-t-"? Lt.:;lp'1lrl:::;f 1§ Lt.:n'li':i!n{ib-o 0) ·c .lii;¥11!1::.:r. 1J-1- :!tffi t,

:x:lt!!O)Jf{Jrmlit.:i:>t 0) r.o 1::-¥"",, "f'n{ib-o t 1,,, "? J: "? ?J: rp9@:0) rz. -c1i

@l,f;t;:n{trfn' L 1,,,t}Gl "? O)"t''To

ii"?V-C"'.J, .:.nti-t-n,::~;b,00)"(:'Tn\ $1:;liUJJM-t-.1!::AA

Ii :::r • :::.71JX A O);ji!R;:11!!1¥J ?J:~Jf(O) 1iltlll:O)/l.1Hlif ii ?J: v'~lF't' ib-o

t § v'1i~ Li Lt.:n{, .:.n1i©z:;is:O)..tf:iL ~ i/2&?-oO)n', f-O)~J&

~r/2&?-o t-tntf, fl.liibx. tr/2&? -o t §"v' i Lt.:n{, .:.O)r•9MO) rz. -C 1i Ii {-"? .liiif.'1i 't' Ii ?J: v ' o

fl.lHJJM-t-.1 l:: ;z_J.O){to"ii 1::/lyl;!lvJT-oo Ln' L, f-nli!tv,.:. t

't'ib-oo iiLf-"?T-oc, ~!lvJ,t$:~O)wJl::.&1t,~f'l:r*, ~1,,,~Jr*

Cv'"?rP9JIJ!n{l±lt<-o:btt't'To iiL -t-n~~)&O)/£*~' .&_1,,,~

Wit.! Ul.n{~!lvJT -ot Lt.:G, f-0).J:"? ?J:T1 ;z_ 1' Hl L 1±1 Lt.:fl.O)

1{,17 :~1'-:1 r.,;., F~SJE L?J:ttntf1,,,tt?J:v'o f-tlli, W;:;is:0)-'E:;t:::.

XAfi~'t'Tn'G, .:.nn"/ft'£.1¥J 1::{J'.(~ L t\t'-o t-tntf, {-0)/ft

'il:!.1¥J ?J: @I 5.t ~ slR& L ?J: 1tntf1,,, It ?J: v' o -t-n 't':i1!sffe Lt.: @I 5.l'I:: ?J:

G?J:<-Cliv'IT?J:v'o i"-ot, .:.niiit.:, lft'it!.1¥J?J:Jt/DR~slR&i"-o

tv, "? t'il:'it!. 1:: ?J: 0-C Li"? o @15.l'li t'' Iv Uv .&. < ?J: 0-C 1,,, < 0) t..:, jfy

$-~ Bt~TtlLf .&. 1,,, Ard! 1:: ?J: -o 0) t..:, Jj.f.: v' ?J:t/ltml:: ?J: 0-C Li"?

:b lt't'T o fl.I± f-0).:. t @I ,f;t;: MF'ffi' 1:::;k ~ ?J: r09J;!!t..: t.'~, 1,,, iT o

t..:n'G, .:i:1," F~lvn" §":bnt.:, ft4 n"-t-n~~J&O)/£*Ua

9?J:#G,L~L,?J:H~0@15.l'O)*~ib-o.ai¥J?J:ii0)0)~~~

tl'i:> ?J: n'>G .& v ,~wr t L tr/2&?-C Li"?, f-"? 1,,, "? @I 5.t ii 1,,, -o 0) t..: t

v'"?.:.t ~, 7:J7 Cv'"?O)lifiiJ/j.O)~~'t'ib-ot v'"? J: "? 1::H0 L'(>

1,,,fLf.:n\ fnfn'f-"?v'"?fffiJj.O)~~tL-Ci/2&?tv'< o 7"1;-1/'-

;.,O)*'t'ii'fiJj.~ 1~ t:?J:n'>G @I c'.~ffiml:: L n,<tv,-?.:.t, *~-f-

y';Af t § Hf*~-f-y';Af ?J:t.:. 0 ,::~m~?J::@":i't. ~tf 0-cflt' i-ot 1,,, "?.:.

t' i:>J:0C V 1' 1Jo/;70)rpiM,::?J:0-C Liv' iTn', f-nn-©z:;i(:O).:r.

9-1'•ffit0)-¥"",,7'~~"?~x.-o~,:::r • :::.79;;t;i.~~"?~x.-o

n' t 1,,, "? ~O) rpt\!!O) rz. -c1i @I ,tt;: ~ .lii;¥i!i{I:: L -c Ii 1,,,1t ?J: 1,,, t v' "?.:. t

c.ffi:?J:-o:blt't'To *~-f.y';Af ?J:.:_ cl± *~-f-y';Af 1::~ x. 7:>t §" x.li,

t..:G L?J:Htv,--Jjl::?J:0-CL iPiTn' (~)' rp,M~T-:>~9~-1±"-C

Li"? O)lin' x.0-C~l!fri?J:O)'t'To

I l o Session If

A;'.::,--;,!-: ifJ'liltJJO)'l'tra,--c'li, 3-D:,J{O)~if.fc-fO)fl;ljf:l!'.i){P/i

lliHs 7'j: 0)--c'li tj: v' n' t 1.i, -3 ,12. 1: ".) v•-C--c'Til{, ji!jj;frO) IMJ~O)~~

tj:=-;,.7:.,;,.~ 1Pli.1&J tv•-3 ~ ~--c''tUJI.T 7.JO)i){,,,q rn'c"-37'.Pli

fll:IH:in' IJ 1-lt lvo -f O) J:-31: $ L...tlf 7., O)t,, fl0)1JJ!O)i=j:q: 1/

.:,:.-AX · 7 ') 7,t- V ~ .;< 7 ')- · JH- ;;:: · 7'7:;1 r 7'j: c"i){t'E:~ L -C

1,,,7., ]1gi.'f:UFJ!9itO)r±4;; cO)til[N;:ll!!E8!m~l=.tHt 7., 1:::i:.,5'7 r'.f­

✓ J O)il\'t~i/{H, 7.J n'~,t"T o t11H,0)5J'i'Jrl: J: tllf, MN;:11!!0).l!il:9:

t v• -3 ::JC/jjRO) i:p ·c v•il•l:~Wf~Xft:ic:ii!til{!Jo/J~~l/£0) v rf .:i:. Jv--c'

~nrtl E8 tj:;x:im ~ L n, t:. ii• t v• -3.::. ci){:/:>i)• 7., n' ~,t''To ".) 1 IJ,

-f O)iTitillJ lij/g it i), G Jftit"-c v• -3- nf8 7'j: ti 0)--c'li tj: ii· 0 t:. 0)--c'

To J:0-C, 1Plil&J tv,-3 - nl:J:7.Jxrit'., ib7.JHi.:E.1ft~~Htf(l,l]

T7.JJ:-3tj: ~ ~--c'ti0-C,Jftj1gO)~ii!t--c'~~T7.J~4tj:~~~~~

7.,.::. c Ii'{'~ 7'j: v' 0) '{'' Ii 7'j: v' i), t ,[I,"? :b It '{''To

=".)§O)R00~,~-r~Y✓KH~7.J71/7~ffi0)::Jv7~3 ✓

~~1FI: ".)1,,,-c-r:-Ti/{, 7l~tj:i){G~t£0)~1F:!xiR. ~+MBW L

-ci,,,tj:1.i,0)--c' H~~ T 7.,.::.t i){--c'~ 1-lt lvo

i\HH:111= B O)Mi[ff/jl: ti IMl-ffiT 7.,0)'t'Til{, 71/7 t v•-3il\'t~O)JJ/l

~t-f nl:MT 7., :::i .;<:., r bl~---zt:.v'c ,1£1, v'iT o .::..::.-r:·raiJ,\fH:tj:0

-C v' 7., .::.Ui, 71/7 t.:ltO) rai~-r:-1i 7'j: v•O)'t', t,0 c - ~E8 7'j: roi~

Session II I JJ

c L -C1t x. -C li-t-: 1,,,t ,[!, 1,,, i To -:::i i 9, ip-:::i-C;ti"/L~:lt!!.:£~0)/!f9:0)

i:p-z"ff/f~~ht-: 1)v-1/3T)v,j: (ffl!Mli¥:J) 71T✓T1T11±, 4-Jmffi

L, fJr L 1,,, rioti 1:£-::11,,,-c Nffl~ ~ h J., ~f.¥1: ii; J., iPG-z"To

,f.:. T, 11UJIJO)r",J[H±5JU t L -c 'b, .:. .:. Tfrbh n,J.>1/ ;.,,t;:}')

1,,t loJ l.'.,J: "J 7j: flg'.@'.O)'bO)i3-• -;;1{-z'•'1f1,,,, 3-0-;;1{0)7,{7;.,

-r1-r11:-:::i1,,,-c~~Lt-:t L-C'h-f.:. Tl& 9 ... tHGhJ.i ro,/H!,¢.U±.:.

.:. T~ Li?ibh-C 1,,,7., 2: t t-f "? i!tbG ,j: 1,,,0)-z"I± ,j:1,,,tpc,[I, 1,,, i

To :IJ/.tt, 3-0-;;J{"('fj:, 13-0-;;J{cl±fliJiP? J Cv'"J ~[n'/ji){ B 4

frbh-Cv'iT o 7:J7il'NJE'.~ ~hJ.it lol~I:, 3-o-;;1{1hl"fJE'.

~~n-:::i-:::i,l;J.,0)-z"To Lil'L, 3- • -;;1{0)71f';.,-r1-r1l:fmT

J., ~~!±, ~1:©zrl1ill!i?it!!::kev'"J fil!l;l!fiil, El i'ltrl::i§ 9, -1;,J~,j:r",J.l!

c,j:0-Cv' iT o l-1v::zil,3-o -;;1{0)- J'.I 1:,j:J.ic "'"? .:.u±c'-J v'

"J J.l.P*,j: O)i),? ,f :tl.1±3-o-;;1{0)71 j';., T1T11: c'O) J: "J ,j:f;

~ i~x_J.,O)i)>? 71T✓T1T11±1l\l: ') v-1/3Tiv't"il;9, ffll[

1:m~,j:IMJ• H~~T J., i:pTt{fbhJ.i'bO)-z"To 3- • -;;1{0)71

T✓T1T10)/!f9:1± , 7:J7 cO)IM!tit..:ltT%nlG ~n,J.,0)-z"f±,j:<,

779nlj:~-f-O)~O):lt!!•tO)~•~'h~vJ.i.:.tT~

-=E-1\-zF~ld±, 3 - • -;;1{i),1,,,iJ,1:L-c, 7:J70)lli§i~JE'.L,

it-:7:J7 c:0)-:::i,j:i),9 Hfr>i:@L-C@ c.%nlZ i L -c M-:il'Cv'"JE~

i~hiL~ o ~ti779ncO)IM!.~'bloJ80)fta#;l;J.,O)-z"ti

,j: 1,,,iJ, t ,[I, 1,,, iT o l 9tit;\e 1:~1v1:frb ht-:1~~ ,j:~~O) i:p 1:-¥

') 1/7-XBJli),x. :J--;f 1-)(lljj 1: Ef3*T J.,-~ i~-C~JE'. LJ: "J t v'"J

1b O)i/'il; 9 i Lt-:o x. :J--;t H: Ef3 *T J.i.:. ti M(d6 J.i tv, "J .:.t 1±, B

Ail'@ 5tt-:i::,O))(lljj O)im(::IR i $».AO) 7 7 1J n )(lljj 1:JRd6 ,j: Ith Ii

,j:G,j:< ,j: J.it ~~1±1t x.Ght-:il'G-z''T o 'b"J Y L- ~1¥:J,j:~i L

iTc, ~.R\:lt!!.:E~il"J v-1/ 3 T Jv,j: 71 T✓T1 T1 N'lt~ L -C ~

t-:tTJ.i,j:Gli, -f2:TftGht-:IM!ffi1±4-- .!=l.Wml~h, it-:, N/Jt ft 9 il! ~h n,J.i/1li:illerl:ft1.t fj:1,,,7.,tv,-J.:.t -z"To 7:J71:IMIT J.,

r",;l!fii, .:.nG - ~1¥:J,j:F"tJM,G-l;,J 9~ L-C1t x. -C li--C 'bi!; i 9~~

P]~ (aJt ) : ;!;9il'c-J2:·~--1,,,iLt-:o 2:0)-t-;;1/3 ✓ II IH!!UF~

hJ.i7:J7 / ~tF~h,j:1,,q:}7 Jc:NrJvil'f.J'ltGhH'iT o L

138 Session II

1!' L t:tiJ,t::,, -f 0/:: -r1 7'-JJ-:11/ 3::., t L -r E'-C, i:iJ:. '? !::' 1 ~ lviJ,J'{;fl,

~.:r.::.,j--v"'(:j--?f:j:!lHt't-= ,~::1::., F· -tf'. ;){-:$"- (mJi!t~;t

-C) J !:: v' '? rp,v'1J'v'0 v' 0-/;t%"'C'::O)-t-:; 1/ 3::., 0), iii, 7.>H±At B 1J'

G 0)-t -:11/ 3::., f: {, im!l-t 7.i 7- x f: t:t 0-r E' f_:O) •f:'fi t:t v' iJ, !:: v' 1

3<CiJ'L -Cv'i"9 o ::0) r mw t ~ .z -r J 1::v, 1:: 1:: 0) i:r f:,±, 3f J.. -/,0) 7- T1 Ar

f: ".:)v'-C~F'ffif: ~6 Ft:t%"'C', i,~ L v,td-:v' t-: J:: '? f:~m89 t:t

OO~Hi;t1.,::/::, ifi,J.,H±li((4-/;tV-y::.,1vt~.zJ.,::!::, ifi,J.,Hi

1!((4 -/;t~*rO)f!llj)r t~.z J.,:: !:: , ifi>J.,Hiffit/&O):¥'.Yf1't~.zJ.,

::/::, -f-1 Lt-:it 4 O)~JJ'i!-t~.zJ.,i::v''? ~li,H,ifi,J.,:blt"'C'To -f-L

-r ~.:r.::.,-t--vifi>J.iH± r 1J .:r. ::.,-f-- vi::v' 10),±, 4-B O).t,~-r-g

Hf, $-::tft:±.~89-t:t%"'C'mWH~.&.z7.ii::v''? ~itt, ~~89 f:~

-t J:: 1 t:t~"'C' ifi> 1., 1::v, 1:: !::t±' 0 t-: !:: -~-v' i T o

/::::0iJ\ ~t::,iJ,f:t:t0 -rM-:::b±, i~f:-f"O)mJJ'i!-t~.zJ.i!::

v' '?:: !:: iJ', ~;(£ O)f9U ;t tl: :~,.o-/, 1J--E-:/ 3::., !:: iJ,, .:t 0) i:p "'C'O) >¥

1J T1-JJJv · .:r.:::r _; ~ -!:: 1!', m:t.J~jf:,js;O)vff.;h,-/;t/::' Uli1:f".:)v'-Cv'7.i

:blt"'C'To ::nt~f4i(lgf:~-t J::'?-/;t%"'C'Jh:$'i;f:mwt~;t n, 7.i 0) ,±x ;z,-!:: g 1 iJ,, $-00ffi89 t:tiil:~'et,$:"'C' ifiJ IJ, .f-L -r -f-1 Lt-:

:ilO-/{ Jv-/;tfH:ll.l:/-0) i:J=l"'C'f!i:4 iJ,mw t ~;{_ ~ -tt G ;h, -C v'J., !:: v' '?

::/::{,ifi>J.,:bft"'C'To ~~!::L-C, -t::·v,7'~-F"'C'~.z~-ttGn-r

\,\ J., 0

-f-1-tJ.i!::, -r-,±, **O)JC/l!iH=~nfiv'v'0)1J'c g 1!::, LiJ'

L .f-0),$:*0)JC)!IR, f9JJHf7V7i::v''?::i::t~.z-rl:l--r{,, .:th

,H ~f:ffl~ ~tlt-:'iJO)/:: L -CL1J'ff1t L-/;tv'o t±'iJ,t::,, ::0)7V7

Cv''?:: !::, $- ::tftb, 1 ::!:: t, v' i 11\ f:ffl~ ~ nt~Ht 7.i 'ii 0) !:: L -r,

flt 4 ,± .:t n tWc~ L n, 7., Cv' '? t}Wi',O) i:p "(\ tU-: i:i ,±~*r Cv' '?

i!llJ&, ifi,J.,H±~.:r.::.,j--v/::v''?illlJ&, ifi,J.,H±li((4-/;tXftt.16("

J., f!llj)r t, -f-0) p;j1l{ljiJ,t::, ~ x_ -C v'1J'-/;t1Jtltf-/;t G-/;t v' o 1!((4 t:tm,\'i:

Ht~~-ttt:tiJ,t::,, t±~O)i:J=l"'C', !f.BeO)i:J=l"'C', ~Tti89, lff¥~89-t:t~

iR. 'ii -t!i.16 t-: :::r::., T 7 7' r 0) i:p "'(:, 7 ') T1-JJJvf:, 11-J;(f(lg f: 71/ 7 Cv'

1*~/:: .f-0)~~ t rp,v'~T!:: v''?ft~ Ht IJ ~ L n,(/:: v''? ::/::

iJ\ ~1=1itf:.!l!~"'C',±-/;tv'1J'c a.16-r ~ti Lt-:o

::O)-t-;;:/3::.,"'C'l±\t-:J::1-t:tiUiili, ifi>J.,HilltcBiJ,t::,O)Mt~,±, -9"

Session II 139

1fl(J)7'1 .7-;/J::,,:,-3 ;.,(J)i:p't'\ ~G!:i*A".J-c1,, ~ t..: 1,,t -~-"' iT o 3 A

(J)$1l~*(l):1J 4 i:~7CJJ:1EI-¥ :a-.t,lj(1,,3& Li To [18-¥ J

140 Session II

7- r'f.,f-;; f . .I. l} :;;j--;; J­~ ;X,UiffiffiJ.:

171/7 c:lifPJipJ t v'-J-:r-?O) ::,,:,, #1/?AI.::, ¥f U'.:B1£ ~ 1,,t.:J!

~, ib fJn' t "? .::·i:'·i,, 1-t o .:: tLIH, -l:,0 !v/ffHtlf'oJfi~lj: rp91,,1:1i;b IJ 1

T:O', 31Flitr, .::O)lff]trp91,,1.::fldi, 1-fhli7'7:,:7*-Jv'"c"·;b7.,J, t v'"J J: 11.::~ ;ULt..: o -f hliibG~7.,>/:,0)~ 5 I ~-:::>ltlJ&~JlT 7.,1!{:liL 11:,

L <Ii, -f hli::ll71/7i!!:W-n', c:'O)J: "? 7j: 7 7 ✓7' 1/-'"c"·>l:,~~T 7->.::

c:O)-C~7.>ff0 m7j:A:79-:,,0)J:17j:'i:,O)o .::ntiIR7j:M~~Gtiff

ifil1,,t.:to0 L'l'7->n''bLh 1-tt !vL, ii=' L< f-11:L.d o Ln' L, fM..:

-1:, h--f n-f'n,~. "? t .::01.:: ~ L --C ~lj: 0 t..:71T7 ~tb--c1,,7., :0' ~·9,

.::O)rp91,,0) r l'.:o/:7 EI.PHili'ittn,GIH.'Eifilv'0)1:T o -:::>1 IJ, J;l;Jffiln'G

~7., 71/7, 71/70)fi~l.::c:0--C0)71/7(i, j'j.fi[IO)>/:,O)l.::c:0--CO)-fh,

tliiffl t1.::1i7j:f)x_7j:1,,0)-CT0 ~r,ijc::tJ;;pJr;o,~:bhl!, >/:,O)O)~x.n

MN l: L 1T o -fL--C.:: "? Lt..:~1l:Hft..:J::I.::, i:'Glj:7.,1fi:~7j:rp91,,;o,1t

:O'if>fJ 1-t - 1v'0t..:1,,;,.",t;- ✓ ~(i1,,--c1,,7.>0)(i%~liITftlj:O);o,? J ' >

i:' --c, l!!li-'Hfil~H.:: J: 7-> i!f:})'ftf!jfJWJl ~ oJfi~I.:: Lt..:>CfffJ1l:O)!luJ1J t L --CO) :X

;f:,,O)f)¾:\tf!Hi, W:9:1¥Jl.::.&<~Gn--cv,1-to 19ilt~~illlt--C, ifH~:.J

$0)8.-C;b7.,:;J;;f:,,t,-fh-O)~hiliL~~~t-~ti,.&0)1JO)

J: -J}j:ff::{f-CLt..:o 1J- · .x.:,,71-1v f-t-'(o-;, 1v-:r1 .::.t v'0t..:'.717 Jv[iJt

Ii, 14" 1JA\'if001.::~~l.::.:tolt 7.,JmflJ~>l:,t..:G Lt..:n''bLh-1-tt /vn', -'jZ

f• ~ ~~ 7j: 11:,0)c Lt..:O)likt;·:,,t!_ 0f..:O)-CT0 :P--1!-'(oft 7j: fJ O)f!G Llj:

i:'C:O)~l,\l.::.:t::,1,,--c, it..:, -f0)~1Jh".l~•ft.1¥JI.:: M..:G Lt..:;fjg~i:'c:O)

~H.::.:t::;1,,--c, ;J;;f :,,~ ~ 1.::1-t1t 7., Wi'lillit±~l¥JtL~O)£,fi:J.JlUllJ tlj:

fJ. i:' G 1.:: li-f 0):/'L~n ' J: 7., t.:: 0 O)~A'Jkfl,IJ~O):jjm t 11:, 7j:0t..: 0) 1:T o L

l!Ll!:X;f:,,~ ~1.::-:::>lt 7->t v'"J 'Jf/'tl'J:li1lHJ:i-i¥JJ!9fflJI.:: J:0--CIUIJ 'i='ht..:

>/:,0)1:To ~<0)77 1)-JJ, 71/7, -fL--C7-:r:,,-7pJ-JJO)tfiOO~IHd±

1.:: .::O)W/•tl'tn'i'fiMil.:: 11:, .J:!ll.-'(o fJ ffl.-lt G ht..: t ~ t --ci,,7., 1.:::iii,1,,7j: 1,,1: L

.dn', ib7.>t~1i.::O)W/•l1Ui, .::.:: 8,fi:O)~~O)J:"?1.::, i!i:f-1'.:fl:~.:BL

TT~,~*~M--C*fJ~ffeO)jg~ffe>l:,1t-t7.>004Kti,ffl•i¥JK~

it J...h-Gh 1 Lt..:o IMJUfil!I.:: L --c ¥1-J-~:,:77j: (1 i:' L <JEO) El El3 lj:!luJ ~~

142 Session Ill

T -r'f ,(·Jl-0 · .I.. 1):t 7 )­

David Elliott

llt l

~\Hi-z' rlllbj<;( ,ts;.,~Jh•-C<•l.>n•J '"'?c/<.!Jlli, l,lfl,l!:IJ 7 -;/'/vQ)rJJ

-z'"i<:ttn' flf il: 1:!L ., , ,. ;., /,!11'l' ~ ii< IIJ1 I., -C1i!!btl.J.,, laJ~I: I., -C, ';"t'li

lllJ11Q):1J7 -;1'1v1:;t,t 1.,-C i,1i!!btl.J., ,

1112 2005Jjc, IU', lliJ!lilH ,t,o/1-·:,- 7-,< ,{ ;.,- J 1:,-~ 1l!/>lQ);/c~~ 7:l7 J;

l!iQ)i!>\@1/iHc ii':OOiL-n •J.>:IJ<, ;:1i1;1

7:l7Q)7:/Jl!J :IJ>/',j'<j',{;., , 71/'vb. ,

ti'~, ·tL-C;lc Jl<:i(jt Q)f§l(,1,'!!>'(! {

ir--t J.,(,Q)c'~J., , ;:.Q)}Rl,'.4li:IJ' lll:ir­

-t J.,r'J'@'.. 1<7;;;\, ,fl, -Clll..!!1;!, {­

Q)7,/ }-J'v:/J<j\'j-:>ll[n ~ ~.j!j 'a,[l!lil['C'.i

lt J.,(,Q)c' ~ J.,,

nJtm,: Lt.:tv,.:;>J2-T) .7:';f-':,,1±. 11J:W,O))IJ~, v'~-f-ht.:lt1.'·/j(, tit

W,O)x~c~O)a • t tj -:, t.: 0)1.'·"to

~W~GX;f-':,,~U(O)U~~~T~9,~~0)~c/j~GX;f-':,,U.

GO)nO)a • ttlj:9.~ttu~O)~•O)•n~m~~~~,•~~~

§ !f O)]j!i: v' ~ «· 9 Wlt/j lthlf/j G tj i,p-:,f,: 0) Ti" o

~-c ~O)J:.1/j/llii.)\ v' -:, t.:1t,A,B0)1/ ✓ *1/'7.b.O)~§', ·-:Yi9, r~ a ~;h.~71/7, tL(li~-~;h./j1t'7:.l7 J ,:fiiJO)~~i.){~~0)7'.),t

~~/vli.~,t:>;h.~7'.),tLtL/jv' o t~i:>/v, X,t':,, §~1±-t'MJIJlffiBJj.O)

~~~mi-r·1±ib9i-ltlv o L7'.)'L, a • O)Jf.nL"c -f-hli3- • :;,1{0)

~-~-~~~•.11tW~T~Gn~mn~ll,!l~i"~84tj~MO)•

1t~~ L "Cv'~O)-r·-t o 71/7 ( it.:, 3- • :;,1{ • ~t:;,¥:~:$"1-lj:Gc'~Tt

-r·-ti.)>) 1:ll,!l-t ~J.iUii',;l:iolt ~~:tt;~nt.:-1 ;/--1/ t 7-17'7,:-:'.)v'"C

~!~t~, i-fi !U~O)Q1.7H:~O) 1 X,t':,, J t 71/70)~fJd:-::)1t,-r~li'i

1:-tttilf/jGtj1t,t, f.&1:1±.1~.b;/1.~0)-r·-t o ~n~t1Y4 M~I:~

:m-tnlf, * Wf/&'eii',;cv'')bO)l;t, X1tl¥JTibM.:ltTlj(. ]j!i:~fl(J

.!JH\\'f-r·;b~. 1:v,1~U:tj9i"t o -f-O)Jlt~ttH!Jl.Mt"M.:~,:1±. 1

f ,f-0) El l¥J t, -f-;h.7'.){if:@i ~ hlfflii ~nt.:>C/!IR H~r.iE L /jlthlf/j G

tj v' o ~ 1 L -CW~-r, /i'eii',;7'.){:J'J~ l±lt"~~/:1,, -:,f.: bO)i.){aJJ G i,pl:

lj ~ 0) -r· -t 0

fllilitr@l ~~THllli LLt.:t~. 71/70)*1,i\ft>Cftl:-:'.)v'"CO):Xffl.

mtj~:t,i';fl(J/i'eii',;7'.),, ;r,;lfj-17'T~MH~ (J:. 1/j ;<,j-v;t11 -;f~ff­

~~-tt ~fit~~l:-::)1t,-rbh1Lt.: o nu.:~!R':li, :t.LH.iliv'b0)1.''To tj

-if/j G. -f-1 Lt.:/i'eii',;li, J! < ilill.ff-~ tLMft!!~ J 1:-:'.)1t,-r0)%AM~

-~ - 1X;f-':,,O)nJO)i~L<••~~~~tO) - ~~~-t~tO)

f,:7'.),GT"to Jii'./J!'.~O)~i~~:t'f~ /±lt"-:'.)Mliib91-lt /vi.)' , td.:V-t~ U HtjGl ;l:', 4-fM.:~li, ~O)J:.1/j;<.j-v::tY-1-;1~. :i2,:-f-h§~~

tJWlt" ~ -=f:fitt L "(, mt~i',;T'fiJffl-t....Z~fitlll\'I: ~ n,~ tflli~ x.1

To fM.:~li. v'v'X. 7 1/70)X1tlit ~ 1 ....Z~7'.), tLtL1-ttlvi.),, A,-t-

53'/j~n ~:J"Sf-:,"(i, 9, 7 1/7 i!l:$"1-1:io It~ /ff~ t-t- 53-t.:i.),;t 9. -~

~:i2-=f:l:*~~U'T~~ o tli ~ x., ii J.J-IHt.:1t.:£ •~Tt" o2 >

94 /jt{tW,O)§'/l[l,:5EWli¥Jl::W ~ 1±1-t, i&Jff1~~T LlfL lf li J!i:±

i/ii;O), 7:/7i'/lf!IO) * if.fH&1/i'ei i',;~7.x.AT11~1v,: -::)1t,-rt, flli

~~ T ll!~-:'.)b91iib91-lt lv o -f-;/1.GO)~ (li, "tlfG Lv'/i ~ c.1{7

,t-7 ✓ A ~13' Iv Tliv ' 1 "91.)', El fl() Ii -::) 1 ~ t~ 0 i&fclfl(JT ib 9. ,f-0)

ftJ!O)lj!i:~fl(J. LlfLlfi&fcl .. L tL(lifFIB)r..l.0)-::)/ji.),9~%-::::f(M.:~

Session Ill 14]

O)ii(lU;j:jO) V'c "? t.:iPG-C'To

-f ;h,W,_t 1:flO)J/-IJt:~ V-< 0) Ii, 198O:¥fUJJMJ21.*0),EJHt*Wrl: IM!

T 1.>-r-1 -7,::i--7,0)W,:ftO)ts, i, f-L--C ;:.O)W,:ftil-71/7~, -fhc ll'1I t < Gv>mEfrl:-f <":b~il'-:it.::~00 t;lt:1:, :ffl.f-t*Wrl:~ i-tt 7.> J:--31: L

t.::ts-i- 01.>Hi 1~{-Jf: J ts--ttl.ic"§"--}A'l:,v,l.,"C:'L.1:--}t,,- "C:'Ta ::.

:=. t:·flil'"§ --}t.1:-:ic Lt.::J.it~ Ii, 71/7il'4"77-;;"./3--J-7';1,,f,:t,,Gt v'

--3 J.!1!1±1 t.:ftt,,71/7 O)f'1,*0)1ffil/i:, 7'"-7 ii:, :lt!!i&~El9 ~:ffl.f-1':*Wr!i:

"-0)~1J•l:~t,,-:i--Cv>l.>t v':blvt T 1.> '/:,O)t:·lia; 9 i-tt Iva filJlilO):m,

.¢!. ~~~3o:¥rai 1: W.:ft ts--ttt.::, '1:i-:iUNi* < 5Alv>llf!4 0)1.Jt,,flv,--cv,

7.>0)t:·Ta -fhGJJO)v,<"?il'liAD;f,c!t, i&it, ts-G1:1ift¥1lEl9~l>

0)"(:'&)9,71/7~%~tl,;h,1.,'/:,0)"(:'~&)9;i-\t/v o *ffi0)1fj:!J'il"(:'&)6

--3t, lfillffl!tLt.:: 1 ?' • -1{ 1J.X1-J tv,--3'1i:Jm-c·a;6--3t, 0Gl-9l1.>~11t:

1: ;J3 v>--C:f-'t4 l;J: v' i, l,'1J t "./ AT 1'0)-lz-;; J--0) g:q:~ ~--c v' 7., t ~ t---c v'

i Ta u, L, ::. hG "./-7, T 1' t,,f[r L v' 'I:, O)"C:' a;J., t,,l-9)i_ 1:*t.:-f O)tt'l'i

li,fflA!Lilf"C:', c' ;:_ 1:,f 0)~~89 ~JJil'ffttT 1.,0)t,,, flt.::tlili-:i~ 9

cli"§" x.~v,-r:·v' iT a3 >

AD;f1ca-rO)v~Jvt:·"§"x.li, ~~5O:¥rai1:1-¥ 1J-7,, 7PJ-JJ, f-L--C

-JJ--J-7"'1±, J,<0)71/7, -fL--C771JMMt~~ 1J/H~L--C~iLt.::a UM tlt----Zhli, 1-¥ 1)-7,/;J:;ffl,;(E 7'7:,, -7, ~ 1--'1'.1/ ct 'l:,l:J,Jtft0)1JR;j-~ Hsy

"?J:--}1:~9;tLt.::a %1:@3- • -;;1{t:·1;J:, 71/7 AO)Jmiffl.HsJ"?rilt

t.::tt,,f-0):lllJ:f!OCl:INJ!X ts-h, -f L --cmJIIZ L --C;B 9, 01.>fi~0)~5JHHl

1.> '/:,0)0), 1//lGO){f~, 11t~'t1't -f L --crRt.l.JO)"§"~t,,, 81:1:lt!!O)Jtftl:

i:W:i!L--Cv'iTa4 >

&m89J.!l!El3~J:J.i71/7~~00~G0)8~0)D~~,fil!J'ilO)l'JRffl~Wc:

ftts--tt"?-:::fftJ.i, :&Hfll:51:~tht.::;ffl.~"C:'Ta ;:.O);ffl_~~/Jl\i!lcTl.i'l:i

O){:, iinli:ft (hybridization) "-0):k ~~:\s.1d11i~il'0 9iT a 'I:, L <1±::.n

~ Al.!lt~5JIJE19~, !Mtt.!ltft (rnongrelization) C v'") "§~{::t:<~x. Thli,

-fhW±ffiJ ts-h, /15~ts-n, -f L --C;j-NJ)[(;t,,GW.:x.Gh--C L i--3::.c"-O)~

·Mi~tv,--}::.U:~9iT a u, L, OO~i'B~AO)!l!JJ~~OOllHMM-a;J.i

1: 'I:, 00:bG-f, ;:_--3 Lt.::Wc:ft~, T----Z--CO)'i:, O)t,q,'in 1: ll'1lft L 't'v' < tv, --};!t,J-ft (homogenization) O)j[Sf~IH:tt /vc'Ji!,G h i-tt Iva J,1JRttli

fftt L "?-:::fft, -f h-f'';h,O)Jtftt,,~~~ 90)f.::,l.".JO)}ijfiJZ ~£-~t LJ: --3

t 'l:i, T----z --cil-1l'11 t niPl"-iPlil' -:i--c v'J.i u~~T 1., 'l:i O)~ t'i-:i t.:: < a; 9

i-\t Iva

-f L --cit.:, i-:i t.:: < -'f Wl ts-n~ il'-:i t.:: 1-r:t • 'f-O)W,:ftt,,J, 4 a; 9

144 Session Ill

llt3

7~9;/JB.t00~E~C~6. - h t'1'7? rB!lt:i<'.f-tJ 1:1l1li'6. Ucfl!! 1ft'i;J; r.tl!Ht~ J 1:ll!Jb6*MiltE l!lli:iE#li;ltl:,ht. -!lltEEi!t!/,!Bit; Ell!i:IJ!n<J1,-!Jlft ltL6f!e>? ,

ltt4

1'•9Ac'ti::CEl?~~ • ~Atim OOM!tfE!eyftl:ia:t-ofc, WH.li;/Jv

-n•1 ••JAE:ttEH <-1-•J-1:nn ;b-:,fcEn•::Elij'Jt/Jc'~6 , tl Hi: L.Mec#~c'I-C-1'.9AAE~ l:-fHl11:t, !Ma~IJEr ;/Jv--, <7 Y-J~~hlliltL~Et'ti~ -o~ n•, ooa,,::t1:. ::E r ;IJ•JJ( t;/Jv - · ,<".JY- ) n<lJ,lci:i,tcGltLfcE i;J;, 1••J:,.Eifo:i!Il!lllll'biliL-Ct'~ -ofc, 8,j;;Eifolliftfc",n<,{••}Aq) *ft8CUtL~~C+tLi~CA -o t • ;;jc1:r~A J L. ;;j;;OO't'fcc,ic, A,itil1/fc(c)c'~6 , P,-c'lilitA.I:' q:i,{ ••JA 'Pilfillftllq:ifi~Afcc,l;J;, ;/Jv- · , <7Y-c'l;J;~( jW4 (c)A,<

1'Ai6~ • c'~v~Vi'6i?C~ 0 f:. o

i!t5

Paris, Centre Georges Pompidou and

La Villette,1989.

i Lt-:o {JU x.li, 1¥f 77 1J :tJ 0) 71{Jvr "-1 r O)~:b l'J t t 'ii 1:{f it-:-c-c

tiJi n~ -tt-:~R:lt!!.:ta, 1/ \::.L H·L -Ci'%lil!GO)*/gJ:ib0t-: 1/!HtJR t \,\ 1tti11J1,7;,.,7.0)}m:!$L r:j=ii!IO)J&/al:.t:Ht J.>ili:f-t11::t -c:-7-;; rO)/ffl!il(o

f.l.§~O),f±JJ'f.i@L-C0)11t!!:'/fJtO)/±l~v'li,.to~LO)@l'J, t-:0t-:

4-.::m~ Lt-:lm!il(O)!li}J~t ffeW,lJ i,g-:b-tt-C~11::iclf-C ~iLt-: o ~HJJ,

1-¥') 7.0);t7 7. 7:t- F ili:1-\':~-Wrfi'iH:!¥};~ L -Cv' t-:;f.&1±, 1970:¥1-1';:;;t;:

~iPG, .L-t-1/'-f--;; 7 t.: 'ii 0)-"-0)iO(~C,±~OJIJO)'.§':;t,·c :m.1-t~-WrO)

tt'l'fl: 01,,""(0)~ffiliiifr• &':>J.,S:c ifl±I* i Lt-:o S: "? Lt-:~l;i.0):7(~1±,

19s9:¥ 1:1{ ,; -c-rm1i ~ nt-: 1 :x:lt!!O)/fd-WrRl!it-:; J ~ s) 0) ::t t.:x~'aO) u­t 0-r:· ib l'J, ~ffiliil±, J: l'J'ti.'JE L -C:bil' 9-'\'Tv'1!{Ef(J!J:IJWr~~O)£,~tt

t,fflW-'\'-ct-7-;;J-~J:0-C~&1:>GtLJ.>mWt~~0~ • Mi~mtt

It l.>Clt'"? § Ef{JO)f-:&1:>l:tr• &':>GtLt-:{iO)"t'"To

-:-:-c-, 1970:¥1-\':-'tW: 1 X:f;,.,O))t11::J 0) r:p,C.,:lt!!-C-ibl.> @Wzt 7 _;1

') :tJO):m.1-t~Wr t f-0)1 / AT1T .:z.-1/3 ;,.,i@:~ Lt-:fcr::11/H:--::>v>-C.::

m~-ttti. lit.: I') i-tt lvo YffilEf(J 1: g 0-C Li x. Ii, -:-: 1: ~ -Cti ~ J: ~ 7 '1

7;,.,-f"°" Jv Fl±~:il&0t-:{H:JE1:t:1Hf-:O)"t'"To 19-tlt;fsc=/=-liW-* ~ ;t~··

it.: 11 XAJ O):ii!liJ.JH~!liJ.J~-tt-cM-:, ~.;J!tEf(J~.Wrt (l!!lif0)%AO))

•:J!tEf(JJ&/at0)000)• -'\'~t.:~M~,~:bl'Ji~x.-CLi0~0)-C-~

~-=--c: 1;x At ::i;,.,-t7°-f-.171v • 7- 1-w.~i, t1 fr< ~~t-:. 01±t.:< t.:

0-C Li 0 t-:o 7~ ~ nt-: 0) 1±11:if!T J.> j][O)J;i. -c-, ll;!:9:.i:aO)lil!GiB& i 'ii--::>

Aa•®#~~Lfra&':>iL~ o L~L,S:O)~M~A'Ai~L~®*O)

$- < 1±, -t-c-1::J,-t,: < t 'ii 20:¥Jitril'G tis!liJ.J L n, t-::'/ft-: -t -r:· Lt-:o S:O):m,

aiH.&1:$, <O)S:c i § rA~ ~-tt J.,S:cl:t.:l')iLt-: o I S:tl.i:,O)i]!jj.t-:'till"

20:¥Jitr 1: J§!. 1,,fr,f/, H,1J1,t L n, t-: 0) t.: G Ii, t.:iff-0) ~ ~'A-::f ii, tj: ii'

0f-:O)f.:0"?il'? J 'ii0c:$@:l:-gx.li, 1-fiiJiltfl;JHftfa:0-Cv'f-:O)il'? J

-: 1 Lt-:.& 1,, ®*t-:-t:,O)f.s!li}Jill" § Jitrt:·ib0t-:1: 'ii~ :bG-f, ;fU-:"tlH·

tL 1: 1/!li IMJ ,C, t.: 0 t-: 0 -c-IH.& 0) ~ = 0) PA9 "' I± 1 S: tLW-:71-1: fjjJ ill";fJ.t-:; 0)

t.JH!fil,t:, ~ it-: If Gn n, t-: 0) t.: 0"? ii'? J Cit'"?-: Co 'ii0t @:~Ef(J 1: -g

x.li, 1 S: tLW-:7\,1:-fiiJ i ;fU-:"tl± § 5tt-: -t 0)1J/.!Uil'G ~ ~·it-c 1,,f_:O)f.:

0 "?ii'? J f-0) ~ O);fJ.O) ::tt.: ll;!:9:'.Ef(J~Jl;,1(1± 1910:¥1-\': t 1920:¥1-\':0) o 1/ 7 · 1/ I::

.Lr••::t•~ibl'J,-:0):5t!lffim11;~~G~~t.:0~0)~,~~0)

7-'r1 7. rt-:-t § :!iif'ill"~ x.J.>tS:.00)11fiGO)f.s!li}J t, i&Gill"f-O)f.s!li}Ji

c'O)J: 11:~fiffi L n,t-:il'i, @ifO)f.lt~•t-='till"~< ~m L n,t-:il',

'ii L < 1±1/!litJI. L -CM-: ii', t 1,, "? $~-r:- Lt-:o l&mtt 1:--::> 1,,-cO) ?1 7.:tJ

Session lll 145

,-:,; 3 ✓ ,i~lm-CJ!JIJl!#i ~ n, Jii-C:f.1,bnt-.:Jl~O)J.i.i.J,~ ~ n 1 Lt-.:o 1

G-C Jii G ~"' I!! :f.l>G 0)1)jl}l'\O) J: '? 1:, .:: nG O)fpJh t-.: t ,±@1lli]A.J!f:r c

L-C~ft}.nGn, ~i.J,-Cf-0)- l}Jlc~niLt-.: o

.:: .:: -r-,± r !l ~ 1: "'.) "' tO)i~~J wmi > 0) 'ffN 1: ,± ob n 1-it lv:i.l',

198O~1-t:f.1,G 199O~1-UJJ<l61: ,±, fl.I: c-::,-C, 1-t* · f'Fa'1iO)Jt~ ~ ~

Wf-tG.::c, ffrLHlll:5!:HeJi-tG.::c, f-L-C§5r~5tAfoli.J,G/!Jif.:!t(

T G c1,, '?.:: Ui, -t-.1 v-17'- c L -CO)tHJ J:!J'f5.JIJ t.:JJ:ft H,"'.J J: '? f: t.:

91L~ o .::n~,~~±-~~Gh-CO).::c-r-b,0•~~*.l6-CO).::

t-r-bt.:<, .lja.1:m1uHr-rc,±1Jt!i!-O)c,.::-r-Mt91:1:1 ~n -cv,GO)t..:cv'

'?.:: c.f:%.-:::fv,t-.:i.J,G-C Lt-.:o 196O~ 1t0)7; 1J tJ A1'F* Ff-Jv F · ::J"'

o/r'O)i§'.i)H:f,LUJ, r~~b;/cG,-Z~fjO),i, 1'Fa'1i:f.1,r::J ✓ 7 ✓#7 1J- J

-C Jii G :l.l•c0 '? :1.,,-r-,i t.: < r .& v' b 0) J -r-i!ii G :1.,, c0 '? :1.,,, -C Jii-::, t-.: 0)-C-To 6 )

fl4 O)~~i.J,fl4 0)-tR/A'.T--C' r .lil LJ C ~h'?G.::c~ flJl G:1.1,,: T GO)

:1.,,, 'fl.O).!i!::kt.:7°• ::l.r.:7rct.:9, 1t-.:f--?-Ci!?9"'.J-:::ffHTo .::O)t-.:il6

f: ,±"j!:i:l(~:;k"j!:-C"j!:/vt..:'i'tl:'t&l ,i Ii li'J!;/J ft 1: (it.: Gt.: 1,,.:: c 1:%.-:::f i.J, ~

n 1 Lt-.:o £,7EO){lj1:'st'IJ9~13!'.c.ffl1-::,f-.:?-'T,-rcO)Jilh%v'O)f-.:il6,

m1t*Wr0)1Jt!j!. ,±, @ 5r W,:7'1-0).:: c ,: (H-::, t-.: < 1Wi9'• t.:, ;flJc.119-Ci~~

t.:bO)O)J:'?~Ji~iL~o~~7fitJ~t.:1JtW-r-Ji>Gc/3!'.4§~nt.:

:f.1,G b, it-.:, f-O)iJt!i!-1:~-t G At-.:tO)f- '? Lt-.:OOA119l1lfilf: b llllb

Gf, ,1:,7,717 .1-:,;3:,c L -c,±, m1t*wr,±i!?MlO)Jt11::11971,11,,

r""-1 re L -C~il~ L -Cv'G J:-?-C Lt-.:o

.::'?L-C, o:,;7, 77:,,7pJtJ, 77 1JtJ, f-L-C7::J70)J/i:m1t*

Wf HVFT G.:: c:1.1,, ::t:7 7-7:t- FJ/i:1t*Wffm0)7°• :7·7 Al:;fnJ jzO)

$5rc t.: 91 Lt-.:o f-0){!!10)7°• :7·7 A:l.l•G 1%/ll!E ~ n -C Ji>GO)-C,it.:C

tl.t-.:t 1: c.-::,-C~i\iljO)@i$*WfO),/iVF7°• :7·7 Ac - 1,l;:11:: ~ nt-.: 0)-C-To

.:: '? Lt-.:JJr.H: J:-::,-CO)J.i., ·~0)~14-C, t-J-15 ~ n\t1l ~-it G.:: c:i.l'nJil~

ct.:-::,f-.:0)-C-To

f-0)~,~-,l!l,bL<~mM~-A~i!?-CG.::c~ft~~/jJJ~-C

,±t.:v' t~ l'.-G At-.:t b 1,, 1 Lt-.:o t.:-tl:'t.: G f-0) J: '? t.: 7:t-tJ7-,i r 11!1

~ J CV''?-r.ltffl HilJ 9 ~-c GJ: '? t.: bO)--C-, § 119:i.l•G~i'rT G.:: c--C·Ji>G

U'.tbnt-.::f.1,G-C-To 11/,G,i r:71-ffilJ :f.l>G0)1'J=*t--=t~, J,(:,-7, r 1J-A

0)7-? J.i~ :7·1v-7"/.i 1:itt 9 Ah -C "'< Ii'? :1.,, .& v'c±~ L 1 Lt-.:o 'fl.

l:(i.::O)J: "?t.:JJ~,i, f1JJ ~,V-t-:,;::i~ B ,$:~tJhv-:,O){t~c L -C

lliJ l'.-f'F*:i.l'~ 9:i!! L::kffl.~t.:l!l~/.i-Cc. 9i!?ffGhGCV''? Ji,$:±ft (r

-:7:::_;i:_A) 0)1'/',~~-ttl<c}.!'.'.bniLt-.:o 11/tGO)±~l:J:n,t, r J-t-:,;

146 Session Il l

m:tt1 Intentional Fallacyl if.~l:-::>1,,""((f)

~llJJ /:Ii, c:.-1- -7')-r-i:,-7'.L<n{{;

,lcA'Jffl:lif'i(, '7-i')TL - ?-iL-1/'c,

(William Wimsatt) t~ ✓a- · l:::'7

7'.•J- (Monroe Beadsley) l:J:7.,1'[ lllio l!iiGli-r4'7-Hc:XH/"t7.>/:/', -{­<nB.ti9ff<n•~-t7.>~/:~-~ ~;;11:1,. -r4'7-HH!:n•••-t7->b <nt!lt~~IJ!"t«/'1:~7.,/: ltc o

ilt6

:hrs i'li~~ 1:r-1:,,-,.;,, PJill'<ni!!:W ;: 13,t ~~.WfQJJE~,:-::,v,--cift-::>--C ,,tc<n1:~7.>o 196O#'fU.:1:, Ii l;f/:' ,nnt.,Jfj,nf,ll{'Fj, r,HliJ /:L-C t,~lt7.>, bL<IJ:$il{'f."t7.,~b)<tfj J![7.,J:01:t.:? -C,,fc o l!ii<n,:Jt,A,/: L~/:~;;ti,.<nR~1:~?~• t,/!<n-{-:h 1:lit.,)l, ? fCo

,mu -1)-;., • ~1 • 7r (sam-cul,mes) l:li7'7 ;.,;,,ff!tt-181!J:lc.//i$)1)11itr/Jtl:, ii!f.tr <1).'j'.;;(;J{;., (~1 0 7 r ) Tli(i't!Vc ;,~,. f<;;(;f-;.,<1:>rfi~'.Jfflb'll"lll'ik/l>;c ll!~<1:>:tl:F :;,,-c1il!-,tc.til1io m~tc ;,1uu:~~>;ci,-,"( 1a,rtct,>;:-!)­✓ - ~,-07rl:11f-/d.: o ,ji:Xt'lif<~ 1:lllJJ;f,ta:<rX ;f-;;JTJli11<1:>g,.11t1: l.,, r;;(;f-;;>;c1U •,t.irn~tct;Jl:Uco

tt7 E. Alkazi, D. Elliott, V. Musgrave

[eds) Indian Myth and Reality:

Aspects of Modern Indian Art; D.

Elliott [ed]. The Other India: Sroen Contemporary Photogrphers; E. Alkazi,

U. Anand Gods of th, Byways:

Wayside Shrines of Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh and Gujarat. ~Ct, -j'-.....Z-C;f­

'/CA7*-l'ili:11:~1'iJlil, 1982"J'tJJ/:iio

::iJ"t'·if;,,1.,b),, 177'):fJJ't"if;,,1.,/:i,p, f-O)J:-jl:!fsffkt·:::Ht1.>-::.a1:, 00

~~t:J:±4;;0)- Je! 't"if;,,1.>f'F*t-="t~t· -=.tt:i:<~,H ~-t 1.,-::.1:1:t;i:1.,tv,-jO)

'Z"Lt.:o fl1:1±-::.n1±&4,fi\t~t:i:JJ:~/:~t.GtLiT o tv,-jO){,, 7

- J--0)1if:J'i!.-/)•f-O)fqi roj't"ti t;i: 1.,,t ~ x. --c 1.,,1.,~t.:-t~, 1.,,-/),(: NJE1¥.H:

~t;i: L n,1.,-/),~~b1: Lf.:-/),G't"To f-L --c i, -t:,.::,A,, /:0 A.-t;i:$:$i-~'Z"

{i-t<·1:-::.0)-::. U:1". f.r'-'' f.:O)'t"T ( f-L --c, =f-::,Jfx. ~ !f!. Ol'iii (:if;,,1., 1 ;(

:f:,, J 1:=f.Hl:l Lt.:) o L,-/), L, fl-/),j,ij;j-,'(H:~1!,!(~{,-::,f.:O)(i, -lf-:,, · -t-.1

•:;, rt.: -1:,, 0 i ~ 1 ;( :f:,, ~ tH>!Qrff lH.:"tJ mm> 0)-::. t 'Z" if;,,~, {, Lfl

7)', El 71-/)•fg l:.1.,:,,-7.-r AO)pgttJl'"('j)J1.,,n,< O)tj:t:,(;J:_ ~~(: 1:$i-tEJ

-t 1.,~Jr~ E153-EI :!iJ'O)!m't" ~1.,1:v,1-::.1:,±~b!o--C!lf{,t;i:-=.tt!-::>t.:

O)'t"To ii'1'f.J~0)7D:7'7A-/){0<GtLtl.(;J'.'tj:Gi', f-0)1&, ffi"Lv'

rn~H'il¥:~4lc, wf'~, f-L --r i/i:g/,f-1'.;~ Jr'il:O) tl:l/11.i!lt,..._0)~11•1:-fili:-t

7.,-/),t'-j-/),O)wf'filli-/)'£·~'t"Lt.:o :g/,;(£, fM.:"tti!jtfti: L --C"t'·t±t:i:<, ~

1&0) i, 0)/: L --C ltt'il: ~ ii1., J:-j 1: t;i: ~, iil:Wli- ;tlc~'t"/i.X: ~ ll.-::,n,1., J:

-j 1: (i~x. t;i: < t;i: ~ i Lt.:o fl 1: /:-::,--C 198Oif:f-t Ii, J'l}wf'filli /: ~~O) 1 O

if: fdl 'Z" Lt.:o f- 0) -:t• --t 7-0) r.U (: Ii, '-'' < 0 {, 0) IIUllE t;i: roi~ {,, i!!!IH'

t.: < i-t -j (t --Cv' i Lt.:o

:t7 7-7:t - r'°?)' 1982if: 1: r,ij~ Lt.: 11;., F ~~21 t m~: i!if-t 1:,, F

~JrO)fflUiilH 1ftlHfiiO).-f:,, F: 7 }I.O):g/,f-1'.;~Jl;*t.:-tJ 1~.mO)f1~4: 7-

.:__;...,;z.7- :,,, '77'1"1' · 77-r·-:,,-.1, 7·.:__;.._,7- J--O)j/[(;J:'t.:O)~JJ!lf:J Cv'

-j 300):,,-'J- X/l¥:li, 194Oif:ft£JJJ/;O),f :.,-F"t'·O).:c:$'".:::;(AO)~it, ~

Jr~~/: F-t-.1J.;.,71J-~ti;, f-L --C~l'...-f :.,-J--'l::l31t 1., 1::::,, F7-fU1-ntr

0)1~H41 t IJ!ljf-t 1., 7:t-7 · 7- t-~f-n-f·nttiiE-t 1.,m:iet4lc'Z" Lt.:071

~*O)','j\'l!JO)lft~-/),t:,, 1 'f"1J7.1±1:,, F /: ~ < 0)5.iJJ t;i:0t;i:-/),~ ~fif

-::,--C~iL~o t-::..::i#m<-::.t~,1'f"0~~U*~~1:,,FO) ~ ffiiW

r, t -t 1.,~JrfrnM3(:~i,::k"¥'0)"¥'$ Mf-tE Li-it A.-o :1t;1:~«t.:/l¥:~

4lcli, 5Ell1l.1& i, it!if!ij[.a';:ltlJ.:i:~O)~iffk 0~ 1., 1:,, Fl:;t-31.,,--c, 1.,,-/),1:

l!Uli:ffl:~jr~/: i, t;i:-::,--C i/if-1'.;-/)'ffirix: ~n --Cv'-::,f.:-/)' HR:~ Li Lt.:o '/5

%' L --r1M-= El m~i:, 771 ✓ • 7- t-~ ~n,i"ll'A G-/),t;i: f-O)fi'fili-1±, 7

:t-7 · 7- H:~GtL1.> El ~f19tj:fi1J~tti: ll'A 1.,1.,,~~/:(i~P.\H19t:i:li

O)'"(' Lt.:o if;,, i 91: {,~ < O)f'J:;*t.:-1:,-/)•1 'f"'}7.0)~;j;f.j$:ti('Z""¥'cf, ,f-::.

'Z"il'&Bmt.: -t 1: 5ffi '-''~~~~it t.: t.: Ii>, ~~O)r~,m i, fif t _u, ~ i Lt.:o

~Jl;1: !Ml L --C Ii, 1:,, Jq± f-0)-lf-7':J .r.71--/: L --C:@.Wt-t 1.,1:1±if;,, i ~ 1: {,

::k~ -t~· 1.,J:-j't" Lt.:o f--::. 't", /l¥:~4lc'Z"li~lt1'c-'\' A El B I< ~·ttHi:G

x.~J:<if;,,1.>~• 'Z"Ut:i:<,:m.t£0)~mO)h~&•L~~£~ • ~-t1.,

Session Ill 147

J::1{,ilqHLt.: o

1 ✓ F c(J)::.. '? Lt.: 1±1~1,,,i),G, 5 I ~~~1fil(J)Mn~il-l±l*;l;Jil>-:,'(I,,'

~ 1 Lt.:o ~jijjj(J);f,' ;7.:$'-c 71 JvA(J)Mn~ (1982if:), 71:::,, J-'7-j-­

r · :r:::t-;i,(J)*~@M (1986if:), K.G.;;z.7'7?.::."\':,,(J)'1'v.t-1/;:,7;;z.

(l)Mi@M (1988if:), -f L -C A1J-t 1J.::. · A:iJJv1/-(J)/,lJt/i1JM (1994if:) ~

c'-z"To8 )

u, L, F/-'r;-~771 ✓ • 7- r(J)Mn~1±@~i)>GlitrL0~\H',E;L

t.:BUlH.· >/i-:,-C if!! x. G tL 1 Lt.:o ii'~ IJ .iilli Lt.: ;i;J t 1:::€f ~ 7.::.:;,1/ .::z. · :iJ

7"-77)' 11 ✓ J-'(l):€f-=p 7-71 ;;z. r J t L-C M~,=~:/J • L -C>/i~ i,, t·1

L-CM'-Jvl::IH!,GtL~v' o ~J.,Lit'tKfl):it&-:,-C l;/-tll.f, -f(J);i;Ji!,G~

11::WHi1.B9~ffl!ilU±t·::.. ii,~·::.. i:,~1,,,t (J)-z" Lt.:o 7·;v-'1'7JIJ 1:::B-1tG

tLt.:1'FJMlf(J) Jil±l L N rJvli, t.:tx.lHtllJlr.'i(l)~:ltl!J (7--t 1:,,, F.N.

;;z.--w, -iJ-71:;, 1/.1 • 7·1/.17 ;i,), 1Mi@(J9 ;1 :r 77-c L -C(J) 13 f'.,!,J ( 7--lf

-, 1WA1/-, 7-A · 7?-Jv), 1~1il~nt.:~1v:1-t J (.:i:-1,:,, • -it?

:,, r, :$'1 :r...7• · ;(-A.:$', KG.A 7·7? .::."'7:,,), 11±~89/fillWU t i&m(J9'1'

07,;z.r J(7 1) 1/.:i:.:,, · :iJ :,,-j--, A. 7?-f--'r::,, J-'7 :,,, l'.::iJ 1/.::z. · 1{:;,:$' 1-

-'r:Jv1/-, 1/33/✓ · 1-3'77'.::z.'J-, 7J11/.::z.1{--7•1v-:r, R.S.:hv:h ),

1-f~m(J)~c/c[IAt.:tJ (1/-'1 · 1,7- Jv, AT-1 Jv · 1,)- '7 JvY-:,,), fi:p

mEflll';ftl(l)tJJ!.~J (-t 1J-=-. °"7 .::.- ) , r~ L H1~1i.s ~ L HJl.~J (A'J-t

1;.::. • A:iJJv1/-, 7 .::.:;,1/.::z. • :iJ '1'-7) o ::..1 Lt.: rJq'§ (::..tt.1:1:t.:1,,,t.: 1,,,

if:f-\':J®H::M~J ~-ltt.:(J)-z"Til') il-@1tt1::t-:,-C M~~""-(J)* • t~-:>t.:

(J)l±li"U'-z"Til', flt.: t li>/i-:, t 1'F£ 131$:1:: t-aG-lt J.i tv, 1 ,C.,ffl x. ~ L

·ct,< .--z~ "t" Lt.:o f.l-1±4-IH"? 7-71 ;;z. r 13 ,Jli),jj!/v"t"IB&?J.i :iJ7 ::t 1J- u,1t1,,,;t-1t /vL, 'ii L <1±, ::..(J)2if:{ll::tf:btLt.: B *(J)jjijf//f,)Hf.r

M(J)llif(J) J:: 11::, 7·1v-'1':B-1t 1±if:1-t:ma-z" .::..1 - r 7 ;i,~:JF31::-t J.i::.. t 1::

L-Cv'iT o

1f'H1H~: B *(J)jjlj//tr*ff-r 1945 - 1965J M (1985if:) 1±/iiJilU• tfi,.(J)

.t-.::z. v-1/ 3 :,,'(', {Jii:t;((l) ::t-7 ;;z. 7:t- F::k~(l)fl§:±t~::,t(J) t.: &? (J)Wi]311'.jiJf

Jl;l::~-:::f< >/i(J)-z"Lf.:o9 > ~llit1 '¥ 1),;z. "t"li, B *(J)ili:{-\':*ff-rl±~<~

Gn-n,~il'-:>t.:t-g-:,-C>/i:i/!il"ei""t"li~<, B *0017'J"t"~x. 1/i, ::_(l)IJit{-\';

(J)*Jrl±Jl-1$:t 7:,, 7:t Jv JIJv(J) @*, tv, 1 J:: 11::::k{<fi:~~(J9 I:: cit x. G

tL -n, 1 Lt.:o ~~il!:fl(J)!lif{-\':l±i&m89T ~-, l 960if:{-\':1JJliJHH'HllH::

'.:hrt&?J.il::l±Wm89T~· J.it ~n -n, 1 Lt.:o Lil' L~il'G, 1!t83ti-*

••••-z";i;JJ.i::k•m~~(J)~•~~~-c,a~~~tooE~mE~Q

(J)X:~l::J::l)::..(J)Mn~~~~ ~-It J.i::..U,l±l*1Lt.: o ~n~i± 11/.1

148 Session Ill

i!t8

R Monk.A Robinson [eds] Rabindranath Tagore: A Cekbration of His Lift and

Work, Rabindranath Tagore Festival

Committee/Museum of Modern Art

Oxford, 1986. D. Elliott, K G. Subramanyan: Fairy Taks of Oxford

and Other Paintings, Museum of

Modern Art, 1988. C. Iles, 0.

Robinson, Mrina/ini Mukhnje, Scu/ptur,, Museum of Modern Art Oxford,

1994.

i!t9

D. Elliott, K Kaido [eds], Reconstructions,

Avant-Gartk An in japan 1945-1965,

Museum of Modern Art Oxford, 1985.

)v VJ') AAtliiHt:0)¥fn'lt~J Cit''? ~ - l}fln>C:, Ml i fJ' ,f-::.-Cttf,'fi],$::;k

Jl!~O):;ld'F{~0)1JE} (1950{p) n' - mA?'-t tj fJ i Lf.:o 1980{p{t-¥1i,

1-=¥') Al: tl:lffi. Lf_::=_O) 77 A j--c."Wlt!r~ nt.= g:;/(c."~IJR tj,fuO)~I±,

Y::.T;,,, -1,- A J-0)~1'., tj;isJv?') ;,,,ii'tltO)~J: fJi'0t£J.liiJO), i! El

0)1,;,,,71¥.J ,1 ;,(-:Jc." U.=o ~i:::,,: ::_O)~ :7 :,,3 ;,,,1±, :;le ~tj'.m ~~{,t.:G

Ti'€ii't'ic.":,, 1J7 Atj:frifii ~~.ztj:n'Gmv'-Cv'~ i Lt.:o -WU.zli, illTJJll

iffi\.O)W<:%n;,,, '7'7 AO)*it® <~A~ > (1955{p) ~w fJ~IJ 1nt.=:tctt. Hlli

< {~~ (:/tt!!lu)} (1954{p), 7PJ:h i:S~JffO)J:ll:J?-~@,( UJT?,\ij= O) {~

.::.,-;f,;,,,ijmtft} (1954{p), it.:1±, 'l![lmtf/ill:fji-t J.,tjn,vrr.fr~ ill'? B ,$:

_AO);.s'~n,£,:YE 1:1{,-'1'1:-f!;-:b-lt-C iiil 0-C v' J.,:fi:Jtjl:$0) { y;,,, A}

(1956:l'.j:.)tj:t'o -::J-::f(~=imHJ.1,$:, 7;,,,7,tJv;,(Jv, -'c-L-CTJ'Ar7

:7r • ,-r J tJH!L ·c J'l,{,$:;?>C:,1,7,t-7/A, ,f-L, •OJ!JfMHf.r"'-C,

1960{p{t-¥1;U-c·~~,m Li Lt.:o -JiHlt0)~:7:,,3:,,1±tl'C 'ffilt-'ffrT

Mi-cr-t--i"·YY, "11,,,-i.:-~ ✓:$1-:Go{pftO),-rJtL, ::.0)/il~

4<0),:pc."l±- :ffi:;.s'v'i!!:{tO){,t* ~ ~&>'.)i Lt.:o :tilJJll~Pl~ 1:J: MldJ

1¥.11:,li.%;/1.,JiE--1? L<ffi.1t1t ~nt.={~Mtl¥.1 B ,$:O)ij'f.JIIJ&t~, 1/IrilHM:.O)

llt~l¥.J-C;l;i fJ tj:n,t:, >lifbfll¥.Jtj:~;tJH!tl'f0)¥-f-=f, -f-VC V · ::1-::i0)1JJ

JlJJ0)711v1-tjt'I±, :;l(~tj:A~1'Fifiic."Lt.:o

::.O)f.i:>'i-tj !il~i4< 1±~~~ t'O) J: 11j 1;,,, 1, 7 r ~ ;1;i t.= x. t.= 0) n'? maJJ T J., O)l±ft L 1,,,::_ t-c·-t"o Wl.1H:l:,h, tj:il,tJ]c."li;l;i fJ i Lt.::>?', ,$:~ O)c

::. 0f!liGlit'11.i/Z-t---Z~ i?'5t'iPG tjn,0t.= o v' i 1-r:-,:~~ Lt.:::. t

O)tj 1,,,11:, 0) t!. 0t .=n,Gc."To llR G n,f!_ 0f.:O)I±, ::. ;/1.,C:,0)7--r1 A rt.=

t,O):j;y-::J'.m < ---Z ~ .:r.;r,Jv ;\"'-t '7'1 :J 3 ;,,,n,, 1,,, ii c."0)/[~ 0) "P -Cl±~

~1:1!\lim ~n n,t.:tlt'1::.t -cLt.=o ::.O)/il~4<1± 11.i-CMM~11TO)

J: 1tj>/:,O)c." Lt.:- N_1t,t1±5-ti?'0n,-c>1:, iirr.'ifc."l±tj:(, t'1 L -C, t·

0) J: 11: L -c -'c nn' N. 1,,, O):>?'IDl >Ii J: < IHll G tj v'o B ;,t;:ii!tliO)/il ~4< :h

:$10:7·1±:PL:illn-C r,-1v · '7'1 '7'7:,, J [tO)-ffltt L-C tl:l!tli~niLt.:

i?', ::.0) J: '? tj~-~ ~ >li0 t.=iil~4<n' B ;,t;:OOr;i-c ni:::, ;/1.,J., J: '? 1: tj:-::, f_:O)

Ii, 1990{p1t-¥1i£J.~O)::.t-CLt.:o

1¥ffflt~J /ilO)T("1&1:, f.&t.: 'ti± B ,$:O)if® ~-r-7 t Lt.=iilfi4<

~{i':jiljj L J: 1 t L -Cv' i Lt.:o ,f-0)~ 8 ;,t;:O)m,Jt:;t1tl:i31t,-c, >li0t >Ii

llt1:Jl¥.J, ffi36, i?'-::JiliJr~tj:51-!Jltl:nx.t.:tPG-c.'·-to Ln'L, ::.O)!t®I±

A#;,,,-lJ--n'G >Ii /!!JOOO) tl:l!tli~H,t:, 11:,~IJ:t:~ 5 I<::. t i?' ft L i?'0t.=o i

t.:, 1 ~ Jv-'7'1 · 71-l:! ✓ 1/.1.:$11 ✓ J 1il (1988{p) ,:m< {i':@t L -C, ~~IJR

0),- rt 711v1-0):;lcffl.lwiil~4<Ht@ L n,t.=O)c."Tn', ::.ntna:

Session Il l 149

~f:;Jf!HJ_tff-CL f 1,,f Lt.:o ~1'} El :!f Ii.:-:, Lt.:7' • 1/.:i:.:7 H:t,J-L-C

li-::>~IJ t/.it-tli L f:tiJ,0t.:(J)c:TiJ{, io-f G< i t.:U:ffifr Ht7.> .:t

1: Al.~~~~ L -C 1,, 7., r:p, .:(J):u':@i Ii ;J;i i 1J 1: 'I:, ;,<-=c 1J 7 Jv(l(J 1:,\!tx.t.:(J)

't''L-d o -fnc:'i:,, fi!!.(J)~4(J):u':@ilimv'-C'.j/UJlLiLt.: o ~1JJ(J)'i:,

(J)fi 1985if:8fl 1:rr:bnt.:/Jlt:lfM'.iT 40mlif: Hc~T 7.,§:fi~c:, t&::lfi

~t.: t ,: J: 7-> Mi lisy(J)icffi HcTff.iiil!!i t F • -1 :,,:7'~ /.t ,lfl;-'fif•Jtft~:,,

:$'- iJ,G .:loft' IJ L -c §:~Li Lt.:o 10 > 1 ~ 1,,:;t:~: 4 A (J)l!IJ §: (l 9861t)

WwWtB ::,js:(J)~Jl;f:-:::i1,,-c(J)11ir<, M*!:t§:fi~-c-Lt.: o 11 > -f L -c 1988

if:~ti,nv-~ft~-•t(J)~-~J:7.,¥~~~@~§:~MMLiL -,,. 12 ) 1~ 0

~GI: 11Hfif~J §:{~, ;fi.lt.:tli-f(J)!/;illsyif.:Jt1ti'itlfll(J)JiE~iJ,G@

1S[r:p t.:0t.:r:p l!lc:io~ n,7.J:Jii.ti-%-t<"I:~ x.iif:i&") i Lt.:o LiJ' Lxtit

~ C 1)-:::i 17, 1f:i':~ ~:i!T 7., f: lillsyfai iJ{iJ,iJ, IJ i Lt.:o l 9861'f:(J) r:p l!!Jt ?'/ •,I. ✓~

1t$N:3:~(J) ;t:7 7-. 7:t- FlJJrp, IHf~Ef(J't''li;l;i IJ i Lt.:iJ{, -f (J){~(J)jil;

~li:Y/:t iJ'0f.:(J)'t''T o -f (J) ra11:ffi L v'il:tft(J) 7-T1 7. r iJ{mniif:i&"),

1iUi(l(J ,: 1u:Jli: (J) :R'li:F9J.t:ti(J)* ~ t:t m:~~:ti-r- r r:p ooffiri¥r~~r J m:

t L -C, Htl!:(l(J f:t,'j!:~ilJ!!JW(J)u\Iff,T(J) 1989if:lffef:~1r ~ n i Lt.:o .:(J)i)J!

!JWiJ{lfil:J:0-CiJU± ~n7.>t, l!!i1lllrntoo fir:j:100 c(J)Jtft(l(J:".x:ifiEHIHsl''t''

~ l:t < l:t I) i Lt.:iJ{, -f n <: 'I:, l:t io;fi.lt.: tli'ttJfJl·JJX~ t 1)-lj---f-~ mlH

Lt.:o 19921tic:f:OO~tt'i~li!'f}t~~~JJ--tt, f'Hf':u':il!!iHIJlLTT

,l/)"(1,,7.,t, t,dt"-f(J)lisy, ,"(Jl,,lJ:,,(J)-jjj:~Jt1t~•H111,¢.i:f:, F1o/

t ;t 7 :,,7"' (J)-f--A 'I:, lliJ t::. J:-:, /:t 7' • 1/ .:i:. :7 r f:J& 1J ;j\[/v 7:1,, 7., t IIl-1 ~ i L

t.:o ;J;itGc:liiJ;i7., J!!ii$(J) r:p OO-liJf~(J)~- A~iJ,W,J:b0-CV'7.>(J)t:i!ilv',

flt.: t1i r:p OOiJ--f (J)fi!!.(J) oo (J)mft~~n t"-:, WJ~ L n, 7., iJ,1: 'i:i0t IJl!.

~iJ,;J;i!JiLt.:o ~Y(J)7f'ti:~~t::.l:tiJ%'i:i, ioKHti:;1JL-fH.:t1:#c

~ L, -f(J)~*' 1--'1 o/1lt1Jc: rr:pOOffiri¥r~~rJ ti,,-:, TLfG L v'n7' • :7"iJ{

/±1/:oc ~fl i Lt.:o 13> §:fi~-f(J)t,(J)f;l:n:$' • :7"/it"~Uizf:!i; Iv 't''liioG

i', 1980if:f-\AJJjjj:{J;}.*(J)~9:Ef(Jf:]i~/:tf'Fo"ii ~?j'J;,-:::l-:::it,;Js::17' · 7-

r ,:~,¢.i: ~ ;J;i-c-t ~?.: ~Gi,,iJ{;J;i IJ 1 u.:-.:n1i-gf 1J El (l(J(J)-'f-v 7

1J-iJ,5AK!ffi L:iit&")n,t.:Mr/iJ<: Lt.:o .:(J)t.:&"), 1993if:l:;fi.lt.:tliT

<· rr:p OOffirm~~rJ m: 1:m <men~ 1ffil-iJ,1:ti:t,1v-¥-: r:p l!i(J)ffi L "'

~~f J l:iov'-C:E'v'filf-\';(J)f'J:,~U.:tl:J: 7->1:,, 7-.7' v-:,, 3:,, t-it1 r · 7-.

-« 1/ 71 o/ :7 f:tftifb ,: ii§ Li Lt.: 0 14 > .: (J) men~,: J: 0-C Ii t::. &")-C 7-r-f·~✓ -h:.. ✓ ·4!✓ ~ - ?:s.. ✓ Y ;'l'?✓ · ?:s..-(,t;y;,, - a;,,l!:,,?;,, N- 1' ;,, 1/ - 1/7 ✓ './;i;,, 1' / · :J:s..r -'r;,,

~~5i, lit~, 'tl-Jt:il, liMw, filidv!(, 3::@-m, ~}t1-I[, -fL -C~t;!iifiJ{

.:(J)Jt!l/Rc:~~r• 1:m:~ ~n, -tn: - ~iut(J)!Jl!.~~lltcf'~.: L, ~

150 Session Ill

:!! IO

••~--~~~,~~a-1~v* l~NHK1J'~lilf't'/Jj/:til.., ,:O)!J0l~ O)t,;JaV/:.l..tc . ll,!i,'.~0)/!I/~• (I985i!' ) Ii, *000)>!\ti:s-tt11vtJ'1 ~9~*00~~ • !h~/:.-~~C( l... ~(O)A .. t,<.:h1:t,tvc&: :lN! IIJ~fi -c,tc.

lit I I

M. Holborn, Black Sun.· Th, Eyes of

Four (Ml!iI~-Z;,, Jf!~mil!fl, ~ilia'}

1A. ,l'j_llJ):i1'iO)j'J,,f/, ~-;';-tr ) , New

York, Aperture, 1986.

J. Noth, I. Poehlmann, K. Reschke

[eds], China Avant~Garde, Berlin, Edition Braus/Haus der Kulruren

der Weir, 1993.

:!!14

D. Elliott, L. Mepham, Si/mt Energy:

New Art From China, Museum of

Modern Art Oxford, l 993.

iRltt3

~~~►~~-~~••~•~~~ i~,t,,,t,,c,)£~:i'.1:-?""n'<> , j/lJ;,.I!,

bloom ll:§JJ\iillll,"1.',Eil'l#HE-t J.> ~I:: >t­

;:< L, ~~"1.'arms>t-rKi!li·tti:/JJl::ilx nl!, ,(;;r't,'/7~ll1~1i,!:!1iHlr,1'1

-t oJ: 11: r 0J,1:im~m:t1tiJ 1::w.1t

;.,, iL bloomingb''i:11,'!1\iillll:1

'1'')7-~i!i;iii bloody~ftb~l:fi/!bll.

J.>tcn, '¥'!Jl!t"t;~1:w.m-t11.1t rw

at~11.~~~J1::t~n;., , t~0~

r<E'ill ~ blooming~::k!JiamsJ I:: 'l':tl! 1:;:/ltr~l::b"l'1'0 ,

ll115

D. Elliott, G. Tawadros [eds], Heri

Dono, INIVA, London/Museum of

Modern Arc Oxford, 1996.

ll116

7 '!7 ~!ll.ft;1elli~JJU'l~il'W>o-C

1Ji11llic'11.tc~ll:, 1980if., JillJ,lrn'.le lliJ!lll:t;,,-cc',t,01 , -f~li>21el~

il:1985if.l:, -fL-C1999if.~li>51el

7'l7'));lli~il'!i'l l lnJli\lJ,l7'l7~lli

r•J.:r.;;7-v"-l::l'Hlhlt ;:<11. -Cfrb

11.tc,

1!117

~~ = ".'.>~~fl~l::ll:, r 7 'l 7 / 7/.

•J'/J :!J!Jt7 'l 7;fs7:f.'J'/JA~7-r

1:;1;1t J., 717'✓T1T1 J ~ (1994if.) ,

-rL-c r •:ir1"•"X1r""•"X: 7'l7~!J!ft'l<lliJ~ 0996if. ) "1.',t,

J.>, tHrll:71::-t-;;•>r---lJ"°"-.,-;;

~:.tJ.:i.::f- .1 V-:.13 ✓o

ll118

John Clark [ed]. Motkrnity in Asian

Art, Sydney, Wild Peony Press, 1993.

:l'<T/ , :3:,,~:,,

ibid~0),{:,,;7.)'v-1/3 ✓ {JHIO 0)- frll-Z:3'.>~ 77 ')Jvmt1:J-.n1:>nt.:

5 il!eO)~t2000il!e0)1,,->10)1\!'.Jfl7'.l{, lli.lJ~ 1:t-J--t M~/Mit:d'r~t-:t L..-c

~WifilH·1er~ l.J.:0)-z"To /iii,:1/1-7'.l'l:>O){'f,*tf±:J'J~T ~.¢.i:"'c'li, 7--Y-17-. r · ,{:,, · v:J-r:,,;;z.it

®7'.l{::t7 ;;z. 7:t- F:k"'t c -lj"·lf-:,, • 7--;; • 71 '7 :,,::,.., 1vO)W1n1t-z::frbn,

/KfiA~l±l.11i{H/:, H,IJ1'FT ~{'F*t.:i:>0)3lrf ~jjffil51: L.. 11..J.:o K.G.:7.

7•77 .::.,V :,,fi 1 ::t7 ::7. 7:t- t,'O)fij{/JUl!tli, {tl!.{'f,,R,J /KO) I±\ o"ii{'f-t--<.-C ~,

~ :t-°"-tj-'J:,, · 71v ,- :J-z"O) 3 n JI O)r,r,t£W! rai <=r, 4lf. 8 ~;j;j\j1J'iiO)i51,,:!{fO)

:;Rj,lll:3'.>~7-.1:J::t-z"flilJ{'FL.. -Cv'1L..f.:o :J37':J°"71Jv>10)-" ') · F/li,

;f'tcJE;/j 1:,, t,',t,::,..,7 O)~/n'. ~-Y--7 t L.t.:ffil/K 17·11,- ~ :,,7· · 1:,, · 7

-1,.,;7. (Blooming in Arms) J il!ll3l 0)$frllO)f.:!6, ]l[;t77-. 7:t- t,'O)i51,,

I~"'c' 1995/96~0)~~flj1]1'f,l:tt~L..1 L.t.:o ,sJ .:,O))K~~li{'F*O)

1).mJi,),1:,0)*£® t1:,, 7-.>' 1,,- ::,.., 3 :,,O)~#c~t t g"? «~tO)·C ;1-7'1

7t-•M*0)~~~1:>:k~tj:OCW~m1L..~~~0)3'J190)0CW~

I:> 7'.l'1:,, t,',t,::,..,7:,k1\!'.1J'ii0){-t*~7'.lq•lf · 11.b.;,; J ~O)ic.$-~ El 1: L.. -c M~l:IDJ;h,, ~0)1&, 1!HJil:lct1H: IUIT ~ 1:;;fiEli'ft;/j*mJ -Z:3'.>~C L.. -C,

~>' □ ~~•*-t~l-JK1erl..-C~1L..~ o ~0)~**~1~1 ✓ Ft::,..,

7tEtt-r·3'J-::,t.:t.:!6, Mlffe L.. -c ~O)t~1t .i3~!6~.:.tt tj 91 L..t.:o

7 :17-7'.l'f:!!;,\':i: 1: tj 91± l.'.-!6 t.: 0)-z"T o 1/ll F,liJ -r·i± 19so~ft0)1JJ !6 7'.l' i:,

ltx~1¥.H: 7 :170)7- r 0)\1,4]1:t L..li l.'.-.161 L..t.:o 16l 11.:, ~~lit.H:

7:J70)fij\~ ~ Jll:.¢.i: 1:: t v'"?blt"'c'li;/ji,),-::,f.:O)-z"T7'.l', 1987~1:li

~ - @1 ;;z.7:,,7·-1v • J!.:r.:,,-j--v7'.l{lffl1ltr~h1L..t.:o ~L.. -c 1990~{-t

1JJ !6 7'.l' i:, *t~i¥J tjlli!J ~ 7'.l-ilt 191 To 1992~, rf 11/-\' 71·-r-tj-17'.l{.::. .:i

-3-70)7:17 · :;-lj".:r.-r1-1:.i3v'-C, 7:17 ~:11!!0);\'-.:i v11-~~

!bt.:7 '7:,, F · -y--7·;1,~{tjjljj L,t.:0)-z"To .:.n~~-::,7'.l'ltl:~ < O)[J!l~

~1,l'tJJ!O-C 1±\~v', °1'0 7·7 J,.,1&1: 7:17 · :J-lj" .I.7,-(-"'c'li = -:JO))K~

~7'.l-m.Jilli ~h1L..t.: o ,n 1993~1:;/j~c, f 1J;;z.r-;:-:,,-z:7:J7:t:SV:itm

{-t~Wi r').I. ✓ -j-- v7'.l'ila19, Iii]~ 7:J70)-t:$>'-=--Y-1-0)jll!]li*7'.l{1JJ

!6-C l±l~~h1L..t.: o'8l 11.:, 1990~1:1±Jfi:J?:-z"OO~?x:iilE£~1: 7-1::

7:,,Jt{t: ✓1- (1995~7:J7-1:::,,1-1:&ft) 7'.l{fill:1l.~h1To m1-t7

:J7~ffi9MO)ft&#::t-:7.r7~7t•M~1:>fflfl~n,1).•••0)

*~711 • ~7'.l-l±l~~n, 11.:, m1-t7:J7~*rlK~~7'.l{~•7:1nt

00, 3-0,-1{, ~L..-C7PJ71-z"blffi-fltr~h-C~1L..t.:o .:.-JL..t.:m~t~

;h,0)~,7;.l±\T-r1 ;;z.::i-:7.lii!!J'i!,<=pO) :t-.:i v11-t.:i:>l::~t'l! ~ 3'.>t.:x..,

Session Ill 151

7:J7:lt!!~~,ftf::;t.J--t 7.:>~~f:::,js:~O)W,:{t~~ Li Lt..:o A4 ;¢tJ!.IJ;/i: ~ t,-::>J:: -31:: >:;i:-::,t..:IDEWel"To

~ L <Jlt]U:: lm~~:/1,7.,~**rfrgO)f!ii¾c L ·c ;fltl:.:::.::: 1 :'tf:W-..t

7 :J 7 l"~ G L t/J 1,,·u, i Lt..:o 4-, fl fi t.-3- JilJ]IJ 0) b Gt::, HJ: 1,,·c

4-i l"fiii < ;¢, G W~cl6-C 1,, t..: t.:. ltO) t, 0) 0) pgg~" c ~ -::,-C ~ t..: 0)-z'T o

;flfi B :,Jl:l"*Wrf!ii Hf's'T 7.:> ..t l"~ L H.lt¢.i: ~ ~ 9 J,.:/1,7., c iulll;f f::,

:f!((4 >::i::lt!!~Jt1tbtf!-t 7.,.::: c UIH;y~:/'L -cv, iT o -f L -c .:::n.:::-f-;¢\

icm,::~7.:>~"et:i;;~t;'H:Jt-t 7.:>.:::ccct.,::, flO)i!Jim:~ El 1¥Jc>::i:9iL.1:

"?o 2003Sf-O)f}(, ~L<::t-7°:---t7.:>.:::0)*Jrfrgli, Jlt7:J7.t3J::C:t]lt

m7:J70):7 1;.x.17'-t..:-t,::c-::,-c, OO!lAfj$aA..0)1JH.f;t&c>::i:G;/;l.1I>::i:

9i-ttlv o ~G>::i:7.:> El-fil~~f::-::>lt7.,t..:cl6f::, it..:, ltH!tJ'i!.cO):'x:iJ!E

Hlt-t t..: cl6 I::, :ffl.1-\';0)Jt{tf::-::> 1,,-cO) J:: 9 liin'l" ::7 1J-r1 tnv >::i: -r1 ;;z. :i

-;;z.~~l;./:1:1 ~>:;i:lt:/'Lli>::i:9i-tt lv o

-f L -cfU..:-t ,:: 71 -;1 r -t 7., .x. vt.r :--r l"1ll! t,± i t..::i§l:-::, t..: :tJ-;1 t-0) _;{ :¥

:--;¢,~ -t1vt ~ ,::1-HtG nt..:c~, .::: nn,G:,Js:~ ,::t··-3 rv A 7-;1 -:t-t 7.,

0);¢, ~ El 53-t..: -t l"i/ccl6 7.:>.::: c ;¢t-z'~ 7.:> 0) -z'To 11(1£4)

152 Session Ill

J,(!t4

.:.:-e1HH·e,( dress (~/tit-!,) I: address(~JlU;:1:'1:,M,Ht<>.:I:) ;, ,Ht-C1Jl;/ll L ,s,-!,/:.\l!,b;/1.-!,f:~,

,b;t_ -c r i'v;,, 777' JI: ~I Lt: o

7 /""t'JV·t"/::r..7.::.

Anmol Vdlani

Y:1/-=E Jv · "f:r.. 7:::.. 1:,, r'ilffi:SC1tlltl'llllll<:G

fU:t~,jf~5J'llltl:;Js1,,·c '** ~;/1.,7., 7:l7 ; *a ~;h,t;i:1,q:J7 J 1:

--::J1t,·Ott7.>¾Jit~*-!~~:j;yi:,-g-;b-tt-Cv't;i:v'o ~s~,Wj0)5J'lffl:.Blt

7.> 1*a ~n7.,1:,,1-· 1*a ~nt;i:1,,,{:,,J-" J ~~~-t 7.>.:./:: ~.:UllL<, 1

t.:!llf,t,ltJ-t~· 7.>/:: {,-g .:z.7.>o flil".:..:.-r-mf/i t7.>~s~Wr t,i, i,i:,i:>lv1

:,, J-"O)-f;h,l:-?1,,-c-z,-Ji>IJ, 1l!!0)7:J7itoo~~lc7:J7 *O)i,0)-r-,it:t

1,,0 ,f.:.-c-, ,{:,,J-"i)'>/::'O)J:11:•iF~h, J1>7.>1,,,i::f;(£l:t;i:I'), -fL-C,

**~;h,7.,0)i/'l:-?1,,-c-g&-t7.> o it.:, fll:.!c;-.:z.C:,ht.:13::~HI<-t

7.>t.:¥>, ~-a~wr~NJt1: "'.)1,,-c-r-,it:i:<, •ti.1 ✓ J-"O)i.~r1J1H:;Js,t 7.,*

aO)rp9JHi~ It<~~ L -c1,,~ t.:v' o

-f n -r-,i, 1:,, F O)ij{JJijO) 't' "t", 1:,, F,i /::'O) J:'? I:**~ h n, 7.> 0)

t!. i:>'? il' o it.:i1il:JJU00i1ir ~=fffl-lt 7.,~f_m.:r.-:J .r..:,, Hi/::'O) J: '? 1: ~ :b

0·n,7.,0)f!. i:>'? il' o .:.O)rp9H:~ .:z.7.> 1:,i, = -?O)jg,Fj ~t.:-C-C~fil

""9 7.,.:./:: i)'>'ffj<JJ-Z,-Ji)i:,')o ii\ lfif}H: 1U (._t/j{) ~;/1.,7.,ij{JJIJ/U (_t

im) ~nt:i:H1il:JJUJ 1:-?1,,·c $l.lJt1,,wi,~~1:t-tL-cJ;~::t.JO)J1>7.>Ail­

mtt:i: O)i),~fiE L -C l;-7.,«-~ "t"Ji>i:>'?o 1{7,t-71/ 7. · '1'v-1:f 1/:$'-/:: 7.

,ts:,,-it-,i-5!1!Ef0)1Ji!2., 1llli®:~~lf, Wl,~0)1<\:'t'r, il;J.,Hi-0i1ir-t

7.> 1Js¥0)::i:,,7:7;;z. J-H!l!E1H:- !l'f5£0)/j{JJIJ%~H!Hl Lt.:l'J, ntl L

t.: l'J-t 7->ffifoll:Ji>l'J, -?17.>/::.:.;s, IIJH:*a (...ti1ir) ~h7.>iUUl:-?v'

-C {, lli]~O).:. u,-g .:z. 7., 0)-c-,i t:t 1,, t!. iS '? il' o it.:, '1'v-1±:,,1-~ ;;z. ,ts

✓ -it-#0M-t7.>Ma-r-*•~;h,7.,,{1/F~-~O)J:1t:i:a~-r-•iF~

;h,, Ji> 7., Hitf!Ji!ilj ~ ;/1., -C 1,, 7., O)f!. i:, '? il' o

'/x1:1{7:t-71/7. · '1'• -'E-1?-~'1'v-1±:,,11-1:J:0-c:st~c ~n-c

1,,7., i1il:JJUm:tJH:-?1,,-c~M-t 7.> £-~il'Ji>U!. iS '?o m~,i, ,{:,, J-"O)i1if

JJIJ0)1.ffoltt, pg~, -fL -C;/f;AO)J;.t:J:G-f, ~i1ifitO)~,WrltJ71T:,,-:r1

-:r11: {, ~~ ~ &ti'-tiJ,t;, t!.o .:.0)11!!1: {, i1il:JJIJil,~f.t L n, < iu,O)i:;

:l:llltl~~l:-?v'-C~~-t 7.,£,~il'Ji> 7., t!. iS '? o /:: v''?O) {,, -f .:.1:,ii1ir

/JU B!i L -c*a ~;/1.,7.,,{:,, F/ *a ~;h,t;i:1,,,1:,, r'"--O)IJ~iJ,Ji -C~;h,7.,

iJ, {, L nt:t 1,,iJ, G"t" Ji> 7.>o

Session 111 I SJ

= :ffi: El O)fJi:illf$~1±, ~~1t1:~~"t"ifi>J.io t1,,-j0){)1{7,t--;,:,,7- ·

-:11,,-1::,,7-~ 7-,ts:,,--it-,±, iH1J El ftiJ'*~ L-J: -3 !:: -t 1., 1:,, 1--··J;J_J'l-O)

1:,, Ff*~-t 1.>.::.t,±"Z"~t.:1,,iJ,Gt.:.- 'il-l:,-7:)lv, ~ilii1i#;;iJ{~iEli'fi

"t"ib-:d-: IJ, ~iYiT J.,-:i :,,.,.-7 7-)--0) g:,-z,*~0)1,tt;;iJ'filElll ~ ;h,J.,tJJJ'g-

1±-f O)lil IJ"Z"l±JJ:v'o it..:, JL~O)ijijv,ili{jlH±, m~,:~J;t-t U.:.lt"t"

,±t.: c 1{ 1--• ✓ ~x•~O),g-~ 1:il-v-tl:-cfi)li)J-t 1.,.::.1::, 7-1r,, 1--i::

t.:Hll.'&l~H=il-:b-tl:-c ,w.J~J -t 1.,.::.1::, ifi>J.>H±OOO)x~c89t.:i&mft

i!ilJ, ilrnt- 71T✓ T1T1 U~~ J T 1.>.::.!:: ""-0)/±1:JiJ,;,j,iJ,J.,o

V-!::-:> El O)~r.iE¥~f :IH~-t 1.,1:ibt..:IJ, t.&1±1:,, FfM12S l n,

1., 7°v-lf:,,7-~ 7-,ts:,,--it-t g:,,C.,1:• il1fuf Mlm lt..:v' o Jl.1*891:1±,

(1) ~r,11'.i1:*, (2) 1:,,F0)1:,,7'1~:,,j':,,)--•7.x.7--r-11{;1,,3:.'flii~, (3)

i&JtL -fl -c (4) :lt!!1fO)Jtf~tlHJ!l"Z"ibJ.io

(l)~FJJ'.i1:.

1:,, )--'O) l::1/.'f,7-1±4lc,±, ~Wf f@:*m.llJJ-t J., it;)li)JiJ,1±4lci1tllikl:t.:J.,

!::l±~tl l n,t.:1,, 0 -f-O)f-t:blJI:, -;,--7.,.-,1:,,7·-f-t):Ht-::i-C !U!t:4lc

~~a~Wf, ~Wf~~o/7-""-tbiittl n,1., 0 '.i1:•tl -c,±1;(-1/f~

m.-t 1., g:,·c /7 ✓ F:1J~91f~O)li!!G~0)- :11n L--c~i~iti)li)Jtxm L-n,

J.>0)-z", ~r!.'it.:iJ,G, ~~~n~-tc 1,p-:>~~1:JO)j(~1,,, -Vfi1L~n

t..:<J;;~t.: 1~11&1:flti-t J.i:lt!!fiLl:ifi>J.,J ~#f0)1fifxml~Tv' o ~Wf1

«:., 1--~7°• 7"7 A""-O)ffitt,±, xmiti[Wf illi l -C, i!liu'1i0)7-7,-1--!::

t.:J.i U'&tffiltr.::. ct 3:.t..:J.i El 89 !:: l n,1., 0

'.i1:.;6{:lt!!1fiYi1'U~, ~:fifit.::lt!!1fgl!H:J:J.,~lH-tiYi1'U txm-t 1.,.::.1::

~8-z"ifi>J.io l~lt.:#G,~~.::.t~a4lctt~J:J.i~B•""-O)xm0)

ll\BI: ,±*v' o - RJ¾:891:1±:M~:lt!!3:.~0)t.: .::.·9 t.:. !:: Ji!. G hJ.i :!RJMU 1:1±,

i&JffiJ,GO)xm,±~<:I\Jll¥-z"~t.:1,,o 1:tiiJ,tP:bG-f, '.i1:*;6{xm-t1.>

--~~m~ - i!li~~tj:J.,~G"t"ifi>J.io ~~.::.~~aOO~O)'.i1:.~,

Eltt~o"li f 1:n,fillj!fm~'ili'.-=f-;(7--(7"-Z,'.ftf~T 1.,.::.1:: ;,j{~ t-Gn n,J.,t..:lil),

:!RJ!1'H± 7°Vi 7 A 7'7:,, Fl:.S-. ~:bl 1,,$ BI~ ~-tl: J., .cf-~!:: l -c J.;. t.:

~;h, "(1,,J.,o

l~lt.:#G,~.::..::.O) • il1fu~fil-::i-Cil1f/i-fJ.,~~A~,'.i1:-#7-;ts:,,

--it-!::t.:-::it..:~1:/::'0)J:-jt.:iYiflJ f tol'&l:lrillt-C*~T J., '/pc 1,,-j .¢!."Z"

ifi>J.,o jy{jljf:,iHtJ.,'.i1:.thi,ffO), Jlll:~O)f7ijf~~l,"(J.;.J:-jo ~~0) 10

fl 22 B, UB 7·;v-7°0)-;,7 )--'ry.x.Jv;¥,,\::;t\4l;W±, 1ttil89i\ilififfit.: '717--:\'-

154 Session Ill

'Giving theatre the Signature touch,'

The Asian Age, Ocrober 23, 2002.

'Audiences look forward to unique

entertainment,' Bangalore Times,

Octobe, 24, 2002.

-077 ✓ FT~or1/~T7¥-J0~~HL~. -~0-•a0A#

✓-it-c,j:ol\t®t~*Lt.: o r·lf · 7:J7✓ · .:r..1-:/J ~0iclH:J:hff,

r-;,:7 F".liJv0iJiiJJIJgi),, 1!1107iAT1 ;{JvcJ/i,j:o0fi. · · · i!IP-10

-15-'ll~m·e · · ·1m0tt'l!111!10i~mu Hltrt-t o.=.u,or~1:,j:oev'-J.:.c

t-:J 1 > C~O o r J{ ✓ ;ffO-Jv · 111.A J ~01 ✓1 l!.:z.-0J:P"c'UB :7·1v

--:10ii!li~J11,tnJIB1-t*T~o".f1:Ji1 · v-.:r-.B:f±. 1{ ✓ :t1 □ -1vTOO

11iU.!-h.t.:* 7iAT1 ;{Jvl:-?v'-C, r .4 ✓ 1{10~ffli0i9fHiiJ ~.:. .:.0ftj!

:&f:Ji!,-ttot.:il6J2 > c~,-Z"(l,>o o

v-.:r-.B:fi r*ffli0i1iffljj i){ r*i';'li0:/JHUIJJ ~:tf.~T ocW~NL -C

1,,,j:1,,0 1m~0~c.!J:I.Tt, U.: • .:.0_m~,j:~ft1:Mn n,,j:1,, 0 v-.:r­.B:f±.L. ✓1{1il't!t-W-T1lft- . 4-?0 N~!- ~kJ!01!!1. -;,7--r1-~!.

:7":J¥7- J, ii!. -f L -Cl:: ✓ -r1-g{l--T.:i:.t-:--::>t.:i~fljftilfr)Ji),fi:bh -C

v'o'll~mt-=cv'-J.:.c 1-r·fHDG,j:1,,c L -ct,. A ✓ 1{10:fJl.f-ti~JJ1J0-g

g!iJ,:/J'ft!t-:ft-r·fi ,j: 1,,.:. cf±~it L -C v'o t-: 0-Ja tJ 7::>lv. tl!Hi.L. ✓ 1{

1T-0i1ir~ho~i'€/i0i~jlji){, £·-fL'i-,:/J'fiiUIJ-r·f±,j:1,,.:_ct,%1--:::,-Cv>

ofift-: o

LiP L,j:iJ{G. v-.:\'- .B;:01/!lift~ ,j:~ -gf:M L -c. 1Biil'M~c To W!

:&iJ,m1¥1 ~3J<:il6o.:.c i, ,j:1,,f_: 0-Ja r 1/:7.77¥- J i~JJrJg t Ji!,I:* o

A4 0ficlvc'fii,c t, c:/J'f~UJ LiJ,Ji!.,j:1,,lJ!:&~ t.=iJ,Gt-:a 1Blil'1!110

-gJml:J:oi~JJIJ ~~~~L -r:1,,t,, D:&0~Jlllttilf~0i:p 1:t,t,ct,c-f0

J: -J ,j:i1ifHiiJ0f?ttil',j:1,,0-r-. W!:&l:-f 0~~ H!Gno.:.cfi,j: v'o

.=.n~>i!.~*oB:&~.:/J'fR~~0 -gffiTfi:bnoMa0u~•mH

J: rf'l!~m0:fJl.~il'Gfi r,JJ ~--~nt.:t!t.W-1:~-t o B:&~ t-:il'G t-:a :/J'ft!

jr]f±. -f 0p;J~ (It <f±i§ifi~JJIJ) ~*~f: Hv>-C, .:.0.1:'J,j:B:&01'±

~Ef{J,j:M,_n: Lt.:.n:~~ &~ L H'o o -'chfi. 1oT-f h~:$7l-0i~HiiJil'

1 ✓ Ff:fif?tE L -c1,,,j:1,,iJ,0J: -J T~o a

:lt~A#✓ -it-fi, M~ c,j: o B:&~ f:ir:b-tt-Cv'oil'G.:.-f • .:.0

.!:'J ,j::niiT:;'flm!:J:oi~JJIJ ~*~ -r·~o o Y//ilEf{J f: -g .zff. 1JllGfiB:&

il'[l!l,C.•~:M°-?*~f:ir:i&Lt.:i~HiiJ t-f011A#✓-tt-c L -C*~ L-C

v'o a :lt~il'-'c0J:-J,j:filf!JJ~co0f±~<l:~L,j:v' o ~mHJllGfi. 13 u•~~-~Tofflft~0-~cMMt-~T~ilO~~-~x-L-C

v'o0T~o a

Lil' L • .:.0J: -J,j::fJl.~filt <- NJ!'.Ef{Jl:Ji!,~ftGhoi,0,j:0f-:0-J

il' o 1£~A#✓ -it- ~~01✓ F0i~jrj 7'v-1±'✓1-i, U.:, Jill:&0~11

1:xffc ~ n,j: n'G. c··0 .1: -J ,j:i~JJrJ ~0i1ir L. u.: c·0 .1: 'J 1:**-t o 0

less ion Ill I 55

7H:·#(:Jt L -n,,7.,0)f.:017'.P? 7-7'-1 7-Hi lol1!H:~lt :!ll:JJ:0 ·C m J-JJ,1:~iJ+~:ttJJ:il{Gft.fa H·!Jft L, fto"ii ~1:<~ L -c1,,,7.,0)t! 01il'? fi;

~ili{f!Hi, 1JiiGO)fi:1'<1fil{*IJ~l;l.t.:H:~ x..7.>l«~/~H:Mr,t L -c, ~~

iE ~n-c1,,,7.,0)t! 01il'?

(2) 1;,,-r1-"';,,7;,, r · 7:r..7-f-11{Jv0)3:-fi1f

taff{N'/W, !fl 1v"f 1;,, f-'O)~iuu ~sttli" .ot~"t.:il{, u-t ~t-=

ltf?ljj'j.;6{il;7.,o if:~li, 1;,,7'1-"';,,T;,,rJJ:7-f-17- r · :'.lJv- -;1';6{3:

iii" 7-> iJi~ -gllifO)iU!J0iJi{O) ib 7., iJirf1J~1: t W,* L -n,, 7->o .:'.:O) J: 1 JJ:

7:r..7-7'-11,Jvli/!~IH!O)@.~~* I) ~l;I., ;)-r17"t't>:k~< tlkb:tL.o

f.:ht)if:~b ~{, ~*-It 7.,0)"f il;.oo

1 ✓ F-z.'•Jt)tlli¥Jl:lfflii ~n.o1 ✓ T1-"' ✓ T✓ rili{f!J~li = ~L ;(/>JJ:

v'o U-t ~Ii A ✓;{,{ 0)7'l)r 7 ry'1-i1&flj~"t', 199Oif:fi:l=~-:i!l:tt §

~mh6, 4-L'·li4iif:1Tb:tt7.>J:1l:JJ:0-CV'.oo i!sJl:t±, f\l!O)'!l~m"-~

imT 7.,.: t ti ii; 7., o .:'.:O) 7:r.. 7-f-11, JH: - :et Lt.:tt1% ti 7J: v'o ,f O)llsJ 4

1:: J: 0-C, ii; 7., :lt!!:n 0)0ilil Hlk 0 t.: IJ, ~00 v ".7':r.. JvO) t 0) Hlih t.: IJ L

-c1,,,7.>;(){, 3- • :;,;{0)i~f!Jliil'IJ~!i'-f~ Lt.::¥ ~x..ib.oo ~00 v".7':r..Jv

O)iJifJi!J HJB if: 1: Ii, 1;,, Fi~f !J il'~F'lil" l: ~Ii\J! < ,m-f)-~ :tL.oo f71J x..l!

1997:¥ 1:1±, m~ -gt{fl:J:7.,~~JJ::ffl.fi:ililf!J ~ .. .ti~ L, ~itliffi~ Rn~ f!Ji"t' ..l.iJirLt.:o t1U-c~O)i~fl j~O){?Uli, -::J!vM' (-JJ!v-JJ:;,7) 0)-j­

✓ 7'1 -JJ!v OOF:iliff!J~"t', Jl1J1f J: IJ "i!i°v'il{:JilHJUi1J, ~ v'o l 98Oif:fi: J: IJ

mif:, :lt!!n O)il; 7., ilif f lj 7'Jv- -;1';6{::J::ii1f c 7J: I), 1;,, F ~:lt!!O)jjjlj ~ Ii

t::h6, llsJ 1: lim 71/7 O),f\l!O)!tfOO O)i~f1J ti ,m-f)-L -n,, 7->o

= ~0)7:r..kr1 J{Jvl±, ffi;ii,Q t,il;7.,;6\ j¾@,QO)(i '? ;(/{f/:fti*v'o

1;,, Fl:iHt 7., 1 ;,,-r1-"';,,7;,, r ijf lj~~f-:ttl:~T 7.,t,O)li, f-:tt-'f

:ttWJJ:7.>§1¥JO)~h6~#~T.oo Mx..~aW~GMm~:tt7.>~.fa~

0iji" 7.,.:t1:J:0-C, &Wil{fJE;z7.,1;,, Fijf !J 1:tttfi:LJ: 1ti" 7.,~..g­

tibU!-01 0 it.:, ;)1;,,7-r ')-AO)ijf lj"fl±rniil':rtlJ:v', !l'-fJtO)~

~~z:1:~,Q~ii;-Ct.:fto"ii~ ..l.iji" .o.:t tibU.:01 0 Lil' L 7' 1J h

':l'1-t-t;,,-r1-JJJvO)iJii § O)~<'..fnli, 1;,, Fijf!Jl:iHt 7.,!l'-fJt0)#1/

:,,3 ;,,~il;Gbi"blt"f tJJ:<, it.:, i1ii1'UW.1:!l'-fJtO) § ii<J ~t,0-C 1r}.. T 7.>.:'.:cl:~,C.,;6{il;7.,;/:;,lt"ft, Wlm!t.:7.> 717';,,f-17'-1 ~ffJL:T 7., ~

zi,/{il; 7., ;/:;, It "t' ti 7J: v ' o

ttlfl:c L -C, .::ttG0)7:r..7-f-1 ;{Jvliill!ITi 7J: 1i:pJtttJ ~il;GbT o 4i

if:, c"O) J: '? JJ:£.ij!\"t'!l'-fJtO)jlj ffi ~iJir § il'i<J"~il' G7!-~:tt -n,,7., O);(),li

I 16 Session Ill

i1i: l.., --C llfal G n'"l"ii 1d: P o 0i1ir (l)a~£$ ii, 91:;:iifs(l(J 1d: ::1 ;,,-t '1' r ~ 7.r.

7'T11,;t,~;{ef(l)~fij:,:~-::J<'ii(l)-z.'•ii1J:<, )Alljfilj(l)~'j'lj, jjlji!!](7)7.r.7-.

T1 J\Jv0i1ir-z.''(7) A~, 1iUJrf1c1: flOT J., • ::J ~ ffiffl1J:c'j,£$c1J:--::,"(

1,,, J.,o j-;,,-r1 n1vOON:i1irltlM(l) 7'1 v'.75"-,i, ~!ill,: bt.:0--Cfk ~JW

;IJ.--C ~--c 1,,,J.,n', m:lill 1 *ili:fnJn'"' 1,,,ftifii ~ Ji --Cv'IJ:"'n'? J t~;IJ.--c <J.,(l)"{"ifJJ.>o

l..,~L,,1;,,r(l)l17J:00(7)001i;';M~M"t"~if/i~a~-t'-'•~.::(l)l

11J:'l'lr"in,£$ t1J: J., ,:ii, 111tn,1;,, ritir!AlrJ c -f (l)U~,:-:::>1,,,--c, ffrim: t L, n,J.,~f!J:n,ifJJ.,(l)f-: 01 0 -fnii, ~1-\':ilir/Altl(l)ftJl~(l)::k~~ h1:i

¥JJ., 1;,, riW$'ffil(l)lf'im.llli'~n'U-c -:::>(l)~"Jt~~;fef L, n,J.,.::t o H.:,

1;,, riUUiiOOl;/;J"l",:Hi':ttJ't11t L, n,u.:¥>, -fn~m~,1<-·-t£-~ii

7J:v'C10CJ£l.., n,J.,(l)f-: o TiJ:b-1:,, im/AllJ HllHt-t J.,::1;,,777, rn'~:f!l'i

"t" ifJJ., ,: 'ii n'n'b GT, i'i&/Altl-f (7) 'ii (l)fi-f hfit'~tiR"l"fi 1d: "' t ~ x. --c

"' J., (7) t-:' ! ,::(7) l 1 IJ: 7.r.7-. f-11,1v(l)-r1 v75"-(7)9cAWlii, <b1J:n't,tJU~n'1J:

v>blt"l"fi 1d: v'o .:: .::-r·fi<b x. --cmllfal L, 1d: 1,,,t!(i4 (7):l!l[EIH: l l'J, 1;,, r(l)

liPtrru~1titir!AlU fi[li)'t'i"t" <b l'J, H.:fJO,C,!JH:-:::>v>--C Mi L,< ffiW L, n,

J.,!!sf~n'<bJ.,- 1;,, r,ic'(l)~:f!l'itl ~'ii-:::> oo ,: L, --c.:: nii~:B-n,:fii<

,-,z~.:: t t-:'o 1;,, r(l) 7.r. 7-. T11,Jv(l):i}jlif (l)~ < fi, ilffi 'b n'ffi--::,"Cv' J.>1111

llti, 1~m~m:~, .!ii~IJ:N:llti, i5Jl1!-Ef(_J1J:-if- ✓A'.7 1hr!AlU, ifJJ.,Hi.::(7)

00(7) lf'im.llli'~n'- ~(l(J ,:@:rm-t J., 1ffilA(l(J 1J:;; v ;,,-z~r"nm:£-:11,,,--c

"''-' o t&,:imJJIJM"l"i<#tl ~nJ.>1;,, rli, jjgl;/J.lf'im.llli'~n'~1'1T J.> 1;,,

r"t"ifJJ.,o -fl..,--C, :lt!l:l:\oc5.JIJ(l)~ i!~m:~, ::i'Cft(l)ill;H:l0tilZIJ~h

J., 71 f-';,,f-1f-1 (l)r"9~-r-1i1J:<, lf'im.lllr~ Hi - -t J.,fiffifi/!Wl~!!m~J.>

iliffij 1d: (7) f-:'o

1 ✓ r,:;t-Jlt J.>T,-,Z"((l)~fti1ir&liJn', lf'im.lll\'~(l)~~T J.,ttJ:Jjl~~ft

:tJ t ~ <'.l"-:::> 1,,,--c 1,,, J., b lt"l"fi 1d: v'o If',: Ii, El (l)jjlj (7)$:tli t ~ I') ¾!I_Jj,,

o-;iJJviJ:!\\_ll;1t, m:~, ~,C,$-, filWWlti*<~bJ.,ilifJ»rJ'li<bl'J, -fhi'it

,:-f(l)~;{ef (l)::1;,,77 7-. r(l)ftJl~,:f/iJltt.:ft~~:@\§'n', ~OOf/iJlt(l)-0

iml''li~bh --Cl, i1 o .::(l)l11J:i1ir&ltln'00Ri'UIJMf:~41fJ-;g-U.:t

l.., --C 'b, -f hli{/1.\~(l(J 1d: 1±1 ~op. ,:if\ ~·IJ: v'o 7.r. 7-. T11, Jv(l) 7'1 v'.77'

-Ii, -f (7) n lJ:0itir Ii, Wl~ ,:t 0--CX'f:l*~'& ~fH>IJ:\i'.::c ~ :l!l!M

L, --c1,,,J.,(l)"t", :tt:lll'~-t J.,.::t 'ii iJ:v'o i&G(l) IMJ,C,,i, 1-6l't1J (7)0il HJtijt

T J.,.:: t-c-<b I'), U~,: 1ffillIDtJ l..,1J:lthlinli:1L L, 7J:v'0im ~ Ji-It J.>.::t

"t"liiJ:v'o ~ H~x.J.>IJ:G, 1&Gli1;,, ritirJ»tl(l)lf' ,:<bJ.>:W~(l)~IJ:J.>

Session Ill 157

(3) i&ltf

1 ✓ Fi&ltfti1 ✓ FMa0A#✓~-T~~t~~~~v~✓7-Tb

~~ a 00.ll.itiVIIJst13<'. (NSD) l±Jt1l:1'!0JlJJJilt·e, 1{-7 r · 7 ✓:7"" · -z N'.J

h~;t (1 ✓ Fi9f/Al1J~) b'"? 00!£;i~jlj~~ 1999:¥£J.*~:¥7' 1J-l.''.±.

ill L -Ci> I), 2OO2:¥1:li.±.1lli Lt-:0iliHi 1441:&~ o

1{-7)- · 7 ✓:7·•xN7r'7~:i-t1 ✓ T1"' ✓ r'iti{/AllJ~tTli, ffl.f~0

:iJ11,,1i~~b 00-f-h.llJ.11-1: ~ L -Ci£J.'i'di,j: "' a 2OO2:¥1:je:f'r ~ht-:

5t/¥v'7:r..AT1 ;{Jv0flH'r!fm0q:, 1:, im § 0~~1:;t:,1,,-cl!Jff ,j: § El3

1i1<;:ffl:,j:G[J"l:i£~1J1l:0x:!zn ~ffl~T ~- 7:r..AT1 ;{Jv0ffiit~)@§'m

ajj ~;Jtct.>~01±11-tfr IJJJ\T~~ o

-f-0fljfr!fml:I±, ::k~~'g,fJit, NSD%f.;f,JJf.iu~-ffi~tr ;(7'17:titM'*J

0~:WJtil;~<!c.~~h, Mt!tl¥.J'etf41tJi\t""'-0~~~~1: L -Cv'~ a fnJ

:,$:00ilitil;, v'<--:J0fli-Z:-, v'<--:J0fH-!f ~1Je-::,-C ..tiJil ~nt-: n't "' "?

:: t Ht IJ :ii! L 5_mW,\J L -Cv' ~ o f0011;J t'fr:bnt-: q:, t'li-©:::kJ 3> t' ~ ~

::t, it-:, ~:¥ffl.ffiil;W:::kL-Cv'~::tn;ll!~,j:0t'~~ a41 it-:,

i>-f-G<, i&/tf0If~il'--:J0:,:P:,j:~~~1FTt-:<t.>I:, 7:r..AT1 ;{Jvil'~

G$~imllJ HfUl L, 13Lt\1il¥.Jt'~~::U;li!t.li ~n -Cv'~ o J:-::,-C, ::0

7:r..AT.-fl{Jvl±, ~IJt~G$~~JHl'.:iHIJ~M~t-t~ o iifll~H:b&i&

ltf~~~ft< i&rol¥.J,j: A 1-1;- 1-• °/79-T~x.., 0i11t0i1£~1=~1n

~ o ::0ffi0A r 1J- r · °/79-1:iB()tf;,j{i,ai:~ 1±\-t,j:t\ ~ijo]VJ iT

li~1t b T El ,j: v':: t t!.-::>t-:o

i&ltf~q=i.l[1¥.J,j:.l[·™·~-:b~J:"'.)~}j:-::,~0ti~<&~0::

t t'~~ o -f-n i-Z:'li, :lli:Hdl, 1 :lt!!~[m:;tf0 (indigenous) J m1-t;iJi{jlj ~

ffi~l¥.J 1:;J,1%!WJ L -c E<t-:o 198O:¥1-t;I:, 1,7,i-- ~ ✓:7""7-o/0i&/tf*i1il

~"('~~~✓.:¥- 1-• 1--97 • 7-JJ?~-iJ', •al/i.t'll§-~xnt-t ~t-=<t.>

-f-h-f'h01/i.t~0/il:!it:lt!!.0!£;1i.UIJl:i/i!i-:::fv,t-:•at1Jft~x1£-t ~**

~ ~Im L, -f-0Ji\t:l!l:li:lt!!.7J~~00ffl.;ffi;07:r..AT1 ;{JvTje£,: ~nt-: o

::0J:"?,j:4JJ-*~5m L-c, r~~J 1:1 ✓ Fa9,j:m1-t;i11t/Al1J0l±lm~~jeL,

Bharat Rang Mahotstav IV - An

Overview (NSD, 2002) p. viii.

ilt4 HIJffl:e}, p. xiio

::n iT0@if ]"'7-z r'7 Jv.:f-0 r1~-1J,:b L v,J n;l,ti/liJ,Gtwlill: ~n~:: n 5

tiJ,JtlH~~nt-:o 71T✓ T1T1""'-0::t!.:bl)iJ\ f;v-o/0/:(i{jlJ (theatre

of the roots) J ~ 00 ~ ~lf-C;J,\%/mJT ~ '/,i':lll;!:~-::,f,:051

1 Jv-o/0iHIJJ 0~.$1:%:bit-C¥:~:ffl9 ,j:71T ✓ T1-r1 H~~T ~7'1v:79-bit-:, 1&G01tt\'li~OO~i¥.J,j:7:r..AT11{;H:11t;J,\%L, x

158 Session Ill

r,~-,;,Cl)i;i{JIIIJ 1:llll-t '->lllJ~:/:JCl),t;'-> ffl:itfl;J::A:~15'!«.o Rustom Bharucha's 'No tes on the Invention of Tradition'

in Theatre & the World: Essays on

Performance & Politics of Culture

(Mano har, I 990), especially pp.266-

270.

ltt6

'In Search of a New Living Theatre,'

The Hindu , June 22, 2001.

m:-t 7.>i&JffO)-m-:,t.:~~1:,~,~i~-:>-CM.:o 4'0)1:,, i-:1.1,:f1iix.J.>ffl.~

ctlt!f:IJJ'.f(,H:Jri]~1rv', I 4 ✓ FGL~J i~-}:::c:1:,J:-:>-c, :'.:O)~O)iHIJ

!±/iiJj"j.O)fulo,~:1: r1iJ ft-C, RJ*tt0)5_m1,,.:i:.-t-:/-f--;,, 71&: 1:,, Fi l!!k: L 1:1:!t"o

**' $/JU<J, t-Hl!i¥J, ffl.1-ti¥J1.1>-:),t<'7'r-'E-7' ✓ 1¥J~*i!Wllls\'l:t'f-t1r

b-tl: 7.,::t 1.1,1c,,@::7., ~i§~U-f J.;.c 1,,-:,t.:ra,m1: f!ll:imt" 7.> 1:,, H'Ht

O)~l±-f:::1:1±1&:v'o ~GI:, 01¥Jl&:~JE'.i~ft-Cv'7.>t.:i\6, +::-c:Wi

'9'. ~;h.7.,1:,, t-:·1:1±, iHJ l_.,-:)-:)i.lUEt" 7., 71 T✓T1T1~, 1:,, F:lt1t

1.1':f1iix. 7., IM!1ri¥.J-c: 1, 17' 1J,, F1&:1ti[rJJ, ffl.1EO)i&r• i¥J:tl't?J!t'i! H!!x. -c ~ l!li¥J 1J:-:)1J:1.1'IJ i ~-it 7.> Jt1ti¥Jtln:J'-:)~0)~9:"-0)~9' • t, :X~• L -c1,,

7.>o :::-}Lt.:ffl,~!±, 1H!c:!t!l~717':,,-r1-r10)i&r • tti~/il/Jt"J.>ffl.

1-\':ilii!liJ 1: (i~i\6 G ;/1.7&: v'o

i&Jff 1: J:7.> 1 Jv-o/O)i1iit1JJ "-O)xm:1±, (.i:,-f GO\iu~~tlt!f:IJ BI~

,@::: Lt.::::c tiiliJ IJ) 4---c::::+T xi: 1&:-:>-Cv'7.>1.I', -fO)ffe.JMFiv' it.:. c

c'i\O-CV'7.>o t"1&:b-t, ~OOiliJ7.>H±#iJjj.O)M~i~9ct"7.>1iiHfiU-c

fil~~J.;.l±!L~ o -G~,a~:lt!l0)$•i•t'ft-7.>~i\6~,.t:,~ilJO)

7:7.::.y:7~LM.: IJ itlJJfl / i"};j<IJJfl L1&:1.1'G, 1il:!v'ci ~;h.t.:#JliJ i1l!!-:>

-Ciliiflj i :i"}~t" 7., 1.)', § O)jjlj 1: 1,, 7.> M~ 1:{rli G 0)0i1ii1.1'JlP;,H t'J'-:)0)

1.1,t'-} 1.1, 1:-:) 1,,-c !± Ii c Iv c' ~,C.,1.1'1&: v' o 1/ll G 0) <fl 0)1fiJ A 1.l'li, 1:,, F

OOpq- ~.t:, J: rl#iJj"\.l:.t::,1,,-c l±i'ili < ~'l'-filli ~n -c1,,7.,1: t, Jjl;j;/:JGf, o­

JJ!v1&: Fa,m~~,i:.,, -fL -Cffl,~ cl±~t.:IJO)iliJJ.> pq~O){-'Jc,l'i, H,!J{-tt" 7.>

t.: i\6, 1:1:! ,!it:lt!lO)J-11 O)M~ 1:1±illl(ff. i t'J't.: n -c 1,,, 7.> c 1,, -3::: c 1±~ < «~

:: t-c: ti 1&: "' t.:. 0 -3 o

r Jv-o/O)i1iif1JJ i±, i!,IJ{-'J:,ffl,tjc:1&:7.> :lt!l~O)j"\.-Z:i'1/i < ll!?J• ~n-c, ~fdfi ~n~t-1,,J:-} 1:, :!at1ti¥J 1&::iiifi)J ctlffttt11t/il1:, 1.'1.Ji:1¥J ;z~:7:$7:7 JH:iJ < -!R~ L -c1,,7.,o 1/"' ✓ 1-ri'I i1-t*t" 7.>IUffi 1-t r '7 :,,jr J 0)7'1 v:7:$1--Z:

iliJ 7., 1,Jv'J ✓ r, :$7-:7 Jv .f.\;;1±, ;fr:(O) J:-31&::f!ll1±11: J: IJ, gii!0)1il:!Jfl i-/ii:1J,

mH:}!f)x.t.:iUU i#~t" 7.>o t"1&:b"t, 1fMfO),!itf,!;:iilli L-Cfli:ffl, ~n 7.,ill{~(±, g 'j\€J.;J,_.U:{iJit" 7.,1] it'J'-:) o f.[.(;l:g 'j\€0)~ i ~ t);j'_l1,,f_:

1,,0)f.:.o 1 J- 1/li, ~;(ef O)g/i!~~i¥.J 1&:r~t'l~'\\f:iliitt H)f-\tt'J'-:) J61

0) t.:.o L 1.1' L, :$7-:7 Jv .f.\;;O)t/li < 1 J-1/i{ll:! -:,-C tf :iii¥J I&: ::i ~ .1.::.-'T­

:,,3;,,i nl1:1L ~-it U.:i\61:1±, -f0)1 J-1/i1.1'7&:IJ¥ ~1t-it~ ' 7.>Hf 1&:

v'o :!:11:t.:L-C, ,fO)J:-}1&:1J-1/il> -:>-C, 1/"':,,1-~;fef0)1jii(t-z,;Q;JiUl¥J

1&:ffl.~i~;Jt-z,~J.,O)t.:.0-}1.1,? g 'j\€0)1JHlsr1JfL-C, -roO)l;l:.:f:::;

u·x. 7., A 4 O){, c ,!it-f*O)WjO).::. .1 7:,, 7-~iJ ~H i x. 7.,::: c 1.1'-z'• ~ 7., 0)

t!.0-31.1'? -tr '7 :,,~1.1,iifi t, Mtfl' 1: lili-7.> « ~ -r-? I: -:)1,,-c, iliJ x. -Cit

Session Ill I 59

(4) :li!!.nO)Jtft~~

1 ✓ rooM-&O)ag~•n0)■$~MatL~••~.m~r~­

YO)ilil:IUJ t.:ftl."lit:i:v'o f~~iUU>I:, it.:. :li!!.:!Jt\:m.UEO)~~~ rl»~-t 7.>

f_:i\61:ili/r.iHtiE L -C M-:o 71 1} fj' • ·lflJ- 1).1:\;:I: J::7.,t, f§lj x_!;J'.'7-7

'7ffl-r:•b~~t:i:• • -r:~7.>n9n~~7-77ffl~n0) • $~~b~

-C,filiJffi-t 7.,1:~t-:IJ. :Ji!1.jcO)Jtft~IMJi,){~)JJ}J Lt-:-~7J' = -::l~7.,t 1,,,

10n = -:::iO).cf-ittb. n9n 1J~flft11tnx:-t7.>1:~t.:1J. n9n 1J~ rr ff

iil¥J t:i: J f~ii:t.J ~ b -::i~:Wn~t~J '> 1: -t 7., W(;R7J'f'Fffl L -c 1,,, 7., t-lf 1J -1J,a;f;t~,-z-c1,,,7.,o J::-::,-C, f§JJ;U.f. l!9ifi1iiJIJl:hGtt7.>1J7 1JXAI:~

-:::i' < ilil:1±17'.l'i!+A ~ti. §"ia~m1HiVH.IH:t:i:1J. B '/j\"~/,sO)~ffii,),i%rJ.&

~;tl,7.,J::11:i';i:-::,fS:o

-lf 1J- 1J .E~;I: J::ttf.f. n9 n') ~flfffinli:T 7., = -::i0)~.7;.li. rretffO) L

M-:IJ~f~~1:-::i1,,,-c, ffiL 1t,&$~ rfxlf J T 7.>::..tJ J:: IJ. r1!1,G7'.l';ff\

JET7.>&$0)~ffnrt~•Lhn~~b~-C.n9n~§-0)1/ATA

HtiE L. ffij:j~i" 7.>J ii[ ~~M.:O)l."~7.>o9 > §"v'~x..ttl.f. r1"11r J ~£,

Jn~·n:. ffiLv'liffl$7J'h9M'"'-IMJ,C.,~*~7.,nr!Hl~L-C ht.:

0) t.:o JO) r JI,,-')' O)il&IUJ i,)tj; ~ 1: loll..'.. El ffl ~~ff""(1,,, t.:::.. t ~::.. ::..-r:·.1!1-

1,,, 1±1-t%t~7J'~ 7.> t.: 01--t t:i: b-l::,. v'7J't:i:7.>&$1:ML -Cb, M~

b/W~H£•~t Lt;.1,,,j1i{f1J~:etJl±l-t 7.,::_to MrJJ:ll':~I: L -CM~i¥J~!}!l

1:L-Cb. i1iiJIJO).±.iJHrfi. ffjJC:,i,),1:mHB$HfxlfJ-t7., ::..u,. 13

ftt.:-t;, O)*t.:-tr-Z ~1'>!:\lllJ t.: t fi.~. -:,-CV' t:i: 1,, ' o •-af-0) b0)7J'T"'-C ~

ta7.>::..tHIHlL-Cv'7.>o i1fiflJHlU:1tL. -t-.:z.v-1/3 ✓ ~/il!iL. fxlf

T 7.,b,-::,f-:i'tif:1:ML-Ctll!E L-CiW~l¥Jt:i:~~fi. ~~0)0ilil:~f~~I:

hGtt7.>t!Uftt:i:J!i!1,,,~f~ii-r:~-f. :'A::fttl:*~b-::,-CV'7.>o it.:. ~Gl:i*

;/iljt;.O)li. ;:..0)~~7J'1!1Jft-r:·i\H\O)~,¾.n:-::ii1iiflj ~ rl!TiillfJ T 7., i1fiflj ~:glJ

ftL • ...tilil:i" 7.>t 1,,,1@'!< r-Z~AAful t - ff,:tt:i:-::>n,7.,::..t-r:-~7.,0

]JIJj/j:{-\';1¥)1{7:t-?/ A%rt;l:ffi L v'8$0)1MJ,[.,~ P31 ~*~J. it.:.

ffi L 1,,,::r ✓ T:7 A )--0) i:p-r:· MI~ ,ffifi,),;tt7., J:: 11: T 7.,1:li. flfffinx:~nO)

~:JRf;tt;.1,,,t.±.~IT 7.>::..t bl."~7.>t.:010 ~~0)&$~::r ✓T:7A !--~

jj.O)~pjrl."fi. 1{7,t-? ✓ AO)%~::k~liil:filall Lt:i:ftttf.f0im7'.l'nli:.n:

L t;.1,,,;{7:t-? ✓ Al:f;t, 1"11r~:!.JD x.. -Cb~ 11J1'>!:l:.n:t-:t;.1,,, t.: 01 o

tv, "? 0) b, !ftJE O)J{ 7:t-"? ✓ .7-0):/fifi. !ftJE 0) ::r ~ .1.::. 710) i:p l."f-

0)~ §'~~'*7J'nli:.n:-t 7.> 0)l." ~ IJ. ffsfti¥Jf!Ut. :imil!HlHL. ~-. t:i:G

160 Session Ill

ilt7

jJ!iO);j(O)'l'f,!;~1>.lfil , 'A Tradition

of Change: The Role of Patrons and

Patronage in Kathakali Dance-Drama'

in Arts Patronage in India: Methods,

Motiv es and Markets, edited by Joan

L. E,dman (Manohar, I 992), especially

pp. I 30- I 40.

l!tB

Jl'u J&l!!, p.132,

i!t9

lll/J&llf, p.135,

:1110

fii L<'lil~l:[iitlt-C/i;,l!:ili!JIJI ~l'Hl!' ~"tJ.,81 JO)(jl)it;k~$ffil, Rusrom

Bharucha's 'Notes on the Invention

of Tradition' in Theatre& the World:

Essays on Perfonnance & Politics of

Culture (Manohar, 1990), especially

pp.26 I -266.

ll"l:1:.itiO) 1J;?-'. J.,,c ~,w, f:*aU'-::i v•-C v• 7., -!), Ge:-j;, 7., o

L-/J' L, .::. tLG O)J:!1!1±1 f: J: 0-C, 1:,, FlBOff-/J,m1\-0)Jii'l$,: fol ft-C :$71

-Y 1.,, i )"':,, .7-0)- llc L -c M:lfr-t 7.,.::. c f:Jiwr®-t 7.,.::. cfi7j:1t•o :$71 -Y 1.,,

,i, 'bC 'b u--7 :Hl•IO)-mA1:frbtL7.,1{7:,t-? ✓ XC Ardl 0) ~ i

~·1 ilk~ i i/,ilJt.: Lt.: l'J, xm:~tit~fet i iil v•:t.&-:d.:36, t11J 4, !&./Jl., wR:JJ

w'O)~J#iNlm, !l!t, !/}./fd:, ffi1l.L ffl.$1:;j;,7.,Hi~tiJt-/J{1Jihn ~tL-C*36G

tL7.>o 7-7:Hl•IO):lt!i:1cO)Jt{~IM!ill!ffifi.<:'ii, :$11-Y J.,,i y:,,-7-0)-fic L

-CtlLz. -Cv•7.> o :$11-Y J.,,-/J,:,R36-C v• 7., O)li, ~;/JD1f'"l:'li 7j: < M$t.: Cit•"?

.::.c iff--t .::.u:J: 0-c, it< ~nt.:c .::.0f: 1t•7.>*Uflfr:t.J0)7j:1t•M$f:J:

7., :$11-Y 1.,, O)rJHH~il+T 7.>o .::.O)J: "7 lj::ffi" L v•JE~O)g:,c:-~iii& ~ n7.>

:$11-Y J.,,O)~~, j;,7.,Hi, :ffi-L 1,.:1:,,77-7-r O)i:j:l1:~btL7., ~~f:-::i

v•-C Ii, mt Ul!nlj: v• ii i:tll!!.-/J''it' G tL -C v•7.>o J&Ji,f-/J, :$11-Y J.,,O)::r:,, 7

7-7-riMfi.<:L7j:fttLli7j:G7j:1t•O)c:-j;,tLli, -lt36-C, 11:1:lil='tfJ UM

$ J f:fol lt-C, .::.O)J:"? 7j: f~~J -/J'v•-/J•,: :$11.Y J.,,0)%Ai¥J71 T✓ 71

71iili36-CLi0-CV•7.JO)-/J•, m~-t7.>fHf:-/J,j;,7.Jo ~i(ilj:fttLfi, M

$Ii, ;t ') :/-t Jvlj: ::r :,,77 -7-H:t,Ji36-C ili:v-%1:'f!f:g'l ~ nt.: :$11.Y J.,,O)

11{7:,t--;,:,, -7-J HlHt L -c v• 7.,-::i 'ii l'J t.: c J:iM L -c 'ii ,f±1JO) 7j: v..::. U.:

0"?0 :$11-Y 1.,,i.::.O)J:"? lj:%1:'fJ'tff-L-::i-::i, 11!!.0)7J1t;;'"l:~~T 7., ~;;.-!),

fi C A.,c'1'rbtL7j: \t•~-fr' f~!jm-/)t:,j>:!jm f:1-t b0-ClPt1TT 7., C \t• "7 *a* i

ftl<o

~~,-~0)•••~~~0-c,=-::i§0)•••~1:••~n7.>«

e-rA~Mi 'b~P.?. Llj:-/J{G• Si:i1136-CM.:o -f:-L -C, 1 ✓ Filflj0)9£ji~fi

f:;}.Ht 7.,'j't,,-1::,,:$7-~ .7-;f-':,,-lj--0)~~:t.J f:-::iv•-Cif ~ lit Lt.:o lo]

~f:, ilfl]EI fi.<:-/J', ~ft ~tLt.:i(iO)"(''j;,fl,, t'l'.lil; ~tLt.:i(iO)"(''j;,fl,, :m ~O) 'ii0)1:j;,n, -f:-O)fm$~mt:UJO)~iin:-trb-tt-ciWl.itHtiE L n,7.,

.\'n:-::iv•-C'b~!tLt.:o -f:-tL"C''li, ,1:,,p-O)jj{jlj-!)ti®f.tL j;,7.,HiililJf-J

i~07.J-f:-O)~O)M:t.J~tt~~j;,7.,0)~0"7-/J ~

'fkfi.::..::. i"C''O)c.::.01:,fiiJ/3(-/J•~i !c :11!!~0)71 T✓7171 O)J&r• tt ,:-::iv•-C~ lit L -c .lf.t.:-/J', -f:-tL-/J\ 1:,, FO)Yl.{-tilfMID!lMii%nlt-t 7.,

g:, 1:-c'O) J: "7 lj:f',tl!itl i :Jll:t.: L -c e-t.:-/J· fi, M 1ii f: L-/J·~IJ!tLlj:-/J• 0 t.:o -f:­

.::.1:, jffd:fti:, J&r• i¥J~~-/J'v• -/J•lj: 7., 7]1±;'<:, it.: \t• -/J· 7j: 7., J:!1!1±11:', -7-

;f-' :,,-lj--, '1'v-E:,,:$1-, M$, -f:-L-Cr/J~O):fT1JiJJJ:%fi7.>-/J•':i*<1:,,

FilllJ f:Jll;?W i 1:,-x. -c v• 7.>-/J•f: -::i v•-C ~«t.: v• c .ill, "7 o -f:-O)Jjl;~:t.J fi,

iNflJA-/J' § 53-t.: t,O)~Jri¥J 717.✓ 7171 i JE~ L, it.:{t fJ l±l-tt.:36

Session Ill 161

O),\!l,~~;f.'£1: i"t" N.~{iO)"{" ;!i,7.,0

1:,, 1-'"t"I±, § 8fr89:'l'f~if~r!-I ~5.)-lt 7.ii&mEf9f.::ltU'f.it'i! ~YcJE'. L -r~

t::.t.:.¥>, 717':,,-r1-r1 ~ JE'.~T 7.i...t. "t"-giffil,;: h t-r-1:~ L -r~~t.:

ic-ry-c L -rmvn7.iJ: 11: t.:-:>-r ~ n,7., 0 rlii&JffO)~lJl0)~1'!trx1trMI

iJEO)'.tt, ~"¥:~i>J:U'I!f.Jfflt~I±, HJ:OOi;ftO)litH:J:-:,-C!j\yJE'.O)J'l·ll:pJr~

T 7.>Cv''? 1~JE'.J ~~1tt.:.1imAO)f.:.¥>1:;t;,7.,o ~1'!tr~rnJ:U'~1'!tr*7.

Jv-7',±, 00iPGO)J!;/Jfflt~~IJ7.,t.:.¥:Jl:1±, if, -f-hf'';/1,0)flii&Jffl:

J: 7.i;ilkilI~ I&~ -:::iltf.:lthlff.: Gt.: v'o i&Jff 1±, ~1'!trxJ":lO)t.:. ¥>1:J'l:;k

'/tffl:O) Mil~ ishn,7.,.:. c ~ :$;/1, -r 1± t.: Gt.: v' t! ;s 1 o

U.:.i,{-:,"( 089'if~O)ftJJff)t ~~It 7.it.:.¥:>,:, ~a7--r1;.,, r-?R!iJffi

1±, !3 5.l-t.:.t i,{F,s-tti" MIH:~ L, i t.:.-f-O)f'!,,l1i,{-f-.:_ 1::m t:rL tv'.:.

c ~ 1LfilET 7., £-~t,,;t;, 7.i o i'li i&Jtfil':/l~ L, fitli" 7., 7--r1;.,, I-0) i:p

,:, jjljjfli,{{il!,O)J'IMl±lc!it"t", 717':,,-r1-r1il'1l~i1UE L -rv,7.JAI±¥>

-:, t.:.1: v' t.: v'o rl-li&JtfO) § 1: t,,t.: '?f.:. ¥> 1:1±, iiRIIJB9 7 ".7 r 7':;, r 0) i:p 1:

:lt!!:1Joc-gi,H<11<:trt l±li" .:.u,m:~"t";t;,7.io it.:., i'!i0)0~-gi;ft"t" ...t.ii~

h-7.i itUIJ"t"f.: ( ti± t.: Gt.: v'o -f-0)...t. ,:ct~-?~Al::11!!:lloc~ !3 O)!j\yfi't

t,,;t;, hi!~ G 1: J: v' c ~ h -r v' 7.i o

*a:l!l:89 ,:, 1:,, FiiR!H:1±- JmJ:;f;:-?ii 1±1 O)v,fnt,,~ rAiv-r-

1:,, F O)?f,-gi;ft89:ffl.~ ~ ll!l!-L l±l T~~t,,,1 c lvc''f.: v'o 1,:,,-Jf'• - JvO)

A40)?f,(I±, 4-:::iO)-gi;ff~;!i,-?-:::i7.io it.:.1:,,FA,:c-:,-C, ~lJiliO):ifti

i:p"t";l;,7.i -gi;ffi1,G5JIJO)-g~"'-b"7 rT 7.,0)1± B '/i;~fl&~Jt!o ~Gl:;f.&

t.:.tl±-4-, -giffil,ffiJU: ii"ii"~(/-j:~i" 7.i~-=f ~ § O)~t.:.~,: L-r

v'7.io I:: :,,71-ilftU~Jfti,{ - :m1:f.:-:,-Cl:: :,,7·1Jo/ ::,,,:1.c L -r~m ~h-7.i

J: 11:, - fi0)-gi;ft0)7 v:t-1HtB I~~.:. L n,7., 0 c'O)XJ¥t1:i~

ilftc I:: :,,7·1-iftO)jjljjJJil'G 5 lffi U.:..:. UJ'.'if1Jebh -rv,7.Jo I:: :,,7·1;:;,

::,,,:,_,±, 4--?;e'=llfO)-gi;{tcL-r1:,,F~:lt!!"t"tf.&.L-:::i-:::i;t;,7.,o Jti5,

MTV, ~;,1 • .to J: u·1:,, J-"O):k*1~@ ,±, gm: t-:::iv7.i .:.O)J: 1 t.:m

~ ~ll!l!-Ll±l L, -f-O)~Gt.:7.inlt*cje§fl:J,t~ L n,7., 0 .:.O)J:-?f.::17;:iR.

,:1t L -r, iiR!IJO)-gi;ftl±ll'Jf\;;il'G~J!Jt U.:.ii, ffl,~0)1 :,,J-" AO)~lJili

;f!f'l!\t,,G-9) ~~~ht.:.:17;:1.l.1H:;!i,7.,o ~lJilic v'-?0)1±, ~lJiliL -rv,7.JAt.:.

t t,{ !3 5.)-~ c'O)J:'7 l:tli':x. n,7., O)t,,~ ll!l!-L l±li"o UP L 1:,, FiiR!IH±,

;:O) J: '? l:tfr L <, ]l!tfr ~ ht.:.71T✓ T1T10)%n\t ~tli':x.7.i c•'.:_ ;st,,,

-f-;/1,~~lt }.;/1,7., .:.c ~X. "t"~f.:v'o

-giftO)i&mttl±, ~a7--r1;.,, J-O)?f,~"t"'.i:/(9Ef971T ✓ T1T1~

J'J'.PEE L, 113 c.J ~JE'.l: Wt.:.*a:l!l:Ht1v'H'7.io !3 cil'1l~-giftO)iJUE

162 Session Il l

1:J:-c:,·O~JiX: ~;h,-c1,,f_:c L -Ct, -f ;h,l;l:fpJ'l,0)9:q:1±rili ~ l±l ~h1d:v' o

(1:.,,Fi,t!IIHi, :t;-_:;t_J-~*fxO)M.1Li:±.Ml:U-:tL-ct, :t;-_:;t_J-~

*fxi),7JftET 7.,,@AO)rA,~JH:Jt,,~ iib-C 7.,.::t,i1d:v') 0 it-:, :ilii~, ft

lliJJ (displacement ) ~ftR;l:J: -c:,-C !'fl:-?ltt-:ffiLv'71T✓ T1T1il'i9l

JIUI: J:-c:,-C ~;ffl, ~ ;h,7.,.:: t t 1d: v' o V-c -?O)fli ii' G ~IJO)fij 1:ft,(1 U-:A

O)ftJi?i~, 7'17.:;t_>f-'77'.l'G 1:/mffl!IJ T 7.i AO)'§=WH~*T 7.iev'"?ii;G

-t t,O)JJt41:,fs:~i,t l±l li~1d: .to J: < ~7'.l,iH o it-:, El 5-rt-: -/::,0) <1=11:J; 7.i l!!l

i$1¥.J~~i J!lv,;J'.lv', 1:.,, ]-'O);fj'R;:lt!!O)~~i) L'f x.t-=~~i71T✓T

1T10) i:pi),G rW L*G1d:ithl.:f1d:G 1d: 1,,t v'".) '1'v:;, 1/-\'- i ~ l.'., -Cv'

7.i•~t • -~ii;7.i o .::O)J:"?1d:~~i~ • -t7.it,.::n1~1:.,,FMa

il'tl~O)tirM:lolll;¥1:rJi'~ U-:IJ, J;7.>1,,1;tt'.::1:UJH-ril'1d:v'iH:.

~7.>A.i :±.A0tL~~Jti~ -c:,-C.::1d:~-c:,~.::t~J;t.lJm~~L1d:

m~O)~ 1d:7.> iltJ!l iffillfr-t 7.i 1:.,, F, J;7.>1,,,i, -f O)~jJ!r,Jl Hll.&'>7.>1

:.,, ]-'O)~il', i9t!IU i:illi L -C ~.i,111:, ii;7.>Hi-t5tl:~;ffl, ~~ H'1d:v'C

Thl.:f, -fhli, ib7.>$5t-r-,i, ,f:.,,]-'O)JJt41:,fs:*, 't.1!:'M-.toJ:rY-tl~flil', El

5t0):,js:~ 0)~ -5t llfr~n, *M#(~, U.:fU.:f;f•~l:ipilji:,-Cv'7.i­

i~Wri :illi L -Ct'!f 7.i.:: tiff L -c .::1d: il'-c:,t-:il'G t-.:o -fO)*a:l,11:, illi G 0)

f'FJtil,Gli, 1f;-< 0)1:.,, F Ail,1:.fti-t 7.i·tttJ!lil'i!XiHlcf-l::,-Cv'7.i- 5t~

~nt-:,\!;',/(1£,L..,, /\,f 7:.,,~-?1d:il'-c:,f_:ff-:{F_ (= -?£/,..t0)71T:.,,T1 T1

il':!¾1:.T 7.iff-tt) , J'All!%T 7.il:li?f;-•-t~· 7.i 71T✓T1T1, -fL-C~~

t M.1L0)1JtJ!lo it-: lol 1!;¥1:, Jal~l:JS-t 7.i iltJ!lil' G bf-: G ~ ;h,7.,ffi L 1,,

J.lt~t El El3 tff-tr. L 1d:v'O)~iliJ7.io

Session Ill 163

-f--1' > 1 -'E?

~~~O) f&JO)r~~ L t J-&J.Qf$t)j0)~!5

v1•f-3".J I mlff 7' '.7 '7 ;,,;}(eJf:i!iftJtft · -"7'17 eJf:llll/ lttilJt~tilfi:tl\'.

1-"t ✓ . ,(--f:?

~!H\U:t- J"&i/iO)~@O)u-t-:::i rnmO)c~ J (1999:'rJo) O)l'j:;(p,:, tY!.

:W:tt,:M-t 7.>flltO)- ~Lt:.1HiE~(J(J~~~~t,si" 7.>t 'ii§ .z-f1tj, i.£ ,:t • 'T'rf::t

§ T~~ - 1/-:.,~f,!i).. L--c1.,,7.,o ~mcv'-J~iPGM/~0)$ L/:1:l ~,Ji:

It t:. IJ;(p IJ O)t-;.-:,t:.ft:110)*-z'\ i7/UJll,::il§lf--Cfi-::,--C L 1-::, t:.1&:t(O)lii/

~il-~v,--cv, -::,t:.AA-r:·01.> § § 0)31:0)Cf-,:, :fi.t:.-t;,,±l±l4d o *a~~~

td&O)~na ~Et< T 1.>t:.&'ll:, -f O)t-;.-:,t:.tt:tt1±, 1.,,-:::i'iitj:GmAA~:$

~frll:ili.>-:::iil•-JO),:, 1&:t<I: 7-1.7.:71J-A~ /:1:l L --C-? 7.>o L ;6• L .:'.:O)~-\;]J

tj k 1., iv'il\M:< O)'b, .:'.:0)~;(),1.,,1., mHJJ t!ltt! o 1&7'.l'!m-::,--C Li 1 t,

-t<·~ ii':.-::>t:.:t<ttl± 71.7. :7 1J-A~@ § O)j;-31:;(J,1:,-'f,J[ <I& IJ __ Uf,

tj: ,: ~ i 0)-:::, Mt! t .\iffiJ L tj: il' G, (jj"~/,IH:~ L --c Li 10) c: ili.> 7.>o

.:'.:O) 1/-:., 7'.l· G tj: lvG 7'.l•O)iJ!f.[(fl(J~Jl/11 BI~ /:1:l-t.:: t 'ii oJil~t.:il' (t:.

t HJ:", ArJJ 0)-/.M!f tv, 1 ~7'.l•:b L '-"~iR. ~ t\'Jv, t:., J: < ili.> 7.> •FA:tj:::O) V­

e -:::it L --c JU.: t1:J:-::,--C), J: IJ~i9Ki*"'O)I±, Ji1.,.::t O)Bc~"j!:ti&

ro"j!: ,: iJ!J L --c, .:'.:O) 1/-:., il":Ji'l:-#t-t 1.,~~ 1: ~ lvt!/W,fRO) ,11 t! o -:::i i

IJ .:'.: .:'.: 1:1±, !JsfJEO)fdfi-fg;(J,~m ~ :/1.:':i(i/J,s ~ :/1,1., ~ v>O), ili.> 1.,f!f(O)!j&o'j{(J(J

tj:Bc~ t L --c, tY!.'.i't-f O) 'ii O);(),tzk:b n --Cv' 1., O)"t'· ili.> 1., o t-:_-:, t:.ft:ttO) .:::­

'li~tr.:i:.~(J(J 7'j: 71.7.:7 1)- A O):j:]k1.,, TJil"~ L --C "' 1., 0) ,±, i!tJ'i!+lli!ioJ

nl'j'iiO)t-t1.,mn~e~l'j'iiO)c:~l'j<--c,Ar(J(Jtjm•1:01.,.::

t, ~ G 1: ,± ~ :b &'l--C;fiJc',(J(J tj:Ji¥!f'F;(J,oJiJ~ 7'j: 'b 0) -r:· ili.> 1.,, tv, "? .:'.: U! o

*-::,~ft:tt~~•(J(J~7~*0)mn~~.:t1.i~<.e~e•O)•L~~

i.liHx T 1., 0 ;()>, V >-::) t:. lv-f 0) tut ;()>ff{!: L 7'j: < 7'j 1., ('. , .:: 0) iJiHi HfM

1.,£,~,±l'j<l'j:1., o § v>il•.zn,J, tJ!.:W;t,±, 'fi.t:.-t;,;(),-tfiili~ .z --Cv>l.,

J:"?l'j:, ~lljjtj:~f;f:;c:'h:fi/WO)-'f,.fil!'.c:'htj:v'o t.J'L0-fn,±, (,iil•O))

Ara10)#-f;t,;l::IJIJ.&'l:i6 i:/1.t:.'iiHJ!.O) .xn .::..:{ Atj: O)f! o -:::, i IJ, ,u,O) t!

:/1.7'.l•il'Ji --c "' 1., t ~, U-t ,±:iifil.iU:~ 1., i :btj: < --c ,± tj G tj: 1.,,;(J,, -f 1 c:

tj:1.,,:mtr1:,±-f1T~~;;fs:'i_'l{(J(Jl'j::fiEl:H±tj:1:'htj:v,o T~*il' 1Ji n,

1.,J'bO)l;I:, ~~- {Bt;()'>lljj Gil•l:Ji --CV>t:.IJ, :iim L n,1.,, t~ .z n,

7.>.:'.:t t,±&t-J"O) 'bO)t!il•G o t-;.-:,t:.t(ttO)fi1,,,;(),f1.t:.-t;,~ ~~ ~-1±-1.,

164 Session lll

H•-f-a'l I 11.Hif Rey Chow

:111 f;J:-4li\<7)/: ;, J 1: llll-t J.,;:<l)j;j!c,~~ ti, ::::c't&1a@ f,b<7)'fi!WL-CJ "-<7)i/JJ../:L-C1!fn•ti-Cii9, iW''ii"'!; n~~~~~<l)~a•G,::nG<l)a J!ij <7)-j-,tf,;.,t,lirli Ii n•<7)Jll4:c 1:tr,,

2

tc/:;l.lJ:~<7)f'F,~,<7)J!tftilifittc f ;b

<l)'f i R1 L -CJ <l)~Jfl, f (- f.l1ifflll'flll j,' } \!>Jt1}~,t,lir J (f q,l!Jllt\!>'1€'l'J 19994'(20004'10/l'ittr )) , -ttil:, f'iltll,~lliJ !f,- -,;· (200111' I H 5 B),

t(l::c-,;· (20004'5/l 58), !f,Ii.\,·

09994'9/l IOl'l)c'<I), ;:<l)a@1: llll-t-1>:lil»iJlJ:o

liB ~mllt rl'fin 1,~•1'00, 1':~fta<Jffl:~ -'i-flifl'lr'llnlft [,t,l!li l'il!!.f~-t-1>::1: - 7'0-1<<J-l,-:,30,<7)J,l:~/:fli IY rr'l,uJfl'JMluJJ]J, flttll,¾ffiJ if, - -IJ(200lielH5R), pp.16-210 %\ PJ'llitl:J:tLIJ:, 19804'f-tl:i:f,1i1!tf-t <7)'!.\'~tc-1:,1: J:-o-Cf'FGtitca@1i, 'l'ooa@<l)&~c'<b-o~rr'llnlfl'l • llilJ ib0a@ ('i'i>!<l)ffil'lt'/:US:CI: t-t-t -1>111J,C,n'trl- c'<b-1>J:1t...a@) 1:&m-t -1>::l:n'c'-"t cltl;;lft...lla'Jl/lt a• L-cio9,-tn•;;..~•<7)u• <7)/iJl:t5 1 <::1:t El fl'll:-t-1> rn1°1 fl'JillllilJ ib-otca@ i 0( 9f.:Lfc o Ln•Liib!r<7)1!1:Ji!fl'J~i/ffilt<7)\l,'ll' c''1'l!Jajlij<l)~;,j.,til,lln''IUH -1,;: /:c', -t1Ltc;,J.1nJfl'JiJlllil<7)fla'Jl/liiil'! ;.·$:-, tc, Ul<iil»l:-1>o 11/il:J:til!, 7'0-,< •J-1:-;;,." n•i!'!all.a<H: rr'l lnlfl'lW.lliU <7)a@<7)fz;~<7)l!!mHt... ~L,'1'00<7)r'l • fl'lnmtab~ • ;.,q,l!J<l)~S~lnl~~-@~f'FG tLO.t-j,:~-·::d.:o r ~o-1'\ 1J-e-:,-3:,1ia@1:/:-,-C1rf.tc'lit...(, r'l • <7)rulmt...<7)f.:J /:~lil'}s,n,-1, (p.19)o

on±, ~ < 0) AO){g~ cli_&.t,H:, t!it~il,tl'.JtO)• @ 'i:-El %El :!'JO) .l§t

,C., cli L --c 1,,, t.: "'.: c, -t t.: b-t, ii:J ]li};fi9 6: ii:J e.itiO)f!WJ ~ H!!b-lt- ~ J:

-'jtj:;0,t.:-t,-Cli, pq:f£1tU.:l'J:;$:1l'HtU.:l'JL n,t.:1,,,;0,c,-c;t;i~ o .:0)

• A~c0--cm'.Jtc~,~~~-cn:fE~t.:••'i:-M0~bO),Ef5J'El:!'r

O);jilJ~O)t.:<161:;filJffi ~ n~,.,z~=f-~I:~ ~·t.: v' o ~@;0,.:0)@' § O)j;'

~ 'i:-<16("0"C5 I~~.: ~n~ 1±1*¥1: J:0--Cff; L, "Cv' < J:-'j 1:, tUtli:lm

~1: bt.:l'Jt.lt~o -fhli1t!!A 'i:-.:.-H,-tffiJ5t.: mf~O).:f,y r '7-7-CiV.i l'J

t.:;0,c,, BU~1 t.:.:c1:, El 5t'i:-i-ti-ti* <:!lll x. --c Li WI bO)i,,tj:O)f.:o

tut 'i:-::(af-t ~cli£,-f Lb m § -c;t;i ~.: cO) oct-t·e1;:1:t.:<, ~1JL1: J:0

--c Ii@§ 0)}1£* c bt.: l'J-'j ~ o -f hli, r~f,1;:~t.:tl:W:llll1~U'iJ t.(t,1,,,,

~~ 'i:-fill:IIJ L, /m~T ~ - f1[0)J\ ✓ T-1' "t .. 1' Y 7"-C b iV.J ~ 0) f! o 1 )

IIJ3nt!r~c il'ffi!':, i!W U.:W'!.~:t.J t.: t· cf~~~ 1:t'/<'.f-?1t Gn --cM.:

tl:W:~~f;j;:O)!Jo/J'f1i1"1 'i:-, _:O)J:-'j 1:IIJ3li1fH:1~!!\l L n,~.: c o _-:0).:c ;0,,

~HH/tO) 1990if:1-ti:r~il' G t~:Jt!l, -f n1:2000Jf:f-t1JJ:JtJlO)~@i 0), 1,,

it!~/±\ U.:~~-C;t;i~.:U:W,:;bl')lit.:v' o t!il 1- 1i-Cli, -'l"-'1"~/W

HB(J:-'jl'j:ffl:jj'f~il-J.HiV.>0--C, -fnf:J:nli', i/!O)J'iii/i:O)~@ili, t!it

'i:-OO~JF-~ 1:~!li ,: u.:1JJM O)b O)~ rt1v, :::r- 'J-v ✓ J c19ssif:), 1-.i,{ 1-7

r?>WJIJ (1990if:), rtJ:J<J (199lif:) ~ biilJ3G;6,f:~t.:0--C@"Cv'~

tv,-'jO)t.:o'1 ~itlli'Uf§°;b;tl~O)li, i/!;61.J;J,JirJO), -t-C·f:~~c~

n "Cv'~ ~@j O) ::t1J .I. ✓7' 1J;(A ~7, :$1,{ )v, -tt.: ;bf:,, nooO)~)Ju:t,:-t,

0),@1311~(1:if!!,fr-t U.:<161:, tilI~ft ~nt.: ,fl7.JO)i:pl!] 'i:-Wi < ftJli:l'Jfij.l'.;'i:-,

~;0,nd,'tj:;0,n:J\%;--C * l'J, -f O)f-1'.;;b l'J 1:, m{-tO) i:rOOt±fl:l:iHt ~tt:im 0) A4 0)1::ili'i:-Wi'9'.T ~ 'J 7 1J;(A ~~@i:l'Jfij.l'.;'i:-~ffiT ~J:-'j 1:t.:0t.:,

tv, -'j b 0) t! a t.: c x. li'iei!li t.: Xftffl:tli*-C' iV.l ~ i/i~JliUi, rt'(?>W O)!Jo/1

ii J c1993if:) , r qc--7" · 7- JH::{aflfililiflifml JC1997if:), r1JJ;{);O) M.:

iti:J (1999-2000if:) Cv'0t.:~@i;0,, r;t;iO)-=f'i:-~L --c J (1999-2000if:)

-'I" rnmO) c ~J c l"l:l'!fi, :xl!ii:r 000)~@ilfi:)li!;O)@c:ft1: U.:i11 0t.::t!fij.\'.;

~@,:ft 'i:-ff; L, "C ;J3 I'), -f hli ::ru-1{ 1)-l::-;;,, 3:,, 0)/±JJ 1: J: 0--C, 4-B

0) i:p l!]O) rp9MH:M-t ~, J: l'J pq !ti]~ t.: T:1U-1-'i:- ~ ~ J: -'j 5fil "' G nt.:

t'i :l;f!d.:·, c 1rmi t, --c 1,,, ~ o 31 i/i!HU 1-f 0) J: -'j t.:@c:ft Hl--C M.: c -t ~ t.:

G Ii', flit b-? H:, il'"J"Clif/itO)~@i 'i:-b0c b ~m L --c1,,,f,: i:p l!]O)i&

~~~~~~~nG~-~~x.~n~J:-'j~t.:0~Cb~X.~~bLh

t.:v' o i:rOOi&f/ffi, 1998if:9fl, ~tJ5'\-CO)'J"y-f--.::.O);t~'J rH-'J

:,, FY r J O)]Jlj17ij0)7'j: "' 00~~,ltl"l...titii (m}l!H;:J:;( ~✓ · ;/--:$') O)j~ 1±\ 'i:­

i/iil't!!~-t ~ .:cl: l"l~ U.:liil' l'J ;0,, 2008Jf:O) ::t '):,, ~y 7'i:-i:p001:

Session 111 165