3 4*$5,(3 ,#- 4*!4&*’3 *$%.’1 +,3 0#-&*+$#& · ci b;cg= >;c :9< o9f mci e=

23
OWNING GENETIC INFORMATION AND GENE ENHANCEMENT TECHNIQUES: WHY PRIVACY AND PROPERTY RIGHTS MAY UNDERMINE SOCIAL CONTROL OF THE HUMAN GENOME* ADAM D. MOORE ABSTRACT In this article I argue that the proper subjects of intangible property claims include medical records, genetic profiles, and gene enhancement techniques. Coupled with a right to privacy these intangible property rights allow individuals a zone of control that will, in most cases, justifiably exclude governmental or societal invasions into private domains. I argue that the threshold for overriding privacy rights and intangible property rights is higher, in relation to genetic enhancement techniques and sensitive personal information, than is commonly suggested. Once the bar is raised, so-to-speak, the burden of overriding it is formidable. Thus many policy decisions that have been recently proposed or enacted ^ citywide audio and video surveillance, law enforcement DNA sweeps, genetic profiling, national bans on genetic testing and enhancement of humans, to name a few ^ will have to be backed by very strong arguments. Each new advance in . . . technology . . . disturbs a status quo. It meats resistance from those whose domain it threatens, but if useful, it begins to be adopted. Ithiel de Sola Pool, Technologies of Freedom Bioethics ISSN 0269-9702 Volume 14 Number 2 2000 ß Blackwell Publishers Ltd. 2000, 108 Cowley Road, Oxford OX4 1JF, UK and 350 Main Street, Malden, MA 02148, USA. * I would like to thank Bill Kline, Scott Rothwell, Mark VanHook, Don Hubin, Peter King, and Kimberly Moore for their comments and suggestions.

Transcript of 3 4*$5,(3 ,#- 4*!4&*’3 *$%.’1 +,3 0#-&*+$#& · ci b;cg= >;c :9< o9f mci e=

!"#$#% %&#&'$( $#)!*+,'$!# ,#-%&#& &#.,#(&+&#' '&(.#$/0&12".3 4*$5,(3 ,#- 4*!4&*'3 *$%.'1+,3 0#-&*+$#& 1!($,6 (!#'*!6 !)'.& .0+,# %&#!+&7

,-,+ -8 +!!*&

!"#$%!&$

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

&9:; <=> 9?@9<:= A< 8 8 8 B=:;<CDCEF 8 8 8 ?AGBHIJG 9 GB9BHG KHC8 $BL=9BG I=GAGB9<:= MICL B;CG= >;CG= ?CL9A< AB B;I=9B=<GN JHB AMHG=MHDN AB J=EA<G BC J= 9?COB=?8

$B;A=D ?= 1CD9 4CCDN $1/*(5052+1, 58 H.11;5:

"+51)*+/, $11# PQRSTSUPQI503:1 JK G3:61. L LMMM

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPPN XPY (C>D=F *C9?N !ZMCI? ![\ X])N 0^9<? _`P +9A< 1BI==BN +9D?=<N +, PQX\YN 01,8

7 $ >CHD? DAW= BC B;9<W VADD ^DA<=N 1:CBB *CB;>=DDN +9IW 59<.CCWN -C<.HJA<N 4=B=I ^A<EN 9<? ^ALJ=IDF +CCI= MCI B;=AI :CLL=<BG 9<? GHEE=GBAC<G8

$#'*!-0('$!#

$< I=:=<B F=9IG B;= =B;A:9D AGGH=G GHIICH<?A<E E=<=BA:=<;9<:=L=<BN E=<= B;=I9OFN :DC<A<EN 9<? OIA@9:F IAE;BG ;9@= J==<;CBDF ?=J9B=?8 "AB; B;= ;HL9< E=<CL= OICa=:B 9::=D=I9BA<E 9<?B;= 9?@9<:=L=<B CM E=<= B;=I9OF >= GB9<? C< B;= :HGO CM 9 JI9@=<=> >CID?8 $< B;= <=9I MHBHI= AB >ADD J= OCGGAJD= BC 9DB=I C<=bG C><E=<=BA: OICMAD= ! L9FJ= 9 :;9<E= CM =F= :CDCI CI 9 DCGG CM >=AE;B8 $BL9F 9DGC J= OCGGAJD= BC 9MM=:B B;= E=<=BA: L9W=THO CM MHBHI=E=<=I9BAC<G8 )CI A<GB9<:= >= L9F J= 9JD= BC J9<AG; ?A9J=B=G 9<?GALAD9I ?AG=9G=G MICL B;= ;HL9< E=<CL=8

';= =B;A:9DN OCDABA:9DN 9<? GC:A9D I9LAMA:9BAC<G CM B;AG JACTB=:;<CDCEA:9D LC@=L=<B 9I= OICMCH<? 9<? ;9@= 9D9IL=? L9<F8c+=GGA<E >AB; B;= ;HL9< E=<CL=b GCL= :D9AL cAG OD9FA<E %C?b8!B;=IG :C<aHI= @AGAC<G CM :DC<= M9ILGN CIE9< J9<WGN 9<? 9 >CID?>;=I= A<?A@A?H9D ?AGBA<:BA@=<=GG ;9G EA@=< >9F BC <=9I A?=<BA:9DN <=9IO=IM=:BN ICJCBTDAW= J=A<EG8 1CL= 9IEH= B;9B =@=< AM ECC? L9F :CL=MICL B;AG B9LO=IA<E >AB; <9BHI= AB >ADD LCGB DAW=DF C<DF 9MM=:B B;= IA:;CI B;CG= >;C :9< O9F MCI E=<= B;=I9OF8 ';= E=<=I9D LCC? CM LCGBD=9?=IG 9<? G:;CD9IG >AB; I=GO=:B BC B;=G= AGGH=G AG C<= CM :9HBAC<8

$< B;AG 9IBA:D= $ >ADD 9IEH= B;9B A<B9<EAJD= OICO=IBF CM B;AG GCIB :9<J= C><=? ! B;9B B;= OICO=I GHJa=:BG CM A<B9<EAJD= OICO=IBF :D9ALGA<:DH?= L=?A:9D I=:CI?GN E=<=BA: OICMAD=GN 9<? E=<= =<;9<:=L=<BB=:;<AKH=G8 (CHOD=? >AB; 9 IAE;B BC OIA@9:F B;=G= A<B9<EAJD=OICO=IBF IAE;BG 9DDC> A<?A@A?H9DG 9 dC<= CM :C<BICD B;9B >ADDN A<LCGB :9G=GN aHGBAMA9JDF =Z:DH?= EC@=I<L=<B9D CI GC:A=B9D A<@9GAC<GA<BC OIA@9B= ?CL9A<G8 $ >ADD 9IEH= B;9B B;= B;I=G;CD? MCI C@=IIA?A<EOIA@9:F IAE;BG 9<? A<B9<EAJD= OICO=IBF IAE;BG AG ;AE;=IN A< I=D9BAC< BCE=<=BA: =<;9<:=L=<B B=:;<AKH=G 9<? G=<GABA@= O=IGC<9DA<MCIL9BAC<N B;9< AG :CLLC<DF GHEE=GB=?8 !<:= B;= J9I AG I9AG=?NGCTBCTGO=9WN B;= JHI?=< CM C@=IIA?A<E AB AG MCILA?9JD=8 $< B;= =<?N $9L <CB GC >CIIA=? 9JCHB B;= OICGO=:BG CM 9 JI9@= <=> >CID?JICHE;B HOC< HG JF E=<= L9<AOHD9BAC< ! $ 9L LH:; LCI= >CIIA=?>;=< GC:A=BA=GN :CLLABB==GN 9<? :C<:=I<=? :ABAd=<G HG= B;= MCI:= CMEC@=I<L=<B BC B=DD HG >;9B >= :9< ?C BC 9<? A< CHI C>< JC?A=G8

, 6!(^&,# +!-&6 !) $#',#%$V6& 4*!4&*'3X

V=MCI= CMM=IA<E 9 ?=M=<G= CM A<B9<EAJD= OICO=IBF IAE;BGN $ >CHD?DAW= BC <CB= 9 M=> ALOCIB9<B ?AMM=I=<:=G J=B>==< A<B9<EAJD=

X , LCI= D=<EB;F 9<9DFGAG CM A<B9<EAJD= OICO=IBF IAE;BG 9<? OIA@9:F IAE;BG9OO=9I A< LF 9IBA:D=G c$<B9<EAJD= 4ICO=IBF2 4IA@9:FN 4C>=IN 9<? $<MCIL9BAC<(C<BICDb !:1.+/-( N*+05,54*+/-0 O3-.)1.09 _` e!:B8 XSSYfN c'C>9I? , 6C:W=9<';=CIF CM $<B=DD=:BH9D 4ICO=IBFb A< '()1001/)3-0 N.541.)9P Q5.-0< R12-0< -(;

SY ,-,+ -8 +!!*&

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

OICO=IBF 9<? B9<EAJD= CI O;FGA:9D OICO=IBF ! ?AMM=I=<:=G B;9B>CIW BC B;= 9?@9<B9E= CM B;= 6C:W=9< LC?=D B;9B $ >ADD GW=B:;8$<B9<EAJD= OICO=IBFN >;A:; A<:DH?=G A<B=DD=:BH9D OICO=IBFe:COFIAE;BGN O9B=<BGN E=<= =<;9<:=L=<B B=:;<AKH=G =B:8f 9G >=DD9G A<MCIL9BAC<N I=OHB9BAC<N 9<? B;= DAW=N AG E=<=I9DDF:;9I9:B=IAd=? 9G <C<TO;FGA:9D OICO=IBF >;=I= C><=IbG IAE;BGGHIICH<? :C<BICD CM O;FGA:9D L9<AM=GB9BAC<G CI BCW=<G CM GCL=9JGBI9:B A?=9 CI BFO=8 $?=9G CI :CDD=:BAC<G CM A?=9G 9I= I=9?ADFH<?=IGBCC? A< B=ILG CM <C<TO;FGA:9D BFO=GN >;AD= B;= O;FGA:9DL9<AM=GB9BAC<G CM A?=9G :9< J= LC?=D=? A< B=ILG CM BCW=<G8$<B9<EAJD= OICO=IBF IAE;BG GHIICH<? :C<BICD CM O;FGA:9D BCW=<GN9<? B;AG :C<BICD OICB=:BG IAE;BG BC BFO=G CI 9JGBI9:B A?=9G8

$<B9<EAJD= >CIWGN H<DAW= B9<EAJD= ECC?GN 9I= <C<TIA@9DICHG8(CLOHB=I OICEI9LGN E=<=BA: =<;9<:=L=<B B=:;<AKH=GN JCCWGNLC@A=GN 9<? DAGBG CM :HGBCL=IG :9< 9DD J= HG=? 9<? :C<GHL=? JFL9<F A<?A@A?H9DG :C<:HII=<BDF8 ';AG AG E=<=I9DDF <CB B;= :9G= MCI:9IGN :CLOHB=IGN 5(*GN 9<? LCGB CB;=I B9<EAJD= ECC?G8$<B9<EAJD= OICO=IBFN H<DAW= O;FGA:9D OICO=IBFN AG 9DGC <C<Td=ICTGHL8 $< B;= :D=9I=GB :9G=N >;=< $ =9B 9< 9OOD= B;=I= AG C<= D=GG9OOD= MCI =@=IFC<= =DG= ! LF ODHG C<= 9<? =@=IFC<= =DG=bG LA<HGC<= GHL BC d=IC8 "AB; A<B9<EAJD= OICO=IBF AB AG <CB 9G AM LF9:KHAGABAC< D=9@=G C<= D=GG MCI =@=IFC<= =DG=8

,<CB;=I ?AMM=I=<:= J=B>==< O;FGA:9D 9<? A<B9<EAJD= OICO=IBF:C<:=I<G >;9B AG 9@9AD9JD= MCI 9:KHAGABAC<8 ";AD= L9BB=IN C><=? CIH<C><=?N 9DI=9?F =ZAGBG B;= G9L= AG <CB BIH= CM 9DD A<B9<EAJD=>CIWG8 ";9B AG 9@9AD9JD= MCI 9:KHAGABAC< A< B=ILG CM A<B9<EAJD=OICO=IBF :9< J= GODAB A<BC B;I== ?CL9A<G8 ';=I= AG B;= ?CL9A< CMA?=9G F=B BC J= ?AG:C@=I=? e<=> G:A=<BAMA: D9>GN L9OOA<E B;=;HL9< E<CL=N =B:8fN B;= ?CL9A< CM A?=9G F=B BC J= :I=9B=? eB;=<=ZB R5.; 58 )*1 %+(2,N #)-. S-.,N =B:8fN 9<? B;= ?CL9A< CMA<B9<EAJD= >CIWG B;9B 9I= OIA@9B=DF C><=?8 1A<:= AB AG OCGGAJD= MCIA<?A@A?H9DG BC A<?=O=<?=<BDF A<@=<B CI :I=9B= B;= G9L= A<B9<EAJD=>CIW 9<? CJB9A< IAE;BGN >= LHGB A<:DH?= :HII=<BDF C><=?A<B9<EAJD= >CIWG 9G 9@9AD9JD= MCI 9:KHAGABAC<8 !<DF B;= G=B CMA?=9G B;9B 9I= A< B;= OHJDA: ?CL9A< CI B;CG= A?=9G B;9B 9I= 9 O9IBCM B;= :CLLC< :HDBHI= 9I= <CB 9@9AD9JD= MCI 9:KHAGABAC< 9<?=Z:DHGAC<8 $ B9W= B;AG D9BB=I G=B BC J= 9WA< BC 9 OHJDA: O9IW8

'HI<A<E BC B;= KH=GBAC< CM aHGBAMA:9BAC<N >= L9F J=EA< JF9GWA<E ;C> OICO=IBF IAE;BG BC H<C><=? CJa=:BG 9I= E=<=I9B=?8

'()1.(-)+5(-0 F+01::-,N ,8 +CCI= e*C>L9< g 6ABBD=MA=D?N XSSUfN (;98 `N 9<?c&LODCF== +C<ABCIA<E 9<? (CLOHB=I '=:;<CDCEF2 &@9DH9BA@= 1HI@=ADD9<:= @84IA@9:Fb MCIB;:CLA<E A< "3,+(1,, T)*+/, O3-.)1.098 $ >CHD? B;9<W B;= =?ABCIG CM!NO<"T&< 9<? *CL9< g 6ABBD=MA=D? MCI 9DDC>A<E L= BC OI=G=<B B;AG L9B=IA9D ;=I=8

!"#$#% %&#&'$( $#)!*+,'$!# SS

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

';AG AG W<C>< 9G B;= OICJD=L CM CIAEA<9D 9:KHAGABAC< 9<? 9:CLLC< I=GOC<G= AG EA@=< JF ]C;< 6C:W=8 c)CI B;AG D9JCI J=A<EB;= H<KH=GBAC<9JD= OICO=IBF CM B;= D9JCI=IN <C L9< JHB ;= :9<;9@= 9 IAE;B BC >;9B B;9B AG C<:= aCA<=? BCN 9B D=9GB >;=I= B;=I= AG1(532* -(; -, 255; 018) 85. 5)*1.,8bQ 1C DC<E 9G B;= OIC@AGC B;9Bc=<CHE; 9<? 9G ECC?b AG G9BAGMA=?N 9< 9:KHAGABAC< AG CM OI=aH?A:= BC<C C<=8 6C:W= 9IEH=G B;9B c#CJC?F :CHD? B;A<W ;ALG=DM A<aHI=?JF B;= ?IA<WA<E CM 9<CB;=I L9<N B;CHE; ;= BCCW 9 ECC? ?I9HE;BN>;C ;9? 9 >;CD= IA@=I CM B;= G9L= D=MB ;AL BC KH=<:; ;AG B;AIGB8 8 8b8_

1HOOCG= B;9B LAZA<E C<=bG D9JCI >AB; 9< H<C><=? CJa=:B:I=9B=G 9 OIAL9 M9:A= :D9AL 9E9A<GB CB;=IG <CB BC A<B=IM=I= B;9B :9<C<DF J= C@=IIA??=< JF 9 :CLO9I9JD= :D9AL8 ';= ICD= CM B;=OIC@AGC AG BC OIC@A?= C<= OCGGAJD= G=B CM :C<?ABAC<G >;=I= B;=OIAL9 M9:A= :D9AL I=L9A<G H<?=M=9B=?8\ ,<CB;=I >9F CM GB9BA<EB;AG OCGABAC< AG B;9B B;= OIC@AGC A< 9??ABAC< BC [N >;=I= [ AG D9JCICI MAIGB C::HO9<:F CI GCL= CB;=I >=9W :D9AL E=<=I9BA<E 9:BA@ABFNOIC@A?=G 9 GHMMA:A=<B :C<?ABAC< MCI CIAEA<9D 9OOICOIA9BAC<8

]HGBAMA:9BAC< MCI B;= @A=> B;9B D9JCI CI OCGG=GGAC< L9F E=<=I9B=OIAL9 M9:A= :D9ALG 9E9A<GB CB;=IG :CHD? OIC:==? 9DC<E G=@=I9DDA<=G8 )AIGBN D9JCIN A<B=DD=:BH9D =MMCIBN 9<? :I=9BAC< 9I= E=<=I9DDF@CDH<B9IF 9:BA@ABA=G B;9B :9< J= H<OD=9G9<BN =Z;AD9I9BA<EN 9<?=@=IFB;A<E A<TJ=B>==<8 ';9B >= @CDH<B9IADF ?C B;=G= B;A<EG 9GGC@=I=AE< LCI9D 9E=<BG L9F J= =<CHE; BC >9II9<B <C<TA<B=IM=I=<:= :D9ALG 9E9A<GB CB;=IG8 , G=:C<?N 9<? OCGGAJDF I=D9B=?aHGBAMA:9BAC<N AG J9G=? C< ?=G=IB8 1CL=BAL=G A<?A@A?H9DG >;C@CDH<B9IADF ?C CI M9AD BC ?C :=IB9A< B;A<EG ?=G=I@= GCL= CHB:CL=CI CB;=I8 ';HGN GBH?=<BG L9F ?=G=I@= ;AE; ;C<CI EI9?=G 9<?:IALA<9DG L9F ?=G=I@= OH<AG;L=<B8 ";=< <CBAC<G CM ?=G=IB 9I==@CW=? :D9ALG 9<? CJDAE9BAC<G 9I= L9?= 9E9A<GB CB;=IG ! B;=G=<C<T9JGCDHB= :D9ALG 9<? CJDAE9BAC<G 9I= E=<=I9B=? JF >;9BA<?A@A?H9DG ?C CI M9AD BC ?C8 ';HG A< M9AIDF H<:C<BIC@=IGA9D :9G=GCM ?=G=IBN >= 9I= >ADDA<E BC 9:W<C>D=?E= B;9B >=9W :D9ALG 9I=E=<=I9B=? 9<? AM ?=G=IB :9< OICO=IDF 9BB9:; BC D9JCI CI :I=9BAC<NB;=< :D9ALG L9F J= E=<=I9B=? A< B;=G= :9G=G 9G >=DD8

)A<9DDFN 9 aHGBAMA:9BAC< MCI B;= @A=> B;9B D9JCI CI OCGG=GGAC< L9FE=<=I9B= OIAL9 M9:A= :D9ALG 9E9A<GB CB;=IG :CHD? J= EICH<?=? A<I=GO=:B MCI A<?A@A?H9D 9HBC<CLF 9<? GC@=I=AE<BF8 ,G GC@=I=AE<

Q ]C;< 6C:W=N $*1 #1/5(; $.1-)+,1 58 U5@1.(:1()N 1=:BAC< QU eAB9DA:G LA<=f8_ 6C:W=N #1/5(; $.1-)+,1< 1=:BAC< __8\ ';AG @A=> AG GHLL=? HO <A:=DF JF (D9IW "CDMN c(C<B=LOCI9IF 4ICO=IBF

*AE;BGN 6C:W=9< 4IC@AGCGN 9<? B;= $<B=I=GBG CM )HBHI= %=<=I9BAC<GNb T)*+/, XP`e]HDFN XSS`f2 USX!YXY8

XPP ,-,+ -8 +!!*&

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

9<? 9HBC<CLCHG 9E=<BGN =GO=:A9DDF >AB;A< B;= DAJ=I9D BI9?ABAC<N >=9I= 9MMCI?=? B;= LCI9D 9<? D=E9D GO9:= BC CI?=I CHI DA@=G 9G >= G==MAB8 ,G DC<E 9G I=GO=:B MCI CB;=IG AG L9A<B9A<=? >= 9I= =9:; MI== BCG=B B;= :CHIG= 9<? ?AI=:BAC< CM CHI C>< DA@=GN BC :;CCG= J=B>==<@9IACHG DAM=DC<E EC9DG 9<? OICa=:BGN 9<? BC ?=@=DCO CHI :9O9:ABA=G9<? B9D=<BG 9::CI?A<EDF8 1ALOD= I=GO=:B MCI A<?A@A?H9DG >CHD?OIC;AJAB >I=GBA<E MICL B;=AI ;9<?G 9< H<C><=? CJa=:B B;9B B;=F9:KHAI=? CI OIC?H:=?8 $ ;9GB=< BC 9?? B;9B 9B B;AG OCA<B >= 9I=BIFA<E BC aHGBAMF >=9W <C<TA<B=IM=I=<:= :D9ALGN <CB MHDD JDC><OICO=IBF IAE;BG8 !B;=I B;A<EG J=A<E =KH9DN >;=< 9< A<?A@A?H9DD9JCIG BC :I=9B= 9< A<B9<EAJD= >CIWN B;=< >=9W OI=GHLOBA@=:D9ALG CM <C<TA<B=IM=I=<:= ;9@= J==< E=<=I9B=? C< EICH<?G CMD9JCIN ?=G=IBN CI 9HBC<CLF8

';= H<?=IDFA<E I9BAC<9D= CM 6C:W=bG OIC@AGC AG B;9B AM <C C<=bGGABH9BAC< AG >CIG=<=?N B;=< <C C<= :9< :CLOD9A< 9JCHB 9<CB;=IA<?A@A?H9D 9OOICOIA9BA<E O9IB CM B;= :CLLC<G8 $M <C C<= AG;9IL=? JF 9< 9:KHAGABAC< 9<? C<= O=IGC< AG J=BB=I=?N B;=< B;=9:KHAGABAC< CHE;B BC J= O=ILABB=?8 $< M9:BN AB AG OI=:AG=DF J=:9HG=<C C<= AG ;9IL=? B;9B AB G==LG H<I=9GC<9JD= BC CJa=:B BC 9 49I=BCGHO=IACI LC@=8 ';HGN B;= OIC@AGC :9< J= H<?=IGBCC? 9G 9 @=IGAC<CM 9 c<C ;9ILN <C MCHDb OIA<:AOD=8

"1))1.+(2< ?5.,1(+(2< -(; )*1 6-,10+(1 4.5601:

,GGHLA<E 9 aHGB A<ABA9D OCGABAC< 9<? B;9B 49I=BC GHO=IACI LC@=G9I= D=EABAL9B=N B;=I= 9I= B>C KH=GBAC<G BC :C<GA?=I >;=<=Z9LA<A<E 9 49I=BC J9G=? OIC@AGC8 )AIGBN >;9B 9I= B;= B=ILG CMJ=A<E >CIG=<=?h ';AG AG 9 KH=GBAC< CM G:9D=N L=9GHI=L=<BN CI@9DH=8 ,< A<?A@A?H9D :CHD? J= >CIG=<=? A< B=ILG CM GHJa=:BA@=OI=M=I=<:= G9BAGM9:BAC<N >=9DB;N ;9OOA<=GGN MI==?CLGNCOOCIBH<ABA=GN =B :=B=I98 ";A:; CM B;=G= :CH<B A< ?=B=ILA<A<EJ=BB=IA<E 9<? >CIG=<A<Eh 1=:C<?N C<:= B;= B=ILG CM J=A<E>CIG=<=? ;9@= J==< I=GCD@=?N >;A:; B>C GABH9BAC<G 9I= >= ECA<EBC :CLO9I= BC ?=B=ILA<= AM GCL=C<= ;9G J==< >CIG=<=?h $G B;=KH=GBAC< C<= CM ;C> CB;=IG 9I= <C>N 9MB=I LF 9OOICOIA9BAC<N:CLO9I=? BC ;C> B;=F >CHD? ;9@= J==< >=I= $ 9JG=<BN CI AM $ ;9?<CB 9OOICOIA9B=?N CI GCL= CB;=I GB9B=h .=I= >= 9I= BIFA<E BC9<G>=I B;= KH=GBAC< c"CIG=<=? I=D=@9<B BC >;9Bhb ';AG AG W<C><9G B;= J9G=DA<= OICJD=L8

$< OIA<:AOD=N B;= 6C:W=9< B;=CIF CM A<B9<EAJD= OICO=IBF J=A<E?=@=DCO=? AG :C<GAGB=<B >AB; 9 >A?= I9<E= CM @9DH= B;=CIA=G8 1CDC<E 9G B;= OI=M=II=? @9DH= B;=CIF ;9G B;= I=GCHI:=G BC ?=B=ILA<=J=BB=IA<E 9<? >CIG=<A<E >AB; I=M=I=<:= BC 9:KHAGABAC<GN B;=<49I=BC GHO=IACI LC@=G :9< J= L9?= 9<? 9:KHAGABAC<G aHGBAMA=? C<

!"#$#% %&#&'$( $#)!*+,'$!# XPX

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

6C:W=9< EICH<?G8 )CI <C>N 9GGHL= 9< ,IAGBCB=DA9< =H?9ALC<AGB9::CH<B CM @9DH= =Z;AJAB=? JF B;= MCDDC>A<E B;=G=G AG :CII=:B8`

X8 .HL9< >=DDTJ=A<E CI MDCHIAG;A<E AG B;= GCD= GB9<?9I? CMA<BIA<GA: @9DH=8

Q8 .HL9< O=IGC<G 9I= I9BAC<9D OICa=:B OHIGH=IGN 9<? >=DDTJ=A<ECI MDCHIAG;A<E AG 9BB9A<=? B;ICHE; B;= G=BBA<EN OHIGHA<EN 9<?:CLOD=BAC< CM DAM= EC9DG 9<? OICa=:BG8

_8 ';= :C<BICD CM O;FGA:9D 9<? A<B9<EAJD= CJa=:BG AG @9DH9JD=8 ,B 9GO=:AMA: BAL= =9:; A<?A@A?H9D ;9G 9 :=IB9A< G=B CM B;A<EG G;=:9< MI==DF HG= 9<? CB;=I B;A<EG G;= C><GN JHB G;= 9DGC ;9G:=IB9A< COOCIBH<ABA=G BC HG= 9<? 9OOICOIA9B= B;A<EG8 ';AG:CLOD=Z G=B CM COOCIBH<ABA=G 9DC<E >AB; >;9B G;= :9< <C>MI==DF HG= CI ;9G IAE;BG C@=I :C<GBABHB=G ;=I OCGABAC<L9B=IA9DDF ! B;AG G=B :C<GBABHB=G ;=I D=@=D CM L9B=IA9D >=DDTJ=A<E8

";AD= AB AG :=IB9A<DF B;= :9G= B;9B B;=I= AG LCI= BC J=BB=IA<E 9<?>CIG=<A<E B;9< 9< A<?A@A?H9DbG D=@=D CM L9B=IA9D >=DD J=A<EA<:DH?A<E COOCIBH<ABF :CGBGN $ >ADD <CB OHIGH= B;AG L9BB=I MHIB;=I9B OI=G=<B8 #==?D=GG BC G9FN 9 MHDDTJDC>< 9::CH<B CM @9DH= >ADD=ZODA:9B= 9DD B;= >9FG A< >;A:; A<?A@A?H9DG :9< J= J=BB=I=? 9<?>CIG=<=? >AB; I=M=I=<:= BC 9:KHAGABAC<8 +CI=C@=I 9G <CB=?J=MCI=N AB AG <CB :IH:A9D BC B;= 6C:W=9< LC?=D J=A<E OI=G=<B=?BC ?=M=<? GCL= OI=M=II=? B;=CIF CM @9DH= 9E9A<GB 9DD :CL=IG8";9B=@=I @9DH= B;=CIF B;9B AG HDBAL9B=DF :CII=:BN AM AB ;9G B;=9JADABF BC ?=B=ILA<= J=BB=IA<E 9<? >CIG=<A<E >AB; I=M=I=<:= BC9:KHAGABAC<GN B;=< 49I=BCTGHO=IACI LC@=G :9< J= L9?= 9<?9:KHAGABAC<G aHGBAMA=? C< 6C:W=9< EICH<?G8

6C:W=9<G 9G >=DD 9G CB;=IG >;C G==W BC EICH<? IAE;BG BCOICO=IBF A< B;= OIC@AGC E=<=I9DDF G=B B;= J9G=DA<= CM :CLO9IAGC<9G B;= GB9B= CM <9BHI=8 ';= :CLLC<G CI B;= GB9B= CM <9BHI= AG:;9I9:B=IAd=? 9G B;9B GB9B= >;=I= B;= LCI9D D9<?G:9O= ;9G F=B BCJ= :;9<E=? JF MCIL9D OICO=IBF I=D9BAC<G8 ';= LCI9D D9<?G:9O= AGJ9II=< CM GH:; I=D9BAC<G H<BAD GCL= OIC:=GG C::HIG ! 9<? AB AG <CB9GGHL=? B;9B B;= OIC:=GG MCI :;9<EA<E B;= LCI9D D9<?G:9O= B;=6C:W=9< >CHD? 9?@C:9B= AG B;= C<DF aHGBAMA=? L=9<G BC B;AG =<?8

` )CI GALAD9I @A=>G G==2 *9>DGN ! $*15.9 58 V3,)+/1 e(9LJIA?E=2 .9I@9I?0<A@=IGABF 4I=GGN XSUXfN :;98 5$$8i ,IAGBCBD=N G+/5:-/*1-( T)*+/,N JWG8 $ 9<? [i^9<BN $*1 H3(;-:1()-0 N.+(/+401, 58 $*1 Q1)-4*9,+/, 58 Q5.-0,< ,:9?=LF &?ABAC<i1A?E>A:WN Q1)*5;, 58 T)*+/,N UB; =?8 e6C<?C<N +9:LADDA9<N XSPUfi *8 V8 4=IIFNU1(1.-0 $*15.9 58 I-031 e#=> 3CIW2 6C<EL9<GN %I==<N XSQRfi 9<? 6CI=<6CL9GWFN N1.,5(,< %+2*),< -(; )*1 Q5.-0 &5::3(+)9 e#=> 3CIW2 !ZMCI? 0<A@=IGABF4I=GGN XSYUf8

XPQ ,-,+ -8 +!!*&

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

)CI <C>N 9GGHL= 9 GB9B= CM <9BHI= GABH9BAC< >;=I= <CA<aHGBA:= ;9G C::HII=? 9<? >;=I= B;=I= 9I= <C OICO=IBFI=D9BAC<G A< B=ILG CM HG=N OCGG=GGAC<N CI IAE;BG8 ,DD 9<FC<= ;9GA< B;AG A<ABA9D GB9B= 9I= COOCIBH<ABA=G BC A<:I=9G= ;=I L9B=IA9DGB9<?A<E8 1HOOCG= )I=? :I=9B=G 9< A<B9<EAJD= >CIW 9<? ?C=G<CB >CIG=< ;AG M=DDC>G ! 9D9GN 9DD B;=F ;9? >=I= :C<BA<E=<BCOOCIBH<ABA=G 9<? )I=?bG :I=9BAC< 9<? =Z:DHGAC< 9?=KH9B=DFJ=<=MABG B;=L A< CB;=I >9FG8 ,MB=I B;= 9:KHAGABAC<N )I=?bG D=@=DCM L9B=IA9D >=DDTJ=A<E ;9G :;9<E=?8 #C> ;= ;9G 9 OCGG=GGAC<B;9B ;= ;CD?G D=EABAL9B=DFN 9G >=DD 9G 9DD CM ;AG OI=@ACHGCOOCIBH<ABA=G8 ,DC<E :CL=G %A<E=I >;C :I=9B=G ;=I C><A<B9<EAJD= >CIW 9<? :C<GA?=IG >;=B;=I ;=I =Z:DHGAC< CM AB >ADD>CIG=< )I=?8 VHB >;9B B>C GABH9BAC<G G;CHD? %A<E=I :CLO9I=h1;CHD? B;= 9:KHAGABA@= :9G= e%A<E=IbG 9:KHAGABAC<f J= :CLO9I=?BC )I=?bG A<ABA9D GB9B=N >;=I= ;= ;9? <CB F=B D=EABAL9B=DF9:KHAI=? 9<FB;A<EN CI BC ;AG GABH9BAC< ALL=?A9B=DF J=MCI=%A<E=IbG B9WA<Eh $M J=BB=IA<E 9<? >CIG=<A<E 9I= BC J= :9G;=?CHB A< B=ILG CM 9< A<?A@A?H9DbG D=@=D CM >=DD J=A<E >AB;COOCIBH<ABF :CGBG 9<? B;AG L=9GHI= :;9<E=G C@=I BAL=N B;=<B;= J9G=DA<= CM :CLO9IAGC< LHGB 9DGC :;9<E=8 $< B;= :HII=<B:9G= >= :CLO9I= )I=?bG D=@=D CM L9B=IA9D >=DDTJ=A<E >;=<%A<E=I OCGG=GG=G 9<? =Z:DH?=G 9< A<B9<EAJD= >CIW BC ;AG D=@=D CM>=DDTJ=A<E ALL=?A9B=DF J=MCI= %A<E=IbG 9:KHAGABAC<8

';= I=GHDB CM B;AG ?AG:HGGAC< CM J=BB=IA<EN >CIG=<A<EN 9<? B;=J9G=DA<= OICJD=L AG B;= MCDDC>A<E OIC@AGC C< CIAEA<9D 9:KHAGABAC<2

$M B;= 9:KHAGABAC< CM 9< A<B9<EAJD= >CIW L9W=G <C C<= =DG=>CIG=TCMM A< B=ILG CM ;=I D=@=D CM >=DDTJ=A<E eA<:DH?A<ECOOCIBH<ABF :CGBGf :CLO9I=? BC ;C> G;= >9G ALL=?A9B=DFJ=MCI= B;= 9:KHAGABAC<N B;=< B;= B9WA<E AG O=ILABB=?8

$M :CII=:BN B;AG 9::CH<B aHGBAMA=G IAE;BG BC :C<BICD A<B9<EAJD=OICO=IBF8 ";=< 9< A<?A@A?H9D :I=9B=G CI :CLOAD=G 9< A<B9<EAJD=>CIW 9<? MAZ=G AB A< GCL= M9G;AC<N B;=< D9JCI 9<? OCGG=GGAC<:I=9B= 9 OIAL9 M9:A= :D9AL BC B;= >CIW8 +CI=C@=IN AM B;= OIC@AGC AGG9BAGMA=? B;= OIAL9 M9:A= :D9AL I=L9A<G H<?=M=9B=? 9<? IAE;BG 9I=E=<=I9B=?8

4*$5,(3

4IA@9:F L9F J= H<?=IGBCC? 9G B;9B GB9B= >;=I= CB;=IG ?C <CB ;9@=9::=GG BC FCH CI BC A<MCIL9BAC< 9JCHB FCH8 $ ;9GB=< BC <CB= B;9BB;=I= 9I= ?=EI==G CM OIA@9:F8 ';=I= 9I= CHI C>< OIA@9B= B;CHE;BGB;9B 9I= <=@=I ?AG:DCG=? BC 9<FC<=N 9G >=DD 9G A<MCIL9BAC< >=G;9I= >AB; DC@=? C<=G8 )HIB;=ILCI=N B;=I= AG A<MCIL9BAC< B;9B >=

!"#$#% %&#&'$( $#)!*+,'$!# XP_

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

G;9I= >AB; L=I= 9:KH9A<B9<:=G 9<? B;= E=<=I9D OHJDA:8 ';=G=OIA@9:F I=D9BAC<G >AB; CB;=IG :9< J= OA:BHI=? cA< B=ILG CM 9 G=IA=GCM ccdC<=Gbb CI ccI=EAC<Gbb 8 8 8 D=9?A<E BC 9 cc:CI= G=DM8bb bR ';HGNG=:I=BG G;9I=? >AB; 9 DC@=? C<= :9< GBADD J= :C<GA?=I=? OIA@9B=N=@=< B;CHE; B;=F ;9@= J==< ?AG:DCG=?8

, IAE;B BC OIA@9:F :9< J= H<?=IGBCC? 9G 9 IAE;B BC L9A<B9A< 9:=IB9A< D=@=D CM :C<BICD C@=I B;= A<<=I GO;=I=G CM O=IGC<9DA<MCIL9BAC<8 $B AG 9 IAE;B BC DALAB OHJDA: 9::=GG BC B;= c:CI= G=DMb !O=IGC<9D A<MCIL9BAC< B;9B C<= <=@=I ?AG:DCG=G ! 9<? BCA<MCIL9BAC< B;9B C<= ?AG:DCG=G C<DF BC M9LADF 9<? MIA=<?G8 )CI=Z9LOD=N GHOOCG= B;9B $ >=9I 9 EDC@= J=:9HG= $ 9L 9G;9L=? CM 9G:9I C< LF ;9<?8 $M FCH >=I= BC G<9B:; B;= EDC@= 9>9F FCH >CHD?<CB C<DF J= @ACD9BA<E LF IAE;B BC OICO=IBF ! 9D9G B;= EDC@= AGLA<= BC :C<BICD ! FCH >CHD? 9DGC @ACD9B= LF IAE;B BC OIA@9:Fi 9IAE;B BC I=GBIA:B 9::=GG BC A<MCIL9BAC< 9JCHB B;= G:9I C< LF;9<?8 1ALAD9IDFN AM FCH >=I= BC MC:HG FCHI ZTI9F :9L=I9 C< LF;9<?N B9W= 9 OA:BHI= CM B;= G:9I B;ICHE; B;= EDC@=N 9<? B;=<OHJDAG; B;= O;CBCEI9O; >A?=DFN FCH >CHD? @ACD9B= 9 IAE;B BCOIA@9:F8

.9@A<E G9A? GCL=B;A<E 9JCHB >;9B 9 IAE;B BC OIA@9:F AG >= L9F9GW ;C> GH:; IAE;BG 9I= aHGBAMA=?8 , OICLAGA<E DA<= CM 9IEHL=<B:CLJA<=G <CBAC<G CM 9HBC<CLF 9<? I=GO=:B MCI O=IGC<G8 , :=<BI9D9<? EHA?A<E OIA<:AOD= CM >=GB=I< DAJ=I9D ?=LC:I9:A=G AG B;9BA<?A@A?H9DGN >AB;A< :=IB9A< DALABGN L9F G=B 9<? OHIGH= B;=AI C><DAM= EC9DG 9<? OICa=:BG8 *AE;BG BC OIA@9:F =I=:B 9 LCI9D JCH<?9IFB;9B 9DDC>G A<?A@A?H9DG B;= LCI9D GO9:= BC CI?=I B;=AI DA@=G 9G B;=FG== MAB8 4IA@9:F OICB=:BG HG MICL B;= OIFA<E =F=G 9<? =9IG CMEC@=I<L=<BGN :CIOCI9BAC<GN 9<? <=AE;JCIG8 "AB;A< B;= >9DDG CMOIA@9:F >= L9F =ZO=IAL=<B >AB; <=> >9FG CM DA@A<E B;9B L9F <CBJ= 9::=OB=? JF B;= L9aCIABF8 4IA@9:FN 9HBC<CLFN 9<? GC@=I=AE<BFNAB >CHD? G==L :CL= JH<?D=? BCE=B;=I8

, G=:C<? JHB I=D9B=? DA<= CM 9IEHL=<B I=GBG C< B;= :D9AL B;9BOIA@9:F IAE;BG GB9<? 9G 9 JHD>9IW 9E9A<GB EC@=I<L=<B9DCOOI=GGAC< 9<? BCB9DAB9IA9< I=EAL=G8 $M A<?A@A?H9DG ;9@= IAE;BGBC :C<BICD O=IGC<9D A<MCIL9BAC< 9<? BC DALAB 9::=GG BC B;=LG=D@=GN>AB;A< :=IB9A< :C<GBI9A<BGN B;=< B;= WA<?G CM COOI=GGAC< B;9B >=;9@= >AB<=GG=? A< B;= B>=<BA=B; :=<BHIF >CHD? J= <=9IALOCGGAJD=8 4HB 9<CB;=I >9FN AM COOI=GGA@= I=EAL=G 9I= BC:C<GCDA?9B= 9<? L9A<B9A< OC>=IN B;=< OIA@9:F IAE;BG eJIC9?DF?=MA<=?f LHGB J= =DALA<9B=? CI G=@=I=DF I=GBIA:B=?8 $M :CII=:BN

R ,D9< "=GBA<N c4IA@9:F A< B;= +C?=I< -=LC:I9BA: 1B9B=b A< -8 ]C;<GC< 9<? ]81<9OO=IN T)*+/-0 ',,31, +( )*1 W,1 58 &5:43)1., e"9?G>CIB; 4HJ82 XSY`fN O8 XYU8

XP\ ,-,+ -8 +!!*&

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

OIA@9:F IAE;BG >CHD? J= 9 :CI= @9DH= B;9B DALAB=? B;= MCI:=G CMCOOI=GGAC<8U

,IEH9JDF 9<F OD9HGAJD= 9::CH<B CM ;HL9< >=DD J=A<E CIMDCHIAG;A<E >ADD ;9@= 9G 9 :CLOC<=<B 9 GBIC<E IAE;B BC OIA@9:F8(C<BICDDA<E >;C ;9G 9::=GG BC CHIG=D@=G AG 9< =GG=<BA9D O9IB CMJ=A<E 9 ;9OOF 9<? MI== O=IGC<8 ';AG L9F J= >;F cO==OA<E 'CLGb9<? I9OAGBG 9I= ;=D? HO 9G LCI9D LC<GB=IG ! B;=F :ICGG 9 JCH<?9IFB;9B G;CHD? <=@=I J= :ICGG=? >AB;CHB :C<G=<B8

1HI=DF =9:; CM HG ;9G B;= IAE;B BC :C<BICD CHI C>< B;CHE;BGN;CO=GN M==DA<EGN 9<? OD9<GN 9G >=DD 9G 9 IAE;B BC I=GBIA:B 9::=GG BCA<MCIL9BAC< 9JCHB CHI DA@=GN M9LADFN 9<? MIA=<?G8 $ >CHD? 9IEH=B;9B >;9B EICH<?G B;=G= G=<BAL=<BG AG 9 IAE;B BC OIA@9:F ! 9 IAE;BBC L9A<B9A< 9 :=IB9A< D=@=D CM :C<BICD C@=I O=IGC<9D A<MCIL9BAC<8";AD= :CLOD=B= :C<BICD CM 9DD CHI O=IGC<9D A<MCIL9BAC< AG 9 OAO=?I=9L MCI L9<F CM HGN GALODF J=:9HG= B;= A<MCIL9BAC< AG 9DI=9?FCHB B;=I= 9<? LCGB DAW=DF :9<<CB CI >ADD <CB J= ?=GBICF=?N B;AG?C=G <CB ?=BI9:B MICL B;= @A=> CM O=IGC<9D A<MCIL9BAC<C><=IG;AO8 ';ICHE; CHI ?9ADF 9:BA@ABA=G >= =9:; :I=9B= 9<?D=9@= ?AEAB9D MCCBOIA<BG B;9B CB;=IG L9F MCDDC> 9<? =ZODCAB ! 9<?B;9B >= ?C B;=G= B;A<EG ?C=G <CB CJ@ACHGDF G9<:BAC< B;=E9B;=IA<E 9<? GHJG=KH=<B ?AG:DCGHI= CM GH:; A<MCIL9BAC< JFCB;=IG8

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

$M $ 9L :CII=:B 9JCHB 9DD CM B;AGN B;=< B;=I= AG 9 M9AIDF GBIC<EOI=GHLOBAC< A< M9@CI CM A<?A@A?H9D OIA@9:F IAE;BG8 ";9B aHGBAMA=G 9O;CBCEI9O;=I B9WA<E OA:BHI=G CM L= 9JCHB B;= ;CHG= CI 9 <=>G9E=<:F OHJDAG;A<E G=<GABA@= L=?A:9D A<MCIL9BAC< 9JCHB L= AG LF

U )CI LCI= 9JCHB OIA@9:F IAE;BG G==N (;9ID=G )IA=?N c4IA@9:FNb X-01 R-? V53.(-0UU eXSRYf2 \UUi ,8 "=GBA< 9<? +8 V9W=IN F-)-6-(E, +( - H.11 #5/+1)9N e#=> 3CIW2/H9?I9<ED= 4I=GGN XSUQfi ]8 *9:;=DGN c";F 4IA@9:F AG $LOCIB9<BNb N*+05,54*9 -(;N360+/ !88-+., \ e1HLL=I XSU`f2 _Q_!__i 9<? 49HD "=AGGN N.+@-/9 e1CHB;=I<$DDA<CAG 0<A@=IGABF 4I=GGN XSY_f8

!"#$#% %&#&'$( $#)!*+,'$!# XP`

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

:C<G=<B8 +CGB >CHD? 9EI== B;9B 9JG=<B GH:; :C<G=<B 9 G=IACHG@ACD9BAC< CM OIA@9:F >CHD? ;9@= C::HII=?8

N.+@-/9P /5().500+(2 953. 21(1)+/ +(85.:-)+5(

$< XSURN ]C;< +CCI= J=E9< BI=9BL=<B MCI :9<:=I 9B B;=0<A@=IGABF CM (9DAMCI<A9 +=?A:9D (=<B=I8

.AG ?C:BCIG KHA:WDF J=:9L= 9>9I= B;9B GCL= CM ;AG JDCC?OIC?H:BG 9<? :CLOC<=<BG >=I= OCB=<BA9DDF CM EI=9B:CLL=I:A9D @9DH=8 ';=F O=IMCIL=? L9<F B=GBG >AB;CHB =@=IB=DDA<E ;AL CM B;=AI :CLL=I:A9D A<B=I=GBN 9<? BCCW G9LOD=G CM=@=IF :C<:=A@9JD= JC?ADF MDHA?N A<:DH?A<E GO=ILN JDCC?N 9<?JC<= L9IIC> 9GOAI9B= 8 8 88 $< XSYXN 9 :=DD DA<= =GB9JDAG;=? MICL+CCI=bG 'TDFLO;C:FB=G >9G O9B=<B=? JF B;= 0<A@=IGABF CM(9DAMCI<A9N >AB; +CCI=bG ?C:BCIG DAGB=? 9G B;= A<@=<BCIG8 ,B <CBAL= ?HIA<E B;AG OIC:=GG >9G +CCI= BCD? 9<FB;A<E 9JCHB B;=:CLL=I:A9D =ZODCAB9BAC< CM ;AG E=<=BA: L9B=IA9D8 ';= DAW=DF:CLL=I:A9D @9DH= CM B;= :=DD DA<= AG ALOCGGAJD= BC OI=?A:B=Z9:BDFN JHB JF XSSP B;= L9IW=B MCI GH:; OIC?H:BG >9G=GBAL9B=? BC J= C@=I j_ JADDAC<8Y

,D9ILA<E 9G B;AG :9G= 9OO=9IG >= :9< =9GADF AL9EA<= :9G=G B;9B 9I=LCI= BICHJDA<E8 ";9B AM B;= B=GBG C< +CCI=bG E=<=BA: L9B=IA9DMCH<?N 9DC<E >AB; :=IB9A< 9?@9<B9E=CHG BI9ABGN ?=M=:BG B;9B >CHD?DAW=DF :9HG= ;AL BC J= ;CGOAB9DAd=? MCI D=<EB;F O=IAC?G CM BAL=80OC< OHJDAG;A<E B;=AI MA<?A<EG 9<? L9FJ= O9B=<BA<E :=IB9A< :=DDDA<=GN +CCI=bG A<GHI9<:= :CLO9<F ?ICOG ;AG OCDA:F 9<? CB;=I:CLO9<A=G I=MHG= :C@=I9E=8

';= :9G= CM ]C;< +CCI= 9<? B;= O9B=<BA<E CM :=DDG OIC?H:=? MICL;AG JDCC?TOIC?H:BG AG A<B=I=GBA<E J=:9HG= AB JIA<EG HO 9 <HLJ=I CMALOCIB9<B AGGH=G I=D9B=? BC :C<BICDDA<E O=IGC<9D A<MCIL9BAC< 9<?JC?F IAE;BG8 ,B C<= D=@=D B;AG :9G= I9AG=G B;= KH=GBAC< CM >;9BA<MCIL9BAC< ?C:BCIG G;CHD? ?AG:DCG= BC B;=AI O9BA=<BGN =GO=:A9DDF>;=< B;= A<MCIL9BAC< A< KH=GBAC< AG 9JCHB B;= O9BA=<B8 VHB 9B 9 LCI=E=<=I9D D=@=DN B;AG :9G= AG :C<:=I<=? >AB; B;= C><=IG;AO CM E=<=BA:A<MCIL9BAC< 9<? CB;=I O=IGC<9D A<MCIL9BAC<8 -C:BCI O9BA=<B:C<MA?=<BA9DABF 9EI==L=<BG 9I= J9G=? HOC< B;= O9BA=<BbG IAE;BG BC:C<BICD :=IB9A< WA<?G CM G=<GABA@= O=IGC<9D A<MCIL9BAC<8 VA<?A<E9EI==L=<BG B;CHE;N OI=GHOOCG= OIACI =<BABD=L=<BG8

Y ]9L=G VCFD=N #*-:-(,< #58)?-.1< -(; #4011(,P R-? -(; )*1 &5(,).3/)+5( 58 )*1'(85.:-)+5( #5/+1)9 e(9LJIA?E=N +9GG82 .9I@9I? 0<A@=IGABF 4I=GGN XSSRfN O8 QQ8';= OI=?A:BAC< CM L9IW=B @9DH= :CL=G MICL V=@=IDF +=IdN cVACB=:;<CDCEF21OD==<T*AE;BGb $*1 T/5(5:+,)N _P e,HEHGB XXN XSSPf8

XPR ,-,+ -8 +!!*&

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

$M +CCI= ;9? 9EI==? BC B;= E9B;=IA<E 9<? ?AG:DCGHI= CM B;=E=<=BA: A<MCIL9BAC< MCH<? A< ;AG 'TDFLO;C:FB=GN B;=< B;AG :9G=>CHD? DCG= LH:; CM ABG LCI9D ALO9:B8 ";9B JCB;=IG LCGB CM HG AGB;= ?=:=OBAC< B;9B C::HII=? ! +CCI=bG ?C:BCIG I=O=9B=?DF 9GW=?MCI 9 GAE<=? >9A@=I 9<? +CCI= I=O=9B=?DF 9GW=? >;F B;=F >9<B=?GH:; 9 >9A@=I8 +CI= E=<=I9DDF ;C>=@=IN >= :9< 9GW AM +CCI=9:BH9DDF C><=? B;= A<MCIL9BAC< B;9B >9G MCH<? A< ;AG 'TDFLO;C:FB=G8 ,G G=DMTC><=IG AB L9F J= B;= :9G= B;9B >= =9:; C><CHI C>< JC?A=GN :9O9:ABA=GN 9<? OC>=IG8 $B ?C=G <CB MCDDC> MICL B;=<CBAC< CM cG=DMTC><=IG;AObN ;C>=@=IN B;9B >= =9:; C>< B;= E=<=BA:A<MCIL9BAC< MCH<? A< CHI :=DDG8 !><=IG;AO CM 9 BCW=< ?C=G <CB=<B9AD C><=IG;AO CM 9 BFO=8 $< CB;=I >CI?GN $ L9F C>< 9 :COF CM $*1#3( !0,5 %+,1, e9 BCW=<fN JHB B;AG ?C=G <CB L=9< B;9B $ C>< B;=A<B9<EAJD= >CIW eB;= ODCBN :;9I9:B=IGN B;=L=N 9<? GBFD= ! CI BFO=Gf8

,DGCN AB AG <CB =@=< :D=9I A< B;AG :9G= B;9B 9 OIA@9:F A<B=I=GB >9G9B GB9W=8 ';= :=DD DA<=N CI ?AG:C@=I=? A<B9<EAJD= >CIWN =GB9JDAG;=?MICL +CCI=bG 'TDFLO;C:FB=G L9F :C<B9A< <C O=IGC<9DA<MCIL9BAC< 9B 9DD8 $M B;=I= >=I= <C OIA@9:F A<B=I=GB 9B GB9W=N <CA<MCIL9BAC< 9JCHB G=ZH9D OI=M=I=<:=GN OCGGAJD= MHBHI= 9ADL=<BGN9<? B;= DAW=N B;=< AB >CHD? J= ?AMMA:HDB BC L9A<B9A< B;9B +CCI=bGOIA@9:F >9G @ACD9B=?8 ';HGN AB AG 9IEH9JDF B;= :9G= B;9B <C OIACI=<BABD=L=<B :D9ALG =ZAGB=?8

, ?AMM=I=<B :9G=N JHB C<= B;9B AG =@=< LCI= 9D9ILA<E B;9< B;=+CCI= :9G=N AG >;9B ;9OO=<=? A< 9 GL9DD @ADD9E= A< %I==:=8 $<!I:;=L=<CG %I==:=N B;=I= 9I= L9<F A<?A@A?H9DG >;C ;9@= 9 E=<=B;9B :9HG=G GA:WD=TG;9O=? I=? JDCC? :=DDG8 ';= OICJD=L AG B;9B>;=< B>C O9I=<BG JCB; :9IIF B;= E=<= B;=AI CMMGOIA<E L9F?=@=DCO GA:WD=T:=DD 9<=LA98 $< 9< =MMCIB BC OI=@=<B B;AG ?AG=9G=I=G=9I:;=IG B=GB=? =@=IFC<= A< B;= @ADD9E= GC B;9B L9IIA9E=GJ=B>==< E=<= :9IIA=IG :CHD? J= 9@CA?=?8

, EICHO CM I=G=9I:;=IG B=GB=? B;= @ADD9E=IG 9B !I:;=L=<CGN9GGHLA<E B;9B :9IIA=IG >CHD? J=;9@= I9BAC<9DDF 9<? >CHD? O9AI>AB; <C<:9IIA=IG A< CI?=I BC LAZ B;= E=<=G G9M=DF 9<? OICB=:BB;= :CLLH<ABFbG :;AD?I=<8 ';= <C<:9IIA=IGN ;C>=@=IN I=MHG=?BC :CCO=I9B=8 &@=< B;CHE; B;= E=<= AG ;9ILD=GG C< ABG C><N:9IIA=IG J=:9L= GBAEL9BAd=? 9<? <C<:9IIA=IG I=MHG=? BC L9IIFB;=L8 $< B;= =<?N B;= :9IIA=IG J=:9L= 9 G;H<<=? GHJ:D9GG >;C>9G MCI:=? BC L9IIF 9LC<E B;=LG=D@=GN L9WA<E B;= GABH9BAC<=@=< >CIG= B;9< J=MCI=8S

";AD= B;= I=G=9I:;=IGb EC9DG >=I= <CJD=N B;=F CJ@ACHGDF M9AD=?BC MCI=G== B;= I9LAMA:9BAC<G CM ?AG:DCGA<E B;AG WA<? CM O=IGC<9D

S (;9ID=G 4D9BB c&@CDHBAC< *=@CDHBAC<b S+.1; Q-2-A+(1 e]9<H9IF XSSUfN O8 QPP8

!"#$#% %&#&'$( $#)!*+,'$!# XPU

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

A<MCIL9BAC<8 $M >= 9I= BC B9W= OIA@9:F IAE;BG G=IACHGDFN B;=I=G;CHD? J= E=<=I9D OIC;AJABAC<G 9E9A<GB ?AG:DCGA<E A<MCIL9BAC< CMB;AG GCIB ! OIC;AJABAC<G A<?=O=<?=<B CM DAW=DF E9A<G A< GC:A9DHBADABF8

(HII=<B ,L=IA:9< OI9:BA:= 9DDC>G :CLO9<A=G 9<? A<?A@A?H9DGBC E9B;=IN G=DDN 9<? JHF 9DLCGB 9<F WA<? CM A<MCIL9BAC<N A<:DH?A<EG=<GABA@= O=IGC<9D A<MCIL9BAC<8 +CI=C@=IN 9::=GG BC O=IGC<9DA<MCIL9BAC< GBCI=? C< ?9B9J9G=G ;=D? JF :CLO9<A=G 9<? CB;=I:ABAd=<G AG OHI=DF @CDH<B9IF ! :CLO9<A=G ?C <CB ;9@= BC G;C> FCHB;= A<MCIL9BAC< B;9B B;=F ;9@= E9B;=I=? 9JCHB FCH8 ,<? A< 9<F:9G=N FCH ;9@= @=IF DABBD= :C<BICD C@=I >;9B :9< J= ?C<= >AB; B;AGA<MCIL9BAC<8 $M 9 :CLO9<F CI B;= EC@=I<L=<B >9<BG BC G=DD B;AGA<MCIL9BAC<N B;=I= AG DABBD= B;9B FCH :9< ?C 9JCHB AB8

&<B=I B;= &0 OIA@9:F LC?=D >;A:; EI9<BG A<?A@A?H9DG ICJHGBOIA@9:F IAE;BG8XP 0<DAW= B;= ,L=IA:9< =:C<CLA: LC?=D >;=I=LCGB WA<?G CM A<MCIL9BAC< :9< J= JCHE;B 9<? GCD? >AB; <C GBIA<EG9BB9:;=?N B;= &0 LC?=D OIC;AJABG B;= H<:C<GBI9A<=? JHFA<E 9<?G=DDA<E CM O=IGC<9D A<MCIL9BAC<8 1ALC< -9@A=G CM S+.1; Q-2-A+(1>IAB=G2

0<?=I B;AG I=EAL=N W<C>< 9G B;= &HICO=9< -9B9 4ICB=:BAC<-AI=:BA@=N 9<F :CH<BIF B;9B BI9?=G O=IGC<9D A<MCIL9BAC< >AB;B;= 0^N )I9<:=N %=IL9<FN 1O9A<N $B9DFN CI 9<F CM B;= CB;=I XP&0 GB9B=G >ADD J= I=KHAI=? BC =LJI9:= &HICO=bG GBIA:B GB9<?9I?GMCI OIA@9:F OICB=:BAC<8 #C OIA@9:FN <C BI9?=8 $BbG B;9B GALOD=8XX

&HICO=9< :ABAd=<G ;9@= B;= IAE;B BC 9::=GG B;=AI ?9B9N B;= IAE;B BCW<C> >;=I= B;= ?9B9 CIAEA<9B=?N B;= IAE;B BC ;9@= A<9::HI9B=A<MCIL9BAC< I=:BAMA=?N B;= IAE;B CM I=:CHIG= A< B;= =@=<B CMH<D9>MHD OIC:=GGA<EN 9<? B;= IAE;B BC >AB;;CD? O=ILAGGAC< BC HG=B;=AI ?9B9 MCI ?AI=:B L9IW=BA<E8 6AW= B;= LCI9D IAE;BG 9MMCI?=?9HB;CIG 9<? A<@=<BCIGNXQ $ 9OOD9H? B;= I=:CE<ABAC< CM B;=G=

XP )CI 9 M9AIDF ?=B9AD=? 9<9DFGAG CM B;= &0 LC?=D CM OIA@9:F OICB=:BAC< G==)I=? (9B=N N.+@-/9 +( )*1 '(85.:-)+5( !21 eVICCWA<EG $<GBABHBAC< 4I=GGN XSSUfN O8_Q!\Y8

XX 1ALC< -9@A=GN c&HICO= BC 08182 #C 4IA@9:FN #C 'I9?=b S+.1; Q-2-A+(1 e+9FXSSYfN O8 X_`8

XQ c+CI9D IAE;BGb 9I= E=<=I9DDF B;CHE;B CM 9G IAE;BG B;9B EC J=FC<? B;==:C<CLA: IAE;BG EI9<B=? A< ,<EDCT,L=IA:9< A<GBABHBAC<G CM A<B=DD=:BH9DOICO=IBF8 )CI =Z9LOD=N B;= LCI9D IAE;BG CM 9< 9HB;CI L9F OIC;AJAB 9DB=I9BAC<CM GCL= A<B9<EAJD= >CIW =@=< 9MB=I B;= MAIGB G9D= ! B;HG 9< 9HB;CI CM 9 JD9:W 9<?>;AB= LC@A= L9F OIC;AJAB :CDCI J=A<E 9??=?8 )CI LCI= 9JCHB B;= LCI9D IAE;BGCM 9HB;CIG 9<? A<@=<BCIG G== '()1001/)3-0 N.541.)9P Q5.-0< R12-0< -(; '()1.(-)+5(-0F+01::-,N =?8 ,8 +CCI= e*C>L9< g 6ABBD=MA=D?N XSSUfN O8 R!UN 9<? +8 ,8 *C=?=INc';= -C:BIA<= CM +CI9D *AE;B2 , 1BH?F A< B;= 69> CM ,IBAGBGN ,HB;CIGN 9<?(I=9BCIGNb Y-.@-.; R-? %1@+1? `_ eXS\Pf2 ``\8

XPY ,-,+ -8 +!!*&

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

OIA@9:F IAE;BG :C<:=I<A<E O=IGC<9D A<MCIL9BAC<8 $B >CHD? G==LB;9B C< B>C MIC<BG B;= &HICO=9<G 9I= >=DD 9;=9? CM B;=AI,L=IA:9< :CH<B=IO9IBG8

'C JIA=MDF GHLL9IAd= B;= MAIGB B>C G=:BAC<GN $ B;A<W AB AG OD9HGAJD=BC L9A<B9A< B;9B A<B9<EAJD= >CIWGN DAW= E=<=BA: =<;9<:=L=<BB=:;<AKH=GN :9< J= C><=? 9<? B;9B B;=I= AG 9 M9AIDF GBIC<EOI=GHLOBAC< A< M9@CI CM A<?A@A?H9D OIA@9:F8 #=@=IB;=D=GGN A<B9<EAJD=OICO=IBF IAE;BG 9<? OIA@9:F IAE;BG 9I= <CB 9JGCDHB=8 'C B9W= 9 GALOD==Z9LOD=N LF OICO=IBF IAE;B A< 9 6CHAG@ADD= GDHEE=I ?C=G <CB 9DDC>L= G>A<E AB 9B FCHI W<==GN <CI :9< $ B;IC> AB 9B FCHI :9I8 4ICO=IBFIAE;BG 9I= E=<=I9DDF DALAB=? JF B;= IAE;BG CM CB;=IG8 )HIB;=ILCI=NB;AG I=GBIA:BAC< ! :9DD AB B;= ;9IL I=GBIA:BAC< ! MABG >=DD >AB; B;=6C:W=9< LC?=D H<?=I :C<GA?=I9BAC<8 ';= OIC@AGCN 9 <C ;9IL <CMCHD IHD=N 9DDC>G A<?A@A?H9DG BC 9:KHAI= H<C><=? ECC?G8 ';= ;9ILI=GBIA:BAC< DALABG ;9ILMHD HG=G CM B;CG= ECC?G8

, G=:C<? :C<GBI9A<B C< >;9B :9< J= ?C<= >AB; A<B9<EAJD= >CIWG;9G BC ?C >AB; OIA@9:F 9<? A<MCIL9BAC< :C<BICD8 "AB;CHB FCHI:C<G=<B 9<? A<?=O=<?=<B CM ;9ILN $ L9F <CB OHJDAG; G=<GABA@=O=IGC<9D A<MCIL9BAC< 9JCHB FCH C< LF >=JGAB=N HG= FCHI AL9E= BCOICLCB= 9< A<B=I<9BAC<9D OIC?H:B DA<=N CI DAGB=< A< C< FCHIO;C<= :C<@=IG9BAC<G8 ';= KH=GBAC< <C> J=:CL=G >;=<N AM =@=IN:9< B;=G= M9AIDF GBIC<E OI=GHLOBAC<GN CI IAE;BGN J= C@=IIA??=< JFCB;=I :C<GA?=I9BAC<G8

4*$5,(3N 4*!4&*'3N ,#- %&#&'$( &#.,#(&+&#''&(.#$/0&1

$< B;AG G=:BAC< $ >ADD :C<GA?=I G=@=I9D :CLLC< 9IEHL=<BG B;9BOHIOCIB BC G;C> ;C> =9GADF B;= OICO=IBF 9<? OIA@9:F OI=GHLOBAC<G9DI=9?F =GB9JDAG;=? L9F J= H<?=ILA<=?8 4D=9G= <CB= B;9B >;9BMCDDC>G AG <CB 9< =Z;9HGBA@= =Z9LA<9BAC< CM =@=IF OCA<B 9<?:CH<B=IOCA<B B;9B L9F J= CMM=I=? >AB; I=GO=:B BC B;=G=OI=GHLOBAC<G8 +F EC9D AG GALODF BC G;C> B;9B OIA@9:F IAE;BG 9<?A<B9<EAJD= OICO=IBF IAE;BGN C<:= =GB9JDAG;=?N 9I= <CB GC =9GADF G>=OB9GA?= 9G GCL= LAE;B B;A<W8 ';HG L9<F OCDA:F ?=:AGAC<G B;9B ;9@=J==< I=:=<BDF OICOCG=? CI =<9:B=? ! :ABF>A?= 9H?AC 9<? @A?=CGHI@=ADD9<:=N D9> =<MCI:=L=<B -#, G>==OGN E=<=BA: OICMADA<EN 9<?<9BAC<9D J9<G C< E=<=BA: B=GBA<E 9<? =<;9<:=L=<B CM ;HL9<GN BC<9L= 9 M=> ! >ADD ;9@= BC J= J9:W=? JF @=IF GBIC<E 9IEHL=<BG8

'()1.81.1(/1 ?+)* R+61.)9 -(; N.+@-/9 !.23:1()

6=B HG J=EA< >AB; 9 M9AIDF GALOD= :9G=8 1HOOCG= B;9B %A<E=I ;9G?AG:C@=I=? B;= E=<=BA: L9IW=IG MCI ?A9J=B=G 9<? ;9G ?=@=DCO=? 9

!"#$#% %&#&'$( $#)!*+,'$!# XPS

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

E=<= B;=I9OF B=:;<AKH= B;9B >ADD :CII=:B B;AG :C<?ABAC<8 $< M9:B;=I B=:;<AKH= >ADD =DALA<9B= B;= E=<= CI :CLJA<9BAC< CM E=<=GB;9B :9HG= ?A9J=B=G A< L9BHI= :=DDG eGCL9BA: :=DDGf 9G >=DD 9G :=DDGB;9B L9F J= O9GG=? C< BC C<=bG CMMGOIA<E eE=IL DA<= :=DDGf8 )I=?N>;C ;9G J==< GHMM=IA<E MICL B;= :CLODA:9BAC<G CM ?A9J=B=G GA<:=:;AD?;CC? :C<B9:BG %A<E=I 9<? 9II9<E=G BC ;9@= E=<=BA: B;=I9OF8+CI=C@=IN GHOOCG= B;9B )I=? ;9G OIA@9:F IAE;BG B;9B 9DDC> ;AL 9:=IB9A< WA<? CM :C<BICD C@=I O=IGC<9D A<MCIL9BAC< 9G >=DD 9G ;AGJC?F 9<? :9O9:ABA=G8 )I=? H<?=IEC=G B;= OIC:=?HI=N O9FG %A<E=IN9<? MCI=@=I 9DB=IG B;= E=<=BA: OICMAD= CM ;AG ?=G:=<?9<BG8

%A@=< B;9B )I=? 9<? %A<E=I :CHD? J= L=LJ=IG CM 9<F GC:A=BFCI :HDBHI= 9<? 9GGHLA<E B;9B OI=GHLOBA@= IAE;BG BC OIA@9:F 9<?A<B9<EAJD= OICO=IBF C><=IG;AO ;9@= J==< =GB9JDAG;=?N >= ;9@= 9<ALL=?A9B= OIAL9 M9:A= :9G= 9E9A<GB G>==OA<E EC@=I<L=<B9D CIGC:A=B9D A<B=IM=I=<:= >AB; B;AG :C<?H:B8 %A<E=IbG DC@= CM G:A=<:=9<? ?=GAI= BC ;=DO CB;=IG ?IA@=G ;=I BC JHI< B;= LA?<AE;B CAD 9<?OIC?H:= 9 I=@CDHBAC<9IF <=> B=:;<AKH=8 )I=?bG IAE;B BC OIA@9:F9DDC>G ;ALN >AB;A< :=IB9A< :C<GBI9A<BGN BC ?=:A?= >;9B ;9OO=<G BC9<? A< ;AG JC?F8 $B >CHD? G==L B;9B B;=I= 9I= <C EICH<?G MCIB;AI? O9IBF A<B=IM=I=<:= A< B;AG :9G= ! <CB;A<E B;9B >CHD?C@=IIA?= B;= OI=GHLOBA@= IAE;BG 9DI=9?F A< OD9:=8

#C> AM )I=? 9<? %A<E=I ;9? :C<GOAI=? BC :;9<E= ;AG E=<=BA:OICMAD= A< GH:; 9 >9F B;9B :9HG=? ;AG ?=G:=<?9<BG )5 *-@1:;AD?;CC? ?A9J=B=GN B;=< GHI=DF A<B=IM=I=<:= CI G9<:BAC<G 9I=>9II9<B=? e9GGHLA<EN CM :CHIG=N B;9B )I=? AG ECA<E BC EC C< BCM9B;=I :;AD?I=<f8 $ >CHD? ;CO= B;9B GH:; 9:BA@ABF >CHD? M9DDH<?=I B;= HLJI=DD9 CM :;AD? OICB=:BAC< D9>G8 ';CG= A<?A@A?H9DG>;C ?C B;A<EG B;9B =<?9<E=I B;= ;=9DB; 9<? >=DD J=A<E CM?=O=<?=<BG >ADD ;9@= G9<:BAC<=? A<B=IM=I=<:=G >AB; OIA@9B=?CL9A<G 9<? C><=IG;AO8 , GALAD9I =Z9LOD= AG B;= A<?A@A?H9D>;C AG OD9FA<E *HGGA9< ICHD=BB= >AB; GCL=C<= >;C ?C=G <CB :9I=BC B9W= O9IB A< B;AG 9:BA@ABF ! GHI=DF B;AG >CHD? JHLO 9E9A<GB B;=;9IL I=GBIA:BAC< CI 9 GALAD9I I=GBIA:BAC<i B;= cIAGW CM EI=9B ;9ILbI=GBIA:BAC<8

, M=> GB9H<:; ?=M=<?=IG CM I=DAEACHG MI==?CL 9IEH= B;9BMH<?9L=<B9DAGBG G;CHD? J= 9JD= BC 9?;=I= BC :=IB9A< IHD=G =@=<>;=< ?CA<E GC >ADD :9HG= 9 :;AD? BC ?A=8 )CI =Z9LOD= GCL=I=DAEACHG @A=>G MCIJA? JDCC? BI9<GMHGAC<G >;AD= CB;=IG L9F MCIJA?9::=GG BC L=?A:9D ?C:BCIG 9DBCE=B;=I8 ';=G= OI9:BA:=G 9I= :D=9I@ACD9BAC<G CM B;= ;9IL GB9<?9I?N 9<? 9::CI?A<E BC LF @A=>N L9FJ= aHGBAMA9JDF OIC;AJAB=?8 +CI=C@=IN B;CG= >;C ?AG9EI== >AB; L=C< B;AG L9BB=I 9<? >AB; I=GO=:B BC E=<=BA: =<;9<:=L=<B G==L BCGB9<? C< G;9WF EICH<? ! B;=F >ADD 9DDC> O9I=<BG BC ;9IL B;=AI:;AD?I=< JF 9?;=IA<E BC I=DAEACHG OIA<:AOD=G >;AD= MCIJA??A<E

XXP ,-,+ -8 +!!*&

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

CB;=I O9I=<BG BC ;=DO B;=AI :;AD?I=< B;CHE; E=<=BA: =<;9<:=TL=<B8

'COT?C>< D9>G B;9B G==W BC I=EHD9B= E=<=BA: B;=I9OF >ADD 9DLCGB9D>9FG A<B=IM=I= >AB; A<?A@A?H9D DAJ=IBF 9<? OIA@9:F8 (C<GA?=I B;=:9G= >;=I= )I=? MDA=G CMM BC GCL= MCI=AE< :CH<BIF BC I=:=A@=E=<=BA: B;=I9OF MICL %A<E=I8 $B AG ?AMMA:HDB BC AL9EA<= ;C> D9>G CIGALAD9I WA<?G CM I=EHD9BAC< 9I= ECA<E BC OIC;AJAB B;AG 9:BA@ABF>AB;CHB 9DGC G9<:BAC<A<E G=@=I= @ACD9BAC<G CM DAJ=IBF 9<? OIA@9:F8

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a=:BG8

";AD= AB L9F J= B;= :9G= B;9B :=IB9A< BFO=G CM E=<=BA:=<;9<:=L=<B 9I= ALLCI9D AB ?C=G <CB 9HBCL9BA:9DDF MCDDC> B;9BB;=F G;CHD? J= I=EHD9B=?8 ';=I= 9I= L9<F 9:BAC<GN JCB; LCI9D9<? ALLCI9D B;9B 9IEH9JDF M9DD CHBGA?= CM B;= ?CL9A< GC:A=B9DI=EHD9BAC<8 6FA<E 9<? ;=DOA<E B;= OCCI 9I= B>C CJ@ACHG=Z9LOD=G8

(=IB9A<DF B;=I= 9I= BFO=G CM 9:BAC<G G;CHD? J= OIC;AJAB=? C<EICH<?G B;9B B;=F OI=G=<B 9< H<aHGBAMA9JD= ;9IL BC CB;=IG ! B;=G=9:BAC<G @ACD9B= B;= ;9IL I=GBIA:BAC<8 !B;=I 9:BAC<G CI OCDA:A=G L9FJ= OIC;AJAB=? J=:9HG= B;=F H<aHGBAMA9JDF A<@9?= OIA@9B= ?CL9A<G8%=<=BA:9DDF OI=?AGOCGA<E FCHI CMMGOIA<E BC DA@= A< O9A< CI BC EIC>9 B;AI? 9ILN :9HGA<E FCHI :;AD? BC J=:CL= 9MMDA:B=? >AB; :9<:=INOCCI =F=GAE;BN 9<? ?A9J=B=GN 9I= 9DD 9:BAC<G B;9B OIAL9 M9:A=>9II9<B OICG=:HBAC<8 +CI=C@=IN AM B;=I= AG =@A?=<:= B;9B GCL=C<=AG 9JCHB BC OIC?H:= B;=G= ;9ILG B;=< GHI=DF A<B=I@=<BAC< AG>9II9<B=?8 4HB 9<CB;=I >9FN OICO=IBF IAE;BG 9<? OIA@9:F IAE;BG 9I=aHGBAMA9JDF C@=IIA??=< A< B;=G= :9G=G8 VHB =@=< AM E=<=BA: ;9IL AG?C<= BC GCL= :;AD? AB L9F J= OCGGAJD= BC :CII=:B ?=M=:BG JFLC?AMFA<E L9BHI= :=DDG B;CHE; GCL9BA: E=<= B;=I9OF8

#C<= CM B;AGN ;C>=@=IN G9<:BAC<G 9 <9BAC<9D ?9B9J9G=:C<B9A<A<E A<?A@A?H9D E=<=BA: OICMAD=G CI CHBD9>A<E GCL9BA: 9<?E=IL DA<= B;=I9OF GALODA:AB=I8 ';= <CILG B;9B EHA?= HG 9G BC>;=< 9<? >;=I= AB AG 9OOICOIA9B= BC A<B=IM=I= >AB; M9LADF DAM=G;CHD? EHA?= HG A< E=<=BA: LC?AMA:9BAC< :9G=G 9G >=DD8 $M 9 O9I=<BB9W=G 9:BAC< B;9B >ADD I=GHDB A< G=IACHG ;9IL BC ;AG ?=G:=<?9<BGNMCI =Z9LOD= HGA<E E=<=BA: LC?AMA:9BAC< B=:;<AKH=G BC :9HG= B;=L

!"#$#% %&#&'$( $#)!*+,'$!# XXX

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

BC ?=@=DCO A<CO=I9JD= B;IC9B :9<:=IN B;=< B;= OIA@9:FOI=GHLOBAC< >CHD? ;9@= J==< C@=IIA??=<8 +CI=C@=IN B;CG=>;C ?=@=DCO GH:; =<;9<:=L=<B B=:;<AKH=G G;CHD? J= DA9JD= 9G>=DD8 ";AD= B;= B;I=G;CD? MCI C@=IIA?A<E B;= OI=GHLOBAC<G CMOIA@9:F 9<? OICO=IBF AG :C<B=<BACHGN AB AG <CB 9G AM >= ;9@= BCI=A<@=<B B;= >;==D >AB; =9:; <=> 9?@9<:= A< B=:;<CDCEF8 1ALODFOHBN B;= 9IEHL=<BG B;9B =GB9JDAG; 9 GBIC<E OI=GHLOBAC< A< M9@CICM OIA@9:F 9<? OICO=IBF A< B;= D9GB B>C G=:BAC<G G=B 9 M9AIDF ;AE;B;I=G;CD? MCI B;= aHGBAMA=? @ACD9BAC< CM B;=G= IAE;BG8 .9OOADFN B;=G=:D9ALG E=<=I9DDF 9::CLLC?9B= :HII=<B LCI9D 9<? D=E9D <CILG8

$< OI=G=<BA<E B;=G= :9G=G $ ;CO= BC =GB9JDAG; B;= MHBADABF CM<9BAC<9DN CI =@=< A<B=I<9BAC<9DN D9>G OIC;AJABA<E E=<==<;9<:=L=<B A< ;HL9< GHJa=:BG8 1H:; D9>G 9I= H<=<MCI:=9JD=9<? >CHD? 9DLCGB :=IB9A<DF G9<:BAC< H<aHGBAMA9JD= A<B=IM=I=<:=G>AB; A<?A@A?H9D DAJ=IBF 9<? OIA@9:F8 1=<?A<E 9 :;AD? BC 9 O9IC:;A9DG:;CCD AG 9 MCIL CM =<@AIC<L=<B9D =<;9<:=L=<B B;9B L9<F MA<??AGB9GB=MHD8 #=@=IB;=D=GGN B;AG 9:BA@ABF AG E=<=I9DDF I=:CE<Ad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aHGBAMA9JD= A<B=IM=I=<:= A< OIA@9B= ?CL9A<G8

$*1 ,5/+-0 (-)3.1 58 +()-(2+601 ?5.E,

, :CLLC< @A=> 9JCHB B;= A<MCIL9BAC< MCH<? A< B;= ;HL9<E=<CL=N C<= B;9B L9F H<?=ILA<= OICO=IBF IAE;BGN AG B;9B B;AGA<MCIL9BAC< AG OHJDA:DF C><=? ! B;HG C><=IG;AO :D9ALG BC E=<=BA:=<;9<:=L=<B B=:;<AKH=G L9F J= H<?=ILA<=?8 &@=< AM B;AG @A=>>=I= 9<F ECC? AB >CHD? GBADD <CB 9HBCL9BA:9DDF G9<:BAC< G>==OA<EEC@=I<L=<B I=EHD9BAC<G :C<:=I<A<E E=<=BA: =<;9<:=L=<BB=:;<AKH=G8 0#&1(!bG $<B=I<9BAC<9D VAC=B;A:G (CLLABB== ;9GHIE=? EC@=I<L=<B I=EHD9BAC< CM 9DD E=<=BA: I=G=9I:; J=:9HG= B;=;HL9<= E=<CL= AG B;= :CLLC< ;=IAB9E= CM ;HL9<ABF8 !<= @A=>AG B;9B FCH L9F ;9@= B;= IAE;B BC :;9<E= FCHI C>< E=<=G JHB FCHL9F <CB L9W= :;9<E=G B;9B >ADD J= A<;=IAB=? JF MHBHI=E=<=I9BAC<G8 c';= ?I9MB 0#&1(! I=GCDHBAC< ?C=G<bB IHD= CHB

XXQ ,-,+ -8 +!!*&

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

GCL9BA: B;=I9OFN >;A:; 9DB=IG B;= -#, C<DF A< L9BHI= :=DDG8%=ILDA<= B;=I9OF AG B;= <CT<CN GA<:= AB :;9<E=G -#, A< GO=IL CIC@9N 9<? B;CG= :;9<E=G >ADD J= O9GG=? C< BC =@=IF GHJG=KH=<BE=<=I9BAC<8bX_

4ICO=IBF IAE;BG 9I= a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

6C:W= ;ALG=DM HG=G =Z9LOD=G B;9B OCA<B BC B;= GC:A9D <9BHI= CMOIC?H:BAC< e$*1 #1/5(; $.1-)+,1 58 U5@1.(:1()N 1=:BAC< \_f8 VHBAM B;= GWADDGN BCCDGN CI A<@=<BAC< B;9B 9I= HG=? A< D9JCIA<E 9I= <CBGALODF B;= OIC?H:B CM B;= A<?A@A?H9DbG =MMCIBN JHB 9I= A<GB=9?B;= OIC?H:B CM 9 :HDBHI= CI 9 GC:A=BFN G;CHD? <CB B;= EICHO;9@= GCL= :D9AL C< >;9B A<?A@A?H9D D9JCI=IG OIC?H:=h )CI B;=D9JCI B;9B B;= A<?A@A?H9D A<@=GBG A<:DH?=G B;= OIACI D9JCI CML9<F CB;=IG8X\

, LAD? MCIL CM B;AG 9IEHL=<B L9F FA=D? 9 aHGBAMA:9BAC< MCI DALABA<EB;= C><=IG;AO IAE;BG CM 9HB;CIG 9<? A<@=<BCIG ! 9D9GN B;=G=A<?A@A?H9DG ?C <CB ?=G=I@= B;= MHDD @9DH= CM >;9B B;=F OIC?H:=

X_ (;9ID=G 4D9BB c&@CDHBAC< *=@CDHBAC<b S+.1; Q-2-A+(1 e]9<H9IF XSSUfN O8QPX8

X\ ,8 ]C;< 1ALLC<G $*1 R5/E1-( $*15.9 58 %+2*), e4IA<:=BC<N #8]82 4IA<:=BC<0<A@=IGABF 4I=GGN XSSQfN O8 QRS8

!"#$#% %&#&'$( $#)!*+,'$!# XX_

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

EA@=< >;9B B;=F OIC?H:= AGN A< O9IBN 9 GC:A9D OIC?H:B8 +9FJ= IHD=GB;9B DALAB A<B9<EAJD= OICO=IBF IAE;BG :9< J= aHGBAMA=? 9G CMM=IA<E 9BI9?=TCMM OCGABAC< J=B>==< A<?A@A?H9D =MMCIB 9<? GC:A9D A<OHBG8 ,LCI= I9?A:9D MCIL CM B;AG 9IEHL=<B L9F D=9? BC B;= =DALA<9BAC<CM A<B9<EAJD= OICO=IBF IAE;BG 9<? OIA@9:F IAE;BG 9G >=DD8 $MA<?A@A?H9DG 9I=N A< 9 ?==O >9FN GC:A9D OIC?H:BG 9<? L9IW=B @9DH=9<? W<C>D=?E= 9I= 9G >=DDN B;=< B;= ICJHGB OICO=IBF IAE;BG MCH<?>AB;A< B;= ,<EDCT,L=IA:9< BI9?ABAC< 9I= GHGO=:B8 +CI=C@=INOIA@9:F AG C@=II9B=? EA@=< B;9B A<?A@A?H9DG G;CHD? J= G==< 9GO9IBG CM :CLLH<ABA=G ! >;F G;CHD? B;=I= J= G=:I=BGh

';AG 9IEHL=<BN A< =AB;=I @=IGAC<N AG ?=MA:A=<B MCI G=@=I9DI=9GC<G8 )AIGBN $ ?CHJB B;9B B;= <CBAC< CM cGC:A=BFb =LODCF=? A<B;AG @A=> AG :D=9I =<CHE; BC :9IIF B;= >=AE;B B;9B B;= 9IEHL=<B?=L9<?G8 $< GCL= @9EH= G=<G=N $ W<C> >;9B AB L=9<G BC G9F B;9B6A<:CD< >9G 9 L=LJ=I CM ,L=IA:9< ,5/+1)9 CI B;9B ,IAGBCBD=bGOCDABA:9D @A=>G >=I= A<MDH=<:=? JF 9<:A=<B %I==W ,5/+1)98#=@=IB;=D=GGN $ B;A<W B;9B B;= <CBAC< CM cGC:A=BFb AG :C<:=OBH9DDFALOI=:AG= ! C<= B;9B AB >CHD? J= ?HJACHG BC 9BB9:; C><=IG;AO CICJDAE9BAC< :D9ALG BC8 ';CG= >;C >CHD? ?=M=<? B;AG @A=> >CHD?;9@= BC :D9IAMF B;= <CBAC<G CM cGC:A=BFb 9<? cGC:A9D OIC?H:Bb J=MCI=B;= 9IEHL=<B :CHD? J= MHDDF 9<9DFd=?8

VHB GHOOCG= MCI B;= G9W= CM 9IEHL=<B B;9B GHOOCIB=IG CM B;AG@A=> :CL= HO >AB; 9 :C<:AG= <CBAC< CM cGC:A=BFb 9<? cGC:A9DOIC?H:Bb8 "= L9F 9GW MHIB;=IN >;F B;A<W B;9B GC:A=BA=G :9< J= 5?1;GCL=B;A<E CI B;9B B;=F :9< 5?( CI ;1,1.@1 GCL=B;A<Eh #CBAC<G CM5?(1.,*+4N 5?+(2N CI ;1,1.@+(2 ?C<bB 9OO=9I BC L9W= G=<G= >;=<9BB9:;=? BC B;= :C<:=OB CM cGC:A=BFb8 $M GC 9<? AM ?AMM=I=<B GC:A=BA=G:9< 5?( W<C>D=?E=N ?C B;=F <CB ;9@= B;= OICJD=L CM CIAEA<9D9:KHAGABAC<hX` 1HI=DFN AB ?C=G <CB MCDDC> MICL B;= :D9AL B;9B [ AG 9GC:A9D OIC?H:B B;9B GC:A=BF C><G [8 6AW=>AG=N AB ?C=G <CB MCDDC>MICL B;= :D9AL B;9B [ AG OIC?H:=? JF %A<E=IN B;9B %A<E=I C><G [8$B AG BIH= B;9B A<B=I9:BAC<G J=B>==< A<?A@A?H9DG L9F OIC?H:=A<:I=9G=? L9IW=B @9DH=G CI 9?? BC B;= :CLLC< GBC:W CMW<C>D=?E=8 ";9B $ ?=<F AG B;9B B;=G= JFTOIC?H:BG CM A<B=I9:BAC<NL9IW=B @9DH= 9<? G;9I=? A<MCIL9BAC<N 9I= A< GCL= G=<G= C><=?JF GC:A=BF CI B;9B GC:A=BF AG C>=? MCI B;=AI HG=8 ";F 9GGHL= B;AG>AB;CHB 9IEHL=<Bh $B AG C<= B;A<E BC :D9AL B;9B A<MCIL9BAC< 9<?W<C>D=?E= AG 9 GC:A9D OIC?H:B ! GCL=B;A<E JHADB HO JF B;CHG9<?GCM A<?A@A?H9D :C<BIAJHBAC<G ! JHB KHAB= 9<CB;=I BC :D9AL B;9B B;AGW<C>D=?E= AG C><=? JF GC:A=BF CI B;9B A<?A@A?H9DG >;C HG= B;AGA<MCIL9BAC< C>= GC:A=BF GCL=B;A<E A< I=BHI<8 6FG9<?=I 1OCC<=I9IEH=? B;9B C<=bG :HDBHI= CI GC:A=BF OD9FG 9DLCGB <C ICD= A< B;=

X` 1== #CdA:WN !(-./*9N O8 XUY8

XX\ ,-,+ -8 +!!*&

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

OIC?H:BAC< CM A?=9G8 c#CB;A<E AGN JF ABG C>< =GG=<:= 9<? <9BHI=NLCI= O=IM=:BDF GHG:=OBAJD= CM =Z:DHGA@= 9OOICOIA9BAC<N B;9< 9B;CHE;B8 $B CIAEA<9B=G A< B;= LA<? CM 9 GA<ED= A<?A@A?H9D8 $B :9<D=9@= ;AG LA<? C<DF A< CJ=?A=<:= BC ;AG >ADD8 $B ?A=G >AB; ;ALN AM ;=GC =D=:B8bXR

1HOOCG= B;9B )I=? 9<? %A<E=IN 9DC<E >AB; <HL=ICHG CB;=IGNA<B=I9:B 9<? J=<=MAB L= A< B;= MCDDC>A<E >9F8 ';=AI A<B=I9:BAC<OIC?H:=G W<C>D=?E= B;9B AG B;=< MI==DF G;9I=? 9<? 9DDC>G L= BC:I=9B= GCL= <=> @9DH=N 58 0OC< :I=9BAC< CM 5N )I=? 9<? %A<E=I?=L9<? B;9B B;=F 9I= C>=? GCL=B;A<E MCI B;=AI O9IB8 VHB >;9B AGB;= 9IEHL=<B MICL B;AI? O9IBF J=<=MABG BC ?=L9<?G CM:CLO=<G9BAC< MCI B;=G= J=<=MABG ! >;F B;A<W B;9B B;=I= 9I=cGBIA<EGb 9BB9:;=? BC 8.1109 G;9I=? A<MCIL9BAC<h $M GH:; 9<9IEHL=<B :9< J= L9?=N B;=< AB AG OD9HGAJD= 9G >=DD BC L9A<B9A<B;9B JHI?=<G :I=9B= I=@=IG= ?=L9<?G8 1HOOCG= B;9B B;=A<B=I9:BAC< CM )I=? 9<? %A<E=I OIC?H:=G M9DG= A<MCIL9BAC< B;9BAG MI==DF G;9I=?8 1HOOCG= MHIB;=I B;9B $ >9GB= B=< F=9IG BIFA<E BCOIC?H:= GCL= @9DH= J9G=?N A< O9IBN C< B;AG M9DG= A<MCIL9BAC<8"CHD? )I=? 9<? %A<E=IN >CHD? GC:A=BFN C>= L= :CLO=<G9BAC<h';= OCGABAC< B;9B cGBIA<EGb 9I= 9BB9:;=? A< B;AG :9G= IH<G O9I9DD=DBC #CdA:WbG J=<=MAB cMCAGBA<Eb =Z9LOD=8 $< #CdA:WbG :9G= 9 J=<=MABAG MCAGB=? C< GCL=C<= 9<? B;=< O9FL=<B AG ?=L9<?=?8 ';AGG==LG 9< 9::HI9B= 9::CH<B CM >;9B AG ECA<E C< A< B;AG :9G= 9G >=DD8

!<= :9<<CBN >;9B=@=I C<=bG OHIOCG=GN aHGB 9:B GC 9G BC EA@=O=COD= J=<=MABG 9<? B;=< ?=L9<? eCI G=Ad=f O9FL=<B8 #CI :9<9 EICHO CM O=IGC<G ?C B;AG8 $M FCH L9F <CB :;9IE= 9<? :CDD=:BMCI J=<=MABG FCH J=GBC> >AB;CHB OIACI 9EI==L=<BN FCH :=IB9A<DFL9F <CB ?C GC MCI J=<=MABG >;CG= J=GBC>9D :CGBG FCH <CB;A<EN9<? LCGB :=IB9A<DF O=COD= <==? <CB I=O9F FCH MCI :CGBD=GGTBCTOIC@A?= J=<=MABG >;A:; F=B 5)*1., OIC@A?=? B;=L8 1C B;= M9:BB;9B >= O9IBA9DDF 9I= cGC:A9D OIC?H:BGb A< B;9B >= J=<=MAB MICL:HII=<B O9BB=I<G 9<? MCILG :I=9B=? JF B;= LHDBABH?A<CHG9:BAC<G CM 9 DC<E GBIA<E CM DC<ETMCIECBB=< O=COD=N MCILG >;A:;A<:DH?= A<GBABHBAC<GN >9FG CM ?CA<E B;A<EGN 9<? D9<EH9E=N ?C=G<CB :I=9B= A< HG 9 E=<=I9D MI== MDC9BA<E ?=JB >;A:; B;= :HII=<BGC:A=BF :9< :CDD=:B 9<? HG= 9G AB >ADD8XU

$ >CHD? 9IEH= B;9B B;AG AG 9DGC BIH= CM L9IW=B @9DH=8 %A@=< CHI:IH?= CAD =Z9LOD=N B;= L9IW=B @9DH= CM B;= CAD AG B;= GF<=IEAGBA:

XR 6FG9<?=I 1OCC<=IN $*1 R-? 58 '()1001/)3-0 N.541.)9P 5. !( T,,-9 5( )*1 %+2*) 58!3)*5., -(; '(@1()5., )5 - N1.41)3-0 N.541.)9 +( $*1+. ';1-,N A< $*1 &5001/)1; S5.E, 58R9,-(;1. #455(1.N =?AB=? JF (8 1;A@=DF eXSUXfN O8 `Y8

XU #CdA:WN !(-./*9N O8 S`8

!"#$#% %&#&'$( $#)!*+,'$!# XX`

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

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cJHB B;AG >9G <CB O9IB CM B;= IHD=G CM B;=E9L=N 9<? AM AB >9GN AB G;CHD? ;9@= J==< GB9B=? J=MCI= B;=A<@=GBL=<B >9G L9?=b8

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cS*-) IAE;BG GC:A=BF ;9@=N A<A?=9GN >;A:; B;=F ?A? <CB OIC?H:=N 9<? ;9@= <=@=I OHI:;9G=?N AB>CHD? OICJ9JDF J= @=IF ?AMMA:HDB BC ?=MA<=i 9<? =KH9DDF ?AMMA:HDB BC=ZOD9A< *5? GC:A=BF J=:9L= OCGG=GG=? CM B;CG= IAE;BG8 $B :=IB9A<DFI=KHAI=G GCL=B;A<E LCI= B;9< 9GG=IBAC<N BC OIC@= B;9B JF GALODF:CLA<E BC 9 W<C>D=?E= CM :=IB9A< A?=9G ! B;= OIC?H:BG CMA<?A@A?H9D D9JCI ! GC:A=BF 9:KHAI=G 9<F @9DA? BABD= BC B;=LN CIN:C<G=KH=<BDFN 9<F .+2*), A< B;=L8bXY

VHB C<:= 9E9A<N GHOOCG= MCI B;= G9W= CM 9IEHL=<B B;9B B;=?=M=<?=I CM B;AG @A=> :9< aHGBAMF GC:A=B9D C><=IG;AO CM E=<=I9DOCCDG CM W<C>D=?E= 9<? A<MCIL9BAC<8 &@=< A< B;AG :9G= >= ;9@=9DI=9?F O9A? MCI B;= HG= CM B;AG :CDD=:BA@= >AG?CL >;=< >= O9F MCI=?H:9BAC< 9<? B;= DAW=8 ";=< 9 O9I=<B O9FGN B;ICHE; M==G CIB9Z9BAC<N MCI 9 :;AD?bG =?H:9BAC< AB >CHD? G==L B;9B B;=A<MCIL9BAC< ! O9IB CM GC:A=BFbG :CLLC< OCCD CM W<C>D=?E= !;9G J==< M9AIDF OHI:;9G=?8 ';AG =ZB=<?G B;ICHE; 9DD D=@=DG CM=?H:9BAC< 9<? =@=< BC A<?A@A?H9DG >;C <C DC<E=I 9BB=<? G:;CCD8

)A<9DDFN AB AG CJ@ACHGDF B;= :9G= B;9B B;= A<MCIL9BAC< MCH<? A<B;= ;HL9< E=<CL= AG ?AG:C@=I=? I9B;=I B;9< :I=9B=?8 ';=G= M9:BGL9F J= ?AG:C@=I=? JF 9<FC<= >;C :9I=G BC DCCW ;9I? =<CHE;8';= E=<=BA: =<;9<:=L=<B B=:;<AKH=G B;9B >ADD J= JHADB HOC< B;AGA<MCIL9BAC< 9I= :I=9B=? I9B;=I B;9< ?AG:C@=I=? ! 9D9GN B;=I= L9FJ= A<MA<AB=DF L9<F >9FG BC LC?AMF ;HL9< E=<=BA: GBIH:BHI=8 ';HGN

XY 1OCC<=IN $*1 R-? 58 '()1001/)3-0 N.541.)9N O8 XP_8

XXR ,-,+ -8 +!!*&

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

=@=< AM 9< 9IEHL=<B :CHD? J= L9IG;9DD=? B;9B aHGBAMA=? GC:A=B9DC><=IG;AO CM B;= A<MCIL9BAC< MCH<? A< B;= ;HL9< E=<CL= B;AG>CHD? <CB 9HBCL9BA:9DDF FA=D? :D9ALG BC :C<BICD =@=IF GHJG=KH=<BA<@=<BAC< J9G=? C< B;AG A<MCIL9BAC<8 ';HG AM $ 9L :CII=:BN B;=GC:A9D <9BHI= CM A<B=DD=:BH9D >CIWG 9IEHL=<B >ADD <CB H<?=ILA<=A<B9<EAJD= OICO=IBF IAE;BG BC :I=9BAC<G DAW= E=<=BA: =<;9<:=L=<BB=:;<AKH=G8

$*1 +(1=3-0+)9 -.23:1()

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

';AG @A=> AG GHJa=:B BC G=@=I9D ?=:AGA@= CJa=:BAC<G8 ,DLCGB =@=IFL=?A:9D 9?@9<:=L=<B 9B ABG J=EA<<A<E >9G 9@9AD9JD= C<DF BC B;=IA:;8 VF I=MA<A<E B;=G= 9?@9<:=L=<BG 9<? B=:;<AKH=G OIA:=G?ICOO=? >;A:; CO=<=? HO <=> L9IW=BG MCI B;CG= D=GG MA<9<:A9DDFMCIBH<9B=8 $< B;= =<?N OIC:=?HI=G B;9B >=I= C<:= :CGB OIC;AJABA@=9I= <C> 9@9AD9JD= BC =@=IFC<=8 ';=I= AG <C I=9GC< BC B;A<W B;9BE=<=BA: =<;9<:=L=<B OIC:=?HI=G >C<bB MCDDC> B;AG G9L= :CHIG=8$< M9:B CHI =<BAI= L9IW=B GFGB=L G==LG BC <=:=GGAB9B= B;AG WA<? CMA<=KH9DABF8 +CGB A<@=<BCIG 9<? :CLO9<A=G JHI< B;= LA?<AE;B CAD9<? :I=9B= CI ?AG:C@=I <=> 9<? I=@CDHBAC<9IF L=?A:9D OIC:=?HI=GA< CI?=I BC L9W= 9 OICMAB8 ';AG OIC:=GG I=KHAI=G D9IE= HO MIC<BA<@=GBL=<BG B;9B A< BHI< <=:=GGAB9B= ;AE;=I A<ABA9D OIA:=G >;=< 9@A9JD= :CLLC?ABF ?C=G :CL= BC L9IW=B8 #=@=IB;=D=GG GCC<=I CID9B=I B;= c;AE; OIA:=?b L9IW=B J=:CL=G G9BHI9B=? 9<? A< CI?=I BCL9A<B9A< OICMABG OIA:=G 9I= ?ICOO=?8 $M B;AG GFGB=L FA=D?G =@=IFC<=J=BB=I OICGO=:BG A< B;= =<?N B;= I=GHDBA<E A<ABA9D A<=KH9DABF CM?AGBIAJHBAC< AG ;9I?DF CJa=:BAC<9JD=8

+CI=C@=IN =@=< AM E=<= B;=I9OF B=:;<AKH=G I=L9A< =ZO=<GA@=B;= D=@=DA<E =MM=:B 9GGHL=? A< B;= A<=KH9DABF 9IEHL=<B G==LGA<?=M=<GAJD=8 1HOOCG= B;9B 9GOAIA<TODHG AG A<@=<B=? 9<? :HI=G >AB;EI=9B =MMA:A=<:F ;=9?9:;=G 9<? :CD?G8 ';= :CGB CM 9GOAIA<TODHGN;C>=@=IN AG @=IF ;AE; ! GHOOCG= j`PP O=I OADD8 ,I= >= BC OIC;AJABB;= L9<HM9:BHI= 9<? 9?LA<AGBI9BAC< CM 9GOAIA<TODHG J=:9HG= AB AGH<M9AI B;9B GCL= >ADD J= 9JD= BC MCIEC B;= GHMM=IA<E JCHE;B C< JF:CD?G 9<? ;=9?9:;=G >;AD= CB;=IG >ADD <CBh ';AG GCH<?G DAW=

!"#$#% %&#&'$( $#)!*+,'$!# XXU

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

GALOD= =<@F 9<? L=9< GOAIAB=?<=GG BC L= ! cAM $ :9<bB ;9@= ABN B;=<<C C<= :9<b CI cAM $ ;9@= BC GHMM=IN B;=< GC ?C=G =@=IFC<= =DG=b8 6=BHG ?AGO=<G= >AB; B;= <CBAC< B;9B A<?A@A?H9DG >;C ;CD? B;=G=G=<BAL=<BG 9I= 9:BH9DDF :C<:=I<=? >AB; D=GG=<A<E ;HL9<GHMM=IA<E8

#C> AB LAE;B J= 9IEH=? B;9B LF 9GOAIA<TODHG :9G= 9<? B;= GC:A9DI9LAMA:9BAC<G CM 9DDC>A<E E=<=BA: =<;9<:=L=<B BC OICDAM=I9B= 9I=>AD?DF ?A@=IE=<B8 (HIA<E ;=9?9:;=G 9<? :CD?G ?C=G <CB ALO9:B 9<A<?A@A?H9DbG =<BAI= DAM= A< B;= >9F B;9B E=<=BA: L9<AOHD9BAC< ?C=G8VHB ;=I= 9E9A< >= JHLO 9E9A<GB CB;=I MCILG CM =<;9<:=L=<B !B=9:;A<E FCHI :;AD? BC I=9?N D=9I<A<E BC OD9F :;=GGN ECA<E BC:CDD=E=N OD9FA<E GOCIBGN <HIBHIA<E LHGA:9D 9JADABA=GN ?=@=DCOA<EB;= @AIBH= CM G=DMT:C<BICD ! B;9B AB >CHD? G==L ADDA:AB BC D=E9DDFOIC;AJAB =@=< B;CHE; B;=F =9:; ALO9:B 9< A<?A@A?H9DbG =<BAI= DAM=8+9<F CM B;=G= =Z9LOD=G 9I= OHIOCG=DF 9LJAEHCHG A< B;9B B;=FL9F J= B;A<EG >= ?C BC CHIG=D@=G CI B;A<EG B;9B >= ?C BC CB;=IG8)=> >CHD? ?=<F B;9B O9I=<BG >;C :I=9B= =<@AIC<L=<BG B;9BOIC?H:= B;=G= :;9I9:B=IAGBA:G G;CHD? J= GBCOO=?8 ";9B AM B;=G==<;9<:=L=<BG :CHD? J= E=<=BA:9DDF OIC?H:=? ! >;F >CHD?=<@AIC<L=<B9D =<;9<:=L=<B CI L9<AOHD9BAC< J= O=ILABB=? F=BB;= E=<=BA: J9G=? :CH<B=IO9IB OIC;AJAB=?h !<= 9<G>=I AG B;9B B;=MCIL=I AG B=LOCI9IFN =<?A<E >AB; B;= DAM= CM B;= O=IGC< A<@CD@=?N>;AD= B;= D9BB=I >ADD J= O9GG=? ?C>< BC 9DD GHJG=KH=<BE=<=I9BAC<G8 VHB B;AG AG :D=9IDF M9DG= EA@=< B;9B =<@AIC<L=<B9D=<;9<:=L=<BG L9F J= O9GG=? C< BC C<=bG :;AD?I=< 9<? AB AGOCGGAJD= B;9B E=<=BA: =<;9<:=L=<BG L9F J= 9DB=I=? >AB; GCL9BA:B;=I9OF8

!<= GCIB CM I=ODF BC B;AG @A=> AG EA@=< JF ';= (CH<:AD MCI*=GOC<GAJD= %=<=BA:GN >;A:; COOCG=G E=ILDA<= LC?AMA:9BAC<H<:C<?ABAC<9DDF8 c';= :HDBHI9D ALO9:B CM BI=9BA<E ;HL9<G 9GJACDCEA:9DDF O=IM=:BAJD= 9IBAM9:BG >CHD? J= =<BAI=DF <=E9BA@=84=COD= >;C M9DD G;CIB CM GCL= B=:;<A:9DDF 9:;A=@9JD= A?=9D >CHD?J= cc?9L9E=? ECC?Gbb8 ,<? AB AG :D=9I B;9B B;= GB9<?9I?G MCI >;9B AGE=<=BA:9DDF ?=GAI9JD= >ADD J= B;CG= CM GC:A=BFbG =:C<CLA:9DDF 9<?OCDABA:9DDF ?CLA<9<B EICHOG8 ';AG >ADD C<DF I=A<MCI:= OI=aH?A:=G9<? ?AG:IALA<9BAC< A< 9 GC:A=BF >;=I= B;=F 9DI=9?F =ZAGB8bXS

!J@ACHGDF $ ?AG9EI==8 ';=I= AG <C I=9GC< BC B;A<W B;9B E=<=LC?AMA:9BAC< CM 9<F GCIB >ADD <=:=GG9IADF D=9? BC cBI=9BA<E ;HL9<G9G JACDCEA:9DDF O=IM=:BAJD= 9IBAM9:BGb CI B;9B B;CG= >;C ?C<bB DA@=HO BC GCL= A?=9D >ADD J= @A=>=? 9G c?9L9E=? ECC?Gb8 +9FJ=E=<=BA:9DDF L9<AOHD9B=? A<?A@A?H9DG >ADD J= D9J=D=? 9G cH<<9BHI9Db

XS (CH<:AD )CI *=GOC<GAJD=%=<=BA:GN.HL9<%=<=BA:G (CLLABB== e)9DDN XSSQfA< '8 V=9H:;9LO 9<? 68 "9B=IGN "+51)*+/,N \B; =?8 e"9?G>CIB;N XSS\fN O8 RUX8

XXY ,-,+ -8 +!!*&

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP

I9B;=I B;9< GHO=IACI8 +CI=C@=IN >;C >CHD? W<C> AM M9AIDF GBIC<EIAE;BG BC OIA@9:F >=I= A< OD9:=h

(!#(601$!#

$M $ 9L :CII=:B B;=I= AG 9 M9AIDF GBIC<E OI=GHLOBAC< A< M9@CI CMOIA@9:F 9<? A<B9<EAJD= OICO=IBF IAE;BG B;9B >ADD DALAB B;= WA<?G CMD=EAGD9BAC< B;9B ;9@= I=:=<BDF J==< CMM=I=? :C<:=I<A<E E=<=BA:I=G=9I:; 9<? E=<= B;=I9OF8 )HIB;=ILCI=N B>C :CLLC<DF :AB=?9IEHL=<BGN B;= GC:A9D <9BHI= CM A<B=DD=:BH9D >CIWG 9IEHL=<B 9<?B;= A<=KH9DABF 9IEHL=<BN M9AD BC aHGBAMF C@=IIA?A<E B;=G= IAE;BG8";AD= B;=I= AG LH:; LCI= BC J= G9A? :C<:=I<A<E B;=G= AGGH=G $>CHD? HIE= :9HBAC< A< 9 ?AMM=I=<B ?AI=:BAC< 9<? OHB B;= JHI?=< CMOICCM A< 9 ?AMM=I=<B OD9:=8 6=B OICO=IBF IAE;BG 9<? OIA@9:F IAE;BGGB9<? A< B;= 9JG=<:= CM GBIC<E C@=IIA?A<E I=9GC<G8 $< B;= =<?N ABG==LG B;9B >= 9I= ;=9?=? BC>9I? 9 >CID? B;9B A<:DH?=G :DC<=M9ILGN CIE9< J9<WGN 9<? E=<=BA: L9<AOHD9BAC<8 $M GCN D=B HG 9B D=9GBM9:= B;AG MHBHI= >AB; CHI J9GA: IAE;BG CM OICO=IBF 9<? OIA@9:FA<B9:B8

S.+2*) #)-)1 W(+@1.,+)9

!"#$#% %&#&'$( $#)!*+,'$!# XXS

" VD9:W>=DD 4HJDAG;=IG 6B?8 QPPP