qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s...

66
CLCU uCJr1qu © UOCC !2 !ACU tO IJJC 2OflLCC uo jo xcccq lwo b icbp urnA pc dnotcq iuponi cxbjicit bcuiou bwAqcq qrnt njj © IQ P E'1 F' O1L q cciqotc VII 4JU2 LC2CLACq jJOLt 2ccq0u2 O UOt qio o qJc 4tOwq J3m.Cfl1 Oj ECOIJOUJ!C KC2C91Cp MBEI Lc2c9Lcp bLouJ u 'poL Vu? ob!u!ou2 cxbLccq c tpoc o tp flWOL uq D!q CU1CL BCU9W!IJ 4cquJmr 2ICACU F'CAItt vuq ICIJIX1 bO2UL JJJ!2 bcbcL bi.t Oj; tpc cop K hcJJoMp!b bLour cJbrq cowwcuj qcnou iicic bLoAqcq p? ntpoi t9UJC tpc MtiOU 2c!cucc orwq ou OL prnucwj 2nbbol.r jpc accouq rnjJoL rjrnujc JJJ12 bbcL 1A92 l11JUU OL fJJG hL2CL I't!Wt COIJ9UCC LOL G11 BCCIL2 Q1JJ pLgJqX IIOtJJ 1U(1LA uJpqq NV OJ38 JOO 42CJJfl2CU2 VACUflG MVIIOL4VF Bf1JEVfl Oh ECOMONIC fiOLJCflJ b1bCL BIJICC 2CC1Xl0tC qq r QJCL 114 CLLIF2 IMIA 12 LHE1E NO1E 14BEB fiO1KII4O &VbEI 2EB1E2

Transcript of qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s...

Page 1: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

CLCU uCJr1qu © UOCC !2 !ACU tO IJJC 2OflLCCuo jo xcccq lwo b icbp urnA pc dnotcq iuponi cxbjicit bcuiou bwAqcq qrnt njj© IQ P E'1 F' O1L q cciqotc VII 4JU2 LC2CLACq jJOLt 2ccq0u2 O

UOt qio o qJc 4tOwq J3m.Cfl1 Oj ECOIJOUJ!C KC2C91CpMBEI� Lc2c9Lcp bLouJ u 'poL Vu? ob!u!ou2 cxbLccq c tpoc o tp flWOL uqD!q CU1CL BCU9W!IJ 4cquJmr 2ICACU F'CAItt vuq ICIJIX1 bO2UL JJJ!2 bcbcL bi.t Oj;tpc cop K hcJJoMp!b bLour cJbrq cowwcuj qcnou iicic bLoAqcq p?ntpoi t9UJC tpc MtiOU 2c!cucc orwq ou OL prnucwj 2nbbol.r jpc accouq rnjJoL rjrnujcJJJ12 bbcL 1A92 l11JUU OL fJJG hL2CL I't!Wt COIJ9UCC LOL G11 BCCIL2 Q1JJ pLgJqX IIOtJJ

1U(1LAuJpqq NV OJ38

JOO 42CJJfl2CU2 VACUflGMVIIOL4VF Bf1J�EVfl Oh ECOMONIC

fiOLJCflJ b1bCL

BIJICC 2CC1Xl0tCqq r QJCL

114 CLLIF2IMIA 12 LHE1�E NO1E

14BEB fiO1KII4O &VbEI 2EB1E2

Page 2: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

Jq 14BE11'W OJ38

HuLq flUAGL2t) cwpqq YW OJ38113 r!lwnGL CGUIGL Huq flu AGL2TOtjba1uJcu1 0j EC0110U! DCbI41JJQIJ1 0, ECOUOUJ!C2EML r QJ2CL BLIICC 2G1.(101

/AJA ffJQ2C CJJL9C1CU2PC2 91.G C0UUQC1G 114 ff1 flLJ I!A!IJ

gIG rapii CL!UJG bLcunnw 12 22oc1cq 1141JJ IJJG2G CIWLC1GL!2ffC2' Pill IItG 9LG jG lIAIU 10 cxbprni

ffLG ffJO2G 1JJ1 LGUGCI W21C2 20C!9j !UUflGUCG2 uq jIUJ!JX 2PJICWLC flJ1UJ11C1Ae MG C1J 2A gI1

02CLAjC CPI2C1CL!2ffC2 0 Uq14qnJ2 uq C!ffG2 BIG CJJLC1GI42ffC2 1JJ1 2GCUJ 111021 !UJb0L1U1

1 W021 5Ø 01 gIG ntpu CI4UJC GGC1 BIG LGUJUTU f-Q1) 0 gIG GUCCI CØIJ pG LG!1G 10

uq JoNci. bLoppJiX 04 LGC0Uff 01? LG GgU1IG 0 1n.pøu I11G fl1 1J1G2G C10L2 2CCUI 10 cxbjnu

CUJG C0IJ1JCC10IJ jOL U0U-bGCflhJ!LX CL!UJG2 2flC 2 LbG OL 22U1J1 0MGL UG21 bLoppfflgc2

bbLoxmrn1cj? 0 gIG CGC1 j0L 0AGLJj C4I1JG 1JJ011J OpA!Ofl2JX WJICJJ JG22 o ffJG flLp1J-

nuJ1ouJJ CUUJG KGb0LI2 H!PGL bCC(1ULA PGUGUI2 0L C4UJG !' JLG C!ffG2 cu cxbjgu

COIJIJGCffOIJ p? n2!1J A!CffUJ!ff0U P1 GAqGUCG ILOW IIJG Ilr'2A 011 CL!UJJIJT PGM0L mJq gIG

2PT1J0U J2 pccII tGJ11AGJA bCLMI2IAG 0L 2CACWJ CGUWI4C2 Jj12bVbCL cwb12 10 GXbjlflhI ff312

C1.!11 L1C2 LG WfICJJ P!PCL !U P! C!1!G2 ff1911 !' C!IPGL 2UJ9JJ Cgc2 OL UIL9J 9LG92e 9Uq iJJ2

VBLKVCI

114 CLL1E21HA 12 IHEKE NO1E C1�IYE

VflJfI9L?

I4BEB IA0L1c1IJ bGL 43O

Page 3: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

noibuboiinl .1

cmtiloqoli9m tst2 btiriU r{i lo tDriadA IBDite!ti 1Qf r1i ot nib1oDDA bim 9itiD crnDh9rnA 19r{to nsrli mii 9lom o\081 9vrI (A2M) E91 o\°Q vi-I A2M ,¼mhD in9loiv ioT Iiin nisdli 9mulD iom o\0OO

riidli 9mh) yiom 0\°OOC iomIfi bnfi AM ni ton J31S ncFii imrli 9ffl D 910m 91J3 iJ3rIi a9J131 mm SVMI 9I9J1A oJ bns )FI0Y w9M .esi Iiirn

rthti!oqoli9m lo aiii 9ffiW sd nrLt ir!irf asmH iuol \I9t13mixoIqqs E. nJ3r{i s'iom sii trr{i asif1 smiw tnsloiv svrI bnc slorlw £ essis

noii3I9rtoD grIt wor1a I swiI .A2M 1113 lo 9iwt smD insloiv srIt esmit bsiinU si-fl cii 9riiD io1 noit13luqoq lo oI bim Istiq13D isq esiri smFn nsswisd

.9i131 si-fIll) \tiD OID i-li noitsnsv Si-LI lo \°I ni13lqxs n&J ib --esil3te

lo iIU9l 9r11 XI919m ton 9Th I9dmUn sesrlt III noitDs2 cii 'ist1 uDib sw A o1 bnfi sii isbium nsswisd noitEisno si-li ework siuil .aseid nit1oqsl

imult isrioti ei isbnim brI13 9ie 1iD nsswlscl noiiscino si-IT .noii13luqoq 1o

f1isns ei ii bnfi iiD bns '1l13'I9n9 smrrn risswiscf noitsnnoD si-li

asviu noitfiimiiDiV .asid thtioqsi lo ss'iI 9113 sii isburm 113± iuluouli urO tiD bn13 smi'o risswisd qirInoitslsl sfdfilisqmo i world aJ3ul 8f cii lfiusbivibni n irli lilidzdoiq si-li 113111 worle tIusi noitr3.imiiDiv

Ii I i (rnirl ini bstitsqisq smh in bEd afsrl .s.i) bsimutDiv nssd sId13lsqmo si-IT .slqosq OOOOOOJ nrfl siom lo lb cii svi1 lEubivibrii 113111

(\4.Q i inEtidErlni bnuorIi or bns I nsswtscl uliiw esilD iol siui1

.1)131 WS1TI £ 1bIr3rI ei ssi iiD bn13 SlTIflD risswisd noit9nno si-li ,5lUO) 10 sbJ3Dsb iol SF1111) bmwoi Dnsbnsi rmdur si-li bea1JDeib svr1 tio1onicnuiJ

cii sI)1tm stsmqse owl io WI uoriothsrl briE orisI 18I nor&l .ss) bsvisedo si-It e9eW)ib (8EI) rltriW nE1loW bn13 iworiib13M

noibScino) eirft tEch 5UW113 bris rioiiEinBchu briE Sfflfl) cisswtsd noii)snno) risvs nio tm1 cii ".sIil lo w as mernEdlir" lo iosdt irI iol s)nsblvs ei

iol silb bsIifieafi eSiflhirtSD lol svfirl aisvisedo Ifii)oe smii cii bid isrilujl I" 113d11 sioiw noelsilsi .iiviiD13 lElommi lo noihslins)cio) bseoqque 115db

bnjs "JIfirri lo esitisdil si-li 4i1sr{ srfi e1BIoffl sd 01 IEiirzslriesq as esiii wsiv snI3J ".esbsqa nEmurl si-li lo e'sdE si-li sm esitiD" uui-h bsrriiuib uuiseeuo5l

.ahoq9$I 9mm) rnloiirlU I8 rIi moil b9vh9b I91firth1Lu lib 9rIT 1

.1 flO!991 Dl 9IdfiT rnoiI fI9)1E 91 el1u9I 9e9r1T

Page 4: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

I efssi is cii 9151 9JTIIID 9111 \çHJicI9D rIfQ.t 91F1 111 fis91 IS 15111 in9rnLrD0b (Qr) .a19v'I9dO rbu lo ain9mmoD rft 1iiaiij of r1uor19 r1ir{ asw 9rlo

.2.U 9rif cii noife o rliod i 9fflulD bns aifiD rl99wfscI nOifD9ilriOD 9111 JDS1 cii

of 91dieoqmi iom1s 9JTioD9d ii isdI iofirf nso lo fmq is cbum o bins i1s lo 9Ds1q 3IS ifiD 9Ds1q rism cii bns ernui rnsm cii fisi-If 19dm9m91

ii eAsm bnsh9siiw2 bins cisqsl lo fsi 9mhD risthu wol sclT .19nsb lo torn

1si)o of b591 fluiD fin9b enoifibrnoD I5iDO fri9l9IIib l9bnu isrif uoivc1o fD9fOlq of tisq cii thud rw asif ID Isv9ib9m cisM .smii b9fimul bris IoifnoD

.(Qf 9nn9iq) ci9cn9ldori brims afibrncsd niv9ir1f rnoil efinsuidisclni 119111

u 9bivolq bhiork 9mhD of b9AthI ion ai noifsinsthu 9191-lw 5D si-If 1IssbI 91-li sisso uibof sisi2 bfiriU srli iii rioifibc1oD I srlw fisodui rioiismiourii 1111w

iuio nufD I e9i 1is SW 9DnIe find 9mD bins si i1D ns9wf9d noiflslsrioD rnoif a 9191-lw sfsb rniriimsxs of bsiimil sd 111w sw .sisb .2.U fn9rtnJD of noifnfls

.b9AnuI 1ir1ii sm srrthD bins 9ia 'fiD

.smit) brims asifb rnsswfsd noifsnnoD srIf tuods iosr{f lo cisf ii is ei 9191-IT

is nsffhw sisw Diqof airli rio assbi 91-11 lo fnsfioqmi taom si-li lo smoe b99bciI bns Jsmrrni2 1o9D rnisr1*wU s1irnI d o1oboa rrisborri lo a9msf a Fimss 9111

srlf IDSIISI asfsi 9mhD rnscfrn usd1 amiuiID (8EQI) r{i'iiW .isdsW xsM (18Qt) ni9farmsH bris rioaliW .1i1 rnnsthu lo infuiri 9IclsfernJ brims aiiomrnons

191-11 1911 1591 orlw afn9biasI nisthu sisioqmsf lo eI9dmuri r1ir1 no auDol oafs

9f ssi asifb usd1 amisiD (OWl) mshiM .alsaiiqsi finummoD ion noifinoD9-i i-ni frrsmsvlovni biovs of eisbrrsfacf ebuisi usd1 buiolisvo Isnoifsmiolni rims

lo ae9nufqms srli no aseuDol (lf) adoDs( .aIodr1i9n ii9r!f faniss a9miiD nsdiu nr1w asifirID isdis 1no asifi fsrlf esuis bins afsifa nsdw

.aSurfDuIfa IsiDoa lisnoifibsif 1191-If (ob rlSfIo sdf as) saol aboorFiodc{isn

n99Wi9d noifsISrloD srIf fuocis ashosrlf lo 1iisv is fasi of afqm9if 5 isqsq airlT

rnsswisd noifDsnnoD bsvIsado si-If soqmoDsb Iliw 9W .sia rnsthu bins 9ffiflD

iii mm of eniufs'i \(minuDeq isr1ur1 (I) :e9nosf SD unol of cii smrn brims asiliD

as9ims nsthur cii bsirroD9i nid io fasiiss lo ii1idsdoIq iswol () ,aui91ui cmthu 1ss1 sill cii arrrnf 91 nnswoi d 1iismhq) smm uDsIIs usd1 aDrIansiDismilD (C)

9d of rnsqqmsrl f sill find noiisDol of bsqesl riliw L1Ofl9OX9 915 fsrli (IoiD9a

rlliw auoi-isobns sis tsrlf aDiiailsiDslsrb (4) bns auf isle nuithu 111kw b9f 5191103

sasrif --aufsf a rIsdlu d bsausD 91S bns smnD 9C1J53 rlfod imsi-li flOilisDOl of lD9qes1

C

Page 5: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

9th bnfi aDr19IiI1ni IJ3bo rIuoidli 9mFID b119 rn eIdsiirw uon9obns aid iii Iiow 1Dhiqm9 11sbI E.e91JJbiTa IDirli9 io atat lo nsrnqoI9v9b

a9mil) 9a11sD3d siiq iq emio iom ir1i ir1i worla dod bluoD m iom sm asmh r1w nislqx9 oe[r bn e9iiiD ni I19VJ no 9u1v 19r1h-1 9vsr1

lo 9lJaal fnttoqcni 9111 no noii&niolni rnoa svsrl 111w 9W .aiiiD ni 9vii1Du1 9111 no auDol Iliw ai1uan mo Jimmhq ftsd rnir. ol abmw9l 9vnb e911 woc1

.rloiiiaoqrnoD9b Dia&1

iiD-aaomD iii rnuim9mq 9mm imthu srIi 10 o\0 Isimixomqqis usd11 bnil sW rIiod 9vJsrf iisrl:I ii imrb 9IcIsvm9ado d b9nifilqx9 9d nrs arIoiaa9m9m

9111 lo omrla ma 91-11 19iismixomqqA .a1n9m919 auonox bim auon9obn9 no1isimiiDiv 111 a9IcIJsvm9acIo d bsr1i1qx9 3d IThD 1)9119 9mm nsdiu

3d cns (insiDifisoD rnscl'iu 9111 lo) rioiiDub9m aid lo AIud 9rIT .anoiaa9m9'I 9111 9bulDm SW 1191IW 19V9WOH .SnoIs a9IdfiImv Dir1q1smom9b rliiw b91s9ID

SW anoiaasmsm 9in 11D-aaomD 9111 ni ablorl9auorl b9bIserl 911511191 lo in9D19q

SrnoD9d aDid1qsmom9b 9111 a9ifinurrIob 19i1qrnoD 91d15iIIsv isrlf usd1 bnil bsbisscl 911511191 ifl9Dl9q sill mol b9IlomlnoD 9V1511 9W 9)110 idrfthoqminu

m a9ld15lmv 1JO119OX9 910111 91111W itsrft ai nort15i9mqm9ini ff0 .ablorlsauorl bns a9IiiD n99w19d noiiD9nrIOD 9111 lo 91151-Ia lfiilnlSiadua lo loom 91-11 l 911

duoir1i suismqo 19111151 hid i1b9mib mm 9Vilb ion ob a91C115i115V 9a9111 9df1flD

fl9V9 aqfirlmsq bins 9mlJiDInia llsiDoa 9IL1iD1flie Iim151 01 mifi191 a9IcIEsllfSV 191-110

.a9ia15i lo noiicsm'yol 9111

abmw9m m9r1ir1 d b9nifilqx9 3d 1115) mmmmq 9fflhlD 1115(1113 9111 lo \0OE iaomJA noiiimiiDiv sill bins attoqs5l srmmD rnmolirzlJ 9111 d11oH .a9iiiD 1-li 91Th1D

srli lo 91311w scIf him ia iiD ns9wb9d nOiiD9rInOD nomia £ worla abmoD9m

9-us aisa filth owl 9111 moml nollDsdIfIOD aid 10 a9lIsmifa9 9dIT .smm ai nibni1 aid lo noiiJsislqmsini 11511311511 silT .sbuiinism ru 9ldssmqmoD oalis

asmoDsd irISmnolivns a'IsrhlmumD lrninsioq 9111 213 1912159 a9moDsd 119111 115111

aidi 1151-li 9ldlaaoq oaIB ai ii msvswoH .amuhiv rlhiw bsi13Iuqoq 19an9b 9mom brus ataim msid cub1usi elfiruiffim dufidmu lo ilisasm sift ai 1)9119 91311w n13&W

asihiD ni 9viiD9119 aasl ai n1Di1oq 1911119 seufiD9d aistdo sldsulisv 9lom nu1159ia

.9rrth 9S91Dfl rnul flu rbidw booth9rliom 91rIie 991Dfli (b 91119 9Iqmfx9 ioI ni b9bulDni ai ii rl9rlw 0\°E 'd 9rnhD brus 9i '1D fl99W9d noinno rIi 9Dub9m ri mm btñ nI

rnj idi ni b1oduor{ b9b9rI 91f1m91 9blJbnI w n9rlw mv9woH .9noLE no19191 Dxd 9r11

.rIie eqill h9119 mi 9111 noi9i9I

lx

Page 6: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

2

MTJJ pG JG CJAG U GU26 flLPU LG9LGboL1iu uX 6Wj1 G quiu pX j GiC/ bojiciu uq fJJG 6L16 fJJ9 LGbO14Jf MOLJ( cJJLOfJJJ JG LGbO141J Ju briijX wGcp9uicJ wguu iu qbGL GUG' JOMGL

EOL GxguIbJG' Tu JG J, OL1J ['ourp1qIJJ T1LAG) Oj )OITIJJ' ALipJG J1CJJG9JJ p GxbJJJGq MJJJJ op OIMJ14Gq b9LcnJLJX GuqouGorJ2' ALpJG.LP6 !q'1 fILJ1J CJ.JWG GUGCI' MpICp 1JIJ 50o\0 O IJJG L9M 61;GC1' C9IJ

GxbJTIJ ¶J IJJO f0\° 0J WG (TLPIJ CLTIJJG bLGWTITUI

LGJgpAGJ?, LpJfLLX rrmbiou)' MG uq fp91 LGGL uouXuJ1X 2W9bbLOXJUJtGX 2o\0 0j IJJG 10LW9J bOJJCG UC1!OII2 OL IJJJIJOL CLJIJJG (icouiunurçX 2IJC1OJJ flUGL fG nwbfou pgj couJuJnuJfX ucpou LGGUJG2 pon JJG LGJJAG TIJJbOI49UCG O OLWJ AGLff TJJOLUJ9JLGJPAG JIJJbo14IJcG O IJJG JJOJJXUJ?I GGCI CJJ pG oriuq OLJIX G ujqupguG12 (oni' COjjGG f.ITqGUf2) iuq JGAGI O CLJUJG ILl g JOCJIOJJ JJJG

flO11G (iT) JJIiG OCJflJJGIJG COUUGCfOU GMGGIJ IJJG LJFJJJJGL O

cowiunuX IJCTOJJ JIJ CLIJJJJJ pGpAoL E!GMPGLG 1LLGJJ uqJG2 GGCIIG bojjcju If J2O IJJg). CLGfG GMGL bbJIc9poIJ2 o iuiowgjfXbG O CrflG2 IJJG GJGCf O ¶IIJOIJ?UJJJfA UJX CLG1fG fJJG JOMGL LGbOLfTJJ LfG2 OL

GUGCf J fLITG GAGJJ COJJfLOJJIU OL fJJG lXbG Oj CLJWG 1DGLbGLfGq IL! GLGUf

UJIICJJ IJJOLG J!J<GJX fO LGcOgurG fJJGJL OGUGL fJJJJ T1LJDJJ LGqGIJf IPI

IPG GGCf O 11LpJJ UOJJXWJfX GGUJ fO G LGgJ giiq UO!J-ThLJD9LE LGqGuf2 LG

bbLoxJuJgfGJX J30\O O fJG (TL9L1 CLIUJG bLGunc1u

JLLGf2 bGL Cf11J CL!IJJG' MG juq fJJG LLG2f LfG GGCf CJJ GXbJg1JJfJJf fJJG JLLG2f LfG cu GXbJgIJJ osiuq 3\0 O fJJG rrpi CLJIJJG GfGCI flJJbuwguj?, I}JLOf1JJ JG LGbOLfJIJ fl2!U LLG2f2 bGL LGbOLIGq CLIJJJG' MG uq

GfMGGLJ Cf) JG uq LLG{2 bGL CfflJ CL!UJG JJJI COLLGJIOU MOLJ<2THJqGLLGbO14IJJ LfG JJJ pi CIfIG' MG puq fJJ9 fJJGLG i g uijq COLLGJfJOIJUJOLG bopcGuiGu bGL c9b fJJU uou-nLpiJ gLGg2 MG f12f jOL pIJJGLCLIIJJG2 CIfJG GGIJJ fO LG2bouq fO pp CL!UJG JGAGJ2 ¶JIJ IJJGX JJAG wuXuJJq LGJfoupIb GfMGGU cJf? 2JG uq fG r.po o 9LLG2f L9fG2 o LGbOLIGqJJJG LG2IIjJ2 OL! LLGf L9fG qGuGq LLGI2 JDGL LGbOLIGq CLIUJG I1Gf g

pp JILp9JJ CLIIJJG LfG fO jJp LGf11LIJ fO CL!UJG ILl C!fIG2

LWGMOLJ( cuuof OLf OITf fGG JfGLL1fA6 urq 1IJJbJX JffLIpfIfG o0\° o fJJG

OL GC9T1G cL!UJ!U9J ILl CIIIG 9LG UJOLG fOJGLJJf O 4J OITL qGCOWbO2JfIOIJJ

Page 7: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

rfriurb 9Dn91oiv Ii3nimh-rrorl bwoi 9!DJ19bn9i iii I3nsIJjimm tiIidfi irr1f ru in i1ini m 11 9Dn9iisq 01 b9i19I 9Id6h1w bru 9Dn13bruMu

bn13 9Dn9bin ruscinu 01 bi1311 m 91d6hv 9eu1i lo 9rno2 .9mnD nislqx9 ol

aa smo th b9119 mir rrEdnr 9r11 9DIJb91 n& no1 9a9rli iol ni11oiIno no 13ifsb ib aeon MDU rft ni 9Idsimv 9r1i 9v1311 ion ob W .II6iicmidne

vm 1D9119 9D '(iiD ninism91 9111 oa b9ad is anoiiioqcnoD9b mo rIDIrIw

.e9Idf3imv 9e9111 fliaim lo iIIJ91 9(11 9d

9S1 n6dns oi b91619I 1noii 9d ol me 9mhD 1r{i nm w 11911w 19v9woH

9113 9w 91dshfiv di rliiw b9nua9m 9113 isrFt a9DlOI 1JOf190br19 lo 9u6D9d

qsie Is (119111 nir1uq 1qmie 1usd 9iolor1f6q n6dmu lo 9IsuJq srIi nivIoa ion

11JD30 139119 smm cmthu 9111 1o o\oO n6rli mom isrIi 91111 ei II .bmuswAmcl

a29I9r1tr3v9V1 .alisubivibni snomq 9mimD 9113913 10 fmmiiis 19(1119 aedi 9ufsD9d 16(11 9Y1o1 9(11 19r11i9 nibnsimsbrrn lo a91a dHnn19d 9111 us I1ii 9113 9 won rIibn13im9bnu mo am rl6dnr 9n9b 01 mooq 9111 lo noiiusminn I9qm! 16(11 9Dn9uI1n1 I6iDoE 10 916i 9lqo9q 9v1 e9v19rn9r11 ain9mnomlvn9 nrsdnr

.9ffliD 9iJ319fl9 ITilli rn

ruin1m6x9 mol no1iloqmoD9b 91qm1 13 in9e9mq l9qIsq 9(11 lo noIiD9e ix9n 9nIT

11911w 9U1 in9m9nra69m 9(11 9aeuDaib bnis 9(11113 lo 93n9I13v91q 9(11

EiIu1 9111 aurr991q III norbs2 .19W113b lo 19v91 riwo 119(11 9eoocb aIfsrIimnD

in99mq VI 11011392 .(2D1'l) 9V1u2 noii13imiiDiV 9rrInD IIsrIodIsVI 9111 inoml

V 11011392 .(Y2JVI) r{iijoY 1o 9vmu2 1snibu1inoJ 16nod6V1 9111 moml i1usm TV 11011392 bns (M1)U) imoq95I 9m11J rrrtolinU 9111 moml i1rJ9m ain9a9Iq

.9bJJ1Dr10D

noiiioqmo)9U A .11

9(11 1o 29IJED Isuin9uoq 9(11 91B1Eq9 ol iqm91i13 noii1oqmoD9b airiT 19bom in11 nil .lOiVSfl9d l6nIlmnD 10 19V91 9(11 bn6 29iiiD n99wi9C1 qIrknOIiEsI9l

snil .9.i '{ii1IsfI1nflflD 10 flit$ffi 9Vifl9i11i 9(11 91Ou11 \{IIfsflOilfl9inul 111w 9W

9mo 16 b9xil i I9dmun idi 16(11 9ffi1JE bn6 IsrnmnD 19q 9ff111D lo m9dJTulJfl

13 9JTIOD9d 01 nioi2b9b 9(11 .9.i fI116ffi 9Vifl9iX9 9r11 1no I9born bnfi irnsiriOD

b926d ei nimnn unrnumoqml 19m91iX9 airli biovE 01 noi1D9b muiO .IlsnImro

iix9 ob 113111mm) m9q emn no eiuoe 911(1W .ii1id61i6v13 isluib no \1iThm11q

9v6n1 '1in9rwD ion ob 9W JQW1 rI9r1oD bnus rui9iamu1 10 8'1 ni)1if3rD)

Page 8: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

91li isjod 2rxoitDibsIq AD9rID ot Xiilidfi 9IfliI svrf 2JJrIi bn m9rli ot 229DDJ

9mhD nd'iu 9rli T9rli9rIW ti ot iiIid ri io Isnimi'ID iq mii lo l9dmun iDhta9i 9w wriT .I&iimh iq 29T) I9i1391 rIuoirli fliffioD i bs11

ii 9rno9d ot ton io 19r1,f9rlw tuod aiorb 2IBubivibrii n ot 29v!921U0

.IrIimnD

b99Dx9 aiiIsn9d 9rlt n9rlw 29D timmoD etfiubivibni (8t) 19)b9H niwo11oI :l9v9nsrlw 9ffl D f tiffimo) ot 21 9liJl 91±1 I19rI9 nI .2t2oD si±1

(1)

rbiclw eiaoD 3i1139q2 1&,bivibrii 91-li m 0 mu1D lo 21i19119d sth 21991191 H 9191-lw

>1 b9ic19D1fi3ni io biim 19rli19 21 I13ubivibni 91-li ton io 19rli911w w:xo 91-li d b9Diion 10 1-11113W 29110 \d flWOJDl fli9d lo ti1iclidoiq 91-11 01 219191

q 1snimnD rj ai b9iliin9bi 21 Isubivibni rli Ii 13rnii2 91-li 21 2 bn13 'iinhJmmo9 91-It ot 11011131991133111 bns 1291113 lo 1209 91-Fl 21 1) t8911S lo tilidficIo1q srFl ot 19191

2teOD 91T111 ot 19191 11139 0 2t2OD 311139q2 Isubivibni 9rlT .Isubivibni lo 1203 srfT .wsl rli rIiAs91d lo 212o3 Dirbveq 91-li bns 9Dn91n9vr1ODn1

o2113 bns 9m11 12o1 lo 1203 iinui1oqqo rli nod 9i1$loqloDni 111w flO1ifi193ThD1-Ii

.9rnli 19V0 Ino 1191 21 eaol 91-lIlt 91-li 991112 11-IlJo3eib lo 91131 91-li

2IJOI190X9 X lo anoiiDnLrI 9Th ) bns 0 29ldsnsv 9rli iisrlt 9ffi1J225 9W

915 1131-B 23ii21191313113f13 lsijbivibni 9113 11311-lW bris a9iudi1ilf3 1jjbivibni ii1idsdrnq 91±1 9mnD lo 21119119d 91-IT .rIoilsDoI 9111 d b9nimI9t9b 29v192m9n11

lo 2noiirrnl us 915 smile lsiDo2 nbs1 lo ii1idsdo1q 91-li bns 1291113 lo S 9d ot b9mu2213 21 £rnil2 lo 1203 91-IT .Y b9ton9b 29iudnhtni IsrIoiisDoI

lo l9dmIJn lisioi rIJ lo noliDnul rIinu1D9b 13 9d 111w H .9Dsqa 19V0 11113121109

Ifuln9ioq 1113 isrIt 9fflU225 9W iiD11qmi2 ioT .(Q b9ion9b) b9flirnmo 29ffi 91-Fl wriT .291dsimv bnis X 9ffl132 91±1 9v5r1 nolisDol 9ffi132 91-li 1-11 eISrIimilD

:noiiibno niwollo1 91-It cl b9nul9b 9d Iliw lTlUIIthlllJp9 Jsnl1-flllD

I911ib '111391D smii 1rno lo 1(ILJOJTI13 911i a DijalIfi9Irju iJ3f1W9ffiO 9d sm rioiqmu ir1T muis sw Ii iIfiI9n9 iii oI 9IfliI 21 919r{i jfirft 9v9i!9d 9w 19v9woH .9HinummoD aoim

li9f{i rh I91Iib a9iJirmmmoD iud 1ri6irioJ 21 2911 1tIUfflOD 2201)13 iuo b919m in9mrlairwq sill 113111

.insrnr{2irIuq li3bo2 irD tuo svi ol asrini1liw io iiIid13 9213) 1IF{t iii .2llsubivibrhi 2201913 iisrisoisjsrf iol wo!113 ol bmw1ojr1i) Isviifi!s1 21 iI'

.Isnimn I13r1imm srIi ro1 Ino b!orl t2um () noiifiups

Page 9: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

.((Y)X)D(Y)q + (Y)A + ((Y) X)O = (QY)H ()

Iinoii&oI thvhb sio1 IItvo scft snhrnssb oi () sifilinsisilib n sW

:smnD riiiw noii)91rnoD

P+ xOXb Dq+ O(Y) Ya(Y)\A(Y)2 +(y)'q-2-=2-. (C)

Yb fl 9E1 Y6

ism ciinscb moil smo n sq isvo scnui lo esiiiifmup cii snJ3cb sc!T lo ii!icIsdoiq siFt snrID (1) fcIim esiijdiifl Dilbsqe noiiisoi .iiiistmcb

iinhJrrrcnoD lo iiIicIsdoiq sill isil () (cn'isi (1)'(k? sill) noiuisclsiqqi

('i)? sib) smm moil ecrrnisi sill tsIIs (C) briE (misl ('I) )k sill) inscnrlarnuq

lsvsl sill snErb iilim asldhfls iinummo sib lsvii:cnsiIA .(misi

sill ls11s bluoD rbirlw eDiithstmlErID lMjbivibrri bsd FIOIIED0I lo lo ieoD siLl io (-ç{)'X sift) smh lo 218o9 lnEhEvni noinsiIsiqqs

lEd sd lclim els11s sesrll lo 2sIqmnx .(crrisl —('I) srll) noi2nsrl9lqqE

Iriiclls icisisiuib 01 bEsI thoorhodilisn l!D tsnni cii 2iIoilDwIslrH llsiDo2

sill IIfiniI .sDdisilEq lo alsvsl lnsl9Ihb io smii 2bmwol sbiJiiilE Isiibivibni auorisoxs isrllo cftiw bslElsrioD sd 1ilim 2sludi1tt linummoD

sift) aloD iswol SJEsiD oelE lrlim 2sludFr1l Isubivibth ssrft bitE a9iiJdhhlf3 P1 + .(misf — m

wo1 olni noilDsnnoD smhD-"1b sill lilq il Iliw sw noilups irli riiwolloI sl 12sr1s slrm esd ID lo iirnnoim bits 'li2nsb sill (F) :enoiisnslqxs lo 2sqi

s8ESlDni esilb () bsaoqmi sd ol 'clsliI esl sm noilDnse Isbo o2ls bits ls>lil IDsills esiib (C) 8rftlssw sift moil 'chshDilmq qsrlisq lssie 01 liIids si-Il

SIflIID cisdiu sift riislqxs ns sfudhiis Isubivibni bits arisilb insisulib

th bsthmh im ru .91911 nsvr s n9Asi 9iS 9f11[T) lo tñsnsd 9th tr1i b991i 9d bhiork i18

ai ii brm mir. iidt o 19nsb 9th rliiw 9m1'ID lo thlfiw9l rli ulo 9bsIi 9111 91911w t9 SD1OfID 9viif1Du1 iom bnu mm 9iom 9AEtl9brIU ot 1snimhD sDubth 11kw m 9113e iom usd1 I9Ai1

.9fflID

8

Page 10: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

X1t9'Iibni bs1 bcm iii19iIrb ubivibrii imcb iib (E) bins cnuim9'Iq lo iom bn c1eijjnuiib of br1 sd 111w () bins (C) sriosr1T .SmFID iscfir1 of

.samoD 1vii1si c1 111w msrlf nsswisd sinsqs of fqmsfls mo

isrlfoim of bsqs rlfiw A sldthmv £ lo iiiDthI9 Ithfmq sib sfonsb 111w eW

fi1iddoiq 9± of bsqesi iii 1w srnhD lo ifbiJa1s silT = a H s1dimv

:ei fsim lo

q 96'19 QaQq6Q ()

sW .asifbifa1s lo emisi iii (C) sfiiwsi of s1dieoq i ti 'cfiDi fils irli niaU ir1i sfonsb 111w sw bins ssie fiD IlfilSvO i sldsimv Y fimvslsi sift fun smiu

:sthw nu sw ELIcIT .L4 u slduiiuv Y

+ pq + 0(M)'i4 33—- — + = 3 ('C)

0H9 Vlb 989

au wollu 111w Ii sin1w isquq sift lo bits sift f is noifisups Einlf of rnuisi 111w sW

ID of iDsqEsl dftiw smin lo iiDifau1s lisfof srlf lo noifiaoqrnoDsb is rrriol'isq of 111w sw sm isf9mumq Euoimv fuclw 1tmxs wornl foci um sw sliniW .sie

rnoil esmo fs11s snnuiD nisdw llfilsvo sib lo c{DUin won wonfE of sidis sd .anioifqmueau lo siisnle fnisislIib £ itO uiibrisqsb E5DIUOE insisllib

C) I(MtD a'\iiD i i'I\

E9iI11D 119± Euo1sImb wonT sEoonID of eIEriimilD woIIu SW ,flOifDSEduE Emil cii

lo EnroifDnuI sd r{fod fEsTlu lo ii1idsc1oiq sift bins Efilsnsd sift rnfis1 d sd 111w

siLt brns j) nil ciith sm smhD lo EfiIsnlsd sift sisnlw 4 bsionisb slclisnisv sDrorb £ :ssimixism 111w alisrumnJ Al) cii WiiEil oalis El fesrns lo ii1idudo1q

D(Y ,l))q —

—0— (Y 4)8 ()

noifibnoD lsblo feiil aunT rbirfw

Page 11: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

(Y4)€ (Y4)H6 —

()

sri d ts11o 1fDf3xs si smhD uo19nfib siom lo fi1snsc1 Iniicn sri idi o sw II .irIuiD nifls 10 iiiIiddoiq Inoiiibb sri no tsnsb lo feoD 1sniism

:bnil w eDifi svifiqmo sri bniI of noiiibno irH sisifns'isllib

— — () —

1eif of rIoiiqrnus d sviisri ai noieaslqx9 inH lo iofsnimonsb silT bn ()H(1'1)d=(Y4)H sisriw sa sift isbinoD .noiiibno) isbio briose

:nsnft ()(1/I)q=(Y4)9

(\,4)'c\()' —

— (8) (I)—)

5TH 9a69IDsb brn (O<(t4)!cE) 9JTHID lo atilsnsd sift 9f591DfiI nod of trs sifb II sd Iliw nb1isi Ih no iDSIlS llisisvo sri (O>(T/I)'q) lr& nifls lo iilidisdoiq

iilidisdrnq sift no 9I fb lo iDsils sri snimisxs nrli sw II .sviiioq Inoif a :fnluisD flifl9 lo

(k(V\)c + (keA)'c:i = + = (Q)

'ism irfrnsD rtrsd lo filidisdoiq 9TH £10 fDSIIs riisdiu b9'nsado 9tH aurlT snri2 ((L/I)q .9.i) lasim lo 'filidisdorq no fD9IIs nisdnr sinf 9tH sflsia'isbnu

bsvisado sift afsmi a1Jo1sf1fib siom rri mflis d sfisarrsqmoD 111w aIisriimh ni misi fail sri nifod sbuIDnI IIiw asfisi ia9iiis bnis a9ifiD nsswisd noitDsnnoD

9rH brrn fasim 10 iilidsdoiq Sri rnDubsi a9if ID of b9f isisi misi sri ai rbii-Iw () lulsau si-tO .isnsb siom lo no nbIrsi 9TH of E9iisIsi T{Diflw (() ni rrrl9i bnoDsa

sri rltjoirif *row '(mo a9IfiD Ii frlf ai ,4uonfi (Q) noifisups lo noifisDilqrni

19W0! 99 SW Ii aurIT .89i:liD ill 9Iis1 fasim irlud 99 111w 9w 19V91 fil9nsd IDisI

£11 9115 a9f £1 fa9ITh sa9TH ITII bns iiuidm15 1fiiI ai sinH asItsi fasim .9ffli91 rIiDiloq 9V1iD9119 aesi is niiiiassm

or

Page 12: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

9i3i9VS 9r11 bncs siib riswicJ noxfD9nnoD 911± 9nimx9 w 11 \19vijfin19j1A :brril 9w 9fflflD lo 19V91 1119119c1

— ()() + ()(V)\ = + = (Of) -

noHnnoD b9v19do 911± xir1i brrn 9viiieoq '1iDni (Of) ni 2m191 hA fil9clsd bcm iib n99wf9d rloiiD9rInoD 9Lrfi 9111 f19VO 111w iiiD n99w19d

111w 19v91 1119n9d bim ie nwf9d noiI9rinoD b3v192do 9th 1 nI .19v91

911± Iii 9a9o9b i ur1T .O>(VI)'q no1 O=(I'I)'cI 11 nv 9vifi2oq 9d

29fflflD lo 19v91 9(11 111 92fi9Dfli cm 26 119211 ia9Iinfim vm lo 1iIidicfoiq .1iIicf6doTq I aim bsvl9ado 911± ni n6rb s a flu lu qu work Ion 111w brrn

shirfw iisrIi ariu9m l9WI6b 10 19v91 9th fIi1fI9Obfl9 fiirD 29Lf 2 fl01b92 21111

9th 9:I61 9111 (11 I1ir1 6 rliiw 9211 121J1fl 9fflhl) lo 11111191 1nim 9th lo 229111)1211 911± I9woI 111w 21urnmnD Isubivibrii fsrli 2iezJe niiism I9nfib

29iEi1 19W01 9V131I 29th) Ii 2ur1T .flirk it1i of 92I10291 111 ioivi1d 11911±

9m11D moil erruJf9l 19r11rf bnu loivsrl9d rib1si Aeh 9iom 9)ubnI vsm I urli lo iiIidudoiq 911± au dmib iaiim Isnimil) 1unimm 9(11 of 2rrluf 91 9111 Ii 119V9

bhior{a 9w 219V91 I 119f19d 19r1xr1 9VBrI 29111) 11 (19Vif6f119i1A .292h 1291m 1)9119 116 1(19219Vn0D .119w a 191{wrI f1i9d i2riu lo Ii1idJ3c1o1q 911± 9v192d0

isiub 9th ru b91uiaI9bnu 9d Iliw 10 \ii1iClf1Cl01q 9th l9wol 29111) 91911w

busl 9111 noiiibbu nI .191mb 910111 no nb1ui 'd 9i6an9qrflOD 2I6nimrt) 9)1112

Sf11 921113) Iliw lOiVf3fl9d 2uO19fmb SlOffi 9)IJbfIi 219v91 iiISn9cf 19r1iH usd1

9IJTI 9(1± siu1219v0 of 219v91 iiI9n9cl bnu 291±!) n99w19c1 noiiDsnno) bSvls2do b91u91 nirnf3w zjoivdo 9(11 9i1qe9U .1oivur19d 1uruirnh of 2rrwf 91 lunoifibbu

bnu 219ve1 bnu iiI9rr9d b9viado 9211 of bSDloI 9d 111w sw noib92 2111± d 001 rrisdli rIif91qI9irui i2nius noiIusD 6 eu 1no eu bns±e Ieium noliDse aidi

.'S11619iul

ii) o i1 \T

ci Sffi D cnoil cnuIsi dir1 u vur1 ei1i r1w thniu1qx9 2i29thOqcl 11311111311 A elunimm I uth bnu r1i11 19m91±XS 9113 911111) iol IloqeumIf lo 2±20) luth

b99bnI .139113 )1rlqu1O9 )111)Sqe bnu flume u nirlfiw asmn) nnoll9q

ff

Page 13: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

rioJ I9v1i foci ob Isnimiij isdi sue Inoiie ktow fisDio!onimhD srli of bsiIt Idioq 9Th sDrIiib lo eioD 9rIT .9mnD rlrloIl9q of 9Dn13iib 9th nivfi9I lo eoiq 9r11 cii elfinimiiD nb1 feim 10 fiIid13cIo1q i9r1icI lo afeoD riici 91IT .9JTh1D 9± oi 9flJOl flO bsIclioif ni9d el13nimnD 10 9D

bnis 9milD lo smlq r{ 9fiD9 of b99r1 9ldieeoq 9JIf of 9i15191 V131TI 9D1Thiib

9Drififib lo io 99rIT .'iw 9mhD rirff Ii 1biqti n9v13r1 &he £ of rnist9i

quoi DifIrfi9 10 D!ffi0fIOD90ID0 s lo i IEfIIiTiflD 91ff Ii rfiri \ImIiJDiimq 9moDed

.boor1iodrfi9n 'mifDiv d11 lo rrrion rIi moil fn9lsIIib 1dieiv i ir1f riittoqn1s1i bus emiD of nu1svsrt lo eioD 9dB lo iuo 9rIi lo 91bm95I

nsdiu 9rIsb 1131ff a9ilqrrli afeoD eor1f lo 9Dfl991 sill srnio moil IDsd boo cii qu worle Iliw alsvsl \(fiCnSb sesriT .elsvsl smuD 19fl1f1 svsrf 111w aiiis

ebiswof svIfDsI9e som 9d of sids s eIsthmilD sill Ii smir isq efiIensd ism1 10 lsdmun Isiof r1i esetsim \liensb II .esiib serisb cii emitiv Isifrrsloq

ScririD s)1Ji-n hue bus smhD Isrioiiibbis IIDES lo sulsv srlf 9DIJb9I sm ii esrrulD bits eulsie cisthu nsswfsd noifsrtrioD s iol IooI sw rtsrfW .sviisiDJJI 910ffi bits bsxil 'fiD 9111 cii esmnD lo isdmuri srff blorl ris 9W 9mI1D lo sulsv sth

.e9iliD bus smm lsq 91111w n9swfScI noilDsrino lsnoif!brroD 5 101 Iool ieu[

\I9Vifc3191 bus smii issue cii slou lsIuDifusq t s1q sm iiensb nsduU lie of XIlsifnsees ci ClSflulTiflD issue lo borlism sill II .r1sD1s1 ifsq bsririslqnu

5 irlie lo SFISI uisrlf thdfiw 9fflOD orlw elsIlimiuD sviisqeolq uol I isw bus iqms 1113 cisrlf emuiDiv Isifn9foq 10 it sue iis1 fIDum 5 5v13r1 111w ssus secisb

no Is1 19±51 md erniiiv uIsili of o fort ob elsrrimiu 1sbom cliff uI .ssus 910111 9113 ei9sIie 919flW Cf3915 cisduci ciT .msrlf of 9ITIOD of emiiDiv usd1

.IsmmiT) Issue sill lo 9fl51 91ff riirliiw usbrtsw 111w emil DIV suom bsbwo1D airlf \hIul915D suom arnuiDiv usd1 fDslse of eIsfIImnD cwolls sDuOI cull Ii IIISA

of bssl 'sm Ii X1sVIfsmsi1A .9111119 usq ehsvsl iilsnsd usr{ir1 of bssl Iliw 99101

'.lsnimiT) usq csmii lo isdmun u9-1s1 S

nsduu bcis 911D rnoul eriuuisu usrlir1 risswisd rroiiDsdicio lo 591110C usrBociA 1ierfT .esifb cii fcIsesuq 9113 1 s1ff C913)1nul Iscioiisrrnoicii u9i59u 9± ci essm

9)lsm aInsmnouivrIs dIscl1JJ cii enoifDsusfni lo 1fi1f s bcis iimixouq lo snsu usissu rlDum s fuods i-iussl of sids sd 111w eIsrnmnD 15111 slthcuslq ii

feom 9111 seOOdD of sids 9d Iliw asifiD id cii alsnirrthD audi bits amiiDiv

auorIox9 cm bis1D aiib Ii auon9obn9 fErlimilD iq amiiD sbsm Jon vsrI w 91idW .8 ru 9asiDni cm as Ibom r{i iii qu work bluow 9as1Dni aidi IsflimflD 19q asriii ill 9afi9Dfli

Page 14: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

ewoll noih3mIoIrIi 19i9ID .CsmnD lo rri 19i91 i nomi 9ITIflD 9v1fs1Du1

II9ati Iliw irft noiisrrnolni niups o eI&ibivibth iol 9ldieeoq ii 9)1EIT1 9iiiD flu

1fi91c1 Oi \(6W 19LC9 flu1TI9I ..9 9mF1D lo 1&IimilD cft oi eieo rli oi sDub91

eoorfD a1nimhD irli nueri b1uor1 flOrlEiTnOlni I9ii9H .ein9rnt1qE oini .ernitiv 9vui1DIJ1 910ffl

d mFrn isfD eiib 1ir{i ci iicn9b lo ctnfivb rli lo miol mliniimq A Isin9toq iooq bnis erniiDiv huiin9ioq r1i19w nwisd iimixoIq nui1D

eiimil ti 9CIJSD9d rlfod 9!d1sr1sv 9d riiisis 111w fimixoTq airfT .eIBrnmnD

9r1i fuodis iooq 9rli of ewoll rioifisrrnolni eseis ii 9elmD9d bnis ateoD ttoqenisif iooq no iooq lo 9Dn9Iisv9lq 9rFt fuodis ctnsl riwor1 119w 9rff fl9Vi .cr1fJrsw rli lo fnthmv cirli iIJodfi !lsDifq91e fsrlw9rnoe 19ithb9mmi 9113 sw rnii

ii nie b9fe9i 9d n&. bnis 'cçio9rff busy is ci fi ee919r1ti9v9n cie9r1foqrf ficn9b .rIDrl rli iol >Ieii hsIuDitrsq 9d 111w riivi1 nisthi.., fsr{i esulqrth

ci fivutm IisrlimuiD of &fiUf9l 9fff eis'i eifb r1w fuodis cie9thoqri usc-ui A of ab9(do nslof a lo 9113e91 9r11 c-ui a9imonoD9 9I5Da wollis csiis rrndiu fisrif

ein9m9lqmi IsnimulD io cboo n9loie 19rhi9 ioi af*ism c9ifb ciT .noifDriul

bisq 9d c-IS) eI9AThfrI 9e9r1f nivsrI lo efeO b9xil 9fIi 9dus9d feux9 ncs. (anu ..s) 9e9d11 lo rierq 9r1T .aboo 9e9rIi o1 3ldslusvcs C9iC i9*usm smI rli d

elsnimh iol isiciss bc-rn aloof 911upD5 of alsnucnh iol 19q139r{) ii 9?Ism ef9kIsm .tI9qo1q n9loia lo 9aOqaub of

nI\ o eiiD

bc-is ic9lls 10 fi1idsdoiq rfi rrn9wo1 sd 9rrIilD 10 afeOD 9fIf l9woI fr1im cufiJ cicsrlioq'r1 Isiufsn A .1 C91113 n9qo lsnorfibrxoD fn9mrleinuq lo fi1idsdoiq fIf

1-iinummoD -Ii9clf lo efn9bue9l 9r11 worn! of 19Ail 9lom c-bum 9Th 9Duloq f sc-if ci Isnoifsrniolni 9rlf 9Dn12 .fn9mruoluvn9 nwof Hisme 91dsf a 1svif £191 Is cii

a9uf ID ClJOfflXflOfth c-Il '19)!59W 9Th fISSlfID bns 9DuIoq c-199wf9d enoib9nno .illJDiIIib 910ffi a9mOD9d ifl9ffl9DlOifl9

9r1f rIfl9biCfl0D d CSffiflD 9vfoe 9Diloq usc-if ci eia9rlfoqrl airif lo flOiCl9V

r1t 10 9c-i fud (Is nifsnimi1e bc-rn 9mh is cii clsnimi'ID 9ldiccoq lo i9a Ilul bc-is nofesW ..9) aloodfx9i 3IlJb9Dolq 9DiIoq Diafid be9bnI .alsnimil lIsifn9foq

rism c-li ac9Do'Iq noiisifcsvni cm rbue icut bn9mmo9l ob (Et !19W

Cf

Page 15: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

111 ehsqeu lo rus'i r{i worirr of 91d13 9113 9DiIoq anwoi Ili3m ii! .9Dn13iani

r{Dum 113nimhD bn9rf9lqq13 bns f i911sm rbum of 9flD mILrDitIsq 1m i wo 9DiIoq lo l9dmun 9111 bn mio lo 'I9drnun c1i Ii fl9V tom of 9fflLD lo oiisi rivi I113 iol line aW01 iiD 9111 lo 91E nIf e 91131 9fflIS 9111

ci CID9qCIJC lthfn9foq 10 Iooq 9111 rr9r{w l9bmr{ 9c1 Iliw noian9d9lqqfi 9DiIoq

.139113 fIE&IIJ 111 9c1 ieuITr ii ei 19t131

9ITIOD 69Th rr13dlu bcr13 1iDiIoq n99w19d floIfD9flfloD 9111 l9vifJ3rn9f IA

II13me morl aboo Dilclnrq I13DoI lo 9lbrrud 1n9r9IIib s 9C001{D eiib 92!mD9d 1uoc113

riiipr bim frluom13 r9ae1 r bri9qe of eeoorb 'm c9111D I13qiDrrnq cr1 .cnwof 9DrIiC) mm lo 1n13191o1 rom 9113 CfrI9biC9l ctsdru 9aIJuiD9d n9m9Di1oq 19w91

10 wonA 9d Of 'c19)1II 910ff! 9113 aIflSbie9l nsdru (e9ifiD th fc of b9iD919c \(9111

li3ubivibrii abl13woi sviiiccisa 910ffl 9Th e1ri9b1e91 cI13dnr ro eI13nimilD frjodc 9ThD

9DiIoq ro 9iIoq 19r119c{W riithm13x9 d b91e91 9(1 IThD c1e9cIf0qr1 cuulT .efr1h

.C139113 1113d1U 111 19W01 9113 e9lrJfibrI9qx9

iini!mmoD f13mIoIni 113111 ci e1e9rifoq'rl mm lo efeoD 9111 lo flOiel9V Isnil A firnjmrno srIT .9fflflD u11113flifflu19 lii frrBflOqrrli l9m91fX9 9Th erloibrl13c

roiiriom vm finummoD 9111 ro eI13uumiID rleinuq bris roiirtom 119c1i i3m fiurrnou113 uIr5d'IU .e9ithorIfu13 9bicfLIO 9111 un fI1II13D d uleinuq bun13 eII3cIimro

of bux13 fHqIuD 9111 ci orlw 9rnm1919b of c9ifinumrnoD 101 r9bmrI Ii 9A13m sm .irI9rrIrIeirnJq I Dilirli cr9111

e9iliD 9eLrsD9d fn9m9DrolrI9 finummoD lo 9101 9111 l9woI "(13m e9111D oeIA fri9m9Dro1u19 \firIuffirno:) .c9v198m9r11 C9iiinhimrnoD lo dfn9rf C 9111 :tiJTIiI

1113 rriDubuIi Iii 1n9rrIrIi em9Idolq I9bn 9911 9111 9ffI0D19V0 01 cbn l9bil 9911 9e9111 '(1I13LreU .c1odr1i9n eicl bsiolq of eq9fe 9)1131 of IBubivibni >IloI 9111 ci) e1D13rfnoD iiDilqmi 111191 noI cli iw 9fflOYI9VO 9113 cmsldorq

ff1191 no1 9d of \I9)1iI CC91 9Th C9ifiD cii CI13ubivibni II .(insmm 1119109111

\9di Ii cr19111 cfD9forq fim'nor113 rI13dru 113111 9v9i19d el13ubivibth 10 9e9r11 119111 eIfirnmrr) iii crirnui cii Cbrfibml13ie IidummoD 9111 of qu 9v11 of 11131

eli-IT .c9iib ci 9DroIns of r9bm11 9d 111w cfD13rfnoD fbilqrrni cr1191 uioI lI3iiqlsD IISIDOC 9111 qol9v9b of 11131 e91f1D rI13Dn9crIA fsi-l1 Hs1in9ee9 ci fn9mur13

.9ffIllD iDir1e9r of \(I13CC9D911 (f m13nfuq 99c)

:tf

Page 16: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

tm blirow 113rli aiu91 rrndw no bJJDo1 9vsr1 noiiD9edira ow eiroivrq 9r1T

rIirI I9vijJ3rn9jIA .9mhD lo 1eo dli Dub9I bim ii19n9cI 91li 9e9'IDni oi

ii diliw 1ubivibni lo iIuei 911i 9d Iqmi m a19v91 9mi1D

oi brr9i a9HiD 9IidIW .ast nsdiu ni 9viI ol niiI 9mhD ebmwoi iierI9qo1q 19913D) Iiiq& nsmud aesI on iom rhiw Ifiubivibni svi no iDtflE

IsJsnothoqoiqeib nwiiib thnbivibni ttittiE oaI 'csrn a9ib XQQ1 mM bn 9d m Ifiubivibni 9e9dIT .noiftjdiiib Isiiqr5D smmurl 911i lo rnoflod si-fl rno'iI

iol siiinutioqqo do 'isusd svrI vm siiiD su&sd sii oi bsbiii nJ3diu lo snssiq srli lo seu&sd io aIIiA lo IsvsI wol rftiw eI&rbivibcii TsrJirf is1o esilb sauf3Dsd to s!dstro1rnoD IssI suIi sisriw boocfiodrIisn

inoil bmwsi ishsi i&lIo esiib oaimDsd nsvs io ,4svsl Jilsnsd ftnscnrnsvo siJb iisrli sIdiaoq \Is1dn9 i i noacsi si-li 19V9113d1w ioI .ioivtirlc1 lI3nifrlhD

ebmwoi Dnsbn9i rlid hsluDii113q s rliiw anoiifiluqoq b9iDsiiic i&r 9vf31-l

smflD

bni 81 lo sr sth isbnu si I&IimhD lo isc1mun 9IJl snie seiuo 10 ni noiiDsnno sill noii13Do1 i-two iirli nioorb iluDi11ib svcl Idsmiisiq

nsrli bnfi 1cin9iisq noiiol ndur nsswlsd sd Jism se lsinsm .ii1slt11rJD 'ns1b1irlD DiIISIDI3mFID Irinsltiq rluoirli bmbnile rltjo'idfl iiiirb a'nslblir{D ii1i 'srn iiensiDslf3dlD

(8W1 esmoT bn isbsH ss) lfiuiq& nsrnurl lo noiimeniti noithisnsreini etonsobns rIuoirli how olii vm noi irririd lisnortiisnssirri idli io

ith i-tI .(IQQ1 nsilIuM bnfi is±s8 ss) ensiblirb lo insrnqolsvsb IfiJ-IimnhD ol bsislsi sl io l1sirqD nmur1 wol diliw alns1q aiasr1toqrI qolsvsb eDi ilstmlf3rb risrli lo 9auD9d nrli brn3 siJb 01 SifiOD siDnsbnsi

srrd sd ol aisrlioqr! idfl ioI .ns'iblirb usd1 ni asrDnSbnsi IsnimilD

.noui l9fflsuiX9 sd lrm snil lsnoiiisns oi noieimniii

01 aboda lo su&sd limrnhq smn sefisiDni esiliD Ui-h slth&oq ei ii '(hIfichiI

lo sniIDsb si-IT O1 iesq si-ft isvo bsrwDo svJ3dl ui-ft 2is>hfim iodl niithu ol b iim siJb ni nnhJiDthnnhsm ImlilDitrq bn nhutm1unm nfiDhsmA lo noittoqolq isclid ii SDIJbni bcm 9ifiviiDE IsI 01 inuisi si-ft sI3s'IDsb

boos bsID1 Iqmie sifiD Ii lIimi2 .smio oini o ol insbiasi nthll

Page 17: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

JiisIuDif1isq riwisib sd oIis bluow nuo srlf risr{f nuo srlf iol ffl9urPoIqm9

.9ifiViiDi5 IisnimnD Oifii

miVD

smhD of bsfDsnnoD sd bluoD sifiD ir{f bsum noiiDsdua uoiv91q silT sisclf tisrlf io siiiD of bsfDisiflis slis srioiq smhD si oriw lisubivibrii simDsd

of bsfDslrnoD sd of nsqqisrl ftr1f lslmm iodisl nsdw lo ifi19bfimcb sm £ '(islq sv1smsdf 9if!D 113F{I 91dioq i ii l9vifisrnsff A .asbnsbnsi If3nimnD

SDlJbni nsrli fisrif &ilrIsfDcs1srlD lo noifmio1 sill n!DiJbrn ii 9101 IiseLnsD

lo fimnocm sill irll 1rioif se sill eslsm (8CQt) cittiW bssbnI .smii ni nojilsIsIllS iom £ sDubrIi frisbiasi rithu lo risiimii bins sifiD

sDiloq I isrif nins9m as fimiriorns imdw bsislqlsfni sw vodA .loivsrlsd

siom svisrl 111w amufDIv io 1rIimhD ni1ifn9bi msldoiq siom svisr1 sm qssb is i sisrft usd1 noilsue a'rIfiiW 11i12 .scni1D nitioqs1 ni ll1JDi11ib

lsnimii lo fnsrnqolsvsb sift bits rzivi1 nsdlu nsswlscl noilDsnnoD .bnsrl lo fuo bsJDss1 sd lonrirsD a9iDrisbrisl

do iooq iftiw bslslsrloD Sm sifrn fsrff svsilsd SW Ii slqmsxs 10I do[ wol sasrft risrfl e1sLrbivibni 1sfiq& rismjn1 wol iol esilinufloqqo

lsubivibrii bins lsboe lo alnsrnqolsvsb insisilib sDIJbrn lrlim asiiirnJtiOqqo

10 1siiqsD risrnuri of arriufsi wol nivisisq .elsubivibrii nuo iol sludnff is

Is)IDs€J lo flOi15V 13 i lnsmuis airft) sDrIsilsq iii elrismlsvni of rnulsl wol is

slasf bins llbk qolsvsb of 9ooilD rlfuo'( fiD isrini sill (IQQ1 risilluM bits eslJbni I sill 11sli lskism do sill Ion i II .svilDsllls srfllID s)lsm fisril

Ion lIiw 19)1mm doj sill iii noif1sulDu11 isioqmsl bits ioivsifsd IsnimilD sill iii aniulsi wol sill lsrlhn lud 9mth lo Inuoms sift no AniI lDslib is svsil

nssm IIsuinvs Isrll noiebsb lnsmlesvni lo siisa is fqinoiq 1olDs Iss1 idf nsswlsd sDnSlsIIib silT .eloD srll bssDxs smn lo alilsnsd sift lsrft

lns1sq noilD9 euoivslq sift ni lisrIf i noilDs euoivsiq sill bits lnsmum iuli ishnU .sfudiifis nwo lisrli lo susD9d eslasi 'ns1blidD bsqolsvsb sill njDn9uh1ni iI 9101 no11e is s1q Ilsali noifsol 1liD sill iasrlloqi1

.aslasf lo fnsrnqolsvsb

iltiw bslslsllo 915 esifb Ii IIJDDO iII3D IDSIIS irll lo rrnol lnsvslsi \11slLnhJmq A

noisq 10 lnsmq s1ni2 bslDsllls esilb sausDsd llsifini boorlfnsmq slni

Page 18: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

9frIi2 10 2!9v91 riirJ 9rlT .boorr1i13q 9Jrxi2 thmwoi noii13rIiIDni n dliiw Ii39I lo lri9rnqol9v9b 91-ft bhi m 119th em nEdiu mI cr1 boorftrr9mq

n9lblirb 9rft IoI lOiV13r{9c1 110 2i11i131i291 lfiDidft9 10 9Dfl9iifiq e1IbIe ioisa nuo 29DIJbnl ri9rft no1 srft lo 9D1192d13 91-IT .29morI ris)1olcf cii qci ftfuoid

.2IIsnimhD 9fnoD9d rI9rFt o &ioaisq

i13rli bris 9v13r1 9w (I fIISffl)Irii9rID bsm 9ob19D132 19e913ID) 919rIw921 IisrIimilD lo 19V9! 9r1 I rIinirn19i9b 111 sIol 9113l '13Iq 2rroi 911-fl I131D02

esDn9uhIrIi 199 9)1cm bim 9Dn9iJIIni 199 lo wofl 91-Ft b99q2 a9iiID II 'ioivl3rl9d

lo 219v91 rIid lmlIJDiimq bn13 2rtoiiDfi19thi IMDo2 nnft 2uoiiupidu iom oals I8Q1 11i9i21Trt9H bn13 rioeliW) 291iiD cii nommo 91O 3d bhiork rnir

IthDo2 9D2 isr{i 21 £9b1 211-li lo rioiisDiIqrrri 9110 .(in9murm id11 9)113m

IThd1iJ 91-Ft 119111 tDBifli tori 3113 29111m131 1191-lW 19fl0112 3d 01 ff1992 211011)13191111

Of 29i11ff1131 1)61111-non 110 fl9lbIirlD 9111 101 I291Io1i2 3d Iliw 91-fIT) lo 1)9119

iIu29B rxoiiimibiV .111 rio1b

(211)T/I) sv1u2 noii&thriiiiV 91-cuD l13noiisT/I 9111 21 9DWO2 13113b 12111 icO 91-IT .2DIierIBi 9)11211110 1m911J€1 2'9Di12111 lo in9mtI13q9U 9r11 d b9l9i2irIirrrbs

nodfimlolrli bnuo1Emd lo 19flsd 13 2in9bnoq2sI 2)1213 1131-If X9VIIJ2 13 2! 2M 1-li 91-1111) 13 lo ff1-IDly 3rD 919W \91-I1 Ion 10 l9fft9rlW ff9111 2)1213 ii bri13 enoiie9up

29ffi:t 9101-fl 10 9110 b9imrbiV 213W irI9bnoqe9l 91-Ft II .dlinorc X12 onq sf11

i119biDfI1 1-1)139 1110(16 2r1o112911p 131-FIIIJI 1o 2fl90b 2)1213 iM 9111

9211 SW 9lqm132 12111 ILIO ru .2i)VI 9tH ff1011 29Iq1TI132 tfl919111b owl 9211 11kw 9W

1110 limil 1191-11 9W .2W91V191111 19:hJllJp burl Q8QI rft ff011 quou Hul srli

.boiusq irI1 nhub bswsivl9frIi 919W 113111 bIorl92uorI lo 2b139r1 9111 01 slqmse

usd1 9v9119d SW brI6 b9w9iv191rii iT10219 91-11 \1161J2L1 21 bIorI9enorI lo bssrl SIlT

b1or1sasorI 11113v9191 ftJodfi bIorl92uorI lo b63r1 dD d 119Vi 219W2fl6 91-li

191110 cf fl9V1 219W21-113 11131-fl 91131UDDS 9101-fl \l1rI13D1l1rt12 9113 fIOii13fflOIfli

clod no 13113b 9VBrl 9W 9lqm132 8t 91-fl 10I .bfod9euod 91-fl lo elSdITI9fII

b9simifDiv ion 919W orlw 2IlslJbiVibJl1 bim b9imi1Div 919W orlw alsubivibni lo einsrrlrnuSi9b srfi lo 2916m1129 1110 101 9lqffiEa 91-Fl 3d 111w eirli 9101919111 bn13

.nolflssImliDiv

(iQ1) )sA bim cD as rbu 119 boorhodr1I9ri rio *10w oi bJsIt i !n9mu1s irIT

Page 19: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

insbbni O8t sill lo wsivislni isimup biirll sill moil i slqme brIoDs urO

is d bsimuiDiv iDisi ru sisw orlw slqosq 's1rxo 9b1J1DrIi slqmisa airIT .9111 Isvsl is) sIqmis iill sn sW .wsivisirii sill 01 loilq arlinom xi srli nhub smri

S usd1 boodlilsAil sill bim aslisi nit1oq91 Is Iool ol (slqmsa Q8Qt srll ais Ilsw

is riivisr{ 10 ss1nsvbs sill svsrl sisb 08Qt srIT .isbnsllo sill wnA mdDlv

ns svisrl ion ob sw I9lsnLtho1nU .ainibiv lo slqmuse ism1 rburn iol 1no cslsb 08Q1 san 111w sw oa O81 ni ernuiDiv-non sill iuods noiisrniolni

-non bns amilDiv nsswied anoaimqmoD tol ion arnibiv nsswisd arioanusqcno .amilDiv

..U sill lo slqmisa mobnst is ol bstsieinimbs Ion stis esviia 2i)L4 silT

as smisa sill sd ion 111w asist noiIsimitiv bslsliJDIisD mo oa brus noiishiqoq slqrnisa sill lo aasnrnobnism-nori sift isvswoH .asism noilssim±iv ..U sill

lo asisl9rlo sill lo esismilas muo lo lDsIIs visw ns iii Ion blior1a fOil fiiiflif DIV

bssimilDiv asw lnsbnoqasi sill ion to tsilisrlw ai 5fID lo smuassm mO imdmu lo ssmsb sill lo asmnessm owl niai sd 111w 5W bns boimsq sill nimnb

sill rlDidlw nirlliw sslq nisthu sill lo sia sill ai suiassm iasd urO .niviI Ii iDsxs sill au Ilsi Ion a9Ob slqmsa sill sliilW .bsvil miiiv lisiliisloq

sW .i1D a'cnilDiv Isilnsloq sill mol esiilisv rroiisluqoq lo snism is arJ svi asob

is cii bsvil noamsq sill Ion mo isilisrlw tt\i1Du lo srnassm mo ais san oals 111w

lnssm ai A2M2 lo san mO .(A2M2) ssm IsDilailisla imuiloqomlsrn bsibmjsbnsia ol oals bins ailnast smit nisthu Diasd sill 1o noilsmmilnoD msillurl is lnsasmq 01

stsilw Y2JT/1 sill moil alluasm sill 1111w sIdSmqfflOD sd Iliw I sill alluasm sissiD 't\(IiDtt 1o smuassm uro as AM 1no san 01 bsDmol sm sw

aM -411 kl athT

vsil sW €11 bins At esidisT cii ciworla sm anoilsivsb btsbnsia bcis arnssM

aslqmsa iliod iii asldsimsv sill Ifs mol anoilsivsb bmbnsla bins armsm bsbivomq mol anoilsivsb bmsbnsla bns anssm sfsmqsa bsbivomq oals svsil sw bins

noilisimilDiv lo slism nssrn silT .alnsbiast AeMe-rion bns airusbiast A2M lo bins noamsq msq asrnim CI. ai siqinsa (?8Q1 sill ni (smilD 10 sql ns c1)

cmsm £ bisri airisbiast A2M silT .aAM iii bsvil ainsbnoqasm sill

81

Page 20: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

bc1 ein9bi9I AM2-norr cfi o\°Q.Ct 10 9i131 10ii6imibiv \0Q8 lo 9i61 flOd6ifflLbiV

9Iqmr3 Ilfime \I9m91jx9 9V6r1 9W 919fIW 9q6I tq9Dx9 9ffiu1D 9ili lo rbi ioI A2M2-non riscli ii noiiirnuiDiv i9rIid bisc{ irI9bi91 A2M2 ssie

a 9D1Wi 919W esi6l noiisicnuiiv %ilimea6 bim rrnY16! lo ee 9th cii .alri9bie9l

019w eisi noiiBirnuiDiv mIiud ecior1 lo 9th cr1 .m nl3diii cii c1ic1

isw f)61 rIOii6imuiD1V i19rfi olrm 10 9± cr1 .eA2M2 cii i9rIicI o\0O

irs rnoil fl9dli) 'ci9ddoI 10 9BD 9± cii bcxs AeM2 cii cIirI s smii 991c1i

9mii 9v11 asw noiisxirniiDiv (9Dro1 lo isicD ro nsrq 9± dliiw Isiibivibni 10 1vI wsi silT .(b9vlovcli 916 slqmisa l1sm niss) A2M2 cii isrlicl

1C Icio lol sldsslisvs i sldsiisv irli Hid eA2Me iii irlirI i 9Jf111D isq t9116 .119biDci1

I9fiSd 19fIXJoX \(11fi19fl9 916 ftt9bi?S1 AM tsrft wocl 9ldfirtsv lSrliO srlT

ciwo o Is)liI sl DiImqiH bns nsDn9rnA-rISD11IA sd oi I9)Iil 910111 b9i6DUb9

1113 ill viI o1 \l9)hl 910111 b9i116m sd oi l9)JiI esI 9Dfl9bi91 nwo 119± svsc{ oals atnsbiesi risdiu grIT .em 19w91 ciwo bns cribJiud rIsmtIsqs

b9imiiDiv ni9d cioqu lsczoiflbcioD 9S19V$ 110 msffi moil ns>Isi 910ffi fIDLIffl

.29th) ill 291T111D lo 916f12 191sl £ 9113 29111119 113c10219q 9111 iDISI 9111 siiqasb slqosq cisdli 219bf19110 119± WOn)! oi \l9)hl 2291 cfDIJm 9113 29iiID cii s1qos

.O8Qt iii 2JTIIiDIV 101 2ThJ291 16111r112 2worl2 HI 9ldf3T .291t19 lo sbithjo

ro itii\J --(lilT Siu DII \thT

sriiii:i) 1rroijs1'I 9111 110 b926d aHuesI lo 192 lii1 1110 2f119291q DI s!dsT bluow i.sdli noiiscrnolcri 9fF! b9srIimi19 9V611 sW .'9Vli,2 fl0ttSimiiDiV

sc-li no b92uDoI bc-is (ws1 919W 919±) enOiissimIiDiv slqiilurn 111011 SITIOD

2iJoivslq 9111 1SVO 195 Iscumm 9ffi02 d b9imibiv rrssd ciivsr1 lo ilidsdoiq sib ci!229191 2Isbom iidolq thu 911131! SW Icsisns ciT .arliciom 9V19W1

isrLio this 9Si2 1(u) 110 9ffl119 13 10 tflIuDLV 9fF! rlS9d nivsrl lo ilidsdoiq bcrs asif$IIJSVOD 191110 011 29bLIIDIII DI sicisT cii cioke9191 i2liI silT .asfsimvoD

rrisd lo iIidsdoiq sib bns cioiusfuqoq 1(HD fl99Wi9d cIOtls!SriOD SIFt awork 1(l9m9liXs 915 2i119i9111909 sc-Ft wo1 ei b9m11p2-1 obus2q 91-li 9lirlW .bsximiiiv

.912 1(119 bns fl0iifiiffluiDiV nsswisd noib9cino smI i 1(lqmi bc-is uflJ3Di11fi12

Page 21: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

9DIq i cr1 niviI" ai noie si tiD 9th lo II ci b9iimo 9rfT

".9D1q b9iioqIoDnmnu ris io OOO.t nrIi I lo noihrqoq rLtiw

rh no ein9iDiuIsoD 9cIT .b9119 si XiiD norIe i wocf athiesi IIsi9vo 3cIT ir noiifthiqoq ii rio icIsiDiII9oD 9rIT .1ibs9ia h b lo b9bib9rq r 9vrc1 eiJb 9ocFi cii nivi1 9lqo9q ififli 9iIqmi OOOOOOJ nr1i

OOOO n99Wi9d thiw ib s cii riiviJ a1ubivibnI .o\08.f 10 9f 131 r1o1f131muiiD1v

riiviI ali3ubivibni bim o\°8.&t lo 9ii noifimdD1v S 9v13r{ 9Iqo9q OOO,Q bris

s 9vlsrI 9DsIq b9fsioqlonmnLr sm io frI9bi291 OOO,1 imr{f iw1 cliiw ciwoi 13 ci noif1simiiDiv isrlf ai ith nis lo sw l9clionA .o\0.8 10 9f 131 nOiffiimuiDiv

.eriwof ciif ci nl3cIf ifiD mI cii 19c1id \°OOf cisrif 910m 9113 29i131

ns fsrft 9IdSimv 9fieoqcnoD 9Iqmi2 s 0mm e9immub 9r1i crud of l9blo cr1

lo ibiies19 b9ilqrni c{f 9isi3ns w 2nOi9l9I isfsl clfiw bsIJsqmoD sd 119111

niI91 rnoil 9ms fi3ifeSI9 b9ilqmni airiT '(fD of fD9qe9t clfiw mm 952 noimshiqoq rLm nirifiw ist noifsimibiv bfDib9lq cft lo mdiiiso1 9111

rbs ci 219v91 croiisluqoq ib cff lo fnioqbim 9± lo mthiiso1 9± no lo 19v91 9± ci 9as9lDni 9sin9D19q 9± 211± 21 iiDifesI9 9rIT .c1iqIJo1

orB bns iiD 9± lo noiisluqoq 911f cii 9s9IDni o\01 s d bosisno noii&imiiDiv orB oldsimv 2111i 9lSfflOD of frisw 111w 9W .t. 21 of smiiao in9biIIooD

29ffiflD lo 1Tidf1ThO1 9± 22919I 9W fIorIW sfsb 5IDU orB moil bnuol 291i191f213I9

of boeoqqo "{IISI9r19 om ow 91111W .noifsluqoq 10 mr1iimoI ocft no Siiq& loq 9sfcr9YI9q ii bsoi1s 9113 iscIf f bns 0 noowfod 2Iodmun lo 2mthi1Iso1 nb1si

or{T .oIdSlsqrnoD 291L1i1 arcH 9)1131T1 Of 19b10 111 1E229D9fl 21 ii 9213) aIIff cii

2911111) olqiflucn orB beu bsrl OW Ii Iofl9d iSrIW9cIIoa ff1992 blciow onJb9Dolq .cioiismiolni rnibiv 19

.eSJfiulfiVOD 191110 lo l9dmkrfl 13 e9bLJIDclI oldsi i± ci noiaaoioi bnoDoe 9fIT

oldsmqmo ovsrl afoa isiiib 191110 9aiJfiDod n9aOclD 11113Di213d 9113 a9ifiilf3VOD 9fIT

992) aflueoi noiisimifDiv Isioc 9rli thiw 9(111 ci om afliJa9l iiiO .291CI13i113V

oci of \I9)h1 2291 9113 oIqo9q 19b10 .(Wt ns11oW bcrs Diwonibs51 ..9 elsubivibni fsc{f bnul 9W .b9icnuf DiV 9d of 1Ai1 910111 9Th noM .bosirnifiv

bnuol OW ciDiciw) b9imif Div 9d of 19)h1 910111 9Th fIi10Of1D2 910111 ihiw olifil bns f99119 fiDinc1fo 10 9)131 011 213W 919r1T .(niai1q1ua fsrlwomoa

cribiovs of bo1nil 1IsifnsfacJua 213W qlrIal9clwoemoH .f 99119 mnomoIqmo

.aof £1 noiisxirrIitiv 19W01 of b9)InuI 11sifcifdu 213W 9f3i1113M .noifssimuiiv

Page 22: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

iv i ii .ieiiI .iIusi ssrIi nii9tqi9lrii i-il IUI9iiD sd 01 irrntloqmi i II Ii nie sn&b iiuesi ion io isdisrIw noiaesi&i ir{i rnoil worn! oi ilijDilIib

lisiol si-ft anoiiEI9r1oD Ithi'IEq sm ssrft snie .bsvomsi sm sith1svoD who hid sviiiaoq sd icsm noifl3xrnuiDiv him Idimv sno nsswisd flOiifI9rIoD

noiifiIsrloD bsvisedo si-Il limlanoD siimvoD isi-Bo nibIorI sm 5W O saufi)sdl ssrft lo im asviib iidli minsrbsm sift bnoD9 .sviiissn smoDsd sisi laiil i sIqmsxs .sIdil 1Ht moil sDubsb ol ilirnillib ai afloiiiSI9TloD

simiiDiv urIim IInimiT) thimiiqo iirhi isue urIim howsmsi1 IsnimilD

sii bnoD9 £ bimrf irhio sill nO .looq 9r11 surniiDiv srIl sro1sd rhihisw si-li

-1Is siom s1fitrsbnu bluow cIlIfi9w sift thril iesu bluow *iowsmt1 iooq si-li iol nisrhl msrli iol isias rw noiisiolq-1Ise Ii bnii noilsioIq

sviiisn £ ss hIsw 19V urIim sw usd1 (bsviI isdi sisrlw lo saIJfDsd aqirhsq)

sw ,isvswoH .(Q1 rbihrL1 bim is>bsa ss) noiifimibiv lo sffiODfll lo 1)5115

11 -io rIlIssw si-li istcsl ion ob IrrimnD sIJ&)sd ai iDsIls IfirIl Ii worn! ion Ihiw

.ssdftoqrI isrilo lo isdrncrn 'ins io rtOIiD9i01q-II9 is boos siis \rhiIs9w si-li

bssbni i simcnub sia iiD rhi no esis £vo sesrli nibuIDni 10 1)9115 si-IT

.f. ol 88E. moil qoib noihhirn sno svods Øb no InsiDiliSoD si-IT .insi1inie -sno Isismixoiqqs lo qoib £ 01 f. rnoi1 ehhcsI lbiisIs bsifqmi si-IT

smo 1)5115 smiID imdiu si-li lo noitroq insDflini £ isrhl mssa sob II bull sm orlw elscibivibni siocn svsrh siii) .rflufDiv lo EDiii1sfDfiThdD rhiotrft

nislqxs 01 amss bslls au-ft bus amiiDiv sviislDJJI siom io 'Isiass 'isrilis .1)9119 smm liD si-li lo b'iirli sno Isismixo'iqqs

ai 1)9119 aurhi isrll sm isIIs qirfaisnwosmorl si-li ioI arioiil3nslqxs sldiaaoq owT bsl ui ai bsIIs au-li isi-li bus iihidsla bus qirle'isnwo Øisqoiq niuriqs iDsi ui

.ev lnsmiisqs .s.i ,iidsrlni 01 asaoorl sno isrhi nieuorI lo sqi si-li ioI nixo'iq ssm cmd'iu us lo lisq Isisini us ai boia niairod si-li sni2 .srnorl bsrfsisb

muiDuv si-li isrlisrhw 'iol 'mmub s thbubni d iihidieaoq aurfi 'ioI bs)Isrb sw insDi1inie IIsDiiaiisia ei mmub isrli IuclW .riibliud lnsmimqs its ui asvil

no irisbillso si-Il srni'i ol shdsisnhsv siorri sis eisllswb lnsmlIsqs bits isi-li SbLIIDn0D laLim sw oa hurIila Ino bsnsI-ID qirla'isnwosrnorh

smorl .av insmiisqs usd1 'isrilo IDSIIS insbnsqsbni us asrl qirlaisnwosrnorl

£ 5i5OD 001 slqrnie ai riiIlswb lrismuisqs ioI Idshsv 'iuo isrhl io) nilIswb si-li srisrb Ion bib sldsiisv nilIswb insmiisqs si-li nibubriI .(siuassrn

Page 23: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

9(11 i9qIini 9W .IismDi1inie 9ie imdw bns mm nwi9cJ noiiD9nnoD 9(11 flO 9Dn9biv9 ir1hn1 ei rIi119wb in9mt1Eq no IJ19IDIII90D frr1sDñinie

.9m bns iien9b ns9wisd noiiDnnoD irri1oqrni

ioI nrnub en hid (C)-(1) enoieesi i9q91 91di1 cirfi di ()-() enoiee919M

ESTh 1oiieiiie nii1oqo1i9m 13 ni bsvil rnibiv l13iin9foq 9(11 ion 'io 191119(1w

lo fn9iDffI9OD A2M2 d13 eworle (1) noieci51 .'iiD lo iuem 9r{i eis (A2M2)

iom 1ini1inie sv13rI e19119wb AM2 113111 eworlc rlDirlw COC.

113th wor{a () bn () enoic tI .ai9ll9wb AM-nori 1113111 cc1oiiimiiDiv .c9I131ISVOD 19(110 9(11 iol bulb) 9W 19(1w C\ I d nii eqoib irI9iDiII9oD eirfi

ns9wi9d l13limic X19V 9113 esirnmvo 9(11 no ein9iDiII9oD 9r11 jS19n9 nI ion ci noiiq9Dx9 113(11 bn13) noiiq9Dx9 no 91{T .() brrn () (C) ) flOiee9u9I

QCI. moil c9miID rbirlw mmiib in9rntl13q13 9(11 ci (irrnDi1inic 1113DiieiifiiC fl9V9

1iiniin silT .() 1101 9191 01 (C) flOiBc9191 cnoil 9VOITI SW C13 I. 01

ci mmub insmimq13 9111 () nOice9191 (Ii 113111 Ci IIIJCSI cirii 10 noii13lslql9inI cli lo scIm)sd bsi13icI9vo ni9d ci 9Dnsiloqmi cii bn13 9iC 'cfiD rfliw bsisIslloD

ciii tnJst1oqmi '(11BDieflhifli ion ci 1151 113111 1ir1W .9i2 "(11) rlliw flOiiEiI9TlOD

bn13 9)1011) nieuor1 9mi1D t199W19d noliDsnnoD no1ie r1i 9ion of niias191ni .9iC tiD lo Isvsl

113111 rIit)fil9irn brrn mmub AM2 9111 fl1C1J cic\16rIfi cirli c9unuinoD UI sldfiT

C2O1D 9111 1ir{W .eIJif$12 91110)11 wol bn13 r1ir1 101 C91f111'flhJb ciliw mcrrnb .sbuiinsm DImOnODS ni sm1 9113 X11 if113Di1inie \ll13D11Cii13ic ion 9113 e1D9119

no noiic ci 1)9119 AM srli isrli icsuc of mssc eflIjesI srIi m1uDif113q iii

srnoDni r1ir1 iol 19)1139W rlDIJm ILrCI e1131Jbivibni SmoDni sibbirn bn13 wol rlfod

of sfdiccoq ciii mmub AM2 9111 bn13 1)9119 CCOID 9111 ninidmoD H .cnoclsq ion ci (1)111W) CII. ci cnoeisq smorui r1ir1 iol InSiDilISOD 9111 isrIi 99C

• 1. ci enoclsq smoni sibbim iol insiDilIso) 9111 bns (in&d1inic 11sDiici113ie

9111 113111 CIflS9C ti \11(3Dife1iBic noiie IsrIl ion 9113 ciIijci 9eSrfi 91111W

ii nsrli 1OO st-li iol isi-l8irI rbum ci iiD id ni nivi1 lo 1)9119 fl0if13iffiu1Div

use iol rIDil 9111 lo esiiinuiioqqo sdi lo saufiDsd cqfifh9q (1)11 9111 uoI ci 1)9119 9D rI13dlu 9111 iir1i ci iluesi eirlf lo noiiBilqmi Isiuisn A t'.noiiDsfolq

113111 19111131 hid esiiiD ni 9!qosq rbn dol of 91d13 sm slqosq ooq sdu13D9d ion ci .ciodr1isn e'srio moil dol oi ISICISS ii cs)113m iicn9b

•diudu i ni vi1 rioiq rbii 9r1i 19riJdw ioI thu!o1irIoD oi teudoi i Iuai idT

Page 24: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

113 Joo! () rIioirIi () noiaa9191 b9119 sdli bnie19bnis t91fr1u1 ol isbio iii bn6 (iIimee bns3 qsi o1s kid .noiq s moil iIsrli liismi'iq) mir I6rroei9q i ii nl3cIi 9miiD I6noei9q ioI inoii2 I 199119 MM2 9rIT .I9iisq9e i16IWrnd

19db r1,ms moil bn9l9lIib iJ3rIi 116 Aoof ion ob J1uei r1i bud 9flD 92IJorI ioI 2111919111909 91-11 lo 1201-lI 9liffW .i boi emm 116 moil 21111291 9th moil io

9miID if3noa19q srli bnis 9mulD uor1 91-li nwisd IEIImi2 'c11uc31 9Th 9d 01 19liI e9I rbum i6 2n6DiirnA-rIBDiI1A Jsrli bnil 9w

h3noel9q d bimiiDiv 9d 01 \(19A11 9iom rIDLrrrI briE m1iud d b9imiiDiv lEno2l9q rfuoirfi rth1iow 2i i119 insmtIEqr3 91-li 113111 bnil oaIE 9W .29mn9

niviI in9mfiEqs rhiiw b9ir3iDoeefi 1r1fib 91-li 93n9H .\(i1311ud ion mhD b:minoD moil bssi2ni bud in9miThqE 2'9r10 lo bi1uD2 l9wol Iii d 01 ion 2992

22013 9moDni Di2Ed 91-IT .s1fi rF1 lo ii2rI9b 11t9vo 91-li io iodr1i9n iissn rlbiw

suor1 iol 1161-li 191-11(31 9ffliiD lErIoal9q lol 19no1i2 bErlw9mo2 2111992 b9119

i11 A2M2 9111 JTh1Ft 19)If39W 21 9Iqo9q 11911 1-10 199119 A2M2 SrIi 9191-lW 9fflflD .9Iqosq iooq no

01 211111191 1(3131161111 9db ITIOTI 9911 \19b9IqrrIoD 916 16111 29111119 9nimEX9 oT b9nul9b n99d 9v13r1 rnui 929rlT .anoifsirniiDiv iii ec b9nimfix9 9W 9ffIi1D

Il3ubivibni nis f2th13 29111113 i1-19101V 9Th 113(11 21111132213 lno 9113 9291-11 bsrli 02 1Eo iuO .ilsrhi b3ilis91 10 bsiqm9biE rFtiw b9ithDoe2s cEw ri6 ni ion 9Th briE

113111 bnul 9W .2b113w9i IEbn13rliI ob b9f19inu 9mm 111910w no 21J)oI 01 aw 1(3 113111 2b291J2 ff311-lw 1d1319bi2noD 91d61Thv 211-11 iol 29211 199119 A2M2 91-li

9d bonfl$D 9miT) nioi1 anlIJi9l 1(3131161111 rfIH 91d61ThV airhb lo 2(11-191 rij 12691

.199119 A2M2 91-li n1n1E1qxs

%w) ol iu ioi\t --1 T 2W0112 ir 9ldET 192o13 910111 9111119 rnoil 21-1111191 lEiDjThrihI 91-fl 9f1-1Ex9 oT

\t19qo1q S 111 119)161 2bO0 1o 9111EV 9E19Vfi 9111 no 2IJiisb2 AM2 lo 199119 srfi

2911110mm 113db 0216 briE t39119 9111031-11 notie 13 WOr1 flO122919i 2IITIT .9mm 9i2 sIqms2 1161112 91-li 1o 921J639H .9E19V6 110 m9rfb moil 1191012 910111 9v61-1

21 9111Ev no 139119 A2M2 srfT .a9fEil6VOD lo 192 i91113m2 13 b9bubni 9v131-l 9W

91319V$ lo 19V91 i1ji1 \°O flf3f{i 910111 13 nhir19a91q91) h1ED1mono39 if1fiDi111I12

19di1u1 911221 arch 9nrmEx9 oT .'cHsD1i2flEb2 ion bud (aA2M2 ril 9111Ev

ciT .anOiiSSIfflubDiV siom '11Eff1 9V611 9W 91911W Eifib O81 b9au () fl01229191

Page 25: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

tom IIisiieiiisi lud 19w01 i 9LJIfiV 110 irt9DñI9OD A2M cft ,isiisb 08Q1 cli .ifIfiDi1ifIi

.mmub A2M srIi nsrlf 19fIisi aimmub 9ia iiD u sw (C) ioi 1s1 i-il i9rIirI 110 n9vhb ei usd1 lo rIDucrr hid b11s noiisluqoq 1iD 9Id1si is briil 9W

W91 is lo i!uei 9111 ion i 1)9119 ir1T .9iiiD i91is1 !9V 9111 riirliiw esrHJi9l

is nAsi e9JJIsv Fri 9o1 9111 b9isni.rIi 9vErI 9W 9ifiD 191s1 lii 19i1ixJo Ifs 'iol IAs9w rIDIJm is ai1uai nAsf 9u113v 9(11 r1uodi Inieiiqiu2 .OOOOf

19r1ir1 nislqx9 irfim 119)1131 9ulsv 9lirlw oe 9i109i13D noiisluqoq 191113m2

91131e 01 iliJDilIib 9d bluow ii rriquoi rioiisliqoq i9rfir1 9rf! iol sisi 9mD 9111 nislqx9 9flD moil erIlIJi9l 19r1irf 113(11 filidiaoq is ine sisb 9e9r11 usd1

.9iiiD 91 rrn.rib9m io1 9151 9flD 19f1if1

0iD 113 4ooI oIs bnis e9ifsilsvO) lo \(I9flsd 19Is1 is 9bIJIDfli (1k) n0!9I91 ernri nsdiu iol s1JIsv 19d1iH .9flo9i5D 9(110)111 bns A2M2 n9swi9d aiD9II9

11)11 9111 niisA .1isubivibni 9fflOC)fl1 wol bns slbbirn ml 1immiiq tml is

01 11199 iD9119 0'ID 99f1T .1)9119 AM2 9(11 01 9FIJITIITII 19Vii5191 m99 fluie919i11i nJS Fri enoi9191 91(51 n01ifiifflrbiV 9(11 101 a199119 01D 9(11 fbism

rrrt9f lii 9flD moil leom I9IIJJe usd1 qnoi 9f{T .1115v9191 ai 9V9119d 9W usd1

9aorli Fri 9isI9V5 no leom 9(11 9E01 o1s esm nisthr fri 9mi1D lo 19dmiJn lo

91S19Vfi 9111 9DUb91 b1uo11 9JTIIT) lo a9!iiinsiJp 19f1if1 usd1 n9vi) .9ffiu1) smi lo sDil19 9(11 9E5919Fr1 01 99 ob 9i11D lsrIi Anirli 9W 9mm 19q iiI9n9d

fri 1snimhD n1iD91ls1 d if1im i1ue91 99df lo 91110e 19V9WoH .Irfid 9ilrJp

.SiTIi1D 1J019nJ3b 910111 nio0dD 9iiiD

brrs 9ffiflD 9JJ0d1 olni 9)fi9biV9 913Isv 9111 9bivib () bns () noiee919M i 91Jod 9111 rnoil 119)151 9u113v 9111 rio AM lo 1)9119 9dIT .29mm) IJsno2lsq

2icft \fnianq1u2 .9m1ID Isno2l9q no A2M2 lo 1)9119 9(11 rusrli 19mI dIDIJm

bsrl 2A2Me 919(1w 9Idsi 101 9(11 ill 9D119biv9 srIf ol '(is1ino 2Fr1J1 nibni1 1-r1u191 i9f11d lo 21 9(1111) 91319V13 9r1T .9(1111) lsno2l9q SlOffi 191isno1ttoqo1q

(ii 9f319Vis (10 910111 9201 usd1 Bquo1 9moDni 9111 mIu)ittsq 111 bnrs 29i1b i-ri

1)9119 nsdn 9111 lo l2om ,9V9WOH .b9simibiv 9d 01 '19)1if 910111 oels 91J3 29111)

is 1sf11Jd io1 211JD)O bns e9iiiD 9m1 19V iol \1r1o 211J))O 119)1131 sIJIsv no .911111) nsdw 2291 \(I9Vi1isI9I

Page 26: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

%%1D \o cO --11 cT cii .9mm riiffimmoD lo foD iisifri9foq 9rIf of ie 'D e9fis!91 If 91c[isT

is smhD ais9m riisdiu cii iisrlf 2i9rftoq'c1 9tH riii9f 31is 9w 1isIuDii11sq

Iliw ia'nis bins b9vlovrii sd Iliw 9DiIoq fr1f XL9AiI ai fi oa e9J b9fioqi 9w fud vIm9rH isiisb faTis 9L1 of 91c1is sd of a1i1 bluow w 11issbI .'wxo

n99wi9d nosiDsrInOD is bnil w IIE19vO .fs isfisb ir1i cii m9rlf 9visrf foci ob

is i ii fud ei isfsb 08Q1 srlf brie Q8t r1f rliod cii ie fb bins ciitIoq91 91-If 9vficI 9ifiD sibbim iisrft atsue fse isiisb Q8t srIT .fasd f is IlOIiD9flcIoD

sns rliod e9ifi IIism bins esifi id cii amif Div fisrli fud 9isi nthoq91 i9norIa isfisb O81 iisrns s'iom 1dismuasiq bnis isiisI srlT .troqsl of 1s)liI esI

lo fiIidiscIo1q rIi bnus sie \fiD cisswf9d noibsnno is lo 29I ci9V9 wor1e i nittoq9i no mmijb AM2 sri fisrlf wor{e (C) cioiasie5I .nitIoq91

r1dDsT[OD 'if Iliw 9W sliriw bnis Aisw 9iis ?JIuesl nitIoq91 srIT .frnsDi1inierii

noiisnrlo 9viisv1sq noif is bnil foci ob SW 10119 nit1oq91 iol iIua91 19fE1

.sie fiD bnis 9iDn9bn9i nif1oq91 n9sWisd

29191 1-1)111W (E) bnis () noi91s1 1-11 i1iJe91 srlf 91is 9viisua1sq 9101(1 r{D1JM

bnis simmijb 9si fiD srli no isbtisllo 9fiO WOfDI 9110 iisrlf \fi1idsdo1q 91-If

noifDscino) vifisn noif a is bnul SW ai-1Oiee9191 nod nil .mmub MM2 9tH

nisd lo ii1idsdoiq sr{T .isbrisllo iuoi nriwornI bnris nivi1 rrisdlu risswfsd el 9IdfsnIsv ainlT .enwoi Ilisme cii ei fi nisnif asifi id cii iwo1 o\0Ot ai ciwon>1

9101 91ff I ais1q I91ue briis fth O8Qt sf11 cii anoiiisvisado iol sldsliisvjs Ino noa1sq nibcis11o sri nIi99a lo sDnBnID siff ii aisrl mif DIV snif 9191-lW asmul) i-n

91-nfl) fliIis1 nIl 9101 is eis1q 1imcionis airlf fisrlf sldiaaoq 1siiins ai ii fud isrlfo lo asfismifas sen Iliw noifDSC mb1JIDri0D srIT .e9iiiD id cii elsvsl

.1 sIIs ainif lo sbufinism srlf rio bnuod is sDislq of elsismfilisq

zftiU YJM 9flT .VI

rbirlw rliuoY lo '(sV1u 1isnibufinoJ lisnoifisVl si-If ci 9DIIJOC csifsb bctoDse mU Iisubivibcii bnis Si-fluID fuods noifismiolni mol sisniwsels bsei nissd eiscl

ci slqmise snIT .(slqmisxs iol I isoiD 10 QQ1 f1iscfI9919I) esfudiiiiis

is cfnsbnoqesm bsAais slIisnnorIesup 08Q1 sri :msnnism niwo1Io1 sri cii nwislb

bsiiimmoD ew isrfi 9rrthD 10 qi rft iol 1dshEv mmub nibu1Dr1i 01 udoi i ilui idT1

Page 27: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

uoimv ni b9n9 bsrl c9r1f f on io 1911f911w nifrtri enoifa9up lo quo 99r1f b919w21m (.s oriw 2fn9bnoqat 11 Iisf 9Iqrn iuO .aifivitm 1cnirnii

Iijbivibni bim Iimth Diad wonA w rnoriw ml .(d bim noifeup ir1T .O8f m srlf bniio (noi91 9ffloDni 9D131 .) aifhfDsmrb

no e91191 ii bcm e1nimi1D Iiin9foq lo f IIifn3s ai fe 13f13b

.fiInimhD lo noiaimbfi b9fioq9l

9Uf2S91fl JiIEnimi1D b9rioq9I-1I9 no ni131 fuod IEDifq9A2 1I3 w slir{W

ascnilD ffq of fimb X''1 of rne thubivibni rbir!w of 999b r1ic1 91-li

of 'cDn9bn9f I1fi9n il nI .b91Lrea91 9mm fsr1w9mo ii .m19f iori 9mf 1qmie efJu91 bsaid of b1391 on Iliw 9mhD of fimbl3l9bnu cmdiu rifiw b9fI911oD ei fir1f fimb19bnu of Dn9bn9f i ni1dxjoii 9mM faum 2f111e9'I mo athd thtroq9r19bnu 13 el 9191-If f13rlf frI9v9 91-li cr1 .eui13f a bnc mh lo 19v91 9u1f rH iuodfi aiIue9l cHod nmnisfnoD at boofaisbnu ni eU of aw 9v1i13n19i113 91-IT .a9ITH1D of aa9Irro) of aa9nrnhI!w elfiubivibni

b9biovs 9W .noahq cii b9wsivl9fni r1r9d I!13JJtm ar IIDJJa 9Idthmv 9rnoDf cr0 C19O1I) ..9) 919r1w9e19 b9IoIqx9 1-199(1 asc{ ii 9eu13D9d nod 91d131mv eiuli nien

bnis amir niffimmoD rifod no noifl3mlolni a9mdmoD fi 9au13D9c1 bns (Ef 'cI9jf3ib9mmi 9moDJ no cm noifsDoI noeilq nieu II13niT .b9fa1m n19d

cm ar elcsnimin lo noifl3DoI 11sDiarIq 91-If au of if f 3cIf nOiaa919I abmJolno .9Idfinfiv Ioffin1s1qx9

dli moll 9lqmfie mobnr £ 9(1 of fn139m 9Th 9IqffI13a 'rico ion Y2JL4 91-If 191-If 19T/I

a9ifnonidn a9Iqrnse-'r9v0 Y2JVI 91-If 'rfi1uDif'rfiq nI .adfuo .U lo norffiliJqoq of a9-rnas9m nif11i9w faix9 ob 9191-IT .a139113 fiD 191111! moil sIqo9q bcm

9Dn919l1ib 13 9)lism f on a9ob as'riem 9a9r1f niau bim ms1do'rq airif 'rol fD9rioD

.E91U139ffi b9ifIi9WnLf b91'roq9'I svisrl 9W oe afIue9'r 1131-HI cii

b19i'c binow el13ubivibni lo 91qmfa rnobnfil is f iscif f9qx9 ic1im Sn 0 9111-lW

ai 91q1-rIIsa airli f rIf fmI srlf bnis iooq sri 10 nu1qmcsa-19vo 91-li aI13nimi1D W9I

SVf3f{ SW usd1 smans bsqlsri (O lo 9is r1139m) alisubivibni nuo 10 qu 9bsrn

13 svisrl foci ob SW ea919rlf19v914 .ioivisrlsd lisnimil) lo aefisi r1iri \1msI

ai flrIw HJiw abnoqario '{JV1 d1 ai briji w x bn 9fi riliw 9mm lo noilD9clnoD 9r1T isdio oi bnoqrIo tori ob i1i r1T .1oivir19d IrIirnhD Juodi IsrIwI9 riwonA (1II9n9

r1thoq91 n9191Iib lo 1fuei r1i n9 d bluork qch9q bsm 1oivfir{9d fsnimh lo 91LJi39 .bnijol oIi 9vr1 D1fi9.9I i±o rbirlw mi ODJ

Page 28: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

sf11 o1A .a9mhD lo iesiiisq srli hid 1(1113 srnmXs ol si sLqmc c1uori s1 i irisbnoqi 9111 nsrlw sisvs esl sd bluorle msldoiq rIii1oq9r19brrn

.sw2ssm 9fflulD 1i9vs2 9211 9W .smth sift lo ihsvse sill iuodr3 bsrrisDrroD

10 l9rlisrlw (. 101 2sIcl13imv 1-0 9111391D SW 9ffl11 lo 2911J2139ffi q iiio 1oT

(.d brrn iq sill iii 0 rirIl 91 911113v rliiw nic1lsmoe slole rloelsq ion 'c(iiD Dicisci sno sen sW ieq ni bsililqorle noeisq sift ion io isrlisrlw

nib1oDD13 A2M2 nis iii esvil insbnoqesi srli ion io isrIisrlw ci rbirlw inesm .aA2M lo &Ioii13fIi29b u13sluH enans) bisbirnia sill 01

nis no Isi oi b9DloI sis sw isili tmI sill ci sisb sesrll rfiiw mslcloiq isrfiiuI A i1D IsIinsD ioI eisiliinsbi 10 Ise £ ieixe ocls 915111 51111W .rncnub A2M2

s cit bsvil sr1l Ion 10 ISHI9HW woriA Ion bib slqmse sill lo riDum sDnsbi2s1 lo noil13nidrno s ci rbirlw) mmjjb iiD IslinsD sill Ilnasi is cA .ib lislinsD

ism (iiD 113iinsD is cii svil uo' usd1 nibnsieisbnu bns fb 113ilnsD is cii nivi1 hO 101 SIdsIq9DDf3nLr ci lisili vsw £ iii IEiiqf3D rismuil r1ir1 rliiw bsiIslsnoD sd 1ii) IfilIflsD-flOfl\\(iiD 11311119) 9± 220D13 9ffhiT) lo 2191191 9111 19V091OM .eiIijcsi bnis cise slisb isifto 1111w slthisqmo Ion 21 rbirlw 1)9119 11iD Islins) on bswor{e

Isismi1ni ci noilfiDol 'c{iiD 11511119) 113111 el29U2 Ifirli 9D119b1119 lo scm-i sbrw is

isili ni1esne cis sDnsb!vs lo kml 1110 b9islqlsini sW .2191191 smnD oi bslslsi 1(h) lslinsD lo siuessm cion 1smsiixs ciii riien 1111w rnsldoiq is arsw sisili

.110116)01

oisQ eiM --INS

cii ciwork siis AMa-non bits A2M d enoiiskvsb bmbnslc bits arissrn sisU sIdsisqino ci siui1 cirlT its iii bsvil slqmse 9111 lo o\0 .A sfdsT

.sv1ue fl0ii13iITIi1DiV sf11 rrroi1 10 bsileds 113)112111312 sill moi1 esiui1 iliiw nsui cesi ilhiow nur1ismoe nslolc nivsil eiioqsi slqrnse sift lo \°8f 1r1uoM

ioI ilsr{i 10 slisi silT .bsililqork nrvsrl ettoqsi o\0 bits ms" lesi sift cii 0 ci einsbiesi AeM2-izon ioI rn!ss1e 1o sisi sili bns \°.(f ci einsbicsi AM 1o \°11. bitis bsililqorie odw icisbii AM lo 0\°ô.8 9115 ir1T •0\°B8.S

sisili es1dsvisedo 191110 cii .nu11i1qoile 01 bslfimbs oilw cinsbiesi A2Me-rion

rlDnm sm elrisbic9i A2M .cslqrnsc owl sift risswisd csrrslsllib wsl 9113

oclis sm elnsbiesi AM .snrnqimm bsen svsil 01 bits DInsqeIH sd 01 19115)111

sm esisi noliDlvnoD sf11 md .siloq d bsqqoic nssd svsil 01 isils)1iI ibum .cslqmse owl sill ni !snps 1iluoi

Page 29: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

ID

s iiIsnimhD lo ainEnimi9b 91ft no ilui iuo nsaiq bnis ff esiclisT

airli ni noisii ieiil 9rIT .noiiisimibiv lo inisnirn19fsb rli oi b9oqqo lo ii!idisc1oiq rft rliiw noffisol AM lo no!iD9nnoD wusi rft wocf 9ldisi

.8O1. ei M9biII9oD wisi r1T .O nisrli 1 rltrow trqo1q n9lofa niviscI 9rfi as nif1ilqorI rhiw fbi 9i mis rli 9qt (1) noise isx D 9IthsT

99fH IirIW ..1. i ln9iDxII9oD rii noiesi'i iisrli nI .9Idisimv IrI9bn9qb 19dmIJn 911i nisrli i911ism m rIi IIisDi iJsi id Im91x9 &iis e9Dn9l9uIrb

Ino enislqx9 9Dn9bi91 A2M2 iorrrr9rit1uI .thIoDsi noiiis.imibiv 9111 ni

.9mm lo !9v9I c11 iii noiisiisv Isubivibni 9111 lo \0j luodis

iol niIIoIinoD lo t11 9111 work DS bnis H aIdisT ni () bnis () &ioi9195J ott iinsqot1q srFt no e9ldthmv brwoibisd Ilsin9iisq bnis Diriqsiomsb

9111 biisiipe s .is 9biiIDni e9Idisf rhod ni () noie9t19I .9mD iirnrnoD Isubivibni 9111 nr1w iDisini limis1 tiol mmiib is 9iist1 in9rff'o1qm9niJ uSD0!

IfiiDJstI bns mmub 911sm Is ,b9v9irlDis Iisijbivibni srIi 9bIs1 1e9riir! 9111 f asw bnis inSDflini 1noii his m a9IdSitlEv isi brns x sis silT .&irlqisomsb

noIiW ssa) saiiisn irhf lo *10w auoiv9lq us fomIs ni bnuol ania rltt svsrl bsiDsqx9 is brns Iultiswoq i sldshsv IDEIIH limth 9rlT .(18Q1 nisiannsH bns nifoorlDe sifT .smi iirnmoD ott IsAil eesl sis sifimth bsini 10 nslblirID

bns iIsrH tIsqoiq iol (noiiDstlib niei1q1u is iii bns) insDilinie i sldisimv

esassIDni aDirlqsIomsb sa9dli iol nih!oifnoD .nii1ilqork iol ttnisDi1iniath sift ai noiaasisi Isrlttisn ni tud lc1isT bns siclisT rhiocl iii bslls A2M2 silt

illsitisq oals ai 9nsrID aunT .IlsDi1aifcstta io '(lisDimonoDs insDi1inia snsrb risrlw lno sDnsIslIib is as)lsm niiiclisw --smsnfDa niiirfisw sill 01 bsislsi

wsi sf11 Isi-1i oa noiaa9I9I siFt ni a9isnsvoD \(mmhq sasrft Ion sm sisnli .aloittno is&o rifiw noiaa9I9I sr{i nisril 9isIUDDS easi isriwsmoa ai noiaasisi

iasr1id bsfsiim nivsrl t ss is eJisfa AM2 sill asbisbrii (E) noiaas-isI isrlttom cli Ion tro isnfisnlw isrliom a'lisxThivibni srli d bsvsirlDis sbs

brrs sioa TIA a'lsubivibni sd ,I esw Isubivibni sift nrlw bs*tow sill nI siom tio rhinom is 9DfIb J-IDIUIID abrisfls Isubivibni srhi ion io isrftsc-Iw

bns sviiiaoq hlnsDi1inia ai M ss lii autlisia AM noiaasisi nii1i1qorla bssI noiea9i9i iIsrli ttsqoiq 9111 nI .A2M2 ttnsIuID 10 o\°OE hsfsrnixoiqqs

8

Page 30: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

ciA .b9119 A2M2 in9rwD scit lo \I 'I9ulsmixO1qq13 eiscl euti A2M2 tsI t13 frli eiesu utsi AM bsI hrIi i nibnil idt lo noiiisTq1stcIi bnfi atEoD iscIirI rIf lo i1Lrsi scit ion i tsIIs smhD A2M2 sill lo \ I oi C\ I

1D9119 AM bs1 silt bsienI nsdnr sill cii smri lo eiiIsnsd 'iswol A2M2 iltiw b9ilsiioD sm irrli sldimv bstiimo isrliis ol estf3lsi 1c1doiq iliisi si-li 5113 113± ldisHsv smoiluo bn13 stat io (9rnul cii tnioq sno t) au1ita

.A2M2 sill 9v13sI lisubivibni sill nrlw snisrb ton ob lisrlt u1fita AM2 10

ei ts11s AM bssI sift Isifl siciens ot tiussm tai4 i mmub noi1isiim silT .smii abmwol iiensqo'iq insislIib 13 sv13rl e1nfnim lo llnsi si-It \lqmi ton

asd nu1ooilDe isi{toM .iIin i1ini iii sm llsisris sldsh13v isdlio si-IT

Ii&isqo'iq si-ft sasnni nuloorfD siom --bstsqxs rI13rli ni slioqqo silt

139IDi1i nbhow isrllom si-li noisisi nul1ilqorf a sill cii .smii abiwol si-Il asDLrbsi IicmDi1ir1ia niobiuirID .smii abiwol iiansqoiq sill

lvilsn 'clnoiia oelis sics esioa TQIA si-It bn13 smin abiwot iian9qoiq sesill lo sno on nifiA .smin ebiwol liansqoiq si-fl r{tiw bstDsriiro

9113 sw saufsDsd noiiistsiqislni n o noite ool nsvi sd bluoifa asfcf13imv

TQIA niblorf nulooiba liscnsl13m siom 10 tDslIs lthimq si-Il lno ni\r1sado .lrmtenoD aslcI13i113v isi-Ito brm noil&)ol nuloorfDa iDcslni lim&I es'I0De

no tnsbillsoD silT .asai-i sldthmv AM silt a9fd13T i-hod lo (C) noiaasisi cii

.I) sldisT i-ri (C) ioiaasisi bins (I) noiaas1si nsswlsd \°I nsaii asH A2M noiaasis1 bins (I) noiaasisi risswtsd \°I nsaii asH A2M2 no tnsiDlIlsOD si-IT

sis etidoiq sasrli cii atnsbillsoD lsriil grIT .noiaasmsl nutuilqorla si-It cii (C)

bslioqsl atidoiq noitsimutDiv sill cii AM2 no alnsbillsoD si-It ot saolD isv bins lsjjbivibni lo is ioI nulloitnoD stsb Y2J1/I silt cii lassi IA .svocfis

bins nivil lb nsswtsd noil9nnoD si-li asassiDni aDilaiIsiDfsIISrID lisilimisl bnsiai-ltiw binow IDSIIS eiilt isdlisilw sa tonnsD sW .asiliarlsqoiq lisciuinir)

si-li cii tassl is tud aDita11stDE1fiulD Isubivibni 10 isitsd isbiw is nibulDni ton 9113 tin-It Y2JT/I silt cii asldsnsv isi-Ito ritiw bns) svsrl sw si-It asldsiisv 101 nuIloilnoD d 1D9119 A2M2 si-It iswol 'c(lIsitnsIadua ton bib sw (bsttoqsi

.astudhils 910ff!

lsth asi-nut lo isdirurn sill ioI ldsrtsv is a9bJJIDni asidist iltod i-ri (I) noiaasis5I lo iDsIls silt asacs ilioci i-IT .rss iasq sill cii isnsu[ncsm bsau Isubivibni silt

A2M silt bsDubsi \IlnsDilinia bins sviliaoq lqssb aISW sisau suisu[rtfsm

Page 31: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

DirfqIomsb a 199119 eirFt nhi9Iq19ini 91cJtio1crioDnu '{ItIifI 9Th 9W .199119

bs9ianI .au inb lo fD9119 9(11 01 bsiBIsI 119i91qmoD nic1i9mo ai io loThioD

b91 flr1i ii.ri1 ndiu mise 9(11 i&Ii ni1qmi at noiesr9i irft 191q191r1i sw ncFu 9r1f ir1i bim 119(11 1nirrthD siom 01 bssl o1 sari rnb siom 01

o\0O isril thrIf 1W .is11s 9mhD AM srli lo o\0O aqrhsq ioI IFIIJODDfi esiuissl isisi) arj uib sesini 01 ob asiib usd1 nir1fns rliod ai sThrIa

ir1i nir1.fnjs bn smi no sari rnb lo 199119 srli bn (.ñs fimiia iswol iIfl1JmmOD I9)I9W miia iwo1 .s.i) arnb ob oi iiansqoiq srli 199119 bluow

.as!iiansqoiq 1nimii aiD9II '1iDsiib oalis usd1 (niioiinom

ins'isllib iol insis111b ai is11s A2M2 srIi i9rIisdIW lasi anoi sisi 1ni1 silT rburn is visr1 alisubivibni TQA ir1ir1 .noxaasisi nifhi1qor1a sri iii .aquoi

ion ob noiiiaoqmo 1imis1 io s:mi fri a9DnslsIIib fld lD911s AM2 iswol jQt sill iDst9'I 'Ilf3D1flflD9i ailuasi sesili slirIW .is11s AM2 sill nrsrb

Ithoa sasrll bnis asDnsuhIni Ithoa rl8uoirli )1iow asIliD I isnil aiesn1ioqr1 bmbnisia sn asi1imth )Is9W nIliw nsiblirb ioI irIsiioqrni siom sm aSDnsIJIIni

9Th SW usd1 an 1191 1no nsD filfib ainil iisnIi 9Th1 oe 915 asfismilas no rio aioris AM bns TQTA nsswisd noihisiini silT .aiasrlioqn1 airIi inods isi siua ion churn 915 aslilD lo aiDsils sill sill aiesua bns noiea9i9i 15(11 ni insDi1inia ai

uisqo1q sri ru .aIlbIa lo alsvsl rlid rliiw alisubivibni ioI auJOil9isIsb aesi iol iswol bnf3 aA:m!d ioI l9wol asw 139119 A2M 9± rioiaasisi 11s±

.insDi1jnia 139119 snIi asw sas isrliisn ni mud iDEifli 'c1ims1 (111w alisubivibni

1th o) T --G thT

bnfi aleoD 9(11 nIliw asislsnsini aulsia iiD won sfsifasvni isnlttul 01 isbio nI ion io isrllsrlw aasisi D sidisT ni () bns (1) ar1Oiaas191 ,asmn lo aiilsnsd

1s9' iasq 9(11 ni srnoni lo inuoms tinsDiliniau is bsvissi Isubivibni ns no A2M2 lo insiDilIsoD 9(11 aworla (t) r1Oiaa9i95I .\liviiDfl lsnlrniT) rnoil

.slqmsa sri iii alsubivibrxi Ifs ioI smoDni IfinhiTlilD insDi1inia nivsd 01 bsfhimbs svsrl oilw elisubivibni ioI lno ailuesi sill eworla () noiaesis5I

.ii9qoiq nu1ssia io niu1i1qor1a isnliis

siom sins ainsbiesi nisdirn oc nia bsiDsqxs sri esnl A2M (f) noiaasisi nI ni isvswoH .asiiiviiDs IsnmrnnD rnoi1 srflODni insDi1inia 9VlSDsi 01 1sli1

sri cfuoidli 1sis1qmoD nb1iow C 139119 AM2 airlf usd1 ssa sw () noiaasisi

Page 32: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

6LGG fO MJJJCJJ b9LfJcnJL LG qLAJJ CJ4IJJJJJ9j pGpAoL JGU MG 2JCMG JUCJflG GUOGUIT2 pGpAoLJ ALTpJG fJJf LG WGgJJI O CbI1LG pGJucJnqru coupoj /upJ qGIJJoL9bJJC couiioj i'-' ipT Gcçiou'M6 J/G o i. ocriq ou iJLj)i 2uqLq pJqJAJqnJ p6pAoL' MJJGLG MG 9LG

E

CLTIJJG GGC

piujaii pJJJGL bLopp!I!G o LLG2I Ofif2G CG qUAG tJJG AVJUGLO1I bJcG2 O COUJUJIf CLIJJG 1f g LG11JI' MG 9LG jJG2IgU pO1-1l:JJGG LGFJJJ2 (JUCOUAJUCJIJ OU MpGIJJGL CJPG LG GJIIJGL IJJOLG OL JG

UG1AG JUJUJJICJUJ GGCJ O JAy 2Jffl2 OJJ 6JJ COLJACGq MG uqI JTC9IJJ GGC4 O IrR Oil p6JIJ CJJLGq M13J g CI4JJJG uq ¶JLGLG2!OJJ MG IJJCJITG OIJJX IJJTG CL!UJ!IJJ IIG !2J CLJUJG jiq IJJG bioppjX O GAGL PG!U COJJAqGq Oil OflL A1LJpJG IJ pqiw LGLG22TOIJ (2) uq (p)' MG LGLG JJG bLoppptX o GAGi pG!IJ cpJLGq MqJ

(sf) F1G22 JJg fpG CO2 O CL!IJJG LG P!PGL U UOf JOMGL

pJq!AJqflgJ CJJL9CGLJ1JC JJJg LG COLLGjfG MJIJJ A\J IS1 JGLGaJOUIAJV ALUJjG JJJX iciiijj) 1JgAG fO qo MJJ couqoJJ LI JJG yJy gjiq U04o piu obbGq couqoJrnj ithou COD IJ C4uJ6 jp JuJbJG JiJ JJGimboiijj-- gr qo uo LGAGJ uXjpiu pon qJG biopppiXCOIJJO14JIJ TC !U LGLG2!OU ('i) J qJ oujX C11LLGUpX i boJicGuJ9u couqrpouJ rrbou JJGJL pAIIJ COUJJJJJG g CLJIJJG QLJG

LGLGBJOU' (sf) MG GG 4JJG nipu JuqJA1qri9J2 LG J2O IJJOLG JJCGJ) fO G obbGq

rn.pu JuqJAiqn9J ¶JLG JuqGGq JJJOLG IWGJX 10 pG obbGq pX boJcGwu IDbbLGpGuJou uq bnuipaJGu TU ITLU LG lu LGLG22JOJJ (a)' MG GG

I�GLGIOU2 ()-() (JG JG fO qqi qJG 2G o p!pGL bLoppjiX o

IJJLJJ PGIMGGU CBfl1J 9JJq bLoGouJ cLwprnJg LG11JI qJJt CJ4JG JJql1CG JJJOLG CrJJ CLJJJJJj prii qo UOf JJJJT1GUCG 4JJ6

LGME1L qnc UJOLG CLIUJG !U CJPG VJfGLIJPAGIX OJJG C9IJ JIJJGLbLG4

bLoAqG g 2OITLCG O iJiouugpOu Oil 4JJG jwboLgIJcG O prJJGL CLIUJTIJJMP!IG JJJ LGLGB2JOU cGLfJuJX uo couti!ucJu ou ob!c' qOG

COUUGCfJOLJ GfMGGU JiG pUUCUJJ LGML Oj CLJJG uJq I1LpJJJ 2fI1 JJJ fJJI2

bLobGIJØi o p ii CLJJJJJJJgJ uq couqouJIJ ou cuwruj pGJJAJOL JGLG !2 HO

Page 33: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

lo ilua9l 9cIi tm ni 'io aijiia ridiu riliw b9ic3I9rtoD 19111 is sm asiat sasrli Ii rrnt4iim lo nibuIDni srIJ 01 n3limia ai insrrthsqxs aidT .noiifiol nfidm

IDS1IS smnD imthn sill idi nibniJ .sIcEfihJ3v 'c1oif3Sm1qx9 sm ari noiiqmsJenoD sill siErlimils ion a9ob anoiebsb Iioiv&fsd isclio asilf 9bubni 9w au asimrl siFt b esnosift 'ioI Iool bluorla sw 113111 an Ilsi a9ob ii md 9IsLrq smm imchu

bn13 Ioiv13rlsd lunimilD rliod ahsIls 2u113l2 ii sisrlw muimslq smii 1113dm

.enoitm Ic3ubivibni msu{io sesril

bim lIsrIl tt9qomq asan iili bth sill mol iqsDxs I13Dilnsbi sm bn13 esld13T

asldEimsv lismoivuriscl owl lamil wO .aslcl13hsv in9bnsqsb 213 nil1i1qorla asau im d lmq ni bsnimmsisb sm svsilsd sw lurll asiorb IBilbivibni 5113

.noii13Di1ifl31 1sb ol 1i1id13 isri mo aid mo 9Dn9it1sq lo 19v91 a1uubivibni sw 11sw au axoiDisi isdilo ot bsi13lsm 1diaeoq sinip sm 291dunfsv sasril sIiilW iii e) isdftsilw I1fiDniqm9 nD12E3 10 isw 9110 2 dDJsolqqfs airli usd1 svsilsd

sis sill 9buIDni 9W (1) noiaasmsm nI .srnnD a9vnb sDnsilJsqmi (P-1 bIsi1n13H

111 .s1dimv molissm1qxs 1113 213 saTIJODISI11i Isuxsa bisd lamil IBubivibrli sill 113111

IsnirnimD nuiDibs1q iii lcmDi1ini2 '1smsilxs ei s1dnisv audi anoiaasmsm i-Dod

A2M sill amswol 9Idsnuv airll nibu1Dni 2flOi229191 ulioci iii .molv13rlsd

13 ar1 lBnbivibni srIi Ion mo msrlisdw 9bulDni sw () noiaasmsm ciT .ins!Di119OD

sd 01 2iii552 oalis md 1U1225DDu2 aesl ai sldisimisv aiuIT .lnuoDDls anivua .moivurlsd I13nimimD rlliw bsiIsIsmmoD yI9Vii139n

ml 9w bnu SD115IOIV mo 912131 9111 ol sDnsil13q momi bssDomq 9W (E) noiae9msm 111

irlno1 Isubivibni 9111 msillsdw a1213 113111 noilasup 13 1111w 912131 aiD 911J2S9ffl 01

sliup ai sld13imv sill anoieasmsm iliad i-iT uasq sill i-ri Amow ma Ioocba 113

Si-rInD dI13ChU sill 1b1im 1no dluodlll13 amswo1 nuiscs bits InfiDiIini2 bns samnoDlslni lo ss sill e1clsnrsv ssmili ils sbulni sw nsilW .insiDiIIsoD

ai sldsimv hrrnoDDs anivsa srll ln13DiIini2 1nomia 5113 dIoci s1duimv lili1 sill sbuf Dcii sw nsilw mswol o\0I ai lnsbillsoD A2M2 si-IT .inisvslsmii 1113ilnsaa9

cii asldisimv sasill lo iDsils sill anoiaasm9m nuIIilqoile sill cii as1dimsv sasril cisdi easi 'd insiDilIsoD AM2 sill mswol ol ai anoiaasmsm usd1 l19qomq sill

iDsIls A2M2 sill lnslmoqmi slicip sd 01 rnssa ob asldsimv sa9ill slirlw o2 .E .aslclsimv sesill d bsnui-rimsisb Ion ai

ol nui1sm asldthmsv Isnoiiibbs sbuIDni sw es1dsi illod lo () noiaasmsm ciT

shuini asldshsv W911 sasdT .srlsloiv abmwoi iran9qo1q sill bits sDnsIlsq

Page 34: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

iio IJoiv9'Iq rfi ni IoIinoD r{tticf iuorFliw xo biri Iubivibrii cm iorliorfw cIDirIw nbInhb boimie Iubivibni cm o odD (noieoioi irIi iii irrnDi1inini)

Iloeii IorIoDI ousDod eqrhoq rIuorI1I) noiaoioi rffod ni inDi1ini i cm oi srft (oDnoiic3q 01 norbonrlo ri r{uoidli ion bcm omm) aiDOllo

bns (iimDilini IrIirI i dIDic'Iw) e fo1iD nbIorri boimie Icubivibni

'io onJtni oi inoini orli rliiw onoornoe bo±iic Isubivibni odD ion om iocDorlw

mooe eoldthmv oeor{i IIiovO .(inDilir1ie ci rbirlw) iio euoivsiq orli ni fib!

iorfio lo foimv c ol boil ci OfflulD isr!i ieouc bcm inctioqmi oiiLrp sd ol csldthmv scodli iovowoH .oioi iojsm cisiq sDnsiiq rbiriw lo ii cii noiciDob

.toIIs smin rrndrn orb nucslqxo ion ob

oi\I rn til1 \o VV -- cST

no bnfi eulia A2M no sDnoiuI3q lo coiueom orii eesioi ow oidJr3T nI AM2 lsrD bnil ow (1) noiccoisi cii .coIdBimv brrnoiADcsd ixsbivibni ioriio ioriiO .iruJoDD enive £ nivfiri rfiiw boiIorioDn1J 'c(fIthinoeeo ci cut cie

cii .noicbob cit-li rliiw bsi!snoD sliup od 01 ifiSOC iovswori ob cDiHqiomob t1 oc i euisie AM bnc won auiie A2M riiocf ifirli bnul ow () rioiccsisi

ifiuxoc br1 iciiI Isubivibrii st-li rbirfw i ss orb rhiw bsiIor1oD slurp om lo iiIicldoiq srli 01 boiDsnno oiiup ci cuiie imdiu irii emssc II .oeluoioini

cIiod rfiiw bolslorioD Inoiie om aoldthmv itth iim&I tiviiDfi IfiISXOC hfis .sioe TQIA bns iivibfi euoiiIoi ci ar coidsimv oDnoiiq scot-Il b

xse bcr{ svri of iicnoqoiq st-if of boislsi IincDi1iriic oclr3 ci eLrlic cmthU rliiw bolIsrioDnu ci eirfEic imdiU .mox euoivolq st-li ni loTino ritrid iuorliiw

ekubivibcti ri rifiw bsilsiioDnu bcm riiActhb boiie Iubivibni cm o st-li

'Il&ncniiini om csfdimv scot-li irIi lnirD ow fliiovO .frIi1 01 'Dnobnsi bnE sDnoiisq slii eoldthmv oici of boiIoi Iofsmiini sm srD e niieo'ioini

isboc lrxoiiDol lo oDnouflni sift icoue ob odi bns oDnsloiv iol oicf st-li

16db svsilsd ion ob 9w lucI coIdsimv coic6i scot-li no esld6imv i6insmq bnfi .iDsIIo OfficiD rIEdm 9111 nini61qx9 ni oloi sml 6 vfiIq sr1i

£hIU etloq9$1 9mnD miolinU ouT .V

.roiq (5E)U) nitIoq95I omiiD miolinU c'Iaq st-li ci ODIHOC 616b i6nuI urO

.mo d 'ib d no461 hoqoTq lo suIfiv brm cieoTIJ3 C9flD cu ovi £ilSb scot-IT

Page 35: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

L\ -- \° CX� D

bobrijpowGL!OfJ CLTIJJG2 bGL uq wraqGL b cbf ijq JJG JOLifpW oj CfXLGbo14pJ) EI1LG2 I IJ 5 JJOM fJJ6 COUUGCI4OU GfM66U 1JJ6 JOLIJJ Ouiq OL GAGLX CLTIJJG (JyG LG LM uq uo qriq OL cIuqGL-C14HiE bGr. XGL OL G/i.X pnuqiq bGobJG uq IJJ IJJGLG YLG pOrJl 5 LLG2f2

OL 1p6 qgg LG 2JJOMIJ JU jpj 3 IPJG 3y 2JJOM fJJGLG LG porit

pX bobnjou 1!! JJG EIJ WGg11LG O IJJG CUUJG LG AgJJ

(uiraqGL LbG2 LoppGL!G' 229f1J' jLCGJJG pnLJ4G' rio p)EOL flCI� q' OfiL UJG11LG O CIJUJG 1 pG U11UJGL O GLOH CLUJG

JLGL qfi2wJGuc2TJJCG JLGL CG 9bbGL fO JJ1AG IJJOLG rnJqGL-LGbO14HJ' JgLGL CJpG Gf gcrX n pi iipo o q1n nbMLq2 p?. qA 21s6 pG flCJ� CJmG LgG2

GJiJ n o GJui i.o o (LGboLIGq CJ4UJG2 \ ccrij cL!wG) pXrruqGLLGboLpu pi q GJIJqX !q cJpG IPG CLIWG AJCJWJJpOU

EO MG MTJJ G COJJCGLJJG MJqJ COLL6CfJU OL qJGLGu9J jGA6J OMG bLTUJLJJX !LJGLGGq m rruq6LLGboLpu 20 L 2 LGJG o Cf?. 2!G'M6 MJJj GuJbJoX iiubj ojrrou fO pG LGboLfpJ bLopJGur LOL orn. LG2flJI2

UfTUJGL iiq UWG O CL!UJ62

1JJ6 G2f qç 2OKTLCG gAgJJgpJG OL GXgwjuiLJ CLO22-C!f ALJOU Hi IJJGMP!JG' pG flIJOLW CL!I J�GbOLf2 pA6 pGGIJ WI1CJJ wJ!JJGq JLG 2fJJ

COJ'1L26' IJJG 2GL0FI2UG22 O IJJG LGbOJ4TIJ bLOpJ6UI AgLJG2 MIII! II6 IXbG o cuun

O CLUJJJ1J 9c C4GU2 rJuqGL-LGbOLf o bopcG CL!UJG2 fJJ OCCIJL

MGJJ J<JJOMIJ 12211G 12 IJJG boGuJ 0L I1CI� UITUJGL2 10 flU6L21G fJJG GXIGIJI

LGLqJJ luG JJI1UJpGL uq lXbG o CI4IJJG2 LGbOLl6q rn lG JocsJ 1ITL2qJCfJOJY

jjJG flCJ� 9LG p2Gq flbOJJ M GJJ0LCGUJGUI GIJCJG2 LGbOLI2 10 IJJG ElM

ip' 52'000 bGobJG uq OL MIJ!CJJ MG JJAG OfJJ CCDB uq flCI� q1l:9•1111!W11GJ) poui luG fl C6112(J2 QUL 2gIJJbJG JJCfIqG2 lJiO2G C1!G2 M!IJJ UJOLG

Dl900J( (ccDn)' uq fJJG2G qGwoLbpc2 JJgAG GUGL9JJX pGGJJ qLMJJM6 JIJJ( luG flCL{ MIII! C!f). qGuJoLbpc2 LOUJ IJJG COUl uq C

Page 36: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

ahoq9T 91D rrrrolinu moil fIui 9111 nimx9 w (JC rIuoirfi HC 9!chT ru

91ff i uuam n.uo bni iiD 9111 ei rioiiiwido lo finn silT .E8f iol sfb ffirlf bruil w HC sIcli3T lo (I) nouessi ff1 .fifiqfi isq siuri smii lo rrnftiioI

bnoqa9noD irlT .CM. i noiifiluqoq f ID 10 mrliiicol srlf no iri9iDIII9oD 91ff

e9bLilDrui () noieasis5I .. lo HI sicifiT ni brrnol fiDifa19 bsilqrni srlf of of qoub frusbilisoD 9111 iisrlf worl bnfi Dirlqs1om9b b'mbnif lo fsimv

suiq Ino nibulDni d b9ffi9lD sd im (o\0O) qoib i1ff lo >HucI srIT .tOt. noia911 ni bIorlsuorl lo bE9rl 9113m91 insD'Isq 9111 nibnIDnI .&)irfqJsom9b fnfiDi1ini Ino srIT .CCO. lo fnsiDiIlsoD ci of qoib isritwl ci e9DIJbni (C)

svifcisii ci uirI ffDlflW siirlw-non trI9Di9q 9111 9Th (C) noieesi9i ni aloiino bbcisrL 91flm91 frIsDi9q Ii 9ct)iIw rIia 9Vifci9n ir11) siusi smm rlf no fD9I19

sift bns ((s) noiasisi ru nwode ci noIe9'I9i sn rnroi1 bsbuJbx9 ai bIorfseuorl

no b11 svifieoq Ism9ifxs nfl asrl riDiriw bIonlsuonl bsbcirf 9!cirnsl fnsDi9q Srrirr) ncidin 91ff 9DuJbsi eDirlqciiomsb ssdf lo noiaubni silT sf cii 5f1D 9111

.0C1 d fnsiDiII9oD

srnrt ncithu lo fiDifacil9 91ff flI snrlDsb iciuirni sd of bnoq9rioD snibsb ef ciT

nsn{w cifrib noifciirnifDiv 51ff ni nworle si noifsfuqoq of fD9q9i rftiw 29f cii Y2JI/I 9111 flI DIdqciiornsb nibubnI .Di1fqciiomsb mIimi bsbulDni sw

fsnlf i sciO .noifcif9iqi9fni owf 9m 9i9rlT .fDsIIs iciuirni ci svisnf f on bib cii cib

sd f on sf cii smir) is1fi1f 91ff nnslqxs arnifiv lo D1fii9fDusici1fD sd 9iiiD ni cifth Y2Jt/I mo fciuf ai noifcifsIq'Isfni bruoDse 9rfT .elcinimh lo Difi19ffiThdlD

91ff niu lno sm sw 5Dfli 9hsftqoIqqfi asl bns sfciiuxm esI \lfnciDilinia sirs .cifcib noifussirnibiv io 5DU sd ncidft mmub A2M2

i1fi ruT .nifioqsrI9bnu ioI usicib sicii SffiflD 91ff eiwbrs (f') n0i2919M fn9Disq 1ff d bsbivib sno d sf cii smm sd bsilqiflnrn svusrl sw n0ia9i9i

idT .srnir Idol lo iscimun bsfcimufa9 nci bruil of bsfioqsi 9ifiu1D lo dDfss ioI filidcidoiq nifioqsi insisilib ci niau snob aciW fnsmieutbs

s1ff 9ci5iDfl! lfnciDi1inia fn9rnfrJtbci eirlf niAsM .29IfiD 10 adlD noifuslLrqoq

smir) ncidiu 1ff lo 9cifn9Di9q sill 9ncidD fon sob ii rluorlfIci fn9iDi119oD

worl () noiesisM .Dirlqciiorn9b Isvsf fiD d bsnicilqxs sd ncs f rinD fD9Ils

DidqEom9b mmub A2M2 dB niu enoi I91 11oiuimii v flfli 9W rx9rIw 91UOD Ibw a 0\°EFi Isucmixoiqq d mmub iiiIi 110 II19iDiH90D 9111 b9Dub9I

Page 37: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

9rli rIibIJIDrrI .a9iM1V0D \f1E iiorliiw 1ijsi 9iE1 9fflulD b9ieiJbE 9d11

idi th si ib rio iri9iDiII9oD sill iii qoib 0\°OC £ ISsiD esfl3imvoD

flsrli-non rio i1usi noiisimiJDiv sill sDi.Iboiqsl sw ) bcrn () noi asisi iii sill briuol bnri () rioi stsi iii iiq isq eti ieer bseu sW .esmin bstiJsi TOl ifISiDiII9OD sill ot scolD \l9ms1jx9 SW J3iiqfSD isq aIIUseel3 110 thsbiIISoD

bni iiqD isq esqi bseu sw ) rioi asisi ciT .sloc{w ai esmriD euoiise silt nl3dll isrlid rbum euiw uitiqsD 19q e9q131 rio tDsIIs ssie tb srli tuirli bcwol

eu SIJJCFIS thsri ob etliesi scsrlT .Ilsisns CSffl11D cioiise rio 1)9115 sie c{uoidft ciDl10W torI ci 1)9115 nsdiu srll esmio 10 iseduc aid iol icuisl tui tuirli

.smit lo abmwsi Ithrluiciil isclirl

sitQ flU aaD tVT -- is ais iasrtui lo iilidisdoiq silt bus abiuiwsi lthcrncuil siFt us AooI sw Ii)C sidisT iii

rFtiw 9ITIflD lsq 9UISV 213911110) (1) flOiC29I9T i)C slcIisT .ssic ib lo rioibrujl svuirl cussiui rtuidiu hurl ebriil bits (lsiiq&) isq C9111fl9 iol niHothioD) sie t!D silup ci ifiSiDilIsO) silT .aussiis rlr3d'Iu-non rn5rli 29f11u13 9ldIStJlfiv SlOffl

hunt \1IDiheuls srI jmrli sbutiriscni iii isiuI ci tbiiasls silt bnui hrifsDi1rnie

sidsusqifio isvswor1 ai icisiDiIISOD culT .s.ie iiD rlliw Ilsati scum eiDsrrnOD

slthccoq rnsse esob ii cudT .f3iuib noiiuisimuiDiv rnoil briuol {iiDiJa6l9 siFt oh

irfirl ri-iou svi'usb vsm is11s smm rusdiu si-It 10 noiiioq in&i1iriia is usd1

.SffhilD lo 9111511

briil bcm CIJISIC h1D 110 Sf11113 isq teSTIS C29151 SW ) flOiCE9191 i)E sldisT i-rI

iluasi cull) smm ahasim buns cioiiuiluqoq rtsdus risswisd nOiiDsnnoD oct

Cl FIDIIIW Stiqis) isq CSfflflD CIJOII9C rio noihibrio 5W 11 srusrb tori asob ciesim teutbis SW (E) flOl229191 iii .(smhD isq aiasiiu ot lurroorltio \lluiuinsccs

iol sisb noituirnutDiv sill moll rroiiumiolni tioqsl silt nicu niuis 9mm) isq siuil iii bsiloqsl 915 csmiiD iswsl bris bsttoqsl sis CSffiflD his tori isdll 13th si-li

cnsSwi9d noiisnno silt irismtci4bs cliii cnlollsq sw sDciO .euisuui rusdm asob ii iuirhi oc svi1usri XlnIo1ie esmosd rxoituiluqoq ii bnui SMhlD isq atesnis cliii lo his se1uOD 10 .csitiD cii iswol sm smFID bsttoqsi 19 2129115 usd1 msse

10 (E) noiacsisi iii .291113 id iii esisi ritioqsi iswol rluoiclt fl!0D ci 135119

no isH qui isq c193111o siloq lo mrJihuol 161111511 silt eesisi SW siduit cliii

Page 38: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

GLLGUCG ricp pipcp (JJOWGL mç o pr pci corijq coucGTA9pJX p 6U6L6 pX IJJG ojqi JTcGL9frJLG OU

cL!uJG uq ou jo o bGL CL!IJJG LG 5 uq -5 LGbGCAGJ) M6 u10 pG!JJ OI1L gJJ9j?2J p gnuJ!iJ JJ JJ6 coGiciGUf2 oil jo A9JITG bGL

porijq ¶JJ20 gbbjX 10 pG AjflG O CL!WG 92 MGjj 'y rrcp I 2GGIJJ LG92OIJJG!iu pot bopc o GGAG 2UJL GJ92C}

pG urrwpGi. o cuw cgbr wp LbGc o pG YLLG2I L9G 91 5J flIJGLjricjajX ncp JflLG qo GX!21 GJGMpGLG FGAJ1 (J2) GlmG JG GJ CJIX oGUGJf2 O CLLUJG MP!IG ncp U GXGLG pGXoJJq cobG o bgbGi'

JJG fjJG GJ9!C!X O CLJJJlJJ G}JE1AOL M!11J LGbGC o pG C0f2 iiqjo qj MJfJJ fpi bLopJGw MG UGG !u2u1wGuf2 Monjq gJJOM I1 O

21&c t%C iic o\ c\ r cou \os

COJJJJGCIOJJ GMGGU Cf)i JG ¶flJ JLLG bGL CLILIJG

LG1IJ2 pJ 11LG o jiif J GI. o GG nuqGLLGboJ4u JJJCLG92G2

ijq L1CJFIG IJJG COLLGCfJOTJ OL nuqGLLGboLfu ELG 2 UOLWJG2 fJJGbobnjpou qGcJJG JIJ JJG flLJJOLIM C4W J�GbOL E!I1LG f 2JJOM qJG LGrIJ42MJJIIG bGL CLJUJG 0L JG JIJJbJ6 92 MJJOJG E!flLG jJOM2 1JJ6 LG11JI2 pXETITLG ' f JJ 2 OM LGf1Jf2 Oil CLIJJG bGL cbf' LLGf2 bGL CL!IJJG iiq

JAGL9G AJfiG O CJ4JJJG bGL cb1g JOMGL ( qcriq JJ IJJG IJJGOLX GCI!OU

jnpj CLUJG JUqrIcG JG2 CJ4IJJG pITs LIJJGL JJU IJJOLG CLTIJJG UJJJ<G IJJG

uq GL!oI12 cumG b cibri cuuoj G 92 G2IJL1 UJOLG

to JJJG IJ11WGL 0j CLJJJJG' tIJG UGçTAG COLL6JfJOU PGtMGGJJ AiJfl6 bGL CLTWG

JOMGL CO22 Oil CLUJIJj pGpAoL \J pOtJi O 1JJ626 ALpJG LG 6IJOGIJO11iJuqiiJ J MG 9LG uot bLobGLJX IJJG92ITILJJJ 1JJ6 GjGCt OJJJJJ6L PGUGUf2 gjjqPGtMGGIJ JJJJGL AJF1G bGL CL!IJJG 9uq P'- O' 6XblU1JJtJOU 01: tTJ!2

JOMGL tJJG COG1:1:JCJGUf ou CX JG gJJ' qGbtG tJJG G6UJIJ COIJIJGCtJOIJtJJG p92C CLIJJJG L6LGTOU iiq uq tJJJt TuCJnqIJ fJJGG AI49pJG qoG IJOtGLGJOU () O pi ipjG JucjrlqG /9JflG bGL CL!IJJG Lrq LLG22 bGL CL!JJJG Il

C1JUO4 G CJrIGq pX JOMGL Uf1WGL OJ bopcG lJ fILpJJJ S'L692

G JJq JJJJq tJJt t ! BpLbJX iu iu crtX bobnjou' O tJJG JOMGL LL6B

Page 39: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

2poLJjX C0LLGjG M!f}J ci1X pJu pG nuqa26q LLG2 LJGtp 9LL621 LYG 2 UJOLG UJb0LI1JT UCG flJG qn2lGq LLG UJJG 2 IJJTlCp IJJOLG

-•5 fJJG COGJpCJGJJf.2 OJJ cijX G JJ PX Oo\0 JU JJG2G LGLG22I0JJ2 WG GJ2PCJTA oj

coG1pcJGJi ou 21S6 WIT2 pX bbLoxrwGJX 52o\O T12JIJ C0G4!C!GU12 oi uqnuqGLLGboJ4Ju iuq nJq 2!WJL LG2cqç2 fl2JJ C0G6U oi uq - pGgGLG22J0U () iuq (2) bLG2Gu LG2rTJ12 i2JJ IJJG CI4IJJG LG2 q)fl2Gq 0L

iG C0G1TCJGIJI Oil 21G2 MJX sjmo couJbJGJXG2UJ1G GJ2lC4X O C4IJJG MJIJJ LG2bGCf J0 LLG212 o LP!2 UCLG2G qLAG2

jIJ LGLG221OU' (3) MG J(GGb pG AJflG o1 B\BC xGq f j uq L1CLG2G JG

pJpGL AIJJITG bGL CLJJJJG Mill ifl pG g LGUGCJOU O fJJG LLG2 L9G

GGCl 0 jOMGL 9LLG2 LfG2 !2 JD JUqITCG CL! UJ!1J912 10 1JCG Oil IJJOLG 142J(' IIJGLJ fJJG

JG22 0 g qJGLGucG fpJU C0IJ1LOJJ!JJ OL C!1X 2G Q COJ1L2G' TJ pG bLuJL?.

(vow JJpjG 3' LGLG22J0IJ (J))' 20 WI C0IJ4iOjIiIJ 0L LLG2 LG2 WgjG2 UJIICjJTJJI1CJJ MGJJGL IJJIJ qiG COUJJGCTJOU PGIMGGU 11JJI1G bGL CLJIJJG iq CJf)I 2JG

C0IJJJGJ0U GMGGJJ LLG2J LfG2 uq c) 2!SG (pow pJG 3C' LGLG22OU (s)) iM0LJJ bLJwL!JX JL0fl IJJG A9JflG O CL!WG iq 1J04 TuG LLG2 LG IPGLGqJ'lCG I4JG COIJJJGCfJOU PGTMGGIJ CJG2 uq CL!LIJG LIG2' ¶JJJ TJJ!2 COLLGCIOU !2

bLTJcnJi. AJflG jOL OJJG O TIJG2G G2fUJJG2 jG2G COLLGCOJJ2 2flp2TLJT9JJX2GU21IJAJX ¶JLJJ?i2J2' LfJJGL qJJJ 9 2TLOIJ COJIImIIJJJGJJI Oil OFIL b9Lf TO 9

CLIJJJG JJ 0 IJJG2G ¶J2BriWbfiOJJ2 ponjq G 26GU buwgLJJ?i 92 9 ouJJ9bbLGpGu2!ou C0212 0J CLTIIJG 9L6 T0GTIJGL 2O 0 JG 9bbLGpGu2!ou C02T2 0

!2 GdfIJA9JGLJT 0 922I1WJU f9 IJJG 20CT9J 2W9 C02f2 9JJq TJJG UOIJ-12 5' PuT JJGLG MG 9LG 9J20 922flwJil TPT B\LC 12 GdlTgj 0 J3' jpJ2 92211mb Oil

9L6 jJGLG 99Jil 922flW!JJ T9 TJJG 6J92T1C11?I 0 CLJUJG2 M!TIJ LG2bGCT TO 9LL62f2

JJJ LGLG22J0JJ (3) 0 j9JG 3D' MG !JJCLG92G TG 6192f!C!TX 62f4W9f62 o -

1AGil JLJ I9PJG 3B

C0GT!C!GU1 Oil C!TX 2!G pX JJ ¶JqqJtJoJJ9 33\0 LGT9TTAG TO TJJG b9L9WGTGL 62T!IJJ9TG

0 J9pjG 3D' MG JUq TJJ9T JucjrrqJu C02T2 9uq PGUG1T2 0J CLIJJG LGqIICG TJJG

21JJ91J 9IJ TJJG COWWIJUITX 2TJW9 GUGCI2 0 CL!UJG 9L6 211J91F JLf LGLG22!0il (i)

GdIT!A9IGJJT 0 922UIJJJ1J pG uou-9bbLGJJGu2Tou L&J9TG C02T2 0 CL!UJG 9LG

bLop9pJJrTX uq 922fflJJJIJ TJJ9T B\bC GdrwJ2 OUG JJJ!2 2GCOU 922rIuJbTTOil !21121JJ FGAJTT2 GaIJW9TG O TJJG GT92fJCJT) O CL!IJJG MJTJJ LG2bGCT TO 9LLG2T

Page 40: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

11L9JJ CLJUJG GGCFT2J1J 9LLG22 bGL CgIJ CLIIJJG W69L12 fi9f 9LLG21 GXbJ9JU CJO2G 0 J3\O 01 fiG

211i9JJ C0JJ1LpIuGq 10 fiG 10191 ITLp9JJ CLTIJJG GGCt (JG22 fJ9IJ o\ VJ4GLIJ9I4AGJX'

bo22IpJJJpG2 Jj MG 112G 9LLG2f2 bGL LGboLlGq CL!WG fiG 9LLG21 G6C !2 91 W021 9

L9fJJGL fJJ9TJ 9 MPOIGPG9LIGq 9CCGbWJJCG 0 911X OliG G2fJJJ91G' MG bLG2GIJI pOtp

JIJIGLbLG49POIJ' p111 2ILJCG OIIL M0LJ 12 JJJ fJG UJ9IJJJGL 0 9 2GU2TpAJJX 91J9JX2J2

9LLG2 bGL 9CISI9J CLJLIJG fGAi2 G2fJW90U GU2 0M9L2 fiG bLIoL!2 J1iGLbLGGq 92 fiG Gj92fJCTØ MIfJ LG2bGCf fO SLLG2f2 bGL LGboLfGq CLUJJG OL

CLJUJG pi 9Cf fiG 122116 0 MJJICp 9LLG2f WG92I1LG fO 112G qGbGUq2 011 MJ.JGfJJGL 5

CLUJJG2 fiG 2GC0U A9JIIG2 I12G f9JG fiG 9LLG2f L91G2 fO G 9LLG2f2 bGL 9C4S19J

fiG UJ9JJIT1qG2 L1A0JAGq fiG 9LLG2f L9fG2 J12G 916 9LLG2f2 bGL LGboLfGq

jJiG O1JLfJJ b9LJGJ 2JJ0M2 fiG LG2IIJf 2 011 fiG 9LLG2f L9fG2 IJJG L2f A9111G2 LtiG

fiG pGIJGTf2 GGCf 12 Qff' OL 5\0 0 fiG IJLp9JJ CLJIJJG GGCf

bLop9pJJrX O 9LLGBf' 9U 911 G2fW91G O 12 0L fiG L9f0 0 B fO LC' MG juq fJ9fLG2bGCf fO 9LLG2f fl2I1J 9 bous G2fIW9fG 0 5 0L fiG G192PCIfX 0 fiGA9LJGfX 0 922flJJibfJOU2 9p0!lf fiG L9f!0 B\bC uq fiG GJ92fCff? 0 CLfUJG MfJJIPG fplLq b9iiGJ IL! fiG f9JG 2OM2 fiG LG2IIJf2 011 fiG pGIJGJJf2 0j CUIJJG !AG11

pX LGLG22IJJ fJ9f A9U9JG 011 Cf?. 2G

WI1JfJbJXJLJ fiG COGfiCJGJJf 011 fiG OfJGL A9LJ9pJG fIIJJG2 fiG COGfiCIGUf jonuq

JJJqILGCf GfJGCf fLOfl OfJJGL A9149pJG2 fiG fOf9J IUqJLGCf GfGCf !2 0fi11q p?

JJq AJ2JJU?' MJJGLG MG qGC0JJJb02G fiG CfX GfJGCf TUfO 9 qJLGCf GfJGCf 911(4 911

G4JGCf IPG2G qGcOuibO21pou2 MGLG O1JG Iii fiG IJJ9JJIJGL 04 J,fnLbpX' 2JJIGI4GL

4GJJJ9JG JJG9G Ji0fl2GJi0J 12 fiG bL4ui9LX 49CfOL fLI LGqnC4u fiG CfX CL!IJJG

4GIJJ9JG JJG9G JJ0I12GOJ 9LG ILLGJGA9LE4 OL 2U19JJ IL! W91J1IS1qG 9Jiq 4JJ9f

GX0GU0112 91J(4 GU(40GU0I12 A9LI9pJG2' MG 4Uq fJi9f 9JJ A9J49JG2 OfJJGL fJJ9U

2JUibJG GX0G1J0I12 qGJJioL9bpcB HOMGAGL' MJJGIJ MG 1JCJ11G 0fVbbLoxJIu9fGJX' OUG-fplLq 04 fJJG IILp9U CLJIJJG G44GCf C9JJ G GxbJ9JiGq M!fIJ

2JJ0M2 fJJG 9IJJOIIUf 04 fiG G44GCf fJJ9f 12 LGJ9fG(4 fO O2GLA9JG A9L!9P1G2GdfT9fIOU () 911(4 fiG L9M GJS2fICIfX fJJ9f 12 fO G qGcouJbo2Gq IJJG UGXf b9JiGJ

COIJIJGC4IOU GfMGGIJ CJfX 2JSG IJq C14111G IJJG fL2f b9uGJ bLG2GUf2 fiG P92!C

JL! I9PIG 'f' MG bLG2GJJf fiG 4T1i91 LG2IIjf2 011 fiG qGcouJbo2fou 04 fiG

-- \J

Page 41: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

0

IG2JqGJJf2 JJ91I6 JOMGL 91LG2t 19I62 J2 9j20 9 LGUJ9LJTJJ br1jG JIJJO11 MG qo

HJG 9CCG o born. CUUJJJJ9J2 o MG9Jp) /CHW flUq6L2J9uqpJ MpX rapiuCOIIJO1f9JG JU 1GIGCJJJ 12 J1J6 G9 CI!62 LS!26 GUG JGAGJ2 p? !uci9u21116 JJOM IJJ&ç COIJIJGCPOIJ COIJJG2 YpOrIç 1JJG oujX pXbofpG22 1P91 MG GGJ

12 9 2lLOU COJJ1J6COU pGIMGGIJ ciiX 2!G JJq PGUGW JGAGJ2' MG 916 UO] drnt6

A9149JG2 16J6CI q6161JJ CPO!C62 JJJ9 CL!UJU9J2 UJ9J6 EITJ3IJGLUJOLG' pEITUCjG9L 92 10 JJOM IJJITCP O26LA6 COIJUGCI4OJJ2 P61M66U cX 2G 9JJ 1JJ626

9J20 U04 6Uf!LGIX 292XpJ JIJCG JGAGJ2 O 9UGL 916 6JJqoGuon2' MG 916IPG 1G211T12 OJJ jJJJJ6L P6116W JGAGJ2 Uq 10M61 9LLG2f 19J62 916 !IJfI4FJJJ Pfl1

111016 CJG9LJX

2pOnJq COUf1JflG u tpi A6!u uq ggGuJbf o JGL29U JG2G couLJGqoJJ2A949JG2 916 COJJIJGCIGq O 9IJJJJX 2f.I.fICffJLG' 9JJ MG p6JJGA6 JJ9I J91G1 MO1J

L6J9I!JJ O b9pGUCG 01 AJOJGJJCG 916 COJJJJGCIGq M!fJJ CJ4IJJG uq 14J91 4JJ62G

MG JJ9AG bL626u6q 9 A9L61X O COIJIJGCIGq 162flj2 2pOM!U qJSf A9LJ9pJG2

dnG2ou O MJJ? HJ!2 A91!9p1G !2 20 !mboi4su !U j69qJJJ J0 CIJJJJJIJ9J pGIJ9A!0L

2!IJJbJG q6uJo19bpc2 (oA6L 0\0)' qji b9b61 2JJ JG9AG2 11JJ9JJ2MGLG JJGMPH6 Wf1C O IJJG JGAGJ 0 GIJJ9JG pG9qGq JJO1126JJO2 C9U G GXbj9JIJGq pX

uOu-9A9fl9pJ6 A91!9p162

162!q119J 12 9 COIJJpJJJ9POU O boppjX O L6COIJ!pOIJ' 911q b162nw9p1X 041J61

bGLCGJJ C9IJ pG GxbJ9u6q pX JOMGL b1op9pJJJ)i 0 9LLG2I IPG IGJ9IJAGJX 2W9JJ

C0JJJJGC0L1 C9U G GxbJ9U6q p) JJJJ6L P6UGTI JGAGJB 111 CcJ62 JJq fMGJAG11J91 9I1Jj62 916 UJFICJJ J622 !Uf9CI J CW62 jMGJJ{?-21X bGLCGJJI 0 fJJGCLJIJJG L9fG2 E01f-UAG b61c6u O fjJJ2 C0UIJ6J01J C911 G GxbJ9JuGq pX 9Cjpi2 b9bGl 92 9f4GusbcGq o GxbJ9Tu f6 COUU6COL1 6M66JJ c!X 2JG uq

A C0IJCIt1!0U

JJJfO J2 A9110112 C0UJbO1J61J2

2\° jG JU9J 1019J 20M2 0M 1JJ6 p926 GJ92IC!1X C9IJ G qGcouJbo2GqjJ9 p61JJ (U0MU pX 0U612 ACHW ouj? L61JC62 fJJG (1L9JJ C1!IJJG GGCt pX JG22

MG 9A6 112G 52 92 0111 boju G2fJUJ96 fl2!1J JJJ12 A9Jfl6 2JIJ ouj?. aubj!629 LG92OIJ9pJG G2JIJJ9G O 1JJ6 IJJ9RJJfI1qG 0 1I40UM9j A6L2112 10LW9J 2911C1J0112'

G2fJUJ96 p1uG2 011 fJJ6 A9JI1G o K\LC MPTJ6 MG }J9AG J!1416 M9A fO Gf GAGIJ

EPJ9JJX' 1JJ6 011L1JJ b9IJGJ J00J(2 9f fJJG G6Cf 0 J(IJOMIIJg 01162 9119CJ(61 JJJJ2

Page 42: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

I

F9LOu' C (i) C'' 1CC cs oCc$1\ XqG: GJJGLJ H911cwpLqG: HLAL flu!AGLA J)LG22

FUG' (j) Oc DW Ct Cc' \cCcgbG' %UC'S i\ ECOOC 'L! OCOO f(f):LJJGJ2 IL! JJ JLGJ IJJG IAJOLG C!W6 GXCGbf jOL ypTLqGL' ygnJ uq

LLGjJ' uq ic HOH2G' (io) jLIJGJJI LoMqJIJ uq CL!1HG IPG AJOLGcnqom HOflG

)COp2' I (Ti) i 's- '\y o cu 14GM AoL:

LL1G2' ic (s�) ,C!c!G uq CLJG: V A[OqGJ' CO\:AOL!JJ JAjGu' 6%4C1\ %tS c ECO%C CX (I) 2I-5

CL0GL' P (I2) jpG EUGCI ° VLLG Oil IJJG EwbJo?uLrGuI JJJq LUTU OIufGLC!0U' c\ OtU%c3 ECOC' ocpcousu

JGGL' E f' if JCGLOtG uq 1 cpeuJ(uJu (To) 4C4JJG uq OCJjfl4 O°'. appJI0u' D : flLpU IUPG bLG2

!u V HI1 Jq c LGIGLOU E1 D1'' O\ELGGW1JJ' W (T) UCL!JJG -iq fG EWbIOXUJGuI o D2qAJLJfGq JOrJqJ2'

LJ9uO' p uq E 2JJGLPOUOIT (I) UBOAGLIX' flLp1J!s9pou uq CL!mG'44fTG uq \JWCil ECOOC : -fJEPLI!CP' J (J) JjJG DGtGLLGU EIGCI oj bij LI-JUIJJUJGJJ V O'I!-' oTOIO-DOt

pu' (j) juq uOu JilWG ruAGX',, guq MOLJ(TLJ bGL MV-uq 14GJJOLOO Oil )Of7jJ2'1 1411E1� MO4(!JJ bgbGL

C9G' iuq F K't (JJ) jJJG OIJJbJJ? JO!T KGGb: jG o wij?LOW VLLG2I jGCOLq' XO%S k o: j-BJflwGJu' r uq 1 COPGU () o juqqrij CL!wG [çJG2: TI23-ITO1 JIJCOIJJG uq TUGLGuGLfl4Ou9J uopijilX ci

DGCJ<GL' C uq J.4 IOWG (io�) vu Gdn!j!pL!riw IJJGOLX O IJJG qLprrJoubLGGLGucG' uJuJGOLbpGq

flGCJGL' C ''q C J/\I1JJJTJil (Jf) QJJ IJJG GUqOGuOrJ OLIJJpOU O UJGbLoGcJou' O ECOO 80

BGCI<GL' C 2 Uq F EPLHCP (I5) 1JtILI(G JUL!LJJJCG' 6Jj-JJJB1TLJJC6 Juq GJ—EC\ : j-jBGCJGL' C 2 (i) ICL!WG uq bnJJ!pwGIJf: v'- ECOuOJ.JJC bbLoCp'

14GM AGU: flIJ!AGLO bLGVLCPGL' D uq J� CLIJGL (Jf) 'I{616LG1JCG

qJJ2 J JJJG prijj O IJJG 1LLG GGCI

J(LIOM fJJJI npu LGJqGul2 LG LJJ!TCJJ IG IWGJX O LGbOLf qJG CLTUJGB uq J9I

Page 43: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

XFIA J-fM!LP F (i) flLpU!uJ g g O FRG ucs ci\ ocoo\

mou rq 2CPflGM!!20 1 6 gjjq w HGLL2GTU (ioo) C$ wus; 1/1GM Jo4C

1/1GM JOL LLGUPCG J-JfMGfOU' j iuq K• MGI! cCL!WJ1191 /JCJIJJJSiOJJ' TO-OOCpJC}JOL' D DGCIGL' D uq Ic OB4GU (J) obnJpou DGU! uq

ECOUOWXgp' (ioo) OCTgJ moai iJq qJG JGJ11LU2 O C4'' [OJ1LIJJ O JOJTJCJ

[JqsrnoMc' F gijq yj M0R11 (Tx) 1/1GM AOLJ<: B!Cws bLWCGOU: bLJJJCGtOU flLriAGLJ LL6

riuw' w () C%SC\ io cc ou ub!LGUUG' H (i) wws J)LTucGoIJ: b4UCGIO flUJAGL2JIX bLGJwb1JcgJou2 OL LoN$p' 4i\ los1 k coocJf\p1Lbp jç J/\J' 2IJJG!GL uq \JJUX (iôi) IIIPG JJocfioU O fgJGTJf:coj? jo CLOMfP.41 J%WCt ECOOC 3: Oô-'fT'f

J,\IrlLbpX' K7U' V PIG!1GL uq w AIPTJGX (T) 12 [{GIJf 6GJ.CJJJ O25W

qGJGLLGUCG' OL WGBTLLGUJGIJ GLLOL1 J/11I� MOLI(!IJ bsbGI.FGA!11' ' (TM) MPX qo 1JCLG2Gq 9LLG2 L9162 BBGL o L6TIC6 CLUJJG:

Page 44: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

I •MPOIC wbIc tot JUG( wq LcboI4 io bolicc cjnc jcu pcR ocugL io oo i b° jii' OL PI jJ io

0 toppitA o pone) (05224) (05528) (ose4)Hoflae CLIWO (pnL8I,LA 000 00238 0029beLeou)(IaLceuA sesrqg o (05133) (0.1288) (05599)b6L0U9I CL!WB OO'fl8 00528 00244o wn,4be oeuqete) (ooo.) (o03) (o48o)KuOM oeuqet (oL oue os O288 04392

(11235200) (ae2'94) 4185100MIfl° o4 bLobeqA 49eU 4881159 38081 209029bolice (o4je) (o98s) (09852)Heboqeq CLIWG 4o O40X4 03913 041558Lonb) (38030) (3eo3)E9W!IA !UCOWG (12 93332 °5881 89424>10 9bSLjwGu4e (03.1.15) (04932) (03494)r!Ae !U pnhiq!ua M14p 01132 005.12 01384

(0420.1) (045.12) (0499.1)0988 0.1202 09.182

(1 oo) (40853) (1020.1)IIflWPØL 04 C918 0MIJG 50954 55208 50029iucowe lu a9wbIe (04382) (09.12.1) (04545)Iii P0440W 320' I8WIIA 05912 03498 05325(*20K 40L 98)lucowe !u aewbie (09415) (o3ee4) (0-429.1)iu 4ob 52 t9W!IA ose4e 0120.1 05823

(09244) (04022) (04249)QMU Lea!qeuce 0.1081 0.1811 02848

(04859) (04880) (0488.1)Hq !OP I4 MOCK 0298 0232 09013

(osle.1) (0.1893) (059.1.1)H!abgUIC 00924 00388 00.132

(03012) (05488) (0319.1)BI9CK 01011 ooeee 01419

(s) (585.14) (see.1o)HIapeal 8taqs acpA,q 15.1551 450891 150141

(04842) (o44) (04922)VSIO 03181 03480 03941

(122408) (.1282.10) (1 93813)yae 4408 490815 434851

(04518) 00000 000002V2V 01994 0 1

(04225) 00000 (04829)CCUIL9I CI4A 05831 0 03912CL!W9 (oseec) (05954) (059.11)yueal Mea wyqe !U 00969 00824 00803

(00863) (0022.1) (008.15)A!C4IW 04 fl40 11J044 00080 00034 00082DnLaIgLA (0-5224) (05520) (0599.1)A!C4!W 04 HOnee 00101 00230 00.129

(01 818) (01408) (04883)A!CI!W 04 rYLCGUA 00392 00505 00414

(00035) (00285) (00002)ft!CIIW 04 V9flh1 00099 00041 00100

(00424) (00559) (00212)FdCg!W 01 bOPPOLA 00055 00002 0005.1

(004 00) (00358) (004.1.1)Auci!W ol j9be 00009 00002 00003

(03352) (05.128) (0349.1)MC4!W 04 CL!W0 01592 00958 01361

(eq• DO') (eiq DA) (aq DA)eau pesu jesu

B 0 VII 9359 U0U 11=1858 2N2V 11B380j,uz pA 2J/\1V uq uou-ij''

,1OIJ C'1" CIWJXJOU flLJG Djpjc jy:

Page 45: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

:flI 9IdlT thU riu noitiisimjbiV ,mnD IsnoiJs'1 O81

AM-non bnt AM d uoiigiU bisbni1 bzu ut}l1

A8M AeMe-non hA 0 8 rrr=ii nBOM nBeM nB9M (.veO .bt2) (.veU .bte) (.veO .btB)

aoM.o 0 ecc.O AM2 (8Q.0) 0000.0 (8C.0) UC 4C.eC 8UC egA

(tF.aF) (e0r.aF) (aaE.aF) ea.o SO.O ehaM

(tee.0) (e.0) (SQ.0) bvrI3B ebsip tee1IH

(reE.a) (S0.) (eatc.e) FBFF.o veao.o ceor.o

(855cc) (eaSS.0) (0c.0) arsa.o eera.o leew teal dot bsH

(ra8,0) (0e.0) (a8I.0) esee.o &2.0 e3nebiee, enwO

(eO.0) (tQ.0) (.0) 581F.o 5EES.0 yhimat O\! qot ni

(58C.0) (C0C.0) (e554.o) elqmae ni emooni (e8 iot 1o81)

8cQe.F SF.5 0.S nwo aia to iedmul4 (aaF.r) (8r.F) (rSr.F)

cr.o oeo.o raoo.o beiiisM (0000.0) (re.o) (0000.0)

e05.0 F080.0 FO8F.0 ritiw pnibhiud ni evij (C00) (aF5.0) (C*8C.0) etnemhaqa OF=<

8eo.or 5080.5 M88.5 8F) emoni yhim& (Ce.2) (05 F SE) (r0O.C) (equoip

erec.o VE.0 V8C.0 ot emiio behoqefl (S88.0) (F8.o) (E8.0) eoiloq

8'VC.0 80F8.0 *3'c.t0 eno rn) iebnetto wen)l (8e.0) (88.0) (ee.0) (eiebnetto aIqitlum to 4oe.cF 6FeF.5 cise.rc nelal ytieqoiq to eulsV

oes.cscr (c0.358) (00S.555, F)

88'.0 B0'VV.O emiio lanoeieq (acS.0) (0e0.0) (t0S.0) a to luaeaa yneoBI)

(noeieq CC8F.0 CSSF.0 ylalpiud) emh3 eeuoH

(SaQc.0) (r8c.0) (F.QC.0) (eeuo,I to yieddoi o .snb OQI ,'viu floiiiimi13iV rniiD lirnoiJk1 :wo

:nAiJ 3uIEv ,-I3bn11o wrnl mix noqi iot 3Iqm1 3IoIW 208 E0S ,8Q1 I :AM iol ldsiuv di io9

Page 46: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

Io(cocwc!cuc) ou jo(cit? 2i) MCLC cicA 2ic=w1q-boiu( o pc bobnjiou uru,,AICL1W M\ w2bcct to citA 2iC 12 C1lJCfliJi OW ipc qi cuu coqjctcut OIJ pc citA 2IC qnwWic2 jc Lc1c22ic gst IL0W 3Ldnuc. icuu ccbcucuccq c4wgnu wouqi bLiol to JUtIJ1GM iwbjicg cticjtA oi

11 93S8 8358 8358 9358 8358 8358

1-ru(r\rO) os 03 '08 'oa

ru (r) -3032 -588 -5885 -3438 -5938 -5933C!IA,,AIC4!W,, M\ Leabecg joIwbI!eq Gl92!c!4A o4 '154 O8

(ooe) (o'o9s) (00915)CRA bob > 10OO0OO 02883 03802 O395a a a a a a (ooa) (00959) (00934)C!JA bob 200DO0- O'299 03585 03592a a aaa (0091 e) (00829) (00993)C!4A bob 52OOOO- O'38O 01852 01984348k a a a (o'oe24) (00883) (o'oeae)C!A bob 400000- O'458 05232 05229aaaaa (o'oes) (o'oxlo) (o'oe)C!4 bob 20000- 03923 05311 055954aaaa (00828) (o'oese) (00883)CII' bob 0'588 01953 01934

(00812) (00845) (00848)CRA bob oooo- 0481.1 01082 01085

(o'oesa) (00822) (00929)C!JA bob ooo-aaaa 00224 -0'003 00100>=io sb9Ltwouta (oo28) (o'o2o)r!A6 !U pn.q!Ua MIflJ 01388 01125

(00505) (00188)IIflWPGL 04 C9L OMIJ 0'042 00321

(oo') (o'o'ts) (o'oi 4J) (o'o 4S)9W!IA !UC0WG (-ia -00530 -00529 -00340 -00580

(0 i4 11) (0044 't) (0 0408) (o' 4 J3)w9L1!6q -03399 -04032 -04158 -04432!UCOWG IU aSWbIG (00989) (00888) (00892) (00882)lu p0410W Seee 49w!IA 00222 00288 00298 00912(2oI 40L 9a)!UCOWG IU 89wb16 (o'ose) (00.158) (00.158) (00.152)iu tob 52.° 49W!IA 01508 011.1.1 01140 01113

(00448) (00482) (00441) (00483)LGIGUC9 -03048 -05813 -03398 -05385

(00433) (0-0433) (00435) (00433)H9 op I9 MOGIC 00298 00204 0029.1 00208

(00.141) (00.143) (00.155) (00.159)HIabgu!c -00082 -0'0040 00900 0028.1

(00289) (ooeoj) (00283) (00298)BI9CI( -00154 00038 00415 00204

(000.12) (o'ooxe) (000.12) (0' 00.12)H!ape4 aL9qe 9cpA,q 00524 00548 00581 00598

(00380) (00381) (00398) (00300)1N916 o'08e4 00.1.10 0083.1 00.124

(00043) (ooo 4) (00013) (coo 44)yâe -00094 -000.1.1 -000.1.1 -000.14

(00422) (00498) (00484)03038 050.13 01883

(00332) (04 942) (01 e02) (00444) (04920) (04988)IUeLCebt -J '3e.12 -0.1393 -09484 -43822 -0.1800 -08808

9 9 CW9 9 CUU3 9 UW9 9 CUWG 9 tUW9MCW 0 tCW O Mt4tU3 O 4Ui O tt1U3 O I.%C%W O

() (s) () (t) (2) (e)

bLoPi oL (j qw) OU Iuqqnøt Hq PJUJIA CP5LCGL!UCJ44JOU CLIWG /iCtWiSiOU HLAtA

Jpi IC:

Page 47: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

hCL2OUj CLiW qcijucq tow bL2ou OL tb OL gajnjr HOfl CL1W qucg pflL1I3 iowLclgcIJc'

11 9358 8358 8358 9359 8359 8358

i-ru(r\rO) 08 II 'n '02 02

ru (r) -5805 -1459 -ise -5018 -soie -3e5(01 348) (01 823) (01 282)

l2v.ii lucowe -044 -01218 -00981(01025) (0' x) (0' 184)

21N2V.IOM !UCOWG 00140 -00423 -00018>=o 9b9Ljweuj (o'o2o) (o'oo4) (ooo4) (00988) (00988) (01 592)rne !u pnulq!ua M!ip 0' 38 03394 0335 -00938 -0'09t -o 014

(00480) (o'os3) (o'os3) (00535) (00535) (00238)IIOWPGL 04 C9L3 OMU 00320 -00058 -00059 00480 00188 -01599dLonba) (00145) (ooie) (o'oa) (00193) (00193) (o'o32)swtA tucowe (.i -ooseo -00430 -00433 -00105 -00105 -00138

(00413) (o'o2eJ) (00295) (o'o48i) (00481) (0.1 040)vLL!eq -04130 -03418 -03403 -0'35..1 -0'3S5 -05855lUcowo lu agwbIe (o'15o3) (o'issa) (o4a) (01048) (01398) (05508)IL POI0W 52 49WA 0'025 -00442 -00058 0109 01109 0'14(22o1 40L Ba)!UCOWG IU a9wbe (01390) (0 loll) (01 aoe) (00948) (0 903) (05009),u ob 2J 19W!IA 01841 03043 04400 -00085 00992 00499

(00493) (o'oeeo) (o'o99i) (00290) (00290) (01504)OMU L!qGuCe -05895 -0'538 -0538 -0'539 -05399 -o'35e9

(00433) (00909) (o'oeoe) (00200) (00200) (0.1158)I4q 0p 1924 MGOI( 00213 01008 01013 00089 00088 00019

(o'ose) (o'oele) (ooa'n) (oo83) (o'o93) (o' 4918)HI2b9U!C 00289 O'058 0058 -00021 -00020 -00344

(00288) (00849) (00849) (00938) (00940) (01851)BI9CIC 00480 -03998 -03984 05318 0533. -04929

(o'oo2) (00404) (00404) (o'oo8) (ooo8x) (00488)H!8PI aL9qe 9CIJA,q 00598 00431 00133 0008 0'008 -00183

(00380) (o'o25) (00258) (00428) (00428) (00883)V1916 002 01113 01119 00025 0'002 05905

(00014) (o'ooo) (00018) (00019) (00019) (00039)vaG -0'004 -00083 -00083 -00025 -00025 -00148

(o'os4) (o'o1 9) (o 1103) (00295) (00858) (01155)2V12V 05404 0498 05595 04590 0'440 05200

(01 29) (05324) (05491) (01828) (05052) (04315)Iu4eLceb4 -00018 -42152 -12898 -11545 -11343 -1 '538

cuwe ciwe c%we cweMIw o beeou be%outctw oi rtcw 0 cw o, cw o cw 0(4) (s) (3) () () (e)

bLOPIr °L (Th" A!4IW) OH UqAqUH HUq EW!l CPLHCGL!I!CJ4J(JOIJJ CL!W6 /iCiWiJiOIJ IIL1G) D

L1JP1G ID:

Page 48: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

:31 9IdlT £lU riu noitiimibiV 9milD IsuodBl4

n9)1IT tiqoi b u1iY 10 JO

000.0 (C200 .0)

8CSS.O (80.0) 800.o- (O0.O)

1E.O 8Q.O (eaC.O) (e8OF.0) (2'cOr.O)

r8o.0- (ea0.0)

(FS0.0)

(8880.0) COO .0

(OS 80 .

0) C8S.0

cee r.0) 8080.0

(F rCO.0) a F .0 (8005.0)

(e0.0) 'cseo.o

(C8 F.0)

5505.0 (9 990 .0)

885.0 (a8t.0)

V8VO.0- (IF0 F .0)

eo.o- (590 tO)

8800- (F&t tO)

t08t.O (t8 F to) SC F 0.0-

(C8t F.0)

tCe F .0 (EVE F .0) F .0 (8C F .0)

8 F 88 .0 (CS F .0) 80.

Co.

89C

tqeieInI

AeMe

eeA

elaM

bvdoe ebs't teeiipiH

,13s1a

oinBqeiH

behlBM

8F) emo3ni ylimeR (aquoip

,leew leel doj beH

e3flebiaet enwO

emo3ni s1iH

nwo eio o iedmull

emooni woJ

iltiw pnibliud ni evij etnemtlsqs 0F=<

emooni rl9irtACMC

emooni eIbbimACMC

omooni wolACMC

eee,e-ooo,r qoq yti3

-000,0 F qoq yti3 eee, -000,85 qoq yti3

eee,e -000,08 qoq yJi3

eee,ee -000,00F qoq y1I3

eee,et.s -000,08 qoq yJi3

eee,ee -000,008 qoq ytI3

eee,eee 000,000,F =< qoq yii3

Fo ytloiteelo beilqml 'mitoiv'

() (C) () (F) (8)

1a o 0t

eF8.C (8 CVC .0)

98CC.0 (99 F .0)

ooo.o (QI00.0)

9 F 00.0 (088 F .0)

0S F

889 F .8 (800C.0)

(8) eu','

not'(Bq

9088.8 (0C F .0)

F 8 90.0 (8 Fo.0)

9800.0- (OSOO.0)

(980.0)

eu'o. F 0t.C (08 F .0)

OF 00.0- (F 500.0) 88 FS .0 (9 F30.0)

(n e 1 F

VC .8 (aCF.0)

8805.0 (S80.0) rooo.o-

(F 500.0) 8855.0

(2S80.0)

9Ue'J'O - 989 F

esae.c (O0C.0)

0 F 85 .0 (F t0S.0)

CSOO.0- (80O.O)

0880.0 (eSF.0)

8898.0 F8I8.O OS.0 (8OF.0) (C8OF.0) (Fe0S.0)

S88.0 (8885.0)

'VeC F.o- (F58r.0)

rao.o (98 tOO)

(880.0) eo.o

(F tOO)

98SF .0- (898 tO)

09F t.O (9SO.0)

o.

cve

88t0.0- (9880.0)

p850.0 (F tOO)

So.

aevs

S80.0- (F 880.0)

C0.0 (8F tOO)

So.

89C

So.

89C

So.

ao II

Page 49: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

:S1I IdiT £itU nohasimibiV 3milD Isiioia'1 1io o 9mrID b*zoq9$l io1 io l3dJ3dW to 2fldo1

ibuTIO w,n){ o'1 io ,nthdW bnt

behoe boc bsoqe bneo bne'ito o mt o en ol emn 0% 0% 9 e3ttoq oc \o

ocee.o *ao. r oea.o- C9B.O- O.O- Iqeoleini (8Ct.0) (CFeF.0) (890.0) (8l80.0) (89.0)

eco.o AaMa (Ot .0) (FCO.O) orO.o- ceoo.o- eoo.o eioo.o reoo.o eA

(FCOO.0) (rCOO.0) (FOO.O) (rOO.0) (8O0.0) crss.o- a8.O- oO.o- r000.o aaot.o- eleM (a80.0) (O8O.O) ('8C0.O) (8ae0.0) (eF80.0)

8900.0- bvrlaa ebsp IeerlpiH (8 too)

rcr.o 88CC.0 CFCF.O ccrr.o FFCO.0- 113818 (Cr.0) (88F.0) (8980.0) (M80.0) (89F to)

3inaqeiH (888 F .0)

reos.o- se.o- 'ceo.o o'cao.o- beillBM (Sae0.0) (0eo.o) (0eC0.0) (SeC0.0) (80.0)

0 too- a rco.o- ovoo.0 F900.0 O0.0 t) emoni yIimsR (Ot0.0) (OFO.o) (8800.0) (aOO.O) (F ro.o) (aquoip

C9F.O Q8F.0 ioeo.o- eee,e-ooor qoq yti3 (88 F .0) (O8O.0) ea F .0)

CC8C.o- F83t.0 9080.0 -000,0F qoq ytiO (C98F.0) (C480.O) (9CF.0) 992.1 8Ut.0- 3C0.J 88E.O -O00,8 qoq yJi3

(08VF.0) (8O0.o) (F8F.O) eeeet aera.o- OC8F.0 C08.O -000,08 qoq yti3

(o0r.o) (8Bo.o) (e8r.o) eee,ee 89IF0 C8FF.O -ooo,oor qoq yllo

(008 F .0) (8o.0) (t1 F .0) eee , e 08.0- 9SF.0 CF.O -000,08 qoq ytiD

(C3 F .0) (t9O.O) (COB F .0) eee ,

e e 8888.0- 0O 290.0 -0000D qoq yti3 (O F .0) (eeO.0) (8 F .0) ee e , eee

t08F.0 0F.0 000,000,t =< qoq yti3 (88 F .0) (0v0.0) (C8 F .0)

VO F. - 800. F0. to yti3iteele beilqml (wen,l' 10) tioqef

ezie ytiz) 01 toeqee, \w ta- CC- CCC- 898- (J) n.J

80. 80. tO. to. to. (J\J)nJ-F

CQ 9F8 9VF8 8FOF II

ib 3r11 no aln3bfll3o3 nn&t1zb di molt bi8Iu3I i ii ol iqi \w rioqi to 'ii3iiab b3ilqml noinIuqoq 3r11 to 3nioq-bim=i 1i3 31311W (,si i3)oL no (n3bi113oo)oI ii W .immijb .bimb b31IIuzlE3 * I - Iit n31l1 briG (n3bffi3o3* I -)oI 3Ij 3W "flo w3fl1 io9 .on1n

Page 50: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

niM --asU iIIuoY lo viu tenibutiiioJ 1noithII A8M2 A8M8-non Y8JII

£8=Il

epA

A2M2

ni 0a2> nii1lemoe dote 16ev lesq

188v esq 01 beltilqorle

10 Iooiloe Is IripuoR .iy lssq 01 *10W

ritiw enoemos bel3sttA lasq 01 O1U(ni 01 trietni

0300 < 1131U113 ebnetlA iitnom ieq

ierltom) t3stni yIimBI (lelitsI B

nertw beliow er1toM ir eps SBW tnebnoqeel

ierltom ebsip teerlpiH b'vrl3s

bvrlos ebsip tseilpiH

elsM

tnemyolqmenu 5301 etsi

Isnoipel) iltioll (ymmub

Isnolpei) rHuoC (ymmub

Isnoipel) ls,tneO (ymmub )l36I8

3inBqaiH

beau aemit iedmu1 1SOV teBq oh snsuiism

eioo2 TO1A

leuxee ben lelit epA eelUOOletfli

10 tnuo3as apIIiVBe S 85H islimia

=< pnblnhb betiste epA )leeW ieq 8300 be,lome taut epA

ettelspi3 nltiid tuontliw xea aSH

1011003

tud ,F eps to ACMC won ACMC-non

to nwotyti3 bepnsll3 rituid d3fliB eoflebiaei

B \w beplenID need iev3 em 113

yd beqqola need iev3 eoiloq

bet3iv003 need iev3

mail emooni bsH ni ytivit3s Isnimiu3

.uy tesg

E0V8 E8E ui loi1no rb-üd o\w x bOB 3)1Om2 ru Aniib rml2 i3z1 nivi 3v&I xa Io uol ii 3Iqmi (AMa-non÷AM) liioT .QII E.Q11 AM or1i1O .l3viJDq1 CÔE 01V 00V

:A 3IdlT

ea=ii nseM (.veO .bte)

0000.0 aaer.o

(tQC.0) F88S.0 (0..0)

(881.0) eror.o

(0C.0) e4e.0

(08e.0) 0Q8.0 (8.0) sa.o

(eee.0) 8l0. I F

(0aC.C) B F a t.o F

(aC0.)

(ee.0) eeet.s

(8e8.0) rac.o (.0)

( F eI.0) 8CO.0

(0I.0) 888.0

(e8C.0) 88 F .0

(aOec.o) *8Q. F

(8OVCS) B08. U

(Cee.8) ecs F

(c80s) aaca.o

(C F8.0) ecao.'c F

(808 F.) 08a.C I (a'r.C) aec.o (.0)

0 0000.0 aaa.o

(a8e.0) 00F.0

(0 F CC. 0) ae r .0 (9C.0)

C80.0 (82.0)

0.0 (08 F .0)

neeM (.veO .bJC)

(8F.) 0

0000.0 88 F .0

(eaaC.0) F FS.0

(F8 F.0)

(t'4.0) IC0 F .0

(al0C.0)

888.0 (8 .1.

. 0)

a0C.0 (8C.0)

aaea.o (8e.0) FC8.0t

(r8Sr.C) 8CC.0 t

(88 rO.S)

ae.o (.0) rca.

(8B.0) 8 F80.0

(8CS.0)

(8ee.0) C F.2.0 (Q.0)

C8S.0 (88 U.0)

28Cr .0 (F 80CC)

8, F (c r.2) F FCC.QC

(28 F 8.82) eea rct

(QOQ. F)

8808.0 (t88t.0) ee.ar (eCe. F)

(FCC.C) 280C.0

(028.0) 8218.0

(2V8.0) es ra.o

(eQQ.0) eao.o

(8882.0) 88E 1.0

(VCC.0) esao.o

(eCss.0) FCO.0

(2EV r.0)

HA

as re=ii oseM (.veO .bte)

CaC.02 (2s.s) e888.0

(28.0) ¶8F.0

(F 88CC) ea2.0 (F.0)

(8.0) 20F.0

(FCOC.0)

(8e.0) C0.0

(0'eI.0) 8828.0

(Cee.0) 2288.0 F

(CC F SC) S0C.0 F

(8CCO.2)

(ae.0) 2888.2

(8IE.0) F .0

(I0eC.0) F 0 BC .0

(F08.0) 8885.0

(Q8Ct..0) cis.o ( FC.0)

558 F .0 (888CC)

C F08. F

(SISC.2) Q8E0.F

(ee8.82) BB s

. V F

(Vt F0,5) rcsa.o

(8C8.0) C850.VF

(eaeO.s) eF F8.CF (8 FS.C)

8S€.o (e8.0)

ase r .0 (5IQC .0)

aea.o (8Ve.0)

CCPO.0 (80e5.0)

F8V 1.0 (008CC)

8580.0 (0CSS.0)

IVCO.0 (VQ8 F.0)

Page 51: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

II 8142 8442

J.ru(rr0) o '04 02 '.10 '02

ru (r) -4324 -4489 -41X5 -3338 -445qnww)) (o'o) (o'o.t94) (00493) (c'o2ot) (00480)CGUL9I (LealouBi 00180 -O044 -00450 00082 -00444qnwwA) (00432) (00490) (0048.1) (00208) (00485)2OfllP (Lea!oueI -oi.x -o'ieo -o''*e -0043 -0.1420qnwwA) (o'c483) (oo2oe) (002.10) (00252) (00240)1101-nj -00509 -0021. -00242 -00302 -00249beL woujp (00354) (00338) (00354)yueuqa cpnLcp > OUCO -01102 00029 -01102

(o000x) (00009) (cools)YEO.L 2COLG 00053 00031 00032Leabouqeui ue (00318) (00358) (o'o3)yoie moeq MIJGU 00548 -00058 005449cpA,q (00084) (00093) (o'ooe)H!3pe84 aLeqe WO4JJGL 00128 00094 0'042

(oo'n2) (00250) (o'o23) (00253)H!2b9U!C -01389 -00314 -00384 -0'088

(oo'n 0) (00428) (0'04 4) (00834)BI9CI -0'5482 -01354 -00492 -00e93

(0034 2) (0031 ) (00358) (003.1 )04883 04818 0'444 04818

(004 35) (004 25) (o'o 24i (004 25)H!dP64 aLeqe 9CIJA, 00320 -00038 -00083 -00032' 14IJ6L) (00324) (0038.1) (o'o3s) (00885)ESW!IA IUI9CI (wozpeL -0'024 -0'0.8 -00400 -005881-940 (oosa) (00538) (00542) (00540)rocet nuewblokweul -00593 -00513 -0058 -00505

(00038) (00039) (o'oo3) (00038)yae adneeq -00053 -00041 00042 -00011

(044.9) (01438) (01242) (01200)yae O043 04388 -01404 04382

(0' 0043)VOJ..2Vl2Y -00008

(o'oa8)E9W!I?t !U49C4.2V2y -00823

(0' 0845)BI9C,(.2vav -0089W9L!fl9U9 U beej ?e9L (00088)nwpe1- g!wee naeq 014X9Leciqeuce aiuce P!'-W (00352) (00334) (00352)CPUQ C!4I\40MU Ot -00439 -0028X -00438

UOU- UOM (o'oeos) (00948) (00802)jy eg ee pfli 01144 00035 0J18

(o'o34e) (o'o34) (00244) (o'o22) (close)2V12V 04082 01304 01828 04193 05810

(00430) (44309) ( '2J3) (12858) (4 '21 94)

lu4eLcebS -08149 -13581 -3'340 00813 -54530rn be'i k w bees ) u bees ) tu ee ) tu be )

<toobei.O b.obe} obetX btobe} bo}2IO0U VOteU 00U 1O0U VOtBU(1) (5) (3) () (2)

uq EW!IbLOPI O (JpGIpCL OL J404 g€2bouqGuI gGbOL 4oIGu) on

WU0U1 f0UtflqW1J PLAG °1. A°'W DIJUjG 3B

Page 52: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

11 0f42 8142 8142 8142 8442

J-ru(r\r0) 03 03

vu (r) -2548 -21.2 - 21 -138 -2444qowwA) (00412) (oo''t) (00421) (00490) (oo'425)CGU4L9I (L081ou91 -008J. -00841 -00821 -00053 -0038qnwwA) (00400) (oottt) (00448) (00499) (00448)2011W (&ediou -05204 -05209 -05544 -01444 -05552qnwwA) (oo44) (oole3) (oo'tee) (00483) (oolee)Ijop (L.a!ougt -00941 -00908 -0044 -00133 -00215beL wougj (oosex) (00313) (oo5a)yueuqa CflLC >= ouce -01204 -00333 -oieoe

(00001) (00001) (00014)VEOI 2COLØ -00053 -00052 00001Leabouqeug M99 9a6 (00583) (00304) (0 0583)VIOIPGL MOL6 MIJCU 00281 00599 00288

(00022) (00021) (00022)H!dPea4 8LUqe WO4PGL 00155 00051 00444

(00453) (oolee) (00484) (0 0488)HIabeUIc -00440 -00014 00155 -00183

(00310) (004.13) (00458) (00128)BI9CK -00898 -01088 -00040 -01 104

(oosee) (00588) (oosa&) (00599)Il9IQ 04849 01893 01321 01803

(00418) (00138) (00141) (00138)H!8PØ4 8LYqG 9CA, -00408 00043 -00059 00038

ipe) (00351) (00351) (00340) (00950)E9WIIA !UI9C4 (wojpoL -01001 -00103 -00004 -00410L940 (00512) (00319) (00554) (00311)roc9i nuewbloAwoul -00549 -00531 -00311 -00589

(00033) (00033) (00032) (00033)yae adn9leq -00435 -00153 -00090 -00131

(01 o) (01389) (01 430) (01398)0laee 04485 01925 04441

(00015)VEOI.2V12V -00044

(00152)E9W!IA !uI9ci.2V12y -00512

(00848)BICCI(.2V12Y -00058W9Lfl9U9 !U beaj 1e9L (00099)IIIIWPeL 41W92 naeq 01925LG8!CUCG 2IUCO P!L4IJ (o'osa) (00308) (00588)cp9uaoq C!X40MU 04 00131 -00003 00133uou-2IJ2V UOM (00241) (oo2e8) (00220)2V2V 94 sae 14 p114 00903 00351 00282

(00334) (00343) (00480) (00200) (ooase)2V&2Y 04219 01280 04813 01015 03199

(00382) (13109) (14033) (14243) (14049)IuleLCeb4 -00191 -20038 -4e3ee -41833 -49120

be u tu be u b9%( uobec obusq oeq obeq sobueq() () () () ()

ou uq 1uiijA CP5L9CG44!CbLOPI( OL (pqpGL OL J404 gGbouqGu gGboL Hau pobjicq)

J,1110U3J fournquBj flL16? OJ JOfljJ D1"IPJC

Page 53: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

II 8142 3199 3142 3488 3188 3188

1-ruj(r\r0) •08 00 13

ru (r) -1353 -.92 -332 -1899 -1558 -880qnwwA)ceuni (Le8uouSl

(00801)O0.13

(01031)00352

(00203)-oisoe (oot8)-O020

(oo84e)-03898

(ooos)-03802

qnwwA)ontp

(00833)-o

(oi isI)-os

(00208)-03488 (oos)-053

(oo8e)-04204

(o. 014)-02588

qnwwA)WOLUJ (kodiousI

(00828)-00238

(0.1109)-01 fl0

(00254)-01833

(oo8J)-01 45

(oo82)-01989

(04052)-03028

be woutpyueuqs CPflLCP >= OLJCG

(oo23)-0 4 3s

(oo4o)-04885

(00338)-0 1998

(00250)-0 i 33

(00904)-oste

(ooo2)-o

YEW. COLO(00013)-00030

(oooi.)-0009

(00008)-00023

(ooois)-00023

(00044)-00023

(o'ooie)-0008

LaSbouqsus M9S saoJO4OL MoLCOq MJSU

(00233)-00203

(oos3)-00815

(00332)00930

(00213)00233

(00282)04.18

(00883)01125

9CpA,qH!aps? aLsqe WOfIJ6L

(00100)0001

(00145)00089

(00083)00508

(00033)00102

(004 12)-00105

(00134)-00184

HIb9U!C(00805)-05413

(01184)-01919

(00258)-00933

(00803)-00833

(00831)-05442

(01100)-03119

BISC$(0 0884)

00420(00824)

0122oo98)-05588

(oo32)-01 88

(00938)-0332

(00035)-0303

Vd916(00238)

04132(ooe2)

09852(00340)

08195(oo2s)

O'X883(00859)008

(ooes)0123

H!8P68i aLgqe gc$m,q(00530)-00289

(00322)-00823

(00125)-00491

(00525)-00444 (oosi)-04335

(00308)-00905

494psL)E9W!IA !U49Ct (wolpeL

(oo2eo)-00004

(oo2a)-o43e5

(oo3o)-01323

(00299)-01404

(00859)-058

(oo34)-05038

L916rocsi nuewbiokweuj

(ooa8)-00350

(00255)-00283

(00542)0000

(oo3e)-00393

(00454)-01428

(oo9s)-0149

yae ednsLeq(oooel)-00092

(05258)01821

(00082)-00102

(o32s)04520

(00039)-00103

(04290)09922

(00020)-00083

(05993)04519

(00099)-00515

(03893)4013

(oooe)-00400

(03581)02541

Leauqeuce SIUCS PILWcpsuaaq C!7tj0MU O

(00290)00.29 (oos)00X82

(00390)-00434

(00212)00402

(00208)005 (oooi)01585

UOU-j UOM2V12Y St S8Q J9 P114

(01093)04883

(01480)-00190

(00843)00954

(04 04)00498

(01519)00900

(04353)000

2V2Y(00822)

0550(52334)-5e9se

(01302)00408

(32384)-'49385

(oo2i)05903

(18054)-28598

boc.e

E"

(00350)05401

(54003)-4058cwe

COWWRQCOUO OU

ottcssobbeq pX

E'('4)

(04090)04 5i

(59950)-i023cweN SC5%

(0.1180)-04 33

(33381)-29252

ou,ceql5l

IuteLCeb4bs } u bS%;

ow CW5 )tOW t4WSUtOWQ S% UCOWC

(1) (s) () (e) (e)OU uq E9W&

J4I'A: bLop!12 O OWE'- JfG9I1LG O C""1 VC1i1JJ'PI

Page 54: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

11 803 l't31-ru(r\rO) '02 '02 '0 '0.

ru (r)qnwwA)CGUIL9I (..eaioue1

qnwwA)eonni (LediOus1

qnwwA)L1°LIP (Lea!ou9I

!UieU( 40 !UlflLe !U b9ejvueciceq aoweoue M4PC a e L$4IOyae Lag awoceqouce be.. MøøI(yde 8f9Leq qL!ulquä >=C0UL0IH98 26X MIIPOflI P!LIIJ

MOLIC !U b984 A..-E0flPl 94 8C00 OL81W!I9L

9 89A1U89 9CCOI1U( OL

IUI8LCOn188yde 4!L( 1J9q CCXfl8l

..eeiqeuce 8!uce P!LIPcpgudeq CIIA\IoMu 04U0U- UOM

94 ae J$ Pfllbe.. woupyueuqa CIJflLCIJ >= ouce

V10.L 2COLO

Leabouqeut M98IØJOIPGL o..uceq MPGU

9CIJA,qH1ape84 dL9qe wope

H!3bSU!C

BIBCI(

V9Ie

H!dPeel aLyqe 8CpA,q

2C 494pe1)E9WIIA !u49C4 (wolpe..(946roc9i nuewbloAweug

yae adn9leq

iuge..cebi

(o'o33)-0094

-5355(00929)

00003(o'oe.4)-0' 1343(0' oe)

0'059

(009.12)0'30.4

(00090)-00580

(o'o00)-0'030

(o'o2e)00538

(00482)030e5

(o'oio2)0'Ol 11

(00.1 o)-005 00(o'o'o)

0' 0040

(o'o83)0'04Q

(00444)-00130

(00010)00038

(00431)-00551

(00099)o'o.ioa

(o'os)00350(00922)-01 39(o'o4o)

03513(0' 08)

00139(00483)-00120

(00350)-00004

(0'002 0)-0'002

(05005)oseo

(0'022)0.1920

(51 300)-5-9ae

(2)

ucrn%w UOtt %flLZ O\ titutou IuqAIqflJ EWII CPL4GLCbLOP!* °L (jpGIpGL OL J4OI gGbouqGu Hu1tu zoIGu)

4OUJ foIJInqwj flLJG) O JOflflJ D*L9PIG

-340 -305 -4092 -3503(00239)-00582

(0020.1)-0'029

(00404)-00384

(0022 i)-00580

(00240)-0.1453

(00203)-01944

(o'o4o)-0'J4Q

(00224)-01249

(00290)-00902

(00253)-0'049

(002.12)-00422 (o'o2)-00244

(00390)0'480

(00405)0'432

(00400)-001 9

(00085)-00384

(ooo82)-0'0351

(00320)-0'0J4

(00335)-00434

(00359)-00215

(00399)-00108

(ooee)00293

(009 3)0082e

(o'oeoe)0.1089

Co oes3)00385

(00328)-0'040

(00335)-01022

(00359)-00008

(00390)-0'001

(00008)00032

(o'0009)00035

(o'ooo)00045

Co 0008)00048

(0032.1)0'000

(o'o35)00592

(00353)00313

(0039.1)00148

(00090)00120

(00093)00190

(o'ooes)00129

(o'oo1)o'o.1e

(0029.1)-O'O00

(00233)-01041

(00259)-00850

(00288)-0'00O

(00200)-01 95

(o'o4s)-01359

(00493)-01451

(002.1 e)-0.1

(00399)04284

(00354)04900

(00335)03919

(o'o38)0'328

(00.192)-00001

(aol 2)0'OO5

(o'o 24)-00035

(001 1)00018

(0-0331)-0'O49

(o'o3xo)-O'O51

(oo3e2)-0'O99

(0-0403)-00448

(o'oseo)-00.193

(00543)-00559

(00540)-00521

(o'osee)-0'050

(00040)-00094

(0' oo3)-00041

(o'oo3e)-00042

(0004.1)-0'001

(01 e1)05549

(01235)01344

(01214)O'1X12

(01 Xl )O'598X

(00900)0'1X29

(00221)01900

(o'o24X)OJXOX

(009.12)01250

(1 'Xoel)-52232

(1 '220X)-5'30X9

(12338)-30115

(.i'X24x)-33851

w be%I A%<%%0

btobtiXIoeu

(.1)

b98L<%0

obAoeu(5)

t9%% AL tU b98%0bobeA obei;Aoeu oeu(3) (4)

2V

'U 'U 'U

Page 55: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

II X432 803 8142 143 415

j-ru(r\rO) 'ot 03 0 09 09

ru (r) -4585 -4808 -48fl -3824qnwwA) (00404) (00985) (00490) (00214) (o'oe)C$U4L91 (LeousI -O0.13 -00954 -00221 -00848 00103

qnwwA) (00434) (00480) (00423) (00214) (00031)ongp (LaaIou9I -05280 -05988 -05525 -05832 -051X5qnwwk) (00211) (oo4e) (oo42) (00233) (ooe4e)IIOL4P (LaiougI -0043 -0020 -00588 -0040 -00038Ày!UiGU4 40 lUinLe !U beat (00233)449CK9 9OWGOU9 MI4IJ

C1d9L944, (00082)ve 1!L2i woceq -001X9ouce beL MQCI( (00109)yae 949L49 qL!uIcIua > -00521couoi (00243)

20X M14p0fl4 pILjp -00093MOLIC iu bees ?tL (00332) (oo34) (00494)eonapi 94 9CPOOI OL 0.5H oe8e2 O915O!W!19L (00338) (oo32) (00490)H9 9 29A!Uä9 9CCOOU4 OL -00444 00138 00080

!u4eLcOnLae (oooe) (00090) (oo los)yae UL84 peq 2GXfl9l -00981 -003.9 -00503teqeuce 9!UCQ P!LW (00358) (00302) (00309) (00340) (00411)cpuu8eq C!4lt\4OMU 0% 00534 000O 0004 00508 00523

U0U- UOM (00904) (00290) (00229) (00859) (oo4)2?2V 94 eae J4 P04 00493 00895 00214 002\ 01123boL W0U4 (00358) (00302) (00303) (00341) (00412)vueuq CIJOLCP > OUCS -01181 -0100X -01408 -01 189 -010�8

(00008) (oooo) (oooox) (00009) (oooo)VEOI 9C010 -00008 -00051 -00002 00004 -0000Leabouqeui M92 9d6 14 (00351) (00300) (00539) (00334) (00402)04P6L M0Laq MPGU 00309 0020 00889 00338 -001439CPA,q (00005) (ooo2) (00020) (00004) (oooa)HI% aL9qe WOW6L 00133 00114 00155 00153 00194

(00251) (oo49) (oo4e) (00241) (ooe)H!ab9U!C 00233 -0050 0008 00468 01409

(00421) (oo4s.) (00455) (oo45) (ooeo)BlCi -0' 133 -01153 -01 30 -01420 -01500

(00333) (00582) (o'o3o) (00328) (00439)1191G 01048 0'L8J 00058 -00893 -01131

(00120) (00143) (00145) (oo12) (00189)H!6IJG4 L9qe 9CJA,q 00084 00139 00082 00105 00335

%g4peL) (00329) (00338) (00334) (o'o3x1) (00423)E9W!?t !U49C4 (WO4GL -00021 -0098 -00230 -00053 00005

L940 (oosae) (oosso) (oosso) (00544) (o'osaa)roc9I nuewboAweu -00359 -00139 -005 -00592 -00588

(o'003) (00034) (00034) (00039) (ooo4)yde edn9Leq -00105 -00112 -00132 -00119 -00105

(01243) (01451) (01410) (oleo3) (01 3X4)03439 04115 0'21.8 04538 03490

(00244) (00203) (00200) (oooe) (o'oo4)2IØ2V 0'1.44 05016 01955 0191 01.45

(1 '234) (1 432x) (1.4354) ( 9323) (501 s)lUiøLCeb4 -59193 -45880 -2843 -41410 56643

IU b9% tU b8% W b9%I \U b99 %U b99%

obneq obeq oneq obieq ob%e(.1) () () () ()Ut% ZI%L O 3cOU I'''1'J aq LW!I

LLOP( ol. (JjxpGL ox. oj KGboq2 pobIGq)wiotrnj fouJ4nqxusJ nLAG? OJ AoW D"1

J,pi

Page 56: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

14 8103 432 043 8142OL

1-ru(rr°)

ru (r) -xo -3539qnww)t) (00484) (oo3) (o02e4) (oo2e) (o'oI83)CBUtL9I (Loa!ou9I -00140 04488 0049 -00184 -00232qnww?t) (oof.l) (ooe2) (00228) (oo2) (oo43)eonw (Leafou9l -00122 00184 00058 -00481 -OO48qnwwA) (00202) (00805) (00281) (0O93) (00488)IloLp (LGa!ougI 008 04 4.4 00582 -0 4 J4 -01002bek wougp (00343) (o'oa8) (00385) (00483) (0031 -i)yjeuqa CflLC >= ouce 04842 oeo -0043 o4435 -0084.1

(oooo) (00045) (00008) (oooi 1) (oooo)YBO! ?COLG 00J3 00088 -00023 00048 -0'002Leabouqeu MCC sae j (oo3o) (00485) (00328) (00492) (oo3oe)VIO4PQL MoIceq MPOU 00\85 -00883 OS3 -oose4 -005449cpA,q (ooo2) (00084) (oooe) (00083) (ooo2)HIapeef aLaqe WOIPOL 00328 -00054 -00089 -00134 00014

(00495) (00840) (oo21) (ooes) (00480)H!eb9UlC -00803 04014 -00145 0J98 -00235

(00412) (00880) (00489) (ooo1) (0044 )BI9CI -04008 -08853 -008S 04498 01039

(00301) (00482) (00322) (ooix8) (00304)vs9Ie -00838 -13980 o4ole -0x028 0048

(00144) (00550) (oo12) (00534) (00143)HIapse4 dL9qG 9CA, 04459 05895 -00441 01188 -00550

t911J0L) (00335) (00242) (00388) (00225) (00339)E9W!IX !UIØCS (woipeu. 05528 04813 -00989 ooeso -00985L819 (00554) (00384) (00594) (00323) (00552)rocei nuewbtoAweu -00805 -00002 00230 -00408 00184

(00032) (00028) (00040) (00022) (00032)yae 2dneLeq 00089 0008 -ooise -00485 -00040

(01494) (05344) (04889) (05313) (04423)-04138 -03391 024 0819 -00258

eqeuce uce !P (00314) (00204) (oo3e2) (00984) (00310)cpuaeq C!X\OMU O -005Q -01388 00H5 -0135 00585uOu-22y UOM (00242) (00881) (00929) (00983) (oo24)

e ede J pfll -00880 -01.\5 00354 -0'J90 00228(00982) (00802) (00234) (00905) (00483)

2V12V -00244 -05393 01333 -00325 00898( 449) (see) (1 (5321) (.1 495)

luleLcebi 58 15330 -X5080 88855 008X2W19t tUeLCOflL% COUkO

cconu ot ieq eine ouce be wPMOfl %ULtUa > %3OO OL

8 S2 8X Ofl1 8(1) (s) (3) (i) (2)

oil uqwqnj iluq EWH CPilLilC1GL!1!CLLOP! "i oi' O hf€UCC J6IIL6

IA3r!011hI ouignqwj ot i°"w Di'L"Pi 3C

Page 57: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

onLcc: cornuA uqC! DPOOF ERI niouJ cuIjbot

(oooQ)hOf!CG bGL c,bj 0018

(ox)bLCCUi WIG pq o ponpojq(oog)

flhJGwbfowGu L4G 0Q(oo)bGLC6IJ MI4JJ ?L COJJGG

(,''5Q)hLCGU !P P!P CJJOOI

()bCGU UOU-iqJJG .1831

(1 t I)bGLCU1 JJOfl1J ONIJCL occnbGq

(oa)KCLIJ bob PGJO boAGLt? J5(3VQ)

b0bflhI4J011 I 1'825

(cff)CGUtL1 (LGornIJ qnwwA)

(.f4.4)2OflP (LGow1J qnwwA)

(IOOQ)frOL (LGIouI qaww)

(og)VLLG2 bL CUWG Yt13

(io4)MJ" jjGu bcr. CLJWC

LCbOI4iU p) ()I4Ofl CL!Wc bL C9b1t (qncq L°' ii(058)

LIOn2 CL!C bcL cbiw (nuqn4Gq)

- GU iiq Duq suqq DG3Z!OU

IIU!LOLW CLIW6 j{6boI3 uuq co,izJr uq DPOOt(CLO C!I D1343

JJ6 y:

Page 58: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

2flLA O1 A!CIiW1tOUvqnq cuw unwpci q1nq ot nuqcL-I.botiu o CUUJC2 yqinuur wctpoqojoA nc CLJW uq LboLLJu qiri LIOW niouijwuqi.q qiuiou2 2OMU!U bm.cu(pc

Ic3 50 18 45 48 '38 '44

Q Qn Q3 Q3 Q3 Qfl

qnww) (o4o) (o) (o4o) (o'i) (ogot) (ox) (o41)CGULI (LiolII -JOàI 0QI -J?QQ -18Q -0381 -'00à -IIOqnww) (o& (on4) ('otsi) (otn) ('os) ('0808) ('otoflouq (L6iou1I '08X "01W '03ô -01 048ô J 134 '0à\qnwuiA) (on) (otn) ('oto'i) ('oo) (oo$) ('oQ) (otQ)OLfJJ (LGiouJ -1814 -3Q03 -3QÔQ -3QÔQ -'334à -1Q "18Q3

ponpojq ('ti) ('og) (l'o.) (103?)bLCU LGWIG pGq O( 3'3Q 3'4 $'3 QQ

('a3x) (8) ('Qos) (ti) (Ii I?)fluGwbJoAwu '5i0 30? 10!Q 3'3H 1383

COI1GG (jg) () ('j)bCLCGU NJflJ -Q334 -40?? -4343 ?0Q8 51O3

cpooi (.si) (s1) (sxi) (3eo) ('?Iag)bGLC€04 IJJflJ 4 AL pp I?53 5388 300Q '1335 50X3

(1105) ('14Q0) ('I?oI) (.3) ('3xa)b6LCGII uou-hjniG 3534 -'5à03 -30X3 -. IQS? -'53?Q

occnbl6q (its) ('is4) ('l?QQ) (lou) (3oQ)bGLCCU p0fl!IJ OMUGL -'413ô -1541 -'I!Q't -'03?5 3Q43

bo,GL (t3st) ('i4) (to1) (aoa) ('gs)b6LCCU4 hob pqoii l8Q3 'Q14? ?54Q '348.1 J'??I

i ew) ('o1) ('oi) 'oi) ('orQ4) (031?) (0304) ('oix)FO (C!4A b0bfl1I0u '1Q3? 'IOIQ 033 '1Q8 '0ôt '30?! 3383

('18I) ('ss) (s) (sst) ('?o) ('t4g) ('soI)JU4GLCGbr -4'4O -3'.X38 -'t533 -4'38 -Qn -1548 -4?000

tt.fl.U% ZI1%% tJW%z. . .(I) () (l) (i) () () ()

OU '1 oJJL CiCLO C Dt"" gGLG2IOU O CI.UJ ffLG

lupic

Page 59: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

riuqmq qcAiriou 2p0/iW IIJ btuip gingcq cuwC unwpcL ac ig1ntcq ot nugcL-LGboL1iu oi CLIW

31 04 0 8

e33 Q33 Q33 Q33 Q33

qnww)) (oQoI) (o3) (o) (oss) (o4I)CGIJLI (LJozrnJ R8?\ -0Q0 -035 1031 -3lQqnwwA) (oo) (os) (o) (oss) (ois)Ofl4 (LG1ornJI OISÔ 0410 O5ô? 50 -034!qnww) (o8e) (oeo) (oes) (o3s) (ot85)14OL1P (Ls,ouøf -01 -08Q3 -08Q1 515.1 -3Q51

(osg&j'o (yu.c CL1WG) 0300

(ossg)['Ok (A'I"\ CL!WG) -.

ponpog (so) '1405) ('t38) (ets) (3Qo)bGLCGU4 pq OL -l00Q 1'OIl -1121 4103 311.1

(.a8) (xe) (8000) (3so) (Qo)fluGwbJo)wGIJ1 L9IG -1Q? -INS -l53 3383 1148

COIGG (t3s) ('311) (3431) (1Q85) (ste3)LGLCGUI &ip 4 -31.10 -38.13 -343 8100 -414.1

cpoo (tte) (e12) (3eo) (1.g) (3Q03)bGLCGUI 4 F!P -3)l8 1212 OQ2Q -.110.1 1Q48

(ste) (1o83) (ii) (0.12) (iti)bLCGU1 IJOU-MJJifG 80Q8 0105 030.1 -525 -. 1XQQ

occnblGq (s8) (soea) (30.18) (1018) (1tx)bGLCGU pOflIJ O1UGL -.104.1 1014 025 -O3Q.1 -304bo,GL (e84) (es!!) (e33e) (3o?e) (tit)hGLCGU bob PION -333 1018 110.1 -1830 1333

(osx) (03w) (031.1) (oloe) ('0128)ro (c& hobnI41ou 14.11 -'0331 -08l '04Q8 '1081

('oexs)GI4Ofl CL!W6 bcL -'3Q3 - - - -

('ee) ('38) ('3os) ('Ioo.1) ('3Io)tU4LCcbr 482 -1181 1000 -.1103 -33.11

C' C" C4 Cubtuxt. b. bt. o' C%I1.oIt '%.

(1) () () (4) ()°fl C'O G uq Ø4L C

CLO C! D4-- gGLGIOU O JJ}1IG JGII VLLG JçJG C4' ff1GLPt c:

Page 60: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

qinq cuujc UUC fl?G q1ntq J1Jt L9(Gwqtq q'!r'°' pomu lu bt rupcc q1n2cq cuwc unwpct nc Jq1n1q ct) 1OL nuqL-Lcbouiu oi CLIUJC2 CLiOlJ2 M

Q33 Q33 Q33 Q33

qnmmA) (ootQ) (ooit) (0oQao) (oo4g) (ooss)(Liou -0003 -0013 0131.X -0031 -00510

qnwwA) (ooa3) (oos) (ooJ4) (ooo3) (ooti)onp (LiouJ -O031.X -00394 -00338 -0OIQa -0018

qnww) (ooxQ) (ooss) (00832) (oo28) (ooQ3s)MOLW (LciozJnJ -03ô9Q -038? -0433? -033Q -03ô

(jxGq) (ux) (uq) (q) (ijxq)fo (LLG CL!WG) -03000 -03000 -04000 -03000 -05000

(xGq) (pxcq) (uq) (uq) (pecq)f'o (jJnG\ CL!W€) 03000 03000 0Q000 03000 03000

ponpoq (oe3Q) (oQ8x) (osti) (oe& (o)I,LCGIJt tZIG }7GJ O( 3Q1?O 383ôc) 43152 33c0 3ö.'8I

(oe8eJ) (oxtoo) (ooo'f4) (oQaoo) (os3)uswbio)wcu Lj lios J3o3J jjg 14oo8

(o3) (o31) (otsQa) (03003) (03333)bLCG11 HJW -O442 -04338 -04Q00 -0$80 -0482

(03119) (o8) (oI3) (03180) (03433)hCLCCU4 Iip AL pJ1J 03?99 04030 0X?3 04343 04à4't

(o1ox) (o1a93) (ostx) (oixto) (oin)bGLCGU IJOU-1i1JirG -04Xl I -02Q32 -0834.X -O4à04 -02820

occnb6q (oI3) (oiss) (03283) (01812) (oIo4)bGLCGUI pOfl!U OHIJL 003 00038 03I1. 003L 00)Q3boIGL (o'2I) (o'2n1) (ox22) (ot) (o28Q2)bGLCG1II bob- pGIoI 12450 103 3133 l413 18340

(ooI8e) (00301) (oosio) (001o) (00304)ro (CiA bobnI4ou 0OQQ4 00221 001 OJ32 0HQ

(03338) (03Q00) (04838) (o34o) (o3x0)IULCGb -2XQ8 -Q4533 -WQ33T -?328 -Q2ô90

ciC4%U C4WZ (UW (flU%¶)$O1t% %.%Ot 4OtZ 'UOIZ c.tOtZvo v r vo vo(1) (s) (i) ('t) ()

!ip gibq 10 VLLG1 ffØG uq AJfl6 bL CL!W6 E'qOil C1 !6 uq OIPCL C!LA CPL9C1GL1JC '!1P EJ51ICI1!G °L CLJWG

CLO C!1 Dill-- gGLG22iO1J oLIP1G 1D

Page 61: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

\ic =oit — i ix —tt \c O4O fP6 E6C OJ B6U61iP: B6f bOJU Ef!W96 O1 B'!f EGCI

b°!PI6 GJ1GW O CLIUJG MIfJJ LG2b6C o bLoppJlX o gLLGf: =' i— 4

L02iPi6 LPO O pGuGr O co: = J—

5

JJJG GJpC!lX O p6UGII2 MIJJ L6bGC O CJIX JG = J

1116 fl6UGTf O C4UJG —------

viiow -oowEGUTG HOpOjq Of

cowpuGq EXO6UOU iJq UO6IJOfT JL!YpJ6

bITL6JA EXO6UOfl JVUJ6 MIIJJ UO Of6L coufLoJ: y— + >ocou1Lomu oL JLjgpj6: AXC'A) 'bC

+c + \Cx

BM F! fC!fA (IucJnqu 6OUj DflW1J.J6): ¶ =ifJQbC h bC b _______ q4 _______O EOb +E0 11OB +bCX

fl2IC D6COubOmou:

1P1 'f 1P D6t0Wb0if10U O JJ6 flLpu CLW6 EU6CI

Page 62: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

Q5f '6wJUu flLPJ C'W-' EUGC4

002 F0MGL J)LOppJJJf?I O J�6COIJJfTOUOO fOMGL Lopp!JJf? o 1TLL6fON HJJJ6L J�GIJTLU2 fO CLIWG

+ OOf QfpGL Qp6LMJpJ6 LrpJG2- Of 6WJ6 Ofl6JJOJ2 E6C

J2 2G J2fJCJfXiuj jOfSJ

=oo —osw =oo�tO fJJG EIGCf2 O KIJoMJJJ: B6 bO!LJf EW9f6 O LL6I2 E6C

E19PCJf)' O I(TJOM1U AOHL 44CJ(6L MIW gGb6Cf fO C!f2' E = —

L°'PJ6 6Jpcrçi62 o CLIWG MJfp LGb6q o fG bLoppjJ o 1LL6Bf: =

JJJ6°:E2\bC: 2-2

JJJG EUGCt OJ gUOM!U OUG yugcJc6L:

OO8 —*O35 OJÔQ

JJIJ6 O fJJG EU6Cf O yLL6f: B6f b0Uf EWf6 O fLL62f EJ6CfEo' VLL62f2 bGL jUIG

OO55 —)OO88 Qo'Oj JJ6 EUGCf2 O VLLG2 B6 LOJIJ Ef!WJcG O TLLGB E16Cf

bGL [GboLf6q

b°'PJ6 6JfiCJfTG O CLTUJG MIfJJ L6bGCf fO fJJG bopprjiX O SLL6f: =

niu LL6f bGL fLTTG CLTIJJG

JJJG GjJfJCifA O 9LLG2f bopprjiX MJfJJ LGbGCf fO CJf) JG =—. g'LL62f bGL LGbOLfGq CLTWG

flI6 GJ2fCfX O LL6f bLopppiX MJfJJ LGb6Cf fO C!f) !SG t = —. o j'

JjJ6 jLoppfJA O VLL62I EEjgpJG f' COiJpIJn6q

Page 63: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

noihduqoI tiD bnfi 9mD :1 91uiI

CF. :beisupe-fl - xFO. = y

rioitiiIuqo IiD brii i9brnM : 91U1

Foo.

eooo.

C)

CD - CD 2 0

8000.

00oJ. 8000. 0

CD

a000.

CD OO0. 9 C

c000.

000.

r000.

nAci nois!uqoq iD bct 9ffiID n99wi9d qirIrIolisI91 rft eworI n.ri1 9e9rLT

9rli ni DiiiEie- 9rIT 08Q1 en{i bnIB ahoq951 9mm) rrriolinU 8I 9111 roil ..f1 ai noix91 brloD92 9111 lii Diiarli-i 9111 .1?4.Q i noiee19i iiil

at ear at e.tr t a.cr Cr 8.t cr a.rr rr e.ot or (noiisIuqo ti3)nJ

8t. :belaup2-R 1-3Fi - xa-38Fe. = y

8.CF Cr e.sr r (noitstuqo

Page 64: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

CitK bobnIuJo1J

•ooo- oooo- iooooo- 5OOOO- OOOOO- >1OOOOOOI I I

3o0t0000800

JO00

AIfl6\ CL!WG (rice)

CO j,obnjiiou

5?OOO OOOO 1OOOOO- OOOO OOOOO >JOOOOOO

000

050_•-M flC1 D

•__________ ___________________________________________I

LL6 \CLIWG

C! b0bflIU101J

'ooo- OOOO- IOOOOO- 5OOOO OOOOO- >OOOOOOI I I

JM flCI� D1.—•— —I010

050 yq1n2Lq OL nuqi LthO!U

0.3. 0—CL!W \ Cb!J

LIDL6

Page 65: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

C! b0bflIU!O11

ooo- oooo- Ior000- oooo- ooooo- >=i oooooo000O5O

o.tocq LOL nuqcL LCbOU1U

VLLG\CL!WG j,oLunqI6q

Cll b0bflPU!011

OOO- OOOO- tOOOOO- 5OOOO- OOOOO- >IOOOOOO

000I

0•500400Q0080

flCI� D

CJ4WG \ C1b!4

L!fILG j

Page 66: qq r QJCL - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · bins o cbum is fmq lo nso iofirf isdI ii 9JTioD9d iom1s 91dieoqmi i1s of 19dm9m91 fisi-If cii rnsm ernui bns cii rism 9Ds1q ifiD 3IS 9Ds1q lo

20210023002002tO0220020O200

b0bf1IWOU D6C!IG liCK wbIGI 3 2 Q 8 ô JO

bobfll?JIJoll DGCJJ6 JIJ liCK JWbIG

030031033

O.3 -

J 3 2 Q 8 a

.I

LLG \ CLUJ6

1IfIG hGL CL!WG

b0bflIU1011 DGCIIG I' 111C1{ 1WbiG

I000

f 2 Q X 8 a43t Jt QiOyiac bobnjtiou ?4o tO3 FtQtQ

0•0t

00Q

008

—.....•

•CL!WG\ CJb!t

E!f1LG