Post on 15-Apr-2017
1
Post-credit crisis governance: The role of the professional
Jaap Koelewijn, Business UniversiteitNyenrode
2
Agenda
• The credit crisis: fiction and facts• Towards solutions• The role of the professional
3
The credit crisis: questions & answers
• What caused it?− Imbalances in the global economy?− Alan Greenspan’s mistakes?− Bonus-hungry bankers?− Wrongly-priced risks?− Globalisation?− Reagan’s and Thatcher’s neo-liberalism?− Lack of integrity?
4
Imbalances: US - China
-300-250-200-150-100
-500
1985 1988 1991 1994 1997 2000 2003 2006
$ Billion
5
Greenspan’s mistakes
0,00
1,00
2,00
3,00
4,00
5,00
6,00
7,00
8,00
2000
-01-
05
2000
-04-
26
2000
-08-
16
2000
-12-
06
2001
-03-
28
2001
-07-
18
2001
-11-
07
2002
-02-
27
2002
-06-
19
2002
-10-
09
2003
-01-
29
2003
-05-
21
2003
-09-
10
2003
-12-
31
2004
-04-
21
2004
-08-
11
2004
-12-
01
2005
-03-
23
2005
-07-
13
2005
-11-
02
2006
-02-
22
2006
-06-
14
2006
-10-
04
2007
-01-
24
2007
-05-
16
2007
-09-
05
2007
-12-
26
6
Bonus-hungry bankers
• Staff at Lehman’s New York office who helped to cause the world’s biggest corporate bankruptcy are to share in a $2.5 billion bonanza.
• A McDonald’s employee earning $35,000 a year is granted a $400,000 mortgage.− ± $37,000 in commissions− No fixed contract− Inadequate documentation
7
Wrongly-priced risks
8
Globalisation
• Globalisation causes the demise of existing systems of checks and balances.
• A decade ago, Dutch pension funds had 60% of their shareholdings in the Netherlands.
• Today, that’s 3%.• Local, informal supervision is dead.
9
Globalisation
• Globalisation also causes:− Risks to be shared across the globe− The relationships between risk-shedders and
risk-takers to become anonymous− Transactions to supersede relationships− The Anglo-Saxon governance model to lead
– to date, that is− Economic cycles to synchronise
10
30 years of neo-liberalism
• After 1979, Reaganomics combined with consistent monetary policies to end:− The power of labour− High interest rates− High inflation
11
Interest rates, real wages and inflation
-6,0
-4,0
-2,0
0,0
2,0
4,0
6,0
8,0
10,0
12,0
14,0
16,0
Contractual wages market sector Reële rente Reële lonen
12
30 years of neo-liberalism
• Increased corporate profits-to-national income ratio
• Power shift to shareholders• Very low interest rates made mergers
and acquisitions easier to finance• The pendulum inevitably swung too far
– ABN AMRO being an unhappy case in point
13
Lack of integrity
14
Lack of integrity
15
And boy did it pay!
16
To recap
• World capitalist crisis caused by:− Macroeconomic discrepancies and policy
errors− Too much focus on the importance of
shareholder value− No/inadequate alignment of stakeholder
interests− The demise of checks and balances in a
globalising world
17
Appropriate remedies
• More and better counterforces:− Shareholders, particularly institutions
• As per comments Wouter Bos− Better protection of external shareholders
• Sentences for WOL underwriters• Class actions against Ahold
− Improved internal controls
18
Improved internal controls
• For Dutch readers who haven’t read this: a textbook case!
• Showing up painfully clear failure of internal controls
• Come up with other examples
19
Internal controls in the Netherlands
• Increased power to Supervisory Boards− Less hands-off− More influence on strategy and operations− Greater – personal – accountability− Improved balance of interests of ALL
stakeholders− More management information
• Not just from the CFO
20
Role and position of the professional
• Changing role as fellow player in the playing field− No management puppet− Not a business partner− Acting in the interests of clients− Reward system should provide appropriate
incentives• Bonus schemes should not encourage
additional risk-taking
21
Only possible when:
• Management and Supervisory Board agree on− The company’s mission and goals− Risk appetite – and get it just right
• Willingness to learn from mistakes− A reasonable and fair balance of all
stakeholder interests− Ethical standards
22
On morality: Adam Smith
• Our conscience tells us what is right and wrong: and that is something innate, not something given us by lawmakers or by rational analysis. And to bolster it we also have a natural fellow-feeling, which Smith calls "sympathy". Between them, these natural senses of conscience and sympathy ensure that human beings can and do live together in orderly and beneficial social organisations.
23
Business and morality
• More regulation, more protocols won’t help
• Companies will have to deliberate their moral actions
• Professionals need to grasp the nettle and take responsibility
24
Real liberalism
• So our morality is the product of our nature, not our reason. And Smith would go on to argue that the same 'invisible hand' created beneficial social patterns out of our economic actions too. The Theory of Moral Sentiments establishes a new liberalism, in which social organisation is seen as the outcome of human action but not necessarily of human design.