DIGNITY Œ FREEDOM Œ HUMAN RIGHTSfreedom and human rights mean something completely different in...

!"##$%& (%)*#+,&(*% #$-,#.(%- &/$ 0*%)$#$%0$12/$ 3*4$ *) &/$ !,&/*4(0 !/"#0/ (% &/$ 5"#*6$,% 7%&$-#,&(*% 8#*0$99:

0,% ;$ )*"%. *% &/$ <$;9(&$<<<=>*90(*4?$"#*6,=*#-=64

7@AB CDE?EF?ECDGH?IG?J

DIG

NIT

Y �

FREE

DO

M �

HU

MA

N R

IGH

TS

�Wok

ó³ n

as� P

ublis

hing

Hou

seG

liwic

e 20

16

Differences in the understanding of human dignity are bornfrom the rejection by EU legislation of the religious element andthe laws of nature, which for Christians are essential sources ofhuman dignity, freedom and human rights. The EU developedthem mostly from the state endowment, and relative stability isnot attributed to them. In reading the convergences anddivergences in the understanding of these three fundamentalconcepts of human dignity, freedom and human rights,a particular difficulty in dialogue with the EU comes from thelanguage which we use to express our views. The terms dignity,freedom and human rights mean something completely differentin both the Christian and Union contexts. This discrepancy arosebecause Christianity derives dignity, freedom and human rightsfrom the truth, and this is the revealed truth, while the EU hasadopted the principle of freedom as its source. [...]

Bp Prof. Tadeusz Pieronek

2/(9 0*+6(4,&(*% <,9 6";4(9/$. "9(%- )"%.9)#*+ &/$ K#*"6 *) &/$ 5"#*6$,% 8$*64$:9 8,#&L

(% &/$ 5"#*6$,% 8,#4(,+$%&

DIGNITY � FREEDOM� HUMAN RIGHTS

The Role of the Catholic Churchin the European Integration Process

This publication contains the transcriptsfrom speeches and discussions during the conference

in Krakow on 25-26 September 2015

M 3 K N B 7 @ 5 3 @ NBO ! M M 8 5 3 N 2 7 M B @

The Pontifical Universityof John Paul II

The Robert SchumanFoundation

The Konrad AdenauerFoundation

�Wokó³ nas�Publishing House

The Groupof the European People's Party

European People�s Party Commissionof the Bishops� Conferences

of the European Union





!"#$%& ()*+ ,-./0*10(2 3#-*45/06074 89:;

!"#$"%& ( )*++!,- ( ./-0$ *"#.%1<14 =#/4 #> ?14 @)?1#/07 @1-A710( ?14 B-A#C4)( D(?42A)?0#( ,A#74**

E !"#$%& ()*+ ,-./0*10(2 3#-*4 89:;

<10* C-./07)?0#( 0* >A44 #> 71)A24F=4CA#G-7?0#( 0* )-?1#A0*4GH CA#I0G4G ?14 *#-A74 0* )7$(#6/4G24GF

BG0?#A0)/ *?)>>J =)>)& K-G(0$H L071)& 5%A)<A)(*/)?0#(J M/0() L0$#&)N7OP$@#CP 4G0?0(2J M(() QCP*OR4*02(J MA?-A S)7O#A,1#?#2A)C1*J L071)& "0?607$0H M(?#(0 "0?607$0

<10* 7#TC0/)?0#( 6)* C-./0*14G -*0(2 >-(G* >A#T?14 5A#-C #> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,4#C/4+* ,)A?P0( ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(?

DQKUJ VWXYXZYXVW:[Y9:Y8

!"#$%& ()*+ ,-./0*10(2 3#-*4-/F S#O04/*$) :X;\\Y:8: 5/060744YT)0/J 6PG)6(07?6#]6#$#/()*FC/666F6#$#/()*FC/

<10* 0* ?14 8[8 C-./07)?0#( #> ?14 !"#$%& ()*+ ,-./0*10(2 3#-*4

!"#$% '( )'*+%*+,

+23456 768436 9:6 +;<= 48 >9? .2=<@>9AKC ,A#>F <)G4-*O ,04A#(4$ FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF [

"@934B2C9>4@RA ^)( _/.AP71? FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF W

D6EC4=6 <@B ,56@>@F@)AGF RA Q?)(0*&)6 RO060*O FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF :ZRA @1A0*?0)( Q71T0?O FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF :[3#A*? `)(24* FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF :WL)A4$ Q#6) FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF :V5PaA2P 3a/Ib(P0 FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF 8:KC ^)(-*O Q?4C(#6*$0 FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF 8Z^4)(Y@/)-G4 ^-(7$4A FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF 8\RA =)>)& <AO)*$#6*$0 FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF 8[

"@934B2C9>4@ 1566C:6? 94 9:6 D43G>@F #3425?=4IF RA c/#A0)( S#/>1)-* FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF Z:@)AGF Kb71)A) K#-?A#* =)0 FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF ZX,A#>F M(GAO4N d#// FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF \8B/T)A KA#$FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF [Z

12==<3A 48 9:6 D43G>@F #3425?Q-TT)AP #> ?14 6#A$0(2 2A#-C 4(?0?/4GJ RD5UD<eBG0?#A MA?-A QC#A(0)$ FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF ;:Q-TT)AP #> ?14 6#A$0(2 2A#-C 4(?0?/4GJ c=BBR_LBG0?#A S)?)AOP() <A)7O FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF ;WQ-TT)AP #> ?14 6#A$0(2 2A#-C 4(?0?/4GJ 3fLMU =D53<QBG0?#A L)A70( gP&) FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF W8

156C><E 16??>4@Bf=_,B h M 5`_KM` ,`MeB=D(?A#G-7?0#( QC44714*

RA ^)74$ Q)AP-*OY"#/*$0 FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF X:,A#>F =#77# K-??02/0#(4 FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF XW

R4.)?4 FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF V[

H4@CE2?>4@ 48 9:6 H4@8636@C6=4IF ,A#>F "#N70471 dPO)$ FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF :9W

156<G63? FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF :::

[

!"# %&'(# )*+,-./ %0,&'1,2!"#$%&#' )* +", -%.#'$/$'. !)&&$++,,

+23456 768436 9:6 +;<= 48 >9? .2=<@>9A

_A2)(0O0(2 ?14 :[?1 SA)$#6 7#(>4A4(74 G4)/0(2 60?1 !<14 =#/4 #> ?14 @)?1Y#/07 @1-A71 0( ?14 B-A#C4)( D(?42A)?0#( ,A#74**+ )(G >#7-*0(2 #( ?14 ?#C07J!R02(0?P h cA44G#T h 3-T)( =021?*+H 64 1#C4G ?1)? 64 6#-/G .4 )./4 ?# *1#61#6 -(0?0(2 B-A#C4 C4A740I4* )(G 4I)/-)?4* 0?*4/> )>?4A ?14 C)*? 1)/>Y74(?-AP 0(A4/)?0#( ?# 0?* >#-(G0(2 >)?14A*+ I0*0#(H )* 64// )* 1#6 ?10* B-A#C4 0* C4A740I4G)(G 4I)/-)?4G .P @1A0*?0)(*H )(G ?14 @)?1#/07 @1-A71 0( C)A?07-/)AH )* ?14 7#TYT-(0?P #> .4/04I4A* 2A#6* 0( )( 0(*?0?-?0#( 60?1 )24Y#/G A##?*F

M? >0A*? 2/)(74H 0? T021? *44T ?1)? ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( )(G ?14 @)?1#/07@1-A71 7#(*0G4A ?14 CA#74** #> B-A#C4)( 0(?42A)?0#( )* (474**)AP )(G CA#T0*Y0(2 >#A 0?* G4I4/#CT4(?F <10* >0A*? 0TCA4**0#( 0* ?A-4H .-? >A#T ?14 >0A*? *?4C* #>0(?42A)?0#(H CA#C4A )? ?1)? ?0T4H ?14 #.N47?0I4* C-A*-4G .P B-A#C4 0(G07)?4G ) /)7$#> 0G4)* #A ?14 /)7$ #> 0(?4A4*? #> 0?* 7A4)?#A* 0( ?14 0(?42A)/ G4I4/#CT4(? #>B-A#C4F @#(74A( >#A 47#(#T07 2A#6?1 GA#6(4G 0? #-?H -(?0/ )? *#T4 C#0(? ?14(44G ?# 7)A4 >#A ?14 *C0A0?-)/H 4*C470)//P @1A0*?0)( I)/-4*H 6)* 7#TC/4?4/P 4i?0(Y2-0*14GF

<14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( )(G ?14 @)?1#/07 @1-A71 *44$ ?# .-0/G ) 2A4)? 7#TT-Y(0?P #> ()?0#(* )(G *?)?4*H .-? 1)I4 7#TC/4?4/P G0>>4A4(? I0*0#(* #> ?14 7#TT-Y(0?P )(G 1#6 ?# C)I4 ?14 G0I4A24(? A#)G* /4)G0(2 ?# 0?* 7A4)?0#(F D? 0* -(>#A?-()?4?1)? ?10* 1)* 1)CC4(4GF <14 Bf 0* ) *47-/)A .#GPj ?14 @)?1#/07 @1-A71 1)* A4/0Y20#-* *?A-7?-A4 )(G #.N47?0I4*F <14 *)T4 C4#C/4 )A4 /)A24/P ?14 70?0O4(* #> ?14f(0#( )(G ?14 T4T.4A* #> ?14 @1-A71F <14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( 1)* (#? )G#C?4G) T#G4/ #> 7##C4A)?0#( .4?644( Q?)?4 )(G @1-A71H 24(4A)?4G .P ?14 Q47#(Gk)?07)( @#-(70/H )**-T0(2 ?14 0(G4C4(G4(74 )(G )-?#(#TP #> ?14 ?6# 7#TT-Y(0?04* )(G ?140A 7##C4A)?0#( >#A ?14 .4(4>0? #> 70?0O4(* )(G ?14 7#TT#( 2##GF3#64I4AH ?10* T#G4/ 0* )G#C?4G 0( *#T4 Bf 7#-(?A04*H )(G *# 0(G0A47?/P 0TC/4YT4(?4G ?14A4F <14 f(0#( 1)* G470G4G ?# T)()24 A4/)?0#(* 60?1 ?14 71-A714* )(GA4/020#-* 7#TT-(0?04* #( ?14 C/)?>#AT 7)//4G ?14 MT*?4AG)T 7/)-*4H 61071H 0() */021?/P T#G0>04G >#ATH 0* C)A? #> ?14 `0*.#( <A4)?PF Q# >)AH 1#64I4AH 64 1)I4*44( >46 A4*-/?* #> ?10* 71)((4/ #> 7#(?)7?*F

<14 :[?1 7#(>4A4(74 0( SA)$#6 7#(>0AT4G ?14 >-(G)T4(?)/ G0>>4A4(74* .4Y?644( ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( )(G ?14 @)?1#/07 @1-A71 #( ?14 I0*0#( #> ) -(0?4GB-A#C4 )(G ?14 T4)(* #> 0?* 0TC/4T4(?)?0#(F R-4 ?# ?14 2A#60(2 CA#./4T #>

;

A4>-244* 0( B-A#C4H ?14 C)A?070C)(?* #>?4( A4>4AA4G ?# G02(0?PH >A44G#T )(G 1-YT)( A021?* 0( ?14 7#(?4i? #> ?14 ?A)24GP #> T0//0#(* #> C4#C/4 )? A0*$ #> /#** #>/0>4 )(G 1#T4F <1#*4 61# T)$4 ) G)(24A#-* N#-A(4P 0( 1#C4* #> *-AI0I)/ )(G ?#A4.-0/G ?140A /0I4* *1#-/G G# *# -(G4A ?14 7#(G0?0#(* #> 1-T)( G02(0?PF

<14 G0>>4A4(74* 0( -(G4A*?)(G0(2 1-T)( G02(0?P )A4 .#A( >A#T A4N47?0#( .P?14 Bf /420*/)?0#( #> ?14 A4/020#-* 4/4T4(? )(G ?14 /)6* #> ()?-A4H 61071 >#A@1A0*?0)(* )A4 4**4(?0)/ *#-A74* #> 1-T)( G02(0?PH >A44G#T )(G 1-T)( A021?*F<14 Bf G4I4/#C4G ?14T T#*?/P >A#T ?14 *?)?4 4(G#6T4(? )(G A4/)?0I4 *?).0/0?P0* (#? )??A0.-?4G ?# ?14TF D( A4)G0(2 ?14 7#(I4A24(74* )(G G0I4A24(74* 0( ?14-(G4A*?)(G0(2 #> ?14*4 ?1A44 >-(G)T4(?)/ 7#(74C?* #> 1-T)( G02(0?PH >A44G#T)(G 1-T)( A021?*H ) C)A?07-/)A G0>>07-/?P 0( G0)/#2-4 60?1 ?14 Bf 7#T4* >A#T?14 /)(2-)24 61071 64 -*4 ?# 4iCA4** #-A I046*F <14 ?4AT* G02(0?PH >A44G#T)(G 1-T)( A021?* T4)( *#T4?10(2 7#TC/4?4/P G0>>4A4(? 0( .#?1 ?14 @1A0*?0)()(G Bf 7#(?4i?*F <10* G0*7A4C)(7P )A#*4 .47)-*4 @1A0*?0)(0?P G4A0I4* G02(0?PH>A44G#T )(G 1-T)( A021?* >A#T ?14 ?A-?1H )(G ?10* 0* ?14 A4I4)/4G ?A-?1H 610/4?14 Bf 1)* )G#C?4G ?14 CA0(70C/4 #> >A44G#T )* 0?* *#-A74F

D? 0* C#**0./4 ?1)? 0> B-A#C4 G0G (#? >)74 ?14 CA#./4T #> A4>-244*H ?14 SA)$#6G4.)?4 6#-/G >#7-* T#A4 #( ?14 >-(G)T4(?)/ 7#(74C?* ?1)( #( ?140A CA)7?07)/)CC/07)?0#(F 3#64I4AH ?14 CA#./4T #> A4>-244* 0( (# 6)P G4?A)7?* >A#T ?14 0TYC#A?)(74 #> ?14 G4.)?4j 61)?+* T#A4H 0? 4(A0714* 0?H 7#(>0AT* 0?* A4/4I)(74 )(G)//#6* -* ?# C#0(? #-? *#T4 #> 0?* 0TC#A?)(? CA)7?07)/ )*C47?*F

<14 C)A?070C)(?* 1)I4 C#0(?4G #-? ?14 /)7$ #> A4)/0*?07 Bf C#/0704* #( A4>-Y244*H 61071H *-ACA0*4G .P ?14 *7)/4 #> ?10* C14(#T4(#(H 0* (#? )./4 ?# T44? ?14?)*$ #> A4*#/I0(2 ?14 *0?-)?0#(F M* ) A4)*#( >#A ?10* 14/C/4**(4**H ?14 C)A?070C)(?*#> ?14 7#(>4A4(74 0(G07)?4G ?1)? B-A#C4 /)7$* ?14 7#-A)24 ?1)? 6#-/G )//#6 0? ?#A4?-A( ?# 0?* @1A0*?0)( A##?*j ?# A47#2(0O4 ?14 C#64A #> *C0A0?-)/ I)/-4*H ?# A47#2Y(0O4 C4#C/4+* CA0#A0?P #I4A 47#(#T07* )(G ?# )CCA470)?4 A4/020#-* I)/-4* 0( *#70Y4?P )* 64//F "4 T-*? C-? )( 4(G ?# ?14 6)A 0( QPA0)H ?# 7)/T ?14 *0?-)?0#(H 20I4C4#C/4 ?14 #CC#A?-(0?P ?# 6#A$ )(G 4)A( 0(7#T4 >#A ?14T*4/I4* )(G ?140A >)T0Y/04*F <10* 0* ?14 #(/P 6)P #(4 7)( *?#C ?14 T02A)?0#( #> C4#C/4F

<14A4 0* (# *1#A?)24 #> 2##G 4i)TC/4* 0( ?14 6#A/G #> 7#4i0*?4(74 #> G0>>4AY4(? 7-/?-A4* )(G A4/020#(*F D( ?14 L0GG/4 B)*?H 614A4 D*/)TH 61071 0* (#? A47#2Y(0O0(2 1-T)( A021?*H G#T0()?4* ?#G)PH `4.)(#( 7#(?0(-4* ?# .4 ) .)*?0#( #>?#/4A)(74H ?1)($* ?# 0?* 7-/?-A4H ?14 @1A0*?0)( A4/020#( )(G 0?* C4)74>-/ 7#4i0*?Y4(74 ?A)G0?0#( 60?1 L-*/0T* /)*?0(2 >#A :H\99 P4)A*F D> ?10* 0* C#**0./4 ?# G# 0(`4.)(#(H 61P *1#-/G 0? (#? .4 C#**0./4 0( B-A#C4l

"4 *1#-/G (#? /#*4 1#C4 ?1)?H 0( ?10* G0>>07-/? 7A0*0* #> ?14 T#G4A( T02A)?0#(#> C4#C/4H B-A#C4 7)( )/*# C)** ?14 4i)T #> 0?* 1-T)(0?PF

!"#$%&' ) *#+,#"- ./012

W

3& 4*1 567&89:;0,&1,% )* +", 23%)4,#' 5#%6$#&,'+7

!"#$%&#' )* +", 5)6$8" 9,6,.#+$)' $' +", 255 $' +", 25

`)G04* )(G 54(?/4T4(H

c0A*? #> )//H #( .41)/> #> ?14 ,#/0*1 R4/42)?0#( #> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,4#C/4+*,)A?P 0( ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(?H D 6#-/G /0$4 ?# 4iCA4** #-A 2A)?0?-G4 >#A ?14#CC#A?-(0?P ?# C)A?070C)?4 0( #A2)(0O0(2 ?14 (4i? 7#(>4A4(74 0( SA)$#6F c#A -*H?10* 0* (#? #(/P ) 2A4)? 1#(#-AH .-? )/*# )( #CC#A?-(0?P ?# )7m-0A4 (46 $(#6/Y4G24 )(G ?# 4i71)(24 4iC4A04(74*F

<14*4 7#(>4A4(74* 0( SA)$#6 )A4 ) I4AP A)A4 4i)TC/4 #> ) T44?0(2 .4?644(C4#C/4 #> ?14 @1-A71H 0(?4//47?-)/* )(G C#/0?070)(* 61# )A4 G4)/0(2 60?1 ?14T#*? 0TC#A?)(? 0**-4* )? ?14 T#T4(? A4/)?4G ?# ?14 A#/4 #> ?14 @)?1#/07 @1-A710( ?14 CA#74** #> B-A#C4)( 0(?42A)?0#(F D(YG4C?1 G0*7-**0#(* )//#6 -* (#? #(/P?# CA#C4A/P G0)2(#*4 )(G 0G4(?0>P ) C#?4(?0)/ 7#-A*4 >#A >-A?14A G4I4/#CT4(?*H.-? )/*# ?# )()/P*4 (474**)AP #A C#**0./4 )7?0#(*F

^-*? ?)$4 ) /##$ )? /)*? P4)A+* C#*?Y7#(>4A4(74 C-./07)?0#( ?# >0(G 7#(>0AT)Y?0#( #> ?14 G0)2(#*4* CA4*4(?4G .P ?14 0(I0?4G *C4)$4A*F e#- 6#-/G *44 ?1)?H-(>#A?-()?4/PH ?14 CA4*4(?4G *74()A0#* CA4G07?4G T)** 0TT02A)?0#( )(G 0?* 7#(Y*4m-4(74*F M// #> -* 61# 64A4 14A4 ) P4)A )2# /4>? 60?1 ?14 7#(I07?0#( ?1)? 6464A4 60?(4**0(2 7#TC/4?4/P (46 CA#74**4*H #A 4I4( ) (46 A4)/0?P >#A 61071 6464A4 (#? CA4C)A4GH 61071 64 G# (#? >-//P -(G4A*?)(GH .-? 61071 64 $(#6 0*0(4I0?)./4F "4 G0*7-**4G ?1)? 0(4I0?).0/0?PH )(G ?#G)P 64 )/A4)GP $(#6 ?1)?n 0?1)* 1)CC4(4GF <#G)P 64 )*$ #-A*4/I4* )(#?14A m-4*?0#(J 1#6 G# 64 >)74 ?14(46 71)//4(24* #> T02A)?0(2 C4#C/4* )(G ?14 #(2#0(2 7#(>/07?* o*#T4 #> ?14*4C14(#T4() )A4 7#((47?4GpH )(G )? ?14 *)T4 ?0T4 6#A$ #( ?14 *1)C4 #> ?14 B-A#YC4)( f(0#( )(G 0?* /420*/)?0#(l "1)? $0(G #> #A2)(0O)?0#( 7#-/G ?14 B-A#C4)(f(0#( .4H ?1)? 7#-/G 1)(G/4 ?14 T#*? G0>>07-/? ?)*$*H )(G )? ?14 *)T4 ?0T4 (#? ?#20I4 -C 0?* -(0I4A*)/ I)/-4*l

<14 *0?-)?0#( ?#G)P 0* (#? 4)*PF M* ) ,#/0*1 C#/0?070)( 6#A$0(2 0( B-A#C4)(0(*?0?-?0#(* D 7)( *)P 60?1 )// A4*C#(*0.0/0?P ?1)? 64 0( ,#/)(GH )* ) *#704?PH G#(#? A4)/0O4 ?14 7#TC/4i0?P #> ?14 CA#./4T* B-A#C4 0* >)70(2F D? *44T* /0$4 64 )A4/0I0(2 0( )(#?14AH 0*#/)?4G 6#A/GF ,#/0*1 C-./07 G4.)?4 A4I#/I4* )A#-(G G470Y*0#(* A4/)?4G ?# ?14 A4/#7)?0#( #> I4A0>04G A4>-244*F "10/4 >)A >A#T #-A *#704?PH#?14A 7#-(?A04* )A4 >)70(2 ?14 (44G ?# 14/C ?1#*4 61# 1)I4 )/A4)GP oT#*?/P 0//4Y

X

2)//Pp 7#T4 0(?# ?140A ?4AA0?#A04* )(G 61# 60// -(G4A2# ?14 I4A0>07)?0#( )(G )*PY/-T CA#74G-A4*F R4*C0?4 ?14 T)(P 7#(74A(* ?1)? )77#TC)(P ?10* CA#74**H 64)A4 60?(4**0(2 I4AP (#./4 )??0?-G4* 7#(74A(0(2 ?14 *0TC/4*? (474**0?04* #> /0>4F

"4 >)74 ?14 m-4*?0#( #> 1#6 64H ,#/4*H C#/0?070)(*H 0(?4//47?-)/*H C4#C/4 #>?14 @1-A71 6#-/G .41)I4H 0> )? ?14 A)0/6)P *?)?0#( ?14A4 64A4 *4I4A)/ ?1#-*)(G*#> 0//42)/ 0TT02A)(?* 61# 6#-/G 4iC47? (#AT)/H 1-T)( *-CC#A?F <#G)P ?10**0?-)?0#( 0* (#? ?14#A4?07)/F

D( ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( ?6# 7#TC/4?4/P G0>>4A4(? G4.)?4* )A4 ?)$0(2 C/)74F_(4 0* A4/)?4G ?# 61)? *1#-/G .4 G#(4 ?# CA4I4(? ?14 -(7#(?A#//4G 0(>/-i #>0TT02A)(?*Hq1#6 ?# *4)/ ?14 4i?4A()/ .#AG4A* #> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( ?# 4(G ?14G4I)*?)?0(2 0TC)7? #> 6)AH 1#6 ?# 14/C 0TCA#I4 ?14 *?)(G)AG #> /0I0(2 0( ?147#-(?A04* >A#T 61071 C4#C/4 )A4 >/440(2 ?# ) CA#*C4A#-* )(G *)>4 B-A#C4F D(?14*4 7)*4*H ,#/)(G 0* ?)$0(2 ) I4AP ?#-21 *?)(74H G4T)(G0(2 *P*?4T)?07 *#/-Y?0#(*H )(G (#? #(/P *1#A?Y?4AT )7?0#(*F <14 *47#(G G4.)?4 0* (# /4** GA)T)?07)(G 0* A4/)?4G ?# 61)? ?# G# 60?1 ?1#*4 61# )/A4)GP )A4 ?14A4H $(#60(2 ?1)?)T#(2 ?14T )A4 .#?1 A4>-244* )(G 0TT02A)(?*F 3#6 G# 64 *0TC/P 14/C C4#C/40( (44Gl M >46 G)P* )2# 0( KA-**4/*H G-A0(2 ?14 )((-)/ L)** >#A B-A#C4H ?14CA04*? ?)/$4G ).#-? ?14 >)7? ?1)? ?14 G47/)A)?0#( ?# 14/C #(/P @1A0*?0)(* 0* 4**4(Y?0)//P ) C)A#GP #> @1A0*?0)(0?PF <14*4 6#AG* 64A4 *C#$4( 0( ) 70?P 614A4 4I4APG)P #( ?14 A)G0# ?14A4 )A4 A4C4)?4G )CC4)/* >#A 14/C ?# C4#C/4 7)TC0(2 0( C)A$*60?1#-? .)*07 /0I0(2 7#(G0?0#(*H A4m-4*?* >#A )GT0**0#( ?# ?140A 1#T4* 4I4( >#A) >46 G)P*F

<14*4 ?6# G4.)?4* )A4 ) >A)2T4(? #> -(G4A*?)(G0(2 #> B-A#C4)( 0(?42A)?0#(HT-?-)/ *-CC#A?H ) 7#TT#( A4*C#(*4 ?# (46 71)//4(24* )(G ?14 CA)7?07)/ )CC/0Y7)?0#( #> ?14 CA0(70C/4 #> *#/0G)A0?PF D? 0* 0TC#A?)(? ?1)? 64 *1#-/G 1)I4 /0*?4(4G?# ?14 7/0T)?4 #> ?14*4 G4.)?4*H .47)-*4 ?14P )A4 A4/)?4G ?# #-A B-A#C4 )(G -*B-A#C4)(*F

<14A4 )A4 )/*# ?14 I#074* ?1)? *#-(G C)A?07-/)A/P *?A#(2F M* ) L4T.4A #> ?14B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(?H D 6)* ) 60?(4** #> 3#/P c)?14A cA)(70*+ CA4*4(?)?0#( .4Y>#A4 ?10* )-G04(74F <10* 6)* ?14 *47#(G 10*?#A07 *C4471 20I4( .P ?14 14)G #> ?14=#T)( @)?1#/07 @1-A71 0( ?14 10*?#AP #> ,)A/0)T4(? h ?14 >0A*? 6)* #> 7#-A*4^#1( ,)-/ DDF ,#C4 cA)(70* *C#$4 ?6074 0( Q?A)*.#-A2j 14 *C#$4 )? ?14 B-A#C4)(,)A/0)T4(? )(G )? ?14 @#-(70/ #> B-A#C4F 30* *C4471 )? ?14 B-A#C4)( @#-(70/6)* G0>>4A4(?/P 7#(*?A-7?4GH CA#.)./P ?)$0(2 0(?# )77#-(? ?14 ()?-A4 #> ?14 #AY2)(0O)?0#( )(G 0?* 60G4AY?1)(Y?14YBf T4T.4A*10CF M>?4A 10* *C4471 ?# B-A#C4Y)( C)A/0)T4(?)A0)(* 0( ?14 A##TH 14 2#? ) *?#AT #> )CC/)-*4 )(G ?14( ) *?)(G0(2#I)?0#( >A#T )// C#/0?07)/ 2A#-C*H 61071 1)G ?# .4 *?#CC4G )? *#T4 C#0(?F

"1P *-71 )( #I)?0#(l D( >)7?H ) /)A24 C)A? #> ?14 )-G04(74 G0*)2A44G 60?1 ?143#/P c)?14A+* 4(?0A4 *C4471H #A 60?1 0?* >A)2T4(?*F D? ?-A(4G #-? ?1)? 4I4AP#(4A4)/0O4G ?1)? ) CA04*? 7)T4H ?14 14)G #> ?14 @1-A71 h (#? ?14 CA04*? 61# )7?* /0$4

V

) C#/0?070)( #A ) C#/0?070)( 61# .41)I4* /0$4 ) CA04*?F M (#AT)/H 1#(4*? )(G 24(Y-0(4 T)( 61# ?4//* ?14 ?A-?1F 34 *)P* 61)? 14 ?10($*H A42)AG/4** #> 614?14A 10*/0*?4(4A* )2A44 60?1 10T #A (#?F 34 ?)/$* ).#-? G02(0?PH ).#-? ?A)(*74(G4(74H).#-? 61)? 0* 2##GH ).#-? 61)? 0* 6A#(2 oA)?14A ?1)( 61)? 0* 7#(*0G4A4G r.)GspFQ#T4?0T4* 14 7A0?070O4*H *)P* /021?/PH 7#TC)A0(2 ?14 Bf ?# ?14 2A)(GT#?14A ?#?14 4/G4A/P o-*0(2 *PTC)?14?07 ?4AT +%++#pF 34 *)P* A4CA#)71>-//P ?# ?14 G4C-Y?04*J !e#- )A4 )// ?0A4G+j 0?+* ) .0? /0$4 *)P0(2H !")$4 -C )(G *?)A? 6#A$0(2F+,)A/0)T4(? /0*?4(4G )??4(?0I4/P )(G >4AI4(?/P ?1)($4G 10T >#A ?14 ?A-4H *0(74A4)(G 2##GY60//4G )??0?-G4F

,)A/0)T4(? 0*H /0$4 )// 7#TT-(0?04* #> ?14 L4T.4A Q?)?4*H G0I0G4G #( T#A)/H4?107)/ )(G 0G4#/#207)/ 0**-4*F _-A G4/42)?0#( #> ?14 ,_Y,Q` o@0I0/ ,/)?>#AT)(G ?14 ,#/0*1 ,4)*)(?*+ ,)A?Pp 7#)/0?0#( 0* )/*# G0I0G4GF K-? 64 )// A4)/0O4 ?14*4A0#-*(4** #> ?14 *0?-)?0#( )(G $(#6 1#6 0TC#A?)(? ?14 A#/4 #> ?14 =#T)(@)?1#/07 @1-A71 0* 0( ?14 4(?0A4 CA#74** #> B-A#C4)( 0(?42A)?0#(F <1)? 0* 61P 64)A4 14A4H )* ) G4/42)?0#(H ?# C)A?070C)?4 0( ?14*4 *4A0#-* )(G G0>>07-/? G4.)?4*F

<14 SA)$#6 @#(>4A4(74* )A4 ) C/)74 >#A A4)/H .A)I4H )(G *0(74A4 7#(I4A*)Y?0#(H *0T0/)A ?# 61)? 64 4iC4A04(74G 0( ?14 ,)A/0)T4(?F

"4H ?14 C#/0?070)(*H 1)I4 7#T4 ?# 2)0( $(#6/4G24H ?# 7#(>A#(? #-A 4iC4A0Y4(74* )(G I046*H )(G ?# 4(A071 #-A*4/I4* 60?1 (46 )A2-T4(?* )(G *-224*?0#(*>#A C#**0./4 )7?0#(*F

<14*4 7#(>4A4(74* )A4 (#? #(/P (44G4GH .-?H )* 0? *44T*H )A4 .47#T0(2 0(Y7A4)*0(2/P (474**)AP >#A ,#/)(G )(G B-A#C4F

Welcome and Opening

:Z

<*&+01*6 3& =;*10.>*? 3/0?0./:", ;%<"1$8")4 )* =%#>)?

c#A ?14 :[?1 ?0T4 #-A 1#(#-A)./4 2-4*?* )A4 T44?0(2 ?# G0*7-** ?14 A#/4 #>?14 @)?1#/07 @1-A71 0( ?14 B-A#C4)( 0(?42A)?0#( CA#74**F <#G)PH B-A#C4)( *#Y704?PH .#?1 C#/0?07)/ )(G 7-/?-A)/H 0* >)70(2 ) *4A0#-* 71)//4(24F

,#/0?07)//PH )// )A4 )*$0(2 1#6 ?# A4*#/I4 CA#./4T #> ?14 (4I4AY4(G0(2 ?0G4 #>A4>-244* 4(?4A0(2 B-A#C4F @-/?-A)//PH ?14A4 0* ?14 0TC#A?)(? 0**-4 #> !B-A#C4)(k)/-4*+ 0( ?14 >)74 #> 0(>/-4(74 >A#T D*/)T )(G L-*/0T 7-/?-A4*F <14 *-.N47? #>?#G)P+* G0*7-**0#(H !R02(0?P h c>A44G#T h 3-T)( =021?*+H 2#4* .)7$ ?# ?14>-(G)T4(?)/ I)/-4* )(G ?1#*4 I)/-4* *1#-/G .4 ?14 *#-A74 0( #-A *4)A71 >#A*#/-?0#(*F ,4A*#()//PH D 6#-/G )GG )(#?14A )*C47? h ?A-?1 h ?1)? *1#-/G .4 ?14*?)A?0(2 C#0(? #> #-A ?)/$*F D? 0* ) 7)AG0()/ I)/-4j 0? 0* ?14 .)*0* >#A C4A*#()/ >A44YG#TH >A44G#T #> 4iCA4**0#(H )(G ?14 A021? #> ()?0#(* ?# 0(G4C4(G4(74F "0?1#-??14*4 .)*07 A021?*H >A44G#T 60// /#*4 ?# C#/0?07)/ 7#AA47?(4** )(G 0(*?4)G #> ?14G0>>07-/? C-A*-0? #> ?A-?1H 64 6#-/G *44 G44C4(0(2 G0I0*0#(*F

D( ?1)? )*C47?H ?14 I#074 #> ?14 @)?1#/07 @1-A71 A4T0(G* -* ?1)? ?14 0TC#AY?)(74 #> @1A0*?0)( I)/-4* 7)((#? .4 )I#0G4GF ,#C4 cA)(70* ?)/$4G ).#-? 0? /)*?P4)A 610/4 )GGA4**0(2 ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( ,)A/0)T4(?F <14 3#/P c)?14A G4Y*7A0.4G ?14 A#/4 #> B-A#C4 )* ) !7)?)/P*?+ #> C#*0?0I4 71)(24F <14 0TC#A?)(? A4Ym-0A4T4(? 60// .4 ?# 2# .)7$ ?# ?14 A##?* #> ?14 B-A#C4)( >#-(G0(2 >)?14A*H 61#G4*0A4G ) B-A#C4 -(0?4G 0( 7##C4A)?0#( )(G ?A-4 *#/0G)A0?PH .#?1 0(?4A()//P )(G#C4( ?# #?14A*F D( ?1#*4 6#AG*H #(4 7#-/G *44 ?14 ,#C4+* 7A0?070*T #> B-A#C4 )*71)(20(2 0(?# ) .-A4)-7A)?07 T)710(4H 614A4 ?A-*? 0( T)( 0* .40(2 A4C/)74G .P(-T4A#-* (#AT* )(G A42-/)?0#(* )(G B-A#C4)( 0(?42A)?0#( *4AI4* C#/0?070)(*H(#? 0?* 70?0O4(*F

<14 I#074 #> B-A#C4)(* 6#AA04G ).#-? ?14 64//Y.40(2 #> ?140A ()?0#(*H ?1464//Y.40(2 #> ?140A 1#T4/)(G*H T-*? (#? .4 02(#A4G (#A *1#-/G 0? .4 C4A740I4G)* !()?0#()/0*?07+ #A 7#(*0G4A4G !>)*70*T+F ,#C4 cA)(70* -*4G ?14 !M?14(* Q71##/+C10/#*#C1P #> L)*?4A =)C1)4/ )* ) *0TC/4 4i)TC/4F M// #A2)(0O)?0#(* ?1)? *?44A)6)P >A#T G0I0(4 #A 1-T)( I)/-4* *##(4A #A /)?4A /4)G ?# *?)2()?0#( )(G ()AYA#6YT0(G4G(4**F <#G)PH B-A#C4 0* >)70(2 ) T-71 T#A4 *4A0#-* CA#./4T ?1)(0TT02A)?0#( h 0? 0* ?14 /)7$ #> 7#-A)24 ?# 2# .)7$ ?# 0?* A##?* )(G ?14 G4*?A-7?0I40(>/-4(74* #> )(?0Y@1A0*?0)( #A2)(0O)?0#(*F <14 7#(*4m-4(74 #> ?1)? T)P .4 ?14/#** #> B-A#C4+* C#*0?0#( )* ) C/)74 ?1)? 0(*C0A4* ?14 6#A/GF

R0*7#I4A0(2 ?14 0TC#A?)(74 #> ?14 *#-/ 7#-/G .4 ?14 A4T4GP ?# B-A#C4+*64)$(4** )(G G0*4)*4H ) !C4#C/4 .4>#A4 CA#>0?+ )??0?-G4 )(G A4G0*7#I4A0(2 A4/0Y

:\

20#-* I)/-4* 0( ?14 /0I4* #> 7#TT-(0?04*F D? 0* 6#A?1 T4(?0#(0(2 ?1)? 614( ?14,#C4 *C#$4 ?# 8X C)A/0)T4(?)A0)(* >A#T ?14 64)/?104*? ()?0#(* #> #-A 7#(?0(4(?H14 6)* )CC/)-G4GF "4A4 ?14P 7#-A?4*P #I)?0#(* #A G0G ?14 /4)G4A* )774C? ?147#(74C? ?1)? #(/P ) B-A#C4 60?1 A4/020#-* A##?* 0* )./4 ?# >021? T#G4A( 4i?A4TY0*?*l R0G ?14P -(G4A*?)(G ?14 >-?0/0?P #> >021?0(2 )2)0(*? 4I4AP?10(2 ?1)? 1)*@1A0*?0)( I)/-4 60?10( ?14 *?A-7?-A4* #> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(l

"4 (44G ?# A4.-0/G #-A B-A#C4)( *C0A0?-)/ 0G4(?0?P )(G 0(?42A0?PH )/*# 0( ?147#(?4i? #> 0TT02A)?0#(F ^-*? )>?4A ?14 (46 T0//4((0-TH #( ?14 G)P #> ?14 A4>-244)(G 0TT02A)(?H Q? ^#1( ,)-/ DDH 0( 899ZH 6A#?4J !<14 CA4*4(74 #> (#(Y@1A0*?0)(*0( 7#-(?A04* #> @1A0*?0)( #A020( 0* ) 71)//4(24 >#A 71-A71 7#TT-(0?04*F D? .A0(2*?14 (44G >#A 7#TC)**0#(H 1#*C0?)/0?P )(G 14/C >#A .A#?14A* )(G *0*?4A* /##$0(2>#A 6#A$ )(G 1#-*0(2F D( *#T4 6)P* 0? 0* )( )7?0I0?P *0T0/)A ?# ?1)? #> T0**0#()AY04* 0( >#A402( 7#-(?A04*H 614A4 ?14P ?)$4 7)A4 #> ?14 *07$H C##A )(G 0//0?4A)?4F<10* 0* ?14 )7?0#( #> >#//#64A* #> @1A0*?J -(G4A*?)(G ?14 (44G* )(G 4iC47?)?0#(*#> ?1#*4 *->>4A0(2 C#I4A?PF K-? ?14 T)0( 2#)/ #> ?14 T0**0#( 0* G4/0I4A0(2 ?14?4)710(2* #> @1A0*? )(G 10* 2#*C4/F <14 @1-A71 0* )6)A4 ?1)? *CA4)G0(2 ^4*-*+2#*C4/ 0* ?14 >0A*? )7? #> 7#TC)**0#( ?#6)AG* ?14 1-T)( .40(2H T#A4 0TC#A?)(??1)( )(P #?14A 24*?-A4 #> T)2()(0T0?PF <14A4 0* (# ?A-4 4I)(24/0O)?0#( 60?1#-??14 ?4)710(2* #> ^4*-*+ /0>4 )(G CA#T0*4* #> 30* S0(2G#T )(G ?14 TP*?070*T #>^4*-* #> U)O)A4?1H Q#( #> 5#GF+

D 60*1 )// C)A?070C)(?* #> ?14 7#(>4A4(74 #( G02(0?PH >A44G#T )(G 1-T)(A021?* ?# *?)P >#7-*4G #( ?14 G44C4*? A##?* #> ?14 7-AA4(? 0**-4*H 60?1#-? ?AP0(2?# *0TC/P CA#C#*4 4)*P *#/-?0#(* ?# G0>>07-/? CA#./4T*F R# (#? .4 )>A)0G #> ?14?A-?1 ?1)? /4)G* ?# ?14 G0*7#I4AP #> ?14 !7#A4 T4)(0(2+F `4? ?14 6#AG* #> ,#C4 Q?^#1( ,)-/ DD .4 ) A4T0(G4A ?1)? ?14 !5#*C4/ #> ^4*-* 0* ?14 >0A*? )7? #> 7#TC)*Y*0#( ?#6)AG* T)(H T#A4 0TC#A?)(? ?1)( )(P #?14A 24*?-A4 #> T)2()(0T0?P+F D 1#C4?1)? #-A )((-)/ T44?0(2 60// (#? 4(G )* #(/P ) 2A#-C .A)0(*?#AT ).#-? ?14 CA#.Y/4T* #> #-A 7#(?0(4(?H .-? ?1)? 0? 60// /4)G ?# CA)7?07)/ *#/-?0#(*F

:[

3& <:&0.;0*1 =9:@0;/9$%,<+)% )* +", =)'%#@ ;@,'#3,% A)3'@#+$)' $' 5)6#'@

c#A T4 0? 0* ) 2A4)? N#P ?# .4 )./4 ?# 64/7#T4 P#- #( .41)/> #> ?14 S#(A)GMG4()-4A c#-(G)?0#( )? ?10* P4)A+* 7#(>4A4(74 #( ?14 !=#/4 #> ?14 @)?1#/07@1-A71 0( ?14 ,A#74** #> B-A#C4)( D(?42A)?0#(+F ,/4)*4 /4? T4 0(7/-G4 ) >46C4A*#()/ A4>/47?0#(* #( ?10* P4)A+* 7#(>4A4(74H 61071 60// ?)$4 C/)74 -(G4A ?14T#??#J !R02(0?P h cA44G#T h 3-T)( =021?*+F

<14 7#(>4A4(74 -(G4A ?10* ?14T4H ?)$0(2 C/)74 G-A0(2 ?10* ?0T4 )(G 1)I0(2) B-A#C4)( 7#(?4i?H #> 7#-A*4H A)0*4* ?14 4iC47?)?0#( ?1)? 0? 60// CA0T)A0/P G4)/60?1 #(4 *-.N47?J ?14 0(?4A()?0#()/ A4>-244 7A0*0*F D? )>>47?* -* 0( ?14*4 G)P* 0( 0?*>-// GA)T)?07 G0T4(*0#(F <10* ?#C07 T#I4* -* 1-T)(/P )(G 0* )/*# ) C)A?07-/)A71)//4(24 ?# C#/0?07*F `##$0(2 )? ?14 C4#C/4H 64 $(#6 ?1)? !1-T)( G02(0?P 0*0()/04()./4H+ ?1)? 0? *1#-/G .4 !A4I4A4G )(G CA#?47?4G+F <10* 0* 4(*1A0(4G 0( ?14@1)A?4A #> c-(G)T4(?)/ =021?*F

D( ) C#/0?07)/ *4(*4H ?14 7-AA4(? *0?-)?0#( A4m-0A4* ?1)? 64 B-A#C4)(*H >#A61#T ?14 >-(G)T4(?)/ I)/-4* )A4 >A44G#TH N-*?074 )(G *#/0G)A0?PH )(*64A .)*07m-4*?0#(* ).#-? .A#?14A1##G )(G *#/0G)A0?PF <10* *0?-)?0#( C-?* B-A#C4 ?1A#-21) ?4*? ?1)? 7)( G4?4AT0(4 ?14 7#TT#( >-?-A4 #> B-A#C4F <14 A4>-244 7A0*0* 7)(C#**0./P G0I0G4 ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( C4AT)(4(?/P )(G ?1A4)?4( 7#TT#( )7104I4YT4(?* )(G *-774**4*F 3#64I4AH D G44C/P .4/04I4 ?1)?H )* B-A#C4)(*H 64 )A4 (#?2#0(2 ?# /#*4 )(G 4I4(?-)//P 64 60// 4I4( 7#T4 #-? *?A4(2?14(4G >A#T ?10* 7A0Y*0*F M>?4A )//H B-A#C4)( 0(?42A)?0#( )(G ?14 -(0>07)?0#( #> 54AT)(P 8[ P4)A* )2#)/*# *44T4G ?# .4 ) ?)*$ 6#A?1P #> 34A7-/4* )(G 0( CA)7?074 -(0T)20()./4F K-??1A#-21 ) 7#(74A?4G 4>>#A? 64 1)I4 T)()24G ?# /)P ?14 >#-(G)?0#( *?#(4 >#A>-A?14A B-A#C4)( 0(?42A)?0#(H )(G ?#G)P 64 7)( 4(N#P ) m-)A?4A #> ) 74(?-AP #>54AT)( -(0?PF "4 7)( )/*# /##$ 60?1 CA0G4 )? ?14 7#TT#( )7104I4T4(?* #>A474(? P4)A*H 61071 64 >44/ T#A4 #A /4** 7#(*70#-*/PF "1)? 64 (44G (#6)G)P*)A4J G44C >)0?1H 7#-A)24 )(G *#/0G)A0?PH )* 64// )* ?14 >-// )6)A4(4** ?1)? #-ACA4*4(? C)?1H 60?1 0?* 71)//4(24*H G0G (#? )/6)P* 2# *T##?1/P 40?14AF <10* 0*61)? c4G4A)/ @1)(74//#A LA* M(24/) L4A$4/ T4)(? 614( *14 *)0G ?# ?14 >4)AY)(G -(74A?)0(?PY*?A07$4( C4#C/4 0( 54AT)(PJ !"0A *71)>>4( G)*+ h !"4 60//T)()24+F D> )(P#(4 6)(?* ?# 7A0?070O4 14A >#A ?14*4 6#AG*H ?14P *1#-/G )/*# )*$614?14A @1A0*?0)( I)/-4* /0$4 G02(0?P )(G 1-T)( A021?* )A4 -(0I4A*)/ I)/-4*H #A7)( ?14P .4 (42#?0)?4GH 0(?4ACA4?4G #A *-*C4(G4GF

`)G04* )(G 54(?/4T4(H ?10* P4)A 64 )A4 T44?0(2 )? ?10* 7#(>4A4(74 )/A4)GP>#A ?14 :[?1 ?0T4F `4?+* *?4C #( ?10* C)?1 )2)0( )(G ?A4)? ?14 7#(7/-*0#(* A4*-/?Y

:;

0(2 >A#T #-A G4/0.4A)?0#(* )* )( 0(*C0A)?0#( ?# >0(G 0( #-A*4/I4* ?14 >)0?1 )(G ?14*?A4(2?1 (44G4G ?# T44? ?14 71)//4(24* )14)G #> -* ?#24?14AF

<10* P4)A D )2)0( )GGA4** 6#AG* #> 2A)?0?-G4 >#A #-A I)/-)./4 7##C4A)?0#(?#6)AG* #-A C)A?(4A*J ?14 ,#(?0>07)/ f(0I4A*0?P #> ^#1( ,)-/ DD 0( SA)$#6H ?14=#.4A? Q71-T)( c#-(G)?0#( 0( ̀ -i4T.#-A2H ?14 B-A#C4)( ,4#C/4+* ,)A?P 5A#-C#> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,4#C/4+* ,)A?P 0( ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(?H ?14 ,#/0*1 R4/42)Y?0#( 0( ?14 B,, 0( ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(?H ?14 !"#$%& ()*+ C-./0*10(2 1#-*4H)* 64// #-A T4G0) C)A?(4A* 3-4%5+6$ 7%&89:;<+- )(G S)?#/07$) M24(7N) D(>#AYT)7PN() o?14 @)?1#/07 D(>#AT)?0#( M24(7Pp )(G ?14 @#TT0**0#( #> ?14 K0*1Y#C* #> ?14 B-A#C4)( @#TT-(0?PF

D 6#-/G )/*# /0$4 ?# ?1)($ ?14 L)A*1)/ #> `4**4A ,#/)(GH LA L)A4$ Q#6)H>#A )// #> 10* *-CC#A? 0( #A2)(0O0(2 ?10* 7#(>4A4(74F <1)($ P#- >#A P#-A )??4(?0#()(G D 60*1 -* )// 0(?4A4*?0(2 G4.)?4* )(G ) >A-0?>-/ 4i71)(24 #> I046*F

:W

A'&.; B*1C,.B)')%#%C !"#$%&#'

)* +", D)1,%+ E<"3&#'' A)3'@#+$)' $' F3G,&1)3%.

`)G04* )(G 54(?/4T4(H

"14( D )??4(G4G T)** /)*? Q-(G)PH D 6)* ?10($0(2 #> 61)? ?# *)P 14A4 0(SA)$#6 G-A0(2 TP 2A44?0(2 *C4471F D 6)(?4G ?# T4(?0#( ?1)? ?14 _A2)(0O0(2@#TT0??44 )? ?14 ,#(?0>07)/ f(0I4A*0?P 0( SA)$#6H G0A47?#A Q71T0?O #> ?14 S#(YA)G MG4()-4A c#-(G)?0#(H )(G -* >A#T ?14 =#.4A? Q71-T)( c#-(G)?0#( 0( `-iY4T.#-A2 4I)/-)?4G ?14 0**-4* 64 )A4 >)70(2 ?#G)PJ G02(0?PH >A44G#T )(G 1-T)(A021?*F D )/*# 6)(?4G ?# ?4// P#- 1#6 2##G )(G )-?14(?07 #-A 4>>#A?* 64A4F

D( 71-A71H D A4)/0O4G ?1)? 0? 6)* ?14 710/GA4(+* Q-(G)PF K4>#A4 TP 4P4* )CYC4)A4G ?14 0T)24* #> ?14 QPA0)( A4>-244* ?1)? RA Q71T0?O 1)* N-*? T4(?0#(4GF<6# #> ?14T *1##$ ?14 61#/4 6#A/Gj D T4)( ?14 #(4 >A#T 3-(2)APH 614A4 )>)?14A 0* 1#/G0(2 10* 710/G 0( 10* )AT* )(G ) >)AYA021? 60(2 3-(2)A0)( *?-G4(?C-?* #-? 10* /42 ?# ?A0C 10T )(G 14 0* CA#?47?0(2 10* 710/G 610/4 >)//0(2F BI4(6#A*4 6)* ?14 C07?-A4 #> ) 710/GH >#-A P4)A* #/GH /P0(2 #( ) <-A$0*1 .4)71H )* 0>)*/44CH .-? 14 6)* G4)GF 34 >4// >A#T #(4 #> ?14*4 *T)// .#)?* )(G GA#6(4GF

D )T ) /)PT)(H .-? D 6#-/G /0$4 ?# m-#?4 ?14 5#*C4/ >A#T ?1)? !@10/GA4(+*Q-(G)P+F "4 A4)G ?14A4 ?1)? ^4*-* @1A0*? 6)* 6)/$0(2 60?1 10* MC#*?/4* )(G?#/G ?14TJ !D 60// .4 $0//4G .-? )>?4A ?1A44 G)P* D 60// A0*4 >A#T ?14 G4)G+F <14P7#(?0(-4G 6)/$0(2 )(G ?14( ?14P *)? G#6( 0( ) 70A7/4 )(G 34 )*$4GJ !"1)? 64A4P#- ?)/$0(2 ).#-?l+ <14P *)0GJ !"4 64A4 6#(G4A0(2 61# 60// .4 P#-A *-774**#A614( P#- )A4 2#(4+l <14A4 6)* ) ?)/$ ).#-? 61# 6#-/G .4 0( C#64A 0( ?14>-?-A4 71-A71F M(G 14 )(*64A4GJ !D G# (#? 6)(? ?# N-G24 P#-+F 34 ?##$ ) 710/G 0(10* )AT*H C-? 10T G#6( 0( ?14 T0GG/4 #> ?10* 70A7/4 )(G *)0GJ !D> ?10* 710/G 0*?A4)?4G 64//H 0? 0* )* 0> P#- )A4 ?A4)?0(2 T4 64//H .-? 0> P#- ?A4)? 10T .)G/PH P#-)A4 ?A4)?0(2 T4 .)G/PF+ <10* 0* 61)? P#- *1#-/G *?A0I4 >#A (#6F

@)AG0()/ RO060*O 1)* 7#AA47?/P C#0(?4G #-? ?1)? 64 64A4 >)70(2 G0>>07-/??)*$*F ^4*-* ?##$ ?14 710/GF ")* 0? ?14 @1A0*?0)( 6)P #A ?14 D*A)4/0 6)PH #A 6)*?10* ) 710/G >A#T Q)T)A0)H #A T)P.4 >A#T 5)/0/44H #A 6)* ?10* 4I4( )( B2PC?0)(710/Gl ^4*-* G0G (#? G4>0(4 ?10*F <14 ,#C4 )/*# 7)//4G #( 10* G0#74*4 ?# ?)$4 0(?14 A4>-244*F <14*4 )A4 (#? N-*? @1A0*?0)(* ?1)? 64 *1#-/G ?)$4 0( (#A )A4 ?14*4#(/P @)?1#/07*F D G# (#? $(#6 614A4 14 6#-/G ?)$4 ?14T >A#TF D> ?14P )A4 0( ?146)?4AH /4? ?1#*4 61# )A4 @1A0*?0)(* A)0*4 ?140A 1)(G*F K-? 61)? ).#-? ?14 #?14A*l

:X

"4 )A4 0( ) *0?-)?0#( 614A4 ?14 ?A-?1 60// 7#T4 #-?H 614?14A 0? 6)* ?A-4 61)? ?14>#-(G0(2 >)?14A* #> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( *)0G ?1)? 64 1)I4 @1A0*?0)( >#-(G)Y?0#(*F U#6 64 1)I4 ?# >0(G ?14 *#/-?0#( ?# 14/C C4#C/4j ?# 14/C 710/GA4( 61# )A4GP0(2F

R-A0(2 ?14*4 ?6# G)P* #-A T0**0#( 0* ?# T)$4 ,#/4*H 54AT)(*H 3-(2)A0)(*)(G #?14A* A4)/0O4 ?1)? 64 7)( G# 0? ?#24?14AH .-? 64 T-*? 1)I4 ?14 7#-A)24 ?#*)P !P4*H 64 60// G# 0?+F M(G /4?+* (#? G0I0G4 T)??4A* 0(?# !Q/)I07+ #A !54AT)(Y07+H .-? 64 )* @1A0*?0)(* >0A*? 1)I4 ) G-?P ?# G# *#T4?10(2 ).#-? ?10* T)??4AF

:V

D*&,2 ='?*0#%8"#6 )* F,88,% 5)6#'@

D )T 1#(#-A4G ?1)? `4**4A ,#/)(G 1)* .44( 1#*?0(2 ?10* 7#(>4A4(74 >#A :[P4)A* )(G ?14A4.P 7#(?A0.-?0(2 ?# ) G0)/#2-4 .4?644( ?6# I4AP 0TC#A?)(? 7#TYT-(0?04* ?1)? 0(>/-4(74 4)71 #?14A )(G ?1)? 64 .-0/G ?#24?14AJ ?14 @)?1#/07 @1-A71)(G ?14 7#TT-(0?P #> B-A#C4)( 70?0O4(*F

<14 ?#C07 #> ?10* P4)A+* 7#(>4A4(74 0* ) $0(G #> A4?-A( ?# ?14 A##?* )(G ?# ?14>#-(G)?0#( #> .#?1 ?14 @1-A71 )(G -(0?4G B-A#C4F K)7$ ?# ?14 T#*? >-(G)T4(Y?)/ I)/-4*J G02(0?PH >A44G#T )(G A4*C47? >#A 1-T)( A021?*F D? 0* 4i?A4T4/P 0TC#AY?)(? ?1)? G-A0(2 ?10* -(G#-.?4G/P G0>>07-/? ?0T4H G-A0(2 ) ?0T4 614( )// #> B-YA#C4 0* -(G4A2#0(2 ) 2A4)? ?A0)/H ?1)? 64 A4?-A( ?# ?14 .420((0(2*F "14( h G4Y*C0?4 #-A 4>>#A?* h T)(P m-4*?0#(* *?0// A4T)0( -()(*64A4GH ?14 .4*? 6)P ?# >0(G) *#/-?0#( 0* ?# A4?-A( ?# ?14 #A020(*H .47)-*4 #(/P ?14P T)P .47#T4 ) .4)7#( #>?14 >-?-A4 >#A -*F

QC4)$0(2 #> G02(0?PH >A44G#T )(G 1-T)( A021?*H 0? 0* 0TC#**0./4 (#? ?# T4(Y?0#( ?14 )7104I4T4(?* #> 2A4)? C4#C/4 >A#T `4**4A ,#/)(GF c0A*? #> )//H ?14)7104I4T4(?* #> ,#C4 ^#1( ,)-/ DDH 61# C4A740I4G ?14 *4(*0.0/0?P #> B-A#C4)(0(?42A)?0#( 0( ?14*4 I)/-4*F M77#AG0(2 ?# 10TH G02(0?P )(G >A44G#T )A4 ?147#TT#( G4(#T0()?#A >#A )// B-A#C4)( ()?0#(*H A42)AG/4** #> 7-/?-A)/ G0>>4AY4(74*F

D? 0* )/*# 6#A?1 T4(?0#(0(2 )(#?14A 2A4)? C4A*#( >A#T `4**4A ,#/)(GJ c)?14A,A#>4**#A ^#O4> <0*71(4AF D( 10* #C0(0#(H !)*$0(2 ).#-? ?14 T4)(0(2 #> 1-T)(G02(0?P 1)* .47#T4 ?14 m-4*?0#( #> #-A ?0T4 onpj 64 A4)71 >#A ?10* 7#(74C? )*?14 7#A(4A*?#(4 #( 61071 ?# .-0/G ?14 4G0>074 #> T#A)/ /0>4+F M/?1#-21 ?14*46#AG* 64A4 6A0??4( )/T#*? Z9 P4)A* )2#H (#.#GP 7)( G4(P ?1)? ?14P )A4 *?0//I)/0G ?#G)PF

c)?14A ^#O4> <0*71(4A 6)* #(/P :: P4)A* P#-(24A ?1)( ^#1( ,)-/ DDF K#?164A4 C10/#*#C14A* 60?1 I4AP *?A#(2 A4/020#-* >#-(G)?0#(*F K#?1 G470G4G ?# .4Y7#T4 CA04*?*F <14 ?6# )/*# *1)A4G ) *0T0/)A 4iC4A04(74J >0A*? ?14 4iC4A04(74 #>6)A )(G ?14 1-T0/0)?0#( #> T)( .P U)O0 54AT)(PH ?14( ?14 4iC4A04(74 #> ?#?)/Y0?)A0)(0*T 0( ?14 ,4#C/4+* =4C-./07 #> ,#/)(GF <14*4 *P*?4T* *?A0CC4G ) T)( #>G02(0?PH G4CA0I4G 10T #> >A44G#T )(G G4(04G 10T ?14 T#*? .)*07 A021?*F ,4A1)C*?10* 0* 61P .#?1 ?14*4 ?10($4A* *)6 *#T4?10(2 ).*#/-?4/P >-(G)T4(?)/H 0()/04(Y)./4 )(G -(G4(0)./4 0( ?14 G02(0?P )(G >A44G#T #> T)(F

D 2A46 -C (4)A M-*7160?OH 0( ?14 *1)G#6 #> ) *C470)/ C/)74J ?14 54AT)(U)O0 @#(74(?A)?0#( )(G Bi?4AT0()?0#( @)TC )? M-*7160?OYK0A$4()-F <10* C/)74

89

0* ) >#AT0G)./4 60?(4** ?# 10*?#AP ?1)? *1#6* 61)? 1)CC4(* 614( C4#C/4 .4?A)PI)/-4* *-71 )* 1-T)( G02(0?P )(G >A44G#TF <10* C/)74 0* ) 6)A(0(2 ?# >-?-A424(4A)?0#(*H .-? )/*# 1)* 1#C4 h ?14 1#C4 ?1)? )* ) 7#TT-(0?P #> B-A#C4)(* 64/4)A(4G ) CA#C4A /4**#( >A#T #-A 10*?#AP )(G ?1)? ?10* 10*?#AP 60// (4I4A A4C4)?0?*4/>F <10* T4**)24 7#T4* >A#T M-*7160?OH *PT.#/07)//P 7)//4G ?14 @0?P #>,4)74F R02(0?P )(G >A44G#T )A4 ?14 C0//)A* #> C4)74 0( B-A#C4 )(G 0( ?14 6#A/GF<14P )A4 ?14 >#-(G)?0#(* #> *#/0G)A0?P .4?644( C4#C/4F K4)A0(2 0( T0(G ?14 (#?*# )(704(? 10*?#APH -(G4A (# 70A7-T*?)(74* *1#-/G 64 /#*4 *021? #> ?14*4 I)/-4*F<14P *1#-/G .4 ?14 .)*0* #> 4I4AP G470*0#( ?1)? 4I4AP B-A#C4)( )(G 4I4AP @)?1Y#/07 T)$4* ?#G)PF <14P )A4 ?14 2-)A)(?44 #> #-A 7#TT#( >-?-A4F

8:

E8F&C8 AF6GH1800,&1,% )* +", 23%)4,#' 5#%6$#&,'+

!D? 0* (#? T)/074H .-? 1-T)( 64)$(4**?1)? T#*? G44C/P G0*?#A?* )(G G42A)G4* 1-T)( G02(0?PF+

c0A*?H D 6#-/G /0$4 ?# 4iCA4** 1#6 C/4)*4G D )T ?1)? 64 )A4 #(74 )2)0( 2)?1Y4A4G )? ?14 SA)$#6 @#(>4A4(74 ?# G0*7-** ?14 ?#C07* #> 1-T)( G02(0?PH >A44G#T)(G 1-T)( A021?*F D )T 1#(#-A4G ?# 1)I4 ?14 #CC#A?-(0?P ?# A4CA4*4(? ?14 71)0AYT)( #> TP #A2)(0O)?0#(H L)(>A4G "4.4AF ,/4)*4H )774C? 10* .4*? A42)AG*F <14B-A#C4)( ,4#C/4*+ ,)A?P 0* ?14 #(/P #(4 ?1)? 1)* .44( 4(2)24G 0( G0)/#2-4 60?1@1A0*?0)( 71-A714* o_A?1#G#iH @)?1#/07 )(G ,A#?4*?)(?p )(G 60?1 ?14 /4)G4A* #>D*/)T07 )(G ^460*1 #A2)(0O)?0#(* )* 64//F <14 >-(G)T4(?)/ C-AC#*4 #> ?10* G0)Y/#2-4H )* 0* 6A0??4( 0( MA?07/4 :W #> ?14 `0*.#( <A4)?PH 0* ?# 7A4)?4 ) *4(*4 #>T-?-)/ A4*C#(*0.0/0?P >#A B-A#C4F

"4 /0I4 0( 4i74C?0#()//P GP()T07 )(G ?-A.-/4(? ?0T4*H >)70(2 7#TC/4i 7A0Y*4*F _-A 4I4APG)P /0I4* )A4 G#T0()?4G .P 0TT02A)?0#( )(G ?14 7A0*0* A4/)?4G ?#?14 6)I4 #> A4>-244*H .P G4.)?4* ).#-? 0G4(?0?PH -(4TC/#PT4(?H ?14 47#(#T077A0*0* )(G 71)(24* 0( G4T#2A)C107*F

<14 4(?0A4 B-A#C4)( f(0#( 0* >)70(2 71)//4(24* A4/)?4G ?# C-./07 *47-A0?PH1-T)(0?)A0)( )0G )(G 7-/?-A)/ )(G /).#-A /420*/)?0#(F M// >#-A 4/4T4(?* )A4 ?021?/P7#((47?4GJ C#/0?07)/ )(G *47-A0?P *?A)?4204* T-*? 7#(*0G4A 1-T)(0?)A0)( )*C47?*)(G I074 I4A*) h 1-T)(0?)A0)( *#/-?0#(* 7)((#? 02(#A4 )*C47?* #> ()?0#()/ *47-YA0?P C#/0704*F M// #> ?14 ).#I4 *1#-/G .4 7#(*0G4A4G 0( /021? #> ?14 (44G ?# CA4Y*4AI4 ?14 ?A)G0?0#()/ I)/-4* #> B-A#C4)( 7-/?-A4F

<10* P4)A+* 7#(>4A4(74 ?)$4* #( ?14 *-.N47?* #> 1-T)( G02(0?PH >A44G#T )(G1-T)( A021?*F <14 G02(0?P #> T)( )(G 1-T)( A021?* )A4 *?0// )CC/07)./4H 0(G0*YC4(*)./P CA4*4(? 0( )// )*C47?* #> #-A /0I4*F "4 )A4 )/T#*? 7#(*?)(?/P .40(27#(>A#(?4G 60?1 CA#./4T* A4/)?4G ?# ?14 0(>A0(24T4(? #> G02(0?P )(G ?14 ).-*4#> 1-T)( A021?*F <14 G02(0?P #> ?14 1-T)( .40(2 )(G 1-T)( A021?* )A4 ?021?/P)(G 0(G0*C4(*)./P 7#((47?4GF <14 G02(0?P #> )( 0(G0I0G-)/ 0* >-(G)T4(?)/ ?#1-T)( A021?*H .47)-*4 ?1#*4 A021?* ?1)? 7)// >#A A4*C47? )(G CA#?47?0#( )// #I4A?14 6#A/G 64A4 7A4)?4G #( ?14 )**-TC?0#( ?1)? 1-T)( G02(0?P 0* (#(Y?A)(*>4A)Y./4 )(G 0(G0I0*0./4F Q)T-4/ I#( ,->4(G#A> o:;Z8Y:;V\pH )( 0(?4A()?0#()/ /)6*71#/)A )(G C10/#*#C14AH 7#((47?4G ?14 0G4) #> 1-T)( G02(0?P 60?1 ?14 0G4) #>) *#-/ )(G ?14 0G4) #> 60*G#T )(G ?14 0G4) #> >A44G#T 0( G470*0#( T)$0(2J !L)(

88

1)* ?14 T#*? G02(0?P .47)-*4 14 1)* ) *#-/ ?1)? *?#$4* ?14 >0A4 #> 60*G#T )(G ?14).0/0?P ?# )**4** ) *0?-)?0#( )(G T)$4 ) >A44 G470*0#(F+

D> #(4 *4??/4* ?14 *-.N47? >A#T ?14 I046C#0(? #> @1A0*?0)(0?PH 4*C470)//P 0(*0?-)?0#(* #> 7#(>/07?H ?14 ?4(4?* #> 1-T)( G02(0?P *1#-/G .4 ?14 .)*0* >#A 4?107)/)7?0#(*F L)( 6)* 7A4)?4G 0( 5#G+* 0T)24H 61071 20I4* 10T >A44G#TF M// >#AT*#> I0#/4(? CA4**-A4 )(G */)I4AP )A4 7#(?A)AP ?# 1-T)( G02(0?PF K-? 0( .40(2 >A44HT)( 0* 20I4( A4*C#(*0.0/0?PF ,#C4 cA)(70* A4T0(G* -* ).#-? ?10* 614( 14 ?)/$*).#-? T)( .40(2 7A4)?4G 0( 5#G+* 0T)24H 61071 T4)(* ?14 A4*C#(*0.0/0?P ?#CA#?47? 30* 7A4)?0#(F D( /021? #> ?10*H 2A4)? 4TC1)*0* 0* .40(2 C-? #( ?14 )6)A4Y(4** #> ?14 0(G0I0G-)/ A4*C#(*0.0/0?P #> T)(F

`)G04* )(G 24(?/4T4(t <14 7-AA4(? 7A0*4* #> 0G4(?0?PH *#704?P )(G 47#(#TP)(G ?14 ?A)207 A4>-244 7A0*0* 1)I4 .47#T4 ) 71)//4(24 ?# )// #> -*H )(G ) 7)// ?#0TT4G0)?4 )7?0#(F D> B-A#C4 6)(?* ?# >-/>0/ 0?* CA#N47? #> 4i74C?0#()/ -(0?PH 610716)* ?14 I0*0#( #> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(+* >#-(G4A*H ?14( B-A#C4 *1#-/G 24? 0(YI#/I4G 0( 7A4)?0(2 0?H (#? N-*? 2#I4A(0(2 0?F <)$0(2 ?10* 0(?# 7#(*0G4A)?0#(H D 60//6#A$ 60?1 ^)( _/.AP71?H 61# 0* CA4*4(? 14A4 )(G 60?1 M(GAO4N 5AOP. h 60?1 ?14./4**0(2 #> L)(>A4G "4.4A h 60?10( ) 6#A$0(2 7#TT0??44 ?0?/4G !D(?4A7-/?-A)/)(G D(?4A>)0?1 R0)/#2-4+F D 6#-/G /0$4 ?# >0(0*1 .P )GG0(2 *#T4?10(2 0TC#A?)(?J0( )// #> #-A 4>>#A?* 64 T-*? (#? >#A24? ).#-? ?14 T)0( C-AC#*4 #> #-A 6#A$F <14GP()T07* #> B-A#C4)( 0(?42A)?0#( 7)// >#A CA4*4AI0(2 4?107)/ .#-(G)A04*F !<14G02(0?P #> ) 1-T)( .40(2H >A44G#T )(G 1-T)( A021?*+ *1#-/G .4 #-A 2-0G4*FD )T *-A4 ?1)? #-A 7#(>4A4(74 0* )( 4i)TC/4 #> 1#6 71-A714* 7##C4A)?4 60?1I)A0#-* C#/0?07)/ 0(*?0?-?0#(*H 4G-7)?0#()/ 74(?A4* )(G 7#TT-(0?P #A2)(0O)?0#(*0( #AG4A ?# 4i71)(24 4iC4A04(74* 0( 7#TT-(0?P G0)/#2-4F

8Z

!0.:'" 4*1-./ =;,"1'?.20:", H$8")4 )* F)&/#7

%,4%,8,'+#+$I, )* +", 5)6$8" 24$8<)4#+, !)'*,%,'<, $' !-02!2

c0A*?H D 6#-/G /0$4 ?# 2A44? )// #> ?14 1#(#-A)./4 2-4*?* #( TP #6( .41)/> )*64// )* #( .41)/> #> @)AG0()/ =40(1)AG L)AiH @1)0AT)( #> @_LB@BF D )T 2/)G?1)? ?14 ?14T4 #> ?10* T44?0(2 0* !R02(0?P h cA44G#T h 3-T)( =021?*+F

D( 10* *C4471H 3#A*? `)(24* T4(?0#(4G /)*? Q-(G)P+* 5#*C4/ #> Q? L)A$H614A4 71)C?4A V ?)/$* ).#-? *4AI0(2 #?14A 1-T)( .40(2*F <14 5#*C4/ *)P* ?1)??1#*4 )*C0A0(2 ?# .4 =>"%?%8@ h !>0A*? )(G 10214*?+ h T-*? .47#T4 =:8;<#?%8@H ?14/)*? #(4H )(G )/*# T-*? .4 =56#;%+%8@ h ) *4AI)(?F M// #> -* 2)?14A4G 14A4 G4*0A4?# .4 ?14 *4AI)(?* #> #?14A 1-T)( .40(2*H /0$4 ?14 >#-(G4A* #> ?14 B-A#C4)(f(0#( *-71 )* S#(A)G MG4()-4AH G4 5)*C4A0H Q71-T)( #A L#(4? 64A4 ?14 *4AIY)(?* #> B-A#C4)(*F c#A ?14TH ?14 >#-(G)?0#(* #> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( 64A4 T)0(/P@1A0*?0)( I)/-4*H )(G ?14*4 I)/-4* 60// )/*# .4 CA4*4(? 0( ?14 ?#C07* ?1)? 1)I4.44( CA#C#*4GF

D( #-A T44?0(2H 64 60// 74A?)0(/P A4C4)? ?14 0**-4 #> C4#C/4 61# 7#T4 ?# -*>A#T ?14 L0GG/4 B)*?H T)0(/P .47)-*4 #> 6)AH .47)-*4 ?14P 6)(? ?# CA4*4AI4?140A G02(0?PH 1-T)( A021?* )(G ?14 A021? ?# >A44G#TF B-A#C4 7)((#? .4 0(G0>>4AY4(? ?# ?10* 6)I4 #> 0TT02A)(?* C)**0(2 ?1A#-21 0?* ?4AA0?#AP >#A ?14 >0A*? ?0T4F D>?14 6)A 0( ?14 L0GG/4 B)*? 7#(?0(-4*H 64 1)I4 ?# 4iC47? T#A4 0TT02A)(? 6)I4*)AA0I0(2 0( #-A B-A#C4F "4 7#(?0(-)//P 1)I4 ?# >0(G ?#24?14A ?1)? ?14 G02(0?P #>?14 1-T)( .40(2 0* ?14 *#-A74 #> /)6F <10* 0* ?14 ()?-A)/ A021?F L)( 0* 5#G+*7A4)?0#(F D( ?#G)P+* B-A#C4H ?14 /420*/)?0#( 0?*4/> 0* */#6/P .47#T0(2 ?14 *#-A74#> /)6H 61071 0* -(G4A2#0(2 */#6 71)(24*F 3#64I4AH 0> ?14A4 0* (# C4AT)(4(?.)*4H ?14( 64 T-*? )*$ 0( 61)? G0A47?0#( 7)( ?#G)P+* B-A#C4)( /420*/)?0#( 2#l"1)? C-AC#*4 7)( 0? )7104I4l "0// 0? G4>4(G /0>4l "0// 0? G4>4(G T)AA0)24l "0//0? #CC#*4 4-?1)()*0)l ,#*0?0I4 /)6 7)( 71)(24 *# T)(P ?10(2*H .-? 60// ?10* /)6.4 T#A4 1-T)(4l

D 60*1 ?14 )-G04(74 ?1)? ?10* N#0(? *4)A71 G0A47?* -* )// #( ?A)7$ #> ?14 G02(0?P#> ?14 1-T)( C4A*#( )(G ?14 ()?-A)/ /)6H 61071 6)* 20I4( ?# T)(F D 60*1 ?1)??10* 7#(>4A4(74 0* )( 4(A071T4(? )(G ) 7#TT#( m-4*? >#A )// #> -*F

8\

4,*1 <6*-+, 4-192,&5%,8$@,'+ )* +", 23%)4,#' !)&&$88$)'

Bi74//4(704*H `)G04* )(G 54(?/4T4(H

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k)/-4* )A4 74(?A)/ ?# ?14 B-A#C4)( CA#N47?F

_(4 ?10(2 ?14 A4>-244 7A0*0* ?4)714* -* 0* ?1)? B-A#C4 0* ) .4)7#( #> 1#C4 ?#T4( )(G 6#T4( 0( ?14 L0GG/4 B)*? )(G M>A07)F _> ?1)? 64 7)( .4 CA#-GF <#G)PP#- 60// .4 G0*7-**0(2 G02(0?PH >A44G#T )(G 1-T)( A021?*F MA?07/4 8 #> ?14 <A4)Y?P T4(?0#(* )// ?1A44 #> ?14*4 I)/-4*F K-? ?14 <A4)?P T4(?0#(* )(#?14A I)/-4 ?1)?0* 7/#*4 ?# TP 14)A? )(G )* 0TC#A?)(? )* ?14 #?14A*H )(G ?1)? 0* *#/0G)A0?PF R-A0(2?14 /)*? 644$* T#*?H B-A#C4)( *#/0G)A0?P 1)* .44( C-? ?# ?14 ?4*? h *#/0G)A0?P60?1 A4>-244* )(G *#/0G)A0?P .4?644( L4T.4A Q?)?4*F "1)? ).#-? ?14 G02(0?P #>A4>-244*l "1)? ).#-? ?140A 1-T)( A021?*l "1)? ).#-? ?140A >A44G#Tl B-A#C4?1)? 0* ?14 .4)7#( )(G S#* 61# 2)I4 .A4)G ?# 1-(2AP A4>-244*F <14 *?-G4(?* 0(L-(071 61# 2)I4 ?14T 7/#?14*F <14 M-*?A0)( C#/074T4( 61# 64/7#T4G ?14T0(?# ?14 7#-(?APF <1)? 0* ?14 B-A#C4 D 6)(? ?# /0I4 0(F <1A44 G)P* )2#H ?14 L4TY.4A Q?)?4* )2A44G 60?1 #-A CA#C#*)/ ?# A4/#7)?4 :;9H999 C4#C/4F D? 0* ?14 .420(Y(0(2 #> *#/0G)A0?P .-? 0? 0* #(/P ?14 .420((0(2F "4 *?0// 1)I4 T-71 ?# G# .-? D )T7#(>0G4(? ?1)? B-A#C4 60// *?)(G -C ?# 0?* I)/-4* #(74 T#A4F D 60*1 P#- )( 0(Y*C0A0(2H CA#G-7?0I4 )(G I)/-)./4 G0*7-**0#(F 5##G.P4F

8[

I*(*> )&/*.2'?.20J %:30$'$8+,% *)% 23%)4,#' ;**#$%8

$' +", J)I,%'&,'+ )* +", D,4316$< )* 5)6#'@

LP 7)?4710*?H 61# 6)* ) I4AP *?A07? cA)(70*7)(H 6)* #>?4( >A-*?A)?4G 60?1TP -(A-/P .41)I0#-AF 34 6#-/G #>?4( ?4// T4H !<AO)*$#6*$0H P#- T)P (#? .4Y7#T4 ) 2##G @)?1#/07H .-? ?14A4 0* 1#C4 ?1)? P#- T)P .47#T4 ) 2##G C4A*#(H.-? #(/P -(G4A ?14 7#(G0?0#( ?1)? P#- 60// (#? >#A24? 61)?+* T#*? 0TC#A?)(?JI)/-4*+F

D )/*# A4T4T.4AH .47)-*4 0? 6)* )? ?14 4(G #> ?14 :VW9*H ?14 .4//* ?#//0(2 0(:VWXF D 6#(G4A4G 61)? 6)* 1)CC4(0(2F M(GH 0( :VX9H 614( D >0A*? 6)/$4G 0(?#TP A4/020#( 7/)**4* )? ?14 cA)(70*7)( @1-A71 )(G 64 64A4 )// 4-C1#A07 oD 6)*P#-(2H .-? D 6)* 0(>/-4(74G .P 61)? 6)* 2#0(2 #( )? 1#T4pF LP 7)?4710*? *)0G14 6)* )>A)0GH 1#64I4AF M>?4A ?1)?H D 7)T4 1#T4 )(G )*$4G TP >)?14A 61)? ,A04*?M/4i)(G4A 6)* )>A)0G #>H *0(74 4I4AP?10(2H )>?4A )//H 6)* >0()//P T#I0(2 0( ?14A021? G0A47?0#(F D( ?14 4(GH ?14A4 6)* ) 71)(74 ?1)? 64 6#-/G 2)0( >A44G#TFD A4T4T.4A ?10* 6)* 0( ?14 G)P* 614( ?14 >0A*? 6#AG* 64 /4)A(4G 64A4 0( D?)/0)(J=+% #A6#?: >#,"#@H T4)(0(2 !G# (#? .4 )>A)0G+F

"1)? 6)* TP 7)?4710*? )>A)0G #>l c0A*?/PH 14 >4)A4G 1#6 64 6#-/G 1)(G/4>A44G#TF Q47#(G/PH 14 >4)A4G ?1)? 64 6#-/G >#A24? ).#-? #-A I)/-4* )>?4A 642)0(4G #-A >A44G#T )(G A4)714G #-A 2#)/*F D T-*? ?4// P#- )//H 60?1 *#T4 *)GY(4**H ?1)? 64+A4 )/6)P* 0( ) 1-AAP *#T4614A4H 6#(G4A0(2 61)? ?# G#H 1#6 ?#A4)7? 0( )(P 20I4( T#T4(?F "4+A4 )/6)P* GA#6(0(2 0( ?1#-*)(G* #> G4?)0/*HG0A47?0I4*H A47#AG* )(G 4I4( ?14( 64 >#A24? ?# 64)A ) ?04 614( 64 1)I4 ?#F BI4(60?1 )// #> ?10*H ?14A4 7#T4* ) T#T4(? 614( #(4 6#(G4A* 61)? ?10* 0* )// >#AH )//#> ?10* 1-AAP0(2 )(G G470G0(2H 4*C470)//P 0( ?14 >)74 #> ?14 m-4*?0#( #> B-A#C4)(0(?42A)?0#(F "1P G# 64 G# )// #> ?10*l "1)? )A4 ?14 A4)*#(*H ?14 >#-(G)?0#(* >#A#-A )7?0#(*l <10* 7A0*0* ?1)? 64 (#6 1)I4 ?# G4)/ 60?1H ?14 4I4(?* -(A)I4//0(2 0(Q#-?14A( B-A#C4 )(G B)*?4A( B-A#C4H 0* ?14 #CC#A?-(0?P ?# *?#C >#A ) 610/4H?10($H C#(G4AJ 61P G# 64 G# )// #> ?10* )(G 61)? 0* #-A T#?0I)?0#(l M(G 1#64IY4A *47-/)A0O4G #(4 T)P .4H 64 T-*? )/6)P* A4?-A( ?# ?1#*4 7#A4 I)/-4* 614( 64/##$ )? 61)? 0* 1)CC4(0(2 ?# ?14 4)*? h ?14 =-**0)( )22A4**0#( 0( f$A)0(4F "14(64 /##$ )? 61)? 0* 1)CC4(0(2 0( ?14 *#-?1H ?14 2A4)? 6)I4 #> T02A)?0#(H ?14A4 0*) (44G ?# A4>/47? #( 61)? 4i)7?/P 0* 0( ?14 ?0?/4 #> ?10* 7#(>4A4(74F k)/-4* /0$4G02(0?PH 1-T)( A021?* )(G *#/0G)A0?P )A4 (#? 4TC?P 6#AG* 0( ,#/)(GF =474(?/PH614( D A4)G "4*?4A( (46*C)C4A*H 61)? .#?14A* T4 ?14 T#*? 6)* ?14 7#(*?)(?

8;

)??4TC? ?# 4iC/)0( ?# -* 61)? *#/0G)A0?P 0*F "1)? -(0?P 0* 0( ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(FBI4( *-.*0G0)A0?PH 61071 0* C4A1)C* ?14 T#*? 7#TT#(/P -*4G 6#AG 0( ?)/$* 0(?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(H 0* )( 0G4) G4A0I4G >A#T ?14 G#7?A0(4 #> ?14 @1-A71F D? 0* ?140G4) ?# T)$4 G470*0#(* )* 7/#*4 ?# ?14 70?0O4(* )* C#**0./4F

D? *44T* ?# T4 ?1)? ?14 T02A)?0#( 7A0*0* 0* ) T#T4(? ?# ?)$4 ?# A4>/47? #( ?14>-(G)T4(?)/ I)/-4*H .47)-*4 #(/P .P 4I)/-)?0(2 )(G CA)7?070(2 ?14T 60// 64 .4)./4 ?# )(*64A ?14 m-4*?0#( #> 61)? 64 *1#-/G -/?0T)?4/P G#F _> 7#-A*4H D G4)/60?1 ?14 ?471(07)/0?04*q.47)-*4 D+T ?14 ,#/0*1 2#I4A(T4(?+* /0)0*#(H 61# 6)*)/*# A4*C#(*0./4 >#A (42#?0)?0(2 ?14*4 /)?4*? G4I4/#CT4(?*F "4 )A4 >#7-*0(2 CA0YT)A0/P #( 1#6 ?# .-0/G ) 7#TCA414(*0I4 C/)( ?# G4)/ 60?1 ?14 T02A)?0#( 71)/Y/4(24H .47)-*4 *#/0G)A0?P 0?*4/> 0* (#? *->>0704(?F "4 (44G ?# ?10($ #> 1#6 ?#*47-A4 ?14 .#AG4A*H 1#6 ?# 0G4(?0>P ?14 C4#C/4 61#T 64 (44G ?# 14/CH ?14 C4#C/461# )A4 4*7)C0(2 G4)?1 )(G C4A*47-?0#(H >A#T ?1#*4 >#A 61#T )? ?14 T#T4(?64 7)((#? /4(G 0TT4G0)?4 )**0*?)(74H .47)-*4 64 1)I4 ?# 1#(4*?/P *)P ?1)? ?14B-A#C4)( f(0#( 7)((#? )>>#AG ?# ?)$4 0( T0//0#(* #> 47#(#T07 T02A)(?*F

D?+* 4)*P ?# *)P h ?# *4C)A)?4 47#(#T07 T02A)(?* >A#T A4>-244*F <10* 60// .4T-71 1)AG4A ?# G# 60?1 A4*C47? >#A 1-T)( A021?* )(GH ).#I4 )//H 60?1 A4*C47? ?#?14 G02(0?P #> ?14*4 C4#C/4F <14*4 )A4 G0>>07-/? m-4*?0#(* ?# 61071 64 )A4 20I0(2)(*64A* )(G ?# 61071 64 *44$ )(*64A*H .47)-*4H #> 7#-A*4H 0? 60// .4 G0>>07-/? ?#0TC/4T4(?q?14*4 CA#I0*0#(*F <14 T#*? 0TC#A?)(? 0*H )(G 0? 1)* )/6)P* .44( )??14 .)*4 #> ?14 ,#/0*1 2#I4A(T4(?+* C#*0?0#(H ?# ?10($ ).#-? ?14 *#-A74* #> ?14CA#./4T )(G ?AP ?# )GGA4** ?14TF "4 1)I4 ?# ?10($ ).#-? 1#6 64 7)( 71)(24?14 *0?-)?0#( 0( #-A 0TT4G0)?4 *-AA#-(G0(2*H #A 64 60// #(/P .4 G4)/0(2 60?1 ?14*PTC?#T*F

<10* 0* ) 2A4)? #CC#A?-(0?P h -(?0/ \ )T P4*?4AG)P 64 64A4 (42#?0)?0(2) *?)?4T4(? >A#T ?14 B-A#C4)( @#-(70/H )(G >0()//P D 7)( *44 ?14 B-A#C4)( f(Y0#(+* 24(-0(4 7#TT0?T4(? ?# 4(2)24 0( ?14 (4)A4*? A420#( )(G *?).0/0O4 ?14 7#-(Y?A04* 0( 61071 ?10(2* 64(? 6A#(2H 0( 61071 C4#C/4 )A4 .40(2 $0//4GH )(G C4A*4Y7-?4GH 0( 61071 @1A0*?0)(* )A4 .40(2 C4A*47-?4GF M(G >#A ?14 >0A*? ?0T4 D *44 )(PA4)*#( >#A #C?0T0*T 0( ?10* G0>>07-/? *0?-)?0#(H .47)-*4 >0()//P D *44 ) 2A4)? )(GT)(0>4*?4G C#/0?07)/ 60// ?# A4*#/I4 ?14*4 0**-4*F

=42)AG0(2 ?14 71)//4(24 #> 0TT02A)?0#(J 614( D 6)*qA4>/47?0(2 ?#G)P #(?14*4 0**-4*H D /0*?4(4G ?# ?14 ,#C4+* *C4471 0( ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(?F ,#C4cA)(70* *)0G #(4 I4AP 0TC#A?)(? *4(?4(74 ).#-? A4>-244*H ()T4/PH ?1)? 0( >)7??10* 7A0*0* 0* ) ?4*? #> 1-T)(0?P 0( ?14 L4T.4A Q?)?4*F <10* 0* 4i?A4T4/P 0TC#AY?)(?H )(G #-A G470*0#( 6)* T#?0I)?4G .P ?14 >)7? ?1)? ,#/)(G T-*? *1#6 *#/0YG)A0?PF

M* 64 ?)/$4G 60?1 ?14 CA0T4 T0(0*?4A ).#-? ?10* 0**-4H A4)710(2 ) G470*0#(6)* (#? 4)*PF "4 )// $(#6 61)? ?14 *0?-)?0#( /##$* /0$4 )? ?10* T#T4(?J ) C#/0?Y

8W

07)/ 7)TC)02( )(G ?14 7P(07)/ C#/0?070)(* A-*10(2 ?# 4iC/#0? ?10* ?#C07F 3#64I4AH0( ?14 4(G 6)* ) *0TC/4 0G4)J 64 T-*? .41)I4 /0$4 2##G 1-T)( .40(2*F <# G# *#6#-/G .4 ?# CA#I4 614?14A 64 )A4 G4*?0(4G >#A ?10* )? )//H ?# C/)P ?14 A#/4 #>C#/0?070)(* 0( ?10* 7#-(?APF

34A4H D 6#-/G /0$4 ?# ?1)($ ?14 ,#/0*1 BC0*7#C)?4 #( .41)/> #> ?14 2#I4A(YT4(? >#A ?)$0(2 ) I4AP 7/4)A C#*0?0#(F R#0(2 *# 4(*-A4* ?1)? ?10* G4.)?4 G#4* (#?*C0( #-? #> 7#(?A#/H .47)-*4 0?+* 0TC#A?)(? ?1)? 64 ?)$4 ) *?4C .)7$ )(G A4>/47? #(61)? 64+A4 ?)/$0(2 ).#-? )? ?10* T#T4(?F "4 T-*? )/*# ?AP ?# CA4I4(? ?10* G0>>0Y7-/? G470*0#( >A#T .47#T0(2 ) C#/0?07)/ ?)A24?H .47)-*4 ?14 7#(*4m-4(74* #> 61)?64 )A4 G#0(2 )? ?14 T#T4(? )(G ?14 7#(*4m-4(74* #> )/04()?0#( )(G )(?)2#(0O)Y?0#( 60// .4 >4/? >#A T)(PH T)(P P4)A*F D )/*# 1#C4 ?1)?H A42)AG/4** #> 614?14A64 )A4 7#//47?0I4/P 0(?4A4*?4G 0( C#/0?07* )(G 61)? #-A I046* )A4H #-A T)0( 2#)/*1#-/G .4 ?# 7)/T ?14 4T#?0#(*Hq?# 4iC/)0( ?1)? (#?10(2 ?4AA0./4 0* 1)CC4(0(2H?1)? 64 1)I4 ?14 #AG0()AP 1-T)( #./02)?0#( ?# 14/C C4#C/4 61# (44G 14/CF

D> #(4 64A4 ?# ?)/$ ).#-? G02(0?P )(G 1-T)( A021?*H 0? 6#-/G .4 1)AG (#? ?#A4>4A ?# 61)? 0* 1)CC4(0(2 0( B)*?4A( B-A#C4F M? ?14 T#T4(?H ?10* 7#(>/07? 0* (#?.40(2 A4C#A?4G #( ?14 >A#(? C)24* #> (46*C)C4A*H .-? 0? 0* *?0// 4i?A4T4/P 0TC#AY?)(?F D( ) *4(*4H #-A A4)7?0#( ?# ?10* 7A0*0*H )(G #-A 7#(*0*?4(7PH 60// G4?4AT0(4614?14A 64 )A4 A4/0)./4 #A (#?F M* ?# 61)? ,#C4 cA)(70* *)0G )? ?14 B-A#C4)(,)A/0)T4(?H ?14 7A-70)/ 4/4T4(? >#A T4 6)* ?14 >)7? ?1)? B-A#C4)( 0(?42A)?0#( 0*) 7#(?0(-#-* CA#74** ?1)? A4m-0A4* I020/)(74F <10* 0* ?14 $4P 6#AGH .47)-*4 0(T)(P L4T.4A Q?)?4* 64 1)I4 .47#T4 )77-*?#T4G ?# ?14 >)7? ?1)? B-A#C4)(0(?42A)?0#( CA#I0G4* ?)(20./4 .4(4>0?*F L#*? #> ?14T 64 )A4 ?)$0(2 >#A 2A)(?4GF<14 >)7? ?1)? 64 7)( ?A)I4/ >A44/PH ?1)? ?14A4 )A4 (# .#AG4A*H ?1)? 64 7)( 6#A$H)A4 (#? 2-)A)(?44G >#A4I4AF <14*4 CA0I0/424* )A4 (#? ) 74A?)0(?PH .-? ?14 I)/-4*T-*? .4 (-A?-A4G )(G G4>4(G4GF "1)? 0* 1)CC4(0(2 0( ?14 4)*? )(G *#-?1 *1#6*-* 7/4)A/P ?1)? 0> 64 )A4 (#? I020/)(?H 0> 64 G# (#? ?)$4 7)A4 #> ?10* CA#74**H #> ?10*7#TT-(0?P ?1)? 0* 4i?A4T4/P 0TC#A?)(? ?# )// #> -*H ?14 T)??4A* T)P ?)$4 ) I4APG0>>4A4(? ?-A(F

D ?10($ 0?+* 0TC4A)?0I4 ?# (#?4 61)? ,#C4 cA)(70* *)0GJ ?1)? ?14 .-A4)-7A)?07*?A-7?-A4 0* *#T4?0T4* G4?)714G >A#T ?14 C4#C/4H 0* ?## ?471(07)/H )(G ?1)? #-A2#)/ *1#-/G .4 ?# .A0(2 0? 7/#*4A ?# ?14 #AG0()AP 70?0O4(F <10* 0* ?14 CA0(70C)/T)??4AF R4)/0(2 60?1 B-A#C4)( 0(?42A)?0#( >#A :X P4)A*H D 1)I4 6A0??4(TPqG#7?#A)?4 #( ?10* *-.N47?H )(G )* D *?)A? ?# ?)/$ ).#-? ?471(07)/0?04*H TP 7#/Y/4)2-4* *)P ?1)? (#.#GP 60// -(G4A*?)(G T4F Q#T4?0T4*H 60?1 ?10* 4**4(?0)/?A)(*T0**0#( #> 0G4)* A42)AG0(2 T02A)?0#(H 64 24? /#*? 0( ?14 ?471(07)/0?04*F "4)A4 24??0(2 /#*? 0( ?14 G4?)0/* )(G A47#AG*j 64 )A4 /#*0(2 *021? #> 61)? 0* T#*?0TC#A?)(?H 61071 0* ?14 T)0( T4**)24F "4 )A4 )/*# /#*0(2H #( ?14 6)PH #-A>4//#6 70?0O4(* 61# G# (#? m-0?4 -(G4A*?)(G 61)? 64 )A4 ?)/$0(2 ).#-?F<10* 0* CA#.)./P ?14 T#*? 0TC#A?)(? ?)*$ .4>#A4 -*H ?# T)$4 B-A#C4)( 0(?42A)Y

8X

?0#( )* 7/#*4 ?# ?14 70?0O4(* )* C#**0./4H *# ?1)? >-?-A4 G470*0#(* )A4 T)G4 )*7/#*4 ?# ?14 70?0O4(* )* C#**0./4F ,4A1)C* 0? 0* (#? ) 7#0(70G4(74 ?1)? 64 ()T4G?10* 7#(74C? ) *-.*0G0)A0?PH *# ?1)? 64 7)( 4iC/)0( 61)? 64 G#H )(G *#T4?0T4*64 1)I4 ?# ?)$4 ?6# *?4C* .)7$ )(G )(*64A ?14 >-(G)T4(?)/ m-4*?0#(J 61P G0G64 A4)//P 7A4)?4 ?10* 7#TT-(0?P )(G 61)? CA0(70C/4* 0* 0? 2-0G4G .Pl D> 64 G#(#? G# ?10*H ?14( ?10* 2A4)? ?4*? ?# 61071 64 )A4 )// 4iC#*4G T)P 4(G -(*-7Y74**>-//PF

Introduction Speechesto the Working Groups

Z:

I,G# 3& K6'&0*1 L'6(:*-.E,<%,+#%$#+ )* E+#+, )* +", B)6C E,,

!>F@>9A ( >@@<96 43 F3<@96BI

<10* *-TT4AH C-./07 #C0(0#( )// #I4A ?14 "4*?4A( 6#A/G 6)* *1#7$4G 614(0? /4)A(4G ).#-? ?14 *1##?0(2 #> ?14 >)T#-* /0#( @470/ 0( d0T.).64F M( MT4AY07)( G4(?0*? >#-(G C/4)*-A4 )(G CA0G4 0( $0//0(2 #(4 #> ?14 (#./4*? )(0T)/* #>M>A07)F 3#6 7)( #(4 G4*?A#P ?14 G02(0?P #> *-71 ) T)2(0>074(?H T)N4*?07 7A4)Y?-A4H N-*? ?# .4 )./4 ?# .#)*? ).#-? ) A)A4 ?A#C1P 0( 10* 1#-*4l M? ?14 *)T4 ?0T4H>)7?* 64A4 G0*7/#*4G A4/)?4G ?# ?14 ?A)>>07$0(2 #> #A2)(* .4/#(20(2 ?# 710/GA4($0//4G .P )( ).#A?0#( CA#74G-A4 CA)7?074G .P ?14 MT4A07)( #A2)(0O)?0#( ,/)((4G,)A4(?1##GH .-? ?10* 7)*4 64(? )/T#*? -((#?074G .P T#*? T4G0) #-?/4?*F <10*#A2)(0O)?0#(H .)7$4G .P 7#(*0G4A)./4 A4*#-A74* G4A0I4G >A#T ?)i4*H *4? 0?* *021?#( ) (46H /-7A)?0I4 *#-A74 #> A4I4(-4J #.?)0(0(2 14)/?1P T)?4A0)/ >A#T )((010Y/)?4G -(.#A( >#4?-*4*F

c#A20I4 T4H 0> ?14 6#AG* D -*4 14A4 )A4 7#TC/4?4/P .##A0*1 )(G G0*A4*C47?Y>-/H .-? >#A 61)? A4)*#( 6#-/G ?14P )7?-)//P G0*C#*4 #> 14)A? )(G /-(2H /0I4A )(G$0G(4PH #A #?14A 1021/P I)/-)./4 24(4?07 T)?4A0)/H 0> ) G4)G .).P 7)( .A0(2 4I4() /0??/4 T#A4 G#-21l

3#6 0* 0? C#**0./4 ?1)? 1-(GA4G* #> ?1#-*)(G* #> C4#C/4 60// *?)(G -C >#A #(4/0#(H 610/4 ?14 T)N#A0?P #> ?14 *)T4 C4#C/4 61# )A4 #-?A)24G 60?1 $0//0(2 @470/)**-T4 ) 7#TC/4?4/P 0(G0>>4A4(? )??0?-G4 ?#6)AG* ?14 C14(#T4(#( #> ?A)>>07$Y0(2 #A2)(* #>q7#-(?/4** 710/GA4( )((010/)?4G ?1A#-21 ).#A?0#(l "1)? $0(G #>G02(0?P G#4* ) 1-T)( .40(2 1)I4 (#6)G)P*H )(G 61)? 0* ?10* G02(0?P G4?4AT0(4G.Pl f(G4A (# 70A7-T*?)(74* G# D 6)(? ?# m-4*?0#( ?14 T4)(0(2 #> 4(2)20(2 0(?14 A4*7-4 )(G CA#?47?0#( #> ?14 *C4704*H .-? 0> ?14 >)?4 #> *#T4 )(0T)/ G4*4AI4*T#A4 )??4(?0#( ?1)( ?14 0(I0#/).0/0?P #> 1-T)( G02(0?PH 0? T-*? .4 *?)?4G ?1)?*##( ?14 1-T)( A021?* #> 4)71 #> -* T)P .4 )? A0*$F

,A#.)./P ?14 T#*? >A4m-4(?/P 0(I#$4G C10/#*#C107)/ *?)?4T4(? A4>4AA0(2 ?#?14 G02(0?P #> ?14 1-T)( C4A*#( 0* ?14 >#AT-/)?0#( G4*7A0.0(2 ?14 >)T#-* CA0(Y70C/4 #> 4?107)/ 7)?42#A07)/ 0TC4A)?0I4H 61071 0* >#-(G 0( ?14 6#A$ #> DTT)(-4/S)(? 4(?0?/4G *,8?6B6;#?6%+ %B ?<: C:?#><-86;8 %B C%"#D8J !M7? 0( *-71 ) 6)PH *#?1)? P#- )/6)P* -*4 P#-A 1-T)(0?PH .#?1 0( P#-A*4/> )(G 0( )(P #?14A C4A*#(H)/*# )* ) 2#)/H (4I4A T4A4/P )* ) T4)(*F+: <14 >#-(G)?0#( #> ?10* 4?107)/ CA0(70YC/4 0* ?14 0G4) #> 1-T)( G02(0?PH 4iC/)0(4G .P S)(? /0$4 ?10*J !<14A4>#A4H A4)*#(

Z8

)CC/04* 4)71 T)i0T #> ?14 60// )* -(0I4A*)//P /420*/)?0I4 >#A )(P #?14A 60//H )(G?# )(P .41)I0#-A 0( A4/)?0#( ?# #(4*4/>H )(G (#? .47)-*4 #> *#T4 #?14A CA)7?07)/T#?0I4 #A >-?-A4 .4(4>0?H .-? .)*4G #( ?14 0G4) #> )( 0(?4//024(? .40(2+* G02(0?PH61071 G#4* (#? #.4P )(P #?14A /)6H #(/P ?14 #(4 ?1)? *14 )/*# 7#(>4A*F D( ) *?)?4#> 2#)/* 4I4AP?10(2 1)* 40?14A ) CA074 #A G02(0?PF <14 #(4 61071 1)* ) CA074H 7)()/*# .4 A4C/)74G .P *#T4?10(2 4/*4 )* 0?* 4m-0I)/4(?H 610/4 ?14 #(4 61071 4iY744G* )(P CA074H )(G ?14A4>#A4 G#4* (#? )//#6 )(P 4m-0I)/4(?H ?1)? 1)* ) G02(0?PF<1)? 61071 A4/)?4* ?# 7#TT#( 1-T)( 0(7/0()?0#(* )(G (44G*H 1)* 0?* T)A$4?CA074j unv 610/4 ?1)? 61071 0* ) 7#(G0?0#( -(G4A 61071 *#T4?10(2 7)( T4A4/P.4 ) 2#)/ 0( 0?*4/>H (#? #(/P 1)* ) A4/)?0I4 I)/-4H 0F4F CA074H .-? )/*# 1)* )( 0(?A0(Y*07 I)/-4H 0F4F G02(0?PF L#A)/0?P 0* ?14 7#(G0?0#(H #( 61071 G4C4(G* T4A4/P ?14>)7? ?1)? )( 0(?4//024(? .40(2 7)( .4 ?14 2#)/ >#A 10T*4/>H .47)-*4 #(/P ?1A#-2110T #(4 7)( .4 ) /420*/)?0I4 T4T.4A 0( ) *?)?4 #> 2#)/*F <14A4>#A4H T#A)/0?P )(G1-T)(0?PH 0> 0? 0* 7)C)./4 #> T#A)/0?PH )A4 61)? C#**4**4* G02(0?PF+8

<14A4>#A4H >#A S)(? ?14 4**4(74 #> 1-T)( G02(0?P 0* !) 2#)/ 0( 0?*4/>+ #A ?14!/)7$ #> C-AC#*4>-/(4**+ #> ) 1-T)( .40(2F 3-T)( /0>4 0* CA074/4**H *# 0? 1)* 0?*!0(()?4 I)/-4+F `0>4 0* 0(I)/-)./4H )* 0? 1)* 0( 0?*4/> ?14 G02(0?P 61071 7)((#? .4*)7A0>074GH *#/G #-? #A -*4G >#A )(P C-AC#*4+* *)$4F "1#4I4A *4AI4* #(/P )*) T4)(* ?# )7104I4 ) 2#)/H /#*4* 10* G02(0?PF <10* 0* 61PH 0( S)(?+* -(G4A*?)(GY0(2H ) T)( 0* ?14 C-AC#*4 0( 10T*4/>H 0* 0AA4C/)74)./4H 1)* )( 0(()?4 )(G 0(14A4(?I)/-4H ?# 61071 )(P A4/)?0I0?P G4A0I4G >A#T ) CA074H A4*-/?0(2 >A#T ?14 4I#/I0(2A4/)?0#(*10C .4?644( *-CC/P )(G G4T)(GF

M/*#H 614( Q? <1#T)* Mm-0()* 6)* *C4)$0(2 #> G02(0?PH 14 T)G4 ) G0*?0(7Y?0#( .4?644( !564+6?#8+ uG02(0?Pv )(G !,?6D6?#8+ uCA#>0?).0/0?PvF !E64+6?#8 864+6B6F;#? A%+6?#?:G #D6;,H,8 >"%>?:" 8:6>8,G' ,?6D6?#8 I:"% >"%>?:" #D6,5F+Z R02(0?PT4)(* ?14 I)/-4 #> ) 20I4( 7A4)?-A4 >#A 0?*4/>H 610/4 ,?6D6?#8H 61071 0* CA#>0?).0/Y0?PH 0* >#A #?14A*F 3#64I4AH 64 60// *44 0( ) T#T4(? ?1)? S)(? )(G Q? <1#T)*Mm-0()* 1)G *#T4?10(2 4/*4 0( T0(G 614( *)P0(2 ?14*4 ?A-?1*F

R02(0?P G#4* (#? 1)I4 )(P !*-.N47?0I4+ I)/-4 40?14AF D> *#T4#(4H >A#T 10*#6( C4A*C47?0I4H C4A740I4* )( 4I0/ G44G )* *#T4?10(2 C#*0?0I4H -*4>-/ )(G CA#CY4AH )(G N-*?0>04* ?10* G44G N-*? .47)-*4 #> ?10* h /4?+* ?)$4 )* )( 4i)TC/4 710/G/).#-A #A ?14 4I)*0#( #> C)P0(2 G474(?H >)0A C)P h ?14( *-71 .41)I0#-A G#4* (#?T44? 60?1 )774C?)(74F M? ?14 >#-(G)?0#( #> ?A4)?0(2 #?14A*H ?14A4 *1#-/G .4 (#

: DTT)(-4/ S)(?H JCK L*,8?6B6;#?6%+ %B ?<: C:?#><-86;8 %B C%"#D8M' NN /OH \8V u?A)(*/)?4G .PLw70*&)6 ")A?4(.4A2vF

8 6A652H \Z\h\Z[FZ Q? <1#T)* #> Mm-0()*H K;"6>?,G 8,>:" 8:+?:+?668H /0.F Z GF Z[ mF : )F \ m7 : 7#F uR02(0?P T4)(*

*#T4#(4+* 2##G(4** C#**4**4G .47)-*4 #> #(4*4/>H 1#64I4A ?14 .4(4>0? *4AI4* #?14A*vF

ZZ

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h 0( 7#(?A)*? ?# 10* G02(0?P h T)( 0* #(/P) T4)(* (44G4G ?# #.?)0( 74A?)0( 2##G* )(G ?1-*H 0> 10* !0(?A0(*07 I)/-4+ 0* (#?I0#/)?4G )(P6)PF 3#64I4AH 0*(+? 0? #>?4( *#H 4*C470)//P 0( ?14 6#A$0(2 6#A/GH?1)? T)( 1)* T4A4/P ) !T)A$4? I)/-4+H 61071 0* -*4G #(/P 0( #AG4A ?# 2)0( 4I4(T#A4 CA#>0?l

<14 #./02)?0#( ?# ?A4)? 4I4AP C4A*#( 0( )77#AG)(74 60?1 10* G02(0?P 0* (#? P4??14 *#-A74 #> ?1)? G02(0?P (#A G#4* 0? 7#I4A 0?* N-*?0>07)?0#(F 3-T)( A021?* #A?140A CA#?47?0#(H )(71#A4G 0( ?14 *?)?4*+ 7#(*?0?-?0#(*H )A4 (#? ?14 4**4(74 #>1-T)( G02(0?PH .-? #(/P )**-T4 0? )* ) *?)A?0(2 C#0(?F D> 0? 6)*(+? /0$4 ?10*H G02Y(0?P 6#-/G .4 *-.N47? ?# (42#?0)?0#(* #I4A )(G #I4A )2)0(H )(G ?10* 6)P 0?6#-/G .4 #(/P ) CA0I0/424 20I4( >#A ) 74A?)0( C4A0#G #> ?0T4 )(G )CC/07)./4 0() *C470>07 C/)74H 61071 6#-/G .4 )I)0/)./4 ?# 74A?)0( C4#C/4 .-? (#? ?# #?14A*F<14(H >#A 4i)TC/4J G0>>4A4(? 1-T)( A021?* 6#-/G )CC/P ?#6)AG* 6#T4( 0(@10() ?1)( 0( ?14 f(0?4G Q?)?4*H )(G 710/GA4( 6#-/G .4 7#(*0G4A4G /4** I)/-)Y./4 ?1)( )G-/?*F L4)(610/4H ?14 >#-(G)?0#( #> G02(0?P 0* ?14 ()?-A4 )(G ?144**4(74 #> 4I4AP T)(F M(P #?14A *?)?4T4(? 7#-/G ?14#A4?07)//P 7A4)?4 ) *C)74>#A )// $0(G* #> )7?0#(* >-// #> 7#(?4TC? ?#6)AG* T)(F U#6H /4? T4 C#0(? #-??14 A0*$* A4*-/?0(2 >A#T ) C47-/0)A !C)A74//0(2 #-?+ #> 1-T)( A021?*H )(G ?14A4Y>#A4 >A#T ) >A)2T4(?4G C4A74C?0#( #> ?14TF L#A4 #>?4( ?14 A021?* #> 6#T4()(G 710/GA4(H #A ?14 A021?* #> 1#T#*4i-)/* )A4 ?)/$4G ).#-? )(G ?14 (44G ?#CA#?47? ?140A A021?* 0* A4T0(G4GF M(G ?14A4+* (#?10(2 6A#(2 ).#-? 0? )* /#(2 )*0? A4T)0(* 0(G0*C-?)./4 ?1)? (40?14A T4( (#A 6#T4(H (#A ?1#*4 14?4A#Y #A 1#YT#*4i-)/H #A ?14 *07$ #A ?14 14)/?1P )A4 4(?0?/4G ?# )(P *C470)/ 1-T)( A021?*A4/)?4G #(/P ?# ?140A #6( 2A#-CF "#T4(H 710/GA4(H 1#T#*4i-)/*H ?14 G0*)./4G#A 4/G4A/P C4#C/4 >0()//P )A4 4(?0?/4G ?# 1-T)( A021?* 4i)7?/P .47)-*4 ?14P )A41-T)(F K4/#(20(2 ?# 74A?)0( 2A#-C* T)P A4m-0A4 *C470)/ 7#(74A(H .-? 0? G#4*(#? 7#(*?0?-?4 )(P *C470>07 1-T)( A021?*F c#A ?14*4 -(0I4A*)/ A021?* )A4 (#? G0YI0*0./4H .-? )/6)P*H 4I4AP614A4 )(G >#A )// T)(G)?#AP )(G #(4 T-*? )I#0G) *0?-)?0#( 0( 61071 ?14 A4>4A4(74 ?# )//424G 1-T)( A021?* >#A #(4 *#70)/ 2A#-C7)-*4* G0*7A0T0()?0#( )2)0(*? )(#?14A 2A#-CF

D> G02(0?P 6)* (#? ) >-(G)T4(?)/ I)/-4H .-? #(/P h )* D T4(?0#(4G 0( ?14/47?-A4+* ?0?/4 h *#T4?10(2 !2A)(?4G+ #A !)**02(4G+H 61)? 6#-/G )7?-)//P CA4Y

Z\

7/-G4 *0TC/P A4>-*0(2 G02(0?P 0( 74A?)0( *0?-)?0#(* h .#?1 0( A4/)?0#( ?# 74A?)0(2A#-C*H )* 64// )* ?# *C470>07 0(G0I0G-)/*l B)71 #(4 #> -* $(#6* *-71 C/)74* )(GC4A0#G* 0( ?14 10*?#AP #> T)($0(G 614( 0? 6)* 1)CC4(0(2 )(G *?0// 1)CC4(*F34(74 1-T)( G02(0?P T-*? .4 ?A4)?4G /0$4 ) -(0I4A*)/ )(G 0()/04()./4 I)/-4H )**#T4?10(2 0(()?4 ?# 1-T)( .40(2*F K-? ?10* *?)?4T4(? *?0// G#4* (#? CA#I0G4 )()(*64A ?# ?14 m-4*?0#( #( 614A4 ?10* G02(0?P 7#T4* >A#T )(G 614A4 0?* I4AP#A020(* )A4F D? #(/P *)P* ?1)? T)( 1)* ?10* G02(0?P h .-? 61Pl <14 >0A*? )(*64A7#-/G 2# /0$4 ?10*J T)( 1)* G02(0?PH .47)-*4 14 0*H )* ?14 =#T)( C10/#*#C14A)(G ?A)(*/)?#A #> MA0*?#?/4 )(G @1A0*?0)( ?14#/#20)( K#4?10-*H >#//#64G .P Q?<1#T)* Mm-0()*H -*4G ?# *)PJ !+#?,"#: "#?6%+#D68 6+56I65,# 8,A8?#+?6#+j *#H ?#C-? 0? *?A)021? )(G *0TC/PH !)( 0(G0I0G-)/ 4(G#64G 60?1 A)?0#()/ ()?-A4+F <14*46#AG* T)$4 -C ?14 7/)**07 G4>0(0?0#( #> !C4A*#(+F L)( 0* )( 0(G0I0G-)/ .40(2?1)? 0* 4i74C?0#()/ )(G -(0m-4F 34 0* 4(G#64G 60?1 A4)*#( ?1)? )//#6* 10T ?#24? ?# $(#6 ?14 6#A/G )(G 10T*4/>F "1)? D+T *)P0(2 14A4H 0* (#? #(/P ?14@1A0*?0)( T4**)24H .-? ) *?)?4T4(? -(G4A 61071 )?140*?* 7#-/G )/*# *02(J L)(HP#-+A4 ) -(0m-4 7A4)?0#( 4(G#64G 60?1 A4)*#(H 61071 0* *#T4?10(2 T#A4 ?1)(N-*? ) T4)*-A)./4 T)??4AF <1)?+* 61P P#- 1)I4 ) G02(0?P ?1)? P#- 7)( (4I4A/#*4H N-*? )* P#- 7)((#? 20I4 -C .40(2 1-T)(F R02(0?P 0* *#T4?10(2 ?1)? #?14A*7)((#? 20I4 P#-H .47)-*4 0? .4/#(2* #(/P ?# P#- >A#T ?14 I4AP .420((0(2F <10*0* G02(0?P ?1)? )/6)P* A4T)0(* 7#(*?)(? )(G G#4* (#? $(#6 ) 2A4)?4A #A *T)//4AI)/-4H .47)-*4 ?14A4 0* (# G0>>4A4(74 ?# 0? 614?14A P#- )A4 ) 1-T)( 0( ?144T.AP#(07 *?)24 #A )( 4/G4A/P C4A*#(H #A 0> P#- )A4 )? ?14 C4)$ #> P#-A C1P*0Y7)/ )(G T4(?)/ C#64AF <14A4 0* (# G0>>4A4(74 614?14A P#- )A4 T)/4 #A >4T)/4H614?14A P#- )A4 ) 70?0O4( #> #(4 *?)?4 #A )(#?14AF L)( 1)* ?14A4>#A4 #(?#/#20Y7)/ G02(0?P ?1)? 0* 0(*7A0.4G 0( 10* .40(2F <14A4>#A4H 4i0*?4(74 0* ) G4?4AT0()(?#> 1-T)(H T#A)/ /0>4F

<10* 0* 4i)7?/P 614A4 64 )A4 G4)/0(2 60?1 *#T4 ?A)C 0(14A4(? ?# ?14 C10/#Y*#C107)/ ?1#-21? #> S)(?F M/?1#-21 )/*# >#A S)(?H )? ?14 A##? #> 1-T)( G02(0?P/04* ?14 >)7? ?1)? T)( 0* )( 0(?4//024(? .40(2F K-? ?14 54AT)( C10/#*#C14A *44$*?10* G02(0?P 0( !)7?0I4/P+ 4iC4A04(70(2 .40(2 ) T)(H 0( 61)? 0* 7)//4G !7#(*70#-*4(?0?P+F S)(? (#?074* )(G A47#2(0O4* G02(0?P 0( ) ?10($0(2 )(G >A44 1-T)( .40(2H61# ?1)($* ?# ?14 C#64A #> 10* T0(G 0* 7)C)./4 #> T#A)/0?P )(G )-?#(#TP #>60//H ?14A4>#A4 #> 7)-*0(2 ?1)? ?14 60//H ?1)($* ?# 0?* T)i0TH 7#-/G )/*# 7#(*0G4A0?*4/> ?# .4 -(0I4A*)//P /420*/)?0I4F <1)? 0* 61P A4*4)A714A* )A4 *?0// G4.)?0(2614?14A S)(?H ?)$0(2 N-*? *-71 ) *?)(74H 6#-/G (#?074 #A A47#2(0O4 ?14 G02(0?P#> ) T)( 61#*4 T0(G 6#-/G /#*4 T#T4(?-TH #A 6#-/G 1)I4 ?# .4 7#(*0G4A4G!0()7?0I4+ h )* 0( ?14 7)*4 #> ) T)( T4(?)//P A4?)AG4G #A 7#T)?#*4F

<AP0(2 ?# /0($ G02(0?P 60?1 A4)*#(H >A44G#T )(G T#A)/0?PH S)(? G#4* (#? 20I4) *)?0*>)7?#AP )(G )-?14(?07 A4*C#(*4 ?# ?14 m-4*?0#( ).#-? ?14 *#-A74 #> G02(0?PFD( 10* ?10($0(2 )( 0(G0I0G-)/ 0* G4CA0I4G #> )(P )-A) #> T4?)C1P*07*H )(G ?14A4Y

Z[

>#A4 A4T)0(* ?A)CC4G 0( 0?*4/>H 60?10( ?14 /0T0?* #> ?140A #6( 7#2(0?0#( )(G ?140A#6( ).0/0?04*j 0? 0* )( 4(?0?P ?1)? G#4* (#? 1)I4 )774** ?# )(#?14A ?A-?1 4i74C? ?14#(4 #> 0?* #6(H 4I4(?-)//P 7#(*?A-7?4G >#A 0?* #6( (44G*F

D( #AG4A ?# >)?1#T 1-T)( G02(0?PH T4?)C1P*07)/ )6)A4(4** )(G ) !A4)/0*?07+H0(G4C4(G4(? )(G )774**0./4 7#(74C? #> ?A-?1 )A4 (44G4Gj P#- (44G ?# 7A#** ?14A#)G /4)G0(2 >A#T ) C14(#T4(#( ?# 0?* >#-(G)?0#(*F D( ?14 B(7P7/07)/ P65:8 :?Q#?6% 64 A4)GJ !<14A4 0* ) (44G >#A ) C10/#*#C1P #> 24(-0(4/P T4?)C1P*07)/ *7#C4HD T4)(H #(4 ?1)? 0* 7)C)./4 #> ?A)(*74(G0(2 4TC0A07)/ G)?) 0( #AG4A ?# G0*7#I4A*#T4?10(2 ).*#/-?4H -/?0T)?4 )(G >-(G)T4(?)/ 0( 0?* m-4*? >#A ?14 ?A-?1F unv D(?10* *4(*4H T4?)C1P*07* *1#-/G (#? .4 7#(*0G4A4G )* )( )/?4A()?0I4 ?# )(?1A#C#/Y#2PH *0(74 T4?)C1P*07* 0* 61)? )//#6* P#- ?# N-*?0>P ?14 7#(74C? #> C4A*#()/G02(0?P C#0(?0(2 #-? 0?* *C0A0?-)/ ()?-A4F+\

3#64I4AH #-A "4*?4A( 7#(74C? #> G02(0?P 1)* G44C4A A##?* ?1)( ?1#*4 G4>0(0Y?0#(* #> ) T4?)C1P*07)/ )(G #(?#/#207)/ ()?-A4H *0(74 0? CA#I0G4* (#? #(/P ) *-.YN47?0I4H .-? )/*# )( #.N47?0I4 *-.*?)(?0)?0#( #> G02(0?PF _-A G4>0(0?0#( #> 1-T)(G02(0?P 1)* .44( *1)C4G .P ?14 ^-G4#Y@1A0*?0)( ?A)G0?0#(H 61071 )* ) ?14#/#207)/6#A/GI046 2#4* .4P#(G C-A4/P C10/#*#C107)/ I046* )(G G#4* (#? 7#(?A)G07? ?14TH.-? A)?14A )GG0?0#()//P *?A4(2?14(* )(G G44C4(* ?14TF _> 7#-A*4H ?14 m-4*?0#()A0*4* 614?14A 0( ?14 *47-/)A 6#A/G 0? 0* C#**0./4 ?# CA#T#?4 ?14 7#(74C? #> G02Y(0?PH 61071 A4>4A* (#? #(/P ?# .4/04> 0( 5#GH .-? *C470>07)//P ?# ?14 @1A0*?0)(TP*?4AP #> A4I4/)?0#(l

M? ?10* C#0(? 0? 0* 6#A?1 A4?-A(0(2 ?# Q? <1#T)* Mm-0()*F 3)I0(2 10* ?1#-21?*)* )( 4i)TC/4H #(4 7)( 7/4)A/P *1#6 ?14 71)(24 ?1)? #77-AA4G 0( ?14 "4*?4A(-(G4A*?)(G0(2 #> ?14 7#(74C? #> G02(0?PF "10/4 0( )(704(? ?0T4* ?14 74(?A4 #>)??4(?0#( 6)* !7#TT-(0?P+H 61071 6)* 20I4( CA474G4(74 #I4A )( 0(G0I0G-)/ )(G?1-* G02(0?P #> 74A?)0( *#70)/ 2A#-C* 6)* 0( ?14 >0A*? C/)74H ?14 ?1#-21? #> Q?<1#T)* 0* )(71#A4G 0( ?14 ^-G4#Y@1A0*?0)( ?A)G0?0#(F <1-*H *?)A?0(2 60?1 ?14*C0A0? )(G ?14 6#A$ #> ?14 @A4)?#AH 4I4AP C4A*#( 1)* G02(0?P )(G )( 0((4AH 0TT)Y(4(? I)/-4F 5#G 7)A4* >#A 4)71 #> -*F M(P?10(2 4/*4 ?1)? 0* (#? 1-T)( /0>4 >0(G*(# T4)(0(2 #> 4i0*?4(74 0( 0?*4/>F <14 T#*? 0TC#A?)(? 14A4 0* ?14 CA4*4AI)?0#( #>?14 4i0*?4(74 #> #-A #6( *C4704*F _(/P ) T)( =+#?,"#D6?:" D6A:" :? >"%>?:" 8:6>F8,G :R68?:+8:@[ h .P 10* I4AP ()?-A4 0* >A44 )(G 4i0*?0(2 >#A 10T*4/>F L)( )*) >A44 .40(2H -(/0$4 )(0T)/*H 0* (#? 2-0G4G .P 0(*?0(7?*F L)( A47#2(0O4* ?14 C#64A#> 10* #6( A4)*#(H 61071 0* 7#(*0*?4(? 60?1 10* ()?-A4F K-? 0> 1-T)( G02(0?P 0* ?#.4 A4*C47?4GH ?14( 7#2(0?0#( 7)( ?)$4 C/)74 #(/P .P >A44 60//F BI4( 5#G !*-AA4(YG4A*+ 30* #6( A-/4* #> 1-T)( >A44G#T )(G G02(0?PH )* 7)( .4 *44( 4I4( 0( *-71

\ ^#1( ,)-/ DDH P65:8 :? "#?6% okMQ :Z[pH :VVXH (# XZF[ Q? <1#T)* Mm-0()*H K,GG# 3<:%D%46#:H DDYDDH mF ;\ )F 8 )G ZF

Z;

) GA)T)?07 *0?-)?0#(H 614( 34 )//#6* T)( ?# 7#TC/4?4/P )(G G4>0(0?0I4/P A4N47?10TF D(G0I0G-)/ 1-T)( G02(0?P 0* ?14A4>#A4 0(4i?A07)./P /0($4G ?# 10* #6( A4Y*C#(*0.0/0?PF Q#H T)( 0* ?14 #(4 61# 0* A4*C#(*0./4 >#A 10* #6( /0>4H 10* #6(G470*0#(*H >#A *1)C0(2 10* 7#(*704(74F "0?1 ?10* A4*C#(*0.0/0?P 14 *?)(G* )/#(4)2)0(*? 5#G )(G #?14A*F

M* 64 7)( *44H 0( ?14 ?1#-21? #> Q? <1#T)*H G02(0?P 0* /0($4G ?# ?14 G4>0(0Y?0#( #> ) C4A*#( )(G ?1-* 60?1 =+#?,"# "#?6%+#D68@F ^-*? /0$4 ?14 G4>0(0?0#( #>) C4A*#(H ?14 0(?4ACA4?)?0#( #> G02(0?P G#4* (#? 1)I4 0?* *#-A74* 0( T)(F D( ?14>0A*? C/)74H )(G 0( ?14 .0224*?H G44C4*? *4(*4H .#?1 0(?4ACA4?)?0#(* A4>4A ?# 5#GFL)( )* ) C4A*#( 0( )// 10* G02(0?P 6)* 7A4)?4G 0( ?14 0T)24 )(G /0$4(4** #> 5#GF<1-*H ?14 *#-A74 )(G ?14 >0A*? !CA#?47?#A+ #> 1-T)( G02(0?P 0* 5#G ?14 @A4)?#A61# 7A4)?4G T)( #> 10* #6( 60// )(G #> /#I4F <10* A4/)?0#(*10C 60?1 5#G ?14@A4)?#A )(G @1A0*?H ?14 Q)I0#-A #> T)($0(GH A4T)0(* )( ).*#/-?4 (474**0?P >#A@1A0*?0)(* ?# 0G4(?0>P 1-T)( ()?-A4J !L)( 7)((#? /0I4 60?1#-? /#I4F L)( A4YT)0(* ) .40(2 ?1)? 0* 0(7#TCA414(*0./4 >#A 10T*4/>j 10* /0>4 0* *4(*4/4**H 0> `#I40* (#? A4I4)/4G ?# 10TH 0> 14 G#4* (#? 4(7#-(?4A `#I4H 0> 14 G#4* (#? 4iC4A04(740? )(G T)$4 0? 10* #6(H 0> 14 G#4* (#? C)A?070C)?4 0(?0T)?4/P 0( 0?F M(G ?1)? 0* 61P@1A0*? ?14 =4G44T4AH )* 1)* )/A4)GP .44( *)0GH r>-//P A4I4)/* T)( ?# T)( 10TY*4/>sF D? 0* ?10* h 0> P#- 60// h 1-T)( G0T4(*0#( #> ?14 LP*?4AP #> =4G4TC?0#(FM T)( >0(G* 10* G-4 2A4)?(4**H G02(0?P )(G I)/-4 #> 10* 1-T)(0?P 0( 0?F unv"1)? $0(G #> I)/-4 T-*? T)( 1)I4 0( ?14 4P4* #> ?14 @A4)?#A 0> 14 G4*4AI4* *-71) 2A4)? =4G44T4A unvH 0> 5#G r2)I4 10* #(/P Q#(s *# ?1)? T)( r*1#-/G (#?C4A0*1 .-? 1)I4 4?4A()/ /0>4s o7>F ^( ZJ :;pF <1)? G44C )T)O4T4(? ).#-? ?14 I)/-4)(G G02(0?P 0* ?14 5#*C4/H #A 5##G U46*F+;

L)(H 4(G#64G 60?1 A4)*#( )(G >A44 60//H 0* ) >)0?1>-/ 0T)24 #> 5#G )(G?14A4.P 0* )./4 ?# 0T0?)?4 10* @A4)?#A )(G 4(G#6 10T 60?1 /#I4F _(/P 0( ?10*@1A0*?0)( C4A*C47?0I4 1)* 14 G#(4 *#T4?10(2 ?1)? )? #(4 ?0T4 CA#>4**#A S)A#/"#N?P/) G4*7A0.4G )* ) !C#*0?0I4+ 71)(24 #> ?14 7)?42#A07)/ 0TC4A)?0I4J ?14 1-YT)( C4A*#( 0* *-71 ) 2A4)? 2##G(4** ?1)? #(/P /#I4 7A4)?4* ?14 T#*? *-0?)./4HA021? )??0?-G4 >#A 14AFWF <10* 0* ?14 *?)?4T4(? ?1)? S)(? 1)G (4I4A .44( )./4 ?#>#AT-/)?4F <14 G4A0I)?0#( #> ?10* >#AT-/) >A#T ?14 ?1#-21? #> /#I0(2 5#G ?14@A4)?#A )(G =4G44T4AH 61071 G47/)A4* ?1)? T)( 0* /0?4A)//P !6#A?1P #> /#I4+H61071 T4)(* ?1)? ?14 0(?A0(*07 I)/-4 #> 1-T)( /#I4 2#4* .4P#(G C10/#*#C107)/

; ^#1( ,)-/ DDH Q:5:G>?%" <%G6+68 okMQ ;pH :VWVH (#F :9F M/*# 7#TC)A4 (#F 8:J !MT0G )// ?10*64)/?1H #(4H 1#64I4AH *44T* ?# .4 ?14 T#*? 0TC#A?)(?J ?14 A#P)/ C)A?070C)?0(2 0( ?14 T0**0#( #>@1A0*? T4)(* A4G0*7#I4A0(2 0( #(4*4/> )(G 0( #?14A* ?10* *C470)/ G02(0?P #> ?14 G0I0(4 7)//H 610717)( .4 G4*7A0.4G )* !$0(2*10C+F <10* G02(0?P 0* 4iCA4**4G 0( A4)G0(4** ?# *4AI4 ?14 4i)TC/4 #>@1A0*?H 61# 7)T4 (#? ?# .4 *4AI4GH .-? >#A 30T ?# *4AI4+ o7#TCF L? 89J 8XpF

W S)A#/ "#N?P&)H S%I: #+5 Q:8>%+86A6D6?-' `-./0( 899:F

ZW

A4>/47?0#( )(G A4m-0A4* #> -* *#T4?10(2 T#A4 ?1)( N-*? 7#TC/0)(74 60?1 ?14 CA#Y10.0?0#( #> G4)/0(2 60?1 T4( )* ) T4)(* ?# )??)0( ?10* C-AC#*4F <10* 0* ?14 *?)A?Y0(2 C#0(? >#A ?14 0TC/4T4(?)?0#( #> ?14 C#/07PH 61#*4 *#-A74 #> 0(*C0A)?0#( 0*@1A0*?0)(0?P )(G ?1)? *-CC#A?* *-71 7#(G0?0#(* #> /0>4 614A4 1-T)( /#I4 7)(2A#6 )(G T)?-A4F D( ?10* 7#(?4i?H D ?10($H >#A 4i)TC/4H #> ?14 CA0#A0?P 61071 0*G-4 ?# ?14 0(*?0?-?0#( #> T)AA0)24 )(G ?14 >)T0/P )2)0(*? )// #?14A >#AT* #> *#70)/0(*?0?-?0#(*F

"1)? *1#-/G 64 )(G 61)? G# 64 6)(? ?# *?)(G >#Al @)( ?14 T0(GH *4C)A)?4G>A#T #-A #A020(* ?1)?H )* @1A0*?0)(*H 64 A47#2(0O4 0( 5#GH .4 ?14 #(/P 2-)A)(?44#> CA4*4AI0(2 T#A)/0?P )(G ?1-* 7#TC/P0(2 60?1 ?14 G02(0?P #> 4I4AP 1-T)(.40(2l @)( 64 )//#6 ) *0?-)?0#( 0( 61071 ?14A4 )A4 )??4TC?* ?# 2A)G-)//P 4/0T0Y()?4 ?14 4**4(74 #> -(G4A*?)(G0(2 ) T)( 0( 10* C4A*#()/ G02(0?P #> ?14 1-T)(C4A*#(H 61#*4 *#-A74 /04* 0( ?14 @1A0*?0)( ?A)G0?0#(H ?14A4>#A4 0( ?14 @1A0*?0)(I0*0#( #> T)(H )(G 61071 0* )/*# ?14 >#-(G)?0#( #> #-A 7#(*?0?-?0#( )(G #-A/420*/)?0#(l <14 >)7? ?1)? ?10* 0* 1)CC4(0(2 0* CA#I4( (#? #(/P .P ?14 4I4(?*)A#-(G ?14 ,/)((4G ,)A4(?1##G #A2)(0O)?0#(F !"14A4I4A 5#G G#4* (#? 1)I4 ?14>0A*? C/)74H 614A4 34 0* (#? A47#2(0O4G )* ?14 10214*? 2##G )(G 6#A*10C4GH 1-YT)( G02(0?P 0* )? *?)$4F+X

<10* @1A0*?0)( I046 0* #>?4( C4A740I4G )* )AA#2)(?F D? 0* 4I4( A4N47?4GH 7/)0TY0(2 ?1)? 0? !0* (#? )./4 ?# 2)?14A ?14 T)N#A0?P+F D( I046 #> *-71 #C0(0#(* 64*1#-/G A4T)0( 7)/T )(G *?0// $44C ?AP0(2 ?# 7#(I0(74 h .47)-*4 T)( 0* 6#A?1 0?F

X K4(4G07? xkDH M(24/-* >A#T 8X M-2-*?H899[F

ZX

<*&+01*6 !H9:*&* !'-;&'. I*00#%)'$+, 5#+%$#%<" )* ;'+$)<"7 ",#@ )* +", 0#%)'$+, !"3%<"

J>=>9? 94 8366B4= 43 8366B4= K>9:429 E>=>9?I

D? 0* 60?1 C/4)*-A4 ?1)? D 2A44?H >0A*? #> )//H 30* BT0(4(74 @)AG0()/ Q?)(0*&)6RO060*OH L4?A#C#/0?)( #> SA)$#6H )(G ,A#>4**#A <)G4-*O ,04A#(4$H 71)0AT)(#> ?14 #A2)(0O0(2 7#TT0??44 #> ?10* 7#(>4A4(74F D 60*1 ?# ?1)($ ?14T >#A 0(I0?Y0(2 T4 )(G 20I0(2 T4 ?14 N#P ?# ?)$4 C)A? 0( ?14 :[?1 ^-.0/44 D(?4A()?0#()/ @#(Y>4A4(74 #( ?14 !=#/4 #> ?14 @)?1#/07 @1-A71 0( ?14 B-A#C4)( D(?42A)?0#( ,A#7Y4**J R02(0?P h cA44G#T h 3-T)( =021?*+F D )T )*$4G ?# )GGA4** ?14 >#//#60(2?14T4J !?14 /0T0?* #> >A44G#T #A >A44G#T 60?1#-? /0T0?*l+ D 60// G4I4/#C 0? 0(?1A44 C#0(?* >#//#64G .P ) 7#(7/-*0#(F

"L %:6 93>2@6 48 B>F@>9AM 8366B4= <@B :2=<@ 3>F:9?M <@B >9? 534NE6=?

<14 ?A0-(4 #> G02(0?PH >A44G#T )(G 1-T)( A021?* 0* )( 0(?42A)/ C)A? #> ?14I4AP 4**4(74 #> @1A0*?0)( 7-/?-A4 )(G 0? T)$4* -C ?14 CA0(70C)/ 7#TC#(4(?* #>?14 B-A#C4)( @1A0*?0)( 14A0?)24H 61071 Q)0(? ^#1( ,)-/ DD 6)(?4G 0(7/-G4G 0(?14 @#(*?0?-?0#( #> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( ?# 7#(*?0?-?4 ?14 .)*0* #> B-A#C4)( 0(?4Y2A)?0#( 610/4 *)>42-)AG0(2 ?14 *C470>07 0G4(?0?P #> 4)71 7#-(?AP )(G ?14 7#TYT#( B-A#C4)( 7-/?-A4:F

<10*q?A0-(4 0* )/A4)GP C-? .4>#A4 ?14 7#(*704(74 #> B-A#C4F K-? 60?1 ?141-24 0(>/-i #> A4>-244*H ?1#*4 G0*C/)74G )(G 4T02A)(?*H 4T)()?0(2 >A#T ) G0>Y>4A4(? 7-/?-A4H ?14 CA#./4T .47#T4* T#A4 )7-?4 *?0//F <10* 0* ?14 B-A#C4)(71)//4(24F <14 B-A#C4)( @#TT-(0?P 1)* .44( 7)C)./4 #> T)0(?)0(0(2 ) 74AY?)0( 1)AT#(P )T#(2 C4#C/4 >A#T G0>>4A4(? ()?0#(* )(G I)A04G 10*?#A07)/ 7#(Y?4i?*H CA470*4/P .47)-*4 #> 0?* .)*07 @1A0*?0)( 0G4(?0?PF 3#6 60// 0? .4 )./4 (#6?# *)>42-)AG 0?* 0G4(?0?P 0( ?14 )7?-)/ 7#(?4i? #> T-/?04?1(070*T )(G T-/?07-/?-AY)/0*Tl

D( ?14 7#-(?A04* #> ?14 L0GG/4 B)*?H 60?1 ?14 4i74C?0#( #> `4.)(#(H G02(0?PH>A44G#T )(G 1-T)( A021?* )A4 (#? A4*C47?4GF <10* 0* G-4 ?# ?140A ?14#7A)?07 C#/0?Y07)/ A420T4*F 3#64I4AH @1A0*?0)(* C)** #( ?1#*4 I)/-4* ?1A#-21 ?14 G0)/#2-4 #>

: MC#*?#/07 Bi1#A?)?0#(J !B77/4*0) 0( B-A#C)+

ZV

/0>4H #> 7-/?-A4 )(G 7#TT#( G4*?0(PF 34(74 ?14 0TC#A?)(74 #> @1A0*?0)( CA4*Y4(74 0( ?14 L0GG/4 B)*? )(G ?14 A#/4 #> `4.)(#( 0( C)A?07-/)A ?1)($* ?# 0?* 24#YC#/0?07)/ *C470>070?P8F

D( 4>>47?H `4.)(#( *4C)A)?4* A4/020#( )(G *?)?4H )(G 610/4 A4(G4A0(2 1#T)24?# M/T021?P 5#G 0? A4*C47?* )// A4/020#(*H )* 64// )* ?14 G0I0(4 /)6H .#?1 A4YI4)/4G )(G ()?-A)/ZF M* ) A4*-/?H `4.)(#( A47#2(0O4* )// A4/020#-* )(G 70I0/ ?PC4*#> >A44G#T*H )* 64// )* )// 1-T)( A021?*F

D( #AG4A >#A ?14 ?A0-(4 #> G02(0?PH >A44G#T )(G 1-T)( A021?* ?# .4 A47#2(0O4G0( ?14 MA). 7#-(?A04*H ?14P #-21? ?# .4 14/C4G ?# 0T0?)?4 `4.)(#( )(G ).)(G#(?14 A4/020#-* C#/0?07)/ *P*?4TH ?1)? 0*H ?14#7A)7PF D( ?1#*4 7#-(?A04*H D*/)T 0* ?14A4/020#( #> ?14 *?)?4H ?14 S#A)( 0* ?14 *#-A74 #> 70I0/ /420*/)?0#(H )(G ?14 C#/0?0Y7)/H N-G070)AP )(G T0/0?)AP C#64A* )A4 0( L-*/0T 1)(G*F

""L $49>4@ <@B E>=>9? 48 8366B4=

cA44G#TH )77#AG0(2 ?# @1-A71 ?4)710(2 )(G ?14 @1A0*?0)( I0*0#(H 1)* 0?* .0.Y/07)/ >#-(G)?0#( 0( ?14 K##$ #> 54(4*0*J !5#G 7A4)?4G T)( 0( ?14 0T)24 #> 30TY*4/>+ o5(F :J8WpH 61# 0* ?14 )// ).*#/-?4J ).*#/-?4 >A44G#TH ).*#/-?4 60// )(G).*#/-?4 /#I4F M* >#A T)( 61# 0* 7A4)?4GH 14 0* *-.N47? ?# >0(0?-G4F <10* 0* 61P14y*14 0* 0( ?14 0T)24 #> 5#GH )(G (#? ?14 0T)24 #> 5#GF K40(2 *-.N47? ?# >0(0Y?-G4 )(G 7#(G0?0#(4G .P *C)74 )(G ?0T4H 10* >A44G#TH 10* 60// )(G 10* /#I4 )A4/0T0?4GF

cA44G#T ?)$4* G0>>4A4(? >#AT*J T4?)C1P*07)/ >A44G#TH C*P71#/#207)/ >A44YG#TH T#A)/H A4/020#-* )(G C#/0?07)/ >A44G#TF <14A4 )A4 )/*# C)A?07-/)A >A44G#T*H*-71 )* >A44G#T #> ?1#-21?H >A44G#T #> )7?0#(H >A44G#T #> 4iCA4**0#(H >A44YG#T #> 7#(*704(74H >A44G#T #> 71#074H >A44G#T ?# 4i71)(24 )(G >A44G#T ?#4T02A)?4F

c#A >A44G#T ?# .4 )-?14(?07H 0(G4C4(G4(?/P #> 0?* ?PC4H 0? #-21? ?# .4 /0T0?4G.P ?A-?1 )(G 2##G(4**F <1#*4 ?6# (#?0#(* *47-A4 >#A ?14 1-T)( C4A*#( 10*y14A2A#6?1 )(G T)?-A0?P\H .47)-*4 >A44G#T 0* A##?4G 0( A4)*#(H 61071 0* ?14 >)7-/?P#> ?A-?1H )(G 0( ?14 60//H 61071 0* ?14 >)7-/?P #> ?14 2##G(4**[F <14 >A44G#T 1)*)/*# /0T0?* 4T)()?0(2 >A#T C-./07 #AG4AH 61071 0TC#*4* (#AT* ?1)? A42-/)?4 ?144i4A70*4 #> #(4+* A021? ?# >A44G#T;F

8 MC#*?#/07 Bi1#A?)?0#(J !U46 3#C4 >#A `4.)(#(+H V9hV:Z Q44F `4.)(4*4 @#(*?0?-?0#(H MA?F V\ @)?4710*T #> ?14 @)?1#/07 @1-A71H :WZ:[ Q44 :F7; Q44 R47/)A)?0#( #( =4/020#-* cA44G#TH oR3p 8 z W

\9

<1#*4 (#AT* 7)( .4 A4G-74G ?# ?1A44J:F _.*4AI4 ?14 CA0(70C/4 #> T#A)/ )(G *#70)/ C4A*#()/ A4*C#(*0.0/0?P 614( )(

0(G0I0G-)/ #A ) 2A#-C 4i4A70*4 ?140A A021? ?# >A44G#TF D( I0A?-4 #> ?14 T#AY)/ /)6H ?1#*4 #-21? ?# 20I4 4m-)/ 7#(*0G4A)?0#( ?# ?14 A021?* #> #?14A*H )(G?# ?140A G-?04* ?#6)AG* ?14T )(G ?#6)AG* ?14 7#TT#( 2##GF

8F ,A#?47? 70I0/ *#704?P )2)0(*? ?A#-./4* ?1)? 7#-/G 4A-C? )* ) CA4?4i? >#A ?144i4A70*4 #> >A44G#TH #( ?14 7#(G0?0#( ?1)? ?1)? CA#?47?0#( 0* (#? G#(4 0( )()A.0?A)AP 6)PH .-? 0( )77#AG)(74 60?1 ?14 N-A0G07)/ (#AT* )(G 0( 7#(>#ATY0?P 60?1 ?14 #.N47?0I4 T#A)/ #AG4AF

ZF R4>4(G ?14 A021?* #> 70?0O4(* >#A ?14 *)$4 #> C-./07 C4)74H )(G >#A ?14.4(4>0? #> ) 7#(I0I0)/0?P 4i4A70*4G 0( )77#AG)(74 60?1 ?A-4 N-*?074 )(G ?14CA4*4AI)?0#( #> C-./07 T#A)/0?PF

<14 /0T0?* #> >A44G#T G# (#? /4)G ?# ?14 (42)?0#( #> A4*C#(*0.0/0?PF <14P7#(*?0?-?4H #( ?14 7#(?A)APH ?14 >#-(G)?0#( >#A ) T#A)/ A4*C#(*0.0/0?P 0( )77#AGY)(74 60?1 ?14 >0(0?-G4 #> ?14 1-T)( C4A*#(F cA44G#T T)$4* ?14 1-T)( C4A*#(A4*C#(*0./4 >#A 10*y14A )7?0#(* .47)-*4 0? 0(I#/I4* ?14 >A44G#T ?# 71##*4 .4Y?644( 2##G )(G 4I0/H )(G ?14A4>#A4 ?14 >A44G#T ?# 2A#6 0( C4A>47?0#( #A ?#>)/?4A )(G *0(F cA44G#T 0* ) 71)A)7?4A0*?07 #> 4I4AP 1-T)( )7?F D? .47#T4*) *#-A74 #> CA)0*4 614( 0? A4*C47?* 0?* /0T0?*H )(G A4)*#( >#A ./)T4 614( 0?/0.4A)?4* 0?*4/> #> )// /0T0?*F <14 T#A4 64 G# 2##G )(G /0I4 0( ?14 ?A-?1H ?14>A44A 64 .47#T4F <14 #(/P ?A-4 >A44G#T 0* ?14 #(4 ?1)? *4AI4* 61)? 0* N-*? )(G61)? 0* 2##GF <# 71##*4 G0*#.4G04(74 )(G 4I0/ 0* )( ).-*4 #> >A44G#T )(G 0?/4)G* ?# !?14 */)I4AP #> *0(+FW

L#A4#I4AH 4I4AP 1-T)( C4A*#( 0* 0( m-4*? #> 10* 1)CC0(4** 61071 0* ?14-/?0T)?4 C#0(? #> )// 10* m-4*?*H )// 10* )T.0?0#(* )(G )// 10* *)7A0>074*F 3)CC0Y(4** 0* 0(?0T)?4/P /0($4G 60?1 >A44G#TF <14A4 0* (# 1)CC0(4** 60?1#-? >A44G#TFD( >)7?H >A44G#T 0* )( 0(?42A)/ C)A? #> ?14 1-T)( C4A*#(j 0? 0* 0(G44G ?14 CA0T#AYG0)/ 7#TC#(4(? #> 10* 4**4(74F D? 0* ?14A4>#A4 10*y14A ()?-A)/ A021? ?# .4 A4*C47?Y4G )(G A47#2(0O4G )* ) >A44 )(G A4*C#(*0./4 .40(2F

"""L O36?6@9 534NE6=?

<14 A021? ?# 4i4A70*4 #(4+* >A44G#T 0* )( 0(*4C)A)./4 G4T)(G >A#T ?14 G02Y(0?P #> ?14 1-T)( C4A*#(F <10* 0* ) A021? ?1)? #-21? ?# .4 A47#2(0O4G )(G CA#?47?Y4G .P 70I0/ *#704?P 60?10( ?14 /0T0?* #> ?14 7#TT#( 2##G )(G ?14 C-./07 #AG4AXF

W Q44 @)?4710*T #> ?14 @)?1#/07 @1-A71H :WZ8h:WZ\X Q44 R47/)A)?0#( #( =4/020#-* cA44G#T oR3p 8 z W

\:

<14 m-4*?0#( 0* )*$4G 60?1 ?14 0(>/-i #> 6)I4* #> 4T02A)(?* >A#T G0>>4A4(? 7-/Y?-A4*H )(G T#A4 )(G T#A4 (#6)G)P*H 60?1 ?14 1-(GA4G* #> ?1#-*)(G* #> G0*YC/)74G QPA0)(* )(G DA)m0* 4(?4A0(2 ?14 B-A#C4)( 7#-(?A04* 0//42)//P )(G *44$0(2A4>-24 ?14A4F 34A4 *4I4A)/ A021?* A4/)?4G ?# >A44G#T )A4 )T)/2)T)?4GJ ?14 A021?#> )*P/-TH ?14 A021? ?# .4 A4740I4G 0( ) 1-T)(0?)A0)( *C0A0?H ?14 A021? ?# 71##*461071 7#-(?AP ?# 2# ?#H ?# *4??/4 ?14A4 )(G >0(G 6#A$ 0( 0?H 4?7F

<1)? T-/?0Y>)74?4G >A44G#T 7#-/G .4 4iC/#0?4G .P 7A0T0()/ 0G4#/#204*H #A >#AC)A?07-/)A C#/0?07#Y*?A)?4207 C-AC#*4*F D? 7#-/G )/*# .4 -*4G )* ) ?##/ ?# 7A4)?4 71)#*HT-?0/)?4 ) 7-/?-A4H CA#I#$4 7#(>4**0#()/ 7#(>/07?H #A *#70#Y47#(#T07 0T.)/)(74 )(G0(*47-A0?PH #A T#A4 *?0//H #C4( ) >A44 C)**)24 ?# I0#/4(74 )(G ?4AA#A0*TF

"10/4 A47#2(0O0(2 ?14 A021? ?# 4i4A70*4 #(4+* >A44G#TH 64 #-21? ?# 4m-)//PA47#2(0O4 0?* /0T0?*H ?1)? 0*J ?14 7#TT#( 2##GH ?14 C-./07 #AG4AH ?14 *)>42-)AGY0(2 #> 7-/?-A4* h ?14 7-/?-A4 #> ?14 7#-(?AP #> #A020( )(G ?1)? #> ?14 64/7#T0(27#-(?AP h )(G ?14 CA#T#?0#( #> /#7)/H A420#()/ )(G 6#A/G C4)74F

H4@CE2?>4@D( #AG4A ?# *)>42-)AG B-A#C4)( 0G4(?0?P )(G >)70/0?)?4 0(?42A)?0#(H )(G ?#

14/C ?14 MA). 7#-(?A04* )/*# ?# *)>42-)AG ?140A 0G4(?0?P )(G ?140A 7-/?-A)/ 14A0?Y)24H 0? 0* ).*#/-?4/P 0TC4A)?0I4 ?1)? ?14 0(?4A()?0#()/ 7#TT-(0?P *1#-/G G4C/#P)// 0?* 4>>#A?* ?# *?#C ?14 #(2#0(2 6)A 0( QPA0)H DA)mH e4T4( )(G ,)/4*?0(4 )(G*44$H )? ?14 *)T4 ?0T4H C#/0?07)/ *#/-?0#(* >#A ) N-*?H 2/#.)/ )(G /)*?0(2 C4)74F D?#-21? ?# *47-A4 ?14 A4?-A( #> ?14 G0*C/)74GH A4>-244* )(G ?14 $0G()CC4G ?# ?140A/)(G )(G ?140A 1#T4*H ?1-* 2-)A)(?440(2 ?140A A021?* #> 70?0O4(*10CF D(*?4)G #>>)70/0?)?0(2 ?14 T02A)?0#( #> 70?0O4(*H ?14P #-21? ?# #>>4A ?14T >0()(70)/ *-CC#A?0( ?140A #6( 7#-(?A04* )(G 14/C CA#I0G4 4TC/#PT4(? #CC#A?-(0?04* >#A ?14TH ?#*)>42-)AG CA470*4/P ?140A 7-/?-A)/ 14A0?)24 )(G ?14 10*?#A07)/ 0G4(?0?04* #> ?140A()?0#(*F

"4 ?14 @1A0*?0)(* #> ?14 L0GG/4 B)*?H 64 CA4>4A ?# 7#(?0(-4 ?# /0I4 0( 7#(YI0I0)/0?P 60?1 ?14 L-*/0T* )* 64 1)I4 G#(4 ?1A#-21#-? 10*?#APF "4 1)I4 /0I4G?#24?14A >#A ?14 C)*? :\99 P4)A*H )GT0??4G/P (#? 60?1#-? G0>>07-/?04* )? ?0T4*F"4 1)I4 C)**4G #( ?# ?14T *#T4 #> #-A @1A0*?0)( I)/-4* )* 64 1)I4 A4740I4G>A#T ?14T *#T4 #> ?140A*F "4 1)I4 *-7744G4G 0( 14/C0(2 G4I4/#C *#T4 T#G4AY)?0#( )(G #C4((4** 60?1 ?14 L-*/0T* #> ?14 L0GG/4 B)*?F

f(>#A?-()?4/PH (#6)G)P*H 60?1 ?14 6)A* 0TC#*4G #( ?14 A420#(H ?14 *-CC#A?#> ?4AA#A0*? )(G >-(G)T4(?)/0*? #A2)(0O)?0#(* *-71 )* R)4*1H M/ {)4G)H M((-*A))(G ?14 MATP #> D*/)TH )(G ?14 >A44 C)**)24 CA#I0G4G >#A T4A74()A04* >A#TG0>>4A4(? B)*?4A( )(G "4*?4A( 7#-(?A04*H T#G4A)?0#( 0* .40(2 4A#G4G )(G C4#C/4)A4 C/)P0(2 60?1 ) >0A4 ?1)? ?1A4)?4(* ?14 C4)74 )(G *?).0/0?P #> ?14 6#A/GF

D 60*1 ?10* 0(?4A()?0#()/ 7#(>4A4(74 *-774**H )(G ?1)($ P#- >#A P#-A )??4(Y?0#(F

\8

%&'(# M1+&/,N O'66K#.$,66)'$#' L'$I,%8$+C

.2=<@ *>F:9?P >9? ?423C6? <@B ?C456>@ 9:6 H:3>?9><@ <@B +/ <5534<C:

qM* ?14 ?0?/4 #> TP *C4471 T)P 0TC/PH ?14 #CC#*0?0#( #> *#-A74* )(G ?14 *7#C4

#> 1-T)( A021?* 0( ?4AT* #> B-A#C4)( f(0#( /)6 I*F /)6 0(*C0A4G .P @1A0*?0)(Y0?P A4m-0A4* 4iC/)()?0#(F

Q<14A4 0* (# G4(P0(2 ?1)? (#? #(/P ?14 /)6H .-? B-A#C4)( 70I0/0O)?0#( 0( 24(Y4A)/H 1)* 0?* A##?* 0( 5A44$ C10/#*#C1PH =#T)( /)6 )(G @1A0*?0)( 4?107*H C)A?07Y-/)A/P 0( ?14 *-.N47?0I4 ?A4)?T4(? #> C4#C/4F <10* C#0(? #> I046 7)//* >#A )7Y$(#6/4G20(2 0(*C0A)?0#( .P @1A0*?0)( ?1#-21? 0( 4I4AP /42)/ *P*?4T #> ) B-A#YC4)( *?)?4H )(G )/*# 0( ?14 /42)/ *P*?4T #> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(F 3#64I4AH #(47)((#? )/*# G4(P ?1)?H 4*C470)//P *0(74 ?14 )24 #> ?14 B(/021?4(T4(?H G0A47? 0(Y>/-4(74 #> @1A0*?0)( G#7?A0(4 #( /)6YT)$0(2 1)* 7#(*0G4A)./P 64)$4(4GH )(G4I4( 0( *#T4 7#-(?A04* 1)* .44( G4/0.4A)?4/P 4/0T0()?4GF <10* )/*# )CC/04* ?#(#AT)?0I4 )7?* *1)C4G .P ?14 f(0#( )-?1#A0?04*F M 71)A)7?4A0*?07 4i)TC/4 #>?10* G4/0.4A)?4 4/0T0()?0#( #> A4>4A4(74* ?# ?14 @1A0*?0)( ?A)G0?0#( 0* ?14 10*?#AP#> ?14 >#AT)?0#( #> ?14 @1)A?4A #> c-(G)T4(?)/ =021?* #> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(H)( 0(*?A-T4(? ?1)? 0* ) C)A? #> ?14 B-A#C4)( <A4)?P (#6F

<14 >0A*? *4(?4(74 #> ?14 CA4)T./4 #> ?14 @1)A?4A *?)?4*J !<14 U)?0#(* #>B-A#C4H 0( ?14 CA#74** #> 7A4)?0(2 4I4A 7/#*4A -(0#( .4?644( ?14T*4/I4*H )A4A4*#/I4G ?# *1)A4 ) C4)74>-/ >-?-A4 .)*4G #( 7#TT#( I)/-4*+F <10* 0* ) I4AP0TC#A?)(? *4(?4(74 0(G07)?0(2 ?1)? ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( G#4* (#? 6)(? ?# .4 C4AY740I4G )* #(/P )( 47#(#T07 7#TT-(0?P .)*4G #( 7#TT#( 0(?4A4*?*H .-? )/*#) 7#TT-(0?P .)*4G #( I)/-4*H #( ) *?A#(2 )i0#/#207)/ >#-(G)?0#(H #( ?14 *C0A0?Y-)/ )(G 7-/?-A)/ 7#TT-(0?PH #( ?14 7#TT-(0?P #> 70I0/0O)?0#(F <10* 0* 7/4)A/P7#(>0AT4G .P ?14 (4i? *4(?4(74 #> ?14 CA4)T./4J !RA)60(2 0(*C0A)?0#( >A#T 0?**C0A0?-)/ )(G T#A)/ 14A0?)24H ?14 f(0#( 0* >#-(G4G #( ?14 0(G0I0*0./4H -(0I4A*)/CA0(70C/4* #> 1-T)( G02(0?PH >A44G#TH 4m-)/0?P )(G *#/0G)A0?Pj 0? 0* .)*4G #( ?14CA0(70C/4* #> G4T#7A)7P )(G ?14 A-/4 #> /)6+F <14 #A020()/ ?4i? #> ?14 GA)>? #> ?14@1)A?4A >-A?14A G0*7-**4G ?14 !A4/020#-* 14A0?)24+ 0(*C0A0(2qB-A#C4)( f(0#()7?0I0?PF <10* 6#AG0(2 )//424G/P /4G ?# cA4(71 ,A0T4 L0(0*?4A `0#(4/ ^#*C0(+*0(?4AI4(?0#(H 61# ?1A4)?4(4G ?1)? cA)(74H .47)-*4 #> 14A0?)24 G4*7A0.4G 0( ?10*6)PH 6#-/G A4>-*4 ?# *02( ?14 ?4i? #> ?14 @1)A?4AF =4/020#-* 14A0?)24 6)* ?1-*A4C/)74G 60?1 !*C0A0?-)/ )(G T#A)/ 14A0?)24+F _(/P 0( ?14 #>>070)/ ?A)(*/)?0#( #>

\Z

?14 54AT)( ?4i? ?14 ?4AT !*C0A0?-)/H A4/020#-* )(G T#A)/ 14A0?)24+ A4T)0(4GF<10* 4C0*#G4 0?*4/> CA#I4* ) G0>>4A4(?0)?4G )CCA#)71 #> /420*/)?#A* >A#T ?14 B-YA#C4)( 7#-(?A04* ?# ?14 14A0?)24 #> 70I0/0O)?0#(F @/#*4A )()/P*0* *1#6* ?1)? ?10*G0I4A*0?P A4/)?4* ?# ?14 >-(G)T4(?)/ 0**-4 #> 1-T)( A021?* h T#A4 *C470>07)//PH0G4(?0>P0(2 ?14 *#-A74 #> ?1#*4 A021?*F R# 64 G4A0I4 1-T)( A021?* >A#T ?14 G02Y(0?P #> ) C4A*#( #A G# 64 G4A0I4 1-T)( A021?* >A#T ?140A >A44G#Tl <14 -(G4AY*?)(G0(2 #> 1-T)( G02(0?P )* ) *#-A74 #> A021?* )(G >A44G#T* 0* 4**4(?0)/ 0( ?10*7#(?4i?F <14 CA#./4T *?)?4G ?10* 6)P A4m-0A4* ) 7/#*4A /##$ )? ?14 T4)(0(2 #>1-T)( G02(0?PF

<14 7#(74C? #> 1-T)( G02(0?P 0* #/G4A ?1)( @1A0*?0)(0?P )(G 1)* 0?* -(G4(0Y)./4 A##?* 0( ?14 K0./4H 0( ?14 ?A4)?T4(? #> T)( )* ?14 @A4)?#A+* 6#A$H 61#T5#G 7)//4G ?# /0I4 0( 30* #6( 0T)24 )(G /0$4(4**F D( ?10* *4(*4H 1-T)( G02(0?P0* ) A4>/47?0#( #> ?14 G02(0?P #> 5#GF K47)-*4 #(/P T)( 6)* 7A4)?4G 0( ?14 0T)24)(G /0$4(4** #> 5#GH ?1)? G02(0?P 0* )( )??A0.-?4 #> C4#C/4 #(/PH (#? #?14A 7A4)Y?-A4*F

R02(0?P -(G4A*?##G 0( ?10* 6)P 0* -/?0T)?4/P @1A0*?0)(F <10* -(G4A*?)(G0(2#> 1-T)( G02(0?P A4m-0A4* ?14 A47#2(0?0#( #> ?14 #?14A C4A*#( )* ) (4021.#-AH ?#61#T ?14 7#TT)(GT4(? #> /#I4H 4m-)/ ?# *4/>Y/#I4H 6)* A4>4AA4GF

<14 G02(0?P -(G4A*?##G 0( ?10* 6)P A4m-0A4G 4m-)/ ?A4)?T4(? #> )// C4#C/4FBm-)/ ?A4)?T4(? #> 4I4AP C4A*#(H .47)-*4 #> ?140A G02(0?PH 0* ?14 >#-(G)?0#( >#A?14 -(0I4A*)/ A47#2(0?0#( #> 1-T)( A021?*F

f(?0/ ?14 B(/021?4(T4(? C4A0#GH ?10* -(G4A*?)(G0(2 #> ?14 7#(74C? #> G02(0?P6)* A4C/)74G 60?1 7#T.0(0(2 ?14 G02(0?P #> ?14 C4A*#( 60?1 ?140A C#*0?0#( 0( ?14*#70)/ 104A)A71PF

R02(0?PH 0> 4I4A )6)AG4G ?# ?1#*4 61# #77-C04G )( 0(>4A0#A C/)74 0( ?14 104AY)A71PH 6)* A42)AG4G )* ) A4>/47?0#( #> ?14 G02(0?P #> C4#C/4 0(I#/I4G 0( *#704?PH0( ?14 10214A )(G ?#C C#*0?0#(*F @#T.0(0(2 ?14 G02(0?P #> ) C4A*#( 60?1 ?14C#*0?0#( #> ?14 C4A*#( /4G ?# ?14 G424(4A)7P #> 14A .40(2H ?# G4(P0(2 ?14 CA0(70YC/4 #> 4m-)/0?P #> )// C4#C/4H ?# G4(P0(2H 0( >)7?H ?14 G02(0?P #> 1-T)(0?P )* *-71F

<14 6A0?4A* #> ?14 B(/021?4(T4(? .42)( ?# 7#T.0(4 1-T)( G02(0?P 60?11-T)( A021?* o<1#T)* ,40(4pF

D( 3<: T#868 B%" ?<: C:?#><-86;8 %B C%"#D8' DTT)(-4/ S)(? 0(?A#G-74G ?14-(G4A*?)(G0(2 #> 1-T)( G02(0?P )* ?14 0(14A4(? )??A0.-?4 #> ?14 o()?-A)/p 61071.4/#(2* ?# 4I4AP C4A*#(H .)*4G #( ?14 ).0/0?P #> 4)71 C4A*#( ?# ?14 T#A)/ /)6FS)(?+* 0TC)7? #( ?#G)P+* -(G4A*?)(G0(2 #> 1-T)( G02(0?P 0( B-A#C4 0* 0(G0*C-?Y)./4F D? 0* )/*# ) 60G4/P )774C?4G >4)?-A4 I)/-4 #> 1-T)( G02(0?PJ !onp 4I4APY?10(2 1)* ) CA074H #A G02(0?PF Q#T4?10(2 ?1)? 1)* ) CA074H P#- 7)( )/*# A4C/)74 .P*#T4?10(2 4/*4 )* 0?* 4m-0I)/4(?H .-? *#T4?10(2 ?1)? 0* ).#I4 )(P CA074 )(G ?14A4Y>#A4 G#4* (#? )//#6 )(P 4m-0I)/4(?H 1)* ) G02(0?PF+

\\

S)(?+* )CCA#)71 ?# G02(0?P 0* 7#(*0*?4(?/P 7/#*4H )/?1#-21 (#? 0G4(?07)/H ?#?14 7#(74C? #> ?14 @1A0*?0)( -(G4A*?)(G0(2 #> G02(0?PF

<14 ?A4)?T4(? #> ) C4A*#( )* )( 4(G )(G (4I4A )* )( #.N47? #> 0(?4A)7?0#(* 0*7#TT#(F <14 G0>>4A4(74 0* 4**4(?0)/ )(G A4>4A* ?# ?14 *#-A74 #> 1-T)( G02(0?PFD( @1A0*?0)(0?PH 0? 0* ) *#-A74 #> ?A)(*74(G4(? 7#((47?0#( 60?1 )( )7? #> ?14 1-YT)( 7)//0(2 ?# /0>4H 0(G4C4(G4(? #> ?14 *?)24 #> /0>4H G4I4/#CT4(? )(G 0(?4//47?-Y)/ /4I4/ #> ) C4A*#(F S)(? 7#((47?* ?14 G02(0?P #> 1-T)( ()?-A4 )* .40(2 7)C)./4#> 4*?)./0*10(2 T#A)/ /)6*H )(G )7? )77#AG0(2 ?# ?14 G07?)?4* #> ?14 /)6F

D? *44T* ?1)? ?14 G0>>4A4(74 /04* 0( ?14 7#A4 #> ?#G)P+* 7#(?A#I4A*04* #> 1-YT)( G02(0?P )(GH ).#I4 )//H 0* A4/)?4G ?# ?14 )??4TC? ?# )(*64A ?14 m-4*?0#( #>61)? 7A4)?-A4 7)( .4 7)//4G ) 1-T)( .47)-*4 #> ?14 .4*?#6)/ #> ?140A G02(0?PF

_> 7#-A*4H >#A ?14 /42)/ #AG4AH 61#*4 .)*07 A021?* )(G >A44G#T* )A4 .)*4G #(?14 G02(0?P #> ?14 1-T)(H ?14q)(*64A ?# ?10* m-4*?0#( 0* >-(G)T4(?)/F

<14 *47#(G )*C47? )>>47?0(2 ?14 G0>>4A4(74* 0( ?14 -(G4A*?)(G0(2 #> 1-T)(G02(0?P 0* 7#((47?4G ?# ?14 >0A*?F D> 64 -*4 ?10* 7#(74C?H G# 64 A4>4A 0? ?# ?141-T)( )* ) *C4704*H )( ).*?A)7? 1-T)(H #A ?# ) *C470>07 1-T)(l ,#C4 ̂ #1( ,)-/ DD0( ?14 B(7P7/07)/ Q:5:G>?%" U%G6+68 7/4)A/P G4>0(4G ?14 C#*0?0#( #> @1A0*?0)(G#7?A0(4H *?)?0(2J !14A4 onp ?10* 0* ).#-? T)( 0( )// 10* ?A-?1H 0( 10* >-// G0T4(Y*0#(F <10* 0* (#? ).#-? )( r).*?A)7?s 1-T)( .-? ?14 A4)/H r7#(7A4?4H 10*?#A07)/s1-T)(F+

@#((47?0(2 1-T)( G02(0?P ?# ?14 )7? #> 7A4)?0#( A4m-0A4* A47#2(0?0#( ?1)?) C4A*#( 4(G#64G 60?1 ?10* >4)?-A4 0* ) .40(2 ?1)? 1)* ?14 1-T)( 24(#T4 *0(74?14 0(74C?0#( #> ?14 4T.AP#F

<14 4T.AP# 0* ) G4I4/#C0(2 1-T)( .40(2 )(G (#? ) 7#//47?0#( #> 74//* ?1)? 0(?14 >-?-A4 60// .47#T4 ) C4A*#(F D( ?10* C4A*C47?0I4H G02(0?P 0* )**#70)?4G 60?11-T)( )(?1A#C#/#2P 0?*4/>F D? 1)*H #> 7#-A*4H 2A4)?/P *0TC/0>04G ?14 G4*7A0C?0I4()?-A4F <14 4T.AP# 4(N#P* ?14 1-T)( A021?* G4A0I0(2 >A#T 0?* G02(0?PH )(G ).#I4)// ?14 A021? ?# /0>4F

D( S)(?+* G02(0?P 0* )/*# ?14 !0(()?4+ o()?-A)/pH 4i74C? ?1)? 0? 0* .)*4G #( ?14).0/0?P #> 4)71 C4A*#( ?# 4*?)./0*1 ?14 T#A)/ /)6F 34(74 P#- 7)(H )/?1#-21 0? 0*(#? (474**)APH 7#(7/-G4 ?1)? G02(0?P 0* )**#70)?4G 60?1 ?14 G4I4/#CT4(? #> *C4Y70>07 ).0/0?04*H 60?1 .47#T0(2 ) C4A*#(F 3-T)( G02(0?P 7)( )7m-0A4 ) (#AT)?0I4()?-A4 ?1A#-21 ?10*F D? 0* (474**)AP ?# 4*?)./0*1 ?14 7A0?4A0) >#A G4?4AT0(0(2 ?1)??14 G4I4/#C0(2 1-T)( 4T.AP# )7m-0A4* >4)?-A4* #> .40(2 1-T)( )(G 7)( .47#(*0G4A4G )* ) C4A*#( 4(G#64G 60?1 G02(0?PF <14 CA#./4TH )* 0? 0* )/6)P* 0(*-71 7)*4*H 7#T4* G#6( ?# G4?4AT0(0(2 61)? ?14*4 7A0?4A0) )A4 )(G 61# *4?*?14*4 7A0?4A0)F <14 4(?0?P *4??0(2 ?14 7A0?4A0) )//#60(2 ?# A47#2(0O4 1-T)( G02(0Y?PH 0( >)7?H *4?* 7A0?4A0) >#A ?14 CA#?47?0#( #> /0>4 )* ) >-(G)T4(?)/ A021?F

D? *44T*H 1#64I4AH ?1)? 0> S)(? C-? ?14 4TC1)*0* #( ?14 0(()?4 )(G ()?-A)/71)A)7?4A #> G02(0?P )* 71)A)7?4A0*?07* #> 4I4AP 1-T)( .40(2H 14 0* A4N47?0(2 ?14

\[

?A)(*74(G4(? *#-A74 #> G02(0?PH )(G 1)* ?14 ).0/0?P ?# A47#2(0O4 ?1)? ?10* 71)A)7Y?4A0*?07 0* A4*4AI4G #(/P ?# 4I4AP 7A4)?-A4 1)I0(2 ?14 1-T)( 24(#T4H A42)AG/4**#> ?14 G42A44 #> G4I4/#CT4(? )(G 0(?4//47?-)/ ).0/0?PF

<10* 6#-/G T4)( ?1)? ?14 !#(?#/#207)/+ -(G4A*?)(G0(2 #> 1-T)( G02(0?P 0*(#? 7#(G0?0#(0(2 ?14 )G#C?0#( #> )( )?140*?07 6#A/GI046F

L0(G>-/ #> ?10* /)*? A4*4AI)?0#(H P#- 7)( CA#744G ?# )()/P*4 ?14 7#(*4m-4(7Y4* 0( ?4AT* #> /42)/ #AG4AH )(G 0( C)A?07-/)A ?14 CA#?47?0#( #> ?14 A021?* )(G>A44G#T* )A0*0(2 >A#T ?6# G0>>4A4(? )(2/4* #> 1-T)( G02(0?PF

`4?+* *?)A? >A#T ?14 7#(*?0?-?0#()/ C/)?>#ATF D( T#G4A( B-A#C4)( 7#-(?A04*H1-T)( G02(0?PH )* ) 7#(74C?H 0* CA4*4(? 0( I0A?-)//P )// )7?* #> 7#(*?0?-?0#()/A)($H CA#I0G4GH 1#64I4AH ?1)? 0( ) G0>>4A4(? 7#(?4i? 0? )/*# 20I4* ?10* 7#(74C?G0>>4A4(? 7#(?4(?F e#- 7)( 7/4)A/P *44 A4>4A4(74* ?# 3<: V+6I:"8#D E:;D#"#?6%+%B U,G#+ Q64<?8 #> ?14 f(0?4G U)?0#(* >A#T :9 R474T.4A :V\XH 0( 61071 ?14>0A*? C#0(? #> 4(?AP A4>4A* ?# ?14 0(()?4 G02(0?P #> )// T4T.4A* #> ?14 1-T)( A)74F

D? *1#-/G )/*# .4 (#?4G ?1)? (#614A4 G#4* 0? T44? ?14 /42)/ G4>0(0?0#( #> ?147#(74C? #> 1-T)( G02(0?PF D? 0* A47#2(0O4G ?1)? ?10* 7#(74C? *1#-/G .4 4*?).Y/0*14G 0( CA)7?074H 0( C)A?07-/)A 0( 7#-A? G470*0#(*H 0(7/-G0(2 ?14 N-G2T4(?* #>7#(*?0?-?0#()/ 7#-A?*F

D 6)(? ?# 70?4 >#A 4i)TC/4 ?14 7#(*?0?-?0#()/ CA#I0*0#(* #> *#T4 B-A#C4)(7#-(?A04* A4/)?0(2 ?# 1-T)( G02(0?PF

D( MA?07/4 :9 ,)A)2A)C1 :H ?14 QC)(0*1 @#(*?0?-?0#( *?)?4*J !L)(+* G02(0?P)(G ?14 >A44 G4I4/#CT4(? #> 10* C4A*#()/0?P >#AT ?14 .)*0* #> ?14 C#/0?07)/ )(G*#70)/ #AG4A+F Q0T0/)A/PH MA?F : #> ?14 @#(*?0?-?0#( #> ,#A?-2)/ *?)?4*J !<14 =4YC-./07 0* .)*4G #( ?14 G02(0?P #> ?14 1-T)( C4A*#( )(G ?14 60// #> ?14 C4#C/4+F

<14A4 0* ) C)A?07-/)A )CCA#)71 ?# 1-T)( G02(0?P 7#(?)0(4G 0( MA?F 8Z #> ?14@#(*?0?-?0#( #> K4/20-TJ !BI4AP#(4 1)* ?14 A021? ?# /4)G ) /0>4 7#AA4*C#(G0(2 ?#?14 G4T)(G* #> 1-T)( G02(0?P+F

MA?F:9 ,)A)2A)C1 : #> ?14 54AT)( K)*07 `)6 CA#I0G4*J !3-T)( G02(0?P 0*0(I0#/)./4F @#TC/0)(74 )(G 0?* CA#?47?0#( 0* ?14 G-?P #> C-./07 )-?1#A0?PF+

f(G#-.?4G/PH MA?F Z9 #> ?14 ,#/0*1 @#(*?0?-?0#( >A#T :VVW 1)* ) /#? 0( 7#TYT#( 60?1 ?14 A47#2(0?0#( #> 1-T)( G02(0?P 0( ?14 K)*07 `)6 #> ?14 c4G4A)/=4C-./07 #> 54AT)(PJ !<14 0(14A4(? )(G 0()/04()./4 G02(0?P #> ?14 C4A*#( *1)//7#(*?0?-?4 ) *#-A74 #> >A44G#T* )(G A021?* #> T)( )(G 70?0O4(F D? *1)// .4 0(I0#Y/)./4H )(G 0?* A4*C47? )(G CA#?47?0#( 0* ?14 #./02)?0#( #> C-./07 )-?1#A0?04*F+

<10* .A04> #I4AI046 )//#6* P#- ?# *1#6 ?1A44 G0>>4A4(? I046* #> 1-T)( G02Y(0?P 0( ?14 7#(*?0?-?0#(* #> *4I4A)/ B-A#C4)( 7#-(?A04*F D( QC)0( )(G ,#A?-2)/H?14 G02(0?P #> ?14 1-T)( C4A*#( 0* ) >-(G)T4(?)/ CA0(70C/4 #> ?14 C#/0?07)/ *P*Y?4TH A4CA4*4(?0(2 T#A4 G0A47?0#()/ G0A47?0I4 >#A /420*/)?0I4H 4i47-?0I4 )(G N-G0Y70)/ C-./07 )-?1#A0?PF <10* CA0(70C/4H G4*C0?4 *-71 G4?4AT0()?0#(H 1)* ) G0A47?0TC)7? #( >-(G)T4(?)/ 1-T)( A021?*H 61071 h )77#AG0(2 ?# ?14 QC)(0*1 @#(*?0Y

\;

?-?0#()/ 4iC4A? cA)(70*7# c4A()(G4O Q42)G# h )A0*4 >A#T ?14 CA0(70C/4* #> 1-YT)( G02(0?PF

D( ?14 K)*07 `)6 #> ?14 c4G4A)/ =4C-./07 #> 54AT)(P )(G 0( ?14 @#(*?0?-Y?0#( #> ?14 =4C-./07 #> ,#/)(GH 1-T)( G02(0?PH )* )( 0(14A4(? )(G 0(I0#/)./4I)/-4H 0* ) *#-A74 #> >A44G#T* )(G A021?*F <14A4>#A4H 0( *C0?4 #> G0>>4A4(? 7#(Y?4i?*H ?14 -(G4A*?)(G0(2 #> 1-T)( G02(0?P 0( ?14 QC)(0*1H ,#A?-2-4*4H 54AT)()(G ,#/0*1 7#(*?0?-?0#(* 0* I4AP *0T0/)AH 0> (#? ?14 *)T4F

<14 K4/20)( @#(*?0?-?0#(+* )CCA#)71 *?)(G* #-? )2)0(*? ?10* .)7$2A#-(GF<10* 7#(*?0?-?0#( T4(?0#(* ?14 A021? ?# /4)G ) /0>4 7#AA4*C#(G0(2 ?# 1-T)( G02Y(0?PF <10* )CCA#)71 0* .)*4G #( ?14 )**-TC?0#( ?1)? ?14A4 7)( .4 1-T)( /0>4 ?1)?G#4* (#? 7#AA4*C#(G ?# ?14 G4T)(G* #> 1-T)( G02(0?PF

@#TC)A0(2 ?14*4 G0>>4A4(? C4A*C47?0I4*H 64 7)( 7#(7/-G4 ?1)? ?14 K4/20)(@#(*?0?-?0#( ?A4)?* 1-T)( G02(0?P (#AT)?0I4/PF 3-T)( /0>4 T-*? T44? 74A?)0(7#(G0?0#(* 0( #AG4A ?# )7104I4 ?14 /4I4/ A4m-0A4G >#A 1-T)( G02(0?PF <1-*H ) C4A*#(?14T*4/I4* 0* (#? ?14 .4)A4A #> ?10* I)/-4H 61071 0* G02(0?PH .-? 1-T)( /0>4 0* ?#)7104I4 ?14 /4I4/ #> 1-T)( G02(0?PF D? 0* (#? 1)AG ?# *44 ?1)? .)*4G #( *-71 )(-(G4A*?)(G0(2 #> 1-T)( G02(0?P 0? 0* 4)*P ?# >#AT-/)?4 ) ?14*0* ?1)? (#? )// 1-YT)( /0>4 0* 6#A?1 /0I0(2F <#G)P+* K4/20-TH .)*4G #( *-71 )( 0(?4ACA4?)?0#( #>?14 7#(*?0?-?0#()/ CA#I0*0#(H 1)* B-A#C4+* T#*? /0.4A)/ /)6* A4/)?0(2 ?# 4-?1)()Y*0)H 0(7/-G0(2 4-?1)()*0) >#A 710/GA4(F

D? 0* 6#A?1 A4?-A(0(2 ?# ?14 A47#2(0?0#( #> 1-T)( G02(0?P 0( ?14 @1)A?4A #>c-(G)T4(?)/ =021?* #> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(F

3-T)( G02(0?P 6)* T4(?0#(4G 0( ?14 @1)A?4A+* CA4)T./4H 0( )GG0?0#( ?# >A44YG#TH 4m-)/0?P )(G *#/0G)A0?PH )* #(4 #> ?14 0(G0I0*0./4 )(G -(0I4A*)/ I)/-4* #(61071 ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( 0* .-0/?F

D( )GG0?0#(H MA?F : #> ?14 @1)A?4A *?)?4*J !3-T)( G02(0?P 0* 0(I0#/)./4FD? T-*? .4 A4*C47?4G )(G CA#?47?4GF+ <14 @1)A?4A ?A04* ?# 20I4 1-T)( G02(0?PG#-./4 T4)(0(2F

_( ?14 #(4 1)(GH 0? 0(7/-G4* 0? 0( ?14 CA4)T./4 (4i? ?# >A44G#TH 4m-)/0?P )(G*#/0G)A0?P 60?1 ?14 >-(G)T4(?)/ CA0(70C/4* #> 70I0/0O)?0#(j #( ?14 #?14A 1)(GH 0??A4)?* 1-T)( G02(0?P )* #(4 #> ?14 I)/-4* ?# .4 CA#?47?4G 4m-)//PH >#A 4i)TC/460?1 ?14 A021? ?# /0>4F

3-T)( G02(0?P 0* ?14 *#-A74 #> )// A021?* )(G >A44G#T*j 0? 0* ?14 N-*?0>07)?0#(#> 4I4AP >A44G#TH 4m-)/0?P )(G *#/0G)A0?PF D( ?14 -(G4A*?)(G0(2 7#(*0*?4(? 60?1@1A0*?0)( G#7?A0(4H 1-T)( G02(0?P 0* ).#I4 ?14 /)6 )(G .4>#A4 ?14 6A0??4( /)6*F

D? .47#T4* ) T#G4/ >#A ?14 4I)/-)?0#( #> /420*/)?0#( )(G ) 7A0?4A0#( >#A ?144/0T0()?0#( #> *#/-?0#(* ?1)? I0#/)?4 1-T)( G02(0?P >A#T /42)/ *P*?4TF <10*4TC1)*0* #( ?14 *C470)/ C/)74 #> 1-T)( G02(0?P 0( A4/)?0#( ?# #?14A I)/-4* 0*T0**0(2 0( ?14 @1)A?4AF c0A*? #> )//H 0? T-*? .4 4TC1)*0O4G ?1)? ?14 @1)A?4A G#4*(#? *C4)$ ).#-? ?14 0(14A4(? ()?-A4 #> 1-T)( G02(0?PF D? 0* I4AP 0TC#A?)(? 0(

\W

*-71 ) 6)PH ?1)? ?10* *?)?4T4(? I4AP 7/4)A/P -(G4A/0(4* ?14 71)A)7?4A #> G02(0?P).#I4 ?14 /)6 )(G .4>#A4 ?14 /)6F 3-T)( G02(0?P 0* (#? )( )??A0.-?4 #> ) C4A*#(20I4( ?# ?14T .P ?14 /42)/ *P*?4T .P ?14 2A)74 #> ?14 7#(*?0?-?0#( 6A0?4A* #A ?14/420*/)?-A4F D? 0* ) 71)A)7?4A0*?07 #> ?14 1-T)( C4A*#( 0(G4C4(G4(? #> ?14 /42)/#AG4A )(G #> ?14 /420*/)?-A4H )(G ?14 /42)/ #AG4A 0* .-0/? #( ?10* ?A)0? h ?14 /42)/#AG4AH 61071 0* ?# CA#?47? ?14 >-(G)T4(?)/ >A44G#T* )(G A021?*H )(G (#? #(/P ?#7A4)?4 ?14TF

<10* 0* (#? ) CA#./4T G4CA0I4G #> CA)7?07)/ *02(0>07)(74F @#(*0G4A >#A 4i)TYC/4 ?14 0(?4ACA4?)?0#( #> MA?F :Z #> ?14 @1)A?4A #> c-(G)T4(?)/ =021?* 61071G47/)A4* ?14 CA#10.0?0#( #> A4*?A07?0#(* #( >A44G#T #> )A? )(G *704(?0>07 A4*4)A71F_( ?14 .)*0* #> ?14 @1)A?4AH *0(74 >A44G#T 6)* /0*?4G (4i? ?# ?14 G02(0?P #>) C4A*#(H ?14A4 )A4 (# )A2-T4(?* 0( ?14 *)T4 @1)A?4A )//#60(2 ?# 7/4)A/P A4*#/I4?14 G0/4TT) #> 614?14A 1-T)( G02(0?P #A >A44G#T #> )A? #A *704(?0>07 A4*4)A71*1#-/G .4 20I4( CA0#A0?P 0( ?14 7)*4 #> ) 7#(>/07? #> I)/-4*F K-? 7#(>/07? 0* )/Y6)P* C#**0./4F

<14 6#A$ #> )( )A?0*? 7)( 7/4)A/P I0#/)?4 ?14 G02(0?P #> 1-T)( /0>4H #A A4Y*4)A71 CA#N47?* 7)( 7#(*0G4A 1-T)( .40(2* C-A4/P )* *-.N47?*F D( ?14 7#TT4(Y?)AP ?# MA?07/4 : #> ?14 @1)A?4A 7A4)?4G )? ?14 #AG4A #> ?14 ,A4*0G0-T #> ?14@#(I4(?0#( CA4C)A0(2 ?14 @1)A?4AH 0? 0* *?)?4G ?1)? MA?07/4 : CA4I4(?* ?14 -*4 #>)(P #> ?14 A021?* 6A0??4( 0( ?14 @1)A?4A 0( ) 6)P ?1)? I0#/)?4* 1-T)( G02(0?PF D? 0*) *1)T4 ?1)? ?10* *?)?4T4(? >A#T ?14 7#TT4(? 0* (#? >#-(G 0( ?14 ?4i? #> ?14@1)A?4AH .47)-*4 ?10* G#4* (#? G0A47?/P A4*-/? >A#T ?14 ?4i? 0?*4/>F _( ?14 .)*0* #>?14 ,#/0*1 @#(*?0?-?0#( ?14A4 0* (# G#-.? 0( ?14 4I4(? #> *-71 ) 7#(>/07?F U# $0(G#> >A44G#T )(G (# /)6 7)( .4 CA#?47?4G 0> ?14P #>>4(G 1-T)( G02(0?PF <14P7)((#? .4 0( 7#(?A)G07?0#( ?# ?14 *#-A74 >A#T 61071 ?14P 7#T4F cA44G#TH ?14>A44G#T #> )A? )(G *704(?0>07 A4*4)A71H )A4 (#? ?14 I)/-4* *?)(G0(2 (4i? ?# 1-T)(G02(0?P h ?10* 0* (#? ?14 *)T4 /4I4/ 0( ?14 104A)A7104* #> I)/-4*F _(/P 1-T)(G02(0?P 1)* ) ()?-A)/ )(G 0()/04()./4 71)A)7?4AF M// #?14A I)/-4* )A4 T#A4 #A /4***-.N47? ?# A4*?A07?0#(*Fq<10* )/*# )CC/04* ?# )// >-(G)T4(?)/ A021?* )(G >A44G#T*F

QC4)$0(2 ).#-? ?14 G02(0?P #> )//H A4)/H 10*?#A07)/ 1-T)(* T4)(* ?1)? ?10*71)A)7?4A0*?07 0* A4>4AA4G ?# ?14 1-T)( 61# 0* )/0I4F M /0I0(2 C4A*#( 0* ) 7)AA04A#> ?140A G02(0?PF <1)? 0* 61P ?14 A021? ?# /0>4 0* *-71 )( 0TC#A?)(? A021? A4/)?4G ?#G02(0?PF <14A4 0* (# *4(*4 ?# ?)/$ ).#-? 1-T)( A021?* 610/4 m-4*?0#(0(2 ?14 A021??# /0>4F D( WI#+4:D6,G X6?#: 64 A4)G 0( A42)AG ?# ?#G)P+* CA#./4T* A4/)?0(2 ?#?14 CA#?47?0#( #> /0>4J !onp ?14A4 0* ) ?A)207 ?-A( 0( ) /#(2 10*?#A07)/ CA#74** ?1)?/4G ?# G0*7#I4A0(2 ?14 0G4) #> r1-T)( A021?*s h )* ?14 0(()?4 A021?* #> 4I4APC4A*#( )(G CA0#A ?# ?14 7#(*?0?-?0#( )(G /420*/)?0#( #> )(P *?)?4 h >)//* ?#G)P 0() *-ACA0*0(2 7#(?A)G07?0#(J N-*? 0( ?14 )24 0( 61071 ?14 0(I0#/)./4 A021?* #> ?14C4A*#( )A4 *#/4T(/P CA#7/)0T4G )(G ?14 I)/-4 #> /0>4 0* C-./07/P G47/)A4GH ?14

\X

*)T4 A021? ?# /0>4 0* I0#/)?4G 0( CA)7?074 )(G ?A)TC/4GH 4*C470)//P 0( ?14 T#*?0TC#A?)(? T#T4(?* #> 10* 1-T)( 4i0*?4(74H 61071 0* ?14 .0A?1 )(G G4)?1F!

<14 CA#I0*0#(* #> ?14 @1)A?4A #> c-(G)T4(?)/ =021?* )(G ?14 B-A#C4)( @#(YI4(?0#( >#A ?14 ,A#?47?0#( #> 3-T)( =021?* )(G c-(G)T4(?)/ cA44G#T*H 4*C4Y70)//P 0( /021? #> ?14 N-A0*CA-G4(74 #> ?14 B-A#C4)( @#-A? #> 3-T)( =021?*H G#(#? *4??/4 ?14 T#*? CA4**0(2 CA#./4T* 0( B-A#C4 A4/)?4G ?# ?14 CA#?47?0#( #> /0>4Fc#A ?14A4 0* (# 4iC/070? A4>4A4(74 0( ?14 @1)A?4A ?# ?14 0**-4 #> ).#A?0#( )(G4-?1)()*0)F M/*#H ?14 B-A#C4)( @#-A? #> 3-T)( =021?* G#4* (#? 4iC/070?/P 7#TYT4(? #( ?14 *7#C4 #> CA#?47?0#( #> /0>4 0( ?14 CA4()?)/ *?)24 0( MA?F 8 #> ?14@#(I4(?0#(F Q-71 A4*?A)0(? 7)((#? 4I4( *-ACA0*4 ?## T-71F <14 *0?-)?0#( 0( ?14B-A#C4)( f(0#( 0* *-71 ?1)? ) 7/4)A #C?0(2 >#A ?14 CA#?47?0#( #> /0>4 >A#T 7#(Y74C?0#( ?# ()?-A)/ G4)?1 6#-/G A-/4 #-? ?14 C#**0.0/0?P #> 7#(*4(*-* (474**)AP ?#*02( ?14 @1)A?4AF 3#64I4AH )? ?14 *)T4 ?0T4 ?10* T4)(* m-4*?0#(0(2 ?14 CA4*Y4(74 #> 4(#-21 7#TT#( I)/-4* *->>0704(? ?# .-0/G ?14 >#-(G)?0#( >#A ) /42)/#AG4AF

<14 0**-4 #> CA#?47?0#( #> /0>4 0* >-(G)T4(?)/ )(G 0* I4AP 7/#*4/P A4/)?4G ?#?14 C#*0?0#( #> 1-T)( G02(0?P 7#TC)A4G ?# #?14A A021?*H 0(7/-G0(2 ?14 A021? ?#/0>4F D> 1-T)( G02(0?PH -(G4A*?##G 0(G0I0G-)//P )(G 7#(7A4?4/PH 0* ?# .4 0(I0#/)Y./4H ?14( 0? T-*? )/6)P* A4>4A ?# ) /0I0(2 C4A*#(F

<10* >-(G)T4(?)/ 71)A)7?4A0*?07 #> 1-T)( /0>4 >A#T 7#(74C?0#( ?# ()?-A)/G4)?1 1)* .44( 7/4)A/P 4iC#*4G 0( ?14 ,#/0*1 @#(*?0?-?0#()/ @#-A? A-/0(2 >A#T8X L)P :VVWF M//#60(2 ?# $0// ) >#4?-* >#A *#70)/ A4)*#(*H )(G )/*# C4AT0??0(24-?1)()*0)H T-*? /4)G ?# )( 0(*?A-T4(?)/ )CCA#)71 ?# 1-T)( /0>4 61071 T4)(*?14 G4(0)/ #> G02(0?PF "4 1)I4 ?# A4)/0O4 ?1)? ?14 .)*07 7#(>/07? #> T#G4A( 70I0Y/0O)?0#( 0* ?14 G0*C-?4 #I4A ?14 #A020( #> 1-T)( /0>4 )(G )? ?14 *)T4 ?0T4 ?14G0*C-?4 #I4A >A#T 61071 C#0(? ) C4A*#( )* 4(G#64G 60?1 0(14A4(? )(G 0()/04()Y./4 G02(0?PH 0* 2##GH )(G ?14 C-./07 )-?1#A0?P 0* #./024G ?# CA#?47?F

k4AP 0TC#A?)(? >#A ?14 A4*#/-?0#( #> ?10* CA#./4T 0* ?14 C-./07 7#(*70#-*Y(4**H C##A/P G0*?A0.-?4G (#? #(/P 0( ,#/)(GH ?14 N-G2T4(? #> ?14 @#-A? #> ^-*?074#> :X _7?#.4A 89:: o@ Z\y:9pF D( 0?* R470*0#(H ?14 <A0.-()/H A-/0(2 0( ?14 C)(4/#> ?14 5A)(G @1)T.4AH A47#2(0O4G ) 1-T)( 4T.AP# )* 4(G#64G 60?1 1-T)(G02(0?P >A#T 0?* 0(74C?0#(H (# T)??4A 1#6 ?14 4T.AP# 6)* 7A4)?4GF

RA)60(2 7#(*4m-4(74* >A#T )*7A0.0(2 1-T)( G02(0?P ?# 1-T)( 4T.AP#* 0(A4/)?0#( ?# ?14 4i0*?0(2 /420*/)?0#( 0( T#*? B-A#C4)( f(0#( 7#-(?A04*H 0(7/-G0(2,#/)(GH )//#60(2 ).#A?0#( A4m-0A4* ) >-(G)T4(?)/ A4I0*0#( #> ?14 /42)/ (#AT*>A#T ?14 C#0(? #> I046 #> ?140A 7#TC/0)(74 60?1 ?14 A-/4* )(G A42-/)?0#(* *?)(GY0(2 10214A 0( ?14 104A)A71P #> *#-A74* #> /)6F <14 *?)A?0(2 C#0(? T-*? .4 ?# 2A)(?/42)/ CA#?47?0#( ?# )(P 7#(740I4G 4T.AP# )* ) /42)/ )**4? G4*4AI0(2 ?10* CA#?47Y?0#(H G-4 ?# ?140A G02(0?PF

\V

<14 I4AP 7-AA4(? CA#./4T >A#T ?14 C#0(? #> I046 #> CA#?47?0#( #> 4I4AP 1-YT)( .40(2+* G02(0?P 0* ?14 )GT0**0.0/0?P #> A4*4)A71 #( 4T.AP#(07 *?4T 74//*F

@#//47?0(2 *-71 74//* T)P 1)I4 ?14A)C4-?07 C-AC#*4* >#A )(#?14A C4A*#(F3#64I4AH 0? 0* )/6)P* 7#((47?4G 60?1 ?14 G4*?A-7?0#( #> ) 710/G+* /0>4 )(G ?10* 0*0AA4/4I)(? 0( ?10* 7)*4 614?14A 0? 0* ) 7)*4 #> ).#A?0#(H #A 0> ?14 710/G G4I4/#C4G)* ) A4*-/? #> 0(YI0?A# >4A?0/0O)?0#(F <14 710/G 0( ?10* 7)*4 0* ?A4)?4G C-A4/P 0(*?A-YT4(?)//P )* ) CA#I0G4A #> *?4T 74//*F

D( *-71 )( 4I4(?H 1-T)( G02(0?P 0* .A-?)//P ?A)TC/4GH )* ?14 @#-A? #> ^-*?074*?)?4G ?1)? )(P 1-T)( 4T.AP# >A#T ?14 T#T4(? #> 0?* 0(74C?0#( 0* 4(G#64G60?1 0?F D( )GG0?0#(H m-4*?0#(* )77#TC)(P0(2 ?14 4(G #> /0>4 )A4 A4/)?4G ?# ?14-(G4A*?)(G0(2 #> 1-T)( G02(0?P )(G ?14 A4*-/?0(2 >-(G)T4(?)/ 1-T)( A021?H61071 0* 1-T)( /0>4F

<10* 0* 4*C470)//P ?14 7)*4 60?1 4-?1)()*0)H 61071 0* ) 1#T070G4 #( G4T)(GFB-?1)()*0) 0* C4AT0??4G 0( *#T4 B-A#C4)( 7#-(?A04* )(G (#? #(/P 0( ?14 *0?-)Y?0#( #> ) G4T)(G ?# 4(G ?14 /0>4 #> ?14 C4A*#( *->>4A0(2 )(G 61# 6)(?* ?# 4(G 10*/0>4H .-? )/*# 0( A4/)?0#( ?# C4A*#(* 61# ?14T*4/I4* )A4 (#? )./4 ?# 4iCA4** *-71G4T)(G* .-? ?140A *?)?-?#AP A4CA4*4(?)?0I4* 7)( G# *#F <14 CA#./4T #> 4-?1)()Y*0) 0* 7#((47?4G 60?1 ?6# *C470>07 0**-4* A4/)?4G ?# ?14 -(G4A*?)(G0(2 #> 1-T)(G02(0?PF

c0A*?/PH )* 6)* T4(?0#(4GH *#T4 ?10($H G4*C0?4 ?14 4iC4A04(74 #> "#A/G ")ADDH ?1)? /0>4 T)P (#? .4 6#A?1 /0I0(2F Q-71 ) /0>4H )77#AG0(2 ?# ?14 CA#C#(4(?* #>?10* ?14*0*H G#4* (#? G4*4AI4 CA#?47?0#(F M2)0(H ?14 CA#./4T )A0*4*H 61)? )A4 ?147A0?4A0) #> ) /0>4 6#A?1 /0I0(2 )(G 61# 1)* *4? ?14 7A0?4A0) )(G 61# 0* ?# )774C??140A >-/>0/T4(?F Q47#(G/PH ?14 CA#./4T #> 4-?1)()*0) 0* )**#70)?4G 60?1 ?14 *?)?4YT4(?H 61071 D 1)G )/A4)GP T4(?0#(4GH ?1)? 1-T)( G02(0?P 0* (#? ?14 >#-(G)?0#(#> )// >-(G)T4(?)/ A021?*H .-? ?1)? *-71 ) >#-(G)?0#( 0* 1-T)( >A44G#TH )(GG02(0?PH 0> 4I4( 6#A?1 T4(?0#(0(2H 0* G4A0I4G >A#T >A44G#TFqf(G4A ?10* )**-TCY?0#(H ) C4A*#( 0* >A44 )(G 1)* ?14 A021? ?# G470G4 >#A 10T*4/>H )/*# 60?1 A42)AG ?#614?14A #A (#? ?# ?4AT0()?4 10* /0>4F

B-A#C4)(* A4*02(4GH )/?1#-21 0( *#T4 7#-(?A04* A4/)?0I4/P A474(?/PH >A#TC-(0*1T4(? >#A )??4TC?4G *-070G4F ,4#C/4 7)( G470G4 ?140A /0I4*F D( >)7?H T)(G)Y?#AP T4G07)/ ?A4)?T4(? 0* 4i7/-G4G )* )>>47?0(2 (#? #(/P ?14 A021? ?# *4/>YG4?4AYT0()?0#( #> ?14 C)?04(?H .-? )/*# ?140A G02(0?PH .47)-*4 ) C)?04(?H 0> -(G4A CA4*Y*-A4H .47#T4* ?14 #.N47? #> ?14 G#7?#A+* )7?0#(*F 3#64I4AH ?14 C)A?070C)?0#( #>?10AG C)A?04* 0( ?14 ?)$0(2 #> ) C4A*#(+* /0>4 7)((#? A4T)0( -(C-(0*14GF D? T-*?.4 A4T4T.4A4G ?1)? ?14 CA#?47?0#( #> /0>4 1)* G#-./4 N-*?0>07)?0#(J ?14 CA#?47?0#(#> ?14 A021? ?# /0I4H ?1)? ?14 ?A-*?44 #> ?1)? /)6 0* )./4 ?# 20I4 -CH .-? )/*# ?14 /0>4#> 4I4AP 1-T)( .40(2 1)* )( #.N47?0I4 *#70)/ I)/-4H 61#*4 *02(0>07)(74 0* (#?)>>47?4G .P ?14 60// #> T)(H ?14 C#**4**#A #> ?10* I)/-4F ,A4*7A0.4G 0( ,#/0*17A0T0()/ /)6 )(G 0( 7A0T0()/ /)6 0( T#*? B-A#C4)( 7#-(?A04*H ) C-(0*1T4(? >#A

[9

4-?1)()*0)H )* 64// )* 7#Y#C4A)?0#( 0( *-070G4H 0* N-*? )( 4iCA4**0#( #> ?14 )7Y74C?)(74 #> *-71 ) C#*0?0#(F

<14 0TC#A?)(74 #> ?14 A47#2(0?0#( #> 1-T)( G02(0?P 0* (#? /0T0?4G #(/P ?#?14 CA#?47?0#( #> /0>4F <14 CA#./4T #> ?A4)?T4(?H 0(*?A-T4(?)/ )(G G4?A0T4(?)/ ?#?14 G02(0?P #> ?14 1-T)( .40(2H 4i0*?* 0( I0A?-)//P 4I4AP )A4) #> *#70)/ /0>4F

c#A 0(*?)(74H T)(P A42-/)?0#(* #> T4G07)/ /)6 )A4 ) *0TC/4 A4>4A4(74 ?# ?147#(*?0?-?0#()/ #./02)?0#( ?# CA#?47? 1-T)( G02(0?P .P C-./07 )-?1#A0?04*F <14A4N47?0#( #> ?14 C)?4A()/0*?07 T#G4/ ?1)? 1)* A402(4G 0( T4G070(4 >#A 74(?-A04*>#A ?14 .4(4>0? #> ) C)A?(4A*10C T#G4/ #> G#7?#AYC)?04(? A4/)?0#(*10C 0* ?14 4iYCA4**0#( #> ?14 CA#?47?0#( #> 1-T)( G02(0?P )(G ?14 4(*-0(2 A021? ?# *4/>YG4?4AYT0()?0#(F

<14 CA#./4T #> ?4(*0#( .4?644( ?14 @1A0*?0)( )(G ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( )CYCA#)71 ?# 1-T)( A021?* 0* C4A>47?/P 0//-*?A)?4G .P MA?F V #> ?14 @1)A?4A #> c-(G)YT4(?)/ =021?* 0( ?14 7#(?4i? #> ?14 A42-/)?0#( )G#C?4G 0( MA?F :8 #> ?14 B-A#C4Y)( @#(I4(?0#( #( 3-T)( =021?*F <14 @1)A?4A 0( ?10* )A?07/4 *?)?4* ?1)? 0? !2-)AY)(?44* ?14 A021? ?# T)AAP )(G ?14 A021? ?# >#-(G ) >)T0/P )77#AG0(2 ?# ?14 ()?0#(Y)/ /)6* 2#I4A(0(2 ?14 4i4A70*4 #> ?14*4 A021?*+F

@1)A)7?4A0*?07 0* ?14 7#TC)A0*#( #> ?10* CA#I0*0#( #> MA?F :8 #> ?14 B-A#C4)(@#(I4(?0#( #( 3-T)( =021?*F <14 @#(I4(?0#( *?)?4*J !L4( )(G 6#T4( 1)I4?14 A021? ?# T)AAP )(G ?# >#-(G ) >)T0/PH )77#AG0(2 ?# ?14 ()?0#()/ /)6* 2#I4A(Y0(2 ?14 4i4A70*4 #> ?10* A021?+F D( ?14 @1)A?4A ?14A4 0* (# *?)?4T4(? ?1)? ?14 A021??# T)AAP )(G ?# 4*?)./0*1 ) >)T0/P )CC/04* ?# C4#C/4 #> ?14 #CC#*0?4 *4iF <1-*H?14 @1)A?4A G#4* (#? CA4I4(? ?14 0(?A#G-7?0#( #> 2)P T)AA0)24* 0(?# ?14 /420*/)Y?0#( #> ?14 f(0#( L4T.4A Q?)?4* )(G 4*?)./0*10(2 >)T0/04* .)*4G #(*-71qA4/)?0#(*10C*F <14 C#/0?07)/ 7#AA47?(4** #> ?14 @1)A?4A 7A4)?#A* 64(? ?##>)AF e#- 7)((#? 4m-)?4 T)AA0)24 60?1 ) A4/)?0#(*10CH 4I4( C4AT)(4(?H #> ?6#C4#C/4 #> ?14 *)T4 *4iF D G# (#? 4i7/-G4 ?1)? ?14 CA#10.0?0#( #> G0*7A0T0()?0#(7)( /4)G ?# ?14 (44G ?# A42-/)?4 ?14 /42)/ .)*0* )(G ?14 /42)/ 7#(*4m-4(74* #>*-71 ) /0($H 4F2F 0( ?14 >04/G #> ?)i /)6 #A 0(14A0?)(74F Q?0//H /42)/ )774C?)(74 #>*-71 ) A4/)?0#(*10C 7)((#? .4 4m-)?4G 60?1 T)AA0)24 )(G 0?* 7A4)?0#( G#4* (#?T4)( 4*?)./0*10(2 ) >)T0/PF <14 7#(*?0?-?0I4 >-(7?0#( #> T)AA0)24 )(G ?14 >)TY0/PH )/?1#-21 #> 7#-A*4 (#? 4i7/-*0I4H 0* ?14 CA#7A4)?0#( )(G -C.A0(20(2 #> (4624(4A)?0#(*F D( ?14 4G-7)?0#()/ CA#74**H 4)71 24(G4A C/)P* )( 0TC#A?)(? A#/461071 7)((#? .4 A4C/)74GF BI4AP 710/G 1)* ?14 A021? ?# 7/#*4*? 7#(?)7? 0( ?14>)T0/P 60?1 ) T#?14A )(G >)?14AH 60?1 ) 6#T)( )(G ) T)(F

<14 CA#74** #> 4G-7)?0#( )(G -C.A0(20(2 0* (#? >A44 >A#T ?4(*0#(*F D( C)A?07Y-/)AH /0T0?0(2 ?14 0(>/-4(74 #> ?14 >)T0/P #( ?14 G4I4/#CT4(? #> ?14 710/GH 10*6#A/G I046H /0T0?0(2 ?14 A021?* #> C)A4(?* ?# )**4(? 0( ?4AT* #> ?14 Bf >A44G#T#> ?14 710/G 7A4)?4* ?4(*0#(F _( ?14 #?14A 1)(GH 64 T-*? (#?074 ?1)? 64 I4AP

[:

#>?4( T44? 60?1 ?14 0(*?A-T4(?)/ ?A4)?T4(? #> 710/GA4( 0( T)AA0)24 7#(>/07?*614A4 ?14 710/G 7#T4* ?# C/)P ?14 A#/4 #> ?14 #.N47?F

<## /0??/4 #.N47?0#( 6)* A)0*4G ?# ?14 A474(?/P )G#C?4G M7?H 7#TT#(/P $(#6()* 0( I0?A# >4A?0/0O)?0#(H ?1)? .P )//#60(2 ?14 CA#74G-A4* >#A #-? #> 64G/#7$7#-C/4* #>>4A* ?## /0??/4 CA#?47?0#( >#A 710/GA4( .#A( )* ) A4*-/? #> ?14 0( I0?A#CA#74G-A4F

_> 7#-A*4H T)AA0)24 G#4* (#? 2-)A)(?44 ) >)T0/P 4(I0A#(T4(? >-//P 7#AA4Y*C#(G0(2 ?# ?14 710/G+* G02(0?PF 3#64I4AH ?14 G0**#/-?0#( #> T)AA0)24 G4C4(G*#( >0(G0(2* ?1)? G0I#A74 G#4* (#? ?)$4 C/)74 )? ?14 4iC4(*4 #> T0(#A 710/GA4(F<14 G0*0(?42A)?0#( #> ) 7#-C/4 (#? N#0(4G 0( T)AA0)24 G#4* (#? 4I4( 2-)A)(Y?44 ?1)?F

M? ?14 4(G D 6)(? ?# 2# .)7$ )2)0( ?# ?14 CA#./4T #> 14A0?)24 >#AT0(2 ?140G4(?0?P #> B-A#C4 )(G B-A#C4)(*F R4(P0(2 ?14 >)7? ?1)? B-A#C4)( 70I0/0O)?0#(0* >#AT4GH )T#(2 #?14A*H .P @1A0*?0)( 4?107*H 0* ) G4(0)/ #> A4)/0?PF @1A0*?0)(0?P2)I4 B-A#C4+* 0G4(?0?PF @1A0*?0)(0?P 2)I4 B-A#C4 ?14 C4A*#()/ -(G4A*?)(G0(2 #>T)( )* ?14 >#-(G)?0#( #> *#70)/ #AG4A )(G ?14 A-/4 #> /)6H 4I4( 614( ?14 74(?A)/C#*0?0#( #> ?14 1-T)( C4A*#( *44$0(2 ?# A4/P #( ?14 >#-(G)?0#(* 0*qG0*?)(? #A4I4( 1#*?0/4 ?# @1A0*?0)(0?PF D> 0? 0* *?)?4G ?1)? cA)(74 )(G #?14A 7#-(?A04* 6#-/G(#? *02( ?14 ?4i?H 61071 A4>4A* ?# ?14 A4/020#-* 14A0?)24 #> B-A#C4H .47)-*4 ?14P)A4 *47-/)A *?)?4* )(G T)(P A4/020#(* 7#4i0*? 0( ?140A ?4AA0?#A04*H 64 1)I4 0( ?10*7)*4 ?# G4)/ 60?1 ?#?)/ 7#(>-*0#( #> T)??4AF <14A4 0* ) G0>>4A4(74 .4?644( ?1470I0/0O)?0#( 14A0?)24 ?1)? 0* ?14 >#-(G)?0#( #> 7#TT#( I)/-4* )(G #?14A *47-/)A71)A)7?4A* #> ?14 *?)?4F <14 >)7? ?1)? ?#G)P 0( B-A#C4 ?14A4 )A4 /0I0(2 C4A*#(*.4/#(20(2 ?# G0>>4A4(? 71-A714* )(G A4/020#(* #A (#(YG4(#T0()?0#()/ C4#C/47)((#? G4(P ?1)? @1A0*?0)(0?P 6)* ?14 A4/020#( ?1)? *1)C4G ?14 >)74 #> B-A#C4FU# A4)*#()./4 C4A*#( 7)( G4(P ?14 MA). *?)?4* ?1)? ?140A 70I0/0O)?0#( 0* .)*4G #(D*/)TF <14 G4(0)/ #> ?14 0TC#A?)(74 #> ?14 A##?* #> 70I0/0O)?0#( G#4* (#? 7#(?A0.Y-?4 ?# ?14 4/0T0()?0#( #> ?4(*0#(*F f(G4A*?)(G0(2 ?14 G0>>4A4(74* ?1)? 4()./4G0)/#2-4 60// T-71 .4??4A *4AI4 !*1)A0(2 ?#24?14A ) >-?-A4 #> C4)74+F _(4 #> ?140TC#A?)(? >4)?-A4* #> ) 7-/?-A4 .)*4G #( ?14 >#-(G)?0#(* #> @1A0*?0)(0?PH 4*C4Y70)//P 1021/021?4G 0( ?14 6#A$ #> ?14 Q47#(G k)?07)( @#-(70/H 0* ?14 )??0?-G4 #>?#/4A)(74 ?#6)AG* #?14A*H ?#6)AG* ) G0>>4A4(? 6#A/GI046 >A#T ?14 @1A0*?0)( #(4FQ?A4**0(2 ?10* 14A0?)24H (#? 0?* G4(0)/H T)P 7#(*?0?-?4 ?14 .)*0* >#A ?14 C4)74>-/7#4i0*?4(74 #> ?14 ()?0#(* ?1)? T)$4 -C B-A#C4 60?1 #?14A ()?0#(* )(G 60?1 ?14(467#T4A* ?# B-A#C4 61# )A4 .A0(20(2 60?1 ?14T ) G0>>4A4(? *4? #> I)/-4* >A#T?14 B-A#C4)( #(4F @#(?4TC#A)AP CA#./4T* 0( B-A#C4 *1#6 ?14 0TC#A?)(74 #>?14 )6)A4(4** #> ) B-A#C4)( 0G4(?0?P G4A0I4G >A#T @1A0*?0)(0?PH ?14 0TC#A?)(74#> ?A4)?0(2 1-T)( A021?* )* .40(2 .)*4G #( ?14 0(14A4(? )(G 0()/04()./4 G02(0?P)(G A021?* #> 4I4AP 1-T)( .40(2H 61071 )A4 4m-)/H A42)AG/4** #> ?140A 0(G0I0G-)/71)A)7?4A0*?07*H #A020(H ()?0#()/0?P #A 6#A/GI046F

[8

`4? T4 2# .)7$ )2)0( ?# ?14 7#(?4(? #> ?14 @1)A?4A #> c-(G)T4(?)/ =021?*H61071 *?)?4* 0( 0?* CA4)T./4 ?1)? ?14 4(N#PT4(? #> 74A?)0( A021?* !4(?)0/* A4*C#(Y*0.0/0?04* )(G G-?04* 60?1 A42)AG ?# #?14A C4A*#(*H ?# ?14 1-T)( 7#TT-(0?P )(G?# >-?-A4 24(4A)?0#(*+F D ?10($ ?10* 0* #(4 #> ?14 T#*? 0TC#A?)(? *?)?4T4(?* 7#(Y?)0(4G 0( ?14 @1)A?4A )(G CA#I0G4* 0TC#A?)(? 0(*021?* #( >-(G)T4(?)/ >A44G#T*)(G 1-T)( A021?*F D? 0* -(G4A*?)(G)./4 ?1)? *# >)A >A44G#T* )(G 1-T)( A021?*1)I4 .44( )774(?4G 0( B-A#C4 ).#I4 )//F Q# G#4* ?14 @1)A?4AF <10* $0(G #> )CYCA#)71 6)* )(G 0* ) A4*C#(*4 ?# ?14 ?A)207 4iC4A04(74* #> ?14 89?1 74(?-AP )**#Y70)?4G 60?1 G0>>4A4(? $0(G* #> ?#?)/0?)A0)(0*TF <14 8:*? 74(?-AP *1#-/G .4 71)AY)7?4A0O4G (#? #(/P .P *?A4(2?14(0(2 ?14 1-T)( >A44G#T* )(G A021?* A4*-/?0(2>A#T 0(14A4(? )(G 0()/04()./4 1-T)( G02(0?P .-? )/*# 4TC1)*0O0(2 ?14 A4*C#(*0Y.0/0?P ?#6)AG* #?14A C4#C/4 )(G ?#6)AG* ?14 7#TT#( 2##GF e#- 7)( )/A4)GP(#?074 ?1)? ?14 CA0T)AP ?1A4)? ?# >A44G#T )(G 1-T)( A021?* 0* (#? #(/P ?14 C-./07)-?1#A0?PF <10* ?1A4)? 7#T4* I4AP #>?4( >A#T I)A0#-* 7#AC#A)?0#(* #> )( 47#Y(#T07 ()?-A4 #A 4I4( >A#T 0(G0I0G-)/* )(G ?140A T#A4 #A /4** >#AT)/ 2A#-C*F D? 0*0TC#**0./4 ?# *47-A4 ?14 #.*4AI0(2 #> >-(G)T4(?)/ A021?* )(G >A44G#T* #> 4I4AP0(G0I0G-)/ )(G ) C)A?07-/)A 1-T)( .40(2 60?1#-? )7?0#( ?# 0(7A4)*4 ?14 0(G0I0GY-)/ )(G 7#//47?0I4 *4(*4 #> A4*C#(*0.0/0?P ?#6)AG* #?14A C4#C/4H )* 64// )* ?#>-?-A4 24(4A)?0#(*F

[Z

P6@*& !&'20,&1,% )* +", 23%)4,#' 5#%6$#&,'+7

!"#$%&#' )* +", 25 !)&&$88$)' *)% A)%,$.' ;**#$%8

D A47)// ?1)? G-A0(2 T)A?0)/ /)6 0( ,#/)(GH 30* 3#/0(4** ^#1( ,)-/ DD 6)**C4)$0(2 0( ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(? )(G 7)//4G >#A ?14 C#/0?07)/ -(0?P #> B-YA#C4H )(G )? ?14 *)T4 ?0T4 >#A )// 7#-(?A04* ?# >0(G C4)74 )(G >A44G#TF U#6)YG)P*H 0?+* T-71 4)*04A ?# 7A0?070O4 ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(F

"4 54AT)( ,)A/0)T4(?)A0)(* G0*?A0.-?4G ,#C4 cA)(70*+ *C4471H 60?1 7A0?07)/6#AG* ).#-? ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(Hq0( #-A 4/47?0#( G0*?A07?* 60?1 1021 70A7-/)Y?0#(F <10* *C4471 0* 7-??0(2H .-? ?14 3#/P c)?14A )0T4G *?A#(24A N-G2T4(? )? ?14k)?07)(F <14 7A0?070*T G0A47?4G ?#6)AG ?14 k)?07)( *?0// G0G (#? *1)$4 TP >)0?10( ?14 @1-A71H )(G (40?14A G0G ?14 7A0?070*T #> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( *1)$4 TP>)0?1 0( ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(F <14 3#/P c)?14A+* C-AC#*4H 1#64I4AH 6)* )7104I4GF<#G)PH 64 )A4 ) -(0#( #> 8X 7#-(?A04* )(G ?14 7#-(?A04* #> @4(?A)/ )(G B)*?4A(B-A#C4 )A4 L4T.4A Q?)?4* #( ?14 .)*0* #> G4T#7A)7P )(G ?14 A-/4 #> /)6H 47#Y(#T07 CA#*C4A0?P )(G *#70)/ N-*?074F

BI4( 0( 899\H ,#C4 ^#1( ,)-/ DD *C#$4 *0T0/)A 6#AG*H 61071 D 7)( >-//P)774C? )* TP 0G4)/ 0T)24 #> B-A#C4F "14( )774C?0(2 )( 0(?4A()?0#()/ @1)A/4*M6)AGH 14 *)0GJ !<14 B-A#C4 ?1)? D GA4)T #> 0* ) C#/0?07)/ -(0?PH )(G 4I4( T#A4) *C0A0?-)/ -(0?PH 614A4 )// C#/0?070)(* )7? 0( ?14 )6)A4(4** #> ?14 64)/?1 #> ?14*C0A0?-)/ T)(H 614A4 T4( )(G 6#T4( )//#6 ?14*4 I)/-4* ?# .4)A >A-0?H *# ?1)?1-T)( /0>4 *10(4* 0( ?14 >)74 #> 5#GF+

D?+* )( )??0?-G4 ?1)? ?#G)P D )T )./4 ?# -(G4A*?)(GH )( )??0?-G4 ?1)? 0* #-A 2#)/F<14A4 0*H 1#64I4AH ) *1#A?)24H .47)-*4 ?14A4 )A4 (#? #(/P @1A0*?0)( C#/0?070)(*H)(G )T#(2 -* @1A0*?0)( C#/0?070)(*H ?14A4 )A4 @1A0*?0)( C#/0?070)(* 60?1 G0>>4A4(?I046*H 61071 )A4 7#((47?4G ?# ?14 G0>>4A4(? ?A)G0?0#(* )(G ?14 CA0(70C/4 #> *-.Y*0G0)A0?PF "4 )// 2A46 -C 0( ?14 ?A)G0?0#(* #> #-A 7#-(?A04*H )(G #> 7#-A*4 641)I4 ) G0>>4A4(? *?)A?0(2 C#*0?0#(F BI4( ?14 T#*? >)0?1>-/ *#( #> ?14 L#?14A #>@1-A71 #> cA)(74 7#-/G (4I4A T#I4 )6)P >A#T *47-/)A0*TF <10* 0* ) G0>>4A4(?-(G4A*?)(G0(2 #> ?14 *?)?4Y71-A71 A4/)?0#(*10C ?1)( ?14 #(4 64 $(#6 >A#T 54AYT)(PH )(G 64 *1#-/G )774C? 0?F D? 6)* A021?/P 7/)0T4G >#A )(G ?14 ,#C4 T4(Y?0#(4G 0? 0( 10* *C4471 )? ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(?F <14 CA0(70C/4 #> *-.*0G0)A0?P*1#-/G .4 A4*C47?4GF

[\

D( #-A C#/0?07)/ CA)7?074 64 *1#-/G )/*# )/6)P* 7#(?A#/ #-A A4*0*?)(74F B-YA#C4 7)( *-AI0I4 #(/P #( ?14 CA0(70C/4 #> ?14 *#I4A402(?P #> ()?0#(* )(G 0(I0#/)Y.0/0?P #> .#AG4A*F <10* 0* 61P ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( ?#/G ?14 )22A4**#A 0( f$A)0(4?1)? 64 0TC#*4 *)(7?0#(* )2)0(*? 10TH 4I4( ?1#-21 0? 7#*?* -* ?# *1#6 ?14 )2Y2A4**#A ?1)? )22A4**0#( 0* 4iC4(*0I4F @#TC)(04* 0( TP G0*?A07? G# (#? .4/04I4?1)? ?10* 0* ?14 #C?0T)/ *#/-?0#( .47)-*4 0? 0* A4/)?4G ?# G4I4/#CT4(? )(G N#.*H.-? *?0// 64 G0G 0? )(G 0? 0* )774C?4GH .47)-*4 C4#C/4 *)P ?1)? 0(?4A()?0#()/ /)6)(G >-(G)T4(?)/ A021?* )A4 T#A4 0TC#A?)(? ?1)( .-*0(4**F <10* 0* ) I4AP 0TC#AY?)(? C#0(?F <10* 0* ?14 T4)*-A4 #> B-A#C4)( *#/0G)A0?PH 61071 D 6#-/G 7#(*0G4A0TC#**0./4 4I4( ?6#Y?1A44 P4)A* )2#F "4 *1#-/G 4TC1)*0O4 ?10*F

"4 1)I4 ?# C)** ?14 *)T4 ?4*? #( ?14 0**-4* #> 6)AH >)T0(4 )(G ?14 7#(*4Ym-4(74* #> 7/0T)?4 71)(24 61071 )A4 7#((47?4G 60?1 A4>-244* )(G 1#6 64 ?A4)??14TF "4 )A4 G0*7-**0(2 ?14 *-.N47?F D( ?14 )A4) #> 4(4A2P C#/07PH ,#/0*1 0(?4AY4*?* )A4 64// $(#6( ?# T4 0( ?14 7#(?4i? #> ,#/0*1 7#)/F M* 64 7)( *44H ?14A4 0*) ?1A4)? >A#T ?14 4)*? )(G ?14 0**-4* A4/)?4G ?# ?14*4j .-? )? ?14 *)T4 ?0T4 7/0T)?471)(24H C#I4A?P )(G T02A)?0#( )A4 )/*# A4/)?4G ?# 0?F "4 *1#-/G >0(G ) A4)*#()Y./4 .)/)(74 14A4H 61071 60// )/6)P* .4 ) 7#TCA#T0*4 h ?14A4 0* (4I4A C-A4*704(74 #( ?14*4 0**-4*F <14A4 60// )/6)P* .4 (474**)AP ?A)G4Y#>>* .4?644( /4Y20?0T)?4 C#/0?07)/ 0(?4A4*?* )(G ?14 7#(*4m-4(74* #> 7/0T)?4 71)(24F D? G#4* (#?14/C #-A C#/0?07)/ 6#A$F <14 C#/07P ?#6)AG* 0TT02A)(?* )(G A4>-244* 0* )/*#7#TC/4iF <14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(H 60?1 ?14 `0*.#( <A4)?PH )7104I4G ?1)? 0**-4* #>G02(0?PH >A44G#T )(G 1-T)( A021?* )7?-)//P 1)I4 ) 10214A *1)A4 0( B-A#C4)(C#/0?07*F

3#64I4AH 614( 64 ?)/$ ).#-? ?14 B-A#C4)( <A4)?PH )(G ?10* 0* ) C)A? #> #-AA4*C#(*4H ?14 @1)A?4A #> c-(G)T4(?)/ =021?* 60?1 0?* C#/0704* )CC/04* #(/P ?#B-A#C4)( /420*/)?0#( )(G 0?* 0TC/4T4(?)?0#(F <1)? 0* 61P ?14 @1)A?4A #> c-(G)YT4(?)/ =021?* *1#-/G (#? .4 G4>0(4G )* ) A4*C#(*4 ?# *#T4?10(2 ?1)? 0* ) ()?0#(Y)/ CA#C4A?PF <10* 0* (#? 0?* N#.F <14A4>#A4H D 1)I4 ) >0AT I046 ?1)? ?14 B-A#C4)(f(0#( 1)* (# 7#TC4?4(74 0( T)??4A* #> ).#A?0#( )(G >)T0/P C#/07PF D )/*# A4>A)0(>A#T /420*/)?0#( ?1)? )??4TC?* ?# )GGA4** ?14*4 0**-4* 0( ) 74(?A)/0*?07 6)PH 0( ?14B-A#C4)( 6)PH )(G 0> *#H ?14 Bf *1#-/G (#? .4 ./)T4G >#A CA4I4(?0(2 74A?)0(?10(2* 61071 )A4 (#? /0$4GF e#- 1)I4 ?# .4 1#(4*?H P#- 1)I4 ?# .4 >)0AH )(G (#? ?#*C#0/ 74A?)0( ?10(2*F

"4 A4)G 0( ?14 CA4)T./4 #> ?14 <A4)?P ?1)? ?14 7-/?-A)/H A4/020#-* )(G 1-T)(Y0*? 0(14A0?)(74* #> B-A#C4 )A4 C4A740I4G )* -(0I4A*)/ I)/-4*H )A4 )* 0(I0#/)./4)(G 0(I)A0)./4 )* ?14 A021?* #> ?14 1-T)( C4A*#( /0$4 >A44G#TH G4T#7A)7PH 4m-)/0?P)(G ?14 A-/4 #> /)6F _?14A )A4)* #> >-(G)T4(?)/ A021?* )A4 71)//4(24)./4 h ?10* 0*) m-#?4 A021? >A#T ?14 <A4)?P #> `0*.#(F

D( MA?07/4 : 64 A4)GJ <14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( 0* .)*4G #( A4*C47? >#A 1-T)(G02(0?PH >A44G#TH G4T#7A)7PH 4m-)/0?PH ?14 A-/4 #> /)6 )(G A4*C47? >#A 1-T)(

[[

A021?*H 0(7/-G0(2 ?14 A021?* #> ) C4A*#( 61# 0* ) T4T.4A #> ) T0(#A0?PF D( MA?07/48 64 A4)G ?1)? #-A ?)*$ 0* ?# CA#T#?4 C4)74H I)/-4* )(G ?14 64//Y.40(2 #> 0(G0YI0G-)/* )(G C4#C/4*F D ?10($ ?10* 0* ) I4AP 0TC#A?)(? *?)?4T4(?H )(G )? ?14 *)T4?0T4 0? 7#((47?* ?# ?14 ?)*$* ?1)? )A4 )**#70)?4G 60?1 N-*?074F <14 B-A#C4)( f(Y0#( >-/>0/* (#? #(/P ?14*4 I)/-4*H .-? T-*? .4 7#TC4?0?0I4 )(G )? ?14 *)T4 ?0T4*#70)//P N-*?H 614A4 ?14A4 0* (# G0*?0(7?0#( T)G4 .4?644( ?14 #A020( #> T)(H )(G?1)? 7#TT0?T4(? 0(7/-G4* (#? #(/P 47#(#T07 0**-4*H .-? )/*# 61)? *#70)/ N-*?0740* )(G 61)? 7#((47?* ?# 1-T)( G02(0?PF "4 A4)G ).#-? A4/020#-* >A44G#TH (#?#(/P 0( ?14 54AT)( ?4i?H .-? )/*# 0( ?14 B(2/0*1 ?4i? h ?14A4 64 1)I4 ?14 ?4AT!A4/020#-*+F

D C)A?070C)?4G 0( ?14 ?)/$* )* ) T4T.4A #> ?14 @#(*?0?-?0#()/ @#(I4(?0#(HD )/*# $(#6 ?14 #A020( #> ?14*4 0**-4*H )(G D A42A4? ?1)? ?14A4 0* (# A4>4A4(74 ?#5#GF

D TP*4/> *-.T0??4G )( )CC/07)./4 CA#C#*)/ #( .41)/> #> ?14 B,, ?# -*4 ?14,#/0*1 I4A*0#(F D? 7A)*14G )2)0(*? ) T0(#A0?P #> 7#-(?A04*H T)0(/P >A#T cA4(71Y*C4)$0(2 )A4)*H )* D CA4I0#-*/P #-?/0(4GF "4 1)G ) /)A24 T)N#A0?P 0( >)I#-AF D>D 7)( m-#?4 0( B(2/0*1 >A#T ?14 CA4)T./4H ?14 f(0#( 0* >#-(G4G #( ?14 I)/-4* #>*#/0G)A0?PH A4*C47? >#A 1-T)( .40(2* )(G ?14 A-/4 #> /)6F ,4#C/4 )A4 )? ?14 14)A?#> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(+* )7?0I0?04*H 7A4)?0(2 ) 70?0O4(*10C #> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(Y0#(H 7A4)?0(2 )( )A4) #> N-*?074 )(G *47-A0?PF D? 0* (#? )* *4? 0( *?#(4F U# #(4*1#-/G .4 7#(G4T(4G #A C4A*47-?4GF M// ?14*4 A47#AG* )A4 I4AP 7/4)AF e#- 7)(Y(#? -*4H >#A 4i)TC/4H ) 1-T)( .#GP 0( #AG4A ?# 24? A071F c#A74G /).#-A 0* CA#10.Y0?4GF D> B-A#C4)( /420*/)?0#( #CC#*4G 0?H ?14 ()?0#(* T)P *-4 ?14 M7? )(G ?1)? 0*) 1-24 0TCA#I4T4(?F D ?10($ 64 *1#-/G (#? ?AP ?# 02(#A4 0?F D? 0* -()(0T#-*/P)G#C?4G .P )// #> ?14 L4T.4A Q?)?4*F D ?10($ 0? *1#-/G 1)I4 2A4)? *02(0>07)(74 ?#-* ?14*4 G)P*F

,#C4 cA)(70* *)0G #( ?14 G02(0?P #> T)( h )(G ?10* )2A44* 60?1 61)? 64*?A0I4 >#A 0( B-A#C4 h ?1)? 4I4( 0( B-A#C4 64 1)G ?# G4)/ 60?1 G0>>07-/? T#T4(?*0( ?14 C)*?H )(G (#6 ?14 A47#2(0?0#( #> ?14 0TC#A?)(74 #> 1-T)( A021?* 0* )**#Y70)?4G 60?1 ?14 #-?7#T4 #> ) /#(2 CA#74** #> *->>4A0(2 )(G >021?0(2F U#6 641)I4 7A4)?4G ) 6#A/G 0( 61071 64 ?AP ?# C)P T#A4 )??4(?0#( ?# ?14 0TC#A?)(74 #>?14 1-T)( .40(2F <10* 0* 7#((47?4G (#? #(/P 60?1 10*?#APH .-? 24(4A)//P 60?1.A#)G B-A#C4)( ?10($0(2F <14 A#/4 #> A4/020#( 0* 14A4 ()?-A)//P 4i?A4T4/P 0TYC#A?)(?H )(G #-A *#-A74* )A4 G4A0I4G >A#T )(704(? 5A4474 )(G =#T4H >A#T 54AYT)(07 )(G Q/)I07 *#-A74*j ?#24?14A )// #> ?14*4 7-/?-A4* 1)I4 )( 0TC)7? #( #-A-(G4A*?)(G0(2 #> ?14 1-T)( .40(2F

3-T)( G02(0?P 0* 20I4( ?# C4#C/4 )(G (#? .#AA#64GF 34(74H 0? G#4* (#? T)?Y?4A 614?14A ) C4A*#( 0* A071H C##AH 61)? A)74H 61)? *4iH )(G ?# 61071 A4/020#(?14P .4/#(2F "14?14A ?10* 0* ) T)( #A ) 6#T)(H #A )(P #?14A A4)*#( >#A G0*7A0TY

[;

0()?0#( 64 6#-/G >0(GF D ?10($ ?1)? ?10* 0* ) 7A0?07)/ 0(?4ACA4?)?0#( #> ?10*H )*D -(G4A*?)(G 1-T)( G02(0?PF

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f(>#A?-()?4/PH (#? )/6)P*F

"4 )/*# (44G ?# *44 61)? ?14 /0T0?* #> ) 7#(?4TC#A)AP *?)?4 )A4F D( TP #C0(Y0#(H ?14 *?)?4 74A?)0(/P 7)((#? 0(?A#G-74 /420*/)?0#( ?1)? 6#-/G A4*?A07? TP /0>4)77#AG0(2 ?# TP @)?1#/07 >)0?1F D 1)G )( 4iC4A04(74 ?1)? *1)C4G T4 )* ) P#-(2T)(F <10* 6)* \[ P4)A* )2#H 614( D 6)* 0( Q7#?/)(GF LP >A04(G*H ) T)AA04G7#-C/4H .47)T4 C)A4(?* >#A ?14 *47#(G ?0T4F <14P 6)(?4G ?# 1)I4 ) .0224A )C)A?YT4(?H *# ?14P 64(? ?# ?14 1#-*0(2 #>>074 0( BG0(.-A21 )(G 14)AGJ !"4 G# (#?1)I4 /)A24A )C)A?T4(?*H .-? 14A4 P#- 1)I4 ) A4>4AA)/ ?# ) 2P()47#/#20*? 61# 7)(C4A>#AT )( ).#A?0#(F+

D> ?14 *?)?4 7#(*0G4A* *-71 )( )/?4A()?0I4H 0? 0* (#? ) *?)?4 ?1)? A4*C47?* 1-T)(A021?*F "4 1)I4 ?# 0(?A#G-74 0? )// ?# ?14 CA)7?074 #> ?14 *?)?4H *# ?1)? C4#C/4 0(*-71 *0?-)?0#(* )A4 (#? >#A74G ?# )7? )2)0(*? ?140A 7#(I07?0#(*F D? 7)((#? .4 *#?1)? ?14 *?)?4 0* 4i)7?/P )* #A2)(0O4G )* D 0T)20(4 0? TP*4/>H .47)-*4 ?14A4 )A4#?14A C4#C/4 61# /0I4 ?14A4F D? T4)(* ?1)? D 1)I4 ?# T)$4 7#TCA#T0*4* 14A4 *#?1)? #?14A* T021? /0I4 G0>>4A4(?/PF <14 7#(>02-A)?0#( #> ?14*4 7#TCA#T0*4* 0( )A4)*#()./4 T)((4A 0* ) I4AP 0TC#A?)(? ?)*$H 61071 64 *1#-/G A4T4T.4A )(G*1#-/G ?)$4 0(?# )77#-(?F

c#A ?10* A4)*#(H >A44G#T T-*? )/*# .4 C4A740I4G 0( *-71 ) 6)P ?1)? 64 7)(Y(#? 4iC47? 4I4AP?10(2 >A#T ?14 *?)?4H 61071 60// A42-/)?4 ?10*H .47)-*4 0> 0? G0G?1)?H 0? 6#-/G .4 ) *?)?4 #> 5#GH 61071 64 G# (#? 6)(?H )* #?14A* )/*# G# (#?6)(? 0?F <10* 0* 0AA47#(70/)./4 60?1 ) (#AT)/H T#G4A( 7#(*?0?-?0#()/ *?)?4H .-? 641)I4 ?# *?A0I4H ?1A#-21 #-A ?4*?0T#(PH *# ?1)? 64 7)( C4A*-)G4 ?14 T)N#A0?P *#?1)? 64 7)( G4>0(4 >A44G#T )* >A44G#T ?# *#T4?10(2F

<1)? 0* 61P D A4/)?4 ?# ?14 @)?1#/07 *#70)/ ?4)710(2 ?1)? .42)( 60?1 `4# xDDDFcA#T TP 0(G0I0G-)/ ()?-A4H >A#T ?14 G02(0?P D 1)I4H 7#T4* ) 7#TT0?T4(? ?#)77#-(?).0/0?PH ?# A4*C#(*0./4 >A44G#TF D? 6)* 6A0??4( .4>#A4 .P TP C)A?P 0( 0?*CA#2A)TF =4*C#(*0./4 >A44G#T T4)(* ?1)? D .4)A ?14 A4*C#(*0.0/0?P >#A ?14 7#TYT#( 2##GH ?1)? )* )( 0(G0I0G-)/ D 7)((#? 2A#6 TP .-*0(4** *# >)A ?1)? 0? (42)Y?0I4/P )>>47?* ?14 >A44G#T )(G /0I0(2 7#(G0?0#(* #> #?14A*F <10* 7)( .4 G#(4 (#?#(/P ?1A#-21 /420*/)?0#(F <10* 0* TP A4*C#(*0.0/0?Pj ?10* 0* 0( TP 1)(G*F <10* 1)*

[W

?# .4 4iC/)0(4GF D? *44T* ?1)? ?#G)P 64 )A4 0( ?## T-71 G0*7-**0#( 0( 61071 64A4)G #(/P ).#-? A021?*H )(G 64 (4I4A A4)G ).#-? #./02)?0#(*F _(4 T-*? 2# 1)(G0( 1)(G 60?1 ?14 #?14AF <10* 0* #-A 7#(74C? #> >A44G#TF <10* 0* ) G0>>4A4(74 0(A4/)?0#( ?# ?14 *#70)/0*? 7#(74C? #> >A44G#TF _-A 7#(74C? h )(G ?10* 0* )/*# )G0>>4A4(74 0( A4/)?0#( ?# *#/0G)A0?P h #-A *#/0G)A0?P A4)G*J !4I4AP#(4 0* A4*C#(*0Y./4 >#A ?14T*4/I4* .-? 1)* ?14 A021? ?# 24? *?)?4 )0G 0> ?14P 0* (#? )./4 ?# 14/C?14T*4/I4*H+ )(G (#? 0TT4G0)?4/P )**-T4 ?1)? D (44G ?# .4 *-CC#A?4G .P ?14*?)?4H .47)-*4 ?1)? 0* ?14 4(G #> >A44G#TF <14A4 0* (# /#(24A )(P *7#C4 #> >A44YG#T >#A T4F

<10* 0* )/*# /0($4G ?# ?14 G02(0?P #> 6#A$F M77#AG0(2 ?# @)?1#/07 *#70)/ ?4)71Y0(2* 7#(?)0(4G 0( ?14 4(7P7/07)/* #> ?14 C#C4* ?0// ?14 CA4*4(? G)PH 0(7/-G0(2?1#*4 6A0??4( .P ^#1( ,)-/ DDH ?14 G02(0?P #> 6#A$ )/6)P* 1)* ) 1021 I)/-4F <14A021?* #> ?14 6#A$4A )A4 (#? #(/P ?14 A021? ?# ) >-(7?0#(0(2 47#(#TPF D )T (#? )*-CC#A?4A #> 7)C0?)/0*T #A 7#TT-(0*TF D ?10($ .#?1 )A4 6A#(2F <14 `0*.#(<A4)?P 7#(?)0(* ) CA#I0*0#( A42)AG0(2 ?14 *#70)/ T)A$4? 47#(#TP ?# ?)$4 )GI)(Y?)24 #> ?14 T)A$4? )(G )GN-*? 0? ?1A#-21 *?)?4 A42-/)?0#(*H ?# 4(*-A4 7#TC4?0?0#(H20I0(2 ) 71)(74 ?# ?14 64)$H )(G (#? ?# 20I4 -C 4I4AP?10(2 #(/P ?# ?14 0G4) #>7#TC4?0?0#(F <10* 0* ?14 T0GG/4 2A#-(G ?1)? *1#-/G .4 C-A*-4G .P @1A0*?0)(R4T#7A)?*F

_I4A ?14 /)*? P4)A )(G ) 1)/>H D )??4(G4G ) (-T.4A #> 7)TC* 0( ^#AG)(H `4.)Y(#(H <-A$4P )(G DA)m0 S-AG0*?)(F <10* P4)AH ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( L4T.4A Q?)?4*h D 7A0?070O4 14A4 .#?1 ,#/)(G )(G 54AT)(P h 1)I4 A4G-74G #A *#T4?0T4* .A#-21??# O4A# 0?* >-(G* >#A ?14 6#A/G >##G CA#2A)TH *# 64 1)G ?# *)P ?# ?14 C4#C/4 0(?14 7)TC* ?1A44 T#(?1* )2#H ?1)? ?14 A4*4AI4* #> >##G 60// .4 A4G-74G .P \9|)(G ?14 G)0/P G#*4 60// .4 #(/PqX99 $7)/F D? 6)* #(4 #> ?14 A4)*#(* 61P ?14*4C4#C/4 >A#T ?14 7)TC* 10? ?14 A#)GF D >0(G ?10* ) /)7$ #> @1A0*?0)( A4*C#(*0.0/0?PH(#? #(/P >A#T L4T.4A Q?)?4*H .-? ?14 4(?0A4 B-A#C4)( f(0#(F

D( )GG0?0#( ?# ?14 #C4(0(2 #> ?14 .#AG4A* #> <-A$4P ?10* 6)* ?14 G470*0I4A4)*#( 61P 64 )* L4T.4A Q?)?4* 1)I4 ?# G0*7-** ?10*F D $(#6 ?14 0**-4* #>0G4(?0?P )A4 A4/)?4G ?# ?10*F D $(#6 ?1)? 64 1)I4 G0>>4A4(? *?)A?0(2 C#0(?* 614( 0?7#T4* ?# A4/#7)?0#(F D $(#6 ?1)? 4I4( 0( 54AT)(PH ?14P /##$ )? 0? G0>>4A4(?/PFD?+* 1)AG ?# )A2-4 ?14A4H 614A4 #(74 ?14A4 6)* 7#TT-(0*TH 61071 *4C)A)?4G0?*4/> )(G C4A740I4G >#A402( )* G)(24A#-*F <1)? 0* 61P D -(G4A*?)(G ?14 G0*7-*Y*0#( 0( ,#/)(GF M// ?14 T#A4 D )T 2A)?4>-/ >#A ?14 )??0?-G4 #> ?14 ,#/0*1 2#I4A(YT4(?H 61071 0( ?14 T0GG/4 #> ?14 4/47?0#( 7)TC)02( *1#64G ) 2A4)? G4)/ #>@1A0*?0)( 71)A0?PF <10* *1#-/G .4 1#(#-A4G )(G 7/4)A/P 4TC1)*0O4GF

D( ?14 6#A/G 0( 61071 ;9 T0//0#( A4>-244* /0I4 h :9Y:8 T0//0#( N-*? 0( ?14L0GG/4 B)*? h 1#64I4AH 64 T-*? .4 )./4 ?# )/*# 1)I4 ) .4??4A C#/07P ?# CA#?47?@1A0*?0)(*F DT)20(4 ?1)? ?14 *0?-)?0#( 0( B2PC? 6#A*4(*F M? Q0()0H D*/)T0*?* )/YA4)GP 7#(*?0?-?4 ) T)N#A0?PF @#C?* /0I4 ?14A4 h ?14A4 )A4 :[ T0//0#( #> ?14TH

[X

:9| #> ?14 B2PC?0)( C#C-/)?0#(F D A4T4T.4A #(4 (021? 614( D ?4/4C1#(4G ?1A44Y>#-A C4#C/4 )(G 64 7#(I0(74G ?14 ?14( ,A4*0G4(? L-A*0 ?1)?H 7#(?A)AP ?# 10*)??0?-G4H 14 >0()//P *4(? ?14 C#/074 ?# CA4I4(? ?14 .-A(0(2 #> ) @#C?07 7)?14GA)/ 0(@)0A#F D?+* ) *74()A0# ?1)? 0* )14)G #> -*F D( ?14 .)7$2A#-(G 64 1)I4 ) >)/*4C#/07P ?#6)AG* DA)m )(G ̀ 4.)(#(H ?# 4(?4A 60?1#-? ?)$0(2 7)A4 #> ?14 C4)74Fq<10*/4)G* ?# G0*)*?4A*F "4 (44G ?# 1)I4 ) G0>>4A4(? ?A)G4 C#/07PH ?# ?14 >0*14A04* )(G7/0T)?4 71)(24F

D> 64 G# (#? CA#I0G4 ) .4??4A 71)(74 >#A ?14 >-?-A4 >#A C4#C/4 0( M>A07)H ?14P60// 7#T4 14A4F `4? T4 T4(?0#( ) >46 (-T.4A*F [9| #> *?)?4 *#70)/ *C4(G0(2C)0G >#A #( ?10* 4)A?1 0* C)0G ?# WFZ| #> ?14 70?0O4(* #> ?14 6#A/GF <14P /0I4 0(B-A#C4F D> D 6)* A4T)0(0(2 0( C#I4A?P )(G G07?)?#A*10C 0( BA0?A4)H D 6#-/G $(#661)? ?# G#F U#6 0? G4C4(G* #( -*H 0> 64 6)(? ?# $44C #-A I)/-4*H 0> 64 6)(? ?#A4T)0( B-A#C4)(*H 0> 0? 0* ?# .4 ) T)0(/P @1A0*?0)( 7#(?0(4(?H *1#-/G 64 (#? N#0()// #-A >#A74* ?# CA4*4AI4 1-T)(0?PH ?# (#? )//#6 C4#C/4 ?# G04 #> 1-(24AH )(G 64CA0T)A0/P *1#-/G T)$4 *-A4 ?1)? 60?1 ?14 14/C #> T#(4P )(G #?14A T4)(* 644(*-A4 ?14T ) G474(? /0>4 )? 1#T4F

D )T 2/)G ?1)? ?14 B-A#C4)( @#-(70/H )>?4A T)(P A4T0(G4A* >A#T #-A *0G4H?##$ ?14 >0A*? *?4C 0( ?10* G0A47?0#(H .-? D ?10($ ?1)? 64 7)((#? 4*7)C4 A4*C#(*0.0/Y0?PF M// #> ?14*4 4i)TC/4* *1#6 ?1)? ?14 ()?0#( *?)?4 0* (#? )./4 ?# G# )(P?10(2FD> ) 7#-(?AP 0* ?AP0(2 ?# 7-? 0?*4/> #>> )(G 7/#*4H 0? 60// .4 T#A4 4iC#*4G ?# ?14?1A4)?F <6# ?1#-*)(G P4)A* )2# 54AT)(07 ?A0.4* >A#T ?14 4)*? )(G (#A?1 #> ?147#(?0(4(? 7)T4 ?# ?14 T#*? C#64A>-/ 7#-(?A04* 0( ?14 6#A/G G-4 ?# 7/0T)?4 71)(24H.47)-*4 )? 1#T4 ?14P 1)G (#?10(2 ?# 4)?F <14P G4*?A#P4G )(Gq/4G ?# ?14 >)// #>?14 =#T)( BTC0A4F <14( 64H ?14 54AT)(*H #77-C04G U#A?1 M>A07)H <-(0*0)H)A4)* ?1)? 64A4 ?14 2A)()AP #> =#T4 0( #AG4A ?# *-AI0I4F Q40O0(2 ?14*4 )A4)* 6)*) ./#6 ?# =#T4F D* ?10* ) *0?-)?0#( ?1)? (#6 A4C4)?* 0?*4/>l D* ?10* (#? ?14 T#YT4(? 0( 61071 G-4 ?# @1A0*?0)( A4*C#(*0.0/0?P 64 *1#-/G 14/C CA4*4AI4 ?14 1-YT)(0?P #> ?14 C4#C/4 61# )A4 *?A-22/0(2 ?# *-AI0I4l "14( 6#T4( >A#T ?14e)O0G0 A4/020#-* 7#TT-(0?P )A4 >/440(2 >A#T DQDQ ?4AA#A0*?*H #>?4( A)C4GH 610/4/0I0(2 0( S-AG0*1 7)TC*H ?14( P#- $(#6 61)? 0* 0TC#A?)(? ?# ?14T ?#G)PF "4*1#-/G )GT0? ?14T )(G 4(*-A4 ?1)? 0? 60// (4I4A 1)CC4( )2)0(H *# ?1)? ?14P 7)(/0I4 0( C4)74 )? 1#T4F

,A4I4(?0I4 )7?0I0?04* 0( M>A07) )A4 )/*# 0TC#A?)(?F D? 60// 7#*? ) /#?F L)(PA4CA4*4(?)?0I4* #> #-A 47#(#TP 60// 1)I4 ) 14)G)714F "4 1)I4 ?# A4)/0O4 ?14*7)/4 #> ?10* C14(#T4(#(H #?14A60*4 ?14*4 *?A4)T* #> C4#C/4 60// 4(G (40?14A?10* P4)A (#A 0( ?14 (4i? :9 P4)A*F D? (44G* ?# .4 G#(4 0( ) CA)7?07)/ 6)PF M? ?144(G /4? T4 m-#?4 ?14 3#/P c)?14A >A#T ; Q4C?4T.4A 89:[J !D )CC4)/ ?# )// ?14C)A0*14*H ?# )// 7#TT-(0?04* )7A#** B-A#C4 ?# ?)$4 0( #(4 A4>-244 >)T0/P+F

Summaryof the Working Groups

<14 4(?0A4 G0*7-**0#( #> )// #> ?14 6#A$0(2 2A#-C*7)( .4 /0*?4(4G ?# #( ?14 7#(>4A4(74+* 64.*0?4

&&&2$%8;6%DF:,"%>#2%"42>D

;:

P+0;'& M&;-& ="'&10*2

=-@@*&8 '( ;:, ?'&201C C&'-" ,1;0;6,+Q

-./0.!1� Existential Value, Personal Value

or Legal Category

?:09: ?*. *;;,1+,+ 78Q

D'+,&*;'&Q!" !$%&'&() *$+,$-.()7 ,@$+)%M$'M<"$,* )* +", &#.#/$', !"#$

PR",&;.Q/"$01 23$%). 4"$.57 4"$6)8)4",% )* %,6$.$)'7 +",)6).$#'7 N)3%'#6$8+6'') 7)8$".()7 09 5"97 0,&1,% )* +", 23%)4,#' 5#%6$#&,'+70,&1,% )* +", 23%)4,#' 5#%6$#&,'+ !)&&$++,, )' O)&,'P8 D$."+8 #'@ J,'@,% 2Q3#6$+C

`)G04* )(G 54(?/4T4(HD 6)AT/P 64/7#T4 P#- )//F "4 )A4 I4AP C/4)*4G ?# .4 14A4 >#A ?14 *47#(G

?0T4F e4*?4AG)P 64 C)A?070C)?4G 0( )// #> ?14 4I4(?*H 7)A4>-//P )(G 60?1 7#TT0?YT4(?F "4 64A4 7)A4>-//P ?)$0(2 (#?4* )(G (#6 64 6#-/G /0$4 ?# A4C#A? ?14T ?#P#-F Q0(74 ?14 CA#2A)T 0* C)7$4GH )* 0? ?-A(* #-?H ?14 T44?0(2* )A4 G0I0G4G 0(?#?1A44 2A#-C* )(G 64 6#-/G 1)I4 ?# 1)I4 ?14 20>? #> .0Y #A 4I4( ?A0Y/#7)?0#( ?# .4)./4 ?# C)A?070C)?4 0( 4I4AP?10(2F <14A4>#A4H #-A ?)*$ 0* ?# .A0(2 P#- 7/#*4A ?#61)? 6)* 1)CC4(0(2 )(G 614A4F

D 71#*4 ?14 2A#-C 7#(74A(0(2 G02(0?PF D 1)G *#T4 7#(74A(* ?1)? *0(74 ?14?0?/4G 7)?42#A04* )A4 I4AP 24(4A)/H 64 6#-/G .4 7)-21? 0( #I4A/P C10/#*#C107)/G0*7-**0#(* #( G4>0(0(2 7#(74C?* )* 64// )* )A2-T4(?* ).#-? T4)(0(2F

D .4/04I4 ?1)? 64 64A4 )./4 ?# )I#0G ?10* CA#./4TH )(G ?14 G0*7-**0#(* )7?-Y)//P #C4A)?4G #( ) 7#(7A4?4 /4I4/F D TP*4/> 6)* )./4 ?# /4)A( *#T4?10(2 >A#T?14TF _> 7#-A*4H ?14 ?#C07 6)* CA4*4(? >A#T ?14 I4AP .420((0(2 #> ?14 7#(>4AY4(74 0( 0(?A#G-7?#AP /47?-A4*F

BI4( @)AG0()/ Q?)(0*/)6 RO060*O 10T*4/>H 2A44?0(2 ?14 )??4(G)(?*H )GG4G#(4 T#A4 7)?42#AP h ?14 7)?42#AP #> ?A-?1j 14 A4T0(G4G 4I4AP#(4 ?1)? ?10* 0* ?14

;8

.)*0* >#A >A44G#T )(G G02(0?PH )(G 60?1#-? ?A-?1H >A44G#T 7#-/G /#*4 ?# C#/0?07)/7#AA47?(4**F

34 4iCA4**4G 10* 1#C4* ?1)? 64 G# (#? *-77-T. ?# ?14 ?4TC?)?0#( #> 4)*P)(*64A* ?# G0>>07-/? m-4*?0#(* )(G CA#./4T*F

<14A4 64A4 0(?A#G-7?0#(* ?# ?14*4 ?1A44 6#A$*1#C ?#C07* h ?1A44 /47?-A4*Fc)?14A RA c/#A0)( S#/>1)-* #> ?14 Q47A4?)A0)? #> Q?)?4 #> ?14 3#/P Q44H 61#.A#-21? 2A44?0(2* >A#T @)AG0()/ ,04?A# ,)A#/0(H ?A04G ?# 7/)A0>P ?14 ?#C07 #> G02Y(0?PF 34 .42)( .P )*$0(2 614?14A G02(0?P 0* )7m-0A4G #A 0(14A0?4GF 30* /47?-A4?A04G ?# )(*64A ?10* m-4*?0#( 0( ?14 7#(?4i? #> A4/020#-* C/-A)/0*TF

R4*C0?4 ?14 >)7? ?1)? ?14 )(*64A 6)*H 64 1#C4GH ?# .4 *#T461)? A4/020#-*H cAS#/>1)-* -A24G ?1)? ?14 )(*64A* .P -* @1A0*?0)(* 1)G )( 0(?4AA4/020#-* 7#(?4i?F

<14 m-4*?0#( )*$4G 14A4 6)* 614?14A ?14*4 I)/-4* 7)( .4 )774C?4G .P #?1Y4A*l D* G02(0?P )7m-0A4G #A 0(14A0?4Gl M* )( 4/#m-4(? *C4)$4AH c)?14A S#/>1)-*.42)( 60?1 )( )(47G#?4F 34 A47)//4G ?14 *0?-)?0#( 1021/021?4G .P ?14 T4G0) 0(?14 7-AA4(? P4)AF M? *#T4 C#0(? )/T#*? )// #> ?14 T4G0) .42)( ?# A4C#A? #( ?14?#C07 #> ?14 $0//0(2 #> ?14 /0#( @470/F <10* *C)A$4G ) 6#A/G60G4 #-?A)24F

c)?14A S#/>1)-* 7#-(?4A4G 60?1 )(#?14A C0474 #> 0(>#AT)?0#( ?1)? *C)A$4G) T-71 *T)//4A 471# 0( ?14 T4G0)H ()T4/PH ?14 *7)(G)/ #> ?14 MT4A07)( ).#AY?0#( 7/0(07 (4?6#A$ ,/)((4G ,)A4(?1##GF D? ?-A(4G #-? ?1)? ) N#-A()/0*?07 CA#I#Y7)?0#( .A#-21? ?# /021? ?14 ?A)>>07$0(2 #> >#4?-*4* )(G ).#A?4G 710/GA4(+* #A2)(*F<14*4 #A2)(* 64A4 *#/G >#A m-0?4 /)A24 *-T*F

c)?14A S#/>1)-* )*$4G 1#6 ?10* 0* C#**0./4H 614A4 64 )A4H 614A4 #-A 7#(Y*704(74 0*H 614( $0//0(2 ) /0#( /4)G* ?# ) 2A4)?4A *?0A ?1)( ?14 ?A)G0(2 #> #A2)(* #>$0//4G 710/GA4(l <14( 14 ?A04G ?# )(*64A ?14 m-4*?0#( #> 61)? G02(0?P 0*H A4>4AYA0(2H #> 7#-A*4H ?# DTT)(-4/ S)(?F <10* 0* )( 0TC#A?)(? A4>4A4(74F D> P#- 6)(? ?#?)/$ ).#-? G02(0?P .P -*0(2 A4/020#-* /)(2-)24H S)(?0)( ?1#-21? 7#T4* ?# T0(G)(G 0? 0* 0TC4A)?0I4F R02(0?P 0* ?14 T#*? 0TC#A?)(? ?10(2 0( ) C4A*#( h 0TT4)*Y-A)./4H CA074/4**H )(G ) 2#)/ 0( 0?*4/>F D> ) C4A*#( 0* #(/P -*4G )* ) T4)(* .P#?14A C4#C/4H 14 #A *14 /#*4* G02(0?P h ?1)? 0* S)(?+* )(*64AF `4? -* $44C 0? 0(T0(GF

c)?14A S#/>1)-* )/*# A4>4AA4G ?# Q? <1#T)* Mm-0()*F Q? <1#T)* T)G4) G0*?0(7?0#( .4?644( G02(0?P )(G .4(4>0? h E64+6?#8 #+5 ,?6D6?#8F <14 *C4)$4A?A04G ?# *1#6 0? ?1A#-21 ?14 4i)TC/4 #> /).#-A )(G /).#-A 4iC/#0?)?0#(F 34 *1#64G1#6 G0>>07-/? 0? 0* *#T4?0T4* ?# G0*?0(2-0*1 614A4 64 )A4 *?0// G4)/0(2 60?1 A4Y*C47? ?# G02(0?PH )(G 614A4 ?14A4 0* )/A4)GP ) -?0/0?)A0)( -*4 #> C4#C/4F

{-4*?0#(* )A0*4H 4F2F 61)? 7#TC4(*)?0#( G# 64 A4740I4 614( 64 ?A4)? ) 1-YT)( >)0A/PH )(G 61)? 7#TC4(*)?0#( T4)(* 614( 64 *0TC/P 4iC/#0? 14AF Q#T4Y?0T4* 0? 0* G0>>07-/? ?# )(*64A ?14*4 m-4*?0#(*F <14 .)*0* #> G02(0?P h )77#AG0(2?# ?14 *C4)$4A h 0* 1-T)( ()?-A4F <10* 0* I4AP 0TC#A?)(? 0( @1A0*?0)( ?10($0(2F

;Z

<14 .)*0* #> G02(0?P 0* ()?-A4H (#? ?140A >4)?-A4* h ,A#>F M(GAO4N d#// A4>4AA4G ?#?10* 0( ?14 (4i? CA4*4(?)?0#(F M* ) /)6P4AH 14 *1#64G 61)? ?14 /42)/ 7#(*4m-4(74*)A4 #> ?14 ?6# 7#TC/4?4/P G0>>4A4(? )CCA#)714* )(G 61)? G0>>4A4(74* ?14P T)$40( ?14 CA#I0*0#(* #> ?14 7#(*?0?-?0#(* #> G0>>4A4(? 7#-(?A04*F <14 .)*0* #> G02(0?P0* ?14A4>#A4 ) 1-T)( .40(2F D( ?-A(H G02(0?P 0* ?14 >#-(G)?0#( #> 1-T)( A021?*F

c#A ?10* ?10AG 4/4T4(? #> #-A ?#C07H ?14 A4CA4*4(?)?0I4 #> ?14 Q47A4?)A0)? #>Q?)?4 *1#64G ?14 A0*$ #> >A)2T4(?)?0#(H *C4)$0(2 ).#-? 1-T)( A021?* )(G 4iYC/)0(0(2 1#6 G02(0?P CA#?47?* )2)0(*? >A)2T4(?)?0#(H .47)-*4 0(7A4)*0(2/P ?14A40* ?14 0**-4 #> >A)2T4(?4G A021?*H 6#T4(+* A021?*H 710/GA4(+* A021?* #A 2)P A021?*F<14 *C4)$4A 7/)0T4G ?1)? ?14P G# (#? 1)I4 *C470)/ A021?*H ?14A4 )A4 #(/P 1-T)(A021?*H .47)-*4 ?14A4 0* #(/P #(4 )(G ?14 *)T4 G02(0?PF "4 )// 1)I4 ?14 *)T4G02(0?Pj 0? 7)((#? .4 >A)2T4(?4GH 0? 0* (#? *#H ?1)? *#T4 2A#-C* 1)I4 ) G0>>4A4(?G02(0?P #A T#A4 G02(0?P ?1)( #?14A*F <10* 0* )( 4i)TC/4 #> 1#6 ?14 7#(74C? #>G02(0?P CA#?47?* -* >A#T ?14 ?A)C* #> *#T4 #> ?#G)P+* *#70#YC#/0?07)/ G0*7#-A*4F

<14 *47#(G ?14*0* ?1)? ?14 *C4)$4A ?A04G ?# *1#6H N-*?0>P )(G G4>4(GH 0* ?1)?G02(0?P T-*? .4 0()/04()./4F "1P G#4* ) C4A*#( 1)I4 G02(0?Pl S)(? 20I4* )()(*64AF M77#AG0(2 ?# 10TH G02(0?P .4/#(2* ?# ?1#*4 61# -*4 A4)*#(F M(G ?10* 0*) G)(24A#-* )(*64AH .47)-*4 0? 0TT4G0)?4/P A)0*4* ?14 m-4*?0#(H 61)? ).#-? ?14G02(0?P #> ?1#*4 61#H (#? #> ?140A >)-/?H G# (#? -*4 A4)*#(H 0F4F T4(?)//P 1)(G0Y7)CC4G C4#C/4l

S)A#/ "#N?P/) )/A4)GP (#?074G ?10* 0( 10* C10/#*#C107)/ )(G 4?107)/ ?4i?*H614( 14 4i)T0(4GH )T#(2 #?14A*H S)(?+* C10/#*#C1P )(G T)G4 A4>4AA)/* ?# 0?F<14(H #> 7#-A*4H )* ^#1( ,)-/ DD 14 )/*# *)0G ?1)? G02(0?P 7)((#? .4 *#/4/P G4YA0I4G >A#T ?14 .A)0(* #> *#T4 1-T)( 71)A)7?4A0*?07*H .-? 0? .4/#(2* ?# 1-T)(()?-A4F

"4 0TT4A*4 #-A*4/I4* 0( *4)A71 >#A ?14 *#-A74 #> ?14 /420?0T)7P #> G02(0?PT#A4 )(G T#A4H G44C4A )(G G44C4AH )(G Q? <1#T)* *1#6* -* ?14 6)PF M77#AGY0(2 ?# ?14 *C4)$4AH 1-T)(* )A4 7A4)?4G 0( 5#G+* 0T)24F Mm-0()* *)6 ?10* *0T0Y/)A0?P 0( 1-T)( A4)*#( )(G >A44 60//F K-? @1A0*?0)(0?P 20I4* ) G44C4A )(*64AF D?*)P* ?1)? T)( 6)* 7A4)?4G #-? #> /#I4F 34 0* (#? #(/P ?14 *-.N47? )(G ?14 A4*-/? #>?14 )7?0I0?P #> 5#GF <14 A4/)?0#(*10C .4?644( T)( )(G 5#G 0* ?14 A4/)?0#(*10C#> /#I4F M(G ?10* 0* ?14 G44C4*? >#-(G)?0#( *?A4(2?14(0(2 1-T)( G02(0?PH 61071)* 64 *)6 0* (44G4GH >#A 4i)TC/4 0( 4*?)./0*10(2 /)6F

<14 *C4)$4A (#?4G ?1)? ?14A4 0* *?0// 4I4AP?10(2 ?# .4 )G#C?4G .P (#(Y@1A0*Y?0)(*H ?1)? ?14A4 0* ) G02(0?PH ) A4>4A4(74 ?# ?14 ?A)(*74(G4(?H ?# 5#GH )(G >-A?14A?# 10* /#I4F c)?14A RA S#/>1)-* )A2-4G ?1)? ?10* 0* C#/0?07)//P )??A)7?0I4F

"4 @1A0*?0)(* *1#-/G .A0(2 ?10* C4A*C47?0I4 ?# C#/07Pj 64 *1#-/G (#? .4)>A)0GF M? ?14 4(G #> 10* *C4471 14 m-#?4G K4(4G07? xkDJ !"14A4 5#G 0* (#? 0(?14 >0A*? C/)74H ?14A4 64 A0*$ ?14 /#** #> G02(0?P+F <10* *4(?4(74 T)P *#-(G ) .0?

;\

/0$4 @1A0*?0)(0?P 6)(?* ?# 0TC#*4 0?* C4A*C47?0I4H .-? D ?10($ ?14 *C4471 N-*?0>04G?1)? ?10* 0* (#? ?14 C#0(?F

<10* 0* (#? ).#-? 0TC#*0(2 ) C4A*C47?0I4 ?1)?H >#A 4i)TC/4H 6#-/G 0(I#/I4?14 )-?1#A0?04*F "4 1)I4 ?14 ?A-?1 14A4 )(G 64 6)(? ?# *1#6 P#- ?1)? .47)-*4 #>0? 64 6)(? ?# 0(*?A-7? P#-F D?+* (#? ?14 0(?4(?0#(F

M>?4A ?10* *C4471 ?14A4 6)* ) I4AP 0(?4A4*?0(2 G0*7-**0#( 0( ?14 6#A$0(22A#-C*F <14 6#A$0(2 2A#-C #( G02(0?P 6)* /4G .P R#T0(0$) S#O/#6*$)H 4G0?#AY0(Y7104> #> Y+#$F Q14 C/)((4G *4I4A)/ ?#C07*H .-? #> 7#-A*4 (#? )// #> ?14T 7#-/G.4 6#A$4G #-?F "4 64A4 2#0(2 ?# ?)/$ ).#-? G02(0?P 0( *C470>07 )A4)*J C#/0?07)/H*#70)/H ?14 /).#-A T)A$4?H 1#6 ?10* G02(0?P 0* CA#?47?4G #A (#?H )* 64// )* ?14G02(0?P #> ?14 *?A)(24A h ?10* 0* ?14 T#*?Y7#(?4*?4G ?#C07F

<14 C)(4/ 0(7/-G4G ,A#>F <1#T)* KA#*4H ) 54AT)( C10/#*#C14A #> A4/020#()(G N#-A()/0*?H )(G M(() d).#A*$)H LR ,1RH ) C#/0?070)( >A#T Q/#I)$0) 61#1)* *C4(? T)(P P4)A* 0( ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(?F

,A#>F KA#*4 >0A*? 0(?A#G-74G ?14 ?#C07H *-224*?4G ) C10/#*#C107)/ #-?/##$H7#(G-7?4G ) C10/#*#C107)/ A4>/47?0#(H )(G )*$4GJ !"1)? G#4* 0? T4)( ?1)? G02(0Y?P 0* 0(I0#/)./4l+

D? 0* I0#/)./4H )>?4A )//F "4 *)P ?1)? G02(0?P 0* 0(I0#/)./4H 610/4 64 4iC4A0Y4(74 *#T4?10(2 G0>>4A4(? )A#-(G -*F D?+* 4(#-21 ?# ?-A( #( ?14 <kF D( 61)?*4(*4 0* 0? 0(I0#/)./4H )(G 0( 61)? *4(*4 0* 0? I0#/)./4l <14*4 )A4 ?6# G0>>4A4(?7)*4* #> !0*+F "14( 64 *)P ?1)? G02(0?P T-*? .4 G4>4(G4GH T-*? 4i0*?H 61)? G#64 1)I4 .4>#A4 #-A 4P4*l 34 A4>4AA4G ?# ?14 U46 <4*?)T4(? )(G ?# ?14 64//Y$(#6( 6#AG* #> Q? ,)-/ 0( =#T)(* 8J:[ ?1)? 64 #AG4A 0( #-A 14)A?*F B)71 C4AY*#( G0*7#I4A* ?10*F _> 7#-A*4H 64 )A4 ?)/$0(2 ).#-? 7#(*704(74F R02(0?P 0* )**#Y70)?4G 60?1 7#(*704(74F <10* /4)G* ?# ?14 m-4*?0#(J "1# 0* ) T)(l M(G 14A4)2)0( ?14A4 6)* ) A4>4A4(74 ?# S)(?H .47)-*4 S)(? *# *?A#(2/P *?A4**4G ?10* m-4*Y?0#( )* ?14 T#*? 0TC#A?)(?H #> 61# T)( 0*F @1A0*?0)(0?P 20I4* ?14 )(*64AH 610710* 71)A)7?4A0O4G .P ) 74A?)0( (#I4/?PF MT#(2 #?14A*H Q? ,)-/ *C4)$* #> ?14 (46T)(F <14 *)7A0>074 #> @1A0*? )(G 30* A4*-AA47?0#( T4)(* ?1)? ?1#*4 61# >#//#6@1A0*?H 61# 2# ?1A#-21 61)? @1A0*? 64(? ?1A#-21 0( .)C?0*TH ?14P .47#T4 (46C4#C/4F

D?+* ) $0(G #> ) (#I4/?PF "1)? G#4* 0? T4)(l "4 1)I4 )( 0T)24 0( #-A*4/I4*H^4*-*+ 0T)24 #> ) T)( h ?14A4 6)* ) A4>4A4(74 ?# ^#1( ,)-/ DD )(G 10* C:G%"-#+5 Z5:+?6?-F D( ?10* .##$H ^#1( ,)-/ DD *)0G ?1)? 0? 6)* ?10* 0T)24 ?1)? .47)T4 0(M-*7160?O ?14 *#-A74 #> *C0A0?-)/ *4/>YG4>4(74F

M(() d).#A*$) *)0G *14 6)(?4G ?# A4>4A ?# ?14 4I4APG)P /0I4* #> Q/#I)$6#T4(H .-? *14 .42)( 60?1 ) m-#?4 >A#T ?14 4T0(4(? 54AT)( 7#(*?0?-?0#()/0*?HBA(*?Y"#/>2)(2 Ka7$4(>aAG4H 61# 6A#?4 ?1)? ?14 /0.4A)/ *?)?4 7)((#? CA#I0G4.P 0?*4/> ) >#-(G)?0#(H )(G ?1)? ?14 >#-(G)?0#( (44G* ?# .4 >#-(G 4/*4614A4F c#A4i)TC/4H ) (474**)AP 7#TC/4T4(? #> ?14 *?A-7?-A4* #> *?)?4 0(*?0?-?0#(* 0* *#70)/

;[

7)C0?)/H 61071 0* T-?-)/ ?A-*?H *-CC#A? )(G 14/CF <10* 0(G07)?4* ?14 G0A47?0#( #>*44$0(2 G02(0?PH .47)-*4 T-?-)/ ?A-*? 0* .)*4G #( G02(0?PF <14 ,)A/0)T4(?)A0)(*)0G ?1)? *#T4 )A4 ?AP0(2 ?# N-*? /##$ 60?1#-? 5#G )? ?14 *#70)/ *?A-7?-A4* .4YP#(G ?14 A4/020#-* I046 )(G ?14( ?14P /##$ >#A 7#(*4(*-*F K-? ?10* 7#(*4(*-* 0*I4AP >A)20/4H .47)-*4 0? 7)( .4 /0$4 ?10* ?#G)PH )(G G0>>4A4(? ?#T#AA#6F M( 4i)TYC/4 6)* 20I4( #> ?14 0(?A#G-7?0#( #> 4-?1)()*0) 0( K4/20-TF <14A4>#A4H LA*d).#A*$) C#*?-/)?4G ?1)? -(0I4A*)/ @1A0*?0)( I)/-4* *1#-/G .4 A4G0*7#I4A4GF

c)?14A RA S)O0T04AO ,)C70)$ h /47?-A4A )? ?14 ,#(?0>07)/ c)7-/?P #> <14#/#Y2P 0( "A#7/)6 h *1)A4G 10* 4iC4A04(74 0( 61071 )* ) -(0I4A*0?P /47?-A4A 14 1)*.44( ?AP0(2 ?# G4>0(4 G02(0?P .4P#(G ?14 A4/020#-* 2A#-(G >#A *4I4A)/ P4)A*F

30* ?4*?0T#(P )* ) C10/#*#C14A 6)* 4I4( *?A#(24A 614( 14 )GT0??4G ?1)? 14>)0/4G )(G ?1)? A4/020#( 0* (474**)AP >#A ?10*H )(G ?1)? 64 *1#-/G A4(46 A4/020#-*?10($0(2F <10* 0* )/*# ) A4>/47?0#( #( B-A#C4 ?# A4?-A( ?# ?14 A##?* #> A4/020#(F,A#>F <1#T)* KA#*4 A4>4AA4G ?# ?10* )(G (#?4G ?1)? @1A0*?0)(0?P )7?-)//P /04* *#T-71 0( #-A ?10($0(2 ?1)? 0? 0* G0>>07-/? ?# *4C)A)?4 >A#T ?10* A##?H >#A 4i)TC/4H?14 A4*C#(*0.0/0?P >#A ?14 64)$ )(G ?14 G4*0A4 ?# G4>4(G ?14 64)$H 61071 0* *0TYC/P ?14 @1A0*?0)( 6)PF

34 *C#$4 ).#-? ?14 *0?-)?0#( 0( 54AT)(PF 34 /0I4* 0( K4A/0(H 61071 0* #(/P[| @)?1#/07F 89| #> K4A/0(4A* )A4 ,A#?4*?)(? )(G :9| )A4 L-*/0T*F <14 A4*?)A4 )7?-)//P C4#C/4 61# )A4 A4/020#-*/P 0(G0>>4A4(?F 3#6 G# P#- 2# .)7$ ?# @1A0*Y?0)( A##?* 0( *-71 ) *#70)/ *0?-)?0#(l 34 70?4GH )/?1#-21 14 G0G (#? T4(?0#( )*?14 *#-A74H ?14 BC0*?/4 ?# R0#2(4?-*F

D?+* )( )(#(PT#-*H T)2(0>074(? T#(-T4(? #> 4)A/P @1A0*?0)(0?PH 61071 1)*?14 >)T#-* *?)?4T4(? ?1)? @1A0*?0)(* )A4 ?# ?14 6#A/G 61)? ?14 *#-/ 0* ?# ?14.#GPF

D( *-71 ) *0?-)?0#(H 614( 64 )A4 0( ?14 T0(#A0?PH 64 *1#-/G ?AP ?# .4 ?14 *#-/>#A ?14 .#GPF K4 ?14 *)/?j #> 7#-A*4H 0? 0* 4I)(24/07)/H (#? ?14 *)/? T0(4H 0( 6107164 6#-/G 6)(? ?# 4(7/#*4 4I4AP#(4F <14 LB, M(() d.#A#6*$) )/*# C#0(?4G#-? >0AT/P ?1)? A4/020#-* >)T0/04* )A4 T#A4 *?)./4H *# ?1)? ?14 A4>4A4(74 ?# A4/0Y20#( 0* 0TC#A?)(? 0( *#70)/ A4/)?0#(*F

Q1#-/G @1A0*?0)( I)/-4* .4 CA4*4(?4G )* ) /42)7P #> A4)*#( 61071 0* ?14 B(Y/021?4(T4(? ?A)G0?0#(H #A )* ?14 #A020()/ 7#(?A0.-?0#( #> @1A0*?0)(0?Pl <14A4 >#/Y/#64G m-4*?0#(*H I#074* >A#T ?14 >/##AF ,A#>F S)O0T04AO S&#*0}*$0 >A#T Sf`o@)?1#/07 f(0I4A*0?P #> `-./0(p CA#C#*4G ?# 4(?4A 0(?# ) T#A4 C/-A)/0*?07 C4AY*C47?0I4H *1#60(2 ?1)? ?14 G0*)*?4A* #> ?14 89?1 74(?-AP A4*-/?4G >A#T ?14 >)7??1)? B-A#C4)(* 6#-/G (#? /4? #?14A* )7? 0( )77#AG)(74 60?1 ?140A I)/-4 *P*?4T*FK0*1#C ,04A#(4$ #.N47?4G ?# ?10* #C0(0#(H A47)//0(2 ?1)? 4I4AP @1A0*?0)( 0* *?0//7)//4G ?# CA#I0G4 ?4*?0T#(P ).#-? 10* >)0?1F

;;

c)?14A RA ,)C70)$ A4T0(G4G -* ?1)? CA4I0#-*/P *#70)/ A4/)?0#(* 64A4 >#-(GY4G #( ()?-A)/ /)6F <#G)PH 0? 0* A4N47?4GF D> (#? ()?-A)/ /)6H ?14( P#- (44G ?#CA#C#*4 ) (46 T4?)C1P*07*F

D 7#(*0G4A4G ?10* I#074 )* ) *-224*?0#( ?1)? 0? 6#-/G (#? 6#A$H .47)-*4 ?14()?-A)/ /)6 0* ?## 7#(>-*0(2 ?# .4 A47#2(0O)./4 CA470*4/P .P )//F D? 0* ?14 I4AP0((4A I#074 ?1)? Q? ,)-/ ?)/$4G ).#-? 0( ?14 `4??4A ?# ?14 =#T)(*F D( 7#(?A)*?H614( 64 ?AP ?# 7/)A0>P 0?H 4I4AP#(4 *)P* *#T4?10(2 */021?/P G0>>4A4(?j 4I4AP#(414)A* *#T4?10(2 G0>>4A4(?F M(G 14A4 64 1)I4 ) CA#./4T 60?1 ?14 ()?-A)/ /)6H.-? ?10* 0* TP 7#TT4(?F

c)?14A ,A#>F <1#T)* 3#T)H ) ^4*-0? >A#T ?14 D2()?0)(-T ^4*-0? f(0I4A*0?P#> ,10/#*#C1P )(G BG-7)?0#(H *C#$4 ).#-? 0? )* 64//F 34 *1#64G ?1)? -(0I4A*)/Y0?P G#4* (#? ?A)(*/)?4 0(?# )774C?).0/0?PH ?1)? 0? 0* (#? *# *0TC/4F "4 G4/-G4 #-AY*4/I4* 60?1 ) @1A0*?0)( I0*0#( #> B-A#C4 )* ) C)A)G0*4 /#*?F <14A4 0* (# A4?-A( ?#?10* C)A)G0*4j 64 T-*? 2# >#A6)AG 60?1 (46 0G4)*F

`4? T4 T)$4 ) *T)// 7#TT4(? ).#-? 61)? D 7#(*0G4A T0**0(2F U)T4/PH 0(YG44G ?14A4 64A4 I#074* ?1)? 64 64A4 /##$0(2 >#A N-*?0>07)?0#( >#A @1A0*?0)(0?PH>A#T ?14 /4I4/ #> G02(0?P 2#0(2 -CF R-A0(2 #(4 7#TT4(?H ) C07?-A4 >A#T ?145#*C4/ 64 )// $(#6 7)T4 ?# TP T0(GF <10* 0* ?14 *?#AP #> ?14 5##G Q)T)A0?)(F^4*-* 20I4* ?14 )(*64A ?14A4 #> 61)? 1-T)( G02(0?P 0*J ?10* 0* ?14 A4/)?0#( #>(4021.#-A ?# (4021.#-AF "1# 0* ) (4021.#-Al ,/4)*4 (#?4 ?1)? 0( ?10* C)A)./4) `4I0?4 )CC4)A*H ) A4/020#-* T)(H A4CA4*4(?0(2 ?14 0(*?0?-?0#(F 34 C)**4* .P )(G^4*-* C4AI4A*4/P *1#6* ?1)? ) Q)T)A0?)(H 61# 0* ) 14A4?07H *#T4#(4 G4*C0*4G #(A4/020#-* )(G 4?1(07 2A#-(G*H ?-A(* #-? ?# .4 ?14 (4021.#-A 61# A47#2(0O4G ?14G02(0?P 0( ?14 T)( 61# 0* -(7#(*70#-*H .4)?4( )(G /P0(2 #( ?14 *0G4Y/0(4*F BI4YAP#(4 1)* ?14 -A24 ?# /4)I4F <10* 0* *#T4 $0(G #> ?A)(*2A4**0#(F K-? ^4*-* *1#6*?14 .#??#TY-C 6)PF D A4>/47? ?1)? P#- 7)( 24? ?# ?10* G02(0?P !>A#T ?14 .#??#T-C+Fq<10* T4)(* ?1)? G02(0?P >0A*? )CC4)A* 0( ?14 7/#*4*? 70A7/4H 0( ?14 >)T0/P70A7/4F "4 *)PH !3#(#-A P#-A >)?14A )(G P#-A T#?14A+F 34A4H >0A*?H ?14 A4/)?0#( #>G02(0?P 7#T4* )(G ?14A4 0* (# CA#./4T 60?1 0?F <10* 0* ?14 4iC4A04(74 #> )//7-/?-A4*F "1)? 0* ?14 #A020()/0?P #> ^4*-*+ 6)Pl _( 7A#**0(2 ?10* 4iC4A04(74FL#A)/ G4I4/#CT4(? T-*? 7A#** )(G A4/)?4 ?10* G02(0?PH 61071 0* 4iC4A04(74G *#I0I0G/P 0( ?14 70A7/4 #> >A04(G* )(G /#I4G #(4*H )* ?14A4 0* (# CA#./4T 0( ?14C4A74C?0#( #> ?140A G02(0?PF "4 *1#-/G *44 0? 0( .A#)G4AH /)A24A 70A7/4*H .47)-*4?10* 0* 61)? ?14 G4I4/#CT4(? )(G 2A#6?1 #> 4?107* 0* ).#-?F

<10* C4A*C47?0I4 6)* T0**0(2 ) /0??/4 .0? >#A T4F L)P.4 ?14A4 60// .4 )(#CC#A?-(0?P 0( ?14 >-?-A4 ?# 7#T4 .)7$ ?# 0?F

;W

P+0;'& L*;*&/81* )&*9/

=-@@*&8 '( ;:, E&'-" ,1;0;6,+Q

2344-56� The Limits of Freedom

or Freedom Without Borders

?:09: ?*. *;;,1+,+ 78Q

D'+,&*;'&Q9:&;$" 78&<'&5- =$.$-.(&7 4316$<$8+ )* +", Q3#%+,%6C %&'( RH)'@S

PR",&;.Q/"$01 >"5') ?&@$-&A+7 *)%&,% -&13@8&#'7 !#%@$'#6 E+,*#' OC8/C'8>$ L'$I,%8$+C/"$01 B)%&" *3)C&C B)%&" BD7 I$<,M%,<+)% )* +", 5)'+$*$<#6 -%$,'+#6 T'8+$+3+, $' D)&,

D 6)* )>A)0G ?1)? 614( ?)/$0(2 ).#-? >A44G#TH G02(0?P )(G 1-T)( A021?* 646#-/G 24? *?-7$ 7/)A0>P0(2 24(4A)/ 7/)-*4*H ?1)? 64 6#-/G .4 G4)/0(2 60?1 G4>0(Y0(2 7#(74C?* ?1)? )A4 G0>>07-/? ?# G4>0(4 )(G 7#TC/4?4/P 02(#A4 ?14 CA)7?07)/ )*YC47?H ?1)? >#A 4i)TC/4 ?14 I#074* ).#-? ).#A?0#(H 4-?1)()*0) )(G 1-T)( A021?* h61071 0(G44G *1#-/G .4 7#(*0G4A4G h 6#-/G .4 7#TC/4?4/P G0*A42)AG4GF

<14 G0*7-**0#( ).#-? >A44G#T *-ACA0*4G T4 0( ) I4AP C#*0?0I4 6)PH .47)-*40? G0*C4//4G )// #> ?14*4 >4)A*F "1Pl c0A*? #> )//H ?14 T#G4A)?#A* #> ?10* G0*7-*Y*0#( od.02(046 U#*#6*$0H ,A#>F DA4() ̀ 0C#607O )(G ,A#>F cA Q)T0A S1)/0/ Q)T0ApCA4*4(?4G ) *?0AA0(2 0G4) ?1)? $4C? C4#C/4 )? ?14 4G24 #> ?140A *4)?* ).#-? ?14)>>)0A #> )-?1#A0?P 60?1 A4/020#(F M(G ?10* 6)* >A#T ,#/0*1H 54AT)(H @1A0*?0)()(G B-A#C4)( C4A*C47?0I4*H )(GH 61071 0* I4AP 0TC#A?)(?H >A#T ?14 C4A*C47?0I4#> D*/)TF

,)A)G#i07)//PH ?14 G0*7-**0#( ).#-? >A44G#TH ).#-? 0?* .#AG4A*H A4G-74G 0?Y*4/> ?# ?14 0**-4 #> >A44G#T #> A4/020#( )(G ?14 A4/)?0#( #> A4/020#( ?# ?14 *?)?4)(G I074 I4A*)F M? ?14 I4AP .420((0(2H ,A#>F `0C#607O CA4*4(?4G -* 60?1 ?6#?PC4* #> ?1A4)?* ?1)? 7#T4 >A#T ?## 7/#*4 A4/)?0#(* #> )-?1#A0?P 60?1 A4/020#(F<10* 7)( 1)CC4( 614( ?14 A4/020#( 0* I4AP *?A#(2F D( *-71 7)*4*H ?14 2#I4A(T4(?1)* ) ?4(G4(7P ?# G4/42)?4 0?* A4*C#(*0.0/0?04* ?# ) A4/020#-* )**#70)?0#(F K-? 0?

;X

7)( )/*# .4 ?14 #CC#*0?4 h ?14 )-?1#A0?04* T)P .4 ?4TC?4G ?# *-CC#A? ) 64)$A4/020#( )(G 1)I4 0? G# 0?* N#.F

c)?14A ,A#>F Q)T0A *1#64G )( 4m-)//P CA#Y*?)?4 )CCA#)71H *)P0(2 ?1)? 614(64 )774C? A4>-244*H 0TT02A)(?* )(G C4#C/4 >A#T ?14 #-?*0G4H 64 (44G ?# A4m-0A4>A#T ?14T ?14 )774C?)(74 #> #-A 7#(G0?0#(*H #-A A-/4* )(G ) A4*C47? >#A #-A I)/Y-4*F "4 T-*? .4 T4A70>-/H 0( *#/0G)A0?PH .-? )/*# A02#A#-*H 0( #AG4A ?# *1#6 ?1)?64 A4*C47? #-A #6( B-A#C4)( I)/-4*F K-? 61)? (44G* ?# .4 (#?4GH c)?14A Q)T0A*1#64G ) 7#TC/4?4/P G0>>4A4(? -(G4A*?)(G0(2 #> >A44G#TH G0>>4A4(? >A#T #-AB-A#C4)( 0G4)F

"4 )A4 >#7-*0(2 0( CA0(70C/4 #( >A44G#T !>A#T+ ?10* (42)?0I4 >A44G#TF <14CA#>4**#A *1#64G ?14 C#*0?0I4 )*C47? #> >A44G#TF U#6H 64 )A4 >A44 ?# /#I4 #-A(4021.#-AH ?# 7)A4 >#A 10TH ?# 14/CH ?# *1#6 *#/0G)A0?PH >A)?4A(0?P )(G 71)A0?PF"1)? 0* 0(?4A4*?0(2 )(G ) /0??/4 G0>>4A4(? >A#T 61)? P#- 14)A 0( ,#/)(G 0() G0*7-**0#( ).#-? A4>-244*H ,A#>F Q)T0A *)0G ?1)? ?14 7#(74A( ).#-? ?4AA#A0*T*1#-/G .4 /4>? ?# *C470)/ *4AI074*H /4>? ?# ?14 *?)?4F <1)? 0* ?140A A#/4F _-A A#/4 )*@1A0*?0)(* 0* ?# 14/C C4#C/4 )(G 64 *1#-/G >#7-* #( ?10*F

,)A?070C)(?* 0( ?14 G0*7-**0#( G-A0(2 ?14 G)P P4*?4AG)P )2A44G #( ?14 >)7??1)? 64 *1#-/G G4>0(0?4/P ?)$4 ?14 A4>-244*H )// ?1#*4 61# $(#7$ #( #-A G##AH61# 7)T4 ?# B-A#C4F

"4 7)((#? /4)I4 60?1#-? 14/C0(2 C4#C/4 61# 40?14A /#*? 4I4AP?10(2 #A 1)I4(#?10(2F K-? ?14A4 64A4 *?)?4T4(?*H )T#(2 #?14A*H .P dGO0*/)6 K04/47$0 >A#T?14 R_L c#-(G)?0#( #(74 0(I#/I4G 0( 14/C0(2 A4>-244* >A#T @1471(P)H ?1)?64 1)I4 ?# 14/C 60*4/PF "1)? 0* ?14 60*4 6)P ?# 14/Cl <# )I#0G 214??#0O)?0#(H61071 0* 61)? "4*?4A( 7#-(?A04* )A4 *?A-22/0(2 60?1 0( ?14 7#(?4i? #> 0TT02A)Y?0#(F M/*#H ) I4AP 0TC#A?)(? )A2-T4(? 6)* T)G4 .P ,A#>F `0C#607O *)P0(2 ?1)?#-A "4*?4A( 4i7-*4* ?1)? 64 7)((#? )>>#AG ?# )774C? ?14 A4>-244* )A4 ) /0??/4 .0?T)(0C-/)?0I4F <14 CA#>4**#A 2)I4 `4.)(#( )* )( 4i)TC/4H 614A4 X9| #> ?14C#C-/)?0#( )A4 A4*0G4(?*H )(G ?14 A4T)0(0(2 89| )A4 )GT0??4G A4>-244*F <14`4.)(4*4 7)( )>>#AG 0?H 4I4( ?1#-21 ?14P )A4 *?A-22/0(2 60?1 ) 1#AA0./4 GA#-21?H)/?1#-21 ?14A4 0* ) /)7$ #> 6)?4A ?14A4H )(G 64 B-A#C4)(* 6#-/G (#? .4 )./4 ?#)>>#AG 14/Cl

M(#?14A ?#C07 ?1)? 6)* CA4*4(?4G P4*?4AG)P G-A0(2 I0A?-)//P ?14 61#/4 G)P 0*61)? ,A#>F K-??02/0#(4 *C#$4 ).#-?J 0(?4//024(?H 60*4 *-CC#A? )(G )**0*?)(74 0(*-71 ) 6)P ?1)? >0A*? 64 >-/>0/ #-A G-?P ?#6)AG* ?1#*4 61# (44G #-A 14/CH ?14(64 7#(*0G4A ?14 /#(24A )(G .A#)G4A C4A*C47?0I4 #( ?14 G4*02( #> ) (46 )7?0I4C#/07P ?#6)AG* ?14 L4G0?4AA)(4)(H .47)-*4 )* dGO0*/)6 K04/47$0 (#?4G M>A07) 0*0( ?-AT#0/j ?1)? ?10* *0?-)?0#( 61071 64 )A4 (#6 *440(2 T)P (#? .4 ?14 4(GH-(/4** 64 G4*02( ) ?A-/P 60*4H A4)*#()./4 )(G /#(2Y?4AT C#/07P ?#6)AG* ?14 A4Y20#(* 614A4 64 1)I4 G#(4 ) /#? #> 1)ATF

;V

e#- 1)I4 ?# )GT0? ?1)? 61)? D )T ?)/$0(2 ).#-? 1)* /0??/4 0( 7#TT#( )? >0A*?2/)(74 60?1 >A44G#TH 60?1 ?14 6)P ?14 G0*7-**0#( 6)* 4(?0?/4GJ !<14 `0T0?* #>cA44G#T h cA44G#T "0?1#-? `0T0?*F+ 3#64I4AH ?14 C)A?070C)(?* #> ?14 G0*7-*Y*0#( *)0G ?1)? >A44G#T T-*? 1)I4 /0T0?*H .-? ?14P )A4 (44G4G *# ?1)? 64 7)( )*) *#704?PH )* 70?0O4(*H N#0(?/P )(G 1)AT#(0#-*/P 4i0*?F <10* 0* 61P 64 (44G /0TY0?* ?# >A44G#TH )(G ?14*4 /0T0?* )A4 )/*# (44G4G *# ?1)? 64 *1#-/G A4m-0A4 7#TYC/0)(74 >A#T ?1#*4 61# 7#T4 ?# -*F

c#A G4**4A?H D /4>? ?14 T#*? 0(?4A4*?0(2 ?10(2 64 ?)/$4G ).#-? P4*?4AG)P 0( ?147#(?4i? #> >A44G#TF <10* 6)* ?14 .4*? /4**#( #>H /4?+* 7)// 0? !C#/0?07)/ D*/)T+H?1)? D C4A*#()//P 14)AG )* ) >#AT4A 0(?4A()?0#()/ A4/)?0#(* *?-G4(?F "1)? 0* 0?).#-?l U)T4/PH 0? 6)* 0(0?0)?4G .P ̂ )74$ "#~(0)$#6*$0H 61# )*$4G c)?14A ,A#>FQ)T0A 614?14A ?14 {-A)( #A ?14 MA). 7#-(?A04*+ ?A)G0?0#(* 0( 24(4A)/ C4AT0? #A)//#6 ?14 )G#C?0#( #> ?14 0G4) #> ) *47-/)A *?)?4 )(G $(#6 *-71 ) ?10(2 )* ?147#(74C? #> 70?0O4(*10CF <14 c)?14A 6)* ?A#-./4G 14A4H )(G *)0G 0? 0* ) I4APG0>>07-/? *-.N47? >#A ?10* A4)*#( .47)-*4 ?A)G0?0#()//P ?14 {-A)(H 0( ?14 D*/)T07?A)G0?0#(H G0I0G4* C4#C/4 0(?# ?1A44 7)?42#A04*F <14 >0A*? #(4 0* .4/04I4A*H >#/Y/#64A* #> D*/)T h ?10* 0* ?14 7#TT-(0?P #> .4/04I4A* h ?14 #?14A #(4 0* .)A.)AY0)(* h (#(Y.4/04I4A* o64+// ?)/$ ).#-? .)A.)A0)(* 0( ) T#T4(?p 61# *1#-/G .47#(I4A?4GH )(G ?14 ?10AG #(4 )A4 0TC4A>47? .4/04I4A* #A >#//#64A* #> )// #?14AA4/020#(* #> ?14 K##$j T#(#?140*?07 A4/020#(*H ()T4/P @1A0*?0)(* )(G ^46*F<14 )CCA#)71 #> L-*/0T* ?# 0TC4A>47? .4/04I4A* )/*# /4)I4* T-71 ?# .4 G4*0A4GH.47)-*4 0? 0* .)*4G #( ?#/4A)(74H .-? -(G4A*?##G 0( ) I4AP C47-/0)A 6)PF c)?14AQ)T0A G4*7A0.4G 0? )* ) (474**0?P ?# C)P )( )((-)/ >44 )(G ?14 (474**0?P #> .40(21-T0/0)?4GF

<14 c)?14A )/*# .A#-21? -C )( )()/#2P ?# ?14 ?A)G0?0#( 0( M(704(? 5A4474614A4 ?14A4 6)* ) *#70)/ G0I0*0#( ?# ?14 70?0O4(*H ?# ?14 .)A.)A0)(*H 60?1 61#T?14P >#-21?H )(G ?14 T4?07*H #A #?14A*H 61# 64A4 *?A)(24A*H .-? 61# 64A4 ?#/4AY)?4GF 34A4H 1#64I4AH 6)* ) I4AP 0TC#A?)(? .#-(G)AP .4?644( 61)? 0* ?14 ?A)G0Y?0#()/ D*/)T07 T4)(0(2 )(G ?14 5A44$ G0I0*0#(*F L-*/0T* G# (#? A47#2(0O4 ?147#(74C? #> ) 70?0O4(t M* 0? 6)* CA4*4(?4G .P ?14 CA#>4**#AH 0? 7)((#? .4 0(?4ACA4?Y4G >A#T ?14 {-A)(H >A#T ?14 Q-(()1 )(G >A#T ?14 4(?0A4 ?A)G0?0#(F <10* ?A)G0Y?0#()/ D*/)T07 -(G4A*?)(G0(2 A-/4* #-? *#T4?10(2 ?1)? >#A -* 0( ?14 "4*?H >#A -*7#T0(2 >A#T @1A0*?0)( 7-/?-A4H *44T* ?# .4 #.I0#-*F "14A4 G#4* ?10* /4)G 0(Y*0G4 ?14 D*/)T07 7#TT-(0?Pl MT#(2 #?14A ?10(2*H ?# ?14 >)7? ?1)? ?14 7#(I4A?**1#-/G .4 1)(G/4G *# A)G07)//PF <14P )A4 I4AP #>?4( ?1A4)?4(4G 60?1 G4)?1H 0> (#?.P ) N-G2T4(? #> ?14 7#-A?H ?14( )? ?14 1)(G* #> ?140A #6( >)T0/PF D? A4T0(G4GT4H D )GT0?H #> ?14 )CCA#)71 #> )(P CA4Y*?)?4 7#TT-(0?P ?# C-(0*10(2 )(P )C#*Y?)?4* #A 7A0T0()/* 61# I0#/)?4G ?14 #AG4A #> ?14 7#TT-(0?P .P 0(?A#G-70(2 71)Y#*F "1)? 64A4 ?14P *-CC#*4G ?# G# 60?1 *#T4#(4 /0$4 ?1)?l D? 6)* (474**)AP ?#

W9

A4T#I4 ?14T >A#T ?14 7#TT-(0?PF <10* *#-(G* ?14 *)T4 )* 0( ?A)G0?0#()//PY-(G4A*?##G D*/)TF

,A#>F Q)T0A )GT0??4G ?1)? ?14 D*/)T07 A4()0**)(74H G-4 ?# ?14 >)7? ?1)? ) .A44O4#> B-A#C4)( 7-/?-A4 6)* 0(?A#G-74GH ?##$ C/)74 0( ?14 >0A*? 1)/> #> ?14 :V?1 74(Y?-APF M( B2PC?0)( 0T)T ?A)(*/)?4G ?14 ?4i?* #> k#/?)0A4 )(G =#-**4)-F <10*/)i0?P )(G #C4(YT0(G4G(4** /)*?4G N-*? ) /0??/4 /#(24A ?1)( ) 74(?-APH .47)-*4)/A4)GP 0( ?14 T0GY89?1 74(?-AP 0? ?-A(4G #-? ?1)? 10*?#AP 0* (#? /0(4)A h 0? 0*) *0(-*#0GH )(G D*/)T )/*# 70A7/4G .)7$ )A#-(G )* ) A4*-/? #> ?14 A)G07)/ Q)/)>0T#I4T4(?F <14 c)?14A I4AP 0//-*?A)?0I4/P G4*7A0.4G 1#6 ?14*4 T#I4T4(?* #CY4A)?4F "0?1 ) G4*0A4 )(G /#(20(2 >#A 0?* >#AT4A 2A)(G4-AH 61071 ?##$ C/)74 0( ?14*4I4(?1 74(?-AP MR )(G ) /0??/4 /)?4AH ?14P G470G4G ?# ?)$4 ) *1#A?7-? h ()T4/PH.P *?)?0(2 ?1)? 0> P#- ?A4)? P#-A*4/I4* ?# ) A4?-A( ?# ?1)? C)*?H 64 60// ?A4)? #-AY*4/I4* ?# ) A4?-A( ?# 2/#APF K-? (#?10(2 /0$4 ?1)? 1)CC4(4GH .47)-*4 0? 6)* )()??4TC? ?# ?A)(*C/)(? ?14 7-*?#T* )(G 7-/?-A4 #> ?14 G4*4A? 0( ?14 *4I4(?1 74(?-YAP MR ?# 89?1 )(G 8:*? 74(?-AP A4)/0?PF 34(74 6#T4(+* 7/#?10(2 7#I4A0(2 ?144(?0A4 .#GPF <14 c)?14A *?A#(2/P 7A0?070O4G ?10* )CCA#)71H *)P0(2 ?1)? 0? /4G ?#7#TC/4?4 .)7$6)AG(4** )(G )/*# ?# ?14 >#AT)?0#( #> T)0(/P A)G07)/ T#I4T4(?*?1)? I4AP /0?4A)//P -(G4A*?)(G ?14 {-A)( )(G ?14 A4/020#-* CA474C?* #> D*/)TF 34CA4*4(?4G )( 4i)TC/4 #> 0T)T* 61# 1)I4 .44( -*0(2 e#-<-.4 ?# CA#T0*4 ?14A)G07)/0O4G >)0?1>-/ W8 I0A20(* )>?4A ?140A T)A?PAG#TF K-? ?14 CA#>4**#A *)0GJ61P 6#-/G D 6)(? I0A20(*H *0(74 )>?4A G4)?1H D 60// (#? 1)I4 ) .#GPl 34 0//-*?A)?Y4G 0( ?10* C4AI4A*4 6)P 1#6 0(?4ACA4?0(2 ?14 *)7A4G ?4i?* /0?4A)//P /4)G* (#614A4H?# ?14 A4N47?0#( #> T4?)C1#AH 61071 0*H 1#64I4AH (474**)AP ?# -(G4A*?)(G ?14?A)G0?0#(* #> D*/)TF

<10* 0(?A#G-7?0#( ?# 1#6 D*/)T /##$* ?#G)P )(G 1#6 64 B-A#C4)(* *#T4Y61)? *4/47?0I4/P C4A740I4 0? 0( >)7? 2)I4 A4)*#(* ?# .4 ?A#-./4G ?1)? ?10* 0* (#? ?146)PF D*/)T /0*?4(4G ?# ?14 .)G *14C14AG*H #A 0? /0*?4(4G ?# ?14 *14C14AG* 61#.A#-21? A4/020#( )*?A)PF ,A#>F `0C#607O A4>4AA4G ?# ?14*4 I4AP A)G07)/ T#I4YT4(?* .P *)P0(2 ?1)? 64 0( B-A#C4 G# (#? A4)//P A4)/0O4 N-*? 1#6 >)A ?14P )?Y?4TC? ?# A47A-0? L-*/0T* /0I0(2 0( B-A#C4 #( ?14 C)?1 #> Q)/)>0 N01)GF Q14 2)I4)* )( 4i)TC/4 ) -(0I4A*0?P 0( M/.)(0) ?1)? 6)* 7A4)?4G N-*? ?# 24? Q)/)>0 T#(4PF

<14 G0*7-**0#( 61#*4 C-AC#*4 6)* ?# ?)/$ ).#-? >A44G#T 4(G4G -C 60?1) I4AP *)G )*74A?)0(T4(?H 61071 7)T4 >A#T ?14 T#-?1 #> DA4() `0C#607OJ 641)I4 7#TC/4?4/P >)0/4G 614( 0? 7#T4* ?# A4/020#-* G0)/#2-4F <1)?+* >0A*?F Q47Y#(G/PH ?14 6)A #( ?4AA#A0*T 64 1)I4 *44( #I4A ?14 P4)A* 6)* (#?10(2 #?14A ?1)()( )??4TC? #(/P ?# 7#T.)? ?14 *PTC?#T* #> ?14 CA#74**4*F

<14 CA#>4**#A (#?4G ?1)? N-*? )* .4>#A4 "#A/G ")A D #A .4>#A4 ?14 =-**0)(=4I#/-?0#(H ?4AA#A0*T 0* )/6)P* ) T)(0>4*?)?0#(H ) CA4*)24 #> T-71 /)A24A GA)YT)*F Q14 6)A(4G -* ?1)? 64 (44G ?# CA4C)A4 #-A*4/I4* >#A *#T4?10(2 /0$4 ?10*H610/4 )**-T0(2 ?1)? ?1#*4 A4>-244* 61# 7#T4 ?# -*H 61# )A4 >#//#64A* #> D*/)TH

W:

7)( 14/C -* 0( >#AT0(2 )( #CC#*0?0#( ?# ?14 T#*? A)G07)/ T#I4T4(?*H .47)-*4?14P )A4H )>?4A )//H C4#C/4 61# )A4 >/440(2 ?14 A)G07)/0*T ?1)? 7#(G#(4* ?A)G0(2:9YP4)AY#/G *4i */)I4* #A 4i47-?0(2 @1A0*?0)(* #( ?4/4I0*0#(F

<10* 0* 1#6 ?14 G0*7-**0#( #( >A44G#T )(G ?14 /0T0?* #> >A44G#TH )* 64// )*>A44G#T 60?1#-? /0T0?*H 4(G4G 0( ) *#T461)? *-ACA0*0(2 6)P h .-? T-71 T#A4(474**)AP )(G A4I4/)?#AP ?1)( >-A?14A 2A-T./0(2 #I4A 1#6 #-A B-A#C4)( 0G4(?0Y?P 0* 0( 7A0*0*F

W8

P+0;'& D*&901 S8>*

=-@@*&8 '( ;:, E&'-" ,1;0;6,+Q

78690 3./7!:� Sources and Scope in the Christian

and the European Union Approach

?:09: ?*. *;;,1+,+ 78Q

D'+,&*;'&Q!" 6':"+5E F")E5-.(&G <)63&'$8+ *)% +", ?,,>6C )*+, "&./0&.123

PR",&;.Q6':"+5E F"+H87 0,&1,% )* +", 23%)4,#' L'$)' 5#%6$#&,'+70,&1,% )* +", 23%)4,#' L'$)' E31<)&&$++,, )' B3&#' D$."+8/"$01 4)C)+. BA3)':)7 B,#@ )* +", 9,4#%+&,'+ )* !)'8+$+3+$)'#6 F#?7!#+")6$< L'$I,%8$+C 5,+,% 5U/&U'C $' H3@#4,8+IJ'K' LMCC5'7 T'@,4,'@,'+ E,'#+)%7 V#+$)'#6 L'$I,%8$+C )* T%,6#'@

e4*?4AG)P D 1)G ?14 CA0I0/424 )(G C/4)*-A4 ?# /0*?4( ?# ?14 G0*7-**0#( 0( ?14?10AG 6#A$0(2 2A#-C ?1)? *C#$4 ).#-? 1-T)( A021?*H 61071 0* ?14 /)*? C)A?F "4?)/$4G >#A *#T4 ?0T4 ).#-? 1#6 ?# 7#(I0(74 #?14A* )(G 1#6 ?# ?)/$ ).#-? #-A)A2-T4(?*F _(4 #> ?14 I#074* 4iCA4**4G 6)* ?1)? 61)? 64 A4)//P (44G ?#G)P 0*(#? N-*? )( 0(?4//47?-)/ G4.)?4F

D> 64 1)I4 #-A h 0> 64 T)P *)P *# h @1A0*?0)( *0G4H 61071 0* ) .4/04> ?1)? 0(61)? 64 .4/04I4 0( 1-T)( A021?* 0**-4* 0* A021?H 0( )GG0?0#( ?# ?14 0(?4//47?-)/)A2-T4(?*H 64 T-*? )/*# .4 )./4 ?# ?)/$ ).#-? 0? )(G 1)I4 *#T4 *?#A04*F

K#?1 @FQF `460* )(G ^F=F=F <#/$04( 64A4 )-?1#A* 61# .-0/? >)(?)*?07 T4?)YC1#A* )(G 0( ) 6)P )/*# *1#64G ?14 2A4)? TP?1* #> ?14 6#A/GH ?14 0G4)* #> @1A0*Y?0)(0?PF Q# .P -*0(2 0(?4A4*?0(2 *?#A04*H 64 7)( 71)(24 10*?#APF Q?#A04* 71)(240G4)*H .-? *# G# 0(?4A4*?0(2 6#AG* C4A1)C* )* 64//F

e4*?4AG)P+* G4.)?4H 61071 6)* /4G .P RA M(GAO4N 5A)N46*$0H ?14 14)G #> ?14>#A402( G4C)A?T4(? #> ?14 J%[\ ]6:596:D+- 644$/PH >4)?-A4G M(GAO4N 5AOP.H) L4T.4A #> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(?H T4T.4A #> ?14 ,#/0*1 ,4)*)(?+* ,)A?P

WZ

)(G ) T4T.4A #> ?14 3-T)( =021?* Q-.7#TT0??44 #> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(?H=#()( L-//4(H )( 0(G4C4(G4(? *4()?#A >A#T DA4/)(G )(G ,A#>F K)/)O* Q71)(G)H) 3-(2)A0)( /)6P4AH 7)(#(0*? )(G C#/0?07)/ *704(?0*?F Q# 64 1)G ) G0*7-**0#( #(*4I4A)/ /4I4/*F M ()?0#()/ /4I4/ 6)* A4CA4*4(?4GH 0( ?10* 7)*4 ?14 DA0*1j ?14 *704(Y?0>07 /4I4/ )(G ?14 B-A#C4)( /4I4/ 64A4 A4CA4*4(?4G .P )( )7)G4T07 )(G ) L4T.4A#> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(?F M7?-)//PH )// #> ?14*4 ?#C07* >#7-*4G )A#-(G ?147#(>/07? .4?644( ?14 @1A0*?0)( -(G4A*?)(G0(2 #> 1-T)( A021?* )(G ?14 -(G4AY*?)(G0(2 ?1)? ?14 C)A?070C)(?* 0( ?14 G0*7-**0#( 1)G )**#70)?4G 0( *#T4 6)P 60?1?14 0(*?0?-?0#(* #> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(F

<14 ?6# 6)P* #> -(G4A*?)(G0(2 )CC4)A4G 0( *4I4A)/ T#T4(?* #> #-A G0*7-*Y*0#(F "4 *?)A?4G 60?1 ?14 .)*07 0**-4 h ()T4/PH ?14 m-4*?0#( #> 614?14A 1-T)(A021?* )A4 0( 7A0*0*F D> P#- 60//H D+T (#? 2#0(2 ?# m-#?4 ?14 ()T4* #> C4#C/4 ?1)?1)I4 *C#$4(H .47)-*4 )// #> ?140A *?)?4T4(?* 64A4 )0T4G 0( #(4 G0A47?0#(F <14A46)* (# >021?0(2H .-? ?14P 7#TC/4T4(?4G 4)71 #?14AF "4 *?)A?4G >A#T ?14 >)7??1)? ?14 >#-(G)?0#( #> 1-T)( A021?* 0* 1-T)( G02(0?PH (#? /420*/)?0#(F <14 CA#.Y/4T #> 1-T)( A021?*H )* 64 14)AG )? ?14 .420((0(2H G#4* (#? )CC/P ?# 0(*?0?-?0#(*?1)? CA#T#?4 1-T)( A021?* #A *#T41#6 2-)AG ?140A 7#TC/0)(74F

<14 /)6* )A4 (#? CA#./4T)?07 (#6)G)P*H .-? 61# ) C4A*#( 0* .47#T4* CA#.Y/4T)?07 *#T4?0T4*F <14 *?)?4T4(? 6)* T)G4 ?1)? ?14 I4AP 7#(74C?0#( #> ?14C4A*#( 0* .40(2 )??)7$4GF <14 m-4*?0#( 0*H #> 7#-A*4H 61# 0* )??)7$0(2 ?10* 7#(Y74C? #> ?14 1-T)(l "4 A4?-A( ?# ?14 B-A#C4)( 0(*?0?-?0#(*H 61071 64A4 C)A?0)//P7A0?070O4G P4*?4AG)P G-A0(2 #-A G0*7-**0#(*H .-? )/*# A4*4AI)?0#(* 64A4 T)G4H1#64I4AH (#? ?# 24(4A)/0O4F

"4 ?)/$4G *4I4A)/ ?0T4* ).#-? ?14 N-A0*G07?0#( #> ?14 B-A#C4)( @#-A? #>3-T)( =021?*H 61071 0* #>?4( )**#70)?4G 60?1 ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(H 610/4 0? 0*)7?-)//P #(4 #> ?14 .#G04* #> )( #-?*0G4 0(*?0?-?0#( (#? G0A47?/P /0($4G 60?1 ?14B-A#C4)( f(0#(H ()T4/P ?14 @#-(70/ #> B-A#C4F Q-71 4iC/)()?0#(* )A4 (44G4GFD? 0* )/*# ) 7)// >#A CA470*0#(F

"1)? $0(G* #> 0G4)* )A4 64 G4)/0(2 60?1H )(G 61)? 7)-*4* ?14 !B-A#C4)(+-(G4A*?)(G0(2 #> 1-T)( A021?*H 61071 D -(G4A*?)(G 0* ?14 4iCA4**0#( #> 74A?)0(7-/?-A)/ ?A4(G* CA4*4(? 0( #-A 7#(?4TC#A)AP /0I4*l "1)? T)$4* 0? 0(?# B-A#C4)(?14 /420*/)?0#(H >#A 4i)TC/4j 1#6 G# ?14*4 0G4)* ?1)? )A4 #>?4( 0G4)* ?1)? 6414)AG #(/P P4*?4AG)PH ?1)? )A4 T)A20()/H 4T4A20(2 *#T4614A4 #( ?14 *0G4Y/0(4*H2#24? ?# ?14 ?#C )(G .47#T4 T)0(*?A4)Tl Q#T4 0**-4* )A4 A)0*4G 0( ?14 B-A#C4Y)( f(0#( .P 1-T)( A021?* #A2)(0O)?0#(*F <14 >0A*? G#7-T4(?* )A4 7A4)?4GH ?14P)A4 0(0?0)//P (#(Y.0(G0(2H )(G *?4C .P *?4C 0? 7/0T.* 10214A -(?0/ 0? .47#T4* ) 1)AG/)6H )(G ?14*4 !#/G+ 1-T)( A021?*H ?14 .)*07 #(4* )A4 .40(2 C-? ?# ?14 *0G4H 0(?##./0I0#(F R4C-?P 5AOP. T)G41)G ) A4*4AI)?0#( h ?1)? ) /#? #> )??4TC?* ?# 0(?A#YG-74 71)(24* 0( ?14 /420*/)?0#( #( 1-T)( A021?* 0* )/*# CA0T)A0/P ).#-? 71)(24*0( 0**-4* #> T#A)/*H 0( 0**-4* #> -(G4A*?)(G0(2 ?14 >)T0/PH ?14 A021?* #> T0(#A0Y

W\

?04*H )(G *-71 7#TC/4i G0/4TT)* *-71 )* ).#A?0#( #A 4-?1)()*0) h ?14P A4)71C-./07 )6)A4(4** 0( ) *#T461)? -(-*-)/ 6)PF Q# 0? 0*H >#A 4i)TC/4H 60?1 ?14m-4*?0#( #> 4m-)/0?P .4?644( 6#T4( )(G T4(F

Q#T4 ?0T4 )2# ?14 24(G4A .)/)(74 0( 2#I4A(0(2 .#G04* 6)* G0*7-**4G 0( ?14B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(? h >#A 4i)TC/4H 0( ?14 T)()24T4(? #> C-./07 0(*?0?-?0#(* h)(G ?14A4 6)* )( )??4TC? ?# ?AP ?# >#A74 ?14 0(?A#G-7?0#( #> ) ?10AG 24(G4A ?#?14*4 A42-/)?0#(*H ?14 *#Y7)//4G 7-/?-A)/ 24(G4AF 3#64I4AH ?10* 6)* T4? 60?1) .02 T0*-(G4A*?)(G0(2F

D? 0* )/*# 0TC#A?)(? ?1)? ?10* 71)(24 0( ?14 -(G4A*?)(G0(2 #> 1-T)( A021?*1)CC4(* )(G ?)$4* C/)74 0( ?14 #?14A G0A47?0#(F 3-(2)AP 6)* 20I4( )* ?14 4iY)TC/4H 61071 )>?4A *4I4A)/ P4)A* -(G4A c0G4*O 1)* .47#T4 ) */021?/P T#A47#(*4AI)?0I4 7#-(?APH )(G ?1)? ?10* 71)(24 #> I)/-4* h D G# (#? /0$4 ?# -*4 ?14C1A)*4 !G4>4(74 #> @1A0*?0)( I)/-4*+H .-? 0( ?4AT* #> *?)(G0(2 #( ?140A *0G4 h 0*)/*# I4AP I0*0./4 >#A 4i)TC/4 )T#(2 3-(2)A0)( L4T.4A* #> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)AY/0)T4(?F

M(P6)PH 0( 24(4A)/ ?14 A4CA4*4(?)?0#( #> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(? #A020()?Y0(2 >A#T ?14 7#-(?A04* #> @4(?A)/ )(G B)*?4A( B-A#C4 0* T-71 T#A4 7#(*4AI)Y?0I4 ?1)( ?14 G4C-?04* >A#T ?14 !#/G+ B-A#C4)( f(0#(F

"4 .42)( ) *-.*?)(?0I4 G0*7-**0#( >A#T ?14 m-4*?0#( #> ?14 A021? ?# /0>4j614?14A ?14 A021? ?# /0>4 0* (#? *-71 ) >-(G)T4(?)/ 1-T)( A021? ?1)? 0? 0* ?14>#-(G)?0#( >#A )// ?14 #?14A*H )(G )2)0(H 614?14A ?14A4 0* ) 7#(?A#I4A*P 14A4.4?644( ?14 @1A0*?0)( )(G ?14 Bf -(G4A*?)(G0(2F

,A#>F Q71)(G) CA#I0G4G )( 0(?4A4*?0(2 4i)TC/4J 614( B-A#C4H 61071 0* )/*#7#(*0G4A4G ?# .4 )( 4iC#A?4A #> I)/-4*H ?A04* 0( *#T4 6)P ?# )>>47? ?14 7#-(?A04*?1)? )CC/P ?14 G4)?1 C4()/?P h ?14 4i)TC/4 #> @10() 6)* .A#-21? -CH 614A4 ) /#?#> 4i47-?0#(* )A4 7)AA04G #-? h .-? )? ?14 *)T4 ?0T4H )(G ?10* 0* ) C)A)G#i #> ?14B-A#C4)( f(0#( #A B-A#C4)( 0(*?0?-?0#(*H ?14A4 0* ) I0*0./4 -(G4A*?)(G0(2 ?#Y6)AG* ?14 C#/07P #> .0A?1 7#(?A#/ 0( @10()H 61071 0> P#- /##$ )? ?14 *?)?0*?07*H)CC/04* ?# ) /#? T#A4 /0I4* ?1)( ?14 G4)?1 C4()/?PH 61071 ?14 C)A?070C)(?* #> P4*Y?4AG)P+* G0*7-**0#( 7A0?070O4GF

M// #> ?14*4 /)6* ?1)? ?14 C)A?070C)(?* G0*7-**4G P4*?4AG)P )A4 *-.N47? ?#74A?)0( 71)(24*H )(G ?14*4 71)(24* )A4 I4AP 4I0G4(? 0( ?14 /)6j >#A 4i)TC/4H ?14N-A0*G07?0#( #> ?14 B-A#C4)( @#-A? #> 3-T)( =021?*F

Q4()?#A L-//4( 2)I4 )* )( 4i)TC/4 P4*?4AG)P #> ?14 )CCA#)71 #> ?14 B-A#YC4)( @#-A? #> 3-T)( =021?* ?# ?14 CA#?47?0#( #> CA0I)?4 )(G >)T0/P /0>4F 34 *)0G?1)? *4I4A)/ P4)A* )2# 0( 10* 7)*4* #( ?14 >)T0/P )(G ?14 CA#?47?0#( #> CA0I)?4/0>4H 14 )/6)P* ?1#-21? ?1)? 710/GA4( 64A4 ?14 T#*? 0TC#A?)(? h ?1)? 0*H ?14 710/YGA4( 64A4 ?14 *?)A?0(2 C#0(?F

f(T)AA04G 7#-C/4* 61# 1)G (# 710/GA4( 64A4 (#? A4)//P 7#(*0G4A4G ) >)T0Y/PF <#G)PH 0( ?-A(H 64 1)I4 7#T4 ?# ?14 C#0(? 614A4 7#-C/4* #> ?14 *)T4 *4i )A4

W[

7#(*0G4A4G ) >)T0/PH *# 64 )A4 ?)/$0(2 ).#-? ) I4AP 7/4)A 71)(24H 614A4 ?147#(*4m-4(74 0* ?1)? ?14 A021?* #> 710/GA4( 7#T4 0(?# ) 7#(>/07? 60?1 ?14 )*C0A)Y?0#(* #> )G-/?* )(G )7?-)//P 74)*4 ?# .4 0TC#A?)(?t

D( )GG0?0#( ?# ?10* 0* ?14 >)7? ?1)? ?14 CA#I0*0#(* A42)AG0(2 ?14 >)T0/P 0( CA)7Y?07)/ ?4AT*H 0( ?4AT* #> N-A0*CA-G4(74 #A 0(?4ACA4?)?0#(H *44T ?# .4 0( 7#(>/07?60?1 )A?07/4* ).#-? T)AA0)24F <14 ?4AT !7#)/0?0#( #> ?14 7-/?-A)//P *?A#(24*?+)/*# )CC4)A4GF D? T021? *#-(G ) .0? 7#(*C0A)?#A0)/H .-? ?14A4 0* *-71 ) ?4AT )*!C#64A #> 7-/?-A4+H 61071 )A4 >#A74* #> 74A?)0( 7-/?-A)/ ?A4(G* ?1)? 7)( >#A74 ?1471)(24 #> 1-T)( A021?* )(G 1)I4 .44( A47#2(0O4G .P -* *0(74 ?14 4(G #> "#A/G")A DD )* *#T4?10(2 I4AP -(0I4A*)/F

<14 m-4*?0#( 6)* )*$4G ).#-? 61)? 6#-/G 1)CC4( 0> ?10* >A)20/4 .)/)(74 0(?14 7-/?-A4 #> ?14 >-?-A4 *#T41#6 71)(24*l "1)? 1)CC4(* 0> *#T4#(4 4I4AG470G4* ?1)? 6#T4( )A4 (#? )//#64G ?# T)AAPl MA4 ?14A4 )(P 6)P* 0(?4A()?0#()/0(*?0?-?0#(* 60// .4 )./4 ?# CA4I4(? ?14 4T4A24(74 #> *-71 0G4)* >A#T ?14 .)*07G4/0.4A)?0I4 /4I4/ ?# ) 10214A /4I4/l

,A#>F d#// 6)A(4G ?1)? 64 *1#-/G (#? I046 ?14 A021? ?# /0>4 )(G 0?* A47#2(0?0#()* ) .)*07 1-T)( A021? #(/P )* ) CA0I0/424H #A )* *#T4?10(2 ?1)? 0* G4A0I4G #(/P>A#T @1A0*?0)(0?PF

BI4AP#(4 *1#-/G )**-T4 ?10* )??0?-G4 )(G A47#2(0O4 ?14 A021? ?# /0>4 )* ?14T#*? 0TC#A?)(?H *# 0> P#- )*$ ) @1A0*?0)(H ) L-*/0T #A ) C4A*#( 60?1#-? A4/0Y20#(H 614?14A 14 7#(*0G4A* ?1)? ?14 A021? ?# /0>4 0* ) >-(G)T4(?)/ A021?H ?14 )(Y*64A 60// CA#.)./P .4 !P4*+F <14 G0*C-?4 7#(74A(* #(/P 614( ?14 1-T)( 61#4(N#P* ?14 A021? ?# /0>4 .420(*F

<1-*H 14A4 64 ?#-714G #( ?14 m-4*?0#(* #> 6#T4(+* A4CA#G-7?0I4 A021?*H61071 )A4 0(7A4)*0(2/P CA4*4(? 0( N-A0*CA-G4(74F <14P )CC4)A4GH )T#(2 #?14A*H*#T4 ?0T4 )2# 0( ?14 >)T#-* ,#/0*1 I4AG07? .P ?14 B-A#C4)( @#-A?+* N-G2T4(?0( ?14 7)*4 #> M/07N) <P*0)7F D? 0* #> 7#-A*4 ?14 m-4*?0#( #> 614?14A *#T4#(46)(?* ?# .4 ) T#?14A #A (#?F M? 61071 C#0(? G#4* ?14 6#T)( .420( ?# .4 ) T#?14AlK47)-*4 0> 64 7#(*0G4A ?1)? )? ?14 T#T4(? #> 7#(74C?0#(H )? ?10* C#0(?H ?14*4A4CA#G-7?0I4 A021?* 4(GH )(G ?14 m-4*?0#( 614?14A *14 6)(?* ?# .4 ) T#?14A #A(#? .420(*l <14( 64 )A4 (#? ?)/$0(2 ).#-? ) I0#/)?0#( #> A4CA#G-7?0I4 A021?*H .-?>A#T ) *?A07? C#0(? #> I046H 64 )A4 *0TC/P ?)/$0(2 ).#-? ?14 74**)?0#( #> /0>4F Q#0? 0* (# /#(24A #(4 .#GPH .-? ?14*4 )A4 ?14 ?6# .#G04*H ?6# 7)AA04A* #> A021?* ?1)?T-*? .4 CA#?47?4G h ?10* 0* ?14 I#074 #> ,A#>F M(GAO4N d#//F

"14( 64 ?)/$4G ).#-? 71)(24* 0( 7#(?4TC#A)AP 7-/?-A4H )(#?14A ?#C074T4A24GH ()T4/P A42)AG0(2 #6(4A*10C )(G ?1)? (#6)G)P* 64 )A4 /4)*0(2 ?10(2*T#A4 )(G T#A4 h .#AA#60(2 ?14T >#A #-A -*4F B-A#C4)(* )A4 /#*0(2 ?140A A4/)Y?0#(*10C 60?1 ?140A /)(GH 60?1 #.N47?*F U#6)G)P*H ?14A4 )A4 64.*0?4* >-(7?0#(Y0(2 ?1)? )//#6 -* ?# )7?-)//P /4)*4 *#T4#(4+* )C)A?T4(?*H *#T4#(4+* 7)A*H )(G-*4 ?14TF

W;

<10* /0($ ?1)? 0* ?14 7#((47?0#( .4?644( T)(H ?14 #.N47? )(G ?14 4)A?1 0* )/*##(4 #> ?14 *#-A74* ?1)? 7A4)?4* *-71 ) *1)$P *P*?4T #> I)/-4*H 61071 0( ?14 4(G/4)G* -* ?# ?14 7#(7/-*0#( ?1)? CA)7?07)//P 4I4AP?10(2 ?1)? 64 .4/04I4 0(H ?1)? 64CA#>4**H 0* 2##G .47)-*4 (#6 ?10* 0* TP T#*? 0TC#A?)(? A021?H (#? ?14 A021? ?#/0>4 )(G #?14A A021?* )A0*0(2 >A#T ?10*H .-? TP A021? ?# 71#074F <14 71#074 #>) T)( )(G 10* )-?#(#TP 64A4 )/*# ?14 *-.N47?* #> P4*?4AG)P+* G0*7-**0#(F

M(G ?14 /)*? ?10(2 ?1)? *44T4G 0TC#A?)(? ?# T4 P4*?4AG)PJ 0( CA4I0#-* 2A#-C*?14A4 64A4 ?)/$* ).#-? A4>-244*F "4 64A4 /4** 0(I#/I4G 60?1 ?10* ?#C07H .-? )?*#T4 C#0(?H ?14 m-4*?0#( #> ?14 0G4(?0?P #> 7#TT-(0?04* )(G 614?14A C4#C/461# /4)I4 ?140A 7#TT-(0?04* /4)I4 .410(G ) 74A?)0( A4*C#(*0.0/0?P )A#*4F D T-*?)GT0? ?1)? 0? 6)* ) m-4*?0#( ?1)? 7)-*4G *#T4 A4*0*?)(74 0( T)(P #> -*H )(G 641)I4 (#? A4)714G ) 7#(*4(*-* 14A4H .-? ?14P *1#-/G 2# G#6( ) /4I4/ /#64A )(G?10($ ).#-? T02A)?0#( )(G 4i0/4H (#? #(/P 0( ?14 7#(?4i? #> ?14 ?A)24G04* ?1)? )A41)CC4(0(2 ?#G)P 0( QPA0) G-4 ?# ?14 D*/)T07 Q?)?4 #A ?14 7A0T4* #> M**)GH .-?4I4( 0( #-A A420#(H ?1)? 0* 47#(#T07 T02A)?0#( ?# ?14 "4*?F "4 $(#6 ?1)? ) /#?#> C4#C/4 4T02A)?4 ?# ?14 "4*? )(G /4)I4 ?140A >)T0/04* 14A4F D( ,#/)(G ?14 ?4AT!4-A#Y#AC1)(*+ 6)* >#AT4G >#A 710/GA4( /4>? .410(G .P ?140A >)T0/04*F <10* 0*4i?A4T4/P C)0(>-/F

M? ?14 4(G #> ?14 G0*7-**0#( 64 A4?-A(4G ?# ?14 m-4*?0#( ).#-? T)(H 61# 140*H 1#6 ?# -(G4A*?)(G 10TH )(G 61)? 10* T4)(0(2 0*F D ?10($ ?14 7#(7/-*0#( ?14A40* ?14 *)P0(2 ?1)? ) T)( 0* .#A(H )T#(2 #?14A ?10(2*H >#A ?14 7#TT-(0?Pj ?1)?7#TT-(0?04* )A4 4i?A4T4/P 0TC#A?)(?F

`4? T4 )//#6 >#A ) C4A*#()/ 0(?4AI4(?0#(F e4*?4AG)PH ?)/$0(2 #( ?14 *0G4Y/0(4* #> ?14 7#(>4A4(74 60?1 ) >46 C4#C/4H 64 6#(G4A4G 61)? T)P .4 ?14 CA)7Y?07)/ )CC/07)?0#( #> ?14 7#(>4A4(74 0( <#T)*O#6074 #( ?14 >-(7?0#(0(2 #> ,#Y/)(GH ?14 @1-A71 )(G B-A#C4F

D A4T4T.4A ?1)? /)*? P4)A D 1)G ?14 C/4)*-A4 ?# /0*?4( ?# ) G0*7-**0#( 0( ) 2A#-C?1)? 6)* /0$4 ) /0??/4 CA#C14?07 G0*7-**0#( 2A#-CH .47)-*4 64 ?)/$4G ?14( ).#-?A4>-244*F

MA71.0*1#C cA)(74*7# L#(?4(42A# 6)* ) 2-4*? 14A4H ?#G)P )/A4)GP ) 7)AG0Y()/H ?14 T4?A#C#/0?)( #> ?14 ?#6( #> M2A024(?# 0( Q070/PH ?1)? 0(7/-G4*H )T#(2#?14A*H `)TC4G-*)F D 6)* C4A*#()//P 0(*C0A4G .P ?14 G0*7-**0#( /)*? P4)A )(G 0?4(7#-A)24G T4 ?# .420( ?# G4)/ 60?1 ?10* ?#C07F <10* P4)AH T)(P #> -* 1)I4 .44(0(*C0A4G .P ?14*4 G0*7-**0#(* )(G 614( 64 T44? (4i? P4)AH 64 60// 1)I4 )(#CC#A?-(0?P ?# 7#T4 .)7$ ?# ?14TF

WW

.43?9 J<@F6?LA @1)0AT)(H D 6#-/G /0$4 ?# CA4*4(? ) >46 #.*4AI)?0#(*F _> 7#-A*4H D 6)*

(#? )./4 ?# /0*?4( ?# )// #> ?14 G4.)?4*H .47)-*4 D G# (#? 1)I4 ?14 20>? #> .40(2 0(?6# #A ?1A44 /#7)?0#(*H .-? D .4/04I4 ?1)? 64 1)I4 7#(G-7?4G T)(P I4AP A4)*#(Y)./4 G4.)?4* #I4A 14A4F 3#64I4AH #(4 *1#-/G )*$ ?14 m-4*?0#(H 61)? 7#-/G 1)I4.44( G#(4 .4??4Al _A 61)? G# 64 1)I4 ?# G# .4??4Al "4 *1#-/G )??4TC? 14A4 ?#C/)74 >0A*? 61)? 0* CA)7?07)//P C#**0./4 ?# )77#TC/0*1F ,#/0*1 7#(*?0?-?0#()/ /)6CA#>4**#A M(GAO4N d#// 6)* CA)0*4G 14A4F 30* I4AP 7#TCA414(*0I4 CA4*4(?)?0#(6)* 4i?A4T4/P 0(?4A4*?0(2 )(G 74A?)0(/P ) *7A0C? >#A *?-G4(?* 6#-/G )/*# .4 -*4Y>-/H .-? 64 G# (#? 20I4 ?## T)(P *C470>07 2-0G4/0(4*H .47)-*4 64 )*$ ?14 m-4*Y?0#( #> 61)? 64 6)(? ?# G# h 61)? *1#-/G 1)CC4( )(G 1#6H 0( #-A #C0(0#(l

"4 G0G (#? 7#T4 14A4 0( #AG4A ?# 7#(I4A? C4#C/4 ?# @1A0*?0)(0?PF "4 )**-T4*#T4 .)*07 7#(G0?0#(* 0( ?14 @1-A71H 61071 0* A4CA4*4(?4G 14A4 .P ?14 104A)A71P)(G ?14 C)*?#A*H ?1)? ) .)*07 7#(*4(*-* 4i0*?*F _> 7#-A*4H T)(P #?14A m-4*?0#(*)A4 6#A?1 )*$0(2H *# D+G 6#(G4A ).#-? ?1)?F Q? <1#T)* Mm-0()* 6)* m-#?4G14A4j 14 )*$* 614?14A 5#G 0* ?14 7)-*4l c#A T4H )* ) @)?1#/07H ?10* m-4*?0#( 0*).*#/-?4/P -A24(? )(G CA4**0(2F <14 T)0( m-4*?0#( 0* ?14 m-4*?0#( CA4I0#-*/PC#*4GF D? 0* S)(?0)( h >#A *#T4 I4AP #./020(2H >#A *#T4 >-// #> 2)C* h .-? ?14m-4*?0#( 0*H 61)? 0* ?14 CA)7?07)/ T4**)24 ?1)? #-A @1A0*?0)(0?P *1#-/G -(G4AY/0(4H )(G )? ?14 *)T4 ?0T4 /##$ >#A )//04*H .47)-*4 64 (474**)A0/P (44G ?14TlD *)? 0( ?14 .4(714* #> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(? >#A ?## /#(2 ?# (#? $(#6 ).#-?0?F "4 *?0// 1)I4 ?# >0(G ) CA)7?07)/ *#/-?0#( ?1)? 0* C#**0./4 ?# )77#TC/0*1FD ?10($ ?1)? 4I4( 0( ?14 CA4*4(?)?0#( #> TP 7#-(?APT)( c)?14A RA S#/>1)-* 0?G0G (#? *#-(G *?A#(2 4(#-21H .47)-*4 )? ?14 4(G #> 10* *C4471 14 CA4*4(?4G 0?0( ) I4AP .A#)G C/)(H 70?0(2 Q? <1#T)*F D 6#-/G A)?14A CA4>4A ?# 4TC1)*0O4 14A461)? 0* CA)7?07)/F

"4 )* @1A0*?0)(* 1)I4 CA#.)./P T)G4 ) T0*?)$4 .)*4G #( ?14 >)7? ?1)? 64 G#(#? GA)6 T)(P 7#(7/-*0#(* >A#T 10*?#APj 64 G0*A42)AG 61)? 0* A4/4I)(?F "4 )A4?)/$0(2 ).#-? G02(0?PH .-? ?14 *?)?4T4(? ?1)? K)A?#/#Tb G4 `)* @)*)* C/)74G.4>#A4 @1)A/4* k 0* T0**0(2J !"4 *1#-/G (#? ?A4)? ?14 D(G0)(* *# .)G/PF <14*4)A4 (#? ?10(2*H ?14P )A4 C4#C/4 /0$4 P#- )(G T4F+ <10* 6)* )/A4)GP 0( ?14 P4)A:[[9F _A ^4*-0? cA04GA071 QC44 I#( `)(24(>4/GH .-A04G 0( TP 1#T4?#6(H 61# 0(?14 :W?1 74(?-AP 1)G ?14 7#-A)24 ?# *)PJ !3-(?0(2 >#A 60?714* 0* T)G(4**F <14@1-A71 7)((#? 7#(?0(-4 ?# ?#/4A)?4 )(G *-CC#A? .-A(0(2 C4#C/4 )/0I4F+ M// *?)?4YT4(?* #.?)0(4G -(G4A ?#A?-A4 )A4 ) T0*?)$4F BI4( ?14 ^4*-0?* 7#(G4T(4G 10T>#A *-71 1)A*1 6#AG*F `4? -* A4T0(G #-A*4/I4* #> 61)? G4?4AT0(4* ?14 T)0(T4**)24 #> ?14 cA4(71 =4I#/-?0#( )(G ?14 fFQF @#(*?0?-?0#(F c#A 74(?-A04*H 0?6)* ) G4I4/#CT4(? ?1)? 64 @1A0*?0)(* *1#-/G )/*# /4)A( *#T4?10(2F "4 *44H)>?4A )//H 61)? ) 7#TCA#T0*4 0*F @#TCA#T0*4 0* (#? )/6)P* !A#??4(+F @#TCA#YT0*4 0* (#? )/6)P* .)GF @#TCA#T0*4 7)( .4 2##G 0> 0? 14/C* -* ?# 2# >-A?14AF

WX

M(G ?10* 0* ) T)??4A #( 61071 D 1#C4 ?1)? G-A0(2 ?14 :;?1 7#(>4A4(74 (4i? P4)A64 60// 4TC1)*0O4 ?10* CA)7?07)/H CA)2T)?07 G0T4(*0#( T#A4 ?1)( 64 64A4 )./4?# G# ?10* P4)AF "4 60// >#7-* #( ?14 2#)/H )(G 64 60// (#? .4 ?1A#60(2 #-? *#T)(P 14)IP ?14*4* ?1)? 60// A4T)0( -()(*64A4Gj >#A 4i)TC/4H ?14*4 .02 m-4*Y?0#(* ).#-? D*/)T )A4 ) ?#C07 >#A ) *4C)A)?4 7#(>4A4(74F D )2)0( m-#?4 #(4 #> TP7#TC)?A0#?*H U071#/)* #> @-*)H 61# G4I#?4G ?6# 6#A$* ?# D*/)TF K-? ?10* 0*) *4C)A)?4 ?#C07H )* C4A ?14 G0*7-**0#(F M(G ?14 ?#C07 #> A4>-244*H )*P/-T *44$Y4A* )(G 0TT02A)(?* 1)* )/*# .44( G0*7-**4GF <1)($ P#- )// I4AP *0(74A4/PF

Special Session

4835;4 < 9 /=5>9= ;=9143

)?@@%*+ .*+%@*"+A'*"$ ;'$A+AB"$ ;@'#$%C,3%D?A@A*E 48 .*F'$F%C%*+

.*+@'G?B+A'* :H%%BI%,

X:

3& 4*9,2 =*&8-./TU'6.200,&1,% )* +", 23%)4,#' L'$)' 5#%6$#&,'+7

W$<,M5%,8$@,'+ )* +", 23%)4,#' 5,)46,P8 5#%+C#'@ $+8 *#<+$)' $' +", 23%)4,#' 5#%6$#&,'+

`)G04* )(G 54(?/4T4(H e#-A Bi74//4(7P K0*1#CH R4)A cA04(G*H

<14 ?#C07 #> ?#G)P+* G0*7-**0#( 0* !B-A#C4 h ) 2/#.)/ C/)P4A+F D> P#- 60//HD 6#-/G /0$4 ?# A4>#AT-/)?4 0? )(G >#7-* #( B-A#C4 )(G 0?* T0**0#( ?# .A0(2 C4#YC/4 ?# ?14 6#A/GJ !B-A#C4 h ) 2/#.)/ C4)74T)$4A+F D 6#-/G /0$4 -* ?# /##$ >#A)(*64A* )* ?# 614?14A ?14 Bf *1#-/G .4 #(/P ) 2/#.)/ C/)P4AH #A T)P.4 *#T4Y?10(2 T#A4F D 6#-/G /0$4 -* ?# ?)/$ ).#-? ?14 A##?* #> #-A CA#N47?H ?14 (4021.#-AY1##G 0( ?14 >0A4H ) 2/#.)/ C)A?(4A*10C >#A C4)74 .)*4G #( #-A @1A0*?0)( I)/-4*H)(G >0()//P 1#6 *#/0G)A0?PH *# >A)0/ 0( ?14 >)74 #> ?#G)P+* 71)//4(24*H ?A)(*>#AT*0(?# ?14 2##G ?1)? 60// .4 )./4 ?# C-A*-4 ) 7#TT#( m-4*? >#A C4)74F

U#? )770G4(?)//PH ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( 6)* CA#-G ?1)? ?1A44 P4)A* )2# 0? 6)*?14 60((4A #> ?14 U#.4/ ,4)74 ,A0O4F L)(P C4#C/4 ?#G)P )A4 )*$0(2 614?14A 0?G4*4AI4G ?14 U#.4/F D G)A4 *)P ?1)? C)A?/P P4* )(G C)A?/P (#F D? 6)* G4*4AI4G.47)-*4 0( A474(? G47)G4* C4)74 1)* A402(4G )T#(2 ?14 ()?0#(* #> B-A#C4H )(G*-71 6)* ?14 T)0( T4**)24 #> ?14 @1A0*?0)( >#-(G0(2 >)?14A*j *-71 6)* ?14 G44CT#?0I)?0#( #> R4 5)*C4A0H Q71-T)( )(G MG4()-4AH )(G *-71 64A4 ?14 A##?* #>?14 B-A#C4)( CA#N47?F _( ?14 #?14A 1)(GH B-A#C4 0* *-AA#-(G4G )? ?10* ?0T4 .P) !70A7/4 #> >0A4+F M? ?14 ?1A4*1#/G #> B-A#C4H 0( ?14 4)*? )(G *#-?1H ?14A4 0* ) 6)A61071 (#? #(/P 6#AA04*H .-? )/*# ?1A4)?4(* -*F 34(74 D *# I0I0G/P CA4*4(? ?14*-.N47? #> #-A G4/0.4A)?0#(* ?10* P4)AF

<14 Bf A4I4)/* ?10* 0(*?0(7?0I4 0TC-/*4 ?# )7? 0( )77#AG)(74 60?1 ?140A (#./4@1A0*?0)( 0G4)/*F D? T)(0>4*?* A4*C#(*0.0/0?PH ?1#-21 #>?4( #(/P 0( ?14 C-A4/P I4AY.)/ *C14A4j A4*C#(*0.0/0?P >#A ?14 A021?* #> ?14 64)$H >#A ?14 A021?* #> ?14 #CYCA4**4GH >#A ?14 >)?4 #> ?14 7/0T)?4H >#A G4I4/#CT4(? C#/07PH )(GH >0()//PH >#A) T#A4 T#A)/ 6#A/G #AG4AF K-? 0( )// ?10*H 0? 0* ?## 64)$H ?## */#6H ?## 7/-T*P)(G G0I0G4GF <14A4>#A4H 64 1)I4 ?# G4>4(G ?10* CA#N47? 4I4( T#A4H A)?14A ?1)(G4>4(G #-A*4/I4* )2)0(*? 0? )(G G0*?)(74 #-A*4/I4* >A#T 0?F "4 1)I4 ?# G4>4(G 0?H.47)-*4 #(/P 0( ?10* 6)P 64 60// .4 )./4 ?# C-A*-4 ?10* CA0T)AP T0**0#( #>.A0(20(2 C4)74F

B-A#C4 1)* ?14 )T.0?0#( ?# .4 ) !2/#.)/ C/)P4A+ )(G ?14 .4)A4A #> C4)74H (#?N-*? ) 2/#.)/ C)P4A h ) !2/#.)/ C/)P4A ?1)? 0* (#? #(/P ) 2/#.)/ C)P4A+F 3#64I4AH

X8

0? 1)* G0>>07-/?04* ?# T44? ?14*4 )T.0?0#(*F D( ?14 >)74 #> *# >)A ?14 G44C4*? 7A0*0*#> 0?* (4021.#-A1##GH ?14 Bf 1)* CA#I4G ?# .4 C#64A/4**F <14 )(*64A ?1)? 0?*1#-/G 1)I4 CA#I0G4G 1)G ?# .4 /##$4G >#A 0( N#0(? )(G *4I4A)/ 7#TT#( B-A#C4Y)( >#A402( )(G *47-A0?P C#/0704*H .-? ?14*4 C#/0704* )A4 0( )( 4T.AP#(07 >#ATFQ?A0I0(2 >#A C4)74 )/*# A4m-0A4* *?A4(2?1 ?1)? ?14 Bf 0* *?0// T0**0(2F M(G 0> ?14Bf G#4* (#? 1)I4 ?14 )(*64A ?# ?10* 7A0*0* )(G 7)((#? 7#C4 60?1 ?14 (4021.#-AY1##GH 7)( 0? .4 ) 2/#.)/ C/)P4Al

<#G)P 64 )A4 60?(4**0(2 ?14 G4*?).0/0O)?0#( #> ?14 L0GG/4 B)*?H ?14 7#//)C*4#> QPA0)H DA)mH `0.P) )(G =-**0)+* )22A4**0#( )2)0(*? f$A)0(4F <14*4 )A4 ?6#*0G4* #> ?14 *)T4 7#0(F <14 4I0/ ?1)? 02(0?4* ?14 4)*?4A( )(G *#-?14A( .#AG4A* #>?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(H -(G4AT0(0(2 ?14 4/4T4(?)AP CA0(70C/4* #> 0(?4A()?0#()/#AG4AH 1)* ) 7#TT#( *#-A74F K#?1 7A0*4* h #( ?14 4)*?4A( )(G *#-?14A( .#AG4A*#> B-A#C4 h )/*# )CC4)A4G )? ?14 6#A*? C#**0./4 T#T4(?H 614( ?14 f(0#( 6)*64)$4(4G .P ?14 47#(#T07 7A0*0*H CA4#77-C04G 60?1 0?*4/>F <10* *?)?4H D+T )>A)0GH7)( *?0// /)*? >#A ) /#(2 ?0T4F

<14A4 )A4 >A#O4( 7#(>/07?* )A#-(G -*F Q#T4 *C4)$ #> ?14 )A7 #> 0(*?).0/0?P>A#T ?14 K)/?07 Q4) ?# ?14 L4G0?4AA)(4)(F <14 >)0?1 0(14A4(? 0( *#T4 #> ?14B-A#C4)( f(0#(H ?1)? P#- 7)( >4(74 #>> ?14 7#(>/)2A)?0#( 0( f$A)0(4 #A 0( ?14L0GG/4 B)*?H 0* 0//-*#APF <14 )6)A4(4** #> ?10* A4)714* -* 0( ) I4AP C)0(>-/ 6)P?1A#-21 ?14 6)I4* #> A4>-244* )(G T02A)(?*F K-? B-A#C4 0* (#? T)?-A4 4(#-21?#G)P ?# *?)?4 I4AP 7/4)A/P ?14 CA0T)AP *#-A74 #> ?10* 0* 6)A h ?14 6)A 0( f$A)0(4H)(G ?14 6)A 0( ?14 L0GG/4 B)*?F "1)?+* T#A4H B-A#C4 )I#0G* /0$4 ?14 C/)2-4)GT0??0(2 ?1)? ?14 ?1A4)? #> A4>-244* ?1A4)?4( -* >A#T .#?1 *0G4*H (#? N-*? >A#T?14 *#-?1F M(G 64 (44G ?# ?)/$ )(G ?10($ ).#-? .#?1 610/4 *44$0(2 7#TT#(*#/-?0#(*F K#?1 71)//4(24* )A4 )/*# ) ?4*? >#A ?14 @1A0*?0)( /#I4 #> ?14 (4021.#-A)(G #-A I)/-4*F D> 64 /#*4 G4T#7A)?07 )(G >-(G)T4(?)/ B-A#C4)( I)/-4* 0(f$A)0(4H #-A B-A#C4)( *?A-7?-A4 60// .4 -(G4AT0(4GF <14 G4>4)? 0( f$A)0(4 0*)( 4i0*?4(?0)/ ?1A4)? ?# ?14 BfF <14 )??4TC? ?# G4>4(G B-A#C4)( I)/-4* 0( f$A)0(40* ) ?4*? #> #-A T)?-A0?PF M /)7$ #> *-774** 60// 7)AAP *4A0#-* 24#C#/0?07)/ 7#(*4Ym-4(74*F

MT#(2 B-A#C4)( C#/0?070)(* 64 7)((#? 14/C (#?070(2 ) 7/4)A )*PTT4?AP 0(?14 C4A74C?0#( #> 7-AA4(? ?1A4)?* ?1)? D+T ?)/$0(2 ).#-?H )(G -(G4A4*?0T)?0(2 ?14G)(24A* 7#T0(2 >A#T =-**0)H .#?1 ?1A#-21 )7?0#(* 0( f$A)0(4H .-? )/*# 0( QPA0)FL#A4#I4AH *#T4 C#/0?07)/ >#A74* 0( B-A#C4 )A4 A4)GP ?# 0(I0?4 =-**0) ?# *#/I4CA#./4T* 0( #-A (4021.#-A1##GH 610/4 0? 0* /)A24/P ?14 *#-A74 #> ?14*4 G0*)*?4A*FD? 0* /0$4 0(I0?0(2 ?14 >#i 0(?# ?14 14(1#-*4F

D> 64 64A4 ?# A46A0?4 ?14 2/#.)/ *?A)?42P #> >#A402( C#/07P *47-A0?P #> ?14B-A#C4)( f(0#( ?#G)PH 64 6#-/G 1)I4 ?# C)P ) /0??/4 /4** )??4(?0#( ?# ?14 2/#.)/A#/4 #> ?14 Bf )(G ) /0??/4 T#A4 ?# 61)? 0* G4)A ?# -* h ?1)? 0* ?14 A#/4 #> ?14 Bf

XZ

0( 0?* 0TT4G0)?4 (4021.#-A1##GF K47)-*4 )2)0(H -(?0/ ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( 1)*(#? T)*?4A4G ?14 7A0*0* 0( ?14 (4021.#-A1##GH 0? 60// (#? C/)P ) 2/#.)/ A#/4FM A4*C#(*4 ?# ?14 (44G >#A ) *?A#(2 B-A#C4 *1#-/G .4 /##$4G >#A 0( *#/0G)A0?P)(G A4*C#(*0.0/0?PH ?1)? 0* 0( 61)? 64H B-A#C4)( @1A0*?0)( R4T#7A)?*H 0(7/-G4G0( ?14 ?A4)?04* )* .)*07 I)/-4*H .-? 61)? *?0// C#*4* CA#./4T* >#A -* 0( ?14 A4)/T#> CA)7?074F

c#A402( C#/07P .420(* )? 1#T4F <14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( ?#A( .P 7A0*4* 60// (#?.4 )./4 ?# C-A*-4 ) *?A#(2 >#A402( C#/07P .-0/? #( I)/-4*H #A ) *?A#(2 *47-A0?PHG4>4(74 #A 4(4A2P *47-A0?P C#/07PF M* /#(2 )* ?14 B-A#C4)( 47#(#TP G#4* (#?A42)0( I02#-A 0? 60// (#? .4 )./4 ?# 7#C4 60?1 ?14 7A0*0*j 64 60// (#? .4 )./4 ?#?)/$ ).#-? ) *?A#(2 Bf >#A402( C#/07PF M(G 0> 0? 0* (#? *?A#(2 )(G *#I4A402(H 0?60// (#? .4 )./4 ?# A4*C#(G 4>>47?0I4/P ?# 7A0*4*F <1-* ?14 Bf ?14 G#4* (#? 1)(G/40?*4/> 0( ?14 *4(*4 #> ?14 C#/0?07)/ *P*?4T #A 0( ?14 *4(*4 #> ?14 47#(#T07 #AT02A)?0#( 7A0*0* 60// 7#(?0(-4 ?# 60?(4** ?14 7/)*1 #> ?14*4 ?6# C#/0?07)/ G0T4(Y*0#(* #> B-A#C4)( )7?0I0?04* )(G )T.0?0#(*J 4i?4A()/ )(G 0(?4A()/H ?# ?14 G4?A0YT4(? #> ?14 >#AT4AF "4 )A4 64)$ #( ?14 #-?*0G4 .47)-*4 64 )A4 *?0// (#? *?A#(24(#-21 0(*0G4F M(G 64 /)7$ A4)/ *#/0G)A0?PF

<14 >0A*? ?4*? #> B-A#C4)( *#/0G)A0?P ?#G)P 0* *#/0G)A0?P 0( ?14 >04/G #> 4(4A2PHA4>/47?0(2 #( 24#C#/0?07)/ *#/-?0#(*F <10* 4/4T4(?)AP C#/0?07)/ *#/0G)A0?P 0* ?1A4)?Y4(4G )2)0( ?#G)PF <14 C/)((4G 7#(*?A-7?0#( #> ?14 *47#(G /0(4 #> ?14 U#AG Q?A4)TC0C4/0(4H ?14 *#Y7)//4G U#AG Q?A4)T DDH -(G4AT0(4* ?14 4**4(74 #> ?14 B(4A2Pf(0#( )(G 0* )( 4i)TC/4 #> ./)?)(? G0*/#P)/?P ?# ?14 0(?4A4*?* #> B-A#C4)( .-*0Y(4** )(G ?14 )2A44G 24#C#/0?07)/ #.N47?0I4* #> B-A#C4F

M ?4*? #> *#/0G)A0?P 0* )/*# -(G#-.?4G/P ) ?A-4 @#TT#( Q47-A0?P )(G R4Y>4(74 ,#/07PH 61071 A4m-0A4* ?14 T0/0?)AP >#A 0?* 0TC/4T4(?)?0#(F L4)(610/4H?14 A4G-7?0#( #> T0/0?)AP 4iC4(G0?-A4 1)* ?)$4( C/)74 0( B-A#C4 *0(74 :VXVF <10*T)$4* B-A#C4 ) !*?#6)6)P A0G4A+ A4/P0(2 #( ?14 T0/0?)AP C#?4(?0)/ #> ?14 f(0?4GQ?)?4*F M* T-71 )* W9| #> UM<_ 7)C).0/0?04* 0( ?4AT* #> 4iC4(G0?-A4 0* .)*4G#( ?14 fFQF C#?4(?0)/H 61071 T4)(* ?1)?H 4I4( 0> ?14 B-A#C4)(* *1#64G ?14 60//H?14P 6#-/G (#? .4 0( ) C#*0?0#( ?# G4>4(G ?14T*4/I4* )2)0(*? 4i?4A()/ ?1A4)?*F<14A4>#A4H 0? 0* (474**)AP ?# 1)I4 0(*?A-T4(?* ?1)? A46)AG 0(I4*?T4(?*H *47-A0?P)(G 0(7A4)*4G >-(G0(2F LP CA#C#*)/ (#? ?# C-(0*1 )( 0(7A4)*4 0( G4>4(74 *C4(GY0(2 ?# ?14 )2A44G N#0(? UM<_Y8 C4A74(?)24 #> 5R, 0* (#? P4? -(G4A*?##G )T#(2B-A#C4)( C#/0?070)(*F <14A4 0* (# #A2)(0O4G B-A#C4)( )ATPj 64 G# (#? 1)I4 ?14(474**)AP 7#TT#( .#AG4A 2-)AGH B)*?4A( B-A#C4 0* (#? *->>0704(?/P CA#?47?4G>A#T 4i?4A()/ ?1A4)?* .47)-*4 ?14A4 0* (# 7#(*4(*-* #( T#I0(2 UM<_ >#A74*)(G .)*4* 4)*? )(G ?14A4 0* (# >-(7?0#(0(2 B-A#C4)( MA?07/4 kH ?14 4m-0I)/4(? #>?14 UM<_ <A4)?PH (#A ?14 T-*$4?44A*+ CA0(70C/4 !M// >#A #(4H #(4 >#A )//+F <14A4)A4 )/*# (# )G4m-)?4 7#(?0(24(7P C/)(*H #A )7?0#( C/)(* 0( ?14 4I4(? #> )22A4*Y

X\

*0#(F K-? ?14A4 )A4 )/*# C#*0?0I4 )*C47?* #> ?14 7-AA4(? 24#C#/0?07)/ *0?-)?0#(F<10* A4)/0*?07 )**4**T4(? #> B-A#C4)( >#A74* T4)(* ?1)? (# #(4 0( B-A#C4 ?#G)P71)//4(24* ?14 CA0T)7P #> UM<_ )(G ?14 7#TC/4T4(?)AP A#/4 #> ?14 *47-A0?P)(G G4>4(74 C#/07P #> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(F

K-? ?14A4 0* 1#C4 0( )// #> ?10*F <14 BfH 60?1 )// #> ?14 )77-T-/)?4G 7A0*4* 0*)( )??A)7?0I4 T#G4/ #> 70I0/0O)?0#(H )* 4I0G4(74G .P ?14 T02A)?0#( CA4**-A4F <14I4AP #C?0T0*?07 A4I#/-?0#( #> G02(0?P 0( L)NG)( CA#I4* 1#6 T)(P *#704?04* 0(?14 4)*? *44$ )(G A4I4)/ )*C0A)?0#(* #> ?14 B-A#C4)( T#G4/ )(G B-A#C4)( I)/Y-4*F <14P )A4 )/*# )??A)7?0I4 ?# ?1#*4 7#T0(2 ?# B-A#C4 >A#T A4>-244 7)TC* 0(?14 L0GG/4 B)*?F <10* )??A)7?0I4(4** 0* )/*#H ?1#-21 D+T )>A)0G ?1)? 0( ?14 I4APG0*?)(? >-?-A4H ) 1#C4 ?1)? 64 60// .4 *#T4G)P )./4 ?# 7#(?0(-4 #-A T0**0#(H )/*#0( 7##C4A)?0#( 60?1 =-**0)H .-? ?1)? #?14A =-**0) h ?14 #(4 #> ?14 ,#/0?$#I*$)P))(G U4T?*#I+* L4T#A0)/H (#? ,-?0(+* =-**0)F

<14 T)2(4? ?1)? 7)-*4G ?14 >0A4.A)(G #> P#-(2 C4#C/4 0( f$A)0(0)( L)NG)(6)* ) *44T0(2/P I4AP ?A0I0)/ ?10(2J ) >A44 ?A)G4 O#(4 h )( )i0* )(G ?14 T)0( C)A?#> ?14 BfYf$A)0(4 M**#70)?0#( M2A44T4(?F <14A4>#A4H B-A#C4)( 0(?42A)?0#(H?14 #(4 .-0/? 0( ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( >#A #I4A ;9 P4)A*H 7)( .4 ) T)2(4? >#A #-AC)A?(4A* .#?1 >A#T ?14 4)*? )(G >A#T ?14 *#-?1F D> 64 )A4 )./4 ?# CA4*4(? ?10*#>>4A )??A)7?0I4/PH )(G 7)-*4 ?1)? *?).0/0?P )77#TC)(04* ?10*H 0? 7)( .A0(2 C#*0?0I471)(24*F K-? ?14A4 0* *?0// T-71 ?# .4 G#(4 0( ?10* )A4)F

D> 64 /##$ )? #-A (4021.#-A1##GH 64 *44H )T#(2 #?14A*H ?14 *?A#(2 CA4*4(74)(G )7?0I0?P #> =-**0)( ?A##C* 0( QPA0)F D? 0* 1)AG ?# .4 *)?0*>04G 60?1 ?10* *?)?4 #>)>>)0A*H )(G 4I4( T#A4 *# >A#T ?14 >)7? ?1)? ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( 0* ) 2A4)? ).Y*4(?44 0( ?10* *0?-)?0#(F

M *?A#(2 Bf 0* (44G4G >#A #-A C)A?(4A*H 4*C470)//P >#A ?14 f(0?4G Q?)?4*H )(G0* ) CA4A4m-0*0?4 >#A ?14 *47-A0?P )(G CA#*C4A0?P ?14 Bf 0?*4/>F

Q0(74 899XH ?14 ?A)(*>#AT)?0#( #> ?14 0(?4A()?0#()/ #AG4A 1)* .44( .#-(G ?#)( -(#A2)(0O4G T-/?0YC#/)A0?PF _.)T)+* MT4A07) ?-A(* ?# ?14 ,)70>07H B-A#C4 0*.-*P 60?1 0?*4/>H ?14 47#(#TP )(G 4T4A20(2 7#-(?A04* o4*C470)//P ?14 K=D@Q2A#-C h @10()H =-**0)H KA)O0/H D(G0) )(G Q#-?1 M>A07)p )A4 7#(?4*?0(2 0(?4A()Y?0#()/ #AG4AH ?14 )i0* #> 61071 0* ?14 f(0?4G U)?0#(*H ?14 "#A/G K)($ )(G ?14D(?4A()?0#()/ L#(4?)AP c-(GF Q/#6/P 64 )A4 /#*0(2 ?14 ).0/0?P ?# *1)C4 0(?4A()Y?0#()/ A4/)?0#(*H ?# *1)C4 ?14 2/#.)/ 47#(#T07 A-/4* o)/?1#-21 ?14 G470*0#( 60//.4 T)G4 14A4 #( ?14 #77)*0#( #> ?14 <<D, )2A44T4(?p )(G >0()//P ?14 G4>4(74 #>>-(G)T4(?)/ I)/-4*H 1-T)( A021?* )(G 0(?4A()?0#()/ /)6F

D( ?14 7#(?4i? #> 2/#.)/ 47#(#T07 A-/4*H ?#24?14A 60?1 ?14 f(0?4G Q?)?4* 64)A4 14)G0(2 ?#6)AG* 7A4)?0(2 *#T4?10(2 64 7)//H )(G 61)? *#T4 7#TT4(?)?#A*G# (#? /0$4H !47#(#T07 UM<_+F D T4)( ) ?A)G4 )(G 0(I4*?T4(? C)A?(4A*10C .4Y?644( ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( )(G ?14 f(0?4G Q?)?4*F <10* 0* #(4 #> ?14 4/4T4(?* #>

X[

0TC/4T4(?)?0#( .P ?14 Bf #> 0?* C4)74$44C0(2 T0**0#( )(G #>>4A0(2 70?0O4(*C4)74 )(G CA#*C4A0?PH )/*# C4)74 0( ?14 Bf+* *-AA#-(G0(2*H 0( #AG4A ?# 1)I4*#T4?10(2 64 1)I4 GA4)T4G #> )A#-(G -* h ) 70A7/4 #> >A04(G* 0( ) A4/)?0#(*10C60?1 -* )(G 0( ) T-?-)/ A4/)?0#(*10CH >A#T L#A#77# ?# K4/)A-*F

D> 64 *#A? #-? #-A )>>)0A* )(G 4m-0C #-A*4/I4* 60?1 ?14 A021? 0(*?A-T4(?*H 641)I4 ?14 )T.0?0#( C#**0./4 ?# )77#TC/0*1 ?10*F D? ?)$4* ) 2/#.)/ 7#TT0?T4(? ?#C)A?(4A* *-71 )* @10() )(G D(G0)H )* D T4(?0#(4GF <14A4 0* ) (44G ?# ?AP ?# CA4YI4(? ?14 2A4)? G4T#7A)704*H *-71 )* D(G0) )(G KA)O0/H >A#T *?)(G0(2 )2)0(*? ?14G4T#7A)?07 ?A)(*)?/)(?07 6#A/G #( #(4 *0G4 60?1 )-?1#A0?)A0)( *?)?4* h =-**0))(G @10()F

<14 Bf 1)* .47#T4 ) I07?0T #> 0?* #6( *-774** ?# *#T4 4i?4(? h #> 61)? 0?*-7744G4G 0(F "4 (44G ) >)AY*021?4G >#A402( C#/07P >#A ?14 *)$4 #> #-A I)/-4*)(G 0(?4A4*?*j .4*0G4*H 0( ?14 /#(2 C4A*C47?0I4H 0(?4A4*?* )(G I)/-4* .47#T4 0G4(Y?07)/F K-? D A4C4)?H 0( #AG4A ?# G# *#H 64 T-*? 1)I4 ?14 ).0/0?P ?# G# 61)? ?14G#7?A0(4 #> 0(?4A()?0#()/ *47-A0?P C#/07P 7)//4G 7#(?)0(T4(? )(G G4?4AA4(74H .4Y7)-*4 ?14 4I0/ )A#-(G -* (44G* ?# .4 CA4I4(?4G )(G G4?4AA4GF D()7?0#( ?1A4)?4(*?14 C4)74H )* 64// )* ()?0#()/ 42#*F D> ?#G)P ?14A4 )A4 7#-(?A04* ?1)? )A4 7#(*0GY4A0(2 /4)I0(2 ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(H A021?/P #A (#?H ?1)? T4)(* ?1)? *#T4614A4 0(?14 B-A#C4)( G0*7#-A*4 64 T)G4 ) T0*?)$4F D> ?#G)P 64 )A4 7#(>A#(?4G 60?1 ?14CA4YT#G4A( =-**0)( A4)/0?PH 64 7)((#? /4)G 60?1 #(/P ) C#*?YT#G4A( >#A402(C#/07PF R)(24A*l ,#/)(G $(#6* *#T4?10(2 ).#-? ?1)?F _(74 64 64A4 ) G4T#7YA)7P *-AA#-(G4G .P ).*#/-?4 T#()A7104*H 61071 ?##$ C)A?0?0#(* #> #-A 7#-(?APH.47)-*4 0( ?4AT* #> ?14 C#/0?07)/ *P*?4T* )(G I)/-4* CA)7?074G 0( C-./07 /0>4 6464A4 24??0(2 )14)G #> ?14 ?0T4*F D( ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(H 614( 0? 7#T4* ?# ?14*47-A0?P )(G G4>4(74 G#7?A0(4H 64 0( ) *4(*4 1)I4 ?# 2# .)7$ ?# CA4YT#G4A(?0T4F "4 *?)(G .4>#A4 ?AP0(2 )2)0(F c#A P4)A* ?14 >#A402( )(G *47-A0?P C#/07P #>?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( 6)* 02(#A4GH -(G4AI)/-4G )(G -(G4AYA4*#-A74GF M(G 60?1Y#-? 0? C4)74 )(G CA#*C4A0?P 7)((#? .4 )7104I4GF Q?0//H ?14 7#(G0?0#( 0* ?10* .)*07*#/0G)A0?PH 61071 1)* )/A4)GP .44( T4(?0#(4Gj ?1)? 0*H 0( ?14 /)(2-)24 #> ?14@1A0*?0)(*J !.4)A #(4 )(#?14A+* .-AG4(*+F 34/C #(4 )(#?14A ?# )7104I4 7#TT#(2#)/*F @1A0*?0)( G#7?A0(4 7/4)A/P G4>0(4* ?14*4 #.N47?0I4* )* ?14 CA0(70C/4 #>*-.*0G0)A0?PJq?10* 7#TT#( 2##G )? G0>>4A4(? /4I4/*F

K-? 7)( P#- CA)7?074 *#/0G)A0?PH 0> ?10* *#/0G)A0?PH 64)A0(2 T-?-)/ .-AG4(*H 0*G0I0G4G 0(?# C)A?*H 0> ?10* 0* ) *4/47?0I4 *#/0G)A0?Pl Q#/0G)A0?P 0* 0(G0I0*0./4j 0?T-*? .4 7#TCA414(*0I4F _?14A60*4H 0? G#4* (#? 4i0*? )? )//F D ?10($ ?1)? 0( ?#YG)P+* G4.)?4 )(G ?14 B-A#C4)( CA)7?074H 64 )A4 6)(G4A0(2H *4/47?0I4/P ?10($0(2).#-? *#/0G)A0?P )(G /4)G0(2 ?# 7#(?A)G07?0#(*F

X;

34A4 )A4 N-*? ) >46 4i)TC/4*J:F D( ?14 )A4) #> *)>4?PJ! *)>4?P )(G G4>4(74 )* ) G47/)A4G 2#)/ h P4*j 0(7-AA0(2 4iC4(G0?-A4* #(

*47-A0?P )(G G4>4(74 h (#j! 4i)/?4G 6#AG* ).#-? *)>4?P h P4*j T0/0?)AP .)*4* #( ?14 4)*?4A( >/)($ #> ?14

B-A#C4)( f(0#(H 61071 6#-/G 20I4 ) *4(*4 #> *47-A0?P h (#j! *4(G0(2 ) @QR, T0**0#(H ?1)? 0* ) 7#TT#( >#A402( *)>4?P C#/07PH *?).0/0OY

0(2 T0/0?)AP T0**0#(* ?# ?14 *#-?1 #> M>A07) h P4*j *4(G0(2 T0**0#(* ?# ?144)*?H ?# 2-)AG ?14 f$A)0(0)( .#AG4A 0( R#(.)* h (#j

! ?14 CA#?47?0#( #> "4*?4A( B-A#C4 60?1 ) T0**0/4 *104/G h P4*j ?14 CA#?47Y?0#( #> ?14 B)*?4A( >/)($ #> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( h (#j

! T0/0?)AP .)*4* 0( "4*?4A( B-A#C4H 61071 >44/* A4/)?0I4/P *)>4A h P4*j .-?0( ,#/)(GH Q/#I)$0)H =#T)(0) )(G 0( ?14 K)/?07 *?)?4* h (#j

! *4//0(2 64)C#(* ?# ?14 )22A4**#AH =-**0) h P4*j *4//0(2 64)C#(* ?# ?14.4220(2 I07?0TH f$A)0(4 h (#j

8F D( A4/)?0#( ?# ?14 4)*?4A( )(G *#-?14A( (4021.#-A1##GJ! 0(?4A4*? 0( ?14 *0?-)?0#( #> `0.P) )(G QPA0) h P4*j 0(?4A4*? 0( ?14 *0?-)?0#(

0( ?14 4)*? #> B-A#C4 h (#H )(G >#A *-A4 ) /#? *T)//4AjZF D( A4/)?0#( ?# A4>-244*J! A4>-244* >A#T QPA0) h P4*j A4>-244* >A#T f$A)0(4 h (#j! *1)A0(2 ?14 .-AG4( #> )GT0??0(2 A4>-24* >A#T ?14 *#-?1 h P4*j >A#T ?14

4)*? h (#j! 0(?4A()/ C#/07P 0( A4/)?0#( ?# A4>-244*H #A A4/#7)?0#( h P4*j 7#TT#( )7Y

?0#(*H 0( #AG4A ?# CA4I4(? 0? )? ?14 *#-A74*H ?1)? 0* /0m-0G)?4 ?14 6)A 0( ?14*#-?1 )(G 4)*? h (#j

\F D( A4/)?0#( ?# 4(4A2PJ! 2)* 7##C4A)?0#( 60?1 =-**0) h P4*j N#0(? C-A71)*4* #> 2)* 0( ?14 4(4A2P

-(0#( h (#F

M(G 14A4 D 6#-/G /0$4 ?# 7#(7/-G4H *?A4**0(2 ?1)? ?14 #(/P )(*64A ?#G)P 0**#/0G)A0?P h 1#/0*?07H (#? *4/47?0I4F @)//* >#A *#/0G)A0?P )(G T#A)/ /4**#(* 60// (#?.4 7A4G0./4 )* /#(2 )* ?10* *#/0G)A0?P 0( 4(*-A0(2 C4)74 0( #-A (4021.#-A1##G 0*(#? 7#TC/4?4H )(G 7)AAP0(2 4)71 #?14A+* .-AG4(* 60// .4 *4/47?0I4F

L8>::;< #B?:" :56?6%+M

XW

%&'(# I'99' !-;;0C60'1,0,&1,% )* +", T+#6$#' 5#%6$#&,'+

D 6)* )*$4G ?# *)P ) >46 6#AG* ).#-? ?14 $4P 0**-4* ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( 0*>)70(2 ?#G)PF <10* 0* (#? G0>>07-/?F "4 $(#6 61)? #-A .0224*? 0**-4 ?#G)P 0* h()T4/P ?14 7A0*0* #> 0TT02A)(?*F 3#64I4AH ?10* >#A-T 0* )( #CC#A?-(0?P ?# ?)/$).#-? #?14A 0**-4*H .47)-*4 610/4 0? 0* 4iC47?4G ?1)? 64 6#-/G >#7-* #( ?10*0TC#A?)(? 0**-4 #> ?14 7A0*0*H ?14A4 )A4 #?14A CA#./4T* (44G0(2 )??4(?0#(F "4*1#-/G 4*?)./0*1 74A?)0( CA0(70C/4* #( 61071 #-A C#/0704* 60// .4 0TC/4T4(?4GF,#/0704* T-*? #A020()?4 T)0(/P >A#T 7/4)A CA0(70C/4*F <14 >0A*? 0**-4 D 60*1 ?#A)0*4 0* ?1)? 64 7)((#? /4? C4#C/4 G04 h ?14A4 )A4 1-(GA4G* #> ?1#-*)(G* #> C4#C/461# )A4 ?AP0(2 ?# .A4)$ ?1A#-21 ?14 L4G0?4AA)(4)( Q4)F U#? 4I4AP#(4 0* )./4 ?#A4)71 ?14 *1#A4F <14*4 )A4H )>?4A )//H A4>-244* 61# ?AP ?# 24? 0(?# B-A#C4H >#A >4)A>#A ?140A /0I4*H )(G P4? ?10* 0* ?14 .)*07 CA0(70C/4H ?14 .)*07 I)/-4F

c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l D? 7)(+? 4(G 14A4F D> 64 G# (#? 1)I4 ) C#/07PH 64 60// (#? .4 )./4 0TC/4T4(?0? 0( ?14 *1#A? ?4ATF D( ?1)? 7)*4H 0? 6#(+? .4 >#-A T0//0#( 7#T0(2 ?# -*H .-?\9 T0//0#( 60// ?AP ?# 24? ?# B-A#C4F <10* 0* *-71 ) C#64A>-/ 71)//4(24j *# 2A4)?0* ?14 *7)/4 #> ?10* CA#./4TF

Q# 61)? 7)( 64 G#l c0A*?/PH D A4C4)? #(74 )2)0(J 64 7)((#? )//#6 ?14 L4G0Y?4AA)(4)( ?# .47#T4 ?140A ?#T.F "4 7)((#? )//#6 >#A C4#C/4 ?# G04 )? *4)j 641)I4 ?# *)I4 ?14T >A#T ?14*4 /0??/4 *0($0(2 .#)?*F "4 7)((#? /4? ?14T G04 #>1-(24AF "4 7)((#? )//#6 >#A C4#C/4 ?# >)// >A#T 4i1)-*?0#( )? #-A .#AG4A*F "41)I4 ?# /4? ?14T 0(F c#A T4 0? 0* 7#TC/4?4/P #.I0#-*F "4 (44G ?# /4? ?14T 0(?#B-A#C4 h ?10* 0* ?14 >0A*? ?10(2F M(G ?14 *47#(G ?10(2 h 64 (44G ?# T)$4 *#T4G0*?0(7?0#(F Q#T4 C4#C/4 )A4 )*P/-TY*44$4A*F D 1)I4 ) C4A*#()/ >A04(G*10C 60?1fT.4A?# K#**0H 61# 0* ?14 /4)G4A #> #(4 #> ?14 T#*? >)T#-* C#C-/0*? >)7?0#(* 0(D?)/PF ,#/0?07)//PH #> 7#-A*4H 64 *C4)$ 60?1 G0>>4A4(? I#074*H .-? 14 0* TP >A04(GFM(G 14 *)P*H P4*H 64 60// )774C? ?14TH )(G ?14( *4(G ?14T .)7$F _> 7#-A*4 6460// (#? /4? ?14T G04 )? *4)H .-? 614( ?14P 7#T4 ?# -*H 64 60// *4(G ?14T .)7$F

XX

M(G D *)P ?10*J A021?H D )2A44 60?1 P#-F ̀ 4?+* G# *#F ̀ 4?+* *4(G ?14T 1#T4F e#-+A4A021?F K-? 1#6 G# 64 G# ?10*H *0(74 ?14P (# /#(24A 1)I4 ) 1#T4l <# *4(G *#T4Y#(4 1#T4H ?14A4 1)* ?# .4 ) 1#T4F D? T-*? C1P*07)//P 4i0*?F K-? 14A4 64 )A4 )//C)A? #> ) 1-T)( ()?0#(F BI4AP#(4 T-*? 1)I4 ?10* C)A? ?# 61071 #(4 A4?-A(*F _(4T-*? 1)I4 ?10* C0474H ?10* C)A? #> /)(G -(G4A>##?F M(G 61)? 1)CC4(* 614( *#T4Y#(4 /#*4* ?10* 1#T4l D> 2#0(2 .)7$ 1#T4 T4)(* C4A*47-?0#( #A 4I4( ?14 G4)?1C4()/?PH 0> 0? T4)(* ?1)? *#T4#(4 60// 2# 0TT4G0)?4/P 0(?# 7-*?#GP )(G 0(?#CA0*#(H ?1)? 710/GA4( 60// (#? .4 )./4 ?# #.?)0( 70I0/ A021?*H 61)? 7)( 64 *)P ?#*-71 C4#C/4H 1#6 7)( 64 *4(G ?14T .)7$ 1#T4l @)( 64 ?4// ?14T !2# .)7$+l D*?10* #-A A4*C#(*4l "1)? G# 64 *)P ?# @1A0*?0)(*l

<14A4 )A4 T)(P C4#C/4 61# )A4 )2)0(*? ?10* 2A4)? 6)I4 #> 0TT02A)?0#(H .4Y7)-*4 ?14P )A4 )>A)0G #> ?14 D*/)T0*)?0#( #> B-A#C4F M(G D 1)I4 ?# 7#(I4P ?#?14*4 C4#C/4 *#T4 *-ACA0*0(2 (46*F <14A4 0* (# G)(24A #> ?14 D*/)T0*)?0#( #>B-A#C4H .47)-*4 T#*? #> ?14*4 C4#C/4 )A4 @1A0*?0)(*F <1#*4 61#H >#A 4i)TC/4H7)T4 ?# D?)/P )A4 @1A0*?0)(*F D G# (#? $(#6 ?14 *?)?0*?07* #> ?14 K)/$)( 7#-(?A04*)(G 54AT)(PH .-? D $(#6 ?14 *?)?0*?07* 0( D?)/PJ ).#-? 1)/> #> ?14T )A4 @1A0*Y?0)(*F "1Pl K47)-*4 ?14 C4A*47-?4G T0(#A0?P )A4 T)0(/P @1A0*?0)(*F M(G ?14*)T4 *?#AP 0* 0( Q-G)(F D 7#-/G )7?-)//P )/6)P* .A0(2 *0T0/)A )A2-T4(?*H T4(Y?0#(0(2 #?14A 7#-(?A04*H T)0(/P 0( M>A07) )(G 0( ?14 L0GG/4 B)*? 614A4 @1A0*Y?0)(* )A4 C4A*47-?4G 7#(*?)(?/PH *# *1#-/G 64 *4(G ?14T .)7$l U#H .47)-*4 ?14P(# /#(24A 1)I4 ) 1#T4F <14P 1)I4 (# 1#T4 ?# 2# .)7$ ?#F

"4 (44G ?# 0(?42A)?4 ?14T 0(?# #-A *#704?PF K-? #> 7#-A*4H )T#(2 ?14T ?14A4)A4 T)(P #?14A C4#C/4 61# )A4 (#? A4>-244*F <14*4 )A4 0//42)/ 0TT02A)(?* )(G?1#*4 64 1)I4 ?14 A021? ?# *4(G 1#T4F K-? 0( #AG4A ?# *4(G ?14T .)7$ 1#T4H 64(44G ?# 7#T4 ?# *#T4 )2A44T4(? 60?1 ?14 7#-(?AP #> #A020(H 64 T-*? $(#6614A4 ?14*4 C4#C/4 7#T4 >A#TF M(G ?14*4 7#-(?A04* 60// )*$ -* >#A *#T4 )*Y*0*?)(74F <14P 60// )*$ -* m-4*?0#(*F "1)? 60// ?14P )*$ P#- >#Al ,A#.)./PT#*? #> ?14T >0A*? #> )// 60// A4m-4*? -* ?# 2-)A)(?44 4TC/#PT4(? >#A ?14*4C4#C/4F M(G ?10* 0* G0>>07-/?F "4 $(#6 >#A 4i)TC/4 ?1)? 0( T)(P B-A#C4)(7#-(?A04* 64 1)I4 ) I4AP /#6 .0A?1 A)?4 *# ()?-A)//P 64 *1#-/G ?AP ?# 71)(24?1)? ?1A#-21 /42)/ 0TT02A)?0#(F "4 )A4 ?14 #(4* 61# (44G ?14 0(>/-i #> C4#YC/4F _> 7#-A*4H 64 *1#-/G .4 )./4 ?# T)$4 ?1#*4 71#074*F `4? -* )774C? ?14C4#C/4 61# 6)(? ?# 0(?42A)?4 60?1 -*H 61# 60// 6)(? ?# 6#A$ >#A #-A 7#-(?AP)(G 6#-/G /0$4 ?# 0(?42A)?4 0(?# #-A *#704?PF "4 6)(? ?# 64/7#T4 C4#C/4 61#6#-/G /0$4 ?# *0TC/P .47#T4 #-A .A#?14A* )(G *0*?4A*F D? *44T* ?# T4 ?1)? .4Y7)-*4 #> ?10* 64 1)I4 ?14 A021? ?# 0TC/4T4(? ?10* G470*0#(F Q#T4 60// 0(?42A)?4.4??4AH #?14A* 6#A*4F

R# P#- $(#6 61# eI4* L#(?)(G 0*l ,4A1)C* *#T4 #> P#- 61# )A4 #/G4AH4*C470)//P /)G04* T)P $(#6 ?10* cA4(71 *0(24AF K-? P#- T)P (#? $(#6 ?1)? eI4*

XV

L#(?)(G 6)* (#? cA4(71F 34 6)* D?)/0)(H )(G )>?4A *# T)(P P4)A*H )* 0? ?-A(*#-?H )( D?)/0)( 7)( .47#T4 ) cA4(71T)(H *0(20(2 >#A #I4A Z9YC/-* P4)A* 0( cA4(71F"1Pl K47)-*4 ?14*4 7#-(?A04* 7/#*4/P 7##C4A)?4 60?1 4)71 #?14AF _.I0#-*/PHD 6)(? ?# .4 C#/0?07)//P 7#AA47?F M* P#- $(#6H D C)0G ) I4AP 1021 CA074 >#A (#?.40(2 C#/0?07)//P 7#AA47? )? *#T4 C#0(?F Q# T)P.4 /4? T4 *)P ?10* 0(*?4)GJ cA)(74)(G D?)/P )A4 7#-(?A04* 7#((47?4G ?1A#-21 ) .A#?14A1##G #> 7#TT#( @1A0*?0)(?A)G0?0#(F Q#H 0> eI4* L#(?)(G .47)T4 ) cA4(71T)(H C4A1)C* )>?4A :9 P4)A*#?14A* 60// .4 )./4 ?# .47#T4 D?)/0)(*H ,#/4* #A cA4(71F

R#4* )(P#(4 $(#6 L#(07) 5AP204/l Q14 0* #(4 1-(GA4G C4A74(? )( D?)/0)(6#T)(H )(G )? ?14 *)T4 ?0T4 #(4 1-(GA4G C4A74(? ) ,#/4j .47)-*4 ?14*4 )A4 ?147-/?-A4* ?1)? T4A24 ?#24?14AF <14P )A4 I4AP 7/#*4F _> 7#-A*4H 614( 7-/?-A4* )A4) /0??/4 >-A?14A )C)A?H 0? 0* A4/)?0I4/P G0>>07-/?F D+T (#? *)P0(2 ?10* 0* 6A#(2F D *)P?1)? *0TC/P 0? 0* ?14 ?A-?1j ?10* 0* ?14 A4)/0?PF "4 1)I4 ?# 7#(G-7? *-71 )( 0TT0Y2A)?0#( C#/07P 0( B-A#C4 ?1)? 60// )//#6 -* ?# .-0/G ) T-/?07-/?-A)/ *#704?PH $(#6Y0(2 #> 7#-A*4 ?1)? ) T-/?07-/?-A)/ *#704?P 0* /0$4 T)AA0)24J 0? 0* (474**)AP ?1)??6# *-0?)./4 C4#C/4 T44? 1)/>6)PH ?14( T)AA0)24 7)( .4 /0$4 ) C)A)G0*4F D>H 1#6Y4I4AH 64 N#0( 0( T)?A0T#(P C4#C/4 61# )A4 (#? 7#TC)?0./4 60?1 4)71 #?14AH 61#)A4 (#? )./4 ?# .-0/G )(P?10(2 ?#24?14AH ?14( C)A)G0*4 0* -(/0$4/PF Q# 61)? $0(G#> T-/?07-/?-A)/ *#704?P G# 64 6)(? ?# .-0/Gl c0A*? #> )//H 64 1)I4 ?# 1)I4 ?14A021? C#/0704*H C#/0704* )? ?14 B-A#C4)( /4I4/H .47)-*4 0? 0* G0>>07-/? ?# 0T)20(4?1)? 8X G0>>4A4(? B-A#C4)( 7#-(?A04* 7)( 4)71 7A4)?4 ?140A #6( C#/0704* #( 1#6?14P 7)( .47#T4 ) T-/?07-/?-A)/ *#704?PF U#H ) 7#TT#( )CCA#)71 0* (474**)APH)* 64// )*H >#A 4i)TC/4H 7#TT#( /)6 #( 1#6 ?# CA#I0G4 )*P/-TH 7#TT#( A-/4*?# )CC/P >#A )*P/-TH )(G (#? N-*? G470G0(2 #( 1#6 ?# G0I0G4 0TT02A)(?* 0(?#0(G0I0G-)/ 7#-(?A04*H 1#6 ?# )**02( ?14TF "4 T-*? 1)I4 7#TT#( A-/4*H )* 64//)* N#0(?/P G470G4 61#T 64 A4N47?H 61# T-*? 2# .)7$F

D* 0? 4(#-21l R#4* ?10* T-71 A4*C#(*0.0/0?P A4*? #( -* @1A0*?0)(*l "1)? G#64 G# 60?1 ?1#*4 61#T 64 G# (#? 6)(? 60?1 -*l <1#*4 61# 60// (#? 1)I4 ?14A021? ?# 4(?4A 0(?# B-A#C4 )* A4>-244* 1)I4 )/A4)GP /4>? ?140A 1#T4/)(G )(P6)PF<14*4 )A4 )7?-)//P I4AP C##A C4#C/4H 61# )A4 /##$0(2 >#A #CC#A?-(0?04* >#A ) .4??4A/0>4H #>?4( /0I0(2 0( 7#(G0?0#(* ?1)? )A4 .4/#6 1-T)( G02(0?PF U#? .47)-*4 #>C#/0?07)/ C4A*47-?0#(H .-? *0TC/P .47)-*4 #> 7A-4/ )(G *P*?4T07 C#I4A?PF M(G61)? 7)( 64 *)P ?# *-71 C4#C/4 )* @1A0*?0)(*l D ?10($ ?1)? 64 60// ?4// ?14T ?10*J64 6)(? >#A P#- ?# .4 0( P#-A #6( 1#T4F "4 60// )**0*? P#- ?14A4F "4 7)( 14/CP#-F _(74H 614( B-A#C4 6)* N-*? ) GA4)TH #(/P ) CA#N47?H 64 1)G ?14 B-A#YL4G0?4AA)(4)( ,)A?(4A*10C h Q)AP-*OH P#- CA#.)./P A4T4T.4A h )(G ?14( .42)(?14 CA#74** #> K)A74/#()F f(>#A?-()?4/PH ?10* L4G0?4AA)(4)( C)A?(4A*10C 1)* (#?6#A$4G #-?F <14A4 6)* ) /)7$ #> C#/0?07)/ 60// )(G )>?4A *#T4 ?0T4 64 (# /#(24AG4C4(G4G #( 0?F

V9

<14A4 64A4 C/)(* 614( D 6)* 7#(*0G4A4G )* ?14 G4C-?P 71)0AT)( #> ?14 B-YA#C4)( @#TT0**0#( )(G ?14*4 64A4 CA470*4/P ?14*4 0**-4* ?1)? D 6)(?4G ?# ?)/$).#-?H .-? #?14A 7#//4)2-4* 71#*4 ?# >#7-* #( #?14A 0**-4*F D? 6)* *# #.I0#-*?14(H :9 P4)A* )2#H ?1)? ?14 4i0*?0(2 C#/0?07)/ *?A-7?-A4* 0( U#A?1 M>A07) 60// (#?7#(?0(-4 )(G ?1)? ?10* *0?-)?0#( 7)((#? 7#(?0(-4 )(G ?1)? 64 (44G (46 0G4)*FM(G 61)? )A4 ?14*4 (46 0G4)*l c#A 4i)TC/4H ) 7#TT#( T)A$4? 0( 7#-(?A04* 0(U#A?1 MT4A07)H /0$4 L)21A4.H )(G T)P.4 4I4( L)*1A4mH .-? *-A4/P 0? 60// .4) /0??/4 G0>>07-/? ?14A4j .-? )? /4)*? 0( L)21A4.F <1-*H ) 7#TT#( T)A$4?H 7#TYT#( A-/4* 0( )// ?14 7#-(?A04* #> U#A?1 M>A07) .47)-*4 64 $(#6 ?1)? ?140A 5R,0* 7#TC)A)./4 ?# ?14 5R, #> ) *T)// 7#-(?AP /0$4 K4/20-TF "1# 60// T)$40(I4*?T4(?* ?14A4H 61# 60// .4 ?14A4 ?# 7A4)?4 N#.*H $(#60(2 ?1)? ?10* 0* ) *T)//T)A$4? )(G 0* G0I0G4G )T#(2 >#-AH >0I4 #A *0i *T)//4A 7#-(?A04*l "1# 60// .4?14A4 ?# 0(I4*?l e4? 0(I4*?T4(?* )A4 (44G4GH .-0/G0(2 0(>A)*?A-7?-A4 0* (44G4GF D?0* 0TC#**0./4 ?# .-0/G ) 7#TT#( T)A$4? 60?1 (# 10216)P*H (# A)0/6)P*H )0AYC#A?* )(G *# #(F Q# /4?+* 7A4)?4 0(I4*?T4(? 7#(G0?0#(* ?14A4F <14 f(0?4G BT0AY)?4* h ?14 T)** #> T#(4PF Q)-G0 MA).0) ?##F `0.P) 0* )./4 ?# 24(4A)?4 1-240(I4*?T4(?* ?1A#-21 ?14 *)/4 #> #0/F M(G 64 0( ?-A( 1)I4 ?471(#/#207)/ 7)C).0/Y0?04*F Q# P4*J *#T4 C)A?(4A* 1)I4 T#(4PH #?14A* )A4 60//0(2 ?# 6#A$ ?14A4F Q#/4?+* 7A4)?4 7#(G0?0#(* >#A ?14 G4I4/#CT4(? #> ?14 7#TT#( T)A$4? )(G ?14 64/Y>)A4 *?)?4F <10* 0* ?14 #(/P 6)P ?1)? 64 60// .4 )./4 ?# *?#C ?10* 6)I4 #> A4>-244*F"4 *1#-/G 1)I4 G#(4 ?10* :9 P4)A* )2#H .-? 64 G0G (#?F

_> 7#-A*4H (#6 0* ?14 ?0T4 ?# 6#A$H .-? 0? 0* )/*# ?0T4 >#A *#T4 7)-?0#(F "4)// $(#6H 64 )A4 )>A)0G #> >)()?070*TH ?10* 6)I4 #> A)G07)/ D*/)T0*?*H )(G P4? 64T-*? A4T4T.4A ?1)? 0? 0* T)0(/P ?14 P#-(2 C4#C/4 61# )A4 G4*C4A)?4H 61# G#(#? 1)I4 1#C4 >#A ?14 >-?-A4H )(G ?#G)P ?14P G# (#? 1)I4 .A4)Gj ?14P G# (#? 1)I44(#-21 >##G ?# >44G ?140A >)T0/04*F "14( ?14A4 64A4 ?14 >0A*? 0(G07)?0#(* #> ?14MA). QCA0(2H ?14*4 64A4 ?14 C4#C/4 61# >#-21? >#A >A44G#TH 61# /##$4G ?#B-A#C4 >#A *-CC#A?F M? ?14 *)T4 ?0T4H ?14P 64A4 >021?0(2 >#A ?140A 4I4APG)P /0>4H>#A .A4)GH )(G 64 2)I4 ?14T (40?14A >##GH (#A 1#C4H (#A 14/CH (#A I0*0#(F "1)?A4*-/?* G# 64 1)I4l D*/)T0*?* 1)I4 A4)//P A)0*4G ?140A 14)G*H )(G (#6 7#(?A#/?14*4 )A4)*F

<14A4>#A4H 64 1)I4 6)A 0( `0.P) )(G QPA0)F U#6 64 (44G ?# 1)I4 ) C/)( >#A?14 )A4) #> 7##C4A)?0#( 0( ?14 L4G0?4AA)(4)(F "4 1)I4 )**0*?4G 0( ) I4AP 0(?4//0Y24(? 6)PH )* 64 G0G 60?1 ?14 L)A*1)// ,/)(F MT4A07)(* #( ?14 #(4 1)(G 2)I4) /#? #> T#(4PH .-? 64 64A4 )./4 ?# .-0/G ) C)A?(4A*10C )(G >A04(G*10CF "4 )A4 )??14 T#T4(? ) 2##G T)A$4? >#A ?14 fFQF T)A$4?H .-? 64 1)I4 ?14 C#?4(?0)/ ?#C)A?(4A 60?1 ?14 MT4A07)(*F "0?1 ?14 14/C #> fFQF T#(4PH 64 1)I4 .47#T4 ?14.4*? ?A)G0(2 C)A?(4A #> ?14 f(0?4G Q?)?4*F

R-A0(2 ?14 2A#6?1 #> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( 64 .41)I4G 0(?4//024(?/PF D? 6)*)( 0(?4//024(? )**0*?)(74H 14/C0(2 #?14A 7#-(?A04* 0( ?140A G4I4/#CT4(?F M// 61#

V:

$(#6 ,#/)(G 60// *)P ?1)? ?10* 7#-(?AP 1)* G4I4/#C4G I4AP 64// ?1)($* ?# Bf>-(G*F Q# 14/C h P4*H .-? 0(?4//024(?/PF

D ?10($ ?1)? K0*1#C <)G4-*O ,04A#(4$ 60// *C4)$ CA0T)A0/P ).#-? T#A)/CA#2A4**H 0( 61071 64 1)I4 )7104I4G /4** *-774** ?1)( 0( 47#(#T07 CA#2A4**H.-? 0( 47#(#T07 ?4AT* ,#/)(G 1)* *02(0>07)(?/P 71)(24G )(G 4I#/I4GF "1PlM/*# .47)-*4 0( )( 0(?4//024(?H ?1#-21 24(4A#-*H 6)PH 64 *-CC#A?4G ?14 G4I4/Y#CT4(? #> ,#/)(GH #> ?14 ,#/0*1 T)A$4?F 54(4A#-*/P h P4*H .-? I4AP 0(?4//024(?Y/PF _(4 *1#-/G .4 24(4A#-*j 64 (44G ?# .4 14/C>-/ .-? 60*4/PH 0( ) *T)A? 6)PF"4 T-*? (#? .4 ()AA#6 14A4F "4 1)I4 ?# /##$ )? ?14 /#(2Y?4AT C4A*C47?0I4F

"4 *1#-/G )CCA#)71 14/C >#A 0TT02A)(?* *0T0/)A/PF K-? 1#6 ?# G# 0?H 0> ?14A40* *?0// ) 6)Al c0A*? #> )//H P#- 1)I4 ?# >0(0*1 ?14 6)AF <14 6)A *1#-/G .4 >0(0*14G>0A*?F D> P#- G# (#? 6)(? ?14*4 >#-A T0//0#( ?# .47#T4 \9 T0//0#(H 64 T-*? *?#C?14 6)AF D> ?14A4 0* (# 6)AH ?14A4 60// .4 (# A4>-244*F D> 64 *?#C ?14 6)AH ?14A460// .4 /4** CA4**-A4 ?# /4)I4 6)AY?#A( 7#-(?A04*F D> 64 6#-/G .4 )./4 ?# *?#C ?141#*?0/0?04*H 64 6#-/G .4 )./4 ?# 7A4)?4 ?14 7#(G0?0#(* >#A ?10* 6#(G4A>-/ CA#N47?H61071 60// .4 ?14 G4I4/#CT4(? #> ?14 U#A?1 M>A07)( 7#-(?A04*F

D? 0* G0>>07-/? ?# 4I4( GA4)T ).#-? *-71 ) CA#N47? 60?1#-? )( )CCA#CA0)?4 7-/Y?-A)/ 7#TC#(4(?F ,A#2A4** ?1A0I4* #( 7-/?-A4F <14*4 7#-(?A04* 60// (#? .4 )./4 ?#G4I4/#C -(?0/ )( -CA0*0(2 #> ?14 7-/?-A4 ?14A4 ?1)? 60// CA#T#?4 70I0/ *#704?P )(GG4I4/#CT4(? #> ?14 >)T0/PH 61071 7#(*0*?* 0( ?14 >)7? ?1)? ?6# )G-/?* 7)A4 >#A?140A 710/GA4(H 1)I4 ) N#. )(G 6#A$ >#A ?14 7#TT-(0?PF D? 0* (#? C#**0./4 ?# 1)I40? 60?1#-? A4/020#-* G0)/#2-4F D G# (#? T4)( A4/020#-* G0)/#2-4 ?1)? 2#4* #( G-AY0(2 ?14 47-T4(07)/ T44?0(2* 614A4 A4)//P 4I4AP#(4 0* )>A)0G ?# *)P )(P?10(2?1)? T021? #>>4(G )(#?14A A4/020#( #A )(#?14A 7-/?-A4F R-A0(2 *-71 47-T4(07)/T44?0(2* ?14A4 0* (# T4)(0(2>-/ ?)/$F U#H *-71 ) G0)/#2-4 6#-/G .4 .)GF D T4)(*-71 ) G0)/#2-4H 61071 K4(4G07? xkD ?)/$4G ).#-?H 614( 14 7#-A)24#-*/P *C#$4).#-? >-(G)T4(?)/ 0**-4* *-71 )* 1-T)( A021?*H 6#T4(+* A021?*H ?14 A021?* #>@1A0*?0)(*H ?14 A021?* #> A4/020#-* T0(#A0?04*H ?14 A021? ?# *?07$ ?# P#-A #6( ?A-?1FQ-71 ) G0)/#2-4 0* (474**)APj 0? 0* #(4 #> ?14 4/4T4(?* #> .-0/G0(2 ) 7-/?-A4 #>G4I4/#CT4(?F

`4? T4 2# .)7$ ?# ?14 CA4I0#-* m-4*?0#(F "4 (44G ?# *?#C ?14 1#*?0/0?04*j 64T-*? 4(G ?14 6)AF 3#6l "4 T-*? *?07$ ?# ?14 >)7?*H )(G P4? 64 G# (#? 7#(?A#/2/#.)/0O)?0#(F 5/#.)/0O)?0#( 0* ?14 CA#74** .P 61071 ?1#*4 61# 64A4 C##A )A424??0(2 64)/?104AF M(G *#T4 61# 64A4 A071 7)( /#*4 ?1)($* ?# 2/#.)/0O)?0#(F@10() 24?* A0714AH .-? B-A#C4 .47)-*4 #> 2/#.)/0O)?0#( T)P /#*4 0?* CA4*4(74)(G ?1-* /#*4 47#(#T07)//PF M(G 64 7)((#? *?#C ?10* CA#74** #> 0TC#I4A0*1YT4(? 0> 64 G# (#? 7#(?A#/ 2/#.)/0O)?0#(F "1P )A4(+? 64 )./4 ?# 7#(?A#/ 2/#.)/0YO)?0#(l c0A*? #> )//H -(>#A?-()?4/PH #-A A4/)?0#(*10C 60?1 ?14 f(0?4G Q?)?4* 1)*G4?4A0#A)?4G I4AP T-71 0( ?14 /)*? :9 P4)A*F "4 (44G ?# 6#A$ #( ?1)?H .47)-*4

V8

64+A4 ?)/$0(2 14A4 ).#-? *1)A4G I)/-4*F D? *44T* ?# T4 ?1)? >#A /)*? :9 P4)A*?14*4 A4/)?0#(* )(G 7#TT#( I)/-4* ?1)? 1)I4 )/6)P* 2-0G4G #-A A4/)?0#(* 60?1?14 f(0?4G Q?)?4* 1)I4 7#(*?)(?/P G47/0(4GF D? *44T* ?1)? ?14 f(0?4G Q?)?4* *#A?#> A)( )6)P >A#T -*F Q)AP-*OY"#/*$0 *)0G ?1)? 0? o?14 fFQFp 2#4* T#A4 0(?# ?14,)70>07 )(G 0? 0* *#F

D( ?14 :V[9* ?14 f(0?4G Q?)?4* 7#(?A#//4G [9| #> ?14 )**4?* )A#-(G ?14 6#A/GFM? ?1)? ?0T4 ?14 f(0?4G Q?)?4* 7#-/G G4)/ *-774**>-//P 60?1 ?14 *C14A4 #> 0(>/-Y4(74 0( .#?1 ?14 M?/)(?07 )(G ,)70>07F M? ?14 T#T4(? 0?+* (#? [9|F @-AA4(?/PH?14 f(0?4G Q?)?4* 7#(?A#/* #(/P 89| #> ?14 )**4?* 0( ?14 6#A/GF M(#?14A 89| 0*7#(?A#//4G .P ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(F <#24?14AH #> 7#-A*4H 64 7#-/G 7#(?A#/ ?14CA#74** #> 2/#.)/0O)?0#(F D* ?14 f(0?4G Q?)?4* A4)GP >#A *-71 ) C)A?(4A*10Cl

D? A4T)0(* #> 7#-A*4 ) T)??4A #> A4(42#?0)?0(2 #-A 0(>/-4(74 0( UM<_F D? 0*4**4(?0)/ ?# 1)I4 ) UM<_ ?1)? 0* *?)(G0(2 #( ?6# /42*H ?6# C0//)A*H )(G ?14A4>#A40? 0* (474**)AP ?# 1)I4 ) -(0>04G B-A#C4H 61071 60// ?)$4 ?14 A4*C#(*0.0/0?PH N-*?)* ?14 f(0?4G Q?)?4* G#4* (#6F c0()//PH UM<_ T-*? 74)*4 ?# .4 ) A420#()/ T0/Y0?)AP #A2)(0O)?0#( )(G .47#T4 ) 2/#.)/ )//0)(74H *# ?1)? MT4A07)(* )A4 60//0(2?# ?)$4 A4*C#(*0.0/0?P >#A 61)? 0* 1)CC4(0(2 0( B-A#C4 )(G #> 7#-A*4 64 ?## 60//?14( .4 A4*C#(*0./4 >#A 61)? 0* 1)CC4(0(2 )A#-(G ?14 6#A/GF <A4)?P (42#?0)?0#(*)A4 -(G4A6)P .4?644( ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( )(G ?14 f(0?4G Q?)?4*F <1)?+* I4AP2##GH )(G ?14 6#A$ 0* #(2#0(2H )/?1#-21 #(4 (44G* ?# .4 )6)A4 #> ?14 I)A0#-*C0?>)//*F "4 T-*? )/6)P* G4>4(G ?14 0(?4A4*?* #> #-A 70?0O4(*H .-? 64 1)I4 ?#(42#?0)?4 ?14*4 ?A4)?04*F M? ?14 *)T4 ?0T4 ?14*4 ?A4)?04* *1#-/G (#? .4 ) TP*?4APH?14P *1#-/G (#? .4 (42#?0)?4G 0( *47A4?F "4 T-*? 4iC/)0( ?# #-A 70?0O4(* 61)? 0*1)CC4(0(2 (#6H )(G 0? *44T* ?# T4 ?1)? 0( ?10* T)((4A 64 *1#-/G (#? 71)(24#-A )CCA#)71F <14A4 *1#-/G .4 T#A4 #C4((4**j 0( ?14 7)*4 #> >A44 ?A)G4 ?A4)?04*H?14A4 )A4 (#? #(/P 7#TT4A70)/ *#/-?0#(*H .-? 0? 0* A4)//P ) (46 >#-(G)?0#( #> ?14U#A?1 M?/)(?07 M//0)(74H 61071 0* .)*4G #( 7#TT#( I)/-4*F M(G 64 T-*? ?)/$).#-? 0? 60?1 #-A MT4A07)( C)A?(4A*F "0?1#-? ?10* 64 60// (#? .4 )./4 ?# 7#C460?1 2/#.)/0O)?0#( )(G 60?1 61)? 0* 1)CC4(0(2 0( `0.P) )(G QPA0)F

f(>#A?-()?4/PH 64 )/*# (44G ?# ?)/$ 60?1 ?14 =-**0)(*F M/)*F "4 T-*? ?4//?14T 7/4)A/PJ 1)(G* #>> f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

VZ

>A#T B-A#C4H .47)-*4 B-A#C4 T-*? .A4)?14 60?1 .#?1 /-(2*J ?14 64*? )(G ?144)*?H *# /4?+* ?)/$F `4?+* ?)/$ ).#-? *)(7?0#(*H 61071 )>?4A )// CA#I4G ?# .4 I4AP4>>47?0I4H )/?1#-21 *#T461)? .P 71)(74H 61071 /4G ?# ) *-GG4( GA#C 0( #0/ CA07Y4*F "4 $(#6 ?1)? =-**0) 0* #( ?14 I4A24 #> 47#(#T07 G0*)*?4AH *# 64 )* ) *?A#(2C)A?(4A *1#-/G ?)/$ 60?1 =-**0)F M(G *)P ?10*J !e#- 1)I4 ?# 60?1GA)6 >A#Tf$A)0(4H .-? 64 G# (#? 6)(? P#- ?# /4)I4 B-A#C4+F

M(G #(4 /)*? ?10(2F D> 64 7)( 7)AAP 0? )//H ?14( 64 60// .4 )./4 ?# A4(46 ?10*).0/0?P ?# T)()24 ?14 CA#74** #> 2/#.)/0O)?0#(F <14( 64 T-*? ?-A( ?# <-A$4PHDA)(H B2PC? )(G Q)-G0 MA).0) )(G 0(I0?4 ?14T ?# ) 7#TT#( ?)./4H .47)-*4 DQDQ0* #.I0#-*/P ) CA#./4TH 61071 64 60// )/*# G0*7-** 60?1 ?14*4 7#-(?A04*F K-?<-A$4P 0* G4>0(0?4/P 0(?4A4*?4G 0( ?14 S-AG0*1 0**-4 (#6 T#A4 ?1)( ) T)??4A #>>021?0(2 60?1 )( D*/)T07 *?)?4H N-*? )* DA)( 0* T#A4 0(?4A4*?4G 0( ?140A #6( CA#.Y/4T*H )* 64// )* Q)-G0 MA).0) 6)(?* ?# A4*#/I4 ?14 T)??4A 60?1 ?14 Q-((0* T#A4?1)( 60?1 DQDQF Q#T4 *)P ?10*J /4? -* *4(G #-A ?A##C* ?14A4 )(G C4A*#()//PH D 6#-/G.4 .410(G 0?F D 6#-/G /0$4 ?# *4(G ?14 ?A##C*H .-? A4)//P 64 (44G ?# $(#6 )2)0(*?61#T 64 )A4 *4(G0(2 ?14 ?A##C*H 61# 0* #-A )//P )(G 61# 0* #-A >#4F M? ?14T#T4(?H 614( 0? 7#T4* ?# QPA0) )(G `0.P)H 64 G# (#? 1)I4 7/)A0?P #( 61# 60//.4 #-A 4(4TPH )(G 60?1 61#T 64 *1#-/G 4*?)./0*1 )//0)(74*F

<14A4>#A4H 64 T-*? >0A*? A4.-0/G B-A#C4+* CA#N47? T)()24T4(? 7)C).0/0Y?04* )(G ?14 CA#74** #> 2/#.)/0O)?0#(F <14A4>#A4H ?14 CA#./4T 0* ?10*J G# 646)(? ?# )7? 0( ?10* 6)Pl "4 )A4 )? ?14 B,,F D ?10($ 64 )/A4)GP 1)I4 )7104I4G#(4 I07?#AP >#A B-A#C4 0( ?14 V9*H 0( ?14 X9*F M.#I4 )//H Q#/0G)A0?P G4A0I4* >A#T-*H ?14 >)// #> 7#TT-(0*T 7#T4* >A#T -*H /)?4A #( 2A#6?1 #> ?14 f(0#( )(G) 7#TT#( 7-AA4(7PF <14*4 64A4 2A4)? I07?#A04*H .-? -(>#A?-()?4/P ?14( ?14 *4YA04* #> >)0/-A4* 7)T4F <14 @#(*?0?-?0#(H (# A4>4A4(74* ?# @1A0*?0)( I)/-4*H )(G?14 /)7$ #> ?10* C#*0?0I4 0TC-/*4 0( B-A#C4F D? *44T* ?1)? ?14 #(/P 7-/?-A4 ?1)? 640( B-A#C4 C-*14G ?1A#-21 6)* ?14 7-/?-A4 #> A021?*H )(G ?1#*4 A021?* 7)( *#T4Y?0T4* .4 /0T0?4G ?# ) 74A?)0( *4/>0*1(4**F ,4A1)C* (#6 .42-( ) 2##G CA#74** 1)*.42-(F L)P.4 ?14A4 0* ) (46 *?)24 .4>#A4 -*F R# P#- A4T4T.4A ?14 C07?-A4 #>?14 >#-AYP4)AY#/G 710/G 61# G04G )? ?14 .4)71l D? *44T* )* 0> 0? *02(4G 0( ./##G?14*4 ?10(2* ?1)? 64 64A4 (#? )./4 ?# *)P 0( #-A @#(*?0?-?0#(F U)T4/PH ?10*./##G *02(4G ?14 (44G ?# A4?-A( ?# ) B-A#C4)( )6)A4(4**H ) B-A#C4)( 7#(Y*704(74F

D )T I4AP 2/)G ?1)? ?14A4 )A4 ?14*4 (46 0(0?0)?0I4* 0( ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(H .-?64 T-*? (#? 7#(G#(4 ?## 4)*0/PH 64 T-*? (#? *C4)$ *#J 64//H /4? 0TT02A)(?*7#T4H )(G ?14( 64+// ?10($ ).#-? 0?F U#H 0? 0* (474**)AP ?# G4I4/#C ?14 )CCA#CA0Y)?4 C#/0704* ?# T)()24 ?14 CA#74** #> 2/#.)/0O)?0#(H ?# .-0/G B-A#C4 )(G *?)A?)(46 ?# .-0/G ?10* CA#74** ?14A4H 614A4 64 /4>? 0? )A#-(G ?14 P4)A 8999F D ?10($ 0?0* 6#A?1 A47)//0(2 14A4 ?14 2A4)? 6#A$ #> ^#1( ,)-/ DDH ?14 T#A)/ 4(4A2P ?1)? 146)(?4G ?# 0(>-*4 0( B-A#C4F D 6#-/G /0$4 ?# T4(?0#( )(#?14A C4A*#( h 34/T-?

V\

S#1/F 34 )* ?14 71)(74//#A A4)//P .-0/? ?10* C#/0?07)/ CA#N47?H 61071 6)* ?#CA#I0G4 ) >A)T46#A$ >#A C4)74 )(G ?14 G4I4/#CT4(? #> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(F"4 GA#CC4G ?10* CA#N47?F D? 0* ?0T4 ?# >0(0*1 0?F <10* 0* ?14 T#*? )CCA#CA0)?4?0T4 ?# .-0/G 0? #( @1A0*?0)( I)/-4*H #-A @#(*?0?-?0#(H )(G 64 6#-/G ?1-* )7104I4?14 I0*0#( #> #-A 2A4)? C#/0?07)/ CA#N47?F M(G D 60// CA)P ).#-? 0?H ?1)? #-A C#/Y0?070)(* 1)I4 ?14 *?A4(2?1 ?# )77#TC/0*1 )// #> ?14*4 #.N47?0I4*F L)P ?14 `#AG/4)G -*F

V[

I,9'&+. '( ;:, +,7*;, ,1;0;6,+Q

4835;4 < 9 /=5>9= ;=9143

)?@@%*+ .*+%@*"+A'*"$ ;'$A+AB"$ ;@'#$%C,3%D?A@A*E 48 .*F'$F%C%*+

D'+,&*;,+ 78QK#<,> E+#?$8>$7 <"$,* ,@$+)% )* XY?$#+P *)% :WVZ[ H$/',8 $ Y?$#+\

%*1,60.;.Q/"$05..$" I$AA$ 4M;;&<C&$'57 0,&1,% )* +", T+#6$#' 5#%6$#&,'+\N(.)') OM"H'5;.7 0,&1,% )* +", E34%,&, !)3'<$6 )* L>%#$',7+", !)&&$88$)' *)% 23%)4,#' T'+,.%#+$)' $' +", E34%,&, !)3'<$6 )* L>%#$',\!" D)A5( B)"HM.+PQ$C.(&7 0257 W$<,M5%,8$@,'+ )* +", 23%)4,#' 5,)46,P8 5#%+C\!" /);"HAE) B).')C7 5%).%#&&, 9$%,<+)% V)%+" ;*%$<# #'@ +", 0$@@6, 2#8+7+", 5)6$8" T'8+$+3+, )* T'+,%'#+$)'#6 ;**#$%8\6"A38&.3$@ >R)' 7$"H)7 0,+%)4)6$+#' )* =$,I7 +", L>%#$'$#' -%+")@)G !"3%<"7 =$,I 5#+%$#%<"#+,]

V;

,G?<@< &23A@69?D A4CA4*4(? ) B-A#C4)( 7#-(?AP 60?1 ) C#C-/)?0#( #> \9 T0//0#(H 610/4 89

T0//0#( /0I4 #-?*0G4 0?* .#AG4A*F <10* 0* ) 7#-(?AP ?1)? 6#( 0?* G02(0?P 0( L)0G)(F<10* G02(0?P 1)* 0?* B-A#C4)( #I4A?#(4*F D? 0* ) >021? >#A B-A#C4)( I)/-4*F "14(64 ?)/$ ).#-? >A44G#TH 0? T4)(* ?14 >A44G#T ?# 71##*4 ) /0>4 #> G02(0?PF cA44YG#T 0* -(-*-)/ >#A CA0*#(4A* 0( =-**0) h *-71 )* U)G0P) Q)I714($#YQ4(7#6)(G #?14A*F cA44G#T 0* *#T4?10(2 ?1)? 7)((#? .4 ?#-714GF "14( 0? 7#T4* ?#1-T)( A021?* 0( f$A)0(4H )CCA#i0T)?4/P #(4 T0//0#( C4#C/4 1)I4 71)(24G ?140AC/)74 #> A4*0G4(74H )(G ?14*4 C4#C/4 )A4 /0T0?4G 0( ?140A A021?* .47)-*4 ?14P G#(#? /0I4 0( ?140A 1#T4*H #( ?140A ?4AA0?#APF

D 6#-/G /0$4 ?# CA4*4(? ?14 A4*-/?* #> *?-G04* 7)AA04G #-? .P ?14 <471(07)/f(0I4A*0?P #> `I#I #( 710/GA4(F "14( 64 )*$4G ?14 m-4*?0#( #> 61)? f$A)0(0)(710/GA4( ?10($ ).#-? 0(?42A)?0#(H 61)? ?14P 6A0?4 0( ?140A C#4T*H 0( A4*C#(*4)CC4)A ?14 ?14T4* #> 6)AH B-A#C4)( 0(?42A)?0#(H ?14 >-?-A4F <14A4 0* )/*# ) /#? #>A4>4A4(74* ?# >)0?1 0( 5#GF <14*4 )A4 ?14 @1A0*?0)( I)/-4* ?1)? 710/GA4( *1#6 0(?140A GA)60(2*F <14A4 1)* .44( ) /)A24 0(7A4)*4 0( C)?A0#?0*T 0( ?14 7#-(?APH)T#(2 710/GA4(H .-? )22A4**0#( 0* )/*# )**#70)?4G 60?1 ?14 2A#6?1 #> C)?A0#?0*TF<14*4 >44/0(2* *1#-/G G0A47?4G 4F2F ?# )( 0(?4A4*? 0( *C#A?*H .-? 64 *1#-/G )/*#G4I4/#C 0( 710/GA4( ) A4*C47? >#A ?14 #?14A C4A*#(F D 6#-/G /0$4 ?# ?1)($ P#- >#A?14 6#A$ #> ,#/0*1 LB,* 61# )A4 CA4*4(? 0( KA-**4/* #( .41)/> #> f$A)0(4F

c#A f$A)0(4 ?14 T#*? 0TC#A?)(? ?10(2 0* C4)74F <14 61#/4 7#-(?AP >44/* ?14#(2#0(2 6)AH (#? #(/P 0( ?14 64*? .-? )/*# ?14 0( 4)*? #> f$A)0(4H 614A4 C4#C/4*4? #>> ?# >021? )(G 20I4 ?140A /0I4*F f$A)0(4 6)(?* ?# 4iC/)0( ?# 4I4AP#(4 ?1)? 0?0* (#? *44$0(2 ?# *40O4 )(P#(4+* ?4AA0?#APH .-? A)?14A ?# $44C ?140A 7#-(?AP+* .#AYG4A* 0(?)7?F <14 *?A4(2?1 #> ?14 ()?0#( /04* 0( -(0?PH >#A 61071 f$A)0(4 0* CA)P0(2?# 5#G 0( ?140A 71-A714*F

03C:N>?:45 "R<@ S43><D 6#-/G /0$4 ?# A4T0(G P#- ?1)? [9Y;9 P4)A* )2#H I)A0#-* *704(?0*?* h C#/0?07)/

)(G A4/020#-* *?-G04* *71#/)A* h *)0G ?1)? *##( A4/020#( )(G A4/020#-* 0(*?0?-?0#(*60// .4 4(?0A4/P #I4A*44( .P ?14 CA0I)?4 *C14A4 )(G 60// (#? 0(>/-4(74 *#70)/ #AC#/0?07)/ /0>4F M? ?14 T#T4(?H 64 *44 ?14 CA#74** 2#0(2 0( ) G0>>4A4(? G0A47?0#(F D?0* CA470*4/P ?14*4 0G4#/#204* ?1)? 64A4 G#T0()(? 1)/> ) 74(?-AP )2#H )(G ?14*?A-22/4 .4?644( ?14 0G4#/#204* #> ?14 B)*? )(G "4*? 1)* 2#(4 ?# A4*?H )(G ?A)G0Y?0#()/ @1A0*?0)( I)/-4* 7)T4 ?# ?14 >A#(?F <14A4>#A4H T)(P #> ?14 7#(>/07?* )(GCA#./4T* ?1)? 64A4 T4(?0#(4G G-A0(2 ?10* 7#(>4A4(74 *?4T >A#T ?14 >)7? ?1)? 0(CA4I0#-* P4)A* ?14A4 64A4 )??4TC?* ?# .A0(2 ?14 0**-4 #> >)0?1 G#6( ?# ?14 CA0I)?4*C14A4F <14 4T4A24(74 #> A4/020#( 0( C#/0?07)/ /0>4 7)-*4* )( 0(7A4)*4 0( 7#(Y>/07?*F <14A4>#A4H 0? 0* I4AP )CCA#CA0)?4 ?# )*$ m-4*?0#(* ).#-? ?14 C/)74 #> ?14

VW

@1-A71 0( *#704?PF <14A4 60// .4 (# *-774** 0( ()?0#()/ #A B-A#C4)( C#/0?07* 0>64 G# (#? -(G4A*?)(G 61)? ?14 C/)74 #> ?14 @1-A71 0*F

R-A0(2 TP *?)P 0( KA-**4/*H D I0*0?4G ?14 71)C4/ #> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(??# 74/4.A)?4 ) T)** >#A f$A)0(4F <10* 71)C4/ 0* /#7)?4G 0( ) ?0(P A##T #( ?142A#-(G >/##A (4i? ?# ?14 ?#0/4? h ?10* 7)( .4 7#(*0G4A4G *PT.#/07 #> ?14 C/)74 ?1)?1)* .44( G4*02()?4G ?# ?14 @1-A71 0( B-A#C4F M(G ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( .42)(>A#T ?14 @1A0*?0)( 0G4) )(G G4T#7A)7P h S#(A)G MG4()-4A )(G =#.4A? Q71-YT)( 64A4 2-0G4G .P @1A0*?0)( T#?0I)?0#(F R# (#? .4 )*1)T4G #A >#A24? ?10*F

<14 A4I#/-?0#( #> G02(0?P 1)G ?14 *)T4 T#?0I)?0#(H A4>4AA4G ?# .P LA*e-AP(4?*F k)A0#-* A4/020#-* 7#TT-(0?04* 1)G ?140A C/)74 #( ?14 L)0G)(F "47)((#? 7-? #>> >A#T ?1#*4 0G4)*F <14 L0$1)0/#I*$P L#()*?4AP oL#()*?0Ap 14/C4G*14/?4A ?14 A4>-244* >A#T L)0G)(H *?-G4(?* >/440(2 C#/074F <10* T#()*?4AP .4Y7)T4 ) 1#*C0?)/ 0( ?14 T#*? G0>>07-/? G)P*H 614( e)(-$#IP71 )2A44G ?# *1##?Y0(2 C4#C/4 #( ?14 L)0G)(F <14( ?14 T#()*?4AP 6)* ?14 *)>4*? C/)74 614A4 ?14P7#-/G >0(G *14/?4AF <14 .4//* ?1)? 7#-/G .4 14)AG #( ?14 L)0G)( ?4*?0>P ?# ?14 ?142A4)? A#/4 #> A4/020#( )(G A4/020#-* I)/-4* 0( ?14 T#G4A( 6#A/GF =#-21/P ?6#)(G ) 1)/> P4)A* )2#H ?14 fFQF Q?)?4 R4C)A?T4(? 7A4)?4G ) *C470)/ *?A-7?-A4 >#AA4/020#-* )>>)0A*H .47)-*4 ?14P -(G4A*?##G ?1)? 60?1#-? )( )G4m-)?4 )CCA#)71 ?#A4/020#-* T)??4A*H C#/0?07)/ CA#74**4* 7)((#? .4 7#(G-7?4GF

<14 CA4*4(? 6)A 60?1 =-**0) 0* (#? ) 6)A .4?644( =-**0) )(G f$A)0(4H 0? 0*) 6)A #> ?14 4TC0A4 #> ?14 Q#I04? f(0#( )2)0(*? ?14 >-?-A4 #> B-A#C4F f(/0$4#?14A 7#-(?A04* ?1)? .4/#(24G ?# ?14 Q#I04? f(0#(H =-**0) 6)* ?14 #(/P 7#-(?AP?1)? G0G (#? -(G4A2# G4*#I04?0O)?0#(F M* /#(2 )* ?10* Q#I04?H *#70)/0*? T4(?)/0?P/)*?*H (#?10(2 7)( .4 71)(24GF

D( K-71)A4*? 0( 899XH ?14 UM<_ *-TT0? ?##$ C/)74F ,-?0( *)0G ?14( ?1)? 0>UM<_ 7#T4* 7/#*4A ?# f$A)0(4H ?14A4 60// .4 (# f$A)0(4F 30* 6#AG* 4iCA4**4G) ?1A4)?F M? ?1)? ?0T4 (#.#GP ?##$ ?14 ?1A4)? *4A0#-*/P )(G 0( #AG4A ?# )I#0G24??0(2 =-**0) -C*4?H (# #(4 )2A44G >#A 54#A20) ?# N#0( UM<_F M >46 T#(?1*/)?4A ?14A4 6)* ?14 6)A 0( 54#A20)H )(G )? ?10* T#T4(? ?14A4 0* ) 6)A 0( f$A)0(4F"1)? 60// ?14 (4i? 6)A .4 /0$4j 61071 7#-(?AP 60// .4 )>>47?4Gl B*?#(0)H `)?I0)H,#/)(GH =#T)(0) h (#.#GP $(#6*F <10* 0* 61P 64 *1#-/G ?)/$ ).#-? ?14*4 C#*Y*0.0/0?04*H .-? 64 1)I4 ?# -(G4A*?)(G ?1)? ?14 71)A)7?4A0*?07* #> =-**0)( C#/07P1)I4 .47#T4 ) *P*?4T)?07 7P(070*T h 614( #(4 ?10(2 0* *)0GH ) /04 0* *)0G #(C-AC#*4H )(G *#T4?10(2 m-0?4 G0>>4A4(? 0* G#(4F <10* 0* N-*? 61)? 64 64A4 ?)/$Y0(2 ).#-? h I)/-4*F "14( ?14A4 0* ) 7#TT#( C/)?>#AT #> I)/-4*H )(G 1-T)( /0>40* #(4 #> ?14 T#*? 0TC#A?)(? I)/-4*H 64 7)( >0(G 7#TT#( C#0(?* #> I046H .-?1#6 G# 64 >0(G *#T4?10(2 0( 7#TT#( .4?644( ?14 ?A-?1 )(G -(?A-?1l <14 5#*YC4/ ?4//* -* ?1)? G)A$(4** )(G /021? 1)I4 (#?10(2 0( 7#TT#(H )(G ?10* 0* #-A .02CA#./4TF

VX

B-A#C4 0* ?14 >A-0? #> ) 7#TCA#T0*4H ) 7#(*4(*-*F <10* T4(?)/0?P #> 7#TCA#YT0*4 )>?4A ?6# 6#A/G 6)A* )(G ?14 G4*?A-7?0#( 0( ?14 89?1 74(?-APH ?10* 7#(*4(Y*-* 4(?4A4G 0(?# #-A B-A#C4)( -(G4A*?)(G0(2 #> ?14 6#A/GF <10* T4)(* ?1)? 0>4)71 #> -* 1)* #-A #6( (44G*H 64 1)I4 ?# A4)71 ) 7#(*4(*-* ?#24?14AF <10* 0*61)? B-A#C4 0* .-0/? #(F <14 *#-A74* #> ?14 SA4T/0(+* A4)*#(0(2 )A4 m-0?4 G0>>4AY4(?H 1#64I4AF D? 0* 40?14A I07?#AP #A G4>4)?F M(P $0(G #> 7#(*4(*-* 0* ) I07?#APFc#A 4i)TC/4H 0( K-71)A4*? 0? 6)* )2A44G ?# ?14 >)7? ?1)? UM<_ 60// (#? .44iC)(G4G h I4AP 64//F <14( 64 T#I4 #(F <10* 0* 61)? T-*? .4 -(G4A*?##G 614(64 ?)/$ ).#-? =-**0)H )(G 60?1 =-**0)F

!3 O<93ACT< 1<?@<ED 6)(?4G ?# ?)/$ ).#-? D*/)TH )(G *C470>07)//P ).#-? ?14 A4*-/?* #> ?14 A4Y

*4)A71 ?1)? D 7#(G-7?4G 60?1 ?14 ,#/0*1 D(*?0?-?4 #> D(?4A()?0#()/ M>>)0A* 0( B2PC?)? ?14 .420((0(2 #> 89:[F D( c4.A-)AP )(G L)A71H 64 6#A$4G )? #-A *0*?4A 0(*?0Y?-?0#( 0( @)0A# h )? ?14 M/)1*A)T @4(?A4 >#A Q?A)?4207 )(G ,#/0?07)/ =021?*F <14A4D ?A04G ?# 4iC/#A4 1#6 ?14 C/)74 #> A4/020#( 0( C-./07 /0>4 0* 71)(20(2H 1#6 ?14C/)74 #> D*/)T 0( ?14 C-./07 /0>4 #> L-*/0T* h ?14 B2PC?0)(* h 0* 71)(20(2F

"1)? 0* 1)CC4(0(2 0( D*/)T ?#G)P 0* (#? *# 7/4)AF D? *44T* ?# T4 ?1)? 64#>?4( *44 ?14 CA#./4T #> ?14 L0GG/4 B)*? )* ) A4/020#-* 6)A #> D*/)T 60?1 @1A0*Y?0)(0?P #A #?14A (#(YL-*/0T A4/020#-* T0(#A0?04* #-?*0G4 #> D*/)TF K-? ?14A4 0*) 6)A 60?10( D*/)TH )(G 0? 0* (#? .4?644( Q100?4* )(G Q-((0*H .-? 60?10( Q-((0D*/)TF

D 6#-/G /0$4 ?# G47#(*?A-7? *#T4 TP?1* ).#-? D*/)TF c0A*?H ?14 TP?1 #> ?14/)7$ #> )( 0(?4AT4G0)AP .4?644( ) L-*/0T )(G 5#GF <14 G47#(*?A-7?0#( #> ?14TP?1 1)* C#/0?07)/ 0TC/07)?0#(*F Q#T4?0T4* 0? *44T* ?1)? .47)-*4 ?14A4 0* (#*0(2/4 )-?1#A0?PH ) *0(2/4 A4/020#-* 0(*?0?-?0#( 0( D*/)TH ?14A4 0* (# *-71 0(*?0?-Y?0#( 61071 6#-/G )>>47? )// L-*/0T*H )(G ?10* 0* (#? ?A-4F D 60// A4>4A ?# ?14A4*4)A71 #> ?6# *704(?0*?*J BA(4*? 54//(4A h ) (#6 G474)*4G KA0?0*1 *#70#/#Y20*? h )(G cA4(71T)( L)i0T) =#G0(*#(F =#G0(*#( h ) cA4(71 #A04(?)/0*?H)/*# )/A4)GP G474)*4G h G0I0G4G D*/)T 0(?# #>>070)/ )(G >#/$j BA(4*? 54//(4A ?#?14 1021 )(G /#6F K#?1 1)G *0T0/)A ?10(2* 0( T0(GF _>>070)/ D*/)T 0* ?14 A4/0Y20#-* 0(*?0?-?0#(* ?1)? >-(7?0#( 0( )(P L-*/0T 7#-(?APF c#/$ D*/)T 0* ?14 0(>#AYT)/ *#-A74* #> 0(*C0A)?0#( >#A L-*/0T*H 61071 )A4 (#? A42-/)?4GF D( BA(*? 54//Y(4A+* G0*?0(7?0#( .4?644( 1021 D*/)T )(G /#6 D*/)TH 1021 D*/)T 0* ?14 D*/)T #>?14 *7A0.4*H )(G ?14A4 )A4 1-(GA4G* #> ?1#-*)(G* #> C)24* #> G0>>07-/? )A71)07?4i? 6A0??4( 0( MA).07F <14*4 *71#/)A* )A4 T)0(/P 7#(74(?A)?4G 0( ?14 70?04*F _(?14 7#(?A)APH >#/$ #A /#6 .4/04>*H ?14 6#A*10C #> *)0(?*H 61071 0* >#A.0GG4( 0(Q-((0 D*/)T )77#AG0(2 ?# ?10* 1021 0(?4ACA4?)?0#(H )A4 T#*?/P 7#(74(?A)?4G 0( ?147#-(?AP*0G4F

VV

3#6 G#4* ?10* T4G0)?#A 6#A$l M I4AP C#C-/)A L-*/0T C#/0?07)/ *704(?0*?o60?1 :;9H999 >)(* #( c)74.##$p *1)A4G 60?1 T4 ?1)? *14 1)* A4/020#-* G#-.?*4I4AP G)PF <10* *1#6* 1#6 A4/020#-* L-*/0T* )A4F D> *#T4#(4 G#4* (#? $(#61#6 ?# *#/I4 ) CA#./4T ?1)? 0* .#?14A0(2 ?14TH ?14P A4)GF Q-71 0* ?14 ()?-A4 #>0(?4ACA4?)?0#( h 61)? L#1)TT4G *)0GH !D> P#- G# (#? $(#6H ?14( A4)G+F K-?A4)G 61)?l <14 {-A)(H )(G ?14 I4A.)/ Q-(()1H 6)* 6A0??4( 0( ) G0>>07-/?H 14AYT4?07 /)(2-)24H 7#TC/4?4/P 0(7#TCA414(*0./4 ?# ?14 C4#C/4F <14 61#/4 /42)7P6)* 6A0??4( #I4A :H\99 P4)A* )2#H )>?4A )//F D>H )>?4A A4)G0(2H *#T4#(4 *?0// G#4*(#? $(#6 61)? ?# G# 0( ) 20I4( *0?-)?0#(H ?14P 6#-/G )*$ C4#C/4 61# T)P $(#6.4??4AH .-? ).#I4 )//H ?14P 6#-/G )*$ ?14 #>>070)/ D*/)TH 61071 0* ?14 0(*?0?-?0#(G4)/0(2 60?1 0**-0(2 /42)/ #C0(0#(*H *#Y7)//4G B#?&#8F K-? 0> )(P#(4 *?0// 1)*G#-.?*H ?14( ?14 {-A)( *)P*H !?)$4 ) >)?6) >A#T P#-A 14)A?+F <10* 0* ?14 /)*?A4*#A?F _(4 *1#-/G G470G4 >#A ?14T*4/I4*H .47)-*4 G-A0(2 ?14 `)*? ^-G2T4(? ?14C4A*#( 60// *?)(G .4>#A4 5#G .P ?14T*4/I4* )(G 60// (#? .4 )./4 ?# A4>4A ?#) >)?6) ?1)? *#T4#(4 1)G 20I4( ?# ?14TF D? 0* #(4+* #6( G470*0#(F

D*/)TH #( ?14 #(4 1)(GH CA#I0G4* -(/0T0?4G C#**0.0/0?04* ?# ) C4A*#( 61#G470G4* >#A ?14T*4/I4*j #( ?14 #?14A 1)(GH )(G C4A1)C* )* ) A4*-/? #> ?10*H 0?T4)(* D*/)T 0* ) I4AP 7#TC/4i A4/020#(F <14 .-AG4( #> ?10* A4*C#(*0.0/0?P >#A?14 G470*0#( )(G >#A ?14 G)PY?#YG)P A47-AA0(2 CA#./4T* 0* 0TT4(*4F D? 0* ) 7#(*?)(?CA#74** #> >0(G0(2 ?14 A021? )(*64AF

=4/020#-* 0(*?0?-?0#(* 0( B2PC? )A4 CA0T)A0/P T)G4 -C #> ?14 =4/020#-* L0(Y0*?AP #> B2PC?H 61071 G4)/* 60?1 ?14 *-C4AI0*0#( #> T#*m-4*j <14 3#-*4 #>c)?6)*H 0**-0(2 /42)/ #C0(0#(*j <14 =4/020#-* f(0I4A*0?PH ?14 *140$ #> 61071 0*) I4AP 0TC#A?)(? )-?1#A0?P 0( Q-((0 D*/)TH )(G ?14 5A)(G L->?0 h ) $0(G #> !14)G#> ?14 L-*/0T 71-A71+ 0( 4I4AP L-*/0T *?)?4Fq

D( D*/)TH ?14 CA#./4T #> *?A-22/4 60?10( A4/020#( )CC4)A*F D? 7)-*4* *#T4)7?0#(* #> #>>070)/ D*/)T 60?1 A4*C47? ?# ?14 0(?4ACA4?)?0#( #> A4/020#(F <14 #>>0Y70)/ A4/020#-* 0(*?0?-?0#(* 0**-4 >)?6)* 7#(G4T(0(2 ?14 D*/)T07 Q?)?4H .-? G# (#?G4?4AT0(4 0?* T4T.4A* )* 0(>0G4/*H .47)-*4 ?14 0(*?0?-?0#( #> G4?4AT0(0(2 )(0(>0G4/ 0* ) ?##/ >#A N01)G0*?*F <10* 0* 61P ?14P 7)( >021? )2)0(*? #?14A L-*/0T*H.47)-*4 ?14P G4?4AT0(4 ?14T )* 0(>0G4/*H 610/4 ?14 >#AT)/ )(G ?14#/#207)/ CA#7Y4** #> G4?4AT0(0(2 *#T4#(4 )* )( 0(>0G4/ A4m-0A4* ) /#? #> A4*?A07?0#( )(G 7#(G0Y?0#(*F D? 7)((#? .4 G#(4 )* 4)*0/P )* ?14P G# 0?Fq

D(*?0?-?0#(* #> #>>070)/ D*/)T )/*# 0**-4 >)?6)* 4iC/)0(0(2 ?14 6#AG =H6<#5@H61071 64 -(G4A*?)(G )* ?14 )7?-)/ 1#/P 6)AH 614A4)* 0( ?14 {-A)( 0? 1)* ?6#T4)(0(2*F c0A*? #> )//H 0? 0* ?14 >021? #> ) T)( 10T*4/> 60?1 )// #> ?14*4 ?4TC?)Y?0#(* ?1)? *-AA#-(G 10TF <10* 0* ?14 I4AP CA#74** ?1)? D G4*7A0.4GH ?14 ?#AT4(? #>?14 G)P h ?10* A4m-0A4* >)0?1H )(G .40(2 >)0?1>-/ T4)(* 4>>#A?F <14*4 0(*?0?-?0#(*G4*7A0.4 0( G4?)0/ 61)? N01)G 0*H )(G ?1)? 0? 0* CA0T)A0/P )( 0((4A *?A-22/4H .-? 0(

:99

?14 7#(G0?0#(* #> 6)AH 614( D*/)T 0* )??)7$4GH ?10* 0* ?14 #?14A N01)GF Q#T4HCA470*4/P N01)G0*?*H 0(?4ACA4? ?1)? D*/)T 6)* )??)7$4G )(G (#6 /4)G ) 1#/P 6)AF

<10* #>>070)/ 0(?4ACA4?)?0#( 0* C-./0*14G #( 64.*0?4* )(G A4C4)?4G )? 7#(>4AY4(74*F D( L)A71H Q)-G0 MA).0) 1#*?4G ) 7#(>4A4(74 #> ?14 5A)(G L->?0* )2)0(*?4i?A4T0*TH 0( 61071 )// ?14*4 0(?4ACA4?)?0#(* 64A4 A4C4)?4GF f(>#A?-()?4/PH ?14A4)A4 )/*# *-71 )7?0#(* ?1)? 7)( ?)$4 )6)P #>>070)/ D*/)T+* 7A4G0.0/0?PF c#A 4i)TYC/4H )>?4A ?14 #I4A?1A#6 0( 89:Z #> ,A4*0G4(? L-A*0H 61# 6)* )**#70)?4G 60?1?14 L-*/0T KA#?14A1##G o#(4 #> >#/$ D*/)T+* 0(*?0?-?0#(*pH )( 0(?4A()/ )?T#*YC14A4 #> C#/0?07)/ *?A-22/4 G4I4/#C4Gj 0F4FH *C470>07 7#(?A#/ 6)* 0TC#*4G #(T#*m-4*F L#A4 *C470>07)//PH .4>#A4 4)71 cA0G)P CA)P4AH ?14 ?#C07 #> ?14 *4AT#()CC4)A* #( ?14 L0(0*?AP #> =4/020#-* M>>)0A*+ 64.*0?4H 61071 0* T)(G)?#AP >#A)// T#*m-4* ?# 7#(G-7? ?1A#-21#-? ?14 7#-(?APF _(/P DT)T* 61# )A4 /074(*4G.P ?14 T0(0*?AP 7)( CA4)71 Q4AT#(*F <10* 0* CA#./4T)?07H *0(74 ?14 *?A07? 7#(?A#/#> A4/020#( )/6)P* ?A0224A* ) >4AT4(? #( ?14 #-?*$0A?*F

M(#?14A )7?0#( #> #>>070)/ D*/)T )2)0(*? A)G07)/0O)?0#( 0* *44$0(2 ?# A4)**-A4?14 T#*?Y)774C?4G 0(?4ACA4?)?0#( 60?10( 4)71 *71##/ #> N-A0*CA-G4(74 #> D*/)TF<14 4iC47?4G A4*-/? 0* )( 0TC)7? #( ) /)A24A (-T.4A #> C4#C/4H #A N-*? )( 0(Y7A4)*4 0( #(/0(4 #>>070)/ D*/)TH .-? )/*# ?# *4(G0(2 0?0(4A)(? 1#-*4* 0**-0(2 >)?Y6)* ?# B2PC?0)( I0//)24*F

c#/$ D*/)T 0* T#A4 0TC#A?)(? .47)-*4 *#T4?0T4* 0? 1)* T#A4 7A4G0.0/0?P 0(A4/)?0#( ?# ?14 #>>070)/ #(4F c#/$ D*/)T 0* G0I0G4G G4C4(G0(2 #( ?14 *#70)/ 7/)**Y4*F <14 G0I0*0#( #> ) *#704?P 0(?# 7/)**4* 0* /0($4G ?# ?14 C#I4A?P #> ) /)A24 C)A?#> ?14 C#C-/)?0#(F <14 T#*? 0(>/-4(?0)/ 7/)** )A4 ?14 Q)/)>0*?*H ?14 L-*/0T KA#?1Y4A1##GF <14P ?14 )A4 *#Y7)//4G ?4/4I)(24/0*?* 61# 1)I4 :[Y:; T0//0#( >#//#64A*#( c)74.##$H )(G *# ?14P 1)I4 4(#AT#-* C#64A #I4A ?14 *#-/* #> ?14 7#-(?APFq

@##C4A)?0#( .4?644( #>>070)/ D*/)T )(G >#/$ D*/)T 0* (474**)APF D? T-*? #7Y7-A .47)-*4 L-*/0T* )A4 T#*? )>A)0G #> ) *#Y7)//4G B6?+#H ) A-C?-A4 0(*0G4 #>D*/)TF D )T C4A*#()//P >)*70()?4G .P ?14 L-*/0T A4/020#*0?PH .47)-*4 0? 0* (#? )*CA4*4(? 60?1 -* 0( B-A#C4F D ?##$ -C ?10* *-.N47?H *440(2 1#6 0? 1)* )( 4>>47? #(L0GG/4 B)*? C#/07PF "10/4 0( @)0A#H D T4? ) T)( 61# 1)G ) *#Y7)//4G =9A6A#@ #(10* >#A414)G h ) .-TC >#AT4G >A#T >A4m-4(?/P ?#-710(2 10* 14)G 610/4 CA)P0(2#( ) 7)AC4?F "14( D )*$4G 10T 0> 14 A4)//P CA)P4G >0I4 ?0T4* ) G)P 0( ?14 T#*m-4H14 .42)( ?# )**-A4 T4 ?1)? G4*C0?4 10* C04?P 14 6)* ) C4A>47?/P (#AT)/ 1-T)(.40(2F <10* T)G4 0? 7/4)A ?# T4 ?1)? 64 C4A740I4 4)71 #?14A m-0?4 6A#(2/PF 34?##$ TP m-4*?0#( )* 0> D 64A4 *# -/?A)/0.4A)/H C#*?Y*47-/)AH ?1)? >#A T4 ) A4/020#-*C4A*#( 0* *#T4#(4 *?A)(24H 610/4 D .47)T4 0(?4A4*?4G 0( 10T .47)-*4 14 6)* *#A4/020#-*F

D? *44T* ?# T4 ?1)? 64 )A4 A4/020#-* ?##H .-? -(/0$4 ?14TH 64 G# (#? 4iC#*4#-A A4/020#*0?P /0$4 ?10*F <14 CA#./4T 0* ?1)? 64 $(#6 I4AP /0??/4 ).#-? #-A*4/I4*FB7-T4(0*T 0TC/4T4(?4G .P ,#C4 ^#1( ,)-/ DD 1)* 64)$4(4G ) /0??/4 .0?F <14

:9:

N#-A(4P* #> ,#C4 cA)(70* ?# ?14 3#/P `)(GH ?# M/.)(0) )(G ?# <-A$4P )A4 .4)-Y?0>-/H .-? >#A 4i)TC/4 L->?0*H 61# A4CA4*4(? ) I4AP G0>>4A4(? D*/)T ?1)( ?14 N0Y1)G0*?*H )A4 (4I4A 0( B-A#C4F <14A4 0* (# *-71 7#4i0*?4(74 ?1)? 0* 4(7#-A)24G 0(?14 T4G0)F

U4>C6 834= 9:6 <2B>6@C6D 1)I4 ) m-4*?0#( >#A ,A#>4**#A K-??02/0#(4F 3#6 G# P#- -(G4A*?)(G ?14 7#(Y

74C? #> 7-/?-A4 )(G 70I0/0O)?0#(l 3#6 G# P#- *44 ?14 G0>>4A4(74* .4?644( ?14*4?6# 7#(74C?*l 3#6 G# P#- -(G4A*?)(G ?14 7#(74C? #> ?14 ()?0#(l

O3486??43 *4CC4 7299>FE>4@6@-/?-A4 0* 61)? 64 1)I4 0( #-A*4/I4*F @0I0/0O)?0#( 0* ?14 6)P 64 /0I4 60?1

#?14A C4#C/4F D> 64 /0I4 60?1 64//Y4G-7)?4G C4#C/4H ?14( #> 7#-A*4 64 C)A?070YC)?4 0( 70I0/0O)?0#(F 3#64I4AH 0> *#T4#(4 1)* ) 7-/?-A4 #> 1)?A4GH ?14( 70I0/0YO)?0#( G#4* (#? 4i0*?F <1-*H 70I0/0O)?0#( 0* ) *P*?4T #> 74A?)0( 0(*?0?-?0#(*HA-/4* )(G *?)(G)AG*H )(G 7-/?-A4H )* D *)PH 64 1)I4 60?10( -*F @-/?-A4 >#AT* -*)* ) C4A*#(F

^#1( ,)-/ DD m-#?4G )( 4i74//4(? G4>0(0?0#( #> ) ()?0#(J ) ()?0#( 0* ) ()?-A)/7#TT-(0?P 61071 0* 0(()?4 >#A -*H 0( 61071 64 )A4 .#A(F <14 ()?0#( ?14A4>#A47#(*0*?* CA0T)A0/P #> ?14 >)T0/PH .47)-*4 0? 0* T)0(/P 0( ?14 >)T0/P 614A4 64/4)A( 61)? #-A 7#TT-(0?P 0* ).#-?F <14 ()?0#( 0* )/*# 0G4(?0>04G .P /)(2-)24H.P 7#TT#( 10*?#APH A4)G0(2 ?14 *)T4 7/)**07)/ .##$*H 4iC4A04(70(2 ?14 *)T4T)N#A C)*? 4iC4A04(74* )(G ?14 *)T4 4iC4A04(74* T#I0(2 0(?# ) 7#TT#(>-?-A4F

D 6)* .#A( 0( MC-/0)H .-? )? ?14 *)T4 ?0T4 ?1)? D )T D?)/0)(H D )T )/*#) B-A#C4)( )(G D .4/04I4 ?1)? )// #> ?14*4 m-)/0?04* 71)A)7?4A0O4 T4 0( *#T46)PF _> 7#-A*4 64 1)I4 G0>>4A4(? ()?0#(* ?1)? )A4 *?0// 2#0(2 ?1A#-21 ?14 *)T44iC4A04(74H *4??0(2 ?14 *)T4 I)/-4* )(G .47#T0(2 ) 7#TT-(0?P #> ?14 *)T44iC4A04(74H .-? )/*# .40(2 G4>0(4G .P #?14A ()?0#(* 0( *#T4 6)P* )* ) 7#TT#(7-/?-A4F

V<@2?W X3WAK4?WAY?G>D 6)(?4G ?# )*$ LAF ^)74$ Q)AP-*OY"#/*$0 ) m-4*?0#(F D /0I4G 0( D?)/P >#A Z[

P4)A*H *# D $(#6 D?)/0)( CA#./4T* I4AP ?1#A#-21/PH )(G D )T )/*# )( D?)/0)( 70?Y0O4(F "1)? 0* 1)CC4(0(2 )? ?14 T#T4(? 0( B-A#C4 0* ).*#/-?4/P ).(#AT)/F D )2A4460?1 61)? P#- *)0G .4>#A4H 7#(*0G4A0(2 ?14 1-24 (-T.4A #> A4>-244* )(G T0Y2A)(?* 61# )AA0I4 ?# ?14 *1#A4* #> B-A#C4F D 6)(?4G ?# /4)A( >A#T P#-J 61)? )A464 G#0(2 ?# *?#C ?14*4 C4#C/4l M>?4A )// 64 /)7$ ) 7##AG0()?4G )7?0#( 14A4F @)(+?64 G# *#T4?10(2 )* *0TC/4 )* 61)? MT4A07)(* )A4 G#0(2 60?1 L4i07)(*H 610710* 20I4 ?14T ) .#??/4 #> 6)?4A 0( #(4 1)(GH ) *)(G6071 0( ?14 #?14A 1)(G )(G ?-A(?14T .)7$l

:98

!3L V<C6G 1<3A2?WZD4E?G><14 *1#A? )(*64A 0*J 64 )A4 (#? G#0(2 4(#-21 )(G 64 )A4 G#0(2 0? ?## /)?4F

`4?+* 0T)20(4 *-71 ) *0?-)?0#(J ) C#/07P #> *-CC#A?0(2H 14/C0(2 )(G *?).0/0O0(2?1)? A420#( 1)* .44( A-((0(2 >#A P4)A* )(G 0? 6)* 4>>47?0I4F 3#64I4AH 64 1)I4(#? .44( G#0(2 ?10*F <14 D?)/0)(* )(G cA4(71 .4/04I4G ?1)? 0? 6)* (474**)AP ?#.#T. `0.P)F <14 54AT)(* )(G =-**0)(* 64A4 )2)0(*? 0?F M? ?10* T#T4(? ?14A40* ) 7#(*4(*-* )* ?# ?14 *#Y7)//4G 7#T4.)7$ C#/07PF

qM* >#A ?14 L4i07)(YMT4A07)( .#AG4AH ?14 G0>>4A4(74 .4?644( ?14 ,#/0*1)(G f$A)0(0)( .#AG4A )(G `)TC4G-*) #A ?14 0*/)(G #> S#*H )* 60?1 ?14 L4i07)(YMT4A07)( .#AG4AH 0* ?1)? /)(G 7A#**0(2* #> T02A)(?* 7)AAP /4** 4?107)/ 0TC/07)Y?0#(*F <14 T02A)(?* >A#T M>A07) ?# `)TC4G-*) #A S#* *60T )7A#**F _( ?14 /)(G.#AG4A ?14P 7)( .4 *?#CC4G )(G *4(? .)7$F "14( ?14P )A4 )? *4) )(G )A4 GA#6(Y0(2H .#?1 1-T)( A4>/4i )(G #-A I)/-4* )* 64// )* T)A0(4 0(?4A()?0#()/ /)6 G4YT)(G ?1)? 64 *1#-/G *)I4 ?14TF <10* 0* ?14 1-T)( C)A? #> ?14 ?A-?1F _> 7#-A*4HP#- 1)I4 ?# A4*7-4 ?1#*4 61# )A4 )? A0*$F _( ?14 #?14A 1)(GH .410(G ?10* 0* )(0(G-*?AP ?1)? 0* *4(G0(2 ?14*4 C4#C/4H 614?14A ?14P )A4 )6)A4 #A (#?H 60?1 ) 1021A0*$ #> G4)?1F <14*4 )A4 ?4(* #> .0//0#(* #> G#//)A*F

Q#T4#(4 0* C)P0(2 >#A ?14*4 7A#**0(2*F <14A4 )A4 *-*C070#(* ?1)? ?10* 0* Q)-YG0 MA).0)F <14 <-A$* G0*?A0.-?4 A-..4A G0(2104*j *#T4?0T4* ?1#*4 61# /4)G ?14*4C#(?##(*H 7-? ?14T )? ?14 *1#A4 0( #AG4A ?# 7A4)?4 ) *0?-)?0#( 0( 61071 0(?4A()Y?0#()/ /)6 #./024* ?14 .#AG4A 2-)AG .#)?* ?# ?14 A4*7-4F <14*4 )A4 G4/0.4A)?4)770G4(?*F D? 0* ?14 T0i0(2 #> T0*4AP )(G 1-T)( ?A)24GPH 614A4 ?14 I4AG07? 0*-()T.02-#-*H 60?1 *#T4?10(2 ?1)? 0* ) C#/0?07)/ C/)( ?# >/##G B-A#C4 60?1 T0Y2A)(?*F

B-A#C4 T)G4 ) T0*?)$4 *)P0(2 ?1)? 0? )6)0?* A4>-244*F D 14)AG 60?1 TP #6(4)A* @1)0AT)( #> ?14 @#-(70/ <-*$H 61# *)0G 14 6)* 0( ?1A44 7)TC* 0( <-A$4P)(G 0( ^#AG)(H 614A4 4I4AP#(4 >4/? 4iC47?4G )(G 0(I0?4G ?# B-A#C4F 3#6 G# 64*4(G ?14T .)7$ (#6l <14A4 0* ) C/)( ?# G0*?0(2-0*1 T02A)(?* >A#T A4>-244*FD(70G4(?)//PH )? ?10* T#T4(? 0? ?-A(* #-? ?1)? Z9 C4A 74(? #> )//424G QPA0)(* )A4(#? QPA0)(*H .47)-*4 ) QPA0)( C)**C#A? 7)( .4 C-A71)*4G >#A �X8[F "4 6)(? ?#*4(G ?14T .)7$H 64 6)(? ?# G0*?0(2-0*1H .-? D )T )>A)0G ?1)? ?10* 0* #( ?14 I4A24#> 0(>4)*0.0/0?PF D $(#6 ?10* 0* (#? ) 2##G )(*64A ?# P#-A m-4*?0#(H .-? )* =#77#K-??02/0#(4 *)0GH 0? 6#-/G .4 .4*? 0> ?14P 1)G ) 1#T4 )(G 0> ?14A4 6)* ) C/)74614A4 64 7#-/G *4(G ?14T .)7$F

.6@3AG D4[@><G4K?G>"1)? 6)* 7#TT#( 0( ?14 *C44714* #> LA Q)AP-*OY"#/*$0 )(G ,A#>4**#A

=#77# K-??02/0#(4 6)* ?14 #.*4AI)?0#( ?1)? >#A )(P C#*0?0I4 71)(24H ?14 2A4)?4AC#/0?07)/ C#64A #> B-A#C4 )* ) 61#/4 0* (44G4Gj ?1)? 0*H ?14 71)(24 *1#-/G .4

:9Z

*?)A?4G >A#T ?14 B-A#C4)( *0G4F D 6)(?4G ?# )*$H 61)? )A4 ?14 CA#*C47?* )(G 0>?14A4 )A4 )(P CA#*C47?* )? ?10* ?0T4H >#A ?10* C#/0?07)/ B-A#C4H 0F4F ) 7#TT#(>#A402( C#/07P #> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( ?# *?A4(2?14( )(G 0(7A4)*4 0?* 4>>47?0I4Y(4**H .47)-*4 0? 0* G4 >)7?# ?14 *?)A?0(2 C#0(? >#A )// ?14 C#**0./4 C#*0?0I4 )(G4iC47?4G 71)(24*l

O3486??43 *4CC4 7299>FE>4@6D> P#- 1)G )*$4G T4 ?10* m-4*?0#( ) >46 T#(?1* )2#H D 6#-/G 1)I4 *)0G ?1)?

?14A4 6)* (# *-71 C4A*C47?0I4H ?1)? ?14 7#TT#( >#A402( C#/07P 7#-/G 71)(24F<#G)P D 1)I4 ?# G47/)A4 ?1)? D 1)I4 71)(24G TP T0(GF D? *44T* ?# T4 (#6 ?1)??14A4 )A4 I4AP *?A#(2 I#074*H ?1)? 0? 0* (474**)AP >#A -* ?# .4 CA#)7?0I4F M>?4A )//H64 1)I4 ) (-T.4A #> ?##/* 64 7)( A4)71 >#AJ .)($0(2 -(0#(*H )CCA#CA0)?4 >0()(Y70)/ C#/07P T)()24T4(? ?##/*H N#0(? )7?0#(* 0( ?10* A4*C47?H 61071 64A4 *?0// (#?C#**0./4 ) >46 P4)A* )2#F <10* 7A0*0* #> T02A)(?* )7?-)//P #./024* -* ?# ?)$4*C470>07 T4)*-A4*H )(G ?# -(0?4 #-A >#A402( C#/07PF :9 #A :[ P4)A* )2#H D 1)G ?140TCA4**0#( ?1)? LA* L4A$4/ 6)* *#T41#6 )( )GT0(0*?A)?#A 61# )7?4G G)P .PG)P 60?1#-? ) I0*0#(F U#6 D 71)(24G TP T0(GH )(G D ?10($ ?1)? @1)(74//#A L4A$4/1)* ) I0*0#(F L)P.4 ?10* 0* ) *1#A?Y?4AT I0*0#(H .-? 0? *44T* ?# T4 ?1)? ?10* 0*) I0*0#( *C4)$0(2 ).#-? ?14 >-?-A4F D ?10($ D?)/P *1#-/G .41)I4 /0$4 ?10*j 4I4APY?10(2 0(G07)?4* ?10*F

cA)(74 *1#-/G )/*# 4i0? ?10* T#G4 #> .A4)$0(2 )(G 24? G#6( ?# 6#A$F D ?10($?1)? 3#//)(G4H )* ) A4*-/? #> ?14 0TT02A)(? 7A0*0*H 1)* */021?/P 71)(24G 10* )CYCA#)71H 61071 0* 61P 64 1)I4 *-0?)./4 0(*?A-T4(?*H 64 1)I4 ) G#7-T4(? *02(4G.P >0I4 B-A#C4)( CA4*0G4(?*H 61071 0* #> 2A4)? 0TC#A?)(74 0( #-A 7#-(?APH )(G?14A4>#A4 ?14A4 )A4 *#T4 2A#-(G* >#A -(G4A?)$0(2 7#(7A4?4 )7?0#(*F B-A#C4 1)*)/6)P* 6)/$4G >#A6)AGH (#? .47)-*4 G470*0#(* 64A4 T)G4 CA#)7?0I4/PH .-? .4Y7)-*4 ?14 *0?-)?0#( >#A74G -* ?#F D> 64 64(? .)7$ (#6H 0? 6#-/G T4)( ?1)? 6464A4 G4*?A#P0(2 61)? 64 1)G )/A4)GP )7104I4GH )(G ?1)? )7?-)//P ?14 *)>4?P #>#-A 70?0O4(* 6)* ?1A4)?4(4GF <14 *0?-)?0#( >#A74* -* ?# .4 CA#)7?0I4H )(G ?10* 60//1)CC4( >#A *-A4 0( ?14 7#T0(2 P4)A*F

!3L V<C6G 1<3A2?WZD4E?G>=4>4AA0(2 ?# ?14 >)7? ?1)? ?14*4 CA#./4T* >#A74 -* ?# >0(G *#/-?0#(*H *#T4

?0T4 )2# D 6#-/G *)P ?10*J ?14 .4*? CA##> 0* ?10* 7#(>4A4(74 614( =#77# K-??Y02/0#(4H ) >A04(G #> T0(4H ) T)( 61#T D 1)I4 2A4)? A4*C47? >#AH ) >A04(G #> ^#1(,)-/ DD )(G ?14 ,#/4*H G0G (#? T4(?0#( 0( 10* *C4471 ) 6#AG ).#-? f$A)0(4F D 1)I4)CC4)/4GH )>?4A )//H >#A -* ?# /##$ )? ?10* 1#/0*?07)//PF "4 )A4 0( ) *?)?4 #> ) G0)Y/#2-4 #> ?14 G4)> .4?644( ?14 4)*?4A( )(G 64*?4A( C)A?* #> B-A#C4F K/)T0(2 )(G*1)T0(2 /4>? I4AP G44C 6#-(G* )(G ?A)74*H 61071 .#G4* I4AP .)G/PF

:9\

"4 1)I4 ?-A(4G #-A .)7$* ?# 4)71 #?14AH 7#(I0(74G ?1)? P#- 7)( T)()2460?1 $0(G(4** )(G *#/0G)A0?P h 61071 0* ) 7#(?A)G07?0#( 0( 0?*4/> h )(G ?1)? P#-7)( 1)I4 *4/47?0I4 *#/0G)A0?PH 61071 D ?A04G ?# 4i4TC/0>PF U#H P#- 7)((#?H )(GD ?10($ ?1)? 64 1)I4 >#A2#??4( ).#-? ?14 ?4)710(2* #> ^4)( L#((4?H ?1)? 0( B-A#YC4)( 0(?42A)?0#( P#- (44G ?# CA#744G *?4C .P *?4CF D? *44T* ?# T4 ?1)? 0( KA-*Y*4/* ?14 ?4TC?)?0#( ?# ).A-C?/P 71)(24 ?14 C#/0?07)/ *P*?4T 1)* 6#(H .47)-*4 ?1471#074* B-A#C4 0* >)70(2 )A4 (#? 71#074* >A#T ?14 )A4) #> T02A)?0#( C#/07P 7#(Y?A#//4G .P ?14 `0*.#( <A4)?PF <14*4 )A4 ?14 CA#./4T* >A#T ?14 )A4) #> ()?0#()/0G4(?0?PH ()?0#()/ *#I4A402(?P )(G C-./07 *)>4?PF U# ?A4)?P 1)* 4I4A 0(7/-G4G7#(*4(? ?# ?14 ?A)(*>4A #> ?1#*4 C#64A* ?# ?14 /4I4/ #> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(FD .4/04I4 ?1)? 64 60// )// .4 .A#?14A* )(G *0*?4A* #(4 G)P 0( B-A#C4H 614A4)* 0>)(P#(4 ?A04* ?# >#A74 *#T4#(4 ?# *4/47?0I4 *#/0G)A0?PH 0? 24(4A)?4* GA)T)?07 7#(Y*4m-4(74*H 61071 0* 61P D )TH -(/0$4 =#77# K-??02/0#(4H I4AP C4**0T0*?07F

D G0G (#? .4/04I4 ?1)? KA0?)0( 6#-/G /4)I4 ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(H .-? 0? *44T*?# T4 ?1)? )>?4A CA4*4(?0(2 ?14 T)??4A 0( *-71 ) 6)PH ?10* 60// 1)CC4(F M* >#A ?14Q/#I)$ G#-.?*H 61071 D G# (#? *1)A4H D G# )7$(#6/4G24 ?14T )(G )T 6)AP #>?14TH .47)-*4 ?1)? 60// T#I4 -* >)A?14A )6)P >A#T 4)71 #?14AF Q# 64 1)I4 ?# G#) /#? ?# .)7$Y>0// ?10* G0?71H )(G D ?10($ ).#-? ?14 7#TT#( 2##GH (#? ?14 *4/47?0I4#(4F <# G# ?10*H 64 (44G ?# 2# .)7$ ?# ?14 #A020()/ @1A0*?0)( T#?0I)?0#( #>B-A#C4H )(G )(*64A 1#(4*?/P ?14 m-4*?0#( #> 614?14A 64 A4)//P 6)(? ?# 7)AAP#(4 )(#?14A+* .-AG4(*F M(G 0> *# h ?# )(*64A ?10* m-4*?0#( 1#(4*?/PF D? *44T* ?#T4 ?1)? ?14 7#(>A#(?)?0#( .4?644( (#A?14)*?4A( B-A#C4 )(G *#-?14A( B-A#C4 0*) G4(0)/ #> ) 7#TCA414(*0I4H 1#/0*?07 )CCA#)71 ?# *-71 I)/-4* )* *#/0G)A0?P #A?14 I)/-4* G4A0I4G >A#T @1A0*?0)(0?PF

Conclusionof the Conference

:9W

I,G# %&'(# U'N90,9: O8/*2D,<+)% )* +", 5)'+$*$<#6 L'$I,%8$+C )* K)"' 5#36 TT $' =%#>)?

<14#G#A 34-**H ?14 >0A*? CA4*0G4(? #> ?14 c4G4A)/ =4C-./07 #> 54AT)(PH .4Y/04I4G ?1)? B-A#C4 6)* .-0/? #( ?1A44 10//*J ?14 =#T)( @)C0?#/H ?14 5A44$ M7A#CY#/0* )(G ?14 @)/I)APF <14 @)C0?#/ 0* ?14 *PT.#/ #> =#T)( ?A)G0?0#(H 4*C470)//P#> 0?* 7#(74C? #> *?)?4 )(G /)6F <14 M7A#C#/0* A4CA4*4(?* ?14 34//4(0*?07 C10/#*Y#C1P )(G ?14 @)/I)AP 0* ?14 *PT.#/ #> @1A0*?0)(0?PF B)71 #> ?14T 20I4* -*) G0>>4A4(? C4A*C47?0I4 #( ?14 #?14A ?6#F <1A#-21#-? ?14 74(?-A04*H ?14*4 ?1A44C4A*C47?0I4* 1)I4 1)AT#(0#-*/P 7#4i0*?4G )* ) C)A? #> B-A#C4)( 7-/?-A4F <14(474**0?P >#A ?140A 7##C4A)?0#( 0* 1021/P I0*0./4 0( ?14 7#(?4i? #> ?14 A4>-2447A0*0*F

c0A*?H 64 *1)// /##$ )? ?14 =#T)( @)C0?#/H 614A4 ?14 >-(G)T4(?)/ >A44G#T*)(G 1-T)( A021?* 64A4 G4>0(4G 0( )(704(? ?0T4*F 3#64I4AH #(/P ?1#*4 61# 64A4>A44 =#T)( 70?0O4(* )(G 64A4 (#? *-.N47? ?# )(P )-?1#A0?P 1)G ?14 >-// /42)/7)C)70?PF D? 6)* ) I4AP *T)// 2A#-C #> C4#C/4F D? *->>074* ?# *)P ?1)? ?14 >)?14A6)* ?14 #(4 ?# G470G4 ).#-? ?14 /0>4 )(G G4)?1 #> 10* >)T0/P T4T.4A*F `)?4A 0(10*?#APH /42)/ C#*0?0I0*TH 610/4 G4(P0(2 ?14 T#A)/ 4I)/-)?0#( #> /)6 )(G *4)A71Y0(2 >#A 0?* *#-A74 #(/P 0( ?14 )-?1#A0?P+* G470*0#(H /4G )? ?14 4(G ?# 34AT)((5#4A0(2+* )??0?-G4 614( 14 7/)0T4GJ !D 1)I4 (# 7#(*704(74H MG#/> 30?/4A 0* TP7#(*704(74t+F <14 U-A4T.4A2 `)6* 64A4 I#?4G ?1A#-21 0( )77#AG)(74 60?1 ?1454AT)( =4071+* CA#74G-A4* )(G G4CA0I4G 4I4AP 70?0O4( #> ^460*1 #A020( #> )//?140A A021?*F <14 C#*?Y6)A ?A0)/* #> 54AT)( U)O0* CA#I4G ?14 6A#(2>-/(4** #>?14 *4C)A)?0#( #> /)6 )(G T#A)/0?PF M/?1#-21 ?14P /4G 0( :V\X ?# ?14 C)**0(2 #><14 f(0I4A*)/ R47/)A)?0#( #> 3-T)( =021?*H ?14 >)7? ?1)? =0..4(?A#C 6)* 1)(24G)(G L#/#?#I G04G 0( 10* #6( .4G 7#(>0AT* ?14 C#C-/)A *)P0(2 ?1)? 10*?#AP )/Y6)P* N-G24*q0(q>)I#-Aq#> ?14qI07?#A*F <14 /)6 *1#-/G CA#T#?4 1-T)( G02(0?PF<14 A4>-244* 7A#**0(2 ?14 .#AG4A* .A4)$ ?14 /)6 .-? G#4* (#? 1-T)( G02(0?P20I4 ?14T ?14 A021? ?# G# 0?l <14A4>#A4H 0? 0* (474**)AP ?# /##$ >A#T ?14 @)C0?#/ )??14 M7A#C#/0* )(G ?14 @)/I)APF

"4 *1)// (#6 *?#C )? ?14 M7A#C#/0* >#A ) T#T4(?F <14 0(>/-4(74 #> )(704(?7#(74C?* #> ()?-A)/ /)6H 4*C470)//P ?14 Q?#07 )CCA#)71H #( =#T)( /42)/ ?1#-21?64A4 *# 2A4)? ?1)? ?14 ()?-A)/ /)6 0?*4/> 6)* 7#(*0G4A4G )* ?14 ?10AG /)6H (4i? ?#?14 =#T)( 70?0O4(*+ /)6 o6,8 ;6I6D:p )(G ?14 (#(Y70?0O4(*+ /)6 o6,8 4:+?6,GpF<14 =#T)( C10/#*#C14A* A4T0(G -* ?1)? )( -(N-*? /)6 0* (#? ) /)6 )(G ?1)? ?14*#-A74 #> 1-T)( A021?* 0* (#? ?14 *?)?4 )(G 0?* /42)/ *P*?4TH .-? ?14 ()?-A)/ /)6FM77#AG0(2 ?# ?14 ()?-A)/ /)6H ?14 2A#-(G* >#A 1-T)( A021?* )A4 ()?-A)/ >#A ?14

:9X

*?)?4H 1-T)( G02(0?P )(G >A44G#TF <14A4>#A4H 1-T)( A021?* )A4 0(.#A(H 0()/04(Y)./4H 0(I0#/)./4 )(G 7#TT#(F cA#T )(704(? ?0T4*H ?14 ?A-4 T)(0>4*?# #> ?144m-)/0?P )(G -(0I4A*)/0?P #> 1-T)( A021?* )A4 ?14 >#//#60(2 6#AG* #> Q)0(? ,)-/J!<14A4 0* (40?14A ^46 (#A 54(?0/4H (40?14A */)I4 (#A >A44Hq(#A 0* ?14A4 T)/4 )(G>4T)/4Hq>#A P#- )A4 )// #(4 0( @1A0*? ^4*-*+ o5) ZJ8XpF <#G)P ?14 *#-A74 #>1-T)( A021?* 0*H m-0?4 A021?/PH (#? ?# .4 >#-(G 0( ?14 60// #> ?14 )-?1#A0?04* .-? 0(1-T)( G02(0?PH 61071 0* 7#(*0G4A4G ?14 7#TT#( I)/-4H ?14 -(0I4A*)/ A-/4 #>T#A)/0?P )(G ?14 2A#-(G* >#A 1-T)( A021?*F 3#64I4AH ?14 10*?#A07)/ CA#74** #>G0*7#I4A0(2 )(G 0G4(?0>P0(2 1-T)( G02(0?P )(G 0?* A021?* )(G >A44G#T* A4T)0(*m-4*?0#()./4F D( >)7?H 7#(?4*?0(2 )-?1#A0?04* 0( ?10* >04/G /4)G ?# ) 7#(G0?0#( 614(H)77#AG0(2 ?# ^4)(Y,)-/ Q)A?A4+* 6#AG*H ) T)( !7#(G4T(4G ?# .4 >A44+ 7A4)?4* 10*#6( CA0(70C/4* )(G *?)(G)AG*F

M? ?10* C#0(?H 64 (44G ?# /##$ >A#T ?14 C4A*C47?0I4 #> ?14 ?10AG 10//H ?14@)/I)APF 3#6 G0*74A(4G )(G )CCA470)?4G 0* ?14 5#*C4/ T4**)24 )? ?14 ?0T4 #>?14 A4>-244 7A0*0*t c#A ?1)? A4)*#(H ,#C4 Q)0(? ^#1( ,)-/ DD 4iCA4**4G 10* A42A4?)? ?14 >)7? ?1)? 0( ?14 @1)A?4A #> c-(G)T4(?)/ =021?* #> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#(H)G#C?4G #( W R474T.4A 8999H ?14A4 0* (#? ) *0(2/4 A4>4A4(74 ?# 5#GF <14 3#/Pc)?14A ^#1( ,)-/ DD G4>0(4G 1-T)( G02(0?P >A#T ?14 #(?#/#207)/ )(G )i0#/#207)/C#0(? #> I046H )* 20I4( ?# )(G 0TC#*4G #( T)(F <14 >0A*? 0* ?14 )??A0.-?4 #>1-T)(0?P >A#T ?14 T#T4(? #> @A4)?0#(H ?14 #?14A 7#T4* >A#T C4#C/4+* (44G ?#>-/>0/ ?14T*4/I4* ?1A#-21 T#A)//P A021? )7?0#(*F D? 0* (474**)AP ?# )GG ?1)? ?14?14#/#2P N-*?0>04* #(?#/#207)/ 1-T)( G02(0?P #( ()?-A)/ )(G *-C4A()?-A)/ /4I4/*F_( ?14 ()?-A)/ /4I4/H 1-T)( G02(0?P 7#T4* >A#T ?14 >)7? ?1)? C4#C/4 )A4 0(?4//0Y24(?H >A44 )(G A4*C#(*0./4 .40(2*F _( ?14 *-C4A()?-A)/ /4I4/H 1-T)( G02(0?P 0*N-*?0>04G .P ?14 >)7? ?1)? 5#G 7A4)?4G T)( 0( 30* #6( 0T)24F 5#G 1)* A4I4)/4G10T*4/> ?# T)($0(GH 34 G04G >#A T)(H 4(?A-*?4G ?14 ?A-?1 ?# 10T )(G 7)//4G T)( ?#7#TT-(0#( 60?1 30TF D( ?10* 7#(?4i?H ?14 0(?42A)/ 1-T)( G02(0?P ?1)? 0* .#?1()?-A)/ )(G *-C4A()?-A)/ 0* ?14 *#-A74 #> 1-T)( A021?*F <14 #(/P A021?* ?1)? 7)(>-//P *47-A4 1-T)( G02(0?P )A4 ?14 #(4* ?1)? A4*C47? ?14 ?A-?1 ).#-? T)( h ?14>A44G#TH *#70)/ )(G *#/0G)A0?P A021?*F <#G)PH ?14 4TC1)*0* #( ?14 0(?42A0?P #> 1-YT)( A021?* 0* 7A-70)/ G-4 ?# ) ?4(G4(7P ?# A4G-74 ?14T #(/P ?# >A44G#T A021?*F <144i)TC/4 #> ) 7#TC/4?4 7)?)/#2-4 #> 1-T)( A021?* )(G >A44G#T* 7)( .4 >#-(G 0(?14 :V;Z 4(7P7/07)/ 7#;:G 6+ ?:""68 .P ,#C4 Q)0(? ̂ #1( xxDDDF <14 *#70)/ ?4)710(2#> ?14 @1-A71H 4*C470)//P #> ?14 A474(? ,#C4*H .47#T4* T#A4 A4/4I)(? )(G (474*Y*)AP 0( ?14 *0?-)?0#( 614( ?14 0//Y7#(740I4G 0G4) #> >A44G#T 0* ) ?1A4)? 4I4( ?#?14 A021? ?# /0>4 )(G m-4*?0#(* ?14 >#-(G)?0#( #> 1-T)( G02(0?PF

D *1)// 7#(7/-G4 ?14 *-TT)AP #> ?10* P4)A+* 7#(>4A4(74 .P 4iCA4**0(2 TPG44C4*? ?1)($* )(G )CCA470)?0#( ?# 30* Bi74//4(74 K0*1#C ,A#>F <)G4-*O ,04AY#(4$H 61# 0* ?14 0(0?0)?#A #> ?14*4 )((-)/ T44?0(2* )(G 61# 1)* .44( ?14 71)0AYT)( #> ?14 #A2)(0O0(2 7#TT0??44 >#A :[ P4)A*F D G0A47? TP 6#AG* #> ?1)($* )/*#

:9V

?# ?14 7#Y#A2)(0O4A* 61# )/6)P* -*4 ?140A .4*? 4(G4)I#-A* 0( #AG4A ?# 4(*-A4?1)? ?14 7#(>4A4(74* )A4 64// #A2)(0O4G )(G #> 1021 m-)/0?Pqh ?14 S#(A)G MG4Y()-4A c#-(G)?0#( 0( ,#/)(GH ?14 =#.4A? Q71-T)( c#-(G)?0#( 0( `-i4T.#-A2H?14 B-A#C4)( ,4#C/4+* ,)A?P 5A#-C 0( ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(?H ?14 !"#$%&U)*+ ,-./0*10(2 3#-*4 0( 5/06074H ?14 @#TT0**0#( #> ?14 K0*1#C*+ @#(>4A4(7Y4* #> ?14 B-A#C4)( @#TT-(0?P @_LB@B )(G ?# #-A T4G0) C)A?(4A*H 3-4%5+6$7%&89:;<+- )(G ?14 @)?1#/07 D(>#AT)?0#( M24(7PF D( C)A?07-/)AH D 6#-/G /0$4 ?#?1)($ ?14 T)A*1)/ #> ?14 ̀ 4**4A ,#/)(G #0I0G4*10Ck#0I#G4*10CH LA L)A4$ Q#6)H>#A 10* 1#(#A)AP C)?A#()24 #> ?14 7#(>4A4(74 )(G >#A 1#*?0(2 ?14 74/4.A)?#APA474C?0#( >#A 0?* C)A?070C)(?*F M? ?10* C#0(?H D *1)// )/*# ?1)($ ?14 R#T0(07)(*61# 64/7#T4G -* /)*? (021? 0( ?140A .4)-?0>-//P A4(#I)?4G T#()*?4APF "4 )A42A)?4>-/ >#A ?14 *1)A4G B-71)A0*? )(G >#A CA4C)A0(2 ?10* *C470)/ )(G I4AP 0(?4A4*?Y0(2 4iC#*0?0#( CA4*4(?0(2 ?14 A071H 74(?-A04*Y#/G 10*?#AP #> P#-A #AG4AF D )/*#G0A47? TP 6#AG* #> 2A)?0?-G4 ?# 30* BT0(4(74 @)AG0()/ Q?)(0*&)6 RO060*O >#ACA4*0G0(2 )? P4*?4AG)P+* B-71)A0*? )* 64// )* ?# 30* Bi74//4(7P MA71.0*1#C @4/Y4*?0(# L02/0#A4H ?14 MC#*?#/07 U-(70# ?# ,#/)(GH >#A 10* 3#T0/PF

D )T I4AP 2A)?4>-/ ?# ,A#>F ^)74$ L)N71A#6*$0 )(G ?# ?14 )-?1#A0?04* #> SA)Y$#6 >#A ?140A )((-)/ *-CC#A? >#A ?14 #A2)(0O)?0#( #> ?14 7#(>4A4(74 )(G >#A CA#YI0G0(2 -* 60?1 .-*4* ?# ?A)(*C#A? #-A 2-4*?*F D 6#-/G /0$4 ?# ?1)($ #-A 71#0A,*)/T#G0) >#A 1#(#-A0(2 /)*? (021?+* L)** 60?1 ?140A *0(20(2H LA d0P)G =)##>>#A 10* 2A4)? 1#*C0?)/0?P )(G ?14 ?A)(*/)?0#( )24(7P >#A ?140A 7##C4A)?0#(F

c0()//PH D 6#-/G /0$4 ?# ?1)($ )// #> ?14 C)A?070C)(?* #> ?10* P4)A+* N-.0/447#(>4A4(74 >#A P#-A )??4(G)(74 )(G I4AP 0(?4A4*?0(2 G4.)?4F

Speakers

::Z

B/T)A KA#$L4T.4A #> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(?H@1)0AT)( #> ?14 B, @#TT0**0#( >#A c#A402( M>>)0A*K#A( 0( :V\; 0( k4A/H 54AT)(PH 14 *?-G04G /)6 )(G C#/0?07)/ *704(74 )(G )>?4A6)AG*6#A$4G )* ) A)G0# N#-A()/0*? )(G (46*C)C4A 7#AA4*C#(G4(?F `)?4AH 14 6)* @#TT0**0#(4A>#A B-A#C4 #> ?14 K#)AG #> ?14 K4A?4/*T)(( @#AC#A)?0#(F cA#T :VWZY:VX:H KA#$ 6)*I074Y71)0AT)( #> ?14 e#-(2 f(0#( #> 54AT)(PF D( :VX9 14 6)* >0A*? 4/47?4G ?# ?14B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(?F KA#$ 6)* ) A4CA4*4(?)?0I4 #> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(? )? ?14 D(Y?4A2#I4A(T4(?)/ @#(>4A4(74 ).#-? ?14 <A4)?04* #> U074 )(G MT*?4AG)TF MGG0?0#()//PH14 6)* 71)0A #> ?14 B,,Y5A#-C )? ?14 Bf @#(*?0?-?0#()/ @#(I4(?0#(F D( 89:: )(G 89:814 6)* ) A4CA4*4(?)?0I4 #> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(? G-A0(2 ?14 (42#?0)?0#(* ).#-? ?14>0*7)/ C)7? )(G ?14 B-A#C4)( Q?).0/0?P L471)(0*TF 34 0* ) .#)AG T4T.4A )(G *C#$4*YT)( >#A >#A402( )>>)0A* #> ?14 B,,F K4*0G4* ?10*H 14 0* ) T4T.4A #> ?14 @#TT0??44 >#Ac#A402( M>>)0A*H 61#*4 71)0AT)( 14 6)* >A#T :VVV -(?0/ 899WH )(G )2)0( 0( 89:\F 34 0*)/*# ) T4T.4A #> ?14 @#(>4A4(74 #> @#TT0??44 @1)0A*H ?14 @#TT0??44 #( @#(*?0?-Y?0#()/ M>>)0A* )(G ?14 G4/42)?0#( >#A A4/)?0#(* 60?1 D(G0)F Q0(74 8998 14 1)* .44( ?14CA4*0G4(? #> ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( #> @1A0*?0)( R4T#7A)?07 "#A$4A* )(G ) .#)AG T4T.4A#> ?14 @RfF 34 6)* 2A)(?4G *4I4A)/ )6)AG*H >#A 4i)TC/4 ?14 _AG4A #> Q? 5A42#AP ?145A4)?H 61071 6)* )6)AG4G ?# KA#$ .P ,#C4 ^#1( ,)-/ DD 0( 8998F MGG0?0#()//PH 0( 899Z14 6)* !L4T.4A #> ?14 e4)A #> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(?+F

RA <1#T)* KA#*4=4/020#-* C10/#*#C14AH ?14#/#20)(H )-?1#AK#A( 0( :V;8H KA#*4 *?-G04G ?14#/#2PH 10*?#AP )(G C10/#*#C1P 0( BA>-A?H K4A/0( )(G )?_i>#AGF D( :VV9 14 C)A?070C)?4G )? ?14 !=#-(G <)./4 #> ?14 e#-?1+ 0( ?14 5R= )(G )7?4G)* 4G-7)?0#()/ 7#(*-/?)(? >#A ?14 @)?1#/07 Q?-G4(? @#TT-(0?P #> K4A/0(F `)?4AH 14 .4Y7)T4 @##AG0()?#A >#A =4/020#( )(G k)/-4 _A04(?)?0#( )? ?14 S#(A)G MG4()-4A c#-(G)Y?0#( )* 64// )* ) T4T.4A #> ?14 B-A#C4)( M7)G4TP #> Q704(74 )(G MA?*F @-AA4(?/PHKA#*4 6#A$* )* ) /47?-A4A )? ?14 -(0I4A*0?04* #> BA>-A? )(G ,#?*G)TF K4P#(G ?1)?H 14 0* )()-?1#A #> *4I4A)/ .##$* )(G C-./07)?0#(*F

,A#>F =#77# K-?02/0#(4k074YCA4*0G4(? #> ?14 D?)/0)( ,)A/0)T4(?K#A( 0( :V\X 0( 5)//0C#/0H D?)/PH 14 *?-G04G /)6 )? ?14 -(0I4A*0?04* #> <-A0( )(G =#T4FK-?02/0#(4 0* ) T4T.4A #> ?14 f(0#( #> @1A0*?0)( R4T#7A)?* )(G ?14 f(0#( #> ?14 @4(Y?A4 ofR@pF cA#T :VV\ -(?0/ 899; 14 6)* ) T4T.4A #> ?14 D?)/0)( ,)A/0)T4(? )(G >A#T899: ?# 899[ L0(0*?4A >#A B-A#C4)( M>>)0A*F 34 6)* @-/?-A4 Q47A4?)AP 0( ?14 7).0(4? #>

::\

K4A/-*7#(0 >A#T 899[ ?# 899; )(G )>?4A6)AG* *4()?#A -(?0/ 899XF 34 1)* .44( I074YCA4*0G4(? #> ?14 D?)/0)( ,)A/0)T4(? *0(74 899XF R-A0(2 10* ?0T4 0( 2#I4A(T4(? 14 6)*)/*# ) L4T.4A #> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(? >A#T :VVVY899:F D( 899[ 14 6)* )6)AG4G?14 2#/G T4G)/ 5/#A0) MA?0* )(G .4P#(G ?1)? 7#(>4AA4G 1#(#-A4G G#7?#A #> ?14 f(0I4AY*0?P #> `-./0( 0( 899\F

M/4**)(GA# @)/7)2(#@#TT0**0#( #> ?14 K0*1#C+* @#(>4A4(74* #> ?14 B-A#C4)( @#TT-(0?Po@_LB@BpK#A( 0( :VW; 0( 54(#I)H D?)/PH @)/7)2(# 1)* .44( ) /42)/ )GI0*4A )? ?14 @_LB@B Q47YA4?)A0)? *0(74 ^-(4 899WF <14A4 14 6)* A4*C#(*0./4 >#A T02A)?0#( )(G )*P/-T 0**-4* >A#T^-/P 899W -(?0/ M-2-*? 89:9F Q0(74 89:9 14 1)* .44( )( )GI0*#A >#A c-(G)T4(?)/ =021?*H7#I4A0(2 ?#C07* *-71 )* 4m-)/0?P )(G (#(YG0*7A0T0()?0#(H G)?) CA#?47?0#(H 710/GA4(+* A021?*)(G ?14 CA#?47?0#( #> T0(#A*H Bf 70?0O4(*10CH >)T0/P C#/0704* )(G N-G070)/ 7##C4A)?0#( 0(70I0/ )(G 7#TT4A70)/ T)??4A* o0(7/-G0(2 >)T0/P /)6 60?1 7A#**Y.#AG4A 0TC/07)?0#(*pH )*64// )* T)??4A* A4/)?4G ?# MA?07/4 :W #> ?14 <A4)?P #( ?14 c-(7?0#(0(2 #> ?14 BfF 34 0*7-AA4(?/P *47A4?)AP #> ?14 @_LB@B `42)/ M>>)0A* @#TT0**0#(F LA @)/7)2(# 1)* ?)$4(C)A? 0( I)A0#-* /42)/ C-./07)?0#(* 7#(74A(0(2 )A4)* *-71 )* *?)?4Y71-A71 A4/)?0#(*H CA0YI)7P /)6 )(G 70I0/ /)6F

@)AG0()/ RA Q?)(0*&)6 RO060*OMA71.0*1#C #> SA)$#6K#A( 0( :VZV 0( =).) "P�()H ,#/)(GH 14 2A)G-)?4G >A#T ?14 R4C)A?T4(? #> ,10/#*#C1P)(G <14#/#2P )? ?14 Q4T0()AP 0( SA)$#6F D( :V;Z 14 6)* #AG)0(4G .P ?14 >#AT4A MA71Y.0*1#C #> SA)$#6H S)A#/ "#N?P&)H 61# 6)* ?# .47#T4 ,#C4 ^#1( ,)-/ DDF Q?)A?0(2 0(:V;;H 14 *4AI4G )* *47A4?)AP ?# MA71.0*1#C "#N?P&)H $44C0(2 10* C#*0?0#( )/*# /)?4A 0(?14 k)?07)(F D( :VVX 14 6)* #AG)0(4G K0*1#C .P ^#1( ,)-/ DDH 61#T 14 7#(?0(-4G *4AIY0(2 -(?0/ 10* G4)?1 0( MCA0/ 899[F D( ^-(4 899[H @)AGF RO060*O 6)* (#T0()?4G )* L4?A#YC#/0?)( MA71.0*1#C #> SA)$#6 .P ,#C4 K4(4G07? xkDF 34 1)* .44( )CC#0(?4G 5%;?%"<%+%"68 ;#,8# )? *4I4A)/ -(0I4A*0?04*H )T#(2*? #?14A* )? ?14 ^#1( ,)-/ DD @)?1#/07 f(0YI4A*0?P #> `-./0( )(G ?14 ,4G)2#207)/ f(0I4A*0?P #> SA)$#6F Q0(74 899W 14 1)* .44() T4T.4A #> ?14 7#-(70/ #> ?14 ,#/0*1 K0*1#C @#(>4A4(74 )(G 71)(74//#A )? ?14 ,#(?0>0Y7)/ f(0I4A*0?P #> ^#1( ,)-/ DD 0( SA)$#6F

RA M(GAO4N 5A)N46*$034)G #> ?14 4G0?#A0)/ G4C)A?T4(? !"#A/G+ #> ?14 644$/P J%[\ ]6:596:D+-K#A( 0( :V[Z 0( K04/*$#YK0)&)H ,#/)(GH 0( :VWX 5A)N46*$0 2A)G-)?4G >A#T ?14 f(0I4AY*0?P #> Q0/4*0) 0( S)?#6074 60?1 ) ?14*0* 0( ?14 >04/G #> C#/0?07)/ *704(74*F <14A4)>?4AH.4?644( :VWX )(G :VX:H 14 6#A$4G )* )( )7)G4T07 )**0*?)(? )? ?14 Q0/4*0)( Q704(?0>07D(*?0?-?4F Q0(74 :VX: 14 1)* 6#A$4G >#A ?14 4G0?#A0)/ G4C)A?T4(? #> ?14 644$/P J%[\]6:596:D+-H 61#*4 7104> 4G0?#A 14 .47)T4 0( :VVXF D( ?14 :VX9* 14 C)A?070C)?4G )7?0I4/P60?10( ?14 Q#/0G)A0?P ?A)G4 -(0#(F D( ?14 :VV9* 14 .47)T4 ) T4T.4A #> ?14 ,#/0*1Y=-*Y*0)( 5A#-C >#A R0>>07-/? D**-4* )* 64// )* 7#Y71)0AT)( #> ?14 c#-(G)?0#( >#A ,#/0*1Y54AT)( @##C4A)?0#(F

::[

M(GAO4N 5AOP.L4T.4A #> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(?HL4T.4A #> ?14 B, Q-.7#TT0??44 #( 3-T)( =021?*K#A( 0( :V[; 0( Q04G/0$%6H ,#/)(GH 5AOP. 0* ) T4T.4A #> ?14 ,#/0*1 ,4#C/4+* ,)A?Po,Q`pF 34 *?-G04G )2A07-/?-A)/ C#/07P )(G )2A07-/?-A)/ /)6 0( ,#O()}F 34 *4AI4G )*) L4T.4A #> ?14 ,#/0*1 ,)A/0)T4(? oQ4NTp .4?644( :VXVY:VV:H :VVZY:VVW )(G 899:Y899VF M? ?14 *)T4 ?0T4H 14 6)* 71)0AT)( #> ?14 ,)A/0)T4(?)AP @#TT0??44 >#A MGT0(0*Y?A)?0#( )(G ?14 D(?4A0#A o:VVZ h :99;pH G4C-?P 14)G #> ?14 ,#/0*1 R4/42)?0#( ?# ?14 D(?4AY,)A/0)T4(?)AP f(0#( o:VVZ h :VVWp )(G 14)G #> ?14 ,)A/0)T4(?)AP @#TT0??44 >#A B-A#YC4)( D(?42A)?0#(F D( )GG0?0#( 14 6)* 7#Y71)0A #> ?14 ,)A/0)T4(?)AP @#TT0??44 #> ?14,#/0*1 ,)A/0)T4(? M**#70)?0#(F cA#T 899: ?# 899[ 14 6)* ?14 G4C-?P 71)0AT)( #> ?14,)A/0)T4(?)AP @#TT0??44 >#A B-A#C4)( M>>)0A*H ) T4T.4A #> ?14 ,)A/0)T4(?)AP @#TYT0??44 >#A MGT0(0*?A)?0#( )(G ) T4T.4A #> ?14 ,#/0*1 G4/42)?0#( ?# ?14 ,)A/0)T4(?)APM**4T./P #> ?14 @#-(70/ #> B-A#C4F R-A0(2 899ZY899\ 14 6)* )( #.*4AI4A 0( ?14 B-A#YC4)( ,)A/0)T4(?F Q0(74 899V 14 1)* .44( ) L4T.4A #> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(?F 5AOP.6)* 4/47?4G ?# ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(? >#A ?14 >0A*? ?0T4 0( 899\H )(G 6)* ) L4T.4A #>?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(? >A#T L)P ?# ^-/P 899\F 34 6)* A4Y4/47?4G 0( 899V )(G )2)0( 0(89:\F @-AA4(?/PH 14 1)* >-(7?0#(* )* ) T4T.4A #> ?14 @#TT0??44 #( ?14 B(I0A#(T4(?H,-./07 34)/?1 )(G c##G Q)>4?PH ?14 Q-.7#TT0??44 #( 3-T)( =021?*H ?14 R4/42)?0#( ?#?14 BfYL#/G#I) ,)A/0)T4(?)AP M**#70)?0#( @#TT0??44 )(G ?14 R4/42)?0#( ?# ?14B-A#(4*? ,)A/0)T4(?)AP M**4T./PF 34 0* ) *-.*?0?-?4 T4T.4A 0( ?14 @#TT0??44 #( c#AY402( M>>)0A* )(G ?14 R4/42)?0#( ?# ?14 BfY<-A$4P ^#0(? ,)A/0)T4(?)AP @#TT0??44F D()GG0?0#(H 14 1)* A4740I4G ?14 =7%D%+6# Q:8?6?,?#@ S(021?+* @A#** #> ?14 _AG4A #> ,#/)(G=4.#A( )(G ?14 5#/G @A#** #> L4A0?F

5PaA2P 3a/Ib(P0L4T.4A #> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(?H=4CA4*4(?)?0I4 #> L)(>A4G "4.4A h @1)0AT)( #> ?14 B,, 0( ?14 B,K#A( 0( :V;8H 14 1#/G* ) ?4)710(2 G42A44 0( 3-(2)A0)( /0?4A)?-A4 )(G 10*?#APH )(G C)**4G?14 C#*?2A)G-)?4 CA#2A)T >#A 47#(#T07* )(G ?#-A0*TF 34 0* ) >#-(G0(2 T4T.4A #> ?14@1A0*?0)( R4T#7A)?07 ,4#C/4+* ,)A?P #> 3-(2)AP )(G >#-(G4A 71)0AT)( #> ?14 e#-?1@1A0*?0)( R4T#7A)?07 f(0#(F Q0(74 8999 14 1)* .44( 71)0AT)( #> ?14 K)A)($#I07* M7)YG4T07 c#-(G)?0#(F D( :VVV 14 .47)T4 R4C-?P Q?)?4 Q47A4?)AP #> ?14 L0(0*?AP #> e#-?1)(G QC#A?*F cA#T 899WY899V 14 6)* R4C-?P Q47A4?)AP 54(4A)/ #> ?14 =#.4A? Q71-T)(c#-(G)?0#( #> ?14 B,, 5A#-CF K4?644( 899VY89:8 14 )7?4G )* ?14 /4)G4A #> ?14 B,,5A#-C+* Q47A4?)A0)? >#A D(?4A7-/?-A)/ R0)/#2-4 )(G =4/020#-* M>>)0A*F cA#T 89:8Y89:\14 6)* Q47A4?)AP #> Q?)?4 >#A ?14 =4/)?0#(* 60?1 @1-A714*H U)?0#()/ L0(#A0?04* )(G@0I0/ Q#704?P )? ?14 3-(2)A0)( L0(0*?AP >#A U)?0#()/ =4*#-A74* oQ#70)/ L)??4A*H @-/?-A4)(G BG-7)?0#(pF M? ?14 T#T4(? 14 0* ) L4T.4A #> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(? )(G ) T4TY.4A #> ?14 @#TT0??44 #( ?14 B(I0A#(T4(?H ,-./07 34)/?1 )(G c##G Q)>4?P )(G ?14 R4/Y42)?0#( ?# ?14 BfYM/.)(0) Q?).0/0O)?0#( )(G M**#70)?0#( ,)A/0)T4(?)AP @#TT0??44FMT#(2 #?14A* 14 0* ) *-.*?0?-?4 0( ?14 @#TT0??44 #( @-/?-A4 )(G BG-7)?0#( )(G ?14@#TT0??44 #( ,4?0?0#(*F

::;

=4IF RA c/#A0)( S#/>1)-*Q47A4?)A0)? #> Q?)?4 #> ?14 3#/P Q44K#A( 0( :VW\ 0( Q?A)-.0(2H 54AT)(PH L#(*F RA c/#A0)( S#/>1)-* 0* ) CA04*? #> ?14 G0#Y74*4 #> =424(*.-A2 )(G *?)>> #> ?14 ,#(?0>07)/ Q47A4?)A0)? #> Q?)?4F 34 *?-G04G )? ?14,#(?0>07)/ 5A42#A0)( f(0I4A*0?P )(G 2A)G-)?4G 60?1 ) G#7?#A)?4 0( 899; 0( ?14 ?A)G4!G#2T)+ )(G ?14 )7m-0*0?0#( #> /074(?0)?4 0( 7)(#( /)6F c#//#60(2 ?10*H 14 7#(?0(-4G 10**?-G04* )? ?14 ,#(?0>07)/ B77/4*0)*?07)/ M7)G4TP .4?644( 899\ )(G 899; )(G 0( ?14U-(70)?-A4 0( K#2#?)H @#/#T.0) )(G 0( 899W 0( ?14 B-A# B-A#C4 0( Q?A)*.#-A2F Q0(74M-2-*? 899V c/#A0)( S#/>1)-* 1)* 6#A$4G 0( ?14 Q47#(G Q47?0#( #> ?14 ,#(?0>07)/ Q?)?4Q47A4?)A0)? 0( =#T4F 30* T)0( 6#A$0(2 )A4) 0* 7#(?)7? 60?1 0(?4A()?0#()/ .#G04* *-71 )*?14 _Q@BH UM<_ )(G "3_F M( 0TC#A?)(? ?#C07 #> 10* 6#A$ 0* ?14 A4*4)A71 #( G0*Y7A0T0()?0#( )2)0(*? @1A0*?0)(* 0( B-A#C4F MC)A? >A#T 10* 6#A$ )* ) CA04*?H 14 0* 0( ?14@)?1#/07 >A)?4A(0?P !@)C0?#/0()+F

RA R#T0(0$) S#O&#6*$)@104> 4G0?#A #> ?14 T#(?1/P T)2)O0(4 Y]N!R#T0(0$) S#O/#6*$) o.#A( 0( :VWXp 0* ) ,#/0*1 C-./070*? )(G C10/#*#C14A 61#+* 7-AYA4(?/P 7104> 4G0?#A #> ?14 T#(?1/P T)2)O0(4 Y]N!F Q14 *?-G04G C10/#*#C1P )? ?14 ,#(Y?0>07)/ <14#/#207)/ M7)G4TP 0( SA)$#6 )(G A4740I4G 14A ,1R 0( ,10/#*#C1P 0( 899;FQ14 6)* 14)G #> ?14 4G0?#A0)/ G4C)A?T4(? !<10($0(2 0( k)/-4*+ )(G 1)* .44( 6#A$0(2 >#A?14 T#(?1/P T)2)O0(4 Y]N! *0(74 89:9H 0(0?0)//P )* T4T.4A #> ?14 !=4/020#-* )(G ,10/#Y*#C107)/ ̀ 0?4A)?-A4+ 4G0?#A0)/ G4C)A?T4(?F D( )GG0?0#(H *14 0* ) /)-A4)?4 #> (-T4A#-* CA0O4*F

3#A*? `)(24*3#(#A)AP ,A4*0G4(? #> ?14 =#.4A? Q71-T)( c#-(G)?0#( 0( `-i4T.#-A2K#A( 0( :V8X 0( S#./4(OH 54AT)(PH 3#A*? `)(24* *?-G04G 54AT)( *?-G04*H 10*?#APH C10Y/#/#2P )(G ?14#/#2P )? ?14 -(0I4A*0?04* #> L)0(O )(G L-(071F 34 )/*# 6#A$4G >#A ) *#T4?0T4 )* ) ?4)714AF D( :V[8 14 N#0(4G ?14 @RfF D( :V;9 3#A*? `)(24* 6)* 4/47?4G ?# ?147#-(70/ #> ?14 70?P #> <A04AF 34 6)* ) T4T.4A #> ?14 =10(4/)(GY,)/)?0()?4 `)(G?)2 >A#T:V;W ?# :VW[ )* ) @Rf C#/0?070)( )(G *4AI4G >A#T :VW\ ?# :VWV )* Q47A4?)AP #> Q?)?4 0(?14 L0(0*?AP #> @-/?-A4 #> =10(4/)(GY,)/)?0()?4F cA#T :VWV ?# :VV\ 14 6)* ) L4T.4A#> ?14 Bf ,)A/0)T4(?H )(G 0( :VV\ 14 14/G ?14 C#*0?0#( #> R4C-?P @1)0AT)( #> ?14 B,,5A#-CF cA#T :VV[ ?# 899W 3#A*? `)(24* 6)* 3#(#A)AP @#(*-/ #> ?14 5A)(G R-71P #>`-i4T.#-A2H <A04AF cA#T :VXV 14 6)* ) T4T.4A #> ?14 =#.4A? Q71-T)( c#-(G)?0#( 0(`-i4T.#-A2 )(G /)?4A #( >#A ) /#(2 ?0T4 71)0AT)( #> ?14 c#-(G)?0#(F @-AA4(?/PH 14 0*?14 3#(#A)AP ,A4*0G4(? #> ?14 =QcF

::W

,A#>F RA 1).0/F DA4() `0C#607O=4?0A4G _T.-G*6#T)( #> ?14 =4C-./07 #> ,#/)(GH@)AG0()/ Q?4>)( "P*OP}*$0 f(0I4A*0?PK#A( 0( :V[\ 0( 5/06074H ,#/)(GH `0C#607O *?-G04G /)6 )(G )GT0(0*?A)?0#( )? ?14 f(0YI4A*0?P #> Q0/4*0) 0( S)?#6074H 614A4 *14 2A)G-)?4G 0( :VW;F M>?4A6)AG*H *14 .47)T4 )()7)G4T07 )**0*?)(? )(G /47?-A4AF D( :VX: *14 A4740I4G 14A ,1R )(G 1).0/0?)?4G *-774**Y>-//P 0( :VV8F Q0(74 :VVX *14 1)* .44( ) CA#>4**#A >#A )GT0(0*?A)?0I4 /)6 )? ?14 @)AG0()/Q?4>)( "P*OP}*$0 f(0I4A*0?P 0( ")A*)6F cA#T :VV: ?# 8999 *14 6)* ) T4T.4A #> ?14Q4NTH ?14 ,#/0*1 ,)A/0)T4(?H 1)I0(2 .44( )( 0(G4C4(G4(? 7)(G0G)?4 #> ?14 cA44G#Tf(0#(H 61071 0* *-7744G4G .P ?#G)P+* R4T#7A)?07 ,)A?PF Q0(74 14A 7#TT0?T4(? 0( ?14Q4NT *14 1)* )/6)P* .44( 0(I#/I4G 0( ?14 >A)T46#A$ #> ?14 0(?4A()?0#()/ 7#TT-(07)Y?0#( .4?644( 54AT)(P )(G ,#/)(GF c#//#60(2 ?10*H `0C#607O 6)* )T.)**)G#A #> ?14=4C-./07 #> ,#/)(G 0( M-*?A0) -(?0/ 89:\F D( )GG0?0#(H *14 6)* A4CA4*4(?)?0I4 #> ?14,#/0*1 c#A402( L0(0*?AP 0( T)??4A* #> 54AT)(Y,#/0*1 7##C4A)?0#( -(?0/ 899;F Q-.*4Ym-4(?/PH *14 6)* G0A47?#A #> ?14 c#-(G)?0#( >#A ,#/0*1Y54AT)( @##C4A)?0#( .4?644(899X )(G 89:9F D( 89:9 *14 6)* 4/47?4G _T.-G*6#T)( #> ,#/)(G )? ?14 *-224*?0#( #>?14 ,_ o@0I07 ,/)?>#ATp )(G *14 A4T)0(4G 0( ?10* C#*0?0#( -(?0/ 89:\F @-AA4(?/PH ,A#>FRA 1).0/F DA4() `0C#607O 0* 71)0A6#T)( #> ?14 B-A#C4)( _T.-G*T)( D(*?0?-?4F Q14 0*1#/G4A #> ?14 L4A0? @A#** #> ?14 c4G4A)/ =4C-./07 #> 54AT)(P )* 64// )* ?14 5#/G4(_AG4A #> L4A0? >#A *4AI074* A4(G4A4G ?# ?14 =4C-./07 #> M-*?A0)F D( 899V *14 A4740I4G )(1#(#A)AP G#7?#A)?4 >A#T ?14 f(0I4A*0?P #> _*().A�7$F

M.C RA @4/4*?0(# L02/0#A4MC#*?#/07 (-(70# 0( ,#/)(GK#A( 0( :V[8 0( @-(4#H D?)/PH L02/0#A4 6)* #AG)0(4G CA04*? #( 8[ ^-(4 :VWWF 34 *?-G04G)? ?14 @4(?A4 >#A <14#/#207)/ Q?-G04* 0( ,#**)(# )(G 2A)G-)?4G 0( ?14 >04/G #> 7)(#( /)6)? ?14 ,#(?0>07)/ `)?4A)( f(0I4A*0?P 0( =#T4F M>?4A 10* 2A)G-)?0#( >A#T ?14 ,#(?0>07)/B77/4*0)*?07)/ M7)G4TP 0( :VX9 14 .42)( 10* G0C/#T)?07 *4AI074 0( M(2#/)F <10* 6)*>#//#64G .P *?)P* 0( ?14 fQ )(G B2PC?F R-A0(2 :VXVY:VV8 14 6)* )( 4TC/#P44 #> ?14MA71.0*1#C ^%O4> S#6)/7OP$F R-A0(2 ?14 >#//#60(2 ?1A44 P4)A* 14 6)* 4(I#P 4i?A)#AG0Y()AP #> ?14 3#/P Q44 )? ?14 B-A#C4)( @#-(70/ 0( Q?A)*.#-A2F D( R474T.4A :VV[ 14.47)T4 R4C-?P Q47A4?)AP >#A Q?)?4 =4/)?0#(* )? ?14 Q47A4?)A0)? #> Q?)?4 #> ?14 3#/P Q44FD( ?10* C#*0?0#( 14 /4G G4/42)?0#(* ?# @10()H k04?()T )(G Q#-?1 S#A4)F D( 8998 14 6)*)CC#0(?4G )A71.0*1#C )(G MC#*?#/07 (-(70# )(G 14 .47)T4 C4AT)(4(? #.*4AI4A #> ?143#/P Q44 )? ?14 fU 0( 89:9Fq

=%(�( L-//4(D(G4C4(G4(? Q4()?#A 0( ?14 Q4()?4 #> DA4/)(GK#A( 0( :VW9 0( @#-(?P 5)/6)PH DA4/)(GH L-//4( *?-G04G )T#(2*? #?14A* B(2/0*1 )(GcA4(71 )? ?14 U)?0#()/ f(0I4A*0?P DA4/)(G 0( 5)/6)P )(G /)?4A #.?)0(4G ) T)*?4A�* G4Y2A44 0( N#-A()/0*T >A#T R-./0( @0?P f(0I4A*0?PF <14A4)>?4A 14 6#A$4G >#A ) 74A?)0( C4YA0#G )* ) ?4)714A )(G CA4** *47A4?)APH )* 64// )* 0( *4I4A)/ )GT0(0*?A)?0I4 C#*0?0#(* )?G0>>4A4(? -(0I4A*0?04*F D( :VVV 14 .42)( 10* *?-G04* >#A ) G0C/#T) 0( /42)/ *?-G04* )(G

::X

) K)AA0*?4AY)?Y`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c)T0/P M>>)0A* @#TT0??44F D( 899WL-//4( .47)T4 ) T4T.4A #> ?14 Q4()?4 #> DA4/)(GH ?14 *#Y7)//4G Q4)()G �0A4)((H 614A414 6)* A4Y4/47?4G 0( 89::F D( ?14 @#-(70/ #> B-A#C4 )* 64// )* 0( ?14 Q4)()G �0A4)((HL-//4( 6)* I#7)/ #( .41)/> #> T02A)(?*+ 1-T)( A021?*H >A44G#T #> 7#(*704(74H I07?0T*#> 1-T)( ?A)>>07$0(2 )* 64// )* G4I4/#CT4(? )0G )(G *#70)/ 64/>)A4 CA#?47?0#( #> ?1447#(#T07)//P I-/(4A)./4F @-AA4(?/PH L-//4( 0* )/*# ) T4T.4A #> ?14 ^#0(? @#TT0??44*#( Q#70)/ ,A#?47?0#( )* 64// )* ?14 ^#0(? @#TT0??44 #( B-A#C4)( M>>)0A*F

d.02(046 U#*#6*$0"A0?4A >#A ?14 T#(?1/P T)2)O0(4 _6`aK#A( 0( :V;8H U#*#6*$0 *?-G04G *#70)/ *704(74* )? ?14 f(0I4A*0?P #> ")A*)6H ?14#/#2P)? ?#G)P+* @)AG0()/ Q?4>)( "P*OP}*$0 f(0I4A*0?P #> ")A*)6 )(G )? ?14 B7-T4(07)/D(*?0?-?4 0( K#**4PH 7/#*4 ?# 54(4I)H Q60?O4A/)(GF Q0(74 899: 14 1)* .44( ?14 7104>4G0?#A #> ?14 @)?1#/07 T#(?1/P T)2)O0(4 _6`aF cA#T 8998 ?# 899X 14 6)* 7#-(*4/ 0( ?14,#(?0>07)/ @#-(70/ >#A ?14 `)0?PF M>?4A6)AG*H 14 .47)T4 I074 CA4*0G4(? #> ?14 ,#/0*1@#-(70/ #> @1A0*?0)(* )(G ̂ 46*F 34 0* 7-AA4(?/P ) T4T.4A #> ?14 @#-(70/ #> ?14 M-*7160?OYK0A$4()- c#-(G)?0#(F D( 899[ 14 6)* ()T4G ) /)-A4)?4 #> ?14 ,#/#(0) =4*?0?-? )6)AGFq

RA ^)( _/.AP71?L4T.4A #> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(?H@1)0AT)( #> ?14 ,#/0*1 R4/42)?0#( 0( ?14 B,, 0( ?14 B,K#A( 0( :V[8 0( =P.(0$H ,#/)(GH 14 *?-G04G )? ?14 R4C)A?T4(? #> Q#70#/#2P )? ?14^)204//#(0)( f(0I4A*0?P 0( SA)$#6 )(G G4>4(G4G 10* G#7?#A)/ ?14*0* 0( :VX\F cA#T :VV9?# :VVX 14 6)* T)P#A #> @04*OP( )(G 7#Y>#-(G4A #> ?14 B-A#A420#( @04*OP( Q0/4*0)F 34/)?4A .47)T4 L)A*1)/ #> ?14 Q0/4*0)( k#0I#G4*10C o:VVX ?# 8998pF 34 6)* ) T4T.4A #>?14 .#)AG #> ?14 M**4T./P #> B-A#C4)( =420#(* o8999Y899\pH ?14 @#-(70/ >#A =420#()/,#/0?07* o8999Y899\p )(G ?14 "#A/G @#-(70/ #> ?14 _A2)(0O)?0#( #> f(0?4G @0?04* )(G`#7)/ 5#I4A(T4(?* o0( 899\pF Q0(74 899\H RA _/.AP71? 1)* .44( ) L4T.4A #> ?14 B-A#YC4)( ,)A/0)T4(? >#A @0I07 ,/)?>#AT o,_pH 614A4 14 *4AI4* )* T4T.4A #> ?14 @#TT0??44#( K-G24?* )(G ?14 G4/42)?0#( >#A A4/)?0#(* 60?1 ?14 7#-(?A04* #> Q#-?14)*? M*0) )(G ?14M**#70)?0#( #> Q#-?14)*? M*0)( U)?0#(* oMQBMUpL 34 0* ) *-.*?0?-?4 T4T.4A #> ?14@#TT0??44 #( =420#()/ R4I4/#CT4(? )(G ?14 R4/42)?0#( ?# ?14 BfYL#(?4(42A# Q?).0Y/0O)?0#( )(G M**#70)?0#( ,)A/0)T4(?)AP @#TT0??44F ^)( _/.AP71? 0* /)-A4)?4 #> *4I4A)/CA0O4* )(G )6)AG*H )T#(2 #?14A* ?14 B-A#C4 ,A0O4 >#A `#7)/ )(G =420#()/ ,#/07P )(G?14 B-A#Y,)A/0)T4(?)A0)( #> ?14 e4)A M6)AG 899W 0( ?14 7)?42#AP =420#()/ ,#/07PF

::V

K0*1#C ,A#>F RA <)G4-*O ,04A#(4$@1)0AT)( #> ?14 _A2)(0O0(2 @#TT0??44>#A !<14 =#/4 #> ?14 @)?1#/07 @1-A71 0( ?14 B-A#C4)( D(?42A)?0#( ,A#74**+K#A( 0( :VZ\ 0( =)GO0471#6PH ,#/)(GH >A#T :V[: ?# :V[\ <)G4-*O ,04A#(4$ *?-G04G )??14 ^)204//#(0)( f(0I4A*0?P 0( SA)$#6H ?14( )? ?14 *4T0()AP 0( SA)$#6F cA#T :V[; ?#:V;9H 14 7#(?0(-4G 10* 4G-7)?0#( )? ?14 @)?1#/07 f(0I4A*0?P 0( `-./0(F cA#T :V;: ?# :V;[14 *?-G04G )? ?14 ,#(?0>07)/ `)?4A)( f(0I4A*0?P 0( =#T4F K0*1#C <)G4-*O ,04A#(4$ 1).0/0Y?)?4G 0( :VW[ )(G 0( :VXW 6)* )CC#0(?4G CA#>4**#A #> 7)(#( /)6F 34 6)* A47?#A #> ?14,#(?0>07)/ M7)G4TP #> <14#/#2P 0( SA)$#6 )(G 6)* 7#(*47A)?4G 0( :VV8 .P ,#C4 ^#1(,)-/ DDF cA#T :VVZ ?# :VVX K0*1#C ,04A#(4$ 6)* ?14 54(4A)/ Q47A4?)AP #> ?14 ,#/0*1BC0*7#C)/ @#(>4A4(74F cA#T :VVX ?# 899\ 14 6)* A47?#A #> ?14 ,#(?0>07)/ M7)G4TP #><14#/#2PF 34 0* @1)0AT)( #> ?14 _A2)(0O0(2 @#TT0??44 #> ?14 D(?4A()?0#()/ @#(>4A4(74*4A04* ?0?/4G !<14 =#/4 #> ?14 @)?1#/07 @1-A71 0( ?14 B-A#C4)( D(?42A)?0#( ,A#74**+F D(89:: 14 A4740I4G )( 1#(#A)AP G#7?#A)?4 .P ?14 ,4G)2#207)/ f(0I4A*0?P #> SA)$#6F

,)?A0)A71 Kb71)A) ,04AA4 =)0 _LLL)A#(0?4 ,)?A0)A71 #> M(?0#71H 14)G #> ?14 L)A#(0?4 @1-A71K#A( 0( :V\9 0( 30T/)P)H `4.)(#(H )>?4A 1)I0(2 )??4(G4G ) ^4*-0? *71##/ 0( `4.)(#(H 144(?4A4G ?14 L)A0)T0?4 L)A#(0?4 _AG4AF 34 *?-G04G C10/#*#C1P )(G ?14#/#2P )? ?14 ,#(Y?0>07)/ `)?4A)( f(0I4A*0?P 0( =#T4 )(G A4740I4G ) ,1R 0( 7)(#( )(G 70I0/ /)6F 34 6)*#AG)0(4G )* ) CA04*? 0( :V;W )(G ?14( .47)T4 G0A47?#A #> ?14 Q71#/)*?07)?4 L)A0)T0?4L)A#(0?4 _AG4A 0( =#T4F M>?4A6)AG*H 14 6)* )CC#0(?4G G0A47?#A #> ?14 Q)0(? =0?) Q71##/0( R.)P41 )(G N-G24 #> ?14 ,)?A0)A71)/ <A0.-()/F D( :VX;H ?14 L)A#(0?4 ,)?A0)A71)/ QP(#G4/47?4G 10T C)?A0)A71)/ I07)A )(G ?0?-/)A .0*1#C #> @4*)A4) G0 c0/0CC#F D( :VV9 14 6)*?A)(*>4AA4G )(G .47)T4 .0*1#C #> ?14 4C)A71P #> ^.40/ oKP./#*pF D( L)A71 89:: Kb71)A),04AA4 =)0 _LL 6)* 4/47?4G L)A#(0?4 ,)?A0)A71 #> M(?0#71 .P ?14 L)A#(0?4 QP(#G )(G*0T-/?)(4#-*/P .47)T4 .0*1#C #> ?14 4C)A71P #> ^-..4H Q)A.) )(G ^#-(041F D( U#I4TY.4A 89:8 14 6)* )CC#0(?4G )* ) 7)AG0()/ .P ,#C4 K4(4G07? xkD )(G *0(74 89:Z 1)* .44() T4T.4A #> ?14 @#(2A42)?0#( >#A @)?1#/07 BG-7)?0#(F

,A#>F RA Q)T0A S1)/0/ Q)T0A Q^,A#A47?#A )? ?14 ,#(?0>07)/ _A04(?)/ D(*?0?-?4 0( =#T4K#A( 0( :VZX 0( @)0A#H B2PC?H 0( :V[[ 14 .42)( ?# *?-GP C10/#*#C1PH ?14#/#2P )(GD*/)T07 *?-G04* )(G *0T-/?)(4#-*/P N#0(4G ?14 ^4*-0? _AG4A 0( M0iY4(Y,A#I4(74H cA)(74Fc#//#60(2 ?10*H 14 2A)G-)?4G 60?1 ) ?14*0* #( #A04(?)/ @)?1#/07 ?14#/#2P )(G D*/)T07*?-G04*F M>?4A 1)I0(2 /0I4G ?4TC#A)A0/P 0( K0AT0(21)T )(G 0( ?14 U4?14A/)(G*H Q)T0A4*?)./0*14G (-T4A#-* 4G-7)?0#()/ 0(*?0?-?4* >#A A4)G0(2 )(G 6A0?0(2 0( B2PC? )(G ?14A4Y)>?4A ?)-21? >#A :8 P4)A* )? ?14 ,#(?0>07)/ _A04(?)/ D(*?0?-?4 0( =#T4F @-AA4(?/PH 14 0*CA#>4**#A )? ?14 ,#(?0>07)/ _A04(?)/ D(*?0?-?4 0( =#T4H )? ?14 @4(?A4 Q4IA4* G4 <1b#/#2040( ,)A0* )* 64// )* )? ?14 L)m)*0G D(*?0?-?4 0( K40A-?F D( 899V 14 6)* )CC#0(?4G 7#(*-/?4A#> ?14 54(4A)/ Q47A4?)AP #> ?14 4C0*7#C)/ *P(#G .P ,#C4 K4(4G07? xkDF Q)T0A 0* (#?#(/P ?14 )-?1#A #> I)A0#-* )A?07/4* )(G .##$*H .-? )/*# ) 7#(*-/?4A #> I)A0#-* 71-A71#>>070)/* )(G C#/0?070)(* 0( B-A#C4 )(G ?14 L0GG/4 B)*?F D( 899[ 14 A4740I4G ?14 3-T.#/G?=4*4)A71 M6)AGF

:89

RA ^)74$ Q)AP-*OY"#/*$0LB,H 7#Y71)0AT)( #> ?14 C)A/0)T4(?)AP B-A#C4)( ,4#C/4+* ,)A?P 2A#-CK#A( 0( :V\X 0( �%G~H ,#/)(GH Q)AP-*OY"#/*$0 *?-G04G )(G 2A)G-)?4G 0( ?14 >04/G #>47#(#T07 *704(74* )? ?14 f(0I4A*0?P #> �%G~F D( ?14 :VX9* 14 C)A?070C)?4G )7?0I4/P 60?10(?14 Q#/0G)A0?P ?A)G4 -(0#(F M? ?1)? ?0T4H 14 )/*# ?)-21? )* ) -(0I4A*0?P /47?-A4AH )T#(2*?#?14A* )? *4I4A)/ >#A402( -(0I4A*0?04* ?1A#-21#-? 10* (-T4A#-* *?)P* ).A#)GF K4?644(:VXX )(G :VV: 14 6)* G0A47?#A #> ?14 @4(?A4 >#A B)*? B-A#C4)( Q?-G04* )? ?14 f(0I4A*0?P#> �%G~F 34 6)* ) 2#I4A(T4(? G4/42)?4 >#A B-A#C4)( )>>)0A* >A#T :VV: ?# :VV; )(G*?)?4 *47A4?)AP >#A B-A#C4)( )>>)0A* >A#T 899: ?# 8998F Q)AP-*OY"#/*$0 6)* I074YA47?#A#> ?14 @#//424 #> B-A#C4 0( KA-24* )(G 0( U)?#/0( o")A*)6p >A#T :VVW ?# :VVV )* 64//)* 7104> )GI0*#A 0( T)??4A* #> B-A#C4)( 0(?42A)?0#( >#A ,A0T4 L0(0*?4A ^4AOP K-O4$F 34.4/#(2* ?# ?14 ,_ o@0I07 ,/)?>#ATp C)A?PH 6)* 0(0?0)//P 4/47?4G LB, 0( 899\ )(G A4Y4/47?4G *0(74 ?14( 0( 899V )(G 89:\F cA#T 899; ?# 89:9 14 6)* 7#Y71)0AT)( #> ,_ 0(,#/)(G )(G 71)0AT)( #> ?14 ,#/0*1 2A#-C 60?10( ?14 C)A/0)T4(?)AP B-A#C4)( ,4#C/4+*,)A?P 2A#-C >A#T 899\ ?# 89:8F<#G)PH Q)AP-*OY"#/*$0 0* ) T4T.4A #> ?14 @#TT0??44 #( c#A402( M>>)0A*H ?14 @#TT0?Y?44 #( @#(*?0?-?0#()/ L)??4A*H ?14 BfYf$A)0(4 ,)A/0)T4(?)AP M**#70)?0#( @#TT0??44o,M@p )* 64// )* ?14 R4/42)?0#( ?# ?14 B-A#(4*? ,)A/0)T4(?)AP M**4T./PF 34 0* >-A?14AYT#A4 G0A47?#A #> ?14 Bf 0(*?0?-?4 #> ?14 @#//420-T @0I0?)*H 71)0AT)( #> ?14 B-A#C4)(@4(?A4 0( U)?#/0( o")A*)6p )(G #> ?14 B-A#C4)( @#//420-T c#-(G)?0#( )(G /)*?/P /47Y?-A4A )? ?14 @#//420-T @0I0?)* 0( ")A*)6F

RA ,)?AP7N) Q)*()/,#/0*1 D(*?0?-?4 >#A D(?4A()?0#()/ M>>)0A*cA#T :VVV ?# 899[ Q)*()/ *?-G04G 0(?4A()?0#()/ A4/)?0#(* )? ?14 D(*?0?-?4 #> ,#/0?07)/Q704(74* )? ?14 ^)204//#(0)( f(0I4A*0?P 0( SA)$#6F Q0T-/?)(4#-*/PH *14 *?-G04G MA).07C10/#/#2P )? ?14 *)T4 -(0I4A*0?PF K4P#(G ?1)?H *14 *?-G04G )* ) *71#/)A*10C 1#/G4A )? ?14^#1( 3#C$0(* f(0I4A*0?P 0( ")*10(2?#( 0( ?4AT* #> ?14 c-/.A021? Q71#/)A*10C ,A#2A)TFM>?4A 1)I0(2 2A)G-)?4G 0( 899;H *14 6#A$4G )* /47?-A4A 0( ?14 R4C)A?T4(? #> @#TC)A)Y?0I4 Q#70)/ Q704(74* )? ?14 ^)204//#(0)( f(0I4A*0?PF Q0(74 899W *14 1)* 6#A$4G )* )()()/P*? >#7-*0(2 #( ?14 L0GG/4 B)*? )? ?14 ,#/0*1 D(*?0?-?4 >#A D(?4A()?0#()/ M>>)0A*F

,A#>F K)/�O* Q71)(G)Ba?Ia* `#A�(G f(0I4A*0?P 0( K-G)C4*?K)/�O* Q71)(G) 4)A(4G 10* G42A44 0( /42)/ )(G C#/0?07)/ *704(74* )? Ba?Ia* `#A�(G f(0YI4A*0?P 0( K-G)C4*?F 34 1#/G* ) /074(?0)?4 0( 7)(#( /)6H ) ,1R )(G ) 1).0/0?)?0#( 0( /42)/*704(74*F 34 0* 14)G #> ?14 R4C)A?T4(? #> @#(*?0?-?0#()/ `)6 )? ?14 c)7-/?P #> `)6 )(G,#/0?07)/ Q704(74* #> ?14 ,�OT�(P ,b?4A @)?1#/07 f(0I4A*0?P 0( K-G)C4*?F 34 /47?-A4*)(G C-./0*14* T)0(/P 0( 7#(*?0?-?0#()/ /)6H 477/4*0)*?07)/ /)6H A4/020#-* >A44G#T 0**-4*)(G 71-A71Y*?)?4 A4/)?0#(*F

:8:

RA BI0?) Q71T042Q?0>?-(2 "0**4(*71)>? -(G ,#/0?0$ o54AT)( D(*?0?-?4 >#A D(?4A()?0#()/)(G Q47-A0?P M>>)0A*pH =4*4)A71 R0I0*0#(J BfyB-A#C4K#A( 0( :V;: 0( L)((140T o54AT)(PpH Q71T042 *?-G04G .-*0(4** )GT0(0*?A)?0#( )? ?14f(0I4A*0?P #> ?14 Q))A/)(G 0( Q))A.A�7$4(H 54AT)(P )(G 2A)G-)?4G 0( :VX; 60?1 ) G0YC/#T) 0( 47#(#T07* )? ?14 f(0I4A*0?P #> @#/#2(4F cA#T :VV: ?# :VV\ *14 6#A$4G >#A?14 Bf @#TT0**0#( 0( KA-**4/* 0( ?14 >04/G #> ?A)G4 C#/07PH T)0(/P >#7-*0(2 #( ?14 M@,2A#-C #> *?)?4*F c#//#60(2 ?10*H *14 6)* *4(0#A 47#(#T0*? 0( ?14 c4G4A)/ L0(0*?AP >#AB7#(#T07 @##C4A)?0#( )(G R4I4/#CT4(?H A4*C#(*0./4 >#A ?14 >04/G* #> ?A)G4 )(G 7#TYT#G0?P C#/07PH )* 64// )* C/)((0(2 )(G 7A0*0* CA4I4(?0#(F <14A4)>?4AH *14 .47)T4 14)G #>?14 <A)G4H 5/#.)/0O)?0#( )(G D(I4*?T4(? R0I0*0#( #> ?14 c4G4A)/ L0(0*?AP >#A B7#(#T07@##C4A)?0#( )(G R4I4/#CT4(? )(G A4T)0(4G 0( ?10* C#*0?0#( -(?0/ 89:ZF Q0(74 ?14(HQ71T042 1)* 6#A$4G >#A 54AT)( D(*?0?-?4 >#A D(?4A()?0#()/ )(G Q47-A0?P M>>)0A* )* )()**#70)?4 0( ?14 BfyB-A#C4 =4*4)A71 R0I0*0#(F D( 899\ *14 #.?)0(4G 14A G#7?#A)?4 >A#T?14 f(0I4A*0?P #> `40CO02F

RA @1A0*?0)( Q71T0?OR0A47?#A #> ?14 S#(A)G MG4()-4A c#-(G)?0#( 0( ,#/)(GK#A( 0( :V[V 0( `0T.-A2 )F GF `)1(H 54AT)(PH 14 *?-G04G 10*?#AP )(G =#T)(07 *?-G04*FK4?644( :VX[ )(G :VXV 14 #.?)0(4G 10* G#7?#A)?4 0( 10*?#AP >A#T ,A#>F RA M(GA4)*30//2A-.4AF 34 6)* ) >A44/)(74 N#-A()/0*? )? ?14 !bD+68;<: Q,+58;<#,H ) >A44/)(74A )??14 54AT)( @##C4A)?0#( #> c#A402( ,#/07P 4FkF )(G A4740I4G ) *71#/)A*10C )? ?14 54AYT)( D(*?0?-?4 #> 30*?#AP 0( ,)A0*F Q0(74 :VV9H 14 1)* 6#A$4G )? ?14 S#(A)G MG4()-4Ac#-(G)?0#( 4FkF oSMQpF D(0?0)//PH 14 6#A$4G )* ?14 14)G #> ?14 K0/G-(2*64A$ o4G-7)Y?0#()/ A420#()/ #>>074p 0( Q))A.A�7$4(F cA#T :VV8 ?# 899Z 14 6)* 14)G #> ?14 R4C)A?YT4(? >#A @0I07 BG-7)?0#( .)*4G 0( ?14 @4(?A4 >#A ,#/0?07)/ BG-7)?0#(H B0711#/O @)*?/4FD( U#I4T.4A 899Z 14 .47)T4 ?14 A4*0G4(? A4CA4*4(?)?0I4 #> ?14 SMQ #>>074 0( d)2A4.H@A#)?0)F cA#T Q4C?4T.4A 899X ?# L)P 89:: 14 6)* ?14 SMQ A4CA4*4(?)?0I4 0(KA)(G4(.-A2H .)*4G 0( ?14 4G-7)?0#()/ 0(*?0?-?4 0( ,#?*G)TF Q0(74 M-2-*? 89:: 14 1)*.44( ?14 G0A47?#A #> ?14 SMQ #>>074 0( ,#/)(GF

L)A4$ Q#6)L)A*1)/ #> `4**4A ,#/)(GK#A( 0( :V;W 0( `0.0��H ,#/)(GH L)A4$ Q#6) 2A)G-)?4G >A#T ?14 M53 f(0I4A*0?P #>Q704(74 )(G <471(#/#2P 0( SA)$#6F Q0(74 :VVV 14 1)* 6#A$4G >#A ?14 L)A*1)/ _>>074#> `4**4A ,#/)(GF D( 899; 14 6)* 4/47?4G ?# ?14 A420#()/ )GT0(0*?A)?0#( #> `4**4A ,#/)(G#( .41)/> #> @0I07 ,/)?>#AT o,_pF _(4 P4)A /)?4A 14 .47)T4 ) T4T.4A #> ?14 .#)AG #>?14 `4**4A ,#/)(G k#0I#G4*10CF Q0(74 10* A4Y4/47?0#( 0( 89:9 )(G 89:\H 14 1#/G* ?14#>>074 #> ?14 L)A*1)/ #> `4**4A ,#/)(GF

:88

MA?-A QC#A(0)$3-4%5+6$ 7%&89:;<+-K#A( 0( :V;;H MA?-A QC#A(0)$ *?-G04G C10/#*#C1P )? ?14 ,#(?0>07)/ M7)G4TP #> <14#/Y#2P 0( SA)$#6F Q0(74 :VVZ 14 1)* 6#A$4G )* ) N#-A()/0*? )(G 0* ?14 G0A47?#A #> ?14A4/020#( G4C)A?T4(? #> ?14 644$/P 3-4%5+6$ 7%&89:;<+-F 34 0* )/*# 7#Y)-?1#A )(G C-.Y/0*14A #> (-T4A#-* )A?07/4*H .##$* )(G 0(?4AI046*H *-71 )* N,?%A6%4"#><-H K?#6"&#- ?%U:#I:+ )(G K:;":?8 %B ?<: c"5:" 7#I4A0(2 ?14 ?#C07* #> >)0?1 )(G 4?107*F

^)74$ Q?)60*$0@104> 4G0?#A #> ?14 !�60)?+ 4G0?#A0)/ G4C)A?T4(?#> ?14 ?4/4I0*0#( *?)?0#( <kU K0O(4* 0 �60)?K#A( 0( :VW9H .4?644( :VVX )(G :VVZ Q?)60*$0 *?-G04G 10*?#AP )? ?14 ^)204//#(0)( f(0YI4A*0?P 0( SA)$#6F M>?4A 2A)G-)?0(2 14 6#A$4G >#A ?14 A)G0# *?)?0#( =Lc cLF cA#T899W ?# 89:Z 14 6#A$4G )* 4G0?#A >#A ?14 ?4/4I0*0#( *?)?0#( <kU8\H 614A4 14 G0A47?4G?14 T)2)O0(4 !3#APO#(?+ ?1)? G4)/* 60?1 0(?4A()?0#()/ )>>)0A*F Q0(74 ^)(-)AP 89:\ 14 1)*.44( 7104> 4G0?#A #> ?14 !�60)?+ 4G0?#A0)/ G4C)A?T4(? #> ?14 ?4/4I0*0#( *?)?0#( <kU K0O(4*0 �60)?F

S)?)AOP() <A)7O3-4%5+6$ 7%&89:;<+-K#A( 0( :VX[H *14 0* ) N#-A()/0*? 61# *?-G04G 0(?4A()?0#()/ A4/)?0#(* )? ?14 <0*71(4A B-YA#C4)( f(0I4A*0?P 0( SA)$#6F @-AA4(?/P *14 *?-G04* /)6 )? ?14 ^)204//#(0)( f(0I4A*0?P0( SA)$#6F Q0(74 899[ *14 1)* 6#A$4G >#A ?14 4G0?#A0)/ #>>074 #> ?14 644$/P 3-4%5+6$7%&89:;<+-H 0( ?14 >04/G #> A4/020#-*H *#70)/ )(G 0(?4A()?0#()/ 0**-4*F M* ) CA#N47? 7##AYG0()?#AH *14 6#A$* )/#(2*0G4 ?14 ;FD#&2%"4 ?10($ ?)($ ?1)? G4)/* 60?1 7#TT4A70)/ )(G7#TC)(P /)6F

RA =)>)& <AO)*$#6*$0Q?)?4 *47A4?)AP >#A B-A#C4)( M>>)0A* #> ?14 c#A402( L0(0*?AP#> ?14 =4C-./07 #> ,#/)(GK#A( 0( :VW8 0( ")A*)6H ,#/)(GH <AO)*$#6*$0 *?-G04G B(2/0*1 /)(2-)24 )(G /0?4A)?-A4)* 64// )* C#/0?07)/ *704(74* )? ?14 f(0I4A*0?P #> ")A*)6 )(G ?14 @#//424 #> B-A#C4 0(U)?#/0(F D( :VV; 14 *?-G04G )* ) *71#/)A*10C 1#/G4A )? ?14 f(0I4A*0?P #> _i>#AGF M>?4AY6)AG* 14 6#A$4G )* ?A)(*/)?#A )(G /47?-A4AF K4?644( 8999 )(G 89:: 14 6#A$4G )* )()GI0*#A >#A ?14 Q47A4?)AP #> ?14 @#TT0??44 #( B-A#C4)( D(?42A)?0#( )(G 0( P4)A* 899\ h899V )GG0?0#()//P )* )GI0*#A >#A ?14 ,_ G4/42)?0#( o@0I07 ,/)?>#ATp 0( ?14 B-A#C4)(,)A/0)T4(?F D( ?14 P4)A* 899VY89:Z 14 6)* ) L4T.4A #> ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(? >#A,_F Q-.*4m-4(?/PH 14 6)* )CC#0(?4G L0(0*?4A #> MGT0(0*?A)?0#( )(G R020?)/0O)?0#( .PR#()/G <-*$ )(G 4i47-?4G ?10* #>>074 -(?0/ 14 6)* )CC#0(?4G Q?)?4 Q47A4?)AP >#A B-A#YC4)( M>>)0A* 0( 89:\F D( 899\ <AO)*$#6*$0 #.?)0(4G 10* G#7?#A)?4 >A#T ?14 f(0I4A*0?P#> ")A*)6F

:8Z

_$*)() e-AP(4?*L4T.4A #> ?14 k4A$1#I() =)G) #> f$A)0(4 o,4?A# ,#A#*14($# K/#7pH@#TT0??44 >#A B-A#C4)( D(?42A)?0#(e-AP(4?* 0* ) f$A)0(0)( C#/0?070)( )(G T4T.4A #> ?14 k4A$1#I() =)G)H .4/#(20(2 ?# ?14,4?A# ,#A#*14($# K/#7H ?1)? 7#(*#/0G)?4G 60?1 ?14 fRM= C#/0?07)/ C)A?P #> k0?)/0S/0?*71$# 0( M-2-*? 89:[ )(G *?A0I4* >#A 7##C4A)?0#( .4?644( f$A)0(4 )(G ?14 B-A#YC4)( f(0#(F K4P#(G ?1)?H *14 0* ) T4T.4A #> ?14 @#TT0??44 #( B-A#C4)( D(?42A)?0#(F

RA M(() d�.#A*$�LB,H L4T.4A #> ?14 @#TT0**0#( #( "#T4(+* =021?* )(G 54(G4A Bm-)/0?Pd�.#A*$� 6)* .#A( 0( :V\X 0( d-A071H Q60?O4A/)(G )(G 0* ) Q/#I)$0)( C1P*070)( )(GC#/0?070)(F Q0(74 :VVZ *14 1)* ?)$4( C)A? )* ) C#/0?070)( 0( ?14 Q/#I)$0)( C#/0?07)/ C)A?PSR3 o@1A0*? R4T#7A)?07 L#I4T4(?p )(G 6)* ) T4T.4A #> ?14 Q/#I)$0)( ,)A/0)T4(?>A#T :VVX ?# 899\F M* ) T4T.4A #> ?14 N#0(? C)A/0)T4(?)AP 7#TT0??44H *14 C)A?070C)?4G0( ?14 CA4C)A)?0#( CA#74** #> Q/#I)$0)+* )774**0#( ?# ?14 BfF M>?4A ?14 4(?AP #> Q/#I)$0)0(?# ?14 B-A#C4)( f(0#( *14 6)* 4/47?4G ?# ?14 B-A#C4)( ,)A/0)T4(? 614A4 *14 .4Y/#(24G ?# ?14 C)A/0)T4(?)AP B-A#C4)( ,4#C/4+* ,)A?P 2A#-CF D( ?14 C4A0#G .4?644( 899\)(G 899V *14 6)* A4Y4/47?4G >#A 14A C#*0?0#( )* LB,F @-AA4(?/PH *14 0* I074Y71)0A #> ?14G4/42)?0#( #> ?14 C)A/0)T4(?)AP 7#TT0??44 @)A0>#A-TYBfH T4T.4A #> ?14 R4I4/#CT4(?@#TT0??44H ?14 @#TT0??44 #( D(G-*?APH =4*4)A71 )(G B(4A2P )* 64// )* ?14 @#TT0??44#( "#T4(+* =021?* )(G 54(G4A Bm-)/0?PF c-A?14AT#A4H d�.#A*$� 0* ) T4T.4A #> ?14G4/42)?0#( #> ?14 M@,YBf N#0(? C)A/0)T4(?)AP )**4T./PFq

,A#>F M(GAO4N d#//=4?0A4G _T.-G*T)( #> ?14 =4C-./07 #> ,#/)(GH ^)204//#(0)( f(0I4A*0?PK#A( 0( :V\8 0( Q04(0)6)H ,#/)(GH ,A#>F M(GAO4N d#// *?-G04G /)6 )? ?14 ^)204//#(0)(f(0I4A*0?P #> SA)$#6H 614A4 #.?)0(4G 10* G#7?#A)?4 0( :V;X )(G *-774**>-//P G4>4(G4G10* G#7?#A)?4 ?14*0* 0( :VWZF 34 .47)T4 >-// CA#>4**#A )? ?14 ^)204//#(0)( f(0I4A*0?P 0(:VV:F D( :VXV 14 C)A?070C)?4G )* ) /42)/ 4iC4A? >#A ?14 .)((4G Q#/0G)A0?P ?A)G4 -(0#( 0(?14 (42#?0)?0#(* 60?10( ?14 >A)T46#A$ #> ?14 ,#/0*1 =#-(G <)./4 <)/$*H 61071 *02(0>0Y7)(?/P 7#(?A0.-?4G ?# ?14 G4T#7A)?07 ?A)(*0?0#( >A#T ?14 7#TT-(0*? A420T4 ?#6)AG* ?14=4C-./07 #> ,#/)(GF 34 6)* 71)0AT)( #> ?14 4/47?#A)/ 7#TT0**0#( #> ,#/)(G >A#T :VV9?# :VVZF K4?644( :VXV )(G :VVZ d#// 6)* N-G24 )? ?14 @#(*?0?-?0#()/ @#-A? 61#*4CA4*0G4(? 14 *-.*4m-4(?/P .47)T4F 34 A4T)0(4G CA4*0G4(? #> ?14 @#(*?0?-?0#()/ @#-A?-(?0/ :VVW )(G 6)* )GG0?0#()//P )CC#0(?4G I074Y71)0AT)( #> ?14 ,4()/ ̀ )6 =4>#AT @#TYT0**0#( >A#T :VXV ?# 8999F K4?644( :VVX )(G 8999 14 6)* 71)0AT)( #> ?14 `42)/MGI0*#AP K#)AG ?# ?14 71)0AT)( #> ?14 L0(0*?4A0)/ @#-(70/F L#A4#I4AH d#// 6)* #TY.-G*T)( #> ?14 =4C-./07 #> ,#/)(G .4?644( 8999 )(G 899; )(G 6)* 4/47?4G I074YCA4*0YG4(? #> ?14 B-A#C4)( _T.-G*T)( D(*?0?-?4 0( 8998F 34 /47?-A4G )? 54AT)(H M-*?A0)( )*64// )* Q60** -(0I4A*0?04* )(G 0* 7-AA4(?/P /47?-A4A )? ?14 Q71##/ #> `)6 )(G ,-./07MGT0(0*?A)?0#( 0( =O4*O%6 o,#/)(GpF 34 1)* A4740I4G )( 1#(#A)AP G#7?#A)?4 >A#T *4IY4A)/ -(0I4A*0?04* )(G 0* >-A?14AT#A4 /)-A4)?4 #> (-T4A#-* CA0O4* )(G )6)AG*H 61071 64A4

:8\

)6)AG4G ?# 10T 0( G0>>4A4(? 7#-(?A04*F K4P#(G ?1)?H 14 6)* )CC#0(?4G 14)G #> ?14 7#-(Y70/ #> ?14 !U04 /4$)N704 *0�+ ,#C4 ^#1( ,)-/ DD @4(?A4 .P ?14 ,#/0*1 CA4/)?4 #> SA)$#6HQ?)(0*&)6 RO060*OF D( )GG0?0#( ?# ?1)?H ,A#>F M(GAO4N d#// 0* )-?1#A #> T#A4 ?1)( :X9C-./07)?0#(* ?1)? 1)I4 .44( C-./0*14G 0( T)(P /)(2-)24*F

,A#>F RA "#N70471 dPO)$=47?#A #> ?14 ,#(?0>07)/ f(0I4A*0?P #> ^#1( ,)-/ DD 0( SA)$#6K#A( 0( :V;V 0( dP6047H ,#/)(GH "#N70471 dPO)$ *?-G04G ?14#/#2P >A#T :VXWY:VVZ )??14 ,#(?0>07)/ M7)G4TP #> <14#/#2P 0( SA)$#6F D( :VVZ 14 6)* #AG)0(4G ) CA04*? >#A?14 R0#74*4 #> K04/*$#YdP6047F K4?644( :VV; )(G 8999 14 A4740I4G 10* G#7?#A)?4 >A#T?14 @)?1#/07 f(0I4A*0?P #> `-./0(F M>?4A6)AG* 14 ?)-21? )? ?14 <14#/#207)/ @#//424 #>Q?F ^#1( @)(?0-* 0( K04/*$#F cA#T 899Z ?# 899; 14 A4*4)A714G 0( @#/#2(4H 614A4-C#(14 6A#?4 10* 1).0/0?)?0#( ?14*0* )? ?14 ,M<F c#A >-A?14A A4*4)A71 I0*0?*H "#N70471 dPO)$64(? ?# MI02(#( ) P4)A /)?4AF Q1#A?/P )>?4A6)AG* 14 *?)A?4G 10* 6#A$ )? ?14 ,#(?0>07)/M7)G4TP 0( SA)$#6F Q0(74 899V 14 1)* .44( 4G0?#A #> 7%D%+6# K#;"# )(G *0(74 89:\A47?#A #> ?14 ,#(?0>07)/ f(0I4A*0?P #> ^#1( ,)-/ DD 0( SA)$#6F

L)A70( gP&)3-4%5+6$ 7%&89:;<+-K#A( 0( SA)$#6H ,#/)(GH L)A70( gP&) 6)* 4G0?#A #> ?14 Q#70)/ LM=S ,-./0*10(2 D(*?0Y?-?4 .4?644( 899; )(G 89:9F Q0(74 89:: 14 1)* .44( ) N#-A()/0*? >#A )(G 4G0?#A #> ?14644$/P 3-4%5+6$ 7%&89:;<+-F 34 1)* A4C#A?4G #( *-71 ?#C07* )* ?14 >#AT4A e-2#*/)I0))(G *#-?14)*?4A( B-A#C4 >#A ]:&8&::$ 7%D#+5H E96:++6$ 7%D8$6 )(G Y+#$F 34 0* )/*#7#Y4G0?#A #> ?14 T)2)O0(4 W,"%>: d N+ V+B6+68<:5 7"%H:;?H 61071 A42-/)A/P C-./0*14*) *4A04* #> 0(?4AI046* 60?1 /4)G0(2 B-A#C4)( 0(?4//47?-)/* *-71 )* L)A?0( ,#//)7$H 3)(*Y54A? ,#4??4A0(2H 5PaA2P QC0A#H R-.A)I$) f2A4�0�H 3)(* =#*/0(2H =#77# K-??02/0#(4 #A`-$4 K�A>-**F

!"#$%&"' )#* +,"&%-."/ )0%/%-01%-234 5#36* 7"$89-0 5%8#3&8:

!3&68#8&;8 #8;84,%3& $8-:

)# !2#%-,%"& +;2<%,0 =3#-, >"&?8-

!3&68#8&;8 ?98-,-

!3&68#8&;8 ?98-,-

@AB#?A =B'CD&A%E"#8: +3/"

1%-234 )# F"&9-0 +,84&3/-:% )# F"& G'H#A;2,

5"#,%;%4"&,- %& ,28 ;3&68#8&;8

)# I"6". 7#0"-:3/-:%F8"&J!'"9$8 F9&;:8#

5"#,%;%4"&,- %& ,28 ;3&68#8&;8

5#36* K&$#08L M3''

I8C* )# N'3#%"& O3'62"9-

P'<"# 1#3:

!"#$%&"' 1D;2"#" 139,#3- I"%**

KH4* )# !8'8-,%&3 E%?'%3#8

=3'A <"-- %& ,28 1"-%'%;" 36 ,28 =3'A 7#%&%,A %& O#":3/

QQ /3#:%&? ?#394 R 8$%,3# MH%?&%8/ S3-3/-:% T<3$8#",3#UV 5#36* Q#8&" >%43/%;0V5#36* +"<%# O2"'%' +"<%# +F

Q /3#:%&? ?#394 R )# )3<%&%:" O30.3/-:" T<3$8#",3#UV 52)* K&&" MWH3#-:W"&$ 5#36* 723<"- 1#3-8

QQQ /3#:%&? ?#394 R K&$#08L @#0AHV )# K&$#08L @#"L8/-:% T<3$8#",3#UV IX&W& E9''8&V5#36* 1"'W0- +;2"&$"

!3'9<&%-,- 6#3< !"#$%&'( *$+,-./0&" R K#,9# +43#&%":V O","#0A&" 7#";0 "&$ E"#;%& YA."R -9<<"#%08$ ,28 $%-;9--%3&- %& ,28 /3#:%&? ?#394-

P$%,3# F";8: +,"/%-:% T<3$8#",3#UV K#;2H%-234 QC"& M3#%"V 5#36* I3;;3 19,,%?'%3&8

G:-"&" Z9#A&8,-V )# F";8: +"#A9-0J[3'-:%V )# 5",#A;L" +"-&"'

At previous conferencesour guests were

Archbishop Celestino MiglioreApostolic Nuncioto the United Nationsin New York

Archbishop Józef ŻycińskiMetropolitan of Lublin

Franz FischlerMember of the EuropeanCommission for Agriculture

Jaś GawrońskiMember of the EuropeanParliament from Italy

Rev. Prof. Andrzej SzostekRector of the CatholicUniversity of Lublin

Archbishop Józef KowalczykApostolic Nuncio to Poland

Cardinal Attilio NicoraItalian Bishops�Conference

Stephen BillerEuropean Parliament,advisor to EPP

Prof. Danuta HübnerMinister for EuropeanAffairs in the PolishGovernment

Dr Piotr Nowina-KonopkaRector of the NatolinEuropean Centre

Prof. Wojciech ŚwiątkiewiczVice-Rector of the Universityof Silesia

Zbigniew SulewskiEconomist fromthe Adam Smith Centre

Rev. Noël TreanorSecretary General of theCommission of theBishops� Conferences ofthe European Community(COMECE)

Tadeusz MazowieckiFormer Prime Minsterof the Republic of Poland

Aleksander KwaśniewskiPresident of the Republic ofPoland

Prof. BronisławGeremekFormer Ministerof Foreign Affairsof the Republic of Poland

Prof. Dr Hans-GertPötteringChairman of the EPP-EDGroup in the EuropeanParliament

Cardinal Jean-Louis TauranSecretary for Relations withStates of the Holy See

Prof. Norman Daviespublicist and historian

Prof. HannaGronkiewicz-WaltzVice-President of theEuropean Bankfor Reconstructionand Development

Horst LangesHonorary Presidentof the Robert SchumanFoundationin Luxemburg

Ursula StenzelMember of the EuropeanParliament from Austria

Jan TruszczyńskiChief negotiatorof Poland�s membershipin the EU

Prof. Aniela DylusCardinal StefanWyszyński Universityin Warszawa

Prof. Rocco ButtiglioneMinister for EuropeanAffairs in the Italiangovernment

Prof. WładysławBartoszewskiFormer Ministerof Foreign Affairsof the Republicof Poland

Cardinal AudrysJuozas BačkisMetropolitan of Vilnius

Elmar BrokMember of the EuropeanParliament fromGermany

Dr Jan KułakowskiFormer Plenipotentiaryof the Republic ofPoland, Poland�s chiefnegotiator for EUaccession

Rev. Prof. RemigiuszSobańskiChurch ConcordatCommission

Cardinal Angelo ScolaPatriarch of Venice

Prof. Hanna SuchockaAmbassador of theRepublic of Polandto the Holy See

Peter LieseMember of the EuropeanParliament fromGermany

Prof. Leszek BalcerowiczPresident of the NationalBank of Poland

Archbishop Paul GallagherApostolic Nuncioto Burundi

Jacek Saryusz-WolskiVice-President of theEuropean Parliament

Cardinal Paul PoupardPresident of the PontificalCouncil for Culture

Prof. Irena LipowiczAmbassador of theRepublic of Polandto Austria

Carl AndersonSupreme Knight of theKnights of Columbus,USA

Bishop Josef HomeyerPresident of the Commission ofthe Bishops� Conferences ofthe European Community(COMECE)

Jan RokitaDeputy to the PolishParliament

Marek GrelaAmbassador of theRepublic of Polandto the EU

Dr Andrzej OlechowskiFormer Minister of ForeignAffairs of the Republicof Poland

Pier-Ferdinando CasiniPresident of the ItalianChamber of Deputies

Bishop Franjo KomaricaBishop of Banja Luka

Jerzy SwatońMinister of EnvironmentalProtection of the Republicof Poland

Cardinal Dr StanisławDziwiszMetropolitan of Krakow

Prof. Hans J. MeyerPresident of the CentralCommittee of GermanCatholics

Ireneusz JabłońskiEconomist from theAdam Smith Centre

Henryka BochniarzPresident of the PolishFederation of PrivateEmployers

Prof. Jacques SanterMember of the EuropeanParliament, Presidentof the Robert SchumanFoundation in Luxemburg

WłodzimierzCimoszewiczMinister of ForeignAffairs of the Republicof Poland

Adam MichnikEditor-in-chiefof Gazeta Wyborcza

Prof. Józef PacynaDirector of the Europeanscale Centre forEcological Economicsat NILU (Norway)

Rev. Prof. Jan DyduchRector of the PontificalAcademy of Theologyin Crakow

Prof. Jerzy BuzekMember of the EuropeanParliament from Poland

Dr Helmut KohlFormer Chancellorof the Federal Republicof Germany

Cardinal Walter KasperPresident of the PontificalCouncilfor Promoting ChristianUnity

Archbishop TadeuszKondrusiewiczMetropolitan of Moscow,President of the Bishops�Conference of theRussian Federation

General MieczysławBieniekCommander-in-chiefof the MultinationalDivision in Iraq

Prof. Bernhard VogelPresident of the KonradAdenauer Foundation,former President ofThuringia

Cardinal Marian JaworskiRoman CatholicMetropolitan of Lvov

Fr Dr Adam Wąs SVDArab Philologist, Centrefor Cultural and ReligiousDialogue in Pieniężno

Dr Andrzej AnaniczFormer Ambassadorof the Republicof Poland to Turkey

Dr Jan OlbrychtMember of the EuropeanParliament from Poland

Dr Naika ForoutanLecturer at the Universityin Göttingen

Cardinal FranciszekMacharskiMetropolitan of Krakow

Fr Prof. Emilio Platti OPExpert on dialogue withIslam, Leuven University

Prof. Alfred GrosserThe Sorbonne, publicistand political scientist

Alojz PeterleMember of the EuropeanParliament from Slovenia

Krzysztof BobińskiPublicist, expert of thePolish Instituteof International Affairs

Prof. Stefan MellerDiplomat, formerMinister of ForeignAffairs of the Republicof Poland, University ofWarsaw

Archbishop GiovanniLajoloSecretary for the HolySee�s Relations withStates

Dr Jacek CichockiCentre for EasternResearch

Rev. Prof. PiotrMazurkiewiczCardinal StefanWyszyński Universityin Warsaw

Archbishop Prof.Alfons NossolBishop of Opole

Jürgen WahlJournalist and publicist

Fr Dr Hans LangendorferSJSecretary-General of theGerman Bishops�Conference

Ewa CzaczkowskaEditor, publicistof Rzeczpospolita

Archbishop EmanuelOrthodox Metropolitanof France

Roman GraczykJournalist and publicistof Tygodnik Powszechny

Maria MartensMember of the EuropeanParliament from theNetherlands

Dr Christoph BöhrVice-President of the CDU

Dr Jarosław GowinSenator of the Republicof Poland, Rectorof the Tischner EuropeanUniversity in Krakow

Dr Jan TombińskiAmbassador of theRepublic of Polandto the EU

Michael GahlerMember of the EuropeanParliament from Germany

Tomasz LisJournalist and publicist

Dieter AlthausPresident of Thuringia

Cardinal José da CruzPolicarpoPatriarch of Lisbon

Vincuk ViachorkaPresident of theBelarusian National Front

Jaime Mayor OrejaVice-Chairman of EPP-EDGroup in the EuropeanParliament

Dr Mariusz SiwońUN expert on Kosovo

Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone SDBSecretary of Stateof the Holy See

Bogusław SonikMember of the EuropeanParliament

Prof. Lech KaczyńskiPresident of the Republicof Poland

Othmar KarasVice-Chairman of EPP-EDGroup in the EuropeanParliament

Paweł KowalFormer Deputy Ministerof Foreign Affairs of theRepublic of Poland

Dr Norbert LammertPresident of the Bundestag

Archbishop DiarmuidMartinPrimate of Ireland,Metropolitan of Dublin

Alexander MilinkevichLeader of the Belarusopposition

Dr Jerzy M. NowakFormer Ambassadorof the Republic of Polandto NATO

Marcin PrzeciszewskiPresident of the CatholicInformation Agency

Stephan RaabeDirector of the KonradAdenauer Foundationin Poland

Michał GóraJournalist

Andrzej SadowskiAdam Smith Centre

Semiha BorovacMayor of Sarajevo

Prof. Michał SerweryńskiFormer Minister of Scienceand Higher Educationof the Republic of Poland

Karl G. WellmanMember of the Bundestag

Marek ZającJournalist and publicistof Polskapresse

Marek OrzechowskiJournalist

Prof. Gerald PillayVice-Chancellor andRector of the LiverpoolHope University

Fr Dr Bernhard FelmbergPlenipotentiary of the Councilof the Evangelical Church tothe German Government andthe European Union

Bronisław KomorowskiSpeaker of the PolishSejm

Cardinal Angelo SodanoDean of the Collegeof Cardinals

Dr Stephan EiselMember of the GermanBundestag

Waldemar PawlakFirst Deputy Prime Ministerof the Republic of Poland

Michel EddeFormer Ministerof Culture andHigher Educationin Lebanese government

Andrzej GrzybChairman of the SejmCommittee for EuropeanUnion Affairs

Lasha ZhivaniaChairman of theParliamentary Committeefor Foreign Affairs

Archbishop Reinhard MarxArchbishop of Munich andFreising

Cardinal Péter ErdöPrimate of Hungary

Jan FigelCommissioner of theEuropean Unionresponsible for Education,Training, Culture and Youth

Donald TuskPrime Ministerof the Republic of Poland

Mikołaj DowgielewiczSecretary of State in theOffice of the Committeefor European Integration

Lech WałęsaFormer Presidentof the Republic of Poland

Dr Janusz LewandowskiMember of the EuropeanParliament, EPP (ChristianDemocrats)

Prof. Krzysztof RybińskiErnst&Young, former Vice--President of the NationalBank of Poland

Dr Werner LangenMember of the EuropeanParliament, EPP (ChristianDemocrats)

Prof. Georg MilbradtFormer Minister-Presidentof the Free State of Saxony

Prof. Jan MiodekDirector of the PolishPhilology Institute, theUniversity of Wrocław

Prof. Franciszek ZiejkaFormer rector of theJagiellonian University

Fr Adam BonieckiEditor-in-chief of theTygodnik Powszechny

Dr Michl EbnerMember of the EuropeanParliament, EPP (ChristianDemocrats)

Prof. Stanisław RodzińskiFormer rectorof the Academy of Fine Artin Krakow

Fr Paul TigheSecretary of the Presidentof the Pontifical Councilfor Social Communications

Bogdan ZdrojewskiMinister of Cultureand National Heritageof the Republic of Poland

Günter VerheugenVice President of theEuropean Commission,Commissioner of the EuropeanUnion responsible forEnterprise and Industry

Fr Prof. Dr Władysław ZuziakRector of the PontificalUniversity of John Paul IIin Krakow

Abp Dominik Duka OPArchbishop of Pragueand Primate of the CzechRepublic

Fr Prof. Dr Tomá� HalikCharles Universityin Prague

Dr Andrzej GrajewskiJournalist of theGość Niedzielny

Dr Maria FlachsbarthMember of the Bundestag

Fr Prelate Dr EttoreBalestreroUndersecretary of Stateof the Holy See forRelations with States

Tunne KelamMember of the EuropeanParliament, Estonia

Ria Ooman-RuijtenMember of the EuropeanParliament, EPP (ChristianDemocrats)

Dr Filip KaczmarekMember of the EuropeanParliament, EPP (ChristianDemocrats)

György HölvényiSecretary Generalof the Robert SchumanFoundation in Luxemburg

Katarzyna WiśniewskaJournalist of theGazeta Wyborcza

Róża ThunMember of the EuropeanParliament, EPP (ChristianDemocrats)

Jean-Claude JunckerPrime Ministerof the Luxemburg

Jochannes ZellerMember of the EuropeanParliament, EPP (ChristianDemocrats)

Christian WulffPresident of the FederalRepublic of Germany

Christine LieberknechtPrime Ministerof the State Thuringia

Prof. Joaquin Navarro-VallsFormer Director of theVatican Press Office

John DalliEU Commissionerfor Health and ConsumerPolicy

Laszlo SzaszfalviState Secretary forChurch and MinorityAffairs and SocialRelations in Hungary

Fr Kazimierz SowaJournalist, publicistand director of Religia.tv

Roland FreudensteinDeputy director of CES,Former director of theConrad AdenauerFoundation in Poland

Bishop Dr Piotr JareckiVice Chairmanof COMECE

Dr Wojciech OlejniczakMember of the EuropeanParliament, Socialists &Democrats

Dr Stefan VesperSecretary General of theCentral Committeeof German Catholics

Konrad SzymańskiMember of the EuropeanParliament, EuropeanConservatives andReformists Group, Poland

Jarosław MakowskiDirector of the CivicInstitute

Zbigniew Nosowskijournalist, columnist,Catholic activist,editor-in-chief of Więzi

Dr Christian Schmitzdirector of the KonradAdenauer Foundation inPoland

Zbigniew Derdziukpresident of the SocialInsurance Institution [ZUS]

Prof. Libero Gerosaprofessor of canon law,doctor of theology

Archbishop Jean-ClaudeHollerichArchbishop of Luksemburg

Klaus Otto Skibowskijournalist and writer,former adviser toChancellor of GermanyKonrad Adenauer

Cardinal Kazimierz NyczArchbishop of Warsaw

Romana De GasperiAlcide de GasperiFoundation in Rome

Maciej Gajekjournalist and press and TVpublicist

Krzysztof Zanussifilm and TV director

Tomasz Arabskichairman of the StandingCommittee of the Councilof Ministers in Poland

José Ramos Ascensăo Jacek Protasiewicz Fr Carlos Simon Vazquez Bishop Tadeusz Szurman

Archbishop Henryk HoserFather Maksim Obuchow Prof. Marguerite Peeters Monika Sieradzka

Prof. Inga Iwasiów Andrzej GodlewskiProf. Pierpaolo Donati François Biltgen

Abp Dr FrancescoMontenegro

Flaminia Giovanelli Dr Cezary Kościelniak Fr Dr Leszek Gęsiak SJ

Fr Dr Maciej Zięba OPFr Ziad Hilal SJ Prof. Paweł H. Dembinski Przemysław Radwan--Rohrenschef

Pascal Lejeune Katarzyna TraczFr. Jacek Stryczek

Artur Sporniak

Marcin Żyła

Prof. Adam Daniel Rotfeld Fr Dr Florian Kolfhaus Fr Dr Patrick Daly

Piotr ChęcińskiJos J.A.M. van Gennip Fr Prof. Wojciech Zyzak Bishop Dr JanuszStepnowski

Dr Rafał Trzaskowski Cardinal Béchara BoutrosRai

Prof. Andrzej Zoll Dr Dominika Kozłowska

PhD., MD Anna Záborská Prof. Thomas Brose Prof. Samir Khalil Samir SJ Prof. Balázs Schanda

Rónán Mullen Oksana Yurynets Dr Patrycja Sasnal Archbishop Ivan Zoria

Jacek Stawiski

!"##$%& (%)*#+,&(*% #$-,#.(%- &/$ 0*%)$#$%0$12/$ 3*4$ *) &/$ !,&/*4(0 !/"#0/ (% &/$ 5"#*6$,% 7%&$-#,&(*% 8#*0$99:

0,% ;$ )*"%. *% &/$ <$;9(&$<<<=>*90(*4?$"#*6,=*#-=64

7@AB CDE?EF?ECDGH?IG?J

DIG

NIT

Y �

FREE

DO

M �

HU

MA

N R

IGH

TS

�Wok

ó³ n

as� P

ublis

hing

Hou

seG

liwic

e 20

16

Differences in the understanding of human dignity are bornfrom the rejection by EU legislation of the religious element andthe laws of nature, which for Christians are essential sources ofhuman dignity, freedom and human rights. The EU developedthem mostly from the state endowment, and relative stability isnot attributed to them. In reading the convergences anddivergences in the understanding of these three fundamentalconcepts of human dignity, freedom and human rights,a particular difficulty in dialogue with the EU comes from thelanguage which we use to express our views. The terms dignity,freedom and human rights mean something completely differentin both the Christian and Union contexts. This discrepancy arosebecause Christianity derives dignity, freedom and human rightsfrom the truth, and this is the revealed truth, while the EU hasadopted the principle of freedom as its source. [...]

Bp Prof. Tadeusz Pieronek

2/(9 0*+6(4,&(*% <,9 6";4(9/$. "9(%- )"%.9)#*+ &/$ K#*"6 *) &/$ 5"#*6$,% 8$*64$:9 8,#&L

(% &/$ 5"#*6$,% 8,#4(,+$%&





M 3 K N B 7 @ 5 3 @ NBO ! M M 8 5 3 N 2 7 M B @

The Pontifical Universityof John Paul II

The Robert SchumanFoundation

The Konrad AdenauerFoundation

�Wokó³ nas�Publishing House

The Groupof the European People's Party

European People�s Party Commissionof the Bishops� Conferences

of the European Union

DIGNITY Œ FREEDOM Œ HUMAN RIGHTSfreedom and human rights mean something completely different in...

Documents

Transcript of DIGNITY Œ FREEDOM Œ HUMAN RIGHTSfreedom and human rights mean something completely different in...