Zoeken voor een Systematic ReviewZwemmen of verzuipen

Janneke Staaks, Mei 2017

Universiteitsbibliotheek

Janneke Staaks

j.staaks@uva.nl

@jstaaks

Subject Librarian UvA

Psychologie

Pedagogiek en Onderwijskunde

Antropologie

https://w

ww

.flic

kr.

com

/photo

s/r

osefire

risin

g/5

621438323

From research question to search question

Systematic search

Screening

inclusion/exclusion criteria

Critical appraisal

validity/relevance

Data synthesis

Narrative, quantitative and qualitative synthesis

The systematic review process

Disclaimer

6

https://www.flickr.com/photos/challiyan/1978399197

“Formulating a good

search strategy is a

dynamic and iterative

process”

Sensitivity and Specificity

Hit Miss

False

alarm

Correct

rejection

Zoekresultaat

Relevant

Artikel

yes

yes

no

no

Sensitivity and Specificity

Uitwerken onderzoeksvraag naar zoekvraag

(kernbegrippen)

Zoektechniek

Keuze databases

Keuze type literatuur

Etc..

Social responsibility

Responsibility

Care responsibility

Health care responsibility

Responsibilization

Individual responsibility

Informal caregiving responsibilities

Authority responsibility

Meest sensitief?

Social responsibility

Responsibility

Care responsibility

Health care responsibility

Responsibilization

Individual responsibility

Informal caregiving responsibilities

Authority responsibility

Zoektechniek

PsycINFO

=> 45.031 versus 5.677

Social responsibilit*

Responsibility

Care* responsibilit*

Health care responsibility

Responsibilization

Individual responsibilit*

Informal caregiving responsibilities

Authority responsibilit*

Vergroten sensitiviteit

PsycINFO

Social responsibilit*

Care* responsibilit*

Responsibilization

Individual responsibilit*

Authority responsibilit*

Vergroten sensitiviteit

PsycINFO

van

5.677 resultaten

naar

6.149 resultaten

En deze dan?

PsycINFO

Informal carers assumed prime responsibility

responsibilities of a caregiver

filial responsibility

responsibility for complex care

responsponsibility resides with spouse

responsibility-related caregiving

Reference check: 2 van de 12

Social responsibilit*

Care* responsibilit*

Responsibilization

Individual responsibilit*

Authority responsibilit*

Sensitiviteit èn specificiteit

PsycINFO

((care OR spouse) ADJ3 responsibilit*) OR social responsibilit* OR

responsibilization OR individual responsibilit* OR authority responsibilit*

OR filial responsibilit*

Social responsibilit*

Care* responsibilit*

Responsibilization

Individual responsibilit*

Authority responsibilit*

Sensitiviteit èn specificiteit

PsycINFO

((care OR spouse) ADJ3 responsibilit*) OR social responsibilit* OR

responsibilization OR individual responsibilit* OR authority responsibilit*

OR filial responsibilit*

van

6.149 resultaten

naar

7.200 resultaten

‘vrije tekst termen’

Velden waar ‘alles’ in kan staan (titel, samenvatting etc)

Dit houdt in dat je rekening moet houden met

spellingsvarianten, synoniemen en gerelateerde termen

Gecontroleerd vocabulaire

Subject headings, Mesh terms, thesaurus etc.

Velden waar de zoektermen uit een vooropgestelde lijst

geselecteerd worden

Zoeken in velden

PsycINFO

PsycINFO

PsycINFO

1 Title,

abstract,

keywords

((care OR spouse) ADJ3 responsibilit*)

OR social responsibilit* OR

responsibilization OR individual

responsibilit* OR authority responsibilit*

OR filial responsiblit*

7.200

2 Subject

headings

responsibility OR social responsibility

OR filial responsibility

10.456

1 OR 2 14.170

Vrije tekst termen en

gecontroleerd vocabulaire

1 Title,

abstract,

keywords

((care OR spouse) ADJ3 responsibilit*)

OR social responsibilit* OR

responsibilization OR individual

responsibilit* OR authority responsibilit*

OR filial responsiblit*

7.200

2 Subject

headings

responsibility OR social responsibility

OR filial responsibility

10.456

2 NOT 1 6.944

Vrije tekst termen en

gecontroleerd vocabulaire

Title,

abstract

and

keywords

Subject

headings

6.944

23

Van onderzoeksvraag naar zoekvraag

Search strategy

key concept

Responsibility

..

..

key concept

Informal care

Care at home

..

key concept

..

..

..

AND AND

OR

25

https://www.flickr.com/photos/challiyan/1978399197

“Formulating a good

search strategy is a

dynamic and iterative

process”

Kernbegrippen

#1 Maatschappelijk werk

#2 Jeugd

#3 Samenwerken

Samenwerken in het sociaal domein

“methoden die multidisciplinaire/interdisciplinaire

samenwerking stimuleren”

Kernbegrippen

#1 Maatschappelijk werk

#2 Jeugd

#3 Samenwerken

1 AND 2 AND 3 6.226 results in PsycINFO

Samenwerken in het sociaal domein

Search Samenwerken in het Sociaal Domein

Research question: Samenwerken in het sociaal domein

Databases

PsycINFO 6.226 results

Medline x.xxx results

Social services Abstracts x.xxx results

Sociological Abstracts x.xxx results

ERIC x.xxx results

Web of Science x.xxx results

Total x.xxx results

Total, deduplicated x.xxx results

Google Scholar xxx results were scanned,

xx results were selected

Other search techniques

• the following journals/conference proceedings/etc. were hand searched:

• Citation tracking (how; which articles, which database (GS or WoS))

• Expert consultation (how, who)

Kernbegrippen

#1 Maatschappelijk werk

#2 Jeugd

#3 Samenwerken

#4 Professionals

1 AND 2 AND 3 AND 4 2.154 results in PsycINFO

Samenwerken in het sociaal domein

Dank voor uw aandacht!

Bonus: Reproduceerbaarheid

Method

Search Strategy

Electronic searches were performed in PsycINFO,

ERIC and Web of Science with final searches

completed by December 26, 2011. The main search

strategy used combinations of keywords for web

lectures (weblectures OR online lectures OR

recorded lectures) and assessment (grades OR ..

((recorded OR recording* OR web OR webcast* OR online OR on-line OR

captur* OR video* OR audio* OR vodcast* OR podcast*) ADJ4 lectur*).ti,ab.

OR ((recorded OR recording* OR web OR webcast* OR online OR on-line

OR captur* OR video* OR audio* OR vodcast* OR podcast*).ti,ab. AND

lecture method/) OR (audiovisual instruction/ AND lectur*.ti,ab.) OR virtual

lectur*.ti,ab. OR videocollege*.af. OR weblecture*.af. OR webcollege*.af. OR

mediasite.af. OR sonic foundry.af. OR presentations 2 go.af. OR

presentations2go.af. OR kaltura.af. OR echo 360.af. OR echo360.af. OR

panopto.af. OR tegrity.af.

1.540

web lectures AND academic achievement 8

web lectures AND grades 13

web lectures AND study success 0

online lectures AND academic achievement 16

online lectures AND grades 33

online lectures AND study success 0

recorded lectures AND academic achievement 5

etcetera...

ERIC

Recorded lectures

Web lectures

Lecture capturing

Online lectures

Video lectures

Results in 185 hits

ERIC (Ovid)

Reproduceerbaarheid

Recorded lectures

Web lectures

Lecture capturing

Online lectures

Video lectures

Results in 731 hits

ERIC (EBSCO)

Reproduceerbaarheid

Reproduceerbaarheid

Ovid

EBSCO