.1360 ] 9\= W 9;7 ] [Z9K74<>fX. ] .1=q7C[X3�5436f�_1. ] 9 � + ] 7 U 9\_Y_ F7C[�3)543BfX_1. ] 9 ] 9\=·0C9;74.102a FW <>523�l U 3B54.13B0«7C[X9\=Ù74[X3)= U W�E 36520©��3{543Bf¸<\527©.1=Ù74[X3�7C9 E _Y360�<>=l U 365 F <Âc\3652_h9\f �bE 3 ] 9 U 043��t3�DX<�=X<\7 ] < U =�7q7C[�3�l U 3B54.Y360k�y[X<>043�7C<>f�. ] 0kDX<�=X<\7�9\f�f¸369\5k<>=7C[�3�fX523BcV.1< U 0�DX9 F 0 �^E U 7�74[X36.Y5º74<>f�DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0¹543�7 U 52=X36D«an52< W l U 3B5 F 3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>=�9\fXfi3�9;5�.Y=7C[�3o543BfX_1. ] 9 � . � 3 � 7C[X3o023B7A<;ag7C<>f�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0e<\ai9�l U 365 F .10®9 ] < W¶E .1=g9�7C.1<\=�<\ag74<>f�DX< ]6U W 3B=�740<\aÖ9\=X<\74[X365A7É��<¶<>5 W <>543o74<>fX. ] 0 �eT .1= ] 3m7C[X3K_1<\p>0ADX<q=X<\7 ] <\=�7C9\.1=�DX< ]6U W 36=�7¹.1D�36=�7C.¾jg36520�9;=XD< U 5o7436087�Dg9�7:9 E 9;043k.10mfX523B727 F 0 W 9\_1_ � ��3 ] 9\=�=X<\7K< E 7C9\.1='74[X3�jgp U 52360�9 E < U 7m7C[�.10m04.¾7 U 9�7C.1<\= �

î %!f-f�ÞXý h� <\74[)7C[�3 syH/M d�+ T _1<>p>0�9\=XD�7C[X3¶Ãeµ ] .Y7C3¶_1<>p©04[X<}�v7C[X3B543�3Úµ^.102740�[X.Yp>[{l U 3B5 F _1< ] 9\_Y.Y7 F .Y=7C[�3¶54369\_ JLu 0 F 027C3 W 0 � r 9 ] [X.1=Xp«l U 3654.Y360�9\=XD{l U 3B5 F 3�µ�9 ] 7 W 9�7 ] [X.Y=Xp W .1020 W 9\= F <}c>3B54_h9;fX0E 3B7É��3636=»l U 3B54.Y360��y.¾7C[�DX.Yظ365236=�7�74365 W 0y7C[g9�7�.Y=�a¦9 ] 7�523B7 U 54=�74[X3¶049 W 3q74<>f)DX< ]6U W 3B=�740 � J a

Ë z

Page 58: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

��3©5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C3Z7C<>f�. ] 0q9\f�f¸369\543BD�<>="7C[X3�fX523BcV.1< U 0�Dg9 F Ô 0 Õ � 7C[X3�543BfX_1. ] 9 ] 9\=�0C9;74.108a F Ä\Ŧq 74<Ì>Ŧq <\a¹l U 3652.13B0 �¶T .1= ] 3�7C[X3 JLu 0 F 02743 W 0/7 F fX. ] 9\_1_ F fi3658an<>5 W 04.Yp>=X.¾j ] 9\=�7k9 W < U =�7/<\a¹l U 365 FfX52< ] 360402.1=Xp©9\=XD�DX< ]6U W 36=�7K9 ]B] 3B040 � < U 5mfX9\5274.h9\_I5236fX_Y. ] 9�04[X< U _1D@0 U f�f¸<>587 E <\74[�<\f¸3B5C9;74.1<>=X0 �

|[)VU �-,�./&Á<K0YE�?G<>5��H.�Õ65+?7:=<FE�?724A �Æ0�:�,6?VEY.X:�E�Z�0�.T .Y= ] 3k< U 5yp><>9\_I.10o74<©. W f�54<}c>3k0 F 087C3 W fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�an<>5 E <;7C[�l U 365 F f�54< ] 360204.Y=Xp«9;=XD�D�< ]Ú½U W 36=�7m9 ]6] 3B040 � 3�9 ] [«5436f�_1. ] 9�.Y0t9q043�9;5 ] [g9 E _13/fg9;527C.19\_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � . � 3 � � 3�9 ] [%5436f�_1. ] 9q.Y= ] _ U DX3B0543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D�DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0�9\=XD�7C[X3B.15 ] <>52543602f¸<\=XDX.1=�p«.1=�DX3�µ^360 � � 3qDX3B74365 W .Y=X3q�y[�. ] [)fi<>587C.1<\=<\atDX< ]BU W 36=�7C0k7C<�543BfX_1. ] 9;743�.Y= 74[X3�an<>_1_Y<Â�y.Y=Xp'�t9 Fi� an<>5q9�p>.¾c>3B=�l U 365 F>� �t3�7:9\p�9\_1_¢7C<>f ¥DX< ]6U W 36=�740©523B7 U 54=X3BD E�F l U 365 F fX54< ] 3B0404.Y=Xp�9\01R49 ]6] 36020436DYS�9\=XD ] < U =�7�74[X36.Y5©9 ]6] 3B040�an543 ½l U 36= ] .13B0 � 543Bp�9\54D�_136020Z<\aK�y[X3B74[X365Z7C[�3 U 043B5Z5436l U 3B02740�74[X3'a U _1_¹7C3Úµ^7�<;aK74[X36023@DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 �� 3©´;3636f�74[X3©9 ]6] 36040qan543Bl U 36= ] F <\at3�9 ] [�DX< ]BU W 36=�7��y.¾7C[X.Y=�[email protected]<^D <\a�7C. W 3 � 0 UX] [�9\0�9��3636´Z<\5A9 W <>=�74[ � 9\=XDZ7C[�36=�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3tDX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 E 9;0436D�<>=Z7C[�36.15º9 ]6] 3B040Aan543Bl U 36= ] .13B0 � 7C[�3W <>543/an5236l U 36=�74_ F R49 ]B] 3B04043BD�S©74[X3kDX< ]6U W 36=�7C0 � 7C[X3 W <>543/74. W 360o74[X3 F 9;543k543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D �� 3Z<>54p�9;=X. ¿ 3�543BfX_1. ] 9\0�9;0k9@[�.136549\5 ] [ F\� .Y_1_ U 02745C9;7436D{.Y= w .1p'Ë � Ä � s [X3Z7C<>f»=�<^DX3Z5236fX52360236=�7C09\= ���Ú¥¾§\¥��i�$¹�¾:�l¹Ç¹1�¿¾��ø¥ ��� 7C[g9�7 ] < U _YD E 3 �\���`¾��¦¡��$¹=¾:�l¹Ç¹1�¿¾��¦¥ ��� 543602.1DX.Y=Xpq<>=«9k=X3�7É�t<>52´�=X<^D�3K<\5�ÅÀ}¥��Ú�¦¡X�$¹4¾:�l¹Ç¹1�¿¾��¦¥ ��� ] <>=�04.1087C.Y=Xp%<\a¹043�c>36549\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0/D�.1027454. E U 7C3BD»<}c>365q9%=X3�7É�t<>52´ � s [X3E <\7474< W =X<VDX360�5236fX52360236=�7 U 043B540 � � 3 W 9 F DX.¾cV.1DX3 U 043B540�.Y=�7C<)D�.Yظ36543B=�7 ] _ U 027436520 � 3�9 ] [�<\a�y[X. ] [ ] <>54523604fi<>=XD�0�74< 9"p\54< U f<\a U 0236540�7C[X9;7�543B04.1D�3'�y.Y7C[�.1=�7C[X3%049 W 3%DX< W 9\.1= � �y[�. ] [] < U _1D E 3%9\=�.Y=X0274.Y7 U 7C.1<\= � 9\=�<\54p�9\=�. ¿ 9�7C.1<\= � <>5�9{p>36<>p\5C9\fX[�. ] 9;_t9\523�9{0 UX] [·9;0Z9{027C9;7C3'<\59 ] < U =�7C5 F � s [X3«.Y=X=X3B5�=X<VDX3B0¶543BfX543B043B=�7�fg9\5274.h9\_A5236fX_Y. ] 9\0 � s [X3©543BfX_1. ] [email protected]=�9�_1<}��365�_h9 F 3B5.10¶9�0 U E 043�7�<\ao74[X3'543BfX_1. ] 9\0q.1= U fXfi365�_19 F 36520 � an<>5q3�µ�9 W fX_Y3 � u 36fX_Y. ] 9 z ½ zS� u 36fX_Y. ] 9 z��M 54.Yp>.1=g9;_ r <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � s [X3�543BfX_1. ] 9'7C[g9�7�.Y0 ] _1<\0436087k7C<�9 U 02365 ] _ U 0274365 ] <>=�7:9;.1=X0�7C[�3©023B7q<\aDX< ]6U W 36=�740¶7C[g9�7�9\523 W <>027qan543Bl U 36=�7C_ F U 0436D E�F 7C[X3 ] _ U 0274365�<\a U 043B540 � s [X3'543BfX_1. ] 9 W 9 F] <\=�7C9\.1=»an5236l U 36=�74_ F U 0236D DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0kan<>5 W <>543�74[g9\="<>=X3 ] _ U 0274365k<\a U 043B540 � an<>5�3Úµ�9 W f�_13 �u 36fX_Y. ] 9 z ] <>=�7:9\.Y=X0o7C[�3/an5436l U 3B=�7C_ F U 043BD�DX< ]6U W 3B=�740man<>5 ¥ U 043B5 ] _ U 027436540 � s [X3k04<>_Y.1D%_1.Y=X360.1_Y_ U 087C549;7C3kDg9;7C9�Ïg<}�y0/D�.104023 W .1=g9�7C36D�an54< W 74[X3¶<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�74<«543BfX_1. ] 9\0 � +�_1<>=�p©7C[�3

Ë Ä

Page 59: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

User Cluster n

Original Collection

Replica Selection

Database 1Replica Selection

Database 2

Replica Selection

Database n

Replica 1

Replica 1-1Replica 1-p

Replica 1-p-1 Replica 1-p-m

User Cluster 2User Cluster 1

õ ò ß�%Sý�à �Sÿ»�Iÿ s [X3k5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\='[X.13B5C9\5 ] [ F �

9\5 ] 0�an52< W 7C[X3�<>54.Yp>.1=g9;_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 7C[X3 W <\027�an5236l U 3B=�74_ F U 043BD"DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0�9;543¶5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3BDW 9\= F 74. W 360 � u 3Bl U 36087C0Aan54< W 7C[�3 U 043B540º.1=�9 ] _ U 087C365 W 9 F p></7C<k9\= F 5436f�_1. ] 9�<>5®74[X3m<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=Z9;_1<>=Xp/74[X3K9\5 ] 0ean54< W 7C[X3m74<>f�=X<^D�3mDX36fi36=XD�.1=Xpq<>=�543B_13Bc;9\= ] 3K9\=XD�<\74[X365 ] 54.Y743652.h9 �0 U�] [·9\0Z023658c>365�_1<>9\DX0 � � 3 E U .1_YD9{543BfX_1. ] 9{043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�Dg9;7C9 E 9\023'7C<"5C9;=X´�5236fX_Y. ] 9;0 E 9\0236D<>=Ù5436_Y3Bc;9\= ] 3 � �y[�. ] [·D�.1543 ] 740©l U 3B54.13B0©74<�9 5436_Y3Bc;9\=�7©fg9\5274.h9\_t5436f�_1. ] 9 � s [�3)DX<\727C3BD·_1.Y=X360.1_Y_ U 087C549;7C3�7C[�3¶.1=�74365C9 ] 7C.Y<>= E 3B7É��363B= U 043B540k9\=XD)Dg9;7:9 � J ae��3ZDX<'=X<;7�DX.¾cV.1DX3q7C[X3 U 043B540�.1=�74<DX.¾ØÖ3B5436=�7�p>54< U fX0 � 7C[X3�[X.Y365C9;5 ] [ F 04. W fX_Y.Yjg3B0/7C<{9@_1.Y=X3�9;5�[X.13B5C9\5 ] [ F � J =�7C[�.10q9\5 ] [�.Y7C3 ] 7 U 543 �543BfX_1. ] 9�0236_13 ] 74.1<>[email protected]�7É��< ½ 087C36f�fX54< ] 3B040 �

z � 549\=X´�.1=Xp�fg9;527C.19\_Ö5236fX_Y. ] 9\0y9\=XD@7C[X3k<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= E 9;0436D�<>=@543B_13Bc;9\= ] 3 �

Ä � 0236_13 ] 74.1=Xp{<\=X3'<\am74[X3 W <>027¶543B_13Bc;9\=�7Z5236fX_Y. ] 9\0�<\5�7C[�3'<>54.Yp>.1=X9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= E 9\043BD�<>=_Y<�9\DX0 �

H 3B543@�t3�p>.¾c>3�9\=Ù3Úµ�9 W f�_13%7C< 04[X<}� [�<Â� 7C[X.Y0©9;5 ] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 523���<>52´V0 � J = w .1p U 523%Ë � Ä^� ��3543BfX_1. ] 9;743�74[X3¶7C<\f{DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0�<;aA7C[X3 W <>087�an543Bl U 36=�7C_ F U 0236D"l U 3652.13B0/.1020 U 3BD E�F 7C[X3 U 0436520.1= U 043B5 ] _ U 027C3B5 z .1= E <\74[ u 3BfX_1. ] 9 z ½ z 9;=XD u 3BfX_1. ] 9 z � u 3BfX_1. ] 9 z 9;_104< ] <>=�7:9;.1=X0�<;7C[X3B5

Ë Ç

Page 60: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

_13B040oan5236l U 36=�74_ F U 0236D�DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0man<>5 U 043B5 ] _ U 087C3B5 z>� 9\=XD%an5236l U 36=�74_ F U 0236D�DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0oan<\5<\74[X365 U 043B5 ] _ U 087C36520 � � [X3B={9 U 04365�.1=@7C[X3 U 043B5 ] _ U 087C365 z .Y040 U 360�9�l U 3B5 F>� 7C[X3�l U 365 F p\<^3B07C<©543BfX_1. ] 9©0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�Dg9;7C9 E 9\023 z 74<«DX3�7C365 W .Y=X3¶5236_Y3Bc;9\= ] 3¶<\a u 36f�_1. ] 9 z ½ z;� u 36fX_Y. ] 9 z>� 9;=XD7C[�3�<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � J a/7C[X3�543BfX_1. ] 9»043B_13 ] 7C<\5©549\=X´�0 u 36fX_Y. ] 9 z ½ z 9\0�7C[X3@7C<>f³<>=X3 � .Y7W 9 F 043B=XD³74[X3@l U 365 F 7C< 9\= F <\a u 36fX_Y. ] 9 z ½ z;� u 36fX_Y. ] 9 z>� <>5�7C[X3@<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�an<\5fX52< ] 360402.1=Xp �iE 9\043BD)<>=�<\7C[�365 ] 54.¾7C3B54.h9 � 0 UX] [)9\0K043658c>3B5�_1<>9\D � =X3�7É�t<\54´%7C549;À ] � 9\=XD�=X3B7É��<>52´DX.Y027:9;= ] 3 � J ay74[X3%043B_13 ] 7C<>5¶5C9\=X´�0 u 36fX_Y. ] 9 z 9\0¶7C[�3'7C<>f�<>=�3 � .Y7 W 9 F 043B=XD�7C[X3%l U 3B5 F 74<36.¾7C[X3B5 u 36f�_1. ] 9 z <>5º7C[�3�<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � M 74[X3658�y.1043�.Y7�9\_¾�o9 F 0t0236=XDX0�7C[X3Kl U 365 F 74<�7C[�3<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �

|[)eu &Á<K0YE�?G<>5©�H.!Õ65G?7:=< �;.�57.X:�E�?72xA �Ó<KWY.X� 24A �H.�5G.=JK<>A�:=.s [X3Kjg54087o027436f'<;aI543BfX_1. ] 9k043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=«.Y0¹[�<Â��74<�jg=�D'9�fX9\5274.h9\_g5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C[X9;7 ] <>=�7:9;.1=X0�36=X< U p>[543B_13�c\9;=�7�DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0/an<\5/9«p>.¾c>3B={l U 365 F � J ={7C[X.Y0�023 ] 74.1<>= � �t3¶.1=�c>3B027C.Yp�9;743�[X<}�v7C<'DX<©7C[X.Y07:9;04´{�y.Y74[�.Y=�an365236= ] 3©=X3�7É�t<\54´�0 � 9\=�D�3�c\9;_ U 9;743�74[X3�3Bظ3 ] 74.Yc\36=X3B040�<\at< U 5q543BfX_1. ] 9%043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=9\fXf�54<�9 ] [ U 02.1=Xp/74[X3 J = Á U 3B5 F 523B7454.13�c;9\_�0 F 087C3 W L z ËON � 9\=XDZ7C[X3 Ä O � syu à r Ä#"�Ç ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=9\=XD"7C[�3 Ä\Å O � syu à r-Ñ�Pbr ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � � 3 U 043©l U 3652.1360qDX3�c>36_Y<>fi36D�an<\5 syu à r 7C<\fX. ] 0Î^z ½ Ç�Î\Å .Y=%< U 5m3Úµ�fi3652. W 36=�7C0 � � 3 ] < W fX9\543/< U 5mfX54<\f¸<>0236D@543BfX_1. ] 9�0236_13 ] 74.1<>='a U = ] 7C.Y<>='�y.Y74[7C[�3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=Z5C9\=X´�.Y=Xpqa U = ] 74.1<>= � � 3 W 3�9\0 U 543m7C[�3K0 F 027C3 W P 0o9 E .1_Y.Y7 F 7C<kfX. ] ´�74[X3y3�µ^fi3 ] 7436Dfg9\587C.19\_^5236fX_Y. ] 9 � 9\=�D�74[X3ofX523 ] .104.Y<>=Z<\a�7C[�3o543B0 U _¾7C.1=�p�543602f¸<\=X043y9\0 ] < W fg9\543BD��y.Y74[Z043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp7C[�3q<\54.1p\.1=g9\_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= �s [X3"543B027@<\aq7C[�3»043 ] 7C.Y<>=�.10%<>52p�9\=X. ¿ 36D�9;0'an<>_1_Y<Â�y0 � T 3 ] 74.1<>=�Ë � Ç � z .1=�c>3B027C.Yp�9;74360@[X<}�è74<5C9;=X´"fg9\5274.h9\_A5236fX_Y. ] 9\0¶9;=XD�74[X3«<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= U 02.1=Xp�7C[X3©.1=�an3B543B= ] 3©=X3B7É��<>54´ W <^DX3B_ �T 3 ] 7C.Y<>=¶Ë � Ç � Ä DX360 ] 54. E 3B0¢74[X3�3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�7C9\_�043B727C.Y=Xp>0 � T 3 ] 7C.Y<>=¶Ë � Ç � Ç ] < W fg9\543B0¢< U 5SfX54<>fi<>0236D543BfX_1. ] 9�0236_13 ] 74.1<>=�a U = ] 7C.Y<>=��y.Y74[�7C[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=·0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�a U = ] 74.1<>= � T 3 ] 7C.Y<>=�Ë � Ç � ËÙ9;=XDT 3 ] 7C.Y<>=�Ë � Ç � Î a U 587C[X3B5®DX3 W <>=�027C549;7C3¹7C[X3t3Bظ3 ] 74.Yc\36=X3B040º<\a�< U 5®9\fXfX52<�9 ] [¶an<\5 E <\7C[�5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3BDl U 3652.13B0'9\=XD U =X5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36DÙl U 3652.1360 � 9\=XD T 3 ] 7C.1<\=·Ë � Ç � Æ 0 U W©W 9\54. ¿ 3B0�74[X3)52360 U _Y740«<\a�7C[X.Y0043 ] 74.1<>= �

Ë>Ë

Page 61: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

D

D0 D1

r0

c0

r1

c1 c2

r2 Network

QueryNetworkc

rm

Dn-1

m

Collection

n

.. .. ..

.. .. ..

Qõ ò ß�%býÂà �SÿT�Iÿ s [X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>='523B7C52.13�c\9;_`.1=�an3B5436= ] 3k=X3B7É��<>52´ �

�SÿT�`ÿ¦þ ñ Þ a ª ò a ß�Ý/Þ�ýÂü ò Þ� ñ à�û! ò_i Þ�g�© ò ü ú ü ú à óba�c à�ýÂà a i à ä à�üC© d ýtª ì/d sbà` � 3@9\Dg9\f�7¶7C[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_t.Y=�an365236= ] 3%=X3B7É��<>52´V0�7C[X9;7 r 9\_Y_h9\= ���q�$¹¾¯ f�54<>fi<>043'74<5C9;=X´ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0}L zÂÎ N^7C<�549\=X´qfg9\5274.h9\_V543BfX_1. ] 9\0®9\=XD�74[X3o<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � s [X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=543�7C52.13Bc;9\_A.Y=�an365236= ] 3©=�3B7É��<>54´ W <^DX3B_ ] <>=�04.1087C0q<\at7É��< ] < W f¸<>=�36=�7q=X3B7É��<>54´�0 � 9 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>==X3�7É�t<>52´�9\=XD9»l U 3B5 F =�3B7É��<>54´ � .Y_1_ U 02745C9;7436D�.Y= w .1p U 543©Ë � Ç � s [�3S��m=�<^DX3B0 ] <>52543B04fi<>=XD7C< ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0 � 9\=XD7C[X3 � �'=�<^DX3B0 ] <>52543602f¸<\=XDÙ74< ] <>= ] 36f�740©.Y=74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 � s [X3 ±=X<VDX3/5236fX5236043B=�7C0K9�l U 365 F>� 9\=XD'74[X3 ° �`=X<VDX360 ] <>54523602f¸<>=�D@74<�l U 365 F ] <\= ] 3Bf�7C0m.Y=«7C[X3�l U 3B5 F �� F U 02.1=Xp 7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_y.1=�an3B543B= ] 3�=X3B7É��<>54´ � ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=5C9;=X´�.1=Xp E 3 ] < W 360«9\=36087C. W 9;743e<\aY� Ô¢¸ §k�� Õ an54< W ] < W�E .1=X.Y=Xpt7C[�3 ] <>=XDX.¾7C.Y<>=g9\_�fX54< E 9 E .Y_1.Y74.13B0i74[X54< U p>[�7C[X3A=X3�7É�t<\54´ �� [X3B=���3"9\Dg9;f�7'7C[�3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=·523B7C52.13�c\9;_�.1=^an36543B= ] 3»=�3B7É��<>54´ W <VDX36_y7C<�549\=X´·5236fX_Y. ] 9\0 ���3 U 023���t=�<^DX3B0�74<�5236fX5236043B=�7�7C[X3©<>54.Yp>.1=X9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= 9\=�D�fg9\587C.19\_A543BfX_1. ] 9\0 � �y[X3B543����543BfX543B043B=�740�7C[X3Z<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � ��e���x� z � Ä �k����� ¥�� z 5436f�54360236=�7qfg9\587C.h9;_¢5236fX_Y. ] 9;0 � 9;=XD�o� � ��� � ���T� � ��� � Ô J =)7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_S.1=�an3B543B= ] 3�=X3B7É��<>54´ � 7C[X3��M�®=X<VDX360�DX<=X<\7/[X<>_1D{74[X3�0 U E 043�7q5436_19;7C.Y<>=X02[X.1f � Õ{s [X3Zf U 52f¸<\043Z<\a¹5C9;=X´�.1=Xp'fX9\5274.h9\_b543BfX_1. ] 9\0/.Y0�7C<©jg=XD9 ��¥��V§$¹1� 543BfX_1. ] 9'7C[g9�7¶049;7C.Y02jg3B0¶9�p>.Yc\36=�l U 3B5 F .1=�027C369\D�<;ay9�0 U E 023B7Z<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0�.Y=�7C[�3] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= 543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_¹.1=�an3B543B= ] 3'=�3B7É��<>54´ � � 3©543�an365¶74<)7C[X.Y0¶.Y=�an365236= ] 3'=X3B7É��<>52´�9\0¶74<)7C[�3543BfX_1. ] 9@043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�.Y=�an365236= ] 3«=X3�7É�t<>52´ � +�0�.1="7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>="543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_º.1=^an36543B= ] 3©=X3B7É��<>52´W <^DX3B_ � � Ôj° �B§ � � Õ .Y0�043�7Z7C< z � Å � s [X3 ] 3B=�7C5C9;_t�t<\54´�<;a�9;fXfX_ F .Y=Xp)7C[�.10¶.Y=�an365236= ] 3%=X3B7É��<>52´

Ë Î

Page 62: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

�Q� �u�f����u� ��� ���d  '' g�¡�¢ * � ¢  ¤£v¥�¦§©¨�ª £v¥«¬� Kp;�N�'�­ ®D­¯�° � m ± w *KM;�Nn'² ³´² � g ± m�*µ ':¶ � ² · � * �Q¸ � ' g�¡ ¸ *   �   «qB>013251�v�$�k� Y�7W6>01�b ^ <¬U�1�2B;$8V`�;�/ ^ <a1�b�6�7W6> ($6{/�;�b�6�($YMb�651325<=¶ � YMb�/�;�KMKM1�/©65Yp;�b�· ��¹º©» � Y�7W6>01�b ^ <¬U�1�2B;$8¼q ;�25` 7 YMb�/�;�KpKM1�/�6YM;�b\· ��¹½�¾�¿ º©» Y�7W6>01@(�c�132�($N�1{b ^ <ÀUn132B;�8oqW;�2�`07 ¹³ Y�7W6>01�b ^ <¬U�1�2B;$8V/�;�KpKM1�/�6YM;�b 7 ¹¯)° Y�7W6>01�b ^ <¬U�1�2B;$8V/�;�KpKM1�/�6YM;�b 7W65> (f6{/3;�b�65(�YpbL¶ � h� Y�7B(a/�;�b�7!6�($b�6,6> ($6{/�;�b�652;�KM7 6> 1�<a(�N�b0Yp6 ^ `�1D;$8 �v� 'Á65>01@`�138)( ^ Kp6�YM7�j�m�m�* ¹¢ Y�7B(a/�;�b�7!6�($b�6Bc�(�2��YMb0N¬8:2;�<Âm¬6; g ^ 71�`�6;�/3;�b�625;�Kn6> 1@7�1�b 7�Yp6YMc�YZ6!��;$865>01D8 ^ b /�6YM;�b�6; º©» 'Á65>01À`�138)( ^ Kp6�Y�7Bm h | w * ¹ ($b `¸ Y�7B(a`�1�8)( ^ KZ6�Un13KMYM1�8�')71�6B65;am h l * hõ ò ß�%SýÂà �Sÿr�bÿ s [�3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=%5C9\=X´�.Y=XpZa U = ] 74.1<>[email protected]= J = Á U 365 F �

7C<�5236fX_Y. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�.10�7C<�DX3�c>3B_1<>f�9\=�3�ØÖ3 ] 74.Yc>3»5236fX_Y. ] 9�5C9\=�´V.Y=Xp�a U = ] 7C.Y<>=·74<�360274. W 9;7C3� Ô_� �#§k�� Õ �T .Y= ] 3��t3©9\Dg9;f�7k7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>="543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_A.Y=�an365236= ] 3©=X3�7É�t<\54´ � ��3©jg52027�3�µ�9 W .1=X3Z�y[X3�7C[X3B57C[�3 J = Á U 3B5 F ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�5C9;=X´�.1=Xpa U = ] 7C.1<\=���<>54´�0���36_Y_��y.Y7C[�5C9\=�´V.Y=Xp³fg9\5274.h9\_�5236fX_Y. ] 9\0 �s [X3 J = Á U 365 F ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�5C9;=X´�.1=Xp"a U = ] 7C.1<\= U 02360��7� Ô 7C[�3�DX< ]6U W 3B=�7�an5236l U 36= ] F <\a/369 ] [7C3B5 W Õ 9;0¶7C[X3 E 9\02. ] W 3B7454. ] � 9;0¶04[�<Â�y=.Y= w .Yp U 543�Ë � ËÓL zÂÎ N � J =�< U 5¶3�µ^fi3652. W 36=�7�023B7474.1=Xp\0.1= T 3 ] 7C.Y<>=�Ë � Ç � Ä^� 74[X3«D�3Ba¦9 U _¾7 J = Á U 365 F ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= 5C9\=�´V.Y=Xp�a U = ] 74.1<>=�DX.1523 ] 740 W <>543�7C[X9\=� Ŧq <\a¹7C[X3Z5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36D"l U 3B54.13B0�7C<'7C[�3�<\54.1p\.1=g9\_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � [X<}�t3�c>3B5 � 02.1= ] 3��t3 U 023�74[X36023543BfX_1. ] 9;7436DÙl U 3654.Y360�7C< E U .1_1D³543BfX_1. ] 9\0 � 7C[�3)543BfX_1. ] 9 0436_Y3 ] 7C<>5©04[X< U _1D·D�.1543 ] 7©7C[X3 W 74<�7C[�3543BfX_1. ] 9\0k.Y=X02743�9\D <\at74[X3�<>54.Yp>.1=g9;_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � +�_Y7C[�< U p>[»��3 ] 9;= 7 U =X3�7C[X3�fg9\549 W 3�7C3B540k<\a7C[�3 J = Á U 365 F ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�5C9\=X´�.Y=Xp{a U = ] 7C.1<\=�7C<»DX.Y543 ] 7 W <>543©l U 3654.Y360�74<{7C[X3%5236fX_Y. ] 9;0 � 7C[�3fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>=%DX54<\fX0m7C<V< W UX] [ � an<>5t3�µ�9 W fX_13 � 7C[X3�f�543 ] .102.1<>=@DX52<>fX0y9\fXf�54<�µ^. W 9;7C3B_ F'Ä>Î#q �y[�36=7C[�3«a U = ] 7C.1<\=�DX.1523 ] 740 Ì>Ŧq <\aK5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36D�l U 3654.Y360�74<)7C[X3«5436f�_1. ] 9\0 Ô 04363 T 3 ] 7C.1<\=�Ë � Ç � Ç an<\57C[�3�DX3�7:9\.Y_10 Õ � s [�3 J = Á U 3B5 F ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�5C9\=�´V.Y=Xpka U = ] 74.1<>=�DX<V360¹=X<\7¹�t<\54´Z�t3B_1_g�y.Y74[©5236fX_Y. ] 9

Ë Æ

Page 63: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �AE 3 ] 9 U 043@.¾7¶a¦9�c><>520 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0q�y.Y7C[�_19\54p\365�7� �AE U 7�fg9\587C.19\_�5236fX_Y. ] 9\0�7 F fX. ] 9\_Y_ F[g9�c>3q0 W 9\_Y_1365x�7�)7C[g9\=@7C[�3q<\54.1p\.1=g9\_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= �T .Y= ] 3t9�fg9\587C.19\_�5436f�_1. ] 9 ] <>=�7:9\.Y=X0¢74[X3�74<>f�DX< ]6U W 3B=�740e<\aX74[X3 W <>087¢an5236l U 36=�74_ F U 043BDZl U 3654.Y360 �E�F 3ÚµX9 W .Y=X.1=Xp©7C[X3�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7k5C9\=X´�.Y=Xp«a U = ] 7C.Y<>= � ��3Z´�=X<}� 74[g9;7/74[X3�7C<>f»D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0k9\5235C9;=X´\3BD�9\0¢74[X3t7C<\f � ¼ U 087 E 3 ] 9 U 043ol U 3B5 F 7C3B5 W 0®< ]6]6U 5 W <>543�<\a�7C3B=�.1=q7C[X3B043oDX< ]6U W 3B=�740®7C[X9\=7C[�3�<\74[X36520 � s [X3B543Ban<\543�.¾a`9q5436f�_1. ] 9 ] <>=�7:9\.Y=X0º7C[X3K7C<>f©DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0¹an<>5t9ql U 365 F>� 74[X3/9�c\365C9;p>37C3B5 W an5236l U 3B= ] F <\a¸3�9 ] [�l U 365 F 7C3B5 W .Y=�74[X3y543BfX_1. ] 9/04[�< U _1D E 3K[�.1p>[X3B5e7C[g9;=�.Y=Z7C[X3y<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= �)� 9\0236D�<>=�74[X.10�[�3 U 52.10274. ] � �t3 ] <>=X087C5 U�] 7�9)5236fX_Y. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�a U = ] 7C.1<\= E 9\0236D<>=�7C[X3�9�c>36549\p>3q7C365 W an543Bl U 36= ] F � J ={9\D�DX.Y74.1<>= � �t3qjg=XD»9Z7C3B5 W .10K. W fi<>527C9\=�7m.1=�043B_13 ] 7C.Y=Xp543BfX_1. ] 9\0�.Yaº.Y7/< ]B]6U 520�<\a�7C3B= Ô W .YDXDX_Y3¶<>5/[�.1p>[{74365 W an543Bl U 36= ] F Õ .1={74[g9;7�5236fX_Y. ] 9 È ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=9\=XD�.Y7¶9\_102<)< ]6]6U 540�.Y=�9 ] 3B527C9\.1=�= U W�E 3B5�<\amD�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0 Ô 9 E <}c\3%9 ]6U 7C<\سan<>5¶D�< ]BU W 3B=�7an543Bl U 36= ] F Õ � + 7C3B5 W < ]6]BU 5452.1=Xp".Y=�7C<V<{an3B� D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0ZDX<V360�=X<\7�[�36_1f�3�c>3B=Ù7C[�< U p>[.Y7[g9\0%[�.1p>[�74365 W an543Bl U 36= ] F � � 3 =�3636D�74< ]BU 7@<\Ø�7C[X3B043»7C3B5 W 0 � w .Yp U 523)Ë � Î .1_1_ U 02745C9;74360< U 5�543BfX_1. ] 9�0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�a U = ] 74.1<>= �y[X. ] [ U 04360�74[X3'9�c\365C9;p>3«7C3B5 W an543Bl U 36= ] F 9\=XD�f¸3B=g9\_1. ¿ 3B07C[�3q74365 W 0y7C[g9;7�9\fXfi3�9;5�_Y36040y7C[X9\={9 ]6U 74<\Ø .1=@7C[X3 ] <>52543B04fi<>=XDX.Y=Xp«5236fX_Y. ] 9 È ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � � 3] < W fg9;543�7C[X.Y0ma U = ] 74.1<>=@�y.Y74[�74[X3 J = Á U 365 F ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=@5C9\=X´�.Y=Xp�a U = ] 74.1<>[email protected]= T 3 ] 7C.Y<>=�Ë � Ç � Ç��9\=XD�DX3 W <>=X087C549;7C3�.Y7C0K3Bظ3 ] 7C.¾c>36=�36040 U 04.1=�p Ç�Î\Å syu à r l U 3B54.13B0�<>=)9 Ä O ��] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=)9;=XD9 Ä\Å O ��] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=%.Y= T 3 ] 7C.1<\=�Ë � Ç � Ë�9\=XD T 3 ] 7C.Y<>=@Ë � Ç � Î �J =Z<>52DX365b7C<�9 U 7C< W 9;7C. ] 9\_Y_ F 043B7®7C[X3 ]6U 74<\Ø«c;9\_ U 3�.Y=�3�9 ] [Z5436f�_1. ] 9 � ��3o3ÚµX9 W .Y=X3�74[X3t087:9;74.10274. ] 0<\ag74[X3tDX< ]6U W 3B=�7®an5436l U 3B= ] F .1=�369 ] [Z543BfX_1. ] 9 È ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � � 3�jg=XD�74[X36523o.10®9\=Z9\f�fX54<�µ^. W 9;7C3543B_h9;74.1<>=�04[X.Yf E 3�7É�t3B36=%9�c>3B5C9\p\3�DX< ]6U W 3B=�7ºan5236l U 36= ] F 9\=XD�7C[X3y= U W�E 365¹<\a¸DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0 � 9;=XDE 3B7É��3636= W 9�µ^. W U W D�< ]BU W 3B=�7'an543Bl U 36= ] F 9\=XD·74[X3{= U W�E 365«<\aqDX< ]BU W 36=�7C0'.Y=�543BfX_1. ] 9\0�y.Y74[�DX.¾ØÖ3B543B=�7¶04. ¿ 360 � .1_Y_ U 087C549;7C3BD .Y= w .Yp U 523�Ë � Æ � w .Yp U 523�Ë � Æ Ô 9 Õ 04[X<}�y0¶74[X3«087:9;74.10274. ] 0kan<\504[�<>527�l U 3652.13B0�an52< W 7436087�7454.19\_ z DX360 ] 52. E 36D³.1= T 3 ] 7C.Y<>=³Ë � Ç � Ä � w .1p U 543%Ë � Æ Ô E Õ .1_1_ U 02745C9;743607C[�3'36l U 9;74.1<>=�0¶7C[g9�7�DX3B0 ] 52. E 3'7C[X3«5436_19;7C.Y<>=X02[X.1f E 3�7É�t3B36=³DX< ]6U W 36=�7�an5236l U 36= ] .13B0ZDX3652.Yc\36Dan54< W 7C[�3�027:9�7C.1087C. ] 0 � � [�36=@�t3k543BfX_1. ] 9;743�7C[�3/7C<>f ¥ DX< ]6U W 36=�740yan<\5o3�9 ] [@an543Bl U 36=�7C_ F U 0236D

Ë �

Page 64: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

ÃfÄfÅ Æ ° � ¯3Æ ° �k��u� ���Ç �Q�ÉÈ Ã$Ä�Å Æ ° YZ8�Ê ° ��� z ¯�Ë�ÆuÌ!Í �Ã$Ä�Å Æ °  ÏÎ�Ð ¦�ѯ�Ë�ÆuÌ!Í � ;$6> 1325qBYM71�Q� Ç �Ç � ���¬  '' gB¡�¢ * � ¢   §©¨�ª Î©Ò £ÔÓ ªuÕ ¦§©¨�ª §©¨�ª Î©Ò £ÔÓ ªuÕ«¬� Kp;�N�' ­ ®D­Ö Ð � m ± w *KM;�Nn'² ³´² � g ± m�*µ ':¶ � ² · � * �Q¸ � ' g�¡ ¸ *   �   «qB>01�21¯3Æ ° ��� YM7W65>01�b ^ <ÀUn132�;�8×;�/3/ ^ 2521�b /�1P7 ;�8×651325<ɶ � YMb�/3;�KMKp1P/©65Yp;�b � 251340KMY�/3(d· ��¹�u�f��� YM7W65>01�b ^ <ÀUn132�;�8o`�;�/ ^ <a13b�657,65> (f6{/3;�b�65(�YpbL61�2<=¶ � Ypb�/�;�KpKM1�/�6YM;�b � 21�40KMYM/�(¬· �!¹¯3Ë�ÆvÌ�Í � YM7W65>01@/ ^ 65;$ØÙb ^ <¬U�1�2�;$8¼`�;�/ ^ <a1�b�6�7BYMb�25134 KpY�/3( � /�;�KpKM1�/�6YM;�b�· �¹³ YM7W65>01�b ^ <ÀUn132�;�8×251340KMY�/3(�7,4 K ^ 7B6>01�;�2YMN�YMb ($K�/3;�KMKp1P/©6YM;�b ¹¶ � YM7W65>01�b ^ <ÀUn132�;�8×251340KMY�/3(�7B(�b `�6>01@/3;�KMKp1P/©6YM;�bL6>�(f6{/�;�b�65($YMb�¶ ��¹ÃfÄfÅ Ê ÌP¯�ÚMÅ�Û � YM7W65>01@(�c�1�25(�N�1J`0;�/ ^ <a13b�6�KM13b0N�6>\Ypb�/3;�KMKp1P/©6YM;�b � 251340KMYM/�(À· �¹ÃfÄfÅ ÃfÄfÅ Ê ÌP¯�ÚpÅ3Û YM7W65>01@(�c�1�25(�N�1 ½�¾�¿ ��Ü º�Ý�¿PÞ � ¹� YM7B(e/3;�b 7�65(�b�6,65> (f6�/�;�b�625;�K�7965>01�<e($N�b0YZ6 ^ `�1�;�8 Ç � ¹¢ YM7B(e/3;�b 7�65(�b�6Bcf($25��Ypb NÀ8:25;�<=m¬65; g ^ 7�1P`�65;e/�;�b�652;�K�65>01@713b 7YZ65Ypc�Yp6!��;�86>01D8 ^ b�/©6YM;�b�65; ÃfÄfÅ Ê Ì�¯3ÚpÅ3Û ¹ ($b `¸ YM7B(e`�138)( ^ Kp6�Un13KMYp138,'�7�136B6;em h l * h

õ ò ß�%býÂà �SÿT�Iÿ s [X3q543BfX_1. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%a U = ] 7C.1<\= �

l U 365 F>� ��3�043B7�7C[�3 ]BU 7C<;Ø�<;a�74[X3�0 W 9;_1_13B027Z5236fX_Y. ] 9 9;0 ¥ � 9\=�DÙ023B7�7C[X3 ]6U 74<\ظ0�an<\5�<;7C[X3B5543BfX_1. ] 9 È ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= U 02.1=XpZ74[X3k36l U 9;74.1<>=�04[X<}�y=�.1= w .Yp U 543�Ë � Æ Ô ] Õ �� 3/. W fX_13 W 3B=�7�74[X3/543BfX_1. ] 9¶0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=«.1=�an3B5436= ] 3�=X3�7É�t<>52´'9\0o9�fX043 U DX< J = Á U 3B5 F DX9;7:9 E 9\043 ��y[X3B543t369 ] [¶f�043 U DX<�DX< ]6U W 3B=�7 ] <\54543B04fi<>=XDX0b7C<�9K5236fX_Y. ] 9y<\5 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � .Y740b.Y=XDX3Úµk0274<>543B0¢7C[�3£2� Ô DX< ]6U W 36=�7San543Bl U 36= ] F Õ 9\=XD ¾�� � Ô 5236fX_Y. ] 9 È ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�74365 W an5436l U 3B= ] F Õ an<>5S3�9 ] [q7C365 W � � 3DX<©=X<\7K0274<>543�9\= F fX54<�µ^. W .Y7 F .1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=%.1=�<>54DX3B5m7C< W .1=�. W . ¿ 3K7C[X3q04fX9 ] 3�5436l U .Y543 W 3B=�740<\a¢7C[X3q543BfX_1. ] 9Z043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�DX9;7:9 E 9\043 � +�0K.1=@7C[X3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=%523B7C52.13�c\9;_`.1=�an3B5436= ] 3¶=�3B7É��<>54´ � 9\_1_fX52<}µ^. W .¾7 F <>fi36549;7C<\540K9\543�5236fX_19 ] 3BD��y.¾7C[ � <V<>_1369\=@+ N ,-<>fi36549;7C<\540 �

Ë Ì

Page 65: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

ßoà3á�â ãkà©äfå�æBçFè ãkà©äfåÁæBçJèé�à©êDë ìÔí!ê�ã î�ï å�æBçFè ð�ñ3ò óÁô ãkà©äfå�ð�ñ3ò óÁô$è õFð�ö óÁô ãkà©ä$åpõJð3ö óÁô$èæ � ÷�ø ù©ú©ù ��ûPü¨��ù �Pü ù�ý �Pø û©ù©ú �©ü þ©úæ � ûPø ÷�û©ÿ �©ÿPü ��� �Pü ù�� ÿPø ÿ©ù�÷ �©ü þ©ú��þ©þ æ � ���Pø ý��©ù �©ûPü ý©ý �Pü ù�� ùPø¨��ù�� �©ü þ©úæ ÷ �ý�ø ÿ©ÿ©ÿ �©�Pü ÷©÷ �Pü ù�� ��þPø ÷�û©ù �©ü þ©úæ ÿ ���©ø ú�÷�� ��÷�ü �©û �Pü ù�� ���Pø û�÷�� �©ü þ©ÿæ � ûPø ÿ�ý�� ���Pü û©ú �Pü ù©ù ÿPø ù��ý �©ü þ©úæ � ��ùPø ���©ú �©þPü ú©ÿ �Pü ù�ý ��þPø ù©ú©ù �©ü þ©ú�©þ©þ æ � �©úPø �©ù©þ �©úPü ÷3ý �Pü ù�� ��ÿPø ý�þ©û �©ü þ©ÿæ ÷ ���Pø¨����� ÷�þPü �©� �Pü ù©� ��ûPø û�÷�� �©ü þ©ÿæ ÿ ÷�þPø ú��V� ÷��Pü¨��þ �Pü ù©� ��÷�ø ����û �©ü þ©ÿæ � ���Pø¨����� ���Pü ú©� �Pü ù©ú ���Pø ù���ý �©ü þ©ÿæ � ÷��Pø ú©ú©û ÷��©ü ý�� �Pü ù©ú �©ÿPø ÷©÷3ý �©ü þ©ÿÿ©þ©þ æ � ú©þPø ��÷�þ ÷�ûPü �©þ �Pü ù�� �©ÿPø û©þ©ù �©ü þ©ÿæ ÷ ý��Pø ý5÷3ý ÿ��Pü ý�ú �Pü ù�� ÷©÷�ø �©�©û �©ü þ©ÿæ ÿ ù©ùPø ý��©û ÿ�ý�ü ÷�ù �Pü ù�� ÿ©�Pø ù©þ©ÿ �©ü þ©ÿé����� ���� å � ��� è ÿ©ú�ý�ø ÿ©�©û ��þ��©ü¨��� �Pü ù�ý �©ÿ©ÿPø ÿ©�©û �©ü þ©ú')(�*,?,>01@7!6�(f65YM7�6Y�/37W8:;�2�7�>0;�2�6 ]�^ 1�2YM1�7,;�bL2513K�(f65Yp;�b 7�> Yp4�;$8¼`�;�/ ^ <a13b�6B8:251 ]�^ 1�b /�YM1�7W8:25;�<X651�7�6B625YM(�K g

KM;�N�'�·�³ � *KM;�Nn' ½�¾�¿ �u�f� * � KM;�Nn')·�³ � *KM;�Nn' ½�¾�¿ �u��� *KM;�Nn')·�³ � *KM;�N '�� ½�� �u�f� * � KM;�N�'�·�³ � *KM;�Nn'�� ½�� �u��� *qB>01�21·�³ � Y�7,65>01�b ^ <ÀUn132B;�8¼`�;�/ ^ <a13b�657,YMb\21�40KpY�/3( � /3;�KMKp1P/©6YM;�b�· �!¹½�¾�¿ �u�f� Y�7�(�c�132�($N�1F`�;�/ ^ <a1�b�6,8:251 ]�^ 1�b /���YMb\21�40KMYM/�( � /3;�KMKp1P/©65Yp;�bL· �!¹� ½�� �u�f� Y�7B<e(f-�YM< ^ <Â`�;�/ ^ <a13b�6B8:251 ]�^ 1�b /���YMb\21�40KMYM/�( � /3;�KMKp1P/©65Yp;�bL· � h':U�*�?,>01D1 ]�^ (f65Yp;�b 7W8:;�2B2513K�(f65Yp;�b 7>0Yp4�Un1�6!qW1313b\`�;�/ ^ <d1�b�6B8:21 ]�^ 13b /3Yp1P7¯3Ë�ÆvÌ�Í � � ¯3Ë�ÆuÌ!Í�� � ��������� ¦ �� ��� �!�"�$# �qB> 13251¯3Ë�ÆuÌ!Í � Y�7,65>01@/ ^ 65;$ØÙcf(�K ^ 1F8:;�2,6>01@7<e($KMKp1P7!6B251340KMYM/�(a· � ¹ qB>0Y�/�>LqW1@71�6(�7W6>01�b ^ <¬U�1�2B;$8o6;�4\`0;�/ ^ <a13b�657W8:;�2B1�(�/�> ]�^ 1�2� ¹¯3Ë�ÆuÌ!Í � Y�7,65>01@/ ^ 65;$ØÙcf(�K ^ 1F8:;�2,6>01�251340KMY�/3( � /�;�KpKM1�/�6YM;�bL· ��%�& z�j ¹·�³ � Y�7,65>01�b ^ <ÀUn132B;�8¼`�;�/ ^ <a13b�657,YMb�6>01@7<e($KMKp1P7!6B251340KMYM/�(a· � ¹ ($b�`·�³ � Y�7,65>01�b ^ <ÀUn132B;�8¼`�;�/ ^ <a13b�657,YMb\21�40KpY�/3( � /3;�KMKp1P/©6YM;�b�· � %�& z�j h')/�*,?,> 1�1 ]�^ (f65Yp;�b�8:;�2,6>01@/ ^ 6;�Ø

õ ò ß�%SýÂà �Sÿ»�Iÿ s [X3o5236_h9�7C.1<\=X04[X.Yf E 3B7É��363B=�DX< ]BU W 36=�7ean543Bl U 36= ] .13B0e.1=�D�.Yظ36543B=�7e543BfX_1. ] 9\0S�y.Y74[DX.¾ØÖ3B5436=�7K04. ¿ 3B0 �

Ë |

Page 66: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

�SÿT�`ÿT� é ÷ ûAà�ý ò f�à a ü�Þ� î à�ü�ü ò a ß�g� 3{3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C3�7C[X3�3Bظ3 ] 7C.Yc\36=X3B040@<\ak< U 5«543BfX_1. ] 9 0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�9\fXfX52<�9 ] [ U 02.1=Xp�7C[X3 J = Á U 365 F543�7C52.13Bc;9\_K0 F 087C3 W L z Ë � � Ä N � 9\=�D�9 Ä O � syu à r ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=7C[g9;7 ] <>=�7:9;.1=X0 syu à r Ä#"�Ç] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 � 9;=XD�9 Ä;Å O � ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>="7C[g9�7 ] <>=�7:9\.Y=X0�9\_Y_ syu à r Æ Ñ/P¢r ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0 Ô 043B3s 9 E _13�+ � z Õ � � 3 U 043©l U 3652.1360qDX3�c>36_Y<>fi36D�an<\5 syu à r 74<>fX. ] 0 Î^z ½ Ç>Î\Å .1="< U 5k3�µ^fi3652. W 36=�7C0 �� 3 W 3�9;0 U 523K74[X3y0 F 02743 W P 0t9 E .1_Y.Y7 F 7C<kfX. ] ´�7C[X3y543B_13�c\9;=�7¹fg9;527C.19\_X5236fX_Y. ] 9 � 9\=XD�7C[X3KfX543 ] .Y04.1<\=<\a¢7C[X3�54360 U _Y74.1=Xp�523604fi<>=X023Z9\0 ] < W fg9\5236D@�y.Y74[)04369\5 ] [�.1=Xp�7C[X3q<>54.Yp>.1=X9\_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � � 3 U 023syu à r l U 3654.Y360q.1=X087C369\D�<;a�74[X3�l U 3654.Y360kan54< W 7C[X3�_1<\p>0 �SE 3 ] 9 U 043�04< W 3�<\a syu à r l U 3B54.13B0[g9�c>3©543B_13Bc;9\= ] 3/¼ U DXp W 36=�7C0�74[g9;7�36=g9 E _13 U 0k7C<�fX54<VD UX] 3©fX523 ] .104.Y<>=�9\=XD 543 ] 9\_1_ejXp U 543B0qan<\53Bc;9\_ U 9;74.1=Xp�74[X3k3Bظ3 ] 74.Yc\36=X3B040 �� F U 02.1=Xp�7C[X3 Ä O � ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � ��3 ] < W fg9\543�7C[�3«3Bظ3 ] 7C.¾c>36=�36040Z<;ao< U 5q543BfX_1. ] 9@043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=a U = ] 7C.Y<>=��y.¾7C[k7C[X3 J = Á U 365 F ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=q549\=X´�.1=�pKa U = ] 7C.Y<>= U 04.1=�p�04[�<>527¢l U 3652.1360 � 9\=XD�DX3 W <>= ½02745C9;743�7C[X3q3Bظ3 ] 7C.Yc\36=X3B040/<;a®< U 5K5236fX_Y. ] 9�0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=@a U = ] 7C.Y<>= U 04.Y=Xp E <\74[�02[X<>527Kl U 3B54.13B0�9;=XD_1<\=Xp�l U 3B54.Y360 � + 04[�<>527¶l U 365 F .Y0q02. W fX_ F 9�0 U W <;at7C[�3©7C3B5 W 0k.1=�74[X3 ] <>52543602f¸<\=XDX.1=�p)DX3 ½0 ] 54.Yf�7C.Y<>=�jg36_YD©<;a¸74[X3o7C<>f�. ]\� P <\=Xpkl U 3654.Y360¹9\523y9 U 7C< W 9;74. ] 9\_1_ F ] 54369;7C3BD©an52< W syu à r 7C<\fX. ] 0U 02.1=Xp J = Á U 365 F l U 365 F p\36=X3B5C9;74.1<>=@7C3 ] [X=X.1l U 3B0ML z Ë$N � �y[X. ] [ ] <>=�04.1087�<;a®7C3B5 W 0 � fX[�5C9\02360/9;=XDfX52<}µ^. W .¾7 F <>fi365C9�7C<>520 � O 3B=X36549\_1_ F>� 9)_1<\=Xp�l U 3B5 F an<>5�9�7C<\fX. ] .10 W <\543�3Bظ3 ] 7C.Yc\3«7C[X9\=�7C[�304[�<>527Kl U 365 F L z Ë$N � s [�3¶9�c>3B5C9\p\3�= U W�E 365y<\ab7C3B5 W 0yf¸3B5ml U 365 F an<\5y74[X3k043�7�<;a®02[X<>527Kl U 3B54.13B0.10 Ì 9;a�7C3B5�523 W <ÂcV.Y=Xpq74[X3K027C<\f���<>52DX0 � 9\=XD©74[X3/9�c\365C9;p>3�= U W¶E 3B5t<\a¸7C365 W 0¹fi365¹l U 365 F an<>5º7C[�3043�7�<\at_1<>=�p�l U 3B54.13B0¶.Y0 zÂÄ;Å � w <>5k3�9 ] [�043B7¶<\aml U 3B54.13B0 � �t3'D�.YcV.1DX3�l U 3B54.13B0¶.Y=�74<�7É��< ] 9;7C3 ½p><>52.13B0 � 5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3BD"l U 3654.Y360¶9\=XD U =X543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D l U 3652.1360 � �y[X3B543 �n¬g���C�É��¹ ¥�¾4�\�É�4£{¨6¡����Ú¥ �:�«�\�C���¬g�}�}�yÜ®¬g�}�}�m�É�:��£V��¾�¡V�«���g�n�y�\�:�m¡��}�4£k�L�¶ª6¡V¥Ç¹¾£q��¬g�y�C�É��¹ ¥�¾4��� �AT .Y= ] 3t<>=X_ F 74<>fX. ] 0 Î^z ½ zÂÎ\Å 9;=XD7C<\fX. ] 0 Ä\Å>Ä ½ Ä>Î;Å [X9}c\3¶5236_13�c;9\= ] 3m¼ U DXp W 36=�7Kjg_13B0Kan<\5K74[X3 Ä O � syu à r ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � �t3¶5C9\= ½DX< W _ F f�. ] ´ Î\Å U =�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3BD«l U 3B54.13B0tan54< W 74[X36023 z Ë | 7C<>f�. ] 0t9\=XD'5236fi<>527�7C[X3�3Bظ3 ] 7C.Yc\36=X3B040an<>5o74[X36023q74<>fX. ] 0m<>=X_ F �� F U 04.Y=Xp�7C[�3 Ä\Å O � ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � ��3»3�µ�9 W .1=X3)[X<}� 74[X3»04. ¿ 3{<;a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�9;ظ3 ] 7C0'7C[�33Bظ3 ] 7C.¾c>36=�36040º<\a�< U 5e543BfX_1. ] 9K5C9\=X´�.Y=Xp�a U = ] 7C.Y<>= �AT .1= ] 3t�t3mD�</=X<\7A[X9}c\3m543B_13Bc;9\= ] 3b¼ U D�p W 3B=�7

Î\Å

Page 67: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

jg_Y360tan<>5¹7C<>f�. ] 0 Î^z ½ z}Î\Å 9\=XD'74<>fX. ] 0 Ä;Å�Ä ½ Ä\Î\Å 9\p>9\.1=X087t74[X3 Ä\Å O ��] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 9\=XD'74[X3 Ä O �] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>='.Y0y9Z0 U E 023B7K<\ab7C[X3 Ä\Å O ��] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � �t3 U 023k74[X3�543B_13�c\9;= ] 3t¼ U DXp W 3B=�7mjX_1360oan<\57C[�3 Ä O ��] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>='7C<�fX52<^D U�] 3�7C[X3kfX523 ] .104.Y<>=%jgp U 52360 �� 3 ] <>=�D UX] 7y< U 5o3�µ^fi3652. W 36=�7C0 E�F 5436fi3�9�7C.1=�p¶7C[X3�an<>_1_Y<Â�y.Y=XpqfX54< ] 3BD U 543 Î 7C. W 360 � 369 ] [%7C52.h9\_U 02360�9�DX.Yظ365236=�7@= U W�E 365@9\0'74[X3»043B36D�7C<�fX52<^D U�] 3»5C9;=XDX< W = U W�E 3B540 � 9\=XD�74[ U 0�f�. ] ´�0DX.¾ØÖ3B5436=�7kl U 3B54.13B0�an<>5�9%l U 365 F 043�7 � J ="3�9 ] [ 7454.h9;_ � ��3�5C9\=�DX< W _ F ] [X<V<>043 Î\Å l U 3B54.13B0�an54< Wl U 3652.13B0� Î^z ½ z}Î\Å��ÖÄ\Å�Ä ½ Ä>Î\Å ��9;0/< U 5 ¡V�g�C�É��¹ ¥�¾4�\�L�4£ l U 3B5 F 023B7(' � 9;=XD»5C9\=�DX< W _ F DX.YcV.YDX3¶7C[�3543 W 9;.1=X.Y=Xp Ä>Î\Å l U 3B54.Y360�.1=�l U 3B54.13B0 Î^z ½ Ç>Î\Å .1=�74< Î 023B740 � � ± ������� z � Ä � Ç �CË�� Î � � 3�9 ] [³043�7] <\=�7C9\.1=�.1=Xp Î\Å l U 3654.Y360 � � 3@7C[X3B= E U .Y_1D³9 Æ ½ _h9 F 365�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=[X.Y365C9;5 ] [ FE�F U 04.1=�p�7C[�3Ä O � syu à r ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=·<>5'74[X3 Ä\Å O � ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�9\0'74[X3»<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=HÈ � 9;=XD] <\_1_13 ] 74.1=Xp{74[X3�74<>f ¥ DX< ]6U W 3B=�740©52360 U _Y74.1=Xp»an54< W 04369\5 ] [X.Y=Xp�74[X3@<>54.Yp>.1=X9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�an<\53�9 ] [�l U 3B5 F .1=Ã� ± �V����� z � Ä � Ç �4Ë�� Î ��74< E U .1_YD Î fg9;527C.19\_Ö5236fX_Y. ] 9\0�� ��e����� z � Ä � Ç �4Ë�� Î � �

y �o� � ] <>=�7:9\.Y=X0/7C[X3Z74<>f ¥ DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0�an<>5�369 ] [�l U 3B5 F .Y="l U 365 F 043B7 ± � � § ± �t§ � Î\Å��74<\7:9\_ ¥*) Î\Å DX< ]6U W 3B=�740 �

y ��� � ] <>=�7:9;.1=X0Z7C[�3�74<>f ¥ DX< ]6U W 36=�740©an<>5�3�9 ] [·l U 365 F .1=³l U 365 F 023B7C0 ± ��9\=XD ± � �§ ± �+§O� Î\Å�� 74<\7:9;_ ¥*) z�Å>Å DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 �

y �+� � ] <>=�7:9\.Y=X0�74[X3�7C<\f ¥ DX< ]6U W 3B=�740tan<>5�3�9 ] [%l U 3B5 F .1='l U 3B5 F 043B740�� ± �����!� z � Ä � Ç � �§ ± �+§O� Î\Å�� 74<\7:9;_ ¥*) z}Î\Å DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 �

y ��÷ � ] <\=�7C9\.1=�0I7C[X3e74<>f ¥ D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0`an<>5I369 ] [�l U 3B5 F .Y=�l U 365 F 023B740>� ± �V����� z � Ä � Ç �CËY� �§ ± �+§O� Î\Å�� 74<\7:9;_ ¥*) Ä;Å>Å DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 �

y ��ÿ � ] <>=�7:9\.Y=X0I7C[X3e74<>f ¥ DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0Ian<\5I3�9 ] [ql U 365 F .1=�l U 3B5 F 023B740>� ± �e���F� z � Ä � Ç �CË�� Î � �§ ± �+§O� Î\Å�� 74<\7:9;_ ¥*) Ä\Î\Å DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 �

r _1369\54_ F>� �o� � ��� � �+� � ��ÿ � È � s [�.10K027C5 UX] 7 U 543 W . W . ] 0 Î 5236fX_Y. ] 9;0o7C[g9;7K.Y= ] 523�9\023�.Y=04. ¿ 3y9\=�D�74[ U 0A.1= ] _ U D�3 W <\543o<\ai7C[�3o7C<>fZl U 3B54.13B0Aan<>5e3�9 ] [�02. ¿ 3m.1= ] 543�9;043 � � 3 E U .1_1D�9/5236fX_Y. ] 9

Î^z

Page 68: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�.1=�an3B5436= ] 3y=X3B7É��<>52´�74<�549\=X´¶74[X36023Kj�c>3K5436f�_1. ] 9\0¹9\=XD�7C[X3y<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � s [X3l U 3652.13B0K.Y=@l U 365 F 023B740p� ± �e���!� z � Ä � Ç �CË�� Î �q9;543 ] 9\_Y_13BD �:�É��¹ ¥�¾4�\�É�4£ l U 3654.Y360 �s 9 E _13�Ë � Ë�_1.1087C0/74[X3«9�c\365C9;p>3©= U W¶E 3B5�<\atDX< ]6U W 36=�7C0q.1= 3�9 ] [�543BfX_1. ] 9%<}c>3B5q74[X3�j�c>3©7454.19\_109;a�74365/DX3B_13�7C.1=�p'D U fX_Y. ] 9;7C3BD»DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 � 7C[X3�9�c>3B5C9\p\3Z= U W�E 3B5�<\aº�t<\54DX0 � 9;=XD{7C[X3�9�c\365C9;p>304. ¿ 3{<;ak5436f�_1. ] 9\0©�y[�36= E U .Y_1DX.Y=Xp�DX.¾ØÖ3B543B=�7'5436f�_1. ] 9\0 E�F U 04.Y=Xp�DX.¾ØÖ3B5436=�7%= U W¶E 3B540%<\a�74<>fDX< ]6U W 36=�740 � 9;0��t3B_1_¢9\0�74[X3�087:9;74.10274. ] 0Kan52< W 7É�t<%<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0 � � [X36= U 04.1=�p«7C[X3 ÄO �³] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�9\0º7C[�3�<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 7C[�3�02. ¿ 3K<\aÖ5436f�_1. ] 9\0º5C9\=�p>360ºan54< WQÅ � Ç#q 7C< z � Î$q%�ztq 7C< Î#q'��Ä#q 7C< z}Ŧq'� 9\=XD Î#q 74< Ä\Ŧq <\a¢74[X3�<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=«�y[X3B=�5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y=Xp¶7C[�37C<\f Ç\Å��Iz}Å>Å^�gÄ\Å>Å^� 9\=XD Î\Å>Å DX< ]6U W 3B=�740 � 523604fi3 ] 7C.¾c>36_ F � � [X3B= U 02.1=XpZ74[X3 Ä\Å O ��] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=9\0m7C[�3�<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 74[X3q04. ¿ 3�<;a®5236fX_Y. ] 9;0K549\=Xp>3B0man54< W Å � ztq 74< Å � Î$q%�iÅ � Ä#q 74< z�q%�9\=XD Å � Î#q 74< Ä#q <\ab7C[X3k<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=«�y[X3B=)5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1=�p¶7C[X3�74<>f z}Å>Å���Ä;Å>Å�� 9\=�D Î\Å\ÅDX< ]6U W 36=�740 � 543B04fi3 ] 7C.Yc\36_ F �w <>5�74[X3 Ä\Å O �!] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � ��3 ] <>=XD UX] 7k<>=X3 W <>523¶3�µ^fi3652. W 36=�7�.1=)<>54DX3B5�74< W 9\´;3 U f)an<\5.1=�0 U À ] .Y36=�7K543B_13Bc;9\= ] 3�¼ U DXp W 3B=�740man<>5o7C<>f�. ] 0[� Î^z ½ z}Î\Å��ÐÄ\Å�Ä ½ Ä>Î\Å � � � 3 U 023kl U 3654.Y360 Ç>Å�z ½ Ç�Î\Å9\0�< U 5 U =�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3BD�l U 365 F 043�7,' � 04.Y= ] 3©7C[X3B043 Î\Å 74<>fX. ] 0�9\523 W <>543�7C[X<>52< U p>[�_ F ¼ U DXp\36D9\p�9;.1=X087Z7C[X3 Ä\Å O � Ñ/Pbr ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�74[g9\=�7C<>f�. ] 0^� Î^z ½ zÂÎ\Å^�¹Ä\Å�Ä ½ Ä>Î\Å � � � 3 U 043@l U 3B54.13B0Î^z ½ z}Å>Å 9\0 ± � �`z}Å�z ½ zÂÎ\Å 9;0 ± � �`zÂÎVz ½ Ä\Å\Å 9\0 ± � �iÄ;Å�Ä ½ Ä\Î\Å 9\0 ± ÷ � 9\=XD Ä>Î^z ½ Ç>Å>Å 9\0 ± ÿ �� [X3B=��t3'3�c;9\_ U 9�7C3'9�DX< ]BU W 36=�7�<>5 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= 5C9\=X´�.Y=Xp)a U = ] 7C.Y<>= � ��3'0C9 F 9�a U = ] 7C.Y<>=�.Y0E 3B7474365®74[g9\=Z<\74[X36520A.Ya�9;=XDZ<>=X_ F .¾ag.Y7 ] 9\=ZfX52<^D UX] 3m[X.Yp>[X3B5®fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>=Z9;7A0236_Y3 ] 7436D�= U W�E 36520e<\aDX< ]6U W 36=�740o<>5�9;7m9\_Y_�027:9;=XDg9\52D%_13Bc\36_Y0t<\a`523 ] 9\_1_ Ô 02363 T 3 ] 74.1<>= Ä � z � Ç Õ � J =«7C[�3 ] 9\023/<\a`5236fX_Y. ] 9043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � ��3{=X3B36D·74<�9\DXD�9;=X<\7C[�365 ] 54.¾7C3652.1<>=an<>5�7C[X3�5C9\=X´�.Y=Xp�a U = ] 7C.Y<>= � DX.Y543 ] 7C.Y=Xp�9;0W 9\= F l U 3652.13B0º9\0Af¸<\0404. E _13�7C<�7C[X3m5236_Y3Bc;9\=�7º543BfX_1. ] 9\0e.Y=Z<>54D�365e7C<�. W f�54<}c>3m0 F 087C3 W 3�µ^3 ]BU 7C.Y<>=fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3 � � 3 ] 9\='7 U =X3/7C[X3�fX9\5C9 W 3B7436520m<\aS< U 5oa U = ] 7C.Y<>=X0t74< ] <>=�7454<>_Ö74[X3�fi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3<\ai543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D�l U 3B54.Y360e7C</74[X3m543BfX_1. ] 9\0 Ô 9\0®04[X<}�y=�.1= T 3 ] 74.1<>=ZË � Ç � Ç Õ � s [X3m5C9;=Xp>3tc;9\52.1360¢an54< WŦq 7C< |>Ŧq � N <>=�3¶<\ae74[X3�a U = ] 74.1<>=��t3q7C36087C3BD ] 9\={D�.1543 ] 7 z}Å>Ŧq <;aA543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D)l U 3B54.Y360�74<7C[�3m5436f�_1. ] 9\0 � H <}��3Bc>3B5¹�y[�36=Z�t3yDX.Y543 ] 7 W <>543tl U 3654.Y360A7C</74[X3m543BfX_1. ] 9\0 � ��3K[X9}c\3m7C</7C<\_136549;7C3

Î>Ä

Page 69: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

ßoà3á�-/. 0Dí!ä�12.é43�ê�í é�à©ê � � í!ê�ã65ká�1 7Bí!ë/8�â 9Àà©ì�î�â ï�3:8�í!âæ ; �©ø ÷�ù©ÿ ÿ�ý��Pø ú©ú�÷ ýæ�< �Pø û���ý �©ø¨���©þPø û©û�ý �!÷�©þ æ>= ÷�ø �©ÿ�ý �©ø ú©ú©úPø ���©� �©þæ>? ÿPø ý��©ú �Pø �©þ©ùPø ���!÷ �©úæ�@ ý�ø þ©ù©û �Pø ý�û©þPø ����� ���æ ; ÷�ø ù�ý�ú �©ø û©���Pø þ�ý�ú ���æ�< ûPø ÿ©�©ù �Pø ý5÷©÷�ø ÿ©þ©û ÷�ÿ��þ©þ æ>= ���Pø û©ú©ù ÿPø ÷�û©ùPø ý+�!÷ ú©úâ�A�à©ìB8 æ ? ��ùPø �©þ©ú ý�ø¨�����©ø ÿ©þ©� ù©ÿC -�í!ì�5kí!â æ�@ �©�Pø �©ú�� ùPø ù©ÿ©ùPø¨��þ©� ��þ©úå �D��� è æ ; ûPø ú��©ú �Pø û©ù��©ø ù�÷�� ÷�ùæ�< ��ùPø ÿ©ÿ©� ý�ø ú���ùPø ÿ©ù©ú û���©þ©þ æ = �©úPø ù©ù©ù ��þPø û©ÿ©þPø û��ý �����æ ? ��÷�ø ú�÷�û �!÷�ø þ©ÿ©þPø þ©ù©ú ��ú©ùæ�@ ÷��©ø û���� �ý�ø þ�ý+�©ø ý5÷©÷ �©þ��æ ; ���Pø �©þ�� ûPø û��©�Pø ��÷�ÿ �V��ùæ < ÷��Pø ÿ©û�÷ ��ùPø �©ù��Pø ú©ù©� ����ùÿ©þ©þ æ>= ú��©ø ý+��þ �©ÿPø ú�ý��Pø ÷�ú©þ �©þ©úæ ? ý©ý�ø ú��V� ���©ø ù©û©úPø ÷©÷�û �©ù©þæ�@ û©�Pø þ©ú�� ��ý�ü ÿ©û©ÿPø ù©û�÷ ÷©÷3ýæ ; ÷�ø ù��©� �Pø¨��ù©ÿPø ú©ÿ�� �©úæ�< ûPø �©û�÷ ÷�ø¨��ù©úPø ���©ú ÿ©þ��þ©þ æ>= ���Pø ú���û ÿPø ù©ù©úPø ÿ©ù�ý ý�þæ ? �ý�ø ý+��ú ý�ø ú���ùPø û�ý�� û©þæ @ ���©ø ÿ©ú©ù ûPø �©ú©ÿPø û©�©þ �V�V�æ ; ûPø ÷�û©� ÷�ø ��÷��©ø û©þ�� ÿ��ãkà©ë�ä æ�< ��ùPø¨��ú�ý ùPø ��÷�úPø ÷�þ©� û�ýC -�í!ì�5kí!â �©þ©þ æ>= �©úPø þ��ý �V�©ø ÷©÷�ûPø �©þ�� ���©ÿå �D��� è æ>? ���Pø ÷3ý�� �!÷�ø ú©��÷�ø þ�ý�ù �ý��æ�@ ÷�þPø �©ÿ©û �ý�ø ú©û��Pø �©ú©ÿ �©þ©ûæ ; �©�Pø ù©�©ú ûPø û©û��Pø û���ÿ �V��ùæ�< ÷��Pø �©ù©ÿ ��ùPø ����þPø ÷�þ©þ ���ýÿ©þ©þ æ>= ÿ©ûPø¨�!÷�û ��÷�ø ù©û�÷�ø ÿ���ù �©û©ÿæ ? ý5÷�ø ����þ �©þPø ù©û��©ø ÷�ú©þ �©ú©úæ�@ ù�ý�ø û���� �©úPø ÷�þ©ùPø ��÷�ÿ ÷����æ ; ÷�ø û�÷�ÿ �©ø ù�ý�ùPø ÿ©û©ú ��ûæ�< ûPø ù©�©þ �Pø ý©ý��Pø ÿ©ú©ÿ �©ù��þ©þ æ>= �!÷�ø ÿ©û�÷ ÿPø ÿ�÷�ÿPø ÿ��©� ÿ©úæ ? ��ûPø ��ý�� ý�ø �©û©ÿPø û©��÷ ý�úæ�@ ���Pø ù©ú©� ûPø ��ý��Pø �©û©þ û�÷æ ; ûPø ù©ÿ�÷ �Pø ý�û©ûPø þ©ù©� �©ûâ�A�à©ìB8 æ�< ��ûPø ÿ©þ�ý ý�ø ú©���©ø ÿ©ù©þ ý©ýC -�í!ì�5kí!â �©þ©þ æ>= �©ùPø û���þ �V�©ø �©�©�Pø ÿ©�©ÿ �V�!÷å �©þ ��� è æ ? �©ùPø þ�÷�þ �!÷�ø ù©ù��Pø ù��V� ��ÿ��æ @ ÷�úPø û©ù©ù ��ùPø ý�þ��Pø �©�©ú ��û©þæ ; ��÷�ø ��ý�� ûPø ÿ©ÿ©ùPø �©ù©þ û©úæ�< ÷3ý�ø ý�ú�� ��ùPø ú�ý�ÿPø ù©û©ù ��ù©ûÿ©þ©þ æ>= ý�þPø ú©ù�� ��ý�ø �©ù��©ø ÿ�÷3ý ��ý©ýæ ? û©�Pø ý�þ�� �©úPø �©�©úPø ù©ú�� �©ú©ùæ @ �V���Pø ú©ú�÷ ÷©÷�ø û©ú©úPø û©ú©ÿ ÷�ÿ©ÿé��E�F� ���� å �G��� è ÿ©ú�ý�ø ÿ©�©û ��ú©ûPø ù©ù©úPø ÿ©ÿ©þ �Pø þ�ý��HJI$�Ùå �©þG��� è ý�ø ÷�û©�Pø þ�÷�ù �©ø û�ý�úPø¨��ù�ý�ø �©ú©ÿ �©þPø ÿ�ý5÷í ÞY�F nà �Sÿr�Sÿ T 7:9;74.1087C. ] 0o<\a¢fg9\587C.h9;_I543BfX_1. ] 9\0

Î\Ç

Page 70: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

9�_19\54p\365AfX523 ] .Y04.Y<>=«_Y<>040 � J =«< U 5�3Úµ�fi3652. W 36=�7C0 � ��3 ] < W fg9\543y7C[�3�fX523 ] .104.Y<>=�<\a`3�9 ] [©a U = ] 7C.Y<>=�y[X3B=).Y7oDX.1523 ] 740 W <>523/7C[g9;= Ì>Å#q <\a¢543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D@l U 3652.1360m74<�74[X3k5436f�_1. ] 9\0 �w <>5�9'5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36D»l U 3B5 F\� 02.1= ] 3��t3�´�=X<}�ö�y[�. ] ["543BfX_1. ] 9 ] <>=�7:9\.Y=X0�.Y740�7C<>f»D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0 � ��3DX3�jg=X3/.¾7C0 �:KB�g�¿¾��L�4£��C�É��¹ ¥�¾4� 9\0¹7C[X3�0 W 9\_1_Y36027¹5236fX_Y. ] 9k7C[g9�7t.Y0 E U .1_Y7º�y.¾7C[«74[X3�74<>f«DX< ]6U W 3B=�740an<>5k7C[X3©l U 365 F � w <\5�9;= U =X5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3BD�l U 365 F>� 02.1= ] 3©5236fX_Y. ] 9;0 W 9 F ] <>=�7:9;.1=�02< W 3©5236_13�c;9\=�7DX< ]6U W 36=�740 � �t3¹3�µ^fi3 ] 7¢< U 5`5236fX_Y. ] 9o0436_Y3 ] 7C<>5`�y.1_Y_\DX.Y543 ] 7S04< W 3º<\aV7C[X3B043ºl U 3652.13B0b74<�9m5236_13�c;9\=�7543BfX_1. ] 9 � � 3�D�3Bjg=X3¹7C[X3 �:KB�g�¿¾��É�4£��:�É��¹ ¥�¾4� an<>5b9\= U =X543BfX_1. ] 9;7436Dql U 365 F 9;0S74[X3¹0 W 9\_1_Y36027S5236fX_Y. ] 97C[X9;7 ] 9 U 04360)9�fX543 ] .102.1<>=�DX52<>f�_13B040%7C[g9;= Î#q � w <>5 E <\7C[´�.1=XD�0�<;a¶l U 3B54.13B0 � 3B04fi3 ] .h9\_Y_ FU =X5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3BD�l U 3652.1360 � ��3»3�µ^fi3 ] 7'�t3{�y.Y_1_y[g9�c>3{74<�7C<\_136549;7C3�04< W 3{_Y<>040©.1=�fX523 ] .104.Y<>=�.Y=<>52DX365t74<Z9�c><>.YD%04369\5 ] [X.Y=Xp�7C[�3�36=�7C.Y543 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � � 3 ] [X<V<>043�9�D�54<>f%.Y='fX543 ] .Y04.1<\= E 3�7É�t3B36=Å 9\=XD z}Å#q an<>5�9{l U 365 F 9\0Z< U 5�9 ]B] 3Bf�7:9 E _13'549\=Xp>3 � . � 3 � � 023�9\5 ] [X.1=Xp»74[X3%043B_13 ] 7C3BD³5236fX_Y. ] 9543�7C52.13Bc\360©9;7 W <>027Z<\=X3@_136020�5436_Y3Bc;9\=�7�DX< ]6U W 36=�7�an<>5�3�c>3B5 Fz}Å DX< ]6U W 36=�740«9\0 ] < W fg9\543BD�y.Y74[@043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp�74[X3k36=�7C.Y543k<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �� 3'DX3BjX=X3 ¾:�l¹Ç¹1�¿¾��ø¥ ���{�i�C�¿¾�¥1�}�'¨6¡����Ú¥ �:� 9\0�7C[X<>023'l U 3652.13B0�7C[g9;7 ] 9\=9 ] [X.13�c>3'7C[�3'fX543 ] .Y04.1<\=9 E <}c>3 z}Ŧq �y[X36= 04369\5 ] [X.Y=Xp@7C[X3Z<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=)an<>5/74[X3�7C<\f ¥ D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0 � . � 3 � � 7C[�3l U 365 F jX=XDX0'9�7«_Y3�9\087«<>=�3)543B_13�c\9;=�7©DX< ]6U W 36=�7©an<>5©3�c>3B5 F 7C36=·DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 � � 3)3Úµ ] _ U DX3] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�. W fX543 ] .1023�l U 3652.13B0/�y[X36=»��3ZfX543B0436=�7k7C[�3�9 E .1_Y.Y7 F <\a�9'5236fX_Y. ] 9©0436_Y3 ] 7C<>5/74<%fX. ] ´7C[�3�5236_13�c;9\=�7«5236fX_Y. ] 9;0�an<\5 U =�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3BDÙl U 3B54.Y360 �mE 3 ] 9 U 023{9�5236fX_Y. ] 9»�y.¾7C[ ¿ 3652<�5236_13�c;9\=�7DX< ]6U W 36=�740t.10ºfX52< E 9 E _ F 9\=©9 ]6] 36f�7C9 E _Y3 ] [X<>. ] 3yan<>5¹9�l U 3B5 F �y[X<>023/fX543 ] .Y04.1<\=©.Y0 E 36_Y<}� z}Ŧq.1=k7C[�3¹<\54.1p\.1=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � � 3�DX3�jg=X3 �C�É��¹ ¥�¾4�t�i�C�¿¾�¥1�}�t¨6¡g���Ú¥ �:� 9\0S7C[X<\043ºan<>5`�y[X. ] [�043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp7C[�3�043B_13 ] 7C3BD»5436f�_1. ] 9 ] 9 U 043B0k9«fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>=)_Y<>040�_136020�7C[X9\= Î#q <\ae74[X3�fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>=»9;727:9\.Y=X36D E�F04369\5 ] [�.1=Xp�7C[X3k<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �

�SÿT�`ÿT� â�d f�ûbÞXý ò a ß ñ Þ a ª ò a ß õ % a i ü ò d�a gJ =�74[X.10K043 ] 74.1<>= � ��3 ] < W fX9\543�7C[�3¶3Bظ3 ] 7C.¾c>36=�36040�<\ae7C[�3 J = Á U 3B5 F ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=@5C9;=X´�.1=Xp�a U = ]Ú½7C.Y<>=q.1_1_ U 02745C9;7436Dk.1= w .Yp U 543AË � Ë�9\=XD¶< U 5S5436f�_1. ] 9K0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=ka U = ] 7C.Y<>=¶.Y_1_ U 027C549;7C3BDk.1= w .1p U 543AË � ÎE�F c;9\5 F .1=Xp ­ 9\=XDMLman<\5�02[X<>527tl U 3652.1360t.1=©7436087t7C52.h9\_ z �y[X36=«��3/5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C3y7C[X3K7C<>f Ä;Å>Å D�< ]Ú½

Î Ë

Page 71: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

�N1�ëPO/5kë�ä Q"1�ìR1�7BíS8Ôí!ì�â TU-�ëPá ü ��í!ê�ã65ká�1 V+8ÔàWìÔí!ê�ã65ká�1�âTU-�ë�áS8�5kà©ë O ø ï á!à3î�í ß�; ß�< ß�= ß ? ßW@ � ì�5kä�A/8 â�7G1�ãkãkí!ì ã�1�ì�ä©í�ì ��"XPê$í!áS8Ôí!î � ��ù ��ú �©ÿ ��� ��û þ ��þ©þ V þ V þ V þ V�N1�ëPî�à�7 ��1�ë �ý �ý �ý ��ú ��ú ��ú ��ú V �©ÿ V ��� V ��ú VYÁë[ZJ-Pí�ìB3 �©þ©þPø$þPü �©ÿ Y � þ þ þ þ þ û©û þ V þ V þ V ��þ©þ V� à©ãkãkí�áS8�5kà©ë �©þ©þPø$þPü ý�ÿ Y � þ � ÷ ÿ �©þ ú©û �!÷ V þ V ��ú V ý�þ V�N1�ëPO/5kë�ä \U]^] ø^_ `Sa \[b _/c \[\ _/c _ ] _[_ dfe[g _hd^g b g _[_hgTU-�ë�áS8�5kà©ë _ ]^] ø^_ `Rc \[b _he \[\ _/c _ ] _ ] dfe[g _Pi[g b g _ ] gc ]^] ø^_ ` e \[j _/c \ a _/c b _[_ d[cfg _Pi[g b g _[_hg\ ø ] k _ \^\ _ \ _ ] _ \ a \ _[_ e j g i^g \ a^g _hg��í!ê�ã65ká�1 \ ø ]ml�\ kn\ \[] _he _[_ _hi \ c _ \ e^i[g j g \[\ g _ \ go í!ãkí!áS8�5kà©ë �Pø�þPü ù � � ú � � ÿ � ù�� ��ÿ V � V � V ù©� VTU-�ë�áS8�5kà©ë �©ø�þPü � � ÷ �ý ú ý �!÷ �©ù ��ý ÷3ý V ÿ V �©þ V ��ý V÷�ø�þPü � � ÿ ��� ��þ ��þ �V� �©ú ��� ÿ�÷ V ý V ��ù V ��� Våp1�èE��í!ê�ã65ká�1q8�í�î C -�í!ì�5kí�âVå û©û C -Pí�ì�5kí!âuè��í!ê�ã65ká�1 QnìÔí!á 5kâ�5kà©ë{ãkà©âÔâ V´à�r0ìÔí!ê�ã65ká�1�N1�ëPO/5kë�ä Q"1�ìR1�7BíS8Ôí!ì�â TU-�ëPá ü � ÿ Vns ê�ìÔí!á 5kâÔíTU-�ë�áS8�5kà©ë O ø ï á!à3î�í ß�; ß�< ß�= ß ? ßW@ � t ÿ V ��þ V u ��þ V C -�í!ì�5kí!âE8ÔàG��"XPê$í!áS8Ôí!î � � ú � ú � ��û�N1�ëPî�à�7 ��1�ë ý ù ÿ ý ÷ ú �©ÿ V ��û V ÷�ú V �©� VYÁë[ZJ-Pí�ìB3 �©þ©þPø$þPü �©ÿ Y � þ þ þ þ þ ��ý ��þ©þ V þ V þ V ��þ©þ V� à©ãkãkí�áS8�5kà©ë �©þ©þPø$þPü ý�ÿ Y � þ þ þ þ ú ��� ù©û V � V ù V ù©û V�N1�ëPO/5kë�ä �©þ©þPøk� Y � ú ÿ �V� ý � ú ÷�þ V �©þ V �©þ V �V� VTU-�ë�áS8�5kà©ë ��þ©þPøk� Y ÷ ÿ ú ��� ý � ÿ �©ù V �©þ V �©� V �V� V÷�þ©þPøk� Y ÿ ú ú �V� �V� ú � ÷�þ V �©þ V �©þ V �V� V�Pø�þ � � ù ý � � û ��þ ÿ�� V ��û V �©þ V ú V��í!ê�ã65ká�1 �Pø�þPü � � � ý ú � � ù ��� ú©ù V ��ú V ��ú V �V� Vo í!ãkí!áS8�5kà©ë �Pø�þPü ù � � þ þ þ þ � �©ú ��þ©þ V þ V þ V û�÷ VTU-�ë�áS8�5kà©ë �©ø�þPü � � ÷ ÷ � � � ��� ��ú ý�� V �!÷ V �!÷ V �©� V÷�ø�þPü � � ÿ ý � � � ��þ ��ÿ ú�÷ V �!÷ V �©� V �©� Våpï$èEv×ë�ì�í�êPã65ká21q8�í!î C -�í!ì�5kí!âVå ��ý á!à©ãkãkí!áS8�5kà©ëJê�ìÔí!á 5kâÔí C -�í!ì�5kí!âuèí Þ��! nà �SÿT�`ÿ r < W fg9\54.Y=Xpk5C9\=�´V.Y=Xp�a U = ] 7C.1<\=X0 U 04.Y=Xp�02[X<>587�l U 3B54.Y360¹<>=�74[X3 Ä O � syu à r Ä#"�Ç] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= Ô 5436f�_1. ] 9\0 E U .1_Y7t�y.Y7C[@7C<\f Ä;Å>Å DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 Õ

U W 36=�7C0Kan<>5y3�9 ] [)l U 365 F � Ô � 3¶9\_Y04<�f¸3B52an<>5 W 3BD�3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�740�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1=XpZ74[X3q74<>f z�Å>Å 9;=XDÎ\Å>Å DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0¹�y.Y74[«04. W .Y_h9\5A52360 U _Y740 � Õ�� 3K�y.1_1_�02[X<}��7C[g9;7t< U 5¹543BfX_1. ] 9k0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=©a U = ] 7C.Y<>=.10 ] < W fg9\5C9 E _13'.Y=�7C[X3�9 E .Y_1.¾7 F 74<"fX. ] ´�74[X3@3�µ^fi3 ] 7436D�5236fX_Y. ] 9)�y.Y7C[02< W 3 ] <>=�jgp U 5C9;74.1<>=�0<\ae74[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�549\=X´�.1=Xp�a U = ] 7C.1<\=�an<>5K543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D)l U 3B54.Y360 �¸E U 7�7C[g9;7�.Y7�04.Yp>=X.¾j ] 9\=�74_ F . W ½fX52<Âc\360�fX543 ] .102.1<>=�9\=XD�jg=XDX0K7C[X3q3�µ^fi3 ] 7C36D)5436f�_1. ] 9 W UX] [ W <>543 ] <>=X04.Y027436=�7C_ F 9\0 ] < W fg9\543BD�y.Y74[%7C[X3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=%549\=X´�.1=XpZa U = ] 7C.Y<>=%an<>5 U =X5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3BD�l U 3B54.Y360 �s 9 E _13qË � Î _Y.1087C0m7C[X3�543B0 U _¾7C0K<\aA543BfX_1. ] 9Z043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= E�F ] < U =�7C.1=�p©7C[�3�= U W�E 365K<\aAl U 3B54.Y360/9;=XD7C<��y[X. ] [%5236fX_Y. ] 9q<>5 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=©369 ] ['a U = ] 7C.1<\='DX.1523 ] 7C0�74[X3/l U 3B54.13B0 � �y[�36='7C[�3/fg9\549 W 3�7C3B540 �­ 9\=XDwL � c;9\5 F � s 9 E _Y3'Ë � Î Ô 9 Õ _1.Y027C0q7C[X3%52360 U _Y740¶an<>5 |>| 5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3BD�l U 3652.1360�an<\5¶�y[X. ] [���3[g9�c>3�5436_Y3Bc;9\= ] 3º¼ U D�p W 3B=�7C0 � s 9 E _Y3�Ë � Î Ô E Õ _Y.102740A7C[X3/52360 U _Y740�an<>5 Ç �qU =X543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=

Î>Î

Page 72: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

fX523 ] .Y043@l U 3652.13B0 ��z�Ì <\a��y[�. ] [Ù9\543%5236fX_Y. ] 9{f�543 ] .1023�l U 3B54.Y360 � J = E <\7C[�7:9 E _13B0 � ] <>_ U W =�0 z7C[�54< U p\[ Ç _Y.1027Ö7C[X3º=g9 W 3A<\aVa U = ] 7C.1<\=X0 � 7C[X3Ac;9\_ U 360`<\a^fg9\549 W 3B7C3B540 ­ 9\=XDxL � 9;=XDq74[X3ea U = ] 7C.Y<>=9 EXE 543BcV.19;7C.Y<>=X0 � w <>5�5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36D�l U 3B54.Y360 � ] <\_ U W =X0�Ë{74[X54< U p>[ | ] <>=�7:9;.1=�7C[�3%= U W�E 3B5Z<\al U 3652.13B0b74[g9;7S7C[X3¹543BfX_1. ] 9m043B_13 ] 7C<\5b0236=XD�0¢7C<K3�9 ] [¶<\a^7C[X3¹543BfX_1. ] 9\0 Ô �M� Õ 9\0b��36_Y_�9\0S7C[X3º<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= Ô È Õ { ] <>_ U W =X0 z}Å 7C[X52< U p>[ z}Ç ] <\=�7C9\.1=�74[X3@f¸3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3B0«<\a�l U 3652.13B0�74[g9;7©9\523DX.Y543 ] 7C3BD¶7C<K7C[X3¹3�µ^fi3 ] 7436D�543BfX_1. ] 9 Ô 52.1p>[�7 Õ � 0 W 9;_1_13B5`543BfX_1. ] 9 � _h9\52p>365S5236fX_Y. ] 9 � 9\=�D�7C[�3t<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � s [X3�R23Úµ^f¸3 ] 7C3BD�S Ô Ã Õ 52<Â�_Y.102740¹74[X3/= U W�E 365t<\a�¼ U DXp>3BD%l U 3652.1360�7C[g9;7��t3/��< U _YD3�µ^fi3 ] 7o7C[X3�5436f�_1. ] 9�0236_13 ] 74<>5�74<�DX.1523 ] 7t7C<�3�9 ] [%5236fX_Y. ] 9¶9\=XD©7C<¶74[X3/<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � .¾a`.Y7��36543¶f¸3B52an3 ] 7��y.¾7C[)523602f¸3 ] 7/74<©7C[�3�l U 3B54.13B0 U 0236D)74< E U .Y_1D�7C[X3q543BfX_1. ] 9\0 � w <>5 U =�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3BDl U 3652.13B0 � ] <\_ U W =X0�Ë 74[X54< U p>[ | ] <\=�7C9\.1=³7C[X3�= U W�E 365�<\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�f�543 ] .1023)l U 3652.13B0©7C[�3543BfX_1. ] 9o0236_13 ] 74<>5`043B=XDX0`7C<y3�9 ] [�<\a�74[X3º5436f�_1. ] 9\0`9\0I��36_Y_�9\0I74[X3º<>54.Yp>.1=g9;_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=I{ ] <>_ U W = z}Å] <\=�7C9\.1=�0t7C[X3�f¸3B5 ] 36=�7:9\p\360y<\a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�fX543 ] .Y043/l U 3B54.13B0o7C[g9�7m9\523�DX.Y543 ] 7C3BD'7C<¶74[X3/<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=k9\=�Dq74[X3º5436f�_1. ] 9\0I7C[X9;7 ] 9 U 023t9mfX523 ] .104.Y<>=q_1<>020`_136020`7C[g9\= Î#q { ] <>_ U W =X0 z>z 74[X54< U p>[zÂÄ ] <>=�7:9\.Y="74[X3Zfi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>360k<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=)f�543 ] .1023�l U 3B54.Y360�7C[g9�7k9\543ZD�.1543 ] 7436D»7C<@543BfX_1. ] 9\07C[X9;7 ] 9 U 023/9qfX543 ] .102.1<>=�_1<\040Aan54< WÓÎ#q 7C< z}Ŧq'� 9\=XD W <>523o7C[g9\= z}Ŧq � r <>_ U W = z}Ç ] <\=�7C9\.1=�07C[�3mf¸3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3y<\a z}Ì 5236fX_Y. ] 9�fX543 ] .1023yl U 3654.Y360e74[g9;7¹9\523mDX.1523 ] 7436DZ7C</74[X3m<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �s [X3�R23�µ^fi3 ] 7436D�S Ô Ã Õ 52<Â�!an<>5K74[X3 U =X543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D�l U 3654.Y360 ] <>=�7:9;.1=X0y7C[X3q= U W�E 365�<\ael U 3B54.13B07C[X9;7o��3/3�µ^fi3 ] 7m74<Zp><¶74<Z3�9 ] [%<\aS5236fX_Y. ] 9\0o9\=�D'7C[X3�<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= E 3 ] 9 U 043/7C[�3/543B0 U _¾7�y.1_Y_ ] 9 U 043�9 Î#q <>5m_Y36020KD�54<>f�.1=%fX523 ] .104.Y<>= �w <>5©74[X3 J = Á U 3B5 F ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=Ù549\=X´�.1=�p�a U = ] 7C.1<\= � c\9;5 F .1=Xp ­ an54< W z}Å>Å 7C<�Ë Å\Å DX<V360'=X<;704.Yp>=X.¾j ] 9\=�74_ F ] [g9\=Xp\3�3Bظ3 ] 74.Yc\36=X3B040 Ô ] < W fX9\543 J Ç ½ J Î Õ � � [X36='��3�043�7 ­ 7C< Ä;Å>Å Ô 74[X3�DX3�a¦9 U _Y7<\ao74[X3 J = Á U 365 F ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>="549\=X´�.1=Xp@a U = ] 7C.Y<>= Õ 9\=XD�.Y= ] 523�9\023©74[X3�c;9\_ U 3�<\ayL � 74[X3©5236fX_Y. ] 9043B_13 ] 7C<\5qD�.1543 ] 740 W <>523�l U 3652.1360k7C<%74[X3�5436f�_1. ] 9\0 � w <>5�7C[X3�543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D"l U 3652.13B0 � 7C[X3�DX3�a¦9 U _Y7J = Á U 3B5 F ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>="5C9\=�´V.Y=Xp�a U = ] 74.1<>= Ô ´�� Ä\Å>Å�� E � Å ��� Î Õ <>=X_ F DX.1523 ] 7C0 Ç\Ŧq <\aol U 3B54.Y360�74<7C[�3©5236fX_Y. ] 9;0 � �y[X. ] [�.10k=X<\7q< U 5 ] [�<>. ] 3 � � [�36=���3�7 U =X3�7C[X3�fg9\549 W 3B7C3B540q9\0q´�� Ä;Å>Å 9;=XDE � z>� 74[X3�a U = ] 7C.1<\=�DX.Y543 ] 7C0 Ì\|¦q <\a¢l U 3652.1360m74<�74[X3q5436f�_1. ] 9\0 �

Î\Æ

Page 73: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

1q8×õ Qnì�í�á 5kâ�5kà©ëJà�r�� í�êPã65ká21q8�í!îzZJ-�í!ì�5kí!âVå{V,èî�à3á!â � ìR1�ë�îPà�7 Y � Y ÷ Y ÿ � � � ���þ ÷�ùPü ý ÷�þPü ÷ å}| �ý�ü � è ÷3ý�ü ý å!| �Pü � è ÷�ùPü � å}| �©ü � è ÷3ý�ü � å!| �Pü � è ÷�ùPü ÷ å}| þPü ù è ÷�ùPü � å!| �©ü ú è�©þ ÷©÷�ü ù �©úPü¨� å}| ��ûPü ú è ÷��Pü � å!| �Pü ý è ÷��Pü � å}| �Pü ÷ è ÷��Pü û å!| ÷�ü ÷ è ÷©÷�ü ÷ å}| �©ü þ è ÷©÷�ü � å!| �©ü ÷ è�©þ ÷�þPü ý �©�Pü ÷ å}| �©þPü ÷ è �©ûPü � å!| �Pü ÷ è �©ûPü ÷ å}| �Pü þ è �©ûPü¨� å!| ÷�ü þ è ÷�þPü � å}| �©ü¨� è ÷�þPü � å!| �©ü � è��þ©þ ���©ü¨� ���Pü û å}| ���Pü¨� è �©ûPü ÷ å!| ÿPü ú è �©ûPü ÿ å}| ÿPü ÿ è �©ûPü � å!| úPü¨� è �©þPü ÿ å}| �Pü � è �©þPü ÿ å!| �Pü¨� è�©þ©þ �©ÿPü¨� ��ùPü ý å}| �©ÿPü � è ���Pü þ å!| ùPü ÷ è ���Pü þ å}| ùPü ÷ è �©�Pü û�~�� b�l i[� ��÷�ü ù å}| �Pü ù è ��÷�ü � å!| �Pü � èåp1�è û©û ��í!ê�ã65ká�1q8�í�î C -�í!ì�5kí�â1q8×õ QnìÔí!á 5kâ�5kà©ëJà�r"v×ë�ì�í!ê�ã65ká�1q8Ôí!îzZJ-�í!ì�5kí�âVå{V,èî�à3á!â � ìR1�ë�îPà�7 Y � Y ÷ Y ÿ � � � ���þ �©ûPü ù ��÷�ü ú å}| �©ùPü � è �©þPü þ å!| ��÷�ü ú è �©ûPü ÷ å}| �©úPü¨� è �©þPü þ å!| ��÷�ü ú è ���Pü ú å}| ��ÿPü ú è �©ÿPü û�~�� jml df��©þ �©úPü ù ���Pü ý å}| �©ÿPü ú è ��ý�ü � å!| �©úPü¨� è �©úPü ú å}| ��ý�ü ý è ��ý�ü � å!| �©ÿPü ù è �©�Pü � å}| ���Pü � è ��÷�ü ÷�~��Si l j ��©þ ���Pü ÷ �©�Pü � å}| ���Pü¨� è ��÷�ü û å!| �©ÿPü ÷ è ��÷�ü � å}| ��ý�ü � è ��÷�ü û å!| �©ÿPü ÷ è �©þPü ù å}| ý�ü ù è ���©ü û�~���c l df���þ©þ �©úPü ÷ ��ÿPü þ å}| ÷��Pü¨� è ��úPü û å!| �©ÿPü û è ��úPü � å}| �©ùPü ý è ��úPü û å!| �©ÿPü û è �©�Pü ù å}| ���Pü ú è ���Pü ÿ�~���_ ]ml b ��©þ©þ ���©ü¨� ��þPü ÷ å}| ÿ©þPü ÿ è �V�©ü ý å!| ÷©÷�ü ý è �V�©ü¨� å}| ÷3ý�ü � è �V�©ü ý å!| ÷©÷�ü ý è �ý�ü¨� å}| ��ûPü � è ��ùPü¨�G~���_:c l e^�åpï$è ÿ©þ v×ëPìÔí!ê�ã65ká�1q8Ôí!î C -�í!ì�5kí!âí Þ��! nà �SÿT�Iÿ ÃeØÖ3 ] 7C.¾c>3B=X36020�<\aºD�.Yظ36543B=�7�5C9\=�´V.Y=Xp«a U = ] 7C.Y<>=X0 U 04.1=�p'04[X<\527kl U 3652.13B0/<>={7C[�3 ÄO � syu à r Ä#"�Ç ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= Ô 543BfX_1. ] 9\0 E U .1_¾7o�y.Y74[�74<>f Ä\Å>Å DX< ]6U W 36=�740 Õ

w <>5k7C[X3�543BfX_1. ] 9@0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�a U = ] 7C.Y<>= � ­ � Ä p>3�7C0 E 3�747C3B5¶52360 U _Y7C0q7C[g9;= ­ � z 9\=XD ­ � ËÔ ] < W fg9\543m74[X3Ka U = ] 74.1<>=X0 u Ç ½ u Î Õ � � [X36=��t3�DX3 ] 54369\043�74[X3yc\9;_ U 3y<\aDL � 7C[�3�5236fX_Y. ] 9k043B_13 ] 7C<\5DX.Y543 ] 7C0 W <>543�l U 3B54.Y360o7C<Z74[X3k5436f�_1. ] 9\0 � w <\5o´�� Ä 9\=�D E � Å � Ä^� 7C[X3�a U = ] 7C.Y<>=%DX.1523 ] 7C0 Ì>̦q <\al U 3652.13B0y74<�74[X3k543BfX_1. ] 9\0 �+ W <>=Xp@7C[�3©a U = ] 7C.Y<>=X0¶_Y.1087C36D .1= s 9 E _13�Ë � Î^� <\=X_ F 02.¾µ a U = ] 7C.1<\=X0 �2�\�i£V��� � J Ç�� J Ë � J Î^� u z>�9\=XD u Ä DX.1523 ] 7 W <\543k7C[g9\= Ì>Ŧq <\aA5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36D�l U 3652.1360�7C<«74[X3¶5236fX_Y. ] 9;0 � � 3 ] < W fg9\523�7C[�3fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>=�<\am7C[�36043@02.¾µ�a U = ] 74.1<>=�0�.1= s 9 E _Y3'Ë � Æ � s [X3'jg54087 ] <>_ U W =�_1.Y027C0q7C[X3%= U W¶E 3B5�<\aDX< ]6U W 36=�740'9;7©�y[X. ] [·��3{fX52360236=�7'7C[�3)fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>= � r <>_ U W = Ä _1.Y02740�74[X3)fX523 ] .104.Y<>=Ù�y[�36=9\_Y_¹l U 3B54.Y360¶p\<)7C<�7C[X3©<>54.Yp>.1=g9;_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � . � 3 � � �y[g9;7¶f¸3B5 ] 36=�7Z<\ao74[X3«74<>f ® DX< ]6U W 3B=�740.10@5236_13�c;9\=�7��y[X3B=!023�9\5 ] [X.1=Xp³7C[X3 <>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � r <\_ U W =X0 Ç 74[X54< U p>[ Ì _1.Y027@7C[�3543B0 U _¾7C0 U 02.1=Xpy5C9;=XDX< W 0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=q9\=�D�369 ] [¶549\=X´�.1=Xpma U = ] 7C.Y<>= � s [X3¹= U W�E 36540b.1=�fX9\543B=�74[X360236004[�<Â� 74[X3 fX543 ] .102.1<>=�fi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3�D�.Yظ36543B= ] 3�9\0 ] < W fg9\5236D��y.Y74[�023�9\5 ] [X.1=Xp³7C[X3 <>52.1p>.Y=g9\_] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � s 9 E _Y3�Ë � Æ Ô 9 Õ _1.1087C0y7C[X3�543B0 U _¾7C0�an<\5�5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36D�l U 3652.1360 � 9\=�D s 9 E _13�Ë � Æ Ô E Õ _1.Y027C07C[�3�543B0 U _¾7C0�an<>5 U =X5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36D»l U 3B54.Y360 � u 36f�_1. ] 9;7C3BD{l U 3652.13B0�fX54<VD UX] 3 W UX] [ E 3B727C365�52360 U _Y7407C[X9\= U =X5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3BD)l U 3652.13B0 �ÖE 3 ] 9 U 023¶7C[X3B.15K7C<>f�DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0�9;543q027C<\5436D».Y={9;7�_1369\027�<>=X3�<\a7C[�3q5236fX_Y. ] 9\0 �

Î �

Page 74: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

J 7y.10m=�<\7K0 U 52fX54.Y04.1=�p�7C[g9;7K549\=XDX< W 043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=@f¸3B52an<>5 W 0mfi<^<\54_ F\��E 3 ] 9 U 043q.Y7o[g9\0y[X.1p\[%fX54< E ½9 E .Y_1.¾7 F <\a®fX. ] ´�.Y=Xp�9�5236fX_Y. ] 9��y.¾7C[%an3B��5236_Y3Bc;9\=�7KDX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 � w <>5 U =X5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3BD�l U 3B54.13B0 � .Y7] 9 U 043B0t9�fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>=�f¸3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3y_Y<>040º5C9;=Xp>.1=�p/an54< WöÇ>̦q 74< Î\Ŧq 9;0 ] < W fg9\543BDZ�y.Y7C[�023�9\5 ] [ ½.1=�pq74[X3�<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � r � w <\5¹5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3BD«l U 3652.13B0 � .Y7 ] 9 U 04360o9�fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>=©_Y<>040¹5C9;=Xp>.1=�pan54< Wôz � q 7C< Ä>Î#q �w <>5®74[X3o<\74[X365ejXc\3ma U = ] 74.1<>=�0e.1= s 9 E _Y3oË � Æ�� �y[X3B=���3m3�µ�9 W .1=X3�7C[X3mfX523 ] .104.Y<>=�an<>5e5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3BDl U 3652.13B0 Ô s 9 E _13«Ë � Æ Ô 9 Õ2Õ � 9\_Y_¹74[X36023%a U = ] 74.1<>=�0Z9\543'9 ]6] 36f�7C9 E _13 � 04.1= ] 3«74[X3%fX543 ] .Y04.1<\=�DX54<\fX0_13B040Z7C[X9\= Ì � � q � H <}��3Bc>3B5 � �y[X3B=Ù��3�3Úµ�9 W .Y=X3'7C[�3�fX523 ] .104.Y<>=�an<>5 U =X5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36Dl U 3B54.13B0Ô s 9 E _Y3ºË � Æ Ô E Õ2Õ � 7C[X3¹fX543 ] .Y04.1<\=qD�.Yظ36543B= ] 3¹.10S02.1p>=X.¾j ] 9;=�7 � R 04.Y=Xp J = Á U 365 F ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=q549\=X´�.1=�pa U = ] 7C.Y<>= ó � �y[X36523º��3º043�7 ­ � Ä\Å\Å 9\=XD�L}� z>� 74[X3ºfX543 ] .102.1<>=k_Y<>0402360`<\a U =X5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36Dkl U 3B54.13B05C9;=Xp>3�an52< W Ä Ë � Ʀq 7C<�Ë>Ë ��� q � � 3tp>3�7e< U 5 E 3B027A52360 U _Y7 U 04.Y=Xp�< U 5®543BfX_1. ] 9K0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�a U = ] 7C.Y<>=ñ � �y.Y74[ ­ � Ä 9;=XD�L�� Å � Ä � s [X3ZfX523 ] .Y04.Y<>=»<\aA7C[�3Z5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3BD{l U 3652.13B0�DX54<>f�0�_136020�7C[X9\=Ç � Ä#q <;ai74[X3m<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 9;=XD�.10 E 3B727C365e�y[�36=�an3B��365ºDX< ]6U W 36=�7C0¹9\523o543�7 U 52=X36D � s [X3fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>='_1<\04043B0t<\a`74[X3 U =�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3BD«l U 3B54.13B0o5C9;=Xp>3�an52< W Ë�� ̦q 7C< z ËY� Î#q � w <>5º7C[X3K7C<>f Ç>ÅDX< ]6U W 36=�740 � 7C[�3qf�543 ] .102.1<>=@_1<\04043B0�<;a U =�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3BD@l U 3654.Y360y5C9;=Xp>3�an54< W Ë�� ̦q 7C< | � Ʀq �J =»7C[X3¶3�µ^f¸3B54. W 3B=�740�fX543B043B=�7436D�.1= T 3 ] 74.1<>="Ë � Ç � Ë%9\=XD T 3 ] 7C.Y<>=»Ë � Ç � Î^� 7C[�3Z5436f�_1. ] 9«043B_13 ] 7C<\5U 02360A7C[X3t5436f�_1. ] 9�5C9;=X´�.1=Xp/a U = ] 7C.Y<>=��y.Y74[ ­ � Ä 9\=XD�L}� Å � ÄV�>E 3 ] 9 U 043y.Y7®0436=�DX0¹9\fXfX52<>fX54.19;7C3l U 3652.13B0q74<�5236fX_Y. ] 9\0/�y.Y74[�9;=�9 ]B] 3Bf�7:9 E _13�fX543 ] .Y04.1<\= _Y<>040�<;am9;7 W <>027 | � Ʀq an<>5/7C[X3Z74<>f Ç>ÅDX< ]6U W 36=�740K.Y=%7C[X.Y0o7C36087�0 U .Y7 �

�SÿT�`ÿr� é�¼ à i ü ònï à a à�gQgM© ò ü ú·ñ à�û! ò_i Þ�ü}à`s [ %bà�ý ò à�gs [X.Y0q023 ] 7C.1<\=�3�c\9;_ U 9;74360q< U 5�fX52<>fi<>043BD�543BfX_1. ] 9%043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>="a U = ] 74.1<>=»an<>5k5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36D"l U 3B54.13B0<>= 9'�y.1DX3B5�5C9\=�p>3Z<\a�l U 3654.Y360q9\=XD ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0 � w <>5�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3BD»l U 3652.1360 � �t3��o9;=�7k74<'7C36087�y[X3�7C[X3B5k74[X3Z543BfX_1. ] 9«0236_Y3 ] 74<>5�DX.Y543 ] 7C0 W <>027/<\aº7C[X3 W 7C<@9\=»3Úµ^f¸3 ] 7C3BD�5236fX_Y. ] 9 � N <\7C3Z.¾7/.Y0fi<>0402. E _Y3tan<>5A9�543BfX_1. ] 9�0 W 9;_1_13B5¢74[g9\=Z7C[X3m3Úµ^f¸3 ] 7C3BD«<>=�3o7C< ] <\=�7C9\.1=�9;_1_^74<>f�DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0ean<\5A9p>.¾c>36=¶l U 365 F\� 04.Y= ] 3�7C[X3¹7C<>f�DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0e<;ag<\7C[�365®l U 3B54.Y360 ] < U _YD¶.1= ] _ U DX3�74[X3�74<>f¶DX< ]6U W 3B=�740

Î\Ì

Page 75: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

ZJ-�í!ì�3 é�à©ê �N��í!ìR1�ä©í���-P7 ü à�r�ZJ-�í!ì�5kí!âE8ÔàD��í!ê�ã65ká�1 V+8�àG��í!ê�ã65ká�1o 56�!í é43�ê�í ë ß�; ßW< ß�= ß ? ßW@ � ì�5kä�A�8 â�7G1�ãkãkí!ì ã�1�ì�ä©í�ì ���X�ê�í!áS8�í�î ���©ü ú ��úPü ú ���©ü ÷ �©þPü ú ��ùPü ù þ�©þ ��úPü þ �V�©ü ú ���Pü � ���Pü � ��÷�ü ú �©þPü ÷ ÿ©�Pü ý V ÷�ü � V �©�Pü ú V �©þPü ú V��þ©þ �ý�ü � ���Pü þ ��ÿPü ù ��ÿPü � ��÷�ü þ ���Pü ù ÿ©ùPü ÷ V ÿPü û V ���©ü ù V ���Pü û V� ��� â�A�à©ìB8 �©þ©þ �©þPü þ ���Pü � �!÷�ü � �ý�ü þ ���©ü þ ���Pü ú ÿ©ûPü ù V ùPü¨� V ��ùPü ÷ V ���Pü ý Vÿ©þ©þ �©ÿPü þ �!÷�ü ÷ ��ÿPü ù ��ùPü ú ��ÿPü ú ûPü ú ú©ÿPü¨� V ���Pü ý V ���Pü ÿ V ûPü ý V�N��í ü ��ûPü ÿ ���Pü þ �!÷�ü ù ��úPü þ ���©ü � �!÷�ü � ÿ©ûPü þ V ý�ü ý V ��ùPü û V �!÷�ü ÷ V��þ©þ ��ÿPü ù ���Pü ÷ ���Pü � ���Pü � �©ÿPü ù �ý�ü ú ÿ©�Pü ý V ÿPü ù V ���Pü ú V �ý�ü ù V� ��� ãkà©ë�ä �©þ©þ ��ùPü þ �ý�ü ÷ ���Pü ú �!÷�ü ÷ �©ùPü � ùPü ÷ ÿ�ý�ü þ V ùPü ÿ V �©úPü þ V ùPü ÿ Vÿ©þ©þ ���©ü ù �ý�ü ú �!÷�ü þ ��ÿPü þ ��÷�ü þ úPü ú ú©�Pü ÷ V ��þPü ý V �©þPü � V úPü ý V�N��í ü ��ùPü ÿ ��úPü¨� ���Pü � �!÷�ü � �©úPü þ ��þPü û ÿ�ý�ü ÷ V ùPü � V ���Pü � V �V�©ü þ V��þ©þ ��ÿPü ú �!÷�ü � ���Pü ù ��ÿPü ù �©þPü � �©þPü ÷ ÿ�÷�ü � V ÷�ü � V ���©ü þ V �©þPü ú V�©þG��� â�A�à©ìB8 �©þ©þ ��ÿPü ÷ ���Pü � ���Pü þ ��ÿPü ÷ ��÷�ü ú ��ùPü ÷ ÿ©úPü ÿ V ÷�ü � V �©þPü ú V ��ùPü ú Vÿ©þ©þ ��ùPü � �!÷�ü ÷ ���Pü � ��úPü þ �©ÿPü ù ���Pü ÷ ú�÷�ü � V ÷�ü � V ��ûPü þ V ���Pü ÿ V�N��í ü ��úPü ÷ ���Pü û ���Pü � ��ÿPü ý ���Pü ÿ �ý�ü¨� ÿ©ùPü � V ÷�ü � V �©þPü � V �ý�ü � Ví ÞY�F nà �Sÿ ¸ÿ u 3BfX_1. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%an<>5m543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D@l U 3652.13B0

an<>5q7C[X.Y0¶l U 365 F � +�_¾7C[X< U p>[���3 U 023 Ä>Î\Å l U 3B54.Y360�7C< E U .1_YD�5236fX_Y. ] 9;0 � ��3'<>=X_ F fX543B0436=�7�7C[�3543B0 U _¾7C0man<>5 |>| 5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36D@l U 3B54.13B0m�y[X. ] [�[g9�c>3q543B_13Bc;9\= ] 3t¼ U DXp W 36=�7yjg_Y360y.1='74[X.10y043 ] 74.1<>= �

õ ò a s ò a ß�ü ú à é ÷ ûAà i ü}à`s ñ à` ¦à ï Þ a ü ñ à�û! ò_i Þs [X.Y0®043 ] 74.1<>= W 3�9\0 U 543B0®7C[�3m9 E .Y_1.Y7 F <\ag7C[X3t5436f�_1. ] 9�0236_13 ] 74<>5¢74</fX. ] ´k7C[�3o3�µ^fi3 ] 7436D�543BfX_1. ] 9 E�F] < U =�7C.1=�p�7C[�3�= U W�E 365¹<\a`l U 3B54.13B0�74[g9;7t9\543�DX.1523 ] 7436D�7C<¶D�.Yظ36543B=�7o543BfX_1. ] 9\0¹9\=�D«7C[X3K<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � 9\0Z04[�<Â�y=.Y= s 9 E _13'Ë ���^� J = s 9 E _13«Ë � � � ] <>_ U W =�0 z 9\=XD Ä .Y=XDX. ] 9;7C3�7C[X3%02. ¿ 3<\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=)9\=�D�7C[�3�7 F f¸3¶<\aAl U 3652.13B0���3 U 043�.1=�< U 5�3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�740 � r <>_ U W = Ç .1=XD�. ] 9�7C3607C[�3'= U W�E 365¶<;am7C<>f�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0�an<\5¶3�9 ] [�l U 365 F � r <>_ U W =�0¶Ë)74[X54< U p>[ | <\=�7C[X3«54<}�Ê<\aR4îµ^f¸3 ] 7436D�S»_Y.1027k74[X3©= U W¶E 3B5¶<\a¢¼ U DXp>36D�l U 3654.Y360q7C[g9;7¶9\523 U 0236D�74< E U .Y_1D�9�5236fX_Y. ] 9 �¢E U 7=X<\7 U 0436D .1="9%0 W 9\_Y_13B5�<>=X3 � r <>_ U W =�0�Ë'7C[X52< U p>[ | <>="<\7C[�365�54<}�y0k_1.Y027/74[X3�7C[�3�= U W¶E 3B5<\a�l U 3654.Y360�7C[X3�543BfX_1. ] 9"0436_Y3 ] 7C<>5�043B=XDX0©74<�369 ] [·<\a�7C[X3�543BfX_1. ] 9\0�9\0��t3B_1_K9\0�7C[X3�<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � r <>_ U W =�0 z�Å 74[X54< U p>[ z}Ä ] <>=�7:9\.Y=�74[X3Kf¸3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3B0t<\a�¼ U DXp>3BD©l U 3B54.Y360º7C[g9;7¹7C[�3043B_13 ] 7C<\5�DX.Y543 ] 7C0K7C<�7C[X3�3�µ^fi3 ] 7436D»5236fX_Y. ] 9;0 Ô 54.Yp>[�7 Õ � 0 W 9\_Y_13B5m5436f�_1. ] 9\0 � 9\=�D)_h9;54p>3B5K5236fX_Y. ] 9\0 �r <>_ U W = z}Ç ] <>=�7:9\.Y=X0�74[X3/fi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3/<\aSl U 3B54.13B0t7C[X9;7t74[X3/043B_13 ] 7C<\5tDX.Y543 ] 7C0t74<¶7C[�3�<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= Ô rmÕ �w <>5y04[X<\527�l U 3654.Y360�<>=�74[X3 Ä O �] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � <\=�7C[�3¶9�c>3B5C9\p\3 � < U 5�5236fX_Y. ] 9�0236_Y3 ] 74<>5�D�.1543 ] 740Ì�Î � Ʀq Ô Î\| � Ŧq�" �^� � qm"�z}Ì � |¦q Õ <\a^543BfX_1. ] 9;7436Dkl U 3652.13B0b74<K74[X3º5436f�_1. ] 9\0 � 9\=XD Æ>Æ � � q <;a�l U 3B54.13B0

Î\|

Page 76: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

7C<q7C[X3�3�µ^fi3 ] 7436D%5236fX_Y. ] 9k<>5�9�5236fX_Y. ] 9k0 W 9\_Y_1365A74[g9\=©��3�3Úµ^f¸3 ] 7 � J = ] 54369\04.Y=Xp¶7C[�3�= U W�E 365¹<\a543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D'D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0m.1= ] 54369\043B0o7C[X3/9 ]6]BU 5C9 ] F <\aS5236fX_Y. ] 9�0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= ��E 3 ] 9 U 043/74[X3�543BfX_1. ] 9\0] <\=�7C9\.1= W <>523¶5236_13�c;9\=�7�DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0�an<>5/543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D{l U 3B54.Y360 � w <>5�3�µ�9 W fX_13 � U 02.1=Xp«74[X3¶74<>fÎ\Å>Å DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0�an<>5�369 ] [{l U 3B5 F 74< E U .1_1D�543BfX_1. ] 9\0 � 74[X3¶5236fX_Y. ] 9©043B_13 ] 7C<\5�DX.Y543 ] 7C0 |>Å � Ǧq <\al U 3652.13B0�7C<�7C[X3�5236fX_Y. ] 9\0�<\=)7C[X3¶9�c>36549\p>3 � �y[X.1_Y3 U 04.1=�p©7C<\f z}Å>Å DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0/D�.1543 ] 740 Ì>Æ � ztq<\a¢l U 3652.1360y7C<Z74[X3k5436f�_1. ] 9\0m<>=%7C[�3�9�c\365C9;p>3 �w <>5/_Y<>=Xp'l U 3B54.13B0k<>={7C[X3 Ä O ��] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � <>={7C[X3�9�c\365C9;p>3 � < U 5�5436f�_1. ] 9'043B_13 ] 7C<>5�D�.1543 ] 740Ì>| � Ŧq Ô Î �^� Ë q�"�Ì � Ç#qm"kÄ\Ç � Ǧq Õ <\a^543BfX_1. ] 9;7436Dkl U 3652.13B0b74<K74[X3º5436f�_1. ] 9\0 � 9\=XD Æ�Î � � q <;a�l U 3B54.13B07C<q7C[X3�3�µ^fi3 ] 7436D%5236fX_Y. ] 9k<>5�9�5236fX_Y. ] 9k0 W 9\_Y_1365A74[g9\=©��3�3Úµ^f¸3 ] 7 � J = ] 54369\04.Y=Xp¶7C[�3�= U W�E 365¹<\a543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D'D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0y9\_Y04<Z.1= ] 54369\043B0o7C[X3k9 ]6]6U 5C9 ] F <\ab543BfX_1. ] 9¶0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � 9\0tan<\5t7C[X3�02[X<>587l U 3652.13B0 � w <\5�3ÚµX9 W fX_Y3 � U 04.Y=Xp©74[X3�74<>f Î;Å>Å DX< ]6U W 3B=�740�an<>5K3�9 ] [)l U 365 F 7C< E U .Y_1D)5236fX_Y. ] 9\0 �7C[�3K5236fX_Y. ] 9/0436_Y3 ] 7C<>5ADX.Y543 ] 7C0 |\Ç � Ç#q <\a¸l U 3652.1360A74<k74[X3m543BfX_1. ] 9\0A<\=�74[X3K9�c>36549\p>3 � �y[�.1_13 U 04.Y=Xp7C[�3k74<>f z}Å>Å DX< ]6U W 36=�740�DX.Y543 ] 7C0 Ì>Ä � Ä$q <\a¢l U 3654.Y360m7C<Z74[X3k5436f�_1. ] 9\0m<>=@7C[X3q9�c>3B5C9\p\3 �w <>5t02[X<>587ol U 3652.13B0m<>=«7C[�3 Ä\Å O �·] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � <>=©7C[X3�9�c\365C9;p>3 � < U 5o543BfX_1. ] 9q0436_Y3 ] 7C<>5oD�.1543 ] 740Ì�Ä � � q Ô Î\Ì � Ǧq�" Ë � Ä$qm"kÄ\Å � Ä#q Õ <\a^543BfX_1. ] 9;7436Dkl U 3652.13B0b74<K74[X3º5436f�_1. ] 9\0 � 9\=XD Æ�Ä � Î#q <;a�l U 3B54.13B07C<%74[X3Z3�µ^fi3 ] 7436D�5436f�_1. ] 9'<>5k9%543BfX_1. ] 9'0 W 9\_Y_1365K7C[g9;="��3�3�µ^fi3 ] 7 � J = ] 523�9\02.1=Xp%7C[�3�= U W¶E 3B5<\a¹543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D»DX< ]6U W 3B=�740�.1= ] 54369\043B0k74[X3�9 ]B]6U 549 ] F <;a�5236fX_Y. ] 9«043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 9\0k9\p>9\.1=X087�74[X3 ÄO �ö] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � w <>5�3�µ�9 W fX_13 � U 04.Y=Xp)74[X3'7C<>f Î\Å>Å DX< ]6U W 36=�740¶an<>5�369 ] [�l U 365 F 7C< E U .1_YD543BfX_1. ] 9\0 � 7C[�3Z5436f�_1. ] 9'043B_13 ] 7C<>5�D�.1543 ] 740 Ì � � Î#q <;atl U 3B54.13B0/7C<%7C[�3Z5436f�_1. ] 9\0/<>=»74[X3�9�c>36549\p>3 ��y[X.Y_13 U 02.1=Xp�74<>f z}Å>Å DX< ]6U W 3B=�740ºDX.1523 ] 740 � | � Ë q <;a¸l U 3B54.Y360A7C</74[X3y5436f�_1. ] 9\0e<>=Z74[X3y9�c>36549\p>3 �

Ýqý�à i�ò g ò d�aÓd c�ñ àVû! òji Þ î à` ¦à i ü ò d�a ï à�ýOgQ%!gZü ú à å ý ò ß ò a Þ� ând j nà i ü ò d�aT .Y= ] 3�7C[X3�543BfX_1. ] 9@043B_13 ] 7C<>5qDX.Y543 ] 7C0�9@an3��Êl U 3652.1360k7C<)9�5236fX_Y. ] 9@74[g9;7�.10k0 W 9\_1_Y365/74[g9\=�3Úµ ½fi3 ] 7436D � �t3 ] < W fg9\523K74[X3�3�ØÖ3 ] 74.Yc>3B=X36020m<\a`3Úµ�3 ]6U 74.1=Xp�l U 3652.1360o9\p�9\.Y=X027¹543BfX_1. ] 9\0º<>5º7C[�3�<>52.1p ½.1=X9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=Ù0236_Y3 ] 7436D E�F 7C[X3�5436f�_1. ] 9�0236_13 ] 74<>5©�y.¾7C[�9;p�9\.1=�027�7C[X3�<>54.Yp>.1=g9;_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �s 9 E _13�Ë � Ì ] < W fg9\543B0q74[X3©9}c\36549\p>3�fX543 ] .102.1<>=�<\ao5236fX_Y. ] 9@0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�<}c>365 Î 7436087�7454.h9;_10/�y.Y74[04369\5 ] [�.1=Xp¶74[X3�<\54.1p\.1=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�an<\5�02[X<>527tl U 3652.1360�<>=«74[X3 Ä O �³] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � _1<>=�p�l U 3B54.13B0

Æ>Å

Page 77: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

(f6 �.251�/3YM7Yp;�b� `�;�/37 ;�25YpN h ?�;�4 t m ?×;�4 g m�m ?×;�4�j$m�m ?�;�4 w m�mg m l | h t l�x0h i ' s m h y * l | h mL' s m h x * l | h l ' � m h t * l�x h i ' s m h y *j$m l�t0hkw l�t0h mL' s5g�h j�* l�t0h mL' s5g�hpg * l�t0h t ' s m h l * l j h i ' s�g�h t *t m t�i0h x t�i0h mL' s5g�h w * t�i0hMg ' s5g�h t * t�i0h l ' s m h | * t�i h jL' s m h i *g m�m t m h y j i0h i ' s j h | * t m hMg ' s j h m�* t m hpg ' s j hMg *j$m�m j l h | j l h m ' sut0h m�* j l�h m�' sut0h m�*w m�m gPx0hkw g�x h m�' sut0hMg *'�(�*W7>0;�26 ]�^ 1325Yp1P7,;�bL6>01Àj�����/3;�KMKp1P/©65Yp;�b(f6 �.251�/3YM7Yp;�b� `�;�/37 ;�25YpN h ?×;�4 g m�m ?×;�4�j$m�m ?�;�4 w m�mg m w�x0h t w�x0hMg ' s m h l * w�x0h l ' � m hMg * w$x h jL' s m h j�*j$m w$l h x w$l h j�' s m h | * w$l h t ' s m h x * wfl�hpg ' s m h i *t m w0g�h | w0g�h t ' s m h y * w0g�hMg ' s�g�hMg * w�g�h jL' s�g�h m�*g m�m l�g�hkw l�g�hMg ' s5g�hpg * l�g�h m ' s�g�h j�* l g�h m�' s�g�hMg *j$m�m t�l hMg t�t0h l ' s j hMg * t�t h x ' s�g�h x *w m�m j�j h i j�j h l ' s j h l *')U�*WKp;�b0N ]�^ 1325Yp1P7,;�bL6>01Àj����S/�;�KMKM1�/©65Yp;�b($6 �.251�/3YM7Yp;�b� `�;�/37 ;�2YMN h ?×;�4 g m�m ?×;�4�j$m�m ?�;�4 w m�mg m gPw�hkw gPw0h w ' s5g�h j�* gPw0h l ' s5g�h j�* gPw0h w ' s m h t *j�m gPw�h m gPw0h m ' s m h t * gPw0h m\' s m h w * gPw0h m�' � m h m�*t m g3l h m g3l�h m�' � m h m�* g3l�h m\' s m hpg * g3l�h m�' � m h j�*g m�m g�g�hkw g�g�h l ' s m h i * g�g�h w ' s m h x * g�g�h w ' s m h t *j$m�m i0h y i h | ' s m h i * i h | ' s m hpg *w m�m | hkw | h l ' s m h y *')/�*,7>0;�2�6 ]�^ 1325YM1�7,;�bL6> 1Àj$my����/3;�KMKp1P/©6YM;�b

í Þ��! nà �Sÿ»�Iÿ ÃAظ3 ] 7C.¾c>36=�36040�<\ae5236fX_Y. ] 9Z0236_13 ] 74.1<>=�an<>5y5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3BD@l U 3654.Y360 Ô 3�9 ] [�7C52.h9\_Ö[g9\0 |>|¼ U DXp\36D�l U 3654.Y360 Õ

�z

Page 78: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

<>=»7C[�3 Ä O ��] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 9\=XD"04[X<\527kl U 3652.13B0q<\="74[X3 Ä\Å O �v] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � J = 74[X36023�7C9 E _Y360 �] <\_ U W = z _1.1087C0k7C[X3©= U W�E 365¶<;amDX< ]6U W 36=�7C0�9;7��y[�. ] [���3'fX5236043B=�7Z7C[X3©fX543 ] .102.1<>= jgp U 52360 �r <>_ U W = Ä _Y.1087C0Z7C[X3�fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>=³jXp U 543B0©�y[X3B=�9\_Y_ml U 3654.Y360©p>< 74<�74[X3�<\54.1p\.1=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �r <>_ U W =�0 Ç 74[X54< U p>[ Æ _Y.1087�7C[X3@fX523 ] .104.Y<>=�jgp U 52360��y[X36= E U .Y_1DX.Y=Xp{543BfX_1. ] 9\0 U 04.1=�p D�.Yظ365 ½36=�7k= U W�E 36520/<\aº7C<\f»DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 � s [�3Z= U W�E 3B540/.Y=)7C[�3Zfg9\543B=�7C[X3B04360k02[X<}� 74[X3ZfX543 ] .Y04.1<\=fi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3�D�.Yظ36543B= ] 3 �w <>5K04[X<>587/l U 3B54.13B0�<>=�7C[X3 Ä O �!] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 5236fX_Y. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>={52360 U _Y7C0�.1=)9©fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>=)fi365 ½] 3B=�7:9\p>3Z_Y<>040�_136020�7C[X9\= Ç � ztq <;aº043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp%7C[X3�<\54.1p\.1=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�an<>5�74[X3Z0C9 W 3�= U W¶E 3B5<\a¢543B04fi<>=X043B0�<>5oan3��t3B5 �w <>5�_1<\=Xp%l U 3652.1360k<>=»74[X3 Ä O ��] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 5236fX_Y. ] 9'0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= 52360 U _Y740q.Y="9%fX543 ] .102.1<>="fi365 ½] 3B=�7:9\p>3q_1<\040m_13B040m7C[X9\= Ä � Ë q �w <>5'02[X<>527'l U 3654.Y360@<>=�74[X3 Ä\Å O � ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 543BfX_1. ] 9�0236_13 ] 74.1<>=�52360 U _Y7C0%.Y=�9�fX543 ] .Y04.1<\=fi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3�_1<\040/_Y36040K7C[g9;= z � Ä$q 9;0 ] < W fg9;5436D�7C<'023�9\5 ] [X.1=Xp'74[X3�<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � 9;=XD04< W 3�7C. W 360o74[X3qfX543 ] .102.1<>=�. W fX52<Âc\360K9�_1.Y727C_Y3 ��E 3 ] 9 U 023�7C[�3q5236fX_Y. ] 9�D�<^3B0�=X<;7 ] <>=�7:9\.Y=�02< W 37C<\f ½ 549\=X´\3BD U =�5436_Y3Bc;9\=�7�DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 � J =�<\74[X365���<>54D�0 � 0236_13 ] 74.1=Xp�9�0 W 9;_1_13B5/543BfX_1. ] 9@< ]B] 9 ½04.Y<>=g9\_Y_ F DX<V360y=X<�[g9\5 W �

�SÿT�`ÿT� é�¼ à i ü ònï à a à�gQgM© ò ü ú�ù�a ý�à�û! ò_i Þ�ü}à`s [ %bà�ý ò à�gs [X.Y0�023 ] 7C.1<\=Ù3�c\9;_ U 9;74360�< U 5�fX52<>fi<>043BDÙ5236fX_Y. ] 9»0236_13 ] 74.1<>=�a U = ] 7C.Y<>=<>=·9»�y.1D�365�5C9\=�p>3%<\al U 3652.13B0�9\=�D ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0tan<>5 U =X5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36D@l U 3B54.13B0 �oT 363 T 3 ] 7C.Y<>=�Ë � Ç � Ä an<>5yDX3B7C9\.1_Y36D%3Úµ�fi365 ½. W 36=�7C9\_I043�7474.1=Xp �

õ ò a s ò a ß�ü ú à ñ à` ¦à ï Þ a ü ñ à�ûF òji Þs 9 E _13ºË � | _Y.1087C0`7C[X3�9�c>3B5C9\p>3�3�µ^fi3 ] 7436D�= U W¶E 3B5¢<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�fX543 ] .Y043tl U 3B54.Y360®.Y=�369 ] [¶5236fX_Y. ] 9<}c>3B5�jXc\3�7C3B027�7C54.19\_10º9;=XD«02[X<}�y0t7C[X3K543B0 U _¾7C0¹<\a`5236fX_Y. ] 9�0236_13 ] 74.1<>= E�F ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1=Xp�74[X3�9�c\365C9;p>3= U W�E 365/<;a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�fX523 ] .1043Zl U 3B54.Y360/7C[X9;7�9\523�DX.Y543 ] 7C3BD{7C<%DX.¾ØÖ3B5436=�7�5236fX_Y. ] 9\0/9\0��t3B_1_e9;07C[�3)<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � � 3�_1.1087�54360 U _Y740©an<>5�04[�<>527«l U 3654.Y360©<>=·7C[�3 Ä O � syu à r Ä#"�Ç

Æ�Ä

Page 79: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

� à©ãkã ü Qnì�í!á�5kâ�5kà©ëFãkà©â�â�ãkí!â�âE8�AU1�ë ÿ Vé�à©ê ZJ-�í!ì�3 Q�ìÔí!á 5kâÔí ����í ü ZJ-�í!ì�5kí!âE��X�ê$í!á 8�í!îo 56��í é�3Pê$í ë C -�í!ì�5kí!â ß�; ßW< ß�= ß ? ßW@ ��©þ �©ùPü � �Pü ú �©ü þ �Pü � �©ü � �©ü ÷ �©ûPü ù��þ©þ ��ý�ü ù �Pü ù �Pü ù �Pü � �Pü � �©ü þ ��÷�ü ù� ��� â�A�à©ì�8 �©þ©þ ��ý�ü ù ÷�ü ú �Pü ù �Pü ú �Pü � �©ü � �©�Pü ÷ÿ©þ©þ ��ý�ü ù úPü � �Pü ù ÷�ü ÷ �Pü ÷ �©ü ÷ ��ùPü ú�N��í ü ��ý�ü û ÷�ü � �Pü û �Pü¨� �Pü ÿ �©ü � ���Pü û��þ©þ ÷��Pü ÷ �Pü ú �Pü ÷ �Pü ÷ �Pü � �©ü � �©ùPü ú� ��� ãkà©ëPä �©þ©þ ÷��Pü ÷ ÿPü � �Pü ù �Pü ÷ �Pü � �Pü þ �©ÿPü ùÿ©þ©þ ÷��Pü ÷ ùPü � ÿPü ÷ ÷�ü þ �Pü ù �Pü þ �©þPü þ�N��í ÷��Pü ÷ ÿPü ý ÷�ü � �Pü ú �Pü ÷ �©ü ý ��÷�ü ù��þ©þ ��ùPü ÷ þPü ù þPü ú þPü ù �©ü þ þPü þ ��ÿPü ��©þ ��� â�A�à©ì�8 �©þ©þ ��ûPü þ þPü ÷ �©ü þ �©ü � �©ü � þPü ú �!÷�ü úÿ©þ©þ ��ûPü � �Pü � �Pü þ �Pü þ �©ü þ �©ü þ �V�©ü þ�N��í ü ��ùPü û �©ü¨� �©ü � �©ü � �©ü¨� þPü ÿ ���Pü ý��þ©þ �©ú þ � � þ � ����©þ ��� �©þ�� | �©ÿ©þ �©þ©þ �©ÿ þ þ � þ ÷ �©þâ�A�à©ì�8 ÿ©þ©þ �©ÿ þ � þ � ÷ �©û�N��í ü �©ÿPü � þ þPü ú þPü ú þPü � �Pü ý �©þPü þåp1�èE�"XPê$í!áS8Ôí!î�ë/-P7Wï$í!ì�à�r á�à©ãkãkí!áS8�5kà©ëFê�ì�í�á 5kâ�í C -�í!ì�5kí�â�5kë{í21�á�ADìÔí!ê�ã65ká�1ZJ-�í!ì�3 é�à©ê �N��í ü ZJ-�í!ì�5kí!âE8Ôà � í!ê�ã65ká�1 Q�ìÔí!á 5kâ�5kà©ë�I�à©âÔâ V à�r"� í!ê�ã ü Qnì�í�á üo 56�!í é43�ê$í � ß�; ßW< ß�= ß ? ßW@ � � t ÿ V ÿ V�s ��þ V u ��þ V C -�í!ì�5kí!â�8�àG��©þ �Pü ú �Pü þ �Pü þ �Pü ù ÿPü ú ���Pü � ý��Pü ÷ V ý�ü ÷ V ��úPü � V ��ý�ü û V��þ©þ �Pü ú �Pü þ �Pü � �Pü ÷ ùPü � �ý�ü ÷ ý�þPü ÿ V ���Pü � V �ý�ü ÷ V ���Pü ù V� ��� â�A�à©ìB8 �©þ©þ ÷�ü þ �Pü ÷ �Pü ÷ ÷�ü ù úPü ù ��úPü ÷ ý+�©ü ÿ V �V�©ü � V �ý�ü � V ��ÿPü � Vÿ©þ©þ ÷�ü ù �Pü þ ÷�ü ú úPü ÷ ÿPü ù ���Pü � ú©úPü � V �©�Pü ý V �V�©ü¨� V ��ÿPü ÷ V����í ü �Pü ÿ �Pü ù �Pü¨� ÷�ü ÷ úPü ú �ý�ü ÿ ý�þPü � V ���Pü ÷ V ��ÿPü ÿ V ��ùPü¨� V��þ©þ �Pü ú �Pü ÷ �©ü ù �Pü ù úPü ú �©ÿPü � ý©ý�ü ÿ V ���Pü¨� V ûPü ÷ V �©ÿPü û V� ��� ãkà©ë�ä �©þ©þ ÷�ü ù ÷�ü þ �©ü ù �Pü þ �V�©ü � �ý�ü ú ý�þPü ú V �ý�ü ú V �V�©ü ù V ���Pü¨� Vÿ©þ©þ ÿPü ÷ ÷�ü ù �Pü � ÿPü þ ��þPü � ���Pü ù ý�ùPü ÿ V �ý�ü ÷ V ÷�ü � V ÿPü ý V����í ü ÷�ü ú �Pü ý �Pü � �Pü ú ûPü � ��ùPü û ý�ÿPü ÿ V ��úPü þ V ùPü ÿ V �!÷�ü û V��þ©þ þPü ÷ þPü ÷ þPü ú þPü ù �Pü � �!÷�ü þ ù�÷�ü ý V ÷�ü ÿ V ��þPü ù V ��ý�ü þ V�©þG��� â�A�à©ìB8 �©þ©þ þPü ú þPü ú �©ü � �©ü ÷ �©ü ù ���Pü ÷ ù�÷�ü � V úPü � V ûPü ÿ V ���©ü ú Vÿ©þ©þ þPü ÷ þPü ù �©ü ù �©ü � �Pü ú ���Pü ÷ ù©úPü ÷ V úPü � V ý�ü � V �©ûPü þ V����í þPü ÿ þPü ú �©ü � �©ü¨� �Pü � ���Pü � ù©ÿPü¨� V ÿPü ý V ûPü � V �©�Pü ÿ V��þ©þ � � þ � � ��� ù©úPü¨� V þPü þ V ���Pü ù V ÿ©þPü þ V�©þG��� �©þ�� | �©ÿ©þ �©þ©þ � � þ � � �©þ ù©ÿPü ý V þPü þ V �!÷�ü � V ÷�þPü þ Vâ�A�à©ìB8 ÿ©þ©þ � � þ � � �©þ ù©ÿPü ý V ÿPü ù V ùPü ÿ V ÷�þPü þ V����í �©ü ý �©ü þ þPü þ �©ü þ �©ü � �©þPü � ù©ÿPü ù V �©ü û V ���Pü � V ÷��Pü � VåMïfè�� í!â�-�ã 8�â à�r�ì�í!ê�ã65ká�1 âÔí!ãkí!áS8�5kà©ë�rMà©ì á!à©ãkãkí!á 8�5kà©ëFêPìÔí!á 5kâÔí C -�í!ì�5kí!âí Þ��! nà �Sÿ � ÿ u 36f�_1. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%an<>5 U =X5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36D@l U 3B54.13B0

Æ>Ç

Page 80: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � _1<>=Xp�l U 3652.13B0�<>=�7C[X3 Ä O � syu à r Ä#"�Ç ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � 9\=XD�04[X<>587�l U 3B54.Y360�<\=�7C[�3Ä\Å O � syu à rÑ�Pbr ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �J = s 9 E _13ZË � | Ô 9 Õ � ] <\_ U W =X0 z 9\=XD Ä .1=XD�. ] 9�7C3�7C[�3�02. ¿ 3Z<\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\="9\=XD»7C[X3Z7 F fi3©<\a¹7C[�3l U 365 F 043�7C0 � r <>_ U W = Ç .1=XD�. ] 9�7C360©7C[X3"= U W�E 365%<\a�DX< ]6U W 36=�740�087C<>5236D�an<>5%369 ] [�l U 3B5 F �r <>_ U W ="Ë@_1.Y02740/7C[X3�= U W�E 365k<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=»fX523 ] .Y043�l U 3652.13B0 � r <>_ U W =X0 Î 7C[X52< U p>[ z}Å _Y.10277C[�3t9�c>3B5C9\p\3t= U W�E 365b<\aX5236fX_Y. ] 9yf�543 ] .1023tl U 3652.13B0¢<}c>3B5¢74[X3¹j�c>3�7454.19\_10`.Y=q369 ] [�<\a�543BfX_1. ] 9\0 Ô �� Õ9\0K�t3B_1_¢9\0�74[X3¶<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= Ô È Õ � �y[X3B543¶74[X3¶5236fX_Y. ] 9�.Y0�7C[�3¶0 W 9\_Y_136087K5436f�_1. ] 9��y[�. ] [] 9 U 043B0�9@fX543 ] .102.1<>="_Y<>040k_13B040k7C[g9;= Î#q � J = s 9 E _Y3�Ë � | Ô E Õ � ] <\_ U W =X0�Ë@7C[X52< U p>[ | ] <>=�7:9\.Y=7C[�3y9}c\36549\p>3y= U W�E 365A<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�fX523 ] .1043ml U 3B54.Y360º<}c>365A74[X3ojXc>3y7C52.h9\_Y0¢74[X3m543BfX_1. ] 9/043B_13 ] 7C<\5043B=XDX0q7C<�3�9 ] [�<\at74[X3�5436f�_1. ] 9\0q9\0��t3B_1_¹9\0�7C[�3©<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � r <>_ U W = z}Å ] <\=�7C9\.1=�07C[�3%9�c>36549\p>3%fi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3%<\a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= fX543 ] .Y043%l U 3652.13B0�7C[g9;7�7C[X3%0236_Y3 ] 74<>5�DX.Y543 ] 7C0�7C<{7C[�3<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�9\=XD�5236fX_Y. ] 9\0q74[g9;7 ] 9 U 02360�9)f�543 ] .102.1<>=�_1<>020¶_13B040q7C[g9\= Î#q � r <>_ U W =X0z>z 74[X54< U p>[ zÂÄ ] <>=�7:9\.Y={7C[X3�9�c>3B5C9\p\3Zf¸3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3B0k<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>={fX523 ] .1043Zl U 3B54.Y360/7C[X9;7/7C[�3043B_13 ] 7C<\5oDX.1523 ] 7C0o7C<¶5436f�_1. ] 9\0�74[g9;7 ] 9 U 02360yfX543 ] .Y04.1<\='_1<>020tan54< W Î#q 7C< z}Ŧq'� 9\=XD W <>523�7C[X9\=z}Ŧq � r <>_ U W = z}Ç ] <>=�7:9\.Y=X0�7C[�3Z9�c>36549\p>3Zfi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3Z<\a¹543BfX_1. ] 9�fX543 ] .1023Zl U 3652.1360�<}c\365/7C[�3jXc\3©7C52.h9\_Y0�7C[X9;7k7C[X3�043B_13 ] 7C<>5qDX.Y543 ] 7C0�7C<@7C[�3©<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � � 3�3�µ^fi3 ] 7�74[X3©5236fX_Y. ] 9043B_13 ] 7C<\5/7C<%DX.Y543 ] 7/7C[�3Z5436f�_1. ] 9'fX543 ] .Y043Zl U 3652.13B0/7C<�9'543BfX_1. ] 9 �¸E 3 ] 9 U 023Z7C[X3 F [g9�c>3�543BfX_1. ] 9\07C[X9;7 ] 9 U 043qfX543 ] .102.1<>=@_Y<>0402360y_13B040m7C[g9;= Î#q �w <>5y04[X<\527�l U 3654.Y360�<>=�74[X3 Ä O �] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � <\=�7C[�3¶9�c>3B5C9\p\3 � < U 5�5236fX_Y. ] 9�0236_Y3 ] 74<>5�D�.1543 ] 740Ì>Ç � Ʀq Ô � Å � Ä#q�"�z}Ç � Ë q Õ <\a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=%fX523 ] .1043�l U 3B54.Y360m7C<Z7C[�3�5436f�_1. ] 9\0o7C[X9;7 ] 9 U 043q9ZfX543 ] . ½04.Y<>="_1<>020�_13B040�7C[g9;= z}Å#q Ô < U 5q9 ]6] 36f�7C9 E _13Z_Y3Bc\36_ Õ 9;0k��36_Y_º9\0�7C[X3�<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 9;=XD<>=X_ F DX.Y543 ] 7C0 z}Ì � ztq <\a¢l U 3654.Y360y�y[X. ] [�9\523�5436f�_1. ] 9ZfX543 ] .1023�7C<Z7C[X3k<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �w <>5/_Y<>=Xp'l U 3B54.13B0k<>={7C[X3 Ä O ��] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � <>={7C[X3�9�c\365C9;p>3 � < U 5�5436f�_1. ] 9'043B_13 ] 7C<>5�D�.1543 ] 740|�z � Î#q Ô � Î � Î#q�"�z}Æ � Ŧq Õ <\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=»fX543 ] .1023©l U 3B54.Y360�7C<@7C[X3�5236fX_Y. ] 9;0k74[g9;7 ] 9 U 043©9@fX543 ½] .Y04.Y<>=�_Y<>040K_13B040y7C[g9;= z}Ŧq 9;0K��36_Y_¢9;0K74[X3¶<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � 9\=XD�<>=X_ F DX.1523 ] 7C0 z Ë�� |#q <\a543BfX_1. ] 9�fX523 ] .1043ql U 3652.13B0y74<Z7C[X3k<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= �

Æ Ë

Page 81: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

w <>5»04[�<>527 l U 3652.13B0�<>=�74[X3 Ä\Å O � ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � �y[X36=-�t3³3�µ^fi3654. W 3B=�7 �y.¾7C[�7C[�3³049 W 3043�7474.1=Xp9\0©7C[X3 Ä O � ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � <>=�7C[X3"9�c\365C9;p>3 � < U 5'5236fX_Y. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C<>5«DX.1523 ] 740 |>Å � ̦qÔ Ì>Î � z�qm"kÎ ��� q Õ <\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=@fX543 ] .1023�l U 3B54.Y360y7C<�7C[X3k543BfX_1. ] 9\0m74[g9;7 ] 9 U 043�9�fX523 ] .104.Y<>=�_1<>020_13B040q7C[g9\= z}Ŧq 9\0k��36_1_�9\0k7C[X3�<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � � [X36=��t3©3�µ^f¸3B54. W 3B=�7q�y.Y74[�l U 3B54.13B0Ç>Å�z ½ Ç�Î\Å 9\0t< U 5 U =X5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3BD'l U 3652.1360 � < U 5�543BfX_1. ] 9¶0236_13 ] 74<>5oDX.Y543 ] 7C0 Ì �^��� q Ô Ì�Î � ̦q�"�z � |#q Õ<\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�fX523 ] .Y043�l U 3654.Y360�74<«7C[�3¶543BfX_1. ] 9\0K7C[g9�7 ] 9 U 043�9�fX543 ] .Y04.1<\={_1<>020�_Y36040K7C[g9;= z}Ŧq9\0m��36_1_S9;0o7C[X3k<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= �

Ýqý�à i�ò g ò d�aÓd c�ñ àVû! òji Þ î à` ¦à i ü ò d�a ï à�ýOgQ%!gZü ú à å ý ò ß ò a Þ� ând j nà i ü ò d�a� 3 ] < W fg9\523/7C[X3�523B7C52.13�c\9;_IfX543 ] .Y04.1<\=%<\a®3Úµ^3 ]6U 7C.1=�p U =X543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D@l U 3652.1360K9\p>9\.1=X087m543BfX_1. ] 9\0<>5%7C[�3�<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�043B_13 ] 7C3BD E�F < U 5@543BfX_1. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C<>5@�y.Y74[�<\=X_ F 023�9\5 ] [X.1=�pÙ7C[�3<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �s 9 E _13¹Ë � z}Å _Y.1087C0b9�c>36549\p>3�fX543 ] .102.1<>=�<}c>365 Î 7C3B027¢7C54.19\_10Ian<\5¢02[X<>527®l U 3652.1360¢<>=�74[X3 Ä O � syu à rÄ#"�Ç ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � _Y<>=Xp�l U 3B54.13B0m<>='7C[�3 Ä O � syu à r Ä#"�Ç ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � 9;=XD%04[X<\527yl U 3652.13B0m<>=7C[�3 Ä\Å O � syu à r Ñ�Pbr ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � J =Ù7C[X3B043)7C9 E _13B0 � ] <>_ U W = z _1.Y027C0Z74[X3)= U W�E 365©<\aDX< ]6U W 36=�740Z9;7��y[X. ] [��t3%f�54360236=�7Z7C[�3'fX543 ] .Y04.1<\=�jgp U 52360 � r <\_ U W = Ä _1.Y02740q74[X3%fX543 ] .Y04.1<\=jgp U 54360k�y[X3B=�9\_1_®l U 3654.Y360�p><�74<�74[X3�<>54.Yp>.1=g9;_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � r <>_ U W =X0 Ç 74[X54< U p>[ Æ _1.Y027�7C[�3fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>=�jgp U 52360Z�y[X36= E U .Y_1DX.Y=Xp{5236fX_Y. ] 9;0 U 04.Y=Xp"DX.Yظ365236=�7�= U W�E 36520�<;a�74<>fDX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 �s [X3q= U W�E 36540y.Y=@74[X3kfg9\5236=�7C[X3B043B0�04[�<Â�!7C[X3kfX523 ] .Y04.Y<>=@f¸3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3kDX.¾ØÖ3B543B= ] 3 �w <>5�74[X3 Ä O �!] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= U 02.1=Xp'02[X<>587�l U 3652.1360 � 7C[�3�fX543 ] .Y04.1<\=)_1<\04043B0/5C9;=Xp>3¶an52< W Æ � Ì#q 74<z � � ztq � J = ] 54369\04.Y=Xp%7C[X3Z= U W¶E 3B5�<\a¹5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3BD»DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0�an<>5�3�9 ] [ l U 365 F . W fX54<}c\360/7C[�3fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>= �SE 3 ] 9 U 043�7C[X3�543BfX_1. ] 9\0 ] <>=�7:9\.Y= W <>543Z5236_Y3Bc>3B=�7¶DX< ]6U W 3B=�740qan<\5q369 ] [�5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3BDl U 365 F>� �y[�. ] [³[X36_YfX0�DX3B74365 W .1=�.1=Xp»7C[�3�02. W .1_19\54.¾7 F"E 3�7É�t3B36= U =�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3BD·9;=XDÙ5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3BDl U 3652.13B0 � � [X3B=³74[X3%= U W�E 365Z<\ay74<>f543B7454.Y3Bc>3BDDX< ]BU W 36=�7C0�.10¶_136020�7C[g9;= Ç\Å DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 ��y[X. ] [�9;543{7C[�3»543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_�_Y3Bc\36_10'74[g9;7 ] <>= ] 3654=<>=X_Y.1=X3 U 043B540 W <>027 � < U 5'543BfX_1. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C<\5] 9 U 043B0�9\=�9}c\36549\p>3�fX543 ] .102.1<>= fi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3«_Y<>040��y.Y74[X.1= z ËY� Ʀq 9;=XD z�Ŧq <\ao023�9\5 ] [X.1=�p�7C[�3

Æ�Î

Page 82: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

($6G� �921P/�Y�7�YM;�b`�;�/�7 ;�2YMN h ?×;�4 t m ?×;�4 g m�m ?�;�4�j�m�m ?×;�4 w m�mg m l j h y t | h y ' s�g�g�h i * t�y0h i ' sui0h j�* t�i0h l ' suy0h m�* t�i h i ' sux0h y *j$m t�i0h l t$l�h m�' s�g�t h y * t�w�h y ' sui0hMg * t�x0hMg ' suy0h l * t�w0h x ' sui0h | *t m t�w�hkw t m h t ' s�g3l�h x * t j h x ' suy0h j�* t j h | ' s | h y * t j h | ' s | h i *g m�m j | h j j t0h t ' s5g�l h m�* j l h m\' s�g�g�h x * j l�h jL' s�g m h y *j�m�m j g�h y gPy0h t ' s�g�x0hkw * g�y h y ' s�g�t h i *w m�m g�l h t g�g�h y ' s�g | hpg *')(�*,7�> ;�26 ]�^ 1�2YM1�7,;�b�65>01Àj�����/3;�KMKp1P/©6YM;�b($6 � �921P/�Y�7�YM;�b`0;�/�7 ;�2YMN h ?×;�4 g m�m ?�;�4\j�m�m ?�;�4 w m�mg m w�w�h t w j h i ' sÔl�h t * w j h m ' sux0h m�* wfl h y ' s m h i *j$m w j h | l�i h l ' svx h j�* l�y0h x ' s | h y * w m h i ' sut0h l *t m w m h m l�x h j ' s | h x * l�w�h | ' suy0h | * l | h i ' svl h t *g m�m l m h l t�w0h t ' s5g j h x * t�w�hMg ' s5gPt0h j�* t�x0h y ' suy0h y *j�m�m t�t0hMg j | h t ' s5g | h l * j i0hMg ' s�g j h m�*w m�m j g�h y g�y0h jL' s�g�x0h x *':Un*WKp;�b0N ]�^ 1325Yp1P7,;�bL6>01Àj�����/3;�KMKp1P/©65Yp;�b($6G� �921P/�Y�7�YM;�b`0;�/�7 ;�25YpN h ?×;�4 g m�m ?�;�4Hj$m�m ?×;�4 w m�mg m g j h y g j h l ' svt hpg * g j h x ' s�g�h x * g j h l ' sut0h l *j$m g j h t g�g�h x ' suw0h w * g�g�h i ' sut0hMg * g�g�h y ' sut0h l *t m g�g�h y g�g�h l ' svt hpg * g�g�h i ' � m h y * g�g�h y ' � m h t *g m�m g m h m i hpg ' svi h x * i h x ' svl h j�* g m hMg ' � m h j�*j�m�m y0h l | h | ' s | h i * y0h t ' s�g�h m�*w m�m x0h l w�h i ' s | h | *'�/�*,7>0;�26 ]�^ 1325Yp1P7,;�bL6>01Àj�my���Q/�;�KpKM1�/�6YM;�b($6 � �921P/�Y�7�YM;�b`0;�/�7 ;�2YMN h ?×;�4 g m�m ?�;�4\j�m�m ?�;�4 w m�mg m l m h l t�x h j�' s5g m h l * t�x0h j�' s5g m h l * t | h y ' sux0h l *j$m t�w�h l t m h | ' s5gPt0h t * t m h | ' s5gPt0h t * t0g�h t ' s�g�g�h x *t m t g�h t j x h i ' s5g�l h j�* j x0h i ' s5g�l h j�* j | h m�' s�g3l h m�*g m�m j�m h j g | h y ' s5g�g�h i * g | h y ' s5g�g�h i * g | h jL' s�gPw�h m�*j�m�m g�l h l g j h y ' s5g m h i * g j h jL' s�g3l h m�*w m�m | h y x0h | ' s�g3l h m�*')` *,7>0;�26 ]�^ 1325Yp1P7�'Á65;�40Y�/37 t m g�sut�w m�*.;�bL6>01Àj�m����S/�;�KpKM1�/�6YM;�b

í Þ��! ¦à �SÿøþB�`ÿ ÃeØÖ3 ] 74.Yc>3B=X36020�<\a U =X5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3BD�l U 3B54.13B0 Ô 3�9 ] [�7454.h9;_I[g9\0 Î\Å l U 3652.13B0 Õ

Æ>Æ

Page 83: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � �y[X36=³�t3�<>=X_ F 5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3'74[X3@7C<>f Ç>Å DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0©9\=XD³7C[X3@7C<\f z}Å\ÅDX< ]6U W 36=�740yan<\5m3�9 ] [�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3BD@l U 365 F\� 543602f¸3 ] 74.Yc>3B_ F �w <>5/7C[�3 Ä O ��] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= U 04.1=�p�_Y<>=Xp@l U 3652.1360 � 74[X3�fX543 ] .102.1<>= _1<\04043B0k5C9\=Xp\3�an52< W Å � |¦q 74<z � � Ë q � w <>5y7C[�3�7C<\f Ç>Å 523B7C52.13�c>36D»D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0 � <>=)74[X3�9�c>3B5C9\p\3 � 74[X3�fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>=)DX52<>fX0/_Y360207C[X9\= Ì � � q �y[X36= �t3�5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C3 W <>543�74[g9\= z}Å>Å DX< ]6U W 36=�740qan<>5�369 ] [ 5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3BD"l U 3654.Y360 ��y[X. ] [�.Y0m04_1.Yp>[�7C_ F«E 3B727C365m74[g9\=�04[X<>587Kl U 3654.Y360 �w <>5Z7C[X3 Ä\Å O � ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= U 02.1=Xp�04[X<>587«l U 3B54.Y360 � �y[X36=·��3)3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�7��y.Y74[³74[X3�049 W 3043�7474.1=Xp 9\0Z7C[�3 Ä O �Ê] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=9\=XD U 043@7C[X3@5236_13�c;9\= ] 3%jg_Y360Zan<>5�74[X3 Ä O �Ó] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �7C[�3«fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>=�549\=Xp>3B0�an52< W _1<>02.1=Xp | � Ʀq 74<). W fX52<ÂcV.Y=Xp Å � Ì#q � w <>5k7C[�3�74<>f Ç>Å 543�7C54.Y3Bc\36DDX< ]6U W 36=�740 � 74[X3�fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>=)_Y<>040�.10�_Y36020�7C[g9;= Î � Î#q � � [X36={��3 U 023�04[X<\527�l U 3B54.13B0 Ç>Å�z ½ Ç�Î\Å9\0/< U 5 U =X5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3BD»l U 3654.Y360 � 7C[X3ZfX523 ] .104.Y<>={_Y<>040�an<\5�7C[X3�7C<>f Ç>Å D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0�.10�_13B040/7C[X9\=z Ë � Ä#q �ºT .Y= ] 3�7C<>fX. ] 0 Ç>Å�z ½ Ç�Î\Å �t3B543 W U�] [ W <>523K74[X<>52< U p>[X_ F ¼ U DXp>3BD'7C[g9\=©7C<>fX. ] 0;� Î^z ½ z}Î\Å��Ä\Å�Ä ½ Ä>Î\Å ��an<>5m74[X3 Ä\Å O � Ñ�Pbr ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � 9\_Y74[X< U p\[�087C.1_Y_I<>=X_ F 7C[X3k7C<\f Ç>Å DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0K<\a3�9 ] [»l U 365 F �t3B543�¼ U D�p>36D � �t3�74[X.1=X´%74[X3�543B0 U _¾7C0 U 04.1=�p«7C<>f�. ] 0 Ç>Å�z ½ Ç�Î\Å .10 W <>523�9 ]B]6U 549;7C3 ��y[X. ] [ W 3�9;=X0Z< U 5�5236fX_Y. ] 9)043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=f¸3B52an<>5 W 0�02_1.Yp>[�7C_ F ��<>54023%<>=�7C[X3 Ä;Å O �Q] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=7C[X9\=)<>=@7C[�3 Ä O ��] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � H <}��3Bc\365 � 7C[X3qfX543 ] .Y04.1<\=�fi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3q_1<>020�<\a z Ë � Ä#q .Y=�< U 5] <\=�743�µV7m<>=�_ F�W 3�9\=X0¹�t3�543B7454.Y3Bc>3�<>=X3�_Y36020t543B_13�c\9;=�7tDX< ]6U W 36=�7tan<\5¹74[X3�74<>f Ç>Å DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 �

�SÿT�`ÿT� î %�f-f�ÞXý hT <\a¦9;5A.1=�7C[�.10 ] [g9\f^7C365 � �t3K.1=�c>3B0274.1p�9;7436D�[X<}�·74<k0436_Y3 ] 7t9/5236_Y3Bc;9\=�7¹fg9\5274.h9\_^543BfX_1. ] 9 U 02.1=Xp�7C[�3.1=^an36543B= ] 3�=X3�7É�t<\54´ W <^DX3B_ � M U 5k9\fXfX52<�9 ] [ 36=g9 E _13B0k9@0 F 027C3 W 7C<@3BÀ ] .136=�74_ F 549\=X´)fX9\5274.h9\_543BfX_1. ] 9\0�9\=XD�0436_Y3 ] 7Z9�5236fX_Y. ] 9 E 9\0236D�<\=�543B_13Bc;9\= ] 3©an<\5¶9)p\.Yc>3B=�l U 3B5 F � � 3©DX3Bc\36_1<\f¸3BD�9543BfX_1. ] 9'0236_13 ] 74.1<>="a U = ] 7C.1<\= � 9\=XD DX3 W <>=X087C549;7C3BD�.¾7C0�3Bظ3 ] 7C.¾c>36=�36040�9\=XD"0 U fi3652.1<>52.Y7 F <Âc\365�9] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�549\=X´�.1=�pka U = ] 74.1<>= U 02.1=Xp�7C[�3 J = Á U 365 F 543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_X0 F 087C3 W 9;=XD syu à r ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0 �M U 5º543B0 U _¾7C0¹04[X<}��7C[X9;7º7C[X3K.1=�an3B543B= ] 3K=X3B7É��<>52´ W <VDX36_X.Y0¹9kc\365 F fX52< W .104.Y=Xp/7C<V<>_Xan<>5º0236_13 ] 7 ½.1=�p@9�5236_13�c;9\=�7k5436f�_1. ] 9 �Z� F U 04.Y=Xp@< U 5�fX52<>f¸<\0436D 543BfX_1. ] 9'0236_13 ] 74.1<>=»a U = ] 7C.Y<>= � 7C[�3�5236fX_Y. ] 9043B_13 ] 7C<\5 ] 9;=¶DX.Y543 ] 7A9;7¢_1369\027 Ì�Ä#q <;ag543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D¶l U 3B54.Y360¢74</9K5436_Y3Bc;9\=�7¢fg9\5274.h9\_�5236fX_Y. ] 9y5C9�7C[X3B5

Æ �

Page 84: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

7C[X9\='7C[X3�<>54.Yp>.1=g9;_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � 9\=XD%.Y7o9 ] [X.Y3Bc>3B0K9�fX543 ] .102.1<>=«f¸3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3�_Y<>040t_136020t7C[X9\= z}Ŧqan<>5�74[X3 Ä O �!] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=»9\=�D z Ë � Ä#q an<\5�7C[X3 Ä;Å O ��] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=)an<>5�74[X3�7C<\f Ç>Å 543�7C54.Y3Bc\36DDX< ]6U W 36=�740t<\a`369 ] ['l U 3B5 F>� �y[X36=©�t3 E U .1_YD©5236fX_Y. ] 9\0 U 04.Y=Xp W <>543y7C[X9\= z}Å\Å 74<>f«DX< ]6U W 3B=�740an<>5m369 ] [)5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36D%l U 3B5 F �J =»7C[X3Z5236087�<;a ] [X9\f�7C3B5 � ��3��y.Y_1_¢.1=�c>3B027C.Yp�9;743Z_1<�9\D ½ E 9\_19\= ] .1=Xp � 02fg9 ] 3�9\=�D"74. W 3�<}c>3B54[X369\DX0an<>5o74[X3k5436f�_1. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�DX9;7:9 E 9\043 � 9\0o�t3B_1_S9\0 U fiDg9;74.1=Xp ] <>02740�9;=XD�087C549;7C3Bp>.13B0 �

|[)_| ��24<K� �Ó<>57<>A�:X?+A��J =�7C[X3"fX523BcV.1< U 0�023 ] 7C.1<\= � ��3�[g9�c\3�DX.Y0 ]BU 040236D�[X<}�è7C<043B_13 ] 7{9�5236_13�c;9\=�7�5236fX_Y. ] 9 U 04.Y=Xp.1=^an36543B= ] 3�=X3�7É�t<>52´�0 � H <Â��3Bc\365'.¾a���3 U 043�543B_13Bc;9\= ] 3�9\0�7C[X3@<>=X_ F ] 52.Y743654.Y<>= � 7C[�3�0 F 087C3 W] < U _1D<}c>3B52�y[X3B_ W <>=X3@<>5Z023Bc\365C9;_�5236fX_Y. ] 9;0 E�F 0436=�DX.1=Xp"7C[�3 W 74<^< W 9\= F JLu ] < W©W 9\=XDX0�y[X3B=�5436f�_1. ] 9\0'9;543)5236_Y3Bc;9\=�7'7C<�04.1p\=X.Yj ] 9\=�7«= U W¶E 3B540%<\a�5236l U 3B027C0 � J =�7C[X.Y0«043 ] 74.1<>= � ��3DX.Y0 ]6U 040�[X<}�v7C< E 9\_h9\= ] 3�74[X3�_Y<�9\DX0�9 W <>=Xp'5236_13�c;9\=�7/543BfX_1. ] 9\0�9\=XD)74[X3�<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=.1=@<>52DX365m74<�f�54<VD UX] 3q9Z543B04fi<>=X023¶9\0yl U . ] ´V_ F 9\0yfi<>0402. E _Y3 �T .Y= ] 3���3/�t9\=�7m7C<�0236_13 ] 7y9�5236fX_Y. ] 9��y.Y74[«7C[X3�l U . ] ´\3B027K543B04fi<>=X023/7C. W 3 � ��3 W 9 F ] [X<^<\043/7C[�3�C�:�É�g�����}�o�¦¥��«� 9\0e< U 5 W 3B7C52. ];� H <Â��3Bc\365º04. W f�_ F U 04.Y=Xp�74[X3o543B04fi<>=X023o7C. W 3º�y.1_1_V=X<\7®fX54<VD UX] 37C[�3 E 36087¹54360 U _Y7Aan<\5º9q=X3�� ] < W©W 9\=XD��y[�36=«023Bc\365C9;_ ] < W�W 9\=�DX0A[g9�c>3 E 3B36=�.1=Z7C[�3ml U 3 U 3K<\a9k5436f�_1. ] 9�<>5 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � � 3 W 9 F 9\_102< U 043y7C[X3 ��¡V�n��� �\�i£\¥��V§¶�g¡^��ª������L��¾:���Z���\�i£�� <\aI369 ] [543BfX_1. ] 9 È ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�9\0t< U 5 W 3B7454. ] � 9\=XD«0236=XD'74[X3�=�3B� ] < W�W 9\=XD�7C<�74[X3�5236fX_Y. ] 9 È ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�y.Y74[�74[X3¶02[X<>527436087�l U 3 U 3 � H <Â��3Bc\365/��3�=X3B36D)74< E 3�9��o9;543¶74[g9;7K7C[X3�_13�9;027�_1<�9\D�36D)5236fX_Y. ] 9<>5 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�.10�=X<\7�74[X3 E 36027 ] [X<>. ] 3%.1=�< U 5�04.¾7 U 9�7C.1<\= �eE 3 ] 9 U 043%023�9\5 ] [X.1=Xp»74[X3'<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= ] < U _1D%7C9\´\3k_1<\=Xp>365o74. W 3�7C[X9\=�023�9\5 ] [X.1=�p©9�0 W 9\_Y_Ö543BfX_1. ] 9¶�y.¾7C[�[X.1p>[�365m_1<>9\DX0 �J =»< U 5�0 F 02743 W�� �t3 ] < W�E .Y=X3¶7C[�3Z9 E <Âc\3�7É�t< W 3B7454. ] 0/9\=�D E 9\_h9;= ] 3�_Y<�9\DX0�9\0�an<>_Y_1<}�y0 � � 3fX5236DX. ] 7e74[X3m543B04fi<>=X043o74. W 3t<\ai369 ] [�5436f�_1. ] 9 Ô2� � Õ 9\=�D�7C[X3m<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= Ô È Õ U 04.Y=Xp/7C[�39�c>3B5C9\p>3�543B04fi<>=X043q7C. W 3q9\=XD�7C[X3q= U W�E 365�<\ae< U 7C027C9\=XDX.Y=Xp ] < W�W 9\=�DX0 � � [�36=)74[X3�5236fX_Y. ] 9043B_13 ] 7C<\5 ] [X<V<>043B0º9/5436f�_1. ] 9 E 9;0436D�<>=Z5236_Y3Bc;9\= ] 3 � ��3 ] 9\_ ]6U _19;7C3¹7C[X3tfX543BDX. ] 7C36DZ523602f¸<>=�043o7C. W 3« �O t´ «B��<\aA7C[X3�543BfX_1. ] 9 � 7C[�3�543BfX_1. ] 9\0K_h9\52p>365m74[g9\=)74[X.10 � 9\=XD�7C[X3�<>54.Yp>.1=g9;_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= U 04.Y=Xp

Æ>Ì

Page 85: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

CJ25YpN�Ypb�($K ��(�2N�1�7�6D��1340KMYM/�( �B1�40KpY�/3(eI�1�Kp1P/©65Yp;�b��F(f6�($U (�7�1G�KMK ?×1325<e7,Ypb �¼1�25/313b�6 h ;$8I�Y}��1 �{b0Y ]�^ 1 ?×;�4 I�Yp�31 �{b0Y ]�^ 1 ?×1325<a7 �B1�40KMYM/�(�7 �×($25N�1P7!6� ;�KMKp1P/©65Yp;�b '�E��B* ?�1�2<e7 b ')E��B* ?�1�2<e7 ')Ex�,* '�E��B* ��1340KMYM/�(g m�m g m l g j y ¹ l�t�w l�l y | h | }? ��+ � j � t jy��� y�t�y ¹ i�l�y j$m�m g�i�i j�m�m ¹ | j t l�w g j x0h m }w m�m l | x t j w ¹ y�w�g l | j$m l h j }g m�m i�w gPx j ¹ j | i | l�g g m g m hkw�}? ��+ ��� � � j�my��� gPt ¹ m y�y ¹ m x$l j$m�m g�i g j w$y ¹ g m | | l j gPw | h y�}w m�m l�w�i l�x m ¹ m l�l | l�x j y x0hMg�}í Þ��F nà �Sÿ¦þ�þgÿ T fg9 ] 3q<}c\3654[�3�9\D)an<\5o7C[X3k543BfX_1. ] 9�0236_13 ] 74.1<>=@Dg9;7C9 E 9\023 �

¤¦£`  �$ t´ «B��� Ô z�" ¥�² ® Ï�¤ �j� ®� t´ � Õ � �y[X3B543 ¤¦£`  �$ t´ «B�¹.10b7C[X3y9�c>3B5C9\p\3m543602f¸<\=X043o74. W 3�an<>5e_19\027Ä\Å>Å 543B04fi<>=X02360�an<>5K36.¾7C[X3B5K74[X3q5436f�_1. ] 9�<\5K74[X3�<\54.1p\.1=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 9\=XD ¥�² ® Ï�¤ �_� ®� t´ ��.Y07C[�3K= U W¶E 3B5¹<;a¸74[X3m< U 74027:9;=XDX.1=�p ] < W�W 9\=�DX0e7C<��y[X. ] [©3B.Y7C[�365e7C[�3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�<>5e7C[�3K5236fX_Y. ] 9[g9\0y=X<;7 F 3B7�543B04fi<>=XDX3BD � � 3k043B=XD�74[X3 ] < W�W 9\=XD'7C<Z74[X3k<>=X3��y.Y74[@74[X3k_1369\027K« �O t´ «B� �T .Y= ] 3¶��3�[g9�c>3�9 ] <>=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 54<\´\365/74<%´\3B36f"7C5C9 ] ´)<\a�9\_Y_¢023652c\36520 � �t3 ] 9\="3�9\02.1_ F < E 7:9\.Y=7C[�3�.1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>=�<>=©74[X3�523602f¸<>=�043�74. W 3�9\=�D©7C[�3�= U W�E 365�<\aS< U 74027:9;=XDX.1=�p ] < W©W 9\=XDX0 � � 3DX3 W <>=�027C549;7C3�74[X3kf¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�<\a¢< U 5m0 F 087C3 W �y.¾7C[@_1<>9\D E 9\_h9;= ] .Y=XpZ.1= r [g9;f�7C3B5 Æ �

|[)VÔ �[Õ�<K:=. <>A�� �v?+8\. $ Jx.X0 ,�.X<K�6W 9�2*0 E�,�. �H.�Õ65+?7:=< �;.�57.�:�E�?72xA

³<FEY<>3�<KWY.s [X.Y0`043 ] 7C.Y<>=k.1=�c>3B027C.Yp�9;74360`[X<}� W UX] [q04fg9 ] 3º.10I=X3B36DX3BDq74<m0274<>543¹9o543BfX_1. ] 9o0236_13 ] 74.1<>=�Dg9�7:9 E 9;043 �9\=XD�[X<}� W UX] [�3ÚµV7C5C9Z7C. W 3�.10 U 0236D).Y=@043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp�74[X3k543BfX_1. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=@Dg9;7C9 E 9\023 �

�SÿT�`ÿ¦þ î ûbÞ i à å ï à�ý ú à�Þ�ss 9 E _13@Ë � z>z _1.Y02740�7C[X3�04fg9 ] 3�<Âc\3652[X3�9\DÙan<>5�7C[X3�543BfX_1. ] 9»043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=³Dg9;7:9 E 9\043%an<>5�9 Æ ½ _h9 F 3B5543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=Z[�.136549\5 ] [ F .Y=Z7C36087�7454.19\_ z 7C[g9�7A�t3KDX360 ] 52. E 36D«.Y= T 3 ] 7C.1<\=©Ë � Ç � Ä � � 3y_1.Y027e74[X3�02. ¿ 39\=XD»74[X3Z= U W�E 365k<\a U =X.Yl U 3�74365 W 0�<\aº74[X3�<>54.Yp>.1=g9;_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � 74[X3�04. ¿ 3�9\=XD»7C[�3�= U W¶E 3B5<\a U =X.Yl U 3�7C3B5 W 0�<\aº7C[X3Z_19\54p>3B027�5236fX_Y. ] 9 � 9\=XD»74[X3Z04. ¿ 3Z<\aº7C[�3Z5436f�_1. ] 9«043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>="Dg9;7C9 E 9\023�y[X3B=���3q5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3/74[X3�7C<>f z}Å>Å^��Ä\Å>Å�� 9\=XD Î\Å>Å DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0 � 543B04fi3 ] 74.Yc\36_ F �

Æ>|

Page 86: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

w <>5`7C[X3 Ä O � syu à r Ä#"�Ç ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � 74[X3¹04. ¿ 3�<;aX7C[X3¹543BfX_1. ] 9y043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=¶Dg9�7:9 E 9;043¹.10¢9\54< U =XDË Î d � � �y[�. ] [ .10q9\fXfX52<�µ�. W 9�7C36_ F»Ä � Ä#q <\at74[X3�04. ¿ 3�<\a¹7C[X3�<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � �y[X3B=���3E U .Y_1D'74[X3�.Y=XDX3Úµ%�y.Y74[X< U 7yDX3B_13�7C.1=�p�9\= F 7C365 W 0y3Úµ ] 36f�7�0274<>f��t<\54DX0 � J ab�t3qDX36_Y3B743k74[X3�7C3B5 W 07C[X9;7bDX<�=X<;7¢< ]6]BU 5b.1=�9\= F <\aX5236fX_Y. ] 9;0 � 7C[X3¹04. ¿ 3¹<\a�74[X3�5236fX_Y. ] 9y0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=qDg9;7C9 E 9\023�.Y0¢D�.1543 ] 74_ FfX52<>f¸<\527C.Y<>=g9\_g74<¶7C[X3�= U W�E 3B5t<\a U =X.1l U 3�74365 W 0o.Y=©74[X3/_h9;54p>3B027o5236fX_Y. ] 9 � 549\=Xp>.Y=Xp�an52< W Ì��izÂÄ7C< Ä\Å d � � 9\fXfX52<�µ�. W 9�7C36_ F»Æ d � an<>5k3�c>365 F·z�Å>Å�� Å>Å>Å U =X.1l U 3�7C3B5 W 0 � �y[X36=��t3©5436f�_1. ] 9;7C37C[�3k74<>f z}Å>Å��gÄ\Å>Å�� 9;=XD Î;Å>Å DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0man<>5m369 ] [)l U 3B5 F �w <>5k7C[X3 Ä;Å O � Ñ�Pbr ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � 7C[�3«04. ¿ 3'<;ao7C[X3«5436f�_1. ] 9�0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�Dg9;7:9 E 9\043©.10¶9\54< U =XD� Ë Ä d � � �y[X. ] [{.10�9\fXfX52<�µ�. W 9�7C36_ F@Ç � Ʀq <\a¢7C[X3�04. ¿ 3¶<\a¢7C[X3�<>54.Yp>.1=X9\_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � �y[�36=)��3E U .Y_1D'74[X3�.Y=XDX3Úµ%�y.Y74[X< U 7yDX3B_13�7C.1=�p�9\= F 7C365 W 0y3Úµ ] 36f�7�0274<>f��t<\54DX0 � J ab�t3qDX36_Y3B743k74[X3�7C3B5 W 07C[X9;7KDX<©=�<\7K< ]B]6U 5y.1=�9\= F <\a¢543BfX_1. ] 9\0 � 7C[X3k02. ¿ 3B0�<;a®7C[�3q5236fX_Y. ] 9�0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�Dg9;7C9 E 9\023k5C9\=Xp\3an54< W z}Å���zÂÎ 74< Ä\Ì d � � 9\_Y04<�9\fXfX52<}µ^. W 9;7436_ F�Æ d � an<>5º3Bc>3B5 F�z}Å>Å�� Å>Å>Å U =X.Yl U 3�74365 W 0 � s [X304. ¿ 3K<\a`5236fX_Y. ] 9;0�9;543K_h9\52p>365A7C[X9\=©74[X<>043Kan<>5A7C[X3 Ä O �Ù] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= ��E 3 ] 9 U 043�74[X3 syu à rÙÑ�Pbr] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= ] <\=X04.Y027C0�<\aADg9;7C9�an52< W W <\543qDX.Yc\3654023¶02< U 5 ] 360�74[g9\=)74[X3 syu à r Ä#"�Ç�� 9\=XD)74[ U 0] <\=�7C9\.1=�0 W <>523 U =X.Yl U 3q74365 W 0 �,/36_Y3B74.1=Xp�74365 W 0®74[g9;7AD�<�=X<\7A< ]6]BU 5A.1=Z9;= F <\ai543BfX_1. ] 9\0¢04.1p\=X.Yj ] 9\=�7C_ F 5236D U�] 360º7C[�3o04. ¿ 3m<\a�7C[�3543BfX_1. ] 9Z043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�Dg9;7:9 E 9\043 � 9\=XD�.Y7y[g9\0y=X<�04.Yp>=X.¾j ] 9\=�7K. W fg9 ] 7y<>=�543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_I3�ØÖ3 ] 7C.¾c>3B=X36020 �� 3 W 9 F�W <^D�.Ya F < U 5A5C9;=X´�.1=Xpk9\_Yp><>52.Y7C[ W 9\0ean<\_1_1<}�y0 � � [X3B=«9�l U 3B5 F ] <\=�7C9\.1=�0º9�74365 W 7C[g9�7DX<V360o=�<\7m< ]6]6U 5o.1=%9;= F <\ab543BfX_1. ] 9\0 � 74[X3/0 F 087C3 W 9\0402.1p>=�0t7C[X3�0 W 9\_1_Y36027¹74a Ô 7C365 W an5236l U 3B= ] F Õ0 ] <>543�an<>5o74[X3k543BfX_1. ] 9\0 � 9\=XD�9\0402.1p>=�0y74[X3k_h9\52p>36087m74a¢0 ] <>543�an<>5o74[X3k<>54.Yp>.1=g9;_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= �

�SÿT�`ÿT� í ò f�à å ï à�ý ú àVÞ�sR =�_1.1´;3�7C[�3qD�< ]BU W 3B=�7yDg9;7:9 E 9\043/��3kDX.10 ]6U 020y.1= r [g9\f^7C365 Æ � z �y[X3B543�7C[X3�l U 3B5 F 3�c\9;_ U 9;74.1<>=7C. W 3�.10'087C52<>=Xp>_ F 543B_h9;7436D�74< E <\74[�7C[X3»= U W�E 365%<;aq74365 W 0%.Y=·7C[X3"l U 3B5 F 9\=�D�7C[X3{74365 Wan543Bl U 36= ] .13B0¢<\a^3�9 ] [�7C3B5 W�� 7C[X3A7C. W 3®<Âc\3652[X3�9\D�an<>5`04369\5 ] [X.Y=Xpy7C[X3º543BfX_1. ] 9o0236_13 ] 74.1<>=qDg9;7C9 E 9\023.10q<>=X_ F 543B_h9;7436D"7C<�74[X3«= U W¶E 3B5¶<\ao74365 W 0q.1="7C[X3©l U 365 F �)T .1= ] 3©��3©7 F fX. ] 9\_Y_ F 5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C3�9] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=k043�c>3B5C9\_�7C. W 3B0 � 7C[X3¹04. ¿ 3¹<\ag9;=¶.1=�c\36527436D�_1.1087S.1=k7C[X3¹543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=�0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�Dg9;7C9 E 9\023

� Å

Page 87: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

?×1325<e7 � ;�KM`\I�6�($26  �($25<ÂI�65(�2�6j m h m i�w m h m�m wl m hMg�i�l m h m�m yy m h t�i g m h m g3lgPx m h | t�x m h m�j xt j g�hMg | y m h m l�ix�l j h t�w | m h m i�yg j y l h l�i j m hpgPi |í Þ��! nà �bÿ¦þ`�Iÿ s . W 3Z<}c\3654[�3�9\D�an<\5q023�9\5 ] [X.1=�p�7C[�3©5236fX_Y. ] 9%0236_13 ] 74.1<>= Dg9;7C9 E 9\023�an<>5�74[X3 Ä\ÅO ��] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= Ô 023 ] <\=XDX0 Õ �

.10yc>3B5 F 0 W 9\_1_ � s [X36523�.10�=X<«02.1p>=�.Yj ] 9\=�7�74. W 3�DX.¾ØÖ3B543B= ] 3 E 3�7É�t3B36="fX54< ] 3B0402.1=Xp%9;={.1=�c>3B527436D_1.Y027o�y.¾7C[@<>=X3k3B=�745 F 9\=�D�fX52< ] 360204.1=�p�<\=X3��y.Y7C[%7436=�36=�7C52.1360 �T .Y= ] 3k7C[X3�04. ¿ 360�<\ae74[X3¶5236fX_Y. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=)DX9;7:9 E 9\043B0�an<>5m7C[�3 Ä O � syu à r Ä#"�Ç ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=9\=XDÙ7C[X3 Ä;Å O � syu à r Ñ�Pbr ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=Ù9\543)9 E < U 7«74[X3{049 W 3 � �t3)<>=X_ F _Y.1027�7C[�3�7C. W 3<}c>3B54[X369\D�an<>5¶023�9\5 ] [X.1=Xp{74[X3'5236fX_Y. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�Dg9;7C9 E 9\023«an<>5q7C[X3 Ä\Å O � Ñ�Pbr �y[X36=���3c;9\5 F 74[X3�= U W�E 365/<;aA7C365 W 0�f¸3B5�l U 3B5 F .Y= s 9 E _Y3¶Ë � zÂÄ � � 3�549\={< U 5�3�µ^fi3652. W 36=�7C0 U 04.1=�p%904.Y=Xp>_Y3 r ? R <>='9¶_1.Yp>[�7C_ F ½ _1<�9\D�36D Ç ½ r ? R ,�à r +�_1fX[g9q043B52c>3B5 Ä^z}Å>ŶÎ>È>Ä>Î;Å Ô ] _1< ] ´\3BD@9;7 Ä>Î;Åd H�G`Õ �y.Y74[ z}Å>Ä ËZd � W 9\.Y= W 3 W <>5 F 9\=XD U 04.1=�p J = Á U 3B5 F c>365204.Y<>= Ç � z � � 3�< E 7:9\.Y=X36D�7C[X.Y0Dg9;7C9%.1=»7C[X3Zan<>_Y_1<}�y.1=�p«�o9 F 0 � an<>5�3�9 ] [�Dg9�7:9@f¸<>.Y=�7�an<>5/7C[X3�= U W�E 365k<\a¹7C3B5 W 0kf¸3B5ql U 3B5 F\���3«5C9;=XDX< W _ F ] [X<>043©7C365 W 0�an52< W 7C[X3�043�7�<\a�7C3B5 W 0q74[g9;7q< ]B]6U 5q.1= 7C[X3 Ç�Î\Å syu à r 02[X<>587l U 3652.13B0 � 9\=XD ] <>=�027C5 UX] 7436D�7C36=�l U 3652.13B0º�y.¾7C[Z7C[�3K049 W 3m= U W�E 3B5º<\a¸74365 W 0b{���3K5C9\=Z7C[�36043y7C3B=l U 3652.13B0¹<\=�74[X3m543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=Z0236_13 ] 74.1<>=�Dg9;7C9 E 9\02360º.1=Z7436027º7454.h9;_ z DX360 ] 52. E 36D�.1= T 3 ] 7C.Y<>=�Ë � Ç � Ä^�9\=XD»_Y.1087C36D{74[X36.Y5/9�c>3B5C9\p\3�3�c;9\_ U 9�7C.1<\=�7C. W 3�.1=)74[X3 s 9 E _13¶Ë � z}Ä � � 3�549\=»< U 5�3�µ^f¸3B54. W 3B=�740U =XD�365y7É�t<�027C9\527K04.¾7 U 9�7C.1<\=X0 � ¾:�l¹¾£���� �\�Ú� �y[X36523q��3 ] [X.1_Y_136D'74[X3k0 F 02743 W×E�F 54369\DX.1=�p©9Z_19\54p>3jg_Y3 E 3Ban<>523�74[X3«0 F 027C3 W f�54< ] 3602043B0�3�9 ] [�l U 365 F 0 U�] [�7C[g9�7¶369 ] [�7C3B5 W �t9\0¶523�9\D�an52< W 7C[�3DX.Y04´ � 9\=�D ܹ�\���Ó��� �\��� �y[X36523�3�9 ] [%74365 W .1=�7C[X3�l U 3654.Y360m[g9;0 E 3B36= ] 9 ] [[email protected]=«7C[X3 W 3 W <>5 F �w <>5¢74[X3 Ä\Å O ��] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � 74[X3t74. W 3�<}c>3B54[X369\DX0ean<>5¢04369\5 ] [X.Y=Xpk9�5236fX_Y. ] 9K043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=ZDg9;7C9 E 9\0235C9;=Xp>3�an52< WÛÅ � Å\|�Î 74<�Ë � Ë |�Ä 023 ] <\=XDX0oan<>5¹7C[X3 ] <>_1D«027:9;527 � 9\=XD'an52< W Å � Å\Å�Î 74< Å � z�| � 023 ] <\=XDX0an<>5�74[X3¶�t9\5 W 027C9\527/�y[�36=»7C[X3Z= U W¶E 3B5/<\aº7C3B5 W 0/f¸3B5/l U 365 F c;9\54.Y360Kan54< WôÄ 7C3B5 W 0�7C< zÂÄ;Ì7C3B5 W 0 �

� z

Page 88: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

|[)�¡ ��Õ��6<FE�?GA��s [X.Y0b023 ] 7C.1<\=q.Y=�c>36087C.Yp�9;7C3B0¢02fg9 ] 3�9;=XDq74. W 3 ] <\027C0San<>5 U fiDg9;74.1=XpmDX9;7:9 E 9\043B0¢5236_h9�7C36D�74<K5236fX_Y. ] 9043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � �y[X. ] [%.Y= ] _ U DX3 ] <>02740oan54< W U fiDg9;74.1=Xp�5236fX_Y. ] 9\0 � 9\=XD U fiDg9;74.1=Xp¶74[X3/5236fX_Y. ] 9�0436_Y3 ]Ú½7C.Y<>=@Dg9;7C9 E 9\023 � � 3k74[X36=�0 U p\p>36087 U f¸Dg9�7C.1=�p�087C549;7C3Bp>.13B0 E 9\043BD)<>=%74[X36023 ] <>02740 �

�SÿT�`ÿ¦þ â�d gBü�g ced ý ù û>sSÞ�ü ò a ß ñ à�ûF ò_i Þ�g� 3 ] < W fg9\543/7É��<©9\fXfX52<�9 ] [X3B0K74< U f¸Dg9�7C.1=�p�74[X3k543BfX_1. ] 9\0 �

y £V��¹1���É��Ñ8�\�i£$Ñ8��£�£ ½ DX36_Y3B7C3m74[X3y<>_1DZDX< ]6U W 3B=�740¹9\=XD�7C[X3B.15A.1=�c\36527436D�_1.Y027C0¢an54< W 74[X3mDg9;7C99\=�D�.Y=XDX3�µ«jg_13B0y<\ae9Z5236fX_Y. ] 9 � 9\=XD�9\DXD@=X3���<>=X3B0 �

y �C�6ª6¡V¥Ç¹¾£ ½«E U .Y_1D%7C[�3q5236fX_Y. ] 9¶an54< W 7C[X3k0 ] 5C9;7 ] [ �

w <>5A< E 7C9\.1=�.1=Xp�74[X3 U fiDg9;7C.Y=Xp W 369\0 U 543 W 36=�740 � �t3yDX.Y543 ] 7C_ F U 0236D«<\5 W <VDX.YjX36DZ7C[X3yfX52<>p>549 W 0fX52<ÂcV.YDX36D E�F J = Á U 3B5 F c>365204.Y<>= Ç � z � w <>5 �C�6ª6¡^¥Ç¹¾£ � �t3 U 043BD'7C[X3 J = Á U 365 F .1=XDX3Úµ^.1=Xp�fX54<>p\5C9 W¥��iª6¡V¥Ç¹¾£ 74< E U .1_YD�7C[�3�5236fX_Y. ] 9�an54< W 7C[X3@0 ] 5C9�7 ] [ � w <>5 £V��¹1���L��Ñ8�\�i£$Ñ8��£�£ � ��3 W <VDX.YjX36D�7C[�3J = Á U 3B5 F fX52<>p>5C9 W �i¡V� §V�4£�ªQÑq¢���� 7C<DX36_Y3B743 D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0�9\=XD W <^DX.¾a F 74[X3 ] <>52543B04fi<>=XDX.Y=Xp.1=�c\36527436D�_1.1087C0 � 9\=XD U 0236D ¥��\���\�C�}� 7C<�fg9\52043q=X3B�!DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0 � 9\=XD �«��� §V� ª6�_¹ 74< W 3B54p>3�7C[�3.1=�c\36527436D%_Y.102740º<\a`=X3���D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0t.Y=�7C<�74[X3�DX9;7:9 E 9\043 � s 9 E _13KË � z�Ç _1.Y02740¹74[X3 U fiDg9;74.1=Xpk7C. W 3an<>5/5236fX_Y. ] 9\0��y.Y74["DX.Yظ365236=�7k04. ¿ 360/�y[�36="�t3 U 023©9%02.1=Xp>_Y3 r ? R <>= 9 Ç ½ r ? R ,�à r +�_1fX[X9043B52c\365 Ô ] _Y< ] ´;36D9;7 Ä>Î;Å d H/G`Õ � � 3 ] <>=X087C5 U�] 7C3BD7436087@5436f�_1. ] 9\0 E�F fX. ] ´�.1=Xp�DX< ]6U W 3B=�740an54< W 0 U E ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0o<\aS7C[�3 Ä O � syu à r Ä#"�Ç ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=©.1=@9�54< U =XD ½ 54< E .Y='a¦9\04[�.1<>= � s [X3= U W�E 36520�.1=�74[X3�7:9 E _13¶9\543q7C[X3Z9�c\365C9;p>3�7C. W 3B0�<}c>3B5/7C[X52363�5 U =X0 � w <>5�3�9 ] ["Dg9�7:9«fi<>.1=�7�<>=7C[�3�5236fX_Y. ] 9Z02. ¿ 3 � �t3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C3BD�74[X3�7C. W 3B0y�y[�36=���3 U f¸DX9;7C3 Ä\Ŧq'� Ë Å¦q'�iÆ>Ŧq'� 9\=�D Ì>Å#q <\a9'543BfX_1. ] 9 ��T .Y= ] 3 �C�6ª6¡V¥Ç¹¾£ E U .1_YDX0�74[X3Z543BfX_1. ] 9©an52< W 74[X3Z0 ] 5C9;7 ] [ � 7C[X3¶74. W 3¶an<>5 U f¸Dg9�7C.1=�p%9543BfX_1. ] 9�.Y0m<>=X_ F 543B_h9;7436D@7C<Z7C[X3k02. ¿ 3k<\a¢543BfX_1. ] 9 �s [X3'52360 U _Y740¶04[�<Â�Ê74[g9;7¶�y[�36=���3 U fiDg9;7C3 Ä\Ŧq <\amD�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0�.Y=�9)5236fX_Y. ] 9 � £V��¹1���É��Ñ8�\�i£$Ñ��£�£ fi3658an<>5 W 0�02.1p>=�.Yj ] 9\=�7C_ F'E 3�747C3B5�74[g9\= �C�6ª6¡V¥Ç¹¾£ � s [�3¶0 W 9\_Y_1365m74[X3¶5236fX_Y. ] 9�.10 � 74[X3 E 3B727C3B5£V��¹1���É��Ñ8�\�i£$Ñ8��£�£ fi3652an<\5 W 0 � � [X3B=«��3 U fiDg9;743 W <>543y7C[g9;='Ë Å¦q <\aIDX< ]BU W 36=�7C0�.1='9q543BfX_1. ] 9 ��C�6ª6¡^¥Ç¹¾£ .Y0�< U 5 ] [X<\. ] 3 � 3602f¸3 ] .19\_1_ F an<>5�_19\54p\3�5236fX_Y. ] 9;0 � s [X3�_h9\52p>365º7C[X3�5436f�_1. ] 9�.Y0 � 7C[X3 E 3B727C3B5

� Ä

Page 89: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

~ ^ < h �J13KM1�651 s ($b ` s GJ`0`��1340KMYM/�( ;$8 �{4n` (f6YMb0N£�¼1�25/313b�65(�N�1 �B1�U ^ YMKM`I�Yp�31 �{;�/ h j�m } l m } x m } y m }g m�maE�� l | ¹ j i$l m hMg j m hpg | m h j g m h j x m hMg�yj�m�maE�� i�l ¹ w$y�y m h j�j m h t g m h l�t m h w | m h t�xw m�maE�� g�l g ¹ y�y j m hkw m m h y�x g�h t�w g�h i | m h i jg ��� j y�t ¹ | x�l g�h j t j h t�w l�h m w x h j w g�h y�ij���� w�x | ¹ w j i j h i�x x h i�t g�w�h l�x j w0h w�i t0h | tí Þ��! ¦à �bÿ¦þ`�Iÿ R fiDg9;74.1=Xp�74. W 3�an<>5m543BfX_1. ] 9\0o�y.¾7C[@DX.¾ØÖ3B5436=�7K04. ¿ 3B0 Ô [X< U 520 Õ �

�C�6ª6¡^¥Ç¹¾£ fi3658an<>5 W 0 � w <\5�3ÚµX9 W fX_Y3 � an<>5 U f¸Dg9�7C.1=�p Æ>Ŧq <\a`9 z O � 543BfX_1. ] 9 � �C�6ª6¡^¥Ç¹¾£ .10 Ä 7C. W 360a¦9\087C365�74[g9\= £V��¹1���É��Ñ8�\�i£$Ñ8��£�£ {¹an<>5 U f¸DX9;7C.Y=Xp Æ>Ŧq <\a�9 Ä O � 543BfX_1. ] 9 � �C�6ª6¡V¥Ç¹¾£ .Y0�Ë»7C. W 360a¦9\087C365m74[g9\= £V��¹1���L��Ñ8�\�i£$Ñ8��£�£ �+�=�<\7C[X3B5K9\D�c;9\=�7:9\p\3�<\a U 04.1=�p �C�6ª6¡V¥Ç¹¾£ .Y0o7C[X3 �C�6ª6¡V¥Ç¹¾£ fX52< ] 36D U 543k.10 W U�] [ W <>543�369\04.Y_ F fg9\5 ½9\_Y_136_Y. ¿ 36D»7C[g9;= £V��¹1���L��Ñ8�\�i£$Ñ8��£�£ � s [�3 �C�6ª6¡^¥Ç¹¾£ f�54< ] 36D U 543 ] <>=X02.1087C0�<\at7É�t<»fg9;527C0 � fg9\5204.1=�pDX< ]6U W 36=�740«.1=�74<�.Y=�74365 W 3BDX.h9;743%jg_13B0 � 9\=�D W 3B54p>.Y=Xp»7C[X3�.1=�7C3B5 W 36DX.19;7C3%jg_Y360�.1=�7C< .1=�DX. ] 360 ��y[X3B543y7C[X3Kfg9\5204.1=�pqfX9\527�9 ]B] < U =�740�an<>5º9\52< U =XD | Ë q <\aÖ74<\7:9\_ E U .1_YDX.1=�p/7C. W 3 � � 3 ] 9\=«369\04.Y_ Ffg9\587C.¾7C.1<\={9'543BfX_1. ] 9�.1=�7C<%023Bc>3B5C9\_®0 W 9\_1_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 � 9\=�D fX9\54023�3�9 ] ["<\aº74[X3 W .1=»fg9;5C9\_Y_136_ �9\=XD»74[X36= W 3654p\3�7C[X3Z.Y=�74365 W 3BDX.h9;743�jg_Y360 � J a�< U 5 W 9 ] [X.Y=X3Z.10 ¥ ½ r ? R W U _¾7C.YfX54< ] 3B0404<\5 � ��3] 9;=@jX=X.102[�523 E U .1_1D�.1=Xp�.1=%=X369\54_ F �� �[' � �y[X3B543('!.Y0t7C[�3 E U .1_YDX.1=�p¶7C. W 3 U 04.Y=XpZ<>=X3 r ? R � 9;[email protected]= s 9 E _Y3qË � z}Ç � J a®��3k543 E U .1_YD�9 Ä\Å O � 5436f�_1. ] 9 U 04.Y=Xp�Ë r ? R 0 � �t3 W 9 F jg=X.Y04[@.Y7y.Y=_13B040m7C[X9\= z�Å [�< U 540 �?®9;527C.¾7C.Y<>=X.1=�p{9\=.1=�DX3�µ�.10�=X<;7Z7C54.¾cV.h9\_º�t<\54´�_Y.1´\3«fg9\5274.Y74.1<>=X.Y=Xp�DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 � J 7Z7:9\´;360 Î ½ ÆW .1= U 7C3B0¹74<¶0236p W 36=�7t74[X3K.1=XDX3Úµ©<\a`9 Ä O �Ù] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � 9;=XD'9\=©[X< U 5º7C<�043Bp W 3B=�7t7C[�3�.1=�DX3�µ<\aÖ9 Ä;Å O ��] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � w <>5 £V��¹1���L��Ñ8�\�i£$Ñ8��£�£ � .Yai�t3y[g9�c>3�9 ¥ ½ r ? R W U _¾7C.YfX54< ] 3B0404<\5 � ��3 ] 9\=jg=X.Y04[ U fiDg9;74.1=Xp¶.1='=X369\54_ F �� �U' " ´ � �y[X3B543�'.10�7C[X3 U f¸Dg9�7C.1=�p¶7C. W 3 U 04.Y=XpZ<>=X3 r ? R 9;=XD´ .Y0m7C[X3k043Bp W 36=�7:9;74.1<>=%74. W 3 �w <>5 �C�6ª6¡V¥Ç¹¾£ � 7C[�3Z04fg9 ] 3Z543Bl U .1543BD»7C< U fiDg9;743Z9'543BfX_1. ] 9«.Y0�9\54< U =XD Ä 7C. W 3B0�7C[�3�04. ¿ 3Z<\aº7C[�3543BfX_1. ] 9 � w <>5 £V��¹1���É��Ñ8�\�i£$Ñ8��£�£ � 7C[X3�04fX9 ] 3�543Bl U .1543BD�.Y0 Ô Ä �O¯ q@"vz Õ 74. W 360/74[X3�04. ¿ 3©<;at7C[�3

� Ç

Page 90: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

�B1�40KMYM/�(aI�Y}��1g m�maE�� j�m�mdE�� w m�m¬E�� g ��� jy��� j�m����6YM<a1�':<aYpb h * m h w m h y g�h l j h i l�h t x�x h |')(�*96YM<d1@8:;�2BN�1�b0132�(f65Ypb N¬YMb�61325<a1�`�Y�(f651�¤ Kp1�')<aYpb ^ 651�7�*� ;�KMKp1P/©6YM;�b�I�Yp�31jy���Q? ��+ � j � t j�my��� � � �g 21�4 h t 25134 h w 21�4 h g 21�4 h t 25134 h w 21�4 h6YM<a1�':<aYpb h * g�h y g�h y g�h i t m h y t g�h m t0g�h t':Un* 6YM<d1D8:;�2B<a1325N�YMb0NaYpb�61�2<a1P`�YM($61�¤ KM1�7@')<aYpb ^ 651�7�*

í ÞY�F nà �Sÿ¦þ¦�bÿ R f¸DX9;7C.Y=XpZ7C. W 3�an<>5m5236fX_Y. ] 9�0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�DX9;7:9 E 9\043 Ô W .1= U 74360 Õ �

543BfX_1. ] 9 � �y[X36523%µ q .10�74[X3 U fiDg9;74.1=Xp{fi365 ] 3B=�7C9\p>3 � w <>5 U f¸Dg9�7C.1=�p{f¸3B5 ] 36=�7:9\p\360�_13B040�7C[X9\=Î\Ŧq'� £V��¹1���É��Ñ8�\�i£$Ñ8��£�£ U 043B0�_Y36020K02fg9 ] 3 �

�SÿT�`ÿT� â�d gBü�g ced ý ù û>sSÞ�ü ò a ß�ü ú à ñ à�û! ò_i Þ î à` nà i ü ò d�aÙê Þ^ü}Þ��bÞ�g6à+�a�74365S�t3 U f¸DX9;7C3¹543BfX_1. ] 9\0 � ��3 W U 087¢74[X36= U f¸DX9;7C3º7C[X3�543BfX_1. ] 9y0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=¶Dg9;7C9 E 9\023 � � 3ºjg54087p>3B=X36549;7C3m7C[�3m.1=�7C3B5 W 36DX.19;7C3tjX_1360ean52< W 74[X3y.1=XD�3�µ^360º<\ai7C[X3m<\54.1p\.1=g9\_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=Z9;=XD©5236fX_Y. ] 9\0 �9\=XD�74[X36= W 3652p>3«7C[�3%.1=�7C3B5 W 36DX.19;7C3�jg_13B0¶7C<{74[X3%543BfX_1. ] 9)0236_13 ] 74.1<>=�Dg9�7:9 E 9;043 � � 3'�y54<\7439'fX52<>p>5C9 W 74<%p>36=X3B5C9;743�9\=».1=�7C3B5 W 36DX.19;7C3qjg_13�7C[g9;7k<\=X_ F ´\3B36fX0�7C[�3ZDX< ]BU W 36=�7�an543Bl U 36= ] F9\=XD ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=»7C365 W an5436l U 3B= ] F <\am369 ] [�7C3B5 W an54< W 3�9 ] [ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= È 543BfX_1. ] 9'.Y=XDX3�µ � 9;=XDU 0236D�7C[X3 J = Á U 3B5 F c\365204.1<\= Ç � z fX52<>p>549 W �«���ø§V� ª6�_¹ 74< W 3B54p>3t74[X36023y.1=�7C3B5 W 36DX.19;7C3tjX_1360 � � 3< E 7C9\.1=�36D)< U 5 W 3�9\0 U 543 W 3B=�7C0 U 02.1=Xp«9 r ? R <>={9 Ç ½ r ? R ,�à r +�_1fX[X9©043B52c\365 ] _Y< ] ´;36D»9�7Ä>Î\Å d H�G �s 9 E _13�Ë � z Ë�_1.Y027C0�74[X3 U f¸Dg9�7C.1=�p@74. W 3Zan<>5�7C[X3�543BfX_1. ] 9%043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�DX9;7:9 E 9\043B0��y.Y74[�D�.Yظ36543B=�7= U W�E 365�<;ay5436f�_1. ] 9\0�9;=XD�DX.Yظ365236=�7Z02. ¿ 3B0�<\am74[X3'<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � s 9 E _13©Ë � z Ë Ô 9 Õ _1.Y027C07C[�3K74. W 3oan<>5�p\36=X3B5C9;74.1=Xpk7C[X3K.1=�74365 W 36D�.h9;743ojg_13yan54< W 7C[X3K.1=XD�3�µ�<\aI9�543BfX_1. ] 9/�y[X3B=«�t3Kc;9\5 F7C[�3/04. ¿ 3/<\a`74[X3/5236fX_Y. ] 9 � s 9 E _13�Ë � z Ë Ô E Õ _1.Y02740�7C[�3�7C. W 3yan<>5 W 3652p>.1=�p�7C[�3/.1=�7C3B5 W 36DX.19;7C3yjg_Y360 �w <>5 E <\7C[ Ä O � 9\=XD Ä\Å O ��] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � ��3�_Y.1027t7C[X3 W 3654p\.1=Xp�74. W 3/an<>5 z 5236fX_Y. ] 9¶�y.Y7C[@7C[�3

� Ë

Page 91: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

04. ¿ 3�<\a Î\Å>Å d � �^Ç 5236fX_Y. ] 9;0¹�y.¾7C[«02. ¿ 360t<;a Ç>Å>Å d � � Ë Å>Å d � � 9\=XD Î\Å\Å d � � 9\=XD Î 543BfX_1. ] 9\0�y.Y74[@04. ¿ 360y<\a z}Å>Å d � �iÄ;Å>Å d � ��Ç>Å>Å d � � Ë Å>Å d � � 9\=�D Î\Å\Å d ���� [X3B=©7C[�3K02. ¿ 3K<;a¸74[X3�<\54.1p\.1=g9\_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=Z.Y0 Ä O � � .¾7A7:9\´;360�9\54< U =XD z�ÅqW .1= U 74360e7C< U fiDg9;7439«5236fX_Y. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=)Dg9�7:9 E 9;043¶�y.¾7C[ Î 5436f�_1. ] 9\0 � � [X3B={7C[X3�02. ¿ 3¶<\aA74[X3¶<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=.10 Ä\Å O � � .Y7t7C9\´\3B0y9\54< U =XD'<>=�3�9\=XD%[g9;_Ya`[X< U 5tan<>5 U f¸DX9;7C.Y=XpZ9¶5236fX_Y. ] 9q043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%Dg9;7C9 E 9\023�y.Y74[ Î 5236fX_Y. ] 9\0 �s [X3Z02fg9 ] 3Z5236l U .Y5436D{74< U fiDg9;743�7C[X3�5236fX_Y. ] 9©043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=»Dg9;7C9 E 9\023�.10�9\54< U =XD z � Î 7C. W 3B0�7C[�304. ¿ 3�<\a¹7C[X3�5236fX_Y. ] 9'0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>="Dg9�7:9 E 9;043 � w <>5�74[X3 Ä O � syu à r Ä#"�Ç ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � 7C[�3�02. ¿ 3<\aA74[X3Z543BfX_1. ] 9©0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=»DX9;7:9 E 9\043�.Y0�9\52< U =XD»Ë Æ d � � 9\=�D{7C[ U 0 U fiDg9;74.1=Xp©=X363BDX0q9\54< U =XD� Å d ��� w <>5/7C[�3 Ä\Å O � Ñ/P¢r ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 7C[�3�02. ¿ 3©<\a�7C[X3�543BfX_1. ] 9%043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= Dg9;7:9 E 9\043�.Y09\52< U =XD � Î\Å d � � 9;=XD%7C[ U 0 U f¸DX9;7C.Y=XpZ=X363BDX0 z � z O ���

�SÿT�`ÿT� ù û>sSÞ�ü ò a ß î ü�ý�Þ^ü}à�ß ò à`g+�_¾7C[X< U p>[ U fiDg9;7C.Y=Xp 9 _19\54p\3%5436f�_1. ] 9».10�7C. W 3 ½É] <>=X0 U W .Y=Xp � an<>527 U =g9;7436_ F>� 7C[X3@027C9;7C.Y0274. ] 0�.Y=T 3 ] 7C.Y<>=»Ë � z � Ç 04[X<}�-7C[g9;7�9'5436f�_1. ] 9 E U .1_Y7 U 04.Y=Xp'7C<\fX. ] 0�7C[g9�7�< ]B]6U 52543BD"9'Dg9 F 9\p>< � 3Bc\36=�9W <>=�7C[�9;p>< W 9 F 0C9;74.108a F 9�02.1p>=X.¾j ] 9;=�7�= U W�E 365q<\aol U 3B54.Y360 � � 3©D�<)=X<\7�=X3B36D�74< U fiDg9;743543BfX_1. ] 9\0�[X< U 52_ F\� <>5t3Bc>3B=@Dg9\.1_ F>� �y[X. ] [ W 9\´;360t74[X3 ] <\027C0�an<>5 U fiDg9;74.1=Xp¶5436f�_1. ] 9\0o9�ØÖ<>52Dg9 E _Y3 �H <}�!<\a�7C3B=@74< U f¸DX9;7C3�5236fX_Y. ] 9;0m.10oDX< W 9\.Y= ½ D�36fi36=XDX3B=�7 ��T < W 3/DX< W 9\.Y=X0o0 U�] [{9\0m=X3��y0�9;=XDjg=g9;= ] 3 W 9 F =X363BD U f¸DX9;7C3B0 W <\543q<\a�7C3B=)7C[g9;={<\7C[�36540 ��T < W 3�7C. W 360�9«0 F 087C3 W =X3B36DX0�74< E 3U fiDg9;7436D�. W�W 3BDX.h9;7436_ F D U 3�7C<�04< W 3 E U 52027 F 3�c>36=�740 �M =X3¶087C549;7C3Bp F an<>5 U f¸Dg9�7C.1=�p«543BfX_1. ] 9\0K.10y7C< U fiDg9;7C3�543BfX_1. ] 9\0�9;7/5236p U _h9\5y.1=�743652c;9\_Y0 � 0 UX] ["9;03Bc\365 F ��3636´ � s [X3/D�.10C9;D�c;9\=�7:9\p>3B0t<\aÖ7C[X.Y0t02745C9;7436p F 9\523�74[g9;7o.¾7 ] < U _YD«54369 ] 7�7C<V<¶02_1<}�y_ F 7C<¶9E U 52027 F 3Bc\36=�7k0 UX] [ 9\0K7C[X3 T 7:9;545�5236fi<>527 � 9;=XD».Y7 ] < U _1D��t9\087C3¶74. W 3q�y[X3B={7C[X3q7C<>f�. ] 0K7C[g9�7U 0236540k9;543¶.Y=�7C365236087C36D".Y= ] [g9\=Xp\3¶c>3B5 F 02_1<}�y_ F � J ={<>52DX365�7C<'<}c>3B5 ] < W 3�74[X36023�fX52< E _13 W 0 � ��3fX52<>f¸<\043k<\7C[�365m7É�t< W <>543�0236_13 ] 74.Yc>3k087C5C9�7C36p\.1360 �

y Ãec>3B=�7�7454.Yp>p>365236D U fiDg9;74.1=Xp � �t9;7 ] [an<>5 E U 54087 F 3Bc\36=�7C0 � 9\=�D7454.Yp>p>365q7C[X3 U f¸Dg9�7C.1=�pfX52< ] 36D U 543��y[X36=�04< W 3k04fi3 ] .h9\_I3�c>3B=�740�[g9;fXf¸3B= �

� Î

Page 92: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

y ?b3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3�7C52.1p>p>3B543BD U fiDg9;7C.Y=Xp � �t9;7 ] [74[X3«fi365 ] 3B=�7C9\p>3%<\at�t<>52´�_1<�9\D�0¶7C[g9�7¶7C[�35236fX_Y. ] 9�0236_Y3 ] 74<>5y043B=XDX0y7C<Z7C[X3k5236fX_Y. ] 9;0 � 9\=�D�7454.1p\p>365t74[X3 U fiDg9;7C.Y=XpZfX52< ] 36D U 523q�y[�36=74[X3kf¸3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3ka¦9\_Y_10 E 36_Y<}��04< W 3/74[X543B04[X<>_YD �

w <>5º7C[X3�3Bc>3B=�7o7C52.1p>p>3B543BD U fiDg9;74.1=Xp�027C549;7C3Bp F>� 7C[X3�3�9\02.13B027t�t9 F 74< U 023/.Y7¹.Y0¹74[X54< U p>['[ U W 9\=.1=�743652c\36=�7C.Y<>= � � [X36=�7C[�3%0 F 02743 W W 9\=g9\p>3B5��t9;7 ] [�360©9{04fi3 ] .19\_o3�c>36=�7 � 9\=XD�.Y= ] 523�9\02.1=Xp\_ FW 9\= F U 043B540¶.Y040 U 3«l U 3B54.13B0�74<�023�9\5 ] [�.Y7 � 74[X3 W 9\=g9;p>365 ] < U _1D�027:9;527q7C[X3 U fiDg9;7C.Y=Xp�fX54< ] 3 ½D U 523 E 3Ban<\543�7C[X3�0 ] [�36D U _Y36D�74. W 3 � + U 74< W 9;7C. ] 3Bc>3B=�7�DX3�7C3 ] 7C.Y<>=�.Y0�9;=�<>= ½ p><>.Y=Xp%543B04369\5 ] [7C<\fX. ];� � [�36=�7C[X3'743 ] [X=�<>_1<>p F ] 9;= E 3'c\365 F 3BÀ ] .Y36=�7C_ F . W fX_Y3 W 36=�7C3BD � ��3 ] 9\= U 023%.Y7¶74<9 U 74< W 9;7C. ] 9\_Y_ F DX3�7C3 ] 7�74[X3k3Bc\36=�7C0�9\=XD%7C52.1p>p>3B5o7C[X3 U fiDg9;74.1=XpZf�54< ] 36D U 543 �s [X3mfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3t7C52.1p>p>3B543BD U f¸DX9;7C.Y=Xp/02745C9;7436p F .10bc>365 F 3�9;0 F 74<�. W fX_13 W 3B=�7e.1=�7C[X3 ]BU 545236=�70 F 087C3 W � � 3 ] 9\=@_13�7t7C[�3�5436f�_1. ] 9¶043B_13 ] 7C<\5m543 ] <>54D%74[X3�f¸3B5 ] 36=�7:9\p\3�<\abl U 3654.Y360m7C[X9;7m.Y7t043B=XDX07C<�3�9 ] [{543BfX_1. ] 9 � �y[X3B=)7C[�3�fi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3�a¦9;_1_10 E 3B_1<}�v9Z7C[X523604[�<>_1D � 7C[�3�0 F 087C3 W .Y=�an<>5 W 0m7C[�30 F 087C3 W W 9\=X9\p>365 � s [X3�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�7C52.1p>p>3B543BD U f¸DX9;7C.Y=Xp�02745C9;7436p F 9\_102<Z9\fXf�_ F 0o7C< E U 54087 F3Bc\36=�7C0 � .¾a¢9�_Y<\7m<\a U 043B540K04369\5 ] [�an<>5y9\=�3Bc>3B=�7�74[g9;7yDX<V360y=X<\7K3Úµ�.Y027K.1='74[X3k543BfX_1. ] 9\0 �w <>5 E U 54087 F 3Bc\36=�7C0 � �t3 ] < U _1D�¼ U 027y9\D�D%DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0m.Y=�74<�543BfX_1. ] 9\0¹�y.Y74[X< U 7tDX36_Y3B7C.Y=Xp�<\74[X36520an<>5ql U . ] ´ U fiDg9;7C.Y=Xp � �y[X. ] [�9\_102< W 3�9\=X0q�t3«=X363BD�7C<{049�c>3'02< W 3�3�µV745C9{04fX9 ] 3�an<>5 E U 54087 F3Bc\36=�7C0 �

|[)�¥ �[Z68 8\<K0�]J =�74[X.10 ] [g9;f�7C3B5 � �t3q[g9�c>3�DX.10 ]6U 02043BD)7C[X3q.1020 U 3B0�5236_19;7C3BD�74<©fg9;527C.19\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=%5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= �� 9\0236D³<>=³< U 5�9\=g9\_ F 04360�<\a�9 ] 7 U 9\_m0 F 027C3 W _1<>p\0 � 9\= JLu 0 F 02743 W ] 9;=³7C9\´\3�9\D�c;9\=�7:9;p>3%<\al U 365 F _1< ] 9\_Y.Y7 F 9\=XD�543BfX_1. ] 9;743y9k0 W 9;_1_Xfi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3K<\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0®7C<q. W fX54<}c\3mf¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 �� 3'fX543B043B=�7436DÙ9 W 3B7C[�<^D�an<\5 ] <\=X02745 UX] 7C.1=�p»9{[X.13B5C9\5 ] [ F <\ayfX9\5274.h9\_º543BfX_1. ] 9\0qan54< W 9 ] <>_ ½_13 ] 74.1<>=��y[�36543%369 ] [543BfX_1. ] 9).Y0Z9{0 U E 043B7�<\aK9;_1_¹_h9\52p>365�5436f�_1. ] 9\0 � � 3'7C[X3B=�3�µV7C3B=XDX3BDÙ7C[�3.1=^an36543B= ] 3�=X3�7É�t<\54´ W <VDX3B_®7C<@5C9;=X´»9\=XD 043B_13 ] 7qfg9\587C.h9;_®543BfX_1. ] 9\0 � � 3 ] < W fX9\543BD�< U 5�=X3B�543BfX_1. ] 9�0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�a U = ] 74.1<>=·74<�fX543�cV.1< U 0'��<>52´Ù<>= ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=Ù043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�<}c>3B5@9�5C9\=Xp\3{<\a7 U =X.1=Xp�fg9\549 W 3B7C3B540 � w <\5¶9@p>.Yc\36=�l U 365 F\� < U 5k543BfX_1. ] 9@043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�9\_Yp><>52.Y7C[ W ] <\54543 ] 74_ F DX3 ½

� Æ

Page 93: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

7C3B5 W .1=X3B0�7C[�3 W <\027�5236_13�c;9\=�7�<\aº7C[X3Z5236fX_Y. ] 9\0�<>5�<>54.Yp>.1=g9;_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � 9;=XD»7C[ U 0 W 9\.1=�7:9;.1=X07C[�3�[�.1p>[X3B027�523B7C52.13�c\9;_o3Bظ3 ] 7C.Yc\36=X3B040«�y[�.1_13«043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp 74[X3@_1369\027�Dg9�7:9"9\0 ] < W fg9\5236D��y.Y74[7C[�3¶<\74[X365�5C9\=X´�.Y=Xp©a U = ] 7C.Y<>=X0 � s [X3�04fg9 ] 3�<}c>3B54[X369\D"<\ae7C[�3¶543BfX_1. ] 9�0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=)Dg9;7C9 E 9\023¶.Y0DX.Y543 ] 7C_ F fX52<>f¸<\527C.Y<>=g9\_S7C<%74[X3�= U W�E 3B5k<\a U =X.1l U 3Z74365 W 0�.1=»74[X3Z_h9\52p>36087k543BfX_1. ] 9 � R 04.Y=Xp�9fg9\549\_1_Y36_e743 ] [X=X.Yl U 3©74< E U .Y_1D ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 � ��3 ] 9\= U fiDg9;743©5236fX_Y. ] 9;0¶9\=�D�543BfX_1. ] 9@043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=Dg9;7C9 E 9\02360o.Y=«523�9\02<>=g9 E _Y3�74. W 3 � w <>5¹3�µ�9 W fX_Y3 � �t3 ] 9\= U fiDg9;743/9 Ä\Å O � 543BfX_1. ] 9k�y.Y7C[�.1= z}Å[X< U 540��y[X3B={�t3 U 043¶an< U 5 Ä>Î;Å d H�G³r ? R 0 � M a ] < U 54023¶�t3 ] 9\=»DX< U f¸DX9;7C.Y=Xp©a¦9\087C3B5��y.Y74[9 W 9 ] [X.Y=X3��y.¾7C[ W <>543¶9\=XD È <>5�a¦9\087C3B5 r ? R 0 � +�_Y7C[�< U p>[ U f¸Dg9�7C.1=�p«_h9;54p>3�5436f�_1. ] 9\0K.10�c\365 F] <\027C_ F>� an<>587 U =g9�7C36_ F>� 7C[�3�087:9;74.10274. ] 0ºan52< W 7C[�3�523�9\_g0 F 087C3 W _Y<>p>0º04[X<}��74[g9;7 U fiDg9;7C.Y=Xpk[X< U 52_ F<>5¹Dg9\.Y_ F .Y0 U =X=X3 ] 36020C9\5 F � � 3�9\_102<�f�54<>fi<>043BD©7É��<�04. W f�_13m02745C9;7436p>.Y360ºan<>5 U f¸DX9;7C.Y=Xp�5236fX_Y. ] 9\0 �J = T 3 ] 7C.Y<>= Æ � Ä^� ��3��y.Y_1_bDX3 W <>=X087C549;7C3¶74[X3Zfi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3¶p�9\.1=)<\a¹fg9\5274.h9\_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>={5236fX_Y. ½] 9�7C.1<\= U =XDX365yDX.¾ØÖ3B543B=�7K0 F 087C3 W ] <>=�jXp U 5C9�7C.1<\=X0K9\=XD U 043B5�fX9;74743654=�0 �

�#�

Page 94: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

���v�'&����)� Ô

����� �K��( ����� ��� $ & ( $ !���

J =q<>54DX3B5`7C<K3�µ^f¸3BDX.Y743º< U 5S.1=�c>3B0274.1p�9;74.1<>=k<\a^fi<>0402. E _Y3A0 F 02743 W ] <>=^jgp U 549;7C.Y<>=X0 � ] [g9\549 ] 743652.10274. ] 0<\a JLu ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0 � 9\=XDZ7C[X3m0 F 027C3 W fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3�an<>5eDX.Y027C52. E U 7C36DZ.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=q543�7C52.13Bc;9\_�9\5 ½] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 52360¹.1_Y_ U 087C5C9�7C36DZ.Y= r [g9\f�74365 Ç�� �t3K. W fX_13 W 3B=�7º9�04. W U _h9;74<>5®�y.¾7C[�= U W 3B54< U 0�0 F 087C3 Wfg9\549 W 3B7C3B540 � 9\=�D�c;9\_1.YDg9;743Z.Y7q9\p�9;.1=X087q74[X3�fX54<\74<\7 F f¸3�. W fX_Y3 W 36=�7:9;74.1<>= � J =�7C[�.10 ] [g9\f�74365 ���3�fX52360236=�7�74[X3k04. W U _h9�7C.1<\= W <VDX3B_ �J = < U 5�04. W U _19;7C<>5 � ��3 W <VDX36_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0�9\=�D l U 3B54.Y360 E�F < E 7C9\.1=X.Y=Xp%027C9;7C.Y0274. ] 0�an54< W 7C36087] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0/9\=XD"54369\_Al U 365 F 043�7C0 � � 3 W <VDX36_¢l U 365 F fX54< ] 3B0404.Y=Xp�9\=XD"DX< ]6U W 36=�7k543�7C52.13Bc;9\_E�F�W 3�9\0 U 54.Y=Xp�543B04< U 5 ] 3 U 049\p>3B0ean<>5e3�9 ] [©<>fi36549;7C.Y<>=�.Y=�< U 5 W U _Y7C.¾7C[X523�9\D�36D�fX52<\7C<;7 F fi3 � s [X3[g9\52D��t9\543���3 W <^D�36_I.Y= ] _ U DX3 r ? R 0 � D�.104´�0 � J È M E U 0 �gW 3 W <\5 F>� 9\=XD@7C[X3k=X3�7É�t<>52´ �M U 5�04. W U _h9;74<>5�[g9;0�7É��<�7 F f¸3B0«<\a�fg9\549 W 3�7C3B540 � 0 F 02743 W ] <\=�jgp U 549;7C.Y<>=³fg9\5C9 W 3�7C36520«9;=XD0 F 087C3 W W 3�9;0 U 523 W 36=�7qfg9\5C9 W 3�7C36520 � s [X3�0 F 087C3 W ] <>=�jgp U 5C9;74.1<>="fg9;5C9 W 3B7436540k.Y= ] _ U DX3�7C[�3= U W�E 365�<\aÖ74[X54369\DX0 � = U W�E 365t<;aIDX.Y04´�0 � = U W�E 3B5t<\a r ? R 0 � ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�04. ¿ 3 � 7C3B5 W an543Bl U 36= ] FDX.Y027C52. E U 7C.1<\= � l U 3B5 F _Y36=Xp;7C[ � ] < W�W 9\=�DZ9\5452.Yc;9\_V5C9;743 � ] < W�W 9\=�D W . µV7 U 523t5C9�7C.1< � 543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=fi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3 � D�.102745C9 ] 7C.Y=Xp@f¸3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3 � 9\=XD�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�fi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3 � s [�3«0 F 087C3 W W 3�9\0 U 543 ½W 36=�7«fX9\5C9 W 3B7436520�.Y= ] _ U DX3@l U 365 F 3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>=�7C. W 3 � DX< ]6U W 36=�7�543�7C52.13Bc;9\_o74. W 3 � =X3B7É��<>52´7C. W 3 � ] <\=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 54<>´;365�7C. W 3 � 9\=XD"7C. W 3q7C< W 3654p\3Z54360 U _Y740 � s [X3�0 F 087C3 W ] <>=�jXp U 5C9�7C.1<\=c;9\_ U 360kDX3�9;_º�y.¾7C["7C[X3 ] <\=�jgp U 549;7C.Y<>="<\at74[X3�0 F 02743 W 9\=XD�Dg9;7:9@_h9 F < U 7q<>="7C[X3�DX.102´�0 � 9;=XD] [g9\=�p>3%�y.Y7C[369 ] [Ù02. W U _h9;74.1<>=�0 ] 3B=g9\52.1<"<>5Zp>52< U f<\a�0 ] 3B=g9\52.1<>0 � s [X3@0 F 02743 W W 3�9\0 U 543 ½W 36=�7C0qDX3�9;_º�y.¾7C[�9 ] [g9;=Xp>3«<;at7C[�3 JLu 0 F 087C3 W 9\=�D�7C[�3 U =�DX3652_ F .1=Xp�[g9\52D��o9;543�fX_h9;72an<>5 W �s [X3�< U 74f U 7C0k<\a¹7C[�3�02. W U _h9;74<>5/.1= ] _ U DX3Z543B04fi<>=X043�7C. W 3B0/an<>5�3�9 ] [ JLu ] < W©W 9\=XD � U 7C.Y_1. ¿ 9 ½7C.Y<>=X0¹<\a`369 ] ['[g9\52D��t9\543�543602< U 5 ] 3 � 0 UX] [@9\0º7C[�3 r ? R U 74.1_Y. ¿ 9�7C.1<\=�9\=XD«74[X3�DX.Y04´ U 74.1_Y. ¿ 9�7C.1<\= �

� Ì

Page 95: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

9\=XD U 74.1_1. ¿ 9;74.1<>=�0�<\a�3�9 ] [ JLu 02<\a�7É�o9;543�0 F 02743 W ] < W fi<>=X36=�7 � 0 UX] [�9;0/7C[X3 J = Á U 3B5 F 043B52c\365U 74.1_1. ¿ 9;74.1<>=«9\=XD@7C[X3 ] <>=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 54<>´;365 U 74.1_1. ¿ 9;74.1<>= �� 3 U 023 x + r T J d � 9kfX54< ] 3B040t<\54.13B=�7C36D©DX.10 ] 523B7C3�3Bc\36=�7m04. W U _19;7C.Y<>=Z_h9\=�p U 9\p>3pL Ë Ì N�74<�. W fX_Y3 ½W 36=�7/7C[�3�04. W U _h9�7C<>5 � x + r T J d ] <\=�7C9\.1=�0�9«043�7k<\aºDg9;7C9«02745 UX] 7 U 52360q9\=XD»_Y. E 549\5 F 52< U 74.1=X3B07C[X9;7 W 9\=g9\p>3 U 043B5 ] 54369;7C3BD�f�54< ] 3602043B0t9\=�DZ543602< U 5 ] 360 � � 3 W <^D�36_X9/02.1=Xp\_13t023658c>365 Ô J = Á U 365 F043B52c\365 � ] <>=�=X3 ] 7C.1<\= E 52<>´\3B5 � ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�0436_Y3 ] 7C<>5 � <\5�5236fX_Y. ] 9�0236_13 ] 74<>5 Õ 9\0¹9�023B7�<\aIfX52< ] 360204360 �ú9 ] [{fX52< ] 36020�02. W U _19;7C3B0m7C[X3�9 ] 74.YcV.Y7 F <\aA9�7C[X523�9\D�.1=%7C[X3q54369\_S0 F 02743 W E�F 5436l U 3B0274.1=Xp'02365 ½cV. ] 360/an54< W 523604< U 5 ] 360 � M U 5/04. W U _h9�7C.1<\= W <^DX3B_®.Y0/04. W fX_Y3 �iF 3B7 ] <>=�7:9\.Y=X0�0 U À ] .13B=�7kD�3B7:9;.1_107C< 9 ]B]6U 549;7C3B_ F 5236fX5236043B=�7©74[X3�. W fi<>587:9\=�7¶an369;7 U 54360�<\aK7C[X3�0 F 087C3 W�� 9;0���3�04[X<}� 74[X54< U p>[fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3/c;9\_Y.1Dg9�7C.1<\= �s [X3%523 W 9\.1=XD�365¶<;am7C[X3 ] [X9\f�7C3B5Z.10�<>54p�9;=X. ¿ 36D�9\0�an<>_1_Y<Â�y0 � �t3%fX52360236=�7Z7C[X3«0 F 02743 W W 3�9 ½0 U 543 W 36=�740�9\=XD�7C[�36.15qc;9\_1.YDg9;7C.Y<>= .1= T 3 ] 74.1<>= Î � z>� 9;=XD�7C[X3 ] <>=�jXp U 5C9�7C.1<\=�fg9\549 W 3�7C3B540�.Y=T 3 ] 7C.Y<>= Î � Ä �

Ôw)+( ��];W`EY.!8 ( .X<KW�Z�0�.�8\.�AwEYW <>A��ô*¶<>5G?G�6<FE�?72xAw <>5º7C[X3�3�µ^f¸3B54. W 3B=�740o.1=�7C[X.Y0tDX.Y040236527C9;7C.Y<>= � ��3 W <VDX3B_i74[X3 JLu 0 F 02743 WÛE�F 9\=X9\_ F ¿ .Y=Xp�9�fX54< ½7C<;7 F fi3/<\ab9�DX.1087C54. E U 7436D W U _Y7C.¾7C[X523�9\D�36D«.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=�523B7C52.13�c\9;_¸0 F 087C3 W E 9\0236D@<>= J = Á U 365 F9\=XD E�F�W 369\0 U 54.1=�pk74[X3y543B04< U 5 ] 3 U 0C9;p>3man<>5º3�9 ] [�<>fi365C9�7C.1<\= � � 3man< ]BU 0º<>= r ? R � D�.104´ � J È ME U 0 � 9;=XD©74[X3�=�3B7É��<>54´�543B04< U 5 ] 3B0 � w <>5 W 3 W <\5 F 9\=�D ] 9 ] [X3�3�ØÖ3 ] 7C0 � ��3�02. W fX_ F 9\040 U W 3�7C[�30 F 087C3 W .10�36.Y74[X365 ] <>_YD{027C9\527436D{�y[X3B543�=�< ] 9 ] [�3Z3Bظ3 ] 740�9\523 ] <>=�04.1D�36543BD � <>5y�t9\5 W 027C9\527436D�y[X3B543 W 3 W <\5 F .10 E .1pZ36=�< U p>[%7C<Z[�<>_1D@9\=%.Y=XDX3Úµ@9\=XD È <>5m9\=@3B=�74.1523 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � R =X_13B040o��33�µ^fX_Y. ] .Y7C_ F 087:9;743�<\74[X3658�y.1023 � 7C[X3K3�µ^fi3654. W 3B=�7C0º�t3KfX543B043B=�7m9\543 ] <\_1D�027:9;527C3BD � . � 3 � � ��3�D�<�=X<;7.1= ] _ U DX3 ] 9 ] [�3 E 36=X3�jX7C0 �� 3 W <VDX36_b7C[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=)<\a r ? R 0q9\0k9 W U _Y7C. ½ 023652c\365/f�54< ] 360204<>5 ½ 02[g9\54.Y=Xp%.1=^jg=X.Y743¶_Y36=Xp\74[l U 3 U 3 � � 3 W <VDX36_�9yDX.102´ � 7C[�3 J È M E U 0 � 9\=XD�74[X3¹=X3B7É��<>54´q9\0¢9y04.1=�p>_13 wbrow T .Y=�jg=X.¾7C3A_Y36=Xp\74[l U 3 U 3 � s [X3»fX54< ] 3B0402.1=Xp�74. W 360 Ô 043658cV. ] 3{74. W 360 Õ 9;7'9�[g9\54D^�o9\523»543B04< U 5 ] 3"9\523 W <^DX3B_13BD9\0Z9{D�3B7C3B5 W .1=X.Y0274. ] a U = ] 74.1<>=�<\ay<}c\3654[�3�9\D³fX_ U 0Z9{_1.Y=X3�9\5qa U = ] 7C.1<\=�<\am7C[X3%DX9;7:9{02. ¿ 3 Ô . � 3 �

� |

Page 96: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

¦ þ " � ¤ � ¤ ´ ��§  y) ¦ � Õ � �y[X3B543n� ¤ � ¤ ´ ��§   .10m543BfX_h9 ] 36D@�y.Y74[)9 W <>543 W 3�9\=�.1=Xp\a U _ ] <>= ] 36f^7�.Y=9�D�.Yظ36543B=�7t<>fi36549;7C.Y<>= � 0 UX] [%9\0º7C[X3y7C3B5 W an543Bl U 36= ] F .Y=«9kl U 365 F ] < W�W 9;=XD � 7C[X3K= U W�E 365¹<\aDX< ]6U W 36=�740o.1=%9�0 U W�W 9;5 F ] < W�W 9\=XD � 9\=XD«74[X3 W 36020C9\p>3�04. ¿ 3/.1='9¶=X3B7É��<>52´©7C549\=X0 W .Y0404.Y<>= �� 3{DX3B74365 W .Y=X3)7C[�3»9 ] 7 U 9\_Kc\9;_ U 3B0«<\a ¦ þ@9\=XD ¦ ��<\ak3�9 ] [�[g9;54D��t9\543»523602< U 5 ] 3{an<>5«369 ] [<>fi36549;7C.Y<>= E�F < E 7:9;.1=X.Y=Xp W 3�9\0 U 543 W 3B=�740Kan52< W < U 5 W U _Y74.Y74[X54369\DX36D%f�54<\74<\7 F f¸3 �� 3 W 369\0 U 523Z543B04< U 5 ] 3 U 049\p>3B0kan<\5/l U 365 F 3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>= � DX< ]6U W 36=�7 È 0 U W�W 9;5 F 543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_ � 543 ½0 U _Y7 W 3B54p>.Y=Xp � ] <>=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 54<>´;3654.Y=Xp � 9\=XD =X3B7É��<>52´ 745C9\=X0 W .Y0402.1<>= � � 3©3Úµ�9 W .Y=X3 syu à r] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 Ô U f%74< Ä\Å O � Õ 7C<Z< E 7C9\.1=%0 F 027C3 W W 3�9\0 U 543 W 3B=�740 Ô 043B3k+�fXfi36=XD�.¾µ%+ Õ � � 3k< E ½7:9;.1=X3BD 74[X3 W 3�9;0 U 523 W 36=�7C0 U 04.Y=Xp)9 ] _Y.13B=�7 ½ 023652c\365 JLu 0 F 02743 W E 9\043BD�<>= J = Á U 365 F c>3B5404.Y<>=Ç � z 5 U =X=X.Y=Xp@<>=�,�à r +�_YfX[g9 T 3658c>365 Ä^z}Å\Å�Î\È>Ä>Î\Å �y.Y74[ Ç r ? R 0 Ô ] _1< ] ´\3BD�9;7 Ä>Î\Å d H ¿ Õ �z}Å�Ä Ë�d � W 9;.1= W 3 W <>5 F 9\=�D Ä;Å>Å � d � <\ab08�o9\f@02fg9 ] 3 � 5 U =�=X.1=Xp�,/.Yp>.Y7C9\_ R�NKJ Í Ñ Ç � Ä , ½ zÔ u 3Bc'Ë z Õ �

�Iÿ¦þ�ÿ¦þ [ %bà�ý hÙé ï Þ� _%SÞ�ü ò d�a·í ò f�àJ =�9\=�369\54_Y.1365�027 U D F>� r 9\[X<V<>=�9;=XD�d ] � .1=X_Y3 F D�3 W <>=X02745C9;7436D 7C[g9;7k74[X3�l U 365 F 3�c\9;_ U 9;74.1<>=7C. W 3«.10�c>3B5 F 087C54<\=Xp>_ F 543B_h9;7436D�7C<»7C[�3�= U W¶E 3B5�<;a�74365 W 0Zfi365�l U 365 F 9\=XD�7C[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=an543Bl U 36= ] F <\ab3�9 ] [@<\ab7C[�3�l U 365 F 7C365 W 06L zÂÄV�Iz}Ç N � s [X3 F%W <VDX3B_¸7C[�3�l U 365 F 3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>=«7C. W 39\0�9«a U = ] 74.1<>=»<\aº74[X3�= U W�E 365�<\aº74365 W 0/fi365/l U 3B5 F 9;=XD{7C[X3�an5236l U 3B= ] F <;a¹74[X3Z.1=�DX.YcV.1D U 9\_l U 365 F 74365 W 0tf�_ U 0m9;DXDX.Y74.1<>=X9\_g<}c>3652[X3�9;DX0man<>5¹74[X3 r ? R 9\=XD«DX.102´ � s [�3�<Âc\3652[X3�9\D�0y9 ]6] < U =�7an<>5o74[X3/7C. W 3 J = Á U 365 F 02f¸3B=XDX0K<>= ] < W¶E .1=X.Y=Xp¶74[X3k54360 U _Y740y<\a®369 ] [�<\a¢74[X3/7C3B5 W 0 � � .Y74[X< U 77C[�36043�9\DXDX.¾7C.1<\=g9\_I<}c>3B54[X369\DX0 � 7C[X3�3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>=%7C. W 360K<\aA_Y<>=Xp©l U 3654.Y360�9\543 U =XDX3B5436087C. W 9;7436D �J =·74[X.10��t<\54´ � �t3»9;DX<>f�7©7C[X3B.15 W <VDX36_ �tE U 7«��3{543 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7©74[X3 W 3�9;0 U 523 W 36=�7C0 � 02.1= ] 3���3U 023�9�a¦9\0274365 W 9 ] [X.1=�3 � w <>5%3�9 ] [�<\a z O � syu à r z>��Ä O � syu à r Ä ½ Ç�� 9;=XD Ç O �syu à r z ½ Ç ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0 � ��3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C36D�74[X36.Y5�?¢3�9;5404<\=IP 0 ] <\54543B_h9;74.1<>= ] <V3BÀ ] .Y36=�7C0 E 3�7É�t3B36=7C3B5 W 3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>=¶7C. W 3B0A9\=XDZ74365 W an543Bl U 36= ] .1360 � s [X3m543B0 U _¾7C.1=�p/c\9;_ U 3B0e�t3B543 Å � | Ë ��Å � |�Î^� 9;=XD

Ì>Å

Page 97: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

¨P© ¿ ¶hª ¿P¾�½�Ý « & � ¿ � Õ¬ �p­ � ¿�¾�½�Ý «!¿ ¶P� « & � ¿ ' «!¿ ¶h� � * � º Ü � ¢ & Þ & Þ® Ü ¾�¿ ¶[¯ ¿�½ �¿P¾�½�Ý «!¿ ¶P� « & � ¿ ' «!¿ ¶P�\* � ºS°"© « & � ¿ ' «!¿ ¶P��* � �f& ± � « & � ¿ ' «!¿ ¶P�\* � «�²[³ ¢ © ± « & � ¿ ' «!¿ ¶P�\*º °"© « & � ¿ ' «!¿ ¶P�\* � ´µµ¶ µµ·

l ± x$l�t ¿ ¡ m t � ' i ± t�t�l ¿ ¡ m x�¸ «!¿ ¶h��* _ «!¿ ¶P�º¹ g m�m�mg ± l�x j ¿ ¡ m�j � '�j�±kj$m i ¿ ¡ m x�¸ «!¿ ¶h��* _ g m�m�m»¹ «!¿ ¶P�¼¹ g m�m�m�mj�± w$t g ¿ ¡ m�j � ' g ± m y�i ¿ ¡ m x�¸ «!¿ ¶h��* _ g m�m�m�m½¹ «!¿ ¶P�¾¹ g m�m�m�m�mg ± w$i�t ¿ ¡ m g � ' g ± x | g ¿ ¡ m | ¸ «!¿ ¶h��* _ «!¿ ¶P�º¿ g m�m�m�m�m�f& ± � « & � ¿ ' «!¿ ¶P�\* � ´µµ¶ µµ·

w ± |�| t ¿ ¡ m�j � '�j�± m l�y ¿ ¡ m w»¸ «!¿ ¶h��* _ «!¿ ¶P�º¹ g m�m�m| ± x�w�i ¿ ¡ m�j � '�j�± w$x�x ¿ ¡ m x�¸ «!¿ ¶h��* _ g m�m�m»¹ «!¿ ¶P�¼¹ g m�m�m�mi ± x m | ¿ ¡ m�j � ' w ± g�y | ¿ ¡ m | ¸ «!¿ ¶h��* _ g m�m�m�m½¹ «!¿ ¶P�¾¹ g m�m�m�m�mg ± l�x�t ¿ ¡ m�j � ' y ±kj$m y ¿ ¡ m | ¸ «!¿ ¶h��* _ «!¿ ¶P�º¿ g m�m�m�m�m«�²[³ ¢ © ± « & � ¿ ' «!¿ ¶P�\* � ´µµ¶ µµ·

w ± m | w ¿ ¡ m x � ' l ± m l�l ¿ ¡ m y�¸ «!¿ ¶h��* _ «!¿ ¶P�º¹ g m�m�mj�± t0gPy ¿ ¡ m w � ' t ± i�t�x ¿ ¡ m y�¸ «!¿ ¶h��* _ g m�m�m»¹ «!¿ ¶P�¼¹ g m�m�m�mg ±kj y�y ¿ ¡ m l � ' t ± t j i ¿ ¡ m y�¸ «!¿ ¶h��* _ g m�m�m�m½¹ «!¿ ¶P�¾¹ g m�m�m�m�mj�± y�x�i ¿ ¡ m t � ' i ± w�g�l ¿ ¡ m i�¸ «!¿ ¶h��* _ «!¿ ¶P�º¿ g m�m�m�m�mº Ü � ¢ & Þ & Þ® Ü ¾�¿ ¶[¯ ¿�½ � � m0± m | wÁÀ� ' Þ ¡�g * À Õ¬ �p­ � ¿P¾�½�Ý «!¿ ¶P� « & � ¿ ' «!¿ ¶P� � *

õ ò ß�%SýÂà �Iÿ¦þ�ÿ Á U 365 F 3�c;9\_ U 9�7C.1<\=«7C. W .Y=Xp¶c;9\_ U 360 Ô 023 ] <\=XDX0 Õ �

Å � | Ë � 543602f¸3 ] 74.Yc>3B_ F\� �y[X. ] [).1=XDX. ] 9;74360�9©c>3B5 F fi<>02.Y7C.¾c>3�5436_19;7C.Y<>=X02[X.1f � � M U 5�54360 U _Y740 ] <\=�jg5 Wr 9\[X<V<>=�9\=XD)d ] � .Y=X_13 F P 0mjg=XD�.1=Xp>0 �w .Yp U 543 Î � z _1.Y027C0o74[X3kan<>5 W U _h9\0oan<>5 ] 9\_ ]BU _h9�7C.1=�pZl U 365 F 3�c\9;_ U 9;74.1<>='74. W 3/c;9\_ U 3B0y.1=�< U 5y04. W ½U _19;7C.Y<>= � � 3 ] 54369;7C3BD'7C[X3�an<\5 W U _19\0ºan<>5  k£`¤B¡ �  k�O® �7� ®� �Ô Õ E�F jX7474.1=Xp¶74[X3�74365 W 3�c\9;_ U 9;74.1<>=7C. W 3 W 3�9\0 U 543 W 3B=�740®�y.Y74[¶an< U 5¢02745C9\.Yp>[�7®_Y.1=X3B0 U 02.1=Xp/9�_1369\027®04l U 9\523 W 3�7C[X<VD � 369 ] [Z<\aX�y[�. ] [] <}c\36540e74365 W an5236l U 36= ] .13B0 E 3B_1<}� z>� Å>Å>Å��Vz>� Å>Å>Å ½ z}Å�� Å>Å>Å��Vz}Å�� Å>Å>Å ½ z}Å>Å^�ÐÅ>Å\Å�� 9\=XDZ9 E <}c>3 z�Å>Å�� Å>Å>Å��543B04fi3 ] 7C.Yc\36_ F � s [X3 W <^DX3B_�.Y0 W <>523m9 ]B]6U 549;7C3 U 02.1=Xp�an< U 5A_Y.1=X3B0e5C9�7C[X3B5e7C[g9\=©9/04.Y=Xp>_Y3m027C549\.1p\[�7_1.Y=X3�an<>5�9\_1_`7C[�3¶Dg9;7C9 � � 3�DX.YcV.YDX3 ��À��$¹ �É���Ú� �ø¥��«��Ã�Ä .1=�7C< r ? R � D�.104´ � 9\=XD J È M E U 0�74. W 3 �+�_¾7C[X< U p>[��t3 ] 54369;7C3BD  k£`¤B¡ �  k�l® �7� ®� �Ô Õ E�F U 04.Y=Xp W 369\0 U 523 W 36=�7C0¹< E 7C9\.1=�36D©an52< W 023�9\5 ] [ ½.1=�p/7C[X3 syu à r z ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � 7C[X3man<>5 W U _19\0e9\_Y04< W 9;7 ] [���36_Y_ W 3�9\0 U 543 W 3B=�740º< E 7:9;.1=X3BD�an54< Wsyu à r Ä ½ Ç 9\=�D syu à r z ½ Ç Ô 043B3 T 3 ] 74.1<>= Î � z � Î Õ �

� �¼1�(�257;�bEÅ 79/3;�2521�KM($6YM;�b�/3;�1�Æ�/�YM13b�6B25(�b0N�1P79Un1�6!qW131�b s�g (�b ` � g�h � ($K ^ 1�7 s�g (�b ` � g YMb `�Y�/3(f651F(d4n1328:1�/�6KMYpb01P($2 21�KM($6YM;�b 7>0YM4�($b `e;�/�/ ^ 2 qB>013b�(�KpKn4n;�YMb�6�7.KMYp1J;�b�(À`�;fqBb�qW(�25`d;�2 ^ 4�qW(�25`e7KM;�40YMb0N@KMYpb 1 ¹ 21P7�4n1�/�6YMc�1�Kp� hG�cf($K ^ 1D;$8VmdYpb `0YM/�(f61P7,6> 13251FY�7,b0;eKMYpb 1�($2B2513K�(f65Yp;�b 7>0Yp4 hÌ�z

Page 98: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

R 02.1=Xpq< U 5 W 3�9\0 U 543 W 3B=�7C0 � 7C[�3K74. W 3t7C<q3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C3K9k04.Y=Xp>_13o74365 W .1=Z7C[X3 syu à r z ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=5C9;=Xp>360`an52< W�Å � Å � 043 ] <>=XD�0¢an<>5S9m7C3B5 W 9\f�f¸369\54.Y=Xpy<>= ] 3º7C< z � Ä 043 ] <>=XDX0ban<>5S9m7C365 W 9\fXfi3�9;54.1=�p|>|�ÎV�ÐÅ>Å\Ì 74. W 360 Ô 7C[X3 W 9�µ^. W U W 7C3B5 W an5236l U 3B= ] F .1= syu à r z 9�a�7C365m523 W <}c^.Y=Xp�0274<>f��t<>52DX0 Õ �s [X3 r ? R 9\=�D�DX.102´ 74. W 360�9 ]6] < U =�7Zan<>5 W <>523©7C[X9\= |>|¦q <\am74[X3«7C<;7:9\_¹3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>=�74. W 3 �s [X3 J È M E U 0�7C. W 3�9 ]6] < U =�7C0/an<\5 Å � Å>Å � q 74< z � Ŧq �y.Y7C[{9\=»9�c>3B5C9\p>3Z<;a Å � z�Ʀq � s [X3ZDX.Y04´9 ]B] 36020¶7C. W 3�.10k7 F fX. ] 9\_1_ F _h9;54p>3B5q74[g9\= r ? R f�54< ] 360204.Y=Xp{D U 3©7C<�74[X3«02f¸3B36D�<\at7C[X3'+�_1fX[X9fX52< ] 360402<>5 � M U 5 W 369\0 U 523 W 36=�7C0q04[�<Â�Ó74[g9;7kDX.Y04´"9 ]B] 3B040�74. W 3Z9 ]B] < U =�740�an<>5 Ç�Ä$q 7C< |>Ŧq<\aA74[X3�74<\7:9\_b3Bc;9\_ U 9;74.1<>=@7C. W 3k�y.Y74[»9\=»9�c>3B5C9\p\3�<\a � Ç#q � w <>5�02_1<}�t3B5�fX52< ] 360204<>520�<>5�a¦9\087C3B5DX.Y04´�0 � 74[X3 r ? R fX52< ] 360402.1=Xp W 9 F«E 3k_19\54p>3B5t7C[X9\=�D�.104´©7C. W 3 �

�Iÿ¦þ�ÿT� ê�d i %!f�à a ü ñ à�ü}ý ò à ï Þ� í ò f�à� 3 W 3�9\0 U 543 J = Á U 365 F 74</DX3B74365 W .Y=X3�74[X3o9 W < U =�7¢<\aX74. W 3�.¾7¢7C9\´\3B0®7C<�543B7454.Y3Bc>3o9�DX< ]6U W 36=�7 �T .Y= ] 3¹7C[X3o02. ¿ 3t<\ai9�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7e.1=¶< U 5¢7436087 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0b.10¢=X<\7¢c>365 F _19\54p\3 � �y[�36543�7C[X3m9�c\365C9;p>304. ¿ 3�<\ao9@D�< ]BU W 3B=�7�.Y0 Ä � Ç � � .1=»7C[X3 z O � syu à r z ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= �SÄ � | � � .1=»74[X3 Ç O �syu à r z ½ Ç ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 9\=XD Ä � Ì � � .1=q7C[X3 Ä\Å O � Ñ�Pbr ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � 74[X3tDX< ]6U W 3B=�7¢543�7C52.13Bc;9\_7C. W 3�.10/c\365 F 04[X<>587q9\=XD"DX<V360k=X<\7/04[X<}�Ó9%087C54<\=Xp@5436_19;7C.Y<>=X02[X.1f)�y.¾7C[{74[X3�DX< ]BU W 36=�7k04. ¿ 3 �s [X3»02. W U _19;7C<\5«543BfX543B043B=�740�74[X3»DX< ]6U W 36=�7%523B7454.13�c;9\_�74. W 3�an<>5%9;= J = Á U 365 F 043B52c>3B5)9;0%9] <\=X027C9\=�7Kc;9\_ U 3 �XÅ � Å>Ä � 043 ] <>=XDX0 � �y[�. ] [�.10o7C[�3�9�c\365C9;p>3kDX< ]BU W 36=�7K543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_Ö74. W 3�an<>5 Ä\Å>Å\Å5C9;=XDX< W _ F 0436_Y3 ] 7C36D·DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0�an54< W 74[X3 syu à r z ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � s [X3{9�c\365C9;p>3�02. ¿ 3�<\a/9DX< ]6U W 36=�7Z.Y0 Ä � Ç � ��� s [X3%DX< ]6U W 36=�7Z523B7C52.13�c\9;_¹74. W 3«.10¶9\_102<{DX.¾c^.YDX36D�.1=�7C<)74[X543B3%fg9\587C0 �r ? R 74. W 3 � DX.Y04´)74. W 3 � 9\=XD J È M E U 0q74. W 3 � M U 5 W 369\0 U 523 W 36=�7C0q04[�<Â�Ó74[g9;7qDX.Y04´»9 ]B] 3B0407C. W 3�9 ]B] < U =�740«an<>5 Ì � q <\a�74[X3�74<\7:9\_y523B7C52.13�c\9;_y74. W 3�<\=�9�c>3B5C9\p>3 � �y[X.1_Y3 J È M E U 0©7C. W 39 ]B] < U =�740Kan<>5 Å � Å>Æ#q �s <%36=X0 U 543�< U 5�04. W U _h9;74<>5K.10�9 ]B]6U 549;7C3�an<\5�< U 5�3�µ^f¸3B54. W 3B=�740 � 74[X3�9�c>36549\p>3ZDX< ]6U W 3B=�7k02. ¿ 3543�7 U 52=X36D E�F 9\= J = Á U 3B5 F 043B52c\365K.10t74[X3k0C9 W 3k9\0o7C[�3�9�c\365C9;p>3k04. ¿ 3�.1=%7C[�3 syu à r z ] <>_1_Y3 ]�½7C.Y<>= � ¥¦¯¦�6¯ �¢Ä � Ç � ��� s [X3©04. W U _h9�7C<>5�9;_104< U 02360q7C[X3�DX< ]6U W 36=�7q543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_e74. W 3�7C< ] < W f U 7437C[�3%0 U W�W 9;5 F .1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=�523B7C52.13�c\9;_�7C. W 3 � � 3%. W fX_Y3 W 36=�7q7C[X3%0 U W©W 9\5 F .Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=

Ì�Ä

Page 99: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

± ¿PÞ � ¿ ¶ « & � ¿ 'B� ¿ ±P± ½f®�¿ ±/&SÇ ¿ * � j�± m y�w ¿ ¡ m w � ' t ± t�y�t ¿ ¡ m y»¸ � ¿ ±P± ½f®�¿ ±:&RÇ ¿ *¶ ¿�º�¿ & ¾�¿ ¶ « & � ¿ 'B� ¿ ±P± ½f®�¿ ±/&SÇ ¿ * � j�± l j y ¿ ¡ m w � ' l ± y$l�y ¿ ¡ m y»¸ � ¿ ±P± ½f®�¿ ±:&RÇ ¿ *Þ ¿h«u» Ü ¶ � « & � ¿ 'B� ¿ ±P± ½f®�¿ ±/&SÇ ¿ * � � ¿ ±P± ½f®�¿ ±:&RÇ ¿ ¸\y ² Þ ¿:«u» Ü ¶ � ± °n¿�¿ �õ ò ß�%SýÂà �IÿT�`ÿ N 3B7É��<>54´'74. W 3�c;9\_ U 360 Ô 023 ] <>=XDX0 Õ �

<>fi36549;7C.Y<>=»9\0�9'023652.1360�<\a¹DX< ]BU W 36=�7�543�7C52.13Bc;9\_¢<>fi365C9�7C.1<\=X0 � w <>5�3�9 ] ["0 U W©W 9\5 F 3B=�745 F\� 9\=J = Á U 3B5 F 043B52c\365¶523�9\D�0¶9 ] < W fX_Y3B7C3�DX< ]6U W 3B=�7 � H <Â��3Bc\365 � 7C[X3 J = Á U 3B5 F 043B52c\36540�<>=X_ F 543 ½7 U 54=)74[X3¶0 U W©W 9\5 F f¸<>587C.Y<>=�<;ae7C[X3�DX< ]6U W 36=�7 � J ={< U 5�3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�740 � 74[X3�9�c\365C9;p>3�04. ¿ 3q<\a9ZDX< ]6U W 36=�7K0 U W�W 9\5 F .10 zÂÄ\ÅZE�F 7C3B0 �

�Iÿ¦þ�ÿT� ä à�üC© d ýtª í ò f�à� 3 W <VDX36_®74[X3Z=X3�7É�t<>52´»7C. W 3Z9\0/74[X3�043B=XDX365q<}c>3B54[X369\D � 7C[X3�543 ] 3B.Yc>3B5�<}c\3654[�3�9\D � 9\=XD"7C[�3=X3�7É�t<>52´�_19;7C3B= ] F � s [X3�0436=�DX365�<Âc\3652[X3�9\D�.Y0%7C[X3 r ? R fX52< ] 360402.1=Xp³7C. W 3»an<>5�9\DXD�.1=XpÙ9W 3604049\p>3{74<�7C[X3»=X3�7É�t<\54´ � s [X3"543 ] 3B.Yc>3B5@<Âc\3652[X3�9\D.10©7C[X3 r ? R 7C. W 3�an<>5%543 W <}cV.1=�p�9W 3604049\p>3{an52< W 74[X3»=X3�7É�t<>52´ � s [X3»=X3�7É�t<\54´�_19;7C3B= ] F .10«74[X3"9 W < U =�7%<\ak74. W 3�74[g9;7%7C[�3W 3604049\p>3�04fi36=XD�0«.1=7C549\=X02.Y7 � s [X36023)7C. W 3B0�9\543�9�_Y.1=X369\5�a U = ] 7C.Y<>=Ù<;a�7C[�3 W 36020C9\p>3�04. ¿ 3 ��y[X3B=�74[X3 E 9\=XD��y.YD�7C[@<\aS74[X3k=X3B7É��<>54´«.10oj�µ^36D � � 3k< E 7C9\.1=X3BD'7C[X3B043 W 3�9\0 U 543 W 3B=�740 U 04.Y=XpsmsKr ? E�FÙW 3�9;0 U 52.1=Xp"7C[X3@7C. W 3'74<�0236=XD W 3B040C9;p>360�an54< W Ç>Ä"E�F 7C3B0«7C< Æ Ë � � E 3�7É�t3B36=7É��<©,�à r +�_YfX[g9 T 3B52c\36540 ] <>=X=X3 ] 7C3BD E�F 9�_Y.1p>[�74_ F _1<>9\DX36D z}Å d E fX0KÃe7C[�3654=�3B7 � w .Yp U 523 Î � Ä_1.Y02740y74[X3q=X3B7É��<>54´%74. W 3q3Bl U 9;7C.Y<>=X0K.1=@< U 5K04. W U _19;7C<>5 � R 04.Y=Xp�74[X36023¶3Bl U 9;7C.Y<>=X0 � 74[X3�0236=XD�365<}c>3B54[X369\D�an<>5�0236=XD�.1=Xp"9 Ä � � W 3B04049\p>3'.Y0 Å � Å>|)W .1_Y_1.Y043 ] <>=XDX0 � 7C[X3'523 ] 36.Yc\365�<}c\3654[�3�9\D�.Y0Å � zÂÄ�W .Y_1_Y.1043 ] <>=�DX0 � 9\=XD@7C[X3k=X3�7É�t<\54´%_h9�7C36= ] F .Y0 z � Æ Ë W .1_Y_1.Y043 ] <>=XDX0 �

�Iÿ¦þ�ÿr� â�d�a�a à i ü ò d�a�ð ý d ªià�ý í ò f�às [X3 ] <>=X=X3 ] 74.1<>= E 52<>´\3B5«7C. W 3�.10�7C[X3 r ? R 7C. W 3@7C[g9;7'9 ] <\=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 54<\´\365«04fi36=XDX0'74<DX.Y027C52. E U 7C3m9\= JLu ] < W�W 9\=�D�7C</7C[�3 ] <>54523602f¸<>=�DX.1=Xp J = Á U 365 F 023658c>36520�<\5e043B=XD E 9 ] ´Z9�543B0 U _¾77C<�9 ] _1.13B=�7 � � 3¹DX.YcV.YDX3¹74[X3�74. W 3º.1=k7C[X3 ] <>=X=�3 ] 74.1<>= E 54<\´\365¢.1=�7C<K7C[X52363 ] 9;7436p><>52.13B0 � 7C[X3º7C. W 3

Ì>Ç

Page 100: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

E�1P775($N�1F+9b /�;�`�YMb0Ne($b `��J1�/�;�`�YMb0N�?,YM<a1¨P©n¿ ¶Pª�'�* � | ± w m�m ¿ ¡ m w± © ��� ½ ¶Pª�' Þ ± © � ± * � g ± x�x�i ¿ ¡ m w � 'Ôj�± l�y�i ¿ ¡ m w»¸ Þ ± © � ± *��Ü º�© � ¿PÞF« Ý &S± « ' Þ ��Ü º ± * � y ± w j t ¿ ¡ m l � ' l ± y�w j ¿ ¡ m x�¸ Þ ��Ü º ± *�.25;�/�1P77Ypb Nd?,YM<a1º Ü �È� ½�Þ � ' Þ ± ¿ ¶ ¾�¿ ¶ ±f% º � � * �ÊÉ x ± g | m ¿ ¡ m l _ º � � � ��Ü º�© � ¿�ÞF«g ± t j i ¿ ¡ m t � ' g ± x�i$l ¿ ¡ m l�¸ Þ ± ¿ ¶ ¾�¿ ¶ ± * _ Ü « ¯ ¿ ¶ » & ± ¿± ¿ ¶ ¾�¿ ¶ ¶ ¿ ± © Ý�« ' º � � * � É | ± g�g�g ¿ ¡ m w _ º � � � ��Ü º�© � ¿PÞF«g ± j i0g ¿ ¡ m t _ Ü « ¯ ¿ ¶ » & ± ¿E�1325N�YMb0Na?,Yp<a1¨P© ¿ ¶hª�' Þ ½�Þ ± »{¿ ¶ ± * � j�± w$x�x ¿ ¡ m w � ' g ± y0g�l ¿ ¡ m x�¸ Þ ½�Þ ± »{¿ ¶ ± *± © ��� ½ ¶Pª�' Þ ± © � ± * � ¡ m0± | w�g ¿ ¡ m w � 'Ôj�± l g3l ¿ ¡ m w˸ Þ ± © � ± *õ ò ß�%Sý�à �Iÿ»�Iÿ r <>=�=X3 ] 7C.1<\= E 54<>´;365y7C. W 3�c;9\_ U 360 Ô 023 ] <>=XDX0 Õ �

7C<«36= ] <^DX3¶9\=XD{D�3 ] <VDX3 W 36020C9\p\360 � 7C[X3�fX54< ] 3B0404.Y=Xp«74. W 3qan<>5K[g9\=�DX_1.Y=Xp W 36020C9\p>3B0 � 9\=XD{7C[�37C. W 3k7C< W 3B54p>3�54360 U _Y740 � w .Yp U 523 Î � Ç _Y.102740�74[X3�an<>5 W U _19\0K��3 U 023¶7C< ] < W f U 7C3�7C[X3�D�.Yظ36543B=�7c;9\_ U 360 �ú9 ] [�74. W 3»9 W 3B04049\p>3 9\5452.Yc\360 � 7C[X3 ] <\=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 54<>´;365 W U 087�D�3 ] <VDX3»7C[�3 W 36020C9\p\3"74<DX3�7C365 W .Y=X3�9\= 9\fXf�54<>fX52.h9;743�9 ] 74.1<>= � s [X3 ] <>=X=�3 ] 74.1<>= E 52<>´\3B5¶9;_104< ] 54369;7C3B0�=X3�� W 36020C9\p>3B09\=XD W U 087�3B= ] <VDX3q7C[X3qDg9;7C9�.Y=�74<�74[X3 W 3B040C9;p>3qan<\5 W 9;7 � s [X3k7C. W 3�7C<�DX3 ] <^D�3¶9\=�D)36= ] <VDX39�l U 3B5 F ] < W�W 9;=XD � ¬ ²� k��ÌÖÔ Õ � .Y0'9 ] <>=X087:9\=�7'c;9\_ U 3 � s [X3)74. W 3%7C<�DX3 ] <VDX3{9;=XD�36= ] <VDX39�0 U W©W 9\5 F .1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\= � ´k² ®^®�¤¦��ÌÖÔ_¥I´�² ®�´ Õ � .10'9 _1.Y=X3�9\5�a U = ] 7C.Y<>=�<\a/74[X3{= U W�E 365©<\a0 U W©W 9\54.Y360 � s [X3Á��Í °C²�®� k¥ � ¡ � ´ � Ô_¥ ��Í °b´ Õ a U = ] 7C.Y<>=Ù.Y0Z7C[X3�7C. W 3'7C<�36= ] <^D�3)9\=�D·DX3 ] <VDX3l U 365 F 543B0 U _¾7C0Q{b7C[X3Zc;9\_ U 3ZDX36fi36=�DX0 U fi<>=»7C[�3�= U W¶E 3B5�<\a�DX< ]6U W 36=�740q523B7 U 54=X3BD�an52< W 7C[�3J = Á U 3B5 F 043B52c\365 �s [X3{f�54< ] 360204.Y=Xp�7C. W 3@an<>5«[X9\=XDX_Y.1=Xp W 3B040C9;p>360%DX3Bf¸3B=XDX0 U fi<>=·�y[�<�0436=�DX0%7C[X3 W 3B040C9;p>39\=XD�74[X3 W 3604049\p>3)7 F fi3 � w <>5 ] < W©W 9\=XD�0«an54< W ] _Y.13B=�740 � 7C[�3 ] <>=�=X3 ] 7C.1<\= E 54<>´;365%fX_19 ] 3B07C[�3 W .1=�74[X3�l U 3 U 360�an<>5Z7C[X3�9\f�fX54<>f�54.h9�7C3%DX3B027C.Y=g9;74.1<>= J = Á U 365 F 043B52c>3B540 � +èD�< ]BU W 3B=�7543�7C52.13Bc;9\_ ] < W�W 9\=�D©.Y0¹<\=X_ F 0236=�7t74<�<\=X3 J = Á U 365 F 023652c\365t9\=XD©7C9\´\3B0o9 ] <>=�027:9;=�7t9 W < U =�7¹<\afX52< ] 360402.1=Xp � +�l U 3B5 F <>5�0 U W�W 9\5 F ] < W�W 9\=XD«.Y0�0236=�7t74< W U _Y7C.YfX_13 J = Á U 365 F 043B52c\36540m02<¶7C[�3fX52< ] 360402.1=Xp©7C. W 3k.10�9�a U = ] 7C.Y<>=)<;ae7C[X3�= U W�E 365�<;aA043B52c>3B540 �kT . W .1_19\54_ F>�^W 3B040C9;p>360Kan54< W 7C[�3

Ì Ë

Page 101: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

J = Á U 3B5 F 023652c\36520 ] <>=�7:9\.Y=�D�.Yظ36543B=�7m7 F fi360K<\ab543B0 U _¾7C0 � � 3�543BfX543B043B=�7K7C[�3qf�54< ] 360204.Y=XpZ7C. W 360U 02.1=Xp ] <\=X027C9\=�7�c;9\_ U 360 �s [X3 ] <>=X=X3 ] 74.1<>= E 54<>´;365Z9\_Y04<�04fi36=XDX0�7C. W 3 W 3B54p>.Y=Xp�l U 3B5 F 9\=XD�0 U W©W 9\5 F 54360 U _Y740 � s [X37C. W 3�7C< W 3B54p>3�l U 365 F 9\=XD 0 U W�W 9\5 F 54360 U _Y740kDX36fi36=XD�0 U fi<>="7C[X3�= U W�E 365k<\ao9\=X02��36520�<\50 U W©W 9\54.Y360t9\= J = Á U 365 F 043B52c\365y543�7 U 52=X0 � � 3 W <VDX36_i7C[X3 W 3652p>3�74. W 360m9\0t_1.1=�3�9\5¹a U = ] 74.1<>=�0<\ab7C[X3k= U W�E 365y<\a¢543B0 U _¾7C0 �

�Iÿ¦þ�ÿT� � Þ� ò sbÞ^ü ò d�a�d�c ü ú à [ %Sà�ý h·é ï Þ� _%bÞ�ü ò d�a·ì�d sSà` s [X.Y0t043 ] 74.1<>='f�54360236=�7C0m74[X3�c;9\_Y.1Dg9;74.1<>=�<\a`74[X3�02. W U _h9;74<>5QP 0�l U 3B5 F 3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>=©74. W 360�9\p�9\.Y=X0277C[�3/9 ] 7 U 9\_�. W fX_Y3 W 36=�7:9�7C.1<\= � � 3KDX.YcV.YDX3K74[X3yc\9;_1.1DX9;7C.Y<>=�.1=�7C<k7C[X52363�027C3BfX0 � Ô z Õ �t3Kc\9;_1.1DX9;7C37C[�3{7C365 W 3Bc;9\_ U 9;74.1<>=·74. W 3)7C[X9;7%.10'74[X3 E 9\023"<\a�74[X3»l U 365 F 3Bc;9\_ U 9;74.1<>= W <^D�36_�{ Ô Ä Õ ��3c;9\_1.YDg9;743q74[X3¶l U 3B5 F 3�c;9\_ U 9�7C.1<\= W <^D�36_�{ Ô Ç Õ ��3�c\9;_1.1DX9;7C3�7C[�3�l U 365 F 3Bc;9\_ U 9;74.1<>=�<>fi365C9�7C.1<\=.1=·9 W U _Y7C.¾7C[X523�9\D�36D JLu 0 F 087C3 W � s [X3{9 ] 7 U 9\_�0 F 027C3 W �t9\0«5 U =X=X.Y=Xp J = Á U 365 F·Ç � z <>=·9Ç ½ r ? R +�_1fX[g9 T 3B52c\365 Ä^z}Å>Å�Î>È\Ä>Î\Å 5 U =�=X.1=Xp�,/.Yp>.Y7C9\_ R�N�J Í Ñ Ç � Ä , ½ z Ô u 3Bc%Ë z Õ �

� Þ� ò sSÞ�ü ò d�a�d c ü ú à�ü}à�ýlf à ï Þ� _%bÞ�ü ò d�a ü ò f�à� 3�c\9;_1.1DX9;7C3BD)7C[X3�9 ]6]6U 5C9 ] F <\a  k£`¤`¡ �  k�l® �7� ®� �Ô Õ .Y= w .1p U 543 Î � zZE�F ] < W fg9\54.Y=Xp«74[X3�c;9\_ ½U 3B0 ] 9\_ ]6U _19;7C3BD U 02.1=Xp�74[X3)an<>5 W U _19\0��y.¾7C[ W 3�9;0 U 523 W 36=�7C0«��3»< E 7C9\.1=�36DÙan52< W 043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xpsyu à r z>� syu à r Ä ½ Ç�� 9;=XD syu à r z ½ Ç ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 � w <>5q3�9 ] [ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � �t3©5C9\=�DX< W _ F] [X<>023 Î;Å>Å 7C3B5 W 0y9\=XD ] 9\_ ]6U _19;7C3BD%7C[X3�fi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3qDX.Yظ365236= ] 3�<\a¢74[X3�7C. W 3B0tan<>5m3�9 ] [�<\ab7C[�37C3B5 W 0 � s [X3�74365 W an543Bl U 36= ] .1360man<>5 syu à r z\� syu à r Ä ½ Ç�� 9\=XD syu à r z ½ Ç �t3 ] [X<>023k5C9\=Xp\3an54< Wôz 7C< Î>Î;Æ�� Î Ë Ì�� an52< Wôz 74< z\�Ð| Ë Å��Ð|\Ì>Ì�� 9;=XD%an54< Wèz 74< Ä^�Ð|\Ç�Î^� |>| � � 543B04fi3 ] 74.Yc\36_ F �t� 3Ban<>523fX52< ] 360402.1=Xp¶3�9 ] [«74365 W�� �t3 ] [X.1_Y_13BD�74[X3�0 F 087C3 WÛE�F 54369\DX.1=�p�9�_19\54p\3yjX_13y7C[g9;7�jg_1_Y0A7C[X3 W 3 W ½<>5 F 0 UX] [�7C[g9;7�3Bc>3B5 F 7C365 W 0��o9\0Z523�9\D�an52< W 7C[X3«DX.102´ � s 9 E _Y3 Î � z 04[�<Â�y0Z74[X3«c;9\_1.YDg9;74.1<>=543B0 U _¾7C0 � r <>_ U W = z _1.Y027C0K7C[X3Z=X9 W 3B0/<\a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 � r <>_ U W = Ä 9;=XD Ç 04[X<}�-7C[X3�9�c\365C9;p>3fi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3mDX.Yظ365236= ] 3m<\ai3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>=�74. W 3 E 3B7É��363B=�74[X3m04. W U _h9�7C<>5¢9\=XD�74[X3y9 ] 7 U 9\_^0 F 02743 W��9\=XD�.Y740m027C9\=XDg9\52D�D�3BcV.h9;74.1<>= � +�fi<>02.Y7C.¾c>3�c;9\_ U 3 W 369\=X0m7C[g9�7m7C[X3q04. W U _h9�7C<>5�<Âc\3652360274. W 9;7C3B0

Ì�Î

Page 102: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

� ^ 1�2� �JYpØn1�21�b /�1? ��4�1 G�c�1 h I�6�` h ÎDw�} άg m } άgPw�}? ��+ � g m hMg�} m h i�} g m�m } g m�m } g m�m }? ��+ � j svt g�h | } t0h m } y�y�} i | } g m�m }? ��+ � g3svt g�h l�} | h y�} y�w�} i�x�} g m�m }í Þ��! ¦à �Iÿøþgÿ s 365 W 3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>='7C. W 3�c\9;_1.1DX9;7C.Y<>= �

7C[�3«9 ] 7 U 9;_¹0 F 027C3 W � r <\_ U W =X0qË�74[X54< U p>[ Æ 04[X<}�Ó74[X3«fi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3«<;at7C3B5 W 0�5 U =X=X.Y=Xp�<>=7C[�3q02. W U _h9;74<>5�74[g9;7ya¦9\_1_i�y.Y74[X.1=ÐÏ Î#q'� Ï z}Å#q%� 9;=XDÐÏ zÂÎ$q <\ab7C[X3q9 ] 7 U 9\_`0 F 027C3 W �T .Y= ] 3@7C[X3@an<>5 W U _h9;0���36523)< E 7:9\.Y=X.1=Xp E�F jX7474.1=Xp»74[X3 W 3�9\0 U 543 W 3B=�7C0�an54< W 74[X3 syu à r z] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � 74[X3 W <^DX3B_ W 9;7 ] [�360'7C[�3 W 369\0 U 543 W 36=�740@an52< W syu à r z E 36087 � 7C[X3"9�c\365C9;p>3fi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3'DX.¾ØÖ3B5436= ] 3'.Y0 Å � ztq �y.Y74[�9�087:9\=�Dg9\54D�D�3BcV.h9;74.1<>= <\a Å � |¦q'� 9;=XD9\_1_e74365 W 0qa¦9\_1_�y.Y74[X.1= Î#q D�.Yظ36543B= ] 3 � w <>5 syu à r Ä ½ Ç�� 7C[X3�9�c>3B5C9\p>3qfi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3¶DX.¾ØÖ3B543B= ] 3�.10 z ��� q �y.Y74[9�087:9\=�Dg9\54D«DX3BcV.h9�7C.1<\=©<\a Ç � Å#q � | � q <\aI74365 W 0ºa¦9\_1_X�y.¾7C[X.Y= z}Å#q 9\=XD'9;_1_X7C3B5 W 0�a¦9\_Y_10e�y.¾7C[X.Y=zÂÎ#q � w <>5 syu à r z ½ Ç�� 7C[X3�9�c>3B5C9\p>3"fi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3�D�.Yظ36543B= ] 3".Y0 z � Ë q �y.Y74[!9027C9\=XDg9\52DDX3�c^.19;7C.Y<>=·<;a �^� Ì#q � |>Ʀq <\a�74365 W 0©a¦9;_1_m�y.Y74[X.1= z�Ŧq 9\=XD�9\_Y_m7C365 W 0�a¦9\_1_Y0��y.¾7C[X.Y= zÂÎ$q �s [X3B043q= U W�E 3B540K.1=XD�. ] 9�7C3�74[X3 W <VDX36_ W 9;7 ] [X360 syu à r Ä ½ Ç^� 9\=XD syu à r z ½ Ç c>3B5 F ��36_Y_ �

� Þ� ò sSÞ�ü ò d�a�d c ü ú à × %SàVý h à ï Þ� _%bÞ^ü ò d�a f d sbà` � 3yc;9\_Y.1Dg9�7C36D�74[X3K9 ]6]BU 5C9 ] F <\ai7C[X3Kl U 365 F 3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>= W <^D�36_ E�F ] 523�9;74.1=Xpq9\587C.¾j ] .19\_�l U 3B54.13B09\=XD ] < W fg9\52.1=XpZ74[X3kf¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3q<\ael U 3B5 F a U = ] 7C.1<\=�an<>5y023�9\5 ] [X.1=Xp«9 z O �] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>[email protected]=7C[�3�9 ] 7 U 9\_®. W f�_13 W 36=�7C9;7C.Y<>=)9;=XD»7C[X3�02. W U _h9;74<>5 � � 3Z5C9\=�DX< W _ F p>36=�365C9�7C36D»74[X543B3Z043B740�<\al U 3652.13B0 ��Î\Å 04[�<>527�l U 3652.1360k�y.Y74[�9\=�9�c>3B5C9\p>3©<\a Ä 7C3B5 W 0qfi365ql U 365 F>�ºÎ;Å�W 36DX. U W l U 3B54.13B0�y.Y74[9\=9�c>3B5C9\p>3@<\a zÂÄ 74365 W 0�fi365Zl U 3B5 F\� 9\=�D Î\Å _1<>=�p{l U 3652.1360Z�y.¾7C[9\=9�c>3B5C9\p\3%<\a Ä �7C3B5 W 0�fi365�l U 3B5 F � � [X3B=< E 7:9;.1=X.Y=Xp W 3�9\0 U 543 W 3B=�7C0 � ��3 ] [X.1_Y_13BD�7C[�3%0 F 02743 W E 3Ban<>523«7C[�30 F 087C3 W fX52< ] 360204360K3�9 ] [)l U 365 F �s 9 E _13 Î � Ä 02[X<}�y0y74[X3�c;9\_1.YDg9;7C.Y<>=�54360 U _Y740 � r <>_ U W = Ä 9;=XD Ç 02[X<}�!74[X3k9�c>36549\p>3kfi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3DX.¾ØÖ3B5436= ] 3'<\ao3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>=�74. W 3 E 3B7É��363B=�7C[X3'02. W U _h9;74<>5q9\=XD�74[X3'9 ] 7 U 9;_�0 F 087C3 W�� 9\=�D�.Y740027C9\=XDg9;54D�DX3�c^.19;7C.Y<>= � + fi<>02.Y7C.¾c>3�c\9;_ U 3 W 3�9;=X0«7C[X9;7'7C[�3{04. W U _h9�7C<>5�<}c>365236087C. W 9;74360'7C[�3

Ì>Æ

Page 103: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

� ^ 1325� �{YpØn1�21�b /�1 G�c�1 h +9c�(�K h?9��4n1 G�c�1 h I�65` h άg m } Î j�m } ÎFt m } ÎJl m } ?,Yp<a1�')71�/P*I�>0;�2�6 j h m } g�x0h j } l j } | j } i�x�} g m�m } m h |E�1�`0Y ^ < l h j } g m hMg�} x�y�} i m } g m�m } g m�m } l h x� ;�b0N j h t�} y0hkw�} | y�} i�x�} g m�m } g m�m } g m hMgG�c�1 h j h y�} g�g�h x�} x�t�} y�x�} i�i�} g m�m } w�hMgí Þ��! ¦à �`ÿT�Iÿ Á U 365 F@W <VDX3B_¸c;9\_1.YDg9;74.1<>= �

?×;$6�($K �JY�7!652YMU ^ 65Yp;�b� ^ 1�2� m } 65; ¡�g m } 6; ¡ j�m } 65;? ��4�1 ~ ^ <¬U�1�2 �¼1�25/313b�65(�N�1 ¡�g m } ¡ j$m } ¡�t m }I�> ;�26 j�j l�l�} g�g | lE�1P`�Y ^ < g | t$l�} g3l t m��;�b0N g�i t�y�} g�y g mG{c�1 h w$y t�i�} l�t g�g lí Þ��! ¦à �Iÿ»�Iÿ ,/.Y027C52. E U 7C.1<\='<\a U =XDX3B5436087C. W 9;7436D�l U 3652.1360 �

9 ] 7 U 9\_b0 F 087C3 W � r <>_ U W =X0�Ë©7C[X52< U p>[ � 04[X<}�v7C[X3�f¸3B5 ] 36=�7:9\p\3Z<\aAl U 3652.13B0/5 U =�=X.1=Xp«<>=)7C[�304. W U _19;7C<>5º7C[X9;7ma¦9\_1_��y.Y74[X.1=�Ï z}Å#q%� Ï Ä\Ŧq'� Ï Ç>Ŧq 9\=XDÑÏ�Ë Å¦q <\aS7C[X3k9 ] 7 U 9;_I0 F 02743 W � s [X3_h9;027 ] <>_ U W =Ù_1.1087C0�7C[X3»9�c\365C9;p>3»3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>=·l U 3B5 F 7C. W 3@an<>5«369 ] [�043B7'<\akl U 3652.1360%.Y=·7C[�39 ] 7 U 9\_`0 F 027C3 W � M =)9�c\365C9;p>3q74[X3k04. W U _h9�7C<>5�.10 Ä � ̦q 02_1<}�t3B5K74[g9\=@7C[X3q9 ] 7 U 9;_`0 F 02743 W �y.Y74[7C[�3/027C9\=XDg9\52D%DX3BcV.19;7C.Y<>='<\a z>z � Ʀq � s [X3�c\9;54.h9�7C.1<\=©<\ab02[X<>527ol U 3654.Y360o.Y0�7É�y. ] 3/7C[X9;7tan<>5�_1<>=�pl U 3652.13B0 � +�_Y_Il U 3652.1360ya¦9\_Y_¸�y.Y74[X.1=%Ë Å¦q <\ab7C[X3q9 ] 7 U 9;_I0 F 02743 W �s 9 E _13 Î � Ç D�3B7:9;.1_10m74[X3 U =XDX365236087C. W 9;7436D{l U 3B54.13B0 � r <>_ U W =X0 Ä 9\=XD Ç 02[X<}��7C[X3k7C<\7C9\_S= U W ½E 365�<\a U =�DX3652360274. W 9;7C3BD·l U 3B54.13B0'9\=�DÙ7C[�3 ] <>54523604fi<>=XD�.1=Xp�f¸3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3�.1=Ù9\_1_tl U 365 F 043�7C0 �r <>_ U W =�0¹Ëq7C[X52< U p>[ Æ 02[X<}��7C[X3K= U W�E 365t<;aÖ7C[�3 U =XD�36543B0274. W 9;7C3BD«l U 3652.13B0�7C[X9;7ºa¦9\_1_X�y.¾7C[X.Y=� z}Ŧq'� � z�Ŧq 74< � Ä;Ŧq 9\=�D � Ä\Å#q 7C< � Ç>Å#q <\a�7C[�3m9 ] 7 U 9\_X0 F 027C3 W � +�_Y74[X< U p\[¶�t3 U =�DX365 ½36087C. W 9;743 Î\Ì l U 3654.Y360o< U 7o<\a z}Î\Å l U 3652.13B0 � Ë Ç l U 3654.Y360ta¦9;_1_g�y.Y74[X.1= z�Ŧq 9\=XD%<>=X_ F an< U 5t02[X<>587l U 3652.13B0�a¦9\_Y_A< U 7C02.1DX3©<\a Ä\Å#q � s [ U 0 � �t3 U 0 U 9;_1_ F <Âc\3652360274. W 9;7C3©l U 3652.1360 � M U 5kc;9\_1.YDg9;74.1<>=543B0 U _¾7C0�04[X<}��7C[X9;7t< U 5�l U 3B5 F 3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>= W <VDX3B_ W 9;7 ] [X360¹7C[X3�9 ] 7 U 9\_�0 F 087C3 W c>3B5 F ] _Y<>043B_ F>�9\_¾7C[X< U p>['�t3qDX<�=X<\7K9 ]B]6U 549;7C3B_ F%W <VDX36_I3�c>3B5 F l U 365 F �

Ì �

Page 104: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

G�252YMcf($K� ^ 1325� �{(f61zÒ ~ ^ <ÀUn132{;$8o?,> 21P(�`07?9��4n1 4�1�2�7�1P/ h g j t l y g�xh w g�h w�} m hkw�} s j hkw�} j h w�} s m h y�} g�h w�}I�>0;�2�6 g gPt0h | } t0h m } g�h i�} s�g�hkw�} g�h m } s m h t�}w Ó�ÔEÕ{Ó4Ö g | h x�} t0h y�} s m h l�} j hMg�} g�h m }h w gPi0h y�} i0h m } l h l�} g�h i�} g�h j } m h w�}E�1�`0Y ^ < g j x0h m } g j h m } j hkw�} ×�ØEÕ{Ù4Ö g�h i�} s m h l�}w j g�hkw�} gPw�h | } | h j } y h y�} w�h m } l�hpgf}h w g�w�h y�} x0h x�} sut0h y�} s m h l�} m h l�} s m h w�}� ;�b0N g g m hMg�} g�h y�} s j hMg�} g�h y�} g�h m } g�h | }w g j h | } g m h t�} g�h | } j h l�} t0h i�} t hpgf}G�c�132�($N�1 gPx0hkw�} y0hkw�} g�hkw�} Ú^ÛpÜ�Ý g�h | } g�h j }í Þ��! nà �Iÿr�Sÿ ?¢365 ] 3B=�7C9\p>3�DX.¾ØÖ3B5436= ] 3Z<\a¹9�c>3B5C9\p\3Z543602f¸<\=X043Z7C. W 3B0 E 3B7É��363B= 74[X3Z. W fX_13 W 3B= ½7:9�7C.1<\=@9\=XD�04. W U _h9;74<>5 �

� Þ� ò sSÞ�ü ò d�a�d c × %bà�ý h d ûAà�ýÂÞ�ü ò d�as [X.Y0�023 ] 74.1<>="c;9\_1.YDg9;74360kl U 365 F <\f¸3B5C9;74.1<>=X0/an<\5�023�9\5 ] [X.1=Xp�9 z O �-] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>="<>=�9 W U _Y74. ½7C[�543�9;DX36D�043B52c\365 U 04.Y=Xp J = Á U 3B5 FZÇ � z 9\0¢7C[X3ml U 3B5 F 9;5454.¾c;9\_^549;7C3o9\=XD�7C[�3m= U W�E 3B5e<\a�7C[�543�9;DX0.1= ] 54369\043¶<>=»9 Ç ½ r ? R +�_YfX[g9 T 3B52c\365 Ä^z�Å>Å%Î>È>Ä\Î\Å 5 U =X=X.Y=Xp%,/.1p\.Y7:9;_ R�N�J Í Ñ Ç � Ä , ½ z Ô u 3BcË z Õ � � 3)9;040 U W 3BD·l U 3652.13B0«9\5254.¾c>360©9\0©9�?b<>.10204<>=ÙfX54< ] 3B040 � ú9 ] [·7C[�543�9;D·3�µ^3 ]6U 74360'<>=�3l U 365 F � s [X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=��t9\0�f U 7/<>={<\=X3�DX.Y04´ � � 3 U 0236D»7C[X3¶0C9 W 3¶l U 3B5 F 043B740k9\0 U 0436D".Y=c;9\_1.YDg9;74.1=Xp¶74[X3kl U 365 F 3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>= W <^DX3B_ �s 9 E _13 Î � Ë"_1.Y027C0�74[X3@f¸3B5 ] 36=�7:9\p\3�DX.¾ØÖ3B543B= ] 3�<\aK7C[X3�9�c>36549\p>3�543B04fi<>=X043@7C. W 3 E 3B7É��363B=·7C[�39 ] 7 U 9\_g0 F 027C3 W 9\=XD�7C[X3y04. W U _19;7C<>5ban<>5º3�9 ] [�l U 365 F 043B7�9\0A74[X3K9\5452.Yc;9\_X549;7C3y9\=�D�74[X3�= U W¶E 3B5<\aI74[X54369\DX0�.1= ] 543�9;043 � ?b<>04.¾7C.¾c>3�= U W¶E 3B540o.Y=XDX. ] 9;7C3m74[X3�02. W U _19;7C<\5¹<}c\36543B0274. W 9;7C3B0�7C[�3/9 ] 7 U 9\_0 F 087C3 W � s [X3Z02. W U _h9;74<>5�5236fi<>52740�543602f¸<\=X043Z7C. W 3B0�74[g9;7q9\523�Ë � Î#q 02_1<}�t3B5/7C[g9;="74[X3�9 ] 7 U 9\_0 F 087C3 W <>={7C[X3�9}c\36549\p>3 � 9;=XD»5C9\=�p>3¶an54< WôÇ � |¦q a¦9\0274365�74< Ä �^� Ä#q 04_Y<Â��365�7C[g9\={74[X3�9 ] 7 U 9\_0 F 087C3 W � s [X3tDX.Yظ365236= ] 3 E 3�7É�t3B36=Z7C[X3o9 ] 7 U 9\_�0 F 027C3 W 9\=�D¶7C[X3t04. W U _h9;74<>5S7C36=�DX0®7C<�DX3 ] 543�9;0439\0A7C[�3K= U W¶E 3B5�<\ai7C[�543�9;DX0�.Y= ] 523�9\02360�9\=XD�7C[X3yl U 3B5 F 9\5452.Yc;9\_^5C9;743KD�3 ] 523�9\02360 � w <>5A3Úµ�9 W f�_13 �an<>5¢9�0 F 087C3 W �y.¾7C[ z�Æ 7C[�543�9;DX0 � 74[X3t02. W U _h9;74<>5`.10San54< WvÅ � Ǧq a¦9;027C3B5¢74<�Ë � ztq 04_Y<}�t3B5¢7C[X9\=¶7C[�39 ] 7 U 9\_¸0 F 02743 W � s [X3�DX.Yظ365236= ] 3 E 3�7É�t3B36=@7C[X3�04. W U _h9;74<>5�9\=XD'7C[�3k9 ] 7 U 9\_Ö0 F 027C3 W .1= ] 54369\043B0

Ì>Ì

Page 105: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

Partitioning (4 disks)Replication (DP=40%)

Ô 9 Õ U 04.Y=XpZ7C[X3k54369\_`0 F 087C3 W

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

Partitioning (4 disks)Replication (DP=40%)

Ô E Õ U 02.1=XpZ7C[�3q02. W U _h9;74<>5

õ ò ß�%SýÂà �Iÿ��Sÿ Ñ 9;_1.1DX9;7C.Y<>='<\ab7C[X3kfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 U 04.Y=Xp�fg9\5274.h9\_Ö5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>= �

9\0�9qa U = ] 7C.Y<>=«<;aÖ7C[�3�= U W�E 365¹<\a`l U 3B54.13B0��t9\.Y74.1=Xpk.Y=©7C[�3�l U 3 U 3 �XE 3 ] 9 U 023�< U 5¹l U 365 F«W <VDX36_U 0 U 9\_1_ F <}c>3B5436087C. W 9;74360y7C[X3ql U 365 F 3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>=%7C. W 3 � M c>3B5C9\_Y_ � 7C[�3�02. W U _19;7C<\5 W 9�7 ] [X3B0�7C[�39 ] 7 U 9\_`0 F 027C3 W ] _Y<>043B_ F �

� Þ� ò sSÞ�ü ò d�a�d c û¢ÞXý}ü ò Þ� ¹ý�à�û! ò_i Þ�ü ò d�a ûAà�ý ced ýlf�Þ a i às [X.Y0¶043 ] 74.1<>= ] < W fg9\52360�74[X3«02. W U _h9;74<>5k9\=XD�74[X3«. W f�_13 W 36=�7C9;7C.Y<>=»<>=�fg9;527C.19\_A543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=an<>5/023�9\5 ] [X.1=�p�9 z�Æ O ��] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�<>="9 W U _¾7C. ½ 7:9\02´�.1=Xp�043B52c>3B5 U 04.Y=Xp J = Á U 365 F"Ç � z 9\0/7C[�3l U 365 F 9\5452.Yc;9\_t549;7C3�.1= ] 54369\043B0©<\=·9 Ç ½ r ? R +�_YfX[g9 T 3658c>3B5 Ä^z}Å\Å�Î\È>Ä>Î\Å 5 U =X=X.1=�p�,/.Yp>.Y7C9\_R�NKJ Í Ñ Ç � Ä , ½ z Ô u 3�c%Ë z Õ � � 3 U 043BD{9 W U _¾7C. ½ 7:9\02´�.1=Xp�023658c>365�.1=X087C369\D�<;aA9 W U _¾7C.Y74[X54369\DX3BD043B52c\365�¼ U 027Z74<»0C9�c>3 U 0�74. W 3©an54< W . W fX_Y3 W 36=�7C.Y=Xp)5236fX_Y. ] 9)043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=.1=�9»_13Bp�9 ] F 0 F 087C3 W

Ì>|

Page 106: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

_1.Y´\3 J = Á U 365 F �y[X. ] [ U 043B0Z7C<V< W 9\= F p\_1< E 9;_¹c;9\52.h9 E _Y360 � M U 5Z3�9;54_1.Y365q�t<>52´�04[�<Â��36D³7C[g9�77C[�3 W U _Y74.Y7C9\04´�.1=�p�023652c\365�fi3652an<\5 W 0�04. W .Y_h9\5�7C<{74[X3 W U _Y7C.¾7C[X523�9\D�36D�023652c\365 � 9\_¾7C[X< U p>[�7C[�3W U _¾7C.¾7C[X523�9\DX3BD�023652c\365Z.Y0�9\_¾�o9 F 0¶02_1.1p\[�74_ F a¦9\087C3B5 Ô |\Ŧq <\a W 369\0 U 5436D�543602f¸<\=X043'74. W 360ka¦9\_1_�y.Y74[X.1= z�Ŧq <\a¢3�9 ] [�<\74[X365 Õ L Î>Î N �J =�7C[�.10¶3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�740 � �t3«DX.1087C54. E U 7436D�7C[�3 z}Æ O �ö] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�<Âc\365ZË{D�.104´�0Z9;=XD U 043BD³9\=3�µV745C9�DX.102´«7C<�0274<>543q9ZË O � 543BfX_1. ] 9 � � 3q9\040 U W 3BD�l U 3B54.Y360�9\5452.Yc>3B0K9\0K9�?b<>.10204<>=�fX54< ] 3B040 �9\=XD U 0436D Î\Å 02[X<>587�l U 3652.1360/�y.¾7C[»9�c\365C9;p>3 Ä 7C3B5 W 0/f¸3B5/l U 365 F � w .1p U 543 Î � Ë ] < W fg9\52360/7C[�3fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3¹<\a U 04.1=�p�7C[�3t54369\_�0 F 02743 W 9\=XD¶74[X3¹04. W U _h9;74<>5I�y[X3B=�7C[X3�5436f�_1. ] 9KD�.102745C9 ] 7C0bË Å¦q<\a ] < W�W 9\=�DX0 � 9\=XD�04[X<}�y0�74[g9;7q7É�t<)0 F 02743 W 0¶fX5236043B=�7C36D�74[X3«049 W 3�74543B=XD�9\=XD�3�µ^fi3 ] 7436D. W fX52<Âc\3 W 36=�7C0�an54< W fg9\587C.h9;_i5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= �AT 3 ] 74.1<>= Æ � z � Ç 9\=XD T 3 ] 74.1<>= Æ � Ä a U 527C[�365o3Úµ�f�_1<>5237C[�3qfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�<\a¢fg9\5274.h9\_Ö5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>= �

Ôw)VU �-24A�Þ��4Z�0�<FE�?72xA &Å<K0�<>8D.IEY.�0�Ws [X.Y0t043 ] 74.1<>='D�360 ] 54. E 3B0o7C[X3�fg9\5C9 W 3�7C36520���3�c;9\5 F .Y='< U 5�3�µ^f¸3B54. W 3B=�740 � M U 5 ] <>=�jXp U 5C9�7C.1<\=fg9\549 W 3B7C3B540¢.1= ] _ U DX3�fg9\549 W 3�7C3B540®74[g9;7eD�3Bjg=X3 ] < W�W 9\=�D ] [g9\549 ] 743652.10274. ] 0e0 UX] [�9\0 ¾:���Z���\�i£�\�Ú�Ú¥ÇÀ��$¹i�2�\�É� � 9\=�D ¾:���Z���\�i£¶�Z¥�K>�¦¡^�C���4�\�¦¥ � � 74[X<>023�7C[X9;7tD�3Bjg=X3�l U 365 F 9\=�D ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= ] [g9\5 ½9 ] 7C3652.1087C. ] 0�0 UX] [�9\0 ¾:�l¹Ç¹1�¿¾��¦¥ ��� ��¥Bß�� � �É�����¶���g����¨6¡����Ú� � 9\=XD ¨6¡����Ú�@�L���Ú�ö�Ú�C�4¨6¡g����¾���£\¥1���ø�Ú¥ÇѪ6¡V�ø¥ ��� � 7C[X<\043�74[g9;7oD�360 ] 54. E 3�Dg9;7:9�fX_h9 ] 3 W 36=�7¹an3�9;7 U 543B0o0 UX] [@9;0 ¾:�l¹Ç¹1�¿¾��¦¥ ���@��¥Bß�� � �g¡V��ª����q�L�¾:�l¹Ç¹1�¿¾��¦¥ ����� � �g¡V��ª����q�L�K�C�É��¹ ¥�¾4��� 9\=�D �C�É��¹ ¥�¾4����¥Bß�� � 9\=�D«7C[X<\043�74[g9;7�DX360 ] 52. E 3�[g9\52D��t9\543�9;=XD04<;a�7É�o9\523�an3�9;7 U 543B0/0 U�] [�9;0 �g¡^��ª������L�¶��¬V�C�4��£�� � �g¡V��ª����©�L�*à¢�,áI� � 9;=XD �g¡^��ª������L��£\¥1�U¢}� �s 9 E _13 Î � Î f�54360236=�7C0o74[X3Kfg9\5C9 W 3�7C36520 � 7C[X3B.15�9 EXE 523BcV.h9�7C.1<\=X0 � 9\=XD�c;9\_ U 3B0¹��3 U 043�74[X54< U p>[X< U 77C[�.10mDX.Y04043B527C9;7C.Y<>= �

ând f-f�Þ a s·ÞXýÂý ònï Þ� �ýÂÞ�ü�àãâPäÁåJ ='7C[�3/04. W U _h9�7C<>5 � ��3 W <^DX3B_¸_Y.1p>[�7�<>5o[X369�c F �t<\54´�_1<�9;DX0 E�F 02_1<}�y.1=Xp¶DX<}�y=%<>5o04fi363BDX.1=�p U f7C[�3 ] < W�W 9\=�D»9\5452.Yc;9\_¢5C9;743 � � 3 W <VDX36_b7C[X3 ] < W©W 9\=XD"9;5454.¾c;9\_®fg9�747C3B54= U 02.1=Xp�9@?¢<>.Y0402<>=

|>Å

Page 107: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

�V($2�($<a136132�7 G�U0U02513c�Y�(f65Yp;�b � ($K ^ 1P7� ;�<a<e($b�`LG{225Ypcf(�KE��(f651 hMg j l x y g m�¼;�Y�757�;�b�`�Y�7!6 h ')(�c�N h /�;�<a<a(�b `07 � 71�/P* Ò g j g3l gPx gPy j$m� ;�<a<e($b�`LE�Yp-�6 ^ 251æ��(f65Yp;]�^ 1325� _ 7 ^ <a<e($25� _ `�;�/ ^ <a13b�6 ç £Rè g _ g�hkw _kj?×1325<a7,4n132J� ^ 1325�Ù')(�c�132�($N�1�*7>0YZ8Á651�`�b01�N h U0YMb0;�<aY�($K�`�Y�7�6 h ³zépê:ë j y g j j |� ^ 1�2��?×1325<íì 21 ]�^ 13b /3� CJU 7 h�JYM7�625YpU ^ 6YM;�b · ëSé Ð �JYM7�6 h~ ^ <ÀUn132B;$8 � ;�KMKM1�/©65Yp;�b 7 ³ £ Ò Ó g y t jg j l y gPx t j� ;�KMKM1�/©65Yp;�b\I�Y}��1a'����B* îDï �}ð ª x$l g j y j w�x g m�j lI�1�2c�132B7�4n131P` ^ 4 ñ ê l~ ^ <ÀUn132B;$8 � �>�J7 ³ £ ê/ò g j l~ ^ <ÀUn132B;$8W�JYM7r�7 ³ Î � ï ó g j l y~ ^ <ÀUn132B;$8V?,>0251�(�`07 ³zéBô g j l y g�x t j~ ^ <ÀUn132B;$8W�B1�40KpY�/3(�7 ³ Ö5ª ê Ó g j l�B1�40KpY�/3($6YM;�b��¼132�/�1�b�6�($N�1 µ Ö�ª ê Ó t�} x h j w�} g j h w�} j w�}g m } j$m } t m } l m } w m }�JYM7�62�(�/�6YMb0Ny�¼132�/�13b�6�($N�1 µ Î � ï é x m } | m } y m } i m } g m�m }I�1�Kp1P/©6YM;�b��¼132�/�1�b�65($N�1 µ ï ª Ó g j h w�} j w�} w m }� ;�KMKM1�/©65Yp;�b�GJ/3/31�757�I�r�1�qõ YM4�8 s KpYMr�1F8 ^ b /�6YM;�b ö m\':4 ^ 21 õ YM4�85* m h t g ' ^ b0Yp8:;�25<e*í Þ��! nà �IÿT�`ÿ r <\=�jgp U 549;7C.Y<>=@fg9\549 W 3�7C3B540 �

fX52< ] 36040y�y.Y74[�549;7C3 ä � � 3kc\9;5 F ä an52< W Å � z ] < W�W 9\=�DX0mf¸3B5y043 ] <>=XD)74< Ä;Å ] < W�W 9\=�DX0yf¸3B5043 ] <>=�D �

ând f-f�Þ a s f ò�÷ üt%SýÂà�ýÂÞ�ü ò d â ��÷ õ å� 3©02. W U _19;7C3 U 043B5¶9 ] 7C.¾c^.¾7 F»E�F .1020 U .Y=Xp@l U 365 F\� 0 U W©W 9\5 F>� 9\=XD DX< ]6U W 36=�7q543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_ ] < W ½W 9\=XDX0 � � 3kc\9;5 F 74[X3 W . µ^7 U 543�<;a®7C[�3 ] < W�W 9\=�DX0m7C< W <VDX3B_IDX.Yظ365236=�7 U 043B5KfX9;74743654=�0 � w <>53�µ�9 W fX_Y3 �ez>�ÐÄ^�ÐÄ«W 369\=X0/74[g9;7�an<>5/369 ] ["l U 365 F ] < W�W 9;=XD � ] _1.Y36=�7C0�.Y040 U 3 Ä 0 U W�W 9;5 F 9\=XD ÄDX< ]6U W 36=�7 ] < W©W 9\=XD�0 � J =»74[X3 syH/M d�+ T _Y<>p«7C[X9;7��t3�9\=X9\_ F ¿ 3BD".1=»+�f�f¸3B=XDX.¾µ � � .Yaº��39\020 U W 3�7C[�3/543B04fi<>=X043/an<\5o9�0 U W©W 9\5 F ] < W©W 9\=XD ] <>=�7C9\.1=X0�7C[X3/0 U W�W 9\5 F .1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=�an<\5z}Å DX< ]6U W 36=�740 � 7C[�3q549;7C.Y<Z<\ael U 3B5 Fi� 0 U W�W 9;5 Fi� D�< ]BU W 3B=�7�.Y0 z>�Yz � Î^�ÐÄ �

ä %�fÃ�Aà�ý d c i d _ nà i ü ò d�a g�âhø ÷ ù�ú å$û i d j nà i ü ò d�a g ò ü àÊâ Èyý¢��þ ò ås [X3B043Kfg9\5C9 W 3�7C36520ºp>.Yc\3y74[X3y= U W�E 365º<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0A9\=�D�74[X3m7C<\7C9\_X04. ¿ 3y<\aÖ9\_1_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0e.Y=p>.Yp�9 E�F 7C360`.Y=/7C[X3 JLu 0 F 02743 W � � 3ec\9;5 F 74[X36023A7É�t<yfg9\549 W 3B7C3B540I74<K3Úµ�9 W .Y=X3®74[X3A0 ] 9\_h9 E .1_1.¾7 F <\a

|�z

Page 108: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

9\= JLu 0 F 02743 W �y[X36='.¾7ºfX54< ] 3B0402360m9\=©.1= ] 54369\04.Y=Xp�= U W¶E 3B5�<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0º9\=�D'9\=©.1= ] 543�9;04.1=�p9 W < U =�7y<\a¢Dg9;7C9 �

í à�ýlf-g�ûAà�ý × %Sà�ý h âhø Ê�ÿ�� år 9\[X<V<>=�9;=XDvd ] � .Y=X_13 F DX3 W <>=X087C5C9�7C36D�7C[g9;7)04[X.¾a�7C3BD�=X36p>9;7C.¾c>3 E .Y=X< W .h9\_�DX.1087C54. E U 74.1<>=X0] _Y<>043B_ FqW 9;7 ] [¶74[X3tD�.1027454. E U 7C.Y<>=X0b<\a�l U 365 F _Y36=Xp;7C[�.Y=¶l U 365 F 023B7C0¢7C[X3 F .Y=�c\36087C.1p>9;7C3BD�L z}Ä^�^z�Ç N �J ='7C[�.10tD�.1040236587:9;74.1<>= � ��3 U 043/74[X36.Y5t543B0 U _¾7C0 � 9\0o02[X<}�y= s 9 E _13 Î � Æ � s [�3 ] [g9\549 ] 743654.Y0274. ] 0t<\ab904[�.Ya�7C3BD{=X3Bp�9;7C.¾c>3 E .1=X< W .19\_`DX.1087C52. E U 74.1<>=�9\523�7C[�3�= U W�E 365�<;aA7C54.19\_10 � � � 7C[�3¶fX52< E 9 E .Y_1.¾7 F <\a0 U�]6] 3B040 � � � 9;=XD{7C[X3�9 W < U =�7�<\a¹04[X.¾a�7 � � � J = s 9 E _13 Î � Æ�� 7C[�36543�9;543¶74[X543B3Z043B740k<\a Ô_¥ ��«=� ´ Õ ��y[X. ] [%fX54<VD UX] 3�DX.Yظ365236=�7o_Y36=Xp\74[X0o<\aSl U 3B54.Y360 � s [X3/jX54027o54<}�DX360 ] 54. E 3B0m04[X<\527ml U 3B54.13B0t�y.Y74[9\= 9�c>3B5C9\p>3Z<;a Ä 74365 W 0�fi365�l U 365 F 7C[X9;7 W . W . ] 7C[X<>023Zan< U =XD".1={74[X3Zl U 365 F 043�7C0�an54< W 7C[�3z}Å>Ç 54D r <\=Xp>543B0402.1<>=g9;_ u 3 ] <>54D � s [�3�7C[X.Y54D©54<}��DX360 ] 52. E 360o_Y<>=Xpql U 3654.Y360t�y.¾7C[«9\=%9�c>3B5C9\p>3�<\aÄ � 74365 W 0�f¸3B5ol U 365 F 74[g9;7 W . W . ] 74[X<>043�an< U =XD%.Y='9 syu à r z l U 3B5 F 043B7 � s [X3/023 ] <\=XD@54<}�y0DX3B0 ] 52. E 360 W 36DX. U W l U 3654.Y360m�y.Y74[ zÂÄ 7C3B5 W 0ofi365ml U 365 F 7C[X9;7m.10o9\=@9\5274.Yj ] .h9\_il U 365 F 043�7m7C[g9�704[�<Â�y0 ] [g9\549 ] 743652.10274. ] 0yan52< W 02[X<>587�9;=XD�_Y<>=XpZl U 3B54.13B0 �

�J1�75/�25Yp4�65Yp;�b � ^ 1325�LI�1�6 G�c�Ny� 1�b0N$65> Û � �I�>0;�2�6J� ^ 1�2YM1�7 g m t 25` � � j l m h y gE�1P`�Y ^ < � ^ 1�2YM1�7 ~D� G g j j m h |�| w� ;�b0N�� ^ 1325Yp1P7 ? �{+ � g j | j m hpg g mí Þ��F nà �IÿT�Iÿ s [X3kc\9;_ U 3B0 U 043BD).1=%74365 W 0mfi365yl U 365 F �

[ %Sà�ý h ü}à�ýlf c ýÂà × %bà a i h s ò gBü}ý ò �!%`ü ò d�a â ����Ê ô åT .Y= ] 3¹7C[X3B543t.Y0¢=�</9\p>52363 W 3B=�7e9 E < U 7®9 ] < W©W <>=X_ F 9 ]6] 36f�7436DZDX.Y027454. E U 7C.Y<>=�an<>5b74365 W an5236l U 3B= ½] .Y360k.1="l U 3B54.13B0~L � Î N � �t3 U 043�9\= < E 023658c>36D�l U 365 F 74365 W an5436l U 3B= ] F DX.Y027454. E U 7C.Y<>=»< E 7C9\.1=X3BDan54< W 7C[X3 syu à r z l U 3B5 F 043�7�9\0�DX360 ] 54. E 3BD{.1= r 9\[X<V<>={9;=XD"d ] � .Y=X_13 F P 0Kfg9\fi365L zÂÄ N � � 3543BfX54<VD UX] 3/7C[X3�jgp U 523�7C[g9�7m04[X<}�y0o74[X3/7C3B5 W an5436l U 3B= ] F DX.1087C54. E U 74.1<>=X0¹.1='74[X3 syu à r z ] <>_ ½_13 ] 74.1<>=Z9;=XDZ7C[X3ml U 3B5 F 023B7 � 9;0e04[X<}�y=�.1= w .Yp U 523 Î � Î � s [�3yjXp U 543m02[X<}�y0A7C[g9;7®7C365 W 0 U 043BD©.Y=

|�Ä

Page 109: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

1 10 100 1000 10000 100000 1e+06C

umul

ativ

e %

Term Frequency

TREC 1 CollectionObserved

õ ò ß�%Sý�à �Iÿ»�Iÿ Á U 3B5 F 74365 W an5436l U 3B= ] F DX.Y027454. E U 7C.Y<>=X0 �

7C[�3 syu à r l U 365 F 043B7y7436=XD%7C< U 043/an543Bl U 36=�7C_ F U 0236D%7C3B5 W 0m.1='7C[�3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � w 5236l U 36= ] .13B0<\a®9 E < U 7 |>Ŧq <\a®l U 3B5 F 74365 W 0y9\523q_19\54p\365t74[g9\= z}Å>Å>Å �� 3«< E 023658c>3'[X<}�Q74[X.10qDX.Y027C52. E U 7C.1<\= ] [X9\=Xp>3B0Z9\0k7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>="04. ¿ 3©.Y= ] 523�9\02360 � 04[X<}�y=�.Y=w .Yp U 543 Î � Æ � � 3�DX549�� w .Yp U 543 Î � Æ Ô 9 Õ U 04.1=�p�549��QDg9;7C9 � � 3�DX5C9�� w .1p U 543 Î � Æ Ô E Õ E�F =X<>5 ½W 9\_1. ¿ .1=�p�7C[�3/an5436l U 3B= ] .Y360 E�F 9�a¦9 ] 74<>5o<\a�L ´ �q§   Í ´ ��§   � �y[X3B543xL ´ ��§   .Y0t7C[�3q02. ¿ 3�<\a¢74[X3 E 9\023] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= Ô z O � .1=»7C[X.Y0 ] 9\023 Õ � 9\=XD ´ ��§   .Y0/7C[X3�04. ¿ 3�<\a¹7C[X3 ]6U 54543B=�7C_ F < E 043B52c\36D ] <>_1_Y3 ]�½7C.Y<>= � w .Yp U 523 Î � Æ Ô E Õ 02[X<}� 7C[g9�7Z7C[X3%7C[�54363�_1.Y=X360�an<\5 syu à r z>� syu à r zÂÄ^� 9\=XD syu à rzÂÄ\Ç <}c\3654_19\f³9;a�7C3B5�=X<>5 W 9;_1. ¿ .1=Xp@7C[�3@74365 W an543Bl U 36= ] F � s [�36543�an<>543 � .Y=�< U 5�02. W U _19;7C<\5 � ��3p>3B=X36549;7C3�9�l U 3B5 F 7C365 W �y.¾7C['74365 W an543Bl U 36= ] F �+��<>=@9�fX9\5274. ]6U _h9\5 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= E�F U 04.Y=Xp�7C[�3E 9\023mDX.1087C52. E U 74.1<>=�< E 7C9\.1=X3BD�an54< W 7C[�3 E 9\043 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= Ô syu à r z ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�.1=�< U 5 ] 9;043 Õ 74<p>3B=X36549;7C3Z9 E 9\023¶an543Bl U 36= ] F L �+� � 9;=XD)7C[�36= W U _¾7C.YfX_ F .1=�p�L �+� E�F 9�a¦9 ] 7C<>5�<\a ´ ��§   Í L ´ �q§   �. � 3 � �+�Å�ºL �+� )�´ ��§   Í L ´ ��§   �º�tU 7e��3o=X3B36D�7C<�=X<\7C3 � 7C[�.10®5236_19;7C.Y<>=�[�<>_1DX0b�y[X36=�74[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=04. ¿ 3y.1= ] 54369\043B0 � D U 3m74<qDX9;7:9 ] < W .Y=Xp/an54< W 7C[X3y049 W 3y02< U 5 ] 360 � J a¸74[X3y=X3B��DX9;7:9 ] < W 3B0ean54< WDX.¾ØÖ3B5436=�7¹04< U 5 ] 360 � 7C[X3}�+� ] < U _1D E 3y_Y36040º7C[X9\=*L �+� )�´ ��§   Í L ´ �q§   ��E 3 ] 9 U 023 W 9\= F =X3���7C3B5 W 0] < U _1D E 3�9;DXDX36D �w <>5S543BfX_1. ] 9\0 � ��3 U 0434�+��� �O  « ¡ � ) L �+� )�´ ��§   Í L ´ �q§   � �y[X36523 �O  « ¡ ��� z\� 02.1= ] 3�5236fX_Y. ] 9;0S�y.Y_1_] <\=�7C9\.1=©DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0¹an<>5 W <>087�an5236l U 3B=�74_ F U 0236D%l U 3652.13B0 � 9;=XD©74[ U 0ol U 365 F 74365 W an5236l U 3B= ] .Y36004[�< U _1D E 3m_h9\52p>365e74[g9\=�7C[X3K9�c>3B5C9\p>3 �º� F 3ÚµX9 W .Y=X.1=Xp�l U 3B5 F 74365 W an5436l U 3B= ] .Y360¹<\aI5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3BDl U 3652.13B0«.1=7C[�3)543BfX_1. ] 9\0Z��3 E U .Y_Y7Zan<>5�7C[�3�3Úµ�fi3652. W 36=�7C0©.1= T 3 ] 7C.1<\=·Ë � Ç � Ä^� ��3�jg=�D·7C[g9�7

|>Ç

Page 110: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

0

20

40

60

80

100

1 10 100 1000 10000 100000 1e+06C

umul

ativ

e %

Term Frequency

TREC 1 - 1 GBTREC 12 - 2 GB

TREC 123 - 3 GB

Ô 9 Õ <>52.1p>.Y=g9\_

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

1 10 100 1000 10000 100000 1e+06

Cum

ulat

ive

%

Term Frequency

TREC 1 - 1 GBTREC 12 - 2 GB

TREC 123 - 3 GB

Ô E Õ =�<>5 W 9\_1. ¿ 3BD

õ ò ß�%býÂà �IÿT�Iÿ Á U 365 F 7C3B5 W an5236l U 36= ] F DX.Y027C52. E U 7C.1<\=X0o�y.Y74[�.Y= ] 523�9\02.1=Xp ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=«04. ¿ 3 �

p>3B=X36549\_1_ F �O  « ¡ ��DX3 ] 54369\043B0¶9;0(L �+��.Y= ] 523�9\02360 � � 3Z< E 7C9\.1=X3BD)7C[�3�an<>_1_Y<Â�y.Y=Xp�an<>5 W U _h9\0 E�FDX.¾c^.YDX.1=�p�L �+�».1=�74<�023Bc\365C9;_b.Y=�7C3658c;9\_10y9\=�D�9�c\365C9;p>.1=XpZ74[X3�c\9;_ U 3B0y�y.¾7C[X.Y=%3�9 ] [�.1=�7C3B52c;9\_ �

� �´µµµµµµ¶ µµµµµµ·w ± l�t _ ¢ « ��� g m�m�mj�± i j _ g m�m�m½¹ ¢ « �� w m�m�mj�± x m _ w m�m�m½¹ ¢ « �� g m�m�m�mg ± w m _ g m�m�m�mz¹ ¢ « �� w m�m�m�mg ± t0g _ w m�m�m�mz¹ ¢ « �� g m�m�m�m�mg ±kj g _ Ü « ¯ ¿ ¶ » & ± ¿¶ ¿q°nÝ � � É � _ � À ±:&SÇ ¿ ² Ü ¶ & ±/&SÇ ¿ ¹ g % qB>01�21 Ü ¶ & ±:&RÇ ¿ Y�7,6>01�;�2YMN�YMb (�K /3;�KMKp1P/©65Yp;�b�7Y}��1Ò Ö � ï �}ð ªï �}ð ª _ Ü « ¯ ¿ ¶ » & ± ¿

î àVý ï à�ý~g6ûAà�à`s�%bû â� ÿ å� 3�9;D�¼ U 027y74[X.10mfg9;5C9 W 3B74365o7C<�02. W U _19;7C3/9�023652c\365 ÿq74. W 360y9\0ma¦9\087K9\0y< U 5 E 9;043q0 F 02743 W �

| Ë

Page 111: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

ä %�fÃ�Aà�ý d c/â Ý ù g �Ys ò gQª=g��^ü ú ýÂà�Þ�s�g�ûAà�ý^f�Þ i ú ò a àÊâ:ø ÷ ÿ�� �Jø ó ��ýj� �Jø Ê�� ås [X3�= U W�E 365q<\a r ? R 0�f¸3B5 W 9 ] [X.Y=X3�9\=XD"7C[X3�= U W�E 365q<\aoD�.104´�0qf¸3B5 W 9 ] [X.Y=X3�9;ظ3 ] 7q7C[�3W 9 ] [X.1=�3tfX52< ] 360402.1=Xp ] 9\fg9 E .1_1.¾7 F 9\=XDZDg9�7:9/_h9 F < U 7e<;aÖ9 JLu 0 F 087C3 W � s [X3m= U W¶E 3B5e<\ag7C[�543�9;DX09;ظ3 ] 7C0�7C[X3 U 7C.1_Y. ¿ 9;7C.Y<>=�<;at[g9;54D��t9\543 ] < W fi<>=X3B=�7C0 � � 3�c;9\5 F 7C[�36043�= U W�E 36520�7C<%3�µ�9 W .1=�3[X<}�!74<�3Bظ3 ] 74.Yc\36_ F 3Úµ^fX_1<>.¾7m[g9\52D��t9\543q543B04< U 5 ] 3B0K74< E U .1_YD@9�[X.Yp>[@f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3 JLu 023658c>365 �

ä %�fÃ�Aà�ý d c ýÂàVû! òji Þ�g âhø�� ò ÿ ú å$ûtýÂà�ûF ò_i Þ�ü ò d�a ûAà�ý i à a ü}ÞXß�à â � � ò ÿ ú å�ûws ò gBü�ý�Þ i ü ò a ß�ûAà�ý �i à a ü}ÞXß�àãâ � ó ��ý_Ê ås [X3B043»7C[X52363»fg9;5C9 W 3B7436540©7C<>p>3�7C[X3B5%DX360 ] 52. E 3{7C[X3{an369;7 U 52360%<\akfX9\5274.h9\_�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>= � [X<}�W 9\= F 543BfX_1. ] 9\0A.Y=�7C[X3K0 F 02743 W Ô ø�� ò ÿ ú Õ � �y[g9;7¹f¸3B5 ] 36=�7:9\p\3�<\a¸Dg9;7C9�.10A543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D Ô � � ò ÿ ú Õ � 9;=XD�y[g9;7�fi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3�<\a®l U 3654.Y360�.10KDX.1523 ] 7436D)74<�74[X3¶5236fX_Y. ] 9\0 Ô � ó ��ý¢Ê Õ � � [X3B=)��3¶0C9 F 9©fX9\5274.h9\_543BfX_1. ] 9¶049;7C.Y02jg3B0�� ó ��ý¢ÊS<\abl U 3654.Y360 � .Y7o9\_102<�.1=XD�. ] 9�7C360�7C[g9;7�7C[X3�5236fX_Y. ] 9��y.1_Y_¸049;7C.Y02a F 7C[X3/049 W 3fi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3�<\aS0 U W©W 9\5 F 9;=XD%DX< ]6U W 36=�7 ] < W�W 9\=�DX0 �^E 3 ] 9 U 023���3 U 043�74[X3/049 W 3�DX.1087C52. E U^½7C.Y<>=�7C<�DX.Y027454. E U 7C3y0 U W©W 9\5 F 9;=XD'DX< ]6U W 36=�7 ] < W�W 9;=XDX0 � s [X36523Ban<>523 � R29�543BfX_1. ] 9kDX.1087C549 ] 740� ó ��ý¢Êe<\a®l U 3652.1360+S«[g9;0K74[X3�049 W 3 W 3�9\=�.1=Xp�9\0oR49�5436f�_1. ] 9ZDX.1087C5C9 ] 7C0[� ó ��ý¢Êe<\a ] < W�W 9\=XDX0+S©.Y=< U 5 ] <>=�7C3ÚµV7 � R2+�543BfX_1. ] 9¶D�.102745C9 ] 7C0o<\5o0C9;74.108jg360y9�l U 3B5 F S W 3�9;=X0t7C[X9;7o7C[�3�5436f�_1. ] 9¶043B_13 ] 7C<\5043B=XDX0y7C[X3kl U 3B5 F 7C<Z74[g9;7K543BfX_1. ] 9 �

î à� nà i ü ò d�a ûAà�ý i à a ü�ÞXß�àãâ ��ý ò ú å$û i d j nà i ü ò d�a Þ i¦i à`gkgmgQª�঩ â��Eås [X3B043m7É�t<�fX9\5C9 W 3B7436520eDX360 ] 52. E 3t7C[X3�an3�9;7 U 543B0A<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=¶0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � �y[X9;7Afi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3m<\a] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0o74[X3q0 F 02743 W 043�9;5 ] [X3B0�9;7�9�74. W 3 Ô ��ý ò ú Õ � 9;=XD�74[X3qan5236l U 3B= ] F <\ae369 ] [ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=E 36.1=�p©9 ]6] 3B040236D»9;a�74365 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=%0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>= Ô �>Õ �� 3 W <VDX36_V7C[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�9 ]B] 36020º04´\3�� U 02.1=Xpk9 G .Yf�a ½ _Y.1´\3ºa U = ] 7C.Y<>=�9\0ean<>_Y_1<}�y0 � 9\020 U W 3o7C[g9�7��3��o9\=�7k7C<%0236_Y3 ] 7� ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0�7C<%023�9\5 ] [�9�7k9«7C. W 3 � ��3 U 043�� 7C52.h9\_Y0 � J ="3�9 ] [»7454.h9;_ ���3 ] [X<^<\043�9 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�an54< W 74[X3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X04È-74[g9;7m[X9}c\3�=X<\7 E 3B36= ] [X<>0236=�9 ]6] <>54D�.1=Xp¶74<7C[�3qD�.1027454. E U 7C.Y<>='a U = ] 7C.Y<>=�� Ô � Õ �¾�

� Ô � Õ � ° Í � � s�� �K�y[�36543 ° � z Í������ �� Ô z Í · � s�� Õ � z! � ! Èp�

|�Î

Page 112: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

+�0 � c;9\52.13B0qan52< W z 74< Å�� 7C[X3�fX52< E 9 E .Y_1.¾7C.13B0/c;9\5 F an52< W 9\= U =X.Yan<>5 W DX.Y027C52. E U 7C.1<\= 74<�7C[�3f U 523 G .Yf�aoD�.1027454. E U 7C.Y<>= � � 3�DX<�=X<\7q[g9�c>3'_Y<>p>0/an<>5 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>="9 ]B] 3B040�fg9�747C3B54=X0q.1=�9�523�9\_W U _¾7C.YfX_13 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=%043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp«3B=�cV.Y54<>= W 36=�7 �iE U 7K04.1= ] 3ql U 3654.Y360K[g9�c>3�_1< ] 9\_Y.Y7 F>� 7C[X3�9 ] 7 U 9\_DX.Y027C52. E U 7C.1<\=%fX54< E 9 E _ F ] _Y<>043B0y74<�9�f U 543 G .1f�aS74[g9\=�9\= U =X.Yan<\5 W a U = ] 74.1<>= �

|>Æ

Page 113: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

���v�'&����)� ¡& �)� #'$ ��( ��&ö��� ��*)�����!�"��� $ & $Ù# $ ��� ������������������

��& #'$ ��( �"��� $ & ���{��������*{��� �}Ö ������(

s [X.Y0 ] [g9;f�7C3B5«.1=�c\360274.1p�9�7C360�7C[�3�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3)9\=�D·0 ] 9\_h9 E .1_Y.Y7 F <\a�< U 5�DX.Y027454. E U 7C3BD·.1=^an<>5 ½W 9;7C.Y<>=543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_m0 F 087C3 W U 02.1=Xp"7C[�3�02. W U _19;7C<\5ZfX543B0436=�7436D�.Y= r [g9;f�7C3B5 Î � � 3@3Bc;9\_ U 9;7437C[�3/f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3�<\aSfg9\549\_1_Y36_ JLu 023658c>36520 U 04.Y=Xp�0 FVW�W 3�7C52. ] W U _Y74.1fX52< ] 360204<>520 � � 3�3�µ�9 W .1=�3[X<}�7C< E 9\_19\= ] 3�[g9\54D^�o9\523k9\=XD@04<;a�7É�o9\523�543B04< U 5 ] 3B0y�y.¾7C[@543B04fi3 ] 7m7C<�= U W�E 36540m<;ab74[X54369\DX0 �r ? R 0 � DX.Y04´�0 � 9\=�D�74[X3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�02. ¿ 3 � � 3 ] < W fg9\523o7C[X3mDg9�7:9�fX_h9 ] 3 W 36=�7º087C5C9�7C36p\.1360e�y[�36=��3Z[g9�c>3�9\DXD�.Y7C.Y<>=g9\_SDX.Y04´�0 � � 3�3�c\9;_ U 9;743¶7C[�3�f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3�<\aºfg9\587C.h9;_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�543BfX_1. ] 9 ½7C.Y<>=�9\=XD ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=Z.1=�9�DX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D JLu 0 F 02743 W � � 3 ] < W fg9\543�7C[X3mfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3<\ayfg9;527C.19\_º543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= 9\=XD ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�fg9;527C.¾7C.Y<>=X.1=�p � 9\=XD�74[X3'fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3�<\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�9\=XD�fg9\587C.h9;_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=%5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\= �M U 5K3�µ^f¸3B54. W 3B=�740�DX3 W <\=X02745C9;743�7C[X9;7/9;DXDX.1=�p«[g9\52D��t9\543�543602< U 5 ] 360�. W fX54<}c>3B0�0 F 087C3 W fi365 ½an<>5 W 9\= ] 3¶<\=X_ F �y[X3B= [X9\54D��t9\523Z543602< U 5 ] 360k9;543 ] 9\543�a U _1_ F�E 9\_h9\= ] 36D � <\74[X3658�y.1043¶.Y7 ] 9\=»DX3 ½p>549\DX3@7C[X3�f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3 � R 02.1=Xp 3�µV745C9�D�.104´�0©<>5�043658c>3B540«74< E U .1_1D³fg9\587C.19\_o543BfX_1. ] 9\0�<\a/9] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�fi3658an<>5 W 0Z04.Yp>=X.Yj ] 9\=�7C_ F�E 3B727C3B5�74[g9\= U 04.Y=Xp»7C[X3 W 7C<"fg9;527C.¾7C.Y<>=�7C[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�y[X3B=�7C[�3�5236fX_Y. ] 9 Ô 0 Õ DX.1087C5C9 ] 7q9 ] 3B527:9;.1= 9 W < U =�7k<\a JLu ] < W�W 9;=XDX0 � s [�3©. W fX52<}c>3 W 36=�740< ]6]6U 5©�y[X3B=�7C[X3�5436f�_1. ] 9 D�.102745C9 ] 7C0©_136020©74[g9\= z�Ŧq <\a ] < W©W 9\=XDX0�.1= W 9;= F ] 9\043B0 � u 3 ½027454. ] 7C.Y=Xp¶74[X3�04369\5 ] [@7C<�9�0 U E 043�7K<\aS7C[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0t. W fX52<Âc\360o0 F 027C3 W f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3��y[�36=36.¾7C[X3B5K74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�9 ]6] 36040/9;a�7C3B5 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�.10ma¦9\.Y54_ F U =X.¾an<>5 W <>5y<>=�_ F 9�0 W 9\_1_fi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3�<;a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0m9\543�023�9\5 ] [X36D �J =�74[X3 3�µ^f¸3B54. W 3B=�740�.Y=74[X.10 ] [g9;f�7C3B5 � �t3 W <^DX3B_/7C[X3 ] < W©W 9\=XD9\5254.Yc;9\_k9;0�9Ù?¢<>.Y0402<>=fX52< ] 36040 � s [X3 U 0236540 U 023�02[X<>527Kl U 3B54.13B0K�y.¾7C[�9\=�9}c\36549\p>3q<\a Ä 7C3B5 W 0yf¸3B5Kl U 3B5 F\� 9;=XD�.Y040 U 3

| �

Page 114: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

l U 365 F>� 0 U W©W 9\5 F\� 9\=XD�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7 ] < W�W 9\=XDX0 � �y.Y74[�9{5C9;74.1<�<\a z>�¾z � ÎV� Ä^� 9\0¶��3'an< U =XD�.Y=7C[�3 s [X< W 9\0�_1<>p\0 Ô 04363ÎL Ä>Ä N/9;=XD T 3 ] 7C.Y<>= � Õ � � 3 W 369\0 U 543)523602f¸<>=�043)74. W 3 � r ? R 9;=XDDX.Y04´ U 7C.Y_1. ¿ 9;74.1<>= � 9\=XD'DX3�7C3B5 W .1=X3y7C[X3�_h9\52p>36087 ] < W�W 9\=�D'9\5254.Yc;9\_g549;7C3�9;7¹�y[X. ] ['74[X3�0 F 087C3 W0 U fXf¸<\527C0©9\=·9}c\36549\p>3�l U 365 F 523604fi<>=X023�74. W 3 U =XDX365 z}Å 043 ] <>=XD�0 � � 3 ] [X<\043 z�Å 023 ] <\=XDX09\5 E .Y745C9\52.1_ F 9\0y< U 5 ]6U 74<\Ø"f¸<\.1=�7oan<>5y9�54369\04<>=X9 E _13�523602f¸<>=�043k7C. W 3 �s [X3�543 W 9\.Y=XDX3B5q<;at7C[�3 ] [g9;f�7C3B5�.Y0q<\54p�9\=�. ¿ 3BD�9;0kan<\_1_1<}�y0 � ��3«3�c;9\_ U 9�7C3�7C[�3©fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3<\aºfg9;5C9\_Y_136_`023658c>36520k.1= T 3 ] 74.1<>= Æ � z\� 7C[�3�f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3�<\aAfg9\587C.19\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=)5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=�.Y=T 3 ] 7C.Y<>= Æ � ÄV� 74[X3�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3y<\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0236_13 ] 74.1<>=�.1= T 3 ] 7C.Y<>= Æ � Ç�� 9\=�D«0 U W©W 9\54. ¿ 3m7C[�3543B0 U _¾7C0y<\ab7C[X.Y0 ] [g9\f�74365K.1= T 3 ] 7C.Y<>= Æ � Ë �

¡})+( &Á<K0�<>5G5G.�5��BA�9C2*0 8D<FE�?72xA �H.IEY0 ?G.=JK<>5 �³W�?GA�� ��][8 8\.IE�0 ?7: ( Z65eE�?#"

Õ�0�2�:=.�W�WY2*0�Ws [X.Y0�023 ] 74.1<>=�3�µ^fX_Y<>543B0t[X<}��74<¶9 ] [X.13�c>3�[�.1p>[�f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3man<>5º.1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>=�523B7C52.13�c\9;_ U 04.Y=Xp0 FVW�W 3�7C52. ] W U _Y7C.YfX54< ] 3B0402<>540 � � 3�.Y=�c>36087C.Yp�9;7C3%[�<Â�Û7C< E 9;_h9\= ] 3%04<\a�7É�t9\523�9;=XD[g9\54D^�o9\523�y.Y74[�543602f¸3 ] 7¹7C< W U _¾7C.YfX_13t74[X54369\DX0 � r ? R 0 � 9\=XD�DX.102´V0¹9\0A74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=Z04. ¿ 3y.1= ] 54369\043B0 � � 3] < W fg9;543/7C[�3qfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�<\ae5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=%9\=XD�fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xp�<}c>365�9\DXD�.Y7C.Y<>=g9\_iDX.Y04´�0 �� 3Z027:9;527��y.Y74["9 E 9\043Z0 F 027C3 W 7C[g9�7 ] <>=�04.1087C0k<\a¹<>=X3�74[X54369\D � r ? R � 9;=XD»DX.102´ � M U 5 E 9\0230 F 087C3 W .10kDX.Y04´ E < U =XD �y[X36523©7C[�3©DX.Y04´».Y0¶9 E <\727C_Y36=X3 ] ´ � � 3�. W fX54<}c>3�7C[�3©fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3<\ab< U 5 JLu 043B52c\365m7C[X52< U p>[ E 3B727C3B5m04<\a�7É�t9\543 Ô W U _¾7C.Y74[X54369\DX.Y=Xp Õ � 9\=�D'�y.Y7C[@9;DXDX.Y74.1<>=X9\_�[g9\54D ½�t9\543 Ô r ? R 0©9;=XDDX.102´V0 Õ � M U 5Zfg9;5C9\_Y_136_�.1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>=�523B7454.13�c;9\_o043B52c\365 U 043B0 J = Á U 365 F 9;07C[�3�523B7C52.13�c\9;_b3B=Xp>.Y=X3�L Ë Æ N � J =�< U 5Kfg9\549\_1_Y36_ JLu 043B52c\365 � 9\0K04[X<}�y={.Y= w .Yp U 523 Æ � z>� �y[X3B=)7C[�3043B52c\365A543 ] 3B.Yc>3B0¹9\= JLu ] < W�W 9\=�D � .¾7A9\0204.1p\=X0¢74[X3 ] < W�W 9\=XD�74</<>=X3t<>5 W U _¾7C.YfX_13A7C[�543�9;DX0A9 ]Ú½] <\54DX.Y=Xpq74<�74[X3 ] < W©W 9\=XDZ7 F fi3/9\=XD ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�fg9\5274.Y74.1<>=X.Y=Xp � w <>5º3�µ�9 W fX_13 � �t3/D�.1027454. E U 7C39 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=»<}c>365qË@DX.102´�0Q{®�y[X3B=�74[X3�043658c>3B5¶543 ] 3B.Yc>3B0¶9@l U 365 F ] < W�W 9\=XD � .¾7q9\0402.1p>=X0k7C[�3l U 365 F ] < W�W 9;=XD»7C<@an< U 5k7C[X523�9\DX0 � 369 ] [�<\a��y[X. ] [�3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C3B0q74[X3 ] < W�W 9;=XD 9\p�9\.Y=X027k7C[�3Dg9;7C9'<>="<>=X3ZDX.Y04´ � 9\=XD»7C[�36=»7C[X3Z023658c>365 W 3654p\360/7C[�3Z54360 U _Y740�an54< W 7C[X3ZË%74[X54369\DX0 � w <\5�90 U W©W 9\5 F ] < W�W 9\=XD � 74[X3y043658c>3B5t9\0204.Yp>=X0º.Y7A74< ¥ 74[X54369\DX0 � �y[X3B543 ¥ .Y0e7C[X3y= U W�E 365º<\a¸DX.Y04´�0

|>Ì

Page 115: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

DISK1

Responses

DISKn

CPUm

CPU1

CPU2

:

:

:

INQUERY Server

:

:

:

DISK2

Shared Memory

Commads

õ ò ß�%býÂà �`ÿ¦þgÿ s [X3kfg9\549\_1_Y36_ J = Á U 365 F 043658c>3B5

�V($2�($<a136132�7 G�U0U02513c�Y�(f65Yp;�b � ($K ^ 1P7� ;�<a<e($b�`LG{225Ypcf(�KE��(f651 hMg j l x y g m�¼;�Y�757�;�b�`�Y�7!6 h ')(�c�N h /�;�<a<a(�b `07 � 71�/P* Ò g j g3l gPx gPy j$m� ;�<a<e($b�`LE�Yp-�6 ^ 251æ��(f65Yp;]�^ 1325� _ 7 ^ <a<e($25� _ `�;�/ ^ <a13b�6 ç £Rè g _ g�hkw _kj?×1325<a7,4n132J� ^ 1325�Ù')(�c�132�($N�1�*7>0YZ8Á651�`�b01�N h U0YMb0;�<aY�($K�`�Y�7�6 h ³ épê:ë j� ^ 1�2��?×1325<wì0251 ]�^ 1�b /�� CJU 7 h`�Y�7!6 h 8:2;�< ]�^ 1325YM1�7 · ëSé Ð �JYM7�6 h~ ^ <ÀUn132B;$8 � �>�J7 ³ £ ê/ò g j l~ ^ <ÀUn132B;$8W�JYM7r�7 ³ Î � ï ó g j l y g�x~ ^ <ÀUn132B;$8V?,>0251�(�`07 ³ é Õ g j l y g�x t jí Þ��! nà �Iÿ¦þ�ÿ r <>=�jgp U 5C9;74.1<>=@fg9\549 W 3B7C3B540man<>5mfg9;5C9\_Y_136_¸3�µ^fi3654. W 3B=�7C0 �

7C[X9;7 ] <\=�7C9\.1=�74[X3mDX< ]6U W 36=�740e�y[X<>043m.YDX36=�74.Yjg3B540º9\523oDX360 ] 52. E 36D�.1=�74[X3 ] < W©W 9\=XD � 9\=XD�7C[�36=7C[�3q023658c>365 W 3654p\360o7C[�3q0 U W�W 9\52.13B0 � w <>5m9ZDX< ]6U W 3B=�7 ] < W©W 9\=XD � 7C[�3q023658c>365�9\0204.1p\=X0m.Y7o74<<>=X3�74[X54369\D � �y[X. ] [�523B7C52.13�c>360y7C[�3ka U _1_¸743�µV7�<\a¢74[g9;7yDX< ]6U W 3B=�7 �s 9 E _13 Æ � z fX543B043B=�740�fg9\549 W 3�7C3B540 � 7C[X3B.15�9 EXE 523BcV.h9;74.1<>=�0 � 9\=XD{c;9\_ U 360���3 U 023�.1=�7C[X3�3�µ^f¸3B54. ½W 36=�7C0�<\a¹7C[�.10�043 ] 74.1<>= � s [X3�5436087k<\a¹7C[X.Y0/043 ] 7C.Y<>=".10�<>52p�9\=X. ¿ 3BD"9\0�an<>_1_Y<Â�y0 � T 3 ] 74.1<>= Æ � z � z.1=�c\360274.1p�9�7C360/74[X3Z3Bظ3 ] 7C0k<\aº7C[�543�9;DX.1=Xp@9;=XD{a¦9 ] 74<>540/74[g9;7k9�ØÖ3 ] 7�7C[�3Z=X3 ] 3604049\5 F = U W¶E 3B5/<\a7C[�543�9;DX0 �¹T 3 ] 74.1<>= Æ � z � Ä .1=�c>3B027C.Yp�9;74360 E 9\_h9\= ] .1=�p�[g9;54D��t9\543K�y[X36='9\DXDX.Y=Xp r ? R 0o9\=XD«D�.104´�0 �

|>|

Page 116: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

T 3 ] 7C.Y<>= Æ � z � Ç ] < W fg9\52360®74[X3mfi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3t<\a�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=q�y.Y7C[¶fg9\5274.Y74.1<>=X.Y=Xpy�y[X36=��t3m[X9}c\39\DXD�.Y7C.Y<>=g9\_¸DX.102´�0 ��T 3 ] 7C.Y<>= Æ � z � Ë�0 U W©W 9\54. ¿ 3B0o7C[X3k543B0 U _¾7C0y<\ab7C[X.Y0m043 ] 7C.Y<>= �

�Iÿ¦þ�ÿ¦þ í¶ú ý�à�Þ�s ò a ßs [X.Y0¹023 ] 7C.1<\=�3Úµ�9 W .Y=X360º[X<}�Ù7C[X3y= U W�E 365º<\ai7C[X523�9\D�0�9�ØÖ3 ] 7C0º0 F 087C3 W 0 ] 9\_19 E .Y_1.Y7 F\� 9\=�D��y[g9�7a¦9 ] 7C<>520�9�ØÖ3 ] 7�7C[X3"=X3 ] 36020C9\5 F = U W¶E 3B5�<;a¶7C[�543�9;DX0�74[g9;7�_1369\DX0%7C[�3�0 F 087C3 W 74<Ù.¾7C0%fi3�9\´fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3 �w .Yp U 543 Æ � Ä 74< w .1p U 523 Æ � ËZ.1_Y_ U 087C5C9�7C3�[�<Â��7C[X3q9�c>3B5C9\p\3ql U 3B5 F 523602f¸<>=�043k7C. W 3/9;=XD�523602< U 5 ] 3U 74.1_1. ¿ 9;74.1<>= ] [g9;=Xp>3k9\0t74[X3�= U W�E 365o<;ab74[X54369\DX0o.Y= ] 523�9\02360o�y.¾7C['c;9\5 F .Y=Xp�= U W�E 36520m<\a r ? R 09\[email protected]´�0 � � [X3B= W U _Y74.1fX_Y3�DX.Y04´�0y3�µ^.1087y.1='74[X3�0 F 02743 W�� �t3kDX.Y027454. E U 7C3/74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>='<}c>3B5DX.Y04´�0y.1=�9Z54< U =�D ½ 52< E .1=%a¦9\02[X.1<\= �w .Yp U 543 Æ � Ä .1_Y_ U 087C5C9�7C360 ] <\=�jgp U 549;7C.Y<>=X0K�y[X36=»7C[�3�DX.102´�.Y0/9 E <\727C_13B=X3 ] ´ � � 3�04[�<Â�-7C[�3�543 ½_h9�7C.1<\=X04[X.Yf E 3B7É��363B="f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�9;=XD{7C[X3¶= U W�E 3B5�<\aA74[X54369\DX0��y[�36=»�t3¶f U 7 W <>543qDg9;7C9<>="7C[X3�DX.Y04´ � 9\=XD�9\DXD r ? R 0 � � 3�027C9\527k�y.¾7C[ <>=X3�DX.102´»9\=XD <>=X3 r ? R an<>5k9 z O �v] <>_ ½_13 ] 74.1<>= Ô w .1p U 543 Æ � Ä Ô 9 Õ2Õ � 9\=XD�74[X36=�.Y= ] 523�9\023)7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=·02. ¿ 3�an54< W z O � 7C<�Ë O �Ô w .1p U 523 Æ � Ä Ô E Õ2Õ � 9\=XD'9;DXD'<>=X3 r ? R Ô w .1p U 523 Æ � Ä Ô ] Õ2Õ � w .1p U 523 Æ � Ä Ô D Õ 04[X<}�y0t74[X3 r ? R 9;=XDDX.Y04´ U 7C.Y_1. ¿ 9;74.1<>=X0º9�7o04< W 3�.1=�7C3B5436087C.Y=Xp¶Dg9�7:9¶fi<>.1=�740t.1= ] <>=^jgp U 549;7C.Y<>=X0 Ô 9 Õ 7C< Ô ] Õ � s [�3 E <�µ<>=%7C[�3/7C<>f%<\a¢3�9 ] [@jXp U 543�_Y.1087C0t74[X3�0 F 02743 W fg9;5C9 W 3B7436540�an<>5o7C[X3�3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�7 � J =�9;_1_¸74[X36023] <\=�jgp U 549;7C.Y<>=X0 � 7C[�543�9;DX.1=XpZ02.1p>=�.Yj ] 9\=�7C_ F . W fX52<Âc\360o74[X3�l U 365 F 543B04fi<>=X043�74. W 3/9\0o74[X3�= U W ½E 365/<\aA74[X54369\DX0/.Y= ] 523�9\02360 � H <}�t3�c>365 � 9;a�7C3B5�7C[�3�= U W�E 365/<\aA74[X54369\DX0�.Y= ] 523�9\02360�74<'Ë �IW <>5437C[�543�9;DX0/. W fX52<Âc\3�74[X3�fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3qc>3B5 F _Y.Y727C_13 ��� F 3ÚµX9 W .Y=X.1=Xp�7C[�3 U 7C.Y_1. ¿ 9;74.1<>=@04[�<Â�y=".Y=w .Yp U 543 Æ � Ä Ô D Õ � Ë�7C[�543�9;DX0�543B0 U _¾7¶.Y=�DX.Y04´ U 74.1_Y. ¿ 9�7C.1<\=»<\a | �^� Ë q an<>5 ä � Ì � s [X36523«.10q_1.¾7 ½7C_Y3�52<^< W an<\5Ka U 587C[X3B5�.Y= ] 523�9\02.1=Xp�7C[X3�DX.102´ U 74.1_Y. ¿ 9�7C.1<\= � � [X3B=)�t3¶.1= ] 543�9;043¶74[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=04. ¿ 3 Ô 02363 w .1p U 523 Æ � Ä Ô E Õ2Õ � 7C[X3�0 F 02743 W 04[X<}�y0¶74[X3�0C9 W 3�74543B=XD�9\0 ] <\=�jgp U 549;7C.Y<>= Ô 9 Õ � 7C[�30 F 087C3 W f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3'02.1p>=�.Yj ] 9\=�7C_ F . W f�54<}c>3B0 U =�7C.Y_¹74[X3«7C[�3'= U W�E 365�<\am74[X54369\DX0�523�9 ] [�360Ë � 9;_Y7C[�< U p>[�043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp»Ë O � 7:9\´;360�_Y<>=Xp>3B5�74. W 3�74[g9\=�023�9\5 ] [X.1=Xp z O ��� � [X3B=��t3%9;DXD9\=)9\DXDX.¾7C.1<\=g9\_ r ? R .Y=�7C<©74[X3 ] <>=�jXp U 5C9�7C.1<\= Ô E Õ Ô 04363 w .1p U 543 Æ � Ä Ô ] Õ4Õ � 74[X3¶0 F 027C3 W fi3658an<>5 ½

z}Å>Å

Page 117: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

$&%(' ç*),+#- æ -.)0/ ��1(2,354 ç6%7+98 ç6: 2,1<;�>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ï�â ü �>��� � �

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20A

vera

ge Q

uery

Res

pons

e T

ime

(Sec

onds

)

Average Arrival Rate (requests per second)

1 thread2 threads4 threads8 threads

16 threads32 threads

åp1�è$�%@' ç*),+9- æ -.)A/ ��1@2B3C4 ç6%7+98 ç6: 2B1(;�>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ïPâ ü ÷G��� � �

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Average Arrival Rate (requests per second)

1 thread2 threads4 threads8 threads

16 threads32 threads

åpï$è$&%(' ç*),+#- æ -.)0/ ��1(2,354 ç6%7+98 ç6: 2,1<;�>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ï�â ü ÷G��� � �

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Average Arrival Rate (requests per second)

1 thread2 threads4 threads8 threads

16 threads32 threads

åMáè� à©ë�Dfä ü å{1�è � à©ë�Dfä ü åpï$è ��à©ëEDfä ü åpáèF \ù F �ú F \ú� í�â ü ç )AG �� ç )0G �� ç )AG L÷ ç )0G \� ç )AG L÷ ç )0G \� ç )AG �÷�Qv ���Pü þ V ��ý�ü ÿ V �©þPü � V ���©ü¨� V ��÷�ü ý V �ý�ü ý V ��ùPü¨� VßNY o�H ý��Pü ù V ù�ý�ü û V û�ý�ü ÷ V ù��Pü ÷ V û�÷�ü � V û��Pü ÿ V û©ùPü ý Våpî$èAU1�ìÔîEIE1�ìÔíW-h8�5kã656��1q8�5kà©ë�1q8oâ�à�7BíJ5kë�8Ôí!ì�í�âB8�5këPäBîU1q8R1,ê$à�5kë�8Ôâõ ò ß�%SýÂà �IÿT�`ÿ ?b3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�9;0y74[X3k= U W�E 365y<\ab7C[X523�9\DX0y.Y= ] 523�9\02360 Ô DX.Y04´ E <\7474_13B=X3 ] ´ Õ �

z}�z

Page 118: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

W 9\= ] 3q0274.1_Y_I04.Yp>=X.Yj ] 9\=�7C_ F . W fX52<Âc\360 U =�7C.Y_S74[X3q= U W�E 3B5�<\a¢7C[X523�9\D�0�.10yË �o�tU 7 Ä 7C[�543�9;DX0�.Y=] <\=�jgp U 549;7C.Y<>= Ô ] Õ .10bc>3B5 F ] _1<>023t7C<�Ë�74[X54369\DX0 � 02.1= ] 3m9\=�9\D�DX.Y74.1<>=g9;_ r ? R W 3�9\=X0 W <>523 ] < W ½f U 7C9;7C.Y<>=»fi<Â��365�74[g9;7k04[�<>527436=X0k7C[X3��t9\.¾7C.1=�p'7C. W 3¶an<>5 r ? R � +�_Y74[X< U p\[{an3B��365k7C[X523�9\DX0k.Y=7C[�.10 ] <>=�jXp U 5C9�7C.1<\= ] < U _1D E 54.Y=Xp W <>523�. W f�54<}c>3 W 3B=�7K7C[X9\=�74[X3¶<\74[X365y7É��< ] <>=^jgp U 549;7C.Y<>=X0 �7C[�3 W 9�µ^. W U W . W f�54<}c>3 W 3B=�7K<\ab7C[�3q0 F 027C3 W .10m087C.1_Y_Ö_Y. W .Y7C3BD E�F 7C[X3kDX.Y04´ U 7C.Y_1. ¿ 9;7C.Y<>= �w .Yp U 543 Æ � Ç .Y_1_ U 02745C9;74360 ] <>=^jgp U 549;7C.Y<>=X0y�y[X36=)74[X3 r ? R .10�9 E <\7474_136=�3 ] ´ � � 3�027:9;527K�y.Y7C[)90 F 087C3 W U 04.Y=Xp z r ? R an<>5®9 z O ��] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=qDX.1087C52. E U 7436D�<}c\365eË/D�.104´�0 Ô w .1p U 543 Æ � Ç Ô 9 Õ2Õ � 9;=XD7C[�36=).Y= ] 523�9\023q74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%04. ¿ 3�7C<�Ë O � Ô w .Yp U 543 Æ � Ç Ô E Õ4Õ � 9\=XD�9\DXD)Ë�DX.Y04´�0K�y[�. ] [)D�.10 ½7C52. E U 7C360b7C[X3�Ë O ��] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=k<}c>3B5 Ì D�.104´�0 Ô w .Yp U 543 Æ � Ë Ô ] Õ4Õ � w .Yp U 523 Æ � Ç Ô D Õ 02[X<}�y0®7C[�3 r ? R9\=XD DX.Y04´ U 74.1_Y. ¿ 9�7C.1<\=»9;7q04< W 3�.1=�7C3B543B027C.Y=Xp@Dg9;7C9�fi<>.1=�740q.Y= ] <>=�jXp U 5C9�7C.1<\=X0 Ô 9 Õ 7C< Ô ] Õ � J =7C[�36043 ] <>=�jXp U 5C9�7C.1<\=X0 � 7C[X3�9�c>36549\p>3�l U 365 F 543B04fi<>=X043�7C. W 3y04.Yp>=X.Yj ] 9\=�7C_ F . W fX52<Âc\360 U =�7C.1_�7C[�3= U W�E 365º<\ai7C[X523�9\D�0¹523�9 ] [�360 Ì�� �y[X36=�7C[X3 r ? R E 3 ] < W 360º<}c>3B5 U 74.1_Y. ¿ 3BD Ô 043B3 w .1p U 523 Æ � Ç Ô D Õ4Õ �+�0«.1=·74[X3 ] 9;043{<\a�74[X3{DX.Y04´ E <;747C_Y36=X3 ] ´ Ô 043B3 w .1p U 543 Æ � Ä Õ � 9\DXD�.1=Xp�DX9;7:9 ] 9 U 02360%_1<\=Xp>36504369\5 ] [�.1=Xp�74. W 3 �VE U 7mDX<V360t=X<\7o02.1p>=�.Yj ] 9\=�7C_ F 9�ØÖ3 ] 7o74[X3/= U W�E 365o<;a`7C[X523�9\DX0o74[g9;7t_13�9;DX0t7C[�30 F 087C3 W 74<kf¸369\´�fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3 � +�DXDX.1=�p�9;DXDX.Y74.1<>=X9\_^ËkDX.Y04´�0 W 9;´\360e74[X3yf¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3o��<>540237C[X9\=�an3B��365�DX.Y04´�0ZD U 3'74<{7É�t< 54369\04<>=�0 � w .154087 � 9\_¾7C[X< U p>[��y.¾7C[ Ì DX.Y04´�0Z3�9 ] [³DX.Y04´ [X<>_1D�0[g9\_¾aº9\0 W UX] [{Dg9�7:9«9;0�Ë'DX.Y04´�0 � 04369\5 ] [X.Y=Xp'.¾7�7C9\´\3B0 W <\543k7C[g9\=)[g9\_Ya¢7C. W 3q<\aA023�9\5 ] [X.1=Xp'9\_1_7C[�3�Dg9;7C9 Ô .Y7K7:9;´\360k9;54< U =�D Ç�È>Î <\aº74[X3¶7C. W 3�9 ]B] <>52DX.1=Xp'74<'< U 5 W 369\0 U 523 W 36=�7C0 Õ ��T 3 ] <>=XD �04369\5 ] [�.1=Xp W <>543KDX.Y04´�0o543Bl U .152360 W <>543 ] <V<>52DX.1=g9�7C.1<\=�74. W 3 � s [�36543�an<>543/74[X3�74<\7:9;_Ö9 W < U =�7�<\a7C[�3 r ? R 74. W 3oan<>5�023�9\5 ] [X.1=�p Ì D�.104´�0�.10 W <>523m7C[g9\=©04369\5 ] [X.Y=Xp�Ë�DX.102´V0 � �y[�. ] ['<}c>3B52�y[X3B_ W 07C[�3 r ? R 04<V<>=X3B5 �w .Yp U 543 Æ � Ë�.1_Y_ U 087C5C9�7C360 ] <>=�jXp U 5C9�7C.1<\=X0��y[X36= r ? R 0¶9;=XD�D�.104´�0�9\543Z��36_Y_ E 9\_h9;= ] 3BD�9\0k7C[�3] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=©04. ¿ 3/.1= ] 54369\043B0 � w .Yp U 543 Æ � Ë Ô 9 Õ ½ Ô ] Õ 04[X<}�7C[X3 ] <>=�jgp U 5C9;74.1<>=�0 U 04.Y=Xp Ä r ? R 0y9;=XDË"DX.102´�0�an<>5 Ä O � � Ë O � � 9\=XD Ì O � <\aKDg9;7C9 � 543B04fi3 ] 74.Yc\36_ F � w .1p U 543 Æ � Ë Ô D Õ 04[�<Â�y0�7C[�3r ? R 9\=XD%D�.104´ U 74.1_1. ¿ 9;74.1<>=�9;7t04< W 3�.Y=�7C365236087C.1=�p�Dg9;7C9¶f¸<\.1=�7C0o.Y= ] <>=�jgp U 5C9;74.1<>=X0 Ô 9 Õ 7C< Ô ] Õ �J =@7C[X3B043�7C[X52363 ] <>=^jgp U 549;7C.Y<>=X0 � 7C[X3k9�c>3B5C9\p\3�l U 3B5 F 543B04fi<>=X023k74. W 3/04.Yp>=X.¾j ] 9\=�74_ F . W f�54<}c>3B0

z}Å�Ä

Page 119: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

$&%(' ç*),+#- æ -.)0/ ��1(2,354 ç6%7+98 ç6: 2,1<;�>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ï�â ü �>��� � ÷

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20A

vera

ge Q

uery

Res

pons

e T

ime

(Sec

onds

)

Average Arrival Rate (requests per second)

1 thread2 threads4 threads8 threads

16 threads32 threads

åp1�è$�%@' ç*),+9- æ -.)A/ ��1@2B3C4 ç6%7+98 ç6: 2B1(;�>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ïPâ ü ÷G��� � ÷

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Average Arrival Rate (requests per second)

1 thread2 threads4 threads8 threads

16 threads32 threads

åpï$è$&%(' ç*),+#- æ -.)0/ ��1(2,354 ç6%7+98 ç6: 2,1<;�>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ï�â ü ÷G��� � ù

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Average Arrival Rate (requests per second)

1 thread2 threads4 threads8 threads

16 threads32 threads

åMáè� à©ë�Dfä ü å{1�è � à©ë�Dfä ü åpï$è � à©ë�D�ä ü åpáèF p��þ F \ù F �ù� í!â ü ç )AG �÷ ç )0G \ù ç )0G L÷ ç )AG \ù ç )0G L÷ ç )AG �ù�Qv ú©ùPü ÿ V ù��Pü ý V ù©þPü ÷ V û©�Pü ý V ù©úPü ù V û©ùPü � VßNY o�H ÿ�÷�ü¨� V ú©ÿPü ý V ÷�þPü ÷ V ÷�ùPü¨� V ���Pü ý V �©úPü ù Våpî$èAU1�ìÔîEIE1�ìÔíW-h8�5kã656��1q8�5kà©ë�1q8oâ�à�7BíJ5kë�8Ôí!ì�í�âB8�5këPäBîU1q8R1,ê$à�5kë�8Ôâõ ò ß�%Sý�à �Iÿ»�Iÿ ?b3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3q9\0m74[X3k= U W�E 3B5y<\a¢74[X54369\DX0y.1= ] 54369\043B0 Ô r ? R E <\727C_13B=X3 ] ´ Õ �

z}Å>Ç

Page 120: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

$&%(' ç*),+#- æ -.)0/ ��1(2,354 ç6%7+98 ç6: 2,1<;�>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ï�â ü � ��� � ÷

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20A

vera

ge Q

uery

Res

pons

e T

ime

(Sec

onds

)

Average Arrival Rate (requests per second)

1 thread2 threads4 threads8 threads

16 threads32 threads

åp1�è$�%@' ç*),+9- æ -.)A/ ��1@2B3C4 ç6%7+98 ç6: 2B1(;�>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ïPâ ü ÷G��� � ÷

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Average Arrival Rate (requests per second)

1 thread2 threads4 threads8 threads

16 threads32 threads

åpï$è$&%(' ç*),+#- æ -.)0/ ��1(2,354 ç6%7+98 ç6: 2,1<;�>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ï�â ü ù ��� � ÷

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Average Arrival Rate (requests per second)

1 thread2 threads4 threads8 threads

16 threads32 threads

åMáè� à©ë�Dfä ü å{1�è � à©ë�Dfä ü åpï$è � à©ë�D�ä ü åpáèF n��þ F n��þ F \ú��í!â ü ç )AG \ù ç )AG n��ú ç )AG \ù ç )AG n��ú ç )AG \ù ç )AG n��ú�Qv ÿ©úPü û V ÿ©ûPü ý V ú©ÿPü¨� V ý�úPü ú V ú��Pü û V ú�÷�ü¨� VßJY o�H ú�÷�ü ý V ú©ÿPü ý V ú�ý�ü ÿ V ý�ùPü ý V ÿ©ùPü ú V ÿ©ûPü � Våpî$èAU1�ìÔîEIE1�ìÔíW-h8�5kã656��1q8�5kà©ë�1q8oâ�à�7BíJ5kë�8Ôí!ì�í�âB8�5këPäBîU1q8R1,ê$à�5kë�8Ôâõ ò ß�%SýÂà �Iÿr�bÿ ?b3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3«9\0�74[X3�= U W�E 3B5k<\a�74[X54369\DX0q.1= ] 54369\043B0 Ô r ? R 0¶9;=XD"DX.102´V0�9\523��36_1_ E 9\_h9\= ] 36D Õ �

z}Å Ë

Page 121: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

U =�7C.Y_i74[X3/= U W�E 365�<\a`7C[�543�9;DX0o54369 ] [X3B0 z}Æ � +�0t7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=©02. ¿ 3�.1= ] 54369\043B0oan54< WÛÄ O � 74<Ì O � �gW <>523�7C[�543�9;DX0 E 54.1=�p�c\365 F 0 W 9\_1_ia U 5274[X365y. W fX52<Âc\3 W 36=�7man<>5y9Z_h9;54p>3B5 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �J =³9\_1_¹7C[X3 ] <>=�jgp U 5C9;74.1<>=�0Z04[X<}�y=³.1= w .Yp U 543 Æ � Ä ½ Æ � Ë � 7C[�3�9�c\365C9;p>3@l U 365 F 543602f¸<\=X043%7C. W 3. W fX52<Âc\360%02.1p>=X.¾j ] 9;=�74_ F 9\0'7C[�3 = U W¶E 3B5%<\a�74[X54369\[email protected]= ] 54369\043B0 U =�7C.1_�36.Y74[X365'74[X3»DX.Y04´·<\57C[�3 r ? R .10�<}c>3B5 U 74.1_1. ¿ 3BD � s <V< an3�� 74[X54369\DX0�_1. W .Y7�7C[X3@0 F 087C3 W P 0'9 E .1_1.¾7 F 74< 9 ] [X.13�c>3�.Y740fi3�9\´�f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 � w <>5�3�µ�9 W fX_Y3%.1= w .Yp U 543 Æ � Ë Ô E Õ � U 04.Y=Xp"Ë"74[X54369\DX0Z<>=�_ F 0 U fXfi<>52740 �543Bl U 36087C0ofi365¹043 ] <>=XD©an<>5¹9\='9�c>3B5C9\p\3�l U 3B5 F 543602f¸<\=X043K7C. W 3 U =XD�365 z�Å 023 ] <\=XDX0 � �y[X.1_Y3 U 04.Y=Xpz}Æ 74[X54369\DX0/0 U fXfi<>52740 z>z 5236l U 3B027C0�fi365�043 ] <>=XD U =�DX365/74[X3¶049 W 3¶[g9\54D^�o9\523 ] <\=�jgp U 549;7C.Y<>= �� <\74[ r ? R 0�9;=XD�D�.104´�0K9;ظ3 ] 7K74[X3k=X3 ] 36020C9\5 F = U W¶E 3B5K<;a¢74[X54369\DX0 �J =q< U 5 ] <\=�jgp U 549;7C.Y<>=X0 � �y[�36=k7C[X3 r ? R .10`=X<\7b9 E <\7474_136=�3 ] ´ � 9mDX.Y04´�=X363BDX0¢Ëm74[X54369\DX0`7C<ma U _Y_ FU 74.1_1. ¿ 3�.¾7C0 ] 9\fg9 ] .Y7 F � � [X36=)74[X3 r ? R .10�9 E <\7474_136=�3 ] ´ � 74[X3�0 F 027C3 W =X3B36DX0�an3B��365�74[X54369\DX0 �J = ] 543�9;04.1=�p�74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%04. ¿ 3 ] 9 U 043B0�_1<\=Xp>365t043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp�74. W 3 �XE U 7KDX<^3B0y=X<\7y04.Yp>=X.¾j ] 9\=�74_ F9;ظ3 ] 7K74[X3k= U W�E 365y<\ab7C[X523�9\DX0m74[g9;7K_1369\DX0o7C[�3q0 F 027C3 W 7C<�.Y740mf¸369\´'fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3 �J =�p>36=X3B5C9\_ � 7C[X3y=X3 ] 36020C9\5 F = U W�E 3B5º<\aÖ74[X54369\DX0º.10º0 F 087C3 W DX3Bf¸3B=XDX3B=�7 � �y[X. ] [©.Y0º9;ظ3 ] 7436D E�F9\= F ] [g9\=Xp>3Z<;aA7C[X3 ] < W�W 9;=XD W .¾µV7 U 523�549;7C.Y< � 7C[X3 JLu 0 F 02743 W .Y7C0236_¾a � 9\=�D{7C[X3 U =XDX3B54_ F .Y=Xp[g9\52D��t9\543�fX_h9;72an<>5 W � H <}�t3�c>365/��3 W 9 F 36087C. W 9;743q74[X3¶=X3 ] 3B040C9;5 F = U W�E 3B5�<\a®7C[X523�9\DX0�.1=�9043B52c\365t74[g9;7 U 043B0 ø ÷ ÿ�� r ? R 0m9\=XD ø ó ��ýj�KDX.Y04´�0�an<>5ºfX52< ] 360204.1=�p�9 Ô ø ó ��ý_�F��J Õ�O �Ù] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=9\0man<>_Y_1<}�y0 �

z � u U =�9 E 9;7 ] [�<\a�0C9 W fX_13@l U 3B54.13B0'9\p>9\.1=X087�7C[X3KJ Dg9�7:9�<\=·9 04.1=�p>[email protected]´ U 02.1=Xp�902.1=Xp>_Y3 r ? R 9\=�D"9'04.1=�p>_13q7C[X523�9\D � 9\=XD ] <\_1_13 ] 7K7C[X3�74<\7:9;_ r ? R 7C. W 3�9\=XD{74[X3¶74<\7:9\_DX.Y04´@7C. W 3kan<>5/9;_1_Sl U 365 F ] < W©W 9\=XDX0 Ô '�Ì ÷ ÿ���9;=XD 'IÌ ó ��ý_� Õ � 9\=XD{74[X3¶74<\7:9\_ r ? R 7C. W 39\=�D"74[X3�7C<;7:9\_¢DX.102´�7C. W 3�an<>5�9\_Y_®0 U W©W 9\5 F 9\=XD"DX< ]6U W 3B=�7 ] < W�W 9\=�DX0 Ô ' æ ÷ ÿ��«9;=XD' æ,ó ��ýj� Õ �

Ä � r 9\_ ]6U _19;7C3�7C[X3 E 9\023�=�3 ] 3B04049\5 F = U W�E 365y<\ab7C[X523�9\D�0 ÔCL ø Ê�� Õ U 02.1=Xp �L ø Ê���� '�Ì ÷ ÿ�� " '�Ì ó ��ýj� " Ô ' æ ÷ ÿ�� " ' æ,ó ��ýj� Õ Í ø ó ��ýj�

® � ¥eÔ '�Ì ÷ ÿ�� " ' æ ÷ ÿ�� Í ø ó ��ýj�l�h'�Ì ó ��ýj� " ' æ,ó ��ý_� Í ø ó ��ýj� Õ �z}Å�Î

Page 122: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

N <\7C3»7C[�3"��<>52´V_Y<�9\DX0�.1=�c\<>_Yc\36D.1=�7C[X3 0 U W©W 9\5 F 9\=XDDX< ]6U W 36=�7 ] < W�W 9;=XDX0@9\523DX.Y027454. E U 7C3BD�<}c\365KDX.102´V0 �

Ç � ÃA0274. W 9;7C3/74[X3k=X3 ] 36020C9\5 F = U W¶E 3B5K<;a¢74[X54369\DX0 Ô øÐø Ê�� Õ U 04.Y=XpøÐø Ê���� ø ó ��ý_�}� L ø Ê��¦�

H 3B543%��3�p>.¾c>3@9\=3ÚµX9 W fX_Y3%[X<}� 74< U 043@7C[X3@9 E <}c>3@an<>5 W U _h9�74<"360274. W 9;7C3'74[X3@=X3 ] 36020C9\5 F= U W�E 365«74[X54369\DX0«an<\5«9�023658c>365 U 04.1=�p z r ? R 9\=XD·Ë�DX.102´�0«an<>5«Ë O � Dg9;7:9 � w 54< W < U 504. W U _19;7C.Y<>=�52360 U _Y740ean<>5 U 02.1=Xp z r ? R 9;=XD z 7C[X523�9\DZan<>5 z O � Dg9;7:9/<\= z DX.102´ � �t3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7436D �

'�Ì ÷ ÿ���� z}| � | 043 ] <>=�DX0'�Ì ó ��ý_�;� Æ ËY� Ä 043 ] <>=�DX0' æ ÷ ÿ���� Ç�Î � Ì 043 ] <>=�DX0' æ,ó ��ýj�[� z>z}Î � Ì 023 ] <\=XDX0

� 3 ] 9\_ ]BU _h9;7436D L ø Ê���� Ô z}| � |�"·Æ Ë�� Ä�" Ô Ç�Î � Ì;"�z>zÂÎ � Ì Õ Í Ë Õ Í Ô z}| � |}"³Ç�Î � Ì Í Ë Õ ��ËY� Ä^� �y[�. ] [W 3�9\=X0'��3 =X363BD�Ë7C[X523�9\D�0@an<\5@9D�.104´ � w <>5@9�043B52c\365 U 04.Y=Xp z r ? R 9\=XD�ËDX.102´�0@an<\5fX52< ] 360402.1=Xp©Ë O � <\aeDg9;7:9 � ��3¶=�3636D"9;fXfX54<�µ^. W 9;7436_ F)z}Æ 74[X54369\DX0�.1=@7C<\7C9\_ � �y[X. ] [ W 9;7 ] [X3B0< U 5ojX=XDX.1=�p©.Y= w .1p U 543 Æ � Ç Ô E Õ �

�Iÿ¦þ�ÿT� í¶ú à � ÞXýls=©�ÞXýÂà ð Þ� ¦Þ a i�ò a ß á i üs [X.Y0¢023 ] 74.1<>=q.1=�c\360274.1p�9�7C360b[X<}��7C< E 9\_19\= ] 3¹[X9\54D��t9\523 ] < W fi<>=X3B=�7C0S�y.Y7C[�543B04fi3 ] 7b7C<Kc;9\5 F .1=�p7C[�3q= U W¶E 3B540y<\a r ? R 0�9;=XD�D�.104´�0 �

ì ò ß�ýÂÞ�ü ò d�a d c �¢Þ� nÞ a i�ò a ß�û d ò a ütg© ò ü ú Þ�s�s ò a ß ú Þ�ýOs=©�Þ�ý�à i d f�û d�a à a ütgJ =·p\36=X3B5C9\_ � 9\DXD�.1=Xp [g9\52D��o9;543 ] < W f¸<\=X36=�7C0�. W fX52<Âc\360�0 F 02743 W f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3 E�F fX54<}cV.1D ½.1=�p W <\543 ] < W f U 7:9�7C.1<\= ] 9;fg9 ] .¾7 F � w .Yp U 523 Æ � Î p>.¾c>360�9\=�3�µ�9 W fX_Y3«<\aK[X<}�Ê7C[X3«[g9\54D^�o9\523E 9\_19\= ] .1=XpZfi<>.1=�740 W .Yp>5C9;743/9\0o��3q[g9\=XDX_Y3k9ZË O ��] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= E�F 9\D�DX.1=Xp r ? R 0�9\=�D�D�.104´�0 �

z}Å>Æ

Page 123: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

$�%@' ç*),+#- æ -.)A/ ��1(2B3C4 ç*%�+>8 ç*: 2,1<; ç )AG�>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ï�â ü ÷ ��� ��1�ì�5kí!î ��1�ì�5kí!î �©�

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20A

vera

ge Q

uery

Res

pons

e T

ime

(Sec

onds

)

Average Arrival Rate (requests per second)

1 CPU + 1 disk1 CPU + 2 disks2 CPUs + 2 disk1 CPU + 4 disks

2 CPUs + 4 disks

å{1�èF1 ��í�ì�1�ä©í.ìÔí!âÔê$à©ë�â�í�8�567Bí��í!â�à�-�ìÔá!í � �FQ4v �� îP5kâ�O � �Qv ¼� îP5kâ�O�â � �Qv�â ¼� îP5kâ�O�â � �Qv o÷ îP5kâ�O3â � �Qv×â o÷ îP5kâ�O3â�Q4v �©þPü û V ý��Pü û V �©úPü � V û©�Pü � V ÷�ûPü ÷ VßJY o�H û©ùPü ÷ V ù©þPü ý V ù©þPü ÷ V ÷3ý�ü ý V ÿ©þPü � VåMïfèEAU1�ì�î�IE1�ì�íW-h8�5kã656��1q8�5kà©ëMI�A�í!ë F �úõ ò ß�%SýÂà �`ÿT�Iÿ ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3¹9\0I7C[�3¹[X9\54D��t9\523 ] <>=�jgp U 5C9;74.1<>= ] [X9\=Xp>3B0ban<>5I9yË O �»] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �

J =«74[X3 ] 9\043/<;a z r ? R 9\=�D z DX.Y04´ � 74[X3�0 F 027C3 W .Y0�DX.Y04´ E < U =XD Ô 043B3 w .1p U 543 Æ � Î Ô E Õ2Õ � � [�36=��3)9\D�DÙ<>=�3�D�.104´ � 7C[[email protected]´ E <\7474_13B=X3 ] ´�.Y0Z5436_Y.13�c>36D � 9\=XD7C[�3�0 F 027C3 W .10Z�t3B_1_ E 9;_h9\= ] 36D �s [X3�_h9\52p>36087 ] < W�W 9\=XD9\5254.Yc;9\_�5C9;743�9;7Z�y[X. ] [7C[�3�0 F 027C3 W 0 U fXfi<>587C0�9\=Ù9}c\36549\p>3�l U 365 F543B04fi<>=X023)7C. W 3 U =XD�365 z�Å 043 ] <>=�DX0%.1= ] 54369\043B0 E�Fz}Å>Ŧq � � [X36=���3{9;DXD�<>=X3 r ? R .1=�74<7C[�.10k�t3B_1_ ½ E 9\_19\= ] 3BD�0 F 027C3 W�� 7C[X3©f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�a U 5274[X365�. W fX54<}c>3B0 �¢E U 7q7C[X3©. W fX54<}c>3 W 3B=�7.10Z5236_19;7C.¾c>36_ F 0 W 9\_Y_ � s [X3�_19\54p\36027�9;5454.¾c;9\_t549;7C3�9;7Z�y[X. ] [Ù74[X3@0 F 02743 W 0 U f�f¸<>587C0�9"l U 365 F543B04fi<>=X023�74. W 3 U =XDX3B5 z}Å 043 ] <>=XD�0¶.1= ] 54369\043B0 E�F"Ä#q � J a���3�9\DXD»7É�t< W <>543ZDX.Y04´�0k.1=X087C369\D<\aº9;DXDX.1=�p©<>=�3 r ? R � an<>5 W .Y=Xp�9©0 F 087C3 W �y.Y74[ z r ? R 9\=XD�Ë«DX.Y04´�0 � 7C[�3�0 F 087C3 WèE 3 ] < W 3B0r ? R E < U =XD@D U 3�7C<�9\DXD�.Y7C.Y<>=g9\_i<}c>3B54[X369\DX0y7C<�9 ]6] 36020�369 ] [�D�.104´ � s [X3qfi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3 U 04.Y=XpË�DX.102´V0�.10m��<>54023�7C[X9\= Ä DX.102´�0 � �y[X. ] [�.1=XDX. ] 9;74360�9\DXDX.Y=Xp�DX.102´V0 ] 9;=)DX3Bp>5C9\D�3�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�y[X3B=«7C[X3�[g9\52D��o9;543 ] < W f¸<>=�36=�7C0t9\543K=X<\7¹�t3B_1_ E 9\_19\= ] 3BD � � [X3B=«��3�9\DXD©<>=X3 W <>523 r ? R �7C[�3�0 F 087C3 W .10m��36_Y_ E 9\_h9\= ] 36D)9\p�9\.Y= � 7C[�3¶fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3ka U 587C[X3B5�. W fX52<}c>360 �y� F ] < W fg9\52.1=Xp7É��<���36_1_ E 9\_h9\= ] 36D ] 9\02360 �oW <\543%[g9\52D��t9\543 ] < W f¸<\=X36=�7C0�p>523�9;74_ F . W f�54<}c>3B0�74[X3�0 F 02743 W �w <>5/3ÚµX9 W fX_Y3 � an<\5�9'Ë O ��] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � 7C[�3Z0 F 02743 W �y.¾7C[ z r ? R 9\=XD Ä DX.102´�0q0 U fXfi<>52740 Ì

z}Å �

Page 124: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

] < W©W 9\=XDX0Kfi365�023 ] <>=XD{�y.Y74[»9\=»9�c\365C9;p>3¶l U 3B5 F 523602f¸<>=�043¶74. W 3 U =XDX365 z}Å 023 ] <\=XDX0 � �y[�.1_137C[�3q0 F 027C3 W �y.Y7C[ Ä r ? R 0�9\=XD�Ë�DX.102´V0y0 U fXfi<>52740 zÂÄ ] < W©W 9\=XD�0mf¸3B5m043 ] <>=XD �s [X3�9 E <}c>3Z< E 043658c;9;7C.Y<>=X0�0 U p>p>3B027�74[g9;7k9\D�DX.1=Xp«[g9\54D^�o9\523 ] < W fi<>=X36=�740/. W fX54<}c\360/0 F 087C3 Wfi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3»<\=X_ F an<>5@9��t3B_1_ ½ E 9\_19\= ] 3BD�0 F 02743 W � J a���3�D�<³=�<\7@fg9 F 9;747436=�7C.Y<>=�7C<7C[�3[g9\52D��t9\543 E 9\_19\= ] .1=Xp�9 ] 7 � ��3 ] 9\=�DX3Bp>5C9;DX3m0 F 02743 W fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3m9\_Y74[X< U p\[��t3y.1=�c\36027 W <>543[g9\52D��t9\543 �+�0¢.1=q7C[X3 ] 9\023o<\aX74[X3t= U W�E 365¢<\ag7C[�543�9;DX0 � 74[X3t52.1p>[�7¢5C9;74.1<K<\aX74[X3t= U W�E 365¢<\a r ? R 0A9;=XD¶7C[�3= U W�E 365e<;a�DX.102´V0®.10®0 F 027C3 W DX3Bf¸3B=XDX3B=�7 � �y[X. ] [Z.Y0e9;ظ3 ] 7C36D E�F 9\= F ] [X9\=Xp>3o<;ag7C[X3 ] < W�W 9\=�DW .¾µV7 U 523¶549;7C.Y< � 74[X3 JLu 0 F 027C3 W .Y74043B_Ya � 9;=XD{7C[X3 U =XDX3B54_ F .Y=Xp%[g9\52D��o9;543ZfX_19;74an<>5 W � +�020 U W 3��3��o9\=�7�f U 7k9NJ O �!] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�<>=»9'DX.Y04´ � ��3 W 9 F 36087C. W 9;743�74[X3�5C9�7C.1< ø ÷ ÿ�� Í ø ó ��ýj��9;0an<>_Y_1<}�y0 �

z � u U =�9 E 9;7 ] [�<;a¸049 W fX_13 JLu ] < W�W 9\=XDX0A9;p�9\.1=�027A9J O ��] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�<>=�9/02.1=Xp\_13oDX.Y04´U 02.1=Xp�9�02.1=Xp\_13 r ? R 9\=�D'9k04.1=�p>_13m7C[�543�9;D � 9;=XD ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7A74[X3�74<\7:9;_ r ? R 7C. W 3K9\=�D©7C[�374<\7:9\_SDX.Y04´%7C. W 3�an<>5�9\_Y_bl U 3B5 F ] < W�W 9\=XDX0 Ô '�Ì ÷ ÿ���9;=XDÐ'�Ì ó ��ýj� Õ � 9;=XD)7C[�3�7C<;7:9\_ r ? R74. W 3�9;=XD�74[X3q74<\7:9;_bD�.104´'74. W 3�an<>5K9\_1_`0 U W©W 9\5 F 9\=XD)D�< ]BU W 3B=�7 ] < W©W 9\=XDX0 Ô ' æ ÷ ÿ��9\=�DÑ' æ,ó ��ýj� Õ {

Ä � r <>_Y_13 ] 7/74[X3Z7C. W 3�<}c>3B54[X369\D Ô ' ù � Õ an<\5�DX.102fg9;7 ] [�.1=Xp@9\=�D W 3652p>.1=Xp%52360 U _Y740kan<\5�l U 365 F9\=�D»0 U W�W 9;5 F ] < W�W 9\=XDX0K�y[X36= U 02.1=Xp«7É��<@DX.102´�0 � 369 ] ["<\aA�y[X. ] ["087C<>52360�9OJ O �] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= �

Ç � ÃA0274. W 9;7C3 ø ÷ ÿP� Í ø ó ��ý_� U 04.Y=Xpø ÷ ÿ��ø ó ��ýj� � ø ó ��ýj�}��'�Ì ÷ ÿP� " ' æ ÷ ÿ�� " Ô ø ó ��ýj� � z Õ �m' ù �ø ó ��ýj�}�m'�Ì ó ��ýj� " ' æ,ó ��ý_� �

H 3B543��t3'p\.Yc>3©9\=�3�µ�9 W fX_13�[X<}�Ê7C< U 043©74[X3'9 E <}c>3�an<>5 W U _h9%7C<�360274. W 9;7C3�7C[�3«= U W�E 365q<\ar ? R 0º�y[X36=���3Kf�_h9\=Z7C<kDX.Y027454. E U 7C3m9�Ë O �] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�<}c>365¹ËkDX.102´�0 � w 54< W < U 5A02. W U _h9;74.1<>=543B0 U _¾7C0man<>5 U 02.1=Xp z r ? R 9;=XD z 74[X54369\D�an<\5 z O � Dg9;7C9�<>= z DX.Y04´ � �t3 ] <\_1_13 ] 7436D �

z}Å>Ì

Page 125: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

'�Ì ÷ ÿ���� z}| � | 043 ] <>=�DX0'�Ì ó ��ý_�;� Æ ËY� Ä 043 ] <>=�DX0' æ ÷ ÿ���� Ç�Î � Ì 043 ] <>=�DX0' æ,ó ��ýj�[� z>z}Î � Ì 023 ] <\=XDX0

w 54< W < U 5º04. W U _19;7C.Y<>=�543B0 U _¾7C0Aan<>5 U 02.1=Xp z r ? R 9\=XD z 7C[X523�9\D�an<>5 Ä O � Dg9;7C9q<}c\365 Ä D�.104´�0 ���3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7436D�' ù �q74< E 3 z}Æ � Ä 043 ] <>=XD�0 �� 3A0 U E 087C.¾7 U 7436Dk7C[X3B043Ac;9\_ U 3®.1=/7C[�3ean<>5 W U _h9 � ��3º< E 7C9\.1=X3BD ø ÷ ÿ��6�Ë ) ÷RQ+��û�S û���©ÿ�S ù� å ÷ s � è Q+��ú�S �÷RQ�ú�÷�S ����V��ÿ�S ù T� Ä �s [X3B543Ban<\543 � ��3{=X3B36D Ä r ? R 0'an<\5©[g9;=XDX_1.Y=Xp�74[X3)Ë O � ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=Ù<}c>3B5'Ë�D�.104´�0 � �y[�. ] [W 9;7 ] [X3B0y< U 5mjg=XDX.Y=Xp�.1= w .Yp U 543 Æ � Î �

óba i ýÂà�Þ�g ò a ß ü ú à i d j nà i ü ò d�a g ò ü às [X.Y0©023 ] 74.1<>=³3�µ�9 W .1=�360�[X<}� 7C< E 9\_19\= ] 3@[g9;54D��t9\543 ] < W fi<>=X36=�740«9\0Z74[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=³02. ¿ 3.1= ] 54369\043B0 � � [X36=�74[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=³04. ¿ 3�.1= ] 543�9;04360 � �t3 W 9 F ] <>fi3)�y.¾7C[Ù74[X.10�fX52< E _13 W E�F36.¾7C[X3B5 E U F .Y=Xp W <\543¶D�.104´�0��y[�36543�369 ] [»DX.102´)[X<\_1DX0K7C[X3Z049 W 3¶9 W < U =�7�<\aºDg9�7:9%9\0 E 3Ban<\543 �<>5m5236fX_19 ] .Y=XpZ7C[X3 ]6U 54543B=�7�D�.104´�0m�y.Y74[�_19\54p\365o<>=�360m�y[X36523�369 ] [)D�.104´©[X<>_YDX0 W <>523�Dg9;7C9 �w .Yp U 543 Æ � Æ .Y_1_ U 02745C9;74360e7C[�3/9�c>3B5C9\p>3�l U 365 F 523604fi<>=X023�74. W 3�9;=XD«7C[�3�523604< U 5 ] 3 U 7C.Y_1. ¿ 9;74.1<>=¶an<\59\DXD�.1=Xp�Ë�DX.Y04´�0º9\=XD�´;3636f�.1=Xp�7C[�3m0C9 W 3m9 W < U =�7A<\aiDg9�7:9/<>=Z369 ] [©D�.104´ � 9\=�D U 04.Y=Xp/7C[X3m049 W 3= U W�E 365�<\amDX.Y04´�0 E U 7¶f U 727C.1=�p�7É�y. ] 3'9\0 W UX] [�DX9;7:9)<\=�3�9 ] [�DX.102´ � �y[X36=�74[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=04. ¿ 3k.1= ] 54369\043B0man54< W z�Æ O � 7C< Ç�Ä O ���w 54< W W 369\0 U 52.1=Xp�< U 5�0 F 087C3 W�� ��3)´�=X<}� .Y7�7:9\´;360©3�9 ] [�D�.104´�_Y36020�74. W 3�9;=XD·369 ] [ r ? RW <>543k7C. W 3k7C<'023�9\5 ] [»7C[X3�0C9 W 3�9 W < U =�7�<\aADg9;7C9«DX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D)<Âc\365�7É�y. ] 3Z9;0 W 9\= F D�.104´�0 �E 3 ] 9 U 043'369 ] [�DX.Y04´"[g9\=XD�_1360�_13B040¶DX9;7:9 �¢E U 7�7C[X3«74<\7:9;_º74. W 3�.1= ] 543�9;04360�9\0�74[X3«= U W�E 365�<\aDX.Y04´�0y.1= ] 543�9;04360 E 3 ] 9 U 043q3�9 ] [ r ? R [X9\0 W <>523/�t<\54´ �J ='9 Ä r ? R 043B52c\365t.Y_1_ U 02745C9;7436DZ.1= w .Yp U 543 Æ � Æ Ô 9 Õ � �y[�36543 Ä r ? R 0t9\=�D«ËqDX.102´V0 ] <\=X0274.Y7 U 7C3K9��36_1_ ½ E 9;_h9\= ] 36D©043658c>3B5 � 9\DXD�.1=Xp�Ë W <\543�D�.104´�0m9;=XD%fg9\587C.Y74.1<>=�.1=Xp Ç�Ä O � <}c>3B5 Ì DX.Y04´�0 W 9\´\3B07C[�3m043658c>3B5 E 3 ] < W 3 r ? R E < U =XD � 9\=�D�74[ U 0ºf¸3B52an<>5 W 0®��<>52043m7C[g9;=©9�023652c\365 U 04.Y=Xp�7C[X3m049 W 3= U W�E 365o<;a`_h9\52p>365¹DX.Y04´�0 �XE 3 ] 9 U 023�7C[X3 r ? R 0y9\543�<}c>3658�y[X36_ W 3BD �¹� F 3�µ�9 W .1=X.Y=Xp r ? R 9;=XD

z}Å>|

Page 126: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

$ %@' ç ),+9- æ -.)A/ ��1(2,3C4 ç %7+98 ç : 2,1<; ç )0G�>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ïPâ ü ��1�ì�5kí!î ��1�ì�5kí!î ��1�ì�5kí�î �©�

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Average Arrival Rate (requests per second)

16 GB (4 GB/disk)32 GB (4 GB/disk)32 GB (8 GB/disk)

åp1�è×ç %7+98 \�

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Average Arrival Rate (requests per second)

16 GB (4 GB/disk)32 GB (4 GB/disk)32 GB (8 GB/disk)

åpï$è�ç %7+98 �÷��ú ��� �©�D����N-P7 ü ÷ îP5kâ�O�â ù îh5kâ�O3â ÷ îP5kâ�O�â�FQ4v×â ��í!âÔà�-PìÔá!í å ÷G���&U îh5kâ�OPè å ÷G���&U îP5kâ�OPè å ù ���&U îP5kâ�O�è�Qv ÿ©ûPü þ V û©úPü û V ý��Pü ú V� ßNY o�H ÿ�ý�ü ú V ÷��Pü ù V ù�÷�ü ÷ V�Qv �©ûPü � V ÿ�÷�ü ý V ÷�þPü ÿ V÷ ßNY o�H ÿ�ý�ü � V ÷�ûPü ÿ V ù©úPü û Våpá5èFAU1�ì�î�IE1�ìÔíW-:8�5kã656��1q8�5kà©ëMI�A�í!ë F �÷

õ ò ß�%SýÂà �Iÿ»�Iÿ J = ] 54369\04.Y=Xp©74[X3q= U W�E 3B5�<\a®DX.102´�0�c>3B540 U 0/.1= ] 54369\04.Y=Xp�7C[X3�Dg9;7:9�04. ¿ 3�f¸3B5�DX.Y04´9\0m7C[�3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\='04. ¿ 3k.1= ] 54369\043B0 �

z>z}Å

Page 127: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

DX.Y04´ U 74.1_Y. ¿ 9�7C.1<\=�.1= w .Yp U 543 Æ � Æ Ô ] Õ � f U 7474.1=Xp W <\543mDg9;7C9q<\=«9kDX.102´ W <Âc\360º7C[X3 E 9\_19\= ] 3Kfi<>.Y=�79)_Y.Y7474_13 E .¾7 Ô 74[X3'549;7C.Y<)<\a r ? R 9\=XD�D�.104´ U 74.1_1. ¿ 9;74.1<>= W <}c>360�an54< W z>� Å�Ä^�¾z 7C< Å � |��¾z an<>5 Är ? R 0 Õ �VE U 7�=X<\7º04.Yp>=X.¾j ] 9\=�74_ F � s [X3 E 9\_h9;= ] 3yfi<>.1=�7 W <Âc\360 E 3 ] 9 U 043y7C[X3y7C3B5 W an5236l U 36= ] F <\a9«p>.¾c>3B=)7C3B5 W .1= ] 543�9;04360/9\0�74[X3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�04. ¿ 3¶.Y= ] 523�9\02360 � 9\=XD)74[X3�74365 W 3�c\9;_ U 9;74.1<>=@7C. W 3.10y9Z_Y.1=X369\5ta U = ] 7C.Y<>=@<\a®74[X3�7C365 W an543Bl U 36= ] F Ô 523Ban365m74< T 3 ] 74.1<>= Î � z � z Õ �J =©9qË r ? R 023658c>365�.1_Y_ U 087C5C9�7C36DZ.Y= w .1p U 543 Æ � Æ Ô E Õ � �y[X36523�Ë r ? R 0�9\=XD�ËkDX.102´V0 ] <\=X0274.Y7 U 7C3K9DX.Y04´ ½ E < U =XDZ0 F 027C3 W�� 9;DXDX.1=�p�Ë W <\543oDX.Y04´�0º9\=XDZfX9\5274.Y7C.Y<>=X.Y=Xp Ç>Ä O � <}c\365 Ì DX.Y04´�0Af¸3B52an<>5 W 0E 3B7474365q7C[g9\=�9)043B52c>3B5 U 02.1=Xp)74[X3«049 W 3«= U W�E 365�<\am_h9;54p>3B5�DX.Y04´�0 �®E 3 ] 9 U 023'.Y7�543B_1.Y3Bc>3B0¶7C[�3DX.Y04´ E <\7474_13B=X3 ] ´%9;=XD W 9\´;360m7C[X3k023652c\365y�t3B_1_ ½ E 9\_19\= ] 36D �s [X3k9 E <}c>3�< E 043658c;9;7C.Y<>=X0o0 U p>p>3B027m7C[X9;7m[X<}�7C<Z[g9\=�DX_13�9\DXDX.¾7C.1<\=g9\_iDg9;7:9�.10oDX3�7C3B5 W .1=X3BD E�F7C[�3 E 9\_h9\= ] 3 E 3B7É��363B={[g9\52D��o9;543�543B04< U 5 ] 3B0 � ? U 747C.Y=Xp W <>543�Dg9�7:9�<>=@3�9 ] [�DX.Y04´'.Y0o0 U f¸3B54.1<\57C<�9\D�DX.1=Xp�DX.Y04´�0m�y[X36=�7C[X3k023652c\365K.10y9\_Y54369\D F ��36_Y_ ½ E 9\_h9\= ] 36D �

�Iÿ¦þ�ÿT� Ý/ÞXý}ü ò ü ò d�a ò a ß � àVýlgk%�g ñ à�ûF ò_i Þ�ü ò d�aJ =�74[X.10q043 ] 7C.Y<>= � ��3'3ÚµX9 W .Y=X3©[�<Â�Ó74<{fX_19 ] 3�7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= <>=�7C[�3'9�c;9\.1_19 E _13ZD�.104´�0 � � 3W 9 F 36.¾7C[X3B5�fg9\5274.Y74.1<>=)74[X3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=»<}c>3B5q9\_1_b7C[X3ZDX.Y04´�0k<>5�fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\={.Y7�<}c\365k04< W 3ZDX.Y04´�09\=XD�543BfX_1. ] 9;743/.Y7y<\=�02< W 3qD�.104´�0 � � 3k.1=�c>3B0274.1p�9;743 E <;7C[@a U _1_`9;=XD@fg9\5274.h9\_Ö5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>= �

Ý/ÞXý}ü ò ü ò d�a ò a ß � à�ýlgk%�g õ %� j ñ à�ûF òji Þ^ü ò d�aw <>5k9 U =X_Y<�9\DX3BD 0 F 027C3 W�� fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xp©<}c>365q9\D�DX.Y74.1<>=g9;_®DX.Y04´�0k5436D UX] 3B0q74[X3 ] < W�W 9;=XD»543 ½04fi<>=X023)7C. W 3 �oE 3 ] 9 U 043»9 ] < W�W 9;=XDÙ.Y0«fX52< ] 36020436D9\p>9\.1=X087�7C[X3{D�.104´�0��y.Y7C[·_136020«Dg9�7:9�.Y=fg9\549\_1_Y36_ � �y[�.1_13{a U _1_/5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=�DX<^3B0@=X<\7 ��E 3 ] 9 U 043�369 ] [DX.102´�0274.1_1_�[g9\=XDX_Y360%7C[�3 049 W 39 W < U =�7©<\a�Dg9;7C9 � w <>5©9�_1<>9\DX36DÙ0 F 02743 W��mE�F U 04.1=�p�a U _Y_K5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= � 3�9 ] [�023B7«<\a�DX.Y04´�0[g9\=�DX_13B0/[g9\_¾aA7C[X3¶��<>52´V_Y<�9\D � 9\=XD{7C[ U 0�5236D U�] 360�74[X3 ] < W©W 9\=XD{523602f¸<>=�043�7C. W 3�D U 3�74<'543 ½D UX] .1=Xp©7C[X3¶�t9\.¾7C.1=�p©7C. W 3kan<>5K7C[X3�D�.104´@023652cV. ] 3 �k� F fg9;527C.¾7C.Y<>=X.1=�p«9 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�<}c>3B5/7É�y. ] 39\0 W 9;= F D�.104´�0 � 369 ] [)DX.Y04´%[g9;=XDX_13B0�[X9\_Ya®<\a®74[X3�DX9;7:9 ��E U 7�.¾7�[X9\=XDX_Y360 W <>523�7C[g9\=�[g9\_¾a®7C[�3_1<>9\D �XE 3 ] 9 U 043�.Y7y=X3B36DX0K7C<©9 ]6] 36020�3�9 ] [)DX.Y04´'7C<�fX52< ] 36020/9�l U 365 F ] < W©W 9\=XD � J =)9\DXDX.¾7C.Y<>= �04369\5 ] [�.1=Xp»[g9;_Yam<\at7C[X3'DX9;7:9�7C9\´\3B0 W <>543�7C[g9\=�[g9\_Yat7C[X3«74. W 3«9;=XD�04369\5 ] [�.1=Xp W <>543�DX.Y04´�0

z>z>z

Page 128: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

=X3B36DX0 W <>523 ] <^<>52DX.1=X9;7C.Y<>=Z7C. W 3 � s [X36523Ban<>523 � a U _1_�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=�0 U fXf¸<\527C0t9¶_h9;54p>3B5 ] < W�W 9\=�D9\5254.Yc;9\_�549;7C3 U =XDX3B5y9¶p>.Yc\36='l U 3B5 F 543602f¸<\=X043/74. W 3K74[g9\=%fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xp�an<>5t9¶_1<>9\DX36D«0 F 02743 W �+�0'9\=�3�µ�9 W fX_Y3 � ��3{DX3 W <>=X087C549;7C3)74[X3)fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3)<\ak023�9\5 ] [X.1=�p9 z}Æ O � ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=U 02.1=Xp©fg9\5274.Y74.1<>=X.Y=Xp�9\=XD)a U _1_S543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= � � 3�9;040 U W 3¶��3¶[X9}c\3 Ì DX.Y04´�0 � �t3 ] < W fg9\523�7C[�3fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3�<\aSfg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xpk7C[�3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=©<Âc\365 Ì D�.104´�0m9;=XD E U .Y_1DX.Y=Xp�7É��< ] <\fX.13B0o<\a`7C[�3] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � 3�9 ] [�<\ab�y[X. ] [ U 02360KË©DX.Y04´�0 � .Y_1_ U 02745C9;7436D%.1= w .1p U 523 Æ ���^�J = w .1p U 543 Æ ��� Ô 9 Õ 9\=XD Ô E Õ � fg9\587C.Y74.1<>=�.1=Xp�<Âc\365 Ì DX.102´�0bfi3658an<>5 W 0Ö��<>54023¹74[g9\=kËyDX.102´�0 ��E 3 ] 9 U 0237C[�3Z9\DXDX.¾7C.Y<>=g9\_S<}c>3B54[X369\DX0k<}c>3658�y[X36_ W 74[X3 r ? R Ô 0 Õ 04<V<>=X3B5 � J = w .Yp U 523 Æ ��� Ô 9 Õ �y[X3B543�7C[�3r ? R .Y0b9 E <\7474_13B=X3 ] ´�an<\5bËKDX.Y04´�0 � a U _1_�5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=�DX<V360S=X<\7bDX3Bp>5C9\D�3�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 ��E 3 ] 9 U 0237C[�3�0 F 087C3 W 087C.1_Y_�04369\5 ] [X3B0eË�D�.104´�0®9;7¢9K7C. W 3 � 9;=XD�74[ U 0®DX<V360b=X<\7¢f¸<\043o9;DXDX.Y74.1<>=X9\_><}c>3B54[X369\DX0<>={74[X3 r ? R � H <}�t3�c>365 � .¾7�D�<^3B0�=X<\7�. W fX52<}c>3¶fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�36.¾7C[X3B5 �IE 3 ] 9 U 023�7C[X3 r ? R .Y09\_Y543�9;D F <}c>3B5 U 74.1_Y. ¿ 3BD�9\=XD%7C[X3B543k.10m=�<�52<^< W an<>5oa U 587C[X3B5m. W fX54<}c\3 W 36=�7 � J = w .1p U 543 Æ � � Ô E Õ ��y[X3B543 Ä r ? R 0º9\=XD�Ë�DX.Y04´�0 ] <\=X0274.Y7 U 7C3y9���36_1_ E 9\_19\= ] 3BD�0 F 02743 W�� a U _1_^5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>=¶. W f�54<}c>3B0fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3 �;E�F 02[X<>527436=X.Y=Xpy7C[X3A�t9\.Y74.1=Xpm7C. W 3ean<\5I7C[X3¹DX.102´/043B52cV. ] 3t9;=XDqa U 527C[�365b.1= ] 543�9;04.1=�pE <\7C[ r ? R 9;=XD©D�.104´ U 7C.1_Y. ¿ 9;7C.Y<>=X0 Ô 043B3 w .1p U 523 Æ ��� Ô D Õ � H <}��3Bc\365�74[X3K[X.1p>[ r ? R U 7C.Y_1. ¿ 9;74.1<>=_1. W .¾7C0�.Y7C0oa U 527C[�365m. W fX52<Âc\3 W 36=�7 �J = w .Yp U 543 Æ ��� Ô ] Õ �y[X36523mË r ? R 0º9\=XDZË�D�.104´�0 ] <>=X087C.Y7 U 7C3o9/0 F 02743 W �y.¾7C[Z9/DX.Y04´ E <;747C_Y36=X3 ] ´ �9\=XD³Ë r ? R 0'9\=�D Ì DX.102´�0 ] <>=X0274.Y7 U 7C3�9»�t3B_1_ E 9\_19\= ] 36D·0 F 027C3 W���E <;7C[³fg9\5274.Y74.1<>=X.Y=Xp{7C[�3] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�<}c>3B5 Ì DX.102´V0t9\=XD�a U _1_g5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=�02.1p>=�.Yj ] 9\=�7C_ F . W fX54<}c\360¹0 F 02743 W f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 �E 3 ] 9 U 043{74[X3»DX.102´ E <\727C_13B=X3 ] ´Ù.10©5436_Y.13�c>36D � H <Â��3Bc\365%a U _Y_�5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=·fi3652an<\5 W 0 E 3B7474365 �E 3 ] 9 U 043©3�9 ] [�DX.102´»9\=XD r ? R [g9\=�DX_13B0q_Y36020q��<>54´�_Y<�9\DX0�7C[X9\=�fg9;527C.¾7C.Y<>=X.1=�p � J =�74[X.10 ] 9\043 �E 3 ] 9 U 043�7C[�3q0 F 027C3 W .10o��36_Y_ ½ E 9\_h9\= ] 36D � a U _Y_Ö543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>='9 ] [X.13�c>3B0�.¾7m_h9\52p>36087m. W fX52<Âc\3 W 36=�7 �9\=XD"0 U fXfi<>52740k7É�y. ] 3�9\0 W 9\= F ] < W�W 9\=�DX0/�y.Y74["9\= 9}c\36549\p>3�l U 365 F 543B04fi<>=X043�7C. W 3 E 3B_1<}�z}Å 043 ] <>=XDX0 ] < W fg9\5236D��y.¾7C[�fg9\5274.Y74.1<>=X.Y=XpZ<}c>3B5�Ë«D�.104´�0 Ô an54< W �^� Ç ] < W�W 9\=XDX0yfi365�023 ] <>=XD7C< z Ë � Î ] < W©W 9\=XDX0mfi365y023 ] <\=XD Õ �s [X3y9 E <}c>3m52360 U _Y7C0 ] <>=�jX5 W 74[g9;7ea U _1_V5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>=q0 U fXfi<>587C0º9/_h9;54p>3B5 ] < W©W 9\=XD¶9\5452.Yc;9\_V5C9;743U =XD�365�9qp>.¾c>3B= ]BU 7C<\Ø%an<\5¹523602f¸<>=�043y7C. W 3o7C[X9\=©fX9\5274.Y7C.Y<>=X.Y=Xp�7C[�3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=Z<}c\365�9\DXDX.¾7C.1<\=g9\_

z>zÂÄ

Page 129: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

$&%(' ç*),+#- æ -.)A/ ��1(2,3C4 ç6%7+98 ç*: 2,1<; ç )AG�>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ï�â ü ��ú ��� ��1�ì�5kí�î ��1�ì�5kí!î �©�

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20A

vera

ge Q

uery

Res

pons

e T

ime

(Sec

onds

)

Average Arrival Rate (requests per second)

4 disks -- Partitioning8 disks -- Partitioning8 disks -- Replication

åp1�è×ç6%7+98 n�

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Average Arrival Rate (requests per second)

4 disks -- Partition8 disks -- Partition

8 disks -- Replication

åpï$è�ç6%7+98 \�

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Average Arrival Rate (requests per second)

4 disks -- Partitioning8 disks -- Partitioning8 disks -- Replication

åMáè�ç %�+>8 �÷�N-P7 ü êU1�ìB8 ü êU1�ìB8 ü r}-�ãkã�FQ4v×â ��í!â�à�-�ìÔá!í ÷ îP5kâ�O3â ù îP5kâ�O3â ìÔí!ê�ã ü�Q4v û©ûPü � V û©ûPü ù V û©ûPü ÷ V� ßNY o�H ÷�ùPü¨� V �©þPü ÷ V ��÷�ü ý V�Q4v ù©ÿPü � V û©ùPü ÿ V û�ý�ü û V� ßNY o�H ù�÷�ü¨� V ÷�þPü � V ÷�ùPü ÷ V�Q4v ÷�úPü û V ù�÷�ü þ V ý�þPü � V÷ ßNY o�H û©þPü ú V ý+�©ü � V ú©ùPü ù Våpî$èAU1�ìÔîEIE1�ìÔíW-h8�5kã656��1q8�5kà©ëVI�A�í!ë F n��þõ ò ß�%býÂà �Iÿ ¸ÿ ?®9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xp�c>36520 U 0Ka U _1_Ö5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>=«an<>5y9 z}Æ O �] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= �

z>z}Ç

Page 130: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

DX.Y04´�0�an<\5©9"_1<>9\DX36D³0 F 087C3 W � H <Â��3Bc\365 � ��3�DX< U 023�fX9\5274.Y7C.Y<>=X.Y=Xp».1=X087C369\DÙ<;a/543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=7C<«´\363Bf»7C[X3�543602f¸<\=X043�74. W 3 E 36_Y<}�-9«p>.Yc\36= ]BU 7C<;Ø � �y[X36= U 0236540�7 F f�. ] 9;_1_ F .Y040 U 3¶c>3B5 F _1<>=�pl U 3652.13B0 � <>5K�y[X36="369 ] ["DX.102´�[�<>_1DX0/9«_h9\52p>3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � w <>5�3�µ�9 W fX_13 � < U 5 W 3�9\0 U 543 W 3B=�74004[�<Â�!7C[g9;7y.¾7m7:9\´;360 Ä � Î^�`z � Ë � 9\=XD Å � Ì 043 ] <>=XDX0K7C<�fX52< ] 36040�9�l U 365 F �y.¾7C[ Ä 7C365 W 0m<\=)9 z}Æ��Ì�� 9\=XD�Ë O ��] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=@<>={9�04.Y=Xp>_13kDX.Y04´ � J a¢�t3�3�µ^f¸3 ] 7�< U 5K043658c>3B5�fX52<^D U�] 360�9©523604fi<>=X0237C. W 3 E 36_1<}� z 023 ] <\=XD'an<>5o9 z�Æ O �Ù] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � �t3�=X363BD@74<�fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=©.¾7o<}c>3B5oË�DX.Y04´�0 � 369 ] [<\ab�y[X. ] [�[X<>_YDX0mË O � <\a¢Dg9;7C9 �

Ý/ÞXý}ü ò ü ò d�a ò a ß � à�ýlgk%�g�Ý/Þ�ýÂü ò Þ� ñ à�û! ò_i Þ�ü ò d�aJ =¶74[X3 ] 9\043�<\aXa U _Y_V5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= � �t3 W 9 F 3�c>36=�_ F DX.1087C54. E U 743¹74[X3���<>54´�_Y<�9\DX0¢<Âc\365ba U _1_�543BfX_1. ] 9\09\=XDk7C[ U 0S. W fX52<}c>3º0 F 02743 W fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 � H <}�t3�c>3B5 � .Y=k74[X3 ] 9\023º<\a�fX9\5274.h9\_>5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= � [X<}�W UX] [�fg9\5274.h9\_A5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=". W fX54<}c>3B0�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3©D�36fi36=XDX0¶<>=�74[X3©D�.102745C9 ] 7C.Y=Xp�fi365 ] 3B=�7 ½9\p>3 � . � 3 � � [X<}� W 9;= F ] < W�W 9\=�DX0kfg9\5274.h9\_A5236fX_Y. ] 9\0k0C9;74.102a F � ?®9\587C.19\_º5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>="f¸3B52an<>5 W 0E 3B7474365¶74[g9\=�fg9;527C.¾7C.Y<>=X.1=�p�<\=X_ F �y[X3B=74[X3'5236fX_Y. ] 9;0¶DX.Y027C549 ] 7 Ô 049;7C.Y02a F Õ 9 ] 36527C9\.1=�= U W¶E 3B5<\a ] < W�W 9\=�DX0 � +�040 U W 3�fg9\5274.Y74.1<>=X.Y=Xp�7C[�3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=@<}c>3B5 ø ó ��ý_� ù � �XW�DX.102´�0�0 U fXf¸<\527C0 ä ù � �0W] < W©W 9\=XDX0qfi365¶023 ] <>=XD��y.Y74[�9\=�9}c\36549\p>3«l U 3B5 F 543602f¸<\=X043«74. W 3 U =XDX3B5¶04< W 3 ]6U 74<\Ø�9;=XDfg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xp�74[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�<}c>3B5m9\DXDX.¾7C.Y<>=g9\_ ø ó ��ýj� � ò5Y DX.Y04´�0 Ô ø ó ��ýj� ù � �0W " ø ó ��ýj� � ò5Y .1=�7C< ½7:9;_ Õ 0 U fXf¸<\527C0 ä � ò5Y ] < W�W 9;=XDX0yf¸3B5�023 ] <>=XD��y.¾7C[@7C[X3q0C9 W 3q9�c>3B5C9\p>3q543B04fi<>=X023�7C. W 3 � 7C[�36=E U .Y_1DX.Y=Xp�fg9\5274.h9\_¹543BfX_1. ] 9\0 U 02.1=Xp»9;DXDX.Y74.1<>=X9\_ ø ó ��ýj� � ò5Y DX.Y04´�0�9 ] [X.Y3Bc\360�7C[�3'0C9 W 3'9�c\365C9;p>3543B04fi<>=X023k74. W 3/9\0tfg9\5274.Y74.1<>=X.Y=Xp��y[�36=%7C[X3�5236fX_Y. ] 9\0tDX.Y02745C9 ] 7m_13B040o7C[X9\= FPZ 4([ s F�\C] 2_^FPZ 4@[ � z�Å>Ŧq <\a] < W©W 9\=XDX0 � .Ya FPZ 4@[ s F�\C] 2,^F Z 4([ � z}Å>Ŧq <\a ] < W�W 9;=XDX0mDX<�=X<\7K<}c>3B54_Y<�9\D%7C[X3k5236fX_Y. ] 9;0 �+�0t9\=«3Úµ�9 W f�_13 � ��3/fX5236043B=�7m9�023B7t<\a`3�µ^fi3652. W 36=�7C0¹7C< ] < W fg9\543m74[X3�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�<\aIfg9\5274. ½7C.Y<>=X.Y=Xp¶9;=XD«fg9;527C.19\_g543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=�an<>5�9 z}Æ O �³] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � � 3�9\040 U W 3�3�9 ] [«DX.102´ ] 9\='087C<>5239;7 W <>087AË O � <;a�Dg9;7:9 � 9\=XD�7C[ U 0e��3y=X363BD�Ë�DX.102´V0e74<�0274<>543o74[X3 z}Æ O ��] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � �y[X. ] [Z.Y0< U 5 E 9\0236_1.Y=X3 � � [X36='��3/[g9�c>3/9\=%9\DXD�.Y7C.Y<>=g9\_gD�.104´ � �t3 W 9 F 0274<>543K7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= E�F 36.¾7C[X3B5fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xp�7C[�3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=)<}c\365 Î DX.Y04´�0 � <\5 E U .Y_1DX.Y=Xp'9©fg9\5274.h9\_b543BfX_1. ] 9�<>={7C[X3 Î 7C[»DX.Y04´�y[X. ] [ ] <>=�7:9;.1=X0 Ä>Î#q <\am7C[X3©<>54.Yp>.1=X9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � J ayl U 365 F _1< ] 9\_Y.Y7 F .Y0¶[X.Yp>[ � 7C[X3'5236fX_Y. ] 9

z>z Ë

Page 131: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

043B_13 ] 7C<\5 W 9 F 043B=XD W <\543Kl U 3654.Y360o74<¶7C[X3�5436f�_1. ] 9q74[g9\=«74[X3/<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � �y[X. ] [ W 9 F543B0 U _¾7�.1=�_Y<�9\D�. W�E 9\_19\= ] 3 � � 3 E 9\_h9\= ] 3'7C[�3%_1<�9\D�0 U 04.Y=Xp{7C[�3 W 3�7C[X<VD��t3%D�360 ] 54. E 3BDÙ.Y=T 3 ] 7C.Y<>=@Ë � Ë �w .Yp U 543 Æ � Ì fX5236043B=�7C0�74[X3K9�c>36549\p>3Kl U 365 F 543602f¸<\=X043K7C. W 3tc\36540 U 0�74[X3yDX.1087C549 ] 74.1=Xpkfi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3�y[X3B= ] < W�W 9\=�DX0/9\5254.¾c>3�9�7 z}Å fi365�043 ] <>=XD 9\0K�t3B_1_e9;0�7C[X3�9}c\36549\p>3�l U 3B5 F 523602f¸<>=�043�7C. W 3c>3B540 U 0�7C[�3 ] < W©W 9\=XD�9\5254.Yc;9\_Ö5C9;743qan<>5yfg9;527C.¾7C.Y<>=X.1=�pZ<Âc\365�Ë©<>5 Î DX.102´V0 � J = w .Yp U 523 Æ � Ì Ô D Õ �7C[�3'54<}�y0Z<\aoR4, J T � S{_Y.1087�74[X3@9�c>36549\p>3%DX.Y04´ U 7C.Y_1. ¿ 9;74.1<>="<}c>3B5�9\_1_¹DX.102´�0�an<>5¶fg9;527C.¾7C.Y<>=X.1=�p �9\=XD�9�c>3B5C9\p>3 U 74.1_1. ¿ 9;74.1<>=�<}c>365k7C[�3©DX.Y04´�0�7C[g9�7�087C<>523�74[X3�<>54.Yp>.1=X9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�{I7C[X3�54<}�y0k<\aR4, J T � Ô 5236fX_ Õ S�_1.Y027o74[X3 U 7C.Y_1. ¿ 9;7C.Y<>=«<;a¢74[X3kDX.102´«7C[g9�7y027C<\54360y7C[�3qfX9\5274.h9\_¸5436f�_1. ] 9 �J = w .Yp U 543 Æ � Ì Ô 9 Õ � �y[�36543t<>=X3 r ? R .Y0®9 E <\727C_13B=X3 ] ´kan<>5¢Ë/DX.102´�0 � fg9;527C.¾7C.Y<>=X.1=�py74[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=<}c>3B5 Î D�.104´�0Z.Y0Z9 ] 7 U 9\_Y_ F �t<>52043'74[g9\=fg9\587C.Y74.1<>=�.1=Xp�.Y7�<}c\365�Ë»DX.102´�0 �¹E 3 ] 9 U 023�9\DXDX.¾7C.1<\=g9\_r ? R <}c\3654[�3�9\DX0�D U 3m7C<q04369\5 ] [�.1=Xp W <\543mDX.Y04´�0�3Úµ�9 ] 3B5 E 9;743K74[X3 r ? R E <\7474_13B=X3 ] ´ � J 7¹.10A=X<;70 U 54fX52.104.Y=Xp¶74[g9;7ofX9\5274.h9\_�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=�fi3652an<\5 W 0 W UX] [ E 3B727C3B5�7C[X9\=%fg9\587C.Y74.1<>=�.1=Xpq9;7o9\_1_�Dg9;7C9fi<>.1=�7C0®<\a�7C[X3mDX.Y02745C9 ] 7C.1=�p/f¸3B5 ] 36=�7:9\p\3 ��E 3 ] 9 U 043y04369\5 ] [X.Y=Xp/7C[�3m5436f�_1. ] 9�<>=�04.Y=Xp>_Y3tDX.Y04´�7C9\´\3B0_13B040 r ? R 7C. W 3/7C[X9\=@043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp©Ë�<>5 Î DX.Y04´�0 � 9\=�D�74[ U 0�5236_1.Y3Bc\360m7C[X3 r ? R E <;747C_Y36=X3 ] ´ �J = w .Yp U 523 Æ � Ì Ô E Õ � �y[X36523 Ä r ? R 0/9\=XD{Ë'D�.104´�0 ] <>=X087C.¾7 U 743Z9���36_Y_ E 9;_h9\= ] 36D{0 F 027C3 W�� fg9\5 ½7C.¾7C.Y<>=X.1=�p¶7C[X3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=@<}c>3B5 Î DX.102´�0�fi3658an<>5 W 0y04_1.Yp>[�7C_ F'E 3B7474365y7C[g9;=�fg9;527C.¾7C.Y<>=X.1=�pZ<Âc\365KËDX.Y04´�0 �«� F 3�µ�9 W .1=X.Y=Xp'7C[�3©52.1p>[�7�jgp U 543 � fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xp«<Âc\365�Ë�DX.Y04´�0q9\=XD Î DX.Y04´�0q0 U fXfi<>587Î ��� 9\=XD Æ ] < W�W 9\=�DX0�fi365/023 ] <>=XD»�y.Y74[»9\="9�c>3B5C9\p>3Zl U 3B5 F 543602f¸<\=X043�74. W 3 U =�DX365 z}Å 043 ]Ú½<>=XD�0 � 543602f¸3 ] 74.Yc>3B_ F � ?®9\587C.h9;_b5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=%f¸3B52an<>5 W 0 E 3B7474365y7C[g9;=)fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=XpZ<}c\365 Î DX.Y04´�0�y[X3B={7C[X3q543BfX_1. ] 9©D�.102745C9 ] 7C0 W <\543k7C[g9\= Î#q <\a ] < W©W 9\=XD�0yan52< W 7C[X3�_13�a�7KjXp U 543 � �y[�. ] [{.Y0] <\=X04.Y027C3B=�7��y.¾7C[@< U 5oan<>5 W U _19 Ô Æ � Î � � Õ Í Æ T� Î#q �J = w .1p U 543 Æ � Ì Ô ] Õ �y[X36523�Ë r ? R 0«9\=XD³Ë D�.104´�0 ] <>=�027C.¾7 U 743�9 DX.Y04´ E < U =�DÙ0 F 087C3 W���E <\74[fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xp'74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>="<Âc\365 Î DX.Y04´�0�9;=XD�fX9\5274.h9\_A5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\= 02.1p>=�.Yj ] 9\=�7C_ F . W fX54<}c\30 F 087C3 W fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3 �mE 3 ] 9 U 043)369 ] [�DX.Y04´[g9\=XD�_1360�_13B040©_1<�9\D�0 � �y[X. ] [�543B_1.Y3Bc>3B0©74[X3)DX.Y04´E <\7474_136=�3 ] ´ � ?¢9\5274.h9\_e5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=»f¸3B52an<>5 W 0 E 3B727C3B5q74[g9\= fg9\5274.Y74.1<>=X.Y=Xp'<}c>3B5 Î DX.Y04´�0q�y[�36=7C[�3'543BfX_1. ] 9)DX.Y02745C9 ] 7C0 W <>543�7C[g9;= z}Ǧq <\a ] < W�W 9\=XDX0 �»� F 3�µ�9 W .1=X.Y=Xp�74[X3'54.Yp>[�7¶jgp U 543 �

z>zÂÎ

Page 132: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

$&%(' ç*),+#- æ -.)A/ � 1 �{þ ò ç6%7+98 ç*: 2,1<; ç )AG�>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ï�â ü ��ú ��� ��1�ì�5kí�î ��1�ì�5kí!î �©�

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

0 20 40 60 80 100

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Distracting Percentage (%)

Partitioning (4 disks)Partitioning (5 disks)

Replication (No Load balancing)Replication (Load Balancing)

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Average Arrival Rate (requests per second)

Partitioning (4 disks)Partitioning (5 disks)

åp1�è×ç %7+98 n�

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

0 20 40 60 80 100

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Distracting Percentage (%)

Partitioning (4 disks)Partitioning (5 disks)

Replication (No Load balancing)Replication (Load Balancing)

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Average Arrival Rate (requests per second)

Partitioning (4 disks)Partitioning (5 disks)

åpï$è�ç %7+98 \�

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

0 20 40 60 80 100

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Distracting Percentage (%)

Partitioning (4 disks)Partitioning (5 disks)

Replication (No Load balancing)Replication (Load Balancing)

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Average Arrival Rate (requests per second)

Partitioning (4 disks)Partitioning (5 disks)

åMáè�ç*%�+>8 �÷��-P7 ü êU1�ì�8�5 8�5kà©ëP5kë�ä êP1�ì�8�5�1�ã�ìÔí!ê�ã65ká�1q8�5kà©ë�Q4v×â � í!âÔà�-�ì�á!í ÷ îP5kâ�O3â ÿ îP5kâ�O3â ë�àWãkà�1�îJïU1�ã ü I�5 8�AFãkà�1�î{ïU1�ã ü�Qv û©ûPü � V û©ûPü ÿ V û©ûPü þ V û©ûPü ÷ V� ßJY oEH ÷�ùPü¨� V �©úPü þ V �©ÿPü ú V �©ùPü � VßNY o�H åMì�í!ê�ãZè ý�ùPü ÿ V ÿ��Pü � V�Qv ù©ÿPü � V û©ÿPü¨� V ù��©ü þ V ù©ùPü û V� ßJY oEH ù�÷�ü¨� V ú©ùPü ý V ú�÷�ü ÷ V ý�þPü ù VßNY o�H åMì�í!ê�ãZè û�ý�ü þ V ù©ÿPü¨� V�Qv ÷�úPü û V ú©�Pü ú V ÷�þPü þ V ÷�ùPü þ V÷ ßJY oEH û©þPü ú V ù©ûPü ÿ V ÿ©þPü¨� V ý+�©ü ÿ VßNY o�H åMì�í!ê�ãZè û©ûPü � V ù©úPü ú VåMî$èAU1�ì�î�IE1�ì�íW-h8�5kã656��1q8�5kà©ëMI�A�í!ëa` : 2B1 ) \ÿ©þ Võ ò ß�%býÂà �`ÿT�Iÿ ?¢9\5274.Y7C.Y<>=X.Y=Xp¶c>3B540 U 0�fg9;527C.19\_Ö5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>='an<>5y9 z}Æ O ��] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= �

z>z}Æ

Page 133: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=XpZ<}c\365/Ë©DX.102´V0�0 U f�f¸<>587C0 �^� Å ] < W�W 9\=XDX0Kf¸3B5�023 ] <\=XDX0��y.¾7C[{9;={9�c>3B5C9\p>3¶l U 365 F543B04fi<>=X023)7C. W 3 U =XDX3B5 z}Å 023 ] <>=XDX0 � 9\=�D�fg9\587C.Y74.1<>=�.1=Xp Î D�.104´�0'0 U fXfi<>52740 Ì � Ë ] < W©W 9\=XDX0fi365«023 ] <>=XD � ?®9\587C.h9;_K5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=04[X< U _1D�9 ] [�.13Bc\3�74[X3)049 W 3)9�c>36549\p>3�543602f¸<\=X043)74. W 3)9;0fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xp@<}c>3B5 Î DX.Y04´�0¶�y[X3B=�7C[X3'5236fX_Y. ] 9�DX.Y027C549 ] 740¶_Y36040�7C[g9\= Ô Ì � Ë � � � Å Õ Í Ì � Ë T� z � q%��y[X. ] [�.Y0 ] <>=X02.1087C36=�7K�y.Y74[�< U 5ojg=XDX.Y=Xp�.1='7C[�3q_Y3Ba�7mjgp U 543 �� F 3�µ�9 W .1=X.Y=Xp w .Yp U 523 Æ � Ì�� ��3y9\_102</jg=XD�7C[X9;7e7C[�3m. W fX54<}c>3 W 3B=�7AD U 3o74<�fg9\5274.h9\_V543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=.1= ] 54369\043B0®9;0S74[X3º543BfX_1. ] 9oDX.Y027C549 ] 740S.1= ] 543�9;04.1=�p>_ F�W 9\= F ] < W�W 9;=XDX0 U =�7C.Y_>7C[X3º5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36DkDX.Y04´_1<>9\D)p>3�7C0/74<^<©[X.1p>[ � +o7/7C[g9�7/fi<>.1=�7 � _1<�9;D E 9\_19\= ] .1=Xp©.10�=�3 ] 3B04049\5 F � J 7�9;_104<«0 U p>p\3602740/7C[g9�7W <>543Z7C[X9\=�<>=�3«543BfX_1. ] 9'�y.1_Y_ E 3�[X3B_1f�a U _A�y[X3B=�7C[�3«0 F 087C3 W 3�µ^[X. E .Y740�[�.1p>[ l U 365 F _Y< ] 9\_1.¾7 FÔRb Ë Å¦q Õ �

�Iÿ¦þ�ÿr� î %�f-f�ÞXý hT .Y= ] 3y7C[X3 JLu ��<>54´�_1<>9\D©.Y0º[X3B743654<\p>36=X3B< U 0 � . � 3 � � .Y7 ] <>=X04.Y02740�<\aÖ04.Yp>=X.Yj ] 9\=�7�9 W < U =�7C0º<\a E <\74[r ? R 9\=XD J È M f�54< ] 360204.Y=Xp ��W U _¾7C.¾7C[X523�9\DX.Y=Xpy. W fX54<}c\360efi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3t<\ag74[X3 E 9\023m0 F 02743 W E�F.1=�7454<VD UX] .Y=Xpm�t3B_1_ ½ ´�=X<}�y= W U _Y74.1fX52<>p>5C9 W©W .1=Xp E 36=X3�jX7C0 ½ .1= ] 543�9;04.1=�py74[X3¹[g9\54D^�o9\523�523602< U 5 ] 3U 74.1_1. ¿ 9;74.1<>= E 3 ] 9 U 043 J È M 9\=XD ] < W f U 7:9;74.1<>=�<}c>3652_h9\f � s [X3�=X3 ] 3B040C9;5 F = U W�E 365�<\aA7C[�543�9;DX07C[X9;7�_Y3�9\DX0q7C[X3«0 F 02743 W 74<{.Y740¶fi3�9\´"fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3«.10�DX.1523 ] 7C_ F 5236_19;7C3BD�7C<)74[X3'= U W�E 365�<\ar ? R 0K9\=XD%D�.104´�0 � s [�3�04. ¿ 3�<\a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>='[X9\0tc>3B5 F _Y.Y727C_13K3Bظ3 ] 7y<>='7C[�3�=X3 ] 3604049\5 F = U W¶E 3B5<\ab7C[X523�9\D�0 �+�D�DX.1=Xp�DX.102´�0�. W fX54<}c\360¶fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 E 3 ] 9 U 043«fg9\5274.Y74.1<>=X.Y=Xp%7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�9 ] 52<>040 W U _ ½7C.YfX_13ZD�.104´�0q.1=�7C52<^D UX] 3B0�9%jg=X3B5 ½ p>5C9\.Y=�3Úµ^3 ]6U 7C.1<\=�<\a JLu ] < W�W 9\=XDX0k.1="fg9;5C9\_Y_136_e9\=XD U 04.Y=Xp9\DXD�.Y7C.Y<>=g9\_�DX.102´V0¹an<>5 E U .1_YDX.1=�pq5236fX_Y. ] 9\0�. W f�54<}c>3B0¹74[X3�0 F 087C3 W 74[X54< U p>[Xf U 7 � +�DXD�.1=Xp r ? R 09\_Y04<k. W fX54<}c\360Afi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3 E 3 ] 9 U 023 W <>543 r ? R 0�fX52<}c^.YDX3 W <\543 ] < W f U 7:9;74.1<>= ] 9\fg9 E .Y_1.¾7 F �H <}��3Bc\365y9\DXD�.1=Xp�[g9\54D^�o9\523 ] < W fi<>=X3B=�740t02.1p>=X.¾j ] 9;=�74_ F . W fX52<}c>360�f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3K<>=X_ F �y[�36=7C[�3 F 9\543¶��36_Y_ ½ E 9\_h9;= ] 3BD � M 7C[�3652�y.Y043 � 9\DXD�.1=Xp'D�.104´�0 ] 9\=»DX3Bp>5C9\D�3¶7C[X3¶f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3��y[�36=7C[�3 r ? R .10K9 E <;747C_Y36=X3 ] ´ � 9;=XD)9;DXDX.1=�p r ? R 0KDX<V360y=X<\7K. W fX52<}c>3kf¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3/�y[X3B=)7C[�3DX.Y04´@.10�9 E <\7474_13B=X3 ] ´ � 9;0K��3�04[�<Â�v74[X54< U p>[�74[X3¶3Úµ�fi3652. W 36=�7C0�.1=�7C[X.Y0�023 ] 74.1<>= � J = ] 54369\04.Y=Xp

z>z �

Page 134: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

7C[�3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>="04. ¿ 3©DX<^3B0�=�<\7�02.1p>=X.¾j ] 9;=�74_ F ] [X9\=Xp>3©[g9\54D^�o9\523 E 9;_h9\= ] 3©fi<>.Y=�7Q{®7C[�3«043B52c\365fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3�.Y0 W <\543/5236_h9�7C36D%74<�74[X3 E 9\_19\= ] 3�<\a®[X9\54D��t9\523 ] < W f¸<>=�36=�7C0m7C[X9\=%7C<Z7C[X3 ] <>_ ½_13 ] 74.1<>={02. ¿ 3 � � 3Zf�54360236=�7k043�c>3B5C9\_ean<>5 W U _19\0�74[g9;7 U 023Z04. W fX_Y3 W 3�9;0 U 523 W 36=�7C0/74<%360274. W 9;7C37C[�3«=X3 ] 36020C9\5 F = U W�E 365�<\ao7C[�543�9;DX0 � 74[X3«= U W�E 365�<\a r ? R 0Z9;=XD�DX.Y04´�0¶7C[X9;7 ] <>=X087C.Y7 U 7C3«9��36_1_ ½ E 9;_h9\= ] 36D%0 F 087C3 W �M U 5«52360 U _Y740'9\_Y04<�02[X<}�×7C[g9;7©�y[X36=�74[X3)523602f¸<>=�043)74. W 3�an<>5�04369\5 ] [�.1=Xp�9 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=ÙD�.10 ½7C52. E U 7C36D�<Âc\365Z9�043B7�<\amDX.Y04´�0�.10 E 3B_1<}� 9 ]BU 7C<;Ø·an<>5k7C[X3«543602f¸<\=X043«74. W 3 � a U _1_º543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=0 U fXf¸<\527C0«9 _19\54p\365 ] < W�W 9\=XD³9\5452.Yc;9\_m549;7C3 U =XDX3B5�74[X.10�543B04fi<>=X023 ]6U 7C<\Ø�7C[X9\=·fg9;527C.¾7C.Y<>= ½.1=�p�74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%<}c>365K7É�y. ] 3�9;0 W 9\= F DX.Y04´�0 � 9\=XD�fg9\587C.h9;_I543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=%0 U fXfi<>52740�9�_h9\52p>365] < W©W 9\=XD@9\5254.¾c\9;_¸549;7C3 U =�DX365m7C[�.10 ]BU 7C<\Ø)7C[g9\=@fg9;527C.¾7C.Y<>=X.1=�p�9 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>='<}c>3B5K9\DXDX.¾7C.1<\=g9\_DX.Y04´�0m�y[X36=�7C[X3q543BfX_1. ] 9�DX.Y027C549 ] 740K9 W <VDX36087�= U W¶E 3B5K<;a ] < W©W 9\=XD�0 � � [X36=@7C[�3�523604fi<>=X0237C. W 3m.Y0º9 E <Âc\3K74[X3 ]6U 74<\Ø � ��3K=X363BD«7C< U 023�fg9;527C.¾7C.Y<>=X.1=�p/.1=X087C369\D©<;aI543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=�7C<q´\363Bf«7C[�3543B04fi<>=X023q74. W 3/DX<}�y= �

¡})VU &Á<K0YE�?G<>5@�-245+57.X:�E�?724A �H.�Õ65G?G:=<FE�?G24A ?+A <Ó ³?GWBE�0 ?G36Z[E�.X� �BA�9C240 8\<M"

E�?724A �H.IEY0 ?G.=JK<>5@��][WBE�.�8s [X.Y0¢023 ] 74.1<>=q.1=�c\360274.1p�9�7C360S7C[�3�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3¹<;ag9yDX.1087C54. E U 7436Dq.1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=/543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_�0 F 087C3 W�y.Y74[�fg9\587C.19\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= � , U 52.1=Xp�7C[X3'3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�740 � ��3'c\9;5 F 7C[X3 ] < W�W 9\=�D9\5254.Yc;9\_�549;7C3 � 7C[�3/543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=©f¸3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3/74[g9;7t.1=XDX. ] 9;74360¹�y[g9;7mfi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3�<\a`74[X3/<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>={.Y0�543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D � 9\=�D"74[X3�DX.1087C549 ] 74.1=Xp%fi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3�7C[g9;7k.Y=XDX. ] 9;74360/�y[g9;7kfi365 ] 3B=�7 ½9\p>3«<\a ] < W�W 9\=XDX0q7C[X3'5236fX_Y. ] 9)043B_13 ] 7C<>5¶DX.1523 ] 740¶7C<{74[X3'5236fX_Y. ] 9;0¶.1=�027C369\D�<\am74[X3'<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � J =�74[X3q3�µ^f¸3B54. W 3B=�740�<;a®7C[�.10y043 ] 7C.Y<>= � ��3 ] <\=�jgp U 523�023658c>36520��y.Y74[)Ë r ? R 0/9;=XDÌ DX.102´�0 � 9\=XD@369 ] [�023658c>365K[g9\=�DX_13B0 Ç>Ä O � <\ab7C3Úµ^7�9\=�D�.¾7C0m.Y=XDX3�µ � + ]6] <\54DX.Y=XpZ7C<�< U 5 W 3�9 ½0 U 543 W 36=�740/an54< W J = Á U 3B5 F>� 74[X.10�043B52c>3B5k0 U fXfi<>587C0�9;7 W <\027 �«] < W�W 9\=�DX0�fi365�043 ] <>=XD»�y.Y74[9\=�9�c>36549\p>3�l U 365 F 543B04fi<>=X043�7C. W 3 U =XDX365 z}Å 023 ] <\=XDX0�an<\5�04[X<>587ql U 3654.Y360��y.Y74[ 9\=�9�c\365C9;p>3Ä 74365 W 0qf¸3B5¶l U 3B5 F � � 3 ] <>=�jgp U 543©74[X3«023658c>365¶.1=�74[X.10k�t9 F ¼ U 087¶74<)p>.¾c>3©9\=�3ÚµX9 W fX_Y3�74<04[�<Â�ö7C[X3�fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3Z745436=�DX0k<\am9%DX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D JLu 0 F 087C3 W � M a ] < U 54023���3 ] 9\= E U .1_YD"9

z>z}Ì

Page 135: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

Q"1�ìR1�7BíS8Ôí!ì�â �×ï�ï�ìÔí ü H41�ã6-�í!â� à�7 7G1�ë�î��×ìÔì�5 ��1�ãf�N1q8�í þPü¨� � ÷ ú ùQ0à�5kâÔâÔà©ëJîP5kâ�8 ü å{1 �Pä ü á!à�7 7G1�ë�î�â U âÔí!áè F ��þ ��� �!÷ ��ú ��ù �©þ� à�7 7G1�ë�î�0�5 X/8�-�ìÔíW��1q8�5kàC -Pí�ìB3 = â�-P7 7G1�ì�3 = î�à3á -P7Bí!ë/8 $ %(' �>=¨�©ü ÿ�= �é�í!ì�7Bâ ê$í�ìNZJ-�í!ìB3Àåp1���í!ì�1�ä©í5èâ�AP5 r!8�í�îJë�í!ä ü ïh5kë�à�7 5�1�ã�îh5kâ�8 ü ç*),+9- �ZJ-�í!ì�3{é�í!ì�7 TfìÔí C -�í!ë�áS3 ? ï�â üîP5kâ�8 ü rMì�à�7 C -�í!ì�5kí!â æ -.)A/ ßJ5kâB8 ü�N-P7 ï$í�ì à�r��Qv�â ç %7+98 ÷�N-P7 ï$í�ì à�r ßJ5kâ�O�â ç6: 2,1<; ù�N-P7 ï$í�ì à�r0éEA�ì�í21�îPâ ç )AG �©�� à©ãkãkí�áS8�5kà©ë o 56�!í ��1(2,354 ú�÷G��� ���©ù ��� �©ÿ©úG�����í!ê�ã65ká�1q8�5kà©ë�Q0í!ìÔá!í!ë/8�1�ä©í ` ] 4 +9c úPü �©ÿ V ���Pü ÿ V �©ÿ V ÿ©þ V��þ V �©þ V �©þ V ÷�þ V ÿ©þ VßJ5kâ�8�ìR1�áS8�5kë�äDQ0í!ìÔá!í!ë/8�1�ä©í ` : 2,1 ) ú©þ V ý�þ V ù©þ V û©þ V ��þ©þ Ví Þ��! ¦à �`ÿT�Iÿ r <>=�jXp U 5C9�7C.1<\=%fg9\5C9 W 3�7C36520man<>5m543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>='3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�740 �

043B52c\365Z�y.Y74[�7C[X3%049 W 3%fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 E�F U 02.1=Xp{an3��t3B5�9\=XD�a¦9\0274365 r ? R 0�9\=�D�DX.102´V0 � � 3.1= ] _ U DX3'9)5236fX_Y. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C<\5�.1=�74[X3 ] <>=X=X3 ] 74.1<>= E 52<>´\3B5 � s 9 E _Y3 Æ � Ä fX5236043B=�7C0�fg9\549 W 3�7C3B540 �7C[�36.15y9 EXE 543�cV.h9;74.1<>=X0 � 9\=XD@c;9\_ U 360o��3 U 023k.1=%7C[X3k3Úµ�fi3652. W 36=�7C0y<\ab7C[�.10y043 ] 7C.Y<>= �

�IÿT�`ÿ¦þ � Þ�ý h ò a ß�ü ú à ê ò gBü}ýÂÞ i ü ò a ß�Ý/à�ý i à a ü}ÞXß�àw .Yp U 543 Æ � | .Y_1_ U 02745C9;74360ºf¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3y�y[X36=©�t3 U 043�Ë�043B52c>3B540t74<¶087C<>523�7C[�3 zÂÄ\Ì O � <>52.1p>.Y=g9\_] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=9\=XD E U .Y_1D9 Ç�Ä O � 5236fX_Y. ] 9 Ô Ä\Î#q <\a�74[X3 <>54.Yp>.1=g9;_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= Õ <\=�7C[�3 Î 74[043B52c\365 � w .1p U 523 Æ � | Ô 9 Õ .1_Y_ U 087C5C9�7C360`74[X3o9�c>3B5C9\p\3tl U 365 F 523602f¸<>=�043t74. W 3¹c\36540 U 0®74[X3tDX.Y02745C9 ] 7C.1=�pfi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3'�y[X36=7C[�3 ] < W�W 9\=XDX0Z9;5454.¾c>3%9�7 z}Å ] < W©W 9\=XDX0�f¸3B5�043 ] <>=�D � w .Yp U 523 Æ � | Ô E Õ.1_Y_ U 087C549;7C3B0®7C[X3K9�c>3B5C9\p\3�l U 3B5 F 543B04fi<>=X023K74. W 3tc>3B540 U 0�7C[�3 ] < W�W 9\=�D©9;5454.¾c;9\_�549;7C3m�y[X3B=©7C[�3543BfX_1. ] 9�DX.Y02745C9 ] 7C0 z}Ŧq'��Ä\Å#q%� 9;=XD Î;Ŧq <\a JLu ] < W©W 9\=XDX0 �T . W .Y_h9\5º7C<�7C[X3 E 36[g9�cV.1<>5m<\=)9�04.Y=Xp>_13�023658c>365 � w .1p U 523 Æ � | Ô 9 Õ 02[X<}�y0�74[g9;7y7C[X3kfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3<\aSfg9;527C.19\_�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=©. W fX54<}c>3B0o9\0�7C[X3/D�.102745C9 ] 7C.Y=Xp¶fi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3�.1= ] 54369\043B0 U =�7C.Y_i74<^< W 9\= F] < W©W 9\=XDX0b9\523ºDX.1523 ] 7436Dq7C<y7C[X3º543BfX_1. ] 9y9\=XD�_1<�9;D E 9\_h9\= ] .1=�pK.Y0`=X363BDX36D�7C<KDX.1523 ] 7¢9K0 U E 023B7¢<\a] < W©W 9\=XDX0 E 9 ] ´�7C<k7C[X3K<>54.Yp>.1=X9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � s [X3�543BDX.1523 ] 74.1=Xpkfi<>.1=�7¹.10A�y[X3B=«7C[�3�523604fi<>=X0237C. W 3'an<\5©023�9\5 ] [X.1=Xp�9 5236fX_Y. ] 9 3Bl U 9\_10�7C<"7C[X3�543B04fi<>=X023�7C. W 3%an<>5�023�9\5 ] [X.1=Xp 7C[X3�<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= Ô Ë Å¦q .1='74[X.10o3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�740 Õ � w <>5 U 04.1=�p�9�02.1=Xp\_13�5236fX_Y. ] 9 � 74[X3�543BDX.1523 ] 74.1=XpZfi<>.Y=�7.10¹_13B040¹7C[g9\= Î\Ŧq'�^E 3 ] 9 U 023�an<>5º7C[X3�0C9 W 3 ] < W�W 9\=�D'9\5254.Yc;9\_g549;7C3 � 74[X3�023658c>365 U 0436D©7C<�087C<>5237C[�3�5236fX_Y. ] 9{[X9\=XDX_Y360 W <>523%_1<�9;D74[g9\=Ù9\=·.Y=XDX.¾c^.YD U 9\_�043B52c>3B5 U 0236D³7C< 027C<\543@7C[X3@<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_

z>z}|

Page 136: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

F $ %@' : çd)_+9- æ -.)0/ ��1@2B3C4��1�ì�5kí�î �>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ï�â ü ���©ù ���ç6%7+98 ç6: 2B1<; ç )AG `e: 2,1 ) ` ] 4 +>c÷ ù �©� ��1�ì�5kí!î �©ÿ V

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 20 40 60 80 100

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Distracting Percentage (%)

Partitioning (4 servers)Partitioning (5 servers)

Replication (No Load balancing)Replication (Load Balancing)

å{1�è F m��þ á!à�7 7G1�ë�îPâ U âÔí!á!à©ë�î

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

Partitioning (4 servers)Partitioning (5 servers)

Replication (Load Balancing,DP=10%)Replication (Load Balancing,DP=20%)Replication (Load Balancing,DP=50%)

åpï$è4��1�ìB3h5këPäÁ8�APí9á!à�7 7G1�ë�în1�ì�ì�5 ��1�ã�ìR1q8�í üõ ò ß�%Sý�à �Iÿ � ÿ Ñ 9\5 F .1=XpZ7C[�3qD�.102745C9 ] 7C.Y=XpZf¸3B5 ] 36=�7:9\p\3 �

] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � 02.1= ] 3�74[X3©5236fX_Y. ] 9 U 02360¶an3��t3B5¶023652c\36520 � 9\=XD �t<\54´�_1<�9;DX0�.Y=�c><>_¾c>36D�.1=�0 U W�W 9;5 F9\=XD)DX< ]BU W 36=�7 ] < W©W 9\=XDX0�9\523�DX.1087C52. E U 7436D � d�<>523�7C[X9\=»<>=X3�5436f�_1. ] 9©.Y0 U 023Ba U _b�y[X36=»7C[�3DX.Y027C549 ] 74.1=XpZfi365 ] 3B=�7C9\p>3q.10m[X.Yp>[ �� [X3B=�74[X3mDX.Y027C549 ] 74.1=Xp�f¸3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3y.Y0�« q'� ��3 W 9 F 52< U p>[�_ F 360274. W 9;7C3¹7C[X3m. W f�54<}c>3 W 3B=�7e<>=7C[�3 ] < W�W 9\=XD%9\5254.¾c\9;_i549;7C3 U =XDX3B5m9 ] 3B527:9;.1=%9�c>3B5C9\p\3�l U 365 F 543B04fi<>=X043/74. W 3�D U 3/7C<�fX9\5274.h9\_543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=©9\0m9qa¦9 ] 74<>5t<\a �� s ÿ V � .Ya�« q <\a ] < W�W 9\=�DX0tDX<¶=X<\7o<}c\3654_Y<�9\D'74[X3/543BfX_1. ] 9\0 � s [X.Y0.10�9»_Y<Â��365 E < U =XD³<\aK7C[X3@. W fX52<}c>3 W 36=�7Z�y[X3B=·5236fX_Y. ] 9;0�9\543@=X<\7�<}c\3654_Y<�9\DX3BD � 02.1= ] [email protected]\36D E�F 9\040 U W .Y=Xp E <\7C[�7C[X3©5436f�_1. ] 9)9\=�D�7C[X3©<>54.Yp>.1=g9;_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�fX52<^D UX] 3�7C[X3'049 W 39�c>3B5C9\p>3�l U 365 F 523602f¸<>=�043t74. W 3 Ô 7C[�3t543BDX.1523 ] 7C.1=�p�fi<>.1=�7 Õ � + ] 7 U 9\_Y_ F>� 9\= U =XDX3B5 ½ _1<�9\D�36D¶5236fX_Y. ] 9fX52<^D U�] 360 W UX] [�l U . ] ´\3B5º543602f¸<\=X043m7C[X9\=�7C[X3t<>54.Yp>.1=g9;_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � �y[X. ] [ W 9\´;360e74[X3o<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_

zÂÄ\Å

Page 137: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=«74<>_13B5C9;743 W <>543 ] < W�W 9\=�DX0oan<>5t74[X3k0C9 W 3�9�c>3B5C9\p>3kl U 3B5 F 543B04fi<>=X023k74. W 3 � � [�36=_1<>9\D ½ E 9\_h9\= ] .1=�p)543BDX.1523 ] 7C0�04< W 3 ] < W�W 9\=XDX0 E 9 ] ´�7C<»7C[X3@<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�an<>5�9"[X.1p\[DX.Y027C549 ] 74.1=XpZfi365 ] 3B=�7C9\p>3 � ��3 ] 9\=�=X<\7K9;727:9\.Y='7C[X.Y0m. W fX54<}c\3 W 36=�7 �+�0º9;=Z3�µ�9 W fX_13 � 3�µ�9 W .1=X3 w .1p U 523 Æ � | Ô E Õ � ,/.102745C9 ] 7C.Y=Xp z}Ŧq � Ä\Ŧq'� 9\=XD Î\Å#q <\a ] < W©W 9\=XDX0.1= ] 54369\043B0m7C[X3 ] < W©W 9\=XD@9\5254.¾c\9;_Ö5C9�7C3 U =XD�365 z}Å 043 ] <>=XD�0 E�F 9�a¦9 ] 74<>5m<\a z � Ä^�Iz � Ë � 9\=�D z � |���y[X.Y_13�< U 5kfX5236DX. ] 7C.Y<>=".10 z � z>�¹z � Ç^� 9;=XD Ä � Å � ,/.1087C5C9 ] 7C.Y=Xp Î\Ŧq <;a ] < W©W 9\=XDX0�fi3658an<>5 W 0q9_1.¾7474_13k�t<>52043�74[g9\={��3ZfX543BDX. ] 7 �IE 3 ] 9 U 043�_Y<�9\D E 9\_h9\= ] .1=�p'543BDX.1523 ] 740�04< W 3 ] < W©W 9\=XD�0 E 9 ] ´7C<Z74[X3k<>54.Yp>.1=g9;_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= Ô 043B3 w .Yp U 523 Æ � | Ô 9 Õ2Õ �

�IÿT�`ÿT� Ý/ÞXý}ü ò Þ� ñ à�û! ò_i Þ�ü ò d�aÓ� à�ýlgk%�g ând _ ¦à i ü ò d�a Ý/Þ�ýÂü ò ü ò d�a ò a ß?®9;527C.19\_�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=k.Y=¶9KDX.1087C54. E U 7436Dq0 F 02743 W f¸3B52an<>5 W 0 E 3�7474365S7C[g9\= ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=kfg9\587C.Y74.1<>=�.1=Xp�y[X3B=·.Y7�DX.1087C5C9 ] 7C0�9 ] 3B527:9;.1== U W�E 365�<\a ] < W�W 9;=XDX0��y[X. ] [Ù.Y0Z_136020Z7C[g9\=7C[�3 ] < W�W 9\=�DDX.¾ØÖ3B5436= ] 3�7C[g9�7�fX9\5274.Y7C.Y<>=X.Y=Xp¶<}c>3B5�9;DXDX.Y74.1<>=X9\_¸023658c>36520 ] 9\=�[X9\=XDX_Y3 �+�0©9\=³3�µ�9 W fX_13 � ��3 ] < W fg9\543%74[X3@f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3@<\a/fX9\5274.h9\_o5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=��y.Y74[ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xpkan<>5m9 z}Ä\Ì O �Ù] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 9\0m04[X<}�[email protected]= w .1p U 523 Æ � | � J = w .Yp U 523 Æ � |�� ��3�36.¾7C[X3B5U 023�Ë�043B52c\36540k7C<�0274<>543�74[X3�<>54.Yp>.1=X9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>={9\=XD E U .1_YD"9 Ç�Ä O � 543BfX_1. ] 9 Ô Ä>Î#q <\a¹7C[�3<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= Õ <>=�7C[�3 Î 7C[�023652c\365�<>5�fX9\5274.Y7C.Y<>=�74[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�<Âc\365 Î 023652c\36520 � +�0.1_Y_ U 087C549;7C3BD{.1= w .1p U 523 Æ � | Ô E Õ � fg9;527C.¾7C.Y<>=X.1=�p©7C[�3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>={<}c>3B5�Ë�9;=XD Î 043658c>3B540q0 U fXfi<>587Æ � Ä 9\=�D �^� Î ] < W�W 9\=XDX0�f¸3B5«023 ] <\=XD��y.Y74[�9\=�9�c\365C9;p>3{l U 365 F 523602f¸<>=�043)74. W 3 U =�DX365 z}Å043 ] <>=�DX0 � . � 3 � � fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xp%74[X3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�<Âc\365�Ë»023658c>36520�[g9\=XDX_Y360 z � q _136020 ] < W©W 9\=XDX07C[X9\=ÙfX9\5274.Y7C.Y<>=X.Y=Xp».Y7�<}c>3B5 Î 043B52c>3B540 � J = w .Yp U 523 Æ � | Ô 9 Õ � fg9\587C.19\_o543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=��y.¾7C[³_1<�9;DE 9\_19\= ] .1=Xp�fi3658an<>5 W 0 E 3B727C365o74[g9\=%fg9;527C.¾7C.Y<>=X.1=�p¶<}c>3B5 Î 043658c>3B540y�y[X36=@7C[X3�5236fX_Y. ] 9¶DX.1087C549 ] 740z Ë q <;a ] < W�W 9;=XDX0 � �y[X. ] [».10K04_Y.1p>[�7C_ F _13B040K7C[g9\=�7C[X3 ] < W�W 9;=XD�fi365 ] 3B=�7C9\p>3�D�.Yظ36543B= ] 3�<\afg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xp Ô z � q Õ �

�IÿT�`ÿT� � Þ�ý h ò a ß�ü ú à ñ àVû! òji Þ�ü ò a ß"Ý/à�ý i à a ü�ÞXß�às [X.Y0`043 ] 7C.Y<>=k3�µ�9 W .1=X3B0I7C[X3A3�ØÖ3 ] 7b<\a�c;9\5 F .1=�po7C[X3º543BfX_1. ] 9t02. ¿ 3A<>=kf¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 � w .Yp U 543 Æ � z�Å.1_Y_ U 087C549;7C3B0q74[X3'9�c>3B5C9\p\3%l U 365 F 543B04fi<>=X023'7C. W 3�an<>5�9 z}Ä\Ì O �ö] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>="�y[X36=���3 U 023'Ë

zÂÄ^z

Page 138: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

F $�%(' çd)_+9- æ -.)0/ ��1@2B3C4��1�ì�5kí�î �>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ï�â ü ���©ù ���ç6%7+98 ç6: 2B1<; ç )AG `e: 2,1 ) ` ] 4 +>c÷ ù �©� ��1�ì�5kí!î ��1�ì�5kí!î

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 20 40 60 80 100

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Distracting Percentage (%)

Partitioning (4 servers)Partitioning (5 servers)

Replication (Load balancing ,RP=6.25%)Replication (Load Balancing,RP=12.5%)

Replication (Load Balancing,RP=25%)

åp1�è F p��þ

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

Partitioning (4 servers)Partitioning (5 servers)

Replication (Load Balancing,RP=6.25%)Replication (Load Balancing,RP=12.5%)

Replication (Load Balancing,RP=25%)

åMïfè�` : 2B1 ) �ÿ©þ Võ ò ß�%Sý�à �IÿøþB�`ÿ Ñ 9\5 F .Y=XpZ7C[X3k5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\='f¸3B5 ] 36=�7:9\p\3 �

043B52c\36540o74<�0274<>543K7C[X3�<>54.Yp>.1=g9;_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 3�9 ] [%<\aI�y[X. ] [%027C<\54360 Ç�Ä O � � 9\=XD%9\='9\DXDX.¾7C.1<\=g9\_043B52c\365¶74<)0274<>543«9�5236fX_Y. ] 9 � � 3�c\9;5 F 7C[�3«543BfX_1. ] 9@04. ¿ 3©an52< W Ì O � �ºz}Æ O � � 9\=�D Ç�Ä O � ��y[X. ] [Ù.Y0 Æ � Ä\Î#q'��zÂÄ � Î#q 9\=XD Ä>Î#q <\a�74[X3�<>54.Yp>.1=g9;_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � � 3@c;9\5 F 7C[�3 ] < W�W 9\=�D9\5254.Yc;9\_¸5C9;743q9\=XD%7C[X3kDX.Y02745C9 ] 7C.1=�p�fi365 ] 3B=�7C9\p>3 �w .Yp U 543 Æ � z}Å 02[X<}�y0�7C[X9;7@543BD UX] .Y=Xp7C[X3 543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=�fi365 ] 3B=�7C9\p>3 <\a ] < U 52043 5436D UX] 3B0�7C[�39�c>3B5C9\p>3»l U 3B5 F 523602f¸<>=�043»7C. W 3 � 9;=XD�.Y7%02.1p>=�.Yj ] 9\=�7C_ F 9;ظ3 ] 7C0%0 F 087C3 W f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3{<\=X_ Fan<>5�[X.1p>[ ] < W�W 9\=�DX0�549;7C3 Ô � z}Å ] < W�W 9\=�DX0�fi365/023 ] <>=XD".1= w .Yp U 523 Æ � z}Å Ô E Õ4Õ � � [X36=»7C[�3543BfX_1. ] 9�DX.Y02745C9 ] 7C0 Î\Ŧq <\a ] < W�W 9\=XDX0 � 543BD UX] .Y=XpZ7C[X3k5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=«fi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3qan52< W Ä>Î#q 74<Æ � Ä>Î#q an<>5�9 z}Ä\Ì O � ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= .1= ] 54369\043B0�74[X3 ] < W©W 9\=XD�9\5452.Yc;9\_A549;7C3��y.Y74[�9\=�9�c\365C9;p>3l U 365 F 543B04fi<>=X043k7C. W 3 E 3B_1<}� z}Å 023 ] <\=XDX0 E�F 9�a¦9 ] 7C<>5m<;a z � Î �

zÂÄ>Ä

Page 139: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

�IÿT�`ÿr� � Þ�ý h ò a ß�ü ú à ând _ ¦à i ü ò d�a�î ò�ü àJ =�7C[X.Y0¹023B7�<\a¸3�µ^f¸3B54. W 3B=�740 � �t3yc;9\5 F 7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=Z04. ¿ 3man54< WÓÆ Ë O � 7C< Ä>Î\Æ O ��� w <>5º9 øO �·] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � ��3 U 043 ø Í Ç>Ä 043B52c>3B540m7C<Z087C<>523�7C[�3/<>54.Yp>.1=X9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 9\=XD@9;=@9\DXDX.¾7C.1<\=g9\_043B52c\365k7C<%0274<>543�9%543BfX_1. ] 9©�y.¾7C[»7C[�3�02. ¿ 3Z<\a Ç�Ä O ��� w .1p U 543 Æ � z>z _Y.102740�7C[�3©9�c\365C9;p>3�l U 365 F543B04fi<>=X023k74. W 3��y[X3B=�74[X3 ] < W�W 9\=XDX0m9;5454.¾c>3k9;7 z}Å f¸3B5m043 ] <>=XD@an<>5m9 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>='<;a Æ Ë O � �zÂÄ\Ì O � � 9;=XD Ä>Î;Æ O � � . � 3 � � 7C[�3©fg9;527C.19\_A543BfX_1. ] 9 ] <>=�7:9;.1=X0 Î\Ŧq'�AÄ\Î#q 9\=XD z}Ä � Î$q <\ao7C[�3<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 523602f¸3 ] 7C.¾c>3B_ F �w .Yp U 543 Æ � z>z Ô 9 Õ 74< Ô ] Õ 02[X<}�è74[X3)l U 3B5 F 523602f¸<>=�043)74. W 3��y[X3B= ] < W�W 9\=XDX0«9\5452.Yc>3)9;7 z}Å] < W©W 9\=XDX0qfi365¶023 ] <>=XDX0�an<>5 Æ Ë O � �¹zÂÄ\Ì O � � 9\=XD Ä>Î\Æ O � � 543B04fi3 ] 74.Yc\36_ F � s [X3'52360 U _Y74004[�<Â� 74[g9;7�fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3@. W fX52<}c>3 W 36=�7�D U 3@7C< fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xp»<}c\365©9\=�9\D�DX.Y74.1<>=g9;_t043B52c\365DX3 ] 54369\043B0)9;0'7C[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=·04. ¿ 3».1= ] 54369\043B0 ��E 3 ] 9 U 023�9;=�9;DXDX.Y74.1<>=X9\_�023658c>[email protected]. E U 7C3B09Ù0 W 9;_1_13B5'fi<>5274.1<>=<\a�DX9;7:9�an<>5�9³_19\54p>3B5 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � �y[�.1_13"fg9;527C.19\_/5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=<\=�7C[�39\DXD�.Y7C.Y<>=g9\_�043B52c>3B5 ] <>=X02.1027436=�7C_ F DX3 ] 54369\043B0©7C[�3�l U 3B5 F 523604fi<>=X023�74. W 3%9\0Z7C[[email protected] ] 7C.1=�pfi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3�.Y= ] 523�9\02360 � =X< W 9;727C3B5º�y[X9;7�74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�04. ¿ 3�.Y0 ��E 3 ] 9 U 043K7C[X3Kl U 365 F _Y< ] 9\_1.¾7 F.1=�DX. ] 9;7C3BD E�F 74[X3)D�.102745C9 ] 7C.Y=Xp�fi365 ] 3B=�7C9\p>3{D�3B7C3B5 W .1=X3B0©74[X3{fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3�. W fX52<Âc\3 W 36=�7 �?®9;527C.19\_º543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= E 54.Y=Xp>0�DX<}�y=�7C[X3«l U 365 F 543B04fi<>=X023'7C. W 360kan54< W Ç�Î � Ì 7C< Ç � Ì 043 ] <>=XDX0 �an54< W×Ç�z � Ë�74< Ç � Î 023 ] <>=XDX0 � 9\=XD�an54< W Ä;| � Ä 7C< Ç � z 023 ] <\=XDX0��y[X3B= ] < W©W 9\=XDX0K9\5254.¾c>3�9;7 z}Å] < W©W 9\=XDX0®f¸3B5e043 ] <>=XD�an<>5 Æ Ë O � �^zÂÄ\Ì O � � 9;=XD Ä>Î\Æ O � � 523604fi3 ] 7C.¾c>36_ F � H 36523o�t3 ] 9;=�jg=XD9\=X<;7C[X3B5�.1=�7C3B5436087C.Y=Xp%fX[X3B=X< W 36=X<>= � �y[X36= 3�9 ] [ 023658c>365k[X<\_1DX0/74[X3Z0C9 W 3Z9 W < U =�7�<;a�DX9;7:9 �04369\5 ] [�.1=Xp¶9 Ä>Î\Æ O �³] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= Ô <Âc\365 Ì 023652c\36520 Õ .Y0ºa¦9;027C3B5¹74[g9\=©043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp�9 zÂÄ\Ì O � Ô <}c>3B5Ëq043658c>3B540 Õ 9\=XD Æ Ë O � Ô <}c>365 Ä 023658c>36520 Õ ��E 3 ] 9 U 043K7C[X3y�t<\54´�_1<�9;D«.1=�c\<>_Yc\36D«.Y=�74[X3K0 U W�W 9;5 F9\=XD�DX< ]6U W 36=�7 ] < W�W 9;=XDX0k.10kDX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D <}c>3B5 W <>543�043B52c\36540 � 9\=XD�3�9 ] [�043B52c>3B5�[g9\=�DX_13B0_13B040m��<>54´ �

�IÿT�`ÿT� ñ à�ûF òji Þ^ü ò d�a�� ò à�ý�Þ�ý i ú�hJ =¶74[X.10¢043B7e<\ag3�µ^fi3652. W 36=�7C0 � �t3o9\040 U W 3��t3o[X9}c\3o043�c>3B5C9\_g9;DXDX.Y74.1<>=X9\_�043B52c>3B540 � 369 ] [Z<\aX�y[�. ] [0274<>543B0Z9�fX9\5274.h9\_A5236fX_Y. ] 9 � 9\=XD �t3«<>54p�9;=X. ¿ 3�74[X3«023652c\36520�9\0�9�[X.13B5C9\5 ] [ F <\ay5236fX_Y. ] 9\0 � � 3

zÂÄ\Ç

Page 140: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

F $ %@' ç ),+#- æ -.)A/ ��1@2B3C4��þ �>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ïPâ ü H1�ì�5kí!îç6%7+98 ç6: 2,1<; ç )AG `e: 2B1 ) ` ] 4 +>c÷ ù �©� ��1�ì�5kí!î ��1�ì�5kí!î

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 20 40 60 80 100

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Distracting Percentage (%)

Partitioning (2 servers)Partitioning (3 servers)

Replication (No Load balancing)Replication (Load Balancing)

å{1�è ú�÷G��� åX` ] 4 +>c �ÿ©þ V,è

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 20 40 60 80 100

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Distracting Percentage (%)

Partitioning (4 servers)Partitioning (5 servers)

Replication (No Load balancing)Replication (Load Balancing)

åpï$è ���©ùD��� å0`e: 2,1 ) ��©ÿ VWè

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 20 40 60 80 100

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Distracting Percentage (%)

Partitioning (8 servers)Partitioning (9 servers)

Replication (No Load balancing)Replication (Load Balancing)

åMáè �©ÿ©úG��� åX` : 2,1 ) n����S ÿ V,èõ ò ß�%býÂà �`ÿ¦þ�þgÿ Ñ 9\5 F .Y=Xp�7C[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=%02. ¿ 3 �

zÂÄ Ë

Page 141: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

9\020 U W 3Z3�9 ] [ 043B52c\365k[g9\=XD�_1360k9�7 W <>087 Ç�Ä O � <\a¹Dg9;7C9 � w <>5�9 ø O ��] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � �t3 U 023ø Í Ç�Ä 023658c>36520q74<%0274<>543�74[X3Z<>54.Yp>.1=X9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � 74[X3Zjg54087q9\DXDX.¾7C.Y<>=g9\_S043�c>3B5�087C<>52360 Ç�Ä O �<\aºDg9�7:9'9\=�D{0C9;74.108jg360/f q <\a ] < W�W 9\=�DX0 � 7C[X3¶043 ] <>=XD"9\D�DX.Y74.1<>=g9;_b023658c>365�087C<>52360 z�Æ O � <\aDg9;7C9»9\=XD0C9�7C.108jg360 Ô f q ½ z�Ŧq Õ _136020 ] < W�W 9\=XDX0 � �y[�. ] [.10Z9»0 U E 043�7�<\ay7C[X3 ] < W©W 9\=XDX07C[X9;7�74[X3¶jg52027k9\D�DX.Y74.1<>=g9;_b023658c>365�049;7C.Y02jg3B0 � 9;=XD{7C[X3�� ½ 74[{3�µV745C9'043B52c\365�0274<>543B0 Ç�Ä Í Ä � s � O �9\=XD�0C9�7C.108jg360 Ô f q ½ Ô . ½ z Õ�f z}Ŧq Õ <;a ] < W©W 9\=XDX0 � �y[X. ] [�.10K9�0 U E 023B7�<\a ] < W©W 9\=XD�0o7C[g9;7K7C[�3_h9;54p>3B5o543BfX_1. ] 9\0m049;7C.Y02a F �w .Yp U 543 Æ � zÂÄ .Y_1_ U 027C549;7C3B0K74[X3�l U 3B5 F 523602f¸<>=�043¶74. W 3q�y[X3B=»�t3Z[g9�c\3 z>�`ÄV� 9\=XD»Ë'9\DXDX.¾7C.1<\=g9\_043B52c\36540@an<>5%9 z}Ä\Ì O � ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � � 3 ] < W fX9\543)74[X3»fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3)<\aqfg9\5274.h9\_�543BfX_1. ] 9 ½7C.Y<>=��y.¾7C[�DX.¾ØÖ3B543B=�7�[X.13B5C9\5 ] [X.13B0 � 9\=XD�a U _1_¹5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>= U 04.1=�p{Ë"9\DXDX.¾7C.Y<>=g9\_A023652c\36520 � w .1p ½U 523 Æ � z}Ä Ô 9 Õ 7C< Ô ] Õ .Y_1_ U 027C549;7C3y7C[�3/0 ] 36=g9\52.1<>0o�y[�36543/74[X3�_h9;54p>3B027o5236fX_Y. ] 9¶0C9;74.108jg360mË Å#q%�XÎ\Ŧq9\=XD Ì>Ŧq <;a ] < W©W 9\=XDX0 � 543602f¸3 ] 74.Yc>3B_ F � M U 5q52360 U _Y740�02[X<}�Ó7C[g9;7k�y[X3B=���3«[g9�c\3©7É�y. ] 3«9;0W 9\= F 043B52c\36540 � a U _Y_t543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=�f¸3B52an<>5 W 0 E 3B727C365Z74[g9\=fg9\587C.Y74.1<>=�.1=Xp�<Âc\365Z7C[�36043�043B52c\36540 �9\=XD«.1=«< U 5�3Úµ�9 W f�_13 � U 02.1=Xp¶9\DXDX.¾7C.1<\=g9\_g043B52c\36540�7C< E U .1_1D©9qa U _1_�543BfX_1. ] 9k. W fX54<}c>3B0�74[X3 ] < W ½W 9\=XD�9\5452.Yc;9\_I549;7C3��y.¾7C[�9\=�9}c\36549\p>3ql U 365 F 523602f¸<>=�043�74. W 3 E 36_1<}� z}Å 043 ] <>=XDX0 E�F 9Za¦9 ] 7C<\5<\a z � Ç�� 9;0 ] < W fg9\5236D{�y.¾7C[»fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xp�<}c>3B5 Ì 043658c>3B540 � ?®9\587C.19\_¢5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= U 02.1=Xp'an3��t3B5043B52c\36540 ] < U _1D�9 ] [X.13�c>3m02. W .1_h9;5`<>5 E 3B727C365®f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3t74[g9\=¶a U _Y_^5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= � ?®9\587C.19\_^5236fX_Y. ½] 9�7C.1<\=��y.¾7C[«<\=X3�5236fX_Y. ] 9k.10�9 E _Y3m7C<�9 ] [X.13�c>3/02. W .1_h9;5ef¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3m7C<qa U _1_�5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=��y[�36=7C[�3�fX9\5274.h9\_¢5436f�_1. ] 9'DX.1087C549 ] 740�Ë Å¦q <;a ] < W©W 9\=XD�0 � ?¢9\5274.h9\_¢5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>=)�y.¾7C[ 9%[X.13B5C9\5 ] [ F<\ao7É��<{5236fX_Y. ] 9;0�. W fX52<}c>360q7C[X3 ] < W�W 9\=XD�9\5452.Yc;9\_A5C9�7C3©�y.¾7C[�9\=�9�c>3B5C9\p\3'l U 365 F 523604fi<>=X0237C. W 3 E 36_Y<Â� z}Å 023 ] <\=XDX0 E�F 9�a¦9 ] 7C<\5�<\a z � � 9\0 ] < W fg9\5236D��y.¾7C[�a U _1_`5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=@�y[�36={7C[�3543BfX_1. ] 9\0mD�.102745C9 ] 7 Î\Ŧq <\a ] < W�W 9\=XDX0 Ô 02363 w .1p U 543 Æ � zÂÄ Ô E Õ4Õ �gE 3 ] 9 U 043q043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp'9�0 W 9\_1_Y365543BfX_1. ] 9�7:9\´;360o_Y36020¹74. W 3 � 9\=XD©.Y7�9\_102<¶3B_1. W .1=X9;7C3B0e7C[X3K543B0 U _¾7 W 3654p\.1=Xp�7C. W 3K9\=�D«543BD UX] 360o7C[�3=X3 ] 36020C9\5 F�W 36020C9\p\3©3Úµ ] [X9\=Xp>3 E 3�7É�t3B36=�7C[�3 ] <>=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 54<>´;365¶9\=XD 043658c>3B540 � � [X3B=�7C[�3_h9;54p>3B027/5236fX_Y. ] 9©0C9�7C.108jg360 Ì\Ŧq <\a ] < W�W 9;=XDX0 � 7C[�3Zl U 365 F 543B04fi<>=X043�74. W 3qan<\5�fg9\587C.19\_¢5236fX_Y. ½] 9�7C.1<\=��y.Y74[{9«[�.136549\5 ] [ F <\aºË«9\DXDX.¾7C.1<\=g9\_`043B52c\36540�.Y0�.Y=X043B=X04.¾7C.¾c>3�74<«7C[�3 ] < W©W 9\=XD�9\5452.Yc;9\_5C9�7C3o7C[X9;7A�t3 ] <>=X04.YDX365º.Y=�7C[X.Y0A3�µ^f¸3B54. W 3B=�7 � s [X.Y0A54360 U _Y7¹.Y=XDX. ] 9;7C3B0®7C[X9;7ºfg9\587C.h9;_�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=

zÂÄ>Î

Page 142: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

F $ %(' ç ),+#- æ -.)A/ ��1@2B3C4��1�ì�5kí!î �>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ï�â ü ���©ù����ç %�+>8 ç : 2,1<; ç )0G ` : 2B1 ) ` ] 4 +>c÷ ù �©� ��1�ì�5kí!î �©ÿ V

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

Partitioning (4 servers)1 Replica

2 Replicas4 Replicas

Full ReplicationPartitioning (8 servers)

åp1�èF8�A�íVã�1�ìÔä©í!âB8×ì�í!ê�ã65ká�1WâR1q8�5kâgDfí!â ÷�þ V´à�r0á!à�7 7G1�ë�î�â

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

Partitioning (4 servers)1 Replica

2 Replicas4 Replicas

Full ReplicationPartitioning (8 servers)

åpï$è8�APíVã�1�ìÔä©í!â�8�ìÔí!ê�ã65ká�1Wâ�1q8�5kâ7Dfí!â ÿ©þ V à�r0á!à�7 7G1�ë�î�â

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

Partitioning (4 servers)1 Replica

2 Replicas4 Replicas

Full ReplicationPartitioning (8 servers)

åMáè8�A�í.ã�1�ì�ä©í�âB8 ìÔí!ê�ã65ká�1Wâ�1q8�5kâ7Dfí!â ù©þ V à�r0á�à�7 7G1�ëPî�âõ ò ß�%býÂà �`ÿ¦þ`�Iÿ ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3��y.Y74[�9�[X.Y365C9;5 ] [ F <\a¢543BfX_1. ] 9\0 �

zÂÄ\Æ

Page 143: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

�y.Y74[@9�[X.13B5C9\5 ] [ F <\ab543BfX_1. ] 9\0t[g9\0o7C[�3�f¸<\7436=�7C.19\_¸74<Z. W fX54<}c\3/f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3�9;=XD%0 ] 9\_h9 E .1_1.¾7 F04.Yp>=X.¾j ] 9\=�74_ F <Âc\365ya U _1_Ö5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>= �

�IÿT�`ÿT� î %�f-f�ÞXý hJ =�74[X.10�043 ] 7C.Y<>= � ��3'DX3 W <>=�027C549;7C3�7C[X3«f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3«<;amfg9\587C.h9;_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=�.Y=9�D�.1027454. E U 7C3BD�.1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>=�543�7C52.13Bc;9\_y0 F 087C3 W � s [X3)fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3). W fX52<Âc\3 W 36=�7©D U 3�74<fg9\587C.19\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�fg9\5274.Y74.1<>=�.10�DX3B74365 W .1=�36D E�F 7C[X3�DX.1087C549 ] 74.1=Xp�f¸3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3�7C[g9;7t.1=XD�. ] 9�7C3609 ]B] 36020«_Y< ] 9\_1.¾7 F � � 3 ] < W fg9\523%7C[X3@fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3%<;a/fg9\587C.19\_t5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=��y.Y7C[ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xp � � 3�04[X<}��7C[g9;7 U 04.1=�pZ<>=X3k9\DXD�.Y7C.Y<>=g9\_i043B52c\365y7C< E U .Y_1D%<>=�3�5436f�_1. ] 9�f¸3B52an<>5 W 0E 3B7474365m7C[X9\=�a U 527C[�365yfg9\587C.Y74.1<>=�.1=Xp¶74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%<}c>3B5K74[X.10K9\DXD�.Y7C.Y<>=g9\_¸043B52c>3B5 � 3Bc\36=)�y[�36=7C[�3�543BfX_1. ] 9qDX.1087C5C9 ] 7C0¹_13B040¹7C[g9\= z}Ŧq <\a ] < W©W 9\=XD�0�.Y= W 9\= F ] 9\02360 � J 7o9\_102<�9 ] [X.Y3Bc\360 ] < W ½fg9\549 E _Y3of¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3¹�y.Y7C[ZfX9\5274.Y7C.Y<>=X.Y=Xp�<}c>3B5e7É�y. ] 3y9\0 W 9\= F 023652c\36520 � 9\=XDZa U _1_V543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=�y[X3B=�7C[�3�5236fX_Y. ] 9ZDX.Y02745C9 ] 7C0KË Å¦q <\a ] < W©W 9\=XDX0 � � [�36=)5236fX_Y. ] 9\0 ] 9\=�DX.1087C549 ] 7 W <>543�7C[X9\=Ë Å¦q <\a ] < W�W 9;=XDX0 � 9�[X.Y36549\5 ] [ F <\a¢543BfX_1. ] 9\0oa U 527C[�365y. W fX54<}c\360y0 F 02743 W fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 �

¡})eu �-245G5G.X:�E�?G24A �;.�57.X:�E�?72xA ?GA < �?7W`EY0 ?+36Z[EY.X� �BA�9�2*0 8\<FE�?72xA �H.h"

E�0 ?7.=JK<>5@��];WBE�.�8s [X.Y0¢023 ] 74.1<>=q.1=�c\360274.1p�9�7C360S7C[�3�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3¹<;ag9yDX.1087C54. E U 7436Dq.1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=/543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_�0 F 087C3 WU 02.1=Xp ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=«0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � +�0y9\=@3ÚµX9 W fX_Y3�7C<Z02[X<}�!74[X3�f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3�. W fX52<}c>3 W 36=�7mD U 37C< ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � ��3�f¸3B52an<>5 W 9«043�7�<\aº3�µ^fi3652. W 36=�7C0�74[g9;7�[g9\=XDX_Y3 Ä>Î;Æ O � <\aADg9;7C9U 02.1=Xp Ì 043B52c>3B540 � 369 ] [Z<\ag�y[X. ] [�[g9\0®Ë r ? R 0º9\=�D Ì DX.Y04´�0 � 9;=XD�[g9\=�DX_13B0 Ç�Ä O � <;a�Dg9;7:9 � � 3.1= ] _ U DX3º9 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�043B_13 ] 7C<>5`.Y=�7C[X3 ] <\=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 54<>´;365 � , U 54.Y=Xpo7C[�3¹3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�740 � �t3ºc;9\5 F7C[�3 ] < W©W 9\=XD©9\5254.Yc;9\_�5C9;743 � 7C[X3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�04´\3�� � 7C[�3�0236_13 ] 74.1<>=�f¸3B5 ] 36=�7:9\p\3 � 9;=XD7C[�3m= U W�E 3B5e<\a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 � � 3y9\_Y04< ] < W fX9\543 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=¶043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=��y.Y74[Zfg9\587C.h9;_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= � s 9 E _13 Æ � Ç f�54360236=�7C0�fg9\549 W 3�7C3B540 � 74[X36.Y5K9 EXE 523BcV.h9;74.1<>=�0 � 9\=�D�c;9\_ U 360m�t3 U 023�.Y=7C[�3q3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�740K<;a¢74[X.10y043 ] 74.1<>= �

zÂÄ �

Page 144: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

Q"1�ìR1�7BíS8�í�ì�â �oï�ï�ì�í ü H41�ã6-�í!â� à�7 7G1�ë�îG�oì�ì�5 ��1�ãf��1q8Ôí þPü¨� � ÷ ú ùQ0à�5kâÔâ�à©ëJîP5kâB8 ü åp1���ä ü á!à�7 7G1�ë�î�â U âÔí!áè F ��þ ��� �!÷ ��ú ��ù �©þ� à�7 7G1�ë�în0�5 X:8�-�ì�íW�N1q8�5kàC -�í!ì�3 = â�-P7 7G1�ìB3 = î�à3á -P7Bí!ë/8 $ %(' �>=¨�©ü ÿ�= �é�í!ì�7Bâ�ê$í!ìNZJ-�í!ì�3@å{1 ��í!ìR1�ä©íèâ�Ah5 r}8�í!îJë�í!ä ü ïP5kë�à�7 5�1�ã�îP5kâ�8 ü ç*),+#- �ZJ-�í!ì�3�é�í!ì�7*TfìÔí C -�í!ë�áS3 ? ïPâ üîP5kâB8 ü rpìÔà�7 C -Pí�ì�5kí!â æ -.)A/ ßN5kâ�8 ü�N-h7Wï$í!ì�à�r�Q4v×â ç %7+98 ÷�N-h7Wï$í!ì�à�rnßN5kâ�O3â ç6: 2B1<; ù�N-h7Wï$í!ì�à�r�éEA�ì�í�1�î�â ç )0G �©�� à©ãkãkí!á 8�5kà©ë o 56��í ��1(2,3C4 �©ÿ©úG���� à©ãkãkí!á 8�5kà©ë��×á!á�í!â�â o O©í<Ii^5kê:r}|Áã656O©í�rp-Pë�áS8�5kà©ë � þPü þ åAi[5kêhruè þPü � �©ü þ å}-�ëP5 rpà©ì�7{èo í!ãkí!áS8�5kà©ë�Q0í!ìÔá!í!ë�8R1�ä©í ` 1(4 c ���Pü ÿ V �©ÿ V ÿ©þ V�N-h7Wï$í!ì�à�r� à©ãkãkí!áS8�5kà©ëPâ ç % \ c ù �©�í Þ��F nà �IÿT�Iÿ r <>=�jgp U 5C9;74.1<>=@fg9;5C9 W 3B7436540oan<\5 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=@3�µ^f¸3B54. W 3B=�740 �

�IÿT�`ÿ¦þ � Þ�ý h ò a ß�ü ú à ând _ ¦à i ü ò d�aÙá i¦i à`gkg î ªi঩ Þ a s·ü ú à î à` ¦à i ü ò d�a Ý/à�ý i à a ü}ÞXß�às [X3»fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3{. W fX54<}c\3 W 36=�7C0'D U 3{7C< ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=Ù043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�9\543 W 9\.Y=X_ F D�3B7C3B5 W .1=X3BDE�F 74[X3)fi<>f U _h9\52.Y7 F <\a�7C[X3 W <>087©an5236l U 3B=�74_ F U 043BD ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=³9;a�7C3B5 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=0236_13 ] 74.1<>= �J =�9;DXDX.Y74.1<>= � 023�9\5 ] [X.1=Xp)9�0 U E 043�7Z<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�049�c>360�7C[X3�7C. W 3Zan<>5 W 3B54p>.Y=Xp@543B0 U _¾7C0�9;=XD3�µ ] [g9;=Xp>.1=�p W 36020C9\p\360 � �y[X. ] [Ù9;_104< ] <>=�7C52. E U 74360�74<{7C[X3%fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3'. W fX54<}c\3 W 36=�7C0 � J af q <;a ] < W�W 9\=�DX0�p><'7C<%74[X3 W <>087/an543Bl U 36=�7C_ F U 043BD ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=»0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>={�y.Y_1_. W fX52<Âc\3�74[X3t_19\54p>3B027 ] < W�W 9\=XD�9;5454.¾c;9\_�5C9;743 U =�DX365A9 ] 3B527:9;.1=Z9�c>3B5C9\p\3ol U 365 F 523604fi<>=X023t7C. W 3E�F 9qa¦9 ] 74<>5t<\a �ÿ V � �y[X. ] [ W 369\=X0�74[X3/0 F 087C3 W ] 9;=%[g9\=XDX_Y3 ��þ©þ Vns ÿ Vÿ V W <>523 ] < W©W 9\=XD�0�7C[X9\=9�0 F 027C3 W �y.Y7C[�< U 7 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=»043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � J am=�3�9\52_ Fz}Å>Å#q <\a ] < W�W 9\=�DX0kp><�74<�74[X3 W <>027an543Bl U 36=�7C_ F U 043BD ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3q. W f�54<}c>3 W 3B=�740K9\543�0 W 9\_Y_`9\=XD�<>=X_ F D U 3k74<©_Y36020543B0 U _¾7 W 3B54p>.Y=Xp¶7C. W 3k9;=XD@=X3B7É��<>54´ ] < W fi3B74.Y74.1<>= �s [X3B543q9\543/7É��<�a¦9 ] 74<>540o74[g9;7mDX3�7C3B5 W .1=X3/74[X3�f¸<\f U _h9;54.Y7 F <\aS7C[�3 W <>087oan543Bl U 36=�7C_ F U 043BD ] <>_ ½_13 ] 74.1<>= � 74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=9 ]6] 36020«04´;3B� 9\=�D³74[X3@f¸3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3�<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 E 36.1=�p ] [�<>043B= �s [X3q0 F 02743 W �y.Y74[ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=)9 ] [X.13�c>360y7C[�3�_19\54p>3B027y. W fX52<}c>3 W 36=�7y�y[X3B=�7C[�3 ] <>_ ½_13 ] 74.1<>=X0/9\543 U =X.Yan<>5 W _ F 9 ]6] 36020436D�9\=XD»7C[�3Z0 F 02743 W 0236_13 ] 740k9\0/an3B� ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0�9\0�f¸<\0404. E _13�y[X.Y_13 W 9\.1=�7:9;.1=X.Y=Xp�9 ]B] 3Bf�7:9 E _13kfX543 ] .Y04.1<\= �� 3 W <VDX36_Ö74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%9 ]B] 3B040�02´\3�� U 04.Y=Xp�7C[X3 G .1f^a ½ _1.Y´\3�DX.1087C54. E U 74.1<>=�L Î\Å N �

zÂÄ\Ì

Page 145: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

� Ô � Õ � ° Í � � s�� �K�y[�36543 ° � z Í�� ��� �� Ô z Í · � s�� Õ � z! � ! Èp�

+�0 � c;9\52.1360�an54< W z 7C< Å^� 7C[X3�fX54< E 9 E .1_Y.Y74.1360�c;9\5 F an54< W 9\= U =X.Yan<>5 W DX.1087C52. E U 74.1<>=7C<�9f U 523 G .1f�ayD�.1027454. E U 7C.Y<>= � � 3%DX<»=X<\7Z[X9}c\3@027:9�7C.1087C. ] 0Z9 E < U 7¶7C[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�9 ]6] 36040�02´\3B�543B0 U _¾7C.Y=Xp�an54< W ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=Z0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=©.Y=«9k54369\_ W U _¾7C.1f�_13 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=Z023�9\5 ] [X.1=�p¶36=�cV.152<>= W 36=�7 �E U 7K_Y< ] 9\_1.¾7 F 0 U p>p>3B02740K74[g9;7 U =X.¾an<>5 W DX.1087C52. E U 74.1<>=�0m9\543 U =�_1.1´;36_ F �� 3 U 023©74[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=».1=�an3B5436= ] 3«523B7454.13�c;9\_A=X3B7É��<>52´"74<�0236_Y3 ] 7�7C[X3 W <>027q543B_13�c\9;=�7 ] <>_1_Y3 ]�½7C.Y<>=X0�L zÂÎ N � s [�3m3�µ^f¸3B54. W 3B=�740efX5236043B=�7C36D©.1=�L zÂÎ^�>Î Ë � �#� NgD�3 W <>=X02745C9;7436D�74[g9;7e�y[X3B=Z�t3 E U .1_Y7] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0¹0 U�] [�74[g9;7o369 ] [ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= ] <>=�7:9\.Y=X0oDX< ]6U W 3B=�740tan54< W 74[X3/0C9 W 3/02< U 5 ] 3 � U 04.Y=Xp7C[�.10 W 3B74[X<^D�7C<%043B_13 ] 7�7C[�3¶7C<>f Î;Ŧq <;a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0�9 ] [X.13�c>360 ] < W fX9\5C9 E _13�9 ]6]6U 5C9 ] F �y.Y74[04369\5 ] [�.1=Xp�9\_1_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 � 9\=XD 0436_Y3 ] 7C.1=�p�74[X3Z7C<>f z}Ŧq 9\=XD Ä\Ŧq <;a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 ] 9 U 02360�9_1<\040�<\a�fX543 ] .102.1<>=³9\52< U =XD Ç>Ŧq 9\=XD Ä>Î#q an<\5�7C[X3%7C<\f Ç>Å 523B7C52.13�c>36DÙDX< ]6U W 36=�7C0 � Í U ����$¹¾¯ L �#� N®a U 527C[�365/DX3 W <\=X02745C9;7436D{7C[X9;7/l U 3B5 F 3Úµ^fg9\=X02.1<>= ] 9;=»5436D UX] 3�74[X3�fX523 ] .Y04.Y<>={_1<\040�an<\504369\5 ] [�.1=Xp'74[X3¶7C<\f z}Ŧq <\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=@7C< z}Ŧq'�¸E U 7�.¾7/.10�fg9\.YD E�F 7C[�3¶7C. W 3kan<>5/l U 3B5 F 3Úµ ½fg9\=�04.1<\= Ô 3Úµ�3 ]6U 74.1=Xp�9\='<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_Xl U 3B5 F 9;=XD%9\=g9;_ F ¿ .Y=Xpq74[X3�74<>f«DX< ]6U W 3B=�740 Õ 9;=XD«7C[�3�7C. W 37C<@fX52< ] 36020¶9;7k_Y3�9\087 Ä\Å 9\DXDX.¾7C.1<\=g9\_ Ä;Å 74365 W 0�<>5�f�[X5C9\02360�9\DXDX3BD E�F l U 3B5 F 3�µ^fg9;=X04.Y<>= an<\53�9 ] [�l U 3B5 F �� 3%DX3 W <>=X087C5C9�7C3%7C[X3%fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3%. W fX54<}c\3 W 36=�7C0ZD U 3@74< ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�an<>5 Ä>Î;ÆO � <;a�DX9;7:9%DX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D»<}c\365 Ì 043658c>3B540 � � 3Zc^.Y3B�-7C[X3�Dg9�7:9'<>="3�9 ] [�023652c\365�9\0k9%04.Y=Xp>_13] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � . � 3 � �^Ì ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0º.1=�7C<\7C9\_ � s 9 E _13 Æ � Ë�_1.Y027C0A74[X3�fi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3/<\a ] < W�W 9;=XDX0A7C[g9�7p><»7C<»74[X3 W <\027Zan543Bl U 36=�7C_ F U 0236D ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= E 9\0236D³<>=�7C[X3 G .1f^a ½ _1.Y´\3©DX.1087C54. E U 74.1<>=��y[�36=

I�13KM1�/�6YM;�b��¼132�/�1�b�6�($N�1ö g j hkw�} j w�} w m }g ' ^ b YZ8:;�2<�* g j hkw�} j w�h m } w m h m }m h t j l h m } l�i0h m } | x h m }m h m ')4 ^ 251 õ Yp4�8�* t�w�h m } x m h m } y | h m }í Þ��! nà �Iÿ��Sÿ s [X3»fi365 ] 3B=�7C9\p>3»<\a ] < W©W 9\=XD�0«7C[g9�7'p><V360'74<�7C[X3 W <>087'an543Bl U 36=�7C_ F U 0236D] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=

zÂÄ\|

Page 146: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

��3�c;9\5 F 74[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�9 ]6] 3B040/02´\3��-an52< W 9\= U =X.Yan<\5 W 7C<«9�f U 543 G .1f�a¢a U = ] 74.1<>= � 9;=XD)7C[�3043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�fi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3'an54< W zÂÄ � Î#q 7C< Î\Å#q � w .Yp U 523 Æ � z}Ç .1_Y_ U 087C549;7C3B0q74[X3 ] <>52543B04fi<>=XDX.Y=Xp9�c>3B5C9\p>3�l U 365 F 523602f¸<>=�043�74. W 3{c>3B540 U 0)7C[X3 ] < W©W 9\=XD�9\5452.Yc;9\_/549;7C3 543B0 U _¾7C.Y=Xp³an52< W < U 504. W U _19;7C<>5 �w .Yp U 543 Æ � z}Ç Ô 9 Õ .1_1_ U 02745C9;74360m7C[�3¶0 ] 36=g9;54.1<\0��y[X3B543¶74[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0�9;543 U =X.Yan<>5 W _ F 9 ]B] 3602043BD �T 3B_13 ] 7C.Y=Xp zÂÄ � Î#q <\aS7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0¹.10o.Y=X043B=X04.¾7C.Yc\3�7C<�74[X3 ] < W©W 9\=XD�0o9\5254.Yc;9\_i5C9�7C3�74[g9;7o��3] <\=X04.YDX365/.Y=)7C[�.10�3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�7Q{`0436_Y3 ] 7C.1=�p Ä>Î#q <\aA7C[�3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0K.1= ] 54369\043B0/7C[X3 ] < W�W 9\=�D9\5254.Yc;9\_®5C9;743��y.¾7C[�9@543B04fi<>=X023©7C. W 3 E 36_Y<Â� Î 023 ] <\=XDX0 E�F 9�a¦9 ] 7C<\5q<;aoË � Å {e0236_13 ] 74.1=Xp Î\Ŧq<\ae74[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0�.Y= ] 523�9\02360K7C[X3 ] < W�W 9\=�D)9\5254.¾c\9;_b549;7C3k�y.Y74[»9©523602f¸<>=�043¶74. W 3 E 36_Y<Â� z}Å043 ] <>=�DX0 E�F 9'a¦9 ] 74<>5/<\a Ä � z � s [X36023�= U W�E 3B540k9\523 ] <>=�04.1087C3B=�7��y.¾7C[»< U 5�fX543BDX. ] 7C.1<\= E 9\0236D<>=%7C[�3kjX54027�54<}�!.1= s 9 E _13 Æ � Ë �ºÌ Ô z}È^zÂÄ � Î#q Õ � Ë Ô zÂÈ>Ä>Î � Ŧq Õ �gÄ Ô zÂÈ>Î\Å � Ŧq Õ �w .Yp U 543 Æ � z}Ç Ô E Õ .Y_1_ U 027C549;7C3B0b74[X3o0 ] 36=X9\54.Y<>0®�y[X3B543t74[X3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=¶9 ]6] 36040A02´\3��Ùan<>_Y_1<}�y0e9 G .1f�a ½_1.Y´\3kDX.Y027C52. E U 7C.1<\='�y.Y7C[ � � Å � Ç �oT 36_Y3 ] 7C.1=�p zÂÄ � Î#q <;a®7C[�3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0m.10y.1=X0236=X02.Y74.Yc>3�74<©7C[�3] < W©W 9\=XDX0k9;5454.¾c;9\_®549;7C3�74[g9;7k�t3 ] <>=X04.YDX365k.Y="74[X.10�3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�7Q{¢0236_13 ] 74.1=Xp Ä>Î#q 9\=XD Î\Ŧq<\a¹7C[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0/. W fX54<}c\3�7C[X3 ] < W©W 9\=XD 9\5254.Yc;9\_¢5C9;743��y.Y74[�9%543B04fi<>=X023�74. W 3 E 3B_1<}� z}Å043 ] <>=�DX0 E�F 9%a¦9 ] 7C<\5/<\a Ä � z 9;=XD z � Ç^� 543602f¸3 ] 74.Yc>3B_ F � s [X36023©= U W¶E 3B540q9\543 ] <>=X02.1087C36=�7k�y.Y74[< U 5�fX543BDX. ] 7C.1<\= E 9\043BD"<>={7C[X3Z023 ] <>=XD 54<}�ö.Y= s 9 E _13 Æ � Ë � Ë � Å Ô zÂÈ\Ä Ë � Ŧq Õ �SÄ � Å Ô z}È Ë | � Ŧq Õ �9\=XD z � Ç Ô zÂÈ � Æ � Å#q Õ �w .Yp U 543 Æ � z}Ç Ô ] Õ .1_Y_ U 087C5C9�7C360�74[X3«0 ] 36=X9\54.Y<>0q�y[�36543©7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= 9 ]6] 36040¶04´\3��Êan<>_1_Y<Â�y0k7C[�3f U 523 G .1f�akD�.1027454. E U 7C.Y<>= � T 3B_13 ] 7C.Y=Xp zÂÄ � Î#q <\ak7C[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0«.1= ] 54369\043B0'7C[X3 ] < W�W 9\=�D9\5254.Yc;9\_�5C9;743K�y.¾7C[©9�543B04fi<>=X023 U =XD�365 Î 043 ] <>=�DX0 E�F 9qa¦9 ] 7C<>5º<\a Ç � z>� 9\=XD«0236_Y3 ] 74.1=Xp Ä>Î#q 9;=XDÎ\Ŧq <\aS7C[�3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0¹. W fX54<}c>3�7C[X3 ] < W©W 9\=XD'9\5452.Yc;9\_i5C9;743��y.Y74[@9�543602f¸<\=X043�7C. W 3 E 3B_1<}�z}Å 043 ] <>=�DX0 E�F 9�a¦9 ] 74<>5A<\a z � Ì 9;=XD z � Ä^� 523602f¸3 ] 7C.¾c>3B_ F � s [�36043K= U W�E 36520t9\523 ] <>=X02.1087C36=�7º�y.Y74[< U 5�fX543BDX. ] 7C.Y<>= E 9;0436D%<\=«7C[X3�7C[X.Y54D«52<}��.Y= s 9 E _Y3 Æ � Ë �ºÄ � | Ô zÂÈ\Ç�Î � Ŧq Õ �iz ��� Ô z}È\Æ>Å � Ŧq Õ ��z � zÔ z}È\Ì �^� Ŧq Õ �s [X3B043�543B0 U _¾7C0�DX3 W <>=�027C549;7C3�7C[g9;7�7C[X3Zfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3¶. W fX52<Âc\3 W 36=�7C0�D U 3�7C< ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\={043 ½_13 ] 74.1<>=)9\543�9©a U = ] 7C.Y<>=)<\aA74[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=)9 ]B] 3B040/02´\3B�ö9\=XD�7C[X3�f¸3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3¶<\a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0

z}Ç>Å

Page 147: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

F $ %(' ç ),+#- æ -.)A/ ��1(2,354 ç % \ c ` 1@4 c ���1�ì�5kí!î �>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ï�â ü �©ÿ©ú ��� ù ��1�ì�5kí!î ��1�ì�5kí!î

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

No SelectionSelection (top 12.5%)

Selection (top 25%)Selection (top 50%)

å{1�èF-�ëP5 rpà©ì�7QåX� p� è ü

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

No SelectionSelection (top 12.5%)

Selection (top 25%)Selection (top 50%)

åMïfèji[5kêhr}|�ã656O©í åX� \þ�S � è ü

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

No SelectionSelection (top 12.5%)

Selection (top 25%)Selection (top 50%)

åMáè�êP-�ìÔí*i^5kêhr�åX� \þ è üõ ò ß�%SýÂà �Iÿ¦þ`�Iÿ ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3/�y.Y74[ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=«0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>='an<\5 Ä>Î\Æ O � <\abDg9;7C9¶<>= Ì 043B52c\36540 �

z}�z

Page 148: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

F $&%(' ç*),+#- æ -.)A/ ��1(2,3C4 ç % \ c ` 1(4 c ���1�ì�5kí!î �>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ï�â ü �©ÿ©úG��� ��1�ì�5kí!î �©ÿ V ��1�ì�5kí!î

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20A

vera

ge Q

uery

Res

pons

e T

ime

(Sec

onds

)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

No SelectionSelection (8,Zipf)

Selection (8,uniform)Selection (32,Zipf)

Selection (32,uniform)

õ ò ß�%býÂà �Iÿ¦þ¦�bÿ Ñ 9\5 F .1=�p�74[X3k= U W�E 365y<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0tan<>5 Ä\Î\Æ O � <\a¢Dg9;7C9�<\= Ì 043B52c\36540 �

E 36.1=�p ] [X<>0236= � [X.Yp>[X3B5 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�9 ]6] 3B040@04´;3B� 9\=XD È <\5 W <\543 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0 E 36.Y=Xp ] [X<>0236=fX52<^D U�] 3k0 W 9\_1_Y365ofi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�. W fX54<}c\3 W 36=�7C0

�IÿT�`ÿT� � Þ�ý h ò a ß�ü ú à ä %!fÃ�Aà�ý d c�ând _ nà i ü ò d�a gJ =�74[X.10y023 ] 74.1<>= � ��3¶087C.Y_1_ U 023 Ì 043B52c>3B540 �ÖE U 7K��3�DX.¾cV.1DX3�7C[�3�Dg9�7:9©.Y=�7C< Ç�Ä ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 � 9;=XD3�9 ] [³023658c>365Z[�<>_1DX0¶Ë ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 � � 3 ] < W fg9\543�7C[X3«f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3'<\am74[X.10 ] <>=�jXp U 5C9�7C.1<\=�y.Y74[%7C[X3k<>=X3 U 0236D�.1= T 3 ] 7C.Y<>= Æ � Ç � z Ô Ì ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0 Õ �w .Yp U 543 Æ � z Ë�.Y_1_ U 02745C9;74360�74[X3�9�c>36549\p>3�l U 365 F 543B04fi<>=X043Z74. W 3¶c>3B540 U 0�7C[�3 ] < W�W 9;=XD"9\5452.Yc;9\_5C9�7C3��y[X3B= ��3Z043B_13 ] 7k7C[X3�74<>f Ä>Î#q <\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 � � [X3B= 74[X3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0�9\543 U =X.Yan<>5 W _ F9 ]B] 3602043BD �`Ì ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0K9\=XD Ç>Ä ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0yfX52360236=�7�04. W .Y_h9\5tf¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 � u 36D UX] .Y=Xp«7C[�3043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>={fi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3 E�F 9«[g9\_¾aADX< U E _1360K7C[X3�_h9\52p>36087 ] < W©W 9\=XD)9\5452.Yc;9\_`549;7C3q�y.Y7C[{9\=»9�c ½36549\p>3�l U 365 F 523602f¸<>=�043«74. W 3 U =XDX3B5�9 ] 36587:9\.Y= ]BU 7C<\Ø � � [X3B=�7C[�3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= 9 ]B] 3B040�02´\3B�an<>_Y_1<}�y0¹74[X3/f U 543 G .1f^a`DX.1087C52. E U 74.1<>= � an3��t3B5 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0¹f¸3B52an<>5 WÛE 3B727C3B5 ��E 3 ] 9 U 023/7C[X3 W <>027an543Bl U 36=�7C_ F U 0236D ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=©.10 ] [�<>043B=��y.¾7C[%9�_Y<Â��365tfX54< E 9 E .1_Y.Y7 F �y[X3B=@0436_Y3 ] 7C.1=�pZ9�0 W 9\_1_Y365= U W�E 365º<\a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 � w <>5A0236_Y3 ] 74.1=Xp/74[X3 Ä>Î#q <\a Ì ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0A9 ]B] <>52DX.1=Xp�74</7C[X3 G .1f^a¸D�.10 ½7C52. E U 7C.1<\= �VÆ>Ŧq <\a ] < W�W 9\=�DX0�p\<�7C<�7C[X3 W <>087�an5236l U 3B=�74_ F U 043BD ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 � w <>5º043B_13 ] 7C.Y=Xp7C[�3 Ä\Î#q <\a Ç�Ä ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0o9 ]6] <>54DX.Y=Xp�7C<Z74[X3 G .1f�abDX.Y027C52. E U 7C.1<\= �X|>Å#q <\a ] < W�W 9\=XDX0op\<�74<7C[�3 W <>087man5436l U 3B=�7C_ F U 0436D ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 �

z}Ç�Ä

Page 149: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

� ^ 1325� � ;�KMKp1P/©6YM;�b\G{/�/�1P77�I�r�13q � ~ ^ <ÀUn132�;�8VI�1�Kp1P/©651�` � ;�KMKp1P/©65Yp;�b 7� ;�/3(�KpYp6!� ��;fq � I�<a(�KpK � ;fq � �×($25N�1 A�YMN�> � I�<e($KMK A�YMN�> � ��($25N�1� ;fq � ;�K h I�1�K �V($26 h �B1340KA�YMN�> � ;�K h I�13K �V($26 h �B134 K hõ ò ß�%Sý�à �Iÿøþ`�Iÿ r <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>='043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%c>3B540 U 0�fg9\587C.19\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=%5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= �

�IÿT�`ÿT� â�d _ ¦à i ü ò d�a�î à` ¦à i ü ò d�a�� à�ýlgk%!gZÝ/Þ�ýÂü ò Þ� ând _ nà i ü ò d�a�ñ à�ûF ò_i Þ�ü ò d�a� <\74[ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= 043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�9\=�D�fg9\587C.h9;_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=�_Y3B7 U 0¶023�9\5 ] [9)0 U E 043�7Z<\aDg9;7C9 � w <>5 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=·0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � 7C[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=·9 ]B] 3B040%04´;3B� 9;a�7C3B5 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=³043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=9\=XD�7C[X3K= U W�E 365¹<\aI0236_Y3 ] 7436D ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0º9;ظ3 ] 7¹7C[�3�0 F 087C3 W fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 � s [X3K= U W�E 365¹<\a043B_13 ] 7C3BD ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0¢9\_102<�9;ظ3 ] 740e7C[X3m523B7454.13�c;9\_�9 ]6]6U 5C9 ] F <\a�7C[�3o0 F 02743 W � M U 5 ]BU 545236=�7A7C3 ] [ ½=X.Yl U 360e<>=�_ F p U 9\549\=�7C3B3t7C[g9�7e043B_13 ] 7C.Y=Xp/[g9;_Yag7C[�3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0¢9 ] [X.Y3Bc>3B0º9 ]6]BU 5C9 ] F ] < W fg9\549 E _137C<q04369\5 ] [�.1=Xp�9\_1_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0e�y[X3B=©��3�DX<q=X<\7�9\fXf�_ F l U 3B5 F 3�µ^fg9;=X04.Y<>= � J =�7C[X.Y0 ] 9\043 � �y[�36=7C[�3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�9 ]6] 36040¹.10A[�.1p>[X_ F 02´\3B��36D Ô an<>_Y_1<}�y.1=Xp�7C[X3Kf U 523 G .Yf�aiDX.1087C52. E U 74.1<>= Õ � ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= ] <>=�7C52. E U 74360�_1.Y727C_Y3�7C<). W f�54<}cV.1=Xp@0 F 087C3 W fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3 � w <>5�fX9\5274.h9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= � 74[X3�fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3�. W fX54<}c>3 W 3B=�7m.10�_1. W .Y7436D E�F l U 365 F _1< ] 9;_1.Y7 F � J ab7C[�36543�.10o=X<;736=�< U p>[%l U 3B5 F _Y< ] 9\_1.¾7 F .1=%9�0 F 087C3 W�� fX9\5274.h9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=«5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=«.Y0 U 0236_13B040 � s [X3B543�an<>543 �3�9 ] [�<\aº74[X36023�7É��<%7C3 ] [�=X.1l U 3B0�fi3658an<>5 W 0���36_1_A.Y=»DX.Yظ365236=�7 ] .Y5 ]BU W 087:9\= ] 360 � 9\0�.1_Y_ U 087C5C9�7C36D.1= w .Yp U 523 Æ � zÂÎ �+�0K9\=�3�µ�9 W fX_Y3 � w .Yp U 543 Æ � z}Æ ] < W fX9\543B0 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=%0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=��y.¾7C[@fg9\587C.h9;_I543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=«an<\5Ä>Î\Æ O � <\atDg9;7:9 U 02.1=Xp Ì 023652c\36520 � w <\5 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= 0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � ��3«DX.Y027454. E U 7C3Z7C[�3 Ä>Î;Æ O �Dg9;7C9/<}c>365 Ì ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0 � 369 ] [�<\a��y[X. ] [�523604.YDX360A<\=Z<>=X3m043B52c\365 � w <>5¢fg9\587C.h9;_^5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\= � ��3U 023 � 043B52c\36540K7C<�0274<>543�74[X3 Ä>Î\Æ O � Dg9�7:9 � 9;=XD E U .1_YD@9 Ç>Ä O � 5436f�_1. ] 9�<>=%7C[X3 Ì 74[�023658c>365 �w .Yp U 543 Æ � z}Æ Ô 9 Õ .1_Y_ U 087C549;7C3B0�7C[�3/0 ] 36=g9\52.1<>0o�y[�36543 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0o9\523 U =X.¾an<>5 W _ F 9 ]6] 3B040236D�9;a�7C3B5] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � �y[�. ] [!.Y0%7C[X3 E 3B027 ] 9\023 �×T 3B_13 ] 7C.Y=Xp7C[X3"7C<>f Î\Ŧq <;a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0fX5236043B=�7C0q04. W .1_19\5Kf¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3¶74< U 04.1=�p�<\=X3Z543BfX_1. ] 9©�y[X3B=�74[X3Z543BfX_1. ] 9'DX.Y027C549 ] 740�Ë Å¦q <\a] < W©W 9\=XDX0 �yT 3B_13 ] 7C.Y=Xp©74[X3q74<>f Ä\Î#q <\aefi3658an<>5 W 0K04.1p\=X.Yj ] 9\=�7C_ F%E 3�7474365y7C[g9\=)9\_1_I74[X3 ] 9\043B0<\a¢fg9\587C.h9;_Ö543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>='��3 ] <>=�04.1D�365y.1=%7C[�.10m3�µ^fi3652. W 36=�7 �

z}Ç>Ç

Page 150: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

F $ %@' ç ),+#- æ -.)A/ ��1(2,354 ç % \ c ` 1(4 c ���1�ì�5kí!î �>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ï�â ü �©ÿ©ú ��� ��1�ì�5kí�î ��1�ì�5kí!î ��1�ì�5kí!î

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

No SelectionSelection (uniform,25%)Selection (uniform,50%)

Partial Replication (1 replica, 20%)Partial Replication (1 replica, 40%)Partial Replication (1 replica, 60%)

åp1�è-�ëP5 rpà©ì�7 ü

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

No SelectionSelection (Zipf-like(0.3),25%)Selection (Zipf-like(0.3),50%)

Partial Replication (1 replica, 20%)Partial Replication (1 replica, 40%)Partial Replication (1 replica, 60%)

åpï$è�i^5kêhr!|Áã656O©í�IN5 8�Ak� \þ�S �Pü

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

No SelectionSelection (Zipf,25%)Selection (Zipf,50%)

Partial Replication (1 replica, 20%)Partial Replication (1 replica, 40%)Partial Replication (1 replica, 60%)

åpáè êh-�ìÔíli[5kêhr üõ ò ß�%SýÂà �`ÿ¦þ`�Iÿ r <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=«0236_13 ] 74.1<>='c\36540 U 0yfg9\587C.h9;_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=�an<>5 Ä\Î\Æ O � <>=Ì 043B52c>3B540 �

z}Ç Ë

Page 151: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

w .Yp U 543 Æ � z}Æ Ô E Õ .Y_1_ U 027C549;7C3B0t7C[�3q0 ] 3B=g9\54.Y<>0m�y[X36523q74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=@9 ]B] 36020�an<>_Y_1<}�y0m9 G .1f^a ½ _1.Y´\3DX.Y027C52. E U 7C.1<\=)�y.Y74[ � � Å � Ç 9;a�7C3B5 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>={0236_13 ] 74.1<>= �ZT 36_Y3 ] 74.1=Xp%74[X3�7C<>f Î\Å#q f¸3B52an<>5 W 0��<>54023«7C[g9;=�9\_1_A74[X3 ] 9\043B0�<\amfg9;527C.19\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>="543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>="�t3 ] <>=X02.1DX3B5¶.Y=�7C[�.10q3�µ^f¸3B54. ½W 36=�7C0 �tT 36_13 ] 74.1=XpZ7C[�3k74<>f Ä>Î#q fi3658an<>5 W 0 E 3B7474365m7C[X9\=�9\_1_Ö74[X36023 ] 9\043B0 �w .Yp U 543 Æ � z}Æ Ô ] Õ .Y_1_ U 02745C9;74360Ö74[X3º0 ] 3B=g9\52.1<>0S�y[X36523¹74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=k9 ]B] 36020ban<\_1_1<}�y0I74[X3ºf U 543 G .Yf�aDX.Y027C52. E U 7C.1<\=�9�a�7C365 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>="043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �@T 36_13 ] 74.1=Xp�7C[X3�7C<>f Ä>Î#q <\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0kfX5236043B=�7C004. W .Y_h9\5¢f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3m7C<�fg9\587C.h9;_X543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= U 02.1=Xp�<>=X3y543BfX_1. ] 9��y[X36=�7C[X3K543BfX_1. ] 9kDX.1087C549 ] 740Ë Å¦q <\a ] < W�W 9\=XDX0 �AT 3B_13 ] 7C.Y=Xp�7C[X3o74<>f Î\Ŧq <;aÖfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3of¸3B52an<>5 W 0e��<>52043m7C[g9;=�fX9\5274.h9\_543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= �s [X3y9 E <}c>3o52360 U _Y740e0 U p\p>36087A7C[g9;7 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=Zfi3658an<>5 W 0 E 3B727C3B5®7C[g9;=Zfg9\5274.h9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ]�½7C.Y<>=%543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>='�y[�36=�36.Y74[X365m74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%9 ]B] 36020�.Y0ma¦9\.152_ F U =X.¾an<>5 W <>5y9Z0 W 9\_1_I= U W¶E 3B5<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0�9\523�0 U À ] .Y36=�7«74< W 9\.1=�7C9\.1=�523B7C52.13�c\9;_y9 ]6]BU 5C9 ] F � J =³fX549 ] 74. ] 3 �oE 3 ] 9 U 043�<\a_1< ] 9;_1.Y7 F\� U =�.Yan<>5 W 9 ]6] 36020�.Y0 U =X_1.Y´\36_ F 74< E 3y543�9;_1. ¿ 36DI{�74[X3 ]6U 525436=�7�7C3 ] [�=X.1l U 3B0¹an<>5 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>='5236l U .1523�74<�043B_13 ] 7 Î\Ŧq <\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0ºan<>5t023�9\5 ] [@9;7m9�74. W 3�.Y=«<>52DX365�7C< W 9\.Y=�7C9\.1=7C[�3)543�7C52.13Bc;9\_K9 ]B]6U 549 ] F � J = ] <>=�7C5C9;027 � ��3)jg=�D�[X.1p\[·l U 365 F _Y< ] 9\_1.¾7 F .Y=·54369\_ JLu 0 F 087C3 W_1<\p>0 Ô 7 F fX. ] 9\_1_ F�Ç>Ŧq ½ Ë Å#q .1= syH�M d�+ T 9\=XD{Ãeµ ] .Y7C3¶_1<>p>0 Õ � +�_1_`74[X36023�.1=XD�. ] 9�7C3�74[g9;7�fg9\5 ½7C.19\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>=�f¸3B52an<>5 W 0 E 3�747C3B5�7C[X9\= ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= U 02.1=Xp«74[X3 ]BU 545236=�77C3 ] [X=X.Yl U 360 �

�IÿT�`ÿr� î %�f-f�ÞXý hJ =�7C[�.10'023 ] 74.1<>= � ��3»DX3 W <>=�027C549;7C3BD�7C[X3{fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3{<\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=Ù043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�.1=�9�D�.10 ½7C52. E U 7C36D.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=�543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_t0 F 027C3 W�� 9\=XD ] < W fg9;5436D�74[X3@f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3'<;a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>="�y.Y7C["fg9;527C.19\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=»5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= � s [X3�f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3Z. W fX52<}c>3 W 36=�740�D U 3�74<] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>={0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>="9;543�DX3�7C3B5 W .1=X3BD E�F 7C[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>={9 ]6] 36040k02´\3B�Ó9\=XD{7C[�3Z= U W�E 3B5�<\a043B_13 ] 7C3BD ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 � ú9 ] [%<\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%9\=�D'fg9\587C.h9;_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=©5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\= ] 9\=fi3652an<\5 W�E 3B727C365S7C[X9\=�74[X3�<;7C[X3B5 U =XDX365¢DX.Yظ365236=�7b04.¾7 U 9;74.1<>=�0 � r <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�f¸3B52an<>5 W 004.Yp>=X.¾j ] 9\=�74_ F%E 3B727C365y�y[X3B=»36.Y74[X365 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�9 ]B] 3B040/.Y0Ka¦9\.Y54_ F U =X.¾an<>5 W <>5�9�0 W 9\_1_`= U W¶E 3B5

z}Ç�Î

Page 152: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

<\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0�9\523¶0 U À ] .13B=�7/7C< W 9\.Y=�7C9\.1=@7C[�3�543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_b9 ]B]6U 549 ] F � H <}�t3�c>3B5 � .1=)fX5C9 ] 7C. ] 3 �=X3B.Y7C[�365'<\ak74[X36023"7É��< ] <>=�DX.Y74.1<>=X0«.10«_Y.1´;36_ F 7C<�049;7C.Y02a FÙE�F U 02.1=Xp�7C[�3 ]6U 52543B=�7 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%7C3 ] [X=X.1l U 3B0 �

¡})_| �[Z68 8\<K0�]J =�74[X.10 ] [g9\f^7C365 � ��3'3�µ^fX_Y<>543BD�[X<}� E 36027�7C< E U .1_YD�9@fg9\549\_1_Y36_ JLu 043B52c\365¶�y.¾7C[�523602f¸3 ] 7¶74<7C[�3q= U W¶E 3B5K<;a®7C[�543�9;DX0 � r ? R 0 � 9;=XD�D�.104´�0 � 3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C3BD�74[X3kf¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3k<\a®9�D�.1027454. E U 7C3BDJLu 0 F 02743 W�� 9\=XD'D�3 W <>=X02745C9;7436D'74[X3�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�. W fX52<Âc\3 W 36=�7oD U 3�7C<¶fg9\5274.h9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>='9\=XD ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �M U 5«52360 U _Y740'04[X<}� 7C[g9�7'<>=�9�fX9\5C9\_Y_13B_K023658c>365 � 74[X3{=X3 ] 3B040C9;5 F = U W�E 365«<\a�7C[X523�9\D�0«7C[g9�7_1369\DX0K7C[X3�0 F 027C3 W 74<'.Y740�fi3�9\´@fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3�.10�DX.1523 ] 74_ F 543B_h9;7436D)74<©74[X3�= U W�E 365/<;a r ? R 09\=XDDX.Y04´�0 � s [�3�02. ¿ 3%<\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�[g9\0Zc>3B5 F _Y.Y727C_13©3Bظ3 ] 7©<\=74[X3%=X3 ] 36020C9\5 F = U W�E 3B5Z<\a7C[�543�9;DX0 � M =·9»fg9;5C9\_Y_136_�043B52c>3B5 � 9;DXDX.1=�p [X9\54D��t9\523 ] < W f¸<>=�36=�7C0�04.Yp>=X.¾j ] 9\=�74_ F . W f�54<}c>3B0fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3�<>=X_ F �y[X3B=@74[X3 F 9\543���36_Y_ ½ E 9\_h9;= ] 3BD � M 7C[X3B52�y.Y043 � 9\DXDX.Y=XpZDX.102´�0 ] 9\=%DX3Bp>5C9;DX37C[�3qfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3��y[X36=�7C[X3 r ? R .Y0K9 E <\7474_13B=X3 ] ´ � 9\=XD)9\DXDX.Y=Xp r ? R 0KDX<^3B0y=X<\7K. W fX54<}c\37C[�3Zf¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3¶�y[X3B= 74[X3ZDX.Y04´).Y0�9 E <\7474_136=�3 ] ´ � � 3ZfX543B043B=�7436D�043Bc\36549\_ean<>5 W U _h9\0K7C[g9�7U 023�02. W fX_13 W 369\0 U 523 W 36=�7C0�74<�3B0274. W 9;7C3�74[X3�=X3 ] 3604049\5 F = U W�E 365�<;a�74[X54369\DX0 � 7C[�3�= U W¶E 3B5<\a r ? R 0�9\=XD�DX.102´V0m74[g9;7 ] <\=X0274.Y7 U 7C3q9��t3B_1_ ½ E 9\_19\= ] 3BD@0 F 02743 W �J =%9¶fX9\5C9\_Y_13B_ JLu 023658c>365m<\5t9¶D�.1027454. E U 7C3BD JLu 0 F 02743 W�� �y[X3B='�t3�[g9�c>3�9\D�DX.Y74.1<>=g9;_g[g9\54D^�o9\523543B04< U 5 ] 3B0 � 0 U�] [�9\0/9\= 9\DXDX.¾7C.1<\=g9\_SDX.102´�<\5�9\= 9\DXDX.¾7C.Y<>=g9\_S043B52c\365 � U 02.1=Xp@9;DXDX.Y74.1<>=X9\_S[g9\54D ½�t9\543 ] < W f¸<>=�36=�7C0«74< E U .Y_1DÙ5436f�_1. ] 9\0«f�54<VD UX] 3B0%04.Yp>=X.Yj ] 9\=�7C_ FE 3�7474365'fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�7C[X9\=fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=XpK�y[X36=�7C[X3B543y.10 W <VDX36087ºl U 365 F _1< ] 9\_Y.Y7 F � s [X3K. W fX52<Âc\3 W 36=�7C0A< ]6]BU 5º3Bc\36=©�y[�36=7C[�3q5236fX_Y. ] 9�0C9;74.102jX360�9\0oan3B�v9;0 z}Ŧq <\a¢l U 3652.13B0 �r <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�9\_Y04<�. W f�54<}c>3B0©fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 �oE U 7'.Y740©. W f�54<}c>3 W 3B=�7©.10�_1. W .¾7C3BD E�F7C[�3Zf¸<>f U _h9\52.Y7 F <\aº7C[X3 W <>027�an5436l U 3B=�7C_ F U 043BD ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>={9;a�7C3B5 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>={043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � s [X3] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=k9 ]B] 3B040®02´\3��·9;=XDq74[X3¹= U W�E 3B5S<\aX0236_13 ] 7436D ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0S9\543A7É��<�a¦9 ] 7C<>520b74[g9;7¢9;ظ3 ] 77C[�3Zf¸<>f U _h9\52.Y7 F <\a¹7C[X3 W <>027�an5236l U 3B=�74_ F U 0436D ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= � r <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>={043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>="f¸3B52an<>5 W 0

z}Ç>Æ

Page 153: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

04.Yp>=X.¾j ] 9\=�74_ F�E 3�747C3B5Z7C[g9\=³fg9\587C.19\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=��y[X3B=Ù7C[�3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�9 ]6] 36020©.Y0a¦9\.Y54_ F U =X.Yan<\5 W <>5�9¶0 W 9\_1_�= U W�E 365�<\a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0¹9\523�0 U À ] .13B=�7m7C< W 9\.Y=�7C9\.1=�7C[�3�543�7C52.13Bc;9\_9 ]B]6U 549 ] F � ?®9\587C.h9;_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=¶5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>=¶fi3658an<>5 W 0 E 3B727C365e74[g9\= ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=��y[�36=7C[�3Zl U 365 F _1< ] 9\_Y.Y7 F .10�[X.1p>[ � J ="fX549 ] 74. ] 3 � fg9\587C.19\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=)543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=)f¸3B52an<>5 W 0 E 3B727C3B57C[X9\= ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\='043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= U 04.Y=Xp�74[X3 ]6U 52543B=�7y743 ] [X=X.Yl U 360 �

z}Ç �

Page 154: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

���v�'&����)� ¥� $�± ��� �K�{����������&ö² � ���)�����ÎÖ���� $Ù# ���Km��

J =)74[X.10 ] [g9\f�74365 � ��3�fX543B043B=�7/3�µ^f¸3B54. W 3B=�740�an<>5K04369\5 ] [�.1=Xp%9�7C36549 E�F 7C3�<\a®7C3�µV7�<>={9 ] _ U 087C3B5<\aK0 FVW�W 3�7C52. ] W U _Y7C.YfX54< ] 3B0402<>540 U 04.1=�p{7C[X3@9\5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 52360�.1_Y_ U 087C5C9�7C36D�.1= r [g9\f^7C365 Ç � � 3jg52027k36087C. W 9;743�7C[X3Z02. ¿ 360k<\a¹543BfX_1. ] 9\0 � 7C[X3�5236fX_Y. ] 9©0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= DX9;7:9 E 9\043 � 9;=XD»7C[X3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�Dg9�7:9 E 9;043'.Y= T 3 ] 7C.Y<>= �^� z � � 3«7C[X3B=�DX3 W <>=X087C549;7C3«74[X3'fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3«an<>5¶02[X<>587l U 3652.13B0��y.Y74[)9;={9�c>3B5C9\p>3q<\a Ä 7C3B5 W 0�fi365Kl U 365 F�E�F U 02.1=Xp Ç�Ä 043B52c>3B540 �`Ì 023658c>36520 E U 7K�y.Y74[_h9;54p>3B5�D�.104´�0 � 9\=XD Ì a¦9\0274365�043B52c>3B540%.Y= T 3 ] 74.1<>= �^� ÄV� T 3 ] 7C.Y<>= �^� Ç�� 9;=XD T 3 ] 74.1<>= �^� Ë � +o7_h9;027 � �t3kDX3 W <\=X02745C9;743/7C[X3kfi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3�an<>5m_1<>=�p>365�l U 3654.Y360m�y.Y74[�9\=�9}c\36549\p>3 Ì 7C3B5 W 0mf¸3B5l U 365 F � s 9 E _Y3 �^� z f�54360236=�7C0�fg9\549 W 3�7C3B540 � 9;=XD»7C[X3B.15�9 E�E 543�c^.19;7C.Y<>=X0k9\=�D"c;9\_ U 360/��3 U 043�.Y=7C[�3q3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�740K<;a¢74[X.10 ] [g9\f^7C365 �M U 5b54360 U _Y740®02[X<}�³74[g9;7®9�5236fX_Y. ] 9m�y.Y74[ Ç�Ä O � .10S0 U À ] .13B=�7®7C<�087C<>523�74[X3¹74<>f Ä\Å\Å DX< ]6U W 3B=�740<\am74[X3©74<>f�7C<\fX. ] 0�7C[X9;7�049;7C.Y02a F 9\54< U =XD�Ë Å#q <;aml U 3652.1360 E 9\043BD�<>=�74[X3%îµ ] .Y743«_Y<>p � M U 5543B0 U _¾7C0k04[�<Â�Ó74[g9;7 U 02.1=Xp�<>=X3�5236fX_Y. ] 9'74<�DX.Y02745C9 ] 7 Ä\Ŧq 9\=�D U 02.1=Xp Ä 543BfX_1. ] 9\0�7C<@DX.Y02745C9 ] 7Ë Å¦q 9;=XD Æ>Å#q <\a ] < W�W 9\=�DX0�. W f�54<}c>3B0¹74[X3�_19\54p\36027 ] < W©W 9\=XD�9\5254.¾c\9;_g5C9;743 U =�DX365�9 ]BU 7C<\Øan<>5q7C[X3%9�c\365C9;p>3'l U 365 F 523604fi<>=X023'7C. W 3 E�F 9�a¦9 ] 7C<>5�<\a z � Ç��ºÄ � Ä^� 9;=XD Ç � Î �"T 3B_13 ] 7C.Y=Xp)7C[�37C<\f Ä>Î#q <\a Ì ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0º. W fX52<Âc\360º7C[X3�_h9\52p>36087 ] < W�W 9\=�D'9\5254.Yc;9\_g549;7C3 U =XDX3B5o9 ]BU 7C<;Ø�an<\57C[�3�9}c\36549\p>3Zl U 365 F 543B04fi<>=X023�74. W 3 E�F 9«a¦9 ] 7C<\5/<\a z � Ì �y[X36="7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>={04´;3B� an<>_1_Y<Â�y07C[�3 G .1f^aeDX.Y027C52. E U 7C.1<\= � M U 5�52360 U _Y7C0�9\_102<«02[X<}�-74[g9;7�9\_Y74[X< U p\[ U 02.1=Xp�an3B��365/_19\54p>3q043B52c\36540 �04fi363BDX.1=�p U f�043B52c>3B540 � 9\=XD U 04.Y=Xp�_1<>=Xp\365ml U 3652.13B0/9;ظ3 ] 7K74[X3q543602f¸<\=X043q7C. W 3 � =X<>=X3q<\a®74[X3 W] [g9\=�p>3�74[X3�543B_h9;74.Yc>3Z. W f�54<}c>3 W 3B=�740kD U 3Z7C<�fg9\587C.h9;_®543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>="9;=XD ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\={043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�y.Y74[ U =�.Yan<>5 W 9 ]6] 36040 � � [�36=�7C[�3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=³9 ]B] 36020«an<>_Y_1<}�y0Z7C[X3 G .1f�a ½ _1.1´;3%DX.1087C52. E U 74.1<>=

z}Ç>Ì

Page 155: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

Q"1�ì�1�7Bí 8�í!ìÔâ �oïPï�ìÔí ü H41�ã6-�í!â� à�7 7G1�ë�îG�×ìÔì�5 ��1�ã���1q8�í þPü¨� � ÷ ú ù ��þQ0à�5kâ�âÔà©ë{îP5kâ�8 ü å{1 �Pä ü á�à�7 7G1�ëPî�â U â�í�áè F ��� �!÷ ��ú ��ù �©þ� à�7 7G1�ë�în0�5 X/8�-PìÔíW��1q8�5kàC -�í!ì�3 = â�-h7 7G1�ì�3 = î�à�á -P7Bí!ë�8 $ %@' �>=¨�©ü ÿ�= �é�í!ì�7Bâ�ê�í!ìNZJ-�í!ì�3@åp1���í!ìR1�ä©íèâ�AP5 r!8Ôí!îFëPí�ä ü ïP5këPà�7 5�1�ã�îP5kâB8 ü çd)_+9- � ùZJ-Pí�ìB3�é�í!ì�7*Tfì�í C -�í!ë�áS3 ? ï�â üîh5kâ�8 ü rpìÔà�7 C -�í!ì�5kí!â æ -.)A/ ßJ5kâ�8 ü��-P7Wï$í!ì�à�r4�Qv×â ç %�+>8 ÷��-P7Wï$í!ì�à�r�ßJ5kâ�O3â ç*: 2,1<; ù��-P7Wï$í!ì�à�r éEA�ìÔí�1�î�â ç )AG �©�o 56��íVà�r�� à©ãkãkí!áS8�5kà©ë ��1(2B3C4 � é ���-P7Wï$í!ì�à�r4� à©ãkãkí�áS8�5kà©ë�â ç % \ c ù �©�o í�ìB��í!ì o ê$í!í!îP-�ê n�+ � ÷� í!ê�ã65ká�1q8�5kà©ë�Q0í�ì�á!í�ë�8�1�ä©í ` ] 4 +9c � VßN5kâ�8�ìR1�áS8�5këPäDQ0í�ì�á!í�ë�8�1�ä©í ` : 2,1 ) �©þ V ÷�þ V ú©þ V� à©ãkãkí!áS8�5kà©ë��oá!á!í!âÔâ o O©í<Ii[5kêhr!|Áã656O©íNr}-�ë�áS8�5kà©ë � þPü þ å0i^5kêhrvè �©ü þ å}-�ëP5 rpà©ì�7{èo í�ãkí!áS8�5kà©ë�Q0í�ì�á!í�ë�8�1�ä©í ` 1(4 c �©ÿ V ÿ©þ Ví ÞY�F nà ¸ÿ¦þgÿ r <>=�jgp U 5C9;74.1<>=@fg9\549 W 3B7C3B540oan<>5o7436549 E�F 743�3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�740

�y.Y74[«7C[�3�3�µ^fi<>=X3B=�7 �po z>� 74[X3/= U W�E 365�<\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0t9;ظ3 ] 7C0t74[X3�fi<>f U _h9\52.Y7 F <\aI74[X3 W <>027an543Bl U 36=�7C_ F U 043BD ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � 9\=�D�74[ U 0�9�ØÖ3 ] 7C0y7C[�3qfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 �

¥w)+( �-,�. �[?Rq=.XW@249�H.�Õ65+?7:=<KWsr{�H.�Õ65G?G:=< �;.�57.�:�E�?72xA ³<FEY<>3�<KWY.trÃ<>A��

�-245G5G.X:�E�?G24A �;.�57.X:�E�?72xA <FE�<>3�<KW�.�W� 3�an<>543q�t3�f�54360236=�7�7C[�3¶fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3�<\aA< U 5�DX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D JLu 0 F 087C3 W an<>5K04369\5 ] [X.Y=Xp@9�74365 ½9 E�F 7C3©<\at743�µV7 � �t3�jg54087¶3B0274. W 9;7C3�[X<}� E .Yp�9�543BfX_1. ] 9%=X3B36DX0q7C< E 3�.1= <>54D�365�7C< ] <}c>3B5�7C[�3DX< ]6U W 36=�740ban<>5`74<>f�l U 3B54.Y360 � 9\=XDk7C[X3¹04. ¿ 3B0¢<\a�9y5436f�_1. ] 9m0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�Dg9�7:9 E 9;043�9\=XD�9 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=@Dg9;7C9 E 9\023 �s 9 E _13 �^� Ä 3B0274. W 9;7C3B0�7C[X3Z5236fX_Y. ] 9«04. ¿ 3¶an<>5/9«7C36549 E�F 7C3�<\aº7C3Úµ^7 � s [�3Z5436f�_1. ] 9«04. ¿ 3Z.Y0/DX3B74365 ½W .1=X3BD E�F 7É��<"a¦9 ] 7C<\540 � 7C[X3'9}c\36549\p>3%DX< ]6U W 36=�7Z02. ¿ 3@9\=XD�l U 365 F _Y< ] 9\_1.¾7 F � s [X3@9�c\365C9;p>3DX< ]6U W 36=�7t04. ¿ 3Kc;9\52.13B0¹an52< W 04< U 5 ] 3�7C<¶02< U 5 ] 3 � w <>5¹3�µ�9 W fX_Y360 � 7C[�3/9�c>3B5C9\p>3�DX< ]6U W 36=�7o02. ¿ 3<\a�7C[X3 R T à N à s×N 3B�y0©.10 Ä � � {e74[X3�9}c\36549\p>3)D�< ]BU W 3B=�7©02. ¿ 3�<\a�7C[X3�+�0204< ] .19;7C3�?A543B040N 3��y02�y.Y543�9\=XD � 9\_Y_ T 7C52363�7 � < U 54=g9\_g.Y0 Ç � � {>74[X3�9�c\365C9;p>3�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7�02. ¿ 3�<\a¸7C[X3m��3 E 02.Y74360<>fi36549;7C3BD E�F�z�Å + U 02745C9\_Y.h9 R =X.Yc\365204.Y74.13B0�.10 | � � {Ö74[X3�9}c\36549\p>3�DX< ]6U W 36=�7k04. ¿ 3Z<\a¹7C[�3 Ä\ÅO � syu à r Ñ�Pbr ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=".10 Ä � Ì � ��� M U 5k3B027C. W 9�7C.1<\= U 04360q7C[X52363�DX.Yظ365236=�7�= U W�E 3B540 �

z}Ç>|

Page 156: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

?×;�4 } ;�8 �B1�40KpY�/3(eI�Yp�31�':6;�4�j�m�md`�;�/ ^ <a1�b�6�7B4n132 ]�^ 1325�0*?×;�4 YM/�7 � ^ 1�2YM1�7 'Ôj�uæ� 4n132�`�;�/�* ' t uæ� 4n132�`0;�/P* ' i uæ�Q4�1�2{`�;�/�*g m�m�m g�x0h m } l m�maE�� x m�m¬E�� g�h y ���w m�m�m j | h i�} jy��� t ��� i ���g m�m�m�m t$l h l�} l ��� x ��� gPy ���j$m�m�m�m l j h m } y ��� g j���� t�x ���í Þ��! ¦à ÖÿT�Iÿ s [X3q543BfX_1. ] 9�02. ¿ 3 E 9;0436D�<>=%7C[X3qîµ ] .¾7C3k_1<>p

Ä � � �SÇ � � � 9\=�D | � ��� w <>5kl U 365 F _1< ] 9\_Y.Y7 F>� �t3 U 043�7C[�3©087:9;74.10274. ] 0�< E 7:9;.1=X3BD an52< W 7C[�3îµ ] .Y743o_1<\p � 02.1= ] 3o.Y740¢��<>54´�_1<>9\DX0A9\523m9;7¢7C[X3o_Y3Bc\36_�<;ag7C[X3o0 F 027C3 W ��3m.1=�c>3B027C.Yp�9;743 � � 3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 77C[�3q74<>f Ä;Å>Å D�< ]BU W 3B=�7C0yan<>5y3�9 ] [{l U 3B5 F � � 3�9\_Y04<©9\040 U W 3k7C[�36543�9\523�=X<�<}c>3B54_h9;fX0�9 W <>=�p7C[�3�DX< ]6U W 3B=�740 � 9\_¾7C[X< U p>[�74[X36523�3Úµ^.102740�<}c\3654_19\f�.1=�543�9;_1.Y7 F � J = s 9 E _13 �^� Ä^� ] <\_ U W =X0 z 9;=XDÄ 02[X<}��7C[X3�l U 365 F _Y< ] 9\_1.¾7 F .Y=�74[X3�îµ ] .¾7C3¶_Y<>p Ô 523Ban365K7C<�7:9 E _Y3kË � Ä Õ { ] <>_ U W =�0 Ç 7C[X52< U p>[ Î04[�<Â��7C[X3k3B027C. W 9�7C36D%02. ¿ 3q<;ab74[X3k543BfX_1. ] 9¶�y[X3B=���3�c\9;5 F 74[X3q9�c>36549\p>3kDX< ]6U W 36=�7y02. ¿ 3 � s [X3543B0 U _¾7C0¹04[X<}��74[g9;7 � an<>5º3�µ�9 W fX_Y3 � 7C[X3K543BfX_1. ] 9k<\aIË O � �VÆ O � 9\=XD z}Ì O � 049;7C.Y02jg3B0o9;7¹_Y3�9\087Ç Ë q <\aSl U 3B54.13B0oan<>5�74[X3�9�c>3B5C9\p\3�DX< ]BU W 36=�7m04. ¿ 3/<;a Ä � � ��Ç � � � 9\=XD | � � � 543602f¸3 ] 74.Yc>3B_ F �+�0KDX.Y0 ]6U 04043BD».1= T 3 ] 7C.Y<>=�Ë � Î^� 74[X3�02. ¿ 3�<\a¢7C[X3q543BfX_1. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�DX9;7:9 E 9\043q.10yDX.Y543 ] 7C_ F fX54< ½fi<>5274.1<>=g9;_V74<k74[X3m= U W�E 365A<\a U =X.Yl U 3o7C3B5 W 0A.1=�7C[�3m_h9\52p>36087A543BfX_1. ] 9 �®� 9\043BD�<>=Z7C[X3m087:9;74.10274. ] 0��3'< E 7C9\.1=X3BD�.1= T 3 ] 7C.Y<>=�Ë � Î Ô Æ d � 3Bc\365 F�z}Å>Å^�ÐÅ>Å\Å U =X.Yl U 3©74365 W 0 Õ 9\=XD�74[X3'= U W�E 365�<\aU =X.Yl U 3q74365 W 0y.1=@7C[�3 Ä\Å O � syu à r�Ñ�Pbr ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= Ô z}Ç�� Å>Ì>Ì�� Å>Æ Ë U =X.Yl U 3q74365 W 0 Õ � �t3�360 ½7C. W 9�7C3k7C[g9;7�7C[X3Z02. ¿ 3¶<\aº< U 5/5236fX_Y. ] 9«043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=»Dg9;7C9 E 9\023�.10�an52< W z O � 7C< Ä O � � �y[X. ] [».Y0Å � ztq 74< Å � Ä#q <\ab7C[X3�7C<;7:9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=%04. ¿ 3 �s [X3¹04. ¿ 3¹<\a^74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�DX9;7:9 E 9\043¹.10b9\52< U =XD Ä#q <\a^7C[X3º7C<;7:9\_>02. ¿ 3�<\a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0E 9\0236D�<\=�7C[�3«< E 023658c\9�7C.1<\=�<\ao74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>="0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�Dg9;7C9 E 9\023©an<>5k7C[�3 Ä\Å O � syu à rÑ�Pbr ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � w <>5 z 7C3B5C9 E�F 7C3k<\ab7C3ÚµV7 � .Y740m04. ¿ 3k.10y9\52< U =XD Ä\Å O ���

¥w)VU &Á.X0�9C240 8\<>A�:=. �³W�?GA��'ØÙZ�.X0 ?7.�Wwv ?eE�,�<>A��HJ4.�0�<K�*.¶249K�xvv2·�m.�0 8\WJ =%7C[X.Y0o043 ] 74.1<>= � �t3�fX52360236=�7/9�023B7y<\ab3Úµ�fi3652. W 36=�7C0oan<\5o04369\5 ] [X.Y=Xp�9¶7C3B5C9 E�F 7C3k<\aS7C3ÚµV7 U 04.Y=Xp04[�<>527¹l U 3652.13B0¹�y.¾7C[�9\=©9}c\36549\p>3 Ä 74365 W 0Afi365ºl U 365 F � +�0�< U 5 E 9\043B_1.Y=X3 � ��3 U 043 Ç�Ä 043658c>3B540�74<0274<>543 z 7C36549 E�F 7C3y<\ag7C3ÚµV7 � 3�9 ] [�<\ag�y[�. ] [�0274<>543B0º9 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=¶<\a Ç�Ä O � fX_ U 0e.¾7C0®.Y=XDX. ] 360 � � 3

z Ë Å

Page 157: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

cV.13��ö9;_1_`7C[X3¶Dg9;7:9'<\={3�9 ] ["023652c\365k9\0/9 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 9\=XD{��3Z[g9�c>3 Ç�Ä ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0K.1=�7C<\7C9\_ �� 3k74[X36= ] < W fg9;543/7C[�3qfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3k<\a¢74[X3�an<>_1_Y<}�y.1=Xp ] <>=�jgp U 5C9;74.1<>=�0o�y.Y7C[%74[X3 E 9\043B_1.Y=X3 �

y ?¢9\5274.Y7C.Y<>=X.Y=Xp�<}c>3B5�7É�y. ] 3 9\0 W 9\= F 043B52c>3B540 � fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xp z s � <\a�7C3Úµ^7�<}c>3B5 Æ Ë023652c\36520 � 3�9 ] [�<\ab�y[X. ] [�0274<>543B0 z}Æ O � <\a®DX9;7:9�9\=XD�.Y740m.1=XD�. ] 3B0 �

y ?¢9\5274.h9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>= � U 02.1=Xp<>=�3�9\D�DX.Y74.1<>=g9;_�043B52c\365�74<027C<\543�9 Ç�Ä O �5236fX_Y. ] 9©9\=XD U 04.1=�p©7É��<@9\DXDX.¾7C.1<\=g9\_`043B52c\36540/74<'0274<>543¶9«[X.Y365C9;5 ] [ F <;aA543BfX_1. ] 9\0K�y.Y7C[)9z}Æ O � 543BfX_1. ] 9�9\=�D©9 Ç>Ä O � 5236fX_Y. ] 9 � �y[X36=�7C[�3m_h9\52p>36087A543BfX_1. ] 9�DX.Y02745C9 ] 7C0 Ä\Ŧq'� Ë Å#q%�9\=�D Æ>Å#q <\a ] < W�W 9\=XDX0 �

y r <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � U 02.1=Xp ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�0236_13 ] 74.1<>=�7C<'0236_13 ] 7�7C[X3q7C<>f Ä\Î#q <>5 Î;Ŧq <\a] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0 �

y ?¢9\5274.h9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=q5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>=¶f�_ U 0 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=¶0236_13 ] 74.1<>= � ] <>=XD UX] 7C.Y=Xp�fg9\587C.h9;_V5236fX_Y. ] 90236_13 ] 74.1<>=�jg52027 � 9\=XD��y[X3B=74[X3"5436f�_1. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C<>5%D�.1543 ] 740�9�l U 3B5 F 74<74[X3»<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= � 74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=¶0236_Y3 ] 74<>5A043B_13 ] 7C0e74[X3t74<>f Î\Ŧq <\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0ban<>5®023�9\5 ] [X.1=Xp �

� 3�f U 7m7C[�3�5436f�_1. ] 9¶043B_13 ] 7C<\5m9\=XD ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>='0236_Y3 ] 74<>5o.Y='7C[X3 ] <>=X=X3 ] 7C.Y<>= E 54<\´\365y9;0m04[X<}�y=.1= w .Yp U 523 Ç � z Ô ] Õ �w .Yp U 543 �^� z .Y_1_ U 02745C9;74360I7C[�3o9�c>3B5C9\p>3�l U 365 F 523604fi<>=X023�74. W 3ºc\36520 U 0e74[X3 ] < W�W 9\=�D¶9\5254.¾c\9;_�5C9;743.1={74[X3�9 E <}c>3 ] <>=^jgp U 549;7C.Y<>=X0 � J = w .1p U 543 �V� z Ô 9 Õ � �t3�DX3 W <>=�027C549;7C3�74[X3�9�c>3B5C9\p>3�523604fi<>=X0237C. W 3��y[X3B=��t3'5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3 Ç�Ä O � Ô Ç#q <;ao7C[X3©7C<\7C9\_�02. ¿ 3 Õ <\= z <>5 Ä 043B52c\36540 � R 04.Y=Xp{<>=�3543BfX_1. ] 9�7C<'DX.Y02745C9 ] 7 Ä\Å#q%� Ë Å¦q'� 9;=XD Æ>Ŧq <\a ] < W�W 9;=XDX0�. W f�54<}c>3B0�7C[�3�_h9\52p>36087 ] < W�W 9\=�D9\5254.Yc;9\_¢5C9;743��y.Y74["9\= 9}c\36549\p>3�543B04fi<>=X043Z74. W 3 E 3B_1<}� z}Å 043 ] <>=XD�0 E�F 9'a¦9 ] 7C<>5/<;a z � Ç��Az � Ì��9\=XD Ä � Å�� 9;=XD U 04.Y=Xp/7É��<�5236fX_Y. ] 9;0¢7C<�D�.102745C9 ] 7 Ä\Ŧq'� Ë Å#q%� 9\=XD Æ>Ŧq <\a ] < W�W 9\=XDX0e. W f�54<}c>3B07C[�3/_h9\52p>36087 ] < W©W 9\=XD%9;5454.¾c;9\_�5C9;743��y.Y74[@9\=@9�c>36549\p>3�523604fi<>=X023/7C. W 3 E 3B_1<}� z}Å 043 ] <>=�DX0 E�F9�a¦9 ] 7C<>5�<\a z � Ç���Ä � ÄV� 9\=�D Ç � Ë � �y[X.Y_13�fg9\5274.Y74.1<>=X.Y=Xpk<}c>365 Æ Ë�043B52c\36540y. W fX52<}c>360�.Y7 E�F 9�a¦9 ] 7C<\5<\a z � Î � R 04.Y=Xpq<>=X3�<\5¹7É��<�9\D�DX.Y74.1<>=g9;_g043658c>3B5�7C<�543BfX_1. ] 9;743 Ç#q <;aÖ7C[�3�Dg9;7C9�9 ] [X.13�c>360t04. W .1_19\5fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3@7C< fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xp»<}c\365 Æ Ë�043B52c\36540 Ô Ç�Ä 9\DXDX.¾7C.1<\=g9\_o023652c\36520%9\0 ] < W fg9\5236DÙ74<

z Ë z

Page 158: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

F $�%(' ç*),+#- ç -.)A/ ��1@2B3C4 ç6%7+98 ç6: 2,1<;��1�ì�5kí�î �>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ï�â ü � é � ÷ ùç )AG ` : 2B1 ) ` ] 4 +>c � ` 1(4 c ç % \ c n +�©� ��1�ì�5kí!î � V ��1�ì�5kí!î ��1�ì�5kí!î �©� �

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

Partitioning (32 servers)Partitioning (64 servers)

Replication (one replica,20%)Replication (one replica,40%)Replication (one replica,60%)

Replication (two replicas,20%)Replication (two replicas,40%)Replication (two replicas,60%)

å{1�è êU1�ìB8�5�1�ã�ì�í!ê�ã65ká�1q8�5kà©ë

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

Partitioning (32 servers)Partitioning (64 servers)

Col.sel.(top 25%, Zipf)Col.sel.(top 25%, uniform)

Col.sel.(top 50%, Zipf)Col.sel.(top 50%, uniform)

åpï$è á!à©ãkãkí!á 8�5kà©ëDâ�í�ãkí!áS8�5kà©ë

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

Partitioning (32 servers)Partitioning (64 servers)

Repl.(Pdist=20%)+Col.Sel.(top 50%,uniform)Repl.(Pdist=40%)+Col.Sel.(top 50%,uniform)

Repl.(Pdist=40%)+Col.Sel.(top 50%,Zipf)

åpáè êP1�ì�8�5�1�ã�ìÔí!ê�ã65ká�1q8�5kà©ë¬åpà©ë�í.ìÔí!ê�ã65ká�1�è ê�ã6-�â á!à©ãkãkí!á 8�5kà©ëDâ�í�ãkí!áS8�5kà©ëõ ò ß�%SýÂà Öÿ¦þgÿ ?b3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3��y[X36=�043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp»9�7436549 E�F 743«<\at7C3�µV7 U 04.Y=Xp)l U 3B54.Y360��y.¾7C[�9\=9�c>3B5C9\p>3q<\a Ä 7C365 W 0 �

z Ë Ä

Page 159: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

7C[�3 E 9;0436_Y.1=X3 Õ �y[X36=�7C[X3K543BfX_1. ] 9�DX.Y027C549 ] 740 Ä\Ŧq <\a ] < W�W 9\=XDX0 � 9\=XD�f¸3B52an<>5 W 0º04.Yp>=X.¾j ] 9\=�74_ FE 3B7474365m�y[X3B=�7C[�3q5236fX_Y. ] 9 Ô 0 Õ DX.1087C549 ] 7 W <>543�74[g9\=�Ë Å¦q �J = w .Yp U 543 �^� z Ô E Õ � ��3ZDX3 W <>=X087C5C9�7C3�7C[�3Z9�c>36549\p>3Z523604fi<>=X023Z7C. W 3��y[�36=»�t3Z0236_Y3 ] 7�74[X3¶74<>fÄ>Î#q 9\=XD Î;Ŧq <\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 U 02.1=Xp"7C[�3�f U 543 G .1f�a�9\=XD U =X.¾an<>5 W D�.1027454. E U 7C.Y<>=X0 � R 04.Y=Xp7C[�3 G .Yf�aKDX.1087C52. E U 74.1<>=�.1_1_ U 02745C9;74360¶9 ] 9\043%�y[X3B543 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�0236_13 ] 74.1<>=[g9\0Z=�<�02.1p>=X.¾j ] 9;=�7. W fg9 ] 7k<>= f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 � 04.Y= ] 3�9\_ W <\027q9\_Y_ ] < W�W 9\=XDX0 Ô z�Å>Ŧq 9;=XD |>Å#q �y[X36=�043B_13 ] 7C.Y=Xp7C[�3q74<>f Î\Å#q 9\=XD Ä>Î#q Õ p><�74<©74[X3q74<>f z ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>= ��T 3B_13 ] 7C.Y=Xp�7C[X3k7C<>f Ä>Î#q 9;=XD Î\Å#q <\a] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 U 04.Y=Xp�7C[X3mf U 543 G .Yf�aiDX.1087C54. E U 74.1<>=�. W f�54<}c>3B0e7C[X3m_19\54p>3B027 ] < W�W 9\=�D�9\5452.Yc;9\_V5C9;743�y.Y74[ 9\= 9}c\36549\p>3�543B04fi<>=X043Z74. W 3 E 3B_1<}� z}Å 043 ] <>=XDX0 E�F 9'a¦9 ] 74<>5/<\a z � Ä 9\=XD z � Å Ë � R 04.Y=Xp7C[�3 U =X.Yan<\5 W DX.1087C52. E U 74.1<>=�.1_Y_ U 087C5C9�7C360q7C[X3 E 36087 ] 9\023'an<>5 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= ��T 36_Y3 ] 7C.1=�p7C[�3q74<>f Ä\Î#q <\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 U 02.1=Xp U =X.¾an<>5 W DX.1087C52. E U 74.1<>=@. W fX52<}c>360m74[X3�_19\54p\36027 ] < W�W 9\=�D9\5254.Yc;9\_A549;7C3��y.Y74[�9\=�9�c\365C9;p>3'543B04fi<>=X023«7C. W 3 E 3B_1<}� Î 023 ] <>=XDX0 E�F 9�a¦9 ] 7C<>5q<\a Ç � |�� 9;=XD043B_13 ] 7C.Y=Xp«74[X3¶7C<\f Î\Ŧq <\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0�. W fX52<}c>360�7C[X3�_19\54p\36027 ] < W�W 9\=XD{9;5454.¾c;9\_S5C9;743��y.Y74[9\=�9�c>3B5C9\p>3q543B04fi<>=X023q74. W 3 E 3B_1<}� z�Å 023 ] <>=XDX0 E�F 9Za¦9 ] 7C<\5m<\a z � | �J = w .1p U 543 �^� z Ô ] Õ � �t3Z.Y_1_ U 02745C9;743¶0 ] 36=g9;54.1<\0/�y[X36523Zfg9\5274.h9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=)5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=»9\=XD ] <>_ ½_13 ] 74.1<>=%0236_13 ] 74.1<>=%��<>54´'74<>p>3B74[X365m74<�. W f�54<}c>3�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 � J =@7C[X.Y0m3�µ�9 W fX_13 � �t3 U 023�<>=�39\DXD�.Y7C.Y<>=g9\_®043658c>3B5¶7C<�0274<>543©9 Ç�Ä O � 543BfX_1. ] 9@9\=XD�DX<)5236fX_Y. ] 9�0236_13 ] 74.1<>="jg54087 � � [X3B=�7C[�3543BfX_1. ] 9¶0236_Y3 ] 74<>5oDX.Y543 ] 7C0y9�l U 365 F 7C<�7C[�3/<>54.Yp>.1=X9\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= Ô 0 Õ � 7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=«0236_13 ] 74<>5m043 ½_13 ] 740®7C[X3o74<>f Î\Ŧq <\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0¢an<>5ef�54< ] 360204.Y=Xp/7C[X3ml U 3B5 F � w 54< W w .1p U 543 �^� z Ô 9 Õ � �t3m´�=X<}�U 02.1=Xp©9Z04.1=�p>_13�5236fX_Y. ] 9�74<�D�.102745C9 ] 7 Ä\Ŧq 9;=XD�Ë Å¦q <\a ] < W�W 9;=XDX0m. W fX52<Âc\360m7C[�3 ] < W�W 9\=�D9\5254.Yc;9\_�549;7C3K�y.Y7C[«9�9�c>3B5C9\p>3�543602f¸<\=X043�74. W 3 E 36_Y<}� z}Å 023 ] <\=XDX0 E�F 9qa¦9 ] 74<>5�<;a z � Ç 9\=XD z � Ì �?A_ U 0 U 04.1=�p ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=��y.Y7C[�74[X3 U =X.¾an<>5 W ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�9 ]B] 3B040 � 7C[X3%fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3a U 587C[X3B5o. W fX54<}c\360t74<�9�a¦9 ] 74<>5 Ä � Ç 9\=�D Ä � | � � [X36='74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=©9 ]6] 36040y02´\3B��an<>_1_Y<}�y0�7C[�3G .1f^aÖDX.Y027454. E U 7C.Y<>= � U 02.1=Xpq9k543BfX_1. ] 9/7C<kDX.Y027C549 ] 7¹Ë Å#q <\aÖl U 3654.Y360¹fX_ U 0¹0236_Y3 ] 74.1=Xp�74[X3m7C<>f Î\Ŧq<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0o. W f�54<}c>3B0Kfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3/7C<�9Za¦9 ] 74<>5m<\a z � | �

z Ë Ç

Page 160: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

F $�%(' ç*),+#- ç -.)A/ ��1@2B3C4 ç6%7+98 ç6: 2,1<;��1�ì�5kí�î �>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ï�â ü � é � ÷ ùç )AG `e: 2B1 ) ` ] 4 +>c � ` 1(4 c ç % \ c n�+�©� ��1�ì�5kí!î � V ��1�ì�5kí!î ��1�ì�5kí!î ù �

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

Partitioning (8 servers)Replication (Pdist=20%)Replication (Pdist=40%)Replication (Pdist=60%)

å{1�è êU1�ìB8�5�1�ã�ì�í!ê�ã65ká�1q8�5kà©ë

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

Partitioning (8 servers)Col.sel.(top 25%, Zipf)

Col.sel.(top 25%, uniform)Col.sel.(top 50%, Zipf)

Col.sel.(top 50%, uniform)

åpï$è á!à©ãkãkí!á 8�5kà©ëDâ�í�ãkí!áS8�5kà©ëõ ò ß�%SýÂà ¸ÿT�`ÿ ?¢3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3��y[X36=�043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp«9�74365C9 E�F 743�<\ab7C3ÚµV7 U 04.1=�p©_19\54p>3B5oDX.Y04´�0

¥w)eu &Á.X0�9C240 8\<>A�:=.yv ?eE�, ��<K0��*.�0� ³?GW���WJ =«74[X.10�043 ] 7C.Y<>= � �t3/f�54360236=�7K9\=X<;7C[X3B5t043�7m<\a`3Úµ^f¸3B54. W 36=�740tan<>5¹043�9;5 ] [X.Y=XpZ9�74365C9 E�F 743/<\aI743�µV7U 02.1=Xp�04[X<\527�l U 3654.Y360y�y.Y74[{9\=�9�c>36549\p>3 Ä 74365 W 0yf¸3B5�l U 3B5 F � ú9 ] [{043B52c\365�087C.Y_1_I[g9;0�Ë r ? R 09\=XD Ì DX.Y04´�0 �VE U 7�3�9 ] ['DX.102´Z0274<>543B0 z}Æ O � <\a`DX9;7:9q9\=XD©.Y7C0º.Y=XDX. ] 360 � s [X36523Ban<>523�369 ] ['043B52c\365[g9\=�DX_13B0 zÂÄ;Ì O � � 9\=XD'9k7C3B5C9 E�F 7C3/<;aI7C3Úµ^7�=X3B36DX0 Ì 043B52c>3B540 � � 3�cV.13���9\_Y_X7C[X3�Dg9;7:9q<>=«369 ] [043B52c\365�9\0K9 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � 9\=�D���3k[g9�c>3 Ì ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0o.1='74<\7:9\_ �w .Yp U 543 �^� Ä .Y_1_ U 027C549;7C3B0A7C[X3�f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�p>9\.1= E�F U 02.1=Xp�fg9\587C.h9;_i5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=�9\=XD ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=".1={74[X.10 ] 9\043 � J = w .1p U 523 �^� Ä Ô 9 Õ � ��3�D�3 W <>=X02745C9;743�7C[X3�9�c>3B5C9\p\3�l U 3B5 F 523604fi<>=X0237C. W 3��y[X3B=)��3¶543BfX_1. ] 9;743 Ç�Ä O � Ô Ç¦q <\a®7C[X3k7C<\7C9\_`04. ¿ 3 Õ <>=�<>=X3�9\DXDX.¾7C.Y<>=g9\_I023658c>365 �/T .1= ] 39@043658c>3B5 ] 9;=�[X<>_YD z}Ä\Ì O � .1="7C<\7C9\_ � ��3«f U 7kan< U 5 ] <>f�.1360q<\a�7C[X3�543BfX_1. ] 9%<>="7C[X.Y0q023658c>365 �

z Ë>Ë

Page 161: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

r < W fg9\52.1=Xpy7C[X3 E 9\0236_1.Y=X3t.Y= w .1p U 523 �V� z Ô 9 Õ �y[X36523 z 7C3B5C9 E�F 7C3�<\ag7C3ÚµV7e.10bDX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D¶<Âc\365 Ç�Ä043B52c\36540�9\=XD�.Y7y0 U fXfi<>52740�9\=�9�c>3B5C9\p>3q543B04fi<>=X023q74. W 3 U =XDX3B5 z�Å 023 ] <\=XDX0/9�7 Æ � �Z] < W©W 9\=XDX0fi365q043 ] <>=XD � U 04.Y=Xp Ì 043B52c>3B540�0 U fXfi<>52740�9\=�9�c>3B5C9\p>3©543B04fi<>=X043�7C. W 3 U =XD�365 z}Å 023 ] <\=XDX0�9�7z ���)] < W�W 9\=XDX0�f¸3B5�043 ] <>=XD � �y[X. ] [�.10 Ç 74. W 360�_136020¶7C[X9\=�7C[X3%0 F 027C3 W �y.Y74[�Ë)7C. W 3B0¶7C[�3043B52c\36540 Ô Ç>Ä 043658c>3B540 Õ � ,/.1087C5C9 ] 7C.Y=Xp Ä\Å#q%� Ë Å¦q'� 9\=XD Æ>Ŧq <\a ] < W�W 9\=XDX0'.Y= ] 523�9\02360%7C[�3_h9;54p>3B027 ] < W©W 9\=XD"9\5254.¾c\9;_e5C9;743��y.Y74[�9\= 9�c>3B5C9\p\3©523604fi<>=X023�74. W 3 E 36_1<}� z}Å 043 ] <>=XDX0 E�F 9a¦9 ] 7C<>5K<\a z � Ç��¸Ä � z>� 9\=XD Ç � ÎV� �y[�. ] [).Y0�02. W .1_19\5t7C<�7C[�3¶. W fX52<Âc\3 W 36=�7�<\aefg9;527C.19\_`543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=an<>5mDX.Y027454. E U 7C.Y=Xp�9�7C36549 E�F 7C3q<Âc\365 Ç�Ä 043B52c\36540 Ô z � Ç���Ä � Ä^��Ç � Ë Õ �J = w .Yp U 543 �^� Ä Ô E Õ � ��3ZDX3 W <>=X087C5C9�7C3�7C[�3Z9�c>36549\p>3Z523604fi<>=X023Z7C. W 3��y[�36=»�t3Z0236_Y3 ] 7�74[X3¶74<>fÄ>Î#q 9\=XD Î;Ŧq <\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 U 02.1=Xp�7C[X3qf U 523 G .Yf�a®9\=XD U =X.Yan<>5 W DX.Y027C52. E U 7C.1<\=X0 �tT 36_Y3 ] 7C.1=�p7C[�3¶7C<>f Ä\Î#q 9;=XD Î\Ŧq <\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 U 04.Y=Xp'7C[�3 G .1f�aºD�.1027454. E U 7C.Y<>=). W f�54<}c>3B0�7C[X3Z_19\54p\36027] < W©W 9\=XD@9\5254.¾c\9;_¸549;7C3/�y.¾7C[�9\=�9�c>36549\p>3k543B04fi<>=X023k74. W 3 E 36_1<}� z}Å 043 ] <>=�DX0 E�F 9Za¦9 ] 7C<\5o<\az � Ì 9\=XD z � Ä^� �y[X. ] [©.Y0 E 3B7474365e74[g9\= U 02.1=Xp Ç�Ä 023652c\36520 Ô w .1p U 543 �V� z Ô E Õ4Õ ��E 3 ] 9 U 043m7C[X3m= U W¶E 3B5<\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0�.Y0�0 W 9;_1_13B5k.1=�74[X.10 ] 9\023 �{T 36_Y3 ] 74.1=Xp�7C[X3�7C<>f Ä\Î#q 9\=XD Î;Ŧq <\a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0U 02.1=Xp U =�.Yan<>5 W D�.1027454. E U 7C.Y<>=¶. W f�54<}c>3B0e7C[X3o_19\54p\36027 ] < W�W 9\=XDZ9\5254.¾c\9;_^549;7C3t�y.¾7C[�9\=�9�c\365C9;p>3543B04fi<>=X023k74. W 3 E 36_Y<Â� z}Å 023 ] <>=XDX0 E�F 9¶a¦9 ] 7C<>5o<;a Ç � | 9\=�D Ä � Å^� �y[X. ] [�9\523/04. W .Y_h9\5A74<�7C[X<>023U 02.1=Xp Ç�Ä 043B52c\36540 �

¥w)_| &Á.X0�9C240 8\<>A�:=.yv ?eE�, # <KWBE�.X0!�;.X0�J4.�0�W <>A�� &�.IE�v-2*0��J =�7C[X.Y0%043 ] 7C.Y<>= � ��3"fX543B043B=�7)9�043�7�<;a¶3Úµ�fi3652. W 36=�7C0 U 02.1=Xp�a¦9\087C3B5�023658c>36520)9;=XD!9�a¦9\087C3B5=X3�7É�t<>52´ � � 3�9\020 U W 3/�t3�[X9}c\3 Ì 043658c>3B540K9\=XD@3�9 ] [�023658c>365y[g9;=XDX_13B0 zÂÄ\Ì O � <\aSDg9�7:9Z9\0m.Y=T 3 ] 7C.Y<>= �^� Ç � � 3¶9\020 U W 3¶023658c>36520/9\=�D�7C[�3�=X3�7É�t<\54´�9\543qË�7C. W 360K9\0ma¦9\087/9;0K74[X<>043 U 0236D{.Y=T 3 ] 7C.Y<>= �^� Ç � w .Yp U 523 �^� Ç .1_1_ U 02745C9;74360K7C[X3Zfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3Zp�9\.1= E�F U 04.Y=Xp@fg9\5274.h9\_b543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=9\=XD ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>='0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>[email protected]=@74[X.10 ] 9\043 �J = w .1p U 523 �V� Ç Ô 9 Õ � ��3�DX3 W <\=X02745C9;743K74[X3/9�c>3B5C9\p\3�543B04fi<>=X023�7C. W 3m�y[X3B=«��3/543BfX_1. ] 9;743 Ç>Ä O �Ô Ç#q <\ab7C[X3�7C<;7:9\_`02. ¿ 3 Õ <>=@<>=X3�9\DXDX.¾7C.1<\=g9\_i043658c>3B5 � +�0K.Y= T 3 ] 7C.1<\= �^� Ç�� ��3qf U 7yan< U 5 ] <\fX.13B0<\ab7C[X3k5236fX_Y. ] 9Z<>=%74[X.10m023652c\365 � r < W fg9\52.1=Xp��y.¾7C[ w .1p U 543 �^� Ä Ô 9 Õ �y[X36523�7C[X3k0 F 087C3 W �y.¾7C[ Ì

z Ë Î

Page 162: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

F $�%(' ç*),+#- ç -.)A/ ��1@2B3C4 ç6%7+98 ç6: 2,1<;��1�ì�5kí�î �>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � � ? ï�â ü � é � ÷ ùç )AG `e: 2B1 ) ` ] 4 +>c æd%@z 1 ` 1(4 c ç % \ c n�+�©� ��1�ì�5kí!î � V ��1�ì�5kí!î ��1�ì�5kí!î ù ÷

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

Partitioning (8 servers)Replication (Pdist=20%)Replication (Pdist=40%)Replication (Pdist=60%)

å{1�è êU1�ìB8�5�1�ã�ì�í!ê�ã65ká�1q8�5kà©ë

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

Partitioning (8 servers)Col.sel.(top 25%, Zipf)

Col.sel.(top 25%, uniform)Col.sel.(top 50%, Zipf)

Col.sel.(top 50%, uniform)

åpï$è á!à©ãkãkí!á 8�5kà©ëDâ�í�ãkí!áS8�5kà©ëõ ò ß�%SýÂà ¸ÿT�Iÿ ?¢3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3��y[X36=�043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp«9�74365C9 E�F 743�<\ab7C3ÚµV7 U 04.1=�p�a¦9;027C3B5y043658c>3B540/9;=XD=X3�7É�t<>52´

043B52c\36540�0 U fXfi<>52740/9\=)9�c>36549\p>3�l U 365 F 543B04fi<>=X023¶7C. W 3 U =XD�365 z�Å 043 ] <>=�DX0�9;7 z ����] < W©W 9\=XDX0fi365k043 ] <>=XD � U 02.1=Xp�9%0 F 02743 W �y.Y74[�Ë@7C. W 3Z9;0ka¦9;027q0 U f�f¸<>587C0�9\=�9}c\36549\p>3�l U 365 F 523604fi<>=X0237C. W 3 U =XDX3B5 z}Å 043 ] <>=XDX0¹9;7 | � | ] < W©W 9\=XD�0Af¸3B5A043 ] <>=XD � �y[X. ] [�.10 Î � Ì 7C. W 3B0A9\0 W 9;= F 9\0A7C[�3<>_YD{0 F 02743 W � � [�36= U 04.Y=Xp%fg9\587C.19\_¢5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= � DX.1087C5C9 ] 7C.Y=Xp Ä\Å#q <\a ] < W©W 9\=XD�0�.1= ] 54369\043B07C[�3�_19\54p\36027 ] < W�W 9;=XD9\5452.Yc;9\_�5C9;743'�y.Y7C[³9\=³9�c>3B5C9\p\3�523602f¸<>=�043@7C. W 3 E 36_Y<}� z}Å 023 ] <\=XDX0E�F 9'a¦9 ] 7C<>5�<\a z � Ë@9;=XD"DX.1087C5C9 ] 7C.Y=Xp'Ë Å#q <\a ] < W©W 9\=XD�0/.1= ] 54369\043B0k74[X3�_19\54p>3B027 ] < W�W 9\=�D9\5254.Yc;9\_`549;7C3��y.¾7C[{9;={9�c>3B5C9\p>3�543B04fi<>=X043q7C. W 3 E 36_1<}� Î 043 ] <>=�DX0 E�F 9�a¦9 ] 7C<>5K<\a Ä � z\� �y[�. ] [.10t04. W .1_19\5A7C<Z7C[�3�. W fX54<}c>3 W 3B=�7m<\abfg9\587C.h9;_¸5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=«an<>5t74[X3�0 F 02743 W .Y= T 3 ] 7C.Y<>= �^� Ç Ô z � Ç

z Ë Æ

Page 163: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

9\=XD Ä � z Õ � ,/.Y02745C9 ] 7C.1=�p Æ>Ŧq <\a ] < W�W 9;=XDX0k.10q.1=X0236=X02.Y74.Yc>3Z74<�7C[�3 ] < W©W 9\=XD�9\5254.Yc;9\_®5C9;7437C[X9;7m�t3 ] <\=X04.YDX365y.1=%74[X.10m3Úµ�fi3652. W 36=�7C0 �J = w .Yp U 543 �^� Ç Ô E Õ � ��3ZDX3 W <>=X087C5C9�7C3�7C[�3Z9�c>36549\p>3Z523604fi<>=X023Z7C. W 3��y[�36=»�t3Z0236_Y3 ] 7�74[X3¶74<>fÄ>Î#q 9\=XD Î\Ŧq <;a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0 U 04.Y=Xp©9�f U 543 G .1f�a¢9\=�D)9\= U =X.¾an<>5 W DX.1087C52. E U 74.1<>= �ºT 36_Y3 ] 7C.1=�p7C[�3¶7C<>f Ä\Î#q 9;=XD Î\Ŧq <\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 U 04.Y=Xp'7C[�3 G .1f�aºD�.1027454. E U 7C.Y<>=). W f�54<}c>3B0�7C[X3Z_19\54p\36027] < W©W 9\=XD�9\5452.Yc;9\_º5C9;743«�y.Y74[�9\=�9�c\365C9;p>3%543B04fi<>=X043©7C. W 3 E 3B_1<}� z}Å 043 ] <>=�DX0 E�F 9�a¦9 ] 7C<\5<\a z � | 9\=XD z � Ä ��T 3B_13 ] 7C.Y=Xp�74[X3©74<>f Î\Ŧq <;a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 U 02.1=Xp U =X.Yan<>5 W DX.Y027C52. E U 7C.1<\=�. W ½fX52<Âc\360/74[X3¶_19\54p>3B027 ] < W�W 9\=XD�9\5452.Yc;9\_S5C9;743��y.¾7C[{9;=»9�c>36549\p>3�l U 365 F 543B04fi<>=X043�7C. W 3 E 3B_1<}�z}Å 023 ] <\=XDX0 E�F 9�a¦9 ] 74<>5«<;a Ä � Å 9\=�D0236_Y3 ] 74.1=Xp�74[X3{7C<\f Ä>Î#q <\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 U 04.1=�p U =X. ½an<>5 W DX.1087C54. E U 74.1<>[email protected]=�0436=�04.Y74.Yc\3�7C<�7C[X3 ] < W©W 9\=XD�9\5452.Yc;9\_`549;7C3q7C[g9;7K��3 ] <\=X04.YDX365�.1=@7C[X.Y03�µ^fi3652. W 36=�7C0 �s [X3�52360 U _Y740�<\ae74[X.10�043 ] 7C.Y<>={02[X<}�-74[g9;7�9\_Y74[X< U p\[ U 02.1=Xp�a¦9\0274365 W 9 ] [X.Y=X360K543BD UX] 3B0/7C[X3�543 ½04fi<>=X023A7C. W 3 � .¾7`DX<V360S=X<\7S02.1p>=�.Yj ] 9\=�7C_ F ] [g9\=�p>3A7C[X3º543B_h9;74.Yc\3e. W fX54<}c\3 W 36=�7SD U 3A7C< ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�9\=XD�fg9\587C.h9;_Ö543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= �

¥w)VÔ &Á.X0�9C240 8\<>A�:=.yv ?eE�, ��24A��4.X0³ØÙZ�.X0 ?G.XWJ =%7C[X.Y0o043 ] 74.1<>= � �t3�fX52360236=�7/9�023B7y<\ab3Úµ�fi3652. W 36=�7C0oan<\5o04369\5 ] [X.Y=Xp�9¶7C3B5C9 E�F 7C3k<\aS7C3ÚµV7 U 04.Y=Xp_1<\=Xp>365�l U 3654.Y360��y.Y74["9\= 9�c>36549\p>3 Ì 7C3B5 W 0�f¸3B5�l U 365 F � s [X3�0 F 087C3 W ] <>=�jXp U 5C9�7C.1<\=»<\aº7C[X.Y0043 ] 74.1<>={.Y0K74[X3�049 W 3¶9\0�.Y= T 3 ] 74.1<>= �V� Ë � w .Yp U 543 �^� Ë«.Y_1_ U 027C549;7C3B0m7C[X3�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�p>9\.1= E�FU 02.1=Xp�fg9\587C.19\_I543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>='9\=XD ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>='043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>[email protected]=%7C[�.10 ] 9;043 �J = w .1p U 523 �^� Ë Ô 9 Õ � ��3�D�3 W <>=X02745C9;743�74[X3�9}c\36549\p>3)523602f¸<>=�043�74. W 3'�y[X36=³�t3�543BfX_1. ] 9;743 Ç�ÄO � Ô Ç¦q <;a�74[X3%7C<\7C9\_o04. ¿ 3 Õ <>=Ù<\=X3@9\DXDX.¾7C.Y<>=g9\_�043658c>3B5 � +�0�.1= T 3 ] 74.1<>= �^� Ç 9\=XD �^� Ë»��3f U 7�an< U 5 ] <>f�.1360�<\am7C[�3«543BfX_1. ] 9@<>=�74[X.10�9\DXDX.¾7C.Y<>=g9\_A023652c\365 � r < W fg9\54.Y=Xp@7C[X3 E 9\043B_1.Y=X3«.Y=w .Yp U 543 �V� Ç Ô 9 Õ �y[X3B543�7C[X3�0 F 087C3 W U 02.1=Xp@l U 3B54.13B0q�y.¾7C[ 9\=�9�c>36549\p>3�<\a Ä 74365 W 0kf¸3B5kl U 365 F0 U fXf¸<\527C0�9\=�9�c\365C9;p>3"l U 365 F 543602f¸<\=X043"7C. W 3 U =XDX3B5 z�Å 043 ] <>=XDX0�9;7 | � | ] < W©W 9\=XDX0«f¸3B5043 ] <>=�D � 74[X3'0 F 087C3 W U 04.Y=Xp»l U 3652.13B0��y.Y7C[9;=9}c\36549\p>3%<\a Ì 74365 W 0�fi365Zl U 3B5 F 0 U fXfi<>52740�9543B04fi<>=X023©7C. W 3 U =XDX365 z}Å 043 ] <>=XDX0¶9;7 z ���@] < W©W 9\=XD�0qfi365q043 ] <>=�D � �y[X. ] [�.10 Î 7C. W 3B0q_Y36020

z Ë �

Page 164: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

F $�%(' ç*),+#- ç -.)A/ ��1@2B3C4 ç6%7+98 ç6: 2,1<;��1�ì�5kí�î �>=¨�©ü ÿ�= � ù ? ï�â ü � é � ÷ ùç )AG `e: 2B1 ) ` ] 4 +>c æd%@z 1 ` 1(4 c ç % \ c n�+�©� ��1�ì�5kí!î � V ��1�ì�5kí!î ��1�ì�5kí!î ù ÷

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

Partitioning (8 servers)Replication (Pdist=20%)Replication (Pdist=40%)Replication (Pdist=60%)

å{1�è êU1�ìB8�5�1�ã�ì�í!ê�ã65ká�1q8�5kà©ë

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 5 10 15 20

Ave

rage

Que

ry R

espo

nse

Tim

e (S

econ

ds)

Command Arrival Rate (requests per second)

Partitioning (8 servers)Col.sel.(top 25%, Zipf)

Col.sel.(top 25%, uniform)Col.sel.(top 50%, Zipf)

Col.sel.(top 50%, uniform)

åpï$è á!à©ãkãkí!á 8�5kà©ëDâ�í�ãkí!áS8�5kà©ëõ ò ß�%SýÂà Öÿr�Sÿ ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3��y[X36=�023�9\5 ] [X.1=�p»9�74365C9 E�F 743«<\ao743�µV7 U 04.1=�p{9\=�9}c\36549\p>3«<;a Ì7C3B5 W 0

7C[X9\=q74[X3A0 F 087C3 W U 02.1=Xp Ä 7C3B5 W 0 � ,/.1087C5C9 ] 7C.Y=Xp Ä\Ŧq'� Ë Å¦q'� 9\=XD Æ>Ŧq <\a ] < W�W 9;=XDX0`.1= ] 54369\043B07C[�3/_h9\52p>36087 ] < W©W 9\=XD%9;5454.¾c;9\_�5C9;743��y.Y74[@9\=@9�c>36549\p>3�523604fi<>=X023/7C. W 3 E 3B_1<}� z}Å 043 ] <>=�DX0 E�F9�a¦9 ] 74<>5m<\a z � Ç��iÄ � z>� 9\=XD Ç � Î �J = w .Yp U 543 �^� Ë Ô E Õ � ��3ZDX3 W <>=X087C5C9�7C3�7C[�3Z9�c>36549\p>3Z523604fi<>=X023Z7C. W 3��y[�36=»�t3Z0236_Y3 ] 7�74[X3¶74<>fÄ>Î#q 9\=XD Î\Ŧq <\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 U 04.1=�p G .1f�a�9\=XD U =�.Yan<>5 W DX.Y027454. E U 7C.Y<>=X0 �¶T 3B_13 ] 7C.Y=Xp%7C[X3�74<>fÄ>Î#q 9\=XD Î\Ŧq <;a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0 U 04.Y=Xpk7C[X3 G .1f^a¸D�.1027454. E U 7C.Y<>=Z. W fX52<Âc\360A7C[�3K_19\54p\36027 ] < W�W 9\=�D9\5254.Yc;9\_V5C9�7C3o�y.Y74[�9\=�9�c>36549\p>3m523604fi<>=X023m7C. W 3 E 36_Y<}� z}Å 023 ] <>=XDX0 E�F 9�a¦9 ] 7C<>5e<;a z � Ì 9\=XD z � Ä �T 3B_13 ] 7C.Y=Xpq74[X3y7C<>f Ä>Î#q 9\=�D Î\Ŧq <\a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 U 04.1=�p U =�.Yan<>5 W DX.1087C52. E U 74.1<>=�. W fX52<}c>360º7C[�3

z Ë Ì

Page 165: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

_h9;54p>3B027 ] < W©W 9\=XD"9\5254.¾c\9;_e5C9;743��y.Y74[�9\= 9�c>3B5C9\p\3©523604fi<>=X023�74. W 3 E 36_1<}� z}Å 043 ] <>=XDX0 E�F 9a¦9 ] 7C<>5m<\a¢Ë � Å 9\=XD Ä � Å �s [X3º543B0 U _¾7C0`<\a�74[X.10`023 ] 74.1<>=k02[X<}��7C[X9;7S9\_¾7C[X< U p>[/7C[X3A0 F 027C3 W U 04.Y=Xpm_1<\=Xp>365Öl U 3654.Y360S.1= ] 54369\043B07C[�3�523602f¸<>=�043�7C. W 3 � .¾7�DX<V360k=X<\7q02.1p>=X.¾j ] 9;=�74_ F ] [g9\=Xp\3�74[X3�5436_19;7C.¾c>3Z. W fX52<}c>3 W 36=�7kD U 3�74<] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=%0236_13 ] 74.1<>=�9\=XD@fg9;527C.19\_I5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\= �

¥w)�¡ �[Z68 8\<K0�]s [X.Y0�023 ] 74.1<>=�fX543B043B=�7436D»7C[�3�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�<\ae< U 5KDX.1087C54. E U 7436D JLu 0 F 027C3 W an<\5�023�9\5 ] [X.1=Xp«97C3B5C9 E�F 7C3k<\aS743�µV7 � � 3/jg54087®¼ U 0274.Yjg3BD%7C[g9;7m9�5436f�_1. ] 9¶�y.Y74[ Ç�Ä O � .Y0o0 U À ] .13B=�7m74<�027C<\543/7C[�3DX< ]6U W 36=�740K<;a¢74[X3�7C<>f@7C<>f�. ] 0o74[g9;7K0C9�7C.108a F Ë Å#q <\a®l U 3654.Y360K9 ]B] <>52DX.1=XpZ74<�74[X3qîµ ] .Y743q_Y<>p �� 3K74[X36=©fX543B0436=�7436D@9\=XD ] < W fg9\5236D�7C[X3Kfi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3 U 02.1=Xpqfg9\587C.19\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=Z543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=9\=XD ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=Zan<>5AD�.Yظ36543B=�7�0 F 027C3 W ] <>=�jXp U 5C9�7C.1<\=X0 �¢Ç�Ä O � fi365º043B52c\365 �¸zÂÄ\Ì O �fi365b043658c>3B5¢�y.Y74[�_19\54p\365`DX.Y04´ � U 02.1=Xpya¦9\087C365b043B52c\36540e9\=XDq=X3B7É��<>54´�0 � 9\=XD U 04.Y=Xp�_Y<>=Xp>3B5Sl U 3654.Y360 �M U 5b54360 U _Y740®02[X<}��7C[g9;7 U 02.1=Xp�<>=X3t5236fX_Y. ] 9y74<�DX.Y027C549 ] 7 Ä\Ŧq 9;=XD U 02.1=Xp Ä 5236fX_Y. ] 9;0S74<�DX.Y02745C9 ] 7Ë Å¦q 9;=XD Æ>Å#q <\a ] < W�W 9\=�DX0�. W f�54<}c>3B0¹74[X3�_19\54p\36027 ] < W©W 9\=XD�9\5254.¾c\9;_g5C9;743 U =�DX365�9 ]BU 7C<\Øan<>5q7C[X3%9�c\365C9;p>3'l U 365 F 523604fi<>=X023'7C. W 3 E�F 9�a¦9 ] 7C<>5�<\a z � Ç��ºÄ � Ä^� 9;=XD Ç � Î �"T 3B_13 ] 7C.Y=Xp)7C[�37C<\f Ä>Î#q <\a Ì ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0º. W fX52<Âc\360º7C[X3�_h9\52p>36087 ] < W�W 9\=�D'9\5254.Yc;9\_g549;7C3 U =XDX3B5o9 ]BU 7C<;Ø�an<\57C[�3�9}c\36549\p>3Zl U 365 F 543B04fi<>=X023�74. W 3 E�F 9«a¦9 ] 7C<\5/<\a z � Ì �y[X36="7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>={04´;3B� an<>_1_Y<Â�y07C[�3 G .Yf�a�DX.1087C54. E U 74.1<>= � s [�36043�543B0 U _¾7C0�0 U p\p>36087©74[g9;7�fg9\587C.h9;_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=9;=XD] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=%0236_13 ] 74.1<>= ] 9\=�04.Yp>=X.¾j ] 9\=�74_ F . W f�54<}c>3/74[X3�0 F 027C3 W f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3/an<>5y04369\5 ] [�.1=Xp©97C3B5C9 E�F 7C3¶<\aA7C3Úµ^7 � M U 5�54360 U _Y740/9\_Y04<©04[X<}�-7C[g9;7�9\_¾7C[X< U p>[�74[X3 F 9;ظ3 ] 7�7C[X3¶543602f¸<\=X043¶74. W 3 �=X<>=�3¶<\ae74[X3 W ] [g9\=�p>3¶5236_h9�7C.Yc\3�. W f�54<}c>3 W 3B=�740�D U 3�7C<©fg9\587C.h9;_b5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=�9\=XD ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=��y.Y74[ U =�.Yan<>5 W 9 ]B] 36020 � w <>5 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=9 ]B] 36020��y.¾7C[7C[X3 G .Yf�a ½ _Y.1´\3©DX.1087C52. E U 74.1<>=Ô ��o z Õ � 74[X3�= U W¶E 3B5�<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0K9;ظ3 ] 7C0y7C[X3qf¸<\f U _h9;54.Y7 F <\ae74[X3 W <>087Kan5236l U 3B=�74_ F U 0236D] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=@9\=�D@74[ U 0�9�ØÖ3 ] 7C0yfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 �

z Ë |

Page 166: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

���v�'&����)� {

� $ &ö�����-�K� $ &ö�

s [X3kp><�9;_Ö<\ab7C[X.Y0mDX.102043B527:9�7C.1<\='�o9\0m74<ZDX3Bc\36_1<\f)9\=�D�3�c;9\_ U 9�7C3�DX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D%.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=©543 ½7C52.13�c\9;_Ö9\5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 52360o7C[X9;7y9;727:9\.Y='l U . ] ´©543602f¸<\=X043/an<>5t5C9\fX.YDX_ F .Y= ] 523�9\02.1=Xp�DX9;7:9�9;=XD%�t<>52´ ½_1<>9\DX0��y[X.1_Y3 W 9\.1=�7C9\.1=X.Y=Xp»543�7C52.13Bc;9\_�9 ]B]6U 549 ] F � M U 5©9\5 ] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 54360«.1= ] _ U DX3 ] < W fi<>=X3B=�7407C[X9;7�DX<"=X<\7�9;fXf¸369\5Z.1=fX523BcV.1< U 0 JLu 9\5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 543B0 � fg9;527C.19\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=�9;=XD043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 9\=XD ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � � 3 ] <>=X04.YDX365236D E <\74[·fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�9;=XD�9 ]B]6U 549 ] FÔ 3�À ] .13B= ] F 9;=XD3Bظ3 ] 74.Yc\36=X3B040 Õ <\a JLu 0 F 02743 W 0«9;=XD[X<}� 7C< W 9\´\3 E 36087 U 043�<\a�9�c\9;.1_h9 E _13543B04< U 5 ] 3B0 � J ='7C[X.Y0�jg=X9\_ ] [g9;f�7C3B5 � ��3�0 U W�W 9;54. ¿ 3K74[X3/52360 U _Y7C0m<;aS3�9 ] [ ] [g9\f^7C365 � 543�cV.13B�7C[�3543B04369\5 ] [ ] <>=�7C52. E U 7C.1<\=X0m<\ab7C[X.Y0mDX.1020436587:9;74.1<>= � 9\=XD�DX.10 ]6U 020Ka U 7 U 523q5236023�9\5 ] [)DX.Y543 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 �

{})+( �[Z68 8\<K0 ?7.�WJ =�74[X.10yDX.Y040236527C9;7C.Y<>= � ��3�jg52027�.1=�c>3B0274.1p�9;7436D�[X<}��7C< U 043qfg9\587C.19\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>='an<\5.1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>=k543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_ � 9\=�D¶7C[X3B=�fX5236043B=�7C36D�9\=�D�3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C3BD�DX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D¶9\5 ] [�.Y7C3 ] 7 U 543B0®7C[g9�7.1= ] <>52f¸<>549;7C3�fg9\549\_1_Y36_�.1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>=©523B7454.13�c;9\_ � fg9\587C.h9;_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=«9\=XD%0236_13 ] 74.1<>= �9\=XD ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\='043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � � 3�3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C3BD'7C[X3�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3/. W fX52<Âc\3 W 36=�7C0tD U 3/7C<Z369 ] [@<\a7C[�36043o74[X543B3 ] < W fi<>=X36=�740A<>=X3 E�F <>=�3 � � 3y9\_Y04< ] < W fX9\543BD�7C[X3mfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3o<\a�fg9\587C.19\_ ] <>_ ½_13 ] 74.1<>='5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=©�y.¾7C[ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=©fg9\5274.Y74.1<>=X.Y=Xp � 9\0t��36_Y_I9\0 ] < W fg9\543BD%fg9\587C.h9;_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>="�y.Y74[ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= 0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= � � 3 U 043BD�.1=�an3B5436= ] 3%=X3�7É�t<>52´�0�74<{043B_13 ] 7Z5236_13�c;9\=�7543BfX_1. ] 9\0y9;=XD ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0m.1=%<\54DX3B5y74< W 9\.Y=�7:9\.Y='543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_`3�ØÖ3 ] 7C.¾c>3B=X36020 �J = r [g9\f^7C365�Ë � ��3Z.1=�c\360274.1p�9�7C36D U 04.Y=Xp'fg9\587C.19\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=�an<\5�.1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>=@543 ½7C52.13�c\9;_ � M U 5%9\=g9;_ F 043B0%<>=9 ] 7 U 9\_�0 F 027C3 W _1<>p\0«DX3 W <>=�027C549;7C3BD�7C[g9;7%74[X36523».10'0 U À ] .Y36=�7l U 365 F _1< ] 9\_Y.Y7 F 7C<«¼ U 087C.¾a F fg9\587C.19\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>= � M U 5�3BcV.1DX3B= ] 3�9\_Y04<".1=�DX. ] 9;7C3BD

zÂÎ\Å

Page 167: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

7C[X9;7k9'04369\5 ] [X9 E _13Z5236fX_Y. ] 9'9 ] [X.Y3Bc>3B0 E 3�747C3B5/fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3�7C[g9\= ] 9 ] [X.Y=Xp@l U 3654.Y360 �`E 3 ] 9 U 0237C[�3t543BfX_1. ] 9K0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�9\_Yp><>54.¾7C[ W jg=XDX0®04. W .1_19\54.¾7 F�E 3B7É��363B=�=X<>= ½ .1DX3B=�74. ] 9\_�l U 3654.Y360 � 9\=XD¶74[ U 0.1= ] 54369\043B0®7C[�3o< E 023652c\36D�_1< ] 9;_1.Y7 F � � 3�fX543B043B=�7436D©9 W 3B7C[�<^Dqan<>5 ] <>=X02745 UX] 7C.Y=Xp�9�[X.Y36549\5 ] [ F <\afg9\587C.19\_`543BfX_1. ] 9\0man54< W 9 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=@�y[X36523¶369 ] [{543BfX_1. ] 9�.10�9©0 U E 043�7�<\ae9\_1_S_h9;54p>3B5K5236fX_Y. ] 9\0 �� 3�3ÚµV7C36=�DX36D³7C[[email protected]=^an36543B= ] 3@=X3�7É�t<\54´ W <^DX3B_t7C<"549\=X´�9\=�DÙ0236_13 ] 7�fg9\587C.19\_t5236fX_Y. ] 9;0 � � 3fX52<>f¸<\0436D@9�=�3B��5436f�_1. ] 9�0236_13 ] 74.1<>='a U = ] 7C.Y<>=%9\=�D%04[X<}��36D@7C[g9;7o.Y7¹�t<>52´�0 E 3B727C3B5tan<>5t5236fX_Y. ] 9043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�74[g9\=�<\74[X365�5C9\=�´V.Y=Xp�a U = ] 74.1<>=X0 � � 3'3�µ�9 W .1=�36D�74. W 3«9;=XD�04fX9 ] 3'<}c\3654[�3�9\DX0�74<E U .Y_1D·9\=XD U fiDg9;743)543BfX_1. ] 9\0«9\=XD�74[X3{543BfX_1. ] 9 0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�Dg9;7C9 E 9\023 � +�_Y7C[�< U p>[ U f¸Dg9�7C.1=�p_h9;54p>3�5436f�_1. ] 9\0o.Y0 ] <>087C_ F>� an<>587 U =X9;7C3B_ F>� 7C[X3�027:9�7C.1087C. ] 0tan52< W 74[X3�54369\_I0 F 087C3 W _1<>p\0o04[X<}�7C[g9�7U fiDg9;74.1=Xp%[X< U 54_ F <>5�DX9\.1_ F .Y0 U =X=�3 ] 3B04049\5 F 7C[X9;7 W 9\´\3B0k74[X3 U fiDg9;743�9;ØÖ<\54Dg9 E _13 � � 3�9\_102<fX52<>f¸<\0436D@7É��<©02. W fX_13/087C549;7C3Bp>.13B0yan<\5 U f¸DX9;7C.Y=Xp�5436f�_1. ] 9\0 �s <©3Úµ�fi36D�.Y7C3q< U 5y.Y=�c\36087C.1p>9;7C.Y<>=@<\aefi<>0402. E _Y3�0 F 02743 W ] <>=^jgp U 549;7C.Y<>=X0 � ] [X9\5C9 ] 7C3B54.1087C. ] 0y<\a JLu] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 � 9\=XD)74[X3 E 9\02. ] JLu 0 F 027C3 W fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 � �t3�. W f�_13 W 36=�7436D{9©04. W U _h9;74<>5o�y.Y74[= U W 3654< U 0y0 F 02743 W fg9\549 W 3�7C3B540 � � 3kfX543B043B=�7436D»9;=XD�c;9\_Y.1Dg9�7C36D'74[X3k04. W U _h9�7C<>5m9;p�9\.1=�027m< U 5fX52<\7C<\7 F fi3k. W fX_13 W 3B=�7C9;7C.Y<>='.Y= r [g9\f�74365 Î �J = r [g9\f�74365 Æ�� �t3�jg52027y3�µ^fX_Y<>543BD@[X<}��74< E U .1_YD'[X.Yp>[%f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3 JLu 043658c>3B540 U 04.Y=XpZ0 FVW ½W 3B7C52. ] W U _Y74.1fX52< ] 360402<>540 � � 3Z.1=�c>3B0274.1p�9;7436D [X<}� 74< E 9\_h9;= ] 3�74[X3Z[g9\52D��o9;543�9\=XD"04<;a�7É�o9\523543B04< U 5 ] 3B0e�y.Y74[Z543602f¸3 ] 7A74</= U W�E 365e<\ag74[X54369\DX0 � r ? R 0 � 9\=XD¶DX.102´V0º9;0®7C[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�02. ¿ 3o.1= ½] 523�9\02360 � � 3/.1=�c\360274.1p�9�7C36D'74[X3�a¦9 ] 7C<>520t7C[X9;7y9;ظ3 ] 7o7C[X3�=X3 ] 3604049\5 F = U W�E 3B5o<\aS7C[�543�9;DX0 � � 304[�<Â��36D�7C[X9;7A9\D�DX.1=Xp�DX.102´V0 ] 9\=ZDX3Bp>5C9;DX3t7C[�3of¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3¹�y[X36=�74[X3 r ? R .10®9 E <;747C_Y36=X3 ] ´ �9\=XD"9;DXDX.1=�p r ? R 0�DX<V360/=�<\7/. W fX52<}c>3�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3��y[X3B="74[X3�DX.Y04´�.10�9 E <\727C_Y36=X3 ] ´ � J = ½] 523�9\02.1=Xp�74[X3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=©04. ¿ 3�DX<V360o=X<;7y04.1p\=X.Yj ] 9\=�7C_ F ] [X9\=Xp>3/74[X3�[g9\52D��o9;543 E 9\_19\= ] 3/f¸<\.1=�7 �9\=XD»74[X3�043658c>3B5�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�.10 W <>543¶5436_19;7C3BD»7C<%7C[X3 E 9\_h9\= ] 3Z<\a�[g9\52D��o9;543 ] < W fi<>=X3B=�7407C[X9\=Z7C[X3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�02. ¿ 3 � � 3mfX543B043B=�7436D©043Bc\36549\_gan<>5 W U _h9\0®74[g9;7 U 023y04. W fX_Y3 W 3�9\0 U 543 W 3B=�7407C<�3B0274. W 9;7C3¹7C[X3m=X3 ] 3B040C9;5 F = U W�E 365e<;ai74[X54369\DX0 � 7C[X3m= U W�E 365A<;a r ? R 0¹9\=XDZDX.Y04´�0e7C[g9�7 ] <>= ½0274.Y7 U 7C3«9��t3B_1_ ½ E 9\_19\= ] 36D�0 F 087C3 W � � 3'9\_Y04< ] < W fg9\543BD�7C[�3'f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3©<\ayfg9\587C.Y74.1<>=�.1=Xp9\=XD�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1=Xp¶Dg9;7:9Z<}c>3B5�9;DXDX.Y74.1<>=X9\_ÖDX.Y04´�0 �

zÂÎ^z

Page 168: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

� 3¶7C[X3B=".1=�c>3B027C.Yp�9;7436D{7C[�3Zf¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3¶<;a�fX9\5274.h9\_b543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=�.1=»9'DX.Y027454. E U 7C3BD JLu 0 F 0 ½7C3 W � � 3�02[X<}�t3BD�7C[�3Zl U 365 F _Y< ] 9\_1.¾7 F DX3B74365 W .1=�360/7C[�3Z. W fX54<}c>3 W 3B=�7kD U 3Z7C<%fg9;527C.19\_ ] <>_ ½_13 ] 74.1<>="543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= � _1<>9\D E 9\_h9;= ] .Y=Xp%.10�=X3 ] 3B040C9;5 F �y[X36="7C[X3�543BfX_1. ] 9\0�D�.102745C9 ] 7�7C<V< W 9\= F] < W©W 9\=XDX0 � � 3%9\_102<{04[�<Â��36D7C[X9;7�fg9;527C.19\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=��y.¾7C[�_Y<�9\D E 9;_h9\= ] .1=Xp] <\=X04.Y027C3B=�7C_ F fi3658an<>5 W 0 E 3�7474365k7C[g9\= ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>="fg9\587C.¾7C.1<\=X.1=Xp � 3Bc\36=��y.¾7C[ an3B��365q[g9\54D^�o9\523543B04< U 5 ] 3B0 � 9\=�D¶543Bl U .152360 W <VDX36087®l U 3B5 F _1< ] 9\_Y.Y7 F � +Ù[X.13B5C9\5 ] [ F <;ag543BfX_1. ] 9\0`a U 587C[X3B5®.1= ] 54369\043B0fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3/an<\5m_h9\52p>3 ] < W�W 9\=XD%5C9�7C360K9\=�D�[X.Yp>[@DX.1087C549 ] 74.1=XpZfi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>360 �� 3�9;_104<m.Y=�c>36087C.Yp�9;7C3BDq74[X3ºf¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3A<\a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=/0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=k.Y=�9mDX.Y027454. E U 7C3BD JLu 0 F 02743 W �� 3�04[�<Â��36D%74[X3�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=©0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=©.10¹DX3B74365 W .Y=X36D E�F 7C[�3�fi<>f U _19\54.¾7 F <\a7C[�3 W <\027/an5236l U 36=�74_ F U 0436D ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=)9\=XD{74[X3�= U W�E 365�<\aº0236_Y3 ] 7436D ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0 � � 3�9\_102<] < W fg9;5436D»74[X3�f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�<\a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>={0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=»�y.¾7C["fg9\587C.h9;_ ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>={5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= �M U 5y543B0 U _¾7C0y04[X<}��36D)74[g9;7K36.¾7C[X3B5m<\a®74[X36023q7É��<�7C3 ] [�=X.1l U 3B0 ] 9;=�fi3658an<>5 W 0 E 3�7474365y7C[g9\=@7C[�3<\74[X365 U =XD�365S04< W 3 ] .Y5 ]BU W 087:9\= ] 360 � ?¢9\5274.h9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=/543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=�.Y0 E 3�747C3B5I7C[g9;= ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>='�y[X3B=�9Z0 F 087C3 W [g9\0m[X.Yp>['l U 3B5 F _Y< ] 9\_1.¾7 F � r <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=«0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=%f¸3B52an<>5 W 0 E 3B727C3B57C[X9\=�fg9\587C.19\_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=»�y[X36=�74[X3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�9 ]6] 36020�.10qa¦9\.152_ F U =�.Yan<>5 W 9;a�7C3B5] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\= �AE U 7 E 3 ] 9 U 023%<\ay_1< ] 9\_Y.Y7 F\� 7C[�.10�52360 U _Y7�.Y0 U =X_Y.1´;36_ F 74< E 3'523�9\_Y. ¿ 36D�.Y=fX549 ] 74. ] 3 �J = r [g9;f�7C3B5 � � � 3©fX543B043B=�7436D3�µ^fi3652. W 36=�7C0qan<>5k043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp»9�7436549 E�F 743«<\at7C3�µV7 U 04.Y=Xp)< U 57C3 ] [X=X<>_Y<>p>.Y360 � � 3�f�54360236=�7C3BD�9;=XD ] < W fg9;5436D{74[X3�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 U 02.1=Xp'fX9\5274.h9\_S543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=9\=XD ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=Zan<>5AD�.Yظ36543B=�7�0 F 027C3 W ] <>=�jXp U 5C9�7C.1<\=X0 �¢Ç�Ä O � fi365º043B52c\365 �¸zÂÄ\Ì O �fi365b043658c>3B5¢�y.Y74[�_19\54p\365`DX.Y04´ � U 02.1=Xpya¦9\087C365b043B52c\36540e9\=XDq=X3B7É��<>54´�0 � 9\=XD U 04.Y=Xp�_Y<>=Xp>3B5Sl U 3654.Y360 �M U 5b54360 U _Y740®02[X<}��7C[g9;7 U 02.1=Xp�<>=X3t5236fX_Y. ] 9y74<�DX.Y027C549 ] 7 Ä\Ŧq 9;=XD U 02.1=Xp Ä 5236fX_Y. ] 9;0S74<�DX.Y02745C9 ] 7Ë Å¦q 9\=XD Æ>Å#q <\a ] < W©W 9\=XDX0t. W fX54<}c>3/74[X3�_h9;54p>3B027 ] < W©W 9\=XD@9;5454.¾c;9\_¸549;7C3 U =XDX365y9 ]BU 7C<\Øan<>5y7C[X3�9�c>3B5C9\p>3�543B04fi<>=X043�7C. W 3 E�F 9�a¦9 ] 74<>5K<\a z � Ç��ÖÄ � Ä^� 9\=XD Ç � Î^� 523604fi3 ] 7C.¾c>36_ F ��T 36_Y3 ] 7C.1=�p7C[�3K74<>f Ä\Î#q <\a Ì ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0A. W fX54<}c>3B0A7C[X3K_h9\52p>36087 ] < W�W 9\=XD©9\5452.Yc;9\_�549;7C3 U =XD�365�9 ]BU 7C<\Øan<>5�7C[X3)9}c\36549\p>3{523604fi<>=X023{7C. W 3 E�F 9 a¦9 ] 74<>5«<\a z � Ì �y[X36=�74[X3 ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=³04´;3B� an<>_1_Y<Â�y07C[�3 G .Yf�a�DX.1087C54. E U 74.1<>= � s [�36043�543B0 U _¾7C0�0 U p\p>36087©74[g9;7�fg9\587C.h9;_ ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=9;=XD

zÂÎ>Ä

Page 169: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=%0236_13 ] 74.1<>= ] 9\=�04.Yp>=X.¾j ] 9\=�74_ F . W f�54<}c>3/74[X3�0 F 027C3 W f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3/an<>5y04369\5 ] [�.1=Xp©97C3B5C9 E�F 7C3K<\a¸7C3�µV7 � M U 5¹52360 U _Y740�9;_104<q04[�<Â��36D©7C[g9;7�9\_¾7C[X< U p>[ U 04.Y=Xpkan3B��365�9\=XD�a¦9\0274365¹043658c>3B5409\=XD³.1020 U .Y=Xp"_1<>=�p>365Zl U 3B54.13B0«9�ØÖ3 ] 7�7C[X3�9 E 04<>_ U 7C3@543B04fi<>=X023�74. W 3 � =X<>=X3@<\a�7C[X3 W ] [g9\=�p>3543B_h9;74.Yc\3m. W fX54<}c>3 W 3B=�7C0ºD U 3y7C<qfg9\587C.h9;_X543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=Z9;=XD ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=Z0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=��y.¾7C[ U =X.Yan<\5 W9 ]B] 36020 � � [�36=Ù74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=9 ]6] 36020©an<>_Y_1<}�y0�7C[X3 G .Yf�a ½ _Y.1´\3«DX.1087C54. E U 74.1<>= Ô �|o z Õ 9;a�7C3B5] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=%0236_13 ] 74.1<>= � 5436D UX] .Y=XpZ7C[X3k= U W�E 365y<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=%9 ] [X.Y3Bc\360 E 3�747C3B5yf¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 �

{})VU �-24AxE�0 ?G36Z[E�?G24A�Ws [X.Y0�DX.Y040236527C9;7C.Y<>=)f�54360236=�7C0/9©04.Yp>=X.¾j ] 9\=�7�027436f)74<Â�t9\52DX0�fX52<}c^.YDX.1=�p�a¦9\087/9;=XD)3�ØÖ3 ] 7C.¾c>3�D�.10 ½7C52. E U 7C36D�.1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>="543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_º.1=�_h9\52p>3 ½ 0 ] 9;_13�.1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>="543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_º0 F 02743 W 0 � � 3©fX543 ½043B=�7C36D)9\=XD@3Bc;9\_ U 9;[email protected]. E U 7436D�9\5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 543B0m7C[g9;7K9�747:9;.1=%l U . ] ´«543602f¸<\=X043kan<>5o549\fX.1D�_ F.1= ] 54369\04.Y=Xp»Dg9;7C9»9\=XD���<>54´�_1<>9\DX0��y[X.Y_13 W 9\.1=�7C9\.1=X.Y=Xp�543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_m9 ]B]6U 549 ] F � M U 5Z9\5 ] [X.Y743 ]Ú½7 U 54360Z.Y= ] _ U DX3 ] < W f¸<\=X36=�7C0�74[g9;7ZD�<{=X<\7�9;fXf¸369\5�.Y=�fX543�cV.1< U 0 JLu 9\5 ] [�.Y7C3 ] 7 U 543B0 � fX9\5274.h9\_] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=�9\=�D«043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � 9\=XD ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � � 3 ] <>=X04.YDX365236D E <\74[©fi365 ½an<>5 W 9\= ] 3k9\=XD�9 ]B]6U 549 ] F Ô 3BÀ ] .Y36= ] F 9\=XD�3Bظ3 ] 74.Yc\36=X3B040 Õ <\a JLu 0 F 027C3 W 0�9\=XD�[X<}�!74< W 9\´;3E 36027 U 023�<;ae9�c;9\.1_19 E _Y3�543B04< U 5 ] 3B0 � s [X3q04fi3 ] .¾j ]k] <>=�7454. E U 7C.Y<>=X0m<\ab7C[X.Y0mDX.102043B527:9�7C.1<\=�9;543 �

y w .Y54087`�t<>52´k<>=�fX9\5274.h9\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=k9\=XD�0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�.Y=�.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=/523B7454.13�c;9\_ �

z ¼ U 027C.¾a F .1=XpZ7C[�3 U 043Ba U _1=X3B040K<\a®fX9\5274.h9\_¸5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>='an<>5 JLu E 9\043BD)<>=%7C549 ] 3B0Q{

z D�3Bc>3B_1<>f�.1=Xp©9Z5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>=%9\5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 523${

z D�3Bc>3B_1<>f�.1=Xp³9\=�3Bظ3 ] 7C.¾c>3"543BfX_1. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�a U = ] 7C.1<\=�9\=XDDX3 W <>=X087C5C9�7C.1=�p�.Y740fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3${

z 3B0274. W 9;7C.Y=Xp U fiDg9;7C.Y=Xp ] <>087C0man<>5m5236fX_Y. ] 9;0y9\=XD�5436f�_1. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=@Dg9;7:9 E 9\043O{

z f�54<>fi<>04.Y=Xp U fiDg9;7C.Y=Xp�02745C9;7436p>.Y360 �

y T^] 9\_h9 E _13/D�.1027454. E U 7C3BD�9\5 ] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 54360�9\=XD�9\=@3Bc;9\_ U 9;74.1<>=%<\ab7C[�36.15mfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 �

z . W f�_13 W 36=�74.1=XpZ9;=XD�c;9\_Y.1Dg9�7C.1=�p�9�04. W U _h9;74<>5�an<\5mDX.1087C54. E U 7436D JLu 0 F 02743 W 0Q{

zÂÎ\Ç

Page 170: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

z fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�3�c;9\_ U 9�7C.1<\=³<;a�fg9\549\_1_Y36_o023652c\36520 U 04.Y=Xp�0 FVW©W 3B7454. ] W U _Y7C.YfX54< ] 3B0 ½02<>540b{

z fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3k3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>='<\a®fg9\5274.h9\_¸543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=I{

z ] < W fg9\54.Y04<>=@<\a¢fg9\587C.19\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=%5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>=%9\=XD ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>='fX9\5274.Y7C.Y<>=X.Y=Xp�{

z fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3k3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>='<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>='043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=I{

z ] < W fg9\54.Y04<>=@<\a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=%0236_13 ] 74.1<>=�9\=XD@fg9;527C.19\_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=«5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>=I{

z W 3 ] [X9\=X.10 W 0man<>5m023�9\5 ] [X.1=�p«9�7C3B5C9 E�F 7C3q<\ab7C3Úµ^7 �

{})eu # Z[E�Z�0�. ± 240��+�_¾7C[X< U p>["�t3©[g9�c>3«_19\54p\36_ F 9 ] [X.13�c>3BD�7C[X3�543B04369\5 ] [�p><>9\_A043�7¶an<>5�7C[�.10kDX.102043B527:9�7C.1<\= � 74[X365239\523k9�= U W�E 365y<\a¢DX.Y543 ] 7C.Y<>=X0o.Y=@�y[�. ] [@7C[X3���<>54´'.Y=%7C[X.Y0mDX.1020436587:9;74.1<>= ] 9\=�f U 540 U 3qa U 527C[�365 �

y u 36fX_Y. ] 9 T 36_Y3 ] 74.1<>= �+�_Y7C[�< U p>[�< U 5 ]6U 52543B=�7º5236fX_Y. ] 9�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�a U = ] 7C.1<\=��t<>52´�0ea¦9\.152_ F �t3B_1_ Ô 9\fXf�54<�µ^. W 9;7C3B_ Fz}Å#q fX523 ] .104.Y<>=�fi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3"_1<>020«an<>5«74[X3{7C<>f Ç\Å DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 Õ � 9 E 3B727C3B5'043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=a U = ] 7C.Y<>= W 9 F 3�µ^.Y027m7C[X9;7m543BD UX] 360m7C[X3�f�543 ] .102.1<>=%_Y<>040 � J =�9;DXDX.Y74.1<>= � �y[X3B=%�t3�7C3B027436D< U 5m0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\='a U = ] 74.1<>= � �t3 E U .1_Y7o5436f�_1. ] 9\0 U 02.1=XpZ74[X3/7C<>f@DX< ]6U W 3B=�740y<\a®369 ] [�l U 365 F52360 U _Y7C.Y=Xp©an52< W 04369\5 ] [X.Y=Xp@9\_Y_ ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0 � H <}�v�t3B_1_b< U 5Ka U = ] 74.1<>=��t<>52´�0/�y[X36={��3<>=�_ F U 023�74[X3�52360 U _Y740�an52< W 04369\5 ] [�.1=Xp�9�0 U E 043�7'<\a ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 Ô D U 3�74< ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=0236_13 ] 74.1<>= Õ =X363BDX0o7C< E 3�a U 527C[�365�7436087C36D � � 3�9\_Y04<�=�3636D'74<¶7C3B027m< U 5 ]6U 54543B=�7m043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=a U = ] 7C.Y<>= U 04.Y=Xp�_h9\52p>365 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0m9\=XD W <>543�l U 3B54.Y360 �

y r <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>= T 3B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= �� 3/=X3B36D%7C<ZDX3�c>3B_1<>f@9 E 3B727C365 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=«549\=X´�.1=Xp�a U = ] 74.1<>='74[g9;7 ] 9\=@fX52<^D U�] 3 ] < W ½fg9;5C9 E _Y3»543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_k9 ]B]6U 549 ] F �y[�36=�023�9\5 ] [X.1=XpÙ90 W 9\_1_/fi365 ] 3B=�7C9\p>3�<\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0 �02.1= ] 3�7C[X3 ]BU 545236=�7y5C9;=X´�.1=Xp¶a U = ] 74.1<>='<\=X_ F �t<\54´�0o�t3B_1_ian<>5t023�9\5 ] [X.1=XpZ74[X3�7C<\f Î\Ŧq <\a] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0 � +�_¾7C[X< U p>[)l U 3B5 F 3�µ^fg9\=�04.1<\= ] 9\={5236D U�] 3¶74[X3¶fX523 ] .104.Y<>=)_Y<>040K7C<«9\54< U =XD

zÂÎ Ë

Page 171: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

z}Å#q �y[X3B=©023�9\5 ] [X.1=Xp�74[X3o7C<>f z}Å#q <\a ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=�L �#� N � ��3Kf�543Ban3B5A7C<�DX3�c>36_Y<>f©9 E 3B727C3B5a U = ] 7C.Y<>=%.1=�027C369\D�<\abl U 365 F 3Úµ^fg9\=X02.1<>= �gE 3 ] 9 U 023ql U 3B5 F 3Úµ�fX9\=X04.Y<>=@=X363BDX0�9\DXDX.¾7C.1<\=g9\_] < W f U 7:9;74.1<>=©7C[g9;7o3�9\02.1_ F ] 9;= ] 3B_10m< U 7t7C[X3�fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3/p�9\.Y='D U 3�7C<Z023�9\5 ] [X.1=�p�_Y36020Dg9�7:9 � 9;0 ] < W fg9\543BD%�y.Y7C[ U 02.1=Xp�<>52.1p>.Y=g9\_il U 3654.Y360 �

y R =X.Ya F .1=�p u 3BfX_1. ] 9 T 3B_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�9\=XD r <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>= T 36_13 ] 74.1<>= �J =Z< U 5¢��<>54´ � ��3y9\040 U W 3t5436f�_1. ] 9�0236_13 ] 74.1<>=Z9;=XD ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=¶0236_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�9\543¹7É�t<kDX.Y027C.Y= ] 7fX52< ] 360204360 � J 7��y.Y_1_ E 3�.Y=�7C365236087C.1=�p©7C<�043B3��y[X3�7C[X3B5�< U 5�5236fX_Y. ] 9Z0236_13 ] 74.1<>=��t<>52´�0���36_1_.Y= ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>={043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= � J a¹7C[�.10/a U = ] 7C.Y<>={�t<\54´�0q��36_Y_ � ��3 W 9 F ] < W�E .1=X3�74[X36023�7É��<fX52< ] 360204360�.1=�7C<Z<\=X3 �

y r 9 ] [�.1=Xp �, U 52.1=Xp�< U 5%fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3»3�c;9\_ U 9�7C.1<\= � �t3"DX<=X<;7 ] <>=X02.1DX3B5 ] 9 ] [�.1=Xp � J 7%�y.1_Y_ E 3.Y=�743652360274.1=Xp�7C</.Y=�c\36087C.1p>9;7C3o[�<Â� ] 9 ] [X.1=�p�a U 5274[X365®. W fX54<}c>3B0®7C[�3o0 F 02743 W f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 �9\=�D�74< ] < W fg9\543 ] 9 ] [X.Y=Xp�74< E U .1_YDX.1=�p�fg9\587C.h9;_Ö543BfX_1. ] 9\0 �

y s 5C9 ] 3k+�=g9\_ F 04360 �J =�< U 5���<>54´ � 7C[�3©7C549 ] 3B0¶��3'< E 7C9\.1=X3BD�<>=X_ F 543BÏX3 ] 7¶7É�t<»02f¸3 ] .Yj ] JLu 9;fXfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=�0 �� 3¶=X3B36D{74<«< E 7C9\.1= W <\543k7C5C9 ] 360�7C<'9;=g9\_ F ¿ 3�7C[�3 U 02365�9 ]B] 3B040/fg9�747C3B54=X0�.1=)D�.Yظ36543B=�79\f�fX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=X0 � 9;=XD"< E 7:9;.1=)74[X3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=»9 ]B] 3B040kfg9;727C3652=X0�.1="9 W U _Y74.1fX_Y3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=023�9\5 ] [X.1=Xp�36=�cV.152<>= W 36=�7 �

y H 3B7C3B54<>p\36=X3B< U 0�ú=�cV.152<>= W 36=�7C0 �s [X3q�t<\54´�DX3 W <>=X087C5C9�7C36D).1=@7C[X.Y0�DX.Y040236527C9;7C.Y<>= U 0436D"9�[X< W <>p>3B=X36< U 0�36=�cV.152<>= W 36=�7 �� 3�9\040 U W 36D"�t3 U 0236D�74[X3Z0C9 W 3 W 9 ] [X.Y=X360/�y.¾7C[»7C[X3Z049 W 3Z= U W�E 3B5k<\a r ? R 0¶9;=XDDX.Y04´�0 � 9;=XD U 043BD9{_1< ] 9\_¹9\523�9)=�3B7É��<>54´ � J =9\=�3B=�cV.Y54<>= W 36=�7��y.¾7C[�[�3B7C3B54<>p\36=X3B< U 0] < W f U 7C3B540k9\=XD È <>5 U 02.1=Xp�9«�y.1D�3©9;543�9'=�3B7É��<>54´ �bW 9\= F =X3B�ö.1040 U 360��y.Y_1_®< ]6]BU 5 � an<\53ÚµX9 W fX_Y3 � [�<Â�-7C<@<\ظ043�7�7C[X3Z02f¸3B36D DX.Yظ365236= ] 3Z<\a¹3�9 ] [ 043B52c\365k.1=»<>52DX365/74<%fX54<VD UX] 3[X.Yp>[%fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3�04.1= ] 3�74[X3 E 3B027yfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3/<\a W U _¾7C.1f�_13 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>='04369\5 ] [�.1=XpZ.Y09 ] [�.13Bc\36DZ�y[X3B=©9;_1_�043B52c>3B540 ] 9;=ZfX54<VD UX] 3o543B04fi<>=X043y9�7®7C[�3o0C9 W 3t74. W 3 � J =�9��y.1DX3t9\54369

zÂÎ>Î

Page 172: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

=X3�7É�t<\54´)0 UX] [ 9\0�74[X3 J =�7C3B54=X3�7 � [�<Â�v74<'54< U 7C3 W 36020C9\p\360�74<%9�c><>.YD»_1.1=�´ ] <>=Xp\360274.1<>=�0.Y0 W <>523 ] 54.¾7C. ] 9\_�74[g9\=.1=9_1< ] 9\_�9;543�9=X3�7É�t<>52´ � s [X36523Ban<>523�[�<Â�ô7C<Ù9\Dg9\f�7�< U 5743 ] [X=X<\_1<>p>.Y360m.Y=@74[g9;7y3B=�cV.Y54<>= W 36=�7K=X3B36DX0y7C< E 3q087 U D�.136D �

y R = ] <>=�7454<>_Y_h9 E _Y3�ÃA=�c^.Y54<>= W 3B=�740 �+�_1_�< U 5b�t<\54´k.1=k7C[X.Y0¢D�.1040236587:9;74.1<>=¶9\040 U W 3BD¶��3���<>54´q.1=�9 ] <>=�7C54<\_1_h9 E _13º36=�cV.152<>= W 36=�7 �. � 3 � � �t3�9\523�9 E _13�74<@9 ]6] 36020k9\_1_b.1=XD�. ] 3B0�74< E U .Y_1D»9«5236fX_Y. ] 9«043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>={Dg9;7C9 E 9\023 � 9;=XD] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=«0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�DX9;7:9 E 9\043 � s [X36523¶9\523�36=�cV.152<>= W 36=�7C0m�y[X3B543kDX< ]6U W 36=�7C0m�y.¾7C[X.Y=9�0 F 087C3 W .Y0'fX52<\7C3 ] 7C3BD � 9\=�D��3»�t3 ] 9;=<\=X_ F p U 36020%7C[X3B.15 ] <\=�7436=�7C0 E�F 043B=XDX.Y=XpfX52< E .Y=Xp�l U 3B54.13B0 � H <}�³74</9 ] [�.13Bc\3m[X.1p\[¶543�7C52.13Bc;9\_V9 ]B]6U 549 ] F U 04.Y=Xp�fX9\5274.h9\_�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=9\=�D ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=«0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=�.Y=%7C[X.Y0m´V.Y=XD�<\a®3B=�c^.Y54<>= W 3B=�7K=X3B36DX0y7C< E 3k027 U DX.13BD �

y d U _Y7C. W 3BDX.h9¶Ãº=�cV.152<>= W 36=�7C0 �J =%< U 5t�t<\54´ � �t3�<\=X_ F .1=�c\360274.1p�9�7C36D@9;=XD@3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C3BD«7C[X3k9;5 ] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 52360oan<>5t043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp743�µV7 � H <}� 74<�f�54<}cV.1DX3�a¦9\087k9\=XD"3�ØÖ3 ] 7C.¾c>3�543�7C52.13Bc;9\_®.1="9 W U _¾7C. W 3BDX.h9�36=�cV.154<\= W 3B=�7=X3B36DX0y7C< E 3k027 U DX.13BD �

s [X3 W <>027k. W fi<>527C9\=�7�fX52< E _13 W an<>5 JLu 0 F 027C3 W 0q.10/74<�9;747C9\.1=»l U . ] ´{543B04fi<>=X043�an<>5�549\fX.1D�_ F.1= ] 54369\04.Y=Xp³Dg9;7:9³9\=XD�t<\54´�_1<�9;DX0��y[�.1_13 W 9\.Y=�7C9\.1=�.1=Xp�523B7C52.13�c\9;_k9 ]6]BU 5C9 ] F>� 5236p�9\52DX_13B040�<\a] < W f U 7C.1=�p�3B=�c^.Y54<>= W 3B=�740�74[g9;7k�y.1_Y_ ] [g9\=Xp>3��y.Y74[ 74. W 3 � s [X.10qDX.Y04043B527C9;7C.Y<>=�9�747:9 ] ´\36D�<>=7C[�.10m´\3 F fX54< E _13 W 9\=XD W 9\DX3k04.Yp>=X.Yj ] 9\=�7 ] <>=�7C54. E U 74.1<>=X0 �

zÂÎ\Æ

Page 173: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

�Æ&1& �)&� ��}m �

����� � � $ ����� ����� $ &ö�

s [X3 syu à r ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0�9\543¶_h9\52p>3�7436027 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0�DX.Y027454. E U 7C3BD E�F N 9;74.1<>=g9;_ J =X087C.¾7 U 743�<\aT 7C9\=XDg9\52DX0¢9\=XD s 3 ] [�=X<>_1<\p F Ô NKJ T sKÕ an<\5S7436087C.1=�p�9\=�D ] < W fg9;54.1=�py74[X3 ]6U 525436=�7b7C3Úµ^7¢543�7C52.13Bc;9\_7C3 ] [X=X.Yl U 3606L Ç>ÆV��Ç � ��Ç>Ì^��Ç>|^� Ë Å N � J =�7C[�.10e7C[�3604.Y0 � �t3 U 023 syu à r ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0e9\0º< U 5A7C3B027 E 36D �

�Â)+( ³<FEY< �;2xZ�0�:=.XWsyu à r ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=�0 ] < W 3©an54< W z}Ì D�.Yظ36543B=�7�Dg9;7C9{04< U 5 ] 3B0 � 0 U�] [Ù9;0¶=X3��y0 � fg9;7436=�7C0 � 9;=XD7C[�3 � 3 E � � 3k_1.Y027y9\_Y_Ö7C[�3qDX9;7:9Z04< U 5 ] 360K.1=%7C[X.Y0m043 ] 7C.Y<>= �

á%á'ëP 36p�9;_¸.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>= W 9;DX3/9�c;9\.1_19 E _Y3 E�F 7C[X3�+ U 087C5C9;_1.h9;=«+o7474<>54=�3 F ½ O 36=X3B5C9\_jP 0o,/36fg9\587 W 36=�7 �J 7K.1= ] _ U D�360m_13Bp>.102_h9;74.1<>=«9\=XD�¼ U DXp W 36=�740 �

á%ê%óBñs [X3 w + s ÃeÍ s Dg9�7:9 E 9;043�<\ab.1=�D U 027454.19\_Ö5236_h9�7C.1<\=X0tDX< ]6U W 3B=�740y0 U fXf�_1.13BD E�F 7C[�3�+ U 087C5C9;_1.h9;=,/36fX9\527 W 3B=�7y<;a J =XD U 027454.h9;_ u 3B_h9;74.1<>=X0 �

á Ý~ �:�}��¾�¥¦�\�L�����C�:�:���q��Ü®��ÜA¥��:� �Öz}|>Ì>Ì��Öz}|>Ì>|��Öz}|>|>Å �

á Ý çÖí+öcV.1587 U 9;_1_ F ] < W fX_13�7C3 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=)<\aºfX52< ] 363BDX.1=Xp\0/�y.Y7C[�.1=�74[X3Z+ U 027C549\_1.19\= w 3BDX36549\_e?¢9\54_Y.h9 ½W 36=�7 Ô z�| � Å ½ z}|>|�Î Õ .1= ] _ U D�.1=Xp H 9\=X049\54D»5236fi<>52740/<\a E <\7C[ ] [X9 W�E 36540�f�_ U 0/=�<\7C. ] 3¶fX9\f¸3B540 �] < W©W .Y727C363�5436fi<>587C0y3B7 ]\�

zÂÎ �

Page 174: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

á�ù�ä�ó,/<}�y=X_1<>9\DX0�<\a¹7C[X3Z��3 E 02.Y74360q<>f¸3B5C9;7436D E�F 7C3B=�+ U 02745C9\_Y.h9\= R =X.Yc\365402.Y74.1360 � + U 087C549\_1.19\= N 9 ½7C.Y<>=g9\_ R =X.Yc\365204.Y7 F\� Ñ . ] 74<>54.19\= R =X.¾c>3B5404.¾7 F <\a s 3 ] [X=�<>_1<>p F>� P 9;7454< E 3 R =X.¾c>365204.¾7 F>� d U 54DX< ] [R =�.Yc>3B5402.Y7 F>� � 9\_1_19\5C9�7 R =X.¾c>3B5404.¾7 F>� ÃADX.¾7C[ r <}�o9\= R =X.¾c>3B5404.¾7 F>� R =X.Yc\365402.Y7 F <;a N 3�� ] 9\0274_13 �r [g9\52_13B0 T 7 U 527 R =X.Yc\365204.Y7 F\� R =�.Yc>3B5402.Y7 F <\a s 9;0 W 9\=X.h9 � +�DX36_19\.1D�3 R =�.Yc>3B5402.Y7 F>� 9\=XD'74[X3 R =�.10 ½3658c>3�9 ] 9;DX3 W . ]�] _13�9;54.1=�pZ[X< U 023 �

â�ñà����V§\�C�:�:��¥ ���i�$¹�Òy�¿¾:���2£ � 74[X3yfX54< ] 3B36DX.Y=Xp>0¹<\aÖ74[X3y_13Bp>.102_h9;74.Yc>3 E 5C9\= ] [«<\a¸7C[X3 R �ÐT O <}c>3B5 W 36=�7Ô z�|>|>Ç Õ �

ê)å�éT [X<\527K+ E 087C549 ] 740yan52< W , M ÃÙf U E _1. ] 9;74.1<>=�0 �

õmð�ó}îT 3B_13 ] 7C3BD»=X<>= ½ R �ÐT¸� E 52<�9\D ] 9\027/9\=XD»fX52.1=�7/f U E _1. ] 9;74.1<>=@an54< W w <>5236.Yp>= � 52<�9\D ] 9\027 J =�an<>5 W 9 ½7C.Y<>= T 3658cV. ] 3 �

õoñ�b�4£V���4�$¹�ÒK� §\¥1���É��� � 74[X3«<;À ] .h9\_A523 ] <>54D�<\ao7C[�3©3Úµ�3 ]6U 74.Yc\3 E 549\= ] [�<\at7C[X3 R �ÐT O <}c>3652= W 36=�7Ô z�|>Ì>|��Iz�|>Ì>Ì��¸z}|>| Ë Õ �

õmí�º¥��i�\��¾�¥¦�$¹¹�S¥��«�:� Ô z}|>Ì>Ì ½ z}|\|>Å��Iz}|\|�z ½ z�|>| Ë Õ �

ë��� ¹¾���4§V��ÜÙ�q���2�$¹¾£ � O _19\04p><}� � TV] <\74_h9\=XD � Ô z}|>|>Î ½ z}|>| � Õ �

ç¹áqíqó6ì�é�î+�587C. ] _13B0o7C[g9�7K9\fXfi3�9\5236D�.1=%7C[X3k=X3��y04fg9;f¸3B5   ~ �S¥��«�:� .Y= z�|>Ì>| 9\=XD z}|>|\Å �

zÂÎ\Ì

Page 175: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

ä�é�æ î ÷ hs [X3 N à � T�] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 ] <>=X02.1087S<\a R T à N à s�N à � T fi<>087C.1=�p>0 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C3BD E�F 7C[X3 R =X.Yc\365204.Y7 F<\a � 9�7C3652_1<V< � s [X3�.¾7C3 W 0A[g9�c\3 E 363B=�jg_¾7C3B5436D�7C<k523 W <Âc\3�02< W 3m<>5¹9\_1_^36= ] <^DX3BD E .Y=g9\52.1360º9;=XD. W 9\p>3�jg_13B0 �

Ý ákíqé�ä)íZîR �ÐT fg9;7C3B=�7C0 Ô z}|>|\Ç Õ �

Ý ë@ù@í?A54<�¼23 ] 7 O U 7C3B= E 3B54p ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�<;ay36_13 ] 7454<>=X. ] 7C549\=X0 ] 54.Yf�7C.Y<>=X0�<\aK< U 7 ½ <\a ½É] <>f F 54.1p\[�7 E <V<>´�0 �M E 7:9;.1=X3BD@an52< W 9�?A54<�¼23 ] 7 O U 7C3B= E 3652p w¢s ?·04.¾7C3 �

îh�Iì� �\�)¤g�}�}��� ���¿¾�¡V�Ú���q��Ü®� Ô z}|>|�z Õ �

æ é�ð �Sþ,/<}�y=X_1<>9\DX0b<\aX��3 E 02.Y7C3B0e<>fi36549;7C3BD E�Fi� + U 027C549\_1.19\= � 54<�9;D ] 9\087C.Y=Xp r < W©W .10204.1<\= � + U 087C5C9;_1.h9;=N 9�7C.1<\=g9\_ P . E 5C9\5 F>� + U 02745C9\_Y.h9\=",/3Bfg9\527 W 3B=�7�<\at,/3Ban36= ] 3 � + U 027C549\_1.19\= r < W f U 74365 T < ] .Y3B7 F>�w 36DX3B5C9\_�?¢9\54_Y.h9 W 36=�7A<;a r 9\=g9;Dg9 � r < W�W <>=���3�9\_¾7C[ T^] .136=�74.Yj ] 9\=�D J =XD U 027454.h9;_ u 3B043�9;5 ] [ M 5 ½p�9\=�.10C9�7C.1<\= �

æ îs����$¹Ç¹ � �ø�C�:���º¤���¡V�Ú�i�$¹ Ô z}|>Ì ��½ z}|\Ì>|��Iz}|\|>Å ½ z}|>|�Ä Õ �

� óBõmõ+�587C. ] _13B0oan54< W à������i¡^�É��� � ��¹1�¿¾��n� Ô G .¾Ø ½ ,�9�c^.Y0o? U E _Y.102[X.1=Xp Õ �

zÂÎ\|

Page 176: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

�Â)VU �}E�<FE�?7W`E�?G:=W 2*9������ � �v2x5G5G.X:�E�?G24A�W

~ ($<a1 I�Y}��1 ~ ^ < h'�E�13N�($U���61�7�* �J;�/ ^ <a13b�657G�� Å y�i j wfl y$l ¹ x | y��CF+ gPy$l j�j x ¹ m y |? ��+ � g ì�� Å y�i j x m j w ¹ i�x m �I��(Å y | suy�i j x | i�y ¹ | t jõ YZØ g j l j | w ¹ gPy mG�� Å y�y j t | | i ¹ i g�iì�� Å y�y j�m i g�i ¹ y�x m? ��+ � j  �I��(Å i m sui j j l j | l ¹ w j$mõ YZØ�j g | w w$x ¹ i j$mG�� Å i m j t | | y ¹ t j g��GV?B+ ~ ?�I j l�t x ¹ | g�g? ��+ � t I���E Å i0g j y | i m ¹ j w |õ YZØ t t�l�w g�x g ¹ m�j g� � j t�w j | ¹ i j�j? ��+ � l ì�� i�l t�i�w w�w ¹ x�t mì¼? w�x$l j g m ¹ gPw$yì��h��I l | m g�t m ¹ l | g? ��+ � w �×GV?s�!EH+ I l | w g�t g ¹ y�i�xGJGG� g�y | w w$x g ¹ w$x�xG��V� � |�| w l j ¹ y�l gG��>��? gPw$l m l j g ¹ x�y0gG � ~ � | j w y0g ¹ t�t$l�DA t�i$l g�t�w ¹ l |�|ì¼? w j | j$m�j ¹ l�t�t~ +� �I�m g i�w�w l�l�x ¹ g m x? ��+ � x � � � ~ +� �I�m�j i�l�t l�w m ¹ m�j |~ +� �I�m t i�t$l l�y j h t�i�w~ +� �I�m l i�x�x l�y�t ¹ g3l�w~ +� �I�m w g�g | m w$i m ¹ j$m�j~ +� �I�m x g�g j g w | g ¹ y�i0g~ +� �I�m | g m y m w j�m ¹ j y j~ +� �I�m y g | j y y�w�x ¹ x m i�Á���{? l�t0g t ¹ t m t Q+��,m g g�l j y ¹ w0g�t40K ^ 7B($KMK�? ��+ � g3suw /�;�KpKM1�/�6YM;�b 7í Þ��! nà á ÿ¦þgÿ s [X3 syu à r!r <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=X0

z}Æ>Å

Page 177: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

�Æ&¶&���&� !�}m �

���³���"��� � $ ² ��&v��xÖ-�K���

s [X.Y0Z9\fXfi36=XD�.¾µ�fX543B0436=�740©9;=g9\_ F 02360Z<\am7É��<"043658c>3B5�_Y<>p>0q�t3%< E 7:9\.Y=X36D�an52< W syH/M d�+ T � 9_13Bp>.102_h9;74.Yc\3{.1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>=�043B52cV. ] 3�<;a�74[X3 R � Ti� r <>=Xp>5236040@7C[�54< U p\[�.¾7C0 P . E 549\5 F L Î>Ä N � 9;=XDîµ ] .Y743 � 9 � 3 E 023�9\5 ] [)3B=Xp>.1=�3mL Ä � N �

�')+( �-,�.v��� $ ( ���×��2*�s [X3 syH/M d�+ T 0 F 02743 W .10b9y_13Bp>.102_h9;74.Yc>3®.1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=/043B52cV. ] 3t<\a^7C[X3 R �ÐT¸� r <>=Xp\5436020¢74[X54< U p>[7C[�3 P . E 549\5 F <\a r <>=Xp\5436020 � �y[X. ] [ U 043B0 J = Á U 365 F 9\0�74[X3�523B7454.13�c;9\_S36=Xp>.Y=X3 � J 7 ] <\=�7C9\.1=�0�7C[�3a U _Y_¸7C3ÚµV7�<;a E .Y_1_Y0t.1=�7454<VD UX] [email protected]='7C[�3 r <\=Xp>543B0402360yan54< Wèz}Å�z 087m7C< z}Å�Î 7C[�9\0o��36_1_I9\0m7C[X3/743�µV7<\ab7C[X3 r <>=�p>543B0404.Y<>=g9\_ u 3 ] <>54D�0yan<\5o7C[X<>023 r <\=Xp>543B0402360 �

ð ÿ¦þgÿøþ [ %SàVý h·ç*d i Þ� ò ü h� 3'3�µ�9 W .1=X3�7C[X3©l U 365 F _1< ] 9;_1.Y7 F{E�F 9\=g9;_ F ¿ .Y=Xp�74[X3'_1<\p)<\a syH�M d�+ T E 3B7É��3636= � U _ F³z Ë9\=XD T 3Bf�7C3 W�E 365 z}Ç��®z}|>|>Ì � � 3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7�74[X3�7C<;7:9\_¢= U W�E 3B5�<\a¹l U 3652.1360 � = U W�E 3B5/<\a U =X.Yl U 3l U 3652.13B0 � = U W¶E 3B5�<\a®7C<>fX. ] 0 � 9;=XD{<}c>3B54_h9;f)<\ae74<>fX. ] 0 E 3�7É�t3B36=»Dg9 F 0 � 9\=XD���363B´�0 ��T .1= ] 3�7C[�3_1<\p)DX<V360�=X<\7 ] <>=�7:9\.Y=�DX< ]6U W 36=�7¶.1DX3B=�74.Yjg3B540�543B7 U 54=�36D�an54< W 369 ] [�l U 365 F 3�c\9;_ U 9;74.1<>= � ��3E U .Y_Y7K9Z7C3B027�Dg9;7:9 E 9\043 U 02.1=Xp�7C[�3 r <>=�p>543B040 u 3 ] <>52D�an<>5 z}Å>Ç 54D r <>=Xp>5236020 Ô Ä;Ç�Î d � �¸Ä � |>|>ÄDX< ]6U W 36=�740 Õ � �y[X. ] [�.10¢9�fg9\587®<;aX7C[X3 syu à r Ë ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=�L Ç>| N � 9\=XD�9;_104<�9�fX9\527¢<\a ] <>_1_Y3 ] 74.1<>=syH/M d�+ T�U 043B0 � � 3«5436549\=�9\_Y_�l U 3B54.Y360Z9\p>9\.1=X087¶74[X.10q7C36087ZDg9;7C9 E 9\023 � 9\=�D�c^.Y3B� DX.Y027C.Y= ] 7l U 3652.13B0 E 3�9\0/74[X3�0C9 W 3Z.YaA74[X36.Y5/7C<>f Ä\Å DX< ]6U W 3B=�740 ] < W fX_13�7C3B_ F <Âc\3652_h9\f � . � 3 � � ��3�p>54< U f7C[�36043ql U 3652.13B0�9;=XD ] 9\_1_¸7C[X3 W 9�7C<>fX. ]\� s 9 E _Y3 ��� z 7C< ��� Î 0 U W�W 9;54. ¿ 3�7C[�3q087:9;74.1087C. ] 0 �s 9 E _13 ��� z _Y.1087C0/7C[�3©= U W�E 365q<\aml U 3B54.Y360 � = U W�E 365q<\a U =�.1l U 3�l U 3654.Y360 � = U W�E 365q<\at74<>fX. ] 0 �= U W�E 365Z<\ay74<>fX. ] 0Z< ]B]6U 5254.Y=Xp»<>= ] 3 � = U W�E 3B5Z<\ay7C<>f�. ] 0¶< ]B]6U 5254.1=�p W <>523«7C[X9\=<>= ] 3 � 9;=XD

z}�z

Page 178: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

= U W�E 365%<\a�74<>fX. ] 0«74[g9;7 ] <>=�7:9\.Y= W <>523�74[g9\=�<>=X3»l U 3B5 F <>=�9�Dg9 F�E�F DX9 F·E 9\023 � s [X3= U W�E 365y<\a®l U 3654.Y360y<>5 U =X.Yl U 3kl U 3654.Y360y�y.Y74[�52360 U _Y740K5236fX52360236=�7C0�74[X3kl U 3652.1360y7C[X9;7K9 ] 7 U 9\_Y_ FW 9;7 ] [ÙDX< ]BU W 36=�7C0�an54< W < U 5�7436087«Dg9�7:9 E 9;043 � � 3 W 9\52´�7C[X3�Dg9 F 0©74[g9;7��t3�<>=X_ F p><\7©9fg9\587�<\aA74[X3�_1<\p©�y.Y74["9 ) � s [X3Z087:9;74.10274. ] 0�04[�<Â�-7C[X9;7�9\52< U =XD Ä;|¦q <;aA7C<>fX. ] 0/< ]6]BU 5 W <>5437C[X9\=)<>= ] 3 � 9\=XD)9 ]6] < U =�7�an<>5 Æ>Ǧq <;ae7C<\7C9\_`l U 3652.13B0 � + W <>=Xp�7C[X3q7C<>fX. ] 0y7C[g9�7�< ]6]BU 5 W <>5437C[X9\=�<>= ] 3 � 9\54< U =XD Ç>Î#q ] <>=�7:9\.Y=X0 W <\543t74[g9\=�<>=X3 U =X.Yl U 3yl U 365 F\� �y[�. ] [�.1=XD�. ] 9�7C360 ] 9 ] [X.Y=Xpl U 3652.13B0y�y[�. ] [)5236l U .Y54360K9\=@3ÚµX9 ] 7 W 9;7 ] [%�t< U _1D�=X<\7yDX3�7C3 ] 7�74[X.10m_Y< ] 9\_1.¾7 F �s 9 E _13 ��� Ä fX543B0436=�740q[�<Â� W 9\= F l U 3B54.Y360k9 ]B] < U =�7�an<>5K7C[X3¶Dg9\.1_ F 7C<>f z�Å>Å��`Ä;Å>Å��`Î;Å>Å��®z�Å>Å>Å��9\=XD Ä\Å\Å>Å 7C<>f�. ] 0 � M = 9«7 F fX. ] 9\_eDg9 F>� 74[X3�7C<>f z}Å\Å 7C<>fX. ] 0 Ô 7C<>f Ä#q Õ 9 ]B] < U =�7kan<>5/9\54< U =XDz � q <\a�74<\7:9;_Al U 3654.Y360b{®7C[X3Z74<>f Ä;Å>Å 7C<>fX. ] 0 Ô 74<>f Ë q Õ 9 ]6] < U =�7�an<>5k9;54< U =�D Ä>Î$q {b7C[X3Z74<>fÎ\Å>Å 7C<>f�. ] 0 Ô 74<>f z}Å#q Õ 9 ]B] < U =�7oan<\5t9\52< U =XD©Ë Ŧq {^74[X3�74<>f z�Å>Å>Å 74<>fX. ] 0 Ô 7C<\f Ä\Ŧq Õ 9 ]6] < U =�7an<>5 Î Ë q%� 9\=�D�74[X3m7C<>f Ä\Å>Å>Å 74<>fX. ] 0 Ô 74<>f Ä\Î#q Õ 9 ]6] < U =�7�an<\5 � Ŧq � � 3K=�<\7C. ] 3o7C[X9;7º7C[X3yDg9;7C9an54< W T 36f�743 W�E 365 z�Å 7C< T 36f�743 W�E 365 z�Ç fX543B043B=�[email protected]\=X.Yj ] 9\=�7C_ F DX.Yظ365236=�7 ] [g9\549 ] 743652.10274. ] 0an54< W 7C[X3�<\74[X365kDg9 F 0 � s [�36043��t3B543�Dg9 F 0��y[X3B=�7C[�3 T 7C9\545k5236fi<>527k�t9\0�f U E _1.Y04[X3BD�<\=�7C[�3J =�7C3B54=X3�7 � s [X3'7C<>f�l U 3B54.Y360�<>=�74[X36023@Dg9 F 0�9;543'02< W 3�c;9\54.19;7C.Y<>=X0q<\aK027:9;545 � 087:9\525�543Bf¸<\527 �] _Y.1=�7C<\= � d�<\=X. ] 9¶_13��y.104´ F\� 9\=XD@. W fi3�9 ] [ W 36=�7 � s [X3 z}Å>Å 74<>fX. ] 0m9 ]B] < U =�7K9;0o[X.1p\[@9\0 � Ç � Ë q<\a¢l U 3652.1360K<>=%7C[�3qDX9 F 0 �s 9 E _13 ��� Ç f�54360236=�7C0º7C[�3mf¸3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3B0º<\ail U 3654.Y360e�y[X<\043m7C<>f�. ] 0 W 9;7 ] [�9�7C<>f�. ] <>5®<>=X3m<\a�7C[�37C<\f z}Å\Å��VÄ\Å>Å��VÎ;Å>Å�� <>5 z}Å>Å\Å 74<>fX. ] 0º<>=�7C[X3KfX543�cV.1< U 0ºDg9 F <>5º<>= � U _ F%z Ë ��z}|\|>Ì 543602f¸3 ] 74.Yc>3B_ F �s [X3k_13�a�7mfg9\587y<\aS7C[X3/7C9 E _Y3/_1.Y027C0�7C[X3k027C9;7C.Y0274. ] 0t<>=@<Âc\3652_h9\f E 3B7É��3636=�Dg9 F 0 � s [X3k54.Yp>[�7mfg9\587<\a¢7C[X3�7:9 E _13k_1.Y02740o7C[X3k027C9;7C.Y0274. ] 0y<>=�<}c>3B54_h9;f��y.¾7C[ � U _ F»z Ë � s F fX. ] 9\_Y_ F>� �y[�36=���3q5436f�_1. ] 9;7C39\_Y_º74<>fX. ] 0¶<;am7C[X3'f�543BcV.Y< U 0�Dg9 F\� 9\54< U =XD�Ë Ç¦q <\aml U 3B54.Y360 W 9;7 ] [�9�7C<>fX. ] .Y=�7C[�3'543BfX_1. ] 9Y{�y[X3B=³��3@5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3©7C[X3%7C<\f z�Å>Å>Å 7C<\fX. ] 0Z<\ay7C[[email protected]< U 0ZDg9 F>� 9;54< U =�D Ä;̦q <\aKl U 3B54.13B0W 9;7 ] [©9k74<>fX. ] .1=Z7C[X3K543BfX_1. ] 9 � H <}��3Bc>3B5 � <>=�74[X3yDg9 F 0�7C[�3 T 7:9\525¹5236fi<>527 ] 9 W 3y< U 7 � 9\0¹[X.1p\[9\0 Ì�Î#q <\aAl U 3B54.Y360 W 9;7 ] [»9�74<>fX. ] <>=�7C[X3�fX543�c^.Y< U 0�Dg9 F � J ae�t3¶<>=X_ F 5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3�7C[�3�7C<\fX. ] 0<>= � U _ F%z Ë � �t3Kjg=XD©an3��t3B5tl U 3B54.13B0 W 9;7 ] ['9�7C<>fX. ] .1=�7C[X3K543BfX_1. ] 9q9\0A7C. W 3y36_19\fX043B0 � w <>5A7C[�37C<\f z}Å>Å>Å 74<>fX. ] 0 � 7C[X3Zfi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3Z<\a¹l U 3652.13B0/7C[g9;7 W 9;7 ] [X360k9�7C<>fX. ] DX3 ] 54369\043B0�an54< WèÇ>Ŧq

z}Æ�Ä

Page 179: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

�N-P7 ï�í!ì�à�rC -�í!ì�5kí!â -�ëP5 C -�í C -�í!ì�5kí!â 8Ôà©êP5ká!âîU1q8�í I�5 8�A I�5 8�A à3á!á -�ìÔì�5kë�ä 7Bà©ìÔíJ8�AU1�ë 7Bà©ì�íJ8�AU1�ëDà©ë�í8�à�8�1�ã ì�í!â�-�ã 8�â 8�à�8R1�ã ì�í!â�-�ã 8�â 8�à�8R1�ã à©ë�á!í à©ë�á!í -�ëP5 C -�í C -�í!ì�3ý>U+�!÷ û©û©ú©û û©ú���û ú©�©�©ú ÿ©û�ý�� ÿ���ù©� �©ú©�©þ ��ÿ©ú©� ÿ©ú�÷ý>U+��ÿ û©ú©ÿ©ú û©�©ù�� ú©þ©ú�ý ÿ©ù©þ©ÿ ÿ©þ��©ú �©ÿ�÷©÷ �!÷�û©� ÿ�÷�ÿý>U+��ú û�ý��©þ û����©ù ú©þ©��ý ÿ�ý©ý�ú ÿ©þ©þ�ý ��÷�û�� ��ÿ���ú ÿ�÷��ý>U+�ý ù�÷��©û ù©þ�ý+� ÿ��©û©û ÿ���ÿ©ù ÷©÷�ú©û ���ý�� ���©û�ý ÿ���þQ©ý>U+��ù ����þ�÷ ��û©ù©ÿ �!÷3ý�û ���©û©ú ���©ù©ÿ û©ú©û ����ú û��Q©ý>U+��û �����©ù �©þ��©ú ��ÿ©ÿ©ÿ �!÷�ù©ú ���©ù©ÿ ��þ�ý�ú �©þ©û ù�÷ý>U��©þ ��þ��V��� û�ý+��ÿ ú��©��÷ ú©þ©ÿ©ÿ ÿ���û©ÿ �©ú���ÿ ��ÿ©ù©þ ú©þ©ûý>U���� û©û©þ©ÿ û©ÿ�ý�� ú©�©þ©ÿ ÿ©û©ù©ÿ ÿ��ý�ú �©ú©ú�ý ��ÿ©þ©û ÿ©ÿ©úý>U��©� ��þ©ú©ÿ©þ ��þ©��ý+� ú�÷�û�ý ú©���©ú ÿ�÷�þ©û ��ý�ÿ©ú ��ú©ÿ�� ÿ©ù©ÿý>U���� ��þ©ÿ©��ý ��þ���ú©ù ú��©ù©ù ú��!÷�û ÿ������ �©ú©û©ÿ ��ú��©ù ÿ©û©úý>U���÷ ù�÷�ú�� ù������ ÿ��ý©ý ÷�û�÷©÷ ÷��©ú©þ �©þ©ÿ©ÿ ���©þ©ÿ ÷���úQ©ý>U��©ÿ �©þ©û©ÿ ��û©ù©ú �!÷3ý�û �!÷�þ©ÿ ���©ù©ù û�ý�� ����ÿ û�÷Q©ý>U��©ú �©����ù �©þ©û©ÿ ��ÿ©ÿ�÷ �!÷�ÿ©ù �����©þ û©ú©û �©ú�� ��þ��Q©ý>U���ý �ý�þ©ÿ ��ú©ú�÷ ���©þ©ù ����ý5÷ �V��ÿ©ú ù�ý�ù ��ý�ù û©ùQ©ý>U��©ù ��ÿ�÷�� �!÷�û©ù �V�!÷�þ �V��þ©û ��þ©þ�� ý�ÿ�÷ ��÷3ý ù�ýQ©ý>U��©û ��ÿ©�©û �!÷�ù©ù �V��ú�� �V����� ��þ���û ý©ý5÷ ��÷�ÿ û��Q©ý>U��©þ ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1ý>U���� ý�ù©ÿ©þ ý�ÿ©��ý ÿ©þ©ÿ�� ÷�ù��©þ ÷���ù�� �©û���û ���©ú�÷ ÷3ý��Q�ù�U�þ�� ��û©û©ú ��ù©ú©ÿ �!÷�ú©þ ���©ú©û ���©ÿ©þ û��!÷ ���©ú û©ÿQ�ù�U�þ©� ���V� ��û�÷ ��ú©þ �!÷�ù �!÷�� ��þ©ú �©ÿ ýQ�ù�U�þ�� ���©ù©ù ����÷3ý ��þ©�©ú û©û�� û©þ©� ý�þ�÷ ��û©ù ý+�ù�U�þ�÷ ù©ù©�©ú ù©ÿ��!÷ ÿ©ÿ�÷�û ÿ����©� ÷�ú��©ú �©��÷�ÿ ���©û�� ÿ©þ©�ù�U�þ©ÿ û���ý�ú û©þ�÷�� ÿ©û©ÿ©ÿ ÿ�ý�þ�ý ÷�û©þ©� ���©ù�ý ��ÿ���ÿ ÿ©ú©úù�U�þ©ú û�÷©÷�ÿ û��V��þ ÿ©û©ú©ÿ ÿ�ý+��� ÷�û©ù�� ��÷�û©ù �!÷�ù�� ÿ©���ù�U�þ�ý ý�þ�÷�û ú©ù©þ�� ÷�ú�÷�� ÷©÷©÷�þ �©û���ú �©ù���ÿ �V��þ�� ��ý�ÿQ�ù�U�þ©ù ��ú©ù�ý ��ú���þ ������� �V��ÿ�÷ ��þ©ÿ©û ý�û©û �©ú©þ ý�ÿQ�ù�U�þ©û �ý5÷�þ ��ú�÷�� �����©ÿ �V��ú©� ��þ�ý�� ý�ù©ÿ �©ù�ý ú©ùù�U+��þ ý�ÿ�ý©ý ý�����÷ ÷�û©ÿ�� ÷3ý�ú©ú ÷���û�� �©û©ù�� ������þ ÷��©�ù�U+�V� ý�ù��V� ý�ÿ�÷�� ÿ��V��þ ÷�û©�©þ ÷��©�©ù �©þ���� ���©û�ý ÷©÷�þù�U+��� ý5÷��©ù ý+�V�ý ÷�ù�ý©ý ÷�ú�ý5÷ ÷���ÿ©ÿ �©þ©��ý �V���©ù �©û�÷ù�U+��� ý�þ©ù�÷ ú�ý�û©ú ÷3ý��©� ÷�ÿ©�©û �©û©ù©û �©ù���� �V�ý©ý ÷���ÿù�U+�!÷ ÿ���ú©þ ÷�û���÷ �©ÿ�÷�� ���©ù©û �©þ©��÷ ����ù©û ù��©ÿ �©ú©ûQ�ù�U+��ÿ �!÷�ÿ©þ ���©�©û ��þ©ÿ©� û©û�ý û©�©ú ý��©ÿ �©þ�� ú©þQ�ù�U+��ú �!÷�ÿ©ù ���©ú�� �V��þ�� ��þ©�©û û©ú�ý ý5÷�� �©�©ú ÿ��ù�U+�ý ú����©û ÿ©ù©ù�� ÷��V��þ �©û��©ù �©ÿ���þ �©ÿ���� û©û�ý �©�©úù�U+��ù ú©ú�ý�� ú��©ú©ÿ ÷©÷�ù©þ ÷��©ú©� �©ù���� ��ý5÷�þ ��þ�ý�� �©ÿ©þù�U+��û ú©�©þ�� ÿ©û�ý5÷ ÷���ú�� �©û©û�� �©ÿ©û©� �©ÿ©ú�� ��þ©�©û ����þù�U��©þ ÿ©û���ÿ ÿ©ú©ÿ©ú �©û©ÿ�� ��ý©ý�� ��÷�þ©û ��÷�ÿ©ÿ û©ÿ�÷ �©þ��ù�U���� ÷�ù�÷©÷ ÷�ú��©� ��÷��ý �©�©ú©ÿ �©û©ù�� �©�©þ©ú ý©ý©ý ���©ùQ�ù�U��©� �����V� ���©�©û û©ù©þ û���ú ù©ÿ©û ú©ÿ©� �©þ�ý ÿ©�Q�ù�U���� �!÷©÷�ÿ ���©ÿ�ý ��þ©û�� ��þ���� û©ÿ©� ý+��ú ���©ú ú©úù�U���÷ ÿ©ù©��� ÿ©ÿ©ú©û ÷�þ���� �©ù©��� ���©û�÷ ��÷��!÷ û©ù©þ ���©ûù�U��©ÿ ú���ú©ù ÿ©û���� ÷��!÷�ù �©û�ý5÷ �©ÿ©ú©ù �©ÿ�ý�ú û©û©� �©���ù�U��©ú ú���ú�÷ ÿ©û©��� ÷������ ÷�þ��©� �©ú��V� �©ÿ©ù©ÿ ��þ©�©ú �©��÷ù�U���ý ú©�©þ�� ÿ©û�÷�ÿ ÷���ù©� ÷�þ©þ©þ �©ÿ©ú©ù �©ÿ©ÿ�ý ��þ��V� ��÷�úù�U��©ù ÿ����©ú ÷�û���� �©ÿ©ú©û ��÷���ú �����©þ ���©þ�� ù��ý �©ÿ©þQ�ù�U��©û ��ú©ú�� ��ÿ©ù©ÿ �V��ù©ù �V���©ù ��þ�÷©÷ ý©ý©ý �©ú�ý ý��Q�ù�U��©þ �©þ©�©ù ��û©��� �!÷�ÿ©û ���©ù©û ���©ù�� û�÷�û ���©� û��ù�U���� ú��©þ©û ú©þ�÷�þ ÷��©ÿ�÷ ÷�þ©ÿ©û �©ú��©ÿ �©ú���� ��þ©��� ���©ûû�U�þ�� ú©û©��ý ú©ú��©û ÷�ÿ��©ù ÷��©��ý �©ù©ú�� ��ý�ù�� ��þ©ù©� ��÷3ýû�U�þ©� ý5÷��©� ý+���©ù ÷3ý�ÿ©û ÷�ÿ©ú©ù ÷�þ�÷3ý �©û���� �V���©ÿ �©ù©ùû�U�þ�� ý����©þ ú©û���û ÷3ý���� ÷�ÿ©��÷ ÷�þ©�©û �©ù©û©ú �V����� �©û��û�U�þ�÷ ú©ù��©ù ÿ©ÿ©ù�÷ �©û�÷3ý ��ý�ú�� ���©�©þ ����ý©ý û�÷�� ���©þQ�û�U�þ©ÿ ��ù���� �ý�ú©ÿ ����÷�þ ���©ú©� �V�ý5÷ ù©ÿ©ú ����ù ý5÷Q�û�U�þ©ú �ý+�V� ��ú��!÷ ���©ÿ�� �V�ý�û ��þ©û©ú ù��©ú �©ú©þ ý��Q�û�U�þ�ý ��ý�ú©ù �©ú©��� ��ù©ù©ú �ý�ù�� ��ú©ÿ©þ �V��û�ý ÷�ÿ�� �V��ûû�U�þ©ù ù©ÿ©þ©ù ù���þ�� ÿ��©û©ù ÿ����©ú ÷©÷�û©ú ����ú�÷ �����©� ÷�ÿ©ÿû�U�þ©û ù©ù©þ©þ ù�÷��©þ ÿ©ÿ©ù�� ÿ��©ú©ù ÷3ý+�ý ���©��� ���©û©ú ÷�ù©ÿû�U+��þ �!÷�ÿ�÷�þ ���©ú©û©ÿ ú©ú©��� ú���ù�� ÿ©�©ÿ�� �©ú©û�÷ ��ÿ©ÿ�ý ÿ©ù©þû�U+�V� ��ÿ©ú©ÿ�ý ����÷�ù�ý ÷�ÿ�÷�ú ÷��V�V� ���©þ©þ ���©û©ú û©þ�÷ ���©ùû�U+��� �����V�!÷ ��þ©�©�©þ �©þ��ý �©ú©û©ú �©þ©�©þ �!÷�ú©ú ÿ©ÿ�÷ ���ýû�U+��� ý�þ©û©ÿ ú©���©ú ��ý+��û ��÷3ý�� �©þ�÷�û �!÷�ù©ú ÿ©ú�� ��û�ýí Þ��! nà ð ÿ¦þgÿ s [X3q027:9�7C.1087C. ] 0oan54< W 7C[�3 syH�M d�+ T _1<>p Ô J8Õ

z}Æ>Ç

Page 180: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

ê$í!ìÔá!í!ë/8�1�ä©í!â¼à�r C -Pí�ì�5kí!â ê�í!ì�á�í!ë�8R1�ä©í!â¼à�r C -�í!ì�5kí!âîP1q8Ôí 8�AU1q8�8Ôà©ên8Ôà©êP5ká!âJ1�á�á!à�-�ë�8�rMà©ì îP1q8Ôí 8�AP1q8N8�à©ê�8�à©êP5ká!âJ1�á!á!à�-�ë�8Jrpà©ì��þ©þ �©þ©þ ÿ©þ©þ ��þ©þ©þ �©þ©þ©þ ��þ©þ �©þ©þ ÿ©þ©þ ��þ©þ©þ �©þ©þ©þý>U+�!÷ ��úPü ÷ V ���Pü û V ��ý�ü ÿ V ÿ©þPü ý V ú©úPü û V ù�U+�!÷ ��ùPü ú V �©úPü ù V ÷��Pü¨� V ÿ©ûPü þ V ý�ûPü � Vý>U+��ÿ �ý�ü ÿ V �©ÿPü¨� V �©ùPü¨� V ÿ��©ü � V ú�ý�ü � V Q�ù�U+��ÿ �©þPü � V ÷�ÿPü � V ú�ý�ü û V ��þ©þPü þ V ��þ©þPü þ Vý>U+��ú �ý�ü � V ��÷�ü ù V �©ùPü ÿ V ÿ��©ü ÿ V ú�ý�ü ù V Q�ù�U+��ú ��ý�ü þ V ÷��©ü ý V ú©ÿPü ý V ��þ©þPü þ V ��þ©þPü þ Vý>U+�ý ��ùPü � V �©ÿPü ù V �©ûPü ÿ V ÿ��Pü � V ú©ûPü ÷ V ù�U+�ý �ý�ü � V �©ÿPü¨� V ÷�þPü ÷ V ÿ�ý�ü � V ý5÷�ü � VQ©ý>U+��ù ��ý�ü ÷ V �©ûPü ÿ V ú©þPü ÿ V ù©ÿPü ú V ��þ©þPü þ V ù�U+��ù ��ÿPü ù V ���Pü ù V �©ùPü û V ÿ�÷�ü ý V ý+�©ü ÿ VQ©ý>U+��û �©ÿPü � V �©úPü ÷ V ÿ©úPü ÿ V ù��©ü¨� V ��þ©þPü þ V ù�U+��û �ý�ü þ V ��÷�ü ÿ V �©ûPü ÷ V ÿ©úPü¨� V ý��Pü ÷ Vý>U��©þ ��úPü ÷ V ��÷�ü � V ��ý�ü ù V ÿ©þPü ù V ú�ý�ü¨� V ù�U��©þ �ý�ü ÿ V �©ÿPü ú V ÷�þPü ÿ V ÿ�ý�ü ÷ V ý�ÿPü¨� Vý>U���� ��úPü ÿ V ��÷�ü � V ��ý�ü ù V ÿ��©ü¨� V ú©úPü ù V ù�U���� ��úPü ÷ V ��÷�ü ú V ÷�þPü ÷ V ÿ�ý�ü � V ý�ùPü ù Vý>U��©� �ý�ü ù V �©ÿPü ÿ V �©ùPü � V ÿ©þPü ù V ú©úPü ù V Q�ù�U��©� �©ûPü ÿ V ÷�ÿPü ù V ý�þPü ù V ��þ©þPü þ V ��þ©þPü þ Vý>U���� ��ùPü � V �©ÿPü ÷ V �©ùPü � V ÿ��©ü¨� V ú�ý�ü � V Q�ù�U���� ��ý�ü � V ÷��©ü û V ú©úPü ý V ��þ©þPü þ V ��þ©þPü þ Vý>U���÷ ��úPü ù V ���Pü ÿ V �©ÿPü ù V ÷�ùPü ú V ú��Pü ù V ù�U���÷ ��úPü � V ��÷�ü � V �©ûPü ÷ V ÿ�ý�ü þ V ý�ÿPü þ VQ©ý>U��©ÿ ��ý�ü ÷ V �©ûPü ÷ V ú©þPü � V ù©ÿPü ÿ V ��þ©þPü þ V ù�U��©ÿ ��úPü ÷ V ��÷�ü � V �©ûPü ù V ÿ©úPü ú V ý��Pü ÿ VQ©ý>U��©ú �©úPü ÷ V �©ùPü ÷ V ú©þPü ÷ V ù�÷�ü � V ��þ©þPü þ V ù�U��©ú ��ÿPü¨� V ���Pü � V �©ùPü ú V ÿ©ÿPü ÿ V ý��Pü ù VQ©ý>U���ý �©ÿPü ý V ��ý�ü û V ú©þPü ú V û©þPü ú V ��þ©þPü þ V ù�U���ý ��úPü û V ��÷�ü ú V �©ûPü ù V ÿ©úPü ú V ý��Pü ú VQ©ý>U��©ù �©þPü þ V ÷��Pü ÷ V ú©úPü ú V û©û©ûPü û V ��þ©þPü þ V ù�U��©ù ��ÿPü û V ��÷�ü ÷ V ÷�þPü � V ÿ©úPü ù V ý©ý�ü � VQ©ý>U��©û �©ùPü ÿ V ÷��©ü û V ú©ÿPü¨� V û©ùPü ý V ��þ©þPü þ V Q ù�U��©û �©ûPü ý V ÷��Pü ÿ V ú©ÿPü ý V û�ý�ü � V ��þ©þPü þ VQ©ý>U��©þ ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 Q�ù�U��©þ �©ÿPü þ V �©úPü û V ÿ©ûPü � V ù©ÿPü ÷ V ��þ©þPü þ Vý>U���� �ý�ü � V �©ÿPü � V �©ûPü ý V ÿ�÷�ü � V ý+�©ü þ V ù�U���� ��ÿPü ù V ���Pü û V �©ûPü ÷ V ÿ©úPü þ V ý��Pü û VQ�ù�U�þ�� ��÷�ü þ V �©úPü ÷ V ÿ©ûPü ù V ù©úPü ú V ��þ©þPü þ V û�U�þ�� ��úPü � V ��÷�ü ú V ÷�þPü¨� V ÿ©ÿPü ú V ý+�©ü û VQ�ù�U�þ©� ý�ùPü û V ��þ©þPü þ V ��þ©þPü þ V ��þ©þPü þ V ��þ©þPü þ V û�U�þ©� ��ùPü¨� V �©úPü � V ÷�þPü û V ÿ©ÿPü ÷ V ý+�©ü � VQ�ù�U�þ�� ��ý�ü ù V ÷��Pü ý V ú�ý�ü ù V ��þ©þPü þ V ��þ©þPü þ V û�U�þ�� ��úPü ú V ��÷�ü ú V �©ûPü ý V ÿ�÷�ü � V ý�þPü ý Vù�U�þ�÷ ��ùPü � V �©ÿPü ù V �©ûPü¨� V ÿ©�Pü ý V ú©ûPü þ V û�U�þ�÷ �ý�ü ÿ V �©ÿPü ù V ÷��©ü ú V ÿ©ùPü ÿ V ý�úPü ÷ Vù�U�þ©ÿ �ý�ü � V ��÷�ü ú V ��ý�ü ý V ÿ��©ü¨� V ú�ý�ü û V Q�û�U�þ©ÿ �©ÿPü � V �©ùPü¨� V ú��©ü ù V û©þPü¨� V ��þ©þPü þ Vù�U�þ©ú �ý�ü þ V ��÷�ü � V ��ý�ü ý V ÿ��©ü þ V ú�ý�ü � V Q�û�U�þ©ú ��ý�ü û V ÷�þPü ù V ú��Pü¨� V û�÷�ü¨� V ��þ©þPü þ Vù�U�þ�ý ��ùPü � V �©úPü¨� V ÷�þPü ý V ÿ©ÿPü ú V ý+�©ü ù V Q�û�U�þ�ý ���Pü ù V �©ÿPü þ V ÿ©úPü¨� V ý�ÿPü � V ��þ©þPü þ VQ�ù�U�þ©ù �©ûPü � V ÷��Pü û V ú©ÿPü � V û©úPü � V ��þ©þPü þ V û�U�þ©ù �ý�ü þ V ��÷�ü û V �©ùPü ù V ÿ©�Pü ù V ú©ûPü � VQ�ù�U�þ©û �©ùPü þ V ÷��©ü ú V ú©ÿPü¨� V û©ÿPü ú V ��þ©þPü þ V û�U�þ©û ��úPü � V ���Pü ú V ��ý�ü � V ÿ��©ü � V ú�ý�ü ù Vù�U+��þ ��úPü � V ��÷�ü � V �©ùPü ú V ÿ��Pü ú V ý�þPü¨� V û�U+��þ ÷�þPü ÷ V ÷�úPü þ V ÿ©ÿPü ý V ú�÷�ü û V ý�úPü � Vù�U+�V� ��úPü � V ���Pü ý V ��ý�ü ù V ÿ��©ü û V ú©ûPü¨� V û�U+�V� ú©ÿPü ÿ V ú©ûPü ÿ V ý�úPü � V ù©�Pü û V û©þPü ÷ Vù�U+��� �ý�ü ÷ V �©ÿPü¨� V �©ûPü � V ÿ��Pü ù V ú©ûPü ý V û�U+��� ý��Pü ÷ V ý�ùPü¨� V ù�÷�ü ú V û©þPü þ V û©ûPü ù Vù�U+��� ��ÿPü ù V ���Pü � V �©ùPü¨� V ÿ��Pü ÷ V ý�þPü � V û�U+��� ÿ�ý�ü ÿ V ú��Pü ÷ V ý5÷�ü � V ù��Pü � V û©ûPü � Ví Þ��! ¦à ð ÿT�`ÿ s [X3�087:9;74.1087C. ] 0oan54< W 7C[X3 syH�M d�+ T _Y<>p Ô J2J8Õ

z}Æ Ë

Page 181: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

7C< Ä>Ä � Ä#q �y.¾7C[X.Y= Ä�W <>=�7C[X0 � r < W fg9\54.Y=Xp��y.¾7C['74[X3/_13�a�7ofg9;527o<;ab74[X3�7C9 E _13 � 74[X3/fi365 ] 36=�7:9;p>3DX52<>f©.Y0ec>3B5 F p>549\D U 9\_ � �y[X. ] [�0 U p>p>36087C0º7C[g9�7¹��3KDX<k=X<\7¹=X363BD©74< U f¸Dg9�7C3y543BfX_1. ] 9\0A3�c>365 F Dg9 F �H <}��3Bc\365 � <\=³74[X3�02f¸3 ] .19\_mDg9 F 0©�y[X3B=Ù7C[�3 T 7C9\545�5236fi<>527 ] 9 W 3@< U 7 � .¾a���3�5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C3%7C[�37C<\f z}Å>Å\Å 74<>fX. ] 0 � 9\0K[X.1p\[)9\0 Ì�Ä#q <\ael U 3B54.13B0 W 9;7 ] [)9�74<>fX. ] <\=�7C[�3�fX523BcV.1< U 0�Dg9 F\� �y[�. ] [0 U p>p>36087C0y7C[g9�7m�t3q=X363BD{9Z04fi3 ] .Yj ] W 3 ] [g9;=X.10 W 7C<�[g9\=�DX_13�7C[�.10m´�.1=XD@<\a E U 52027 F 3�c>36=�7 �s 9 E _13 ��� ˶fX52360236=�7C0t74[X3Kf¸3B5 ] 3B=�7:9\p>3�<\a`l U 3B54.13B0��y[X<\043�74<>fX. ] 0 W 9�7 ] ['9k7C<>f�. ] <>5¹<>=X3K<\aI7C[�37C<\f z}Å\Å��VÄ\Å>Å��VÎ;Å>Å�� <>5 z}Å>Å\Å 74<>fX. ] 0º<>=�7C[X3yfX523BcV.1< U 0¹023Bc\36='Dg9 F 0t<\5A<>=�74[X3m�t3B36´�<\a � U _ F«z Ë7C< � U _ F«Ä\Å��iz}|>|\Ì�� 523602f¸3 ] 7C.¾c>3B_ F � s [X3�_13Ba�7�fg9\587o<\a`74[X3�7C9 E _13K_1.Y02740¹74[X3/027C9;7C.Y0274. ] 0�<>='<}c>3B54_19\fE 3B7É��3636=�74[X3 ]6U 52543B=�7¶Dg9 F �y.Y74[ 74[X3©f�543BcV.Y< U 0q043Bc\36=�Dg9 F 0 � s [X3«52.1p>[�7kfg9\587¶<;at7C[�3�7C9 E _13_1.Y02740º74[X3K027:9�7C.1087C. ] 0¹<>=«<}c>3B54_19\f©�y.¾7C[�7C[X3y�t3B36´�<\a � U _ F%z Ëq7C< � U _ F©Ä\Å � s F fX. ] 9\_Y_ F\� �y[�36=«��3543BfX_1. ] 9;743y9\_1_V7C<>f�. ] 0A<;a¸74[X3yfX543�c^.Y< U 0º043�c>3B='Dg9 F 0 � 9\54< U =XD Î\̦q <\a¸l U 3652.13B0 W 9;7 ] [«9/7C<\fX. ] .Y=7C[�3�543BfX_1. ] 9Y{��y[X3B='�t3�543BfX_1. ] 9;743K74[X3K74<>f z}Å\Å>Å 74<>fX. ] 0¹<\aI7C[�3�fX523BcV.1< U 0tDg9 F>� 9\54< U =XD Ç>Î#q <\al U 3652.13B0 W 9;7 ] [©9q74<>fX. ] .1=�7C[X3K543BfX_1. ] 9 � H <}�t3�c>3B5 � <\=�74[X3�DX9 F 0¹7C[X3 T 7:9;545º543Bf¸<>587 ] 9 W 3y< U 7 �9\0m[X.Yp>[%9\0 Ì>Î#q <;a¢l U 3B54.Y360 W 9;7 ] [@9¶74<>fX. ] <>='7C[X3�f�543BcV.Y< U 0mDg9 F � J ab��3�<>=X_ F 543BfX_1. ] 9;743�7C[�37C<\fX. ] 0/<>={7C[�3¶�t3B36´{<;a � U _ F�z Ë«7C< � U _ F{Ä\Å�� an3��t3B5kl U 3654.Y360 W 9;7 ] ["9«7C<>fX. ] .Y={7C[X3�5236fX_Y. ] 99\0m7C. W 3�36_h9;fX043B0 �s 9 E _13 ��� Î fX543B0436=�740�74[X3'fi365 ] 36=�7C9\p>3%<\ayl U 3B54.13B0��y[X<>023'7C<>fX. ] 0 W 9;7 ] [9�7C<\fX. ] <>5¶<>=�3'<\a7C[�3�74<>f z}Å\Å��¢Ä\Å>Å��®Î\Å>Å�� <>5 z}Å>Å\Å 74<>fX. ] 0�7C[g9;7q��3«9 ]B]6U W U _h9;743�an52< W 74[X3�c\365 F�E 36p\.1=X=X.Y=Xp �. � 3 � �t3 ] < U =�7�7C[X3yan543Bl U 36= ] F <\aI3�9 ] [«74<>fX. ] �y.¾7C[X< U 7 ] <>=X02.1DX3B54.1=�pq74[X3�74. W 3 � s [X3�087:9;74.10274. ] 09\523�c>3B5 F 04. W .1_19\5¶74<�7C[X<\043{.Y= s 9 E _13 ��� Ë�3�µ ] 3Bf�7'�y[X3B=��t3)5436f�_1. ] 9;7C3�9\_Y_y74<>fX. ] 0 � �y[�. ] [.10k=X<;7qan369\04. E _13�.Y=�523�9\_A02.Y7 U 9;7C.Y<>=X0 � s [X3©027:9�7C.1087C. ] 0k0 U p\p>36087���3 W 9 F <>=X_ F =X363BD�74< ] < U =�7an543Bl U 36= ] .13B0�<\ab7C<\fX. ] 0y�y.¾7C[X.Y=@9Zf¸3B54.1<VD@<\ab7C. W 3 �

ð ÿ¦þgÿ»� ê^d i %!f�à a ü á i¦i à`gkgZÝ/Þ^ü�ü}à�ý a gJ =�7C[�.10�043 ] 7C.Y<>= � �t3)3�µ�9 W .1=X3�7C[X3�5C9;74.1<�<;akl U 365 F ] < W©W 9\=XDX0«9\=XD�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7'543�7C52.13Bc;9\_] < W©W 9\=XDX0 � 9;=XD�[X<}� W 9\= F DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 E 3B.1=Xp�c^.Y3B��36D�a¦9;_1_A.1=�74<�7C[�3�74<>f ¥ DX< ]BU W 36=�7C0 �R =�_1.1´;3�9q7 F f�. ] 9;_ JLu 0 F 087C3 W �y[X36523 U 0236540 ] 9\='.Y040 U 3 W <>543y7C[g9;=«<>=X3�0 U W�W 9\5 F ] < W©W 9\=XDX0

z}Æ�Î

Page 182: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

ê$í�ì�á!í�ë�8�1�ä©í�â×à�r C -�í!ì�5kí�â ê$í!ìÔá!í!ë/8�1�ä©í!âoà�r C -Pí�ì�5kí!âîU1q8�í 8�AP1q8J7G1q8�áRA�1>8Ôà©ên8Ôà©êP5ká 8�AU1q8J7G1q8�áRA�1�8Ôà©ên8Ôà©êh5káà©ën8�APí9êPìÔíS�h5kà�-Pâ×îU1 3 à©ë ý>U+�!÷1�ãkã ��þ©þ �©þ©þ ÿ©þ©þ ��þ©þ©þ 1�ãkã ��þ©þ �©þ©þ ÿ©þ©þ ��þ©þ©þý>U+�!÷ ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1ý>U+��ÿ ÷��Pü � V ���Pü ÷ V ��ùPü þ V ��÷�ü ù V �©þPü¨� V ÷��Pü � V ���Pü ÷ V ��ùPü þ V ��÷�ü ù V �©þPü¨� Vý>U+��ú ÷©÷�ü ÷ V ���Pü û V ��ùPü þ V ��÷�ü ÷ V �©þPü ÷ V ÷��Pü ú V ���Pü ý V �ý�ü û V ��÷�ü þ V �©ûPü � Vý>U+�ý ÷©÷�ü þ V �!÷�ü¨� V ��ùPü û V �©ÿPü ÿ V �©þPü ÷ V ÷��Pü þ V ���Pü û V �ý�ü ÷ V ���Pü ÿ V �©ùPü ý VQ©ý>U+��ù ÷�þPü � V ���Pü ý V �ý�ü ý V ���Pü � V �©ùPü � V ÷��©ü þ V ���Pü ù V �ý�ü û V ���Pü ÿ V �©ùPü ù VQ©ý>U+��û �©ÿPü ý V �V�©ü � V ��ÿPü � V ��ûPü ÿ V ��÷�ü þ V �©ûPü ÷ V ���Pü ù V ��ùPü � V ���Pü ú V �©ùPü þ Vý>U��©þ �©�Pü � V ùPü � V �V�©ü¨� V ��ÿPü � V ��ûPü � V ÷��©ü � V ���Pü¨� V ��úPü ÿ V ���Pü¨� V �©ùPü ÷ Vý>U���� ÷��Pü þ V ���Pü ÿ V �ý�ü û V ��÷�ü ý V �©ûPü ù V ÷��©ü ú V ���Pü � V ��úPü ý V ���Pü ú V �©ùPü ÿ Vý>U��©� ÷©÷�ü ÷ V �!÷�ü þ V ��ûPü û V ��ý�ü ÷ V ���©ü û V ÷��Pü ÿ V ���Pü ÷ V �ý�ü � V ��÷�ü þ V �©ûPü ú Vý>U���� ÷�ÿPü û V �!÷�ü � V ��ûPü ý V ��ý�ü � V ���©ü ÿ V ÷��©ü ÷ V ���Pü ú V �ý�ü � V ���Pü ÷ V �©ùPü ý Vý>U���÷ ÷�ÿPü¨� V ��ÿPü ý V �©þPü � V ��ý�ü � V ���©ü ù V ÷��Pü ÿ V ���Pü ú V �ý�ü ÷ V ���Pü ÷ V �©ùPü ú VQ©ý>U��©ÿ ÷��Pü ÿ V ��ÿPü þ V ��ùPü ÷ V ��÷�ü ÿ V �©þPü¨� V ÷��Pü¨� V ���Pü þ V �ý�ü ù V ���Pü û V �©ùPü¨� VQ©ý>U��©ú ��ý�ü¨� V �V�©ü ý V �!÷�ü � V ��ùPü û V ���Pü ÿ V ÷��Pü ÷ V �V�©ü � V �ý�ü � V �©ÿPü ÷ V �©þPü � VQ©ý>U���ý �©�Pü � V ùPü¨� V �V�©ü � V ��úPü ý V �©þPü ý V ÷��Pü û V ��þPü þ V �!÷�ü¨� V ���Pü þ V �©ùPü û VQ©ý>U��©ù �©þPü ú V ��þPü � V ��ÿPü þ V �©þPü þ V �©úPü ý V ÷©÷�ü � V ûPü ÿ V ���Pü � V ���Pü � V �©ûPü � VQ©ý>U��©û �©úPü ý V ��þPü ÷ V ���Pü û V �ý�ü ý V �©úPü ý V ÷�þPü ù V ��þPü þ V �!÷�ü ÷ V ���©ü û V ��ý�ü¨� VQ©ý>U��©þ ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1ý>U���� ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 �©ùPü ÿ V �V�©ü � V ��ÿPü¨� V ���©ü û V �©úPü ÷ VQ�ù�U�þ�� �©ùPü þ V �V�©ü ú V �ý�ü þ V �©�Pü ú V �©úPü ÿ V �©úPü ÿ V �V�©ü þ V ��ÿPü � V ���©ü ÿ V �©úPü¨� VQ�ù�U�þ©� �©ùPü û V ùPü ý�ú V �!÷�ü ÷ V ���Pü ý V �©úPü ù V ÷��Pü � V ùPü ù V �!÷�ü ÷ V �©þPü ú V �©ÿPü¨� VQ�ù�U�þ�� �Pü û V �Pü � V �Pü û V �Pü û V �Pü û V ÷�þPü � V ùPü ý V ���Pü � V �©�Pü¨� V ��ý�ü þ Vù�U�þ�÷ ��ûPü¨� V úPü ÷ V ûPü ÷ V ���Pü ý V ��ûPü¨� V �©ûPü ù V �V�©ü þ V ��ÿPü¨� V �©�Pü ý V ��ý�ü ý Vù�U�þ©ÿ ÷��©ü ÿ V ���Pü ÷ V �ý�ü � V ���Pü û V �©ùPü ú V �©ùPü ÷ V ��þPü ú V ��ÿPü ÷ V ���©ü ú V �©úPü ú Vù�U�þ©ú ÷��©ü ÿ V ���Pü ÿ V �ý�ü ù V ��÷�ü � V �©ùPü ý V ��ý�ü ù V ��þPü ÷ V �!÷�ü � V ���©ü � V �©úPü þ Vù�U�þ�ý ÷��Pü¨� V ���Pü û V �ý�ü û V ��÷�ü û V �©ûPü ÷ V �©ùPü ú V ��þPü ÷ V ��ÿPü � V ���©ü û V �©úPü þ VQ�ù�U�þ©ù �©ûPü ÷ V �!÷�ü � V ��ûPü þ V ��÷�ü ù V �©ûPü � V �©ÿPü ú V �V�©ü ú V ��úPü ù V �©�Pü¨� V �©ÿPü û VQ�ù�U�þ©û ��÷�ü ý V ûPü û V ���Pü þ V ��ùPü � V ���Pü ÿ V ÷��©ü ú V �V�©ü ú V ��úPü � V ���Pü û V �©ùPü � Vù�U+��þ �©þPü ÷ V ý�ü � V ûPü ù V �!÷�ü ù V ��ûPü ú V ��ý�ü � V ûPü ù V ���Pü û V �©þPü¨� V ��÷�ü ý Vù�U+�V� �©ùPü ú V �V�©ü � V ��ÿPü ÿ V �©þPü û V �©úPü þ V ��ý�ü � V ��þPü � V �!÷�ü ú V �©þPü¨� V ��÷�ü ÿ Vù�U+��� ÷�þPü ý V ���Pü¨� V ��úPü ú V ���Pü � V �©ùPü � V �©ùPü ÿ V ��þPü þ V �!÷�ü ÷ V ���©ü � V �©úPü � Vù�U+��� ��ý�ü¨� V ��þPü û V ��ÿPü � V �©�Pü þ V �©úPü ù V �©úPü¨� V ûPü ù V ���Pü ù V �©þPü þ V ��÷�ü ÿ Vù�U+�!÷ �©úPü ú V �V�©ü ý V ��ÿPü ÷ V ���©ü û V �©úPü¨� V �©ùPü¨� V �V�©ü ú V ��úPü¨� V ���©ü � V �©úPü þ VQ�ù�U+��ÿ �©ÿPü¨� V ���Pü � V ��úPü þ V ���©ü ý V �©úPü � V ��ý�ü û V ���Pü ÿ V �ý�ü � V ���Pü þ V �©úPü � VQ�ù�U+��ú �©þPü þ V úPü ù V ûPü ù V ���Pü ù V �©þPü þ V �©ÿPü ù V ��þPü þ V �!÷�ü þ V ��ûPü þ V ���Pü ÷ Vù�U+�ý ��ùPü � V ý�ü � V ùPü ù V ���Pü � V ��ùPü � V ��÷�ü ú V ��þPü þ V �!÷�ü þ V ��ûPü � V �©�Pü û Vù�U+��ù ���Pü ÷ V ûPü ÷ V ���Pü û V ��ûPü þ V ��÷�ü ÷ V �©úPü � V ûPü ý V ���Pü ÷ V ��ûPü � V ���Pü ý Vù�U+��û ��÷�ü ú V ��þPü û V ��ÿPü þ V �©þPü þ V ��÷�ü ú V �©ÿPü � V ûPü ù V ���Pü � V ��ûPü � V ���Pü � Vù�U��©þ ��÷�ü ù V ��þPü ù V ���Pü � V ��ûPü þ V ��÷�ü ÷ V ��÷�ü ÿ V ûPü ú V ���Pü û V ��ùPü ú V �©�Pü ý Vù�U���� ���©ü � V ùPü ý V ���Pü � V ��úPü ý V ���©ü � V �©ÿPü � V ûPü ÷ V ���Pü � V ��ùPü ÷ V ���Pü � VQ�ù�U��©� �©�Pü û V ��þPü¨� V �!÷�ü � V �©þPü¨� V ��÷�ü ù V �©ÿPü ÿ V ��þPü � V ��ÿPü � V �©þPü þ V �©ÿPü¨� VQ�ù�U���� �©þPü þ V ý�ü ý V �V�©ü þ V ��ÿPü þ V �©þPü þ V ��ý�ü¨� V ��þPü ÷ V ��ÿPü þ V ��ûPü¨� V ��÷�ü � Vù�U���÷ ��úPü ú V ÿPü � V ùPü � V �V�©ü ú V ��úPü ú V ��ý�ü � V ��þPü¨� V ���Pü ù V ��ûPü � V ��÷�ü¨� Vù�U��©ÿ ���Pü ý V �V�©ü þ V �!÷�ü ú V ��ûPü ÷ V �©ÿPü þ V �©úPü ý V ��þPü ÷ V �!÷�ü � V ��ûPü ù V ��÷�ü � Vù�U��©ú �©ÿPü ú V ��þPü � V ���Pü û V ��ûPü ÷ V ��÷�ü ÿ V �©úPü û V ûPü � V ���Pü þ V ��ûPü þ V ��÷�ü¨� Vù�U���ý �©úPü¨� V ûPü ý V ���Pü ÿ V �©þPü � V �©ÿPü û V ��ý�ü ÷ V ûPü û V ���Pü ú V ��ûPü ý V �©ÿPü � Vù�U��©ù �©�Pü û V ûPü � V ���Pü ÿ V ��ûPü¨� V ���Pü þ V ��÷�ü � V ûPü ÿ V ���Pü ù V ��ùPü � V ���Pü ÷ VQ�ù�U��©û �©ÿPü � V ��þPü � V ��ÿPü ù V �©þPü û V �©úPü � V ÷�þPü ú V �V�©ü û V ��úPü ý V �©�Pü ù V �©ùPü ÷ VQ�ù�U��©þ ��÷�ü � V �V�©ü ÷ V �!÷�ü ý V ��ûPü ÿ V ��÷�ü � V ��ý�ü þ V ��þPü þ V �!÷�ü ú V �©þPü ú V �©úPü � Vù�U���� �©þPü ÷ V úPü û V ûPü ÷ V ���Pü ú V �ý�ü ÿ V ��ý�ü � V ûPü û V ���Pü û V ��ûPü ú V ��÷�ü ù Vû�U�þ�� �©ÿPü ÷ V ��þPü ù V �!÷�ü¨� V �©þPü � V �©ÿPü ý V ��ý�ü ú V ûPü ÿ V ���Pü ú V ��ûPü ú V ��÷�ü ÿ Vû�U�þ©� ÷�þPü þ V �V�©ü ú V ��ÿPü ý V ��÷�ü � V �©ûPü ÷ V �©ûPü¨� V ��þPü ÿ V �!÷�ü ú V ���©ü þ V �©úPü � Vû�U�þ�� �©ûPü � V �V�©ü ÷ V ��ú�U5÷ V �©�Pü ú V ��ý�ü ÷ V �©ùPü þ V ûPü ù V ���Pü ú V �©þPü¨� V �©ÿPü ý Vû�U�þ�÷ �©ùPü � V �V�©ü ÷ V ��ÿPü ú V �©�Pü ÿ V �©úPü ÷ V �©úPü ÿ V ûPü ÿ V ���Pü û V ��ùPü û V ���Pü û VQ�û�U�þ©ÿ �©úPü � V ���Pü ÿ V ��ÿPü ÷ V ���©ü ý V �©úPü¨� V �©úPü � V ��þPü ú V �!÷�ü ù V �©þPü ÿ V ��÷�ü û VQ�û�U�þ©ú ��÷�ü þ V �V�©ü ú V �!÷�ü ý V ��ùPü ú V �©�Pü ù V �©ùPü � V ùPü ù V �!÷�ü û V ���©ü ý V �©úPü û VQ�û�U�þ�ý �©�Pü ù V ûPü ú V ���Pü¨� V ��úPü � V ���©ü � V �©úPü¨� V �V�©ü¨� V ��ÿPü¨� V ���©ü þ V �©ÿPü ý Vû�U�þ©ù ��÷�ü ú V ùPü � V �V�©ü ù V �ý�ü ÷ V �©þPü � V �©úPü¨� V ûPü û V ���Pü û V ��ûPü ý V ��÷�ü � Vû�U�þ©û �©ùPü ù V �V�©ü � V ��ÿPü û V ���©ü û V ��ý�ü þ V �©úPü ÿ V ûPü ù V ���Pü ÷ V ��ùPü û V ���Pü ÷ Vû�U+��þ ÿ�ý�ü¨� V �©þPü ù V ÷��Pü¨� V ÷�þPü û V ÷3ý�ü þ V �©ùPü � V ý�ü ÿ V ��þPü ÷ V �!÷�ü � V �©þPü ÿ Vû�U+�V� ý�ùPü¨� V ú��Pü¨� V ú©ÿPü ÿ V ú©ûPü � V ý+�©ü ý V ÷©÷�ü þ V ÷�ü¨� V úPü � V ùPü ý V �©�Pü � Vû�U+��� ù��©ü¨� V ý+�©ü ÿ V ý��Pü � V ý�úPü � V ý�ùPü¨� V ÷3ý�ü ú V �Pü þ V ÿPü � V úPü ù V ��÷�ü ú Vû�U+��� ú©ÿPü ÷ V ÿ��Pü þ V ÿ©úPü¨� V ÿ©ûPü ý V ú©�Pü þ V ÷©÷�ü ù V ÿPü ÿ V ùPü ú V �V�©ü � V �©ÿPü ú Ví Þ��! ¦à ð ÿ»�Iÿ s [�3�087:9;74.10274. ] 0oan54< W 7C[X3 syH/M d�+ T _Y<>p Ô J2J4J8Õ

z}Æ>Æ

Page 183: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

ê$í�ì�á!í�ë�8�1�ä©í�â×à�r C -�í!ì�5kí�â ê�í!ì�á�í!ë�8R1�ä©í!â×à�r C -�í!ì�5kí!âîU1q8�í 8�AU1q8N7G1q8Ôá�A�í!âJ1�8Ôà©ê�8�à©êP5ká!â 8�AU1q8N7G1q8Ôá�A�í!âJ1�8Ôà©ê�8�à©êP5káà©ë�8�A�í.ê�ì�í �:5kà�-�â âÔíS��í!ëDîU1 3Pâ à©ë�8�A�í*I�í!í O�à�r ý>U+�!÷ | ý>U��©þ1�ãkã ��þ©þ �©þ©þ ÿ©þ©þ ��þ©þ©þ 1�ãkã ��þ©þ �©þ©þ ÿ©þ©þ ��þ©þ©þý>U+�!÷ ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1ý>U+��ÿ ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1ý>U+��ú ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1ý>U+�ý ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1Q©ý>U+��ù ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1Q©ý>U+��û ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1ý>U��©þ ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1ý>U���� ú©þPü � V ���Pü � V ��ùPü û V �©ùPü � V ���Pü � V ú©þPü � V ���Pü � V ��ùPü û V �©ùPü � V ���Pü � Vý>U��©� ú��©ü ú V ���Pü ÿ V ��ûPü ù V �©ùPü � V ��÷�ü û V ú©þPü ý V �!÷�ü ú V ���©ü � V �©ûPü ù V �©úPü ù Vý>U���� ú©�Pü ú V �!÷�ü þ V ��ûPü ú V �©ùPü ù V ��÷�ü ú V ú��©ü þ V ��ÿPü � V ���©ü¨� V �©ûPü � V �©úPü ù Vý>U���÷ ú©�Pü þ V ��ÿPü ù V ���©ü ú V �©ùPü ù V ��÷�ü � V ú©þPü ÷ V ��úPü ÷ V �©�Pü � V �©ûPü û V �©úPü ý VQ©ý>U��©ÿ ú©þPü � V ��úPü ú V ���©ü þ V ��ý�ü ÷ V ���Pü � V ÿ©ùPü � V ��úPü ÷ V ���©ü ù V �©ùPü ù V �©ÿPü ÿ VQ©ý>U��©ú ú��Pü¨� V �!÷�ü¨� V ��ûPü û V �©ûPü � V �©ÿPü ù V ú��©ü þ V ���Pü ý V �©þPü ÷ V �©þPü ÿ V �©ùPü ú VQ©ý>U���ý ú��Pü þ V ���Pü ú V ��ùPü ý V ��ý�ü ÷ V ��÷�ü ÷ V ú��©ü¨� V ���Pü ú V ��ûPü ú V ��ý�ü ý V �©ÿPü û VQ©ý>U��©ù ú�÷�ü ý V ���Pü ÷ V �©þPü¨� V ��ý�ü ù V �©ÿPü ÷ V ú��©ü ÿ V ���Pü ÿ V ��ûPü ÷ V �©úPü ú V �©úPü ÷ VQ©ý>U��©û ÿ©ÿPü � V ���Pü û V ��ùPü ÿ V �©ÿPü ù V �©�Pü ÿ V ÿ©ùPü þ V ���Pü ý V ��ùPü � V �©úPü û V �©ÿPü¨� VQ©ý>U��©þ ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1ý>U���� ÷�ûPü ù V ���Pü ÷ V �ý�ü ú V ��÷�ü ÿ V �©þPü þ V ÿ©ûPü¨� V ���Pü ú V ��ûPü þ V ��ý�ü � V ��÷�ü � VQ�ù�U�þ�� ÷�ùPü ÿ V �V�©ü � V ��úPü û V ���Pü ÷ V �©ùPü ÿ V ÿ©úPü ÷ V ���Pü þ V �ý�ü ú V �©úPü ú V ���©ü ý VQ�ù�U�þ©� ÷3ý�ü ÷ V ùPü � V ���Pü ÷ V �©úPü ù V ���©ü ÷ V ú©�Pü û V ���Pü ÷ V �!÷�ü û V ��ý�ü � V ���Pü ÿ VQ�ù�U�þ�� ÷�ùPü ÷ V �V�©ü � V �ý�ü � V �©úPü � V �©�Pü ÷ V ÿ©ûPü¨� V �V�©ü ÿ V �ý�ü � V �©úPü¨� V ���Pü û Vù�U�þ�÷ ÷3ý�ü þ V ���Pü û V ��ùPü ù V �©úPü¨� V ���©ü ÿ V ú��©ü � V �!÷�ü � V �©þPü ÷ V �©ûPü¨� V �©úPü � Vù�U�þ©ÿ ÿ©þPü ÷ V ���Pü û V ��ùPü ý V �©úPü¨� V ���©ü¨� V ÿ©ûPü ÷ V ���Pü ÿ V ��ûPü � V ��ý�ü ú V �©ÿPü þ Vù�U�þ©ú ÿ©�Pü ý V ���Pü ú V ��ùPü û V �©úPü � V �©�Pü ÿ V ÿ©ùPü ý V ���Pü ÿ V ��ûPü þ V �©úPü ý V ��÷�ü � Vù�U�þ�ý ÿ©ÿPü û V ���Pü ý V ��ûPü � V ��ý�ü¨� V ���Pü ÿ V ÿ�ý�ü û V ���Pü ÿ V ��ùPü ÿ V �©úPü ú V ��÷�ü ú VQ�ù�U�þ©ù ÿ©úPü � V ��ÿPü ÷ V �©þPü ù V �©ùPü � V ���©ü û V ÿ�ý�ü ÿ V ���Pü � V �©þPü þ V �©ùPü ù V ��÷�ü � VQ�ù�U�þ©û ÿ©úPü ý V ���Pü ÿ V ��ûPü ù V �©ùPü � V ���Pü ù V ÿ�ý�ü þ V ���Pü � V ��ûPü ý V ���©ü � V ��ý�ü ú Vù�U+��þ ÿ©úPü þ V ���Pü ý V �ý�ü ù V �©ÿPü ù V ���©ü û V ÿ©ùPü ù V ���Pü ù V �ý�ü ù V �©úPü ù V ���Pü ù Vù�U+�V� ÿ©úPü � V ���Pü ù V �ý�ü � V �©ÿPü � V ���©ü ÿ V ÿ©ûPü þ V ���Pü¨� V �ý�ü ú V �©ÿPü ý V �©�Pü � Vù�U+��� ÿ©ùPü û V ���Pü ý V ��ûPü¨� V ��ý�ü þ V ���Pü � V ÿ©ûPü ú V ���Pü ÷ V ��ùPü � V ��ý�ü � V ��÷�ü � Vù�U+��� ÿ©ÿPü � V �V�©ü ý V ��úPü � V ��÷�ü¨� V �©ûPü ú V ÿ�ý�ü þ V ���Pü � V �ý�ü þ V ��÷�ü û V ���©ü ÿ Vù�U+�!÷ ÿ�÷�ü¨� V ���Pü ý V ��ùPü ÷ V ��÷�ü û V �©ûPü ù V ÿ�÷�ü ú V ���Pü ù V ��ûPü � V �©úPü ù V �©�Pü � VQ�ù�U+��ÿ ÿ©úPü ÿ V ���Pü ÿ V ��ûPü û V �©úPü ÷ V �©�Pü � V ÿ©ùPü ÷ V �!÷�ü¨� V ��ùPü ÷ V �©úPü ú V ��÷�ü ÿ VQ�ù�U+��ú ÿ��Pü¨� V �V�©ü û V ��úPü � V ��÷�ü ù V �©þPü û V ÿ©úPü ý V ���Pü ÷ V �ý�ü û V �©ÿPü ù V ���©ü ÷ Vù�U+�ý ÿ©�Pü û V ���Pü¨� V ��úPü � V ���Pü � V �©ûPü ÿ V ÿ©úPü ÿ V ���Pü þ V �ý�ü � V ��÷�ü ÿ V ���©ü ÿ Vù�U+��ù ÿ��©ü ý V �V�©ü � V ��úPü ÷ V ���Pü ÷ V �©ùPü ù V ÿ©ûPü ÷ V �V�©ü û V ��úPü ÷ V �©ÿPü¨� V �©�Pü þ Vù�U+��û ÿ©�Pü¨� V �V�©ü ÷ V ��ÿPü ù V ���Pü¨� V �©ùPü¨� V ÿ©ùPü � V ���Pü ú V ��úPü û V ��÷�ü ÿ V ���©ü � Vù�U��©þ ÿ©þPü � V �V�©ü � V ��ÿPü¨� V ���©ü ý V ��ý�ü ÿ V ÿ©úPü û V �V�©ü � V ��ÿPü û V ���Pü û V �©þPü � Vù�U���� ÷�ûPü¨� V ��þPü ÿ V �!÷�ü ÿ V �©þPü ÿ V �©úPü � V ÿ��Pü ÷ V �V�©ü þ V ��ÿPü ý V ���Pü ÷ V �©ûPü¨� VQ�ù�U��©� ÿ��Pü ý V ���Pü ÷ V �ý�ü ÿ V ��÷�ü ú V �©þPü ý V ÿ©úPü ù V �!÷�ü þ V ��ùPü ù V ��ý�ü ú V �©ÿPü � VQ�ù�U���� ÿ��Pü ú V �V�©ü ý V ��ÿPü þ V ���©ü ý V �©ùPü ÷ V ÿ©úPü ý V �V�©ü ÿ V ��úPü ý V ���Pü � V �©þPü ý Vù�U���÷ ÿ©�Pü ÷ V �V�©ü � V ��úPü � V ���Pü ú V �©ûPü ÿ V ÿ©ùPü¨� V �V�©ü û V ��úPü ÷ V �©ÿPü ÿ V �©�Pü ÿ Vù�U��©ÿ ÿ��©ü ÿ V �V�©ü � V ��úPü � V ���Pü ý V �©ûPü þ V ÿ�ý�ü û V ���Pü ý V �ý�ü þ V �©ÿPü � V �©�Pü þ Vù�U��©ú ÿ��©ü ÷ V �V�©ü � V ��ÿPü ÿ V �©�Pü û V �©ùPü � V ÿ�ý�ü ú V �V�©ü þ V ��úPü þ V ��÷�ü � V ���©ü ú Vù�U���ý ÿ��©ü � V �V�©ü � V ��úPü¨� V �©�Pü � V �©ùPü � V ÿ©ùPü þ V �V�©ü ù V ��úPü ý V �©ÿPü þ V �©�Pü û Vù�U��©ù ÷�ûPü ÿ V �V�©ü � V ��ÿPü ú V �©�Pü � V �©úPü ý V ÿ�÷�ü þ V �V�©ü ÿ V ��úPü þ V ���Pü ÿ V �©þPü ý VQ�ù�U��©û ÿ��Pü û V �!÷�ü ú V ��ùPü û V ��ý�ü ý V �©�Pü ÿ V ÿ©ùPü ÷ V ���Pü û V ��ùPü ÿ V �©ùPü þ V ��÷�ü ý VQ�ù�U��©þ ÷�ûPü ù V ���Pü ù V �ý�ü þ V �©ÿPü ÿ V �©þPü ù V ÿ�ý�ü ú V �V�©ü ú V ��úPü ú V �©úPü¨� V ���Pü � Vù�U���� ÿ��©ü ÿ V ��þPü û V ��ÿPü ý V ���Pü ÿ V �©ùPü ÿ V ÿ�ý�ü ÿ V �V�©ü ÷ V ��úPü ù V �©ÿPü þ V �©�Pü � Vû�U�þ�� ÿ��©ü ù V �V�©ü � V ��úPü � V ��÷�ü � V �©þPü þ V ú©þPü¨� V �V�©ü � V ��úPü ÿ V �©úPü ÿ V ���Pü ÷ Vû�U�þ©� ÿ©ÿPü ÿ V ���Pü � V �ý�ü ý V ��ý�ü þ V ���©ü¨� V ú©þPü � V ���Pü ÿ V �ý�ü � V ��ý�ü þ V ��÷�ü û Vû�U�þ�� ÿ��Pü � V �V�©ü ÿ V ��úPü û V �©ÿPü � V �©þPü ÷ V ÿ©ùPü ù V �V�©ü ú V ��úPü ý V �©ÿPü û V �©�Pü û Vû�U�þ�÷ ÿ��Pü ù V �V�©ü þ V ��úPü � V �©ÿPü¨� V �©þPü � V ÿ©ÿPü û V �V�©ü þ V ��úPü � V �©ÿPü¨� V ���©ü ù VQ�û�U�þ©ÿ ÿ��Pü � V ���Pü ÿ V �ý�ü ÿ V �©ÿPü ú V �©�Pü¨� V ÿ©ÿPü ù V ���Pü þ V �ý�ü¨� V ��÷�ü ÿ V ���©ü û VQ�û�U�þ©ú ÿ�÷�ü � V ���Pü¨� V ��ûPü þ V �©úPü � V �©�Pü � V ÿ©úPü � V ��þPü ý V ��ÿPü û V �©úPü ÷ V ���Pü¨� VQ�û�U�þ�ý ÿ©�Pü ú V ���Pü ÷ V ��ùPü û V ��÷�ü ú V �©ûPü ú V ý+�©ü þ V ���Pü ý V ��úPü ÿ V �©ÿPü ú V ���Pü¨� Vû�U�þ©ù ÿ©�Pü¨� V �V�©ü ù V �ý�ü � V �©ÿPü þ V �©þPü ÿ V ý��Pü û V ���Pü¨� V �ý�ü þ V �©úPü þ V �©�Pü ú Vû�U�þ©û ÿ��Pü ú V �V�©ü û V ��úPü ÷ V ���Pü û V �©ùPü û V ý�ÿPü ú V ���Pü þ V �ý�ü þ V ��÷�ü ù V �©�Pü þ Vû�U+��þ ú©úPü û V ���Pü � V ��÷�ü ÷ V ÷��©ü � V ÷�ÿPü ù V ù��©ü¨� V �©ùPü � V �©ÿPü¨� V ÷��©ü ý V ÿ©þPü þ Vû�U+�V� ù©�Pü ú V ú©þPü � V ú��Pü û V ú©ùPü ú V ý+�©ü � V ù©�Pü ù V ���Pü ÿ V ÷3ý�ü ù V ÿ�÷�ü ÿ V ú�÷�ü ÿ Vû�U+��� ù©úPü ú V ú©ùPü ù V ý+�©ü ú V ý�ÿPü ù V ý©ý�ü ù V ù�÷�ü � V �©ùPü þ V ÷3ý�ü¨� V ÿ�ý�ü þ V ú�ý�ü û Vû�U+��� ý©ý�ü ÿ V ÿ��Pü ÷ V ÿ�ý�ü¨� V ú��©ü ú V ú�÷�ü û V û��©ü¨� V ���Pü � V �©ùPü � V ÷�ùPü ý V ÿ©ùPü û Ví Þ��F nà ð ÿr�Sÿ s [X3k027C9;7C.Y0274. ] 0oan52< W 74[X3 syH/M d�+ T _1<\p Ô Ñ/J8Õ

z}Æ �

Page 184: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

ê$í!ìÔá!í!ë/8�1�ä©í!âoà�r C -�í!ì�5kí!âîU1q8Ôí 8�AU1q8J7G1q8�áRA�í!âN1>8�à©ê�8�à©êP5káà©ë�1�ãkã�ê�ì�í �:5kà�-�â�îU1�3�â1�ãkã ��þ©þ �©þ©þ ÿ©þ©þ ��þ©þ©þý>U+�!÷ ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1ý>U+��ÿ ÷��Pü � V ���Pü ÷ V ��ùPü þ V ��÷�ü ù V �©þPü¨� Vý>U+��ú ÿ©�Pü ÿ V ���Pü ù V ��ùPü û V �©úPü � V ���©ü ú Vý>U+�ý ÿ©ÿPü¨� V �!÷�ü¨� V ��ûPü ý V ��ý�ü ÿ V ���Pü ú VQ©ý>U+��ù ÿ©úPü û V ���Pü û V ��ûPü � V ��ý�ü � V ��÷�ü ÷ VQ©ý>U+��û ÿ�÷�ü ÿ V �!÷�ü¨� V ��ûPü � V �©úPü � V ���©ü � Vý>U��©þ ÿ�ý�ü ù V ���Pü¨� V ��ùPü ÷ V �©úPü þ V �©�Pü � Vý>U���� ú©þPü � V ���Pü � V ��ùPü û V �©ùPü þ V ���Pü � Vý>U��©� ú©�Pü ù V ���Pü ÿ V ��ûPü ÷ V �©ùPü ý V �©ÿPü þ Vý>U���� ú�÷�ü ý V �!÷�ü � V ��ûPü � V �©ùPü ý V ��÷�ü ù Vý>U���÷ ú©ÿPü � V ��ÿPü ÷ V �©þPü û V �©ùPü ý V ��÷�ü ÷ VQ©ý>U��©ÿ ú��Pü û V �!÷�ü ú V �©þPü ÿ V �©ùPü � V ���Pü ú VQ©ý>U��©ú ú�ý�ü¨� V ���Pü ÷ V ��ûPü ù V �©ûPü û V �©ÿPü ÿ VQ©ý>U���ý ú�ý�ü ù V ���Pü¨� V �ý�ü ý V ��ý�ü ù V ��÷�ü û VQ©ý>U��©ù ý�þPü ú V �V�©ü¨� V �ý�ü ÿ V �©ùPü � V �©ÿPü ù VQ©ý>U��©û ú©ùPü ÿ V �V�©ü � V �ý�ü ÿ V ��ý�ü � V ���Pü ÿ VQ©ý>U��©þ ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1ý>U���� ú©ÿPü¨� V ���Pü ÿ V ��ùPü � V �©ÿPü ÿ V ���©ü ú VQ�ù�U�þ�� ú��©ü � V ���Pü þ V ��úPü ú V �©ÿPü ÷ V ���©ü ý VQ�ù�U�þ©� ú©ûPü¨� V ���Pü ÷ V ��ùPü ú V ��ý�ü ù V ÷�þPü ý VQ�ù�U�þ�� ú©ûPü � V ��þPü þ V ��ÿPü û V ��ý�ü¨� V ���Pü � Vù�U�þ�÷ ú©ùPü¨� V ���Pü ÿ V ��ùPü û V ��ý�ü ý V ��÷�ü û Vù�U�þ©ÿ ú�ý�ü ÿ V ���Pü � V ��ûPü¨� V ��ý�ü � V �©�Pü ù Vù�U�þ©ú ú�ý�ü ú V ���Pü ÷ V ��ùPü ý V �©úPü ÿ V �©�Pü ÿ Vù�U�þ�ý ú©ùPü ù V ���Pü � V ��ùPü ÷ V �©úPü ý V ���Pü � VQ�ù�U�þ©ù ú©ûPü¨� V ���Pü ý V ��ûPü¨� V ��ý�ü ÿ V ���Pü � VQ�ù�U�þ©û ú�ý�ü � V ���Pü þ V �©þPü þ V �©ûPü ÷ V �©ÿPü ÷ Vù�U+��þ ú©ùPü û V �V�©ü ÷ V �ý�ü � V �©ÿPü � V ���©ü ú Vù�U+�V� ú©ûPü¨� V ���Pü¨� V �ý�ü ú V �©ÿPü ú V ���©ü û Vù�U+��� ý�þPü ÿ V ���Pü ú V ��ùPü¨� V ��ý�ü þ V ���Pü ù Vù�U+��� ú©ùPü ý V ���Pü¨� V �ý�ü þ V �©ÿPü � V �©þPü û Vù�U+�!÷ ú�ý�ü � V �!÷�ü þ V ��ûPü � V �©ÿPü û V ���©ü ÷ VQ�ù�U+��ÿ ú©ûPü ý V ���Pü ù V ��ùPü ý V �©úPü¨� V �©�Pü ú VQ�ù�U+��ú ú©ùPü ý V ���Pü ý V �ý�ü þ V �©�Pü û V �©þPü¨� Vù�U+�ý ú©ùPü ù V �V�©ü ÷ V ��úPü � V ���Pü ý V �©ûPü ù Vù�U+��ù ý�þPü ú V �V�©ü þ V ��úPü � V ��÷�ü � V �©þPü ý Vù�U+��û ý�þPü ú V �V�©ü ÷ V ��úPü ý V ���Pü û V �©ûPü ù Vù�U��©þ ý�þPü û V ��þPü ÿ V ��ÿPü ÿ V ���Pü � V �©ùPü û Vù�U���� ú�ý�ü û V ��þPü ý V ��ÿPü ú V ���Pü þ V �©ùPü ú VQ�ù�U��©� ú©ùPü û V �V�©ü ý V ��ùPü û V �©ÿPü ÷ V �©�Pü¨� VQ�ù�U���� ý+�©ü¨� V �V�©ü¨� V ��úPü ý V ���Pü þ V �©ûPü ú Vù�U���÷ ý+�©ü¨� V �V�©ü ÷ V ��úPü ÿ V ��÷�ü ú V �©þPü ú Vù�U��©ÿ ú©ûPü ý V �V�©ü ú V ��úPü ù V ��÷�ü ù V �©þPü ý Vù�U��©ú ý�þPü ú V ��þPü ÷ V ��ÿPü ù V ���Pü ÷ V �©ûPü ý Vù�U���ý ý�þPü ÿ V �V�©ü¨� V ��úPü ÷ V ��÷�ü � V ���©ü¨� Vù�U��©ù ú©ûPü � V ��þPü ý V ��úPü þ V ���Pü ÷ V �©ûPü � VQ�ù�U��©û ý�þPü¨� V ���Pü ÷ V ��ùPü ù V �©úPü ÷ V ���Pü ú VQ�ù�U��©þ ý+�©ü þ V �V�©ü þ V ��úPü ý V �©ÿPü ÿ V ���©ü ÷ Vù�U���� ý��Pü¨� V ��þPü ù V �ý�ü þ V ��÷�ü ÿ V ���©ü þ Vû�U�þ�� ý��Pü � V ��þPü ú V ��úPü � V �©ÿPü ú V �©�Pü¨� Vû�U�þ©� ý��Pü ú V �V�©ü û V �ý�ü ÷ V �©úPü ú V ��÷�ü¨� Vû�U�þ�� ý��Pü ù V ��þPü ú V ��úPü ú V �©ÿPü ý V ���©ü ÿ Vû�U�þ�÷ ý+�©ü þ V ��þPü ý V ��ÿPü ù V ��÷�ü ÷ V �©þPü ú VQ�û�U�þ©ÿ ú©ûPü ú V �V�©ü ý V ��ùPü þ V ��÷�ü ý V �©ûPü ù VQ�û�U�þ©ú ý��Pü ú V �V�©ü þ V �ý�ü ÿ V �©ÿPü ÷ V ���©ü ÿ VQ�û�U�þ�ý ý�ûPü¨� V �V�©ü ý V �ý�ü � V �©ÿPü ú V ���©ü ÷ Vû�U�þ©ù ù©�Pü þ V �V�©ü ÷ V �ý�ü þ V ��÷�ü ÿ V �©þPü ù Vû�U�þ©û ù��Pü ù V ��þPü ý V ��ÿPü û V ��÷�ü þ V �©þPü¨� Vû�U+��þ ù�ý�ü � V ùPü � V ��ÿPü û V ��÷�ü û V ÷©÷�ü ú Vû�U+�V� ù©ûPü � V ÷�úPü ÷ V ÿ�ý�ü ý V ú��Pü � V ú©ûPü ÿ Vû�U+��� û��©ü þ V ú©�Pü � V ú©ÿPü ý V ý+�©ü � V ý�ÿPü þ Vû�U+��� û©ÿPü ÷ V ÷�ùPü û V ÿ�÷�ü þ V ÿ©ûPü � V ú��Pü û Ví Þ��! ¦à ð ÿT�`ÿ s [X3�087:9;74.1087C. ] 0oan54< W 7C[X3 syH�M d�+ T _Y<>p Ô Ñ�Õ

z}Æ>Ì

Page 185: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

an<>5¹9kl U 365 F\� . � 3 � � 7C[�3�0 F 087C3 W 523B7 U 54=X0º7C[X3K0 U W©W 9\5 F .1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=Z<\aÖ74[X3K74<>f ¥ DX< ]6U W 3B=�740E 9\0236D�<>=%7C[X3 U 04365bP 0K543Bl U 36087C0 � 74[X3 syH/M d�+ T 0 F 087C3 W 523B7 U 54=X0K9\_Y_Ö0 U W©W 9\5 F .Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=<\aX74[X3º7C<>f ¥ DX< ]6U W 3B=�740e9;7®9K74. W 3 � . � 3 � � .¾7bDX<^3B0¢=�<\7®f�54<}cV.1DX3�3�µ^fX_1. ] .¾7S0 U W�W 9;5 F ] < W©W 9\=XDX0an<>5 U 0236520¢7C< U 023 � s 9 E _13 ��� Æ 0 U W©W 9\52. ¿ 3B0I7C[X3º087:9;74.10274. ] 0 � r <>_ U W = z _1.1087C0I74[X3�DX9;7C3 � r <>_ U W =Ä _1.1087C0e74[X3y= U W�E 3B5º<\aIl U 3B54.13B0 � r <>_ U W = Ç _Y.102740e7C[X3y= U W�E 365¹<\a¸DX< ]6U W 36=�7 E 3B.1=Xp�9 ]B] 3602043BD �r <>_ U W =%Ë�_Y.102740o7C[X3�549;7C.Y<Z<\a¢DX< ]BU W 36=�7y7C<�l U 365 F ] < W�W 9\=XD � r <>_ U W =X0 Î 7C[X52< U p>[ z ËZ_Y.10277C[�3Z= U W�E 3B5/<\a¹DX< ]6U W 36=�7 ] < W©W 9\=XD�0�7C[X9;7k9 ]B] 36020q9'DX< ]BU W 36=�7/7C[X9;7�.10�5C9\=X´;36D�9\0 z ½ z}Å��z>z ½ Ä\Å��XÄ^z ½ Ç\Å��XÇ�z ½ Ë Å�� Ë z ½ Î;Å��gÎ^z ½ Æ>Å���Æ�z ½ Ì>Å��XÌ\Å ½ z}Å\Å��Öz}Å^z ½ Ä\Å\Å�� 9\=�D�_19\54p>3B5t7C[X9\= Ä;Å>Å �M =�7C[X3'9}c\36549\p>3«an<>5�3�9 ] [l U 3B5 F ] < W�W 9\=�D � 74[X3 U 02365¶cV.13��y0 z � | DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0 � | �^��� q <\a7C[�3�DX< ]6U W 36=�7C0/74[X3 U 0236520/c^.Y3B��36D�9\543�5C9\=�´\36D�9\0�74[X3¶74<>f Ç>Å � M =X_ F)Å � Ʀq <\aºDX< ]6U W 3B=�7407C[�3 U 0436520�c^.Y3B��36D�9\543Z549\=X´\3BD�[�.1p>[X3B5/7C[g9;= Ä;Å>Å � M = 9'7 F f�. ] 9;_ADg9 F>� an<>5�3�9 ] [�l U 3B5 F>� 7C[�3U 02365ºc^.Y3B�y0�9\54< U =XD Ä DX< ]6U W 3B=�740 �º�tU 7�<\=©7C[�3KDX9 F 0¹�y[X36=�7C[X3 T 7:9;545º543Bf¸<>587 ] 9 W 3m< U 7 � an<\53�9 ] [{l U 365 F>� 7C[X3 U 043B5�cV.13��t3BD»9\0yan3B�v9\0 Å � Ë«DX< ]6U W 3B=�740 � . � 3 � � 7C[X3 U 043B540/D�.1D�=X<\7Kjg=XD{9;= F.1=�7436543B0274.1=Xp%DX< ]6U W 3B=�7�an<\5 W 9;= F l U 3652.13B0 � s [�3�523�9\02<>=".10�74[g9;7 W 9\= F U 0436520k36=�7C3B5436D .1=�74<7C[�3�0 F 02743 W ¼ U 087m7C<�54369\D%7C[X3 T 7C9\545t5436fi<>587 � [X<}��3Bc\365 � 9;7o74[g9;7m74. W 3 � 7C[X3 T 7C9\545o5236fi<>527y[X9\D=X<\7�.1=�f U 7K7C<«74[X3¶0 F 087C3 W � + ] 7 U 9\_Y_ F\� 023Bc\365C9;_®Dg9 F 0/_h9�7C365 � 7C[X3 syH/M d�+ T 0 F 02743 WôE 3 ] 9 W 39��o9;543'<\at7C[X.Y0¶fX52< E _13 W�� 9\=XD�023B7 U f�9\=X<\74[X365�_1.Y=X´{7C<�_13�9;D�7C[X3 U 043B540��y[X<�¼ U 027��o9\=�7�74<54369\D@7C[X3 T 7C9\545m5236fi<>527m74<«9\=�<\7C[X3B5mfg9\p>3k.Y=X02743�9\D�<\a¢043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp�74[X3��y[X<>_Y3�Dg9;7:9 E 9\043 �

�')VU �-,�.��O��:X?eEY. ��2*�s [X3�îµ ] .¾7C3�_1<>pq�t3/< E 7:9\.Y=X36D ] <>=�7:9;.1=X0�<>=X3�DX9 F _1<\p�.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=�<>= T 36f�743 W�E 365 z�Æ��¸z�|>| �^�� 3 U 043BDZ7C[X3o049 W 3 W 3B7C[�<^DX<\_1<>p F 9;0®�t3 U 043BD�.Y=Z9\=g9;_ F ¿ .Y=Xp�74[X3 syH/M d�+ T _1<>p � � 3 E U .Y_Y7®97C3B027ADX9;7:9 E 9\043¹7C<�9 U 7C< W 9;7C. ] 9\_Y_ F DX.102043 W .1=X9;7C3¹l U 3652.1360 E�F U 02.1=Xp/D�<Â�y=�_1<�9\D�0®<\ag74[X3���3 E 02.Y74360<>fi36549;7C3BD E�F 7C3B=%+ U 087C5C9;_1.h9;= R =X.¾c>3B5404.¾7C.Y360 Ô � Ä>Î d � �gÌ�z}Ç>Ç Ë¶DX< ]6U W 36=�740 Õ � �y[X. ] [@.10t9�fg9\587<\ab7C[X3 syu à r Î ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=¶L Ë Å N �s 9 E _13 ����� _1.Y02740S74[X3o087:9;74.10274. ] 0ban<>5S7C[�3oîµ ] .Y743t_Y<>p � 7C[�3t= U W�E 36520e<\agl U 3B54.13B0 � U =X.1l U 3�l U 3654.Y360 �7C<\fX. ] 0 � 7C<>fX. ] 0b< ]B]6U 5254.Y=Xp�<\= ] 3 � 7C<\fX. ] 0¢< ]6]BU 5452.1=Xp W <\543A7C[g9;=�<>= ] 3 � 9\=XDk7C<>fX. ] 0S7C[g9�7 ] <>=�7:9\.Y=

z}Æ>|

Page 186: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

�N-P7 ü ��-P7 ü î�à�á ê�í!ì�á�í!ë�8R1�ä©í9à�r î�à3á�-h7Bí�ë�8�â�rp1�ãkã65kë�ädIN5 8�AP5këJìR1�ëPO3âîP1q8Ôí à�r à�r = � | �V� | ��� | ��� | ÷�� | ÿ�� | ú�� | ù�� | ��þ�� | uC ìB3 î�à3á ü C ì�3 ��þ �©þ �©þ ÷�þ ÿ©þ ú©þ ù©þ ��þ©þ �©þ©þ �©þ©þý>U+�!÷ û©û©ú©û ��ù©þ�÷�ú �©ü ù ý�ùPü¨� V ùPü û V ÷�ü ú V �Pü � V �Pü ÷ V þPü � V þPü ú V þPü ú V þPü � V þPü¨� Vý>U+��ÿ û©ú©ÿ©ú �ý�ù©ú�ý �©ü û ý©ý�ü ÿ V ûPü ý V ÿPü � V �Pü � V �Pü¨� V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü ÷ V þPü¨� Vý>U+��ú û�ý��©þ �ý�ú©ú�� �©ü ù ý�ùPü � V ûPü � V ÷�ü ù V �Pü ÷ V �Pü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � Vý>U+�ý ù�÷��©û �!÷�ù��©þ �©ü ù ý�ûPü¨� V ûPü ÷ V ÷�ü ú V �Pü þ V �Pü þ V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü¨� V þPü¨� VQ©ý>U+��ù ����þ�÷ �©û��©ù �©ü û ý��Pü ý V �V�©ü ÷ V ÿPü ý V ÷�ü � V ÷�ü ù V þPü þ V þPü � V þPü � V þPü ÷ V þPü � VQ©ý>U+��û �����©ù ÷©÷���þ �Pü¨� ú©ùPü ý V ���Pü û V ùPü � V ÷�ü ú V ÷�ü¨� V þPü þ V þPü¨� V þPü¨� V þPü � V þPü¨� Vý>U��©þ ��þ��V��� ��û���ú©� �©ü û ý�ùPü � V ûPü ú V ÷�ü ù V �Pü ÷ V �Pü¨� V þPü � V þPü � V þPü¨� V þPü � V þPü¨� Vý>U���� û©û©þ©ÿ ��ù��©ù©þ �©ü û ý©ý�ü ý V ûPü � V ÷�ü û V �Pü þ V �Pü û V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V �©ü ÿ Vý>U��©� ��þ©ú©ÿ©þ ��û©ú©þ©þ �©ü ù ý©ý�ü � V ûPü ú V ÿPü ÿ V �Pü � V �Pü � V þPü � V þPü ÷ V þPü � V þPü � V þPü¨� Vý>U���� ��þ©ÿ©��ý �©þ©ù©þ©ÿ �Pü þ ý©ý�ü � V ûPü¨� V ÷�ü û V �Pü � V �Pü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V �©ü¨� Vý>U���÷ ù�÷�ú�� ��ÿ���ý�� �©ü ù ý©ý�ü ù V ûPü ÿ V ÷�ü ý V �Pü � V �Pü þ V þPü � V þPü ÷ V þPü ÷ V þPü ú V þPü � VQ©ý>U��©ÿ �©þ©û©ÿ ÷�þ©ù�� �Pü þ ý�ÿPü¨� V ûPü ú V ÿPü ÷ V ÷�ü ú V ÷�ü¨� V þPü¨� V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � VQ©ý>U��©ú �©����ù ÷�����û �Pü þ ý�ÿPü ý V ûPü ý V ÿPü � V ÷�ü � V ÷�ü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü¨� VQ©ý>U���ý �ý�þ©ÿ ����þ©ù �©ü ù ý©ý�ü û V ûPü¨� V �Pü û V �Pü þ V �©ü ý V �©ü � V �©ü û V �©ü þ V þPü � V þPü û VQ©ý>U��©ù ��ÿ�÷�� �©�©ÿ©� �©ü ÿ ù©þPü þ V ûPü þ V �Pü ù V �©ü ú V �©ü � V þPü ù V �©ü þ V �©ü ÿ V �©ü þ V þPü¨� VQ©ý>U��©û ��ÿ©�©û �©ù�ý�ú �©ü û ý�ûPü � V ý�ü ý V ÷�ü û V �Pü¨� V �©ü ÷ V þPü ú V þPü û V þPü û V þPü � V �Pü þ VQ©ý>U��©þ ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1 ë U 1ý>U���� ý�ù©ÿ©þ ��ú©ú©þ�� �Pü¨� ù��©ü ú V ý�ü ù V �Pü ù V �Pü ú V �Pü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü¨� V þPü¨� VQ�ù�U�þ�� ��û©û©ú ÷��©þ©� �Pü � ý�ÿPü ú V ûPü¨� V ÿPü¨� V ÷�ü þ V ÷�ü � V þPü � V þPü ÷ V þPü � V þPü ÿ V þPü ý VQ�ù�U�þ©� ���V� ÷�ù©ÿ �Pü � ú©úPü ù V ���Pü þ V ùPü � V úPü þ V ÿPü ù V þPü þ V þPü þ V þPü ÷ V þPü þ V þPü þ VQ�ù�U�þ�� ���©ù©ù �©�©ÿ©þ �©ü ù ù�÷�ü ÿ V úPü þ V ÷�ü þ V �©ü ú V �©ü ÿ V �©ü þ V �©ü þ V þPü ÷ V þPü þ V þPü þ Vù�U�þ�÷ ù©ù©�©ú ��ù©ú���÷ �Pü¨� ù©þPü ù V ý�ü ù V ÷�ü¨� V �Pü � V �Pü � V þPü¨� V þPü � V þPü � V þPü¨� V þPü¨� Vù�U�þ©ÿ û���ý�ú ��û©û©ù�ý �Pü¨� ù©þPü � V ùPü ÷ V ÷�ü ÷ V �Pü � V �Pü û V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � Vù�U�þ©ú û�÷©÷�ÿ ��û��©��� �Pü¨� ý�ûPü � V ûPü � V ÷�ü ý V �Pü¨� V �Pü þ V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü¨� V þPü¨� Vù�U�þ�ý ý�þ�÷�û �!÷�ú©þ©ÿ �Pü¨� ý�ûPü¨� V ùPü ÿ V ÷�ü ù V �Pü � V �Pü¨� V þPü � V þPü ÿ V þPü � V þPü¨� V þPü � VQ�ù�U�þ©ù ��ú©ù�ý �©��ý�ÿ �©ü û ý��Pü � V �V�©ü þ V ÿPü ú V �Pü û V ÷�ü ÿ V þPü ÷ V þPü ÷ V þPü¨� V þPü ÷ V þPü ú VQ�ù�U�þ©û �ý5÷�þ ÷����©ÿ �Pü ÷ ú��Pü û V ûPü ÷ V úPü þ V ÷�ü � V ÿPü¨� V �©ü þ V �Pü¨� V �©ü ù V ÷�ü¨� V �Pü ÷ Vù�U+��þ ý�ÿ�ý©ý ��ÿ©ÿ©ÿ©ù �Pü¨� ý�ùPü � V ùPü û V ÷�ü ÿ V �Pü � V �Pü¨� V þPü � V þPü ÷ V þPü ÷ V þPü ý V þPü � Vù�U+�V� ý�ù��V� ��ú����ý �Pü¨� ý©ý�ü ÷ V ûPü � V ÿPü þ V �Pü¨� V �Pü � V þPü � V þPü ÿ V þPü ÷ V þPü ý V þPü � Vù�U+��� ý5÷��©ù ��ÿ���û©ÿ �Pü¨� ý©ý�ü ÷ V ûPü¨� V ÿPü þ V �Pü ú V �Pü¨� V þPü � V þPü ÿ V þPü � V þPü ý V þPü¨� Vù�U+��� ý�þ©ù�÷ �!÷��©ÿ©û �Pü þ ý5÷�ü ÷ V ùPü û V ÿPü � V �Pü ú V �Pü ÿ V þPü ý V �©ü þ V þPü ù V þPü ù V �©ü � Vù�U+�!÷ ÿ���ú©þ ��þ©ÿ©ú©û �Pü¨� ý�ÿPü ú V ùPü ú V ÷�ü ù V �Pü ù V �Pü ÿ V þPü ÿ V �©ü þ V þPü ú V þPü ú V þPü û VQ�ù�U+��ÿ �!÷�ÿ©þ �©ù�ý�û �Pü þ ý��Pü � V ��þPü � V ÿPü ý V ÷�ü û V ÷�ü ú V þPü � V þPü ÿ V þPü¨� V þPü ÷ V þPü¨� VQ�ù�U+��ú �!÷�ÿ©ù ��ý��©ù �Pü þ ý��Pü ÿ V �V�©ü þ V úPü � V ÷�ü ÷ V �Pü û V þPü � V þPü � V þPü¨� V þPü � V þPü þ Vù�U+�ý ú����©û �����V��� �Pü þ ý©ý�ü ý V ùPü ý V ÿPü � V �Pü ý V �Pü¨� V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü û V þPü¨� Vù�U+��ù ú©ú�ý�� ���©ÿ©ú�� �©ü û ý�ûPü¨� V ùPü ÷ V ÷�ü ÷ V �Pü¨� V �Pü û V þPü � V þPü ÿ V þPü � V þPü ÿ V þPü ú Vù�U+��û ú©�©þ�� ���©ÿ�ý�ú �Pü þ ý�úPü ÷ V ý�ü û V ÷�ü ú V �Pü ÿ V �Pü ÷ V þPü � V þPü ÿ V þPü ú V �©ü ú V �©ü ÿ Vù�U��©þ ÿ©û���ÿ ��þ©û©ù©þ �©ü û ý©ý�ü þ V ûPü ÿ V ÷�ü ý V �Pü ÿ V �Pü � V þPü � V þPü ÷ V þPü ÷ V þPü ý V þPü � Vù�U���� ÷�ù�÷©÷ û�ý©ý�ÿ �Pü þ ý�úPü ý V ûPü ý V ÿPü¨� V �Pü ù V �Pü ú V þPü � V þPü � V þPü¨� V þPü¨� V þPü ý VQ�ù�U��©� �����V� ��÷�ù©þ �©ü û ý�ÿPü þ V ��þPü ÷ V ÿPü ú V �Pü ý V �Pü û V þPü¨� V þPü þ V þPü � V þPü þ V �©ü¨� VQ�ù�U���� �!÷©÷�ÿ �©ú���þ �©ü ù ý�þPü ÿ V ���Pü¨� V úPü¨� V ÷�ü ù V ÿPü ÷ V þPü � V þPü¨� V þPü � V þPü ÿ V þPü � Vù�U���÷ ÿ©ù©��� �V�V�!÷�ú �©ü û ý�ÿPü � V ûPü � V ÿPü � V �Pü ù V �Pü ÿ V þPü ÷ V þPü ý V þPü ÿ V þPü ú V �©ü¨� Vù�U��©ÿ ú���ú©ù �V��û���ÿ �©ü û ý�ÿPü � V ûPü � V ÿPü ý V �Pü ú V �Pü ý V þPü ÿ V þPü ú V þPü � V þPü � V þPü û Vù�U��©ú ú���ú�÷ ���©�©ú©û �Pü þ ý�úPü û V ùPü ý V ÷�ü ù V �Pü � V �Pü ÿ V þPü ÷ V þPü ÿ V þPü ÿ V �©ü þ V þPü ú Vù�U���ý ú©�©þ�� ��������� �Pü þ ý��Pü ÿ V ûPü ÿ V ÿPü ý V ÷�ü þ V �Pü ÷ V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü ù V �Pü � Vù�U��©ù ÿ����©ú û©ÿ©þ�� �©ü û ý�úPü ú V ùPü ý V ÿPü¨� V �Pü ú V �Pü ÷ V þPü ÷ V þPü ú V þPü ÿ V þPü ù V þPü ÷ VQ�ù�U��©û ��ú©ú�� ���©��� �Pü þ ú�÷�ü � V ��þPü ÿ V ÿPü ù V ÷�ü � V ÿPü¨� V þPü � V þPü ù V þPü û V �Pü � V ÿPü þ VQ�ù�U��©þ �©þ©�©ù �©����� �©ü ú ý��Pü¨� V �V�©ü þ V ý�ü¨� V ÷�ü ý V ÷�ü � V þPü þ V þPü¨� V þPü þ V þPü ÷ V þPü � Vù�U���� ú��©þ©û �V��ÿ©û�� �©ü ù ý©ý�ü � V ûPü ÷ V ÷�ü ù V �Pü ÷ V �Pü ÷ V þPü � V þPü ÿ V þPü ÷ V þPü � V þPü � Vû�U�þ�� ú©û©��ý ���©ÿ©��ý �©ü ù ý�ùPü¨� V ûPü¨� V ÿPü¨� V �Pü � V �Pü ÷ V þPü¨� V þPü ÷ V þPü � V þPü � V þPü¨� Vû�U�þ©� ý5÷��©� �!÷�ú©þ©ù �Pü þ ý�ÿPü þ V ùPü ÿ V ÷�ü û V �Pü ú V �Pü � V þPü ÷ V þPü ú V þPü ú V �©ü ÷ V �©ü ú Vû�U�þ�� ý����©þ ���©���©ù �©ü ù ý�ùPü¨� V ûPü � V ÷�ü ù V �Pü � V �Pü ÷ V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü ú V þPü � Vû�U�þ�÷ ú©ù��©ù ��þ©ù��©û �©ü ú ý�ÿPü ÿ V ûPü � V ÿPü � V �Pü ý V �Pü¨� V þPü � V þPü ÿ V þPü ÿ V �©ü � V þPü ý VQ�û�U�þ©ÿ ��ù���� �©�©��ý �©ü ù ý��Pü � V ��þPü¨� V ÿPü ú V ÷�ü ú V ÷�ü ý V þPü¨� V þPü¨� V þPü¨� V þPü ÿ V þPü û VQ�û�U�þ©ú �ý+�V� �©��÷�� �©ü û ú©ûPü ÿ V ��þPü ý V úPü ÿ V ÿPü ÷ V ÿPü � V þPü ÿ V �©ü þ V þPü û V þPü � V þPü¨� VQ�û�U�þ�ý ��ý�ú©ù ÿ�÷���÷ �Pü þ ú©úPü¨� V ��þPü � V úPü ù V ÿPü ú V úPü � V �©ü � V �©ü ý V �©ü ý V þPü ÷ V þPü þ Vû�U�þ©ù ù©ÿ©þ©ù ��ÿ©ÿ©û�� �©ü ù ý�ùPü � V ûPü � V ÷�ü ý V �Pü ÿ V �Pü ÷ V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü¨� Vû�U�þ©û ù©ù©þ©þ ��ú�����ý �©ü ù ý©ý�ü � V ûPü ú V ÿPü¨� V �Pü ÷ V �Pü ÿ V þPü¨� V þPü ÷ V þPü ÷ V þPü � V þPü¨� Vû�U+��þ �!÷�ÿ�÷�þ ��ú�ý�ù�÷ �©ü � ý�ùPü � V ûPü � V ÷�ü ù V �Pü ÷ V �Pü ú V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü � V þPü¨� Vû�U+�V� ��ÿ©ú©ÿ�ý ù��!÷©÷ þPü ÿ ý©ý�ü¨� V ùPü ý V ÷�ü û V �Pü ý V ÿPü þ V þPü¨� V þPü¨� V þPü þ V þPü � V þPü � Vû�U+��� �����V�!÷ ÿ©þ©þ©ÿ þPü ÷ ý��Pü ú V ��þPü ÿ V úPü þ V ÷�ü � V ÷�ü û V þPü � V þPü � V þPü¨� V þPü¨� V þPü � Vû�U+��� ý�þ©û©ÿ ÿ�÷�ù©ù þPü ù ý��Pü � V ��þPü ù V úPü ÷ V ÿPü þ V ÿPü¨� V þPü � V þPü¨� V þPü¨� V þPü¨� V þPü¨� V1���í ÿ©û©�©ù ��þ�÷���� �©ü û ý�ÿPü ù V ûPü ÿ V ÿPü � V �Pü ý V �Pü ú V þPü � V þPü ÿ V þPü ÷ V þPü ÿ V þPü ú Ví Þ��F nà ð ÿT�Iÿ ,/< ]6U W 36=�7K9 ]B] 3B040�087:9;74.1087C. ] 0oan54< W 7C[X3 syH�M d�+ T _Y<>p

z � Å

Page 187: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

��-P7Wï$í!ì�à�rC -�í!ì�5kí!â -�ëP5 C -�í C -Pí�ì�5kí!â 8�à©êP5ká!âà�á!á -�ì ü 7Bà©ìÔí�8�AP1�ë 7Bà©ìÔíN8�AU1�ëDà©ëPíîU1q8Ôí 8�à�8R1�ã I U ì�í!â�-�ã 8�â 8Ôà�8�1�ã I U ìÔí!â�-Pã 8Ôâ 8�à�8R1�ã à©ë�á!í à©ë�á!í -�ëh5 C -�í C -�í!ì�3þ©û�U+��ú�U�û�ý ÷�û©û©ù��©ú ÷©÷©÷�ù©û©û �©ú©ÿ©��ý�ú �©�©þ©û©ù�ý ��÷�û�÷�þ©ÿ ��û©ú©ú�ý�� ÿ©��ý���� �©��ý�ÿ©þê$í!ìÔá!í!ë/8�1�ä©í!âoà�r C -�í!ì�5kí!âF8�AU1q8�8�A�íW8Ôà©ên8Ôà©êP5ká!âN1�á!á�à�-Pë/8NrMà©ìÿ©þ©þ ��þ©þ©þ ÿ©þ©þ©þ ��þ©þ©þ©þ ��ÿ©þ©þ©þ �©þ©þ©þ©þþ©û�U+��ú�U�û�ý ���Pü � V ��úPü þ V ��ý�ü û V ��÷�ü ÷ V �©ùPü ú V ÷��Pü þ Ví Þ��! ¦à ð ÿ Öÿ s [�3q087:9;74.1087C. ] 0oan54< W 7C[X3qîµ ] .Y743k_1<>p �

W <>543¹7C[g9\=¶<>= ] 3 U =X.1l U 3tl U 365 F � J 7A9;_104<�_1.1087®[�<Â� W 9\= F <\a�l U 3652.1360¢7C[X3t74<>f Î\Å\Å���z}Å\Å>Å���Î;Å>Å>Å��z}Å>Å\Å>Å�� 9\=XD Ä;Å>Å>Å>Å 7C<>f�. ] 0 ] <}c\365e523604fi3 ] 7C.¾c>36_ F � s [X3o027C9;7C.Y0274. ] 0S02[X<}�³74[g9;7b7C[X3�îµ ] .Y743tl U 3B54.13B09\_Y04<k[g9�c>3�[X.1p>[�l U 3B5 F _1< ] 9\_Y.Y7 F {\74[X3m7C<>f Î\Å>Å 7C<>f�. ] 0 Ô 9\54< U =XD Ä$q <\aÖ74[X3m7C<\7C9\_X7C<\fX. ] 0 Õ ] <}c>3B5z>z � Î#q <\aKl U 3652.1360 � 9\=XD�7C[X3©7C<>f Ä\Å>Å\Å>Å 7C<\fX. ] 0 Ô 9\52< U =XD z�Ŧq <;aK74[X3'7C<;7:9\_º7C<>f�. ] 0 Õ ] <}c>3B5Ç>| � Ʀq � + W <\=Xp©74[X3¶7C<\fX. ] 0K74[g9;7/< ]6]BU 545236D W <>543q7C[g9;={<>= ] 3 �IÆ>Ä#q Ô Ç�Ä � Î\Å Õ ] <>=�7:9;.1= W <>5437C[X9\=»<>=X3 U =�.1l U 3�l U 3B5 F ��T .1= ] 3¶��3�<>=X_ F [g9�c\3�74[X.10�<>=X3�Dg9 F _1<>p � �t3 ] 9\=»=X<\7 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7/7C[�3.1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>='9 E < U 7y<Âc\3652_h9\f�<\ab7C<>fX. ] 0 E 3B7É��3636=�Dg9 F 0 �

z � z

Page 188: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

������� $ ²����Æ&��³Ö

L z Nq+ ] [g9;5 F 9 � T¸� � 9\=XD G DX<>=�.1´ � T¸� ��� +�=@3BÀ ] .Y36=�7y0 ] [�3 W 3kan<\5tD F =g9 W . ] Dg9;7:9�5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= �s 3 ] [ � u 3Bf � r T�½ |>Ç ½ Ë Ç�� ,/3Bfg9\587 W 36=�7¹<\a r < W f U 74365 T^] .Y36= ] 3 � � 54<}�y= R =X.Yc\365204.Y7 F\� T 36f�7 �z}|>|>Ç �

L Ä Nq+�p�9;52�t9\_ � , � � 9\=XD�+ E�E 9\DX. � + � à � s [X3m7C52363yl U <>5 U W fX52<\7C< ] <>_ � +�=�3BÀ ] .Y36=�7o9;fXfX54<>9 ] [an<>5 W 9\=g9\p>.Y=Xp�543BfX_1. ] 9;7436DDg9;7C9 � J = ���C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§����L�»��¬g��������¬��I ���� à����������C����¾:�Ô z}|\|>Å Õ �

L Ç Nq+�[g9 W 9\D � d � � 9;=XDö+ W©W 9\5 � d � H � ?b3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3 ] [g9;5C9 ] 7C3652. ¿ 9;7C.Y<>= <;a'l U <>5 U W ½] <>=�0436=�0 U 0@9\_Yp><>52.Y7C[ W 0Zan<>5�543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D�Dg9�7:9 � Ð������ ���2�\���6�`¾��ø¥ ���!�L� � �L�Ú�¦Ü¹�\�:�O����ѧ\¥��Ö�:���Ú¥��V§��}� � Ë Ô +�fX5 � z}|\Ì>| Õ �

L Ë$Nq+�_¾7:9 Ñ .1027C9 � ¬V�¦� �h�,�}�iÜAÜAܹ¯��$¹ �Ò�$À}¥1��� ��¯_¾:����� �L Î N � 9\3B=�740 ] [ � d � � d�<>_¾7C365 � O � � 9\=XD T 7 U 5 W�� ? � J =�7454<VD UX] .Y=Xp/9;fXfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= ½ _13�c>3B_\543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=9\=XD�=g9 W .1=Xpk.Y=�74<q74<^DX9 F P 0 � 3 E � J = ���:��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§����L���º¥ �Ú��¬Ð��g�É���Ú�i�\�ø¥ ���i�$¹t�)���C¹¾£��%¥¦£V��{�6ª à����������:����¾:� Ô ?®9;54.10 � w 5C9\= ] 3 � d�9 F"z�|>|>Æ Õ �

L Æ N � 9\.Y_13 F\� ? � � 9\=�D H 9��y´�.1=Xp � , � +öfg9;5C9\_Y_136_S9;5 ] [X.¾7C3 ] 7 U 523�an<>5Kl U 365 F f�54< ] 360204.Y=Xp'<}c>3B5�97C3B5C9 E�F 7C3�<\ae7C3ÚµV7 � s 3 ] [ � u 36f � syu ½ r T�½ |>Æ ½ Å Ë � s [X3�+ U 087C5C9;_1.h9;= N 9;7C.Y<>=g9\_ R =X.Yc\365402.Y7 F\�� U =X3 z}|>|\Æ �

L � N � 36087:9�cV54<>0 � + � ,/3 W 9\=XD ½ E 9\0236D@DX< ]6U W 36=�7KDX.Y04043 W .Y=g9;74.1<>=«74<�5436D UX] 3k7C549;À ] 9;=XD E 9\_ ½9\= ] 3�_1<�9;D).1=)DX.1087C54. E U 7436D{.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=�0 F 02743 W 0 � J = ���C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��©�L� � ���/�p� �}�}���I¬g�  �n¬ÓÐ������ � �;���g�}��¥�¡V� ����m�\�2�$¹Ç¹1��¹/�\�i£¡�k¥1���¦�Ú¥¦ª6¡^�É�4£���C��¾:�:�:��¥��V§ Ô T 9\=+�=�<\7C<>=�.1< �s 3Úµ�9\0 � M ] 7 � z}|>|�Î Õ �

L Ì N � [g9;727:9 ] [X9\5n¼23B3 � Ti� � + W�W 9\5 � d � H � � G 36p U 5C9 � à � � � � T [X9\[ � Ñ � � 9\=XD w 36. � G �+�fXf�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>= ½ _h9 F 3B5o9\= F ] 9\087C.Y=Xp � J = �t�C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§����L��Ð��¢��£(à�£¤�¥�   Ô z}|\| � Õ �

L | N � <}� W 9;= � r � d � � ,�9\= ¿ .1p � ? �Ð��� � H 9\52D F>� , � u � � d)9\= E 365 � R � � 9\=XD T^] [��o9\587 ¿ � w � H 9\5 ½c>3B027 � 9«0 ] 9\_h9 E _13 � ]6U 027C< W . ¿ 9 E _Y3�D�.10 ] <}c>365 F 9\=�D"9 ]6] 36040�0 F 027C3 W � s 3 ] [ � u 36f � roR ½ r T�½� Ç�Ä ½ | Ë � ,/36fX9\527 W 3B=�7�<\a r < W f U 7C3B5 T^] .Y36= ] 3 � R =X.Yc\365402.Y7 F <\a r <>_Y<>5C9\D�<�9�7 � < U _1D�365 �� U _ F)z}|>| Ë �

L z}Å N �tUX] ´�_13 F>� r � J W fX_13 W 3B=�7C9;7C.Y<>=�<;aK74[X3'0 W 9\587�.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>= 543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_¹0 F 02743 W � s 3 ] [ �u 3Bf � Ì�Î ½ Æ>Ì>Æ�� r < W f U 7C3B5 TV] .13B= ] 3o,/36fg9\587 W 36=�7 � r <>54=�36_1_ R =X.Yc\365402.Y7 F\� J 7C[X. ] 9 � Nyx � d�9 Fz}|>Ì�Î �

z � Ä

Page 189: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

L z>z N �tU 52´\<}�y04´�. � w � � � u 3�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_ofi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3@<\a/9"DX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D7C3ÚµV7©DX9;7:9 E 9\043 U 7C.Y_1. ¿�½.1=Xp{9"fX9\5C9\_Y_13B_�fX52< ] 36020�D�< ]BU W 3B=�7�043658c>3B5 � J = �}�}��¦�ÐÚ�g�L���Ú�i�\�¦¥ ���i�$¹ � �����g�}��¥�¡^� £o����\� ��ª:���}�:��¥��@�o�\�4�$¹Ç¹1��¹Ö�\�i£§�k¥1���ø�Ú¥¦ª6¡V�L�4£ � �Â���É���¶� Ô s 52.1=X.¾7 F r <>_1_Y36p>3 � , U E _1.Y= � J 5436_19\=XD �� U _ F)z}|>|>Å Õ � fXf ��� z�½ � | �

L zÂÄ N r 9\[X<V<>= � ��� � 9\=XDd ] � .1=X_Y3 F>� � �eT¸� ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3©3Bc;9\_ U 9;7C.Y<>=�<;ay9�DX.Y027454. E U 7C3BD�9\5 ½] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 523)an<>5�.1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=³523B7454.13�c;9\_ � J = ���C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��»�L����¬g�O�/¥��Ö���É�:���g��¬ ~ �g�g¡��$¹Ð��g�É���Ú�i�\�ø¥ ���i�$¹ ~ àM� � Ð � Ð�Ò à����������:����¾:�©���vÒy�:�}�4�\�¿¾:¬��\�i£N����À\��¹1�:�i�«���g�y¥��¶Ð��������CÑ���\�ø¥ ����ÒK���¦�Ú¥ ��À��$¹ Ô G U 54. ] [ � T �y.¾7 ¿ 3B54_19\=XD � + U p � z�|>|>Æ Õ � fXf � z>z�Åt½iz>z}Ì �

L z}Ç N r 9\[X<V<>= � ��� � d ] � .1=�_13 F\� � �eT¸� � 9\=�D P U � G � ÃAc;9\_ U 9;74.1=Xp)74[X3%fi3652an<\5 W 9\= ] 3«<\a�D�.10 ½7C52. E U 7436Dq9\5 ] [X.Y743 ] 7 U 543B0`an<>5`.1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>=�523B7C52.13�c\9;_ U 04.Y=XpK9yc;9\52.13�7 F <\aV�t<\54´�_1<�9;DX0 � ~ àM��X�2�\���6�`¾��¦¥ ��� ����ÐÚ�����������\�¦¥ ��� � �����L���¶��Ãø��¡Xª6�Z¥��¦�L�4£^Ä Ô z}|>|>| Õ �

L z Ë$N r 9\_1_19\= � � � ? � � r 52<\a�7 � � �¢��� � 9\=XD H 9\54D�.1=Xp � T¸� d � s [X3 JLN Á R à ubx 543�7C52.13Bc;9\_º0 F 0 ½7C3 W � J = ���:��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��k�L�K��¬g��¨>�2£pÐ��g�É�����i�\�¦¥ ���i�$¹Gà����������C����¾:�k���N�q�\�Ò��ª:���}�/�\�i£©��KB�g������ �Â���É��� ~ ����¹ ¥�¾4�\�ø¥ ����� Ô Ñ 9\_13B= ] .19 � T fg9\.1= � T 36f�7 � z}|>|�Ä Õ �

L zÂÎ N r 9\_1_19\= � � � ? � � P U � G � � 9\=XD r 52<\a�7 � � �®���)T 369\5 ] [X.Y=Xp{DX.Y027454. E U 7C3BD ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0��y.Y74[.1=�an3B543B= ] 3/=�3B7É��<>54´�0 � J = ���C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��q�L�/��¬g����¥¾§�¬V�L�:���g��¬ ~ �g�g¡��$¹�ÐÚ�g�L���Ú�i�\�¦¥ ���i�$¹ ~ àM�� Ð � Ð�Ò�à����������C����¾:�y���ÒK�:�}�4�\��¾:¬Z�\�i£ª����À\��¹1�:�i�«���g�Ö¥���Ð��������Ú���\�¦¥ ����ÒK���¦�Ú¥ ��À��$¹ Ô T 3�9;7 ½7C_Y3 � � + � � U _ F)z}|>|�Î Õ �

L z}Æ N r 9\543 F>� d � � � � 9\=�D P .YcV= F>� d � ,/.1087C52. E U 7436D ] <\= ]6U 52543B= ] F ] <\=�7454<>_yfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3 � +027 U D F <;a¶9;_1p><>52.Y74[ W 0 � DX.1087C52. E U 74.1<>=·9\=XD�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>= � J = ���C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��"�L�)��¬g���¬«g��¬�I ���� à����������C����¾:� Ô P <>0m+�=Xp>36_Y360 � r + �bz�|>Ì>Ì Õ �

L z � N r 9\5274365 � u � P � � 9;=XD r 54<}c>3B_1_19 � d � à � , F =X9 W . ] 023652c\365�043B_13 ] 7C.Y<>= U 04.Y=Xp E 9\=�D��y.1D�74[fX54< E .1=Xp».Y=��y.1DX3 ½ 9\523�9»=X3�7É�t<>52´�0 � s 3 ] [ � u 3Bf �º� R ½ r T�½ |>Æ ½ Å\Å � � � <>087C<>= R =X.Yc\365402.Y7 F\�d)9\5 � z}|>|>Æ �

L z}Ì N r [g9\´�5C9�c;9\587C[ F>� + �ÐT¸� � 9\=XD H 9>9\023 � � � ��� N 3�7C043B52a � R 04.1=�p�043 W 9\=�74. ] ´V=�<Â�y_Y36DXp\3�7C<qjg=XD.1=�7C3B54=X3�7q.1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=»9\5 ] [�.Yc>3B0 � J = ���:��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��«�L���n¬g����­>��¬ ~ �g�g¡X�$¹�ÐÚ�g�L���Ú�i�\�¦¥ ���i�$¹~ àM� � Ð � Ð¿Ò à����������C����¾:�/���~ÒK�:�}�4�\��¾:¬«�\�i£©����À\��¹1�:�i�«���g�S¥���Ð��������Ú���\�¦¥ ����Òy���ø�Ú¥ ��À��$¹Ô T 369;7474_13 � � + � � U _ F{z�|>|�Î Õ � fXf � Ë ½�z>z �

L z}| N r [X3 U =Xp � T¸� x � � + W�W 9\5 � d � H � � 9\=XD»+�[X9 W 9;D � d � s [X3Zp\54.1D)fX54<\74< ] <>_ � 9'[X.Yp>[{fi365 ½an<>5 W 9\= ] 3«0 ] [X3 W 3'an<>5 W 9\.1=�7C9\.1=X.Y=Xp@543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=�Dg9;7:9 � J = ���C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��@�L�'��¬g�©��¥�K>��¬Ð��g�É���Ú�i�\�ø¥ ���i�$¹�à����������:����¾:�¶�������\� ���t�V§\¥��Ö�:���Ú¥��V§ Ô � 9\= � z}|\|>Å Õ � fXf � Ë Ç>Ì�½ Ë>Ë Î �

L Ä\Å N r < U cV543 U 5 � s � u � � � 3B= ¿ 3B_ � u � N � � d�.1_1_Y365 � Ti� w � � G 36.¾7C_Y365 � , � N � � P 3B3 � , � P � � T .Y=Xp>[g9;. �d � � T [X.¾c\9;5C9;7454. � N � � 9;=XD � <>=Xp � � � x � ? � +�=�9\=g9\_ F 02.10q<\amfi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3'9\=XD ] <>087a¦9 ] 74<>540�.1=�043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp%_h9\52p>3k7C3�µV7�DX9;7:9 E 9\043B0 U 04.Y=Xp'fg9\549\_1_Y36_`023�9\5 ] [ 0 F 027C3 W 0 � ¤g��¡^�Ú�i�$¹�L����¬g� ~ �«����¥�¾4�\� � ��¾�¥ ���ø�y�����;Ð��������Ú���\�¦¥ ��� � ¾�¥ ����¾:�   � Ë Î Ô z}|>| Ë Õ � Ë>Ë Çt½ Ë Æ Ë �

L Ä^z N r 54.Y=Xp>3�9;= � � � � � � ÃA=Xp>_19\=XD � u � � d)9;04<>= � O � + � � 9\=XD � .1_1_Y3B727 � ? � ?¢9\5C9\_Y_13B_�7C3Úµ^7¹023�9\5 ] [ ½.1=Xp�.Y=�043652.h9\_XjX_1360 U 02.1=Xpq9�fX52< ] 360402<>5ºa¦9\5 W � J = ���C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��/�L�y�n¬g���I¬V¥��Ú�É�:���g�n¬ ~ �g�g¡��$¹Ð��g�É���Ú�i�\�ø¥ ���i�$¹ ~ àM� � Ð � Ð�Ò à����������:����¾:�©���vÒy�:�}�4�\�¿¾:¬��\�i£N����À\��¹1�:�i�«���g�y¥��¶Ð��������CÑ���\�ø¥ ����ÒK���¦�Ú¥ ��À��$¹ Ô � 5 U 04043B_10 � � 36_1p\. U W�� T 36f�7 � z�|>|>Å Õ �

z � Ç

Page 190: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

L Ä>Ä N r 54<\a�7 � � �;��� � r <V<>´ � u � � 9\=XD � .Y_1DX3B5 � , � ?º52<}c^.YDX.1=�p�p><}c>3B54= W 36=�7®.1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=�<>=¶7C[�3J =�7C3652=X3B7 � îµ^f¸3B54.13B= ] 3B0��y.Y74[ syH�M d�+ T¸� J = �I¬g� � �¿¾:���i£MÐÚ�g�L���Ú�i�\�¦¥ ���i�$¹zà����������C����¾:����{��¬g�@�I¬g�:�����©�\�i£����2�`¾��ø¥�¾:�¶�L���k¥¾§\¥��Ò�$¹i ®¥¦ª6�2�\�Ú¥ �:� Ô + U 0274.1= � s Í � � U =X3 z}|>|>Î Õ �

L Ä\Ç N�,�9\= ¿ .1p � ? ����� � +�[X= � � � � N <>_Y_ � � � � 9\=�D M E 5C9 ]6¿ ´�9 � � � ,/.1087C52. E U 7436DÙ.1=XDX3Úµ^.1=Xp � +0 ] 9\_h9 E _13 W 3 ] [g9;=X.10 W an<>5�DX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D".Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=�543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_ � J = ���C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��«�L�Z��¬g��¢��¡V�Ú�L�:���g��¬ ~ �g�g¡��$¹�ÐÚ�g�L���Ú�i�\�¦¥ ���i�$¹ ~ àM� � Ð � Ð¿Ò à����������:����¾:�Z����Òy�:�}�4�\��¾:¬)�\�i£w����ÑÀ\��¹1�:�i�«���g�A¥���Ð��������Ú���\�¦¥ ����Òy���ø�Ú¥ ��À��$¹ Ô r [X. ] 9\p>< � JLP �`z}|>|�z Õ � fXf � Ä>Ä^z�½�Ä\Ä\| �

L Ä Ë$N�,/<}�yD F>� , � � 9\=XD w <>087C3B5 � , � r < W fg9;5C9;74.Yc>3 W <^D�36_10y<\a¢7C[X3kjg_Y3�9;0404.Yp>= W 36=�7KfX54< E _13 W �à������i¡^�¦¥��V§ � ¡V�CÀ\���Â�§�¬« ��Ä Ô � U =X3 z}|>Ì�Ä Õ �L Ä>Î N�ú9\p>365 � , � P � � 9\=XD T 3�cV. ] ´ � � � r � + ] [�.13BcV.Y=Xp54< E U 027C=�[email protected]=�DX.1087C54. E U 7436D�Dg9;7C9 E 9\023

0 F 02743 W 0 � ~ àM� �X�2�\���6�`¾��ø¥ ���������K���\� ��ª:���}� � �Â���É���¶��­ ��Ç Ô T 36f�7 � z}|>Ì>Ç Õ �gÇ�Î Ë ½^Ç>Ì�z �L Ä\Æ N�Ãean5C9\. W .YDX.10 � ? � � O _ FVW .YDg9\´�.10 � r � � d)9 W 9\_Y.10 � ��� � T f�.15C9;´V.Y0 � ? � � 9\=XD s 9 W fg9\´�9\0 � ���

?®9\549\_1_Y36_o743�µV7'523B7C52.13�c\9;_K<\=�9�[�.1p>[Ùf¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�0 U fi365 ] < W f U 74365 U 04.1=�p�7C[�3�c>3 ] 74<>504fg9 ] 3 W <^DX3B_ � J = ���C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§����L�m��¬g����¥¾§�¬V�L�:���g��¬ ~ �g�g¡��$¹BÐ��g�É���Ú�i�\�ø¥ ���i�$¹ ~ àM� � Ð � пÒà����������C����¾:�t���Òy�:�}�4�\�¿¾:¬q�\�i£¢����À\��¹1�:�i�«���g��¥��pÐ��������Ú���\�ø¥ ���pÒK���¦�Ú¥ ��À��$¹ Ô T 3�9�747C_Y3 � � + �z}|>|�Î Õ � f�f � Î\Ìt½^Æ\Æ �

L Ä � N�îµ ] .Y743 � ¬V�¦� �h�,�}�iÜAÜAܹ¯¦�:K�¾�¥��É�6¯_¾:��� �L Ä\Ì N w 9\_1< U 7C04<\0 � r � � 9;=XD r [X52.10274<^D�< U _h9;´V.Y0 � T¸�gT .Yp>=X.¾7 U 523ºjX_1360 � +�=Z9 ]B] 36020 W 3�7C[X<VDX0ban<>5¢D�< ]Ú½

U W 36=�7C0�9;=XD».Y740�9\=g9\_ F 7C. ] 9\_Sf¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3�3�c;9\_ U 9�7C.1<\= � ~ àM� �X�2�\���6�`¾��¦¥ �������®£h¯H¾:�Ð��������Ú���\�¦¥ ��� � �}���L���¶��° � Ë Ô M ] 7 � z}|\Ì Ë Õ �gÄ\Æ � ½�Ä;Ì>Ì �

L Ä\| N w U [X5 � N � +�DX3 ] .104.Y<>= ½ 7C[X3B<>543�7C. ] 9\f�fX54<�9 ] [«7C<�DX9;7:9 E 9\043�0436_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=«.1=«=X3B7É��<>54´;[email protected] � J =�{���P¢}�:¬g�:�����±�k¥1���ø�Ú¥¦ª6¡V�L�4£MÐ�Ò Ô O 3B5 W 9\= F>�Iz�|>|>Æ Õ �

L Ç>Å N O .¾ØÖ<\54D � , � � 36.1p\[�7436Dc><\74.1=Xp"an<>5Z5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C36DDg9�7:9 � J = �t�C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��{�L�   �n¬ ~ àM�� �;���g�}��¥�¡V�è���¡£¢�g���2�\�¦¥��V§ � �}���L��� ���Ú¥���¾�¥Ð��¹1�:� Ô z}| � | Õ � fXf � zÂÎ;Åt½iz}Æ�Ä �

L Ç�z N O 549�c\9;=X< � P � � 9\=XD O 9;5 ] .19 ½ d�<>_1.Y=g9 � H � O 36=X3B5C9\_Y. ¿ .Y=Xp�p\_1<>020®7C<�c>3 ] 74<>5 ½ 04fg9 ] 3yDg9;7:9 E 9\043B09\=XD E 52<>´\3B5Z[X.13B5C9\5 ] [X.13B0 � J = ���C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§����L�«�n¬g��°������±�Ö V��� à����������C����¾:� Ô G U 52. ] [ �T �y.Y7 ] [X_h9;=XD �Iz}|\|�Î Õ �

L Ç�Ä N O 549�c\9;=X< � P � � O 9\5 ] .h9 ½ d�<>_1.Y=g9 � H � � 9;=XD s < W 9\02. ] � + � s [�3Z3Bظ3 ] 74.Yc\36=X3B040q<\aºp>_1<\040�an<\57C[X3k7C3ÚµV7/Dg9;7C9 E 9\023¶DX.Y0 ] <Âc\365 F fX52< E _Y3 W � J = ���:��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��Z�L�q��¬g� � Ð � �¡£¤�²�¬« Ô T 36f�7 �z}|>| Ë Õ � f�f � zÂÄ\Æt½�z}Ç �^�

L Ç>Ç N O 549 F>� � � � H 36_1_19\=XD � ? � � M P N 36.Y_ � ? � � 9\=XD T [g9;04[g9 � , � s [X3kDg9\=�p>36520m<\ab5436f�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>='9;=XD9�04<>_ U 7C.Y<>= � J = ���C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��/�L� ~ àM� � Ð � �³£¤�´� ��� Ô d�<\=�7454369\_ � r 9\=X9\Dg9 � � U =X3 z}|>|\Æ Õ �fXf � z � Çt½iz}Ì�Ä �

L Ç Ë$N O U F 74<>= � � � � 9;=XD T^] [��t9\5 ¿ � d � P < ] 9�7C.1=�pÙ=X369\5 E�F ] <>f�.1360�<\a�543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D�.1=�7C3B54=X3�7043B52c>3B540 � s 3 ] [ � u 36f � roR ½ r T�½G� Æ>Ä ½ |�ÎV� R =�.Yc>3B5402.Y7 F <;a r <\_1<>549\DX<�9;7 � < U _YDX365 � w 3 E � z�|>|�Î �

z � Ë

Page 191: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

L Ç�Î N H 9\52D F>� , � u � � 9\=�D T^] [��t9\527 ¿ � d � w � r U 087C< W . ¿ 36D�.1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\='3�µV7C549 ] 74.1<>=�9\0�9 E 9\04.Y0an<>5�543602< U 5 ] 3{DX.Y0 ] <Âc\365 F � ~ àM� �X�2�\���6�`¾��¦¥ �����{��� à������i¡^�É��� � �}���É���¶�K�¬« �KÄ Ô d�9 Fz}|>|>Æ Õ �Öz � z�½iz}|\| �

L Ç>Æ N H 9\5 W 9;= � , � � úD � �I¬g���º¥��C���k�¸�:K>�KÒµ�t�¦�Ú¥ ��À��$¹zà����������C����¾:� Ã6�IÒµ��à ÑR�^Ä � N 9;7C.Y<>=g9\_ J = ½0274.Y7 U 7C3/<\a T 7:9\=XDX9\54DX0y9;=XD s 3 ] [X=X<>_Y<>p F T f¸3 ] .19\_I? U E _Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= Ä\Å>Å ½ Ä^z � � O 9\.¾7C[X3B540 E U 54p �d), �Iz}|\|�Ä �

L Ç � N H 9\5 W 9;= � , � � ÃAD � �I¬g� � �¿¾:���i£%�i�:K>��Òµ�t�¦�Ú¥ ��À��$¹Dà����������C����¾:��Ã6�IÒ¢��à Ñ>°�Ä � N 9;74.1<>=g9;_ J = ½0274.Y7 U 7C3/<\a T 7:9\=XDX9\54DX0y9;=XD s 3 ] [X=X<>_Y<>p F T f¸3 ] .19\_I? U E _Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= Ç>Å>Å ½ Ä^z � � O 9\.¾7C[X3B540 E U 54p �d), �Iz}|\|>Ç �

L Ç>Ì N H 9\5 W 9;= � , � � úD � �I¬g�©�I¬V¥��4£»�¸�:K>�!Òµ���¦��¥ ��À��$¹�à����������C����¾:�+Ã6�IÒµ��à Ñ�¨fÄ � N 9;74.1<>=g9;_ J = ½0274.Y7 U 7C3/<\a T 7:9\=XDX9\54DX0y9;=XD s 3 ] [X=X<>_Y<>p F T f¸3 ] .19\_I? U E _Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= Î\Å>Å ½ Ä>Ä>ÎV� O 9\.¾7C[X3B540 E U 54p �d), �Iz}|\| Ë �

L Ç>| N H 9\5 W 9;= � , � � úD � �I¬g���b��¡V����¬�¸�:K>�}Òµ�t�¦�Ú¥ ��À��$¹ à����������:����¾:�ÐÃ6�IÒµ��à Ñ<«4Ä � N 9;7C.Y<>=g9\_J =X0274.Y7 U 7C3�<;a T 7C9\=XDg9;54DX0k9\=�D s 3 ] [�=X<>_1<\p F T fi3 ] .h9\_®? U E _1. ] 9;74.1<>= � O 9\.Y74[X36520 E U 52p � d), �z}|>|�Î �

L Ë Å N H 9\5 W 9;= � , � � úD � �I¬g�O�º¥ �Ú��¬ �i�:K>��Òµ���¦��¥ ��À��$¹�à����������C����¾:� Ã6�IÒµ��à ÑR�^Ä � N 9;7C.Y<>=g9\_J =X0274.Y7 U 7C3�<;a T 7C9\=XDg9;54DX0k9\=�D s 3 ] [�=X<>_1<\p F T fi3 ] .h9\_®? U E _1. ] 9;74.1<>= � O 9\.Y74[X36520 E U 52p � d), �z}|>|>Æ �

L Ë z N H 9\5 W 9;= � , � � d ] r < F>� � � � s <^3B=X043 � u � � 9\=XD r 9\=XDX3B_h9 � O � ?A54<;7C<\7 F fX.Y=Xpq9kD�.1027454. E U 7C3BD.1=�an<\5 W 9;7C.Y<>=/543�7C52.13Bc;9\_�0 F 027C3 W 74[g9;7 U 02360®087:9;74.1087C. ] 9\_�5C9;=X´�.1=Xp � ÐÚ�������Ú���\�ø¥ ���¶���C��¾:�:�:��¥��V§¶ �»�\�i�}§V���«���g�t°   �gÎ Ô z}|>|�z Õ � Ë>Ë |t½ Ë Æ>Å �

L Ë Ä N H 9��y´�.1=Xp � ,�9}cV.YD � r 5C9;02��36_1_ � N . ] ´ � 9\=�D s [�.10274_13��o9\.¾7C3 � ?®9 U _ � M c\3658c^.Y3B�·<\a¸74543 ]�½G� c\365 F_h9\52p>3 ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=k7C5C9 ] ´ � J = ���:��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��y�L�t�n¬g�   �n¬)�¸�:K>��Òy���¦��¥ ��À��$¹�à����������C����¾:� Ô z}|>|\Ì Õ �

L Ë Ç N H <}�t9\54D � � � H � � � 9 ¿ 9;5 � d � P � � d�3B=X363B0 � T¸� O � � + � N . ] [X<>_10 � , � � T 9;7 F 9;=g9\5C9 F 9\=g9\= � d � �T .1D�3 E <\7C[g9 W�� u � N � � 9\=XD � 3B027 � d � � �¹T^] 9;_13k9\=XD@fi3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�.1=�9ZDX.1087C54. E U 7436D'jg_Y30 F 02743 W � ~ àM� �¦�2�\���6�`¾��ø¥ ��������� à������i¡^�É��� � �Â���É���¶��� �Iz Ô w 3 E � z}|>Ì>Ì Õ �

L Ë>Ë$N H U 9;=Xp � x � � 9;=XD � <>_¾an04<>= � M � + ] < W f¸3�7C.¾7C.Yc\3/D F =g9 W . ] Dg9;7:9Z5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=%9\_1p\<>54.¾7C[ W �J = Ð��t�������C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��Z�L�·�\��¬~Ð��g�É���Ú�i�\�ø¥ ���i�$¹zà����������C����¾:�����´���\� �����V§\¥��Ö�:����¥��V§ Ô Ñ . ½36=X=X9 � + U 087C52.h9 �Iz�|>|>Ç Õ � fXf � Ç^z}Åt½^Ç>Ç �^�

L Ë Î N J =�an<>023636´ � ¬V�ø� �h�,�}��§\¡V¥¦£V�6¯1¥������}�}�:�U¢\¯_¾:��� �L Ë Æ N J = Á U 365 F � ¬V�¦� �h�,�}�=¾�¥�¥��B¯_¾:�6¯1¡V�����:�6¯¦�4£\¡��i¥��������g¬V¥¾§�¬`¹ ¥¾§�¬V���6¯¾¬V�ø�M¹ �L Ë � N � 36<>=�p � �º½8T¸� � 9\=�D M W .Y3 ] .1=X02´V. � à � J =�c\36527436D�jg_Y3�fX9\5274.Y7C.Y<>=X.Y=Xp%0 ] [X3 W 3B0�.1= W U _¾7C.YfX_13

DX.102´�0 F 02743 W 0 � Ð����t�ö�X�2�\���6�`¾��¦¥ �����q���%�o�\�2�$¹Ç¹1��¹I�\�i£§�k¥1���¦��¥¦ª6¡V�É�4£ � �}���L���¶�©� �XÄ Ô w 3 E �z}|>|�Î Õ �Öz Ë Ä�½izÂÎ;Ç �

L Ë Ì N � U W f � � � u ��¸ ~ à � Ð�� ÒK�n�����C����¾:���»�\�g¡��$¹ � c\365402.1<>= Ä � z � z 3BD � u . ] 3 R =X.Yc\365204.Y7 F\�¸z�|>|>Ç �

z � Î

Page 192: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

L Ë | N � 9;7 ¿ � à � , � �tU 74_13B5 � d � � 9;=XD�d ] O 5C9;74[ � u � +Ó0 ] 9\_19 E _13 HKsms ?�043B52c>3B5 � 7C[X3 N�r T +fX54<;7C<\7 F fi3 � J = �t�C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��@�L���º¥��C����Ð��g�É���Ú�i�\�ø¥ ���i�$¹��)���C¹¾£¹�%¥¦£V�¡�{�6ª�à����������C����¾:�Ô O 36=X3�c;9 � T �y.¾7 ¿ 3B54_19\=XD � d)9 F»z�|>| Ë Õ �

L Î\Å N � = U 7C[ � , � à � �I¬g� ~ �Ú�y�L�*à������i¡V�É���k���C�4§\�2�\�Z�Z¥��V§¡�i�l¹�¨&� � ���Ú�¦¥��V§��\�i£ � �4�\��¾:¬V¥��V§ �+�DXD�.104<\= ½ � 3602_13 F �

L Î^z N � U W 9;5 � + � � u 9 E .Y=X<}cV. ] [ � d � � 9\=�D T .Y=X[g9 � u � � � +³f¸3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3A087 U D F <\a^p>3B=X36549\_�p>54.YD02745 UX] 7 U 52360�an<>5�543BfX_1. ] 9;7436D"Dg9;7C9 � J = ���C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��«�L����¨>��¬ÅÐ��g�É���Ú�i�\�ø¥ ���i�$¹»à����������C����¾:������k¥1���¦�Ú¥¦ª6¡^�É�4£ à������i¡^�¦¥��V§ � �}���L���¶� Ô z}|>|>Ç Õ �

L Î>Ä Nq_13Bp>.102_h9;74.Yc>3 J =�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=«<>=�74[X3 J =�7C3652=X3B7 � syH/M d�+ Ti� ¬V�¦� �h�,�}�i�n¬g�������6¯»¹1��¾6¯ §V�lÀ �L Î\Ç N P .1= � G � � 9\=XD G [X< U � T¸� ?¢9\5C9\_Y_13B_1. ¿ .1=Xp J È M .Y=�7C36=�04.Yc\3Z9\fXf�_1. ] 9;7C.Y<>=X0man<>5�9©�t<\54´�027C9;7C.Y<>=

] _ U 0274365 � 9 ] 9;043k027 U D F � à������i¡V�L��� ~ ��¾:¬V¥��É�¿¾��ø¡V�C������Ü®��°�� ��Î Ô ,/3 ]\� z�|>|>Ç Õ �IzÂÎ�½�Ä\Ä �L Î Ë$N P U � G � � r 9;_1_h9;= � � � ? � � 9\=XD r 52<\a�7 � � �Ð��� +�f�fX_ F .1=�p«.1=^an36543B= ] 3¶=X3B7É��<>54´�0/74< W U _¾7C.YfX_13

] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=³043�9;5 ] [X.Y=Xp � s 3 ] [ � u 36f � syu |>Æ ½ Ë Ä^� ,/36fX9\527 W 3B=�7«<\a r < W f U 74365 T^] .13B= ] 3 �R =X.¾c>3B5404.¾7 F <\aed)9\020C9 ] [ U 023B74740�9;7y+ W [X3B54087 �`z}|>|\Æ �

L Î>Î N P U � G � � d ] � .1=X_Y3 F\� � �yT¸� � 9;=XD r 9\[X<V<>= � ��� s [X3"[g9\52D��t9\543 È 04<\a�7É�t9\523 E 9;_h9\= ] .1=Xp9 ] 7�an<>5�.Y=�an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=�523B7454.13�c;9\_m<>=³0 FVW©W 3B7454. ] W U _Y74.1fX52< ] 360204<>520 � J = ���C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��)�L���¡^�C�:���\�º��­ Ô T < U 7C[X[X9 W f^7C<>= � R�� �`z}|>|>Ì Õ �

L Î\Æ N¶d)9 ] _136<VD � J � + � � d)9;527C.Y= � s � ? � � N <\54DX.Y= � ��� � 9\=XD�?º[�.1_1_Y.1fX0 � � � u �T 7C549;7C3Bp>.13B0�an<\5E U .Y_1DX.Y=Xp�D�.1027454. E U 7C3BD�.1=^an<>5 W 9;7C.Y<>=³543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_K0 F 02743 W 0 � Ð��������Ú���\�¦¥ ���·�t�C��¾:�:�:��¥��V§ ¶�"�\�i�}§V���«���g��°&¨ �gÆ Ô z}|>Ì � Õ ��Î^z>zC½�Î>Ä\Ì �

L Î � N¶d)9 W 9\_1.Y0 � ��� � T fX.Y5C9\´�.10 � M � � 9\=XD s 9 W fX9\´�9\0 � ?¢9\5C9;_1_13B_�7C3 ] [�=X.1l U 3B0ºan<\5®3BÀ ] .136=�7º023�9\5 ] [ ½.1=Xp©<}c>365/c\365 F _h9;54p>3q7C3�µV7 ] <>_1_Y3 ] 7C.1<\=X0 � J = �t�C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§����L�)�I¬g���º¥ �Ú��¬·�i�:K>�4Òµ���ø�Ú¥ ��À��$¹à����������C����¾:� Ã6�IÒ¢��à ÑR�^Ä Ô O 9\.Y74[X36520 E U 52p � d), ��z}|>|>Æ Õ � N 9�7C.1<\=g9\_ J =X0274.Y7 U 7C3)<;a T 7:9\= ½Dg9\52DX0K9\=XD s 3 ] [X=X<>_Y<>p F T f¸3 ] .h9;_S? U E _1. ] 9;74.1<>= �

L Î\Ì N¶d)9\587C.1= � s � ? � � d)9 ] _13B<^D � J � + � � u U 040236_Y_ � � � J � � P 3602043 � � � � 9;=XD w <>087C365 � ��� + ] 9\023027 U D F <\a ] 9 ] [X.1=Xpy087C5C9�7C36p\.1360Ian<\5S9yD�.1027454. E U 7C3BD/a U _1_;7C3�µV7S523B7C52.13�c\9;_>0 F 02743 W � Ð��������Ú���\�¦¥ ������:��¾:�:�:��¥��V§ ¶ �"�\�i�}§V���«���g��°»� ��Ä Ô z}|>|>Å Õ ��Ä>Ä � ½�Ä Ë �^�

L Î\| N¶d)9\587C.1= � s � ? � � 9;=XD u U 02043B_1_ � � � J � ,�9;7C9 ] 9 ] [�.1=XpZ087C5C9�7C36p\.1360oan<\5oDX.1087C52. E U 7436D'a U _Y_¸743�µV7543�7C54.Y3Bc;9\_I0 F 027C3 W 0 � Ð��������Ú���\�ø¥ ��� � �Â���É���¶�©��� �`z Ô z}|\|�z Õ �Öz�½iz>z �

L Æ>Å N M 5C9 ] _13 r < W fg9\= F �tT 7C5C9�7C36p\.1360y9;=XD�743 ] [X=�.1l U 360Kan<>5 U 02.1=Xp M 5C9 ] _13 � 5236fX_Y. ] 9;7C.Y<>= �¬V�ø� �h�,�}�iÜAÜAܹ¯¦���2�`¾�¹1�6¯_¾:�������i�C�6£\¡ ¾����>�g�}���CÀ\���:�>�i�C�É��¹ ¥�¾4�\�¦¥ ���¼�g¬V�ø�M¹ �=¾:�l¹Ç¹¾�\�É���2�$¹¾¯¾¬��¦�M¹ Ô d�9 Fz}|>|�Î Õ �

L Æ�z N u . E 3B.152< ½ N 3B7C< � ��� + � � 9\=�D � 9\5 E <>0C9 � u � + � Á U 365 F f¸3B52an<>5 W 9\= ] 3�an<>5�7C.1p\[�74_ F ] < U fX_13BDDX.1087C52. E U 7436D�DX.1p\.Y7:9;_�_1. E 5C9;54.13B0 � J = ���C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§����L� ~ àM�½�k¥¾§\¥�� �$¹X ®¥¦ª6�2�\�Ú¥ �:� à����������C����¾:�Ô ?A.Y727C0 E U 54p\[ � ?¸+ �`z}|>|>Ì Õ �

z � Æ

Page 193: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

L Æ�Ä N u < E 3B527C02<>= � Ti� à � s [X3kfX52< E 9 E .Y_1.¾7 F 549\=X´�.1=�pZfX54.Y= ] .YfX_13/.Y=%.15 � ¤g��¡^�Ú�i�$¹¢�L���¶��¾�¡^�«���g� �$Ñ�ø¥ ���´¨}¨ � Ë Ô z}| �#� Õ �gÄ;| Ë ½^Ç>Å Ë �

L Æ>Ç N T 9\_¾7C<>= � O � ~ ¡V�L�����\�¦¥�¾��¸�:K>�����C��¾:�:�:��¥��V§}�@�I¬g���X�2�\���n�����Ú���\�ø¥ ����� ~ �i�$¹ �}��¥1�:�K�\�i£�Òy��Ñ�ø�Ú¥ ��À��$¹¢�L�[ÐÚ�������Ú���\�ø¥ ���{ª6� à������i¡V�L��� � +�DXDX.102<>= ½ � 3B04_13 F>�`z}|\Ì>| �

L Æ Ë$N T 9\_¾7C<>= � O � � 9\=�DQd ] O .Y_1_ � d � ÐÚ�g�ø�C�6£\¡�¾��ø¥ ���-�É�®���6£V���Ú��Ð��������Ú���\�ø¥ ����Òy���¦��¥ ��À��$¹ �d ] O 5C9�� ½ H .1_Y_ �iz}|>Ì>Ç �

L Æ�Î N T [g9\[ � + � � 9;=XD�d)9\5 ¿6U _Y_ � � � s 549\DX3 ½ <\ظ0 E 3�7É�t3B36=�543BfX_1. ] 9;74.1<>=Ù9\=XD�9}c;9\.Y_h9 E .1_1.¾7 F .Y=DX.1087C52. E U 7436D@Dg9;7C9 E 9\02360 � s 3 ] [ � u 36f � syu Ì>| ½ z}Å>Æ>Î^� r <>52=X36_Y_ R =�.Yc>3B5402.Y7 F>� ,/3 ]\� z}|>Ì\| �

L Æ>Æ N T 7:9;=�jg_1_ � r � ?®9;527C.¾7C.Y<>=X36D�fi<>087C.1=�p{jg_13B0 � +×fg9\549\_1_Y36_¹.1=�c>3B527C3BD³jX_13%02745 UX] 7 U 523�an<\5�.1= ½an<>5 W 9;74.1<>=�543�7C52.13Bc;9\_ � J = ���C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��k�L����¬g�«�I¬V¥��Ú�É�:���g�n¬ ~ �g�g¡��$¹�ÐÚ�g�L���Ú�i�\�¦¥ ���i�$¹ ~ àM�� Ð � Ð�Ò¼à����������:����¾:�t����ÒK�:�}�4�\��¾:¬¶�\�i£¢����À\��¹1�:�i�«���g��¥��pÐÚ�����������\�¦¥ ���nÒy���¦��¥ ��À��$¹ Ô � 5 U 0 ½043B_10 � � à PbO�JLR d �`z�|>|>Å Õ � fXf � Ë z}Çt½ Ë Ä;Ì �

L Æ � N T 7:9;=�jg_1_ � r � � 9\=XD � 9\[X_Y3 � ��� ?®9\549\_1_Y36_ban54363 ½ 743�µV7k04369\5 ] [�<>={7C[X3 ] <>=X=X3 ] 74.1<>= W 9 ] [X.1=�30 F 02743 W � à����Z�Z¡^�g¥�¾4�\�¦¥ �����¶�L�k��¬g� ~ àM�¾°�� �`zÂÄ Ô ,/3 ];� z}|>Ì>Æ Õ �Öz}Ä>Ä\|t½iz}Ä\Ç>| �

L Æ>Ì N T 7:9;=�jg_1_ � r � � s [g9 U � u � � 9\=�D � 9\_Y7 ¿ � , � + fX9\5C9\_Y_13B_I.1=XD�3�µ^36D»9;_1p><>52.Y74[ W an<>5K.1=^an<>5 W 9 ½7C.Y<>=)523B7C52.13�c\9;_ � J = ���C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��©�L����¬g�{�SÜt��¹ �Ú��¬ ~ �g�g¡��$¹IÐÚ�g�L���Ú�i�\�¦¥ ���i�$¹ ~ àM� � Ð � пÒà����������C����¾:�/���oÒy�:�}�4�\�¿¾:¬«�\�i£©����À\��¹1�:�i�«���g�S¥��mÐÚ�����������\�¦¥ ����Òy���¦��¥ ��À��$¹ Ô r 9 W�E 54.1D�p>3 �d�+ � � U =X3 z}|>Ì>| Õ � fXf � Ì\Ìt½^| �^�

L Æ>| N s [X< W 9\0 � u � H � + W 9}¼2<>54.¾7 F ] <>=X043B=X0 U 0e9\fXf�54<�9 ] [k7C< ] <>= ]6U 54543B= ] F ] <>=�7C54<\_\an<>5 W U _¾7C.YfX_13] <>f F Dg9�7:9 E 9;043 � ~ àM� ���2�\���6�`¾��ø¥ ���������K���\�Ò��ª:���}� � �}���É���¶�¢« �iÄ Ô � U =X3 z}| � | Õ �Iz}Ì>Å�½Ä\Å>| �

L � Å N s < W 9\02. ] � + � �k¥1���¦��¥¦ª6¡V�É�4£�­o¡����Ú¥ �:�'�\�i£^Ð���¾��C���«���g� �$¹(ág��£��\�É�:�Ð��¶ÐÚ�����������\�¦¥ ���1Òy��Ñ�ø�Ú¥ ��À��$¹ � �}���É���¶� � ?º[X,-7C[�3604.Y0 � ?A54.Y= ] 3�7C<>= R =�.Yc>3B5402.Y7 F>� � U =X3 z}|>| Ë �

L � z N s < W 9\02. ] � + � � 9\=XD O 9\5 ] .h9 ½ d�<>_Y.1=g9 � H � ?¢3658an<>5 W 9\= ] 3¶<\aº.Y=�c>36587C3BD».1=XDX. ] 3B0�.Y={04[g9;5436D ½=X<\74[X.1=XpqDX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D�7C3Úµ^7tDX< ]6U W 36=�7�.1=�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\=Z543B7454.Y3Bc;9\_�0 F 02743 W 0 � J = ���C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§���L����¬g� � �¿¾:���i£�Ð��g�É�����i�\�¦¥ ���i�$¹æà����������C����¾:�¶���)�o�\�2�$¹Ç¹1��¹b�\�i£p�k¥1���¦�Ú¥¦ª6¡^�É�4£MÐ��������Ú���\�¦¥ ���� �Â���É���¶� Ô T 9\=),/.Y36p>< � r + �`z�|>|>Ç Õ �

L � Ä N s U 527C_Y3 � H � u � ÐÚ�������C����¾:�¤�q���øÜt���P¢}�Ö�����¤����¾�¡V�«���g��ÒK���¦�Ú¥ ��À��$¹ � ?A[g,�7C[�3604.Y0 � R =X.Yc\365204.Y7 F<\aed)9\04049 ] [ U 043�74740 � w 3 E � z}|>|^z �

L � Ç N Ñ 9\= u . ¼20 E 3652p>36= � r � � � Ð��������Ú���\�¦¥ ���ÅÒy���ø�Ú¥ ��À��$¹ �º�tU 747C3B52��<>5274[X0 �Sz}| � | �L � Ë$N Ñ <^<\54[X3B360 � à � d � � O U f�7C9 � N � � � � 9\=XD � <>[�=X04<>= ½ P 9\.152D � ��� P 369\54=X.Y=Xp ] <\_1_13 ] 74.1<>=qa U 04.Y<>=

02745C9;7436p>.Y360 � J = �t�C��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��©�L���n¬g����¥¾§�¬V�É�:���g�n¬ ~ �g�g¡��$¹XÐ��g�É���Ú�i�\�ø¥ ���i�$¹ ~ àM� � Ð � пÒà����������C����¾:�t���Òy�:�}�4�\�¿¾:¬q�\�i£¢����À\��¹1�:�i�«���g��¥��pÐ��������Ú���\�ø¥ ���pÒK���¦�Ú¥ ��À��$¹ Ô T 3�9�747C_Y3 � � + �z}|>|�Î Õ �

L � Î N � <\_Yan5C9 W�� , � +�fXfX_ F .1=Xp�.1=^an<>5 W 3B7454. ]�] [g9\5C9 ] 7C3B54.Y027C. ] 0y<\a¢Dg9;7C9 E 9\02360y7C< JLu 0 F 02743 W jg_Y3DX3602.1p>= � fg9;527 J � J =�an<>5 W 3�7C54. ] W <VDX36_Y0 � Ð��������Ú���\�¦¥ ���'�t�C��¾:�:�:��¥��V§ ¶ �»�\�i�}§V���«���g�k°&­ �izÔ z}|\|�Ä Õ �¸zÂÄ^z�½�z}Ç>Ç �

z �#�

Page 194: 1020436587:9;74.1=@?A5236043B= 7C36Dciir.cs.umass.edu/pubfiles/ir-168.pdf · 2000-10-13 · -² ( &v ³ w.152027 9\= Dan

L � Æ N � <\_Yan04<\= � M � � 9\=XD � 9¼2<VDX.19 � T¸� +�="9\_1p><\54.Y74[ W an<>5/D F =X9 W . ] 5236fX_Y. ] 9�7C.1<\=)<\a¹Dg9;7C9 � J =���:��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§��m�L�¿�}�\��¬ ~ àM� � �;���g�}��¥�¡V�ö�����n¬g�¹���Ú¥���¾�¥Ð��¹1�:�m�L���q�\�Ò��ª:���}� � �}���L���¶� Ô T 9\=,/.13Bp>< � r 9;_1.Yan<\54=X.19 � � U =X3 z}|>|�Ä Õ �

L �#� NkÍ U � � � � 9;=XD r 9\_Y_h9\= � � � ? � ÃAظ3 ] 7C.¾c>3¶523B7454.13�c;9\_I�y.Y74[)DX.Y027C52. E U 7C36D ] <>_Y_13 ] 7C.Y<>=X0 � J = ���C�lѾ:�:�4£\¥��V§��¶�L� � Ð � пÒ���­ Ô d�3B_ E < U 52=X3 � + U 02745C9\_Y.h9 � + U p � z}|>|>Ì Õ �

L � Ì N x U � ? �`T¸� � 9\=�D d)9 ] N 9\.15 � à � + � ?¢3B52an<>5 W 9;= ] 3�087 U D F <\a�9 ] <>_1_19 E <\527C.¾c>3 W 3B7C[�<^D)an<\5[X.1369\5 ] [�. ] 9;_ ] 9 ] [X.1=�p%.1={fX52<�µ F 043B52c>3B540 � J = ���:��¾:�:�4£\¥��V§����L�   �n¬�Ð��g�É�����i�\�¦¥ ���i�$¹��{���C¹¾£�@¥¦£V�±�{�6ªMà����������C����¾:� Ô � 54.Y0 E 9\=�3 � + U 02745C9\_Y.h9 � +�fX5 � z}|>|>Ì Õ �

L � | N G < E 36_ � � � � d�<\ØÖ9;7 � + � � 9;=XD u 9 W 9 W <>[g9\=g9;5C9\< � � � J =�c>3B527436D«jg_Y360ec\360 U 0t04.Yp>=X.¾7 U 523ojg_13B0an<>5o7C3ÚµV7�.Y=XDX3�µ^.Y=Xp � s 3 ] [ � u 36f � rtJÉsyuyJ È syu ½ |�Î ½ Î^� r <>_Y_h9 E <>5C9�7C.Yc\3 J =�an<>5 W 9�7C.1<\= s 3 ] [ ½=X<>_Y<>p F u 3B04369\5 ] [ J =X0274.Y7 U 7C3 � ,/3Bfg9\5 W 3B=�7�<\a r < W f U 7C3B5 T^] .Y36= ] 3 � u < F 9\_yd�3B_ E < U 54=�3J =X0274.Y7 U 7C3�<\a s 3 ] [X=X<\_1<>p F\� + U 087C5C9;_1.h9 � � U _ F{z}|>|>Î �

z � Ì