+ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld...

22
@ti L? +ith}i?| W?_@ L?_t

Transcript of +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld...

Page 1: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

���� �� ������� �� �� ��� �

�4@h B@?_i @?_ �@?�� ��h� �

+i��ti_G a@?�@h) 2ff�

Devwudfw

Lq Dxjxvw 4<<;/ Vwdwh Edqn ri Lqgld/ Lqgld*v odujhvw edqn udlvhg '715 eloolrq wkurxjk

d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw Lqgld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh

wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg lq wkh Lqgldq �qdqfldo suhvv dv ehlqj kljko| dwwudfwlyh/ dqg wkdw

wkh| zhuh r�huhg h{foxvlyho| wr Lqgldqv olylqj deurdg/ nqrzq dv Qrq0Uhvlghqw Lqgldqv1

Wklv fdvh h{dplqhv wkh iroorzlqj lvvxhv= Zdv wkh |lhog rq wkhvh erqgv vljql�fdqwo|

orzhu wkdq wkh |lhog lpsolhg e| wkhlu fuhglw udwlqj diwhu dffrxqwlqj iru frpplvvlrqv/

wd{hv dqg rwkhu srwhqwldo h{sodqdwlrqvB Li vr/ zk| duh vrph lqyhvwruv/ vxfk dv wkh

Qrq0Uhvlghqw Lqgldqv zloolqj wr sd| pruh iru wkhvh erqgv +dffhswlqj d orzhu |lhog,

wkdq iruhljq lqyhvwruvB Ilqdoo|/ vkrxog wkh lvvxhu uhvwulfw r�hulqj ri wkhvh erqgv wr

Qrq0Uhvlghqw LqgldqvB Wklv fdvh kdv lpsruwdqw lpsolfdwlrqv iru xqghuvwdqglqj wkh

uroh ri rzqhuvkls uhvwulfwlrqv rq wkh lvvxhu*v frvw ri fdslwdo1

�Dpdu Jdqgh lv iurp wkh Rzhq Judgxdwh Vfkrro ri Pdqdjhphqw/ Ydqghuelow Xqlyhuvlw| dqg Pdqmx Sxullv iurp wkh Judgxdwh Vfkrro ri Exvlqhvv/ Vwdqirug Xqlyhuvlw|1 Zh wkdqn Jhhuw Ehndhuw/ Ylnudp Mdlsxuld+Flwledqn QUL Vhuylfhv, dqg Urjhu Kxdqj iru khosixo frpphqwv1 Zh dovr ehqh�wwhg iurp dq lqirupdwlyhfodvv surmhfw rq Uhvxujhqw Lqgld Erqgv e| Grqj|x Mlq/ Pdxur Vrx}d/ Fkhhvh Ohghvpd/ Odzuhqfh Wvhdqg Frqvwdqfd Hvwhyhv +Vwdqirug Xqlyhuvlw| PED vwxghqwv,1 Zh wkdqn Vxgkdndu Jdqgh/ Qlohvk Mdlq riOh{lfrq Ilqdqfh Olplwhg/ Lqgld iru surylglqj xvhixo gdwd1 Zh dovr wkdqn Vkhux Fkrzgku| dqg Doh{ Iudqwdiru ydoxdeoh uhvhdufk dvvlvwdqfh1 Sohdvh dgguhvv doo fruuhvsrqghqfh wr Pdqmx Sxul/ Judgxdwh Vfkrro riExvlqhvv/ Vwdqirug Xqlyhuvlw|/ Vwdqirug/ FD <7638083481 Who= +983, :56067351 Id{= +983, :58094851 Hpdlo=psxulCjve1vwdqirug1hgx1 Wklv fdvh zdv suhsduhg dv d edvlv iru fodvv glvfxvvlrq udwkhu wkdq wr looxvwudwhhlwkhu h�hfwlyh ru lqh�hfwlyh kdqgolqj ri d exvlqhvv vlwxdwlrq1

Page 2: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

+it�h}i?| W?_�@ �L?_t �@ti

W| �@t ��}�t| ��c �bbH� �h� Vih4@c ��@�h4@? Lu 5|@|i �@?! Lu W?_�@ E5�W� �@t hi��i��?}

|�i Thiti?|@|�L? T@U!@}i ThiT@hi_ M) ��t t|@g uLh ��t Thitt UL?uihi?Ui ���U� t|@h|t �? @ML�|

@? �L�h� A�i Thitt UL?uihi?Ui �@t @�4i_ @| �T_@|�?} |�i �?@?U�@* Thitt @ML�| |�i t�UUittu�*

UL4T*i|�L? Lu |�i hiUi?| R+it�h}i?| W?_�@ �L?_t� �tt�ic @ uLhi�}? U�hhi?U) ML?_ Lgih�?}

Lu 5�W� Vih4@ �@t @*tL �LT�?} |L �ti |��t LTTLh|�?�|) |L hitL*�i tL4i Lu |�i UL?|hL�iht�it

t�hhL�?_�?} |�i +W� �tt�i� �t �i �@t }L�?} |�hL�}� |�i Thiti?|@|�L? T@U!@}ic ��t 4�?_

_h�u|i_ |L�@h_t |�i i�i?|t _�h�?} |�i T@t| ui� 4L?|�t�

�? a�?i �c �bbHc W?_�@<t �?@?Ui 4�?�t|ihc v@t��@?| 5�?�@c @??L�?Ui_ �? ��t �?�L? M�_}i|

@__hitt �? |�i T@h*�@4i?| |�@| 5|@|i �@?! Lu W?_�@ E5�W�c W?_�@<t *@h}it| M@?! ��** h@�ti uLh�

i�}? i U�@?}i |�hL�}� +it�h}i?| W?_�@ �L?_tc |L Mi Lgihi_ i U*�t��i*) |L |�i �L?�+it�_i?|

W?_�@?t E�+Wt��� A�i +W�t �L�*_ �@�i @ 4@|�h�|) Lu ��i )i@ht @?_ �L�*_ Mi _i?L4�?@|i_

�? |�hii 4@�Lh U�hhi?U�itc N�5� _L**@htc TL�?_t @?_ #i�|tU� �@h!t� A�i ThLUii_t uhL4 |�iti

ML?_t �L�*_ Mi �ti_ |L �?@?Ui Th��@|i�tiU|Lh �?uh@t|h�U|�hi ThL�iU|t �? W?_�@c �? *�i� Lu |�i

uLhi�}? U�hhi?U)2 *L@?t |�@| @hi ?Lh4@**) hi^��hi_ uLh t�U� ThL�iU|t� A��t �L�*_ @*tL �i*T

t�Lhi �T W?_�@<t uLhi�}? i U�@?}i hitih�it TLt�|�L? �? |�i i�i?| Lu @ t�}?��U@?| _i|ih�Lh@�

|�L? �? |�i M@*@?Ui Lu T@)4i?|t TLt�|�L? uL**L��?} |�i hiUi?| _L�?}h@_i M) h@|�?} @}i?U�it�

, ��M�| � Thiti?|t @ |�4i *�?i Lu i�i?|t ThiUi_�?} |�i +W� �tt�i�

+W�t _�gih uhL4 |h@_�|�L?@* uLhi�}? U�hhi?U) ML?_t �? @ ui� �@)t� 6�ht|c +W�t �ihi

4Dq Lqgldq Flwl}hq zkr vwd|v deurdg iru hpsor|phqw2fduu|lqj rq exvlqhvv ru yrfdwlrq rxwvlgh Lqgld

ru vwd|v deurdg xqghu flufxpvwdqfhv lqglfdwlqj dq lqwhqwlrq iru dq xqfhuwdlq gxudwlrq ri vwd| deurdg lv d

qrq0uhvlghqw1 Qrq0uhvlghqw iruhljq flwl}hqv ri Lqgldq Ruljlq duh wuhdwhg rq sdu zlwk Qrq0uhvlghqw Lqgldq

flwl}hqv1 D iruhljq flwl}hq +rwkhu wkdq d flwl}hq ri Sdnlvwdq ru Edqjodghvk, lv ghhphg wr eh ri Lqgldq ruljlq/

li/ kh2vkh/ dw dq| wlph/ khog dq Lqgldq sdvvsruw/ ru kh2vkh ru hlwkhu ri klv2khu sduhqwv ru dq| ri klv2khu

judqg sduhqwv zdv d flwl}hq ri Lqgld e| yluwxh ri wkh Frqvwlwxwlrq ri Lqgld ru Flwl}hqvkls Dfw/ 4<88 +8: ri

4<88,1 Iru pruh ghwdlov/ ylvlw kwws=22zzz1qulro1frp2uhvrxufhv2idtv2jhqhudo1kwpo15Lqgld*v grphvwlf fxuuhqf|/ wkh Lqgldq Uxshh lv qrw d iuhho| frqyhuwleoh fxuuhqf| dqg lv frqyhuwleoh lqwr

iruhljq fxuuhqf|/ vxfk dv X1V1 grooduv rqo| rq wkh wudgh dffrxqw +lpsruwv dqg h{sruwv, ru zlwk h{solflw

shuplvvlrq iurp wkh Uhvhuyh Edqn ri Lqgld +wkh htxlydohqw ri wkh Ihghudo Uhvhuyh lq wkh Xqlwhg Vwdwhv,1

2

Page 3: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

@�@�*@M*i uLh �?�it|4i?| i U*�t��i*) |L �+Wt� W? L|�ih �Lh_tc uLhi�}? �?�it|Lht ��L @hi ?L|

W?_�@? UL�*_ ?L| �?�it| �? +W�t i�i? �u |�i) �@?|i_ |L� 5iUL?_c +W�t �ihi �**�^��_ @t |�i)

@hi ?L| |h@_i_ L? @?) i U�@?}i� OL�i�ihc |h@?tuih Lu L�?iht��T Lu +W�t |L @?L|�ih �+W

�@t Tih4�||i_ |�hL�}� i?_Lhti4i?| Lu +W�t� 6�?@**)c +W�t �ihi 4@h!i|i_ L? @ Mit| igLh|t

M@t�t |�hL�}� |�i Mh@?U� ?i|�Lh!t Lu 5�W @?_ Lu |�i UL**iU|�?} M@?!t h@|�ih |�@? tL*_ |L @?

�?_ih�h�|�?} t)?_�U@|i Lu M@?!t� , ��M�| 2 Thiti?|t |�i t@*�i?| ui@|�hit Lu |�iti ML?_t�

Vih4@ _iU�_i_ |L uLU�t L? |�i Thiti?|@|�L? T@U!@}i� Oi t|@h|i_ |L hi@_ |�i �?�|�@* T@h|

UL?|@�?�?} M@U!}hL�?_ �?uLh4@|�L? L? |�i |�hii !i) T*@)iht �? |�i +W� �tt�ic |�i UL�?|h)

EW?_�@�c |�i UL4T@?) E5|@|i �@?! Lu W?_�@� @?_ |�i �L?�hit�_i?| W?_�@?t E�?�it|Lht��

�L�?|h) �@U!}hL�?_

W?_�@ �t |�i *@h}it| _i4LUh@|�U ?@|�L? �? |�i �Lh*_ @?_ |�i tiUL?_ *@h}it| UL�?|h) �? |ih4t

Lu TLT�*@|�L? E?i | L?*) |L ���?@� ��|� @TThL �4@|i*) L?i M�**�L? TiLT*i� W?_�@ }@�?i_ �|t

�?_iTi?_i?Ui uhL4 |�i �h�|�t� �? �be.� 6Lh @ *@h}i T@h| Lu |�i TLt|��?_iTi?_i?Ui Tih�L_c

W?_�@ �@t Mii? }L�ih?i_ M) |�i �L?}hitt T@h|)� �h�?U�T@* @4L?} W?_�@<t *i@_iht �ihi a@�@�@h

w@* �i�h�c ��t _@�}�|ihc W?_�h@ B@?_��c @?_ �ih tL?c +@��� B@?_��� ,UL?L4�U hiuLh4t t�?Ui

�bb� �@t *i_ |L @ t|hL?} iUL?L4�U }hL�|� Lu |�i W?_�@? iUL?L4)� `��*i |�i }hL�?_ �Lh! uLh

|�iti hiuLh4t �@t _L?i �? |�i *@|i i�}�|�it _�h�?} |�i +@��� B@?_�� }L�ih?4i?| M) |�i |�i?

�?@?Ui 4�?�t|ihc V� �� 5�?}�c 4�U� Lu |�i �4T*i4i?|@|�L? �@t _�h�?} �� V� �@ht�4�@ +@L<t

}L�ih?4i?| M) |�i |�i? �?@?Ui 4�?�t|ihc �@? �L�@? 5�?}�� A�i hit�*| Lu |�iti hiuLh4t

�@t Mii? 4L_ih@|i h@|it Lu �?�@|�L?c @? �?Uhi@ti �? |�i uLhi�}? i U�@?}i hitih�itc @ 4L_it|

M@*@?Ui Lu T@)4i?|t _i�U�|c ��}�ih �?�it|4i?| �L�t @?_ @ ��}�ih }hL�|� �? |h@_i� W?_�@<t

4L_it| U�hhi?| @UUL�?| _i�U�| @?_ *L� *i�i*t Lu t�Lh|�|ih4 uLhi�}? _iM| �@t i?@M*i_ �| |L

�i@|�ih |�i �t�@? �?@?U�@* Uh�t�t ��|� 4L_it| �?_�hiU| igiU|t�

�Lt| Lu W?_�@ �t �? |�i ��**@}it @?_ |�i �hM@? TLT�*@|�L? @UUL�?|t uLh L?*) @ uL�h|� Lu

|�i |L|@* TLT�*@|�L?� �Lhi |�@? @ |��h_ Lu |�i TLT�*@|�L? t|�** *��it Mi*L� |�i TL�ih|) *�?i

@?_ ?i@h*) �@*u Lu |�i TLT�*@|�L? �t �**�|ih@|i� OL�i�ihc W?_�@ �@t @ M�h}iL?�?} 4�__*i U*@tt

��Lti TLT�*@|�L? i^�@*t |�@| Lu |�i ,�hLTi@? UL44�?�|) @?_ �t |�i |@h}i| 4@h!i| Lu |�i

Page 4: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

4@?�u@U|�hiht Lu 4@?) �?|ih?@|�L?@* UL?t�4ih Mh@?_t� `��*i |�i u�?_@4i?|@*t Lu W?_�@<t

iUL?L4) �@�i Mii? 4L��?} �? |�i h�}�| _�hiU|�L?c |�i iUL?L4) �t t|�** �@4Tihi_ M) �?@_�

i^�@|i �?uh@t|h�U|�hic ��}� �?|ihit| h@|itc @?_ @ *@h}i �tU@* _i�U�|� , ��M�| � t�44@h�3it

W?_�@<t !i) �tU@* @?_ iUL?L4�U �?_�U@|Lht�

�L4T@?) �@U!}hL�?_

A�i Lh�}�?t Lu |�i 5|@|i �@?! Lu W?_�@ _@|it |L �HfS ��i? |�i �@?! Lu �@*U�||@ E*@|ih

U@**i_ |�i �@?! Lu �i?}@*� �@t it|@M*�t�i_� W? �b2�c |�i �@?! Lu �i?}@* @?_ |�L L|�ih

M@?!t E�@?! Lu �@_h@t @?_ �@?! Lu �L4M@)� �ihi @4@*}@4@|i_ |L uLh4 |�i W4Tih�@* �@?!

Lu W?_�@� W? �bDDc |�i UL?|hL**�?} �?|ihit|t Lu |�i W4Tih�@* �@?! Lu W?_�@ �ihi @U^��hi_ M)

|�i +itih�i �@?! Lu W?_�@ E|�i i^���@*i?| Lu |�i 6i_ih@* +itih�i �@?! �? |�i N?�|i_ 5|@|it�c

@?_ |�i 5|@|i �@?! Lu W?_�@ �@t Uhi@|i_ M) @? @U| Lu |�i �@h*�@4i?| |L t�UUii_ |�i W4Tih�@*

�@?! Lu W?_�@� A�i +itih�i �@?! Lu W?_�@c ���U� �@t t�Tih��tLh) UL?|hL* L�ih |�i M@?!�?}

t)t|i4 �? W?_�@c �t @*tL |�i t�?}*i *@h}it| t�@hi�L*_ih Lu 5�W E��|� Db�.�I t�@hi �L*_�?}��

5�W �t |�i *@h}it| M@?! �? W?_�@ �? |ih4t Lu ThL�|tc @tti|tc _iTLt�|tc Mh@?U�it @?_ i4�

T*L)iit� �t Lu �@hU� ��c �bbHc 5�W TLttitti_ |L|@* @tti|t �Lh|� N5m eDceH. 4�**�L? @?_

|L|@* _iTLt�|t �Lh|� N5m ��c�HH 4�**�L?� `�|� @ ?i|�Lh! Lu HcHbD Mh@?U�it �? W?_�@ @?_ D2

uLhi�}? L�Uit �? �e UL�?|h�itc 5�W UL44@?_t @ML�| L?i��u|� Lu |�i |L|@* _iTLt�|t @?_ *L@?t

�? |�i UL�?|h)� 5�W<t t�@hit @?_ ML?_t @hi *�t|i_ uLh |h@_�?} L? @** |�i 4@�Lh W?_�@? t|LU!

i U�@?}it @?_ 5�W �@t L?i Lu |�i *@h}it| 4@h!i| U@T�|@*�3@|�L?t Lu @** UL4T@?�it |h@_i_ L?

t�U� i U�@?}it� 5ii , ��M�| e uLh t�44@h) �?@?U�@* _@|@ Lu 5�W�

5�W T*@)t @ !i) hL*i �? W?_�@<t iUL?L4) |�hL�}� �|t ThL_�U| ti| |�@| UL�iht UL?t�4ih

*i?_�?}c �Lh!�?} U@T�|@* �?@?U�?}c �?uh@t|h�U|�hi *i?_�?}c 4ihU�@?| M@?!�?}c }L�ih?4i?|

tiU�h�|�it _i@*�?}c @?_ Th�Lh�|) *i?_�?} Ei�}�c @}h�U�*|�hi @?_ t4@** M�t�?itt tiU|Lht Lu |�i

iUL?L4)�� W? @__�|�L?c _�i |L 5�W<t i |i?t��i Mh@?U� ?i|�Lh!c @*4Lt| i�ih) ��**@}ih �? W?_�@

�@t @? @UUL�?| ��|� 5�W� W? L|�ih �Lh_tc @TThL �4@|i*) |�hii�uL�h|�t Lu W?_�@<t TLT�*@|�L?

���U� *��it �? |�i ��**@}it hi*�it i |i?t��i*) L? 5|@|i �@?! Lu W?_�@ uLh |�i�h M@?!�?} tih��Uit�

5�W �t @*tL @? @U|��i T*@)ih �? |�i �+W 4@h!i| |�hL�}� �|t t�Lh| |L 4i_��4 |ih4 uLhi�}?

e

Page 5: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

U�hhi?U) _iTLt�|t E���U� h@?}i uhL4 |�hii 4L?|�t |L |�hii )i@ht� @?_ @UUL�?|tc _i?L4��

?@|i_ i�|�ih �? uLhi�}? U�hhi?U) Lh �? W?_�@? +�Tiit� wL?} UL?t�_ihi_ |�i �@}t��T Lu W?_�@?

M@?!�?}c 5�W �t @*tL |�i Th���*i}i_ �?@?U�@* �?|ih4i_�@h) Lu |�i W?_�@? }L�ih?4i?| �? h@�t�?}

tL�ihi�}? _iM|�

�L?�+it�_i?| W?_�@?t

A�ihi @hi it|�4@|i_ |L Mi @TThL �4@|i*) b�S 4�**�L? �+Wt �? |�i �Lh*_� �@?) Lu |�i

�+Wt �i?| @MhL@_ uLh ��}�ih t|�_�it @?_ _iU�_i_ |L UL?|�?�i |�i�h U@hiih @MhL@_c i�}�c |�Lti

��L �i?| |L |�i N?�|i_ 5|@|it� 5i�ih@* L|�ih �+Wt �i?| @MhL@_ L? uLhi�}? �Lh! @tt�}?4i?|t

@?_ _iU�_i_ |L *��i @MhL@_c i�}�c |�i 6@h i@t|c ,�hLTi @?_ |�i N?�|i_ 5|@|it� 5i�ih@* L|�ihtc

uLh i @4T*ic |�Lti |�@| �i?| |L |�i ��__*i ,@t|c �@�i }L?i uLh @ tTiU��U |�4i Tih�L_ |L t@�i

@ TLh|�L? Lu |�i�h i@h?�?}t @?_ hi|�h? |L W?_�@� WhhitTiU|��i Lu |�i �?_ih*)�?} 4L|��@|�L?

uLh }L�?} @MhL@_c �+Wt �@�i Uih|@�? _�t|�?}��t��?} U�@h@U|ih�t|�Ut� 6�ht|c 4@?) Lu |�i �+Wt

ThL��_i �?@?U�@* @tt�t|@?Ui |L |�i�h T@hi?|tc t�M*�?}t @?_ hi*@|��it *���?} �? W?_�@� 5iUL?_c

�+Wt �?|i?_ |L hi|�h? |L W?_�@ �? |�i u�|�hic i�}�c �u |�ihi �t @ Uh�t�t �? |�i uLhi�}? UL�?|h)c t�U�

@t |�i �?�@t�L? Lu k��@�| M) Wh@^ �? i@h*) �bbftc Lh @u|ih |�i�h U��*_hi? }L |L UL**i}ic Lh @u|ih

hi|�hi4i?|� 6�?@**)c _h��i? M) |�i�h i Tih�i?Uit @MhL@_c �+Wt _it�hi |L 4@!i u�?_@4i?|@*

U�@?}it �? W?_�@<t iUL?L4)� AL 4ii| |�i @ML�i 4i?|�L?i_ LM�iU|��itc �+Wt �@�i Mii? !?L�?

|L ti?_ 4L?i) |L |�i�h T@hi?|tc t�M*�?}t @?_ hi*@|��it *���?} �? W?_�@c M�) ThLTih|) �? W?_�@c

L�? M�t�?ittit �? W?_�@c L�? t|LU!t @?_ ML?_t �? *LU@* UL4T@?�it �? W?_�@c @?_ UL?|h�M�|i

t�}?��U@?| @4L�?|t |L U�@h�|@M*i Lh}@?�3@|�L?t �? W?_�@�

�+Wt T*@) @ Uh�|�U@* hL*i �? W?_�@<t iUL?L4) �? ti�ih@* �@)t� 6�ht|c �? ThL��_�?} |�i

UL�?|h) ��|� �@*�@M*i uLhi�}? i U�@?}i |�hL�}� hiU�hh�?} @?_ t|@M*i uLhi�}? U�hhi?U) U@t�

�?�L�t EW?_�@<t _L4it|�U U�hhi?U)c |�i W?_�@? +�Tii �t ?L| @ uhii*) UL?�ih|�M*i U�hhi?U) � tii

uLL|?L|i � L? T@}i 2 uLh 4Lhi _i|@�*t�� A�i BL�ih?4i?| Lu W?_�@c |L @||h@U| �@*�@M*i uLhi�}?

i U�@?}i �?�L�t uhL4 �+Wt |L �i*T 4@�?|@�? �|t M@*@?Ui Lu T@)4i?|t �@t �?t|�|�|i_ ti�ih@*

t�Lh| |L 4i_��4�|ih4 uLhi�}? U�hhi?U) _iTLt�|t E���U� h@?}i uhL4 |�hii 4L?|�t |L |�hii

)i@ht� @?_ @UUL�?|tc @_4�?�t|ihi_ M) |�i �?_���_�@* M@?!tc �?U*�_�?} 5|@|i �@?! Lu W?_�@c

D

Page 6: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

_i?L4�?@|i_ i�|�ih �? uLhi�}? U�hhi?U) Lh �? W?_�@? +�Tiit� +�Tii _i?L4�?@|i_ _iTLt�|t

@?_ @UUL�?|t U@? Mi �i*_ M) �+Wt L? @ hiT@|h�@M*i M@t�t EUL?�ih|�M*i �?|L uLhi�}? U�hhi?U) L?

|�i _@|i Lu hi_i4T|�L? Lh ��|�_h@�@*� Lh L? @ ?L?�hiT@|h�@M*i M@t�t E?L| UL?�ih|�M*i �?|L uLh�

i�}? U�hhi?U)�� , ��M�| D Thiti?|t |�i L�|t|@?_�?} M@*@?Uit �?_ih �@h�L�t �+W _iTLt�|t @?_

@UUL�?|t @t Lu �@hU� ��c �bbH� 5iUL?_c M) ThL��_�?} i4T*L)4i?| |�hL�}� L�?�?} M�t�?ittit

�? W?_�@� 6Lh i @4T*ic ti�ih@* W?_�@? i?|hiThi?i�ht uhL4 t�*�UL? �@**i) �@�i ti| �T tLu|�@hi

i?|ihTh�tit �? U�|�itc t�U� @t �@?}@*Lhi @?_ O)_ih@M@_� 6�?@**)c |�hL�}� u@4�*)c hi*@|��it

@?_ @�*�@|�L?t ��|� TL*�|�U@* Lh}@?�3@|�L?t UL?|hL* @ ?L?�|h���@* ThLTLh|�L? Lu i*iU|Lh@* �L|it�

�hitt �L?uihi?Ui

W? ��t 4�?_c Vih4@ ui*| |�@| |�i +W� �tt�i �@t @ M�} t�UUitt t�?Ui |�i +W�t �ihi Lgihi_

@| )�i*_t t�}?��U@?|*) *L�ih |�@? |�@| �4T*�i_ M) |�i�h Uhi_�| h@|�?} Etii , ��M�|t S�. uLh

)�i*_t L? ?i� @?_ ti@tL?i_ tiU�h�|�it�� W? @__�|�L?c @}@�?t| |�i |@h}i|i_ 2 M�**�L? _L**@htc

|�i +W� �tt�it }hLtti_ 4Lhi |�@? e M�**�L? _L**@ht Etii , ��M�| H�� A��t �@t _itT�|i W?_�@<t

?L?��?�it|4i?| }h@_i Uhi_�| h@|�?} @?_ |�i iUL?L4�U t@?U|�L?t u@U�?} |�i UL�?|h)�

OL�i�ihc *LL!�?} @| , ��M�|t S�.c Vih4@ �L?_ihi_ ���U� Mi?U�4@h! _iM| �tt�iEt� Mi

�ti_ @t @ UL4T@h@M*i |L @? +W�q 6Lh i @4T*ic t�L�*_ �| Mi |�i N�5� Ahi@t�h) tiU�h�|)

Lh @ tL�ihi�}? uLhi�}? U�hhi?U) ML?_ Lh @ ULhTLh@|i uLhi�}? U�hhi?U) ML?_ Lu UL4T@h@M*i

4@|�h�|)q #iTi?_�?} L? ���U� UL4T@h@M*i tiU�h�|) �i �tic �i 4�}�| �?_ @ TLt�|��i Lh @

?i}@|��i _�gihi?Ui Mi|�ii? +W� )�i*_t @?_ )�i*_t L? UL4T@h@M*i Mi?U�4@h!t� W| �L�*_ Mi

_��U�*| |L UL?��?Ui |�i _��ih}i?| u@U|�L?t �? |�i �?@?U�@* Thittc L?i t@)�?} |�@| |�i )�i*_

L? +W�t �@t |LL ��}� @?_ |�i L|�ih t@)�?} |�@| |�i )�i*_ �@t |LL *L��

� hi*@|i_ �tt�i �t |�@| |�i UL**iU|�?} M@?!t 4@) �@�i T@tti_ L? @ T@h| Lu |�i�h UL44�tt�L?

|L |�i �+Wt @t @? �?�it|4i?| �?Ui?|��i� Wu L?i �ihi |L @UUL�?| uLh |�iti UL4�tt�L? !�U!M@U!t

Etii , ��M�| b�c �L�*_ |�i igiU|��i )�i*_ L? +W�t Mi UL?t�t|i?| ��|� |�i�h Uhi_�| h@|�?}q W?

@ t�4�*@h tT�h�|c }��i? |�@| +W�t �ihi uhii uhL4 W?_�@? �?UL4ic �i@*|� @?_ }�u| |@ itc �u L?i

�ihi |L @UUL�?| uLh |�iti |@ igiU|tc �L�*_ |�i igiU|��i )�i*_ L? |�i +W�t Mi UL?t�t|i?|

��|� |�i�h Uhi_�| h@|�?}q Vih4@ ui*| |�@| @ }LL_ �?_iht|@?_�?} Lu |�iti �tt�it �@t Uh�U�@* �u

S

Page 7: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

�i �ihi |L U*@�4 �? |�i Thitt UL?uihi?Ui |�@| |�ihi �ihi t�Mt|@?|�@* t@��?}t _�i |L |�i *L�ih

)�i*_t L? +W�tc ��i? �?_ii_ |�i igiU|��i )�i*_t �ihi 4�U� ��}�ih�

�t �i t|@h|i_ |��?!�?} _iiTihc Vih4@ ui*| |�@| |�i) UL�*_ Mi ti�ih@* U�@**i?}�?} ^�it|�L?t

|�@| 4�}�| UL4i �T �? |�i Thitt hLL4� OL� �@t �i }L�?} |L UL?��?Ui |�i @�_�i?Ui ��)

�+Wt �ihi ��**�?} |L T@) ��}�ih |�@? uLhi�}? �?�it|Lht uLh |�i +W�tq Vih4@ �@t t!iT|�U@*

@ML�| @? i T*@?@|�L? M@ti_ L? T@|h�L|�t4 @?_ ui*| |�@| |�ihi �@_ |L Mi @ tL�?_ iUL?L4�U

hi@tL? uLh |�i ��}�ih �@*�@|�L?t M) �+Wt�

�? i^�@**) �4TLh|@?| �tt�i |�@| �t ML�?_ |L UL4i �T itTiU�@**) uhL4 |�i t!iT|�Ut �? |�i

@�_�i?Ui �@t i�i? �u �+Wt �@_ ��}� �@*�@|�L?tc ��i|�ih |�ihi �t @ ?ii_ |L hit|h�U| |�i +W�t

uLh �?�it|4i?| i U*�t��i*) |L |�i �+Wtq L̀�*_?<| |�i �?�it|Lht ��**�?} |L T@) *L�ih Th�Uit

EM) @UUiT|�?} ��}�ih )�i*_t� ti*u�ti*iU| |�i4ti*�it L�|q 5L4i L|�iht 4@) i�i? @h}�i |�@|

M) hit|h�U|�?} |�i L�?iht��T |L @ t�Mti| Lu �?�it|Lhtc L?i 4@) Mi h@�t�?} |�i UL4T@?)<t ULt|

Lu U@T�|@*� W? u@U|c |�ihi �@t Mii? @ t�Mt|@?|�@* @U@_i4�U *�|ih@|�hi |�@| t�L�t |�@| i^��|)

L�?iht��T hit|h�U|�L?t @hi ULt|*) @?_ |�@| t�@hit ��|� hit|h�U|�L?t |h@_i @| @ t�Mt|@?|�@**)

*L�ih Th�Ui |�@? UL4T@h@M*i t�@hit ��|�L�| hit|h�U|�L?t�� �? �4T*�U@|�L? Lu |��t *�|ih@|�hi

�t |�@| L�?iht��T hit|h�U|�L?t �@�i @ ?i}@|��i igiU| Lu hi_�U�?} |�i Th�Ui Lu @ tiU�h�|) @?_

h@�t�?} |�i �h4<t ULt| Lu U@T�|@*� �?Ui @}@�?c Vih4@ ui*| |�i ?ii_ uLh @? iUL?L4�U@**) tL�?_

@h}�4i?| uLh ��) 5�W U�Lti |L hit|h�U| +W�t i U*�t��i*) |L �+Wtc @?_ _L�?} tLc ��i|�ih �|

h@�ti_ |�i UL4T@?)<t ULt| Lu U@T�|@* Lh *L�ihi_ �|q

`��*i |�iti _��U�*| �tt�it 4@) ?i�ih Mi h@�ti_ �? |�i "�it|�L?t @?_ �?t�iht E":��

titt�L?c Vih4@ ?i�ih|�i*itt ui*| �?i@t)� OL�i�ihc �i ui*| �i UL�*_ _�i** �TL? L|�ih hi@tL?t

uLh ��) �i |��?!t |�i +W� �tt�i �@t @ M�} t�UUitt� B��i? |�@| |�i +W�t �ihi Lgihi_ L? @

Mit| igLh| M@t�t h@|�ih |�@? �?_ih�h�||i? M) @ t)?_�U@|i Lu �?_ih�h�|ihtc 5�W t@�i_ L? |�i

�L@|@|�L? ULt|t� 6Lh �?t|@?Uic 5�W _�_ ?L| �?U�h ULt|*) �?_ih�h�|ih tThi@_tc ���U� h@?}i

6Iru h{dpsoh/ Grprzlw}/ Johq dqg Pdgkdydq/ lq d sdshu wlwohg _Pdunhw vhjphqwdwlrq dqg vwrfn sulfhv=

hylghqfh iurp dq hphujlqj pdunhw/% wkdw dsshduhg lq wkh 4<<: Mrxuqdo ri Ilqdqfh +Yro1 85/ 438<043;8,

grfxphqw hfrqrplfdoo| vljql�fdqw vwrfn sulfh suhpld iru xquhvwulfwhg vkduhv +l1h1/ wkrvh rshq iru lqyhvwphqw

wr doo lqyhvwruv, uhodwlyh wr uhvwulfwhg vkduhv +l1h1/ wkrvh rshq iru lqyhvwphqw rqo| wr Ph{lfdq lqyhvwruv, ri

wkh vdph frpsdq|1

.

Page 8: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

uhL4 ��2DI�2�DI uLh UL4T@h@M*i �tt�it M�| �?t|i@_ T@�_ ThL}hitt��i UL44�tt�L?t U@TTi_ @|

��DI |L UL**iU|�?} M@?!t @t @? �?Ui?|��i Etii i ��M�| b uLh _i|@�*t�� W? @__�|�L?c Vih4@ ui*|

|�@| 5�W t@�i_ |�4i @?_ igLh| �? 4@h!i|�?} |�i +W�t |L �+Wt M) �t�?} |�i �?|ih?i|�

`�|� |�iti |�L�}�|t �? 4�?_c Vih4@ i?|ihi_ |�i Thitt hLL4� `��*i |�ihi UL�*_ Mi tL4i

_��U�*| ^�it|�L?t |L @?t�ihc �i ?i�ih|�i*itt ui*| LT|�4�t|�U |�@| �i �L�*_ Mi @M*i |L @?t�ih

|�i4 M@ti_ L? ��t �?_iht|@?_�?} Lu U@T�|@* 4@h!i|t @?_ ?�4ihL�t )i@ht Lu i Tih�i?Ui�

H

Page 9: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

5�}}it|i_ "�it|�L?t

�� `�@| �t |�i @TThLTh�@|i Mi?U�4@h! |L �ti �? it|�4@|�?} |�i )�i*_ L? |�i +it�h}i?|

W?_�@ �L?_t @t �4T*�i_ M) |�i�h Uhi_�| h@|�?}q Wt |�i Lgihi_ )�i*_ L? |�i +it�h}i?|

W?_�@ �L?_t t�}?��U@?|*) *L�ih |�@? |�i it|�4@|i_ )�i*_q #Lit |�i _�gihi?Ui �? )�i*_t

E�u @?)� _�t@TTi@h L?Ui )L� @UUL�?| uLh |�i igiU| Lu UL44�tt�L?tc |@ it @?_ @?) L|�ih

TL|i?|�@* i T*@?@|�L?tq , T*@�?�

2� W| @TTi@ht |�@| tL4i �?�it|Lhtc t�U� @t |�i �L?�+it�_i?| W?_�@?t @hi ��**�?} |L T@)

4Lhi uLh |�i +it�h}i?| W?_�@ �L?_t |�@? uLhi�}? �?�it|Lht� �@? |��t Mi tL*i*) @|�

|h�M�|i_ |L |�i�h T@|h�L|�t4 |L W?_�@ Lh �t |�ihi @ tL�?_ iUL?L4�U hi@tL? uLh |�i�h

��**�?}?itt |L T@) 4Lhiq , T*@�?�

�� ,�i? �u tL4i �?�it|Lht @hi ��**�?} |L T@) 4Lhi uLh @ tiU�h�|)c t�L�*_ |�i �tt�ih hit|h�U|

|�i Lgih�?} Lu tiU�h�|�it |L t�U� @ U*�i?|i*iq `�@| @hi |�i |h@_i�Lgt �? _L�?} tLq

#�tU�tt�

e� `�@| �t |�i |L|@* t@��?}t E�? 4�**�L?t Lu _L**@ht� |L 5|@|i �@?! Lu W?_�@ uhL4 Lgih�?}

|�i +it�h}i?| W?_�@ �L?_t i U*�t��i*) |L �L?�+it�_i?| W?_�@?t hi*@|��i |L Lgih�?} t�U�

tiU�h�|�it |L uLhi�}? �?�it|Lhtq

D� L̀�*_ )L� hiUL44i?_ |�@| �h4t uhL4 L|�ih i4ih}�?} 4@h!i|t @*tL uL**L� @ t�4�*@h

t|h@|i}) Lu Lgih�?} ?i� tiU�h�|�it |L ti*iU| U*�i?|i*itq , T*@�?�

b

Page 10: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

H{klelw 4

Wlpholqh ri hyhqwv

Wklv h{klelw suhvhqwv d wlpholqh ri hyhqwv ohdglqj wr wkh Uhvxujhqw Lqgld Erqgv lvvxh lq Dxjxvw 4<<;1

Gdwh+v, Hyhqw

Mdq </ 4<<; Prrg|*v sodfhv Lqgld*v lqyhvwphqw0judgh +Edd6, vryhuhljq udwlqj rq uhylhz iru d

srvvleoh grzqjudgh flwlqj srolwlfdo suhvvxuh iru pruh surwhfwlrq ri orfdo exvlqhvvhv

wkuhdwhqv wr vorz uhirupv vwduwhg lq 4<<41

Pd| 46047/ 4<<; X1V1 lpsrvhv hfrqrplf vdqfwlrqv djdlqvw Lqgld lq uhvsrqvh wr Lqgld*v frqgxfwlqj

qxfohdu whvwv gxulqj Pd| 44046/ 4<<;1 Vwdqgdug ) Srruv +V)S, dqg Prrg|*v sodfh

Lqgld*v vryhuhljq fuhglw udwlqj xqghu uhylhz iru d srvvleoh grzqjudgh1

Pd| 5;063/ 4<<; Suhvv uhsruwv rq srwhqwldo hvfdodwlrq ri whqvlrqv dv Sdnlvwdq/ Lqgld*v qhljkerulqj

frxqwu|/ frqgxfwv vlplodu qxfohdu whvwv1

Mxqh 4/ 4<<; Lqgld*v Ilqdqfh plqlvwhu/ Pu1 \dvkzdqw Vlqkd lqglfdwhv lq klv Xqlrq exgjhw wkdw

Vwdwh Edqn ri Lqgld +VEL,/ Lqgld*v odujhvw edqn zloo pdunhw _Uhvxujhqw Lqgld Erqgv%

+ULEv, wdujhwhg wrzdugv lqyhvwphqw e| Qrq0Uhvlghqw Lqgldqv +QULv, zruog0zlgh1

Mxqh 4</ 4<<; Prrg|*v orzhuhg Lqgld*v vryhuhljq fuhglw udwlqj e| wzr qrwfkhv iurp Edd6 wr Ed5

rq frqfhuq ryhu wkh idloxuh lq d _iudfwlrxv% srolwlfdo hqylurqphqw wr wdfnoh hfrqrplf

uhirupv dqg wkh lpsdfw ri X1V1 vdqfwlrqv diwhu uhfhqw qxfohdu whvwv1

Mxo| ;/ 4<<; VEL*v suhvv uhohdvh rq wkh lqglfdwlyh lqwhuhvw udwh/ plqlpxp lqyhvwphqw dprxqwv

dqg wkh fxuuhqf| ri ghqrplqdwlrq ri wkh ULEv1

Mxo| 57/ 4<<; Urdg0vkrzv frpphqfhg lq ydulrxv sduwv ri wkh zruog1

Dxjxvw 8/ 4<<; ULE lvvxh rshqv iru vxevfulswlrq1

Dxjxvw 57/ 4<<; ULE lvvxh forvhg iru vxevfulswlrq1

�f

Page 11: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

H{klelw 5

Vdolhqw ihdwxuhv ri ULEv

Wklv h{klelw suhvhqwv wkh vdolhqw ihdwxuhv ri Uhvxujhqw Lqgld Erqgv +ULEv,1

Lvvxh rshqhg rq Dxjxvw 8/ 4<<;

Whqru Ilyh |hduv iurp wkh gdwh ri lvvxh

Frxsrq udwh :1:8( +',/ ;133( +m,/ 9158( +GP, rq dq dqqxdol}hg edvlv1 Lqyhvwruv fdq uhfhlyh

lqwhuhvw hlwkhu kdoi0|hduo| ru rq d fxpxodwlyh edvlv dw pdwxulw|1

Plqlpxp lqyhvwphqw ' 5/333/ m4/333/ GP 6/333 dqg lq pxowlsohv ri 4/333 +' ru GP, dqg 833 +m,1

Uhsdwuldelolw| Wkh sulqflsdo dprxqw dv zhoo dv wkh lqwhuhvw hduqhg rq wkh ULEv lv ixoo| uhsdwuldeoh

lq wkh fxuuhqf| ri ghqrplqdwlrq iru doo Qrq0uhvlghqw kroghuv1 Suhpdwxuh hqfdvkphqw

lv shuplwwhg zlwkrxw dq| shqdow| diwhu vl{ prqwkv iurp wkh gdwh ri lvvxh rq d

qrq0uhsdwuldeoh edvlv lq Lqgldq Uxshhv1

Ordqv djdlqvw ULEv Wkh ULEv fdq eh suhvhqwhg dv froodwhudo iru edqn ordqv xswr <3( ri wkh lqyhvwhg

dprxqw/ hlwkhu lq Lqgldq Uxshhv ru lq iruhljq fxuuhqf|1 Wkh lqwhuhvw udwh rq vxfk

ordqv lv dw wkh glvfuhwlrq ri wkh lqglylgxdo edqnv1 Krzhyhu/ ordqv lq iruhljq

fxuuhqf| uhtxluh sulru dssurydo ri wkh Uhvhuyh Edqn ri Lqgld1

Kroglqj2Wudqvihudelolw| Wkh ULEv fdq eh khog mrlqwo| e| Qrq0Uhvlghqw Lqgldqv +QULv, zlwk uhvlghqw

Lqgldqv rq d _Iruphu ru Vxuylyru Edvlv1% Wkh ULEv duh iuhho| wudqvihudeoh wkurxjk

_hqgruvhphqw dqg gholyhu|% ehwzhhq QULv dqg2ru Ryhuvhdv Frusrudwh Erglhv

+RFEv, ^rzqhg gluhfwo| ru lqgluhfwo| wr wkh h{whqw ri dw ohdvw 93( e| QULv`1

Wd{ ehqh�wv Wkh lqwhuhvw hduqhg rq ULEv lv qrw vxemhfw wr dq| zlwkkroglqj wd{ ru lqfrph0wd{

lq Lqgld1 Wkh ULEv duh iuhh iurp zhdowk0wd{ oldelolw| lq Lqgld dqg zrxog qrw

dwwudfw dq| jliw0wd{ lq Lqgld hlwkhu lq wkh kdqgv ri wkh grqruv ru wkh grqhhv1

Doo ri wkhvh wd{ ehqh�wv zloo frqwlqxh wr dsso| lq wkh kdqgv ri wkh wudqvihuhhv

dw ohdvw lq wkh fdvh ri wkh �uvw wudqvihu1

Lvvxh forvhg rq Dxjxvw 57/ 4<<;1

Vrxufh= Grz Mrqhv Qhzvzluhv1

��

Page 12: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

H{klelw 6

Lqgld*v nh| hfrqrplf dqg �vfdo lqglfdwruv

Sdqho D ri wklv h{klelw suhvhqwv Lqgld*v nh| hfrqrplf lqglfdwruv1 Doo �jxuhv lq sdqho D duh lq eloolrqv ri

XV'/ h{fhsw zkhuh lqglfdwhg1 Sdqho E ri wklv h{klelw suhvhqwv Lqgld*v nh| �vfdo lqglfdwruv1 Doo �jxuhv duh lq

eloolrqv ri Uxshhv/ h{fhsw zkhuh lqglfdwhg1

Sdqho D= Nh| Hfrqrplf Lqglfdwruv

Hfrqrplf Lqglfdwru 4<<7 4<<8 4<<9 4<<: 4<<;H 4<<<H

Uhdo JGS Jurzwk +(, 919( :14( :18( 813( 713( 718(

Fkdqjh lq Frqvxphu Sulfhv +(, <18( 4315( <13( :15( ;18( ;18(

Exgjhw Edodqfh2JGS +(, 0913( 0817( 0815( 0914( 0914( 0819(

Wudgh Edodqfh +XV' Eloolrq, 0'71< 0'91: 0'<18 0'4313 0'4418 0'4618

Fxuuhqw Dffrxqw Edodqfh +XV' Eloolrq, 0'61; 0'819 0'816 0'813 0':13 0'4313

Fxuuhqw Dffrxqw Edodqfh2JGS +(, 0415( 0419( 0418( 0416( 041;( 0518(

Lqwhuqdwlrqdo Uhvhuyhv +XV' Eloolrq, '471: '4:1< '5315 '571: '5614 '5513

Lpsruw Fryhu +9 prqwkv, 91; 91; 919 :17 91: 81<

Iruhljq Ghew +XV' Eloolrq, '<716 '<717 ';<1; '<813 '43313 '43;13

Ghew Vhuylfh2Wrwdo H{sruwv +(, 6417( 661;( 5<19( 5:15( 5;1<( 5<15(

Dyhudjh Uxshh2XV' udwh 64199 65176 68176 69164 75133 79133

Dyhudjh Uxshh2mudwh 83146 8414< 88167 8<17: 991<3 :31;3

Sdqho E= Nh| Ilvfdo Lqglfdwruv

Ilvfdo Lqglfdwru 4<<6 4<<7 4<<8 4<<9 4<<: 4<<;H

JGS +Uv1 Eloolrq, ;/3<;13 </86:13 44/4<313 45/::313 47/75;13 49/55<17

Wrwdo Uhyhqxh +Uv1 Eloolrq, ;4913 4/36313 4/4;313 4/67613 4/7;<13 4/:9<13

Uhyhqxh Jurzwk +(, 5915( 4719( 461;( 431<( 4;1;(

Wrwdo H{shqglwxuh +Uv1 Eloolrq, 4/74<13 4/93:13 4/:;513 5/34313 5/68513 5/9:<13

H{shqglwxuh Jurzwk +(, 4615( 431<( 451;( 4:13( 461<(

Jryw1 Ilvfdo Edodqfh +Uv1 Eloolrq, 093613 08::13 093513 099:13 0;9613 0<4313

Gh�flw Jurzwk +(, 0716( 716( 431;( 5<17( 817(

Uhyhqxh2JGS +(, 4314( 431;( 4318( 4318( 4316( 431<(

H{shqglwxuh2JGS +(, 4:18( 491<( 481<( 481:( 4916( 4918(

Edodqfh2JGS +(, 0:17( 0914( 0817( 0815( 0913( 0819(

Vrxufh= Edufod|v Frxqwu| Uhsruw +Lqgld,/ Mxo| 4<<;1

�2

Page 13: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

H{klelw 7

Vxppdu| �qdqfldo gdwd ri VEL

Wklv h{klelw suhvhqwv vxppdu| �qdqfldo gdwd ri Vwdwh Edqn ri Lqgld1 Xqohvv rwkhuzlvh lqglfdwhg/ doo �jxuhv

duh lq ploolrqv ri htxlydohqw XV'1

72<:062<; 72<9062<: 72<8062<9

Uhyhqxh +XV' Ploolrq, '7/9<716 '7/;:41< '7/8:<1<

Rshudwlqj Lqfrph +XV' Ploolrq, '76318 '67718 '54917

Rshudwlqj Pdujlq +(, <15( :14( 71:(

Wrwdo Qhw Lqfrph +XV' Ploolrq, '7:416 '6:913 '5761;

Qhw Sur�w Pdujlq +(, 4313( :1:( 816(

Wrwdo Dvvhwv +XV' Ploolrq, '78/7<;16 '76/94314 '75/68714

Wrwdo Oldelolwlhv +XV' Ploolrq, '76/39815 '74/6;91; '73/:8518

Wrwdo Htxlw| +XV' Ploolrq, '5/76614 '5/55616 '4/93419

Vrxufh= Krryhuv Rqolqh1

��

Page 14: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

H{klelw 8

Rxwvwdqglqj edodqfhv xqghu ydulrxv Qrq0Uhvlghqw Lqgldq Ghsrvlw Vfkhphv gxulqj 4<<70<;

Wklv h{klelw suhvhqwv wkh rxwvwdqglqj edodqfhv lq ploolrqv ri X1V1 grooduv dv dw wkh hqg ri Pdufk xqghu ydulrxv

Qrq0Uhvlghqw Lqgldq ghsrvlw vfkhphv gxulqj 4<<70<;/ qdpho|/ Iruhljq Fxuuhqf| Qrq0Uhvlghqw +IFQU, gh0

srvlwv/ Qrq0Uhvlghqw H{whuqdo +QUH, Uxshh Dffrxqwv/ dqg Qrq0Uhvlghqw Qrq0Uhsdwuldeoh +QUQU, Uxshh

Ghsrvlwv1 Wkh IFQU ghsrvlwv duh khog lq iruhljq fxuuhqf| dqg duh dovr uhsdlg lq iruhljq fxuuhqf|1 Wkh QUH

dffrxqwv duh khog lq Lqgldq uxshhv/ frqyhuwhg dw wkh fxuuhqw vsrw h{fkdqjh udwh dqg duh ixoo| uhsdwuldeoh dw

wkh ixwxuh vsrw h{fkdqjh udwh +dw wkh wlph ri zlwkgudzdo,1 Wkh QUQU dffrxqwv duh khog lq Lqgldq uxshhv/

frqyhuwhg dw wkh fxuuhqw vsrw h{fkdqjh udwh dqg duh qrw uhsdwuldeoh lq iruhljq fxuuhqf|/ l1h1/ uhsd|phqw lv

rqo| lq Lqgldq uxshhv1

Fdwhjru| 72<6062<7 72<7062<8 72<8062<9 72<9062<: 72<:062<;

Iruhljq Fxuuhqf|

Qrq0Uhvlghqw +IFQU, Ghsrvlwv 4373; 43447 <<:8 <;35 ;79;

Qrq0Uhvlghqw H{whuqdo

+QUH, Uxshh Dffrxqwv 6856 7889 6<49 7<;6 896:

Qrq0Uhvlghqw Qrq0Uhsdwuldeoh

+QUQU, Uxshh Ghsrvlwv 4:87 57;9 6875 8937 9595

Wrwdo dprxqw 489;8 4:489 4:766 536;< 5369:

Vrxufh= Uhvhuyh Edqn ri Lqgld +UEL, Exoohwlq/ Wudgh dqg Edodqfh ri sd|phqw/ 4<<;1

�e

Page 15: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

H{klelw 9

\lhogv ri qhz erqg lvvxhv

Wklv h{klelw suhvhqwv wkh |lhogv/ phdvxuhg lq shufhqw/ dqg |lhog vsuhdgv ryhu X1V1 Wuhdvxulhv ri frpsdudeoh

pdwxulw|/ phdvxuhg lq edvlv srlqwv/ ri �{hg0udwh X1V1 groodu ghqrplqdwhg qhz ghew lvvxhv iurp hphujlqj

pdunhwv/ l1h1/ r�huhg gxulqj wkh fdohqgdu |hdu suhfhglqj wkh Uhvxujhqw Lqgld Erqgv +ULEv, lvvxh/ l1h1/ 4242<;0

;272<;1 Sdqho D suhvhqwv wkh gdwd rq vryhulhjq erqgv dqg Sdqho E suhvhqwv gdwd rq frusrudwh erqgv1 Lq wklv

h{klelw/ ESV dqg PG\ uhihu wr wkh erqg*v edvlv srlqwv vsuhdg dqg lpsolflw fuhglw udwlqj rq wkh r�hulqj gdwh1

Vlqfh pdunhwv w|slfdoo| idfwru lq lqirupdwlrq rq srwhqwldo xsjudghv dqg grzqjudghv dqg derxw wkh ixwxuh

rxworrn ri wkh lvvxhu +dv vhw iruwkh e| d udwlqj djhqf|, lq ghwhuplqlqj wkh sulfh dqg |lhog ri d ghew lvvxh/

zh fdswxuh vxfk lqirupdwlrq lq wkh iroorzlqj pdqqhu= li d udwlqj djhqf| sodfhv dq lvvxhu xqghu uhylhz iru d

srwhqwldo xsjudgh +grzqjudgh, ru li wkh dvvrfldwhg rxworrn iru dq lvvxhu lv srvlwlyh +qhjdwlyh,/ zh lqfuhdvh

+ghfuhdvh, wkh fuhglw udwlqj e| d qrwfk1 Zh uhihu wr wklv dv wkh lpsolflw fuhglw udwlqj1 Vrxufh= Vhfxulwlhv

Gdwd Frpsdq|> Eorrpehuj1

Sdqho D= Vryhuhljq erqg lvvxhv

VQR LVVXHU LVVGDWH PDWXULW\ H[FKDQJH \LHOG ESV PG\

4 Dujhqwlqd 3523624<<; 3<24<2535: OX[EJ <1;93 733 Ed6

5 Dujhqwlqd 3624:24<<; 342632534: OX[EJ <1;:3 6<9 Ed6

6 Dujhqwlqd 3725724<<; 3525625334 OX[EJ :15:3 498 Ed6

7 Dujhqwlqd 3725724<<; 3525625334 OX[EJ :1983 536 Ed6

8 Dujhqwlqd 3:25<24<<; 4525325336 OX[EJ ;16;3 5;9 Ed6

9 Frorpeld 3625924<<; 372342533; OX[EJ ;1983 5<: Ed4

: Frorpeld 3924<24<<; 3924825336 RWF 4;1;53 663 Ed4

; Ph{lfr 3623824<<; 362452533; RWF2OX[EJ ;1963 5;8 Ed5

< Sklolsslqhv 3723524<<; 372482533; OX[EJ ;1<93 673 Ed5

43 Uhsxeolf ri Yhqh}xhod 3:26324<<; 3;2482534; RWF2OX[EJ 461<;3 ;49 E5

44 Uhsxeolfd gr Eudvlo 3625324<<; 3625:2535: OX[EJ 431633 773 E5

45 Uhsxeolfd gr Eudvlo 3625324<<; 382482535: RWF 431633 773 E5

46 Uhsxeolfd gr Eudvlo 3626424<<; 3723:2533; OX[EJ <1753 6:8 E5

47 Uxvvld 3923624<<; 3924325336 OX[EJ 4513;3 984 E5

48 Uxvvldq Ihghudwlrq+Uxvvld, 3924324<<; 3924325336 OX[EJ 4513;3 986 E5

49 Uxvvldq Ihghudwlrq+Uxvvld, 3924;24<<; 392572535; OX[EJ 451<93 :59 E5

4: Uxvvldq Ihghudwlrq+Uxvvld, 3:24524<<; 3:2572534; OX[EJ 491993 43;9 E5

4; Vorydn Uhsxeolf 3824724<<; 3825;25336 OX[EJ <1863 6;: Ed4

4< Vrxwk Nruhd 3723;24<<; 3724825336 OX[EJ ;1<83 674 Ed4

53 Vrxwk Nruhd 3723;24<<; 372482533; RWF2OX[EJ <13;3 683 Ed4

54 Wxunh| 3725;24<<; 3824525336 OX[EJ ;1<73 649 E4

55 Xuxjxd| 3723424<<; 3723:2533; OX[EJ :1393 477 Edd6

�D

Page 16: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

Sdqho D= Vryhuhljq erqg lvvxhv

VQR LVVXHU LVVGDWH PDWXULW\ H[FKDQJH \LHOG ESV PG\

4 Edqfr gh Prqwhylghr 3725624<<; 372632533; QRQH ;18;3 5;< Ed4

5 Edqfr Pd|r Frrshudwlyr0Eudqfk 3625724<<; 3626425334 QRQH <1783 6<6 E4

6 Elvwur Wu <;05333 3:23424<<; 3926325336 Q2D <1753 6<< Ed6

7 Elvwur Wuxvw 4<<;04333 3824624<<; 3625925334 Q2D 918;3 <; Ed4

8 Fld Udglrfrppxqlfdflrq Prylohv 3823824<<; 3823;2533; QRQH <1743 6:4 Edd6

9 Frqsurfd +VN Frus, 3925924<<; 3924925343 Q\VH 451333 97; Ed5

: Frusrudflrq Dqglqd gh Irphqwr 3624524<<; 3624825338 RWF 91;63 454 Edd4

; Frusrudflrq Dqglqd gh Irphqwr 3824524<<; 3824<25336 OX[EJ 91;83 453 Edd4

< FWL Jurxs Kroglqjv V1D1 3723624<<; 372482533; Q2D 441833 936 E6

43 Hghoqru 3625924<<; 3723525338 Q2D 431833 7:9 Edd6

44 Hxulglv0Glvfr+Vrjh�sd, 3823824<<; 3824825336 Q\VH <1473 67; Ed6

45 Hxulglv0Glvfr+Vrjh�sd, 3823824<<; 382482533; Q\VH <1<;3 75; Ed6

46 Jorersdu 3624:24<<; 452382533; QRQH 4319:3 83: E5

47 Jorersdu 3824424<<; 452382533; Q2D 4318:3 7:8 E5

48 Juxsr Lqgxvwuldo Plqhud Ph{lfr 3625824<<; 372342533; RWF ;1663 59< Edd6

49 Juxsr Lqgxvwuldo Plqhud Ph{lfr 3625824<<; 372342535; RWF <1593 665 Edd6

4: Mdiud Frvphwlfv Lqwo+Jloohwwh, 3725;24<<; 382342533; Q2D 441:83 8<8 Fdd

4; Nd}nrpphuwv Lqwhuqdwlrqdo EY 3726324<<; 3823;25334 OX[EJ 441693 8:7 E5

4< Pdvwhoorqh Khupdqrv VD 3625924<<; 372342533; Q2D 441:83 93: E4

53 PJWV Prvfrz 3623824<<; 3624<25334 OX[EJ 451833 9;: Ed6

54 Prvfrz Flw| Whohskrqh Fr 3623824<<; 3624<25334 OX[EJ 451833 9;: Ed6

55 PRYLFRP 3823824<<; 3823;2533; QRQH <16;3 69; Ed6

56 Pxowlfdqdo VD+Juxsr Fodulq, 3724924<<; 372482534; QRQH 431:33 7:9 Ed6

57 Qdwlrqdo Edqn ri Kxqjdu| 3626324<<; 3723;25336 OX[EJ 91893 ;9 Edd5

58 Qdwlrqdo Srzhu Frus+Sklolsslq, 3823424<<; 382482535; RWF <1;43 6;: Ed5

59 SGYVD 3823824<<; 3524825337 OX[EJ 917:3 :9 D6

5: SGYVD 3823824<<; 3524825339 OX[EJ 919;3 <7 D6

5; SGYVD 3823824<<; 442482533; OX[EJ 91;63 443 D6

5< SGYVD 3823824<<; 3;24825349 OX[EJ :1773 479 D6

63 SGYVD 3823824<<; 442482535; OX[EJ :1873 489 D6

64 SHPH[+Ph{lfr, 3625824<<; 3626325338 OX[EJ ;1753 5:5 Ed5

65 SHPH[+Ph{lfr, 3625824<<; 362632534; OX[EJ <1593 659 Ed5

66 Sur|hfwrv gh Hqhujld 3824524<<; 3:24825346 OX[EJ <1<43 737 Ed5

67 Vdpvxqj Hohfwurqlfv Fr Owg 3725:24<<; 3823425336 QRQH <1:93 6<< Ed4

68 Vdwholwhv Ph{lfdqrv VD 3425524<<; 4423425337 Q2D 431463 793 E6

69 Vxshufdqdo VD 3823:24<<; 3824825338 Q2D 441833 8:; E6

6: Whohirqlfd gh Dujhqwlqd VD 3725<24<<; 3823;2533; OX[EJ <1553 674 Ed6

6; Wxunfhoo Lohwlvlp Kl}phwohul 3:24:24<<; 3;23425338 Q2D 481333 <76 E5

6< WY Edqgu+Eud}lo, 3823;24<<; 3824825339 RWF 461333 :59 E6

73 Ydulj Ohdvlqj VD Duuhqgdphqwr 3523624<<; 3524325338 SRUWD <1:83 74< Ed6

74 \SI VD 3623724<<; 3624825336 RWF :15;3 48: Ed6

�S

Page 17: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

H{klelw :

\lhogv ri vhdvrqhg erqg lvvxhv

Wklv h{klelw suhvhqwv wkh |lhogv/ phdvxuhg lq shufhqw/ dqg |lhog vsuhdgv ryhu X1V1 Wuhdvxulhv ri frpsdudeoh

pdwxulw|/ phdvxuhg lq edvlv srlqwv/ ri �{hg0udwh X1V1 groodu ghqrplqdwhg vhdvrqhg ghew lvvxhv iurp hphujlqj

pdunhwv1 Sdqho D suhvhqwv wkh gdwd rq vryhulhjq erqgv dqg Sdqho E suhvhqwv gdwd rq frusrudwh erqgv1 Lq

wklv h{klelw/ ESV dqg PG\ uhihu wr wkh erqg*v edvlv srlqwv vsuhdg dqg fuhglw udwlqj rq Dxjxvw 7/ 4<<;/

wkh gd| suhfhglqj wkh r�hulqj ri wkh Uhvxujhqw Lqgld Erqgv1 Vlqfh pdunhwv w|slfdoo| idfwru lq lqirupdwlrq

rq srwhqwldo xsjudghv dqg grzqjudghv dqg derxw wkh ixwxuh rxworrn ri wkh lvvxhu +dv vhw iruwkh e| d udwlqj

djhqf|, lq ghwhuplqlqj wkh sulfh dqg |lhog ri d ghew lvvxh/ zh fdswxuh vxfk lqirupdwlrq lq wkh iroorzlqj

pdqqhu= li d udwlqj djhqf| sodfhv dq lvvxhu xqghu uhylhz iru d srwhqwldo xsjudgh +grzqjudgh, ru li wkh

dvvrfldwhg rxworrn iru dq lvvxhu lv srvlwlyh +qhjdwlyh,/ zh lqfuhdvh +ghfuhdvh, wkh fuhglw udwlqj e| d qrwfk1

Zh uhihu wr wklv dv wkh lpsolflw fuhglw udwlqj1 Vrxufh= Vhfxulwlhv Gdwd Frpsdq|> Eorrpehuj1

Sdqho D= Vryhuhljq erqg lvvxhv

VQR LVVXHU FRXQWU\ PDWXULW\ H[FKDQJH \LHOG ESV PG\

4 DUJHQWLQD DUJHQWLQD 44242<< OX[HPERXUJ :1639 4<; Ed6

5 DUJHQWLQD DUJHQWLQD 5256234 OX[HPERXUJ ;134< 593 Ed6

6 DUJHQWLQD DUJHQWLQD 45253236 OX[HPERXUJ ;1346 58: Ed6

7 DUJHQWLQD DUJHQWLQD 432<239 OX[HPERXUJ <1958 749 Ed6

8 DUJHQWLQD DUJHQWLQD 426324: OX[HPERXUJ 431786 7:; Ed6

9 DUJHQWLQD DUJHQWLQD <24<25: EXHQRV DLUHV 431689 7:3 Ed6

: EUD]LO0JOREDO EG EUD]LO 4428234 OX[HPERXUJ ;13746 595 E5

; EUD]LO UHS RI EUD]LO 72:23; OX[HPERXUJ 431<:7 887 E5

< EUD]LO0JOREDO EG EUD]LO 824825: OX[HPERXUJ 4418<5 8<6 E5

43 FKLQD +SHRSOH*V, FKLQD :26234 OX[HPERXUJ :13:9 499 Edd4

44 FKLQD +SHRSOH*V, FKLQD 4325;235 OX[HPERXUJ :14;< 4:9 Edd4

45 FKLQD +SHRSOH*V, FKLQD 4248236 QRW OLVWHG :153; 4:; Edd4

46 FKLQD +SHRSOH*V, FKLQD 524:237 OX[HPERXUJ :15;; 4;5 Edd4

47 FKLQD +SHRSOH*V, FKLQD :28239 OX[HPERXUJ :16; 4<4 Edd4

48 FKLQD +SHRSOH*V, FKLQD 4325;25: OX[HPERXUJ :1:;< 546 Edd4

49 FRORPELD UHS RI FRORPELD 43292<< QRW OLVWHG 91:8< 476 Ed4

4: FRORPELD UHS RI FRORPELD 5248236 QRW OLVWHG ;19:7 656 Ed4

4; FRORPELD UHS RI FRORPELD 9248236 QRW OLVWHG ;19:< 657 Ed4

4< FRORPELD UHS RI FRORPELD 5256237 QRW OLVWHG ;1:7: 65; Ed4

53 LQGRQHVLD +UHS, LQGRQHVLD ;24239 Q2D 46169: :<3 E5

54 PH[LFDQ XWG VWV PH[LFR 529234 OX[HPERXUJ :179 537 Ed5

55 PH[LFDQ XWG VWV PH[LFR 424823: OX[HPERXUJ <1476 69: Ed5

56 PH[LFDQ XWG VWV PH[LFR 624523; OX[HPERXUJ <135; 693 Ed5

57 PH[LFDQ XWG VWV PH[LFR <248249 OX[HPERXUJ <1<9; 75< Ed5

58 PH[LFDQ XWG VWV PH[LFR 8248259 OX[HPERXUJ <1;<7 756 Ed5

59 SKLOLSSLQHV +UHS, SKLOLSSLQHV 724823; OX[HPERXUJ <17<9 73: Ed5

5: SKLOLSSLQHV +UHS, SKLOLSSLQHV 432:249 OX[HPERXUJ <168; 69; Ed5

5; SRODQG SRODQG :24237 QRW OLVWHG 91754 <9 Edd6

�.

Page 18: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

Sdqho D= Vryhuhljq erqg lvvxhv +frqwlqxhg,

VQR LVVXHU FRXQWU\ PDWXULW\ H[FKDQJH \LHOG ESV PG\

5< SRODQG SRODQG :2424: QRW OLVWHG 91;74 446 Edd6

63 PLQILQ RI UXVVLD UXVVLD 442472<< QRW OLVWHG 451858 :53 E5

64 UXVVLD UXVVLD 4425:234 OX[HPERXUJ 491636 43;; E5

65 PLQILQ RI UXVVLD UXVVLD 8247236 QRW OLVWHG 4;164; 45;; E5

66 UXVVLD UXVVLD 9243236 OX[HPERXUJ 4:1748 44<; E5

67 PLQILQ RI UXVVLD UXVVLD 8247239 QRW OLVWHG 4:1356 4488 E5

68 UXVVLD UXVVLD 925923: OX[HPERXUJ 4:146: 449< E5

69 PLQILQ RI UXVVLD UXVVLD 824723; QRW OLVWHG 4915<; 43;: E5

6: VORYDN UHSXEOLF VORYDNLD 825;236 OX[HPERXUJ <197; 754 Ed4

6; UHS RI NRUHD NRUHD 7248236 OX[HPERXUJ <17:5 736 Ed4

6< UHS RI NRUHD NRUHD 724823; OX[HPERXUJ <1<78 785 Ed4

73 WKDLODQG NLQJGRP WKDLODQG 724823: QRW OLVWHG <19;7 756 Ed5

74 WXUNH\ UHS RI WXUNH\ 8256235 OX[HPERXUJ ;1;:6 677 E4

75 YHQH]XHOD0SDU YHQH]XHOD 924;23: OX[HPERXUJ 441486 8:3 E5

76 YHQH]XHOD0SDU YHQH]XHOD <24825: OX[HPERXUJ 471364 ;6: E5

Sdqho E= Frusrudwh erqg lvvxhv

4 FRORPELD UHS RI FRORPELD 5248249 QRW OLVWHG <1:5; 738 Ed4

5 EDQFR EDQVXG DUJHQWLQD 452462<< OX[HPERXUJ <138< 6:6 Ed6

6 EDQFR GH JDOLFLD DUJHQWLQD ;259235 ORQGRQ ;1857 63< Ed6

7 PRYLFRP DUJHQWLQD 82;23; OX[HPERXUJ <17;< 739 Ed6

8 PXOWLFDQDO VD DUJHQWLQD 524235 EXHQRV DLUHV <146: 6:5 Ed6

9 PXOWLFDQDO VD DUJHQWLQD 52423: EXHQRV DLUHV 43183: 837 Ed6

: SDVD VD DUJHQWLQD ;24235 EXHQRV DLUHV <155: 6;3 Ed6

; SHUH] FRPSDQF DUJHQWLQD 4263237 EXHQRV DLUHV ;1834 639 Ed6

< SHUH] FRPSDQF DUJHQWLQD :24823: OX[HPERXUJ <13578 68: Ed6

43 WHOHFRP DUJHQW DUJHQWLQD 4324;233 OX[HPERXUJ :1878 545 Ed5

44 WHOHIRQLFD DUJHQ DUJHQWLQD 4324233 OX[HPERXUJ :1874 544 Ed6

45 WHOHIRQLFD DUJHQ DUJHQWLQD 82:23; OX[HPERXUJ <16:: 6<8 Ed6

46 \SI VD DUJHQWLQD 6248236 QRW OLVWHG :19: 556 Ed5

47 EDQFR EFQ EDUF EUD]LO 927237 OX[HPERXUJ <1737 6<7 E5

48 EDQFR EUDGHVFR EUD]LO 4424;2<< OX[HPERXUJ ;1;;4 688 E5

49 EDQFR EUDGHVFR EUD]LO 43249233 OX[HPERXUJ ;1<<; 68: E5

4: EDQFR VDIUD FL FKLOH 44243233 OX[HPERXUJ <186; 744 E5

4; HQGHVD0FKLOH FKLOH :24823; QRW OLVWHG :1:6; 564 Edd4

4< HQGHVD0FKLOH FKLOH 52425: QRW OLVWHG ;154: 588 Edd4

53 HQHUVLV VD FKLOH 4524239 QHZ \RUN :1:;< 565 Edd4

54 VFLFL LQGLD :263234 OX[HPERXUJ ;187: 646 Ed6

55 LQG FU LQY LQGLD LQGLD 52:236 OX[HPERXUJ ;1;97 675 Ed6

56 D[D VD PH[LFR ;27237 OX[HPERXUJ 4317:5 834 Ed6

57 EDQFR QDF GH FRP PH[LFR 7247233 OX[HPERXUJ :188< 546 Ed5

�H

Page 19: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

Sdqho E= Frusrudwh erqg lvvxhv +Frqwlqxhg1,

58 EDQFR QDF GH FRP PH[LFR :24233 QHZ \RUN :1749 4<< Ed5

59 EDQFR QDF GH FRP PH[LFR :24;235 OX[HPERXUJ ;16<5 5<9 Ed5

5: EDQFRPH[W WUXVW PH[LFR ;28236 OX[HPERXUJ ;1857 63; Ed5

5; EDQFR QDF GH FRP PH[LFR 525237 OX[HPERXUJ ;179 635 Ed5

5< EDQFRPH[W WUXVW PH[LFR 8263239 OX[HPERXUJ <15<4 6;5 Ed5

63 JUXSR LPVD VD PH[LFR 432462<< ORQGRQ :1744 53; Ed5

64 QDFLRQDO ILQ VQF PH[LFR 924<233 ORQGRQ :1878 545 Ed5

65 QDFLRQDO ILQ VQF PH[LFR 44255234 OX[HPERXUJ ;14<7 5:: Ed5

66 QDFLRQDO ILQ VQF PH[LFR :248235 OX[HPERXUJ ;156: 5;4 Ed5

67 SHWDFDOFR WRSROR SHWWRS PH[LFR 45248236 OX[HPERXUJ ;1;<; 679 Ed5

68 SUR\HFWRV HQHUJ FIHSUR PH[LFR :248246 Q2D <1<;< 773 Ed5

69 YLFDS VD PH[LFR 8248235 Q2D <1<< 789 E4

6: YLFDS VD PH[LFR 824823: Q2D 441499 8:5 E4

6; URPDQLDQ FRPP EN URPDQLD 6264233 OX[HPERXUJ 4513<7 999 Ed6

6< PRVFRZ FLW\ WHOH UXVVLD 624<234 OX[HPERXUJ 541835 493; E6

73 VEV DJUR ILQ UXVVLD :254233 OX[HPERXUJ 57167; 4;<5 E6

74 H[S0LPS EN NRUHD NRUHD 8248233 QRW OLVWHG 4415<4 8;9 Ed5

75 H[S0LPS EN NRUHD NRUHD 9258234 OX[HPERXUJ 451574 9;5 Ed5

76 H[S0LPS EN NRUHD NRUHD <253234 OX[HPERXUJ 4417:8 939 Ed5

77 H[S0LPS EN NRUHD NRUHD 5243235 OX[HPERXUJ 44146; 8:4 Ed5

78 H[S0LPS EN NRUHD NRUHD 5248239 OX[HPERXUJ 4413:9 894 Ed5

79 NRUHD WHOHFRP NRUHD 45242<< QRW OLVWHG 44139; 8:7 Ed5

7: NRUHD GHY EDQN NRUHD 4259233 KRQJ NRQJ 431;:4 887 Ed5

7; NRUHD GHY EDQN NRUHD 824233 QRW OLVWHG 4413<7 899 Ed5

7< NRUHD GHY EDQN NRUHD 4524233 Q2D 431;:9 878 Ed5

83 NRUHD GHY EDQN NRUHD 6248234 Q2D 431< 87; Ed5

84 NRUHD GHY EDQN NRUHD 6248234 Q2D 431< 87; Ed5

85 NRUHD GHY EDQN NRUHD 6263234 Q2D 431<36 87; Ed5

86 NRUHD GHY EDQN NRUHD <24:234 OX[HPERXUJ 441337 88; Ed5

87 NRUHD GHY EDQN NRUHD 6258235 Q2D 431<8< 886 Ed5

88 NRUHD GHY EDQN NRUHD 44248235 OX[HPERXUJ 4413<9 89: Ed5

89 NRUHD GHY EDQN NRUHD 44254236 KRQJ NRQJ 441376 893 Ed5

8: NRUHD GHY EDQN NRUHD <24:237 Q2D 4415<7 8;6 Ed5

8; NRUHD GHY EDQN NRUHD <24:237 OX[HPERXUJ 4413:8 894 Ed5

8< NRUHD GHY EDQN NRUHD 8248239 OX[HPERXUJ 4315; 7;4 Ed5

93 NRUHD HOHF SZU NRUHD :24235 QRW OLVWHG 4414<< 8:: Ed5

94 NRUHD HOHF SZU NRUHD 4524236 OX[HPERXUJ 4415: 8;6 Ed5

95 LFLFL LQGLD 3523:25336 OX[HPERXUJ ;19<9 659 Ed6

96 LFLFL LQGLD 3;2482533: OX[HPERXUJ <194 749 Ed6

97 UHOLDQFH LQGXVWULHV LQGLD 3<25:25338 Q2D <16<4 6<3 Ed6

98 UHOLDQFH LQGXVWULHV LQGLD 3;2462533: ORQGRQ 431;78 873 Ed6

99 VFLFL LQGLD 3:26325334 OX[HPERXUJ ;1:6< 665 Ed6

�b

Page 20: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

H{klelw ;

Glvwulexwlrq ri ULE lq�rzv

Wklv h{klelw suhvhqwv wkh glvwulexwlrq ri lq�rzv +lq shufhqw, iurp Uhvxujhqw Lqgld Erqgv +ULEv,/ edvhg rq

wkh fxuuhqf| ri ghqrplqdwlrq/ jhrjudsklf uhjlrq/ dqg edqn w|sh1

Vhjphqw Shufhqw

Fxuuhqf| ri ghqrplqdwlrq

' <813(

m 518(

G1P1 518(

Jhrjudsklf uhjlrq

Plggoh Hdvw 83(

Vrxwk ) Idu Hdvw 53(

Hxursh ) Xqlwhg Vwdwhv 63(

Edqn w|sh

Vwdwh Edqn ri Lqgld 7318(

Froohfwlqj edqnv 8<18(

Wrwdo 433133

Vrxufh= Vwdwh Edqn ri Lqgld> Grz Mrqhv Qhzvzluhv

2f

Page 21: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

H{klelw <

Frpplvvlrq vwuxfwxuh

Wklv h{klelw suhvhqwv wkh surjuhvvlyh frpplvvlrq vfkhgxoh +lq shufhqw, sd|deoh wr froohfwlqj edqnv edvhg rq

wkh dprxqw froohfwhg +lq ploolrqv ri grooduv,1

Dprxqw froohfwhg Frpplvvlrq

+' ploolrqv, +shufhqw,

� 8 3183(

81405813 31:8(

581408313 4133(

8314043313 4158(

A 43313 4183(

Vrxufh= Vwdwh Edqn ri Lqgld> Grz Mrqhv Qhzvzluhv

2�

Page 22: +ith}i?| W? @ L? t @timpuri/RIBcase.pdf · 2001-02-13 · d ghew lvvxh/ qdpho| _Uhvxujhqw qgLld Erqgv%1 Wzr nh| ihdwxuhv ri wkhvh erqgv zhuh wkhlu |lhogv/ wrxwhg ql wkh Lqgldq qdqfldo

Dsshqgl{

Ghvfulswlrq ri Prrg|*v fuhglw udwlqjv

Wklv h{klelw suhvhqwv d eulhi ghvfulswlrq ri Prrg|*v fuhglw udwlqjv1

Prrg|*v fuhglw udwlqj Eulhi ghvfulswlrq

Lqyhvwphqw Judgh 0 Kljk Fuhglwzruwklqhvv

Ddd Jlow hgjh/ sulph/ pd{lpxp vdihw|

Dd60Dd4 Yhu| kljk judgh/ kljk txdolw|

D60D4 Xsshu phglxp judgh

Edd60Edd4 Orzhu phglxp judgh

Glvwlqfwo| Vshfxodwlyh 0 Orz Fuhglwzruwklqhvv

Ed60Ed4 Orz judgh/ vshfxodwlyh

E60E4 Kljko| Vshfxodwlyh

Suhgrplqdqwo| Vshfxodwlyh 0 Vxevwdqwldo Ulvn ru lq Ghidxow

Fdd Vxevwdqwldo ulvn/ lq srru vwdqglqj

Fd Pd| eh lq ghidxow/ h{wuhpho| vshfxodwlyh

F Hyhq pruh vshfxodwlyh wkdq wkrvh deryh

Vrxufh= Zlovrq/ U1V1 dqg Ider}}l/ I1M1/ Wkh Qhz Frusrudwh Erqg Pdunhw +Fklfdjr= Surexv Sxeolvklqj

Frpsdq|/ 4<<3,1

22