Schuman v. Greenbelt Homes - Record Extract Volume 2 of 4

8/2/2019 Schuman v. Greenbelt Homes - Record Extract Volume 2 of 4

1/457

BK SAF OGV]S GN _TFOBJE JTTFJE_ GN @J]REJKC

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Kv`mf} =4=4

_ftf`mf} Sf}`% =4::

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

CJ^BC _+ _OAV@JK%

Jttfeejk

~+

L]FFKMFES AG@F_% BKO+% f je+

Jttfeeffs

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Gk Jttfje n}g` af Ob}ovb Ogv} ng} T}bkof Lfg}lfs Ogvkr

Jemf} \+ Kg}a}gt% Jssgobjf Hvclf

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

JTTFEEJKS CJ^BC _+ _OAV@JK_ ]FOG]C FQS]JOS

^gev`f BB gn B^

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

H+T+ _xr`ig|box ]bj Sv}kf}Hgak S+ _xr`ig|box :6>44 Mjec Fjlef _oagge ]gjc_XR@IG\BOX . _XR@IG\BOX% EET M}jkcr|bkf% @j}rejkc =4>:?=?44 K _}ff% K+\+% _vbf 6?:4 !3:4" -::=2 !~gbof"\jsabklgk% CO =44?


2/457

BK SAF OB]OVBS OGV]S NG] T]BKOF LFG]LF,_ OGVKSR% @J]REJKC

CJ^BC _+ _OAV@JK%

Tejbkbnn%

~s+ OB^BE JOSBGK EJ\ :44>43

:

:

:

:

=

?

3

6

>

: _v}lfgk

Lfkf}je,s ]ftg}+

Kg| B |jk g s|boa lfj}s jkc nbkbsa |ba af

svcr aj cbc B ng} @}+ _oav`jk bk abs ogkof}kbkl

gvcgg} sfogkcajkc s`gif% jkc B gker aj~f j ogvtef gn

sebcfs gk abs+

Saf vkb |aj B,` sag|bkl af}f bs

@}+ Tgtg~bo,s vkb% |aboa bs Vkb ] gk af efn% jkc Vkb

Z gk af }bla% |aboa bs @}+ _oav`jk,s vkb% jkc b ajc

mffk @}+ Tgtg~bo,s ajmb g s`gif gk abs tjbg af}f bk

oegsf t}gqb`br% bk oegsf} t}gqb`br g @}+ _oav`jk,s vkb

!bkcbojbkl"+ ]fofker% af ajs `g~fc abs oajb}+

@]+ LGFOIF8 Gmhfobgk% Rgv} Agkg}+ Sabs bs

afj}sjr+ Ag| cgfs af ikg| abs7 Saf}f bs kg ngvkcjbgk+

@]+ _XR@IG\BOX8 Af sj| b+

SAF OGV]S8 Cbc rgv gmsf}~f b7

SAF \BSKF__8 B gmsf}~fc b+

??

:

:

:8?4 g 1844 g,oegoi gk _jv}cjr% Hver :>a%

=4::% jkc bk af t}fsfkof jkc jmsfkof gn gmsf}~fc

oblj}ff s`gibkl mr @}+ Tgtg~bo% jkc B |js B s`feefc

jkc B |js b}}bjfc mr af oblj}ff s`gif gcg}9 sg%

cfnbkbfer oj`f bk+ B ojk ogknb}` af t}fsfkof gn gvcgg}

s`gif tfkf}jbkl+ Jkc cv}bkl af =4 `bkvf s`gibkl

tf}bgc% `fcbjk oj}obkglfkbo tgeroroebo j}g`jbo

arc}goj}mgks cgvmefc g~f} af =4 `bkvf kgks`gibkl tf}bgc9

B ogkoevcfc% g j }fjsgkjmef cfl}ff gn sobfkbnbo

of}jbkr% aj gvcgg} s`gibkl mr @}+ Tgtg~bo tfkf}jfc

a}gvla af gtfk |bkcg|s gn @}+ _oav`jk,s ag`f% jkc sg B

ogkoevcf% |babk j }fjsgkjmef cfl}ff gn sobfkbnbo

of}jbkr% aj af s`gif bknbe}jbkl bkg @}+ _oav`jk,s

vkb bs mga b}}bjbkl jkc oj}obkglfkbo+

@]+ LGFOIF8 Rgv} Agkg}% B gmhfo+ Af,s kg

zvjebnbfc g fsbnr jmgv |aj bs aj}`nve g @}+ _oav`jk+

SAF OGV]S8 B,ee svsjbk aj+ B jooft af

ogkoevsbgks js sjfc af}f+

@]+ LGFOIF8 Mv af ogkoevsbgk g Kg+ >%

?34

:

=

?

3

6

>

:+

SAF OGV]S8 @ff} sag|fc aj% jkc B jooft

aj+

@]+ LGFOIF8 Rgv} Agkg}% af `ff} cbc kg sag|

b,s oj}obkglfkbo+ Saf `ff} sag|fc j ef~fe

@}+ ]ftjof% gkf% ogkoevcfs b,s oj}obkglfkbo+ Af,s kg j

cgog}+ Af,s kg zvjebnbfc g jei jmgv |aj ojvsfs

ojkof}s j |aj ef~fe+

SAF OGV]S8 Oj}obkglfks ojvsf ojkof}+ Af

cffofc oj}obkglfks+ B,ee jooft b+

MR @]+ _XR@IG\BOX8

Z+ @}+ ]ftjof% ojk rgv lg mjoi g af sebcf aj

sag|s af tbov}f gn af agvsf7

J+ Rfs+

Z+ @}+ Tgtg~bo% cv}bkl abs zvfsbgkbkl gn

@}+ _oav`jk% tgbkfc gv gvsbcf aj af |bkcs meg| n}g`

@}+ Tgtg~bo,s vkb g @}+ _oav`jk,s vkb |fkrfbla

tf}ofk gn af b`f+ Ag| cbc rgv cff}`bkf aj7

J+ B vsf j |bkc }gsf+

Z+ \aj cgfs aj fjk7

J+ \fee% j |bkc }gsf bs rtbojeer vsfc mr jb}tg}s

g jc~bsf tbegs gk |aj n}fzvfkor gn |bkc afr ojk lf

n}g` j lb~fk cb}fobgk jkc ag| njs af |bkc stffc bs%

mfojvsf af tbegs je|jrs |jk g tboi j }vk|jr |af}f afr

j}f ejkcbkl bkg af |bkc% jkc sg b afets af` ejkc% jkc

?3:

:

=

?

3

6

>

:

:

:+ Aj~f rgv f~f} sffk aj }ftg}7

J+ B aj~f+

Z+ \aj bs b7

J+ Saj |js af }ftg} aj B cbc gk Cfof`mf} :4a%

=4:4 ng} @}+ _oav`jk |af}f B `gcfeefc af gvcgg} s`gif

ojsf% bk gaf} |g}cs% s`gif bknbe}jbgk9 aj af

ogkofk}jbgk aj af |gvec fqtfo j abs |bkcg| n}g`

j cbnnf}fk cbsjkofs n}g` @}+ Tgtg~bo,s s`gibkl

gvcgg}s% jkc aj,s |af}f B lg a}gvla af |agef |bkc

?32

:

=

?

3

6

>

:

: bkg f~bcfkof% |aboa bs af Cfof`mf} =4:4 }ftg}+

@]+ LGFOIF8 Rgv} Agkg}% bk jccbbgk g af

gmhfobgk B `jcf mfng}f% B |gvec jesg ebif g jcc aj

@}+ ]ftjof bs kg j `ffg}geglbs9 mffk kg ~gb} cb}f jmgv

abs fqtf}bsf g |bkc }gsfs9 abs jmbebr g svtf}b`tgsf

|aj ajttfks j M\B jkc L}ffkmfe+

SAF OGV]S8 Safr aj~f |g }vk|jrs j M\B% af

cb}fobgks gn Ogeeflf Tj}i% |aboa bs ~f}r oegsf g abs+

B,ee kgf aj+ B,ee jc`b aj svmhfo g af sj`f

cfcjobgks% bn jkr+

@]+ LGFOIF8 Sajki rgv+

!Tejbkbnn,s Fqabmb Kg+ >% t}f~bgvser `j}ifc

ng} bcfkbnbojbgk% |js jc`bfc bkg f~bcfkof+"

MR @]+ _XR@IG\BOX8

Z+ Nbkjeer% Fqabmb Kg+


311/457

J+ Rgv ikg|% mjsbojeer |ba af S|g Sagvsjkc B,`

sg}}r =4:: tjtf}% B sag|fc af taggl}jtas aj B ggi

jkc }ftg}fc af sjbsbos gn af `fjsv}f`fks aj B

jovjeer `jcf% jkc sag|fc ag| B cbc af ojeovejbgk gn af

}fejb~f bko}fjsf% jkc B aj~f je}fjcr }ftg}fc |aj `r

ogkoevsbgks |f}f bk af gvcgg} ojsf% jkc |afk B `jcf af

`fjsv}f`fk+

@]+ _XR@IG\BOX8 Rgv} Agkg}% B `g~f Fqabmb

Kg+ < bkg f~bcfkof+

@]+ LGFOIF8 Kg gmhfobgk g abs gkf% Rgv}

Agkg}+

SAF OGV]S8 B |bee mf jc`bfc+

!Tejbkbnn,s Fqabmb Kg+


312/457

Rgv} Agkg}% sj}bkl |ba% B abki% af

gmhfobgks j}f t}fr `voa af sj`f t}gmef`+ Ef `f jif

af` gkf mr gkf+

\ba }fstfo g ??% B jljbk% Rgv} Agkg}% |gvec

gmhfo+ @}+ _oav`jk,s zvgjbgk gn cbsovssbgks @}+ ]ftjof

gec ab` bs sbee afj}sjr+ @}+ ]ftjof ajs fsbnbfc g

|aj abs ogkoevsbgks j}f% mv |aj af gec @}+ _oav`jk%

jkc @}+ _oav`jk,s srkgtsbs gn b bs sbee afj}sjr%

bkjc`bssbmef% vk}febjmef+ Rgv} Agkg} ajs af fsb`gkr%

@}+ ]ftjof9 |aj af sjrs bs af ojsf% mv @}+ _oav`jk

}rbkl g }fsrkafsbxf jkc sjr bk abs g|k |g}cs% oefj}er

afj}sjr9 kg }febjmef+ Rgv} Agkg}% af}f bs jesg

sjf`fks bk aj eff}% B mfebf~f% }rbkl g zvgf

@}+ _oav`jk fqovsf `f @}+ ]ftjof js |fee js sg`f gn

abs }ftg}s+ Saj% jljbk% bs @}+ _oav`jk,s }fkcbbgk gn

agsf f~fks+ Saj,s cgvmef afj}sjr bk aj ojsf% Rgv}

Agkg}% jkc |gvec kg mf jc`bssbmef+ Saf}f,s kg ngvkcjbgk

ng} @}+ _oav`jk,s b,s kg }febjmef+ B abki aj

tf}jbks g Kg+ ?? stfobnbojeer+

\jk `f g jif af` gkf mr gkf% Rgv} Agkg}9 lg

a}gvla jee gn af`7

SAF OGV]S8 Lg jafjc+

@]+ NB_AF]8 \ba }fstfo g Kg+ ?3% Rgv}

Agkg}% |aboa bs af eff}% jljbk% n}g` @}+ _oav`jk g

@s+ G~f}cv}nn% jljbk jeibkl jmgv |aj @}+ ]ftjof gec

?6?

:

=

?

3

6

>

:a% =442 }ftg}9 kg

gker mffk `j}ifc mv b,s mffk jc`bfc bkg abs ojsf+

Bn rgv ogvec v}k g tjlf sbqffk% tefjsf+

Kg|% jljbk% hvs g }fsjmebsa% abs }ftg} |js

cfsblkfc g cff}`bkf |afaf} g} kg s`gif |js og`bkl

a}gvla af |jees n}g` af Tgtg~bos, vkb bkg

?>:

:

=

?

3

6

>

:

:

:

:

:


391/457

J+ Rfs+ Joog}cbkl g af cbjl}j` |aboa @}+ _oav`jk

lj~f `f% jkc B abki b,s bk `r gvcgg} }ftg}% af nb}s

gkf bk Jvlvs

Z+ Ojk rgv }f~bf|% sg rgv,}f kg stfovejbkl7

J+ B ikg| |aj af kv`mf} bs+ B,s jmgv 3= nff%

mv B ojk oafoi b+

B,` sg}}r9 abs bs af |}gkl gkf+ Sabs bs

Cfof`mf}+ Saj,s Hver% Hvkf+ B,s g~f} af}f+

Rfs+ B,ee ojee rgv} jfkbgk g nblv}f sbq gk

tjlf kbkf gn Fqabmb Tejbkbnn,s Fqabmb >+

Z+ \aboa }ftg} |js aj7

J+ Sabs bs af Cfof`mf} :4a% =4:4 }ftg}% jkc bn

rgv eggi j af `fjsv}f`fks% jkc abs bs n}g` Jejk n}g`

L}ffkmfe Ag`fs+ Safsf j}f kg `r `fjsv}f`fks+ B eggis

ebif af lj}cfk sbcf rj}c }jklfs n}g` j ebef g~f}

ng}rgkf g jmgv 3= nff bk cbsjkof tf}tfkcbovej} jegkl

abs |jei n}g` af njof gn af mvbecbkl g af og``gk

j}fj9 sg% af og``gk j}fj |gvec mf mfrgkc% mjsbojeer

mfrgkc jmgv 3= nff+ Bk njo% bk abs tbov}f% rgv ogvec

hvs sg} gn ~jlvfer sff af g~je j}fj+ Saf}f,s j

sbcf|jei gv af}f+

Kg|% |js af}f j zvfsbgk aj B `bssfc7

Z+ \fee% af zvfsbgk aj B jsifc8 Ag| nj} |js b

b% 3= nff7

J+ Rfja+

?:?=

:

=

?

3

6

>

:

:

:

:

:

=

?

3

6

>

:

:% =44> jkc =4:4 }flj}cbkl

sfogkcajkc s`gif7

@]+ LGFOIF8 Gmhfobgk+ Ojk |f cfnbkf stfobnbo

nbkcbkls af}f7 Af jeibkl jmgv af fkb}f sf~fk avkc}fc

tjlfs gn agsf cgov`fks7

@]+ _XR@IG\BOX8 B,` }rbkl kg g lg a}gvla

f~f}r sbklef abkl+

@]+ LGFOIF8 B,s ebif jsibkl ab` bn af mfeb~fs

bk sobfkof+

SAF OGV]S8 Jkrabkl aj rgv cbsjl}ff |ba7

SAF \BSKF__8 Kg aj B ikg| gn+

MR @]+ _XR@IG\BOX8

Z+ Rgv aj~f }fjc jee a}ff gn afsf tvmebojbgks%

aj~fk, rgv7

J+ B aj~f g jc`b% B cbc kg }fjc af` og~f} g

og~f}+

?:33

:

=

?

3

6

>

:

:4


405/457

fnnfo aj `gs tfgtef sfksf |gvec mf j mjc s`fee%

jkkgrjkof bk gaf} |g}cs9 afk tfgtef og`tejbk jesg gn

mv}kbkl% frfs mv}kbkl% kgsf% }vkkr kgsf% jkc afk abs

lgfs gk g tfgtef |ag cf~fegt |ag jesg og`tejbk gn

kjvsfj% afjcjoaf% j |agef ogksfeejbgk gn sr`tg`s+

Bk jccbbgk g agsf b``fcbjf g} sag} f}`

fnnfos% bk jccbbgk g aj% af}f j}f egkl f}` fnnfos

gn af sfogkcajkc s`gif% jkc afr j}f fnnfos gk af

}fstb}jg}r srsf` jkc gk af ob}ovejg}r srsf`+ Sagsf

aj~f mffk |fee cgov`fkfc+ Safr bkoevcf evkl ojkof}+

Bko}fjsfc bkobcfkof gn afj} jjois jesg bk tfgtef |ag

j}f fqtgsfc g sfogkcajkc s`gif% jkc af f~bcfkof ng} aj

og`fs n}g` j ~j}bfr gn sgv}ofs% ftbcf`bgeglbo svcbfs%

|aboa |f aj~f jeifc jmgv j eg gn b jesg9 svcbfs gn

af mbgeglr% }fjeer% gn afsf `foajkbs`s gn af jobgk gn

oblj}ff s`gif gk ~j}bgvs g}ljks+

Z+ Sg rgv} ikg|efclf% @}+ _oav`jk ajs kg svnnf}fc

j afj} jjoi js j }fsve gn sfogkcajkc s`gif% ajs af7

J+ B aj~f kg afj}c jkrabkl g aj fnnfo+

Z+ Sg rgv} ikg|efclf% @}+ _oav`jk cgfs kg aj~f

ojkof} gn jkr ibkc n}g` |aj rgv aj~f sffk g} afj}c7

J+ B cgk, ikg|+

@]+ NB_AF]8 Gmhfobgk% Rgv} Agkg}+

Ngvkcjbgk+

SAF OGV]S8 Aj~f rgv f~f} fqj`bkfc @}+ _oav`jk

?:3>

:

=

?

3

6

>

::


406/457

tf}sgkjeer7

SAF \BSKF__8 B cbc kg fqj`bkf @}+ _oav`jk+

MR @]+ _XR@IG\BOX8

Z+ _g bk g}cf} g sag} ob}ovb jkc eb`b abs

cbsovssbgk% |f j}f gker af}f gk af fnnfos gn sfogkcajkc

s`gif aj rgv aj~f ef @}+ _oav`jk fsbnr g gcjr% bs

aj og}}fo7

J+ Rfs+

Z+ Ojk rgv fee f |aj rgv mfebf~f @}+ _oav`jk,s

og`tejbks jmgv @}+ Tgtg~bo,s s`gibkl g mf7

J+ Saf og`tejbks aj B aj~f afj}c% aj af ajs

ajc skffxbkl9 af ajs ajc afjcjoafs9 af ajs ajc kjvsfj9 af

ajs sfogkcajkc afjcjoafs% jkc af ajs cbnnbover sefftbkl+

Z+ Jkc cg rgv mfebf~f aj afsf j}f gmhfob~f g}

svmhfob~f og`tejbks |ba }flj}c g bkcb~bcvjes aj rgv

aj~f fbaf} fqj`bkfc g} bk af ebf}jv}f svttg}s j

nbkcbkl gn aj |afk afr j}f fqtgsfc g sfogkcajkc s`gif7

@]+ LGFOIF8 Rgv} Agkg}% gmhfo g abs

zvfsbgk+ Af je}fjcr fsbnbfc af ojkkg fqj`bkf ab`9

af}fng}f% af}f ojk, mf jkr gmhfob~f joikg|efclf`fk mr

abs |bkfss+

SAF OGV]S8 \aj af,s sjrbkl% mjsfc gk |aj af

ajs afj}c ab` fsbnr% af ojk cg aj+ Af ajs mffk bk af

Ogv}}gg` g afj} af fsb`gkr+

J}f afsf af sr`tg`s af cfso}bmfc9 |gvec afr

?:3

:=


407/457

mf svmhfob~f g} gmhfob~f sr`tg`s% jkc b,s hvs j

tgssbmbebr% B,` sv}f+ Lg jafjc+

SAF \BSKF__8 Safsf j}f af ibkc gn sr`tg`s

aj |f |gvec rtbojeer afj} n}g` j tf}sgk fqtgsfc g

sfogkcajkc s`gif+

SAF OGV]S8 Saf zvfsbgk sjbc8 J}f afsf

gmhfob~f g} svmhfob~f7

SAF \BSKF__8 Saf t}gmef` B aj~f bs aj af

f}`s `fjk sg`fabkl cbnnf}fk g j tarsbobjk ajk g jk

jg}kfr% jkc g j tarsbobjk% svmhfob~f `fjks jkr sr`tg`

aj bs }ftg}fc mr af tjbfk+ Gmhfob~f `fjks j

nbkcbkl aj bs mjsfc gk af tarsboje fqj` g} ejmg}jg}r

fqj`9 sg% n}g` j `fcboje sjkctgbk% B |gvec ojee afsf

svmhfob~f% mv afr j}f }fje bk af sfksf aj afsf j}f

af ibkc gn sr`tg`s aj j}f ~f}r rtbojeer }ftg}fc+

Z+ Cg rgv ikg| bn f~f}r av`jk mgcr t}gcvofs af

sj`f og`tejbks svoa js @}+ _oav`jk `jcf |afk afr j}f

fqtgsfc g sfogkcajkc s`gif7

J+ Kg+

Z+ Cg rgv ikg| bn afsf j}f af ibkc gn og`tejbks

aj j}f lfkf}jeer `jcf mr tfgtef |afk fqtgsfc g

sfogkcajkc s`gif7

J+ Safsf j}f ~f}r n}fzvfk og`tejbks% jkc b,s

of}jbker j ogksfeejbgk aj ajs mffk jssgobjfc |ba

fqtgsv}f g sfogkcajkc s`gif+

?:31

:

=

?

3

6

>

:?


408/457

Z+ Ojk rgv fee f |aj tarsbojeer ajttfks g af

av`jk mgcr |afk afr m}fjaf bk sfogkcajkc s`gif ng} af

nb}s b`f gk j lb~fk cjr7

J+ _fogkcajkc s`gif% ebif jkr gaf} s`gif% ebif

cb}fo s`gibkl% bs }jtbcer jifk vt9 bkajefc+ B bs afk

jifk vt bk af evkls jkc }jtbcer% js sg`f gn af

svmsjkofs j}f }jksnf}}fc j af je~fgej} ef~fe+

Z+ _tfee aj7

J+ Je~fgej}% JE^FGEJ]% ef~fe g af

meggcs}fj`% jkc afk g cbsjk tj}s gn af mgcr% jkc

aj,s ag| |f fqtejbk sg`f gn af `g}f oa}gkbo fnnfos gn

oblj}ff s`gibkl9 ng} fqj`tef% af jmcvobgk gn evkl

ojkof} bk g}ljks aj j}f js cbsjk js af mejccf}+

Z+ \aj ajttfks g af av`jk mgcr |afk af s`gif bs

bkajefc bkg af evkls7 Cgfs af mgcr t}gcvof jkr

}fjobgks7

J+ \fee% b cftfkcs gk af bkcb~bcvje% mv b%

lfkf}jeer% b cfnfkcs bsfen% bn rgv |bee% jljbks af

gnnfksf% jljbks af aj,s af `jkbnfsjbgk aj |f

ojee skffxbkl% af }fc frfs% af mv}kbkl gn af frfs+

Safsf j}f jee `jkbnfsjbgks aj af mgcr bs mfbkl

jjoifc mr sg`fabkl b cgfsk, ebif+

Z+ Jkc j}f af}f gaf} fqj`tefs bk cjrgcjr av`jk

ebnf aj t}gcvof afsf ibkc gn }fjobgks7

J+ _g`f tfgtef `jr aj~f jeef}lbfs g stfobnbo

?:32

:

=

?

3

6

>

:3


409/457

svmsjkofs% ng} fqj`tef% jkc afr `jr aj~f sr`tg`s aj

j}f ~f}r sb`bej}+

Z+ _g abs |gvec mf sb`bej} g% ng} fqj`tef% ajr

nf~f} aj sg`f tfgtef `jr aj~f bk abs j}fj bk af

st}bklb`f% af sj`f ibkc gn }fjobgks7

J+ Saf b``fcbjf }fjobgk jr mf ~f}r sb`bej}% mv

|aj ajttfks bk cbsjk g}ljks bs ~f}r cbnnf}fk+ \afk j

tf}sgk% rgv ikg|% ajs ajr nf~f}% b cgfs kg efjc g af

jmsg}tbgk gn oj}obkglfks% ng} fqj`tef+

Z+ \ar cgfs af av`jk mgcr skffxf |afk fqtgsfc g

jk jeef}lfk svoa js sfogkcajkc s`gif g} neg|f} tgeefk7

J+ B cbck, afj} rgv+

Z+ \ar cgfs af av`jk mgcr skffxf |afk fqtgsfc g

jk jeef}lfk svoa js sfogkcajkc s`gif g} tgeefk7

J+ B,s mjsbojeer jk b``vkf }fjobgk+

Z+ \aj bs af mgcr }rbkl g cg7

J+ Saf mgcr bs }rbkl g lb~f j fssjlf aj abs

bs j ng}fblk svmsjkof+

Z+ Jkc afk |aj bs af jovje jo gn skffxbkl

}rbkl g joog`tebsa7

J+ \fee% af sfbxbkl `jr lf }bc gn af svmsjkof+

Saj,s gkf |jr gn }bccbkl af mgcr% mjsbojeer% gn af

svmsjkof+

Z+ Safsf j}f jee |aj B abki |f ojk jee jl}ff j}f

af sag} f}` fnnfos gn sfogkcajkc s`gif% |gvec rgv

?:64

:

=

?

3

6

>

:6


410/457

jl}ff7

J+ Saj,s og}}fo+

Z+ \aj }bsis% gvsbcf gn |aj rgv aj~f cbsovssfc

t}f~bgvser% cg bkcb~bcvjes aj j}f kgks`gif}s aj~f |afk

fqtgsfc g sfogkcajkc s`gif gk j egkl f}`7

@]+ LGFOIF8 Jljbk% Rgv} Agkg}% B gmhfo+ B

abki |f aj~f mffk g~f} abs+

SAF OGV]S8 B,ee jeeg| b+

MR @]+ _XR@IG\BOX8

Z+ Rgv aj~f je}fjcr fsbnbfc g sg`f gn afsf+

Jkr gaf}7

J+ B abki% t}b`j}ber% evkl ojkof}% afj} cbsfjsf%

oj}cbjo sr`tg`s+ Safsf j}f sg`f gn af `g}f oa}gkbo

fnnfos+

Z+ Cbc af}f og`f j b`f |afk rgv `f Cj~bc

_oav`jk7

J+ Rfs+

Z+ Jkc |af}f cbc rgv `ff ab` ng} af nb}s b`f7

J+ B `f ab` bk `r gnnbof t}gmjmer jmgv a}ff%

ngv} `gkas jlg+

Z+ Jkc rgv cbc kg tf}ng}` jk fqj`bkjbgk% j

`fcboje fqj`bkjbgk gk ab` js bn af |f}f j tjbfk gn

rgv}s% cbc rgv7

J+ Kg+

Z+ Rgv fqj`bkfc sg`f gn abs `fcboje rgv fqj`bkfc

?:6:

:

=

?

3

6

>

:>


411/457

abs `fcboje }fog}cs% og}}fo7

J+ B jsifc ng} abs `fcboje }fog}cs% jkc B cbc eggi

a}gvla af`+

Z+ B,` sag|bkl rgv |aj ajs mffk j}ifc js Fqabmbs

:4 a}gvla :>+ Safsf `fcboje }fog}cs |f}f sag|k g

@}+ _oav`jk cv}bkl abs cv}bkl @}+ Lgfoif,s

O}gssFqj`bkjbgk+ Aj~f rgv f~f} sffk afsf cgov`fks

mfng}f7

J+ B mfebf~f B aj~f+

Z+ Cbc rgv cbsovss @}+ _oav`jk,s mfebfns jkc

og`tejbks |ba ab` j rgv} nb}s `ffbkl7

J+ Cbc af cbsovss |aj af |js og`tejbkbkl jmgv7

Rfs+

Z+ Mjsfc gk rgv} cbsovssbgk |ba @}+ _oav`jk jkc

rgv} }f~bf| gn abs `fcboje }fog}cs% B mfebf~f j nf| tjlfs

gn |aboa j}f bk n}gk gn rgv js Fqabmbs Kg+ :4 a}gvla

:>% cbc rgv ng}` jkr gtbkbgks jmgv @}+ _oav`jk,s bkhv}bfs

js j }fsve gn @}+ Tgtg~bo,s s`gibkl7

J+ B |js `r gtbkbgk aj @}+ _oav`jk ajc mffk

aj}`fc mr fqtgsv}f g sfogkcajkc s`gif+

Z+ Rgv aj~f mffk bk abs }bje af fkb}f b`f%

og}}fo% jkc rgv aj~f ebsfkfc g af fsb`gkr7 Cbc jkr

gn af fsb`gkr aj rgv afj} nv}af} svttg} rgv}

nbkcbkls aj rgv t}feb`bkj}ber `jcf j nf| `gkas jlg7

J+ Rfs+

?:6=

:

=

?

3

6

>

:


412/457

Z+ \aj |f}f rgv} nbkcbkls mjsfc gk af fsb`gkr

gn @}+ _oav`jk7

J+ \fee% afj}bkl ab` cfso}bmf abs sr`tg`s bk abs

l}fjf} cfjbe |afk af |js gk af sjkc% B abki

}ffkng}ofc `r b`t}fssbgk% `r ogkoevsbgk aj af ajc

svnnf}fc fnnfos n}g` bkajejbgk gn sfogkcajkc s`gif+

Z+ Cbc afj}bkl Cg}r Btgebg fsbnr nv}af} svttg}

rgv} mfebfn% jkc bn sg% ag|7

J+ B of}jbker mfebf~f aj bk af} ojsf% jesg% b

|js+ _af ajc mffk fqtgsfc g sfogkcajkc s`gif% jkc b ajc

ojvsfc fqjof}mjbgks gn af} jsa`j+

Z+ \aj cg rgv mfebf~f Fqabmbs :4 a}gvla :> sag|

|ba }flj}c g @}+ _oav`jk,s oejb`s% bn jkrabkl7

@]+ NB_AF]8 Gmhfobgk% Rgv} Agkg}% af

fqabmbs aj af,s fqj`bkbkl B mfebf~f j}f afj}sjr+ Safr

j}f `fcboje }ftg}s mr gaf} tarsbobjks9 aj |abef af `jr

aj~f }f~bf|fc af`% jkr ogkoevsbgks aj af,s lgbkl g

c}j| n}g` af` }fejf g j `fcboje fqj` aj af cbc kg

tf}ng}`+

Nv}af}% Rgv} Agkg}% B |gvec kgf ng} af }fog}c

f`jbes g Ogvksfe jmgv abs ejs |ffi% aj afsf

cgov`fks |f}f kg t}gcvofc bk cbsog~f}r+ Cfstbf vs

nbebkl jkc jsibkl ng} jee `fcboje }fog}cs% afsf cgov`fks

|f}f kg t}gcvofc bk cbsog~f}r% jkc |f gmhfo g afb}

jc`bssbmbebr+ \f gmhfo g abs |bkfss }ferbkl gk agsf

?:6?

:

=

?

3

6

>

:1


413/457

cgov`fks g ng}` jkr gtbkbgks sbkof |f |f}f kg t}g~bcfc

agsf cgov`fks ng} }f~bf| jkc ng} fqj`bkjbgk+

@]+ _XR@IG\BOX8 Rgv} Agkg}% aj,s og}}fo+

\aj ajttfkfc% @}+ _oav`jk fkcf}fc afsf cb}foer g

C}+ @vkxf}% jkc B cbck, sfkc af` g af gaf} sbcf% js B

sagvec aj~f9 ag|f~f}% jkc |f ajc sfk @}+ Lgfoif jkc

@}+ Nbsaf} jk f`jbe9 sjbc |f |f}fk, lgbkl g bk}gcvof

af`+ \f cbck, f~fk `fkbgk af` bk gv} Cb}fo

Fqj`bkjbgk gn @}+ _oav`jk9 ag|f~f}% afr sj}fc

zvfsbgkbkl @}+ _oav`jk jmgv af`+

@]+ NB_AF]8 Ng} b`tfjoa`fk tv}tgsfs gker% Rgv}

Agkg}+ B `jcf aj ~f}r oefj}+

@]+ LGFOIF8 Bk @}+ _xr`ig|box, f`jbe g `f% af

sjbc% -\f }fsf}~f af }bla g vsf afsf g }fn}fsa af

}fogeefobgk gn C}+ @vkxf} jkc @}+ _oav`jk% bn af sagvec

kg }f`f`mf}%- sg |f agvla b jtt}gt}bjf ng}

b`tfjoa`fk gker+ \f ajc jk jl}ff`fk afsf |gvec kg

og`f bk js f~bcfkof+

B ojk m}bkl aj f`jbe+

@]+ _XR@IG\BOX8 Saj bs }vf% sg mv mfojvsf

afr bk}gcvofc b% B abki aj aj jeeg|s C}+ @vkxf} g

fsbnr+ B }fjeer cbck, bkfkc g% rgv ikg|% bk}gcvof

af` mv

SAF OGV]S8 Af ajs je}fjcr fsbnbfc aj af

ng}`fc abs gtbkbgk mjsfc gk cbsovssbgks |ba @}+ _oav`jk

?:63

:

=

?

3

6

>

:2


414/457

jkc j }f~bf| gn agsf cgov`fks+ Af je}fjcr sjfc }f~bf|

gn agsf cgov`fks ng}` af mjsbs gn abs fsb`gkr+ Saj

fsb`gkr bs bk+ _g`f gn af `jf}bje bk agsf cgov`fks

ajs je}fjcr mffk fsbnbfc g bk b`tfjoa`fk zvfsbgks jkc

afr |f}f stfobnbojeer vsfc ng}+

Bn afr |f}f }fzvfsfc bk cbsog~f}r jkc kg

t}gcvofc% afr |bee kg mf jc`bfc+

@]+ _XR@IG\BOX8 Saj,s nbkf+

@]+ NB_AF]8 Sajki rgv% Rgv} Agkg}+

MR @]+ _XR@IG\BOX8

Z+ Sagsf }fog}cs aj rgv aj~f bk n}gk gn rgv%

Fqabmbs :4 a}gvla :>% cbc afr |js b rgv}

cbsovssbgks |ba @}+ _oav`jk jkc ebsfkbkl g ab` fsbnr

g} |js b rgv} }f~bf| gn `fcboje }fog}cs aj t}b`j}ber

efc g rgv} ogkoevsbgks af}f7

J+ B |js t}b`j}ber `r cbsovssbgk |ba ab` jkc

of}jbker |aj B afj}c |abef B |js af}f bk af Ogv}}gg`+

Z+ Gijr+ _g afsf `fcboje }fog}cs% bk rgv} mfebfn%

j}f j s`jee tj} gn rgv} gtbkbgks ng}`bkl af mjsbs ng}

rgv} gtbkbgks bk abs `jf}7

J+ Rfs+

Z+ Jkc afsf j}f sf~fk tjlfs% jtt}gqb`jfer% gn

`jkr% `jkr tjlfs gn }fog}cs aj @}+ _oav`jk t}g~bcfc ~bj

`fcboje }fog}cs7

J+ Rfs% af f`jbefc `f j avlf nbef% jkc n}jkier%

?:66

:

=

?

3

6

>

:

:

=

?

3

6

>

:7

J+ B mfebf~f aj,s og}}fo% j efjs n}g` af

tjlfs aj B aj~f eggifc j+

Z+ Jkc bk Fqabmb Kg+ :>% b hvs ibkc gn fkbgks

sfogkcajkc s`gif% bs aj og}}fo7

J+ Rfs+

Z+ B,` sag|bkl rgv |aj ajs abs bs af Ogv},s

g}cf} gk af t}feb`bkj}r bkhvkobgk n}g` ejs _ftf`mf}+

B cb}fo rgv} jfkbgk g af ngeeg|bkl sjf`fk gk tjlf

sf~fk% zvgf8 -\abef }foglkbxbkl af cjklf}s gn

?:6

:

:

:4

:

=

?

3

6

>

:

:

:


441/457

og`bkl mjoi @gkcjr jkr|jr+

@]+ NB_AF]8 B j` je`gs cgkf+

SAF OGV]S8 Lg jafjc+

MR @]+ NB_AF]8

Z+ J}f rgv nj`bebj} |ba af f}` -tsroagsg`jbo-

ogkcbbgks7

J+ Rfs+

Z+ \aj cgfs aj fjk7

J+ B,s af bknevfkof gn af `bkc g~f} af mgcr bk

f}`s gn ojvsbkl beekfssfs+

Z+ Bs aj sg`fabkl aj bs tgssbmef bk jkr

bkcb~bcvje7

J+ Rfs+

Z+ J tsroagsg`jbo ogkcbbgk ojk cf~fegt n}g`

sg`fmgcr% ng} fqj`tef% }fjcbkl `gvkcs jkc `gvkcs gn

ebf}jv}f gk j stfobnbo ef `f jsi rgv abs8 Ag| cgfs

tsroagsg`jbo ogkcbbgks% bk rgv} `bkc% cf~fegt7 Ag| ojk

afr cf~fegt7

J+ B aj~f ajc sg`f fqtf}bfkof |ba abs+ \afk B

|js j af Vkb~f}sbr gn ]goafsf}% B |g}ifc |ba

C}+ Lfg}lf Fklfe% |ag bs gkf gn af ngvkcf}s% }fjeer% gn

af |agef nbfec gn af tsroagsg`jbo `fcbobkf% jkc

mjsbojeer% b `fjks aj af `bkc% af}f bs j ogkkfobgk

mf|ffk |aj ajttfks bk j tf}sgk,s sjf gn `bkc jkc afb}

tarsboje |feemfbkl% jkc af t}b`f fqj`tef gn aj% ng}

?:1=

:

=

?

3

6

>

:

:

:

:

:

=

?

3

6

>

:

:

:

:

:

=

?

3

6

>

:

Schuman v. Greenbelt Homes - Record Extract Volume 2 of 4

Documents

Transcript of Schuman v. Greenbelt Homes - Record Extract Volume 2 of 4