mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o...

41

Transcript of mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o...

Page 1: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

�������������� ����������� ������� ����������������� !��"����� # ����%$'&���"(�

�*)����+�������-,.�/�+"0�������1&����2�3�4 �56���+�����

798;:/<>=@?BADCFE4G�=IHKJMLN4O/PRQBS#TVUXW�YZQ\[RO/]MYZQK^`_/a

b�cd^fegS�TZU#h#ij^kQj^laj[nm�TZofpR]�qd^`Yr#YZcs_'T@pReIO/iBtuh#ij^kQj^laj[nm�TZofpR]�qd^`Y

mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z�{Z|g}

��~��/�B���s�Z���c�Y�]�pdofQK^f��v@^f]�O/cga�^fTIcsY�oDvdT@]�Y�^fctIQ\[RO�a�ofTZ��]�TIQK^fTIc�qsO/[sY�e@^fTIi�TZUR^fc>Q�O/i\csY�oRo`Y��IO/i�ajTZofpRQK^fTIcsa���^fQ\[�aKPR[RO/i��

^`_/Y�o�^fc>Q\O/ijU�YI_'OBa�t�i�O'U�O/i\i�OBv�Q\T�YIa4qRpRqRqdofO9aKTVokpRQj^kT@csa/t�^`a�YZcsY�of�>�/OBv2U�TIi�Q\[ROMcRTIcdofTR_/Y�o���o�ofO/cR�KmYZ[Rc�OB�IpsYZQj^kT@c��^fQ\[�]�Y@a\a�_'TIcsaKO/i�e�YZQK^fTIcS�z�[d^`a�PRi\TIqdofO/]�i�O/PRi\OBaKO/cdQ�a�Q�[RO�a�^f]�PdofOBaKQ�]wT�vdO'oU�TIi�Q�[RO6PR[sYIaKO�aKO/PsYZi'YZQK^fTIc(TVU�Yqd^fcsYZi\��]�^��RQ\pRi\Ow^kc Q\[RO�PRi\OBaKO/cs_'OMTZU¡YM]�Y@a\a6_'TIcsaKQ\i'Y�^fc>QBS�z¡[RO�qRpRqRqdofOM^`a�aj[RT���c9Q�T(vdiK^�U�Q+O'��P¢TIcRO/c>Qj^lY�o£of�a�ofTZ��of�9YI_'i�T>a\a�Q\[RO�vdTI]MY�^fctu��^fQ\[RTIpRQ�_�[sYZcR¤IO�TZUaK[sYZP¢OItuQ\TZ��YZi�vRa�Q\[RO�_�ofT>aKOBaKQ6P¢TZ^fc>Q6TIc�Q\[RO�qsTIpRcsvRYVi\�(TZUQ\[RO6vdTI]�Y�^fcS���cMO'�RPdo£^`_�^fQ4TIi�v@^fcsYZi\��v@^�¥3O/i�O/c>QK^`Y�o�OB�IpsYZQj^kT@cMU�TIi�Q\[RO4]�TIQK^fTIcMTZUQ\[RO�_'O/cdQ\O/i�TZUQ\[RO�qRpRqRqdofO*^lavdO/iK^feIOBvMqd��O'�RQ\O/csv@^fcR¤stsQ�T�Y6]�pdofQK^f��v@^f]�O/cga¦^kT@cgY�o#aKO/Q\QK^fcR¤stdQ\[RO6YIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_�PRi\T@§¦OB_'Qj^kT@c�]�O/Q\[RTRv�vdO/eIO'ofTIP¢OBvPRi\O/e@^fTIpsa�of�nqd��Q\[RO�YZpRQ�[RTIi6Q\T�Q\i\OBYVQ�]�O/Q�Y@aKQ�YZqdofO�PRi\T@qdokO/]Ma6^fc�TIcRO�aKPsYVQK^`Y�ov@^f]�O/csa�^fTIcS��4cnYIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_U�TIi\]�pdo`YMU�TIi�Q\[ROMQK^f]�OMTZU¡_'TVo£o`YZPsajO�TZU�Q\[RO�qRpRqRqdofO(YZ¤dY�^fcsaKQ�Q\[RO�qsT@pRcsvRYZi\��TZU�Q\[RO�vdTI]�Y�^kc ^`a�vdO/iK^feIOBv ^fcQ\O/i\]Ma�TZU�Q\[RO+PRiK^fcs_�^kPsY�oi�YIv@^�^#TZU#_'pRi\eZYZQ\pRi\O�TZU#Q\[RO+qsTIpRcsvRYVi\�9YZQ�Q\[RO6^fcd^fQK^`Y�o¡_'T@c>Q�Y@_'Q�P¢TZ^fc>QBS��4c�YZcsY�ofTI¤I�qsO/QK��O/O/c�a�ofT���qRpRqRqdofO�]�TIQj^kT@c�YZcsvwQ\[RO�_�o`YIa\a�^`_/Y�o�O'�>^fQ�PRi\TIqdofO/]¨U�T@iv@^�¥psa�^fTIcM^fc©Y*PsTIQ\O/cdQK^`Y�ou�O'o�ou^`a�¤Z^feIO/cS

ª�«d¬­,�®g�Z¯��I°���cdQ\O/i\csY�o�o`Y��IO/i�a/tFPR[sYIaKO�aKO/PsYZi'YZQK^fTIct¢qRpRqRqdokO�aKTVokpRQj^kT@csa/tsO'�RPsT@cRO/c>QK^`Y�o�of��aK]�Y�o�o�O'^f¤IO/cde�Y�okpROBa�taKTZofeZYZqd^�o£^fQK��_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIcsa/tvd�dcsYZ]�^`_+]�O/Q�YIajQ�YZqd^�o�^kQK�IS

L9z¡[d^la4��TIi�±���YIa�aKpRPRP¢TIi\Q\OBv�qd��Q\[RO�²6³>´�µ�m¶¤Ii'YZc>Q4·Z��¸R{B·Z¹¢{

{

Page 2: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

��� ���s�B��®3¯���Z���f®� cRO�TZU#Q�[RO�a�^f]�PdofOBaKQ6]�TRvdO'o`a4U�TIi�Q\[RO+PR[sYIaKO�aKO/PsYZi'YZQK^fTIc(TVUY�qd^fcsYZi\�(]�^£�RQ\pRi\O+^fc�Q\[RO�PRi�OBaKO/cs_'O�TZU#Y]�YIa�a�_'TIcsaKQ\i'Y�^fc>Q�^`a�Q\[RO4U�TZo�ofTZ��^fcR¤(_'TIcsaKQ\i�Y�^kcROBv���o�okO/cR�Km�YZ[Rc�OB�@psYZQK^fTIc�^fc>Q\i�T�vdps_'OBv%^fc�� }Z¹� �°����������������������� �"!�# $&%&')(�*,+-# � {�.f{�/ �021 �,�435# $�% 0 '6# � {�.f{�7 �8:9 ����$;#=<��?>:$@�4A . � {�.f{�B �C�O/i\O �-D {It !E�F!G�H<�� ^la�Y�IYZ¤Ii'YZcR¤IO�]�pRQK^fPdo�^fO/i�J PsYZi�YV]�O/Q\O/i�K�Q\T­q¢OnvdO/Q\O/i\]�^kcROBvut ' ^`a(Y _'T@c>eIO'�vdTI]�Y�^kct � ^la*Q\[RO�_'TIcs_'O/cdQ\i�YZQK^fTIc�TZU�TIcRO�TZU#Q\[RO�QK��T©aKP¢OB_�^fOBa/t�YZcsv2Q\[RO�]�YIa\a A ^`a6_'TIcsaKQ'YZc>Q�S���c � {�.f{�/ � t���L�M�N�O�5PRQS�L�M� t@��[RO/i\O PT�L�M� ^`a�Y�vdT@pRqdokO/����O'o�o�PsTIQ\O/cdQK^`Y�o��^fQ\[M��O'o£o`a�TZU�OB�@psY�ovdO/PRQ\[MofT�_/YZQ�OBv�YZQ�Q\[RO4Q¦��TPRi\O'U�O/i\i\OBvMPR[sYIajOBa5U�V�W 3 YZcsv@U�X-Y 3 ��[RO/i\O PZ� U\[ �N��3 S#z¡[RO�cRTIcR�;ofTR_/Y�o�csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU � {].f{ � ^`a�i\O_^sOB_'Q\OBv©^fcQ\[RO+U�YI_'Q�Q�[sYZQ !G�H<�� ]�psaKQya�YZQK^`a�U�� !`�H<=�a�bP Xdce f 9 � � �M��$#�<�� >2$ ^fc�TIi�vdO/i4U�TIi�Q�[RO�]MYIa\a�Q\T�q¢O�_'TIcsaKO/i\eIOBvuSC�O/i\O P e ^`a�Q�[RO�eITZofpR]�O+TZU ' S

³IQ'YZi\QK^fcR¤�U�i\TI] ^fcd^fQK^`Y�o#vRYZQ�YRtdQ\[RO�ajTZofpRQK^fTIc(Q\T � {].f{ � �@pd^`_\±@of�9vdO/eIO'ofTIPsa¡^fc>Q�O/i\csY�oo`Y��IO/i�a � TIi�^kcdQ\O/iKU�YI_'OBa �TZU���^`vdQ\[�g ���h� Q\[sYZQ�aKO/PsYZi�YVQ\O�i\O/¤Z^fTIcsa+��[RO/i�O �ji U V U�i\T@]!i\O/¤Z^fTIcsa+��[RO/i�O �-i U X S���a�^f]�^�o`YZi�PR[sYIajOaKO/PsYZi'YZQK^fTIc PRi\TR_'OBa\a/t4qRpRQ�PsT>a\a¦^kqdof� �¡^kQ�[ eIO/i\�1_'TI]�Pdo�^`_/YZQ\OBv�vd�dcsYZ]�^`_/a/t4ofOBYIvRa%Q\T­Q\[RO�U�T@i\]�YZQK^fTIc1TZU�YPsYZQ\Q�O/i\c(TZU�^fcdQ\O/i\csY�o�o`Y��IO/i�a¡U�TIi�T@Q\[RO/i6PR[sYIaKO�Q\i�YVcsa�^fQK^fTIc�]�T�vdO'o`a/t¢^fcs_�ofpsv@^`cR¤�Q\[ROMmYZ[RcR�HC¡^�o�o£^�YZi�v OB�IpsYZQj^kT@c� �f{ 3 � YZcsv�Q\[ROMe@^la�_'TIpsaMmYZ[RcR�HC¡^�o�o£^`YZi'v OB�@psYZQK^fTIc � � } 3 � S���c Y�TIcRO/��v@^f]�O/csa¦^`TIcsY�o�vdTI]�Y�^fct#ajTI]�OMi\OB_'O/c>QaKQ\psv@^fOBa¡U�i�TI]�e�YViK^fTIpsa�e@^fO/��PsTV^kcdQ�a � ajO/OT�f{k �t;� ·\ �tM�ml� �tn�l{I{k �t;�f{B}o �tM�f{�p\ �t;�f{B·\ �t;�l{\l� �tM�f{�q\ �t;� }F{k �tn� }I}\ �t;� }�po �t� }2l� � t[sY�eIO�aK[RTZ��c�Q\[sYVQQ�[RO6]�TIQK^fTIc�TZU#Y+PsYZQ\Q\O/i�c�TZU�^fcdQ\O/i\csY�oDolY��IO/i'a�^`a�O'��P¢TIcRO/cdQK^`Y�o�o`�9a�ofTZ� � ^�SROISF]�O/Q�YIaKQ'YZqdofO � Sz�[d^`a�]�O/Q�Y@aKQ�YZqdofO�]�TIQK^fTIc�i\OBajpdokQ'aDU�i\T@]�Q\[RO�O'�RPsTIcRO/cdQK^`Y�o�of����OBYZ±4^fc>Q�O/i�YI_'QK^fTIcsaXQ\[sYZQ�T�_/_'pRi�q¢O/Q¦��O/O/c�cROBYZi\qd�o`Y��IO/i�a/S

z¡[RO�]�TIQK^fTIc�TZU�^fcdQ\O/i\csY�o�o`YB�@O/i�a�^fcnYM]�pdofQK^f��v@^f]�O/csa�^`T@csY�o�aKO/Q\QK^fcR¤M^`a6psaKpsY�o£of��eIO/i\��v@^�¥3O/i�O/c>Q+Q\[sYZc�^fcQ\[RO+TIcRO/��v@^f]�O/csa�^fTIcsY�o�_/YIaKOIS���c�Yw]�pdokQj^k��v@^f]�O/csa¦^kT@cgY�o�vdTI]�Y�^fct¢Q\[RO+^kcdQ\O/iKU�YI_�^`Y�o�]�TIQK^fTIc%^`a4psaKpsY�o�of�2vdij^ke@O/cqd�(Q\[RO�_'pRi\eZYZQ\pRi\O�TVU#Q\[RO+^kcdQ\O/iKU�YI_'O�YVcsv(O'�RPsT@cRO/c>QK^`Y�o�of���OBYV±�^fc>Q�O/i�YI_'QK^fTIcsa*qsO/QK��O/O/c�cRO'^f¤I[>q¢TIiK^fcR¤�o`YB�@O/i�aYZi\O�YIaj�>]�PRQ�TIQK^`_/Y�o�of�ncRO/¤Zo�^f¤Z^fqdofOISM� cRT@Q�YZqdofO�O'�s_'O/PRQK^fTIc­Q\TMQ\[d^`a6^`a4Q\[ROw�T@i\±(TZUr� }I·\ DU�TIi6Q\[RO���o�okO/cR�Km�YZ[RcOB�@psYZQK^fTIcM��^fQ\[©Y+Q\ij^k��ajQ�YZqdofO �s���M� ��[RO/i\O�^fQ��YIa�aK[RTZ��c�Q\[sYVQY�ajQ\OBYIvd��^fcdQ\O/iKU�YI_�^`Y�oPsYZQ\Q\O/i\c�_/YZc�q¢O4U�T@i\]�OBv^fcnQ�[RO�cROB_�±�TZU�Y�vdpR]�qR��qsO'o�oyaK[sYZP¢OBv�i\O/¤Z^fTIc�Q\[Ri\TIpR¤@[ Y%qsY�o`YZcs_'O�qsO/QK��O/O/c aK]�Y�o�o�^kcdQ\O/iKU�YI_�^`Y�oy_'pRi�e�YZQ\pRi�OYZcsv%O'��P¢TIcRO/c>Qj^lY�o£of����OBYZ±Mo`Y��IO/i�^fc>Q�O/i�YI_'QK^fTIcsa/StFTIi � {�.f{ � ^fc Y�]�pdofQK^f��v@^f]�O/csa�^`T@csY�o�vdTI]MY�^fct�Q\[RO�YIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_(YZcsY�of�Ra�^`aMTZUu� }Z¹] �U�T@i �wv 3 aK[RTZ��aQ\[sYZQ6Q�[RO�cRTIi\]�Y�o#eIO'ofT�_�^fQK�"x�TVU�Y�a¦^kcR¤VokO�_�ofT>aKOBv2^fc>Q\O/ijU�YI_'O,y�^`a*¤Z^feIO/c�qd�9Q�[RO�eITZofpR]�O�PRi�OBaKO/i\e@^kcR¤�]�OBYVc_'pRi\eZYZQ\pRi\Oz^sT�� x i�� �|{�} � {~ y ~ 8�� } >�� � . � {�. } �C�O/i\O }M� }4^`a�Q\[RO�]�OBYZc�_'pRi\eZYZQ\pRi\O�TZU�y�YZcsv ~ y ~ vdO/cRTIQ\OBaXQ\[RO�YZi\OBY4TVU�y�S���Q#��YIa�PRi\TZeIOBv�^kc��f{/¹� �t>YVcsv�aK[RTZ��ccdpR]�O/iK^`_/Y�o�of�(^fc���qo sU�TIi�Q\[RO�_/YIajO|� � }RtdQ\[sYZQ�Y�_�ofT>aKOBv�_'TIcdeIO'��^fcdQ\O/iKU�YI_'O6O/eITZofe@^fcR¤�pRcsvdO/i � {�. } � �¡^£o�o�Q�O/csvQ\T�Y�ajPR[RO/iK^`_/Y�o�^fc>Q\O/ijU�YI_'OwO/cs_�okTda�^fcR¤(Q\[RO�a\YZ]wO�eITZofpR]�OIS4��c9Q�[RO�_/YIaKO���[RO/c�aKO/e@O/i�Y�o#_�okTdaKOBv�^fc>Q�O/iKU�Y@_'OBa6YZi\OU�TIi\]�OBvwU�i\TI]¨^fcd^fQK^`Y�o�vRYZQ�YFt�Y�_'T>YVi�aKO/cd^fcR¤�PRi�T�_'OBa\a¡Q¦�dPd^`_/Y�o�of�(TR_/_'pRi�a/tR��[d^`_�[(_/YZc(YZ¤>Y�^kc�pdofQK^f]�YVQ\O'of�MokOBY@vMQ\TY�a�^fcR¤ZofO(aKPR[RO/iK^`_/Y�o�^fcdQ\O/iKU�YI_'OIS�z�[d^`a+PRi\TR_'OBa\a/t�aKQ\psv@^fOBv2^fc�� }V¹� �U�T@i6Q\[RO�_/YIaKOwTZU�cRTIcR��TZeIO/iKo`YZPRPd^fcR¤naKPR[RO/i\OBaYZcsv�^fc�� ¸o dU�TIi#Y+_'TZo�ofOB_'QK^fTIc(TZU�_'TIcs_'O/cdQ\iK^`_�i�YIv@^`Y�o�of�©aj�>]�]wO/Q\iK^`_�^fcdQ\O/iKU�YI_'OBa/tsvdOBa�_'iK^fqsOBa�Q\[RO�¤Ii\TZ��Q\[�TVUgo`YZi�¤IO/ii\O/¤Z^fTIcsa+YZQ4Q\[RO�O'�RPsO/csaKOMTZUaK]�Y�o£ofO/i�i\O/¤Z^fTIcsa*pRc>Qj^£o�tDO/eIO/c>Q�psY�o�ok�It�TIcdof��Y�a�^fcR¤ZofO�_�okTdaKOBv�^fc>Q�O/iKU�Y@_'O�i\O/]�Y�^fcsa/S

}

Page 3: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

z�[d^`a�aKpRi\e@^feI^fcR¤­i\O/¤V^kT@c Q\[RO/c1Q\O/csvRawQ\TnY�ajPR[RO/iK^`_/Y�o�aK[sYZP¢O9pRcsvdO/i � {�. } � S���csYZQ�pRi�Y�oy�@pROBaKQK^fTIc1Q\[RO/c ^laQ\T(vdO/Q\O/i�]�^fcRO�Q\[RO�aKpRqsajOB�IpRO/cdQ�O/eITZofpRQK^fTIc�TZU�Y�a�^fcR¤ZofO©ajPR[RO/iK^`_/Y�o#^fcdQ\O/iKU�YI_'O�_'TIcdQ�Y�^fcROBv2^kc Q\[RO�vdTI]�Y�^fc ' S³Z^fcs_'OIt�U�i�TI] � {�. } � tNx � 3 U�TIi�aKps_�[¶Y�aKPR[RO/iK^`_/Y�o4^fc>Q\O/ijU�YI_'OIt�Q\[RO(YIaj�>]�PRQ�TIQK^`_(YZcsY�ok�Ra�^`awTZUR� }Z¹] ¤V^ke@OBa�cRT^fcsv@^`_/YZQK^fTIc�TIc�Q\[RO6csYZQ\pRi�O�TZU�^fQ�a�]wTIQK^fTIcStFTIi�Q�[RO�i\O'o`YZQ�OBv­mYV[RcR�HC�^�o�o�^�YZi�v OB�IpsYZQj^kT@ct�^fQ�[sYIa+qsO/O/c�PRi\TZeIOBv2^fc�� }o #YZcsv � p\ �psa�^fcR¤nY(vd�dcsYZ]�^`_/Y�oaK�RaKQ\O/]�a�YZPRPRi\T>Y@_\[�Q�[sYZQ�^fc>Q\O/i�csY�ouolY��IO/i�aKTZofpRQK^fTIcsa���^fQ\[�Y+aKPR[RO/iK^`_/Y�o�aK[sYZP¢OItd��[d^`_\[�YZi\O�i\O'U�O/i\i\OBvwQ\T�YIaXqRpRqR�qdofO�aKTVokpRQj^kT@csa/tYZi\O6]�O/Q'YIaKQ�YZqdofOIS�z�[RO�]MY�^fc9�@psY�o�^kQ'YZQK^feIO+U�OBYVQ\pRi\O4^`a�Q�[sYZQ�Q\[RO6qRpRqRqdofO�vdiK^�U�Q�a�O'��P¢TIcRO/c>Qj^lY�o£of�a�ofTZ��of�©Y@_'i\T>a\aXQ\[ROyvdT@]�Y�^fc���^fQ\[RTIpRQ�_�[sYZcR¤Z^fcR¤�aK[sYZP¢OItR��[d^�ofO6]�Y�^fcdQ�Y�^fcd^fcR¤©Y�_'TIcsaKQ'YZc>Q�i�YIv@^fpsa�Q\T�_'TIcsaKO/i\e@O]�YIa�a/S�z�[ROyYVcsY�of��a�^`aX^fc�� }\ gYZcsv ��p\ R^`aXqsYIaKOBvwTIc�_'TIcsaKQ�i\ps_�^fcR¤�YZc�YZPRPRi�TB�d^f]�YZQ\O�^fc>eZYZiK^`YZcdQ�]�YZcd^�U�TZo`vutR��[d^`_�[_/YZPRQ\pRi�OBa4Q\[RO�a�ofTZ� vd�dcsYZ]�^`_/a/tYZcsv�Q\[RO/c�PRi\TZe@^kcR¤�OBajQK^f]�YZQ\OBa¡U�T@i�Q\[RO�YZQ�Q\i�YI_'QK^fe@^fQ¦��TVU#Q\[d^`a4]�YZcd^�U�TVolvuS4��of�Q\[RTIpR¤@[(Q\[d^`a6YZcsY�of�Ra�^`a4PRi\TZeIOBa�Q\[RO�O'�d^`aKQ\O/cs_'O�TZUa�ofTZ��]wT�e@^fcR¤�qRpRqRqdofO�ajTZofpRQK^fTIcsa/t¢U�pRi\Q\[RO/i4�T@i\±M^`a�cRO/OBvdOBvQ\T�T@qRQ�Y�^fc9YZc�O'�RPdo�^`_�^kQ N6´�Q\[sYZQ��@psYZcdQK^ � OBa4Q\[RO6qRpRqRqdofO�vd�>csYV]�^`_/a/S

z¡[RO(¤IT>Y�oTZU6Q\[d^`a�PsYZP¢O/i�^`a�Q\T�¤Z^feIO(YVc ?����uA£8;:B8���YIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_�_\[sYZi'YI_'Q\O/iK^f�BYZQK^fTIc1TZU6Y9a¦^k]�^£o`YZi�O'�RPsT@�cRO/cdQK^`Y�o�ok�­a�ofTZ��qRpRqRqdofO�]�TIQK^fTIc�Q�[sYZQ6T�_/_'pRi'a6U�TIi6Q\[RO�YZcsY�ok�dQK^`_/Y�o�of�­]�TIi\O�Q\i'YI_'Q�YZqdofO�PRi\T@qdokO/] � {].f{ � S pRiYZcsY�of�Ra�^`a�U�TIi � {�.f{ � ^`a�qsY@aKOBv�T@c©YZcMO'�RQ\O/csa�^fTIc(Q�T�Y+]�pdokQj^k��v@^f]�O/csa¦^`TIcsY�o#aKO/Q\QK^fcR¤�TZU�Q�[ROyYIaj�>]�PRQ�TIQK^`_4PRi\TI§KOB_'�QK^fTIcM]�O/Q\[RTRv�vdO/e@O'okT@PsOBvM^fc�� } l� �t�� }I}o gYZcsv,� }�p\ sQ�T�Q\i\OBYVQ#]�O/Q�Y@aKQ�YZqdofO4PRi\TIqdofO/]�a�^fcMTIcROyajPsYZQK^`Y�o�v@^f]�O/csa�^fTIcS

z¡[RO�TIpRQKo�^fcRO�TVU�TIpRi�YZcsY�ok�Ra�^`a�^`a�YIa�U�TZo�ofTZ��a/S���c��}+Q\[RO6]�O/Q\[RTRv�TVU�]�YZQ�_�[ROBv(Y@aK�>]wPRQ\TIQK^`_4O'�RPsYZcsa�^fTIcsa^`a�psaKOBv Q\T�_'TIcsaKQ\i\ps_'Q�Y�_/YZcRTIcd^`_/Y�o6qRpRqRqdofO2ajTZofpRQK^fTIc Q\T Q\[RO�OB�Ipd^�o�^fqRiK^fps] PRi\T@qdokO/]-U�TIi � {�.l{�/ � ^fc Y�o�o�TZU* + S���c� p*Q\[RO4O'^k¤@O/c>eZY�ofpRO�PRi\TIqdofO/]�YIa\ajT�_�^`YZQ\OBvM�¡^kQ�[�Q\[RO¡o£^fcROBYZij^k�BYVQK^fTIc�TZU � {�.f{�/ # 7 � YZq¢TIpRQ#Q\[RO6_/YZcRTIcd^`_/Y�oqRpRqRqdofO�aKTZofpRQK^fTIc�^`a�YZcsY�of�d�/OBv YIaj�>]�PRQ�TIQK^`_/Y�o�of�IS z¡[RO(YZcsY�of��a¦^la�TZU�Q\[d^`a�PRi\T@qdokO/]-O'�RQ\O/csvRa�Q\[RO�i\OBajpdokQ'a+^fc� }\ �q>�­PRi\TZe@^`v@^kcR¤�O'��Pdo�^`_�^fQ�YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQK^`_©U�TIi�]�pdo`YIawU�TIi�Q�[RO(qsO/[sY�e@^fTIi(TZU�_'O/i\Q�Y�^kc1O'^f¤IO/cdU�pRcs_'QK^fTIcga%TIc1Q\[ROqsT@pRcsvRYZi\��TZU�Q\[ROMvdTI]�Y�^fcS�z¡[ROBaKO�OBajQK^f]�YZQ\OBa/tD��[d^`_\[­YZi\OM_'O/c>Q\i'Y�oQ\T(YVc�O'��Pdo�^`_�^fQ�vdO/Q\O/i\]�^kcsYVQK^fTIc­TZU�Q\[ROqRpRqRqdofOnvd�dcsYZ]�^`_/a/t�YVi\O9vdO/iK^feIOBv�psa�^fcR¤ Y qsTIpRcsvRYVi\�­o`Y��IO/i�YZcsY�of��a¦^la�S1��c��\¹nQ�[ROBaKO(OBaKQj^k]MYZQ\OBaMYZi\O(psajOBvQ\TI¤@O/Q\[RO/i��¡^kQ�[9Q�[RO�PRi�TI§KOB_'QK^fTIc�]�O/Q\[RTRv(Q�T©vdO/iK^feIOMYZc�O'��Pdo�^`_�^fQ N6´ U�TIi4Q\[RO�a�ofT���]wTIQK^fTIc�TZU#Q\[RO�_'O/c>Q\O/i$ e �E$ e �H<�� TZU6Y(qRpRqRqdofOIS�z�[RO�PRi\TI§KOB_'QK^fTIc­]�O/Q�[RT�v ^`a�qsYIajOBv�TIc�o�^fcROBYZiK^f�'^fcs¤ � {�.f{ � YZq¢TIpRQ�Y�_/YZcRTIcd^`_/Y�oqRpRqRqdofO�aKTZofpRQK^fTIc(��[RO/i\O6Q\[RO�_'O/cdQ\O/i $ e �H<�� ^la¡Q\T�qsO�vdO/Q\O/i\]�^kcROBvuS4h���^f]�P¢T>a�^fcR¤©ajTZofe�YZqd^�o�^fQ¦��_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIcsa¡U�TIiQ\[RO4o�^fcROBYZiK^f�/OBv�PRi\T@qdokO/] Q\[sYZQ�]�psaKQ�[RTVolv©^fc�Q\[RO4o�^k]�^kQ � v 3 tsYVc N6´ U�TIi $ e �H<=� ^`a�TIqRQ�Y�^fcROBvuS���c���·�YVcsv��x���O�ajQ\psvd��Q\[d^`a N6´�YVcsvnvdO/Q\O/i�]�^fcROM^kQ'a6pRcsaKQ�YVqdokO�OB�@pd^�o�^kqRij^`pR] ajTZofpRQK^fTIc�U�T@i�Q\[RO�_/Y@aKOBa�� � }�YVcsv�� ¶}Rtdi\OBajPsOB_'QK^feIO'of�IS���PdofTIQ4TZU�Q\[RO4o`Y��IO/iyajQ\i\ps_'Q\pRi\O*U�T@i¡Y�qRpRqRqdokOMaKTZofpRQK^fTIc�^`a�aK[RTZ��cM^fc�tD^f¤sS{IS

�1[RO/c6� � p2TIpRi�]MY�^fc Y@aK�>]wPRQ\TIQK^`_�i�OBaKpdofQ(_/YZc q¢O2ajpR]�]�YZiK^f�/OBv1i�TIpR¤I[dof� YIa�U�TZo�ofTZ��a � aKO/O�/x � °³IpRPRPsTdaKO(Q\[sYVQ�Q\[ROMqRpRqRqdofO(^`a*^fcsa�^`vdO ' YVQ <��E3 YVcsv okO/Q $ e ��32� � $ ee %4' ( * + S��ya\ajpR]�O�Q\[sYZQ�YZQ< ��3 Q\[RO/i\O6O'�d^lajQ�a�Y+pRcd^`�IpRO�PsTV^kcdQ $���� e � % 0 ' _�ofT>ajOBaKQ�Q\T $ ee S�z�[RO/ctdU�TIi�O'��P¢TIcRO/c>Qj^lY�o£of��ofTIcR¤�QK^f]�OBa�tRQ\[RO]�TIQj^kT@c(TZU#Q\[RO�_'O/c>Q�O/i6TZU#Q\[RO�qRpRqRqdofO�^`a�^fc�Q\[RO�v@^fi\OB_'Qj^kT@c�TZU $M��� e �G�-$ ee S�W�TIi�O/T�e@O/iBtRQ\[RO�v@^lajQ�YZcs_'O���� �H<=�qsO/QK��O/O/c $���� e � YZcsv $ e �H<�� a�YZQK^`a � OBa�Q\[RO�YIaj�>]�PRQ�TIQK^`_ N6´

�� � ib��� � X�c� � � � { � � � ��� c � Xdc�� � � { � � � ��� � � X�c�� � � X ��!#"$&%('*),+�-/. X -1012 . � {�.�p �C�O/i\O � c YZcsv � � td��^fQ\[ �43 W5� � U�TIi�6 � { # }Ft>YZi\O4Q\[RO6PRiK^fcs_�^fPsY�o#i�Y@v@^£^�TZU�_'pRi\eZYZQ\pRi\O6TZU 0 ' YZQ $M��� e � YVcsv��7�^`a�Q\[RO4qRpRqRqdofO�i�Y@v@^kpsa�SW�TIi\O/TZeIO/i�t � YZcsv98 %V YZi\O6_'O/i\Q�Y�^fc(_'TIcsajQ�YZcdQ�a/td��[d^`_\[�vdO/PsO/csv%�OBYV±Iof�MTIc � t>Q�[sYZQ_/YZc�qsO�_/Y�ol_'pdo`YZQ�OBv9Y@aK�>]wPRQ\TIQK^`_/Y�o�of��U�TIi4Y�¤Z^feIO/c �s���M� S

z¡[RO©YIaj�>]�PRQ�TIQK^`_�YVcsY�of��a�^`a*ofOBYIv@^fcR¤�Q\T � {�.�p � ^`a+e�Y�o�^`v�TIcdof����[RO/c�Q\[RO�qRpRqRqdofO�^`a+aKQ\iK^`_'QKof�n_'TIcdQ�Y�^fcROBv��^fQ\[d^fc ' � ^�S OIS � � W:��7 � S���c;�kl>t���OMTZ¥O/i�ajTI]�O�aKPsOB_'pdo`YZQK^fTIcsawTIc�Q\[ROM]�TIQK^fTIc­Q\[sYVQ�TR_/_'pRi�a�Y�U�Q\O/i�Q\[ROp

Page 4: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

qRpRqRqdofOn_'TZo�o`YZPsaKOBa�YZ¤>Y�^fcsaKQ 0 ' S ��c��kl(��O9Y�o`aKT�]�YZ±IO(YVc¶YZcsY�ofTI¤@�­qsO/QK��O/O/c¶Q�[RO9vd�dcsYZ]�^`_/a � {�.�p � YVcsvY�a�^f]�^�o`YZi�q¢O/[sYBe@^fTIiMQ\[sYZQ�TR_/_'pRi�a�^kc�Q\[RO9_�o`YIa�a�^`_/Y�oyO'�d^fQ�Qj^k]wO(PRi\TIqdofO/] � aKO/O-�f{B¸\ � U�TIi�Q\[RO(]wTIQK^fTIc­TZU�Yh�i\TZ��cd^`YZc(PsYVi\QK^`_�ofO�_'T@c � cROBv�^fc�Y�vdTI]MY�^fc(qd�©YwPsTIQ�O/c>QK^`Y�o��O'o�o�S�n� ���u«n&+�M�g®���;�Z���6�Z�3~�~��f«­�u®�� �u���f®�

��c1Q\[RO�o�^f]�^fQ ��v 3 t���O9_'T@csaKQ\i\ps_'Q�YZc OB�@pd^�o�^kqRij^kp¢] aKTZofpRQK^fTIc1Q\T � {].f{�/ � ^fc * + Q\[sYZQM[sYIa�i'YIv@^`Y�oaK�d]�]�O/Q\i��¶YZcsv�Q\[sYZQM[sYIaMO'�sYI_'QKof� T@cRO(^fcdQ\O/i\csY�o6o`Y��IO/i(_'O/cdQ\O/i\OBv YVQ©aKT@]�O � � ��7�S z�[dpsa/t���O�YZi\O�Q\TvdO/Q\O/i\]�^kcRO+U�pRcs_'QK^fTIcsa ! 7 ���_� YZcsv�� 7 � � �_� t�_/Y�o£ofOBv�Q�[RO�_/YZcRTIcd^`_/Y�o#qRpRqRqdofO�aKTZofpRQK^fTIctu��[d^`_�[9a\YZQj^la¦U��� � � � 7 ����� � 7 �N��! 7 # 3 Y;�|Y�� � Q7 W 3 # � }?.f{�/ �� 7 � � 7� �h�N��3 � 7 � � �_�Nv � [ ���_�M# YIa � X�c � � � ��7 �Nv�� � . � }?.f{�7 ���c � }?.f{�/ � t ������� [sYIa�O'�sYI_'QKof��Q\[Ri�O/O6�/O/i\T>OBa�TIc�Q\[RO4^fcdQ\O/i\eZY�o � U�X # U�V` uofT�_/YVQ\OBv(YZQ � � U]X�Y 3 t �,��3 t�YVcsv� � U V W 3 ��^fQ\[

� Q � U [ � Y 35# � Q ��32� W 35# PZ� U V �N��3 # PZ�����N� � 8��� ' �����d� >� . � }?.f{�B ���c � }?.f{�7 � t � [ ���_� YZi\O6Q\[RO�Y@aK�>]wPRQ\TIQK^`_�ajQ�YZQ\OBa/t¢vdO � cROBv9Y@a�Q\[RO�i�T>TIQ'a�TZU� � � [ ���_� ��! 7 �L�_�n# � }?.f{ >?�U�TIi���[d^`_\[ � [ ���_� v U\[�YZcsv ! 7 ���_�Nv 3 YIa �av 3 S�z�[RO¡^kcdQ\O/i\csY�ogo`Y��IO/iXokTR_/YZQK^fTIc � 7 ^`a�vdO � cROBvwpRcd^l�@pRO'of��q>�� 7 � � 7� �_�N�63 S�b�a�^fcR¤�Q�[RO�]�O/Q�[RT�vMTZU�]�YZQ�_�[ROBv�Y@aK�>]wPRQ\TIQK^`_4O'�RPsYZcsa�^fTIcsa/tR��O4cRTZ� _'T@csaKQ\i\ps_'Q�Q\[RO6aKTZofpRQK^fTIcQ\T � }?.l{ � ^fc(Q\[Ri\O/O6v@^�¥O/i\O/c>Q�i\O/¤Z^fTIcsa/°�^fc�Q\[RO4^fcRcRO/i�^fc>Q\O/i�csY�ouolY��IO/i�i\O/¤V^kT@c���[RO/i\O � � � 7 � g ���_� YZcsvw^fc�Q\[ROQK��T�T@pRQ\O/i�i�O/¤Z^fTIcsa�T@pRQ�a�^`vdO�YZcsv©^fcsa�^`vdO�Q\[RO6qRpRqRqdofO���[RO/i\O ��W5��7�YZcsv� Y5��7'tRi\OBaKP¢OB_'QK^feIO'of�IS�n� � ���u«����s�/«R���u���� ��d¬u«��� w«��M�f®�

��c(Q\[d^`a�i\O/¤Z^fTIc���O4^fc>Q�i\T�vdps_'O�� ��� X�c � � � � 7 � YZcsv � 7 � �� �h� � � 7 � � 7 �"� �� �_� S�z�[RO/ct � }?.l{ � qsOB_'TI]�OBa� Q Q7 � �M� � � { �

��7 ��� � � Q 7 �"����� 7 �N��! 7 # � � Y��uY�� # � }?. }]/ �� 7 ��3 �_�N��3 � 7 � �� �h� v � [ ���_�M# YIa�� v�� � . � }?. }]7 �zDT4okOBY@v@^kcR¤�TIi'vdO/iYIa � v 3 tZQ\[RO�ajTZofpRQK^fTIc�Q\T � }�. } � ^la�a�^f]�Pdof��Y4Pdo`YZcsYZiX^kcdQ\O/i\csY�oRolY��IO/i�PRi\T � ofOIS�³IP¢OB_�^ � _/Y�o£o;�ItU�TIi �av 3 tR��O6[sY�eIO�Q\[sYVQ ! 7 �L�_� v 3 t � [ �L�_�Nv U [ YZcsv � 7 � �� �_�Nv � e � � � td��[RO/i\O � e � � � a\YZQK^`a � OBa� Q Qe �"�s��� e �N� 3 # � � Y��@Y��� � e ��32�N��3 # � Qe � � � W 35# � }?.�p]/ �� e � � �Ni U V � / V � X ! $� # � v �� � e � � �Ni U X � / X � ! ' # � vF� � . � }?.�p]7 �z�[RO+PsT>a�^fQK^feIO�_'TIcsajQ�YZcdQ�a�8 [ YZcsv,/ [ ^fc � }?.�p�7 � YZi\O�vdO � cROBv�qd�

8 [ �"! �5� Q � U [ �$# c�� � # okT@¤ / [ � ofTI¤ �%� U [ �;� 8 ��&e ' � 8 [� } Ps�(�d� c � � � {��� U [*) >�� . � }?.�p�B �²�O'�RQBts��O6O'�RPsYZcsv�Q�[RO�aKTZofpRQK^fTIc�Q\T � }?. } � YIa

� 7 � �� �_�Ni +,-%. e � - � � ��� - # ! 7 ���_� i +,-%. c ! - � - . � }?. ¹2/ �¹

Page 5: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

��c�YIvRv@^fQK^fTIctuQ\[RO�YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQK^`_6aKQ'YZQ\OBa � [ ���_� YVi\O�O'�RPsYZcsvdOBv%^fc(Q\O/i\]Ma�TZU�Q\[RO�pRcR±dcRTZ��csa � - �%� � � YIa� [ �L�_� i Uo[ � +,-%. c � - �%� � �L� - . � }?. ¹27 �

zDT(vdO/iK^feIO©YVc9OB�@psYZQK^fTIc U�TIi � - �OMaKpRqsaKQK^fQ\pRQ\O � }?. ¹ � ^fcdQ\T � }?. } � YVcsv � }?.f{ >?� S tRTIi�aKT@]�O+U�pRcs_'QK^fTIcsa � - �� - ��� e # . . # � - Xdc � YVcsv�� - [ � � - [ ��! c # . . #_! - X�c � td��O�TIqRQ�Y�^kc�Q\[sYZQ � - t�U�TIi��� {@tsa\YZQK^`a � OBa

� � -�� � Q Q- � � Q �L� e ��� - �4! - � � - ��� e # . . # � - Xdc �M# � � Y��uY�� # � }?. ·]/ �� - � � �Nv �5! - 8 X �[ � � - [ ��! c # . . #_! - X�c �n# YIa�� v�� �� � - ��32�N�43 . � }?. ·]7 �z�[RO � i�aKQ�U�O/� U�pRcs_'QK^fTIcsa � - YZcsv� - [nYVi\O�¤Z^feIO/c�O'��Pdo�^`_�^fQKof��qd�

� c �b� � � � { ���7 � Qe # � � �b� � �c} � Q Q ��� e �`� � � � { �

��7 � Qc � �

� 7 � Qe�� # � }?. x]/ �� c_[ ��35# � � [ � {

} ! �c 8 X� [ � Q Q � U [ � . � }?. x]7 �tFi\TI] � }�.�p�/ � YZcsv � }?. ·�/ � tF^fQ4U�TZo�ofTZ��a6Q�[sYZQ � Qe � � � a\YZQK^`a � OBa�� � Qe �O3 YZcsv � Qe � � � � �O3 S�z¡[RO/i\O'U�T@i\OItQ\[RO6iK^f¤I[dQ6a�^`vdO�TZU � }?. ·]/ � ]�psaKQ�a\YVQK^`a�U���Y�aKTVokeZYZqd^�o�^kQK��_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIcS5tFi\TI]��4i\O/O/c;K a�^`vdO/cdQK^fQ¦�(YVcsv � }?. p�7 � tIQ�[d^la_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIc�vdO/Q\O/i\]�^kcROBa ! - YIa

! - � � {� U V � U X � 8 +X + � Qe � - ��� e # . . #_� - X�c � > �r. � }?.ml ���^fQ\[ ! - ¤V^ke@O/c­q>� � }?.ml � tD��O©_/YZc�O/e�Y�okpsYVQ\O � - �%� � � ^kc � }?. ·�7 � S�z�[RO�aKTZofpRQK^fTIc�Q\T � }?. ·�/ � _/YZc�Q\[RO/c­q¢O_/Y�o`_'pdo`YZQ\OBv%pRP�Q\T�Y*]�pdokQj^kPdofO+TZU � Qe � � � S�z�[RO6_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIc � - ��32� ��3 � �ROBa�Q\[RO�]�pdofQK^fPdokO+TZU � Qe YZcsv�Q\[RO/i�O'U�TIi�OvdO/Q\O/i\]�^kcROBa � - pRcd^`�@pRO'ok�dS4³Ips_\[(Y+aK�RaKQ\O/]�YZQj^l_�PRi\TR_'OBvdpRi\O�_/YVc�q¢O�psaKOBvMQ�T�_/Y�o`_'pdo`YZQ\O�Y�o�oQ\[RO4Q\O/i\]�a ! - YVcsv� - U�T@i�� {@S�z�[RO/i\O'U�TIi\OIt¢^fc�PRiK^fcs_�^fPdofO>t���O�_/YZc�TIqRQ�Y�^kc�U�pdo�o¡YIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_�O'�RPsYZcsa�^fTIcsa*U�TIi � 7 � �� �_� t ! 7 �L�_�YZcsv � [ ���h� S

z¡[RO�aKTZofeZYZqd^�o£^;Q¦��_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIc�U�TIi � }�. · � ��^fQ\[�� � {6�@^fO'o`vRa

! c � � � � � { �� U V � U X � � 7 # ��[RO/i\O � � 8 +X + ! � Qe � � � # � > � ��� } 8 � $� ' � PZ����� c�� � >2� . � }?. ¸ �z�[RO*U�pRcs_'QK^fTIc � c � � � ^la�¤Z^feIO/c�q>�

� c � � �N��! c � Qe � � � 8 X +�L� e �(�d�;� U X �� � Qe �(�d� � >�� � � � � { �

��7 � Qe � � � 8 X +� �(�d�� � Qe �(�d� � >��z� ' c � Qe � � � . � }?.�q �

C�O/i\O � �(�d� � f��X + � ��Qe ���2� � >�� YZcsv ' c ^`a�Q\TMqsO�_�[RT>aKO/c�aKTwQ\[sYZQ � c ��32� � 3 S#��c(Q\O/i\]Ma�TZU � e YZcsv � c t¢Q\[ROaKTZofeZYZqd^�o£^fQK��_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIc�U�TIi � }?. · � ��^fQ\[�� � }�vdO/Q�O/i\]�^fcROBa ! � YIa! � � � � � { �� U V � U X � � � 7 � 7 8 +X + � Qc � � �L� Qe � � � > � � 8 +X + �M� � Qe � � � � > � �� {� U�V � U�X � 8 +X +

{} � � c � � � � � Q Q � � e � � � � Qe � � � > � . � }�.f{ 32�

·

Page 6: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

tRpRi�Q\[RO/iy_'TdO��©_�^fO/cdQ�a6YZi\O6Q\OBv@^fTIpsa4Q�T�O/eZY�ofpsYZQ\O�O'�RPdo£^`_�^fQKo`�IStFTIi�aKT@]�O�_'TIcsajQ�YZcdQ�a�� - [ td^fQ�_/YZc�qsO�aj[RT���c�U�i\TI] � }�. · � Q\[sYZQ � 7 � �� �_� [sYIa�Q\[RO*U�YZi � O'o`v�qsO/[sY�e@^kT@i� 7 � �� �_�Ni6� [ ���_���� +,-%. e � - � - � - [�� �� ! & # YIa�� v � �). � }�.f{I{ �

C�O/i\O� e [ ��� /?[ YZcsv � ch[ ���r� � � { � /?[ � � } � 7 � S���Q\[Ri\O/O/��Q�O/i\].Y@aK�>]wPRQ\TIQK^`_6O'�RPsYZcsa�^fTIc�U�TIi � [ �L�_� ^`a� [ ���_� � U [ �-��! c 8 X �[ �"� � { {} ! �c 8 X� [ � Q Q � U [ � ��! � 8 X �[ � � g �����]� . � }�.f{B} �

³Z^fcs_'O � }?.f{I{ � ^la�cRTIQ�pRcd^�U�TIi\]�of�­e�Y�o£^`v U�TIi � � g ��� X�c � t��OM]�psaKQ�_'T@csaKQ\i\ps_'Q�TIpRQ\O/i�aKTVokpRQj^kT@csa�qsTIQ�[^fcsa�^`vdO�YZcsv%TIpRQ�a�^`vdO�Q\[RO+qRpRqRqdofOISyz¡[d^la4cRT@cR��pRcd^£U�TIi\]�q¢O/[sY�eI^fTIi�YZij^lajOBa�U�i\T@]�Q\[RO+U�Y@_'Q�Q\[sYZQ4Q\[RO�_'pRi�e�YZQ\pRi�OQ\O/i\] ^kc � }?. }�/ � ^la g � { � ��[RO/c � � g ��� X�c � YZcsvMQ\[sYVQQ�[RO4U�YZi � O'o`vMo�^fcROBYZiK^f�BYZQj^kT@c�TZU � }�. }�/ � ^`a�vdT@cRO�YZq¢TIpRQU [ i�YZQ\[RO/i4Q\[sYZc � [ ���_� S�n� � ���u«��u�u�/«R���g®�� �u���f®�3�

��c Q\[RO�i\O/¤Z^fTIc1TIpRQ'a�^`vdO�Q\[RO�qRpRqRqdofO�U�TIi�4W � 7 t���O���iK^fQ\O�� 7 � � �h�,�F� V �L�_�5�b� V � �� �_� t���[RO/i�O� V D � V S�z�[RO/ctsqd�wo£^fcROBYZij^k�'^;cR¤ � }?.l{�/ � YZq¢TIpRQ � V ���_� tF�O6T@qRQ�Y�^fc(Q\[sYVQ � V � � �_� a\YZQj^la � OBa� Q QV � � � � { �

� � QV � � � X�c 8 %V � � � V ��3 # ��W5��7� � V v 3 Y@a � v � . � }�.f{�p �C�O/i\O 8 %V �����5� Q � � V �L�_� �� c�� � S tFi\TI] � }?.f{B} � ^fQ�U�TZo�ofT��4a�Q\[sYVQ

8 %V � 8 V { � ��! c} 8��V � Q Q � U V �;� g ��� � � � # YIa � v 3 . � }�.f{/¹ �

z�[RO+O'�FYI_'Q4aKTZofpRQK^fTIc�Q\T � }�.f{�p � ^`a� V � � #_�_�N��� V � � � � 7 � ckX + � ��� � � 8 %V � Xdc �� # �)�6� � � } � � } . � }�.f{B· �C�O/i\O � � � �2� t>�¡^kQ�[ � � � � �Nib��� � } �2� c�� � � X�� YIa ��v � td^`a�Q\[RO6]�TRv@^ � OBv(h�OBa\aKO'oU�pRcs_'QK^fTIc�TZU�Q\[RO�aKOB_'T@csv±@^kcsv�TVU¡T@i�vdO/i � S©z¡[RO©_'TIcsajQ�YZcdQ � V ^fc � }�.f{B· � ^`a+Q\T(q¢OMU�T@pRcsv�qd��]�YZQ�_�[d^fcR¤ � }?.f{�· � ��^fQ\[ � }?.f{I{ � S�zDT]�YZQ'_\[­Q\[ROBajO�Q\O/i\]�a���Ow^fc>Q\i�T�vdps_'O�YZc�^fcdQ\O/i\]�OBv@^`YZQ\O�e�YZij^lYVqdokO� � vdO � cROBv q>� � � � 7 � �d���_� � � t���[RO/i�O�aD �d���_�ND {�YIa � v 3 S�z�[RO/ctF^fc�Q\O/i\]�a�TVU � � t � }?.f{B· � YVcsv � }?.f{I{ � q¢OB_'TI]�O�Q\T�ofOBYIv@^fcR¤�TIi'vdO/i� V i�� V � c � ��� } 8 %V � X�c ��7 � X�c�� � � X ! "$ % '*) -10 � X ! "$ % '*) � + % 2 -"! # � }?.f{Bx]/ �� 7 �j� V ���_� ib� / V � X ! $ % '*) � +(% 2�-"! . � }?.f{Bx]7 �³Z^fcs_'O�8 %V � 8 V � g ���_� t¢Q\[RO/c �d�L�_��� X�c � � � 8 %V � 8 V � v 3 YIa �av 3 Sz¡[RO/i\O'U�T@i\OIts��O�_/YZc�]�YZQ�_�[(Q�[RO�iK^f¤I[dQa�^`vdOBa4TZU � }?.f{�x�/ � YZcsv � }?.f{Bx�7 � Q\TwTIqRQ�Y�^fc

� V ib� /:V � X�c�� � � } 8 %V � X�c � 7 � c�� � � ! "$ % '*) -10 . � }�.f{\l �tRT@i �|W;��7'tRQ\[RO6TIpRQ\O/i6aKTZofpRQK^fTIc%^`a � 7 � � �_�N�6� V ���h�;� � V � � �_� tF��[RO/i\O � V ^`a�¤Z^feIO/c%^fc � }?.f{B· � Sx

Page 7: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

� O�_/YZcnvdO/Q\O/i�]�^fcRO�Q\[RO�TIpRQ\O/i�ajTZofpRQK^fTIc�^fcsa�^`vdO�Q\[ROwqRpRqRqdokOIt���[RO/i\O 3�� ��Y � 7�t¢^fc Y�a¦^k]�^£o`YZiw�¡Y��IS³IpRqsaKQK^fQ\pRQj^kcR¤ � 7 � � �_� � � X ���h�N�j� X � � �_� ^fc>Q\T � }?.f{�/ � tu��[RO/i\O � X D � X t��O�T@qRQ�Y�^fc YVc9OB�@psYZQK^fTIc U�TIi� X � � �_� S�z¡[RO�aKTZofpRQK^fTIc�Q\TwQ\[d^`a�OB�@psYZQK^fTIc�Q\[sYZQ�^`a�i\O/¤Ipdo`YZi6YZQ � ��3 tsYZcsv%��[d^`_\[�]�YVQ�_\[ROBa¡Q\T � }?.l{I{ � ^`a

� X � � �_� ��� X � � � � 7 � ckX + � ��� � � 8 %X � X�c �� # � X i /�X � } � 8 %X � X�c � 7 � c�� � � X !#"' %('*) -10 . � }�.f{B¸ �C�O/i\O � � � �2� ^`a�Q\[RO6]�TRv@^ � OBv(h�OBa\aKO'oDU�pRcs_'QK^fTIc�TZU�Q\[RO � i'aKQ�±@^kcsv%TZU�TIi'vdO/i � �6� � � } � � }dS���c � }�.f{B¸ � t@Q\[ROvdOB_/Y��(_'TIcsaKQ�YVc>Q 8 %X ^`a�vdO � cROBv�qd� 8 %X � � �5� Q � � X �L�_� � c�� � tsYZcsv%[sYIa�Q\[RO+O'��PsYZcsa¦^kT@c

8 %X � 8 X { � ��! c} 8��X � Q Q � U X �� g �L� � � � # Y@a �av 3 . � }�.f{�q �

� OnaKpR]�]�YViK^f�/OnTIpRi�i�OBaKpdofQ�aMU�TIi�Q\[ROn_/YVcRTIcd^`_/Y�o�qRpRqRqdofO aKTZofpRQK^fTIc qd� psa�^fcR¤ Q�[RO�o`YZi\¤IOnYVi\¤IpR]�O/cdQO'�RPsYZcsa�^fTIcsa4TZU � � ���2� YZcsv � � � � � Q\T�a�^f]�Pdo�^�U�� � }?.f{B· � YZcsv � }?.f{B¸ � S�z¡[d^la��@^kO'o`vRa/t� 7 � �� �_�`ib� V �L�_� � / V � � � � 7 � + c X + 2 � � � X ! "$ % '*) +�- X -1012 # ��W ��7 # � }?. } 3 / �� 7 � �� �_�`� � 7 � �� �_�Ni +,-%. e � - � � ��� - # � � � X�c � � � ��7 � � g � { �M# � }?. } 3 7 �� 7 � �� �_�`ib� X �L�_� � / X � � � ��7 � + ckX + 2 � � � X !#"' %('*),+�-10 X -�2 # 3�� ��Y5��7�. � }?. } 3 B �z�[RO�U�pRcs_'QK^fTIcsa � - � � � U�T@i �� {�YVcsv�Q\[RO�_'TdO��©_�^fO/c>Q'a�^fc�Q�[RO�YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQj^l_¡O'��PsYZcsa¦^kT@csa�U�TIi � [ ���_� YZcsv ! 7 ���h� t��iK^fQ\Q�O/c�^fc � }?. ¹ � t�_/YVcnq¢O�TIqRQ�Y�^fcROBv U�i\TI] � }?. · � SM� U�O/� TZU�Q\[ROBaKO�Q\O/i�]�a�YZi�O�¤Z^feIO/c­O'�RPdo�^`_�^kQjok� ^fc � }�. ¸ � t� }?. q � t � }?.f{ 32� YZcsv � }?.f{�} � S�n��� &�®��D�s�\�`��®;�­®��6���/¬ ��D�/®s���;���M�¯ �w���9«R�\�`�V���� �«R�\� �l�B�

� O�cRTZ� _'TI]wPsYZi\O�TIpRi�YIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_�i�OBaKpdofQ�a�U�T@i ! 7�YZcsv 8 %V ��^fQ\[�_'TIi\i\OBaKP¢TIcsv@^fcR¤�c>pR]�O/ij^l_/Y�oi\OBaKpdofQ�a_'TI]�PRpRQ�OBv+U�i�TI]�Q\[RO�U�pdo�ouPRi\TIqdofO/] � }�. } � psa�^fcR¤�Q\[RO�qsT@pRcsvRYZi\��e�Y�ofpRO6aKTZofeIO/i�m I�³���³,� ¹� �S�³Z^fcs_'O�m I�³���³Y�o�ofTZ��a�U�TIi�cRT@cdo£^fcROBYZi+qsTIpRcsvRYVi\�(_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIcsa�YVcsvMU�TIi�^fc>Q�O/iK^fTIi�P¢TZ^fc>Q6_'TIcsaKQ�i�Y�^fc>Q'a/tsQ�[RO�PRi\TIqdofO/] � }?. } � _/YZcqsO6i�OBYIv@^�ok��aKTZofeIOBvMpsa�^fcR¤MQ\[d^`a�PsYI_�±�YZ¤@O6q>��i�O/����iK^fQK^fcR¤�^fQ�Y@aY � i�aKQ�TIi�vdO/i�aj��aKQ�O/] U�TIi�Q\[RO�·+pRcR±dcRT���csa � 7�t� Q 7 t � [ YZcsv ! 7�S � O�Q\[RO/c�Q\i\pRcs_/YZQ\O � }�. } � Q\T�Y � cd^fQ\O�vdTI]�Y�^fc ~ � ~ Y �­qd�M^k]wPsT>a�^fcR¤ � 7 �%� � � �b� [ S ��O_�[RT>aKO � � {/¹�^kc�Q\[RO�_'T@]�PRpRQ�YZQK^fTIcsa�qsO'ofTZ��S�zDT�TIqRQ�Y�^kc�c>pR]wO/iK^`_/Y�oXajTZofpRQK^fTIcsa�U�T@i�^fcs_'i\OBYIa�^fcR¤(eZY�ofpROBa4TZU � t��O6psaKOBv(YM_'TIcdQK^fc>psYVQK^fTIc9aKQ�i�YZQ\O/¤I��aKQ�YVi\QK^fcR¤�U�i\TI]�Q\[RO+Pdo`YZcsYZi�^kcdQ\O/iKU�YI_'O�aKTZofpRQK^fTIcS

z¡[RO�_'TI]�PRpRQ'YZQK^fTIcsa4��O/i\O�vdTIcRO*U�TIi�Q\[RO6U�TZo�ofT��¡^kcR¤MQK��T�U�T@i\]�a�TZU ���L�M� °� �����k���M� � } ���Z�"� � �M# � }?. }R{�/ �� ����� �L�M� � �M���s� { ��� B e �-�M��� B c �-�M� B c � B e � � p � B e � }�B �e �

· � B e � { � # B e � {�. } . � }?. }R{�7 �z�[RO+[RO/Q\O/i\TR_�o£^fcd^`_wTIi\qd^fQy_'T@csaKQ�YZcdQ�a�8][td/?[�t�U\[­YZcsv � U�T@i � e � � � tdTIqRQ�Y�^kcROBv%U�i\TI] � }?.�p � YZcsv � }?. ¸ � t>YZi\O

� ����� ��� 8 [ � } # / [ � } # U [ � � { # � � ¹ � p # � }?. }I}]/ ��O����� ��� 8 V � {]. ¸IxIxI¸ # 8 X � }?.ml�¸@}I¸ # / V � {�. ¸ 3�3�35# / X � }?. }R{ 3 { #U V � {�. } # U X �O� {�. 3 # � � {�.�q 3 ¹I¹ . � }?. }I}]7 �l

Page 8: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

b4a�^fcR¤�Q\[RO�e�Y�ofpROBa4^fc � }?. }I} � tR��O�_/YZc�O/e�Y�ofpsYZQ\OwQ\[RO�YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQK^`_+i\OBaKpdofQ4U�TIi48 %V ts¤V^ke@O/c�^fc � }?.f{/¹ � tsYZcsv�Q\[ROofOBYIv@^fcR¤�TIi�vdO/i6YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQj^l_*i\OBaKpdofQ ! 7 i4��! c tR��[RO/i\O ! c ^`a�¤Z^feIO/c�^fc � }?. ¸ � S

�1[RO/c �O��� � ���M� t � 7 � {6YZcsv,� � }Rt@^kc&tD^f¤sS¢}���O6PdofTIQ�Q�[RO6c>pR]�O/ij^l_/Y�o�aKTZofpRQK^fTIc � 7 � �� �_� Q�T � }?. } �YZQ6QK��T�e�Y�ofpROBa+TZU � STtFTIi6Q\[d^`a*U�TIi�]�TZU ������� YZcsv���^fQ\[ ��7 � {Itu^fc�tD^k¤¢S;p(YZcsv�tD^f¤sSu¹���O�_'T@]�PsYZi\OMQ\[ROcdpR]�O/iK^`_/Y�o�of� _'TI]wPRpRQ\OBv�eZY�ofpROBa+TZU 8 %V YZcsv ! 7��¡^kQ�[�Q\[RO�_'TIi�i\OBaKPsT@csv@^kcR¤�YIaj�>]�PRQ�TIQK^`_�i\OBaKpdofQ�a � }?.f{�¹ � YVcsv! 7 iO��! c STtRTIi|� � }�YZcsv�� � pFtuQ\[ROBaKO � ¤IpRi�OBa�aK[RTZ��Q\[sYZQ6Q�[RO�YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQj^l_�i\OBaKpdofQ�a6PRi�T�e@^`vdO©Y�_�ofT>ajOvdO/Q\O/i\]�^kcsYVQK^fTIc�TZU#Q\[RO�_'TIi\i\OBajPsTIcsv@^fcR¤(cdpR]�O/iK^`_/Y�o#i�OBaKpdofQ�a�U�T@i�Q\[RO+i�YZcR¤IO 3 Y � YO.f{B·FS#��c2z�YZqdofOBa�{BY�YVcsv{/qM��O�aK[RTZ� Y�a�^f]�^�o`YZi6YZ¤Ii\O/O/]�O/cdQ�qsO/QK��O/O/c�Q\[RO6YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQK^`_4YZcsvwc>pR]�O/ij^l_/Y�o�e�Y�ofpROBa�TVU 8 %V YZcsv ! 7�U�TIi�Q\[ROU�TIi\] � ��� �\����� ��^fQ\[ ��7 � {�YZcsv&B e � {�. }RS�;� � �«R�Z�B�������4�/��� ���R�/«�� ��®g�M� �u«2 � �u«d�s� � � «R¯��+��®g~��f« �

� O�cRTZ� aKQ\psvd� Q\[RO�aKP¢OB_'Q\i�Y�o�PRi\TIPsO/i�QK^fOBa�YIa\aKTR_�^`YZQ\OBv ��^fQ\[�o�^fcROBYZiK^f�'^`cR¤�Q\[RO � cd^fQ\O(vdTI]MY�^fcnPRi\T@qdokO/]� {�.l{�/ # 7 � YVqsTIpRQ�Q\[RO�_/YZcRTIcd^`_/Y�oqRpRqRqdofO�aKTZofpRQK^fTIc�� 7 � � �h� tZ��[d^`_\[w^`a�vdO � cROBvw^kc�Y�o�ogTVU * + S#z¡[RO�O'^f¤IO/c>eZY�ofpROPRi\TIqdofO/]!YIa�aKT�_�^`YZQ�OBv���^fQ\[�Q\[d^`a�o�^fcROBYZiK^f�BYZQK^fTIc ^`a

� � ���Z�"� Q � � 7 � � �_� ��������# $&%�'b# � p?.f{�/ �0:1 ���435# $�% 0 ' � �`#� � � { . � p?.f{�7 �C�O/i\O �S�;# x�� � f 9 � x >2$ YZcsv � � ~ $���$ e ~ td��[RO/i\O $ e ^`a�Q�[RO6ofT�_/YVQK^fTIc(TZU�Q\[RO�_'O/cdQ\O/i4TZU�Q�[RO6qRpRqRqdokOIS�z¡[ROO'^f¤IO/cde�Y�ofpROBa�YVcsvMO'^k¤@O/cdU�pRcs_'QK^fTIcsa*TZU � p?.f{ � YZi�O4olYVqsO'ofOBv�qd� � - YZcsv � - tIU�TIi � ��3?# { # . .ftZ��^fQ\[ � - vF� � YIa� v � S

��c�Q\[RO�YZcsY�of�Ra�^`a�qsO'ofTZ� ��O6YIa\aKpR]�O6Q�[sYZQ�Q\[RO�qRpRqRqdofO*^la�aKQ\iK^`_'QKof�w^kcsa¦^lvdO ' ajT�Q�[sYZQ#Q\[RO�v@^`aKQ'YZcs_'O4U�i�TI]0 ' Q\T+Q\[RO�^fcdQ\O/i\csY�oDolY��IO/i�i\O/¤V^kT@cM^laag � { � � aKO/O tD^f¤sSu{ � S ��^fQ\[�Q\[d^`a�Y@a\aKpR]�PRQK^fTIctFQ\[RO�]wO/Q\[RT�vMTVU3]MYZQ�_�[ROBvYIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_�O'�RPsYZcsa�^fTIcsa�^`a�psaKOBvwQ\T�YIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_/Y�o�ok��_/Y�o`_'pdo`YZQ\O+Q\[RT>aKO�O'^f¤IO/cRPsY�^ki'a � - t � - U�TIi���[d^`_\[ � - v 3YIa � v 3 S�z�[RO�YZcsY�of�Ra�^`a*^la*i�YZQ\[RO/i�a¦^k]�^£o`YZiwQ\T�Q\[sYZQ4^fc ��}Rt��^fQ\[ Q\[RO�O'�s_'O/PRQK^fTIcnQ�[sYZQ���O�]�psaKQ6^fcsaKO/i\Q�YqsT@pRcsvRYZi\��o`Y��IO/i�Q\O/i\] U�TIi � - cROBYVi 0 ' ^kcMTIi�vdO/i�Q\T�a�YZQK^`a�U���Q�[RO�qsTIpRcsvRYVi\�©_'T@csv@^kQj^kT@c � p?.f{�7 � O'�sYI_'QKof�ISz¡[d^laqsT@pRcsvRYZi\��o`Y��IO/i�YZcsY�of�Ra�^`a/t���[d^`_\[ ¤Z^feIOBa6O'�RPdo�^l_�^fQ�Y@aK�>]wPRQ\TIQK^`_�OBaKQj^k]MYZQ\OBa4U�TIi�_'O/i\Q'Y�^fc � - T@c 0 ' t¢^`a6e�Y�o£^`vTIcdof����[RO/c ' ^la4_'TIcdeIO'�S#z�[ROBaKO�aKPsOB_'Q\i'Y�o�i�OBaKpdofQ�a�YVi\O6Q\[RO/c(psajOBv�^fc��\¹sS�;� � ���u«���\� �3��� D����� � �¢«�� D���`� ��� �M�3¯ � �

z¡[RO�PRiK^fcs_�^fPsY�oO'^f¤IO/cdU�pRcs_'QK^fTIc � e ^la�i�YIv@^`Y�o�of�9aj�>]�]wO/Q\iK^`_4^fc�+O'�F_'O/PRQ�^fc9YZcwg ���_� i\O/¤Z^fTIc(cROBYVi 0 ' S��cnQ�[RO�^fcdQ\O/i\csY�o�o`Y��IO/i�i\O/¤Z^fTIc��OMaKO/Q�� � � Xdc � � � � 7 � YVcsv�� e � �� �_�r��� e � � 7 � � � � S�³Z^fcs_'OIt�U�i�TI]� }?. } 3 7 � t � 7 � � �_�Ni�� +-�. e � - � � ��� - ^fc(Q\[d^`a�i\O/¤Z^fTIct¢Q\[RO�_'TdO��©_�^fO/c>Q � QS� � 7 � ^kc � p�.f{�/ � [sY@a�Q\[RO�O'�RPsYZcsa�^fTIc

� Q � � 7 � ��� Qe ������� c � ����� � ��� Q Qe � � �} �d�c � Q Q Qe �������M# Y@a �av 3 . � p?. } �C�O/i\O���O6[sY�eIO�vdO � cROBv � Qe � � Q �L� e � t � Q Qe � � Q Q ��� e � tdO/Q�_ZS ��O6Q\[RO/c�O'��PsYVcsv� e � �� �_� YZcsv � e ���_� YIa

� e � �� �h�Ni +,-�. e � e - � � ��� - # � e ���_� i +,-%. e � e - � - . � p?.�p �³IpRqsaKQK^fQ\pRQj^kcR¤ � p�. } � YZcsv � p?.�p � ^kcdQ\T � p�.f{�/ � tgYVcsv9_'TVo£ofOB_'QK^fcR¤�P¢TZ�O/i'a4TZU � tu��O�TIqRQ�Y�^fctT@c � � Y���Y � tQ\[sYZQ

��� e�e ��� e�e � e�e # � p?. ¹2/ �¸

Page 9: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

��� e c �O�5� c � e�e � Q Qe � � � � { �� 7 � Qe�e � � e c � e�e � � e=e � e c # � p?. ¹27 �

��� e � �O� � � � { �� 7 � Qe c � � � � { � �

� �7 � Qe�e ��� c � e c � Q Qe �-� � � e�e � Q Qe � {} �d�c � e�e � Q Q Qe��� e�e � e � ��� e c�� e c � � e � � e�e . � p?. ¹:B �C�O/i\O � ^la4vdO � cROBv�q>� � x � x Q Q�� � Qe x�YVcsv���O6i\OB�@pd^ki�O�Q�[sYZQ � e 3 � � �Nv 3 YIa � v � � S

³Z^fcs_'O � � Qe �43 td��^fQ\[ � Qe �%� � � ��3 tRQ\[RO�aj��aKQ�O/] � p?. ¹ � ]�psaKQ4a\YZQK^`a�U���Q�[RO�aKTZofe�YZqd^�o�^`QK�9_'T@csv@^kQj^kT@c9Q�[sYZQ� � e 3 t�U�TIi 6 � 3?# { # }Ftu^`a�TIi\Q�[RTI¤ITIcsY�o�Q\T � Qe ��^fQ\[­i�OBaKPsOB_'Q�Q�T9Q�[RO�^fcRcRO/iMPRi\T�vdps_'Q � �;# x�� � f +X + � x > �gStRT@i � p?. ¹2/ � Q\[d^`a4_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIc��@^kO'o`vRa � e�e �43 S#z�[dpsa � e�e � � e � Qe tR��[RO/i�O � e ^`a�Y�cRTIi\]�Y�o�^f�BYZQK^fTIc�_'TIcsajQ�YZcdQBS³IpRqsaKQK^fQ\pRQj^kcR¤ � e�e � � e � Qe YZcsv � e�e � 3 ^fcdQ\T � p�. ¹:7 � t���O�Q\[RO/c i�O/����iK^fQ\O(Q�[RO(iK^f¤I[dQ�a�^`vdO(TVU � p�. ¹:7 � q>�O'�RPdo£^`_�^fQKo`��psa�^fcR¤MQ\[RO�OB�@psYZQK^fTIc � }?. ·]/ �5� ��^fQ\[ � � { � a�YZQK^`a � OBv�qd� � c S�z�[d^`a��@^fO'olvRa

� � e c � � e � � Qc � � e c � e � Qe . � p?. · �³Z^fcs_'O � � � Qc # � Qe � � � � Qc # � � Qe � � 3 t#Q\[RO�aKTZofe�YVqd^£o�^fQK� _'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIc1U�TIi � p?. · � ¤Z^feIOBa � e c � 3 S¶z¡[RO/i\O'U�T@i\OIt� e c � � e ��Qc S�z�[RO�YZi\qd^fQ\i�YVi\��]�pdokQj^kPdofOMTZU ��Qe tR��[d^`_�[n_/YZc(q¢O�YIvRvdOBv�Q\T � e c tu_/YZc(q¢O�_\[RT>ajO/c9Q�T�q¢O��/O/i�TsS³IpRqsaKQK^fQ\pRQj^kcR¤ � e 3 � � e � Q3 YZcsv � e 3 �b3 U�TIi46 � { # }+^fcdQ\T � p?. ¹:B � tsYZcsv�psa�^fcR¤ � }?. ·]/ � �¡^kQ�[� � }Fts��O�_/YZci\O/����ij^kQ�O � p?. ¹:B � YIa ��� e � � � e { � � Q� � � � � { �

� � 7 � Qe � � � e � � e � Qe . � p?. x �z�[RO�aKTZofeZYZqd^�o£^fQK��_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIc�U�TIi � p?. x � ¤Z^feIOBa � e � �O� � � { � � X �7 YZcsvutuQ�[>psa/t � e � � � e � Q� S�z¡[RO/i\O'U�T@i\OItuQ\[RO^fcRcRO/i6O'��PsYVcsa�^fTIc�U�TIi � e ^`a

� e � �� �_�N� � e ! � Qe � � �M����� Qc � � �M��� � � Q� � � �� g ��� � � # # � p?.ml �YZcsv%Q\[RO6O'��PsYVcsa�^fTIc�TZU�Q\[RO6O'^f¤IO/cde�Y�ofpRO�^`a

� e ���_� ��� � � � � { �� � 7 � g �����]� . � p?. ¸ �

��okQ�[RTIpR¤I[ � e ^`a�PsT>a¦^kQj^ke@OIt�YZcsv�[RO/cs_'O���TIpdo`v(cRT@i\]�Y�o�of��okOBY@v(Q�T�O'�RPsTIcRO/cdQK^`Y�o#¤Ii�T���Q\[tsQ�[d^la�]�TRvdO+^la6ajpRPR�PRi\OBa\ajOBvM^fc �\¹�q>�MQ\[RO+PRi\OBaKO/cs_'O�TZU�Q\[RO�]�Y@a\a�_'TIcsaKQ�i�Y�^fc>Q�S

��c�Q�[RO�TIpRQ�O/i#i\O/¤Z^fTIc�U�TIi ��Y5� 7 ��O�ofO/Q � e i � e � X � � �_� S���c�Q\[d^`a�i\O/¤Z^fTIc � 7 ib� X �L�_� tRaKT6Q\[sYZQ � p?.f{�/ �qsOB_'T@]�OBa

� Q QX � � � � { �� � Q X � �H� X�c��8 %X � � � X �635# 3 Y ��Y5��7� �8 %X � 8 %X�� { � � e � � 8 %X ���� c�� � . � p?.�q �

³Z^fcs_'O � e � g ��� � � Y@a � v 3 tF^fQ�U�TZo�ofTZ��a�Q�[sYZQ 8 %X � �8 %X � g ��� � � Sz¡[RO�O'�sYI_'QyajTZofpRQK^fTIc�Q\T � p?.�q � td��[d^`_�[�^lai\O/¤Ipdo`YZi6YZQ � �63 tRYZcsv���[d^`_�[�]�YZQ�_�[ROBa�Q\T � p?.ml � ^`a

� X � � �_�N�� X � � � ��7 � ckX + � � � � � �8 %X � X�c � � # X i / X 8 X � } � 8 %X � X�c � 7 � c�� � � X �! "' % '*) -10 # � p�.f{ 32���[RO/i\O �)�6� � � } � � }dS q

Page 10: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

��c�Q\[RO#TIpRQ�O/ii\O/¤Z^fTIc+U�TIi � W � 7�tBqRpRQ�YZQ�YVc|g � { � v@^lajQ�YZcs_'O�Y���Y���U�i�TI] 0 ' t���O#��ij^kQ�O � e i � e � V � �� �_� S��c�Q\[d^`a�i�O/¤Z^fTIc�� 7 i � V ���_� t¢aKT�Q\[sYZQ � p?.f{�/ � qsOB_'TI]wOBa

� Q QV � � � � { �� � QV � �H� X�c �8 %V � � � V �435# � W;��7� �8 %V � 8 %V � { � � e � � 8 %V � � � c � � . � p�.f{I{ �

²�TIQ\O6Q\[sYZQ �8 %V � 8 %V � g ��� � � S�z�[RO+O'�FYI_'Q6aKTZofpRQK^fTIc�Q\T � p�.f{I{ � td��[d^`_�[(]�YVQ�_\[ROBa�Q\T � p?.ml � t@^`a� V � � �_�N� V � � � � 7 � ckX + � � � � � �8 %V � Xdc �� # V i /2V 8\V � Xdc�� � � } 8 %V � X�c � 7 � c�� � � �!#"$ %('*),-10 # � p�.f{B} �

��[RO/i\O �)�6� � � } � � }dS²�TIQK^`_'OMQ\[sYZQ � V ^`a6O'�RPsTIcRO/cdQK^`Y�o�of� aK]�Y�o�o�U�TIi �,W � 7 t�YVcsv�[sYIa4Q\[RO�U�TZo�ofTZ��^fcR¤9YIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_�OBaKQK^f]�YZQ�O

TIc 0 ' °0:1 � V � �8 %V � X�c V � � � ��7 � ckX + � � � Q� � �8 %V � X�c � � ���� � ��@� g �L�_� # ��[RO/i\O:� � ~ $��-$ e ~ #6$,% 0 ' . � p�.f{�p �C�O/i\O��� ^`a�Q\[RO�pRcd^fQ6TIpRQK��YZi�vwcRTIi\]MY�o�Q�T 0 ' t��� � ��$T�-$ e � � Xdc YZcsv��� � �� vdO/cRT@Q\OBa�Q�[RO�vdTIQ4PRi\TRvdps_'QBSz¡[ROYZcsY�of�Ra�^`a�ofOBYIv@^fcR¤�Q\T � p?.l{�p � i\OB�@pd^ki�OBa�Q\[sYVQ ' ^`a�_'TIcdeIO'�S

��c�\¹���O4cRO/OBv(YZc(Y@aK�>]wPRQ\TIQK^`_4U�TIi\]�pdo`Y+U�TIi � e TIc 0 ' S C�TZ��O/eIO/iBtRa�^fcs_'O � V U�Y�^�o`a�Q�T�O'�sYI_'QKof�(a\YVQK^`a�U��Q\[RO�qsT@pRcsvRYZi\� _'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIc � p�.f{�7 � t���O2_/YVcRcRTIQ�psaKO � V v@^fi\OB_'Qjok�1Q\T�TIqRQ�Y�^kc1Q\[d^`a©U�TIi�]�pdo`YRS ��csaKQ\OBYIvut�Q\TOBaKQK^f]�YVQ\O � e TIc 0 ' td��O4]�psajQ � i'aKQ�YIvRv�Y+q¢TIpRcsvRYZi\�wo`YB�@O/iQ�O/i\] Q\T � V ��[d^`_�[�^`aXokTR_/Y�o�^f�/OBv�cROBYZi 0 ' S�zDTi\O/PRi\OBajO/c>Q � e cROBYZi 0 ' ts��O+^fc>Q�i\T�vdps_'OMYwokTR_/Y�o_'TdTIi�v@^fcsYZQ\OMaK��ajQ\O/]!vdO � cROBv�cROBYZi 0 ' S � O�ajO/Q �,��� � � t��[RO/i\O ��� ^la�Q\[RO�v@^`aKQ�YVcs_'O6U�i\TI] $,%w' Q\T 0 ' tRYZcsvM��O4ofO/Q � vdO/cRTIQ\OR� � {6_'T>TIi'v@^kcsYVQ\OBa�T@i\Q\[RTI¤IT@csY�oQ\T� S���c�Q�[RO6i\O/¤Z^fTIc �Z� g � { � td��O���ij^kQ�O � e � � e � � V ��`� td��[RO/i\O ��� �`���M#��2� ^`a�Q\[RO6qsT@pRcsvRYZi\�Mo`Y��IO/iU�pRcs_'QK^fTIcS�z�[RO/ct¢Q\T+okOBY@v@^kcR¤�TIi�vdO/iBtF�O6T@qRQ�Y�^fc�U�i\TI] � p?.f{ � Q\[sYZQ0 � � � ��� �8 %V � � � ��35# � Y 3 � v 35# Y@a �Zv � � #0 � � ���������2�n# �Z��3 �M���2� � � � 0:1 � V � � . e . � p�.f{/¹ �z�[RO�aKTZofpRQK^fTIc�Q\T � p?.f{�¹ � td��[d^`_\[�vdOB_/Y��Ra�O'�RPsTIcRO/cdQK^`Y�o�of��YIa �Zv � � tF^`a

� � �H���M���2� � �8 %V � � �! "$ � . � p�.f{B· �tRi�TI] � p?.l{�p � t � p?.l{B· � YZcsv � e � � e � � V � � � td��O�TIqRQ'Y�^fc�^fc9YZc&g ���_� cRO'^f¤I[>q¢TIi\[RTdT�v�TZU 0 ' Q\[sYZQ

� e i � e V � � � � 7 � ckX + � � � � � �8 %V � X�c � � � � �! "$ 1 % '*) � �� � �� � Q� � �8 %V � Xdc � � � � . e � . � p�.f{Bx �tD^fcsY�o�of�Itpsa�^fcR¤ � p?.f{B} � tdQ\[RO�i\OBajpdokQ �8 %V � 8 %V � g ��� � � tsYZcsv%Q\[RO6o`YZi�¤IO�YZi�¤IpR]�O/cdQ�YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQj^l_/a�TZU � ��YVcsv� Q� tR��O�_/Y�o`_'pdolYVQ\O�TIc 0 ' Q\[sYVQ

� e i � e / V 8 V � � � ��7 � + ckX + 2 � � � X ! "$ % '*) + - X -10,2 �f{ � �� � �� # � � ~ $Z�"$ e ~ #,$�% 0 ' . � p�.f{\l �� O�_/YZc9aKpR]w]�YZiK^f�/O�T@pRi�i\OBaKpdofQ�a�U�TIi � e qd��psa¦^kcR¤ �8 %[ i 8 %[ YZcsvMQ\[RO*olYVi\¤IO�YZi\¤@pR]�O/c>Q�O'��PsYZcsa¦^kT@csa�TZU� � � � � t � � � �2� YZcsv � Q� ���2� Q\T�a¦^k]wPdo£^�U�� � p?.f{ 3 � YVcsv � p?.f{B} � S�z�[d^`a��@^fO'olvRa

� e i � e / X 8 X � � � ��7 � + ckX + 2 � � � X ! "' % '*) +�-10 X -�2 # 3 � ��Y5��7 # � p?.f{B¸]/ �� e i � e ! � Qe � � �M����� Qc � � �M������� Q� � � �M� ����� # # � ��� X�c � � � � 7 � � g � { �M# � p?.f{B¸]7 �� e i � e / V 8 V � � � � 7 � + c X + 2 � � � X ! "$ % '*) +�- X -10�2 # ��W5� 7 #���� g � { � . � p?.f{B¸]B �

{ 3

Page 11: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

zDT­cRTIi\]MY�o�^k�/O � e qd� � � e # � e � � {@t���O(cRTIQ�O9Q�[sYZQ � Xdce � e ^la,g � { � U�T@i � � ��7 � g ���_� t�qRpRQM^laO'�RPsTIcRO/cdQK^`Y�o�of�naK]�Y�o�o�O'o`aKO/��[RO/i\OIS�z�[RO/i\O'U�TIi\OItuYTIYZPdo`YI_'O/��QK�dPsO�O/eZY�ofpsYZQK^fTIc�TZU�Q\[d^`a�^fcRcRO/i6PRi\TRvdps_'Q4�I^fO'o`vRa

� � e # � e � i�� � �e�� + � + X�c7 8 +X + � � e � � � Q � > � # ��� � e i � � + � � + Xdc7 � � X�c�� � . � p�.f{�q �C�O/i\O � + ^`a�Q\[RO�aKpRijU�YI_'O�YVi\OBY�TZU�Q�[RO6pRcd^kQ4qsY�o�o�^kc * + YZcsv � ^`a�vdO � cROBv%^fc � }?. ¸ � S�� a¦^k]�^£o`YZi6YIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_O/e�Y�okpsYVQK^fTIc�PRi\TZeI^`vdOBv

� � e # { � i4� � e � + � + X�c7 � U�V � U]X � � g ��� c�� �o� . � p�. } 32�tD^fcsY�o�of�Itsa�^fcs_'O � e [sYIa�cRT+cRT�vRY�oso�^fcROBa�^fQ�^`a�_�okOBYViQ�[sYZQ � e ]�psaKQ�q¢O�Q\[RO � i�aKQ#O'^f¤IO/cdU�pRcs_'QK^fTIcS�z�[RO4PRiK^fcs_�^fPsY�oO'^f¤IO/cde�Y�ofpRO � e ���_� [sYIa�Q�[RO�OBaKQK^f]�YVQ\O � p�. ¸ � S�;� � ���u«����B�M�� �l�R���l®;� � � �s«d� �=� ��Z���l®`�3�I3O/Q � 7 � � �_� a\YZQK^`a�U�� � }?.f{ � �¡^kQ�[ � � ~ $Z�"$ e ~ tRYZcsv©okO/Q $ - YVcsv $ e - vdO/cRTIQ\O�Q�[RO � Q\[ _'T>T@i�v@^fcsYZQ\O�TZU $YZcsv $ e t¢i\OBaKP¢OB_'QK^feIO'of�IS�z¡[RO/ctuq>��v@^£¥O/i\O/cdQK^`YZQK^fcR¤ � }?.f{�/ � ��^fQ\[�i\OBajPsOB_'Q�Q�T $ - t¢��O�TIqRQ�Y�^kc�U�TIi � � { # . . # �Q\[sYZQ ����� � 0���� � 7 � � �_� �N� � Q � � 7 � � 0���� � 7 � � �_� � ��3 . � p�. }R{ �h��9_'TI]wPsYZiK^fcR¤ � p?. }F{ � YZcsv � p?.l{�/ � tR^fQ�^la6_�ofOBYZi+Q\[sYZQ4Q\[RO�O'^f¤IO/c>eZY�ofpRO�PRi�TIqdofO/] � p?.l{�/ � ^kc * + [sYIar� �/O/i\TO'^f¤IO/cde�Y�ofpROBaM��^fQ\[­O'^f¤IO/cdU�pRcs_'QK^fTIcsa � - � 0���� � 7 � � �_� U�TIi � � { # . . # ��S���c * + t�Q\[ROBajO��/O/i\T�O'^k¤@O/c>eZY�ofpROBaYZi\O�Yn_'T@csaKOB�IpRO/cs_'O TZU�Q\[RO(Q�i�YZcsa�o`YZQK^fTIc�^fcde�YZiK^`YZcs_'OIS tRTIiMQ\[RO � cd^fQ\O�vdTI]�Y�^fc1PRi\TIqdofO/](t�Q\[RO�qRpRqRqdokO2^laYIa\ajpR]�OBv�Q�T�qsO6aKQ\ij^l_'Qjok��^kcsa¦^lvdO ' tdYZcsvwQ\[>psa�^fQ#U�TZo�ofTZ��aXU�i\T@] � }?. } 3 / � Q\[sYZQ 0 ��� � 7 � � �h� U�Y�^�o`a�Q\T�a�YZQK^`a�U���Q\[ROqsT@pRcsvRYZi\�­_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIc � p?.f{�7 � q>��T@cdok� O'��P¢TIcRO/c>Qj^lY�o£o;� aK]�Y�o�o�Q\O/i\]�a�S(z�[RO/i\O'U�TIi\OItD^fQ+^la+csYZQ�pRi�Y�o�Q\T(O'�RPsOB_'QQ\[sYZQ�Q�[ROQ�i�YZcsa�o`YZQK^fTIcwO'^k¤@O/c>eZY�ofpROBa�YZcsv�O'^f¤IO/cdU�pRcs_'QK^fTIcsa�YIa�aKT�_�^`YZQ�OBv���^fQ\[�Q\[RO¡^kc � cd^fQ\O6vdTI]�Y�^kcMPRi\TIqdofO/]¨¤IO/QPsO/i�Q\pRi\qsOBv2TIcdof��eIO/i\��a�o�^k¤@[>QKof��qd��Q\[RO+PRi\OBaKO/cs_'O�TZU�Q\[RO � cd^fQ\O�vdTI]MY�^fcS4³IPsOB_�^ � _/Y�o�o`�It��O�aK[RTZ� Q\[sYZQ � p?.f{ �[sYIa`�¨O'��P¢TIcRO/c>Qj^lY�o£of��aj]�Y�o�o>O'^f¤IO/cde�Y�ofpROBa � - ��^fQ\[�_'TIi\i\OBajPsTIcsv@^fcR¤�O'^f¤IO/cdU�pRcs_'QK^fTIcsa � - i � - � 0���� � 7 � � - � tU�TIi � � { # . . # ��S;C�O/i�OIt � - ^`a#Y4cRTIi\]MY�o�^k�BYVQK^fTIc(_'TIcsaKQ�YVc>Q#YZcsv � - ^`a�Y4qsTIpRcsvRYVi\��o`Y��IO/i�U�pRcs_'QK^fTIcwokTR_/Y�o�^f�/OBvcROBYZi 0 ' t¢��[d^`_\[�Y�o�okTZ��a � p?.f{�7 � Q\TMqsO�a\YZQj^la � OBvuS�zDT�OBaKQK^f]�YZQ\O � - t¢��O�_/YZc�psaKO���i\O/O/c;K a�^`vdO/cdQK^fQK�9YZPRPdo�^fOBvQ\T � p?.f{�/ � YZcsv 0���� � 7�Q\T�vdO/iK^feIO

� - � 0���� � 7 #� - � �b�5��� 8 � 9 � - 0:1 � 0���� � 7 � >��u# � p�. }I} ���[RO/i\O >�� ^`a�Q�[RO�aKpRiKU�YI_'O�YZi\OBY�O'ofO/]�O/cdQ4TIc 0 ' S�³IpRqsaKQK^fQ\pRQj^kcR¤ � - i � - � 0 ��� � 7 � � - � YZcsv � }?. } 3 / � ^fcdQ\T� p?. }I} � ��O � csvut�U�TIi � � { # . . # ��tuQ\[sYVQ � - � g ��� � X�� %('*) � U�TIi�aKT@]�O� ­YZcsv � W 3 S���]�TIi\OMPRi\OB_�^`aKOOBaKQK^f]�YVQ\O6U�TIi � - ^la�¤Z^feIO/c�qsO'ofTZ��TIcs_'O+��O�[sY�eIO�vdO/Q\O/i\]�^kcROBv � - S

zDT9_/Y�ol_'pdo`YZQ�O � - ��O�aKO/Q � 7 iE� V ���h� YZcsv � � 3 ^fc � p�.f{�/ � S�z¡[RO/ct�cROBYVi 0 ' tD��O���iK^fQ\O � p?.l{ � ^fcQ\O/i\]Ma�TZU�Q\[RO6ofTR_/Y�o ���M#��2� _'TdTIi�v@^fcsYZQ\O�aK�RaKQ\O/] ^kcdQ\i\TRvdps_'OBv�^fc� pFSf{IS#zDT�ofOBYIv@^fcR¤�TIi�vdO/iBt � - a�YZQK^`a � OBa0 � � � - ��� 8 %V ����� - �435# � Y 3 � - v 35# YIa �ZvF� � #0 � � - �4���M���2�M# �Z��3 �����2� � � 021 � 0���� � 7L

� . e . � p�. }�p �h��(aKTZofe@^kcR¤ � p?. }�p � ��O�TIqRQ�Y�^kc � - YZcsv%Q\[dpsa

� - � � - ! 0 ��� � 7 � �H�������2� � 8 %V � � !#"$ 1 %('*) #,# � p�. }Z¹ �{I{

Page 12: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

��[RO/i\O ��� ^`a�Q�[RO�v@^`aKQ�YZcs_'O+U�i\TI] $ %&' Q\T 0 ' S��c�\¹6��O�i�OB�Ipd^fi\O6YZc�YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQj^l_U�TIi�]�pdo`YyU�TIi � - TIc 0 ' S�zT�vdO/iK^feIO6aKps_�[�Y4U�TIi\]�pdo`YRt@�O�psaKO � }?. } 3 / �

Q\T�T@qRQ�Y�^fc(TIc 0 ' Q\[sYZQ

0���� � 7 � 8 %V / V � X�c � Xdc � � � � 7 � + c X + 2 � � � X ! "$ % '*) +�- X -10�2 � ��$ - �"$ e - �;� g ���_� # � p?. }I·]/ �021 � 0���� � 7 �5�O� � 8 %V �L� / V � Xdc � X � � � � ��7 � + ckX + 2 � � � X ! "$ % '*) +�- X -1012 �L$ - �"$ e - � � �� � ��Z� g ���_� . � p?. }I·]7 �z�[RO/i\O'U�TIi\OItXq>�najpRqsaKQK^fQ\pRQK^fcR¤ � p�. }I· � YZcsv � }?. } 3 / � ^fc>Q�T � p?. }Z¹ � YVcsv�qd��i\O/Pdo`YI_�^fcR¤ 8 %V qd� 8 V ^fc�Q\[RO�PRi�O/�O'�RPsTIcRO/cdQK^`Y�o�U�YI_'Q\TIi�a�t>��O6TIqRQ'Y�^fc9Q�[RO4U�TZo�ofTZ��^fcR¤(YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQj^l_yU�T@i\]�pdolY�U�TIi � - T@c 0 ' U�TIi � � { # . . # �n°

� - i � - 8 V / V � X�c � X�c � � � � 7 � + ckX + 2 � � � X ! "$ % '*) +�- X -1012 ��$ - ��$ e - � �f{ � �� � �� # $�% 0 ' . � p�. }Ix ���c � p?. }@· � YZcsv � p�. }Ix � t � � ~ $Z�"$ e ~ t��� � ��$Z��$ e � � Xdc tRYZcsv �� ^la�Q\[RO6pRcd^fQ6TIpRQK��YZi�vMcRTIi�]�Y�oQ\T 0 ' S

zDT�OBaKQK^f]�YVQ\O � - YZcsv � - ��O�cRO/OBv2Q\T�O/eZY�ofpsYZQ\O � 0���� � 7 # 0���� � 7 �+U�TIi �rvF3 S tRi\TI] � }?. } 32� ^fQ4U�TZo�okTZ��aQ\[sYZQ�Q\[RO�vdTI]�^kcsYVc>Q�_'TIc>Q�iK^fqRpRQK^fTIc�Q\T�Q�[d^la�^fc>Q\O/¤@i�Y�o3YViK^`aKOBaXU�i\T@]�Q\[RO�i\O/¤Z^fTIcMcROBYZi � � ��7�S�z�[RO/i�O'U�TIi�OIt>psa¦^kcR¤� }?. } 3 7 � U�T@i � 7 tF�O�_/Y�ol_'pdo`YZQ�O�Q�[sYZQ

� 0���� � 7 # 0���� � 7 � ib�H� � � Xdc � + X�c7 � � + . � p�. }2l �C�O/i\O � ^`a�vdO � cROBv%^fc � }?. ¸ � YZcsv � + ^`a�Q\[RO�aKpRiKU�YI_'O�YZi�OBY�TZU�Q\[RO6pRcd^fQ�qsY�o�o�^fc * + S#z¡[RO/i\O'U�T@i\OItdU�TIi �av 3 tQ\[RO+cRTIi\]�Y�o�^f�BYZQK^fTIc�_'TIcsajQ�YZcdQ � - a�YZQK^`a � OBa

� - i � � � � � � + X�c7 � � + � � c � � . � p�. }I¸ �²�O'��QBtdqd�©ajpRqsaKQK^fQ\pRQK^fcR¤ � p?. }I·]7 � t � p?. }@x � t � p?. }2l � YVcsv � - i � - 0 ��� � 7 ^fcdQ\T � p?. }I} � tI��O4TIqRQ�Y�^fc�Q\[RO�U�TVo£ofTZ��^fcR¤YIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_4U�TIi\]�pdo`Y+U�T@i�Q\[RO�O'�RPsT@cRO/c>QK^`Y�o�of�naK]MY�o�o�O'^f¤IO/c>eZY�ofpROBa � - U�TIi�� � { # . . # ��°

� - i / �V 8 �V �� � + 8

�9 � ckX + � X ��!#"$&%('*),+�- X -10�2 { $ - �"$ e -

� � � �� � �� ��{ � �� � �� >?� . � p�. }�q ���c;��·�YZcsv ��x���O�psaKO&IYZPdo`YI_'O�K a�]�O/Q\[RTRv�Q\T9Y@aK�>]wPRQ\TIQK^`_/Y�o�of�­O/e�Y�ofpsYZQ�O�Q\[RO(aKpRiKU�YI_'Ow^kcdQ\O/¤Ii'Y�o�^kc � p?. }�q � SC�T���O/eIO/i�tZU�i\TI] � p?. }�q � t�^kQX^`a�^f]�]wOBv@^lYVQ\O'of�(_�okOBYViQ�[sYZQBt�U�TIiaKT@]�O t � - � g � � � X � ! "$ % '*) + -/. ��� X -10,2 � SNC�O/i�O� � � � ^`a�Q\[RO�i'YIv@^fpsa�TZU�Q\[RO*olYVi\¤IOBaKQ�qsY�o£o�^fc * + t¢_'O/c>Q\O/i�OBv9YVQ $ e tRQ�[sYZQ�_/YZc�qsO6^fcsa\_'ij^kq¢OBv���^fQ\[d^fc ' StD^fcsY�o�of�It�^fc �\¹stu��O�cRO/OBv�YMi\T@pR¤I[�YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQK^`_+OBaKQK^f]�YVQ\O�U�TIi6Q\[RO+^fcRcRO/i�PRi\TRvdps_'Q � � - # { �ZS�³Z^fcs_'OIt�q>�aK�d]�]�O/Q\i��ItRQ\[RO4^fc>Q�O/¤Ii�Y�o�TVU � - e�YZcd^`aK[ROBa�^`vdO/cdQK^`_/Y�o�ok��TIc�i'YIv@^`Y�o�ok��aK�d]�]�O/Q\iK^`_+vdTI]�Y�^fcsa4_'O/c>Q\O/i�OBv(YZQ $ e td^fQU�TZo�okTZ��a¡U�i\TI]�Q\[RO+O'��P¢TIcRO/cdQK^`Y�oXvdOB_/Y���TZU � - U�T@i �|W ��7�Q\[sYZQ

� � - # { � � g ��� � X ! "$ % '*) +�-�. ��� X -1012 � # U�TIi � � { # . . # �b. � p�.�p 32��;��� ���u«���� �u«R��� � �s«d� D���;�����u�l� � ���5v �s� �av 3tFTIi#a�^f]�Pdo�^`_�^fQ¦�w�O�_'TIcsa¦^lvdO/i�TIcdof��Q\[RO�QK��TI��v@^f]�O/csa�^fTIcsY�o_/YIaKO5� � }RSD��c � pFSf{YVcsv � pFS }���O�_/Y�o`_'pdo`YZQ\OBv� - YZcsv � - U�T@i � � 3�# { # }RS ��O+cRTZ� _/Y�o`_'pdo`YZQ\O�Q\[RO+TIQ\[RO/i4O'^f¤IO/cRPsY�^fi�a4U�TIi���[d^l_�[ � - v 3 YIa �5v 3 S�³Z^fcs_'OQ\[ROBaKO4TIQ\[RO/i�O'^f¤IO/cde�Y�ofpROBa6YZi�O�cRO/¤>YZQK^feIO�YVcsv�a�^fcs_'O+]�YIa\a�^la�_'TIcsaKO/i\eIOBvw��OyYVi\O�ofOBYIvMQ�T�Q\[RO6_'TIcs_�ofpsa�^fTIc(Q�[sYZQ

{B}

Page 13: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

Q\[RO+i�YIv@^`Y�o�of�9aK�d]�]�O/Q\ij^l_+qRpRqRqdofO�aKTVokpRQj^kT@c�^`a6aKQ�YZqdofO+��^fQ\[(i\OBajPsOB_'Q6Q\T�^fc � cd^fQ\OBaK]MY�o#PsO/i\Q�pRi\qsYZQK^fTIcsa4[sY�e@^kcR¤�/O/i\TM]�OBYZcS

��c(Q\[RO*^fc>Q\O/i�csY�o�o`Y��IO/i�i�O/¤Z^fTIctsQ�[ROBaKO�O'^f¤IO/cdU�pRcs_'QK^fTIcsa4U�TIi � � } # p�. .d[sYBe@O6Q\[RO6U�TZo�ofT��¡^kcR¤MU�TIi\]� � � X�c � � � � � X�c � � � � 7 � � B_'T>a � ���]�n# � � � � � � � � X�c � � � � 7 � � Ba�^fc � ���]� . � p�.�pR{ �C�O/i\O � � #���� ^`a�YMP¢TZo`YZi�_'TdTIi�v@^fcsYZQ\O�aK�RaKQ\O/]!_'O/cdQ\O/i\OBv�YZQ $ e S�z�[RO�_'T@i\i\OBaKP¢TIcsv@^fcR¤�O'^f¤IO/c>eZY�ofpROBa � � � X�c �L�_�YZcsv � � � ���_� _/YZc�OBYI_�[�qsO�O'��PsYVcsvdOBv�^fc�PsTZ��O/i�a4TZU � S6z�[RO�_'TdO��©_�^fO/c>Q'a4^fc�Q\[ROBaKO�O'�RPsYZcsa�^fTIcsa/tD��[d^`_\[�YZi\OvdO/Q\O/i\]�^kcROBvwU�i\TI]�Q�[RO#^fcdQ\O/i\csY�o¢o`YB�@O/i#i\O/¤Z^fTIctdYZi\O�U�TIpRcsv�Q\T�YZ¤@i\O/O�Q\T�Y�o�ogTIi'vdO/i�aD^fc � S�z�[RO/i�O'U�TIi�OItIQ\T6��^fQ\[d^fc

Y�o�o#Y�of¤IO/qRi�Y�^`_+Q\O/i\]�a^kc � tF�O+[sY�eIO � � � X�c ���h� i����� ���_� YZcsv � � � ���h� i����� ���_� S tFTIi�YZc(YZi�qd^kQ�i�YZi\�(vdTI]MY�^fcQ\[sYZQ�^`aXcRTIQ_'TIcs_'O/cdQ\iK^`_���^fQ\[�� � � 7�tI��O�O'�RPsOB_'Q�Q\[sYZQ�Q\[RO�¤>YZP���^`vdQ\[ � � � ���_�:� � � � X�c ���_� ^`a�O'��P¢TIcRO/c>Qj^lY�o£of�aK]�Y�o£o�YIa � v 3 S C�TZ��O/eIO/iBtR��O�vdT�cRTIQ�OBaKQK^f]�YZQ\O+Q\[RO�¤dYZP���^`vdQ\[�[RO/i\OIS³IpRqsajQK^fQ\pRQK^fcR¤ �@��� �� YVcsv � p�.�pR{ � ^fc>Q\T � p?.f{�/ � t���O�TIqRQ�Y�^kcwTIc � � Y��uY�� tdQ\[sYVQ � � � �� �_� a\YZQK^`a � OBa� Q Q� � �

��7 ��� � � Q� � � � � �� � 7 � � � � � � � �"� Q � � 7 � � � ��� �� � � # � � �%� � �a��3 . � p�.�pI} �C�O/i\O � ��� X�c � � � � 7 � S#²�O'��QBtF�O+O'��PsYVcsv � �� ���_� YVcsv � � � �� �_� YIa

� � � �� �_�Ni +,-�. e � � - � � ��� - # � �� ���_�Ni +,-%. e � �� - � - . � p�.�p�p �³IpRqsaKQK^fQ\pRQj^kcR¤ � p?. } � YVcsv � p�.�p�p � ^fcdQ\T � p�.�pI} � t�YZcsv�_'TZo�ofOB_'QK^fcR¤�PsTZ��O/i�a6TZU � t���O�TIqRQ'Y�^fcnQ\[sYVQ � � - � � � t¢U�TIi� 3 t�a\YZQK^`a � OBa�Ynaj��aKQ�O/] a�^f]�^�olYVi9Q�T � p�. ¹ � S z�[RO�aK��ajQ\O/]-U�T@i � � - U�TIi � � 3?# { # }%^`a�TIqRQ'Y�^fcROBv1q>�aKO/Q\Qj^kcR¤,� � }�^fc � p?. ¹ � tdi\O/Pdo`YI_�^fcR¤� e - YVcsv � e - ^fc � p?. ¹ � qd� � � - YZcsv � �� - tsYZcsv�YIvRv@^fcR¤�Q\[RO+cRO/��Q�O/i\]� � � X �7 � � e Q\T�Q\[RO6ij^k¤@[>Q�a¦^lvdO+TZU � p?. ¹:B � S�z�[RO/i\O'U�TIi\OItFq>��i\O/P¢OBYZQK^fcR¤MQ\[RO�_/Y�o`_'pdo`YZQK^fTIcsa4^fc � p�. · �;�-� p?. ¸ � tI��Oi\OBYIv@^�of�(T@qRQ�Y�^fc�U�TIi �)� } # p # . .IQ�[sYZQ

� � � �� �_�Ni � � ! � Qe � � �M����� Qc � � �M������� Q� � � �M� g �L� � � #,# � p?.�pZ¹2/ �� � � ���_� i�� � � Xdc ���_� i�� �� �L�_� ��� � � { � � � �

� �7 � g ��� ��� . � p?.�pZ¹27 �z�[RO�O'^f¤IO/cdU�pRcs_'QK^fTIcsa�YVi\O�Q\[RO/c�¤V^ke@O/c�q>��_'TI]�qd^fcd^kcR¤ � p?.�pZ¹2/ � YZcsv � p�.�pR{ � S+z�[RO�cRTIi\]MY�o�^k�BYVQK^fTIc _'T@csaKQ�YZcdQ� � ts_\[RTdaKO/c9aKTwQ\[sYZQ � � � � #� � � � � {It@^`a�¤Z^feIO/c�YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQj^l_/Y�o£of��qd�

� � i ��� � � 7 � � X�c � � . � p�.�pI· ���c�Y6a�^f]�^�o`YZi���YB��Y@a��¡Y@a�vdTIcRO�^kc � pRSf{@tZ�O�_/YZc�_/Y�o`_'pdo`YZQ\O4Q\[RO�qsO/[sY�e@^fTIi�TZUgQ\[RO�O'^f¤IO/cdU�pRcs_'QK^fTIcsa � � � X�cYZcsv � � � ^kc�Q\[RO�QK��T�TIpRQ\O/i+i\O/¤Z^fTIcsa*^fcsa�^`vdO(YZcsv�TIpRQ'a�^`vdO�Q\[ROMqRpRqRqdofOIS�³Z^fcs_'O�Q\[RO�i\OBajpdokQ'a6U�i\TI]!ajps_\[­YZc

YZcsY�of�Ra�^`a6YZi\O6cRTIQ�cRO/OBvdOBv�o`YZQ\O/i���O�vdTwcRTIQ�_/YZi\i���TIpRQ�Q\[RO�vdO/Q�Y�^�o`a�[RO/i\OIS���c �\¹���O6TIcdof��cRO/OBv(YZc�TIi�vdO/i�TZU]�YZ¤@cd^kQ�psvdO�OBaKQj^k]MYZQ\O�U�TIi#Q�[RO�^fcRcRO/iPRi�T�vdps_'Q�a � � � � # { ��YZcsv � � � � X�c # { �ZS�z�[d^`a�OBaKQK^f]�YZQ�O�_/YZc�q¢O�TIqRQ�Y�^fcROBvU�i\TI]�Q\[RO+TIqsaKO/i\eZYZQK^fTIcsa4Q\[sYVQ�Q\[ROBaKO*^kcRcRO/i6PRi�T�vdps_'Q�a�e�YVcd^laj[�^`vdO/c>QK^`_/Y�o�of��TIc(i'YIv@^`Y�o�ok��aK�d]�]�O/Q\iK^`_�vdTI]�Y�^kcsa_'O/cdQ\O/i\OBv�YZQ $ e tYVcsv(Q�[RO�O'^f¤IO/cdU�pRcs_'QK^fTIcsa�YZi\O�O'�RPsTIcRO/cdQK^`Y�o�of� aj]�Y�o�o�^fc9Q�[RO�T@pRQ\O/i6i\O/¤Z^fTIcsa4��[RO/i�O �@W � 7�Sz�[RO/i\O'U�TIi\OItXQ\[RO�OBaKQK^f]�YZQ�O � p?.�p 3 � Y�o`aKT�[RTZo`vRa+U�TIi�Q\[ROBaKOM^fcRcRO/i�PRi\TRvdps_'Q�a/S ³Ips_\[ YVc­OBaKQK^f]�YZQ\O�Y�o`aKT�[RTVolvRa

{�p

Page 14: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

U�TIi�YZcd�9O'^f¤IO/cdU�pRcs_'QK^fTIc � - TZU � p?.f{ � ^kc * + tD��^fQ\["� }FtQ\[sYZQ4^`a+cRTIQ6i�Y@v@^lY�o£of�­aK�d]�]�O/Q\iK^`_wqRpRQ�Q\[sYVQ4^laofT�_/Y�o£^f�/OBv�cROBYVi � � � 7YZcsv©^la�O'�RPsTIcRO/cdQK^`Y�o�of�2aj]�Y�o�o�U�TIi � W5� 7�S�;��� &�®��D�s�\�`��®;�­®��6���/¬ ��D�/®s���;���M�¯ �w���9«R�\�`�V���� �«R�\� �l�B�tFTIi�OBYI_�[�TZUuQ\[RO�Q¦��T�U�T@i\]�a�TZU ������� ¤Z^feIO/c�^fc � }?. }R{ � �O�psaKO*m I�³��+³ � � ¹� � Q\T6c>pR]wO/iK^`_/Y�o�ok��_'TI]�PRpRQ�OQ\[RO�PRij^kcs_�^fPsY�o�O'^f¤IO/cde�Y�ofpRO � e YIa6YwU�pRcs_'QK^fTIcnTVU � S �1[RO/c � � ��� YZcsv� 7 � {It¢^fc"tD^f¤sS�·M��O�_'TI]�PsYVi\OItU�TIi � � }�YZcsvw� � pRtRQ\[RO+c>pR]wO/iK^`_/Y�o�ok��_'TI]�PRpRQ\OBv � e ��^fQ\[�Q\[RO�YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQj^l_*i\OBaKpdofQ � p?. ¸ � S#z�[d^`a � ¤IpRi�OaK[RTZ��a+Q\[RO(_�ofT>aKO�YZ¤Ii\O/O/]wO/c>Q�q¢O/QK�O/O/c­Q�[RO(YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQK^`_�YZcsv�c>pR]wO/iK^`_/Y�o�i\OBaKpdofQ�a�U�TIi � e TZeIO/i�Q\[RO�i'YZcR¤IO3 Y � Y . } 3 S"tFTIi�Q\[RO(_/YIaKO � � � � t ��7 � {�YZcsv�B e � {�. }%^fc � }?. }R{�7 � tD^kc1z�YVqdokO�}IY���O(aK[RTZ��Q\[ROU�YBe@TIi�YZqdofO6YZ¤Ii\O/O/]�O/cdQ�qsO/QK��O/O/c�Q\[RO6YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQK^`_6YZcsvwcdpR]�O/iK^`_/Y�o�eZY�ofpROBa�U�TIi � e TZeIO/i�Q\[ROya�YZ]�O4i�YZcR¤IO�^fc � StFTIiMQ\[RO�U�TIi�] � � � � ��^fQ\[ � 7 � {�YZcsv4� � }Rt�^fc z�YVqdokO�}Zq ��O�_'TI]�PsYZi�O9Q�[RO9YIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_U�TIi\]�pdo`Y � p?.�pZ¹27 � U�TIi � � YVcsv � � ��^fQ\[�_'TIi\i�OBaKPsTIcsv@^fcR¤ U�pdo�o�cdpR]�O/iK^`_/Y�o�i�OBaKpdofQ�a�_'TI]�PRpRQ\OBv¶U�i\T@] � p�.�pI} �psa�^fcR¤�m I�³��+³sSgz�[RO�YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQj^l_4i�OBaKpdofQ�a�U�TIi�Q\[ROBaKO+[d^f¤I[RO/i�O'^f¤IO/cde�Y�okpROBa+YZi\O6YZ¤>Y�^fc%U�TIpRcsvMQ�T�q¢O6^fc9_�ofT>ajOYZ¤Ii�O/O/]�O/c>Q4��^fQ\[�Q\[RO6c>pR]wO/iK^`_/Y�o#i\OBaKpdofQ�a/S� � ���u«2���u���l¬����;�M®��6� �l® � �Z�3~�~��f«��M¬��g�����`�@���3��� ���n� �u« �+�B®��/«R�Z���l®;�¶� «d� �u®3¯

� O�cRTZ� _'TIcsa�^`vdO/i�Q\[RO�QK^f]�O/��vdO/P¢O/csvdOBcdQ�PRi\TIqdofO/] � {�.f{ � U�TIi � � �M��$#�<�� YVcsv !-� !`�H<=� tu��[RO/i\OMQ\[RO]�YIa�a A ^fc � {�.l{�B � ^laM_'TIcsaKQ'YZc>Q�S ��O9Y@a\aKpR]�O�Q\[sYVQ�Q\[RO�^fcd^fQK^`Y�o�vRYZQ'Y�U�T@i � {�.f{ � ^`aMY�_/YZcRTIcd^`_/Y�o�qRpRqRqdofOaKTZofpRQK^fTIc ����$;#_32�|� � 7_� ~ $T�-$ ee ~ � #�¡^kQ�[ !4�E! 7 ���_� S���ofQ\O/i�csYZQK^feIO'of�It���O�_/YZc­e@^kO/� Q\[d^`a+^fcd^fQK^`Y�o�vRYZQ�Y�YIai\O/PRi\OBajO/c>QK^fcR¤�Q�[RO�O/csv�i�OBaKpdofQ�TZU¡Y�_'T>YZi�ajO/cd^kcR¤ PRi\T�_'OBa�a�Q�[sYZQ�[sYIa*Q�YZ±IO/c PdolY@_'O�qsO/QK��O/O/cn]�YVc>��qRpRqRqdofOBa/Sz�[RO6qRpRqRqdofO�^`a�YIa�aKpR]�OBv�Q�T�o�^fO�O/c>Qj^ki�O'ok����^fQ\[d^fc ' YZcsvutsYIa�aK[RTZ��cM^fc(�4PRPsO/csv@^�����td^fQ�a¡i�YIv@^fpsa � 7_/YZc�q¢O_/Y�o`_'pdo`YZQ\OBv�U�TIi � v 3 ^fc(Q�O/i\]�a�TZU�Q�[RO6]�YIa\a A Y@a

��7 � � e 7 � � � c 7 � g ��� � �n# ��[RO/i\O � e 7 � { �� + � { P U V ��AU V � U X � � c � + . � ¹�.f{ �

C�O/i\O P ^`a�Q�[RO�eITZofpR]�O+TZU ' YZcsv%Q\[RO�_'T@i\i\OB_'QK^fTIc�Q\O/i\] � c 7 ^`a�¤Z^feIO/c(O'�RPdo�^`_�^kQjok�2^kc � � . ·�/ � S� O�cRTZ� ofTdTI±�U�TIi6Y�aKTVokpRQj^kT@c�Q\T � {�.f{ � ��[RO/i\O�Q\[RO+qRpRqRqdofO�^`a4Q\i�YVcsa�o`YZQ\OBv���^fQ\[RT@pRQ�_\[sYZcR¤@O�TVUaK[sYZPsOIS

z�[ROMPRi\TI§KOB_'QK^fTIc­]�O/Q�[RT�v2^`a�psajOBv�Q\T9vdO/Q\O/i�]�^fcRO(Q\[ROMQ\i�YV§¦OB_'Q\T@i\� $ e � $ e �H<�� t���^fQ\[ $ e ��32� � $ ee t�TVU�Q\[RO_'O/cdQ\O/i�TZU�Q\[ROMqRpRqRqdofOISnz�[RO�YZcsY�of�Ra�^`a�qsO'ofTZ� ^`a+e�Y�o�^`v­pRP­pRcdQK^�o�Q\[RO�OBvd¤@O�TZU�Q\[RO�qRpRqRqdofO%^lawYZQ�YZc�g �L�_�v@^`aKQ�YZcs_'O+U�i\TI] 0 ' S�Q\TIps_�[ROBa 0 ' S

zDT6psaKO�Q�[ROPRi�TI§KOB_'QK^fTIc�]�O/Q\[RTRv���O � i'aKQ#aKO/Q �M�L$ <=�N� � 7 � ~ $Z��$ e ~ � ���z��$;#=<�� YZcsv !`�H<=� ��! 7 ��`�H<�� t��[RO/i\O $ e � $ e �H<=� S��ya\ajpR]�^fcR¤�Q\[sYZQ � D � 7�YZcsv ��D ! 7�pRcd^£U�TIi\]�ok�%^fc9Qj^k]wOIts��O�T@qRQ�Y�^fc(Q\[RO*U�TVo£ofTZ��^fcR¤o�^fcROBYZiK^f�/OBv�PRi�TIqdofO/]�U�i\TI] � {�.f{ � °

� % � � ������j�"� Q � � 7 ��� � 0 � � 7 ���@��� � # $&%�'b# � ¹�. }]/ �021 � �b� 021 � 7 # $�% 0 ' # � ¹�. }]7 �8 9��>:$ ��3 �r�L$;# 3 �N��3 . � ¹�. }�B �

��O6Q\[RO/c�O'��PsYVcsv � � � +-�. e B - �S<�� � - tR��[RO/i\O � - U�TIi �9 3 YZi\O+Q\[RO6cRTIi\]MY�o�^k�/OBv�O'^f¤IO/cdU�pRcs_'QK^fTIcga*TZU � p�.f{ � S³Z^fcs_'O � � ~ $|�w$ e �H<�� ~ ^fc � p?.l{�/ � tIQ\[ROBaKO6O'^f¤IO/cdU�pRcs_'QK^fTIcua4cRT�� vdO/P¢O/csv(PsYVi�YZ]�O/Q\ij^l_/Y�o£of��TIc�Qj^k]wOIS���PRPdof�@^fcR¤��i�O/O/c;K a�^`vdO/cdQK^fQK��Q\T � p?.l{ � YZcsv � ¹d. }�/ # 7 � ��O�vdO/iK^feIO

� �5�=#� - � � ��� # � % � - � �O�5��� 8 � 9 � - 021 � 7 >?�&� � 0 � � 7 # � - � ����� { # � - � # � ¹�.�p �{/¹

Page 15: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

��[RO/i\O � �# x � � f 9 � x >2$ S#²�TZ��a�^fcs_'OTB - �H<=�N� � � - # � � YZcsv � � - #� - � � {ItF�O�_/Y�ol_'pdo`YZQ�O�Q�[sYZQ

B Q- ��� � - # �5� � � ���|# � - � � � +,��. e B � � � � # � - � � � +,

��. e���. - B � � � � # � - � � . � ¹�. ¹ �

²�O'��QBt¢aKpRqsaKQK^fQ\pRQK^fcR¤ � % � - ��� - � - YZcsv � ¹�. ¹ � ^fc>Q�T � ¹�.�p � td�O � csv�Q\[sYVQ B - �S<�� U�TIi � ��3?# { # . .lt>a\YZQj^la � OBaB Q- ��� - B - � +,

��. e���.�- B � � � � # � - � � ��� - B - ��32�N�43 . � ¹�. ·]/ �

C�O/i\O � - ^`a�vdO � cROBv�qd�� - �b� � 0 � � 7 #� - � � ��� { #� - � �� - . � ¹�. ·]7 �

��c � ¹�. ·]/ � t � - ^la4YZc�O'^f¤IO/cde�Y�ofpROMTZU � p?.f{ � YZcsvM��O+[sYBe@O�vdO � cROBv(Q�[RO�qsT@pRcsvRYZi\��Q\O/i\] - q>� - �6��� 8 � 9 � - 0:1 � 7 >�� . � ¹�. x �

b4a�^fcR¤ � }�. } 3 / � Q\T�_/Y�o`_'pdo`YZQ\O 021 � 7'tR��O � csv - i4� / V 8 %V 8

�9� - � � � ��7 � + ckX + 2 � � � X ! "$ % '*) +�- X -1012 �� � ��r>�� . � ¹�.ml �

��c�YIvRv@^fQK^fTIctuQ\T�a�YZQK^`a�U���Q\[RO+]�YIa\a�_'TIcsaKQ\i�Y�^kcdQ�^kc � ¹�. }]B � ��O6i\OB�@pd^fi\O�Q\[sYZQ+,-%. e B - � � - # { � ��3 . � ¹�. ¸ �

b4a�^fcR¤�Q\[RO6YIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_�OBaKQj^k]MYZQ\OBaXU�T@i � - YZcsv � - T@qRQ�Y�^fcROBvw^fc� pRt@��O�cRTZ�¶vdO/ij^ke@O|� � {6_'TIcsa�^`aKQ�O/cs_'�_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIcsa�Q�[sYZQ(vdO/Q\O/i\]�^fcRO­Q\[RO2U�pRcs_'QK^fTIc �)� � �S<�� YVcsv YZc O/eITVokpRQj^kT@c�OB�IpsYZQj^kT@c U�TIi�Q\[RO"����eIOB_'Q�TIi$ e �H<�� S�z�[ROBaKO�_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIcsawYZi\O�Q\[sYVQ � ¹�. ¸ � ^`a+YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQK^`_/Y�o�of�­a\YZQK^`a � OBv�YZcsv�Q\[sYVQ6OBYI_\[-B - �H<=� ^fc � ¹�. ·�/ � ^laO'�RPsTIcRO/cdQK^`Y�o�of� aK]�Y�o�o#TZeIO/i6Q\[RO�O'�RPsT@cRO/c>QK^`Y�o�of��ofTIcR¤(Qj^k]wO�^fc>Q\O/i�e�Y�o�^kcsvdps_'OBv�qd�(Q�[RO�O'��P¢TIcRO/cdQK^`Y�o�ok� aj]�Y�o�oO'^f¤IO/cde�Y�ofpROBa � - U�TIi � � { # . . # �nSuz�[ROBaKO4QK��T�_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIcsa�YVi\O�aKp��©_�^fO/cdQ�Q\T�O/csaKpRi�O�Q\[sYVQ �4D � 7�pRcd^�U�TIi�]�of�^fc�QK^f]�OIS���QX^`a�OBYIaK��Q�T�aK[RTZ��U�i\TI] � p�.f{ � Q\[sYVQ � � � #� - � � �b� � � - #� � � �YVcsv�Q\[sYZQ � � � # � - � ��^`aXO'��P¢TIcRO/c>Qj^lY�o£of�aK]�Y�o£o�S#z¡[>psa/tdQ\[RO¡olY@aKQ#Q\O/i�] TIc�Q�[RO�ofO'U�Q�a�^`vdO4TZU � ¹d. ·�/ � _'TIi\i\OBaKP¢TIcsvRa�Q\T�Y6aj±IO/����aK�d]�]�O/Q\ij^l_4]MYZQ\iK^��S#³Z^fcs_'OaKps_�[nYM]�YZQ�iK^��2vdTdOBa6cRTIQ4ofOBYIv�Q�T�O'�RPsTIcRO/cdQK^`Y�o�¤Ii\TZ��Q�[(TZU5B - �H<=� ^fc � ¹�. ·]/ � t¢Q\[d^`a6Q�O/i\] ^`a4^fcsa�^f¤Icd^ � _/YZcdQ�^fcQ\[RO�vdO/iK^fe�YZQK^fTIc�TZU�Q\[RO�_'TIcsa�^`aKQ\O/cs_'��_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIcsa4qsO'ofTZ��S

�1[RO/c�Q\[ROMqRpRqRqdokOM^`a�aKQ\ij^l_'Qjok�2^kcsa¦^lvdO ' t���O�i\OB_/Y�o£o�U�i�TI] � p%Q\[sYZQ � e W 3 ��^fQ\[ � e � g ��� � � tQ�[sYZQ� c tfSfSft � + YZi\O6O'�RPsT@cRO/c>QK^`Y�o�o`��aK]MY�o�oXYZcsv�Q\[sYVQ � - Y 3 ��^fQ\[ � - � g ��� � � U�TIi � 4� � {IS�z�[dpsa/tR^fc � ¹�. ·�/ � tQ\[RO+TIcdof��Q\O/i\]�a�Q\[sYZQ�_/YVc�ofOBYIv�Q�T�¤Ii\TZ��Q\[M^fcwB - �H<=� YVi\O6Q\[RT>aKO�_'TIi\i\OBajPsTIcsv@^fcR¤�� ��3?# { # . .���S��c�YIvRv@^fQK^fTIctqd� _'TI]wPsYZiK^fcR¤ � p?. } 32� ��^fQ\[ � p�.�p 32� ^fQ�U�TZo�ofTZ��a�Q�[sYZQ � � - # { �wU�TIi � !{M^`awO'��P¢TIcRO/c>Qj^lY�o£o;� aj]�Y�o�ofO/i�Q\[sYZc� � e # { �ZS6z�[RO/i\O'U�TIi\OItDQ\T�YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQK^`_/Y�o�of�na\YVQK^`a�U���Q\[RO�_'TIcsaKQ\i'Y�^fc>Q � ¹d. ¸ � �O+i\OB�@pd^ki�O�Q\[sYZQ|B e �H<=�5� 3 U�TIi�Y�o�oQK^f]�OIS�z�[dpsa/tRQ\T�O'o�^f]�^fcsYZQ\OwO'��P¢TIcRO/c>Qj^lY�o#¤Ii\TZ��Q\[MU�TIi B e �H<=� TIc�Q\[RO6QK^f]�O6^fcdQ\O/i\eZY�o <a� g � � X�ce � tF�O6i�OB�Ipd^fi\OQ\[sYZQ6Q�[RO�ij^k¤@[>Q�a�^`vdO�TZU � ¹�. ·�/ � e�YZcd^`aK[���[RO/c � � 3 S�²�O'�RQBt��O�TIqsaKO/i\e@O�U�i�TI] � p?. }@x � t � p?. }I¸ � � p�. }�q � YVcsv� ¹�. l � Q\[sYZQBtRY�ofQ\[RT@pR¤I[ - ^la�O'�RPsTIcRO/cdQK^`Y�o�of�9aK]MY�o�o�t�^kQ�[sYIa�Q\[RO6a\YZ]wO�O'��P¢TIcRO/cdQK^`Y�o�OBaKQK^f]�YVQ\O�YIa�Q�[sYZQ�U�TIi�Q\[RO

{B·

Page 16: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

O'�RPsTIcRO/cdQK^`Y�o�of�naK]�Y�o�o�O'^f¤IO/cde�Y�okpROBa�S�z�[RO/i\O'U�TIi\OIt¢pRcdofOBa\a4Q\[RO6iK^f¤I[dQ6a�^`vdO�TZU � ¹�. ·]/ � e�YVcd^laj[ROBa4U�TIi � � { # . . # ��t��O���TIpdo`v�TIqRQ�Y�^fc�YZcwg � { � i\OBaKPsT@csaKO�U�TIi B - �H<�� TZeIO/i�Q�[RO�O'�RPsTIcRO/cdQK^`Y�o�o`��ofTIcR¤MQK^f]�O+^fc>Q\O/i�e�Y�o`a4^fcsvdps_'OBv q>�� c # . . # � + S�z�[d^`a���TIpdo`v�Q\[RO/c(e@^fTZo`YZQ\O�Q\[RO�YIa\aKpR]�PRQj^kT@c9Q�[sYZQ � D � 7 S�z¡[RO/i\O'U�T@i\OIts��O+]�psajQ�i\OB�@pd^ki�O�Q�[sYZQQ\[RO�iK^f¤I[dQ�a�^`vdO�TZU � ¹d. ·�/ � eZYZcd^`aK[�U�TIi � � { # . . # �nS���c�aKpR]�]�YZi��ItuQ\[ROT� � {�_'TIcsa¦^lajQ\O/cs_'��_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIcsa�YZi\OQ\[sYZQ

� 0 � � 7 # � - � �b� ��� { # � - � � - # � ��3?# . . # � . � ¹�.�q �tD^fcsY�o�of�ItucRTIQK^`_'O6Q\[sYZQ���[RO/c �9 �� � {ItdQ\[RO6iK^f¤I[dQ�a�^`vdO6TZU � ¹d. ·�/ � ^`a�O'�RPsT@cRO/c>QK^`Y�o�of�9aj]�Y�o�o�YZcsv � - � g ��� � ���^fQ\[ � - Y 3 S4³Z^fcs_'OuB - �S<�� U�TIi � 4� � {*^`a�vdOB_'i\OBY@a�^fcR¤�^fc�QK^f]�OItuQ\[RO�_'T@csv@^kQj^kT@csa � ¹�. q � YZi\O�aKp��©_�^fO/cdQ6Q\TO/csaKpRi\O+Q\[sYZQ � ^`a�O'�RPsT@cRO/c>QK^`Y�o�o`��aK]MY�o�o�pRcd^�U�TIi�]�of�(^fc�QK^f]�OIS

z¡[RO/i\O9YZi�O�Q\[Ri\O/O�]�Y�^fc­TIqsajO/i\e�YZQj^kT@csa/t���[d^`_\[ U�TVo£ofTZ��a�U�i�TI] Q\[RO�i\OBaKpdofQ�a�^fc � pRt�Q�[sYZQ�O/csYZqdofO(psa�Q\TYIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_/Y�o�ok� vdOB_'TIpRPdofO � ¹�.�q � ^fcdQ\T­QK��TnaKO/PsYZi�YVQ\O9aKpRqR��aj��aKQ�O/]�a/°�T@cRO�U�TIi � � 3 YVcsv Q�[RO(TIQ\[RO/iwU�TIi� � { # . . # ��S;tD^fi�aKQKof�It@U�i\TI] � p?.l{\l � t � p�.f{�q � t � p?. }Ix � YZcsv � p?. }I¸ � tZ�O�TIqsaKO/i\eIO�Q\[sYZQ - ^fc � ¹d.ml � [sYIa�Q\[RO��/=���?YIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_�TIi�vdO/i�YIa ��v 3 U�TIi6OBYI_�[ � � 3?# . . # ��S�³IOB_'TIcsv@of�It�^fQ*U�TZo�ofTZ��a4U�i\TI] � p?. } 32� YVcsv � p?.�p 32� Q�[sYZQ� � e # { �y^la�O'�RPsTIcRO/cdQK^`Y�o�o`� A�=IH��I?�H�Q\[sYZc � � - # { �*U�T@i � � { # . . # ��S#z�[d^fi�v@of�It3^£U#��O�_\[RTdT>aKO�Q\[RO+QK^f]�O�a\_/Y�ofO�aKTQ\[sYZQ � 0 � � 7 #� - �*U�TIi�� � { # . . # � [sYIa�Q�[RO�a\YZ]wO�YIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_�T@i�vdO/iyY@a - U�T@i � � { # . . # ��tIQ\[RO/c�a�^fcs_'O � e^`a�i�YIv@^`Y�o�of�(aK�d]�]�O/Q\ij^l_ � O'�s_'O/PRQ�^fc(YRg ���_� i�O/¤Z^fTIc�cROBYZi 0 ',� t@^fQ�U�TZo�ofT��4a�Q\[sYZQ � 0 � � 7 # � e � ^la¡O'��P¢TIcRO/c>Qj^lY�o£of�����=@A`A�?BH4Q\[sYVc e S�z�[ROBaKOMQ\[Ri\O/OwTIqsaKO/i\eZYZQK^fTIcsa�aK[RTZ�¨Q\[sYZQ���O�_/YVcncRO/¤ZofOB_'Q�Q\[ROwofO'U�Q�a�^`vdOMTZU � ¹�.�q � ��[RO/c� �O3 YZcsv���O�_/YZc�cRO/¤VokOB_'Q�Q\[RO�Q\O/i�] � { #� - �+U�TIi�� � { # . . # ��S6z�[RO/i\O'U�TIi\OItDpsa�^fcR¤ � ¹�.ml � ts��O�TIqRQ�Y�^fc�Q\[ROU�TZo�okTZ��^fcR¤(YIaj�>]�PRQ�TIQK^`_/Y�o�of�9vdOB_'TIpRPdofOBv�PRi\T@qdokO/] U�TIi $ e �H<�� YZcsv �`�H<=� °

� � { # � e � ib�5� / V 8 %V 8�9� e � � � � 7 � + ckX + 2 � � � X ! "$&% '*) +�- X -1012 �� � ��r>��u# � ¹�.f{ 3 / �

� 0 � � 7 #� - � ib�5� / V 8 %V 8�9� - � � � � 7 � + ckX + 2 � � � X ! "$&% '*) + - X -10,2 �� � ��r>��u# � � { # . . # � . � ¹�.f{ 3 7 �

²�O'�RQBt���O�O/eZY�ofpsYZQ\O�Q\[ROMe�YViK^fTIpsa�Q\O/i\]Ma6^fc � ¹d.f{ 32� S�zDT�O/e�Y�ofpsYZQ\O � - TIc 0 ' t���O�psaKOMQ\[ROMOBaKQK^f]�YZQ�O� p?.l{\l � U�T@i � � 3 YZcsv�Q\[RO+OBaKQK^f]�YZQ�O � p?. }Ix � U�TIi � � { # . . # ��S�z¡[RO6^fcRcRO/i6PRi\TRvdps_'Q � � e # { �y^`a�OBaKQj^k]MYZQ\OBv%^fc� p?. } 32� S tD^kcsY�o£of�It�Q\T�_/Y�o`_'pdo`YZQ\O � 0 � � 7 #� - �*U�TIi�� � { # . . # ����O�cRTIQ\O�Q\[sYZQ4Q\[RO�vdTI]�^fcsYZcdQ�_'TIcdQ\iK^fqRpRQK^fTIc Q\TQ\[d^`a�^fc>Q�O/¤Ii�Y�oYZij^lajOBa�U�i\T@]�Q\[RO�i\O/¤Z^fTIc�cROBYZi � � ��7�S+³IpRqsaKQj^kQ�pRQK^fcR¤ 0 � � 7 � � � Q7 �� � �$ e YZcsv � - i � - 0���� � 7^fc>Q�T�Q\[d^`a¡^fcRcRO/i�PRi\TRvdps_'QBt¢��O�TIqRQ�Y�^kct�U�TIi�� � { # . . # ��tZQ\[sYZQ

� 0 � � 7 # � - � i � � - �$ e - 8 ��� � Q7 � � X �\�L$ - �"$ e - ���>:$ �b� � -� �$ e - 8 ��

� � Q7 � � �_� � � + X�c > � > � + . � ¹d.f{I{ �C�O/i\O5�$ e -�� >:$ e - � >]< S#z¡[RO/ctspsa�^fcR¤ � }?. } 3 7 � t � ¹�.f{I{ � q¢OB_'TI]�OBa� 0 � � 7 #� - � i � � - �$ e - ��� � � X�c � + � + X�c7 � # � � { # . . # � . � ¹d.f{B} �

h���aKpRqsaKQK^fQ\pRQK^fcR¤ � p?.f{\l � t � p?. }Ix � t � p?. } 32� YVcsv � ¹�.f{�} � ^fc>Q\T � ¹�.f{ 32� ��O�T@qRQ�Y�^fcnQ�[RO�U�TVo£ofTZ��^fcR¤�a�ofTZ� ]�TIQj^kT@ci\OBaKpdofQB°����®��®g���l���l®;��/� �f® � � ®¢���f®� w«��o� �l� ��������������? �;<>= �4�;<>?���������A£?����IA�� ��8������ �@H � {].f{ � 8!�"����H�8;: ��A�#�8��%$�/8`JI?&�'� ' =��¢J�;<>= � ' 8(��:��)�+*B? �VE-,<>?.��/ �;<>?&�/A���01�2� ��83���4�'��;<>?��������/A�?�8!�©JI?5� :�H�8���?�J6�5# �M�L$ <=��i� 7 � ~ $��-$ e �H<=� ~ � =)�sJ !�i�! 7 � �`�H<=� /70�<>?�HK?

�`�H<=�aib� / �V 8 �V� + � U V � U X � 8 � 9 � c X + � X � !#"$&%('*),+ - X -10,2 �f{ � �� � �� �� � ��r>?�u# � ¹�.f{�p]/ �

�$ e i � �w/ �V 8 �V� + � 8

�9 � ckX + � X ��! "$ % '*) +�- X -10�2 ��@�f{ � �� � �� �� � ��r>�� . � ¹�.f{�p]7 �

{Bx

Page 17: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

��c � ¹d.f{�p � t � � � ���?#�<�� � ~ $����2�5��$ e �H<=� ~ t �� � �� ���?#�<�� � � $����2� ��$ e �H<�� � � ���2� t �� � �����2� ^`awQ\[RO�pRcd^kQTIpRQK��YZi�v�cRTIi\]MY�oQ\T 0 ' t � + ^la*Q\[RO�aKpRiKU�YI_'O�YZi\OBY%TZUQ�[RO�pRcd^fQT����qsY�o�o�t�YZcsv ���E��� c # . . #�� + X�c � YZi�O�Q\[ROaKpRiKU�YI_'O�_'TdTIi�v@^fcsYZQ\OBa¡Q\[sYZQ�PsYZi�YZ]wO/Q\iK^f�/O 0 ' S���c(YIvRv@^fQK^fTIct&� 7 t?/2V�t 8\V­YZcsv 8 %V YZi�O�¤Z^feIO/cM^fc � ¹d.f{ � t � }?.�p�B � t� }?. p�B � YZcsv � }?.f{/¹ � tsi\OBajPsOB_'QK^feIO'of�IS�z�[RO�U�TZo�ofTZ��^fcR¤(i\OBaKpdofQ*U�TIi6Q�[RO�OB�@pd^�o�^kqRij^`pR] PRi\TIqdofO/] ^la+YZc�^f]�]�OBv@^`YZQ\O_'TIcsaKOB�@pRO/cs_'O�TZU � ¹�.l{�p � °&�®u�B®�� �l�s��¬ �� � �;� � �`~��\� ��� �T�~�~ �l«n �®�Z�R���l®;� � � GM<>?�� ' 8!��:���� *B? ��/ �;<>?�?����d8`A�8��/H'8�����A���:�= ��83��� $ e �$��e ���IH �;<d?�:�?.� ��?�H �'� �;<>? �5� �.�/A�?2�/= ��8(���?5�8

�9 � X + � X ��! "$ % '*) + - X -10�2 �L$ - �"$ e - � �f{ � �� � �� �� � ��r>�����35# � � { # . . # � . � ¹d.f{/¹ �

,<>?�?����d8`A�8��/H'8���� *B=@A �d?"�'� � 8!� � ����=I83�s?'J���# � ?��(��8���� $ e �4$ �e 8�� � ¹d.f{�p�/ � Ez¡[RO�¤IO/TI]�O/Q�iK^`_/Y�o�^f]�Pdo�^l_/YVQK^fTIcga�TVU � ¹�.f{�p � YZcsv � ¹�.f{/¹ � U�T@i6Q\[RO�vd�dcsYZ]�^`_/a�YZcsv2Q\[RO�OB�Ipd^�o�^fqRiK^�Y�TZU�Q\[RO

qRpRqRqdofO�aKTZofpRQK^fTIc�YZi\O+O'�FYZ]�^kcROBv%^fc��·�U�TIi�Q\[RO�_/YIajOR� � }�YZcsv©^kc�� x+U�TIi�Q�[RO�_/YIaKOR�� }RS�n� � �l® � �Z�~�~��f«�� ®s���l®;��� �¶� � � �,� �9«d�3���f®�3�

� O�cRTZ��O'�sYZ]�^fcROMQ\[RO�vd�>csYZ]�^l_/a+pRcsvdO/i � ¹�.f{�p]7 � ��[RO/c"� � }FS6��c�Q�[d^la6_/Y@aKO � ^la6YVi�_�ofO/cR¤IQ\[nY�ofTIcR¤0 ' YZcsv�Q\[dpsa >���� > � ^fc � ¹d.f{�p � S�³IpRPRPsTdaKO�Q\[sYZQ6YZQ4QK^f]�O <a�b3 t¢Q\[RO�v@^lajQ�YZcs_'O � ���?# 32� � ~ $M���2� �-$ e ��32� ~^`a4]�^fcd^f]�^f�/OBv­YZQyYwpRcd^`�IpROwPsTZ^fcdQ $M��� e � % 0 ' ��^fQ\[�YZi'_�okO/cR¤@Q\[n_'TdTIi�v@^fcsYZQ\O �@� � e S���c�Q\[RO6o�^f]�^fQ � vF3 t��O6cRTZ��aK[RTZ�1U�i\TI] � ¹d.f{�p�7 � Q\[sYZQ $M��� e � i�O/]�Y�^fcsa4Q\[RO�_�ofT>aKOBaKQ4PsTV^kcdQ4TIc 0 ' Q\T $ e �S<�� YIa < ^fcs_'i\OBY@aKOBa/S

zDT9aj[RT��¨Q\[d^`a+�OMcRO/OBv Q\T�^fcdQ\i\TRvdps_'O(aKTI]�O�cRT@Q�YZQK^fTIcS,IuO/Q ��� � � �H<�� t��¡^kQ�[ � � ��32�r� � e t�vdO/cRTIQ�OQ\[RO�YZi�_�ofO/cR¤IQ\[1_'T>T@i�v@^fcsYZQ\O(YZQ�QK^f]�O < ��[RO/i�O�Q\[RO�]�^fcd^f]�pR]-e�Y�okpRO�TZU � ���?#�<=�|� ~ $����2� � $ e �S<�� ~ TZeIO/i�Y�o�o$M���:� % 0 ' ^`a�YZQ\Q'Y�^fcROBvuS6�ya�aKpR]�O�Q\[sYVQ � � �H<=� ^`a4Q\[RO�pRcd^`�IpROMaKps_\[ ]�^fcd^k]�pR] PsTV^kcdQBS4� O���YZc>Q4Q\T�aK[RTZ�Q\[sYZQ �� � ��3 SNIuO/Q � � � � � �H<�� � �2� � � �H<=� #�< svdO/cRTIQ\O�Q\[RO�]�^fcd^k]�pR]�v@^`aKQ'YZcs_'O�U�i\TI] $ e �H<=� Q\T 0 ' YZQ�QK^f]�O <YZcsv�ofO/Q �� � �S<�� vdO/cRT@Q\O�Q�[RO�pRcd^fQ�eIOB_'Q\TIi �� � �H<�� �6��$ � � � �H<�� �-$ e �H<���� � X�c� SNtRTIi � � �H<�� Q\T�q¢O�Q\[RO�]�^fcd^k]�^k�/O/i�tQ\[RO*U�TZo�ofTZ��^fcR¤�cROB_'OBa�a\YZi\��_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIc�]�psajQ�[RTZo`v

$ Q � � � �H<=� � �� � �H<=�N��3 . � ·?.f{ �²�T��+t/U�TIi �av 3 tZQ�[ROvdTI]�^fcsYZcdQ#_'TIcdQ\iK^fqRpRQK^fTIc�Q\T4Q\[RO�^fcdQ\O/¤Ii�Y�o>^fc � ¹�.f{�p�7 � YZiK^`aKOBaDU�i\TI] Q\[RO�i\O/¤V^kT@c �5� � �H<=���[RO/i\O � ���?#�<�� ^la¡]�^fcd^k]�^k�/OZvuS6³Z^fcs_'O � ^la4YZi�_�ofO/cR¤IQ�[tuQ\[RO�z�Y��@ofTIi�O'�RPsYZcsa�^fTIc�TZU � ���?#�<=� cROBYVi � � �H<�� ^`a

� ���?#�<��N� � � � {} � � X�c� � } � � ���r�� � ���a�������M# YIa ��v � � . � ·?. } �C�O/i\O } � ^`a�Q�[RO�_'pRi\e�YVQ\pRi\O�TZU 0 ' YVQ �|�;� � �S<�� S�³Z^fcs_'O ' ^`a#Y@a\aKpR]�OBv�Q�T6qsO�_'TIcdeIO'�tIQ\[RO/c } � � 3 S�²�O'�RQBt

psa�^fcR¤ � ·?. } � YZcsv�Q\[RO�_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIc �� � � �� � {�Q�[sYZQ�[RTVolvRa�YZQ4Q\[RO�]�^kcd^f]�pR] PsTZ^fcdQBt��O�_/YZc�psajOsIDYZPdo`YI_'O�K a]�O/Q\[RTRv�T@c � ¹�.l{�p�7 � Q�T�TIqRQ�Y�^fc

�$ e i4� � � � � � X�c � ��� { � } �4� � � c�� � � X � ! "$ % '*) + -/. X -10,2 �� � # YIa � v 3 . � ·?.�p]/ �C�O/i\O���O6[sY�eIO�vdO � cROBv � qd�

�s� }�/ �V 8 �V � Xdc ��� 8 %V � X�c � � . � ·?.�p]7 ���c�vdO/iK^feI^fcR¤ � ·�.�p�/ � ��O6[sY�eIO�YIa�aKpR]�OBv�Q�[sYZQ�Q\[RO�aKQ�iK^`_'Q�^fcROB�IpsY�o�^fQK� } � � � W � {*[RTZo`vRa�aKTwQ\[sYZQ���� � W 3 YZQ� � �H<=� S

{\l

Page 18: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

³Z^fcs_'OItdU�i\TI] � ·?.�p]/ � t �$ e ^`a�^kcMQ\[RO6v@^fi\OB_'QK^fTIc�TZU �� � �H<=� tZ^fQ�U�TZo�ofTZ��a�Q\[sYZQ �� � �S<�� Y 3 S�³Z^kcs_'O6Q�[d^la�v@^`aKQ�YZcs_'O^`a�vdOB_'i\OBYIa¦^kcR¤¢tsQ\[RO6aKpRiKU�YI_'O�_'TdTIi�v@^fcsYZQ\O6��[RO/i\O � ���?#�<�� ^`a�]�^fcd^f]�^f�/OBv�_/YZcRcRTIQ�qsO�Y�v@^`a\_'TIcdQK^fcdpRTIpsa�U�pRcs_'QK^fTIcTZU < S�z�[RO/i\O'U�TIi\OIt¢��O�_/YZc�YIa�aKpR]�O�Q\[sYZQ �Z� � � �H<�� ^`a�v@^�¥O/i\O/cdQK^`YZqdofOISRtD^fcsY�o�of�ItQ�T�OBaKQ�YZqdo�^`aK[�Q\[sYZQ �� � �63 t��O � i�aKQ�v@^�¥O/i\O/cdQK^`YZQ\O � ·?.l{ � ��^fQ\[(i\OBajPsOB_'Q6Q\T < Q\T�¤IO/Q

�� � � { � } � � � �N��$ Q ��� � � � �$ e . � ·?. ¹ �z�[RO/ct3U�i\T@] � ·?.f{ � t � ·?.�p]/ � YZcsv � ·�. ¹ � tF^fQ4^la6_�ofOBYZi+Q\[sYZQ �� � �O3 S|C�O/cs_'OIt � � �H<=�5� � e U�TIi < W 3 S|tD^fcsY�o�of�It��O�_/YZc(psajORIYZPdo`YI_'O�K a4]�O/Q\[RTRv�TIc � ¹d.f{�p�/ � Q\T�_/Y�o`_'pdo`YZQ\O �`�H<�� S ��O�ajpR]�]�YZiK^f�/O�TIpRi�i�OBaKpdofQ�YIa�U�TZo�okTZ��a�°����®��®g���l���l®;� /� �f® ���Z�3~�~��f«�� ®s���l®;� ��®u��� � � ������ � ����?4�;<>= ��= � <a��3 / $���� e � 8(� �;<>? � �¢8 �.�>? ���I83� ���� 0 ' 0�<>8;:/<�8(��:BA�� �/?���� ��� $ e ��32�a�b$ ee E�,<d?���/ � �@H � v 3 / �;<>? �2� ��83��� �'� �;<>?M:'?�� ��?�H �'� �;<>? ��������A�?�8(�83��;<>?�JI8;HK?�:���8������'� $M��� e �n��$ ee ���IH6? ��� �)�s?�� ��8`=@A`A�#�A������ ��83��?5��/#=)�sJ9�;<>?�JI8(����=��¢:�? � � �H<�� � ~ $M��� e �n�w$ e �H<=� ~�/= ��8(���?5� �;<>?�= ��# � � ��� ��8`: �����

�� � ib� � � � � � � X�c � ��� { � } � � � � c�� � � X ��! "$ % '*) + -/. X -1012 . � ·?. · �����=IJIJ@8 ��83����/ �`�H<�� �/= ��8!� ��?��

�wiO� � � � c�� �} � U V � U X � � X�c�� ��� { � } � � � � c�� � � X ��!#"$&%('*),+�-/. X -1012 . � ·?. x �C�O/i\O } � ^la�Q\[RO�_'pRi\e�YZQ�pRi\O�TZU 0 ' YVQ � e YZcsv � ^`a�vdO � cROBv%^fc � ·?.�p]7 � S

b4a�^fcR¤�IYZPdo`YI_'O�K a*]�O/Q\[RTRv�TIc � p?. }�q � ts��O�_/YZcnY�o`aKT(_/Y�ol_'pdo`YZQ�O�Q\[ROwO'��P¢TIcRO/c>Qj^lY�o£of� aK]MY�o�o#O'^k¤@O/c>eZY�ofpROBa� - U�TIi � � { # }RS ��O � csv%Q\[sYZQ

� - i �]� c�� � 8 V � X�c�� ��� { � } � � � � c�� � ! �� � � �6 - # � � X � !#"$ %('*)�+ -/. X -10,2 # � � { # } . � ·?.ml �C�O/i\O �6 - ^`a�Q\[RO�pRcd^fQ4qsYIa�^`a�e@OB_'Q\TIi�^fc�Q\[RO $ Q�[- v@^fi\OB_'QK^fTIcS

z¡[ROyvd�dcsYZ]�^`_/a � ·?. · � ^`a#Y@aK�>]wPRQ\TIQK^`_/Y�o�of��eZY�o�^`vMPRi\TZeI^`vdOBvwQ\[sYZQ � � �H<=� W5� 7 S �¶[RO/c � � �H<=�:� � 7 � g ���h� tQ\[RO�qRpRqRqdofO6q¢O/¤Z^fcsa�Q\T�_'TZo�o`YZPsaKO�YZ¤dY�^fcsaKQ 0 ' TIc�Y�U�YIaKQ\O/i�QK^f]�O/��a\_/Y�ofOIS ��O�vdO � cRO�YZcMYZPRPRi\T��>^f]�YVQ\O�_'TZo�o`YZPsaKOQK^f]�O <�� q>��Q\[RO�_'T@csv@^kQj^kT@c � � �H<��_�N� ��7�S�³IpRPRPsTdaKO�Q\[sYZQ � � ��32�N� � e W5��7'S tRi\T@] � ·?. · � t <�� ^la�¤Z^feIO/c�q>�

< � � � X � � ��

8 --,0� c�� ��� { � } � �2� c�� � � ��! "$ % '*) + �kX -,0/2 >�� . � ·?. ¸ �

��O�_/YZc�Q\[RO/c�^fcdQ\O/¤Ii�YVQ\O � ·�. ¸ � q>��PsYVi\Q�a�QK��^`_'O�Q�T�T@qRQ�Y�^fctRU�TIi � v 3 t>Q�[sYZQ<��ai � X�c�� �

} � 8 %V � � � e � { � �¹ 8 %V { {� e � } �

{ � } �4� e � � � ��!#"$&%('*),+�- X -10,2 . � ·?.�q �C�O/i\O � � � e � � � c�� �e � { � } � � e � c � � S�zDT�O/eZY�ofpsYZQ\O6Q\[RO4O'�RPsTIcRO/cdQK^`YZQ\OBv%Q\O/i\]�aX^fc � ·?. · � YZcsv � ·?.�q � �O�psaKO6Q\[ROQK��T�Q\O/i�]�O'�RPsYZcsa�^fTIcsayU�TIi 8 %V YZcsv ��7�¤V^ke@O/c(^fc � }?.f{/¹ � YZcsv � �|. ¹ � S�z¡[ROBaKO�Q\O/i\]Ma�YZi�O�a¦^k¤@cd^ � _/YVc>QKof��]wTIi\OYI_/_'pRi�YVQ\O�Q\[sYVcM^£U#O/eZY�ofpsYZQ\OBv�Q\[RO/] q>��psa¦^kcR¤MTIcdof��Q\[RO*okOBY@v@^kcR¤�T@i�vdO/i�q¢O/[sY�eI^fTIi�a 8 %V i 8 V YZcsv� 7 i � e 7 S

{B¸

Page 19: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

�n� � ��� � �;���f�(������� �l«R�M®��6� �f® � �M¬N�u��� �;�I�zDTM¤IO/cRO/i�YZQ\O�_'TIcdeIO'�9vdTI]�Y�^fcsa4��O4U�TZo�okTZ� �f{Bx\ �SaIuO/Q4Q\[RO�TIij^k¤V^kc�q¢O�_'TIcdQ�Y�^fcROBv�^fc ' YVcsvMofO/Q �L$ c # $ � �qsO�Y�P¢TZ^fc>Q6T@c 0 ' S5I3O/Q �vdO/cRTIQ\O�Q\[RO+PsO/i\P¢O/csv@^l_'pFo`YZi�v@^lajQ�YZcs_'O+U�i�TI]�Q�[RO�TIiK^f¤Z^fc�Q\TMQ\[RO�Q'YZcR¤IO/cdQ�o�^fcRO�Q\T0 ' Q\[sYZQ4PsYIa\aKOBa4Q�[Ri\TIpR¤I[ ��$ c # $ � � S IuO/Q � vdO/cRTIQ\O�Q�[RO�YVcR¤ZofO�q¢O/QK�O/O/c�Q\[d^`a*PsO/i\P¢O/csv@^l_'pdo�YZi+o£^fcRO�YZcsv�Q\[ROPsTda�^fQK^feIO $ c Y��>^`a/S�z�[RO/ct���[RO/c � i�YZcR¤@OBa6TZeIO/i 3�� � � } � t¢�O�aK��O/O/P�T@pRQ�Y�_�okTdaKOBv�vdTI]�Y�^kc ' ��[RT>aKO

qsT@pRcsvRYZi\��^`a�¤Z^feIO/c(PsYVi�YZ]�O/Q\ij^l_/Y�o£of��q>�$ c � �]� � � �]� _'T>a � �]�N� Q � �]� a¦^kc � �]�n# $ � � ��� � � �]� a�^fc � �]�;� Q � �]� _'T>a � �]� . � ·�.f{ 32�z�[RO�_'pRi\e�YZQ�pRi\O } � �]� TZU 0 ' tFQ\[RO4ofO/cR¤IQ\[ �­TZU 0 ' tRYZcsv%Q\[RO�YVi\OBY P TZU ' YZi�O6¤Z^feIO/c�^fc(Q�O/i\]�a�TZU � �]� q>�

} � ��� � � ! � �]�`� Q Q � �]� # X�c # � � 8 ���e � �]� > �a# P � {}8 ���e � � � �]� � � � Q � �]� � � > � .� ·�.f{I{ �

z�[dpsa�¤Z^feIO/c(YZcd� � �]� �¡^kQ�[� � �]� � � �N� } �G� t � �]� W 3 YZcsv � �]�?� Q Q � �]� W 3 tI��O4TIqRQ�Y�^fc�Q\[RO4qsT@pRcsvRYZi\�TZU#Y�aKQ\ij^l_'Qjok�(_'T@c>eIO'�9vdT@]�Y�^fc � } Y 32� S

� O�cRTZ� ^�o�ofpsaKQ\i�YVQ\O�TIpRi�i�OBaKpdofQ�a�U�T@i�QK�TM_\[RTZ^`_'OBa4TZU � �]� YZcsvMU�TIi4Q\[RO�QK��T�_\[RTV^l_'OBa*TZU ������� ¤Z^feIO/c�^fc� }?. }R{ �r� aKO/O � }?. }I} � U�TIi�aKTI]�OM[RO/Q\O/i\TR_�o�^kcd^`_�TIi\qd^fQ�_'TIcsaKQ'YZc>Q'a6U�TIi+Q\[ROBaKO ��������� S&tFTIi�_'TIcdeIO/cd^fO/cs_'OIt�^fc­Q\[ROO'�sYZ]�PdofOBa4qsO'ofTZ����O6¤Z^feIO+Q\[RO�i'YIv@^fpsa � 7YZcsv�Q�[RO/c9_/Y�o`_'pdo`YZQ\O�Q\[RO+]�YIa\a A ��A ���_� ^kc�Q\O/i�]�a�TZU ��7#psa¦^kcR¤� � . } � S�zDT�_/Y�o`_'pdo`YZQ\O A YZcsv�Q�[RO�Q\O/i�]�a�^fc � ·?. · � U�TIi�OBYI_\[�_�[RTZ^`_'O6TZU ������� t � 7XYVcsv � t@��O�cRO/OBvwQ\T�O/eZY�ofpsYZQ\O! c t 8 %V t � YVcsv � [ ¤Z^feIO/c�^fc � }?. ¸ � t � }?.f{/¹ � t � ·?.�p�7 � YZcsv � � .�p � tRi\OBaKP¢OB_'QK^feIO'of�IS �1[RO/c � � ��������� t ��7 � .ml�·YZcsv �a� .f{�·Rtd�O+psaKO � }?. }R{�/ � YZcsv � }?. }I}�/ � Q�T�TIqRQ�Y�^fc! c � ¸ � q # 8 %V � {�.�q # � [ � ofTI¤} # �s� q?. ¸I}�p�p . � ·?.f{B}]/ ���okQ�O/i\csYZQK^feIO'of�It��[RO/c � ��� �\����� t*��7 � .ml�·�YZcsv �a� .l{B·Rtd��O � csvMU�i\TI] � }?. }R{�7 � YZcsv � }?. }I}]7 � Q�[sYZQ! c � {�.l{B·Z¹>} # 8 %V � {�. ¸R{\l�x # � V �63 .ml q@¸ 35# � X ��3 . ·R{\l p # ��� ¹d.�qIxI}I· . � ·?.f{B}]7 ���c Q\[RO�O'�FYZ]wPdokOBa*qsO'ofTZ��t�ajTZofpRQK^fTIcsa+Q\T � ·?. · � ��O/i\O�_'TI]�PRpRQ\OBv�psa¦^kcR¤�Q\[ROM³>YZcsv@^`Y N6´ ajTZofeIO/iu� }@x\ �Syz¡[ROvd�dcsYZ]�^`_/Y�o�i\O/��a\_/Y�o�^fcR¤(]�O/Q�[RT�v%TZU � }2l� u��YIa�psaKOBv%Q\T�¤IO/cRO/i�YVQ\O�YZPRPRi�TIPRiK^`YZQ\O+QK^f]�O�aKQ�O/Psa/S��������l« �n� � ��IuO/Q � �]�r� p � 3 . ¹�a�^fc �\� �]� ��3 . ·#_'Tda � � �]� t �)�O� ���L�M� t � 7 � .ml�·MYZcsv � � .f{�·RS|tRi�TI]� ·?.l{I{ � ��O�T@qRQ�Y�^fc�Q\[sYZQ PO� }�p?.�pV¹�YZcsvwU�i�TI] � ·�.f{B}�/ � t � }?. }I}�/ � YZcsv � � . } � ��O6_/Y�o`_'pdo`YZQ\O�Q�[sYZQ A � {�q�. 3 pRS��c-tD^k¤¢Sx���O�aK[RTZ��Q\[RO�]�TIQK^fTIc TZUQ\[RO�_'O/cdQ\O/i6TZU�Q\[RO�qRpRqRqdofO©ajQ�YZi\QK^fcR¤MU�i\TI]�Q\[RO�Q\[Ri�O/O�v@^�¥O/i\O/cdQ6^fcd^fQK^`Y�o_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIcsayolYVqsO'ofOBv�qd�&g 3 tdU�TIi46 � { # } # pRS#z¡[RO�_�ofT>aKOBaKQ6P¢TZ^fc>Q6T@c 0 ' Q�T g 3 � o`YZq¢O'ofOBv�qd����^fc�tD^k¤¢Sgx � ^la_'TI]�PRpRQ�OBv(cdpR]�O/iK^`_/Y�o�of��YZcsv�Q�[RO�_'pRi\eZYZQ\pRi\O } � TZU 0 ' YZQ�Q\[d^`a4_�okTdaKOBaKQ4PsTZ^fcdQBts��[d^l_�[�^`a�cRO/OBvdOBv%^fc � ·�. · � t^`a�_/Y�o`_'pdo`YZQ\OBv U�i\TI] � ·?.f{@{ � S�z�[RO�qRpRqRqdofO�Q\[RO/c­]�TZeIOBa+^fc­Q\[RO(v@^fi\OB_'Qj^kT@c¶TVU�Q\[RO(YZi\i�T��4a�YVcsv�qsO/¤Z^fcsawQ\T_'TZo�o`YZPsaKO�YZ¤>Y�^fcsaKQ 0 ' ��[RO/c�^fQ�a�_'O/cdQ\O/i+^`a�YZQ � 3 S���c tD^f¤sSNl���O�PdofTIQ�Q\[ROwU�pRcs_'QK^fTIc�ofTI¤ c e � { � <�� eIO/i'aKpsa� � � ��7�U�TIi#OBYI_�[�TZUQ\[RO4Q\[Ri\O/O¡^kcd^fQK^`Y�o�_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIcsa/S�²�TIQK^`_'O�Q�[sYZQ#Q\[RO�qRpRqRqdokO*^`a#OBa�aKO/c>Qj^lY�o£of��aKQ�YZQj^kT@csYZi\��TZeIO/iYweIO/i\�MofTIcR¤MQK^f]�O+^kcdQ\O/i\eZY�o�S tFTIi�OBY@_\[ 6\td^fc�z�YVqdokOTpw��O�¤Z^feIO+Q\[RO�_'TdTIi�v@^fcsYZQ\OBa4TVU#Q\[RO6^fcd^fQK^`Y�o#ofTR_/YZQK^fTIc�g 3YZcsvM��O6¤Z^feIO6Q\[RO4^fcd^fQK^`Y�o#v@^`aKQ�YZcs_'O � � ��32� Q\T 0 ' S � O�Y�o`aKT�aK[RTZ�1Q\[RO4U�YBe@TIi�YZqdofO�_'TI]�PsYViK^`aKTIc(q¢O/QK�O/O/c�Q\[ROYIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_�_'TZo�o`YZPsaKO�QK^f]�O � ·?.�q � YZcsv%Q\[RO�_'T@i\i\OBaKP¢TIcsv@^fcR¤�c>pR]�O/ij^l_/Y�o#e�Y�ofpRO�_'TI]�PRpRQ\OBv©U�i�TI] � ·?. · � S��������l« �n� � � IuO/Q � �]� � p � {�. ¹a¦^kc �]� �]� t � � ���\���M� t ��7 � .ml�·wYZcsv � � .f{�·RS tFi\TI] � ·?.f{I{ � t � ·?.f{B}�7 � t� }?. }I}�7 � YVcsv � � . } � ��O(_/Y�o`_'pdo`YZQ\O�Q\[sYZQ P � }Ix?.mlB¹�YZcsv A � }Ix�.ml�}RS ��c�tD^f¤sS�¸���O�PdofTIQMQ\[RO�]�TIQj^kT@c

{�q

Page 20: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

TZU�Q�[RO©_'O/cdQ\O/i�TZU�Q\[RO�qRpRqRqdofO%U�TIi�Q\[Ri�O/O©v@^�¥O/i\O/cdQ�^fcd^kQj^lY�o*_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIcsa�Snz�[RO(_'TIi�i\OBaKPsT@csv@^kcR¤�Q\i�YV§¦OB_'Q�TIiK^fOBaofTI¤ c e � { � <=� eIO/i�ajpsa � � � � 7yYZi�O�aK[RTZ��c ^kc�tD^f¤sS qFS�z�[RO�_'T>T@i�v@^fcsYZQ\OBa�TZU�Q\[RO�^kcd^fQK^`Y�o6_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIcsa�YZcsv�Y_'TI]�PsYViK^`aKTIc(TVU�Q\[RO�YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQj^l_+YZcsv�cdpR]�O/iK^`_/Y�o�e�Y�okpROBa�U�TIi�Q�[RO�_'TZo�o`YZPsaKO�QK^f]�OBa4YZi\O6¤Z^feIO/c%^fc2z�YZqdofO�¹¢S�n� � ���u«�� � ��� � �;~�� � ��� �Z�~�~��f«� �®�Z�R���l®;��� � �tFTIi �zv 3 tu��O�cRTZ��psaKO � ¹�.f{/¹ � Q\T(vdO/Q\O/i\]�^kcROMQ\[RO�_'O/cdQ\O/i $ e � $ �e TZU#Q\[RO � pRcsajQ�YZqdofO � OB�@pd^�o£^fqRiK^;pR]qRpRqRqdofO9aKTVokpRQj^kT@cS�³IpRPRP¢T>aKO(Q�[sYZQ�Q\[RO�_'O/cdQ\O/i $ 3 1 TZU�Q\[ROwolYVi\¤IOBaKQ+^fcsa\_'iK^fqsOBv�_�^fi�_�ofO�� U�TIi ' ^`a+pRcd^`�IpRO'of�vdO � cROBvuS6��c�PsYZi\QK^`_'pdo`YZiBtuQ�[d^la*T�_/_'pRi'a4��[RO/c ' ^`a6aKQ\iK^`_'QKof��_'TIc>e@O'� � ^�S OIS } Y 3 TIc 0 ' � S���c�Q\[d^`a6_/YIaKOItu��OaK[RTZ�1Q\[sYZQ $ �e ^`a�ofT�_/YVQ\OBv�YZQ�YZc,g ���_� v@^`aKQ�YVcs_'O6U�i\TI] $ 3 1 S���c�TIQ\[RO/i���TIi�vRa/t $ �e ^`a�YIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_/Y�o�ok�(_�ofT>ajO6Q\TQ\[sYZQ�PsTZ^fcdQ�^fc ' ��[d^l_�[�^`a¡U�pRi�Q\[ROBaKQ�U�i\T@]�Q\[RO6qsT@pRcsvRYZi\�IS

³IpRPRP¢T>aKO�Q\[sYZQ�� ^`a�pRcd^`�IpRO'of�¶vdO/Q�O/i\]�^fcROBv YZcsv�Q�[sYZQ�� ^la+Q�YVcR¤IO/c>Q�Q\T 0 ' YZQ�O'�FY@_'QKof�nQK��T(P¢TZ^fc>Q�a$M��� c �u% 0 ' YZcsv $���� � �u% 0 ' ��^fQ\[ � c���:� � S�IuO/Q � 3 1 qsO�Q\[RO�i�YIv@^fpsa�TZU�� YVcsv okO/Q��¶qsO�Q\[RO(_�[RTIi�v§KTZ^fcd^kcR¤ $���� c � YZcsv $���� � � S � O�YIa\ajpR]�O�Q\[sYVQQ�[RO�TIi�vdO/i�TZUX_'T@c>Q�Y@_'Q�TZU� ��^fQ\[ 0 ' ^`a�ajps_\[�Q\[sYVQ�Q\[RO�ajQ\iK^`_'Q^fcROB�IpsY�o£^fQK� } 3 � 3 1 W � {�[RTZo`vRayU�TIi46 � { # }RS C�O/i\O } 3 ^`a4Q\[RO�_'pRi\eZYZQ\pRi\OwTZU 0 ' YZQ �@� � 3 S I3O/Q �� 3 q¢O�Q\[ROpRcd^fQ�T@pRQ¦��YZi'vMcRTIi\]�Y�o�Q\T 0 ' YVQ � 3 S#z�[RO/ct¢Q\[RO4U�TZo�okTZ��^fcR¤MofTR_/Y�oX_'T@csv@^kQj^kT@csa4]�psajQ�[RTZo`v�YZQ � c YVcsv � � °

�� c �b� �� � ��$M��� 3 �`��$ 3 1 �~ $M��� 3 �`��$ 3 1 ~ � �� 3 � { # 6 � { # } . � ·?.f{�p]/ �W�TIi\O/TZeIO/iBtua�^fcs_'O�1]�YZ±@OBa4O'�FYI_'Qjok��QK�T@��PsTZ^fcdQ�_'TIc>Q'YI_'Q��¡^kQ�[ 0 ' tsQ�[RO�U�TZo�ofTZ��^fcR¤(¤ZofTIqsY�o_'T@csv@^kQj^kT@c�]�psaKQqsO�a\YZQK^`a � OBvu° ~ $M���2� ��$ 3 1 ~ � � 3 1 W 35# � $����2� % 0 'b# ��^fQ\[ � �� � c # � ��5� � . � ·?.f{�p]7 �tFi\TI] � ·?.f{�p]7 � ^kQ+^`a�_�ofOBYZi�Q\[sYZQ6^�U���O�ajO/Q $ �e � $ 3 1 ^fc � ¹�.f{�¹ � tuQ\[RO�vdTI]�^fcsYZcdQ�_'TIc>Q�iK^fqRpRQK^fTIc Q\T�Q\[RO^fc>Q�O/¤Ii�Y�oR^fc � ¹�.f{�¹ � ��TIpdo`v�YZiK^`aKO�U�i\TI]�Q\[RO�i\O/¤V^kT@csa�cROBYZi � c YZcsv � � S�z�[RO/i\O'U�TIi\OItZqd��psa�^fcR¤�IYZPdo`YI_'O�K aX]�O/Q\[RTRvTIc � ¹�.f{/¹ � Q\TI¤@O/Q\[RO/i���^fQ\[ � ·?.f{�p]/ � t���O � csv�Q\[sYVQ � ¹�.f{/¹ � ^`a�YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQj^l_/Y�o£of��a�YZQK^`a � OBvw��[RO/c } c � } � S�z�[dpsa/t^fc�Q\[d^`a�_/YIaKOIt¢Q\[RO�_'O/cdQ\O/i6TZU#Q\[RO�OB�@pd^£o�^fqRiK^`pR] qRpRqRqdokOMaKTZofpRQK^fTIcn_'TZ^fcs_�^`vdOBa+��^fQ\[�Q\[RO�_'O/c>Q�O/i $ 3 1 TZU��4S��4cO'�sYZ]�PdofO�TZU�Q\[d^`a�_/YIajO4^la^£o�ofpsaKQ\i'YZQ\OBv%^fc�tD^f¤sSu{ 3 ��[RO/i�O6�O�aj[RT��1Q\[RO4ofTR_/YZQK^fTIc�TZU�Q�[RO6OB�Ipd^�o�^fqRiK^`pR]!qRpRqRqdofOaKTZofpRQK^fTIc�_'TIi�i\OBaKPsT@csv@^kcR¤�Q�T�Q\[RO�vdT@]�Y�^fc(¤Z^feIO/c%^fc tD^f¤sS¢xRS

�1[RO/c�Q\[RO�_'pRi\e�YZQ�pRi\OBa�YVQ�Q\[RO�QK��T�_'TIcdQ�YI_'Q4PsTZ^fcdQ�a�YVi\O�pRcROB�@psY�o�tuQ\[RO�qRpRqRqdofO�_'O/cdQ\O/i $ �e aKQj^£o�o�o�^fOBa4TIc�¶qRpRQ+^`a�cRTZ��YZQ�YZc�g ���_� v@^`aKQ�YVcs_'O�U�i\TI] $ 3 1 S�IuO/Q � 3z� ~ $���� 3S� � $��e ~ YZcsv��� 3r� �L$M��� 3 � � $ �e � � X�c3 U�TIi6 � { # }RS�³Z^fcs_'O $ �e % � YZcsv ~ $ �e �"$ 3 1 ~ � g ���_� t��O�[sYBe@O �� 3 � �� 3 � {It �� c �E� �� � YZcsv�� c � � � � g ���h� Sz�[ROBaKO+i\O'o`YZQK^fTIcsa6YZi�O6psaKOBv���[RO/c�YZPRPdof�I^fcR¤wIYZPdo`YI_'O�K a4]�O/Q�[RT�v%Q\T � ¹�.l{/¹ � Q\T�TIqRQ�Y�^fc

� X�c�� �c� { � } c���c � c�� � � X � ! "$ % '*) + - ) X -,012 i � X�c�� ��� { � } � � � � c�� � � X ��! "$ % '*) +�-� X -1012 . � ·�.f{/¹ �³Z^fcs_'O � c � } � 3 1 � � � tR��O�_'TIcs_�ofpsvdO�Q\[sYZQ

� c i � 3 1 � �¸ 8 %V okT@¤ { { � } � � 3 1{ � } c � 3 1 � # � � i � 3 1 � �

¸ 8 %V ofTI¤ { { � } � � 3 1{ � } c � 3 1 � . � ·�.f{B· �²�TIQ\O6Q\[sYZQ���[RO/c ~ } c ~ W ~ } � ~ t>Q�[RO/c � c W5� 3 1 YZcsv � � Y5� 3 1 S2,< �)��/ �;<>?�:�?.� ��?�H �'� �;<>?w? �.�>8;A�8 ��H�83� � ��������A�?���IA�� ��83���­8!��A��B:'= ��?�J&����� = ��=���g ���_� JI8!� ��=)�s:'? �/H'��� $ 3 1 83� �;<>?�JI8;HK?�:���8��)� �'���;<>?�: ��� ��=@: � � �I83� � 0�<>?BHK?�;<>?"��=��)�s8����>J@? �'� �;<d?�:��dH�*�= ���dH¦?M8!� � ��=IA;A�?BH/E

} 3

Page 21: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

� O�cRTZ�­qRiK^fO_^s��_'TIcsa�^`vdO/i�Q\[RO�_/YIajO���[RO/c ��]�YZ±IOBaXO'�FY@_'QKof��Q�[Ri\O/O/��PsTZ^fcdQ�_'TIc>Q'YI_'Q#��^fQ\[wQ\[RO�qsT@pRcsvRYZi\�TZU�Y(ajQ\iK^`_'QKof� _'T@c>eIO'�nvdTI]MY�^fcS&IuO/Q $ 3 1 qsO�Q\[RO�pRcd^`�@pRO�ofTR_/YZQK^fTIc­TZU�Q\[RO�_'O/cdQ\O/i�TZU ��S�z�[RO/ct�q>��psa¦^kcR¤IYZPdo`YI_'O�K a�]�O/Q\[RTRv�T@c � ¹�.l{/¹ � t'^fQD^`a�_�okOBYVi�Q\[sYVQ � ¹d.f{/¹ � ^`a�YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQj^l_/Y�o£of��a\YZQK^`a � OBv���[RO/c $ �e ��$ 3 1 PRi\TZeI^`vdOBvQ\[sYZQ�Q\[RO�_'pRi\eZYZQ\pRi\OBa�YVQ�Q�[RO�Q\[Ri�O/O(_'TIc>Q'YI_'Q�PsTZ^fcdQ�a�YZi\OMOB�@psY�o�YZcsv�Q�[sYZQ�Q\[RO(YZcR¤ZofOBa�q¢O/Q¦��O/O/c YIv�§\YI_'O/cdQo�^fcRO9aKO/¤I]wO/c>Q�ay§¦TZ^fcd^fcR¤ $ 3 1 Q�T9Q�[RO(_'TIc>Q'YI_'Q�PsTZ^fcdQ�a�YZi\O�{B} 3 � YZPsYVi\QBS��4cnO'�sYZ]�PdofO(TVU�Q\[d^`a�a�^fQ\psYZQj^kT@c�^la^�o�okpsajQ\i�YZQ\OBv%^fc&tD^f¤sSu{I{4��[RO/i\O6��O6aK[RTZ�¶Q�[RO4okTR_/YZQK^fTIc�TVU�Q\[RO6OB�@pd^£o�^fqRiK^`pR]�qRpRqRqdofO�aKTZofpRQK^fTIc�_'TIi\i\OBajPsTIcsv@^fcR¤Q\T�Q\[RO6Q\ij^lYVcR¤Ipdo`YZiyaj[sYZPsOBv�vdTI]�Y�^fc(¤V^ke@O/c�^fc�tD^f¤sSRxRS���c(Q\[RO6]wTIi\O6QK�>Pd^`_/Y�o�_/YIaKO6��[RO/c�Q\[RO�YZcR¤ZofOBa�YZi�O6cRTIQ{B} 3 � YZPsYZi\Q6T@i6��[RO/c�Q\[RO�_'pRi�e�YZQ\pRi�OBa�YZQ6Q\[ROM_'TIc>Q'YI_'Q6PsTZ^fcdQ�a�YVi\O�pRcROB�IpsY�o�t�Q�[RO�_'O/cdQ\O/i $ �e ^`a�aj[d^£U�Q\OBv q>�YZc�g �L�_� YZ]�TIpRcdQ�Y���YB�MU�i\TI] $ 3 1 S6��a�^f]�^�o`YZi�YVcsY�of��a�^`a�YIa4��YIa�¤Z^feIO/c­YZqsTZeIO+U�TIi�Q�[RO�QK�T@��PsTZ^fcdQ�_'TIc>Q'YI_'Q_/YIaKO�_/YZc�qsO�vdTIcRO+Q\T�_/Y�o`_'pdo`YZQ\O�Q\[d^`a4aK[d^�U�Q4PRi\OB_�^`aKO'of�IS�z�[RO+i\OBaKpdofQ4^`a�YIa¡U�TZo�ofTZ��a/°&�®u�B®�� �l�s��¬ ������«>«d$ �4®n� �s�M&�®;�¢�/�s�Z� ��� � � ��� ��?4�;<>= � � 8!� � �¢8 �.�>?�A�#�J@? �7�¢?�J+=��sJ �;<>= � � ��=���?��4?���=@: ��A�#�;<>HK?'?�$ ���I83� ��: ��� ��=@: �20�8 �;< 0 ' = � $���� 3S��% 0 ' � �IH96 � { # } # psE�� � � � � � ?�=IA � � �;<d= � } 3 � 3 1 W � {����IH6 � { # } # p�/ 0�<d?BHK? } 3 � 3 8(� �;<d?�:.�>H *B=)�>HK?��'� 0 ' = � $M��� 3 � E ,<>?.��/ $ e ��$ e ���_� � = ��8!���?��

$ e ���_� ��$ 3 1 � ��$ ce � g �������M# � ·�.f{Bx �0�<>?�H¦? $ ce 8(� �;<d?2� �@A � ��83��� ��� �;<>?�A�8��¢?�=@H � #.����?��� �� � � �� c � ��$ ce � � } 8 %V � Xdc�� okT@¤ � � c � � � �;� ofTI¤ �=� �� c � �< � � �� � � �< � �� #� �� c � �� � � ��$ ce � � } 8 %V � Xdc � okT@¤ � � � � � c �;� ofTI¤ �=� �� � � �< � � �� c � �< � ��&. � ·�.f{\l �6?BHK?�� 3 � � { � } 3 � 3 1 � Xdc�� � =��¢J �� 3 =��sJ �< 3 =IHK? �;<>? � �¢8 � ��� ��0�=IHKJ��+�IH ��=IA *�?�:����IH�=)�sJ�;<d?"� �¢8 � ��=����I?.� �*B?': ���@H�= � $M��� 3 �r% 0 ' /�HK?�����?': ��83*B?�A�#VE+��a�^f]�^�o`YZi�i\OBaKpdofQ*^la*TIqRQ�Y�^fcROBv2^fc�� }@¸\ U�TIi6OB�@pd^�o£^fq¢iK^fps]0aKPd^f±IO/��QK�dPsOaKTZofpRQK^fTIcsa4Q�T�Y�_�o`YIa\a�TZU�i\OBYI_'QK^fTIcR��v@^�¥psa�^fTIc�OB�@psYZQK^fTIcsa¡^fc2Y�]�pdofQK^f��v@^f]�O/csa�^;TIcsY�o¡vdT@]�Y�^fcStD^fcsY�o�of�It6��[RO/c1Q\[RO�vdTI]MY�^fc ^`aMcRTIQ�aKQ\ij^l_'Qjok�1_'TIcdeIO'�¶Q\[RO�_'O/cdQ\O/i $ 3 1 TZU���]�Y��­cRTIQMqsO�pRcd^`�IpRO'of�vdO/Q\O/i\]�^kcROBvuS5tFTIi�^fcsaKQ�YZcs_'OIt¢_'TIcsa�^`vdO/i�Q\[RO�i\OB_'Q�YVcR¤Ipdo`YZi�vdTI]�Y�^fc ~ $ c ~ Y 7 c t ~ $ � ~ Y�7 � ��^fQ\[u7 c W 7 � S�z�[RO/ct� 3 1 � 7 � YVcsv $ 3 1 ^`a6YZc>��PsTZ^fcdQ6TIc�Q\[RO+o�^kcRO�aKO/¤I]wO/c>Q $ � � 3 ��^fQ\[ ~ $ c ~ Yb7 c � 7 � S4��c9Q�[d^la+vdO/¤IO/cRO/i�YZQ�O_/YIaKOItdY�a¦^k]wPdokO6YZPRPdo�^`_/YZQK^fTIc�TZUnIDYZPdo`YI_'O�K a�]wO/Q\[RT�v�TIc � ¹�.f{/¹ � aK[RTZ��aDTIcdof��Q\[sYZQ�Q\[RO�qRpRqRqdofO4]�psajQ�o£^fO�T@c�Q�[d^lao�^fcRO�aKO/¤I]�O/cdQBS C�TZ�O/e@O/iBtIqd��O'�FYZ]�^kcd^fcR¤�Q�[ROyaKpRquvdTI]�^fcsYZcdQ�_'TIcdQ\iK^fqRpRQK^fTIcsa�Q�T�Q\[RO�^fcdQ\O/¤Ii�Y�os^fc � ¹�.f{/¹ � Y���Y��U�i\TI]�Q\[RO�_'T@c>Q�Y@_'Q#PsTV^kcdQ�aX^fQ�^`a#_�ofOBYZi�Q\[sYVQ � ¹�.f{/¹ � ��^�o�oqsO6YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQj^l_/Y�o£of��a�YZQK^`a � OBvwTIcdof����[RO/c $ �e �6�L3?# 32� S�;� � �l® � �Z�~�~��f«�� ®s���l®;��� �¶� � �,� �9«d�3���f®�3�

� O9cRTZ��YZcsY�of�d�/O � ¹�.f{�p � ��[RO/c6� !}FS6IuO/Q � � ��� c # . . #�� + X�c � q¢O2Y PsYZi�YV]�O/Q\O/iK^f�BYZQK^fTIc TZU�Q\[RO� � {�v@^k]wO/csa�^fTIcsY�o�aKpRiKU�YI_'O 0 ' S�³IpRPRP¢T>aKOMQ\[sYZQ6YZQ4QK^f]�O < �b3 tuQ\[RO�v@^`aKQ�YZcs_'O � ���?# 32� � ~ $����2�G�-$ e ��32� ~^`a6]�^fcd^f]�^f�/OBv­YZQ6YMpRcd^`�IpROMPsTZ^fcdQ $���� e � % 0 ' ��[RO/i\O �@� � e S6z�[RO/ct�YIa�^fc�Q�[RO�_/Y@aKOu� � }RtF^fQ�_/YZc�q¢OaK[RTZ��c�Q�[sYZQ6Q\[RO�]�T@QK^fTIc�TZU�Q\[RO�_'O/cdQ\O/i+TZU�Q\[RO�qRpRqRqdofOIt�^fcnQ�[RO�o�^k]�^kQ � v 3 t¢^la*^fc�Q\[ROMv@^ki�OB_'QK^fTIc­TZU�Q\[ROeIOB_'Q\T@i $M��� e �`�"$ e ��32� U�TIi < W 3 S

zDT�vdO/iK^feIO�YZcMO'��Pdo�^`_�^fQ N6´ U�T@iQ�[ROyv@^`aKQ�YVcs_'O � � �H<=� qsO/QK��O/O/c $M��� e � YVcsv $ e �H<=� ��O4cRO/OBvMQ\T�O/eZY�ofpsYZQ\OQ\[RO*U�TZo�ofTZ��^fcR¤©ajpRiKU�Y@_'O6^fc>Q�O/¤Ii�Y�o#YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQj^l_/Y�o£of�u°

� + X�c � 8�9 � ckX + � X ��!#"$&%('*),+�- X -1012 �f{ � �� � �� �� � ��r>�� . � x?.f{ �

z�[RO�vdT@]�^fcsYZc>Q�_'TIcdQ\iK^fqRpRQK^fTIcwU�TIi � + X�c YViK^`aKOBa�U�i\TI]¨Q\[RO�i\O/¤Z^fTIcwcROBYZi ���5� e S�z�[RO C�OBa\a¦^lYVc�TZU � ���?#�<=� YVQ � e_/YZc�qsO�v@^`YZ¤@TIcsY�o�^f�/OBv�qd�©_�[RTdT>a�^fcR¤�Q\[RO�PsYVi�YZ]�O/Q\ij^k�BYVQK^fTIc�TZU 0 ' aKps_�[(Q\[sYZQ4OBYI_�[ � - tdU�TIi � � { # . . # � � {It

}R{

Page 22: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

_'TIi\i�OBaKPsTIcsvRa4Q�T�YZi�_�ofO/cR¤IQ\[�Y�ofTIcR¤MTIcRO�TZU�Q\[RO�PRij^kcs_�^fPsY�o�v@^fi\OB_'QK^fTIcsa6PsY@a\a�^fcR¤�Q�[Ri\TIpR¤I[ � e S���c�YZPRPdo�^l_/YVQK^fTIcTZU�Q\[RO�]�pdofQK^f��v@^f]�O/csa�^`T@csY�o IYVPdolY@_'O�K a�]wO/Q\[RT�v � aKO/O@� x\ � Q\[RO/c��I^fO'o`vRa

� + X�c i } { ��8 %V � � � + + X�c 2 � ��� � � � � � X ��! "$ % '*) + -/. X -10�2 # YIa �av 3 . � x?. } �

z�[RO*U�pRcs_'QK^fTIc � � � � � ^`a�vdO � cROBv2Q\T�qsO�Q\[RO6PRi\TRvdps_'Q6TZU � � {yU�YI_'Q�TIi�a�TZU�Q\[RO*U�TIi�]� � � � � � � { � � � ��� c � X�c�� � � { � � � ��� � � X�c � � .�.�. � { � � � ��� + X�c � X�c�� � . � x?.�p �C�O/i\O � - 3 U�TIi � � { # . . # � � {ItgYVi\O�Q\[RO�PRiK^fcs_�^fPsY�o�i�YIv@^�^#TZU_'pRi\eZYZQ\pRi\O�TZU 0 ' YZQ $M��� e � S���c�TIqRQ�Y�^fcd^fcR¤� x?. } � ��O�[sY�eIO9YIa�aKpR]�OBv�Q\[sYZQ�Q�[RO(cRTIcR��vdO/¤IO/cRO/i'YI_'��_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIc � - W�� � U�TIi � � { # . . # � � {([RTZo`vRa/S³IpRqsaKQK^fQ\pRQj^kcR¤ � x?. } � ^fcdQ\T � ¹d.f{�p � ofOBYIvRa4Q\T�Q\[RO*U�TZo�ofTZ��^fcR¤�O'��Pdo�^`_�^fQ�i\OBajpdokQ�S����®��®g���l���l®;� /� �l® �.�Z�~�~��f«(� ®¢���f®� � � �3�"������� ��?4�;<>= ��= � < �63 / $���� e � 8(� �;<>? ���s8����d? ���I8�� � �)�0 ' 0�<>8;:/<�8(��:BA�� �/?���� ��� $ e �L32�a� $ ee E&,<d?���/ � �@H�? �������s?.� ��8;=IA`A�#MA���� � ��83��?���=��sJ�� �IH � vF3 / �;<>? �2� ��83����'��;<>?�:'?�� ��?BH��'��;<>? ��������A£?�8!�©83�;�;<>?�JI8;H¦?': ��83��� �'� $M��� e � � $ ee =��¢J �;<d?9J@8(����=��s:'? � � �H<�� �/= ��8(���?5���;<>?= ��# ���&��� ��8`: ��� �

�� � i ��� � � { �� � � + + Vc 2 � ��� � � � � � X � ! "$ % '*) +�-/. X -1012 . � x?. ¹ �

����=IJIJ@8 ��83����/ �`�H<�� �/= ��8!� ��?��

�wi � � �� � U V � U X � { �� � � + + Xdc 2 � ��� � � � � � X ��! "$ % '*) + -/. X -10,2 . � x?. · �

6?BHK? � 8(��JI? �7�¢?�J ��#

��� }��w/ �V 8 �V� + � { �

8 %V � + + Xdc 2 � � . � x?. x ��1[RO/c�� � }Ft>Q�[RO�i\OBaKpdofQ�a4YZ¤Ii�O/O���^fQ\[�Q\[RT>aKO4^fc�/·RS

b4a�^fcR¤�IYZPdo`YI_'O�K aw]�O/Q\[RTRv­TIc � p?. }�q � t���O(_/YZc­OBaKQK^f]�YVQ\O�Q\[RO�O'�RPsTIcRO/cdQK^`Y�o�of� aj]�Y�o�o�O'^f¤IO/cde�Y�ofpROBawU�TIi�av 3 YIa� - i � 8 V { �

� � � + + X�c 2 � ��� � � � � ! �� � � �6 - # � � X ��!#"$&%('*),+�-/. X -10�2 # � � { # . . # � . � x?.ml �C�O/i\O �6 - ^`a�Q\[RO�pRcd^fQ4qsYIa�^`a�e@OB_'Q\TIi�^fc�Q\[RO $ Q�[- v@^fi\OB_'QK^fTIcStFTIi6Q\[RO N6´ � x?. ¹ � tuaKpRPRPsT>ajO�Q\[sYVQ � � ��32� � � e W ��7'S�z�[ROM_'TZo�olYVPsaKO�QK^f]�O < � ^`a�YZ¤dY�^fcnvdO � cROBv�q>�� � �H< � � � � 7 S tRTIi � v 3 td^fQ�^`a�OBYIaj��Q\TMaK[RTZ�1U�i�TI] � x?. ¹ � Q\[sYZQ < � a\YVQK^`a � OBa

< � i � + c X + 2 � �} � 8 %V � � � e � � { � �

¹ 8 %V ' � � {� e � + X�c,

3 . c {� �43 � � e � )�� � ��! "$ % '*) + - X -1012 . � x?. ¸ �C�O/i\O � � � e � � � + + Xdc 2 � �e � � � � e � X�c YZcsv � � U � ^la4vdO � cROBv�^fc � x?.�p � S��������l« �;� � ³IO/QT� � p(YZcsv2ofO/Q ' q¢O©YZc�O'o�o�^kPsajTZ^`v �¡^kQ�[nq¢TIpRcsvRYZi\� $ �c � p � �4$ �� � ¹ � ��$ �� � } � � {IS³IpRPRPsTdaKO6Q\[sYZQ�Q\[RO�_'O/cdQ\O/i�TZU3Y*qRpRqRqdokO+TZUgi'YIv@^fpsa � 7 � . l�·4^`a�^fcd^fQK^`Y�o�o`�MofTR_/YZQ\OBvMYZQ#Q\[RO�PsTZ^fcdQ �L$ c # $ � # $ � �N�

}I}

Page 23: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

��3?#_3?# 3 . }I· � Sz¡[RO/ctspRcdQK^�o�Q\[RO6qRpRqRqdofO�_'TZo�o`YZPsaKOBa6YV¤>Y�^fcsaKQ 0 ' t>Q�[RO�]�TIQj^kT@c�TZU�Q�[RO�_'O/c>Q\O/i4TZU�Q\[RO6qRpRqRqdofO+^laQ\TZ��YZi�vRa�Q\[RO�_�okTdaKOBaKQ4PsTZ^fcdQ6TIc 0 ' tR��[d^l_�[�^`a ��3�# 3?# } � Sz�[RO+PRiK^fcs_�^kPsY�oi�YIv@^�^�TZU#_'pRi\e�YZQ�pRi\O�YZQ ��3?# 3�# } � YZi\O� c � ¹�. ·�YZcsv � � � ¸�. 3 S ��^fQ\[ � � �L32� � {�. l�·�YZcsv �)� � � ����� tu^fc�tD^k¤¢S�{B}���O�PdofTIQ�Q\[RO�Q\i�YV§¦OB_'Q�TIiK^fOBaofTI¤ c e � { �4<�� eIO/i�aKpsa � � �S<�� � ��76U�TIi�Q\[Ri\O/O(v@^�¥O/i\O/cdQ�eZY�ofpROBa�TZU � S­z�[ROBaKO�Q\i�YV§¦OB_'Q�TIiK^fOBa���O/i\O(_'TI]�PRpRQ�OBvcdpR]�O/iK^`_/Y�o�of�­U�i\TI] � x?. ¹ � psa�^fcR¤�Q\[RO(vd�dcsYZ]�^`_/Y�o�i\O/��a�_/Y�o�^kcR¤�]�O/Q\[RTRv�TZU|� }2l� �S�²�pR]�O/iK^`_/Y�o�eZY�ofpROBa�U�TIi�Q\[ROPsYZi�YV]�O/Q\O/i�a 8 %V YZcsv � psaKOBv�^fc � x�. ¹ � tD��[d^`_\[��O/i�O©_/Y�o`_'pdo`YZQ\OBv U�i\TI] � }?. ¸ � t � }?.f{/¹ � t � }?. }I}�/ � YVcsv � x�. x � tYZi\O�¤Z^feIO/c ^fcnz�YZqdofO©·RS+��c�z�YZqdofO�·M��O�Y�olajT(aK[RTZ� Q\[RO+U�YBe@TIi�YZqdofO�_'TI]wPsYZiK^`aKTIc�q¢O/QK�O/O/c�Q\[RO�YIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`__'TZo�o`YZPsaKO�QK^f]�O � x?. ¸ � YZcsv%Q\[RO�_'T@i\i\OBaKP¢TIcsv@^fcR¤�c>pR]�O/ij^l_/Y�o#i\OBaKpdofQy_'T@]�PRpRQ\OBvMU�i\TI] � x?. ¹ � StD^fcsY�o�of�Itu��O�i\O/]MYZi\±MQ\[sYZQ�Q\[RO�vdO/Q�O/i\]�^fcsYZQK^fTIc�TZU�Q\[RO6OB�@pd^£o�^fqsij^kpR] qRpRqRqdofO�_'O/c>Q�O/i $ �e PRi\T�_'O/OBvRa6Y@a�^fcQ\[ROT� � }M_/YIaKO�_'TIcsa¦^lvdO/i�OBv�^fc ��·RS }RS4³IpRPRP¢T>aKOMQ\[sYZQ4Q\[RO�_'O/cdQ\O/i $ 3 1 TZU#Q�[RO�o`YZi�¤IOBaKQ�aKPR[RO/i\O�Q\[sYVQy_/YZc�q¢O^fcsa\_'iK^fqsOBv ��^fQ\[d^fc ' ^la4pRcd^`�@pRO'of�nvdO/Q\O/i\]�^fcROBvuS�z¡[RO/ctuq>��psa�^fcR¤&IYZPdo`YI_'O�K a*]�O/Q\[RTRv(T@c � ¹�.f{/¹ � ^kQ�U�TZo�okTZ��aQ\[sYZQ $��e ^`a�ofTR_/YZQ\OBv�YZQ�YZc&g ���_� v@^`aKQ�YVcs_'O�Y���YB��U�i\T@] $ 3 1 S tRTIi�^fcsaKQ�YZcs_'OIt_'T@csa�^`vdO/i�Q\[RO�_/YIaKO6TZU�QK��TI��PsTZ^fcdQ_'TIcdQ�YI_'Q�YZcsv+ofO/Q5� � pFS�z¡[RO/ct $ �e ^`a�okTR_/YZQ\OBv�Y�okT@cR¤�Q\[RO�_�[RTIi�v���§¦TZ^fcd^fcR¤�Q\[RO4_'TIc>Q'YI_'Q#P¢TZ^fc>Q�a�S#W�TIi\O/TZeIO/iBt^fc9YZcsY�okT@¤I����^fQ\[ � ·?.f{B· � t>��O6TIqRQ'Y�^fc�U�i\TI] � ¹d.f{/¹ � YZcsv � x?. } � Q\[sYVQ

� c i � 3 1 � �¸ 8 %V ofTI¤ � ' { � � 3 1 ��� + � 2c{ � � 3 1 ��� + c 2c ) ' { � � 3 1 ��� + � 2�{ � � 3 1 ��� + c 2� )�� # � � � } � 3 1 � � c . � x?.�q �

C�O/i\O � + 3 2- ^`a�Q\[RO � Q\[ PRiK^fcs_�^fPsY�oi�YIv@^fpsa�TVUg_'pRi\e�YZQ�pRi\O�TZU 0 ' YVQ�Q\[RO�_'TIcdQ�YI_'Q�PsTV^kcdQ � 3 YZcsv � c ^`a�Q\[RO�v@^`aKQ�YZcs_'OY�ofTIcR¤ ��U�i\T@]�Q\[RO�_'TIcdQ�YI_'Q�P¢TZ^fc>Q�YVQ � c Q\T�Q\[RO�_'O/c>Q�O/i $ �e TZU�Q�[RO�OB�@pd^£o�^fqRiK^`pR] qRpRqRqdofO�aKTZofpRQK^fTIcS

� � �,�`���2�3�����l®;���ofQ\[RTIpR¤I[­Q�[RO�]�O/Q'YIaKQ�YZqd^�o�^fQK�ni\OBajpdokQ'a6^fc ��¹I��x%PsO/i\Q'Y�^fc­TIcdof��Q\T(Q�[RO���o�okO/cR�Km�YZ[Rc OB�@psYZQK^fTIct���O�YZcR�

QK^`_�^fPsYZQ\OMQ\[sYZQ6Y�a�^f]�^�o`YZi6U�TIi\]�Y�oYIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQK^`_�YZcsY�of�Ra�^`a�_/YZc qsO�vdTIcRO�Q\T�O'�RPdo�^`_�^kQjok�­_�[sYZi�YI_'Q\O/ij^k�/OwQ\[RO�a�ofTZ�qRpRqRqdofO�]�TIQK^fTIc2U�TIi+Q\[RO�mYV[RcR�HC�^�o�o�^�YZi�v OB�IpsYZQj^kT@c YZcsv9U�TIi6Q�[RO�e@^`a\_'TIpsawmYZ[RcR�HC¡^�o£o�^`YZi�v OB�IpsYVQK^fTIct�^fc>Q�i\TI�vdps_'OBvM^fc�� } 3 �S�³Ips_\[(YVc©YZcsY�ok�Ra�^`a��T@pdolv�_'T@]�PdofO/]�O/c>Q4Q\[RO4iK^f¤ITIi\T@psa�i\OBaKpdofQ�a�TVU � }\ uYZcsvw��p\ �td��[d^`_\[�PRi\TZeIOBvQ\[RO+O'�>^`aKQ\O/cs_'O�TZU#a�ofTZ� qRpRqRqdofO�]�TIQj^kT@c�U�TIi�Q\[RO�mYV[RcR�HC�^�o�o�^�YZi�v�OB�@psYZQK^fTIcS

�4cRTIQ\[RO/i�Q�TIPd^`_MU�TIi�U�pRi\Q\[RO/iw^kcdeIOBaKQj^k¤dYZQK^fTIc�^`aMQ\TnYZcsY�of�d�/O(Q\[RO�]�TIQK^fTIc�TZU�Q\[RO�qRpRqRqdokO TIcs_'O�^fQM[sYIaqsOB_'T@]�O�YZQ\Q'YI_\[ROBv�Q\T�Q�[RO�q¢TIpRcsvRYZi\�IS�µ�OB_/Y�o�o�Q\[sYZQ6Q\[RO�i\OBaKpdofQ�ay^fc �\¹I��xMYZi\O�e�Y�o�^`v TIcdof�9pRcdQK^�o#Q\[RO�qRpRqRqdofOqsO/¤V^kcsa4Q�T�_'TZo�o`YZPsaKO�YZ¤dY�^fcsaKQ 0 ' SatRT@i�Q\[RO�QK��TI��v@^f]�O/csa�^fTIcsY�o_/YIaKOItR��O�cRTZ��ajPsOB_'pdo`YZQ\O�T@c�Q\[RO��@psY�o�^fQ�YZQK^feIOqsO/[sY�e@^fTIi6TZU�Q\[RO�aKpRqsaKOB�@pRO/c>Q6]wTIQK^fTIcS�zT�a�YZQK^`a�U���Q\[RO�²�O/pR]MYZcRc�qsTIpRcsvRYZi��9_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIc�YZcsv%Q\T�]�^fcd^f]�^f�/OQ\[RO(aKpRijU�YI_'O�O/cRO/i�¤I� YZQ�Y�¤Z^feIO/c­QK^f]�OIt�Q�[RO�qRpRqRqdokO�^fcdQ\O/iKU�YI_'O(]�psaKQ+^fc>Q�O/i�aKOB_'Q 0 ' YZQ�iK^f¤I[dQ�YZcR¤ZofOBa�YVcsvaK[RTIpdo`v�q¢O�YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQK^`_/Y�o�of��_�ofT>aKO�Q\TwQ\[RO�YZi�_6TVUY�_�^ki'_�okOwQ\[sYZQ4O/cs_�okTdaKOBa6Q\[RO�i\OB�@pd^fi\OBv�]�Y@a\a/S�z¡[RO�qRpRqRqdofOaK[RTIpdo`v�Q\[RO/c�]�TZeIOMTIcnY%U�YIaKQ�Qj^k]wO©a\_/Y�okOM^fc�Q\[RO�v@^ki�OB_'QK^fTIc ��[RO/i�O�Q\[ROM]�YZ¤@cd^kQ�psvdO�TZU�Q\[RO�_'pRi\e�YVQ\pRi\Ow^la^fcs_'i\OBYIa�^fcR¤�Q�[RO�]wT>aKQBS�z�[d^`a6PRi\TR_'OBa\a�vdOB_'i\OBYIajOBa6Q\[RO�ajpRiKU�Y@_'O�O/cRO/i\¤I��YZcsv�aj[RTIpdo`vn_'TIcdQK^fcdpRO�pRc>Qj^£o�YwofT�_/Y�o]�^fcd^f]�pR]!TZU#Q\[RO�aKpRijU�YI_'O�O/cRO/i\¤@��^`a6YZQ\Q�Y�^kcROBvuS�³Ips_\[�Yw]�^fcd^k]�pR] PRi\OBaKpR]MYZqdof�9TR_/_'pRi�a4cROBYZi�Ywi\O/¤Z^fTIc�TZU0 ' ��[RO/i�O�Q\[ROw]�YZ¤Icd^fQ\psvdOMTZUQ�[RO�_'pRi\e�YVQ\pRi\OM[sYIa�YwofTR_/Y�o]�Y��>^f]�pR](S���U 0 ' _'TIcdQ�Y�^fcsa�aKTI]�O�ajO/¤I]�O/cdQ�a��[RO/i\O�Q\[RO�_'pRi\e�YZQ�pRi\O�^`a#_'TIcsajQ�YZcdQBtZQ\[RO�qRpRqRqdofO4]�TIQK^fTIc�Y�okT@cR¤ 0 ' ]�Y���q¢OB_'TI]�O�aKQ�ps_\±�YZcsv�YZc�YIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_]�O/Q�Y@aKQ�YZqd^�o�^fQ¦��YZcsY�of�Ra�^`a4]�Y���qsO�i\OB�@pd^fi\OBvuS#��Q���TIpdo`v%qsO���TIi�Q\[>��[d^£ofO�Q\T�O'�sYZ]�^fcRO+Q\[ROBaKO6^`a\ajpROBa�^kc�vdO/Q�Y�^�o�StD^fcsY�o�of�ItR��O�i\O/]MYZi\±�TIc�YZc�^fcdQ\O/i\OBaKQK^fcR¤�_'TI]�PsYViK^`aKTIcMqsO/QK��O/O/c�Q\[RO�O'^k¤@O/c>eZY�ofpRO6PRi\TIqdofO/] � p?.f{ � YZcsvwQ\[ROO'^f¤IO/cde�Y�ofpRO�PRi\TIqdofO/] Q\[sYZQ�^`a�Y@a\aKTR_�^lYVQ\OBv���^fQ\[MQ\[RO6O'�d^fQ�QK^f]�O6qsO/[sY�e@^fTIi�U�TIi�Y�h�i\TZ��cd^`YZc�PsYVi\QK^`_�ofO�_'TIc � cROBv^fc(Y�vdTI]MY�^fc ' q>�MY6PsT@Q\O/c>Qj^lY�o���O'o£o P � ajO/OR�f{�¸\ � S�zT�vdO/Q\O/i\]�^kcRO+Q\[RO4O'��P¢OB_'Q\OBv�QK^f]�O�U�TIi#Q\[d^`a�PsYVi\QK^`_�ofO6Q\T

}�p

Page 24: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

ofOBY�eIO ' tR��O6]�psaKQ�_/Y�o`_'pdo`YZQ\O+U�TIi � v 3 tRQ�[RO6PRiK^fcs_�^kPsY�oO'^f¤IO/cRPsY�^fi � e t � e TZU�Q\[RO�tRTI±d±IO/i\����olYVcR±�OB�IpsYZQj^kT@c�=� ��� � � �TP ��� # $&%�'E( * + ��35# $�% 0 ' . � l:.f{ ��6a\aKpR]�O�Q\[sYZQ P [sYIa4Q�[RO6U�TIi\] PE�bP � ~ $Z�"$ e ~ U�TIi6aKTI]�O $ e %�' YVcsv�Q\[sYZQ PZ��32�a�b3 YZcsv P Q � � � W 3U�TIi � W 3 S�h��(aKO/Q\Qj^kcR¤ � � X��*� + � % 2 � ^fc � l2.f{ � td��O6TIqRQ�Y�^fc�Y�PRi\TIqdofO/]�eIO/i\��a�^f]�^�o`YZi4^fc�U�TIi\]�Q�T � p?.f{ �

� % � � �=� �@� � � � �_� ��������# $ %�' ���435# $�% 0 'b# � l:. }]/ �� � � �_� �b� � X�c¹ � P Q � � � � � {

} ! P Q Q � � �M� � � � { � � X�c P Q � � � # # � � ~ $��-$ e ~ . � l:. }]7 �²�TZ� a�^fcs_'O

�� e � � X��*� + � % 2 a\YVQK^`a � OBa � % �� e � 3 t¢^`a6TZU�TIcRO�a�^f¤Ict�YZcsv9U�Y�^�o`a6Q�T(a\YZQK^`a�U���Q\[RO�qsT@pRcsvRYZi\�

_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIc�q>�MTIcdof��O'�RPsT@cRO/c>QK^`Y�o�of�9aj]�Y�o�oQ\O/i\]�a/t@^fQ�U�TZo�ofT��4a�Q\[sYZQ � e � �� e � � td��[RO/i�O � ^`a�Y+qsT@pRcsvRYZi\�

o`Y��IO/i�U�pRcs_'QK^fTIcS�³Z^fcs_'O P ^`a�i�YIv@^`Y�o�of�9aK�d]�]�O/Q�iK^`_�YZq¢TIpRQ $ e tdQ\[RO�O/i\i�TIi�]�YIvdO6^fc(a\YVQK^`a�U��@^fcR¤�Q�[RO�qsT@pRcsvRYZi\�_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIcw^`a�]�Y��d^f]�^f�/OBv�YZQ�Q\[sYZQ�PsTV^kcdQ $ � % 0 ' ��[d^l_�[w^la�_�ofT>aKOBaKQ�Q\T $ e S��1qsTIpRcsvRYVi\�+olY��IO/i�YZcsY�of�Ra�^`a�U�TIi� e Q\[RO/c�ofOBYIvRaXQ\T6Q\[RO�OBajQK^f]�YZQ\O � e � g ����� � X %('*) � +�-/. 2 � ��[RO/i\O � � � ~ $ � �R$ e ~ � aKO/O �f{B¸\ � S�z�[RO/i\O'U�TIi\OItdQ\[ROPsYZi\Qj^l_�ofO4^`a�]wT>aKQ�o�^f±IO'of�MQ\T�O'�d^fQ 0 ' YZQ $ � YZcsv�Q\[RO�O'��P¢OB_'Q\OBvMQK^f]�O�U�TIi�O'�>^fQ�^`a g � � X�ce � S�z�[d^`a�OBaKQK^f]�YVQ\O�U�TIi� e ^`a#�@psY�o�^fQ�YZQK^feIO'of��a�^f]�^�olYViQ�T�Q\[RO�OBajQK^f]�YZQ\O � x?.ml � Q\[sYZQ���YIa�vdO/iK^feIOBvwU�TIi�Q\[RO�qRpRqRqdokO�ajTZofpRQK^fTIcSz¡[RO/i\O'U�T@i\OItY�ofQ\[RTIpR¤@[nQ\[ROwc>pR]�qsO/i+TZU�O'��P¢TIcRO/cdQK^`Y�o�ok�­aK]�Y�o£o�O'^f¤IO/c>eZY�ofpROBa�U�TIi � p�.f{ � YZcsv � l:. } � v@^�¥3O/i�t�T@pRi�_'TIcs_�ofpsa�^fTIcQ\[sYZQ6Q�[RO�qRpRqRqdofO���^�o�o]wT�e@O6^fc�Q\[RO�v@^fi\OB_'Qj^kT@cnTZU�Q\[RO�_�ofT>aKOBaKQ+PsTZ^fcdQ�TIc 0 ' TZeIO/i�YZc�O'�RPsTIcRO/cdQK^`Y�o�of��ofTIcR¤QK^f]�O�a\_/Y�ofO�[sYIa4Y�csYZQ�pRi�Y�o�_'TIi�i\OBaKPsT@csvdO/cs_'O���^fQ\[9a¦^k]�^£o`YZi6q¢O/[sY�eI^fTIi�^fc9Q�[RO6O'�>^fQ\��QK^f]�O�PRi\T@qdokO/]�S����`�u® � �f«R¯ � ��«��s�B�

��YZ] ¤Ii�YZQ\O'U�pdo�Q\T��Xi\TZU\S�N�S��4psaKQK^fct�Xi\TZU\S��RS#h4S� 4O'o�ofO/i(YZcsv��Xi\TZU\S�µ*S#W%^kpRi'Y�U�TIi�aKTI]�O�eZY�ofpsYZqdofOv@^`a\_'psa\a�^fTIcsa*TIc�Q\[RO6]�YVQ\O/iK^`Y�o^fc�/·RS }RS����T@pdolv�Y�o`aKTwo£^f±IO+Q\T�Q\[sYVcR±©N4iBSdI�Ssµ�O/�dcsY�U�TIi�[d^`a4_'TI]�]�O/cdQ�a�YVcsv��i�TZUjS�²�SR��o�^f±�YZ±ITda�U�TIi4aKO/csv@^fcR¤�]�O6[d^`a4PRi\O/PRiK^fc>Q'a/S� ��«��¯ � � ����&����`� � �l�R��� ���1� �g«��Z�~�~��f«� ��s¯`� ��

z¡[RO�i'YIv@^fpsa4��7�TZU�Q�[RO�_/YZcRTIcd^`_/Y�o#qRpRqRqdofO�aKTZofpRQK^fTIc�� 7k� ~ $��-$ e ~ � u^`a6vdO/Q\O/i\]�^kcROBv YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQK^`_/Y�o�of��^fcQ\O/i\]Ma�TVU�Q\[ROM]�YIa\a A q>� A i f 9 � 7 >2$ S�IuO/Q ' V YVcsv ' X vdO/cRT@Q\O�Q\[RO�aKpRqRi\O/¤Z^fTIcsawTZU ' Q�[sYZQ�YZi\OTIpRQ�a¦^lvdO � ^�S¢OIS �TW � 7 � YZcsvM^fcsa�^`vdO � ^�S¢OIS �ZY � 7 � Q\[RO+qRpRqRqdokOItDi\OBaKP¢OB_'QK^feIO'of�ISyzDT�YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQK^`_/Y�o�of�(O/eZY�ofpsYZQ\OQ\[RO+]�YIa\a�_'T@csaKQ\i�Y�^fcdQ�^fQ�^`a4_'TIcdeIO/cd^fO/c>Q6Q\TMvdOB_'TI]�PsTdaKO6^fQ6YIa

A i6�LP6�"P X �?� V ���_�;��P X � X ���h� � 8 9$� � 7 �j� V ���_� >:$s� 8 9

'� � 7 �-� X ���_� >:$ . � � .f{ �

C�O/i\O P ^`a#Q�[RO�eITVokpR]wO�TZU ' t P X � � + 7 � + � � ^`a�Q\[RO4eITZofpR]�O4TZU ' X#t � + ^`a�Q\[RO6aKpRiKU�YI_'O6YZi\OBY+TZUQ\[RO4pRcd^kQ����qsY�o�o3YZcsv � [ ���_� ^laX¤Z^feIO/c�^fc � }�.f{B} � SX³Z^fcs_'O�Q\[RO4vdTI]�^fcsYZcdQ_'TIcdQ\iK^fqRpRQK^fTIcsa�Q\T6Q\[RO¡^kcdQ\O/¤Ii'Y�o`a�^fc � �|.f{ � YZij^lajOU�i\TI] Q\[RO�i\O/¤Z^fTIc�cROBYZi4� � ��7�tuQ�[RO�^fcdQ\O/¤Ii�Y�ola6_/YVc9q¢O�O/e�Y�okpsYVQ\OBv�U�TIi � vF3 psa�^fcR¤ � }?. } 3 7 � S4³IpRqsaKQK^fQ\pRQK^fcR¤� }?. } 3 7 � YZcsv � }?.l{B} � ^fc>Q\T � � .f{ � tRYZcsv%i\O/Q�Y�^fcd^fcR¤�Q\O/i\]Ma�TZU�TIi�vdO/i � t¢��O6TIqRQ�Y�^fc�Q\[sYZQA i4P U�V ��P X � U]X � U�V �� � � ! c P X � 8 X �V � 8 X �X � �-! c�8 X �V P � � + � + X�c7 � � X � � V � � . � � . } �C�O/i\O ! c ^`a�vdO � cROBv%^fc � }?. ¸ � YZcsv � [ W 3 ^`a�vdO � cROBv�qd�

� V � 8 +e ��U V �"� e � � � > � # � X � 8 eX + � � e � � � � U X > � # � � .�p �}Z¹

Page 25: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

��[RO/i\O � e � � � ^`a�¤Z^feIO/c�^fc � }?.�p � S�zDT�TIqRQ�Y�^kc� 7 �L�_� ^fc�Q\O/i\]�a�TVU A ��O6O'�RPsYZcsv

��7 � � e 7 �"� � c 7 � g ��� � � . � � . ¹ �³IpRqsaKQK^fQ\pRQj^kcR¤ � � . ¹ � ^fc>Q\T � � . } � YZcsv�_'TZo�okOB_'Qj^kcR¤�PsTZ��O/i�a�TZU � t¢��O � csv�Q\[sYZQ

� e 7 � { �� + � { P U V �-AU V � U X � � c � + # � c 7 �b� � e 7� U V � U X � � ! ec 8 X �V { PP eX � ��� � # � �|. ·]/ �

��[RO/i\O P eX YZcsv � YZi\O�vdO � cROBv�qd�P eX � � Xdc

� + � � e 7 � + # �&��! ec � 8 X �X � 8 X �V �;� �� e 7 � � V � � X � . � � . ·�7 �

C�O/i\O ! ec ^`a�¤Z^feIO/c�q>�MQ\[RO+iK^f¤I[>Q4a�^`vdO�TVU � }�. ¸ � pRPsTIc�i\O/Pdo`YI_�^fcR¤ � 7#q>� � e 7 S M�4���� M�4��&��*��f{k �²+SI��o�^f±�YZ±ITda/t ��S���S>h�YZQ\OBa/t ��S�tFpsa\_'Tst �uA���0�7�� ��83��� ���IH �;<>?��#=Z< �%$ 68`A;A�8`=@H¦J � ���d= ��83���(83� � �s? � �R=I:'?

� 83��?.���/8��)�st �RSuN�^�¥O/iBS#´#�@psYZQK^fTIcsa q 3 t � {�q�qR{ � tdPRPSs¸R{/�\{�p@·RS� }\ �²+Su��o£^f±ZYZ±IT>a/t���S;tRpsa\_'Tst �gA���0 � # �s=���8;:�� ���IH �;<>?��#=V< ��$ y8;A`A�8;=IHKJ � ���d= ��8��)� 83� y8��Z<d?BH � ��= ��8;=IA � 8($��?.���/8����%��/��=IH���� � �R?�:���HK=IA � ����8���= ��?5� t�mYVi\i�µ�O/PsT@i\Q�a*^fc W�YZQ\[RO/]MYZQK^`_/Y�o �X[>�Ra�^`_/a/t#b�cd^feIO/i�a�^fQK��TZUµ¡TI]�OIt � {�q�q�p � S��p\ �²+Su��o£^f±ZYZ±IT>a/t���S;tRpsa\_'Tst �gA���0 � # �s=���8;:�� ���IH �;<>?��#=V< ��$ y8;A`A�8;=IHKJ � ���d= ��8��)� 83� y8��Z<d?BH � ��= ��8;=IA � 8($��?.���/8����%��/���=IH�� �� ,<>?�7�� ��8��)� �'��� � �.�/A�?��/tRPRi\O/PRij^kcdQBt � {�q�q]p � S� ¹� �b+S4�ya�_\[RO/iBt+µ6S+m#[RiK^`aKQK^`YZcsaKO/ct�µ*Syµ¡psa\aKO'o�o�t���IA;A ��:�= ��8���� � �'����0�=IHK? ���IH�� �����sJI=IH # *�=IA��>? ��� ��� ��/W�YZQ�[Sum#TI]�PS p�pRt � {�q2l q � tdPRPSsx@·�qZ��x2l qFS� ·\ ��S���SIh�YZQ\OBa/t �RS ��S���pRct¢7�? ��= ����= �/A�?��= �(��?�H��%� ���IH��;<>?��#=V< ��$ y8;A`A�8;=IHKJ � ���d= ��83���st �RSIN�^�¥#SI´#�@psYZQK^fTIcsa{@{I{It � {�q�qZ¹ � t@PRPSs¹d}R{/��¹>·2ldS� x\ �²+S�hXokO'^`aKQ�O'^kc�t479= �;<d?���= ��8;:�=IA�79?��;< �BJ ��� �IH­G�=�*B?���<>?�� ����?��s=@t�m#T@]�PRpRQ\O/iM³>_�^fO/cs_'O2YVcsv���PRPdo�^fOBvW�YZQ�[RO/]�YZQK^`_/a*³IO/iK^fOBa/tu�y_/Y@vdO/]�^`_ �Xi\OBa\a/t iKo`YZcsvdTst � {�q@¸Z¹ � S�ml� |IXS>h�i\TIcsa\YVi�vutRN�S:C¡^£of[RTIi'aKQBt � � �;<>? �uA���0 � # �s=���8;:�� � �@H �;<>?���=Z< ��$ y8;A;A£8;=IHKJ � ���d= ��8��)�(83� � �s? � �R=I:'?� 83��?.���/8��)�st �Xi\T�_ZS�µ�TZ�IS�³ITR_ZS I3TIcsvdTIc(��t¢r�TZo�S#¹:p]qRt � {�q�qI} � tdPRPSsxIx�qZ��x@¸I}RS� ¸\ |IXS�h#i�TIcsa\YZi�vut6h4S�³IQ\TIQ\[t����IA�� ��?��HK?5� ?�H�*�8�����7�?�=)����dH�*�= ���>HK?��#A���0 = ��=���8���8�� � �2=�� ����� � $:'=IA ��8���!5�5�>H��"�=��¢JI=�� � �.�>= ��8����¢t�mYZi\cRO/¤V^kO�W�O'o�ofTIcnb�cd^ke@O/i�a�^fQK�9µ�OBaKOBYVi�_\[�µ�O/P¢TIi\Q�²�TsSMqZ¹I��²���� 3�3 ¸Rt� {�q�qZ¹ � S��q\ |IXS�h�i\TIcsa\YVi�vut6h�S ��O/Q\Q\T@ct �#� ����?BH'8`:'=IA*79? �;<��BJ&� �@H ,RHK=I: �Z8����$� �>H *B?��6? ��0 �IH ����7���*B83� � 0�8 �;<� �>H *B= ���dHK?�7�� ��83���stRQ�T�YZPRPsOBYViBt � {�q�qI· � t �FSum#TI]�PS ��[d��a/S�f{ 3 �FS�mYZ[Rct �RSNC�^�o�o�^`YZi�vut��uHK?�? � �s?�H���#��'�(=�� ����$�% �¢8 ���IH � � #.����?���E � E ��� ��?�H(�/=I:B8;=IA �gHK?'? � �s?BH��)#�t �RSm�[RO/](S �X[>�Ra/S#}@¸Rt � {�q@·I¸ � tdPRPSs}I·@¸Z��}Ix2l>S�f{I{k �FSumYZi\i�tsµ6S ��O/¤IT¢tu79?���= � ��=��/A�?&�= �(��?�H��%��8�� � �@A � ��83����� �'� ������� � � � � � � �L�M� t¢m#TI]w](S���pRi�O��4PRPdo�SW�YZQ�[S�¹>}Rt � {�qI¸�q � t>PRPS¢·I}�pZ��·2lZxRS�f{B}\ �m4SsW�Ss´�o�o�^fTIQBtuN�SR��SdtRi\O/cs_�[t'� ����?�H�8;:'=IA � ���dJI8;?��2�'� �;<>?"�#=V< ��$ y8;A`A�8;=IHKJ � �.�>= ��83���2���IH(�#<>= �/? �u?1��= $HK= ��83���¢ts�KW(� �RS¢��PRPdo�S�W�YZQ\[S�r�TZo�SapI¸Rt � {�qI¸2l � t>PRPSdq2lB�\{B}I¸FS�f{�p\ ��S;tRpsa\_'T¢t �RS;C�Y�okOIt �uA���017 � ��8���� 79=)�s8 � �IA�J / � �IH ��=�� � ���%� ��= ��8`A�8���#�=)�sJ �u8������dA�=IH&�?BH����dH ��= ��83���st �RSN4�dcsYZ]�^`_/a6YZcsv�N�^�¥XS�´#�@psYZQK^fTIcsa+{It � {�q@¸�q � tdPRPSMl�·V�HqZ¹sS

}I·

Page 26: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

�f{/¹� �W�S �yYZ¤IOIt � �­=�� �6HK?�= $ �HK?5� ?�H�*�8���� � *��IA�� ��8����&���IH���A£=)�s?���dH�*�?��/t�m#TIcdQ\O/]�PS�W�YZQ\[S(·R{@t � {�q@¸Ix � tPRPSu·R{/��x@}RS�f{B·\ �m4S���i�YZcdQBt �gA���0 7 � ��83��� 8�� � �s?5$ � 8���?��%� 83���¢=IA��#=Z< �%$�7��IH�HK?�A � #.����?����/t6³I���6W �FS�W9YVQ\[S���csY�o�Sr�TVo�Su}Ix�²�TsS{@t � {�q�q@· � tdPRPSs}R{/�HpV¹sS�f{Bx\ �m4Ssm4S C4a�^fpRcR¤st ���#8;H � � ��)�>H � ?�83� � 8 � ?BHK?�� ��8`=IA ��?�����?���H�#Zt*��^�ofO/����cdQ\O/i�a\_�^fO/cs_'OM³IO/iK^fOBa�^fc �XpRi\OyYVcsv�4PRPdo�^fOBvnW�YZQ\[RO/]MYZQK^`_/a/ts²�O/� ��T@i\± � {�qI¸R{ � S�f{\l� �W�S 4p>��YZ]�pRi�YFtI³sS���SZ´�^�tIW�SBW%^f]�pRi'YRt��R?BH # �gA���0 � # �¢=���8`:5� � �IH � ����?���?�=I:���8��)��$ � 8 � ���/83��� � #.� ��?.� �� � �;<>? �4:���8�*�= ���IH $ ���F<>8 ��8 ���@H�,�#/��?5/ �IYVPsYZc �RS¢��csvdpsajQBS#�4PRPdo�S�W�YZQ\[S qRt � {�q�qI} � tdPRPSMpI·Z�Ll�ldS�f{B¸\ �h4S �RSW�YZQ�±ITZ��aK±d�It�|�S³>_�[dpsa\a/t ,D<>? � ��8�� ��H'� �/A�?�� ���IH��=)�sJ�����A�# ��?BH����>H���?�J � # �¢=���8`:'=IA � #.� ��?.��� t³I���yW �RSR�4PRPdo�SgW�YZQ�[S�r�TZo�Snp]p�²�T¢Ss}Rt � {�q2l�l � t@PRPSnp@xI·Z�HpI¸I}FS�f{�q\ �FSg²�O/ptgb�cRPRpRqdo�^`aK[ROBvn²�TIQ\OBa�S� } 3 6��S�²�TZeI^`_�±>�Km�TI[RO/ct � � �;<>?���8!�/:����)� �#=Z< �%$ 68`A;A�8`=@H¦J � ���d= ��83���stD^fc�J£W�YZQ�O/iK^`Y�o��csaKQ�YZqd^�o�^fQK^fOBa�^fc�m#TIcR�Qj^kcdpRpR]!W�OB_\[sYVcd^l_/a6YVcsv�µ�O'o`YZQ\OBv�W�YZQ\[RO/]�YZQj^l_/Y�o �Xi\TIqdofO/]�akKft � �RSsh�Y�o�o�OBvuS � t �dU�T@i�v�³>_�^fO/cs_'O �XpRqdo£^f�_/YVQK^fTIcsa/tDm�o`YZi\O/csvdTIc ��i�OBa\a/t � {�qI¸I¸ � tdPRPS�p@}�qZ�HpZ¹>}FS� }R{k �z*S [dQ�YRtdWnSZW%^f]�pRi'YRt��= �(��?�H�� � # �¢=���8`:5��83� � �Z:B8���= �/A�?��?'=I:���8����%$ � 8 � ���/8��)�M79?'JI8`=@t�^kc@J tFTIi\]�YVQK^fTIctN4�dcsYZ]�^`_/a�YZcsv ³IQ�YZQK^`aKQK^`_/aMTZU ��YVQ\Q\O/i\csakKlt�r�TZo�S { � �S 6Y��¡Y@a\YZ±@^yO/Q�Y�o�Sft�OBvRa�S � t ��TIijolv ³>_�^fO/cdQK^ � _Zt� {�q�q 32� t>PRPSu·I·Z�\{@{B}RS� }I}\ |IXS ��SRµ�O/�dcsYRtuWnS �RS �nYVi�vutu79?���= ����= �/A�? ��� ��?�H��¢=IA �=�#Z?BH � # �¢=���8`:5� � �@H �;<>?���8(�/:��)�����#=Z< �%$ 68`A;A�8`=@H¦J� ���d= ��83���st¢Q\T�YZPRP¢OBYZiBtuW�O/Q\[RT�vRa4YZcsv%��PRPdo�^`_/YZQK^fTIcsa*TZU��4csY�of�Ra�^`a � {�q�qI· � S� }�p\ |IXS���SBµ�O/�dcsYRtdWnS�RS��nYZi�vut���?����IA�*B83� ��G�?'= � ��� ��?�H��¢=IA �3=)#�?�H ��� ��?�H¦=@: ��83����� � �IH �;<>?&��83� !����dH � $ �=��¢JI=��� ���d= ��83���stu´�pRi\T@PsOBYZc �RSR�4PRPdo�S�W�YZQ\[S�r�TZo�Ss·Ft ��YZi\Q�¹¢t � {�q�qZ¹ � t>PRPS¢¹:qI·V��·I}�pRS� }Z¹� �FS�µ�pRqd^fcsaKQ\O'^;ct ��S�³IQ�O/i\c>q¢O/i\¤st � ���¢A ��:�=@A��?'=I: ��83����$ � 8 � �)� 83��� � ���d= ��83�����M=��sJ�� �d:BA�?�= ��8����¢t�KW(� �RS�4PRPdo�S�W�YZQ\[S�r�TZo�S�¹>¸Rt � {�q]qI} � tdPRPSu}Z¹:qZ��}IxV¹sS� }I·\ �FS�µ�pRqd^fcsaKQ\O'^fc�t ��S�³IQ�O/i\c>q¢O/i\¤st��RS�h�S 4O'o�okO/i�t �gH'��� � ��� ��?BHK=I:���8����­=)�sJ�� �)�R< ���2� �I?��¢?��)��� � ���d8`A�8��/H'8`=���IH4,RH'8(����= �/A�?��?'=I: ��83���%$ � 8 � �)�/8���� � ���d= ��83�����/t�³I���6W �RS���PRPdo�S6W�YZQ\[S¨r�TZo�S�·�p­²�TsS�xFt � {�q]q�p � tPRPS�{BxIx]qZ�\{BxI¸I·FS� }Ix\ |IXSGt�SX³I[sYZ]�Pd^fcROIt�WnS �S���TIi�vdT@ct � ��� � � ��?�H � �IA�� ��8��)� �'� � HKJI83�s=@H�# � 8 � ?�HK?�� ��8;=IA � �.�>= ��8����%��/4�;<>?� �s8���8`=IA��R=IA��>?���H'� �/A�?���t ��S C+SMtRi\O/O/]�YVc(PRpRqdo�^`aK[RO/i�a/t�³>YZcwtRi�YVcsa�^`a\_'T � {�q2l�· � S� }2l� �W�S��RS �nYZi'vut#7�? ��= ����= ��A£?���= �(��?BH ��� / �=�#Z?�H ��@A`A�=��+�/?�� /6=��sJ�� �B=IH � ?.�s83� �����IH�= � �¢?�$ � 83��?.���/8��)�s=IA��83� !����dH�� $ �3=)�sJI=�� � ���d= ��8��)�stD³IQ\psv@^fOBa�^kc���PRPdo�SuW�YZQ\[S�r�TZo�SaqR{�²�TsSf{It � {�q�qZ¹ � PRPS¢·R{/�Hq�pRS� }I¸\ �W�S �FS��nYZi�vut � � ����# � � ��� ��8`:���s=IA�#.� 8!��'� � ��:�=@A£8 !/?�J�� �IA�� ��83���%�+���IH ������?���?�=@: ��83����$ � 8 � �)� 83����7��BJI?�A �83��7 �dA ��8($ � 83��?����/83���s=IA � ����=I8��%� tuaKpRqR]�^fQ\Q�OBvut�³IQ\psv@^fOBa�^kc���PRPdo�SW�YZQ\[�¹ qI· � } 3 PsYV¤IOBa � S

}Ix

Page 27: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

� 8 %V � cdpR](S � 8 %V � YIaj�IS � 8 %V � c>pR](S � 8 %V � Y@aK�IS �3 S 3 }I· {@S ¸Ix 3 · {IS ¸@x 3 x {IS ¸I·Z¹¢{ {IS ¸I·V¹>·3 S 3 l�· {@S ¸Z¹?l�x {IS ¸V¹>¸�p {IS ¸I}Ix@¸ {IS ¸I}]q�q3 Sl{B}I· {@S ¸�pZ¹ 3 {IS ¸]pIx 3 {ISml qIx@x {IS ¸ 3 ·�p3 Sl{B·R{ {@S ¸I}IxIx {IS ¸@}�qIx {ISml�l q@¸ {ISml q@}I·3 Sl{\l�· {@S ¸R{�qIx {IS ¸@}�p2l {ISml�x�p@x {ISml�¸ 3 l3 Sl{�q�q {@S ¸R{B}Z¹ {IS ¸F{\l�¸ {ISmlB¹>x@x {ISml�x@¸�q���s~��f« � �° m#TI]�PsYZij^lajTIc(TZU#YIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_�YZcsv%c>pR]�O/ij^l_/Y�o�eZY�ofpROBa�U�TIi 8 %V ��[RO/c

��7 � {�YZcsv � ����� �L�M� ��^fQ\[wB e � {�. }5.Rz�[RO�ajOB_'TIcsv(YZcsv%Q\[d^fi�v(_'TVokpR]wcsaYZi\O4U�TIi � � }�YVcsv�Q\[RO4U�TIpRi\Q\[�YZcsv � U�Q\[9_'TZofpR]�csa6YVi\O4U�T@i � � p5.

� ! 7 ���h� � cdpR](S � ! 7 �L�_�5� YIaj�IS � ! 7 ���_�5� c>pR](S � ! 7 ���_� � YIaK�IS �3 S 3 }@· 3 S 3 }R{B·]q 3 S 3 }R{BxV¹ 3 S 3 ¹:pR{�p 3 S 3 ¹:p@}I¸3 S 3 lZ· 3 S 3 xZ¹>· 3 S 3 xV¹:q 3 Sf{B}I¸�p 3 Sf{B}�qI¸3 Sf{B}@· 3 Sl{ 3 l 3 3 Sf{ 3 ¸I} 3 S }R{I{�q 3 S }R{BxZ¹3 Sf{B·F{ 3 Sl{B}�q 3 3 Sf{�p 3 l 3 S }I·Z¹>x 3 S }IxR{/¹3 Sf{\lZ· 3 Sl{/¹:qI} 3 Sf{B·F{B· 3 S }�q�pI· 3 S�p 3 p 33 Sf{�q]q 3 Sl{Bx�q�p 3 Sf{\lZ}�p 3 S�p�pR{�q 3 S�pZ¹I¹>·�#�s~��l« � ~�° m�TI]�PsYZiK^`aKT@c(TZU#YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQj^l_+YZcsv�cdpR]�O/iK^`_/Y�o�e�Y�okpROBa�U�TIi ! 7 ���_� ��[RO/c

� 7 � {+YZcsv � �6� � ����� ��^fQ\[wB e � {�. } .Rz�[RO�aKOB_'T@csv(YZcsv%Q\[d^fi�v(_'TZofpR]�csaYVi\O4U�T@i � � }�YZcsv%Q\[RO4U�TIpRi\Q\[�YZcsv � U�Q�[9_'TZofpR]�csa6YZi�O4U�TIi � � p .

� � e �L�_� � c>pR](S � � e ���_� � YIaK�IS � � e ���h�5� cdpR](S � � e �L�_� � YIaK�IS �3 S 3 }I· 3 S xI}�pZ¹���{ 3 X � 3 S xI}@· 3 ��{ 3 X � 3 Sl{B}Z¹?l���{ 3 X � 3 Sl{B}I· 3 ��{ 3 X �3 S 3 l�· 3 S ·I·�qR{���{ 3 X � 3 S ·Ix@}I·���{ 3 X � 3 S 3 {I{@{\l 3 S 3 {I{B}I·3 Sf{B}I· 3 S 3 {B·I·I} 3 S 3 {B·Ix�p 3 S 3 p 3 qZ¹ 3 S 3 pR{B}I·3 Sf{B·R{ 3 S 3 }I}IxI· 3 S 3 }I}I¸ 3 3 S 3 ¹>·F{I{ 3 S 3 ¹>·Ix 33 Sf{\l�· 3 S 3 p 3 ¹>x 3 S 3 p 3 x�p 3 S 3 x 3 ·2l 3 S 3 xR{B}I·3 Sf{�q�q 3 S 3 p�qZ¹>· 3 S 3 p�qIx 3 3 S 3 l�¸]pI} 3 S 3 l qI} 3���s~��f« � �° m#TI]�PsYZij^lajTIc(TZU#YIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_�YZcsv%c>pR]�O/ij^l_/Y�o�eZY�ofpROBa�U�TIi � e �L�_� ��[RO/c

��7 � {�YZcsv � ����� �L�M� ��^fQ\[wB e � {�. }5.Rz�[RO�ajOB_'TIcsv(YZcsv%Q\[d^fi�v(_'TVokpR]wcsaYZi\O4U�TIi � � }�YVcsv�Q\[RO4U�TIpRi\Q\[�YZcsv � U�Q\[9_'TZofpR]�csa6YVi\O4U�T@i � � p5.

}2l

Page 28: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

� � � �L�_�5� cdpR](S � � � �L�_�5� YIaj�IS � � � ���_� � c>pR]�S � � � ���_� � YIaK�IS �3 S 3 }I· � 3 S 3�3 {B¸2l�·I¸ � 3 S 3�3 {�¸2l�· 3 � 3 S 3�3 · 3]3 } 3 � 3 S 3�3 · 3�3�33 S 3 l�· � 3 S 3 {Bx�qZ¹ � 3 S 3 {�xI¸I¸ � 3 S 3 ¹>·F{Bx � 3 S 3 ¹>· 3]33 Sf{B}I· � 3 S ¹�l pI·R{ � 3 S 3 ¹dxI¸I¸ � 3 Sf{B}Ix@} 3 � 3 Sf{B}I· 3]33 Sf{B·R{ � 3 S 3 x�qZ¹s{ � 3 S 3 x@¸Z¹ 3 � 3 Sf{B¸Z¹d¸2l � 3 Sf{B¸I}Z¹¢{3 Sf{\l�· � 3 S 3 q�pIxI¸ � 3 S 3 qF{B¸2l � 3 S }Z¹:q@}I· � 3 S }Z¹>· 3]33 Sf{�q�q � 3 Sf{�}R{\l q � 3 Sf{I{�¸I¸ 3 � 3 S�pI}�p@·R{ � 3 S�pR{BxI¸F{���s~ �l« � ~�°1m#T@]�PsYZiK^`aKTIc�TZU#YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQK^`_+YZcsv�cdpR]�O/iK^`_/Y�o�e�Y�ofpROBa�U�TIi � � ���_� YZcsv

� � ���_� ��[RO/c ��7 � { # � � } # YZcsv �O�4� �k����� .o`YZq¢O'o 6 $ e c $ e � � � ��3 � <�� � YIaK�IS �T� ·RS�q � <��r� cdpR](S �{ 3 S · 3 S · {IS�qI} l�¸�q 3 S x@}2l pI} 3 ��{ 3 c � 3 S xI}2l 3 l�}���{ 3 c �} � 3 S · � 3 S · {IS ¸�qF{B¸2l 3 Sf{�·R{B·Ix 3 ��{ 3 c � 3 Sf{B·R{ 3 qIx���{ 3 c �p � 3 S · {IS }I· {IS xR{�}2l>{ 3 S } 3 x@·�qI·���{ 3�� 3 S } 3 xI· 3 { ��{ 3��

���s~��f« � °4tRTIi�Q�[RO�vRYZQ�Y+^fc�� � . � . � ��O6¤Z^feIO�Q\[RO�_'T>T@i�v@^fcsYZQ\OBa $ e c #5$ e � # YZcsv%Q\[RO6^fcd^fQK^`Y�o#v@^lajQ�YZcs_'O� � ��32� U�TIi�OBYI_�[M^fcd^fQK^`Y�o_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIc�^fc�tD^f¤sS¢x�YZcsv&tD^f¤sS�l>S#z�[RO*olY@aKQ�QK��T�_'TZofpR]�csa4_'TI]�PsYZi\O_'TI]�PsYZi\O+Q\[RO�YIaK�d]�PRQ\T@QK^`_�_'TZo�o`YZPsaKO�QK^f]�O � ·RS�q � ��^fQ\[�Q\[RO�_'T@i\i\OBaKP¢TIcsv@^fcR¤(cdpR]�O/iK^`_/Y�o�i\OBaKpdofQBS

o`YZq¢O'o 6 $ e c $ e � � � �L32� <��r� YIaK�IS ��� ·RS q � < � � cdpR](S �{ 3 S ¹ {IS ¹ }FSf{B}2l>{�¹ 3 S ·R{Bx 3 pZ¹ ��{ 3 c � 3 S ·F{B·�qR{ 3 ��{ 3 c �} � 3 S · {IS x {@S�q�pI·�pV¹ 3 S ¹>¸I}V¹s{�q���{ 3 c � 3 S ¹d¸I}I}�qI}���{ 3 c �p 3 S · 3 S · }FS 3 xIx 3 { 3 Sf{I{B·@}Ix 3 ��{ 3 c � 3 Sf{@{B·I}�p 3 ��{ 3 c �

���s~ �l« � °4tRT@i�Q\[RO�vRYZQ�Y�^kc���� . � . � ��O6¤Z^feIO+Q\[RO�_'TdTIi�v@^fcsYZQ\OBa $ e c #5$ e � # YVcsv�Q\[RO4^fcd^fQK^`Y�ov@^`aKQ�YZcs_'O� � ��32� U�TIi�OBYI_�[�^fcd^fQK^`Y�o_'TIcsv@^fQK^fTIc�^fc�tD^f¤sSs¸�YZcsv�tD^f¤sS�qRS#z¡[RO6o`YIaKQ�QK��T�_'TZofpR]�csa6_'TI]�PsYVi\OQ\[RO�YIaj�>]�PRQ�TIQK^`_�_'TZo�o`YZPsaKO�QK^f]�O � ·RS�q � �¡^kQ�[9Q�[RO�_'TIi\i\OBaKP¢TIcsv@^fcR¤(cdpR]�O/iK^`_/Y�o�i\OBaKpdofQBS

}I¸

Page 29: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

� 8 %V � <��r� Y@aK�IS ��� xRS ¸ � <�� � cdpR](S �3 Sf{ 3 {IS ¸@xIx2l qRS xV¹>}�q 3 S ·Z¹I¹?l\q2l ��{ 3 c� 3 S ·Z¹@¹>x2l�·���{ 3 c� 3 Sf{/¹ {IS ¸F{�p�p qRS�q@}IxI· 3 S ¹>}R{B¸@}I¸���{ 3 c�c 3 S ¹>}F{Bx�pI}���{ 3 c�c3 Sf{B¸ {ISmlZx 3�3 { 3 S }I}2l 3 S · l>{B}�qR{ ��{ 3�� 3 S ·2l 3 ¸@}�p���{ 3���#�s~��l« � ° tFTIi�Q\[RO�vRYZQ�Y+^fc�� � . � . � �O+¤Z^feIO6Q\[RO+e�Y�ofpROBa4TZU 8 %V YZcsv � psaKOBv%^fc(Q\[RO+c>pR]�O/ij^l_/Y�o

ajTZofpRQK^fTIc�Q\T � xRS ¹ � S�z�[RO4o`YIaKQ4QK�T�_'TZofpR]�csa6_'T@]�PsYZi\O+Q\[RO�YIaK�d]�PRQ\TIQj^l_+_'TZo�o`YZPsaKO�QK^f]�O� xRS ¸ � ��^fQ\[�Q\[RO�_'TIi�i\OBaKPsT@csv@^kcR¤�cdpR]�O/iK^`_/Y�o#i�OBaKpdofQBS

}�q

Page 30: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

������� ��

��� �

� ��

������

��� ��

� �

� ��

!

"$#&%('*)�+-,(.0/21*'*1*143&+65870):9(;<#='?>A@CBD@FEG#=HI96JLKM5(NO;<#&P-+QH?>R#&5(H?9S30T:5(HVU(+XWY;V5(PZ9F#=HI[]\

p 3

Page 31: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

� �����

� �����

�����

�����

�����

� ��� � � ��� ����� � ��� ���

���������

������� ������ � � � �"!

#%$'&)(+*-,/.+0�1�2'3)4537684-9+,�:;3)<>=+(?4@,BAC:�DFE+3)E?$G:�DH2JI+(+I+I?2',LKM372'(+4N$O3)EPDF454MQR3�A�$ SJ,�*@,�ET4�UFDH2O(+,BKV376%WXQ�9+,�EPY[Z�Y]\H^_B` Z[a]DFEbAdceZf.+gXh�9+,iKM372 $�Aj2'$'E+,k$�K56l3)*�WRZ[m nFoCDFEbAP4@9?,kAT3)4-4-,BA>2'$'E+,p$GK�6�3)*�WRZ[mOaBq+g

pR{

Page 32: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

�����

�����

�����

���

��� ���� ����� ����� �����

����

�������! #"%$&(' � �

)+*-,

).*0/

1

2 22 3

4�57698!:<;>=!?A@CB9DFEHGI:�5�J�B9KLBNMOG9J�PQDFE!R<B9R�5�STGIKHUVKQ8!DF;#:�5�S#GXW�YIGXWZ8!;[J\M�B9:^]!_` M�B9:badcfegGIKHULadch=>i�j!;#Kk c kml GIKnUpo[q�csr9t�uj!;vJ�BNW 5�Ugw�UQB9R<R<;[UHx�W 5ZK!;[JyGI:<;%R<j!;yKQ8!DF;z:�5{S#GXWCw�G9J�PQD^E!R<B9R�5{SXxC:<;[J�8QWZR|J#t

pI}

Page 33: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

�����

�������

�����

������

��� ���

��� ���

����� ������� ������� ������ ��� ���

���������

�����! ��"#�$� � �

%'&)(

%*&)+

,

,

-�.0/21436587:9<;>[email protected]=2GH=JI�B2EKL?8@4M6=2M6.FNOBDG:PHGL14?85Q3�.FN�BSRUTDBSR0145VEWI�=23<XCY[Z\^]_I =23O`'acbdBDG:Pe`fahgji�k45�Gl a lWm BDGCPonVYparq2s�tUk45uE=JR .�PeZPL=2M6M65VP:]pR .vG45VEwBD365#M6k45wGL14?85Q3�.FN�BSR>ZB2EKL?A@4M6=2M�.FNS]>365VE�1LRvM^E�s

p�p

Page 34: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

�����

�������

������

�����

������

����� ������� ���� �� ���� �� �������

���������

��� �"!���#$�

%'& �

(*),+

(*),-

../

0

1�24365�798;:�<>=@?6ACB�DE792GF�?6HI?KJ�D6F�LMANB�O9?6O92GPQDRH�STHM5�AC8�7�2GP�DEUWVRDEUX5Y8ZF[J�?67]\Y^E_�`ba�J�?67[cedgfhDRH�SIcedgikj�l�8�Hm d m[n DRHoSqpZrsdut6v�wWl�8>F�?KU 2�SI_�SM?6O9O98ZS�asU 2XH�8ZFxDR798$O9l�8xHM5�AN8y7�2GP�DEU@_�D6F�LMACB�O9?6O�2GPEa@798ZF�5MUXObF�v

pZ¹

Page 35: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

� ��� �

��� � �

��� �

� � �

��� �

��� �

� ��� � � ��� � ��� � � ��� � � � � ��� � ��� �

��� � ��

� ����

�� �

�����

�� �

� �

��

����

��������� �"!�#���$���%'&(%*),+.-0/21�34& � �6587:9<;>=6? & ��@ 5 16AB�4CED�$�F�F G��BH>$�FI��$ 9 $KJ<F G��ML2� 9 F �N�O$KJ 78P � P�P DQ��R.$KDQ��FI��$ 9JS$��TF G�� �,� ; � UV�,� � 9 FO� 9 �QFI� 7 DWL2$ 9X; �QFI��$ 9 R,Y�Z[�,�\�M]0^_�`RTC 7 � 7 Ha�,F � ��b,� ;cPedgf +.h�/T& ��ij��� k Rl� 9em +Ih�/ � ��� 5 L2$eR.n,+.h�/oYp4GE�jL2� 9 F �,�g$KJ�F G�� P � P�P DQ�j�`RM� 9 �QFI� 7 D�D dq7 FgrMstJS$��*u"& ��v � v � Y�p4G��aL2� 9 F �,�wF G�� 9 Ha$:x��6RM� 9 F\G�� ; ��� �6LoFI��$ 9$KJOF G�� 7 � � $KAMR�� 9 F � DOF G��*CX$K� 9 FgyBsTA"G��,� �*F G�� P � PEP DQ� P �,�K� 9 R8F $zL2$KD�D 7 CXR.� 7 � 7 � 9 R.F8F G��*A 7 D D{YMp4GE�cL\D�$eRI�6R.FCX$K� 9 F8$ 9 ]0^|F $>rMs��`R[D 7:P �oDQ� ;}Ped>~ Y

pI·

Page 36: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

��� �

��� �

��� �

��� �

��� �

���� �

���� �

���� �

��� � ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� �

�� ���������������

���! "�$#

% �

& �

%('

&�'

%()

&�)

**+

,

-

.

-

/

02143�5�687:9<;2=�>4?�@BA2?DC$>4?�3<EGFIH �$JLK8MON 76�AP5�ARQSTH K8M<U QV(WI687X3D1 N 7YZC[?�6�7\W�]8^L?DC�@8^�7_@�6�WD`a7]�@�?D68147ARAP^�?Ib�Yc14Yd0O1e3�f � fgX^h7T14Yh1e@G1iW\>_WIY�jk7Y�jml�?D14Y<@BAXCn?�6X@8^�7AP7c@86�WD`a7\]�@8?�6G147\A_WI687T>iWIo�7B>e7jp14YqW�]r]�?�6�j�WIY�]�7Tbs14@8^q021e3�f � f

pIx

Page 37: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

� ��� �

��� �

��� �

��� �

��� �

�� �

� ��� � � ��� � � ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� �

��

���

���

���

��

���

��

��

��

��������� �"!�#%$'&)(*�,+-&).�/0�21�34&�57681��9�����:<;,�>=?+@�-.�/9/BA?&)/C3�1)DFEHGIEKJ)LNMPO@Q<R9G �2�TS Q<UTVWG ��X)S QY&)3Z\[P]H�^5.&)�@&)(*�-/B�0��_-�`Z"a'b%cdLNe�OfG �hgi��� � 5j�23�k)LNe�O@:

p2l

Page 38: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

��� �

��� �

��� �

��� �

��� �

���� �

���� �

���� �

���� �

��� � ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� �

�� ���������������

���! "�$#

% �

& �

%('

&�'

%()

&�)

**+

,

-

../

0

1

24365�7�8:9<;�=4>�?6@�ACB4@ED$?6@�5GFIHKJ �$LNM:OQP 98�BR7�BTSUVJ M:OGW SX(YK8:9Z5E3 P 9[\D]@�8�9^Y�_:`N@ED�A:`�9aA�8�YEbc9_�A�@E8:369BTBR`�@Kd�[e36[f2Q3g5�h � hiZ`j9V36[j3gAI3kY^?aYK[�lm9[�lon�@E36[GACBZDp@�8ZA:`�9BR9eA:8�YEbc9^_�A:@�8I369^BaYK8:9V?kYKq�9C?g9lr36[sY�_t_�@�8�l�YK[�_�9Vdu36A:`s243g5�h � h

pI¸

Page 39: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

� ��� �

��� � �

��� �

� � �

��� �

��� �

� ��� � � ��� � ��� � � ��� � � � � ��� � ��� �

��

�� �������� � ��� ������������������� "!#�� ��%$�&('���)*�+�,'-�.�+��/0���.���1)2�3 "!%)�4��* "5%�1�64. ��74./���89���;:=<>/?��5%�7/��1�@5BAC����������)2���1�4. "��4./���D7E�'F�+ 04��G ?)�4��H!B�.�H���1�I���J�.���K/0��5%�7/JLB$(M����N4��������#5%�H�2'��H�H!I�����K�2'��O����!����H!B��P%�, "!B��)��,8Q���+ 0) 4. ���4�/�����SRT:U 0)�)2����'F!V$QW, �!%4��X������4����.Y��������������3�������*'Q�X����!����H!B�ZP%�, "!B��)3 ?)Q����� )���[N��EB����� �1\��+ /� �5��* "�+[=5���5�5+/��)2�,/"���* ���!I<]/0��5%�7/��1�^5BAO������)*��/� 0�G4. ���4./"��D3 ?)J�_/?)2�O4��`!B���H���1�#����������P%�, "!B��LB$

p�q

Page 40: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

� ��� �

��� �

��� �

��� �

��� �

�� �

� ��� � � ��� � � ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� �

����������� ����� ����������������� �!�#"$�����%�&('��*)+�,�-'.�/�,�*01���/���2)3�4�#")�5 �+�#6�2�75/���85/0���9:���<;>=?0@��6�80��2�A6CBD�����*����)3���2�5/�#� 5/0���E8FG'H�,�15��I�@)J5 �K"C���K���L�M���N�����D0@��6O�K0QPC%MRG���S�2T��C��0 �#6��+����UV6,��6�6,0#�W)3�-0����+�#��"X=?01��6�80#�2�Y6CBZ�����$)3�-0��1�5/�#� 5/0���EG�1)[�L01)+�J5 �K"C���K���L�$���*PC%

¹ 3

Page 41: mYZcsYIvRYwryx@z{Z|g}ward/papers/bub.pdf3 YZcsv @U X-Y [RO/i\O PZ U\[ N 3 S#z¡[ROcRTIcR ;ofTR_/Y o csYZQ\pRi\O4TZU {]. f{ ^`a i\O _^ sOB_'Q\OBv©^fc Q\[RO+U YI_'QQ [sYZQ!G H< ]

��� �

��� �

��� �

��� �

��� �

���� �

���� �

���� �

���� �

���� �

��� � ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� �

�� ���������������

���! "�$#

%'&)(+* ��,

%'&)(+* ��-

%'&)(+* � (

.

/

/

02143�5�687 ���92:�;4<�=?>�<A@B;C< 3�DFEHG �BIKJ�L�M 76 > 5 >2NO G J�LPKNQSR 687T3A1 M 7U @V< 6 =8W 6877YX�14Z�7687U =SMHR[; 5�7 >T<A@]\�^?< 6�687 >F_�< U�X`14U�3=8<aR+b 5 b�bc; 7 <A@ 6 R X�1C5 >dN[Q�ef��� gHh�i 1 =8Wkjlefjam GFn L�i�W 1 ^8W 1 > 14Uc1 = 1 R[;4;4op^ 7U = 7687X R[=S=8W 7 _�< 14U = GFq DHr q�s r q�t LueG � r � r ��� ��h�L 1CU > 1vXB7 =8W 7�7 ;4; 1 _]>w< 1vXxq sDyHz s I q ss y � s I q st y � s e{��|Y}~W 7a� <�= 1 < U <A@S=�W 7 ^ 7U = 76 <A@�=8W 7 b 5 b�bc; 71 >�=8<Hi�R 6�X >~=8W 7 _�< 1CU = G � r � r �BL�R U�X�1 =Kb 73A14U >�=8<p^�<A;4;vRH_�> 7 R 3 R 1CU >F=�=�W 7 b�< 5�U]X R 6 o'<A@u=8W 7�7 ; ; 1 _�>F< 1�X i+W 7UN O efN Q |

¹s{