!1436˝ 2015 ˘ , 273 − 249 # # , 2 ,27

25
, 27 , 2 , 2015 1436 249 , 27 , 2 , 249 273 , 2015 1436 1 , 2 15 02 1436 ; 30 04 1436 : , , , , 65 592 , α=0.05 , , , , , : , , , , , _________________________________________________________________________ ________ Effect of Some Demographics’ Variables on the Availability Degree of Entrepreneurial Skills of Sultan Qaboos University Students Wajeha Thabit Al-Ani (1) , and Aisha Salim Al-Harthi (2) Sultan Qaboos University (Received 07/12/2014; accepted 19/02/2015) Abstract: Acquiring the entrepreneurship culture for university students has become a necessity to enter the competitive labor market. This study aims to investigate the availability of entrepreneurship skills and the effect of some demographic variables. The study used a descriptive research design with a questionnaire of 65 skills. The study sample was 592 students at Sultan Qaboos University in Oman. Study results showed that SQU students possessed these skills at a moderate to a high level with the highest mean score for personal skills and the lowest mean score for technical skills. For the effect of demographic variables, gender differences showed statistical significance differences (α=0.05) for the leadership skills favoring female students. Statistical differences were also found in the desire variable favoring those with a desire to start an entrepreneurial project compared with those who did not report this desire, the college variable favoring colleges of medicine, education and engineering, and the housing variable favoring students living on campus compared with that off-campus with a family. No statistical differences were found for the entrepreneurial experience variable. The study concluded with some recommendations, which included establishing training strategies for university students in entrepreneurship with systems and regulations to sponsor their entrepreneurial initiative. Keywords: entrepreneurial skills, demographic variables, gender, desire, residence, college. _________________________________________________________________________ ________ 1 , , , , 31 , 123 (1) Associate Professor in the Department of Educational Foundations and Administration at Sultan Qaboos University. Muscat, Sultanate of Oman, P.O. Box (31) , Postal Code: (123) : [email protected] e-mail: 2 , , (2) Assistant Professor in the Department of Educational Foundations and Administration at Sultan Qaboos University.

Transcript of !1436˝ 2015 ˘ , 273 − 249 # # , 2 ,27

�� �������� ���� ���� ,27 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

– 249 –

�� �������� ���� ���� ,27 � ��� ,�2�# # , 249 − 273����� , ��2015��1436 !�

���� ��� �� �� �������� ����� ������� ���� ��� � !�� ��� "# $%� &��'�� ���(!)�

�$�* +,�-���� +���.10* ,$���2� 3�4 +,� 56�#.20

%��& '�(�)�� ��*�+ � , -.�� � &15�02�1436; !-.�� 01&2 , 30�04�1436 !�

)�!�8�9:3145 ��� �6�78 9�):;� <������ 0= � �*�>� � 1�? '� @� A @�2 ,�) 6�.�� B =@C <D�� 0=��� E�F , ��*�>� �1�? G�H � �*IJ KL2M NO�PH �6�Q R* J S����L5 �.! R*2 ,�T�@�:=� �.U�* V�L�W* 25 VXF 2 Y6 ! �F�L �� ZD![\ R] ^_@�� �+L� R * �.U] ` � �������� V�L�W�� �6�Q

�1�?�(�)�� ��*�+ �WU�] �U6��a�=� �� V�bc:�� d� b8eQ2 ,'X] �.(�) %��& ' fg�2�+ R] �5Ah 4��� iW. �� �� j: F� k Q � F�L �� ��l F,2 \ �� ] R* �m�@* �m�1:F��65 �n� , K������ V�L�W* R* KL�W*GX]f R* �F�L �� �.U] Ym�@Q�592 ��1��?2 �1��? f2� �6� Q �+L� '5 �F�L �� iO�:m V�Wo5 V�L� W�

V�L�W�� L�p q�+ rUs �(F�:��2 �U����� S Ys2��Q ���������� tF�:* u]e; �UPj_ ,v�)st F�:* 0 &e; � U.7:�� V�L� W�� L� p2v�) s f2 V� Wo5 �F�L ����+2 ���� E2�6 \�UO�Ps `�:)* .] �α=0.05� w� 3��P� ����U7�� V�L�W�� L�p , x�.�� bc:* ,bc:* ,2 ,y�m <�� �L x2- * 0 =] , �1a���

R@) �� � 1�? 3��P� R@)�� bc:* ,2 ,�F .z�2 �U��2 {(�� V�U�; �1�? 3��P� �U�@�� bc:* ,2 ,|�} , S1a���� 3��P� , ~H� �� 0 �7* , � �*�>�K��� bc:� �1).�� �UO�Ps\ ���� E2�h�� R@Q �2 ,K�n� �* A�*�>� R@)�� �L�H �1�(���������� f V�U 4�:�� R * � ��� ��2 kQ �F�L �� iO�:m q�� ,2

�W.* V�s7��2 ��2\ �1�(�� �U1�L Q V�U�UQ�F SU�*�>�n� K���L G�� ,GX]2 , y� �:F�5��L��1* ���]�� Sm��&2 �=�mk�������� f

�� �;�<)�$=�!>: �������� V�L�W��,�U6��a�=� �� V�bc:�� x�.�� ,,�1a��� , �U�@�� ,R@)�� '�@*f _________________________________________________________________________________

Effect of Some Demographics’ Variables on the Availability Degree of Entrepreneurial

Skills of Sultan Qaboos University Students

Wajeha Thabit Al-Ani(1), and Aisha Salim Al-Harthi(2) Sultan Qaboos University

(Received 07/12/2014; accepted 19/02/2015)

Abstract: Acquiring the entrepreneurship culture for university students has become a necessity to enter the competitive labor market. This study aims to investigate the availability of entrepreneurship skills and the effect of some demographic variables. The study used a

descriptive research design with a questionnaire of 65 skills. The study sample was 592 students at Sultan Qaboos University in Oman. Study

results showed that SQU students possessed these skills at a moderate to a high level with the highest mean score for personal skills and the lowest mean score for technical skills. For the effect of demographic variables, gender differences showed statistical significance differences

(α=0.05) for the leadership skills favoring female students. Statistical differences were also found in the desire variable favoring those with a

desire to start an entrepreneurial project compared with those who did not report this desire, the college variable favoring colleges of medicine, education and engineering, and the housing variable favoring students living on campus compared with that off-campus with a

family. No statistical differences were found for the entrepreneurial experience variable. The study concluded with some recommendations,

which included establishing training strategies for university students in entrepreneurship with systems and regulations to sponsor their entrepreneurial initiative.

Keywords: entrepreneurial skills, demographic variables, gender, desire, residence, college.

_________________________________________________________________________________

�1� }�:F5 �L�_* k)7 ,����� KL��w�2 G�4n� ,�(�)�� ��*�+'%��& t7)* ,'X] �.(�F , 9 #�31� < ���� �*��� ,�123�����

(1) Associate Professor in the Department of Educational Foundations and

Administration at Sultan Qaboos University.

Muscat, Sultanate of Oman, P.O. Box (31) , Postal Code: (123)

�2@�w� ����: [email protected] e-mail:

�2� �(�)�� ��*�+ ,����� KL��w�2 G�4n� k)7 , ]�)* }�:F5'%��& (2) Assistant Professor in the Department of Educational Foundations and

Administration at Sultan Qaboos University.

�WU+2����� Y�82 ,�U8L��� ��F �_O�]: b8eQ d���:*� �+L� u] �U6��a�=� �� V�bc:��fff

– 250 –

4��'�� $>�?$�@ ��2�*��:

�� A :�� K�� ��� VJ� �:�� 0o , U �� ] �W_ 0@ ��U��52 �z�@�5 � ��@h��2 � U6�7���2 �U=���� �W?Xm

�m ,�U+���.@:��25w� ' '�)m ,�� Fn� L� ��� � !\ {+2 �D� � � B �=:� �U=.Q , ���)=�� B.U@�2 Z�� ]

�L Q2 � U=U��Q i*�� R* B� � 7�1 � U B � � A =.Q { s2 K������� ��U�F L�@:J�2 � �:��2 KL��1� B �=:� q� .1�

2 0*�@:*2 0*�� 0@_e�� :)* <�=.Q 9��Ff 2 0=���2 K�U�� , S�+�.�� '5 [\ V�F�L �� b_Q

�� �.�� �*�] VXF2 NO�PH k� � ^ �:� ��:H� � � '��=�� A:�� V�lU1��2 V��=:���*� ; ��� FL kW;�:

,K�U���2tU (j:�� u] KL 7�� KL��\2 ,�� !n� � C2 V�D��, R�� H�� � * 0*��:�� u] KL 7��2 � �m � �(:��2

x� w�2 � �:��(Carswell & Gunaratne, 2003)f � �2'� ; � , K O�) �� � 6�7���2 � lU1��2 A ]X:+J� tU �=�

,� =:����2{�L :��2 kU ��:� k��L� W* � U=.Q , �L2� ;GX]n� K���L G�� , �4�H2 �6| �} ' x��w� { �(:�

,\K������ KL�W* ��*�>� �1�? 9�); K�� ����2 �� ] 0@_#� H 0@_ 0=��� E�F �* 0*��:�� ,; , k! ]�) Q

B =U&2 B U6 E�) �� k�m2 BQ�1�(:*2 �=:��� V�+�s kW6BQ�U&�H52, 2 ZLX�: F� R) s2 Y &��� kU�.Q E�? �6��*

0 =��� G� � , �U]�m V�bcQ R* y � �*2 (Werhane,

Posing, Gundry, Ofstein, & Powell, 2007)f

Y;L�5 �.! R*2 K����� V��=:����U�5 �;L�_ * � U�=:��� � U=.:�� , A�*� >� 9�1_ ��k!L� 1:]� �� :h*

b cQ '5 � �4�H ,�W:��s R* L & �U7C2 ���& 9�):;��F '�; X; �U(=.�� k):� ��] �* <D��  ��� 0=��� t=m ��7 ,

}\ V��.F YF 0; K�* x�.:Q2 0=��� #�6 � �:Q� ,�� ]2002� �:��2 ,, <�� ���� 0 =��� �6�78 9�):;� [\ �+���6

E� F , � �*�>� � 1�? G�H � � *IJ KL2M Y�145�)6�.�� B=@C <D�� 0=��� f u ] 0 =�Q A :�� � 6�7��� | �Q

,0 =��� E� F V�� C � * 0 *��:�� u ] KL 7�� k��);\2 { m�+ [\ |�- ; V�) F¡�� K��U&5 ��L�_ �� 9�� 4

BU6 R��=�:)��2�Bilimoria & Piderit, 2007, p. 119f� R * J S��� �L � �*�>� � 1�? '� @� A @�2

NO�PH5 L� �5 rUs ;�T�@�:=� �.U�* �UPj� VXF 2 �L�1*�2011 � VX) �� | �Q S �7U82 �&�] ��.! '5 [\

5 UQw� S 2 NO�P �� 2 k W;�L�\ , � U]� \ L� @6e '� q�U �n�2 �?� j�� Z� ¢ kWU ]2 � +L�2 � =:��� ���£7�

k�L &2 ,KL�£�� u] &2 ,�=:��� 0;�_* 0sQ '5 S 1 ��.!�� R* � ��� k!b a R] S������� �U� A:�� NO�P

<������ ���. ¡1.:�� �z�H R* �U(:)m A:��2 ;� W�5 R *w� [\ �+���2 �1a���2 ,I� �m K� @6 K�(U F u ] KL 7��

�UF�F52 ,�?�j�� 0=�:� �� �:FJ�f � ��� ��.! '5 X; R ] ^_ @:� Y== 4 A :�� ¤U�� 7��2 V�L�1:HJ� R*

� W.* �;D m <�� ���� �� h�� �UP j_�� V�hP��:L� 1:H�

�� �������� ���� ���� ,27 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

– 251 –

�The Mayers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI)�; rUs � ���5 ��L5 u] L�1:HJ� �D! .:F� �Ws&� A:�� �UPj_�

¥ h.�� ������Carl Gustav Jung �2A !: u ] �� :hmJ�R��H��2 ,%�)sw�2 ,b@h:��2 ,�� 7:��2 k@��f

� & X; R) 1*�Q2 R:��(Bolton & Thompson

2000) L�_�� �WU�\ , �L�1*�2011 �u] <�:C �=O�& � �;5 S�L5 R* �h4V�hP�� |�Q R* �;Dm S�������: V� 1���

,I� �mw� [\ � +���2 ,��) ��� K�?� j��2 ,�P ��2 ,�� ��2 �� !5 ��m B+�:��2 ,�U�2¡)�� G�C2 KL��1��2 �*�7: FJ�2 #� Hw�2 , � �:��2 L� @:J�2

�U��7:FJ�2 f X;5 '\ ��� F , V�hP �� ZD! 0�� �Um�@* {�(:� ,��h��¦:+� �lU b6�QX=U��Q2 �U6�782 �U]U:Q � ^P

< �:��2 K�*�c��,w� B� � I��Q2 ��L�e u ] L�� & ��6 Bm�:�� u] KL 7��2 ,K��U)��2 �(�)�� ��:*e�� , b8 ,R�� H

0 U��2\n� [� ������ b a2 K� (�� GX ]§� <��z� 1] ,K� ���21999 # ,65f� b_ � � .!2| �2�� 2006 �

'XU�F2�2005 �\ [5� h�� �W1) :@� A :�� V�� �� ' , ��� V�)F¡��: � 4��� � U�=��� V�7U1(:�� G�H R* �U=U��

A :�� A .W�� BU+�:��2 {�L :�� i*��2 ,<������ ���)�� �!�7�:� B:F�L� K6 q�.85 {��(��0 *����� R * �Q � =W��

Q�L�W* 074 u] 0=�Q A:��B 31P� A@� B:lU�2 �UPj_�� ������L f6  �Q �U=U��:�� V�)F¡��5 �U� ��� + ¨ U�2 � c�� 1F�.* �� � W*�U& G� H R * | �}2 ,�������� �U��2 K������

�n�2 L�@:J� V�.��s q�_m K������ kU��Q2 ,�������� GX]n� u ] �W:1�? {�L Q2GX ]f� I� �� B �; �D !2 � &���

n� , K�� ����2 A .W�� L��7�� }��� �U�=] S K U?��� GX ]:U�=] XT�;S*�@:* :�S:(1Q� *2 S, �� :� � ��;2 \ [

=U��Q � lU U �2L �� h�� , r �1Q K� U© NO�P H V�} � X; ,�W=U&2 K������5 1Q 0s��= '��=� XT5 AW:.Q2 A]���

X ; x� w�2 L� (:��2 �=.�� K� ���2 <�� z� 1] � W.U�1999� 3���� 0@_�� ,�1 � �D ! , B=U=P Q kQ <D��

r�1��f

A<5��.10B C�� �� D��!��* E,�)� �� F�� G�H� I� � ���

A=� �G�H�E,�)� �� F�� C�� �� D��!��

�WU+2����� Y�82 ,�U8L��� ��F �_O�]: b8eQ d���:*� �+L� u] �U6��a�=� �� V�bc:��fff

– 252 –

� �.�� G� H R *2\ 0@_ �� [�1� '5 �m �� 762 � �:Q 0 ,K�7:) * Y)U� ��h�� �U.W�� V�L�)�� � W��ª � © � U.W�� B Q�Us G�H ��h�� �� �=� V�h(�.�

�]�.:*2 K� �:*� ,� Q�U!2 �L�_U;2009 f�� '\ }\ }� ���7�� � ��(�� L�P :H� u ] 0=�� kU�)�� A.W�� L5 �� *

n� k� ]�)* , S������� ���6u] � * ��« �� ^U@:�� �2����2 � U=:Q A :��2 ��&�:�� ba2 ���W��� ^&����

�� L�@6n x�£�� � ]2 K�*�c�� K��] R��H5 �U�1:�� 2x� .:&J� '2� k z,2 5 , S�7:) * �� m�@� '5 k!L� @6

2 kWO�L¬2 kzX]5�Nehrt, 1987f��L� Y6 ! &2 � F�William, Schallenkamp & Eichholz, 2007 � [\

R] ^_@��5V�L�W�� k!}\ ,� ������� k Q �� ]\1: F� �m� m�@*� R* �17 ������L KL�W*, R���Q��� R* V�m�U1�� �­ kQ

AhUo��� ���(:�� �;��f52 � F�L �� iO� :m V�Wo5 '5 � �;:�� V�L�W�� KL� W* A ! � U��] � 1QL u ] Y�Ps A\ KL��

KL�W*2 ,V�U�=���\ ���) :�� KL� W*2 ,� U���� '2¡_�� KL���U1��2,Sm��7��2 V���-:�� KL�W*2 �UW�:�� KL�W*2 f

5 � F�L� � *�Pihie, Bagheri & Sani, 2012 � 76 6 ![\ Y � +L� R ] ^_ @�� � � 1�? ��: *

�* , � 4���  ���� kU��:�� V�)F¡* V�L� W=�� � ��U���������, , � U.W�� k��L� U:H� u ] �8¡Q A:�� 0*�����2

017:) ��f� R * � F�L �� � .U] Y�=: ��391 � 1��? �� �1��?2 f G�H R* V�m�U1�� �­ kQ\ �m�@* �m�1:F� �� ]

u]�50 �� ����L KL� W* f52 � F�L �� iO� :m V� Wo5 '�71 �% R*�1�(��n �U�6� �� k� � �� m�@� 'S��� �L, 2�74 �%'��P� kW.*u] R* k] �� 5 *�7U� k !�� �

S s , ,� ����L GX]e �67 �% '� @�:=� J kW. *5 <GX]n� G�� , K�H ,��] 0@_ 2�68 �% �1)� � kW.*

kz5GX ]n� K���L G�� , V�L�7* ��FL� ', 2�81 �% kW.*5u] �2 ; 5 K�� �L G� � , V�L� 7* � F�L� � U�

n�X]G f X;5 �F�L �� iO�:m V�Wo�1�(�� '5 '� @�:=� V�D �� kU �.Q�Self-Regulation � � U�]�h�� KL� W*2

�Self-Efficacy� K�� ���� �X: !J� KL� W*2 ,�Entrepreneurial-Intention�,�( F�:* � +L

� *�] � ����L V�L�W*2�General-Entrepreneurial f� X;5 � F�L �� iO�:m V�Woe �� .! ' &2�6� � +L� ,

L�;D �� S � ������� V�L� W=�� � F�L �� �.U] ��:*�L�;D�� 3��P�2 y�mw�2f

R*25 �+�s R] ^_@�� 0+�1�? V�L�W� ��*�>� R�-���2 <���� '�7�� {�(:=; K������ V�L�W*2 �6����

� F�L� Vq�+ 76�Boyles, 2012 � R ] ^_ @:�5 � U��� | �:� � �*�>� �1�? ��:*�V�L� W; }\ � ª�H G�� � J

'2 7:h�  ���� kU��:�� R* � ��� � ������� V�L�W��0 �* :w�2 , &�.�� b@h:�� KL�W*K�� U7��2 ,x� f &2 YP �H

��� �F�L ��5 �U) UOL V� ��h; y� 8 3 ��� �}� =m R * J � ����L5V� �*�>� � ª�H � W@�:=� ',A !2 :

�� �������� ���� ���� ,27 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

– 253 –

� U6��* V� ��h;�Cognitive-Competency� V� ��h;2 , �U]X:+��Social-Competency � V���h;25+�* GX]� W

�Action-Oriented Competencyf� G�s V��*�>� �1�? V�L�PQ R]25 �U=.Q �U�

� F�L� Vq� + ,� ������� G� � , k��L� W*2 k��L & �Chang & Rieple, 2013 � 3 ��:�5 R * � W:U=.Q � U�

A1�L Q i*�m� iO�:m kUU7Q G�H � 1�? {�L Q u] kO�&n� �FL�© u] ��*�>� G�� , �U7U7s �lU , �������� GX]

n� K���LG� ��2 GX]f52 � F�L �� iO� :m V� Wo �� +2 k��L� W* � �m � 1�(�� V�L�P Q , �� ��2 V�b UcQ

n� � �s��� , � 4�H2 � ������� , kW:;L�_ * R * [2 S� ��* i*� m����� +2� 17 �h. 4 �� R * 5 4 ��.

�������� V�L�W��5�;L�� 5i*� m��� G�H R* �W:U� f5 � * K��] �F�L��2011 �Y6 ! 76[\ � +L� R ] ^_@��

�!� ] ¯ � �1�(�� R* �l6 ��:*��100 � � 1��?2 { ��? Ys2��Q5S k!LX]� 9 −16� � ������� V�L� W=�� �. F

� � x2- * � U1(Q G�H R*[\ 9�1_ �� q� 7QLJ� UP j� k W62k��,k��L & ��_ :;� u ] 0 =���2 ,

k� � ^�£��2 K�7�� °�7. kWh���Q2f i*� m��� '� @Q R*5�U)UOL L2�p ��L,A ! :~17:) *2 ,±� Us2 ,±�} ,

A.?22 f5 � F�L �� iO� :m V� Wo5 R * � ��� �� .! ' { ª A :�� �������� V�L�W��5 R * � lh�� ZD ! � W@�:� '

�1�(��,A!2 :_�� 0s V�L�W*w� V�L�W*2 ,V�@ K��L

KL�W*2 ,¤h.�� �7���2\K��U7�� KL�W*2 ,V�D�� KL��f

5 � * � F�L� k�� @�� 1]2 =p�2011 � 76 ^_ @�� Y6 ! R ]n� K�� �L � &�2 � =:��� , GX ]

A.U() �h��, ����. F Sª� �� � ] 0P � r Us R * � U.W�� !����2 V��*�>�\ [�25 �5i�� H ^ � ,25 '

s�1�� �1)m 0P Q 0 =��� R ] S�\ [�30 �%\ { m�+ [ V�l6 R* 0=��� R] S�s�1��5`�Hf52 iO� :.�� V�Wo

5 �1)m '�33 �% k z �1) � � kW.*5 �� Wh= ���= F '2 ,K�� ����5 '�50 �% ��L�_ * � *�&� �� 1a�� � kW. *2 ,� ����L5 '�50 �% ��;L � � kW. *5K�� ���� � U� f

52� F�L �� iO� :m V� Wo�� +2 |�D ; R * � ��� n� K���L G�� , V�&����GX],�W.* : t1Q� Q V� &��* V�&��*2 , �1�� �F�U)\ ,�U+���.@Q V�&��*2 ,��L��

� U:�:�� � U.1�� ^� � V� &��*2 , N 7m V� &��*2K m�)��2 �=]� �� V�)F¡�� f

n� ��+��* G�H R*2 V� F�L ��2 <��.�� 9� S1Q �7�)��5�] �����L V�L�W* ��.! ' � WU�] � h:* �*

A!2 : � U.h�� V�L�W��5 ,� ���U7�� V�L� W��2 ,� U.7:�� 22w� V�L� W��2 ,�UP j_�� V�L� W�� ,� �DUh.:�� � �L��

X; x� w� V�L�W*2 , &�.�� b@h:�� V�L�W*25 �� .! '5 x� .�� b c:=; �U6��a�=� �� V�bc:�� R* � ��� �£��L� ;}, \y� m�J�2 ����P :&J� � Uh���2 ,:+X � U]�Pihie, Bagheri & Sani, 2012� � U=U��:�� � �s��� ,

�WU+2����� Y�82 ,�U8L��� ��F �_O�]: b8eQ d���:*� �+L� u] �U6��a�=� �� V�bc:��fff

– 254 –

�Chang & Rieple, 2013 �Q �z A:��e ²�1* b852 b an� K���� �1�(�� �X:!� u] ²�1* ���Q � �4�H GX]

� V��*�>� R* Sª��� � ]U 0P\ �1)m [�120 �% X; ���� � W.U�Boyles, 2012�, ¤6� .:�� K�� �I2 ,

0=] �4�6 u] G�P�� f '� 6 ,� 7Q � * u ] �)UFeQ ZD ! q�� +\ � U�5

R] ^_@�� [\ � � �T�; R* ±eQ �F�L �� d� b8eQ � +L� u ] � 1a���2 K� ��2 � U6��a�=� �� V�b c:��

� �������� V�L�W=�� %��& '�(�)�� ��*�+ �1�? ��:*W: F�L� '\ }\ ,V�L� W�� | �Q V�²¡ � ^ ���Q � * �

Y�145 , � s2�(��2 0 ,�=W�� r�1�� VJ�� R* '2¡_ �=:W�� �U.?��� '�����2 �U�2 �� VX�.�� K .+5

n� K���L2 �1�(�� ,GX] '52F V�bc:�� ZD! b8eQ ]�)U X Sª�j�� A.W�� BU+�:�� , V�L��7�� }��� �U�=] ,

@�:=�'�! ]�) Q � ����L V�L� W* R * k ���W F , J�m0=��� E�F , ��* f

4��'�� �<5�:

B +��Q v� ��� R?� �� , V� �*�>� G�� Q J E� F , G�H �� � WUª�H � lU� , t1Q� Q V���4

,0=���}\ V� F�L �� R* � ��� iO�:m b_Q \[ �� +2 � +�� <D ��2 0 =��� E� F2 V��*�>� S K��6\ [

L�� 7�� }��� , �8¡Q A:�� V�bc:�� R* � ��� { F�.�� <�¡� <D��2 ,�1�(�� A.W�� 017:)=��\ b F , qt1�� [

k z �*� :) �� �U�17:) �� � U.W�� K�U��� AO�.1�� 0@_:���Gelardin, Sally, Muscat & Whitty, 2010 f� X 25n� K���L 'n� R * �Q A :�� V�L� W�� R * GX] L� *

n�2 9�1_ �� k:� A:�� V��=:��� , �UF�F\� ] k!�0 =��� E�)�2 �U�=��� K�U���}\ ; KL�� 1�� b_ Q �2 � ,

w�Q�FU�U ��� �w� �(j�� ����� L���� , �U�UQ�Fw�2 %��& '�(�)�� ��*�> ��F�:�� �UOXm2016−2020

\ [ �U�5 K�� �L2 L� @:J� , �UP P� V�L� 7* �� ?n�n� i*���� , GX]���;=2 ,��P �� V�} � U\ [5 U� �

V�L� W��2 &�.�� b@h:�� V�L�W* '�@�:=� �1�? i��� � �+�m �U.W* K�Us �U7C kz 0h@Q A:�� �U.W��� � �*�+

,%��& '�(�)��2014�; � F�L �� ZD ! Vq�+ �.! R* u] ��&��� �+L�� %��& '�(�)�� ��*�+ �1�? ��:*

k!��m �W+2 R* <������ 0=��� V�L�W� R @=� A:��2:m G�H R* k z �U F�L �� t (�� , ��.�� K��]\ �W�O�

,GX ]n� K�� �L G� � , �UPP� V�L�7* R=£:Q 'ew� G�H R* |�}2 R] ��+SUQ�� S��¡)��:

1 − '�(�) �� � �*�+ � 1�? ��: *� � +L� � *n� V�L�W� %��& ?k!��m �W+2 R* �������� GX]

2 − �� �* ��J� V�} E2�h\�UO�Ps `�:) * .] �α≥0.05� � +L� , � 1�(�� � �m �W+2 S � kW;�: *

n� V�L�W��������� GX]A:��2 `��Q \ [�� d� V�bc:=� ���?�U6��a

�� �������� ���� ���� ,27 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

– 255 –

4��'�� J�'KL:

1 − �� !n� � U7C [\ � U���� �F�L �� ´�)Q�UQ��:

2 − � W@�:=� A:�� �������� V�L�W�� R] ^_@���W+2 R* %��& '�(�)�� ��*�+ �1�?k!��m f

3 − �� �:��5 [\ � U6��a�=� �� V�b c:�� I� '�(�) �� � �*�+ � 1�? ��: *� � +L� u] �8¡8 A:��2

W=�� %��&��������� V�Lf

4 − � R * A:��2 V�s7�� R* �=O�& ��2e �T0=���n� V�L�W* �U=.Q u] � 1�? ` � � ������� GX ]

V��*�>� f

L4��'�� $M:

±eQ 5�� ZD! �U� V� F�L �� R* �T�; R* �F�L , %��& '�(�)�� ��*�+ �1�? u] Y��+5 A:�� ��U�7��

n� K���L G��GX]S:�s�1�� k�] {)s f Q |�D;2 e ±5�F�L �� ZD! �U�R* K��5 �Q �T�; ^_@�� , ]�)Q

� ��*�>� �1�? ��:*� �+L� R] A :��2 � ������� VX)� �� &��� � W�O�:m G�H R* k:UF K� 7�� { m��+ u ]

n� K�� �L G� � , �1�(�� ` � ^�£�� {m��+2GX ], 2 '5 0*¡�� R*=O� 7�� iO� :.�� ZD ! R* Uh:)�� u ] '

n� i*���� , � U=���;\ i*�� �� `� :p , � �.�� K�� ]25 �WWU+�Q k:� rU� �U�=���2 �Um� U�� ���7U1(Q {U��F

u] 0=�� <D�� 0@_��\���h; �1�(�� 9�); 0 =��� V

<������\n� NPj:�� {m�+ [kz A=���;f �*'=4��'�� :

� �:Q iO�:m �F�L �� ZD! <D�� �=:��� q�� , L�U:H� kQ <D�� �UO��_] �.U] R* '�(�) �� ��*�+ �1�?

n� �� ��� %��& A=��� ;2012�2013X ; , Y�=: �� � U6��a�=� �� V�b c:�� d � u ] � F�L �� �2 s

�� ���=:��2 ,R@) �� '� @*2 ,� U�@��2 ,A]X:+J� x�. 0 =��� , K� �� ��: *� , � ��=:* `� H5 V�bc:*2

<�� �L x2-* �*�&\ , �1a��� `�:)*2 ,<������ f X ;�T5 k Q A :�� � F�L �� K��5 B) U7Q � * q� � , � �:Q

�W6� !5 �U7C 0+5 R* �!�� ]\f 4��'�� ��N��O�:

(��� P C�� �� Q��>�:

,�)R$SS4��� DSST� : 0@_ K�� ���� � =�; �� Q �,3�� �m 05 �+�Q �=�@�� '\ [¦ 0�h��� µ��L5 �q¶�� :2 , ·Z µq��5 ·B1s§ O����2 , : ¸ @�� k z ¹ 1� ��7�� � 7:� R*

rUc�� t&�)*22¦B�!5 ·9 ºD@� J · O����§� ,# 381 f� 5 �*U �VW� P '� �I � »��U6�2005 ,# ,9 �

�Te K������¦ #� h�� Z}��:) Q <D �� �¹ :�� |�} ~ H�� � 6�� b8eQ ��U:m <������ ZI�� <D��25 �6� s 2

L��1:� A+L�H\ 0@ � , R!D�� [5 ��L�_ *2 L� @65 2�W�1_Q2 BQ�1aL2 BQ�+�s A1�Q �����L #�6§ f

'�)s2 ��; �W6���2(Kayad & Hassan, 2011,

�WU+2����� Y�82 ,�U8L��� ��F �_O�]: b8eQ d���:*� �+L� u] �U6��a�=� �� V�bc:��fff

– 256 –

p.1) �Te: ¦ u] ��h�� KL &\ �hUo2 ��ª5] 2� x 1* 0=: k)w� R* �U��] �+L �)6�.�� u] KL 7��2 '�7Q§f

5 �*E6� �W� X �!��6 �z �, 0�=:� Bm: VX) �� K�U© �UQ�} V�L 7 '��:=:� R�D�� ���6n� �W@�:=� A:��,

¤h.�� �U��] �78 k� �2, I� �mw� , K � _ �� �1a���2 [\ �6��\ ,|�} u] �1o����2 L��w�2 �=.��2 x� w�

�U��7:FJ� {s2 L�@:J�22 R ] r �1�� u] KL 7��#�h��, u ] KL 7��2 �F2L �� K�?�j=�� �� �:FJ�2

� + q¶ '�UQw�, Z�� � J S s #� h�� Z� 1:mJ�2 V�£&�.:��2 ¼�h�� J\ '2�H��f

��Y� �Z�* F ���:

4��'�� [�,�:

ZL� 1:]� Ah 4��� iW. �� �� j: F� k Q

{) m5 � F2L �� K�!� ��� ^ 42 , � U��1�� i!� .�� � ,<2� @�*2 K�� ]1992 # ,112� k Q }\ ,

V�b c:�� d � b8e Q R ] ^_ @�� �m�1: F� kU=PQ V�L�W=�� ��*�>� �1�? ��:*� �+L� u] �U6��a�=� ��

�������� f ��!,$#* 4��'�� \�!]:

½�@Q �F�L �� �=:� ' �1�? R* '�(�) �� � �*�+�2 %�� & k!� ] ¯�� 1��15402 � ��L �� �� ���

2012�2013 f5�F�L �� �.U] �* 6 Y c� 7�749�, <5 �1).�5 �%� F�L �� �=:�� ~@�� x�=��� R* f �2

�* j:)�� �U��h�� �.U��� Ym�; �P&�.�� V�m�U1�� ���1:F�0U��:�� , �592�1��? ��� 1��?2 f G2 + 3 ���2�1 �

=� �� ��I�:���U��� ,��a�F�L �� �U��h�� �.f

^*'�.1 04��'�� $��>�� ,$��� P� &��'�� \_�!��B

���(!)� `>�� �'��� ��,��

L�;} 289 %48.8 x�.��

y�m\ 303 %51.2

{(�� 44 %7.4

J�2 KL��:����P:& 91 %15.4

�U�� 101 %17.1

'�m�7�� 28 %4.7

�F .z� 122 %20.6

�U]X:+J� ������2 9���� 53 %9.0

������ 88 %14.9

d��=:�� 18 %3.0

�U�@��

����1�� ������2 �]�L��� 47 %7.9

�� �������� ���� ���� ,27 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

– 257 –

\��� a ^*'�.10B

���(!)� `>�� �'��� ��,��

��*�>� 0H�� 228 %38.5

n� �* ��*�>� �L�H0! 102 17.2 R@)�� '�@* ��*�>� �L�H 262 %44.3

�U�H� �� 94 %15.9

t7)* 143 %24.2

�U&-�� GX�2 9�.+ 92 %15.5

�.?�1�� GX�2 9�.+ 157 %26.5

K�!���� 65 %11.0

� .)* 6 %1.0

A=���� 12 %2.0

L�ho 18 %3.0

V��6����

´(F��� 5 0.8%

4��'�� C��L:

9�n� [\ x�+��� � F�L �� K��5 �� ]\ k Q)�� ���:�� <��.����h�� �������� VX� ,�L�1*2011� ,

�������� VX)�� %�U7* [\ x�+��� |�D;2�Mayers-

Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) � 0 1& R* ����C.

G. Jung f� B U�] V�� �:�� d � q�� +\ k Q r Us � ��* ;�X��� �=:��� ��U1? �* ^U@:���1 �2 '� @Q

R�5�+ R* : ^*b� Ycd�: 7* u ] 0=: �� R ] � Uh���Q � *

R] �W�­ {�(:� �*�] V�m�U2 �W:U�52 �F�L �� '��.] ,x�.�� � ��=:�� ��*�@U) �� kWPO�PH2 S1U�:)��

R@)�� '�@*2 ,NPj:��2 ,�UF�L �� �.)��2f -�SSe�� YcSSd�: R * '� @Q �65 � ��P :* K� 76

G� H R * �W F�U& k:U F A :�� ��h�� �������� VX)�� 0P� A:�� �+L �� R ] � �Q A :��2 {U�:) �� �WU�]

k Q r Us ;� W@�:=� A :�� � ������� V�L� W�� `�:) *V�@U� �L :* �� j:F��X�� A! V���:)= :5 ,4 ,

3 ,2 ,1 ·� rUs »� �+L �� 0�5 � `�:)=¦� + ¾G�] § BU�� �+L ���4 � `�:)=¦ ¾G�]§ �+L �� k8 ,�3 � `�:) =

¦tF�:*§ �+L ��2 ,�2 � `�:)=¦0U�&§ �+L ��2�1 � `�:)=¦� + ��U�&§f

�f���* C��b� g'V:

R * | �}2 K��n� `� :p E 4 R * ;e:�� kQ KL��w� , S =@��� R * � .> u ] �W ��] G� H

�����,�U��2 ,¤h. �� k �]2 ;2 q� \ kW. * { �?1: FJ� , K�L�� �� V�*����� , k�5L�m� ¤ @�Q A :��

�WU+2����� Y�82 ,�U8L��� ��F �_O�]: b8eQ d���:*� �+L� u] �U6��a�=� �� V�bc:��fff

– 258 –

�F�L �� x���* f DHn� kQ2 q�.2 ,k���s�* �U=� �� ]\ kQ |�} u]J��m�1:FB

K��5 ��I�Q kQ ,K��n� V�18 R* �7�:�� 0+5 R*2 Y c� � F�L �� � =:� R * �UO��_] �.U] u] �F�L ��

�23 �,�1��?2 �1��?� =:� �L� H R * ,� F�L �� k Q2 0*��* 9�)sÀ� 1m2�;−�5 � h�Chronbach -Alpha �

� � U=> ~H� �� E�) Q�� � ! X ;2 � F�L �� VJ�G2 + , 3��*�2f�

^*'d�.20: ���e�� D$� L�>�− 4��'�� �W�T) i��j* kl<�� m��T)�*B

� �W�T)� �� F>�� �>�� −i��j* k

1 �UPj� V�L�W* 1 −17 0.871 2 �U.62 �U.7Q V�L�W* 18−29 0.902 3 ��L��\ V�L�W* 30−46 0.934 4 ����U& V�L�W* 47−65 0.853

4��'�� ���(!�:

V�bc:* �F�L �� ZD! Y.=£Q�F!�S� K � ] bc:* A!x�.��� ´�m5 ,�;}�2 , x2- * 0 =] , �1a���

<�� �L2 ,� ������� GX ]n� , K� ��2 ,� U�@�� x� m ,2R@)�� '�@* f bc:�� �*5\��!�� , 0�=:U6� A :�� �+L �

(�)�� ��*�+ V�1��?2 9�? ��:*� �+L� R] ��Q '��������� V�L�W=�� %��&f

$6�O=Z� d��)�:

�� j: F� k Q ,� F�L �� ��l F5 R ] � �+g�

�� j: F� �UO�P sw� V�U ��:�� i*� m� �I� �� �UO�Psw��SPSS� 9�)s kQ2 , �U�) �� V�(F�:��

L� 1:H� 0 U�C2 � �L�U��� V� 6���mJ�2¦V§ 0 U�C2 � �:�� R�� 1:�� �MANOVA� � L� 1:H�2 , BUhU�� �1�� V�mL�7=��f

��!�`4b �F%* ��!5��,�* [6�!,�� n #:

��l Fn � 762 �W:_ &�.*2 iO� :.�� �� ] k:UF�F�L �� }\ , kQ� v�) �� { ��7:�� K ]�& �X:]� k @��

� +L� G� s � F�L �� � .U] V���: F� `�:) * u ]��������� V�L�W=�� kW;�:* ,X2'5 � j:) �� %�U7��

:)* � C ,w� `� R * �� Á �L :* V��+�1−5 � �D�'�6 <5 �lh�� ^P:.* � �+L� <5 5 u]�0.50 �

�WU�Q A:�� �lh�� 3��P� {)C,±e� X; : • � + �U��] �+L : S v�)�� tF�:�� '�; �}\

4.50−5.00

• �U��] �+L : S v�) �� t F�:�� '� ; �}\3.50−4.49

• �(F�:* �+L :F�:�� '�; �}\ S v�)�� t2.50−3.49

• �£hj.* �+L : S v�)�� tF�:�� '�; �}\1.50−2.49

• � + �£hj.* �+L : v�)�� tF�:�� '�; �}\ S1.00−1.49

�� �������� ���� ���� ,27 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

– 259 –

^*b� ^�o�SS��: � �+g�R ] G2n� G�¡) �� � � <D��2 �F�L ��\ R ] ^_@�� [ ��: *� � +L�

� %�� & '�(�)�� ��*�+ �1�?�� ������� V�L� W= R * �U�) �� V�( F�:�� ���j: F� k Q k!� �m � W+2

J�2 V���:FJ ��L�U��� V�6���m5 � F�L �� � .U] ���6L2���� �U­ , K�L���� V��7h�� G2 + 3���2 ,�3 �

V��� 7:� � �L�U��� V�6���mJ�2 �U�)�� V�(F�:��~@�� x�=���2 �F�L �� L2�p u] �.U��� f

^*'d�.3 0�4�!)�4��'�� �*�p "# ,$��� �� 'F!� ��$�)� ��%� NjW�* $���2� ��B

�� �� ^�T)� D�� �����)� �*�p q��2� R4�!)� r��$�)� J� NjW� C���)� � !�� ���

1 1 �UPj� V�L�W* 3.99 0.47 �U��]

2 4 ����U& V�L�W* 3.90 0.52 �U��]

3 3 ��L��\ V�L�W* 3.77 0.57 ]�U��

4 2 �U.62 �U.7Q V�L�W* 3.23 0.80 �(F�:*

G2 >� 3 ����3� �U�) �� V�( F�:�� '5

�( F�:��2 � U����� S �W=U& Ys2��Q �F�L �� L2���; ·F rUs �+L 2 v�)s tF�:* u]5 0�¦�U��] § L���

¦�UPj� V�L�W*§ ,� L� p BU�¦� ���U& V�L� W*§ k 8 ,¦ V�L�W*\��L��§ f+ Ss , L� �� v�) �� tF�:�� q�

�+L �U.7Q V�L�W*¦�(F�:*§ f b� ��N)�^* :$O8s ������:

kQJ�2 �U�)�� V�(F�:�� ���j:F� V� 6���mw� `�:) *2 � 1Q���2 � �L�U��� � F�L �� � .U�� V� �+

n� L���� V��7h�G2 , G2 + , S1* �! X;�4f�

^*'d�.40:W�* $���2� ���4�!)� l<�� m��T)�* $O8s ��� ������ ��p �� F% "# ,$��� �� 'F!� ��$�)� ��%� NjB

�� �� C F>�� �� �� �����)� R4�!)�

q��2�

J� NjW�

r��$�)� C���)� � !�� t�!��

1 1 ���.�� ���& �1aL < �f 4.68 0.57 � + �U��]

2 3 ¥h. �78 < �f 4.23 0.80

3 9 5R��H�� �* K�=�* V�&�] R��@Q u] #�sf 4.16 0.83

4 10 A.W�� ~17:)* N� L�*5 , b@h:�� kO�� ¥hm +5 f 4.14 0.87

5 2 �W.* k��Qn AO�(H5 �F�L ��&5f 4.12 0.83

6 5 B� �� p2 �����2 ��6 ! ��5 ,�* 0=� ��U7�� , {aL5 �* .]f 4.11 0.82

�U��]

7 15 U+5R��H� V�Pmw�2 xX:FJ� f 4.09 0.79

�WU+2����� Y�82 ,�U8L��� ��F �_O�]: b8eQ d���:*� �+L� u] �U6��a�=� �� V�bc:��fff

– 260 –

\��� a ^*'d�.40B

�� �� C F>�� �� �� �����)� R4�!)�

q��2�

J� NjW�

r��$�)� C���)� � !�� t�!��

8 16 5 u] #�s\�*n� A.h�; XW*   ��;��� GX]n� I��mf 4.07 0.80

9 11 5bUc:�� �U�6� �� |�:*f 4.03 0.82

10 8 5 , �U��7:FJ� u] KL 7�� |�:*\  X]5 I��m 3.96 0.86

11 4 �*n� A.h�@� XW* ±�L��7 |)�5 f 3.92 0.90

12 17 u] � � L��\ < �\�h�@:�� Ym�; XW* 0=] I��mf 3.88 0.84

13 6 �]�.:*2 K � + ��L�@65 |�:*5 f 3.86 0.89

14 7 u] KL 7�� < �^&����2 �2���� �U­ �* ^U@:�� f 3.80 0.92

15 13 ±J��hm� u] K�(U)�� , KL 7�� < �f 3.70 0.91

16 12 0_h�� ��H5 Jf 3.66 1.000

�U��]

17 14 R* �6I��=�� �:)*5�m�=£* ba Ym�; �� ´:s K � + K�@6 0+f 3.43 1.040 �(F�:*

l<�� m��T)� 3.99 0.47 $��#

V� Wo5 G2 + , � F�L �� iO� :m�4 � '5

� W=U& Y s2��Q �UP j_�� L��� �U�)�� V�(F�:�� S¦ + �U��] ��§2 ¦�U��]§2 ¦�( F�:*§; ·F r Us 0�

�+L 2 v�)s tF�:* u]5¦� + �U��]§ K� 7h� ¦ � � ����.�� ���& �1aL§ f5 �*´m�5 , 0� F v�) s tF�:*

KL� W� '�@6 L���� �D!¦ * � 6I��=�� �:) * R5 0 +

�m�=£* ba Ym�; �� ´:s K � + K�@6§f -�e�� ��N)� :$,%* $,F� ������:

J�2 �U�)�� V�(F�:�� ���j:F� kQ V� 6���mw� `�:) *2 � 1Q���2 � �L�U��� � F�L �� � .U�� V� �+

����� L���� V��7h� , G2 + , S1* �! X;�5f�

^*'d�.5 0* $���2� ���4�!)����%� Njl<�� m��T)�* $O8s ��� ������ ��p �� F% "# ,$��� �� 'F!� ��$�)� B

�� �� C F>�� �� �� �����)� R4�!)�

q��2�

J� NjW�

r��$�)�

� !�� t�!��

C���)�

1 18 �& ��:@�� u] KL 7�� < �f 3.77 0.89

2 19 5���� b1�:�� u] KL 7�� |�:*f 3.76 0.90

3 21 YmmJ� �@1� ���? R] R��H�� �* 0*��:�� u] KL 7�� < � 3.65 1.03

4 20 5�U+���.@:�� �* 0*��:�� , KL 7�� |�:*f 3.64 0.95

5 25 5�U+���.@:�� �� j:F� , ±�L & ���(Q u] KL 7�� |�*f 3.61 1.01

�U��]

�� �������� ���� ���� ,27 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

– 261 –

\��� a ^*'d�.50B

�� �� C F>�� �� �����)��� R4�!)�

q��2�

J� NjW�

r��$�)�

� !�� t�!��

C���)�

6 24 V�*����� �U+���.@Q G�� , V� �:)�� ��Q5f 3.28 1.15

7 23 �U=F��� V�1?�j�� ��:; u] KL 7�� < �f 3.17 1.17

8 22 w� �h�Ln� 0=] u] KL 7�� < ��Um2@� 2.96 1.23

9 27 7�� < ��U+�:m\ ��L�_* kU=PQ u] KL f 2.87 1.25

10 29 �Um2@�w� V�@1_�� ���? R] V��:.* ���)Q u] KL 7�� < �f 2.75 1.33

11 26 �&��* kU=PQ u] KL 7�� < �\��L�¢ GX]n �Um2@� 2.60 1.32

12 28 w� ����� u] KL 7�� < �n �Um2@���L�¢ GX]f 2.59 1.31

�(F�:*

�l<�� m��T) 3.23 0.80 �4�!�

G2 + , � F�L �� iO� :m V� Wo5�5 � '5

L� �� �U�) �� V�( F�:��¦� U.62 � U.7Q V�L� W*§ 0�F rUs �(F�:��2 �U����� S �W=U& Ys2��Qu ]5

�+L 2 v�)s tF�:*¦�U��]§ K�7h� ¦ u] KL 7�� < ��& ��:@��§ f5 �* �D ! , 0� F v�) s t F�:* ´m�5

KL�W� '�@6 L����¦w� ����� u] KL 7�� < � �Um2@�

��L�¢ GX]w§f u��e�� ��N)� : ������@���:

V� 6���mJ�2 �U�)�� V�(F�:�� ���j:F� kQw� `�:) *2 � 1Q���2 � �L�U��� � F�L �� � .U�� V� �+

r����� L���� V��7h� , , S1* �! X; G2 +�6 f�

^*'d�.60:W�* $���2� ���4�!)� ��� ������ ��p �� F% "# ,$��� �� 'F!� ��$�)� ��%� Nj@l<�� m��T)�* ���B

�� �� C F>�� �� �� �����)� R4�!)�

q��2�

J� NjW�

r��$�)�

� !�� t�!��

C���)�

1 40 �U�2¡)* 0=C u] KL 7�� < �±�L��& �.4f 4.01 0.83

2 31 �U�17:)�� ,� !5 �a�U4 u] KL 7�� < �f 3.97 0.85

3 41 5x2-* <e q 1�� 01& B:=�m52 0=��� 3O��� u] ���:�� u] #�sf 3.96 0.90

4 38  X]5 kU�.Q u] KL 7�� < �f 3.88 0.82

5 36 GX]n� ���:* u] KL 7�� < �f 3.87 0.83

�U��]

6 35 0+5 R* #�h�� 0c:F5\ �L5 �* I��mf 3.86 0.88

7 39 w �U).:�� u] KL 7�� < �GX]n� I��mf 3.81 0.86

8 34 w 0O� +5 '5 G2�s5�*n� A.h�; XW* ~=] I��mf 3.81 0.87

�(F�:*

�WU+2����� Y�82 ,�U8L��� ��F �_O�]: b8eQ d���:*� �+L� u] �U6��a�=� �� V�bc:��fff

– 262 –

\��� a ^*'d�.60B

�� �� C F>�� �� �� �����)� R4�!)�

q��2�

NjW� J�

r��$�)�

� !�� t�!��

C���)�

9 30 5 X]5 tU(� u] KL 7�� |�:*f 3.79 0.91

10 43 V�*In� �W+��* u] KL 7�� < � ��W�* 0*��:��2 �?�j��f 3.79 0.87

11 37 ���� V�L��& }��� u] KL 7�� < �f 3.78 0.89

12 32 Y&��� KL��\ KL�W* |�:*5 f 3.77 0.94

13 42 V�?�1sw�2 V�F�@:mJ� u] {�c:�� u] KL 7�� |�:*5f 3.74 0.90

14 44 A��L�_* I��mw K � + 0O�F2 ���: ��&5f 3.71 0.92

15 33   ��;��� ��W�� I��mJ <DUh.Q i*�m� kU=PQ u] KL 7�� |�:*5f 3.60 0.96

16 45 �U+�:mw� ��L�_�� 0=] u] KL 7�� |�:*5f 3.34 1.10

17 46 ��L��:�� GX]n� KL��\ u] KL 7�� |�:*5f 3.26 1.15

�(F�:*

l<�� m��T)� 3.77 0.57 $��#

G2 + , � F�L �� iO� :m V� Wo5�6 � '5

L��� �U�)�� V�(F�:��¦ V�L�W*\� �L��§ Y s2��Q t F�:* u ]5 0�F rUs �(F�:��2 �U����� S �W=U&

�+L 2 v�)s¦�U��]§� K�7h¦ 0 =C u ] KL 7�� < �±�L��& �.4 �U�2¡)*§ f5 0�F v�)s tF�:* ´m�5 �*

KL�W� '�@6¦� �L��:�� GX]n� KL��\ u] KL 7�� |�:*5§

`�:)= q�+2¦tF�:*§f \�� �� ��N)� :��$� ������:

V� 6���mJ�2 �U�)�� V�(F�:�� ���j:F� kQw� `�:) *2 � 1Q���2 � �L�U����� V� �+ � F�L �� � .U

����� L���� V��7h� , G2 + , S1* �! X;�7f�

^*'d�.7 0l<�� m��T)�* ��$� ��� ������ ��p �� F% "# ,$��� �� 'F!� ��$�)� ��%� NjW�* $���2� ���4�!)�B

�� �� C F>�� �� �� �����)� R4�!)�

q��2�

J� NjW�

r��$�)�

�� t�!�� � !

C���)�

1 60 �=:��� ���65 �* � x�(:�� 5 1= R*Ã5f 4.18 0.90

2 63 ��2L2 q2 � L�*¸� ��m5f 4.06 0.85

3 61 AO�(H5 iO�:m 017Q u] KL 7�� < � f 4.01 0.88

4 47 ���6 , 0=��� KL�W* < �f 4.00 0.90

5 62 R��HÂ� �U�1:�� d6L5 f 4.00 0.98 6 53 5 X]5 , W+ Ä&5 GD u] #�sf 3.97 0.86

�U��]

�� �������� ���� ���� ,27 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

– 263 –

\��� a ^*'d�.70B

�� �� C F>�� �� �� �����)� R4�!)�

q��2�

J� NjW�

r��$�)�

� !�� t�!��

C���)�

7 59 �� &w� u] KL 7�� |�:*5�KL��1��f� 3.96 0.87

8 57 ±�(UF YC L�*n� '�@Q '5 {s5f 3.96 0.91

9 65   ��;��� ��W�� I��m\ , �& �� �U�5f 3.95 0.89

10 52 S�* � ! �U7�:� ±�} ��L�\ u] KL 7�� < �f 3.92 0.84

11 54 A.W�� ~17:)= �7��:�� V�L��7�� �.4 , ���Q5 Jf 3.89 0.92

12 56 KL� � GX]n� I��m� u] KL 7�� < �f 3.88 0.86

13 48 |�:*5 KL 7�� u] b8e:�� ,R��H�� f 3.86 0.88

14 49 ����] ba V�]���* ^_@:F5��6��e* ba � R*5 �� � + ��lU� k��Q5 '5 0+f 3.79 0.91

15 64 �7�7��2 �m��_�� ^&���� , AO2 ! u] Å6�s5f 3.79 1.00

16 55 ��&�:�� ba ^&���� �W+��* u] KL 7�� < �f 3.73 0.87

17 58 �£*�c�� ^&���� �* 0*��:�� u] KL 7�� < �f 3.70 0.89

18 51 R��H� x�+��� '2� �4��� A:7��( q�U�n� ��m5f 3.68 0.93

19 50 *n� ����? ��=:p VÆ6�@* {)@� V�U�£Q k� 7:� �� �:FJ� < �f 3.67 0.94

�U��]

l<�� m��T)� 3.90 0.47 $��#

F�L �� iO�:m V�Wo5 G2 + , ��7 � � U­ '5

Y�� F � ���U& V�L� W* L� �� �U�) �� V�(F�:�� �+L ¦� U��]§; v�) s t F�:* u ]5 0� F r Us

K� 7h�� 3��P �¦ ��� 65 � * � x� (:�� 5 1= R *Ã5�=:���§ 3��P � 0� F v�)s tF�:* ´m�5 Ss , , K� 7h��¦ {) @� V�U�£ Q k� 7:� �� �: FJ� < �

� ����? ��=:p VÆ6�@* *n§f -�e�� ^�o���: �� G�¡F u] ��+g�2�L ����� �F

���:���+L S �UO�P s\ � �J� V�} E2� 6 ��+2 � ������� V�L�W=�� kW;�:*� �+L� , �1�(�� ��m �W+2

�U6��a�=� �� V�bc:�� d� [\ `��Q� ,x�.��2 �1a��� ,<�� �L x2-* 0=] ,2 ,� ������� GX ]n� , K� ��

2�m ,�U�@�� x2R@)�� '�@* f� 0 ; iO� :m �� ] k:UFbc:* ,� X;e±:

m�,�� �(!�:

L�1:H� �� j:F� kQ¦V§:.U�� S �6��� S:�7:)* �+L� � +L� , � 1�(�� � �m � W+2 S E2� 6 ��+2

� x� .�� b c:� `� �Q � ������� GX]n� V�L�W� kW;�:* G2 + , 3��* �! X;2�8f�

�WU+2����� Y�82 ,�U8L��� ��F �_O�]: b8eQ d���:*� �+L� u] �U6��a�=� �� V�bc:��fff

– 264 –

^*'d�.8 06�!j ���!?� [v�w !�� ��'� m�,�� �(!) � xF%* I!#��T) � ��� �� �����)B

V�L�W�� L2�p x�.�� � ��� v�)�� tF�:�� ����mJ�

<L�U��� �=U&¦V§

��)��� ����� V�+L�

��J ���UO�Psw�

� ;} 289 3.984 .484 �UPj� V�L�W*

´� m5 303 4.004 .462 -.507 590 .612

� ;} 289 3.839 .525 ����U& V�L�W* ´� m5 303 3.966 .508

-2.981 590 .003

� ;} 289 3.790 .539 ��L��\ V�L�W*

´� m5 303 3.743 .605 .978 590 .328

� ;} 289 3.276 .758 �U.7Q V�L�W*�U.62 ´� m5 303 3.185 .844

1.376 590 .169

� ;} 289 3.760 .4661 �m�1:FJ� 0@; ´� m5 303 3.773 .496

-.336 589.853 .737

S � ��!�o E2� 6 �� +2 R * ka� �� u ]

w�2 L�;D�� V���:F� G2 + , 3 ��* � ! X; y�m�8�'5 J\ ,\ L�1:H¦V§ Y) U� E2� h�� ZD ! '5 Y185

��UO�P s\ � ����α=0.05 � p � 8�8 ,A ! L2� : L� p¦�UP j� V�L�W*§2 ,¦� �L��\ V�L� W*§2 ,¦ V�L� W*

�U.62 �U.7Q§ Ss , ,5 &2�6 �� .! '� � ��� \ , �UO�P s

w� 3��P�2 ����U& V�L�W* L�py�m L�;D�� �mL�7*f r��� m*y� A�# P �& �� �(!�:

� �J� V�} E2�6 ��+2 R] ^_@��\ �UO�P s V���:F� S5F�L �� �.U] ���6 , � 1a��� b c:� �762 �

k Q ,<�� �L x2- * 0=]\ L� 1:H� 0 U�C q�� +¦V§ G2 + , 3��* �! X; S:�7:)* S:.U���9f�

^*'d�.9 0 ���!?� [6�!jv�wr��� m*y� A�# P �& �� �(!) �xF%* I!#��T) B

�����)� �*�p �& �� �'��� q��2� R4�!)� J� NjW�

r��$�)�

�$�v�w

���N)� 2� �����

�W'��

$6�O=Z�

k�m 299 4.070 .459 �UPj� V�L�W* J 293 3.918 .476

3.967 590 .000

k�m 299 3.962 .530 ����U& V�L�W* J 293 3.844 .504

2.778 590 .006

k�m 299 3.858 .551 ��L��\ V�L�W* J 293 3.672 .584

3.996 590 .000

�� �������� ���� ���� ,27 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

– 265 –

\��� a ^*'d�.90B

�����)� �*�p �& �� �'��� q��2� R4�!)� J� NjW�

r��$�)�

�$�v�w

���N)� 2� �����

�W'��

$6�O=Z�

k�m 299 3.338 .811 �U.7Q V�L�W*�U.62 J 293 3.118 .782

3.358 590 .001

k�m 299 3.848 .464 0@; �m�1:FJ� J 293 3.684 .484

4.198 590 .000

iO� :m Y :185� L� 1:H¦V§ S:�7:) * S :.U��

G2 >� , 3 ��* �! X;�9 � &2�6 �� .! 'e � � ��� R�D �� � 1�(�� S �������� V�L�W�� ��:*� , �UO�Ps\

'� 1a�� kTe �2�;} , ZD ! , <�� �L x2- * 0 =] k!� ] '�; R�D��2 kW:F�L� R* ��s����299� �� 1��?

��1��?2, |�D '� 1a�� J kTe �2� ;} R�D�� �1�(��2 k!� ] '�; R�D��2�293 � ��1��?2 ��1��? f ZD ! Y m�;2

��L�_* 0=� '�1a�� R�D�� �1�(�� 3��P� ���� E2�h������L� f

�� �� ^;#b� P Cz{� �(!�: � ] 'n ���mTe ��� +5 R�D �� �1�(�� k �1 F

�*�& '52�e �����L GX]53 0 �7* , �� 1��?2 ��1��? 539 <���L x2-* <e ��*�7� � Bme �2L��5 R�D�� f � 6���2

b8eQ bc:�� �D! u]�+L� V�L�W�� ��:*� ,�1�(�� ` � �UO��_] �.U] L�U:H� kQ ��2�)* k� � R@Q � R�D�� R*

K���� 0+5 R* � �J� V�} E2� 6 �� +2 R ] ^_@��UO�Ps\S b c:� � 762 �F�L �� �.U] ���6� V���:F� , K���GX]n� kQ ,�������� \ L� 1:H� 0U�C q��+¦V§

G2 + , 3��* �! X; S:�7:)* S:.U���10f�

^*'d�.10 0 ���!?� [6�!jv�w�����)� �*�p "#* r��� m*y� A�# P Cz{� �(!) �xF%* I!#��T) B

�����)� �*�p �Cz{ �'��� q��2� R4�!)� J� NjW�

r��$�)�

�$�v�w

���N)� 2� �����

�W'��

$6�O=Z�

k�m 53 4.097 .436 �UPj� V�L�W* J 53 4.004 .462

1.056 104 .293

k�m 53 4.014 .565 ����U& V�L�W* J 53 3.936 .534

.741 104 .461

k�m 53 3.859 .549 ��L��\ V�L�W*

J 53 3.758 .618 .889 104 .376

�WU+2����� Y�82 ,�U8L��� ��F �_O�]: b8eQ d���:*� �+L� u] �U6��a�=� �� V�bc:��fff

– 266 –

\��� a ^*'d�.100B

�����)� �*�p Cz{� �'��� q��2� R4�!)� J� NjW�

r��$�)�

�$�v�w

���N)� 2� �����

�W'��

$6�O=Z�

k�m 53 3.398 .736 �U.7Q V�L�W*�U.62 J 53 3.112 .777

1.946 104 .054

k�m 53 3.882 .438 J�0@; �m�1:F J 53 3.756 .503

1.377 104 .171

G2 + 3 ����10 � �� .! '5 &2�6� � ��!�o iO� :m '5 J\ K� �� <2} � 1�(�� 3��P �� V L� 1:H

� ��� E2� 6 �� +2 � ] Y :185 S:�7:) * S :.U�� ��UO�Ps\ f

$�<�� m�j �(!�: ��J� V�} E2�6 ��+2 R] ^_@��2\ �UO�P s

kQ ,�U�@�� x�m bc:� �762\ � �:�� R�� 1:�� 0 U�C q��+�MANOVA � V���:FJ5 � 762 � F�L �� � .U] ��� 6

G2 + , 3��* �! X; �U�@�� bc:��11f�

^*'d�.11 0�����)� "# $�<�� m�j �(!� ���!� �'�!)� |��!�� A$�} [6�!jB

|��!�� �'O� �����)� �*�p ]���� )� m�� 2� ����� ���� )� R4�!� �$�vJw���N)� $6�O=Z� �W'��

�UPj� V�L�W* 4.888 8 .611 2.799 .005

�U.62 �U.7Q V�L�W* 44.354 8 5.544 9.570 .000

��L��\ V�L�W* 9.199 8 1.150 3.606 .000

�U�@��

����U& V�L�W* 4.272 8 .534 1.999 .044

�UPj� V�L�W* 127.291 583 .218

�U.62 �U.7Q V�L�W* 337.757 583 .579

��L��\ V�L�W* 185.920 583 .319

e(��

����U& V�L�W* 155.724 583 .267

5 G2 + , � �:�� R�� 1:�� 0 U�C iO�:m V�Wo�11 ���+2 ��J� V�} E2�6 \V���: F� S �UO�Ps 562 �F�L �� �.U] ���6,�Ln� V�L�W�� , �U�@�� bc:� �7

�=U& Ym�; &25 1� ¤@�2 Wills’ Lambda =3.527

�=U&2¦�§� z ���7�� =0.827 �UO�P sw� � �J ��2 =0.000, k Q ,V� U�@�� S E2�h�� Z�¢� u] ��&���2

\q��+� L�1:HBUhU� �� �1�� V�mL�7=�� , 3��* �! X; G2 >��12�f

�� �������� ���� ���� ,27 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

– 267 –

^*'d�.12 0 [6�!j'���� ��j��F��� ~$>$s ���!?�B

�����)� �*�p j��F)� ��$�<�� $���2� ���4�!)� P g* >�� $6�O=Z� �W'�� ����O� g* >�� ���

�UPj� V�L�W* 9����2 {(�� 0.409 0.019 {(��

�U��2 {(�� 0.657 0.004 {(��

������2 {(�� 0.817 0.000 {(��

�]�L���2 {(�� 0.699 0.015 {(��

�F .z�2 �U�� 0.496 0.003 �U��

������2 �F .z� 0.656 0.000 �F .z�

9����2 �F .z� 0.616 0.002 �F .z�

�]�L���2 �F .z� 0.538 0.032 �F .z�

�U.62 �U.7Q V�L�W*

9����2 {(�� 0.777 0.002 {(��

��L��\ V�L�W* ����2 {(��9 0.468 0.037 {(��

5 iO� :m V� Wo >� G2 �12 �E2� 6 �� +2 � ���\ � U��2 { (�� V� U�; � 1�? 3��P � �UO�P s

�F .z�2 f

|<��� ��<� �(!�:

'�@* {)� �Ln� V�L�W�� , E2�h�� �6���2R@)��, � �:�� R��1:�� 0U�C q��+\ kQ �MANOVA� ,

G2 + , 3��* �! X;�13 f�

'd� ^*.13 0�����)� �*�p "# |<��� ��<� �(!� ���!� �'�!)� |��!�� A$�} [6�!jB

|��!�� �'O� �����)� �*�p ���� )� m��] 2� ����� ���� )� R4�!� �$�vJw���N)� $6�O=Z� �W'��

�UPj� V�L�W* .215 2 .108 .480 .619

�U.62 �U.7Q V�L�W* 2.039 2 1.020 1.580 .207

��L��\ V�L�W* .211 2 .106 .319 .727

R@)�� '�@*

����U& V�L�W* 2.033 2 1.016 3.789 .023

�UPj� V�L�W* 131.964 589 .224

�U.62 �U.7Q V�L�W* 380.072 589 .645

��L��\ V�L�W* 194.908 589 .331

e(��

����U& V�L�W* 157.963 589 .268

5 � �:�� R��1:�� 0U�C iO�:m V�Woe &2�6 ��.! '� ��J� V�}\�UO�Ps; rUs 5 iO�:.�� V�Wo5�=U& ' ¤@�2

5 1�WilKs’ Lambda =0.970 �=U&2 ¦�§� z � ��7�� =2.259�UO�P sw� � �J ��2 =0.021 ZD ! Vq� + }\ ,

�WU+2����� Y�82 ,�U8L��� ��F �_O�]: b8eQ d���:*� �+L� u] �U6��a�=� �� V�bc:��fff

– 268 –

3��P� E2�h������U7�� V�L�W�� bc:* L�1:H� �W���� X; � BUhU� G2 >� , �� �1�� V�mL�7=��14f�

^*'d�.14 0|<��� ��<� �(!) '���� ��j��F��� ~$>$s ���!?� [6�!jB

�����)� �*�p |<��� ��<� $���2� ���4�!)� P g* >�� �W'��

$6�O=Z� ����O� g* >�� ���

������

��$� * ��*�>� �L�H R@F2 ��*�>� 0H�� V�1��(�� R@FK�n� � 0.155 0.044 ��*�>� 0H�� V�1��(�� R@F

G� H R *2q��7: F� iO� :m L� 1:H� �BUhU �� �1�� V�mL�7=�� G2 + ,�14�Vq�+ , E2� h�� ZD !

3��P�V�1��? R@)�� 0H�� � 1�(�� 0 �7* , ��*�>�K�n� �* A�*�>� R@)�� �L�H f

G� H R*2 �_ &�.*iO� :m G2n� G�¡) �� S 1Q��+2 �+L� , V2�hQ� V�L� W=�� ��*�>� �1�? ��:*

� 1�? �W@�:=� A:�� V�L�W�� � ] Yc� rUs ,�������� + �U��]2 �U��] �+L ��*�>� ��� 55 � x�=� R* KL�W*

�65 � KL�W*5 �1). <�84�%, � mL�7* � U��] �1)m A!2 X 6 �( F�:* �+L �1�(�� �W@�:=� A:�� V�L�W�� � �

�1). '2��16 �% �!� ] ¯� A:��2�10 ��L�W*t76 V f5 76 V�L�W�� x�.� �1).�� �*5 �F�L �� iO�:m V�Wo5 '

~ @�� � W]�=� 0P s A :�� V�L� W��u ] u ]5 A ! �U�) �� V�(F�:��¦V�L� W* �UP j�§ � WU�Q ,

¦� ���U& V�L� W*§ k 82 ,¦� �L��\ V�L� W*§ ��b H52 , ¦�U.62 �U.7Q V�L�W*§6 |�D2 ,�:m ' ZD ! � F�L �� iO�

b_Q\ [5 � ������� V�L�W�� R* '�@�:=� ��*�>� �1�? '

0@_ � �L��w�2 ����U7��2 �UPj_�� {m��>� �7��:��m��+ 0@_Q2 b1;{ V�L�W�� G��Q J Ss , k� � K�&

07Q J A:��2 �U.7:��2 �U.h��5n� V�L�W�� R] �U� `� H � U�=��� V�L�W�� R* �Q �T�; K�� ] A !2 � U7U1(:��2

�� + �=W*����� 0=��� , �<, 52 5 1� <�� ���� 0=��� ' � U�=��� { m��>�2 K� @h�� ZD ! � U1(Q R @�2 K�@h

��m� � 0 7Q J � � �(1Q���n� R * � z2 , Kb 1@�� � U� 0=��� , q 1�� x2-��5B �� U7�� ����� x2-�� 2, �D �

6��+�� '����� J ��*�>� �1�? ' \ {�L Q [5 0 U!eQ 2 ��:;2 �U+���.@:�� �* 0*��:�� , ���=:��2 V�L�W�� u]

n� 0 =] u ] KL 7��2 V�1?�j��w� �h �L � Um2@�w� ��L�_�� kU=PQ2 � ����2 V��:.�� ���)Q2 �U+�:m

w��Um2@� f �*5 V�L�W�� L��= �7��:�� iO�:.�� �1).��w� � �L�� 76� * � 7h:* Vq� + R * � ��� iO� :m

�F�L� �W.* V�F�L ��William, et al., 2007)� A :��25 VL��\ [5w� V�L�W�� �U� , ��L�� t1Q�Q �T�; K������

�W=U�.Q R)s2 GX]¸� tU(j:�� , �4�H25n� �T ��;

�� �������� ���� ���� ,27 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

– 269 –

X; ,AhUo��� ���(:�� i*�� , SL :�� 01& R* �1�?5 '�7��:�� iO�:.�� L��=¦�W* V�L\��L��§ iO�:m �* �h:Q �

� F�L��Pihie, et al., 2012 � ,5 '�67 �% � 1�? R * '� @�:=� J � ��U��* , �4���  ���� kU��:�� V�)F¡*

G� � , K�H <5\n� KL�� � �2 { �(:� r Us GX ]¬ ���� kU��:�� i!�.* , KL�W�� ZD! ��*�w V�U�f

n� G�¡)�� iO�:m Vq�+ X; G25* �£ � � * � 7h: � F�L� iO� :m�William et al., 2007 � ,5 V�L� W�� '

�+L �U�)�� ���(F�:* Y��F A:��¦�U��]§ A :��2 �1�? �WU�]5 A ! ���) :;J V��*�>� �1�? 01& R* ��;

n� G�� , �U.h��2 �U.7:�� V�L�W�� �F�L�2 ;�������� GX] k��@�� 1]2 =p�2011 � A:��25 VL��\ [5 R* '5 k!

V�&��*\n� KL�� �* �D!2 �U+���.@:�� A! �������� GX]5 � F�L �� ZD! iO�:m BQ�Wo �� +2 � 1�? ` � ^� �

w� � ���� KL� W* ��: *� , ��*�>� G� � , � Um2@�n���L��:�� GX]f

5 , ���:��2 ����� G�¡)�� iO�:m �_&�.� �1).�� �*� � �J �� V�} E2� h�� R ] ^_ @��w .] �UO�P s

`�:) * �α≥0.05 � V�b c:�� d�1 � � 762 ,�U6��a�=� ��5 76 b c:� �1).�� �F�L �� iO�:m V�Wo

x�.��5&2�6 ��.! '� ��J� V�} \ L�;D �� S �UO�P s L�p , y�mw�2¦� ���U& V�L� W*§y� mw� 3��P �2 ;

� F�L� iO� :m � * � 7h:* ba ��U:.�� ZD! Vq�+ rUs

�Pihie et al., 2012 � ,5� ' � R * '� @�:=� L�;D �������� V�L�W��5 ��;*w� R kU ��:�� V�) F¡* , y�m

���U��* , �4���  ���� SF�� �F�L� �* �7h:* �W.@�2 ,(Yaseen, 2010) V�L� W�� E� hQ [\ VL� �5 A :��

R * �(U) � .U] G� H R* 0+��� u] K5�=�� ����U7���) �� KL2���� V�L�*w� ��2��.( f ZD ! �2 s R= �

� 7��:* 9�1 Fn E2� h�� ZD ! 2� �m � .m�6 � F�L �� ,� ���U7�� V�L� W�� �U=.Q , V�1��(�� ��]�h�� �;L�_�� ,#�h�� ZD! 0�* , L�;D�� 9�(�� R* ��& �_� X.U

A @=��� V� ;} X ; � �U:m '�@� & X;(Al-Lamki,

2007)V� ���U7�� q�) .�� d � E� h:� �!b)hQ , , S � ������ � �*����2 <�n� k] �� �X��� �=:��� , Z2L�2 kU ��:�� b 1@�� �� 7:��2 y� mw�2 L�;D �� �7Q u ] q�) .�� qJ¡ ! ]� F <D �� � *n� �=:���

����U& {4�.*f 5 �1) .�� �*\ x2- * 0 =] , � 1a��� b c:* [

76 <���L5 �F�L �� iO�:m V�Wo5k� � R�D�� �1�(�� ' � ����L V�L� W* '�@�:=� <���L x2-* 0=] , �1aL ,2 � ����L V�L� W* '�@�:=� J R�D�� R* u]5 �+L

��J 2 L2���� �U­\ �!L & �UO�Ps�α=0.05�f ZD!2 � F�L� iO� :m �* �76��:* Vq�+ ��U:.���Pihie et al.,

2012 � ,5 � ��U��* , � 4��� V� �*�>� , � 1�(�� '� � R�D�� <�� �L x2- * 0 =�� �U�6� �� k5 R * � �;

�WU+2����� Y�82 ,�U8L��� ��F �_O�]: b8eQ d���:*� �+L� u] �U6��a�=� �� V�bc:��fff

– 270 –

�� � 1�(�� R* k!baR�� H, kW:1) m 0P Q r Us \ [�71 �%� F�L �� � .U�� ~@�� x�=��� R* f �1) .�� � *�

n� G�� , K��� bc:� E2� 6 � W�Q k �6 �������� GX] ��J� V�}\ �UO�Ps�α=0.05 � k� � R�D�� �1�(�� S

n� G�� , K�H�� GX]=� J R�D��2 ������: K� H '�@�n� G�� ,�������� GX]f

5 � U�@�� b c:� �1) .�� � * 76 5 iO� :m V� Wo�F�L ��'5 , KL�P p Y)U� �������� V�L�W�� ��:*�

� �*�>� � 1�? � U­ S K- :.* �! �m 0 �.U�* �U�;� U�@�� x� m R ] ��.�� dc }\ , ZD ! '5 { ��c�� R *

R@Q � E2�h��J�2 KL� �:�� � U�; 3��P � � ��� ��P :& �n� � U�@�� � :�Q A:��2 , � 7��:�� V�L� 7�� ¤�L Q

b_� �© �D!2 ,K������[\ Y) U� � ������� V�L�W�� '5 ,�!ba '2� �.U�* V�PP� u] ���@s k]� R* J }\

V�L�W�� ZD! � 1�(�� ��� F , � !����Q2 �� �X:!J�2¢ A @� �� j:�� 01& , �� j:�� � S .@=:* k W��

� , K������ �FL�©� Y &��� , ;� ]�.:*2 � h�:È VJ �m <D��5 '� FLX� %�� & '�(�) �� � �*�+ �1�? '

R* � ��� G�H R* K�������(_mn� A :�� V� U���h��2 �(_ mn�2 �U�(�� V�]X>� , ���=:��2 ��*�>� 7�Q

��h��2 ��j:�� ��L�_*2 �U��1�� K��] A:�� �U=���� V�U� V� U�@�� `�:) * u ] �� :h�� �� U�� �1 F�.* , � 7Q , � 1�(�� #� h�� 3. � V� U���h�� ZD! 0; ,��*�>�2

� !2 <�� ���� 0 =��� G�� , �W=UU7Q2 k��L & L�1:H� � �s�* �1) Q A :�� � U�*�>� � �s��� , k W* { �(*

�7h:* Vq�+ ��U:.�� ZD!2 0=��� E�F , G�H �� � * Z�;} �*|�2�� 2006 � 'XU�F2�2005 � , � lU� � U�5

V�L� W* k��) ;\ , �U F�L �� kW�s�� * q� .85 �1�(�� � (1Q��� | �Q � 4�H �W�7 4 u ] 0 =���2 � ����L u ] KL 7* � �;5 �� m�@U� � U=���;n� k��P Pj:

0=��� E�F , G�H �� f 5 76 R@) �� '� @* bc:� �1).�� �*5 Y� �2

iO�:mR��1:�� 0U�C��+2 � �J� V�} E2� 6 \ �UO�P s�α=0.05 � � ���U7�� V�L�W�� 0�=:��2 ����� L���� ,

K�� ]2 ,A�*� >� ���� 0H�� S.;�)�� �1�(�� 3��P�2�m�@�R* ' �� ¤U�2 V�1��(�� R* �1�(�� �mL�7* 9�(

�� � * A�*� >� �� �� �L� H '�.@) � R�D �� R�� Hn�0! f)hQ R@=�2b |�}e R@) �� 0H�� V�1��(�� '

� ���:� � ;5 0@_ #� h�� R z V�6� Q A�*� >� � 1�(�� 0�7* , �������� R��L�W*�V� 1��?2 9� ? �

] � * '�.@) � R�D ��k��O� � &�:* �D !2 ,�6 K� U� 0 =C � 1�(�� u ] k: C � �O���� R ] ��7:)�� �U�*�>�k� � %� cQ2 kW: F�L�2 kW) hm5 R] �;5 �U�2¡)*

�.�2 V�L��7�� }��� , �4�H2 ¤h.�� �7���kW 4�6 � 5n� , �;L�_ =�� � ; �� �� 0 H�� 7�Q A :�� �(_ m

, k��L� W* 074 u] 0=�Q A:�� |�Q �4�H A�*�>�

�� �������� ���� ���� ,27 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

– 271 –

n� , K������ G��GX]f � WU�\ Y�4�Q A:�� iO�:.�� k!5 NUj�Q R@=�2

� @�:=� %�� & '�(�)�� ��*�+ �1�? '5 , ,�F�L �� ' G��= �7��:�� |�Q �4�H �������� V�L�W�� R* � ��� ,�� �.�� � ��7�� � 1a��� kW;�:*� ���=:��2 �UPj_�� �D ! '5 �m <D�� Y&��� , ,k��L��& �U�2¡)* 0=C2 J r Us ;�WhUo�Q u] KL 7�� kW;�:*� '2 Ah@� J , �£ hj.* � U.7:��2 � U.h�� { m��>� , k�L�W* G��Q

Uh.QK������ V�]2-�� D f '5 � F�L �� iO�:m V�Wo5 X; �UO�Ps\ ��J� V�} �&2�6 ��.!�α≥0.05� `�:) * ,

u ]2 S1a�� �� 3��P � <�� �L x2-* 0=] , �1a���L2���� �U­f

��=�F)�* ��$V�!��:

Y�4�Q �* G�H R*2BU�\ iO� :m R * � F�L �� �Y� X V�U4�:�� e±:

1 − ��� �2 u ] 0 = � U1�L Q V�U�UQ� F� � , kW�U!e :� � U1�L Q 0=] ÉL2 7] G�H R* �1�(��

n� K���L G�� G� � , � 4�H2 k��L� W* 07 42 GX] � &��* kU=P Q\ � Um2@�n A 1�Q K O�L � �L�¢ GX ]

�U.W�� k��s�=?2 k��+�U:s� f

2 − y� �:F� u] 0=���5 ���]�� Sm��&2 �=�m���� �1�(�� V�L��1* X �WWU+�Q2 �]�.:�� ��J�� , ����

� =:��� V� +�U:s� A 1��2 G� H R * | �}\ q�_ m

L�@:J�2 K������ V�.��sf

3 − V�L��1=�� �U�U�_Q �O��+2 �6��s NUP�n� K�� �L G� � , �U�(�� �!L��=: F� R=£ � X GX ]

��762 �W:*�=��2�=:��� , �*� :)�� �U=.:�� V�1�(:� f

4 − � �*�>� � 1�(�� �U F�L �� t (�� R=£Q V�L�W* 0742 �U=.Q [\ � � �U7U1(Q �UF�L� V�L�7* KDQ� F5 ��²\ Y C � ������� GX ]n� G� � , �1�(��

GX]n� K���L G�� , SF�=:* 25 SPPj:*f

5 − � �*�>� KL��\ S �;�- �� V�� .& 3: 6L ��L�_ * � *�&\ , ~ ��� � =:��� V�) F¡*2 � ����

� U=.Q2 � �*�>� � 1�? {�L Q � z�H R* k:� �;_*�U.h��2 �U.7:�� �������� V�L�W�� , �4�H k��L &f

��&� R@=� ���U4�Q2 �F�L �� iO�:m q�� ,2±e� �*:

1 − \ V� U�@�� � U­ `�:) * u ] �F�L� q��+ � �U1? u ] �� &��� � 4���2 � U*�@�� V� �*�>�2

�L 7��2 V�L�W�� K�� �L G� � , �1�(�� �W@�:=� A:�� Vn�GX]f

2 − \ V� �*�>� L2� R ] ^_ @:� �F�L� q��+ V�L�� 1= �� U7�� �1�(�� �UhC , �.(�)��5 ��L�_ * 2

� =:��� , �*� :) �� � U=.:�� V� +�U:s� A 1�Q �����L�X���f

* * *

�WU+2����� Y�82 ,�U8L��� ��F �_O�]: b8eQ d���:*� �+L� u] �U6��a�=� �� V�bc:��fff

– 272 –

�6��\�� )�* ���O)�

xW*L :$� ��� \�� )�:

�)�� ��*�+%��& '�(� f2014�� f � UOXmw�2 �U�UQ� Fw� �(����F�:��%�� & '�(�) �� ��*�> , K h�� 2016−2020 ,

%��& '�(�)�� ��*�+f ~] ,V����f �2007�� f�( F�:��2 KbcP�� V�]2-�� : V�2�5

� U=.:�� , �;L�_ =��, � �� 0 4��QB KL�I2 � U��kU��:��2 �'X] �.(�F ,7 ,44−53f

�G2L� ; ,|�2f� 2006�f� � U�6� �� , � !L2�2 V�D �� V� ���m�=.��2 �UPj_��2, .�!�* �­�Q =p 1]2 ,G� ! �5

<2� »�L A= ��z� ~]2 ,<�X��� Ë� 1] L��7���, S ��� :A�*�>� 9�:@�� L��f

,'� �I2�=]f� 2005�f�K���L n� AÌL� :�� L� (:��2 ��Wh�� ,GX]f �U�O���� V�;-���U����f 2�5� ,5−14 f

=p q�.F ,'XU�Ff �2005�f� V�D�� ��Wh* S)C : A]� �� �U=.QK�U�� VJ�� ´:� , ���.��2 V�D��f¹ * ,K�!� 7�� ,

{:@�� ��]f A.) s U� F ,Z����2 ;K�] V��+ ,<��z� 1]f� 1999�f� A .W�� B U+�:��

BQ����m2fn� '�L,�:��2 -.�� �6�7��� L�� �1:@* ��If =p �X:]� ,��]f �2002�f� 0 =��� E�F , K5��� �;L�_*2 ������

�U�W.*2 ����m �L�7* �U=F���, K5� �� ���£&2 ������ K2 m 0=���2 ,��*�@:�� V�* ��2 y��1��2 V�F�L �� �;�* �

,¤=� S] ��*�+ V�.1�� �U�;103 −125f R) s A�:6 ,<2�@�* ;'XU�F Í5 ,K��]� f1992��f V�U F�F5

�Um�)mJ� ������2 �U�� , A=���� r�1�� f L\, � 1:@* ��:U@��f

X�L ,K��]f� 2011�f� M���2 V�D�� �]�.4e 017:)� K�U=:* V�2�

K������2 K��U7�� �7�w� , ,K �:�� �U���� V�L�*5 ,A1o� ,�4��� %L� =�� r����� <�.)�� ��¡��133−148f

! ;'�+ ,�L�_U;G�_U* ,�:Uf �2009�f� A .W��2 <� �� BU+�:�� �U1(:��2 ����.�� Sf�­�Q :< U�� ��Hfn� '�L, �� ]

{:@�� f ��] < � ,�L�1*f� 2011��f <�� ���� kU ��:��2 �������� �U��

A;��F ¥hm 0H *'�Ln� ,,r� �� {:@�� ��] f ¹m ,k��@�� 1]2 '�FL , =pf� 2011�� f �&�2n� K�� �L GX ]

A.?� �� ��P:&J� , �!����Q 01F2 �(F�:��2 KbcP��f ¸� � s�:h�� % 7�� � �*�+ ���V� F�L ��2 y� � ,

23�2� ,43−82 f tUF��� k�����V 9/ � 12 2 � ��&�H��B+ :\ ,´h(P* kU!��

25 ~ ] =p2 ,L�� 7�� 1] *�s2 ,V����� R)s Í F� ,L� �.��G�1.( ,� U;�Q ::@��w� � 1 � ]�1(�� �U*� F

��I�:��2 -.��2f x�$j��:$�,�b� \�� )� :

Al-Howat, A. (2007). The Small and medium business:

Tools for participation in the development,

Tawasol. (Arabic). Ministry of Education, Sultanate

of Oman, (7), 44-53.

Al-Lamky, A. (2007). Feminizing leadership in Arab

societies: the perspectives of Omani female leaders.

Women in Management Review, 22(1), 49-67. doi:

10.1108/09649420710726229

Boyles, T. (2012). 21st Century Knowledge, Skills, and

Abilities and Entrepreneurial Competencies: A

Model for Undergraduate Entrepreneurship

Education. Journal of Entrepreneurship Education,

15, 41-55. Retrieved from

http://search.proquest.com/docview/1037693030?ac

countid=27575

Carswell, P., & Gunaratne, A. (2003). The Relationships

between the Inventory, Entrepreneur and Marketer

in New Zealand, ANZMAC Conference

Proceedings Adelaide 1-2 December, 879-886.

Chang, J., & Rieple, A. (2013). Assessing students'

entrepreneurial skills development in live projects.

Journal of Small Business and Enterprise

�� �������� ���� ���� ,27 � ��� ,�2� ������ ,�2015��1436 !�

– 273 –

Development, 20(1), 225-241.

doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/14626001311298501

Bilimoria, D., & Piderit, S. (2007). Handbook on Women

in business and Management, Edward Elgar

Publishing, Inc U.S.A.

Bolton, W., & Thompson, J. (2000). Entrepreneurs: talent,

temperament, technique, Butterworth Heinemann:

London.

Gelardin, S., Muscat, E., & Whitty, M. (2010). Slow career:

Mapping out a slow & sustainable lifework process.

Business Renaissance Quarterly, 5(1), 31-54.

Retrieved from

http://search.proquest.com/docview/212539650?acc

ountid=27575

Nehrt, L. (1987). Entrepreneurship Education in

Bangladesh: a beginning, Journal of Small Business

Management, January, 76-78.

Pihie, Z., Bagheri, A., & Sani, Z. (2012). Exploring

regulatory focus, entrepreneurial intention, self-

efficacy and entrepreneurial skills among Malaysian

higher learning institution students. Paper presented

at the 430-XVI. Retrieved from

http://search.proquest.com/docview/1325747229?ac

countid=27575

The Mayers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) (retrieved

5/6/2011). MBTI Basics

http://www.myersbriggs.org/my-mbti-personality-

type/mbti-basics

Werhane, P., Posing, M., Gundry, L., Ofstein, L., & Powell,

E. (2007). Women in Business the Changing Face

of Leadership, PRAEGER, Publisher, U.S.A.

William L. Smith, Ken Schallenkamp, Douglas E.

Eichholz. (2007). Entrepreneurial skills assessment:

an exploratory study, Int. J. of Management and

Enterprise Development, 4(2), 179 – 201 Retrieved

from

http://www.inderscience.com/info/inarticle.php?arti

d=11791 DOI: 10.1504/IJMED.2007.011791

Yaseen, Z. (2010). Leadership styles of men and women in

the Arab world”, Education, Business and Society:

Contemporary Middle Eastern Issues, 3, 63k70.

doi: 10.1108/17537981011022823

Zydan, A. (2005). The Entrepreneurship, the concept and

historical development. The Arabic Family

Companies. (Arabic). 2(5), 5-14.

* * *