0+aih +iN 0 N P iyokoya.naist.jp/paper/datas/483/9551003.pdf · 0 #1+ 2& 34 !#5 6 *+#5+ # 7 8:9...

$: 0+aih +iN 0 N P iyokoya.naist.jp/paper/datas/483/9551003.pdf · 0 #1+ 2& 34 !#5 6 *+#5+ # 7 8:9 8:;+< =->?;@8BADCD8 E.F G'HJI@KMLNH PO $ RQ RSTVUNWXOZYN[\O*OZU^]M_`Oa_Jb`O.S.U+c$
��

$N@8

mP9H}WrQ$?XJLVg;KpE/

\0+aih|+iN\0*NjP

+, i

��/ � n ��

|

‘Ih<JX;QgX!gX

psJX&fJ ps79F‘Xl6

\@8O‘Ih<JX;QgX!gXpsJX&fJK

$N�)X � x?NWoH7FsP7?$N@8G"k#

+, i

X351 ’ #p >B 5x

i6 "( 5x

]< #: u5x

mP9H}WrQ$?XJLVg;KpE/

\0+aih|+iN\0*NjP�

+, i

bF<5

0h|+iN\0*NjPO0h|h}K*1kEWJ]jNlDG"k#C

K\0+aiGO\0*NJ0NXJKb++1N0-,88k?aK\0*N

NjP,$qHJk#\@8GOD-d+aiN0-,T@Ju7<K*$F\

0+aih|+i\0*NrjP9kj!rsF9k#sFj!GOh|VNP

~@+imP9H}WrQ$FXJN++1N0-rdj7"=NdjkLrp

KXJLVg; J+ai\0Khk++1N0-r-cs;kK5l?h|VG

N1YNQ=rxQ7F\0*NNhrjP9k#sFj!NC’OBjJXJ

N0-djrT&?aK

djH� �

djrHg;FQ$F$k3H"*hS

.j-Nb$\0*NjPrT&?aKXJLVg;Nm9rM87FXJH\

0*Nr,%7F$k3HG"k#\@8GOBh|rQ$?\0*NNjPB

3KhjsFj!N-z-r(9#

-<o<I

0h|h} � \0*NjP � \0+ai � mP9H}W � dj � � �

dj �LVg;

�‘Ih<JX;QgX!gX psJX&fJ ps79F‘Xl6 $N@8 �� / ! n ��" | #

$

� �� !�"�#%$&�'��(� � �*) �+� � ,-�.� /�� 0 #1�+� � 2&��34�!#5� �6� �*��+#5��+��#

�

7�8:9 8:;+< =->?;@8BADCD8

E.F�G'HJI@KMLNH

�PO $RQ $RS�TVUNWXOZYN[\O*OZU^]M_Òa_JbÒ.S.U+c $R[Md?Ufehgi_JbÒaQkjlWiUfS $mS.YNdf_nQo_JprqM_J[MbJ_JQ $m[sbJUNS.TMqhOa_JWc $mQ $mUf[Dt u�qhO $vO $mQw] $vxybJqhz{O1OZU|]M_ÒZ_JbÒ�S�U+c $m[Md/Ufe\gi_JbÒaQ jlWiUfS $RS�Yfdf_"Qo_JprqM_J[MbJ_JQ1UfehOZY $R[M_J]eh}^Y?S.U~c $R[Md�bJYfS�_JWoY?e�_�bJYNqMQo_�U�j�OZ�M_yYfTMTMYNWo_J[\O*eMYfb`�rdNWoUfqM[M]�S.U@O $RUN[Dt �X[4Oa� $RQ�Oa�M_ Q�$RQ � �/TMWoUNTVUNQa_.Y�S�_ÒZ�MUr]!OaU�]M_Òa_�bÒ*S�U@c $m[MdnUfehgi_JbÒaQ/jlWiUfS $RS�YfdN_�Qo_JprqM_J[MbJ_JQ/� ${OZ�!YS.U�c $R[Md.bJYNS._JWiYMt/�$mWoQXO � eMYfb`�rdNWoUNqM[M]?S�U@O $RUf[�TMYfWiYfS�_ÒZ_JWiQ�YNWo_k_JQXO $mS.Y�OZ_J]�� ${OZ� TVU $R[\ObJUfWiWo_JQoTVUN[M]M_J[MbJ_JQ�qMQ�$m[Md�WoUNeMqMQXO�QXOZY�O $mQiO $RbJQJt �X[�OZ� $mQw_JQiO $RS�Y@O $RUN[ �1qMQo_"Y�bJUfSke $R[MY@O $RUN[.U�j �_�QXO $RS�Y@O $RUN[�Yf[M] � �._JQiO $RS�Y@O $RUN[6jlUNW�QiOaYfehzm_�_JQXO $mS.Y�O $mUf[�U@j�YfTMTMYNWo_J[\O�eMYNbJ�rdfWiUfqM[M]S.U�O $mUf[Dt ��M_�eMYfb`�rdNWoUNqM[M]MQ5YNWo_wOZ�M_J[*Wi_Jd $mQXOZ_JWo_J]�qMQ $m[Md�_JQiO $RS�Y@Oa_J]�S�U@O $mUf[�TMYfWiYfS._Òa_JWoQJt�$m[MY@z{zv} � S.U+c $R[Md.Ufehgi_JbÒaQ"YfWi_�_��hOZWiYfbÒa_J]�jlWiUfS�Wi_Jd $mQiOa_JWo_J]�Yf]�gXYfbJ_J[\O $RS�YfdN_|jlWiYfS�_JQJt�X[OZ� $mQ�S.U�O $mUf[!]M_Òa_�bÒ $RUN[ ��Y@z{zRU+��jlUNW/_JWoWiUfWiQ $R[ Oa� $RQ/Wo_Jd $RQXOaWoY�O $mUf[4YN[M]!] $vc $m]M_kOZ�M_�UNW�$md $R[MY�z $mS.YNdf_JQ $m[rOaUnS�U+c $m[�d�Ufehgi_JbÒaQ|YN[M]!eMYfb`�rdNWoUNqM[M]MQ�j�UfW/Wi_`z�$mYfehzm_�S.U�O $mUf[!]M_Òa_Jb'O $RUN[Dt��MT�_JW�$mS._J[\OZY�z:Wo_JQoqhzvOaQ"Qo�MU+��OZ�M_�j�_JYfQ�$Re ${z�${Oo}yU�j�OZ�M_|TMWiUfT�UNQo_J]�S�_'Oa�MUr]Dt

��D��MI@��Gf��XS.YfdN_|Qo_JprqM_J[MbJ_JQ � �U@O $RUN[?��_ÒZ_JbÒ $mUf[ � �U+c $m[Md�bJYNS._JWiY �� UfeMqMQXO�QXOZY�O $mQiO $RbJQ � �_�QXO $RS�Y@O $RUN[ � � ��_JQXO $RS�Y@O $RUN[ �V _Jd $RQXOaWoY@O $RUN[

� �|¡�¢l£¥¤i¦¨§ ¢ :© ¤X¢lª«¢ � ¬ ¤i+¡`¦�£¥®�¤i¯'£/°Z± ¯�±v°`¦²®�¡Z£lª³°`¯ �J´ ¢l£¥¤i®�¢ ��µ ¦²¡`¶+·+¡Z£�¤ �~¸P© °J°Z¹w°Z± ¯~±{°`¦²®�¡Z£²ª«°`¯�~¸ ª«¤i¯ ¸ ¤ � � ¡`¦²¡ ¯�¢�£²ªº£�·�£�¤�°Z± ��¸ ª³¤X¯ ¸ ¤»¡`¯�¶ ¤ ¸¨© ¯+°Z¹³°`¼ ´�� ½ ¤X¾�¦²·+¡`¦ ´ ��"�� #

$�$

\ !

��O8aK

�

��mP9H}WrQ$?XJN0-dj �� t � XJN0-djKX9k>j ��

� t � h|VNP~@5w ��

� t � mP9H}WNXJN0-djXN,Q �� t � � �

djKhkXJN0-Qia<?dj�� Khkr! ��

� t � djKhk0-Qia<?N:)= ��

��XJLVg;rQ$?\0*NjP

��rt �

\0*NjPN"k4j:‘ �� rt � vFNhH7-$MN_j ��

� � \0*NNjPB3��

� t �XJN0-,MFQ9GI%KawG-klg �� t �@t �

B3� � }[*Ju7 J:<‘N_K ��

� t �@t � B3 �� \0*NNmk Js6jN_K �� t �@t �

B3� � +aiN#g\0 Jm<k\s6jK ��

� t �@t �B3

� � #t\0*N J:<‘\s6jK �� t � B3

� � XJN0-bGkKfS*g-Jawm9,"klg J>

hNUl<‘V9,Khk\0*NjPHNfSK �� t �

M! ��

��‘9S

��

U-� �

2M8%��

$�$ $

^ \ !

� t � C’@jPN?aN&#sI&N_j �� rt �

XJLVg;Nm9rM87?s‘wY �� t �

\0*NNjPkL JB3��

:<‘$sK �� t � \0*NNjPkL JB3 � � 8}XNs6jK �� t �

\0*NNjPkL JB3��

~WsjNm<k\&}XNs6jK � �� t �\0*NNjPkL JB3

��:<‘"&H\&}XNs6jK � � �� t �

\0*NNjPkL JB3��

+aik@N0}XN?T\0K � ��

$vc

��O8aK

0h|+iN\0*NjPO0h|h}K*1kEWJ]jN1DG"k,"

\0+aiGO\0*NJ0NXJKb++1N0-,88k?aK\0*NN

jP,$qHJk#\0+aih|+iN\0*NjPO"c(P\09k+0

V+i0}r+aiG+F>N+0VdbTTJIN\0c2*r/+9kh&

Ju7G,WHJk#\@8GOD-d+aiN0-,T@Ju7<K*$F\

0+aih|+i\0*NrjP9kj!KD$FRYk#

3l^G\0+aih|+iN\0*NjPKX9kM9Jj!,sF5lF

-?#e=*Jj!H7FKB8Q9rQ$k}! � �� "*WF#+kUm<

rQ$k}! � �� "}W*J!jrQ$k}! � � � "XJLVg;rQ$k}

! � �� JI,"k#

KB8Q9rQ$k}!GOFh|KP7FKB8Q9 J#4Kw%"D4

KQYKrT&#+ai?0,BJN_Nlg"XJOh|eN1@ J��UfbJqMQ�U@j

��MTMYN[MQ�$RUN[ � ��K+iN|MuN0-H7FQ,5lkNG"

��r6@H9

ke-NQ9h|fGOXJOe?.,N_N0-r}D#7?,CFQ9h|

fGb>.,N0-r}DNhH7F\0*N,jPG-k � � � � � � #7+73N

}!GO+aiH18}~K\09k*NOjP$qHJk#

*WF#+kUm<rQ$k}!GOUm<Nc$+iXJH\0*Nr,%

9k � �� #7+73N}!GO5NJ*WF#+kUm<,@ilJ$lg

KO\0*NjPO$qHJk#*WF#+kUm<djKX7FO3l^GK

M9Jj!,sF5lF$k � �� ,"5NJ*WF#+kUm<djOM

3H7F$qJdjG"k#

}W*J!jrQ$k}!GO\0*NNhK09kF@,}W*J!jKh

jXJN0-bGkK>oJ$0-r}D@H7F!P5lk � � � #7+73N}

!O#(Jt}rOrQ$k?aKW;39H,g-$H$&g@,"k#

XJLVg;rQ$k}!GO"^:Y[* J]MUfS $R[MYN[\O

KJ0-H7FXJN

0-rdj9k#=7F=NdjkLKpE$Fh|VGXJLVg; J+ai

\0Khk++1N0-r-cs;kK7"=liNh|VGNQ=, J?H(

P1YNQ=JIKrxQ7F\0*NrjP9k � �� #3N}!GOY[*JX

�

JN0-, � !50-bGkJIGawG-kJiP\0*NrBj7FjP9

k3H,G-k#?/N0h|K*$FXJN0-r � !50-bGkGaw9

k3H,G-kNG"3N}!rQ$k3HKhCFz(*+DBj*JBQ-

Nb$\0*NjPNB=,|TG-k#

XJLVg;KpE/}!GOhLbKXJJ0N\0*N,8_9kh|+

iXJN0-rdj9k3H,Wa5lk#XJH\0*N,,%5lF$J$

u7GO"\0*NK09kG<?,0lM JUfqhOiz�$m_JW

KHJk?aXJN0-r

57/dj9kN,$qG"k#{W]i � �� Oh|VNF$P~@rQ$FX

JN0-rdj7F$k#3NH-G<?fK^^lkUfqhOiz�$m_JW

r"i+8aS

|9k3HKhjXJN0-raaF$k#{W]iOUfqhOiz�$m_JW

N=jKRe<

j9F#C/rQ$F$k?aKsoKTBjG"kHM(ilk#UfqhOiz�$m_JWr^‘G<?KP7F

UfqhOiz�$m_JWNFAru1:KQia<?rdj9k

-zJj!KmP9H}W � �� ,"k J?@7"UfqhOiz�$R_JW

NdgO��

$~G

J1lPJiJ$K#�\Y+��M[M_`}

i � � � � OP~@rQ$:Kh|VN1YMN9r

>\D9H7FmP9H}WrQ$FXJN0-rdj9kj!rsF7F$k#�\Y@�"�M[M_`}iOmP9H}WNlj!G"k

dj J

�_JQXO $RS�Y@O $RUN[KrQ$F$

k,"

djO@ilkr,i|MKM89k?a,ZJi|M,T@JlgK

OBj7?kL,@ilJ$#

^?"{W]i � �� Oh|VGNXJLVg;rTC?e"XJLVg;5l

?h|VGN9,KpE$F\0*NNjPrTCF$k#9,KpE/}!G

Oawm9JIK/x9kXJLVg;Nm9 J:lKKhCFmjPr88d

9$#

=3G\@8GOh|VNXJLVg;KpE$F\0*NrjP9k7?J

j!rsF9k#sFj!GOh|VNP~@+imP9H}WrQ$FXJN

++1N0-rdj7"=NdjkLrpKXJLVg;5l?h|VGN1Y

NQ=rxQ7F\0*NNhrjP9k#sFj!NC’OBjJXJN0-

djrT&?aKmP9H}WK*1k

djHG. � hfVM J�D_JYfQXO �_J] $mYf[

U@j��\prqMYNWo_JQ � � �"k$O

� �_J] �KdjrHg;FQ$F$k3H"*hS.

j-Nb$\0*NjPrT&?aKXJLVg;Nm9rM87FXJH\0

�

*Nr,%7F$k3HG"k#

J<"� OGmP9H}WrQ$?XJN0-djKD$F"�OGXJLVg

;rQ$?\0*NjPKD$F=l>lb@7"�OGBh|rQ$?\0*

NNjPB3KhjsFj!N-z-r(7"GeK�OG^HaH#eN]j

rRYk#

�

� �mP9H}WrQ$?XJN0-dj

\0+aih|VNXJLVg;rT&?aKOXJN++1N0-raak

,W,"k#\OGOXJN0-rh|bNY[*J0-G"kH+J7"h|

VNP~@+imP9H}WrQ$FXJN0-rdj9k}!KD$FRYk#

��XJN0-djKX9k>j

hLbKXJJ0N\0*N,8_9kh|+iNXJN0-djO"\0*

NJIK/x9kUfqhOiz�$m_JW

r^‘G<?+iNdjHJkNG$qJdjG"k#

5iK"+aiN\0KhCF88kXJN++1N0-O#(JNG=N0-

r5NKdj9kNO$qJdjG"k#=3G\&fGO3liNdjrrh

9k?aKlLK.j)DJ<N � DN>j� � *hS � � rxQ7Fh|VNP

~@+imP9H}WKhjXJN0-rdj9k#^?"\&fN\* Jdj

_jK+i>j� � ,.)9k#� � G<?fNUfqhOiz�$m_JW

NdgO��

$~G"k

3N>jOXJN0-djKmP9H}Wr,Q9k?aN,WroG"j"

3NlgNUfqhOiz�$m_JW

O\0*NeNC’@*hSXJeNmP~@G"k#?/

Nh|K*$F\0*NNNhOXJhjb.5/""39kh|VGNP~@

5wGOmP~O/J$HM(ilkNG"3N>jOB]*G"k#

� � XJN++1N0-O � !50-bGk JMFQ9KGawG-k

MFQ9 � � �� K �� O��

� �� ! �� #" �� %$ ��&� �%'�!( �� %) ��&� �%*

��

G=5lk#33G"K �,+ �#".-,�! 0/

O0-Qia<?G"j"�� " �1��2�3 ��4�2� �

O=l>lQ90"eNB8G"k#MFQ9Ok@rGj7Fk4rQ(kl

gNB8Q90G"k,"k@\0KX7FbXJ,?LGawG-klg"D

^j+aiNk@\0KhkXJeNF@GN|T-}~NQ=,+aiHXJ

Nw%KfYF.5$lgK3N>jO.)9k#0h|GO"39kh|VG

�

Nk@\0,.5$NG3N>j,.)7d9/"0h|h}KX9k?/N&

fG3N>j,Q$ilF$k � �� #� � h|VG88kXJN++1N0-OT@G"k

3N>jO\&f,D-d+aiN\0,T@Ju7<GN\0*NjPr\

*H7F$k+iG"j"3lO\j!N,QOOrH%9kbNG"k#

��h|VNP~@5w

\&fGOh|VNP~@rQ$FXJN0-rdj9k#33GO""39

k � DNh| Jp‘h|H2Hh|KVGNP~@rD9‘!!j! J�\_JprqM_J[\O $mY@z

� $RS $vzmYfW $vOi}n��_`Oa_Jb`O $mUf[ �"zRdNUfW $vOa�MS �� h��K � � �� rQ$Faak#

[email protected]/aak?aKO3<J<@d9]CHuN@JINC’@

rQ$FP~E1rT&,W,"k#^?"XJN0-r.j-I/dj9k?

aKOP~@,h|4NKlMK,[7F$kN,>^7$#=3Gp‘h|e

K � �� DN&#sI&ryVVK[V J��

K7"F&#sI&b+i$s

?l9H*Zl<? � � �� NPOM,GgG"k@ �� - �

� � � - � �r=l>l

�@:DC’@H7FjP9k#$s?l9H*Zl<?GOh|e

N.NhK*1k}~-N,6,g-J@ J3<J<@d9]CHuN@JIK

,C’@H7FjP5lk#3NC’@r� �h��

rQ$F2Hh|eN@ �� HP~E1k#

�

N

1 2 M

12

^ � t � C’@jPN?aN&#sI&N_j

��mP9H}WNXJN0-djXN,Q

\&fGOh|VNXJLVg;rT&?aK0a � t � G@il?P~@rQ

$FXJN0-Qia<?Krdj9k#3NH-eRNP~@KO

UNqhOoz $R_JWJ*

bK\0*NeNC’@K,TDr*K^^lF7^&?a"GblL*JG.

� h!GOUfqhOiz�$m_JW

NFAru1F57$Qia<?,@ilJ$H$&dj,"

k#\&fGO3Ndjrrh9k?aKmP9H}WrQ$k#

mP9H}WKO"3*Jj!G"k

djH%6*Jj!G"k� �

dj

N2DNe=*Jj!,"k#

djOb:YJdj,D=G"k,"+V7!

rQ$Frraak?aK\&fNh&K,ZJi|M,T@JlgKO,Q9

k3H,G-J$#l}N� �

djOpt/8*Jr!KhCFdjG-kN

Gi|M,TWG"k#7+7� �

djOs~ANG,=djHJk?aG,

rr+D1kN,q7/"lL*KO‘G,r7+aak3H,G-J$#=3

G\&fGO0RNF$P~@rQ$F"^:� �

djKhjXJN0-Qi

a<?raa"@il?‘G,rri|MH7F

djrT&3HKhjQi

a<?r:)=9k#J<GO"P~@ � � � H � �� Nw%rD9 � � �

� �� K � � � � � � �� K � ��

�

� � �� $ � ��

$ � � �H7FdjrT&#33G"

�� % �� " � � � � � � � O=l>l � �� " � � K � � � � NB8

G"k#

�� djKhkXJN0-Qia<?dj �� Khkr!

\&fGOh|VNXJLVg;KQ$kXJN0-Qia<?raak?a

K"^:i|MN_j,TWJ� �

djrQ$Fh|VNP~@+iXJN0

-Qia<?rdj9k#3N� �

djO!0GjA5lk#� � K �� S�_J] $RYN[ + � �� $ � K � /�� S $m[ � � ��

djGO3Nh&KD9N � hNfVMrG.H9k3HKhjUfqhOiz�$m_JW

N

FAru1:K0-Qia<?Krdj9k3H,G-k#lL*KOis@‘

5sWjs0rQ$?dj,Tolk � �� #3NdjON(*J‘nG"j"57

$dj,TolkN(,G<?fNUfqhOiz�$m_JW

Ndg"8\NWGNt*hS8\

N5sWjs0stKM87F7^&#=N?a"h}NB4-rN]9k?a

KOjvg-J5sWjs0st,,WHJj"z(,-=9kH$&dj,"

k � �� #\&fGOdA*"k4j:‘ J _J[�_`O $Rb ��zRdNUfW $vOa��S � � K� �� rQ$F

� �

djrT&# � O>hj!GOrh,$qG"C?M9JG,=djKP7F

‘G,rrz(*Kaak3H,G-k-zJj!G"j"^?\&fGO"3

9kh|VGN0-Qia<?djrP]H7F$k?aKrN5wOOr"k

xY)B9k3H,G-kNG � KhjBj*+Dz(*Jdj,|TG-

k#5iK" � NC’H7FBsh}K,7F$k3H,"k#=T79F‘

GOBsh}rQ$F$J$,"-h*KOBsh}Khj5iJkb.=,|

TG-k � � �� #J<GO" � rQ$?� �

djKhkXJN0-Qia<?N

dj}!KD$Fb@9k#� ��w’NNjA

0-Qia<?K � + � "&- �! 0/

rDN � Nw’N �� H9k#

�� " �!$ �!' �!( �!) ��* �� ! � � � ��

� � �,~YNjA

FDNN,~Y� � r � � � �

S�_J] $RYN[ + � �� $ � K � � / � � �KhCFW;9k#33G

K � Ow’N �� N=90-Qia<?G"k#� � �dA,’N_j

D.Nh&K7F!$eNDN2r8.9k#^:=$eNDN2r,~YN

g-$gKBYk#=Ne"<LNljNdgNDNrqA7FCG5;k#=7

FqA5lJ+C?eLNDNNf+iis@‘K*s@Z"rr95;F J3

3GO � @r9rHQK77$DNr8.9k3HKhjDNNmtrljK]

D#GeKFDNKP7FM3Q[rBT9k#� � � djh}NBT

\&fGOis@‘K8.5;?i|DN2rljNstN$ereGbCF

J=5;"J=*;~K*$FGg,~YrbDDNNw’NG"k0-Qi

a<?K �rrH9k#

�� djKhk0-Qia<?N:)=

\&fGO.j-Nb$XJLVg;rT&?aK"0a � t � N� �

dj

KhCF@il?0-Qia<?K �ri|MH7F

djrT&3HKhj0

-Qia<?r:)=9k#

djGOJ<Nh&J+V7E_D1G. � hJ�¨Oa_JWoY�O ${cr_`zv} _`��_�$RdN��Oa_J] �D_JYNQiO �\prqMYNWo_JQ � � � � K! � �� KhCFQia<?dj

rT&#

� � djMK��

J� O+V7str=9KNi|MH7FK �r?(k#

K��K � � � �

� � FP~@4HKD9 � �� K�� KpE$FE_ �� K�� rW;9k#33GO

E_XtH7F}+-NI$��qM�N_`}

Nu ${��_�$mdf�fO

Xt � �� rQ$F$k#

��

$�$ ${j � � � �� ${j � � � ��

� � �

�

33G" � � � � � �� S._J] $mYf[ + � � � / � � �G"k#FG<?KE_ �� r?(k3HKhj?M+i0l?G<? J

UfqhOiz�$m_JWK

NFArS|9k3H,G-k#� � !NG. � h!rBT7"djMr979k#

� � K �� " ��

�� "��

�� " �� K � � � ��

$ � K �� " � � S $R[ � � �� E_ �� ,Q=7J/Jk^G � � *hS

� � Nh}r+V7"}+M �Kr@k#

\&fGO\0*NrjP9k?aK"JeNh&K7F@il?XJN0-

Qia<? �KrQ$Fh|VNXJLVg;rT&#

�

� �XJLVg;rQ$?\0*NjP

\&fGO0OG@il?XJN0-Qia<?rQ$Fh|VNXJLVg

;rT&3HKhjXJN++1N0-r-cs;k7"XJLVg;5l?h

|rQ$F\0*NrjP9k#\OGOXJLVg;5l?h|+i\0*N

rjP9k}!KD$FRYk#

� ��\0*NjPN"k4j:‘

.j-Nb$\0*NjPrT&?aKOXJN0-bGkNawm9JIK

/x9kXJLVg;Nm9 J:lKr[}7J1lPJiJ$#=3G\&f

GOh|r � �� hGN.VmC/K,d7"J<Nh&JVmC/1LGN

rOKhj\0*NNhrjP9k#

^: � OG@il?XJN0-Qia<? �KrQ$Fp‘h| �� H2Hh| ��

HNVGXJLVg;rT$"=Ne3liNh|VGVmC/r1LH7Fs

‘wYrW;9k#b7XJLVg;Km9,J$JiP"h| �� fNVmC/ � � � � ,XJNhNlg" � � � � HP~9kLVNh| � � fNNh � � � � �

HNs‘wY � Jb.=N?a!0G>AK

� �� "

� ��

� � " � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

O.5/"UK\0*NNhNlgg-/JkNG7-$Mh}Khj\0*N

Nhr!PG-k#7+7\&fNlg"XJLVg;KawKhkm9,\A

*K8_9k#=3GNh � � � � � N~UGs‘wYraak3HrM("~U

Nh JvFNhK� K*1ks‘wY � ��

� �� "

� ��

� � " � � � � � � � � � ��

N&A�DGb7-$M � J<NbN,"lP

� � � � OXJNhG"kH7"

=&GJ1lP\0*NNhH9k#?@7"�� G"k J

�� K#

� � � � �� XJNh

${j! � � � �� "�\0*NNh

U�OZ�M_JW¨� $mQo_

� �

R(m,n)

R(m+u,n+v)B(m,n)

IB IR

A

^�rt �

XJLVg;Nm9rM87?s‘wY

� ��vFNhH7-$MN_j

0aN"k4j:‘K*$FdjHJkN,vFNh � H7-$M � Ng-

5G"j"\0*NNhr57/jP9k?aKO3lir,ZK_j9k,W

,"k#\&fGOmP9H}WrQ$FvFNhr_j7"&DiNm9bG

k � �� rQ$F7-$Mr_j9k#

vFNh,.5$HXJr\0*NH7Fm!P9k2l,"k#UKg-a

.kH\0*NrXJH7F!PLl9kdg,g-/Jk#=3GLVg;N

m9,[,,&9-G"kH>j7FmP9H}W+idj8‘P9 �� r�� S._J] $mYf[ + � ��

�K � / � � � �

H7 � �� "LVg;m9NGgM JvFMK� �� rdj8‘P9 �� N � t � \� ��

� � � � � � � � �� S._J] $mYf[ + � �� K � / � ��

K_j7 � �� ">B, � �� N_brvFNh � H9k#

^?"7-$MH7FGjMrQ$?lg",ZJ7-$MN_j,$qJ?

aKFQ-,;Jolk#=3G7-$M � rh|NF/9AcKpE$FVmC

/4HK_j9k#

��

&DiNm9bGkrQ$kH"VmC/r�� :i7?H-N5NV

mC/HNs‘wYOF<i<8+7"b!Ny.‘r5k9k3HG

� ��"� ��" ��

��

�� "��" ��

��

HawG-k#33G"�� "�

�� O=l>lVmC/bN@�� " �� K*1k1YMG"j"�"�

�O=l>l

�"�}~N

y,MG"k#3N0+iXJNhNVmC/ � � � � KP7Fh|NLR=K

hCF88@ks‘wY � �� NGgM JvFMK,aailkNG"3lr

7-$M � H9k#

� � S�Y�� ) � � � � � �� ) +� ��"� ��" �� / � ��

J*"3N7-$M � Oh|NN$:r4/M87F$J$NG"CKh|VG

N1YNQ=KP7Fe$#\&fGOs‘wY � �� raakH-VmC/

4HKh|r5,=7F+iaakh&K7F$k#h|N5,=OF@N1Y

M+iVmC/bN?Q1YMrz/3HKhjT&#

JeNh&KvFNh � bG@ilks‘wY � �� H7-$M � HNg.

fSrT$"XJLVg;5l?h|+i\0*NrjP9k#

� �

� �\0*NNjPB3

sFj!N-z-r(9?aK+air\05;J,i#F7?Bh|rQ$

F\0*NNjPB3rTC?#W;!Oo</9F<7gs J�� Y@zmTM�MY

Kr

HQ7"+aiOTNNSG*+ai J� �� YN[M]h} bJYfS�� KrHQ7?#

B3GO��DNC’@ J� � � � �

KrQ$FXJN0-djrTC?#� �h� �KhkP~@5wKO

� ��

hGNFsWl<HrHQ7"P~Ll,

/3iJ$h&K5wOOOg-aKHC? J� � � � � hGK#\0*NNjPh

}Oh|r��hGNVmC/ J� � � � � � �

KK,d7""39k � Ul<

‘VGTC?#J*"h|N~UtNljNh J<+i � � hGxYKO"i+

8aXJNhH7Fh}7?#

^?"XJN0-djK*1k � NQia<?O=l>lDNt��"$e

ret � � "qA(��

"M3Q[(� �

"w’N9� � SCHG"k#w’N9

NbuOQia<?� " - �%*

=l>l�SCHG"j"FQia<?NOOO=

l>l �� " �!) � � � � � � �� " � " � � � � �� 0t ��!$ � ( � � � � �� $ � $ � � � � �� 0t ��!' �!* � � �� ' � ' � � � � �� 0t �

� � � �

G"k#J*" � Khk� �

djGO5wOOr:i9?aK� � ��

r�K

Gj JXJN0-r"U#sQ9GawK7""i+8aw’N+ihj|$F

djrTC?#?@7"e3N

djGO4FNQia<?� "&-��%

KD$Fd

jrTC?#3liN � Qia<?O4FP3*Kja?#

J<GO"�Mt �

GXJN0-,MFQ9GI%KawG-klgN\j!N-z

-rN’9k?aK+aiNk@\0,fS*.5JM9J\0+aih|KP

9k\0*NNjPB3"� t � GXJN0-bGkKfS*g-Jawm9,"k

lgGb\j!KhCF"kxYNm9r[}7F\0*NrjPG-k3Hr

(9?aK+aiNk@\0,fS*g-J\0+aih|KP9k\0*NN

jPB3r=l>lTC?#

� �

� ��XJN0-,MFQ9GI%KawG-klg

XJN0-,MFQ9GI%KawG-klg"\j!KhCF\0*NrI

%KjPG-k3HrN’9k?aKM9JD-d+aiN\0KP7FB3r

TC?#J*"J<NB3kLGO�s\"� s\K=l>l6h| J

� � ��

hG"ru � � � ,4K*hS\j!KhCFjP5l?\0*NNhr(9#

� � �� B3��

}[*Ju7 J:<‘N_K

k@\0r<oJ$+ai‘n J:<‘"Qs"AkH"m<kKNlg"XJ

N0-OMFQ9Gm957K==G-k#3NB3GO=Nh&J}[*Jc

H7F+air:<‘$s5;J,i#F7?h|s J� �

Ul<‘�CKKP7

FTC?B3kLNltr^ � � � K(9#?@7"+airjK}CF#F7?

?a7)KOjVlKhky.Jk@\0,8_9k#h|VGN1YNQ=,

.5$?aK/3C?HWolkjPLl*hSh|NN$:,6xHWolk

mjP,ltG/87F$k,"\j!Khj\0*N JbTT*hSjd+<K

,[\57/jP5lF$k#

� � �� B3��

\0*NNmk Js6jN_K

+aiK8}XNs6jr?(F\0*Nrmk7J,i#F7?h|s J� �

Ul<‘�CKKP7FTC?B3kLNltr^ � � � K(9#3NB3GO\0

*Nrmk7J,i#F7??a6h|fGN\0*NN++1N0-,XJN

0-hjb.5$#3Nh&JlgKOXJN0-Ni|MH7F,ZJMr?

(kN,soK$qJ?a"

djN_GO5NJXJLVg;,q7$HW

olk#\j!GOXJLVg;,57/TolF\0*N JbTTK,[\5

7/jP5lF$k#?@7"h|VGN1YNQ=,.5$?aK/3C?H

WolkjPLl*hSh|NN$:,6xHWolkmjP,ltG/87F

$k#

� �

� � �� B3� �

+aiN#g\0 Jm<k\s6jK

+aiK~WsjNm<kH&}XNs6jr1~K?(J,i#F7?h|

s J��

Ul<‘�CKKP7FTC?B3kLNltr^ � � � K(9#3NB3

GO+aiK#(J0-r?(?,"\j!Khj\0*N J+0VK,[\5

7/jP5lF$k#?@7"h|VGN1YNQ=,.5$?aK/3C?H

WolkjPLl*hSh|NN$:,6xHWolkmjP,/87F$k#

CK+0VNf{t,K*$Fg-JjPLl,88F$k,"3lO+0V,

[\e?K\07??aKf{t,K*1k1YNQ=,.5+C??aHWo

lk#

� � �� B3 � � #t\0*N J:<‘\s6jK

+aiK:<‘"&HH&}XNs6jr1~K?(J,i#tN\0*Nr

#F7?h|s J��

Ul<‘�CKKP7FTC?B3kLNltr^ � � � K(

9#3NB3GOhLbK_$Kr99k#tN\0*N,8_9k,"\j!

Khj=l>lN\0*N J� fN+0VK,[\57/jP5lF$k#?@

7"h|VGN1YNQ=,.5$?aK/3C?HWolkjPLl*hSh

|NN$:,6xHWolkmjP,ltG/87F$k#

J*"3liNB3K*$F�sN\0*NjPKW7?W;~VOP~@5

w Jh|Nh~_b^‘KKs � � C"XJN0-djKs�rt �

C"\0*NjP

Ks�C"Ws � � CG"k#

� ��B3

� XJN0-bGkKfS*g-Jawm9,"klg

J>hNUl<‘V9,Khk\0*NjPHNfSK

+ai,k@rfS*g-/?T\09klg"XJNB]N0-H>jN0

- JMFQ9KHNVKfS*g-Jm9,/89k#3NB3GO=Nh&J

cH7F"+air\09F<8NeK\;Fs� ��bJS

:D0}X?T\05;

J,i#F7?h|sKP7FTC?#J*"i|LV+iXJ JIK^GNw

%Os��S

G"j"XJN|T-Os�Nt �@S

G"k#

� �

B3kLNltr^ � � � K(9#8e,6h| J� ��

�� hG"ru � � � ,4K

G"k#XJK++1N0-,88F$kMRr&eK(9#3lO!Ul<‘

HN6h|1NN9,h|G"k#!Ul<‘HNVGXJLVg;,Tol?

MRr8<K(9#3lOXJLVg;rTC?eN9,h|r � M=7?bN

G"k#r$t,, � M=KhCFjP5l?t,G"j" � M=N7-$MO

\0*NNNh,I%KjP5lkh&KB3*K��

Hja?#3NB3GO

XJLVg;KfS*g-Jawm9,8_9ku7GTC??a"XJeKb

g-JjPNh,88F$k#\j!KhCFjP5l?\0*NNhr&<K

(9#\j!KhjXJLVg;Nm9,[}5lF\0*N JM*KN_,[

\57/jP5lF$k#?@7"h|VGN1YNQ=,.5$?aK/3C

?HWolkjPLl*hSh|NN$:,6xHWolkmjP,ltG/8

7F$k#

J*"3NB3K*$F�sN\0*NjPKW7?W;~VOP~@5w

Jh|Nh~_b^‘KKs��

C"XJN0-djKs�rt �

C"\0*NjPK

s� � C"Ws

��CG"k#

� ��M!

� t � aN>j� � *hS � � ,.)9klg"

�Mt �aNB3kL+i\j!KhC

F\0+aih|+i\0*Nr[\I%KjPG-k3H,N’G-?#CK�Mt �Nt � aNB3 � GOi|MN_j,q7$u7GTC??a>hN

djKpE

/XJN0-djj!GOBjJdj,$qG"kHM(ilk,"\j!GO

BjJdj,D=G"C?#5iKXJN0-bGkKfS*g-Jm9,"k

lg">hNUl<‘V9,KpE/\0*NNjPj!GOg-JmjP,/

89kHM(ilk,"�Mt � aNB3kL+i\j!KhCF"kxYNm9Ji

[}7F\0*Nr[\I%KjPG-k3H,N’G-?#?@7"�Mt � � �Mt � N

ltK*$FjPLl JB3�K*1k+0VNf{t,JIKKdmjP JB

3�NUl<‘

�dB3

�NUl<‘

�JIKK,88?#

D-d+ai\0NQ=Kb++oi:[\I%JjPkL,@il?}3H

7F

� �

� � djH

� �djrHg;FXJN0-rdj7?3H

� � XJLVg;Nm9rM87FXJH\0*Nr,%7?3H� � h|NF/9AcKpE$F\0*NjP~N7-$Mr_j7?3H

JI,M(ilk#J*"� t � aN>j� � � � � ,.)7J$lg"D^j\j!,

6}*K]/$+J$lgH7F"� � hLbK?tN\0*N,8_7FXJe

NC’@hjb\0*NeNC’@N},t?/jP5lklgd � � 0bD-

Nh&JXJNzL,c7$D-bK*$F+ai,k@rg-/Q99klg

JI,M(ilk#

jPLlO1YMN9KpE/s‘wYKhCF\0*NNjPrTCF$k

?aK/3k1YMNQ=,.5$t,GNjPLlKhkH3m,g-$#P

vH7FO(C8JIN>Nh|C’+i@il?kLHN}g,M(ilk#

mjPN*bJ6xH7FOh|NN$:,M(ilk#\j!GOh|NN

$:r4/M8;:K\0*NjP~N7-$MrjaF$k+iG"k#7+

7mCFjP5l?NhN[HsI,I)7?y.NhJNGN$:.,H7F

|nD=G"k#

^?"\&fGOXJN0-djKQ$kP~@r� �h��

KhCF5w7F$

k?aFP~@KOh|NLR=KhjGg�ht �

JhGKNm9,"j"=l,

\0*NjPN.j- JXJN0-*hSLVg;m9Ndj:YKKg-/F

A7F$kHM(ilk#=3G"\0*NjPN.j-re2k?aK(C8

Nr@H7FC’@NLVrjak}!Khj5VT/;k1LN:YGP~@

raak3H,M(ilk#

5iK"B3KHQ7? � NQia<?*hSUl<‘VV J?$‘91<

kKO\0*NNh,I%KjP5lkh&KP3*Kja?bNG"j",Z

J � Qia<?*hS?$‘91<kN_jj!NN)KD$FO#e!$9

k,W,"k#

� �

��

Ul<‘�

��

Ul<‘�

��

Ul<‘��

��

Ul<‘� �

��

Ul<‘ � �

^� t �

\0*NNjPkL JB3� �

:<‘$sK

� �

��

Ul<‘�

��

Ul<‘�

��

Ul<‘�

��

Ul<‘�

��

Ul<‘�

^�Mt � \0*NNjPkL JB3 � � 8}XNs6jK

� �

��

Ul<‘�

��

Ul<‘�

��

Ul<‘��

��

Ul<‘� �

��

Ul<‘ � �

^� t �

\0*NNjPkL JB3��

~WsjNm<k\&}XNs6jK

� �

��

Ul<‘�

��

Ul<‘�

��

Ul<‘�

��

Ul<‘�

��

Ul<‘�

^�Mt �

\0*NNjPkL JB3��

:<‘"&H\&}XNs6jK

� �

��

6h| Ul<‘�HN9,h| ��

9,KhkjPkL \j!KhkjPkL

Ul<‘�

! ��

6h| Ul<‘�HN9,h| ��

9,KhkjPkL \j!KhkjPkL

Ul<‘�

^�Mt �

\0*NNjPkL JB3��

+aik@N0}XN?T\0K

��

� �‘9S

\@8GOmP9H}WrQ$?XJLVg;KpE$F\0+aih|+i

\0*NrjP9kj!rsF7"?o‘NBh|KP7F\0*NNjPB3

rTC?#sFj!GO

djH � Khk� �

djrHg;F"3Ul<

‘VNP~@+iXJN0-rdj9k3HKhjXJLVg;rT$"P~@

Nw% JD9K+imP9H}WKhj>A5l?XJLVg;Nm9rM87

FXJLVg;5l?h|eGXJH\0*NN,%rTC?#B3KhjM9

JD-d+ai\0KP7FBjKh|VNXJLVg;,G-k3HrN’7

?#5iK"\j!GOXJLVg;Nm9r"kxY[}7FBjK\0*N

,jPG-k3HrB3KhjN’7?#

\j!Ndj@H7FOh|VGN1YNQ=,.5Jt,K*$F\0*N

NjPLl,88k3HG"k##eOM9Ju7<GN,QrD=H9k?a

NXJN0-bGkN#(="B~VGN0nrD=H9k?aNFoh} JP

~@5w"XJN0-dj"\0*NjPKNb.=JI,]jG"k#

� �

U-

|"+i-WJfX3&fu@r:$?=UH&’"pCVBN#p>B5x"

]<#:u5x"37l?uj"d4Q’ujK6U7^9#

^?"\@8r^HakK"?j-WJfu@r:$?|psh}XVB&i

6"(5xK6U7^9#

GeK"B3QNh|G<?rs!7F:$?;’E$)Ht0qRN{W]

RaBSK\&frT&K"?jf(Or:$?=UH&’"pCVBtaK6

U7^9#

� �

2M8%

� �� t ��WiY��$m_JWDYN[M] t �"_`cfY�O $mY � H��_Òa_JbÒ $m[Md �U+c $m[Md �e\gi_JbÒZQDjlWiUfS�Y �U+c $m[Md �»zmY@OijlUfWiSI�� ! #"%$�&!'(�)�+*, ��-��#" � TMTDt � � � � �� t

� � ��t �"Y $mW�Yf[M].� t0/kt ��dfdfYNWX��Y@z � H��_Òa_JbÒ $m[Md21"[M_�� TV_JbÒZ_J] �U@c $R[Md �eMQXOZYNb`zR_JQ�Oa�MY@O

��TMTV_JYNW$m[|OZ�M_��»Y@Oa�|U@j�Y �"Y~c $RdNY@O $R[Md UfeVU�O I��3�4 �� 56�� 47 U�z�t � �DU�j � � � � TMTDt � �� t

� �� @D>H � H.j-psrbC?*WF#+kUm<+iNAu|5H=N

\0*N!PXN~QI� .X@ �87 U�z�t0� � � ¨�� "UMt � � TMTDt � � � � �� t

� �� &DJ � <T.B � HOUQ9rQ$?+aiQia<?NdjZS0h|

+iN\0*NN,%I� h|N’1&}r7s]8&‘ J � 1:9 � � KVi

@88 � TMTDt � � �� t

� �� _3-s � HmP9Hs"KpE/?E*WF#+kUm<NdjKD$FI�.X;s � � ;1�� t

� � � �5t � t ��t ��UfWiW�Yf[M]!��t=< t �qMWoWiY+} � H�fOaY@O $RQXO $RbJY�z1��_Òa_JbÒ $mUf[ U@j �X[M]M_JTV_J[M]M_J[\O �U�c�_

S._J[\OwjlWiUfS Y �U+c $m[Md �wYfS�_�WiYI�>�3*, @?�AB #"%$.CD��3��+"E5F�+*HG�'(�-�I"J? ��7 U@z¥t �� "UMt � �TMTDt � � � �� t

� �� {W]R � #p>B � d4Q’ � ]<#: � H� J,"U#sQ9rxQ7?

\0+aih|+iN0*NNjPI� .X;s � � 1 �� t

� � � ��t � Qoq � �»t ��[�YN[M]MYf[ Yf[M] ��t ��_`zR_Jd � H��bJbJqMWoY�OZ_��wUfS�TMq OaY@O $RUN[sU�j �ThO $mbJY@z��:zRU��

er}K1"Q�$m[Md �DY+}�_JWi_J] �U@O $RUN[ _JTMWi_JQo_J[rOaY@O $RUN[MQ I�L�M��4 �(� 5D�N� ��7 U@z¥t � � TMTDt � �� t

� �� t u�Ufe�_JW5YN[M]�� tO/ ${OoOozm_JW � H UNe�qMQXO �U@O $RUN[ ��[MY@z{} Q�$RQ I��@ ��5:C�� T�TDt � � �� t

� �

� �� 4#E- � Hh|h}K*1k}WbGkxQKX9kGaN0~�

mP9H

dj!H ?� �

p‘I�� A $+��3 � �3*, @?#��"J?��>A��"%� � � ?�� 7 U�z�t � � � ��UMt � � TMTDt � � �� t

� �� »tO� t UfqMQoQo_J_Jq�� Yf[M] �*t 4t �D_JWoU+} �J� � � 'J� �%� A ? �A��3�3��#" � '(� � ��A�� A��A ��+" � �NUN�M[< ${zR_`}�� \UN[MQ � �"_`� �wUfWo� � � � � � � t

� � � � � t ��t �\Y~��M[M_`}sYN[M] ��t �"}r_JW � H��UNS.TMYNb`O _JTMWo_JQo_J[\OZY�O $mUf[MQ�U@j 7 $R]M_JUNQ ��MWoUNqMdf�

��UNS $m[MYf[\O/YN[M] �qhz{O $mThzR_ �U@O $RUN[!�1QXO $mS.Y�O $mUf[I� ��L� #"L�� D&�� %7 U@z¥t � � ��"UMt � � TMTDt � �� t

� �� t �»t �UfWiY�c�_Jb � H7 $RQoqMY�z� �YfTMT $m[Md�e\}�Y Ufe�U�O U~c\_JW I��3�4 ��+�� >56&�� TMTDt �� t

� ��tO� t u�YfWi[M_JY?Yf[M] � t«�wt � ${zvcr_JWiS.YN[ � H� �1zRYNQaQ*U@j��"zmdfUNW�$vOa�M_JS.Q|jlUfW��YfQXO�� $Rd ${OZY�z

�iS�YfdN_ _Jd $mQXOZWiY@O $mUf[ I�J��N��L� #"L�� 5 �+*�G%'(�)A�� #7 U�z�t � � � � TMTDt � � � �� t

� �� Bo!T � 9xR2 � H8’MF#C/"k4j:‘I� <82� �� t

� � � � +,i � #p>B � ]<#: � 37l? � HmP9H}WrQ$?XJLV

g;KpE/\0+aih|+iN\0*NjPI� .X;s � � 1 � � �� t

� � �� +,i � #p>B � ]<#: � 37l? � HmP9H}WrQ$?XJLVg

o;KpE/\0+aih|+iN\0*NNjPI� phXh��

s4gV

i@88 � h � ,} � �� t

� �

0+aih +iN 0 N P iyokoya.naist.jp/paper/datas/483/9551003.pdf · 0 #1+ 2& 34 !#5 6 *+#5+ # 7 8:9...

Documents

Transcript of 0+aih +iN 0 N P iyokoya.naist.jp/paper/datas/483/9551003.pdf · 0 #1+ 2& 34 !#5 6 *+#5+ # 7 8:9...